{"records":[{"record_id":"contribution-97c307a8f67bfe94a6294594","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316805,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I was listening to the member speaking before me with interest. I just want to make\n               the comment that B.C. is actually the best place to invest. In mining alone, there are 27 projects in waiting. In mining alone, there are 27 projects in waiting — 27 projects in waiting. And that's\n               not my list. That's the B.C. Mining Association list. That's not mine. That is $50\n               billion investment into this province and 10,000 good family-supporting jobs. That's\n               what B.C. is at this point in time, my friends. B.C. is the best place to invest in\n               mining and other projects. I'm really proud to stand up in this House to talk about Budget 2026, which makes\n               careful choices to protect what matters most and secure B.C.'s future. It's wonderful to be here this afternoon on the territory of lək̓wəŋən-speaking People. I will come back to the budget speech in a couple of minutes, but first I would like\n               to convey my sincere thanks to the people of Surrey for electing me six times as their\n               representative. That is a rare honour for me and my family. My heartfelt thanks to\n               the people of Surrey-Fleetwood for giving me the opportunity and putting their faith in me. I exist in this House\n               because of them. Special thanks to my two staff members in the Surrey-Fleetwood office, Priyanka Mehta\n               and Maseeh Dlir, and my staff in Victoria office. They are exceptional people and\n               doing excellent jobs serving the people of British Columbia, assisting me daily to\n               solve a constituency matter and permit a new mine or expansion. Last but not least, from the bottom of my heart, thank you to the love of my life,\n               my friend, my trusted advisor and my beautiful wife, Rajwant Brar, my daughter, Noor\n               Brar, who recently graduated from UBC school of medicine, and my son Fateh Brar, who\n               recently entered at UBC Sauder School of Business. Your love, strength, unwavering\n               support means everything to me, and I am forever grateful to walk this journey by\n               your side. Coming back to the Budget 2026, in a world of uncertainty, as we all know, Budget\n               2026 makes careful choices to protect what matters most and secure B.C.'s future.\n               Over the last 80 years, we built the foundations a strong province depends on. Hospitals,\n               schools, roads, transit, housing, clean electricity are being delivered to support\n               communities and good jobs across British Columbia. We made these investments while guiding people and businesses through extraordinary\n               challenges — a global pandemic, as we all know, devastating floods and wildfires,\n               and now a direct attack on our economy and sovereignty. We all know that. We entered this period from a position of strength. Our economy stayed resilient,\n               and a low debt-to-GDP ratio gave B.C. the capacity to respond when it mattered most. That work is making a difference. Major job creating, mining and other projects moving\n               forward, faster than any other province, in British Columbia. More family doctors than ever before. I know they were there for 16 years. I know\n               the ratio. There were 1 million people at that time without a physician. Rent prices dropping from their peaks, everyday costs eased through the B.C. family\n               benefit, more affordable child care and lower car insurance rates, as we all know\n               what happened to ICBC under the B.C. Liberals. It was in debt for over a billion dollars,\n               and we fixed it. This budget defends those gains. It also faces a tough reality with clarity. Global\n               uncertainty is slowing growth everywhere. It's not only British Columbia. It's not\n               in other provinces. It's everywhere on the globe. High costs, global instability,\n               volatile commodity prices are putting pressure on public finance. We must be realistic. Yes, you can stand up in this House with slogans and say all\n               those kinds of things. This is a very serious time, and we must be realistic and disciplined,\n               very disciplined about the choices ahead. Budget 2026 makes disciplined choices to protect what matters most. So our priorities\n               are clear. Protect core public services like health care, education, public safety.\n               Keep B.C. one of the lowest-taxed provinces for working families. B.C. is the lowest-taxed\n               province in the country with working families, as we speak. And reduce the deficit responsibly over time. To achieve this, we are taking three\n               key actions. Make the public sector smaller and more efficient so more dollars reach\n               different lines. Pace infrastructure projects carefully, delivering them efficiently\n               without driving up costs, because that's very important, and generate new revenue.\n               That's very important to grow the economy, while taking action to grow the economy\n               and scale the long-term impact of major projects. At the same time, we continue to invest in B.C.'s future, doubling trades training,\n               supporting major job creation projects and ensuring families and communities benefit\n               from what we have built. Budget 2026 is serious work for serious times. We are focused on what matters most\n               and protecting services, keeping taxes low for working families and strengthening\n               B.C.'s finances for the long term. Now I would like to talk about my ministry, the Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals.\n               I had the opportunity to become the Minister of Mining and Critical Minerals about\n               14 months ago. Reflecting on my first year as Minister of Mining and Critical Minerals, I have seen\n               the vital role this sector plays in shaping the path ahead. And 2025 began with a\n               constant stream of threats from across the border, yet we remain steady, moving forward\n               with confidence, rising to every challenge and delivering strong results. Over the past year, we have worked together with industry and our counterparts from\n               across the country to respond to global challenges in a way that protects the interests\n               of all Canadians. On the world stage, we showed that Canada and B.C. have so much\n               to offer, not only through our valuable resources but through our unity, our respect\n               for the land and our ability to build meaningful, lasting partnerships. Our efforts are working. In 2025, B.C. saw mineral exploration expenditures totalling\n               an estimated historic high of over $750 million and a projected mineral production\n               value of $16.4 billion. We remain a global mining and critical mineral hub. with approximately 1,000 mining\n               and mineral exploration and development companies headquartered in the region — 40,000\n               employees in the mining sector. These are pretty good family-supporting jobs with\n               an average salary of $130,000. By 2040, new and expanded critical mineral projects could represent an investment\n               opportunity of $44 billion. And the proposed Anglo-Teck merger and its headquarter\n               location to Vancouver signals global confidence in B.C. mining. We're not stopping there. Looking ahead, we will continue to listen, collaborate and\n               work hard to secure B.C.'s position as one of the world's leading mining jurisdictions,\n               while building a stronger, more resilient future for all British Columbians. I know the opposition has been speaking about this, but I want to clearly state here\n               that as part of Budget 2026, my ministry will receive a budget lift of $3 million\n               to support our move to fixed permitting times. There will be $1 million to provide\n               extra staff and a further $2 million to support the mineral claims consultation framework,\n               shortly known as MCCF. This funding will build on efficiencies already created, which includes almost 35\n               percent more exploration permits issued in 2025 than 2024, reducing timelines for\n               major mine applications by 35 percent, a record-breaking investment of more than $750\n               million in mining exploration. Our government is also dedicating up to a billion-dollar loan guarantee program to\n               support equity ownership for B.C.'s First Nations. This positive step helps create\n               pathways for First Nations towards more inclusive participation in the economic benefits\n               of mining and other projects. This reflects our commitment to valuing First Nations as true partners and advancing\n               a more collaborative, inclusive approach to a shared prosperous future. I also want to acknowledge that dedicated, hard-working people are at the heart of\n               the mining and mineral exploration industry. That's why Budget 2026 opens the door\n               for more British Columbians to train for in-demand skilled trades, getting good family-supporting\n               jobs needed to help B.C. become Canada's economic engine. A total of $283 million in funding includes $241 million to double skilled-trades\n               funding over three years; $12 million over three years to enhance the employer's training\n               grant, helping double apprenticeship seats by 2028-29; $30 million to train highly\n               qualified professionals by adding specialized streams to existing programs, including\n               engineering, geology, computer science, biology and aerospace. Last month my ministry was proud to announce that we will be the first jurisdiction\n               in Canada to have fixed permitting timelines for mineral exploration. The first province\n               in the country. The mineral explorers play the most critical role in building new\n               mines. It is exploration work that finds, proves and develops projects of the future,\n               because every major mine starts with exploration. That's why it is important for us\n               to continue advancing our regulatory That's why it is important for us to continue advancing our regulatory framework,\n               ensuring that we provide a clear, efficient path for industry to grow and thrive.\n               So beginning in April 2026, exploration permits will be processed within 40 to 140\n               days, depending on the complexity of the proposed activity. Factors will include consultation with First Nations, the size and complexity of the\n               proposed project, the extent of ground disturbance and other variables. This will\n               be achieved through a combination of improvements, including clear, upfront guidance,\n               system changes and process transparency. We are also introducing a new, permanent escalation process, so it will not just stop\n               there. We want to make the system completely accountable because we truly believe\n               in providing certainty to the industry. That's the key to bringing more investment\n               to the province and to start more mining projects in the province. So in these actions\n               we are fulfilling our pledge to introduce fixed permitting timelines for B.C.'s vital\n               mineral exploration sector while still protecting the environment and respecting reconciliation\n               with First Nations and will drive even further investment in the booming mining industry. The new fixed permitting timeline fulfils a mandate commitment and will build on efficiencies\n               achieved to date. Since 2022, the regional permitting backlog has dropped by 75 percent\n               for mineral exploration. They are not just numbers. They are backed by real, concrete\n               examples. For example, Shaft Creek, Teck Resources Ltd., 112 days processing time. A large-scale\n               advanced exploration project, just 112 days. Newmont, 95 days processing time. Large-scale\n               advanced exploration project surrounding Brucejack mine, just 95 days. Duke project,\n               Amarc Resources Ltd., 71 days processing time. Kemess project of AuRico Metals Inc.,\n               Centerra Gold, 97 days processing time. These are real numbers, and nobody can deny\n               these numbers. We are showing strong progress, thanks to this budget. We will have the support needed\n               to make B.C. the best place to explore and mine. B.C. is actually already the best\n               jurisdiction for mining and mineral exploration. Last year, we identified four major mining projects as priority projects, ensuring\n               that government processes do not hold up decision timelines. The results are already\n               evident. This summer, the Teck Highland Valley Copper expansion, one of our priority\n               projects, received its environmental assessment certificate and all required permits. I want to convey my sincere thanks to the minister sitting on my right for her exceptional\n               work to issue the environmental assessment certificate, because that's a very complex\n               job, and that is a very important step to issue a mining permit to a mine. Highland Valley Copper represents an investment of $2.4 billion, a $2.4 billion capital\n               investment, to extend the mine life by nearly 18 years, creating 200 new jobs and\n               expanding the workforce to 1,500. Again, these are very good, family-supporting jobs,\n               where the average salary is $130,000. Last month we proudly announced the expansion of the Mount Milligan copper-gold mine\n               near Fort St. James. Another priority project, the mine expansion will bring a projected\n               capital expenditure of up to $400 million, will support 574 existing jobs and extend\n               the life We also permitted the reopening of the Eskay Creek mine, a historic underground mine,\n               as a new open-pit gold-silver mine near Stewart, B.C. It's anticipated that the project\n               will create approximately 1,000 construction jobs and more than 770 jobs during the\n               operation. The mine involves a projected capital expenditure of $713 million, as estimated\n               during the environmental assessment process, and is expected to generate approximately\n               $1.19 billion in provincial revenue — only from one mine. Nationally, the inclusion of the Red Chris expansion and the critical minerals conservation\n               corridor initiative on the federal priority project list is an important recognition\n               of the significance of B.C.'s critical minerals sector to Canada's future. As you can see, hon. Speaker, we are following our ambitious agenda closely. We are\n               living in an extraordinary era for the industry, and we are seizing opportunities\n               for the benefit of all. B.C. is geologically rich and produces or has the potential\n               to produce 22 of Canada's 32 critical minerals. These minerals and metals are essential\n               to fight climate change and to develop clean technology. In today's world, the global economy needs a reliable partner who can offer not only\n               critical minerals but also a stable and predictable investment climate, grounded in\n               strong environmental, social and governance standards. That's what British Columbia\n               is doing. As part of my mandate, and in partnership with other western jurisdictions, we signed\n               a memorandum of understanding, committing to develop a western Canadian critical minerals\n               strategy. This strategy will maximize the west's opportunity to grow its mining and\n               processing capacity in critical minerals and showcase that the west can truly be Canada's\n               economic engine. None of this progress happens in isolation. That's why I look forward to working with\n               our industry partners, First Nations and the public to support a thriving mineral\n               exploration and mining sector. This is a great industry doing great work for B.C.,\n               and we are deeply committed to growing it at every stage. In the end — I know I have six minutes left — I will briefly talk about....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316805","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I was listening to the member speaking before me with interest. I just want to make\n               the comment that B.C. is actually the best place to invest. In mining alone, there are 27 projects in waiting. In mining alone, there are 27 projects in waiting — 27 projects in waiting. And that's\n               not my list. That's the B.C. Mining Association list. That's not mine. That is $50\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9fa0635a6ea712d6782a109ed9449457035852d646db0cf674c6e865b2e66231"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["374b0ca739e49883cdfdd2aa589a2129861e5cb515f57541d112bfc07d4dc00a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35d283e126a59e94f8a6c194","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316806,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm proud to stand in this House again today to continue my discussion about Budget\n               2026 from yesterday when I left. Budget 2026 is good for the people of Surrey. Yesterday we just started talking about\n               Surrey when I was asked by the Hon. Speaker to stop because of procedural matters.\n               So I would like to continue from the same place again. Surrey is, as we all know, a fast-growing city in the province and probably in the\n               country. We bring now, they say, roughly about 1,400 people every week, and that's\n               huge. If you look at the education sector, I met with the school superintendent. What they\n               told me was that about five years ago, the average growth in Surrey schools for new\n               kids was about 600 kids, which means the province is required to make one new school, In five years, rather than making five schools, now you're supposed to build 25 schools.\n               That's a huge difference. We have made huge progress during the last eight years. Budget 2026 reflects government\n               choices. I just want to say that even at a time which is a very challenging time,\n               when we talk about the financial situation, we continue to invest in the city of Surrey,\n               big time, to make sure that city of Surrey people get what they deserve. Also, we have to deal with the huge gap left over by the previous administration,\n               which was B.C. Liberals, and then it was B.C. United and then something else. I don't\n               know what the future will be. We have been investing in building schools for kids, extending SkyTrain to Langley,\n               replacing an unsafe Pattullo Bridge, a new second hospital for patients and a medical\n               school for our young students at SFU. We are putting the people of Surrey first, making\n               different choices than the previous government. For 16 years, B.C. Liberals refused to build affordable housing, as we all know; public\n               transit and schools for our students; and a new second hospital for our fastest-growing\n               city in the country. Members of the official opposition are pretty surprising. I see them constantly stand\n               in this House and talk about Surrey in their budget speeches and during the question\n               period, believing that the people of Surrey will trust them one day. That is not going\n               to happen. People of Surrey will never trust. They gave them 16 years to fix problems,\n               but they completely ignored the city of Surrey, though, at that time. The record is very clear. They refused to build the second hospital for Surrey. Not\n               only that, they sold the land that was purchased by the previous NDP government to\n               build the second hospital. We are building the state-of-the-art second hospital, with a cancer care centre in\n               it: the first, the only, hospital being built in the province — new hospital I'm talking\n               about — of that size. It's a million-square-foot building, ten-story building, with\n               a cancer centre on the side of it. We are doing it. They refused to build it, clearly, and they sold that land to build\n               housing at that time. They also refused to build a medical school.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316806","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'm proud to stand in this House again today to continue my discussion about Budget\n               2026 from yesterday when I left. Budget 2026 is good for the people of Surrey. Yesterday we just started talking about\n               Surrey when I was asked by the Hon. Speaker to stop because of procedural matters.\n               So I would like to continue from the same place again. Surrey is, as ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ffaae1347ee3c3fcce35bb7f0d5d477b03a90f87167031a9d7b4a9da2a46053"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a4a39055ffb85164aa2ff4a86cfd8668cc762ecace2d461b7f4b4cad6747d0e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20441d661aff6c6a3aecd043","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413666,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome and introduce my constituents from the organization of Hindu Mahila Society. This organization focuses on community services, charity projects and organizing\n               cultural events. I want to say that our province is a better place because of the\n               ongoing and exceptional work they do for the community. With us today in the House are Remiya R. Nair, president; Rajumen Playatu, vice-president;\n               Raju Menon; Dr. Alladi Sukumar","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413666","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to welcome and introduce my constituents from the organization of Hindu Mahila Society. This organization focuses on community services, charity projects and organizing\n               cultural events. I want to say that our province is a better place because of the\n               ongoing and exceptional work they do for the community. With us today in the House are Remiya R. Nair, pre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5fede699c9aa645f23509be27ce16dee957c99150ae0c3547a38cf6b73d8843"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ddfe7d434db35ee3e027a3d537f9613c2f5514ed7ab2360731328e51ad8eaf19"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07be9c512dd6370f86255fe8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414191,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to introduce and welcome two of my constituents visiting the Legislature\n               today, my friend Raman Sharma and Urmila Sharma. Raman is the president and founder\n               of the Tradesman Association of B.C. The Tradesmen Association BC. is a non-profit organization dedicated to supporting\n               and advancing the construction industry through collaboration, innovation and knowledge\n               sharing. Last week I had the opportunity to attend the 9th Construction Expo organized\n               by Raman Sharma and his team. Well done, very well organized and well attended. I will ask the House to please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414191","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to introduce and welcome two of my constituents visiting the Legislature\n               today, my friend Raman Sharma and Urmila Sharma. Raman is the president and founder\n               of the Tradesman Association of B.C. The Tradesmen Association BC. is a non-profit organization dedicated to supporting\n               and advancing the construction industry through collaboration, in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["574798166ee6f51a09467c955cc47e8fbe12282e90087848bff2920c306d29d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2faee70d16ca403a1a23b0cb29c9b64396ecfd0531928da76e5ad1430453966a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-833a04414692821eb6897c99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721228,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today is Administrative Professionals Day. The Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals\n               is powered by our amazing teams of administrative staff who support the work that\n               we do. Today it was a pleasure to invite our minister's DMO administrative staff to\n               the Legislature for lunch in the dining room and to watch question period here in\n               the chamber. Please join me in welcoming Magdalena Golacka, Leon Gajowski, Ashley Giasson, Tamara\n               Crosby, Staci Krauss, Melanie Mitchell, Rue Pope, Chris Munkacsi, Julie Hutchins Please join me in welcoming Magdalena Golacka, Leigh-Anne Gajowski, Ashley Giasson,\n               Tamara Crosby, Staci Krauss, Melanie Mitchell, Ru Hope, Chris Munkacsi, Julie Hutchins,\n               Jane Mayall and Maryann Sloan. I'll ask the House to please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721228","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today is Administrative Professionals Day. The Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals\n               is powered by our amazing teams of administrative staff who support the work that\n               we do. Today it was a pleasure to invite our minister's DMO administrative staff to\n               the Legislature for lunch in the dining room and to watch question period here in\n               the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","label":"Mining technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93ba115881cfa72272d896d2584e65d9eba2bf5645caed09e80f5d450abf40e8","13907dbc678a246952cdac26cf9e11828a19d1399a1d816a9fb4b886f1e68037"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7da0497b88f5769455c4cda06f8a0919bc2e17473db76f84f3e779795435f0e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10b66cdaf684cacc5718808f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728836,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize members of the C Face Society and 2Cents Care Foundation\n               who are in the gallery today on this side and, of course, some of them on this side. From organizing cultural stage at Surrey Vaisakhi Nagarkeet then to planning Canada's\n               first Bhajan clubbing concert, these organizations work hard at promoting cultural\n               unity and engagement across B.C. They do everything to make this province a better\n               place for everyone. In the gallery today, I'm pleased to introduce.... We have Srikanth Mogulala; Bhupinder Ladher; Amrit Pal Singh Dhot, who is also a constituent of my friend Minister\n               of Jobs and Economy; Inderjit Ladher; Mankatha Reddy; Langke Reddy; Kanthi Sadabarthi;\n               Mukul Seth; and Vapav Seth. I would like to ask the House to please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728836","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize members of the C Face Society and 2Cents Care Foundation\n               who are in the gallery today on this side and, of course, some of them on this side. From organizing cultural stage at Surrey Vaisakhi Nagarkeet then to planning Canada's\n               first Bhajan clubbing concert, these organizations work hard at promoting cultural\n               unity and engageme","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5805477d0cab80e1e5a72282b512d40ed77ede020d15894ad391a2d3615431c9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a51a8c8bb65aaf5e9787ad079c637eae63b9023a57dcff49504acfad5363885"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d0d821e27eb2e7b9225274b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752179,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to introduce and welcome two well-known leaders in the Surrey community, Mr.\n               Gaurav Bhutani and Mrs. Pooja Bhutani, who are the CEO and vice-president and creative\n               director of ICONS magazine, a new platform that seeks to highlight community members who are making\n               positive impact to our community. Gaurav and Pooja have toured the Legislature and enjoyed lunch at the dining room\n               today and are also celebrating Gaurav's birthday, which was yesterday. So I ask the\n               House members to please make them feel welcome and also wish Mr. Bhutani a very happy\n               birthday. I ask the House members to please make them feel welcome, also wishing Mr. Butani\n               a very happy birthday. I have one more introduction to make. I also would like to welcome and introduce members\n               of the Kerala cultural association of British Columbia. They are joining us in the\n               gallery today for question period. This organization has been serving the Indian and\n               Malayalee community since 1989 through creating a space where Kerala tradition and\n               culture can be celebrated across our communities. I am pleased to introduce my friend President Mathew John and board members Rajeev\n               Rajan, Prince Vigal Thomas, Jack John, Riyaz Khudju Mohammed, and James. I will ask the House to please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752179","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to introduce and welcome two well-known leaders in the Surrey community, Mr.\n               Gaurav Bhutani and Mrs. Pooja Bhutani, who are the CEO and vice-president and creative\n               director of ICONS magazine, a new platform that seeks to highlight community members who are making\n               positive impact to our community. Gaurav and Pooja have toured the Legislature and e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Explorations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035191","label":"Explorations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["478188643e05c6c2520193112aa9375933fc5ab2dd488a51deb2d48d7e638ecc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fb90ea36f94bf78b41312f2899e74643a3114e9972b4c809c534f1f7b91b168"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e22d2f9837b40165418ac6ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017123,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us today is a group of members of the BongMilanti Metro Vancouver Bengali Cultural Association who are here in the Legislature. BongMilanti is an important local organization that brings the Bengali community together and\n               fosters cultural pride through festivals and events across the Lower Mainland. So I would like to introduce their president, Susmita Das, and directors Souvik Dey, Amartya Chattopadhyay, Ranjita Chowdhury, Arnab Ray, Soumya\n               Sharma, Atanu Das and Sourav Mukherjee. I would like to urge the House to please make\n               them feel welcome. I have one more introduction, hon. Speaker, if you allow me to do that today I am\n               very pleased to welcome the Surrey-Delta Indo-Canadian Seniors Society to the Legislature.\n               This society is vital in supporting Indo-Canadian seniors in my riding and across\n               the region. They offer a wide range of services that cater to the unique needs of\n               this community, including cultural events and wellness classes. If you or a loved\n               one is an independent senior in the Surrey or Delta area, this organization is excellent\n               for fostering community and belonging. I am pleased to welcome a group of 56 seniors who are on their way right now to our\n               Legislature today. I also want to recognize president Avdar Singh Dhillon, who is\n               from my riding of Surrey-Fleetwood, and board members Kripal Singh Johal, Harchand\n               Singh Gill, Hari Singh Chhokar and member Naranjan Singh Lehal . I would like to ask the House to please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017123","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Joining us today is a group of members of the BongMilanti Metro Vancouver Bengali Cultural Association who are here in the Legislature. BongMilanti is an important local organization that brings the Bengali community together and\n               fosters cultural pride through festivals and events across the Lower Mainland. So I would like to introduce their president, Susmita Das, and directors Sou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d758ccdc51616ac14a17bd313fe9df13c567cd68f854e29358fdbf26ee3560c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eeaaa285c1e9029e4c5ffcd2b274727611afeb390521478ca7fed99de05de35f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a639f13e65da922a1f18a82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017128,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have the pleasure of welcoming a delegation from the Berke Mining Co., who\n               I will be meeting with later today. Berke is a Canadian-based company that operates\n               mines across multiple continents. Although they are headquartered in Toronto right now, I hope they are reflecting on\n               the weather here in B.C. today and the booming mining sector here in B.C. Vancouver\n               is a great place to put a head office, and perhaps Surrey will be even better. Watching us in the gallery, I'm happy to introduce Christina Erling, Allison Brown and Kerri Harmati. I will ask the House members to please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017128","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I have the pleasure of welcoming a delegation from the Berke Mining Co., who\n               I will be meeting with later today. Berke is a Canadian-based company that operates\n               mines across multiple continents. Although they are headquartered in Toronto right now, I hope they are reflecting on\n               the weather here in B.C. today and the booming mining sector here in B","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","label":"Mining technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501252","label":"Conservation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["edf325adaf1d8d218cd62a6be1b4949b7ca1dd989685d3bdb33f429ae94afc54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc9304498a8a81946c3e159747d49f8719e87d0bc158c5df862b99b0f57b119b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c164a394f34740e1fc71c460","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017153,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jagrup Brar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome and introduce my good friend Todd Stone. I've been told he\n               is here in the building. He is the president and CEO of the AME, known as Association\n               of Mineral Exploration. I just want to say Minister Stone","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017153","member_id":"bc-mla-12","member_name":"Jagrup Brar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to welcome and introduce my good friend Todd Stone. I've been told he\n               is here in the building. He is the president and CEO of the AME, known as Association\n               of Mineral Exploration. I just want to say Minister Stone","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5fe085b504e1c3a3ee0d2054032d593630df3cc84777dfd239657f85a430e02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfd9531c2ef1c0f412e84bfa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327929,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Spencer Herbert","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, I will be clear. I do not know what is in that agreement. I do not have the\n               text of the agreement. I have made a request to the federal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327929","member_id":"bc-mla-13","member_name":"Spencer Chandra Herbert","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Again, I will be clear. I do not know what is in that agreement. I do not have the\n               text of the agreement. I have made a request to the federal government.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0680bca43f27a733e7e2f9bccd7746d138df0eb93150afd393964827dcf4d0df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16e0ca1811281b5ed012361c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327930,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Spencer Herbert","venue":"Hansard","text":"Has the member ever spoken with Chief Sparrow from xwməθkwəy̓əm? Because if he would, and if he did, he would understand that Chief Sparrow and the\n               xwməθkwəy̓əm are not coming for people's private homes. You know, one thing that the member might want to look at....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327930","member_id":"bc-mla-13","member_name":"Spencer Chandra Herbert","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Has the member ever spoken with Chief Sparrow from xwməθkwəy̓əm? Because if he would, and if he did, he would understand that Chief Sparrow and the\n               xwməθkwəy̓əm are not coming for people's private homes. You know, one thing that the member might want to look at....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ea5ec349da25a1ebbca8b28319410cab588ab0859209d29684e2f0fc1787af1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7acddbac6abf5ab55f741a7f","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187115,"date":"2026-04-14T12:00:00+00:00","title":"K'ÓMOKS TREATY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov20-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov20-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187115","member_id":"bc-mla-13","member_name":"Spencer Chandra Herbert","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd39675e9028c778f632f193","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187116,"date":"2026-04-14T12:00:00+00:00","title":"K'ÓMOKS TREATY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov20-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov20-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187116","member_id":"bc-mla-13","member_name":"Spencer Chandra Herbert","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2c489a500c9ca07974956d4","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187117,"date":"2026-04-15T12:00:00+00:00","title":"KITSELAS TREATY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov21-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov21-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187117","member_id":"bc-mla-13","member_name":"Spencer Chandra Herbert","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd9ce8209a02f915b20a1671","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721262,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Spencer Herbert","venue":"Hansard","text":"\"Why won't you extinguish?\" he says. \"Why won't you extinguish?\" he says, as if Indigenous\n               Peoples' rights were like a cigarette. They're not. We have to sit down in consultation\n               and cooperation. That's the court-ordered rights. That's the responsible thing. That's\n               the economically responsible thing. That's the morally responsible thing. We will do it in such a way that we ensure that British Columbians know what we're\n               doing, that we work with them to ensure that they're part of that. And indeed, we\n               saw that example last week as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721262","member_id":"bc-mla-13","member_name":"Spencer Chandra Herbert","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"\"Why won't you extinguish?\" he says. \"Why won't you extinguish?\" he says, as if Indigenous\n               Peoples' rights were like a cigarette. They're not. We have to sit down in consultation\n               and cooperation. That's the court-ordered rights. That's the responsible thing. That's\n               the economically responsible thing. That's the morally responsible thing. We will do it i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b06aaef2de3b29ff5d006c7ae62d919b0e5fe2c0c52bc0f570c3c34057f16cf9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4aab13946bee18015e69e417df14ea04c4accecd7834150bb5a10e30cff1fd23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72220a76967f1f187fb501c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316814,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker, for the opportunity to speak on this very, very important\n               topic. First, I'd like to acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, particularly the Songhees and the Esquimalt, also known as the xwsepsəm. When I am at home in North Vancouver–Seymour, I work and live on the unceded territories of the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nations. I am always grateful to be learning from Indigenous partners, especially related to\n               the stewardship of land, water and air around us. I consider myself very lucky to have had the opportunity to be around Canadian veterans\n               for most of my life. When I joined the military in 1979, my first coxswain and his\n               winger were both veterans of the Korean War. We would host World War I and World War\n               II veterans at various events, always impressed by their medals and hoping to hear\n               stories. We would see them at the Battle of the Atlantic and Remembrance Day in their\n               blues and greys, some of them. Others would be in a variety of coats, but most would\n               wear a beret. I've also seen the most lovely ribbon skirt worn by one of our Indigenous legion members.\n               As time progressed, things evolved to a tented area with room for wheelchairs, blankets\n               available to keep folks warm, and the number of veterans from the various wars slowly\n               diminished, with announcements of the passing of the last World War I and the last\n               World War II veterans in our groups. I also want to acknowledge the veteran component of the group that staffs the chambers,\n               the galleries and the hallways in our legislative buildings. Many of them are veterans,\n               and they're always watching and being careful of everyone in this building — members,\n               visitors, staff. I have been at cenotaphs across Canada, laid a wreath at the Menin Gate, wandered\n               in Commonwealth cemeteries in Belgium, Hong Kong, India and Canada, gazed at the monument\n               at Vimy and moved through the tunnels and trenches that remain open there. I've spoken\n               with the students who manned the information kiosks at Juno Beach, walked on those\n               sands. These are all places dedicated to remembering those who died in service of\n               their country. Our ceremonies — Battle of the Atlantic Sunday, Battle of Britain These are all places dedicated to remembering those who died in service of their country. Our ceremonies — Battle of the Atlantic Sunday, Battle of Britain Remembrance Day,\n               Indigenous Remembrance Day — all commemorate the dead. True, at those times, we do\n               acknowledge the veterans, but they are part of the overall event. Each of our veterans has their own story — why they joined, what arm of the service\n               did they join, where did they serve, what occupation or trade did they follow. If you're lucky,\n               they'll tell you some of that story — but never all of it. People who join the Canadian Armed Forces are amongst the few who know they may be\n               asked to die in service. Often you will see a chest full of medals, medals which represent a combination of\n               service, operations and commemorative events. It is very easy to engage a veteran\n               by asking about the significance of their medals, as medals are often the only thing\n               that is still on their uniform. Designation of occupation, trade, rank or unit cannot\n               be distinguished on a veteran's uniform, as those identifiers are only seen on current\n               members. In the reserve forces, we also see a large crossover between members of the first\n               responders groups: police, firefighters, ambulance crews and reserve service. Members\n               will be dealing with their community in a variety of roles and then working for the province and country as reservists who are deployed to fires, floods\n               and other events needing rapid, trained response. They can also be posted overseas\n               to support international operations that support disaster mitigation or assist in\n               maintaining the rule of law in other countries. Remember the peacekeepers. Our veterans are important and unique members of our community, and as such, we continue\n               to recognize and value their contributions, both in the past and our current lives. I spoke of the crossover between first responders and our veterans. In that vein,\n               I want to go on to honour the work of the first responders in our province. Of particular note at this moment, I want to acknowledge those police, ambulance,\n               firefighters, dispatchers and more who responded quickly and without hesitation when\n               shots were fired in the high school in Tumbler Ridge. Their swift, decisive actions,\n               some of which put the members at risk of losing their own lives, have been recognized\n               as instrumental in saving lives of the children in that school. Immediate and skilled interventions on the part of all of the first responders not\n               only saved lives but reduced the extent and complexity of injuries and transported\n               all those in need of further medical support. For all these actions and many more,\n               we thank you. I want to speak briefly about the chief of the North Van district fire service. His name is Mike Danks. Mike had been a firefighter for many\n               years before assuming the role of chief. During the time, he was also the leader of\n               the North Shore Rescue services, a nationally and internationally known group of volunteers\n               who respond to local emergencies and beyond, offering their expertise in finding and\n               recovering and stabilizing and supporting and transporting lost and injured people.\n               They are particularly well known for their longline rescues and now for their capacity to go out and do search and rescue at nighttime. Our North Van district firefighters are also trained in both structural fires and wildfires because\n               our community is an interface with heavily forested areas and rugged and mountainous\n               terrain. They often will send a team off to other communities and to other areas of\n               the province to help out when there are fires and when the call comes. I am very,\n               very grateful to the work that our North Van district firefighters do. Additionally, we are served in North Van district by the North Vancouver RCMP, who\n               are always there. They are always there, whether they are in ceremonial events, whether\n               they are there in a crisis, whether they are there to just pass information along,\n               whether they're there to slow down a domestic. They are always there, and as one of my colleagues pointed out, they are always calm.\n               They are always professional, as all of our first responders are and as we see in\n               our members of the Canadian Armed Forces and subsequently our veterans. In closing, we in this House, in our communities, in our province and in our country,\n               will continue to recognize and honour In closing, we in this House, in our communities, in our province and in our country\n               will continue to recognize and honour our veterans and our first responders. The members\n               of these unique groups are and have been the final defence between crisis and stability,\n               and we thank them in perpetuity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316814","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker, for the opportunity to speak on this very, very important\n               topic. First, I'd like to acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, particularly the Songhees and the Esquimalt, also known as the xwsepsəm. When I am at home in North Vancouver–Seymour, I work and live on the unceded territories of the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nations. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["115b30f214bf1b70cd6823822cfc20ed4e5c0e75ed87f6eeb811b2c9ff15dca3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c7812b909f4f5890b282e1eb3dcd0977628ee1bcf3dc3ccaa64b16ff4343301"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdf5dca6daefb0a886793c9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316815,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the members' gallery this afternoon is His Excellency Jean Claude Kugener,\n               the Ambassador of Luxembourg to Canada, who is here on his official visit to B.C.\n               He is accompanied by Charles Andrianalizah, economic attaché at the embassy. They are taking part in many meetings with the government officials\n               today and tomorrow. Would this House please make them truly welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316815","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Joining us in the members' gallery this afternoon is His Excellency Jean Claude Kugener,\n               the Ambassador of Luxembourg to Canada, who is here on his official visit to B.C.\n               He is accompanied by Charles Andrianalizah, economic attaché at the embassy. They are taking part in many meetings with the government officials\n               today and tomorrow. Would this House pl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5deea71a62174723da645c7cc684778572028316d79eb93286eaa4c04c5c585d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be1a95139483769a8e297fe2fa873e58aaf7e43c5ee2591fa4597a474520ec93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee07b07ff9a591392d468257","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316816,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"I will start by acknowledging with gratitude that I am speaking on the lands of the\n               lək̓wəŋən People, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm. When I am at home in the riding of North Vancouver–Seymour, I am on the lands of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ. I speak these names with honour and pride. Today I would like to talk about and commend the extraordinary bravery of the Iranian\n               people as they stand up for their dignity and their fundamental right to peaceful\n               protest. Their courage in the face of repression has inspired people around the world,\n               including many here in British Columbia who are deeply worried and troubled about\n               their loved ones in Iran. In British Columbia and in my community of North Vancouver, we are lucky to have a\n               vibrant Iranian population, many of whom have shared stories about their families\n               and the crushing fear that they feel. I am proud that our Premier and Attorney General, as well as our federal government\n               and governments across the world, condemn the killing of protesters, as well as the\n               violence, arbitrary arrests and intimidation carried out by the Iranian regime against\n               its own citizens. The Iranian government has a responsibility to protect its population, not harm it.\n               It must allow freedom of expression and peaceful assembly without fear of reprisal. The right to protest is fundamental, and no one should be threatened or punished for\n               exercising it. I stand firmly with the Iranian people, who continue to demonstrate remarkable courage\n               as they call for justice and basic human rights. We mourn those who have been killed\n               while peacefully protesting, and we call on the Iranian government to allow these\n               demonstrations to continue without violence or intimidation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316816","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I will start by acknowledging with gratitude that I am speaking on the lands of the\n               lək̓wəŋən People, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm. When I am at home in the riding of North Vancouver–Seymour, I am on the lands of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ. I speak these names with honour and pride. Today I would like to talk about and commend the extraordinary bravery of the Iran","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7e54960f9343c1a58daf9151fda375e2edd9413f62d3abbe1ce210a9533fd25"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a221380dc7d3e3f9aaff24854c5dbc8fade798ec634cc182070e5350088c1d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21857b8a197b737e898f9262","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316817,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Infrastructure and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316817","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Infrastructure and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9d9dc6543b31490952942c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327931,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of\n               the Attorney General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327931","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of\n               the Attorney General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4336ac519bf0a86a5ecb8864","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327932,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you so much, Madam Speaker. Sorry, I snuck in. I appreciate the opportunity to speak to the bill, the legislation of Motor Vehicle\n               Act amendments. I, as always, will start by acknowledging that we are on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm. I am very grateful to be here, working and learning. Of course when I'm at home, in North Vancouver–Seymour, I am working with the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh nations. Again, I keep looking at our beautiful, beautiful inlet in North Van that is so much\n               prettier than it used to be because of the work of the nations that are cleaning the\n               water up, making the shoreline much more reasonable. The work that our various non-profits\n               are doing around the shore is amazing. Anyway, I digress. Here we are talking about the Motor Vehicle Act and the amendments\n               to it. Because I'm at a certain point in my life and a certain age in my life, I've had the\n               opportunity to renew my licence quite a number of times now. I got my original licence\n               when I was 17. My brother was kind enough to give me the car he was finished with,\n               because he felt guilty that he had wrecked my mother's car a couple of times and because\n               of that I wasn't allowed to drive until I was 17 and he and my other brother had been\n               able to start driving at 16. Anyway, regardless of that, I got driving at the age of 17. I fondly remember my first\n               car, but I also fondly remember my first licensing experience, which was significantly\n               less complex than it is now. As time progressed, the complexity grew, the lineups grew, the getting down to the\n               ICBC office and taking your number and getting in line and going through whatever\n               this time's process was for renewing your driver's license just was a real challenge. When I was doing that So when I was doing that..... You know, you just took it for granted. You just did it.\n               You just went through. But you realize, as you look back on it retrospectively, how\n               much time you actually lost in renewing your driver's licence. Some days you would....\n               I mean, I can literally remember booking a day off work, a vacation day, to go and\n               renew my driver's licence. Then you got your six-week yellow piece of paper that you would have in your pocket\n               and you would hope like heck you wouldn't lose. And then when it came back and you\n               got your next driver's licence, you were very excited. Then all of a sudden five years\n               would go by, and you'd look at your licence, and it's time to do it again. The other scenario is, oh dear, here we are in Desolation Sound. We've tied up, and\n               we're going from boat to skiff to go ashore, and my wallet went overboard. We didn't\n               have any divers handy. We didn't have anybody useful handy, and I couldn't get after\n               it. Therefore, I had lost my driver's licence, and the process to go through that,\n               with all my other lost ID, was quite painful. From both of those sets of experiences, I am very happy to support this legislation. The other piece of this is the BCID card. Now, my mother passed away at age 94 after\n               having quite a good life, thank you very much. But when she had to give up her driver's\n               licence at age 80, it was a real loss for her. Not only that, but the loss of her\n               driver's licence as a primary source of ID was very distressing to her, and so getting\n               the BCID was at least some help to her, to make sure that she at least had that primary\n               source of identification. And yet again, to go and get that.... I think she gave up her licence when she was 84.\n               Here's my mother, 84 years old, and if you think I'm difficult to get along with,\n               you should meet my mother. We go down to the ICBC place, and we take our number in\n               the line. Then we go up to the desk, and they ask her how old she is, which was a\n               mistake. She's trying to renew just her BCID, and they're telling her she can't renew\n               her driver's licence. Well, she'd already given up her driver's licence, and she knew\n               that. However, there was an interchange of interest. So it took quite a while for\n               her to get her BCID for a couple of reasons. Now to see that these amendments will make it easier for our seniors to get their\n               BCID, or for other people who don't have the joy of a driver's licence or don't want\n               the joy of driving, parking, moving in traffic, trying to get across a bridge and\n               all those other things that are associated with driving.... It'll be a lot easier for\n               folks to get those various IDs. Also, to be able to do it online is a real bonus to a lot of people. I've already\n               spoken several times about making the trip down to the driver's licence office. And\n               I'm lucky. I live in an environment where the driver's licence office is within, basically,\n               my community, whereas in the rural environments, there are some places that there\n               are not driver's licence offices, and they have to go somewhere else or be somewhere\n               else, and/or.... I was able to, you know, take a day off work, take a vacation day. Well, when you're\n               working on a farm, sometimes you can't do that. You can't take a day to go and do\n               that, and Lord help you if you need to renew your licence sometime when it's a really\n               hard time to work on the farm as well. So again, saving people time, saving people the trip to the office — absolutely marvelous\n               stuff. The other part is that the modernization.... This is part of the work that ICBC is doing\n               to modernize the work that they do and to make their services faster, easier, more\n               accessible, and that benefits all of us. There's nothing more positive you can say\n               about that, because services are really, really important to people, and in this day\n               and age, time is such a critical factor. It seems that we have so little time to achieve things, and if we can make these services\n               more accessible and make it so that we go through quicker, we're doing quite well. I think I will stop at that point. I don't think anybody wants to hear any further\n               history of I think I will stop at that point. I don't think anybody wants to hear any further\n               history of my driving in the last many years. I'm not going to say a number because\n               that would embarrass me. On that note, I will take my seat and support this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327932","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you so much, Madam Speaker. Sorry, I snuck in. I appreciate the opportunity to speak to the bill, the legislation of Motor Vehicle\n               Act amendments. I, as always, will start by acknowledging that we are on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm. I am very grateful to be here, working and learning. Of course when I'm at home, in North Vancou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f1143f6dc392c08cab2bb3be8010670c0972997cb1bed4e1c6e631b6923e4e99"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74fada747330eaf80cbd57f439155c9244736fac9533c0d9c288d2661a705794"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-466832828ad8586e212f9ca9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327933,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning joining us in the members' gallery is His Excellency Rob Tinline, the\n               High Commissioner of the United Kingdom to Canada. He is accompanied by Tom Codrington,\n               the British consul general in Vancouver. They will be taking part in a number of meetings with government officials today,\n               and I am hoping this House will make them truly welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327933","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This morning joining us in the members' gallery is His Excellency Rob Tinline, the\n               High Commissioner of the United Kingdom to Canada. He is accompanied by Tom Codrington,\n               the British consul general in Vancouver. They will be taking part in a number of meetings with government officials today,\n               and I am hoping this House will make them truly welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f12442ceba1145c8a900d3e5d1e18413d3e385ecbc4de5dcbe6b0d269faa2183"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b07b1d4c8db700550346abce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327934,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Education and Child Care and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327934","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Education and Child Care and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["38a640acf3ea1fef67a0b18dbf60af641b1692ee60930639bc29a58fb38a1837"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["085ea41ae327b08fcce4ac20c47ba024a4c58d2e3619dfea6b88545d92240fe6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c94dafd9c6f4bcee27d325bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359647,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to rise and speak to Motion 201, \"that this House affirms\n               its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an important\n               component of Canadian sovereignty.\" Initially, I will acknowledge that I speak today on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, specifically\n               the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. When I am at home in North Vancouver–Seymour, I work, live and learn on the traditional lands of the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh\n               Nations. Especially in this instance, I honour the stewardship, past and present,\n               of the water that First Nation communities have continued to do. B.C.'s most precious natural resource does not need to be extracted, processed, refined\n               or shipped. As a province of lakes, rivers, streams, creeks, oceans, glaciers, wetlands,\n               bogs, aquifers and swamps, we often forget about water being a commodity in many other\n               parts of the world. As you have heard from my colleague from Kootenay-Monashee, the province has a variety of policies, regulations and legislations that speak\n               to the stewardship of water, making it accessible and ensuring that it is safe for\n               all users. My husband and I lived for three years on a small island in Micronesia. When we arrived\n               there, I was surprised to see that most of the houses had large water cisterns attached\n               to them. The water was available between 2 and 3 a.m. If you wanted water pressure,\n               that was the time to do laundry, run a bath and other such things as we take for granted.\n               The municipal water was briny and not potable. We purchased large bottles of drinking\n               water that used a dispenser. One did not use a tap to fill the glass. We have travelled to other parts of the world where clean water is not a given. We\n               take care not to drink non-processed beverages, not to use ice, to make sure that\n               fruit and vegetables can be peeled and to use vaccinations, such as those for hepatitis,\n               to keep ourselves safe. In other areas of Canada, boil-water advisories are a regular part of community life,\n               and although the water is potable in other communities, it has a taste that is not\n               palatable. However, here we are lucky. The water looks, tastes and is clean. I appreciate hearing from the members who recognize that water is critical to all\n               aspects of life. People, animals, health, agriculture, industries, recreation and\n               tourism are all affected if the supply of clean, safe water is impacted. Rivers don't have enough water for the salmon to spawn or survive. Aquifers are getting\n               low, unable to replenish for a whole variety of reasons, which includes runoff that\n               goes straight to drainage, creeks or rivers. Heat domes have resulted in deaths, where dehydration and hyperthermia combine to create fatal results. Flooding in\n               our agricultural lands has resulted in fields having to be fallow for a number of\n               years because the ground has become toxic. Oil spills have coated birds, marine mammals and shorelines, again, creating a poisonous environment that is incompatible to life for an extended period.\n               Streams and creeks buried during construction, filled with debris and pollutants,\n               are not able to sustain life for the creatures that used to inhabit them. Fortunately, in the past several decades, the world as a whole has become much more\n               aware of the importance of keeping water clean in all of its forms. I used to polar\n               bear swim in Coal Harbour in Vancouver in the '80s and early '90s. You didn't worry\n               about the cold, although that was awful; you worried about the contamination from\n               the oil and pollutants that were in the water. Now the water is clear enough that\n               you can see the bottom at three metres — not possible 30 years ago. Streamkeepers, salmon aid societies and Indigenous communities, among others, are rehabilitating and rebuilding\n               rivers, streams and shores through a variety of projects, initiatives and ongoing\n               activities, cleaning and maintaining and preserving the waterways of B.C. Water treatment plants are critical in the maintenance of clean drinking water for\n               many of our communities, and others are dependent on keeping watersheds as pristine as possible. We all depend on water for life and all that life entails. As such, I am very happy\n               to support this motion going forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359647","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to rise and speak to Motion 201, \"that this House affirms\n               its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an important\n               component of Canadian sovereignty.\" Initially, I will acknowledge that I speak today on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, specifically\n               the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. When I am at ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","label":"Water conservation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9463da6965afcddad980d77c82aba9c24548e0d75943ce72ec1207a98cc441c3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fd26599ffa5aec9f3454602f7276f5e0ba386da28858f62956af675ae3b6053d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9afd5bf70987faa524ce58e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359648,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning I am very happy to introduce Ruth Hansen. She's a friend, a constituent\n               and a real estate professional who is in Victoria today with her colleagues to speak\n               to members of the House. I also want to introduce Mark Cooper, who is a new friend, who builds houses and lives\n               in Lynn Valley and has been part of my community for many years. I hope the House will make them feel most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359648","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This morning I am very happy to introduce Ruth Hansen. She's a friend, a constituent\n               and a real estate professional who is in Victoria today with her colleagues to speak\n               to members of the House. I also want to introduce Mark Cooper, who is a new friend, who builds houses and lives\n               in Lynn Valley and has been part of my community for many years. I hope t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4c596a70df3164d4820379ca2fe0c3c43d5e1f17b4a2fd296d937fba8e4e399"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8712479d8860cd9c191c94c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359649,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"I truly appreciate this opportunity, and I'm very glad to speak to the Freedom of\n               Information and Protection of Privacy Act. I'm going to probably refer to it as FOIPPA\n               to reduce the amount of exertion involved in saying that every time. Before I start, of course, I acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, specifically the Songhees and xwsepsəm Before I start, of course, I acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən\n               People, specifically the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. When I'm at home in North Vancouver–Seymour, I work, learn and live on the territories of the  səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nations. I am always grateful for the opportunity to learn\n               and practice the work of reconciliation and commit to continuing this process ongoing. When we think about it, information is a form of power, a type of currency. It's the basis for all sorts of services, decisions, plans and many other things. Personal\n               information is gathered for a variety of purposes — health care, access to public\n               services, education, job applications and many more reasons. For that reason, freedom of information and privacy protection is crucial. It's been\n               around for a while. It's been around for quite a long time. We started to realize\n               many years ago that access to information that didn't belong to you could be crippling\n               — could cripple a business, an organization, an individual. So we started to create\n               a framework to try and protect that information. And that was done many, many years\n               ago in a time when our ways of gathering were different. We used an awful lot of paper.\n               Our ways of storing were different. I don't know about you folks; I've dealt with filing cabinets that filled rooms and\n               had locks that looked like this. They were called sargent greenleafs. If anybody has\n               ever worked with a sargent greenleaf lock, I'm really glad to hear that, and I hope\n               you were better at it than I was. But all these documents were also vulnerable to things like floods and fires. They\n               could be lost. They could be taken. They could be inadvertently disposed of in a way\n               that ended up with the information out where it wasn't supposed to be. So things have to change, and things have to improve. And that has happened, happening over time, and it's time for it to happen again. And that is why we've got these\n               amendments coming forward. I had the privilege of being on the FOIPPA special committee several years ago. And\n               it was remarkable the many ways that presenters found that information, either sought\n               or provided, had an impact on their lives. Information, like any other commodity,\n               needs to be collected appropriately for appropriate reasons, stored securely, utilized\n               for only the purposes it was collected, accessed by only those authorized to do so\n               and destroyed or archived properly when no longer applicable. Having worked in the health care sector for many years, these things make full sense\n               to me and are ingrained as given. We've had many times within the health care system\n               where we've had notifications come out that people have been looking at people's files\n               and not supposed to be there. That has resulted in employee discipline. It has resulted\n               in all sorts of weird and wonderful things. And it is also showing that the systems being put in place are allowing us to know,\n               now, when people are inappropriately accessing information and allow us to deal with it quickly and efficiently and also manage what is called a\n               breach. And for that, I am very, very grateful, because we are all in situations where\n               we don't want information of a sensitive nature or information that could lead to\n               somebody else benefiting from something, such as business information or intellectual\n               information.... We want to make sure that information is properly cared for and is used appropriately. These amendments that are being presented here meet a variety of goals and have been\n               generated through consultation with the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner.\n               Additionally, I am very happy to confirm that the report generated by the FOIPPA special\n               committee, of which I was a member, also provided recommendations that are incorporated\n               into this bill. One of the things that we have to acknowledge is that for many people in British Columbia,\n               access to digital services is a legitimate expectation. Reliance on paper forms, faxes\n               and other, older mechanisms is no longer effective, efficient or secure. This necessitates an updating and modernization of systems at the level of public\n               service in government, one which enhances the experience of those who use it. This\n               update demonstrates the commitment on the part of our government to strengthening the connected digital services for the people of B.C. In the past, particularly when my kids were still in school, we would fill out numerous\n               forms, usually with the same information, over and over and over. Each year seemed\n               like a new start was needed through duplication and replication, and this experience\n               can be found in many different settings. Our government has committed to diminishing\n               or eliminating that duplication of work by establishing a unified system, one which\n               is simpler, more predictable and allows for streamlining of services. This will be partially achieved through connected digital services that will have\n               information moved through government with the knowledge of the person or people involved\n               and, of course, with their permission. Public service entities will be able to share\n               information securely and appropriately with safeguards in place. The connectivity will promote the provision of increasingly effective service that\n               is able to meet the needs of those who access the services. Privacy is maintained,\n               while duplication is reduced or eliminated. A single point of contact, information\n               is gathered only once and added to as situations require, and timely responses are\n               securely prepared and delivered. Other aspects of this bill address the recognition that freedom of information requests\n               continue to increase in volume and complexity. All of the public services are finding\n               that time, money and administrative resources are regularly engaged through meeting\n               FOI requests. Ministries, health authorities, municipalities, school districts, police\n               forces and many other public services are spending time away from their primary responsibilities\n               in order to do FOI work. The administrative components of this bill address some of\n               those concerns through managing some recognized inefficiencies, maintaining people's\n               access to information rights, increasing transparency and generally providing increased\n               efficacy. Another area of improvement will be in the communication process, with an addition\n               of the ability to have a dialogue that seeks to clarify and focus the request so that\n               information requested not only is made available in a timely fashion but is useful\n               for the purpose that it was in fact requested. Another process that will be facilitated through this legislation will be the proactive\n               release of information to individuals who are seeking information about themselves.\n               A good example of where this is beneficial would be in the area of people who have\n               grown up in the care of the government. Their personal information is important in\n               a variety of ways and can be fragmented among a series of entities; i.e., their vaccination\n               status, health issues, school reports, various assessments and so on. Data has shown\n               us that about 60 percent of the FOI requests are for those trying to get personal\n               information. I was a foster parent for 12 years. We had a variety of kids come through with us\n               because we did \"short term,\" which was 6 months to a year, to a year and a half, with\n               the exception of one young lady who stayed with us for quite a bit longer than that.\n               Different story. When we would get kids to us, we would get very limited information.\n               We were expected to get them into school, from wherever, get them sorted out with\n               sports, get them sorted out with various things. The information available to us was\n               negligible at that time. Now, admittedly, this was quite some time ago. I can tell you that a kid who has been in the foster system.... A lot of things go on\n               while they are under the care of somebody else, and those records go a whole variety\n               of places and not necessarily in a way that is supportive of that child. At least\n               they did in the past. What I see in this legislation is the ability for those records to be managed in a\n               way that when that individual needs access to the information that was gathered about\n               them as they were progressing through their childhood and into early adulthood, it\n               is available and is available in a way that is accessible to them and is useful to\n               them. I believe this legislation I mean, I've had kids come back to me saying: \"Do you remember when we got this done?\"\n               And the big one was vaccinations, actually. And I would say yeah. They said: \"Well,\n               we can't get the record.\" At which point, I would go with them. We'd march down to\n               the health authority, and I'd find the public health person and say: \"Where do I find\n               this record?\" And we would find it. But it was not necessarily easily found, partly because they kept putting it under\n               my name, not under the kid's name, because we kept bringing a variety of kids in.\n               Anyway, different story. I digress. Another to do.... The scope of the oversight role of the Office of the Information and\n               Privacy Commissioner has been enhanced in this legislation. Currently, there are specific\n               circumstances under which an FOI request can be disregarded, and public entities are\n               required to apply for approval to disregard an FOI request. If an applicant is abusive or malicious, under this legislation, the OIPC can direct\n               that the request be disregarded, again allowing the public entity to focus on the\n               work that they are designated to do, be it providing education, health care, public\n               safety or the many other services provided. Of course, a clear understanding of what is meant by abusive or malicious must be\n               incorporated into the work in such a way that service providers and the OIPC are able\n               to categorically make a decision. Conduct that intends to harass, intimidate, threaten\n               or overwhelm an individual, such as issuing threats, would be viewed as a reason to\n               disregard an FOI request, and that decision would indeed be made by the OIPC. A clear and understandable FOI request should provide clear and understandable results,\n               which is why the system is being updated to incorporate a mechanism whereby applicants\n               have an actual process to clarify their requests. By integrating the capacity to \"stop\n               the clock\" when clarification is being sought, both the applicants and the bodies\n               providing the information will benefit — the applicants by having a clearer understanding\n               of when their information will be available and the public body by knowing clearly\n               what information is being sought. This will save time and money and provide a higher\n               level of customer satisfaction. I have worked in a number of systems, both as a professional and as a volunteer. Often\n               one will hear, \"Where do I go for....,\" wishing that there was a single access point\n               where information and services could be accessed. Well, Connected Services B.C. is\n               seeking to answer that question for access to public services. This system provides a government gateway that people and businesses can use to apply\n               for and receive government services and one that will update information across all\n               services as it is received. This model will only enable secure sharing of information\n               between public bodies. It does not facilitate an accumulation and storage of information,\n               personal or otherwise. These amendments represent thoughtful, balanced and necessary updates to legislation\n               that sits at the very heart of two core democratic values: the public's right of access\n               to information and the protection of personal privacy. Both of these principles matter\n               deeply, and this legislation strengthens both. FOIPPA was created in a different era, before digital services were central to how\n               people interact with government. Today, British Columbians expect services to be seamless,\n               secure and accessible online. They expect government to work together and not in silos. The amendments before us do two important things. They improve the experience of people\n               using the freedom of information system, and they enable the next stage of connected\n               digital government services. These are not competing goals. They are complementary.\n               We can and we must protect privacy while delivering better service. Let's talk a little bit more about Connected Services. British Columbians do not think\n               about government in terms of ministries and program areas. They think in terms of\n               needs. They need to renew a license. They need to access benefits. They need to update\n               their address. They need support for their family or their business. Yet too often\n               they are required to British Columbians do not think about government in terms of ministries and program\n               areas, they think in terms of needs. They need to renew a licence, they need to access\n               benefits, they need to update their address, they need support for their family or\n               their business. Yet too often they are required to provide the same information repeatedly\n               across multiple systems and programs. These amendments support the creation of Connected Services B.C., a single government\n               gateway that will allow people and businesses to apply for services and update their\n               information across programs in a streamlined way. This is not about building a massive database. It is not about consolidating everyone's\n               personal information into a giant repository. It is about allowing information, with\n               a person's knowledge and permission, to flow securely between public bodies so services\n               can be delivered more efficiently. These public bodies will continue to hold and safeguard information within their own\n               systems but, where appropriate, they will be able to securely share information in\n               a way that reflects how people actually interact with government, not by department\n               but by need. And privacy protections remain robust. FOIPPA already contains strong safeguards for collection, use and disclosure of personal\n               information. These amendments go further by allowing the minister to establish clear\n               data standards and privacy and security requirements specific to Connected Services. Additionally, the office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner will be notified\n               when a Connected Services provider is established, and retains the discretion to review\n               the associated privacy impact assessments. This is modernization with accountability. Again, we know that the volume and complexity of FOI requests have grown significantly.\n               Across ministries, school districts, municipalities and health authorities, public\n               bodies continue to experience real administrative pressure. We have a responsibility\n               to ensure that access to information remains timely and equitable for all applicants. These amendments will improve efficiency without diminishing access rights. As an\n               example, they minimize duplicate disclosure processes so that time is not wasted processing\n               records that are already being released through other mechanisms, such as through\n               legal discovery. They also enable, as I spoke to before, proactive disclosure of personal information\n               back to individuals that are seeking their own records. Currently we find approximately\n               60 percent of FOI requests are for that purpose. By allowing public bodies to proactively provide personal records directly to the\n               individuals, we can improve access while relieving pressure on the FOI system. This\n               is not restricting access. This is improving it. Another key improvement is strengthening the provisions around request clarity. The\n               current act requires applicants to provide enough detail to allow records to be identified\n               with reasonable effort. However, there is no clear, structured process for clarifying\n               unclear requests. These amendments create a formal mechanism for allowing that clarification. This does not force applicants to narrow their requests, it simply creates a transparent\n               process to ensure that when clarification is needed, it is requested formally and\n               responded to promptly. It serves no one if a public body is unsure what records are\n               being sought while the statutory clock continues to run. These changes provide accurate\n               timelines and encourage engagement, ensuring applicants receive the information that\n               they're actually looking for. It strengthens fairness and accuracy and it just is, that clear requests allow for\n               clear responses. I talked a little bit about rare, but disruptive, abuse. There's\n               also been discussions about amendments that allow public bodies, in extremely rare\n               circumstances, to apply to disregard a request that is abusive or malicious. I spoke about this earlier, and I want to be precise. There's already a process under\n               which a public body can apply to the office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner\n               to disregard a request. That's already there. It's been there before and it can be\n               done. However, these amendments clarify and expand the circumstances in which that\n               application can be made. The oversight continues to remain entirely with the Commissioner. The oversight continues to remain entirely with the commissioner. A public body cannot disregard a request, and it must apply to the commissioner\n               and the commissioner makes that decision. Abusive or malicious behaviour. Again, patterns of conduct that harass, intimidate,\n               threaten or overwhelm. These patterns of behaviour have become more evident in current\n               day. We know this. We hear from a variety of places. There are signs in just about\n               every workplace saying that respect is expected here, respectful behaviour is required\n               and that they reserve the right not to offer service if the person providing the service\n               is being disrespectful or abusive. These situations are extremely rare, but when they occur, they are highly disruptive.\n               I've been in circumstances where somebody comes in cursing and swearing and angry\n               and distressed, and it upsets everybody in the area. It can be very disruptive and\n               very triggering for people. The ability to de-escalate these things is not expected of a front-line worker, but it often is something that they need to be able to do. Protecting public servants from harassment while maintaining access rights is not\n               a controversial thing. It is responsible governance. Consultation was done with the office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner on these proposed amendments, and the commissioner has been engaged throughout the\n               process of this legislation coming together. We value the commissioner's role in protecting\n               privacy and ensuring access to information, and that the oversight remains strong. Government must balance two responsibilities in this situation: protecting access\n               rights; and ensuring that a system functions effectively so that all requests, regardless\n               of size, can be processed within reasonable timelines. This legislation supports that\n               balance. British Columbia is moving towards more connected digital services, enabling people\n               to access government through secure digital identity tools like the B.C. Services Card. And to support that modernization, our legislative framework must evolve. But it does not mean weakening privacy; it means embedding privacy into service design.\n               It means building systems that are secure, accountable and transparent. It means ensuring\n               that as a government becomes more digitally connected, it remains grounded in democratic\n               values. And these amendments achieve that through improving efficiency and transparency\n               of the FOI process; protecting public servants from rare but disruptive abuse; enabling\n               proactive disclosure of personal records; modernizing information-sharing frameworks\n               to support connected services; maintaining strong oversight by the office of the Information\n               and Privacy Commissioner; and reinforcing privacy protections while improving service\n               delivery. This is a balanced legislation that responds to recommendations from the FOIPPA special\n               committee and operational realities across public bodies. It reflects extensive consultation,\n               and it prepares British Columbia for the next generation of digital government responsibly\n               and thoughtfully. Access to information and protection of privacy are not competing principles. They\n               are complementary pillars of public trust. These amendments strengthen both. I am very proud to support this legislation, and I encourage all members of the House to do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359649","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I truly appreciate this opportunity, and I'm very glad to speak to the Freedom of\n               Information and Protection of Privacy Act. I'm going to probably refer to it as FOIPPA\n               to reduce the amount of exertion involved in saying that every time. Before I start, of course, I acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, specifically the Songhees and xwsep","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e01920360ec00c9a8702cf2a36699e62fe60c333cb4564242796994a0c3794d5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4d077fbcf7bae16c06e0f8b4f97584f80c7b06f9a993d5090e635fd717514b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa9871158e15e4d9bef3e830","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359650,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Children and Family Development and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359650","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Children and Family Development and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c7894e7df695362d94a75e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414198,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank you for the opportunity to speak to Motion M203. Before I begin, I would like to acknowledge that, as always, I am speaking on the\n               lands of the lək̓wəŋən, specifically the Songhees and xwsepsəm groups, and I am always grateful to be here. When I am in North Vancouver–Seymour, I have the opportunity to be on the lands of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and the səlilwətaɬ People. From everybody in the Coast Salish and elsewhere, I am\n               always learning and learning more. I am very grateful for those opportunities. The Merit Commissioner's primary role has been to perform random audits for hiring\n               and just cause dismissals within the public service. The role was created under the\n               old government to ensure the Public Service Agency, or PSA, was upholding the principle\n               of merit. Since we have been in government, merit has become part of the culture of the PSA.\n               The PSA has strengthened its work to create a hiring culture that is transparent and\n               accountable, one that attracts and retains the top-level talent we need to improve\n               the lives of everyone in this province. In the commissioner's own words, from page 32 of the most recent annual report: \"Due\n               process is being followed, with process steps being completed, interviews being fairly\n               conducted and employees having full and fair opportunities to respond to issues.\" In the last fiscal year of 2024-25, the Office of the Merit Commissioner conducted\n               276 audits of hirings and appointments in the public service. They found that \"there\n               was no evidence of patronage in any appointment this year.\" That's from page 18, if you care to follow up. The office has also stated that, in the '24-25 annual report, \"with respect to fair\n               hiring principles, we observe that open and transparent processes continue to be a\n               cornerstone of hiring for organizations who hire under the act, as is the use of objective\n               and relevant means of assessment.\" Also on page 18. In fact, the commissioner found an increase of 8 percent in merit findings in the\n               2025 year. Page 15. The Public Service Agency is a non-partisan professional organization. Similar to\n               the Office of the Merit Commissioner, the PSA does not make hiring decisions about\n               employees and individual ministries. This allows the agency to provide the same level\n               of arm's-length oversight for staffing purposes. Going forward, the PSA will continue to provide staffing reviews, quality assurances\n               and public annual reports on hiring, promotions and dismissals in the public service.\n               The reintegration of these functions into the PSA will reduce costs, improve access\n               to services for government workers and align us with practices of other provinces\n               of Canada. There is always room to improve operations, and the PSA is well set up to continue\n               to do this work so that we can attract and retain top-level talent and make B.C. an\n               even better place to live.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414198","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I thank you for the opportunity to speak to Motion M203. Before I begin, I would like to acknowledge that, as always, I am speaking on the\n               lands of the lək̓wəŋən, specifically the Songhees and xwsepsəm groups, and I am always grateful to be here. When I am in North Vancouver–Seymour, I have the opportunity to be on the lands of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and the səlilwətaɬ People. From everyb","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d51202755dd035ecdc5363d23d190497dd67d2e5b2d17f9ef4f2e336f2bbdd8e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ce85a88628a84cad75edcccd1f256bba0a98e57e62cf502706a9c277d2f31d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d246b8639dbdb153b385787c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414199,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity to address this House regarding one of\n               British Columbia's key strategies in response to the ongoing economic turmoil. I'm going to begin, of course, by acknowledging that I am speaking on the traditional\n               territories of the Coast Salish Peoples — in Victoria, the Songhees and Kapsilan,\n               in North Vancouver–Seymour, the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nations. I remain grateful for the teachings shared over the years and committed\n               to continuing my journey of truth and reconciliation. Over the past year, we have advanced the StrongerBC action plan with determination,\n               reaching out across Canada and around the world to strengthen trade and investment\n               ties as we defend workers and businesses against unjustified tariffs. Interprovincial negotiations continue to open new markets within our great country,\n               while international missions to Europe and Asia are deepening economic relationships. Here at home, in my role as parliamentary secretary responsible for the Consular Corps,\n               I have had the privilege of chairing three significant meetings with representatives\n               from the European Union and the United Kingdom, the ASEAN member states and, most\n               recently, Mexico and Mercosur nations from South America. Our Premier, along with the Minister of Finance, Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth\n               and the Parliamentary Secretary for Trade have played central roles in these comprehensive\n               discussions. Across all of these engagements, a consistent theme of collaboration\n               and mutual support has emerged. While sharing our ideas and ideals, we identified\n               new opportunities for trade and investment. British Columbia has long benefited from solid ties across Canada and around the world.\n               Today, as we strengthen and diversify those partnerships, our province is better positioned\n               to thrive in a changing global landscape.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414199","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity to address this House regarding one of\n               British Columbia's key strategies in response to the ongoing economic turmoil. I'm going to begin, of course, by acknowledging that I am speaking on the traditional\n               territories of the Coast Salish Peoples — in Victoria, the Songhees and Kapsilan,\n               in North Vancouver–Seymou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4b675b425a13ecbe89bb5876cc4c53e2507adbb1c084b334aa7f0faca35b5730"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af98abb53d3e4b373b7fd50416c22f25530ab931eba3694ba508d90acacf0aa3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-552aa46c30b4b7197bb11a14","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414200,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 2 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414200","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 2 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c11ee9f7356af4bbc520375f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720191,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning I would like to acknowledge I am speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking\n               People, specifically the Songhees and xwsepsəm, and when I'm in North Vancouver–Seymour, I live and work on the lands of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and the səlilwətaɬ. I rise today to speak about an incident that unfolded not far from where many of us\n               work, live and raise our families along the rugged and beautiful waters of Indian\n               Arm. On February 5, 2026, as featured in a recent Vancouver Sun article and in the North Shore News , a 70-year-old diabetic hiker became disoriented and lost on a day hike near the\n               Baden-Powell Trail. What began as a routine excursion quickly escalated into a dangerous ordeal. After\n               he ended up on the rocky shoreline, he attempted to paddle a kayak that he found without\n               a life jacket and flipped into the frigid waters of Indian Arm. A nearby boater, a 23-year-old Emma Elvin, was finishing up her work day as a small\n               vessel captain responsible for a water taxi in Indian Arm. As she enjoyed the winter\n               sun at the dock by her home cabin, she heard the man and spotted him in the water\n               near a submerged kayak. She did not hesitate. She got back on her boat and reached him within seconds. Clinging\n               to a rope on a dock, the man was breathless, speechless and in shock. Knowing the basics of cold water survival from her marine first aid training, including\n               the 1-10-1 principle, Emma noticed his smartwatch showed he had had 32 minutes of\n               intense She knew she had to get him out of the water immediately if he was going to survive\n               this emergency. Unable to lift him directly, due to the height of the dock and his\n               condition, she applied her marine training and cold-water knowledge, hauling him to\n               safety with an extra rope. She quickly helped him undress from his wet clothing, asked\n               essential medical questions, and established that the man was diabetic. Luckily, her boyfriend, Mika Heiskanen, was nearby at their dock. He, too, is diabetic.\n               He gathered towels, blankets, dry clothing and a glucometer, bringing the gear over\n               by kayak. They warmed him up and kept him stable until the Coast Guard arrived at\n               the scene and transported the victim to the ambulance to Lions Gate Hospital for further\n               care. These quick-thinking actions provided critical, life-saving assistance in those\n               crucial moments before the Coast Guard and other responders took over. The hiker later\n               thanked Emma for saving his life. I met Emma when she was honoured for her actions at the 114th annual B.C. and Yukon\n               Lifesaving Awards, receiving the Governor's Gold Medal chosen by the branch governor\n               of the Lifesaving Society. It's presented for the most heroic rescue of the year.\n               As well, Emma received a silver medal for bravery and Mika earned a silver medal for\n               merit. Emma additionally received a commendation from the Coast Guard. This story serves as a reminder that British Columbia's natural beauty is unmatched\n               but that it also demands respect. As well, when things go wrong, we are extremely\n               fortunate to have skilled and dedicated individuals, like Emma, who are willing and\n               able to step up and help. Indian Arm, like many B.C. natural wonders, may appear calm\n               from a distance, but it is surrounded by deep cliffs, unpredictable weather and very\n               limited access points. In this case, the man ended up in distress in the water, highlighting\n               just how quickly conditions can deteriorate. While we celebrate these successful rescues, and we should, we must also ask what\n               more can be done to prevent them, because preparation matters. Learning to swim and\n               knowing first aid can save your life and that of others. This incident underscores\n               the growing pressure on outdoor spaces that are close to urban centres, which is something\n               to celebrate, but it also must be matched with education and responsibility. Let us take a moment to recognize Emma Elvin for her courage and quick action, and\n               the professionals who supported it, including her boyfriend, Mika. Her professionalism,\n               courage and commitment embody the very best of British Columbia. Let us also use this\n               moment to remind British Columbians: enjoy our incredible outdoors, but do so safely,\n               responsibly and prepared, because the mountains, forests and waterways that define\n               our province are as deadly as they are beautiful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720191","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This morning I would like to acknowledge I am speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking\n               People, specifically the Songhees and xwsepsəm, and when I'm in North Vancouver–Seymour, I live and work on the lands of the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and the səlilwətaɬ. I rise today to speak about an incident that unfolded not far from where many of us\n               work, live and raise our families ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diabetes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44236","label":"Diabetes","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c74a2d2bae2b15447c9520742d3ea8a0c682a7089e31ec5455e8cf62cc7d511"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8f7708d871b958ca0c71d03086c66ffed21c6e6d0813996b96bb7c63f723ade"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aca2c019dad4a3380a699bf5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720192,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 11 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720192","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 11 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56304c2648f72d1d0c62e603","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720194,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"First of all, I'd like to acknowledge today that I'm speaking on the lands of the\n               Songhees and xwsepsəm People, and when I'm in North Vancouver–Seymour, I live and work on the lands of the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nations. I'm always grateful for the opportunities to walk alongside, learning as\n               I go. I'd like also to welcome our health care system partners and their guests who are\n               with us today. I'm glad to see you here. This week we join communities across Canada\n               in celebrating Medical Laboratory Week from April 12 to 18. Here in British Columbia,\n               we are especially proud to mark the fifth year of formally proclaiming this week,\n               recognizing the essential role that laboratory professionals play in patient care. This year's national theme, \"Every Patient, Every Test, Every Stage of Life,\" speaks\n               to the profound role that laboratory professionals play at every point in a patient's\n               health care journey. Across the lifespan, from prenatal and newborn screenings through\n               infectious and chronic disease management, to end-of-life care, laboratory tests and\n               results inform between 50 and 70 percent of all clinical decisions. In B.C., more than 290 laboratory facilities are approved to provide publicly funded\n               services under the Laboratory Services Act. These services, whether provided in our\n               hospitals and emergency departments or in the 200-plus outpatient collection sites,\n               rely on the expertise and dedication of highly skilled laboratory medicine professionals. In 2024-25 alone, more than 63 million outpatient laboratory claims were processed\n               in B.C., demonstrating the enormous volume and critical importance of the work. The\n               celebration of Medical Laboratory Week also aligns with the province's commitment\n               to strengthening and sustaining a resilient health care workforce, care that can meet\n               the growing and evolving needs of people across Congratulations and happy medical laboratory week.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720194","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"First of all, I'd like to acknowledge today that I'm speaking on the lands of the\n               Songhees and xwsepsəm People, and when I'm in North Vancouver–Seymour, I live and work on the lands of the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nations. I'm always grateful for the opportunities to walk alongside, learning as\n               I go. I'd like also to welcome our health care system partners and thei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","label":"Laboratories"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","label":"Laboratories","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28927124811933eb7c08b8daea207d93d3cc4e90ad79602080465cc3292a2291"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["594f472777f542800b41f8b3d76c6c1d67a06bf45cff7530fe97eae5bf3f9f82"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9600998640c7bfe206e2bc74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720196,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery this morning is His Excellency Stefan Tomanczewicz, the\n               Ambassador of the Republic of Serbia to Canada, who is here on his first official\n               visit to B.C. He is accompanied by Peter Vladikovic, the honorary consul. They will have the pleasure of meeting with you, Mr. Speaker, later this afternoon. Would the House please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720196","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery this morning is His Excellency Stefan Tomanczewicz, the\n               Ambassador of the Republic of Serbia to Canada, who is here on his first official\n               visit to B.C. He is accompanied by Peter Vladikovic, the honorary consul. They will have the pleasure of meeting with you, Mr. Speaker, later this afternoon. Would the House please make them feel very welco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cccecdc461dfe5e864a0ace88ff4b6577a917ba80b83176d269b1ae6170e09b7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fc98e0e951d76e323a73ce4392713b546084f55327bf127ddaca68a2f9629eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6fb8db15c58b77ef4330b146","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721266,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak to Bill M237, the Insurance (Vehicle) Amendment\n               Act, 2026, as proposed by the member for Prince George–North Cariboo. To begin, I will acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. I remain grateful for the time that I spend here\n               and for the opportunities to learn and work towards meaningful reconciliation. I also\n               recognize, with appreciation, the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh nations, whose territories form the foundation of North Vancouver–Seymour. Their ongoing stewardship of land and water is actively restoring local ecosystems.\n               It has been an honour to witness and acknowledge the impact of their work. Any time a vehicle crash happens, it significantly impacts those involved. Whether\n               it's the sadness of damaging a beloved car, the inconvenience of not having the usual\n               mode of transportation or the enormous effect of injury and/or death, all of these\n               things can be life-changing. So it is imperative that restoration work begins right away, particularly in the case\n               of sustained injury. As a registered nurse for many years, specifically working in\n               community, I've been involved with a number of people who have come home from prolonged\n               hospitalization and rehabilitation. Oftentimes in the past, they were waiting for the courts to make decisions that would\n               determine whether they could afford accommodation renovations; ongoing at-home care\n               or a vehicle that allowed independent transportation; and many other things that were\n               needed, which included income replacement. Fortunately, in 2021, our government brought in the enhanced-care model, which brings\n               benefit directly to those who are injured, rather than having funding determined by\n               the courts. Since then, over $1.5 billion have been paid out to manage the care needs\n               of individuals who have been injured in vehicle crashes. At the same time, our government has been able to keep insurance rates amongst the\n               lowest in Canada and provide rebates to drivers. ICBC has an ongoing feedback mechanism\n               that encourages customers and stakeholders to provide input, which, in turn, strengthens\n               and improves the enhanced-care model so that funding goes where it is needed, when\n               it is needed. Additionally, if subsequent needs are identified at a later date, a claim can be established\n               up to two years after the event or later, as determined with the input of a health\n               care provider. The definition of the degree of injury is found in regulation, which\n               means that the statute does not have to be amended in order to facilitate change. Currently, the B.C. definition is consistent with that of other provinces, including\n               Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Quebec. Consultation for these definitions, including\n               that of \"permanent impairment,\" included many subject-matter experts, doctors of B.C.\n               and disability advocacy groups. In 2021, the government committed to reviewing the model in five years, which is in\n               the process of incurring now, with a Special Committee to Review Provisions of the\n               Insurance (Vehicle) Act that was stood up in this Legislature on February 19 of this\n               year. As with all committees, this one is tasked with looking at the enhanced-care model — seeking input and feedback from stakeholders; the general public; and many others who have thoughts, ideas, experiences or other expertise\n               that could make the legislation better. Also, as with many committees, it is comprised\n               of members from various parties, and collaborative process is encouraged — one that\n               supports fulsome discussion and thoughtful recommendations based on comprehensive\n               consultation. This committee is in full swing now, with the recommendation report due early in 2027.\n               In hearing the bill that has been brought to this House, I truly recognize the underlying\n               intentions and inspiration that lead to its generation. I applaud the advocacy that has brought it to this point. I believe it can be readily\n               incorporated into the work that has already been started, to provide yet more breadth\n               to the discussion and reflection of the Special Committee and all those who participate. Vehicle crashes are life-changing, and the resultant injuries are often the most significant\n               factors of those changes. As efforts to provide effective care Vehicle crashes are life-changing, and the resultant injuries are often the most significant\n               factors of those changes. As efforts to provide effective care and rehabilitation\n               with subsequent accommodations that allow quality and comfort back into life for the\n               individual and their family.... They are necessary to be both timely and without financial\n               hardship. I thank the member opposite for bringing this bill forward and look forward to highlighting\n               his efforts during the discussions of the appropriate committee, in this case, the\n               Special Committee to Review Provisions of the Insurance (Vehicle) Act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721266","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak to Bill M237, the Insurance (Vehicle) Amendment\n               Act, 2026, as proposed by the member for Prince George–North Cariboo. To begin, I will acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People, the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. I remain grateful for the time that I spend here\n               and for the opportunities to learn and work ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bfa5a314cb2cb616ffca5cfd9a5e3796db58d047d58e18705b6414d872ab176f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["402719a5ee5f10926514bc59fd6bbad322419bf9c4d263483e0965d07c9d1f10"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0205ae37de5ac510d343bd8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721268,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity to speak as a new hockey fan about the\n               Vancouver Goldeneyes. First, I would like to acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən people, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm. I'm very grateful to work here, and I also live and work in North Vancouver–Seymour, home to the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ nations. The arrival of the Vancouver Goldeneyes marked an exciting and important moment for\n               the city of Vancouver, the province and for the future of women's sport in Canada.\n               As Vancouver's first team in the new Professional Women's Hockey League, the Goldeneyes\n               represent more than just a new franchise. They represent progress. For generations, women's hockey has produced world-class athletes but too often without\n               the professional opportunities, visibility and support they deserve. This is now changing. The name Goldeneyes, inspired by the common golden-eyed duck native to our coast,\n               reflects the strength, speed and resilience that defines both the team and our region.\n               It's a uniquely Vancouver identity, one that connects sport with the natural beauty\n               and character of our home. The response has been incredible. Fans are filling arenas. Families are showing up.\n               Young girls across British Columbia are seeing, for many, a clear pathway from grassroots\n               hockey to the professional stage for the first time. Just a few months ago, my husband and I had great fun at the Pacific Coliseum, where\n               the Goldeneyes beat the Toronto Sceptres 5-0, with Sarah Nurse scoring twice and Kristin\n               Campbell earning the shutout. But this momentum doesn't sustain itself. Continued investment, media coverage and\n               community support are essential to ensuring women's hockey not only grows but thrives.\n               When we support teams like the Goldeneyes, we're doing more than cheering from the\n               stands. We're building a more inclusive, equitable future for sport, one where every\n               athlete can succeed at the highest level.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721268","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity to speak as a new hockey fan about the\n               Vancouver Goldeneyes. First, I would like to acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən people, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm. I'm very grateful to work here, and I also live and work in North Vancouver–Seymour, home to the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ nations. The arrival","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["adfe409e2a8080cb727759a7e24c5a47f3f135cadb5b477566caf94f1370e92c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b304df286b577c2b588aa85d8e1d54c4c13e104871c1ff8eb36188a668a9ff25"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67a4014ce17d34436929d9ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721270,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the members' gallery this morning is His Excellency Andrii Plakhotniuk, the Ambassador of Ukraine to Canada, who is here on his first official visit to\n               B.C., with members of his staff from the embassy. I am pleased to say that yesterday they took part in many meetings with government\n               officials, including yourself. Mr. Speaker. Would the House please make them feel very welcome. Would the House please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721270","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joining us in the members' gallery this morning is His Excellency Andrii Plakhotniuk, the Ambassador of Ukraine to Canada, who is here on his first official visit to\n               B.C., with members of his staff from the embassy. I am pleased to say that yesterday they took part in many meetings with government\n               officials, including yourself. Mr. Speaker. Would the House please make","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69da79891c23277caa4cdef80224373367a81ae89b3315a114a3af3b8f5cb514"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72e96f330b6948508a1b4f20e7dcda71e0eca0d932af7b8e61ec739518e9cb3b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86d0ac7aacdb142e9e2b6a7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721273,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Energy and Climate Solutions and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721273","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Energy and Climate Solutions and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-479d68baae3288a3c9044313","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721274,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act, something that gives me joy — joy that was reflected in the Hall of Honour on the day this bill was brought to the chamber. Before I start, I acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People,\n               specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm Nations. When I'm at home in North Vancouver–Seymour, I work, learn and live on the territories of the Tsleil-Waututh and Squamish Nations. I am always grateful for the opportunity to learn and practice the work of reconciliation\n               and commit to continuing that ongoing process. These acknowledgements that I do each time I speak serve to ground me in\n               the ever-present work that our government has started and maintains in strengthening\n               relations with the First Nations of British Columbia. As has been indicated already, this treaty is a result of three decades of focused\n               and maintained effort by the people of the K'ómoks Nation, the province and Canada, and I find it very difficult when people characterize\n               that work as reckless. I find it very difficult when people try to second-guess the work that the nation, the province and the country have done together over 30 years to bring this to fruition.\n               They have created a treaty that reflects the living and evolving relationship between\n               the three entities. When fully ratified, a treaty becomes a series of constitutionally protected agreements that support strong\n               community, benefit the First Nation and the surrounding regions and continue to move\n               forward on the path of reconciliation. A reminder that treaties are meant to be able\n               to evolve over time to reflect current state and to support the union of the entities,\n               rather than continue to foster division. Among the range of benefits are included the following: predictable relationships;\n               recognition and strengthening of partnerships; and providing a reference framework that promotes clarity in decision-making, which in turn promotes a strong future for all of British Columbia. The treaty will also reinforce recognition of the inherent rights of the First Nation,\n               including that of self-determination. This results in a move from the imposed band government model of the Indian Act to that of government authority for all citizens of a treaty nation\n               on treaty land. Other benefits that have been enjoyed through the identification of shared priorities\n               are things such as improved overall community health; enhanced services that make\n               life easier; new investments and improved community prosperity; more sustainable jobs\n               that provide a decent income; support of the ongoing land, water and resource stewardship.\n               The certainty and stability that is brought about by treaty promotes a continued growth\n               of these benefits. The other thing that cannot be overstated is the empowerment of the nation to continue\n               the work of once again embracing their culture, heritage and language and all of the\n               strength that comes when a nation sees its future in its own hands and in its own\n               children. I have outlined some of the benefits of the treaty process in realigning First Nations as those who will determine their own outcomes and make their own decisions\n               about their own affairs. Now let's talk about some of the other positive impacts. Increased certainty can be established by all British Columbians related to treaty\n               land ownership Now let's talk about some of the other positive impacts. Increased certainty can be\n               established by all British Columbians related to treaty land ownership and governance.\n               Shared decision-making, economic benefits, and resource revenue sharing are all advantages\n               that will be garnered as treaties are established. are established. For all these\n               reasons, and because this is the next step in ratifying an agreement that has taken\n               30 years to come to fruition, and it was ratified by the people of K'ómoks Nation in March of 2025 with a significant voter turnout, I strongly support Bill\n               20 as the next step in the completion of the K'ómoks Treaty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721274","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act, something that gives me joy — joy that was reflected in the Hall of Honour on the day this bill was brought to the chamber. Before I start, I acknowledge that I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən People,\n               specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm Nations. When I'm at home in North Vancouver–Se","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5cf733333cabc561394484078f3a5a997b9363f2e0c9332a204c5d1616a1ad86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad723fbe04335ac9984242af72b0ba5a4e8aa07e3d006b462a857e0a73389dc4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-974324745b7cc1315f2f3fae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728872,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you so much for the opportunity to speak about a commemorative service that\n               I've been attending annually for many years on Battle of the Atlantic Sunday, which\n               is the first Sunday in May. As always, I acknowledge with gratitude that I am speaking on the ancestral lands\n               of the Coast Salish People — here in Victoria, the Songhees and xwsepsəm; and at home\n               in North Vancouver, the səlilwətaɬ and Sḵwx̱wú7mesh. These peoples have also depended\n               on the ocean for its bounty and as a transportation between communities and nations. I attended my first Battle of Atlantic service at St. Stephen's Church in West Vancouver\n               in 1981. It was there that I first began to understand the enormous impact that the\n               Canadian navy had on the outcome of World War II. Transportation of food, goods, equipment,\n               vehicles, armaments and personnel from Halifax to England was critical for the Allies.\n               The merchant marine was vital as the carrier of these supplies, and our navy was there\n               to escort them through the dangers of the sea and the violence of the enemy. The losses of ships, sailors, planes and airmen were horrific, and this battle was\n               sustained throughout the war, 1939 through 1945. At the service, prayers were said,\n               those of invocation, remembrance and, of course, the At the service, prayers were said, those of invocation, remembrance and, of course,\n               the naval prayer. Psalm 107 verses 23 through 31 are read. A litany of ships is recited,\n               three at a time. Then the bell rings, and a clear voice responds: \"Sir, they do not\n               answer.\" HMCS Margaree, Guysborough, Valleyfield, Bras D'Or, Shawinigan and Windflower\n               are some of the names that are read, only to not answer. This is an excerpt from the program. On the third of September, 1939, the Athenia\n               was sunk off the coast of Northern Ireland, and one week later, Canada was officially\n               at war. From that day, until the last day of the German U-boats surrendering at VE\n               day in May 1945, the Allied navies and air forces could not for a moment relax their\n               vigilance. Battle of Atlantic Sunday commemorates the sacrifices of the Canadian sailors, merchant\n               seamen, air force and army personnel who gave their lives in the North Atlantic. The\n               Royal Canadian Navy lost over 2,000 dead and 24 warships. More than 900 Royal Canadian\n               Air Force and Canadian Army personnel were killed during this battle. The elements were often as vicious as the foe, with raging storms, pack ice, bitter\n               cold, fog and the dense blackness of the North Atlantic nights. The RCN and the merchant\n               navy made nearly 26,000 safe crossings, carrying over 181 million tonnes of supplies\n               to Great Britain. With victory in the Atlantic secured, victory in Europe was assured. The freedom of\n               all Canadians was then, is now, and shall forever be the legacy of this courageous\n               band of comrades. Those words give us a slight idea of what was endured and what was achieved during\n               that time. When we gather at Sailors' Point in North Van, the sight is wonderful.\n               On parade, uniforms tidy, boots shining, caps straight, is the naval community in\n               its many forms. The Navy League, young kids, often bundled up in coats bigger than they are, parents\n               hovering around the perimeter; Navy cadets, older cadets, older kids, some getting\n               ready to graduate high school, who have learned seamanship, rifle drill, first aid,\n               leadership and many other skills practised during summers away at cadet camp. The\n               naval reservists, people from all walks of life who come to the unit, evenings and\n               weekends, learning trades and occupations, being posted to ships on the east or west\n               coast to augment the regular naval force. The regular force Navy who train and work, day in and day out, to maintain security\n               on Canadian waters, coast to coast to coast, to help other nations in need or to promote\n               international safety. The veterans, now none from World War II, but others who have\n               served in war and in peacetime. The merchant mariners, still those who ply their trade\n               on the waters, moving goods locally or internationally. It is a gathering of the maritime community to remember, to honour and to renew their\n               commitment to peace and security. The Battle of the Atlantic was a continuous component\n               of World War II, and although the losses were dreadful, the achievements were heroic\n               and will always be remembered. There will be a service at this cenotaph on the precinct grounds this coming Sunday,\n               May 3, at 11 a.m., if you want to see for yourself.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728872","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much for the opportunity to speak about a commemorative service that\n               I've been attending annually for many years on Battle of the Atlantic Sunday, which\n               is the first Sunday in May. As always, I acknowledge with gratitude that I am speaking on the ancestral lands\n               of the Coast Salish People — here in Victoria, the Songhees and xwsepsəm; and a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["beb20b43486abf939e6bf2f0161df1667efa3723f39aea6e92498116e475e842"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7e60a0e6d06cea9d2d8830f8b0c50ee55e4c1ab36d82eb8cfebf41ebc51c456"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a11db8844a28af76b93c5efc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728876,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm going to be very naughty and introduce a particular scientist today. She fills\n               me with awe, and I had the opportunity to talk to her for about an hour this morning,\n               which was quite remarkable. Nancy Clark, who is a registered nurse, a bachelor of science in nursing, a master\n               of science in nursing, a PhD in science and nursing and who is on a Michael Smith\n               research grant right at the moment. She's working on working with new immigrants and\n               integrating them into the health system and looking at ways that we can do much better\n               at that particular task. She's using social determinants of health to look at how do we make things better\n               for the people, not only in our province already, but for those who join us here in\n               the health area. I am very, very happy to have her here, and I hope that the chamber will make her\n               most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728876","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm going to be very naughty and introduce a particular scientist today. She fills\n               me with awe, and I had the opportunity to talk to her for about an hour this morning,\n               which was quite remarkable. Nancy Clark, who is a registered nurse, a bachelor of science in nursing, a master\n               of science in nursing, a PhD in science and nursing and who is on a Michael","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["455e567c8b8637188199d2594a0c382cd0385ef8a4fa40738357d67b17b23906"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2d5420f033e611871fefcbad0929a2212cda0f1ca7e939e25f348c2d0bfb199"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b0410dfb691d90d737353e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752188,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning I have two introductions to make, if I may. First of all, joining us in the members' gallery this morning is His Excellency Jose\n               Victor V. Chan-Gonzaga, the Ambassador of the Philippines to Canada, who is here on\n               his first official visit to B.C. He is accompanied by Consul General Gina Jamoralin and her staff from both their offices. I am pleased to say that they will be taking part in many meetings today with government\n               officials, including yourself, Mr. Speaker. Would the House make them feel truly welcome. I've got one more. I'd also like to warmly welcome an amazing group of people that\n               are joining us in the gallery, our constituency advisers from across the province,\n               who are here this week for their conference. There are too many to name everybody\n               individually, but their work is at the heart of everything we do. They are the face\n               and voice of our work in the community, helping people, planning events and keeping\n               our busy offices running every day. We are grateful for all that they do, and we really\n               could not do this work without them. Please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752188","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This morning I have two introductions to make, if I may. First of all, joining us in the members' gallery this morning is His Excellency Jose\n               Victor V. Chan-Gonzaga, the Ambassador of the Philippines to Canada, who is here on\n               his first official visit to B.C. He is accompanied by Consul General Gina Jamoralin and her staff from both their offices. I am pleased to say t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historic sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035683","label":"Historic sites","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e65e1e2b46de66630130257f58b87b076cbe1b01550e6f9b85c1df344ef20b7","37e3aa68c414f17c7f8df2a4e64ddfaa8a13f55017305833bf44a69e0cdc4c56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c24b5d5b650e20eea94d722f6e62888b1060d881fa9c285310a6ec9efe02d65"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffc8ea5d26d79e431e9737b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017190,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Jobs and Economic Growth and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017190","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Jobs and Economic Growth and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["738e162c05973c7c3df2051beb26aa62f78b96f16ff3d4c0471c84baa6ac2a56"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a6d5223a14b0190de68b022","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017191,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise today to recognize a very distinguished group visiting the Legislative\n               Assembly today. Members of the British Columbia Consular Corps have joined us, and\n               later this afternoon they will take part in briefings with ministers and senior officials. The Consular Corps of British Columbia represents more than 80 countries and four\n               international organizations from around the world. Through their work, these dedicated\n               individuals strengthen relationships between B.C. and the international community\n               by supporting diplomacy, trade, investment, tourism, education and cultural exchange.\n               They also provide invaluable support and assistance to citizens from their respective\n               countries who are living, working or travelling here in British Columbia. I would like to extend a special acknowledgement to the dean of the Consular Corps,\n               my friend Ricardo Arredondo, consul general of Argentina, and thank him for his leadership.\n               I also want to recognize all members of the Consular Corps for the important work\n               that they do in building connections and fostering cooperation. I ask that all members of this House join me in extending our warmest welcome to our\n               distinguished guests today. I have a second intro....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017191","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise today to recognize a very distinguished group visiting the Legislative\n               Assembly today. Members of the British Columbia Consular Corps have joined us, and\n               later this afternoon they will take part in briefings with ministers and senior officials. The Consular Corps of British Columbia represents more than 80 countries and four\n               internat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5dab8c12b507ab2aa36b98daafb070b5135d5fda4812b789143ef4e538e0cc13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b35dc88620a823abf5c3aed89905dcaa37ee3d72419df477ff5482dc9016b71e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0623c4da7ca19eb79aed1680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017193,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to discuss an important topic, elder abuse. Initially, I want to recognize I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm, and, at home, the səlilwətaɬ and Squamish. The way the Indigenous people revere their elders sets a positive example\n               for all of us. Elder abuse is defined as an action or inaction by someone in a position of trust,\n               such as family, friends or caregivers. It results in harm or distress to an older\n               person and can be physical, sexual, psychological, emotional, financial or just plain\n               neglect. Often more than one type of elder abuse occurs at the same time. According to a new\n               Stats Canada report, the victimization of seniors by family members has reached a\n               record high. It has increased by 49 percent since 2018. Financial abuse accounts for 62 percent of reported cases, which is consistent for\n               British Columbia. It can include misusing of seniors' property and/or funds, bank\n               cards or power of attorney; theft or forgery; sharing the senior's home without paying\n               a fair share of expenses; unexplained disappearance of personal belongings, such as\n               jewellery; undue pressure to move from, sell or relinquish their home or other personal\n               property; or legal documents that they don't understand. Protection for older adults in B.C. includes preventing isolation, taking action when\n               an older adult confides in you about a situation of abuse and helping them create\n               a safety plan if needed. If you suspect or know of someone that is experiencing elder abuse, they can call\n               866-437-1940. There is an agency that is based out of New Westminster — they call\n               themselves SHINE; they started in 2018 — that has done amazing work to help adults\n               in finding housing if they're at risk of losing housing or finding safe housing if\n               they need it. I just want to say thank you to my friend Alison Silgardo for championing that cause.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017193","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to discuss an important topic, elder abuse. Initially, I want to recognize I'm speaking on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən, specifically the Songhees and the xwsepsəm, and, at home, the səlilwətaɬ and Squamish. The way the Indigenous people revere their elders sets a positive example\n               for all of us. Elder abuse is defined as an action or inaction by someone i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15226557f1b557eaa40314f72d469617c93303e5f1eeff06f01d42939fb64d74"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abc17603fe9d20a62b0942cd0620417c6046a01547bdb2744c4e6378015ed9c7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e02e286a7fe8c2db6340dcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017194,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports the progress on Bill 20 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017194","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section C reports the progress on Bill 20 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4151b654fe4648f400337cb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036422,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036422","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c08ced855f01cda7dd52dd58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036423,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports Bill 20 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036423","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports Bill 20 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ef81996c5dc0e316b21c8f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036425,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Susie Chant","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions for this morning, if you will bear with me. To start out, I want to recognize Hannah Harris Hope for her exceptional contributions\n               to our government caucus, constituency offices and the people of British Columbia.\n               For the past 51⁄2 years, Hannah has been a dedicated and deeply valued member of the\n               B.C. NDP caucus team, bringing professionalism, kindness, compassion and an unwavering\n               commitment to supporting both our constituency assistants and our ministries. Her\n               work has touched countless people across this building and beyond. I've known Hannah since I got here. I have enjoyed working together. She will do so\n               much for so many. Thank you very much, Hannah, for the work that you do. She is going\n               off to law school in the U.S. in the fall. Well done on getting in and doing that.\n               Maybe we'll see you back, or maybe our trails will cross again. I certainly hope so. A second introduction. Somewhere in this gallery, I hope, because my communication\n               wasn't so good this morning, is my husband. I love him dearly; he loves me dearly,\n               which is very fortunate. We've been together for 41 years. He is the most remarkable\n               fellow, who does the things that he does — quietly, most of the time, and really,\n               really effectively. He fixes things for people who have disabilities, low and no vision. He's your guy\n               if you need something with Braille or that kind of stuff. He's your guy; he's the\n               only guy in Canada now, and he also takes care of me so well. I just want to say thank you to him and acknowledge him, and I'll sit down now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Visual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036425","member_id":"bc-mla-14","member_name":"Susie Chant","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two introductions for this morning, if you will bear with me. To start out, I want to recognize Hannah Harris Hope for her exceptional contributions\n               to our government caucus, constituency offices and the people of British Columbia.\n               For the past 51⁄2 years, Hannah has been a dedicated and deeply valued member of the\n               B.C. NDP caucus team, bringing ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","label":"Visual disabilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Visual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","label":"Visual disabilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","label":"Physical disabilities","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["798a695b4a36eb0727c977a4699cbaf8aeaf1b4fda7e218a9f81e29dd07b8578"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Visual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1a724d3445bf85478f0e9a57f93bd6a0390fafc3ce3c77c2bb9c06c9996759c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Visual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016918","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18d895ba8f3f7b0018563127","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86150,"date":"2026-02-12T08:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I ask the Minister of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness to lead the House\n               in prayer or reflection.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86150","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I ask the Minister of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness to lead the House\n               in prayer or reflection.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036005","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job promotion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036005","label":"Job promotion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cd6d0eeafa72f5dac06f946dfeebc61d9b8ebe3448ef3abea210e86dc20cdae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59fdd4a5c5111f64dd368a02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316822,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316822","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92bf4861c4b4a24e50d8dc99daafac73e239c23a97e6f8b5a7e3feb783634450"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce317c7ef136d6b5fb6a4000","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316823,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, a reminder to all members that the two-minute statements ought to be not\n               more than two minutes. And I ask members to practise it before you come to the chamber\n               and deliver it. Time it. If you need to edit it, please do so. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316823","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Members, a reminder to all members that the two-minute statements ought to be not\n               more than two minutes. And I ask members to practise it before you come to the chamber\n               and deliver it. Time it. If you need to edit it, please do so. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35d30abcb1296f66ad117bda","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316824,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Congratulations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316824","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Congratulations.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-734c0e6eaff2b4364ec949c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316825,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316825","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4cbfeeeab6db5d7feaabf66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316826,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"The question is the first reading of Bill 9.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316826","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"The question is the first reading of Bill 9.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e10ae3df2c4585793a9eb3d9e3059a6c4874005429cafe5d3ece298cb318935","049f8bc2eab729005f6a03a36d67f8dc2fe96edb82bbeca06c1c88a682ae2343"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f908bd5609945237942448d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316827,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"This House stands adjourned until Monday morning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316827","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This House stands adjourned until Monday morning.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-643fd8472c029a744dea6edd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327936,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Shhh.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327936","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Shhh.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32171cceab8c2210f6ef292b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327937,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, today we are so happy that we have all our wonderful firefighters from all\n               parts of British Columbia here today, so we will not be making any individual introductions.\n               On behalf of all of us, I would like to welcome all firefighters to be here with us\n               today. [Applause.] They're here to meet with their individual MLAs. We're looking forward to their meetings.\n               Thank you so much for all the wonderful work you do every day, 24-7.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327937","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Members, today we are so happy that we have all our wonderful firefighters from all\n               parts of British Columbia here today, so we will not be making any individual introductions.\n               On behalf of all of us, I would like to welcome all firefighters to be here with us\n               today. [Applause.] They're here to meet with their individual MLAs. We're looking forward to t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42ef7839d579aaea069ebfbac4bf2021c3300f83628449284e1fde4c7f98ebef","46fecf6659adb7a43c3c8c5c18642375c98fd1bb2ebea4e88537166ddbf007bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df4ca167ab32d0ee0d5a0b88e3d4a186c1998e27133b93509438ac7a2b2f1ed8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1c850a6b37be12adfe98e70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327938,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thanks, everyone. We'll call this chamber back to order, where we are contemplating\n               the estimates of the Ministry of Attorney General today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327938","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thanks, everyone. We'll call this chamber back to order, where we are contemplating\n               the estimates of the Ministry of Attorney General today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f6a6514e1e86a500f6be1bce68e9d4d7d25615f0ff3e5929127ebed1090018d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a90cd97debf2c82a11bed1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327939,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member for Abbotsford South.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327939","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Member for Abbotsford South.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdd0b920a149e7c8281629898ef1be6227e4c865919100cdff0221578c9ff1db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44a023c2620e13cdad2590f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327940,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327940","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b82ad4c94ab362bbdd98d2ca0e1808f852ad5c2a9275759a6e75e68a01af896"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc991376902172eda1ded217","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327941,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"The question is third reading of Bill 3, Budget Measures Implementation Act (No 2),\n               2026. Division has been called. The Speaker : Members who are participating remotely, please make sure your cameras are on. The Speaker : Member for Kootenay-Rockies, would you please confirm that you are in a private place indoor, sorry, indoor and\n               private?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327941","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The question is third reading of Bill 3, Budget Measures Implementation Act (No 2),\n               2026. Division has been called. The Speaker : Members who are participating remotely, please make sure your cameras are on. The Speaker : Member for Kootenay-Rockies, would you please confirm that you are in a private place indoor, sorry, indoor and\n               private?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8eb4ebf836e68eb8135951c915e9af356ee50c88badf3c4f7df0d43a42e45bdd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97293b448f1db66f8f63afff21b65817ff28f96d4481792ecc58b763bd21ac34"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ea30ae895729a2dc5892ac0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359652,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"This House stands adjourned until 1:30 p.m.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359652","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This House stands adjourned until 1:30 p.m.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7acbe1c0f17b96de73a3dbbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359653,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359653","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2e31992c1d5905083e02b3f5e715dd058122f8932ad4af7e1feb7a187996213"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0a130b43b14113139be6357","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359654,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"This House stands adjourned until 1:30 p.m. tomorrow.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359654","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This House stands adjourned until 1:30 p.m. tomorrow.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b10457a096aa595c4fb6470","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359655,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. members, as the House is aware, following the introduction, first reading and\n               printing of a private member's bill, the Chair undertakes an examination of each clause\n               of the bill to ensure its procedural admissibility. On Thursday, March 5, the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream introduced Bill M235 intituled, Drug Recovery and Community Safety Act. Clause 13\n               of the bill invokes section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, commonly\n               called the notwithstanding clause. The Chair will remind the House that Standing Order 76 provides: \"Any bill affecting\n               the constitution must be introduced by a member of the government or with the sanction\n               of the government.\" As noted in previous rulings by the Chair, this applies to private members' bills\n               as well. That touches upon the Provincial Constitution Act as well as the Constitution\n               Act, 1867 or the Constitution Act, 1982, being Canada's constitution. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is entrenched in the Constitution Act,\n               1982. A private members' bill that seeks to invoke the notwithstanding clause therefore\n               offends Standing Order 76. In consideration of the above, it is the ruling of the Chair that Bill M235 is not\n               in order. As such, the bill will be removed from the order paper. Pursuant to Standing\n               Order 27A(5), the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream is moved to the bottom of the list of precedents for consideration of private members'\n               business.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359655","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Hon. members, as the House is aware, following the introduction, first reading and\n               printing of a private member's bill, the Chair undertakes an examination of each clause\n               of the bill to ensure its procedural admissibility. On Thursday, March 5, the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream introduced Bill M235 intituled, Drug Recovery and Community Safety Act. Clause","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1182066b3ff6ca66fe52f4b9d56eea7950d11ac9ba957aa10215caf6c26dfc2a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f2f974558d66ccf0949236bf9dc00a5ad894225a3657378a57dfd9ff3ddd88c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6eab679a901ddfe203a8026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359656,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member for Esquimalt-Colwood, and the baby.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359656","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The member for Esquimalt-Colwood, and the baby.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df3c91a3548f46b262652bd6e0d82d87e457529ce06da0e40f2510a87824012e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-491fa8aacb3fca694260bb7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359658,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question before the House is the amendment to Motion 13 moved by the\n               Opposition House Leader.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359658","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Members, the question before the House is the amendment to Motion 13 moved by the\n               Opposition House Leader.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95c5b826ad68e49c024752535d2befa35b6d43a7cbe4de28d0f79359313172f7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3f35d2dfd416ee787865fb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414201,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Premier. That was a fitting tribute to a very extraordinary person\n               and a dear friend. Many of you may know that when I started my reconciliation project in the Parliament\n               a few years ago, he was one of the four advisors who accepted my request to be on\n               my council. He was an extraordinary person going out of his way, always willing So I, on behalf of all of us, am joining the Premier to send our condolences to the\n               family, and he will be missed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414201","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Premier. That was a fitting tribute to a very extraordinary person\n               and a dear friend. Many of you may know that when I started my reconciliation project in the Parliament\n               a few years ago, he was one of the four advisors who accepted my request to be on\n               my council. He was an extraordinary person going out of his way, always willing So I, o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7edcdeb475f854dc379413c142b03ecc3013462a99bd06bb5c54b329a5c34cae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f20acabcec5a0ec7c194b685","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414202,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414202","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3f7c417e81df091ce619c9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414203,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member, I would appreciate.... We are talking about places of public worship.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414203","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Member, I would appreciate.... We are talking about places of public worship.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-088ddd209d0d7d163174e4e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415697,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think we have recognized everybody sitting upstairs today. If not.... Member for Cowichan Valley.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415697","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think we have recognized everybody sitting upstairs today. If not.... Member for Cowichan Valley.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adoption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Audiovisual equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036296","label":"Military communications","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","label":"Adoption","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752302","label":"Audiovisual equipment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df30a8ebe648c6cd2bbe22e32fbc358e10087af85a2b3c0c9b2d3f817f7d7ad5","5bd7347980b07e56e2815975e8557bbcc10440fbaa7a051d92f3541eb4b2e85a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c1628480be85578b3af2d70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415698,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415698","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["080c19b215cd0220ae5e8eaff155b5a53e50b6d9bd31bcba9eabd336f1dcbf30"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4041536cec5a683aec9c182c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415699,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Members, it is on behalf of all of us that I rise today to express deepest condolences\n               to former Lieutenant Governor, the Hon. Janet Austin, who recently lost her dear husband,\n               Ashley Chester, a friend to many of us here and whose memorial service at Government\n               House earlier today several of us were privileged to attend. At the service, Ashley was remembered over and over again for his genuine interest\n               in people and his intellectual curiosity. He was known for his wit, quiet thoughtfulness\n               and creativity, and Her Honour perfectly summarized his extraordinary character by\n               describing him simply as a lovely man. Our deepest sympathies go out to his wife, the Hon. Janet Austin, his sister Carol\n               and all of those who loved him.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415699","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Hon. Members, it is on behalf of all of us that I rise today to express deepest condolences\n               to former Lieutenant Governor, the Hon. Janet Austin, who recently lost her dear husband,\n               Ashley Chester, a friend to many of us here and whose memorial service at Government\n               House earlier today several of us were privileged to attend. At the service, Ashley was ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5366b1292d8065fae0f258e3c0e2a6a4aa4f8aebb992be0a59bdd435179510b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05945c1a9f899f29a2486c2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720201,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Seeing no further speakers.... Is the member for Courtenay-Comox speaking on the bill?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720201","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Seeing no further speakers.... Is the member for Courtenay-Comox speaking on the bill?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e82abf77aea0e6462c71d3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720206,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, this is first reading of the bill. Division has been called.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720206","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Members, this is first reading of the bill. Division has been called.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb4c8b9c6b0273cd3edefcf4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720212,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720212","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf395d43389fa3dd5af9d84b5e46181503e2891ba6ed2275ecea511104133890"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af3af41d5692fa06bac6789f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720214,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you so much. On behalf of all the members, I welcome the many guests who have joined us today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720214","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you so much. On behalf of all the members, I welcome the many guests who have joined us today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","label":"Indigenous culture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a5c3a05b5844249ac0d99fa1297d0a004d64b91f1b474143e0374f1bb8bbe9c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f32268f2c0a166de12a781d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720215,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member, supplemental.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720215","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Member, supplemental.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02c2b77a3ba2e67b24806061ac80b8ad6d946842575bef1e6b7aabd14d1da82c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9aa17a5105cbc61b45370888","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720216,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720216","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Members, the question is the first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9815287de901c4c3545739da8ed99000cb7f48d04730ce424bb71ac893969525"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1abf6b19c5cb8df44bd21475","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720219,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"No, hold it. We're not there yet.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720219","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"No, hold it. We're not there yet.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7442b4d2a9621642c68a0de37d044730ee5d362d98ecc607f71b698571f35653"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab8077cc2a51fb28bb4ef87f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721280,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy birthday, Minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721280","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Happy birthday, Minister.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5eb00205a9b999e6f7c73c60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721281,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member for North Vancouver–Seymour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721281","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Member for North Vancouver–Seymour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f0f339cfec5651e29c6064f11ea1195296516d48a638da4047c39cba8a700ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-763b71b896e341d4162c9e77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721282,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"You'll want to seek leave.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721282","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You'll want to seek leave.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Heating","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","label":"Heating","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae88370924c222a806a49c031a2c64863c0c972f2be16f4688120e78cb9debbf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5a7358de4a10421ccde5d22","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721286,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members. Shhh. Member for Peace River North, participating remotely, the Chair would ask him to please remove his hat. Thank you, Member. The question is third reading of Bill 14, Forest Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721286","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Members. Shhh. Member for Peace River North, participating remotely, the Chair would ask him to please remove his hat. Thank you, Member. The question is third reading of Bill 14, Forest Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["13444a4fd3b5b3d23e086180b0388509cd386aac5c3494cef639069eceecd695"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82f7c5f4c353bf14f7e3e0f3be5a02f6e82dbea812565d85a2bd513d618f8102"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5fc0f153e316e10f6759b9e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721290,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill. Division has been called.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721290","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill. Division has been called.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adoption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","label":"Adoption","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bb05914f2356bb0046907c3f4b7c9466a4693a19a8a4e3fd1f2b430870dafa0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ffe715219e72652cfe0e6f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721291,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member, supplemental.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721291","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Member, supplemental.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bda21aba98b797d6495444a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721294,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Chair will ask the Member to save her space and adjourn the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721294","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Chair will ask the Member to save her space and adjourn the debate.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb29a561500b47ff79fe45dc3c84bc216ebe8716bbac41827494330b100a12a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adbd8b65c73cb0b2d2befe6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728894,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member, supplemental.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728894","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Member, supplemental.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82c0391e3a34c6eb24211be0a1a8d54d96ec90ca54e6ec275c3ccf0185f479e9","07daf2f6fa0ebc9d25775b31ff79adf450899c7f85233f9e6672c3be3ef44dbb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f266cecf3eb36bec0b927ea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728907,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Shhh. Members.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728907","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Shhh. Members.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5dfc6647fabf8bd46f5146dfaa8194444f68b7ed81ecc08f3955ccb3274eccec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-132841d2e57a0be7b7dc816b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728931,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Good afternoon, Members. I'm going to call just a very brief recess while we get our\n               teams in place for our estimates this afternoon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728931","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Good afternoon, Members. I'm going to call just a very brief recess while we get our\n               teams in place for our estimates this afternoon.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce8052d52ebfce6ec94ea3599011f60117bd518e4220a7c12ff567dcfea124bc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9de2e6154e59cbc63bd14df7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728932,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Members, the Chair is prepared to rule on the question of privilege raised by\n               the Member for Vancouver-Quilchena on Monday, April 27, which was taken under advisement. The Chair thanks the member for Vancouver-Quilchena for following the correct procedure, for raising a question of privilege and for\n               her submission on the matter. The member's allegations are serious and require careful\n               examination. In her submission, the member for Vancouver-Quilchena outlined that the Vancouver school board obstructed the member's ability to perform\n               her core constituency duty by cancelling, at the last minute, a confirmed booking\n               for a public town hall in a school facility. The member submitted that the decision of an administrative body The member submitted that the decision of an administrative body blocked her access\n               to constituents and, therefore, interfered with parliamentary functions and amounts\n               to breach of privilege. The Chair understands the importance of a member's representative duties and the frustration\n               that may arise when arrangements or engagements with constituents are disrupted. At the heart of the question of privilege raised by the member for Vancouver-Quilchena is the freedom from obstruction that extends to this House and its members. The scope\n               and application of this privilege have limitations. The Chair must examine whether\n               this privilege applies to the circumstances at hand. As noted in Parliamentary Practice in British Columbia , fifth edition on page 384: \"Parliamentary privilege is primarily, but not solely,\n               exercised in the context of parliamentary proceedings.\" Fundamentally, privilege is\n               essential to enabling members to carry out their parliamentary business as outlined\n               on page 392 of our procedural authority. Parliamentary Immunity in Canada , by Joseph Maingot, is regarded as one of the pre-eminent authorities on the application\n               of parliamentary privilege in our country. On pages 223 to 224, Maingot outlines that\n               to be constituted as a breach, an obstruction must be connected to a member's parliamentary\n               work, that is to say, connected with their duty to participate in parliamentary proceedings. Maingot also notes that while members can experience interference with their ability\n               to carry out their duties and responsibilities unattached to the work that happens\n               in this House or a committee thereof, \"such situations do not constitute a question\n               of privilege because they do not relate to the member's parliamentary work, but rather\n               to his or her constituency work or other work in his or her official capacity as a\n               member.\" The Chair appreciates that the circumstances are unfortunate. However, upon careful\n               review of the submission of the member for Vancouver-Quilchena and the procedural authorities, the Chair concludes that the scope of the freedom\n               from obstruction as a privilege attached to this House and its members does not extend\n               to the circumstances at hand. It is therefore the ruling of the Chair that a prima facie breach of privilege has\n               not occurred.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728932","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Hon. Members, the Chair is prepared to rule on the question of privilege raised by\n               the Member for Vancouver-Quilchena on Monday, April 27, which was taken under advisement. The Chair thanks the member for Vancouver-Quilchena for following the correct procedure, for raising a question of privilege and for\n               her submission on the matter. The member's allegations are serio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b20e77f29ea63df09084b2f4b65964d96aac59c3a71a8e9b928004e95d4109d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b94642a30323d975207836ac49ab73de294bc0cf8e5895697a51c013fd1bdd32"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72dd705e7047d05956f81ddf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728945,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member, supplemental.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728945","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Member, supplemental.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["171e02c29d006e88eeb7af23bb14ee698e10c0ace5445a14d887d601114fe8da"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de6533235b2f5f70870db167","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728946,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll call the committee to order. Recognizing the Minister of Health.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728946","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll call the committee to order. Recognizing the Minister of Health.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a09437aeea6e3dd71d91cbdb2e803115cd5414c8a66a806e3571f8e87eca766"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c12949474d66e4a2bedd41c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752193,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, according to the order paper, we will consider Bill M217, Dashboard Cameras\n               in Commercial Vehicles Act, as reported complete with amendment from the Select Standing\n               Committee on Private Bills and Private Member Bills.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752193","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Members, according to the order paper, we will consider Bill M217, Dashboard Cameras\n               in Commercial Vehicles Act, as reported complete with amendment from the Select Standing\n               Committee on Private Bills and Private Member Bills.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c679c4a4debad81ebceb05041681861e51cb2b4f0eb02977a5797c81478f4f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["193fb807ad48a1aa83708ffd10d7b3aadcd38d22884099a16a86cfb9dd507b67"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac95145898c5c58ac5e6f154","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752194,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I recognize other members, Juan De Fuca has one more introduction to make.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752194","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Before I recognize other members, Juan De Fuca has one more introduction to make.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","label":"Photography","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a00efad53af09c592102ecf772529d4c09cd06d1fe49df2d0cce6401e8bdba8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-28d396d85dce64413d5f9b10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752195,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Anyone else? Now is the chance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752195","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Anyone else? Now is the chance.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21090fa20834b240fb9e024e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752196,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, I'm going to just interrupt you for a moment. Recognizing the MLA from Burnaby\n               North.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752196","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Members, I'm going to just interrupt you for a moment. Recognizing the MLA from Burnaby\n               North.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8db2a30f65693aadab4af0bbec6e8edb4624edb7dc0e8222172b68352786fe72"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2878641310ea138e5f36a988","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752197,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I understand my CA, Gurvinder Hanjra, is also somewhere in the gallery. Is she's standing\n               up? She's the best.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752197","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I understand my CA, Gurvinder Hanjra, is also somewhere in the gallery. Is she's standing\n               up? She's the best.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9970cdb710317edeb9386cd4a61ba4a23120ef7054c3d56c299e04365aa297c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18c6d27f29478a434c48cc05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752198,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before we do the introductions, I want to say a few things. On behalf of all members, all of us, I want to start off this morning by recognizing\n               the Legislative Assembly staff from the Sergeant-at-Arms team, the Hansard team, the\n               Office of the Clerk and all staff throughout the building, many of whom took on additional\n               duties last night, for the exceptional professionalism and dedication they showed\n               last night on a very short notice. It takes the collaboration and expertise of several departments for this chamber to\n               function, and we owe them a debt of gratitude for the service they provided into the\n               early hours of this morning. So on behalf of all of us, I want to say thank you to all the staff. You are the best.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752198","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Before we do the introductions, I want to say a few things. On behalf of all members, all of us, I want to start off this morning by recognizing\n               the Legislative Assembly staff from the Sergeant-at-Arms team, the Hansard team, the\n               Office of the Clerk and all staff throughout the building, many of whom took on additional\n               duties last night, for the excepti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6eac19aa0c39bf7aa6fd526a18fe761ab7e188564ce6f2096bc70bc3cdd96ac9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f59cc885f0607eae9fecbdf0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752199,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Clerk. Sorry. Leader of the Third Party.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752199","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Madam Clerk. Sorry. Leader of the Third Party.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b4324ab88f9155acb267a755c7e62469fc8638bb19f3417dee2b88e9e7d46df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-482244e1208c6a1f499e55af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017200,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"The minister forgot to tell you that you will only get ice cream if you behave in\n               the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017200","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The minister forgot to tell you that you will only get ice cream if you behave in\n               the House.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ecb6c5bb503e755eb3975e35f9bb3ffaf48d0d75207f78c812ffc3b2318af94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a25f62e635b5494045151028","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017202,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Proceed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017202","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Proceed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2fcecc6cc13d649348182118c9d313f191f090234cdbf589ccb4007eeb0ba153"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4501b398feb2b4b5d33ca83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017203,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member for Langley-Abbotsford.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017203","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Member for Langley-Abbotsford.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bec56724adf6f9bba7fcefefdf4d2e7ad21d33cfcf8b80c8fcf3992f43cf24f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-daef832d078ee87ebfad906b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017207,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Minister of Water, Land and.... Resource Stewardship. It's a mouthful. It's such a mouthful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017207","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Minister of Water, Land and.... Resource Stewardship. It's a mouthful. It's such a mouthful.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d52f5e7cefb0cd24da5889abf3f5f8636d651d101b1df8c8b8543f045aa26f3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f8f5403d937a0f07085df03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017217,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017217","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Members, the question is first reading of the bill.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15f5786094a4d29b687159a340a391b14f3256b9250b87def0852edc9ce46be3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-050885c685a3a9ba90834dfb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036427,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"This House stands adjourned until 1:30 p.m.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036427","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This House stands adjourned until 1:30 p.m.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3c7b97ab030f83a238303cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036428,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Members, on Tuesday, May 19, the member for Skeena raised a point of order regarding\n               comments made by the Premier during oral question period earlier that day. The Government\n               House Leader made a submission on the point of order at the end of the sitting day\n               on Thursday, May 21. The Chair took the matter under advisement, has had an opportunity\n               to review the Hansard transcript and now is prepared to rule on the point of order. The member for Skeena submitted that the Premier misled the House through his comments.\n               As the Chair noted in a ruling delivered on April 20, such an allegation is extremely\n               serious, and the Chair must examine any evidence that proves that As the Chair noted in a ruling delivered on April 20, such an allegation is extremely\n               serious, and the Chair must examine any evidence that proves that the statement was\n               misleading, that establishes that the member — in this case, the Premier — making\n               the statement knew at the time that the statement was incorrect and that establishes\n               that the member intended to mislead the House in making the statement. Based on the submissions made to the Chair, that high threshold of evidence has not\n               been met in the matter at hand. At the heart of the matter, it is a dispute on the\n               characterization and interpretation of words spoken by the Premier, which are not,\n               by their nature, unparliamentary. The member for Skeena felt that those words were\n               a mischaracterization and took the opportunity to correct the record through her point\n               of order. The submissions of the member for Skeena and the Government House Leader point to\n               what appears to be a matter of debate, which is not for the Chair to wade into. The\n               Chair has no further remedy to offer and therefore deems the matter closed. As the House enters its final sitting week this spring, the Chair implores all members\n               to be mindful of the language they use in this House and to be respectful toward one\n               another in the course of debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036428","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Hon. Members, on Tuesday, May 19, the member for Skeena raised a point of order regarding\n               comments made by the Premier during oral question period earlier that day. The Government\n               House Leader made a submission on the point of order at the end of the sitting day\n               on Thursday, May 21. The Chair took the matter under advisement, has had an opportunity\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["431cec087be07371a2575a314647694540a597a63a2bad216acd6c31e5851adb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-381c036ee91463154481cf62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036429,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, I would like to make a statement, a statement about a person. That person\n               is in the House, and I want him to stand up. His name is Ray Robitaille. Yesterday we had an opportunity to welcome our incoming Sergeant-at-Arms, Jason Laidman.\n               Today we have an opportunity to pay tribute to our departing Sergeant-at-Arms, Ray\n               Robitaille. As Speaker, I have a unique vantage point into the operations of the Legislative Assembly.\n               Every day I see the hard work and dedication that goes into ensuring that all aspects\n               of operations run smoothly so that members can undertake their important duties. For\n               the past 41⁄2 years, I have witnessed Ray's commitment to this institution and to supporting members,\n               and I have been amazed by his visionary leadership, commitment to continuous improvement\n               and attentiveness to the staff he leads. The position of Sergeant-at-Arms predates British Columbia's entry into Confederation.\n               Ray stepped into the historic role in October 2021 after a tumultuous period, a period\n               that brought the position into the public spotlight in a most unfortunate way. I want\n               to particularly commend Ray for restoring credibility, honour, integrity and trust\n               to this position, and for demonstrating exemplary leadership, a commitment to excellence\n               and a dedication to service. Most members did not serve in this place at the time of Ray's appointment. It coincided\n               with a time when security and safety needs and expectations started to shift significantly.\n               I cannot begin to list the reforms and transformations in services and service delivery\n               that were implemented under Ray's leadership in response to these rapidly evolving\n               expectations and challenges. I will summarize by saying that this transition was to\n               the benefit of the Legislative Assembly and that we were extremely fortunate to benefit\n               from Ray's leadership during his tenure. Ray, your entire adult life is a testament to a deep commitment to service, whether\n               in the Canadian Armed Forces, the Calgary police service or the Legislative Assembly\n               of British Columbia. I hope that you will spend the next chapter enjoying retirement\n               and doing the things that bring you joy, surrounded by your loved ones. I trust that members will take the opportunity to say a personal thank-you over the\n               lunch hour in the Legislative Library. In the meantime, on behalf of all of us, I want to say thank you, Ray, for everything\n               you have done for this institution. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036429","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Members, I would like to make a statement, a statement about a person. That person\n               is in the House, and I want him to stand up. His name is Ray Robitaille. Yesterday we had an opportunity to welcome our incoming Sergeant-at-Arms, Jason Laidman.\n               Today we have an opportunity to pay tribute to our departing Sergeant-at-Arms, Ray\n               Robitaille. As Speaker, I h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752433","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752433","label":"Safety equipment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aa6a6abab32e35936cbe7ca1ed2fc83d4bac398837492abfcd7178e2ff35d769","35bd1e045be885ab84a6c1595888b57fa0a96921eb9d8a08c0020784402dda28"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a6f6ac439066cba450fa0534a897f173ce858ce968faa748012e1c27beb6d3f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f702d4c40896ca9477b2314","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036430,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Members. This morning a division was requested on the amendment by the\n               Minister of Citizens' Services to clause 13 of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act of 2026. Pursuant to the motion adopted on May 19, 2026, with respect to the Standing Order 16(4), the division will now take place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036430","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Members. This morning a division was requested on the amendment by the\n               Minister of Citizens' Services to clause 13 of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act of 2026. Pursuant to the motion adopted on May 19, 2026, with respect to the Standing Order 16(4), the division will now take place.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd35a9bf205ee615b9d433eb2cb7db1b61e0c535f95605dff6439c9c9a790096"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0182fde0aa6e034b4b5a2b5d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036431,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Member for Kootenay-Rockies.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036431","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Member for Kootenay-Rockies.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7ba5d0eede7a8343e356b63075d073ad01e4c7c591bf79a4f13074738f8d85e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b1afbd3af602cb1ae454dbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036432,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, it's the last day of the school. Anyone else want to introduce anybody? Now's\n               your chance. Or we can introduce each other. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036432","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Members, it's the last day of the school. Anyone else want to introduce anybody? Now's\n               your chance. Or we can introduce each other. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725906","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034999","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical appliances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034611","label":"Electronic equipment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034999","label":"Electrical appliances","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725906","label":"Electronics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af13380d87db53407735389fd21fe46ff355396dac59a0f9c2873381f869a6e0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e38926f92a177c526ce796f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036433,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Raj Chouhan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Members, you heard the motion. It's the third reading of Bill 20. Division has been called.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036433","member_id":"bc-mla-16","member_name":"Raj Chouhan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Members, you heard the motion. It's the third reading of Bill 20. Division has been called.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["719339b133f64a33e1e37f6bddc3893e093995e65cc874790eaf2a10434269fd","46d7f2c606b727d9a98e0f24043940c8feac4a882bb0406810b66daf628d516d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a20ec3b9373afdfe786fc43f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316828,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in support of Budget 2026, and I'd also like to acknowledge the lək̓wəŋən\n               People, the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations, upon whose territory we are gathered\n               today, and to thank them for sharing these lands. Like my colleagues who have spoken before, my heart goes out to everyone in Tumbler\n               Ridge, especially those families who have lost their loved ones. My thoughts are with\n               the entire community that has experienced such devastating tragedies. We are grateful\n               to the police and the school staff who acted quickly to protect students the best\n               they could. About Budget 2026. In a world of uncertainty now, Budget 2026 makes careful choices\n               to protect what matters most and to secure B.C.'s future. For this, I'd like to thank\n               the Minister of Finance for her diligent and hard work in Budget 2026. It's not an easy task. Over the last eight years, we have built the foundation for a strong province. Hospitals,\n               schools, roads, transit, housing and clean electricity are being delivered to support\n               communities and good jobs across British Columbia. We made these investments while\n               guiding people and businesses through extraordinary challenges: a global pandemic,\n               devastating floods and wildfires and now direct attack on our economy and sovereignty\n               by our neighbour to the south. We entered this period from a position of strength, though. Our economy stayed resilient\n               with a low debt-to-GDP ratio that gave B.C. the capacity to respond when it mattered most. That work is making a difference. Major job-creating projects are moving forward.\n               More family doctors are practicing in B.C. than ever before. Rents and prices are\n               coming down from their peaks. Everyday costs for British Columbians are eased through the B.C. family benefit, more affordable child care and lower car insurance rates. This budget defends\n               those gains. But we are also facing a tough reality ahead. Global uncertainty is slowing growth\n               everywhere. High cost, global instability and volatile commodity prices are putting pressure on public finances. We have to be realistic and\n               disciplined about the choices ahead. Budget 2026 makes disciplined choices to protect what matters most. Our priorities\n               are clear: protecting core public services like health care and education; keeping\n               B.C. to be one of the lowest-taxed provinces for working families; and reducing the\n               deficit over time, doing it responsibly. To achieve this, we are taking three key steps: make the public sector smaller and\n               more efficient, so that more dollars reach the front lines; pace infrastructure project\n               carefully, delivering them efficiently without driving up costs; and generate new\n               revenue, while taking action to grow the economy and secure the long-term impact of\n               major projects. At the same time, we continue to invest in B.C.'s future, doubling trades training,\n               supporting major job-creating projects, and ensuring families and communities benefit\n               from what we have built. Housing has always been a top priority for our government, and we have been very clear\n               about that. Over the past eight years, we have introduced a number of incentives to\n               build housing, and we'll continue to address the housing crisis in B.C. Through Budget\n               2026, our government is adjusting the pace of some housing investments. This includes\n               reallocating nearly $1.4 billion across the fiscal plan, while maintaining government's\n               overall unit targets over a longer period of time. Of this, government is reinvesting over $900 million to support demand for existing\n               housing services and programs, including increased funding for non-profit housing\n               operators, assisted-living supports for seniors and people with disabilities, and\n               supporting thousands of new below-market homes through the attainable housing initiative\n               partnership with the xwməθkwəy̓əm, Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ Nations. Even as the pace of housing investment is being adjusted, capital investment in housing\n               remains at a historically high level. We're still investing heavily in new housing\n               and increasing funding for existing housing operations. In fact, Budget 2026 housing\n               investments are nearly five times what they were in 2016, when the opposition was\n               in power. This demonstrates our continued commitment to delivering the homes that\n               people need. The facts are that since 2017 the province has delivered, or is in the process of\n               delivering, more than 95,000 homes in communities throughout B.C. For example, in\n               my riding of Vancouver-Fraserview, we have completed 600 new housing units, with 272 units that are ongoing. Because\n               of the new supply — not just because of that, of course — the average asking rent\n               has fallen 4.7 percent, compared to this time last year. We are also taking care of renters. Since 2017, when we took power, the province has\n               taken other actions to help strengthen supports for renters, with the renters tax\n               credit — which provides $400 per year to low- and moderate-income renters, individuals\n               and families; and tying the annual allowable rent increase to inflation — at 2.3 percent\n               for this year, 2026, which is down from last year's allowable increase of 3 percent.\n               Increasing rental supply through actions like this will help rein in the rents. Also, we did this by implementing the speculation and vacancy tax — which is a tax\n               to encourage people renting out their homes; it's not to punish property owners —\n               protecting tenants by deterring and preventing bad-faith evictions and reducing wait\n               times for tenancy-dispute hearings by two-thirds in the last three years. Our actions\n               strike a balance between protecting renters from increased living costs and ensuring\n               that landlords can confidently rent their units, keeping rental units on the market\n               for years to come. We also devote a lot of effort in terms of seniors care. My riding of Vancouver-Fraserview has the highest number of seniors living in the city of Vancouver. Seniors, of course,\n               comprise 20 percent of our population in B.C. They helped build B.C. to what it is\n               today. So it's certainly important that we look after our seniors. We are continuing\n               to invest in services and supports for seniors through Budget 2026, bringing more\n               than 5,000 care home workers This way, strengthening the workforce and promoting high quality and reliable care\n               for seniors.... Because it's not just bricks and mortar that help seniors, it's actually\n               the people who take care of them. And in order to achieve the standard that we set\n               out, which is 3.36 hours per person per week, we need to have care workers with the\n               skill and the commitment to their job. We have also completed five long-term-care facilities in communities across B.C. and\n               in Nanaimo, Colwood, Vancouver, Richmond and Cranbrook. And we have devoted $35 million\n               over three years for Independent Living British Columbia. This funding will continue\n               to support rental housing and services to low- and moderate-income seniors and people\n               with disabilities who require some assistance to live independently. We have secured $447 million from the federal government to support health care for\n               seniors including treating complex conditions outside of hospitals and improving the\n               quality and safety of long-term-care facilities. The province is committed to expanding\n               long-term care availability to meet the needs of the aging population. In fact our\n               capital plan maintains construction of over 1,100 long-term care beds, an important\n               first step in addressing the current need, but we also must build long-term-care beds\n               in a financially sustainable manner. As you have heard today during question period, the Minister for Infrastructure has\n               been reviewing long-term care construction and exploring options to ensure that we\n               are best positioned to meet the needs of B.C.'s seniors and their families. In order\n               to do that, I think.... As an engineer, I'm keenly aware of that our construction industry\n               is very important to the economy of British Columbia. It comprises of 15 to 20 percent\n               of our GDP. So we have been devoting a lot of effort into skills training in this\n               budget so that we could not only build housing but we could also build major projects\n               which is important for trade diversification and bringing revenue for the province. Budget 2026 was created at the time of heightened economic risk with global markets\n               and trade relationship changing, and we must chart a path forward to secure our economic\n               future. The landmark investment in trades training ensures B.C. has a skilled workforce\n               needed to deliver on our economic priorities from housing and infrastructure to clean\n               energy and emerging technologies. Our effort to increase apprenticeships is working. In 2024-25 nearly 17,000 people\n               registered as apprentices, bringing the total number of apprentices in B.C. to nearly\n               50,000, the highest in our province's history. And in trades training, we are working\n               with SkilledTradesBC and B.C. Building Trades as well as post-secondary institutions,\n               industry and trainers to strengthen the trade system by expanding access to trades\n               training and helping employers access the skill force they need. Increasing per-seat funding to stabilize the trades training system, reducing long\n               wait-lists for critical industrial trade, ensuring fast access to training, continuing\n               to implement skilled trades certification, beginning with crane operator. That's a\n               focus of our industrial safety program, the crane operators. Ensuring workers can\n               move easily between the industry as the opportunity evolves. You see that we are working very hard with this B.C. Budget 2026, and it's not an\n               easy task. Like I said, it's serious work and in serious times. We are focused on\n               what matters most, protecting services, keeping taxes low for working families and\n               strengthening B.C. finances for the long term.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316828","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise to speak in support of Budget 2026, and I'd also like to acknowledge the lək̓wəŋən\n               People, the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations, upon whose territory we are gathered\n               today, and to thank them for sharing these lands. Like my colleagues who have spoken before, my heart goes out to everyone in Tumbler\n               Ridge, especially those families who have lo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e7794cb24e8f3202bb9a9ed7e2bd3c0e9b7ae9f01d7b75136455900fbe1570d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["412fcc6be613bf72f50b7b10eedc9334702fbd9c85c4adaf5d3eed347edd3514"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f8a3bbc69a76f6437f571c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359659,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last Friday I was invited to speak to a group of grade 4 and grade 5 students in my\n               riding of Vancouver-Fraserview. They wanted to know how governments work. I began by telling them that there are three\n               levels of government and we are like a big family. I said the federal government is\n               the grandparents, the provincial government the parents, and the city government are\n               kids like you. The city government has a limited amount of money but manages to have fun, like you\n               kids. They build ice rinks, swimming pools, libraries and parks. They sponsor street\n               festivals and sporting events so you kids can have a good time. Now the provincial government has more money but has more responsibility that costs\n               a lot of money, like making sure you're not sick, you can go to school or ride the\n               buses, SkyTrain and the ferries when you need. The federal government is responsible for dealing with foreign countries, our armed\n               forces and making criminal laws, and has the most money because it owns a bank that can print the money. The provincial government, like many parents, would try to get more money from grandparents,\n               the federal government. However, not unlike some grandparents, the federal government\n               plays favourite sometimes when giving out money to the provinces. Then came the question period. For example, what does the opposition do? I said the opposition is there to ask hard questions of the government. But sometimes they get carried away and will not listen, not unlike you kids sometimes. What do the Clerks do? I said the Clerks are really nice people who listen and write\n               down everything that the MLAs said, but seldom say a word themselves. And last question, what about the Speaker? The Speaker is an MLA who sits in the big\n               chair at the front of the House to make sure MLAs don't say bad things about each\n               other, like your teacher. On that happy note, my visit ended.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359659","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Last Friday I was invited to speak to a group of grade 4 and grade 5 students in my\n               riding of Vancouver-Fraserview. They wanted to know how governments work. I began by telling them that there are three\n               levels of government and we are like a big family. I said the federal government is\n               the grandparents, the provincial government the parents, and the cit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b36b3f706f402b3c6facd3cf0552f10749400e0e9799dcea3ba7502e4e910857"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["018aae353457bba5f979d16c154e69547fe86196dcdc444682dbc4572b981d37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed3972a8384cf960d39cbbb3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359660,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in support of Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. As the Minister of Citizens' Services said, for over 30 years, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act — or known as FOIPPA, for short — has played an important role in These principles remain unchanged. What has changed is technology and how people interact\n               with government and how government must work if it is to meet modern expectations\n               and maintain people's trust. I'd like to thank the member for Saanich North and the Islands for going into the details of this, the history of this bill. But one thing about\n               this amendment act: it's not about fees. Fees that we charge.... It's in line with other\n               jurisdictions in Canada. The people who are seeking personal information do not pay\n               a fee. For example, former children in government care, when they ask for information,\n               do not pay a fee. Also, as the member said, we have increased proactive disclosure so that the number\n               of requests for information has remained the same. It's just that people are now more\n               targeted when they want to get information. I think that's certainly very important. This amendment is not about fees. We also have found that the fees did not stop people\n               seeking information, and the number of requests remained about the same before and\n               after the fees were enacted. So it's not about the fees. Of course, opposition members are saying that this amendment will disadvantage rural\n               British Columbians. This is, again, not true. This amendment is a direct response to requests made by the FOIPPA special committee,\n               and the ministry has consulted extensively with the Office of the Information and\n               Privacy Commissioner. The amendment process has been transparent and open. As a side note, the Ministry of Citizens' Services, which is responsible for Bill\n               9, has a mandate to serve all British Columbians equally. For example, the ministry\n               has 64 Service B.C. offices to serve the province, especially in rural B.C. It also\n               has a mobile van that can be dispatched to remote communities, and the van is very\n               useful during emergency situations such as fires and floods when people have fled\n               their homes without their government documentation such as drivers' licences and B.C.\n               Service Cards. These people can get their documents replaced at the mobile van. These are all the good works that the ministry is doing. The ministry also embarked\n               on an important program in rural and remote communities, and the program is called\n               Connecting Communities B.C. The goal is to provide broadband internet access to all\n               communities in B.C. by the year 2030, in cooperation with the federal government. Let's talk about Bill 9. The Bill 9 amendments to the B.C. Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Act will improve the experience of people using government\n               services and allow the new Connected Services B.C. system to improve digital service\n               delivery for people and businesses. This makes available more complete digital services\n               for people using their B.C. Service Cards. What are the new FOIPPA amendments? The proposed amendments to FOIPPA are grouped\n               into three categories. First is to enable the delivery of connected services, like\n               connected B.C., which I just mentioned, and also to improve FOI efficiencies. Lastly,\n               to deal with miscellaneous issues and procedure clarifications. I'll talk about the first two. Regarding Connected Services, it will help streamline\n               information-sharing and create the ability to issue directions and standards with\n               the goal of providing applicants with a one-stop-shop approach to getting the information\n               they need. Second is about improving FOI efficiencies. The amendments are to improve process\n               efficiency and transparency for applicants and to enable public bodies to better manage\n               the Second is about improving FOI efficiencies. The amendments are to improve process\n               efficiency and transparency for applicants and to enable public bodies to better manage\n               the administrative workload associated with processing FOI requests. These amendments,\n               together with the connecting community B.C. that I mentioned earlier, reinforces our\n               government's commitment to strengthen connected digital services for British Columbians,\n               especially in rural B.C. as well as improve FOI efficiency and service delivery. That\n               is exactly what we want to accomplish. This is what the member from Saanich has said,\n               that we are using technology. More on connected services. The provisions in this bill will help enable government\n               to work as one unified system, providing people with simpler, more predictable and\n               more streamlined services. These amendments will support the delivery of connected\n               digital services across government by enabling information to flow within government,\n               provided we have the people's permission. The proposed amendments will allow public bodies to securely and responsibly share\n               information with appropriate safeguards, so that services can be delivered in a more\n               seamless, centralized gateway that gives people more control over how their information\n               is shared. People repeatedly giving the same information across government program\n               areas.... These changes will enable better information flow between programs and ministry\n               while protecting people's privacy. So there are some concerns that were expressed about connected Service B.C., where\n               they would create a centralized data system with large amounts of personal data. The\n               answer to that is no. This is not the case. Connected services are content to improve\n               service delivery by ensuring information is appropriately shared across program area\n               using existing systems. The connected services model is designed to enable secure sharing of information between\n               public bodies, but it does not consolidate all personal information into one central\n               registry. Public bodies will be able to securely share information in ways that better\n               reflect how people interact with government — not by department, but by need. This\n               will reduce the personal information collected by government over all programs and\n               services. Personal information will continue to be secure even when parts of the services\n               are managed by different programs or ministries. In addition, the amendments require that the Office of the Information and Privacy\n               Commissioner be notified when a connected service provider is established and that\n               the office can assess the privacy impact at the commissioner's office's discretion. More about freedom of information. The goal is to increase efficiency so we can actually\n               reply to requests much quicker, but the complexity and the volume of FOI requests\n               has grown, and public bodies across the province, from ministries to school districts,\n               municipalities and health authorities, are struggling under the administrative pressure\n               of maintaining timely and equitable access for all FOI applicants. These amendments will help with administrative inefficiency while maintaining people's\n               right to information access. These amendments are intended to make the FOI process\n               more transparent and workable for everyone involved. They will allow public bodies\n               to better communicate with applicants, including seeking clarification when a request\n               is unclear so that people will see the information they're looking for. So right now, people who requested information and they sent their information to\n               the ministry, but the ministry has to find that information.... Sometimes, because the\n               applicant was unclear on what they what they want to get, the ministry has to get\n               back to the applicant. That takes a lot of time, and we would like to improve on that\n               procedure. One example of increasing efficiency is minimizing duplicate disclosure processes.\n               Though time isn't getting wasted processing records, they're already being released\n               through a different process like legal discovery. Enabling the proactive release of\n               information to individuals who are seeking their own personal Enabling the proactive release of information to individuals who are seeking their\n               own personal information without always needing them to go through a formal FOI process.\n               And that's really what's happening in the MCFD ministry for example, the Ministry\n               of Children and Family Development. We are trying to resolve that issue. This will\n               improve the access for applicants, especially the former children in government care,\n               which I already mentioned. This will take pressure off the system, as currently 60 percent of the FOI applications\n               are for personal information. Most of that information is in paper form, making the\n               FOI process very challenging. Improvements in this area will free-up resources so\n               that we can respond to FOI requests faster. I'll close by reiterating my support for Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendment Act, because the amendment will improve the experience of people\n               using government services, improve digital service delivery for people and businesses,\n               and improve FOI efficiency.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359660","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to speak in support of Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. As the Minister of Citizens' Services said, for over 30 years, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act — or known as FOIPPA, for short — has played an important role in These principles remain unchanged. What has changed is technology and how people interact\n               with go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6cfd07a0066249d69b70d4adccea640b2dd1b52ca922b88c83cbb700443b18d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e59a4757002b94c68af1cbd0117a121ed70bc47b99971d2152fc2ea374ef2f6b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d327bb36fc5ef3c000076d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415700,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last week the Vancouver Chinatown community came together to celebrate the life of\n               Harold Johnson, who worked in Chinatown as a security guard for two decades, helping\n               to keep the neighbourhood safe. This gathering meant a great deal to Harold's wife,\n               Brandy, and to the Chinatown community to see so many people gathered to celebrate\n               his life. Harold was more than a security guard. His connection to the community went far beyond\n               his job. He was a constant presence, a familiar face and a source of comfort for many\n               people in Chinatown. Day after day, year after year, he walked the streets of Chinatown,\n               not just doing his job but truly caring for the people and businesses that make up\n               this community. Harold would stop in to visit the merchant shops. He never rushed those moments. He\n               would check in to ask how they were doing and genuinely listen. It wasn't just about\n               safety. It was about connection. It was about making sure people felt seen and supported. But what truly set Harold apart was how he treated people. Part of his job often meant\n               asking people sleeping in doorways or storefronts to move along so businesses could\n               open. That could easily have been confrontational, but Harold never treated people\n               like they were a problem. He treated them like human beings, with patience, with respect\n               and with dignity. Even in difficult situations, Harold understood that the people\n               he encountered were still part of the same community. That compassion is something\n               many people remember. Four years ago, Harold was brutally attacked while patrolling in Chinatown. He suffered\n               a broken nose, a broken cheekbone, a black eye and head trauma. Despite this attack,\n               Harold returned to work, serving the community he loved until his retirement. The merchants and residents of Chinatown are deeply thankful for Harold's years of\n               service, but even more for his kindness, his presence and his unwavering care for\n               the community. Harold, you will be missed but never forgotten. Let's give a big clap to Harold for his community service.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415700","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Last week the Vancouver Chinatown community came together to celebrate the life of\n               Harold Johnson, who worked in Chinatown as a security guard for two decades, helping\n               to keep the neighbourhood safe. This gathering meant a great deal to Harold's wife,\n               Brandy, and to the Chinatown community to see so many people gathered to celebrate\n               his l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1bb5de6a1b39855154d67f207da2290b5776e5fc7d8b07ac0b4afe955692894e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da079bc0e0f98fbb844cadce0ba5c7143815f512bd39fedee4e1ad1ca54cffc8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a76b966cc14363f9d8cdc39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721302,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today marks the 56th anniversary of Earth Day, which is especially significant because\n               the Artemis moon mission just returned to Earth 12 days ago and reminded us once again\n               that the Earth is not flat and that there is only one Earth. Having one Earth is becoming quite a challenge, because if everyone in the world lives\n               like Vancouver, we need three Earths. Since we only have one Earth, and until we get\n               to Mars, we need to love Earth and cherish it. So let's celebrate Earth Day in my riding of Vancouver-Fraserview at Everett Crowley Park this coming Saturday, April 25. Vancouver's longest standing annual Earth Day\n               celebration, Earthfest is organized by the Everett Crowley Park Committee within the\n               Champlain Heights Community Association in my constituency. It is a local group of volunteer environmental\n               stewards who have tended to Everett Crowley Park since 1985. I would like to give recognition to this group of passionate residents who advocate\n               for and implement the Champlain Heights community vision for Everett Crowley Park as an urban wilderness. They work closely\n               with the three host First Nations, the Vancouver park board, local residents and NGOs\n               to ensure that their work is inclusive and collaborative and that it leads to a cohesive\n               community with a lasting connection to the park and the land. Thanks to the tireless efforts of the committee, Everett Crowley Park has come a long\n               way from being a former city garbage dump to a beloved space for many in the Vancouver-Fraserview community. There's lush greenery, a duck pond, many varieties of wildlife and even\n               off-leash dog trails. There is something to enjoy for everyone. I invite all of you to join me at the annual Earthfest taking place in Everett Crowley\n               Park this Saturday, April 25, from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721302","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today marks the 56th anniversary of Earth Day, which is especially significant because\n               the Artemis moon mission just returned to Earth 12 days ago and reminded us once again\n               that the Earth is not flat and that there is only one Earth. Having one Earth is becoming quite a challenge, because if everyone in the world lives\n               like Vancouver, we need three Ear","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07aefa83631ecc27cc0231edcb82c74bdb2e3a99268e67eabf98656a8e27bb4f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ded4d1131d2e7e1f914d886a3dc0f4c414e571e543a9361a43bb7bc1f2b11adb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a97970ae60b2e3371386aa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752200,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mondays are usually slow, but today is different. Today we celebrate Music Monday,\n               a celebration of the power of music and the role it plays in connecting and strengthening\n               our communities. Music Monday was created to highlight how music brings people together and how that\n               connection begins in our schools. Throughout British Columbia and across the country,\n               Music Monday is observed in classrooms, school assemblies, group concerts, community\n               bands and choirs with special events that unite students, educators, families and\n               local communities through music. In our schools, music education offers far more than performance skills. It plays\n               a vital role in the holistic development of children and youth, nurturing creativity,\n               discipline and emotional expression. Through learning an instrument, singing in a\n               choir or engaging in musical composition, students develop skills that extend far\n               beyond the classroom. Studies have shown that music education can improve academic performance and support\n               mental well-being, making it a powerful tool for both personal and educational growth.\n               It provides students with a means to connect with their heritage, explore diverse\n               traditions, and express their unique identities. This is why music continues to be\n               core learning in B.C.'s arts education curriculum This is why music continues to be core learning in B.C.'s arts education curriculum.\n               From kindergarten to grade 12, students have the opportunity to learn about music,\n               whether in younger years where students can learn through purposeful play, or as they\n               get older and take musical theatre or choir. All students can be artists. B.C.'s curriculum supports the notion that all students, in becoming educated citizens,\n               can develop an artistic mindset in all aspects of their daily life, both during and\n               beyond their school years. On Music Monday, we celebrate the teachers, students, volunteers\n               and community partners who make music education possible and who ensure that music\n               remains a vibrant part of learning and community life.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752200","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mondays are usually slow, but today is different. Today we celebrate Music Monday,\n               a celebration of the power of music and the role it plays in connecting and strengthening\n               our communities. Music Monday was created to highlight how music brings people together and how that\n               connection begins in our schools. Throughout British Columbia and across the coun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d8e55a009d59455e7322f3ec25a800384c45d930d528c933b20386fe19a1b37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac5002724532882a7c079f9f54ac6d53eb282b95baf5d1de5506cc4f1caa885b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa0e6af68d4dd135e881a9ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752201,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"May is Child Care Month and a time to celebrate the important role child care plays\n               in the lives of children and the families in our communities and in our economy. Last November, Salmon Stone Childcare Centre, in my writing of Vancouver-Fraserview,\n               welcomed children and families to this brand-new child care facility. Operated by\n               the South Vancouver Neighbourhood House, this child care centre provides 49 new spaces\n               for infants to five-year-olds. This facility will also offer a family drop-in program,\n               which is a play-based learning opportunity for children. The Salmon Stone Childcare Centre was jointly funded by our government and the city\n               of Vancouver. Our provincial government contributed $6.2 million to this project,\n               a very significant investment to bring necessary child care services to residents. Located in the growing River District neighbourhood in southeast Vancouver, Salmon\n               Stone Childcare is literally a stone's throw away from the Fraser River and will be\n               one of the only active child care facilities in the community, providing much-needed\n               access to affordable child care in the area. The name Salmon Stone came from Geraldine Lalande, a member of the Indigenous council\n               of the Neighbourhood House. Salmon Stone signifies life, rebirth and represents determination,\n               strength, protection and courage. The child care centre will be hosting its grand opening next Saturday, May 16, during\n               Child Care Month. I welcome you all to join South Vancouver Neighbourhood House, the\n               city of Vancouver and the residents of Vancouver-Fraserview in celebration of this\n               opening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752201","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"May is Child Care Month and a time to celebrate the important role child care plays\n               in the lives of children and the families in our communities and in our economy. Last November, Salmon Stone Childcare Centre, in my writing of Vancouver-Fraserview,\n               welcomed children and families to this brand-new child care facility. Operated by\n               the South Vancouver Nei","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aad8f28831703ba0b31b3f172a5d841ab452cfa559f1c2496148a5dbc251e6d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d95da0c1a2eabc900ed7847ec617c0b5c756be10b570fec3602a306999af819"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cabbe9065bbfec0afc138bf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017222,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Chow","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Happy birthday, Mom. I love you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017222","member_id":"bc-mla-17","member_name":"George Chow","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Happy birthday, Mom. I love you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Multiculturalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","label":"Multiculturalism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d28d9ebeec5f137139d36e011ce35dabd05d921485bbbf22183b121dbec18c72"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a891d17a6dbdd7c5914647ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720073,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brittny Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call second reading on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 15, Environmental Assessment\n               Amendment Act. In the Birch Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 11, Residential Tenancy Act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720073","member_id":"bc-mla-2","member_name":"Brittny Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call second reading on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 15, Environmental Assessment\n               Amendment Act. In the Birch Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 11, Residential Tenancy Act.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b31f6493bd479083de0a54fb631de4f7ef4d104b54dfe9b70a5de1377f63ec2d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["075450cf5f4cd4ce5900e23974db0972207985a95bb68660368ccc105c6b754a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06ecb1a1ae438fc6c47670b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728719,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brittny Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this House, I call Committee of Supply with the Ministry of Health. In the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of Supply with the Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals, followed by Labour.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728719","member_id":"bc-mla-2","member_name":"Brittny Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this House, I call Committee of Supply with the Ministry of Health. In the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of Supply with the Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals, followed by Labour.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b2a2d64295883a549a7abb3ef1959e2ac586ca3231e3d3770c867a567fe8841"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-765151e1e8aea3e7278cb3f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317127,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd just say, with respect to the last aspect of the question — I know my colleague,\n               on supplementary, would want to respond to the first aspect of the question — this\n               is just not the case. In fact, the government has got rid of those various subsidies\n               the member talks about. We did so in the period when we were working on a confidence\n               and supply agreement with the Green Party. So he will well know this. What we're seeing in British Columbia is, in fact — and this is a critical aspect\n               — the growth of natural resource ministries through the extraordinary work of the\n               minister responsible for mining, tripling mining revenues in the period that the budget\n               addresses, which is, I think, good news for everyone, including for the very social\n               programs he talks about. The increases in revenues coming to government, for example, from natural gas, because\n               we're upgrading the value of that gas, the work that we're doing across British Columbia\n               in expanding renewables — all of this benefits the provincial economy, because we\n               need to grow the provincial economy, and we are doing exactly that. The reason we're doing it that's, at least for me, the most important is to support\n               the very social programs the member is talking about — supporting the health care\n               system, supporting the education system, supporting the reduction of inequality across\n               things.... And the record of the government on those questions. a lot of which were done in alliance\n               with the B.C. Green Party, is outstanding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317127","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'd just say, with respect to the last aspect of the question — I know my colleague,\n               on supplementary, would want to respond to the first aspect of the question — this\n               is just not the case. In fact, the government has got rid of those various subsidies\n               the member talks about. We did so in the period when we were working on a confidence\n               an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b214b21e7811a437d3a32eebcb8755e7001481720be7d1a9c82f032a6b60717"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["555b84242bf986b8f8fc7676a45115f86ed959a472799cbfc291d590d0ba7767"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ce9528bb61ec36f7fd13404","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317128,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour to rise in this session of the Legislature, as I have in many before,\n               and represent the people of Vancouver-Renfrew, who every day surprise me and impress me with their entrepreneurship, with their\n               generosity to their fellow citizens, to the wonderful work that's done in our public\n               schools, the wonderful work that's done in schools such as St. Mary's, which are independent\n               schools that are deeply embedded in the community. The work done.... I think there are more health care workers, health care assistants\n               who live in Vancouver-Kingsway than almost any other community. During the COVID-19\n               pandemic, I understood and saw, when they came back to work — working morning shifts\n               from eight to four, working four to midnight, working midnight to eight — and would\n               come back at the Joyce Street SkyTrain station, the contribution they had made. They\n               went to work in a time of uncertainty to help their fellow citizens. I am so proud to represent the people of Vancouver-Renfrew, and it's with that in mind, since some of those people have suffered an immense\n               tragedy this year — we think back to April 26 of last year and the Lapu-Lapu tragedy\n               — that I want to reflect briefly on the events that occurred in Tumbler Ridge. I think\n               it's impossible for people to grasp the extent of the tragedy, and I think it's important\n               to recognize, even members of the House to recognize, the importance of standing together\n               in these moments. I know a little bit about this. Members of my family have died in two separate mass\n               murders over time. June 23rd, 1984 — you don't forget these days, you know — was the\n               Air India bombing. December 21, 1988: the Lockerbie bombing. We remember who they\n               were — Umar Jethwa, Zebunnisa Jethwa, Peter Dix — and what they meant to their families and what they meant to their communities, and\n               it never gets better. It gets longer ago, but it never gets better. The only thing I would say to people in Tumbler Ridge is that we will be there for you. Members of this House will be there for you. I'll\n               be there for you. I want to express my appreciation to my colleague from Peace River South who, I think, demonstrated real courage and determination in this I want to express my appreciation to my colleague from Peace River South, who has,\n               I think, demonstrated real courage and determination in this difficult moment. It's\n               hard to be with people in this moment. It's exhausting to be with people in this moment. I just want to say, in the prospect of hope, that when the bombing occurred in Air\n               India, Irfan Jethwa, who was the only son, lost both his parents. They were both doctors,\n               and he had a certain kind of life in mind and possible to him. He survived that and\n               a lot in between. He's now in his 40s. He has children of his own, and he is a generous, wonderful person.\n               There is hope in those moments. You don't get over this, but there's hope in those moments, and so we think today\n               of the people of Tumbler Ridge and what they've been through. I want to talk a little bit about the budget in this moment as well, because these\n               are challenging times in our world. Sometimes they get expressed in this way and the\n               ways we've seen, and we are able to support each other. They are very challenging\n               times, and this tests us. I believe this budget and our efforts are worthy of that\n               moment. I believe that. We have the actions of the U.S. President and the U.S. government really breaking\n               a relationship with Canada that existed all the way back to the Ogdensburg Agreement\n               in the early 1940s, through free trade agreements at Auto Pacts and the work we did\n               together, our young men and women, in war. To a degree, that relationship has been\n               broken. We have a profound and tight relationship with the United States — the longest, as\n               we always used to say, undefended border in the world. The actions even in the last\n               week of the President, never mind the last 58 weeks or 60 weeks that it's been, have\n               disrupted that, and they've affected negatively the economy of the world. We have\n               to be there for people in these times, and this budget is there. But it's not just that, of course. We've seen, in 2020 on, the COVID-19 pandemic.\n               We've seen the impacts of climate change and how it's profoundly affected, for example,\n               industries such as forestry — but also in terms of natural disasters in communities. When I was first Minister of Health, I went to your community, hon. Speaker, and visited\n               there. People had been evacuated, and how could one imagine that happening? Yet it\n               did, and people came together. But these are challenges that are, in fact, unique\n               in this time and that we need to address with resilience. We've got to be there with our elders, absolutely, and with young people in these\n               times, taking actions that support us, making our society and our community and our\n               economy more resilient in these times. That is exactly what I think we need to do. Now, there's a lot of discussion in terms of this budget about where we are in terms\n               of our fiscal situation. You see the same pattern if you look across governments that\n               are similar to us. Really, there are only two parallel governments to us in Canada\n               right now, which are non-equalization provinces. One is Alberta, and the other is\n               the government of Canada. Saskatchewan is in a slightly different situation. Alberta\n               and Canada. The last budget tabled by the new Prime Minister and his Finance Minister had a budget\n               deficit of $78.3 billion, federal deficit, largest in history, except for the COVID\n               years, and double what it had been coming out of the COVID years. In other words,\n               the fiscal situation facing this government is facing that government. Alberta will be tabling its budget tomorrow, and I would expect we will see a record\n               deficit. Why? Because Alberta's circumstances parallel ours. We're not equalization\n               provinces. Quebec gets a $14 billion cheque on its $13 billion deficit. Manitoba gets\n               a $5 billion — actually, larger in size than Quebec — equalization payment on a much\n               smaller economy. We are not an equalization province, nor is Alberta. Some of the challenges in natural resource industries that we're facing — the relatively\n               low price of oil, which is important to provincial revenues in Alberta — are there.\n               You're going to see the Alberta government have a very significant deficit. In addition to that, you see — in part because of federal policies, but what's happened\n               over the last few years, particularly in the years since 2020 — very large increases\n               in population, which Alberta has seen and British Columbia has seen. In my last I was Minister of Health for a while. People may remember. In the last three years\n               that I was Minister of Health, the number of people on MSP in three years increased\n               by 540,000 people, or 11 percent. That's population growth in three years what you\n               would normally expect in eight or nine. It happened in three, maybe even more than\n               that in the past. If you look at the ten years before that, when there was another government in power,\n               three years was about 100,000. This was 540,000. So that significantly demands.... There\n               are very few health care systems that could expand service to absorb 540,000 people\n               in a population of 4.9 million. Alberta has the same situation. You heard, by the way, the Alberta Premier speak about\n               it — I don't agree with her remedies entirely — that very question, because they face\n               the same situation. So they are going to face a large deficit, and we are facing a\n               large deficit. How do we deal with that circumstance? Canada faces a large deficit. It seems to me\n               what you have to do is do what the Minister of Finance has done, which is decide what\n               is important. I think what is most significant, most important and most recognized\n               is health and education. They're the significant provincial responsibilities, and\n               they require our support. Because I hear a lot about health care, so I'm going to say a few things about health\n               care. This week we had a report on health care, on primary care, in Canada. And what\n               did it show? It showed in British Columbia, contrary to repeated speeches by the opposition,\n               which use another number almost twice as high, that there are 750,000 people without\n               a family doctor. I think one generally might argue that's too much. It was 910,000, according to the Canadian community health survey, when the current\n               government took office in 2017. We've added, in that time, 900,000 people, and it's\n               lower, according to the survey — not a small survey, a survey of 16,000, one of the most substantial surveys done\n               on the question in Canadian history. It showed that the number of people without a\n               family doctor has declined by 300,000. Now, how did that happen? It happened because of government action combined with the action of communities,\n               combined with the action of health care professionals. We changed the payment model\n               for doctors. We established primary care networks, which had never happened before.\n               They talked about them, but it didn't happen before. We established primary care networks.\n               We established urgent and primary care centres. We doubled the number of nurse practitioners\n               we were training, and we increased their role in primary care. This is a good-news story, and we can continue to grow, because these are last year's\n               numbers. They're going to continue to get better — 750,000. So all of those other\n               numbers people have been using have been debunked by an independent study which shows\n               the reality. People are getting access to primary care, which is a critical aspect\n               of health care, and we've got to maintain the momentum. The current Minister of Health is doing that by recruiting more doctors, by recruiting\n               more nurse practitioners, by recruiting more health care workers and by training more\n               doctors, in the budget, with a new Surrey medical school and by adding seats to the\n               University British Columbia. You need a plan, you need to be committed to that plan, you need to invest in that\n               plan, and it's got to be there for the long run. The problem in primary care has been,\n               historically, that emergent care always displaces spending in primary care. This government\n               hasn't done that. They've gone in with a very succinct plan, and that means for real\n               people in communities access to a family doctor who have not had them for years, because\n               that action was taken. It's not just the government that deserves credit. It's communities that have built\n               out primary care networks. It's teams of medical professionals. It's the Doctors of\n               B.C. It's many more. It's post-secondary institutions. But that's how you bring change.\n               You commit to it, you make the right decisions, and then you support it over time.\n               And we've seen an unprecedented success in British Columbia on the issue of primary\n               care, and we should acknowledge that. How do we deal, though, with these circumstances broadly now? We've seen this. We've\n               taken action on the fiscal side to ensure that we're making efficient use of our resources.\n               We're investing in critical services like health care and education. And I think there\n               are three other things that I suggest we must do. The first is we've got to build things. And we are building things in British Columbia\n               in an unprecedented way, I'd argue. That is B.C. Hydro, which, historically, has been\n               a builder in B.C. deeply connected to the economic prosperity of British Columbia.\n               In the '60s and '70s and '80s was the decision to nationalize B.C. Hydro, because\n               at that time Deeply connected to the economic prosperity of British Columbia in the '60s and '70s\n               and '80s, was the decision to nationalize B.C. Hydro., because at that time, the private\n               sector wouldn't provide the capital to develop two rivers at once. So the Premier\n               of British Columbia, who would not describe himself as a socialist, W.A.C. Bennett,\n               made the decision to nationalize and to build. Well, in this moment, with the potential of our economy — just look at our integrated resources\n               plan, about to grow — we have to invest and use B.C. Hydro as it has been used before\n               to drive economic growth, and we are doing that. It is a difference between ourselves\n               and the members on the other side. We did a call for power — $6 billion in investment; $3 billion of First Nations equity\n               in partnerships; power the equivalent of Site C to power 500,000 homes; electricity\n               purchase agreements; and, by the way, projects that are mostly creating jobs in opposition\n               members' ridings. Now we're doing it again. In May, we'll be announcing the winning projects for the next call for power, because\n               we need electricity, and the price of electricity, the price of solar, the price of\n               wind have dropped 75 percent in the last 15 years, and 90 percent respectively. So\n               we are investing in effective, efficient economic opportunity for our province. In addition to that, we're building Revelstoke 6. In addition to that, we're making\n               improvements to the Mica dam. In addition to that, also opposed by the opposition,\n               we're building the North Coast transmission line, which will enable mining in our\n               province. It is a moment for those things. It's a moment for those things in our province. This\n               is what you do with B.C. Hydro. In addition to that, a call for expressions of interest on firm power. We received\n               103 responses — we'll be putting that forward soon — which in total combined to 19\n               gigawatts of power, of capacity, an extraordinary opportunity for B.C. B.C. Hydro\n               must invest to create opportunities for the future, and it is doing that — enabling\n               mining, enabling LNG, enabling people. All of those people I talked about who are requiring family doctors.... All of those\n               people also require, of course, electricity. That means investment in Surrey. That\n               means investment in Burnaby. That means investment in Vancouver. New substations all\n               over our province. In addition to that.... We see, because we need the public sector, the public agencies\n               like B.C. Hydro, like B.C. Timber Sales and the work being done by the Minister of\n               Forests, to drive and support economic growth in our province, and they are doing\n               so in an unprecedented way.... This is like the 1960s, and we are operating in that\n               way. The way you address deficits is to increase wealth, and we want to do that. My inspiration\n               for addressing wealth and driving energy projects is the public health care I feel\n               passionately about. That's what you do, and that's what we need to do in our province. That also requires.... You see it in the budget — page 155, approximately. You see the\n               impact of the work of the Minister of Mining and Critical Minerals. You see it reflected\n               in resource rents that pay for health care and education. They're going to double\n               in two years, mining resource rents, mining royalties — double in two years, triple\n               in four years. That doesn't count all of the projects that are coming connected to the North Coast\n               transmission line — outstanding work by the minister, but also by the Mining Association\n               and the proponents and communities and First Nations who all, again, partnered on\n               those initiatives. Let's talk about natural gas. With a very cautious estimate on the price of natural\n               gas, dramatically below the average of estimates, we're seeing a very significant\n               growth in natural gas royalties in the fiscal period, over $800 million. That reflects,\n               in part, the LNG policies of the government, which are, I think, to my way of thinking,\n               progressive and serious. There were no final investment decisions, no LNG projects, in B.C. when the NDP government\n               took office. Now we have LNG Canada. We have Ksi Lisims LNG. We have Cedar LNG, First\n               Nations–led, Haisla First Nation. We have Woodfibre LNG. We have the work that's being done with Tilbury and the xwməθkwəy̓əm\n               First Nation — Woodfibre is with the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh First Nation and Tilbury with the\n               xwməθkwəy̓əm First Nation — that is significant and important work, and other proposals. You see the immediate effects, and we But I want to make one point about all that. There's a lot of talk, and we've heard\n               it, especially from some members on the other side –– not all members on the other\n               side — about reconciliation. Tilbury partnership with xwməθkwəy̓əm First Nation. Woodfibre LNG partnership with Sḵwx̱wú7mesh First Nation. Cedar LNG, a project of the Haisla First Nation. Ksi Lisims LNG, the\n               Nisga'a First Nation. In other words, you look down the list of projects, and what you see is the value\n               of partnerships. You see it in mining and the work being done by the Minister of Mining and Critical Minerals and the Mining Association and the companies. You see it in the work and the enormous potential of the AltaGas project in Prince\n               Rupert LNG, which is a significant risk that was taken that is bearing fruit today\n               and will bring more wealth and prosperity and jobs to the province. You have to build, and you have to ensure that there is electricity available to projects\n               that create jobs, that our electricity, first and foremost, is for people. That is\n               precisely what we're doing. Secondly, you need some capacity for government. This is not new. It's being looked\n               at, of course, and advanced in other jurisdictions in Ontario and Quebec and other\n               jurisdictions in Canada and even in the United States. You hear the decision by the\n               United States government and the Trump administration to invest money in ownership\n               share of, for example, in that case, Intel and all their companies. We've created in this budget an investment fund directed by the Minister of Jobs and\n               Economic Growth that will allow us to partner with other levels of government and\n               business to create wealth and long-term jobs in our province and for the province\n               itself to have a share of that wealth. I think that makes a lot of sense. It gives\n               us the flexibility in our province to have opportunities. Members of the opposition who oppose NCTL, who oppose the allocation framework, who\n               oppose wind projects, who oppose renewable energy, are also opposed to this. But we\n               need to invest right now. We need to build right now. We need to work together and\n               advance while other jurisdictions are doing the same. It would be uncompetitive for\n               us not to do precisely what the Minister of Finance and the Minister of Jobs, Economic Development and Innovation are doing in this budget, and we should do it. Finally, I think the most important thing.... I want to reflect on something that people\n               will understand, I think, and is of concern with people. We've seen COVID-19. We've\n               seen the Trump administration and the breaking of the old international order so eloquently\n               described by the Prime Minister in Davos recently. We've seen the impacts of climate\n               change and the needs to invest in clean electricity, which is precisely what the government's\n               doing. If you don't have clean electricity, you cannot address climate emissions in a province.\n               We are doing that with B.C. Hydro in a leadership role. So we do all of those things\n               we need to do. But we are facing other significant challenges in addition, if you\n               can believe it, to climate change and to Trump and others. One of those challenges is the challenge brought forward by artificial intelligence,\n               which presents a significant challenge to a whole generation of workers. I just want to quote what the people in charge of the companies and the leaders of\n               it say about this. Dario Amodei, the CEO of AI company Anthropic, says: \"AI could drive unemployment up 10 to 20\n               percent in the next one to five years and wipe out half of all entry-level white-collar\n               jobs.\" Sam Altman, of OpenAI, has a bet about the inevitable date when a billion-dollar company is\n               staffed by just one person. I think, in this time, we've said.... We've looked in these times. You think of the\n               great advances of the past, how long it was from Edison to the advent when electricity\n               was in 50 percent of people's homes. How long it took for the telephone to be invented, then be in 50 percent of homes.\n               It was decades and decades and decades. So its impact on the economy was dealt with\n               through attrition and other means. We're talking about immediate impact, and that\n               is why governments that have a focus on We're talking about immediate impact, and that is why governments that have a focus\n               on the future will do exactly what this government is doing, which is to invest in\n               training. We need to arm young people with the training they need for the jobs of\n               the future. When we talk about medical schools and investment in post-secondary education and\n               allowing people in housing to live near their campuses and have an opportunity for\n               people elsewhere to go other places to learn more and we invest in communities, we\n               are building the resilience of society. We are standing up for people at a time when\n               all of these things, Trump and climate change, require a government committed to young\n               people and humans in the future. That is what we are doing. It is when you invest, for example, in the $283 million\n               in incremental spending on a skilled workforce to fill new jobs — that's responding\n               to the future. It is foolhardy not to do that. It's foolhardy to say we are seeing\n               disruptions in our economy and not to allow the young people that we represent to\n               be supported in these times. We need more skills training, and this budget delivers it. It delivers it. And I would\n               say.... When you're facing this, we need to ensure, as we did with our allocation framework,\n               that our electricity responses go to human beings first, that they advance projects\n               that support jobs and communities. That is precisely what we did, even though the\n               Conservatives and the Green Party opposed it. We think our electricity.... We have an ALR in B.C., and I say thank God. Our land and\n               our water should go first to human beings and to our future. That our young people\n               and all people have access to the training they will need in this time of disruption....\n               That's what this budget seeks to do, not to see this moment, which is facing every\n               government in Canada, as an opportunity to cut on things that are essential in the\n               future, like public education and public health care. The budget defends public education and it defends public health care, but it is also\n               future-seeking in that it is saying that we need to build in our province, we need\n               to build capital projects in the public system, we need to build them in the private\n               system, and we need to make it happen now. That's how we respond. You improve the revenue side, and that is what we're doing. You can see the results\n               of the investment in mining. You can see the results in the investment in natural\n               gas. You can see the results in the investment in clean tech. You can see the results\n               in our investment in public health care, which means hundreds of thousands of people\n               who didn't have a family doctor now have a family doctor. You see that impact. This is a time for government to respond, to make our province more resilient, to\n               support the future, to support the future of young people, to be there with them in\n               these disruptive times. We can't stop the development of artificial intelligence,\n               even if we wanted to. There are opportunities there, and you're going to see them\n               in British Columbia soon with new projects launched here soon. We can ensure that\n               the people that matter, the people who live here, the people who are going to live\n               here, have access to opportunity. We can't stop, sometimes, a worldwide pandemic from coming to B.C. Oh if we could,\n               but we can't. But we can respond better than anyone else, supporting our workers more,\n               having the best outcomes, making sure our children got back to school earlier than\n               anywhere else. You can do that. We can't stop worldwide climate change. But we can do our part to fight it and to\n               make people more resilient against it and to ensure that people have access to a cleaner\n               future, which the world is pointing to, even if the current U.S. government is not\n               right now. We know that there are challenges in the future. We know we have an aging population.\n               But this budget presents another opportunity to say what we're about in B.C. We're\n               about addressing our challenges head-on. We're about supporting health care and education.\n               We're about building and creating jobs in our province. We're about ensuring that\n               inequality in these times, which will drive inequality, is reduced, not increased,\n               in our province. You bet that's what we're for. That's what this government is for, that's what this\n               finance minister is for, and that's what this budget is for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317128","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It's an honour to rise in this session of the Legislature, as I have in many before,\n               and represent the people of Vancouver-Renfrew, who every day surprise me and impress me with their entrepreneurship, with their\n               generosity to their fellow citizens, to the wonderful work that's done in our public\n               schools, the wonderful work that's done in schools such a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c91ce8dd4e843fbfce3adec8be6d82a9baaea61aa5c3ef31f552392c4946fd7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07fa9fd143acd036f2bffd773173143d9d6548579d81ef37fd6dbb0f73fac1f3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8aa2aed88ef8057155e015a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415715,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"Obviously, first of all, I am honoured to give my congratulations to Mr. Lewis, who\n               won the leadership to the NDP in a respectful and democratic contest. The position of the government is clear on these matters. The Ksi Lisims LNG project\n               received its environmental assessment approval. B.C. Hydro, under my direction, has\n               an agreement on electricity with Ksi Lisims. We're supporters of the project. It will be some of the lowest emission LNG in the\n               world. It will build jobs and growth and resources and revenues for the people of\n               B.C. Equally, on other LNG projects, we continue to maintain our five principles in\n               terms of supporting LNG in British Columbia. There were no LNG projects when Premier Horgan became Premier. There are now six under\n               construction or in final levels of approval. I think that demonstrates the position\n               of the government and the success of the policy we've undertaken, which focuses not\n               just on economic development but ensures climate action as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415715","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Obviously, first of all, I am honoured to give my congratulations to Mr. Lewis, who\n               won the leadership to the NDP in a respectful and democratic contest. The position of the government is clear on these matters. The Ksi Lisims LNG project\n               received its environmental assessment approval. B.C. Hydro, under my direction, has\n               an agreement on electricity with","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef9038eae8f08ec26fa8082587d073829c3194371a1ee31c669757bce5ee8e52","be7f3b11b7c2030b8f59c11d36e71a599e5578e251d00b669102a6464e2b7f48"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5905d9c603ea3cb7b1610718194258e16bc033ea4a5eb5ecf620df99e959fcb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97bbe7f6d1f528eff413c013","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415716,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"Earlier today I had the opportunity to present the official provincial proclamation\n               to declare that April 2026 shall be known as Safe Digging Month in the province of\n               B.C. In the gallery today, we have 27 members of the Common Ground Alliance and B.C. One\n               Call. They include Tony Milliken, the chair of the B.C. Common Ground Alliance; M.J.\n               Whitemarsh, government and stakeholder relations for the BCCGA, who's well known to\n               people in this legislature; Donna Grant, the president of B.C. One Call and Paul Chernikhowsky\n               from Fortis, the vice-chair of B.C. One Call. Now, members on all sides of the House had the opportunity to meet over lunch with\n               the Common Ground Alliance, with B.C. One Call. We learned a great deal about what\n               they have to tell us about safe digging. It is occasionally the case that what I say doesn't unite all the members of the Legislature.\n               But let me say this. I think I can do this today. Let's all remember to dig responsibly.\n               Call or click before you dig.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415716","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Earlier today I had the opportunity to present the official provincial proclamation\n               to declare that April 2026 shall be known as Safe Digging Month in the province of\n               B.C. In the gallery today, we have 27 members of the Common Ground Alliance and B.C. One\n               Call. They include Tony Milliken, the chair of the B.C. Common Ground Alliance; M.J.\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5be66598400d97601a80bb221ff14a67fee394d22d076e4ead6beb9ee018984b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d578636212c80d50bc0aa86b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720277,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, it's always good when you get your question period material from the Western Standard. I'll just say this. The pipeline proposal doesn't exist, at least not yet. There's\n               been a lot of talk of it. B.C. has expressed its position. The member will know that\n               we're opposed to the lifting of the tanker ban on the north coast and that we're of\n               course working closely with other jurisdictions in all of these matters. But it seems to me reasonable, when people put forward a project that will greatly\n               affect British Columbians, that the British Columbia government be informed and develop\n               evidence with respect to that project. That's precisely what we are doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720277","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, it's always good when you get your question period material from the Western Standard. I'll just say this. The pipeline proposal doesn't exist, at least not yet. There's\n               been a lot of talk of it. B.C. has expressed its position. The member will know that\n               we're opposed to the lifting of the tanker ban on the north coast and that we're of\n               course wor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","label":"International development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","label":"Water quality","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c9bd2495db5010ec9a9dd4dc7746f8953edb56228c96e598b2513c2fb6832da","99c2f4647ff6b888cc009984b742e0bc2560b08d3ebc305f473cee621201e890","966076d5bfc02e488b1bdc6c7a9010bba6939a160d099f82f5cb16e7c54a9270","9156d0656ad925739a5dcc84edd9acee5b36cbe446f8cd200a33ae1ac8cc4191","6a3616d404374cfa0caeba27adbfbf93b24f7aa5fa73eceee758cc0c6be9d409"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ef8aca8e5ed9bfc461ac59ae342481d336fa7a245f6bbd71859a5600d867fee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85a66ba644c0cc8d7e6cd8ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720282,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"I've spent a lot of time responding to questions about the pipeline proposal that\n               the province How long has the provincial Minister of Energy known about Woodfibre's plans to double\n               or triple in size?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720282","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I've spent a lot of time responding to questions about the pipeline proposal that\n               the province How long has the provincial Minister of Energy known about Woodfibre's plans to double\n               or triple in size?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6514e3bfe03d6c815ce249eed7d071f011a05f3fc9a51968f86a9dc1fafcb966"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e405636410abcbc46f7f6eb24e4db03c5d2790c826da15a525ea0f452f5650fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f3b151f8c9455d0610ade60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720284,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this moment of our tributes in our Legislature, I wanted to pay tribute to a significant\n               figure who passed away this week in Washington state. The person's name is Joel Connolly. Mr. Connolly was a very significant journalist in Washington state. He wrote for the Seattle P-I for something like 50 years. He was the leading voice — he was the voice, really\n               — of political analysis in Washington state. And many of us who follow both Washington state and U.S. politics and who are interested\n               in Washington state and U.S. politics would have learned a lot of what we knew about\n               Washington state and U.S. politics from Joel Connolly. Interestingly, Mr. Connolly had an extraordinary relationship with Canada. He started\n               working at the Seattle P-I in early 1970. One of his first stories is his mother was But interestingly, Mr. Connelly had an extraordinary relationship with Canada. He\n               started working at the Seattle P-I in early 1970, and one of his first stories — his mother was a journalist; it was\n               in his blood — was to come to Victoria. One of his first major stories, front-page\n               stories, involved former Premier Dave Barrett. Mr. Connelly came here to British Columbia from Washington state on behalf of the Seattle P-I because Premier Barrett wanted to take action and was demanding that the National\n               Energy Board take action on the price of the export of natural gas, which was then\n               a Crown corporation in B.C. Mr. Barrett was using the 1974 energy crisis — these things\n               repeat themselves — to pressure the National Energy Board to hike the price of natural\n               gas south of the border. British Columbia was a very important source of natural gas for Washington state,\n               and the two very powerful U.S. senators from Washington state, Henry \"Scoop\" Jackson\n               and Warren Magnuson at the time, Democrats from Washington state, demanded that the\n               Canadian government intervene to stop the Premier of B.C. So Mr. Connelly came up\n               as a young journalist and was invited into the Premier's office to hear the Premier's\n               response in Victoria. This is from Mr. Connelly's words in his obituary to Dave Barrett: \"Over in Victoria,\n               Barrett fumed to a visiting Yank reporter that any red-blooded American worker would\n               want his Canadian counterpart to be paid the going rate for gas. The Premier got carried\n               away and offered an on-the-record response to Maggie and Scoop. Dave Barrett delivered\n               a Bronx cheer and raised the middle finger of both hands.\" Back at the newspaper — you can imagine a 23-year-old reporter coming home and getting\n               this story to the newspaper, and they were obviously looking at his notes — Mr. Connelly\n               explained what was happening, and the newspaper characterized Mr. Barrett's statement\n               as \"a gesture of defiance.\" In any event, Dave Barrett, who had, as a paperboy, delivered the Seattle P-I — many know he went to Seattle university — had shared that in common with Mr. Connelly.\n               Mr. Connelly wrote a beautiful obituary of Dave Barrett. Often in our lives and Canadians lives, we think we don't have the attention of the\n               United States, and we pay a lot of attention to the United States. When I grew up,\n               majority of the channels on cable TV were American channels — ABC, KOMO News. We knew\n               the American reporters on all the different local affiliates — KOMO, King, Cairo and,\n               of course, KCTS. Joel Connelly paid attention to Canada. From his first articles, he wrote articles\n               about Canada, and he informed Washington state residents about Canada. He loved Canada.\n               He travelled in Canada. When the COVID-19 pandemic ended, he wrote a beautiful column\n               about ten places to visit in B.C. and encouraged Americans, once the border was reopened,\n               to come here. He really cared about this place. He influenced it as well. He led an American campaign to get Victoria to treat its\n               sewage, which was a controversial issue for a long time in this town and had a huge\n               impact. People will remember Mr. Floatie, I think. Joel Connelly had a lot of influence. But he was also an admirer and a lover of Canada.\n               His last column was about the election of Avi Lewis as leader of the NDP. He wrote\n               beautifully about it, covered B.C. politics, brought B.C. people, towns, communities\n               and parks to Washington state people. I think it's important to remember, in a time when relationships between Canada and\n               the United States are so difficult, that the ties binding those of us who live in\n               British Columbia and those who lived in Washington state are profound. They're ties\n               of people, not just fans of the Seahawks but people, of communities. Joel Connelly, who was born in Bellingham and wrote about British Columbia and, of\n               course, Washington and the United States politics for 50 years, had a profound influence.\n               He was a great contributor to American democracy and, in his own way, a great contributor\n               to our own. I had the honour to know him and to admire his work, and I wish on behalf of the Legislature\n               to pay our best to his family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720284","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this moment of our tributes in our Legislature, I wanted to pay tribute to a significant\n               figure who passed away this week in Washington state. The person's name is Joel Connolly. Mr. Connolly was a very significant journalist in Washington state. He wrote for the Seattle P-I for something like 50 years. He was the leading voice — he was the voice, really\n               — of polit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a98bf683abc473cffacd437a2ca370858c3e920e4ebe830fb35873f625a0422","bcb5ad927bc3951c82688d3f46ec880f1f2bf9e8f1c467da303f928c1f859cb6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e56e4cd19897d96b079932a933285f8cc96fefd3a6e8585afe69629a43e3d9b3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-212a4d79fbfec42c8293d238","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721356,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, because we're discussing the same issue over and over again, I'll say it very\n               clearly. There is, with respect to Alberta's pipeline proposal, no proponent, no proposal, no route.\n               Alberta missed deadlines so far in their MOU with the federal government. When there's\n               an actual proposal and an actual route and an actual idea and actual customers for\n               a line, which surely no one will pay for, then of course we'll engage. We continue, as well, to engage with the government of Alberta, to engage with the\n               government of Canada on a host of energy issues, including with Minister Jean, with\n               Minister Neudorf and of course with Minister Hodgson, and we'll continue to do so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721356","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Again, because we're discussing the same issue over and over again, I'll say it very\n               clearly. There is, with respect to Alberta's pipeline proposal, no proponent, no proposal, no route.\n               Alberta missed deadlines so far in their MOU with the federal government. When there's\n               an actual proposal and an actual route and an actual idea and actual customers for","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b42ee8af6b32ea56f90968f97ceaeec3df3e83ae17631ddd8271b9682a47f06c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f18d35d7ef8f926a92ea507ff168cebae022c7d3a06283a43b92954c9b8a349"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c1ff19997560f5cf07f1413","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721364,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to recognize today members of the Armenian-Canadian community who are with\n               us in the Legislature in advance of our commemoration at noon of the Armenian genocide.\n               I invite all members to join us at that time. It is always an important and moving\n               event. Joining us today are members of the Armenian National Committee of Canada and the\n               United Armenian Committee of British Columbia. We're honoured to have with us archpriest\n               Reverend Father Keghart Garabedian, pastor of St. Vartan Armenian Apostolic Church; as well as Right Reverend\n               Vartan Tashjian, pastor of St. Gregory's Armenian Apostolic Church. I would also like to recognize members of the Armenian Youth Federation, including\n               is Seza Korajian and Mher Asayan, who will be sharing their reflections today during the lunchtime commemorative ceremony\n               in the Hall of Honour. I ask all members to join us at noon and also to wish our guests welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721364","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to recognize today members of the Armenian-Canadian community who are with\n               us in the Legislature in advance of our commemoration at noon of the Armenian genocide.\n               I invite all members to join us at that time. It is always an important and moving\n               event. Joining us today are members of the Armenian National Committee of Canada and the\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84d1b89cfa129cd7a5fcc9f87a0a8c3c575aa0938270ffa538f990bc0fddeaa6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f80db64d6b9b66e405f2957d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729027,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome to the Legislative Assembly today members of the Vietnamese-Canadian\n               community who are here to join us in commemoration of Journey to Freedom Day. We'll\n               be holding an event at noon in the Hall of Honour, and I welcome all members of the\n               House to join us for that event. Journey to Freedom Day marks, I think, one of the greatest moments in Canadian history\n               of my lifetime. The welcoming to Canada of Vietnamese, now Canadian, refugees in the\n               hundreds of thousands, a decision made by the government of Canada but supported by\n               churches and synagogues. We are honoured to be joined by Quyn Le, who will be speaking at the ceremony, a powerful voice of resilience, a TEDx speaker,\n               a health care worker, whose life story reflects the journey of so many Vietnamese\n               refugees who rebuilt their lives in Canada. We welcome everyone to join us at noon,\n               and welcome our guests to the Legislative Assembly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729027","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome to the Legislative Assembly today members of the Vietnamese-Canadian\n               community who are here to join us in commemoration of Journey to Freedom Day. We'll\n               be holding an event at noon in the Hall of Honour, and I welcome all members of the\n               House to join us for that event. Journey to Freedom Day marks, I think, one of the greatest moment","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Insulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","label":"Insulation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["229bc8b6495fd88fdcfe2cd6adbc95bf5fde1ec1ab77c907676ac111bb7899e3","b18163ec5167ed86dccf7900b750fb68e24084b2f3cbcd8571ac860ff02e4d07","3a9da0b9b3535c0157103ae70e6377e0fdcc13d37c3cb0033250eaa87c52636a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bebe48dcb3c41503d33354610efdd857ed764dd0d354f1c02730ff76323f6cc4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c926479961c58d1e98641dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752223,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member knows they're not being ignored. They're significant. All LNG facilities, indeed all such facilities in B.C., are subject to strict regulation.\n               All of them have been through environmental assessment processes led by the outstanding\n               staff at the environmental assessment office. All of those processes include substantial\n               study and review of the impact of projects, whatever they may be, on human health. There is an absolute and continuing obligation on the part of regulators to ensure\n               that the conditions on projects are followed. When there are issues, action is taken,\n               as has happened recently by the B.C. Energy Regulator with respect to the issue of\n               black smoke. And we're going to continue to see those actions taken.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752223","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The member knows they're not being ignored. They're significant. All LNG facilities, indeed all such facilities in B.C., are subject to strict regulation.\n               All of them have been through environmental assessment processes led by the outstanding\n               staff at the environmental assessment office. All of those processes include substantial\n               study and review of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","label":"Air quality"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","label":"Atmospheric emissions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","label":"Air quality","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","label":"Atmospheric emissions","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3a99bf8dd9d575844161e1138b30359505d4fe0195248221c1e1439ae085d810","1295ecbfdaff1fdd0d1e0fb00d5d051dd2461e2dda79d9f536be60507c710976"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d0e7f03846ee7a823ee8d0f1d15de7f8fa7e19c7817f5756b9e5c6a087f8ec4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5909559d1e95521b4b47063b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017271,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today joining us in the gallery this morning are four amazing staff from the Deputy\n               Minister's office of Energy and Climate Solutions. They are Shauna Little, the executive\n               director of operations and issues and project management; Sarah Nichol, the manager\n               of executive operations; Charlene Evers, the senior executive assistant; Whitney Bertoia,\n               the project assistant. They all provide leadership and expertise, deliver the corporate\n               services that support the ministry executive, the minister's office and staff in achieving\n               our many diverse mandates. I ask the House to make them all welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017271","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today joining us in the gallery this morning are four amazing staff from the Deputy\n               Minister's office of Energy and Climate Solutions. They are Shauna Little, the executive\n               director of operations and issues and project management; Sarah Nichol, the manager\n               of executive operations; Charlene Evers, the senior executive assistant; Whitney Bertoia,\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","label":"Water conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f91620f77ded835c36b8957eaaf52ed1cc37a108609af4559c221d5b5ec4547f","f9031e34f6e722dd221d497a1d09523fcb5f177a85a57aef2b352c600e83f5eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99eb8cfe2ac719505b557a09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017272,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's EV Drive and Ride Day, with the B.C. New Car Dealers Association, today on the\n               front lawn. I know many members took part in seeing all the new cars and meeting the\n               new car dealers. I want to extend a warm welcome to executives from the New Car Dealers Association\n               of B.C. — Blair Qualey, president and CEO; Jared Williams, chair; Ann Marie Clark,\n               vice-chair. The New Car Dealers represent more than 468 new car and truck dealers,\n               doing business in over 55 communities throughout B.C. Over 30,000 British Columbians\n               support their families by working in this sector, and they're responsible for more\n               than $17 billion in retail sales. They also, as many of you know, operate the largest auto trade show in western Canada,\n               the Vancouver International Auto Show. You had a chance to visit there this year.\n               Thanks to their partnership with the government, over 229,000 EVs are now on B.C.\n               roads today. Let's let them all feel welcome here in the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017272","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's EV Drive and Ride Day, with the B.C. New Car Dealers Association, today on the\n               front lawn. I know many members took part in seeing all the new cars and meeting the\n               new car dealers. I want to extend a warm welcome to executives from the New Car Dealers Association\n               of B.C. — Blair Qualey, president and CEO; Jared Williams, chair; Ann Marie Clark,\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["efc8732f95d6c98634a00d1258eb4bef75b14de8d3202919c3b82e63a16c7da4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c67e3a9caf4f6e52f67e23a4619b7c2650058ce9fc44151c403b56e75cfd80c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18c35cf75535e848d4bf6527","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036457,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to extend a warm welcome to representatives — who are, I think, in the Speaker's\n               gallery — from Innergex Renewable Energy and representatives from the Stellat'en, from the Nadleh Whut'en, West Moberly and Westbank First Nations. They're here to discuss successful wind power projects, all majority — 51 percent\n               — First Nations–owned, selected from B.C. Hydro's 2024 and 2025 calls for power. There\n               is a significant list, which I will share with Hansard and people who are here. But\n               we're very honoured to have them here, and I look forward to meeting with them, as\n               do other members of the House, throughout the day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036457","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to extend a warm welcome to representatives — who are, I think, in the Speaker's\n               gallery — from Innergex Renewable Energy and representatives from the Stellat'en, from the Nadleh Whut'en, West Moberly and Westbank First Nations. They're here to discuss successful wind power projects, all majority — 51 percent\n               — First Nations–owned, selected from B.C. Hydro's ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","label":"Wind energy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Heating","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","label":"Heating","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","label":"Wind energy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21a393e3d82248445b9211a8b2da0f9657237bec535c295c3bc58c3041fcfe29"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e988fe9d98427d8faa69d2dc9ab00ecc24569fe3455e487a631fec73ace9ff2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a2c0dc77356cdf3e338b419","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036458,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"As I try to do, as often as possible, I think I can follow the logic and the force\n               of the answer the Premier gave — that the threat to B.C. Hydro and the threat to ratepayers\n               is over there. It's over there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036458","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As I try to do, as often as possible, I think I can follow the logic and the force\n               of the answer the Premier gave — that the threat to B.C. Hydro and the threat to ratepayers\n               is over there. It's over there.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Shipping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501219","label":"Shipping","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0dd5fe0f1b913d23976071c2d503ada05ea2cfe1579a9c0abe619b29bd38bae","6ac19cd01cc74a10bc2a9ace5cc9e33d86706223adb8172485841b3e5423b5d8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35f0618bd86924bbbc782663","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036459,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Adrian Dix","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036459","member_id":"bc-mla-26","member_name":"Adrian Dix","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020172","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Burials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020172","label":"Burials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5aff871c73555308069706edbeea2385361aa1054891f43495b30a5ad4ff1eb7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6384d8303db21b0381a20293","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327957,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last night I had a very emotional conversation with a couple that reached out to me\n               after losing their job at the West Fraser mill in 100 Mile House after 171⁄2  years\n               of service. In a letter to me, they said: \"We can't even afford groceries.\" What does this Premier have to say to this family and the thousands upon thousands\n               of families who have lost their jobs in this forest sector under his watch?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327957","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Last night I had a very emotional conversation with a couple that reached out to me\n               after losing their job at the West Fraser mill in 100 Mile House after 171⁄2  years\n               of service. In a letter to me, they said: \"We can't even afford groceries.\" What does this Premier have to say to this family and the thousands upon thousands\n               of families who have lost th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["552ee0b29c3586e59b3045c059c8fed554f52f1392b9c5b69a3258d0f6a8adcd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e18250e4b03a46d95ef69c2b4711d82d8d856a62ebb9b583c34f89dbb810b236"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b5e825f7193be3930ec810f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360146,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's great to hear support on both sides of this House today for M201, that this House\n               affirms its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an important\n               component of Canadian sovereignty. I'm going to take a slightly different approach at this as well, but I do want to\n               speak to the challenges that some of our members have mentioned this morning with\n               respect to small communities and the challenges that they find with respect to drawing\n               from an aquifer. We have communities like Tatla Lake in my riding, which really is only a couple hundred\n               people. The well there in Tatla serves not only the medical clinic but the local restaurant,\n               and I do mean one restaurant. I mean it supports the We have communities like Tatla Lake, in my riding, which really is only a couple hundred\n               people. The well there in Tatla serves not only the medical clinic but the local restaurant.\n               I do mean one restaurant. I mean it supports the community hall and, of course, the\n               store and that kind of thing. We have noticed levels of arsenic in that well. Of course\n               there's been a number of applications to the province for support for what would be\n               really an affordable, pretty affordable, well for that community, but we haven't been\n               successful. Even in communities like Williams Lake with a little bit more robust population, 100\n               Mile, those areas are really struggling as well with millions of dollars of expense\n               for their water system. In smaller communities, again like Horse Lake, where, you\n               know, we heard about the tea-coloured water.... We're really seeing that a lot throughout\n               our riding. These challenges are real for these small communities, small regional districts, that\n               just simply can't raise that kind of money through taxation. So we're really calling\n               on the province for some support there and, certainly, the federal government as well.\n               I think that's important that those levels of government get involved. I want to turn my thoughts to dams, weirs, diversion points that are on the landscape\n               that have become pretty challenging pieces of infrastructure. The reason really is\n               — I think, innocently, frankly, what we've seen — that you've got a dam that might\n               be six or seven or eight decades old, and different levels of government and different\n               governments decide to build 100 houses below that dam. Suddenly that dam — the liability\n               that is attached to it, the challenges around inspection, the challenges around repair\n               — has become significantly more than they were because they are now deemed as high\n               consequence dams. I can assure you that I never thought that, in my tenure, we would see residents and\n               neighbours fighting over water supply. But that's happening in Cariboo-Chilcotin. It's happening in areas where we are now seeing rivers and creeks going dry. The problem that I just mentioned is real. The cause of that is that we're seeing\n               a few of these pieces of infrastructure actually being removed. In the case of Borland\n               Creek, where I actually witnessed the dam being removed, the dam was only removed\n               for that reason — because of the high level of liability for homes and structure below\n               it and because of the high level of expense not only to ensure it but, as I said,\n               to inspect it. Some of these ranchers and different families that might control these\n               waterways are facing fees of $100,000 just for inspection. The loss of that freshet that we would regularly enjoy in a dam situation or in the\n               situation of a weir.... We're losing all of that water. We're seeing it obviously flow\n               out to the ocean, and it's a huge loss. It's a huge loss not for just the residents\n               that need that water for consumption later on in the year when the rivers are typically\n               dry.... And they are now — Borland Creek, Knife Creek, many of them. Bridge Creek was so dry, two years ago, that we had the annual duck race. If you haven't\n               got your ducks, Madam Speaker, you should. We had the annual duck race. It wasn't\n               much of a race because we had to push the ducks down the river, right? There's no\n               water in some of these areas. That is a result, in some cases, of the loss of this\n               piece of infrastructure. I suppose why I'm speaking here today is that I really think that the government must,\n               absolutely must, contemplate, considering some of these high consequence dams as part\n               of the infrastructure and supporting the people that see this high expense. Potentially,\n               the last thing that I want to remind members of is that it also allows us to keep\n               water on the landscape for that very important wildfire effort.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360146","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's great to hear support on both sides of this House today for M201, that this House\n               affirms its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an important\n               component of Canadian sovereignty. I'm going to take a slightly different approach at this as well, but I do want to\n               speak to the challenges that some of our members have mentio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc8bf82361ed98fc422644f5a45f44c1638dd61d0938f4add3f08ab20e9169dd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04c78c6c3a913052debdf75e846dddd16aa03abbaf7baf7ba3f3a5f6a032a37e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbc9907666a4856b3f4be4d2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360147,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am proud to introduce Vanita Des Mazes and Tim Johnson. They are realtors from the\n               B.C. Northern Real Estate Board here. They are fierce representatives and advocates\n               for the realtors of northern British Columbia. I wanted to just add that Tim Johnson is from Williams Lake. He is a personal friend\n               of mine. I would like the House to make them feel very welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360147","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am proud to introduce Vanita Des Mazes and Tim Johnson. They are realtors from the\n               B.C. Northern Real Estate Board here. They are fierce representatives and advocates\n               for the realtors of northern British Columbia. I wanted to just add that Tim Johnson is from Williams Lake. He is a personal friend\n               of mine. I would like the House to make them feel very","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","label":"Pollution","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b93c4d08dbce52044ff9c773f476b8e4c2790d9e22ed44cae7c4b6884bba9454","e15d0c40f9faf201219ab9bf912c51db92fe9966bfd8dba450575bac31b4148f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68a3f570c6ed91b7ca01b0f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720288,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let's be clear. Management of projects by this government is absolutely abysmal. If\n               a 34 percent This is important work. We're proud of that work. We're going to continue to do that\n               work for British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720288","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's be clear. Management of projects by this government is absolutely abysmal. If\n               a 34 percent This is important work. We're proud of that work. We're going to continue to do that\n               work for British Columbians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035152","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Erosion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035152","label":"Erosion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","label":"Hazardous waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50189cd7c059087663b19ad48b33f9114676e59c13bc638caa3f4760e774c729","21af4bb6cfa278fc83f6e5067215a4abe2e5f9eaf9d0d348fc7a62cde61628fa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f43e84db59798e8c34316b40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720291,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's New Year's Day 1868 inside the Clinton Hotel. Guests are dressed in their finest\n               gowns and suits as they waltz across the floor. This was the first Clinton Annual\n               Ball. It is believed that the ball began in the late 1860s, most likely in the hotel's\n               new billiards room after the Smith family acquired the Clinton Hotel. Accounts differ as to whether or not that happened in 1863 or 1867, but what is agreed\n               is that Mrs. Smith was the driving force behind the first ball. What began as a community\n               celebration has grown into a remarkable tradition. This year marks the 159th anniversary\n               of the event, which is recognized as the longest continuously running event in British\n               Columbia and one of the longest in Canada. In the early years, people travelled to Clinton by sleigh, horseback and on foot to\n               attend. Participants planned for months, ordering gowns and suits from distant places,\n               making this event a true social highlight of the region. The ball has been held in\n               several venues before finding its home at the Clinton Memorial Hall, a hall built\n               in remembrance of fallen war veterans, famous for its hardwood-sprung dance floor,\n               so much so that rumours persist that it is built on used tires. Through 159 years, this event has endured floods, fire, war, two pandemics, yet it\n               continues to bring residents of Clinton and the South Cariboo together each year in\n               celebration of their shared history and community spirit. The Clinton Ball remains\n               one of the Cariboo Chilcotin's truly treasured traditions, and I invite everyone to\n               come and experience this remarkable piece of living history. I'm especially pleased to share that legislative intern Annika Clark will be joining\n               me this year at the ball, and that Bernice Weiss-Anderson has already picked out a\n               gown for her. We're very much looking forward to the music and, of course, the tall\n               tales that accompany this event, and we are very excited to attend. I ask this whole House to congratulate the Clinton Ball on 159 years of celebration.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720291","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's New Year's Day 1868 inside the Clinton Hotel. Guests are dressed in their finest\n               gowns and suits as they waltz across the floor. This was the first Clinton Annual\n               Ball. It is believed that the ball began in the late 1860s, most likely in the hotel's\n               new billiards room after the Smith family acquired the Clinton Hotel. Accounts differ as to whether ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3fe4b62d8d4907bee9d980a43a520b5478e42c4df69703e66f1a97775db45098","2c717d166af16a38916eccd8a5ce1cdff299bfe34eb7a623affa8b3cd356990c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["faa1593f6d498b776c2b3fd8fa720f0e542e868030259e83f888fb7e06871983"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-784d07c8d0d7b6028fa0012e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720296,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a few brief remarks, too, that I want to make regarding Bill 14 and the Forests\n               Statutes Amendment Act. I certainly share a number of similar opinions with the members\n               for Nechako Lakes and also Peace River North. I guess I'm always happy to hear that we're in a position to speak about forestry\n               in this chamber and bring comments from some of the rural ridings. But I think what\n               often gets forgotten in this I think, what often gets forgotten in this room is that this really has an incredibly\n               serious effect on the entire province. You just have to fly into the Vancouver Airport\n               one time and look below in the Fraser River and see how much of our forestry products\n               are sitting in that river. This is so serious throughout the province. While I appreciate the fact that we have a bill before the House that has a goal of\n               solving some of the issues with respect to BCTS, B.C. Timber Sales, I really don't\n               see it as a fulsome solution to our challenges in the forest industry in general terms. First off, BCTS is being asked to do certainly more at a time when they're already\n               struggling to deliver on their core mandate. They're already facing challenges delivering\n               existing volume. Planning, permitting, operational constraints remain unchanged. Adding\n               new responsibilities like wildfire and thinning, those types of things, frankly, are\n               outside of the scope of what BCTS should be doing. Frankly, this really puts the government in the seat as a general contractor when\n               we're surrounded by extremely well-outfitted loggers and mill operators through the\n               entire province. Peace River North had pointed out earlier that there are 31 mills that have closed\n               in this province. When we talk about this bill having some sort of potential great\n               impact on the province, I can't wait to hear in committee — potentially, we'll hear\n               it in closing remarks today — what kind of volume is expected here? The member from Nechako Lakes touched on what is the mandate of the Forestry Ministry\n               in this province: to generate 45 million cubic metres. I don't want to throw out a\n               whole bunch of numbers, but the budget shows 30 for the next couple of years. I'm\n               very concerned about that, because that just doesn't feel like a commitment to me. More importantly, the chief forester has made a number of comments around that 60\n               million range, which should be sustainable from my understanding. I'm not a forester,\n               but I have to believe the people that are in those places to certainly determine those\n               numbers. What I will say is this: Cariboo-Chilcotin is on pins and needles about bills like this one. I have to paint a bit of a picture\n               about my riding. The reality is that it stretches from the West Chilcotin all the\n               way to Savona, Cherry Creek, almost to Kamloops town. When you come to Williams Lake from Kamloops, you'll encounter a mill in Savona. You'll\n               encounter a closed mill in Chasm. You'll encounter a closed Norbord plant in 100 Mile\n               House and now a closed West Fraser, which just closed, obviously, more recently, something\n               that we've shared in this chamber before. When you come to Williams Lake, you will see seven milling operations within the boundaries\n               of our city. We had eight, but we just lost a pellet plant. When you think about the\n               thoughts that are on the minds of Cariboo-Chilcotin, what we are hoping for is improved processes. I can appreciate what Bill 14 is trying to do with respect to gaining access to all\n               of the fibre that it proposes to get at. But, I guess, what I'll be asking of the\n               minister and hoping to better understand is: how is this different than what we're\n               doing now? If you come to Williams Lake and, certainly, tour any of our forests or some of the\n               forests around, you will notice that Tsi Del Del, companies like that.... The minister has been there, and we've certainly shared a\n               conversation about this. Some of the thinning that has been done is absolutely amazing.\n               This bill talks about doing thinning work. That work is happening now, in my mind. But the challenge around that is, honestly, permits. Permits that are applied for\n               in September are still not approved in April. The Forests Minister has done incredible\n               work to help on that, but we had to bring it to the Forests Minister's attention. One of the members here mentioned the One of the members here mentioned the seasons and how things have changed. Roads get\n               soft in the spring. You've all of a sudden lost a few weeks of productivity. We're\n               dealing with wildfire like we've never seen before. In the province, but certainly\n               in Cariboo-Chilcotin. Again, you lose that time. You lose that opportunity to conduct some of this work. But the challenge is not necessarily accessing it through BCTS. We just have to be\n               able to access it, period. The specific permit that I'm speaking about was in a place\n               that was already.... It had been consumed by fire. We were trying to access that. I just think that Bill 14, probably more than ever, really puts BCTS in a spot to\n               be a general contractor. Trust me when I say this, and I'll certainly look for clarification\n               on that, but if the notion is that BCTS will hire someone like San Jose Logging or\n               Hytest logging to do that work and then retain the logs, then it would strike me that\n               there's going to be another level of cost in there. Now, maybe the permitting process\n               doesn't improve, maybe the permit.... I don't know. We'll look for clarity on that,\n               obviously, in committee stage. But we have amazing contractors in our area: San Jose, I just mentioned; PHL; Hytest\n               Timber; AI Logging; the McNeil family in the south. We have some incredible logging\n               families that have been literally doing it for generations, and they're good at it.\n               I've been to second-generation growth areas that we can absolutely log again. I've seen how modernized logging has become in some areas throughout our riding. The\n               one that I'm most absolutely amazed by is one that the Williams Lake First Nation\n               did through Borland Creek Logging, where they've contemplated everything. They've\n               contemplated leaving blinds for the wildlife to be protected in hunting. They've contemplated\n               berry picking on the side of the road so that it's accessible to elders that might\n               not be able to get around that much. I guess the point that I'm trying to make is that these logging companies have done\n               such an amazing job, but where they're finding a pinch point is getting through some\n               of the paperwork. I think the member from Vanderhoof mentioned the absolute costs that all of these\n               companies are dealing with. It's not just.... We talk about stumpage. Yes, stumpage\n               is a challenge for sure. But it's everything else. The cost of diesel, the cost of\n               everything else has risen so much, and it is having a very serious effect. There was never a time more important than right now for us, collectively, as a province,\n               that we have to be competitive. We have to engage that world market. We definitely\n               have to get our costs down. I don't see how this bill will actually do that. I'll\n               hope for some clarity on that. I want to talk a little bit about wildfire as well. I know that there is some interest\n               in getting to some of those blocks quicker. I can appreciate that very much. I think\n               that it is a very important part of the process. Not just cleaning up what is out\n               there in the hinterland, but it is also a matter of getting planting, getting on that. I do know that in places like the Elephant Hill fire in Cache Creek.... That fire burned\n               in 2017. We only got to it two years ago. That is a very serious concern. When you\n               think of that area, Madam Speaker, I don't know if you're familiar with it, but if\n               it pleases the House.... It would take you a couple of hours to drive across that area.\n               It burned in 2017, and here we are cleaning it up two years ago. Honestly, shame on\n               us. We talk about this being sustainable. We talk about it all the time. It is. I've\n               seen it with my own eyes. But for us not to be motivated to get that done is shocking\n               to me. There are so many other things happening on the landscape. It's not just replanting\n               the trees. We're seeing weeds that we've never seen before. We're seeing a landscape\n               that, really, is in chaos itself. I just don't know how this bill is going to help\n               with that Madam Speaker, I speak often about permitting, and the reason I speak about it is\n               because I know that it is a very serious challenge. I've spoken many times to you\n               about Dan Perrin, but it really is valuable to make that comparison over and over. Nothing happens without a permit. I'm talking about employment. I'm talking about\n               revenue to the province. I'm talking about all of the things that come because that\n               permit is approved. And the second it's approved, contractors start spending money.\n               They start hiring people. They start buying equipment. All of that is revenue to this\n               province. It's all taxable. It's income tax. It's tax on equipment. It is all taxable.\n               So we really need to move these permits through this House. And I just....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720296","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a few brief remarks, too, that I want to make regarding Bill 14 and the Forests\n               Statutes Amendment Act. I certainly share a number of similar opinions with the members\n               for Nechako Lakes and also Peace River North. I guess I'm always happy to hear that we're in a position to speak about forestry\n               in this chamber and bring comments from some of the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f91214d679aa433556f07ab6e47b3b39b0c7ecd2aced33b77b21d12dfbf94996"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef4ffffae440fa6430ee2f3b55ceb9b07c73d08dd37ab45143b80c98c6f099aa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c37d4b00c58635b1fa54833b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721366,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"We know that this government loves to give out lucrative contracts to their friends\n               and insiders. Doug Caul, a recently retired Deputy Minister, was hired by this government\n               to give advice on amending DRIPA. Mr. Caul was the Deputy Minister when DRIPA was\n               passed in 2019. His contract","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721366","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We know that this government loves to give out lucrative contracts to their friends\n               and insiders. Doug Caul, a recently retired Deputy Minister, was hired by this government\n               to give advice on amending DRIPA. Mr. Caul was the Deputy Minister when DRIPA was\n               passed in 2019. His contract","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0497a14b2c6d4396bf91eb7246174507fedf12383d578e357cd4243cd53cfd0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["522aedf94fd3c04843cf3a669a4f7fceb37834ba6e4bf1c4b8ec60745195bd07"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8b34ae081506c75b61f065f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721367,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to introduce a petition signed by 689 residents of the South Cariboo demanding\n               that the province and the Ministry of Health provide full-time access to the 100 Mile\n               Hospital emergency department in a reliable and consistent manner.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721367","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to introduce a petition signed by 689 residents of the South Cariboo demanding\n               that the province and the Ministry of Health provide full-time access to the 100 Mile\n               Hospital emergency department in a reliable and consistent manner.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68ab3beb81432bee8db4ee0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721373,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise sadly to honour the life of a remarkable woman, Cecilia DeRose. She passed\n               away, sadly, on April 8, 2026. Cecilia was deeply respected as an Elder in our community. She was a tireless advocate\n               for the preservation and renewal of Indigenous language, culture and traditional knowledge\n               across the interior of British Columbia. Her life was rooted in the land. Those who knew her would often find her out in the\n               wilderness picking berries, gathering pine needles or carefully collecting birch bark\n               for the traditional baskets that she so beautifully created. But Cecilia's greatest gift was not only the knowledge that she carried, but it was\n               the knowledge that she shared. She generously taught the traditions, values and skills\n               of Indigenous Peoples to anyone who wished to learn them. Her children, her grandchildren\n               and great-grandchildren were constant companions in that learning, and through them,\n               her teachings will continue for generations. Her influence extended far beyond the family, reaching classrooms and communities\n               throughout the region where she mentored and guided countless people. In recognition\n               of her extraordinary contributions, Cecilia was named the Indspire laureate in 2018,\n               an honour she held very close to her heart. In 2023, the Thompson Rivers University awarded her an honourary doctorate of letters,\n               acknowledging a lifetime devoted to cultural knowledge and education. Education was\n               profoundly important to Cecilia. This was reflected in the recent release of her book, One Arrow Left , which continues to share her wisdom and story to others. Cecilia DeRose leaves behind a powerful legacy, one of culture, teaching and connection\n               to the land. Her impact will be felt for generations. She was loved by so many. I've\n               had conversations with people like Dan Peron and with friends from the rodeo world that have shared that she was like a mother\n               to them as they rodeoed across this province, not to mention that she was an amazing\n               doctor on the side. She is survived by DeeDee Mobs, Charlene Ostrom, Leonard DeRose, Danny DeRose and,\n               of course, David DeRose, who is the self-professed favourite son of the family. He's a great friend of mine. On behalf of this House, I extend my deepest condolences to her family, friends and\n               all of those whose lives she touched. May we all remember and honour the teachings\n               she so generously shared.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721373","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise sadly to honour the life of a remarkable woman, Cecilia DeRose. She passed\n               away, sadly, on April 8, 2026. Cecilia was deeply respected as an Elder in our community. She was a tireless advocate\n               for the preservation and renewal of Indigenous language, culture and traditional knowledge\n               across the interior of British Columbia. Her life was root","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","label":"Indigenous culture"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","label":"Indigenous culture","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5c6f02d27cc1ce2e4caba2c9dda2fd56fc2015fd929266303c97f7c9bdfdd52"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33a34221beade2d7e44ac7515150338ee12de1b6712b52b0bf2676bef27bf775"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45630a1a1835270f46deee0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729037,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to introduce two constituents of mine today, Leigh Granberg and Laura\n               Dewar. They are here representing Watch Lake/Green Lake fire departments. They've\n               had a very, very busy morning. I'm grateful to the Ministers of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship; Forestry; and also Public Safety, along with the Speaker of the House, for meeting\n               with them this morning. Thank you very much. Please make them very welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729037","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to introduce two constituents of mine today, Leigh Granberg and Laura\n               Dewar. They are here representing Watch Lake/Green Lake fire departments. They've\n               had a very, very busy morning. I'm grateful to the Ministers of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship; Forestry; and also Public Safety, along with the Speaker of the House, for meeting\n               with t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52713","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Famine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Famine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035753","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hunger","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035753","label":"Hunger","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52713","label":"Famine","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47948c3780f87ae8c037b21bae2c335bbb32409f890681a22921c4141e712079","9b59125fb02be0582999c94599dbf6bcff36d2d12ea7d5569641d67017478ab9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["450b51a343d01051ab80f2f358920c2e08f5f8ebeca3b9bad123413321fbdd32"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5dc2d49a12ad8d9775013afd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729042,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"The province is co-governing B.C.'s legislative agenda with groups of leaders that\n               aren't elected by all British Columbians, who have \"no obligation to the public interest\n               for the other 5.7 million British Columbians.\" Those are not my words. Those are the\n               words of Geoffrey Moyse. Members of this House are elected to govern on behalf of every single British Columbian.\n               During these new negotiations, who in government speaks on behalf of the 5.7 million\n               British Columbians that are not at the table?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729042","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The province is co-governing B.C.'s legislative agenda with groups of leaders that\n               aren't elected by all British Columbians, who have \"no obligation to the public interest\n               for the other 5.7 million British Columbians.\" Those are not my words. Those are the\n               words of Geoffrey Moyse. Members of this House are elected to govern on behalf of every single Bri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10621ccacf2916558e1eae804cc3137788bb6a793e76d85d31737f3172c5149d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c3c1fb092dcc6fa251569cad2ed445c10410357ce4a1064c8249b49f56caf13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61bba805d525e07ad0f1b02a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729043,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729043","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4b685a4cfda76e11655021a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729044,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"On April 1, the Premier said, and I quote: \"It is our international reputation on the line, which is why\n               the federal government has committed to being our partner in this work, but they haven't\n               cut the cheque and we can't pay the rent with promises.\" As the minister just confirmed, the federal government has cut the cheque. It's $100\n               million for Vancouver to cover the security costs. My question today is: how much money is the provincial government committing to this, and where in the budget can we find it?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729044","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On April 1, the Premier said, and I quote: \"It is our international reputation on the line, which is why\n               the federal government has committed to being our partner in this work, but they haven't\n               cut the cheque and we can't pay the rent with promises.\" As the minister just confirmed, the federal government has cut the cheque. It's $100\n               million for Vancouv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4842308900a3a330f63a2bfe20609227e16d943c92ef90c9fa4135612fb667ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9180de0e18dee55b4c8bcf66d1c229fbea4854a017f8054fd72e9c35f289d0ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4b823028f08cdc3d7b0813c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729047,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks to leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729047","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks to leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-470473e4dd7678c25a40a41a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729055,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize one of my constituents, an amazing person. His name is Lawrence Joiner. And I do rise to recognize his remarkable achievements. This is a man whose life absolutely reflects the very spirit of British Columbia. He was raised in Chilliwack. Lawrence was a cowboy from the very beginning. He grew up surrounded by family, hard\n               work and wide-open fields that shaped his character. From his days riding horses near Sardis Elementary and racing with the Chilliwack riding club, the cowboy way of life was never just something he did. It was truly who he was. Lawrence carried that spirit with him throughout his life. Together with his wife,\n               Joan, and family, he built a life grounded in honesty and determination and quiet strength.\n               He raised four boys, teaching them the lessons about hard work, laughter, resilience\n               and pride in a job well done. His true calling was on the ranch, and that ranch was the OK Ranch — 16,000 acres at Big Bar. There, Lawrence built not just a livelihood but a legacy. The K brand became known far and wide, and the ranch became a place where stories were shared,\n               memories were made and the work of each day was faced with determination. Life on the ranch was never easy. There were always fences to mend, machines to fix and, of course, miles of work still ahead. But Lawrence approached\n               it all with a grin and a simple philosophy: that he was blessed to do the work he\n               loved. And to him, ranching was never just labour; it was a life well lived. Those who knew Lawrence would remember a man who was steady and strong and deeply\n               kind, a man with a cowboy's heart who loved every moment of the ride. In remembering\n               him today, we recognize something special: the kind of man you don't often find but\n               one whose legacy will live on in the land, the family he raised and the community\n               that knew and loved him so much. He was an amazing man. May he rest in peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729055","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize one of my constituents, an amazing person. His name is Lawrence Joiner. And I do rise to recognize his remarkable achievements. This is a man whose life absolutely reflects the very spirit of British Columbia. He was raised in Chilliwack. Lawrence was a cowboy from the very beginning. He grew up surrounded by family, hard\n               work and wide-open fields that shap","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfc7ee17eac24ae3aa29d12e70e2943e964f8c262f4fcf0e6bf16f54b567617c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05992395eea9ad65530d043b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752224,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"It appears that our hero will complete his NHL contract with the Montreal Canadiens,\n               closing the book on a remarkable 15-year career. Carey Price gave the Canadiens elite\n               goaltending and a chance to compete every single season. At his best, he was one of the most dominant goaltenders of his generation. His 2014-2015\n               season remains one of the greatest ever by any goalie — 44 wins and a sweep of the\n               game's top honours: the Hart Memorial Trophy, the Vezina Trophy, the William M. Jennings\n               Trophy and the Ted Lindsay Award. He's also helped bring gold home for Canada at the\n               end of the 2014 Olympics, the World Cup of Hockey and the IIHF World Junior Championship.\n               His contract ends as the Canadiens' all-time leader with wins of 361 finishing his\n               career and more than 700 games played. But for those of us in my riding, his story is about more than just statistics. Carey\n               was raised in Anahim Lake in the heart of the Chilcotin, and to pursue hockey, he\n               travelled hundreds of kilometres to Williams Lake — long winter roads and even a plane\n               on occasion. Carey is known throughout the Cariboo-Chilcotin as a true gentleman. He's remained\n               connected and continues to give back in meaningful ways. He's donated game-worn gear\n               to local auctions, roped in the arena at the Williams Lake Stampede. He's personally\n               sponsored the indoor rodeo and continues to support youth and community across British\n               Columbia. Those actions speak volumes about the kind of man he is and why so many\n               people in Cariboo-Chilcotin look up to him. From the frozen ponds in the Chilcotin to the bright lights of Montreal, Carey is\n               absolutely the pride of Cariboo-Chilcotin. While members from Kelowna may like to\n               claim him as their own, those of us in Cariboo-Chilcotin know Carey Price will always\n               have a home right here. Please help me congratulate No. 31, Carey Price, the Montreal Canadiens goaltender.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752224","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It appears that our hero will complete his NHL contract with the Montreal Canadiens,\n               closing the book on a remarkable 15-year career. Carey Price gave the Canadiens elite\n               goaltending and a chance to compete every single season. At his best, he was one of the most dominant goaltenders of his generation. His 2014-2015\n               season remains one of the greatest ev","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:735732","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armouries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Auctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083656","label":"Auctions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:735732","label":"Armouries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13660855af95f8603bf273c237d0a1ad28d7e06ae5b5021e7e94c5d195be663c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31e6fc8f471fad13512e95c240e3e95d4f653e4e1df504cdd400ebb3e7738b60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5446ef9041df33917ef009b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752226,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"It gives me excitement to be here on Beef Day. I want to point out a couple of people\n               myself. Kenny Ilnicki is representing a beautiful spot on earth called Cariboo-Chilcotin. He's here today. And I want to thank Cory Lepine, who is the province's cow cop,\n               for the work that he does for us. I'm grateful to both those gents. Please make them very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752226","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It gives me excitement to be here on Beef Day. I want to point out a couple of people\n               myself. Kenny Ilnicki is representing a beautiful spot on earth called Cariboo-Chilcotin. He's here today. And I want to thank Cory Lepine, who is the province's cow cop,\n               for the work that he does for us. I'm grateful to both those gents. Please make them very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c27790847341afbf5bfa47acddeee5be2d49657df6d0b452bfa6ef71c83fd9d8","bb70ffb481e0301504420f46571eceba17ee1eec36ca9950d1c572dc550c58ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac5237b0235973ed9819a2cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752227,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the opportunity to go first here this evening. As always, I feel pretty\n               glad to bring greetings from Cariboo-Chilcotin to you, especially at two o'clock in the morning. I don't think it'll be any surprise. I am certainly in support of the hoist motion,\n               and I will try to explain why — I think that's important — rather than, as some of\n               my colleagues have indicated, just saying: \"hoist motion.\" This bill is not done. It's not complete. I have debated bills, like 31, where we\n               spent a day on definitions alone — a day on definitions alone. The words that are\n               in this bill.... The reason for this hoist is to clear up some of those issues. I'm frankly shocked. I mean, I've heard the member from Penticton speak opposed to\n               this motion, but that's all that I've heard for opposition. The leader of the Green\n               Party the other day mentioned in his comments that it'd be great to hear why this\n               shouldn't go forward, why it shouldn't be contemplated. I really think we need to\n               contemplate this. It's difficult to talk about what we should change without talking about how it impacts\n               people. I can tell you right now. If you talk to the Cunningham family at the Flat\n               Lake fire in 70 Mile that spent a year trying to figure out why they lost so much\n               because of a controlled burn that happened just outside their fence line.... The definitions\n               that are in this bill, that are not defined, could have dragged that entire FOI off\n               the rails. It's not fair to British Columbians, and I get a sense that members in this place\n               know that. Otherwise, they would be standing up and defending this. We have had so many serious situations develop in this province that we do need a\n               moment to take a look at this. The definitions that need to be defined before this\n               bill goes forward are those definitions that so many members have been speaking about.\n               So many of us are concerned about it. Frankly, I am very concerned that somebody will be able to determine whether or not\n               an FOI goes forward or doesn't go forward because of language that we're not willing\n               to even consider over the next six months. I can appreciate the concern about the fatal action that may happen if this passes.\n               I absolutely understand the points that the member from Penticton made, but this is But this is serious legislation. I haven't been here for a long time. We've debated\n               some pretty serious legislation in the time that I've been here, but this one has\n               conjured up feelings right across the province. I really am speaking in favour of\n               the infamous hoist motion. I think that we do need to just slow down and better understand\n               some of these terms that have not been defined. It's not right that they weren't defined,\n               and they needed to be defined in the bill. This gives us an opportunity to better\n               understand how these words are going to impact people, and frankly that's my biggest\n               concern. The words that we have heard and that are undefined that need to be defined. If this\n               motion is to pass, words like malicious, abusive.... We've heard them in here repeatedly.\n               We've all heard them for two days it feels like, maybe even longer. But it's important\n               to talk about these words because the reality is people's livelihoods depend on us\n               scrutinizing this bill. Their livelihoods, their lives. I've got a woman trying to get freedom of information about her deceased mother. What\n               would be the liability around that? I don't know. Potentially because we're worried\n               about how that woman became deceased? But why she wants the information is because\n               she doesn't know if something is lurking in her own body. She is trying to get that\n               information, but because this is not defined.... And because somebody decides that her\n               asking for that information is too broad... I don't know. I suppose asking for someone's\n               entire health file is a pretty broad question. Not for me because I'm not that old. This is serious. It is really serious. We've seen loss. We've seen serious health\n               issues across this province, and to have this bill go forward without this hoist motion\n               taking the time to consider these definitions, I think that we set ourselves up to\n               fail. I really honestly believe that. I have experienced the challenge myself with\n               respect to trying to get FOIs, but in the case of that Cunningham family, it took\n               us months to traverse this system. If we don't take the time to get this right, that\n               could have been years for them. Any person at any point in that experience could derail this family from trying to\n               find out why they've lost two cabins, why they've lost hundreds of thousands of dollars\n               of their own timber on private property. Because somebody decides that they're malicious\n               and because we didn't take the time, because we didn't stop for a minute.... I agree.\n               The conversation has been happening for months, years about this bill. I've heard\n               all kinds of things about a committee that potentially put all kinds of information\n               forth that wasn't contemplated. Well, shame on us. This is an opportunity. I'm not speaking about the politics of\n               this. I don't really care about that. It's two o'clock in the morning. I care about\n               my constituents. I care that the Cunningham family can navigate a system that should\n               serve them as British Columbians. That doesn't get derailed because their question\n               is excessively broad. Why we lost $100,000 worth of timber, or why this young woman\n               is told that maybe she's malicious, or maybe the health authority is too afraid to\n               provide the information. We have to take the time. We have to use this hoist motion in a way that will allow\n               us just to take a breath here. It's not just me saying this. Media outlets are saying\n               it. British Columbians are saying it. I have not had It's not just me saying this. Media outlets are saying it. British Columbians are saying it. I have not had one email — not one — that said we shouldn't stop this.\n               I haven't had an email that said: \"Wow, get out there and support Bill 9. Don't worry about the hoist.\" I haven't had anybody email me that. And I'd love\n               to hear from anybody, to please stand up and tell me that they're receiving a bunch\n               of support and reasons why this shouldn't be contemplated. I think we're making a big mistake to not, at the very least, stop and consider these\n               definitions. And frankly, again, I opened up with the fact that we have debated bills; at times, we have spent days,\n               hours, talking about a few words, because those words are important, and we all know\n               it here. This is exactly why this hoist needs to pass. Somebody has to take the time to sit\n               down and define what repetitious.... Madam Speaker, nobody knows the word repetitious\n               like you do. What is excessively broad? What is unreasonably interfering with the\n               operations of government? Those definitions have to be defined before this bill passes.\n               I mean, I could never support the bill or the motion. Sorry, I have come to support the motion.\n               We need to go back to the drawing board on this. I don't think this is a big ask to consider this motion. I can appreciate the frustration that this bill has created,\n               and I can appreciate the emotion that it's conjuring up in this House. We're all tired. It has been a long couple of days, and I get that. But for heaven's sake, stop and consider this motion. Stop and consider it, I'm begging you. It is going\n               to have a profound effect. We'll be standing in this same place, two years from now,\n               arguing back and forth about what could have happened right now. I can't stress it enough. Our residents are extremely frustrated, I think, with the impact that the bill is going to have.\n               I had a couple of calls today with respect to this hoist motion as well. Granted,\n               people were trying to understand what it meant, but I haven't heard a real good reason\n               to not support this motion. In fact, I haven't heard any, other than from the member\n               from Penticton, and I appreciate that because I do think that the reason for us to be here is to\n               debate these things, to consider. I've learned a lot in this chamber. I can assure you of that. And I would love to\n               better understand these terms. I would love to be a part of any kind of a committee\n               that might take a moment to consider this motion, pass this motion, and let's go get to work. I would be terribly supportive of that. The effect that this has had on the Cunninghams is staggering, and I can't say that enough. I've sat with that family. I went through\n               the process with them. The redactions in the reports were unbelievable. Unbelievable. And knowing that those redactions, because we didn't stop tonight.... We didn't stop\n               tonight knowing that those redactions could be a straight denial. We're not going\n               to give you that information. We're not going to tell you where that fire was lit.\n               We are not going to tell you why it was lit. And we're not going to tell you or explain\n               to you why your losses are above a quarter million dollars. Because we didn't take\n               a simple pause. I actually now understand. Because of debate, I understand more broadly the concern\n               around the impact that this may have on that bill. But it doesn't mean that we shouldn't\n               stop and contemplate this. My riding is not unique. I've talked to people in the Lower Mainland, I've talked to constituents all over the province that have suffered horrendous\n               loss. It doesn't need to be financial. It doesn't need to be the impacts because of\n               wildfire, although they are many. I mean, this is a I mean, this is a true passion of mine, Madam Speaker. The losses on the north shore\n               of the Shuswap Lake were staggering. And you know better than anybody that I am completely\n               supportive of B.C. wildfire and everybody in that system. They do so much for our\n               province. But the reality is, shame on us if this bill doesn't improve through this process.\n               I just can't imagine for a moment that we wouldn't stop. What happens if this bill\n               does not pass for six months? What happens? I'd like to hear from members, and I mean that genuinely. I would like to hear from\n               members what the impact on British Columbia is if this bill just sits for six months\n               or if it has to come back because of this, if it has to come back in a different format\n               or if it has to wait a year. I mean, it would be hard to say that it's been rushed\n               if it's taken four or five years to get to this point. We've had a committee that\n               offered up 20 or 30 potential solutions that weren't contemplated. And so the whole notion that the member for Surrey–White Rock has introduced this motion to slow this process down, the notion that the Green Party\n               has been supportive of the motion, the notion that there hasn't been a lot of information\n               provided as to why we shouldn't do this, doesn't make any sense to me. I'm willing\n               to bet that most people in this room have had some experience with this, with our\n               own constituents. I am completely in favour of this motion. I absolutely am begging the government to\n               reconsider the fact that this bill is not complete. It's not complete. And this hoist\n               will give an opportunity to figure out these definitions. and this is what I'm most\n               worried about. I've said it now a number of times, but I'm going to say it one more time. You cannot\n               not define words like \"malicious\" or \"unreasonably interfere with operations of government\"\n               or \"repetitious\" or \"excessively broad.\" I don't know what the motive is for any of\n               that. We are here to serve British Columbia, and I am frustrated to think that we\n               can't agree on this point. I know we're all tired tonight. I get that. But I am glad that the motion came forward.\n               I'm thankful to the member for Surrey–White Rock for bringing it forward. And I do just want to read it into the record for anybody\n               that.... I've got it here. The motion is simply this: that the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled\n               Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act of 2026, be amended\n               by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting \"for six months hence.\" I am begging the government to consider this for all of the serious reasons that I've\n               mentioned here this evening. I definitely look forward to more debate, and I would\n               love to hear some comments from the government side to explain why this hoist motion\n               is not a good idea. Potentially, we'll hear that from some of the independents, but\n               we haven't heard it from the government, and that is frustrating to say the least\n               because I think they owe British Columbians to explain why there is no value in slowing\n               down, stopping, etc., to at least consider this. I'm grateful for the time tonight, and I look forward to hearing more debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752227","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the opportunity to go first here this evening. As always, I feel pretty\n               glad to bring greetings from Cariboo-Chilcotin to you, especially at two o'clock in the morning. I don't think it'll be any surprise. I am certainly in support of the hoist motion,\n               and I will try to explain why — I think that's important — rather than, as some of\n               my col","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c35cbec9ab3d1490656a4f2f4a08269582d88d62da307a4dd85e0f869ad7dc25"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d54317c1d24039ffe8cf33e5774d109ddb64ee72afe92c63ab4077e289a59d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08b2d055310830c0f132f06e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752228,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Proud to welcome four people to our precinct. They're not strangers here. They are\n               on a whirlwind tour of ministry offices. They're representing the Thompson-Nicola\n               regional district. Barbara Roden, Michael Grenier, Scott Hildebrandt, Corbin Kelly. An amazing team of representation from this very important area in our province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752228","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Proud to welcome four people to our precinct. They're not strangers here. They are\n               on a whirlwind tour of ministry offices. They're representing the Thompson-Nicola\n               regional district. Barbara Roden, Michael Grenier, Scott Hildebrandt, Corbin Kelly. An amazing team of representation from this very important area in our province.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f985b696a779e7974c4286f42258cbe83f6c8a1d7a9086f53d7630056e707af6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17e51512a89f25b0798381e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752229,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752229","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72b32acad940a2cd17a548d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017274,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017274","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb50944e1815ebe5108fa1a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017276,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"The committee on Bill 9 reports progress and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017276","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The committee on Bill 9 reports progress and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12a971295854e95fb8c5e393","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036460,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"This is an open invitation to visit the heart of British Columbia, Cariboo-Chilcotin. I have often had the opportunity to visit communities throughout our region, and\n               at every stop, I am reminded why I am so proud to represent Cariboo-Chilcotin. Whether it is the West Chilcotin, where neighbours still gather and stories still\n               matter, or the incredible Savona bean dinner and fire department fundraiser, where\n               communities come together to support one another, these events are about more than\n               just entertainment. They are about community spirit. In Ashcroft, people come from all over to paint the landscape and capture the beauty\n               of this community on canvas. Artists from all over British Columbia are inspired by\n               the rugged beauty and unique landscape at the yearly plein air event. These two communities\n               hosted the CPKC holiday train last year at Christmas, where the Barenaked Ladies entertained\n               hundreds of people in Savona and Ashcroft. Cache Creek graffiti days is absolutely amazing. If you've never stood near a drag\n               racing strip and literally heard the thunder echoing through the valley from the roar\n               of these fast cars, you're missing out. You can enjoy the burnout contest and, certainly,\n               the sock hop too. Beautiful classic cars converge from all over, and the pride in\n               that community is absolutely impossible to miss. Along the way, you'll find bakeries\n               and farm gardens like you can't imagine — fresh produce, home baking, roadside stands,\n               even a taco shop. Then there's the Fishing Highway. Now let me tell you a secret about the Fishing Highway.\n               The fish are huge, and they are biting. The lodges and the campgrounds are amazing,\n               but the events are even bigger. Amazing fishing derbies like Deka Lake, Sulphurous Lake, Sheridan Lake, to name a few. Every year the Fishing Highway 24 association\n               hosts the legendary outhouse races. Yes, Madam Speaker, I said outhouse races. And\n               if you've never witnessed people in costume racing decorated outhouses on skis in\n               the middle of winter with crowds cheering them on, then you haven't fully experienced\n               the Cariboo spirit. Hot July Nights in 100 Mile House is a massive car show. The lakers car club does\n               the same thing in Williams Lake. Cars come from all over western Canada, the U.S.\n               — thousands of people in attendance and hundreds of cars along so many events. The 108 heritage site stands as a stunning reminder of years gone by, preserving the\n               history and character for so many future generations. We're blessed with incredible First Nations culture, celebrations like powwows in\n               communities like Stuktous, Iskettum and of course Williams Lake First Nation that\n               bring together tradition, drumming, dancing, community and culture in ways that are\n               deeply meaningful. And let me assure you, Madam Speaker, that golfing is pretty darn good too, whether\n               that's at Williams Lake Golf Club, the Coyote Rock Golf Course, Tobiano or the 108\n               Resort. They're beautiful courses. And since you're coming, don't forget your mountain\n               bike, because we've got some of the best mountain bike trails in all of British Columbia. Now, if you want rodeo action, oh my goodness is this the place for you. From Bridge\n               Lake and the Interlakes to the Logan Parent bull-riding event to Alkali Lake, from\n               Anahim Lake and Stone, the Spring Classic Indoor Rodeo, high school rodeo and Little\n               Britches events, and of course the legendary Clinton Rodeo. This region knows rodeo, but don't forget the Clinton Ball. The Anahim Stampede is\n               something to see — a wonderful parade, a barbecue. This special stampede and community\n               knows exactly how to throw a party. And if you're on your way to Anahim, don't forget\n               to stop at Tatla Lake for a nice piece of pie or potentially a farm market. Of course, there is the world-famous Williams Lake Stampede every July long weekend.\n               The parade is incredible. The rodeo action is some of the best you're going to see\n               in the entire world. It is truly one of British Columbia's premier sporting events.\n               So many events that weekend — pancake breakfast, stakeouts and of course stock car\n               racing at the incredible Thunder Mountain Speedway. To say I'm proud would be an understatement. Come and experience our museums, our\n               farm markets. Come and enjoy the incredible hospitality in our lodges, our fishing\n               resorts, spas, guest ranches, hotels and restaurants. Come and fish our lakes, ride\n               our trails, attend our rodeos and meet the people who make our region so incredibly\n               special. This is really only a small sampling of what you're going to find in the Cariboo-Chilcotin. There's simply so much to see and do. I hope you'll come and visit Cariboo-Chilcotin this summer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036460","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This is an open invitation to visit the heart of British Columbia, Cariboo-Chilcotin. I have often had the opportunity to visit communities throughout our region, and\n               at every stop, I am reminded why I am so proud to represent Cariboo-Chilcotin. Whether it is the West Chilcotin, where neighbours still gather and stories still\n               matter, or the incredible Savona bean dinn","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["89cc61f232074c5f9009b50bbcc6e559b5d54ab76ab8a8ebd0473a795b7e3e07"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e28ec9f70061277f2cdd3a60d92205c6e2a806a9646fd62f2ae0233f4ea1c44"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-482489f7e3ba31346652b8dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036461,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm certainly proud today to introduce a great friend of mine. Her name is Amber\n               Nehring. She is a fierce advocate for all things western. She's involved with cattle\n               producers, but her mainstay is that she is the president of the B.C. Cowboy Hall of\n               Fame. She is joined today with some guests that are visiting the precinct from Europe, and\n               that is Nancy Fox and Stuart Boodle. Very happy to have them here. Looking forward\n               to a piece of pie, potentially, and a little bit of a tour of the Legislature. Please make them feel very welcome","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036461","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm certainly proud today to introduce a great friend of mine. Her name is Amber\n               Nehring. She is a fierce advocate for all things western. She's involved with cattle\n               producers, but her mainstay is that she is the president of the B.C. Cowboy Hall of\n               Fame. She is joined today with some guests that are visiting the precinct from Europe, and\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037635","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wharfs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037635","label":"Wharfs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b9295e2f5c0f830d02079ab55482be8ec2ddfec74fd83b7cb189533dff76938"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-106ead6cf62d38e8f76e5e61","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036462,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"The committee on Bill 9 reports progress and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036462","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The committee on Bill 9 reports progress and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7da4e33636489fd8596b44e6","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933909,"date":"2026-05-26T12:00:00+00:00","title":"CROWN LAND AND FINANCIAL TRANSPARENCY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m247-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m247-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933909","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d03fd010e66674447319d707","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036463,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Certainly pleased to introduce two gentlemen here today, Luca Calabrese and Matteo\n               Calabrese. Luca is a student of UVic. Matteo is working at a mill in Williams Lake.\n               They're here to visit their brother and our intern, Massimo Calabrese. I hope that\n               everybody will welcome them. I believe they're going to be touring the precinct a\n               little bit later today. Please give them a big round of applause and welcome them here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036463","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Certainly pleased to introduce two gentlemen here today, Luca Calabrese and Matteo\n               Calabrese. Luca is a student of UVic. Matteo is working at a mill in Williams Lake.\n               They're here to visit their brother and our intern, Massimo Calabrese. I hope that\n               everybody will welcome them. I believe they're going to be touring the precinct a\n               little b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["127699fb5f80d4755b781ae3625640a7a8312e347e74fb663edd3b1833e26a7d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97ce06707b9a5df803dd58dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036464,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm excited to announce and welcome Michelle Laplace. Now, this is a woman from Williams\n               Lake, and she's a powerful woman. This is the person that might phone to tell you\n               that you are late for the airplane, so this is a very important person in our community.\n               I've volunteered much with her, and I'm so glad that she's here. She's joined by her\n               friend Jillian Chaney, who grew up in Williams Lake, now resides in Victoria. I'm excited to welcome them both here. We're going to do a tour and have lunch, so\n               I'm really excited about that. Welcome to these two women.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036464","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm excited to announce and welcome Michelle Laplace. Now, this is a woman from Williams\n               Lake, and she's a powerful woman. This is the person that might phone to tell you\n               that you are late for the airplane, so this is a very important person in our community.\n               I've volunteered much with her, and I'm so glad that she's here. She's joined by her\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Parole","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945722","label":"Parole","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbce76f7ab36a4fb509b6c2b91aba7fb7149e218e649bf291d521f2617fe531d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d645c106f60ae1c9d20a699","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036465,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lorne Doerkson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Office of the Premier and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036465","member_id":"bc-mla-27","member_name":"Lorne Doerkson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Office of the Premier and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b747acf6ede3a866944aef7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317129,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I think the member, as a former political staffer, understands\n               the crucial role that these staff play in government. Now, he wouldn't have taken\n               the job if it were a nonsense job.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317129","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I think the member, as a former political staffer, understands\n               the crucial role that these staff play in government. Now, he wouldn't have taken\n               the job if it were a nonsense job.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child custody","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035697","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Home education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035697","label":"Home education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","label":"Women workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","label":"Single parent families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51813","label":"Child custody","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99e87adc1489d033f1b39f9e1cff970d944ebc6e8ab60d095bd700b8973abed9","fd9f71fcb0b0f275fed579fb36dcd42e5d0123dddb3c072cb4896b848d3cd79f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b40e59832e90031a9e19e7f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317130,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question. My commitment to British Columbians is clear, and I'm happy to make it on the record.\n               There's a police investigation underway. They'll release what information they can\n               at the conclusion of their investigation. The coroner is likely to play a significant\n               role here. There may be a coroner's inquest that will reveal additional information. Whether it's a coroner's inquest or a public inquiry, we are committing, I am committing,\n               on the record that we will use any tools available to ensure that all questions are\n               answered about this tragedy, so, at a minimum, from the wreckage, we can say with\n               confidence we've done everything possible to prevent anything like this from ever\n               happening again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317130","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question. My commitment to British Columbians is clear, and I'm happy to make it on the record.\n               There's a police investigation underway. They'll release what information they can\n               at the conclusion of their investigation. The coroner is likely to play a significant\n               role here. There may be a coroner's inquest that will reve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4361952075e73c54b48fb4dd7bcc7c7f8d77b383e0705bb2cd572401ef76849e","e8b5a2123aed8772a04e98f725ecbd0624fb9326f7e83dd72b74c0390232a435"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdeb7d78a363e1baa1f16140","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327958,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to address the war unfolding in Iran and across the broader Middle East. First and foremost, our thoughts are with all of the innocent civilians across the\n               Middle East and in Iran whose lives are in danger as I stand and speak here right\n               now. My thoughts are with the Iranian families, who have suffered under the tyranny\n               of a brutal dictatorship, for the people of Iran, whose only demand was freedom and\n               democracy and who are now facing the horrors of war. This is an exceptionally dangerous and volatile situation. We pray that they are protected.\n               We pray that all Canadians and British Columbians and all permanent residents who\n               are presently in the Middle East and Iran are safe. As tourist destinations, hotels,\n               airports and other public places in neighbouring are being targeted by Iran, I'm thinking\n               of the more than 85,000 Canadians in the region. Iranian attacks on innocent civilians\n               anywhere are reprehensible and must stop immediately. In this environment, I urge us all to recognize the courage of our armed service members\n               in Canada who are often called on to protect civilians in situations like this, and\n               recognize the anxiety of their families about possible deployment. For now, Global\n               Affairs Canada is providing consular support to help Canadians throughout the region,\n               and we hope that everyone is able to make it home to Canada as quickly as possible.\n               We pray that escalation does not result in calling on our courageous soldiers, navy\n               members, air force members to sacrifice for our country yet again. We could see a turning point begin to unfold at the end of December when massive protests\n               broke out across Iran. They were driven by economic collapse, out-of-control inflation\n               and demands for the end of the Islamic Republic. It was, indeed, a moment of hope.\n               Authorities responded with a violent crackdown. It was a horrific atrocity, the mass\n               murder of thousands of protesters, a regime using violence, arbitrary arrests and\n               intimidation tactics against its own people. When things like this happen on the other side of the world, it can feel far away.\n               But for many people here in British Columbia, it is close to our hearts. For weeks,\n               people attending rallies in Vancouver have been calling for an end to this oppressive\n               regime. For many Iranian Canadians, people in Canada and across the world, the fall of the\n               Ayatollah has come as welcome news. He was a butcher, a tyrant and a coward. But the\n               fallout causes deep worry. People worry for their loved ones in Iran and in the region.\n               They worry for the future of their country But the fallout causes deep worry. People worry for their loved ones in Iran and in\n               the region and they worry for the future of their country. They worry about Iran being\n               plundered by the regime, stealing the future before it even begins. We stand with\n               them in solidarity. We stand with them with a shared hope for peace, freedom and safety\n               for their families and friends. British Columbia will not be a refuge for war criminals and stolen money. The rules\n               have changed. We will ensure their prosecution and the seizure of ill-gotten gains. We stand with the Iranian people in praying this darkness will soon end and the sun\n               will begin to rise on a new, brighter future led by the people of Iran.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327958","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to address the war unfolding in Iran and across the broader Middle East. First and foremost, our thoughts are with all of the innocent civilians across the\n               Middle East and in Iran whose lives are in danger as I stand and speak here right\n               now. My thoughts are with the Iranian families, who have suffered under the tyranny\n               of a brutal dictator","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4d53c68c0c6fb65b9c7be0ed5c0cb7e42eafb32bf48d5d7e63bcb282237c556","66094ba323f40455b36110ba87d9578c7043b1c9787fb52531a661bf20fd4b48","fb2e8f259df5a8235937eb6ed6e68679aab41b6a6ad072c9fd14dd6012522bea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfb8b19ec1ce4a310a65c2cf68dd1cc510bb921a65fda327f3c8e071a4f6cad0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5662899c2772634ea36f8aa0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327959,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I had a call from Chief Sparrow of the xwməθkwəy̓əm yesterday. I want to thank the Chief for the call. He wanted to apologize to me for\n               inviting me to their community celebration of the agreement they'd signed...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327959","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I had a call from Chief Sparrow of the xwməθkwəy̓əm yesterday. I want to thank the Chief for the call. He wanted to apologize to me for\n               inviting me to their community celebration of the agreement they'd signed...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42728","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Immunization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Infectious diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87170","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Epidemics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","label":"Coronavirus diseases","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42728","label":"Immunization","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718399","label":"Infectious diseases","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","label":"Vaccination","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87170","label":"Epidemics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bbdef44eebfbe728557d1a1c415cb2b240014179b6a75cf4a9ebd5e7a7027d1","d0a20c66d6f07ee580ade455e6c0ce5c75169642137b531d0c700c1be14de194","8e44e7ca349b5e0c75bf6e5d589df438a0364ee799d8ec345d4af7c5815c0539","793b51ff1be1d4ed03d57f926ce429ea259dd587fa722938899587e0f21d18ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19a926a94f2469303e2a1b1dca4e8e77a18f4120a9fd0047de2e9481c95506c2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a84542652f30307c285263c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327960,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've canvassed this for a couple of days. I've been as clear as I can be about the\n               information that was provided to me in advance of attending the event. I understand\n               the member is a leadership candidate. He wants his own chance to ask the question\n               as well. He does raise an important issue. There is clearly a difference between this side\n               of the House and that side of the House, n terms of what we understand our legal obligations\n               are in relation to working with First Nations people. The member who asked me a question\n               is a leadership candidate. The current leader of the Conservatives has been clear\n               on the record. He says: \"I fully support reconciliation.\" You're either on the team or you're not. I'm on the team, and I'm focused on what\n               we need to be focused on. I'm clear in terms of my position. Our government believes\n               that this is core to the economic success of our province. Agreements with First Nations,\n               including with xwməθkwəy̓əm and others, pave the way for the $50 billion in final investment decisions that are\n               coming forward just this year and the $200 billion in final investment decisions that\n               we are targeting over the next ten years. With uncertainty, those projects will not\n               move ahead. If the member wants to govern this province — he says he does; he wants to be the\n               leader — does he support this work? We support the work. I attended as a witness.\n               I was honoured to attend. I support the federal government's work on this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327960","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We've canvassed this for a couple of days. I've been as clear as I can be about the\n               information that was provided to me in advance of attending the event. I understand\n               the member is a leadership candidate. He wants his own chance to ask the question\n               as well. He does raise an important issue. There is clearly a difference between this side\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Propaganda","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","label":"Propaganda","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["34de61ff964b9e64390d70f86957acd7e9837ba4d65bddec89c4f12d9390521c","4d388ed460b8846bcb86d293e3bf9c5fb7dc3e552b7eefe4e6bcc287bbd80cad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6f539e717bbbd8bcbf94ea1ea47bfceeeda5031a5814f7934a2054496dd5d14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9b85202d8b1a78bfd2e7d2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360148,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the next 12 months, the province has in the neighbourhood of, and it is in excess\n               of, $50 billion in final investment decisions for major projects in British Columbia. Not one of these projects — and these are the big ones; these aren't the small ones\n               — not one of them would be reaching a final investment decision if there weren't strong\n               partnerships with First Nations. If the member is the critic for Indigenous Relations and he doesn't understand that, then his advocacy that this government cease conversations\n               with First Nations, stop reaching agreements with First Nations, would terminate those projects in their tracks. It\n               would lead to roadblocks instead of jobs and opportunity. It would lead to pink slips for British Columbians. The Conservatives' continual advocacy against this work, that even just a few months ago they supported....\n               The current leader of the Conservative Party saying he's on the reconciliation team. The leader before him, citing all of the\n               Indigenous agreements that he signed The Conservatives' continual advocacy against this work that even just a few months\n               ago they supported.... The current leader of the Conservative Party is saying he's on\n               the reconciliation team. The leader before him citing all of the Indigenous agreements\n               that he signed, including recognizing rights and title.... And now, suddenly, they're\n               saying that they're opposed to that. The chaos in our economy would be immeasurable. We cannot afford that approach, and\n               if the member doesn't understand that, he shouldn't be the critic for Indigenous Relations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360148","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the next 12 months, the province has in the neighbourhood of, and it is in excess\n               of, $50 billion in final investment decisions for major projects in British Columbia. Not one of these projects — and these are the big ones; these aren't the small ones\n               — not one of them would be reaching a final investment decision if there weren't strong\n               partnerships","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd1ff2b2126849919ab04f6ef848bd61ab1f9e72e6e31b1045801ebdc52de5cf","6eeab51bd1b48102fd83015404557843e8ce73be1befc7cfb8d2211f8b722d5e","19028a90f03b7e66a9ae874e5073ece144ad3982dd18d060219c4c37d5cc9b44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02b5747da8acbfdd49f9991c225251ae3446eea998e29c09597f1d1b339d2483"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2e511d9e3a6e69363c4db10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360149,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order. The member for Kelowna-Mission. His conduct yesterday was sexist and inappropriate, and now he shows up today dressed\n               as if the vote interrupted his trip to the gym. You issued a reminder to all members\n               to dress in contemporary business attire. The member has disrespected this House now\n               two days in a row, and I ask that you issue a direction to the member.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360149","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order. The member for Kelowna-Mission. His conduct yesterday was sexist and inappropriate, and now he shows up today dressed\n               as if the vote interrupted his trip to the gym. You issued a reminder to all members\n               to dress in contemporary business attire. The member has disrespected this House now\n               two days in a row, and I ask that you i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","label":"Clothing industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a33beab4d85a264fff82b2803eaaef8a59a1251da51fe9dfa6af8bfd03a3c643"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6adcef761bece931a1c51bd3f47d1c1a08879fd909ce800157bc41e3b9cea697"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cf8ca5351cb208ca20cb290","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415717,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise with a heavy heart to share with the House that Howard E. Grant, Knowledge\n               Keeper and Elder of xwməθkwəy̓əm First Nation, has passed away. He spent 37 years on xwməθkwəy̓əm council and 26 years as executive director of the First Nations Summit society. He worked\n               for the federal government in senior bureaucracy for ten years, which assisted him\n               — knowing both the federal, provincial and Indigenous governments — in setting up\n               some crucial institutions that we rely on today: the First Nations Health Authority and the First Nations Finance Authority. He was an instrumental figure in establishing both of those, as well as the creation\n               of the MST Development Corporation, a business partnership among the xwməθkwəy̓əm,\n               Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ Peoples, which allowed him to make significant contributions to the Guerin and Sparrow cases as well. You can't talk about fostering connections between cultural groups in this province\n               without mentioning Mr. Grant. His father was a Chinese immigrant. His mother was a\n               xwməθkwəy̓əm Matriarch. His mother was one of the last fluent speakers of Hul'q'umi'num',\n               connecting her community to its past and its future. It's important to note that her marriage to his father actually lost them status and\n               resulted in Howard growing up in Chinatown as well as the xwməθkwəy̓əm and avoiding\n               residential schools. In 2013, he travelled back to China to visit his father's homeland. It's captured\n               in a documentary film called All Our Father's Relations , a remarkable story about his family but really about British Columbia. I encourage\n               all members to see it. We pass on our condolences on behalf of the government caucus and, I'm sure, the whole\n               House to his family, including Member of Parliament Wade Grant, for their loss and\n               for in fact our entire province and country's loss with the passing of Mr. Grant.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415717","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise with a heavy heart to share with the House that Howard E. Grant, Knowledge\n               Keeper and Elder of xwməθkwəy̓əm First Nation, has passed away. He spent 37 years on xwməθkwəy̓əm council and 26 years as executive director of the First Nations Summit society. He worked\n               for the federal government in senior bureaucracy for ten years, which assisted him\n               — ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Forgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035383","label":"Forgery","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23ac156293bdd6f9fdf589f2267d44f3aae728b16146f34771d0d6a465b90c90","b3ea055333ed7cba6f32100cfb1b75796ad9078c5f5b72cc30599a4e4b963188","336ad3eb6ed4227fb69fc3f27392f625aaafd01e3c68359c475d8fe1fdaf5c66","49526989a9d38ba7d1785d1c75f0b2bf17bddad98e9657ddaff4e974a42733e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19145f6b7b3ab7b00c46aadbbaa49ef4fd9d1ad19ad6ff107f01ae75d373de33"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c75fa7f206f0b98bb06a2c7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720299,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know the member is....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720299","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I know the member is....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31d777ff149bdf0f30d03ae651fbf66b3f9ec0a2e656d0917daf2077cf2686e2","b66818cf3868d3de6d11a9d3233945c66015b5f52563c5c76b0679e1c3bd5763"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-339307b1d5400df65d4d84c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720302,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am honoured to rise today and provide remarks on this historic occasion of the\n               introduction of the K'ómoks Treaty Act. First and foremost, let me congratulate you, Hegus, Hereditary Chiefs, the K'ómoks people. Your unwavering commitment to your community, your strength and your enthusiasm\n               for a brighter future is recognized by all of us here today. Members of this House, while this treaty has been a remarkable 30 years in the making,\n               the work of the K'ómoks people to insist on their rights to protect their land has been going on for much,\n               much longer than that. Their ancestors arrived in their territory thousands of years\n               ago. They harvested and managed the land and its rich natural resources. Shortly after European contact in the 1800s, wars and disease forced them to leave\n               the land that was their home for millennia. They had to relocate south to amalgamate\n               with other tribes at the time. Today the K'ómoks First Nation consists of descendants from numerous separate and distinct tribes with\n               their own origin stories and languages. In their history, in their present, the K'ómoks people define resiliency, define strength. They never ceded their territory. They\n               continued to fight for their rights, and they are standing strong, as you see here\n               today. I know there's been a lot of talk inside and outside of this House about what reconciliation\n               means. This treaty act today, this treaty, is what reconciliation is. It is the very\n               definition of it. This agreement is a major step forward in repairing damaged trust,\n               in creating certainty and building a new relationship from which all of us will benefit. Once ratified by all the parties, the treaty doesn't begin and end here. It's a living\n               agreement. It means it can be updated so it stays current, innovative and responsive.\n               It will not extinguish rights. It will recognize the rights and title, including the\n               inherent right to self-government, of the K'ómoks people. It includes co-management and shared governance throughout the K'ómoks First Nation territory and will provide certainty and a framework for sharing the\n               land. It will create the foundation for ongoing cooperation and partnership. British Columbia is different than other parts of this country. Most of our land was\n               never covered by treaty. Courts have consistently recognized Indigenous rights and\n               title in British Columbia. These rights cannot be erased by any government of any\n               stripe. But for too long that reality was ignored. The result was constant conflict,\n               court battles and uncertainty. More than 30 years ago British Columbia decided that part of the way forward would\n               be modern treaties with the Nisg̱a'a treaty. Today continues that proud tradition. Once the treaty is fully ratified, K'ómoks will join eight other modern treaty nations in B.C. This is a path of healing, of\n               partnership, of affirming long-sought rights and self-determination towards lasting\n               reconciliation that is at all similar to the other treaties our government has signed.\n               It will lift the boats of everyone — the K'ómoks people, the entire region and all British Columbians. It is my honour to stand here and speak in support of the act and the treaty. May\n               we continue to work together, government to government, to build a stronger and brighter\n               future for all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720302","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am honoured to rise today and provide remarks on this historic occasion of the\n               introduction of the K'ómoks Treaty Act. First and foremost, let me congratulate you, Hegus, Hereditary Chiefs, the K'ómoks people. Your unwavering commitment to your community, your strength and your enthusiasm\n               for a brighter future is recognized by all of us here today. Members of this H","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67f27d7969512a26f20067087de83e7634db33316df09590213bd9fca5d5c2d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["03a7a6272697d636fa00d1d71f9bdfadefae25358fb2e4b17b34a2a40b31120d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccd479fa1b0ebb47b7bf9fa4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720307,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is a great honour for me to rise today in the Legislative Assembly in this historic\n               moment of a recognition of a formal agreement, a treaty act, the Kitselas Treaty Act,\n               between the province of British Columbia and the Kitselas First Nation. First and foremost, I want to offer my congratulations. Congratulations, the Kitselas First Nation, for your work, more than 30 years of work,\n               to get to this moment. So many people involved. It's difficult to know where to begin, but thank you, Deputy Chief, for your very\n               moving words this morning. Thank you for being here on behalf of Chief Bennett. Thank you to the senior negotiator and the entire negotiation team for enduring, persevering\n               and delivering this agreement for the provincial government, the federal government\n               and, of course, for the nation. Thank you to all the Elders, the Hereditary Chiefs, the councillors who served over\n               the many years, all the community members, the treaty team, past and present leadership.\n               It is your strength, determination and commitment that brought us to this state. Thank you, Diane Sam, for the welcome to the territory. It's so good to see you. Thank\n               you for the language lesson. Thank you, of course, to Elder Anne for the beautiful peace song. What a wonderful\n               way to start. This was 30 years in the making, but of course, for the Kitselas People, the path\n               to this day has been much longer than that. Kitselas People have lived in the Kitselas\n               Canyon area for at least 5,000 years. Their nation is rightly proud of their heritage\n               and achievements. They define resiliency and strength. They have continued to fight for their rights, for their land, for their title for\n               generations. They have continually sought agreement with the government to be able\n               to move forward together. We heard about that today from the Deputy Chief. Today,\n               as in every year past, the people of the canyon stand strong and united, and it is\n               an honour to stand with you. The Kitselas treaty is the second treaty in as many days to reach this important milestone,\n               with the introduction yesterday of the K'ómoks Treaty Act. This marks a significant step forward for both nations, for the province\n               and for the treaty process as a whole. I said it yesterday, and I'll say it again. This is what reconciliation means. It\n               is the way forward to certainty, to shared prosperity, to the best future for all\n               people in British Columbia. This agreement is a major step forward in repairing damaged\n               trust and building a foundation that we can grow together. Once it's ratified by all parties to the treaty, it doesn't begin and end there. It\n               is a living agreement. It can be updated so that it remains current, innovative and\n               inclusive. When it is ratified, this provides the foundation for the revitalized relationship\n               between the Kitselas First Nation, the provincial government, the federal government,\n               local governments and a government-to-government relationship that will create jobs,\n               opportunity and prosperity for not just the Kitselas People but for the entire region\n               and for our province. It will provide certainty. It will provide a framework for sharing the land. It will\n               create a foundation for cooperation and partnership. I'll say it again. This is the\n               way forward. I thank the Deputy Chief for reminding this House, and I thank the former Leader of\n               the Opposition I'll say it again, this is the way forward, and I thank the Deputy Chief for reminding\n               this House, and I thank the former Leader of the Opposition for his work in 2014,\n               helping set this path as part of its 30-year journey. Unlike other parts of Canada, most of our land in B.C. was never covered by treaty.\n               This was a deliberate decision by the governments of the day. There were some historic\n               treaties, but they were the exception, not the rule. That was the case until about\n               the year 2000, when the Nisg̱a'a treaty began the work of the provincial government to see modern treaties as a way to find\n               a path forward. In the absence of treaty, courts have consistently recognized First Nations rights\n               and title in this province, rights and title that cannot be erased by any government.\n               Despite this, we have seen successive governments fight against this reality. That\n               has resulted in conflict, in uncertainty and in what feels like endless court battles. This modern treaty is indeed the path forward. Once fully ratified, Kitselas will\n               join eight other modern treaty nations in British Columbia. This makes a path of healing\n               and relationship, an affirmation of the rights of the people who always insisted those\n               rights be recognized. This is the path towards lasting and true recognition and reconciliation. It is my honour on behalf of the government to stand up and speak in support of the\n               Kitselas Treaty Act. May we continue the path together. We have much work to do in\n               the years to come, government to government, building a stronger future for all British\n               Columbians in this amazing province we call home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720307","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is a great honour for me to rise today in the Legislative Assembly in this historic\n               moment of a recognition of a formal agreement, a treaty act, the Kitselas Treaty Act,\n               between the province of British Columbia and the Kitselas First Nation. First and foremost, I want to offer my congratulations. Congratulations, the Kitselas First Nation, for your work, more than ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa8eaad5b8e374df9b6aa8a18f4a520576ca2aa81366eca67fa9151cac61499a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe84915e2907005a86e600c9f779126f755419efb3f59c62bfdece6f1bbb3353"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df8cffaa63cb19902f11b410","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721383,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the House today, the mayor of Tumbler Ridge, Mayor Darryl, is here. I don't know\n               if I can spot him; he's somewhere on the precinct, I can advise the House — oh, great\n               — with the Peace River regional district folks here to talk about local issues. Obviously, the House is well aware of the mayor's leadership in the period following\n               the horrific events in Tumbler Ridge. He is a champion of the community and the region.\n               He is the person that people look to in their moment of crisis. He was solid as a\n               rock. He continues to be so, to advocate for the community and to encourage people\n               to come up and visit Tumbler Ridge. They have an incredible tourist opportunity for\n               British Columbians and all Canadians. He's an advocate in the best of times for Tumbler Ridge, and he was their rock in\n               the most challenging of times. I want to thank him so much for his work on behalf\n               of the government caucus and express huge appreciation for his efforts in his whole\n               time in office, particularly through the challenges faced by the community of Tumbler\n               Ridge and our province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721383","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the House today, the mayor of Tumbler Ridge, Mayor Darryl, is here. I don't know\n               if I can spot him; he's somewhere on the precinct, I can advise the House — oh, great\n               — with the Peace River regional district folks here to talk about local issues. Obviously, the House is well aware of the mayor's leadership in the period following\n               the horrific events ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Municipal buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","label":"Municipal buildings","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8fa43d68e350aa120369191b9470ca79eab3819f7d3c99e1834b4c31df8eedc","d820ee712187c9777b989c1b8dc05be2b7724158bdb84b70b9792c185ab1d1a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4f510582e743ebfa1c04b24","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721386,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am honoured to have the support of both my caucus and the House. If the member wishes\n               to move a motion of confidence in the House, we can test her allegations. But I'm a little bit.... Well, I guess I'm not surprised to hear Conservative voices\n               stand and speak against government taking the opportunity — yes, it is...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721386","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am honoured to have the support of both my caucus and the House. If the member wishes\n               to move a motion of confidence in the House, we can test her allegations. But I'm a little bit.... Well, I guess I'm not surprised to hear Conservative voices\n               stand and speak against government taking the opportunity — yes, it is...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a70a9dc4326226668f086abd7a73cca27642ffd38bcd85614268aff9630add22","ea74d4410fb7519c6f18db155b29d83179d5515bb4964ae8fc69d945c3f1d8e0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2a9906dd28815e26aa621e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729066,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"A year ago it was a spring evening after a beautiful day, a festival celebrating a\n               community that I know every member of this place holds close to their heart of the\n               Filipino community in British Columbia. Vendors were packing up, families were getting\n               ready to go home, and volunteers were cleaning up the site when a man drove a vehicle\n               through the crowd on the street, killing 11 people and injuring countless more. This was a year ago, and I know a number of us were at commemorations of this horrific\n               and tragic event over the last week. For those of us who were there, it is very obvious\n               this could have happened yesterday for the families of those who didn't make it. The\n               healing is feeling a long way off for that. But with a year in the passage of time, it does create the possibility to reflect\n               on the heroism of those who remain. There are so many heroes I've met over the last\n               week, and since that tragic event, the families who are living with people who are\n               profoundly injured, like AJ, who are struggling to recover abilities that we all take\n               for granted every day. His life forever changed. His family's life forever changed.\n               The families of those who didn't make it, who have to go on with their lives, who\n               have to go to work, who have to pay the bills, despite the enormous grief that they\n               face. The organizers of the event, who put together an amazing event only to see it turned\n               into grief and tragedy and who turned around to support a community, a city, a province,\n               a nation and a world that was shocked by what they had seen. The first responders,\n               the police, the fire, the ambulance workers, paramedics seeing the coverage on the\n               news coming in to cover shifts, the health care workers, HEU, doctors, nurses, health\n               science professionals, all of them pitching in to ensure people got treatment as the\n               911 calls came in. There is a lot of work ahead for this province still. Criminal process is ongoing.\n               The community deserves answers they will need to get. But I know for myself, for the\n               government, and for every member of this House, we stand in grief remembering the\n               events of a year ago. We stand with the survivors, the Filipino community and with\n               all who are affected, in both thanking those who stepped up, who continue to step\n               up and in remembering those who didn't make it home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729066","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"A year ago it was a spring evening after a beautiful day, a festival celebrating a\n               community that I know every member of this place holds close to their heart of the\n               Filipino community in British Columbia. Vendors were packing up, families were getting\n               ready to go home, and volunteers were cleaning up the site when a man drove a vehicle\n               t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083672","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Radio","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083672","label":"Radio","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a134f55247ccc6bf2f1f0978d1af6786af2b18192227bf86656491115d39f536","4e911e0bcece26055971d11a33064376830d72debe249d11ccb1f0d9809d8093","52787145f95d0c850d0f655c3f21becbcad194eef7a2d12ee20a1446f6c47ce0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["260d96d4ec6b9c2945fc51ee133da7f901b85539fb010c694a35bf97c6195445"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-847697bf139a9a0835c31be8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752230,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Leader of the Opposition will be aware that I have taken significant efforts in\n               order to be able to be briefed by both CSIS and the federal RCMP on issues of national\n               security that relate to the government of British Columbia. That could be about a\n               member of the public, an organization, a company, an individual but, certainly, a\n               member of the government caucus. I have had multiple briefings with CSIS, with the RCMP since obtaining top-secret\n               clearance. In addition, following amendments to the federal law relating to CSIS that\n               allows them to share more information with the B.C. government and treat us as a client,\n               something that was previously a barrier to us accessing information.... I can advise the Leader of the Opposition, every member of this House, I have never\n               once been briefed by either the RCMP or CSIS about concerns related to any government\n               caucus member or cabinet member — period. If I had been, members of the public should\n               be aware, should know, that I would not hesitate to act. At a minimum, if there was\n               concern about a cabinet member, given the sensitive information that cabinet has access\n               to, I would remove that person from cabinet.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752230","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Leader of the Opposition will be aware that I have taken significant efforts in\n               order to be able to be briefed by both CSIS and the federal RCMP on issues of national\n               security that relate to the government of British Columbia. That could be about a\n               member of the public, an organization, a company, an individual but, certainly, a\n               membe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba4d6a6dfe225cdbdbd147d2e2d1c0c1a882c697e6da91427f498796ea2631ad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["834ddb74b5c1b23c574d0e0c31c29e7072fa3169b93842bc0e5cde1504ab4fec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e4b7bb4e00f794ff7945d83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752231,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"Looking up in the gallery, I see two of my hard-working CAs. I see Saheeti and Eman.\n               Together with Sofia, they are the trio that keeps the office running. They are the\n               front line for all of the important feedback from constituents near and far. I want\n               to thank them for the hard work they do in Vancouver–Point Grey every single day. Nice to see you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752231","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Looking up in the gallery, I see two of my hard-working CAs. I see Saheeti and Eman.\n               Together with Sofia, they are the trio that keeps the office running. They are the\n               front line for all of the important feedback from constituents near and far. I want\n               to thank them for the hard work they do in Vancouver–Point Grey every single day. Nice to see you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e15cb9b5303f2aa9639cf3750a9aba8819f92bffac368bc60be71598853bf2e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9394fa02e57e6b0f6ed839740a4e3c532c5dbfba5d16046a52352c3ead6f4fd0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-981b77994493eedfe2a4f9ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017281,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"It was last week I stood with the Energy Minister from the Government of Canada celebrating\n               the passage through yet another gateway towards the largest private sector investment\n               in Canadian history — LNG Canada phase 2. I keep waiting for the opposition to stand up and fight for projects that are British\n               Columbia projects Now, I keep waiting for the opposition to stand up and fight for projects that are British Columbia projects, that have\n               private sector investors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017281","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It was last week I stood with the Energy Minister from the Government of Canada celebrating\n               the passage through yet another gateway towards the largest private sector investment\n               in Canadian history — LNG Canada phase 2. I keep waiting for the opposition to stand up and fight for projects that are British\n               Columbia projects Now, I keep waiting for the opp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56e9cee40904122335d82c1c6c846c4db6f0b364ed453717957e24147775f4f7","dd46223e40f6798d1e09133a2a0e288cd1de64b2c2b6d66dd8b6b1f0908ca7a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75a6215b0fbd55f2f2311c722006015bef32c8ff2c8a69c2dfe7fdc8f749c936"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-046a92b2090b66105ac04227","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036466,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to begin by acknowledging we're on the territory of the lək̓wəŋən People, the Songhees and the Esquimalt First Nations. I note that I am joined by staff from the Premier's office here today. I have Shannon\n               Salter, deputy minister to the Premier; Tom McCarthy, deputy minister of policy and\n               coordination; and Ben Bisset, project director. I want to thank all of them for their\n               hard work on behalf of British Columbians. Note that I'm joined by staff from the Premier's office here today. I have Shannon\n               Salter, Deputy Minister to the Premier; Tom McCarthy, Deputy Minister of Policy and\n               Coordination, and Ben Bisset, project director. I want to thank all of them for their\n               hard work on behalf of British Columbians. I, first of all, want to reflect on this process. This process matters. This is a\n               hallmark of our democratic system, the Westminster system, where everybody, including\n               the Premier, within government is held accountable to the Legislature and, by extension,\n               to the public. Estimates is a way the government is held to account. These are democratic\n               institutions that are worth protecting in a tumultuous time when it feels like these\n               institutions are under attack. I am ready for a strong and thorough debate recognizing the context of this, which\n               is ensuring that British Columbians get the answers that they need about the questions\n               that the opposition has. These are uncertain times from the impacts of the war in Iran on daily life for British\n               Columbians that we see at the gas pump. We're seeing in the grocery store impacts\n               of the Trump trade war on Canada. This is on the heels of the pandemic, global inflation,\n               slowing global economies, so many challenges that British Columbia has seen and fought\n               off, and we will do that. But in order to be successful, we need a self-reliant economy. Both here in British\n               Columbia and as Canadians, we need to be able to stand on our own two feet. It has\n               to be an economy that works for people, that supports people in having more money\n               in their pocket at the end of the day, higher wages, supports in their communities\n               like affordable child care, strong public transit and strong community infrastructure,\n               including health care, especially in rural British Columbia. We are moving in the right direction on these important issues. The spring session\n               has really been about seizing opportunities. Here in this session, there have been\n               laws about ensuring that British Columbia is able to seize the economic opportunities\n               to grow our economy and create jobs and also training opportunities for British Columbians. Just in the first four months of this year, more than $3 billion of investment in\n               new mines. I was sitting around the table with other premiers, western Premiers, just\n               the other day. Our success here is the envy of many jurisdictions across Canada and\n               around the world, but we do this as British Columbians to support the entire country. We are excited about the opportunities in energy — LNG Canada phase 2, reflecting\n               on our accounts, somewhere around $80 billion of investment related to energy projects,\n               and 5,000 new trades-training seats so that British Columbians are at the front of\n               the line to take those jobs. The happy news, just yesterday, is that our work here in British Columbia is supporting\n               people in Germany that have shut off their access to Russian natural gas and have\n               signed a $10 billion agreement with Ksi Lisims LNG to access B.C. natural gas. The reason why they choose our natural gas is that\n               it is lower carbon than other jurisdictions, and it helps them in Germany to achieve\n               their climate goals as well. Over half a million British Columbians have been connected to family doctors or nurse\n               practitioners to primary care since 2023. We are recruiting more health care workers\n               from the United States than anywhere else, and we are thrilled that more than 2,000\n               American doctors and nurses have applied for jobs here in British Columbia and more\n               than 700 have accepted those jobs. We're building a new SkyTrain in Surrey, a jurisdiction long overlooked for major\n               capital investment, and a new hospital in Surrey as well. For cost of living, we made a commitment to make housing more affordable. Rents are\n               dropping faster here than anywhere else in Canada, because we built and we focused\n               on building more rental housing and addressing some of the excesses in the market,\n               including in relation to Airbnb. Prices are stabilizing in the housing market, giving\n               people the hope that they may be able to buy into the market, but we know we have\n               more work to do in that area. We have a new energy savings plan from B.C. Hydro that will support families by reducing\n               their hydro bills and put money back into their pockets for saving energy. We've opened\n               more child care spaces. We have kept car insurance low. B.C. Hydro rates have been\n               below the rate of inflation for the last several years, and we have some of the lowest\n               car insurance rates in the entire country with some of the best benefits. We're protecting schools and places of worship in this province from hate and attack\n               and affirming the human rights code as a priority for this government, protecting\n               people's dignity and the diversity that makes this province a beautiful place to live. We are making this progress despite massive uncertainty. In fact this uncertainty\n               has spurred all of us as Canadians to do more. That is the commitment I made at the\n               table with the western Premiers yesterday and I will continue to make on behalf of\n               all British Columbians — that we will ensure this province is strong, that our public\n               services are strong and are all in service to British Columbians and Canadians. I will admit frustration to seeing the opposition voting no to key measures that will\n               strengthen our provincial economy and our independence like the North Coast transmission\n               line I will admit frustration to seeing the opposition voting no to key measures that will\n               strengthen our provincial economy and our independence, like the North Coast transmission\n               line. To even see the member for Skeena voting against the North Coast transmission line, despite knowing that that will\n               feed major projects in and near her constituency — Cedar LNG, Ksi Lisims LNG — and that it will deliver high-capacity, high-voltage electricity to communities\n               that have been underserved for generations.... I don't understand that opposition but\n               I know that it will not turn us away from doing what we need to do to build up this\n               province. B.C. has what it takes. We are focused on delivering for not just people now but for\n               the next generation in this province and a more secure and hopeful future for all\n               British Columbians. I look forward to the questions, and let's get this show on the road.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036466","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to begin by acknowledging we're on the territory of the lək̓wəŋən People, the Songhees and the Esquimalt First Nations. I note that I am joined by staff from the Premier's office here today. I have Shannon\n               Salter, deputy minister to the Premier; Tom McCarthy, deputy minister of policy and\n               coordination; and Ben Bisset, project director. I want to thank all of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86956","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sponsorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:184310","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nationalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watercourses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036696","label":"Pollution prevention","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036981","label":"Watercourses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:184310","label":"Nationalism","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86956","label":"Sponsorship","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["617e58dba46511b0a2d694f7c999760e4020070401c3fef569971377268c36ab","f29baddcae96a960ef59b0a90411fd5c72b1a9d2186b309873912bbad472fab1","4b395d369ef5296f724f6c6f3f54cb9b037f36de31dfdf364866fcf1f0d7392d","26dbef98d503440b1791114819fc2058d451f59a8464f73207ada94be152ffa4","0c7115510c4c24d931860e939522a7928c8df219103be2616e39d4e8b3cc3c71","b71a053647a9543b6292bcaa1119f81eb5922a8df0ca7e29f534130a306c0175","ddf5899ed4976050d4a5ce0d625d6952cf5b3312244b955b5bdcee42d8982406","c2f8bb9116e1c64d0ab99e830f7a210ac233f5a0dd11a783834655090eb68b6b","a50e2d8500cfcfc0080928058c83c8d1e54311572cadf48a1f80424670e625a6","f99337f912772b61285aa7e4598aeae4a259c9171014bb55a0c872e9dcdc5fc9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00e2bd1131b468deee7e911ae6bb351f8bc31c37f6392f9e7c794db38bfb75f9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-469d8cbb23151a0b5bbddc40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036467,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"Looking up in the gallery, I see a familiar and friendly face. A former MLA in this\n               place, former Member of Parliament in Ottawa representing Skeena and area. Nathan\n               Cullen is joining us here. I invite the House to welcome him back, please. Wow, didn't\n               get a huge round of applause there. I thought people would be happier to see you,\n               Nathan. I'm sorry about that. I'm glad to see you. I also want to take a moment to recognize the Leader of the Opposition. It's his last\n               day here in service of this role. I mentioned it last night during estimates. I want\n               to mention it in front of the entire House and those watching question period. Leadership roles in politics are challenging at the best of times. These days, regardless\n               of which party you serve in, the cost is often paid by family at home. It's time away\n               on the road. It is dedication to a lot of priorities that aren't necessarily consistent\n               with what you know you need to do for your family. He has made a lot of sacrifices to serve in this role. He is the fourth leader of\n               the official opposition that I've had the opportunity to work with. I can't say that\n               I've enjoyed every moment, frankly, but I do respect that he has operated within a\n               framework of accountability and integrity. I want to thank him on behalf of the people\n               of B.C. for fulfilling that important role during the time that he did.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036467","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Looking up in the gallery, I see a familiar and friendly face. A former MLA in this\n               place, former Member of Parliament in Ottawa representing Skeena and area. Nathan\n               Cullen is joining us here. I invite the House to welcome him back, please. Wow, didn't\n               get a huge round of applause there. I thought people would be happier to see you,\n               Natha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30fc2558dbdb7cdcfeb28ffd2212fb378d9d005ca75412697b6c3b8e91953cff","f7a8814155e2ca506bdacfc85bdd283b60ea68210d1084edac0be6fe6e121bc5","1947ebd83ec796ebc56a966cb8586bd233a8ce99cf05a49c937f69a1fbd5e0aa","dc96feef9994b0bac96cae7e3358f2a7329d698a0505fa3b7d95a8a80f82aa7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5d034a09ebff43941313457ffe882a6659f9ca1ac9f317583336b1655336e0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-765ac1c59ac0105660dcbf37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036468,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Eby","venue":"Hansard","text":"In estimates, we canvass all matters of government policy with the Office of the Premier,\n               not just the matters related to the budget. I understand that. I think I do my best\n               to provide answers to the members. But to ask for this time to be for the Premier to comment on the positions of other\n               organizations.... It's just hard to see what the end of that would be, so I'll respectfully\n               decline to answer, given the total disconnect from what we're doing here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036468","member_id":"bc-mla-30","member_name":"David Eby","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In estimates, we canvass all matters of government policy with the Office of the Premier,\n               not just the matters related to the budget. I understand that. I think I do my best\n               to provide answers to the members. But to ask for this time to be for the Premier to comment on the positions of other\n               organizations.... It's just hard to see what the end of that w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47777","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Corporate income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47777","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Corporate income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42728","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Immunization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42728","label":"Immunization","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47777","label":"Corporate income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","label":"Vaccination","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c887cc8922d0b46db60629a5da3f1f74ef965263b66d96b418c52241620b8ec0","45aaaff8825c62bb026a6cf3ff5ef5f3b77a54969909332f4430bf3845b2d306","86be48bd35224552315a5c0c03478542b37f0fcde15558a9ff189c6668fb32cd","7aff969ea632f0639489c76378da724c746e54105217758db9a18b8bfc95c6de","32e366e97bd2c1f1101967b52a86bc1d01e1161e91283fcfe56b72cdcf592529","15590d02edbcdc49f1e29c0fc1175b7ce7ba409401084bccf4ebfcfb7f12769a","f133505b564c3980c1fd823c360f65b0bc763f23d284bd018505835507160d65"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-611d2a99d3e9e99464fca86c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327961,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to talk about local news and why it matters. I also wish to talk about\n               Rod Raglin, who lives in Vancouver-Kensington and has been a journalist for many years. In March 1977, Rod, who was then 28 years old, published volume 1, No. 1 of the South Vancouver Revue . Forty-nine years later, in March this year, the independently owned neighbourhood\n               newspaper lives on simply as The REVUE , and it continues to serve residents of southeast Vancouver. Nowadays, it's easy to overlook the importance of community newspapers like The REVUE . We live in a time dominated by digital media giants, international headlines and\n               24-hour news cycles. Why is local news important? Local news is essential in building tight-knit and strong\n               communities. Through publications like The REVUE , residents get to know what's happening in their neighbourhoods, from the state of\n               bus service on East 49th Avenue to cultural events, renewal of parks, fresh produce\n               shops, new property developments on Victoria Drive, school updates, unveiling of new\n               public artworks. Reporting by The REVUE has a direct significance on the lives of many in Vancouver-Kensington and the rest of southeast Vancouver. By focusing on the grassroots level, local news\n               highlights the interesting things that make our community really a delightful place\n               to live in. Rod Raglin has seen it all. When he started the review at age 28 in 1977, Rod already\n               had two decades of experience in the newspaper business, starting as a delivery boy\n               when he was eight years and later as advertising director for another publication. Born and raised in East Vancouver, Rod is an accomplished author. He has written 14\n               novels, two plays and short stories. He's also a poet, and he has taken thousands\n               of photographs as well. Rod has been married to Chandra for 56 years. You can see\n               him at all community events. Mr. Speaker and dear colleagues, let's give a great round of applause to writer, editor\n               and publisher Rod Raglin, a real treasure in Mr. Speaker and dear colleagues, let's give a great round of applause to writer, editor\n               and publisher Rod Raglin, a real treasure in Vancouver-Kensington.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327961","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to talk about local news and why it matters. I also wish to talk about\n               Rod Raglin, who lives in Vancouver-Kensington and has been a journalist for many years. In March 1977, Rod, who was then 28 years old, published volume 1, No. 1 of the South Vancouver Revue . Forty-nine years later, in March this year, the independently owned neighbourhood\n               newspaper li","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be0cfc095f935a3465d694b6d22a50bdc68ed726495d2a4651a787502275e85d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e13dc20a180c48e32a421477dbfe75eed50d4d065294e450d38c5ecb0c5fbb4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d51dd2c126fb7a8fcc108445","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327962,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today with profound sadness over the passing away of a dear friend, Anthony\n               Michael Maria Remigios.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327962","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today with profound sadness over the passing away of a dear friend, Anthony\n               Michael Maria Remigios.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c115e1ae174bf0e54250ef0584a6aaab0945fd514cefba313fc65c8c693ed0cb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a7c396fa453b15369a60bc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327963,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Attorney General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327963","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Attorney General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4693d676aaa93b9867f030be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360150,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"In a news item dated May 22, 1926, the local paper reported that particular Saturday\n               was a red-letter day in the history of South Vancouver. The report went on: \"Reverend George O. Fallis, assisted by Reverend A.D. Archibald\n               and Reeve Jack Cornet, in the presence of a large crowd, solemnly dedicated and officially\n               opened a 37-acre memorial park and memorial pavilion, thus bringing to fruition a movement started in 1918 to establish a suitable memorial\n               in honour of South Vancouver citizens who rallied to the colours and gave their lives\n               to the Empire during the Great War.\" For context, Jack Cornet was Jonathan Webster Cornet, and he carried the title of\n               Reeve because he was head of the town council of South Vancouver before it was absorbed\n               into the City of Vancouver. Jack Cornet later became an alderman and mayor of Vancouver,\n               and before that, a member of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. Jack was\n               here and served in these chambers. Once a grazing area for cattle, Memorial South Park has served residents of the southern\n               area of Vancouver for the last 100 years. Enjoyed by neighbours and sports teams,\n               the park features a track field, the synthetic turf field, a pond and a war memorial. The field is used by soccer, field hockey, lacrosse and ultimate players. It's a popular\n               area for picnics and festivals. There's a lot of excitement building up to the centennial,\n               the 100-year anniversary. I want to thank park champion Beth Ringdell and her friends for organizing the centennial.\n               In addition to Beth Ringdell, kudos to Cindy Heinrich, Sharon Olson, Sherry Luff and\n               neighbours. Cheers as well to Eddie Carringhan and the John Oliver legacy association. I also\n               wish to mention Cherry Wong, Lisa Bautista, and Prabh Deol with the I also wish to mention Cherry Wong, Liza Bautista and Prabhi Deol with South Vancouver\n               Neighbourhood House. Thanks as well to South Vancouver's Rob Howatson for the material\n               about the history of Memorial South Park. Everybody is invited to a great celebration for 100 years for Memorial South Park\n               coming up.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360150","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In a news item dated May 22, 1926, the local paper reported that particular Saturday\n               was a red-letter day in the history of South Vancouver. The report went on: \"Reverend George O. Fallis, assisted by Reverend A.D. Archibald\n               and Reeve Jack Cornet, in the presence of a large crowd, solemnly dedicated and officially\n               opened a 37-acre memorial park and memo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["32cc2d77bf567c081128fa2ce3540d2dfcc951e68f4177025a4f4812233bab58"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a76e7b9f265c79294b1a5ae67c4b55211ba18ffc2442634d0a7933453fa716d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83e3cda27b142682c5c4a7f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415718,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"This April my community will observe a cultural tradition that is deeply imbued with\n               love and remembrance. It's called Babang Luksa, or the dropping of the veil of mourning,\n               a custom rooted in family and friendship. It will be an occasion to pray together\n               and honour the memory of those who were lost in the April 26, 2025, festival tragedy\n               in Vancouver. It does not mean that grief comes to an end. It simply means that we are taking another\n               step in our shared journey of healing. It also reinforces the importance of community\n               and ongoing social supports to reassure victims and their families that they are not\n               alone. I am reminded about the Sermon on the Mount, wherein Jesus said: \"Blessed are those\n               who mourn, for they shall be comforted.\" Individually and collectively, Filipinos\n               know grief well. Whether it's the loss of a loved one or the loss of the ability to\n               practise a profession in Canada because of challenges in foreign credential recognition,\n               Filipinos have had their own share of suffering. But we know that sorrow is not a\n               permanent place. With God's grace, we will find new strength, together with the broad\n               community. Thank you for your solidarity. In memoriam, Jenifer Darbellay, Kira Ganapol Salim, Vicky Bjarnason, Glitza Daniela Samper, Glitza Maria Caicedo-Samper, Daniel Samper Toro, Jendhel Sico, Richard Le, Katie Le, Linh Hoang, Nerissa Pagkanlungan. I invite everybody to join a commemoration mass at St. Andrew's Parish, 480 East 47th\n               Avenue, on April 10 at 2 p.m., and also a community dinner of commemoration where\n               victims will be there to give tribute to their loved ones, at Fraserview Banquet Hall\n               on April 12 at 5 p.m.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415718","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This April my community will observe a cultural tradition that is deeply imbued with\n               love and remembrance. It's called Babang Luksa, or the dropping of the veil of mourning,\n               a custom rooted in family and friendship. It will be an occasion to pray together\n               and honour the memory of those who were lost in the April 26, 2025, festival tragedy\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40d2f3eaf506a44f5c0ae212853dc8907ee7fd30f0b2baa4d72ed989634b9d86"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24de16465b20f2be6b083e78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720308,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"In a world dominated by huge corporations and monopolies, local businesses serve as\n               the backbone of our communities. Local businesses are the indispensable threads that\n               weave vibrant communities, building social cohesion, neighbourhood character and economic\n               resilience and prosperity at the grassroots level. A great example is Bains Travel, whose offices at 6550 Fraser Street are a few blocks\n               south of my Vancouver-Kensington constituency office. For a bit of history, Bains Travel was founded in April 1951\n               by Khaldip Singh Bains, here in Victoria, British Columbia, which was 75 years ago. Built on a strong commitment to service and community, the company quickly established\n               itself as a trusted travel provider. In 1969, a second location was opened on Fraser\n               Street in Vancouver, marking the beginning of what would become the company's long-standing\n               presence in the area. The location was managed In 1969, a second location was opened on Fraser Street in Vancouver, marking the beginning of what would become the company's long-standing\n               presence in the area. The location was managed by Kuldip's nephew Narinder Paul Singh Bains, who is also known as Paul. In 1998, Paul, alongside his wife Dolly, assumed leadership of the business and continued to expand and strengthen its operations. Today the Fraser Street operation remains the head office and has been serving the\n               community for over five decades, or 57 years. The company has since grown to include\n               additional locations in Surrey, Abbotsford and Mississauga. Now in its third generation,\n               the day-to-day operations of Bains Travel are managed by Sumeet Bains, continuing the family legacy of service and innovation. Originally founded to serve the Indian immigrant community and their travel needs\n               to their native country, Bains Travel has evolved into a full-service travel agency,\n               offering a wide range of travel solutions, including corporate travel, leisure travel,\n               group tours and specialized itineraries. Looking ahead, Bains Travel is focused on continued growth through technology, enhanced\n               customer service and expansion of its service offerings, while preserving the personalized,\n               community-focused approach that has defined the company for over 70 years. An important member of the Sunset on Fraser Business Improvement Association, I ask\n               everybody to please join me to wish Bains Travel a very happy 75th anniversary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720308","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In a world dominated by huge corporations and monopolies, local businesses serve as\n               the backbone of our communities. Local businesses are the indispensable threads that\n               weave vibrant communities, building social cohesion, neighbourhood character and economic\n               resilience and prosperity at the grassroots level. A great example is Bains Travel, whose office","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c982d05154f377d956b154b35ec605e1f2b3afde69d3895387dc44e2abfa9432"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e5a00bc47d38982cd62af0a80553c0a39eb59e1521acc830eb20f877a27f45e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdaa59be5a75716c8ef32a54","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720311,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Agriculture and Food and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720311","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Agriculture and Food and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["721481e5c6fc18123bd02c3e9f72a450e43922608143db7e87f59882113efc62"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf72472551f2777f6e0b1405","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720313,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining colleagues to welcome friends from the Filipino community. We've got Madge Yee. Madge is the president and managing director of Goldilocks Bakeshop.\n               If you don't know Goldilocks Bakeshop or you haven't had one of the delicacies, you\n               have an opportunity, because she's brought some snacks for everybody here: ensaymada\n               and also polvoron We've got Maj Yee. Maj is the president and managing director of Goldilocks Bake Shop.\n               If you don't know Goldilocks Bake Shop or you haven't had one of the delicacies, you\n               have an opportunity, because she's brought some snacks for everybody here — ensaymada\n               and also pulveron, Filipino-style shortbread. That's for everybody to share, and that's\n               really a cultural tradition of the Filipino community — to bring snacks. I appreciate\n               her. She's a graduate of the University of British Columbia, graduate of the Sauder School\n               of Business, member of Les Dames d'Escoffier and has volunteered with the Alpha Delta\n               Pi Foundation, supporting women's leadership and philanthropy. Very active in the\n               community, participating in the city of Vancouver response to the April 26 tragedy,\n               recognized among the 75 faces of immigration commemorating 75 years of Canada–Philippines\n               relations. She's also the vice-chair of the Filipino Legacy Society. We're joined by Christine DeCastro, an innovation and tech entrepreneur. She got a\n               drone startup, very accomplished. She led Canada's payment modernization efforts for\n               ISO 222 compliance, which is pretty impressive, everything on the tech and innovation\n               front. She volunteers profusely. She was former chair of Hope 604, Rotoract; Rotoractor\n               of the Year 2024; vice president, Bridge of Hope world internationally; and also the\n               secretary for the Filipino Legacy Society. So I ask you to please give them a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720313","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joining colleagues to welcome friends from the Filipino community. We've got Madge Yee. Madge is the president and managing director of Goldilocks Bakeshop.\n               If you don't know Goldilocks Bakeshop or you haven't had one of the delicacies, you\n               have an opportunity, because she's brought some snacks for everybody here: ensaymada\n               and also polvoron We've got M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ca7900719c92e514324a9a101beaa95b1441b941b569837189a01044da1b688"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72fdc555290b00ccd1b748301542025be02063d516d3e77776ec005d478d94bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d286fabff641cfbf7e133020","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721390,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today, on Earth Day, in a world buffeted by climate change and biodiversity loss,\n               the activism by environmental advocates has never been more important. Activists play\n               a vital role in driving change to protect our planet and promote sustainable alternatives. Vancouver-Kensington is home to three change-makers who are committed to green initiatives\n               and environmental justice. They are Donelda Rose, Jeanie Morton and Ben Ernst. On a side note, Ben Ernst is the co-founder of Earnest Ice Cream, a chainlet of artisan\n               ice cream that is widely known for its unique flavours and its commitment to sustainable\n               operations, charitable work and sourcing local and fair trade ingredients. Ben and\n               a friend started Earnest Ice Cream on Fraser Street, not far from my Vancouver-Kensington\n               community office, and now have two other branches in Vancouver and one in North Vancouver.\n               I encourage you to try their scoops and pints. Also, Ben and Donelda live in Vancouver's first co-housing project, an intentional\n               community where sustainability and caring for the environment are among its shared\n               passions. Ben, Donelda and Jeanie visited me recently to talk about how British Columbia can\n               meaningfully live up to its commitments to climate action. They brought with them\n               a report by the B.C. climate emergency campaign, a group of nearly 650 diverse agricultural,\n               arts, business, community, environment, faith, health, housing, Indigenous, labour,\n               government, outdoor recreation, research, senior tourism and youth organizations across\n               the province. As the report notes: \"We need to build for the future, not the past. Investing in\n               climate action reduces energy and transportation costs, creates jobs, builds healthier\n               communities and improves energy security.\" We need more everyday heroes for the environment, like Donelda Rose, Jeanie Morton\n               and Ben Ernst. We also need to encourage and empower the youth to take up advocacy\n               for the environment. I close with a quote from Xiye Bastida, a 21-year-old Indigenous climate justice activist\n               from Mexico: \"We are on earth to take care of life. We are on earth to take care of\n               each other.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721390","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today, on Earth Day, in a world buffeted by climate change and biodiversity loss,\n               the activism by environmental advocates has never been more important. Activists play\n               a vital role in driving change to protect our planet and promote sustainable alternatives. Vancouver-Kensington is home to three change-makers who are committed to green initiatives\n               and e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9a4b3d24c1cb0015871feaebfd02e94453c194254973552b6d0b970fc6ab6e1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ebe61d4505a21c8232c4227debf1dbba39ad641297a91d95a2718b87a51a88e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fba2f03ae1e32304d4916383","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729069,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to wish a happy birthday to my brother-in-law Eric Haynes. He's celebrating\n               today. Unfortunately, I can't be with him, but I ask everybody here in the House to\n               please wish him a very happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729069","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to wish a happy birthday to my brother-in-law Eric Haynes. He's celebrating\n               today. Unfortunately, I can't be with him, but I ask everybody here in the House to\n               please wish him a very happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f34fc83d6620557847e6c0d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729070,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks to leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729070","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks to leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e3970af84b049faff669500","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729071,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729071","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Health and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63146b051824170600d5158e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729072,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to present the report of the Special Committee to Review Provisions of\n               the Human Rights Code of the 43rd Parliament, titled Review of Sections 47.01 to 47.24 of the Human Rights Code . I move that the report be taken as read and received. I ask the leave of the House\n               to move a motion to adopt the report. I move that the report be taken as read and received. I ask leave of the House to move a motion to adopt the report.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729072","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am pleased to present the report of the Special Committee to Review Provisions of\n               the Human Rights Code of the 43rd Parliament, titled Review of Sections 47.01 to 47.24 of the Human Rights Code . I move that the report be taken as read and received. I ask the leave of the House\n               to move a motion to adopt the report. I move that the report be taken as read and receive","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5671ac367bfc26443d98852883a7975df9d6388e441e2110e2b626b461096817"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9edf7c01160efe95b7163189801cf6eb77f4cf80c2abbc66ff26e84c63514e0b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5bac13a3becc80aa54984e5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729073,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of Health and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729073","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of Health and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be133f6ca568fca22f680db9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752232,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the House, we have joining us the legislative tour guides and Parliamentary\n               Players who tour and act at the building. Every spring there is a new cohort of folks,\n               all students currently in post-secondary education programs to join the permanent\n               tour team and work on the grounds and in the buildings welcoming hundreds of thousands\n               of visitors. Will the House please help me welcome Taylor Bowden, Eakam Dhillon, Martin Moreno\n               Anderson, Niloofar Riazibeydokhti, Rowan Rallison, Cassidy Lemay, Lawrence Barss, Lawson Farman, Louisa Whitmore, Grace\n               Wiebe, Naomi Duska, Makayla Madill, Mariah Madill, Marlee Young, Scott McCollom, Evan\n               Utzinger and Jesse Hutchinson. Let's give them a warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752232","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the House, we have joining us the legislative tour guides and Parliamentary\n               Players who tour and act at the building. Every spring there is a new cohort of folks,\n               all students currently in post-secondary education programs to join the permanent\n               tour team and work on the grounds and in the buildings welcoming hundreds of thousands\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-250a846f11ff572a09b21b40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017287,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017287","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3468f8fadab96563458ac1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017294,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017294","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54b936fbef9dd3da3c2cd251","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017298,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017298","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a80450be8b5cf5202e2f7a184b545ac928b1fdd150ae3fcdece668d10d08f4f4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0726470b8ba4cad02bb8178e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017304,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of Finance and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017304","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of Finance and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d86d70163f3028a232fab5a3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036470,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today, we have students from the Reynolds Secondary School flexible studies program visiting the Parliament Buildings as part of an educational project facilitated by the legislative internship program: legislative interns Bethany Shimko, Priya Minhas, Jenna Inch and Kira Ames, together with the flexible studies teacher Brad Cunningham, who has been supporting students in a model parliament and learning more about democracy in British Columbia. Can you please join me in making the students and their teacher feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036470","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery today, we have students from the Reynolds Secondary School flexible studies program visiting the Parliament Buildings as part of an educational project facilitated by the legislative internship program: legislative interns Bethany Shimko, Priya Minhas, Jenna Inch and Kira Ames, together with the flexible studies teacher Brad Cunningham, who has been supporting students in a model pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a026715b208ff852ceb9bdd519ceaabec539b278065f03bd21ed56fda704ffb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7479374a16b035d5bb58e5a5fe01cfc1c01ee98e4022da007322754cf0f35aa5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb23983178c67f9d9cf8e605","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036471,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Finance and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036471","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Finance and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e94e4b6a4a38940f9cdcfb48","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036472,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mable Elmore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Office of\n               the Premier and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036472","member_id":"bc-mla-31","member_name":"Mable Elmore","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section B, reports progress of the estimates of the Office of\n               the Premier and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6dd3d46618a5532767afdf6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86151,"date":"2026-02-12T08:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to move a motion to ratify membership changes on the Select Standing\n               Committee on Private Bills and Members' Bills.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86151","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I seek leave to move a motion to ratify membership changes on the Select Standing\n               Committee on Private Bills and Members' Bills.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86a1645764bb5a3b2f31ff2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317131,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call continued debate on the budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317131","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I call continued debate on the budget.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2768f5269619571cbf191ed3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317132,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"The only banana republic would be that side of the House if they ever sat on this\n               side of the House. Their lack of knowledge about the role of the Merit Commissioner is unbelievable.\n               The Merit Commissioner does not deal with boards and political appointments. Does\n               not ever. Somehow they don't seem to understand that. But what we have seen in the last few questions is them get up and try and tarnish\n               the reputation and the names of people who have spent a lifetime of public service.\n               Whether it is in the labour movement.... The member stands up from time to time in this House and likes to go on about union\n               workers and then uses terms like \"union bosses.\" That tells you everything you need\n               to know. They want to impugn the reputation of a former Premier of this province who\n               chairs The member stands up from time to time in this House and likes to go on about union\n               workers and then uses terms like \"union bosses.\" That tells you everything you need\n               to know. They want to impugn the reputation of a former Premier of this province who\n               chairs B.C. Hydro, who managed Jimmy Pattison's empire in this province for 15 years,\n               which was more than that member or any of them could ever do — ever. Finally, let's talk about how this whole issue has come up with the Leader of the\n               Opposition, a former political staff member. The hypocrisy from that side is unreal. You know what, hon. Speaker? I can't wait for a supplemental, because I've got a lot\n               more to give.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317132","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"The only banana republic would be that side of the House if they ever sat on this\n               side of the House. Their lack of knowledge about the role of the Merit Commissioner is unbelievable.\n               The Merit Commissioner does not deal with boards and political appointments. Does\n               not ever. Somehow they don't seem to understand that. But what we have seen in the last fe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hatcheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Eggs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035593","label":"Hatcheries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128176","label":"Eggs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d2bde36dec98b98f8b456474cb63a25bb96dda4a616246799a07ced3a58c98e","63c2dbcae0def0feaaa1c937528cf5cfc6c782a66c12b0a50405afb8511f0301"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2cfe2087c325517787f5b29e414d0e2aec2fa0be581e960180c285623fa213ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98da6d90f67b32a776a13644","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317133,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call continued debate on the budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317133","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I call continued debate on the budget.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-087f69a9b97d9943101fe752","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317134,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Continued debate on the budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317134","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Continued debate on the budget.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0275afbc0af2706a305f66fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317135,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317135","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I call","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93e7932a28fdc303850adb2a3b1ffa1f936f0ae70d76ca6c7623d110e55d4fb6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0aeabc9f40b257d0736793dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327964,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 7, Post Secondary International Education. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call Committee of Supply, ministry of the deputy","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327964","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 7, Post Secondary International Education. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call Committee of Supply, ministry of the deputy","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9693fea85aa825d42cfe6ffa5198ab315941ef5ac739081203b47f7c9004731b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f6055037343bfff3f0879497d317a4efddb88c65077dccb151f73f62a2edee3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfb90c758bdcf9c9b4eb1bea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327965,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, for a grand total of eight minutes, I call the Committee of Supply,\n               estimates for the Ministry of Infrastructure. After that.... Until that's done.... That's what will take place for eight minutes. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call the Committee of Supply, estimates for\n               the Ministry of the Deputy Premier and Attorney General. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call the Committee of Supply, estimates for the Ministry\n               of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327965","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, for a grand total of eight minutes, I call the Committee of Supply,\n               estimates for the Ministry of Infrastructure. After that.... Until that's done.... That's what will take place for eight minutes. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call the Committee of Supply, estimates for\n               the Ministry of the Deputy Premier and Attorney General. In Section C, th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a52b1f1114cb7e593065b1c95bd0e79014c0c964f6865ffe295699d7d846c14"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4e744fd813f87cb201b94076e80d2b3d70f99f2ab68732e0535c52ac63786ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37b1810cea5af8fd37dd03d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327966,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir room, I call Committee of Supply, the estimates for\n               the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply on the Ministry of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills. Just for the information of members, when that is done, they will report out and\n               then, after that, it will be calling the committee stage on Supply Act. I was looking at the second half. I wasn't quite looking at the top part. In this chamber, Section B, it is Committee of Supply, estimates for the Ministry\n               of the Deputy Premier and the Attorney General.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327966","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir room, I call Committee of Supply, the estimates for\n               the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply on the Ministry of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills. Just for the information of members, when that is don","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdd6a36be84323d46f7aeb62f4b5bd598cde5f88ccff33399ce74f37d54b2b67"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5d25b35018abf915b5e9580ec2a075c3d5c29ad04d400aef82af8ef239acb9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a8210ca46d01ca59fab4be1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327967,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act. In section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee on Bill 3, the Business Measures\n               Implementation Act. In section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates committee of supply for the Ministry\n               of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327967","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act. In section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee on Bill 3, the Business Measures\n               Implementation Act. In section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates committee of supply for the Ministry\n               of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53813fa7f04af861b77015ec5187e30994d816ccdd17c5f54549cd92395510f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f1eff0c0147917d705272bb0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327968,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call second reading of Budget Measures Implementation Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee stage on Bill 3, Budget Measures\n               Implementation Act (No. 2). In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply, estimates for the Ministry\n               of Education and Child Care.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327968","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call second reading of Budget Measures Implementation Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee stage on Bill 3, Budget Measures\n               Implementation Act (No. 2). In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply, estimates for the Ministry\n               of Education and Child Care.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["edd05f05ccfe6ed59c2310131f498cef7fcdb4209af086e6a38dfd705f954a99"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b879dccaf6ab1556e5f7a0bcbe14005c7ed2433add037419cd7b73e558851686"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5792bfb197ea10d0faf66389","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327969,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call third reading on Bill 3, Budget Measures Implementation Act (No. 2), 2026.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327969","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I call third reading on Bill 3, Budget Measures Implementation Act (No. 2), 2026.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19b50187ed0ecd3ec24530e165506573504b40274991f5622332c2964e4d06c8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8997996f0e1bcb66a398a2dc9361b92062e2dcf76c6d358657a2a5ccb25848d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fec448ce6eff3053d4d06e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360151,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Hon. Speaker. I'll start by going, I appreciate the question from the member,\n               but the member will know, in this budget, that there is an additional $475 million\n               being invested to assist the people that he is talking about.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360151","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Hon. Speaker. I'll start by going, I appreciate the question from the member,\n               but the member will know, in this budget, that there is an additional $475 million\n               being invested to assist the people that he is talking about.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["08e93a755af52fc6923b197bf657a361da2f0c449366ed2b3f57b63351b28334"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02854434bdd5aea837f82321147553116d3f67b472c0450049efd5061407e01a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-826a9b224ee100fe2fba2a47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360152,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued second reading of the debate on Bill 10, Labour\n               Statutes Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call committee stage on Bill 7, international education bill. Then in Section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Housing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360152","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued second reading of the debate on Bill 10, Labour\n               Statutes Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call committee stage on Bill 7, international education bill. Then in Section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Housing.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3eae8784ccb49a704b6542e96b6715386a625c3e9e5d37f7c94c5a69f9c91400"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b93d6f562ea38b855dc664d9f2bbb636b9793ee81715eda055f89b630258212"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73439e8b0d02faf91b4bc24d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360153,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Speaker, in this chamber, I call continued second reading debate on Bill 9, the\n               Freedom of Information and Privacy Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call Committee of Supply, estimates for the\n               Ministry of Children and Family Development. In section C, the Birch Room, I call continued Committee of Supply, estimates for\n               the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360153","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Hon. Speaker, in this chamber, I call continued second reading debate on Bill 9, the\n               Freedom of Information and Privacy Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call Committee of Supply, estimates for the\n               Ministry of Children and Family Development. In section C, the Birch Room, I call continued Committee of Supply, estimates for\n               the Ministry of Housi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ff6d5e2b94b905281dec3d151448ca693c00e59a60c757e2892267f24abe292"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8d7285c656a72a0399a685d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360154,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure but also my sadness today to thank my communications director, Dave\n               Crebo. Today is his last day of service to me but also to my ministry and to government\n               in general. He has had an amazing career over the years. He's retiring to go on to,\n               I think, more pleasant things than, sometimes, being in charge of the communications. I just want to thank him for the amazing work that he has done, wish him well in his\n               retirement and ask the House to please thank him for his years of dedicated service\n               to this place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360154","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's my pleasure but also my sadness today to thank my communications director, Dave\n               Crebo. Today is his last day of service to me but also to my ministry and to government\n               in general. He has had an amazing career over the years. He's retiring to go on to,\n               I think, more pleasant things than, sometimes, being in charge of the communications. I just want ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f88457e23e4843db2107e55957e6a1e4dfb26d7fb08bfe3fac2d819bfadc08f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d41326a07ab58363c41bfa4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360155,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call Motion 13 on the order paper. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call estimates for the Ministry of Children and Family Development. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call estimates for the Ministry of Forests.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360155","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call Motion 13 on the order paper. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call estimates for the Ministry of Children and Family Development. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call estimates for the Ministry of Forests.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b56cbdeef2c3120e2efdbc033c810bee3f795f78a33fcf8027b5f4d863b15d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11fe9a2f189090a509e5b79858da2dec9f75fbc42d5b3d75deb6228bb982cfdd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e047364a1730a13021b79b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415719,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move, pursuant to Standing Order 16.4, that this morning's private members' time\n               deferred division be further deferred until the start of orders of the day to the\n               next sitting day and that any division in section B in today's sitting also be deferred.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415719","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move, pursuant to Standing Order 16.4, that this morning's private members' time\n               deferred division be further deferred until the start of orders of the day to the\n               next sitting day and that any division in section B in today's sitting also be deferred.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c8e2f5e3b23915a28116e979a5d9a9ae0e3824c1ae5048aa47c7abaef5f3e56"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7dbdefea28560ac8a49b683e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415720,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"By leave, I move: \"that Claire Rattée replace Hon Chan as member of the Select Standing Committee on Private Bills and Private Members'\n               Bills.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415720","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"By leave, I move: \"that Claire Rattée replace Hon Chan as member of the Select Standing Committee on Private Bills and Private Members'\n               Bills.\"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55d69879116470f26b55ec84c51acd5e25b995a6059f47bae6a6a9a87765cbf3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0db2fc885cc85148441016be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415721,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Picking up from where we left just before we broke for lunch, by leave, I move that\n               Debra Toporowski replace Steve Morissette as a member of the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415721","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Picking up from where we left just before we broke for lunch, by leave, I move that\n               Debra Toporowski replace Steve Morissette as a member of the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government Services.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35a0bfa7d1cac78d56ba6dc63ef66bcabcab64d84224335ca7c405704317043c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-643fc4ef4759aa6a9d92b205","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415722,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure today to introduce two members from the Canadian Institute of Steel\n               Construction who are joining us here in the gallery. As you know, steel is a major\n               component of construction projects here in British Columbia and indeed across our\n               entire country. So I'm very pleased to welcome Rita Rahmati, the director of public\n               affairs, and Chris Weckesser, manager of business initiatives for western Canada. Would the House please make them most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415722","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's my pleasure today to introduce two members from the Canadian Institute of Steel\n               Construction who are joining us here in the gallery. As you know, steel is a major\n               component of construction projects here in British Columbia and indeed across our\n               entire country. So I'm very pleased to welcome Rita Rahmati, the director of public\n               affair","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","label":"Construction materials","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67164822178d543fabf5a0bc0dc574ef8d23d3f9da1d60a348d1c2a44081ec4f","6e5c05d367f2d360acc2348fcd0cf2dc7e9a2b4035d4dfd8bd9a6017acecef26"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-479cd3559552381f3ffc0b1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415723,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the member for the question. I obviously realize the importance of the Taylor Bridge in his neck of the woods and\n               the importance it is to the province as a whole. We take bridge safety very seriously. Bridges are inspected on a regular basis to\n               ensure that they are safe, and that happens with the Taylor Bridge. We also know that the Taylor Bridge does need to be replaced, and that's why we're\n               spending $40 million to date in terms of engineering and project development to do\n               just that. Extensive field assessment, structural and environmental, hydrotechnical,\n               utilities, traffic and economic analyses have been completed. This past summer, load\n               tests were done on some of the key areas in terms of where a new bridge would be. So I can assure the member that work is underway to determine the best way that the\n               bridge needs to be replaced and how it should be replaced. At the same time, I want\n               to assure the member that the bridge is safe. It is inspected on a regular basis,\n               as are all our bridges in the province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415723","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank the member for the question. I obviously realize the importance of the Taylor Bridge in his neck of the woods and\n               the importance it is to the province as a whole. We take bridge safety very seriously. Bridges are inspected on a regular basis to\n               ensure that they are safe, and that happens with the Taylor Bridge. We also know that the Taylor Bridge does need to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","label":"Inspection"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","label":"Transportation safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036880","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036880","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Railway safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036880","label":"Railway safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","label":"Transportation safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","label":"Inspection","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd8f5470d30a6ac91bcb9bab932b13ce615b1c22ae3378a87f4eb39f138d5e68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d5db3648ee75188731ebb6337507e265020a9846eba5e66910ffeedbdf7d47a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c8795f5d8c4cf177967a5b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415724,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the comments from the member opposite. Government will take its time,\n               and the minister will respond at a later opportunity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415724","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the comments from the member opposite. Government will take its time,\n               and the minister will respond at a later opportunity.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f830411f3ea41a005198044028f38d519d9498185a730fc062639fd7b499f1fa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13959b93abb53c446fec3fec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720318,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's been interesting hearing the questions from the opposition on infrastructure\n               investment in the province of British Columbia. You know what. We've said yes to building the Surrey-Langley SkyTrain.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720318","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's been interesting hearing the questions from the opposition on infrastructure\n               investment in the province of British Columbia. You know what. We've said yes to building the Surrey-Langley SkyTrain.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad60493138a8998cd12a093b4639225ea7dd3ba5974e96d247ef214e1ab3a86f","3cc57f5ece20a360fa1594da3c58c83fc12f6c45e0520637816a7d72e2c10cb4","0956f4b7c6085b054412fd6d2a13e66ff8d47106999eb231926a4783a0511873"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22913d4995b12b388a57f38264a2eb4101178ff65959e7d7f7b3ad21422b8276"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86e930c751f00c49f8382cbf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720320,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm happy to answer the question that the member has raised. First off, as the member\n               would be aware, B.C. Ferries is an independent body. It is not a Crown corporation.\n               I hear a little bit of chuckling from the other side. I'd remind the other side of\n               the House that the reason it is that is because the last time that some of them were\n               on this side of the House, I hear a little bit of chuckling from the other side, and I'd remind the other side\n               of the House that the reason it is that is because the last time that some of them\n               were on this side of the House — and most of them voted for the government that was\n               on this side of the House — they set up that format under which B.C. Ferries operates.\n               B.C. Ferries — the authority appoints the board, and the board appoints the CEO. They're\n               the ones who determine the contract. In terms of B.C. Ferries and the recent challenges that it has had, the CEO did go\n               and publicly apologize and said that what happened over the long weekend was unacceptable. The reality is that 99 percent of the time, B.C. Ferries meets its sailing targets.\n               There are new vessels coming to replace the aging fleet. There are also new vessels\n               that are arriving as we speak, the new Island class ferries. The CEO and the great people who work at B.C. Ferries are doing everything they can\n               to maintain an important transportation network on the coast of British Columbia,\n               and I have confidence that they will continue to do that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720320","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm happy to answer the question that the member has raised. First off, as the member\n               would be aware, B.C. Ferries is an independent body. It is not a Crown corporation.\n               I hear a little bit of chuckling from the other side. I'd remind the other side of\n               the House that the reason it is that is because the last time that some of them were\n               on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8b89d96ca8a9898bc78803842cc47bc045d50c54db6679903ef085b6fc5fe90","3c2b67167e2cd2bd45ec2f8e7c5ac8e2e96fc28a80f8a08e146e56c7a190e740"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0685584b101707757c9a0da67124fe87b2d9c67053395ab7c3d6eb1c46e9c616"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4054ea1a27f47c98a4504b80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720321,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates for the Ministry of Agriculture and Food.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720321","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates for the Ministry of Agriculture and Food.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a17c687cba46a007b1f930d4a43df3f2214bf614e47e966225219698c8146694"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["061f5948f75bdedd3b4202c59b017f2d8191f31564aed414bacc384f3afc7461"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42b986e64432dcd4d859a3e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720324,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Given the acknowledgement that pictures were taken, I would request that you request\n               anything that was taken against the rules be deleted.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720324","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Given the acknowledgement that pictures were taken, I would request that you request\n               anything that was taken against the rules be deleted.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c06c7ef58aeec18d76d059f6badc795885975924237fe4629edca1763f5844d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6ead3a344275dc93813b9a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720326,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure today to introduce two individuals to the House. One is no stranger; she has been around these buildings and these chambers since she\n               was a toddler because she is the daughter of former MLA Rob Fleming, and that is his daughter, Rory Fleming. She's a student at the University of Victoria and she's here today. She's with a friend of hers who is a constituent of mine, and his name is Shay Hines. He's from Port Coquitlam and a graduate of Riverside High School, but he's also attending the University of Victoria. They're both here to see the\n               proceedings today. Would the House make them both very welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720326","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's my pleasure today to introduce two individuals to the House. One is no stranger; she has been around these buildings and these chambers since she\n               was a toddler because she is the daughter of former MLA Rob Fleming, and that is his daughter, Rory Fleming. She's a student at the University of Victoria and she's here today. She's with a friend of hers who is a constituent of mine,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Maritime law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360866","label":"Maritime law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52e7278b31ad80e108a80b1ad2db070c934de153ce68b5fc928250c8be5f9412","a2256dc3c3dc0185b8f5a0312208660c4348b35b8962a07b308ac04e544f9f2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb88d276489c30ac9d162dcd422223b420befc773a2326f52448bd7e418406fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e2327241d230357377417ea7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721391,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 16, Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee stage on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721391","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 16, Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee stage on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f40d96fd846a8cbcf1f235280086dce47d9e4cf7a77ad4a94bb27367b96dd2a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11d5623f6f61b6a26390b6c13c799f454c04c095c2a0cffdfbac40bffc8ae968"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-014de82b0e1c9b7f359f7c79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721392,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued second reading debate on Bill 9, the Freedom of\n               Information and Protection of Privacy Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 14, the\n               Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply, the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721392","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued second reading debate on Bill 9, the Freedom of\n               Information and Protection of Privacy Act. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 14, the\n               Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply, the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4eee6c504db1d5e8daaef1fbab3ad55efdc0c425e809b893841c7b35e0313068"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f650bbd9763d121f5b390c3f1c1ecd833fa9ec1b5e1036cc9ba79bc81c54eed0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f51af62cc333acd1dbac291","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721394,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Speaker, in this chamber I call second reading of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Privacy Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee stage on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply, for the estimates of the Ministry of\n               Emergency Management and Climate Readiness and, when that's finished, for the Ministry\n               of Environment and Parks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721394","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Hon. Speaker, in this chamber I call second reading of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Privacy Act. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call committee stage on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act. In the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply, for the estimates of the Ministry of\n               Emergency Management and Climate Readiness and, when that's finished, for the Ministry\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a28b47f61897ef2fd221122a83298a6081f312ef4f230f149b496624117be48a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["64d9af3e7643eb3739d9c137cf13c25bc1aac13ca22e1541da9b93220f94bfae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6e81d5996ec6f142bf8ae0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721402,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that pursuant to Standing Order 16.4, any division called in Sections A, B\n               or C during the morning sitting on Thursday, April 23, 2026, be deferred until start\n               of the orders of the day for the afternoon sitting on Thursday, April 23, 2026.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721402","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move that pursuant to Standing Order 16.4, any division called in Sections A, B\n               or C during the morning sitting on Thursday, April 23, 2026, be deferred until start\n               of the orders of the day for the afternoon sitting on Thursday, April 23, 2026.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c21088e92b872fd926e651a2c15df11461e31605eb05591008ed1f2b10b27f3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0f2ed63b9990edb7f6f5a83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721405,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the member for his question. I think we had a good meeting in my office the\n               other day on the issue that the member faces. Just on a couple of the points the member raises, in terms of money going back to\n               his particular region, I'd like to remind him that I was the minister that brought\n               in place the first Fair Share agreement in the northeast in his area so that some\n               of the resource revenues that come from that area actually fall back to his community,\n               and that's something that this side of the House has continued. In terms of the slide that he talks about, that is a very challenging situation, as\n               the member does know. It is a 400-metre-long slide in an area that is significantly\n               prone to slides. What we have seen in terms of mitigation.... The member knows that\n               a new alternative route for that particular area would cost probably between $250\n               and $300 million and would not give a guarantee that it would not be impacted by slides. What we are currently doing in terms of the situation in the area.... Emergency Management\n               is dealing with the individuals in the 50 homes in that community. At the same time,\n               my ministry is monitoring the slide in terms of getting an understanding of how this\n               particular stage of the slide is moving. It has slowed down somewhat, but it initially\n               was moving at a rate of about 90 cm an hour, which is pretty significant and pretty\n               fast. We continue to do that work. We will continue to meet that member, keep him updated,\n               and I know that we're meeting with the regional district later today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721405","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank the member for his question. I think we had a good meeting in my office the\n               other day on the issue that the member faces. Just on a couple of the points the member raises, in terms of money going back to\n               his particular region, I'd like to remind him that I was the minister that brought\n               in place the first Fair Share agreement in the northeast in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76a65b4e7c79af55817262460cf580f8565da0e3690ce14a14f546275d9e5bbc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["675502037686e4e0014d0f676063f344432bfec2370677ccf0e27070bb9e7066"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2078ea6e993bda7b414b0bf0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721415,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call continued debate on Bill 20.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721415","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call continued debate on Bill 20.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cae66dda4b665903cf202432","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729074,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the question from the member, but I have to say the member is incorrect\n               and wrong, which is not something that is unusual in this House. At the time, I told the member, in response to his questions back on April 1, that\n               I would be meeting with the city of Abbotsford. I met with the city of Abbotsford\n               and outlined to them the efforts being undertaken by my ministry and other ministries\n               involving the relocation of individuals who are engaged in camps, of the work that's\n               underway. The Cole Road campsite, for example, is being shut down. We have been working with\n               Housing and the city of Abbotsford to ensure that we're able to relocate those who\n               are camping in inappropriate places, such as this one, to more appropriate a shelter. I can tell the member that the Peardonville camp is going to be decamped and closed\n               down by the beginning of summer, but it will be done in an orderly fashion. To somehow\n               suggest that government didn't bother to do anything and ignored the problem is simply\n               incorrect.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729074","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the question from the member, but I have to say the member is incorrect\n               and wrong, which is not something that is unusual in this House. At the time, I told the member, in response to his questions back on April 1, that\n               I would be meeting with the city of Abbotsford. I met with the city of Abbotsford\n               and outlined to them the efforts being u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["17acf0d130d9bbfcd9f5ea59912ef0a77b16820e358777417cd6330d687cc85e","b0fd000a1d603c7fcc5ea39d8b8cc8de6d7a87b7409d45bfb560eca627089706"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d0da7ba2621b3e96723357cc6bc2a9e9c4ba92328d5e3e703a7904fc63b116e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e87b0f5f01b12674051c484","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729082,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates, debate for the Ministry of Health, and\n               in the Douglas Fir Room, I call continued committee stage on Bill 16, Miscellaneous\n               Statutes Amendment Act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729082","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates, debate for the Ministry of Health, and\n               in the Douglas Fir Room, I call continued committee stage on Bill 16, Miscellaneous\n               Statutes Amendment Act.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46d5db968b6ae667681474f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729088,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates debate for the Ministry of Health. In Section A, in the Douglas Fir Room, I call continued committee stage on Bill 16.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729088","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates debate for the Ministry of Health. In Section A, in the Douglas Fir Room, I call continued committee stage on Bill 16.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32a4340a6649794056da3f04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729092,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the member for the question. You'll get no disagreement from me on the importance of transit along the Sea to Sky\n               Corridor. I know the member would like to see buses being ordered, but in order to\n               do that, one of the things that has to be put in place is an understanding and agreement\n               with the communities along there on how the system is going to be governed, and that's\n               what we've been working on. We've made it clear that right now in the province there are two models that have\n               been in place. We've been looking at Nanaimo and in Victoria in terms of how transit\n               is governed and, just as importantly, as to how they're funded. That's been a particular bit of a challenge, because there is a point of view on how\n               that should be that is quite different. I've recently met with the mayor of Whistler,\n               for example. What I have said is that we're willing to look at: is there another alternative\n               that could be put in place that would meet the requirements that we must have in terms\n               of governance and how something is funded but also recognizes that there are some\n               unique issues when it comes to the Sea to Sky Highway and some unique opportunities? We are continuing to do that work. But to suggest that what we need to do is be ordering\n               buses.... I understand the desire for that. The reality is we're working to make sure\n               that what's put in place is right for the communities and right for the province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729092","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank the member for the question. You'll get no disagreement from me on the importance of transit along the Sea to Sky\n               Corridor. I know the member would like to see buses being ordered, but in order to\n               do that, one of the things that has to be put in place is an understanding and agreement\n               with the communities along there on how the system is going t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b26d80c6cdcadd2d23f164b877727be3c193a58f0f44b482da04b92a5a66c81","ed2222d6c862697117ab40aa573f4e6c55df839ab44a3a429b1193ece9793c82","bdef68131e9f721cd80239e876dcd6c5e8eb5d6db3d3ce19a24ca31c6f20ee2a","3d054dc74ac794dffb5d3aced7229c80fca4d82a3d0c16c722a352f9cf77c10c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["60c647589c522671b3795bd2478e31c061137f51d7219e70494ac859b0c069e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad171c84099a2c4cc4d208cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729106,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued committee stage estimates debate on the Ministry\n               of Health. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call the continued estimates debate for the\n               Ministry of Mines.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729106","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued committee stage estimates debate on the Ministry\n               of Health. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call the continued estimates debate for the\n               Ministry of Mines.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f70c944ac07637d0ea28e8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752233,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"While we do our jobs here and when we're back in our ridings doing our jobs, there\n               are some very important people who work in our offices, and they are our constituency\n               assistants. They do incredible work helping constituents day, in day out. Ours are over here for a couple of days on their annual conference, and many of them\n               are here in the galleries. Would the House please make them all very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752233","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"While we do our jobs here and when we're back in our ridings doing our jobs, there\n               are some very important people who work in our offices, and they are our constituency\n               assistants. They do incredible work helping constituents day, in day out. Ours are over here for a couple of days on their annual conference, and many of them\n               are here in the galleries. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86d409c6cdf8c1b35a2c067ff3142c42bc536bbbfa95d680c88a790c4eb6ec84","85092580c1cd5b350751c7c57bfe4d49c9599919ca7c14cdd952038bc3af62db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7aa2693cee08b1f81122501c0c992118855851214b0dae7f691695e823f3c2b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04009a18af99bb5966896a6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752234,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I guess I appreciate the question from the member because this is now day three on\n               the same topic. He's now asked me a very specific talk about the question of where\n               the 18 cents came from. That was presented to me by the Sea the Sky communities who\n               want a transit system in place. That's where that number came from. I said to them that there are two models that we would, the two options that we gave\n               them. One, the Nanaimo model, the Victoria model. They don't like that. What they\n               wanted was the one that put 18 cents a liter on. That's the context.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752234","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I guess I appreciate the question from the member because this is now day three on\n               the same topic. He's now asked me a very specific talk about the question of where\n               the 18 cents came from. That was presented to me by the Sea the Sky communities who\n               want a transit system in place. That's where that number came from. I said to them that there are two mod","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","label":"Beverages","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","label":"Accessible transport","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42244bb66ee1e7b13cdc93802cc0e66b194f15499e0b3e86cbbe6dd7397408ec","060de8587ccefeec98bb336c1129a205e247f73d3685d4425b34ad757ef3a57a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21be0e2fa1e43fd44fb9851c6ddbcbd501b3e1cfa9d9c80b939a31801e069ef7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b14856ce6f0767812e0d81d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752235,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued second reading debate on Bill 9. In the Douglas Fir room, I call Committee of Supply for the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Ministry of Labour estimates.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752235","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued second reading debate on Bill 9. In the Douglas Fir room, I call Committee of Supply for the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Ministry of Labour estimates.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["491fcd7edb0218df92c84d1adc36d68187a1cc8d23ba07abae0c94bf278ce00f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ae7a9977d40120ad8c790ee62b109024fe5302c98b18915e9edb0c96200cbab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4808056e255f1f17eb91f22d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752236,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call Motion 16 on the Order Paper. I move Motion 16 of which notice has been given\n               in my name on the Order Paper, which recommits Bill M217 to the Select Standing Committee\n               on Private Bills and Private Members' Bills. I want to be very clear, as the Minister of Transportation, that I support this bill\n               and look forward to it receiving royal assent. My recommittal motion is to fix an\n               error that my ministry identified once the committee reported to the House. Specifically, this motion is to give instructions to the committee to consider two\n               amendments to clause 1. There are two small amendments that we hope to see. One is\n               to revise the proposed definition of commercial vehicle to mean a commercial vehicle,\n               as defined in the Commercial Transport Act, that has a gross vehicle weight rating\n               of more than 11,793 kg, and two, to define gross vehicle weight rating to mean gross\n               vehicle weight rating as defined in the Motor Vehicle Act. These changes will narrow the scope of the mandatory dashboard camera requirement\n               to apply to the heaviest types of commercial vehicles that regularly cross borders\n               and for which there is the greatest need for consistency among the federal and provincial\n               regulatory frameworks. As the bill is written now, it would apply to taxis, Uber,\n               pizza delivery drivers and not the heavy commercial vehicles that the MLA who brought\n               in this bill has intended. This would make the mandatory dashboard camera requirement consistent with the requirement\n               for these vehicles to be equipped with speed limiters. A narrow scope of the application\n               will ensure that the mandatory dashboard requirement does not unintentionally apply\n               to smaller commercial vehicles such as delivery vehicles and landscaping trucks. Gross vehicle weight rating is defined in the Motor Vehicle Act to mean the value\n               specified by the vehicle manufacturer as the loaded weight of a single vehicle. The\n               gross vehicle weight rating is the maximum total safe operating weight of a vehicle\n               as determined by the manufacturer, including the vehicle itself. That is curb weight,\n               passengers, fuel, accessories and cargo. The gross vehicle weight rating acts as a crucial safety standard to prevent overloading.\n               It is an easily discernible measure for enforcement purposes because it is found on\n               the driver's side door jamb label. I bet you didn't know that. Finally, I know that\n               the chair of the committee and the vice-chair of the Finally, I know that the Chair of the committee and the vice-Chair of the committee\n               are following these proceedings closely, and I request that the committee work on\n               these very small amendments expeditiously so that this bill can receive royal assent\n               before we adjourn for the summer on May 28.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752236","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call Motion 16 on the Order Paper. I move Motion 16 of which notice has been given\n               in my name on the Order Paper, which recommits Bill M217 to the Select Standing Committee\n               on Private Bills and Private Members' Bills. I want to be very clear, as the Minister of Transportation, that I support this bill\n               and look forward to it receiving royal assent. My ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","label":"Transportation safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","label":"Sustainable transportation","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","label":"Transportation safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["126b6f60ecbda10359c1c0fd73743d1da8f54be062b54abe7e5438ad4f6cf767","35c514b4a3b39946aa18ac3236b397c14a701a28ff5d68db6f75d70d28b950f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["acd731b2f7fd323668cc98b4cc80867b5d9c3a45911eb54a47a4c90f3a1969de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transportation safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47268","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2467e16aca540b6968cc6f86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752237,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the question from the member. I can tell you that we have an incredible transit system in this province, and they\n               are policed by the transit service, which do an amazing job day in and day out for Hon. Mike Farnworth : I appreciate the question from the member, and I can tell you that we have an incredible\n               transit system in this province, and they are policed by the transit service, which\n               do an amazing job, day in and day out, for the people of the province. I can tell you, hon. Speaker, that the transit police enforce the laws of this province\n               every single day, and they will continue to do so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752237","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the question from the member. I can tell you that we have an incredible transit system in this province, and they\n               are policed by the transit service, which do an amazing job day in and day out for Hon. Mike Farnworth : I appreciate the question from the member, and I can tell you that we have an incredible\n               transit system in this province, and they are pol","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["27923f59fbb886a3d76e5d9c9d1df70d147c2530ead09960c2cb53de19e76772"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c7260c00fe267235bd06dcffd31fa19a47150705f887c8464b8727722a166fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34819f638675827e90213288","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752238,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call the Committee of Supply for the estimates for the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of Supply for the estimates for\n               the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, estimates of the Legislative Assembly and the estimates of the officers of the Legislative\n               Assembly. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply estimates for the Ministry of Jobs and Economic Growth.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752238","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call the Committee of Supply for the estimates for the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of Supply for the estimates for\n               the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, estimates of the Legislative Assembly and the estimates of the officers of the Legislative\n               Assembly. In Section C, the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5dd80747d658ed8a9abacf1b4e956d5c231378dc5b4a42862e0b8db0ed14db8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19a42b1a4785cb920d636020621f3c4019fc7c4b7a87f3eeba8cf59fdad0cd85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5bc474a94725cbb08d2d17f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017314,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that, pursuant to Standing Order 16.4, division call in Committee of the Whole\n               on Bill 9 intituled Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act,\n               2026, to an amendment standing in the name of the Minister of Citizens' Services on\n               the order paper be deferred until the start of orders of the day of the next sitting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017314","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that, pursuant to Standing Order 16.4, division call in Committee of the Whole\n               on Bill 9 intituled Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act,\n               2026, to an amendment standing in the name of the Minister of Citizens' Services on\n               the order paper be deferred until the start of orders of the day of the next sitting.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["196f9d9596bd545f64dc67d01bdf127d9677629325706265a98ae5d7ebe17e07"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8a1ec0322ef62b04079e70a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017322,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call Committee of Supply, the estimates of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and the Legislative Assembly. For the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply for the Ministry of Jobs and Economic Growth. And just advisement: in terms of the Douglas Fir room, there are about ten minutes left, so we will be\n               back to call the next items after that. I called Transportation and the officers of the Legislative Assembly. Just for information\n               of members, that is for Votes 1 through 10 on the legislative officers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017322","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call Committee of Supply, the estimates of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General. In Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and the Legislative Assembly. For the Birch Room, I call Committee of Supply for the Ministry of Jobs and Economic Growth. And just advisement: in terms of the Douglas Fir room, there are about","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aaf835d096ae740050bed3cfc9ddad34969d0f46c35970b271f219b46b2e62ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9aca428c2f9f751df131d309d92f64bcbcce20621096cbd695933df38f7c11d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f77e8caec35f86f698a7edbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017326,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think the member just answered his own question by outlining the number of tickets\n               in the policy that was outlined by the minister in regard to FIFA. It does give me an opportunity to remind members of this House of the policy that\n               was in place under the previous government, a number of whose members do continue\n               to sit in this House — the member for Nechako Lakes, the member for Delta South, the member for Richmond Centre. There were others — the Leader of the Opposition, who was a staffer at the time.\n               I'll come to him in a moment. I know that they get upset when I say they were part of the previous government. I\n               will admit that most of them were not, but I will say this: they did vote for the\n               previous governments. So it is my pleasure to inform that when some of those members sat on this side of\n               the House — and the Leader of the Opposition in fact worked in the office — the ticket-palooza\n               that took place during the 2010 Olympics involved the opposition giving its own MLAs\n               143 tickets to Olympic events. That was 57 of them. Almost half were used for hockey, 49 for men's hockey, but only eight for women's\n               hockey. That's more free tickets than they had MLAs at the time. They gave figure\n               skating 20 tickets; short-track speed skating, ten tickets; all 13 other sports, zero\n               tickets. None of them took a ticket to the Paralympics; they completely skipped the\n               Paralympics. So we've outlined a policy that if MLAs want to go, they'll be buying their own tickets,\n               unlike the ticket-palooza that took place when many of them sat on this side of the\n               House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017326","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think the member just answered his own question by outlining the number of tickets\n               in the policy that was outlined by the minister in regard to FIFA. It does give me an opportunity to remind members of this House of the policy that\n               was in place under the previous government, a number of whose members do continue\n               to sit in this House — the member for N","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3fa187aea935371be1423b0b735fdb2162a282bd4818284a29061bf1f04d084f","4341d74775cae03f33784678cf87f2c5cfd32a877a531d25b25702dd2e4357d9","46fade821de96863821c784dcab7dde2f47b99dd1e35a09d152231a4497b829a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ba2f18c6d96508e21d1c145efd96a6f7e80398579cba814de4aed40e4c7718f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29c75fa25cf9ec71908b986f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017332,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today, we have four representatives from a great B.C. company, Terra\n               Remote Sensing. It is an aerial marine survey mapping company based in North Saanich,\n               B.C., that has been involved with a lot of infrastructure projects, disaster mitigation,\n               environmental monitoring in our great province. I'd like the House to welcome Dave Mostyn, Dean Johnson, Ted Roesch and Taylor Davis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017332","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery today, we have four representatives from a great B.C. company, Terra\n               Remote Sensing. It is an aerial marine survey mapping company based in North Saanich,\n               B.C., that has been involved with a lot of infrastructure projects, disaster mitigation,\n               environmental monitoring in our great province. I'd like the House to welcome Dave Mostyn, Dean ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035484","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Geographic information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035484","label":"Geographic information systems","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","label":"Air quality","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722633","label":"Inspection","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47d0d9b8d228e1f559d81e1ebca73bd2f8de377fbb4e7312a4c1a8ad9c062646","7a0a7f32c5c14433d405cf37d4ad6c19cda59105d512783bb45b7afce4824605"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1828314b447b8974c7d9e89cd084f4e540cf3d67faf5ac904c3e0a0571b99c2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d806dc767e1a968debe988d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017337,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates debate for the Ministry of Finance. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call continued committee stage on Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Privacy Act. And in the Birch Room, Section C, I call continued committee stage on Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017337","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In this chamber, I call continued estimates debate for the Ministry of Finance. In the Douglas Fir Room, Section A, I call continued committee stage on Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Privacy Act. And in the Birch Room, Section C, I call continued committee stage on Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7001aff350174b27340b07fc9a913e71ddb79172efdfe3e846d68c5da64acc98"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["302da6155d8342e4c715b7166d49e8b189f0bb0d380539c98f0bef21a60f872a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b376537757927ef79ca86e38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036473,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the question from the member. I'm happy to respond on the initiatives\n               that the ministry has undertaken while this project has been underway to ensure a\n               minimum of inconvenience as possible to the businesses that he's talking about in\n               the area. By the very fact that there is traffic diversion taking place.... The work was done\n               with traffic engineers, with the city of Vancouver, with the local businesses to understand\n               exactly the challenges that they're facing. I can tell the member that, without that\n               rerouting that's taking place, the inconvenience would last for twice as long. The reality is that those decks have to be removed and the underground infrastructure\n               replaced. That work is underway. The time period is being reduced from 14 months down\n               to six months. That's a significant improvement. At the same time, working with the businesses to ensure that the rerouting is done\n               in a way that allows for things such as parking to be taken into account, ways in\n               which we can improve that.... At the same time, pedestrian access is still there, in\n               place, so that pedestrians can go to the businesses impacted. The critical thing is\n               to get it done as quickly as possible, and that's what these changes and the rerouting\n               will do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036473","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the question from the member. I'm happy to respond on the initiatives\n               that the ministry has undertaken while this project has been underway to ensure a\n               minimum of inconvenience as possible to the businesses that he's talking about in\n               the area. By the very fact that there is traffic diversion taking place.... The work was done\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","label":"Accessible transport","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ff5f69a7bcd033093059fae642bd00c0e766ac3a267b4a96a39a8752c70af0b7","cc1c874693a19508a98cd37b82acecdf86504d4a0b7b849e39799c29002351f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4785025e219bf196963f766faa3ee5ed9ebcb608027ff30b31fa2a5842fa0356"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc71e7e796fc6e8609394175","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036474,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to take this opportunity to do something which I don't usually do, which is\n               to introduce someone who has already been introduced. But in this case, I think it's\n               worthy of it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036474","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to take this opportunity to do something which I don't usually do, which is\n               to introduce someone who has already been introduced. But in this case, I think it's\n               worthy of it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cde48125b4a3ba27b14542efc05e1643cdf8e0577c31e661089f1a85c7cfc03"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ceceeec9e988bf7e9a0d679d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036475,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call committee stage on Bill 9.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036475","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call committee stage on Bill 9.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3eaf9809614380dc3889c8b8d354aa9f0f292bb74e9cae1e7610da219cb8a4a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3361f49677d5d6c51cfd8684","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036476,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"At lunchtime today, many members on the government caucus had an opportunity to meet\n               with the concrete industry, which does such an amazing job in building the infrastructure\n               that helps to grow our economy and power our province. They're in the gallery today, and I'd like the House to make them all welcome and\n               recognize the important contribution they make to British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036476","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"At lunchtime today, many members on the government caucus had an opportunity to meet\n               with the concrete industry, which does such an amazing job in building the infrastructure\n               that helps to grow our economy and power our province. They're in the gallery today, and I'd like the House to make them all welcome and\n               recognize the important contribution they m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","label":"Heritage buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","label":"Concrete","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6151f898e42e022bacbfaf5ce3af1b4999370204e842dcccfb2ecf68428a8e0c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fda752bed9fec69cd2a7c4de2583b90b3f209a189b3a3ce8c2e3850b0f281364"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Concrete","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300230","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9861f7ef2bbd5fa7ef0d5011","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036477,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday the opposition introduced some very important people to this House, their\n               interns. Today it is our turn to introduce some amazing young people, interns who've\n               helped the government caucus in this last session. They're amazing individuals who\n               I know have learned a lot while they're here, and I'm looking forward to knowing what\n               they're doing in the next stage of their careers. But I'd like, at this time, to introduce Keira Emes, Lauren Onderwater, Abedah Siddiqui, Adnana Nduagu and Bethany Shymko. Will the House please make these remarkable individuals welcome\n               and thank them?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036477","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday the opposition introduced some very important people to this House, their\n               interns. Today it is our turn to introduce some amazing young people, interns who've\n               helped the government caucus in this last session. They're amazing individuals who\n               I know have learned a lot while they're here, and I'm looking forward to knowing what\n               th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e394ad080d39a1df12bef761f1a58c67eb3a4a6058624c33e53d3b5be6cddeda"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d24975eff29ac6564e54f2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036478,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mike Farnworth","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call third reading of Bill 20.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036478","member_id":"bc-mla-33","member_name":"Mike Farnworth","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call third reading of Bill 20.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a92b48db0444d705d879c465428f0af91f48463743c9858726b75b4734a281a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41cd6167606a44732e510136","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317215,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I just quickly thank the member for his advocacy for his community that led us to\n               this bill and offer my sincere condolences to the family. Full disclosure, I met with the family virtually. That obviously does impact, sometimes,\n               our views of these things. But as a father of 12-year-old daughters who are four years\n               away from driving, I think there's still a lot of value in that in that viewpoint. I think what I want to focus on is whether some of these events are preventable. We\n               know that the nomenclature has changed from calling these accidents to calling them\n               what they are. They're crashes. They're not accidents when they're entirely predictable\n               and preventable. I'll just briefly talk about my community, the riding I represent. The Sea to Sky\n               Highway is a winding, dangerous, sometimes snowy road. For such a dangerous road,\n               you would not believe.... I drive it way too often. Actually, when I have the opportunity\n               to take the bus, my blood pressure goes way down because the amount of reckless driving\n               that I see on that highway is almost incomprehensible. The community and I have advocated for speed cameras, speed over distance, more speed\n               limit enforcement. There has been more enforcement lately, and the results are quite\n               telling. But around 90 percent of trips on this highway are private vehicles, commuters,\n               locals, tourists. When there's an accident, the closure can last for hours, significantly disrupting\n               people's lives. The team has to come from the Lower Mainland, which takes a lot of\n               time. There's currently an open petition with thousands of signatures asking for safety\n               improvements on the Sea to Sky. I'm trying to remember the name of the integrated unit. It's not IHIT. I will retract\n               that. Because of the lack of buses on that highway, I've been in a Poparide, which is a\n               ride-sharing service, carrying four passengers, with a driver going 150 kilometres\n               an hour in an 80 zone. Least to say, I was not impressed, but this is a common thing. Understandably, some of these accidents are not just recklessness. Sometimes drivers\n               lack experience, sometimes skill. But the majority of the drivers on this highway\n               are locals and commuters. I will say there is work to be done on this bill. I think the intent is there, and\n               that's well supported at second reading. But a 30-day driving suspension that doesn't\n               follow due process or is perceived to be unfair or unconstitutional can be crippling\n               to livelihoods. That's where the Charter of Rights, I think, comes in. Nothing in this bill can be discretionary. But it is clear that we need more solutions\n               for reckless driving, whether they come from the federal Attorney General or provincial\n               Attorney General. I'm not picky about where these changes come from. But I am of the firm belief that driving is a privilege and not a right. I've personally\n               observed many occasions when somebody should be given 30 days time out to think about\n               the way they've been driving. I think we need to sort out the process. If there's\n               duplication If there's duplication, I think we can solve that in committee. If there's infringement\n               on rights then we can handle that. It may be that we get to the end of the committee\n               and we find that we can't solve these problems, in which case maybe the bill won't\n               go forward, but I think the spirit and the intent is on the money given the state\n               of our roads and the state of public safety. These are preventable. They're the predictable result of a system that is coming up\n               short in terms of training good drivers and enforcing good driving behaviour. I will support it at second reading, and I will hope that there's a lot of input.\n               We've had some good discussions in our private members' committee. I recognize that\n               there is some hesitation about the amount of time that things take, but I think it's\n               a really valuable process. We'll hear from experts and those with opinions on how\n               to strike the right balance. I'm optimistic that it can be done, and I support second\n               reading.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317215","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I just quickly thank the member for his advocacy for his community that led us to\n               this bill and offer my sincere condolences to the family. Full disclosure, I met with the family virtually. That obviously does impact, sometimes,\n               our views of these things. But as a father of 12-year-old daughters who are four years\n               away from dri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe888ed8b4f502f958886f94118ae86841e407022c487162f0f5a92622c68244"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["620a51977f8e36c934b5512ea83814749bc7e90011f1d43ace1b204f836f5005"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44c4f72d83343cd2c87e2004","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317216,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"We desperately need to talk about our society's mental health. For centuries, as we\n               know, a conversation about mental illness was silenced by stigma. Of late, this conversation\n               has been reconstituted so that when we talk about mental illness in this chamber,\n               we're often talking about involuntary treatment, incarceration and public safety. True health comes from preventative care and proper diagnosis. True safety comes when\n               all of us have access to the care we need and deserve — family doctors, specialists\n               and psychologists, not just for those who can afford to pay out of pocket but for\n               all British Columbians. In 2025, this government promised in writing to expand coverage for psychologist visits\n               under our public health system. The agreement, endorsed by the entire government caucus,\n               stated that \"this investment will benefit all British Columbians, including youth\n               and children.\" My question to the Minister of Health. When will this government break through the\n               minor bureaucratic barriers and deliver on this major promise?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317216","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"We desperately need to talk about our society's mental health. For centuries, as we\n               know, a conversation about mental illness was silenced by stigma. Of late, this conversation\n               has been reconstituted so that when we talk about mental illness in this chamber,\n               we're often talking about involuntary treatment, incarceration and public safety. True health co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c019e34d3ba48da6b5b633252a0c966b17fdeffa572248e9d96d25db3264d7c","1f10ec201bb55087783cab490498bce6fad6bb160d0ffb4424037f16253cf6d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["683780aae419e8482f7d5d2c31f5d21d5bcd16a3e8b2a0fef3fceada487c943f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78227bcf16a97bb2735d211c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317217,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"The 2026 Winter Olympics have come to a close, and the Paralympics will open on March\n               6. Today I'd like to celebrate the grit, determination and excellence of our Olympians\n               and Paralympians. West Vancouver–Sea to Sky plays an outsized role in Canada's success. Vancouver and Whistler 2010 facilities\n               are the training ground for many of our athletes. In recent months, we watched athletes\n               who live and train in Whistler represent Canada on the world stage, carrying the strength\n               and support of the local community with them. They inspire us to dream big, train\n               hard, overcome adversity and support our teammates. They inspire me too. After watching the alpine skiing events, my daughters and I went\n               for a few fast groomers, and I dreamed of what might have been for me and what could\n               be for them. They are speed demons, and I've never been so proud. Olympians also inspired me to sign up for the 40th annual legendary Peak to Valley\n               race this Saturday. Over one vertical kilometre of thigh-burning fun. Please wish\n               me luck.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317217","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"The 2026 Winter Olympics have come to a close, and the Paralympics will open on March\n               6. Today I'd like to celebrate the grit, determination and excellence of our Olympians\n               and Paralympians. West Vancouver–Sea to Sky plays an outsized role in Canada's success. Vancouver and Whistler 2010 facilities\n               are the training ground for many of our athletes. In re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56801","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037465","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Veterinary drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037465","label":"Veterinary drugs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56801","label":"Trains","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ddd6f9cd76c800cf2deb867d28407b3751286bc135a4e64a779b96c3f5dfead","fc5422cd84b207797ced2d210bc28a86f67144d35ddb41f0b3b016ec863e7d18"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f546c70cfcc01c44c3a9b262c72e2a94efa4431bb166d75ca4ff4ce2b6057056"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a51d9a7b7e7b095b77fe771f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317219,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my pleasure to speak to Bill 5, which aims to bring into legislation the removal\n               of interprovincial trade barriers by recognizing how other provinces regulate the\n               sale of goods and services. Trade policy remains top of mind for British Columbians, with continued threats from\n               the U.S. to many sectors of our economy. I've heard this in my constituency and from\n               people across this province. The Third Party caucus recognizes the value in reducing\n               unnecessary barriers and making it easier to buy from other provinces and to ensure\n               our products are for sale across the entire country. We should be making it easier to trade with provinces and territories across Canada,\n               and therefore I want to support this bill. I really do. But I have questions and concerns\n               about what the real benefits of this bill are for our economy and the people of B.C. We have to strike a balance between facilitating trade while upholding the high standards\n               and protections that people rely on, and we need to make sure that economic efficiency\n               isn't the reason to sacrifice key safeguards like labour standards or environmental\n               protections. The first issue I want to talk about is that we've been talking about removing trade\n               barriers for over a year now. Last year part 1 of Bill 7, the Tariff Response Act, was passed to great fanfare for the huge economic benefits it would have for our\n               province, and we were told that these were urgently needed changes that were so urgent\n               that the Premier would be forced to call an election if they weren't passed. The problem is that the section of that bill on interprovincial trade barriers was\n               never brought into force by this government. It did functionally become established\n               in December 2025 with the Canadian mutual recognition agreement, but how can we and\n               the public know what benefits or harms of this new bill are since these trade barriers\n               were only finally eliminated two months ago? Is this bill necessary? Has the federal government made this piece of legislation\n               redundant? And why was the original piece of legislation never brought into force?\n               These are all questions that the minister needs to answer to assure this House that\n               this bill is of benefit to all British Columbians and to assure us that he understands\n               the complicated patchwork of legislation governing this federation. I'm glad my Third Party colleague the member for Saanich North and the Islands is here, because he spent a huge amount of effort successfully advocating last year\n               for the sunset clause in the Tariff Response Act, as well as transparency, oversight\n               and accountability provisions to make sure that we could have a real-world assessment\n               of the impacts on removing these barriers for British Columbians. But now this new bill is being proposed, and these provisions are conveniently omitted.\n               We keep hearing about these major benefits of removing internal trade barriers for\n               Canada and B.C.'s GDP, but where is the analysis on what has happened over the last\n               few months since the signing of the Canadian mutual recognition agreement? I believe we need to see some of the early results of this work. I believe we need to see some of the early results of this work. The impact on small\n               businesses that are the backbone of our provincial economy is unclear. Unlike the\n               oil and gas lobby, they don't have the direct ear of senior ministers. So we need\n               a better understanding of who will benefit and who will incur potential new costs. Some exemptions have already been added to this bill from consultation that has happened\n               across sectors, which is a good start to make sure it is responsive. But we don't\n               yet know if there will be ongoing structured consultation mechanisms for further exemptions\n               and who will make these decisions. Seems like many of these questions are still not answered after this government has\n               already had a full year to remove trade barriers. Second issue. The other big concern we have is how much this is really doing. Removing\n               these barriers sounds great on the surface, and I'm sure there will be benefits for\n               some sectors. But we also need to make sure we acknowledge the limits of how much\n               this will help people in this province and make sure that this government isn't giving\n               people in small businesses false hope. The benefits and trade-offs from this legislation need to made clear to British Columbians,\n               yet another reason why a one-year trial would have been so helpful. This is one potentially useful tool, but it isn't a whole toolbox. I think it's important\n               to be clear that this change is not a substitute for the real reforms we need to make\n               to make sure that we have a strong, diversified and climate-aligned economy that works\n               for people all across this province. We've raised some of these issues recently. For example, the B.C. government is currently\n               purchasing nasal naloxone at a higher price from an American company when they could\n               be supporting a B.C. business and saving public money while doing it. This government also continues to directly subsidize the LNG industry that also funds\n               President Trump and his war on trade. If we're truly committed to economic independence,\n               then ending those ties would have a much bigger and more direct impact on our economic\n               security. Moreover, the government continues communicating largely through the very social media\n               platforms that are used to promulgate disinformation and drive the MAGA movement,\n               including X, formerly Twitter, rather than supporting local media. None of these issues will be solved with the removal of internal barriers, so I want\n               to make sure that this bill doesn't take away from the focus on other important issues.\n               Especially now, we have to maintain high standards that support workers and businesses\n               to make sure these are not unintentionally eroded by this legislation. I hope the promised benefits from removing internal barriers come to fruition, but\n               I worry that the focus on internal trade barriers will prove more of a communications\n               exercise than something that delivers real results. To close, I think it's important we keep our eye on the bigger picture of protecting\n               our climate, one; ensuring affordability, two; and three, helping workers in all parts\n               of our province. With those concerns in mind, I look forward to hearing more specifics from the minister\n               on this bill at the committee stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317219","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is my pleasure to speak to Bill 5, which aims to bring into legislation the removal\n               of interprovincial trade barriers by recognizing how other provinces regulate the\n               sale of goods and services. Trade policy remains top of mind for British Columbians, with continued threats from\n               the U.S. to many sectors of our economy. I've heard this in my constituen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016051","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016051","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016051","label":"Experiments","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3071c42287935ad623a9ac645fb41850ea387938f713951362ce1783cc29031c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ccabc2176444e4e7b534da848a48c2d47025f741f2915c678e31a3e750c5b08a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bee526867c435b3adeb5a75e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328063,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"This past weekend Vancouver General Hospital patients more than 20 weeks pregnant\n               were told that within 24 hours the hospital would begin diverting them elsewhere for\n               obstetrical care. A fundamental benchmark measured by the World Health Organization\n               is maternal and infant mortality, and a VGH medical director says diversion can be\n               a matter of life or death for both mothers and children at risk. This crisis is now\n               adding pressure to surrounding hospitals who are already at or above capacity. To the Minister of Health, VGH forecasted this diversion of care 15 months ago. Why\n               wasn't this resolved in that time? Why were vulnerable patients and front-line clinicians\n               given just 24 hours notice? When will this crisis be resolved?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328063","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This past weekend Vancouver General Hospital patients more than 20 weeks pregnant\n               were told that within 24 hours the hospital would begin diverting them elsewhere for\n               obstetrical care. A fundamental benchmark measured by the World Health Organization\n               is maternal and infant mortality, and a VGH medical director says diversion can be\n               a matt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5fb2dd680bc2b7427ac3cf17eb295aa2a86cbe8cf05753a2d8ef4a4b93fa569"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d7a13cd65ebddd35f25b9c28b215b1e3fc0332f7159ac66ecd29ca5afc3e6e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38e17b313b88e61df405e3eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328064,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the Premier and Leader of the Opposition for their words of reflection\n               this morning. I struggle with this feeling of helplessness, making statements on events on the other\n               side of the world, with no jurisdiction, little or no ability to effect positive change.\n               I just want to recognize we're in yet another critical moment for Persians and Iranians\n               especially but also for all British Columbians and people around the world. These\n               moments seem to be arriving fast and furious, with a dizzying rate of change that's\n               creating fear and anxiety that we also see reflected in our provincial politics. The people of Iran have been protesting for their rights and freedoms for years, including\n               the nationwide protests of November 2019 and the \"Women, life, freedom\" uprising in\n               2022. Protests earlier this year culminated in the deadliest period of repression\n               by Iranian authorities in decades, with a death toll somewhere between 3,000 and 32,000.\n               The uncertainty speaks to a total lack of transparency and democratic accountability. The regime led by Ali Khamenei was responsible for sweeping mass arrests, torture and repression. Iranian women\n               in particular have borne the brunt of this regime for 46 years. Accordingly, we celebrate\n               the freedom that Iranians in British Columbia and across the world are feeling today.\n               Yet we know that this is an illegal attack under international law, led by the perceived\n               impunity of the President of the United States. This attack has already resulted in retaliations that have killed, since Saturday,\n               787 people in Iran, 40 people in Lebanon, 11 in Israel, 6 U.S. service members and\n               multiple fatalities in surrounding Middle East countries. Warfare is spreading around\n               the Middle East with further rocket strikes and a new ground incursion between Israel\n               and Hezbollah overnight. Dubai, Bahrain and Kuwait have all been implicated, despite\n               playing no role, as far as we're aware, in the killing of Khamenei. Open warfare serves no one's security, least of all the Iranian people. So we look\n               to our federal leaders in Ottawa to be a voice for peace, to call out our allies who\n               lecture us about peace while tearing up agreements and throwing bombs, to support\n               the people of Iran to form a government of their own making in their own way, to do\n               all that they can to stop the bloodshed that we've seen for too long in this part\n               of the world. And for us in this chamber, to think about how we can conduct our work in a way that\n               builds respect for the rule of law, fundamental human rights and ends the cycle of\n               violence and brings peace. [Farsi was spoken.] Peace be with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328064","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the Premier and Leader of the Opposition for their words of reflection\n               this morning. I struggle with this feeling of helplessness, making statements on events on the other\n               side of the world, with no jurisdiction, little or no ability to effect positive change.\n               I just want to recognize we're in yet another critical moment for Persians and Ir","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036871","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway installations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","label":"Rail transport industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036871","label":"Railway installations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","label":"Railway networks","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04933c476592d412ff08eba8e25cc90f6657ca7e1533b1ad482162ad9ec7b1ba","d8228e3daee9b62184cecfbf95ecfbab86d775b3c4959dbb82186b90ea12a9af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5acc48976c72a2cc940f54011f6d54b1779dd3dc2e14d2f866461a815c9ba3e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-119860d196c9a0298ef440bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328065,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy birthday, Mr. Speaker. I am pleased to welcome Jatinder Sidhu and Paige Calvert from my constituency office\n               who are visiting today. They continue to do impressive work out of our Squamish office\n               and across the riding, and they're not discouraged by tough problems and the occasional\n               grumpy constituent. I also want to repeat the welcome to the Canadian Hydrogen Association delegation.\n               Check out their hydrogen vehicles on the front lawn. A special nod to my friend of 30 years, Ron Klopfer, who is the CEO of Hyfluence,\n               a Burnaby-based company that makes hydrogen fueling systems. Please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328065","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Happy birthday, Mr. Speaker. I am pleased to welcome Jatinder Sidhu and Paige Calvert from my constituency office\n               who are visiting today. They continue to do impressive work out of our Squamish office\n               and across the riding, and they're not discouraged by tough problems and the occasional\n               grumpy constituent. I also want to repeat the welcome to the Canad","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034971","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Educational technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034971","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44932","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034971","label":"Educational technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44932","label":"Information technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43bd2569c168353d3801c24e3465a31681da285752056dfff34a59b875e636b7","7c55645bd19dbf7e020ea825269e94881237eba048b7f54eaad40c9b4495f252"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48c3630955cb39c7763294eabfd48fa918cb4ac4ffaa692c9a8227c1071c5fb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c2d6ba8a8200ee4e6ee70478","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361199,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also was particularly interested in the title of this motion. I was glad to hear\n               the member speak to it. I'll just start out by saying this caucus is quite supportive and believe that working\n               for clean, accessible, affordable water can happily coexist with and benefit items\n               of priority for us, climate action, biodiversity protection and co-governance with\n               First Nations and other local governments. We have a distinct advantage in Canada. All people can and should have access to it. We have a distinct advantage in Canada. All people can and should have access to clean\n               water. It's the foundation of our health and the backbone of our local communities\n               and forests, fish and wildlife. Yet we know that, particularly in rural and First\n               Nations communities, this access is not guaranteed and water sources are regularly\n               contaminated with bacteria, fossil fuels and other pollutants. This is an injustice\n               that has been slow to be rectified, disrespects these communities and endangers reconciliation. There are currently 11 First Nations in B.C. with a water quality advisory notice,\n               21 with a boil-water advisory and 13 with a do-not-consume notice. In 2021, SEMYOME First Nation had a 16-year boil-water advisory lifted after connecting to the nearby\n               Metro Vancouver water supply through the city of Surrey. The community is only a five-minute\n               drive from the city of White Rock. I'm old enough to remember the Walkerton, Ontario, crisis, where there were multiple\n               fatalities. Very serious, and I know it's changed the way we look at water, yet the\n               results and the outcomes have not materialized. With regards to climate, as climate change intensifies, risks to our environment increase\n               and so here in B.C., as has been mentioned. Water scarcity and contamination of water\n               sources threaten access to clean, potable water. Declaring equitable, affordable access to clean water means adopting a new direction,\n               one grounded in the realities of our climate crisis. It doesn't involve sticking our\n               heads in the ground as another fracking well is drilled or we cave to another pipeline\n               proposal. The foundation of our health and water is being seriously impacted by the\n               expansion of fracking and reliance on the LNG industry for economic salvage. Climate\n               action is integral to B.C.'s access to water. On biodiversity and environmental protection, as B.C. faces more frequent and intense\n               wildfires and floods, it only becomes clearer that we need a fundamental shift in\n               how we manage our land, air and, of course, water. We have to prioritize resilience,\n               value ecosystem services — I will note a primary ecosystem service that is generated\n               is clean water — and we have to invest in our communities for the long term. The member for Ladysmith-Oceanside mentioned the watershed security fund, a good first step. I believe it's about $5\n               million a year, which is, I have to say, a paltry sum for something that's so important.\n               We also know that the watershed security strategy has not been released by this government. It presents a real opportunity to rise above some of the recent anti-reconciliation\n               and anti-Indigenous rhetoric and actually work with local communities, including First\n               Nations and municipalities, to ensure the clean water that we're looking for is accessible\n               to all. A lot of this is to do with watershed governance and watershed security tables. The\n               B.C. government can engage with, for example, the Quw'utsun, the Nicola Valley watershed,\n               the Okanagan Basin Water Board, on public input for development of a watershed and\n               a water sustainability plan. B.C. government can work with members across this province\n               to ensure that, whether rural or urban, British Columbians have access to clean water. Very quickly finishing up, what this caucus sees is needed in response to this motion\n               is that equitable access to water will remain an integral component and that no cost-prohibitive\n               barrier should exist for British Columbians who wish to access or obtain clean water.\n               Water rental rates for commercial and industrial users need to rise to a level that\n               demonstrates respect and value for this diminishing resource. The other piece is, of course, 30 by 30, 30 percent land and water protection by 2030,\n               and modernizing our mining and mineral staking regimes to respect Indigenous rights\n               and reduce risk to our watershed and communities. We support this motion and look forward to tangible government actions to achieve\n               it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361199","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I also was particularly interested in the title of this motion. I was glad to hear\n               the member speak to it. I'll just start out by saying this caucus is quite supportive and believe that working\n               for clean, accessible, affordable water can happily coexist with and benefit items\n               of priority for us, climate action, biodiversity protection and co-governance ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e7f79bdc16b5a452ca606e06b3580becc928466ecadde36e4f7691ac7519f12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["547b3d587c12f662d7c4b4179f81ef6c744ddb17b098f7069e0c037c73230944"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-44c6c19f7e9a42dfa4f38c9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361200,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm delighted to introduce to the House today Liza Brechbill. Liza joins the B.C. Green caucus as a policy advisor, where they will focus on health, education and social justice.\n               Liza comes to us from the B.C. First Nations Justice Council, where their expertise in the interaction between people and systems was used to\n               full effect. Liza has experience in addressing barriers to health and justice across\n               Canada and addressing colonial harm within education and political spaces. We are\n               very excited to have Liza join our team and to help us continue being a strong voice\n               for underserved and equity-deserving communities across British Columbia. Would the House please welcome Liza Brechbill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361200","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm delighted to introduce to the House today Liza Brechbill. Liza joins the B.C. Green caucus as a policy advisor, where they will focus on health, education and social justice.\n               Liza comes to us from the B.C. First Nations Justice Council, where their expertise in the interaction between people and systems was used to\n               full effect. Liza has experience in addressing ba","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9301a882bda09cac4f1c4af7372f85389f7ed0cd13d756fd511ced655c9fd3e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1daf6a1c2309a3c608ed797f672171405939803105a1ee64ae7aa694efe0d1a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc46a215c11d64b83e463f7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361201,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Monsieur le president de la chambre, s'il vous plaît, et mes amis, on March 20, the\n               United Nations celebrates French Language Day. I will also be marking French Language\n               Day, and you will have to brace yourselves for my second language, French. [French was spoken.] Le français est une des deux langues officielles du Canada. C'est une langue commune\n               qui unie et rassemble partout à travers notre pays. Avant la ruée vers l'or (la Gold Rush), la langue la plus parlée dans l'ouest du Canada\n               était le Français. Maintenant, plus de trois cent mille résidents de la Colombie-Britannique\n               sont capables de soutenir une conversation en Français. Les communautés avec la plupart de francophones sont toutes situées a West Vancouver\n               – Sea to Sky : Pemberton a dix-neuf pour cent, ses environs a dix-sept pour cent,\n               et  Whistler a seize pour cent. La ville britanno-colombienne de Maillardville (salut a la membre de Coquitlam-Maillardville)\n               honore les traditions franco-canadiennes chaque année avec le Festival du Bois. Les\n               gens mangent la soupe aux pois, la tourtière, et la tarte au sucre, tout en écoutant\n               la musique francaise, traditionnelle et mondiale. Parmi les personnes qui parlent le Français au Canada, plusieurs sont arrivées d'ailleurs\n               dans le monde. Ils proviennent de la France, d'Algérie, du Maroc, du Cameroun, de\n               la Syrie, de l'Haïti, de la Tunisie, de la Côte-d'Ivoire, et de bien d'autres endroits\n               dans le monde. Les cultures de ces nouveaux arrivants contribuent au dynamisme de\n               la francophonie canadienne. (Si vous êtes tannés déjà et vous voulez aller grimper dans les rideaux), je finis\n               en disant que c'est tiguidou de reconnaitre la journée de la langue française, le\n               vingt mars deux mille vingt-six a la langue française, Monsieur le president de la\n               Chambre! Please join me in celebrating the beautiful French language.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361201","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Monsieur le president de la chambre, s'il vous plaît, et mes amis, on March 20, the\n               United Nations celebrates French Language Day. I will also be marking French Language\n               Day, and you will have to brace yourselves for my second language, French. [French was spoken.] Le français est une des deux langues officielles du Canada. C'est une langue commune\n               qui ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Estates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Estates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Estates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Student loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","label":"Estates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037242","label":"Student loans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791167","label":"Fraud","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d902d690c7f61f0f7059f186a1c0adc99c3f7ffb52fac02edab8d01e5270e0aa","86af606651faef441c4450d68b1b61af58a94984fcb327cd8572cd6b1cb01ea1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d7cac4eb596ca8e47dba213498f8d400632b2bfe4f5684c6b98ba400edb56c9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bfa3621964ac4cfbdc94eaa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415840,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"We raised an issue outside this House over the break that drew a strong reaction from\n               the government caucus. It turns out that the minister of AI and New Technologies has\n               personal investments in a targeted AI and technology ETF, or exchange-traded fund. I checked, and the Minister of Health doesn't have a personal stake in health care\n               companies, nor does the Minister of Mining have investments in mining operations. It's a clever diversion for the NDP to focus on the $11 worth of Oracle share that\n               is buried deep in a sub-fund in my retirement savings, but I'm still not the AI minister,\n               and the original question remains unanswered. A conflict of interest can be reasonably....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415840","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We raised an issue outside this House over the break that drew a strong reaction from\n               the government caucus. It turns out that the minister of AI and New Technologies has\n               personal investments in a targeted AI and technology ETF, or exchange-traded fund. I checked, and the Minister of Health doesn't have a personal stake in health care\n               companies, nor doe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0edd528251e0d9895da31ee74696ea534422dd21ddf32570d2c501fd423d113f","a663a427c1f5ceffdf9a3c25f8b2d9d82474692cbb3087802cf5f3a6261256d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eecf9fc73142ffc6b25e67056679a603499fd27641cc2289bcb9f9d8e9af56c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd90dffa0b3a315f8b83549f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415841,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Nice to see you again today, and I'm so proud to be speaking\n               to the right bill at the right time in the right place. It didn't seem to make No\n               Context BC yesterday, but maybe it will now. Dozens of Canadian churches have been burned down since May 2021, with many being\n               confirmed as arson. Mosques have received federal security funds to combat Islamophobia\n               and hate attacks against Muslim women. We have heard sentiments of uneasiness during\n               Ramadan and when entering mosques and attending services. These sentiments have persisted\n               for years and reportedly have grown in recent years. Recent synagogue attacks come after three separate Toronto area synagogues were shot\n               at since March 2. The shootings prompted police in Vancouver and Victoria to send\n               additional patrols to Jewish places of worship and community organizations. The Third Party caucus The Third Party caucus supports the intent of this bill. We do have a few concerns that we expect will\n               be addressed, clarified or potentially amended in committee. There are concerns regarding\n               the broad definition of interference. This definition as currently stated would likely\n               overlap with activity that would be present at many protests. Opponents to the broadness of the definition have stated that \"in other words, any\n               protest outside a place of worship would be illegal, regardless of the actual activity\n               taking place in the facility\" and further stating that this new law would include those who have recently protested,\n               for example, Indian government events at a gurdwara, Israeli realtors talking about\n               investment opportunities in the occupied West Bank at a synagogue, and MAGA concerts\n               at various churches. The B.C. Civil Liberties Association has similar concerns. \"Implementing bubble zones\n               limits peaceful protests and our right to freedom of expression. In a time when having\n               our voice heard is harder than ever, protecting our right to speak out is critical\n               to democracy.\" So, the way we're considering this legislation, the major considerations are the potential\n               of protesting restrictions on secular events that are held at a public place of worship.\n               There is a need to ensure that those attending these events feel safe, and balanced\n               with the public's right to protest at secular events. We'll have some clarification for vague drafting on actions that could lead to arrest\n               including \"impede access,\" \"disrupt activities,\" or \"intimidate or attempt to intimidate,\"\n               as well as conditions that could lead to arrest including concern for a person's physical\n               or mental safety. Clear metrics are needed to evaluate the efficacy and impact of\n               this legislation, including enforcement data, incident prevention, number of institutions\n               using access zones, etc. As I said, we'll support this through second reading and seek clarification and potentially\n               amendments at committee stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415841","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Nice to see you again today, and I'm so proud to be speaking\n               to the right bill at the right time in the right place. It didn't seem to make No\n               Context BC yesterday, but maybe it will now. Dozens of Canadian churches have been burned down since May 2021, with many being\n               confirmed as arson. Mosques have received federal security fu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d847aad64a1470e900519e7fca88745530f300ad5e6265fb1336d381ee680ca1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4e01942e4f0047abd45a693cf66f73b4495dc708d695cef540f2ab93496512e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e9e7a9b8e6120f405dbf30f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415842,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is April Fool's Day, and exactly a year after dismantling the carbon tax to appease\n               Pierre Poilievre, this government's climate policy has turned into a fool's errand. It all started so promisingly, with transformational","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415842","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is April Fool's Day, and exactly a year after dismantling the carbon tax to appease\n               Pierre Poilievre, this government's climate policy has turned into a fool's errand. It all started so promisingly, with transformational","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011992","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biodegradation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011992","label":"Biodegradation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["38d843c72be2d716c39cd0709b9faad080463217beac2aacbe13e7ec79863796"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["599dd495cb4e91ee48abdae47ddf54a62cdc2385bf22ae19effb67d0d43adc9e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68e62306dabdceb80658c4a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415843,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to introduce, and please stand if you're comfortable, Prym Goodacre and\n               Thomas Reimer from the Green team, dream team. Please welcome them, visiting the House today, and give them a round of applause,\n               if you don't mind.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415843","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to introduce, and please stand if you're comfortable, Prym Goodacre and\n               Thomas Reimer from the Green team, dream team. Please welcome them, visiting the House today, and give them a round of applause,\n               if you don't mind.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa823398bc8f9a4e71b08c27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720639,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll just start by saying I don't have any entrenched views. I'm happy to wade into\n               this passionate debate. I don't have any strong views one way or the other. I've only\n               been a union member for brief periods in my career.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720639","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll just start by saying I don't have any entrenched views. I'm happy to wade into\n               this passionate debate. I don't have any strong views one way or the other. I've only\n               been a union member for brief periods in my career.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d044f573f42a0176058e07916e35d76c2a6ea07fc4786d8f9e683f6093fcaa1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd9d4941463744a5300f98a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720651,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Once a quiet forest and rail community, Squamish is now a bustling regional hub, centre\n               for innovation, outdoor recreation, tourism and the new B.C. economy. I'll also mention it's a shining example of reconciliation and action with the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation. Squamish is one of the fastest-growing communities in Canada. After decades of neglect,\n               Squamish was just inching onto the radar of this government, to their credit, to be\n               fair. Unfortunately, they were the first to be dropped when money got tight. Squamish\n               Hilltop House long-term-care facility was slated to be completed in 2030. This government\n               gathered community leaders for a 2024 election campaign announcement, but has now\n               pulled the plug, along with six others, to be facilities with 2030 scratched out and\n               replaced with to be confirmed. My question to the Minister of Infrastructure. Squamish can't wait. The demographic pressures are real and growing by the day.\n               When will the desperately needed new Hilltop House be open for the seniors of the\n               Sea to Sky?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720651","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Once a quiet forest and rail community, Squamish is now a bustling regional hub, centre\n               for innovation, outdoor recreation, tourism and the new B.C. economy. I'll also mention it's a shining example of reconciliation and action with the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation. Squamish is one of the fastest-growing communities in Canada. After decades of neglect,\n               Squamish was just inchin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a480bff47243ab88140946aac9f057536812fec9fe973baa636add217263fbf7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c76461559729c4a5b68c234d63f87f6b48bfe5757c7bd9acb7dab6df9361d05a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33e576273bb794cda27ab095","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720653,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order under Standing Orders 36, 40(3) and 43. I understand there's a tradition of heckling in the people's House. I believe there's\n               a fine line between gentle heckling to indicate disapproval and outright yelling of\n               statements. This place only works if one person has the floor at a time. I don't think\n               the voters would be too impressed. I'm asking, Mr. Speaker, for your assistance in returning some productive dialogue\n               to this place. We are here for six of the next seven weeks. It's only bound to get\n               worse. Thank you, Mr. Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720653","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order under Standing Orders 36, 40(3) and 43. I understand there's a tradition of heckling in the people's House. I believe there's\n               a fine line between gentle heckling to indicate disapproval and outright yelling of\n               statements. This place only works if one person has the floor at a time. I don't think\n               the voters would be too impress","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035319","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Folklore","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035319","label":"Folklore","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2847b69363a7733ecc2466c1c5b6325441aaeb421f6cb896df5e1841c1b99629"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49e994e668505a9e02e5212c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720659,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm so glad to be on topic today and present a different perspective on the fossil\n               fuel debate from my riding. Since Woodfibre LNG was first proposed more than ten years\n               ago, communities in Átl'ka7tsem–Howe Sound have worried that it would be larger, dirtier and more damaging than advertised.\n               Now it looks like Woodfibre has been planning from the beginning for much more than\n               the two-megatonne export it was permitted for, a classic Trojan Horse strategy. Fortis and B.C. Hydro seem to have known for a while, because they're overbuilding\n               pipeline and electrical infrastructure to accommodate greater capacity. Then three\n               weeks ago, federal Energy and Natural Resources Minister lets the cat out of the bag,\n               speaking in Texas, of all places, about a potential doubling or tripling of gas exports.\n               More tankers; more water, air and climate pollution than were ever discussed with\n               those affected. My question to the Minister of Energy and Climate Solutions. How long has this government\n               known about this gas export scope creep?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720659","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm so glad to be on topic today and present a different perspective on the fossil\n               fuel debate from my riding. Since Woodfibre LNG was first proposed more than ten years\n               ago, communities in Átl'ka7tsem–Howe Sound have worried that it would be larger, dirtier and more damaging than advertised.\n               Now it looks like Woodfibre has been planning from the beginn","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","label":"Pollution"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","label":"Pollution","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b3d843814cffdc327dd7f05f56a67eb44ceda30d3c0539f2cde33630957b09b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b62954d2cb2853713db5b912446e9a6782565f7ceecf1f6245e9c36c6a3acb9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee4110c785e7e34960eda5e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720662,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have to say I really enjoyed the energy-themed question period yesterday, so I'm\n               back for more. I'm told I got a thumbs-up from the member for Peace River South, and\n               I particularly appreciate the Minister of Energy and Climate Solutions talking about\n               the unreliability of fossil fuels as a result of global conflicts like the one in\n               Iran, and that we should be doubling down on clean electricity for energy independence. I agree and support, but I didn't get an answer to my question about how long this\n               government has known about Woodfibre LNG's plans to balloon in size. I mentioned B.C.\n               Hydro as supporting evidence, but they're a minor player in this saga. Instead, I\n               got a long answer about the B.C. Hydro community engagement process and a suggestion\n               that I visit the Woodfibre site — which, the minister will know, I did last Friday. So I'll try again. The federal minister spilled the beans three weeks ago. How long\n               has the provincial Minister of Energy known about Woodfibre's plants to double or\n               triple in size?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720662","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have to say I really enjoyed the energy-themed question period yesterday, so I'm\n               back for more. I'm told I got a thumbs-up from the member for Peace River South, and\n               I particularly appreciate the Minister of Energy and Climate Solutions talking about\n               the unreliability of fossil fuels as a result of global conflicts like the one in\n               Iran,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76824","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biomass","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017302","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Bioenergy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017302","label":"Bioenergy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76824","label":"Biomass","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["93e5a10a7bc52da5fc385921a54360e23849844e535befcec37524b856a44880"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e5c561e53a82dc493abde36c7787c0c0291b5ba3b3ba23c098bd86da5560153a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-898ef338fe72e71f64bd628a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721730,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll try and be brief, but I do want to start out by saying that my heart really goes\n               out to the member's constituent who brought this forward and the member who has had\n               to absorb all this and try to chart a path forward. As I usually do when taking an item like this fresh, I went back to our 2024 election\n               platform. As it turns out, not surprisingly, we agree with the sentiments of the bill.\n               People who have been injured in a car crash should be able to access care and support\n               without having to fight the system that's meant to provide it. The current no-fault system doesn't always put the well-being and recovery of those\n               who have been injured in a motor vehicle accident at the forefront. There are many\n               cases in which people cannot access necessary medical care or return to their studies\n               and careers because of existing limitations in ICBC policy. I appreciate the argument between efficiency and comprehensive care. Those who have\n               sustained long-term injuries due to an MVA should feel supported and be treated with\n               respect rather than being handed inadequate compensation or subject to undue administrative\n               burdens and barriers. I would suggest that two limbs over one is an administrative\n               barrier. It's long overdue for the culture of ICBC to be oriented more towards providing\n               adequate care than minimizing payouts. This bill put forward.... I feel very blessed that I get to sit on both these committees.\n               It is what the private members' process was intended to be. There is an unfortunate\n               concurrence of committee work here. But, you know, we each get one shot in this session,\n               and this is what the member chose to bring forward, looking to remedy what's essentially\n               an unjust situation. I respect the arguments on both sides. It's my view that these can proceed concurrently.\n               Actually, I wonder if it might be consecutive given the February I respect the arguments on both sides. It's my view that these can proceed concurrently.\n               Actually, I wonder if it might be consecutive, given the February 2027 deadline for\n               the IVA committee. So the special committee on the Insurance Vehicle Act might choose\n               to recommend the exact same thing, might find something different, might modify the\n               definition of catastrophic injury, but these are still a recommendation that are sometimes\n               acted on and sometimes sit on a shelf and nothing happens with them. I'm concerned that we could potentially undermine this private member's process that\n               we all know has some flaws and needs some fixes. We're just over a year in, and I\n               agree that those need to happen.  But if we say.... Well, I mean, to be totally frank,\n               if we said you can't bring forward anything where there's a process of some kind underway,\n               I don't think.... That would really limit the scope of what private members can bring\n               forward. I will finish off by just saying.... I'll repeat the same pieces. It is an interesting\n               confluence or concurrence of work. I don't love the inefficiency of it. The duplication\n               is annoying. At the same time, I don't know that there's that much confusion or repetition.\n               This is a one-line bill, and the committee will consider vast amounts. If they choose\n               to come to a different conclusion in a bunch of coordination, then that's something\n               we'll deal with in due course. Yeah. I won't repeat the overall kind of philosophy of why we agree with the general\n               intent of the bill, but I will say that I don't agree with knocking it off course\n               because it might be dealt with at some point in the future by a different committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721730","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll try and be brief, but I do want to start out by saying that my heart really goes\n               out to the member's constituent who brought this forward and the member who has had\n               to absorb all this and try to chart a path forward. As I usually do when taking an item like this fresh, I went back to our 2024 election\n               platform. As it turns out, not surprisingly, we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8c687394ae2961b6d9d3c15f10a18dcfdaaf2ef48547f0e2401ca5a09766ef9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5dd845cfe1a8ecf758362e2e7e7dfcd1f3e68d2bbda8c28604974a7c0d309ee2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d03bc6fc61cb580792e4f2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721732,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here I go, changing the subject again. In many communities in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, we have a large number of temporary foreign workers. This will be the last time\n               I use the word \"foreign\" in this because it sounds pejorative to me. These workers\n               help to keep local businesses running and play an active role in local communities\n               in hospitality, agriculture, construction, and food service. We know the importance of this program as well as how much and how badly it needs\n               to be reformed. Closed work permits that tie workers to one employer are frankly inhumane,\n               open to abuse and create real stress for people and families who are looking for a\n               path to permanent residency and citizenship. I know this program is largely federal\n               jurisdiction, but the province also has a duty to look after all workers in the province,\n               even those who are here temporarily. To the Premier, what tangible steps is the province taking to make sure that B.C.\n               is a safe place for people on TFW visas, especially those on closed work permits who\n               remain most vulnerable to exploitation?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721732","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Here I go, changing the subject again. In many communities in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, we have a large number of temporary foreign workers. This will be the last time\n               I use the word \"foreign\" in this because it sounds pejorative to me. These workers\n               help to keep local businesses running and play an active role in local communities\n               in hospitality, agri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32188431c728b0e26037195e85ee41d271b9a6d39506f07306646bfa81bb6838","eec497f45bc4627d513c498dff25c5af94aeb616a1e741897f0e7721e2721906"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5b3df3800406ed6897dd9b418566362bd8d52ffa842ec64fe8a360aad33ca03"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a462f78b4d26fbad7a5f9c66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721736,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"As several members have noted, it's Creative Industries Week, and artists' livelihoods\n               are at risk, along with the livelihoods of workers in many other sectors. We've heard this government advocate for a social media ban for teenagers, but the\n               public has no concept of their plan for artificial intelligence. As long as the government\n               remains focused on the economics and energy requirements of the AI boom and patiently\n               waits for the federal government to regulate the sector, we put at risk that which\n               makes us human: artistic expression and creativity. B.C.'s creative industries need to know what the plan is. So to the minister of AI,\n               he's been in this role for nearly a year. When will he share his service plan so that\n               British Columbians know their government's plan to address AI in B.C.? To the minister of AI, he has been in this role for nearly a year. When will he share\n               his service plan so that British Columbians know their government's plan to address\n               AI in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721736","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As several members have noted, it's Creative Industries Week, and artists' livelihoods\n               are at risk, along with the livelihoods of workers in many other sectors. We've heard this government advocate for a social media ban for teenagers, but the\n               public has no concept of their plan for artificial intelligence. As long as the government\n               remains focused on t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da2a2b9aaba13f38b46968934091f76ed308af31ce011630e70bf7022e1f3796"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d50faa86c6266a4ab1625d5d6c9d1081401ce01a935e2029062479de74dab2d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d516440a287fc88e5d141c79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721737,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I learned recently that the Haíłzaqv Nation teach the following: \"We don't own the land; we borrow it from our children.\"\n               So for parents, grandparents and caregivers in this House, I have a few questions. Do you want to tell your kids about the old-growth forests that once towered over the land, or do you want to walk amongst them with\n               your families? Do you want to point out to where a salmon once ran or watch them swim\n               upstream together? Members, do you want to look at a muddy, collapsing moraine or marvel at the beauty of a glacier cascading down a mountainside? The decisions we make in this House about our natural environment aren't abstract.\n               We're in a unique, privileged position here. Our choices become the stories we and\n               our children pass down. This is our legacy, and it may not be realized within our\n               elected terms or even our lifetimes. Many of us in this House are already having these conversations with our families.\n               I encourage all of us to continue dialogue with the next generation about our planet\n               and, if I can put in a plug on the heels of B.C. Book Day, read books with them about our environment and our future. As we start to see climate change chip away at our natural beauty, we're also living\n               in an increasingly artificial world, one where the only mountains or forests we see\n               are digital As we start to see climate change chip away at our natural beauty, we're also living\n               in an increasingly artificial world, one where the only mountains or forests we see\n               are digital screen savers or wallpaper, where we reach out to AI chatbots in times\n               of crisis. Our old-growth forests, rivers and glaciers, our landscapes, the art we\n               create — these are what inspire us and make us human and what make our home planet\n               beautiful. If we're not careful, what replaces this beauty? Will we outsource birdsong to metallic\n               beaks, replace our fish with artificial imitations to replicate annual salmon runs?\n               This sounds like a science fiction hypothetical, but a lot of what we couldn't imagine\n               even 20 years ago is now coming true. There is risk to our environment and our species\n               when we sacrifice ourselves and our world to convenience and complacency. We risk\n               losing the connection to what is natural, imperfect and alive. These are warnings, and too often the voice of the natural world is drowned out or\n               ignored entirely. On Earth Day, our responsibility in this place couldn't be clearer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721737","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I learned recently that the Haíłzaqv Nation teach the following: \"We don't own the land; we borrow it from our children.\"\n               So for parents, grandparents and caregivers in this House, I have a few questions. Do you want to tell your kids about the old-growth forests that once towered over the land, or do you want to walk amongst them with\n               your families? Do you want to po","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Endangered species","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47314","label":"Endangered species","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","label":"Environment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b324256ea62cdb477b6c45f43d6e39d35880baf77509b2666cd0a2f19135adb3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e28f72c37c0d102c8e394d731911ae5e9e66b925718d605cf5b94ad0d1f7129c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:861","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-205f7a3713e26a051c1fde32","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729518,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll speak very briefly to the amendment, and I hope I will still have the opportunity\n               to speak to the motion. I, too, love Monday mornings because this is the two hours in our schedule that's\n               supposed to be private members' time — not partisan. Yet this is exactly what I feared\n               this motion would bring about, which is a partisan bun fight about which members can\n               count better. I honestly appreciate the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville's creativity in bringing this forward, and I appreciate the member for Kelowna-Mission introducing this piece of art that is meant to elicit a response, but I suggest it's\n               a complete misuse of this private members' time. We've had some difficulty on the private members' bills committee in keeping the partisanship\n               out and focusing on what we are meant to do as private members, which is move forward\n               the public interest of British Columbia. Yet we keep slipping back into this partisanship,\n               and this is a perfect example. So I won't be supporting the main motion, but I unfortunately also can't support the\n               amendment because it just looks to me like, as I said, more partisanship that has\n               no place in these two hours.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729518","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll speak very briefly to the amendment, and I hope I will still have the opportunity\n               to speak to the motion. I, too, love Monday mornings because this is the two hours in our schedule that's\n               supposed to be private members' time — not partisan. Yet this is exactly what I feared\n               this motion would bring about, which is a partisan bun fight about which me","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28dd11071a525e457544d574a6de418fd674a7d5b47995c20e1072991753a6d0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4dd8ba1c835e825e5d8e7dbb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729521,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand to buttress the thoughtful words from the Premier and the Leader of the Official\n               Opposition as we mark one year since this horrible attack. The violence of that tragedy\n               stays with me and all British Columbians, and we hold all the victims in our thoughts\n               and prayers — yesterday, today and tomorrow. I think particularly of the Filipino community, who mourn those that were lost and\n               support people who were injured and hold deep trauma from that day. One year is such\n               a short amount of time, where the wounds of the attack feel so raw. It's also such\n               a long time, where people are so deeply missed and their absence so keenly felt. It's so important that we have places to gather, that we invest money and energy in\n               celebrations that recognize B.C.'s multicultural foundations. We can't let the tragic\n               events of last year's festival lead us toward further isolation. We must resist the\n               temptation to shrink away from each other, stay indoors or layer on armour. The only\n               lasting remedy for the pain and loss of this day is to come together, to lean on each\n               other, to open our hearts, share our cultures and keep making time to celebrate. As members of this House, we all remember together, and we must all take action together.\n               We honour those whom we lost and the resilience and strength thrown by the local community.\n               We must do more too. We must make sure that victims receive full support, that public\n               sector agencies learn from this tragedy, that there is work undertaken to look at\n               how this event occurred and how future ones can be prevented. Remembrance in mourning is the first step toward healing, but it cannot be the last.\n               I ask all members of this House to answer the call and recommit to the serious work\n               of keeping British Columbians safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729521","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I stand to buttress the thoughtful words from the Premier and the Leader of the Official\n               Opposition as we mark one year since this horrible attack. The violence of that tragedy\n               stays with me and all British Columbians, and we hold all the victims in our thoughts\n               and prayers — yesterday, today and tomorrow. I think particularly of the Filipino community,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Water transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","label":"Hazardous waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037590","label":"Water transport industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["413b5052f54fb274f802c3cb4cf145c534c07810a83a15da1b135e822b017e0b","4ad94120a6c498927584440878db159dafb361016fb17a8ca59fb867b2eef159"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7c28cd9d14a3735aedd3a15f54a54fb5875739e163f5ab91c7be8faedab079f9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f676921f09d31191e22cb11d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729533,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729533","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a7b5913434c950c8423fcba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729534,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand up today to shine a light on the urgent need for regional public transit between","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729534","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I stand up today to shine a light on the urgent need for regional public transit between","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18d9175337f846bc9fea92e864136dee2fd70b408a85c6508ae1f9f76f8644e1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee9a96ad3634176b86ef7425","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729535,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the minister and her team. I understand you're 15 hours in, and it's\n               a Thursday afternoon. My understanding is I have 90 minutes, so unfortunately this\n               will go into Monday. Just a request, if we can, to leave a significant amount of time\n               for Monday so that we're not crammed into five minutes. We'll see how it goes. Apologies for being remote. I've been attending the Lower Mainland Local Government\n               Association. I would lament being virtual, except, given where our seats are in the\n               chamber, I think I'm actually, if only virtually, closer in this format. I'll get started. I'll start with youth mental health funding. Actually, I'll just\n               preface this by expressing gratitude for the minister's intervention, I guess, and\n               visit in the winter around the Pemberton Foundry, and then the question is kind of\n               broadly based on that. We've spoken at length about the Mental Health Act needing a fulsome review. In the\n               meantime, the province has appointed a chief scientific officer to issue guidance\n               documents which centre on the Mental Health Act and involuntary care. These measures\n               largely focus on responding to an adult population that experiences concurrent In the meantime, the province has appointed a chief scientific officer to issue guidance\n               documents which centre on the Mental Health Act and involuntary care. These measures\n               largely focus on responding to an adult population that experiences concurrent issues,\n               mental health crises, substance use acquired brain injury and others. This is all\n               taking place while we know that investing in youth mental health can prevent issues\n               down the road, not only for the youth, but families, communities and governments around\n               them. We've identified in particular, as well as the Foundry programs, the Take a Hike Foundation\n               that supports youth in grades 10 through 12 in their academic and social lives, known\n               to provide a port in the storm and also prevent expensive and invasive measures in\n               the future. The minister will recall when we had the Foundry announcement, there was\n               a discussion from an Indigenous participant about this being like a storm, and I really\n               appreciate that analogy. So my question for the minister is: what investment is taking place to ensure that\n               youth mental health programs like Take a Hike are properly resourced and able to provide\n               the support the British Columbia need? Can the minister point to specific items in\n               the 2026 budget?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729535","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the minister and her team. I understand you're 15 hours in, and it's\n               a Thursday afternoon. My understanding is I have 90 minutes, so unfortunately this\n               will go into Monday. Just a request, if we can, to leave a significant amount of time\n               for Monday so that we're not crammed into five minutes. We'll see how it goes. Apologies for being remot","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb7c210c78054841df48320f52da29b47cd2dfda7a84730bdca2fb9d58f16cb5","f71cd0ae6287733f10c5ce9624b98e616da34f007dc589542342455e8992e792"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d51c8a8aba5eaf7d7491c4b1e0aef08fdc9908552f68a165c2311cf66589293"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d39ccc7c34d176be9099b5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752362,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last week I asked about Sea to Sky regional transit, the most important issue in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, and the minister said he agrees with the importance of transit along the Sea to\n               Sky corridor. I can tell you, there are 50,000 residents that are glad he put that\n               on the record. Even in a fiscal bind, this government added public transit funding to this year's\n               budget, showing some leadership, to their credit, and reflecting the importance of\n               this service that returns money to the economy roughly 4 to 1 for every dollar invested.\n               Setting aside the contributions of Squamish and Pemberton, the resort municipality\n               of Whistler alone attracts over 3 million annual visitors, generating $1.5 billion\n               in spending, roughly one quarter of B.C.'s tourism export revenue, $1.4 million per\n               day in tax revenue. The problem is businesses are looking at setting up in Whistler and saying: \"We can't\n               move forward. All our staff would need their own personal vehicles.\" Especially in\n               the hospitality business, this isn't feasible or practical. The minister last week said it's too early to order buses, but after 16 months, he\n               hasn't even instructed B.C. Transit to start planning for this service he recognizes\n               is important. Local governments and First Nations have taken this as far as they can\n               on their own and have made a number of concessions to get this done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752362","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Last week I asked about Sea to Sky regional transit, the most important issue in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, and the minister said he agrees with the importance of transit along the Sea to\n               Sky corridor. I can tell you, there are 50,000 residents that are glad he put that\n               on the record. Even in a fiscal bind, this government added public transit funding to this year's\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"International transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035961","label":"International transport","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05c7f4a293b689ca7cc73eae89da5e2c16bf6eee1592dff6c7fee37ebc8847a9","bbf5fb9df65e8222c55360b98265bce030e46701c70a8f16937728fc3fc90fa2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8be517c6755f74fa4adb00fd4758481d4a14d9c1cdc68c04cde6196b14d8b295"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99fd446af4275bb083303c65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752363,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"With regards to regional public transit in the Sea to Sky corridor, I asked the minister\n               yesterday about directions to B.C. Transit. The minister said: \"In terms of B.C. Transit,\n               we work with them in terms of what they're looking at, in terms of plans for the coming\n               years, much of which is determined at the local level. We've had a number of meetings.\n               The member knows what the issues are.\" The issue is that after a year of meetings\n               to hear from the local level, the ministry came up with an artificial governance obstacle\n               in December to slow this down. But what I really object to is the minister throwing out the vigour of $0.18 a litre\n               of gas tax yesterday. This is irresponsible considering the discussions have been\n               mirroring the Victoria model at $0.5 a litre. The only time $0.18 has been discussed\n               in the context of the TransLink levy and how Sea to Sky motorists are paying the equivalent\n               of that levy because prices are a single market with the Lower Mainland, meaning residents\n               have been paying extra without the transit to show for it for the last ten years.... What was the minister's intention in using an inflammatory high gas tax figure in\n               this time of high gas prices when he replied yesterday?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752363","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"With regards to regional public transit in the Sea to Sky corridor, I asked the minister\n               yesterday about directions to B.C. Transit. The minister said: \"In terms of B.C. Transit,\n               we work with them in terms of what they're looking at, in terms of plans for the coming\n               years, much of which is determined at the local level. We've had a number of meetings.\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2f18fea037569f0975d44d1545aa93a494a8c6132e63e4d64a08e13e5edf337"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5c1b165413b80f5c36cfdad7e418c42559a5fc5f830bd746a95960eea1f1cb96"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c79de39f4940904c6951cac4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752364,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am deeply gratified and very excited to be here to speak to the motion to delay\n               Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I'd like to start by saying that I, of course, fully support all the comments made\n               by my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who is an expert in this area of legislation. You may find at some point that these\n               words sound familiar because I defer to him on all matters FOI, given his stature\n               as the grandfather of freedom of information in this province. I'd also like to thank my colleague, the member for Surrey–White Rock, for bringing this motion forward. It's very clear to me, crystal clear to me, that\n               this piece of legislation is simply not ready. Not ready for prime time. Not ready\n               to be passed into legislation. The government needs to take the summer to do the work to get this bill right. Instead,\n               what we have is the government rushing this piece of legislation through. After all,\n               that's why I'm standing here at 8:34 p.m. rather than enjoying the B.C. Ale Trail,\n               which is, I think, where we'd all rather be. This motion is necessary because of exactly the kinds of moves that the government\n               has pulled tonight. When this government has an opportunity for collaboration, for\n               reconsideration, for hearing and responding to the valid concerns that members of\n               this House have raised, they insist that they know better, that critique is a challenge,\n               that dissent is unacceptable. This is not a government that can be trusted with weaker freedom-of-information laws.\n               This is a government that is widely said to be the least transparent in Canada, and\n               they are currently showing that with their actions again and again. So I want to speak to why it's necessary that this bill be stood down for six months\n               and amended. Freedom of information is the cornerstone of our democracy. People must have access to information. They must understand why decisions are being\n               made on what information and at whose request. As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.\n               When people can access information, they are more likely to believe that government\n               is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that\n               empowers As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.\n               When people can access information, they're more likely to believe that government\n               is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that\n               empowers journalists, researchers and citizens to have direct oversight of government.\n               This keeps decision-making connected to the people it affects, and that is why we\n               must delay this bill for six months. People cannot meaningfully participate in public debate if they don't have access\n               to the facts, and when access is restricted, reduced or delayed, suspicion grows.\n               Even good decisions can be questioned if they're made without transparency. Strong access-to-information laws set expectations inside government as well, encouraging\n               better recordkeeping, clearer reasoning and more careful decision-making. These are the questions that the government can use six months to answer: how this\n               bill is not an attempt to evade necessary scrutiny, how this bill isn't simply making\n               it harder for citizens to access more information and giving more discretion to centralized\n               decision-makers to determine who gets what and when. The concerns that my colleagues from across this side of the House have raised are\n               real. The questions we are asking are legitimate. If we can't get answers from where\n               we stand here, how on earth are we supposed to believe that they will tell the public\n               anything that they don't want to hear? I would like the government to spend six months thinking about what \"reasonable\" means,\n               how they define it now and how they intend to define it when they're back on this\n               side of the House. We haven't had any certainty or scrutiny.... Because that is what\n               this is about. We trade sides, except for the Third Party. We always stay on this\n               side. How would we want to be treated when we're on this side of the House? I think\n               we should all apply that test. We haven't had any certainty or security about how the government intends to define\n               \"reasonable.\" I stand here unclear on what a reasonable amount of time is, other than\n               whenever the scrutiny they're trying to avoid has passed. Perhaps when the media has\n               moved on to the next scandal? I stand here unclear on how a public body can determine\n               when to refuse to disclose information about a proposed program — again, a level of\n               certainty that I should be able to have. The government has not done the work on this, and they need six months more to do\n               it. There should not be members of this House who are legitimately concerned about\n               their access to detail on programs and government spending. Freedom of information is not just the access to the information itself. It's the\n               wider regime in which it sits. It's about the level of trust that members of the public,\n               business, civil society, academics can have in the institutions governing them. It's very clear that this regime is under threat because of this bill and because\n               of the way in which it has been introduced and debated without the work being done,\n               without sufficient consultation, without rigorous analysis, without the ability for\n               the concerns of people from across this province to be assuaged — work that requires\n               six more months. Government information does not belong to the government; it belongs to all of us,\n               and the government owes the people of British Columbia the responsibility to do this\n               work carefully, with precision, with care for not only the change that they're making\n               but the precedent that they're creating. A six-month delay gives the government that opportunity. If this legislative change\n               is necessary, the government must prove it. Bring us along with you. Bring us along\n               so we don't have to sit through the night objecting to this bill, proposing amendments. If the government can be trusted to make decisions in the best interests of British\n               Columbians, then you'll hear the people of British Columbia when they say, \"stop,\"\n               when they ask you to pause, when they tell you that what you're doing is dangerous\n               and that you haven't brought them along with you. Access-to-information systems exist precisely because governments are not infallible.\n               History has repeatedly shown that secrecy can conceal waste, corruption, abuse of\n               power and poor decision-making. As the saying goes: \"Act in haste; repent in leisure.\"\n               This is not something that should be rushed through. I hear that government officials have been surprised by the backlash to this bill,\n               that they thought it would pass with minimal fuss, that it was an administrative change.\n               The fact that they are surprised shows the danger of this bill and details exactly\n               why this pause is so desperately needed. The government has once again proven that\n               they're out of touch with the reality on the ground in British Columbia, that they're\n               not listening to anyone outside of their bubble. This motion gives them the opportunity to fix that, to speak to people who haven't\n               been consulted on this information, to look at other jurisdictions and how they manage\n               freedom-of-information requests in the age of mass information. I suspect they'll\n               be surprised by what they find, because I suspect the answer is proactive release,\n               not limiting the grounds, the time frames or the discretion. Once again, I repeat that the work here has simply not been done. Once again, I echo\n               my colleague, who was critical in the development of this piece of legislation when\n               it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation. Once again, I echo my colleague who was critical in the development of this piece\n               of legislation when it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation.\n               In his speech to this bill at second reading, he spoke to the work that was done in\n               the development of the bill — the consultation, the amendments, the gaining consensus\n               from across the province. In his speech on this motion yesterday, he said by way of comparison that in 1992\n               when the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act was introduced in this\n               Legislature, a discussion paper was released publicly. There was feedback sought from\n               all interested parties, including journalists, including future users of the act,\n               including organizations, including businesses — essentially any British Columbian\n               and any British Columbia organization or business that had any interest in legislation,\n               either because it intended to use the legislation or because it wanted to ensure the\n               legislation was robust. By way of comparison, that hasn't been done in six months. Hoist is needed to do it.\n               I note that after that feedback was provided on the discussion paper, there was actually\n               a televised debate regarding the legislation. Imagine a televised debate on a piece of legislation like this, involving the minister\n               and others. The submissions made during that period of time were made public. This\n               all resulted in amendments to the legislation, which is a far different process than\n               the process that's been undertaken for this bill. It gives a clear indication of the\n               type of work that could be conducted over the next six months if this motion is adopted.\n               None of this work has been done. These legislative changes are difficult. They speak to some of the biggest powers\n               that government has and can most easily misuse. Restricting this access in haste is\n               a mistake, one that we don't have to make. We're fortunate there are experts and stakeholders\n               who stand by to advise the government on what the path forward is here. We should be looking to the 2022 report as a whole from the Special Committee to Review\n               the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act for changes. We should remember\n               that six months is not a long amount of time. If the government can come back with\n               proof that these changes are necessary, then we look forward to receiving that information.\n               We look forward to the discussions that could be had, the discussion papers that could\n               be disseminated, the experts in democracy and informed electorates that could provide\n               us with information, televised debates on this piece of legislation that could occur. The only way for freedom of information to be protected in this province, which is\n               fundamental to our democracy, is by hoisting this motion. The hoist of this motion\n               is required because the changes to freedom of information introduced in Bill 9 will\n               fundamentally change freedom of information to freedom from information. I am speaking in support of the motion, and for every point I make for the balance\n               of the time I have, I will link every line to why it relates to the motion because\n               I definitely do not want to lose my opportunity to speak at this important juncture.\n               I have 19 minutes to.... I have a lot of minutes left. There are parts of this bill, to be frank, to be fair, that solve some real issues\n               that this caucus doesn't have a problem with. I'm supporting the hoist motion because\n               there are other parts of the legislation that are very problematic. There are clauses,\n               and they did not influence my decision, like clause 22, that allow people to access\n               their own information more easily, and that's important. That's the problem and another reason why I support this hoist motion, because there\n               is no amount of amendments that will save this legislation and protect freedom of\n               information. It's unfortunate that in this legislation there are some provisions that\n               protect or support personal information access, but on the balance, I am supporting\n               and speaking in favour of this hoist motion because the changes that are problematic\n               far outweigh the changes that are supportable. I want to note that clauses that expand the ability of government to delay, deny or\n               limit access to information are not changes that improve freedom of information. For\n               that reason, this act needs to be hoisted for six months. My colleague covered some\n               of this in his second reading speech. That was in a different context. That was in\n               opening debate of this legislation. This is about the six-month hoist. I think it's important for the public of British Columbia and everybody who follows\n               the deliberations of this House to understand why I support the hoisting of this bill,\n               which is a very major step that none of us on this side of the House are taking lightly,\n               especially when it comes to the middle of the night when we're standing here talking\n               about a hoist motion. It's a big decision. It's important to provide an overview of\n               the specific clauses that we see as problematic in the legislation, as the government\n               is now proposing to amend some of these clauses. There's clause 1. It removes from FOI records the records that fall within a general\n               class of records that is listed or identified as part of a proceeding. That section\n               stands as it is, and it creates a whole new class exemption for general records in\n               relation to the items mentioned in clause 1. Clause 2 proposed amendments that would remove, in the opinion of the head of the\n               public body....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752364","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am deeply gratified and very excited to be here to speak to the motion to delay\n               Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I'd like to start by saying that I, of course, fully support all the comments made\n               by my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who is an expert in this area of legislation. You may find a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f3b8fef66db8e3a8c0a89942190b4d66e49fec01f6a575ab0dc23d3b0ecfca5c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c32c55ed459433e8074471977bbf809ddf59c44042243469352a9c99767d128c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5975dea160a63b229b61d724","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752365,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Sorry to be slow. I attended two memorials in Whistler the weekend before last for very different people, but both impressively well-attended by hundreds of people. I wanted to mark these two very important people in the community,\n               in the Sea to Sky community. Nigel Woods lived to the age of 74 and he was a pillar of the Whistler community, first visited\n               when he was a UVic student, founded coastal mountain excavations that shaped modern Whistler. It was Whistler's oldest operating company. From a chairlift, he spotted an island in Alpha Lake that he bought in 1974 — for some unknown, but it had previously changed hands for $50. He built a home there, affectionately called Woods Island. He was known in his family for his ZFL — zest for life. His daughter Carly said: \"I've had friends only decide on their life partner because that person had the ZFL.\" She said of Nigel: \"You could be lined up in the\n               village, 200 people deep with little kids that are crying and it's pouring down rain,\n               and Nigel would be like, 'It was the best day ever.'\" There was always a silver lining. It was said that if you rode a chairlift with him, he became your friend. And I have....\n               Several people told me examples of that. His son Matt said he lived 100 lives in one, and he'll be missed by his family and by the community. Nigel was 74, which is still too early, but the hardest one for me was in the Whistler Conference Centre for 23-year-old Kai Smart, who is a rare breed. He was born and raised in Whistler, the son of two Olympians, John and Julia, who were founders of momentum ski camps. Kai was first overall in B.C. as a competitive skier, and Kai and his brother Luke cut their teeth on the ski ramp their family had in the back of their house. Kai was a film-maker focused on skiing but also on social and climate issues. Kai passed away from doing what he loved. He died from injuries he sustained in an\n               avalanche while filming for a ski and climate film in Japan. He'll be sorely missed by his parents, John and Julia, and his brother Luke. And I thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity I thank you for the opportunity.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752365","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Sorry to be slow. I attended two memorials in Whistler the weekend before last for very different people, but both impressively well-attended by hundreds of people. I wanted to mark these two very important people in the community,\n               in the Sea to Sky community. Nigel Woods lived to the age of 74 and he was a pillar of the Whistler community, first visited\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","label":"Avalanches"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","label":"Avalanches","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db2fb49589101a5c5ffb733ec9d39fdd100246143d1b9d8f229b4d4e99619ac6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["218a8aa59362771bf06efa08bb6428216b968af34ab3886518c123eaf686187c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca86819e5ed590ccacfa3dc2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017679,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to ask about Joffre Lakes Provincial Park, also known as Piipiuk in the Ucwalmícwts\n               language. It's a very important place in my riding for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous\n               people, a place of cultural significance, recreation, tourism and connection to the\n               land. In 2018, the province established a visitor management plan and collaborative working\n               group with the Líl̓wat and the N'Quatqua Nations to help guide decisions about the\n               park. These recognized the importance of closing the park for periods over the summer\n               months for the nations to reconnect with the land and allow the park to recover from\n               the effects of overtourism, which in prior years climbed to around 200,000 visitors.\n               In each of the last two years, the park has been closed for about 60 days for cultural\n               practices and healing. Two weeks ago, the ministry dictated by press release the 31 days it decided on for\n               the summer, different from what the nations requested, without any apparent consultation\n               with the working group. In this climate, even 31 days of closure...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017679","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to ask about Joffre Lakes Provincial Park, also known as Piipiuk in the Ucwalmícwts\n               language. It's a very important place in my riding for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous\n               people, a place of cultural significance, recreation, tourism and connection to the\n               land. In 2018, the province established a visitor management plan and collaborative workin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Lakes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168629","label":"Lakes","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["acfe5abd288cc79a7621b65f73478cbfad8f92884146e47840688c63c3851054","cc2ff4e517b1a1ebf5aabf6c6e5dab0f57522e8734f5b5fb3ef625859c6fd2e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46ec7f4c7a390691238d457b7795077f0345a810e02bc012c122a7c0cdd2e677"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41948bfe30381b66064932f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017684,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a privilege to speak today to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I will be brief, and I will be echoing my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, and many others in expressing the importance of treaties and the treaty-making process.\n               As a province that has established and continues to establish itself in the absence\n               of negotiated processes with First Nations, treaties represent an avenue to right\n               that wrong. I wish to convey my congratulations to the K'ómoks Nation on their arrival to this stage of the process, an incredibly delicate endeavour\n               that has spanned 30 years and undoubtedly many many meetings, collaborations, agreements,\n               disagreements and resolutions. We do not take it lightly that this treaty legislation\n               is in front of the House and we honour the legacy of labour that has brought it here. We've also heard many perspectives in this House on this specific piece of legislation.\n               It's clear that the environment and moment in time in which this bill has been introduced\n               has been, and is, complex. As we all know, and it's been named multiple times during this process, there are\n               significant concerns in regard to this treaty act. These include concerns of overlap,\n               of economic development considerations and of non-derogation. These concerns and those\n               voicing them — and we would like to thank the Chiefs and leaders of the Wei Wai Kum\n               again for sharing their time and insight with us — have reminded us of the incredible\n               care, time and work that is required when passing treaty legislation through this\n               House. It is also critical for many of us to remember that Indigenous Peoples in British\n               Columbia have developed and practised intercommunity negotiation and protocols for\n               far longer than the rest of us have even been here. Many of these practices were intentionally\n               disrupted, banned and even outlawed through colonial interference and legal orders. It is important to remember this because we are placed in a very specific situation\n               in responding to this legislation as Members of the Legislative Assembly. As elected\n               officials, we're not here to determine the quality or validity of the claims for or\n               against this treaty nor are we here to control what treaty is or isn't supposed to\n               be. We're here to do our part in ensuring that the self-determination of all First\n               Nations in B.C. is, at the very least, not impeded by the laws created and passed\n               in this House. Keeping this responsibility in mind, the comments in the House on this act have been\n               announcements and assertions, not dialogue. The second reading vote we have directly\n               in front of us is not whether this treaty passes through the Legislature but whether\n               we are willing to have a further conversation about it. We want to We want to be sure that the concerns are brought forward for the record and that this\n               legislation will, without a doubt, not impede the self-determination of any nation\n               impacted by its ratification. I believe we owe it to the decades of work, negotiation,\n               relationship-building and community effort that has gone into this treaty process\n               to take our time at this stage. It is in the spirit of the democratic process that the Third Party supports this act\n               to move into the committee stage. We will be looking to the government to answer,\n               in detail, the hard questions that have been raised. It's an opportunity to continue\n               the conversation, move this bill to committee and ensure the concerns raised by nations\n               regarding overlap in territory are fully responded to by government on the public\n               record. There are clearly misunderstandings, fears and competing interpretations circulating\n               publicly right now. Government has an opportunity at committee to provide clear, factual\n               responses and help build confidence in this treaty and in the treaty process more\n               broadly, at this important moment in our province, by approaching it constructively\n               and bringing in the appropriate experts to support them in providing those informed\n               responses to what has been raised.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017684","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's a privilege to speak today to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I will be brief, and I will be echoing my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, and many others in expressing the importance of treaties and the treaty-making process.\n               As a province that has established and continues to establish itself in the absence\n               of negotiated processes with Fi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01754215d9378e2e4c3732a02351c845805f5e461beba2fc49bca66fb5612e51"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["191cd92470f434e08a01b2ff6f9ee1de461d510082988e10ed2bbf908f8f6f15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2100bf54854de7c2b15a1ded","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017688,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have been listening carefully, and I feel like this is a true debate. I've been\n               a little disappointed, coming from a municipal council background, that sometimes\n               what passes for debate in this House is sort of entrenched monologues, so I'm happy\n               to listen to this. I want to thank my colleagues for the time and effort they've put into this dialogue.\n               Treaties are incredibly important, and it is critical we take our time to ensure we're\n               honouring the time and relationship and labour that's informed them. I'm going to put together a slightly different view here, and I'm going to be a little\n               pedantic with my colleague. I don't think this is a hoist motion. We had a lot of\n               discussion about whether a six-month delay was effectively killing the bill or not.\n               I'm open to further comment on this, but it seems to me that referring to a committee\n               that hasn't met in decades either could easily or is intended to stop this in its\n               tracks. In any case, I'll explain why we are currently opposed to this dilatory motion. The Third Party, the B.C. Greens, support the self-determination of First Nations\n               in all the forms that may take, including treaty-making. We're all here to do our\n               part in ensuring self-determination of all First Nations is supported by the legislation\n               passed in this chamber. It's been made crystal clear there are long-standing issues with the treaty process,\n               including the Crown's interference in Indigenous relations, governance and legal orders.\n               We also know that negotiation tables have not yet been successful in avoiding the\n               need for First Nations to seek justice or redress through the judicial branch. As we see through this conversation — and more to come, I'm sure — and throughout\n               this entire session, there are not sufficient venues for the cross-partisan consideration\n               of Indigenous affairs issues needed to find consensus. I would say, perhaps subjectively,\n               that political opportunism has further degraded this conversation. The B.C. Greens have been calling for the re-establishment of the Standing Committee\n               on Aboriginal Affairs as a space where this House can come together, with support\n               from First Nations and legal experts, to move past partisanship and actually make\n               progress on these critical issues. In April, the B.C. Greens invited the government to consider this proposal, which\n               included the following three things — and I will get to the motion in just one second,\n               if you bear with me: reviewing progress on the agreed approach, with regular updates\n               to the Legislature and the public — pretty key, in keeping the public informed; reviewing\n               funding for the B.C. Treaty Commission, the Declaration Act secretariat and other\n               treaty and reconciliation initiatives, which involves treating this work as a major\n               project; and reviewing and making recommendations on additional ways to advance reconciliation,\n               such as establishing an independent reconciliation commissioner, selected by the all-party\n               committee together with First Nations. For all these reasons, we appreciate the effort being made to create space for these\n               more nuanced and non-partisan conversations. It's an important goal, and I thank the\n               opposition for bringing it forward. We also believe it's important to recognize the larger context in which this House\n               sits and that the substance of this act is not, nor should it be, created and stewarded\n               solely through legislative processes. To clarify this, the development of treaties is an incredibly complex process. It\n               spans generations, requires skill in Crown litigation, Indigenous legal orders, relationship-building,\n               historical and cultural knowledge, humility, critical thinking and grace. This is not to say that the process is without flaws. It's clear that it has many.\n               But it's important to remember that the document in front of us is not the K'ómoks treaty but the K'ómoks Treaty Act. This is a critical distinction. It is fundamentally for First Nations\n               themselves — with the support of the Crown, when requested — to determine what are\n               and aren't their own historical boundaries. The process through which the government participates in treaty-making is made possible\n               through the B.C. Treaty Commission, an organization that draws on the skills I just\n               named. If British Columbia is involved, this is where litigation specifics of a treaty\n               are meant to be unpacked and negotiated, not in the Legislative Assembly. Speaking to the motion, the Aboriginal Affairs Committee should be a place for provincewide\n               consideration of reconciliation and how to all move forward together. It should not\n               be where the details of a treaty, which has been discussed and contributed to by generations\n               of people.... This should not be a place where these are dissected and determined. With all that said, questions about the process remain. As the Third Party shared\n               in our statement yesterday, our role is to ensure that laws passed in this House,\n               at the very least, do not impede or disrupt With all that said, questions about the process remain, and as the Third Party shared\n               in our statement yesterday, our role is to ensure that laws passed in this House at\n               the very least do not impede or disrupt the self-determination of any First Nation. For that reason, the Third Party's caucus is not inclined to support the motion proposed.\n               We recognize the intention and appreciate the attempt to give space for issues to\n               be resolved, but we don't believe a pause of this form is appropriate or will be effective. In acknowledging this, this caucus believes that for this specific piece of legislation,\n               the committee stage of the legislative process is the appropriate venue in which to\n               voice concerns about the impacts of the legislation — an important point; that's impacts\n               of the legislation — that have been raised. I thank you for the time, Mr. Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017688","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have been listening carefully, and I feel like this is a true debate. I've been\n               a little disappointed, coming from a municipal council background, that sometimes\n               what passes for debate in this House is sort of entrenched monologues, so I'm happy\n               to listen to this. I want to thank my colleagues for the time and effort they've put into this dialogue.\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d7394ef2e83aed68df16ba16b401ae4dd0682ea7caf205977a58221aebcf54c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b66cf939f6ead47b2df55e789691b5d5b4307eed7d2f7291f8e3800c79154aa8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff184b28fe65c28ef17c8c76","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017697,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"The B.C. Greens have long called to disband the RCMP's critical response unit, or\n               CRU. It's timely, with former MLA Adam Olsen in the House. CRU has faced hundreds of complaints and multiple court cases for systemic charter\n               violations, but these government enforcers seem to be getting more powerful. A B.C.\n               RCMP media relations officer said that CRU \"does not monitor treaty negotiations but\n               that it is briefed during secretariat meetings by other ministries that are directly\n               involved in those discussions.\" To the Minister of Public Safety: what information about treaty negotiations are government\n               ministries providing to the critical response unit and for what purpose?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017697","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The B.C. Greens have long called to disband the RCMP's critical response unit, or\n               CRU. It's timely, with former MLA Adam Olsen in the House. CRU has faced hundreds of complaints and multiple court cases for systemic charter\n               violations, but these government enforcers seem to be getting more powerful. A B.C.\n               RCMP media relations officer said that CRU \"doe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035182","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Exchange programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035182","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Exchange programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035182","label":"Exchange programs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bfeade233bbd5b5a6a1abda1ab6f9867e2a2d35f02b7ad919cac91c5820471c3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-345f5a7361d9ff4ad46339e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036597,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here's a sampling of pleas we're hearing from British Columbians with disabilities,\n               for the record. \"In B.C., being disabled and unable to work is punishable by neglect\n               and deep poverty which can lead to death,\" and \"We are beyond desperate.\" Disability assistance rates in British Columbia are still $1,000 per month below the\n               poverty line and under CARGA, the 2025 cooperation agreement, this government committed\n               to review these rates and make recommendations for future increases. A year into that agreement, that review hadn't even begun. If it's okay with the minister,\n               please, can we skip the part about how it's our fault because we walked away from\n               CARGA? Making progress on basic dignity for persons with disabilities should never\n               have hinged on having two Green members constantly asking when. It's reasonable to expect that work to have continued, so to the Minister of Social\n               Development and Is this government unable or unwilling to raise rates without constant pressure from\n               two members of this Third Party?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036597","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Here's a sampling of pleas we're hearing from British Columbians with disabilities,\n               for the record. \"In B.C., being disabled and unable to work is punishable by neglect\n               and deep poverty which can lead to death,\" and \"We are beyond desperate.\" Disability assistance rates in British Columbia are still $1,000 per month below the\n               poverty line and under CARG","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036842","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Quarantine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hearing disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Textile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037349","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Textiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","label":"Coronavirus diseases","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","label":"Hearing disabilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036842","label":"Quarantine","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037344","label":"Textile industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037349","label":"Textiles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","label":"Beverages","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","label":"Clothing industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e15e419c468590f2e611dc19155f366f106af6143ead6183c144b7c500852fec","cd5b35bd5a372eb66c5f83fe89837f22b862badd3adbb3c5331ebbdf912b24a8","9a4efa94c4e20a732817fd9395851e09d43a919814a0b1152c7f475a85094018","d3c730cdfa6baf4908b8ac5727b664731b5a1aa40d67774afb4c49d497d38deb","8ab4814694ffe8204397203a0c01a7f05693f9eab5cb0c9948afaa63b6e6f5ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e51e6dfbd68a64c2e06abea334af33aad19f4707d3362a83ee40670e2ba71c8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-784c6f414caf2ee053d5c03b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036599,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"I haven't had any constituents in the House for a little while, so I'm very pleased\n               to have two today. The first is Greig Walsh, a close friend and ski buddy. He's one of the founders of\n               Greenlight Innovation, a leading hydrogen equipment supplier. Greenlight has sold half-a-billion dollars in their history into global markets, and\n               that represents clean tech jobs and revenue into B.C. It's my hope that inBC will\n               adopt some of this technology. The second is Ruth Simons. Ruth is the powerhouse behind the Howe Sound Biosphere\n               Region Initiative, president and executive director since 2017, previously a Lions\n               Bay council member and recipient from the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation of a blanketing ceremony and an honorary degree from Capilano University. Most importantly, Ruth has convened the House Sound Community Forum for over a decade,\n               which is the most valuable place for me to find out what's going on in the Howe Sound\n               biosphere and watershed and a great service to all our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036599","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I haven't had any constituents in the House for a little while, so I'm very pleased\n               to have two today. The first is Greig Walsh, a close friend and ski buddy. He's one of the founders of\n               Greenlight Innovation, a leading hydrogen equipment supplier. Greenlight has sold half-a-billion dollars in their history into global markets, and\n               that represents clean","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["821ac9005ed75202924f4f690e6d4c2c2e7cce827ef888598f99b91e95a4e54e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f37980d37127d685cb2c0fa196bc72f137a3f5bf57936258febfe8f0f93ffe94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5de195e37a0a3ca511b62a04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036600,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've talked a lot about economic sovereignty and data sovereignty in this House.\n               Our food sovereignty is clearly also under threat. In response to President Trump, the government has proudly promoted the Buy B.C. label,\n               but it looks like that moniker also applies literally to B.C. farmland, with billionaires\n               buying up ALR land as investments. Near Merritt, an heir to the Walmart fortune now controls 1.2 million acres of farmland\n               and is blocking the public from accessing public land. In my riding, in Pemberton\n               Meadows, luxury real estate is booming as farmland is sold off for multi-million-dollar\n               mansions, equestrian facilities and even landing pads for private helicopters. Farming\n               operations are priced out or faced with unstable leases. In Dunster, an American billionaire\n               who profits from ICE detention centres is buying up ranchland for a game hunter's playground. To the Minister of Agriculture and Food, arable land is the foundation of thriving\n               communities, and its ownership needs oversight. What is this government doing to stop\n               the ultra-wealthy from treating B.C. farmland as nothing more than a safe financial\n               asset?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036600","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We've talked a lot about economic sovereignty and data sovereignty in this House.\n               Our food sovereignty is clearly also under threat. In response to President Trump, the government has proudly promoted the Buy B.C. label,\n               but it looks like that moniker also applies literally to B.C. farmland, with billionaires\n               buying up ALR land as investments. Near Merr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034607","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Technical services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034607","label":"Technical services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034950","label":"Economic research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d4062e48da19fb971e7ec94b9eb793d9b7e2f41cad659efba0423308c1939c4f","e5b24a934d153b3a0e0e8154e5648afa9cdd6432333c36eab5ee8ef300dc980f","af62b5c7782e358cb1a1e44760fc86f9241eba16f28433c893f9033bd2ef9c6c","145ded1bf5f31d481b816508bc57fb70595d83073f7c62061f41aaa21f1e62e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f337810304bebc9d86f9013575ddc2b4cf03b1808edd0c96621e1a0d25e0a1b6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-181e2f6fd21cd055a7d5b78c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036601,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jeremy Valeriote","venue":"Hansard","text":"She's been introduced to this House before, but would the House please give a warm\n               welcome in the gallery to our B.C. Green Party Leader, Emily Lowan?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036601","member_id":"bc-mla-355","member_name":"Jeremy Valeriote","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"She's been introduced to this House before, but would the House please give a warm\n               welcome in the gallery to our B.C. Green Party Leader, Emily Lowan?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31a86cb9cc6e47347f198bcdb962f632f1d14ff3fe563e6348307c00fa8d67b3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91bfde1de8406c3f74aee35c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317136,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is always a joy when we have members from our community visiting. Miriam Bozman wears many hats, but she is the executive director of the chamber of commerce in our\n               community, serving our business community very well. Would the House just welcome her again? Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317136","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is always a joy when we have members from our community visiting. Miriam Bozman wears many hats, but she is the executive director of the chamber of commerce in our\n               community, serving our business community very well. Would the House just welcome her again? Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["20c33eacff4dad6352a585e00b16647cbc284c982deffc5352a195f12c60efb3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d037b3b4c53d81ec8bed733","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327970,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"British Columbia has built a global reputation as a destination for world-class education.\n               Students travel from every corner of the world to study here, to build futures, to\n               support families back home, to contribute to our communities and to invest in the\n               promise of Canada. International education is not a small program. It is a multi-billion\n               dollar sector. It supports jobs, it strengthens communities, it enriches classrooms,\n               it connects British Columbia to the world. But let us be equally clear. Where there is growth, there must also be accountability.\n               Where there are vulnerable students navigating a foreign system, there must be protection.\n               And where government proposes new regulatory powers, there must be an inspection.\n               Bill 7, the Post-Secondary International Education (Designated Institutions) Act,\n               replaces the previous education quality assurance framework work with a designation\n               system. The government's stated purpose is to protect international students and safeguard\n               British Columbia's reputation. That is the goal we support. We support credible oversight.\n               We support removing bad actors. We support transparency. We support protecting international\n               students from exploitation. But we must examine whether this bill strikes the right\n               balance. Because while protection is essential, so too is fairness. While oversight\n               is necessary, so too is due process. And while reputation matters, so too does regulatory\n               restraint. Under the previous system, operated as an administrative framework, this bill removes\n               that framework into a statute. This change is not insignificant. When government shifts\n               from policy guidance to legislative enforcement powers, it is not merely procedural,\n               it is structural. Bill 7 creates a mandatory designation certificate system. Under clause 2, institutions\n               must not advise, offer, contract with, enrol or deliver programs to international\n               students without a valid designation certificate. This is a significant tightening\n               of authority. It moves beyond recognition. It moves into prohibiting enforcement backed\n               by inspection, cancellation and reapplication bans. Legislation of this kind must be examined not for what it intends to prevent, but\n               for how it exercises power. Clause 3 defines eligible institutions. Clause 4 sets\n               out the application process. Clause 5 outlines the criteria and factors for designation.\n               On the surface, these factors appear reasonable. Continuing of programs, clear information\n               to students, safe, positive experience, services that promote well-being, protection\n               of B.C.'s reputation. All commendable goals. But when we look closer at clause 5(3), we see the administrator may consider any\n               other factors that the administrator considers But when we look closer at clause 5(3), we see: \"The administrator may consider any\n               other factors that the administrator considers relevant.\" That is extremely broad.\n               And when criteria are open-ended, discretion expands. When discretion expands, predictability\n               diminishes, and when predictability diminishes, institutions and students face uncertainty. We must ask: what safeguards ensure consistency of decisions? What metrics define\n               reputation risk? What prevents uneven application? The bill does not clearly define\n               these limits. Clause 8 allows the administrator to impose, amend or remove terms and conditions\n               on a designation certificate at any time. Not just at renewal, not just upon proven\n               non-compliance, at any time. This grants ongoing regulatory controls over institutions,\n               even those acting in good faith. We must ensure that flexibility does not become unpredictability. Institutions plan\n               years ahead — staffing, facilities, student intake, housing, academic partnerships.\n               If terms can shift at any time without clearly defined thresholds, that creates operational\n               instability. We support accountability, but accountability must be paired with clarity. Let's examine enforcement. Clauses 15 through 17 authorize inspections. Inspectors\n               may enter business premises during business hours without a warrant. They may inspect\n               records, remove documents, make audio or video recordings, question individuals, and\n               institutions must not obstruct. Inspection powers are serious powers. They are justified when addressing genuine misconduct,\n               but we must ensure that they are appropriate. Is there a clear guidance on frequency\n               of inspections? Are there protections for confidential academic materials? Are there\n               safeguards against these kinds of expeditions? Oversight is necessary. It must remain\n               targeted but not intrusive by default. Clause 18 permits cancellation of designation and bars reapplication for up to three\n               years. Three years in a sector built on enrolment cycles, international recruitment\n               timelines and immigration coordination. A three-year ban is not a minor administrative\n               consequence. It can effectively close an institution's international program. Now let's look at the appeals. Clause 21 establishes the appeal process. Appeals must\n               be filed within 30 days. They require a prescribed fee. They may be based only on\n               limited grounds. And crucially the commencement of an appeal does not stay with the\n               decision. What does that mean? Appeals don't automatically stay with the decision,\n               so an institution's designation may be cancelled immediately, even while appealing. That's not a small detail. This is a fundamental procedural issue. Due process is\n               not just the right to appeal; it is meaningful appeal. If operations collapse before\n               appeal is heard, what remedies remain? What happens to the students caught in the\n               middle? In clause 19, it allows an institution whose certificate is cancelled to continue\n               providing programs to already enrolled international students — that's important —\n               but it is subject to the administrator rules. Students may face visa complications, uncertainty about credential recognition, loss\n               of confidence from families abroad, housing disruptions, employment impacts. International\n               students are not statistics. They are young people navigating a foreign system. When\n               regulatory actions occur, communication must be immediate, transparent and International students are not statistics. They are young people navigating a foreign\n               system. When regulatory actions occur, communication must be immediate, transparent\n               and coordinated with federal immigration authorities. Does this bill mandate that\n               coordination? It does not clearly say so. Clause 9 requires a public directory of designated and former designated institutions.\n               It allows publication of enforcement actions and, if authorized by regulation, publication\n               of personal information deemed in the public interest. Transparency matters, but reputational\n               damage, especially if decisions are later overturned, is reversible. Is there is a requirement to update directory entries if an appeal succeeds? Is there\n               a clear standard for what personal information may be public? This balance must be\n               handled with precision. Clause 24 allows the administrator to make binding rules on a wide range of matters\n               — instructional delivery methods, in-class proportions, reporting obligations, student\n               policy requirements, notification requirements, use of designation mark. These rules\n               may establish different classes, adopt external standards and evolve over time. This\n               is a delegated legislative authority. It is powerful, and it exists largely outside\n               of this chamber. We must ensure that rule-making remains transparent and consultive. Clause 31. Clause 31 provides immunity from legal proceedings for the administrator\n               and appeal officer acting in good faith. Clause 32 exempts the act from section 5\n               of the Offence Act. These may be technical provisions, but technical does not mean\n               trivial. When we grant enforcement authority, inspection power and cancellation power,\n               injunction power and immunity, we must ensure checks exist. Accountability must run\n               both ways. Let me be clear. We believe in protecting international students. We believe in removing\n               bad actors. We believe British Columbia's reputation must be upheld. But legislation\n               of this scope demands careful implementation. Power concentrated in a single administrator's\n               office must be exercised with restraint. Appeal processes must be meaningful. Inspection\n               powers must be transparent. Student welfare must remain central. And the regulatory\n               ambition must not become regulatory overreach. This chamber must ensure that in protecting students, we do not undermine institutional\n               stability; in safeguarding reputation, we do not sacrifice fairness; in straightening\n               oversight, we do not erode due process. International students choose British Columbia because they trust our system. Let's\n               ensure that trust is strengthened and not shaken by the way we implement this act. There is another aspect of this legislation that deserves serious attention, and that\n               is the injunction power set out in clause 20. Under this provision, the administrator\n               may apply to the Supreme Court for an injunction if there are reasonable grounds to\n               believe that a person has violated or is likely to violate the requirement to hold\n               a designation certificate or prohibit against a false representation. Now, at first glance, that may be straightforward, but subsection 20(3) does something\n               unusual. It directs the court to give greater weight to the enforcement of this act\n               than to continue operation of the institution, and it explicitly states that the administrator\n               need not establish irreparable harm. This is a significant departure from the traditional\n               balance courts apply in injunction proceedings. This is a significant departure from the traditional balance courts apply in injunction\n               proceedings. Typically courts weigh irreparable harm and the balance of convenience\n               carefully. Here, the statute instructs the court to prioritize enforcement. Again, I understand the rationale to prevent rogue operators from continuing harmful\n               practices, but we must ask: are we confident that this threshold protects against\n               unintended consequences? Are we confident that legitimate institutions facing complex\n               administrative disputes will not be caught in sweeping enforcement action. Because\n               once an injunction is granted, reputational damage is immediate. In international\n               education, reputation is everything. We must also consider the regulation-making authority in clause 33. This provision\n               gives the Lieutenant Governor in Council broad power to regulate education agents,\n               including vetting, contract and monitoring requirements. Education agents are a critical part of the international recruitment ecosystem. In\n               many countries, students rely on agents to navigate complex visa and institutional\n               processes. If those agents are poorly regulated, students can be absolutely harmed.\n               But if the regulatory burden becomes excessive or unclear, institutions, especially\n               smaller private institutions, may withdraw from international recruitment altogether. We must ensure that oversight of agents improves integrity without cutting off legitimate\n               access points for students. Regulation must target bad actors, not suffocate responsible\n               operators. Another area that warrants discussion is personal information. Clause 30 authorized\n               the collection, use and disclosure of personal information for administrating the\n               act. The directory provisions in clause 9 allow publication of information, including\n               personal information, if deemed in the public interest and authorized by regulation. Transparency is important, but privacy protection is also important. We must ensure\n               that the threshold for publishing personal information is clearly defined, consistently\n               applied. International students already face vulnerability — immigration status, housing\n               insecurity, financial strain. They must not become collateral damage in public enforcement\n               messaging. Let me return to the first principles. International education is not merely an economic\n               driver. It is a human story. It is a 19-year-old arriving in Vancouver for the first\n               time. It is a family in another country investing their life savings in tuition. It\n               is a graduate who hopes to build a life here and contribute to our economy. We must\n               protect them. This is a non-negotiable. But protection must be grounded in fairness\n               and clarity This legislation replaces a policy framework with a statutory system. That shift brings\n               strength, but it also brings responsibility. Because once power is written into law,\n               it endures. When we legislate enforcement authority of this magnitude, we must be\n               certain that we have built in the right safeguards. British Columbia's reputation depends not only on removing bad actors. It depends\n               on demonstrating we are fair, predictable, transparent and principled. That is the\n               balance we must strike. That is the balance we will continue to insist upon as this\n               bill continues. At its core, this legislation asks us to trust that concentrated authority will always\n               be exercised wisely. It asks institutions to trust that discretion will always be\n               fair. It asks students to trust that enforcement will never destabilize their future.\n               Trust is important. But in governance, trust must be reinforced by structure. Trust is important, but in governance, trust must be reinforced by structure, because\n               good intentions do not substitute for safeguards, and strong powers must be matched\n               with strong accountability. We cannot say to international students, \"You are protected,\" while building a framework\n               that allows sudden cancellations without interim protection. We cannot say to institutions,\n               \"You have the right to appeal,\" while ensuring that the consequences take effect immediately\n               and publicly. We cannot say to the world that British Columbia is a stable destination\n               if our regulatory model creates unpredictability. Oversight must inspire confidence,\n               not anxiety. This is not a debate about whether bad actors should be removed. They should. This\n               is a debate about whether good actors are given clear rules, fair processes and proportionate\n               remedies. The strength of a regulatory system is not measured by how quickly it can\n               be punished. It is measured by how consistently it can apply standards. And consistency\n               requires guardrails. I have talked through some structural risks, but I do want to just talk through some\n               solutions. I want to propose some safeguards and some balance. I want to propose some\n               improvements that strengthen protection and not weaken it. I want to say again, on\n               this side of the House, we support protecting international students. We support removing\n               bad actors. We support transparency. But we also believe that strong oversight and\n               procedural fairness must exist together. That is the balance. We can protect students and preserve fairness at the same time. This is not a choice\n               between compassion and accountability. It is about designing a system that achieves\n               both. First, this legislation shall allow for structured interim relief during appeals in\n               the appropriate cases, not automatic stays, not blanket suspensions, but a narrow\n               criteria-based mechanism allowing the appeal officer to grant temporary relief where\n               students are at risk, public safety is not compromised, there is credible evidence\n               of procedural error. This would not protect bad actors, but it would protect due process.\n               An appeal should be meaningful and not symbolic. Second, the online directory must include safeguards. If enforcement actions are published,\n               there must be clear criteria for what is disclosed, immediate updates when decisions\n               are varied or rescinded, defined timelines for how long information remains posted.\n               Transparency builds trust, but permanent, reputable damage from overturned decisions\n               undermines it. Third, before major administrative rules take effect, especially those affecting instructional\n               delivery models or compliance burdens, there should be a structured consultation.\n               International education is dynamic. Federal immigration policies shift, housing pressures\n               fluctuate, institutions need stability. When rules change, consultation should come\n               first, not after. This bill has the potential to strengthen British Columbia's reputation. But reputation\n               is not built through authority alone. It is built through fairness, predictability,\n               independence, transparency. If we incorporate safeguards into this act, we will not\n               only protect students, we will protect trust. And trust is the foundation for international\n               education. At the heart of this debate are young people. At the heart of this debate are young people. Most of our international students coming\n               from other countries are youth, young people who leave their homes and their families,\n               and they choose British Columbia. They arrive with ambition and hope, and they arrive\n               believing that this province offers opportunity, stability and integrity. We must\n               not forget that. This legislation is about protecting them, and that is a responsibility we all share.\n               But our protection must be thoughtful and fair. It must be structured in a way that\n               builds confidence and not fear. International education is not just a revenue stream.\n               It is not just enrolment data. It is human lives. It is human future. It's human trust.\n               When a student chooses British Columbia, they are placing their future in our hands. When an institution earns designation, it is replacing its reputation into our regulatory\n               framework. When this legislation grants enforcement authority, we are placing power\n               into structure, and that structure must be strong. It must also be just. The strength\n               of our system will not be measured on how quickly we can cancel it but how fairly\n               we can govern it. If we get it right, we will protect students and we will uphold institutional integrity.\n               If we get it right, we will send a message to the world that British Columbia remains\n               a place where quality, accountability and justice coexist. This is the balance we\n               must strike, this is the responsibility before us, and this is the standard we must\n               meet.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327970","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"British Columbia has built a global reputation as a destination for world-class education.\n               Students travel from every corner of the world to study here, to build futures, to\n               support families back home, to contribute to our communities and to invest in the\n               promise of Canada. International education is not a small program. It is a multi-billion\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d4263221b4b99168cef78e93107a27c25b0161838699d746f901991322b3d33d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6214d9d8600eb0aa38d468f70686c6a8856887bada678615a3b056320e576717"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc3d7c3fa38db1deaf188adf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327971,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"When I think about Mission Sunrise Rotary Club, what stands out to me is how connected\n               they are to our community. This is a group of people who care deeply about Mission\n               and who consistently step forward to serve and support the people who live there. When I first visited one of their meetings, I remember saying to them: \"I feel like\n               I've just met the heart of Mission.\" Being in that room left a real impression on\n               me. Listening to how they care for this community and seeing the passion they bring\n               to their work was incredibly moving. I left that meeting feeling both humbled and\n               inspired by their service. The Mission Sunrise Rotary Club has a strong commitment to investing in our young\n               people. Through the starfish backpack program, youth leadership initiatives, mentorship\n               and scholarships, they are helping to support the next generation and encouraging\n               young people to understand the value of leadership and giving back. Their impact can also be seen in the everyday ways they serve, from volunteering from\n               Hope Central to helping with local environmental cleanups that keep our community\n               spaces healthy and cared for. With International Women's Day just around the corner, it is also important to recognize\n               the women of this club. Their leadership, their dedication and the spirit of service\n               play an important role in the work that the club does and the positive impact it has\n               across our community. What I admire most is the example this club sets. They remind us that strong communities\n               are built by people who care enough to serve and look out for one another. Mission\n               is stronger because of this club, and our community is better because they show up,\n               serve and lead with heart.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327971","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"When I think about Mission Sunrise Rotary Club, what stands out to me is how connected\n               they are to our community. This is a group of people who care deeply about Mission\n               and who consistently step forward to serve and support the people who live there. When I first visited one of their meetings, I remember saying to them: \"I feel like\n               I've just met the h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["482c20d626a770f4382ff0afade6102931446d1d7b5d91c464862d070204d8c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68e6f400870b38a1bf9fcab3a1379bd33428b1115228a9f61cab3b9ae403fa00"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b788e7087253f954ab4035a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360156,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"A couple days ago, my community was hit with a tragedy. Chartwell retirement residence, which housed the elderly, caught on fire. Thankfully, no lives were lost, but would the House please thank the first responders,\n               the people that just wrapped around our community to support this time. It is worth giving them a round of applause.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360156","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"A couple days ago, my community was hit with a tragedy. Chartwell retirement residence, which housed the elderly, caught on fire. Thankfully, no lives were lost, but would the House please thank the first responders,\n               the people that just wrapped around our community to support this time. It is worth giving them a round of applause.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd456b3a0998a94cb404e4da42624611b90a8f17e061890079a659417d7c91df","a631645c5a2f3ae4ff8cc22329deb11ca98b2efe74d80b13ac76380ea5ff3aae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e78c503b53708cfaf87c6ceeda77b430076826baafc9f4946029a6df4cb58126"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a8030b75130ac0df68fb1f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415725,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to begin a little differently today because for me this motion is not just\n               about policy, it is personal. I stand in this House as a woman of colour, only a handful who have ever had the privilege\n               of","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415725","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to begin a little differently today because for me this motion is not just\n               about policy, it is personal. I stand in this House as a woman of colour, only a handful who have ever had the privilege\n               of","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6b9405263c6c201d840ce1d2e98fd261684840ac81733de007c6c8cf1f344fc3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e57debaca38ee65a9a3bdb9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415726,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"First this government cuts funding for families with autistic children, and now they\n               have quietly brought back the cuts to the B.C. family residence program, a program\n               that will allow families to be with their sick children when they receive critical\n               medical care away from home. This is not just wrong. It is inhumane. Why is this government cutting the funding for families who want to be next to their\n               children when they need it the most?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415726","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"First this government cuts funding for families with autistic children, and now they\n               have quietly brought back the cuts to the B.C. family residence program, a program\n               that will allow families to be with their sick children when they receive critical\n               medical care away from home. This is not just wrong. It is inhumane. Why is this government cutting the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["73b59560743068b7824c26745015421dddd4f5598d2785bea538d07669b833f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75d4eb341e5e8e7fa9ac0296d44f4a491b8c1a95245935b4e5a1c2939d09cf96"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc0a5836e1d93a1f140d0345","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415727,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act. Freedom of religion is not theoretical. It's walking into a church on Sunday. It's\n               attending a mosque on Friday. And it's gathering at a synagogue, a temple or a gurdwara.\n               The question before us is this: can people do that without fear? In 2021 alone, multiple churches in British Columbia were burnt — four in just a matter\n               of days. Across Canada, more than 30 places of worship have been destroyed by fire.\n               That should concern every one of us in this House. In Vancouver alone, there were 47 antisemitic incidents in 2023, and these included\n               threats, harassment, vandalism and attacks on Jewish institutions, including synagogues.\n               The point being, attacks on worship are on the rise in our nation and in our province. I believe that we are all here because we want to leave a better future for the next\n               generation. And that future must include something fundamental — that our children\n               in this province can walk into a place of worship I believe that we are all here because we want to leave a better future for the next\n               generation. And that future must include something fundamental — that our children\n               in this province can walk into a place of worship without fear. Because if we cannot\n               guarantee that, then we still have work to do. Let's bring this theory into real life. In the Fraser Valley, in communities like\n               my own, Mission, B.C., places of worship are not just buildings. They're where families\n               find support when life falls apart, new immigrants find community, people gather when\n               they're grieving and where hope is rebuilt week after week. I have stood in those buildings, and I have sat with people in those pews, and I have\n               prayed with families going through some of the hardest moments of their lives. And\n               I can tell you this: that when fear enters those spaces, it changes everything. Because\n               those are supposed to be the safest places in our communities. Let's talk about what this bill does. Bill 13 creates access zones about 20 metres\n               around places of worship. Inside those zones, people cannot block access, disrupt\n               services, intimidate individuals or interfere even by trying to persuade someone not\n               to enter. Police can arrest without a warrant if they believe these rules are being\n               broken, and courts can step in. At its core, this bill creates a protective buffer. But let me be clear. We support the principle of this bill. I think it's been said\n               many times today, but no one should be harassed on their way into worship. No one\n               should be intimidated for practicing their faith. Because freedom of religion means\n               nothing if we are afraid to walk through the door. This bill exists because something has gone wrong. We see a rise in vandalism, harassment\n               and targeted hate. We need to say it clearly. Government did not act early enough.\n               Because when communities are forced to respond on their own, there is already a failure\n               of leadership. We now have situations where Jewish communities are spending over $100,000 a month\n               on private security just to protect their places of worship. Let that sink in. I think\n               we need to let that sink in, because that is not for luxury. It is not for an expansion.\n               It is for basic safety. When people have to pay for their own protection just to pray,\n               government has already fallen behind. While this bill is a step, it is not a solution. And British Columbians are starting\n               to recognize that pattern. We see it across sectors. A problem grows. Communities\n               feel pressure, and the government responds with legislation, but not with the full\n               weight of action required to actually fix it. And that's what concerns me here. Because\n               creating a 20-metre access zone is one thing, but actually ensuring people are safe\n               within it is something else entirely. We cannot pretend that drawing a line on the ground automatically creates safety.\n               Safety comes from presence. It comes from enforcement. And it comes from knowing that\n               when something happens, someone will respond. Right now, too many communities do not\n               have that confidence. So let's actually talk about what's happening on the ground. We have faith communities\n               right here in British Columbia spending tens of thousands of dollars every month on\n               private security not because they want to, but because they feel they have no other\n               choice. And that should stop every one of us in this House. Because when citizens are forced to step in and fund their own protection, this is\n               not a sign of strength in public safety. It is a sign of a gap. When safety becomes\n               something you have to buy, government is no longer delivering it. If the government is serious about protecting places of worship, then it must answer\n               some very real questions. Where are the additional policing resources tied to this\n               bill? What enforcement plan exists beyond signage and boundaries? How will smaller\n               communities like those in the Fraser Valley and up north be supported when resources\n               are already stretched thin? Because in places like Mission, we already know In places like Mission, we already know what it feels like when systems are stretched.\n               We've seen it in our health care, we've seen it in our emergency services and now\n               we're seeing the same pressure show up in public safety and around places of worship\n               across this province. This bill gives police the power to arrest without warrant. This is a significant\n               expansion of authority. But authority without capacity is not effectiveness. There\n               are not enough officers. If there are not enough officers, if response times are already\n               strained, then who is actually enforcing these zones? You cannot enforce a promise\n               without the people to back it up. There is also a deeper issue. What this bill is really responding to is a rise in\n               hate. The legislation alone does not address that. We need stronger public safety\n               strategies, clearer consequences for targeted harassment and leadership that is proactive,\n               not reactive. If we are always responding after the fact, communities will always\n               be the ones to step up behind the risk. This is where the difference lies. Government says, \"We've introduced a bill,\" but\n               communities are asking: \"Will you actually stand with us when it matters?\" Government\n               says, \"We've created a zone,\" but families are asking: \"Will someone be there if something\n               happens?\" We will support measures that protect people any day, and we will also continue to\n               push because British Columbians deserve more than a line on the pavement. They deserve\n               real safety. They deserve real support. They deserve a government that does more than\n               respond, a government that takes responsibility. In Mission, we don't talk about our stretched systems as theory. We are living it.\n               We've watched our emergency close, not once. For the last two weeks, it's been shut\n               down every evening. Every time this happens, the message to the community is clear:\n               you're on your own tonight. Families are redirected, first responders are stretched,\n               neighbouring hospitals carry the load, and the people feel it immediately, instantly. What we're seeing in this bill follows the same pattern. When the systems are stretched\n               and resources aren't there, when enforcement is uncertain, people have to step in.\n               Communities have to adapt and slowly and quietly, the responsibility shifts. This is exactly what is happening with places of worship. Faith communities are not\n               just opening their doors anymore. They are hiring security. They are monitoring their\n               entrances. They are preparing for risk. Not because they want to but because they\n               feel they have to. This is not what public safety is supposed to look like. Public safety is not something\n               communities should have to build for themselves. It is something they should be able\n               to rely on. You can't legislate safety and then outsource responsibility. If this government is serious about protecting faith communities, then this bill cannot\n               be the end of the conversation. It cannot be the headline, it cannot be the talking\n               point, it cannot be just about an announcement and it cannot be where the work stops. Passing a law is one thing and making people feel safe is something else entirely.\n               Right now there are gaps between what is being announced and what is being experienced.\n               Communities feel that gap. Let's talk about what needs to happen next or what could happen next. We need visible\n               policing presence. Not just policies but people on the ground. We need real enforcement\n               capacity. A rule means nothing Let's talk about what needs to happen next or what could happen next. We need visible\n               policing presence, not just policies but people on the ground. We need real enforcement\n               capacity, because a rule means nothing if there's no one there to uphold it. We need targeted support for communities facing hate, not generic responses but focused\n               action where it is needed most. We need to address, frankly, that this shouldn't be happening at all. It's sad. It's\n               sad that I'm even having to say what we could be doing because of the hate that we\n               are experiencing and the acts of violence against places of worship. But here we are.\n               So we have communities being forced to hire private security and then being taxed\n               on it. That doesn't make sense to me. Why, in this climate, when the reality of both sides — we are recognizing there is\n               a problem. Now we have put a tax on our security guards. They are paying to protect\n               us, and now they are having to pay the tax on top of it. This is not just a policy\n               gap. This is a disconnection from reality, because you can't say one thing and do\n               another. That's the definition of insanity. If safety is a priority, it should be funded like one. Leadership is not about reacting\n               when things get bad. Leadership is about recognizing where things are going and acting\n               before they get there. But too often we see a pattern. Government waits. Communities\n               absorb the impact. Pressure builds, and only then legislation arrives. And by that\n               point, the damage is already being felt and trust is already shaken and communities\n               are already adapting on their own. That is not proactive leadership. That is reactive\n               governance. When government arrives late, communities pay the price. We need to reverse that. We need a government that steps in early not after the fact,\n               that listens before crisis not after it, that protects before people feel unsafe not\n               after they already do. The role of government is not just to respond to risk but to\n               prevent it. At the heart of this bill is something very simple. People want to feel safe. They\n               showed up to the announcement because they want to feel safe. They want to trust that\n               this bill will help that process. They want to feel safe to gather. They want to feel\n               safe to worship. They want to feel safe to believe. In a province as diverse as ours,\n               that matters more than ever, because our diversity is not our weakness; it is our\n               strength, but only if people feel free to live it out. Yes, I support this bill. But let's not stop here. Let's do the real work, because\n               safety is not created by a 20-metre boundary. It is created by leadership that act.\n               And it is created when government takes full responsibility for the people it serves. The first and most immediate step that government could take alongside this bill is\n               visible, dedicated policing around places of worship. It creates a boundary. It defines\n               space, it sets rules within that space, but a boundary on its own does not create\n               safety. Presence does. Right now Bill 13 establishes access zones around places of worship, and we need to\n               ask the obvious question: \"Who's going to be there to enforce it?\" Because if no one\n               is there, then that boundary becomes symbolic and not practical. We need to make sure that funding targeted patrols during high-risk times, not randomly,\n               not occasionally, but strategically during the Sabbath, during major religious holidays\n               and large gatherings and community events, because those are the moments when vulnerability\n               is the highest and when presence is the most.... The reason I wanted to say some of\n               those things is because we have to be clear on the plan when we are leading. We cannot\n               be vague when we put forward a bill. We have to actually follow it through right to\n               the end and communicate it effectively to British Columbians. It can also mean working directly with local police departments to develop faith-based\n               safety plans, because not one size fits all policy. It's not a one-size-fits-all but\n               plans that reflect the realities of each faith-based community, because what a synagogue\n               may need may be different from what a church or a mosque or a gurdwara may need. The\n               people who understand those risks best are the communities themselves. We must ensure that rapid response protocols are clearly in place, because when something\n               happens near a place of worship, time matters. Minutes matter. People need to know,\n               not hope, not assume, but know that someone will respond quickly, that they will not\n               be left waiting and that they will not be alone in that moment. Another practical step that could be taken immediately is the government could remove\n               the PST on security services. As the opposition, it is my job to oppose, but it is\n               also my job to potentially bring things that could make the bill better. Faith communities\n               are having to do.... I have it here again. They're forced to hire private security not\n               because they want to expand, not because they're choosing to, but because they feel\n               they have no other option. And as they're paying for that, they're now having to be\n               taxed on it. If the government is serious about standing with faith communities, then this is one\n               of the clearest ways to show it — not with words, not with statements, but with action\n               that people can actually feel. There comes a point in every debate where we have to stop speaking like legislators\n               and start speaking like leaders. Because outside this chamber, this is not theoretical.\n               People are not debating definitions, and they are not analyzing clauses. They are\n               asking: am I safe — safe to walk into my church, safe to bring my children to synagogue,\n               safe to gather, to pray, to believe? If the answer to that question is anything less\n               than a clear and confident yes, then we still have work to do. I refuse to accept a province where fear follows people into sacred spaces. I refuse\n               to accept that communities should have to hire guards and lock their doors or look\n               over their shoulders just to worship. I refuse to accept a government that can check\n               a box with legislation and call the job done. Because this is not the finish line.\n               This is the starting point. I'm so happy to hear that so many faith leaders came out to that announcement. But\n               I would be embarrassed if the government did not take this bill and do right by the\n               people of British Columbia, because they have been advocating for being safe for a\n               very long time. So I celebrate with them. It is the start. It is not the beginning. And I hope that\n               the government will do right So I celebrate with them. It is the start. It is not the beginning.... I hope that the\n               government will do right by British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415727","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act. Freedom of religion is not theoretical. It's walking into a church on Sunday. It's\n               attending a mosque on Friday. And it's gathering at a synagogue, a temple or a gurdwara.\n               The question before us is this: can people do that without fear? In 2021 alone, multiple churches in British Columb","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036926","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036926","label":"Religious architecture","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85c36ee9c0ae26e5712c708dd21dcc67bc5fc1097a2a525c07037ab8a9c8f297"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab7358cd3d1d501e7851a1d1a19127a81df9d30701464330c77c33048b42e706"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21700f71844dc6f3921a3ea5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415728,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Please join me in welcoming So thank you so much for being in the House today. It's so good to see you here but,\n               as always, I can't wait to see you at home as well. Please, House, make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415728","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Please join me in welcoming So thank you so much for being in the House today. It's so good to see you here but,\n               as always, I can't wait to see you at home as well. Please, House, make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e8ce489b238ac93f60343afae6e59ec7eb2229bf27f90117ac93a1fb5b45e7f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aac114f17c00cb520e95fbcd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720328,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Across British Columbia, families, service providers and advocates are stepping forward\n               with courage, not just for their own children, but for every child who depends on\n               these supports to grow, learn and participate in their communities. Right now, I want\n               to honour each community for standing up for all children. I am happy to stand alongside\n               them to see a balanced system where no child is left behind. What they are standing up for is not abstract. They are standing up for funding that\n               is stable, predictable and individualized, funding that allows families to build trusted\n               teams, funding that recognizes that no two children are the same. They are standing\n               up because they know what happens when stability is taken away. When you have children on wait-lists for two to three years that have finally been\n               approved for funding and then they get a letter when the announcement happens and\n               you say they no longer qualify and now you say that isn't a cut, families know exactly\n               what that is. I want to share a story that reflects what we are hearing across this province. A\n               father from northern British Columbia reached out, not from a major centre but from\n               a region where services are already limited, where access is already fragile. His\n               son was diagnosed with autism at age three. Like so many families, they did everything\n               they were told to do. They sought early intervention. They moved communities to access\n               better services. They built a care team over time. Today that child is ten years old. For the past five years, he has worked with the\n               same interventionist, one consistent person, one trusted relationship, one place where\n               progress has been built slowly and meaningfully. Even with the current funding, his\n               family can only afford one session per week. Now they have to sit down with their\n               son and tell him that his therapy is going to stop, not because it isn't working,\n               not because he doesn't need it but because they simply cannot afford it anymore. In northern communities, there are no alternatives waiting. The public system is already\n               stretched. Wait-lists are long. This is what happens when policy is announced before\n               systems are built. So what happens now? What happens in the gap between what exists\n               and what is being promised? This family is left with impossible choices. Do they drain their savings to continue\n               therapy, holding onto hope that their child may one day live independently? Or do\n               they stop therapy, protect their financial future and live with the question they\n               will carry for the rest of their lives? \"What if we had done more?\" No family should\n               ever be placed in that position. This is not one story. This is what we have heard in two town halls with over 400\n               participants from across British Columbia. This is what we are hearing in over 2,000\n               emails that have come into my office alone. Parents are exhausted. Professionals who\n               are warning us. Communities are telling us clearly that the math is not adding up.\n               They are simply asking reasonable questions. Who decides which child is high needs\n               enough? What criteria will be used? Who is doing the assessments, and are they qualified?\n               Where is the workforce coming from when we are already experiencing shortage? What\n               happens to children in rural communities where services do not exist? What happens\n               in the time between funding being removed and the services being built? These are not political questions. These are practical questions, and right now families\n               are not getting the answer. We all agree that children should receive support. We\n               all agree that the system should be fair. But fairness cannot mean taking stability\n               away from one child to give uncertainty to another. What we're seeing right now is a system being changed before replacement is ready.\n               Families are being asked to leave supports that are working to enter systems that\n               do not yet What we're seeing right now is a system being changed before replacement is ready.\n               Families are being asked to leave supports that are working to enter systems that\n               do not yet exist and to trust timelines that come with no certainty. The result is\n               what we are hearing across the province: fear, confusion and the very real risk of\n               children losing the progress they have fought so hard to achieve. So my question to the minister: if this plan is truly ready, where are the services?\n               Where are the professionals. Where is the clear criteria? Because right now families\n               across British Columbia are not seeing a system that is ready.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720328","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Across British Columbia, families, service providers and advocates are stepping forward\n               with courage, not just for their own children, but for every child who depends on\n               these supports to grow, learn and participate in their communities. Right now, I want\n               to honour each community for standing up for all children. I am happy to stand alongside\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["054b9d3856d92175fe008287ddb9ef0faf6e05f40f1de02c29607ea3081e8038"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b941917de3b6640033e735369b04b4b533402be6519381485348531686ea3851"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d477c15eefbfb3cd9f509874","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721423,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am so privileged to introduce a distinguished guest who is seated with us on the\n               floor today, Randy Hawes. Randy is no stranger to this house. He has served with great\n               distinction, including being the mayor and MLA for Abbotsford-Mission. His dedication\n               to public service and to the people of the Fraser Valley has left a lasting impact\n               on communities, and I am proud to have him as a friend. His many stories and conversations\n               just leave me in awe sometimes. Would the House please make him feel very special\n               today and welcome him here. I do have a second introduction. I have two guests in the gallery, and it is not often\n               that I do get to have people from my riding. So it is a very special day because Doug\n               and Donna are visiting. They are in my riding association. It's Doug's birthday today.\n               Would the House just make them feel really special. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721423","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am so privileged to introduce a distinguished guest who is seated with us on the\n               floor today, Randy Hawes. Randy is no stranger to this house. He has served with great\n               distinction, including being the mayor and MLA for Abbotsford-Mission. His dedication\n               to public service and to the people of the Fraser Valley has left a lasting impact\n               o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8e370e7dc01ca49cb767b04db84f76c0cad4e44dd9d4ae39a3f7bd687538890"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-51a5fe5ea0a96ceb083ee510","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721425,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"At a time when this government is cutting supports for children and families with\n               autism, they have no problem giving their deputy ministers and associate deputy ministers\n               car allowance for up to $1,200 a month — over $14,000 a year for deputy ministers\n               to lease new vehicles. This government is paying for their deputy ministers to drive six-figure cars while\n               families are losing funding needed to put their children through therapy. How can this government justify giving deputy ministers $14,000 car allowances while\n               ripping funding away from children with autism?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721425","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"At a time when this government is cutting supports for children and families with\n               autism, they have no problem giving their deputy ministers and associate deputy ministers\n               car allowance for up to $1,200 a month — over $14,000 a year for deputy ministers\n               to lease new vehicles. This government is paying for their deputy ministers to drive six-figure cars ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["df21717b9f9b7898e95a011e3a94915b6ca1832cafea32df612b9b6b71939a76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c9342a3e3ac0f6d91cee7f2c9162770bdb609fd3d9b43f1147d30874d30a961"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-299c7796dee65397afad7fe5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752239,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I consider it an honour and a responsibility for my role in this House to speak to\n               Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I want to take a moment to begin with a word that sits at the centre of this legislation:\n               freedom. It is a word used often in this assembly — sometimes, so often we stop hearing\n               its weight. But freedom in the context of information is not procedural language.\n               It is not administrative language. It is democratic language. Freedom of information is one of the tools the public uses to examine power. It is\n               how decisions are tested. It is how conduct is scrutinized. It is how trust is preserved.\n               Without it, government operates in shadow. With it, government operates in light.\n               That distinction matters because democracy is not only what happens during an election.\n               It is what happens between elections. It is whether people can ask hard questions\n               and get answers. It is whether decisions affecting lives can be examined. It is whether\n               power can be held accountable in real time. Freedom of information is not a convenience. It is not a privilege. It is a democratic\n               safeguard. Question period is a democratic tool. Independent officers of this Legislature\n               are democratic tools. Free press is a democratic tool. The courts, a democratic tool.\n               Take away access to information and every other democratic tool begins to weaken. Let us be honest about what that means. When government can call scrutiny interference,\n               accountability is already weakened. When asking questions can be labelled abusive,\n               oversight is no longer protected. It is managed. And once accountability is managed\n               by government instead of exercised by the public, freedom has narrowed. Accountability\n               cannot be treated as an interference. Freedom of information does not exist because government can always be trusted to\n               volunteer what the public needs to know. If that were true, this system would not\n               need to exist at all. Freedom of information exists for the moments when trust breaks,\n               when answers do not come easily, when decisions are unclear, when people have reason\n               to test what they are being told. That is its purpose. It is not designed for convenience.\n               It is designed for scrutiny. Scrutiny is often uncomfortable. It can be repetitive. It can be broad. It can be\n               persistent. But those things do not make scrutiny abusive. Very often, they are what\n               accountability looks like. Some of the most important public questions begin as inconvenient\n               questions. Some begin as questions government would prefer were never asked. But that\n               has never been the test. The test is whether the public has the right to ask them. Under this bill, that line becomes blurred. When \"abusive\" is undefined, who decides?\n               When \"repetitive\" becomes grounds to disregard a request, how many times a citizen\n               can seek answers before persistence is treated When \"abusive\" is undefined, who decides? When \"repetitive\" becomes grounds to disregard\n               a request, how many times can a citizen seek answers before persistence is treated\n               as misconduct? When a request can be rejected because it may interfere with operations,\n               who determines whether accountability has become inconvenient? These are not technical questions. They are power questions. Because vague standards\n               do not restrain power; they enlarge it. The legislation should be judged not only\n               by how it operates under a reasonable government but by how it could be used under\n               an unreasonable one. This is the discipline of good law-making, because law outlives\n               government, powers outlive ministers, and precedence outlives intention. If we create\n               authorities today that can be stretched tomorrow, we should not pretend risk does\n               not exist simply because government says it will use those powers responsibly. Responsible governments do not ask to be trusted more. They build systems where trust\n               is tested. So we must ask a very clear question. Does this bill strengthen that democratic\n               safeguard or weaken it? Does it bring people closer to the truth or place more distance\n               between them? When we look honestly at what is proposed, the answer is clear. The bill does not\n               strengthen freedom of information; it constrains it. It allows government to label\n               requests as abusive, malicious or repetitive without clear definitions. It expands\n               the ability to reject requests said to interfere with operations. It introduces fees\n               where information was previously free. That means fewer people may access information,\n               more barriers stand in the way, and more discretion sits with government. It reshapes the balance, it shifts decision-making power, it softens duties, and it\n               centralizes control. That is not a small thing. That is a shift in power. I want to\n               say it plainly that this bill is not a solution. It is an escalation. It takes a system\n               people already struggle with and gives government more power to limit access and not\n               expand it. Here's what people should see clearly. First, government can delay, then it can deny,\n               then it can charge you for asking. Delay, deny, charge. That is not expanded access;\n               that is managed access. People already struggle to access information. They already\n               face delays. They already receive incomplete answers. So the expectation would be\n               reform that makes access easier, clearer, faster. That is not what this bill delivers, and nowhere is that clearer than the change from\n               responding without delay to responding without reasonable delay. Words matter. \"Without\n               delay\" means \"act.\" \"Without reasonable delay\" means \"explain the delay.\" One creates\n               duty, and the other one creates excuses. This is not a small change. It lowers the\n               standard. People already believe that the system is too slow, and that is not to be disputed.\n               So what should reform do? Raise standards, tighten duties, improve response. But unfortunately,\n               the bill does the opposite. It takes a firm duty and softens it. It takes access problems\n               and introduces fees. It takes concerns and adds undefined refusal grounds. This is\n               not correcting failure. It is adjusting the standard downward to fit the failure. Lowering the standard is one of the oldest ways institutions protect themselves without\n               fixing themselves. If response times are poor, redefine delay. If requests are difficult,\n               redefine the requester. If scrutiny is uncomfortable, redefine scrutiny as interference.\n               This is not modernization. It does not This is not modernization. It does not fix the problem. It changes the rule around\n               the problem. Government should answer plainly: why is the answer to delays not stronger\n               timelines? Why is the answer to burden not better administration? Why is the answer\n               to frustration more discretion for the system causing the frustration? Those are serious\n               questions. People do not lose trust because government admits a system struggles. People lose\n               trust when government changes the rules in ways that appear to protect the system\n               from scrutiny. Clarity is missing because vague language replaces clear rules. Discretion\n               replaces consistency, and interpretation replaces certainty. Words like \"abusive\",\n               \"malicious\", \"repetitive\" and \"excessively broad\". Not defined in law, yet carrying\n               consequence. A broad request is not abuse. Repeated requests are not malicious. Persistence is\n               not misconduct. Sometimes persistence is what accountability looks like. My simple\n               question is: why? If the goal was to truly fix the system, why broaden the ways to\n               say no? If delays are already the problem, why weaken the duty to respond without\n               delay? If access is already difficult, why add fees? I reserve my place in the debate and move adjournment of the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752239","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I consider it an honour and a responsibility for my role in this House to speak to\n               Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I want to take a moment to begin with a word that sits at the centre of this legislation:\n               freedom. It is a word used often in this assembly — sometimes, so often we stop hearing\n               its weight. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hearing disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034780","label":"Hearing disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["465f00ab4aedff08b4270864643203c9e32bd87ceeae50cfbfa9da15515722ed","065e138550fc9c9580a069f837980f06ca36e298c57a53e71619acb0623f759b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fb490a6f0db7d2ca929fb238b73ea69214a5a7ccd7fda5b2fac7f6d49b7f87f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14f93f960529865773721fba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752240,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to recognize National Nursing Week, coming up next week. I want to honour\n               the incredible nurses serving communities across British Columbia. Nurses are there\n               for people during some of the most important and vulnerable moments in life. They\n               are there moments of fear, relief, heartbreak, healing and hope. As a mother of three, I know how much those moments matter. Many of us can remember\n               a nurse who brought comfort during a difficult time, who stayed calm in the middle\n               of uncertainty or who simply showed kindness when it was needed most. Nursing is not just a career. It is a calling rooted in compassion, patience, skill\n               and service. Today nurses work under pressures that did not exist a generation ago.\n               Patient volumes are higher. Cases are more complex. Workplaces are more demanding\n               and, at times, more dangerous. Yet despite these realities, nurses continue to show\n               up. Day after day, shift after shift, they persevere not because it's easy but because\n               it matters. This week is an opportunity for all of us to pause and recognize the sacrifices nurses\n               make every single day — the long hours, the emotional weight they carry and the dedication\n               they bring to caring for others. Whether they work in hospitals, long-term care, community\n               health, school clinics or emergency care, nurses are truly the backbone of our health\n               care system. To every nurse across British Columbia, including those serving in communities like\n               Mission Memorial Hospital, Abbotsford Regional Hospital and throughout Fraser Valley,\n               thank you. Thank you for your compassion. Thank you for the countless ways you care\n               for people every single day. We see you. This province thanks you, and this country\n               is better because of you. Happy National Nursing Week.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752240","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I want to recognize National Nursing Week, coming up next week. I want to honour\n               the incredible nurses serving communities across British Columbia. Nurses are there\n               for people during some of the most important and vulnerable moments in life. They\n               are there moments of fear, relief, heartbreak, healing and hope. As a mother of three, I know how much","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["354389f97cb87db612804e912c31fe79cefdd44c47bada34c90261388f642c6f","6f36268c548ff0bafd663bf287ad649e0c7dfdbad192cd77843cae88f924e784"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f943e0a33146d85fdb6712ad58f94328d2944f08df47f67f3f2b70924fd4025d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f13dde4ce35786f18200891","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036479,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"School district 62 are proposing to cut early childhood educators across the district.\n               The president of the Canadian Union of Public Employees: \"When you remove even one\n               line of connection between a student and a trusted adult in their school, you make\n               it harder for every other student to find safe places and supportive spaces to learn.\" My question is to the Minister of Education. Why are children losing vital classroom\n               supports while this government continues to claim education is a priority?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036479","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"School district 62 are proposing to cut early childhood educators across the district.\n               The president of the Canadian Union of Public Employees: \"When you remove even one\n               line of connection between a student and a trusted adult in their school, you make\n               it harder for every other student to find safe places and supportive spaces to learn.\" My question is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["765b3391479217b08fb78f38e30f0de67178999900e1b094cadae8d66081c64b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1479d72782ce2fa5592544dfd96b0b03c51f1ec72c155ae8e84bb57fd884d56c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb9db9ddf25049dd4249e857","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036480,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to present a petition on behalf of 638 Mission residents who are deeply concerned\n               about the repeated closures to the emergency department at Mission Memorial Hospital.\n               The people of Mission are calling for reliable, around-the-clock emergency care. I\n               am honoured to present this petition in their name.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036480","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to present a petition on behalf of 638 Mission residents who are deeply concerned\n               about the repeated closures to the emergency department at Mission Memorial Hospital.\n               The people of Mission are calling for reliable, around-the-clock emergency care. I\n               am honoured to present this petition in their name.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e474ceb7ade70797b2b3554e0f601fbb391d6fe36a02bb1d4d52bde98c081d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f0fcde819adf7102489c52f587166e7c5f7b5fd053322ebd133964137342485"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e067989b1d57bfa7c71588e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036481,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Reann Gasper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to recognize and sincerely thank the many people who make the work of this\n               Legislature possible each and every day. To our Conservative caucus staff, our LAs,\n               our EAs, communications team, research staff, our chief of staff, thank you for your\n               professionalism, your dedication and countless hours of work behind the scenes. Members may stand in this chamber, but none of us can do this work alone. Your preparation,\n               advice, organization and steady support allow us to better represent our constituents\n               and hold the government accountable on behalf of British Columbia. I want to extend a special thanks to our CAs across this province. In many cases,\n               they are the first voice people hear when they call for help and the first face they\n               see when they walk into a constituency office. I also want to express my appreciation to the many staff throughout this building\n               who keep this Legislature functioning smoothly, professionally and respectfully every\n               day. To the Clerk's office, community staff, legal and procedural teams, Hansard, IT and\n               client services, thank you for the expertise and professionalism you bring to this\n               institution. To the chamber pages, thank you for your hard work, for your composure, your support\n               of the daily work in this House. To the security staff, the dining room staff, the maintenance crew, the cleaning staff,\n               thank you for everything you do, often outside the spotlight, to ensure we remain\n               safe, welcoming and operational each and every day. Public service is not carried out by elected officials alone. It depends on the hundreds\n               of people who work diligently behind the scenes with patience and pride in their work.\n               On behalf of the official opposition Conservative caucus, I offer a sincere gratitude\n               and appreciation to all of you for your service in this institution and to the people\n               of British Columbia. On behalf of the official opposition Conservative caucus, I offer sincere gratitude\n               and appreciation to all of you for your service in this institution and to the people\n               of British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036481","member_id":"bc-mla-356","member_name":"Reann Gasper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to recognize and sincerely thank the many people who make the work of this\n               Legislature possible each and every day. To our Conservative caucus staff, our LAs,\n               our EAs, communications team, research staff, our chief of staff, thank you for your\n               professionalism, your dedication and countless hours of work behind the scenes. Members may stand in thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["866a929952336b264c2992b40809b2fd44d19e06ddf087f2bc6134931ed60d89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a37c7ecd96eb3f7ef2fab2da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317182,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"In-home hospice and end-of-life care in British Columbia has been sidelined. Budget\n               2026 revealed that care beds promised to British Columbians have been shelved indefinitely,\n               which is very, very short-sighted.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317182","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"In-home hospice and end-of-life care in British Columbia has been sidelined. Budget\n               2026 revealed that care beds promised to British Columbians have been shelved indefinitely,\n               which is very, very short-sighted.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3964d23eb1b25c336abcdb71187cd62105b7f2c0ab93ec1e3527835f72ea9190"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea01975d988b6594c3eddc4dadfcf716b2d92edce1813219a840990171724779"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-882d1d1c2a608b317999a212","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317183,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always rewarding to welcome constituents into the House but especially when they're\n               also community leaders. So I'd like to welcome to the House Andrea Critchley, CEO\n               of Abbotsford Hospice and Grief Support, and Miriam Bozman, board member of the Abbotsford\n               Hospice Foundation. Would the House make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317183","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It's always rewarding to welcome constituents into the House but especially when they're\n               also community leaders. So I'd like to welcome to the House Andrea Critchley, CEO\n               of Abbotsford Hospice and Grief Support, and Miriam Bozman, board member of the Abbotsford\n               Hospice Foundation. Would the House make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55e74d8a06e47d64b2c0088012385c9ec760cf677a9893903fdc1c9e78736782"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-412dd30d1218e00db16d3ad8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328023,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a privilege to stand in this House and represent the constituents of Abbotsford West. I'm honoured to speak to this bill, Bill 7, Post-Secondary International Education\n               (Designated Institutions) Act. Our side of the House absolutely supports efforts that actually create quality degree\n               assurance. And I want to repeat that. This side of the House absolutely supports efforts\n               that create quality degree assurance. Those who receive a degree, a certificate and\n               training need to be competent in delivering quality service in their field of training. In the international student permit cap, the federal government's intent was to deal\n               with bad actors, schools that did not give quality training to international students\n               receiving degrees, certificates and training. They did not, however, target bad actors.\n               Instead, they have now punished all institutions across Canada and here in B.C. The needs of our trained workforce in British Columbia are growing. We do not have\n               enough students going to institutions to get the training they need to supply our\n               economy with trained workers. The unintended consequences of the federal cap on student\n               permits in 2024 has had a huge negative impact on all of our institutions across the\n               country and this province. And now we have Bill 7. During the briefing, I was given some insight. Let me just\n               read to you some background and overview: \"Education quality assurance is B.C.'s official\n               designation for post-secondary institutions that meet or exceed provincial standards\n               for quality and student protection.\" Couldn't agree with it more. \"Institutions must\n               have EQA designation if they want to enrol international students who have study permits. \"In January 2024, the province announced the international education framework, which\n               was already referenced, to improve standards and better protect students. The ministry\n               is planning to introduce new legislation in spring to formally establish the EQA framework\n               into law.\" But the question is: is Bill 7 the right next step? What are the possible unintended\n               consequences of Bill 7? Does the language in Bill 7 serve the intent? Second in this briefing was the purpose of proposed new legislation, \"establish legal\n               authorities.\" So we're moving now from policy to law, which requires scrutiny with\n               every word in this bill. It's not just policy anymore; it is now legal framework. Number two: \"Enable oversight and enforcement. Set clear rules for institutions. Make\n               it easier to enforce those rules, and give government better tools to make institutions\n               follow them.\" I guess I would have to ask first at the outset: have all the safeguards been enforced\n               in the policy part of this agreement? In other words, we've had policy out there for\n               a number of years. Do we know.... Have they been enforced, the guardrails for that policy?\n               If they Number 3, enables cost recovery. The proposed act will allow government to charge\n               institutions fees to help cover the cost of running the enforced EQA program. We already\n               know — there are newspaper articles that can stack that high — of institutions who\n               are cash-strapped already. Number 4, implement international education framework commitments. Complete and put\n               into law the commitment made in the international education framework announced in\n               2024. When we move from policy to law, we need to move forward carefully. Why? Because\n               every word matters. There is ample evidence that higher education in Canada and B.C. and across the West\n               is not adhering to social contract implied by its public funding. Pick your favourite\n               example: limited learning, the excess of DEI, discriminatory hiring, cancelling unpopular\n               viewpoints, anti-Semitism, extreme left skew in faculty political viewpoints. In spite\n               of claiming to embrace diversity, equity and inclusion, the activists turn in to the\n               universities' scholarships questionable research. Something is seriously wrong with\n               our universities. And provinces currently fund universities by handing over large sums of money to cover\n               operating costs while giving institutions considerable autonomy on how they spend\n               it. This approach gives universities little incentive to line with public priorities.\n               Here is where I believe the abuse of international student growth, because of lack\n               of oversight, has manifested itself. Post-secondary institutions, PSIs, are critical to Canada's economic growth. Teaching\n               programs improve people's skills needed for today's fast-developing economies. Discovery\n               and applied research support a more innovative society. The institutions themselves\n               are significant contributors to the quality of life in the communities they serve,\n               whether in the local area or a business sector ranging from agriculture to health\n               services requiring stabilized skills. Yet, as obvious as this may be, we overlook it at our own peril. Today's PSIs are\n               challenged on many fronts with a sharp reduction in full fee paying international\n               students. Institutions have lost a significant revenue source that helped cover the\n               cost of domestic programs. And here is the crux of it. Institutions that run their operations correctly take\n               the extra funds from international students, then give domestic students a cut in\n               tuition and allow more domestic students to take courses and degrees and certificates.\n               The most pressing cases are B.C. and Quebec PSIs, which derive almost three-fifths\n               of their revenue from international students, followed by Ontario PSIs, which is 50\n               percent. Governments have capped domestic student tuition fees and reduced per-student funding.\n               During this challenging financial squeeze, institutions are facing growing public\n               scrutiny when the principles of freedom of expression, open inquiry and non-discrimination\n               are perceived to be eroding in hiring, admission and teaching practices. We need a\n               wake-up call to fundamentally address governance, funding and the quality of post-secondary\n               education in Canada. Let's bring it home. The federal government's cap on international student visas is translating into staff\n               cuts at least at two major Lower Mainland post-secondary schools. Since Ottawa implemented\n               the cap in 2024, citing pressures on housing, health care and other services, Kwantlen\n               Polytechnic University is expecting about 2,360 international students this fall,\n               down almost 60 percent from last year. Foreign students typically pay four to five times more than Canadian students to study\n               at B.C. post-secondary institutions. Schools are now feeling the bite. In a notice\n               to faculty, Kwantlen said it was expecting a $5 million to $10 million drop in revenue\n               in its 2025-2026 budget. The school said that funding gap will translate into loss\n               of 40 to 45 full-time positions. I quote: \"We anticipate that between early retirements and departments and the dry-up\n               of contract work, this might represent 10 to 20 percent of the entire faculty workforce,\"\n               said Mark Diotte, president of the Kwantlen Faculty Association. Langara College, meanwhile, said it expects to see 2,400 fewer students than two years\n               ago, enough to shrink its overall student body by 20 percent. Langara College, meanwhile, said it expects to see 2,400 fewer students than two years\n               ago, enough to shrink its overall student body by 20 percent. \"As a result of 2,400\n               less students, we need less courses. There's less demand for some of the courses that\n               we're offering in the past,\" Langara president Dr. Paula Burns said. \"It does mean\n               that we're looking at reduced revenue, particularly when the decrease is coming from\n               the international student population. As a result of that, we also have to look at\n               expenses across all of our areas of all employee groups.\" Burns said Langara is dealing with a $13 million deficit this year but were required\n               yet to deliver a balanced budget in the next year. The school has already notified\n               69 staff members that they will see their classes cut next year. And Burns said it\n               was too early to say how many people may ultimately be let go. President Diotte from Kwantlen said that educators are frustrated, and the provincial government has not stepped\n               in with new funding to bridge the gap left by international student tuition. \"We have\n               Ontario's government that stepped up and offered $1.3 billion in a stabilization fund.\n               The B.C. NDP has $4 million in contingency funding, but it has been silent.\" What we've been really seeing is the federal government pointing fingers towards the\n               provincial government and the provincial government pointing fingers at the federal\n               government. What we need to see is all levels of government getting together with\n               faculty, unions, administration and students and finding a sustainable path forward. Now to Bill 7. On the surface, it claims to protect international students and uphold\n               British Columbia's reputation. But in reality, it centralizes extraordinary power\n               in the hands of a single administrator while placing sweeping discretionary authority\n               over our post-secondary institutions. Let's be clear again. Accountability in international education matters, and I strongly\n               support quality degree assurance when it can be created. But I don't know if Bill\n               7 answers that. British Columbia has built a strong global reputation through institutions established\n               under the College and Institute Act, the University Act, the Royal Roads University\n               Act and the Thompson Rivers University Act. These institutions, including Royal Roads\n               University and Thompson Rivers University, are respected worldwide. But respect is\n               not strengthened by vague authority, by regulatory overreach and diminishing procedural\n               fairness. We have a good international reputation. It took us a long time to build. I believe\n               Bill 7 is going to hurt that, because it's easy to lose. This bill requires any institution\n               offering programs to international students to obtain and maintain a designation certificate.\n               Failure to do so results in the inability to advertise. They can't even advertise.\n               So they're supposed to apply for this before they have any students. Once they apply,\n               then they can advertise, then they can enrol, then they can contract and then continue\n               instruction. On its face, that sounds reasonable. But when we examine the structure, the concentration\n               of authority becomes deeply concerning. We've seen from this government, in previous\n               bills, that they want more control. They want more power. Under section 5, the administrator must determine whether an institution is unlikely\n               to damage the reputation of British Columbia. That phrase alone should give this House\n               pause. What does that mean? Who defines reputational harm? What objective standards\n               apply? Reputation is not a measurable metric. It is subjective. It's fluid and politically\n               vulnerable. Let me just explain. Reputation is rooted in public trust, admiration and respect,\n               which are emotional and subjective, making them difficult to reduce to a simple number. Companies often rely on a patchwork of social media sentiment and media mentions,\n               which track what is said rather than measuring the actual impact of those words on\n               business value. There is no single industry-wide standard for measuring trust and\n               credibility, leading to proprietary or inconsistent formulas. Even more troubling is section 5.3, which allows the administrator to Even more troubling is section 5.3, which allows the administrator to consider \"any\n               other factors that the administrator considers relevant.\" That's not oversight. That\n               is open-ended discretion. Under section 8, the administrator may impose, may amend, may remove terms and conditions\n               at any time. Under section 18, they may cancel designation certificates altogether. Section 20. They may seek an injunction where the court is directed to give greater\n               weight to enforcement of the act than to the continuing operation of the institution.\n               Let me read that again. Section 20. They may seek an injunction where the court is\n               directed to give greater weight to the enforcement of the act than to continue the\n               operation of the institution. This is extraordinary language. It tilts the scale of justice before the case is even\n               heard. And what of appeals? Well, under section 21, filing an appeal does not stay the decision.\n               An institution could lose its designation immediately, suffer reputational and financial\n               damage, and only afterward attempt to challenge the decision without suspension of\n               penalty. How often have we seen on the news where there's a false accusation on an individual,\n               it gets into the front page of a paper, everybody reads it, only, \"Oops, we made a\n               mistake.\" The retraction's where? Page 14, bottom right-hand corner, in small print.\n               Once the damage is done, it's irreversible. We must also examine the inspection powers under section 17. Inspectors may enter\n               premises without a warrant during business hours — just think about that for a second\n               — remove records, make audio or video recordings and question individuals. Boy, that\n               sounds like a socialist state. While oversight is necessary, such powers must be balanced with safeguards. The legislation\n               provides credentials, yes, but it provides no meaningful threshold for initiating\n               inspections. And then there's section 31, \"Immunity from legal proceedings.\" This one.... I always\n               find they have to put it in in almost every bill. The administrator and appeal officer\n               are shielded from damages for actions taken under the act unless, and here's the quote,\n               \"Unless bad faith can be proven.\" So \"Oops, we made a mistake.\" But there's no way for you to undo all that unless bad\n               faith can be proven. Think about how difficult it would be for an institution to make\n               sure that they get all the things right together to say: \"You know what? Bad faith\n               can be proven.\" That is so subjective. That's a very high bar. Combined with broad discretion and limited appeal protections, this structural sufficiency\n               weakens institutional recourse. We are told, and I heard it again from the minister,\n               this bill will protect students. But let me ask you a question. Does it also risk\n               destabilizing institutions that serve those very students? That's an honest question\n               that needs answering. Many of our public institutions already operate under rigorous legislative frameworks.\n               Have we exhausted all of that? Is there a measurable that these things were not working?\n               Where are the findings? Where's the report? Let us see it. Private institutions regulated under the Private Training Act already undergo compliance\n               reviews. Institutions authorized under the Degree Authorization Act already face oversight. Why duplicate structures while layering additional administrative authority on top?\n               Why not ensure first that every bit of authority under the policy has been exhausted\n               and there's a report that clearly says, you know what, it was insufficient; we need\n               laws. Furthermore, smaller institutions, particularly those not structured as corporations,\n               given the exclusion of sole proprietorship and partnership, may be disproportionately\n               affected. I can just see a small Furthermore, smaller institutions, particularly those not structured as corporations,\n               given the exclusion of sole proprietorship and partnership, may be disproportionately\n               affected. I can just see a small school in the Interior. They don't have a whole lot\n               of legal beagles running around. So now this is going to put an extra burden on them. Compliance costs, administrative fees, reporting requirements and potential penalties\n               could discourage innovation and specialization in niche programs that international\n               students seek. International education is not a marginal sector. It supports communities from Victoria\n               to Kamloops, from the Lower Mainland to the North. It funds research, sustains local\n               economies and enriches our campuses culturally and intellectually. If regulatory unpredictability\n               enters the equation, institutions may hesitate to expand international offerings and\n               students may choose other jurisdictions. We have seen over the last several years the number of people leaving British Columbia.\n               It's not the seniors that are leaving. It's the 25- to 40-year-olds that are leaving.\n               The brain trust, the trained people, the people that need to be working here in British\n               Columbia.... They're leaving our province. We must also address transparency. The online directory under section 9 allows the\n               publication of information considered, and I quote, \"in the public interest,\" \"including\n               personal information.\" Well, what defines public interest? The NDP's public interest?\n               The Conservatives' public interest? The international students' public interest? What\n               procedure of safeguards protect against reputational harm from premature disclosure?\n               This legislation, though framed as protective, centralizes authority, broadens discretion,\n               narrows appeal protections and weakens institutional certainty. We can and should protect international students from bad actors — 100 percent. We\n               know who they are. Why don't we deal with them? No, no, instead of taking a scalpel\n               and cutting out the sore, we're going to beat it out with a hammer. And it's going\n               to impact every institution. We can and should prevent misleading recruitment practices.\n               Absolutely. We can and should ensure education agents operate ethically. Absolutely.\n               But let us not use a hammer, but a scalpel instead. Remove the bad actors instead\n               of potentially harming every institution. Protection must be balanced with fairness. Oversight must be balanced with accountability\n               of the overseer. Regulations must be precise, not open-ended, especially when it's\n               moving from policy to law. This bill needs clearer definitions, stronger appeal safeguards, objective standards\n               for decision-making and limits on discretionary power. Without these improvements,\n               we risk replacing confidence with uncertainty and substituting partnership with these\n               institutions with control over these institutions. British Columbia's reputation was not built through administrative concentration of\n               power. It was built through excellence, collaboration and institutional integrity.\n               Let us ensure that in seeking to protect that reputation, we do not undermine the\n               very institutions that sustain it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328023","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's always a privilege to stand in this House and represent the constituents of Abbotsford West. I'm honoured to speak to this bill, Bill 7, Post-Secondary International Education\n               (Designated Institutions) Act. Our side of the House absolutely supports efforts that actually create quality degree\n               assurance. And I want to repeat that. This side of the House absolutely ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d5db3891463b0cd984b1fb71279a9ef0e588c94e9375d0f27adc89e31b4ca6e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["554213b3bd50aa9b407def35ec90a0d0290817d0c06d1aefbf40785c9a15922d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f2cbd8ecaa2734e5bdfa478d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328024,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"For those of us who have grandchildren, it makes us realize how quickly time flies.\n               My granddaughter Everlee just turned two today. I just want to say to you: your smile brightens up my day. Have a wonderful birthday.\n               I love you very much and miss you. She lives in Wenatchee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328024","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"For those of us who have grandchildren, it makes us realize how quickly time flies.\n               My granddaughter Everlee just turned two today. I just want to say to you: your smile brightens up my day. Have a wonderful birthday.\n               I love you very much and miss you. She lives in Wenatchee.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68749be2eb65a8413a35f3f05f369ed064514d331f8d749a5ed528ac7890cf2a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55eced12fb4f0f91ab9b45e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328025,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning, we had the 20th anniversary of the MLA prayer breakfast, and we had\n               40-plus MLAs in attendance from across political lines. The speaker's, Dr. Gordon\n               Smith's, message was resilient hope. Let's thank Leading Influence and Jason and Anna, our Leg. chaplains, for hosting\n               such an exceptional event.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328025","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This morning, we had the 20th anniversary of the MLA prayer breakfast, and we had\n               40-plus MLAs in attendance from across political lines. The speaker's, Dr. Gordon\n               Smith's, message was resilient hope. Let's thank Leading Influence and Jason and Anna, our Leg. chaplains, for hosting\n               such an exceptional event.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06a774c7704b9de3dd3b9ad78e41c065379c53999ff51ad49215947836cc592c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73e0f218d06d6dd09a37d268","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360421,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Truth. Well, here's some truth. This government is coming for our homes. The government is doing everything they can to make life less affordable here in B.C.\n               We have heard from strata councils here in Victoria of the NDP PST hikes forcing them\n               to hike-strike strata fees. They're paying $6,000 more due to PST on strata management,\n               on land-line entry They're paying $6,000 more due to PST on strata management, on land-line entry phones,\n               on building security — nickel-and-diming, a death by a thousand cuts. That's the truth. Why is this government making life for B.C. residents living in condos unaffordable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360421","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Truth. Well, here's some truth. This government is coming for our homes. The government is doing everything they can to make life less affordable here in B.C.\n               We have heard from strata councils here in Victoria of the NDP PST hikes forcing them\n               to hike-strike strata fees. They're paying $6,000 more due to PST on strata management,\n               on land-line entry The","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b19672eafa8a5d3e4c5490022e686b0323fd7d62224d70a61209b95fdbe62905"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09c98604f62f44ce64f62746","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360860,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a privilege and an honour to speak in these chambers and also representing\n               Abbotsford West. I rise today to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. I'm sure I'm going to probably repeat things that have already been spoken, but I\n               think it's important that we do. A bill that amends both the Employment Standards\n               Act of British Columbia and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act in British\n               Columbia deserves attention. At its core, labour law should do one thing above all else: protect fairness in the\n               workplace, both for the worker and the employer. Workers deserve to receive the wages\n               they have earned, and the employers deserve a system that is predictable, a system\n               that is transparent and a system that's workable. Healthy workplaces are built on\n               balance, and when balance shifts from one side to the other and it's lost, when either\n               the workers or the employers feel the system is stacked against them, confidence in\n               the system begins to erode. While this bill contains elements that move us in the right direction, it also raises\n               serious questions about fairness, questions about due process, questions about whether\n               the government is providing the resources necessary for the system to function effectively.\n               So before discussing the clauses themselves, we must look at the broader context. This was already mentioned by the speaker before, but I'm going to repeat it. The\n               government's own service plans show that only 32 percent of the employment standards\n               complaints are resolved within 180 days. That's only 32 percent. That means 68 percent\n               do not. That means the majority of workers who file complaints wait longer than six\n               months just to see their cases resolved. Even the government's future target about resolving 80 percent of the complaints within\n               180 days by 2027-28 still means one in five workers could be waiting longer than six\n               months. That is not a system working efficiently. Here is why. Workers who have not been paid their wages often cannot wait a half a\n               year. Rent doesn't wait a half a year. It's due every month. Groceries don't wait\n               for six months. You need groceries almost every day, and you go shopping every week.\n               Child care bills don't wait. At the same time as this, the provincial budget freezes\n               funding for labour programs at $22.3 million for the next three years, which is actually\n               lower than the previous year's estimate. So we have to ask a fundamental question here. How does the government expect the\n               employment standards branch to resolve complaints faster with fewer resources? I'm\n               not a math whiz, but if you have less resources, which means you have less people,\n               you're going to get less productivity. At least that's how my math works. I don't\n               know how their math works I'm not a math whiz, but if you have less resources, which means you have less people,\n               you're going to get less productivity. At least that's how my math works. I don't\n               know how their math works, but that's how my math works. Improving labour standards enforcement requires not just legislative changes. That's\n               the easy part. But it also means people. You need investigators. You need administrative\n               capacity to make those changes meaningful. Without that, legislation risks becoming\n               little more than paperwork. It's easy to make rules and legislation, but you need\n               people to enforce it. And I think sometimes we're really good at making legislation.\n               Here's what we expect from people. Here are the regulations, and this is how we're\n               going to enforce it. But then we don't put the investment on the ground for people\n               to actually enforce it. So then the legislation becomes actually very meaningless. If you ever want to make systemic change.... I was on the school board for 16 years.\n               We knew as a board that unless you had buy-in at the teacher level in the classroom,\n               it really doesn't matter what you do at the board level. You need buy-in at the ground\n               level. Another issue raised that touches on that — repeatedly by employer organization —\n               is the lack of consultation before these changes were introduced. So there's no buy-in.\n               They got no skin in the game. They had no say. Labour policy works best when workers,\n               employers and government all participate in shaping it because then they have buy-in.\n               Then they own the legislation instead of it being imposed on them. Most employers in this province want to follow reasonable rules in a reasonable time.\n               They want clarity. They want fairness. They want to know the policies affecting their\n               businesses are developed with their input. That is not what happened. And when significant\n               policy changes appear without consultation, it undermines the trust process. Why wouldn't\n               you talk to us? Now you're imposing this on us, but you haven't talked to us. That\n               matters because compliance works best when stakeholders believe the rules were developed\n               fairly and without a voice at the table, how can that be fair? And one of the most significant changes in this legislation appears in clause 9, which\n               amends the appeal process under the Employment Standards Act. Under this bill, an\n               employer appealing a determination that requires payment must deposit the full amount\n               owed before the appeal can proceed. The tribunal may allow a smaller amount, but that\n               is at their discretion. Well, I don't think that's going to be likely. Once you have\n               the opportunity to grab a little money, I don't think anybody's going to say: \"Well,\n               let's just grab a little less.\" Let us be clear about what that means in practice. For a large corporation, depositing\n               a disputed amount during an appeal may not be difficult at all because they have a\n               large budget. But for a small business.... Let's say a family restaurant, mom and pop,\n               working hard. Someone's in the kitchen, someone's doling out, and someone's cleaning\n               up. A small construction contractor, where he still puts on the belt and is working\n               every day in the sun and the rain and snow — been there. A local retail shop. This\n               requirement could be extremely challenging to those smaller businesses. Small businesses often operate on tight margins and probably tighter today than ever\n               before. Cash flow can be unpredictable. Especially today, now that we've added some\n               PST requirements onto them, the cost of doing business is getting harder and harder\n               each day. Just trying to stay afloat is what I'm hearing from businesses every day. Requiring the full amount of disputing determinations upfront may effectively eliminate\n               the ability to appeal for some people. And that's not fair. In other words, the appeal\n               process could become inaccessible not because the case lacks merit but because the\n               business simply cannot afford the deposit upfront. I know business owners are probably working. They used to hire staff. This was years\n               ago. And they could manage the organization, manage the restaurant, manage the little\n               shop, the local retail shop or the construction company So how are they going to afford this? Justice should not depend on the size of one's\n               bank account. Appeals exist for a reason: to correct errors fairly. If the cost of\n               accessing an appeal becomes prohibitive we risk undermining the fairness of the system\n               itself. Another major challenge appears in clause 4, which introduces a new complaint resolution\n               process during the investigation. Under this bill, the director may require parties\n               to participate in a complaint resolution process as part of the investigation. You\n               know what, at first glance, mediation or facilitating resolution sounds like a positive\n               step. Resolving disputes early absolutely saves time. It saves money and stress for\n               everyone involved. However, the bill also allows the director to impose this process. Impose it. They\n               don't have a choice. This is the direction you're going. You have no choice. And specify\n               how parties must participate. Here it is again. It's not equal to every size of business. For instance, for large\n               employers with HR departments and legal advisors, this may not present a significant\n               burden at all. But here we are again. Mom-and-pop businesses, the small businesses,\n               the backbone of every community, many of which do not have dedicated HR staff or mandatory\n               mediation. This mediation then becomes an administrative hurdle. Preparing for mediation. Can\n               you imagine a mom and pop trying to run a business, now they're working harder than\n               ever before. Now they've got to create all this paperwork, gather all the documents\n               and navigate a process. All require time and expertise, which they don't have because\n               they can't afford it. The government must ensure that dispute resolution processes\n               are accessible and fair for everyone involved, not just those with legal teams. Another noteworthy change appears in clause 6, which modifies section 78.1. In the\n               previous legislation, it required directors to prepare a written report before making\n               a determination. And what a written report does is it allows everybody to see things\n               ahead of time. You can see everything laid out. You know what is coming. No surprises. Under the new bill, the director may prepare such a report. Now let me ask you something\n               here. If they have less money, less people, less investigators, what do you think\n               they're going to do? They don't have time to write a report. They're going to skip\n               this altogether because they may. So it's no longer mandatory and that's unfair to\n               those who are trying to find resolution. They need it written out in plain English. These changes raise questions about transparency. Written reports provide an opportunity\n               for both parties to understand the reasoning behind the decision. If you want to resolve\n               this and make peace it's got to be written down clearly for everyone to see. They\n               help ensure that determinations are based on clear evidence and analysis. By making the report optional, the legislation potentially reduces the transparency\n               of the process. And that's what this bill does. If decisions are made without detailed\n               written explanations, both workers and employers may find it hard to understand or\n               challenge those decisions. Can you imagine? You don't get a report when they're making the decision. How long\n               before a report comes, if it comes at all? So what are you doing? When the decision\n               comes down, you're writing frantically with all these legal jargons. You don't even\n               know what it says. But if it's written down clearly in a report, you know exactly\n               what it says. You know what exactly you can get clarification on. You can go directly\n               to that report to find out what you're going to oppose, what needs to be challenged.\n               Without that report, you have nothing. Clause 2 removes the requirement that a director attempt to locate an employee for\n               one year before transferring unclaimed wages to the administrator. One year. One year\n               goes pretty quick. We've been here now over one year and that went quick. Is that\n               enough time? Is that enough time? I think the guy that's owed the money definitely thinks it's\n               not enough. The administrator? We could shorten that a little. It depends which end\n               of the stick you're on. The intention here appears to be administrative efficiency,\n               but the removal of a defined waiting period raises questions about how long efforts\n               must be made to locate the worker. Now, I wouldn't think anybody in this House would disagree that workers deserve to\n               receive the wages they've earned. They do — period. I think we would all agree with\n               that. Any changes to the process for handling unclaimed wages should ensure that genuine\n               efforts are made to locate employees before funds are transferred elsewhere. This bill also introduces similar appeal deposit requirements under the Temporary\n               Foreign Worker Protection Act. This is a particularly sensitive area. Temporary foreign\n               workers are among the most vulnerable workers in our labour market. I understand this full well. I come from a city in the country, where we have all\n               kinds of agriculture, in the Fraser Valley. They rely heavily on temporary foreign\n               workers. They're great employees. I have talked to the workers that work there. They\n               come back year after year for 17 years, 20 years, some of them. Some of them have\n               their children coming. That's how solid these relationships are. But we can't say that about everybody. Strong enforcement mechanisms are essential\n               to protect them from exploitation. Totally agree. But again, fairness in enforcement\n               requires transparency and due process. Policies must ensure that legitimate employers\n               can challenge determinations when appropriate while still holding bad actors accountable. I'm seeing this appearing more and more, and the federal government just did this\n               recently. They used a hammer with the international students, punishing every institution\n               across the country, rather than taking a scalpel and dealing with the bad actors and\n               shutting them down. Now every institution has a limited amount of international students.\n               Their budgets are.... Their deficits are running high. They're laying off employees.\n               They're laying off staff. They're closing programs. Less students are able to go to\n               those schools. This does the same thing. It uses a hammer instead of a scalpel. Perhaps the most concerning issue surrounding this bill is the gap between expectations\n               and resources. The government wants complaint resolution times to more than double\n               in speed. If I do the math, it means you need two times of everything. At least that's\n               how it works for me. If I want to get a house built twice as fast, either I have to\n               work twice as long or I need twice the employees to help me build that house twice\n               as fast. Yet the funding allocation to labour programs remains frozen. So the question. How\n               does it magically double? How do the outcomes magically double? If the employment\n               standards branch does not receive additional investigators, if it doesn't receive\n               additional mediators and additional administrative staff, these legislative changes\n               may simply shift the burden rather than solve the problem. The risk is that workers will still wait months for resolution while employers face\n               new procedural requirements. This is not the outcome anybody wants. This does not\n               help anyone. Success in labour policy should not be measured solely by how quickly files are closed.\n               Success should be measured by whether workers actually receive the wages they're owed\n               and whether employers believe the system treats them fairly. It's almost like the housing rented. I'm hearing people don't want to rent their houses\n               anymore because the fairness has shifted to one side. Why would you buy a house to\n               rent it out when the renter has all the rules and the laws going on their side? It's\n               the same here. We need to make sure the employee gets paid and this process is fair\n               for the employer. When those two outcomes align, we achieve what labour law should strive for — balance\n               and healthy workplaces. We need to make sure the employee gets paid. And the employer, this process is fair\n               for them. When those two outcomes align, we achieve what labour law should strive\n               for, balance and healthy workplaces. Second reading debate provides an opportunity for members to raise concerns and ask\n               questions about proposed legislation. In the case of Bill 10, there are several questions\n               that remain unanswered. How will the employment standards branch significantly reduce complaint resolution\n               times without additional funding or staff? I think I've highlighted that very clearly. Two, what consultation occurred with employer groups and small business organizations\n               before these changes were introduced? Is this going to be a surprise to them? They've\n               had a lot of surprises in the last couple of years. I don't think they can handle\n               too many more. Three, how will the government ensure that the appeal deposit requirements do not\n               prevent legitimate appeals from being heard? Five, how will the new complaint resolution process be implemented in a way that is\n               fair and balanced for both workers and employers? These are not partisan questions. I think everybody in this House would want those\n               fairly answered. They are practical questions about how legislation will work in the\n               real world. Bill 10 contains provisions aimed at improving enforcement and dispute resolutions\n               within British Columbia's labour standards system, but legislation alone cannot fix\n               structural problems. Without adequate resources — I've mentioned it before — proper\n               consultation, without talking to the people on the ground and careful attention to\n               fairness for both workers and employers, these changes may create new challenges rather\n               than solving the existing ones. Let's be clear. Workers deserve to be paid what they're owed. Employers deserve a\n               system that is transparent, fair and workable. And this Legislature has the responsibility\n               to ensure that labour laws achieve both. We have serious questions with this bill that we want to open up, unpack and make\n               amendments to, to make it stronger and fairer for both the employee and the employer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360860","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's always a privilege and an honour to speak in these chambers and also representing\n               Abbotsford West. I rise today to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. I'm sure I'm going to probably repeat things that have already been spoken, but I\n               think it's important that we do. A bill that amends both the Employment Standards\n               Act of Briti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b035dad07ba0b5bbf87db781e84fc76cbe6e432d4f2dde23aa1c276bc525cf14"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["689f409590207d0081205495b2b854f22052c2d6f6797cc9950af34039f9351b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34f62040ef45ac17555c2826","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360861,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to choose my words carefully, but I'm extremely proud today to speak in this\n               chamber, not only representing Abbotsford West but, because of this bill, representing every British Columbian. I want to start off, as the last speaker mentioned, with an article by a senior author\n               and pontificator, Vaughn Palmer, in his article of February 27, 2026. The headline\n               states this: \"NDP Set to Weaken B.C.'s FOI Law and Keep Public in the Dark; New Bill\n               Would Give Public Servants More Power to Refuse to Supply Requested Information.\" Now, these aren't my words. In fact, as I googled Bill 9, there was a flood of responses,\n               all across British Columbia, of people who had dire concerns over this bill. It goes\n               on in this article to say: Here's what Vaughn Palmer said: Well, I listened to the member from the Green Party, for Saanich North and the Islands, speak so eloquently, in an hour and a half, of the history of FOI, where it came\n               from, what it represents, the foundation of our FOI, and he scathed this bill. He\n               opposed it strongly, as did most, if not all, the speakers on this side of the House. It was really interesting. When the member for Kelowna-Mission got up, it definitely hit a nerve across the aisle. You have to ask the question:\n               \"I wonder why.\" I reserve the right to continue debate, and I move to adjourn debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360861","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to choose my words carefully, but I'm extremely proud today to speak in this\n               chamber, not only representing Abbotsford West but, because of this bill, representing every British Columbian. I want to start off, as the last speaker mentioned, with an article by a senior author\n               and pontificator, Vaughn Palmer, in his article of February 27, 2026. The headline\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62de231c83ed34e638642092b9f3e197413a2967db12e71cc099405538cd63a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b071199b34ac075105bde034","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360862,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I celebrate an incredible local success story, one that started in Abbotsford\n               with a teenager who simply loved to hit the drums. At just 15 years old, Jared Falk fell in love with music. What began as passion quickly became purpose, and by his\n               early 20s, he was touring, teaching and carving out a path that few would have imagined.\n               What makes Jared's story so extraordinary isn't just his talent. It is his vision,\n               his work ethic and his unwavering belief that music education should be accessible\n               to absolutely everyone. From the early days of breaksticks.com, freedrumlessons.com, to the creation of Drumeo in 2012, Jared and his team built something revolutionary. What started in a small\n               Abbotsford studio has now become a global online powerhouse with over 50,000 active\n               students, over six million followers and a library of lessons featuring some of the\n               greatest drummers in the world. Drumeo didn't just change how people learn drums. It changed the industry entirely.\n               It brought world-class instruction to living rooms everywhere, from beginners picking\n               up sticks for the first time to seasoned musicians looking to sharpen their craft.\n               Through Musora Media, that same spirit has expanded to guitar, piano and vocals, creating an entire community\n               of people who simply want to play music because they love it. What I admire most is that behind all this innovation Jared has kept one thing at\n               the centre: the human connection. Whether it is through live stream, feedback videos,\n               interactive lessons, Drumeo reminds us that learning is most powerful when it feels\n               personal. Jared's journey from duck farming roots to global musician education leader\n               is a reminder to every young person in any community that if you follow your passion,\n               work relentlessly, stay creative and never stop learning, there's no limit to what\n               you can build. Congratulations, CEO of Drumeo. Members, look up Drumeo online for yourself. Thank\n               you, Jared Falk.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360862","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I celebrate an incredible local success story, one that started in Abbotsford\n               with a teenager who simply loved to hit the drums. At just 15 years old, Jared Falk fell in love with music. What began as passion quickly became purpose, and by his\n               early 20s, he was touring, teaching and carving out a path that few would have imagined.\n               What makes Jared","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6aff8a4f46ec0a5e4033e9e3acab8ec07bed1ee7a8e5b2016ea8712c7bcb216c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f66f94477b21ce31f060893f250f06c853acd6ed7aafdea2088d1eb287c6f2e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04242cb30bb2ee090856a6f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360864,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, this is strike three for me. I've had two interruptions on this, speaking to\n               this bill. I hope there won't be any others. I just want to read a quote from Thomas Paine, which states: \"A body of people holding\n               themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody.\" I also have an article here from the United Kingdom, and I just want to read a couple\n               of phrases from this. This was six months old, but they're going through exactly the\n               same tension that we're going through about FOI. Here it states and I quote: \"Labour is facing a backlash over plans to dramatically\n               curb access to government documents under freedom of information rules. The Attorney\n               General, Michelle Rowland, has announced the biggest changes to transparency rules\n               in more than a decade, including new changes and charges for freedom of information\n               requests and government departments and ministers, as well as tougher rules related\n               to cabinet confidentiality.\" We're not the only area going through this, but it's a deep concern. Let's go to clause 21. I think that's where I left off. Clause 21 allows government\n               to charge a fee for copies of records that are available without filing an FOI. Currently\n               proactive disclosures are accessible without a fee. Proactive disclosures should mean\n               open access, not pay-per-view government. This is not administrative housekeeping. It is a new financial barrier, and we know\n               how British Columbians are squeezed financially. Let us not forget that this government\n               already introduced a $10 filing fee in previous amendments. We were told that fee\n               was absolutely necessary, and now we see further expansion of financial barriers. Transparency should not depend on the size of a citizen's wallet. The public already\n               paid for these records through their taxes, thank you very much. Charging again to\n               access them is not modernization. It is monetization of accountability, and I'll repeat\n               that. It is monetization of accountability. Clause 7 introduces new sections in section 16(1) allowing refusal of disclosure of\n               communications from judicial officers about policy, about programs or legislation.\n               That is a significant expansion. Section 16 already protected sensitive intergovernmental\n               and Indigenous negotiations. This goes further, shielding policy communications involving\n               judicial officers. Judicial independence is fundamental. But transparency in executive policy-making\n               is also fundamental. If members of the judiciary are communicating with government\n               about legislation or programs, the public has an interest in understanding the context.\n               This new exemption expands secrecy into a whole new territory. Clauses 8, 9, 11 and 20 establish a power a connected service provider has. This entity\n               may operate centralized digital platforms, facilitate sharing of personal information\n               across ministries, identify program eligibility, share categories of personal data\n               between public bodies. The minister may issue binding directions regarding what data\n               is shared, how much is shared, what source must be used, which categories of a person\n               are affected, all by administrative, mysterious direction. Yes, privacy impact assessments must be shared with the commissioner upon request.\n               But here there's no veto, no mandatory approval, no binding oversight. We are centralizing\n               data authority while weakening statutory guardrails in an age of cyber security risks,\n               of AI analytics, of data breaches. I remember when I worked at the school board, and we were well ahead of the game as\n               far as spending a lot of money on computers and security around our computer systems\n               and our data collection. But we would get hit hundreds, if not thousands, of times\n               a week. I'm sure this provincial government gets that as well. hundreds, if not thousands,\n               of people trying to collect data. And now we're going to be spreading more data around.\n               I think it's going to cause leaks to come out. We're going to have data breaches.\n               We're going to have personal information now come to the public. We've had some in\n               other areas. I think it was one of the drugstores had all their information We've had some in other areas. I think it was one of the drugstores that had all their\n               information leaked. So expanding executive control over data-sharing should come with\n               stronger, not weaker constraints. Clause 15 allows the commissioner to extend review timelines beyond 90 days. Currently\n               there is a hard limit. Applicants already wait nearly a year for responses. Instead\n               of accelerating the reviews, the government is adding flexibility to extend them.\n               Efficiency should mean faster resolution, not more elasticity in delay. Freedom-of-information laws exist because governments do not naturally lean toward\n               transparency. I hadn't watched a lot of debate here in the House prior to becoming\n               an MLA. I saw some things on postings and stuff, and you hear about things. I watched\n               question period once in a while. But transparency from government is lacking. Now we wonder why the public is not trusting us as politicians. I knocked on doors,\n               and people would say: \"You know what? You're all crooks. You're all crooks. I'm not\n               even voting, because it doesn't matter who gets into office. You're all crooks.\" Now we're going to tighten transparency and hope trust builds. It's going to make\n               it harder for us knocking on doors. \"Hi, I'm MLA Neufeld.\" \"Oh, you're one of those\n               people who doesn't like transparency.\" They lean toward control. They lean toward convenience. They lean toward risk management.\n               Strong statutory language counters that instinct. How about if we had clear timelines?\n               Clear timelines, so the people requesting the information know exactly the timelines.\n               Narrow exemptions, not broader exemptions. Narrow the exemptions. Define standards.\n               It would be wonderful to know what we're understanding. Limit discretion. But Bill 9 moves in the opposite direction. They have looser timelines, undefined\n               standards, expanded dismissal categories, new fees, centralized data authority. Individually\n               they may appear incremental. Collectively they represent a philosophical shift, a\n               dangerous philosophical shift. How dangerous? It moves from citizens-first access to institution-first discretion.\n               It moves from transparency to manageability. It moves from accountability to control. People often say that this side of the House is always negative. Here are some solutions\n               for the other side of the House. This is what we think should happen. If government were serious about strengthening this system, it would: One, impose enforceable service standards. Two, fund backlog reduction. Three, narrow exemptions. Four, expand proactive disclosure. Five, strengthen the binding authority of the Information and Privacy Commissioner. Six, limit discretionary refusal powers. Seven, protect access rights from retroactive application. That is modernization. That is reform. That is democratic strengthening. In conclusion, freedom-of-information laws are not technical statutes. They are democratic\n               statutes. They reflect a simple and powerful principle. Government records belong\n               to the people unless there is a compelling reason otherwise. Bill 9 weakens that principle.\n               You may ask how. It expands secrecy. It broadens discretionary refusals. It softens timelines. It introduces\n               new fees. It centralizes personal data authority. It shifts power away from the citizen. Transparency should not be optional. It should not be expensive. It should not be\n               vulnerable to undefined discretion. In a healthy democracy, governments narrow secrecy.\n               They do not codify it. For this reason, I cannot support the bill as it is written. I urge the House to reconsider these amendments we just talked about carefully, clause\n               by clause, before we erode the rights that took decades to build and that British\n               Columbians depend on to hold their government that they elected to account.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360864","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Well, this is strike three for me. I've had two interruptions on this, speaking to\n               this bill. I hope there won't be any others. I just want to read a quote from Thomas Paine, which states: \"A body of people holding\n               themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody.\" I also have an article here from the United Kingdom, and I just want to read a couple","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0d071d9b060450a7645db3eccf063e72351067ded9bd6887db817415498aa84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eabe0342c29f6fdaef6eaeb3c87dc8ec0671fa3060292af2742fe528296e7837"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-783614fe3241d0eba42b4a51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415789,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415789","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["649bc3f69f2e0343b7eee14c61f7428dcba825312232cc46401e72f7efe236ab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6dbfdbdf87efa4b6046fda13","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415790,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a privilege to represent the constituents of Abbotsford West, and it's always an honour as well to rise in this House to speak to issues that\n               impact all British Columbians. I rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act,\n               2026. This is a bill that touches on something deeply important, not only in law but\n               in the daily lives of British Columbians. It is the ability to gather, to worship\n               and to do so in safety and dignity. At its core, this legislation is a response to a troubling reality we've seen played\n               out time and time again. Across our province, and indeed across our country, we have\n               seen an increase of acts of vandalism, harassment, intimidation and targeted disruption\n               directed at religious communities. So these are not abstract concerns. These are real\n               experiences affecting real people, families, seniors and children who simply wish\n               to attend a synagogue, a church, a mosque, a temple, or a gurdwara in peace. So before we look at this legislation, we have to ask ourselves a fundamental question.\n               How did we get here? It just happens that last week, when I was home for the spring\n               break, I sat down with one of the leaders of our Hindu temple. And he explained to\n               me that on a weekly basis — sometimes up to 15 times a month — their temple experiences\n               vandalism, harassment, intimidation, and it's targeted at their members in their temple. So let's peel this back a bit. In Canada and in British Columbia, both governments\n               have allowed our culture and our society to normalize discrimination and racism. And\n               here's how: by not enforcing existing laws. And that is fundamental. Before we create\n               new legislation, do we have laws in place? Are we enforcing those laws? And I would\n               say this is why we need this bill, because we have not been enforcing those laws. So I rise today to speak about something deeply uncomfortable and yet absolutely necessary.\n               The presence and normalization of racism in our culture I rise today to speak about something deeply uncomfortable yet absolutely necessary\n               — the presence and normalization of racism in our culture and how it has quietly and\n               sometimes loudly manifested in our communities, our secondary campuses and even the\n               causes we claim are rooted in justice. Let us begin with what we are seeing here in British Columbia. For over two years\n               now, there have been sustained weekly pro-Palestinian rallies in Victoria, over 126\n               consecutive weeks. These are not isolated gatherings. They are organized. They are\n               persistent and highly visible demonstrations, often marching through downtown and\n               around the Legislature. Police have spent over 10,000 hours managing these events,\n               and now even they are stepping back, acknowledging the strain and scale of these ongoing\n               protests. Across the province, similarly, demonstrations have taken place, from large-scale\n               marches in Vancouver to encampments and rallies on university campuses such as UBC\n               and UVic. These protests are part of a broader global movement calling for a ceasefire,\n               criticizing Israeli government actions and advocating for Palestinian rights. Yet\n               protesters are allowed to yell and chant: \"From the river to the sea.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415790","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's always a privilege to represent the constituents of Abbotsford West, and it's always an honour as well to rise in this House to speak to issues that\n               impact all British Columbians. I rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act,\n               2026. This is a bill that touches on something deeply important, not only in law but\n               in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","label":"Vandalism"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","label":"Vandalism","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2032106a02244853a5994eb5964f4cb1ecd4bdf05bac5dc7468eeb3592b48d7a","f7d060ab25d2acfca3bf7e877b88fd41ad7042b94c0cb712200822d84c5bf6e5","c676a13cb84167f649a95778ffbfd427f95cb0b8b5b42ae539e0466500c7406f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77259a4f5ce7b4de7fc53b88c390d7125345f9afb136668a5ad5e52f8a044f48"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6112fddfcbe5896280a8a5b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415791,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"This coming weekend many British Columbians will be focused on","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415791","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This coming weekend many British Columbians will be focused on","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e152b1c21e73cda474dafc50821ba0ff15dc3ae93e48cfc9727a4d987d88651f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5a915d9bab125fa0651ad16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415792,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, it's a privilege to be here to serve the constituents of Abbotsford West, and I'm honoured to rise to speak to legislation that impacts all of British Columbia. I rise today to speak, with reservation, to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. I really appreciate the lens that the previous speaker brought up, which\n               I think needs to be highlighted here, and that is that different areas of the province\n               have unique challenges with respect to supports, wraparound supports, for these housing units. What I also want to do is start off by talking\n               about the context of which I live in. Supportive housing in the Fraser Valley provides low-income adults experiencing or at risk of homelessness with private, self-contained units and 24-7 on-site support services such as meals, counselling and life skills training. Managed by organizations such as B.C. Housing and local partners, key sites include, in Abbotsford, Hearthstone Place, an 18-24 month program providing 24-7 on-site supports. The second one is Riverside Road, but it's up-and-coming: 63 new supportive housing near Cole-Starnes residence, focused on Indigenous programming. But there was, on Riverside Road, a 40-bed temporary shelter right in my neighbourhood. So if you can picture this, I would drive out of my driveway, turn right on King Road, go down a windy road, and head to Riverside. Right at the corner of Riverside, there's this 40-unit\n               temporary housing. You turn left and you go right under Highway 1. And every day — sometimes at 6:30 in the morning, 7 o'clock in the morning — I'd be\n               heading off to my construction job. And then at about 4:30, 5 o'clock, I'd be driving\n               right back to that same location. And here's some of the things that I noticed, just\n               keeping an eye on this 40-unit temporary housing unit. Cars were parked there. Not of people who resided there, but they were offering their\n               goods to the people living inside the units. Drugs. I saw open drug use. I saw violent\n               and aggressive behaviour on a regular basis. Now, I didn't witness half of it because\n               I was only driving by, but I know there were many visits by the police, by the ambulance\n               and by city staff on a regular basis. We also have, in our city, SARA for Women We also have, in our city, SARA for Women. It's also another supportive service. It\n               offers transition housing in Abbotsford for women and children escaping violence or\n               at risk of homelessness — a great facility. I visited there. I had an event there\n               and talked to the ladies there. It's a really great, safe environment. Nobody knows\n               that they're there. It's kind of quiet, stuck in right by a school, and it works for\n               them. Then we also have Lookout Housing and Health Society, which operates shelters on Pauline\n               Street in our region, 24-7 care. Now, what are some of the concerns in the Fraser Valley of supportive housing? These\n               are some of the key ones. It's not exhaustive. The first and foremost is safety and\n               crime. It doesn't take long to go through the Abbotsford newspaper or to watch the news on\n               Global or CTV to find a story relating to some sort of supporting housing unit in\n               our province and even in our city of Abbotsford. Those safety of crime causes neighbourhoods\n               to push back. When proposed projects come into our area, they face questions and opposition\n               and concerns about proximity to schools, secondhand fentanyl smoke and fire risks.\n               Those are the main things that keep coming up in the Fraser Valley when it comes to\n               supporting houses. Another one is operational challenges, increased reports of crime in surrounding areas.\n               I was in my house, oh, 10, 11 o'clock at night, just before bedtime. I was just watching\n               the highlights of the Blue Jays. I got a window looking out my back here, and there's\n               this guy trucking off with my propane tank. So I go out and I say: \"Hey, what's happening?\"\n               He looks at me, puts it down and just walks right on by. Anyways, I'm not sure where\n               he was from, but I would imagine.... Anyways, reports of crimes in surrounding areas where supportive housing is located,\n               alongside the need for specialized care for residents with severe mental health and\n               addiction challenges.... Again, I witnessed that firsthand just in my neighbourhood. Let me begin by acknowledging what this government will say in defence of this legislation.\n               They will say it's about safety, and the reason is because most of these facilities\n               have safety concerns. They will say it's about protecting residents of supporting\n               housing from dangerous neighbours. They will invoke images of weapons, fires and chaos\n               in single-room occupancy and say that this bill is the solution British Columbians\n               have been waiting for. Those problems that they're speaking about are real. Anyone who has spent time in\n               supportive housing communities or who has spoken to front-line workers, who has read\n               the incident reports from housing providers across this province, knows that the status\n               quo is not working. When I went on my wonderful ride-along with the APD, we made several stops at these\n               locations in my city. So I saw firsthand what these officers were dealing with just\n               in one shift. You can imagine, now, in a week how many times they go by, in a month\n               and in a year, how much resources are spent. People living in supportive housing do deserve safety, they do deserve dignity, and\n               they deserve a stable place to call home. But the community around these units does\n               as well. The test of this legislation is not whether it identifies real problems. The test\n               is whether it actually solves them and whether it does so without creating new ones.\n               I would say that on both counts, Bill 11 fails on that count. This bill talks tough on safety while ignoring the conditions that make supportive\n               housing unsafe in the first place. It dramatically expands the power of cabinet and operators to evict, to restrict and\n               to seize while doing almost nothing to address the staffing shortages, the drug crisis,\n               the fire risks and the lack of mental health support that makes supportive housing\n               a daily emergency for the people who live and work there, for the community around\n               them and for the first responders. This is a bill about looking like you are doing something. It is not a bill about\n               actually doing the work that's required. This is a bill about looking like you are doing something. It is not a bill about\n               actually doing the work that's required. So before we get to the specific provisions,\n               we need to talk about the structure of this bill because the structure itself is the\n               problem. Bill 11 is not — and I am going to repeat — is not in any meaningful sense a complete\n               piece of legislation. I cannot emphasize that enough, and here's the proof. It is\n               an authorization for cabinet to write the legislation. When? Later — in private, without\n               debate, without amendment, without the scrutiny of this House. That is not democratic process, and the word \"democratic\" is in their party name. Look at how many times this bill defers\n               substance to regulation. Section 4.2, what qualifies as a supportive housing rental unit? The answer? It's subject to prescribed criteria not yet created. Section 4.3, whether landlords can unilaterally amend tenancy agreements is subject\n               to regulation deferred sometime in the future. Section 4.4, whether landlords can seize tenant property is subject to regulation\n               sometime in the future. Trust us, we'll get it right. Section 4.5, when landlords can enter units is subject to regulation. Who knows when,\n               who knows what. Section 4.6, when landlords can restrict tenants from accessing their own homes is\n               subject to regulation. No one will be able to question or debate this now or in the\n               future. Section 4.8, what constitutes a weapon is subject to regulation not yet clarified. Section 4.9, what compensation tenants are owed when landlords violate their rights\n               is subject to regulation. This bill is woefully incomplete. It is not ready for debate because what are we debating?\n               We're debating something in the future. The expansion of regulation-making authority is perhaps the most consequential clause\n               in this entire bill, and it has received almost no public notification. It authorizes\n               cabinet to make different regulations for different classes of persons, for different\n               classes of residential property and for different circumstances or purposes. This\n               is an extraordinary grant of executive authority. When we pass legislation in this chamber, we are accountable to the people of British\n               Columbia for what we can enact. Considering that side of the House, I need just to\n               remind them that this is not democracy. This is not how democratic processes are made.\n               It's in fact the opposite. When cabinet writes legislation, that accountability disappears. The public cannot\n               amend the regulation. The opposition cannot propose changes. This Legislature cannot\n               reject it. This isn't democracy. We need to make sure in a democratic process that the public can see it, that the\n               opposition can see it and that we can debate it in this House. The government has\n               chosen to put the most important decisions — what can be seized from tenants' homes,\n               when a tenant can be locked out, what counts as a weapon, how much landlords owe for\n               violating rights — not in this bill, but in regulations that have not yet been written. So what are we debating? We're debating a hollow bill, in fact. It cannot be debated\n               here, and the public has no meaningful ability to shape it. That is not good governance.\n               It's actually a blank cheque that says, \"Trust us. Trust us, we'll get it right.\" Let us turn to the eviction provisions because this is where the real-world consequences\n               of this bill becomes most clear. Clause 15 and 16 significantly expand the grounds\n               for ending tenancy. Under the existing act that we have now, conduct that could trigger\n               eviction is tied to the tenant. This new bill expands those grounds to include the\n               conduct of occupants and persons permitted on the property. In other words, individuals\n               the Under the existing act that we have now, conduct that could trigger eviction is tied\n               to the tenant. This new bill expands those grounds to include the conduct of occupants\n               and persons permitted on the property. In other words, individuals the tenant did\n               not necessarily invite, did not necessarily know and may not have been able to control\n               could trigger an eviction. Think about what that means in the context of supportive housing. A resident whose\n               neighbour enters their unit uninvited and causes a disturbance. I'm sure this happens\n               on a regular basis. Or a resident whose caseworker brings in a colleague who behaves\n               inappropriately. Or a resident whose family member, during a visit, gets into a conflict\n               with another resident. Under this bill, the resident's tenancy can be terminated for the actions of \"who\n               are not them.\" That is profound departure from the basic principle that we are responsible\n               for our own conduct. It will fall disproportionately on the most vulnerable people\n               in the province. People with complex mental health needs. People in recovery. People\n               who have already experienced homelessness and for whom losing housing is not just\n               an inconvenience; it could be potentially fatal. And when we evict them, where do they go? As the previous speaker said, in some of\n               these remote communities, there's no place for them to go except on the streets, in\n               a park. Then there's section 4.8, the weapons eviction provision. I'm not going to stand here\n               and defend weapons in supportive housing. No one should be at risk from a neighbour\n               with a knife, a machete or a firearm. That is not a debatable position. But section\n               4.8 creates an expediated pathway for eviction tied to the possession of a weapon\n               or — and here's the key one — the observation of a weapon in plain view in a unit.\n               It doesn't say whose observation. It raises more questions than it answers. What is the definition of a weapon? The\n               bill does not say. That definition is left entirely to cabinet by regulations. When?\n               Well, nothing that we can debate here today. It's going to come sometime in the future.\n               Does it include a kitchen knife, a baseball bat, a hunting knife owned by someone\n               who has never threatened anyone? We genuinely do not know because the government has\n               chosen not to tell us. That's why I say Bill 11 is incomplete. Some more questions. Who assesses whether a weapon has been observed in plain view?\n               A housing worker who entered the unit for inspection, an operator, an employee who\n               may not have training in crisis intervention, de-escalation or safety assessment?\n               Think about that. If someone is brandishing a weapon and you're an operator or an\n               employee of an operator, and like my previous speaker said, you're the only one in\n               the building, and in some cases the police are far, far away, what are you going to\n               do? Put your life in danger? I don't know. What happens when the person who possesses the weapon is armed and in crisis at the\n               moment the eviction is served? The government left police, fire and paramedics out\n               of the room when they wrote this bill. It does not address who responds when a tenant\n               is armed and dangerous. It does not establish protocols for front-line housing workers\n               to safely navigate those situations. And it creates new eviction pathways but does\n               not build the safety infrastructure to support the people who have to carry it out. Again, I've said this before, we can write legislation in this building, but we've\n               got to look at that legislation. How is it going to be fulfilled on the ground, on\n               the front lines? Housing workers are being put at risk. Without clear rules, without\n               clear authority and without clear protection, this is not tough on safety. That is\n               offloading risk onto the most underpaid, under-resourced workers in our social system. Section 4.6 may be the most troubling provision in this entire bill. It allows cabinet\n               to create exceptions permitting landlords to restrict tenant access to residential\n               property in prescribed circumstances, and it permits the interim orders to be made\n               without notice. Let us be clear about what this means in practice. On the ground, under this provision,\n               a person living in supportive housing, a person who is likely dealing with mental\n               illness, possibly addiction and mental illness, trauma and housing instability, can\n               be locked out of their home, potentially with You know, I think Swiss cheese has less holes in it than this bill. There's no guarantee\n               to right to notice. There is no guarantee to right of hearing before the order takes\n               effect. There's no guaranteed timeline for challenging the restriction. These are\n               all left to regulation, but regulations that do not yet exist. Again, this bill is\n               woefully incomplete. Locking a person in crisis out of their home does not make them safer. I want to repeat\n               that. Locking a person in crisis out of their home does not make them safer. It does\n               not make their neighbourhood safer. It puts vulnerable people on the streets. We have heard from businesses, we have heard from neighbourhoods that see this day\n               in, day out, and now we're going to kick them out of their home when they're aggravated,\n               when they're angry. Now we're going to kick them onto the streets in front of businesses\n               in neighbourhoods, potentially in withdrawal, potentially in mental health crisis,\n               potentially in danger. Now we're endangering everyone they come in contact with. They're\n               left on the street while their belongings remain inside, their legal status in limbo. This government prides itself on details. It prides itself on making evidence-based\n               decisions. Well, let's look at the research. The research on this is not ambiguous.\n               Temporary evictions, temporary lockouts and temporary displacement in supportive housing\n               populations consistently lead to worse outcomes. It leads to more hospitalization,\n               more emergency room visits and more deaths, never mind the havoc it creates in the\n               surrounding neighbourhood and the possible danger it puts on to first responders. The government is proposing a tool that, the evidence tells us, will inflame conflict,\n               not resolve it. Section 4.4 allows cabinet to create exceptions to the existing protection\n               preventing landlords from seizing or interfering with tenant property. The government has given the example of butane torches, fire hazards that pose genuine\n               risks in supportive housing buildings. Again, no one disputes that fire safety is\n               important. It is. Buildings with shared kitchens and common areas and residents who\n               smoke present real fire risks, and there are legitimate conversations to be had about\n               how to manage those risks. But the provision is not limiting butane torches. It grants cabinet the authority to prescribe the classes of property that can be seized,\n               without defining those classes, without establishing independent oversight, without\n               guaranteeing that tenants have a meaningful way to challenge a seizure, and without\n               clarity on what happens to seized property afterwards. A person's belongings, especially\n               someone that is at the lower end of the economic ladder, however humble.... I remember I worked with a young.... Not a young man — well he was younger than me.\n               His name was Bruce, a beautiful man. He was not a drug user. He's got OCD, and he\n               can't even walk down a sidewalk where there are cracks without doing a massive, massive\n               dance back and forth. He had trouble, but he couldn't stay in a closed building. He had an apartment, but it was full of junk. He had three storage units that were\n               full of junk, and he lived out in the open. I'm telling you. You would look at his\n               cart every day, and it's junk, but to him, this cup that he found had meaning for\n               him. That piece of newspaper with the word had meaning for him. These are all of his\n               humble belongings. They're amongst the most important things these people own. In\n               supportive housing, those belongings may represent everything a person has left after\n               losing their home, after losing their family, after losing their independence. The right to security of property is not a luxury right. It is a foundational one,\n               as humble as those belongings are. This bill proposes to carve exceptions into that\n               right and fill in the details later. That concerns me. Through regulation at the government's\n               discretion This bill proposes to carve exceptions into that right and fill in the details later.\n               That concerns me. Through regulation, at the government's discretion. Again, in secrecy,\n               behind closed doors, with no opportunity for debate. That is not an acceptable approach. But you know what? We see this again and again with this government. Legislation that\n               is not complete, that will be done later by cabinet: \"Trust us.\" For all that this bill does, there's actually a longer list of the things it refuses\n               to do. It does not address staffing. Supportive housing across British Columbia is\n               chronically understaffed. Workers are stretched thin, covering a multitude of floors,\n               managing complex caseloads and, here's the key one, often alone on overnight shifts.\n               I would venture to say that most of the problems happen in the evening. You cannot create a safe, supportive housing environment without adequate staffing.\n               This bill does not add a single worker nor fund a single position nor set a single\n               staffing standard. Another thing this is woefully short on is that it does not address drugs. Again,\n               from my city, there was an announcement of supportive housing units. And the community of Abbotsford is citing concerns about its location. The project, located on Martin Street, on B.C. Ministry of Transportation land, across\n               from Abbotsford Traditional School. Actually, it's 80 metres from a middle school.\n               Middle-school age — what would that be, 12? 12-year-olds within 80 metres. The most disturbing thing about this is that until we as MLAs pressed on that, they\n               kept the consumption room out of any announcement. Until we dug and said: \"Is there\n               going to be consumption space, drug use, on this site?\" Only after we pushed did that\n               come out. So there's a trust issue. This bill does not address drug issues. The toxic drug supply crisis is killing people\n               in supportive housing every day. Fentanyl, methamphetamine and benzodiazepines are\n               driving the violence, the chaos and the instability that this bill purports to address\n               — along with mental health illness. You take drugs and mental health, and I'm telling\n               you.... The bill does not create a single new harm reduction service, not one single treatment\n               bed or a crisis-response protocol. If you want safer supportive housing, you have\n               to address the drug crisis inside those buildings. This bill does not. Another thing this bill does not do.... This bill does not address fire safety. Building after building in British Columbia's supportive housing stock is unsafe.\n               They're usually older buildings with old electrical systems, inadequate sprinkler\n               infrastructure, insufficient fire exits and overcrowding. These are conditions that\n               kill people. This bill does not fund a single fire safety upgrade or mandate a single inspection\n               standard or create a single accountability mechanism for operators who run these buildings.\n               It also does not address mental health supports. It creates more tools to remove people\n               from housing and it creates no tools to help them stay there. The government has chosen to address the symptoms of underfunding, understaffing,\n               and under-support systems by expanding the authority to punish the people that the\n               system has failed. That is not housing strategy; that is abdication. I want to return briefly to clause 18 in the few minutes I have left because its implications\n               extend far beyond supportive housing. This clause expands regulation-making authority\n               under section 97 to include transitional housing definitions, inspection procedures,\n               compensation provisions and, most broadly, the authority to make different regulations\n               for different classes of persons, property, circumstances or purposes. That is a sweeping grant of authority. It means that government can, through regulation\n               alone, create entirely different legal frameworks for different categories of tenants,\n               different types of housing or different geographical areas without returning to this\n               Legislature, with no accountability and with no open debate. That concern is not hypothetical.\n               We've seen this before in other It means that government can, through regulation alone, create entirely different\n               legal frameworks for different categories of tenants, different types of housing or\n               different geographical areas without returning to this Legislature — for no accountability,\n               for no open debate. That concern is not hypothetical. We have seen this before in other jurisdictions and other policy areas: how broad\n               regulation-making authority gradually becomes the instrument through which government\n               reshapes policy without accountability. The more we move substantive decisions-making\n               from the Legislature, the more we hollow out the democratic function of this institution.\n               This chamber exists precisely to provide that check. Bill 11 is an extensive reliance\n               on cabinet regulation that deliberately avoids democracy. In conclusion, supportive housing in British Columbia is in crisis. The people who\n               live in it deserve better. The workers who staff it deserve better. The communities\n               that are surrounding it deserve better. The families of people in supportive housing\n               who lie awake at night wondering whether their loved one is safe deserve better. But better does not come from legislation. The expansion of eviction grounds without\n               expanding supports, the authorization of property seizure without defining what can\n               be seized, which permits lockouts without guaranteeing due process and which has cabinet's\n               sweeping regulatory authority to fill in every important detail.... When? Later. In\n               private. Without debate. We believe in safe housing. We believe in adequate staffing and treatment and clear,\n               fair rules that protect both tenants and workers. We believe that people who live\n               in supportive housing are not problems to be managed. They are people who have been\n               failed by the system, and Bill 11 does not solve that. We will fight for amendments that find the terms that government has deliberately\n               left undefined. We will advocate for workers and tenants who bear the consequence\n               of this legislation, and we will continue to demand a government that measures success\n               not by the number of evictions it enables but by the number of people it actually\n               helps rebuild their lives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415792","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Again, it's a privilege to be here to serve the constituents of Abbotsford West, and I'm honoured to rise to speak to legislation that impacts all of British Columbia. I rise today to speak, with reservation, to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. I really appreciate the lens that the previous speaker brought up, which\n               I think needs to be highlighted","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bab2a9916dc13b3d64c7b47aa8939adce5dc7c2cf0ab74bb4912d3280ce1efa6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92c5c96e84e35175337565492101b0212342d75db1bc5614bed3d1a3f717c4a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2da73ec2745008e30713f35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721582,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce Paulina Chow-White. She's not in the chamber. She's somewhere on the precinct, probably having meetings\n               all afternoon. She's the CEO of the Terry Fox humanitarian award program. We had an inspiring discussion with our caucus","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721582","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce Paulina Chow-White. She's not in the chamber. She's somewhere on the precinct, probably having meetings\n               all afternoon. She's the CEO of the Terry Fox humanitarian award program. We had an inspiring discussion with our caucus","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["131ecb967a09d41905b13c52888fa26ad4442827240846fa501b2f662174c237"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7242372e7eaecab7a411cbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721584,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It gives me no pleasure to ask this question in the House today. I've had numerous\n               discussions with the minister over the last two months, to no avail. A former elementary school principal in Abbotsford who's on disability is now caring\n               for her husband after he suffered a permanent injury at the Abbotsford Regional Hospital.\n               We all know front-line nurses and staff are overworked. Our hospitals are understaffed.\n               But while under hospital care, he became dizzy. He asked for assistance to go to the\n               bathroom. No one came. He went alone. He passed out, struck his head, and his life\n               changed forever. A judge acknowledged this life-altering injury happened at the hospital, and now Fraser\n               Health's lawyers are demanding over $200,000 — court costs — from this disabled couple,\n               requiring them to sell their home. This is gut-wrenching. It is unjust. Does the minister think it is acceptable for Fraser Health to force a disabled couple\n               to sell their home to pay for an injury that happened in one of the hospitals under\n               her watch?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721584","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It gives me no pleasure to ask this question in the House today. I've had numerous\n               discussions with the minister over the last two months, to no avail. A former elementary school principal in Abbotsford who's on disability is now caring\n               for her husband after he suffered a permanent injury at the Abbotsford Regional Hospital.\n               We all know front-line nurse","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72d378f3c8b096946cf56affe2e168de21ec5f198f607764824b0310b90243ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d25008eee13857ea0e667d8103a4a5f892572ce62546d729b25128cc09c05f5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bb5ebd128a3d15a5e6ae4bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729337,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"There was an old farmer in the Fraser Valley who once told his son-in-law that his\n               idea was the stupidest thing he had ever heard. Cut patterns in a cornfield and then\n               charge people to walk around in it? Ridiculous. Then John Bruinsma showed up every weekend until the day he died. That's how, in 1999, the Bruinsma\n               farmhouse, Green Acres, became Canada's first corn maze. That's the thing about a good idea. Sometimes it takes someone else living it out\n               before you can see it. Sometimes faith isn't something you have at the beginning.\n               It's something you find in the middle of the rows. What started as one article, one\n               phone call, one leap into the unknown became Canada's first corn maze and eventually\n               something much larger — a place where strangers become regulars, regulars become friends\n               and friends become family. Strangers were just someone they hadn't known long enough\n               yet. Three sisters, Danielle, Vanessa and Mariah, who learned hospitality before they learned\n               long division, who never asked for this life but chose it anyway, not because it was\n               easy but because some things are worth holding onto, such as the land, the table that\n               always has room and the idea that work we do matters, not just to our own families\n               but to everyone who walks through the gate. We have watched this family work, I mean, really work, the kind that doesn't stop\n               when the lights go down. We have seen what it costs them and what it gives back. We\n               have watched them choose again and again to keep the table long and the gate open. What they've built here isn't just a farm. Green Acres is a place where people make\n               memories they'll carry with them for the rest of their lives. This is for you, Bruinsmas, for the mud on the floors, the SOS techs, the 3 a.m. drainage\n               projects and every single person you've ever pulled up a chair for. You made room\n               for us all, and we're better for it. Wherever you are today This is for you, Bruinsmas, for the mud on the floors, the SOS techs, the 3 a.m. drainage\n               projects, and every single person you've ever pulled up a chair for. You made room\n               for us all, and we're better for it. So wherever you are today, whatever field you're\n               standing in, whatever idea sounds a little too strange to say out loud, remember this.\n               The best things rarely make sense at first. They just need someone willing to start\n               cutting. Thank you Green Acres for the memories. Thank you Bruinsma family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729337","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There was an old farmer in the Fraser Valley who once told his son-in-law that his\n               idea was the stupidest thing he had ever heard. Cut patterns in a cornfield and then\n               charge people to walk around in it? Ridiculous. Then John Bruinsma showed up every weekend until the day he died. That's how, in 1999, the Bruinsma\n               farmhouse, Green Acres, became Canada's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034900","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drainage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034900","label":"Drainage","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57801e1b11f248c989280392468cea3386ea64a0c2498895b15941ccf0fa4965"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a26ba66f803072c45ee5c706a5742dde7c96f5764b18d93a8a3c710ceee94c51"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-444f01cf69945429dd8cd828","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729339,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's not often you get an email from a grade 7 student, which means that my wife is\n               not my only fan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729339","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not often you get an email from a grade 7 student, which means that my wife is\n               not my only fan.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Developing countries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:248929","label":"Developing countries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8a3f031bedd95481fd5a36be0c3f9f743258547d984a4f30f665a7bd82ffb1f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29c90bb9761f66834b6c1fef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729342,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"We had a great meeting with members from the Fairleigh Dickinson University of Vancouver\n               here today. They met with both sides of the aisle. Tonight there's a reception at\n               the Union Club at seven o'clock. I'd just like to make them feel welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729342","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We had a great meeting with members from the Fairleigh Dickinson University of Vancouver\n               here today. They met with both sides of the aisle. Tonight there's a reception at\n               the Union Club at seven o'clock. I'd just like to make them feel welcome here today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["764abc9165cee2a379c81a84a9d0de596e27266e5caa26735f9a9876605a48e2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfe1bbe30f36ed3f66ed3832","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752306,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, this is not a one-off. On February 9, 2023, James Zimmer took his own life within\n               hours of being discharged from Royal Columbian Hospital here in Victoria. His sister, who had been supporting her brother during his mental health challenges,\n               had been receiving updates from doctors on a regular basis. However, she was not informed\n               of his release and only learned he was out of care when police showed up at his door\n               to tell her that her brother had taken his own life. Does the minister think it's acceptable for family members to find out their loved\n               ones were discharged from care only after they've taken their own life?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752306","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, this is not a one-off. On February 9, 2023, James Zimmer took his own life within\n               hours of being discharged from Royal Columbian Hospital here in Victoria. His sister, who had been supporting her brother during his mental health challenges,\n               had been receiving updates from doctors on a regular basis. However, she was not informed\n               of his release and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa920b742ca191767899ef62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752307,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a privilege to rise in this house to speak. I never take that for granted.\n               Not only do I represent the citizens of Abbotsford but, I believe, in many ways, the\n               residents across this province. Please forgive me ahead of time. I've got a head cold, so I'll be coughing and gagging\n               in between. I rise today to speak to the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled Freedom\n               of Information Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the\n               word \"now\" and substituting \"six months hence.\" Therefore, it's called the \"hoist.\" The need to pause Bill 9 introduced by the opposition is paramount to getting this\n               cornerstone legislation to our democracy right. There's a saying, a true saying, that\n               said there's nothing new under the sun. It's very interesting that on the other side\n               of the planet, in Australia, they went through the same process here in March. I just want to read this article for you. It's a short couple of brief notes from\n               it. \"A win for democracy: Labor abandons freedom of information laws change that would\n               have reduced transparency. The Labor government has dumped its controversial changes\n               to the freedom of information request system, which would have imposed new fees and\n               further reduced transparency.\" As we are going through this process, so is the government in Australia going through\n               the same process. But they saw the light of day. They saw the light of day, and they\n               pulled it before we got to this point where we're asking to delay it for six months\n               hence. \"The government's changes to the FOI system would have imposed tighter rules\n               on accessing information, including new grounds to refuse requests based on cabinet\n               confidentiality\" — sounds familiar — \"banning anonymous requests\" — sounds familiar\n               — and \"rules to deter what the government characterized as vexatious and frivolous\n               requests.\" That is why we need to delay implementation of Bill 9 as it stands in order to get\n               it right this time around, because the bill amends one of the most important statutes\n               in our province. The act is not administrative housekeeping, as what has been stated.\n               It is not procedural fine print. It is not bureaucratic technicality. The reason a six-month hence is required because this bill is the backbone of government\n               transparency and the legal guardian of citizens' privacy rights in British Columbia.\n               It is the mechanism by which journalists uncover waste. That's why we need six months\n               to look at and say: \"Is this the right bill? Is this going to increase transparency,\n               or is this going to limit transparency?\" It is the tool citizens use to hold government to account. We need a delay to look\n               at this. It is the safeguard that ensures personal information is not casually collected,\n               casually shared or casually exposed. Today, Bill 9 weakens both transparency and privacy\n               at the very same time, and that is precisely why a six-month extension would allow\n               for a more careful, responsible approach to getting this legislation right. We need a pause of this bill as it stands today because it is not modernization. It\n               is a shift, a complete shift, a lane change in power. Well, another reason for six months hence is because the B.C. Freedom of Information\n               and Privacy Association has sent the alarm, and it's reached deaf ears on the other\n               side. We want to make sure that the delay of six months minimum would allow these people\n               who understand freedom of information.... Many of these people who crafted the original\n               document, have deep concerns. Here's one. They're warning that weakens access rights\n               at a time when government has failed to meaningfully implement its own recordkeeping\n               law, and that fails to address need for reforms to the act. That is why six months hence is absolutely necessary. That is why six months hence is absolutely necessary. We need to look at those people\n               and talk to those people who understand freedom of information and say: the amendments,\n               do they go far enough? Are the amendments too restrictive? How does this change the\n               intent of the original document to the point where it's ineffective? Number 2, the government has framed the bill as modernization effort to improve digital\n               service delivery. However, FIPPA notes that the real source of FOI delays is upstream.\n               It's inconsistent record creation. So it's basically saying here that the amendments\n               put forth in Bill 9 actually aren't the issue. The issue is record creation, record\n               classification, record retention and digitization practices across the ministries.\n               We need to delay this bill in order to review the government's handling of this file\n               in its entirety. They also say.... \"Access delays are often a symptom of recordkeeping failure,\" said\n               FIPPA Executive Director Jason Woywada. We cannot fix the system's information management problems by weakening public access\n               to rights. Another reason for pausing this bill. And we're not talking for an infinite amount of time. It's six months. Would it kill\n               the bill? We'll see. There are also some glaring absences in Bill 9 that is deeply\n               flawed because of what it does not include. FIPPA says the bill ignores the work of\n               the last special legislative committee that reviewed FIPPA back in 2022. That is four\n               years ago. The report entitled FIPPA for the Future listed 34 recommendations. So, the reason for a six-month hence is to look at how\n               many of these 34 recommendations were actually thought through or implemented in this\n               bill. We have rushed this through. We need to slow it down. We need to look at it\n               again. To improve and modernize access to information and privacy rules in British\n               Columbia public sector, Bill 9 represents a failure to act on these recommendations.\n               That's what FIPPA says. So we must delay to look at how the implementation of these\n               34 recommendations would either strengthen or weaken this legislation. They also bring forward.... \"This is the worst than missing the opportunity,\" said FIPPA\n               President Mike Larsen. It reflects a pattern of successive governments receiving clear\n               advice on gaps in the act and then completely disregarding this guidance. Six months\n               hence allows us to go back to the drawing table and say to these people: \"Okay, what\n               are we missing? How are we missing it? What would make it clearer? What would make\n               it better?\" I think here is a comment they make, which is kind of alarming. Why after the Legislature\n               wood splitter scandal and the subsequent joint recommendations by B.C. independent\n               regulators does Bill 9 not extend FIPPA to cover the administrative offices of the\n               Legislative Assembly? We need to delay in order to ask these questions to review this\n               document so it makes it stronger.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752307","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's always a privilege to rise in this house to speak. I never take that for granted.\n               Not only do I represent the citizens of Abbotsford but, I believe, in many ways, the\n               residents across this province. Please forgive me ahead of time. I've got a head cold, so I'll be coughing and gagging\n               in between. I rise today to speak to the motion for second readi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034677","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Respiratory diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034677","label":"Respiratory diseases","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f4364d43b42aaec691426593b6909bbff1582536fb5ef270e85839a27c3e6a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a7a9c68c83223a1904d11d7913880e0f5713d5de52b17e1be8c1bf15fff49e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40e947998d39a49eeadfd5dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752308,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is always good to have somebody from the city of the country, Abbotsford, to come\n               visit. Please join me in welcoming Warren to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752308","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is always good to have somebody from the city of the country, Abbotsford, to come\n               visit. Please join me in welcoming Warren to the House.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c12bbdd1595a4971a108290fff82fd5242f72ebae2906e9529e10cf4ed67bdab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a15f9598bf478acfddf2031b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017497,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a privilege for me to welcome to the Legislature my wife's close relatives,\n               Rudy and Donna Raby. Rudy was a long-time, well-regarded educator for 33 years at\n               the École Dr. Charles Best Secondary School in Coquitlam, and he's most profoundly grateful\n               he never had me in his class. Would the House make Rudy and Donna feel welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017497","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's a privilege for me to welcome to the Legislature my wife's close relatives,\n               Rudy and Donna Raby. Rudy was a long-time, well-regarded educator for 33 years at\n               the École Dr. Charles Best Secondary School in Coquitlam, and he's most profoundly grateful\n               he never had me in his class. Would the House make Rudy and Donna feel welcome?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","label":"Family law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79988247b0f33928ef1fd354cd7ee81646791bb45ae423095ca468839d65a155"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-255e39b80b1979bab8f9c4b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036538,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak about Motion M207 and to raise what I believe is a fundamental\n               issue of fairness, of consistency and common sense in the government's approach to\n               liquor policy in British Columbia. That is why removing the word \"independent\" levels\n               the playing field for all movie theatres across British Columbia. Why not let the\n               owners decide whether they want to serve liquor or not in their theatres instead of\n               government restricting certain theatres from doing it? This bill proposes allowing liquor services during mixed-age movie screening for small\n               and independent theatres. While supporters of the bill argue this is about helping\n               local cinemas survive, the legislation creates more questions than answers. The central\n               issue is this. If responsible liquor service during mixed-age movie screenings is\n               appropriate public policy, then why would the government not apply it to small and\n               independent theatres instead of all theatres? Why restrict it? Why create another arbitrary distinction? Why would some theatres\n               be trusted while others are restricted under the exact same circumstances? That's\n               why removing the word \"independent\" is clear, and it is fair. Either adults can responsibly consume alcohol while attending a movie with minors\n               present under regulated provincial laws or not. The standard should not change based\n               on the size of the building, the number of screens or the business model of the theatre\n               operator. Who decides these distinctions? Public safety rules should be based on behaviour and standards, not on square footage.\n               Yet this bill proposes exactly that. One set of rules for some theatres, another set\n               of rules for others. That is not fairness; that is selective policy-making. That's\n               why removing the word \"independent\" is an important legislative change. We already allow liquor services in countless mixed-age environments across British\n               Columbia. Adults can consume alcohol at restaurants where families dine together.\n               Adults can drink at concerts attended by minors, at sporting events, at community\n               festivals, at bowling alleys, at live theatre productions, at conference centres,\n               at airports. All of those places responsible adults are trusted to consume alcohol\n               under regulated conditions while minors are present. Importantly, those venues are\n               not divided into small or large categories before government decides whether liquor\n               services are acceptable. The rule applies equally. But not to allow small and independent theatres? Why not include all theatres? Removing\n               the word \"independent\" clarifies this inconsistency, so why are movie theatres treated\n               differently? And why does Motion M207 deepen the inconsistency instead of solving\n               it? This bill risks creating an uneven, distorted playing field across British Columbia's\n               entertainment industry. A theatre with two or three screens may qualify for expanded liquor permission, while\n               other theatres with four or five screens down the road remain restricted, despite\n               serving the same community, operating under the same provincial liquor laws and employing\n               trained staff allowing the same rules. How does that make sense? How is that fair\n               competition? And perhaps, most Perhaps, most importantly, where exactly does government draw the line? If a theatre\n               expands and becomes successful, does it lose its privilege? If a theatre has different\n               ownership, does it lose its licence? There are problems with legislation built around\n               arbitrary classifications rather than consistent principles across the board. Businesses across the province are exhausted by government's constant creative carve-outs,\n               exceptions, pilot projects and selective rules instead of establishing one fair, transparent\n               framework for all. This bill continues that trend. Instead of modernizing our liquor\n               policy for all theatres in British Columbia, government proposes another narrow exemption\n               targeting one category of business.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036538","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak about Motion M207 and to raise what I believe is a fundamental\n               issue of fairness, of consistency and common sense in the government's approach to\n               liquor policy in British Columbia. That is why removing the word \"independent\" levels\n               the playing field for all movie theatres across British Columbia. Why not let the\n               owne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","label":"Beverages"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","label":"Beverages","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09d0581c49938801ff5d11fb6d7b9dbdcd449cd0ac63b25372a371f8ca40e567"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac94e84db3b53fa2b731cf29789858afd8639a8d50150e175139771458621fe5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a03c2ccc6e3cedb0b0f5daea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036539,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Growing our economy on whose backs? Basic cable, landline phones and yarn — what do\n               they have in common? These are the new luxury items worthy of being taxed by this\n               government. Seniors crocheting blankets for their grandchildren. Seniors using the\n               only phone they have, which is a landline, now have to find money elsewhere, with\n               the little savings they have left, in order to survive. Why is this government pinching pennies from B.C. seniors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036539","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Growing our economy on whose backs? Basic cable, landline phones and yarn — what do\n               they have in common? These are the new luxury items worthy of being taxed by this\n               government. Seniors crocheting blankets for their grandchildren. Seniors using the\n               only phone they have, which is a landline, now have to find money elsewhere, with\n               the littl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034417","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034417","label":"Communications equipment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3962f93d24e7836be4235c99144bd350e11082c35b4d9c75c3786e91bf97d87"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3eb98ab91b08b684fd2e221eeb9f3a3a692e2f61605d17433f995f795bd23cf2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58f2d1761fc45b5732cb21c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036540,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036540","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["593d94d9da3abbc5fff8f27cab29d5d8fd5bb55697eed579f5d8f3a5b9682047"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6dc9cebfad352b4ace46033d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036543,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"May 27 is my wife Cynthia's birthday. We're very grateful to be growing older together\n               before social media, because we did most of our stupid stuff before social media. I just want to wish you a happy birthday, babe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036543","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"May 27 is my wife Cynthia's birthday. We're very grateful to be growing older together\n               before social media, because we did most of our stupid stuff before social media. I just want to wish you a happy birthday, babe.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a6853f58e856941f27c49891020d1dc1c1138091a3b8324f5eccdeab77220df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-221fc8b0540cf75ab8634259","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036544,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Korky Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would just like to ask some constituents in my riding to please stand. They're good\n               friends of my wife and myself — Grant and Judy Gaudet. They have served the community\n               of Abbotsford for many, many years, volunteering, sitting on boards, committees, etc. Would the House make them feel really welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036544","member_id":"bc-mla-357","member_name":"Korky Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would just like to ask some constituents in my riding to please stand. They're good\n               friends of my wife and myself — Grant and Judy Gaudet. They have served the community\n               of Abbotsford for many, many years, volunteering, sitting on boards, committees, etc. Would the House make them feel really welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adulthood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","label":"Adulthood","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e994568e34dc2d7a5542e3295e5b7a90f555a73183b87125c7ff29a7c821682"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f4e6e1d08c932db9020a50db2db94b0e17dff33026b867cba93ef74df111140"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85aa48f62ed86692375578e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317350,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to table a petition on behalf of 754 residents of the South Okanagan. The petition respectfully calls on the Legislative Assembly to urge the government\n               of British Columbia to prioritize improvements to drinking water infrastructure in\n               the South Okanagan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317350","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to table a petition on behalf of 754 residents of the South Okanagan. The petition respectfully calls on the Legislative Assembly to urge the government\n               of British Columbia to prioritize improvements to drinking water infrastructure in\n               the South Okanagan.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c453a62dca5e7084bae84b425c2f5f2443fe017bf46067c282d0f1055a696f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8dca7ae89a947ef72a00b1a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317351,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the importance of the Kettle Valley Rail Trail, one of\n               British Columbia's most remarkable heritage and recreation corridors. Stretching across\n               the southern interior, the Kettle Valley Rail Trail connects communities, landscapes\n               and generations. What was once a vital transportation corridor that helped build this province now\n               serves a new purpose, bringing people together through recreation, tourism and shared\n               history. This trail welcomes hikers For many smaller communities, the Kettle Valley Rail Trail has become an important\n               economic driver, supporting local businesses and encouraging visitors to explore parts\n               of this province they might not otherwise see. Beyond its economic value, the trail\n               represents something deeper. It tells the story of the workers in communities who\n               helped build British Columbia, and it reminds us that the infrastructure of the past\n               can continue to serve future generations in meaningful ways. The Kettle Valley Rail Trail is a provincial treasure. It was entrusted to the province\n               as a recreational asset for the people of British Columbia. With two sections in my\n               riding now being abandoned, this asset is gradually losing its full potential. I believe\n               the way forward for the Kettle Valley Rail Trail requires us to think outside the\n               box. One possibility is for the trail to become the province's first lineal provincial\n               park. This would provide a mechanism for local groups to undertake work, raise funds\n               and collect user fees that can be reinvested directly back into the trail. It would\n               also allow the province to formally recognize the importance of this corridor, preserve\n               and share its history, and develop a cohesive park plan for the entire route. Most importantly, it would provide economic certainty for community groups and investors\n               by clearly establishing that the trail is valued and will remain that provincial asset\n               for future generations. Recreational infrastructure, like the Kettle Valley Rail Trail,\n               is worth protecting.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317351","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the importance of the Kettle Valley Rail Trail, one of\n               British Columbia's most remarkable heritage and recreation corridors. Stretching across\n               the southern interior, the Kettle Valley Rail Trail connects communities, landscapes\n               and generations. What was once a vital transportation corridor that helped build this province now\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Railway networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036876","label":"Railway networks","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab3a9b28bcd15f549fada1064ef00a3eabf5c0b171b44868d140c694940fcb87"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5dd08431e475bed27fe5fa0c735d2c69b3396de46ace79dc97eff319aa595a54"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2146a9d2bfc96419c7fba5d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317352,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Saturday night, the Princeton emergency room was closed, which offers overnight virtual\n               emergency room care. If this minister can't keep a virtual emergency room open, I've\n               lost a lot of hope for what we have for the future of British Columbia. When will this government ensure reliable emergency care for my constituents in Boundary-Similkameen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317352","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Saturday night, the Princeton emergency room was closed, which offers overnight virtual\n               emergency room care. If this minister can't keep a virtual emergency room open, I've\n               lost a lot of hope for what we have for the future of British Columbia. When will this government ensure reliable emergency care for my constituents in Boundary-Similkameen?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["69ab353d71b9b84cfa363d1e2a9654cef2fc2bb772e0db153f3ccdc798b4dcb2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f711619a42f205b0ef8803698bc9a474734541f54ab78110ce28718a4097604d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20d5173d940932b05c3938b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328445,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just wanted to do a warm welcome to the members of the B.C. Parks Foundation who\n               joined our Conservative caucus for lunch today. On the precinct today, we have Andy\n               Day, Jennie McCaffrey, Cohen Bradley, Kaaren Lewis and Ashley Aubrey. I really appreciate the opportunity to learn more about the foundation and what they're\n               doing for parks in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328445","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I just wanted to do a warm welcome to the members of the B.C. Parks Foundation who\n               joined our Conservative caucus for lunch today. On the precinct today, we have Andy\n               Day, Jennie McCaffrey, Cohen Bradley, Kaaren Lewis and Ashley Aubrey. I really appreciate the opportunity to learn more about the foundation and what they're\n               doing for parks in British Col","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034900","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drainage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034900","label":"Drainage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9977d536dbe534c659162664c4ed5221f39c06064c9bf48102bec1ff8cd9817f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b64c60189fc3828690887787e4428acb54a9973685fb933d77168fecaf3079a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8eee2c2d38e6c61532708546","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361208,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to the motion put forward by the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine affirming the importance of affordable, equitable and accessible water. I want to begin with something that every member in this House should be able to agree\n               on. Clean water is not a luxury. It's not optional. It is one of the most fundamental\n               services required for people to live, work and raise their families in communities\n               across British Columbia. It represents life. It supports our homes, our schools, our\n               hospitals and our local economies. It supports agriculture, industry and the long-term\n               health of all British Columbians. When we talk about strong communities, when we talk about economic development, when\n               we talk about sovereignty, none of that is possible without reliable and affordable\n               access to drinking water. For many people in large urban centres, access to drinking water is something we rarely\n               think about. We turn on the tap, and it's just there. But in many smaller communities\n               across British Columbia, water infrastructure is aging, costs are rising and residents\n               are increasingly being asked to shoulder financial burdens that are becoming difficult\n               and, in some cases, impossible to manage. As the critic for Water, Land and Resource Stewardship, I hear about these pressures\n               regularly from communities across the province. But today I want to bring this conversation\n               down to the ground, to the real experience of families in my own region, because behind\n               every policy discussion about water infrastructure are real people trying to manage\n               real costs in their daily lives. In the community of Sage Mesa, just outside Penticton, families are facing a crisis.\n               This subdivision operates on a private water system that was seized by the provincial\n               government in 1990. Residents have In the community of Sage Mesa, just outside Penticton, families are facing a crisis.\n               This subdivision operates on a private water system that was seized by the provincial\n               government in 1990. Residents have paid their water bills for decades, seeing modest increases along the\n               way. Then, last week, they received a letter from the comptroller of water. Their\n               water bills must increase by 300 percent, up to $3,600 per year, simply to keep their\n               water system operating. That's $300 a month. Imagine opening that bill today. But that's not the end of their story. Next month, residents will vote in a referendum\n               on transferring the utility to the regional district, along with borrowing of up to\n               $32 million to rebuild their system. That cost will be shared between a couple of\n               businesses and just over 200 homes. If approved, the estimated cost to households will average roughly $9,000 per year.\n               Combined with the operational costs that they've already been told to expect, that\n               means these residents are going to be approaching $12,000 a year just for their water\n               — $1,000 a month. That's not their mortgage, not their hydro, not their groceries.\n               That is just their water. I want every member in this chamber to imagine going to their mailbox today and finding\n               a bill for $1,000 that you need to pay every month, going forward, just to turn on\n               your tap. I've spoken directly with families in that community, young families who bought homes\n               only a few years ago, seniors on fixed incomes, people who stretched financially to\n               purchase a home in what they believed was a stable community. They did not know this\n               was coming, and now they are being told the cost of keeping water flowing to their\n               homes is going to exceed what they can afford. I ask members of this House: is that what we consider affordable water in British\n               Columbia — $1,000 a month? Because for the families in Sage Mesa, that is the reality\n               facing them today. Unfortunately, Sage Mesa is not alone. Across my riding, small communities are facing\n               similar pressures. In Heritage Hills, a water infrastructure solution is estimated\n               at roughly $13 million. In Skaha Estates, another community facing infrastructure\n               needs, it's estimated at $12 million. These are small communities with less than 300\n               homes. They do not have a large tax base. They cannot simply tax their way out of\n               the problem. At the same time, policy changes are triggering additional infrastructure requirements.\n               In Kaleden, I have a new treatment standard requiring an ultraviolet system estimated\n               at $4.5 million. In Hedley, naturally occurring arsenic levels have now exceeded updated\n               thresholds, requiring the development of an entirely new water source for the community. In Keremeos, residents were asked to support a new well simply to meet provincial\n               housing density requirements. And in Osoyoos, the community faces a $73-million price\n               tag for the water treatment infrastructure required to meet their current standards.\n               Their water today comes out looking like tea. For small communities, numbers like that are simply beyond their means. Across British\n               Columbia, we are now seeing the consequences of decades of underinvestment in water\n               infrastructure. The issue is systemic, and local governments are expected to manage\n               these systems.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361208","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to the motion put forward by the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine affirming the importance of affordable, equitable and accessible water. I want to begin with something that every member in this House should be able to agree\n               on. Clean water is not a luxury. It's not optional. It is one of the most fundamental\n               services required for people to live","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["812f50f5ace36a8ab8456969f8e171e5882e921920e0cdc340fda82a45d419a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["83d3fd8758fc5ddde7e7e021a35f19db78edf931a0f19004ccda0ea4e3ff82ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0c33ea70f784797c470d5ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361209,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to rise in the House today to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026. In reviewing the bill, it proposes a series of amendments to the Employment Standards\n               Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act — legislation that forms the background\n               of how we protect workers in the province while also establishing the rules that employers\n               and employees must operate under. I've heard many times in the Boundary-Similkameen that changes need to be made to these pieces of legislation. I'm not sure these were\n               the highest priorities for the people in my I've heard many times in the Boundary-Similkameen that changes need to be made to these pieces of legislation. I'm not sure these were\n               the highest priorities for the people in my riding, but I look forward to discussing\n               it nonetheless. At its core, this legislation touches on three key areas: how employment complaints\n               are investigated, how disputes are resolved between workers and employers, and how\n               decisions are appealed when there is disagreement with a ruling. These are not small\n               administrative details. These processes determine whether workers receive the wages\n               they are owed, how quickly those disputes are resolved and whether employers have\n               fair access to appeal when they believe a decision has been made incorrectly. Because\n               of that, legislation like this deserves careful scrutiny. I want to begin by saying something that should unite all members of this House. Healthy\n               workplaces require balance. Workers deserve strong protections. Employers deserve\n               rules that are fair, clear and workable for business. If we get that balance right,\n               we build a labour system that supports both opportunity and accountability for British\n               Columbia. But if we get it wrong, we risk creating systems that are slower, more complicated\n               and harder for both workers and employers to navigate. Workers must be paid what they are owed. One of the most fundamental principles of\n               employment law is simple. Wages earned must be wages paid. Employment standard law\n               exists to ensure that workers receive the compensation that they have worked for. Most employers across this province understand that and support that. In fact, the\n               overwhelming majority of businesses want to follow the rules and exceed them in many\n               places. They want to pay their workers properly. They want to treat them fairly and\n               operate within the law. In my own career, I've been extremely fortunate to work in many small businesses and\n               non-profits where I felt like a member of the family. When I needed time off to do\n               something with my family, they were always more than accommodating. And it went vice\n               versa. I was willing and able to help my employers when they needed a little extra\n               here and there, because that relationship was good. But when disputes arise — even in the best of circumstances, they can — workers need\n               a clear pathway to resolve those issues. That is the role of the employment standards\n               branch. It is the body responsible for investigating complaints, determining whether\n               wages are owed and ensuring that those wages are paid. Bill 10 introduces several procedural changes to how those complaints are handled.\n               Some of those changes are relatively minor administrative adjustments, but others\n               are going to raise important questions about fairness, accessibility and capacity\n               that I look forward to investigating during committee stage as we move forward. I think one example relates to what happens when wages are owed to a worker who cannot\n               be located. Under our current legislation, if an employer owes wages but the worker\n               cannot be found, the director must wait one year before transferring those funds to\n               an administrator responsible for holding them. Bill 10 removes that one-year waiting\n               period. Instead, the director would have the authority to transfer those wages earlier\n               after attempting to locate the employee. On the surface, this may seem like a small housekeeping change, but it does raise\n               some questions, I think, at least for me. What efforts will be required before those\n               wages are transferred? How will workers be notified? And how will we ensure that the\n               workers who move, change jobs or temporarily leave the workforce are still able to\n               recover those wages that belong to them? The goal always is, to be clear, that money belongs to the worker, not to the administrator,\n               not to the employer. In the case where an employee is owed the wages, they belong\n               to the worker. Any administrative change must ensure that workers remain our priority. This bill also introduces a new complaint resolution process during investigations.\n               Under the proposed changes, the director would be able to require parties to participate\n               in a complaint resolution process as part of that investigation. In principle, early\n               resolution can be a good thing. It should be our goal at all times. When disputes\n               are resolved quickly and fairly, both workers and employers will benefit. The workers will receive their wages faster, the employers avoid prolonged investigations,\n               but there are some practical questions here. Many small businesses in British Columbia\n               do not have a dedicated HR department. They don't have a legal team in-house. It's\n               usually the wife or the husband who's in the background in the evenings trying to\n               figure it out, read the laws, interpret it and figure out how to run their Mandatory participation in complaint resolution processes could create additional\n               burdens for these businesses. We need to ask whether those changes will simplify dispute\n               resolution or actually make it more complicated. I look forward to committee stage,\n               where we can dig into this to better understand where government is going with this\n               and the details around how that's going to look going forward. Another key change in Bill 10 relates to the appeal deposit. If an employer wishes\n               to appeal a determination that requires them to pay wages, they must now deposit the\n               full amount of the ruling with the director before filing that appeal. The tribunal\n               would have the discretion to accept a smaller deposit in some circumstances. It isn't\n               clear how discretionary that is or what those circumstances might be. Financial hardship\n               of the employer — it's not clear whether that would be considered. But I do understand the intent behind the policy. It is meant to discourage frivolous\n               appeals and ensure that workers are not left waiting indefinitely while employers\n               challenge decisions also indefinitely. But the reality is that while the administrator takes the deposit, it doesn't actually\n               go to the worker. It's sitting in trust, so it hasn't sped up anything for the worker.\n               That money has just gone from the business to the trust, and the worker is still out\n               the money, and the business is out the money, while it's sitting there locked up during\n               this dispute process. I'm concerned about what the timeline around the appeals process could be. Is this\n               another year? I look forward to also delving into that during committee stage. For large corporations, depositing that full amount of a ruling is probably manageable.\n               It's something that's within their existing cash flow. But for many small businesses,\n               especially ones that may already be facing financial hardship.... As we know, many businesses\n               in B.C. are struggling to make ends meet. I know payroll every second Friday — or\n               mid-month and end of month, depending on the cycle you're on — is very stressful for\n               many employers in Boundary-Similkameen as they struggle to make those ends meet. The hearing itself could really stretch those small businesses out further, not only\n               with the cash flow sitting in trust but also in the time and energy of, again, going\n               through the appeal process, learning the laws and trying to figure out how to do it. I'm nervous, I guess, that the full amount up front could effectively prevent some\n               employers from exercising that right to appeal. They may decide, \"I financially cannot\n               afford to appeal this,\" which puts them in a system that restricts the access to appeal.\n               It's kind of fundamental to our democracy and how we do things in British Columbia. We know that mistakes happen. Evidence may be disputed. Interpretations of the laws\n               can vary. So ensuring that that appeal mechanism remains accessible to all parties,\n               for me, is part of the fairness of the system. I'm concerned that putting that deposit\n               — full requirement — up front into trust over an undetermined amount of time while\n               that's happening could deter and curb the ability to do appeals. Perhaps the most significant issue related to employment standards in British Columbia\n               is not addressed directly by this bill, and that is the time it takes to actually\n               resolve the complaint. I touched on it a little bit during the appeal process, but\n               I believe that it's an overall issue within the employment standards branch. According to the government's own service plan, over the past several years, only\n               about 32 percent of employment standards complaints have been resolved within 180\n               days. That means that the majority of workers are waiting longer than six months to\n               see their complaints resolved. That's six months that they don't have money for their\n               groceries. It's their unpaid wages that they're waiting six months to get to. This is a time when people are struggling to pay rent, to pay their bills. I spoke\n               in the House a couple of days. Some people are struggling to pay for their water in\n               this province, and that six months is really meaningful for a struggling family. I will acknowledge that the government has set a target of resolving 80 percent of\n               complaints within 180 days by '27-28. But that's a 50 percent improvement. It is a\n               lofty goal. I commend the government for going for it. But they've matched that with a static budget and no significant changes flagged within\n               the service plan. So it is unclear to me how the minister intends to meet that goal. If we pretend they are going to meet it and we are going to get there, then that means\n               that, still, one in five workers would be waiting longer than six months. There's\n               still a significant amount of If we pretend they are going to meet it and we are going to get there, then that means\n               that still one in five workers would be waiting longer than six months. So there's\n               still a significant amount of cases that won't be resolved within that six-month window. Is that acceptable? Is that something that we are willing to just accept here in British\n               Columbia? Because for me, success should not be measured simply by how quickly we're\n               closing the files, but success should be measured by whether workers actually are\n               receiving the wages they are owed and whether the system delivers those results in\n               a timely manner. I want to talk about a small business in my riding which unfortunately went insolvent.\n               It's a sad story. There were a lot of employees that lost their jobs. It resulted\n               in a case that landed in my office last summer. What it was was a lot of the management\n               team were owed their severance packages from the employer. For whatever reason, they\n               are actually listed as a creditor in the insolvency. They're not guaranteed those\n               severance packages and wages. And at that time, that person had been waiting 15 months\n               for their severance package. I don't see anything in here that would solve that. That concerns me because it was\n               a significant amount of money for that person who had moved, had only been in the\n               job a short period of time but had uprooted their entire family to come work for this\n               business, and had them unfortunately go insolvent. And, unfortunately, that story\n               played itself across several management employees within this organization. I wish that this legislation spoke to what we're going to do about that going forward,\n               and I encourage the minister to look at that as something for future legislation. But that brings up another concern. This government expects complaint resolution times\n               to improve significantly. With a frozen budget at $22.3 million for the next three\n               years, that's actually lower than last year's estimate of $22.85 million. So the question\n               becomes: how will the employment standards branch resolve these complaints faster\n               without those resources? Faster timelines require more investigators. They require\n               more administrative staff. They require capacity within the organization. Without\n               those resources, legislative changes alone will not solve the problem. If I go back to the same insolvent business, the case that I had.... I went to employment\n               standards and was looking for some guidance. I talked to an investigator within the\n               branch. I was told that it was in her workload, coming up at 15 months is how far\n               they had been at that time. But she was going on maternity leave in the next week.\n               And I asked her who was taking over her case files and she said: \"I am the last investigator\n               in the office, and I don't have anybody taking over my files.\" I seriously wonder whether this legislation can be enforced on the ground. Do we have\n               the investigators actually to work through these files? Because in the case of my\n               constituent, I can tell you that there was nobody there to get through the files.\n               I'm very concerned about that and what we're going to do ongoing to make sure those\n               employers.... To my knowledge, they still have not got their wages out of the bankruptcy.\n               So they would be approaching 24 months at this point. I want to talk a little bit about some concerns raised by some employer organizations\n               relating to consultation. I've heard from some groups in my riding specifically that\n               they were not consulted before these changes were introduced. Many small businesses\n               didn't know this was coming. They weren't included. I believe that labour policy works best when both sides of the workplace are part\n               of the conversation. We need the employer and the employee together, making these\n               decisions and figuring out the best path forward. The employers bring that perspective\n               of practicality and implementation, what it looks like on the ground. What looks good\n               in this chamber doesn't necessarily translate down to the bush in Grand Forks, a logging\n               truck employee out in the middle of the bush trying to do something. So we need to\n               make sure that we are including people on the ground in the legislation that we're\n               doing. I really encourage British Columbians to engage with the minister if they have concerns\n               about this legislation, but also include the official opposition in those concerns\n               so that we can help have a fulsome discussion at committee stage and make sure those\n               concerns are heard and addressed. I believe that good policy is built through dialogue and through consultation, through\n               engagement with people who actually live on the ground and will live with the consequences\n               of this legislation. We need to include them and bring them along. British Columbia's labour laws play an important role in shaping our economy. They\n               protect workers, they set expectations for employers, they help ensure their workplaces\n               remain safe, fair and productive. But legislation British Columbia's labour laws play an important role in shaping our economy. They\n               protect workers. They set expectations for employers. They help ensure their workplaces\n               remain safe, fair and productive. Legislation must also recognize the diversity of workplaces across this province.\n               You heard me speak about the logging truck driver who's out in Grand Forks. I'm sure\n               that there is a tire repair guy right now on the side of the highway somewhere in\n               Beaverdell as a lone worker working through that. We need to make legislation that\n               protects those workers. We need to set expectations that the employer can meet and\n               understand clearly and help ensure that our workplaces remain safe, fair and productive\n               for everyone. Legislation must also recognize that large corporations in the Lower Mainland are\n               very different from those of a small rural community in B.C. Many employers in Boundary-Similkameen are very small and have one or two employees. In my own business, we don't actually\n               have a full-time employee. We hire when we need them, based on the workload. They're farmers. They're tradespeople. They're tourism operators. They're loggers.\n               They're family-run companies. They care about their employees. They want to treat\n               them fairly. But they need rules that are clear and systems that are workable. In closing, Bill 10 contains several procedural changes to employment standards processes.\n               I think some of those changes may improve efficiency. I think others raise important\n               questions about fairness, access to appeal and whether the system has the resources\n               it needs to function effectively. Workers deserve to be paid what they are owed. Nowhere in any of this.... That has to\n               be kept at the core of what we're doing. And employers deserve a system that is fair\n               and accessible. British Columbians deserve a labour system that resolves disputes quickly and transparently.\n               We need to ensure that we properly resource our investigations office so that we can\n               meet the goal of 80 percent, even. One in five not being addressed in six months still\n               seems not okay to me, but it is a goal, and I hope that the minister is able to achieve\n               it. As legislators, it is our responsibility to ensure that these laws achieve our goals,\n               because at the end of the day, employment standards legislation is not just about\n               regulation. It's about people, people who work hard every day, people who rely on\n               our workplaces and our businesses, and people who expect their government to build\n               systems that work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361209","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am pleased to rise in the House today to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026. In reviewing the bill, it proposes a series of amendments to the Employment Standards\n               Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act — legislation that forms the background\n               of how we protect workers in the province while also establishing the rules","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["46749db6eff5a0bf24b8cdb4d9c74baadca2c840b45b4d55b3b64fda2afc5873"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12f9dad1b6274068a9b2ef10862e280f2dc8a66f90bee139517fe0986bd31e4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-339778c156326169eafca9fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361210,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I feel like that answer probably provides little assurance to the residents of the\n               Okanagan Lake Resort. Residents in Sage Mesa are also now facing a combined water cost exceeding $12,000\n               a year. That is $1,000 a month. Can the minister explain how things have gotten so bad that these residents can no\n               longer afford to live in their homes because of this government's mismanagement?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361210","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I feel like that answer probably provides little assurance to the residents of the\n               Okanagan Lake Resort. Residents in Sage Mesa are also now facing a combined water cost exceeding $12,000\n               a year. That is $1,000 a month. Can the minister explain how things have gotten so bad that these residents can no\n               longer afford to live in their homes because of this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f11d8f91de20cecce87574d63f1697d31c1a3469451b1ddf68882ab93bf2a626"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54ed10bdd078e5c4ddc72fec791d92663cb4e78e55043b11891e13dbb72ad767"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0cf3133745c5b8cec3bc2735","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415858,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's spring and a time to celebrate, but as the snow melts and the rains arrive, communities\n               in the Otter and Similkameen Valleys in my riding begin watching the water levels closely. For\n               them, flooding is not a theoretical risk. It is a question they ask every spring and\n               increasingly every time heavy rainstorms arrive. Will our community be safe this time?\n               It is a question I hear often from residents across my riding and one I have to ask\n               myself as well, who lives along the river. British Columbians will remember the atmospheric rivers of 2021, which caused catastrophic\n               flooding across our province. Communities were cut off, homes were destroyed, and\n               entire neighbourhoods in communities like Princeton and Tulameen were underwater.\n               As devastating as that flooding was, the damage did not end there. Temperatures dropped\n               soon after and those flood waters froze, expanding and compounding the destruction\n               those communities faced and were already struggling to recover from. This past winter we have experienced three atmospheric rivers that again pushed rivers\n               and creeks beyond their banks across the valley. For many residents along these rivers,\n               every major rainfall brings real anxiety. People watch the forecast. They watch the\n               river levels. They start lifting their belongings. They start filling sandbags. And\n               they remember what happened last time. During these rain events, people are up all night walking the riverbanks, and first\n               responders are preparing, knowing there's little they can do except to help people\n               get to safety if the river rises again. That constant uncertainty is taking a mental\n               toll on the communities and well-being of the people who live there. One of the challenges in our valley is that flood protection is often approached community\n               by community, rather than viewed from a watershed perspective. But we all know that\n               rivers, lakes and tributaries do not have municipal boundaries. When one community\n               strengthens their dikes or their mitigation, the risk just moves downstream to the\n               next community. So protecting one section of river without addressing the entire system\n               can increase risk for communities further along the valley. Residents need a coordinated,\n               watershed-wide strategy that protects communities together. Another serious concern in the valley is the presence of orphaned dikes. These aging\n               infrastructure no longer have a clearly defined owner responsible for maintaining\n               them. Communities like Tulameen and Keremeos rely on them as their only flood protection\n               in these events. Today no one is clearly responsible for maintaining them. Just as\n               concerning is that no one has the legal authority to do the maintenance or repairs\n               on them either. Authorization and funding only become available once the emergency\n               has been declared. In other words, the only time we can legally work on these is when\n               the river is already rising. During that atmospheric event in 2021, the Similkameen rose over four metres in a\n               single day. That is 12 feet in 24 hours. We have no ability to prepare for that until\n               that's already coming up, and now we have hours to try to maintain the safety of our\n               communities. That is not a strategy. It is only a gamble. The other issue we face is that many First Nations along the Similkameen River are\n               not fully included in our provincial flood mitigation planning because their lands\n               fall under federal jurisdiction. But as I mentioned before, water does not recognize\n               jurisdictional boundaries. If First Nations communities are excluded from planning,\n               gaps remain that affect everyone along that river. True watershed planning must include\n               all communities If First Nations communities are excluded from planning, gaps remain that affect everyone\n               along that river. So true watershed planning must include all communities along the\n               system. These communities cannot manage these challenges alone. Flood mitigation often costs\n               tens of millions of dollars, far beyond the tax base of communities like Tulameen,\n               Princeton, Hedley, Keremeos or even Chopaka. The Similkameen Valley needs a coordinated\n               flood mitigation strategy with investment from all levels of government. Because for\n               families who live along that river, flood mitigation is not a policy exercise. And I wish I was only talking about the Similkameen Valley that's at risk. But as\n               the opposition critic for Water, Lands, and Resource Stewardship, I know these government\n               failures repeat themselves across British Columbia. This is simply the story I'm sharing\n               today as one of those residents who, three times this winter, watched the rain forecast,\n               looked at the snowpack and checked river gauges every hour from behind the orphaned\n               dike in Keremeos. Until we have a government that will prioritize investment in infrastructure that\n               prevents emergencies, rather than only providing funding to respond to them, families\n               like mine will keep watching the river instead of sleeping when the rain begins.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415858","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's spring and a time to celebrate, but as the snow melts and the rains arrive, communities\n               in the Otter and Similkameen Valleys in my riding begin watching the water levels closely. For\n               them, flooding is not a theoretical risk. It is a question they ask every spring and\n               increasingly every time heavy rainstorms arrive. Will our community be safe this t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["866e950a4ddbd2f8861f8872c40bc62de823826089cb2f281cb6a9d55b08492a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["355e2d0d83d2abf3134214372c3ad8ad6d9abe34658b0436a8e84f6d3ea76394"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3411439bcc16c48f285ad39d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415859,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I believe those words are pretty hollow for the families in the House today. Two parents, Kaomi and Mike, told us their daughters gained life-changing communication\n               and emotional regulation skills through early intervention. They said clearly that\n               early intervention works. Why is this government taking away support for these children when we know it's working?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415859","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I believe those words are pretty hollow for the families in the House today. Two parents, Kaomi and Mike, told us their daughters gained life-changing communication\n               and emotional regulation skills through early intervention. They said clearly that\n               early intervention works. Why is this government taking away support for these children when we know it's working?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50b1a60d6f3076be2dd9324aed896f7beb91960721dbe4e8b715a656f5dff4f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29e0f51402bed85747c7124ee09c2efe8fa6276f7dc65ce07bd1558c197a96bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-012a8fba6fd83bc4388612a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720686,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 15 as the designated speaker for the opposition,\n               a legislation that proposes changes to British Columbia's environmental assessment\n               framework. Environmental assessment is one of the most important responsibilities\n               entrusted to this Legislature. It is where we make decisions that shape how development\n               proceeds, how landscapes are protected, how watersheds are safeguarded and how communities\n               understand their place in the future of this province. These decisions are not abstract. They affect whether projects move forward with clarity\n               or uncertainty. They affect whether communities feel heard or left behind, and they\n               affect whether British Columbians continue to have confidence in the systems that\n               guide land and resource decisions across our province. As the critic for Water, Land and Resource Stewardship, I approach this legislation\n               from the perspective that environmental assessment must do two things at the same\n               time. It must protect what makes British Columbia extraordinary — our landscapes,\n               our water and our wildlife. And it must provide a clear, stable pathway for responsible\n               development to move forward. These are not competing objectives. They are complementary responsibilities and something\n               that we must figure out for the prosperity of British Columbia. Environmental assessment\n               exists to ensure that projects proceed in a way that respects ecosystems, supports These are not competing objectives. They are complementary responsibilities and something\n               that we must figure out for the prosperity of British Columbia. Environmental assessment exists to ensure that projects proceed in a way that respects\n               ecosystems, supports communities and provides certainty to those making long-term\n               investments and jobs in our province. That balance matters, especially in rural British\n               Columbia where many of these projects exist today. In the communities I represent, environmental assessment is not a distant administrative\n               process; it is part of our everyday reality. I come from a region rich in mining,\n               forestry, water, recreation and all of the things that require environmental assessments.\n               It shapes whether infrastructure is built, whether resource projects proceed, whether\n               employment opportunities expand and whether environmental values that define these\n               regions are protected for our future generations. So when we consider legislation that proposes changes to how environmental assessments\n               operate, we're not simply debating process. We're debating how those decisions are\n               made, and we're debating today who participates in those decisions. We're debating\n               whether the framework we create today will provide the clarity British Columbians\n               expect tomorrow. I want to acknowledge at the outset that the Environmental Assessment Act review process\n               did include engagement with Indigenous governments, local governments, proponents,\n               environmental organizations and communities across British Columbia. That work was\n               completed last year. Participants identified areas where the system could be strengthened,\n               particularly with respect to early issue resolution, coordination between decision-makers\n               and clarity in how those assessments move forward. I believe this Bill 15 is an attempt to work towards those goals. They are important\n               objectives. They are objectives that deserve careful attention in this House. Bill 15 proposes to respond to some of these priorities. But as legislators, our responsibility\n               is not only to consider what a bill is intended to do but what the actual outcomes\n               it creates are. We are to examine how clearly those intentions are reflected in the\n               legislation itself. Predictability in environmental assessment does not come with just intentions. It\n               comes from structure. It comes from timelines. It comes from transparency in the process\n               overall. And honestly, it comes from clarity about how those decisions will be made\n               in practice and applied in every single project equally. Many of the changes proposed in this bill introduce new mechanisms intended to support\n               that coordination and earlier resolution of issues within the environmental assessment\n               process. Those mechanisms may prove useful — I believe they could — but many of the\n               details that determine how they will operate remain to be defined through regulation\n               at a later date rather than established directly in statute. That distinction, I believe, matters, because environmental assessment functions best\n               when communities understand how the process works before it begins, not after it has\n               already started. It also functions best when proponents understand the sequence of\n               decisions they will face with attached timelines. Investors need to know how long\n               they're planning for. It also needs to function with Indigenous governments, local\n               governments, and so that the public can see clearly how their participation shapes\n               that outcome. Today my remarks will focus on three questions that I believe are central to understanding\n               the legislation before us. First, how does Bill 15 respond to what participants identified\n               during the Environmental Assessment Act review process? I think that's a really valid\n               question. Second, where does the legislation strengthen the environmental assessment framework?\n               Are those timelines clearly defined? Third, where does the bill leave important operational details to regulation that\n               will need further examination as it moves forward through committee stage? Regulation\n               doesn't have that, whereas statutes do. We need to understand in committee stage what's\n               being moved to regulation and what that's going to look like going forward. Environmental assessment is one of the places where this Legislature most directly\n               shapes the long-term future of British Columbia's land, water and communities. It\n               deserves careful attention. It deserves thoughtful scrutiny. It deserves legislation\n               that provides the clarity that British Columbians expect from the framework that With that in mind, I would like to begin by speaking about the role environmental\n               assessment plays in protecting British Columbia and the natural resources and landscapes\n               that define it. Environmental assessment is one of our most important tools this province has so that\n               development proceeds responsibly and the landscapes British Columbia depends on are\n               protected for future generations. It is where environmental protection and economic\n               opportunity meet. It is where long-term stewardship is translated into practical decision-making.\n               And it is where the province demonstrates how it intends to balance growth with responsibility. Bill 15 is an important tool to try to meet that responsibility. And as the critic\n               for Water, Land and Resource Stewardship, I see environmental assessment as part of a broader system that protects the natural\n               foundations of our province — our watersheds, our forests, our wildlife habitat and\n               the landscapes that define both. It is not simply a procedural requirement. It is a safeguard. It ensures that projects\n               are evaluated not only for what they build but what they will affect for this generation\n               and the generations that follow. It ensures that cumulative impacts are understood\n               before decisions are made. It ensures that our drinking water, our fish habitats,\n               our agricultural land and our species at risk are all considered in that decision-making\n               to influence outcomes. And it ensures that decisions made today do not create unintended\n               consequences for future generations. That is why I think Bill 15, introducing the dispute resolution earlier in the process,\n               really helps us in this process. British Columbia's natural environment is not only\n               central to our identity as a province. It is essential to our economic future. We\n               need to figure out how to get this right. We need to figure out how to bring that investment to our province. That comes from\n               predictable timelines with known processes for all investors and companies in British\n               Columbia. We also need to support our landscapes for tourism, recreation and other\n               economies that exist within our landscape. We need to support biodiversity that is\n               recognized around the world as one of our defining strengths in this province. Environmental assessment plays a role in protecting all of these values and is why\n               we have worked so hard over many years to make sure this act learns and grows. It\n               also provides the framework that allows Indigenous governments, local governments\n               and the public to participate meaningfully in decisions. I think that Bill 15 is aspiring to create that framework but is lacking in the public\n               and proponent sections. I look forward to digging into that in committee, because\n               I think that those are two key things that seem to be missing in this legislation. I know in many rural communities, major projects are not abstract discussions. In\n               my own communities at Princeton, we've been on a long journey together as a community\n               as Princeton has looked to expand their copper mine. We have seen views from all sides.\n               Hudbay Minerals has worked very hard to get through the environmental assessment and\n               to bring the community along. We are thankful to see that the permit has come through\n               but at the same time feel sad that not all communities came out and supported it in\n               the end. The Lower Similkameen Indian Band has come out with a letter. They do not support\n               this project. I don't know whether this bill would have prevented that or what that\n               looks like going forward, but my hope is that this bill would have caught that and\n               solved it much sooner and not created that instability for my community. I lived in Princeton in the 1990s when the copper mine closed the first time, and\n               I can tell you the devastating impacts it had for that community. More than half the\n               community lost their jobs. We lost doctors. We lost dentists. We lost everybody who\n               supported that industry. It became somewhat of a ghost town, and so I am fearful that\n               the boom-and-bust will again come to Princeton if we can't get this solved. If this\n               bill helps prevent that, then I look forward to committee stage to learning how that\n               could happen. In many rural communities, major projects are not abstract policies. I just shared\n               what it means for one community. I have many other mining communities in my riding.\n               I have Greenwood, which has built a whole legacy on mining. I have forestry. I have recreation. I have tourism. I have community forests. I have\n               all of these things that go through environmental assessments. It's really important\n               that we figure out how to get this right, because they do shape employment opportunities\n               and infrastructure investments long-term. They also shape land use decisions that\n               affect entire regions for decades. They also shape land use decisions that affect entire regions for decades. And they\n               shape whether development proceeds in a way that strengthens communities, or creates\n               uncertainty within them. Environmental assessment helps ensure that those decisions\n               are made carefully. It helps ensure that development proceeds with awareness of the\n               long-term impacts. And it helps ensure that British Columbians can have confidence\n               that projects moving forward have been reviewed through a structured and accountable\n               process. It also plays an important role in supporting reconciliation. It creates opportunities\n               for Indigenous governments to participate in decision-making that affects their territories.\n               It supports collaboration between governments, and it helps establish processes through\n               which knowledge, priorities and stewardship responsibilities can be reflected in project\n               review. I am hoping that Bill 15 will be able to move that process through sooner\n               so that we don't have these communities in disagreement at later stages of the project\n               that create more uncertainty. I believe that environmental assessment works well when it protects ecosystems and\n               it supports communities. It strengthens public confidence. I believe the minister\n               said that in her opening remarks. I did hear her say specifically that providing public\n               confidence was a key thing in this particular piece of legislation, and I look forward\n               to committee stage where we're able to dig into that a little bit because I don't\n               necessarily see how communities do participate in this process, how proponents participate\n               in this process. I see a government-to-government protocol agreement, but I don't\n               see how the rest of the people involved in the decision are brought into that process.\n               So I look forward to digging into that in committee stage. But I know what happens when environmental assessments lack clarity, when timelines\n               are uncertain, when participation structures are not clearly defined or when operational\n               details are left unresolved. Uncertainty does not remain contained within the assessment\n               process itself. That rolls out into community. It rolls out into investments. It rolls\n               out into housing. In Princeton we have a large number of unhoused people, largely because of the uncertainty\n               of that permit in Princeton. People did not move their families and purchase properties or build new town and\n               community housing because they didn't know whether employment would continue long\n               term. It had a lot of social implications to that permit being held up for many, many\n               years. I hope that this process, without a timeline in it defined within the statute, isn't\n               going to just add a length to that but will actually translate into quicker decisions on the ground. But I do know that it does spread\n               outward. It affected the community greatly. It affects proponents. Definitely the\n               Hud Bay spent I don't know how much time trying to bring the community along in their\n               process, trying to educate people, open houses, one-on-one meetings, trying to get\n               through the process of the environmental assessment. But it did affect the confidence of British Columbia's system as a whole. It is an\n               unknown, a lot of the environmental assessment process. We outlined that it's going\n               to be 180 days, but there's been many mechanisms to pause it. And this process actually\n               is before the 180 days start, and there is no timeline with that. So this could take\n               years, and those investors have no idea how long that timeline is, how long they're\n               going to be out that money, or whether they can actually invest and move forward in\n               British Columbia. I think that's why we need to figure out a predictability in this environmental assessment\n               amendment. The changes proposed in Bill 15 I think deserve really careful attention\n               as we consider how they will shape that framework going forward. Before turning to the specific changes proposed in Bill 15, it is important to recognize\n               that British Columbia's environmental assessment framework already reflects many years\n               of development, experience and improvement. We're not writing this on day one. We\n               know exactly what we have learned. We went and we consulted. We have a whole report\n               on what we heard, on what the changes need to be to the Environmental Assessment Act,\n               so we're not starting from zero. It is a system that has evolved over time in response to lessons learned from projects,\n               from communities, from Indigenous governments and from those responsible for implementing\n               the process So we're not starting from zero. It is a system that has evolved over time in response\n               to lessons learned from projects, from communities, from Indigenous governments and\n               from those responsible for implementing the process itself, our staff here at the\n               ministry. It is also a system that already contains important strengths. We have some\n               strong winds within that legislation. I think that the what-we-heard report outlined some key recommendations that we need\n               to bring forward to make this act really work for all British Columbians. My concern\n               is that this particular Bill 15 is only one of the many recommendations that are included\n               in this act. I did not see or hear from the minister her plans to implement or introduce\n               more legislation to implement the changes requested by community and industry. I believe that the commitment to early engagement is a great commitment. I believe\n               that it is a necessary commitment. I hope that the government actually implements\n               that, that it's not just lip service — that we just put this in legislation and then\n               we end up in court later and find out we knew we had to consult, but we didn't. It's similar to what has happened in Okanagan Falls, where they knew that the First\n               Nations should be consulted on their incorporation, but at the same time they just\n               kept pushing it off and saying: \"yeah, we'll do that. Yeah, we'll do that.\" Well,\n               they sent it to referendum without including First Nations and then sent it to First\n               Nations after a decision was made. Not surprisingly, the First Nations have some concerns.\n               They have things they want to see implemented into those changes. But it was already\n               after the referendum, after the community thought they decided on something. So now we are in a perpetual conflict. There is anti-Indigenous sentiment in my communities.\n               People don't understand what is happening. We have moved to tables. I bring that up\n               because Bill 15 talks about moving into tables. How do people in communities know\n               what is happening at these tables? How do we understand when we are not there to hear\n               the history, to hear what we are going to do and why we're doing these decisions?\n               All we get is a decision at the end. I did not see in this Bill 15 anything that talks about reporting out to the public\n               about how that decision was made. It says: \"to the parties.\" How do the rest of us\n               understand how those decisions were made and what happened at those tables? I'm concerned\n               that they're separate tables. These aren't community tables. They're Indigenous tables. I understand the government-to-government relationship, but by not including the proponent\n               and, possibly, the local elected officials in those tables, we are setting our communities\n               up for division because we can't bring them along. We can't include them in why these\n               decisions were made. I went a little off script there. That's okay. I think it's important that the communities\n               stay engaged, that they know what's going on, and I'm hoping that this Bill 15 can\n               be adapted to allow that participation, that it isn't just government to government\n               with a final decision and the rest of us have to live with it. I think that there's a real need to bring community along. Reconciliation includes\n               the people that live in the community and where the project's taking place, the people\n               that work at that particular business that are going to be impacted by it, both negatively\n               and positively. Everybody needs to be brought along so that they understand the decisions. Over time, our framework has evolved to better reflect the importance of Indigenous\n               knowledge, Indigenous priorities and government-to-government relationships within\n               project assessment. I know that work continues, and it remains an essential component\n               of building a system that reflects the realities of decision-making. It also supports coordination across ministries and agencies. It's supposed to be\n               kind of a one-window application process, but we can see clearly in the engagement\n               that that is not how industry feels. They don't feel like they're dealing with one\n               particular agency on the environmental assessments. They are being sent all over into\n               WLRS, into Environment, into forestry, into Mining, and they don't know where they're\n               going next or what the steps are. I'm hoping that Bill 15 will help to clarify some\n               of that, but I'm concerned that it just adds another layer and doesn't provide that\n               clarity. Environmental assessments often require decisions from multiple parts of government.\n               As I just said, the environmental assessment office plays an important role in bringing\n               all those decision-makers together and ensuring those assessments proceed within a\n               structured framework rather than through disconnected approval pathways. That is our\n               stated goal — structured framework. But I think the reality on the ground is disconnected approval pathways. That is what\n               we heard in the what-we-heard report. It doesn't seem to matter what what-we-heard\n               report. Whether it's on the Environmental Assessment Act or any of the other bills\n               that we've heard in this House, the disconnected approval pathways continue to be\n               the number one concern. I was I was at COFI last week, and we heard that clearly. Disconnected government processes,\n               the unknown, not knowing the pathway, not understanding how permits necessarily go\n               through decision. Yes, once they get to a certain point, they go into the timeline,\n               but it's all the steps prior to that that are really unknown. I think that this environmental assessment process has the ability to build public\n               confidence if we do make it public and we do bring them along. I believe that there\n               needs to be clear participation opportunities that are understood, that communities\n               are better able to follow the decisions that affect their regions and that transparency\n               supports trust, not just individual project decisions, but in the broader framework\n               overall. People need to understand the framework, how it works, when they can expect to be\n               updated and what those updates look like. I think environmental assessments intend\n               to provide better project outcomes, and I think in those what-we-heard reports, that\n               is the desire, but obviously not our current practice. We heard that clearly in there.\n               It allows technical issues to be examined before they become barriers later. I'm hoping\n               that Bill 15 allows us to get to that. I think that engaging participants during the environmental assessment doesn't require\n               wholesale change. I think it's there. It's in the act already. I think it's creating\n               that framework for how we are going to deliver on it. The participants in the what-we-heard report called for targeted improvements. They\n               asked for earlier issue resolution, which we're discussing here today. They asked\n               for clearer timelines, which is not in this legislation. This is actually one of my\n               biggest concerns going forward. What are the timelines for this new process? We introduced\n               it, but we have not attached any kind of timeline to it. They asked for the better coordination across approvals. They want that one window.\n               They want a single point. They want to understand the framework of how their decisions\n               are made, when they'll know and how they will be communicated with. Bill 15 responds\n               to a couple of their requests but is pretty silent on some of the big ones. So again, I'm going back. I did not hear from the minister when she introduced this\n               bill that this is the first of upcoming legislation changes that will implement the\n               what-we-heard recommendations or whether we're just cherry-picking a couple. The question\n               becomes, then: if you only do part of it, is it enough? I hope in her response at\n               the end that she will clarify whether there's more legislation coming. As part of the Environmental Assessment Act review process the province undertook\n               engagement across the province. I've mentioned before that it included Indigenous\n               governments, local governments, industry, environmental organizations, technical experts\n               and members of the public across B.C. These participants were not asked whether this\n               should exist. That is a given. The environmental assessment process must exist. They\n               were asked how it would work better. What could they do or what could they implement\n               to make things better? The responses were remarkably consistent across British Columbians. They asked for\n               predictability in timelines. It was their number one ask. They asked for clarity about\n               how decisions move forward and when those decisions can be expected. Are you sensing\n               a theme? This is coming forward in the speech. They asked for transparency in how issues are raised, discussed and resolved during\n               assessment. They ask for clearer participation structures so that everyone involved\n               in the process understands their role and their responsibility. They asked for earlier\n               resolution of issues so that concerns are addressed before they come barriers later\n               in project review. That's No. 5 in what we're talking about today. No. 6, they asked for better coordination across ministries and agencies, recognizing\n               that environmental assessment does not operate in isolation of other approvals. They\n               ask for consistency across projects so that expectations do not change depending on\n               sector, region or individual assessment pathways. We don't want to see different decision pathways with different facilitators. We don't\n               want to see the huge differences from region to region, or we risk that decision framework,\n               that investment, because nobody knows if I'm going to this region, is it different\n               than if I go to that region? It's important that the framework is consistent. In 8, they emphasized the importance\n               of meaningful Indigenous participation throughout the environmental assessment and\n               a foundation of the decision-making moving forward. I think that one, as well, is\n               what we're discussing here today. And (8), they emphasized the importance of meaningful Indigenous participation throughout\n               the environmental assessment and a foundation of the decision-making moving forward.\n               I think that one, as well, is what we're discussing here today. I don't think these are abstract policy observations. They were operational concerns\n               raised by people working within our system and participating in it directly. These\n               are the people on the ground. Participants were describing how environmental assessment\n               functions in practice. They want to know how this looks, how it feels, what it looks\n               like on the ground. They were describing where improvements could make processes more\n               understandable, more efficient and more predictable for everyone involved. Predictability emerges as one of the strongest themes throughout the engagement. I'm\n               hoping that Bill 15 actually introduces clear predictability for proponents, for the\n               people in the community, so that we can all understand how this is going to work and\n               what the timeline attached to it. I believe that the people that made those recommendations believe that we need all\n               eight. I don't think that only addressing two of the eight recommendations will necessarily\n               create the improvements on the ground that they want. I acknowledge this is a first\n               step, but I hope to hear from the minister that there's more legislation coming, that\n               she is going to signal in committee what's happening in regulation around timelines\n               and what those changes to those timelines could look like. What pauses a project? Participants indicated that they understand how assessments move forward and when\n               decisions are expected. It is essential not only for their proponents but for their\n               communities, for their investors, for their local governments and everybody affected\n               by those decisions. Transparency was the other consistent theme. While this bill talks about transparency\n               and the reporting, that reporting seems to live within the tables. It doesn't necessarily\n               go out to the proponent, that I can see in the wording that has been provided, and\n               it certainly does not speak to public. So I'm interested to dig into that at committee. I think that participants emphasized that environmental assessment works best when\n               the processes are clear, visible and understandable for everyone. That's not laid\n               out in the legislation necessarily, the whole process, and I'm hoping that, again,\n               the minister can speak to that in committee — what this will look like on the ground\n               in regulation. She spoke to having a template that they would pick up. I'm hoping she'll be able\n               to table that template for us to consider at committee so that we can really see how\n               this works or is intended to work, understanding that there are differences between\n               nations and governances and that it's not going to be the same for everyone. But the\n               template and the framework should be similar. I believe that earlier issue resolution was also one of their clear priorities, and\n               that's why we're here today. I believe this government is trying to meet that. I do\n               feel like it falls short, and I look forward to perhaps making some amendments at\n               committee or at least getting clarification on the record of the minister's intent\n               during that process. I believe that coordination across approval systems was also raised consistently.\n               Not waiting for one permit from one ministry that cascades to another permit for another\n               industry which cascades to needing some kind of archaeology which cascades to.... And\n               it just keeps going. I also think that I've seen on the ground that many of the professional members, whether\n               they're engineers or whatever.... Their credentials are not necessarily accepted these\n               days, and I wonder where that is going as a government overall. These are people that\n               are qualified, and we have people within government staff, not necessarily with the\n               same qualifications yet that have decision-making over these items. I could go into\n               that, but I'd be down a rabbit hole of us talking about docs and other things, which\n               I won't do today. I believe that aligning assessment timelines with permitting decisions needs to happen,\n               and it needs to happen to strengthen the process overall. Participants indicated that\n               stable expectations across sectors and regions strengthened confidence, and that confidence\n               will translate into investment, jobs, economic opportunity for our communities. I believe that the maintenance of the public confidence.... That is lacking. It was\n               so lacking in our incorporation in Okanagan Falls. It's so detrimental to our community.\n               We have an open house coming up. After a year, the people in Okanagan Falls are going\n               to find out what's happening. I know that it'll be a respectful discussion, but it's\n               really late in the process, considering that those I know that it will be a respectful discussion, but it's really late in the process,\n               considering that those letters patent have to be approved so they can have an election\n               this fall. My understanding is by June, from the minister, so I don't know how much\n               input the public is actually going to have at this point. So I'm a little disappointed\n               in that. I'm hoping that this Bill 15, if it had been there — and I know that's not an environmental\n               assessment, but the core beliefs of this, the minister said, is that they use this\n               process in other applications, in her opening remarks. I hope she takes that to heart,\n               and the other ministries, as well, that we need to do this stuff earlier. We need\n               to figure it out. But they can't be tables isolated from community and from the proponent. I think that the one area where Bill 15 doesn't respond directly to engagement feedback\n               is the request. Clearly, Bill 15 is trying to do it, but I feel like we didn't hit\n               the nail on the head with the issue resolution. I see that the First Nations have\n               a way to escalate into this process, but how does the proponent have a way to escalate\n               into this process? If they get into a stalemate where they're not able to move forward,\n               how do they escalate into a process? I'm not terribly familiar with the Environmental\n               Assessment Act. Perhaps that exists. But I think that the proponent also needs to be able to move\n               into this framework if they are also feeling like something is being flagged and not\n               being addressed, that not only the government, First Nations or proponent can initiate\n               the tables to start this. I look forward to committee to be able to ask those questions,\n               whether that is something the minister would consider. They're looking for predictable issue resolution, predictable timelines, predictable\n               structure. What does that look like? None of that is outlined in the bill. Again,\n               the minister referenced a template that I am hoping can be tabled during committee\n               stage for us to have a review, so we can better understand what implementation on\n               the ground looks like. Predictability is one of the strongest and most consistent themes in the what-we-heard\n               report. We need to know what the timelines are. I can't get past that. Without knowing\n               the timelines, this could create a two-year process to do these tables properly. We\n               have.... I don't know if I'm allowed to speak to the treaties, because they've been tabled.\n               Theoretically, there are some treaties coming. I believe that the need for those tools\n               to operate in practice is necessary. I'm going to just go away from the other thought. Transparency is the priority identified repeatedly through this engagement. They emphasize\n               that environmental assessment must remain understandable to communities affected by\n               project decisions. If I look at Princeton, what does that look like? We saw an announcement\n               by the minister. Everybody celebrated for about one hour. And then we get a letter\n               from the Lower Similkameen Indian Band that says they do not support it. What does that mean? The people in Princeton, again,\n               don't know what's happening, what's going forward. Is the Lower Similkameen Indian Band not supporting it, enough to stop the application? We don't know. I don't know whether this process or these timelines will do that. But the treaties\n               took 15 years, some of them 30 years to get to where they are today. Yet this process\n               could be the same. We don't know how deep the resolution or the issue is that we're\n               trying to resolve. So what is the timeline? Do we say that you have six months to\n               get through this process? Do we actually put some framework around it? Because my\n               fear is, without framework or a timeline around the process and the tables — they're\n               consensus tables — we may never get there. So what does that look like? It also doesn't establish any reporting expectations to the public or to the proponent.\n               I think the decision will be communicated, but the reasons for decision may not be.\n               It may be communicated at a very high level. We were at a First Nations presentation last night over at the museum, which was an\n               amazing opportunity to celebrate with First Nations and hear their concerns. It was\n               a great opportunity, but how do we We were at a First Nations presentation last night over at the museum, which was an\n               amazing opportunity to celebrate with First Nations and hear their concerns. It was\n               a great opportunity. But how do we ensure that those opportunities for our communities\n               continue? How do we make sure that our communities stay intact, neighbours to neighbours? These assessments involve multiple decision-makers. If we go to these tables and the\n               technical table doesn't have the technical expertise it needs to make a decision,\n               then what happens? Do we have to wait another month to get the technical expert? What\n               does the timeline look like? I think that is going to be key for how this bill moves\n               forward. I invite the minister to put a timeline in an amendment into this bill. I would support\n               that 100 percent. I believe that we need to put some framework around this, because\n               otherwise these could be ongoing, never-ending tables where we try to get to consensus\n               and can't. What does that mean for the project proponent who is sitting there waiting\n               and waiting and waiting to get into the 180-day window to get into the...? And we could go on about all the reasons they pause and all the things that happen\n               after that. I think an average application right now is three to five years, with\n               some of them going as long as ten. What is this going to add to that window? Is it\n               going to shorten it, or is it going to make it longer? I think we need clarity around\n               that. I think that the environmental assessment must align more clearly with other provincial\n               decision-making processes so that projects do not face unnecessary duplication or\n               uncertainty. What do these tables look like? What is the information they are going\n               to require? Is it included in the original application? Are we looking at another\n               huge bundle of preparation for the proponent of data and information that they need\n               to bring forward? We need to provide some guidelines around that for the proponents\n               when this comes into implementation. I don't think that this bill describes how these mechanisms interact with approvals\n               outside of the framework. And I think that that's typical within government. We move\n               within silos, and this bill could really become its own silo, where it sits outside\n               of the other decision-making. But all the other decision-making is likely to be held\n               up while that silo is working. How do we make sure those silos don't start, and how\n               do we address them going forward? I think that many of these details would allow communities to understand how the processes\n               operate and figure out how they can be involved in it. I think that this bill reflects\n               some of the direction identified through engagement, particularly around earlier issue\n               resolution and structured collaboration between governments. But I think most of the most important expectations identified in the report remain\n               deferred to regulation rather than established in this statute. I do not know that\n               that is just a detail. I know why we do things in law versus regulation, but I think\n               that the framework itself needs to be in law so that we can clearly understand what\n               the timelines are, what the structure of this is and how it will fully integrate and\n               not become its own siloed, stalled process, where we still can't get projects done\n               in B.C. I think that the predictability.... I must have said it ten times. I'm sure someone's\n               got a little ticker going over there on how many times I've said it. I need Korky here. I need my colleague here who keeps a running ticker. The reality is we need to do these things, and we need to ensure that this bill gets\n               it right. I think the participants were clear about what they wanted. I keep going back to why this is the only piece that we're working on this sitting.\n               Is there more coming? That was not mentioned in the minister's remarks. I'm hoping\n               there's more coming, because there was a lot more in that report than this one little\n               piece. We need to make sure, in order to make the improvements that people need, that we\n               implement the changes they requested. We engage them. I'm not familiar, but.... I'm\n               going to guess, having participated in many other engagements, that government, industry,\n               non-profits and ENGOs probably all had countless hours and days and travel and written comments and\n               everything in to this report. And now what government does with it, I think, is key to signal to those people that\n               what they did matters. It actually fed into a decision. We didn't just take one thing\n               out of your — I'm going to guess — year's worth of work and make that happen. We actually\n               heard you, and we're going to implement I believe that Bill 15 does support several mechanisms that will get to earlier issue\n               resolution. It doesn't include what the issue is. There are no guidelines around what\n               kind of issue can be lifted. That may be a positive, but it could also, perhaps, have\n               unintended consequences. We may go into this dispute resolution process about title\n               that may be not anything to do with the actual environmental assessment. We may end\n               up in that process trying to solve something that's actually not part of the environmental\n               assessment. I look forward to hearing the minister in committee share a little bit around how\n               she sees that and how they're going to limit the scope of those tables to the actual\n               project they're working on and not having a creeping scope on those tables, which\n               could further delay the time that they have. I believe that those statutory timelines have to be included. I feel like if we don't\n               put some timelines around this, we actually could just be adding more to the process.\n               We could be driving away more investment and jobs in British Columbia. We are one\n               of the hardest jurisdictions to do business in in Canada, and I would challenge, maybe,\n               North America. We do have a complicated land base. We do have unsettled land claims. We have reasons\n               for those complications. But we are seeing jobs and investment flee this province. We need to solve it, and I don't know that Bill 15 alone can do that. I hope that\n               it doesn't just add another regulatory burden, another consultant report that is required,\n               another eight months of legal requirements from the proponent to participate in these\n               tables and the government properly resources the tables and the people participating\n               at the tables to get to a resolution, that we don't just strike the table and set\n               it up for failure. It is integral that those tables are set up for success, especially\n               with a timeline that is attached to it. I think distinction matters. I think legislation provides certainty. Regulation provides\n               flexibility. I get the difference between the two. Those timelines.... I think we should\n               signal to our investors that we need to have a defined timeline on these tables so\n               that we can signal to our investors exactly what is expected, and that should be in\n               law. It should not be in regulation. I hope the minister will either introduce it\n               or accept an amendment in committee that adds a date to the legislation. I don't think that the timelines eliminate the complexity, but I do think that it\n               will provide assurance to investors and people that are.... It is not even necessarily\n               investors. Snowmobile clubs, ATV clubs, cross-country ski clubs.... They all do environmental\n               assessments as part of their trail-building. Many outdoor water recreation groups\n               also do environmental assessments. House-building. Just about everything we do in\n               British Columbia requires some kind of environmental assessment. So this process.... Speaking of properly resourcing, what are we going to do if this gets triggered on\n               every environmental assessment we have currently in B.C.? What does that look like?\n               What does the resourcing for that look like? How do we plan for that? How do we make\n               sure that this process is reserved specifically for resolutions of items that are\n               big and that need to be resolved, not just every single environmental assessment gets\n               triggered into this process? Some of that would, I would suspect, come from the uncertainty\n               that we have on the land base in British Columbia. I think that it is not clear, also on the timelines, whether this pauses the other\n               processes. The investor goes through the environmental assessment, they think that\n               they're going to be 180 days to the first phase decision. Lo and behold, this pops\n               up. Does that pause the 180 days or does this have to be completed within the 180\n               days? My belief is that it will pause it, but I think that we need some clarity on\n               that in committee. I think, again, it creates an unknown. How long is that pause, and what does that\n               mean as an investor in B.C. when you think you're finally at the 180 days to getting\n               to a decision? I believe that this does provide predictability by doing it before the process begins.\n               Maybe this all happens before the 180 days, but I think, from reading the legislation,\n               that it could be brought in at any point as a dispute resolution. It doesn't say primarily\n               that it can only happen at the beginning, though there is other dispute resolution. I did hear the minister speak specifically about another dispute resolution process,\n               so maybe this is only the pre-process, and then they go into the other dispute resolution\n               once they're in the 180 days. I'll look for some clarity on that in committee. I think that predictability depends on understanding the structure of a process before\n               it begins. Environmental assessment does not operate in isolation from the broader\n               approval system. Projects move forward within financing windows. They move forward\n               within construction seasons. They move forward within regulatory sequences that involve\n               multiple ministries and multiple governments. When they're undefined, the uncertainty created within that process extends outward\n               into those broader decision-making systems. Looking, even, at the Indigenous governance\n               system, many of their elections happen, I think, every two years. What does that look\n               like for these tables if the decision-making bodies of government are changing as\n               well? Bill 15 introduces a structured issue resolution pathway between governments, but\n               again, where is the proponent? How does the proponent participate in these tables?\n               I think that we need to understand who has authority at each stage of the process\n               and where this particular Bill 15 legislation fits into that legislation. I think details may emerge later through regulation. I believe, in reading this, there's\n               not enough in the bill to actually implement it, so there must be lots coming within\n               regulation. I hope that the minister is able to speak to some of that regulation in the committee stage, as we move forward, on what that looks like, because I think\n               that without knowing those regulations and what it looks like on the ground, this\n               bill standing alone does not create the necessary steps to create that certainty in\n               British Columbia. I was pretty wordy. I'm going to skip a couple pages. We're going to go a little further\n               here. I want to make sure I get to the parts.... I think that multiple agencies and multiple interests need a process, and I'm hoping\n               that that regulation outlines what that is. I think that that matters for Indigenous\n               governments as well. I think that they need to understand, again, what the timeline\n               and expectations are for them and what resourcing requirements they should be asking\n               for to participate in these processes. I believe that creating the pathway between\n               the governments without proper resourcing could have a negative effect for all of\n               us. Looking at my time. The consistency across assessments. I think I want to talk about\n               this a little bit. This is specifically the regional nuances between these processes.\n               As each of these tables are set up, they're going to be local project-specific tables.\n               I think that the possibility exists for precedent-setting to happen between table\n               and table. We could see, again, that creeping scope where we don't know.... The decision-making\n               in the North went really smooth, and we were done in 21 days. The decision-making\n               in the Kootenays took two years. How do we make sure that that comes together and becomes workable for the people of\n               B.C.? I think that we need confidence in that timeline and what the process is going\n               to look like that's going to be outlined in regulation later. I think that consistency\n               doesn't mean that it has to be identical. It doesn't have to be I think consistency doesn't mean that it has to be identical. It doesn't have to be\n               the same for every single project, but it does have to have a structure. It has to\n               have that framework, and I'm hoping it has that template. I'm so excited that the minister mentioned the template, because I was like, \"this\n               tells me that it exists today\" and that maybe we're going to be able to see it at\n               the committee stage. I look forward to seeing that. I made myself a note, like, \"yay,\n               there's a template. Let's see what that says and what it looks like on the ground.\" I think that the regulation-later framework is as necessary as a government, but at\n               the same time, we want to make sure that we legislate what is required, that it's\n               debated in this House, that we understand clearly what should be debated and what\n               should be left for government decision-making. So I am concerned that much of the\n               decision-making around how these tables operate and how this bill is implemented is\n               left to regulation that we don't know about today. As we move to committee stage, I look forward to examining how the changes proposed\n               in Bill 15 will operate in practice. I think that it allows us to examine how those\n               implements are implemented, and perhaps see the template. In a legislation that introduces\n               new coordination mechanisms and new issue resolution pathways within the EA program,\n               I think that distinction matters. I think that it's important that we put on the record so that all of the proponents\n               that are looking to invest in British Columbia clearly know what to expect when this\n               bill passes and what it means for investing in B.C., that we clearly get that done. In closing, I believe that environmental assessment is one of our most important decision-making\n               frameworks this Legislature is responsible for maintaining. I believe that it is where\n               we protect our watersheds, our ecosystems and the landscapes that define our province\n               and it is where communities, Indigenous governments and local governments and proponents\n               come together within a structured process to consider projects that shape the future\n               of our province. I believe it supports responsible development, and it can create\n               a path forward for prosperity for British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720686","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 15 as the designated speaker for the opposition,\n               a legislation that proposes changes to British Columbia's environmental assessment\n               framework. Environmental assessment is one of the most important responsibilities\n               entrusted to this Legislature. It is where we make decisions that shape how development\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2968b840c3dd26e99cb3982f6e70ee13f164fe944b5203ae519f52b7a3143e00"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f5c41dd39fed56996ad67dda50a655a15189609241665d50230728186451817"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be49e2255dcc49763df99673","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720689,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to echo Abbotsford South around the two-acre issue. I do see it quite\n               often in the South Okanagan, where we have rotating crops like garlic. So 2 acres\n               is very hard to make $10,000 when you're rotating a crop every first, second or third\n               year. Most garlic farms are doing three-year rotations. We also see it a lot in small livestock. And 2 acres isn't enough to have a livestock\n               breeding program big enough to make the $10,000. So I would echo my colleagues there. The reason I'm getting up today. I wanted to talk about Movi, and I'm going to try\n               to pronounce this — Mycoplasma ovipneumoniae, otherwise known as Movi. It continues\n               to threaten the wild sheep populations here in British Columbia. I'm wondering if\n               the minister could share what actions are being taken to implement mandatory testing\n               for domestic sheep here in B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sheep","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720689","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to echo Abbotsford South around the two-acre issue. I do see it quite\n               often in the South Okanagan, where we have rotating crops like garlic. So 2 acres\n               is very hard to make $10,000 when you're rotating a crop every first, second or third\n               year. Most garlic farms are doing three-year rotations. We also see it a lot in small livestock. And 2 a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","label":"Animals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","label":"Sheep"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724339","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Animal testing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Slaughtering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sheep","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","label":"Sheep","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","label":"Slaughtering","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","label":"Animals","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724339","label":"Animal testing","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8341895b0b4171fd6c7be6055cbe8f679b593b13e1c84147c903232117df965b","4d942650bb780349773438b92a83f57e3b2d3738c6a00caaae139c3cfcaece52"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sheep","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["afcbf1b5ec782ed25bf30efd318a943c35dc652e110d4c2f88db3f1a0b0a3a10"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sheep","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037107","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:222070","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43560446d4be98d276f20117","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720693,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome on the precinct today Mayor Joe Hansen, here from the town\n               of Oliver, advocating on behalf of his community for work on the agricultural canal\n               in his region, as well as for some expansions at his local airport. I appreciate the time of the ministers and the meetings that we have today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720693","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to welcome on the precinct today Mayor Joe Hansen, here from the town\n               of Oliver, advocating on behalf of his community for work on the agricultural canal\n               in his region, as well as for some expansions at his local airport. I appreciate the time of the ministers and the meetings that we have today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["afc1290ac75acb5a2068563930273b694a577ef420a9ea03510fb14d9aa2d251"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18304bfe5361d70a6641dcb85e41fe23fd0b6a93bfb91bb01cb33c1c92067587"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c334eba4afe778e9f291c9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720698,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you. I look forward to continuing. It's always interesting when your speech\n               gets split halfway, so I'll do a little bit of a recap. I do appreciate the minister's shout-out last night on his social media, but it was\n               a little disappointing that he didn't actually know my position on the bill, so I'm\n               guessing he wasn't actually watching the debate, which is interesting. For his benefit\n               today, I will briefly recap what I covered yesterday. Bill 14 makes several structural changes to how B.C. Timber Sales operates, including\n               the introduction of contract logging authorizations that allow contractors to harvest\n               Crown timber without holding ownership of that timber. It expands the authority of the Timber Sales managers and the minister to impose licence\n               conditions that may go beyond what is set out in statute, and it raised important\n               questions about predictability and consistency for operators across the province. It also broadens what expenditures can be made from the B.C. Timber Sales account,\n               shifting the spending authority beyond activities directly tied to generating timber\n               revenue and toward a wider range of operational planning — road construction, forest\n               protection, administration and silviculture activities. While I believe there are opportunities within these changes to support wildfire mitigation,\n               salvage operations and additional forest management work, I did raise that stakeholders\n               in my region have also raised some concerns about uncertainty, compliance costs and\n               the potential for conditional While I believe there's opportunities within these changes to support wildfire mitigation,\n               salvage operations and additional forest management work, I did raise that stakeholders\n               in my region have also raised some concerns about uncertainty, compliance costs and\n               the potential for conditional creep, over time, of policies. These are some significant shifts in this bill and how timber\n               is managed, and they do deserve careful consideration as we continue examining the\n               implications. I'll continue on my speech from where I left off yesterday, now. I definitely want\n               to talk about the expanded use of planning tools. I have some questions that we'll\n               cover in committee around forest operations plans and the forest stewardship plans that are now going to be through B.C. timber sales. I do believe that planning tools support coordination across landscapes. I actually\n               believe industry would like decisions to be made at those planning tools levels, rather than block by block. I've heard that across industry. I do believe those plans support stewardship objectives and support our environmental\n               values, which are very important to me and all British Columbians. I think that they\n               will deliver fibre, but it could cause further delay. Across the Interior, mills are already facing supply shortages, contractors are already facing uncertainty,\n               and I think workers are already facing and feeling that instability in our markets.\n               So when we add additional planning layers and uncertainty into the process, we have\n               to ask whether it's reasonable to replace existing ways we're doing business. The question I guess we'll bring into committee is whether the B.C. timber sales are creating these from scratch, whether that's going to be a delay in how we do\n               business going forward, or whether these exist today. And I'm not as in touch with the actual forest processes on the ground, so I look forward to digging into that with the minister in committee, because I\n               think the industry can't experience any more delays or any more planning processes. I also believe that the concerns that were raised to me by industry — about expanding\n               the discretionary authority for the timber sale managers to impose licence conditions beyond what we've included in statute — from their perspective, could\n               introduce some significant uncertainty. What does that look like region to region? It creates the potential for inconsistent application between districts, it creates\n               uncertainty around what further discretionary authority will be applied, and it may\n               increase compliance costs in ways that are difficult to anticipate. I think that these are real concerns, and we need to not introduce any more uncertainty.\n               We need to figure out a way to level that playing field and make processes predictable.\n               So if the minister is able to articulate how this bill supports that, I'm looking\n               forward to it. I also want to acknowledge that this bill reflects government's effort to respond\n               to our changing forest conditions across the province. You can't live in B.C. and\n               not see that on the ground today. Wildfire impacts are increasing. We had our very first wildfire in the Similkameen Valley this past weekend at the Chopaka reserve. We were fortunate no homes were lost, but it's dry already this year. Pest damage also continues to affect timber supply, and I believe that communities\n               across British Columbia are asking for stronger fuel management work near infrastructure and population centres. I think that legislation that will help remove those barriers can play a really constructive role, and I support this\n               bill if that's where we get to. In communities like mine, people understand the connection between the act of forest\n               management and wildfire risk reduction. They understand that removing merchantable fibre near infrastructure can improve our safety outcomes and save our communities. I have\n               many historical communities in my riding where the houses are very close together,\n               and wildfire incurring into town can have direct consequences. I support anything that's salvage harvesting after a wildfire as well, if we can use that timber. We've lost it to fire; we should\n               be doing everything we can to get that to the mill as soon as we can. You can go up\n               the Ashnola Valley right now, into the Cathedral Park: dead standing timber from fire, all up the valley, that was unharvestable for a number of reasons. But to this day, it seems like there's a lot of fibre there\n               that we could have salvaged, and it's too late now. So where this legislation supports that work, I think it deserves support of everyone\n               in this House. I also believe that flexibility must be matched with clarity. Expanded authority must\n               be matched with accountability, and structural changes must be matched with implementation\n               capacity. Because without that alignment, legislation I also believe that flexibility must be matched with clarity, expanded authority must\n               be matched with accountability, and structural changes must be matched with implementation\n               capacity. Without that alignment, legislation risks creating expectations that cannot\n               be delivered on the ground. From a rural perspective, the most important question remains a simple one. Will this\n               bill help get fibre to mills faster? Will it support our workers in rural B.C.? Will\n               it strengthen our forestry-dependent communities? Or will it introduce uncertainty\n               into a system that is already under strain? Government has framed Bill 14 as a modernization bill. I want to take a moment to\n               talk about what modernization actually means. Modernization is not just simply the\n               introduction of new authority or new statutes. Modernization is the responsible management\n               of change. We need to do this responsibly because over the last number of years....\n               I heard this clearly both at COFI and again from the Truck Loggers Association, that\n               this sector has already absorbed more than 50 policy and regulatory changes affecting\n               how forests are planned, accessed, harvested and managed in this province. Fifty. At some point, modernization requires us to pause and ask a simple question. Are these\n               changes working? Is the forestry sector strengthening? I can tell you that every measurement\n               that I see says that what we're doing is not working. Industry is asking us to pause,\n               to take a breath, let them catch up, figure out what's happening on the ground. With\n               50 changes already, I'm concerned that these new changes could add more regulatory\n               burden to an already struggling industry. Government has also framed this bill as a step toward better alignment of fibre, the\n               right log to the right mill. I agree with that objective. It's something that all\n               the companies in my riding already do. They work together to make sure that PWP is\n               getting our post and rails and that the right size is going over to Kelowna, to Gorman.\n               Now Gorman also owns in Princeton. That work happens on the ground today. Industry\n               is doing it themselves. It is an important objective. We don't want to be taking house logs and turning them\n               into chips. But right now that risk sits primarily with industry, the person who has\n               put the bid in for the B.C. Timber Sales. That risk lies with them. If they've made\n               the wrong bid or made the wrong choice or don't have the places to sell them, that\n               risk lies with them. I believe this bill is looking for the province to step in and take some of that risk.\n               It seems like they're shifting towards log sort yards, that they're going to take\n               this timber and put it into log sort yards that are perhaps managed by the province. Markets are volatile. I used to work at the local lumber yard in Keremeos, and my\n               job was to update the plywood, OSB and lumber inventory as it came in every day The\n               market is so volatile that the business could lose significant money if you did not\n               reflect the new cost of the new wood that hit the yard immediately when it hit the\n               yard. We know this is volatile, and the government is now going to step into that process.\n               I'm not really understanding why, and I hope the minister is able to explain that\n               in committee, about why we feel that government retaining the timber and going into\n               these log sort yards is going to help get the right log to the right mill. My understanding from industry is that it's been tried before, and it has failed.\n               We have not been successfully able to run these sort yards. These logs end up rotting\n               because they aren't moving fast enough or they are not at a cost that actually benefits\n               the small industry, which I think is what we're trying to cater to in this particular\n               bill. I definitely support small industry and small bills. I support getting the right log to the right mill,\n               but I think the industry does it better. I don't know that we should be getting into\n               that, and I'll hear the reasons from the minister in committee. I do know that if we keep going down this route of modernization without the checks....\n               When we're not going back and looking at the checks and balances to see if the work\n               we're doing is achieving the objectives we're trying to create, if we look at those\n               50 changes over a period of, I think, it's five years.... I'm sure somebody will correct me on social media if I'm wrong, but I think it was\n               five years. In that period, we've also seen that the actual cut that we're doing is\n               going down significantly. We're definitely going in the wrong direction, and industry\n               has indicated in every way possible to both this government and the opposition that We are definitely going in the wrong direction. Industry has indicated in every way\n               possible to both this government and the opposition that they need help, and they\n               need it now. This is a time of crisis for them, and I am very concerned about the\n               communities in my riding if we don't get this right. We need to make sure that if we expand again and do another modernization, there are\n               some checks and balances to make sure these changes had the intended outcomes that\n               we were trying to create. Because in communities like the ones I represent, we don't\n               need any more experiments. We want things that work, and we want to make sure if it's\n               not working that we correct course quickly. They need fibre certainty. They need predictability. They need government to get out\n               of the way. In some cases, there are so many different regulations that some of my\n               mills have only weeks to get all the wood into the yard due to hauling restrictions,\n               road restrictions and cutting time restrictions. There are so many layers that are\n               falling into the mill. The planning process alone has tripled in costs for these companies,\n               just to get to the point where they can actually start logging. I hope this legislation will make a practical difference. I'm hoping, at committee\n               stage, that we can get into exploring these changes in more detail. In particular,\n               I believe it would be really important to clarify the intended role of expanded contract\n               logging and what those authorities look like, the implications of removing revenue\n               linkage expectations within B.C. Timber Sales and whether new planning requirements\n               could affect fibre delivery times. Will this make it so that we're not making it actually slower for our mills? How will\n               these changes be supported through operational resourcing? Can B.C. Timber Sales today\n               actually do what is in this bill? What resourcing are we adding to make sure that\n               this doesn't become another good idea that we don't actually have the people to put\n               into place or the money to get it done? The success of legislation like this is not measured by how it reads on paper or how\n               we talk about it in this chamber. It is measured by whether it works in practice,\n               whether the bush in British Columbia.... Those forestry workers deserve that clarity\n               from this House. Communities deserve that clarity from this House. And this House\n               deserves the clarity as we consider these amendments going forward. I look forward\n               to committee stage. I thank you for the time to speak today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720698","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I look forward to continuing. It's always interesting when your speech\n               gets split halfway, so I'll do a little bit of a recap. I do appreciate the minister's shout-out last night on his social media, but it was\n               a little disappointing that he didn't actually know my position on the bill, so I'm\n               guessing he wasn't actually watching the debate, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b24e4fdd0dfba210cbffa3dd082f28a33b81177fdc87d37ef38b1a8046a29ad3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf9606eb74b54886ba475a24f0e1d7aad2bada9452afe3b93bb2f136f9f97baa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59d60f7001df4f1dc9c3f275","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721769,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am pleased to rise to speak about something that should never be controversial\n               in British Columbia: that people should be able to turn on their tap and have","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721769","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I am pleased to rise to speak about something that should never be controversial\n               in British Columbia: that people should be able to turn on their tap and have","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drinking water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47475","label":"Drinking water","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5ed36e0f48a35061ad3790589bcb92a60be9e3ae786696e5207d05fedf278af"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-077c77924c62031b506f2103","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721776,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026. As members know, miscellaneous statutes bills bring together amendments\n               across several ministries and policy areas. Some of those changes are technical Donegal Wilson : I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026. As members know, miscellaneous statutes bills bring together amendments across several\n               ministries and policy areas. Some of those changes are technical in nature. Others\n               reflect adjustments to programs already underway. Occasionally they include more substantive\n               policy shifts that deserve closer examination by this House. Sometimes they just tuck\n               in a little something. Bill 16, I think, contains elements of all three. There are provisions in this legislation\n               that respond to practical operational needs, things that we need to do, housekeeping\n               and things to modernize statutes. There are sections that reflect some changes in\n               policy direction, which I'll highlight. There are others where important details are\n               being left to implementation, decisions that we want to better understand as the bill\n               moves forward. My remarks this afternoon will focus on several key areas within the bill where I\n               think clarification would be helpful, where the intent appears constructive and where\n               committee stage will provide the opportunity for members to examine how these amendments\n               are expected to operate in practice across British Columbia. I think you'll hear me speak, similar to my colleague, a lot about rural B.C. and\n               how some of these statutes don't have the same application across the province. I\n               look forward to highlighting some of those from my region. I'll start with part 1 of the bill, which is to amend the Judicial Review Procedure\n               Act. At first glance, it looks like these provisions may appear mostly technical,\n               but it does look like there are a few minor housekeeping amendments that will affect\n               how decisions of government can be reviewed and challenged. I think that makes them\n               important for this House to examine carefully. I think judicial review is one of the core accountability tools available to British\n               Columbians. It allows individuals, organizations, local governments and Indigenous\n               communities to ask courts to examine whether a decision made by government was lawful,\n               reasonable and procedurally fair. I think in many cases, particularly in rural B.C., judicial review is the only practical\n               mechanism available when decisions are made far from the communities that are affected\n               by them. This bill makes two significant changes in that area. First, it repeals a provision\n               that previously ensured that passage of time alone could not be used as a barrier\n               to judicial review unless another statute explicitly created that limit. I believe\n               that protection mattered. It recognized that access to review should not depend simply\n               on how quickly a person is able to navigate a complex legal process. Removing that safeguard raises an important question for this House: what problem\n               is this amendment intended to solve? I look forward to discussing that in committee\n               and hopefully getting some clarification. I also want some clarification on if there is a pattern of litigation that required\n               this change. Why are we making these changes? Is there uncertainty in the courts about\n               how the existing provision operated? Or is this a preventative amendment in anticipation\n               of future disputes? It feels a little bit like the government is trying to find a\n               way to do things a little more secretive. So these are questions that deserve answers\n               as this bill moves forward, and I look forward to the committee stage. I think the second change also allows cabinet to designate additional information\n               as cabinet confidence and prevents that information from being compelled for disclosure\n               in the course of a judicial review. Cabinet confidence already plays an important role in protecting collective decision-making\n               at the executive level. I think that principle is well-understood and long-established.\n               However, expanding that authority to designate materials as confidential within the\n               context of judicial review shifts the balance between transparency and executive protection.\n               I think it is reasonable for the members of this House to understand why that shift\n               is being proposed now. Judicial review does not exist to interfere with the role of cabinet. It exists to\n               ensure that decisions made under statutory authority remain within the bounds set\n               by this Legislature. So when legislation expands the scope of what may be withheld from review, it is appropriate\n               to ask how that authority will be used, what limits will guide its application and\n               what safeguards will ensure that it does not unintentionally restrict access to the\n               accountability mechanisms that British Columbians rely on. These amendments may ultimately prove to be reasonable and necessary, but they are\n               not self-explanatory in the legislation or the changes that were highlighted with\n               it. So I look forward to committee to dig into that. In part 2, the Fuel Price Transparency Act. I'd like to speak briefly to the amendments\n               to this act. These provisions introduce authority for government to charge fees under the act and\n               to collect interest if those fees are not paid. The legislation also enables cabinet\n               to establish the amount and structure of those fees by regulation. At one level, this appears to be administrative adjustment. I don't think it's unusual\n               for legislation that creates a At one level, this appears to be administrative adjustment. I don't think it's unusual\n               for legislation that creates a regulatory framework to include some mechanism for\n               cost recovery. Many statutes operate this way, particularly where government is collecting\n               and managing data from industry participants. However, what stands out for me in this case is that the bill creates the authority\n               to impose fees without specifying who will pay them, how they will be calculated or\n               what limits may apply to them. I don't think that those are minor details, and I look\n               forward to a committee where we can get some background on that. They also will determine\n               whether a fee functions as a straightforward administrative charge or whether it has\n               a broader implication for compliance costs, reporting requirements or participation\n               in the program itself. The Fuel Price Transparency Act plays an important role in improving public understanding\n               of fuel pricing and market conditions in British Columbia. I think greater transparency\n               can support better policy decisions and greater public confidence. But transparency\n               mechanisms themselves also benefit from transparency in how they are administered.\n               As this bill proceeds, it would be helpful to understand whether these fees are intended\n               strictly for cost recovery or whether they represent a new funding stream for program\n               expansion and what consultation has taken place within the parties that may be affected\n               by these changes. I think these are practical implementation questions, and they are\n               exactly the kind of questions that can be explored further in the committee stage\n               of the bill. For section 3, and I think this one might take a little bit longer.... This is the amendments\n               to the Zero-Emission Vehicles Act, and it represents one of the most substantive policy\n               shifts contained in this legislation. These amendments remove the legislated targets\n               that required 26 percent of new light-duty vehicle sales to be zero emission by 2026\n               and 90 percent by 2030. They also reduced the 2035 target from 100 percent to 75 percent. These are not small adjustments. They are a significant change in direction and somewhat\n               support what the Conservatives put forward, I believe last spring, around how these\n               targets were unrealistic and that this should be repealed. For several years, the\n               government described these targets as central to its climate strategy and positioned\n               British Columbia as the jurisdiction leading the transition to zero-emission transportation.\n               Members of this House will recall that when concerns were raised about the feasibility\n               of those timelines, they were just dismissed by this government. So I think it is reasonable to now ask what has changed. Here we are a year later,\n               and here we are. So if the earlier targets were actually achievable, why are we now\n               removing them? If they are not achievable, which I believe they weren't, why were\n               they defended so strongly when those concerns were first raised? This bill also shifts future target-setting out of legislation and into regulation.\n               That worries me a little bit. That means those targets are no longer going to come\n               to this Legislature for discussion and will be made unilaterally by cabinet. I think\n               that may provide flexibility for government as technology evolves and markets change,\n               but it also changes how those decisions are reviewed and debated. They will not be\n               debated here. Targets that were previously set transparently in statute will now be adjustable without\n               returning to this House in the same way. I think it makes it even more important to\n               understand what framework will replace that one that was being removed. At the moment,\n               we are being asked to approve the elimination of near-term targets without seeing\n               the replacement structure that will guide the transition over the coming decade. To\n               be clear, I support removal of these targets because I heard from dealers across B.C.\n               that this is unachievable. Similar to my colleague from Prince George–Mackenzie, dealers were telling me that they were essentially selling these vehicles at a loss\n               to try to meet the targets so that they could continue their business. They were moving\n               vehicles between dealers, and it was seriously impacting their business. I was at\n               a dealer in Cranbrook when I was there last summer that shared how much impact this\n               particular piece of legislation was having for their business and the employees that\n               they employ. But I think moving from statute to regulation does not create that certainty that\n               these dealers and the public are looking for. It also doesn't signal to manufacturers\n               and infrastructure planners and local governments what to anticipate as we go forward.\n               While I didn't like the targets that we had, at least everybody knew what we were\n               working towards. Now, with the rollback, and then moving to regulation, it creates a lot of uncertainty.\n               I think almost every speech in this House that I give speaks about the uncertainty\n               that this government is injecting into our economy I think it's important to recognize the experience that this transition is not the\n               same across the province. If I lived here in Victoria, I probably would have an electric\n               car, because there are electric charging stations where you work. There are electric\n               charging stations at your buildings, many of the malls. And as you move around the\n               city, it's very easy to charge your car. When you go to rural B.C., that is not the experience that you have. This weekend\n               I flew into Penticton, drove to Keremeos, turned around, drove to Grand Forks, attended\n               an event and then drove back to Keremeos. With an electric car, I'm not sure that\n               that would have been doable with the timelines that I had. On top of that, in the\n               summer and in the winter, the heating and the cooling of those cars is not practical\n               for people to travel. I also think of a family that I encountered in 100 Mile that were on their family\n               holiday. They had an electric SUV, and they were pulling their travel trailer. My\n               husband and I came upon them going slower and slower and slower. They were down to\n               20 kilometres an hour, and they were still about 40 kilometres from 100 Mile. That\n               family's whole holiday was put on hold while they waited for a tow truck to come tow\n               their vehicle to the nearest charging station so that they could continue their family\n               holiday. I don't think that translates well when you go into rural British Columbia. That was\n               saying that 100 Mile had the charging station that they need. I think they do in 100\n               Mile. It's a larger centre, but they certainly didn't in the rural communities between\n               where they were and 100 Mile. We need to think about what this looks like in rural\n               B.C., what it looks like in cold climates. The charging and the batteries don't keep\n               the same. In hot climates, air conditioning is not just a nicety. It is actually a\n               necessity in many areas. It gets to over 40 degrees in my community in the summer,\n               and travelling long distances with the 280, air conditioning doesn't work necessarily\n               in that situation. Families and businesses in my region often depend on vehicles that have to travel\n               long distances. We have no taxis. We have no bus service. You're not calling Uber.\n               If you needed to get to the hospital in Keremeos, you'd need to drive to Penticton.\n               That is 45 minutes away, unless it's Monday, Wednesday or Friday between eight and\n               five, which is when my emergency room is open. But the rest of the time, you do have\n               to drive to Penticton to get service, so you better make sure your car is charged\n               and that you're able to handle whatever family emergency you have with an electric\n               car. I believe that the amendment reflects the reality, to some extent, but perhaps not\n               enough. It's talking about rolling back the mandate, but I still don't know that they've\n               looked at what it looks like in rural B.C. and how many cars we can actually convert\n               to electric in rural B.C. in a viable way. We need to be able to charge them. We need\n               to be able to provide electricity. The grid in many rural communities especially doesn't\n               have the capacity to add those second chargers into their households, many people's\n               electric panels. I know my friend's strata is trying to figure out how to put a couple of chargers\n               in their strata, and it's a considerable investment for them to upgrade. They have\n               told the members of their strata that basically they won't be able to charge their\n               car at home unless the strata comes up with that money. Definitely concerning, and\n               anyone who is moving to rural B.C. should do some investigating before they move. I think removing the legislated targets without presenting the clear replacement plan\n               leaves an important gap. Industry and consumers alike benefit from predictable policy\n               direction, particularly where major purchases and infrastructure investment are involved.\n               Our towns are making these investments. Our government is investing in grants and\n               bursaries to get these charging stations in. We see them expanding across the province,\n               which is good news, but how are we going to continue to maintain that investment,\n               and what does that look like, going forward, when we are rolling it back a little\n               bit and moving it into regulation where it could be even further rolled back? It provides\n               that uncertainty. I definitely think that government needs to look for greater clarity on where this\n               is going, what the targets are going to look like, what the regulation is going to\n               look like, how this Legislature will be engaged as we move forward on these goals. I believe these are significant changes that were kind of buried in a miscellaneous\n               statutes bill that probably should've had its own debate and committee stage for itself\n               without being buried in a miscellaneous bill. I'd also like I would also like to talk a little bit about the Housing and Municipal Affairs amendments.\n               This bill includes amendments affecting several statutes related to housing and local\n               government, including the Local Government Act, the Greater Vancouver Sewerage and\n               Drainage District Act, the Vancouver Charter and the South Coast British Columbia\n               Transportation Authority Act. These amendments create authority for government to\n               designate development projects by regulation for the purpose of reducing development\n               cost charges. Development cost charges, DCCs, are a significant factor in the cost of building housing\n               across British Columbia. They are one of the tools that local governments rely on\n               to fund the infrastructure that supports growth. Water systems, sewer systems, roads,\n               drainage and other essential services are usually done under the DCCs. At the same\n               time, they will also affect whether projects move forward at all. Too many DCCs cost\n               too much to build, and the project becomes no longer financially viable. I think that's what this government is trying to create, a pathway to provide flexibility\n               to reduce the DCCs on projects that they would like to accelerate. Of course, the\n               barrier becomes: how do you get into that queue? How do you become one of the projects\n               that you're moving forward, that we're accelerating? Are there going to be clear pathways\n               so that the developers understand how they can get into this? How are we going to\n               actually accelerate housing and not just give projects to preferred construction companies\n               or preferred supporters into certain communities? It also moves some things to regulation, but it does not describe how those projects\n               will be selected through regulation either, so I'm hoping the minister will be able\n               to provide some clarity on that during committee. For me, in smaller communities, it's particularly concerning because we're managing\n               infrastructure deficits all the time. My own community of Keremeos.... I know I've shared\n               in this House that we have been provided the mandate to densify our housing, to add\n               carriage houses and in-law suites to our houses, but we don't have any more water\n               in Keremeos. We need a new well. How do we fund that if a new project is provided some kind of pass on the DCCs, when\n               there's probably only one new major project in my community a year? Is government\n               going to cover the DCCs for the community so that they can get the well they need\n               for these projects, or is it again going to fall down to the taxpayers? In my community, we had a referendum, and we voted to take on more tax burden through\n               our water rates to ensure that we could have that well to outfit the apartment building\n               that government is building that didn't have water secured for it. In many rural municipalities, this is the only way. Communities like Keremeos, Greenwood,\n               Hedley and Osoyoos are already facing significant infrastructure pressures related\n               to water treatment, distribution systems and aging underground service. Greenwood\n               is one of our oldest cities and still has many pipes within the municipality that\n               need to be upgraded. I learned an interesting fact about clay pipes the other day. I know that we have\n               some in Greenwood for sure. I know the community is looking at ways to retrofit those\n               clay pipes and extend their lifespan. But I do not know what that looks like. Without\n               any DCCs or major projects contributing to infrastructure, I don't know what that\n               looks like going forward. If this new authority is intended to support housing delivery, it's really important\n               that we understand how government plans to balance that objective with the financial\n               realities facing local governments. It's also important to understand whether municipalities\n               will be partners in identifying those eligible projects or whether designations will\n               be made centrally, similar to how we saw the housing mandate, where we all had to\n               add carriage houses to our communities when our water and our sewer pipes weren't\n               set up to have two houses on a lot. So what does this look like? Is this something the government is going to send down\n               centrally, or are the communities going to be active participants in this? Because I know that many of my municipalities are feeling a little dictated to by\n               this government and are not feeling that real effort to be a partner. So I'm hoping\n               with this legislation that that is not the intent, that the communities will be included\n               in the decisions around who these fast-tracked projects would be. I think these amendments may provide a useful tool to support housing construction,\n               but like several other sections of this bill, their effectiveness will depend heavily\n               on how they are implemented on the ground. This is something I hope we will have the\n               opportunity to explore as we move into committee I think these amendments may provide a useful tool to support housing construction,\n               but like several other sections of this bill, their effectiveness will depend heavily\n               on how they are implemented on the ground. This is something I hope we will have the\n               opportunity to explore as we move into committee stage. There are also some changes to the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act and the Residential\n               Tenancy Act included in these bills. If it feels like I'm going all over the place,\n               that's because this is a miscellaneous statutes bill that goes all over the place.\n               This is not the easiest speech to write as we navigate many acts in a single speech. These amendments expand the authority of the director to admit oral or written evidence\n               during dispute resolution proceedings that might not otherwise be admissible under\n               the traditional rules of evidence. At one level, this change reflects the practical\n               reality that tenancy dispute resolution is designed to be more accessible and less\n               formal than court proceedings, but many participants appear without legal representation,\n               and the system is intended to allow people to present their concerns without needing\n               to navigate complex evidentiary rules. I think there is a clear rationale for providing flexibility in how information is\n               considered during these hearings. But at the same time, when legislation broadens\n               discretion around what evidence may be admitted, it is important to ensure that the\n               process remains fair and predictable for both tenants and landlords. I think dispute resolution decisions can have very real consequences. They affect\n               housing stability, financial obligations, and in the case of manufactured home parks,\n               sometimes the long-term security of people who own their homes but rent the land beneath\n               them. I know recently Okanagan Falls had an entire mobile home park that was evicted, and\n               many of them were not even able to get their trailers out. There was nowhere to take\n               their trailers to and those people effectively were made homeless by the eviction\n               of their trailers from the trailer park. It's significant in rural communities. Losing\n               20 houses in Okanagan Falls represents a significant portion of the housing availability\n               in Okanagan Falls. I think that for the most part, manufactured home parks represent one of the most\n               affordable and stable housing options available. A lot of first-time home buyers are\n               in this market, and a lot of seniors, people that are downsizing and looking for the\n               more tighter sense of community. I think this could make it more accessible, but it would be important to understand\n               what guidance will be provided to dispute resolution officers to ensure decisions\n               remain consistent and transparent as we move forward. I think it will also be helpful\n               to understand whether this change responds to a specific operational challenge within\n               the branch or whether it's intended to support a broader shift in how dispute resolution\n               hearings are conducted. Are we hearing from the ground that what we're doing is not working? Is this something\n               that we're doing pre-emptively or is this something that tenants are asking for perhaps?\n               It's not flagged in the press release or notes that accompanied the bill. I think\n               these are practical implementation questions, and I hope we can explore them further\n               as we move forward. This bill also includes some changes to the University Endowment Land Act. These changes\n               establish authority for bylaws to be created within the University Endowment Lands\n               area and allow fines imposed under those bylaws to be paid into the consolidated revenue\n               fund of the University Endowment Lands administration. Say that three times fast. The amendments also clarify that these fines may be treated as debts, recoverable\n               through the courts. In practical terms, these provisions appear intended to support\n               local administration and enforcement within the Endowment Lands by providing clear\n               authority around bylaw-making and fine collection. I believe that type of clarification\n               can help ensure that rules adopted at the local level are enforceable and that the\n               mechanisms operate consistently with other jurisdictions that rely on those bylaws. But at the same time, one provision specifically stands out for me, and that's the\n               search and seizure provision that would otherwise apply in relation to professional\n               conduct. Oversight under the Legal Profession Act does not apply in this context.\n               I think that raises a reasonable question about why that exclusion is necessary and\n               what circumstances it is intended to address. I think whenever legislation creates\n               enforcement authority while also carving out exceptions to oversight-related provisions,\n               it is appropriate for this House to understand the policy and rationale behind that\n               choice. I think overall these amendments appear administrative in nature, but they are still\n               part of the broader pattern within this bill of updating statutory authorities in\n               ways that rely heavily on how the resulting powers will be exercised in practice.\n               I look forward to hearing from the minister on how those provisions will be implemented\n               on the ground and how they will be resolved. Finally, I would like to turn to part 4 of the bill, which introduces amendments to\n               the Finally, I would like to turn to part 4 of the bill, which introduces amendments to\n               the Correction Act. This section authorizes the proportionate use of force for the\n               purpose of delivering mental health treatment within correctional facilities and establishes\n               a new investigation and standards office responsible for reviewing complaints made\n               under the act. I think these are significant changes, again, and they respond to a\n               very real challenge within the corrections system. I recently toured the new corrections centre in Oliver and had a great opportunity\n               to tour the centre and meet the staff and hear some of the challenges they are facing\n               on the ground. Individuals in custody do not lose their need for medical care simply\n               because they are in incarcerated. In fact, correctional settings often include individuals\n               with some of the most complex mental health needs in the province. Providing appropriate\n               treatment in this environment is essential, not only for the well-being of the individuals\n               involved but also for the safety of staff and the overall functioning of the correctional\n               system. Authorizing proportionate intervention in order to deliver necessary care\n               recognizes that there are situations in which treatment cannot occur without some\n               level of structured support. I think the creation of the investigation and standards office is an important companion\n               measure within this section of the bill. Establishing a body responsible for reviewing\n               complaints provides an oversight mechanism that helps ensure decisions made under\n               this authority remain accountable and transparent. As this portion of the legislation\n               moves forward, it would be helpful to understand how this office will operate in practice,\n               how it will interact with existing review structures and what reporting expectations\n               will be in place to ensure that both the public and this House can understand how\n               the framework is functioning over time. Stepping back from the individual amendments contained in Bill 16, there is a broader\n               pattern across several parts of this legislation that is worth noting. In multiple\n               sections of the bill, we see authority being created in statute, while the key details\n               of how that authority will operate are deferred to regulation. An example in the amendments to the Fuel Price Transparency Act, the bill establishes\n               authority to charge fees but leaves that structure and amount of those fees to be\n               determined later. In the amendments of the Zero-Emission Vehicles Act, near-term targets are removed\n               from legislation, and future targets are expected to be set through regulation rather\n               than this House. In the housing-related provisions affecting development cost charges, the designation\n               of eligible projects is left to regulation rather than being defined directly in the\n               legislation itself. These all may seem reasonable on their own. Regulation is an important tool. It allows\n               government to respond to changing circumstances, to adjust technical requirements\n               and to refine implementation over time. But it also has scope creep, where government\n               knows best and is implementing from a very small lens from a small group of people. I think legislation provides a framework that members debate publicly and vote on\n               directly. In closing, Bill 16 is a reminder of the unique role that miscellaneous statutes amendment\n               acts play in our legislative process. They bring together a wide range of changes\n               across multiple ministries, and some of those changes are technical, some reflect\n               policy adjustments already underway, and some represent more substantive shifts that\n               deserve careful attention of this House. In this bill, we see examples of each. We see amendments responding to operational\n               needs within correctional facilities and the delivery of mental health care. We see\n               adjustments to the development cost charge authorities that may support housing construction\n               in some communities but do require some review. And we see changes to vehicle electrification\n               targets that reflect evolving realities across the province. At the same time, we also see amendments affecting access to judicial review, the\n               expansion of cabinet confidence protection and several areas where important implementation\n               decisions are being left to regulation rather than defined directly in statute. There are provisions in this bill that I think members will welcome. There are provisions\n               that raise questions that deserve clarification. And there are provisions where the\n               details of implementation will matter just as much as the wording that appears in\n               the statute itself. For that reason, I look forward to the opportunity to examine\n               these sections more closely as the bill proceeds to committee stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721776","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026. As members know, miscellaneous statutes bills bring together amendments\n               across several ministries and policy areas. Some of those changes are technical Donegal Wilson : I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment\n               Act, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["93ea3371ec9edb1f17e06608a22e96c65667ee4bad0f1280ca7618c7083caace"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6dadb6118eb6608e2e685a5550ad97ff078c0086d6e6e38bb3ff289cf26b6dfe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-254cf217de3a75bf17b154fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721778,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yes, I'd like to seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721778","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yes, I'd like to seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","label":"Secondary education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81eea171a6077bb102acc63ce42c730a3514e1e64304f9ba9da19bc73c811ad1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a5260b448fe0670750825790","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721781,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize National Volunteer Week and to celebrate the extraordinary\n               people across British Columbia, especially those in Boundary-Similkameen who give their time, energy and compassion to many groups across B.C. This year's\n               theme is \"Ignite volunteerism.\" It reminds us that strong communities don't just happen.\n               They are built by people who step forward to help their neighbours, organize local\n               events, support families in crisis, coach our youth, protect trails, respond to emergencies\n               and keep community organizations running. In rural communities like mine, volunteers are not simply helpful. They are essential.\n               They are the backbone of our volunteer fire departments, service clubs, agricultural\n               fairs, search and rescue teams, seniors programs and even our community halls. They\n               are the reason small communities remain connected, resilient and welcoming places\n               to live. Volunteers support nearly every part of our lives in British Columbia. They ensure\n               our families have food on the table. They create opportunities for children to play\n               and grow through sport and mentorship. They welcome visitors and strengthen local\n               economies while supporting neighbours through community and housing services. They\n               also steward our land, water and wildlife, maintain our trails and recreation spaces\n               and advocate for important infrastructure that helps communities thrive. There are\n               far too many contributions that I can list today, but every one of them matters. Today I want to thank every volunteer in British Columbia and in the Boundary-Similkameen. Your contributions often happen quietly and often without recognition, but they\n               make a lasting difference every single day. During National Volunteer Week and throughout the year, I encourage all of us to take\n               a moment to recognize the volunteers in our lives and communities. Please take the\n               time to thank that volunteer when you see one. And to everyone who gives their time and makes our communities better, thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721781","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize National Volunteer Week and to celebrate the extraordinary\n               people across British Columbia, especially those in Boundary-Similkameen who give their time, energy and compassion to many groups across B.C. This year's\n               theme is \"Ignite volunteerism.\" It reminds us that strong communities don't just happen.\n               They are built by people w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d8e06d373ca881d67b7dff2b321383e70ba5f60bc7d06ef63ef63bf1d3e37f1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63683e9130c92eba10b443c84a8609677b143f24fc589b57c2d504f0baebac6e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c41c79398601598e70c662f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721785,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"As always, I appreciate the opportunity to rise in this chamber. Today is to speak\n               to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. Now, I want to begin by being very clear. I support treaties. I have always believed\n               that this is the path forward for British Columbia. They are our path to reconciliation.\n               We need that certainty, and we need that path today. They are the path for generations of unresolved legal questions that should have been\n               addressed long ago. My colleague from Skeena articulated this very well, in the sense\n               that it hurts my heart that we have people in our province that live like it's a third-world\n               country. This is British Columbia. There should be nobody living like that in British\n               Columbia. I'm fortunate in my region that many of the nations are struggling but strong. But\n               we have neighbouring nations that are not as strong. I believe that this treaty process\n               is necessary. but I also believe, and I'm kind of sad, at the way this came forward. I believe that for too long in this province, we've avoided that difficult work. We've\n               avoided negotiating the treaties. We have avoided tough conversations around land,\n               resources and wildlife. I believe it has created an imbalance in our society, and\n               it creates different rules for different people. The Indian Act itself creates those\n               different rules for different people. We're all British Columbians. We all deserve to prosper. The modern treaty process\n               exists today to correct that history. It is our attempt to achieve reconciliation.\n               It exists so that rights can be recognized, that lands can be transferred, that governance\n               can be established and that relationships between governments can move forward, and\n               to do that in a stable and respectful foundation where everyone understands the rules. Treaties, when they come forward, should have resolved all outstanding issues. It\n               should not be the role of this House to make those decisions on behalf of nations.\n               That should be done at the treaty table through negotiation. They should bring clarity\n               to jurisdiction. They should create predictability for future decision-making. Most\n               importantly, they should replace conflict with agreement. That's why my heart hurts\n               today, because this treaty is coming forward without those key pieces. It's what reconciliation\n               should look like in practice, but we're not there yet. I want to affirm that treaties are not symbolic documents. These are not intention\n               papers. These are constitutionally protected agreements. They shape how governments\n               will work together for generations. Not today. Not tomorrow. Generations. When this\n               Legislature ratifies a treaty, we're not just simply approving a policy. We're establishing that permanent framework for land, governance, relationships that\n               will affect people across British Columbia long after all of us in this chamber are\n               gone. I'm honoured to be here today to be part of this historical debate. I believe\n               this is why treaties matter and that we need to get this work right. They must be done carefully, thoughtfully, and in a way that strengthens relationships\n               and communities, not only between the Crown and one nation, but among all nations\n               and communities, because the purpose of a treaty is to settle the issues, not to leave\n               them unresolved for the courts to decide later. Bill 20 cannot be discussed without discussing the content of the treaty itself because\n               it literally is the legal mechanism to enact the treaty. I do want to share a quick story from last week. I was having lunch with some constituents\n               here in the Legislative Dining Room, and we had a conversation that of course turned\n               to treaties. It was the day that this treaty was being introduced, that afternoon. One of their questions was, and they asked me directly, what I believed about the\n               treaty process in British Columbia. They asked whether I supported it, and I told\n               them I absolutely did. I told them I believe treaties are the right path forward for\n               this province. I told them that modern treaties are how we move forward and beyond\n               uncertainty, beyond litigation and toward a future built on agreement instead of conflict. And I also told them something else. I told them that I hoped sincerely that nothing\n               in this treaty would put me in a position of not being able to support it, that this\n               government would not put anything in this treaty that would jeopardize this agreement,\n               because I recognize the work that has gone into getting to this point. I recognize the effort by K'ómoks leadership — over generations, at this point. They've\n               been at this for decades. I recognize what this moment represents for them. I was\n               in this chamber when they danced, when they shared from their leadership. I was in\n               the Hall of Honour. I celebrated with them. I want this agreement to be successful. My heart hurts that there are items in this\n               agreement that put that at jeopardy. I believe it is not the role of members of this House.... That we're not at the negotiating\n               table to settle the question of lands. I don't believe.... We weren't there for the\n               decades of discussions. We didn't hear. We don't know what those contexts were. But\n               yet today the responsibility shifts here to this Legislature. This government has brought forward and rushed, in my opinion, a piece of legislation\n               to ratify the results of that work in a week. We'll call it a week. It was eight days\n               ago that this treaty was introduced. And just to be clear, this isn't the only treaty that was introduced last week. We\n               have two treaties that we're working on as opposition. This treaty here is — let me\n               look — 398 pages plus over 700 in appendices. One treaty. We have two of these we're\n               going through right now here in this Legislature, in a week. I take that as a serious responsibility, and I have been reading. I have been educating\n               myself. I have been trying to understand the decisions that were made in this treaty.\n               And I'm hoping that somebody in government can explain to me why they made the decisions\n               they did, because once legislation like this passes, it cannot easily be revised later. All three parties must agree to reopen the treaty. That's the provincial government,\n               the federal government and K'ómoks. All three have to agree to reopen the treaty.\n               And these are not just statutes. These are constitutional frameworks that govern that\n               relationship between our government, the federal government and this country as we\n               move forward. I think one of the most serious concerns for me, being implemented with Bill 20 at\n               this time, is the embedding of the United Nations declaration on the rights of Indigenous\n               Peoples, referred to as UNDRIP. It is embedded into the treaty itself. This is being\n               done at a time in this province where uncertainty exists around UNDRIP and the B.C.\n               legislative framework that we have in B.C. to implement it, which is referred to as\n               DRIPA. I just want to read the section out of the treaty that refers to this. It says on\n               page 7, general provisions, nature of the agreement, section 5, that the United Nations\n               declaration on the rights of Indigenous Peoples is an authoritative source for the\n               interpretation of this agreement and accordingly informs the parties in their implementation\n               of this agreement. Everything we do forward in this agreement will be embedded with UNDRIP. Reading this I struggle with how this government can put forward that legislation\n               today and not ignore the framework that we're sitting in as a province. We're not\n               doing this in isolation Reading this, I struggle with how this government can put forward that legislation\n               today and not ignore the framework that we're sitting in as a province. We're not doing this in isolation of the legal landscape that we live in today. The\n               Premier in the last month has changed positions six times on his direction forward\n               for DRIPA. I'll do a brief quote from an article recently published by Rob Shaw on\n               April 20: \"After another confusing 24 hours of reversals by Premier David Eby, here's\n               where things now stand on his once 'urgent' and 'non-negotiable' changes to the Declaration\n               on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act: they aren't happening after all. For now,\n               anyways, maybe. That's about as much certainty as we can get out of this New Democratic\n               government these days. It seems to switch positions on DRIPA every other day, like\n               a weathervane spinning in the wind.\" I feel, in this Legislature, that quite often we see that as well. At a time when\n               it is clear that this government has no idea how to move forward, they're talking\n               about amendments, they're talking about pausing it, they're talking about kicking\n               it down the road, they're talking about, now, a joint path forward, six months from\n               now. All of those things are in discussion today, and yet this is still embedded in\n               a treaty they also introduced in that framework and context. We're also in the process.... This government is in the process of appealing lawsuits,\n               backstopping mortgages and trying to find a path that protects fee simple land. All\n               of that uncertainty is around, and yet this government, after 30 years, chose this\n               time in history to introduce these treaties. They have done a disservice to the First\n               Nations that put that work in to do that today. It hurts my heart that they would\n               pick this time in history to bring this forward, amongst this chaos. I think with the language of UNDRIP introduced into these treaties, it has fundamentally\n               and foundationally changed the treaties. I think the Minister of Housing and Municipal\n               Affairs clearly articulated that in her speech, where she spoke about this being a\n               living document, that this is going to grow with us, it's changing. All of that is\n               not the certainty that people are looking for within a treaty. I think the cover page alone is the clear marker of the difference. It says: \"K'ómoks First Nation treaty, a living agreement.\" At the same time, when we signed the Nisg̱a'a\n               treaty, the cover page at that time said, \"Nisg̱a'a, final agreement,\" meaning we\n               were reconciled. We agree at this point in time and forever forward that they no longer\n               live under the Indian Act and they are equals in British Columbia. It was a final\n               move. I think it's worth putting a little bit on the record around the timelines around\n               this treaty. I did touch on it briefly. This treaty didn't begin last year. It didn't\n               begin five years ago. It didn't even begin ten years ago. This is over three decades\n               of work. It comes to this Legislature with a week for the opposition and British Columbians\n               to better understand where this is going. Even a year ago, K'ómoks Nation ratified it. This isn't new. The government has known what has been contained\n               in this agreement and yet has not shared it with British Columbians and the opposition\n               until a week ago. We are being asked to review a constitutionally protected agreement,\n               one that will shape land ownership, governance authority, consultation structures,\n               fiscal relationships, wildlife, fish and decision-making processes for generations\n               in the space of a few days. I want to be clear that this is not a criticism of K'ómoks First Nation. They have done the work. They have put in the 30 years. I believe it's\n               this government that is choosing this time and place to introduce this treaty that\n               is flawed. They have included language in here that makes it hard to support. Even beyond the timelines, I think, what is even more concerning for me is that it's\n               clear that the negotiation work isn't done. Last week, as these treaties were being\n               introduced, all members of this chamber were receiving letters. They were letters\n               from neighbouring nations, clearly in opposition and outlining their concerns. This demonstrates to me that the work of the This demonstrates to me that the work of the negotiation table is not done and that\n               this government is choosing to push forward quickly to ratify this treaty, through\n               Bill 20, in spite of that opposition. They are asking us to make the decision to elevate\n               one nation over another. We are legislators. We weren't at the table. Why would you bring a treaty forward\n               that is not finalized, that is not settled? We're asked to make a decision toward\n               settlement of lands to the K'ómoks nation, with neighbouring nations claiming as much as 80 percent overlap with infringement\n               on their rights. These nations are threatening legal challenge if they proceed with this treaty and\n               are requesting that K'ómoks pause their treaty and come to the table to settle the dispute. They can do that either\n               through Indigenous protocol or traditional negotiation tables. When neighbouring nations are telling us they need more time to get a solution, I\n               think that matters. I think it's key that that letter included solutions. It included\n               directions forward. I was also invited by Wei Wai Kum, as were all members of this Legislature, to witness a ceremony with them and their\n               neighbouring nations, to hear them. While all members of this Legislature were invited,\n               I will share that only members of the B.C. Conservative caucus attended, and I was\n               one of those that attended, because as I shared earlier, I'm trying to learn. I'm\n               trying to understand, and I'm trying to support. It is my responsibility to listen\n               to people and to educate myself. What we were asked specifically, at this gathering, to do.... We had ceremony. We had\n               speeches. We heard from Elders, Hereditary Chiefs and elected Chiefs, and what they\n               asked us to do that day was to listen and to bring that message here to the chamber. To honour that, I am going to read a little bit of the letter in from Wei Wai Kum with some of their concerns, to honour that commitment. And I quote from the letter\n               from Wei Wai Kum First Nation on March 27, 2026. I just want to highlight another little section from the letter. It was where they\n               highlighted some of the major impacts and infringements on their treaty. I'm not going\n               to quote it directly, because it's very long. I'm going to just hit the key points\n               from it. I believe the letter is public and available on the Wei Wai Kum website if somebody wants to read the entire letter. But here are a few examples\n               of what they've highlighted. When this treaty is passed, Wei Wai Kum will have no core territory. Their ancestors fought and won many wars to conquer\n               this territory, and they believe that with the lines on the map and words in the treaty,\n               they will have no land to pass on to their grandchildren. This treaty will make it so every project they do as a nation will need K'ómoks permission. K'ómoks will have a treaty right to be consulted on every land development, every economic\n               development initiative and every conservation and stewardship initiative taking place\n               by Wei Wai Kum. K'ómoks will be given preferential treatment as a treaty nation and could block their projects.\n               They provided the example that K'ómoks is already trying to block their wind farm project, underway with the Ministry of\n               Energy and that has been strongly supported by this government. The K'ómoks treaty will give K'ómoks fee simple ownership of the Salmon River reserve, which was created for their ancestors\n               in 1886. K'ómoks only gained an interest via a failed amalgamation in 1941. It also says that K'ómoks will have a right to harvest fish stocks that they have spent decades restoring.\n               They'll be able to interfere with their enhancement projects and their treaty right\n               to harvest sockeye from the enhancement work they have done. They will have no ability to negotiate exclusive fishery areas in their own treaty\n               if they so choose to go that path. They will have no ability to negotiate exclusive fishery areas in their own treaty,\n               if they so choose to go that path, because K'ómoks will have a treaty right already. And K'ómoks will have a treaty right to at least 13.8 percent of the elk in the territory, and\n               the treaty will give B.C. the right to unilaterally increase that harvest amount in\n               the future, something that is not guaranteed for Wei Wai Kum. I hope I honoured the commitment I made to Wei Wai Kum to share that in this House. I believe that they've brought forward some concerns\n               that shouldn't be on us here as legislators to try to sort out. That should have been\n               handled at the negotiation table prior to these treaties coming here. And I know that Wei Wai Kum is not alone in raising these concerns. Those aren't the only letters that we've\n               received as legislators in the last week. There have been nearly two dozen neighbouring\n               nations that have called for a pause on the.... There are three different treaties currently\n               being considered, two that are before the House now. And when nations themselves are\n               asking this Legislature for more time, I believe it's reasonable and responsible for\n               us to listen. I also believe it's important to take additional time when leadership organizations\n               themselves are asking us to take a break, to take a pause, to provide some room. Just yesterday myself and others in this chamber received a letter from the Union\n               of B.C. Indian Chiefs that has also called for a pause in implementation in legislation\n               so that unresolved overlap concerns between nations can be addressed before ratification\n               proceeds. That letter is a news release that can be found online. But I quote from\n               the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs: \"Reconciliation cannot be achieved through incomplete\n               or unilateral processes. Moving forward without resolving shared territory and overlap\n               issues risks undermining relationships between nations and creating long-term uncertainty.\" Treaties are supposed to be creating certainty. These letters prove that that is not\n               what's happening here. And reconciliation is not strengthened by speed. These are\n               decisions that we need to slow down and ensure that we get this right. It has to be\n               durable, transparent and clearly understood by everybody that has to live with them\n               for generations. I think that at their very core, and why I support treaties as a path forward, is\n               that modern treaties are meant to do something very specific. They are meant to create\n               certainty. They define rights. They establish governance relationships. They clarify\n               how decisions will be made between governments, going forward, and they reduce the\n               need for courts to resolve these questions that should instead be resolved through\n               agreement. That certainty will benefit everyone. It benefits First Nations seeking recognition\n               and stability. It benefits communities planning infrastructure and growth. And it\n               benefits industries that are looking to make long-term investments and be partners\n               in these projects. And it benefits the province as a whole by replacing uncertainty\n               and court cases with durable agreements. But when we have this treaty in the House with people threatening legal action before\n               it's even been ratified, we have to ask ourselves if we are achieving those goals.\n               Does this agreement actually increase certainty? Because if it doesn't, it risks shifting\n               unresolved questions from negotiation tables back into the courtroom. And British\n               Columbians don't want to be in court. We need certainty. We need to find a way forward. In the week I've had to review this, I'm struggling. I'm not going to lie. The terms\n               of the treaty and the outcomes that it will create are not clear for me. I believe\n               that I don't want to jeopardize the work of K'ómoks. I know how hard they worked on this. My goal, in fact, is to bring everyone up. I hope that K'ómoks will support a pause to do that work with their neighbouring nations to find a path\n               forward, that they don't put legislators in that position to make that decision. My\n               understanding is that it could be done through standard negotiation tables or through\n               traditional Indigenous protocols, some of which were shared with us by Wei Wai Kum. I think all of this brings me back to the question of timing. Why are we doing this\n               now? I get that we want to get out of court, but by adding UNDRIP language into this\n               treaty at a time when we're already in court about that seems wrong. They define our\n               relationships, going forward. It's supposed to define how our governments will work\n               together. It's supposed to shape land ownership and jurisdiction, yet we hear 80 percent\n               of the land is being They establish long-term fiscal commitments. Normally, those commitments are clearly\n               laid out within the legislation, within the treaty, but in this case it is a living\n               agreement. Those are all put to future agreements that will not come before this Legislature,\n               that will be made by cabinet. Those include finance agreements, governance agreements.\n               There are future agreements around fish harvesting and wildlife coming, and none of\n               that is actually included in the treaty, which is very different from past treaties. You know, these treaties are supposed to be durable. They're supposed to give us a\n               path forward. Right now it's supposed to be the reconciliation that we're all looking\n               for. It's supposed to provide the end. British Columbians want to know how to get to reconciliation. Right now I think many\n               British Columbians don't even know what it is. There is so much confusion around reconciliation\n               and First Nations in this province. This treaty had the opportunity to solve it in\n               one area of our province, but it unfortunately elevates one nation over another. I will want to close by returning to where I began. These treaties matter, because\n               they do provide clarity or should provide clarity, where uncertainty has existed for\n               generations. They should recognize the rights that were never resolved through historical\n               agreements in most of British Columbia. We wouldn't be here today if we'd done that\n               work a long time ago. I think they matter, because they create a framework for governments\n               to move forward together, instead of continually relying on courts to define our relationships. I think that's one of my biggest concerns as we go forward. This is clear, that we're\n               going to be back in court. They've come right out and said it. We're only talking\n               about one treaty here today, but this isn't the only letter, and this isn't the only\n               treaty where we have these letters. I don't believe that it is the role of this Legislature to solve that. I believe the\n               treaty table, the Treaty Commission and the negotiation team should have solved that\n               before it got here. I believe that the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, also asking this\n               Legislature to pause, needs to be heard. I think that we can't continue with unresolved\n               overlap concerns between nations and then be expected to ratify this treaty before\n               that has been solved. I believe that neighbouring nations have asked to be heard. Wei Wai Kum, in this particular treaty, has asked to be heard. With that uncertainty still present,\n               I think our work isn't complete. My hope is that this process can pause here so that\n               this agreement can move forward with the confidence not only of this House, but of\n               the inherent governments whose relationship it will shape for generations. I want treaties to unite us all around a shared certainty. I want us to get to final\n               reconciliation. Taking the time to achieve that certainty now will help ensure this\n               agreement succeeds for everyone involved, for generations. I know that I will reflect back on that conversation I had last week with the constituency\n               in the dining room. I wish that the province had not included language in this treaty\n               that made it questionable whether I could support it. I can say today that, regrettably,\n               they did. That will make supporting this treaty very difficult. I hope with more time\n               and, maybe, through committee stage on this bill, that perhaps those concerns will\n               be addressed, but I'm not feeling very hopeful today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721785","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As always, I appreciate the opportunity to rise in this chamber. Today is to speak\n               to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. Now, I want to begin by being very clear. I support treaties. I have always believed\n               that this is the path forward for British Columbia. They are our path to reconciliation.\n               We need that certainty, and we need that path today. They are ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe44708623ddaff6d7acdf61bb61ac7834fb91b93c98de197e6a7314b146fa0a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8920c1c0327eee3305f01a74e04bad94e85fa19e4dceeae7d87743ff39189ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8cacc872d9eda1b53d3ed4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729593,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Premier announced last Monday that rather than proceed with legislation, this\n               government will now sit down together with the First Nations Leadership Council to\n               find a path forward. Let's examine his track record on transparency and let it speak\n               for itself. The Haida Gwaii deal in September 2025, the Minister of Indigenous Relations\n               found out afterwards. On the shíshálh agreement, the Minister of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship, who is also the local MLA, also was not briefed. My question to the Attorney General: will she commit today that the negotiations underway\n               with the First Nations Leadership Council will be conducted transparently? Or will\n               British Columbians once again find out what their government has agreed to after the\n               deal is done?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729593","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Premier announced last Monday that rather than proceed with legislation, this\n               government will now sit down together with the First Nations Leadership Council to\n               find a path forward. Let's examine his track record on transparency and let it speak\n               for itself. The Haida Gwaii deal in September 2025, the Minister of Indigenous Relations\n               f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a0945150353cf7d6a14f4d42de77e17583f633eb5cabc475862d8ffbb3e37257"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d0164ac910d6ffaed7f8afb87602593f4e60b7d8ab8d9be8f3baf71d8a5eb4a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82d00487e56d2e87cb70727f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729597,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"My office is working with a family whose mother recently broke her femur. This is\n               her third fall and fourth hospitalization in a single year. She cannot stand without\n               a walker. She cannot cook for herself, and she cannot bathe herself. Yet this government\n               has decided that she is eligible six weeks from now for one shower per week, and it's\n               going to be two years before a care home is available for her. Does this minister think that's acceptable, that a senior can only get one shower\n               per week?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729597","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My office is working with a family whose mother recently broke her femur. This is\n               her third fall and fourth hospitalization in a single year. She cannot stand without\n               a walker. She cannot cook for herself, and she cannot bathe herself. Yet this government\n               has decided that she is eligible six weeks from now for one shower per week, and it's\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1161842658366dfc9100068f9e93a064235996b4294f4459ad24fe7f21142c6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af89cd24bfed6e0dd6c0aaed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752376,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I definitely want to stand up in support of the motion, as well as the amendment.\n               In my riding, I only have small independent theatres. I appreciate that the member\n               for Kootenay-Monashee is looking to level the playing field. In my region, I have the Gem Theatre in Grand Forks, as well as the Oliver Theatre\n               in Oliver. Honestly, they're not competing with other large theatres, so the amendment\n               doesn't have a lot of impact in my riding, which is why I support it. We should be\n               enabling businesses in every single way we can to make businesses successful in British\n               Columbia. If it allows liquor to be served in large theatres in certain circumstances\n               now, why wouldn't we just make it level? The rules are the same for everybody. The one thing I do want to say is that I don't really understand why this came forward\n               as a motion. I wish the member had brought it forward as a bill that was actually\n               going to make change. This motion is kind of a temperature check of the House. I find\n               it a little hard to see how this is going to impact change and why we're arguing,\n               unnecessarily, semantics around why the government themselves would be opposed to\n               just saying \"all theatres\" and why there's such strong opposition to that in a motion\n               where we're just checking the temperature in the room. I believe that all businesses need equal rules. When we start trying to figure out\n               who's small and independent, is it somebody who has three theatres? Are they still\n               small and independent? What makes them become a not independent theatre? I think just\n               having a straight \"all theatres\" rule makes sense to me. I wanted to share that I had a fundraising event in Vernon at the Vernon Towne Theatre\n               many years ago. It was for the Lumby Mabel Lake Snowmobile Association. They were\n               doing a screening of a local snowmobile movie. One of the challenges we had at that\n               particular theatre was getting people to attend, getting the 20- to 25-year-olds to\n               come out and participate in a fundraising event when we weren't able to provide any\n               alcohol at the event. We ended up having to rent the entire theatre and get a liquor\n               license and having to do it as a special event venue. I do support the member's motion in removing those barriers. I definitely feel like....\n               Like I said, I just wish it had come forward as a bill that was actually going to\n               make an impact for my theatres in my region. Doing this temperature check, to me,\n               feels kind of.... I wish it was more. I guess, I'll say that. I wish that we were actually\n               making a change for my theatres. I do appreciate that Kootenay-Monashee is probably in a similar position to me, where he has only independent theatres,\n               and I believe that's probably why there is the wording of his motion the way it is.\n               But I don't see omitting \"all theatres\" like we have in the amendment as a negative.\n               I think it just creates a temperature check in the room that we support small business,\n               and we support all small business and large business in British Columbia on an even\n               playing field. I do think that whether alcohol should be served or not is kind of a non-issue. I\n               believe that we have laws and rules in British Columbia. We've had other members speak\n               to being able to lawfully drink in hockey arenas and other venues. I know that in\n               Oliver, regularly, in their arts theatre, they are able to serve some great Oliver,\n               B.C., wine as part of their showing and as part of your evening out on those particular\n               events. I believe that this isn't about whether drinking is responsible or not. I believe\n               that we have the laws in place and we have precedents all over the place. The fact\n               that these independent theatres have not been able to take advantage of that, I think,\n               is why this member has brought forward this motion. I also think that we I believe that this isn't about whether drinking is responsible or not. I believe\n               that we have the laws in place, and we have precedents all over the place. The fact\n               that these independent theatres have not been able to take advantage of that, I think,\n               is why this member has brought forward this motion. I also think that we just want to ensure that there's flexibility in the business\n               model for all businesses. I agree with the other member that this gets people out.\n               It gets them.... They go out for dinner. They make it an evening. They might actually\n               do something else while they're out. In small towns, quite often, once we get home,\n               not much is open. We end up tending to kind of find at-home pursuits. So I support\n               anything that gets people outside in their community and being part of their community. But I do support the amendment and want all businesses to be on an equal playing field.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752376","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I definitely want to stand up in support of the motion, as well as the amendment.\n               In my riding, I only have small independent theatres. I appreciate that the member\n               for Kootenay-Monashee is looking to level the playing field. In my region, I have the Gem Theatre in Grand Forks, as well as the Oliver Theatre\n               in Oliver. Honestly, they're not competing wit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de4d6fa19f9eff9acf8c6ef199ed49622c665455dcec173e562b54e57868bad2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0c5b1f293ab3942287c0518d474397c890e64ce3d17cea7887d4a14425b0e27"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d03f05a8f70390d092eab3b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752377,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the incredible playoff run of our Princeton Posse. Over\n               the past few weeks, the excitement has been building. Our community watched with pride\n               as this team fought its way to the Kootenay International Junior A Hockey League finals,\n               then carried our region all the way to game seven to a double-overtime finish. That's\n               not just hockey. That is heart, that is resilience, and that is what small communities\n               do best. On behalf of myself and the member for Columbia River–Revelstoke, I want to extend a congratulations to the Kimberley Dynamiters on a win they truly\n               earned. Over the last few weeks, we've enjoyed connecting after every game to cheer\n               our teams on in a little fun. But kidding aside, a game seven double-overtime finish\n               reflects the determination and the skill of both teams, and it was a series worth\n               watching to the very end. The Princeton Posse represented Princeton and the entire Boundary-Similkameen region with determination and class right to the final shift. They carried forward\n               a proud hockey tradition in a town where our arena remains a gathering place for our\n               whole community. Runs like this don't happen by accident. They happen because of coaches who led, volunteers\n               who organized, billets who opened their homes, families who travel thousands of kilometres\n               and get up early, early hours, donations that help pay the bills and put gas on the\n               bus and fans who packed the arena to believe in their team. But most of all, they\n               happen because of players who chose to represent a small town with big pride. To the Princeton Posse, thank you. I am proud to stand here today and say that across\n               Boundary-Similkameen, we are all proud of how you represented our region with grit, with heart and with\n               everything that defines small-town British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752377","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the incredible playoff run of our Princeton Posse. Over\n               the past few weeks, the excitement has been building. Our community watched with pride\n               as this team fought its way to the Kootenay International Junior A Hockey League finals,\n               then carried our region all the way to game seven to a double-overtime finish. That's\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0ad908d84c0f22daf0d2c5781ed059c3f393323f03aaa5fc6b0e65dc0db5aa4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58c6232e5decb6c15f7bbd50401bd324d0d7c375bb24ac0e6d0b299706de6cea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43ee4635a10df1d958830f65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752378,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government has a dismal record and already has the most projects with cost overruns\n               in B.C.'s history, yet this Finance Minister has decided to try and balance her budget\n               by taxing her own government. Applying PST to provincial infrastructure projects doesn't\n               balance the budget, and it doesn't make these projects any more affordable for British\n               Columbians. A simple question to the minister. Did government exempt themselves from their own\n               PST expansion, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752378","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This government has a dismal record and already has the most projects with cost overruns\n               in B.C.'s history, yet this Finance Minister has decided to try and balance her budget\n               by taxing her own government. Applying PST to provincial infrastructure projects doesn't\n               balance the budget, and it doesn't make these projects any more affordable for British\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ccd5ec716a2e9b2b0e2c74a3ca6a33a23565803bf050a21a5cfa64403d2e202"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e77037d828c25dd04abc765aa1b19de565016b3fb67afe9948750b17d482dfb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a15ed22aa0fbd89a46c4c099","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017725,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"A few weeks ago, the Minister of Environment said: \"We're going to continue to make\n               sure that our B.C. parks have access for everyone.\" Since then, she has announced\n               that Joffre Lakes Provincial Park will be closed","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017725","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A few weeks ago, the Minister of Environment said: \"We're going to continue to make\n               sure that our B.C. parks have access for everyone.\" Since then, she has announced\n               that Joffre Lakes Provincial Park will be closed","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a358800bd6cc830f2177b34713f0e7f627865a0882c34f127e80bef9fc8ca01d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da88dd9bb8a0ab1560f27e9007c1515785f11346770c27b2de3d615f7cf8c513"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff552ad82222f4e0e597f0f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017726,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the opportunity to rise today to speak to this motion to refer Bill 20,\n               the K'ómoks Treaty Act, to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I was very excited when I was appointed to that committee when I first came to this\n               building and was equally disappointed when I realized that they have not met in over\n               20-something years. At a time in this province where Indigenous relations is at an\n               all-time high, you would think that this cross-party committee would be doing the\n               important work needed for British Columbians. Similar to my first speech, I want to be clear that I support treaty. I do believe\n               it is the way forward. I shared in that speech how I felt disappointed in the treaty,\n               the way it came forward and some of the language that was chosen to be included in\n               that treaty. I think that this motion allows us to go away and correct that, to allow\n               the people of K'ómoks, who have invested 30 years — as the member for Nechako shared, generations — into getting to this day. But we can't stand here today and pretend that this treaty is operating in isolation\n               of other things happening in our province. We have a Premier who has had five plans\n               in five weeks about what he's doing with DRIPA. We have legal challenges. We have\n               U.S. tribes that are pushing in. We have all of these happening at the same time that\n               this government has chosen this moment in time to bring these treaties forward in\n               that landscape. To me, it was a disservice to the people of K'ómoks, Kitselas, and Kitsumkalum eventually. I believe that this is.... Nechako mentioned it is an olive branch. I think this is\n               the olive branch. I think this is an opportunity for us to come together across party\n               lines and find a durable solution forward. Yes, I did use the word \"durable,\" which\n               has been driving me nuts all week, but I will use it in this particular case. The reason that it's important is because Bill 20 is not an ordinary bill. This is\n               a treaty. It brings into force the modern treaty. This is not the modern treaties\n               that we've seen to date. There's language included in these treaties that is new and\n               different than any treaty we've seen before, specifically the fact that it is a living\n               agreement and that that living agreement demands some scrutiny. When I did my first speech here on this particular bill, I spoke about how I felt\n               I had a responsibility, that Wei Wai Kum and other members of the Island brought forward their concerns. I agreed during that\n               ceremony to bring those concerns forward and read them into the record, which I did.\n               I believe that I did honour that commitment. But by using the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs, it allows them to\n               read their own story into the record. It's not me reading it into the record for them.\n               It allows us to hear from those nations, to understand the concerns. It allows us\n               to have discussions around governance, around land harvesting rights, around resource\n               development and how that has impacts on neighbouring nations and what that looks like\n               going forward. It allows that testimony to come in as evidence. It allows public submissions. It\n               allows direct testimony from affected parties on all sides. It allows us to have detailed\n               questions and conversations, and it creates that transparent public record. While there was extensive consultation done in the Comox area, around the K'ómoks treaty, the fact that this treaty is new and different sets the precedent for all other\n               treaties in the province. I believe that other British Columbians want to participate\n               and have a say in what these treaties look like going forward. For me, this isn't about being obstructive. It is not about For me, this isn't about being obstructive. It's not about standing here and filibustering.\n               For me, it's about due diligence, and I believe that this committee allows us to do\n               that due diligence to come to a solution. I think, frankly, if government feels confident\n               in both the treaty and the process that got us here today, they should welcome this\n               opportunity to make it public and not be seen as a threat. It should be viewed as\n               an opportunity. I think that opportunity is to strengthen public confidence to try to undo some of\n               the damage this government has done in creating any Indigenous sentiment across this\n               province. It allows us to go and work in a cross-party way to find solutions for this\n               treaty and the future treaties that will follow. I think they will succeed, because we have to have confidence in the process, and\n               to date, I don't think that confidence exists, and that is why people are looking\n               for a new way forward. That's why this motion was brought forward to send it to the\n               Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I look forward to being part of that\n               committee, and I look forward to being part of that work. I have spoken previously in this chamber about why treaties matter, and I want to\n               be equally clear again today that I support modern treaties, but there is language\n               in these treaties that I cannot support. That really, really hurts my heart for both\n               the K'ómoks People, who have put so much time and energy into it, and the other nations that will\n               follow with future treaties. I support that treaties are supposed to create greater certainty for Indigenous nations,\n               governments, communities and British Columbians, and that has always been my position.\n               I have always said that I believe treaties are the way forward. I shared in my last\n               speech.... I shared with somebody that I really hoped that these treaties were something\n               I could get behind, because this is what I want for the future of British Columbia. But these treaties have language in them that is very concerning. It is clear that\n               there is work still to be done. There are unclear overlaps between neighbouring nations\n               that have brought that forward. I think that we have the ability, through the standing\n               committee, to hear those voices, implement them into the decision and find a direction\n               forward. I feel like it will create an avenue to bring forward legitimate concerns that I feel,\n               today, perhaps have been unheard. I think that it will increase transparency in the\n               treaty process and engage British Columbians in a direction forward. I believe that\n               it could prevent us from just going back to court. While we are trying to do a treaty with K'ómoks and we're creating certainty for K'ómoks, at the same time, we're creating uncertainty with neighbouring nations. There has\n               been very strong language used by the neighbouring nations around their concerns that\n               they've brought forward. Those court challenges could just tie us up even further. The Premier has shared,\n               though he has yet to name, the 20 court cases that exist today. Are we looking to\n               add to that number, or are we looking to find solutions? By moving this to a standing committee, we can find solutions. It doesn't just shift\n               that uncertainty into the future, onto a different nation. It allows the playing fields\n               to level. We're not, as a legislature, being forced to pick one nation over another\n               and trying to validate whether those claims are valid or not. Their claims need to\n               be on the record, and the select standing committee provides that opportunity for\n               them to come onto the record. I think that we need to find a way, and thank you to the member for Langley–Walnut Grove that brought this motion forward, because I think the standing committee is the way,\n               and it is a way for us to move forward. I think it creates a process for the concerns\n               to be heard, and I believe that it provides an opportunity for all of this to come\n               onto the record in public. I don't have to stand here and read other people's concerns\n               into the record for them. They can come and share their concerns themselves. I think we need to be really clear that Bill 20 is not regular legislation. This is,\n               honestly, life-changing legislation for K'ómoks, but it could be life-changing for the neighbouring nations as well. It could permanently\n               pull them down in a way that they can't get back up. We need to figure out a way forward,\n               and we need to hear those concerns, and the select standing committee would provide\n               that opportunity. If this agreement took decades to negotiate, which we know it did.... I shared this\n               before. Why is the Legislature now rushing to get this to the finish line? We have\n               eight days left in the legislation, and I think it is our role to get that to the\n               finish line. I think the select standing committee will do that, and I hope that the\n               members on all sides of the House will support I think the select standing committee will do that, and I hope that the members on\n               all sides of the House will support this motion to move this to a select standing\n               committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017726","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the opportunity to rise today to speak to this motion to refer Bill 20,\n               the K'ómoks Treaty Act, to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I was very excited when I was appointed to that committee when I first came to this\n               building and was equally disappointed when I realized that they have not met in over\n               20-something years. A","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ed4f62e84f2af6caf3def7c70da4acc8fe5e84b0dc139f7705a8e421af9a9a4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31f45cad9548b3eff2a70469cd2652d80c10d7d336fffceeb8eb64f9aab560b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-993932faae6edfe3ea1cf2be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036617,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak about something I'm hearing with increasing frequency from across\n               British Columbia. That's from small business owners, tourism operators, ranchers,\n               tenure holders, resource users and ordinary British Columbians simply trying to navigate\n               government. That is this. The Ministry of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship appears increasingly frozen in place, not because staff do not care and not because\n               applicants are failing to do the work but because government has created a system\n               where staff themselves seem unclear on what the rules actually are. British Columbians are trying to renew land tenures. They're applying for foreshore\n               leases. They're advancing their water licence applications. They're moving projects\n               forward that should be straightforward. Instead, they find themselves trapped in a\n               bureaucratic purgatory. Months become years. Files sit untouched. Applicants receive\n               vague responses like \"more engagement required,\" \"further information needed,\" \"additional\n               studies may be necessary.\" But there's no clear pathway to resolution, no certainty,\n               no timelines and no actual decision-making. Increasingly, what I hear is this. If you don't arrive with letters of support already\n               in hand from every potentially affected First Nation, your file will simply just sit\n               there — not because legislation clearly says that, not because a formal decision has\n               been made, but because staff no longer seem confident in what standard applies. Is\n               it consultation? Is it consent? Is it something else entirely? Because of that uncertainty,\n               files are simply left to drift. That is not reconciliation, and that is not transparency.\n               It certainly is not good governance. So let me be clear. Meaningful consultation with Indigenous communities matters. Respectful\n               engagement matters. Strong relationships matter. But what does not serve anyone, including\n               First Nations, is a provincial government that refuses to provide clear direction\n               to its own public service. What happens when government staff are left without clarity? Applicants are sent chasing\n               their tails, more reports are commissioned, more studies are required, and more procedural\n               hoops are created. When frustration inevitably grows, government quietly allows the\n               perception to form that Indigenous consultation is the cause for this delay. That\n               is deeply unfair because in many of these cases, the real issue is not consultation That is deeply unfair, because in many of these cases, the real issue is not consultation.\n               It is provincial indecision. It is a ministry that no longer appears confident in\n               its own authority to make decisions. We have watched this shift over time from consultation\n               to discussions around consent and now increasingly towards a model that is true co-governance. Whether members support that evolution or not, one thing should be obvious. Government\n               has a responsibility to clearly define how British Columbia continues to function,\n               how business continues, how applications move, how decisions get made, what the timelines\n               are. Because right now, that clarity does not exist, and sectors are feeling it. During estimates this year, we heard directly that stakeholders in the adventure tourism\n               sector, operators whose livelihoods depend on access, renewal and predictable approvals,\n               are stalled. And the solution? A dedicated single window process just for them to\n               navigate government dysfunction. Think about that. An entire sector now believes that the only way to survive is to\n               create a special access point into government that goes around the regular system\n               that no longer functions. Surprisingly, government has agreed to this. They've stood\n               up the mechanisms to do just that — help one sector try to move while thousands of\n               other applicants will remain stuck in the same broken queue. Small operators, farmers, community groups, businesses, families, people trying to\n               renew what they already hold. People are simply asking for a decision — not special\n               treatment, just a decision. This is becoming a competitiveness issue, an affordability\n               issue and a true survival issue for small businesses in British Columbia. Uncertainty\n               kills investment, and bureaucratic paralysis destroys trust. British Columbians should\n               not need consultants, political intervention or insider navigation just to get a basic\n               government file processed. At the narrows in Sicamous, one applicant has spent years and hundreds of thousands\n               of dollars just trying to rebuild his dock that sits amongst hundreds of other docks.\n               Its own staff doesn't appear to have the proper training, understand the proper process,\n               and it owes applicants clear expectations. I believe that it owes First Nations a process that is respectful, transparent and\n               not its political cover for provincial dysfunction. Because right now what we're seeing\n               is not leadership; it is paralysis, and British Columbians are paying the price.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036617","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak about something I'm hearing with increasing frequency from across\n               British Columbia. That's from small business owners, tourism operators, ranchers,\n               tenure holders, resource users and ordinary British Columbians simply trying to navigate\n               government. That is this. The Ministry of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship appears increasin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23009acaff8c48f1853154d8975166d197a6ef6d292a925a2bde5e19afb09cdd","493989cab81afa7213d6ed88c451ae3aef26ef23fb60dafa5d8040b735b0075c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53804fe35c260f2f42caebb46e04846a1afb171e5dd998b2f9e63ee15b644543"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b138a2a455f6358c00bafb91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036618,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Donegal Wilson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would also like to make a few comments about the report. The committee's spring meeting with statutory officers was a really important opportunity\n               to receive operational updates from each of the offices and hear about what their\n               key priorities and focus areas are going to be for the coming year. This year, the committee also asked for updates regarding the corporate shared services The committee's spring meeting with statutory officers was a really important opportunity\n               to receive operational updates from each of the offices and hear about what their\n               key priorities and focus areas are going to be for the coming year. This year the\n               committee also asked for updates regarding the corporate shared service agreements,\n               office space and lease agreements and grants that were being administered by the offices. Committee members continue to encourage our statutory officers to examine these areas\n               of focus and other areas to find savings and efficiencies as they prepare for their\n               budget requests for this fall. I'd like to extend my appreciation to all the statutory officers for taking the time\n               to meet with us and for their valuable work for all British Columbians. I would also\n               like to acknowledge the members of the committee for their hard work and the staff\n               of the Parliamentary Committees Office for supporting our work, as well as Hansard. In closing, I would like to thank all of the committee for their work, and I look\n               forward to heading out for public consultation on this year's coming budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036618","member_id":"bc-mla-358","member_name":"Donegal Wilson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would also like to make a few comments about the report. The committee's spring meeting with statutory officers was a really important opportunity\n               to receive operational updates from each of the offices and hear about what their\n               key priorities and focus areas are going to be for the coming year. This year, the committee also asked for updates regarding the corporate","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f0ad95df571a9bf17c4fa74b74bd85482fd5f3b1d9d2118f6a5979d45d7b85d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f65d65061779e183c7a175b6cd418178d84d78109d85696f7a86906da9a6be6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b51345b0c4c72d5a60d4563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317144,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin my remarks, I would like to send my condolences out to Tumbler Ridge.\n               As former mayor of a small community, my heart reaches out to you. I know council\n               and mayor are going to be struggling for some time to wrap your heads around the tragedy\n               that happened. Whether it's one family or more, you don't heal that quickly. We're here, we're thinking\n               about you, and my colleague from South Peace.... He'll be with you. I rise today I rise today to speak to Budget 2026, and I do so as the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine, as a critic for rural infrastructure and rural development and as someone who represents\n               one of the largest, most geographically complex and most resource-dependent regions\n               in this province. I rise not simply to speak about the fiscal plan, but to speak about the people behind\n               that plan, the communities that will feel its impact and the growing disconnect between\n               what this government promises and what rural British Columbia is actually experiencing. I would like to begin by acknowledging the highlights of this budget. Sadly, after\n               reviewing the document in detail and speaking with constituents across my riding,\n               I must say I see no mention of any that meaningfully apply to Bulkley Valley–Stikine or to many of the rural and northern communities that I represent. That is not a rhetorical point, nor is it intended to be dismissive for the sake of\n               opposition. It is an honest conclusion that comes from asking a very simple question.\n               Where in this budget do the people of the northwest see themselves? I find it not\n               only disappointing but frankly disrespectful that once again, there is no meaningful\n               mention of investment in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. The province continues to look to the northwest for resource revenue and economic\n               contribution. It continues to rely on the industry's workers and the communities of\n               the North to support provincial prosperity. Yet when it comes time to reinvest in\n               those same communities, to build the infrastructure required to sustain that contribution\n               or to support the families who make it possible, the North is once again overlooked. That imbalance is not new. But it's becoming more and more pronounced, and this budget\n               does nothing to correct it. Instead, it reinforces a pattern that many people in my\n               riding have come to expect, which is that rural communities are asked to contribute\n               more while receiving less in return. This budget must also be understood in the broader context of the province's fiscal\n               position. We're now facing a projected deficit of $13.3 billion. Even as the government\n               introduces new taxes and expands existing ones, this is not a situation where the\n               province is struggling due to a lack of revenue. It is a situation where the spending\n               has grown beyond what can reasonably be sustained, and where the government has not\n               demonstrated a credible plan to bring that spending under control. For the people in my riding, this raises serious concerns about accountability and\n               long-term sustainability. They're being asked to pay more in taxes while seeing little\n               improvement in services, infrastructure or economic opportunity. They're being asked\n               to trust that this government has a plan, even as the numbers suggest otherwise. I want to take some time to speak about what has actually happened over the past year\n               in Bulkley Valley–Stikine, because this budget does not exist in isolation. It lands in communities that are\n               already facing significant challenges, and it must be evaluated in that context. In Houston, the closure of the Canfor mill has had a profound and ongoing impact.\n               This was not just a loss of a workplace; it was a loss of a central economic pillar\n               that supported families, local businesses and municipal revenues. The ripple effects\n               of that closure have been significant and far-reaching. Workers have lost stable employment,\n               and many have been forced to leave the community in search of other opportunities. Small businesses have seen reduced activity, as fewer people are able to spend locally.\n               The municipality itself is now facing a substantial budget shortfall due to the loss\n               of industrial tax revenue, forcing difficult decisions about service levels and long-term\n               planning. This is not a temporary setback. It represents a structural shift in the local economy,\n               one that requires a coordinated and meaningful response from the province. Yet when\n               we look at this budget, we see no targeted support for Houston, no transition strategy\n               for forestry-dependent communities and no acknowledgement of the scale of the challenge that these communities are now facing. Houston is not alone. Across Bulkley Valley–Stikine and across northern British Columbia, the forest sector is experiencing one of the\n               most difficult periods in recent history. Communities like Burns Lake, Smithers and\n               Hazelton have relied on forestry for generations. It has provided stable employment,\n               supported families and sustained local economies. Today that stability is increasingly\n               uncertain. We are seeing mill closures, reduced harvest levels, declining investment and growing\n               concern about the future of the industry. Workers who have spent decades building\n               their lives around forestry are now facing difficult questions about what comes next.\n               Young people are leaving communities because they do not see opportunities Young people are leaving communities because they do not see opportunities for themselves\n               in the region. Local governments are struggling to maintain services as their tax\n               base declines. And we all know, those who have been in local government, local municipalities\n               are bound by the province to balance their budgets. The province is not. Industry leaders have been clear in their assessment of the situation, with some stating\n               that they have never seen conditions this severe in decades of experience. That level\n               of concern should prompt urgent action from this government. Instead, what we see\n               in this budget is a reduction in forestry funding and no clear path for how to support\n               the sector or the communities that depend on it. That is not a strategy. That is an\n               absence of leadership. As a critic for rural infrastructure and rural development, I must also speak to the\n               broader issue of infrastructure, because this is where the consequences of government\n               decisions are often most visible in rural communities. Infrastructure in rural British\n               Columbia is not simply a matter of convenience. It is essential to safety, connectivity\n               and economic viability. Roads, bridges, health care facilities and emergency services are the lifelines that\n               connect communities, that allow them to function. However, what we continue to see\n               is a pattern in which major infrastructure projects in urban centres receive significant\n               attention and funding, even as they experience substantial cost overruns and delays,\n               while rural infrastructure needs remain underfunded or even ignored. Billions of dollars have been added to the costs of large-scale projects across the\n               province, yet comparatively modest investments in rural communities continue to be\n               deferred. In Bulkley Valley–Stikine, the infrastructure needs are clear and well documented. Highway 37 requires upgrades\n               to ensure safety and support of economic development. This is where the province is\n               setting their sights. This is a critical corridor for northern British Columbia, yet\n               it continues to be overlooked in favour of projects elsewhere. In Telkwa, the existing bridge across the Bulkley River is aging and no longer adequate\n               for a growing community. In Hazelton, Wrinch Memorial Hospital is operating beyond capacity, placing strain on both staff and patients. In Atlin, there has been a long-standing effort to secure funding for a new ambulance\n               station and fire hall, yet progress has been slow. In Kitwanga, residents have raised nearly $1 million themselves to support essential\n               infrastructure, demonstrating extraordinary commitment, yet still waiting for meaningful\n               provincial support. These are not new issues. They have been raised repeatedly in this House and in discussions\n               with government, yet they remain unaddressed. When communities are raising their own funds for basic infrastructure, when they are\n               organizing bake sales in local fundraising efforts to support projects that should\n               be the responsibility of the province, it raises a fundamental question about priorities.\n               How much more are these communities expected to do on their own? At what point does\n               the province step in and fulfil its role? The reality is that the cost overruns on a single major project elsewhere in British\n               Columbia could fund multiple critical infrastructure projects in my riding. This is\n               not an exaggeration. That is a reflection of how resources are currently being allocated. Example: Site C dam, over budget by $7.225 billion. Surrey-Langley SkyTrain, over\n               budget by $1.98 billion. Second Surrey hospital, over budget by $1.21 billion, etc.,\n               etc., etc. One of those overruns would have funded projects in my riding. This issue extends beyond my riding and speaks to a broader provincial challenge.\n               As a critic for rural infrastructure and rural development, I hear from communities\n               across British Columbia that are facing similar issues. In the Cariboo, in the Kootenays,\n               in the Peace region and on the north coast, communities are dealing with aging infrastructure,\n               limited access to services and increasing financial pressures. They are struggling\n               to maintain what they have, let alone invest in what they need for the future. The message from these communities is consistent. They feel overlooked. They feel\n               underfunded. They feel like they are expected to contribute to the province's economy\n               without receiving the support necessary to sustain their own communities. I want to turn now to the issue of affordability, because this is another area where\n               this budget fails — fails to meet the needs of British Columbians. This budget introduces\n               over a billion in new taxes on working families, including increases to personal income\n               taxes and the expansion of provincial sales tax to additional goods and services. In rural communities, the impact of these changes is even more pronounced. People\n               already pay more for fuel, more People already pay more for fuel, more for groceries and more for basic services due\n               to distance and limited options. The expansion of the PST to services such as shoe\n               repair, bookkeeping and other essential services may seem minor in isolation, but\n               for families who rely on these services as part of their daily lives, the additional\n               cost is significant. This is not about luxury spending. This is about everyday necessities. When people\n               are working hard and still struggling to get ahead, adding new costs only makes that\n               situation worse. Stakeholders across this province have raised serious concerns about the direction\n               of this budget. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business has warned that it\n               will deepen what it describes as an entrepreneurial drought. Highlighting the challenges\n               facing small businesses is already difficult in this economic environment. The Business\n               Council of British Columbia has similarly raised concerns about weak private sector\n               growth and the impact of new taxes on investment. These are not partisan voices. These are organizations that represent businesses,\n               workers and communities across the province. When they raise concerns, those concerns\n               should be taken seriously. The cumulative effect of these policies is a growing sense of uncertainty. Businesses\n               are hesitant to invest. Workers are uncertain about their future. Communities are\n               questioning whether they will have the resources they need to sustain themselves.\n               That uncertainty has real consequences, and it is felt most acutely in communities\n               that do not have the same margin for error as larger urban centres. In rural British Columbia, when a major employer closes, when a piece of infrastructure\n               fails or when a service is reduced, there are fewer alternatives available. People\n               cannot simply relocate services, switch providers or observe increased costs without\n               consequence. Instead, they are forced to make difficult decisions about their livelihoods,\n               their families and their futures. This is why the decisions reflected in this budget matter so deeply. They're not just\n               fiscal choices. They are choices about whether communities will grow or decline, whether\n               families will stay or leave and whether real British Columbia will be treated as an\n               equal partner in this province's future. I've heard many of the ministers across the aisle speak about investing in every corner\n               of this province. Every corner. Well, I certainly don't see it in Bulkley Valley–Stikine, so I think maybe they figure the province stops at Prince George. I'm not really\n               sure. I want to turn now to health care because this is one of the most pressing and personal\n               issues facing my constituents. In Bulkley Valley–Stikine, access to health care is not guaranteed. It is uncertain, it is inconsistent, and\n               in some cases, it is simply unavailable when it's most needed. As I mentioned earlier, taxpayers in this province contribute to health care at multiple\n               levels. They contribute federally, provincially and in many cases locally through\n               municipal taxes and hospital districts. In some jurisdictions, local tax dollars are\n               used to support health care infrastructure, including clinics and hospitals. This\n               means that in many cases, individuals are effectively paying into the same system\n               multiple times. Given that level of investment, is it reasonable to expect a certain level of service?\n               Yet what are we seeing across British Columbia and particularly in rural areas? It\n               is a system that is struggling to meet basic expectations. Emergency rooms have been\n               closed temporarily due to staffing shortages. Hospital hours have been reduced. Patients\n               are being asked to travel significant distances for care that should be available\n               in their own communities. In 2025 alone, there were over 250 temporary emergency room closures across the province.\n               That number is not just a statistic. It represents real situations where people arrived\n               at a hospital expecting care, only to find that it was not available. It represents\n               moments of uncertainty, anxiety and, in some cases, serious risk. For someone living in a major urban centre, an emergency room closure may mean travelling\n               to another facility a short distance away. For someone in Bulkley Valley–Stikine, it may mean travelling hours to access care. That difference matters, and it highlights\n               the importance of ensuring that rural health care is not treated as an afterthought. Despite these challenges, this budget does not provide a clear plan to address health\n               care access in rural British Columbia and rural communities. It does not offer new\n               solutions to staffing shortages, nor does it outline a strategy for reducing service\n               disruptions. Instead, it continues with the same approach that has led us to this\n               current situation, leaving communities uncertain about what that future holds. I also want to speak about seniors, because this budget fails I also want to speak about seniors, because this budget fails to recognize their needs\n               in a meaningful way. Seniors in my riding, like seniors across British Columbia, have\n               contributed to their communities for decades. They have worked, raised their families\n               and helped build the province we all benefit from today. Many of them now live on\n               fixed incomes and are facing increasing costs for housing, utilities, and basic necessities.\n               The expansion of taxes in this budget combined with rising costs places additional\n               pressures on seniors who are already managing tight budgets. At the same time, delays in long-term care, infrastructure and ongoing challenges\n               in health care access create further uncertainty about their ability to receive the\n               care they need as they age. As one seniors advocate has noted, this budget does little\n               to address the needs of seniors, leaving many to question whether their concerns are\n               being heard. That is a serious concern, and it is one that should be addressed with\n               urgency. I had a constituent when I was home last time. His mother is 91. They're a farming\n               family. This is probably the second generation. She's moved into a smaller home, so\n               she's close to her family. At 91, their assessments on their properties have gone\n               up 30 percent, and now they're going to lose their $200 homeowners grant on top of\n               everything else. I want to return to the broader issue of economic development, because this is where\n               the long-term implications of this budget become most apparent. The government has\n               spoken about the importance of critical minerals, of natural resource development\n               and of economic opportunity in the North. These are important discussions and they\n               reflect real potential. However, potential alone is not enough. Economic development\n               requires a foundation and that foundation is infrastructure, services and community\n               stability. Without that foundation, investment will not occur, projects will not proceed\n               and opportunities will not be realized. This is particularly important in the context of the northwest, where the province\n               is increasingly looking to support its economic future. The history of this region\n               provides an important lesson. In the late 1860s, the discovery of gold in the Omineca\n               region brought attention and investment to northern British Columbia. People came\n               in search of opportunity, and communities were built as a result. Today we are seeing a similar moment with renewed interest in the resource of the\n               northwest but if the province hopes to benefit from that opportunity it must also\n               be prepared to invest in the communities that will make it possible. It cannot simply\n               extract value without reinvesting in the infrastructure and services that support\n               that value. This is where the role of rural infrastructure become so critical. It is not just\n               about maintaining roads or building bridges. It is about enabling economic activity,\n               supporting communities and ensuring that growth is sustainable. It is about recognizing\n               that rural British Columbia is not peripheral to the province's success, but central\n               to it. In my role as critic for rural infrastructure and rural development, I've had the\n               opportunity to speak with communities across the province, and the message is remarkably\n               consistent. Rural communities want to be part of the solution. They want to contribute\n               to economic growth. They want to build a strong sustainable future, but they need\n               the tools to do it. They need reliable infrastructure. They need access to health\n               care. They need support for industries. They need policies that recognize their unique\n               challenges and they need a government that listens. I also want to address the issue of fiscal accountability because this underpins everything\n               else. The scale of spending in this budget is unprecedented, approaching $100 billion\n               annually, yet the outcomes do not reflect that level of investment. Services are not\n               improving at the rate that spending is increasing. Infrastructure is not being delivered\n               efficiently, and the province's financial position continues to deteriorate. Stakeholders have raised serious concerns about this trajectory. The Canadian Taxpayers\n               Federation has warned about rising debt and the need for spending restraint. Business\n               organizations have highlighted the impact of uncertainty on investment decisions.\n               Economists have pointed to the growing gap between spending and results. These concerns are not ideological; they are practical. They reflect a recognition\n               that fiscal sustainability is essential to long-term prosperity. Without it, the province\n               will face increasing constraints, and the ability to invest in communities will be\n               diminished. I want to return, in closing, to the people of Bulkley Valley–Stikine, because ultimately, this is who this discussion is about. This riding spans over\n               164,000 square kilometres and includes communities that are diverse, resilient and\n               deeply connected to the land. Many families in this region are multigenerational with\n               strong ties to their communities and a commitment to building their futures there. People choose to live in the North because they value the lifestyle, the sense of\n               community and the opportunities that it provides. They are proud of where they live,\n               and they are willing to work hard to sustain it, but they should not be expected to\n               do so without support. They should not be expected to accept a lower standard of service\n               or lack of investment simply because of where they live. They deserve the same level\n               of attention, the same level of respect and the same level of support as any other\n               community in this province. This budget does not deliver that. It does not invest in the infrastructure that rural\n               communities need. It does not address the challenges facing key industries. It does\n               not improve access to health care. It does not provide meaningful relief to families\n               or seniors. And it does not demonstrate the fiscal responsibility that British Columbians\n               expect. Budgets are about priorities. They reflect what a government chooses to focus on and\n               what it chooses to leave behind. In this case, it is clear that rural British Columbia\n               has once again been left behind. The people of Bulkley Valley–Stikine deserve better. They deserve to be recognized for their contributions, supported\n               in their challenges and included in the province's vision for their future. They deserve\n               a government that understands their realities and is prepared to act on them. This\n               budget does not meet that standard, and for that reason, I cannot support this budget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317144","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Before I begin my remarks, I would like to send my condolences out to Tumbler Ridge.\n               As former mayor of a small community, my heart reaches out to you. I know council\n               and mayor are going to be struggling for some time to wrap your heads around the tragedy\n               that happened. Whether it's one family or more, you don't heal that quickly. We're here, we're thin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d3322b2f9771c9eceae8ff42573744d38126d9f2eb4257859a256bc0763136c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8bc4ea85f512daa570bf4a5249815f95971abd1e93186fbdfa60abfe12fb5e29"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-707e28e7239c422c672bd478","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327979,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"June 5, 2020 marked the 100th anniversary of the Bulkley Valley District Hospital\n               auxiliary. This volunteer-run society, which has provided financial and material support\n               to the hospital since its beginning, may well be the oldest service organization in\n               the valley. When the BVDH auxiliary was first founded, Smithers didn't have a hospital. In its\n               early years, the town relied on Dr. Horace Wrinch from Hazelton Hospital for medical\n               aid. In its early years, the town relied on Dr. Horace Rinch from Hazelton Hospital for medical aid. Spanish flu sufferers were treated in the public school\n               during the 1918 pandemic. Afterwards, support grew for a proper facility in Smithers. The construction began in 1934 and the addition of a new wing in 1955. The Todd building,\n               located at the southwest corner of King Street and Second Avenue, was selected to serve as the new hospital. Community support was strong, with financial contributions pouring in from residents\n               as well as from the provincial government. In the midst of all this, a group of Smithers\n               women met at the Methodist Church on June 11 in 1920. They went away having founded\n               the Ladies Hospital Auxiliary, which would eventually become BVDH Auxiliary that we\n               know today. The 23 women attending paid a membership fee of $1 for their first meeting. The initial purpose of the auxiliary was to provide the hospital with necessities\n               such as clothing, linens, towels, utensils and staple foods. By the time the hospital opened on September 1, 1920, auxiliary members had\n               sewn sheets and pillowcases for all its 12 beds. They also donated treats on holidays,\n               provided all the furnishings for the hospital and nurses' house and helped to pay\n               the nurses' salaries. Hospital support work was highly gendered, with the board comprised mostly entirely\n               of men and fundraising and clothes-making being seen as the female domain. On October 6, 1926, it was announced that the Ladies Auxiliary was planning a home\n               nursing class. Local graduate nurses would come and teach the high school girls in\n               basic home nursing over a series of 12 lessons. Interested parties could register\n               for $2. From the beginning, the auxiliary has relied primarily on community fundraising. The\n               gift shop in the hospital was opened in 1972 and the new-to-you thrift store in 1988.\n               Once again the community steps in to fill the gaps. Many community members, including\n               my sister, have volunteered there for years. Some of the funding raised goes to support a free ice cream day at the Bulkley Valley\n               long-term Lodge and provides bursaries to high school students entering the medical\n               field. A 1980 Interior News article celebrating the hospital's 60th diamond jubilee stated: \"It is difficult\n               to estimate just how much the Ladies Auxiliary has donated to hospital functions over\n               the years.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327979","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"June 5, 2020 marked the 100th anniversary of the Bulkley Valley District Hospital\n               auxiliary. This volunteer-run society, which has provided financial and material support\n               to the hospital since its beginning, may well be the oldest service organization in\n               the valley. When the BVDH auxiliary was first founded, Smithers didn't have a hospital. In its\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ff907b50cf69653834bff394d145e1f3468cf91dfd4e4c6b4f3839ead2009245"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ca79286e5063151ad6bd48d46bdcd34646ce9d968ceabb0c4b966d399a025a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bde459e49a0d60c8ee8ebe0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327980,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I was invited to hear the presentation on the Resource Benefit Alliance in the\n               northwest and what it means for communities. It was a pleasure to welcome people from\n               home. Joining us today is Mayor Gladys Atrill from the town of Smithers and also a person\n               who, at least for me, needs no introduction and has worked in municipal government\n               in the northwest for most of his career. Please welcome Ron Poole and the guests to\n               the chamber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327980","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I was invited to hear the presentation on the Resource Benefit Alliance in the\n               northwest and what it means for communities. It was a pleasure to welcome people from\n               home. Joining us today is Mayor Gladys Atrill from the town of Smithers and also a person\n               who, at least for me, needs no introduction and has worked in municipal government\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67cb25fe3bfb5235703dfefb80ccf4b5d0f78a67b00d5ed1907b96cb99eaff94"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bab9cc3743af7f1623ad7fb8bb404503b89c3c4546325b35659570b1dc172f44"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27bd1428fafb45e35b37396f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360164,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move Motion M201 standing in my name on the order paper: Affordable drinking water is defined as the ability of a household to pay for essential\n               water and sanitation services without sacrificing the ability to meet other basic\n               needs such as food, housing and health care. It is a human rights–based concept where\n               costs do not prevent access. As of February 2026, a combination of all health authorities in B.C. have issued a\n               total of 1,027 boil-water notices and advisories. For many communities, this is an\n               ongoing reality. When I started looking into water security in B.C., I found the information very unsettling.\n               I did find that in Canada our freshwater is not protected under our Canadian constitution.\n               This all started with trying to work with the provincial and federal governments to\n               fund a water treatment plant. Canada possesses 20 percent of all the fresh water. This is a resource that should\n               not be taken for granted. B.C. is rich in resources, and our water is a resource that\n               should be protected for all British Columbians. Access to sufficient, safe and affordable\n               drinking water shall be recognized as a fundamental human right held equally by all\n               residents of British Columbia. Ensuring successful delivery and management of community water supplies requires sourcing,\n               treating, distributing, planning, engineering, monitoring and managing infrastructure\n               systems. Most local governments will have a wide range of water-related responsibilities. While some communities have reliable access, gaps remain in rural areas, with small\n               systems and underserved communities. Many of these systems use raw, untreated water\n               to supply the residents. Many communities have aging infrastructure, and updating\n               or investing in new delivery systems is expensive. Cities like Prince Rupert, which is now using surface water, are required to provide\n               water samples to Northern Health. This for many communities is a requirement to ensure\n               that the water meets the regulation standards. No person or community should be denied clean water due to cost Cities like Prince Rupert, which are now using surface water, are required to provide water samples to Northern Health. This, for many communities, is a requirement to ensure that the water meets the\n               regulation standards. No person or community should be denied clean water due to cost, geography, infrastructure\n               failure or regulatory neglect. In addition, many local governments are grappling with\n               underinvestment in water infrastructure, compounded by a backlog of maintenance and capital improvement projects, rising systems costs, limited resources,\n               changing technology, changing regulations and legislation, requiring system upgrades,\n               and a history of underpricing and/or inadequate funding. Communities that are using surface water as their source are required to provide weekly\n               bacteriological samples from locations and send them to their health authority for testing, and in many cases this will cause a boil water advisory. Annual metal tests are also performed to ensure that they meet Health Canada's guidelines for safe drinking water. Ensuring successful delivery and management\n               of community water distribution requires sourcing, treating, planning, engineering,\n               monitoring and managing infrastructure systems. Most local governments will have a wide range of water-related tasks and ongoing financial\n               responsibilities. Small communities like Telkwa pumped raw water directly from the Bulkley River into their system. The only treatment for water in some systems is chlorinization. The village is on the confluence of two river systems, the Telkwa and the Bulkley. In extreme weather events, such as spring freshet as well as heavy rain events, the water turbidity was extreme, and that is where the concern is. Fecal coliform attaches to the silt and is then distributed to the community water system. The community\n               lived with this for decades. For years the community had made presentations to government,\n               then were told they were required to use all their capital reserve money before they were considered for a grant-sharing program. The community at that time had approximately 1,200 residents. The population has increased\n               by over 11 percent and is still growing. Now, the community is facing another challenge.\n               The upgrade for the treatment plant is estimated to be $9.8 million to keep up with\n               community growth. You must remember. Many of our smaller rural communities have no industrial tax base\n               to assist with this cost. The other factor is ongoing operational cost. Is it moral or reasonable to expect\n               a small community to pay hundreds of dollars per month for safe, clean drinking water?\n               We need to preserve this legacy and ensure that our water resources are not abused\n               or turned into private commodities. Access to safe, reliable drinking water is essential to the well-being of every British Columbian. Local governments across B.C. are responsible for providing drinking water to their\n               communities. Local governments face a broad range of challenges, including aging infrastructure,\n               evolving workforces, changing populations, groundwater and surface water quality. To this end, we must make water a priority for our communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360164","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move Motion M201 standing in my name on the order paper: Affordable drinking water is defined as the ability of a household to pay for essential\n               water and sanitation services without sacrificing the ability to meet other basic\n               needs such as food, housing and health care. It is a human rights–based concept where\n               costs do not prevent access. As of Febru","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2cd93880ca1c0f7c025a6be77d373189fd1b6d640c924ff15002e82497bbd9fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ad340a36bb05e9aa8c5147495700311d5a4cdbff86c4883b082933f186b5223"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4059afe6d3348d95bbe80882","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360166,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would also like to join my colleague across the aisle to show my respect and my\n               gratitude for the First Nations ladies that joined us this morning. It was enlightening,\n               and we really enjoyed their company here and showing them around. So I just want to say welcome, and I hope you enjoy your afternoon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360166","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would also like to join my colleague across the aisle to show my respect and my\n               gratitude for the First Nations ladies that joined us this morning. It was enlightening,\n               and we really enjoyed their company here and showing them around. So I just want to say welcome, and I hope you enjoy your afternoon.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Innu","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Innu","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","label":"Innu","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd0771de2fe93f8b205e16915fec5587088c6abe5fc32f631b400a4d229b26e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7dff17c4fdc10de164ec4f61afea875f91ce61f7193408c1c9eb4d9c26bdfb6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccd28bc50e0f06b7ad762609","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415735,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"This motion is being presented to bring attention to the state of our water delivery\n               and consumption in our communities across B.C., all our communities. I find it disturbing\n               that we have let the state of our most precious resource, water, become an afterthought\n               for the residents in our communities. We welcome people to live in our communities\n               but have not kept up with failing and inadequate infrastructure, and communities are\n               falling behind. Every year, communities need to make uncomfortable choices. What do we need to ask\n               our taxpayers for in this budget year? Should it be upgrading our parks, investing\n               in our sidewalks or investing in tourism? What are the needs of the community? So\n               we then sacrifice, making the choice of putting off upgrades for water infrastructure. Clean, affordable water is a human right for each and every one of us. Each time we\n               turn on the tap, we expect clean, safe water for brushing our teeth, making our coffee\n               in the morning, doing the dishes, laundry, all of those things. People move to communities\n               for many things. Lifestyle is part of this. They are expecting an affordable quality\n               of life. They are expecting the basic services that come with living in a community. Every year the tax bill goes up. The cost of maintaining the failing infrastructure\n               leaves them putting off the upgrades so desperately needed. In doing so, the costs\n               go up. This is a constant struggle, to find the balance of providing for the needs\n               of the communities. We are seeing the consequences of poor funding choices in Alberta and the cost of\n               not providing regular upgrades to water infrastructure to maintain what the public\n               expects. The taxpayers deserve the services that they are being taxed for. Recently, there was an incident in West Kelowna, with a breach into their water reservoir.\n               Communities are now needing to upgrade systems just to protect their water source.\n               This isn't just a municipal concern. It affects each and every one of us, no matter\n               where we live or what lifestyle we have, whether you live in a rural community or\n               an urban environment. Here are some stats. Boil-water notices as of February 24 of this year: Interior Health,\n               505; Northern Health, over 150; Vancouver Coastal, 66. Water quality advisories at\n               the same time: Interior Health, 101; Northern Health, over 40; and Vancouver Coastal,\n               21. These stats should concern everyone. Do you know the quality of water being delivered to your home? In 2024 more than 14,000 residents in Prince Rupert had a boil-water advisory for\n               more than two months, yet residents still had to continue to pay for non-potable water.\n               The Comox water treatment plant project design and construction has been under way\n               since 2019 to bring system capacity and standards in line with regulatory objectives.\n               This is only one of many projects that are currently falling behind. According to\n               the CVRD status reporting, a treatment plant solution is required to meet health authority\n               objectives for microbiological concerns and is undergoing design review and evaluation\n               ahead of construction, indicating future work needs and pending delivery. The government needs to re-evaluate the importance of investing in community infrastructure.\n               The theme of this year's budget is \"Look West.\" I would strongly encourage the government\n               to do just that and commit to listening to communities about their needs. The infrastructure\n               not only in the North but across the province is inadequate and out of date. This is from the Minister of Infrastructure's mandate letter: \"Recognizing B.C.'s\n               growing communities and aging infrastructure, we are to ensure faster delivery of\n               cost-effective, high-quality generational investments.\" One would ask, which generation? Water quality advisory in Canal Flats. Residents have had to advocate for access to\n               water. They have formed a water protection and advisory committee with the goal of\n               implementing Interior Health's orders to upgrade and disinfect the water. This project\n               could cost the small village millions of dollars. These are just a few examples of the state of infrastructure across B.C. I would urge\n               all members to vote in favour of safe, affordable water for every community in British\n               Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415735","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This motion is being presented to bring attention to the state of our water delivery\n               and consumption in our communities across B.C., all our communities. I find it disturbing\n               that we have let the state of our most precious resource, water, become an afterthought\n               for the residents in our communities. We welcome people to live in our communities\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","label":"Water quality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","label":"Water quality","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e9973fde181c7d505589e2f608f7712a8ef6d077fcf417e108a1aa2dec54b69"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8b66fd4a14bfc6a3f5e2358d9ab958e2c8e5b13b0286f960779f374455f76a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47503","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55438a7052cb26b6fa6db3f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415736,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, 2026, and\n               I do so with a growing level of concern the deeper one looks into what is being proposed. At the outset, I think it is important to ground this discussion in what the Residential\n               Tenancy Act is intended to do. It is the primary piece of legislation that governs\n               the legal relationship between landlords and tenants in this province. It establishes\n               rights, it establishes responsibilities, and it provides a framework that is supposed\n               to bring clarity and stability to something as fundamental as housing. On the surface that sounds straightforward, and for many people it is. So it is entirely\n               reasonable to ask why changes of this magnitude are being brought forward at this\n               time, who has been asking for them and whether the consequences have been fully considered. This legislation introduces a new framework for what is described as supportive housing\n               within the residential tenancy system. It creates a new division dealing specifically\n               with supportive housing rental units. It expands the authority of the Lieutenant Governor in Council to make regulations,\n               and it alters provisions related to tenant conduct, landlord authority, inspections,\n               compensation and dispute resolution. These are not minor adjustments. They represent a shift in how housing is categorized,\n               managed and enforced within the province. These are not minor adjustments. They represent a shift in how housing is categorized,\n               managed and enforced within the province. That shift carries with it implications\n               that extend well beyond the wording of the bill itself. One of the first challenges that arises when reviewing this legislation is the lack\n               of a clear and practical definition of \"supportive housing.\" The term is used broadly,\n               yet it captures a wide range of circumstances that are not the same and should not\n               be treated as though they are. There are individuals who require affordable housing due to income constraints, including\n               seniors who are trying to maintain independence on fixed incomes. There are individuals\n               experiencing homelessness who require stability and access to services. There are\n               those dealing with mental health challenges. There are those navigating substance\n               abuse. There are distinct realities, each with different needs, different levels of support\n               and different expectations around supervision and safety. What this bill appears to\n               do is bring those different realities together, under a single legislative approach,\n               without sufficient distinction. That creates uncertainty for those who are expected to implement the policy and for\n               communities that must live with the outcomes. When definitions are unclear, interpretation\n               fills the gap and that leads to inconsistency. It also makes it difficult to establish\n               appropriate standards because the needs of one group may be very different from the\n               needs of another. Without that clarity, there is a risk that housing solutions will\n               be mismatched to the populations they are intended to serve. There is also the question of who has been consulted in the development of these changes.\n               Concerns have been raised about the process, about the level of engagement and about\n               the absence of key voices, particularly those involved in public safety. Fire service\n               stakeholders and emergency responders have been clear in expressing that their concerns\n               have not been adequately addressed. These are individuals who understand how buildings function under pressure, who responds\n               when situations escalate and who are often the last line of defence when something\n               goes wrong. Their perspective is not theoretical; it is based on experience. It reflects\n               what is happening on the ground in communities across the province. When those voices\n               are not meaningfully included in the development of legislation that directly affects\n               the environments they respond to, it raises serious questions about whether the full\n               scope of risk has been considered. This bill addresses tenant behaviour, and it does so in a way that suggests conduct\n               is at the centre of the issue. While behaviour is certainly a factor in any housing\n               environment, it's not the only factor, and, in many cases, it is not the root cause\n               of the challenges that are being observed. There are broader issues that come into\n               play, including building safety, security staffing levels, maintenance and environmental\n               conditions within the units themselves. There are also concerns related to drug activity within these spaces, which adds another\n               layer of complexity that cannot be addressed simply through tenancy provisions. Focusing\n               on behaviour without addressing those underlying factors risks creating a situation\n               where the symptoms are managed without dealing with the cause. It also places expectations\n               on tenants and on those managing these facilities that may not be realistic given\n               the conditions that they are working in. Housing environments are shaped by their design, by the resources available to support\n               them and by the systems that are in place to respond when issues arise. Without a\n               comprehensive approach that takes all of these elements into account, the framework\n               remains incomplete. There's also a practical concern about enforcement and responsibility. The bill does\n               not provide a clear indication of who is responsible for ensuring safety when situations\n               escalate beyond what would normally be considered tenancy matters. In cases where\n               tenants may pose a risk to themselves or others, where there may be the presence of\n               weapons or where behaviour becomes unpredictable or dangerous, there needs to be a\n               clear understanding of who is responsible for responding and what authority they have\n               to do so. In many of these environments, supportive housing workers are the individuals present\n               on a day-to-day basis. They are tasked with providing support, managing cases and\n               assisting tenants in navigating complex challenges. Their training is centred on support\n               and harm reduction, not on enforcement or crisis intervention at a level that involves\n               significant risk. Expecting them to manage situations that fall outside their training\n               creates pressure that is not sustainable and raises concerns about safety for both\n               workers and residents. This issue becomes even more pronounced in smaller and rural communities. Many of\n               these communities do not have facilities that were designed with supportive housing\n               in mind. Instead, they are dealing with temporary shelters or adapted spaces that\n               may have little or no supervision and staff who may not have the specialized training This issue becomes even more pronounced in smaller and rural communities. Many of\n               these communities do not have facilities that were designed with supportive housing\n               in mind. Instead they are dealing with temporary shelters or adapted spaces that may\n               have little or no supervision and staff who may not have the specialized training\n               required to respond to a wide range of situations. Resources are limited and access to additional support services is not always readily\n               available. In those settings, the introduction of a legislative framework that assumes\n               a certain level of capacity can create additional strain. It can place communities\n               in a position where they are expected to meet standards or manage situations without\n               having the necessary tools or support to do so effectively. That is not a reflection of a lack of willingness at the community level. It is a\n               reflection of the reality that different communities have different capabilities and\n               policy must take that into account. Another concern relates to the classification of those housing environments. Many\n               of the buildings being used for supportive housing were originally designed as single-room\n               occupancies. They were not built as care facilities, and they do not necessarily include\n               the features or safeguards that would be expected in a setting where residents may\n               require a higher level of supervision or support. When those buildings are used in ways that extend beyond the original design, it introduces\n               risks that need to be fully carefully managed. Those risks are not limited to structural\n               considerations. They extend to how spaces are used, how occupants interact and how\n               emergencies are handled. Without clear standards and appropriate oversight, there is a potential for conditions\n               to develop that are not safe for residents, for staff or for the first responders.\n               The legislation does not provide sufficient detail to address those concerns in a\n               way that inspires confidence. There is also the broader context of housing supply in the province. There is no question\n               that there is a shortage, and there is pressure to find solutions. However, the approach\n               reflected in this bill suggests an attempt to incorporate supportive housing into\n               a broader effort without fully addressing the unique requirements that come with it. Housing is not a single category, and the needs of different populations cannot always\n               be met with a single framework. When policy moves in that direction, there is a risk\n               that solutions become generalized to the point where they lose their effectiveness.\n               Housing that is intended to serve one purpose may be asked to serve another, and over\n               time that can lead to challenges that affect both residents and communities. It can\n               also place additional demands on systems that are already under strain, including\n               emergency services and local support networks. Emergency responders are already dealing with increasing demand, and supportive housing\n               environments often contribute to that demand due to the complexity of the situations\n               involved. Calls may involve medical emergencies, mental health crises or incidents\n               that require coordination between multiple agencies. These are not routine situations,\n               and they require resources, training and clear protocols to manage effectively. The\n               legislation does not appear to address how these pressures will be mitigated or how\n               coordination will be improved. There is also the matter of regulatory authority. The bill expands the power of the\n               Lieutenant Governor in Council to make regulations related to supportive housing.\n               While regulation-making authority is a common feature of legislation, the scope of\n               the authority being granted here raises questions about how key aspects of the framework\n               will be defined and implemented. When significant elements of policy are left to regulation,\n               it can reduce the level of scrutiny and debate that would otherwise occur within this\n               House. That approach may offer flexibility, but it also creates uncertainty. Stakeholders\n               may not have a clear understanding of what is expected until regulations are developed,\n               and those regulations can be changed without the same level of legislative oversight. For a framework that has such broad implications, there is a strong argument to be\n               made for greater clarity within the legislation itself. All of these considerations\n               point to a broader issue, which is the need for a more comprehensive and deliberate\n               approach to supportive housing policy. The intent to provide housing and support for those in need is not in question. It\n               is something that all members of this House recognize as important. The context lies\n               in how that intent is translated into policy and whether the framework that is being\n               established is capable of achieving its objectives in a way that is safe, effective\n               and sustainable. The decisions we make in this area have real consequences. They affect individuals\n               who rely on those housing environments for stability and support. They affect workers\n               who are committed to providing assistance under challenging circumstances. They affect\n               communities that are working to balance compassion with safety. They affect the systems\n               that respond when things do not go as planned. For those reasons, it is essential that legislation of this nature is clear with its\n               intent For those reasons, it is essential that legislation of this nature is clear with this\n               intent, grounded in practical reality and informed by those who have direct experience.\n               At this stage, there are too many unanswered questions and too many areas where clarity\n               is lacking. That is not a position that lends itself to confidence in the framework\n               being proposed. As I continue, I think it is important to reflect on the communative effect of what is being proposed. Legislation of this nature does not operate in\n               isolation. It interacts with existing systems, with existing pressures and with the\n               realities that communities are already navigating. When those interactions are not\n               fully considered, the result is often a layering of complexity rather than a solution\n               of the underlying issue. There's a growing concern that what is being advanced through this bill is an attempt\n               to streamline or consolidate multiple challenges to a single legislative approach,\n               and while that may appear efficient on paper, it does not reflect the lived experience\n               of those who are directly affected. Housing challenges are not uniform across this\n               province. They vary by region, by population and by the resources available to support\n               them. A framework that does not account for that variation risks creating outcomes\n               that are uneven and in some cases counterproductive. In many communities, there is already a sense that systems are being stretched beyond\n               their intended capacity. Local governments, non-profit organizations and service providers\n               are doing their best to respond to increasing demand with limited resources. They\n               are adapting, they are innovating and they're often stepping in to fill the gaps that\n               exist at a broader level. When new legislation is introduced, it should serve to support those efforts, to provide\n               clarity and to strengthen the overall system. It should not introduce additional uncertainty\n               or place further strain on those who are already operating at their limits. What is particularly concerning is the absence of clear accountability mechanisms\n               within the framework being proposed. When responsibilities are not clearly defined,\n               it becomes difficult to determine who is responsible when something goes wrong. That\n               lack of clarity does not remain within the pages of legislation. It manifests in real\n               situations where decisions must be made quickly and where the consequences of an action\n               or misdirection can be significant. There are also implications for landlords and housing providers who may find themselves\n               operating within a framework that is not fully defined. Expectations around inspections,\n               compliance and dispute resolution appear to be shifting, yet the details of how those\n               expectations will be applied remain uncertain. That creates a level of risk for those\n               providers, particularly smaller organizations that may not have the capacity to navigate\n               complex regulatory environments without clear guidance. It is also worth considering the impact on tenants themselves. Individuals who reside\n               in supportive housing environments often face complex challenges, and stability is\n               a key factor in their ability to move forward. When the framework governing their\n               housing is unclear or subject to change through regulation, it can create uncertainty\n               that undermines that stability. Predictability in housing is not a minor consideration.\n               It is a foundational element of well-being. Another issue that arises is the relationship between this legislative framework and\n               existing enforcement mechanisms. When disputes occur within the residential tenancy\n               system, there are established processes for resolution. The introduction of a new\n               category within that system raises questions about how those processes will adapt\n               and whether they are equipped to handle the unique circumstances that may arise within\n               the supportive housing environments. These are not always straightforward disputes,\n               and they may involve factors that extend beyond traditional tenancy matters. The role of inspections is also an area that warrants attention. Inspections are a\n               critical component of maintaining safety and ensuring compliance with standards. However,\n               the effectiveness of inspections depends on clarity in what is being assessed and\n               consistency in how those assessments are conducted. Without clear standards that reflect\n               the realities of supportive housing, inspections may vary in their application, leading\n               to inconsistencies that undermine their purpose. There's also the broader issue of how this framework aligns with other areas of policy,\n               including health services, social services and public safety. Supportive housing does not exist in a vacuum. It intersects with multiple systems,\n               each of which has its own mandates and challenges. Effective policy in this area requires\n               coordination across those systems, and that coordination must be reflected in the\n               legislative framework. At present there is little within this bill that provides assurance\n               that such coordination has been fully considered. The absence of that consideration\n               raises concerns about At present, there is little within this bill that provides assurance that such coordination\n               has been fully considered. The absence of that consideration raises concerns about\n               how effectively the framework will function once implemented. It also raises questions\n               about whether the burden of coordination will fall on those at the local level who\n               may not have the authority or resources to manage it effectively. It is also necessary to consider the long-term implications of the approach being\n               taken. Housing policy is not something that can be addressed through short-term measures\n               alone. It requires a long-term perspective that takes into account demographic trends,\n               economic conditions and the evolving needs of the population. When legislation is\n               introduced without that perspective, there is a risk that it will need to be revisited\n               or revised in relatively short order, creating further uncertainty. The expansion of regulatory authority within this bill contributes to that uncertainty.\n               While it allows for adjustments to be made over time, it also means that key aspects\n               of the framework may shift without the same level of public debate or legislative scrutiny. That can\n               make it difficult for stakeholders to plan and to invest in the systems that infrastructure\n               needed to support supportive housing effectively. There's also a question of balance that must be considered. The Residential Tenancy Act has traditionally sought to balance the rights and responsibilities of landlords\n               and tenants. That introduction of a new framework within that act must maintain that\n               balance while also addressing the unique circumstances of supportive housing. Achieving that balance requires careful consideration and a clear articulation of\n               how rights and responsibilities are allocated. At this stage, it is not evident that\n               the bill achieves that balance. The emphasis on certain aspects, combined with the\n               lack of clarity in others, creates a framework that appears uneven. That unevenness\n               can lead to challenges in implementation and can affect the confidence of those who\n               are expected to operate within it. Throughout this discussion, there has been a recurring theme, and that is the need\n               for clarity. Clarity in definitions, clarity in responsibilities, clarity in standards\n               and clarity in how the framework will be applied across different contexts. Without\n               that clarity, even well-intentioned policy can fall short of its objectives. It is also important to recognize that clarity is not something that can be achieved\n               solely through regulation after the fact. It must be built into the legislation itself. It must be present at the outset, so that those who are affected by the policy have a clear understanding of what\n               is expected and how the system will operate. There's an opportunity here to take a more deliberate approach, to engage more fully\n               with those who have expressed concerns and to ensure that the framework being established\n               is one that reflects its realities on the ground. That approach may take more time,\n               but it is time that would be well-spent on developing policy that is both effective and sustainable. I do not believe that anyone in this House would suggest that the challenges associated\n               with housing can be addressed through a single piece of legislation. They are complex,\n               they are interconnected, and they require a range of responses. Supportive housing\n               is one part of that response, but it must be developed in a way that acknowledges\n               its complexity and its importance. The bill before us represents an effort to move in that direction, but it does so\n               in a way that leaves significant gaps. Those gaps are not minor, and they have the\n               potential to affect the safety, stability and effectiveness of supportive housing\n               across the province. Addressing those gaps requires more than incremental adjustments;\n               it requires a reconsideration of how the framework is structured and how it will be\n               implemented. As members of this House, we have a responsibility to ensure that the legislation\n               we pass is not only well-intentioned but also well-designed. That responsibility includes taking the time to ask difficult questions, to listen\n               to those who are affected and to adjust where necessary. It also includes recognizing\n               when a proposal is not yet ready to proceed in its current form. This is one of those instances. The concerns that have been raised are substantive,\n               and they reflect the experience of those who are directly involved in housing, in\n               public safety and in community support. They are not abstract concerns, and they should\n               not be set aside. There is still an opportunity to address these issues, to refine the approach and\n               to bring forward a framework that commands broader confidence. Doing so would strengthen\n               the policy and would better serve the individuals and communities that it is intended\n               to support. In its current form, however, the bill does not provide that level of confidence.\n               It introduces significant changes without sufficient clarity. It expands authority\n               without corresponding details, and it does not fully address the practical In its current form, however, the bill does not provide that level of confidence.\n               It introduces significant changes without sufficient clarity. It expands authority\n               without corresponding details, and it does not fully address the practical realities\n               of implementation. For those reasons, it is difficult to support. The goal of providing safe, stable and appropriate housing for those in need is one\n               that we all share. It is a goal that deserves careful attention and thoughtful policy.\n               Achieving that goal requires more than broad frameworks. It requires precision, consultation\n               and a willingness to address complexity rather than simplify it. I would encourage the government to take a step back, to engage more fully with stakeholders\n               and to ensure that the framework being developed is one that reflects the diversity\n               of needs across this province. That approach would not only improve the legislation\n               but would also contribute to more effective outcomes in the long term.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415736","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, 2026, and\n               I do so with a growing level of concern the deeper one looks into what is being proposed. At the outset, I think it is important to ground this discussion in what the Residential\n               Tenancy Act is intended to do. It is the primary piece of legislation that governs\n               the legal ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e54cee6eebbff98807bc2f630d1c28ddda981b18b5c9f35e487e9e35f664e6c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69f2dad27b035ab0025c81d58c250eab446d4de6f32f4fb3c222c4329ee461b2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b9b9986f3bfb912c58673f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720344,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Seabridge Gold holds 100 percent interest in several North American gold projects.\n               Their principal asset, the KSM project, is in northwest B.C. in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. The northwest of the province is rich in resources and opportunities. The government\n               is setting their attention to these prospects. And 2026 marks a milestone for Seabridge Gold. They are celebrating 25 years of investment\n               in the northwest. During this time, they have invested $1.2 billion in their property\n               here in the northwest. This success at KSM has defined one of the world's largest\n               copper and silver projects, containing 19.4 billion pounds of copper and 414 million\n               cubic ounces of silver. The combined gold, copper and silver constitute an outstanding\n               economic opportunity. Being leaders in their sector, the subsidiary KSM mining has received the AME David\n               Barr Award for excellence in mineral exploration, health and safety. The awards celebrate\n               remarkable individual and team achievements, contributions and innovation in mineral\n               exploration and recognize excellence across the industry, including health and safety\n               and innovation. KSM mining earned its distinction for its pioneering efforts to foster collaboration\n               and enhance emergency preparedness across British Columbia's remote Golden Triangle.\n               In fall of 2023, they launched the Golden Triangle emergency response coordination\n               meeting, bringing together emergency response and safety professionals from multiple\n               projects and organizations. Rudi Fronk, Seabridge chair and CEO, said: \"I'm very proud of our team for establishing\n               a collaborative approach to regional safety capabilities, including supporting community\n               emergency responses. This is our commitment to safety and community.\" AME president and CEO Todd Stone said: \"On behalf of the AME board of directors, we\n               congratulate and thank all 2025 AME award recipients. Their leadership exemplifies\n               the spirit of mineral exploration and will continue to develop minerals that are essential\n               to our future.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720344","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Seabridge Gold holds 100 percent interest in several North American gold projects.\n               Their principal asset, the KSM project, is in northwest B.C. in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. The northwest of the province is rich in resources and opportunities. The government\n               is setting their attention to these prospects. And 2026 marks a milestone for Seabridge Gold. They are celebrating","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b66054d9a8f179b83c9fcd4967f145db57115e3c890eac1eabb3a127a313ae2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7598d710d0316c83a7a3e3d1a6b4b64ea008b5275015501ea5d1a809c933b058"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26d4a3958fe857e7f013b754","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720349,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to introduce to the House today a distinguished guest joining us in the\n               gallery, Cyra Yunkws, electoral area B representative and chair of the regional district of Kitimat-Stikine. Ms. Yunkws has demonstrated strong leadership in advancing the\n               interests of her community, working collaboratively to support local governance, regional\n               development and the well-being of residents across the district. I'm looking forward\n               to having a meeting with her tomorrow.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720349","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am pleased to introduce to the House today a distinguished guest joining us in the\n               gallery, Cyra Yunkws, electoral area B representative and chair of the regional district of Kitimat-Stikine. Ms. Yunkws has demonstrated strong leadership in advancing the\n               interests of her community, working collaboratively to support local governance, regional\n               developm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6c476585decf52c8321785066060292eda4a00f45604f2f47543f657c5b21ad0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82980c863c4e353addafb7880eff47532e61b702130df641cc3c0c532b635348"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e105d7851ee3f785046753a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720355,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm sorry to jump into this conversation, Minister, but I heard my colleague talk\n               about a piece of property with multiple dwellings on it. I have a situation at home which was agricultural land. It was called the experimental\n               centre in Smithers. You might be familiar with it. So now it's been purchased for probably the second or third time, and the gentleman\n               on it.... All the buildings are original buildings, is my understanding, and he has\n               rented them out, fixed them up for rental units. Now he's being told that they either\n               have to leave or he has to spend X amount of dollars doing that. So where are these\n               people going to go? It has been traditionally used for other purposes as well, not just agricultural use.\n               He's done nothing. There's still agricultural land there, and it's all in the same\n               title. I don't know if there's anything that you can.... We can have a discussion about that,\n               and I can bring the file forward. But when my colleague had mentioned five residences\n               on the same property — and this is already existing old buildings from in the '50s,\n               except for they've been, you know, brought up to date for whatever. So that's a concern\n               at home too. Not only do we need rental accommodations, farmland is not being impacted\n               and it's still the original dwellings that are on the property.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720355","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm sorry to jump into this conversation, Minister, but I heard my colleague talk\n               about a piece of property with multiple dwellings on it. I have a situation at home which was agricultural land. It was called the experimental\n               centre in Smithers. You might be familiar with it. So now it's been purchased for probably the second or third time, and the gentleman\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5a35e53e1452b03f5a6ddd0b39c40b24846769e94e933f5fcbba981ac3aa271"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec0b0bd25a75be774611b04aad7e97e836a018f77ae3a04a8e66ed7b81826fd7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c931e267f406216b515e7d1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720356,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 14, the Forests Statutes Amendment Act, 2026, a piece\n               of legislation that, while presented as a modernization effort, raises serious concerns\n               about transparency, accountability, economic stability and the future of forestry\n               in British Columbia. At its core, this bill proposes sweeping changes to how timber is harvested, how contracts\n               are structured, how authority is exercised and how public funds are spent. Yet despite\n               the scale and significance of these changes, we are being asked to approve them without\n               the level of clarity, detail and consultation that such changes demand. Forestry is not just another sector in this province. It's foundational. It is woven\n               into the history, identity and the economy of British Columbia. It sustains families,\n               supports communities and provides livelihoods in regions where fewer alternatives\n               exist. Because of that, any legislative changes affecting forestry must be approached\n               with caution, with respect and with a deep understanding of its real-world consequences One of the most significant changes introduced in this bill is the creation of what\n               are called contract logging authorizations. Under this new model, contractors will\n               be permitted to harvest Crown timber, but they will not own that timber. Under this new model, this represents a fundamental departure from the existing timber\n               sale licence system, where the licensee who harvests the timber also owns it. That\n               distinction matters because ownership is not just a technical detail. It is whatever\n               drives accountability, efficiency and economic incentive. Under the current system, companies take on risk. They invest capital, they manage\n               operations, and they're responsible for the outcomes. Under the proposed contract\n               logging model, that dynamic changes. The contractor becomes a service provider. The\n               government, through B.C. Timber Sales, becomes more directly involved in the harvesting\n               process without necessarily being subject to the same market pressures or financial\n               discipline. That raises serious concerns, because when you separate the act of harvesting\n               from the ownership of timber, you also risk separating responsibility from incentive. This new contract logging authorization model raises several critical questions that\n               remain unanswered in this legislation. How will these contracts be awarded? What criteria\n               will be used to select contractors? Will the process be transparent and competitive? The system already has implemented 50 policy changes since 2018. The industry is struggling\n               with continuing regulatory changes. Every time the government implements or changes\n               policy, it affects contractors and operators and introduces additional costs. How will these contracts be supervised on the ground? Who will have the authority\n               to make operational decisions if conditions change? And perhaps most importantly,\n               who is accountable when things go wrong? Without clear answers to these questions, we are not creating certainty. We are creating\n               confusion. And confusion in a sector like forestry, where operations are complex,\n               capital-intensive and time-sensitive, can have serious consequences. Another deeply concerning aspect of Bill 14 is the expansion of authority to impose\n               rules and conditions that go beyond what is already required under the existing legislation.\n               Through amendments to sections governing timber sale licences and forestry licences\n               to cut, this bill allows the minister or a timber sales manager to impose additional\n               terms and conditions that they consider appropriate. Let us be clear about what that means. It means that even if a company is fully compliant\n               with the Forest Act, the Forest and Range Practices Act and the Wildfire Act, they\n               can still be subject to additional requirements that are not clearly defined in this\n               legislation. It means that licences can be made tougher than the law. That is a profound shift because laws are meant to establish clear, consistent and\n               predictable standards. They are meant to provide a level playing field. But when we\n               allow decision-makers to go beyond those laws without clear limits, we introduce uncertainty,\n               we introduce inconsistency, and we introduce risk. We must consider this in context.\n               The forest sector in British Columbia is already struggling with declining fibre supply. The actual cut gap. Industry groups like the Council of Forest Industries note that\n               while the official AAC ceiling is 60 million cubic metres, the actual volume harvested\n               has dropped significantly lower, roughly 30 million to 35 million, due to economic\n               factors and policy changes. Mill closures in B.C.'s forest sector have counted 21 permanent or indefinite mill\n               closures since 2023. According to the Council of Forest Industries, since 2022, the\n               organization has counted some 15,000 job losses in this sector. Rising operational costs and the cost of fuel and repairs have increased. In 2025,\n               a licence holder forced a contractor to have a rate cut just to keep the contract.\n               Who makes these decisions? Increased regulatory burdens. At a time when industry is calling for greater efficiency\n               and reduced red tape, this government is moving in the opposite direction. It is adding\n               more rules. We have seen more regulatory complexity adding more conditions, including\n               significant delays in approvals and permitting. We do not need any more regulatory\n               hurdles. More uncertainty. There is less access to fibre, including rising stumpage costs.\n               That is not how you support an industry that is under pressure. That is how you make\n               it harder for that industry to One of the most concerning financial aspects of this bill is the expansion of what\n               the B.C. Timber Sales account can be used for. Currently, the BCTS account is tied\n               largely to revenue-generating activities. Bill 14 changes that. We also heard from\n               another colleague that this has happened before, and it didn't work out very well,\n               so I don't know why they would go back there. It expands allowable expenditures to include planning and operational assessments,\n               road and bridge construction and maintenance, forest protection activities, administrative\n               costs, silviculture beyond minimum requirements and costs associated with contract\n               logging authorizations, including harvesting itself. Let us be very clear about what this means. This is a significant expansion of spending\n               authority. Does this mean that the government will create a new ministry to administer\n               these changes? Yet we have not been provided with clear budget projections. We have\n               not been given detailed cost estimates. We have not been shown how these expenditures\n               will be tracked, reported or controlled. In fact, the bill explicitly allows these expenditures to override certain provisions\n               of the Financial Administration Act. That should raise alarm bells for every member\n               of this House. Because public money must be spent with transparency, it must be spent\n               with accountability, and must be subject to clear oversight. This bill does not provide\n               that. Let me be clear. We support investments in forestry. We support reforestation. We\n               support wildlife mitigation. We also support responsible forest management. But those\n               investments must be made responsibly. They must be cost-effective, and they must be\n               transparent. What we cannot support is blank cheque. That is what this bill is creating,\n               an open-ended ability to spend public funds without clear limits, without clear reporting,\n               and without clear accountability. Another critical concern is a shift away from revenue-driven forestry operations.\n               Under the traditional model, timber sales generate revenue. That revenue creates discipline.\n               It ensures that operations are efficient, and it also ensures that decisions are made\n               with cost in mind. But under this new model, where the government is more directly\n               involved in harvesting through contract logging and where expenditures are expanded\n               beyond revenue-generating activities, we risk losing that discipline. We risk creating\n               a system where decisions are made without the same financial accountability, and that\n               is not sustainable. When we examine this bill clause by clause, these concerns become even more apparent.\n               Clause 1 introduces a definition of contract logging authorization. Clause 5 establishes the framework for these authorizations, allowing contractors\n               to harvest timber without owning it. This is not a minor administrative change. It\n               is a structural transformation in how forestry operations are conducted. Clauses 2 and 3 amend the contract for timber sale licenses and forestry licenses\n               to cut. They explicitly allow additional terms and conditions to be imposed, terms\n               that can exceed existing legal requirements. This means that compliance with the law\n               is no longer sufficient. Operators must also comply with potentially variable discretionary\n               conditions. And who makes those decisions? Clause 6 further reinforces this by allowing terms and conditions that are stricter\n               than the law, again without clearly defined limits and without standardized criteria\n               or without guaranteed consistency. Clause 7 shifts authority from timber sale managers to the ministry in key areas,\n               including decisions about fee waivers. This centralizes power. Who has access to the\n               minister, and under what conditions? Does the minister hold an RPF license? Is he\n               able to make those decisions? This is a position for a highly trained expert responsible\n               for managing forests, ecosystems and resource sustainability. It reduces the role\n               of experienced professionals and increases the risk of politicized decision-making. Clause 8 significantly expands what the B.C. Timber Sales account can fund, including\n               moving away from the forest stewardship plan to transition to FLPs. The province is moving away from a model where licensees primarily define their own\n               plans to a model where the province, in partnership with First Nations, sets the operational\n               direction through FLPs. This is a transition to forest landscape plans. Infrastructure Infrastructure development as of April 2025. BCTS is expanding its role in active\n               forest stewardship, including leading road development and planning in several business\n               areas across the province. Contract harvesting costs in the forest industry in British Columbia's Crown land\n               system. The forest tenure holder or licensee, such as the large forest company, is\n               generally responsible for contract harvesting costs. They hire independent contractors\n               to perform harvesting, road building and hauling, and are responsible for paying these\n               contractors. Does this mean that this will eliminate independent contractors? It also allows these expenditures to override existing financial legislation. That\n               is not a minor change. That's a major shift in fiscal governance. Subsequent clauses amend the Forest and Range Practices Act to fully integrate contract\n               logging authorizations into planning, mapping and operational frameworks. This will\n               include requiring forest operation plans to include contract logging areas, mandating\n               public maps and schedules showing these areas, treating contract logging authorizations\n               similar to timber sale licences. While this may appear administrative, it reinforces\n               the scale of the shift being proposed. The bill also introduces new requirements for planning and mapping. Timber sales managers\n               must now include contract logging authorizations in forest operation plans, forest\n               operation maps and also annual forest development schedules. These maps must show\n               planned harvest areas, road construction and areas subject to contract logging. While transparency and planning are important, we must ask: are we adding clarity\n               or complexity? Are we improving efficiency or increasing administrative burden? Every\n               additional requirement has a cost, and those costs are ultimately borne by industry,\n               by government and by taxpayers. We cannot lose sight of the people who will be most affected by these changes: forest\n               workers. How will this affect independent contractors who have been working in the\n               industry for decades? Small businesses are the foundations of our northern and rural\n               communities, and they are key in supporting our people. These are individuals who\n               operate in challenging conditions, who take on significant financial risks and who\n               depend on stability. What this bill offers them is the opposite of stability. It is uncertainty. Uncertainty\n               about contracts. Uncertainty about rules. Uncertainty about who makes decisions. Uncertainty\n               about the future. And that uncertainty has real consequences. It affects hiring decisions.\n               It affects investment. It affects livelihoods. Perhaps one of the most concerning aspects of this legislation is what it does not\n               include. It does not include a clear implementation plan, nor does it include timelines.\n               It does not include detailed guidelines, and it leaves critical details to regulation\n               and future policy decisions. That is not good legislative practice. We should not\n               be asked to approve a framework without knowing how it will be implemented. Opposing this bill does not mean opposing change. It does not mean opposing innovation.\n               What it means is demanding better — better planning, consultation and obviously transparency.\n               It means ensuring that changes to harvesting models are clearly defined and justified;\n               rules are consistent and predictable; public spending is transparent and accountable;\n               industry is supported, not burdened; and workers are given stability, not uncertainty. Forestry has built this province. It has supported communities for generations, and\n               it has provided livelihoods, opportunities and stability. It deserves legislation\n               that reflects that importance. Bill 14, as it stands, does not. It introduces uncertainty\n               where we need clarity. It expands authority without sufficient safeguards. It increases\n               spending without transparency and accountability. It adds complexity where simplicity\n               is needed. Being born and raised in the North, Bulkley Valley is my home. My father was part\n               of the forest service government at that time, and he worked hard in the forest service. My children were in forestry. You know, it's been part of my life for a long, long\n               time, and seeing communities devastated by the downturn in the forest industry and\n               all the mill closures is heart-wrenching. One of the members on the opposite side\n               spoke One of the members on the opposite side spoke about all the mills and all the forestry\n               that was happening in her community, and I thought: \"Well, lucky. Isn't that great?\"\n               What I'd like to get back to is all our communities having that same opportunity,\n               all of them having that same stability in the forest industry. For those reasons and for the workers and families in communities who depend on forestry,\n               I simply cannot support this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720356","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 14, the Forests Statutes Amendment Act, 2026, a piece\n               of legislation that, while presented as a modernization effort, raises serious concerns\n               about transparency, accountability, economic stability and the future of forestry\n               in British Columbia. At its core, this bill proposes sweeping changes to how timber is harvested, how","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f482972598e335c64662dcff64f15e78b138061cdfdbb1da3ab13c4e50cf89a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04b9d2cb01101025a289917827e67d618a1ad01222e87bf89f18e95300849f47"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d226830e274bad356353645","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721448,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"\"The true north, strong and free,\" as it is written in our national anthem, a place\n               where individuals live, carved out communities while also contributing to the financial\n               growth and development of our","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721448","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"\"The true north, strong and free,\" as it is written in our national anthem, a place\n               where individuals live, carved out communities while also contributing to the financial\n               growth and development of our","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","label":"National heritage","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["931db40e65ca6d01d9aeb92c0f48caad4029db0e130f397779c908b9ce35ce66"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27841a4cf6e8edc30ec8c6a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721450,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"We know that this government has cut access to the travel assistance program in secret. A family in my riding is directly affected by this cut. Their family, like many others\n               from northern B.C., have no choice but to travel long distances for specialized care,\n               something we've talked about a lot in this House. Their son is scheduled to undergo\n               a colonoscopy and MRI in Vancouver this May. This involves significant travel, approximately\n               13 hours, and requires flights, accommodations, meals and time away from work. To the Minister, can she please explain to my constituents and families across B.C.\n               why she is cutting these vital supports?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721450","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We know that this government has cut access to the travel assistance program in secret. A family in my riding is directly affected by this cut. Their family, like many others\n               from northern B.C., have no choice but to travel long distances for specialized care,\n               something we've talked about a lot in this House. Their son is scheduled to undergo\n               a colonosc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment abroad","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035045","label":"Employment abroad","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["353d957272746181f2d2bbd35ffaa6ff580f7af0ec83beb7ed1a2fdb4d9a63f0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["310e3e26d8e35fcabc0ab38a0ee4145e6523beeb71ea5c06ba9a53f3d4b1220b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d7980b7f9339423ca2c68b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752250,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise in this House to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At the outset, I wanted to say this plainly: access to information is not a courtesy\n               that government extends when it's convenient. It is not a favour. It's not a privilege\n               reserved for those who know how to navigate bureaucracy, hire experts or wait months\n               on end while their request disappears into the machinery of government. Access to information is a democratic right. It's one of the few practical tools ordinary\n               people have to hold government accountable between elections. That is why Bill 9 matters.\n               And that is why the government's framing of this bill is so difficult to accept. We are told that this legislation is about efficiency. We are told it's about modernization.\n               We are told it's about improving the experience of British Columbians engaging with\n               government. Those are fine words. They sound polished. They sound reassuring. But\n               when one looks past the talking points and reads the actual text of the bill, a different\n               picture emerges. What this bill really does, in several important respects, is make it easier for government\n               to delay, easier for government to reject and easier for government to charge people\n               for access to information that should, by all reason and principle, remain accessible.\n               That is not transparency. That is not modernization. It's certainly not accountability. Freedom-of-information legislation exists because government records do not belong\n               to the government of the day in any moral sense. Those records are created using public\n               dollars by public bodies in the course of public administration. Ministers may sit\n               on those benches for a few years. Staff may rotate in and out. When a resident wants to know how a decision was made, when a journalist wants to\n               investigate waste, when a researcher wants to understand government process, when\n               a municipality wants answers, when a family wants records tied to an issue affecting\n               their lives, they should not be met with more obstacles. They should not be met with\n               more discretion in the hands of the very institutions they are trying to scrutinize.\n               They should not be priced out of information. They should not be treated as a burden\n               simply for asking questions. But that is the direction Bill 9 takes us. Let us begin with one of the clearest examples of the bill. That's clause 3. Clause\n               3 changes the obligation on a public body to respond to an access request without\n               delay and replaces it with a duty to respond without unreasonable delay. Now, on first\n               hearing, some may say that's only a small wording change, but members of this House\n               know full well that legislation wording is never casual. Words are chosen carefully\n               because words create standards, and standards shape behaviour. \"Without delay\" is a firm expectation. It is clear. It tells the public body that\n               time matters. It tells the applicant that the law recognizes urgency. It tells everyone\n               involved that records should not simply sit idle because government is busy, disorganized\n               or politically uncomfortable with disclosure. \"Without unreasonable delay\" is softer. It's more elastic. It leaves far more room\n               for justification, more room for interpretation, more room for excuses. What is unreasonable\n               to the applicant may appear entirely reasonable to an office already accustomed to\n               backlog. What is unreasonable to the public may appear acceptable to a government\n               that has grown comfortable with delay. That is the problem. British Columbians are already frustrated by slow response times\n               in the FOI system. They are already dealing with a process that can feel distant,\n               drawn out and opaque. The answer to that problem is not to lower the legal standard owed to them. The answer\n               is to improve performance. The answer is to ensure proper staffing, clear procedures\n               and a culture that treats disclosure as the rule, not the exception. Government should\n               be working to speed up the system, not legislate the slowdown into more acceptable\n               language. Then we come to clause 2, which is also deeply concerning. Clause 2 changes section\n               5 so that an FOI request must, in the opinion of the head of the public body, provide\n               enough detail to enable an experienced employee, with reasonable effort in a reasonable\n               amount of time, to identify the record sought. Again, that wording matters. \"In the opinion of the head of the public body,\" \"reasonable\n               effort,\" \"reasonable amount of time\" — who defines those things? Who decides when\n               the request is detailed enough? Who decides when the amount of time spent searching\n               is too much? Who decides whether the request is sufficiently precise, especially when\n               the applicant may not know exactly what records exist in the first place? This House should remember that many people file FOI requests precisely because they\n               do not already have a full picture. They're seeking clarity. They're trying to identify\n               what happened, who said what, what records exist, what advice was given, what emails\n               or briefing materials are on file. They're not always in a position to provide a perfectly\n               narrow or tailored request on the first attempt, nor should they be expected to know\n               the internal filing systems, terminology or administrative practices of every ministry,\n               agency and public body in the province. That is why the law should lean toward helping the applicant, not screening them out.\n               But this bill leans the other way. It shifts more discretion towards the institution.\n               It makes the opinion of the public body's head more central. It introduces vague standards\n               that can easily become barriers. It increases the chances that a request can be pushed\n               back, narrowed, delayed or treated as defective before the applicant has even had\n               a fair chance to obtain the records. And what will this mean in practice? It'll mean more frustration for people who are\n               already trying to navigate an intimidating process. It'll mean more correspondence\n               back and forth over wording instead of substance. It will mean more opportunities\n               for delay. And when people see that happening over and over again, their confidence\n               in the system deteriorates. Our freedom-of-information regime only works if people\n               believe it is A freedom-of-information regime only works if people believe it is real. It only works\n               if they believe that when they ask a legitimate question, they will receive fair treatment\n               and a lawful disclosure. Once people begin to suspect that every ambiguity in the\n               law will be read in favour of government convenience, then the right still exists\n               on paper but becomes weaker in practice. That is why clause 13 is so significant. Clause 13 expands the grounds upon which\n               the commissioner may authorize a public body to disregard a request. It adds the behaviour\n               of the applicant being abusive or malicious and broadens the language concerning requests\n               that would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the public body or the government\n               of British Columbia. It also refers to requests that are repetitive, systematic, or\n               excessively broad. Now, let us be careful here. No one is arguing that truly bad-faith conduct should\n               be tolerated. No system can function properly if it is deliberately weaponized against\n               public servants or used as a means of harassment. There must be safeguards against\n               genuine abuse. But safeguards must be clear, narrow and carefully constrained. This clause is not that. Instead, it introduces broad language without meaningful\n               definition in the bill itself. Once again, that should concern every member of this\n               House, because vague terms can become elastic terms, and elastic terms are very often\n               used to the advantage of those already holding power. What is abusive? What is malicious? Does that mean a request that is angry in tone?\n               A request filed after months of government silence? A request by someone who has asked\n               too many uncomfortable questions? A request by a journalist following a story government\n               wishes to go away? And what about unreasonable interference with operations of government? That is a\n               particularly troubling phrase. Would a broad request into the Premier's office be\n               said to interfere with operations? Would multiple requests into major procurement\n               decisions be deemed systematic? Would opposition researchers, journalists, advocacy\n               organizations or municipal leaders be told their efforts amount to a burden on government\n               rather than an exercise in democratic oversight? These are not far-fetched questions. They are the obvious questions that arise when\n               legislation uses broad language and leaves the boundaries unclear. If the government\n               wanted merely to target truly vexatious conduct, it would have drafted narrow, well-defined\n               provisions. Instead, it has chosen language that opens the door much wider. That is\n               the concern. And British Columbians are right to be concerned when a government that\n               already struggles with transparency seeks broader authority to disregard requests. Accountability is often inconvenient. That is simply the nature of accountability.\n               It takes time to answer questions. It takes effort to gather records. It requires\n               a willingness to endure scrutiny. But inconvenience to government is not the same\n               thing as abuse by the applicant. The right to ask hard questions is not an administrative flaw. It is one of the essential\n               features of a functioning democracy. If government finds public scrutiny burdensome,\n               the answer is not to weaken access rights. The answer is to govern in a way that can\n               withstand scrutiny. I also want to speak to clause 21, because it represents one of the clearest examples\n               of this government taking something that should be easier and making it harder. Clause\n               21 allows the head of a public body to require a person who asks for a copy of a record\n               that is otherwise available under protective disclosure to pay a fee. That is astonishing. These are records that government itself says should be available\n               without a formal access request. That is the whole point of proactive disclosure.\n               It's supposed to mean less friction, fewer obstacles, more openness and easier public\n               access. It's supposed to reduce the need for formal FOI filings by making records\n               accessible up front. But under this bill, government can now say: \"Yes, the record is available, but you\n               may have to pay for it.\" That is not proactive disclosure in any meaningful public\n               sense. That is restricted access dressed up in a modern language. Let us be honest about who feels these kinds of changes most. It's not the large institution\n               with in-house counsel, not the ministry with taxpayer-funded staff, not the government\n               with all the records and all the procedural leverage. It is the ordinary person. It\n               is the local journalist on a tight budget. It is the resident trying to get information\n               about a matter affecting their family or community. It's the volunteer group. It's the student researcher. It is the taxpayer who already\n               paid once for the creation of the record and is now being asked to pay again to receive\n               it. The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous\n               to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step The government may say these fees are modest, but a barrier does not have to be enormous\n               to be effective. Sometimes all it takes is one more step, one more charge, one more\n               discouragement, and people walk away. That is especially true in a system that is\n               already slow and already difficult for many people to navigate. I would remind this House that that is not happening in a vacuum. British Columbians\n               have seen this government move before in ways that reduce access to information rather\n               than expand it. So when this bill arrives with new fees, broader refusal grounds and\n               weaker timing language, people notice the pattern. They notice that \"free\" is generally\n               being taken out of \"freedom of information.\" This government speaks often about trust. It speaks often about service delivery.\n               It speaks often about people-centred systems. Those are nice phrases, but trust is\n               not built through slogans. It is built through conduct. It is built when government\n               answers questions instead of dodging them. It is built when disclosure is timely,\n               instead of delayed. It is built when access is broad, instead of narrow. It is built\n               when rights are strengthened, instead of qualified away. On that test, Bill 9 does\n               not meet that standard. There's another feature of this bill that deserves careful examination. That is the\n               growing use of information-sharing powers and centralized service mechanisms without\n               sufficient public explanation. Clause 12 permits the commissioner to exchange information\n               and enter into information-sharing agreements with commissioners in other jurisdictions.\n               What jurisdictions? Clause 20 establishes what is called a \"connected services provider\" and authorizes\n               the minister to designate a public body for that role, with powers relating to online\n               platforms, data sharing between public bodies, identifying services for which a person\n               may be eligible, and other services the minister considers appropriate. Now, no one in this chamber is opposed to technology being used wisely. No one is\n               opposed to making public services easier to navigate. If a resident can access multiple\n               services through one platform, that may be beneficial. If systems can be modernized\n               responsibly, that may be beneficial. If duplication can be reduced while privacy is\n               preserved, that may be also beneficial. Legislation must be judged not by aspiration\n               alone but by powers it grants. What powers are being granted here? The minister may designate a connected services\n               provider. The minister may direct what type and quantity of personal information is\n               shared. The minister may direct formats of sharing. The minister may determine sources\n               of data. The minister may issue different directions for different classes of persons,\n               public bodies or categories of personal information. Those are substantial powers. When government centralizes information flows and expands the movement of personal\n               information across institutions, the public deserves detailed safeguards, clear limits\n               and confidence that privacy rights are not being eroded under the banner of convenience.\n               British Columbians live in an age of data breaches, cyberthreats, identity theft and\n               increasing concern over who holds their personal information. They are asked for more\n               information than ever before to access basic services. They are told to trust systems\n               they often cannot see and cannot inspect. Against that backdrop, government should proceed with humility and caution. Instead,\n               Bill 9 gives broad enabling authority first and leaves many practical questions unanswered.\n               How long is data retained? Who has access? What auditing mechanisms will exist? How\n               will consent be managed? How will errors be corrected when multiple systems rely on\n               shared data? What happens when a mistake in one database is replicated across several\n               agencies? How are vulnerable people protected from bureaucratic harm caused by incorrect\n               information? These are not technical afterthoughts. They are central questions of public trust.\n               If government wishes to expand such powers, it should welcome rigorous scrutiny rather\n               than expect automatic confidence. Clause 15 also merits attention. It permits the commissioner to extend the timeline\n               for a review, beyond the current 90-day requirement, by specifying a later date and\n               notifying relevant parties. Again, government may say this is practical administration.\n               Perhaps, in some circumstances, flexibility is needed, but let us consider the broader\n               pattern of this bill. The duty to respond becomes softer. Requests become easier to challenge for lack of\n               detail. Grounds to disregard become broader. Fees may be charged for certain available\n               records. Review times become more open-ended. At some point, these cannot be dismissed\n               as isolated housekeeping measures. They point in one direction: away from timely public\n               access At some point, these cannot be dismissed as isolated housekeeping measures. They point\n               in one direction, away from timely public access and toward administrative convenience\n               for the state. This is what concerns so many people when they look at this legislation. Accountability often dies not through dramatic scandal but through routine delay.\n               A request is unanswered. An extension is granted. A clarification is requested. Another\n               review is pending. Another deadline moves. Months pass. The news cycle moves on. The\n               issue fades. When records finally released no longer carry the same public value. Anyone who has observed access-to-information systems across Canada knows this pattern.\n               Delay itself can become a form of denial. Information released too late may satisfy\n               a legal check box while defeating the purpose of public scrutiny. That is why timing\n               matters so deeply. That is why weakening timing language matters. It is why open-ended\n               extensions matter. It is why a government serious about transparency would focus first\n               on response capacity rather than on new refusal mechanisms. I also wish to address the philosophical question at the centre of this debate. Who\n               does government work for? That may sound simple, but legislation like Bill 9 tests\n               whether this House still answers it properly. If government works for itself, then\n               public requests are interruptions. They are annoyances. They interfere with operations.\n               They consume time better spent elsewhere. They must be managed, filtered, narrowed,\n               discouraged and sometimes priced. But if government works for the public, then requests are legitimate acts of democratic\n               participation. They are how citizens supervise institutions larger than themselves.\n               They are how journalists investigate. They are how opposition members test claims.\n               They are how communities seek fairness. They are how truth is often assembled from\n               paper trails. I know which view I hold, and I believe most British Columbians know which view they\n               hold as well. They know instinctively that asking government questions should not\n               feel like trespassing. They know instinctively that public records should not be treated\n               as private possessions. They know instinctively that transparency delayed is transparency\n               diminished. There is another issue that cannot be ignored, and that is trust. Trust in institutions\n               has declined across much of the democratic world. People feel that discussions are\n               made far from them, explained poorly and shielded away from scrutiny. Whether one\n               agrees with every sentiment expressed publicly or not, that broader erosion of trust\n               is very real. When trust is fragile, government should respond by opening windows, not drawing curtains.\n               They should disclose more, not less. They should simplify access, not complicate it.\n               They should narrow discretion, not broaden it. They should make it easier for citizens\n               to see how decisions are made. Instead, Bill 9 risks sending the opposite message:\n               trust us more while we show you less. That is not a wise message for any government\n               to send. I do not doubt that some officials involved in drafting this legislation believe portions\n               of it are sensible. I do not doubt there are genuine administrative frustrations inside\n               ministries dealing with large volumes of requests. I do not doubt that systems need\n               updating. But inconvenience inside government cannot be the primary lens through which public\n               rights are viewed. Rights are often inconvenient. Elections are inconvenient. Question\n               period is inconvenient. Independent audits are inconvenient. Judicial review is inconvenient.\n               Freedom of information is inconvenient. Yet we maintain all of these because free\n               societies require institutions to answer to the people, not merely to themselves.\n               That is the balance government seems to forget. If government truly wished to improve the FOI system, there are many constructive\n               paths available. Increase staffing and access offices. Set enforceable service standards.\n               Publish more contracts, reports, calendars and briefing materials proactively. Reduce\n               unnecessary redactions. Create plain-language portals for applicants. Improve communication\n               with requesters. Invest in records management so searches are faster. Strengthen penalties\n               for deliberate obstruction. Report publicly on ministry performance. Those reforms would deserve support. Those reforms would align with the language of\n               efficiency and transparency. But this bill instead spends too much effort empowering\n               the institution rather than empowering the citizen. That is why we oppose it. I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism\n               is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process I wish to speak directly to public servants who may hear this debate. This criticism\n               is not aimed at the many hard-working professionals across government who process\n               requests, manage records and try to serve the public under difficult conditions. Many\n               of them do excellent work with limited resources and under heavy pressure. They often\n               inherit systems and workloads not of their making. Our concern is with the policy direction set by government. When front-line staff\n               are overburdened, the solution is support. When systems are outdated, the solution\n               is investment. When demand rises, the solution is capacity. The solution should not\n               be fewer rights for the public. Future governments of every stripe should pay attention.\n               Powers created for one administration are inherited by the next. Precedents accepted\n               today become tomorrow's tools. That is why opposition to measures like these should\n               not be viewed narrowly or temporarily. This House should legislate with constitutional maturity. Members should not ask merely:\n               will my side benefit from this now? They should ask: would I accept this power in\n               the hands of my opponents later? That test often clarifies matters quickly. If members\n               opposite would object to these provisions under a different government, then they\n               should reconsider supporting them under this one. Democracy depends not only on voting day but on the thousands of ordinary acts by\n               which citizens remain informed between elections. A parent asking for records, a reporter\n               following expenses, a research or tracing policy development, a community group seeking\n               environmental data, an opposition caucus testing government claims. These are not\n               hostile acts. They are signs of a healthy society. They are evidence that people still\n               care enough to ask. Government should meet that care with respect, not resistance. Bill 9 does not do enough of that. Instead, it normalizes a mindset that public inquiry\n               is a burden to be managed. It treats access too often as a problem rather than a principle.\n               It moves the dial, however politely, towards less openness. Those incremental moves\n               matter. I return to where I began. Access to information is not a favour. It is not a public\n               relations option. It is not something government may celebrate in speeches while constraining\n               in statute. It is a democratic safeguard. It is one of the few tools that equalizes\n               the relationship between the citizen and the state. Without it, power grows darker.\n               With it, power remains answerable. For those reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its present form. I urge government\n               to withdraw the restrictive provisions, remove the free fee barriers, tighten the\n               vague refusal clauses, restore stronger timelines and return to this House with legislation\n               that genuinely advances openness while protecting privacy. British Columbians deserve\n               a government confident enough to be examined, mature enough to be questioned and honest\n               enough to know that transparency is not a threat. It is the price of public power.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752250","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise in this House to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At the outset, I wanted to say this plainly: access to information is not a courtesy\n               that government extends when it's convenient. It is not a favour. It's not a privilege\n               reserved for those who know how to navigate bureaucracy","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a5e79820774c62bb49d2468df6561abf8a2633c4d2de42ba103e6cb49502a51"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ea466b5e870fe3ed9fb01c7d015adaf81393b5de420a493f3ad558e7203f199"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e316961a0a09529fe84fc41c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752251,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"A constituent of mine has been on a wait-list for a psychiatrist since 2023. And I\n               think if the minister keeps promising help, she's going to have to hire a psychiatrist\n               for that help, because we're not seeing it. Across the province and especially in\n               the North, health care is lacking everywhere. She was diagnosed with a mental illness and had been sober for 20 years, but without\n               access to proper psychiatric care, she relapsed. Since then, she has attempted to\n               take her own life, cycled through emergency care. Today there is no psychiatrist in\n               Houston or Smithers. To the minister, how does this government expect people to maintain recovery when\n               they cannot even access psychiatric care that they need to stay well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752251","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A constituent of mine has been on a wait-list for a psychiatrist since 2023. And I\n               think if the minister keeps promising help, she's going to have to hire a psychiatrist\n               for that help, because we're not seeing it. Across the province and especially in\n               the North, health care is lacking everywhere. She was diagnosed with a mental illness and had been sobe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c767fe1d475f485432a8f120d9f5536783400694c5ae33cde8bb2000e1565c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1eb38c918308dacef95feb5f7ce71077de56bd519a392637e69f41b9cf27fad9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ea2515ad1ea9497df1a036d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017362,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural\n               development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments\n               if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the minister and\n               their team who are here to assist in helping address some difficult questions regarding\n               this budget as they relate to the rural infrastructure and development in our vast\n               province. I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural I would be remiss by not stating at the outset that there are many rural British Columbians\n               who are increasingly frustrated that they continue to be treated as an afterthought\n               by this NDP government. Budget 2026 asks rural British Columbians to accept another\n               massive deficit, another dramatic increase in provincial debt and another series of\n               broad promises about future growth and resilience. Yet when rural communities look\n               for concrete investments in highways, bridges, broadband, emergency infrastructure,\n               transportation corridors, resource roads and economic-enabling projects, far too often\n               they find omissions, delays, deferrals and vague language instead of actual delivery. I did a little bit of research this morning. It was interesting because I wanted to find out. In our rural area,\n               Bulkley Valley–Stikine district.... It is 20 percent of the total land mass of this province, that district.\n               It remains in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. So 20 percent of the area of the province is in Bulkley Valley–Stikine. There's an awful lot of roads. There's an awful lot of infrastructure to take into\n               account, and I understand that. The government speaks frequently about reconciliation, economic development, climate\n               resilience, public safety, affordability and securing British Columbia's future. But\n               none of those goals can be achieved if rural British Columbians are left behind. The\n               people I represent do not measure infrastructure in press releases. They measure it\n               in whether ambulances can get through during winter storms. They measure it in whether\n               highways remain open during wildfire evacuations. They measure it in whether bridges\n               are safe for school buses and heavy trucks. We talked a lot about bridges today. They measure it in whether businesses can move goods efficiently, whether workers\n               can travel safely, whether internet service is reliable enough to run a business or\n               access health care, and whether communities can realistically grow and attract investment. Just thinking about the internet, it wasn't that long ago, two or three weeks ago,\n               my colleague from Skeena.... We were very concerned because I think from Burns Lake\n               down, somebody had cut the cable and there was no internet service. That means no\n               food, no gas, no calling for an ambulance. Nothing. So that is a grave concern about\n               connectivity. That is the reality of rural British Columbia. Instead, what we continue to see in Budget 2026 is an increasingly urban-centric infrastructure\n               strategy. Billions are allocated toward major metropolitan transit systems and large\n               urban capital projects, while many rural transportation corridors remain underfunded,\n               aging and vulnerable. One of the clearest examples is Highway 37, which is going to be the gateway to our\n               prosperity in looking west. For years, northern residents, Indigenous communities,\n               industry leaders, local governments and economic development organizations have called\n               on substantial improvements to Highway 37 as well as other rural roads. This corridor\n               is not merely a regional highway. It's a strategic economic artery supporting mining,\n               tourism, forestry, Indigenous economic participation, trade, emergency response and\n               northern development opportunities. This budget also fails to provide sufficient clarity regarding bridge replacement\n               priorities across northern and rural British Columbia. Critical bridges are aging,\n               deteriorating and increasingly vulnerable to climate-related impacts. Communities\n               deserve transparency about what structures are at risk, which projects have been delayed\n               and whether fiscal pressures inside government are quietly pushing vital infrastructure\n               further into the future. The same concerns apply to broadband infrastructure. Government members often speak\n               as though the connectivity challenge has already been solved. But many rural residents\n               continue struggling with unreliable internet service, cellular dead zones and inadequate\n               telecommunications infrastructure that limit economic opportunity, public safety,\n               health care access and education. For rural communities, broadband is no longer optional\n               infrastructure. It's essential infrastructure. We're also seeing growing concerns regarding emergency preparedness. Recent wildfire\n               seasons demonstrated the vulnerability of many rural communities that rely on single\n               transportation corridors with limited evacuation capacity. Yet this budget provides\n               insufficient detail regarding evacuation route improvements, flood mitigation investment,\n               slope stabilization work or climate resilience upgrades in vulnerable northern regions. At the same time, the government continues to increase borrowing dramatically. British\n               Columbians are being asked to carry unprecedented debt obligations, yet many rural\n               taxpayers legitimately question where the benefits are flowing. Are they being equally\n               distributed? Rural British Columbia contributes enormously to this province's prosperity. Northern\n               and rural communities generate revenues through forestry, mining, energy, agriculture,\n               tourism and transportation corridors that support the provincial economy. Rural workers\n               and industries help fund the service and infrastructure enjoyed throughout British\n               Columbia. The expectation of those communities is not The expectation of those communities is not special treatment. The expectation is\n               fairness. Fairness means recognizing that rural infrastructure is not a luxury. Indeed,\n               it is the backbone of economic development, public safety and provincial prosperity. Over the course of these estimates, I will be asking detailed and serious questions\n               about the government's infrastructure priorities, project delays, regional inequities,\n               deferred maintenance pressures, capital plan omissions and the long-term consequences\n               of failing to invest adequately in rural British Columbia. These are not abstract\n               policy debates. These are real concerns affecting real people in communities that\n               deserve to know whether this government has a credible plan for their future. Rural British Columbians are hardworking, resilient and resourceful people. They do\n               not ask for applause from government, but they do expect competence, transparency\n               and meaningful investment in the infrastructure that keeps their communities functioning\n               and their economies alive. I look forward to examining those questions in detail today. I will now proceed with my questions for these estimates. Budget 2026 projects taxpayer-supported debt rising towards $189 billion over the\n               fiscal plan, yet many rural highway projects remain absent from the capital plan.\n               Why is this government dramatically increasing debt while failing to identify major\n               rural highway upgrades in northern British Columbia? Can the minister provide a complete\n               list of rural highway expansion projects funded in Budget 2026?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017362","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to be able to discuss rural infrastructure and rural\n               development in the House today with estimates. I'd like to make a few opening comments\n               if I may, and I'll get into some questions. It is my pleasure to speak today on behalf of the people of the Bulkley Valley–Stikine and rural British Columbians across this province. I appreciate the m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5670db92437fb04ea1a3b06fc9e8efca63506821daec826627834c682c907beb","52a7f09fa7813f34e69dbe4194d24fe9c1136b978f1bb436cc1afbdda2c4285e","b2e6cb1dcca58f2d9fc0e777a8ce713f8c1cf9099f1ddbf1c135945d07076d1f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4dc42d4967dddb6696477f47e5387d939f10bb57c1edc6bd535970ebe76bf66d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c24d01a59cc4713f6921a5c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036492,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sharon Hartwell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yes I am.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036492","member_id":"bc-mla-359","member_name":"Sharon Hartwell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes I am.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d6417cb890ff88aa6e1069c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316778,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to speak to you about an issue that's near and dear to my heart. According\n               to Stats Canada, 44 percent of women in Canada have experienced abuse in a relationship\n               — almost half. Even worse, women are killed by partners every year after the abuse\n               escalates. It doesn't start deadly. You've heard the story about the frog in water. Drop it into\n               boiling water, and it jumps out immediately. But warm the water slowly, and it will\n               stay until it dies. Abuse and control can start subtle, and it's important to learn the signs. Attention\n               can feel like oxygen. Intensity can feel like security. First it's: \"Text me when\n               you get home.\" Then:  \"Why didn't you answer?\" Then: \"I don't like your friends. I\n               don't want you hanging out with them anymore.\" Then it's silence, tension, fear or\n               worse. If you feel confused rather than safe, those are signs. If you feel afraid to upset\n               him or them, and you shrink yourself, that is not love. Many women say they begin\n               to not recognize themselves anymore. They feel alone. But I hope all women will hear this. His insecurity is not your burden to carry. To\n               the young girls who feel alone, who don't have parents checking in or feel that they\n               wouldn't understand, you are not alone. If you see the signs and you want to get out,\n               we are here. Signs live in the body, like feeling anxious, tight or frozen. The first time you\n               feel that pit in your stomach is the moment you should begin to back away. That is\n               self-love. A show of your internal strength is to say, \"If you continue doing x, y,\n               z, I will remove access,\" and meaning it. Even when your voice trembles, we're holding your hand. Each one of you, no matter\n               your story, deserves calm, steady and safe love. Women and girls of B.C. who are in\n               these controlling and abusive relationships, jump while the water is still warm. VictimLinkBC is a toll-free, confidential, multilingual service available 24-7. Call\n               1-800-563-0808.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316778","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I want to speak to you about an issue that's near and dear to my heart. According\n               to Stats Canada, 44 percent of women in Canada have experienced abuse in a relationship\n               — almost half. Even worse, women are killed by partners every year after the abuse\n               escalates. It doesn't start deadly. You've heard the story about the frog in water. Drop it into","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","label":"Aquatic wildlife","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e6f9142b079596ecd095175f3aff7540ef1c3154e6a7701504aba222c468f3e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8774d2d1ca0ef906be0dbef92aeaea07586d2c088b43c7b2032f020b528f6d07"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b5e2bc07648e3362b2c18e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316779,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316779","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a058ba0cd668c3de01fa5392d48d7ce61683d06022920a92f5d46b4e8f159e9","2caa1d0e68c6eac6c01d595a52a5e4a6c82bead3ce951b2de37e6f03e2ab363d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4f9ada42ccf590d1d3e8872","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316780,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"My Whip's assistant, my very capable Whip's assistant, has some special guests here\n               today. So please join me in welcoming her dad, Jeff Keenliside, and her grandma, Janice\n               Murray. Please join me in welcoming her dad, Jeff Keenliside, and her grandma Janice Murray.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316780","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"My Whip's assistant, my very capable Whip's assistant, has some special guests here\n               today. So please join me in welcoming her dad, Jeff Keenliside, and her grandma, Janice\n               Murray. Please join me in welcoming her dad, Jeff Keenliside, and her grandma Janice Murray.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["004fa55dd9aa46acfd3b6dc6b87175acaa2caefc3b0ccc2e45a5796a4fa15def"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31e9a8924514e42704bf351f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327901,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am thrilled to announce and introduce, of course, many folks that the minister just\n               spoke to, but there are three staunch advocates of workers and the forestry sector\n               and they are members of my union local 2009. I want to give a shout-out to Aman Chumber,\n               who is the newly minted president, and thank Al Bieksa for his time as president.\n               His retirement party is coming up this Friday, so get your ticket. I'd also like to shout out my friends Kelly Gulka and, my union pops, Mike Duhra. Thank you so much for joining us today, and I wish I could be there with you. Please join me in welcoming them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327901","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am thrilled to announce and introduce, of course, many folks that the minister just\n               spoke to, but there are three staunch advocates of workers and the forestry sector\n               and they are members of my union local 2009. I want to give a shout-out to Aman Chumber,\n               who is the newly minted president, and thank Al Bieksa for his time as president.\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["441f640dd9ec1f3151433cb04acbee3d023bef48610ab0f17a064ec0f9fe74e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c3fbce0fe95d7238a956f7d96ee1eafbdcfa4028457706d2a5af0f4869b2c0c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9e45dfe84fbd944c249479e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358939,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Housing and Municipal Affairs and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358939","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Housing and Municipal Affairs and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8dd055ec4a07f95e1e155e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358940,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I had the honour of hosting a lunch today with the B.C. Epilepsy Society. They're\n               joining us in the gallery today, and I just want to take a moment to welcome them.\n               I hope you'll all join me. Trevor Young is the chair of the B.C. Epilepsy board of\n               directors. Deirdre Syms, executive director of the B.C. Epilepsy Society. Irene, Trevor's partner, is\n               also joining us. Quina Wong and Esther McConia. Please join me in welcoming these amazing advocates. Without the work you do, so many people would be left navigating epilepsy without\n               you. Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358940","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I had the honour of hosting a lunch today with the B.C. Epilepsy Society. They're\n               joining us in the gallery today, and I just want to take a moment to welcome them.\n               I hope you'll all join me. Trevor Young is the chair of the B.C. Epilepsy board of\n               directors. Deirdre Syms, executive director of the B.C. Epilepsy Society. Irene, Trevor's partner, is\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["521d399600a0511113401c39b9071ea2b7023e83ef015d1d47b6b86f8439d0ef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f2cd8fe7e8c7165b7fac530","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358941,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order. I want to highlight the very harm that comes from even\n               bringing these types of bills forward that the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream just did. I would like to bring it on the record that this is stochastic terrorism.\n               It is using your platform to mobilize people who are willing to cause harm, and I\n               think that we should do something about this. I just want to bring this to your attention\n               and I would like a response from you on it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358941","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order. I want to highlight the very harm that comes from even\n               bringing these types of bills forward that the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream just did. I would like to bring it on the record that this is stochastic terrorism.\n               It is using your platform to mobilize people who are willing to cause harm, and I\n               think that we sh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","label":"Hazardous materials transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73fca7e4a5c6b9a49d6b2861374e76324b1efbc569fbbbb0075f3e0a8e2c6621"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c1e426023ab160a9883214f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413643,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to take a moment to introduce the Afghan community society of Nanaimo. Please\n               stand up so everybody can see you. These are amazing advocates that support newcomers\n               from Afghanistan with a special focus on women, ensuring to build leadership capacity\n               so that they can support all the other members of their community. They came from\n               across B.C. They're supporting people in Burnaby, Vancouver, Victoria and Nanaimo.\n               We're so thankful you were able to make it today. Would the House please join me in\n               welcoming them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413643","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to take a moment to introduce the Afghan community society of Nanaimo. Please\n               stand up so everybody can see you. These are amazing advocates that support newcomers\n               from Afghanistan with a special focus on women, ensuring to build leadership capacity\n               so that they can support all the other members of their community. They came from\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f7c569aad8a89ea230eacbbe4e66da37a4e063a0404f91cb15e3c77fbe47548"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf471d1fbd33eb873510e420","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720087,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to start by thanking the firefighters. I'd be remiss to not mention the third anniversary of the passing of Ray Sawada, former NHL player and member of the Burnaby Firefighters, who joined in 2017. Rest in power, Ray. Firefighters put their lives on the line every day to protect us all. Your courage\n               and commitment do not go unnoticed, and we are deeply grateful for the sacrifices\n               you and your families make. I also want to thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove and all the members of the committee for the time and care you've put into examining\n               this important issue. To everyone who participated in the process, through written submissions or presentations,\n               thank you for contributing to our democracy in such a meaningful way. Supporting the mental health and well-being of our front-line workers, including firefighters,\n               has been a top priority for our government since 2017. Supporting the mental health and well-being of our front-line workers, including firefighters,\n               has been a top priority for our government since 2017. Over the years, we've taken\n               steps, important ones, to strengthen protections by expanding presumptive coverage\n               and ensuring it reflects the realities firefighters are facing today. This includes\n               broadening the definition of who's covered, moving beyond firefighters employed by\n               local governments to include federal firefighters — such as those working on military\n               bases in B.C.; provincial wildfire firefighters — that is a mouthful; firefighters\n               employed by First Nations and Indigenous organizations; and fire investigators who\n               are members of a fire brigade. We've also expanded the list of cancers recognized as occupational diseases and reduced\n               the minimum cumulative employment periods for several cancers, including testicular,\n               colorectal and esophageal cancer. Most recently we took a significant step forward\n               by increasing the number of cancers covered under presumptive legislation from 18\n               to 26. This means British Columbia now has the most comprehensive firefighter cancer\n               presumption protections in Canada. The addition of cancers such as skin cancer, mesothelioma, soft tissue sarcoma and\n               several respiratory-related cancers reflects evolving scientific understanding and\n               ensures more firefighters can access timely support when they need it most. Importantly,\n               these protections now extend to approximately 15,000 firefighters across the province,\n               including career, volunteer and wildland firefighters. For wildland firefighters,\n               we recognize the unique nature of their work by counting a single fire season as a\n               full year of exposure for compensation purposes. Our work doesn't stop here. We are actively supporting efforts to improve data and\n               research, including collaboration with Statistics Canada on the development of a national\n               firefighter cancer registry. Together, we are building a stronger, more informed system, one that honours the service\n               of firefighters and supports their health today and into the future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720087","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to start by thanking the firefighters. I'd be remiss to not mention the third anniversary of the passing of Ray Sawada, former NHL player and member of the Burnaby Firefighters, who joined in 2017. Rest in power, Ray. Firefighters put their lives on the line every day to protect us all. Your courage\n               and commitment do not go unnoticed, and we are deeply grateful for the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4156207eee59ead9726359bcef2a300c6c150223fcc5ae6d010c0a190ece4303"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84530090a13b4df089007dd56383b2e2cf1e3c70df4115d16524e24ef2b44cf5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-573cbc123c639953c13550da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720088,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last month, at the Durpin's IWD event, I was introduced to an amazing woman panellist,\n               Farkhunda Muhtaj. A professional soccer player and coach from Calgary, she's captain\n               of the Afghanistan national team and shared her story as being a key figure in evacuating\n               the girls' youth team from Afghanistan following the Taliban's takeover. To say I was incredibly inspired would be an understatement. I asked her if she wanted\n               to share a message with us, and I'll read directly from what she had to say. \"I would like legislators to know that although Canada has historically been supportive\n               of resettling refugees, we cannot forget about the root I would be remiss if I didn't take a moment to say [a language other than English was spoken] to MLA for Surrey City Centre's parents for being here. As you can see, Afghan women lead the way again and again,\n               and it is a pleasure to be working with your daughter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720088","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Last month, at the Durpin's IWD event, I was introduced to an amazing woman panellist,\n               Farkhunda Muhtaj. A professional soccer player and coach from Calgary, she's captain\n               of the Afghanistan national team and shared her story as being a key figure in evacuating\n               the girls' youth team from Afghanistan following the Taliban's takeover. To say I was incredi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","label":"Women workers","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f620650b1b4a2d3477deac30e29fd8471a51210985c4b7a5837201784eafcb2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f0c474c29cd1b5183e6636a989addcfdb544f1a24815df713b1fa9eae581d16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-073990040f1dacdc1381eb80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721164,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today not just to support Bill 20 but to respond directly to many of the remarks\n               made today by members of the opposition, and also by the critic for Indigenous Relations\n               yesterday, in the House When we first begin to think about the lay of the land, we have to talk about the\n               original violence that occurred on these lands. That has to be the basis for where\n               the conversation begins. There has to be a foundational understanding. It is very\n               clear, based on the comments I've heard from several of the members of the opposition It is very clear, based on the comments I've heard from several of the members of\n               the opposition speaking today, that that level of understanding varies. That's okay.\n               I understand that. When my colleague, Minister of Environment, stood up to speak and shared her thoughts\n               about herself as an Indigenous woman standing in this building, working directly on\n               issues that impact the broader community of which she belongs to, it is not a hypothetical.\n               We're not talking about racism over there somewhere. That is a woman embodying the\n               experience, the cultural backlash, the challenges of being an Indigenous woman, and\n               the way that she is treated. It is really important to understand that when someone in front of you who has the\n               lived experience as a racialized person, Indigenous or Black person — that when they're\n               sharing their experience, believe them. That is the first place to start. I've heard so many different comments today. It's going to take me some time to go\n               through many of the comments that I think are important to expand upon. I heard several\n               times over from the members that they want to hear the reason to support this treaty.\n               Yet I've heard time and time again from just a few members, recently, that just spoke,\n               that their intention is to support treaties, that their intention is that they do\n               support First Nations, that they are willing to go and meet with First Nations. Yet\n               I hear a double standard. And I say this respectfully. You know, many of you, that I can be very passionate on particular topics, but this\n               is an issue that not only is it near and dear, but as a racialized woman myself, as\n               someone belonging to the Punjabi community with parents who are immigrants, who came\n               here in the 1970s.... By the way, people of India and Pakistan share the same — not\n               the same, but we share the same colonizer, slightly different history. So this topic\n               really hits close to home. When I hear that there are challenges, whether it be jurisdictional, whether it be\n               that there are some nations that have frustrations, why is it that it's held to a\n               different standard? Often there are laws that are passed that will address the issue\n               of the moment, whatever that may be. There's ongoing work to work with other communities.\n               It is rich to me to say that we should hold back the work of this treaty. Thirty years\n               since 1994, 32 years. The Canadian government, the provincial government and K'ómoks began discussions. Finally, we get to a place where I never thought as a six- or seven-year-old watching\n               parliamentary proceedings that I would be standing here, being able to witness a treaty\n               celebrated as a member of this Legislature, to be in community, in the Hall of Honour,\n               celebrating and feeling not only my spirits rise but hope for the future. It is a\n               historic moment. To say that it's rushed is a really unfortunate perspective. I'm trying to understand\n               why 32 years feels rushed. The treaty process is done by the treaty commissioner and\n               their team. Several times the member who spoke just before me said that the province\n               was taking part in the decision-making and, at the same time, saying the Treaty Commission\n               was making decisions. So which is it? Once the treaty agreement has been reached, our job is to help propel it forward.\n               And that is to keep us out of courts. That is to keep K'ómoks out of courts. Yes, there are always challenges, no matter what, in any law that's being passed.\n               There will be people that are happy with the law that's passed, and there will be\n               people that have concerns. That's the reason in the treaty process that there's a\n               certain amount of time where engagement is actually ongoing even though the treaty\n               has been ratified. This is that time, not to mention the member who spoke before me Not to mention, the member who spoke before me also spoke to the fact that during\n               committee stage, we'll be able to have robust discussions about it as well. There\n               is ample opportunity in front of you where discussions can be had and will be had. And yet there's this hesitation to support it. I understand that we're on opposite sides. I really get it. I know that we have to\n               represent our parties and our values. But from what I heard from the few members that\n               spoke before me, it seems that we're all on the same page. We want the same thing.\n               Yet we in these chambers are not on the same page about how we go about it. Is that a reason to stall 32 years of work? I really struggle with that. It isn't that I just heard a concern about the process. From many of the members,\n               not including a few that I heard speak today — I'm thankful that they reiterated their\n               support — I heard a pattern of language that casts Indigenous rights as chaos, that\n               treats Indigenous governance as suspect. It frames reconciliation as something to be feared rather than fulfilled. I have to say this at the outset. After listening to the speech from the critic yesterday,\n               it's difficult for me to maintain confidence in his approach being taken toward what\n               should be a role of constructive criticism. It should help move us forward. But we\n               have to understand the ramifications when we speak about a community in a blanket\n               way. Indigenous communities and their populations were much larger. Because of colonization,\n               not only did their populations dwindle. Their language was taken from them. They were\n               taken from their homes. I mean, imagine you opening your door, a police officer and\n               someone from a church standing outside, ripping your child out of your arms, and you\n               never see them again. You can imagine the damage that does to you for your own generation\n               — likely the pain of being unwilling to talk about it because it's unfathomable. I have to say, respectfully, to my friends across the aisle: you have a residential\n               school denier that's being courted right now to come back into your ranks. It is really\n               important, if you're going to be values-driven, to be values-driven regardless if\n               it makes you popular or not. I know that firsthand. I have taken time to speak to the Elders in community. I live in the riding of Burnaby East. My riding is situated on the lands of the xwməθkwəy̓əm, Sḵwx̱wú7mesh, səlilwətaɬ\n               and kwikwəƛ̓əm Nations. Four nations. Elders who have lived through some of the darkest\n               chapters in this province's history are telling me now that the racism that they are\n               facing today reminds them of when they were in residential schools. Why does that matter? Because since the beginning of this session.... By the way, what\n               a diverse group of MLAs. We have four Indigenous women here. It's something to celebrate on both sides. I'm hearing that the racism that these Elders are facing today reminds them of being\n               in residential schools. That is such a profound thing to hear. What that says to me\n               is that the beginning of this session, where several of the members on the other side, many\n               of whom are not in the caucus today.... Not only was a documentary filmed — harming\n               Indigenous communities, calling reconciliation an industry. Yet members of the caucus even today on the other side have shared that they support\n               treaties. There isn't a single person on our side that doesn't support treaties. There isn't\n               a single person on our side that doesn't understand to some degree the history There isn't a single person on our side that doesn't support treaties. There isn't\n               a single person on our side that doesn't understand to some degree the history of\n               the original violence of colonization that took place on these lands. This is not \"everyone is bad, and some people are good\" or \"some people are bad, and\n               some people are worse.\" We can't simplify it to this zero-one-sum game. It's not.\n               Just because some First Nations are receiving their rights, it doesn't mean that others\n               are losing out in some way. This is equity in action — justice and equity. It's not a piece of pie that you can\n               eat. They are rights that, when fulfilled, may feel uncomfortable for those who have\n               never had to have their existence, their rights and their freedom of movement challenged. First Nations were forced onto reserves. Many of them were fishing, farming communities,\n               nomadic. They moved up and down with the seasons because that's where their food sources\n               were, caring and stewarding this land. They were pushed back further and further.\n               So from having access to fish, now you can't fish. You've got to go back further. Well, guess what. The government of the day — no conversation. Just, by the way, a\n               law has been passed. You've got to move back further. So now maybe you're a few miles\n               away. And we have cars today. First Nations didn't have cars back then. Many people\n               didn't. So imagine the trek you have to make. Not only that, but you're not welcome\n               when you do make it. You're looked at as some kind of scourge in society. Laws being passed is one thing, but there's a need for language and cultural revitalization,\n               and that means that members in this House have to be very careful about the approach\n               that they take when they're talking about First Nations. Racialized people – Indian,\n               Pakistani, Jewish, Muslim — every community that is here has the right to live with\n               dignity, with respect and be able to move freely. Partially, the treaty process seeks to recognize the rights that were inherent to\n               First Nations, not rights that are being made up. These always existed. The perspective\n               of the original governments.... This province itself formed in 1871. In 1872, First Nations and the Chinese community\n               lost the right to vote. I don't know if members on the other side know this. What\n               happened is that the First Nations of the time were incredible organizers, and they\n               supported one candidate that was running. The governing party didn't like that, so\n               they took their rights away, and it took years to get it back. I am from here, born on the territory of the xwməθkwəy̓əm, Sḵwx̱wú7mesh and səlilwətaɬ. I don't have to prove how much blood of mine is Indian. I don't have to do that.\n               It's just accepted. First Nations have to prove through blood quantum. Who else lives\n               by these rules? Do you have to prove how Asian you are, how Black you are, how Jewish\n               you are, how Muslim you are, how Christian you are? These things matter because at the end of the day, it's a deep othering, a deep injustice\n               that's not just entrenched through laws of the past but also socially. My friendly\n               colleague across from me, from Maple Ridge East, Burnaby East, we have that in common. I have seen people pick on you for the fact that you speak English a little differently,\n               and yet you are such an intelligent, sharp person. Why is it that people who are Indigenous or racialized or Black have to be limited\n               and almost watered down and diluted to only how we don't fit in? A treaty process recognizes that the people that have been here since the beginning\n               have a right, have always had those rights, and it's our government that's doing the\n               hard work to recognize them. And at 32 A 32-year process could have been any government. It's not that we're trying to rush\n               something through. We're told that an agreement is reached. We're told that there\n               is space by the Treaty Commission, by the way, through a clearly defined process where\n               Wei Wai Kai and Wei Wai Kum and other neighbouring nations would have the ability to speak about any concerns\n               that they have so that it can be continually addressed. Laws are evolving. I heard the member before me say that we need to achieve final\n               reconciliation. I would be interested to know how she defines that. What does final\n               reconciliation mean? I've heard my friends on the other side talk about economic reconciliation.\n               Fine. That's a part of it, of course. But what about social reconciliation? What about\n               dignity? What about the fact that there are First Nations communities with their status\n               Indian cards who are sometimes denied access because of communities that don't have\n               a good understanding of the history? They don't even recognize those as licences or\n               appropriate government ID when we know that they are. There's something to be said about the fact that so many people in our province don't\n               have knowledge about First Nations. Why is it that we're looking at communities so\n               separately in that way? Humanity should unite us all, number one. But rights that\n               have been withheld through laws, policies, when being made right, is not taking rights\n               away from anyone else. I can understand that there are frustrations and there are\n               challenges and that Wei Wai Kum has some thoughts, and I'm thankful that they're bringing them forward. I know that\n               the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation is absolutely focused on the challenges that they're bringing forward and is looking\n               for a way to support them. That is the role. The problem for me personally, through my experience, is when the K'ómoks treaty is becoming so politicized. Yes, there are concerns right now. British Columbians\n               are trying to understand the ramifications, the legal concerns. But legal chaos? That's\n               the wrong word. The official opposition critic yesterday said legal chaos. Is it really\n               chaotic to find a way and a path forward with First Nations, hand in hand, in lockstep? When the member said that recognizing Indigenous rights will create legal chaos, I\n               thought: \"What does he call the last 150 years in British Columbia?\" Was it not chaos\n               when treaties were never signed across most of this province? There is a reason we\n               call it unceded territory, unsurrendered territory. Was it not chaos when First Nations\n               were confined to reserves that represented a fraction of their lands? Was it not chaos\n               when children were taken to residential schools and entire cultures were targeted\n               for erasure? That is the real history of the province. Bill 20 is not creating instability. It's not creating legal chaos. It's confronting\n               it. It's confronting that real history. The dismissal of the United Nations declaration\n               on the rights of Indigenous Peoples.... Let's talk about that. We heard it described\n               as aspirational. We heard it mocked, as though it were some abstract idea that does\n               not belong here. But let me be clear. UNDRIP is not foreign to British Columbia. It reflects principles\n               that have existed on this land long before the Legislature ever did, principles of\n               shared stewardship, consent, and respect for territory. To dismiss it is not just\n               a legal argument. It is a dismissal of Indigenous governance itself, and that is something\n               this House collectively shouldn't tolerate. To dismiss it is not just a legal argument. It is a dismissal of Indigenous governance\n               itself, and that is something this House collectively shouldn't tolerate. The member also warned of uncertainty again and again, but the truth is that uncertainty\n               is what happens when rights are ignored. Treaties like this do not create uncertainty.\n               They replace courtroom battles with negotiated agreements. They replace conflict with\n               clarity. They replace decades of litigation with a path forward. And I heard many times that we have to find a way to address this. We do have a way:\n               modern treaties. That is the way. There was language used that suggested Indigenous nations somehow are drawing lines on a map or creating claims out of thin air. But let's\n               be honest about what that implies. First Nations did not arrive here recently; everyone else did. And that's okay. We all make up\n               this beautiful province of British Columbia, and clearly, from even some of the comments\n               of my friendly colleagues on the other side, I heard that they too want to live with\n               First Nations and other communities harmoniously. And yet there's a cognitive dissonance,\n               because there are statements being made that would speak contrary. There's no invention of a connection to this land. It exists. It simply does. Their\n               laws, their governance and their stewardship go back thousands of years. If there\n               are lines on a map that do not reflect that reality, it's because those lines were\n               drawn without them. B.C., Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec, P.E.I.,\n               Newfoundland, Nova Scotia, the territories — these were lines that were drawn on a\n               map and then given names. Bill 20 seeks to partly correct that with ongoing work. And the reality is that things\n               evolve. Reconciliation, in my view, is not something to be final; it's ongoing work.\n               Because it's not just political. It's social. It's cultural. Of course, the concerns that I've heard about overlapping territories and the need\n               for consultation is something we've heard very clearly. We are alive to the issue.\n               It's not that we are ignoring it. And yes, that work will continue and that dialogue\n               matters, but we shouldn't use the complexity of the issue as paralysis to take action.\n               Because if we wait for perfection before moving forward, reconciliation would never\n               happen. That's not acceptable. For too long, this province has been built like a house without a foundation, constructed\n               quickly, unevenly and without the consent of those who were already here. Every time\n               we take a step toward treaty, we are not tearing that house down; we're actually reinforcing\n               it. We are making it stronger, fairer and more livable and stable for everyone who\n               lives here. We have to move past the rhetoric of fear. It's in our best interest. Racism and discrimination\n               impacts — materially — resources. It limits workforce participation, affects mental\n               health because of discrimination, over-policing We have to move past the idea that recognizing rights of Indigenous communities somehow\n               threatens the rest of society. It doesn't. I'm not threatened by it. I know my colleagues\n               on my side of the aisle are not either. Bill 20 is not something radical. What was\n               radical was ignoring Indigenous title for over a century. That was radical. Bill 20\n               is not uncertain. What was uncertain was leaving these issues unresolved for generations.\n               Bill 20 is not chaos. It's responsibility. This is not about politics. This is about finishing the work that should have been\n               done long ago. It is about doing it with honesty, with respect and the courage to\n               move it forward. I strongly support this bill. I urge all members of this House to\n               do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721164","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today not just to support Bill 20 but to respond directly to many of the remarks\n               made today by members of the opposition, and also by the critic for Indigenous Relations\n               yesterday, in the House When we first begin to think about the lay of the land, we have to talk about the\n               original violence that occurred on these lands. That has to be the basis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["051364f39b40d0278ec8704f4fe20abbea85af63b65439636da5e7137c330f83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f36593433076c638f78db0d394743bad6aded229da1c684a5c0314e5e8b04f67"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-582e663fa8bfe0e9f9471d78","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728744,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last year during Sikh Heritage Month, I spoke about Vaisakhi and shared the story\n               of the founding of the Khalsa by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. I spoke about what happened\n               that day in Anandpur Sahib, in the year 1699, but not fully about who made it happen. This year, I aim to do just that. Because to understand this story more deeply, we\n               must first understand one word — \"caste\". Caste is a system of social hierarchy rooted\n               in birth. Yes, birth, that which we cannot control. It assigns people a status that\n               cannot change, historically shaping opportunity, dignity and belonging. At the very bottom, were people treated as \"Untouchable,\" now commonly known as \"Dalits,\"\n               who were excluded and marginalized. Caste is an unequal system with clear benefactors,\n               much like racism. It is against this backdrop that we return to the year 1699. When Guru Gobind Singh\n               Ji stood before a crowd and asked people to literally give their heads for faith,\n               five individuals stepped forward. This year, I want to return to who they were It is against this backdrop that we return to the year 1699. When Guru Gobind Singh\n               Ji stood before a crowd and asked people to literally give their heads for faith,\n               five individuals stepped forward. This year, I want to return to who they were – the\n               panj pyare, or the five beloved ones. What made this moment revolutionary was not only their courage. It was that they came\n               forward in spite of who the world said they should be. They came from different regions,\n               professions and places within that very caste system, some from so-called higher castes;\n               others from communities forced into the margins. They entered the tent with the guru\n               as five individuals, five faithful individuals emerging from a fearful crowd, and\n               yet when they came out dressed in royal saffron robes, something had fundamentally\n               shifted. Their decision to stand together as equals paints an image so vivid that if you looked\n               up the word \"unity\" in the dictionary, their image would suffice. Guru Gobind Singh\n               Ji gave them one surname, Singh, meaning lion; one identity; one responsibility —\n               to protect the vulnerable, to stand against injustice, to see all humanity as equal.\n               This was not just the birth of the Khalsa. It was a direct rejection of caste. And that is where Sikh Heritage Month and Dalit history month meet — at the intersection of faith and humanity, of courage and equality, of bravely\n               standing up for what is right. However, my friends, history does not stay in the past. It is relived when the lessons are not embodied. That same struggle lived on through leaders\n               like Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Jyotirao Phule, who refused to accept inequality as destiny and instead\n               demanded justice through action. Today we are reminded that this issue has not disappeared. In June 2020, a landmark\n               case was filed against Cisco Systems by the California civil rights department. At\n               the centre was a Dalit engineer in Silicon Valley who alleged discrimination, harassment\n               and retaliation by higher caste managers. He reported that he was outed without consent, leading to isolation,\n               lost opportunities and barriers to advancement. The response? That caste was not a protected category. But injustice does not disappear simply because it is unrecognized in the law. The\n               case continues to unfold, the impact clear. It forced a conversation. Companies like\n               Apple moved to explicitly ban caste discrimination. IBM updated its policies. At Google,\n               employees organized and pushed for change. And in 2023, Seattle became the first city\n               in the U.S. to ban caste-based discrimination. The question for me becomes: what about us? Here in British Columbia, we pride ourselves\n               on leadership in human rights. But leadership is not what we say. It is what we choose\n               to do. We have the opportunity to be ahead of the curve, to recognize caste-based\n               discrimination, to ensure that equality is not conditional but universal. The message of those two months is not separate. It's shared. It is the courage of\n               the panj pyare. It is the fight for dignity. It is the refusal to accept injustice\n               anywhere. The question is not whether this fight exists. The question is whether we are willing\n               to stand in it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728744","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Last year during Sikh Heritage Month, I spoke about Vaisakhi and shared the story\n               of the founding of the Khalsa by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. I spoke about what happened\n               that day in Anandpur Sahib, in the year 1699, but not fully about who made it happen. This year, I aim to do just that. Because to understand this story more deeply, we\n               must first understand","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","label":"Social structure"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","label":"Social structure","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","label":"Vaccination","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a54ecebd89a88db77eb05ea72f8e098716e7bf6eb41fa3084be6b930e10d6c31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89449ada804dc9961d4d279d37d676e2d97f18135a84be0a200435c8bde9c22e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4a86113bd7795bcf2b86ded","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728748,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to take a moment to shout out three amazing advocates and supporters: Jessie Kaur Lehail, who's the chapter director of Shelter Movers; Shana Slater, as well as Preetka Pattar. All three of them were supposed to be here today, but they actually had an emergency\n               and are supporting someone escaping intimate partner violence, hence the organization\n               Shelter Movers. Please join me in welcoming them. I will be speaking about them later today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728748","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to take a moment to shout out three amazing advocates and supporters: Jessie Kaur Lehail, who's the chapter director of Shelter Movers; Shana Slater, as well as Preetka Pattar. All three of them were supposed to be here today, but they actually had an emergency\n               and are supporting someone escaping intimate partner violence, hence the organization\n               Shelter Movers.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aa39744dcb964f16bf0c58c7375e364b48c766c050198e5cadc2b59f5fc02ac3","61ebc8b356e6c2889c3b0ca5fd86921f385cec2ba4612ca6f3cafba3e739e57c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-105504ddb34ab19be7f5cdcd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728751,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also wanted to join some of my colleagues in expressing my gratitude for meeting\n               with the NCCM, many of the advocates in leadership. But I just happened to see a dear friend up in the gallery, Kabir Khurban, who I initially\n               met in 2015 working on a campaign for Surrey Centre federally, and he has gone on\n               to run on campaigns But I just happened to see a dear friend up in the gallery, Kabir Qurban, who I initially\n               met in 2015 working on a campaign for Surrey Centre federally. He has gone on to run\n               on campaigns, put his name bravely forward as a candidate, and I see him to be a shining\n               star. So please join me in welcoming Kabir Qurban to the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728751","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I also wanted to join some of my colleagues in expressing my gratitude for meeting\n               with the NCCM, many of the advocates in leadership. But I just happened to see a dear friend up in the gallery, Kabir Khurban, who I initially\n               met in 2015 working on a campaign for Surrey Centre federally, and he has gone on\n               to run on campaigns But I just happened to see ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4d8f3830ca2305e1313ccf9b1c478dc750992cf2d1de88e8201f55e4f176bef"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41df3b6c98f76f2795ad9523","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728756,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm not going to start this speech by telling you what artificial intelligence is,\n               because you already know, or at least you think you do. AI is the voice finishing\n               your sentences, the map predicting your turns, the feed deciding what you see before\n               you even know you want to see it. It is invisible until it isn't. Let's be honest. AI is impressive. It can diagnose diseases faster than doctors in\n               some cases, translate languages in real time and solve problems that would take humans\n               years, sometimes centuries. It doesn't get tired, it doesn't forget, and it doesn't\n               need coffee breaks. That's the promise. But every promise has a shadow, because the same system that helps a doctor detect\n               cancer can also decide whether you get hired or rejected without explanation. The\n               same intelligence that connects the world can quietly divide it, feeding each of us\n               a slightly different version of reality until truth becomes negotiable. And then there's the uncomfortable question. If AI can do what we do, only faster,\n               cheaper and at scale, where does that leave us? Not obsolete, but not unchanged. Jobs\n               will shift, skills will evolve, and some doors will close before we even realize they\n               existed. But here's the part we don't talk about enough. AI doesn't have ambition. It doesn't\n               have ethics. It doesn't have a sense of meaning. Those things still belong to us.\n               So maybe the real question isn't: is AI good or bad? Maybe the question is: what do\n               we choose to do with something this powerful? Because AI is not the author of our\n               future. It's the amplifier. Whatever we do, curious or careless, fair or biased, thoughtful\n               or reactive, AI will make us more of it. So if you're looking for a conclusion, here it is. The story of AI is not really about\n               machines becoming intelligent. It's about humans deciding what kind of intelligence\n               we value and whether we're ready to live with the answer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728756","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm not going to start this speech by telling you what artificial intelligence is,\n               because you already know, or at least you think you do. AI is the voice finishing\n               your sentences, the map predicting your turns, the feed deciding what you see before\n               you even know you want to see it. It is invisible until it isn't. Let's be honest. AI is impressive. It c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","label":"Beverages","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e39200bb268536ac69207d2d714e3225100c00110eddad4c705709c6da73a83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c56d1d507241df74f2a9443137c558b236f485bc960b88b5005d7a5206c64bbe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6291992b103b9be22486b9f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752145,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to take a moment to congratulate my baby sister, Jasleen. She gave birth to the very handsome Sehej James Singh Arora. He was due on Valentine's Day, but he was a day late, fashionably, like his brother,\n               Jeevan. Please help me congratulate my sister and Sehej not just to the Legislature but to\n               this world. I'm super excited that we have two very rambunctious babies kicking around\n               at my sister's place now. I love being an auntie, and I am so thrilled he's here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752145","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to take a moment to congratulate my baby sister, Jasleen. She gave birth to the very handsome Sehej James Singh Arora. He was due on Valentine's Day, but he was a day late, fashionably, like his brother,\n               Jeevan. Please help me congratulate my sister and Sehej not just to the Legislature but to\n               this world. I'm super excited that we have two very rambunctiou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d0aca1f76d079e834f2f1ab3ceb926c42b3a7ce74ce7a40cbc53b1e18bf65db0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25aba553b526c34058f70031c56c537e42885d7bc8ef15b53f628b05ca435115"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75d9183de1a3bd562614dbfe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752146,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to take a moment to shout out my two CAs that are joining me here today,\n               Jessica Wei and Dhalianna Kafunda. I would not be able to do what I do without them. Would the House please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752146","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to take a moment to shout out my two CAs that are joining me here today,\n               Jessica Wei and Dhalianna Kafunda. I would not be able to do what I do without them. Would the House please join me in making them feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["586aa4c8ff9a3dc7194dd46f74203bf5c91f99ee74bc3bf3c5c3a2b5235596bd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0a963ce7fbe8ef0fa907aef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752147,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completeness of the Estimates\n               of the Ministry of Labour and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752147","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completeness of the Estimates\n               of the Ministry of Labour and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80f070d6600f329c4a9cae73f9d33f4c022a84bca64100125b793a270750ca88"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0902718e7b3f26122fed5ff2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752148,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning we met with the Canadian Men's Mental Health Foundation Will the House give them a warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752148","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This morning we met with the Canadian Men's Mental Health Foundation Will the House give them a warm welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b342f6a0da7c94a9255c80e5cd20ff1b43c680e594e03cc2f53eccfc65bf454"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79e5199dc75d52ccc2defb95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752149,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have to join my colleagues in recognizing my dear friend Jane Shin. She was the\n               former MLA for my riding, which used to be called Burnaby-Lougheed. Much has been\n               said about Jane, what she does for work currently, her beautiful son that's in the\n               House and the impact that she's had on many of us. But the main thing I would like to lift up is that because of Jane Shin, it's like\n               watching a pathway carved into seeing yourself in a space like this. For racialized\n               young women all across this province and this country, I thank Jane Shin for carving\n               that pathway. Without you, sister, we wouldn't be here. Much love. Without you, sister, we wouldn't be here. Much love.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752149","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have to join my colleagues in recognizing my dear friend Jane Shin. She was the\n               former MLA for my riding, which used to be called Burnaby-Lougheed. Much has been\n               said about Jane, what she does for work currently, her beautiful son that's in the\n               House and the impact that she's had on many of us. But the main thing I would like to lift up is that becaus","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037057","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sculpture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037057","label":"Sculpture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","label":"Ethnic minorities","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c8b9ec5118da828f4eae44de027f5a5891571694b2e7bc5b4a2d28fda1c3aeca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88aa76ff9555eaa25e6267c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036374,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour today to recognize an extraordinary young British Columbian whose story\n               reflects perseverance, determination, talent and the incredible value of skilled trades\n               in Canada. I first learned about Badanbir Singh through skilled trades instructor James Smith,\n               who reached out to me after hearing my debate in the House speaking up for workers.\n               James wanted to share the story of a remarkable student and apprentice whose journey\n               represents exactly why we must continue championing skilled trades and supporting\n               the next generation of workers in our community. Badanbir Singh came to Canada in 2016 as an international student at Camosun College.\n               Like so many newcomers to Canada, he arrived with ambition, determination and a willingness\n               to work hard to build a better future. During his studies, he worked as a manager at Husky while building a life here in\n               Canada. His path later took him to P.E.I. and into long-haul trucking, but along the\n               way, Badanbir realized he wanted something more hands-on, a career where he could\n               build, solve problems and make a difference in people's lives every single day. After receiving permanent residency, he decided to pursue plumbing, a trade he had\n               always felt drawn toward. That decision has already led to remarkable success. In\n               2024, Badanbir was awarded the plumbing and pipe trades foundation award, recognizing\n               both his talent and dedication. More recently, he represented British Columbia at the provincial skills competition\n               in Abbotsford, where he won gold in plumbing, an incredible accomplishment that reflects\n               countless hours of preparation, discipline and hard work. And if this isn't an immigrant\n               success story, I don't know what is. Now Badanbir Singh is preparing to travel to Toronto to compete in the Skills Canada\n               National Competition, 2026, where he will proudly represent British Columbia on the\n               national stage. What an honour that is. He is not only representing himself but his\n               family, his instructors, his fellow apprentices and our entire province. I can only\n               imagine how proud his family is, his friends, and they must be incredibly proud watching\n               him I can only imagine how proud his family and his friends are, and they must be incredibly\n               proud watching his journey unfold, from arriving in Canada as an international student\n               to now standing among the very best young plumbing competitors in the entire country.\n               His story also reminds us of how important skilled trades are to the future of British\n               Columbia and Canada. Tradespeople build our homes, maintain our infrastructure and\n               keep our communities functioning every single day. His story is exactly why I am incredibly proud of our government for investing $241\n               million in skilled-trades training, creating opportunities for the next generation\n               of tradespeople right here at home. It means attracting talented instructors whose\n               passion inspires apprentices like Parambir Singh and preparing our province with the\n               knowledge and passion to build B.C. Behind many successful apprentices stands a passionate mentor. In Parambir's case,\n               that mentor is James Smith, an instructor and trades advocate who cares deeply about\n               supporting the next generation. Whether preparing students for their Red Seal or for\n               provincial and national competitions, introducing young Indigenous workers in remote\n               communities to the pipe trades or mentoring newcomers to Canada through hands-on workshops,\n               James exemplifies the leadership and dedication that this province needs. Because of instructors like James Smith, talented individuals like Parambir Singh\n               are given the opportunity to pursue excellence and realize their full potential. Who\n               knows? Perhaps we are watching the future greatest plumber this country has ever known. To Parambir Singh, congratulations on your incredible accomplishments. British Columbia\n               is proud of you; Canada is proud of you. Bring home gold, Parambir Singh. We believe\n               in you. Good luck at the Skills Canada National Competition 2026. We will all be cheering\n               you on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036374","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's an honour today to recognize an extraordinary young British Columbian whose story\n               reflects perseverance, determination, talent and the incredible value of skilled trades\n               in Canada. I first learned about Badanbir Singh through skilled trades instructor James Smith,\n               who reached out to me after hearing my debate in the House speaking up for workers.\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0ddaa67a8bd061caca0121f9626655b0b57343ae6da1bafc05948ba5b518cf9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f49b1c4d928fb855bc7b2a151d39afa3b6cb8b59400dc498b9e4fa1272c9a86a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7edcbcc6b2602f2c8b103e4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036375,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"There has been a growing discussion about AI data centres being developed here in\n               British Columbia, including projects connected through the federal government partnerships\n               with private companies as part of building Canada's sovereign AI infrastructure. The\n               federal government is positioning this as an important economic opportunity for the\n               future. There is no question that AI and digital infrastructure will be part of Canada's\n               long-term competitiveness, but we also need to be clear about what that means for\n               British Columbians. These facilities require significant electricity, major infrastructure investment\n               and substantial water and land use. That raises real questions about energy capacity,\n               affordability, environmental impact and the pressures placed on local communities\n               here in B.C. There is also an important national interest at stake. Building sovereign AI capacity\n               here in Canada helps ensure that Canadian data research and critical digital infrastructure\n               are not left vulnerable to the laws or political decisions of foreign governments,\n               including countries like France. We've seen them move aggressively to protect their\n               own digital sovereignty, and Canada should be thinking carefully about this as well.\n               That's why the federal government has a responsibility to ensure that these projects\n               deliver real benefits back to the communities that host them. If we are going to build and host this level of industrial-scale digital infrastructure\n               in B.C., then a portion of the value created should be reinvested locally. That could\n               mean supporting renewable energy expansion here in B.C., investing in infrastructure\n               that growing communities depend on and advancing Indigenous rights and reconciliation\n               through meaningful partnerships, economic participation and long-term community benefits. We can stay open for business and continue attracting investment into Canada's digital\n               future, but we cannot do it at the expense of working people, Indigenous communities\n               or the environment. The federal government has a chance to lead in a way that is responsible,\n               balanced and fair, and British Columbians will expect nothing less.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036375","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There has been a growing discussion about AI data centres being developed here in\n               British Columbia, including projects connected through the federal government partnerships\n               with private companies as part of building Canada's sovereign AI infrastructure. The\n               federal government is positioning this as an important economic opportunity for the\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["937fec387110a76e6d0dc1673b835116815693831400887a7393f508c5dd4e2e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e54112abdcb12560438abcca148a721d9ccc318b39b0d8a60ea086ce06b0095e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c84c77ab94db6a2b6b50363a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036376,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to take a moment to shout out to my CA Anika Dhaliwal, who I have been\n               working with for quite a while, almost two years now. She's a third-year political\n               science student, and today she helped me out by bringing out the Burnaby East Youth\n               Council. I'd like to have the House welcome our chair, Jas Kaur; our comms coordinator, Gurjot Bhatti; and events coordinator, Cairen Velasquez. They have been supporting me in Burnaby East. The office is getting a wonderful mural that has been painted and drawn by an elementary\n               school, and there is a professor The office is getting a wonderful mural that's been painted and drawn by an elementary\n               school, and there is a professor that's actually writing a paper on it to talk about\n               how we can engage youth in civic education from a young age. We're super excited, and I'm so thankful to this team for coming out today to watch\n               QP, but for all the work you do in community. These are the next leaders in our province.\n               They'll likely be sitting down here one day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036376","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to take a moment to shout out to my CA Anika Dhaliwal, who I have been\n               working with for quite a while, almost two years now. She's a third-year political\n               science student, and today she helped me out by bringing out the Burnaby East Youth\n               Council. I'd like to have the House welcome our chair, Jas Kaur; our comms coordinator, Gurjot Bhatti; an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9340de7c15e5b05c937f4e8ffc50004e19c46c99aa75512d9da99688b3077187"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fca45ad1dd2f400822a8d95421dc4ff5b97801e66ad51a00be7afff19ab47e21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c46f7c507d418a410b069b6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036377,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rohini Arora","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to take a moment to shout out all of the EAs and legislative assistants\n               that support us, Dakota, Sushant, Sage, Brian, HK. We could not do what we do over\n               in the east annex without their continued support with every single detail. I just\n               want to give them a major shout-out. Would the House please join me in welcoming and supporting them as they continue to\n               do the work in the next session.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036377","member_id":"bc-mla-360","member_name":"Rohini Arora","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to take a moment to shout out all of the EAs and legislative assistants\n               that support us, Dakota, Sushant, Sage, Brian, HK. We could not do what we do over\n               in the east annex without their continued support with every single detail. I just\n               want to give them a major shout-out. Would the House please join me in welcoming and supporting them as t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15cfad5b055f9e0e341d1a79e379995009df706497ecdd094f2ac0d51f79ffb4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64eed3cfea87f838255993c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316819,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to first acknowledge that I'm speaking on the territories of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking\n               People, the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. I would also like to take this opportunity to stand in this House for the first time\n               this session and extend my deepest condolences to the people of Tumbler Ridge, who\n               have faced unimaginable tragedies. My heart goes out to everyone, and my heart breaks\n               for those families who have lost a loved one, those who have lost friends, who lost\n               neighbours. I want to thank the dedicated officers of the RCMP and many others who are on the\n               ground and respond immediately, without hesitation, to save lives. It is bravery in\n               the purest sense of the word. My thoughts are with Tumbler Ridge. We are with you, and we will continue to support\n               you. I am pleased to speak today in support of Budget 2026. This is not a budget written\n               in calm waters. It is a budget written in a world of instability, tariffs, global\n               uncertainty, high costs and economic pressures that are not unique to B.C. This is not a budget written in calm waters. It is a budget written in a world of\n               instability, tariffs, global uncertainty, high costs and economic pressures that are\n               not unique to B.C. This is a budget about securing B.C.'s future. This is a budget\n               that protects the services that British Columbians rely on while setting out a responsible\n               path to declining the deficit. As Chair of the Finance and Government Services Committee, I can say that this budget\n               was not one of easy decisions. Our government is making careful choices to safeguard\n               the things that matter most to British Columbians like health care and education.\n               But global uncertainty has introduced challenges here in B.C. and across Canada. This\n               instability and the tariffs imposed by the American administration has put pressure\n               on public finances. The seriousness of this global situation demands a serious provincial\n               budget that will deliver stability to British Columbians. This is what this budget\n               represents. Before I was elected, I served as a law enforcement officer. When police respond to\n               a crisis scene, we don't panic. We assess, we prioritize, and we protect lives first.\n               This too is a budget that takes a deliberate, carefully considered approach. We hear\n               time and time again how much the British Columbians value and defend and depend on\n               public services. That's why we are protecting these services. As Chair of the Finance and Government Services Committee, I have had the privilege\n               of hearing directly from British Columbians and communities across this beautiful\n               province. Small business owners, seniors worried about long-term care, families concerned\n               about child care costs, construction workers asking what their next project will be.\n               What they told us was clear and simple. Protect health care, protect education, protect\n               affordability, use public funds responsibly. This budget reflects that. Budget 2026 is a budget based in the difficult reality that B.C. is facing. We are\n               forecasting declining deficits over the fiscal plan so that we can protect these services\n               for the next generation. This will be achieved through targeted reductions in spending\n               as well as strategic re-pacing of capital projects. This is what fiscal discipline\n               looks like. Every dollar is scrutinized. In addition to protecting our valued public services, we're keeping taxes low for\n               working families. B.C. remains one of the provinces with the lowest tax for those\n               working and middle income families. With increases to the B.C. tax reduction credit,\n               more than 40 percent of the taxpayers will be paying lower taxes this year. We are making further investments in core services. Budget 2026 is investing an additional\n               $2.8 billion in health care over three years, including $2.3 billion to increase capacity\n               to our health care services and systems, $131 million to support mental health and\n               addiction treatment, and $185 million to strengthen seniors care. In our education system, we are investing $634 million in K-12 over three years, including\n               $167 million for the classroom enhancement fund to put more teachers, special education\n               teachers and counselors in B.C. classrooms. And we are absolutely committed to making our neighbourhoods and communities safer.\n               That's why we're investing $139 million over three years in public safety measures,\n               and this includes $42 million towards initiatives to target repeat violent offenders\n               and the new chronic property offenders initiatives. We are investing $73 million in our courts to support timely access to justice, recruit\n               and retain sheriffs, and move cases through the justice system faster. These critical investments across health care, education, public safety and more will\n               make a real difference in my riding in Burnaby South–Metrotown and across B.C. These are investments that will help hire more doctors, nurses and\n               health professionals in our hospitals and long-term-care homes. Investments that will\n               put more teachers in our schools and help deliver a quality education to our kids.\n               Investments that will double the amount of skilled trades training in this province\n               to provide new opportunities and good-paying jobs for young people. Investments that\n               will help increase the sense of safety in our neighbourhoods so that B.C. residents\n               and businesses have confidence and peace of mind. Not only are we investing in public services, but we are investing in the projects\n               that will continue to deliver results for British Columbians and the people of Burnaby.\n               Across the province, we are building what communities need to grow, hospitals, schools,\n               transit, roads and bridges. The capital plan invests $37.7 billion In Burnaby, one of B.C.'s most diverse and dynamic cities, we are investing $68 million\n               for a new expanded Cameron Elementary to create 770 new student spaces and over $40\n               million for a brand new francophone elementary school. We are making schools seismically\n               safer and adding capacities at Brentwood Park, Stride Avenue and Kitchener Elementary.\n               And we are incredibly proud of the seismically safer $101 million Burnaby North Secondary\n               replacement school that recently opened to 1,800 students. Burnaby is a hub for the talent that drives B.C.'s economy. At BCIT, we're investing\n               over $150 million in the new trades and technology complex, adding 1,200 student seats\n               and generating over 1,100 construction jobs. We also recently completed BCIT's $144\n               million Tall Timber student housing project. Over at SFU, we're delivering phase 3 of the student housing, a $197 million mass\n               timber building providing 445 beds and 160 child care spaces. This builds on the beautiful\n               First Peoples gathering house, and these projects take pressure off of Burnaby's private\n               rental market, helping everyone find an affordable place to live. Finally, I want to highlight the monumental transformation of health care in our city.\n               The Burnaby Hospital redevelopment and the new B.C. care centre represent a multi-billion\n               dollar commitment. With two new patient care towers, a modernized emergency department,\n               399 beds and a state-of-the-art cancer treatment centre, people in Burnaby will get\n               the care closer to home. This massive project is expected to create over 17,000 direct\n               jobs and 8,500 indirect jobs. These are meaningful investments that British Columbians\n               have been asking for, that British Columbians expect, and we are delivering. As Parliamentary Secretary for Trade, I have spent many of the past months engaging\n               with B.C.'s businesses, big and small, to hear from them directly about what they\n               need. This work is practical and focused on key terms and goals: enhancing B.C.'s\n               trade diversification strategy and our Look West goals to exports around the world,\n               engaging industry about real world opportunities and deepening ties with key partners\n               across the Indo-Pacific and supporting the people-to-people connections that make\n               trade work. Trade is one of B.C.'s great strengths, but we also know the risk of overreliance\n               on a single market. In 2023, about 54 percent of B.C.'s goods exports went to the\n               U.S. Tariffs and tariff threats on aluminum, steel, softwood lumber, autos and other\n               goods have created unacceptable uncertainty for B.C.'s employers and workers. Our\n               response is targeted and long term. We need to diversify markets, reduce barriers\n               at home, move faster on major projects and back small and medium-sized exporters with\n               hands-on support. We are working every day to help B.C. businesses export their goods and services around\n               the globe. B.C. has an abundance of what the world needs, from critical minerals,\n               clean energy and sustainable forestry to world-class tech talents and innovations\n               that can solve global challenges. We have a global network of more than 50 trade and investment representatives in 14\n               key markets, including new representation in Mexico, Taiwan and Vietnam. These teams\n               connect B.C. companies to buyers and investors every day. We also have opened Forestry Innovation Investment offices in Vietnam and England\n               to grow B.C.'s market share beyond traditional destinations. We have renewed and signed\n               cooperation agreements that position B.C. in strategic sectors with Gyeonggi province\n               in South Korea, with KOMIR on critical minerals, with Japanese partners in clean transportation\n               and a letter of intent with Karnataka, India, on life sciences and tech. Interest in B.C.'s advantage continues to rise, and trade missions are essential to\n               capitalizing on this. These missions are absolutely crucial. They are sales calls\n               for Team B.C. Over the past two years, our delegations have showcased clean energy\n               tech in Germany and Norway, focused on food security and critical minerals Over the past two years, our delegations have showcased clean energy tech in Germany\n               and Norway, focused on food security and critical minerals in Japan, Malaysia and\n               South Korea, put B.C.'s tech on major stages in Europe, promoted life sciences in\n               Boston, and positioned B.C. for investment at Climate Week in New York City. In January\n               2026, we laid a mission to India to strengthen ties in responsible mining, forestry\n               and tech. The benefits of these relationships are practical. As part of our Look West goals to double exports to non-US markets over the next ten years, companies get\n               B2B meetings they cannot get on their own, and they build long-term relationships\n               that turn into procurement and inward investments. In Mexico, we are building relationships with aerospace, ICT and clean tech. In Taiwan,\n               we are positioning B.C. as a low-carbon supplier. In Vietnam, our presence is opening\n               doors for B.C. wood products and agrifood. These are new customers for B.C. exporters\n               and new jobs right here at home. Trade is not an abstract. It is about supporting businesses to reach new customers.\n               This is why programs like export navigator matter, providing free one-on-one advisory\n               support. In 2022, we added a technical specialist pilot so businesses can access the\n               logistical and cross-border legal expertise that makes a first export deal possible.\n               We're also expanding proven partners like trade accelerator program. The goal is simple:\n               more B.C. firms exporting to more markets faster. As B.C.'s representative at Pacific NorthWest Economic Region, I spent time speaking\n               with American legislators and business leaders. Let's be very clear. Tariffs are not\n               theoretical. They are not a threat. They are real. I have sat across from state elected\n               officials who agree that these tariffs benefit nobody. They harm working people and\n               businesses on both sides of the border. But while diplomacy continues, our responsibility is here, right here at home. That's\n               why this budget invests $283 million in new funding to support our new Look West strategy for jobs and prosperity, doubles funding for Skilled TradesBC and establishes a $400 million B.C. strategic investment fund. This is not reactive\n               budgeting. This is strategic positioning. We are diversifying markets and identifying\n               new opportunities, and we are reducing our dependency on an unstable trading partner. We are strengthening internal trade and breaking down interprovincial barriers. At\n               PNWER, I have heard the same thing many times. Canada must knock down its internal trade\n               barriers. Economic analysis suggests mutual recognition, where we agree to allow the\n               sale of goods that are permitted to be sold in other provinces and territories, could\n               increase Canada's GDP by up to 7.9 percent. This is transformational. B.C. continues to be at the forefront of that work. We led the establishment of the\n               Canadian mutual recognition agreement, and we continue to push for further reduction\n               in trade barriers. We are advancing direct-to-consumer alcohol sales. Since the new\n               B.C.-Alberta program launched in 2025, nearly 100 B.C. wineries have joined, and interprovincial\n               wine shipments have grown sharply, proof that cutting internal barriers helps businesses\n               grow. Budget 2026 does three things: it protects core services, it keeps taxes among the\n               lowest Canada-wide for working and middle income families, and it sets B.C. on a disciplined\n               path towards deficit reduction. It invests in skills, infrastructure, major projects,\n               trade diversification, health care, seniors, children, and working families, and it\n               acknowledges uncertainty but does not surrender to it. As Parliamentary Secretary for Trade, I will continue working to open new markets\n               and create new opportunities for B.C. businesses. As B.C.'s rep for PNWER, I will\n               continue to strengthen people-to-people relationships across our shared borders. As\n               Chair of the Finance Committee, I will continue to pursue fiscal discipline. As MLA\n               for Burnaby South–Metrotown, I will continue advocating for families who expect serious leadership in serious\n               times. Budget 2026 is responsible, it is disciplined, and it is forward-looking. And Budget\n               2026 is securing B.C.'s future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316819","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I would like to first acknowledge that I'm speaking on the territories of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking\n               People, the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. I would also like to take this opportunity to stand in this House for the first time\n               this session and extend my deepest condolences to the people of Tumbler Ridge, who\n               have faced unimaginable tragedies. My heart go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fe6bc17914d6a87b064e4524c69c1bf1c41e4207fabfcc9f354bb1b3643a0548"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ef60e81c2f388c3f9004a45de325cfc8b81e3c6581bfbe66a3df986fe2aea23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5967ba17205bce84e086d3f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316820,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Japan's National Foundation Day observed annually on February 11. Known in Japan as [a language other than English was spoken], this day reflects on the founding of the Japanese nation and the enduring continuity\n               of its culture, tradition and institutions. It is a moment to celebrate national identity,\n               resilience and unity. As we reflect on National Foundation Day, we also note that His Majesty Emperor Noru Hito's birthday was on February 23, a significant national occasion in Japan that symbolizes\n               continuity and constitutional democracy. Here in B.C., and especially in my riding of Burnaby South–Metrotown, we are proud of the vibrant Japanese-Canadian community that has shaped our province's history for generations. I would like to especially acknowledge the incredible work of the Nikkei National Museum and Cultural Centre. The Nikkei Centre is more than a cultural institution,\n               it is a living testament to heritage, perseverance and reconciliation. It preserves\n               the history of Japanese Canadians, including the painful chapters of internment during\n               the Second World War, while celebrating the contributions of Japanese Canadians to\n               our society today. I also want to invite members of this House and our community to join us on March\n               7 for an enchanting evening of the Nikkei Place Foundation Sakura Gala celebrating\n               25 years of Nikkei Place, a community built through the vision and dedication of Japanese\n               Canadians, or nikkei, to preserve history, culture, and to provide compassionate care This milestone is a powerful example of community leadership and intergenerational\n               responsibility in action. Japan remains one of B.C.'s most important economic and\n               strategic partners. In my role as Parliamentary Secretary for Trade, I've seen firsthand\n               the strength of the B.C.–Japan relationship, from forestry to natural resources to\n               technology, clean energy and cultural exchange. May we continue to deepen these ties and celebrate the shared value of democracy,\n               peace and mutual respect. Arigato gozaimasu. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316820","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Japan's National Foundation Day observed annually on February 11. Known in Japan as [a language other than English was spoken], this day reflects on the founding of the Japanese nation and the enduring continuity\n               of its culture, tradition and institutions. It is a moment to celebrate national identity,\n               resilience and unity. As we reflect on N","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","label":"National heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","label":"National heritage","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdf3c11fcb9ff2d72f85384c4946daf71547ef978fc2ea2fd518f4aa0c031b3e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75b316536b6cc20c64eb4cab201522b959be3f84de7094417cffebd6f97b74bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae59f80bd398bffe2aad29bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316821,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to speak today in support of the Trade Recognition Act. Bill 5 will replace\n               part 1 of the Economic Stabilization Act with a permanent framework to reduce interprovincial\n               trade barriers in B.C. As Parliamentary Secretary for Trade, I understand the critical need for Canada to\n               take significant steps towards breaking down its interprovincial trade barriers. Now\n               each province and territory has a part to play in this mission, and B.C. is at the\n               forefront of the push to make domestic trade simpler. Now, when I meet with local businesses and partners, one of the top concerns are interprovincial\n               trade barriers. When I meet with business leaders around the world, they express uncertainty\n               and sometimes confusion as to why there are barriers to trade within Canada. Well, it's a tough question to answer, but what it means is that the Canadian economy\n               is not as integrated as it should be. It means that we are not only dealing with uncertainty\n               because of our disabled trading partners to the south but also that Canada that has\n               historically been limited in its ability In this time of great uncertainty, we need to move with great urgency. This is why\n               our government has introduced Bill 5. This bill will enable B.C. to align with the\n               national effort, which B.C. is leading, to allow freer movement of goods across provincial\n               barriers. I want to take a moment to explore the impact that the interprovincial trade barriers\n               have had in B.C.'s businesses, big and small. The OECD reports that most Canadian\n               businesses, especially small businesses, don't engage in interprovincial trade. More\n               than half of businesses that do trade interprovincially reported some kind of obstacle.\n               It's clear that interprovincial trade barriers are getting in the way of internal\n               trade and provide this incentive for businesses to look for domestic opportunities. This has a wide range of effects in every community. A business in Burnaby or Merritt\n               or Terrace wants to send their products to Alberta, Manitoba or New Brunswick or any\n               other province. Right now, they often need to spend time and money combing through\n               the thousands of legislation each jurisdiction maintains just to understand what is\n               and isn't allowed. That's thousands of regulations each across 14 different jurisdictions. This is the definition of burden. I think it goes without saying that businesses in\n               B.C. should not need to hire a trade lawyer to send their products over the Rockies.\n               It should not be easier to trade north to south than it is east to west. At a time\n               when others may be turning inward, our approach should be to expand opportunity, remove\n               these unnecessary barriers and lead with confidence in free and fair trade. Interprovincial trade barriers mean that the movement of goods is slower than it needs\n               to be, which increases costs for exporters, truckers, railways, warehouses and consumers.\n               It means that investment potential is diminished because investors do not see the\n               stability and certainty that they need to make business-critical decisions. This is\n               a real problem for Canada's productivity, for our consumer products and for our major\n               products. The impacts of this are significant, and it's long overdue that we take\n               a unified national approach to reducing and eliminating these barriers wherever possible. As B.C.'s representative to PNWER, the Pacific North West Economic Region, I have\n               firsthand experience in conversations with political, business and community leaders\n               on both sides of our shared border. Nearly universally, these leaders are condemning\n               tariffs. They know that these old-fashioned, outdated and harmful trade measures are\n               not beneficial for businesses or workers. Tariffs are costly, and B.C. needs a deliberate,\n               targeted response. Last year, our government introduced Bill 7 to do exactly that, and we knew that we\n               needed to move quickly to provide relief and work to open new markets for B.C. businesses.\n               The threat of North American trade being so severely interrupted means that we need\n               to look closer to home. There is a plethora of untapped opportunities in Canada, and\n               one of those opportunities is interprovincial trade. That's why we made it provincial\n               law that B.C. would recognize goods and services sold in other provinces as goods\n               and services that can be sold in B.C. Our actions alone are not going to solve the Canada-wide problems of interprovincial\n               trade barriers, though. When we passed Bill 7 in B.C., we set an example for other\n               provinces to follow. We have indeed seen many provinces follow suit. For B.C.'s leadership,\n               we have been recognized by the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade, the B.C. Chamber\n               of Commerce, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business and more. As we set out to find a consensus among provinces and territories to reach an agreement\n               that will significantly reduce inter-trade barriers, in November B.C. signed the Canadian\n               Mutual Recognition Act as did the federal government and all other provinces and territories. Under the CMRA, provinces agree that we will recognize each other's approvals, testing\n               and certification when it comes to the sale of goods. This was difficult work, and\n               there is much more work to do at the table among provinces. But because of B.C.'s\n               leadership, we have broken new ground on reducing That brings us to Bill 5. When we passed Bill 7 last year, we didn't know what the\n               future held, but we knew we needed to act. But the enabling section of Bill 7 expires\n               this May, so B.C. needs a permanent legislative solution for interprovincial barriers,\n               and Bill 5 is the piece that establishes B.C.'s permanent framework for simpler and\n               affordable trade within Canada. Bill 5 will allow B.C. to continue meeting our commitment under the CMRA. In fact,\n               Bill 5 goes farther than that in the CMRA. This legislation recognizes all goods and\n               services, and we hope that all other provinces will join us in this broader recognition.\n               While this is unilateral recognition on B.C.'s part, having this legislation in place\n               permanently will help us qualify as a reciprocal jurisdiction to those provinces whose\n               legislation is more stringent. And our framework will reduce the administrative burden\n               on small businesses who are looking for new markets to export to. We know that, right now, many businesses would not only prefer to sell to other Canadians\n               but they are relying on that opportunity to keep their businesses running. This framework\n               will reduce paperwork and keep products from being held up in the warehouse until\n               duplicate certifications and approvals have been acquired. It will strengthen competitiveness\n               for B.C.'s businesses, and it will make it easier for British Columbians to buy Canadian. This is what B.C.'s leadership looks like. This government is absolutely committed\n               to doing the hard work to advance the cause of breaking down interprovincial trade\n               barriers. We will continue to lead, and we will continue to get results for British\n               Columbians. With B.C.'s leadership, we are protecting the things that are most important\n               to British Columbians. While we firmly believe in mutual recognition and the reduction of inter-trade barriers, we will also firmly defend our strong protections that keep British Columbians\n               healthy, keep workers safe and keep our environment undisturbed. Under Bill 5, we\n               retain the full authority to maintain exceptions. We will not jeopardize health and\n               safety or the environment. B.C.'s standards are the baseline, because a rising tide\n               lifts all boats. These exceptions will be clear and they will be public. In fact, B.C.'s exceptions\n               under the CMRA are already published online for anyone to access. Under Bill 5, recognition\n               does not apply to monopolies. This allows us to keep things like Liquor Distribution\n               Branch and ICBC so that we can continue to provide public car insurance with some\n               of the lowest rates in the country, and that's something to be proud of. As new products enter the market and efforts towards simpler interprovincial trade\n               unfold, we will continue to monitor the effects. Bill 5 allows to add and remove exceptions\n               quickly as necessary. As I have laid out, the Trade Recognition Act is a flexible,\n               modern piece of legislation that is the right tool to deal with our new reality. It will allow us to continually evaluate B.C.'s needs, while giving us the ability\n               to respond to the evergreen threat of American tariffs. It means that there will be\n               greater investment opportunities here in B.C., which will drive economic growth and\n               help create good jobs for folks in every sector across British Columbia. It means\n               that folks will be able to buy more Canadian goods at a time when we all want to support\n               our local businesses. It will mean more B.C. products on shelves in the rest of Canada. We are going to confront economic hardships head-on, and the Trade Recognition Act\n               is an absolutely critical tool in our toolbox. I'm very happy to support Bill 5, and\n               I hope all members will join me in doing so.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316821","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I am pleased to speak today in support of the Trade Recognition Act. Bill 5 will replace\n               part 1 of the Economic Stabilization Act with a permanent framework to reduce interprovincial\n               trade barriers in B.C. As Parliamentary Secretary for Trade, I understand the critical need for Canada to\n               take significant steps towards breaking down its interprovincial t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["31ecff659bf711e54e3ac9512cb3cd8ceec7bd7246cd69222f62fd9c6e4e57dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6c8809b98a86b2e017dadb23ad60d9ddee1f18c42bc32c53da279cd462b4943"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-272605245d71831f8d8c0c3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327935,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"A strong economy is built from the ground up. In B.C., that foundation is our small\n               businesses. Across our province, more than 98 percent of businesses are small businesses.\n               There are cafes on our main streets, the family-run stores in our neighbourhoods,\n               manufacturers creating local jobs and entrepreneurs turning ideas into opportunities. This is not just a statistic to me, it is personal. My family ran a small convenience\n               store after we immigrated to Canada. Like many small-business families, we worked\n               long hours behind the counter. We learned quickly that success depends on resilience,\n               hard work and collaboration. This is not just statistical to me; it is personal. My family ran a small convenience\n               store after we immigrated to Canada, and like many small business families, we worked\n               long hours behind the counter. We learned quickly that success depends on resilience,\n               hard work and collaboration. That experience shaped my understanding of the economy long before I studied law or\n               tax policies and long before I had the privilege of serving in this chamber. Those\n               early lessons shaped my understanding of how important small businesses are to our\n               economy and to our communities. Today, as chair of the Finance Committee and as Parliamentary Secretary for Trade,\n               I have the privilege of engaging with business leaders, entrepreneurs, industry groups\n               across B.C. And I hear a consistent message: when we work in partnership with small\n               businesses, our entire economy grows stronger. Supporting small businesses means helping them navigate new markets through our trade\n               and invest reps around the world, strengthening trade opportunities through export\n               navigator and trade accelerator programs, reducing barriers to growth through Look West strategy and ensuring our policies create the condition and innovation for job creation. Our role in this chamber is to continue championing the businesses, workers and innovators\n               who power our economy, so let's keep our communities thriving.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327935","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"A strong economy is built from the ground up. In B.C., that foundation is our small\n               businesses. Across our province, more than 98 percent of businesses are small businesses.\n               There are cafes on our main streets, the family-run stores in our neighbourhoods,\n               manufacturers creating local jobs and entrepreneurs turning ideas into opportunities. This is not j","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a20b8fb6aa7c5cc2dde78fc1b09460bda2a9eb7be540829dc2aa4b97e5906f92"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37d634ec18b8f57ccddadde80f6736c7437c30d664e76d5ae2807f71bab9d818"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc01c791367d104e6c87531d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721275,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome several guests to the House who are helping drive B.C.'s\n               success as a global centre for film and television production. Joining us are Spencer\n               Kent, VP of finance at Industrial Light and Magic, Kendrie Upton, executive director\n               of the Director's Guild of Canada, B.C.; along with Amy Belanger and Heather Hawthorn\n               Doyle, board members of the Directors Guild of Canada, B.C. District Council. We're also pleased to welcome Rylah Gutman, who is senior director of B.C. and national\n               member development with CMPA-BC. Their work supports a thriving industry that creates jobs, develops talents and brings\n               B.C.'s creative expertise to audiences around the world. So please join me warmly\n               in welcoming them to the Legislative Assembly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721275","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome several guests to the House who are helping drive B.C.'s\n               success as a global centre for film and television production. Joining us are Spencer\n               Kent, VP of finance at Industrial Light and Magic, Kendrie Upton, executive director\n               of the Director's Guild of Canada, B.C.; along with Amy Belanger and Heather Hawthorn\n               Do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8a3d05df61b9dd8ad4601b9c9bfae2f2d1fb917e3948ee1c2c1b0d278cd86b42"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a14386bdf099e68bbdfc810a5d68706a5071c01f599834c906b8c18ddc7c005"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3863d17e9d1c6182e54dda43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721277,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm very excited to welcome my friends from MOSAIC today, if I can get them to stand\n               up for me. MOSAIC is actually celebrating its 50th anniversary. It's exactly today,\n               50 years ago, when MOSAIC started. So I'm really honoured to have them here today\n               in the chamber. We have Olga Stachova, who is MOSAIC's CEO. We have Susan Trevor, who's director of\n               finance and administration; David Lee, director of employment, language, and social\n               enterprise; Caitlin Johnston, director of MOSAIC community clinic; Payvand Gonzalez,\n               director of people, culture and inclusion; and Vanya Ganacheva, manager of executive\n               office. We know that MOSAIC is doing fabulous work to support our community and help newcomers\n               to our lovely British Columbia settle in and get integrated. Please, if I can get all the members of the House to make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721277","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm very excited to welcome my friends from MOSAIC today, if I can get them to stand\n               up for me. MOSAIC is actually celebrating its 50th anniversary. It's exactly today,\n               50 years ago, when MOSAIC started. So I'm really honoured to have them here today\n               in the chamber. We have Olga Stachova, who is MOSAIC's CEO. We have Susan Trevor, who's director of\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","label":"Language education","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1cdc54649b60fae16a9721566a1a8b205f2be5cc413935a137f2df1b070c9d84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5426297e403bf1f1cb5eaf5969937896597f5d3eca4edf81a97bc81ccdb371b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d12892f093bdcd5402a7fee3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728889,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"My colleague already briefly mentioned them, but I think they just walked in, so I\n               also want to mention how excited I am to have students from SFU master's in legal\n               studies program here, led by Professor Margaret Hall. Megan Cawthorne, Amy Middle,\n               Mackenzie Anderson, Sarah Miller, Sam Schwab, Ashley Chung and Jody Lamb. They're our future legal professionals who are here to learn about how law gets made\n               in B.C. They had the privilege of meeting the Attorney General briefly as well. If I could ask the House to please make them feel very welcome here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728889","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My colleague already briefly mentioned them, but I think they just walked in, so I\n               also want to mention how excited I am to have students from SFU master's in legal\n               studies program here, led by Professor Margaret Hall. Megan Cawthorne, Amy Middle,\n               Mackenzie Anderson, Sarah Miller, Sam Schwab, Ashley Chung and Jody Lamb. They're our future legal professi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea0126ead758cb707d9b73a1f88b4d77c939eb0c4ae0dff023227ed83c3294e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce56414d2e9c7f28beacb66e9b8b9f4569307b43b97617fffd74abdb07b042ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-554b10041cd3ba079be7689c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728892,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize and congratulate an outstanding group of students from Burnaby\n               South Secondary School in my riding, Burnaby South–Metrotown. Burnaby South Secondary has been selected as a finalist in Samsung Canada's 2026\n               Solve for Tomorrow competition, a national STEM competition that invites students\n               from grades 6 to 12 to develop innovative solutions to real-world problems. This is a tremendous achievement. Through this competition, students are not simply\n               learning science, technology, engineering and math in the classroom. They're reapplying\n               and learning through the challenges they see around them. They're being asked to think\n               critically, work collaboratively and imagine practical ways to improve their community\n               and their future. This is exactly the kind of learning we need to encourage. STEM education is not only about technology; it's about curiosity; it's about problem-solving.\n               It's about giving young people the confidence to ask, \"How can we make things better?\"\n               and then giving them the tools to act on that question. I want to recognize the students for their creativity and dedication and perseverance.\n               Reaching the national final is something that they should be very proud of. And I\n               also want to thank the teachers, staff and families who supported them along the way. Today, right now as we speak, these students will have the opportunity to present\n               their ideas at Samsung Canada's headquarters alongside other national finalists. Regardless\n               of the final results, they have already represented Burnaby and British Columbia with\n               excellence. To the Burnaby South Secondary STEM team, congratulations. Your work shows the power\n               of youth innovation, and you are helping to inspire the next generation of leaders,\n               problem-solvers, and change-makers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728892","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize and congratulate an outstanding group of students from Burnaby\n               South Secondary School in my riding, Burnaby South–Metrotown. Burnaby South Secondary has been selected as a finalist in Samsung Canada's 2026\n               Solve for Tomorrow competition, a national STEM competition that invites students\n               from grades 6 to 12 to develop innovative","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c73cc994045e80d8a8e7b1763d898825e8c28f5fda7bddec3614ddeb3b68578"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1fae67fa515772e712ff72c7c2a479fa4bfecdb3ef2b725fee545e9d9d0cf19"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33eae8302efd901acf0b2c79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752191,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to rise today in support of the original motion and oppose the amendment\n               for the simple reason that the original motion is doing exactly what we were talking\n               about to bring fairness and equitable to the liquor in theatres, because already large\n               theatres and multi-complexes have ability to serve liquor. I want to thank the member for bringing the original motion forward. This is one of\n               the motions that may sound small at first, but it speaks to something much bigger.\n               It is about how we support local businesses, arts and culture and community spaces\n               that people genuinely value. Now, independent theatres are special places. They are not just buildings with screens\n               and seats. They're places where families gather on the weekend, where students discover\n               film and films that you may not see on streaming platforms. From someone who enjoys\n               that as well, sometimes being able to see something that is different and unique,\n               especially when it's local film, is something that we should ensure that we support\n               and encourage. It's where community groups come together as well. In many communities, especially\n               smaller towns, the local theatre is one of the few remaining cultural gathering places.\n               It is part of the identity and character of the community. I want to thank all of us in this House who understand how hard it is to become a\n               small business and survive these days. As a former small business owner myself, I\n               know that small businesses do not operate in unlimited margins. You worry about rent,\n               utilities, staffing, insurance, maintenance and whether enough people can come through\n               the door. For independent theatres, these pressures are even greater now. They face rising costs,\n               changing consumer habits and competition from streaming services. A theatre cannot\n               simply move online and offer the same experience. The whole point is that people come\n               together in person, in the community. So when we talk about allowing small, independent\n               theatres to have an additional revenue option, we're not talking about something extravagant.\n               We're talking about giving them one more tool to keep their doors open. This original motion is about fairness, as I said. And right now, as we talked about,\n               we already allow liquor services in many mixed-age settings. People can attend concerts,\n               sports events, art events, festivals and community events where adults may purchase\n               liquor while families and young people are also present. We trust those venues to follow the rules. We trust them to check ID, train their\n               staff, follow Serving It Right requirements and serve responsibly. Why should small\n               independent movie theatres be treated differently? That is the reasonable question\n               that we ask here. The original motion does not say every theatre must serve alcohol. It does not say\n               every screen must have liquor. It does not remove public safety rules. It does not\n               change the obligation to ensure minors are not served. This simply says that small\n               independent theatres should have the option to make it fair if they choose to apply\n               for the opportunity and operate within the rules. Now, this matters because every community is different and every theatre is different.\n               Some may want this option, some may not, but giving them the choice is a practical\n               and respectable approach. It can also help cultural spaces come alive. It also matters for local economic development.\n               When people go to local theatres, they often do more than just buy a movie ticket.\n               They may go out for dinner, they may stop at a cafe and they may support other businesses\n               in the area. This kind of local activity matters. Cultural venues bring foot traffic,\n               energy and life into our neighbourhoods and town centres. If we want vibrant communities, if we want to support the actual places where arts\n               and culture happen, independent theatres are where it brings people together. They\n               support local filmmakers, Canadian films, documentaries, international If we want vibrant communities, if we want to support the actual places where arts\n               and culture happen, independent theatres are where it brings people together. They\n               support local filmmakers, Canadian films, documentaries, international films and community\n               programming where that may not be available in larger community venues. And they give\n               people a reason to leave their house, meet their neighbours and share an experience.\n               That is worth protecting. That is why I oppose the amendment but support the original motion, because it is\n               practical, it is modest, it's targeted, and it's respectful to both public safety\n               and small business realities. For this reason, I'm pleased to support the original motion but oppose the amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752191","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am pleased to rise today in support of the original motion and oppose the amendment\n               for the simple reason that the original motion is doing exactly what we were talking\n               about to bring fairness and equitable to the liquor in theatres, because already large\n               theatres and multi-complexes have ability to serve liquor. I want to thank the member for bringin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d58056bd863e166428a61c7c6bd341d9a0ecf37884d7267362bb1029fd5d511"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bcc147cfc2264e758170da0ac1c4addc71b8940f03638ea7a6af2ca49d73b56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db129e02eae43163e42debf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752192,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak about the important work of the Pacific NorthWest Economic Region\n               known as PNWER and the role it plays in strengthening our region. Now, PNWER brings together provinces, territories, states, legislators, governments,\n               Indigenous leaders, businesses and community partners across the Pacific Northwest.\n               Its work is practical, regional, and focused on solving common challenges together. Now this year, that work is essentially important because it marks a 35-year anniversary\n               being established by statute. Also, I want to take this opportunity to welcome and\n               congratulate Brandon Hardenbrook as the new executive director. As Canada, the United States and Mexico prepare for FIFA this year, but also for review Also, I want to take this opportunity to welcome and congratulate Brandon Hardenbrook\n               as the new executive director. Now, as Canada and United States and Mexico prepare for FIFA this year, but also for\n               review of CUSMA, we know how important stable trade relationships are for the people\n               in B.C. Cross-border trade is more than about policy. It affects workers, small businesses,\n               farmers, manufacturers, forest communities, ports, supply chains and families across\n               our province. Through PNWER, regional leaders are working to support trade predictability,\n               supply chain resilience, infrastructure, energy security, innovation, agriculture\n               tourism and economic competitiveness. These are issues that cannot be solved with one jurisdiction alone. They require relationships,\n               trust and ongoing dialogue. As B.C.'s lead delegate to PNWER, I have been proud to\n               support this work and to ensure that B.C.'s voice is part of these important regional\n               conversations. This year PNWER's work will continue through its executive meetings, policy working\n               groups and the upcoming annual summit in Edmonton, where leaders from across Canada\n               and the U.S. will come together to discuss shared economic opportunities and challenges.\n               B.C. will continue to work with our partners through PNWER to strengthen regional\n               cooperation, support good jobs, protect prosperity for families and build a more resilient\n               Pacific Northwest.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752192","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak about the important work of the Pacific NorthWest Economic Region\n               known as PNWER and the role it plays in strengthening our region. Now, PNWER brings together provinces, territories, states, legislators, governments,\n               Indigenous leaders, businesses and community partners across the Pacific Northwest.\n               Its work is practical, regional,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e78e85de4004763247d84050b89c04436b05bcfe87c9c1972c179f72423eacb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["515b9700e28bb329dbab8bebb776ad11947f45a7f19e173f83c90d3033cae0e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55ebe160ca0444e1752154a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017196,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the incredible success and impact of Web Summit Vancouver\n               last week, which brought together innovators, entrepreneurs, investors, technology\n               leaders and policy-makers from around the world right here in B.C. This event showcased\n               not only the strength of our growing technology sector but also the talent, creativity\n               and entrepreneurial spirit that exists across our province. As example, we had 800\n               investors, 1,200 start-ups and 22,000 attendees. It was so much bigger and better\n               than last year. From AI and clean technology to digital media, life sciences, global trade, B.C. continues\n               to establish itself as a leader in innovation and economic opportunity. What stood\n               out most was the energy and optimism from businesses and young entrepreneurs who see\n               B.C. as a place where new ideas can grow and compete at the world stage. As Parliamentary Secretary for Trade, I had the opportunity to speak with companies\n               and international delegates who were excited about the opportunities in our province\n               and our strong connection to global markets across the Indo-Pacific and North America. Events like Web Summit are important because they create partnerships, attract investment,\n               support job creation and help position B.C. as a competitive destination for innovation\n               and business growth. I also want to recognize the Minister of Finance, Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth\n               and Minister of State for AI and New Technologies for their leadership and recognize\n               the many local businesses, start-ups, universities, organizers, volunteers and community\n               partners who helped make this event such a success. B.C.'s future economy will be driven by innovation, technology and global collaboration,\n               and events like Web Summit help ensure our province remains at the forefront of that\n               future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017196","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the incredible success and impact of Web Summit Vancouver\n               last week, which brought together innovators, entrepreneurs, investors, technology\n               leaders and policy-makers from around the world right here in B.C. This event showcased\n               not only the strength of our growing technology sector but also the talent, creativity\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","label":"Business start-ups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","label":"Business start-ups","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c075fa8fc4a434ecc62764a2c26991920ff2a83526110484b6d89acc0ca8cc67"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["949279d871c950495922882dce9206798c38c925d18a2ae99579cca5217b1aed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3776cdb0fe9f0eb3510242ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036426,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Paul Choi","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize one of B.C.'s true","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036426","member_id":"bc-mla-361","member_name":"Paul Choi","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize one of B.C.'s true","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43d1ec93a936b2b4c252a5fef53fd842c081d4d0036de4e554890e2326eb9d56"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-096667f414239ece84d9f431","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328004,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328004","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0f685aa6c485a46c1918e3e5a08a310c33f53033f8a57aec8c1819fc2d11a30"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ef83d1175a634d77cd09b51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360407,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"That's a tough act to follow. So speaking of children, children are society's most precious resource. Children are\n               a sacred trust, first and foremost to their mothers and fathers, siblings, grandparents,\n               extended families and to their communities. They are the legacy and lineage that remind\n               us of all who have gone before and the rich heritage from which we come. Children are a sacred trust bestowed on us here in the Legislature, as our children\n               are the future of our culture, of our society, of our country. We must do everything\n               we can to support parents and families as they love and nurture their children, giving\n               them the respect and acknowledging the responsibility that they embrace in this incredible\n               duty as parents. Children depend on their families to provide for them. But if they can't, they depend\n               on us. Children depend on their families to provide for them, but if they can't, they depend\n               on us, the lawmakers of this province, to provide the necessary support. We must do\n               everything within our power to ensure they are loved and cared for, housed, fed and\n               educated, always mindful of what is in their best interest. Someday we will be dependent on them to provide for us. We must be wise and treat\n               our precious children with the utmost care in everything we do and decide in this\n               House. I believe this is a sacred trust, and we will be held accountable for our decisions\n               and our actions one day. May God give us wisdom.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360407","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"That's a tough act to follow. So speaking of children, children are society's most precious resource. Children are\n               a sacred trust, first and foremost to their mothers and fathers, siblings, grandparents,\n               extended families and to their communities. They are the legacy and lineage that remind\n               us of all who have gone before and the rich heritage from which","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd4276934884a92994ec0de495127f851f38230a520d19b7a308f9816bb38d13"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3fe2fe76acc7fff9a5b963ebb5fd00cb7fa87120c5e689b2e866e49ff64f227"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3bc4cc5eecd79b851ee72ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415769,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let's start by talking about what Bill 13 is and what it isn't. We've seen support for this bill from organizations like CIJA. I would encourage everyone\n               here to read their press release and understand why they feel this legislation is\n               necessary. Their concerns are real. The fear and the rise in antisemitism that Jewish\n               communities are experiencing today is real, and it's serious. But as the opposition, it is our responsibility to look beyond support, beyond headlines\n               and beyond intention and ask a very simple question: does this bill actually solve\n               the problem that it claims to address? Because if it does not, then we are not doing\n               our job. In order to battle antisemitism and hostilities around other faith groups, we must\n               look to the root of the problem that Jewish people have faced for hundreds of years.\n               And that is tolerance for hatred against them. Hatred has been ignored. It has been\n               excused. At times, it has been justified. History has shown us very clearly where\n               that leads. Now, in this day and age, this is no longer something that only Jewish people are\n               facing. This is something that Christians also are now experiencing. We've seen this\n               recently with the federal Bill C-9. This newest iteration of legislation has raised\n               serious concerns because it promotes, in effect, hostility towards both Jews and Christians\n               in what we refer to as Judeo-Christian values. We know this is not speculation because\n               a federal minister explicitly named three books of the Bible that he considers to\n               be hate speech in justifying his bill. All that to say, as a Christian, I stand in solidarity with the Jewish community.\n               We have seen what persecution has done, especially during the Second World War, and\n               we cannot allow ourselves to go down that path again. Jewish people must not be persecuted\n               for who they are as a people, and they must not be persecuted for their religious\n               beliefs. Perhaps this bill is well-intentioned by the government. Perhaps they truly believe....\n               As we have heard, they do believe that this is the solution, or the beginning of the\n               solution, to the increasing number of attacks on Jewish people. If that is the case,\n               then I will say this: I applaud that effort. But effort is not the same as effectiveness,\n               because all we need to do is look at what happened with the Safe Access to Schools\n               Act. That legislation came about after a large-scale Because all we need to do is look at what happened with the Safe Access to Schools\n               Act. That legislation came about after a large-scale protest, particularly from parents\n               and citizens who disagreed with SOGI 123. And what did the government do? They decided\n               to create safe access zones around the schools, effectively limiting the ability of\n               parents and taxpayers to express their concerns. Although that bill was presented as a way to protect children, what it actually did\n               was censor people who disagreed with government policy. And in many cases, a lot of\n               those people were the parents themselves. Now we're seeing the same approach again. Bill 13 proposes to create protective zones\n               around places of worship. But we have to ask, what does that actually accomplish?\n               Does it prevent antisemitism? Does it stop violence? Does it reduce the need for synagogues\n               to spend $100,000 every month on private security due to the risk of terrorism? The\n               answer is obvious. It does not. It is quite simply paying lip service to safety. Because putting up a barrier does not stop someone who is intent on doing harm. We\n               know this. We have seen school shootings. We have seen acts of terror. We have seen\n               violence carried out in spite of every effort to create safe zones. In Canada and B.C., we have seen churches burned to the ground. The last one was in\n               Burns Lake. That was in December this past year. To suggest that drawing a boundary\n               around a place of worship will prevent arson or destruction is simply not grounded\n               in reality. So what are the actual issues that are creating the need to protect places of worship?\n               We don't have to look far. Every single Saturday, there is a pro-Palestinian protest\n               on the front lawn of this Legislature. Within those protests, we hear calls for Israel\n               to be removed from the map. That is antisemitism. At the same time, we have one of\n               our largest unions in this province, the BCTF, endorsing boycotts against Israel in\n               solidarity with that movement. So we have to ask. Isn't that hate speech? Don't we\n               already have laws against that? Because here's the point. Restricting where people can protest does not change what\n               they are saying. And it does not eliminate hatred. And it certainly does not solve\n               the problem. So what is the solution? The solution is not new legislation that limits where people\n               can stand. The solution is enforcing the laws we already have. We already have laws\n               against hate speech. We already have laws against inciting violence. We already have\n               laws against destruction of property and terrorism. Let's empower the RCMP and law enforcement to enforce those laws. We heard this morning\n               that the RCMP have not increased their numbers since 2012. That's a problem. Let's\n               support them in doing their job without infringing on the rights and freedoms that\n               are protected under the Canadian Charter. Because in reality, this bill flies in the\n               face of that Charter. One of the most troubling aspects of this bill, just like the Safe Access to Schools\n               Act and similar to the federal Bill C-9, is the expansion of police powers. This bill\n               allows for individuals to be arrested without a warrant, based on what is described\n               as \"reasonable grounds.\" That is a significant shift because now we are no longer dealing strictly with clear\n               violations of the law. We are dealing with subjective interpretation, and that should\n               terrify us. And it gets worse because the bill also allows action to be taken against\n               someone who is considered likely And it gets worse, because the bill also allows action to be taken against someone\n               who is considered likely — likely — to contravene the law. Not someone who has done\n               something wrong, but somebody who might. This introduces the concept of a potential\n               crime, and on the face of it, that should concern every single one of us because that\n               is a dangerous precedent for us to set. We are placing an enormous burden on law enforcement. Police officers are now expected\n               to act not just on evidence but on judgment, on interpretation, on what they believe\n               might happen. The officers I've spoken to want no part of that. They want clarity.\n               They want objectivity. They want to enforce the law as it exists, not to be put in\n               a position where they must interpret intent. There is also inconsistency in this bill. Unions, for example, are not affected in\n               the same way. They are allowed to picket within these zones because their activities\n               fall under what is considered prescribed. So again, we have to ask. If this is about\n               safety, why are there exceptions? Why are some groups allowed to operate within these\n               zones while others are not? As His Majesty's Loyal Opposition, it is our job to look at this bill and every other\n               bill objectively. What we are saying is this. This bill will not accomplish what the\n               title suggests. It will not achieve what organizations like CIJA are hoping it will\n               achieve. It is at best a well-intentioned attempt, but it is not the solution because\n               it does not address the root of the problem. It does not stop antisemitism, it does\n               not stop violence, it does not stop churches from being burned down, and it does not\n               remove the need for costly security measures. What it does do is create the appearance of action. It allows the government to say\n               they have done something, but in reality, it is virtue-signalling. This bill needs\n               to go deeper. It needs to address the root of the problem, and that starts with enforcing\n               the laws that already exist. Nothing is more sacred than the freedom to worship and the freedom to speak. The Canadian\n               Charter of Rights and Freedoms is very clear. Everyone has the fundamental freedom\n               of conscience and religion, thought, belief, opinion and expression, peaceful assembly\n               and association. These are not suggestions. These are rights. While this bill claims\n               to protect access to places of worship, that has never been the core issue. The core\n               issue is safety. The issue is violence. The issue is hatred. Those laws are addressed\n               not by restricting space but by enforcing the law. I will say this to government in conclusion. This is a nice try. It's a great attempt.\n               But this isn't it. We owe it to the Jewish communities. We owe it to people of faith.\n               We owe it to every Canadian to do better than this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415769","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Let's start by talking about what Bill 13 is and what it isn't. We've seen support for this bill from organizations like CIJA. I would encourage everyone\n               here to read their press release and understand why they feel this legislation is\n               necessary. Their concerns are real. The fear and the rise in antisemitism that Jewish\n               communities are experiencing toda","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89dacc553f960d660275ebc59127b74cf187daef5a3fe690273e89950afed030"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b879134d8ce6d53059e37c07d2c9493a6fa0f586ca423b73fa8867b865dc356"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-883f18e8dcf806352a13ae49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415770,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"My condolences to the Joiner family as well. On the other end of life, I would like to take this opportunity to wish my two granddaughters,\n               Marigold and Violet, a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415770","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My condolences to the Joiner family as well. On the other end of life, I would like to take this opportunity to wish my two granddaughters,\n               Marigold and Violet, a happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c2a667f9c0d480d880f27ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721531,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"Point of order, Madam Chair. This member deserves the right to do his closing statement\n               without being constantly heckled by the member across the aisle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721531","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Point of order, Madam Chair. This member deserves the right to do his closing statement\n               without being constantly heckled by the member across the aisle.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035305","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fitness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035305","label":"Fitness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","label":"Physical disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5689ff7dca0178655733156a42312648d5377fe170beafcda058cde8b0deff06"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ee22c080ecd2fb5ab63c698","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721533,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act. As is often the case with omnibus-style legislation, this bill touches on a wide variety\n               of policy areas — justice, energy, housing, municipal governance, tenancy law and\n               public safety. That breadth alone demands careful scrutiny from this House, because\n               when government packages contain so many changes in a single bill, it becomes more\n               difficult for members to give each measure the attention it deserves and to ensure\n               that British Columbians fully understand what is being done in their name. Let me say this at the outset: this is not a bill without merit. There are provisions\n               here that the opposition has long called for. There are elements that respond to real\n               pressures facing British Columbians. Where the government has taken steps in the right\n               direction, we will acknowledge that clearly and directly, but there is also a deeper\n               story here, because Bill 16 is not simply a routine statutory update; it is a quiet\n               course correction. It is a government adjusting policies that were overpromised, underplanned and disconnected\n               from the realities faced by British Columbians. Nowhere is that more evident than\n               in the changes to the Zero-Emission Vehicles Act. This bill spans multiple areas.\n               Taken individually, some of these changes may appear technical or incremental, but\n               taken together, they reveal a pattern: bold announcements followed by quiet retreats,\n               ambitious targets followed by reduced expectations, and a government increasingly\n               trying to manage the consequences of decisions that were not grounded in practical\n               reality. The provisions aimed at reducing development cost charges are a step in the right\n               direction. These costs have significantly increased the price of new housing across\n               British Columbia, making it harder for families to enter the market and driving up\n               rents for those who have no choice but to remain in it. For years, we have said that\n               government-imposed costs are a major driver of the housing crisis. Builders have said\n               it, municipalities have said it, and families trying to buy their first home have\n               certainly felt it. We welcome any move to reduce those burdens, but we must ask the obvious question:\n               why now? Why did it take a housing crisis of this magnitude for the government to\n               begin addressing cost drivers that were identified years ago? More importantly, will\n               these changes go far enough? Or will they be applied selectively, inconsistently and\n               at the discretion of cabinet, through regulation rather than through transparent legislation\n               debated in this House? British Columbians do not need partial fixes; they need meaningful, structural change\n               that addresses the root causes of unaffordability, not just the symptoms. Part 4 of the bill authorizes the use of proportionate force to ensure individuals\n               in custody receive necessary mental health treatment. This is a difficult provision, Part 4 of the bill authorizes the use of proportionate force to ensure individuals\n               in custody receive necessary mental health treatment. This is a difficult provision,\n               but it reflects a difficult reality. Our correction system is increasingly dealing\n               with individuals facing serious mental health challenges. In many cases, those individuals\n               are unable to consent to treatment that is clearly in their best interest. Without\n               appropriate tools, correctional staff are placed in an impossible position, responsible\n               for care but without the authority to ensure that that care is delivered. For that\n               reason we support this provision, provided it is implemented with clear safeguards,\n               strong oversight, and a focus on dignity and appropriate medical care. We also note the creation of an investigation and standards office to oversee these\n               complaints and ensure accountability. This is a positive step, but as always, oversight\n               must be real, not just symbolic. The effectiveness of this office will depend entirely\n               on how it is resourced and how independently it operates. Let us turn to the provisions that raise significant concern. The amendments to the\n               Judicial Review Procedure Act expand the government's ability to designate documents\n               as cabinet confidence and shield them from disclosure during judicial review. At the\n               same time, they remove protections that previously ensured judicial review could not\n               be denied solely due to the passage of time. Taken together, these changes make it\n               harder for British Columbians to challenge government decisions and harder for them\n               to access the information necessary to do so. That should concern every member of\n               this House. Judicial review is one of the fundamental tools citizens have to hold government accountable.\n               It is a safeguard against overreach. It is a check on executive power. Transparency\n               is not an inconvenience for government. It is the cornerstone of democracy. We will\n               be asking, why does this government feel the need to expand its ability to withhold\n               information? What decisions is it anticipating that it may need to shield from scrutiny?\n               Because when governments reduce transparency, public trust is inevitably eroded. But the most revealing part of this bill by far is the government's retreat on the\n               electric vehicle mandates. This bill cuts the 2035 target from 100 percent to 75 percent.\n               It removes the 2026 and 2030 targets from legislation, and it moves those targets\n               into regulation where cabinet can change them without debate or a vote in the House.\n               This is not a minor technical adjustment. This is a fundamental shift in policy. Let's be honest about what that means. This is the government stepping back from its\n               own commitments quietly and without clearly acknowledging it. This is now the second\n               major retreat on EV policy in less than a year. First the government cancelled the\n               EV rebate. Now it is dismantling its own mandates. Six years ago, this government\n               made British Columbia the first jurisdiction to legislate EV sale targets. Two years\n               ago, they doubled down, setting aggressive benchmarks of 26 percent by 2026, 90 percent\n               by 2030 and 100 percent by 2035. They described these targets as urgent. They described\n               them as historic. When concerns were raised, when we said these targets were unrealistic and disconnected\n               from infrastructure and affordability, our concerns were dismissed outright. When\n               our caucus brought forward legislation to repeal these mandates, the government voted\n               it down. Now they are doing exactly what we said they would eventually have to do.\n               The only difference is they are trying to do it quietly, tucked away in a miscellaneous\n               statutes bill, rather than standing in the House and admitting that the original plan\n               didn't work. What is even more concerning is that there is no clear replacement plan. The new regulatory\n               framework will not be ready until fall 2026. Targets for the coming years depend on\n               federal policies that have not yet been finalized. The government is dismantling its\n               own plan today without presenting a credible alternative. And then it asks British\n               Columbians to trust them — trust the same government that set the targets, defended\n               the targets, missed the targets and is now dismantling the targets. This outcome was not unpredictable. Analysts warned that aggressive EV mandates would\n               collide with hard realities — insufficient electricity supply, massive infrastructure\n               requirements, declining fuel tax revenues and slower-than-expected consumer adoption.\n               Those warnings were dismissed at the time, but now reality has arrived. EV adoption\n               rose quickly for a period, but then it plateaued. Sales declined. The government eliminated\n               the rebate that had supported adoption and then expressed surprise when demand weakened.\n               As has been said, you cannot kick away the ladder and then blame people for not climbing. While this policy unravels, it is British Columbians who are paying the price. Manufacturers\n               that could not meet the targets faced difficult choices: raise prices, buy credits\n               or cut supply. That translates directly into higher costs and fewer options for consumers.\n               Even now, as the government backs away from those targets, those structural pressures\n               remain in place, so families continue to bear the cost of a policy that the government\n               itself no longer appears confident in. There is also a fundamental issue that cannot be ignored. Even if every British Columbian\n               wanted an electric vehicle tomorrow, the province does not have the power supply or\n               charging infrastructure to support that level of adoption. That is not a partisan\n               claim. That is just simply practical reality. Policies that assume that infrastructure\n               will simply appear after the fact are not sustainable. Infrastructure must come first.\n               These mandates were built on the assumption that supply grid capacity and consumer\n               readiness would all align on schedule, and they have not. That is why we are seeing\n               this retreat. These policies also failed to reflect the diversity of British Columbia. They may\n               have been designed with urban centres in mind, but they were never realistic in rural\n               communities in the North or in the Interior, where distances are longer, conditions\n               are more challenging and infrastructure is limited. Families in those regions were\n               left with fewer choices and higher costs. This bill restores some of that choice,\n               but only because reality has forced the government to reconsider its approach. This is the broader pattern. Set ambitious targets for headlines, dismiss concerns\n               and then quietly adjust when reality intervenes. We are seeing that pattern again\n               in this bill. Reality means aligning policy with infrastructure capacity. It means\n               ensuring affordability. It means respecting consumer choice. It means being honest\n               with British Columbians about what is achievable and when. In closing, Bill 16 reflects a government that is finally being forced to confront\n               reality. There are elements we support. There are steps in the right direction. But\n               there are also serious concerns about transparency, accountability and the approach\n               this government has taken to major policy decisions. The changes to the EV mandate\n               are not just technical adjustments. They are an admission that the original plan didn't\n               work. The question now is whether government will learn from this. British Columbians deserve policies that are grounded in reality from the beginning,\n               not policies that have to be scaled back after the fact. British Columbians deserve\n               transparency, accountability and leadership that is willing to get the details right.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721533","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act. As is often the case with omnibus-style legislation, this bill touches on a wide variety\n               of policy areas — justice, energy, housing, municipal governance, tenancy law and\n               public safety. That breadth alone demands careful scrutiny from this House, because\n               when government packages","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0709bb2f915078be075ae5f769f2059e9a2545087364e7744e5896eeb71d44d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93d0cd4d85df63306b722e32034703fd066718ae48964796c237b3ddb191f243"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-937c5bc0edd58b2d5db2dd5c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721535,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let's stop dressing this bill up in the language of modernization. Let's stop pretending\n               this is a technical cleanup, an administrative tune-up, or a harmless rewrite of procedure;\n               it's not. Bill 9 is a political decision to give government more control over what\n               the public can learn, when the public can learn it, and whether the public can learn\n               it at all. The official explanation notes alone tell the story. They say the bill \"changes the\n               duty to respond without delay to a duty to respond without unreasonable delay,\" lets\n               the head of a public body decide whether a request contains enough detail, excludes\n               certain records tied to court proceedings, creates a new refusal power for communications\n               by or for judicial officers on policy or legislation, expands the grounds for disregarding\n               requests, and permits longer review times. This is not a package of reforms aimed at openness; it is a package of reforms aimed\n               at discretion, delay and denial. Freedom of information exists for one reason: because\n               the public has a right to know what the government is doing in its name and with its\n               money. It exists because the public records are not the private property of ministers,\n               deputy ministers, chiefs of staff, political operatives or communications directors.\n               It exists because democratic accountability is impossible when the government controls\n               the flow of information about itself. That principle was baked into British Columbia's original FOI law. Rob Botterell,\n               who was a part of that, my colleague from the Greens....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721535","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's stop dressing this bill up in the language of modernization. Let's stop pretending\n               this is a technical cleanup, an administrative tune-up, or a harmless rewrite of procedure;\n               it's not. Bill 9 is a political decision to give government more control over what\n               the public can learn, when the public can learn it, and whether the public can learn\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Foster children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","label":"Foster children","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e013259cf200f52bd9a127e07f429cb6981774bf44852efb1588f8b7720e6537","ba8b96888387bfb275ad379dbd1d075b3b84ccdb96bea42e1e6ce6a2654c629a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a567db7ee35df83bcc313fd4d520ef7b793911a37dba0b68d1a033777d7ac09"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-798f326241836d0c1ccd9cad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721546,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"What do the Netherlands and Chilliwack have in common? Of course beautiful fields\n               of tulips, but also nurseries, greenhouses, farms and canals or sloughs. Chilliwack\n               boasts approximately 40 greenhouses. Did you know that the Netherlands is the world's second-largest agriculture exporter,\n               despite the limited land available to them? Their advanced farming technologies and\n               knowledge utilize the least amount of space, incorporating such innovations as vertical\n               cultivation to yield these fantastic results. Using automation and beneficial insects,\n               they have revolutionized the way we grow food. This past weekend, I attended the opening of a brand new nursery in Chilliwack called This past weekend I attended the opening of a brand-new nursery in Chilliwack called\n               The Flowerhouse. Pete De Vrij took the land in the ALR that was unusable for crop\n               production and built a huge greenhouse, thus making the best use of land and yielding\n               a spectacular array of beautiful flowers. Chilliwack boasts many greenhouses and nurseries, almost exclusively run by the hard-working\n               Dutch community, bringing with them their knowledge, technology and expertise in growing.\n               Many are now proudly using self-serving refrigerators that come directly from the\n               Netherlands and that the community can utilize to purchase eggs, flowers, dairy, hazelnuts,\n               you name it. Of course, we value all diverse contributions from all folks from all countries, but\n               on this day, I want to recognize the contribution of the good, hard-working people\n               who live in Chilliwack, whose Dutch heritage helped make Chilliwack the beautiful\n               and productive agricultural hub it is today, and say thank you to them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721546","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What do the Netherlands and Chilliwack have in common? Of course beautiful fields\n               of tulips, but also nurseries, greenhouses, farms and canals or sloughs. Chilliwack\n               boasts approximately 40 greenhouses. Did you know that the Netherlands is the world's second-largest agriculture exporter,\n               despite the limited land available to them? Their advanced farming","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","label":"Food processing","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01ce76e4dd6c942bb38d86c646d9cbcd2ff2790aeaf2fdb55b67c4f504d3205c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0c815129d727503524cffd0632ec1ba89cd9055f3bc7b1be736af3e423e5341"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9c293782ae4e3d6d56959e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729226,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"Of course, we all appreciate the wonderful job that the security team does in the\n               Legislature. There should be a little perk to that, so today I would like to wish\n               Meghan's daughter Charlotte a happy 16th birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729226","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Of course, we all appreciate the wonderful job that the security team does in the\n               Legislature. There should be a little perk to that, so today I would like to wish\n               Meghan's daughter Charlotte a happy 16th birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf19aa8e8716bdaad00687c3c689422f3a525bb486d192170d08a644e390c398"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14251983658a444f9ef74e5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729231,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"Chilliwack literally has it all. Located in the heart of the Fraser Valley, surrounded\n               by beautiful mountains and flanked by the mighty Fraser and Vedder River, lie the\n               fertile fields of hay and, of course, our famous Chilliwack corn. It's all going in\n               the ground as we speak. Do you enjoy fishing? Chilliwack boasts a dozen fishing guide companies. Or how about the exciting and a little scary river rafting? We have three companies. Come and stay for a week, a weekend or a day excursion. Fish for those amazing dinosaur\n               fish, the sturgeon, but catch and release only. There are literally dozens of mountain hikes — Mt. Thom, Mt. Shem, Elk Mountain, just\n               to name a few. You can choose your difficulty level — a nice stroll or a robust cardio-enhancing\n               workout. Or how about horseback riding? There are at least ten stables for riding. Or you can\n               come and take lessons. And lest we forget, the incredible Circle Farm tours that showcase all the locals\n               and their hidden gems: Minter Country Gardens, Rustic Soap Company, Anita's Bread,\n               Farmhouse Brewing, Hofstad's Country Barn, and the Local Harvest, to name a few. And of course, there are plenty of places to go camping, for a swim, either in Cultus\n               or a nice cold mountain spring-fed lake like Lindeman. While you're driving in town, look for signs that sell farm-fresh eggs on roadsides\n               or pick up a bouquet at a roadside flower stand. Include a stop for some amazing Gouda\n               cheese at Smits & Co.w. And I must mention again, if your timing is right, you'll\n               also find lots of corn stands with fresh, same-day-cut corn on the cob to enjoy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729231","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Chilliwack literally has it all. Located in the heart of the Fraser Valley, surrounded\n               by beautiful mountains and flanked by the mighty Fraser and Vedder River, lie the\n               fertile fields of hay and, of course, our famous Chilliwack corn. It's all going in\n               the ground as we speak. Do you enjoy fishing? Chilliwack boasts a dozen fishing guide companies. Or ho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","label":"Farm buildings","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5020cf4c58b91056560a9c2c19a7e06c6d0621d7f1c46c6d1ca08deaed328b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e22c71aafea8c31897dcec67a84fee76e022f552adc0d400eb20bbec6d6a6d99"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2270d89c94c7d23a4359baf6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729236,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, April is an action-packed month in my family, so today I would like to wish\n               my son-in-law Kyle a happy birthday, my mom a happy birthday and my granddaughter\n               Georgia a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729236","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, April is an action-packed month in my family, so today I would like to wish\n               my son-in-law Kyle a happy birthday, my mom a happy birthday and my granddaughter\n               Georgia a happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-01ffc381411ca4a489b21511","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729238,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my pleasure today to introduce my friends Richard and Tera Procee. They are\n               wonderful philanthropists in Chilliwack. Richard is my former colleague on the school\n               board. Tara is currently the treasurer of the Chilliwack North riding association.\n               They are owners of Hofstede's Country Barn, and I am so happy and honoured to have them here. Will the House please make them\n               welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729238","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is my pleasure today to introduce my friends Richard and Tera Procee. They are\n               wonderful philanthropists in Chilliwack. Richard is my former colleague on the school\n               board. Tara is currently the treasurer of the Chilliwack North riding association.\n               They are owners of Hofstede's Country Barn, and I am so happy and honoured to have them here. Will the H","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3526ad0d38d426ab34ca14c96031a92db7e6126735a0473d63f7ca5a7324d122"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8c4e4fd90ed07b7148056e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752284,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752284","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220373","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220373","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:220373","label":"Adults","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c00d44c988e897aa1d11f44e263c15e26b1868dcb5e0191653d408547f9c218"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85708cdf3443b5f88c553483","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752285,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm very pleased to speak to this hoist motion today, not simply to oppose Bill 9\n               but to defend one of the most important democratic principles we have in British Columbia:\n               the principle that government must remain accountable to the people it serves. I rise to defend the principle that information does not belong to politicians, ministers,\n               bureaucrats or governments. It belongs to the people. I rise today in support of the\n               hoist motion And I rise today in support of the hoist motion before this House, because the concerns\n               surrounding Bill 9 are too serious, too numerous and too unresolved for this legislation\n               to proceed without a pause, because this is not a routine amendment. It is not a harmless\n               administrative update. It is not simply modernization, no matter how many times the\n               government repeats that word. Bill 9 fundamentally changes the relationship between citizens and their government.\n               It changes the balance between transparency and control, which is why the hoist motion\n               is so necessary. When legislation carries consequences of this magnitude, this Legislature\n               has a responsibility to stop, to reflect and scrutinize and, at the very least, reconsider. This is precisely why a hoist motion exists, and this is precisely why this House\n               needs to support a six-month pause on Bill 9. A hoist motion is not obstruction. A\n               hoist motion is responsibility. It is a parliamentary mechanism designed specifically\n               for situations where legislation raises profound concerns that require deeper public\n               examination before moving forward. Bill 9 unquestionably meets that threshold, because\n               opposition to this bill is not isolated. The concerns surrounding Bill 9 are broad,\n               serious and credible. Former architects of British Columbia's freedom-of-information legislation have raised\n               alarms. Journalists have raised alarms. Transparency advocates have raised alarms.\n               And when legislation designed to govern access to information generates this level\n               of concern about transparency itself, this House has an obligation to proceed with\n               caution, not speed. This is why a hoist motion matters, because legislation affecting\n               democratic accountability deserves more scrutiny, not less. Let us remember why freedom-of-information legislation exists in the first place.\n               The original FOI legislation was introduced in British Columbia in the 1990s and was\n               built on a very simple but powerful principle. Government information belongs to the\n               public. That principle shaped the legislation as it was originally written. The law was designed\n               not to protect government from scrutiny but to protect the public's right to scrutinize\n               government. It was designed to ensure that citizens could understand decisions made\n               in their name and with their tax dollars. It was designed to ensure accountability.\n               It was designed to ensure transparency, and it was designed with the understanding\n               that democracy cannot function properly when information is hidden from the people. That original vision matters, because Bill 9 moves us away from it. And one of the\n               strongest reasons to support the hoist motion is to allow this House the opportunity\n               to reconsider whether legislation remains faithful to the original principles of the\n               freedom of information as it was conceived in the 1990s. A former architect of British Columbia's freedom-of-information system warned us that\n               this bill risks turning FOI into freedom from information. We heard that today from\n               the MLA for Saanich North and the Islands. This is not partisan rhetoric. In the Times Colonist , it was argued that this government appears to no longer care about access to information.\n               Again, those are not casual criticisms. Those are fundamental warnings about the direction\n               this legislation takes us. When warnings of that magnitude are raised, the responsible response is not to rush\n               the legislation forward. The responsible response is to pause, to listen and to reconsider,\n               to hoist the bill for six months so that the public can fully examine what is being\n               proposed. The irony here is impossible to ignore. A bill dealing with access to information\n               is itself being pushed forward without sufficient openness and scrutiny. That should\n               concern every member of this House. One of the most troubling changes in Bill 9 is the weakening of the response timelines.\n               Under the current legislation, government is required to respond to requests \"without\n               delay.\" Bill 9 changes that standard to \"without unreasonable delay.\" At first glance,\n               this may seem insignificant, but it is not insignificant at all. Words matter, especially\n               in legislation. Standards matter. This change fundamentally weakens the obligation\n               placed on government. \"Without delay\" creates urgency. It creates accountability, and it creates a clear\n               expectation. But \"without unreasonable delay\" introduces flexibility and also introduces\n               interpretation and subjectivity. Most importantly, it gives government greater room\n               to justify delays. That is not strengthening transparency. That is weakening accountability. Changes of that magnitude deserve far more scrutiny than this government appears willing\n               to allow. That is exactly why this bill needs to be hoisted. Because when government\n               weakens the standard for responding to information requests, this House should not\n               simply wave it through. It should pause. It should examine the consequences carefully,\n               and it should ensure that any reforms remain faithful to the original spirit of the\n               legislation. Another deeply concerning aspect of Bill 9 is the expanded authority for government\n               to reject requests. Under this bill, requests may be dismissed if they are considered\n               \"abusive,\" \"malicious,\" \"repetitious,\" \"systematic,\" \"excessively broad\" or \"interfering\n               with operations.\" Let's think carefully about those terms. Who decides what is repetitious or systematic?\n               Who decides what is excessively broad? The government does — the very institution\n               being scrutinized. This is a profound problem. It makes me think of a term that we\n               sometimes use, which is the fox guarding the henhouse. Freedom-of-information legislation was never intended to allow government to define\n               the limits of accessible scrutiny. Yet that is precisely what Bill 9 risks doing.\n               A journalist investigating a pattern of conduct could now A journalist investigating a pattern of conduct could now be described as systematic.\n               An opposition member pursuing repeated follow-up questions could now be described\n               as repetitious. A citizen attempting to obtain comprehensive information could now\n               be described as excessively broad. Once those labels are applied, requests can be\n               rejected. That is not transparency. That is control. When legislation increases government control over public access to information, that\n               legislation deserves more scrutiny, not less. That is why this hoist motion is necessary.\n               Kirk Lapointe warned that Bill 9 will make access to information slower, less predictable\n               and more discretionary. Those words should concern every member of this House — slower,\n               less predictable, more discretionary. Transparency only functions when access is timely,\n               reliable and governed by clear standards. When delays increase, accountability weakens. When predictability disappears, confidence\n               in the system erodes. This should be greatly concerning to government. It certainly\n               is on this side of the House. When discretion expands, government gains greater power\n               to decide what the public gets to know. That is not modernization. That is regression. Lapointe also warned that this legislation enables government to defer, delay and\n               deny the public's right to know. Again, those are not minor criticisms. Those are\n               warnings about the democratic accountability system in and of itself. When legislation\n               raises concerns about democratic accountability, this House should not rush forward.\n               It should pause, and it should certainly support the hoist motion. Transparency advocates have described Bill 9 as an assault on government transparency.\n               Whether members agree with that exact wording or not, the fact remains that there\n               is widespread concern that this legislation weakens public access rather than strengthens\n               it. That concern is not isolated. It is repeated again and again across multiple sectors.\n               That alone should justify a six-month pause. But legislation affecting transparency should itself be subjected to the highest possible\n               level of scrutiny. That is what the hoist motion would, in fact, accomplish. More\n               scrutiny, more public input, more consultation, more accountability, not less. One of the strongest arguments in favour of the hoist motion is that it would allow\n               government the opportunity to return to the original principles of freedom-of-information\n               legislation. I've mentioned this. The original FOI laws. introduced in the 1990s.\n               were designed to expand transparency. Bill 9 risks narrowing it. The original legislation\n               placed the burden on government to justify secrecy. Bill 9 risks shifting the burden\n               on to citizens to justify access. The original legislation recognized that scrutiny strengthens democracy. Bill 9 risks\n               treating scrutiny as interference. That is a profound philosophical shift, and philosophical\n               shifts of this magnitude deserve deep public examination before legislation proceeds.\n               That is why the bill should be hoisted. The government may argue that these changes are necessary for efficiency. The government may argue that these changes are necessary for efficiency, but the\n               public is not the problem. Citizens asking questions are not the problem. Journalists\n               seeking accountability are not the problem. Opposition members demanding answers are\n               not the problem. The problems are internal. Record management systems need improvement.\n               Resources need investment. And instead of addressing those issues directly, Bill 9\n               shifts the burden onto the public. That is the wrong approach. And wrong approaches should not be rushed through the\n               Legislature. They should be paused and reconsidered. And that is precisely what a\n               hoist motion would allow. Let us also consider the cumulative effect of these changes. One change weakens timelines.\n               Another expands refusal powers. Another increases discretion. Another narrows access.\n               Individually, the government may attempt to portray each change as modest, but collectively,\n               the direction becomes unmistakable. The cumulative effect is reduced transparency,\n               reduced accountability and reduced public access. And when legislation moves us steadily away from openness and toward control, this\n               House has a duty to intervene. That is why the hoist motion is so important, because\n               it allows us to stop before those changes become law. It allows us to reassess. It\n               allows us to ensure that democratic accountability remains the guiding principle. This bill does not simply affect journalists or opposition members. It affects ordinary\n               citizens — citizens trying to understand decisions that impact their lives; citizens\n               trying to obtain records about services, policies or actions affecting them personally;\n               citizens who rely on freedom of information laws, because they have nowhere else to\n               turn. And what will happen under Bill 9? Requests will take longer, requests will\n               face more barriers, and they will be subject to more discretion. And eventually, some\n               people will simply give up. You have to wonder if that's not part of the purpose here. That is how transparency erodes, not suddenly but gradually, through delay, through\n               frustration, through exhaustion. That is why the House must proceed carefully, and\n               that is why this bill must be hoisted. A six-month hoist is not unreasonable. In fact, given the scale of concern surrounding\n               this legislation, it is the minimum responsible course of action. Six months would\n               allow more public hearings; more expert testimony; more consultation with journalists,\n               watchdogs and transparency advocates; more examination of how these changes compare\n               to the original principles of the FOI legislation; more consideration of whether this\n               bill truly strengthens access or weakens it. Most importantly, six months would allow\n               for more public scrutiny, not less, because transparency legislation should never\n               move forward without maximum transparency in its own review process. If this government truly believes Bill 9 strengthens access to information, then it\n               should welcome a six-month pause, it should welcome scrutiny, it should welcome debate,\n               and it should welcome public input, because good legislation only improves over scrutiny.\n               Only weak legislation fears it. And if this bill cannot withstand six more months\n               of public examination, then perhaps that tells us everything we need to know about\n               the legislation itself. When I was on the school board, I used to say: \"Public scrutiny and complaints contain\n               improvement information.\" And that is what we truly need to be looking after and looking\n               for. This debate is, ultimately, about trust — trust between government and citizens, trust\n               that government remains accountable, trust that transparency is being strengthened,\n               not weakened. And trust cannot be built through secrecy. It cannot be built through\n               delay. It cannot be built through expanded discretion and increased barriers. Trust\n               is built through openness, through accountability and transparency. Those principles\n               shape the original freedom-of-information legislation in British Columbia, and those\n               principles should continue to guide us today. That is why the House must support this hoist motion, because the concerns surrounding\n               Bill 9 remain unresolved; because the public deserves more scrutiny, not less; because\n               democratic accountability deserves stronger protection, not weaker standards; and\n               because legislation that reshapes public access to information should never be rushed\n               through legislature without full and proper examination. Transparency is not a nuisance, and scrutiny is not interference. Accountability is\n               not optional. Those principles mattered in the 1990s when British Columbia first established\n               its FOI legislation, and they matter just as much, if not more, today. Once transparency is weakened, it becomes very difficult to restore. Once accountability\n               erodes, public trust declines. And once public trust is lost, democracy itself suffers.\n               That is why this House must pause, must reconsider why this House must support the\n               hoist motion before us, not to obstruct accountability but to strengthen it, certainly\n               not to reduce scrutiny but to ensure more scrutiny, more consultation and more public\n               examination before this legislation proceeds any further. To conclude, for those reasons, I will support Bill 9 be read a second time this day,\n               six months hence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752285","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm very pleased to speak to this hoist motion today, not simply to oppose Bill 9\n               but to defend one of the most important democratic principles we have in British Columbia:\n               the principle that government must remain accountable to the people it serves. I rise to defend the principle that information does not belong to politicians, ministers,\n               bureaucrats ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63dfb2a901d447821dbd7a8c776cc1f2dfecaecdd883bf803c84a08cc46ea34a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f7d98e9a5014c7d283fb60425de925d260231760a0926b939e0a635ae495a7f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e156cee4adc4343fbed35c85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017420,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Heather Maahs","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government has been keeping a 140-unit hotel, SRO, open for just two tenants\n               over the past two months. One left, but the last remaining tenant, Robert, has been\n               offered multiple different housing options but is refusing to leave. Atira, the operator\n               of the Colonial Hotel, said the contract to operate expired at the end of April. This is costing taxpayers $550,000 for two months. How can the Minister of Housing\n               justify spending over half a million dollars to house one person?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017420","member_id":"bc-mla-362","member_name":"Heather Maahs","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This government has been keeping a 140-unit hotel, SRO, open for just two tenants\n               over the past two months. One left, but the last remaining tenant, Robert, has been\n               offered multiple different housing options but is refusing to leave. Atira, the operator\n               of the Colonial Hotel, said the contract to operate expired at the end of April. This is costing tax","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b134a858af79dd3802aee729f3022fbba418954652da8b2067f15cc4a86356f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04b3e0c7f9d6dd4121ffe79a7baac193abc4a23deced0da4361d4eba08974a7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fc29bfc5a82f8fe91bbf3cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415848,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Á'a:líya Warbus","venue":"Hansard","text":"líya Warbus: I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge a great person and the celebration and the\n               send-off I was very honoured to attend today, uncle Howard Edward Grant, qiyəplenəxw VII . There are no words for the incredible send-off. Over 600 people in attendance, leaders\n               from across B.C., Canada, to share with his children and his legacy, Trent, Larissa,\n               Wade, Gordon, Keegan and Logan. I just want to take a moment to really honour him\n               and his memory. There were definitely more people that could not attend and that watched\n               and joined and prayed with the family on Zoom. To all of you, what an amazing, incredible send-off for our uncle, our leader. We\n               lost somebody very incredible in the world, and he'll be greatly missed. So I just\n               wanted to share my condolences and strength, love, prayers with the family. [An Indigenous language was spoken.]","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415848","member_id":"bc-mla-363","member_name":"Á'a:líya Warbus","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"líya Warbus: I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge a great person and the celebration and the\n               send-off I was very honoured to attend today, uncle Howard Edward Grant, qiyəplenəxw VII . There are no words for the incredible send-off. Over 600 people in attendance, leaders\n               from across B.C., Canada, to share with his children and his legacy, Trent, Larissa,\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","label":"War memorials","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ea6ecb8c5a6d445416fd58206101c5b219b9010d4d8d322a10b9bfb76bdcdf6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c67304647c7999d8598f07a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036609,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Á'a:líya Warbus","venue":"Hansard","text":"líya Warbus: Education is a vital part, and we value education on this side of the House just as\n               much as every other parent in British Columbia. It's been two years since this government\n               promised an educational assistant in every kindergarten-through-grade-3 classroom,\n               and since then","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036609","member_id":"bc-mla-363","member_name":"Á'a:líya Warbus","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"líya Warbus: Education is a vital part, and we value education on this side of the House just as\n               much as every other parent in British Columbia. It's been two years since this government\n               promised an educational assistant in every kindergarten-through-grade-3 classroom,\n               and since then","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["665d072ea84d9e5f3352d6913ea27e0ac982bd9eb19efd236b80c39ac0626784"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f6e4b42717c367873b186c2407307f59c6938ce826a5bafb3128e5769935037"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d815eb969572ff3948d0447","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317173,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to welcome newly elected Chief Justin Davis and the delegation from Doig\n               River First Nation. We had a good chinwag in the airport last night as well as a very\n               productive meeting this morning. Would the House please make Chief Davis and the Scott McInnis : I just want to welcome newly elected Chief Justin Davis and the delegation from Doig\n               River First Nation. We had a good chinwag in the airport last night as well as a very\n               productive meeting this morning. Would the House please make Chief Davis and the delegation most very welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317173","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I just want to welcome newly elected Chief Justin Davis and the delegation from Doig\n               River First Nation. We had a good chinwag in the airport last night as well as a very\n               productive meeting this morning. Would the House please make Chief Davis and the Scott McInnis : I just want to welcome newly elected Chief Justin Davis and the delegation from Doig\n               Ri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b44c9243c04d3675365289de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317174,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real honour to rise today and speak about a group that has been the character\n               and spirit of Kimberley for nearly a century, the Kimberley Pipe Band. There's nothing\n               quite like it — the first notes rising, ancient and bold; the steady cadence of the\n               drums falling in behind; and then at that moment, when the band rounds a street corner\n               and crests a hill, the music swells with a force that seems to lift the whole community\n               to its feet. As we gather in 2026, we celebrate an extraordinary milestone, the band's 99th year.\n               For almost a century, their music has been the heartbeat of our community — steady,\n               proud and unmistakably Kimberley. Year after year, the pipe band enriches some of\n               our most meaningful moments. As we gather in 2026, we celebrate an extraordinary milestone: the band's 99th year.\n               For almost a century, their music has been the heartbeat of our community, steady,\n               proud and unmistakably Kimberley. Year after year, the pipe band enriches some of\n               our most meaningful moments. They lead us in reflection on Remembrance Day, reminding\n               us of the service and sacrifice that built our freedoms. They celebrate achievements\n               at graduation, marking new beginnings with the traditional strength of the pipes.\n               Of course, they bring unmatched energy and tradition to local parades and community\n               events, weaving music into the story of our town. I want to offer a special and heartfelt thank-you to pipe major Jock MacDonald. Jock\n               has dedicated over 30 years to this band, a commitment that began before he was even\n               a teenager. His leadership, passion and unwavering service have kept this tradition\n               alive, inspired by new players, and strengthened the culture and fabric of Kimberley.\n               Jock, this community is deeply, deeply grateful to you. And if anyone here has ever thought about picking up a set of pipes or a drum, this\n               is your invitation. The band is always ready to welcome new members of all ages and\n               all experience levels to carry this legacy forward. As we stand just one year away\n               from an incredible milestone, the 100th anniversary in 2027, let's continue celebrating,\n               supporting and growing this proud Kimberley tradition. Thank you, and here's to the next century of music.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317174","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It's a real honour to rise today and speak about a group that has been the character\n               and spirit of Kimberley for nearly a century, the Kimberley Pipe Band. There's nothing\n               quite like it — the first notes rising, ancient and bold; the steady cadence of the\n               drums falling in behind; and then at that moment, when the band rounds a street corner\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c340b3159a4aedb44d19ca27c4473fde5c32be4ea6dd025381e8c6eb6a82531"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55a27d2451fda63eacf5a343b269d222d906d37c1d914e6a9946522e4adb7593"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-adb29abfc3103bd3add562bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317175,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here's something that's not working. For over a year, I've been asking when health\n               care professionals in Cranbrook and Kimberley will receive the provincial rural retention\n               incentive. Continuously, these health care professionals express extreme frustration at being\n               excluded. Government has offered vague assurances of ongoing evaluations, with no\n               further explanation as to what that criteria is. My question to the Premier is a simple one. When will these hard-working individuals\n               in rural B.C. get paid what they deserve?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317175","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Here's something that's not working. For over a year, I've been asking when health\n               care professionals in Cranbrook and Kimberley will receive the provincial rural retention\n               incentive. Continuously, these health care professionals express extreme frustration at being\n               excluded. Government has offered vague assurances of ongoing evaluations, with no\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["67cab371d19d9242a38198f8b424f8445df68e22f5a12f51e13f13b678d7bb0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a4e78def12d0d402f749bea2f59e378aa38c4e9b02f85adc43df16f2bcd0da5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1afb3fb6721fed2d0103bdde","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328011,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"This weekend we learned that another agreement has been signed with a B.C. First Nation\n               that could potentially have far-reaching implications in British Columbia. On February 20, the federal government announced an agreement recognizing xwməθkwəy̓əm\n               Aboriginal rights, including title, and establishing shared marine and fishing decision-making\n               in and around Metro Vancouver. In the nearly two weeks since that agreement was signed, we've heard nothing from\n               this government. The agreement \"recognizes that xwməθkwəy̓əm has Aboriginal rights,\n               including title, within their traditional territory.\" Can the Premier please explain to us exactly what this recognition means in the context\n               of our province today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328011","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This weekend we learned that another agreement has been signed with a B.C. First Nation\n               that could potentially have far-reaching implications in British Columbia. On February 20, the federal government announced an agreement recognizing xwməθkwəy̓əm\n               Aboriginal rights, including title, and establishing shared marine and fishing decision-making\n               in and aro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["958fd454e307bdc2bb4721e18e80a6e87c277d3c862dbc23798375b31da44124"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ee7f9b8b921b0946e5e978769aa1592421a376f42c70d952235c229c4b1b707"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbccdec5342e2d8ee68008c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328012,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"As noted on February 20, the Premier was attending the signing ceremony in person\n               in his riding in the front row. Now he's claiming he was there as a local MLA. When\n               you're the Premier, you don't get to take a day off from that role. He also talks about not being briefed on the details of this agreement. He's had two\n               weeks to brief the public that there was a significant agreement coming down the line.\n               No wonder people are jumping to conclusions. There are serious times right now when we're talking about reconciliation in British\n               Columbia. This government keeps going down a dangerous path of hiding information\n               until pressed hard by either the media or the official opposition. My question to the Premier is a very simple one. What exactly is being negotiated\n               with the Cowichan related to their Aboriginal title, which includes the city of Richmond?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328012","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"As noted on February 20, the Premier was attending the signing ceremony in person\n               in his riding in the front row. Now he's claiming he was there as a local MLA. When\n               you're the Premier, you don't get to take a day off from that role. He also talks about not being briefed on the details of this agreement. He's had two\n               weeks to brief the public that there","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["444adb6f45a7c39c3a3bf1dc0e68a724494b9144bb8c5cb2725f51c9df8d73a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdd463a5b7cc4aff6f1a0ebcfb5a90dc572eaf33cdd7fee2874072390621b2e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04c98aac8084f836d5760154","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328013,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"the Premier must have been a really good dodgeball player, because he's exceptional\n               at dodging the questions. This is a dire situation. We have seen that this Premier has not been forthright and\n               honest with British Columbians and this House when it comes to his knowledge of a\n               major rights and title agreement between the Musqueam Indian Band and the federal government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328013","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"the Premier must have been a really good dodgeball player, because he's exceptional\n               at dodging the questions. This is a dire situation. We have seen that this Premier has not been forthright and\n               honest with British Columbians and this House when it comes to his knowledge of a\n               major rights and title agreement between the Musqueam Indian Band and the fede","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b59366c64949f53c10fe8fc87f51408a8a9ccab227cab6b3f16235364f8f4edf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1e3adf73feb61c745ba63e06668954b8d7a75d3200c551f28d49cb01bd46d7c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ef3682cd33b052124177662","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328014,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order. The Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation accused opposition of not\n               having positive relationships with local First Nations, when in fact he has no idea. And from the nations I talk to, it's the Minister of Indigenous Relations who has\n               work to do on his relationships.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328014","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order. The Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation accused opposition of not\n               having positive relationships with local First Nations, when in fact he has no idea. And from the nations I talk to, it's the Minister of Indigenous Relations who has\n               work to do on his relationships.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1241c8e5fefe4f7c39493d91be8d434a60d58863865ad73bc144b952da20a1ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d43b6bb33416713c5198f010237c74715929873b6d944481c7c8e043f8d5aec5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2def70868295af9bfe42cd06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328015,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd just like to highlight a very important moment for a former student of mine coming\n               from Kimberley. Kalle Eriksson has been selected to compete in the visually impaired\n               para-alpine team in the Milano-Cortina Paralympics. Kalle is 21 years old, grew up\n               skiing at the Kimberley Alpine Resort. He began his journey with a para-alpine team\n               in 2024-25, winning ten medals, including two golds, with his guide, Sierra Smith,\n               who is a former World Cup skier herself. I'm just wishing Kalle all the best. I hope to provide updates on some medal success\n               for him. He's a ripping skier, but even more, he's just a heck of a young man. Thank you very much, and good luck, Kalle.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328015","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd just like to highlight a very important moment for a former student of mine coming\n               from Kimberley. Kalle Eriksson has been selected to compete in the visually impaired\n               para-alpine team in the Milano-Cortina Paralympics. Kalle is 21 years old, grew up\n               skiing at the Kimberley Alpine Resort. He began his journey with a para-alpine team\n               i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083611","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Snow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ski trails","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037124","label":"Ski trails","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083611","label":"Snow","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["708b7e6aa34a0db6091d3ec48a40b451f161d7356d2dc4ae3c4820857e0f608b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c54b451b23fe1525d90aa9b10c74d5b474b34f22071038a8ebded2ea31ffba88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b09f6e71311f6998306e8a23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360412,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real pleasure to rise this morning and speak to my friend's bill, from Courtenay-Comox, Long Term Care Access and Transparency Act. Although it's not a be-all, end-all fix to some of the challenges we're facing with\n               seniors care, I do find this to be quite a good SOS bill — save our seniors. I'm going\n               to address the merits of this bill, and then I want to just speak briefly about some\n               of the issues raised by government related to this. It's very simple. The nature of this bill is to provide that timely, transparent and\n               equitable access to long-term care and hospice services. Families across B.C., they're\n               struggling to find that reliable, timely information about that long-term-care availability. I have to say, as somebody with — sorry, Mom and Dad, if you're watching — parents\n               that are getting older, it's important to me, as within the next decade or so, hopefully\n               longer, we'll be looking into various levels of care and areas for care for my parents.\n               I just find on a personal level, accessing timely information is going to be helpful\n               in many respects for myself and my brothers and my sister. It's no secret that we do have an aging population, and that number and that demographic\n               is growing. We have to find ways and methods to ensure that our long-term-care system\n               is keeping pace. Just to address specifically what my friend's bill does, it identifies the total number\n               of patients on wait-lists, the median and maximum wait times, the number of alternative\n               level of care patients that are stuck in hospitals.... This is a real issue. We are seeing seniors that are in hospital, taking up time in\n               hospital when there could be another way to find them care. Just addressing these\n               issues and knowing where people are will help us find strategies in order to deal\n               with that. The number of admitted to long-term care; very importantly, patients who have passed\n               away on waiting lists; how many patients have waited various thresholds for specific\n               days to be on lists; and several other components. I just find this to be a very transparent bill that really provides that accountability.\n               I want to make this very clear, and it's not the intention of my friend with bringing\n               this bill up. It's not meant to point fingers. The nature of this bill is to find\n               specifically targeted data around seniors and the waiting lists and find how we can\n               actually address those. The minister also must compile these reports and publish them for public consumption,\n               which I think is very, very important. When we don't know what we're measuring, it's\n               really difficult to find those targeted strategies, again, and policies to help fix\n               some of these issues. I just find this to be a very, very sensible bill, again, in\n               addressing those concerns. I really like the idea of developing a provincial plan within a year here to address\n               those specific concerns from within the data that's being compiled and to update that\n               plan annually so it is a working document. Transparency does drive improvement. I\n               think this regular publicly accessible data does create that sense of accountability\n               when we're looking at addressing the growing concern of senior care. Families, they shouldn't have to guess about waiting times and access to services.\n               I know it's a very nerve-racking time as families enter that chapter of their life\n               where they're having to find various options for their Families shouldn't have to guess about waiting times and access to services. I know\n               it's a very nerve-racking time as families enter that chapter of their life where\n               they're having to find various options for their parents moving forward.... Options\n               for various facilities. Having that data is not meant to make people nervous, it's\n               to help them plan. It's that simple. Health authorities can better plan their staffing, that's extremely important, and\n               they're also able to look at targeted investments around such pieces as well. With\n               the better data and planning, we can reduce the alternative-level-of-care backlogs\n               and free up acute care beds for patients where we need them. I do want to address a couple of things raised by government. One member had brought\n               up the concern around staffing hours — to be able to report on this. Let's figure\n               that out. We have a growing bureaucracy in the Health Ministry. There's got to be\n               a team in there somewhere that can actually sit down and look at this data, compile\n               it and publish it. I'm sure it's not something with the intention of my friend's bill\n               here, to be overly onerous on the public service within the Ministry of Health to\n               be able to do this. Another member was quoted as saying, \"This gives people a false sense of hope.\" I\n               look at that differently.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360412","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's a real pleasure to rise this morning and speak to my friend's bill, from Courtenay-Comox, Long Term Care Access and Transparency Act. Although it's not a be-all, end-all fix to some of the challenges we're facing with\n               seniors care, I do find this to be quite a good SOS bill — save our seniors. I'm going\n               to address the merits of this bill, and then I want to just ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0626c01e95a3ce54fccd52e54f8b16a37ec892ed9cae31b35bcb2a20d4ff626b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a5e29b15d358035c691efe4cbd8152c7dcec0bd10de5f5ecaa148eb3642e7fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b584cc6c65f3902a04c4a81","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360413,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I see two of my four guests from Kimberley are here today. I hope the other two can\n               get in for question period. Angela and Perry Symes are small business owners, downtown Kimberley. They employ my son, which is very\n               generous of them as well. They've also brought their fathers here. Larry Johnson and\n               Milton Symes are here today watching. In addition, my friends from Cranbrook building association, Interior Realtors, are\n               here. As well, my man, No. 9, Jamie Stein is here. Can we give everybody a big welcome this morning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360413","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I see two of my four guests from Kimberley are here today. I hope the other two can\n               get in for question period. Angela and Perry Symes are small business owners, downtown Kimberley. They employ my son, which is very\n               generous of them as well. They've also brought their fathers here. Larry Johnson and\n               Milton Symes are here today watching. In addition, my ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b6a3ea1a9930823fe853cd6facb7953665fbc3aae3fa5d16e956331453af866"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d657654d2ed0483b6a04dd04","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360414,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"What a week for young athletes in Kimberley. It came into my attention this morning that another former student of mine, Abigail Betker, from Capilano University, has received the Canadian Collegiate Athletic Association women's volleyball player of the year. Abby is a phenomenal athlete since she came into high school in grade 8. She's been the\n               best volleyball player in the East Kootenay, boy or girl, and she continues on with that. She's studying kinesiology, sports sciences. I know how proud Abby is to represent her community, and I wish her and her family\n               all the best. Would you please join me in congratulating her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360414","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"What a week for young athletes in Kimberley. It came into my attention this morning that another former student of mine, Abigail Betker, from Capilano University, has received the Canadian Collegiate Athletic Association women's volleyball player of the year. Abby is a phenomenal athlete since she came into high school in grade 8. She's been the\n               best volleyball player in the East Ko","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fb412413d2dc2d095c9b41b0038cbafc6b77eb62a5d81e18ffb46439ce51390b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4cd81ff80c28bcd1d3dec639d4652115d05deb4480bf899a458ae670de71231"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9fc1c0e87a99c1d0f84c95b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360415,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a bittersweet day for our household. Our one and only son, Luke, turns 16 today,\n               so I'd like to wish him a happy birthday. But I would like to speak directly to my son for a second, if I may. No, you and the\n               boys cannot borrow the truck, so don't ask your mother. Would the House help me wish my son a happy birthday today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360415","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's a bittersweet day for our household. Our one and only son, Luke, turns 16 today,\n               so I'd like to wish him a happy birthday. But I would like to speak directly to my son for a second, if I may. No, you and the\n               boys cannot borrow the truck, so don't ask your mother. Would the House help me wish my son a happy birthday today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","label":"Tax avoidance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f10a01971ef6c2115ba016d3a79b4ad8fc4271064b1131122128f6d976e2e4a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d2ba82bbaf1898d4255fe5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415778,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill entitled the Aboriginal Title Transparency Act, of which notice\n               has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read for a first time\n               now. At a time when transparency in British Columbia is not just lacking but increasingly\n               absent, this legislation is not optional. It is essential. British Columbians are\n               asking a very simple question: \"What is happening on the ground?\" Right now they are\n               not getting answers. This government wants to go to the wall for private property owners. Well, here's\n               a first step in the right direction on behalf of the official opposition. Across this\n               province, negotiations and legal proceedings related to Aboriginal title are unfolding\n               quietly, often behind closed doors, while the people most directly affected are left\n               in the dark. Landowners, families, communities, businesses — they are not asking to\n               be obstructive. They are asking to be informed. This bill certainly changes that. It ensures that when government enters into negotiations\n               or is involved in proceedings that could affect privately held land, those impacted\n               will receive clear, timely notice — not after the fact, not through rumour but directly,\n               transparently and in plain terms. It requires that notices be filed to the land title\n               office so there is a public record. It requires annual reporting so British Columbians\n               can see the full scope of what is happening across this province. This is not about choosing sides. It is about restoring trust. Reconciliation cannot\n               happen in the shadows. It cannot succeed if people feel excluded, uncertain or blindsided\n               by decisions that affect their homes, their land and their future. British Columbians\n               want to understand. They deserve to understand, and they have every right to know.\n               This legislation brings sunlight into a process that for too long has operated without\n               it. In doing so, it strengthens — not weakens — the path forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415778","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that a bill entitled the Aboriginal Title Transparency Act, of which notice\n               has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read for a first time\n               now. At a time when transparency in British Columbia is not just lacking but increasingly\n               absent, this legislation is not optional. It is essential. British Columbians are\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bea06510a32f9765b3ce832461a197e3944c567e8e4fa0747ea7c33ef90fa64f","917916675f3586d5a48ac11f7fbf707a8c9c2c2a92d9bda3671108be14b05379"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a97fc100a65c3366a6c1d152b5d4a504f7db17b1e49353a42827d5bcb0cc5265"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23478dcc2b0abe80e41d6ee0","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187134,"date":"2026-03-30T12:00:00+00:00","title":"ABORIGINAL TITLE TRANSPARENCY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m239-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m239-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187134","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-921e3f6ee030931b2f964175","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415779,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the minister's walk again down memory lane, but it was his flip-flopping\n               which actually cost him the Premiership several years ago. Again, as my colleague reiterated, the federal NDP did elect a leader, Avi Lewis,\n               last weekend. Mr. Lewis was a key signatory to the Leap Manifesto, which states: \"There\n               is no longer an excuse for building new infrastructure projects that lock us into\n               increased extraction for decades into the future.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415779","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I appreciate the minister's walk again down memory lane, but it was his flip-flopping\n               which actually cost him the Premiership several years ago. Again, as my colleague reiterated, the federal NDP did elect a leader, Avi Lewis,\n               last weekend. Mr. Lewis was a key signatory to the Leap Manifesto, which states: \"There\n               is no longer an excuse for building new ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e183fd557088fc1f2c72382d6e09731b2080310522ea1ea5d7f93c7e22be304"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da5b1614b3dd40b05d62d2da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415780,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have to admit, Mr. Speaker, when I first started hanging out with my wife, as a\n               lowly teacher, I felt like a bit of a loser. I have three members of my wife's family here today, and you'll know why here in a\n               second. First of all, my wife's cousin Marlis Neumann is here. Marlis plays the harp in the Munich Chamber Orchestra, a responsibility\n               she's had for over 30 years. She's one of the best harpists in the world. Joining us here also is my wife's sister Kelly Fowler. It's amazing she balances being\n               a lawyer with raising their two beautiful children, Lyndon and Maeve. Lastly, my brother-in-law Maj. Joseph Fowler, who flies the CF-18 Hornet with the\n               Canadian Air Force. Very proud to have Joe here today. Funny enough, mentioning Mr. Hansen who's on his way to circumnavigate the moon....\n               That was Joseph's first commander in the Air Force. So a funny connection there. Would the House please make them all welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415780","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have to admit, Mr. Speaker, when I first started hanging out with my wife, as a\n               lowly teacher, I felt like a bit of a loser. I have three members of my wife's family here today, and you'll know why here in a\n               second. First of all, my wife's cousin Marlis Neumann is here. Marlis plays the harp in the Munich Chamber Orchestra, a responsibility\n               she's had ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","label":"Military aviation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","label":"Military aviation","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57161","label":"Military aircraft","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b294be98038c27fb3ebc17a9760508993f71a56c7ca38a5b394d44203355fa8e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fcaf8aa377548b8a0a1a1c6c27894141301d5e283efcb5f27ff86e7d4aead0b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5396b6eea24ed132b7ca471f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415781,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have Nick and Trudy here, new friends from Columbia River–Revelstoke. We met at the legion in Edgewater during the Remembrance Day ceremonies. I'm so\n               thrilled they reached out that they're going to be in Victoria. I look forward to\n               taking them for a tour and introducing them to you, Mr. Speaker. Please welcome Nick and Trudy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415781","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have Nick and Trudy here, new friends from Columbia River–Revelstoke. We met at the legion in Edgewater during the Remembrance Day ceremonies. I'm so\n               thrilled they reached out that they're going to be in Victoria. I look forward to\n               taking them for a tour and introducing them to you, Mr. Speaker. Please welcome Nick and Trudy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","label":"War memorials","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63812f37b93d71ff77baf33fb52b8fb6d0e14668c73afd655ec8e464c7b26b81"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5bc69f49bcbdb062fd78af23","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415782,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I just want to start by wishing you a happy Easter\n               and everybody in the gallery a happy Easter coming up. I also want to make a note of the Deputy Speaker's comments earlier today and how\n               brave she was in her words that she delivered to the House. It was quite an emotional\n               delivery, and I applaud her courage for doing that. I understand there's quite a remembrance\n               ceremony taking place in her community over the break and I just wish everybody that\n               was impacted by that tragedy all the best over that time. I'm sorry I can't be there,\n               but I will be there in spirit. My comments are going to be relatively brief for a couple of reasons. Number one, I'm not a housing expert. My critic portfolio My comments are going to be relatively brief for a couple of reasons. Number one,\n               I'm not a housing expert. My critic portfolios are, as everybody knows, Indigenous\n               Relations and Reconciliation, tourism and resort municipalities and the Columbia River\n               treaty. But also, I live and represent constituents of a riding that has small communities\n               and some of the supportive housing models. I don't think it's as prevalent, obviously,\n               as we see in some of the more urban areas. I'm going to try and address my comments\n               from more of a rural lens, specifically, and some of the challenges, perhaps, that\n               will be faced with this legislation related to communities such as Revelstoke. I have to start by saying that it is unfortunate.... I understand where the government\n               is coming from on this. I really do. There's an attempt here to make these spaces\n               safer for everybody who occupies them. I understand that component of it. I think\n               there's some really good debate to have in the committee stage of this bill about\n               some of the particulars and the nuances that come along with this. As my friend from West Kelowna–Peachland made very clear, we're talking about a spectrum of issues here, right? When we're\n               looking at those that are in distress for various reasons, everybody that requires\n               various levels of supportive housing, everybody has a different story. We're kind\n               of looking on that spectrum at the end result here. If something wrong happens, we\n               kind of boot them out. I think there's a lot more to be discussed here as far as what are the challenges\n               that individuals face before we get to that point. I know my friend from West Kelowna–Peachland.... His expertise specifically in law enforcement made that very, very clear. Before I get into that, I want to say that, unfortunately, one of the housing projects\n               that was scheduled for Revelstoke is one of the ones that's on pause. I do have a\n               call with an individual later today to discuss that. She's quite upset and frustrated.\n               It's been a long process since 2018 to get this project moving forward in Revelstoke.\n               I know the minister knows this, because we've had lots of communication. Revelstoke is in a bit of a unique housing crisis in its own right for various reasons.\n               But that's a debate for another day. Some of the supportive housing that we're talking\n               about here in the communities I represent, they're small organizations, and the units\n               are not large, like with the number of rooms. In turn, they are staffed at a bare\n               minimum. Sometimes it's kind of a skeleton staff. I know a lot of these staff members are not necessarily equipped with the skills and\n               the training needed for some of the situations, the crisis situations, that arise\n               when individuals for various reasons, whether it's mental health challenges or addiction\n               issues, are faced with a crisis. A lot of the employees at these various centres just\n               simply don't have the training or the expertise available to them in order to deal\n               with some of these situations. I really worry, to be honest with you, about it, because situations do arrive in the\n               small communities. I've spoken with the RCMP and operators about this as well. Although\n               it's a little bit different than we see in some of the more urban centres, they do\n               arise. It's complicated, and it's difficult for folks who run some of these facilities\n               to deal with those situations. I worry that with some of the regulation and legislation that comes down here, by\n               essentially kind of locking people out, that might escalate some of these situations\n               and perhaps create a situation that's worse than what we see. The reality is that in Columbia River–Revelstoke, we don't have a lot of full circle wraparound services. We don't have the additional\n               shelter spaces, detox facilities and other services that are required for people that\n               are going through challenges in their life. That's a by-product of.... Again, our communities are quite small, and these issues\n               that we're talking about are fairly localized. But having said that, like I mentioned,\n               they still exist. With the enforcement piece here, just to kind of lay a bit of a picture out With the enforcement piece here.... Just to kind of lay a bit of a picture out for this,\n               our first responders in Columbia River–Revelstoke are world-class. I want to start by saying that. But at times, they can be a little\n               bit understaffed. The resources aren't quite there for several reasons, particularly\n               the geography. Police and fire in Columbia River–Revelstoke are managing quite a large geographical area. I've spoken to the firefighters in\n               Golden many times, as well as Revelstoke, and I'm using these two specific examples\n               for this reason. They cover a huge area over Kicking Horse Pass between the two communities,\n               Golden and Revelstoke. When there are accidents, the ability for them to respond to\n               these issues can be very strained at times — to these situations that will arise from,\n               I think, the intention of this legislation. I just worry a little bit here. I didn't see.... Again, I think it's a good conversation\n               for committee stage. We're looking at the removal of weapons, which I think is a positive\n               step in the right direction, obviously, to keep everybody safe in these housing units. As everybody has mentioned, a weapon can be fairly subjective. I know the member for\n               Saanich North and the Islands mentioned a broom handle. Others had mentioned forks, steak knives. These things\n               can be used as weapons, so I think we have to sort of delineate. What does it look\n               like to have a regular tool for life, and when does it become a weapon? I think that's a fair conversation to have. I didn't see it, going through the legislation,\n               and I'm sure this will be, perhaps, in some of the regulation that's talked about\n               in the discussion. But when a tenant is going through crisis and is armed and perhaps dangerous, who's\n               the first line of response to that? Again, I know that the folks that I know personally\n               that are employed in these units are definitely, like I said, not trained for this. Coming back to my point about first responders, if they are at a call halfway up Kicking\n               Horse Pass to a fatal car accident, heaven forbid.... It's the most dangerous stretch\n               of highway in the country. That's a reality. How do we deal with that? It could be\n               hours before the ability of a first responder to address the situation. I just worry about, knowing the people that run the operations, them being in a potentially\n               dangerous situation that has an escalating chance of risk for them being a serious\n               consideration. Again, there are a lot of volunteers that work at a lot of these supportive\n               housing facilities in Columbia River–Revelstoke. Again, I just hope there's a really good conversation in the committee stage about\n               how we equip them with the proper tools to deal with what is an increasing number\n               of people that require this supportive housing. That's the reality. We have seen, over the past ten years in Columbia River–Revelstoke, an increased need for this, and I think part of it is just changing social dynamics.\n               But also, I think there are.... People come to these communities for various reasons,\n               whether they're working in the resort sector and then aren't able to leave, perhaps. I just wonder about.... If people are forced out of these units, there's just really\n               nowhere else for them to go. That's my biggest concern, especially when we've seen\n               additional spaces being paused. The result of that is increased encampments or people\n               being on the street. That's a serious worry. I mean, in Columbia River–Revelstoke, when people don't have those supportive housing facilities available to them, they\n               end up in encampments just outside of town on Crown land. That creates a whole new\n               set of risks on its own. So I worry about the ability to remove people. Then what\n               happens? I think this is a pretty common concern across rural British Columbia for my friends\n               that represent different areas of the province as well. Again, it wasn't clear to me in the legislation who is responsible for Again, it wasn't clear to me in the legislation who is responsible for the confiscation\n               of a potentially dangerous weapon. Where is it stored until it can be properly disposed\n               of or taken care of? I just think those are important details that we have to get\n               around here, when we're looking at some of this. We did have a.... Unfortunately, in a private operation in Radium, there was a fire\n               which burned several units a few months ago. So it's a serious concern. I worry, again, about how on overnight watch and supervision and things like that, it's often a single employee here. So\n               again, dealing with a crisis situation, if somebody is removed or weapons have to\n               be confiscated, I just worry about the safety aspect, and thinking about it from a\n               rural British Columbia lens. Again, I think there's a lot to pull through here. I know my colleagues who are experts\n               in housing have a lot of really good questions to ask about the details of this legislation.\n               Unfortunately, again, it's a piece of legislation which enacts a series of regulations\n               which we don't have the chance to look at or debate here today. So we're kind of counting\n               on the government to get those pieces right. But specifically for rural British Columbia, again, I just have those specific concerns\n               that are unique to us when we're looking at the changes to the Residential Tenancy\n               Act here. I really hope that there's some really good conversation and questions asked\n               about those specific components, when we get to it. Thank you for the time today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415782","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I just want to start by wishing you a happy Easter\n               and everybody in the gallery a happy Easter coming up. I also want to make a note of the Deputy Speaker's comments earlier today and how\n               brave she was in her words that she delivered to the House. It was quite an emotional\n               delivery, and I applaud her courage for doing t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ae8ce638021bcc21727ec7cbada37ec4987696084cbc9b3388cfe1217fb17baf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9ab33858e0ff5f5012bcfaba5f51a45c4cc31e1c9559a8d70a337bbfaf7dbad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-112770af9f0aa8ed2356c51a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720446,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Unfortunately, she's not able to be here in the gallery today, but I know that she's\n               watching at home. A very special constituent in the town of Revelstoke, Mrs. Helen\n               Anderson, turned 103 years old yesterday. I know she has put on a smiling face and is already planning a big party for her 105th\n               birthday. If the House would help me in wishing Ms. Anderson a very happy 103rd birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720446","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Unfortunately, she's not able to be here in the gallery today, but I know that she's\n               watching at home. A very special constituent in the town of Revelstoke, Mrs. Helen\n               Anderson, turned 103 years old yesterday. I know she has put on a smiling face and is already planning a big party for her 105th\n               birthday. If the House would help me in wishing Ms. Anders","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c42e472e277b8b4805a25bacc6b1d0dcfaab8d7cc387f19c86cd94f608197198"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-276f14dda016d66f98186a51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720450,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd also like to welcome in the gallery today several members from the Lax Kw'alaams First Nation, which we had an opportunity, in opposition, to discuss some issues\n               with yesterday. I would like to welcome here to the House today. Mr. Gary Reece, Mr. Rodney Henry,\n               Ms. Tami Dudoward, Mr. Ted White, Mr. Vernon Alexcee, Mr. Andrew Tait, Mr. Stan Dennis,\n               Mr. Stan Dennis Jr., Mr. Rob Hughes, Mr. Don Wesley, Mr. Kelly Sampson and Mr. Joey\n               Wesley. Thank you all for the opportunity to discuss and meet yesterday. Would the House please help me make them welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720450","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd also like to welcome in the gallery today several members from the Lax Kw'alaams First Nation, which we had an opportunity, in opposition, to discuss some issues\n               with yesterday. I would like to welcome here to the House today. Mr. Gary Reece, Mr. Rodney Henry,\n               Ms. Tami Dudoward, Mr. Ted White, Mr. Vernon Alexcee, Mr. Andrew Tait, Mr. Stan Dennis,\n               Mr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d27785ea3c1a9daa1c540fc8ff6457ce12a3228133918e96e8b8ce4395af2a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-290d4ae6fc4fe53fc553631d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720453,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to wish a happy 27th birthday to my good buddy the member for Kootenay-Rockies, who has a birthday today. Unfortunately, he's been working really hard battling a difficult medical condition\n               since the holidays. It's his birthday today. I know he misses everybody in the Legislative\n               Assembly and not being here. Would the House please wish the member a happy birthday today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720453","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to wish a happy 27th birthday to my good buddy the member for Kootenay-Rockies, who has a birthday today. Unfortunately, he's been working really hard battling a difficult medical condition\n               since the holidays. It's his birthday today. I know he misses everybody in the Legislative\n               Assembly and not being here. Would the House please wish the member a happy birt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e0013bffe714221621802adc3f1411c1f229180c73f699640402659378e9bf02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dde01e3c86b4e300cfcb5a69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720458,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is with sadness that I express the loss of two very important constituents in Columbia River–Revelstoke. First of all, Mrs. Isabel Hogg passed away at the age of 94 just a few days ago. Isabel\n               was a neighbour of mine two doors up. She is survived by her husband, George, who\n               is a famous painter of Indigenous artwork in the East Kootenay and western Alberta.\n               In October, they celebrated their 75th wedding anniversary. I am just at a loss with Isabel. I have known her since I moved to Kimberley in 2010.\n               It's just very sad knowing that George survived Isabelle. But I know they're very\n               faithful and that she is in a very happy place now. I have to tell a quick story. During COVID, our street was helping the Hoggs get groceries\n               so that they could stay comfortably at home. I received a beautiful handwritten grocery\n               list one day. It was the cutest thing. There were two apples, six slices of baloney\n               and some other items. But George and Isabel — I'll never forget this — each had their\n               own flavour of ice cream I had to get. George liked chocolate sauce and Isabel liked\n               butterscotch. So it was just a very cool memory that I'll always have. The second is the passing of Beth Bennett, a constituent of mine, on a beautiful Easter\n               Sunday at the age of 69, surrounded by her friends and family. Beth was just a wonderful\n               woman. Anybody who has had the opportunity to meet her knows just how wonderful and\n               kind and loyal and loving that she was. Beth is survived by her husband, Bill, who is known very well in the House here, served\n               as the member for Kootenay East for 16 years, as well as a cabinet minister — Bill\n               Bennett. It's a very sad loss for not only the Bennett family but for Columbia River–Revelstoke. So my heart and prayers and thoughts are with both Isabel, her family, as well as\n               the Bennetts at this time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720458","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is with sadness that I express the loss of two very important constituents in Columbia River–Revelstoke. First of all, Mrs. Isabel Hogg passed away at the age of 94 just a few days ago. Isabel\n               was a neighbour of mine two doors up. She is survived by her husband, George, who\n               is a famous painter of Indigenous artwork in the East Kootenay and western Alberta.\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:191593","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hogs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:191593","label":"Hogs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","label":"Fruits","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42dda57d0c8bd8ee1bc46298a5f3054426fa10854738d8d3b070b800ea1f0352"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a0fbfa4b321df38492d5a30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721551,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Clear as mud over here. This government likes to go down memory lane, so I'm going to take them on a trip\n               on one. From March 4, 2026, the Premier said: \"I was not briefed on this. I was not\n               aware of the content of the agreements.\" From the same day, the Premier said: \"It's\n               possible that somebody in the public service received a heads-up or knew about it.\" British Columbians have a right to know what their government is doing on decisions\n               that affect their rights, their property and their way of life. But this Premier has\n               decided they don't. When caught in the trap of his own making, he claimed he attended\n               the xwməθkwəy̓əm signing agreement as just the regular old local MLA. But we now know, through freedom\n               of information — thank goodness for that — that an invitation went directly to the\n               Premier's office, not a junior staffer, not his constituency office, to the Premier's\n               office. We also know that this government sent a letter of support for this agreement a full\n               year ago. A very simple question. Why is this Premier so determined on keeping British Columbians\n               in the dark on decisions that affect them directly?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721551","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Clear as mud over here. This government likes to go down memory lane, so I'm going to take them on a trip\n               on one. From March 4, 2026, the Premier said: \"I was not briefed on this. I was not\n               aware of the content of the agreements.\" From the same day, the Premier said: \"It's\n               possible that somebody in the public service received a heads-up or knew about it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034394","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034394","label":"Capital markets","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2055d5657cd7b802f3fb24f1d6c268cf2214a5132d344056d70f3a82c3f7c8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2389e052f81839ce6d58ab27afd7176dc7d13b197074708de16351037e1ae900"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61d7e94749630569fd3be5d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721553,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I received a surprise text last night that I would have two constituents here in town\n               from Kimberley. Erin and Jamie are here to take a little getaway to co-celebrate their\n               50th birthdays together here in Victoria. So would the House please make them feel\n               very welcome this morning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721553","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I received a surprise text last night that I would have two constituents here in town\n               from Kimberley. Erin and Jamie are here to take a little getaway to co-celebrate their\n               50th birthdays together here in Victoria. So would the House please make them feel\n               very welcome this morning.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea00cc1195c9874cf573f3138ad3a2f1d22fccf102302d3d22fb45e34e2b807f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5de5130a55ddd5007ed4464a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721554,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real pleasure here today to speak in very staunch opposition to Bill 9. It's\n               nice to say welcome to all the guests in the gallery today, and I'm sure the tens\n               of thousands of people at home watching on TV. Very simple here, and I have a lot of things I want to cover here today. I want to\n               have some fun with this, because I certainly don't think, and I'm sure everybody in\n               the gallery would agree with me and everybody at home, that it is a public government's\n               responsibility to walk towards transparency and accountability when it comes to freedom\n               of information, not away from it. And that is exactly what we're seeing with these\n               amendments in I appreciate the Minister of Citizens' Services for bringing the bill forward in the\n               two-minute introduction speech. If the vote was based on those words, we would probably\n               all vote unanimously in favour of this bill. But after peeling back the layers, it is very obvious that this government, which\n               has a pattern and a reputation — not from the official opposition; this is in the\n               public — of not being overly transparent, to say the very least.... This further adds\n               to that, and it is extremely concerning. I want to thank my friend the member for Saanich North and the Islands for his very eloquently put speech a number of weeks ago on this. As far as I recall,\n               he was involved in the original drafting of the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act several decades ago, and I agreed with just about everything he said. This is outrageous, what we're seeing here with Bill 9. The public deserves to have\n               timely access to information. To put up barriers to make it slower and less efficient\n               is an abdication of responsibility on a public government. I can't believe that we\n               are seeing this bill come forward. At a time when the FOI system is already in somewhat of a crisis.... I'll get to the\n               details here in a moment. I've got lots of great examples to share on the record.\n               The government response times are now the worst in 13 years. So if I send in a request\n               for a freedom-of-information response, we are in the slowest response time in over\n               a decade. There's nothing in here that even attempts to speed that process up. In fact, it's\n               going to dramatically slow it down. The OIPC found the province takes an average of\n               85 business days to respond to a freedom-of-information request, the longest delay\n               on record. And 5,100 requests in recent years were delayed without any type of legal\n               authority, forcing applicants to wait an extra 192 business days on average. I don't understand why we're trying to make this system more delayed and more complicated.\n               I certainly, when I get to sit in government, would welcome the opportunity to have\n               the public understand how we are spending their money as quickly as possible. We see quite a change in language in Bill 9. We're replacing, when we're talking about\n               freedom-of-information requests, \"without delay\" with \"without unreasonable delay.\" Now, let's put that into context for a second, because words matter here. If my wife\n               says to me, \"Honey, will you take out the trash without delay?\" you best bet I'm going\n               to do it right away. But if there's leeway, \"Honey, can you take the trash out without\n               unreasonable delay?\" I'm going to watch the sports highlights, kick back, maybe take\n               the dog out for ten minutes. That matters. What is unreasonable delay? That matters. What is unreasonable delay? I certainly don't see that quantified anywhere\n               in this bill. It builds a permanent excuse for slow-walking even further these requests,\n               at a time when they are the slowest in our province's history. \"Reasonable\" becomes\n               whatever the government thinks that says. Ignoring requests that are abusive, malicious, excessively broad or interfering with\n               operations. All subjective. No definitions. Nothing concretely explained as to what\n               that actually means. And in the examples I'm going to give on the record today, I'm\n               sure there'd be a great way for this government to steer any one of those examples\n               as abusive, malicious, excessively broad, interfering with operations, when in fact,\n               it's information that's critical for the public to know. The expansion of the mass data sharing in a time when we have issues around privacy? There's no way I can support that,\n               in section 69.3 of this bill, with no corresponding expansion in public access rights. That makes absolutely no sense to me. Transparency is mandatory from public government.\n               It shouldn't be at government's discretion to decide what that means. I'd like to thank — I'm sure the government doesn't like this association — the Canadian Taxpayers Federation for their work in exposing some of the egregious expenditures of government. Things\n               that, under this amendment of this bill, they will surely sweep under the rug with\n               the new subjective language that we see here. So let's walk through the list a little bit here, and then I'll get to the more recent conversation\n               from earlier today. Thanks to the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, through freedom-of-information requests, they found and exposed that deputy ministers within government get a $14,000\n               vehicle allowance every year. And I'm not criticizing the work of deputy ministers;\n               it's critically important. But when you're making $350,000 to $400,000 a year, a $14,000 vehicle allowance? Is that a good use of the public purse? I certainly\n               don't think so. We had a coronation medal ceremony — very important for local folks. And I'm not opposed to government perhaps providing\n               a reasonable level of entertainment, a venue. But recently in Victoria, for this celebration,\n               there was a $35,000 bill. A $35,000 reception. That included 42 glasses of Prosecco Again, the coronation celebration — extremely important. Yes, there should be a reasonable\n               level of snacks and beverages provided, but a round of J.D. for the boys? I'm speechless. The minister who brought this bill forward charged taxpayers — again, this is all\n               through freedom-of-information exposure — $3,900 for a happy hour in Amsterdam. And\n               that wasn't good enough. They extended it another hour and a half for a cost of an\n               extra $600. The Finance Minister on a recent trip to the United States, through a\n               freedom-of-information request, billed taxpayers $6,600 for limousines. We'll let\n               the public digest that as they will. Now, moving ahead to more modern times, I was involved in an exchange with the Premier\n               earlier today about his knowledge of a very significant rights and title agreement\n               between the federal government and the Musqueam Indian Band. His story changed several\n               times over his involvement, level of knowledge for that agreement. First of all, he didn't know anything about it. Then it turned out he was actually sitting there\n               in the front row. Then he said: \"Yeah, but I was just there as the local MLA, not\n               as the Premier. I still didn't know anything about it.\" But through freedom of information\n               and a relatively timely response, we were able to ascertain that, yes, on February\n               12, weeks before that signing agreement, the Premier received an official invitation\n               to that, to the Premier's office. One of two things could be correct. There's an extreme lack of communication in the\n               Premier's office, very concerning on its own. Or he didn't want to be forthright,\n               actually, about his knowledge of this agreement. Now, the Premier got his hackles up today with me, saying how dare I say that there\n               was a letter of support sent by his government to the federal government a year ago,\n               congratulating the xwməθkwəy̓əm on this agreement being signed. Well, I just want to read. Again, this is through a freedom-of-information request.\n               This is a communication between the Deputy Minister of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and their federal counterparts. It says, this is the Deputy Minister: \"B.C. provided\n               a letter of support to Minister Anandasangaree last year.\" So thanks to freedom-of-information\n               requests, we were actually able to connect the dots that, certainly, in that very\n               significant agreement that was signed around the Premier by the federal government,\n               he certainly knew what was going on. We cannot go down this road away from transparency and accountability with a bill\n               like Bill 9. Why? When you go down these roads, they're very hard to walk back. They're\n               not going to be in government forever. Just imagine for a second. Let's just play\n               the what if Just imagine for a second.... Let's just play the what-if game. If the Conservatives\n               were sitting in government, and we brought forward a bill like this, the outrage from\n               the NDP for trying to make freedom-of-information requests slower, more subjective\n               as to what can be processed and what can't be.... They'd light their hair on fire. But\n               when they do it, it's: \"Oh we're just helping everybody out. We're making it faster.\" The Freedom of Information and Privacy Association raised \"serious concerns about\n               the legislation, warning that it weakens at a time when government has failed to meaningfully\n               implement its own recordkeeping law.\" It's not just the official opposition, independents\n               and Third Party members raising the concern here. This is systemic opposition to this. This is very dangerous legislation. \"Access delays are often a symptom of recordkeeping\n               failures,\" said the Freedom of Information and Privacy Association executive director\n               Jason Woywada, further saying: \"You cannot fix systemic information management problems\n               by weakening public access rights.\" This is not an attempt to modernize freedom of information. This is a calculated play\n               to make it harder to access.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721554","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a real pleasure here today to speak in very staunch opposition to Bill 9. It's\n               nice to say welcome to all the guests in the gallery today, and I'm sure the tens\n               of thousands of people at home watching on TV. Very simple here, and I have a lot of things I want to cover here today. I want to\n               have some fun with this, because I certainly don't think, a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["833824b59dd435e2282f4cd9fc28b328c1872cc856ae05abc122da7acb5169fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["68c3a38bc16cb0c6554c3adde86358bfa20e6310a2709f6286ed5f76ffe89d16"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcd481e959b90916d08cdabc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721556,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Legal experts on Aboriginal law are speaking out against this government's utter mishandling\n               of Indigenous relations in British Columbia. Geoffrey Moyse, a government lawyer for\n               over 30 years, said this government is displaying a level of \"ineptitude and incompetence\"\n               he has never seen before. Tom Isaac, who literally wrote the book called Aboriginal\n               law, said the NDP \"seems to be co-governing with undemocratically elected governments.\" My question is a very, very simple one. Does the Attorney General agree with these\n               statements made by leading Aboriginal law experts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721556","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Legal experts on Aboriginal law are speaking out against this government's utter mishandling\n               of Indigenous relations in British Columbia. Geoffrey Moyse, a government lawyer for\n               over 30 years, said this government is displaying a level of \"ineptitude and incompetence\"\n               he has never seen before. Tom Isaac, who literally wrote the book called Aboriginal\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:184310","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nationalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:184310","label":"Nationalism","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f52c9cde7b161c63abc7edb57b0e736d0dfcd64c57cac8fbd2144f0212ef570","db55eddd364e9b57dbf015c331ea5c7abfefab5e839f6a698b9e9a6df1222b2f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b392522735981365ab04b0ac08d5b887e15f508c14e2cd92d8417300b70bffef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b720bf12d6fd4f2d638a6f18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729291,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour and a pleasure to speak to my friend for Kelowna-Mission's motion this morning, M205. The intent of this motion, I think, is pretty straightforward.\n               Those making multi-billion-dollar decisions should have a basic understanding of arithmetic\n               and finances. I'm not sure, hearing some of the comments from the other side, why\n               that's so contentious. In the Legislature, we're tasked with voting on taxes, spending, debt, regulation,\n               labour costs. Those decisions affect everybody in this province — families, businesses,\n               public services — in real ways. It's a modest ask that there is something brought\n               before legislators in this building that just gives us a basic understanding of some\n               of those principles. I welcome this. I'm not a financial guru, and I'll be first to\n               put my hand up to admit that. I would welcome more training and more expertise in\n               this field. Now, members opposite for some reason in this motion are talking about the election\n               platform and also speaking about how we're outraged over the deficit. You're darn right. We're outraged over the deficit. I've referenced this several times in this House. Mounting\n               deficit, mounting debt, will result in $1 million an hour in debt servicing payments\n               in the coming couple of years — $1 million an hour that's not going to seniors housing,\n               children with autism, education, transportation. We're going to be flushing that money down the toilet because these members don't\n               have a basic understanding of finances. I can't believe they're talking about their\n               election platform promises on a deficit number, and then they're blowing it out of\n               the water here in reality. I'm gobsmacked by that. Economic misunderstanding is not theoretical. It becomes public policy in this building. And it goes deeper than that. I'm glad the member for Ladysmith-Oceanside mentioned some of the vague outlines in some of our school curriculum related to\n               numeracy. After being a teacher and principal for 15 years, there is one topic which\n               students who graduated said to me they had wished they learned more about in our school\n               system. That is entrepreneurship and finances. Students are starving to learn more about personal money management, and we're not\n               giving it to them at the very basic level. We have much more work to do in our education\n               system to prepare everybody, including who will eventually be members of the Legislative\n               Assembly, a basic understanding of financial literacy. This is an extremely important motion. A little bit of extra financial literacy for\n               members who are making extremely consequential decisions about the public purse surely\n               cannot be a bad thing. I want to thank my friend for Kelowna-Mission for bringing this forward. It's not supposed to be a contentious motion. I think\n               we should all be embracing it. It's not asking for perfection. It's asking for something\n               reasonable — just a basic understanding of costs, incentives and consequences of the\n               decisions made in this House. If we want these better decisions, we should expect\n               a basic level of this understanding. This is a very modest, practical step toward\n               more competent government, one that all members should be fully in support of. In closing, I'm going to put my hand up and say I would welcome additional financial literacy training. Again, it's something\n               that I am not an expert on. As my wife and I have deep Scottish roots, we're very\n               careful with our money. Some might even call it cheap. And I think at times In closing, again I'm going to put my hand up and say I would welcome additional financial\n               literacy training. Again, it's something that I am not an expert on. As my wife and\n               I are have deep Scottish roots, we're very careful with our money. Some might even\n               call it cheap. And I think, at times, we need to understand how we're making these\n               decisions about finances that affect everybody in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729291","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's an honour and a pleasure to speak to my friend for Kelowna-Mission's motion this morning, M205. The intent of this motion, I think, is pretty straightforward.\n               Those making multi-billion-dollar decisions should have a basic understanding of arithmetic\n               and finances. I'm not sure, hearing some of the comments from the other side, why\n               that's so content","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2b9db3d5b46b5f7a7db2ae481f063c5fa84d3d65fabc0cdef341e7a2c1482ba4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f89cdab9bc234ce0913bd42a49391d7beb5f0660f97c5eafcafe72071dd078ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d64e9d9eeea88028fb594d89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729294,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Wow, it sounds like in 22 minutes and 43 seconds, there's going to be an awkward phone\n               conversation between the Premier's office and Mr. Teegee. A U.S.-based tribe, the [An Indigenous language was spoken.] confederacy, is actively trying to disrupt a vital critical mineral mine within the\n               Interior. The mine is co-owned by WHY Resources and the Osoyoos Indian Band. My question to the Attorney General: why is she letting this happen?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729294","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Wow, it sounds like in 22 minutes and 43 seconds, there's going to be an awkward phone\n               conversation between the Premier's office and Mr. Teegee. A U.S.-based tribe, the [An Indigenous language was spoken.] confederacy, is actively trying to disrupt a vital critical mineral mine within the\n               Interior. The mine is co-owned by WHY Resources and the Osoyoos Indian Band. My ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da34fcc5edc73296fa16eca58ddf018b3e48918cbb059788e84b922b460e7085"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a159dc71d388ee817dbe2ca0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729296,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to join my friends from Ladysmith-Oceanside as well as West Vancouver–Sea to Sky in welcoming Science Meets Parliament 2026. This is just a fantastic initiative.\n               Mr. Speaker, I want to thank you personally for organizing this through your office. I know B.C. is an innovation hub on the planet for science and innovation and technology,\n               and we are absolutely thrilled, all members, to have you here today. Welcome to the\n               Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729296","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to join my friends from Ladysmith-Oceanside as well as West Vancouver–Sea to Sky in welcoming Science Meets Parliament 2026. This is just a fantastic initiative.\n               Mr. Speaker, I want to thank you personally for organizing this through your office. I know B.C. is an innovation hub on the planet for science and innovation and technology,\n               and we are absolutely th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1337bcdcee6e526d54f753e04744136d9c8a64ae27f11227d9db02cac19e39c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-51361d9c6734d65e914dd271","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729297,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real point of pride for us in Columbia River–Revelstoke to be home to one of the most innovative and exciting businesses in British Columbia,\n               Edison Motors, right in Donald, B.C. Edison is proving that world-class innovation\n               doesn't have to come from big cities. It can come from small, determined communities\n               with big ideas. One of the best examples of this is their youth EV challenge, where students are encouraged\n               to get hands-on with real engineering, problem-solving and teamwork. We were especially\n               proud last year when local students from Golden Secondary School took home the win.\n               Even better, those winning students didn't just walk away with a trophy. They earned\n               jobs at Edison Motors, turning classroom learning into real careers right here at\n               home. Edison also has a bold vision to become an innovation hub for the province, a place\n               where cutting-edge businesses can set up shop, collaborate and grow, all while having\n               access to affordable, functional space. That kind of ecosystem is exactly what rural\n               and small communities need to attract the next generation of makers, builders and\n               entrepreneurs. Anyone who's been out to the site knows Edison doesn't take itself too seriously,\n               either. Some of my favourite moments have been the tours that Chase and Eric have\n               taken me on in a convertible Jeep, sometimes after it's been left out in the rain\n               the night before, hitting jumps and always reminding me that innovation can still\n               be a ton of fun. None of this would be possible without clear, commonsense regulatory processes. Edison\n               is quick to say how straightforward and easy it is to navigate approvals with the\n               Columbia Shuswap regional district. That certainty makes a real difference for businesses\n               trying to move fast and do things right. Finally, it wouldn't be Edison without seeing their work on the road, including their\n               plow truck they built for EmCon, showing how innovation can provide safety, efficiency,\n               sustainability in real-world applications. Edison, we couldn't be prouder of you. Thank you so much for calling Columbia River–Revelstoke your new home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729297","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a real point of pride for us in Columbia River–Revelstoke to be home to one of the most innovative and exciting businesses in British Columbia,\n               Edison Motors, right in Donald, B.C. Edison is proving that world-class innovation\n               doesn't have to come from big cities. It can come from small, determined communities\n               with big ideas. One of the best exampl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168620","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Mountains","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016923","label":"Mountains","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168620","label":"Ecosystems","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3e3f0f633d9fb32e13b1f684adf0fa557bd5162a5a033efd9f9c73225561f10","47dd12ee1583e06a7f0b3fdaa331204dbef01f06f9499094ae875ee20f8742a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4bba0377c49b93601a016cfa870b33df21a420bbb3263d696e7e690e7e885359"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c2de5b1ee98adfd235fe132","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752295,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll take a quick second and congratulate the Kimberley Dynamiters on being the '25-26\n               Kootenay International Junior Hockey League champions for the year. Kimberley has\n               really been a powerhouse in junior hockey for the last number of years. This is their\n               second championship in the last four. Would the House please help me in congratulating the Dynamiters, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752295","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll take a quick second and congratulate the Kimberley Dynamiters on being the '25-26\n               Kootenay International Junior Hockey League champions for the year. Kimberley has\n               really been a powerhouse in junior hockey for the last number of years. This is their\n               second championship in the last four. Would the House please help me in congratulating the Dynamiter","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["630358d29d1c86283a8b2cab2b18be2c9f36cd223810f785282bb6257e17a4e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39299f7a42ef7c26597999208fc73622c335159efa444f09e1a86a0cc5e6590f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87ddd3679c9d20376cf6f5bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752296,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"We need to get some serious answers this afternoon, because there's something fishy\n               going on here. The sn̓ʕaýckstx case has potential to enable Americans to have serious influence in B.C. affairs,\n               beyond what the constitution requires. To the Attorney General: were you aware two weeks ago, when you famously tapped the\n               Premier on the shoulder, that the WHY Resources case was scheduled to be heard in\n               the B.C. Supreme Court on May 5 yesterday?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752296","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We need to get some serious answers this afternoon, because there's something fishy\n               going on here. The sn̓ʕaýckstx case has potential to enable Americans to have serious influence in B.C. affairs,\n               beyond what the constitution requires. To the Attorney General: were you aware two weeks ago, when you famously tapped the\n               Premier on the shoulder, that the W","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd9aa7f70cf41cb8ee27d585fa9604a4a71c21c287363355012d5cccb36cab6a","f92fb23a760fb74630da4706310640ae830ccd0cae1e1a6ff0f06e4ed0c11950"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["590134a3f47364d779d22d5fd245abdfb4cdf69eb7421b6db2117e5f48e7350a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b61a32ce4c4ed6305408864","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017441,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour to welcome two very special guests here today from the East Kootenay.\n               First of all, Rob Morrison is here, the Member of Parliament for Columbia–Kootenay–Southern Rockies. Mr. Morrison served 35 years in the RCMP, retiring as a chief superintendent. With\n               him today is Wes Graham, his chief of staff, who also serves as a city councillor\n               in Cranbrook. Welcome to both of you today. Thank you for being here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017441","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's an honour to welcome two very special guests here today from the East Kootenay.\n               First of all, Rob Morrison is here, the Member of Parliament for Columbia–Kootenay–Southern Rockies. Mr. Morrison served 35 years in the RCMP, retiring as a chief superintendent. With\n               him today is Wes Graham, his chief of staff, who also serves as a city councillor\n               in C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a935e18b1c28009a82decf255d2e2425d5a6b9a4ae210a7b1f696c545d378a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-352fdacdcf068322b2eb75c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017442,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today we have a delegation from Junior Achievement B.C., a wonderful\n               educational program. They provide support to teachers and school districts throughout\n               the province, teaching entrepreneurship and business skills. I've used them personally;\n               it's free. I just want to speak to all the school districts out there for a second. Reach out\n               to Junior Achievement. They just provide excellent resources Scott McInnis : In the gallery today we have a delegation from Junior Achievement B.C., a wonderful\n               educational program. They provide support to teachers and school districts throughout\n               the province, teaching entrepreneurship and business skills. I've used them personally.\n               It's free. I just want to speak to all the school districts out there for a second. Reach out\n               to Junior Achievement. They just provide excellent resources and supports for teachers. Would the House please make them feel very welcome here today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017442","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery today we have a delegation from Junior Achievement B.C., a wonderful\n               educational program. They provide support to teachers and school districts throughout\n               the province, teaching entrepreneurship and business skills. I've used them personally;\n               it's free. I just want to speak to all the school districts out there for a second. Reach out\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2ca031ae3021d9b3cdaab87f8294fc3adb0e1c62dec204a9ef05ee887f99e8e6","dd28d6f3f0cf7f8a06a9b072db8a4bf3b0997999b0b7a12bf1f498822f8fdb37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bdf4bd2291ccde52eca061bd2d25499b86f8ea40e65063d681c9e53b88e8a64d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07a8fb09a79522f8599b072b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017445,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank goodness for freedom of information. The Public Land Use Society has obtained an FOI that reveals a foundation agreement\n               between the British Columbia government and the Tāłtān Central Government. This agreement involves land transfers, governance restructuring\n               and recognition of Tāłtān My question to the Minister of Indigenous Relations is a very simple one. Is there\n               a completed final agreement which recognizes Tāłtān Aboriginal title in the northwest, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017445","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank goodness for freedom of information. The Public Land Use Society has obtained an FOI that reveals a foundation agreement\n               between the British Columbia government and the Tāłtān Central Government. This agreement involves land transfers, governance restructuring\n               and recognition of Tāłtān My question to the Minister of Indigenous Relations is a very simple one. Is ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0b688442dba492f6f19320b2a9a0b50183d3f3ac96d740485f35916cfa41c45"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d532e1b476233336b37280959ef0957be7a3359b0113a07d3265bbc6ab7df31"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-673d33059d6d712dbd3fb021","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036521,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have three guests in the gallery which I'll introduce briefly. First of all, my\n               beautiful wife, Diana, is here. My dad, Rob McInnis, is here. We have a friend, an\n               absolute legend from Kimberley here — Jim Boudreau, better known as Boots. He's one\n               of the best golfers in the area. At 69, he shot his age. At 73, he shot his age. I'm\n               not going to say how old he is this year, but I think he's got a shot at doing it\n               again. Would the House please make them all feel very welcome. He is one of the best golfers in the area. At 69, he shot his age. At 73, he shot\n               his age. I'm not going to say how old he is this year, but I think he's got a shot\n               at doing it again. Would the House please make them all feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036521","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have three guests in the gallery which I'll introduce briefly. First of all, my\n               beautiful wife, Diana, is here. My dad, Rob McInnis, is here. We have a friend, an\n               absolute legend from Kimberley here — Jim Boudreau, better known as Boots. He's one\n               of the best golfers in the area. At 69, he shot his age. At 73, he shot his age. I'm\n               not go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6758b48fd16203eb2acd6cc888e955d63c96ae43d4bb3b8f0592313bfc913cca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-992a71e6a33c6e40de176be4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036522,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my understanding that Mr. Stephen Bagan is here from Oak Bay High School with\n               21 students in grade 10. Mr. Bagan has deep roots in Columbia River–Revelstoke — especially with my predecessor, the MLA there. I just wanted to welcome Mr. Bagan and all the students here this afternoon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036522","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my understanding that Mr. Stephen Bagan is here from Oak Bay High School with\n               21 students in grade 10. Mr. Bagan has deep roots in Columbia River–Revelstoke — especially with my predecessor, the MLA there. I just wanted to welcome Mr. Bagan and all the students here this afternoon.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ffad278e01743f4396d4f074e3bc09c00a08941fe0004a3435c9c8aa30b48ade"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e73ed7fbda759ab628d073a681a44406cea83a674af52c941789fb5458229ac8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d8c01270138233cf5a8bb83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036523,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Scott McInnis","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to take a moment this morning to highlight something that is absolutely vital\n               to our community in Columbia River–Revelstoke: the Fairmont Hot Springs airport and the amazing volunteers which operate it. This isn't just a runway; it's a lifeline. The airport plays a critical role in emergency response across the Columbia Valley. Whether it's medevac flights transporting patients to urgent care, Angel Flights, firefighting aircraft responding to wildfires, or search and rescue teams reaching those in danger, this airport saves lives. It operates in all seasons, ensuring that when minutes matter, help can arrive without\n               delay. Its location is strategic. It provides access that cannot be replicated anywhere\n               else in the region, cutting response times and improving outcomes for residents across\n               the valley. But what truly makes this airport exceptional is not just the infrastructure. It's\n               the people behind it. The Columbia Valley airport society is entirely volunteer run. Think about that. A group of dedicated local residents that gives their time, day in and day out, to keep this essential service operating. They fuel planes, maintain facilities, support pilots and handle the countless small,\n               often unseen tasks that keep everything running smoothly. These volunteers stretch every dollar,\n               maximize limited resources, and quietly ensure that this community asset continues\n               to serve all of us. Our community recognizes this importance. The overwhelming majority of residents view\n               this airport as absolutely essential. Today we thank you. Thank you to the volunteers. Thank you to those who support and\n               advocate for this airport. I encourage anybody who is able to come out to the society's\n               pancake breakfast and air show this year on September 12. They put on a great air\n               show, and the flapjacks are top-notch. If you have an airplane, you can always fly\n               in too. Let's continue to stand behind this incredible asset and the people who make this\n               possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036523","member_id":"bc-mla-364","member_name":"Scott McInnis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to take a moment this morning to highlight something that is absolutely vital\n               to our community in Columbia River–Revelstoke: the Fairmont Hot Springs airport and the amazing volunteers which operate it. This isn't just a runway; it's a lifeline. The airport plays a critical role in emergency response across the Columbia Valley. Whether it's medevac flights transporting patien","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","label":"Aircraft"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","label":"Airplanes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","label":"Airplanes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","label":"Aircraft","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6d5e7a20fe0a08067f9eb3d9b46d61ab989f10f23cb9525d6fb75d1b7ee2518"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a260f2ba183d6f912b24fdbbde51888f91b9869d712c7bd6fa2b01d70f7160ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3fb8f1bc8d2f610b1fea62d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316796,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Citizens' Services and reports progress on the Ministry of Attorney\n               General and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316796","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Citizens' Services and reports progress on the Ministry of Attorney\n               General and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc61ea34b69dac97346cfc5bea91e0c72493950d5b5bc6838477f75630adbb7f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-551efdebf93f800bcae66b7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327915,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"There have been some challenges in the world lately, and our hearts go out to all\n               those here, at home and across the world who are facing the most difficult of times.\n               We wish them safety and peace for themselves and their families. We grieve for them\n               and hold harder to the sacred trust to provide welcoming, safe spaces for young people\n               to find their paths in life. In my riding just this last month, there were so many reasons to be proud of the young\n               people of Coquitlam-Maillardville. Charles Best Secondary, I have been incredibly impressed with the work of your youth\n               action team and the collaboration in your school to help support our unhoused community\n               members. Not only did the youth action team collect a warm-weather clothing drive,\n               but the culinary program at Charles Best is making two meals a week for the people\n               who are staying overnight at a local shelter and looking to do more. Congratulations, I think, just like everyone else in this entire House, to my Centennial\n               Secondary grade 9 boys basketball team, provincial champions in their division. I was just at the Gleneagle Secondary jazz gala, a fundraising event that brings together\n               the musical talent, so strong, and the equally impressive talent in their cooking\n               program — an evening spent listening to an orange-coloured sky with some fantastic\n               chicken parm. I walked out singing, and I haven't stopped. The actions of these secondary school students does us all proud — working hard to\n               achieve their goals, becoming better artists, better athletes, better people. Along\n               with that pride, there is a deep gratitude for the opportunity we have created here\n               in British Columbia, in Canada, for them to have the resources and support to make\n               their dreams possible. May every bright success make us more committed to ensuring that every child has the\n               same opportunities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327915","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"There have been some challenges in the world lately, and our hearts go out to all\n               those here, at home and across the world who are facing the most difficult of times.\n               We wish them safety and peace for themselves and their families. We grieve for them\n               and hold harder to the sacred trust to provide welcoming, safe spaces for young people\n               to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","label":"Secondary education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","label":"Secondary education","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77ce66bd19858e99f33b260c292afa17a435173b682c6c398118cacde083b486"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78f70695564e5e5aabe2d71dc2e39830f1b9e384b3bb7177dc04c3b3c25fd135"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2480ccbd81a7ede24827a243","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327916,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am rising today to support Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, and I want\n               to thank the Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General for bringing this forward\n               and her staff for making such careful amendments. This change to the Civil Forfeiture Act will streamline processes and ensure more\n               funds are returned to the community. Since its inception, the CFO has forfeited over\n               $221 million. Approximately half of the funds from all forfeitures go back into B.C.\n               communities. The civil forfeiture grant program provides one-time funding to support community-safety-related\n               initiatives across this province. Funding is allocated through streams chosen on an\n               annual basis that align with government priorities. These funding streams include\n               priority areas that matter deeply to me in my role as Parliamentary Secretary of Gender\n               Equity. The civil forfeiture office's largest funding stream is focused on preventing and\n               responding to gender-based violence. The gender-based violence funding stream provides\n               grants that develop or enhance culturally relevant, culturally safe and trauma-informed\n               responses to gender-based violence in communities across our province. This includes\n               projects that address domestic violence, sexual assault, sex trafficking, sexual exploitation,\n               including online child sexual exploitation, sex worker safety and helping those who\n               are wanting to exit from sex work and taking broad action to address gender-based\n               violence, including through providing stable funding to sexual assault response services. This includes programs to support victims of gender-based violence, like No Pet Left\n               Behind, run by the Paws for Hope Animal Foundation in Maple Ridge. This program provides\n               crisis foster care for pets of women fleeing domestic violence. We know that animal abuse is present in nearly 90 percent of domestic violence cases.\n               The fear is real, and so is the love people feel for their pets, and abusers will\n               use that fear to control their target. Recognizing that pets are a vital emotional support but that the fear for the pet\n               and the worries around finding a new living situation that's appropriate for their\n               whole entire family, including their four-legged friend, can pose a barrier to leaving\n               abusive situations, the program offers free, confidential foster placements for pets\n               while women access shelter, rebuild stability and secure permanent housing, so women\n               and their families can escape violence without having to worry about their animals. If you live in Metro Vancouver or the Fraser region, Paws for Hope is looking for\n               foster homes. Operating province-wide in partnership with the Ending Violence Association of B.C.\n               and the B.C. Society of Transition Houses, the program will cover all pet-related\n               needs, including food, supplies and veterinary care. Since its inception, No Pet Left\n               Behind has supported nearly 300 women, 425 children and 400 pets across British Columbia,\n               offering critical peace of mind and empowering women to seek safety and healing. Amy FitzGerald, executive director of B.C. Society of Transition Houses, has this\n               to say about No Pet Left Behind: \"Women who once thought they couldn't leave violence\n               as they would never leave their pets behind now can leave safely, knowing that their\n               companion animals will accompany them and find shelter.\" Let me speak about another project that's making a direct impact on exploited youth.\n               In Vancouver, Covenant House's supporting homeless exploited youth project is making\n               a real difference. It's making youth safer. The project engaged 70 trafficked and\n               exploited youth, ages 16 to 24, who were either unhoused or at risk of being unhoused.\n               A social worker connects with every single one of the youth and supports their needs\n               across a continuum of care. Projects from United for Literacy in Surrey and VI Counselling Centre for Immigrants\n               and Refugees provide supports for mothers and children living in transition homes\n               while fleeing domestic violence. During that same time, the civil forfeiture office provided nearly $500,000, half\n               a million dollars, to the domestic violence prevention and intervention program, providing\n               grants to support the direct delivery of group-based programming for individuals who\n               use violence in intimate partner relationships. The focus is on offering programming prior to the charge, conviction and sentencing\n               stage of the criminal justice process. These initiatives aim to enhance the safety\n               and well-being of victims who have experience or who are at risk of experiencing domestic\n               violence. Projects like Nicola Family Therapy's men's counselling program, delivering trauma-based\n               counselling sessions for men-identified people who have used Also including the Become the Change project run by the Canadian Mental Health Association\n               in Williams Lake. BTC is a psychoeducational group program for adults aged 18 plus\n               who are at risk or have previously perpetrated domestic violence. The program helps\n               participants recognize harmful behaviours, develop healthier relationship skills and\n               foster accountability in a supportive group setting. Delivered in partnership with organizations like the Ministry of Children and Family Development and First Nations communities, BTC continues to grow in demand with wait-lists forming\n               before sessions are posted. Many participants encourage others, including partners,\n               to attend BTC or its companion program, Growth for a New Beginning. The program's\n               growing regional reputation has led to recent outreach to First Nations women, setting\n               the stage for further expansion. The updated strategy includes actions that were identified by and for Indigenous people,\n               reflecting their priorities and unique needs related to poverty reduction, including\n               economic, social and cultural development. In Smithers, the Northern Society for Domestic Peace operates the Domestic Peace program,\n               which helps break the cycles of violence by offering counselling to adult clients\n               who are at risk to use violence. The program's goal is to assist men in making choices\n               that lead to a healthier, more respectful way of living and being in relationship\n               with others. The program's goal is to help men who wish to change. They can choose to stop their\n               abusive behaviours. The program can also support with coping with separation and divorce,\n               healing past abuse, and parenting. It's so important to ensure that services are available across this province. Organizations\n               like Agassiz-Harrison Community Services that provide support services, service navigation\n               and therapy services to the underserved area of Agassiz and Harrison, a rural location\n               with no transition houses, hospital, legal or established victim services. The civil forfeiture office has an Indigenous healing funding stream that awarded\n               $1,430,156 for 37 projects. The Indigenous healing fund provides grants to support\n               healing of Indigenous people from impacts of intergenerational trauma, crime or victimization\n               in communities across British Columbia. Projects focus on healing approaches reflective\n               and/or aligned with Indigenous culture and world views, including healing for the\n               individual, the family and the broader community; emotional, mental, physical and\n               spiritual aspects of healing; and other culturally identified practices that contribute\n               to the path forward. One of these programs is the resiliency program, a provincewide initiative delivered\n               by Pacifica Treatment Centre Society. It provides individuals from Indigenous communities\n               who are undergoing treatment for substance use disorders with essential skills and\n               coping strategies. In this last year, they integrated resiliency practices into their Indigenous treatment\n               services through the 2024 Resilience Project. This engaged 68 clients in biweekly\n               healing circles led by Elders and Indigenous alumni, emphasizing strength, connection,\n               harmony and cultural renewal. In Salmon Arm, Rise Up Indigenous Wellness Society was awarded funds for their Peaceful\n               Warriors program, a decolonized, trauma-informed mentorship program designed to prevent\n               sexual and domestic violence by mentoring Indigenous boys aged 8 to 11 through traditional\n               teachings that foster kindness, empathy and respect. Grounded in Indigenous knowledge and social-emotional learning, the nine-week program\n               delivers culturally relevant lessons. Focused on youth working together to set up\n               tents in a forested area, they spend that time out in the woods, out in the wilderness,\n               out on the land, connecting in real time, fostering social development, emotional\n               accountability and identity. Developed in collaboration with Indigenous community members, sessions are guided\n               by local traditions and values. Early outcomes show strong participant engagement\n               and growth in empathy, self-awareness and cultural connection. The program envisions\n               broader impact through future expansion into other Indigenous communities, promoting\n               healing and violence prevention across generations. The impact is felt by participants and their families together. One mother said: \"I'm\n               so happy for my son to have participated in Peaceful Warriors. As a single mom, it's\n               difficult to share what it means to be a respectful man for my son.\" Peaceful Warriors facilitator Scott had this to say about the program: \"I wished I\n               had something like this when I was a kid, especially because I didn't have a father\n               figure. Peaceful Warriors taught the boys life skills, and as a facilitator, I was\n               able to model those skills.\" Not only does the civil forfeiture office return money through grants, but it has\n               established the victim compensation program to provide financial assistance to Not only does the civil forfeiture office return money through grants, but it has\n               established the victim compensation program to provide financial assistance to individuals\n               who have suffered a financial loss due to unlawful activity linked to property forfeited\n               by the civil forfeiture office. To date, approximately $1.7 million has been distributed\n               to support eligible victims across B.C. Bill 8 introduces new measures to cut costs and protect asset value, including a presumption\n               of vehicle depreciation to allow for earlier liquidation. This means greater value\n               for forfeited items and more money returned to the community through grants. As I mentioned earlier, about half of the funds received from forfeiture go back to\n               B.C. communities. So how do we maximize the benefit to British Columbians? How can\n               we improve this process? Currently, more than 8 in every ten civil forfeiture cases\n               are uncontested and result in a default judgment. Even though most cases are uncontested,\n               they require a full hearing, consuming valuable court time and legal resources. Bill 8 changes the default order power to quicken uncontested cases while preserving\n               judicial discretion. This change speeds up the process, and the province is able to\n               liquidate forfeitures before their value depreciates while simultaneously reducing\n               labour costs associated with long, uncontested hearings. Bill 8 also introduces the presumption of vehicle depreciation. Vehicles can sit in\n               storage for months or years, losing value and costing the program hundreds of thousands\n               of dollars annually. Currently, the act does not require judges to consider depreciation\n               or storage costs, so by the time a case concludes, the vehicle's value could be gone.\n               This presumption is consistent with best practices in other jurisdictions internationally. The presumption prompts courts to consider early liquidation. This is intended to\n               reduce storage costs, preserve value and ensure proceeds can be reinvested in community\n               safety. This doesn't mean that judges lose authority to decide on sale on forfeited\n               vehicles. Presumption simply informs the court's decision. Judges retain full discretion\n               to refuse sale where fairness requires. While Bill 8 streamlines liquidation of forfeited assets, it also extends statutory\n               timelines from 30 to 60 days. This is beneficial to the system because the current\n               30-day window is too short for complex cases, and we need more time. Extending timelines\n               aligns B.C. with other provinces and improves accuracy. Mistakes in the proceedings\n               can result in longer cases or reversal of forfeiture. The goal is to reduce error\n               and ensure lawful retention of property. The amendments improve fairness and reduce\n               procedural challenge, ensuring property is held under lawful authority while giving\n               people a fair chance to respond. Providing supports to victims and the community is only one aspect of civil forfeiture.\n               The civil forfeiture office is giving our province one more tool to combat crime in\n               our communities. The province will continue to go after gangs, guns and toxic drugs\n               that are hurting loved ones, taking away their illegally acquired assets and protect\n               British Columbians. Funds gained from liquidated assets are distributed to the crime prevention funding\n               stream from the civil forfeiture office. The civil forfeiture office awarded $1,643,328\n               to 44 projects dedicated to crime prevention. No one should be able to lure young\n               people into criminal activity with promises of material goods and quick money. These\n               initiatives focus on preventing criminal activity through direct interventions for\n               vulnerable individuals at risk of criminal activities and behaviour. We know that many can see criminal activities as a way out of poverty. In my home\n               city of Coquitlam, the Low Entropy Foundation was awarded $40,000 to run the thrift\n               and thrive youth internship program. This initiative targets approximately 30 youth\n               aged 16 to 24 who are at risk and equip them with practical job skills, soft skills,\n               and financial literacy through hands-on experience at a thrift store. I want to recognize\n               the hard work of the volunteers and the staff. I have spent many hours with you and\n               really appreciated the work that you do with the youth, bringing them forward into\n               a new life where they can choose their path. As you can see, the Civil Forfeiture Act already makes a big impact in supporting\n               the community, And this legislation will ensure B.C.'s civil forfeiture office can\n               continue to take the profit out of unlawful activity, prevent property from being\n               used to cause harm, and support victims and crime prevention. For these reasons, I wholeheartedly support Bill 8 and thank the minister and her\n               team for bringing it forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327916","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am rising today to support Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, and I want\n               to thank the Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General for bringing this forward\n               and her staff for making such careful amendments. This change to the Civil Forfeiture Act will streamline processes and ensure more\n               funds are returned to the community. Since its incep","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["24b4934e8784d4b390e685d4705c3f16953c7fed0faef8f4f903cd3474748491"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5d2038aa16e3266df7130462a45ed6ec5d770caa7796745e45177f459ea2647"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a7c3920c2ad006609c55e82f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327917,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am here today to speak in support of Bill 2. Our budget does not pretend the world is easy. It recognizes fiscal constraint and\n               the enormous challenge of a much smaller working generation supporting our parents\n               as they age and need more complex care. We simultaneously also need to invest in the future of the young people of this province,\n               especially with training that allows them to create a stable life here. This budget\n               eyes the challenges honestly and chooses stability, fairness and long-term strength\n               for British Columbia. It's not a budget crafted in comfort or a time of global abundance. Each line recognizes\n               a time of uncertainty — economic, environmental, geopolitical and social. We hear in our offices every day the struggles and successes of our constituents.\n               Our neighbours. We hear about the effect of tariffs, we see the changes in We hear in our offices every day of the struggles and successes of our constituents,\n               our neighbours. We hear about the effect of tariffs. We see the changes in people's\n               everyday choices. Their choice is to buy and support Canadian, to buy local, to ensure\n               that we stay strong. I'm so heartened when I go to local farmers markets, the restaurants in my area, the\n               small local businesses, and I see more of my neighbours than ever before continuing\n               to invest dollars back into our province, with their choices, to ensure that we choose\n               Canadian. Sometimes those choices are hard: \"Made in Canada,\" \"Grown in B.C.\" Looking\n               for those labels means we need to take time, make the effort and vote carefully with\n               our limited budgets. Each individual choice is a powerful investment in B.C.'s future.\n               Thank you. This budget recognizes the difficulty of those hard-thought, careful choices and respects\n               them. Here's what we know. We cannot ruthlessly cut our way to a stronger province.\n               On the other hand, borrowing has consequences, even if those funds are investments\n               in capital projects and in people that are growing our province. It's reasonable and\n               prudent to sustain services for our province, our businesses, our non-profits and\n               our people. We defend our core services and discipline the spending. This budget tells the story of global economic uncertainty, our changing alliances\n               and our commitment to forge our way through to the future by strengthening international\n               relationships with our long-standing partners and reaching out to create new paths\n               with our newer allies. Across the globe, we see slower economic growth, shaped internationally\n               by trade uncertainty, war and the ongoing climate crisis. Here in B.C., we have localized challenges that we must respond to: the stresses created\n               by reduced federal immigration targets and rising borrowing costs worldwide. The budget\n               must also grapple with the rising cost of debt. Every dollar spent on interest is\n               a dollar not spent on nurses, teachers or public safety. The budget maintains front-line\n               core services in health care, education and social services, while making deliberate,\n               thoughtful choices to slow spending growth, modernize revenue and protect the front\n               line. This budget demonstrates a commitment: front-line services will be protected at levels\n               comparable to pre-pandemic benchmarks, even as economic seas become rougher. That\n               means concrete investments in the supports that protect us here in B.C. Over $2.8\n               billion in new funding, over three years, is directed to strengthening health care,\n               expanding capacity, supporting workforce recruitment and improving access to mental\n               health and addictions treatment. We will keep connecting people to family doctors and nurse practitioners. Back in\n               2010, under the previous government, there was a promise that everyone would have\n               a family doctor by 2015. I want to acknowledge that there was, at the time, an enormous\n               and complex challenge in growing and expanding our health care system. Personnel were retiring in an unprecedented wave. As the pattern of service of medical\n               professionals changed, the dominant age demographic was beginning to shift from working-age\n               adults to seniors. The province was becoming increasingly urbanized, but rural, remote\n               and northern areas still needed support, services and connections. All of those challenges\n               meant that the previous government could not complete their promise. By the time they\n               left government in 2017, there were 900,000 people — close to a million people — without\n               a doctor, some 250,000 more people without a doctor than before they made that promise. I wish they had succeeded, because that would have been good for all people here in\n               British Columbia. It was a tough challenge, and the past plan didn't work, but now\n               in 2026, every single one of those challenges has intensified. We now have a higher\n               proportion of seniors than at any other time in our history, plus there is now a global\n               shortage of health care workers, with other provinces and countries competing fiercely\n               for the same pool of doctors, nurses and health care professionals. Yet even with all of those challenges, let me talk about what is working: the current\n               plan. Under this government, B.C. is succeeding. We are turning a corner. We have\n               attached a record number of people to family doctors. In 2024, we attached a record\n               number of 250,000 people, outpacing the population growth of 167,000. Some 4,000 people\n               are connected each week, which is a 52 percent increase from the previous year. Additionally, more than 850 new family doctors have been added since the launch of\n               the new physician pay model in 2023. We now have the most doctors per capita of any\n               province in Canada, with more on the way. We will keep going. Of that $2.8 billion, $131 million is specifically dedicated to evidence-based mental\n               health and addictions services, helping ensure that we are able to support the most\n               vulnerable people in this province. Health care matters, and education matters. Health care matters and education matters. For families and children, we will spend\n               $634 million over three years strengthening K-to-12 education, hiring more classroom\n               teachers, special education teachers, counsellors and psychologists. We know how important it is for families to have safe, accessible and affordable child\n               care. We want parents to be able to choose to participate in our economy, so this\n               budget commits $330 million to maintain affordable child care fees and support operators\n               and educators. These historic and ongoing investments in child care have allowed thousands\n               and thousands of women to choose to join the workforce. In the last quarter of 2025, over 900 new child care spaces opened all across this\n               province. Here are some: Burnaby, 74 spaces, including 24 for infant and toddlers;\n               Courtenay, 31 spaces, including 15 for infant and toddler; Douglas First Nation, 46\n               spaces; Kelowna, 48 spaces; Langley, 72 spaces; Maple Ridge, 110 spaces; Merritt,\n               76; North Van, 37; Skatin, 26; Sooke, 37; Sorrento, 56; Surrey, 80; Vancouver, 32 spaces and Victoria, 224 spaces.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327917","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am here today to speak in support of Bill 2. Our budget does not pretend the world is easy. It recognizes fiscal constraint and\n               the enormous challenge of a much smaller working generation supporting our parents\n               as they age and need more complex care. We simultaneously also need to invest in the future of the young people of this province,\n               especially w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8939015b947e57c1e4aceff4ed27aa235c7ce03410b3d17c59075b14a7aa4cac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f1d68b2766481cb3976131b8559a0d0422c5477d79f1b5f35b35f682de21611"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-236bfe7df421fa608d410c37","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359628,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I had a speech prepared for International Women's Day, but this morning I had the\n               privilege of meeting with a bunch of women who work deeply in women's health research.\n               They reminded me that, in fact, this is women's health research month. I would like to acknowledge those women who visited us here today to speak so knowledgeably\n               and deeply about their work: Dr. Jen Gunter, Dr. Gina Ogilvie and Dr. Lori Brotto\n               from the Women's Health Research Institute of British Columbia, and Dr. Laura Schummers,\n               who is a reproductive epidemiologist. And I hope So I would like to acknowledge those women who visited us here today to speak so knowledgeably\n               and deeply about their work: Dr. Jen Gunter, Dr. Gina Ogilvie and Dr. Lori Brotto\n               from the Women's Health Research Institute of British Columbia and Dr. Laura Schummers,\n               who is a reproductive epidemiologist. I hope that you hear some of your words in my words today and know that both the Minister\n               of Health and I listened so carefully to what you had to say, because it was for the\n               good of all women and all people in British Columbia. One of the things that we are so fortunate to have in British Columbia is a unified\n               system of research. If you swim in other systems, if you live in other systems, where\n               research is not unified across your jurisdiction, you know how challenging it is to\n               receive a unified theory of care, especially around women's health. Women's health has only been a focus in research and medicine for the last 25 years.\n               Women were not equitably included in health care studies. Women were not even thought\n               of when drugs were designed and systems of care were implemented. Over the last two\n               decades, we've seen significant changes, but there's still more to do. We know that, broadly, women receive less than 7 percent of the health care focus\n               when it comes to dollars, despite the fact that women are 50 percent of the population.\n               And we know that when women receive the care that they need, it benefits not just\n               them, not just British Columbia and the societies in which they live. We know that\n               women take care of everyone else in their lives. We know that it changes the health\n               outcomes of the children in their lives as well. There's a real practical basis to caring for women. They need the things in their\n               lives — the medication, the health care and the supports — that allow them to continue\n               to raise their children, to care for elders, to continue with their careers and make\n               the lives they choose. And in British Columbia, they have a better chance to do that\n               than almost anywhere else in the world. In January of 2024, British Columbia was the first province in Canada to launch a\n               cervix self-screening program. Now, this means that women who don't have access to\n               health care because they have to work, they have to take care of their kids, they\n               live in areas where it's difficult to access a gynecologist or even a family doctor\n               can do their screening right in their own home and get those results. And because\n               now we have an improved test, we know that we can spread that test from three years\n               to five and get the same and even better high-quality results. Between February 2024 and November of 2025, 230,000 cervix self-screening kits have\n               been mailed to eligible patients. British Columbia was the first jurisdiction in Canada\n               to provide free prescription birth control. Since it was introduced on April 1, 2023,\n               approximately 394,000 people in British Columbia have benefited from this policy. We have seen a 49 percent increase in long-term reversible reproductive health care\n               uptake. That means for methods of birth control like IUDs and implantable birth control,\n               there were women who were not getting that birth control because cost was a barrier,\n               and now that has been removed. We can do more. There are women, especially youth in British Columbia, who have no\n               idea that this program exists. So please take the time to share this information with\n               the young people especially in your lives. It will help them save thousands of dollars\n               a year, hundreds of dollars a year, and it will help make an enormous change to the\n               rest of their life if they can choose the timing of when they reproduce. In June of 2023, the province also expanded the pharmacists' scope of practice so\n               they could provide contraception. We've also improved access to IUDs and cervical\n               anesthetic by increasing physician compensation for those procedures. We've launched\n               the province's first publicly funded in vitro fertilization program, with more than\n               1,600 individuals and couples approved for funding this fiscal year, with more applications\n               still in process. These are the practical steps we have taken. We have taken them for British Columbians,\n               and we will continue to advance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359628","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I had a speech prepared for International Women's Day, but this morning I had the\n               privilege of meeting with a bunch of women who work deeply in women's health research.\n               They reminded me that, in fact, this is women's health research month. I would like to acknowledge those women who visited us here today to speak so knowledgeably\n               and deeply about their ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f4367c85cfb1e109ae999a0fe1e78295ad6065b310a9baaf3a0946055199ae94"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43852e2be3d40cc7ca2bc6a3a4395e9cb7a30554b8a98bc1edfd3c8e3795998b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38ce110f0c8fc2df63063167","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359629,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Housing and Municipal Affairs and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359629","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Housing and Municipal Affairs and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fea2ae1c0ea0761143e46c21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359630,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"On March 20, British Columbia will join voices around the world to celebrate la Journée internationale de la francophonie. French speakers around the province link us to a global francophone family that connects\n               us to a larger cultural story. I would like to thank the members of the international and Canadian francophone family\n               for reaching out to us to express their sorrow and offer their condolences after the\n               tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. At noon, we'll gather in the Hall of Honour to celebrate this occasion together. As\n               you know, each year the province highlights a particular theme. This year's theme,\n               \"Le français pour la vie,\" underscores how French is important at all life stages, beginning in early childhood\n               with parents, grandparents and caregivers, libraries, community hubs and schools,\n               and continuing into young adulthood through opportunities such as Le Parlement Jeunesse Francophone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359630","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"On March 20, British Columbia will join voices around the world to celebrate la Journée internationale de la francophonie. French speakers around the province link us to a global francophone family that connects\n               us to a larger cultural story. I would like to thank the members of the international and Canadian francophone family\n               for reaching out to us to express their ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d445390d712d64a186d8897e122c679189e8a20999d5e19113d8ff3ab2e73b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9012014f02fb40539741614f8a63e91cd77298931d07370b600fc7be6d8d8d1e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8125387d3173db4af149e16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413655,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we celebrate Transgender Day of Visibility and the achievements of transgender,\n               Two-Spirit and non-binary people. This is the first year that B.C. is officially proclaiming\n               March 31 as the Transgender Day of Visibility in honour of the more than 18,000 transgender,\n               Two-Spirit and non-binary people living in our province. In recognition of the significant contributions of transgender, non-binary, Two-Spirit\n               people to this province, I am proud to stand firmly with them and affirm my belief\n               in a British Columbia that values diversity, recognizes strength and upholds dignity\n               and belonging for all of us. Visibility matters. Everyone deserves to see themselves and their contributions represented\n               in their communities, and we all benefit when people can be their most authentic selves.\n               This day serves as an opportunity to uplift transgender, Two-Spirit and non-binary\n               people and their accomplishments in every part of our society, from the sciences,\n               to the arts, to health care, to business, to education, to social services and beyond. Today is also a reminder that not all transgender, Two-Spirit and non-binary people\n               are free to live their lives safely. Many still face hate and discrimination on an\n               ongoing basis and struggle to access the life-saving health care and supports that\n               they need. The rights of people to live safely are not up for negotiation in British\n               Columbia. This day affirms and reaffirms that we are committed to continuing to remove\n               systemic barriers, addressing transphobia, delivering inclusive programs and supports\n               and upholding the rights of transgender, Two-Spirit and non-binary people. On this day of transgender visibility, I call on everyone in British Columbia to come\n               together to celebrate our diversity and to continue to make our province safer and\n               more welcoming for every single person.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413655","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today we celebrate Transgender Day of Visibility and the achievements of transgender,\n               Two-Spirit and non-binary people. This is the first year that B.C. is officially proclaiming\n               March 31 as the Transgender Day of Visibility in honour of the more than 18,000 transgender,\n               Two-Spirit and non-binary people living in our province. In recognition of the sign","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","label":"Queer people"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","label":"Gender-nonconforming people"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","label":"2SLGBTQI+ people"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","label":"Gender-nonconforming people","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","label":"Queer people","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["29f2816fdd134f92cc7465577b98b585625a8ccde74c176115181a7b5cb67661"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["307a89686c6a4a5c75ee1242ee2e3342552b8b20faf466ef049980d06c6ab639"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Queer people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"2SLGBTQI+ people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036844","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501131","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d52844917daa1a7e881263c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413656,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports Bill 8 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413656","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section C reports Bill 8 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49feb65f405356e7f86cafeb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413657,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports Bill 13 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413657","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports Bill 13 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c52026dac7cc035e16d0d820","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720123,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the pleasure of introducing one union member, but this one belongs to me. It\n               is the president of the Coquitlam-Maillardville first husbands club, my husband, David Blatherwick. May the House make him welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720123","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have the pleasure of introducing one union member, but this one belongs to me. It\n               is the president of the Coquitlam-Maillardville first husbands club, my husband, David Blatherwick. May the House make him welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99fdeeefbadf594e1446d0b7dc78e68b255a5fc40d801cbdb465e1f437eb0b21"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f38931e4692781fe0900662","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720126,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the honour of not introducing any dignitaries but people who are incredibly\n               important to me. Would the House please make welcome my parents, Bill and Cindy Brooks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720126","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have the honour of not introducing any dignitaries but people who are incredibly\n               important to me. Would the House please make welcome my parents, Bill and Cindy Brooks.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2933b3bf5cda70cb3a8c4653526169fd6983ee6d352a5a788d7f215f0f98d831"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a02d187b13aa2b6784f4ed1807cb9434fa1e25bd3e572eb44097c1aaf5a15061"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f16c0c101cb83567ca253c9e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720127,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports Bill 15 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720127","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports Bill 15 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-074b3cc3179fa39eeee14b03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721201,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is always good to sound wise in our statements to the House, even if we have to\n               borrow a little wisdom from others, so I'd like to quote Hank Green: \"Bad news happens\n               all at once, but good news happens slowly.\" In that quote he was discussing the enormous\n               improvement, the determined improvement in health care over the last century that's\n               led to so many children becoming physically healthier. But I think it equally applies\n               to the steady improvement in our treatment and awareness of mental health for children\n               and youth. Now we all speak about this. You hear about it in the news, you hear about it in this\n               House, and you hear about it in the community. But we weren't always so supportive.\n               And here I want to raise up the work of one of the pioneers in my community, Diane\n               Thorne, who was a past MLA in this House but before Now we all speak about this. You hear about it in the news, you hear about it in this\n               House and you hear about it in the community. But we weren't always so supportive. Here, I want to raise up the work of one of the pioneers in my community, Diane Thorne,\n               who was a past MLA in this House. Before she was an MLA, she was a determined mother\n               and a determined community advocate, who managed to work with non-profits in our community\n               and get $1 million of funding for youth housing from the federal government back in\n               1992, when $1 million was a big deal. But the community reception was very negative. She received threats, both at her work\n               and at her home. In the end, the community organization she partnered with had to\n               give the money back. Community resistance to any program supporting youth was very\n               negative. Today, things are different. In our province, there is a broad, sustained improvement\n               for youth mental health: the Foundry. If you've heard me talk about it before, be\n               prepared to hear me talk about it again and again. I am planning to get a tattoo. Foundry can be reached from anywhere in this province, online. Youth and their caregivers\n               living in British Columbia can access free mental health and wellness information,\n               supports and same-day services virtually from the Foundry app. The system is real,\n               it is staffed by qualified professionals and it is free for youth and caregivers in\n               British Columbia. Last month I was there when the new Tri-Cities Foundry opened its doors to provide\n               a wide spectrum of in-person supports. This new, modern centre is open to the young\n               people of the Tri-Cities and the surrounding areas, ensuring that youth aged 12 to\n               24 and their families can get help when they need it. The new Tri-Cities Foundry will be operated by SHARE Family and Community Services\n               society with ongoing funding from the provincial government as part of our commitment\n               to expand responsive wraparound care for youth. The Foundry model brings together\n               government services and non-profits to break down those barriers and ensure services\n               are centred on each youth, meeting them where they are. The services at our Tri-Cities Foundry will be delivered in partnership with organizations\n               like the Fraser Health Authority, ACCESS Youth Outreach Services, NaloxHome society,\n               school district 43, the Ministry of Children and Family Development, Douglas College,\n               the Fraser Northwest Division of Family Practice and other community partners. I've been very privileged to work with many of the organizations under this umbrella,\n               and I recognize their long commitment to meeting youth in the community and helping\n               them however they can. I have seen you develop food programs for youth to teach them how to cook. I have\n               seen you sit through art projects while you have discussed the most difficult topics\n               and the hardest thing that could happen in a youth's life. I have seen you support\n               them into jobs, into housing, back into education and back into community, where they\n               belong. I raise my hands to you for your work. You are on the ground, you are on a bus, you\n               are out there at night, you are in the rain, you are there with those kids, helping\n               them walk along the path to better health. There is no replacement for a hand held\n               out to someone who is in trouble, and you do that. We thank you. When young people go through a difficult time, they can rely on the Foundry centres\n               to connect them with free counselling services. Counselling can help people, the young\n               people of our province, see their own strengths and figure out who they are, figure\n               out their goals while honouring the individual's values, beliefs and identity. Those Foundry centres can provide meaningful peer-to-peer supports for young people\n               to feel seen and heard and less alone. Centres organize events for young people throughout\n               our community to meet and learn new skills in supportive environments. Make sure the youth in your community know the Foundry exists, that it is there —\n               it is there for them, it is there for their families and it is there for their friends.\n               When I say that good news happens slowly, I don't mean that the implementation happens\n               slowly...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721201","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is always good to sound wise in our statements to the House, even if we have to\n               borrow a little wisdom from others, so I'd like to quote Hank Green: \"Bad news happens\n               all at once, but good news happens slowly.\" In that quote he was discussing the enormous\n               improvement, the determined improvement in health care over the last century that's\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aa0af715ab59311ea8a1518d45321f7b4242af20b4306db02e47cfcbd395446c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abc848e9d136dc79cd3ffa5396855ca48b8d6f5688a1353895acc40c522abc50"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-515e523457f69345c0a12a5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721202,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness and the Ministry of Environment and Parks and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721202","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness and the Ministry of Environment and Parks and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fab04a29a57fa56efd3039f45eb56472a8aadb85b32a88dd64d4ab2f2d73e96c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56e616bad4f8d9aaa405dff7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721204,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721204","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75a0288a5eafe9fa9d08ac390053c03ce720077a78685375d61ef67767c17357"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30db2043915269cf4a9b66be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728794,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have been considering this motion for a while and its effort to help increase the\n               broad base of knowledge for members of this House, and I agree. I would like to move an amendment to the motion. Do I directly read the text to the\n               motion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728794","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have been considering this motion for a while and its effort to help increase the\n               broad base of knowledge for members of this House, and I agree. I would like to move an amendment to the motion. Do I directly read the text to the\n               motion?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","label":"Vaccination","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["07c78d63e125208bc0d34ec45c0bc8eff4c1aec2ba463c5e25356e681f0046ea"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e830b91233d4fdacccdca93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728804,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to have the House welcome someone who is very close to me, my constituency\n               assistant, Adrian Watson-Babij, who is here this week, enjoying Victoria and watching\n               our debates and conversations very closely in the House. If we could all make him feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728804","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to have the House welcome someone who is very close to me, my constituency\n               assistant, Adrian Watson-Babij, who is here this week, enjoying Victoria and watching\n               our debates and conversations very closely in the House. If we could all make him feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12f9feea69c0f8332a29f46deefc4df532261f05e694a2842b36f006adfc0af8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3942294d1e919206ae8071ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728809,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to talk today about Guy Black and a journey of remembrance he is making\n               for all of us, for those who cannot walk beside him and for those who never came home. On April 20, he left Canada for South Korea. A military historian and former reservist,\n               he spent months preparing for this moment, training on long hills and distances for\n               a single purpose — to ensure the sacrifices of the past are not forgotten. Over the\n               course of a month, he will walk 625 kilometres, a distance chosen with care, echoing\n               June 25, 1950, the day the Korean War began. His journey will take him from Seoul to Gapyeong, then south along roads and trails to the United Nations military cemetery in Busan.\n               He will carry only what he needs, sleeping where he can, pushing through injury and\n               exhaustion, determined to finish what he began. But he won't be alone. Before he left, Guy connected with officials from the Canadian\n               and British embassies in Seoul and a non-profit group called the United Nations Korean\n               War Allies Association, which will help provide him with maps and materials. As he\n               walks, he is also heard. He will receive support from city officials, Olympians and\n               the military while he's there in Korea. The Battle of Gapyeong remains one of the most defining moments of the Korean War. In April 1951, Australian\n               and Canadian soldiers faced overwhelming odds. Princess Patricia's Canadian Light\n               Infantry, just 700 strong, held a vital hill against nearly 5,000 Chinese troops.\n               Cut off and surrounded, they endured relentless assault and brutal close combat. At\n               one point, they even called in artillery on their own position. Still, they held, and their stand helped save Seoul. Ten Canadians fell, including\n               Cpl. Gerald Robert Evans, who was one of B.C.'s own. They were among the 516 Canadians\n               who gave their lives. Guy Black walks so we will remember, and we will never forget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728809","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to talk today about Guy Black and a journey of remembrance he is making\n               for all of us, for those who cannot walk beside him and for those who never came home. On April 20, he left Canada for South Korea. A military historian and former reservist,\n               he spent months preparing for this moment, training on long hills and distances for\n               a single pu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aa6bb06439f830418400242909beb6f106747a45826e6fc98916609c4b29d787"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d866b819f4fc43b9ddd74d12e4ab572b367a7fff133d64a960c490e7705327d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3126992a2e06e81a9d5d4292","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752166,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I will not take up too much of this House's time. as written.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752166","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I will not take up too much of this House's time. as written.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["086ff51f7e76258c96c36f9a095763e4e1750f296114554682523180a8f491be"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46304ffb8ed29f5b906263cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752167,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today there are red dresses hanging outside homes, outside of schools, libraries,\n               parks, in front of businesses and non-profits. There is a red dress hanging here inside\n               this House, because today, on May 5, we observe Red Dress Day to honour and remember\n               missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and Two-Spirit people. Indigenous people face disproportionately high rates of violence rooted in colonialism,\n               systemic racism and gender-based discrimination. Red Dress Day reminds us that that\n               violence is ongoing, not just historical. We honour the voices of families, respect their loss and commit to walking forward\n               together. And thank you to people who are here in this House, who are visiting today\n               and who do this life-changing work. I raise my hands to the family members and the\n               friends of those who are gone but never forgotten. Thank you for sharing with me, showing pictures of the beautiful pillar of hope memorial\n               and the hundreds of people standing together hand in hand at the Highway of Tears\n               Symposium. I knew that we had been working to complete the cell phone service. I did\n               not know that there were red dresses hanging on the towers. I will carry that with\n               me. I knew that we had been working to complete the cell phone service. I did not know\n               that there were red dresses hanging on the towers. I will carry that with me. Thank\n               you. In B.C. and Canada, we will continue to do better. We will continue to work together.\n               Through the Canada-B.C. national action plan to end gender-based violence, we will\n               continue to support the B.C. First Nations Justice Council to advance the Indigenous\n               women's justice plan. We will continue to fund the First People's Cultural Council\n               to strengthen cultural practices as prevention. Today, let us honour those who have been lost and those who continue to take action.\n               If you or someone you know needs support, please contact VictimLinkBC and, if it is\n               an emergency, call 911. We will be there, and you deserve help.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752167","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today there are red dresses hanging outside homes, outside of schools, libraries,\n               parks, in front of businesses and non-profits. There is a red dress hanging here inside\n               this House, because today, on May 5, we observe Red Dress Day to honour and remember\n               missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and Two-Spirit people. Indigenous people face dispropor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1bc204a14514cae601364ad29cbba66972640e534b5e3f7a6012dcc55b6905a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5fbc56f69834a81932d17e4324ebb4f03a9219e2e96c4a9065511fcc88aa0508"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3f775b46f142696319b5bd1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752168,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am very pleased to introduce the House to my longtime constituency adviser, Iti\n               Kalsi. I think everyone here can empathize. I make Iti do two events every month out in the\n               community, and with her expertise and guidance and warmth, she makes each of those\n               events a delight. If the House could please welcome her. I am also pleased to welcome my newest constituency assistant, Negar Sheban.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752168","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am very pleased to introduce the House to my longtime constituency adviser, Iti\n               Kalsi. I think everyone here can empathize. I make Iti do two events every month out in the\n               community, and with her expertise and guidance and warmth, she makes each of those\n               events a delight. If the House could please welcome her. I am also pleased to welcome my newest co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65edee98977adc2ada8cbac49b1f47181d00e18e110609f7f8c5784e01d73f90"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a01f9a4889357dd5817d5ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752169,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of\n               Transportation and Transit and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752169","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of\n               Transportation and Transit and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf8001f53102c5779c4db8b8e2d167e959005e1d70256e526846ba1019db8a19"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["184547714f1cf1bc9ce0aeb14e5893c910dfb847e0cbabe62451caf5e2bb825b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-774b394300cc0af8f7144e18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017077,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Transportation and Transit and further reports resolution and completion of the estimates of the Legislative\n               Assembly and Officers of the Legislature and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017077","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Transportation and Transit and further reports resolution and completion of the estimates of the Legislative\n               Assembly and Officers of the Legislature and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e6921b86f7ff9d5deadcb99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017079,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to present the report of the Special Committee on Democratic and Electoral\n               Reform for the second session of the 43rd parliament, titled Review of the 2024 Provincial General Election , a copy of which has been deposited with the Office of the Clerk. I move that the report be taken as read and received.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017079","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am pleased to present the report of the Special Committee on Democratic and Electoral\n               Reform for the second session of the 43rd parliament, titled Review of the 2024 Provincial General Election , a copy of which has been deposited with the Office of the Clerk. I move that the report be taken as read and received.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["347a68241ccb6432437a4e1f3caca289d1783b28025e1fdeb20ed77d9a5885e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28d149bb66ff18c3e48171ada9095ad590a4966ce34db74db3760f0ce96857a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5daa37b2c7a400c4a9ffb14e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017082,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am very pleased today to welcome to this House members of the Butterfly Support\n               Network. I would like to have the House welcome Erin Saraby-Green, bereaved mother\n               of Briar; Kimberly Lockhart, bereaved mother to Wilder; Nick and Laura Bordignon,\n               with baby Marcus, who are bereaved parents to Michaela. Thank you for the work you do to support bereaved parents across British Columbia. I ask the House to welcome them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017082","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am very pleased today to welcome to this House members of the Butterfly Support\n               Network. I would like to have the House welcome Erin Saraby-Green, bereaved mother\n               of Briar; Kimberly Lockhart, bereaved mother to Wilder; Nick and Laura Bordignon,\n               with baby Marcus, who are bereaved parents to Michaela. Thank you for the work you do to support bereaved pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035242","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033771","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Butterflies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033771","label":"Butterflies","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035242","label":"Fertility","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1e069d94104cc384708f1302e1990a94525482f516f1884b2624cba409fbbb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61a7671a9ba4c50cf954769c1432b739c4128f132c9a1694d91b10d55abe58b3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a358d3e5dd6ab08bfc23a32","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017086,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017086","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1820a61527b82895441173e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036399,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like the House to make welcome Lauren Polet and Jenna Lamb. Please stand. Laura and Jenna are here today to watch me present a petition about dog and cat breeding\n               here in British Columbia. They are very keen grade 12 political science aficionados. I think we all want to encourage that level of interest and engagement, so please\n               join me in welcoming them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036399","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like the House to make welcome Lauren Polet and Jenna Lamb. Please stand. Laura and Jenna are here today to watch me present a petition about dog and cat breeding\n               here in British Columbia. They are very keen grade 12 political science aficionados. I think we all want to encourage that level of interest and engagement, so please\n               join me in welcoming them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","label":"Animal reproduction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","label":"Domestic animals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","label":"Domestic animals","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","label":"Animal reproduction","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a901c78d401addb4ad58a3620b1df282339209bcd1b76cb0ed6a9d7af6e72458"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69921cc036818e80203b01d220489fe935011c2eecd55c9d2b7d40eaf8c1057a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal reproduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:102588","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083624","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-074efadf52a405cb897852bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036400,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the member for Port Coquitlam for stealing one of my introductions. Richard Stewart is the longtime mayor of Coquitlam.\n               I actually don't know him as the mayor of Coquitlam, really. I know him as Anna-Rose's\n               husband, and I want to thank her for sharing her husband with us all these years.\n               Her dedication has held us up. Although Richard and I have come from different parts of the House — he sat in this\n               House as an MLA; I'm sorry, but I can't remember what year — he is an incredibly fierce\n               advocate for mental health, and that has only benefited my community. But my real introduction today is that one of my children is here in the House today.\n               I know I have many, and you're all going to get confused between them. But this one\n               is But my real introduction today is.... One of my children is here in the House today.\n               I know I have many, and you're all going to get confused between them. This one is\n               also a fierce advocate for mental health and served with me as an outreach worker\n               when we were working with the unhoused population in Coquitlam and stood by my side\n               in some of the most difficult situations. I am incredibly proud of them, and I would like the House to welcome them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036400","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I thank the member for Port Coquitlam for stealing one of my introductions. Richard Stewart is the longtime mayor of Coquitlam.\n               I actually don't know him as the mayor of Coquitlam, really. I know him as Anna-Rose's\n               husband, and I want to thank her for sharing her husband with us all these years.\n               Her dedication has held us up. Although Richard and I have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b3e7c375078c8286d4bea1c3bbe8f68da11619a90654389a83e93b456b8388e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aed9148c5495c2861fcdd15aaa8b2a45025f9bb25f4943500f3df4c2aa130052"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4825dd0c489adc5ecf5892e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036401,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Blatherwick","venue":"Hansard","text":"May 28 recognizes something that 51 percent of people experience for more than one-third\n               of their lives. And that's why tomorrow, B.C. joins the global movement to acknowledge\n               menstrual health day. No one should be held back because of their period. And menstrual hygiene day, menstrual\n               health day, world global recognition of menstrual health is not only about awareness\n               but about practical action. We need to continue to work to reduce stigma, through\n               awareness and education, to ensure that everyone recognizes that menstruation and\n               periods and the end of menstruation are facts of life for more than half the population. I want to be clear. The societal infrastructure that supports people who menstruate\n               doesn't need special attention. It just needs a similar level of open, practical consideration\n               that other aspects of our biology receive. Menstrual health is about dignity, equity\n               and full participation in everyday life. It means people can show up at school, at\n               work and in community. Research shows that about half of the people in British Columbia who menstruate have\n               struggled to afford products, and no one should have to choose between food and menstrual\n               supplies. This affects girls and women, Two-Spirit, non-binary, transgender people,\n               families, parents and caregivers who support children and youth. They feel it too. I want to acknowledge the important work that is happening across British Columbia\n               in partnership with the United Way and in grassroots organizations. B.C. was the first\n               province in Canada to ensure that there were free menstrual products in school bathrooms.\n               This helps students learn without barriers. There is more to do. We also want workers to participate in their jobs without barriers,\n               people to be in public spaces without challenge, so B.C. joins that global movement\n               toward a period-friendly world, where everyone has access to products and information\n               and support without stigma or shame.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036401","member_id":"bc-mla-366","member_name":"Jennifer Blatherwick","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"May 28 recognizes something that 51 percent of people experience for more than one-third\n               of their lives. And that's why tomorrow, B.C. joins the global movement to acknowledge\n               menstrual health day. No one should be held back because of their period. And menstrual hygiene day, menstrual\n               health day, world global recognition of menstrual health is not only","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cbdc337ca74410a37dcbc95ac3420ba9d7a5ebbbf55983971d96e6f0681b9ee2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e7bbba4e825b8544e099cb19aaec4230da79943252fa31ec2cb700ddc180a5f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5db0ee98f32d036b5b53450","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316831,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"With the Olympics wrapping up, I just wanted to give a big shout-out to Comox Valley's\n               own Cassie Sharpe, an Olympic champion and Canadian half-pipe legend. After a recent\n               yard sale in Milan, her final run was sidelined, but this is her third Olympic appearance. The whole Comox Valley and the entire country is behind you, wishing you a fast and\n               full recovery.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316831","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"With the Olympics wrapping up, I just wanted to give a big shout-out to Comox Valley's\n               own Cassie Sharpe, an Olympic champion and Canadian half-pipe legend. After a recent\n               yard sale in Milan, her final run was sidelined, but this is her third Olympic appearance. The whole Comox Valley and the entire country is behind you, wishing you a fast and\n               full rec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8620f9ed618f9e64589906015924c0350487aa96e0f845700b948deac3d05142","fd3d52e7869afb24cb74cccc5e12fde5ac353835a84e7bad31d0f61cdc7dcb54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11ab0182e270a58a540e9b821d0b4e0a2a41954128d32a0137d2e2a31b40fe23"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b90e3d273f76bda4a1fc6a38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316832,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a couple of introductions today. I'd first like to introduce two guests joining\n               us in the gallery, Mr. Scott Jackson, manager of advocacy, and Ms. Rebecca Frederick,\n               director of community engagement with the Alzheimer's Society of B.C. The Alzheimer's\n               Society of B.C. provides vital support, education and advocacy for individuals and\n               families affected by dementia across our province. Their work makes a meaningful difference\n               in communities large and small and in the lives of British Columbians across this\n               province. I would also, since I just got notified about 20 minutes ago, like to introduce the\n               six-pound, three-ounce beautiful baby girl, Amara Mackenzie Okagabe-Day, who showed\n               up right on time this morning. I could not be more proud of my amazing sister-in-law\n               Aiko and my brother Ian and niece Kyra. To all my amazing Nigerian in-laws who've flown across for this amazing event, big\n               love from everybody here in B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316832","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I have a couple of introductions today. I'd first like to introduce two guests joining\n               us in the gallery, Mr. Scott Jackson, manager of advocacy, and Ms. Rebecca Frederick,\n               director of community engagement with the Alzheimer's Society of B.C. The Alzheimer's\n               Society of B.C. provides vital support, education and advocacy for individuals and\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1672b6e0098c8cba3e3eb112cfbb5a97c39129534630b073b1dddfe4eadf7373"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3954e9f8a157775dd0ceff89e9ae59d70f5b7cea60223fc70a094b684bfeb3e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-577fc067cc1847cfd5e6cea8","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187128,"date":"2026-02-25T12:00:00+00:00","title":"LONG TERM CARE ACCESS AND TRANSPARENCY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m232-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m232-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187128","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c65ec8d9272e4bdd6e710bce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316833,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd just like to join into the Minister of Health and the Kootenay-Monashee MLA's acknowledgement of the B.C. Care Awards dinner last night, especially the most\n               hilarious speech I've heard in a good long while from Linda Frew. If anybody here\n               needs to hire a joke writer, I highly recommend her. On that note, I would like to recognize all of the award winners: Nahin Ahmed, Linda\n               Frew, Gloria Larson, Judy Calhoun, Graham Freeman, Christian Buns, Nancy Webb, Nitin\n               Jain and Don Ho, as well as the B.C. Care Provider staff that are doing a fantastic\n               job advocating for seniors across our province, especially the former Minister of\n               Health, Mary Polak, and their amazing team led by Tiffany Trownson. Would the House make them all feel very welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316833","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'd just like to join into the Minister of Health and the Kootenay-Monashee MLA's acknowledgement of the B.C. Care Awards dinner last night, especially the most\n               hilarious speech I've heard in a good long while from Linda Frew. If anybody here\n               needs to hire a joke writer, I highly recommend her. On that note, I would like to recognize all of the award winners: Nahin Ah","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45c9e0260828af9afc5bcfa62b9c83a3cd9cab7152fc4e456ced38d21d3a7820"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64b1deecc75706c5df8e3311","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327945,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's not just obstetrics that are failing British Columbians. There are 7,400 people\n               on wait lists for a long-term-care bed in British Columbia. Last year the seniors\n               advocate reported an average of 718 average daily unoccupied beds across the province. With alternative level of care patients now jamming up hospital hallways and jamming\n               up patient flow because they have nowhere appropriate to go, how many long-term-care\n               beds are there empty in British Columbia today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327945","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's not just obstetrics that are failing British Columbians. There are 7,400 people\n               on wait lists for a long-term-care bed in British Columbia. Last year the seniors\n               advocate reported an average of 718 average daily unoccupied beds across the province. With alternative level of care patients now jamming up hospital hallways and jamming\n               up patient flow ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d5e1c52378a74245ebe7fd64884fb4482760c20866104b6a33a5e528495272a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e40ebceae299efb95268cbdc725ccc793e99587b31d201208e976ce6a8143fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aec515a650bdcc05cd0d5324","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327946,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the Interior, even when they call for virtual health support for a closed ER,\n               the phone just keeps ringing. B.C.'s largest hospital, Vancouver General, is now the latest in a growing list of\n               maternity service failures across B.C. For four days, this government hid the fact\n               that VGH was not accepting pregnant trauma patients. Expectant mothers suffering injuries were turned away from the province's flagship\n               hospital because the system couldn't staff the service for four days. My wife has\n               been one of those people. It is terrifying to think. How did B.C.'s largest hospital turn away expectant mothers How did B.C.'s largest hospital turn away expectant mothers in trauma for four entire\n               days while this government hid it from British Columbians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327946","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the Interior, even when they call for virtual health support for a closed ER,\n               the phone just keeps ringing. B.C.'s largest hospital, Vancouver General, is now the latest in a growing list of\n               maternity service failures across B.C. For four days, this government hid the fact\n               that VGH was not accepting pregnant trauma patients. Expectant mothers sufferi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Telehealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telehealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","label":"Medical products","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88233","label":"Telehealth","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f212211b86af99e9aa060c7031ea067d4334dd1786cd6aa867644a90d100a186"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e46b41e31a8569dbe4b2a1e8f8416dd5ea3d7019ea0d2deae550c2563a456ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85de13538575c2f9d1f0b94a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327947,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to move my motion M204.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327947","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to move my motion M204.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2c064d4c1d01e42172b86ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359663,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"The way this Legislature has been practising politics at first reading is hurting people in this room and people across this province. As elected officials,\n               we have a duty to do better. First reading was never intended to be a vote on the merits of legislation. Its purpose\n               is simple. A bill is introduced. The text of First reading was never intended to be a vote on the merits of legislation. Its purpose\n               is simple. A bill is introduced. The text is printed. Members receive the legislation\n               so they can actually read it. Only then does the work of this Legislature begin. This\n               is the process in the United Kingdom. This is the process in the House of Commons.\n               That is how it works across jurisdictions that share the Westminster tradition. First reading is procedural. Standing Order 78 explicitly states that first reading\n               is not debatable. It exists so members can read the legislation before they are asked\n               to render judgment on it. Today in this House, members can be forced into a vote the moment a bill is introduced,\n               before the text has been circulated, before anyone in this House has read the legislation,\n               before the public or the media have seen what is actually in the bill. We are asked\n               to vote on something no one in this chamber has had the opportunity to read. Increasingly,\n               these votes have been turned into political theatre. Let me give two examples. Last fall, a bill was introduced recognizing freedom convoy\n               recognition day. If we follow the political logic that now surrounds first reading,\n               the government voted yes for this motion. That is exactly the conclusion that somebody\n               might draw — inferring something where it does not exist. Just last week, another bill was introduced that, according to the member presenting\n               it, would shut down all 58 provincially authorized drug consumption sites in British\n               Columbia within six months. Moments later, the entire House voted yes on first reading,\n               unanimously on the voice vote. Then, for reasons that remain unclear, the House spent another ten minutes conducting\n               a standing vote to reach the same outcome. Two Greens voted no, and several government\n               members left the chamber to avoid scrutiny. If we apply the same logic, should we\n               now conclude that the NDP supports closing every safe consumption site in British\n               Columbia? I think not. Of course, that is not what those votes actually mean, and everybody in this chamber\n               knows it. First reading votes were never intended to be endorsements of policy. They\n               were meant to do one simple thing — allow the text of a bill to be printed so members\n               could actually read it. But because we still allow forced votes at first reading in this Legislature, those\n               procedural votes can be twisted into something they were never meant to be. Members\n               are asked to vote on legislation they have not seen, and those votes are then used\n               to suggest they support or oppose policies they have not even had the opportunity\n               to read. That is not good parliamentary practice, and it is not good for public trust\n               in this institution. A straightforward reform would restore first reading to its original purpose. Bills\n               would still be introduced, they would be printed and circulated, but members would\n               not be compelled to vote on legislation before they had the opportunity to read it.\n               That would bring British Columbia back into line with the House of Commons, the United\n               Kingdom and provinces across this great nation. The current process creates the wrong incentives. It encourages members to shape the\n               title of the bill and their two-minute introduction not to inform this House, but\n               to manipulate the moment. A harmless title can conceal legislation with serious consequences.\n               A provocative title can make entirely mundane bills appear extreme. In both cases, the House is asked to vote before anybody has even read the text, and\n               if a bill is defeated at first reading, the House never gets the opportunity to examine\n               it at all. So the decision being made is not about the legislation; it is about the\n               framing of the moment. That was never the purpose of first reading. This reform does not advantage government or opposition. It simply restores common\n               sense to a step in the process that has increasingly become performative rather than\n               practical. Under the rules of this House, the government controls the agenda. At any\n               time, they can choose to call my motion for debate. The question before us is simple. Will the government allow this House to have that\n               conversation? If we are serious about improving the functioning of this Legislature,\n               reforms like this should not be controversial; they should be obvious. From this moment\n               forward, if the sideshow continues, the responsibility rests entirely with the NDP\n               government. To my colleagues in this chamber and to my constituents watching from home, I apologize\n               for the shame that this Parliament has allowed to persist. But I will not accept it.\n               I will continue pressing for the reforms needed to modernize this Legislature and\n               restore the standard British Columbians expect from those they entrust to govern.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359663","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The way this Legislature has been practising politics at first reading is hurting people in this room and people across this province. As elected officials,\n               we have a duty to do better. First reading was never intended to be a vote on the merits of legislation. Its purpose\n               is simple. A bill is introduced. The text of First reading was never intended to be a vote on th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30e13081120ce6c51460bb7fddd8f3d034d23f7a72dc7fc7c0a2b3ab46918290"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ea2d88bdd94c5b8113123c461082e7960a8b3b9714dbcd640dba6d13656d591"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be15718f6361662ffbcf6405","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359664,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"There may be no kings in Oceanside, but there certainly are in the Comox Valley. I\n               want to give a quick shout-out to our very own Comox Valley Glacier Kings of the VIJHL\n               for sweeping the Oceanside Generals four games to none in the playoff series. A truly\n               incredible performance by a great young group of athletes. The boys are going to be out hunting the Cougars and the Panthers from the south Island\n               in the next round, and with this group, they've got it in the bag. Go, Kings!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359664","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"There may be no kings in Oceanside, but there certainly are in the Comox Valley. I\n               want to give a quick shout-out to our very own Comox Valley Glacier Kings of the VIJHL\n               for sweeping the Oceanside Generals four games to none in the playoff series. A truly\n               incredible performance by a great young group of athletes. The boys are going to be out hunting the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hunting (Sport)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Life expectancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035503","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Glaciers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035503","label":"Glaciers","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035754","label":"Hunting (Sport)","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083626","label":"Life expectancy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a61b45fe394c5fff0c29b7209fd9b3e70de3d044d806bc2bdc06f64d490bec5f","770d7d89bedf84fe3e3866f4c8f12dce4283910064da8eb4666eb7837dc9ce97"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b67624a329cfa65ff3ba0fb834ed80697b9b87201ce9951ca3ba2965f2fd795"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b72abb6abb4cdd7dbe75b763","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360139,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I can't wait to hear the minister say that to the parents on the lawn on Saturday. In this budget, this government quietly changed the seniors property tax deferral\n               program, raising the interest rate by 4 percent and switching to monthly compound\n               interest. To the Minister of Finance, this disastrous budget is hurting seniors. Why is this\n               government making it more expensive for seniors struggling? Will you commit to reversing\n               this damaging tax hike today? The Speaker : Questions through the Chair, Members.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360139","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I can't wait to hear the minister say that to the parents on the lawn on Saturday. In this budget, this government quietly changed the seniors property tax deferral\n               program, raising the interest rate by 4 percent and switching to monthly compound\n               interest. To the Minister of Finance, this disastrous budget is hurting seniors. Why is this\n               government maki","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2932bfe5dd9875912b4616990373673caf54debf354bb854cbc56069d5395a6c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["288643ea2578bd30fbba6cb16046d0391f6df69d2dc428415effa5dfc096ff92"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88e949dd441adbf6e1a33398","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360140,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"Talking about stability and predictability, across B.C., seniors are being charged\n               wildly different prices for ICBC-mandated drivers' medical assessments. Some seniors\n               are paying $100 and some over $300 for the exact same paperwork. For seniors on fixed\n               incomes, that is not health care; it's an affordability lottery. Will the Minister of Health commit today to standardizing ICBC's mandatory driver's\n               licence assessment fees for seniors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360140","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Talking about stability and predictability, across B.C., seniors are being charged\n               wildly different prices for ICBC-mandated drivers' medical assessments. Some seniors\n               are paying $100 and some over $300 for the exact same paperwork. For seniors on fixed\n               incomes, that is not health care; it's an affordability lottery. Will the Minister of Health commit t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["507e0268bb7ac060a220924c20d33bb66941df4e0c3850f834acdd8acd21c2a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ead5df0971538397467bdd33a14f43437331a4443fff5fa76336f77d5dc7269"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc4fd2729b021ac5924e4085","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415704,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today in strong support of Motion M203, brought forward by my friend and colleague\n               for Fraser-Nicola. I have to say, it is remarkable that we are even debating something this basic in\n               this House. But given the performative, divisive and chronically unproductive record\n               of this government, I suppose it is right on-brand that we are now watching core principles\n               like transparency and accountability treated as optional. The idea that hiring in the B.C. Public Service should be based on merit, on qualifications,\n               on the ability to actually do the job — not on who you know — should not be particularly\n               controversial. It should be, in fact, beyond debate. It should be the floor. But here we are. Because\n               while this They have eliminated the independent Office of the Merit Commissioner in this $13.3\n               billion budget boondoggle. Not improving it, not modernizing it, just eliminating\n               it. And the justification? Cost savings. That is what stands between independent oversight\n               and a system where the government oversees itself. In a budget approaching $100 billion, accountability is apparently the line item that\n               they've decided to trim. Very convenient, and extremely shameful. Not a cut to the\n               web of appointed boards and agencies filled with NDP friends, insiders, donors, or\n               loyalists, many of whom it is worth noting, are not even subject to the Merit Commissioner's\n               oversight in the first place. So let's be clear about what is actually being lost\n               here. In the most recent year, 10 percent of appointments reviewed did not apply merit —\n               10 percent, one in ten. So to minimize 1 in 10 is truly shocking by the previous speaker. That is not\n               a minor issue. That is a system warning you that something is not working, and that\n               the government is not their own best watchdog. And that is trending in the wrong direction.\n               The Merit Commissioner — sorry, I should say former Merit Commissioner since the NDP\n               has already kicked him to the curb — stated in his most recent report and, turns out,\n               final report: \"We are seeing the highest rate of flawed hiring in nearly a decade.\"\n               So what was the government's response? Fix the problem? Tighten the system? No. Fire\n               the guy that's launching the warning flares. We have seen this government steadily tighten its grip on information, making it harder\n               to access, easier to delay and more convenient to control. And now we are seeing that\n               same instinct applied to hiring. It is a pattern, and one that should be very concerning\n               to everybody in British Columbia. Less sunlight, more discretion and fewer independent\n               eyes. Because when you remove oversight, when you bring everything inside the executive\n               office, you are not increasing efficiency. You are simply reducing accountability,\n               and that includes accountability by the members on the other side of this room. This NDP government is already quietly reshaping the public service, altering job\n               titles and descriptions to mask a decline in qualifications and basic standards. Roles\n               that once required certified accredited professionals are being diluted. Certified\n               social workers are being replaced with analysts and case managers. Engineers replaced\n               with specialists. Project managers being downgraded to project coordinators. That\n               is not modernization. That is a slow erosion of competency and capacity. And British\n               Columbians are feeling it. You see it in projects that come in years late and billions of dollars over budget.\n               You feel it when you pick up the phone and hope the person on the other end actually\n               knows how to navigate the system. Because today, it has become a lottery. If you get\n               the right qualified person, you get help. If you get the wrong person, you get trapped\n               in a bureaucratic maze that goes nowhere. Everybody in this room, including our staff and CA offices, understand that experience.\n               And that is the real-world consequence of lowering the bar. It is not theoretical.\n               It shows up in the lives of people trying to support an aging parent, a child with\n               special needs or a friend struggling with mental health. When competency slips, people\n               pay the price. This motion does not undermine the public service. It protects it, because government\n               should not be marking its own homework. Independent oversight reporting to this Legislature\n               is not optional. It is essential in the basic functioning and transparency of government. So the question for the members opposite is simple. If you believe in merit, support independent oversight. If you believe in fairness, support independent oversight.\n               If you believe the public deserves to trust the system, then support this motion.\n               And if you do not, then at least have the courage to explain why with more than simple\n               obfuscation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415704","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today in strong support of Motion M203, brought forward by my friend and colleague\n               for Fraser-Nicola. I have to say, it is remarkable that we are even debating something this basic in\n               this House. But given the performative, divisive and chronically unproductive record\n               of this government, I suppose it is right on-brand that we are now watching cor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d69556f89c3b317efa3aeefa793d7794bddcc5230b420401ef8d9c18806b00b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0fe109cde28d3cccd79bc5457a3349ad2c8da6daa7a4c0e0fb5847f91dd67899"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7cb0bd00f0006769b1b2c25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415705,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I don't have any equity cards with me, but I'm going to stand up for struggling British\n               Columbians anyways. This government is cutting support for families with sick children across rural B.C.\n               through pullbacks of the B.C. family residence program. Tomorrow they are reducing\n               stays from 30 to 21 and imposing an $80,000 income cap. And $80,000 in British Columbia\n               is not wealthy. That's families barely holding it together. Less than the living wage\n               in my community. So to the Premier: how much money is this government planning to save by cutting support\n               to families with sick kids?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415705","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I don't have any equity cards with me, but I'm going to stand up for struggling British\n               Columbians anyways. This government is cutting support for families with sick children across rural B.C.\n               through pullbacks of the B.C. family residence program. Tomorrow they are reducing\n               stays from 30 to 21 and imposing an $80,000 income cap. And $80,000 in British ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Minimum wage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","label":"Minimum wage","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92c4a0e27d1765eff343c4503dc7a9ef42fcafe6ef8a01b393db5c47ae26221c","1f6a9690abfcdcf7d12340e1b89fafc41b22b652eb779878aa597649e6583513"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c57b2db884bda27bc2b1c28b15acb650d0bb6d2b27d1e60fe34a0df45344a38a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42016f37d7ea64d4677f458b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415706,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to take a moment to introduce Ben Colling with Rhodes Wellness and Jeremy\n               Sable with Stenberg College — fantastic post-secondary education in the health care\n               space. Interesting fact. Jeremy Sable's father Bob, who has unfortunately recently\n               passed, was my first boss in the Christmas tree farm, a Christmas tree farm that my\n               parents now proudly run and carry on that condition. Thank you very much. Make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415706","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to take a moment to introduce Ben Colling with Rhodes Wellness and Jeremy\n               Sable with Stenberg College — fantastic post-secondary education in the health care\n               space. Interesting fact. Jeremy Sable's father Bob, who has unfortunately recently\n               passed, was my first boss in the Christmas tree farm, a Christmas tree farm that my\n               pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccb45cb2fb730bd45e9de0ef8a57d5d3a2d23352dd5dd43a052144077d90e5c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-225db5f90c2ceeed20766f2a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720230,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I reserve my time, yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720230","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I reserve my time, yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66e2e82f0af81476a6ebc0fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720232,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize something remarkable in the Comox Valley. The Comox Valley\n               Healthcare Foundation has raised $1.3 million to improve diagnostic imaging services\n               at the Comox Valley hospital. That community effort has already helped deliver six\n               new ultrasound machines, a new mammography unit and a second portable ultrasound machine\n               for our ER. Those are not abstract upgrades. They are tools that will be used every day in obstetrics,\n               cancer care, women's health, routine diagnostics and emergency medicine. The new ultrasound\n               machines alone are expected to be used roughly 14,000 times every year. That is something\n               worth celebrating. It says something about the people of the Comox Valley that when a need is identified,\n               they step up. They don't wait around. They get involved. They raise the money. They\n               support local health care because they understand exactly what is at stake, and they\n               should be proud of that. But this story also makes something very clear. When communities are being asked to\n               fundraise for critical hospital equipment, local generosity is doing more than supporting\n               extras. It's helping sustain core basic care in communities across this province.\n               That should give this House pause, because equipment matters, but so does having the\n               staff in place to use it. In one of the wealthiest provinces in the country, in one\n               of the wealthiest countries on earth, communities should not be left wondering whether\n               the tools are there, whether the people are there or whether the system is keeping\n               up. The people of the Comox Valley will always do their part. That is who we are. But\n               local generosity should be strengthening the system, not compensating for basic health\n               care equipment needs. Today I want to thank every donor, volunteer, organizer and everyone at the Comox\n               Valley Healthcare Foundation for what they have accomplished. They have done their\n               part, and we need to make sure that this House does ours.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720232","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize something remarkable in the Comox Valley. The Comox Valley\n               Healthcare Foundation has raised $1.3 million to improve diagnostic imaging services\n               at the Comox Valley hospital. That community effort has already helped deliver six\n               new ultrasound machines, a new mammography unit and a second portable ultrasound machine\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aff90688b0ee3018a578fdb8cf569ecdbbb5e71ae2f46fbcf05262b805c0aca2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["98ba7c393af7f04b307c41fccb44f30b4474f05d6b014979aec556b0b4577217"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0019193229d142adc40bff2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721315,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my wife's birthday today. We've been married 15 years this year, and I've known\n               her since high school. She shares a birthday with the minister. She'll be very disappointed\n               to hear that, I feel. Anyways, if the House could please wish her a very happy birthday. And I will not\n               say how old she is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721315","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is my wife's birthday today. We've been married 15 years this year, and I've known\n               her since high school. She shares a birthday with the minister. She'll be very disappointed\n               to hear that, I feel. Anyways, if the House could please wish her a very happy birthday. And I will not\n               say how old she is.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f06152035b2dc3a66c2d0fd62f89c7cb29985b2132dac785225bc58c962bd8ae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d7a59a74de84127921ac498","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721320,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let's talk about results. This government loves","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721320","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's talk about results. This government loves","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["725c9c34d6100dbeb0bb03cc502ce8e005baf39c9be3dbea42e55bbe19c4be45"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3198b9832d1fd60f547df6bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721326,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have very much been looking forward to speaking to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, because I have a passion for freedom\n               of information and transparency in the province of British Columbia. I want to begin not with legalese and not with process and not with the sort of soft\n               language governments use when they're trying to smuggle something past the public.\n               Let's be clear. This is exactly what this bill is trying to do. I'd like to begin\n               with the truth, because this bill reflects a government that is getting very short\n               on ideas. It reflects a government whose record is starting to catch up to it. It\n               reflects a government that has made so many mistakes and fumbles and offered so many\n               inflated claims and buried so much under delay and deflection, that it isn't trying\n               to fix the underlying problems anymore. It's trying to hide from them. That is exactly what Bill 9 is. This is not a government bursting with confidence\n               in its own record. A confident government does not make access to information harder.\n               A confident government does not lower the standard from responding without delay to\n               responding only without unreasonable delay. A confident government does not broaden\n               the grounds to disregard requests by calling applicants abusive or malicious or by\n               saying requests may interfere with the operations of government. A confident government\n               does not start attaching fees to records that are supposed to be proactively available,\n               open and transparent to the public. A confident government certainly does not make\n               new disregard powers apply retroactively to requests that are already in the system. No, Madam Speaker, those are the actions of a government that knows its record is\n               extremely vulnerable. Those are the actions of a government that knows the gap between\n               what it says and what the documents show is getting harder and harder to manage. Those\n               are the actions of a government that has learned painfully that the truth always has\n               a way of surfacing. Far too often in this province, the truth has surfaced, not because government volunteered\n               it, not because they proactively disclosed it, but because somebody fought for it,\n               because somebody filed the request, because somebody appealed the delay, because somebody\n               refused to take what the government said in a press release as gospel. That is why freedom of information matters. It matters because without it, governments\n               get to narrate their own performance unchecked, and this government is shameless about\n               that narration. With it, the public gets a chance to compare the sales pitch of the\n               press release to the actual numbers. And that comparison has not been kind recently\n               to this government. Let's talk about health care, because that is where this pattern has become impossible\n               to ignore. We have watched ministers stand up and announce headline numbers on recruitment\n               and access daily. We have watched flashy claims, broad declarations of progress and\n               carefully curated figures rolled out for public consumption. Time and again, when\n               you drill into the numbers, when you ask what the figures actually mean, when you\n               compare one release to another, the story gets far murkier. Take primary care. The government wants applause when it can point to attachment rates\n               or percentages. But when we have done the math, when we have taken the province's\n               own population and compared it to the share of British Columbians still without a\n               primary care provider, the number remains flat; 23 percent of British Columbians still\n               don't have a care provider. That's 1.3 million British Columbians. The reason this matters to FOI is because without FOI disclosures, the government\n               would be happy to stand behind their claim of 750,000 British Columbians attached\n               since 2017. A bold claim, but a claim that doesn't even keep up with population growth\n               in this province. It's not a rounding error. It's not a minor gap. That is a system\n               failure at a massive scale, only recovered through information and transparency. What made that so politically revealing was not only What made that so politically revealing was not only the number itself, but it was\n               the discrepancy. It was the fact that the number sat only 70,000 below the reported\n               figure from the primary care report from a year ago, even as the government continued trying to present the story as\n               though the crisis were being decisively turned around. Just today, the minister and the Premier waxed poetic in question period about 600,000 primary care attachments — absolutely\n               head-breaking, headline numbers. But those aren't just attachments; those are attempted\n               attachments. Those numbers don't include all of the British Columbians across this\n               province who lost their primary care provider to retirement or relocation. That is why transparency matters, because you cannot run a government on press releases.\n               You run a government on results. If you only listen to the podium, you hear progress.\n               If you examine the numbers, you see stagnation dressed up as progress. If you press\n               a little harder, you start asking the question the government hates most: what are\n               they not telling us from this flashy press release? The same pattern shows up in health care recruitment. The minister wants headlines\n               for accepted job offers — accepted job offers. But British Columbians don't receive\n               care from press releases of job offers; they receive care from actual workers actually\n               hired, actually onboarded, actually accredited, actually practising and actually retained\n               in our system. That's where the shine comes off, because the real question is not how many expressions\n               of interest there were. It's not how many people entered a pipeline. It's not even\n               how many offers were accepted. The real question is net capacity. How many health\n               care workers are actually in the system after departures, retirements, burnout, interprovincial\n               movement, administrative bottlenecks, licensing lag and attrition are all taken into\n               account? And how do we find those numbers? With this government, it's through freedom of information.\n               Or it was, until the government tabled this damaging bill. How many more people are\n               actually at the bedside in the ER, in rural communities, in long-term care, in diagnostics,\n               in home care and in the places where patients feel shortages in real life? Because\n               the reality of British Columbians does not match the press releases. Time and again, this government has preferred the gross headline to the net truth.\n               Why? Because gross numbers are for announcements: $2.7 billion more in the health\n               care system. A flat investment in real terms, when you account for inflation and wage\n               growth, and that's the pattern Bill 9 is designed to protect. Then we can go into long-term care. For all the government's rhetoric, families are\n               still waiting. Seniors are still stuck, hospitals are still clogged with patients\n               who shouldn't be there, because the next level of care doesn't exist in this province\n               or was cancelled. We have pressed this government over and over on long-term-care\n               wait-lists, on bed shortages and the relationship between long-term-care failure and\n               acute care gridlock. And what do we run into again and again? Delay, deflection, partial disclosure, fragments\n               of the story and press release headlines that obfuscate the truth. That is exactly\n               why freedom of information matters more now than ever to British Columbians, because\n               without it, government gets to hide inside aggregate talking points. Without it, it\n               can announce a project here, a couple billion dollars in funding there, a future commitment\n               somewhere else down the road, and hope nobody compares that language to the government's\n               actual delivery record. And this government's delivery record is abysmal. Without\n               it, they can sell movement where what mostly exists is simply government drift. When documents do emerge, when internal concerns do surface, when staff level warnings become visible, suddenly the government is forced to answer for what it\n               knew and when it knew it. That's what transparency does and why FOI is so important.\n               It drags reality back into the room. And this government, increasingly, does not like\n               reality. It does not like being asked why wait-lists remain so high. It does not like\n               being asked how many beds are truly available because of staffing. It does not like\n               being asked how many patients are stuck in hospital as alternative-level-of-care patients\n               because the continuing-care system is falling behind.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721326","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have very much been looking forward to speaking to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, because I have a passion for freedom\n               of information and transparency in the province of British Columbia. I want to begin not with legalese and not with process and not with the sort of soft\n               language governments use when","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d9a98aea10c0081ba0b35fc433eb4134f850931db59266254e8958d5eb00f371"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d197ccd26a1f82ff3825e5e54f06aa3a1789a82e16629cbd3f2eda8cc0c0d490"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55051317f9f7341381786640","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721328,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721328","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e16b4821e83322306c2e7912bc1c668f9c2f934edc4669d7464c235117142ba9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91820353033171bc6faefc80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728978,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I've got a couple introductions today. First is Mayor John Henderson from the amazing\n               city of Sechelt, and he joined us this weekend for the Brennan Day : I've got a couple introductions today. First is Mayor John Henderson from the amazing\n               city of Sechelt. He joined us this weekend for the ABICC conference. Some fantastic\n               discussions happened there. As well, I would like to introduce Jennifer Humphreys from AbbVie. This is a drug\n               company that's dealing in cutting-edge treatments for things like ulcerative colitis\n               and doing that research right here at home in British Columbia. Would the House please make them all feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728978","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I've got a couple introductions today. First is Mayor John Henderson from the amazing\n               city of Sechelt, and he joined us this weekend for the Brennan Day : I've got a couple introductions today. First is Mayor John Henderson from the amazing\n               city of Sechelt. He joined us this weekend for the ABICC conference. Some fantastic\n               discussions happened there. As","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","label":"Medical products","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5ed79802cb25f29f05e62a3683f6d4a795818d91318e0caf6bb9f2a2c1772ff","efab61875f0db8ad55b51d627e23f04dad102d91c092e49340f6fe177a1f9716"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5fdb5d1da64feaef3f813334c2ee520151dbcd6536598e6081693243bb16886"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87af55f9403d632a5ceb08d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728979,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome Denise Praill of Canuck Place. She is the president and CEO\n               of this extraordinary organization that provides compassionate pediatric palliative\n               care and support to children with life-threatening illnesses and the families who\n               love them. Their work brings comfort, dignity and hope to families during some of\n               their most difficult moments. Please join me in making Denise feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728979","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome Denise Praill of Canuck Place. She is the president and CEO\n               of this extraordinary organization that provides compassionate pediatric palliative\n               care and support to children with life-threatening illnesses and the families who\n               love them. Their work brings comfort, dignity and hope to families during some of\n               their mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5223a05d81a77011aac0459043e90f84276b8db5ac1853be0df29b1b4136fe1a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bf18bff1af57b7351c9107d224ab33b3a0148a5bee3cec13cc75dc8f6ddfb3e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e9062297be9103ecbd3f1d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728996,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"Nice to see everybody again this year. I feel we've all aged in dog years over the\n               past 12 months, but it's great to see everybody back. I'll jump right into it. The\n               plan today is to do some general health questions, and then we'll get into seniors\n               and rural health. My first question. Last year when asked for net new nurses, you provided gross registration\n               numbers, so I guess I'll re-ask the question again this year. How many net new nurses\n               are practising today, compared to this time one year ago, after accounting for those\n               who left the system? Hon. Josie Osborne : I know how much the member likes numbers, and so I am going to provide numbers. First of all, just to say that nursing supply-and-demand challenges remain, as the\n               member knows, and as we've canvassed in question period many times. That's why we\n               are hard at work to make British Columbia the most attractive place for a nurse to\n               work with fair pay, with modernized facilities and workforce models and really reducing\n               the barriers for internationally trained nurses to come practice here in British Columbia. I just want to quickly point out and say thank you to the work that the B.C. College\n               of Nurses and Midwives has done around speeding up the credentialing of international\n               nurses. I'm going to give some overall stats and then dive into some of the details. The growth\n               in B.C.'s nursing workforce has outpaced population growth since 2018. As of December\n               1, 2025, there were 76,594 nurses registered with the B.C. College. Registrations\n               have grown by 29 percent since 2018. In that time as well, nursing full-time equivalents,\n               or FTEs, have grown by 16 percent. So that is net growth. Specifically, from 2023 to 2024, which is the most recent year-on-year comparison\n               that I can provide, we went from 53,059 FTEs to 56,193, which is a net growth of 5.9\n               percent. I want to break down again the different kinds of nurses that we have in our nursing\n               workforce. So of those 76,600-odd nurses, LPNs comprise 17,164 who are registered.\n               Of those, 16,214 are actually practicing. That's 94.5 percent. There are 55,490 registered\n               nurses; 50,810 who are practising. That's 91.6 percent. Registered psychiatric nurses:\n               3,940 registered, 3,716 practising or 94.3 percent. We also have 2,141 employed student\n               nurses or student psychiatric nurses. We have a nursing turnover rate of about 4.6 percent here in B.C., which is actually\n               the second lowest of all provinces, and our retention of early-career nurses is the\n               highest in the country. Earlier I referred to outpacing population growth. Just to add a little onto that,\n               compared with population growth of 13 percent between December 2018 and December 2025,\n               nursing registrants grew at 29 percent. From January 1, 2025 to December 1, 2025,\n               the number of nurses registered in B.C. grew by 2 percent, compared with a projected\n               just under 1 percent decline in the population over the same period. Again, just making\n               the point that the growth in the nursing workforce is outpacing population growth. I think I'll leave it there and see if the member has any follow-up questions on that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728996","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Nice to see everybody again this year. I feel we've all aged in dog years over the\n               past 12 months, but it's great to see everybody back. I'll jump right into it. The\n               plan today is to do some general health questions, and then we'll get into seniors\n               and rural health. My first question. Last year when asked for net new nurses, you provided gross registrat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","label":"Medicine","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d8c09570561e5f04aaa86c7fd185487b63f4505d744093b5b8ca7bb3c47aa14","c48018e4c83a6d47ea13f9f72105ddfe7eebc4a7f28d4aea411a696637e1009f","cf7daaa1a1faa1fa765c5147b313fc26c85b01d1d2385bf16b17dbbadc8fbe13","3a47cc70ba23fb516bc1ac3453e4b4cb0ffb1364f23756550e1444f025777e2a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["89b9d951574db2393a0a3f7d90d9fe6fde774925e0677e8d2564d19f085dae59"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fce832d743c32279893465fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728997,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday in estimates, we asked for some pretty specific numbers and what we got,\n               after some very long explanations and repeated attempts, were a few admissions that\n               should concern every British Columbian. The minister confirmed that more than 15,000 funded health care positions are currently\n               vacant, including 7,200 nursing positions. The minister confirmed 8,645 hours of ER\n               closures in 2024, despite an FOI from her ministry confirming 10,360. Then the minister\n               confirmed those numbers did not include planned overnight or weekend closures. That's not stabilization in the province of B.C. On primary care, after several attempts,\n               the minister finally confirmed that there are more than 1.3 million British Columbians\n               that remain unattached to a primary care provider, up from 821,000 in 2016. The minister claims the methodology for measuring has changed, and the new system\n               is far superior but will not offer up any clarity as to the presumed baseline that\n               this government started at. The government's latest headline claim of 600,000 new attachments since 2023 is getting\n               a lot of press, but the minister confirmed that numbers include people who moved communities\n               or changed providers are included in that total. It's a gross number presented as\n               progress without any clear accounting. Based on the minister's own numbers, that claim\n               is overrepresented by at least 33 percent, with the year-to-year data that the minister\n               provided yesterday. We asked for a net number. Neither was provided. We asked how many of the 581 U.S.\n               recruits with accepted job offers are actually practising in British Columbia today.\n               The number was not provided. We asked how long it takes to go from application to\n               practise. That number was not provided. It wasn't tracked or it wasn't convenient.\n               We asked for maximum wait times for people on the health connect registry. That was\n               not disclosed. That is the pattern we see here before us. Announcements instead of outcomes and gross\n               numbers instead of net results. Inputs rather than outputs. Now I'm going to move into seniors health, where the consequences are even more severe.\n               The seniors advocate has reported thousands of seniors waiting for long-term care\n               in B.C. — 7,000 in his most recent report. We know seniors are stuck in hospital beds because the right level of care is not\n               available. We know British Columbia is already short thousands of long-term-care beds\n               and that the predicted shortfall grows dramatically in the years ahead, compounded\n               by the fact that six long-term-care facilities across British Columbia were cancelled\n               or re-paced in the most recent budget. So today we will be asking a simple question on behalf of seniors and families, and\n               we will be making sure we get accurate numbers. I will begin by asking the minister, noting that last year 6,464 seniors were waiting\n               for a long-term-care bed in estimates at this time and the seniors advocate's most\n               recent report has now estimated 7,000 people waiting on the long-term care list —\n               an increase of 2,000 percent since this government took power: could the minister\n               please confirm how many seniors are currently waiting for a long-term-care bed in\n               the province of British Columbia today? What are the median and maximum wait times,\n               broken down by health authority? Hon. Josie Osborne : Welcome back to the member for Courtenay-Comox. The member started off with a little bit of a recap of the discussions we had yesterday.\n               I'll offer my recap, as well, which is to say I think it was a good discussion about\n               a variety of different statistics and data and, frankly, the progress that government\n               has made in attracting new physicians and health care workers to the province; in\n               attaching people to primary care providers; in the seats that we've added to the system\n               to train more nurses, nurse practitioners, allied health care workers; opening a new\n               medical school; talking about vacancies in the health care system and all the work\n               that's being done to address those vacancies at a time of just simply phenomenal population\n               growth. Much of what we talked about yesterday was how, in the progress that government is\n               making, we are outpacing population growth when it comes to much of this work, particularly\n               around patient attachment to primary care providers and in adding physicians and health\n               care workers to our workforce here in British Columbia. I know the member looks for precision in certain things that I think he understands\n               just simply isn't possible. When health care workers move to our province and accept\n               a job offer, it is a very individual experience — and to know how long it takes people\n               when you're relocating a family and going through immigration processes as well as\n               through the job security process and moving your family. The point is, and as we heard from the member from Ladysmith-Oceanside earlier today,\n               that people are making the choice to move to this province because of what we offer\n               here in our public universal health care system. I also just want to briefly address the discrepancy that the member is pointing out\n               with what his records, obtained through FOI, on emergency department unplanned closures\n               don't reconcile with the numbers that I read into the records yesterday. I'd be happy to talk to the member more afterwards, but what we have learned by looking\n               at the same FOI result — I believe it's the same one that he has in his hands — is\n               that his includes certain types of facilities that are not truly classified as emergency\n               departments. I want to be very clear: the numbers yesterday I spoke about were emergency departments\n               and, further, just make the point that we are again making progress in bringing down\n               the number of hours that emergency departments are closed in the province. Let me turn now to the question at hand here. I'm really pleased to be able to take\n               some time today and talk about seniors care and just how important that is. As we know, seniors comprise a large proportion of British Columbia's population.\n               It's no wonder. It's a beautiful place to live. People make the choice to retire here\n               and to move here. In 2025, seniors represented 20.5 of B.C.'s population, and that\n               proportion is projected to rise to 23.4 in ten years, in 2035. That's why it is so important to ensure that this growing and aging population has\n               the supports that they need and that we're able to invest in the full continuum of\n               care, of what seniors need to access in terms of health care, whether it's primary\n               care and then stepping up into more intense forms of care and sometimes, for some,\n               in the form of assisted living or in long-term care. I know that the member and I are going to have a discussion over the next few hours\n               about this and talking about how that care is being provided. I just want to take a moment to set the stage and remind everybody that when this\n               government came into power in 2017, we walked into a situation where there was an\n               incredible amount of work to do in order to catch up with the lack of investment in\n               seniors care previously and in order to invest particularly, if we're going to talk\n               about long-term care, in the facilities that are required to accommodate this growing\n               proportion of seniors — and, as well, to be able to meet the standards of care that\n               all seniors deserve to have, and the dignity and respect with which they need to be\n               able to live as well as to be cared for. In the Gordon Campbell years.... I don't need to re-canvass too much what happened there.\n               But there were terrible things that happened with respect to contracting out of care\n               for seniors. When we arrived at the point of the COVID-19 pandemic, we really saw\n               the impact of some of those changes in those years and the cutbacks and the privatization One of the early actions that was undertaken by the former Minister of Health was\n               to look forward and say: \"How do we develop a plan?\" How do we make sure that as people\n               age, they can age in a way that is as healthy as possible, that they can stay home\n               as long as possible, and that we increase not just lifespan, but health span, the\n               ability of a person to thrive and to be able to live their best lives as they grow\n               older? The age-forward plan, British Columbia's 50-plus health strategy and three-year action\n               plan, brought this together in a way that really outlines the commitment to improving\n               quality of life for older adults. Of course, as I was just saying, it's so important\n               that as the population ages, we support people to thrive and to continue contributing\n               to their communities. That means that health care services need to adapt. They need to meet evolving needs.\n               They need to really emphasize that proactive, personalized and culturally safe care,\n               as well as investing in upstream approaches. Those are early interventions that are\n               needed to help detect health issues, to help prevent health issues — again, about\n               expanding the health span and undertaking initiatives to reduce frailties and preventable\n               falls, some of the situations that older adults find themselves in when they must,\n               in some cases, move into assisted living or into long-term care. Part of this work, too, in promoting an increase in health span, is around supporting\n               seniors to be able to live in their homes independently for as long as possible. That's\n               why the work that we have done and the investments that we have made in the Better\n               at Home program, for example, the partnership with United Way; our investments into\n               community care, which I have to point out, have more than doubled now, compared to\n               what they were when we entered government. That community care and home-based care is an incredibly important part of supporting\n               people, those community-based senior services that deliver non-medical home support\n               services. They deliver light housekeeping, some visiting, information and referral\n               supports, transportation to appointments. But then also the work that health authorities\n               do in being able to provide more supports for clients, for residents who are living\n               at home, with clinical services like nursing, allied health, home support and respite. These are all an important component of community care. Over the course from when\n               we formed government to just a year ago, those service levels have increased by over\n               a quarter, by over 28 percent. We continue to uphold that in our budget and to deliver\n               these services for people. There are also adult day services, short-term respite stays for seniors in long-term-care\n               homes to give their caregivers a little bit of extra support and meeting not only\n               the clients' needs that they have, but also giving caregivers a break and being able\n               to help them as they continue to care for their loved ones in their families. That,\n               too, helps to extend again the ability of an older adult to be able to stay at home. Let me turn now to long-term care and note, too, that in the continuum of care and\n               services that are provided for adults, we understandably focus a lot of our time on\n               long-term care. It does serve a small portion of older adults, and it's incredibly\n               important that those services are there. Again, just coming back to the fact that upon entering government in 2017, there's\n               been an incredible amount of work to do to invest in in British Columbia's long-term-care\n               system. Investing in the renewal and the expansion of health authority long-term-care\n               facilities has been a priority in improving the existing aging infrastructure at the\n               same time as building new long-term-care homes. I know this is canvassed partly in the estimates with the Minister of Infrastructure,\n               but it bears repeating that since 2017 there have been 37 projects that have been\n               approved. Using both the operating and capital funding, that incorporates over 2,000 replacement\n               beds, at net new — I know the member likes to likes to hear \"net new\" — 3,397 beds\n               that have been approved. That's a combination of At net new — I know the member likes to hear \"net new\" — 3,397 beds that have been\n               approved. That's a combination of private long-term-care beds. If you add the 177\n               net new private long-term-care beds, that brings us to a total of 5,572 long-term-care\n               beds. As our population increases, there is absolutely no doubt — it's very clear — that\n               there will be an increase in the number of seniors who will want to plan for or who\n               will find themselves in the need of having to enter into long-term care. I think this\n               is where the members' interests lie with respect to wait-lists. He mentions the work of the office of the seniors advocate, and I want to say that\n               I really appreciate the work that Dan Levitt is doing, and prior to him, Isobel Mackenzie.\n               The service they provide in raising the voices that need to be heard by government\n               and working with us to identify gaps and places to improve the system, as well as\n               where the system is working well, is part of a really valuable relationship. I also want to express gratitude for the Parliamentary Secretary for Seniors' Services\n               and Long-Term Care, the MLA for North Vancouver–Seymour, who has a particular focus on this work and is also of great help for me in delivering\n               around this part of government's commitment. I'm going to move to the specific data that the member has been asking for around\n               long-term-care clients wait-listed. I'll read these numbers out. The member has asked\n               for median and maximum. I can give average and maximum, and I will break it out by\n               health authority. In the Interior Health Authority, the average days waiting is 150, and the maximum\n               wait is 1,211 days. In Fraser Health Authority, the average is 270, with a maximum\n               of 1,284. In Vancouver Coastal Health Authority, the average is 315 and maximum 2,825.\n               In Vancouver Island Health Authority, the average is 345 days, with a maximum of 1,861.\n               In Northern Health Authority, it is 376 days on average and a maximum of 1,609. I also want to reflect, though, that as health authorities manage these wait-lists,\n               that it's not strictly first come, first serve but that there is the level of acuity,\n               that a person's experiences will impact the amount of time that they may wait for.\n               I also want to say.... I know the member will make the point that there's more work\n               to do, and that's absolutely right. There's more work to do. That includes continuing to invest in the community services, in in-home services,\n               in partnerships with organizations like United Way, all of the not-for-profits, community\n               service providers that do absolutely incredible work in serving seniors and in continuing\n               to build out the long-term-care system here in British Columbia, one that is as high\n               a quality as can be expected and should be expected, with workers who are paid fairly,\n               who are treated fairly and who have the kind of workplace conditions that they need\n               to be able to support the seniors that they truly love working with and working for\n               and caring for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728997","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yesterday in estimates, we asked for some pretty specific numbers and what we got,\n               after some very long explanations and repeated attempts, were a few admissions that\n               should concern every British Columbian. The minister confirmed that more than 15,000 funded health care positions are currently\n               vacant, including 7,200 nursing positions. The minister conf","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22100dd8373e9aa77188f645933a688236569b222b916050faff5227b8b51e73","e9cdd46162635cc43ac27a41fcf3f7aca054b4287c169445ca3be659b9bf65ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0878c1844082ae7fdb6f83c8b4f1b8cc4370ad2e25da791009bb3d4e7b4aff18"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd7b1b80252a7451c168e3da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728999,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I note the minister did not talk about Burnaby in that statement. Yesterday it took\n               the minister over 25 minutes and two attempts to answer a basic question, so we'll\n               try again. To the minister: how many British Columbians are on the long-term wait-list today\n               in British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728999","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I note the minister did not talk about Burnaby in that statement. Yesterday it took\n               the minister over 25 minutes and two attempts to answer a basic question, so we'll\n               try again. To the minister: how many British Columbians are on the long-term wait-list today\n               in British Columbia?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["810303c622a627724baea1735ed3764aea1b2051226bd08a4eaad741ce0f6f09"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c009efa71850bdaa7dc49a5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752205,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to respond to the amendment from the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville. Frankly, this amendment is exactly the problem this motion is trying to address. The\n               motion before this House is simple. It says elected officials who make billion-dollar\n               decisions on behalf of British Columbians should have a basic understanding of economics,\n               public finance, debt, deficits, inflation, productivity and the cost of government\n               decisions. That should not be controversial to this House. But instead of debating that reasonable proposition, the government has done what\n               it so often does in this place. It has tried to turn a practical debate into a wedge\n               issue. It has tried to change the channel. It has tried to make out a basic motion\n               to be something far darker than it really is — the absolute horror of basic economics\n               education. But this motion is not about ideology. This is about competence. Nowhere is that more obvious than in health care. This government has spent years\n               announcing inputs — more money, more plans, more strategies, more press releases,\n               more ribbon cuttings. But the outputs tell a very different story. Emergency rooms\n               are still closing in rural British Columbia. Seniors are still stuck in hospital beds\n               because long-term-care capacity doesn't exist. According to the seniors advocate,\n               more than 7,000 British Columbians were waiting for long-term care in 2025. It is\n               now 7,800 this year, an average wait time of over a year. This is what happens when government confuses spending with results. A government\n               can spend more and deliver less. It can announce more and build less. It can hire\n               more administrators and still leave patients waiting, seniors stranded and families\n               desperate. That is why economic literacy matters, because debt has to be serviced. Deficits have\n               consequences. Capital delays cost money. When government mismanages major projects,\n               that is not government money being wasted. It is money earned by the people of British\n               Columbia. British Columbians do not need another amendment designed to turn a serious debate\n               into a partisan morality play. They need a Legislature that understands the real-world\n               consequences of the decisions it makes. That is what this motion is about, and that\n               is why I cannot support this amendment. I fully support the original motion as written.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752205","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to respond to the amendment from the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville. Frankly, this amendment is exactly the problem this motion is trying to address. The\n               motion before this House is simple. It says elected officials who make billion-dollar\n               decisions on behalf of British Columbians should have a basic understanding of economics,\n               public finance","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fbe85dcce16ad375a9c1c2d0dc1ea7a4eb56f9c2dd66a603c8dcf4855eb7e058"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c088b75f2b5cf388dfbe8808ff0080612d321155daf49e15b76c7e954d68384"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0484c9fb55771724fcf3879a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752206,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm glad the minister of ribbon cutting could get up and address his constituents, because we haven't heard a peep from him\n               as a long-term-care facility in his riding was....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752206","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm glad the minister of ribbon cutting could get up and address his constituents, because we haven't heard a peep from him\n               as a long-term-care facility in his riding was....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3056a7dd42d8a3412a0dd5e239af52de9b8f1a36fa9542f91aea93e6c6bf849b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3210a1ded342776f43bc24ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752207,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just wanted to take a moment to introduce my friend and constituent Brad Chappell.\n               He's here with Vancouver Island Cattlemen's. According to his colleagues with the\n               B.C. Cattlemen's, he's the only person that can run over an unlimited phone minute\n               plan. Please can the House make him feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752207","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just wanted to take a moment to introduce my friend and constituent Brad Chappell.\n               He's here with Vancouver Island Cattlemen's. According to his colleagues with the\n               B.C. Cattlemen's, he's the only person that can run over an unlimited phone minute\n               plan. Please can the House make him feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b65e6a642c7967c8314b903","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752208,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I think that's an excellent reminder because that is exactly\n               what this government should be doing with this terrible piece of legislation that\n               is an absolute affront to openness and transparency in the province of British Columbia. On that note, I rise in support of the motion before this House to kill this bill,\n               that the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled the Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the word \"now\"\n               and substituting \"six months hence,\" because that is exactly what this bill deserves. Currently in the province of British Columbia, six months is not enough time to get\n               an FOI return back. There are bigger problems than this bill is willing to address.\n               What this bill does is hide the truth from British Columbians across this province.\n               That should make everyone in British Columbia and in this House, on both sides of\n               this House, extremely worried. As I said in my previous speech on Bill 9, it'll be\n               a very different story when the Birkenstock is on the other foot. Now, what we need to do with this bill is scrap it, because we've seen from this minister\n               that changes are dramatic and changes are clearly required. This amendment that she's\n               proposing absolutely goes to the core of why the motion is so critically important\n               in this House today. It tacitly admits that this government got it wrong, that this\n               bill does not deserve to see the light of day, that it is not worthy of consideration\n               in this House and it does not fix the fundamental problems with freedom of information\n               in this province. This bill should not proceed. If it does proceed, it should proceed six months hence.\n               As Madam Speaker says, that will effectively kill this bill. That's the motion, that\n               is the argument, and I intend to keep coming back to it because this House should\n               not be distracted from the central point. The question before us is not whether the minister can still stand up and pretend\n               this was all a misunderstanding, that this was: \"It just slipped through. It was a\n               clerical error. I didn't see it.\" The question before us is whether Bill 9 should\n               move now or whether this government should be told to sit down, take six months and\n               come back with something that is workable for British Columbians, is in the benefit\n               of British Columbians and is in the benefit of transparency for democracy in the province\n               of B.C. This government doesn't need this motion to do that. This government could kill this\n               bill today on its own merits. They've admitted as much in their proposed amendments.\n               The government has already admitted the bill is a disaster, and that's what the amendments\n               mean. They can dress it up in whatever lipstick they like. They can call them clarifications,\n               they can call them targeted adjustments, they can call them minor refinements, tweaks,\n               nibbling around the edges, but the House knows exactly what they are. They are an admission, an admission that the bill they introduced was not ready to\n               see the light of day, should never have seen the light of day and was a mistake in\n               the first place. Now this government is desperate to try and show that they still\n               have the confidence of this House. I can tell you, Madam Speaker, they do not. This is an admission that this government, on a bill dealing with the public's right\n               to know, still couldn't get it right the first time. And when a government has to\n               start patching a freedom-of-information bill while second reading is still underway,\n               that is not a sign the House should hurry up and just pass it. It's a sign that the\n               House should say: \"Not now. Six months hence.\" Six months is not some procedural gimmick. Six months is what seriousness looks like\n               in the development of a bill, seriousness that was clearly not considered when this\n               bill was in its draft form. Six months means the government stops trying to repair\n               a bad bill in midair. Six months means it goes back to the drawing board, gets the\n               proper scrutiny that it should've had on the Six months means it goes back to the drawing board, gets the proper scrutiny that\n               it should have had on the first pass and comes back to this House in a way that is\n               presentable and acceptable to both the opposition and the people of British Columbia. Six months means it finally does the work that it should have done before, dragging\n               Bill 9 into this chamber unready. And six months means the public gets a chance to\n               examine something more than a rushed first draft and a panicked set of amendments\n               that they only came up with after massive push-back from members likely in their own\n               caucus — to the affront that this bill is to the democratic process and openness and\n               transparency in the province of British Columbia. That is why this motion matters, because this bill was not brought here in a condition\n               that deserves passage. Not now, but if the government chooses, they can fix this bill\n               and bring it back for real consideration. We do need to address problems with the\n               FOI system, backlogs in FOI. Right now, that system is truly broken. This government\n               cannot even disclose proactive disclosure on time. They are now three months behind.\n               Ministerial calendars — hidden. Non-compete contracts — hidden. This is not a government acting in good faith in the best interests of British Columbians.\n               This is a government that is desperate to change the channel. They think that these\n               amendments may do that. I am sorry to say to everybody in this House that that is\n               not the case. What needs to happen is this motion needs to be voted on. It needs to\n               pass, and this bill needs to be taken off the table and treated exactly the way it\n               should — shoved in a closet or taken to a draft table and started again. This bill proves the government thought it could get away with broad, vague, overreaching\n               language, slip it through the net, and only when people pushed back did the government\n               begin to retreat on this bill. That is not thoughtful law-making. That is a government\n               desperate to hide its failures. That is political damage control in a state I have\n               not seen since taking this House. And there has been some truly flawed legislation\n               put before this House. This bill takes the cake. That is why this House should tell the government: \"You do not get to salvage this\n               on the fly. You get to come back in six months and try again.\" Let us remember what freedom of information actually is. It is not some annoying administrative\n               burden. It is not some nuisance process for troublesome citizens. It is not an inconvenience\n               for ministers who would rather hide their calendars and their non-compete contracts\n               and internal records that may be damaging to the narrative that the government has\n               decided to spin. It is one of the only real tools the public has, and the opposition has, to force\n               truth out of the government. That is what it is. It is how journalists get past the\n               talking points and partial truths of press releases. It's how researchers get past\n               the spin and partial statistics of press releases. It's how opposition members get\n               beyond the press conference and into the actual documents, where the rubber meets\n               the road, where the promises meet results. It's how British Columbians find out what\n               government knew, when they knew it and what they were trying to hide. That is why governments that are short on answers are often tempted to tighten control,\n               especially as we see the end of a reign coming. All of those decisions are now on\n               the government of the day. And when the government of the day was the government also\n               of yesterday, the chickens tend to come home to roost. That's what Bill 9 looked like from the start, and that's why the answer is not passage\n               now. The answer is six months hence. If this bill were sound, the amendments proposed\n               by the minister would not be appearing in the order papers today. If this bill were\n               careful, these amendments would not be appearing today. If this bill were well drafted,\n               well-thought-out, and well rounded, these amendments would not be appearing today. If this bill sought to remedy the description that we heard initially from this minister,\n               we would not be having this discussion today. But it did not do that. This bill attacked the democratic process, openness and transparency in the province\n               of British Columbia, and now this government is desperately trying to change the channel\n               and turn the page. If this bill genuinely reflected the kind of transparency regime this government claims\n               that it wants, then this House would not be watching ministers scurry around trying\n               to sand down the roughest edges before a critical vote. And that is the point. The\n               amendment does not save this bill. That is the point. The amendment does not save this bill. They condemn this bill.\n               This motion condemns this bill. They tell this House the government itself knows the\n               original version couldn't withstand basic scrutiny. And if the original version could\n               not withstand scrutiny, then this House should not move it now. It should send it\n               away six months hence. One of the clearest examples of why six months is necessary is health care. Because\n               if there's one field in this province where freedom of information is not theoretical,\n               it is certainly health care. In health care, freedom of information is often the only\n               way to get past the slogans and net numbers. It is the only way to get past the ministerial\n               talking points. It is the only way to compare what government says publicly with what\n               its own internal records say privately. It casts a light on the state of the system.\n               That is information that should be the right of all British Columbians to access. Now what is the reality in health care today? Not timely access, not openness, not\n               a system functioning the way the law says it should. We are seeing health care FOIs\n               take roughly eight months to come back. Some, years. Eight months is not a modern\n               system of FOI disclosure. That is not a responsive, open, and transparent government\n               that is responsible to those that pay their bills and elected them to be here. That\n               is not transparency. That is a backlog so severe that the truth arrives after the\n               damage is done. What did this government decide to do in the face of that compounding failure? Did\n               it prove it could meet the standard already in the law before trying to change the\n               law itself? No. It brought forward Bill 9. That is exactly why this bill should not\n               proceed now. It should go away six months hence. The bill was already offensive enough on the formal FOI side, but even proactive disclosure,\n               as I described earlier, is falling behind. Three months behind in areas where government\n               is supposed to be proactively putting information into the public domain so that the\n               FOI system, which isn't collapsed, which is the point of this bill, can be avoided. If the government comes out and gives you the data, guess what goes away? The need\n               for freedom of information requests. Transparency should be the default setting of\n               government. We should not have to kick, pull and scream for basic disclosure out of\n               government. What did this government decide to do in the face of the failure of these backlogs?\n               Three months behind. This government now wants to tell the House that what it really needs to do is a new\n               bill touching access law. Nope. What it needs is six months to go back and explain\n               why it cannot even operate the system that it already has. That is why the motion\n               says \"six months hence.\" It kills this horrible, undemocratic bill. Health care is where we have used FOI again and again to shine a light on what this\n               government would rather leave in the dark. FOI is how both this opposition and members\n               of the public have brought records forward on emergency room closures. FOI is how\n               briefing materials, internal warnings, staffing realities and operational failures\n               come into clear focus. FOI is how the public gets beyond the stagecraft and the politics\n               and into the substance. Without FOI, people get the headline. With FOI, they get the truth behind the headline,\n               which is why this bill is so dangerous and needs to be killed today. And that is why\n               these amendments, even now, are simply not good enough. Because the government has\n               already shown us the instinct behind the bill. The instinct was not openness. The\n               instinct was not humility. The instinct was not to strengthen trust in our institutions.\n               The instinct was to manage scrutiny. A government with that instinct should not be rewarded with the passage of a damaging\n               bill like that now. It should be sent away for six months hence and killed. If this\n               House needs one more reason why Bill 9 should not proceed, but should be sent away,\n               the government cannot even manage the freedom of information system that it already\n               has. And that is not some abstract concern. That is not a theoretical concern. That\n               is not an opposition invention designed to grab headlines. It's not just us. The Green Party agrees with us. The press agrees with us. What's the saying? Don't pick a fight with people that buy ink by the barrel. Well,\n               you certainly have picked a fight with a group of people that buy ink by the barrel.\n               Or bandwidth at this point. And that is the lived reality of people who actually use\n               the system. The journalists that file those requests, the researchers who track That is the lived reality of people who actually use the system — the journalists\n               that file those requests, the researchers who track ministries, the advocates who\n               are trying to get records. The ordinary citizen is just trying to find out what the\n               government is doing in their name with their dollars. They're actively tracking these\n               delays. Many people have reached out to me over the FOI requests. Many people who do deep\n               dives into the state of health care in British Columbia and rely on a functional,\n               efficient and reasonably expedient FOI system so that we can have eyes on what is\n               going on in our province. What are they finding? That FOI returns are not coming back\n               in anything close to a reasonable time — not 30 days, not promptly, not in a way that\n               makes the right to freedom of access meaningful. They are stretching out towards a\n               year — eight months, on average. Just stop to think about what eight months are. We're only asking for a six-month\n               delay with this motion. Eight months to get records from a government in a system\n               that is supposed to be built around timely public access. Eight months is not a delay.\n               Eight months is a culture that has been built by this government. Eight months is\n               not a hiccup; eight months is a management failure. Eight months means the truth arrives\n               after the decision is made, after the damage is done, after the 24-7 headline has\n               moved on, and after the minister has already stood up in this House, delivered talking\n               points, and hopes that that information doesn't get out in time to damage them further. That is not access to information; that is access to stale information. It does not\n               help steer decisions, it does not improve transparency, and it needs to be fixed.\n               That is a government making sure that by the time the records arrive, they're no longer\n               politically dangerous. I refer back to many conversations about limousine rides, gift cards and the like.\n               I know it's a sensitive topic in this time of austerity with a $13.3 billion budget.\n               Now the same government wants this House to believe that what we really need is Bill\n               9. No, what the system needs is not Bill 9. What the system needs is a six-month delay\n               — and as the Speaker so rightly pointed out — which would, in effect, kill this terribly\n               damaging bill in the province of B.C., to the benefit of all British Columbians. Six months to ask a very basic question. If returns are stretching to eight months\n               already, why is the government touching the law before it fixes the administration?\n               Perhaps that's the real issue here. Perhaps what this government should be looking\n               at is not how to give the department more tools, more language and more direction\n               for cover. Perhaps what we should be looking at is the management of the department\n               itself, because if the people using the system are telling us that requests are taking\n               the better part of a year, then something is clearly wrong with the FOI system. That is how this bill was sold to this House. \"We're going to fix the system. This\n               will speed it up.\" What was buried in there was: \"We're going to speed it up by just\n               doing less, because you don't deserve the information. We are not willing to be transparent\n               with the province of British Columbia. We are ashamed of our record, and we are going\n               to hide from it.\" Very, very shocking, very sad, but very telling of a government\n               that is out of ideas and running from its very own record. If people are using the system are telling you that these requests are going wrong,\n               you need to deal with it. Is it staffing? Is it workflow? Is it prioritizing FOIs?\n               Badly wrong — something is badly wrong with the basic administrative culture of our\n               freedom-of-information system here in B.C., because the default setting on government\n               should be transparency, not obfuscation. That is before we even get to proactive disclosure. I'm going to keep hitting on that,\n               because I know it's a sensitive subject for many ministers here. Proactive disclosure\n               is supposed to reduce the pressure on the formal FOI system. That is the theory of\n               proactive disclosure. If a government proactively releases materials in a timely way,\n               then fewer people need to file far-reaching requests in the first place. And the people\n               that do have an idea of where to start looking. If there's a questionable meeting in a ministerial calendar, they can request those\n               records. If there is a meeting with a drug company, they can specify they would like\n               information on that meeting, not go on a broad, sweeping, dragnet search, wasting\n               people's time. I will agree with you. I have gotten many, many FOIs back myself that were a complete\n               waste of both my and the bureaucrats' time. You know why? Because the document I knew\n               was there that I had a copy of, which was handed to me by a concerned citizen, was\n               covered in nothing but black lines. That If government proactively releases materials in a timely way, then fewer people need\n               to find those requests in the first place. But what's happening there? That is behind,\n               too, not by a few days, not by a harmless little lag, again, by nearly three months.\n               Three months behind on proactive — and I'll say the word again — proactive disclosure. We've got the front door jammed up, the side door is now jammed up, and the formal\n               FOI process is bogged down. The proactive disclosure stream is bogged down, and the\n               government's answer is not to clean the house, not to tighten management, not to restore\n               performance, not to properly resource the department, not to ask what on earth is\n               happening — in a department run by a former deputy minister, I might add, from Newfoundland\n               — who clearly understands the troublesome, pesky annoyance of what can happen when\n               disclosure is set to open as a default. This government's answer was Bill 9, which is why this motion — and I'll come back\n               to it so I do not get called out of order — looks to push this six months hence and\n               kill this terrible, destructive bill. That is one more reason that this House should\n               support this motion and say that this bill should not proceed now, because six months\n               would allow this House and the public to ask the questions that really matter. Consult\n               the stakeholders that have been affected. Do the actual work on this bill to get it\n               right. If we have a problem with the process and the bureaucracy operating behind this bill\n               and the function of this bill in reality, let's have that conversation. But let's\n               not do it behind closed doors. Having a closed-door conversation on a freedom-of-information\n               bill is, to say the least.... I'll leave it there. Why are the requests taking eight months? That's a question that this government should\n               ask. Who is tracking that performance? Again, we should be asking that. Who is accountable\n               for that performance? Well, actually, in fact, it is this government that is responsible\n               for that performance. And that performance is that proactive disclosure is now taking\n               three months. Ministerial calendars, non-compete contracts and the like, all forcibly\n               and legislatively required to be disclosed, are now being dragged. That is not including\n               FOIs that are just in the queue taking eight months. That is ministers hiding. Hiding from public scrutiny. You should be ashamed, truly,\n               truly ashamed. Before any of that has been honestly dealt with, is this government asking for legislative\n               changes instead of managerial compliance? Are we trying to legislate changes onto\n               a department that what they really need is new management? I think that's a question\n               we should ask, and I believe six months may be the appropriate time required to answer\n               that question. I did google a few things on my way over here. I was looking for some good examples\n               of things that would take six months to do. I've got some very interesting examples.\n               Dostoyevsky wrote The Gambler in 26 days. That's a fairly considerable and lengthy classic. The Apollo 8 planning\n               and training mission to the moon was completed in four months, much less than the\n               six months we're asking for here. The Alaska Highway took just over six months, at\n               7.7, 1,700 kilometres from border to border. They got an entire highway built. I believe we can probably fix this flawed legislation in six months, bring it back\n               and pass it. Because if we've got enough time to fight a war, land on the moon, negotiate\n               an armistice, write a novel, we should probably be able to fix a fairly simple, straightforward\n               housekeeping bill that should have been a fairly straightforward housekeeping bill.\n               But that is not what this bill was. This bill tried to backdoor opaqueness and remove scrutiny on a government desperate,\n               desperate to change the page. If that's the case, this bill should not proceed now. It should come back, if it comes back at all, six months hence, after the government\n               has demonstrated that it can manage the system it already controls before it dares\n               ask this House for more breathing room and room to manoeuvre, more ability to cover\n               up what they're already covering up, more ability to hide from their own performance\n               problems. If the existing system is taking eight months to over a year to produce basic records\n               of government and proactive disclosure is now three months behind, then the first\n               reform this government should undertake is not If the existing system is taking eight months to over a year to produce basic records\n               of government, and proactive disclosure is now three months behind, then the first\n               reform this government should undertake is not legislative; it's managerial, it's\n               administrative, and it is cultural. Until that work is done, this House should be\n               very wary of letting this government touch this important law at all — again, not\n               now; six months hence. Another reason we need six months is because this file was already studied. This is\n               not a new issue to this House. There was a special committee. There was a 2022 report\n               by that special committee. There were already recommendations on how to improve British\n               Columbia's access and privacy laws, while strengthening transparency and accountability. What possible excuse does this government have? This government issued that 2022 report.\n               This House loves to use the Wayback Machine, so let's go way back to 2022 and ask\n               ourselves who the government was in 2022. Certainly, I feel dusting that off might\n               be a start. It cannot say there was no roadmap. It cannot say there was no prior work. It cannot\n               say no one had thought seriously about FOI reform. All of that had already existed,\n               which means the case for six months is even stronger. The problem was not a lack of\n               time before introduction; the problem was that the government had used that time badly. Even if some of those recommendations made it into Bill 9, this government decided\n               to try and back-door the ability to hide more information from British Columbians,\n               not allow more visibility on that information to British Columbians. That is why this\n               government needs to be punished for their poor decision-making. You don't go to war\n               with people that buy ink by the gallon. So when the government uses its time badly, this House should not reward it. It should\n               let that government take another six months to try and do the job properly. I want\n               to keep tying this back to the original motion, because I know the government members\n               will try to pull the debate somewhere else. They will want to say, \"Well, surely the member agrees that some reform is needed.\"\n               Yes, I don't disagree. I don't disagree that reform is needed, but that reform needs\n               to improve transparency, not reduce transparency. \"Well, surely the member sees some merit in in parts of the bill.\" That's not the\n               question before us today. The question is whether this bill should proceed now in\n               the shape that it's in, and that answer is clearly no. The minister has admitted that\n               that's clearly no, by tabling amendments before committee has even started, trying\n               desperately to get an independent or two to jump on board and prop this government\n               up. We're not going to let you do that. We're not going to let you do that. The amendments prove the concerns of this side of the House were real. The concerns\n               of all the stakeholders were real. Because those concerns were real, this House should\n               not proceed now; it should proceed six months hence. That is the motion, that is the\n               test, and that is the standard. One of the most revealing things here has been tone. The government's tone has not\n               been grateful that people read the bill carefully. It has not been reflective; it\n               has not been humble; it has been irritated that people noticed, irritated that people\n               objected, irritated that the broad overreach in this bill was actually recognized\n               for exactly what it was — a government trying to hide from their terrible, decades-long\n               record and hide from British Columbians. Now having tabled amendments, the government still wants to act like it's no big deal:\n               \"Nothing serious here, nothing to see.\" This pretty much describes Bill 9 in a nutshell:\n               \"Nothing to see here, just a simple housekeeping bill, just affecting the transparency\n               that we're terrible at, by default, and that now we're not even doing by legislated\n               proactive disclosure. No, no, we'll just try to slide a few more so we can delay and\n               defer longer.\" That is why, Madam Speaker, the six months' delay, as you said, kills this bill. That is exactly what this House needs to do. This House needs to accept this motion,\n               kill this bill, go back to the drawing board and come back to British Columbians with\n               something that works in the benefit of all British Columbians, not just government,\n               because this side of the House believes that the default setting of government should\n               be open and transparent. You are responsible for the finances and the decisions being\n               made here, but it is the people of British Columbia that will keep you honest. Honesty is driven by the ability for the citizens to access information in a timely,\n               meaningful way, to ensure that you're not hiding behind press releases; you're hiding\n               behind deliverables. On that, this government has failed. By every measure in health care, things are going backwards in health care. Things\n               are going backwards in affordability. Food bank use is probably the only By every measure in health care, things are going backwards in health care. Things\n               are going backwards in affordability. Food bank use is probably the only metric that\n               is rising rapidly under this British Columbian government currently. So in conclusion, I fully support this motion, and I believe that this government\n               has the opportunity to not take a step forward that they ring a bell that they will\n               be unable to ring should they pass this terrible bill. You will wear that, and the\n               worst part about it is the next government will have the same lack of transparency\n               applied do it and you will be the ones that laid the trap.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752208","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I think that's an excellent reminder because that is exactly\n               what this government should be doing with this terrible piece of legislation that\n               is an absolute affront to openness and transparency in the province of British Columbia. On that note, I rise in support of the motion before this House to kill this bill,\n               that the motio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c62a622e6641e31f050e2c6c1a1b9fbd9571cfe6f9360a48b64f801c56d95a1c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0bebb6f94ba501f72a7b1ab649f35b914da4e89aa7ef1a2ee1fac0ebaccb86c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a085028f96ecf13ca0b6eef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752209,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"Very, very quiet from the five members of the NDP from Burnaby. Today is McHappy Day, a day when Canadians step up to support families with seriously\n               ill children.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752209","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Very, very quiet from the five members of the NDP from Burnaby. Today is McHappy Day, a day when Canadians step up to support families with seriously\n               ill children.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","label":"Family law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4dbbade4c837e503e2ac7a299f6a02ada449661777113bcd96ba85489f5968f7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75d0bd1f065afdb0ce83865f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017250,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think we may have a different definition of clear. Another court case is in front of the courts now due to this government's inaction\n               on DRIPA. The Lillooet First Nation owns the Rockford hydro project near Whistler\n               and are unhappy with the terms brought by this government. They claimed B.C. Hydro\n               failed to consult and are now taking this government to court again. Using DRIPA, the Lillooet are demanding a whopping 48 percent increase in their power\n               generation payment because they are First Nation–owned. DRIPA is consistently being\n               used as a weapon in courts in this province when talks break down with this government. To the Minister of Indigenous Relations, because we now have to guess, is this one of the 20 court cases amended due to the\n               Gitxaała decision?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017250","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think we may have a different definition of clear. Another court case is in front of the courts now due to this government's inaction\n               on DRIPA. The Lillooet First Nation owns the Rockford hydro project near Whistler\n               and are unhappy with the terms brought by this government. They claimed B.C. Hydro\n               failed to consult and are now taking this government t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bac786bab421b9321715979a0fec4a7b94b3d23c4658bb03f1ceef05c2124f72"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["37326760dd994f05462b96737ecaff3783099666ee6dfd30204460ca4f1a0889"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9732c796173f6056c4cbaa26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036443,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my privilege today to introduce Trevor and Karen Stevenson and their son, Dash,\n               from the Comox Valley. They are extremely active in the agricultural community with\n               Comox Valley Farmers Institute. Would the House make them, please, feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036443","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my privilege today to introduce Trevor and Karen Stevenson and their son, Dash,\n               from the Comox Valley. They are extremely active in the agricultural community with\n               Comox Valley Farmers Institute. Would the House make them, please, feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e28fc0b887cb75f13f1a6319b67296b7d7506ed72165d25461a9fe7b891a13c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5aebf2627990a1aca0f063867ee1f91b742691abf3c29328cc44efdb7b8e2b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8cf3d7bd3e3a6dda3973ade","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036444,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to wish my brother, Ian, a happy 39th birthday. I've committed not to\n               discuss who in the family got the looks, the charm and the brains, but he's had a\n               very big year welcoming another daughter. I wish him all the best.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036444","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to wish my brother, Ian, a happy 39th birthday. I've committed not to\n               discuss who in the family got the looks, the charm and the brains, but he's had a\n               very big year welcoming another daughter. I wish him all the best.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f4be7691e5caab19e08f9ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036445,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brennan Day","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome Concrete B.C. into the gallery. They're up top there. Give\n               a wave, guys. Eric Anderson, Terrance Byrd, Matt DeVries, Glen Furtado, Dean Neufeld, Greg Parker,\n               Carly Pisterzi, Ryan Mathwig and Jason Saunderson. Ryan actually is a former colleague\n               of mine. So fantastic to see them in there and all they do to build B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036445","member_id":"bc-mla-367","member_name":"Brennan Day","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome Concrete B.C. into the gallery. They're up top there. Give\n               a wave, guys. Eric Anderson, Terrance Byrd, Matt DeVries, Glen Furtado, Dean Neufeld, Greg Parker,\n               Carly Pisterzi, Ryan Mathwig and Jason Saunderson. Ryan actually is a former colleague\n               of mine. So fantastic to see them in there and all they do to build B.C.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb404733f5e9ba358169ba108d4b80f26b8dde6d8d3ae5178bc7fe325423f24e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71ff74904b6ff090b93bdc95","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317214,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to speak about a serious issue that threatens trust and reconciliation\n               in Canada: the spread of misinformation about residential schools. Residential school denialism doesn't usually deny the existence of these institutions.\n               Instead, it distorts history, downplays abuses and questions survivors to protect\n               the colonial legacies. This misinformation harms not only survivors and their families\n               but all of us by obscuring the truth and delaying the healing our country still needs. To stop this, we need truth-telling at the centre of education, teaching the full\n               story, grounded in evidence and survivors' testimony. Schools, workplaces and communities\n               must create space for honest discussions about the residential school system's legacy. We also need to support Indigenous-led education organizations that counter denial\n               directly. Every person in Canada can play a role by challenging the misinformation when they\n               see it, by learning from survivors and by refusing to amplify denialism voices. Public institutes and media outlets must apply standards of accountability, ensuring\n               facts are protected from distortion. And as some have called for, we must consider\n               strong measures to protect survivors from hate and denialism online. Reconciliation depends on truth. Confronting misinformation Reconciliation depends on truth. Confronting misinformation is not only about correcting\n               history; it's about honouring those who lived it and ensuring their stories are never\n               erased again, like my mother's.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317214","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I want to speak about a serious issue that threatens trust and reconciliation\n               in Canada: the spread of misinformation about residential schools. Residential school denialism doesn't usually deny the existence of these institutions.\n               Instead, it distorts history, downplays abuses and questions survivors to protect\n               the colonial legacies. This misinfo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","label":"Corruption","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["941af17e36cdba62cedc75c3549a38ff2828b2c6633a40c12ecb40ca221e69c7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef613985e4785639e0678c84e11e75e9ab090c01fdcb61a04a29e4610660c90f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f1fce46b63496e20cb6274ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328059,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"C ommittee of Supply, A, reports progress on the estimates of Ministry of Attorney General\n               and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328059","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"C ommittee of Supply, A, reports progress on the estimates of Ministry of Attorney General\n               and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1212f96d32737f6fd4e45cda","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328060,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills and asks leave to sit\n               again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328060","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Post-Secondary Education and Future Skills and asks leave to sit\n               again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d709ece352adb12df275af6922fedbabf53c17e82fda2fe3a50f89deb5a84062"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9404635085ec05b6b2578588f642075f85cb28e8cba94d1f304cf854589d1327"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b1d1e796c6a842b2036f30a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328061,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"My nephew James was on a waiting list for a kidney. We had hoped just over a year\n               ago that his cousin was a match, but then during the screening process, she found\n               out she was pregnant. So different options were started and pursued. He received a\n               call on December 27, 2025, and had the surgery on December 29. I know not everyone has the same outcome, as I have witnessed over the many times\n               over the 20 years, with community members not receiving the call and passing away.\n               Every year in British Columbia, hundreds of people are waiting, like my nephew, to\n               receive that call that could save their life. In British Columbia, more than a million people have already registered their intent\n               to be donors through B.C. Transplant. That's encouraging, but we can do better. There\n               are still many more people waiting than there are organs available. Each registration\n               donor has the potential to save up to eight lives and improve many more through tissue\n               donation. Registration is easy. It takes just a few minutes online — register.transplant.bc.ca.\n               What takes the longest is the conversation with your loved ones so they know your\n               wishes when it comes, and that matters most. Organ donation isn't just about medicine or policy. It's about compassion and community.\n               When one person says yes to donation, it ripples out, saving patients, comforting\n               families and strengthening our shared humanity. Today, I invite you to take the small but powerful step: register. I have. Talk about\n               it. Inspire others. Together we can turn waiting lists into second chances and transform\n               loss into the ultimate gift. Together we can turn waiting lists into second chances and transform loss into the\n               ultimate gift, life.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328061","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"My nephew James was on a waiting list for a kidney. We had hoped just over a year\n               ago that his cousin was a match, but then during the screening process, she found\n               out she was pregnant. So different options were started and pursued. He received a\n               call on December 27, 2025, and had the surgery on December 29. I know not everyone has the same outcome, as ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","label":"Transplantation (Medicine)"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","label":"Organ transplantation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","label":"Organ transplantation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd2960f3b3659fd48b77388f4cca2ac040a44875832eeff33a22d83c903fd276"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b2898a49ec2fdfeff016545a00436da132d9711e6cb0ceda9c1a5e8a7d4997c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transplantation (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Organ transplantation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036552","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036554","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85bffe551ca0c56d1fee7ee8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328062,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I start, this is the first time I've been able to share this, so I wanted to\n               share my deep condolences for the community of Tumbler Ridge. We were heartbroken\n               by the devastating tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. I'm sorry I'm fumbling through the words.\n               I spoke with my sister-in-law, and her friend had lost her daughter that night. Our thoughts are with the community and with those who are grieving, the loved ones,\n               those who are recovering, the first responders and everyone whose lives have been\n               forever changed. We are all grateful for the work of the police officers, the first\n               responders, health care workers, teachers and the school staff, who showed bravery\n               beyond measure. Their commitment reflected the very best of who we are. Thank you. I would like to start by acknowledging the lək̓wəŋən Peoples, the Songhees and Esquimalt\n               Nations, upon whose territory we are gathered here today. Budget 2026 makes careful choices to protect what matters most and secure B.C.'s future.\n               There is so much I could speak about in this budget. I will share highlights in the\n               Cowichan Valley. Eight years ago, people in the Cowichan Valley sent a clear message: fix what is broken,\n               invest in people, and make sure this beautiful valley is not left behind. Under this\n               Premier and this government, we have been doing exactly that. This year's 2026 budget\n               keeps us on that path. The most visible symbol of that change is on the hill above Duncan — the new Cowichan\n               District Hospital. After decades of talk and delay under the previous governments,\n               our government approved the concept plan in 2018, the business plan in 2020, awarded\n               the contract in 2022 and has been steadily building ever since. The nine-storey, 204-bed hospital will more than double emergency space, expand operating\n               rooms from four to seven, add advanced imaging including a built-in MRI, and provide\n               a 20-bed patient psychiatric unit with a psychiatric intensive care unit. Budget 2026 keeps this project on track as part of nearly $38 billion in capital investment\n               in hospitals, schools and transit across the province, with Cowichan named specifically\n               among the major hospital builds. Construction is anticipated to be completed in 2026,\n               with the doors opening to patients in 2027, meaning people here will soon receive\n               quality of care they deserve close to home. The new Cowichan Urgent and Primary Care Centre in Duncan is a big step forward as\n               well. With over $12 million in start-ups and improvements and a team of 30 health\n               professionals, families will see fast access to care and less pressures on the emergency\n               rooms. We're also continuing the low, no-cost counselling through the house of friendship,\n               because mental health matters. I just wanted to share that I did have a chat with a constituent of mine that accessed\n               the Cowichan Urgent and Primary Care. They were very impressed of the service that\n               was provided and very happy that they didn't have to wait any longer to see someone.\n               So that was great. Over the last eight years, this government has built the supports that families in\n               the Cowichan Valley count on, from schools to child care to youth and mental health.\n               The new Cowichan Secondary School that opened in my riding in January and upgrading\n               schools province wide through billions in capital funding for seismic upgrades and\n               enrolment growth, including a fast-growing community like ours. Our child care budget 2026 adds another $330 million to stabilize the child care system,\n               helping keep spaces open and affordable for parents in communities like Duncan, North\n               Cowichan, Cowichan Bay and Lake Cowichan, with 238 open or soon-to-be open child care\n               spaces. At the same time, Cowichan has been selected as a phase 3 community for integrated\n               child and youth teams, bringing multidisciplinary, community-based mental health,\n               substance use support for kids and youth through Island Health, the school district\n               79, Ministry of Children and Family Development, and the partners like family smart.\n               These are not abstract programs; they are the counselling in our schools, the clinicians\n               visiting families and the culturally rooted support for First Nations, Métis and Inuit\n               children and youth across the valley. With work between the province and Cowichan tribes and local organizations, the youth\n               emergency shelter in Duncan was opened, which provided safe space for youth in the\n               community. I was just in estimates chairing and listening to the Minister of Education and Child\n               Care. Budget 2026 includes $634 million in new funding for teachers, school, student\n               services and to support inclusive learning as the number of inclusive learning students\n               enrolled is on the rise. So $169 million invested in the classroom enhancement fund\n               will result in more teachers for everyone, as well as special education–educated teachers and teachers-psychologists and counselors. As I said, I was listening to a passionate debate on the estimates and how important As I said, I was listening to a passionate debate on the estimates and how important\n               it is for us to continue this work and supporting child care and K-to-2 education.\n               Another $3.9 billion in capital funding is allocated for seismic replacements and\n               upgrades, as well as projects to address enrolment growth in B.C.'s fast-growing communities. Budget 2026 provides a $330 million lift to ChildCareBC to stabilize the programs\n               and services that families rely on as government works to modernize B.C.'s child care\n               system. This stabilization is critical as provinces and territories continue negotiations\n               with the federal government to deliver flexibility and resilience across the system.\n               This funding will maintain lower fees and the spaces and support for operators and\n               educators achieved over the past eight years. During this stabilization period, the\n               province will work to bring more equity into the system. After hearing from operators that currently funded models limit their flexibility\n               to support high-quality inclusive care, the province will pause the enrolment for\n               new providers into operating funding models and the $10-a-day ChildCareBC program. During the stabilization, people, family and providers currently\n               in the $10-a-day program will see no changes. Cowichan is a rural region with deep Indigenous history, and our government has treated\n               that as a strength to build on, not a barrier. As Parliamentary Secretary for Rural\n               Health and as MLA for the Cowichan Valley, I have worked to make sure rural voices in Indigenous communities are at the centre\n               of the provincial decisions from primary care access to culturally safe services.\n               In the last eight years, we have seen landmark steps in reconciliation in this valley,\n               including the historic 312-hectare land transfer near Skutz Falls to Lyackson and\n               Cowichan Tribes, work that this government helped lead with local nations to restore\n               culturally significant land and support true land-based healing and economic opportunity. Another historical moment was the agreement with Canada and the province. Cowichan\n               reclaimed the right to govern their children and family services. This was a historic\n               pathway forward for children and families. As I had been a witness at the ceremony,\n               it was so heartfelt to see the children dancing and celebrating this historical moment\n               and the Elders also being there to witness this. Our government's approach to reconciliation\n               here is not just about words. Indigenous-led housing, watershed stewardship in the\n               Cowichan, and the skills training rooted in Indigenous knowledge and prosperity.... Budget 2026 continues to prioritize health, education and social services as the main\n               areas of new spending so that rural communities like ours do not have to choose between\n               reconciliation, health care and economic opportunities. People in the Cowichan Valley\n               know that a healthy community also needs good jobs and a resilient local economy.\n               Over the past eight years, this government has raised the minimum wage, lowered ICBC\n               rates for drivers and invested in new industry and skills training so that working\n               people could build a life here. Through the rural economic diversity and infrastructure program, more than $1 million\n               has been invested directly into the Cowichan Valley projects: $500,000 for the economic\n               development Cowichan tech initiative I'm going to circle back after I say this next one. It's $500,000 for North Cowichan\n               to service industrial land and attract new employees. I just wanted to touch on the circular economy project. Duncan Paving was a really\n               good example of businesses or people just thinking about: \"Do I really want to get\n               into this circular economy? What is it all about?\" I was a witness to one of the meetings where this fellow got up and talked about it\n               and found out how easy it was. It was at a North Cowichan meeting. He just said how\n               easy it was to implement it into his business. He was looking forward to meeting up\n               with this lady that was helping him find new ways to save money and also making it\n               fun. I just wanted to share that fun story because when we think about changing things\n               or doing something new and we hear about it, it can be anxiety. All of these different\n               things can creep in. You could be afraid to try something new and not know if it would\n               be disastrous or not. I want to take a moment to share a story. Oh, sorry, I just did. I put it in my speech\n               already. But I will go on to say that the Duncan Paving Co. participated by processing milled\n               asphalt, repurposing on-site materials like tires and pallets and using reclaimed\n               asphalt in new designs. Those are just some of the examples that I had written down\n               here. I didn't realize that I included it in my speech. He also shared that he was\n               quite excited to incorporate more, so that's great. These are practical, on-the-ground investments that create jobs and support small\n               businesses and help us transition to a more sustainable regional economy. The province has taken action on all fronts in enforcement, housing, health and justice.\n               To stop the cycle of crime and get people the help they need to make the B.C. community\n               strong and safe for everyone, Budget 2026 provides $139 million over three years to\n               reduce repeat violent offending and chronic property crime and support timely access\n               to justice. This includes $73 million to continue to improve access to the justice system and\n               support court operations, including sheriff recruitments and retention, Crown counsel\n               and judiciary legal aid and the B.C. prosecution service; $16 million for the new\n               chronic property offending intervention initiative that strengthens monitoring and\n               enforcement for crimes such as vandalism and shoplifting that are hurting businesses;\n               $26 million for repeat violent offenders intervention initiatives, for which early\n               evaluations show the program is resulting in significant fewer police interactions\n               and faster charge approvals for high-risk violent offenders. There is also $24 million for the continuum of the special investigation and targeted\n               enforcement program and the community safety and targeted enforcement program, both\n               which provide valuable resources to police to combat repeat violent offenders and\n               address street disorder and I know this is going to be really welcomed in our North Cowichan detachment, which\n               is a new police station, but that's a story for another day. We're supporting growth and diversity: $1.4 million for the Canadian Bavarian millwork in Chemainus and $1.5 million for projects in tech initiatives and agricultural training. These\n               investments protect existing jobs and create new ones. Here are some highlights for the forestry workers for Budget 2026. Expanding skills and training. Apprenticeship and support. And the budget puts money\n               towards training and working for in-demand jobs, especially in trades and technical fields. Skills and trades training: $283 million over three years. The budget builds on the\n               employee training grant, which helps employers pay for training apprentices and workers. A new $400 million B.C. Strategic Investment Special Account will enable B.C. to quickly take advantage of the opportunities to work with the\n               federal government as it invests billions of dollars to defend Canada's sovereignty. Creating jobs and economic opportunities. This special account will help the province\n               attract investments that leverage B.C.'s strength in the sector, such as clean energy,\n               sustainable forest manufacturing, responsible mining and clean technology. Budget 2026 invests over $40 million over three years to remove barriers and avoid\n               duplications in permitting, including forest and resource permits, with the goal of slashing permitting backlogs\n               and reducing duplications and shortening timelines. The other thing that I wanted to highlight. The largest investment last year in my\n               riding was $74 million in building nearly 200 homes for Quw'utsun Tribes at the rivers edge, which will help ease the critical housing shortage; and the 92-unit co-op housing development on Sherman road and North Cowichan. These are the two projects that I know about when I was sitting at North Cowichan\n               as a councillor, so I just wanted to share those things that have moved forward. I know these projects\n               take time, and I was just glad to be a witness to that moving forward. This 2026 budget is not about starting something new or from scratch. It is about\n               finishing the work people here asked us to do eight years ago. It keeps the new Cowichan District Hospital on schedule, strengthens child care and youth mental health, supports rural health and reconciliation and continues to diversify our local economy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328062","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Before I start, this is the first time I've been able to share this, so I wanted to\n               share my deep condolences for the community of Tumbler Ridge. We were heartbroken\n               by the devastating tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. I'm sorry I'm fumbling through the words.\n               I spoke with my sister-in-law, and her friend had lost her daughter that night. Our thoughts are with ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c1ab228b90467a4715b17701b7d4a8a5c07eded00b2017d704c9f8869cbacee8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97b355a3e3e1b4f55c08fd14e16ab7e1170646f01aa58f5734a44e1ef71f5758"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96ed6a00d87f8d16a41fdcf9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361198,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to speak about what International Women's Day means to an Indigenous\n               woman. For many Indigenous women, this day is both a celebration and a challenge. It is a\n               day to honour the strength in monarchs, knowledge-keepers and land defenders whose","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361198","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I rise to speak about what International Women's Day means to an Indigenous\n               woman. For many Indigenous women, this day is both a celebration and a challenge. It is a\n               day to honour the strength in monarchs, knowledge-keepers and land defenders whose","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Monarchy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","label":"Monarchy","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["667c9fee4cf0624976235fb71375e256faf855af82ad8b462e295b70de882717"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0688fcd847011456b3ad54f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415835,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of Ministry of Forests and reports progress on the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415835","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of Ministry of Forests and reports progress on the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b837c730964d8ae6eacfce2aee5f70fc7450ea56f84f0b82b8217c075fb2af89"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0699d8fa2df2e348a62f5850","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415837,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"There are few places on earth as breathtaking as the Cowichan Valley. Nestled between\n               the mountains and the sea, our valley offers a harmony of natural beauty and warm\n               community spirit that's hard to put into words but easy to feel the moment you arrive. From the rolling vineyards and orchards that catch the morning light to the glimmering\n               waters of Cowichan Bay, this land inspires gratitude every day. The forest From the rolling vineyards and orchards that catch the morning light to the glimmering\n               waters of Cowichan Bay, this land inspires gratitude every day. The forest breath\n               with ancient cedars and towering firs.... Our fields, lakes and rivers provide abundance\n               that sustains both body and soul. But what makes Cowichan truly beautiful isn't only the scenery; it's the people who\n               care for this place. Generations of farmers, artists, knowledge keepers and neighbours\n               have worked together to protect its spirit. The deep roots of the Cowichan Tribes\n               remind us that this beauty has been cherished since time immemorial and that we share\n               a sacred responsibility to protect it for those who come after us. In every sunrise over the Mount Tzouhalem, every herring lifting from the estuary and every act of kindness between our neighbours,\n               we see what makes Cowichan extraordinary — a place where nature, history and heart\n               meet.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415837","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"There are few places on earth as breathtaking as the Cowichan Valley. Nestled between\n               the mountains and the sea, our valley offers a harmony of natural beauty and warm\n               community spirit that's hard to put into words but easy to feel the moment you arrive. From the rolling vineyards and orchards that catch the morning light to the glimmering\n               waters of Cow","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","label":"Natural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","label":"Natural heritage","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["699bcb21951d3f956c830251a8156007a17a8e46c754ab0ee1849c90641abd3c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f0e5a1e2cb30a69337eeef26513d7773999ea2b6ebb5aa23186d7429efbc8ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5892efc43483db98297ae13e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415838,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction and seeks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415838","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction and seeks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbd75eea83acac572086fd10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415839,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I will try to make this quick. I'd like to introduce Declan Williams, Leo Chen, co-chairs of the B.C. Youth Council;\n               as well as Antonio and Yanny DiNardo, director of youth engagement initiatives; and\n               his team, Maslow Low, Madison Perrault, Sarah Black and Colin Sparks. The B.C. Youth Council is an organization dedicated to increasing youth engagement\n               and participation in politics through regional youth councils and initiatives like\n               today's session on youth homelessness. They work to help Members of the Legislative\n               Assembly connect directly with young people in their communities. Please join me in welcoming all of them here to the House today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415839","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I will try to make this quick. I'd like to introduce Declan Williams, Leo Chen, co-chairs of the B.C. Youth Council;\n               as well as Antonio and Yanny DiNardo, director of youth engagement initiatives; and\n               his team, Maslow Low, Madison Perrault, Sarah Black and Colin Sparks. The B.C. Youth Council is an organization dedicated to increasing youth en","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0066071540bb604c3e901aa62dd8bb60475c7b566afa6448c4741f1abc5b345d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4046b925dcac7d6ae7e58c02f2cd05eba660f8690c3b04be91e6e180c20db850"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-824c3a7f0d8da34327bc20ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720620,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720620","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ab4163fa62b0a4622dfd1aab379268c652ad343b76d9378d6bc6d74ae9f74bb","ba87be572b0d3f65ffe8ef37f448155e6c46b714069f9eaa2b27643b62558b73"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef08cae82513585384537baf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720625,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 11 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720625","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 11 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6dc830210267eb7e56a47989","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720630,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to recognize the Cowichan Capitals, a team that means so much to our community.\n               For years the Caps have brought excitement, pride, and a strong sense of local spirit\n               to Duncan and the Cowichan Valley.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720630","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to recognize the Cowichan Capitals, a team that means so much to our community.\n               For years the Caps have brought excitement, pride, and a strong sense of local spirit\n               to Duncan and the Cowichan Valley.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62e636394625582d2fb21ad0a353f86e9d909a1f3014d6d58fc05d4a2e40cc88"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b65324eb8edec1706d4f752","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720633,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here in B.C., we're proud of our forest sector, but we know we cannot keep going without\n               addressing the pressures facing the sector. Our path forward for forestry means a\n               B.C. Timber Sales, BCTS, that moves fibre faster, creates more opportunities for workers\n               and contractors and ensures local logs go to local mills. It is an honour to speak today about something that is deeply woven into the identity\n               of the Cowichan Valley — our forestry sector and our forestry history. For generations,\n               forests have shaped this region, not just our economy but our communities, our working\n               lives and our sense of place. The forests of the Cowichan Valley have long been a\n               source of livelihood, local industry and pride. They have supported families, built\n               towns and connected us to the land in a way that is both practical and profound. Our forestry history is part of the story of how this region grew. From early logging\n               camps and mills to the transportation of lumber through places like Lake Cowichan,\n               forestry helped establish the foundation of our local economy. Entire communities\n               developed around the industry and the knowledge, skill and hard work of loggers, millworkers,\n               foresters, truckers and small business owners that helped build the Cowichan Valley\n               into what it is today. That legacy deserves recognition. The forest sector has never been just about trees. It has been about people, people\n               who worked in difficult conditions, adapted through change and passed down a strong\n               ethic of resilience and craftsmanship. It has also been about innovation. Our local forestry has evolved over time to include\n               better management, community forestry and a growing understanding of sustainability\n               and stewardship. We should also be proud that in Cowichan Valley, the forestry is not only part of\n               our past but still part of our present and the future. North Cowichan municipal forest\n               reserve is one example of how forestry can be managed for long-term public benefit,\n               balancing economic value, recreation and environmental responsibility. That kind of\n               approach reflects the values of our region — hard-working, practical and forward-looking. At the same time, we know that the story of forestry in this valley is not only one\n               of industry. It is also a story of land stewardship and relationship. The forests\n               here are part of the heart of Quw'utsun territory, and any honest reflection on our\n               forestry history must recognize the deep culture and environmental significance of\n               these lands. Our responsibility now is to honour that history, while ensuring that\n               future forest practices reflect respect, sustainability and shared responsibility. So when we say we are proud of our forestry sector, we are saying more than that it\n               has contributed to our economy. We are saying that we value the generations who built\n               it, the communities it supported and the lessons it has taught us about working with\n               the land over the long term. We are proud of the skill in this region. We are proud of the history. We are proud\n               of the people who made this industry strong. And we are proud to be part of the valley\n               that understands that We are proud of the skill in this region. We are proud of the history. We are proud\n               of the people who made this industry strong. And we are proud to be part of the valley\n               that understands that forestry done well can be a source of jobs, identity and stewardship\n               for generations to come. Here is a quote from Geoff Dawe, president of the Public and Private Workers of Canada.\n               \"These changes to B.C. Timber Sales are a positive step for workers across the pulp\n               and paper sector. Streamlining salvage, logging and commercial thinning means more\n               fibre for local mills and more opportunity for our workers. I commend the government's\n               ability to listen to the sector, now ready to make BCTS work for our needs. I will\n               watch these changes closely, and I'm optimistic they will result in noticeable improvements\n               for workers in our pulp mills and beyond.\" We are putting forward targets, legislative changes to support the next phase of the\n               BCTS review and strengthen its ability to provide a wider range of fibre, generating\n               and forest stewardship activities. These amendments enable B.C. Timber Sales to develop\n               and auction a suite of new timber sale licences and provide a range of different fibre\n               generation and forest stewardship activities. BCTS managed 20 percent of the available harvest in B.C., planning a vital role in\n               delivering timber sales auctions to the forest sector and providing credible data\n               for B.C.'s market price systems. These new licence types build on this work and provide\n               a wide range of contract types that better reflect regional conditions, project scope\n               and diverse skill sets. Salvage licence types, known as undeveloped timber sales, will make it easier for\n               the forest sector to quickly access timber damaged by wildfire and natural disturbances.\n               BCTS will now be able to move into a greater full rotation for a stewardship role\n               to supporting a healthier, predictable working forest into the future. Legislative changes empower BCTS to manage working forests for multiple values, building\n               on B.C.'s position as a leader in the highest quality sustainability and environmental\n               practice in the world. The legislative amendments support jobs for logging contracts,\n               deepen partnerships for First Nations and increase harvest volumes by moving local\n               logs to local mills at the right time. Our path forward for forestry means a BCTS that moves fibre faster, creates more opportunity\n               for workers and contractors and ensures local logs go to local mills. The work toward\n               a working forest model is rolling out to support a balanced approach to the sector\n               that incorporates conservation and harvesting values. These legislative changes give\n               BCTS the ability to operate differently than in the past, moving away from rigid approaches\n               towards working together in a new and better way. I would like to read another quote, from Lenny Joe, CEO of the B.C. First Nations\n               Forestry Council. \"The forestry council supports the current BCTS legislative amendments,\n               as they align with First Nations long-term stewardship and enable more flexibility\n               within the program. The legislation emphasizes full rotation management and a stronger\n               accountability. These changes are a positive first step towards rebuilding social\n               licence, and we look forward to BCTS better reflecting the needs of First Nations\n               and forestry communities.\" First Nations have emphasized the need for earlier involvement, clearer roles and\n               approaches that better reflect rights, title and community priorities. These changes\n               respond directly to the feedback by enabling more adaptable, long-term relationships\n               that support community stability, capacity-building and shared stewardship outcomes. For our region, this is not an abstract forestry policy debate. It is about jobs,\n               local mills, wildfire resilience, community partnerships and the future of working\n               forests that have shaped life in the Cowichan Valley for generations. These changes are meant to improve fibre access, create more opportunity for contractors,\n               deepen partnerships with First Nations and strengthen stewardship of the B.C. forests.\n               That matters here because forestry is still part of the economic and social fibre\n               of the valley. The amendments are designed to move local logs to local mills faster, increase the\n               amount of fibre available to the market and to create new opportunities through commercial\n               thinning, salvage, wildfire risk reduction and community partnerships. In practical\n               terms, that means more work for logging contractors, more reliable supply for mills\n               and more chance to keep forestry dollars circulating in our communities. One of the clearest benefits for the Cowichan Valley is the support for local employment.\n               The changes will increase fibre supply by as much as 500,000 cubic metres, and this\n               would support fast fibre delivery and stronger local economies. For a region where\n               forestry jobs and trucking, milling and value-added manufacturing all affect family\n               incomes, that kind of supply improvement can help stabilize work and support local\n               businesses. The amendments also support smaller and mid-sized manufacturers, which is especially\n               important in communities like ours. B.C. Timber Sales say that the new contract types\n               are intended to improve access to fibre for value-added manufacturers and ensuring\n               the right logs go to the right mills. That could help local businesses that make specialty\n               wood products, housing materials and other high-value items instead of simply shipping\n               raw logs out of the region. Another major benefit is wildfire resilience. The legislation makes it easier to salvage\n               damaged timber from wildfire, windstorms, insect outbreaks, while also supporting\n               commercial thinning and wildfire risk reduction. In a time where climate change is\n               making forests more vulnerable, that is not just good for forest management; it is\n               community protection. Healthier more resilient forests can lower risk, improve long-term\n               planning and reduce the chance that future fires will threaten homes, roads, watersheds\n               and businesses in the Cowichan Valley. There is also an important reconciliation dimension. B.C. Timber Sales say its work\n               is increasingly tied to partnerships with First Nations and local communities, and\n               the province says that the amendments will deepen their partnerships. That is especially\n               relevant here, where forestry decisions intersect with Indigenous rights, land stewardship\n               and shared responsibility for watersheds and surrounding forest lands. Stronger partnerships\n               can help create more legitimate, local-rooted decisions that better reflect the people\n               who live, work and steward this land. The changes are also supporting long-term stability. B.C. Timber sales is being empowered\n               to manage timber sales licenses through a full rotation, from harvesting to replanting\n               to the long-term stewardship and future harvesting. That matters because the Cowichan\n               Valley needs a forestry sector that is not just reactive to crisis but planning for\n               the long haul. A stable, predictable working force supports investment, jobs and healthier\n               ecosystems over time. We should also be honest about the challenges. These amendments will not solve every\n               problem in forestry. They will not, by themselves, and mill curtailments, resolve\n               every land use conflict or fix all the pressures facing rural communities. But they\n               do represent a step forward toward a more flexible, more responsible and more community-focused\n               forestry system. For the Cowichan Valley, that means more than timber. It means local work for contractors.\n               It means better chances of keeping the logs and jobs close to home. It means more\n               support for First Nations partnerships For the Cowichan Valley, that means more than timber. It means local work for contractors.\n               It means better chances of keeping the logs and jobs close to home. It means more\n               support for First Nations partnerships. It means stronger wildfire resilience. It\n               means a forestry system that is better aligned with the needs of the community that\n               depends on the forest, that lives beside it and cares about its future. If we want a Cowichan Valley that is prosperous, resilient and respectful of the land,\n               then we should welcome reforms that help local fibres stay local, support good jobs\n               and strengthen stewardship for the next generation. I'm looking at the time. I do have a little bit more time. I would like to end with\n               a quote. It's a quote from Kelly Marciniw, chairperson, B.C. Wood Specialties Group association. \"B.C. Wood is pleased to see the continued evaluation of B.C. Timber Sales moving\n               forward on the recommendations from the BCTS task force. Increasing opportunities\n               to access fibre in B.C. means we can build more in B.C. for housing to world-class\n               wood products sold locally and internationally. Local fibre supply is part of the\n               modern value-creating ecosystems that include good-paying jobs and locally paid taxes.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720633","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Here in B.C., we're proud of our forest sector, but we know we cannot keep going without\n               addressing the pressures facing the sector. Our path forward for forestry means a\n               B.C. Timber Sales, BCTS, that moves fibre faster, creates more opportunities for workers\n               and contractors and ensures local logs go to local mills. It is an honour to speak today about ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["30301973dd75c9399f31659f1afac65f5765ba3682915b8941b1e9983a214a0a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["90ea6fc5fc18b3cef6e76d6dba166c2a3d061b14702dd84e2b122f79b21a41c3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c82cd83496f19e7646b323fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720636,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports Bill 11 complete without amendments. Deputy Speaker : Thank you very much. When will the bill be read a third time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720636","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section C reports Bill 11 complete without amendments. Deputy Speaker : Thank you very much. When will the bill be read a third time?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a204ace276b1d997be185a4138755f877242b46644a12bfc914b65117b770bab"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-933006a7b62415ee097e4b9d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721726,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two individuals to introduce. Michelle Staples is the mayor of the city of\n               Duncan and a long-time Cowichan Valley resident. First elected to Duncan council in\n               2011 and then chosen as the city's first female mayor in 2018, she is known to bring\n               people together and is focused on community inclusion and collaboration across the\n               valley The second individual is Audrey George, former deputy chief of Quw'utsun. She has been a visible voice for reconciliation and community healing. She has also\n               helped lead Every Child Matters march in Duncan, which has become an important annual\n               event recognizing residential school survivors and children who never made it home. Together, these two leaders represent the strong relationship between the city of\n               Duncan and Cowichan Tribes, especially around reconciliation, public dialogue and\n               working together on community issues. Please join me in welcoming them here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721726","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have two individuals to introduce. Michelle Staples is the mayor of the city of\n               Duncan and a long-time Cowichan Valley resident. First elected to Duncan council in\n               2011 and then chosen as the city's first female mayor in 2018, she is known to bring\n               people together and is focused on community inclusion and collaboration across the\n               valley","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9623d4919e6fb8d682d5d0ef095e2bef4dc8880920c34384aaabcc5bd3616a17"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66a182ef11041e46cdb5579fc9265e26f9ab6674933c629f37005e29b7da5621"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15fe82bb38eba1668449ec89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721727,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize the vital contributions of the Clements Centre Society,\n               which has served the Cowichan region since 1957. For nearly seven decades, the organization\n               has provided a continuum of care for children, youth, adults and seniors with developmental\n               disabilities, offering essential support that fosters dignity, independence and belonging\n               at every stage of life. Clements Centre plays a foundational role in strengthening families and communities.\n               Through early intervention child development services, its child care resources and\n               referral programs, the organization supports parents and caregivers across the region,\n               from Saltair to the Malahat, including Duncan, Chemainus, Lake Cowichan and the surrounding\n               communities, helping ensure children receive the care and opportunities they need\n               to thrive. Beyond early years supporting, Clements Centre delivers inclusive, personal-centred\n               service for adults, including home-share and staff-lived programs. These initiatives\n               provide safe, supportive environments where individuals can build life skills, participate\n               in their communities and pursue meaningful relationships, work and personal goals,\n               always with dignity and choice at the forefront. At the heart of their work, it is a commitment to inclusion, a vision of community\n               where all individuals are valued and celebrated. Their holistic approach to supporting\n               not only health and the personal care but also education, housing, employment and\n               recreation, and a cultural and spiritual well-being, reflecting best practices in\n               developmental services and community-based care. As demand continues to grow, Clements\n               Centre is advancing a campus-of-care vision, including a new child development centre\n               to expand access to critical services. Today let us thank the Clements Centre for the support it provides, the help it offers\n               and the inclusive community it helps to build.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721727","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize the vital contributions of the Clements Centre Society,\n               which has served the Cowichan region since 1957. For nearly seven decades, the organization\n               has provided a continuum of care for children, youth, adults and seniors with developmental\n               disabilities, offering essential support that fosters dignity, independence and belonging","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["678d471ec37c4bf411a58134f37e2fd7f526bb3acb097b13745d33c086fe2439"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af4f2cbcf08decd007b6a9914f871eaaa49a2d49eede372ef869a1e33234543b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5a29e86cf860569c47b244f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729516,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"What does the loss of heritage look like? It doesn't always arrive with noise. Sometimes\n               it slips in quietly between generations, between languages, between stories that were\n               once told and are now forgotten. It looks like a child who cannot understand the words\n               that their grandparents' speak. It looks like the songs that were once sung on the land, not only remembered in fragments\n               now. It looks like sacred places that stand unchanged in the earth but are no longer\n               recognized, no longer visited, no longer protected in the same way. Loss of heritage is not just about the past. It's about reshaping the future. It looks\n               like young people searching for identity in a world that never taught them where they\n               came from. It looks like Elders carrying knowledge they fear will not be passed on.\n               It looks like ceremonies that were once outlawed, languages that were once punished\n               and traditions that were pushed into silence. And yet this loss is not total, but even after generations of disruption, something\n               remains — in the resilience of community, in the revival of language, in the return\n               of the land and the culture. But we must be honest. What was interrupted cannot be\n               simply restored without care, respect and action. To witness the loss of heritage\n               is to understand what was taken but also to recognize what is still being protected,\n               rebuilt and fought for every single day. The questions we're left with now.... Just what has been lost, but what we are willing\n               to do to ensure it is never lost again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729516","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"What does the loss of heritage look like? It doesn't always arrive with noise. Sometimes\n               it slips in quietly between generations, between languages, between stories that were\n               once told and are now forgotten. It looks like a child who cannot understand the words\n               that their grandparents' speak. It looks like the songs that were once sung on the land, not ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6948b107a8031c2cd35c1f8c831753da506d364e54ed432b1fdff2b04c20d2f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dae77ed09afee38010d05da284c128b10f71743b2de9f6c4d8ccd0be29ee615b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e40b61994b344adc9f00cf00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752359,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to speak about Robert Barron, a man who made a lasting contribution to\n               the Cowichan Valley through his writing, his curiosity and his care for local history. For many people in our community, Robert Barron's name is connected with the Cowichan Valley Citizen and with stories that helped people better understand the place they call home. He\n               was part of the tradition of local journalism that gives a community its memory. In\n               that sense, his work mattered far beyond the newspaper page. The local history coverage associated with Barron's name is the Cowichan Valley has\n               been remembered, an important record of the region's past. What made Robert Barron's\n               work meaningful was not just that he reported on the events, but that he helped preserve\n               the character of the valley. Local newspapers do more than share news, they capture the voices, struggles, achievements\n               and everyday life of a community. Writers like Robert Barron helped ensure that the\n               future generations can look back and see how the Cowichan Valley changed over time\n               and what values shaped it. This kind of work required patience, attention to detail\n               and a genuine interest in people. The history of Barron's contribution tied to the\n               long-running local reporting in the Cowichan leader and the Cowichan Valley publications. There is also something especially important about the local journalism in a place\n               like Cowichan. It connects neighbours to each other. It makes civic life more visible.\n               It gives recognition to people and the events that might otherwise be forgotten. Robert\n               Barron's legacy reminds us that strong communities are better built not only by the\n               leaders and institutes but also by the people who tell their stories honestly and\n               carefully. His writing helped shape the way the valley saw itself and understood its\n               own heritage. Today we think about Robert Barron. We should be thinking about more than a newspaper\n               byline. We should think about a community historian, a storyteller and someone who\n               helped preserve Cowichan's identity. The value of the contribution is lasting, because\n               the community that remembers itself is a community that stays connected to its roots.\n               Robert Barron's work helped to do exactly that for the Cowichan Valley. Thank you for your ten years at the Cowichan Valley. I know I will miss him also sharing\n               about our double hip surgeries and recoveries. I just wanted to let him know I'm still\n               doing well in my recovery. I will end by saying the Nanaimo News Bulletin is lucky to have you, and I look forward to seeing your byline and your next column\n               in the Cowichan Valley Citizen from time to time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752359","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I want to speak about Robert Barron, a man who made a lasting contribution to\n               the Cowichan Valley through his writing, his curiosity and his care for local history. For many people in our community, Robert Barron's name is connected with the Cowichan Valley Citizen and with stories that helped people better understand the place they call home. He\n               was part of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["84ac095a3fb198247cf737da3d262bb6be126830f1472e138437b1a579d2334c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6841e6b8602d88bd0531d537a3e4d49366139da3dfc0f5fcff1324dd81cc1926"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-504a37fd766c2a2459448725","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752360,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of Ministry of Labour\n               and asks to leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752360","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of Ministry of Labour\n               and asks to leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00a33090c4955b89c2522352f005ba1eed6194a5d2178e5a446dad99401898e3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4ee7b5252556cd81cb081411","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752361,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Transportation and Transit and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752361","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Transportation and Transit and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81b0ecd1373d5d73e6ed4c2fbd3ccce2bb6477271e82f2fdad980d6f26397366"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-85a5574e2794311f1cbb893e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017661,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to introduce a group of 38 students from grade 9 at Quamichan School, led by\n               Jesse Whittington, in my riding of Cowichan Valley, who will be joining us as question period is starting to ramp up, so I took this\n               opportunity to introduce them now. May the House please make them feel welcome once they arrive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017661","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to introduce a group of 38 students from grade 9 at Quamichan School, led by\n               Jesse Whittington, in my riding of Cowichan Valley, who will be joining us as question period is starting to ramp up, so I took this\n               opportunity to introduce them now. May the House please make them feel welcome once they arrive.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f176b225c1315a89f57f1c8a562d4a6f5c82f398a83ad3c828331a7c2ba32e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8b38bf073b6fc76d8a461939c4fc29832b3543af6ef20dc0e935959d918af98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f913cf795721afcefbf8cd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017664,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of estimates of\n               the Ministry of Jobs and Economic Growth and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017664","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of estimates of\n               the Ministry of Jobs and Economic Growth and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6859f1b509ba3d8d2966b4e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017669,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"A member across the way recently shared that his favourite song is \"Beds Are Burning\"\n               by Midnight Oil. It happens to be mine as well. I wanted to speak about what this\n               song means to me. It's a song that has endured for a reason, not just because of its sound but because\n               of what it asks of us. At its core, it speaks to responsibility, particularly when\n               it comes to land, justice and consequences of looking the other way. The bigger message\n               of the song.... The lyrics point to disposition of Aboriginal land, broken promises,\n               inequality and the moral responsibility to fix it. The line \"How can we sleep when our beds are burning?\" continues to resonate because it captures something uncomfortable but true — that\n               awareness carries with it an obligation to act. Here in British Columbia, that message\n               is all too real. It connects directly to the work of reconciliation, to the question\n               of land and title, and to the need for meaningful partnership with Indigenous Peoples.\n               These issues are present, ongoing and require our collective attention. What I appreciate about what the member raised — that song — is that it reflects a\n               shared understanding, at least in part, of those responsibilities. It is worth recognizing\n               when there is common ground in principle, because progress often begins there. I want to thank the member for raising it. It's a reminder worth sharing that the\n               work before us is not just political but moral and that we each have a role to play\n               in ensuring we respond to those words.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017669","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A member across the way recently shared that his favourite song is \"Beds Are Burning\"\n               by Midnight Oil. It happens to be mine as well. I wanted to speak about what this\n               song means to me. It's a song that has endured for a reason, not just because of its sound but because\n               of what it asks of us. At its core, it speaks to responsibility, particularly when\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["adeaf21b200e50807fdc29a487fda76a8058038d48bcaa4c7d7fced06440220b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05919e2b6a08da963158eafec9c009193854b5fe3307c6a35048ea3ff86c39ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccb59cbc47868ffd78712db9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036595,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036595","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76c69d2cda542eb52815392f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036596,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Debra Toporowski","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports progress on Bill 20 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036596","member_id":"bc-mla-368","member_name":"Debra Toporowski","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section C reports progress on Bill 20 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa4ca702cd2395d4efb8f878","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317193,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Me and the member from Prince George–Valemount were thinking quite alike this morning. I rise in the House to recognize an extraordinary milestone, the 100th anniversary\n               of our Canadian Legion. For a century, the legion has stood as a pillar of remembrance,\n               advocacy in the community, in our province and across our nation. Established in 1926\n               by veterans returning from World War I and World War II, the legion was born from\n               a simple but powerful promise: those who serve Canada would never stand alone. A hundred\n               years later, that promise still holds. In communities across British Columbia, and especially my constituency of Esquimalt-Colwood, the legion is worn in the fabric of daily life. In Esquimalt, a proud naval town,\n               the presence of the legion carries particular meaning. Our community is home to generations\n               of sailors, soldiers, aviators, veterans and their families. Service is not an absent\n               concept for us. It is personal. It is visible. It is a part of who we are. The men and women who gather under the Legion's crest are not only veterans of the\n               First and Second World Wars, Korea and Afghanistan and more recent missions; they\n               are neighbours, mentors, volunteers and friends. They are the steady hands organizing\n               Remembrance Day ceremonies each November. They are the ones ensuring that the stories\n               of sacrifices are told to our next generations, not as a distant history but as a\n               living memory. Each year at cenotaphs across British Columbia, we see the legion at work. Poppy boxes\n               appear in storefronts. Volunteers give their time in all types of weather. The poppy\n               campaign remains one of the most recognizable acts of remembrance in our country.\n               Funds raised go to directly supporting veterans and their families, whether through\n               emergency assistance, housing support, mental health programs or advocacy work. The legion work extends far beyond remembrance ceremonies. Across B.C., legion branches\n               serve as community hubs. They host youth programs, provide bursaries and scholarships\n               and support cadet corps. They organize meal programs and community dinners. They create\n               space where seniors can connect in combat isolation. In times of crisis, from natural\n               disasters to economic hardship, legion members are often among the first to step forward\n               and ask: \"How can we help?\" In Esquimalt-Colwood, the spirit of service is alive and well. Our local branches of our military families\n               navigate deployments. They partner with community organizations to ensure veterans\n               have access to resources. They open the doors for community events, celebrations and\n               commemorations alike. For many, the legion is a hall, not just a building. It is also\n               a second home. As Parliamentary Secretary for Armed Forces Development and Veterans Affairs, I have\n               the privilege of working closely with veterans and military communities across the\n               province. I hear firsthand how critical peer support and community connections are\n               to our well-being. The legion provides exactly that, a place where lived experience\n               is understood without explanation, a place where camaraderie continues along after\n               the uniform is hung up. This centennial is also an opportunity to reflect that the legion has evolved. Today's\n               Canadian Armed Forces look much different than they did in 1926. They are more diverse,\n               more representative of the Canadian we serve. The legion has embraced that evolution,\n               welcoming new generations of veterans, including women, Indigenous, 2SLGTBQ veterans,\n               ensuring their sacrifices are also recognized and respected. The legion has also adapted to meeting modern challenges, addressing homelessness\n               among our veterans, supporting those struggling with operational stress injuries and\n               advocating for fair treatment and recognition at all levels of our governments. One hundred years is a remarkable achievement, for few organizations can claim a century\n               of continuous service to their country and their community. The Royal Canadian Legion\n               can, and it has done so not through gestures alone but through steady daily acts of\n               dedication carried out by the volunteers in every corner of this province. As we mark the anniversary, we honour the founders who saw the need in 1926. We honour\n               the generations who carried that torch forward, and we recommit to ourselves to ensuring\n               the legion remains strong past the next 100 years. Anniversaries are not only looking back, but they are about looking forward. The centennial\n               year is also a time to invite British Columbians to be part of that proud legacy.\n               The legion is not only for veterans. It's for anyone who believes in remembrance,\n               in service and in supporting those who have worn our country's uniform. This year, British Columbians can sign up and become members, actually, at no cost,\n               an opportunity to stand alongside a century of service and help shape the next one. I encourage everyone in this House and everyone watching to consider joining your\n               local branch, attending a community event, volunteering your time and supporting the\n               vital network that legions continue to do, because they can't do it without us. To the members of the Royal Canadian Legion of Esquimalt-Colwood, across Vancouver Island and throughout British Columbia, thank you. Thank you for\n               100 years of unwavering service and for keeping remembrance alive and ensuring no\n               veterans stand alone. Lest we forget. To the members of the Royal Canadian Legion of Esquimalt-Colwood, across Vancouver\n               Island and throughout British Columbia, thank you. Thank you for 100 years of unwavering\n               service and for keeping remembrance alive and ensuring no veterans stand alone. Lest\n               we forget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317193","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Me and the member from Prince George–Valemount were thinking quite alike this morning. I rise in the House to recognize an extraordinary milestone, the 100th anniversary\n               of our Canadian Legion. For a century, the legion has stood as a pillar of remembrance,\n               advocacy in the community, in our province and across our nation. Established in 1926\n               by veterans","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ab934684f82c4f68b47375213b767bf2bd415ea0a1dbed8454640a7dbba7645","ffdb77f2df9b5d537c241c43b9aaa8f9b8139907ab37047aff36ad58acf29517"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae15e16f6d27586173440aec4658b07ef8a9761be49df6f531a4a7a3fc504904"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72ff3cf6e35e4ed862da0b1b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317194,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Good afternoon, everybody. I would like to acknowledge that we are gathered here today on the traditional and\n               unceded territories of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, known as Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. As well, I'm going to give a shout-out to my husband and my two little girls, because\n               they watch this, because they just love hearing from all of us. It's very exciting.\n               They're learning how, apparently, we're supposed to do this, so we should all behave\n               a bit more for the record. I stand in strong support of Budget 2026 today. As the Parliamentary Secretary for\n               Armed Forces Development and Veterans Affairs, I am especially proud to say that British\n               Columbia is showing the country and the world what we can do right here at home to\n               build our economy and protect our country at the same time. When I was the first elected as MLA of Esquimalt-Colwood and I had my conversations with our government, I said we should be highlighting\n               the work we do, the amazing work we're already doing, and show how we can build that\n               work. So when I was privileged enough to have a change in my parliamentary secretary\n               role, I was very excited at the work we can do, as well as getting to highlight all\n               the work that the military families do to hold up our Canadian Armed Forces around\n               the province. These are financially challenging times. We are navigating global instability, ongoing\n               inflammatory pressures, shifting trade relationships and direct economic threats that test our resilience\n               as a province and a country. In moments like this, budgets are not accounting documents;\n               they are statements of values. Budget 2026 makes careful choices to protect what matters\n               most and secure British Columbia's future. Our priorities are clear. We are protecting core public services like health care\n               and education. We are keeping British Columbia as one of the lowest-taxed provinces\n               for working families. And we are reducing the deficit responsibly over time with discipline\n               and clarity. Over the last eight years, we have built the foundation a strong province depends\n               on. We did so while guiding people and business through extraordinary challenges —\n               a global pandemic, devastating floods and wildfires, supply chain disruptions, economic\n               pressures and sovereignty threats by the United States under President Trump. British Columbians have never backed down from a challenge. Canadians don't back down\n               from a challenge, and we will not start now. Global uncertainty is the slowing growth\n               everywhere. Commodity prices are volatile. Trade instability affects investment decisions.\n               We must be disciplined. To achieve our goals, we are taking three key steps. First, we are making the public\n               sector smaller and more efficient so that more dollars can reach our front-line workers.\n               Second, we are pacing infrastructure projects carefully, delivering them efficiently\n               without driving up cost. Third, we are generating new revenue while growing the economic and securing the long-term impact of major projects. We continue to invest in British Columbia's future. We are strengthening health care\n               with $2.8 billion over three years. This includes $2.83 billion to increase capacity in the health care system, $131 million to support mental\n               health and addiction treatment, $185 million to strengthen seniors care, $102 million\n               for in vitro fertilization. This one is especially near and dear to my heart. As someone who has heard my story,\n               I wouldn't have been able to start my family if we didn't put investments in things\n               like this, like many British Columbians across our province. We have secured $442 million in federal funding to support services for seniors and\n               $653 million to expand public coverage for free medication for diabetes and enhance\n               hormone replacement therapy. That is money that will get put back in the pockets of\n               our seniors by supporting them. In my own community, this commitment is visible in the Western Communities long-term care project in Colwood. This new facility will be located on a five-acre site and accommodate\n               298 patients in a small home module, 14 private rooms per home, forming 28 neighbourhood beds. It will include an 18-bed\n               hospice unit, 35 adult daycare spaces and 37 child care spaces — an innovative integration\n               of services that reflects how communities actually live and support one another. If anyone, unfortunately, has ever had to go to a hospice, and you've seen that process\n               play out for our seniors who don't always get the privilege of aging at home and end\n               up in hospital, being able to transition in your care is going to mean so much for\n               those seniors and their families when they're being cared for by the same people through\n               their age and The province is investing $258 million, with construction expected to be completed\n               in.... This is what protecting seniors looks like. I'm going to take a moment here to talk about my time in health care. You've heard\n               me say that I was a proud health care worker. I still am a proud health care worker.\n               I can't do that, because I've been sitting here listening to some comments by the\n               opposition saying: \"We weren't in government. Those were the Liberals.\" Well, with\n               all due respect, leopards do not change their spots. So we're going to do a little\n               education here for a moment. I started in health care in 2007, and when I was successfully elected, I took my leave\n               in 2023. So that means I worked under four Premiers, two Liberal governments and two\n               NDP governments. So I have some things to say. The previous Leader of the Opposition has a lot of cojones to sit here and tell me\n               that we have done nothing for health care. Under the Horgan government, we saw the\n               biggest investment in home supports by bringing them back into government. We saw increased services in mental health and addiction, because I worked under the\n               Clark government and the Campbell government where they cut services. People couldn't\n               get individual treatment. It was group therapy for everyone. It was an all-or-nothing\n               model, and it didn't work. Again, they have the cojones to stand here and tell me that we have done nothing.\n               The current Leader of the Opposition was a former B.C. Liberal and a staffer with\n               the B.C. Liberal government. Again, he has the audacity to stand here and say: \"Well,\n               I was never in the Conservative government, in the opposition.\" Our MLA for Richmond Centre — a similar situation. I could go on, because I have a long list of people who were\n               under that government or under that umbrella before. Again, those spots didn't change,\n               and here we have our opposition. If anyone disagrees with me, go ahead and google it for yourself. We are going to continue to make sure we're investing in health care. That is my commitment\n               not to the people in the riding but to my colleagues who I stood beside when we begged\n               and pleaded under Liberal governments — again the spots didn't turn their colours\n               — for funding for our core services. I held the hands of workers in detox who came for services, and we said: \"Unfortunately,\n               those services aren't there.\" It was the reason I got involved in politics. It was\n               the reason I chose to run with this government, and it is the reason, every day, I\n               will show up here and support this government— to make sure the people of this province\n               and our health care, again, is supported. In education, we are investing $634 million for K to 12 over three years, including\n               $167 million for the classroom enhancement fund and funding for First Nation reciprocal\n               tuition. We're also investing $330 million over three years to expand child care spaces\n               and reduce fees for families. For families raising children and youth with disabilities, we are committing to $475\n               million over three years, which will create more flexible, streamlined and equitable\n               support systems, replacing the existing autism funding program with one that better\n               reflects the diverse needs for children. As a mother, I know how it's important for families to feel supported rather than\n               burdened by the systems that are difficult to navigate. I have one child in daycare.\n               I have one with a disability, and I have another soon to go to daycare. These things\n               are near and dear to my heart personally, for the people of my community and for people\n               across the province. Public safety also remains a priority. It was a priority for me when I was in my local\n               government, for Esquimalt, and it's just as important now here as the MLA for Esquimalt-Colwood. We are investing $139 million over three years in justice and community safety, including\n               funding for repeat violent offender initiatives, timely access to justice and target\n               enforcement programs. Our capital plan commits to $37.7 billion of infrastructure investments in schools,\n               hospital, transit, community and infrastructure. In Esquimalt-Colwood, that includes the Highway 1 bus on the shoulder project between the McKenzie interchange\n               and the Colwood exchange. This project will make transit faster and more reliable\n               for commuters on south Vancouver Island. It includes a new pedestrian and cyclist bridge at Craigflower Creek, improvements\n               to the Galloping Goose Trail crossing, upgraded bus stops at the Helkin road, realignment\n               of Portage road and ecological restoration work. The province is providing $68 million\n               towards the $95 million projects, with completion expected in 2027. Now on to our Look West strategy. In B.C., we understand the connection between economic strength and national\n               security. A strong industrial base, a trained workforce and resilient communities are not abstract\n               concepts. They are essential pillars of sovereignty. This is why our Look West strategy matters so deeply. Look West leverages British Columbia's strengths to position us as Canada's economic engine This is why our Look West strategy matters so deeply. Look West leverages British Columbia's strengths to position us as Canada's economic engine.\n               It advances national building projects, creates skilled jobs, strengthens supply chains\n               and ensures we are not dependent on external forces for our prosperity or our security. This is not theoretical for me. It is happening every day in my constituency of Esquimalt-Colwood. Esquimalt-Colwood is home to CFB Esquimalt and Canada's Pacific fleet. It is home to Seaspan shipyards,\n               a critical partner in Canada's national shipbuilding strategy. It is home to HECATE\n               shipyards and a proud tradition of skilled trades, marine engineering and defence\n               innovation. We are a working community, a trades community, a community where people build things\n               that matter, that build my riding, that build the province. This is why I am particularly\n               excited by the $241 million investment in the budget to strengthen B.C.'s trades-training\n               system and double annual skilled trades in B.C. by 2028-2029. When we build projects here with our skilled workers here, that's how we're going\n               to keep them here for generations to come. As someone who jokes that they're an import\n               to B.C., I want to ensure that when my daughters choose whatever their career paths\n               are, they can stay here in B.C. This investment is about the training seats. It's about ensuring that when ships are\n               built at Seaspan, when maintenance is conducted at CFB Esquimalt, when infrastructure\n               projects break ground across Vancouver Island, British Columbians are trained and\n               ready for work. Through $283 million over three years to support commitments made through Look West , we are investing in our people and our economic sovereignty. This includes $241\n               million to double funds to skilled trades, $30 million to support highly qualified\n               professionals and $12 million to enhance the employer training grant and double apprenticeship\n               seats. Budget 2026 also invests $400 million for a new B.C. strategic investment to seize\n               opportunities for collaboration with the federal government on major economic initiatives.\n               More than $40 million will build on progress made in streamlining permitting, increasing\n               capacity in our natural resource and tourism sector. In 2025-2026, $50 million will\n               support the forestry sector as it adapts and strengthens. We enter this period from a position of strength. Our economy remains resilient. Our\n               debt-to-GDP ratio gives us room to respond when it matters most. That work is making\n               a difference. Major job-creating projects are moving forward. B.C. already has 18 major projects\n               underway, ranging from critical mineral mines to renewable energy developments. Nearly\n               half of Canada's major federal projects are happening here, far more than in any other\n               province in this country. With Look West , we set ambitious goals throughout the important sectors of our economy. Key sectors\n               of the plan will be vital in strengthening our province. B.C.'s industrial maritime\n               sector includes over 1,000 companies with capabilities in vessel construction, maintenance,\n               repair and overhaul, refits, life extensions and marine innovation. That was a mouthful,\n               but that shows you the great work and the people we have in this province that are\n               doing that work. The sector contributes an estimated $7.2 billion output, $4 billion towards our GDP,\n               and sustains over 34,250 jobs. When people ask why I am invested in working with the\n               military, those numbers should say something. Through Look West , we have set a clear goal to secure 35 percent of all federal defence vessels contracted\n               for B.C. in 2035. We know how to build ships. We've been doing it for a long time.\n               We, again, just need to show them that we can do it. We're also growing our ship recycling industry, an effective and environmentally sound\n               method of disposing of aging ships and reusing scrap metals. Ship recycling is an\n               emerging business opportunity that can create good jobs and diversify local economies\n               in coastal communities, many of which have been impacted by the recent forestry downturns. The province is committed to fostering growth and developing the maritime sector through\n               ongoing collaboration with First Nations and Indigenous Peoples. Shipbuilding and our robust maritime supply chain have been key to the sector's growth\n               and B.C.'s economy and prosperity for over 130 years. We're continuing to find ways\n               to improve this important sector. We're making new funding available through the province's integrated marketplace platform\n               to help B.C. tech companies test renewable energy solutions from the maritime sector,\n               including the Canadian Coast Guard and Royal Canadian Navy. This funding will accelerate\n               the sector's transition to renewable energy as part of our Look West plan. We are growing more important sectors through Look West , including expanding aerospace capacity to support defence procurement, growing our\n               life science sectors in support of Canada's Here in CFB Esquimalt, one of their procurement processes is actually looking at some\n               of the modular homes that are built right here in B.C. Not only can they build their\n               housing faster, but they can build it with B.C. timber. All of this will be critical\n               as we ensure people in business in B.C. benefit from good jobs and strong communities\n               throughout this province. These strains position this province well to compete for national projects that benefit\n               from a skilled workforce, strong industry clusters and global connectivity. We're\n               backing a private sector bid to bring the new defence security resilient bank, DSRB,\n               headquarters right here to Vancouver. If the bank chooses B.C., we will benefit from\n               thousands of new high-paying jobs into defence finance, research and international\n               operations. British Columbians understand that national security and defence matter\n               more now than ever. The DSRB will support industries central to our shared safety,\n               economic strength like defence cybersecurity, advanced manufacturing and dual-use\n               technologies. Around the world, governments recognize that economic and national security are deeply\n               linked. Supply chains, innovation and resilience all matter. The bank ensures that\n               countries like Canada can reshape global solutions, not just respond to them. Vancouver\n               is Canada's gateway to the Indo-Pacific, a region vital to global trade, security\n               and stability. Our location prefers unmatched connectivity across the Asia Pacific,\n               North America and beyond. Vancouver also has a diverse, world-leading innovation ecosystem. We are home to leading\n               firms in cybersecurity, AI, clean tech, advanced manufacturing, and these sectors\n               are all central to the bank's mandate. B.C. has established defence capacity, including\n               operations like Seaspan, alongside innovators like Pyotech, AB Celeron and Sanctuary\n               AI. This mix of industry and cutting-edge technology creates ideal conditions for\n               defence, security and again, dual-use innovation. A little about my work at Seamless Canada. People hear me talk all the time about\n               military families, and one of the things I am privileged enough to sit on is a working\n               group called Seamless Canada. The Seamless Canada working group — and I can't make\n               this up — seamlessly looks at how we get a military family from coast to coast and\n               make their posting season the easiest. Some of the things we work on in that committee\n               to ensure that it happens are similar problems to what we have here in B.C. for everyday\n               British Columbians: housing, access to doctors, education plans, child care. If we want people to protect our country, to go out last minute and do what we need\n               them to do, then we need to make sure all of the supports they need are here in British\n               Columbia, and I get to do that work on Seamless Canada. There will be more to come\n               on that, so stay tuned. But again, I can't talk enough about our Canadian Armed Forces\n               families and the great work they do to keep us safe. We secure our future by investing in people, investing in skills, investing in infrastructure,\n               protecting health care and education — things that British Columbians over and over\n               again tell us are important: maintaining fiscal discipline, strengthening our industrial\n               base and support for the Canadian Armed Forces community that contributes so much\n               to my constituency to our province. Budget 2026 is serious work for serious times. It reflects restraint where necessary\n               and investment where it matters most. It protects services. It keeps tax low for working\n               families, like those in my riding of a Esquimalt-Colwood. It strengthens B.C.'s finances for the long term. British Columbians expect us to\n               govern responsibly, especially in uncertain times. I won't lie if I were to not say, \"I really hope I never hear we're in unprecedented\n               times in my lifetime again.\" And I am always cautiously an optimist. One thing we\n               can agree on here today. This budget means that moment. We are making careful choices,\n               we are protecting what matters most, and we are securing British Columbia's future. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for your time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317194","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Good afternoon, everybody. I would like to acknowledge that we are gathered here today on the traditional and\n               unceded territories of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, known as Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. As well, I'm going to give a shout-out to my husband and my two little girls, because\n               they watch this, because they just love hearing from all of us. It's very exciti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","label":"Defence industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e617b22983a6fa146580c9b50437750be31f7b28baee40f1a9a0db4aaabc5e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["60782b1d1a8c4b56fd1661b899be26823c1c6aad5fcf4cf552a73de966d07aee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Defence industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49266","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f92442cb024e7c167bc92b5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317195,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to make an introduction. Today I have Neil Parkinson Dow, national coordinator\n               of events and partnership of Public Service Pride Network. He's not just a constituent.\n               He's also a member of one of three chambers of commerce in my riding. As well, another proud chamber member, Brenda MacFarlane, financial assistant with\n               IG Wealth Management. Thank you for joining us in the House today. Everyone make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317195","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'd like to make an introduction. Today I have Neil Parkinson Dow, national coordinator\n               of events and partnership of Public Service Pride Network. He's not just a constituent.\n               He's also a member of one of three chambers of commerce in my riding. As well, another proud chamber member, Brenda MacFarlane, financial assistant with\n               IG Wealth Management. Than","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b924738707a01fd47b19525249b9a765894ff0d2cdb66cda2d838638d74e084"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c41a778b79fa492d6d2159a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317196,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am honoured to highlight an extraordinary organization in my community of\n               Esquimalt-Colwood that is changing lives every single day: the Rainbow Kitchen, located at 500 Admirals\n               Road. Rainbow Kitchen's mission is simple yet profound: to provide food security and access\n               to resources to all who walk through their doors through effective community partnerships,\n               to feed bellies and feed souls in the community they serve. That is exactly what they\n               do. What began in 2001 in a small Anglican Church hall on the border of Vic West and Esquimalt,\n               serving tea, coffee and sandwiches one day a week, has grown into a cornerstone of\n               food security in the capital regional district. In 2010 the Rainbow Kitchen was formally\n               established, and then just In 2010, the Rainbow Kitchen was formally established, and then just two years later,\n               it expanded and moved into its home on Admirals. Today Rainbow Kitchen acts as a hub for food security programming across the region.\n               They rescue more than 10,000 pounds of food every single month that otherwise would\n               go in the trash, and they transform it into nourishment and dignity for our neighbours.\n               They serve over 250,000 meals each year and welcome everyone: seniors, family, children\n               and anyone who needs a meal. Under the leadership of CEO Patrick Daroski, along with a dedicated team and over 200 volunteers committed who are collectively\n               contributing hours annually, this organization delivers hope alongside their meals.\n               Their impact is especially felt among children. Rainbow Kitchen operates school meal\n               programs supporting five schools, providing over 6,000 meals each month to students\n               in our community. That means thousands of children are better able to focus, learn\n               and thrive because they are not distracted by hunger. During the week they serve breakfast from 7:30 to 8:30 and from 11:30 to one, no questions\n               asked. Simple, free, to effect something powerful: dignity, compassion and community. I want to extend my sincere thank you to Patrick and his team, donors and community\n               partners for making this work possible. Your compassionate commitment embodies the\n               very best of British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317196","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I am honoured to highlight an extraordinary organization in my community of\n               Esquimalt-Colwood that is changing lives every single day: the Rainbow Kitchen, located at 500 Admirals\n               Road. Rainbow Kitchen's mission is simple yet profound: to provide food security and access\n               to resources to all who walk through their doors through effective community ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["99964751ef7eda6137d92a7a930ca38e76abb970f416cff10b6f76ffdc1dc338"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["829ba51848c2030fc57f63403dc4f43aafd26297de22904e2a2c9a719311176a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30072d79abb3cc4af7f14172","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317197,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak today in support of the trade recognition\n               act. One of the foundational pieces of our Look West strategy is to secure more ambitious\n               Canadian mutual recognition agreements. The MRA, which B.C. signed in November of\n               2025, will see each and every Canadian province and territory agree to recognize each\n               other's regulations on the sale of goods except food. The practical impact of this is that if a product can be sold in one province, it\n               can be sold in another without further testing, approval or certification. This was\n               an unprecedented step and marked one of the most significant reductions in interprovincial\n               trade barriers in Canadian history. B.C. led this work around the negotiating table. It was a momental achievement to\n               get this agreement concluded. But we must go further, and that is why our government has introduced Bill 5. Bill\n               5 represents a continuation of B.C.'s national leadership on internal trade. We passed\n               Bill 7, the Economic Stabilization Act, last year. It was because we knew we needed\n               to act fast. We will cast our minds back to the time last year. Nobody knew what was coming. There\n               were new threats almost every day. In North American history, trading relationships\n               began to quickly fall apart. Part 1 of Bill 7 gave B.C. the ability to recognize other provinces' regulations and\n               allow for goods sold in these provinces to also be sold here. Many other provinces\n               have taken this step, and the MRA signalled that each province intends to align with\n               this national strategy to reduce interprovincial barriers. As more provinces move toward similar legislation, the benefits for provinces As more provinces move towards similar legislation, the benefits for provinces like\n               B.C. grow greater. B.C. businesses, if they wish, will be able to more easily expand\n               to new domestic markets. These are new opportunities that are unlocked by purposeful\n               work to remove interprovincial trade barriers wherever possible. Part 1 of Bill 7 will expire this May, so B.C. needs a legislative framework to be\n               able to continue its progress on interprovincial trade. Bill 5 will ensure that there\n               is a continuity so that we can stay aligned with the CMRA and continue to work to\n               make progress on internal trade while we negotiate further with other jurisdictions.\n               When we can bring other provinces together to come to a broader mutual agreement,\n               we will already have the legislation in place to enact the agreement right away. We know that this global instability is not going to subside easily, so we are planning\n               for our future. Bill 5 is one measure that will help us build a stronger economy here\n               in B.C. and help us contribute to a more unified Canada. B.C. is leading by example. We were one of the first provinces to introduce interprovincial\n               trade legislation. It was B.C.'s leadership working with other jurisdictions to address\n               concerns and find common ground that will help bring the CMRA to completion. Make no mistake, the CMRA is a landmark agreement. But while the CMRA establishes\n               mutual recognition for the sale of goods except food, Bill 5 goes further. This bill\n               would establish recognition for all goods and services. Not only does Bill 5 enable\n               us to align with the CMRA, but it also puts us on the leading edge of reducing unnecessary\n               trade barriers. This is a long time coming. Report after report highlights the considerable economic\n               benefit that easier interprovincial trade could bring. For B.C., it could mean billions\n               of dollars added to our provincial economy output. This is growth that would deliver\n               good jobs for British Columbians in every community across the province. We are doing\n               it without compromising the protections that British Columbians rely on. We will uphold regulations concerning health and safety, the environment and consuming\n               standards. We will also protect our critical public services, like ICBC. It is plain\n               to see that not only is interprovincial trade economically beneficial for business\n               and workers and consumers alike, but it is also possible to do it without sacrificing\n               the values we hold dear. Our government's Look West strategy has established a clear plan for the growth in\n               B.C. It lays out the path forward for B.C. to become the economic engine of Canada.\n               To be the engine, we need to be competitive. Interprovincial trade barriers have often\n               been obstacles to economic development, not just in B.C. but right across the country.\n               That's why we are targeting economic growth with a multi-pronged approach, so all\n               British Columbians can share in the benefits. It all starts with workers. B.C. has incredible talent across many diverse sectors,\n               from life sciences to professional services to our skilled trades. That's why, through\n               Look West, we're doubling our investment to trades training to $214 million over three\n               years. Our talent is one of our key selling points. While businesses are making investment\n               decisions, we're looking for readily available talent and a predictable talent pipeline. When we are reducing interprovincial trade barriers, which increases our global competitiveness\n               and tracks levels of investment from within Canada and abroad, we are raising B.C.'s\n               stature as we compete for major projects and investments. As we aim to grow our strategic sectors, like life science, advanced technology, mining\n               and critical minerals, maritime and aerospace, construction, innovation and more,\n               B.C. will need highly qualified professionals to lead that growth. Many of the major\n               projects that will be advanced in the upcoming years will require B.C. to recruit\n               and retain many more of the skilled-trades workers who will get the job done. That's\n               why we'll continue to work with other provinces and territories towards an agreement\n               on labour mobility. You can see how our interprovincial trade is a subtle but necessary component of our\n               plan to deliver good jobs and prosperity here for a stronger British Columbia. Bill 5 is necessary and a practical step forward as we work to modernize our internal\n               trade rules. The Trade Recognition Act provides new opportunities for B.C. businesses\n               by opening new markets inside of Canada. It also provides administrative relief for those businesses, particularly our small\n               businesses, who cannot afford to do businesses in other provinces due to the cost\n               of duplicate regulatory compliance. For B.C. exporters, it means their products will be more readily available across\n               Canada, and for B.C. consumers, that means more opportunities to buy Canadian-made\n               products. Bill 5 provides stability, continuity and predictability as we establish For B.C. exporters, it means their products will be more readily available across\n               Canada, and for B.C. consumers, that means more opportunity to buy Canadian-made products. Bill 5 provides stability, continuity and predictability as we establish a permanent\n               provincial framework for internal trade. It does so while preserving the health, safety\n               and environmental attractions that we all value. The Trade Recognition Act is forward-looking and sets the stage for B.C. to continue\n               its national leadership on breaking down interprovincial trade barriers. I hope all members will join me in supporting Bill 5.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317197","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I am pleased to have the opportunity to speak today in support of the trade recognition\n               act. One of the foundational pieces of our Look West strategy is to secure more ambitious\n               Canadian mutual recognition agreements. The MRA, which B.C. signed in November of\n               2025, will see each and every Canadian province and territory agree to recognize each\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97e5bb1cbd767fbe7d143cfb9baed636bfbad2cfbc684bd969a17697f1a50445"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1648168cf5acebaf25af36108a913703398896f4f1677d94815ddd218cbc66bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04dcf2659704f2989dc6b9b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328036,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in favour of Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act. The CFO seeks\n               to obtain the","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328036","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to speak in favour of Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act. The CFO seeks\n               to obtain the","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26877232c374f7d37a953e764ddb426ca994d1d46a8974841812361bbce4b2c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["735ab2aec7610dc8790af98924d95a236b6dc7b5c05e660c43b96437841ed7a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8a38d142c5c416c40762f5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328037,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, known as Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. I'd like to thank them for their stewardship on their land, as someone whose\n               office is also located on their lands. I'm pleased to rise today in support of the legislation to amend the Motor Vehicle\n               Act, legislation that represents a practical, thoughtful step toward modernization\n               of services that British Columbians rely on every day. At its core, this bill is about something simple: making it easy for people to renew\n               or replace their driver's licence, their BCID card or their B.C. Services Card. If\n               passed, these amendments will enable the Insurance Corp. of British Columbia to offer\n               online applications for simple licence renewals and replacements. This means that\n               for the majority of eligible drivers, those who simply need to extend an expiry date\n               or replace a lost or damaged card, this can be done through ICBC's website without\n               a trip to an office. This matters. It matters most to parents who cannot easily take time off work. Or\n               I will use a different example. People here know I have two little ones. To all your\n               new parents who are extremely sleep-deprived, have been up all night with their little\n               one, and let's just say they ran out of diapers.... It's the middle of the night. The\n               poor second parent needs to go get them, because that's just how things are. Can you\n               imagine realizing your ID has expired? That horrible feeling? Not only are you going to feel bad it has expired. Now, with your crazy schedule with\n               kids and potentially the second parent working, you need to find time in your schedule\n               to somehow get to an ICBC office to get it renewed. That is a lot of pressure and\n               anxiety on new parents. I'll give another example. It matters to our seniors who are finding travel challenging.\n               We heard a lot about seniors in the Legislature this week and how we need to ensure\n               we're taking care of our seniors. Seniors are very resilient when it comes to using\n               online technology, contrary to some people's belief. If you have a senior who doesn't maybe always have accessibility to transportation,\n               but they have access to a computer in their home or their phone or, say, the library\n               in their community or their senior centre, they will be able to go in — if this legislation\n               is passed — and renew, say, their health care card or their ID. It matters to workers in rural communities who currently must drive long distances\n               for what amounts to simple paperwork. Again, we hear our colleagues on both sides\n               of the House saying we need to support rural communities better. We need to simplify\n               things for those people. It's a great first step. You hear them go: \"They're going to have to drive five towns over to get this.\" Totally.\n               The cost of gas is expensive. People's time — we want to make sure people have time\n               in their lives to do the things they love, not having to go and do a task that now\n               will be done online. Then I'm going to talk about shift workers. You've heard me get up here and say I\n               was a shift worker for many years. Anyone who has done night shifts for a long period\n               of time.... People are shaking their heads like: \"We've all been there.\" You've worked\n               7 p.m. to 7 a.m. You're tired. You want to go home. And again, it's just another task. Now, do you really want to go home and then go: \"Oh wait, I can't go home. I now need\n               to go wait in line at ICBC after a 12-hour night shift to go get my ID renewed or\n               my driver's licence renewed or my CareCard renewed\"? Absolutely not. What you want\n               to do is go home and go to bed because you're exhausted. This will make that easier\n               for them. It also extremely matters to our Canadian Armed Forces members and veterans I represent\n               and advocate for every day. The world is a very scary place right now. We talked a\n               little bit about what's going on in the world. Here in Esquimalt, home to one of the largest naval bases in our country, members\n               of our Royal Canadian Navy deploy around the world, sometimes at a moment's notice,\n               sometimes for months. They serve on ships in the Pacific, in the Atlantic and in international\n               waters. They deploy on humanitarian missions, security operations and joint exercises.\n               They serve Canada with dedication and professionalism. But while they're deployed overseas, life goes on. It does not pause. Expiry dates\n               do not pause. Under the current system, a service member deployed abroad may face\n               significant difficulty renewing their licence before it expires. If you're over doing\n               some type of peacekeeping mission, doing some type of support, and you realize it\n               expires, and you're going to need to, say, get home, it can cause a lot of anxiety. This new system will ensure that If you're over doing some type of peacekeeping mission, doing some type of support,\n               and you realize it expires and you're going to need to say, \"Get home,\" it can cause\n               a lot of anxiety. This new system will ensure that we can make it easier for them\n               again to renew those cards. This legislation moves us towards a solution. Once implemented, expected in 2027,\n               following development and regulatory work, eligible drivers will be able to submit\n               an online renewal application. Upon approval, an interim licence will be issued electronically,\n               and the physical card will be mailed. I'm going to use an example. I'm not going to tell you her name, because that's awful,\n               but I had a friend recently.... We had to fly to Vancouver for work. We put our IDs in — no problem.\n               Well, we come to come back here and realize her ID expired. Had the same person on\n               both sides. So now we have to figure, well, how do we get her home? Do we drive to\n               the ferry to get her home? And we were just like, \"Well, you know it was us,\" so we\n               had to plead this big case; it took a bunch of time. Thank god someone was sweet enough to ensure that, \"Okay, we'll let you go this one\n               time,\" but in this new system? Could have pulled up her phone, could have had it done,\n               could have had it digitally and could have had it ready, and this wouldn't have been\n               an issue. This is modernization in action. For a sailor being deployed overseas, this means\n               renewing a licence digitally instead of worrying about returning home to an expired\n               document; it means fewer administrative headaches during an already demanding period\n               of service; and it means peace of mind. I think everyone on both sides of this House can agree that whoever is leaving to\n               support our country, to keep us safe, that we need to put every tool in their toolbox\n               to make sure that they can have what they need to take a little less anxiety off them\n               at home. As the Parliamentary Secretary for Armed Forces Development and Veterans Affairs, I believe we must be constantly asking ourselves: \"Are we removing barriers for\n               those who serve? Are we making everyday life simpler for them and their families?\" Some of the work I do on Seamless Canada is actually look at how we're taking down\n               barriers between each province, coast to coast, ensuring that when military families and their serving member move here, we make\n               it easier for them. And I believe this legislation is actually a good step. This legislation answers a question with a clear yes. I want to be clear what this bill does and what it does not do. It applies simple\n               renewals and replacements. It does not eliminate requirements for in-person visits\n               where they are absolutely necessary. If a driver needs to change their name, report\n               a new medication, or address outstanding fines or remedial requirements, they will\n               still be required to find a local ICBC office and go in there, just like they would\n               with the previous process, and get what needs to get done. Because let's be very clear. This is not about lowering the standards. It's not about\n               putting unqualified drivers on the road. All existing eligibility conditions will\n               remain in place. Those with unresolved violations or program requirements will not\n               be able to renew online until those matters are addressed, because road safety remains\n               paramount. I know some may ask: \"What about fraud? What about identity protection?\" ICBC is working\n               closely with the Ministries of Health and Citizens' Services to ensure robust security measures are built within the system. High standards for\n               identity and resilient verification will be maintained. Law enforcement perspectives\n               have been incorporated, including consultation with British Columbia Association of\n               Chiefs of Police Traffic safety committee. We can modernize while maintaining integrity. We can improve convenience while preserving security. I'm going to give you another example. If you come to a detox facility, you want to\n               get on your feet. Right? Everyone's like: \"I want to get on my feet. I want to better\n               my life. I want to start my road to recovery.\" If you come to the detox facility without\n               your CareCard, it actually causes a whole list of problems. So I'm going to start at the beginning of the first problem. Say you need income assistance.\n               You need some form of identification so we can look at how we can support somebody\n               to get on income assistance, which may not seem like a big deal, but is really the\n               first step to be able to afford treatment, to afford 30-day programs in recovery houses. In theory, under the old system, if it were to stay the same, as a detox worker I'd\n               have to find that person In theory, under the old system, if it were to stay the same, as a detox worker, I'd\n               have to find that person, someone in the community, to drive all the way to detox,\n               pick up the person. Then they have to do a urine and breathalyzer before they go.\n               It's time of the staff who work there. We let them go to ICBC with this worker. Now, keep in mind, they still need some form of identification to prove it is who\n               they are to do this, to get this. It can cause some problems. Hopefully, they can\n               get it worked out. Then they have to drive all the way back to detox. We have to,\n               again, do a urine screen and breathalyzer to make sure things are good, just to get\n               the little piece of paper. All of that just to get an ID and make sure we're helping somebody get where they\n               need to go. Seems a bit silly, right? As a detox worker now, if we were to put this in place, I would be able to take someone\n               within a program, sit them down and help them do this — some of our most vulnerable,\n               who are out of place mentally, that don't know that two plus two is four. They'll\n               tell you two plus two is 30, because they have no idea what's going on in the world. We want to simplify their life. We want to make their life easier. This legislation\n               would actually do that, because we want to help people. We want to make sure that\n               we make things easier for everyday British Columbians. Again, this is a first step\n               to doing that. In fact, eight other provinces and territories, including Alberta, Ontario, Quebec,\n               New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland, Prince Edward Island and the Northwest Territories\n               — shocking — already do this. They're already offering some form of online driver\n               licence service. These amendments bring British Columbia in line with those jurisdictions. I'll go back to that other work I'm doing with Seamless Canada. We want to make sure,\n               whenever possible, where anyone's moved in the country, we're making it easier. We\n               want to make it easier for them to come to British Columbia. We don't want to put something like this, that could be a sillier barrier, in place.\n               We want to make sure it's easier. This is, again, the first stage of modernization,\n               not the final stage. We are starting with simple renewal with the expectation that\n               more services will be offered online in the future. You will often hear me say we need to baby-step things. We need to take it one step\n               at a time. We need to take a little baby step to get to a place so we can fix systems\n               that are broken. That way, when we're doing that and we're doing it along the way\n               in a reasonable pace, some of the concerns that were flagged, we're making sure we're\n               staying on top of that. We're working with other ministries to get that work done. I would be remiss if I did not address the graduated licensing program changes that\n               are forthcoming. Some people may not know about this, but I have massive, massive anxiety when it comes\n               to tests. I hate them, will cause me panic, have no desire to do it whatsoever. What other people in this House may not know is I actually don't have a driver's licence.\n               Because I have such anxiety around tests, I haven't gotten there. I know, right? But\n               you know what? We're going to do the great things that are going to make my anxiety\n               way less and other British Columbians less — how again we're making it easier for\n               access services. We're taking away red tape, buried access. Affordability. You know, we talk about that second driving test. There's a lot of\n               costs associated for people — younger people, new immigrants to Canada, people who\n               are trying to get ahead. We again want to make it so much easier for them. In this summer of 2026, here in British Columbia, we'll be removing the requirement\n               for a second road test to obtain a class 5 license. I know my husband's watching right now, because I promised him, before 2027, this\n               will be done. Now I don't have an excuse, to be like: oh, there's two tests. That's\n               real anxiety. He can actually thank the ministries for doing that. You're welcome,\n               Joey. The second test will be replaced by a 12-month extension period, during which new\n               drivers must demonstrate safe driving behaviours unrestricted before a learning licence. You know, when we talk about that two step, a lot of like other provinces again....\n               When we're looking at making access and things easier, other provinces don't do that.\n               This is going to be a really good step in that direction. I remember moving here and being like: what do you mean you need to take two tests?\n               I mean, I come from Nova Scotia, where literally if I just would have went and got\n               a tractor licence, I could have gotten my licence — for the record, not saying maybe\n               that's the best way to do it, but you could technically do it. Research shows that maintaining a clean driving record over a longer period is a reliable\n               predictor of future safe driving behaviours, often more so than a single road test.\n               Road safety remains a priority, and these changes are grounded in evidence. As someone who has two young kids and is a pedestrian, I'm extremely invested in road\n               safety. The amount of times crossing roads where we've near head near misses? It's\n               really important that we're working with all people and all levels of government to\n               ensure road safety is a priority for everybody. I thought about that when I was in\n               local government, and I say that now here in the Legislature. Importantly, these improvements will also lower barriers for drivers in rural, remote\n               and Importantly, these improvements will also lower barriers for drivers in rural, remote\n               and Indigenous communities. Again, travelling long distances for a second road test\n               can also be challenging. It can be challenging not just for the travel. I mean, you\n               talk about the time of year. Right, our friends in the North. We're grateful here\n               on the south Island to not have snow, and I will say that before something happens. Again it's not just about the distance. It's about: is the weather there? Is there\n               staff going to be available? How far away is it? Do I need child care to go take that\n               test? There's a whole list of those things. Again, by looking at how we're going to\n               get rid of those barriers, it's making access more accessible, especially for our\n               friends in the rural areas. Taken together these forms reflect a broader commitment to making services faster,\n               easier and more accessible. For the residents of Esquimalt-Colwood, that means fewer unnecessary trips and more effective service. For families juggling\n               working in child care, that means time saved. For rural and remote British Columbians,\n               that means reduced travel and expenses. That means one less thing to worry about for\n               those members who are serving our country. Government should work for people, not\n               the other way around. Modernization may not have flashy headlines, but it is about removing friction in\n               everyday life. You will quite often hear me go: \"I respect people's time more than\n               anything else because time is invaluable.\" It's about respecting people's time. It's\n               about recognizing that in 2026, we should not require an in-person visit for tasks\n               that can be completely securely done online. This legislation reflects the commonsense\n               principle. Madam Speaker, welcome to the chair. I am proud to support the amendments to the Motor Vehicle Act. I believe they strike\n               the right balance between convenience, accountability, modernization and security.\n               Most importantly, they demonstrate that were listening to families, to people in our\n               rural communities and to the members of the Canadian Armed Forces, who serve our country\n               with honour. But I would be amiss not to give a shout-out to my past colleagues at MoveUp, our\n               good union members at ICBC. Again, people know in this House I always stand and talk\n               about my time on labour council and the good work that those people do, so I want\n               to give them a shout-out and thank them for giving good public service to our people\n               at ICBC, whether that's renewing your health care card, your CareCard, and all those\n               things that come with it. Again, thank you Madam Speaker. Thank you, everyone, and have a good time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328037","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I rise on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, known as Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. I'd like to thank them for their stewardship on their land, as someone whose\n               office is also located on their lands. I'm pleased to rise today in support of the legislation to amend the Motor Vehicle\n               Act, legislation that represents a practical, thoughtful step toward mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6ecad374ba6f0025cebadf08d297bbd644b9ab0b4cddf439809591f019163b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0806c91c6cb57ed09bcfcd3bb01cdda5ca9e1c3eec9c6efb84ee4abaab207e2d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36905e998e569fecf54c9da2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328038,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before we carry on, I think it's worthwhile to wish every woman in the Legislature\n               today an early happy International Women's Day. International Women's Day is this\n               upcoming Sunday, and with the most women ever elected to this building, I think there's\n               value in wishing everyone on both sides of the House a happy International Women's\n               Day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328038","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Before we carry on, I think it's worthwhile to wish every woman in the Legislature\n               today an early happy International Women's Day. International Women's Day is this\n               upcoming Sunday, and with the most women ever elected to this building, I think there's\n               value in wishing everyone on both sides of the House a happy International Women's\n               Day.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ffcbab2379fbf9bccaffc8acd2f4c70184ba3dfb52469a02d473cd739ffc7da"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69d1d0ce426448c4382a9343","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360875,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to start by acknowledging that I'm on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, known as the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. I also am grateful to have my constituency\n               office on their lands as well. I rise to speak in support of Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment, legislation\n               that strengthens the fairness, accessibility and efficiency of employment standards\n               enforcement in British Columbia. As people in this House know, I come from and have a fairly extensive labour background\n               in the broader labour movement, standing up for workers rights. But as well as: \"How\n               do employers and workers work together in fairness?\" This bill does something simple but profoundly important. When people have a problem\n               at work and believe their employment standards are not being represented, they deserve\n               to be heard. They deserve to be taken seriously, and they deserve a system that works\n               for them. For many workers across British Columbia, the employment standards branch is a place\n               they turn to when they have nowhere else to go. It is where they can seek help if\n               they have not been paid what they are owed, if they have been denied their basic workplace\n               rights or if they feel they have been treated unfairly. The bill strengthens the system\n               so it can work better for everyone involved. The employment standards branch, or ESB, as I'll refer to it, plays a critical role\n               in protecting workers throughout our province. It receives and investigates complaints\n               under the Employment Standards Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act.\n               It helps ensure that employees receive minimum standards of compensation and working\n               conditions they are entitled to under the law. At the same time, the branch provides guidance and support for employers who want\n               to understand and comply with those laws. In other words, the branch exists not only\n               to resolve disputes but also to promote fairness, predictability and accountability\n               in workplaces across B.C. Bill 10 introduces targeted amendments that will improve the complaint and dispute\n               resolution process at the employment standards branch. These changes are practical,\n               thoughtful and focus on helping people reach fair resolutions more quickly. I will say that, during my time as the president of the Victoria Labour Council and\n               recording secretary, the self-help toolkit that was utilized under the employment\n               standards program was very clearly not working. We had workers who would email or\n               call our labour organization quite regularly asking for help and support because they\n               couldn't get the support they needed because of the toolkit. As well, it put those workers in a really hard place. For those who don't know how\n               that toolkit worked, it required employees to attempt to resolve their issues directly\n               with their employer before the branch would accept that complaint at all. How are\n               you supposed...? If you have a dispute with your employer, and you're supposed to go\n               talk to the employer at the time.... It put people in a really precarious place. It was one of the reasons our organization at the time supported the Together Against\n               Poverty Society's employment standards organization, or ESO, as we called it. That\n               organization was actually supporting those workers because they felt they had no one\n               else to turn to. One of the most important elements of the legislation is improving service timelines.\n               Anyone who has ever been involved in a workplace dispute knows that time matters.\n               When a worker believes that they have not been paid properly, they cannot always afford\n               to wait months or years for answers, because that means their bills aren't getting\n               paid. They're not able to keep a roof over their head. They're not able to put food\n               on their table. When an employer faces a complaint, they also deserve clarity and certainty about\n               that outcome. Delays actually help nobody. The amendments before this House streamline several steps within the complaint system\n               while preserving the protections already established under the law. These changes\n               will allow the employment standards branch to resolve straightforward The amendments before this House streamline several steps within the complaint system,\n               while preserving the protections already established under the law. These changes\n               will allow the employment standards branch to resolve straightforward issues earlier\n               in the process and reduce administrative delays. The results can be significant. When the branch facility's resolution meeting between parties is, in approximate cases....\n               Approximately 75 percent of those meetings resolve involuntary resolutions within\n               30 to 45 days after a file is first assigned to an officer. That statistic demonstrates\n               something important. When people are given the opportunity to communicate and resolve\n               issues in a structured and fair environment, many disputes can actually be settled\n               quickly and effectively. In my previous role, when I was with my union, BCGEU, in the community health sector,\n               quite frankly, one of my favourite meetings was actually my labour management committee.\n               People used to think I was crazy, absolutely crazy. They were like: \"Why would you\n               want to sit with the employer and the unions?\" Because I believed through collaboration\n               that we could get to a common place because we had common goals, which were: how do\n               we keep the worksite going, and how do we work together to better the lives of the\n               people who work for us? Bill 10 kind of builds on that success. But requiring participation in resolution\n               means — in cases that are clear, straightforward — the legislation will help more\n               workers and employers reach solutions sooner. Another improvement in this Bill is to address an issue that may surprise many people:\n               unclaimed wages. Every year in British Columbia, those workers who are owed money\n               but cannot be located when those funds actually become available.... Sometimes they've\n               moved. Sometimes their contact information has changed. And sometimes they simply\n               do not know that a payment has been ordered in their favour. Bill 10 will allow the employment centre's branch to transfer those funds more effectively\n               to unclaimed B.C., the provincial organization responsible for safeguarding unclaimed\n               money and locating its rightful owner. Those workers went to work. Those workers earned\n               all those wages. And we want to make sure that we can take every effort they're compensated.\n               This change increases the likelihood that workers will eventually receive those wages\n               that they are owed. Wages are not just numbers on a page. They represent groceries on a table, rent payments,\n               child care costs and the ability to support themselves or their loved ones. Ensuring\n               those wages reach workers who earn them is a matter of fairness. It is also important to address concerns that are sometimes raised about impartiality\n               in the employment service process. The ESB is committed to a fair and balanced process\n               that supports both workers and employers. Investigators contact all parties involved\n               in a complaint. They invite submissions and gather facts from both sides. They examine\n               evidence carefully before making any determination, and when a decision is made, it\n               can still be appealed. Appeals are heard by the Employment Standards Tribunal, an\n               independent body that reviews decisions to ensure they are consistent with the law.\n               These safeguards ensure administrative justice is respected through the process. Bill 10 does not change that fundamental principle. Instead, it improves the procedure\n               that allows the system to function more effectively. One change included in this legislation involves the appeal process for employers.\n               Under the proposed amendments, employers who wish to appeal a determination on the\n               owed wages will be required to deposit the amount owed in trust before the appeal\n               process. It is important to clarify what this requirement means. It applies only in the situation\n               where the ESB has already determined the wages are owed, the employer has chosen not\n               to comply with the order to pay those wages, and the employer wishes to appeal that\n               determination. If the appeal overturns the decision, the deposit will be returned.\n               However, if the determination is upheld, that fund will already be available for the\n               worker who was rightfully owed that money. This approach is consistent with practices in many other jurisdictions across Canada.\n               Its purpose is straightforward, ensuring that workers are not left waiting and definitely\n               for wages that have already been determined to be owed. Before entering this House, like I said, I spent many years in the labour movement.\n               During that time, I saw firsthand how important employment standards protections are\n               for working people. For many people who do not know, as a trade unionist and as a\n               proud union member, one of our other goals is to lift everybody up. It was to represent\n               and support workers who did not have the same protections that I had under my collective\n               agreement. I like to believe most employers in B.C. do the right thing. They treat their employees\n               fairly and comply with the law. In some cases, those same owners and businesses treat\n               their employees like family. They truly care. However, when problems arise, though,\n               and there are some bad apples, workers must have confidence that the system However, when problems arise, though, and there are some bad apples, workers must\n               have confidence that the system does designate to protect them with functioning efficiency.\n               Responsible employers also deserve a system that resolves dispute quickly and predictably\n               so they can focus on running their business. I can appreciate that sometimes these\n               processes take up a lot of time, and if you are a small business owner, time is money.\n               Bill 10 helps achieve that balance. In my current role as Parliamentary Secretary for Armed Forces Development and Veterans Affairs, I wanted to speak briefly about how strong employment standards benefit members\n               of our CAF and their families. Members often relocate across the country as part of\n               their service, with spouses getting new jobs in unfamiliar communities while supporting\n               deployments and postings. I'm quite proud. I don't know if people on both sides of the House heard. On Friday,\n               we actually made a really good announcement for military families, for job postings.\n               It's very exciting. I can send you the link. If you're a military spouse now coming to British Columbia, the day you receive your\n               posting message you can actually start looking for employment opportunity. We want\n               to ensure that we're getting those skilled workers that are military spouses, across\n               the province, jobs before they put their foot on the ground. Not only will that help\n               keep the family unit stronger. It will help the businesses here. It will also ensure\n               that financial stability is there for housing and other options. That labour mobility for those people can sometimes make them a little more vulnerable\n               in our labour market. Ensuring that employment standard protections are accessible\n               and effectively enforced is a part of supporting those families. When workers know\n               there is a reliable system in place to address workplace concerns, it creates greater\n               confidence in the labour market for everybody, including those families in my community\n               of Esquimalt. Since the test of time, it's been very clear. You go to work; you get paid. People\n               should know that they can rely on that system from when it started until today. It's also important to emphasize that these amendments do not weaken protection for\n               vulnerable workers. The changes are designed to improve efficiency in the interpretation\n               and administration and enforcement of the Employment Standards Act and Temporary Foreign\n               Worker Protection Act without compromising the rights those laws provide. Investigators will continue to assess whether resolution meetings are appropriate\n               in each case. They will consider language barriers, health and safety concerns, relationships\n               between the parties involved and any other factors that may affect someone's ability\n               to participate. If a resolution meeting is not appropriate, the branch will continue\n               to investigate complaints using existing processes. I recognize that this system may not be for everyone. However, I can say that, again,\n               for anyone who's ever sat down at a table to work collaboratively through that kind\n               of mediation process, it is such a valuable tool to get ahead. The goal is not to\n               force resolution where it is not possible. The goal is to create more opportunities\n               for fair and timely solutions where they are appropriate. British Columbia's economy depends on strong workplaces built on fairness and respect.\n               Workers deserve to know their rights will be protected, and our government has a long\n               track record of doing that. Workers deserve a system that is clear, predictable and\n               efficient. Government has a responsibility to ensure that the institutions responsible\n               for enforcing those laws are equipped to do their job effectively with the tools necessary. Bill 10 reflects that responsibility. It strengthens the tools, which were not there\n               before our government came into effect, for the employment standards branch, streamlines\n               processes that currently slow down resolutions and helps ensure that workers receive\n               the wages they are owed as quickly as possible. Again, that is the food on someone's\n               plate, the rent over their head or the child care they may need. Behind every complaint file is a real person: a worker trying to make ends meet, a\n               family relying on a paycheque or an employer trying to resolve a dispute and move\n               forward. This legislation ensures that when those situations arise, the system works\n               the way it should. For those reasons, I am proud to support the Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act, and I encourage all members of this House to support Bill 10 as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360875","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to start by acknowledging that I'm on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, known as the Songhees and xwsepsəm Nations. I also am grateful to have my constituency\n               office on their lands as well. I rise to speak in support of Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment, legislation\n               that strengthens the fairness, accessibility and efficiency of employment stand","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c3078cf3206eaa2e017ac306da20415dc0c3c08877b6bdcd4ede952d4d3883f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a212b9bec130eb3ae2f197bf5b991b880448b1bbf725ddf17cbb3b9a1d4fc35"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96b337c4ca1d6e4053526b66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360876,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you Mr. Speaker. I have three introductions to make today. First I'd like to\n               recognize, in the gallery, my staffer Alex, from my constituency office. Alex started\n               part-time with me and is now moving into a full-time position. During the last federal\n               election, unfortunately, her employer wasn't re-elected, so I was very excited to\n               pick her up for my office. Will the House make her feel most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360876","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you Mr. Speaker. I have three introductions to make today. First I'd like to\n               recognize, in the gallery, my staffer Alex, from my constituency office. Alex started\n               part-time with me and is now moving into a full-time position. During the last federal\n               election, unfortunately, her employer wasn't re-elected, so I was very excited to\n               pi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2330fcf9e56fe865a4bbc7567f05b7cd97932c3ec8f1eaf4aae13bb813d0854"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f861cef085eb91d36f95a02d2b90ca7bd872f4e5bd8bd44588a3b631676c0908"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a69ebbc43e7d3f44e2c623ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360877,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress of the estimates for the Ministry\n               of Forests and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360877","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress of the estimates for the Ministry\n               of Forests and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["da848dd044b9c691209a5d9a2537d8eabc884ad6d7355939f491375fc1d2dcf8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fc0e02971d45d11a2625471e81f6cc7095c7429130efda54514f56a85b2f34c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-daf6a5765d27a714ec5fd814","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415809,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a few, so please bear with me. First, I will start with, in the gallery, I\n               would like to recognize we have the president of the B.C. Federation of Labour, Sussanne\n               Skidmore, here with us, as well as the president for Victoria Labour Council, Kirk\n               Mercer, who is also the CUPE skilled trades spokesperson. As well as, today, we'll be having joining us Kale Anguish, marine government representative\n               for Indigenous outreach with IBEW 230; Shane Scott from North Island Construction,\n               representative; Rob McGatt, dispatcher; Cory McGregor, training coordinator; Cassidy\n               Van Waugh, apprentice coordinator; Russell Alexander and Jake Herrmann, membership\n               development; Raj Chikhar, president; Jackie Oliver, vice-president; Adrian Livingston,\n               treasurer; Al Stokke, Victoria chair; Dave Lambert, Nanaimo chair; Shane Varley, Courtenay–Campbell River chair; Jeremy Switz, marine and veterans committee chair; Lexi Redman,\n               youth chair; Jack Sainer, youth guest; as well as Phil Van Waugh, the business manager\n               and financial secretary; as well as Lauren Scott-Moncraft, the recording secretary;\n               and Jim Watson, a retired IBEW international trainer. We will also have, from our plumbers and pipefitters union, Stefan Ploza, Kevin Povacki\n               and Jim Noon, their business manager and financial agent; as well as from our sheet\n               metal worker union here, Jason Pedestrian. He's the business manager, financial agent\n               and secretary as well. Will the House make them feel welcome. Will the House make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415809","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have a few, so please bear with me. First, I will start with, in the gallery, I\n               would like to recognize we have the president of the B.C. Federation of Labour, Sussanne\n               Skidmore, here with us, as well as the president for Victoria Labour Council, Kirk\n               Mercer, who is also the CUPE skilled trades spokesperson. As well as, today, we'll be having joining ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035259","label":"Financial services","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","label":"Business services","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c33e88f8f08f1311090ea730278c1e6ac57690bbd5f9338012ca4d4985dfa10"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a61e0979c35b212f989631dd1a8aba651ab29b962cf38c8aa9fa28475b847972"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bff48a539cc0e68d1390efd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415810,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to start by acknowledging that I'm on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən people, known as Songhees and xwsepsəm, and thanking them for allowing me to work on their land. I'm honoured to rise here today in the House to speak strong on this bill. I would\n               hope that we can all agree within this chamber.... Sometimes we disagree on a lot of\n               things, but I think the safety of one of our most valuable assets is something we\n               can agree on. Our children are one of the most valuable things we have in this province. This legislation is at the very heart of what it means. We want to ensure that our\n               children have a safe, respectful, inclusive learning environment for when they go\n               to school. We want to make sure they're safe. At the core of this bill is something\n               very simple, but profoundly important — ensuring people in British Columbia can access\n               the place that matters to their children the most, our schools, not just for our children\n               but for all the people who work there and volunteer there as well. Schools should be a safe place for children. This is not a controversial statement.\n               I believe this is probably a shared expectation among many in this province. Yet in\n               recent years, we have seen a troubling rise in incidents that challenge these basic\n               expectations. We have seen protests and confrontations outside schools that disrupt\n               learning and leave students and their educators feeling very unsafe. We have seen\n               threats and we have seen vandalism and intimidation targeting our schools. This is very concerning for someone who has young children, for what the future may\n               look for them if we don't do this and get a handle on it. This is not abstract concern;\n               these are real experiences. Here in the south of Vancouver Island, whether you're talking to our Greater Victoria\n               Teachers Association, our CUPE members, our ECEs or the parents, there is a very underlying\n               anxiety in these people when they're talking about their children going to school,\n               especially with some of the recent incidents, unfortunately, that have happened in\n               this province. These are real experiences affecting real people — children who are\n               just going to school to learn, parents trying to drop their kids off at school and\n               families simply trying to gather. This is why our government is taking action. Bill 12, the Safe Access to Schools Amendment\n               Act, extends protections we first introduced in 2023. Then, just like now, it was\n               to ensure that safe access to school zones around schools would remain in place and\n               now will be in place, if this passes, until July 1, 2028. These zones have already proven effective in reducing disruptive behaviours near schools,\n               but we know that issue has not disappeared. Since its introduction, there have been\n               dozens of reported disruptions outside of kindergarten-to-grade-12 schools. Even one\n               incident that interferes with a child's ability to feel safe and By extending this legislation we are sending a clear message. There is no place for\n               intimidation or disruption when our children are trying to learn. Within these zones certain behaviours are prohibited. Not opinions, but behaviours\n               — actions like physically blocking access, using intimidation or deliberately causing\n               it that students can't access their schools. I want to be very clear about this, though.\n               This law does not ban protest. In fact, I can't deny it. There are many pictures of me in front of this building, perhaps on a picket line with our BCTF and our CUPE members a time or two, having\n               some peaceful protest, standing up for the rights of those teachers and, at times,\n               actually the students with us. But I think, as I stand here and kind of giggle with some of my colleagues across\n               the way in here.... I think to say that was a peaceful protest with respectful debate\n               and we're not blocking access and I think that's what's really important. We still\n               encourage those peaceful protests. There's a time and a place for it but not at the\n               cost of intimidating or not allowing our children to have safe access to their schools. Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of our democracy, and our government fully\n               supports that right. People may remain free to express their views, to gather and\n               to protest. What this bill does is set reasonable boundaries, ensuring that expression\n               does not cross that line to harm, intimidation or obstruction, because it's about balance. It is about balancing the right to protest\n               with the right of a child to walk into their school without fear. It's about recognizing\n               that rights come with responsibilities. I also want to highlight that this bill is not about being introduced in isolation.\n               It's part of our broader effort to address rising hate and protect our students, again,\n               our staff and our volunteers across this province. We are also listening. We're listening to educators, to parents, to community organizations\n               and to our law enforcement. Their feedback has been clear. These protections are needed\n               and it will help make a difference. Police have told us that safe access zones around\n               schools have already been an effective tool for de-escalation. And importantly, these measures include safeguards. This legislation contains a sunset\n               clause, ensuring that it will be reviewed and reassessed. This reflects our commitment\n               to getting the balance right, not just today but into the future. I appreciate the\n               comments made across the way because, at the end of the day, this is a constantly\n               changing environment. One would hope that we could be optimistic that maybe down the\n               road we won't need this, but I think having that sunset clause makes sure that we\n               are keeping it alive and real and looking at how that is. We also have to acknowledge the broader context. Around the world, here at home, we\n               are seeing increased polarization and, at times, rising hostility directed at different\n               communities. In moments like this, leadership also matters. We have a responsibility\n               to stand up for the values that define us — respect, inclusion and safety for all. That bill does exactly that. It does not take sides. It does not target any particular\n               group or viewpoint. It applies equally, regardless of who you are and what you believe.\n               The focus is clear and narrow to prevent harmful conduct and ensure safe access for\n               our students to their schools to get the learning that they deserve. To being safe\n               while they're getting the learning that they deserve. As legislators, we are often called upon to make difficult decisions, to weigh competing\n               rights and interests. And in this case, I believe this bill strikes the right balance.\n               It protects our children, our most valuable asset. Because if we don't, we know what\n               that consequence will be. It doesn't just physically protect them. As someone who\n               worked in mental health and addiction, who has seen directly the outcomes, if someone\n               isn't protected and their mental health isn't protected, that can come from that....\n               So it's also ensuring that we're protecting them It upholds the fundamental principle that everyone deserves to feel safe in our schools.\n               Again, if our children are the most valuable asset in a school, then one could argue\n               the next most valuable asset is the people who actually teach them, the volunteers\n               who go in and volunteer there. So we also have to ensure that we're taking care of\n               them as well. I really hope that everyone here can support this bill. Before we went on break —\n               for anyone who listened to my two-minute statement, I know you're all very excited\n               about it — I talked about how we can.... My office right across the way is laughing. You know, we talked about.... We need to come together and work together. We may not\n               always agree how to get there, but we agree that we care about British Columbians\n               and, again, the most valuable asset we have as British Columbians are our children. I hope that everyone will support this bill, because we need to ensure that when our\n               children go to school, they are safe, they're taken care of while they're there, so\n               they can go home at the end of the day, their teachers can go home at the end of the\n               day, our volunteers can go home at the end of the day, and they're all safe while\n               trying to access that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415810","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to start by acknowledging that I'm on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən people, known as Songhees and xwsepsəm, and thanking them for allowing me to work on their land. I'm honoured to rise here today in the House to speak strong on this bill. I would\n               hope that we can all agree within this chamber.... Sometimes we disagree on a lot of\n               things, but I think the safety ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["437a1b2083571e2ec19af6132cf9968fd438d940940d0cf729e45afd0b0d0c46"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7de6d2fc10c0c65b2f8a18b28efb2e4e94874d8722a218fa27ca3258642970e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c069e51e6f63a91806126aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415811,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to start by acknowledging we're on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən people known\n               as the xwsepsəm and Songhees Nations and thanking them for allowing me to do the work\n               I do not just here in this building but within my riding of Esquimalt-Colwood. I am honoured to rise here today in this House to speak in strong support of Bill\n               13, legislation that goes to the very heart of what it means to live in a safe, respectful\n               and inclusive environment. At the core, this bill does something simple but profoundly\n               important — ensuring that people in British Columbia can access the places that matter\n               most to them, our places of worship, and that they can do so free of intimidation,\n               obstruction and fear. Places of worship should be a safe place for people. This is not a controversial statement;\n               this is a shared expectation. The ability to gather in prayer, reflection and community\n               without harassment or disruption is fundamental to who we are as Canadians and British\n               Columbians. Yet in recent years, we have seen a troubling rise in incidents that challenge that\n               basic expectation. We have seen threats, vandalism and intimidation targeting places\n               of worship — spaces that serve not only as centres of faith but that anchor our communities\n               right across British Columbia. These are not abstract concerns. These are real experiences affecting people simply\n               trying to get to a place to gather in peace. I will note, toward some comments that were made across the way, that we're seeing\n               this not just here in British Columbia through a fault of any policy of ours but across\n               the country, under different governments whether that is a progressive NDP government,\n               a progressive Conservative government, a Conservative, Liberal.... Across the board,\n               everyone is seeing this. All of us equally are looking at different ways we can mitigate\n               this and support people across the country. So this is why our government is taking action. Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places\n               of Public Worship Act, establishes protections to ensure that people can attend services,\n               ceremonies and gatherings without being obstructed, threatened or harassed. Importantly, this legislation is carefully designed to allow places of worship, such\n               as churches Importantly, this legislation is carefully designed to allow places of worship, such\n               as churches, mosques, synagogues, gurdwaras and temples, to establish safe access\n               zones simply by posting clear signage. These zones are limited in size, generally\n               including the building, its property and a modest buffer area of approximately 20\n               metres. Within those zones, certain behaviours are prohibited — not beliefs, not opinions\n               but behaviours, actions like physically blocking access, using intimidation or deliberately\n               disrupting services. I want to be clear about this. This law does not ban protest. You heard me talk yesterday\n               about another bill. I believe foremost in the right to peaceful protest. I had joked that I had been perhaps on the front\n               lawn a time or two here myself or some other organizations during strike action in\n               my previous life, and I stand for that right to do so as long as it's done peacefully\n               and people aren't hurt. Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of our democracy, and our government fully\n               supports that right. People remain free to express their views together and to protest.\n               What this bill does is set reasonable boundaries, ensuring that expression does not\n               cross the line to harm, intimidation or obstruction. It is about balance. It's about\n               balancing the right to protest and balancing freedom of expression with the right\n               of a family to attend a place of worship without being shouted at or blocked or harassed\n               for entering. It's about recognizing that rights come with responsibility. I also want to highlight that this law is not being introduced in isolation. They\n               are part of a broader effort to address rising hate and protect communities across\n               our province. The member just said that public safety needs to be taken seriously.\n               Well, I believe this legislation is an example of another tool that we can do to do\n               that. We are investing in the B.C. hate crimes unit, expanding its capacity and supporting\n               community organizations through our anti-hate community support fund. We are also\n               listening, learning from people of faith, faith leaders, community organizations and\n               law enforcement. The feedback has been clear. These protections are needed, and they\n               will make a difference. In fact, when this legislation was brought forward and was\n               announced, our minister, with people of multiple different faith groups, stood together\n               in solidarity to say that they supported this, right here in the Legislature. People have told us that safe access zones around schools have already been an effective\n               tool for de-escalation. We want that. We expect similar results when we see that within\n               a place of worship. Importantly, these measures include safeguards. This piece of legislation contains\n               a sunset clause, ensuring they will be reviewed and reassessed. This reflects our\n               commitment to getting the balance right, not just today but into our future. We must also acknowledge the broader context. Around the world, here at home, we are\n               seeing an increased polarization and, at times, rising hostility directed at different\n               community groups. At moments like this, leadership matters. We have a responsibility\n               to stand up for the values that define us: respect, inclusion and safety for all.\n               I would hope in this building that that's something we can all agree on. I believe this bill does that. It does not take sides. It does not target any particular\n               group or viewpoint. It applies equally regardless of who you are or what you believe.\n               Its focus is clear and narrow: to prevent harmful conduct and ensure safety. As legislators, we are often called upon to make difficult decisions, to weigh competing\n               rights and interests, and in this case, I believe this bill does strike that right\n               balance. It protects communities of faith. It upholds our fundamental principle that\n               everyone deserves to feel safe in spaces that matter most. If you were to tell me when I was a child going to Catholic school on Sundays and\n               participating in my own religion that I would be up having to even have this debate\n               or conversation, I don't think I would have actually believed anybody. I don't think\n               I would have taken it seriously. There's no way we would have even had to have these\n               conversations. I often joke, you know.... I was raised Catholic. Sometimes I joke I have had some concerns\n               with my own religion, but I think at the base of most religions, it's about taking\n               care of our communities. I believe as legislators we all have an equal responsibility to do that no matter\n               what our background is, whether it's the religious or not actually. I believe it should\n               be based on policy, good policy, good legislation, and I believe this does that. With that, I do urge all members of this House to support Bill 13 during With that, I do urge all members of this House to support Bill 13. During question period throughout this session and last session, people have asked\n               us questions from the opposition about what we're doing to keep the public safe. I\n               think this legislation is a great example of how we're doing that for our faith-based\n               communities across the province, whatever that may look like. Again, I hope people on the other side can support this legislation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415811","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to start by acknowledging we're on the lands of the lək̓wəŋən people known\n               as the xwsepsəm and Songhees Nations and thanking them for allowing me to do the work\n               I do not just here in this building but within my riding of Esquimalt-Colwood. I am honoured to rise here today in this House to speak in strong support of Bill\n               13, legislation that goe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c8a0ce136d48d56b8ec43dc427c02d1005db73cafd11011985a7a509e476c40a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["81c086165bcd20793c128ef52749fdab55531b3cd679700478a926f183f6d2c3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b99b4fa05cf22e2f222494b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415812,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports Bill 10 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415812","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section C reports Bill 10 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2563edfca6400e7852621246","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720531,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy Monday, Mr. Speaker. Today I have many guests in the House, so please bear with\n               me. First and most importantly, I have some of our firefighters in the House. I'd like\n               to make an introduction for BCPFFA President Todd Schierling, as well as some of our\n               members from Local 730; IAFF Local President Josh Montgomery and one of his men as\n               well. I also want to introduce BCFED President Sussanne Skidmore; Brynn Bourke, B.C. Building\n               Trades executive director; Dan Jajic, business manager, IUPAT DC38; Roy Bizzutto,\n               business manager, Cement Masons 919; Bryan Railton, business manager, IUOE 115; Paul\n               Beacom, president, Ironworkers 97; Barry Capozzi, Teamsters 213; Pete Hayes, Ironworkers\n               97; Brian Lefebvre, IUOE 115; Wayne Peppard, former executive director, B.C. Building\n               Trades. Also, Phil Venoit, business manager, IBEW 230; Corry Anderson-Fennell, LiUNA, 1611;\n               Jim Noon, business manager, UA 324; Andrew Brown, CMAW; Josh Towsley, IUOE 115; Janna\n               Little, Ironworkers 97; Brad Demelo, IUPAT DC 38 Can you please make them all feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720531","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Happy Monday, Mr. Speaker. Today I have many guests in the House, so please bear with\n               me. First and most importantly, I have some of our firefighters in the House. I'd like\n               to make an introduction for BCPFFA President Todd Schierling, as well as some of our\n               members from Local 730; IAFF Local President Josh Montgomery and one of his men as\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc20cae7cde7a014eb63432328215fd7199eb40119278c866d4c2fd558f2adc3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84dfdc1ee97a93f85ce485745030e0dbe55b484b9f17bed06b6c251633bb5e13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c2ffa87e9ee406260b20201","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720533,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two guests in the House today. One is Councillor Ken Armour and his stepdaughter\n               Leah Massine-Philip. I had a lovely time spending my time in local government with Councillor Armour, and\n               now I get to work with him in another capacity. I'm always excited to see our local government in the House, so hopefully everyone\n               can give them a big welcome to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720533","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have two guests in the House today. One is Councillor Ken Armour and his stepdaughter\n               Leah Massine-Philip. I had a lovely time spending my time in local government with Councillor Armour, and\n               now I get to work with him in another capacity. I'm always excited to see our local government in the House, so hopefully everyone\n               can give them a big welcome to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:735732","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armouries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:735732","label":"Armouries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52f8f320c13f12622289687a99895b80bfdf3d62b2666bc07dcb452a74c38116"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d748823ade25cc8001a1feb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720535,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am proud to highlight the work of Victoria Brain Injury Society, an extraordinary\n               local organization that supports people living with brain injuries in our community\n               for over 40 years. In B.C., more than 180,000 people live with brain injuries — caused by concussion,\n               head injuries, motor vehicles, domestic violence, workplace injuries — that can change\n               theirs lives in the blink of an eye. Survivors often experience memory loss, cognitive\n               challenges and difficulties with emotional regulation affecting their independence,\n               careers and relationships. Yet acquired brain injury is often misunderstood as a hidden disability, leaving many\n               survivors dismissed or without validation for symptoms that can persist long-term.\n               Through their programs, advocacy and commitment to public education, the Victoria\n               Brain Injury Society provides wraparound supports that improve quality of life for\n               survivors and their families. Their dedicated staff and volunteers foster a supportive\n               community where individuals navigating the challenge of a diagnosis feel understood\n               and valued. When a loved one receives a brain injury diagnosis it can be overwhelming for families\n               and caregivers to know how to best provide support, especially as they try to understand\n               challenges in memory, mood or energy. VBIS provides personalized support through their\n               Stronger Together program, helping families feel empowered and informed about available\n               resources and better able to advocate for their loved ones. Survivors of brain injury also face significant barriers to accessing safe and affordable\n               housing. Challenges with memory, retention and emotional regulation increase the risk\n               of depression, anxiety, substance abuse and homelessness. Through their housing outreach\n               program, survivors have accessed safe, reliable housing. Participants build skills\n               that foster resilience, confidence, independence and empowerment, reminding them that\n               their diagnosis does not undermine or limit them. I am grateful for the Victoria Brain Injury Society's dedication and continued commitment\n               to supporting people with brain injuries and for the remarkable impact they have on\n               survivors, family and our community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720535","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I am proud to highlight the work of Victoria Brain Injury Society, an extraordinary\n               local organization that supports people living with brain injuries in our community\n               for over 40 years. In B.C., more than 180,000 people live with brain injuries — caused by concussion,\n               head injuries, motor vehicles, domestic violence, workplace injuries — that can","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["81e3cee30ecfb026440d4bcc9c722fa7acdd0ef80865fbd0e1d9687ed1050639"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45b7d62ae57eac2b538244add7dc0c4547a7e0e9ed918c04dc6da88688aa609e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-940605a5999d5f899f8f3acb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720538,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Good afternoon. It's a privilege to rise in this House in strong support of Bill 14,\n               the B.C. Timber Sales legislative amendments. I'd like to thank the minister for bringing this forward and being a champion for\n               this sector. For many of you who may not know, I'm actually not originally from British Columbia.\n               I've talked in this House that I'm from a very small town in Nova Scotia, which was\n               a mill town. We're an industry-based town. I've seen firsthand how a mill closing\n               of 650 people overnight can actually affect your community, how an industry that dies\n               can affect your community. For those who don't know, that's also where the Westray\n               mine disaster happened. So I take industry and all that comes with it very seriously\n               when we're talking about community, jobs and what we're doing within them. At its core, this legislation is about people. It is about men and women, people working\n               in the bush, often in challenging conditions, who rely on the steady opportunities\n               to support their families. It is about the workers on mill floors who depend on a\n               consistent, predictable supply of fibre. And it's about the communities across British\n               Columbia whose economies are built on forestry and whose future depends on us getting\n               it right. For anyone who has ever taken a tour of the Legislature, and you go up in the rotunda\n               and you look, one of the key people standing there is in forestry, because we were\n               built on the forestry industry here in British Columbia. Bill 14 recognizes that reality.\n               It responds with practical, meaningful action. But one of the most important aspects of this legislation is that it expands timber\n               sales options in a way that directly supports good-paying jobs, something I think\n               we can all agree in this House on. By creating a wider range of contract opportunities\n               through B.C. Timber Sales, we are opening the door for more contractors, including\n               small and medium-sized operators, to participate in this sector. These are not By creating a wider range of contract opportunities through B.C. Timber Sales, we\n               are opening the door for more contractors, including small and medium-sized operators\n               to participate in this sector. These are not abstract policy changes. They are real opportunities for people to bid\n               on work, to grow their business, to invest equipment and to hire and train workers. For many contractors who do not hold long-term tenders and rely on access to fibre\n               through the open market, these changes represent a significant and long-overdue improvement. They mean better access to market price fibre. They mean great participation in the\n               forestry economy. They mean more stability in an industry that has experienced too\n               much uncertainty over the years. We've heard clearly from stakeholders across the sector that access to fibre is one\n               of the most pressing challenges they face. Without reliable access, mills cannot operate\n               on capacity. Without capacity, jobs are at risk. Without jobs, communities suffer. Bill 14 addresses this challenging but improving fibre flow across the province. By\n               expanding the types of timber sale licenses available and increasing the flexibility\n               of B.C. Timber Sales, we are ensuring that the right log gets the right mill at the\n               right time. This is particularly important for value-added manufacturers who often depend on specific\n               types of fibre and have historically faced barriers to accessing it. In fact, these\n               changes are expected to significantly increase the amount of fibre available to the\n               sector. This includes not only the overall increase in supply that has already been discussed\n               but also targeted improvements that will help ensure that fibre is distributed more\n               efficiently and equitably. Another key component of this legislation is a focus on salvaging logging and the\n               recovery of damaged timber. In recent years, British Columbia has experienced devastating\n               wildfires and other natural disasters that have left significant volumes of timber\n               damaged but still usable. Without timely action, that fibre is lost, representing both an economic loss and\n               a missed opportunity to reduce fuel loads and improve forest health. Bill 14 addresses\n               this by streamlining access to salvage opportunities, something people have been asking\n               for. These new approaches will allow for faster recovery of damaged timber, increasing\n               the amount of usable fibre that can be brought forward to market. They will support\n               mills, particularly in the pulp sector, that rely on that type of material. They will\n               create additional work for contractors who are ready and able to take on these projects. Importantly, this work also contributes to building a more wildfire-resilient landscape,\n               something I think we can all agree on. By removing damaged and high-risk material,\n               we are taking proactive steps to reduce future fire risk and protect communities. This legislation is also about strengthening long-term forest outcomes. For too long,\n               aspects of our system have been focused primarily on short-term harvest cycles. While\n               that approach has delivered benefits in the past, it is not sufficient to meet the\n               challenges we face today. Bill 14 supports a shift toward full-rotation forest management. This means looking\n               at the entire life cycle of a forest, from initial harvest through replanting and\n               ongoing stewardship, all the way to future harvest. By empowering B.C. Timber Sales to pay a strong role across that full cycle, we are\n               improving our ability to plant for the long term. We are shaping future forests for\n               resilience, for health and for high-quality timber. We are providing greater certainty\n               for workers, for communities and for investors who are dependent on stable predictable\n               supply of fibre. This long-term approach also reinforces B.C.'s position as a global\n               leader in sustainable forestry practices. I also want to highlight the importance of partnership in this Legislature. We know\n               that the future of forestry in B.C. must be built on collaboration. This includes\n               collaboration with First Nations, with our local communities, with industry and with\n               workers. Bill 14 enables more flexible and meaningful partnerships by giving B.C. Timber Sales\n               the tools it needs to work differently than in the past. It allows for approaches\n               that are tailored to our local priorities and that support shared stewardship outcomes. We've already seen encouraging results in this direction. The comments before me about\n               repealing UNDRIP and prioritizing different things.... I want to remember that it is\n               about partnerships with First Nations, having helped bring additional The support for these changes extends across the forestry sector. Industry associations,\n               labour organizations. As someone who has represented many labour organizations in\n               my time, including being the president of Victoria Labour Council and representing\n               the Island and the Sunshine Coast in the B.C. Federation of Labour and the Pacific\n               Region for the Canadian Labour Congress, it's an area I'm very familiar with. Representatives of value-added manufacturers have all recognized the importance of\n               improving fibre access and creating more flexible opportunities with B.C. Timber Sales.\n               They've spoken about the need for stability so that contractors can invest in their\n               workforce and modernize their equipment. They've emphasized the importance of ensuring\n               that mills have access to cost-effective logs so they can continue to operate and\n               support families, supporting jobs. Good jobs — good jobs in our community, good jobs\n               in the province. They've highlighted the role that increased fibre availability plays\n               in strengthening the communities across our province. This broad support reflects a shared understanding that we need to act. Bill 14 is\n               a meaningful step in the right direction. It is also worth noting that the changes we are advancing today build on real, measurable\n               progress. We've already seen an increase in timber sale volumes, improved access to\n               fibre for value-added manufacturers and expanded stewardship activities here on the\n               ground. We've seen innovative approaches, including the use of new technologies to support\n               forestry professionals and improve outcomes. These early results demonstrate that\n               when we give B.C. Timber Sales the tools they need, they can deliver. Bill 14 takes that momentum and builds on it. It strengthens B.C. Timber Sales as\n               a more flexible and responsible supplier of fibre, including those without traditional\n               tender, and it ensures that we continue to balance economic opportunities with strong\n               environmental stewardship and public interest outcomes. Because again, we all need\n               to work together, as we work together to ensure that British Columbians have everything\n               they're going to need. Forestry is not just an industry in B.C. It is a cornerstone of our economy and a\n               foundation of many of our communities, especially in our rural areas. The decisions\n               we make in this House have real consequences for people who depend on it. We have heard of those communities who are struggling. Mills closing across the province,\n               in the North and here on the Island. Bill 14 is protecting those communities. It's\n               about supporting those workers. It's about making sure that little kid has got what\n               they need to play baseball. That that parent has enough money to afford groceries,\n               that they can afford their mortgages and they can afford everything they're going\n               to need to live a good life in their community so they can stay here in British Columbia. I don't want to have to look at someone who did what I had to do and leave their home\n               province. I want to ensure whatever we do gets to keep those people here. It's important. So we're ensuring that our forests continue to provide economic, environmental and\n               social benefits for many generations to come — for me, for my daughters, for their\n               kids and for generations after. We're building a forestry sector that is more resilient, more inclusive and more sustainable.\n               We're doing so in a way that reflects the values of British Columbians. We cannot control global markets. We cannot control the policy of other countries\n               or stupid people on different levels of government. But we can take action here at\n               home to strengthen our own system, support our own workers, our own government and\n               to make the most of the resources we do have. Bill 14 does exactly that. It improves access to fibre, supporting good jobs. You\n               will never not hear me stand up here in this House and talk about good-paying jobs\n               for British Columbians, because it's at the heart of who I am. It's not just about my community. It's about making sure that there are good paying\n               jobs, again, for generations and generations to come. It enhances stewardship. It\n               sets the stage for a more stable, prosperous future for British Columbia — something,\n               again, I think all sides of the House can agree on. For all of those reasons, I am proud to stand here in support of this legislation.\n               I would be remiss if I didn't talk about some of those unions who are also fighting\n               the good fight, who unfortunately have lost their jobs. We need to get a path back\n               for them. Our steelworkers, our Unifor members — people who have stood the test of\n               time, long-standing union activists. I stand up here quite regularly and talk about\n               those workers I would be remiss if I didn't talk about some of those unions who are also fighting\n               the good fight, who unfortunately have lost their jobs. We need to get a path back\n               for them. Our steelworkers, our Unifor members, people who've stood the test of time,\n               long-standing union activists. I stand up here quite regularly and talk about those\n               workers. I was on a labour council that was established in 1887, and guess what one of the\n               first unions were — forestry workers. It talks about them and the work they did. They\n               helped build this province and, again, the very building we're in. We could not do\n               it without them today, then and in the future. I encourage all members of this House to join me in supporting Bill 14 and supporting\n               workers, communities, family, the forests themselves that it will benefit not just\n               today but for future generations, for those of my kids and for their little friends\n               and perhaps whoever they marry because, hopefully, they will stay in B.C. Hopefully,\n               you're watching this one day, and you choose to stay here. Again, I'd like to thank the minister for bringing this bill forward. I think this\n               bill is helping us move in the right direction to continue all the things I have stated\n               before.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720538","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Good afternoon. It's a privilege to rise in this House in strong support of Bill 14,\n               the B.C. Timber Sales legislative amendments. I'd like to thank the minister for bringing this forward and being a champion for\n               this sector. For many of you who may not know, I'm actually not originally from British Columbia.\n               I've talked in this House that I'm from a ve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e02d3111da8f430ee7dfe8b68ac38a6ec1ec71ecd400eb462fc90d0d83898f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e808aade12efb9ce622037a2686bae82fc301ebb09004beaa2e8b395fc01186"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfb4dfb2f37321e50d3de1cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721639,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions to make today. One.... he's watching from home. We all talk\n               about our partners in this House and how important they are. This past Saturday I\n               celebrated my five-year wedding anniversary with my husband. We were a COVID bride and groom, so it's never been a boring story — how we got married.\n               For those who don't know, we actually had our first dance on the front steps of this\n               Legislature, so it's kind of serendipitous to stand here today inside the Legislature\n               and get to acknowledge that. More importantly, today is also someone's birthday in the Legislature. I would like\n               to wish a very happy birthday to one of our favourite ministers, Minister of Emergency and Climate Solutions. Can everyone join me in wishing him a happy birthday?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721639","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have two introductions to make today. One.... he's watching from home. We all talk\n               about our partners in this House and how important they are. This past Saturday I\n               celebrated my five-year wedding anniversary with my husband. We were a COVID bride and groom, so it's never been a boring story — how we got married.\n               For those who don't know, we actually ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e464ba20ba510a9a3432e9e38a489dd451a6953904589e01759bab16a6531e03","f122202bb1675d8038a7127a2a72ee3983522c61e05e8697a9ffa3da02a736ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48fadd96afca1dbb7d7d65e6f41b99a354d35de407543c7c2ae345ff7f78ad7e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7559be17b863c187f6a03d10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721642,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker. It's nice to see you in the chair, making sure people\n               stay in line. I know it's hard in this place. It's an honour to rise in this House and speak to support Bill 16, the Miscellaneous\n               Statutes Amendment Act of 2026. I'd like to thank all of our ministers who brought\n               forward parts of this act, because I have complete faith in my ministers and my government\n               — unlike some people in this House, apparently. At a glance, this bill may not carry the same headline-grabbing weight as some of\n               the more sweeping legislation we debate in this chamber. It does not propose a single,\n               transformative policy shift, nor does it focus on one issue alone. Instead, it does\n               something equally important, something foundational to good governance. It ensures\n               that the laws we've already passed are working in the way they are intended to work. That matters very deeply, because government is not only about introducing new ideas;\n               it's about maintaining, refining and improving the system we already have in place\n               so that we remain fair, efficient and responsible to the people we serve. I believe\n               that is exactly what Bill 16 does. So I will speak a little bit about different parts\n               of this bill and break down what some thoughts are around that. A commitment to transparency and good governance. One of the core principles of responsible\n               governance is transparency. British Columbians expect their laws to be clear, consistent\n               and up to date. Bill 16 reflects that expectation, bringing forward a series of targeted,\n               practical amendments across several statutes. These are not sweeping ideological changes.\n               They are careful, thought-out updates designed to clarify intent, correct inconsistencies\n               and ensure that legislation is implemented as it was meant to be. This is a standard practice in any well-functioning legal system. More importantly,\n               it is commitment to openness, to accountability and to doing the work properly. By\n               bringing these amendments forward publicly, rather than quietly allowing inconsistencies\n               to persist, the government is demonstrating respect for both this House and the people\n               of British Columbia. Strengthening access to justice. Let me begin with the amendments to the Judicial Review Procedure Act. Access to justice is a cornerstone of our democracy. When individuals challenge\n               decisions made by government or administrative bodies, they deserve a process that\n               is fair, timely and affordable. The amendments in this bill move us closer to that goal. They introduce a clear 60-day\n               deadline for filing most judicial reviews. This reduces uncertainty and prevents prolonged\n               legal disputes that can become costly for individuals and institutions alike. They\n               also clarify how sensitive cabinet information is protected during current proceedings. This is about balance. This is about ensuring accountability, while also protecting\n               the integrity of confidential decision-making processes that are essential to effective\n               government. Without these protections, we risk turning judicial reviews into lengthy,\n               trial-like proceedings, driving up costs, increasing delays and ultimately making\n               that system less accessible. With these changes, we are creating a process that is\n               more predictable, more efficient and more accessible for everybody. With some of the comments about transparency and concern about our government, I would\n               like to remind the members of the House that I am not a minister. This doesn't and\n               wouldn't apply to me directly, and I still support our ministers and our Premier with\n               this change.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721642","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Good afternoon, Mr. Speaker. It's nice to see you in the chair, making sure people\n               stay in line. I know it's hard in this place. It's an honour to rise in this House and speak to support Bill 16, the Miscellaneous\n               Statutes Amendment Act of 2026. I'd like to thank all of our ministers who brought\n               forward parts of this act, because I have complete faith i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["baf1bb8e0d274e0028808f3b6a487eb06c0b61434d38d5b97c71e6466de86900"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94d764174ce5f6147f2fdb8928b6d0b7cad763dc260efa27c21cc1bd84cb0f0b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c8cb5da7798b5b463951349","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721645,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize an important milestone in my community, the 70th anniversary\n               of our West Shore Chamber of Commerce. In my riding of Esquimalt-Colwood, I am privileged to have three chambers, but this one is extra special this year,\n               and I am also a proud member of it. For seven decades, the chamber has been a cornerstone of economic growth in our West\n               Shore. It has brought to there local business, supported entrepreneurs, and helped\n               shape a vibrant, resilient, regional economy that reflects the energy and ambition\n               of the people of our western communities and beyond. From small family-run shops to\n               growing industries, the chamber has been a steady partner advocating, connecting and\n               championing local business. That work matters more now than ever. Our governments works with strategies about building on that foundation. It recognizes\n               that B.C.'s future depends on strong, connected regional economies, especially here\n               on south Vancouver Island. By improving infrastructure, supporting trade, investing in workforce development,\n               and strengthening local supply chains, we are creating the condition for businesses\n               to grow and communities to thrive. We know that success doesn't happen in isolation.\n               It happens through partnership between government, business leaders and organizations\n               like the West Shore Chamber of Commerce. Together we are helping local businesses\n               reach new markets, attract investment and good paying jobs right here at home and\n               right here in our western communities. We're ensuring that the West Shore continues to be not just a great place to live,\n               but a great place to build a business and a future. On behalf of this House, I want\n               to extend my sincerest congratulations to our West Shore Chamber of Commerce for 70\n               years of outstanding service. Here's the next 70 years of growth, collaboration and\n               success, and I look forward to next month celebrating it with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721645","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize an important milestone in my community, the 70th anniversary\n               of our West Shore Chamber of Commerce. In my riding of Esquimalt-Colwood, I am privileged to have three chambers, but this one is extra special this year,\n               and I am also a proud member of it. For seven decades, the chamber has been a cornerstone of economic growth in our West\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2afe282da2689aaafcb4d12e0c5b1cfb6556b8c9260956dac07320524353bd27"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24dcebac06c044dd639e08c917dc93807d73087b5ee6864060ed5e2b8aa4e98d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d771ceadd8d9974549234f74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729413,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Good morning, Madam Speaker and everyone in this House. It's a lovely Monday. God,\n               I hate Mondays. I know, right? I rise to speak in support of your motion, but I want to begin by generally commending\n               the member opposite for bringing it forward, because it takes a certain level of self-awareness,\n               actually, to recognize when there may be gaps in understanding. Especially when it\n               comes to something as fundamental as economics, public finance and numeracy. I want to acknowledge that this motion is a constructive step, because when we are\n               entrusted with making decisions about taxes, spending, debt regulation, we actually\n               owe it to British Columbians to understand numbers behind those decisions. That's\n               not optional; it's actually foundational. Unfortunately, time and again, we've seen the opposition make those suggestions, in\n               fact, that some work needs to be done in that area. So yes, I support that motion.\n               I support it enthusiastically, actually, because it may address some of the inconsistency\n               we've been hearing from opposite members in this House. For example, we regularly hear calls to significantly reduce government spending at\n               a time when we also hear them advocate for increased investment in certain priorities.\n               You know, let's pick on health care for an example. Madam Speaker, that doesn't add\n               up. It's not a matter of political perspective; it is just basic math. If you're going\n               to cut spending dramatically while maintaining or increasing services, those numbers\n               have to be balanced. An exact comment was made. Everything is a trade-off. What was\n               said is a trade-off. So either you reduce services, or you increase costs, or both. There's no version of public finance where the equation resolves itself without consequences.\n               There is no magic accounting that just makes it work. Yet members opposite continue\n               to suggest otherwise. They criticize our government about spending. They don't explain\n               how their own plans would even pay for it. I can tell you as a health care worker\n               exactly how they would pay for it: on the backs of those workers. Which is why I say again this motion is a good idea, because maybe after taking a\n               course in public finance, we'll finally hear an answer on how they plan to support\n               the health care system that they plan on cutting in half, which a member from their\n               own side of the House made as comments to our government. The member for Fraser-Nicola said it clearly. If health care and education are the largest areas of spending,\n               then they're the ones that would have to take the brunt of cuts. Well, I would like\n               to hear your plan. As a health care worker, I can tell you how it worked out. It wasn't\n               great. It's why we're in the mess we're in now. I worked under two Liberal governments, and it was shameful how our health care system....\n               And it would roll back. It highlights exactly why financial literacy matters, because\n               once you understand the basics, it becomes clear that choices have consequences, and\n               that's something that British Columbians deserve to hear plainly. On this side of the House, we understand that. We know that managing the deficit is\n               important. That's why we take responsible steps to do that over time but also by protecting\n               the services we rely on. I don't get up here lightly and say that. I say that as a\n               mother of two who wants to look at what I'm going to be leaving my children long after\n               I'm gone and my grandchildren and, hopefully, great-grandchildren down the road. The Conservatives have it very clear. They want to cut deeper and they want to cut\n               faster. That would come at a cost. That is not speculation. Again, that is just math.\n               We don't have to take a look far to see what that would mean in practice. Because\n               many of the individuals shaping the current B.C. Conservative approach are the same\n               as some of those former B.C. Liberals and staffers and people who were in government\n               when I worked in health care. Again, I think it's important that if we're talking about financial literacy, we need\n               to learn from experience. They're going to show exactly how those numbers are balanced.\n               They would double our MSP premium, costing families $1,800 a year. They would cut\n               hundreds of millions of health care again by contracting out, and God knows what else\n               they'd come up with. They took $1.2 billion from ICBC so rates'll increase for drivers. They would put the tolls\n               back on the major bridges, costing a family up to $1,500 annually just to get to work. They sold off land intended for a secondary hospital, and they chose not to build\n               critical infrastructure like a medical school. Shocker, short doctors. That is why\n               our government built one. We're going to bring more doctors, and that's what we're\n               doing. These are the outcomes of their budgeting approach, and they understand why understanding\n               public finance is just theoretical. It really impacts on the lives of British Columbians.\n               I could go on. I have 57 minutes. We are investing in health care, connecting more\n               people with family doctors. We are hiring teachers, supporting students in classrooms.\n               We are building infrastructure and strengthening communities, and we are doing so\n               while managing our finances responsibly. Yes, there is an effort. We are managing\n               it, and we are looking forward. Finance and literacy is not just about numbers; it is about honesty, so being upfront\n               with people about what your plan is. We have a plan, and we have been honest with\n               what that looks like. And we are ensuring those decisions are grounded in reality,\n               not just wishful thinking. Again, I commend the member opposite for bringing this motion forward. It is a step\n               in the right direction. I could also add a whole list of other courses we should be,\n               especially if people have opinions about health care and how they are going to manage\n               it. Happy to chat with them in the House while we can look at that. I sincerely hope that all members of this House, especially those who have demonstrated\n               the greatest need, take full advantage of the opportunity it presents, because So again, I commend the member opposite for bringing this motion forward. It is a\n               step in the right direction. I could also add a whole list of other courses we should be recommending, especially if people have opinions about health care and how they're going to manage it.... Happy to chat with them in the House while we\n               can look at that. And I sincerely hope that all members of this House, especially those who have demonstrated\n               the greatest need, take full advantage of the opportunity it presents, because again,\n               if we're going to support British Columbians, we need to do it in a way that we all\n               financially understand how that works. But again, I could add other courses: HR; ethics, for one; truth and reconciliation,\n               what that looks like; and my list could go on, because again, we all should be informed\n               when we come in this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729413","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Good morning, Madam Speaker and everyone in this House. It's a lovely Monday. God,\n               I hate Mondays. I know, right? I rise to speak in support of your motion, but I want to begin by generally commending\n               the member opposite for bringing it forward, because it takes a certain level of self-awareness,\n               actually, to recognize when there may be gaps in understa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2dc72f91bc0c7d4622104b7f3bb640d7b4084de4bef9d75365c1367bde55466a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a687fa713c70d399fe1124b4fefa07f13002f1a0e60e98094e3bde3c134172de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9dd359f290007313e1cc34c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729416,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize two significant observances this week, May Day and the\n               National Day of Mourning. May Day is a time to celebrate workers, the people whose skill, dedication and resilience\n               keep our communities running. In Esquimalt-Colwood, we see that every day, in our shipyard workers, in our health care teams, our tradespeople\n               and our service workers. Their contributions shape not only our local economy but\n               the strength and character of our province. But as we recognize these workers, we must also be reminded that we have lost some.\n               National Day of Mourning is a solemn reminder of lives that have lost, the injuries\n               sustained and the families forever changed by workplace incidents. It calls on all\n               of us to reflect on our responsibility to ensure that every worker returns home safely. This year's Day of Mourning theme is \"Psychological health and safety is occupational\n               health and safety.\" To truly protect workers from all workplace hazards, we must treat\n               psychological health with the same seriousness as physical health in our laws and\n               in our compensation system. We must continue to take meaningful steps to prevent occupational\n               psychological injuries through enforceable protections. These are not abstract ideas. They are practical steps that will save lives, reduce\n               harm and support a healthier workplace here across British Columbia. As we mark these two observances, let us recommit not only to recognizing the contribution\n               of these workers but to protecting their full well-being, physical and psychological\n               alike. It is why I got involved in this work myself, as a health care worker in mental\n               health and addiction. I saw firsthand what can happen if we don't support these people.\n               I saw good workers relapse because of their psychological injury, and I saw amazing\n               employers support them. But we need to make sure we continue to do our part, because\n               honouring workers means ensuring their safety in every sense of the word. Tomorrow I hope everyone in this House will join me, and everyone on south Vancouver\n               Island will join us, on the front lawn of the Legislature at 12 o'clock to ensure\n               that we honour those who have passed and the families who have lost those loved ones,\n               as well as to recommit to ensuring that all workers across this province are safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729416","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize two significant observances this week, May Day and the\n               National Day of Mourning. May Day is a time to celebrate workers, the people whose skill, dedication and resilience\n               keep our communities running. In Esquimalt-Colwood, we see that every day, in our shipyard workers, in our health care teams, our tradespeople\n               and our service","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4c5c018ac29bc992359a5f2eeca4128da194be41e391dcfc1d29fd601614a957"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["daf960966ac455c35e2725810b4c4c1f145409801917f68bf3524ff67d93a358"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f732f196c177d9ee9107dfe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729418,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would be remiss to not also recognize Orion Irvine with the CLC in this House. I\n               know how much he hates these things, so it gives me extra joy. During my time at the Victoria Labour Council, Orion was assigned to it, and I can\n               truly say part of my journey was having Orion, which is why I stand here today for\n               all of his tireless advocacy for Victoria Labour Council in supporting us group of\n               misfits, as I would joke. But all kidding aside, during COVID, I could not have done\n               it without him. So I just wanted to actually thank him on the record so he now can\n               picket me later. So again, can the House make him feel extra welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729418","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would be remiss to not also recognize Orion Irvine with the CLC in this House. I\n               know how much he hates these things, so it gives me extra joy. During my time at the Victoria Labour Council, Orion was assigned to it, and I can\n               truly say part of my journey was having Orion, which is why I stand here today for\n               all of his tireless advocacy for Victoria L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Coronavirus diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034682","label":"Coronavirus diseases","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1feb177b7c8d27256a66ff085be091ccca5b0855408c841496e588917269333c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41f1de840e40e315254afa51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752325,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we mark a day that everyone in this House has talked about and that I think\n               we can all support. Today marks International Firefighters Day. I want to begin by recognizing the service of British Columbian firefighters right\n               across our province. These are individuals who run towards danger when others must\n               run from it. Every day they put their lives on the line to protect our communities.\n               They save lives, safeguard property and do so at a great personal risk to their own\n               health and safety. They deserve our unwavering support, our deepest respect and our\n               sincere gratitude — quite frankly, not just today but every day. The work firefighters do is inherently dangerous and can have lasting impacts on both\n               physical and mental well-being. While most of us seek safety in times of crisis, these\n               brave men and women move directly into harm's way, driven by a singular purpose: to\n               keep us all safe. At times, their selfless service comes at an ultimate cost. That is why we must do everything in our power to support them, not only for their\n               sake but for their families' sakes and our communities' sakes. That's why in 2017,\n               important steps were taken to better support firefighters by examining presumptive\n               coverage under our Workers Compensation Act.At that time, a limited number of illnesses\n               were covered. Heart injuries, diseases, along with ten types of cancers, were recognized. For those who may not be familiar, presumptive coverage means that when a firefighter\n               is diagnosed with one of those conditions, it is assumed to be work-related, unless\n               proven otherwise. Now this ensures that claims are accepted more quickly, allowing\n               them to access the care and support they need through WorkBC without unnecessary delays\n               — something, again, I think we can all agree with. While this is an important start, it is not enough. Thanks to the tireless advocacy\n               of our B.C. Fire Fighters Association, it has become clear that firefighters face\n               elevated risk for so much of a broader range of serious illness. That's why, in 2018, the act was amended again to include PTSD and other mental health\n               conditions as presumptive illnesses, not only for firefighters but for our other first\n               responders. We all can recognize the profound psychological impacts of repetitive\n               exposure to traumatic events for the people who do that work every single day. That's\n               why we made further changes in 2019 to expand those protections to include wild fire\n               fighters, fire investigators and those serving First Nations and our Indigenous communities. In the years that followed, additional cancers were added to this presumptive list\n               — again, something I think we all know needs to continue to be done. Today British\n               Columbia recognizes 18 types of cancers, along with heart injuries and diseases, as\n               conditions that firefighters face at increased risk of development. We are leading here in British Columbia for our firefighters. I think we should all\n               be proud of that — both sides of the House. It's great. As of March 16, 2026, we've now also, all of us, added eight additional cancers that\n               have been officially recognized as presumptive diseases linked to firefighting — another\n               meaningful step forward, ensuring firefighters receive the support they deserve. While we've made significant progress, our work is not done. We all can remain committed\n               to working in partnership with our B.C. Professional Fire Fighters Association, our\n               local firefighter locals, our federal firefighters, our forestry and our First Nation\n               firefighters to build a compensation system that is effective, responsive and centred\n               on workers, one that fully supports firefighters and all of our emergency responders\n               here in British Columbia. We need to ensure we continue to look for opportunities that strengthen protections,\n               improve outcomes, ensure the health and well-being of those who dedicate their lives\n               to protecting us. With my last minute, I would like to just take a moment to thank my local firefighters:\n               IFF Local 730 here in Victoria, Local 4264 in Esquimalt, Local 5419 in View Royal,\n               our firefighters at CFB Esquimalt and our Local 5420 in Colwood. You keep our communities safe. You keep my family safe. You do so at great personal\n               risk. You spend time away from your family. You miss holidays. You miss milestones.\n               You still give back for charity work, even when you're off duty. You are nothing short\n               of a class act. So thank you. Thank you for everything you do to keep us safe. Thank you for everything\n               you do to give back to your community, and thank you. Today on International Firefighters\n               Day and every day, we would like to thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752325","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today we mark a day that everyone in this House has talked about and that I think\n               we can all support. Today marks International Firefighters Day. I want to begin by recognizing the service of British Columbian firefighters right\n               across our province. These are individuals who run towards danger when others must\n               run from it. Every day they put their lives","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c568867edd8c398e13abb76f1159ba7995bfeed8f7ecd55f379a97312e90f72"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27c8e6bea285adc0a5d2fe977e363ed20450fb9ca6da78f98cd18b768782e8c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d74fac2bdbaefb43821dc3a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752326,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"As the weather grows warmer and more British Columbians spend time exploring the natural\n               beauty our province has to offer, it's an important time to recognize Emergency Preparedness\n               Week right here in B.C. This year's theme is \"In it together,\" which highlights a simple but powerful truth.\n               Emergency preparedness is a shared responsibility. When neighbours know one another,\n               when communities stay connected and when we look out for one It's an important time to recognize Emergency Preparedness Week right here in B.C.\n               This year's theme is \"In it together.\" It highlights a simple but powerful truth:\n               emergency preparedness is a shared responsibility. When neighbours know one another,\n               when communities stay connected and when we look out for one another when we need\n               additional support, we strengthen our collective ability to respond effectively in\n               times of crisis. Preparedness also begins here at home, understanding the risks in our communities,\n               developing an emergency plan and ensuring our households have both an emergency kit\n               and a grab-and-go bag, which are essential steps. These practical measures help families\n               remain calm, organized and resilient when the unexpected occurs. Sharing knowledge with others further strengthens the readiness of our communities\n               — and, more importantly, making sure we're all familiar with resources such as PreparedBC\n               that offer valuable guidance for those to get started. It is also strengthening emergency services, from wildfires to floods and severe weather\n               events. In those moments, some of our Canadian Armed Forces and our reservists, who\n               also have to be our public servants in some cases, play a very critical role in supporting\n               operations. Whether it's assisting with evacuations here in B.C. if needed, delivering\n               essential supplies or helping communities recover, the Canadian Armed Forces are a\n               trusted, capable partner in emergency responsiveness right across our province. I'm particularly proud in my community of Esquimalt-Colwood that we have the regional joint operations centre, located right in my backyard,\n               serving as a hub for coordinating military support to domestic operations in British\n               Columbia. The work carried out there ensures that assistance can be deployed quickly\n               and effectively when it is needed most, reinforcing that strong partnership between\n               our communities and those who serve. Emergency preparedness is an opportunity for us all to reflect on our readiness and\n               take meaningful steps to be better prepared. By working together, staying informed\n               and supporting one another, we will build a safer, more resilient community right\n               here across our province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752326","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As the weather grows warmer and more British Columbians spend time exploring the natural\n               beauty our province has to offer, it's an important time to recognize Emergency Preparedness\n               Week right here in B.C. This year's theme is \"In it together,\" which highlights a simple but powerful truth.\n               Emergency preparedness is a shared responsibility. When neighbou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e91d156c4abc9ba4dbd548e022e9166f6cfbf3e104bfcf05cfa544c1d1b4882c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fcb0e033106de4187420d4de74401a8ae84ce9a229442c0b0839ecbf6ad44973"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6606c73803f96a84763d9abc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752327,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"This afternoon I will have Rear-Adm David Patchell from MARPAC and his wife Christian Patchell joining me in the House to talk about how we can continue to support military families\n               in the province. B.C. is actually leading the charge in Seamless Canada and everything we are doing\n               for military families, so I'm super excited to welcome them. Could everyone in the House make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752327","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This afternoon I will have Rear-Adm David Patchell from MARPAC and his wife Christian Patchell joining me in the House to talk about how we can continue to support military families\n               in the province. B.C. is actually leading the charge in Seamless Canada and everything we are doing\n               for military families, so I'm super excited to welcome them. Could everyone in the House","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06350eda6fe9822c85df70eb706e6d01a6dadeede115624fc04f3ae72545159e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02148e89cfd6fdbb335d6c03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752328,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Jobs and Economic Growth and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752328","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Jobs and Economic Growth and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f1ecb0253eed80d9c6ebb91eb48b4a2893759e481b8cabbe30e566a3b1f8d1c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80fc9f013a9a18aaf91da585","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017548,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the Legislature I will be having two schools visiting. First I would like\n               to welcome Vic West Elementary School. There will be 26 grade 5 students. As well, we'll have the pleasure of also having Wishart Elementary joining us, which\n               will have 28 grade 5 students and their teachers. I hope the House will make them\n               feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017548","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the Legislature I will be having two schools visiting. First I would like\n               to welcome Vic West Elementary School. There will be 26 grade 5 students. As well, we'll have the pleasure of also having Wishart Elementary joining us, which\n               will have 28 grade 5 students and their teachers. I hope the House will make them\n               feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["30096c73e6907a05e0838b246511cf629534e65f82ee972f93a95b315aa25eca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40258b60a09b97bddaf2819f3dcc7c6e91b50c5cca2eb2aeb42c93a00727c141"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-036606fc55db81c7327f132c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017560,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Bear with me. I have four introductions to make in the House today. First and foremost, I would like to welcome Valerie Chamberlain, the intern lobby\n               coordinator for south Island for BCNU, and I would like to welcome Caitlin Jarvis,\n               the regional council member for BCNU. I had the privilege of spending a day at Victoria\n               General Hospital last week celebrating our nurses on south Vancouver Island. Can everyone give them a warm welcome and welcome to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017560","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Bear with me. I have four introductions to make in the House today. First and foremost, I would like to welcome Valerie Chamberlain, the intern lobby\n               coordinator for south Island for BCNU, and I would like to welcome Caitlin Jarvis,\n               the regional council member for BCNU. I had the privilege of spending a day at Victoria\n               General Hospital last week celebra","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f629632e35aae49b857b045651b348ee230ec31cc494018e1efec49c8bb2296"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d97790738d35572617c18adc8ea28e225c68593ad3fa34bdb11e5f22da90eabc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-863c11e712a75932565f7a38","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036566,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions to make this morning. First, over the weekend in CFB Esquimalt,\n               in my riding of Esquimalt-Colwood, we have the Korean Navy arrive for two weeks of exercises and visits to the south\n               Vancouver Island. I hope the House can make them feel very welcome. Some of them, you may see as well,\n               are touring the Legislature today. So yeah, make them feel welcome. And No. 2, and very important, it is my father-in-law's birthday. Many people in this\n               House hear me talk about my in-laws. I know not everyone's relationship with their\n               in-laws is always the same, but I'm very grateful for Joe Rotchford, to wish him a\n               happy 76th birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036566","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two introductions to make this morning. First, over the weekend in CFB Esquimalt,\n               in my riding of Esquimalt-Colwood, we have the Korean Navy arrive for two weeks of exercises and visits to the south\n               Vancouver Island. I hope the House can make them feel very welcome. Some of them, you may see as well,\n               are touring the Legislature today. So yeah, ma","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","label":"Allied forces"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine installations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","label":"Marine installations","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","label":"Military training","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","label":"Allied forces","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc11c66fa9fbc8abf64737c835edf950f86e0ab74d306fd4f0e02614183de6a4","adfa2b506a53df1a73fbbcb35f1aae7359619a9f3bbab6497777e9170de9eb1d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0322abaeadab3ad0d79a15d5b1076cdf014aae1717cb82f93a184bbbc62c82a1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Military training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44826","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14f15df0e934f9b7ffa94e43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036567,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know Mayor Alto has been recognized, the mayor of Victoria, but I would like to\n               just recognize her for her work for women in politics. Every year she makes sure she's bringing women together on the south Vancouver Island,\n               party aside, party politics aside, to ensure we're electing more women in politics. I've known Mayor Alto before she was a mayor, during my time in Victoria Labour Council\n               and it has been an honour watching her supporting other women across the south Vancouver\n               Island. I think we can all do that in this House a lot more and all levels of government. Again, I'd just like the House to make her feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036567","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I know Mayor Alto has been recognized, the mayor of Victoria, but I would like to\n               just recognize her for her work for women in politics. Every year she makes sure she's bringing women together on the south Vancouver Island,\n               party aside, party politics aside, to ensure we're electing more women in politics. I've known Mayor Alto before she was a mayor, during my time i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0c7a8840a7c609657446d147a46e6ae4a6a8367f4e7f32929a6ebd3b1b5f2db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a11e35a5f2f026e78939aa1bdeab017fbaa1736972d4a2a2db50de93b437d4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-77523da5371093217dfb4009","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036568,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"My sister is watching us because she has nothing better to do with her time, apparently,\n               most days. But the reason that today is extra special is, for anyone on both sides\n               of the House who have had health things, my sister turns 50 today. The reason it's a really important birthday is not just because it's a milestone,\n               but she had a core belief she would not make it to 50 because my mother died at 50\n               with a heart attack. So today for her is not only her 50th birthday. Today proves\n               to her that it's all about bettering your mindset. So Chassidy, happy 50th birthday. I wouldn't be here in this building without you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036568","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My sister is watching us because she has nothing better to do with her time, apparently,\n               most days. But the reason that today is extra special is, for anyone on both sides\n               of the House who have had health things, my sister turns 50 today. The reason it's a really important birthday is not just because it's a milestone,\n               but she had a core belief she woul","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8b9923879d11ed457232274d609b6d0a9d7ae9afaf942cc58fd878e3ef3cd8f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f13105dce3aa1cf1c301a46169f9da8232f7db6253087676b33351be6a2c5cc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee327fd4d9147aaf7f77399c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036569,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Darlene Rotchford","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's kind of fitting, at the last day of session, we all get kind of chirpy with each\n               other, but there are some shared things within this House and I have the privilege\n               of sharing the birthday of someone on the opposition side tomorrow. So I would actually like to wish the member from Richmond-Bridgeport tomorrow a very happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036569","member_id":"bc-mla-370","member_name":"Darlene Rotchford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's kind of fitting, at the last day of session, we all get kind of chirpy with each\n               other, but there are some shared things within this House and I have the privilege\n               of sharing the birthday of someone on the opposition side tomorrow. So I would actually like to wish the member from Richmond-Bridgeport tomorrow a very happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b4e257ce76c18cae31a647d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317165,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to take this opportunity to introduce a couple of visitors to the Legislature\n               this morning. Cooper Meyer and Carson Wengert are visiting from the United States\n               and are excited to be here to witness our system of governance in British Columbia.\n               They are accompanied by our good friend Colin Chia. If you could please join me in giving them a warm welcome, that would be appreciated.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317165","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I would like to take this opportunity to introduce a couple of visitors to the Legislature\n               this morning. Cooper Meyer and Carson Wengert are visiting from the United States\n               and are excited to be here to witness our system of governance in British Columbia.\n               They are accompanied by our good friend Colin Chia. If you could please join me in giving them a w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce35e354cefe1ea977f5e0416196d25234dbd860ef1072e4865a055cc0810c8a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d52d7b4bb6eca4512d135111","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317166,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize the district of Lillooet, a historic, resilient and truly\n               remarkable rural community in British Columbia. Nestled along the Fraser River, surrounded by rugged mountains and wide-open skies,\n               Lillooet is as beautiful as it is remote. Known as Mile Zero of the Cariboo gold rush\n               and home to the proud and deeply rooted First Nations in the area, it is a community\n               built on strength, history and neighbours who stand shoulder to shoulder in time of\n               need. This is a tight-knit community in every sense of the word, but remoteness brings challenges. Lillooet is approximately 21⁄2 hours from the nearest tertiary hospital. When emergency\n               services close, there is no nearby alternative, only distance, winding highways. The\n               reality is that in an emergency, every minute matters. Over the past year, the community has endured multiple emergency department closures.\n               In any town, that would be difficult. In a rural community, this isolation is deeply\n               concerning. Families were left uncertain in moments of crisis. First responders carried\n               heavier burdens. Anxiety across the region was very real. Yet, through it all, Mayor Laurie Hopfl and council remained steady. They did not inflame tension. They did not give\n               up. They were respectful and persistently alongside Interior Health, physicians, provincial\n               representatives, neighbouring communities and First Nation partners to find practical\n               solutions to stabilize emergency services. Their leadership reflects what makes rural\n               British Columbia strong, resilient, and collaborative and determined in their need\n               for strength at this time. Today, I ask the House to recognize Mayor Laurie Hopfl and the council of Lillooet for their steadfast advocacy and their unwavering\n               commitment to protecting the health and safety of their residents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317166","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize the district of Lillooet, a historic, resilient and truly\n               remarkable rural community in British Columbia. Nestled along the Fraser River, surrounded by rugged mountains and wide-open skies,\n               Lillooet is as beautiful as it is remote. Known as Mile Zero of the Cariboo gold rush\n               and home to the proud and deeply rooted First Nations","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c417c77807b4b711a17b6c7bf41ef41c874517bcc839b8e9b208be44f41bc5f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c1d51d4032b3f178ae3a1ec2016b92e05134da6934b4157f47e3229a6ca8676"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ad1104b299f9de19575cca3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327999,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I was pleased to welcome the grades 6 and 7 French immersion students from Ecole\n               Collettville Elementary School from Merritt. This is a school that my wife recently\n               graduated, and she had a great time teaching there. They were accompanied by their teacher, Jory Berthelet; their principal, Brandon Sambrook;\n               and parent helper Toby Lepke. They toured the Legislature and said meeting Mr. Baldrey\n               was one of the highlights of the tour today. Anyway, unfortunately, they are headed back to Merritt, and they are not going to\n               be able to sit with us today. Would you please join me in offering them a safe trip\n               home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327999","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I was pleased to welcome the grades 6 and 7 French immersion students from Ecole\n               Collettville Elementary School from Merritt. This is a school that my wife recently\n               graduated, and she had a great time teaching there. They were accompanied by their teacher, Jory Berthelet; their principal, Brandon Sambrook;\n               and parent helper Toby Lepke. They toured","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f41390d0e44b513c955f8297d812cb731e9bb67f30b5b9ccf96334c650dd15a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a58bc9151ebb75ed33964ec91b9cd3c54a671c0d3794ec410cf848d190f42a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-205f97e59fb8bdd8570d7472","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328000,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real pleasure to be here today and speak a little bit about the budget here. I'd like to thank my previous colleague for some of the comments he made. I'd rather\n               be standing up here and talking about elk all day long rather than doing what I'm\n               doing here, but that's okay. And I'm recognizing some of the challenges he has with\n               his farmers in that area as well, and of course directly related to some of the budget\n               changes that are coming down the pipe. What I'd like to speak to is mostly about the gutting and the elimination of the Merit Commissioner, in my comments this afternoon. Because I think that's an integral piece and it kind\n               of sets the tone for a lot of the things this government has been doing and what's\n               happening moving forward. Out of this big document, the budget, they sneak in these little things like this\n               that are eliminating hugely important I don't care if it's this government, when we become government or whatever it is.\n               It's really important for the people in British Columbia to know that the things happening\n               in government are being well looked after and there's a proper oversight in place. Today I would like to speak to that budget. I stand today, and to be very, very clear\n               about this, strongly against Bill 2, just as I was about the budget. I'm strongly\n               against the budget, and I am strongly against this bill, too, here. In Bill 2, it appears that.... A lot of the things within this budget are being sold\n               as minor budget measures, a small inefficiency, so tucked into the Budget Measures\n               Implementation Act. But what it really represents is something much, much larger on\n               the bigger stage here and much more dangerous, I think, in the long run. That's another\n               deliberate step in the steady erosion of openness, accountability and independent\n               oversight in British Columbia. There is a track record of this happening with this government. It is the quiet, creeping\n               dismantling of the guardrails that protect every British Columbian and protect the\n               public interest. When a government removes independent oversight, it doesn't just\n               save money. It removes friction, it removes scrutiny, and it removes consequences.\n               That is precisely why independent oversight exists in the first place. Why does the Office of the Merit Commissioner matter? Well, it exists for a simple\n               reason — to ensure that hiring in the public sector services is based on merit, on\n               competence and qualifications, not political connections, internal favouritism or,\n               especially, patronage. In plain language, it is a watchdog that helps ensure public\n               service jobs go to the most qualified applicants, not the best connected. This is not theoretical at all. It happens all the time in other jurisdictions. We\n               certainly don't want it creeping into the public service here within British Columbia. The Merit Commissioner has audited thousands of appointments, reviewed fairness complaints\n               and, in some cases, helped reverse flawed hiring practices. This office is not red\n               tape. It is a public guarantee that people who run government programs, manage permits, oversee public safety, administer grants, procure contracts and deliver\n               front-line services are hired through a process that can be independently verified.\n               That is what trust looks like in a democracy, not blind faith in government but transparent\n               systems with independent verification. Bill 2 dissolves the independent Office of the Merit Commissioner and shifts its function\n               into government itself, specifically to the B.C. Public Service Agency and the Minister\n               of Finance, through transitional controls of assets, liabilities and records. This\n               bill explicitly dissolves the office and transfers responsibility and records to the\n               Minister of Finance. This is the essence of the problem. The watchdog is being put on the government payroll.\n               The Public Service Agency will be both the operator of the hiring system and the overseer\n               of these systems. That is not independent oversight by the last time I checked. That\n               is self-policing. That is exactly what critics warned about the moment this became\n               public. Now, don't take our word for it on this side of the bench, because they're always\n               pointing fingers at us and everything. Here, let me give you a couple of quotes here.\n               As BCGEU president Paul Finch put it: \"They're overseeing themselves. It effectively\n               eliminates the audit function.\" The union also made clear that they were not consulted\n               and oppose the move because independent oversight is the point, not the paperwork. When the watchdog becomes the guard or the fox starts guarding the henhouse, the public\n               loses its independent The government likes to frame decisions like this as a drive for efficiency. So let\n               me talk a little bit about that. They say cutting oversights may govern leaner and\n               more effective. But British Columbians should ask themselves: \"What exactly does this\n               government mean by inefficient?\" This government, maybe not our side of the House\n               but this government — because if we look at the government's actual record of delivering\n               major projects, the definition becomes hard to understand. Time and again, we see projects that are years behind schedule and billions over budget,\n               from major infrastructure to housing programs, while the government lectures everyone\n               else about efficiency. The irony is striking. They are prepared to eliminate an independent\n               oversight office that costs a fraction of 1 percent of the provincial budget yet preside\n               over projects where costs spiral and timelines collapse. Cutting the watchdog that protects transparency is not efficiency. It is convenience.\n               Real efficiency means competent management, honest reporting and independent scrutiny.\n               What this government calls efficiency too often looks like removing the people who\n               ask difficult questions while continuing to deliver projects late, over budget and\n               with far less accountability than taxpayers really deserve. Hon. Speaker, $1.7 million is not a cost problem in the context of a provincial budget.\n               It's minuscule. But more importantly, what is the cost of losing independent oversight?\n               Well, the Merit Commissioner himself answered that directly, warning that the cost\n               of losing independent oversight may ultimately far exceed the savings from eliminating\n               a small oversight body. If I was a betting man, I'd probably take that wager. That's not partisan rhetoric. That is the independent officer whose job is being eliminated,\n               stating plainly why any governance expert already knows oversight is cheaper than\n               scandal. Oversight is cheaper than patronage, and oversight is cheaper than flawed\n               competitions, wrongful dismissals, grievances, payouts and the institutional rot that\n               follows when fairness becomes optional. It's worth noting that the office was not struggling for legitimacy. A non-partisan,\n               multi-party committee of the Legislature approved a three-year budget for the office\n               to continue its oversight work recently and expressed appreciation for its commitment\n               to merit-based practices. So the legislators' own oversight committee recognized the\n               value of this position. Yet government, for some reason, moves to eliminate it anyway?\n               Something's not adding up. This should alarm every member of this House, every citizen\n               in British Columbia. Why now? Why is this happening now? The Merit Commissioner's service plan reported\n               that since 2022-23 there has been an increase in the merit-not-applied findings and\n               a decrease in merit findings. In the audited results of 2023-24, merit not applied\n               reached 10 percent, the highest rate since 2016-2017. That means, in a growing share\n               of reviewed competitions, the office found that the merit principle was not properly\n               applied. Now, I'll ask the obvious question. If the trend line is moving in the wrong direction,\n               why would you eliminate the independent office that detects and reports the problem?\n               That is not efficiency, and I think I explained the efficiency problem previously.\n               That is simply evasion. The Merit Commissioner's most recent audit work also underscored the point, describing\n               the highest rate of flawed hiring process and outcomes in nearly a decade. Just as\n               independent oversight is flagging more issues, the government moves to shut the oversight\n               down. When I was a kid, I'd go: \"Hmm.\" That is the opposite of reform. This is shutting\n               off the alarm because the fire is inconvenient. Bill 2 goes even further. It doesn't just dissolve an independent office. It amends\n               FOIPPA to exclude records created by or for the Merit Commissioner from freedom-of-information\n               requests. It's kind of like putting cement shoes Bill 2 goes even further. It doesn't just dissolve an independent office. It amends\n               FOIPPA to exclude records created by or for the Merit Commissioner from freedom-of-information\n               requests. It's kind of like putting cement shoes on something and throwing it in the\n               ocean. It disappears. Let's be clear about what that means. Government is not only moving oversight inside\n               government; it is also creating a new barrier to public access for the historical\n               records of the independent oversight. That should disturb anybody who believes in\n               openness and fairness with government, because the public can no longer rely on FOI\n               as a backstop to understand how hiring oversight was carried out, what patterns were\n               found or what systematic issues may have been documented. It's not a minor technical change. The bill explicitly adds this exemption to FOIPPA.\n               So the direction of travel is unmistakable. Less independence, less disclosure, more\n               internal controls and more secrecy. Bill 2's commencement provision shows that sections 8 to 10 and 13 to 27, which include\n               the FOIPPA changes and the Public Service Act changes affecting the Merit Commissioner,\n               come into force by regulation of the Lieutenant Governor in Council. Have we heard\n               that before? That matters because it reinforces the pattern this government keeps returning to\n               — big power shifts, brought into force later by cabinet regulations, away from the\n               moment of legislative attention, away from full public scrutiny and, often, away from\n               meaningful accountability. That means, folks, we're becoming irrelevant in the process. We have no oversight\n               in this House, and it's slowly slipping away from us. Is that how you build trust?\n               I think this is more like how you avoid it. However, the deeper issue — this is the pattern. The public understands patterns even\n               when government hopes they won't. This government has repeatedly limited transparency\n               and weakened independent scrutiny, and we have seen it in many areas before. Giving a couple of examples. British Columbia introduced, and this government introduced,\n               a $10 application fee for general FOI requests, a fee that government itself described\n               as applying before a request will be processed. A $10 fee for everybody that wants\n               to apply for an FOI for every ministry. Whether you call it cost recovery or a filter,\n               the effect is the same. It deters access, particularly for ordinary citizens, small\n               media outlets, researchers and community watchdogs. In 2022, the B.C. government received a Code of Silence Award, connected to widely\n               criticized changes to access-to-information rules. These awards exist to highlight\n               governments that distinguish themselves by denying public access to government, to\n               which the public has a right. You don't win this kind of notoriety by accident. You\n               earn it, and you have earned it. We have seen legislation flawed by giving cabinet extraordinary override powers, including\n               concerns raised publicly by UBCM on Bills 15, 44 — we saw that in the last session;\n               we pointed it out time and time again — providing cabinet with powers to override\n               local government processes such as OCPs, zoning and subdivisions. You can debate the\n               merits of any one bill, but the trend is the point. The trend is the point. Move decisions\n               upward, narrowly scrutinizing broader cabinet discussions. And now, with Bill 2, the government approach to merit-based hiring oversight becomes,\n               \"Trust us. We'll oversee ourselves,\" but that is exactly what independent oversight\n               is designed to prevent. I remember a long time ago there was somebody that used to\n               say: \"Trust, but verify.\" We've got rid of the \"verify,\" and we're supposed to just\n               trust. No, ladies and gentlemen, we should be trust, and we should be verifying. This is not just about politics. It's about public administration. Merit-based hiring\n               protects the taxpayers by ensuring competent people manage public funds and programs.\n               It protects the public servants by ensuring promotions and competitions are fair,\n               especially in tight labour markets and hiring freezes. It protects service delivery\n               by ensuring qualifications are real, verified and relevant. Public confidence, by preventing the suspicion or the reality of Public confidence, by preventing the suspicion or the reality of patronage — in today's\n               climate, that matters even more. As Paul Finch noted, in a partial hiring freeze where\n               competition is intense, it is more important than ever that sought-after positions\n               be awarded on merit. This isn't this side of the House talking. Once again, this is\n               their side of the House. These are their folks, on that side of the House, concerned\n               about how their government is acting. Now, governments will always say that the merit principle remains in law, but a principle\n               without enforcement is just a slogan. A rule without an independent checker becomes\n               a rule that can be bent, quietly, until it breaks. That is why merit must be more\n               than words on a page. It requires independent auditing, independent reporting and\n               a credible threat of exposure when the system is abused or neglected. The Merit Commissioner\n               put it plainly; the proposed legislation removes core functions like random audits\n               and dismissal reviews, and it removes the requirement for government to report on\n               these matters for public transparency. While the government remains, the bill strips out the very mechanisms that make merit\n               real. When a government is confident in its processes, it welcomes independent verification:\n               \"Look, we're doing everything right. Come on and have a look, and make sure we're\n               doing everything right.\" That's the sign of good government. That's what makes good\n               government: they're not afraid of having the sunshine or the light shine on them. When a government is proud of the hiring integrity, it does not dissolve the office\n               that verifies it. So we have to be suspicious. What are you hiding? Why are you getting\n               rid of this office? What has gone on? Oh, and you're also locking away the records.\n               So we can't even see what's happened in the past? We can't see what happened yesterday?\n               When a government believes in transparency, it does not add new FOI exemptions for\n               oversight records. So the question becomes unavoidable: what is government afraid that the public will\n               see? I think that's a great question. What are they hiding? If the government truly\n               believes that merit is embedded in culture, as the Finance Minister suggested, then\n               independent oversight would only confirm that and strengthen trust. Instead, they\n               are tearing it apart. Whatever little last vestige of trust that the public has is\n               being torn apart by bills like this. The most dangerous attacks on democracy are not always dramatic; they are incremental.\n               Bit by bit, slowly, slowly, they move towards complete collapse. They're procedural;\n               they're buried in budget bills. They happen by dissolving an independent office, transferring\n               its records to a ministry, removing FOI access to those records, changing reporting\n               lines away from the Legislature into the government, stripping enforcement tools like\n               powers to compel answers and disclosure, and bringing key provisions into force later\n               by cabinet regulations. Each step may be defended as administrative, but put together, they describe a philosophy.\n               This is the creep, the gradual closing in towards a government that can operate with\n               less daylight, fewer independent checks and more internal discretion. Once that culture\n               takes hold, it is very, very difficult to reverse. If the government's true concern is cost, there are definitely constructive options\n               for streamlining and making this more efficient. They could start by modernizing the\n               office. They could streamline audits. They could improve reporting formats. They could\n               even align oversight with current workforce realities. They could reduce duplication by maintaining independence — we might have a few more\n               up our sleeves as well; all they have to do is ask — but do not eliminate independence.\n               Do not make the hiring referee part of one team. Above all, do not weaken FOI access\n               and public transparency at the same time as you centralize control. In closing, British Columbians do not expect perfection from any government, but they\n               do expect honesty. They do expect a fair system. In closing, British Columbians do not expect perfection from any government. But they\n               do expect honesty. They do expect fair systems. They do expect that when government\n               hires, promotes and appoints, it does so based on merit and that someone independent\n               can prove it. When you remove independent oversight, you are not just changing an org chart. You\n               are changing the relationship between citizens and the state. You are asking British\n               Columbians to trade verification for trust, transparency for assurance, and accountability\n               for press releases. Once government starts down the road, once it begins dismantling\n               the watchdogs and narrowing the windows, it really stops on its own. Bill 2 is not an efficiency bill. It is a warning sign to everyone in the province\n               of British Columbia. It is a line in the sand about what kind of province we want\n               to be, moving forward: a province where the public service is protected from patronage\n               through independent oversight or a province where government oversees itself, shields\n               the records and calls that good enough. British Columbians deserve better than self-policing, they deserve better than creeping\n               secrecy, and they deserve a government that strengthens accountability when problems\n               emerge, not one that silences the process and reveals them. That is why this House should reject the elimination of the independent Office of\n               the Merit Commissioner and demand that transparency and merit-based oversight remain\n               where they belong — independent, public and accountable to the Legislature and to\n               the people of British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328000","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's a real pleasure to be here today and speak a little bit about the budget here. I'd like to thank my previous colleague for some of the comments he made. I'd rather\n               be standing up here and talking about elk all day long rather than doing what I'm\n               doing here, but that's okay. And I'm recognizing some of the challenges he has with\n               his farmers in that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07d1bb7c5d04cb0dca1616b676451ea18000c836ab8342f510d61e07d78e7390"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9558841ff89b4b08c6b9a886b7b0b68bbc0e466da06098453fa3294469c838fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f0d45ffe1459465be935cbf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360402,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real pleasure to be here this morning to talk to this absolutely critical motion\n               that's been placed on the form by a member of the opposition here. I really thank\n               her for doing that because in my area, as in my colleague's to my right here.... It's\n               fundamentally important to our area because we're a large agricultural","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360402","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's a real pleasure to be here this morning to talk to this absolutely critical motion\n               that's been placed on the form by a member of the opposition here. I really thank\n               her for doing that because in my area, as in my colleague's to my right here.... It's\n               fundamentally important to our area because we're a large agricultural","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037333","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Terrestrial ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037333","label":"Terrestrial ecosystems","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","label":"Water conservation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f063b57196ad45c79a891cc113436fa083f0bf05dd657f1dc817f78c96c01e33"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4844d18a756f781ba1ce7776","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360403,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a pleasure when you can introduce a group of young people here that are\n               interested in politics and listening. As you know, last week I had grades 6 and 7\n               French immersion students here from Collettville in Merrit. They're actually tuned\n               in today watching the procedures because they were unable to stay late last week. So please welcome them again to watch us, and let's try to behave today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360403","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's always a pleasure when you can introduce a group of young people here that are\n               interested in politics and listening. As you know, last week I had grades 6 and 7\n               French immersion students here from Collettville in Merrit. They're actually tuned\n               in today watching the procedures because they were unable to stay late last week. So please welcome them a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","label":"Heritage buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eba6d9305a52963398f4f884dfb68b0747f5df07e1d807317587d223635e47fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36267cd9d0512c53b104de94acf46ebdf16d2a863aa19c19a77ca7ae89d219a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68a23a9bbb46c12433182d4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360404,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"I really appreciate the opportunity here to stand and talk to Bill 9, the Freedom\n               of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act of 2026. I do so with a sense\n               of urgency on this bill. I feel that things are happening here that don't seem very\n               transparent to the public, and they need to know where we're going with this. Now, when I first started looking at this bill and everything, I thought: \"Is this\n               a one-off? Is there some oversight on this particular bill? Is something going on\n               in here that I haven't seen before?\" But the more I look at this bill and a number\n               of the bills since the 18 months ago that we came into this House.... I can safely say\n               that there's certainly an entrenched trend going on, and this bill exemplifies that\n               in no small measure. This bill is not simply about administrative adjustments to a statute. It is about\n               whether the people of British Columbia will still have the right to see what their\n               government is doing. It is about whether transparency will remain a pillar of democratic\n               government in this province or whether it will continue to erode under a growing culture\n               of secrecy and shutting out. So let me begin with a simple principle that every democratic society must uphold\n               if they want.... As my colleague before me said, shining the light on some of this stuff.\n               As a legal scholar, Harold L. Cross once wrote, and I quote: \"Public business is the\n               public's business. The people have the right to know.\" This bill is doing everything but that. It is slowly squeezing out the people's right\n               in British Columbia to know what this government is doing, what any government is\n               doing, whatever future government is doing, whatever past government has done. This\n               quote is a foundation of freedom-of-information laws that is used a lot when we're\n               talking about freedom of information. So government records do not belong to the politicians, they don't belong to us, they\n               do not belong to ministers, and they do not belong to the bureaucrats. They belong\n               to the people. But this bill seems to be putting that aside. And there's an emphasis\n               in this bill, as I look at it and as I analyze it, that this is about.... The government has the right to all the information and is making it harder and\n               harder for the public to get to the thing. The taxes that fund government programs come from the people, the authority that government\n               exercises is granted by the people, and the decisions that shape this province affect\n               the lives of the people. Therefore, the people have the right to know what decisions\n               are made and why those decisions are made for them. Freedom-of-information law exists because democracies understand a simple truth: power\n               must be watched. History is full of situations where power was not watched, it was\n               not monitored, and it has changed fundamentally countries all over the world and the\n               history of our world. So when transparency weakens, accountability weakens as well. Former Prime Minister\n               Stephen Harper once said about the dangers of secrecy in government, and I quote:\n               \"Without adequate access to key information, incompetent or corrupt governments can\n               be hidden under a cloak of secrecy.\" Those words apply just as much today as when\n               they were first spoken by Harper. When governments restrict access to information, they do not simply hide the documents.\n               They hide what's written on those documents. They hide mistakes. They hide waste.\n               They hide decisions that the public might otherwise question. And that is precisely\n               why the debate before us today matters so much to the people of British Columbia. Bill 9 does not strengthen transparency. It weakens transparency. And it does so at\n               a time when British Columbia is already facing serious concerns about secrecy and\n               accountability. Trust is blown. People in the province of British Columbia are having\n               trouble respecting politicians, respecting the process, because they're losing trust\n               in the government. And this kind of bill is exactly why that happens. I'm sorry they don't like it over there. They're chuckling. But this is what's happening.\n               Trust is gone, and part of trust is making sure government is.... I thought as well, if a government is so proud of the work they're doing, let it be\n               shown. I'm sorry they don't like it over there. They're chuckling. But this is what's happening.\n               Trust is gone, and part of trust is making sure government is.... I thought as well, if a government is so proud of the work they're doing, let it be\n               shown. Show the processes and what's happening. And it does so at a time.... Let me\n               speak plainly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360404","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I really appreciate the opportunity here to stand and talk to Bill 9, the Freedom\n               of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act of 2026. I do so with a sense\n               of urgency on this bill. I feel that things are happening here that don't seem very\n               transparent to the public, and they need to know where we're going with this. Now, when I first started ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bbf7abfe8aab86b724d0b5161c461e19e0631c26274bdd854dfad95c4a07a842"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab97bf842cf2c3792f571460e1a955ffd54728b9d05c34e2546cc9c6bff34caf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98e6a245251acc8f43f3dd0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415766,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move motion M203, standing in my name on the order paper. I rise today to speak to my motion 203, and I do so with a very clear message. This\n               is about trust, this is about accountability, and this is about the steady erosion\n               of legislative oversight in this province. The people of British Columbia are not asking for perfection from their government,\n               but they are absolutely entitled to expect fairness, transparency and accountability.\n               Remember, the people's business is the people's business. Increasingly, they are asking\n               a simple question: \"Who is watching the government?\" In a healthy democracy, we operate on a principle that is both practical and wise.\n               Trust but verify. We trust our institutions. We trust our public servants. We trust\n               that decisions are made in the public interest. But we also verify. We verify through\n               independent officers of this Legislature, and we verify through a transparent process.\n               We verify through oversight that is separate from power, not controlled by it. Because\n               trust without verification is not trust at all. It is blind faith, and blind faith\n               has no place in modern democracy. That is why Motion 203 matters, because it affirms a principle that should never be controversial — that\n               the application of the merit principle in the B.C. Public Service must be overseen\n               by an independent officer of this Legislature. Not internalized, not absorbed, not\n               controlled by the executive. Independent. But what we are seeing from this government tells a very different story. We are seeing\n               a pattern of centralizing authority, a pattern of removing independent oversight,\n               a pattern of asking British Columbia to simply accept that government police will\n               police itself. We have seen it in the elimination of the Merit Commissioner. We have\n               seen it in the weakening of other oversight mechanisms. Each time, the justification\n               is the same: efficiency, streamlining, and cost savings. But the result is also the\n               same: less accountability, less transparency and less trust. This is where we must step back and understand what is really happening. This is not\n               about one office. This is not about one decision. It's about a broad trend, one that\n               thinkers like John Michael Greer have warned about. Greer reminds us that societies and governments do not lose their\n               integrity all at once. He writes: \"Collapse doesn't happen all at once. It proceeds\n               by a ragged series of crises, and each of these pushes the system to a lower level\n               of complexity and capacity.\" That is not a dramatic collapse. That is a slow erosion, a safeguard removed here,\n               an oversight body eliminated there, a quiet shift of power away from independent scrutiny\n               and into centralized control. Each step is small enough to defend, but taken together,\n               they tell a very different story. Here is the reality. When government removes independent oversight, it is not just\n               removing a process; it is removing confidence. When government says, \"Trust us,\" but\n               eliminates the mechanism that allows the public to verify that trust, it creates doubt.\n               When that doubt grows, it does not stay contained. It spreads. Greer also warned that when this process takes hold, government begins to lose something\n               even more dangerous than oversight. They begin to lose the narrative. As he puts it,\n               when a society's leadership loses the ability to make its preferred narrative stick,\n               the process of decline accelerates. Because British Columbians can see the contraction.... They hear the word \"transparency,\" but they see oversight being dismantled at every\n               corner. They hear the word \"fairness,\" but they see independent verification removed.\n               How do they know? They hear the word \"accountability,\" but they see government increasingly\n               accountable only to itself. This is why this motion matters. It is not radical. It is not partisan. But it's foundational,\n               and it simply says that merit must be protected, that oversight must remain independent\n               and that accountability must flow to the Legislature, not be absorbed by the executive.\n               Because at the end of the day, this House does not belong to government. It belongs\n               to the people of British Columbia. It is through this House that accountability must\n               be exercised. The question before us is very clear. Do we believe in trust but verify, or do we\n               believe that government should be trusted without The question before us is very clear. Do we believe in \"trust but verify,\" or do we\n               believe that government should be trusted without verification? Do we strengthen oversight,\n               or do we continue down a path where oversight is being quietly diminished and eroded? Democracy is not lost in a single moment. It is weakened incrementally. I urge all\n               members of the House to have the courage to stand and support this — stand for trust,\n               stand for accountability and stand for independent oversight.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415766","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move motion M203, standing in my name on the order paper. I rise today to speak to my motion 203, and I do so with a very clear message. This\n               is about trust, this is about accountability, and this is about the steady erosion\n               of legislative oversight in this province. The people of British Columbia are not asking for perfection from their government,\n               b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb11358cecff65868baa20b192c6feed9c1d8a654efa4ef8b94e4a6e995d9a4c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28b45818eb66b1087887a800bdd401981b13becb8c79128e24af79f7b54ff7c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50c481fdeef4ff2866cef3fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415767,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a pleasure to be here in the House this afternoon and speak to Bill 11. Public policy is often judged not by its stated intent but by its structural design\n               and its real-world consequences. Governments frequently introduce legislation framed\n               around urgent and legitimate concerns — public safety, social stability, or economic\n               necessity. Yet history repeatedly demonstrates that the effectiveness of such legislation\n               depends less on its framing and more on how power is allocated, how rights are preserved\n               and whether underlying problems are genuinely addressed. Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, is a compelling example of this dynamic.\n               Presented as a targeted response to safety concerns within supportive housing, the\n               bill is positioned by government as a necessary intervention to protect residents,\n               staff, communities and owners. At face value, this objective is both reasonable and widely supported. Supportive\n               housing environments have experienced serious safety challenges, including incidents\n               involving violence, threats and absolute disorder. However, a deep examination of\n               the bill reveals However, a deep examination of the bill reveals that Bill 11 is not merely a safety-focused\n               reform. It represents a significant restructure of tenancy law within supportive housing,\n               characterized by expanded discretionary authority; increased reliance on regulation\n               rather than statute; and a shift in the balance of rights between tenants, operators\n               and government. More importantly, attempts to address symptoms of instability without meaningfully\n               confronting the systematic failures that have produced those conditions.... Bill 11,\n               while grounded in legitimate concerns, ultimately reflects a policy approach that\n               prioritizes control over capacity, enforcement over support, and executive discretion\n               over legislative clarity. As such, it risks exasperating the very challenges it seeks\n               to address, particularly in rural and smaller communities, where the impacts of homelessness\n               and addiction are much more acute. To properly evaluate Bill 11, it is essential to situate it within the broader context\n               of British Columbia's evolving homelessness and addiction crisis. Over the past decade,\n               these challenges have expanded significantly beyond major urban centres, increasingly\n               affecting smaller cities, towns and rural communities. How do I know that? I am from a small, rural community. In these environments, the impact of homelessness and untreated addictions are not\n               only present, they are amplified. Unlike large metropolitan areas, where social order\n               may be diffused across a larger population, smaller communities experience these issues\n               in a more concentrated and visible manner. The absence of anonymity, combined with\n               limited service capacity, intensifies both the perceptions and the reality of the\n               problem. Empirical evidence supports this observation. Overdose deaths in rural and smaller\n               communities are often higher than provincial averages, reflecting reduced access to\n               treatment, harm reduction and recovery services. At the same time, substance use remains one of the leading contributors to housing\n               instability in Canada, accounting for more than a quarter of the homelessness cases.\n               This creates a self-reinforcing cycle. Addiction contributes to housing loss. Housing\n               instability exasperates addiction. Breaking this cycle requires more than temporary\n               shelters. It requires integrated, sustained, supportive systems. Yet in many parts of British Columbia, particularly outside urban centres, these systems\n               are incomplete or entirely absent. Treatment facilities are limited and often located\n               far from communities in need. Mental health services are stretched thin, shelter capacity\n               is insufficient, and as a result, individuals experiencing complex challenges are\n               frequently unable to access the care necessary to stabilize. The outcome is a pattern of circulation rather than resolution. Individuals move between\n               emergency departments, temporary accommodations, interaction with law enforcement\n               and periods of unsheltered homelessness. Without sustained intervention, the underlying\n               issues remain unsolved, and the cycle continues. Supportive housing has long been recognized as a critical tool in addressing homelessness,\n               addiction. When properly implemented, it provides not only shelter, but also access\n               to essential services, including mental health, addiction treatment and social support.\n               Evidence from multiple jurisdictions demonstrates that well-designed supportive housing\n               can reduce reliance on emergency services, improve health outcomes and enhance community\n               services. However, the effectiveness of supportive housing is contingent upon adequate resourcing\n               and appropriate design. It requires sufficient staffing, integrated clinical support\n               and clear pathways to treatment and recovery. In British Columbia, and in particular in rural communities, these conditions are\n               often not met. Supportive housing units are frequently under-resourced, with limited\n               access to clinical services, insufficient staffing levels, and in some cases, facilities\n               are expected to manage individuals with complex and high-risk needs without necessary\n               infrastructure. This mismatch between expectation and capacity has contributed to the emergence of\n               safety concerns within the supportive housing environment. Incidents involving violence,\n               threats, disorder are not indicative of a failure of the supportive housing model Incidents involving violence, threats and disorder are not indicative of a failure\n               of the supportive housing model itself but rather of its incomplete implementation.\n               It is within this context of strained capacity and rising instability that Bill 11\n               seems to have been introduced. It seems to have reasonable intent, but the structure.... Bill 11 introduces a new legal framework for supportive housing within the Residential\n               Tenancy Act. While presented as a targeted response to safety concerns, the bill fundamentally\n               alters the governance of tenancy relationships in this sector. Three key structural\n               elements define the legislation. One is creation of a distinct tenancy regime. Bill 11 establishes supportive housing\n               as a separate category of tenancy, distinct from traditional rental housing. This\n               distinction is not merely administrative. It has substantive implications for the\n               rights and obligations of tenants and operators. Under this new regime, the criteria defining supportive housing may be determined\n               by regulation or, in some cases, by the operator himself where regulations are not\n               explicitly described. This introduces a level of variability and discretion that is\n               not present in the standard tenancy framework. The creation of a distinct tenancy category enables deviations from established protections\n               under the Residential Tenancy Act, effectively placing supportive housing tenants\n               in a different legal position from other renters in the community. Two, expansion of executive orders and operative authorities. A central feature of\n               Bill 11 is its reliance on regulations to find key aspects of the new framework. Cabinet\n               is granted broad authority to undermine.... Once again, this supports the theme that\n               has been going on in this new parliament with a lot of the bills that are being introduced. Cabinet is granted broad authority to determine when tenancy agreements may be modified\n               without mutual consent, the circumstances under which personal property may be seized\n               or interfered with, conditions under which tenants' access to a residence may be restricted,\n               definitions of prohibited items, including weapons, and procedural rules related to\n               enforcement and compensation. As noted in the legislative analysis, the bill establishes the framework while leaving\n               many substantive rules to be defined later by cabinet. That's the theme that's been\n               going on in this parliament. It's defined later by cabinet and orders in cabinet.\n               This approach shifts decision-making authority away from the Legislature and into\n               the executive branch, reducing transparency and limiting opportunity for proper scrutiny\n               by this duly elected Legislature. Three, expansion of enforcement and eviction mechanisms. Bill 11 introduces new pathways\n               to eviction, particularly in cases involving weapons or threat. I think, on the surface,\n               we would probably all like to see some different rules in place to deal with some\n               of these weapons and threats. But it can become problematic, because it also broadens\n               the scope of misconduct provisions through the use of the term \"authorized person,\"\n               extending the range of individuals whose interactions with the tenant may trigger\n               enforcement actions. These changes collectively lower the threshold for intervention and accelerate the\n               process by which tenants may be removed from housing. At its core, Bill 11 is an enforcement-oriented response to instability within supportive\n               housing. It provides operators with additional tools to manage risk and respond to\n               dangerous situations. However, this approach is limited by a fundamental constraint.\n               Enforcement mechanisms cannot substitute for system capacity. If individuals are removed from supportive housing due to safety concerns, the effectiveness\n               of the removal depends on the availability of alternative supports. If treatment programs\n               and transitional housing and recovery services are accessible, removal may serve as\n               a step toward stabilization. If those alternatives are lacking, removal becomes displacement. That is why I began this debate with comments around rural communities, because rural\n               communities are stretched at best to provide those alternative services to anything\n               like this. In the current context, where supportive capacity is already insufficient,\n               displacement is the more likely outcome. In the current context, where supportive capacity is already insufficient, displacement\n               is the more likely outcome. As the policy analyst indicates, removal without adequate\n               alternatives does not resolve underlying issues. It redistributes them across other\n               parts of the system. So we have a systemic failure in the process and in the system. Implications of rural and small communities. The consequences of this redistribution\n               are particularly significant for rural and small communities, as I have mentioned.\n               These communities operate with limited infrastructure and fewer resources. They lack\n               the capacity to absorb increased demand for services. When individuals are displaced from supportive housing, the impacts are immediate\n               and highly visible. Increased homelessness, greater pressure on local health and policing\n               systems and heightened concerns about public safety can quickly emerge. Unlike in\n               large urban centres, there is little ability to diffuse these effects across a broader\n               population. This dynamic raises concerns about the potential for policy decisions to disproportionately\n               affect communities that are least equipped to manage the resulting challenges of such\n               displacement. From an economic perspective, the implications of Bill 11 extend beyond the supportive\n               housing sector. While the legislation may reduce certain risks and costs within the\n               individual facilities, it may also contribute to increased expenditures elsewise.\n               We've kind of laid a few of those out already, but let's continue. The costs associated with homelessness, including health care, policing, emergency\n               services and the justice system, are well documented and often exceed the costs of\n               providing stable housing and support. If Bill 11 leads to increased displacement without\n               corresponding increase in supportive capacity, it is more likely to result in higher\n               overall system costs. The key question, therefore, is not whether the bill reduces costs in a specific context\n               but whether it contributes to more efficient outcomes across the system as a whole. Another critical aspect of Bill 11 is the reliance on regulation to define substantive\n               rules. While regulation is an essential component of modern governance, its expanded\n               use and its content raises concern about transparency and accountability. By delegating\n               significant authority to cabinet, the bill reduces the role of the Legislature in\n               determining the rights and obligations of tenants and operators. This shift has implications for democratic oversight — once again a troubling pattern,\n               another bill concerned about implications of democratic oversight, oversight that\n               the House should be doing rather than going into another process — as regulation decisions\n               are subject to less rigorous scrutiny than statutory provisions. In areas affecting fundamental aspects of daily life, such as housing, clarity and\n               predictability are essential, especially for the people that we're dealing with in\n               the supportive housing. A framework that relies heavily on discretionary regulations\n               will undermine many principles. It is important to acknowledge that the safety concerns addressed by Bill 11 are real\n               and require attention. Nobody doubts that for a minute. Staff and residents in supportive\n               housing have a right to safe environments, and incidents involving violence or threats\n               must be addressed effectively. However, safety and support....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415767","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a pleasure to be here in the House this afternoon and speak to Bill 11. Public policy is often judged not by its stated intent but by its structural design\n               and its real-world consequences. Governments frequently introduce legislation framed\n               around urgent and legitimate concerns — public safety, social stability, or economic\n               necessity. Yet history r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["49180e77e759d88a0aca2de7ce1568d3999fdf8cfc099be416ec8affe9ceae84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fcafbcb03ce51f5fade5ad398659f79aafb93e56024c70cf6b30698197f4d0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e7c48ab80d26940e0ef87ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720432,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I would like to introduce a couple of very, very good friends. We've been friends\n               for decades here in the House today, and they're visiting. Sitting beside my lovely\n               wife here, Len and Elaine Servo. They are from the member from Mission's riding, and\n               they're really honoured to be here today and seeing the workings of the House and\n               everything today. I would like just to highlight that Len was a corrections supervisor with B.C. Corrections\n               for 47 years. He tried retiring two or three times, but he got bored, so he had to\n               go back to the service. At the end of his service, at the end of 47 years, he received\n               the Corrections Exemplary Service Medal from the Governor General of Canada upon his\n               final retirement. So if I could get help in welcoming them to the House, that would be really appreciated.\n               For his service that he gave to the province....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720432","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I would like to introduce a couple of very, very good friends. We've been friends\n               for decades here in the House today, and they're visiting. Sitting beside my lovely\n               wife here, Len and Elaine Servo. They are from the member from Mission's riding, and\n               they're really honoured to be here today and seeing the workings of the House and\n               e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036558","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ornamental plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036558","label":"Ornamental plants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5cefb6aa3a99a531fce8ee9ee0e3b000be9f9db0e6621831979883f02e2913e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40143c3586891167d38deb956e1898d059e8a9dd9084f9c6dc8d667fd9080068"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-456e2853e0b04a3ac9bdbd80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720434,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"Once again, it is a pleasure to stand before the House and debate Bill 16 here. So\n               I rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.\n               A bill, like many of the bills we've seen in this House before, that on its surface\n               appears to be a routine legislative housekeeping exercise, but upon closer examination\n               reveals a familiar and increasingly concerning pattern in how this government approaches\n               lawmaking. Let me begin by acknowledging an important truth. There are elements within this legislation\n               that are necessary, overdue and, in some cases, aligned with recommendations that\n               we on this side of the House have made numerous times and have been advancing for\n               some time. But as has become all too common with this government, what is presented\n               as incremental improvements is paired quietly, almost subtly, with provisions that\n               shift authority away from this House, away from this Legislature and into the hands\n               of cabinet. Once again, a troubling continued trend. That is where concern lies, because legislation\n               is not just about outcomes. It's about process. It's about accountability. It's about\n               the optics. It's about who decides, how they decide and whether those decisions are\n               subject to the scrutiny that is necessary upon making legislation. Increasingly, the\n               answer in this government is not here in this chamber. So we'll go through some parts\n               here, and we'll try to clarify that a little bit more as we go through this bill bit\n               by bit here. Bill 16 spans multiple ministries and statutory frameworks. I'll hit lightly on some\n               and a little bit heavier on others. This one here is statutory frameworks. Attorney\n               General amendments to the Judicial Review Procedure Act. Energy and climate adjustments\n               to the Fuel Price Transparency Act and the Zero Emission Vehicles Act. A wide range\n               of Housing and Municipal Affairs changes. Public Safety amendments under the Correction\n               Act. We just heard from a colleague across the floor here making some arguments for\n               some of the necessary changes in corrections. Each part contains provisions that, taken individually, may appear just technical.\n               But taken together, they reveal something far more significant, a continued reliance\n               on regulation-making authority, a continued preference for flexible over transparency\n               and a continued erosion of the role of this Legislature. Part 1. Judicial review. Expanding the shield of cabinet confidentiality. Let us begin\n               with Part 1 and have a quick look at that. This section continues two deeply consequential changes to the Judicial Review Procedures\n               Act. It removes a safeguard that prevents judicial review from being denied simply\n               because time has passed. It expands cabinet's ability to designate documents as confidential,\n               shielding documents So let's be clear here. Cabinet confidentiality has a legitimate purpose. There's\n               no question about that. Government must be able to deliberate candidly. But what this\n               bill does, is not merely preserve confidentiality, it expands it and broadens it greatly.\n               It allows cabinet to designate information as confidential in a manner that may shield\n               decisions from judiciary scrutiny. When combined with limits of judicial review timelines, the result is clear — less\n               transparency, less accountability and less ability for citizens to challenge government\n               decisions. That should concern every member of this House. We've talked about that before, and it looks like this is going to be an ongoing pattern with these bills. Judicial review is not a procedural inconvenience. It is a cornerstone of democratic\n               accountability, and it's what the people of this province expect of us. So let me go on to the EV mandate for a little bit and talk about that. We've had\n               a little bit of talk about that from one of my colleagues and the Energy Minister\n               across the floor here. There's some interesting debate and chat about that. So I think the EV mandate — we could position it and title it in different ways —\n               it's a quiet admission of failure on the government side. We have talked about this\n               numerous times on this side of the House, how this act needed to be changed and moved\n               along, modernized and brought up to date, with so many of the challenges. Just to be clear, as my colleague mentioned as well, I have nothing against EVs. We\n               finally leased a hybrid ourselves. We enjoy it, we like it, we get great mileage,\n               and, I think, like many in this House, we have a love-hate relationship with the oil\n               companies. I think, for years, I've always wanted to find a way to get off of the addiction to\n               oil, but it's a necessary evil that we have in our society. It runs society, it makes\n               us richer and all kinds of things. But moving to the hybrid that we did, we've really\n               enjoyed it. I get to watch how much good mileage I can get from it if I back the pedal\n               off a little bit and kick that EV in. I really enjoy my EV. It does well for us, and\n               we hope to continue with that for some time here in the future. The most striking element of this bill is the changes to the Zero-Emission Vehicles\n               Act, which has brought some radical changes in here. What we are witnessing here is\n               not a simple policy adjustment. It looks like a full reversal of where we're going.\n               Once again, we've asked for this many times sitting in the House here. Some of the\n               things had to stop, some of the changes. The EV mandates went against the convention\n               of regular markets, and that forcing something, forcing a square peg into a round\n               hole, it was very, very difficult. I agree with the Minister of Energy who said that we do have the highest rate of EV\n               adoption anywhere in Canada because of low electricity rates. He likes to tout that\n               whenever he can. I agree with him, we have some very good, low electricity rates. The other thing he likes to tout and talk about is the North Coast transmission line.\n               What a wonderful thing that would be. One of the things we're a little puzzled about\n               on this side.... We're importing 20 percent of our electricity already. They're building\n               a.... I'm going to back up a little bit. We're going to build a transmission line that\n               in the beginning, was going to cost $3 billion. Now we're at $6 billion. It looks....\n               The final figure is going to be in around the $9 billion mark. That, added to the financial debt of B.C. Hydro, which is sitting at about $33 billion\n               right now, is going to put Hydro debt at over $40 billion. When you understand economies\n               and everything like that, what the Minister of Energy likes to talk about, his cheap\n               electricity.... B.C. Hydro just recently got put on credit watch. That doesn't mean\n               their credit is going up or anything, but they are on credit watch. You add $9 billion more to the debt that Hydro is servicing. The regular taxpayers\n               don't service that debt; the Hydro ratepayers service that debt. There is tremendous\n               upward pressure on the rates for B.C. Hydro. They're going to have to pay for that\n               $9 billion transmission line. I'll use that number because, until we're corrected,\n               that's what it looks like it's going to be. I don't know how much longer the Minister of Energy is going to be able to tout the\n               low rates of electricity in here with that kind of pressure on there. The transmission\n               line that has gone up three times since it was first proposed. The other thing about that is, where are they going to get the electricity to put\n               into that line? Because as far as we understand on this side of the House, it's The other thing about that is: where are they going to get the electricity to put\n               into that line? Because as far as we understand on this side of the House, it's at\n               capacity — Site C dam. So we're a little bit befuddled on this side, and hopefully\n               tomorrow or next week, he'll be able to straighten us out on that because, heaven\n               forbid, we know where it's coming from. But there is upward pressure on that, so maybe that's part of why these EV mandates\n               are going to change, because we're going to put a tremendous amount of pressure on\n               the grid to be able to supply the electricity we need there, and rates are going to\n               go up. Rates go up. People aren't going to be so willing to buy the electric vehicles\n               that have done well here. And it's good. I'm glad that in British Columbia the people\n               have enjoyed the EVs. Like I say, we've got a hybrid now. We have electric bikes.\n               We enjoy them immensely, but I just hope the rates can stay down. The EV sales. They were demanding that EV sales by 2026, this year, had to be 20 percent\n               of sales for a car and in 2030, four years from now, 60 percent of sales. And by 2035,\n               100 percent of car sales were to be EV. It seems like a little bit.... They're very, very ambitious goals, and obviously the auto industry had a hard time.\n               But we're not the only nation that's turning its back, not necessarily turning its\n               back but certainly ramping down the demand that we put on the need to buy electric\n               vehicles moving forward here, because they've become a bit of a challenge here, especially\n               in the Interior. We've talked about that. My colleagues talked about that, how an EV just doesn't work in the north. Diesel\n               pickups are used for doing farm work and vacationing and all those kinds of things,\n               and it's hard to get people that can fill up their truck with diesel and drive for\n               700, 800, 900 kilometres. You can't do that in an EV, especially in a truck that's\n               pulling a trailer. But things are changing, and that's good. These are sweeping transformational mandates that fundamentally reshaped the automotive\n               market, especially here in B.C. As we talked about — 229,000 EVs at last count, I\n               guess it is, and that's great. But today those targets are being scaled back, and\n               the final targets are being reduced. I think there's some common sense being brought\n               in that picture. On this side of the House, of course, we always let the market decide\n               what people want in there, and if we can keep the electricity rates, they're going\n               to decide to go to EV, and that's good. So it's happening because jurisdictions around the world and here at home have begun\n               to recognize the same reality. The mandates were ahead of the infrastructure, ahead\n               of consumer demand and ahead of economic feasibility. In fact, we do not need to look far for evidence. The federal government itself, recently,\n               under new policy direction, has already taken decisive action to pull back its demand\n               on the electric vehicles. Canada has now replaced its national EV sales mandate, replacing\n               it with the more flexible emission standards. So they're going to have to bridge the\n               gap until we're able to have this greater uptake of electric vehicle gain. But even the automakers have realized that this was a bit of a dead end here. The\n               costs were too high. Range anxiety and batteries and things like that were just out\n               of reach for some people. So these targets have proved unrealistic here, and the government\n               has come around and seen that, and now they're going to be tweaking the numbers a\n               little bit. Other jurisdictions are doing the same, and this is not unique in Canada. The United\n               States has moved to roll back aggressive EV mandates. The United Kingdom has already\n               softened its ZEV EV mandates, introducing flexibility in credit systems. Even Europe's\n               stricter emission standards have also looked at that. So the pattern is clear. Governments\n               are recognizing that mandates without infrastructure, without affordability and without\n               consumer readiness do not succeed. It's good that we're able to see that sentiment shift here. To some degree, it is\n               sad. We would like to move away from our addiction. I know the members of the Third\n               Party would certainly like to see that. They talk about that numerous times. It would\n               be nice to let go of our oil dependence. But we just don't see that. Realistically,\n               we don't see that happening any time in the near future. But we need to be flexible. Having said that, let's move on to the next piece of information here. The heart of\n               this bill and the area that demands the most scrutiny is part 3. This is where we see amendments to the Local Government Act, the Vancouver Charter,\n               the Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District Act, and the South Coast B.C.\n               Transportation Authority Act. At first glance, again, the intent appears reasonable, and some of it is reasonable\n               — to allow certain development projects to be designated by regulation for the purpose\n               of At first glance, again, the intent appears reasonable, and some of it is reasonable\n               but to allow certain development progress to be designated by regulation for the purpose\n               of reducing development cost charges. Now as a former city councillor and that, looking\n               at what DCCs do for a community, I'm a little concerned about what that may look like. We support efforts to reduce development costs. We support efforts anyway we can reduce\n               costs of housing. We're all in the housing kick. We need more housing and everything.\n               But as we know, the cost of housing is usually three components. About a third of\n               it is land, a third of it is the construction costs and a third of it is government\n               fees, red tape, regulations and that kind of things. So anything we can do to reduce\n               any of those costs, not just building and everything, would be really, really good. We support any of those efforts to be able to do that. We have consistently raised\n               concerns about the impact of DCCs on housing affordability. But the question is not\n               whether DCC should be addressed. The question is: who decides and how will those questions\n               be addressed? Under these amendments, the cabinet is given the authority to designate specific projects\n               by regulation that may be exempt from or subject to reduced development cost charges.\n               That to me is red lights, red herrings, whatever you want to call it. That's a great\n               concern. What are these projects? Are they government-built housing, government-built courthouses,\n               government-built whatever, especially around the housing? Are they going to go to\n               the cities and say: \"Hey, we're reducing DCCs. As a matter of fact, we're going to\n               eliminate them on any building the government comes in here to build, social housing\n               or anything.\" That's a huge concern. Let me just take.... Let's go a step back a little bit and look at the tremendous pressure\n               that municipalities and cities are under. You all know the numbers, but for the sake\n               of Hansard and the sake of the people watching here, once again I'll reiterate. Municipalities\n               are responsible for 60 percent of the infrastructure funding in Canada and in the\n               province. Yet, they receive less than 10 cents of every tax dollar that's collected\n               in here. So they have 10 cents to do 60 percent of the work that needs to be done\n               in the province. Now, you get a government that comes along and says, \"Guess what? We're going to reduce\n               that even more, and we're going to say: 'On this project of social housing, you're\n               not going to be collecting DCCs from us',\" because they're going to sell them the\n               fact that if we can lower the price of the social housing for people, we can lower\n               the cost. We keep hearing about those $1.8 million doors for long-term care and that, and they\n               want to reduce DCCs, and maybe.... I'm not suggesting that's where they're going, but\n               it sure looks like that. There's a red herring here. We have to look at that, right?\n               Reduce that. Local governments, municipalities, cities are already strapped to the hilt, trying\n               to find money to look after the infrastructure, policing, roads, sewer, water and\n               that. I've just given you the formula there. This could be another blow to the cities,\n               another downloading blow to the cities that we have in the province. Once again, the larger cities might be able to take some of the impact here, but the\n               smaller rural communities cannot. They struggle every day to find the money they need\n               to keep the infrastructure, the police and the fire going in their communities. So this is a scary proposition. It will be good to get into committee and second reading\n               here and be able to discuss this, ask those tough questions. What is the real intent\n               of reducing these DCCs? Is this a broad reduction for everybody or is it just government\n               specific? So there will be some good questions we may want to ask around them. Decisions that were traditionally made at the local level, decisions that reflected\n               local infrastructure capacity, local priorities and local accountability are now being\n               centralized. Once again, here's another piece of centralization where the government\n               is going to come in: \"We will set your DCC rates. We'll decide which ones we can exempt\n               and which ones we'll keep going and that.\" So it's not through legislation. If the bill passes, it won't be in this House. They'll\n               make that in the Premier's office, not through debate in the House but through regulation,\n               once again. Just a little bit of history here for those that don't understand. DCCs, development\n               cost charges, are not arbitrary. They exist for a very important reason. They ensure\n               that growth pays for growth, infrastructure keeps pace with development and existing\n               taxpayers are not forced to subsidize new construction. They fund water systems and\n               sewer, new bridges, if they need in the town, or whatever kind of infrastructure there. It's going to be really important to make sure that we don't eliminate development\n               cost charges for the municipalities, because where else would they get the funding?\n               We can talk about that later. Funding is a real challenge for municipalities in how\n               they get their funding to do the things they do. Because Because municipalities are not administrative arms of the province — they are democratically\n               elected governments — they are responsible for all the infrastructure planning, all\n               the water and sewer, as I mentioned, roads and transportation, and the development\n               cost charges are not arbitrary fees. They are critical tools to ensure that growth\n               pays for growth. Now we move down to comparative.... Let's compare this to other jurisdictions and have\n               a look. In Ontario, when the province introduced changes to development charges under\n               Bill 23, it was paired, albeit imperfectly, with discussions around infrastructure\n               funding and municipal compensation. When the DCCs, and they changed the way it was\n               done there.... The city and the province would actually sit down and collaborate and\n               talk about different ways of funding the needs within the community. They just weren't\n               cut out, they were reduced, but they weren't left holding the bag. In Quebec, infrastructure planning is closely tied to provincial funding agreements,\n               ensuring that municipalities are not left carrying the burden alone. I think I just\n               mentioned that. In Saskatchewan, municipalities retain stronger control over local fee structures\n               with provincial involvement focused on partnerships rather than override. In each of these cases, there is a recognition of basic principles. If the province\n               changes the rules, it must also share the responsibility. And that principle is pretty\n               much present here in any of the legislation we've seen through this Parliament with\n               anything around housing and that. I think it's really important. We've talked about\n               that before. We need to really have that collaboration so that the cities are not\n               left holding the bag, as we've seen. So moving on, Bill 16 connects to a broader trend we have seen from this government.\n               We've mentioned that before, because this is not the first time we have seen authority\n               shifted to cabinet through regulation. We've seen it in Bill 7, the Economic Stabilization\n               Act; Bill 14, Renewable Energy Act; and Bill 15, the Infrastructure Projects Act. I always like when I read here, we're not just coming from a blank or an empty bucket.\n               We like to remind everybody to validate the opinion that this has been going on for\n               some time and that there's a trend in the structure here. Now we see it again in Bill 16, a constant pattern which identifies a legitimate policy\n               issue, introduces a broad legislative framework, delegates key decisions to cabinet\n               through regulation and limits the role of legislative oversight. This is not accidental.\n               It is a governing philosophy that seems to be entrenched within this Parliament. So municipal implications and some real-world consequences that are happening because\n               of this. Let us bring this down from theory to reality. In communities across British\n               Columbia, especially in rural and smaller municipalities, the impact of these changes\n               will be felt immediately. Take a community like my own, Merritt. Infrastructure capacity is not theoretical;\n               it is finite. Water system, sewer system, roadworks, these are not easily expanded.\n               If the province designates a project and reduces DCCs, the municipality still has\n               to serve. The money is still needed to do that. If this government is determined to proceed with this approach, then at a minimum,\n               we must ask where are the safeguards, where are the guardrails, where is the requirement\n               for municipal consultation within this bill, a requirement for infrastructure capacity\n               assessments, a requirement for official funding, and a requirement for transparency?\n               None of these are clearly embedded in this legislation. Instead, we are told: \"Trust\n               the regulation-making process.\" With respect, that is not good enough. Let's move on to the tenancy amendments, flexibility versus fairness. Bill 16 also\n               introduces change to the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act and the Residential Tenancy\n               Act, allowing directors to admit evidence that would not otherwise meet legal standards\n               of thresholds. Now, there is a rationale here to some degree. Tribunals are meant to be accessible.\n               They are not courts. Flexibility can help ensure that individuals are not excluded\n               on technical grounds. But again, we must ask, where are the limits? Where are the guardrails? Where are\n               the protections to ensure that decisions remain fair, evidence remains reliable, and\n               outcomes remain consistent? Flexibility without safeguards can lead to unpredictability,\n               and unpredictability undermines confidence in the system. We've seen that lots here. Where are the protections to ensure that decisions remain fair, evidence remains reliable\n               and outcomes remain consistent? Flexibility without safeguards can lead to unpredictability,\n               and unpredictability undermines confidence in the system. We've seen that lots here.\n               And that one thing us politicians don't need is more lack of confidence from the general\n               public out there. They need to make sure that we're confident. Optics is huge. The\n               public has to be confident in the things that we do. Correction Act. The minister across the way there spoke quite eloquently to some of\n               the things that need to be changed around that this is going to help with the Correction\n               Act, including authorization of proportionate force for mental health interventions.\n               That's a good thing. Everybody realizes that's one of the big challenges in society\n               right now, mental health, and so those are some good changes there. Establish an investigations and standards office. And here's the reason for cautious\n               support, though, on some of these things. You know, some of the things are looking\n               good, but like I say, we'll drill down to the nuts and bolts here when we get into\n               committee on this. For too long, we have lacked adequate mechanism to address mental health challenges\n               in this province within correctional facilities. The creation of an independent investigative\n               function is a step in the right direction. But even here, questions remain. We must ask the right questions. How independent\n               is this office in practice? What oversight mechanism will exist? What reporting requirements\n               will ensure transparency? Independence must be more than structural. It must be operational. With these provisions taken individually, many may appear modest, but taken together\n               they tell a story. A story of a government that increasingly prefers regulation over\n               legislation, flexibility over accountability and centralization over partnerships.\n               And that is a great concern. If we go back and ask the question, \"Who did you speak to? Who did you collaborate\n               with?\" we kind of know what the answer on that already is. That is a great concern\n               to us on this side of the House, because democracy is not eroded by a single, sweeping\n               act. It is eroded incrementally, piece by piece, and I think I've spoken to that before. But a better path forward. This does not have to be the path, of course, and we would\n               agree with that on there. I think many bills.... And we've sat down and talked. We offer\n               amendments, and we would hope the government would be looking at doing that as we\n               offer amendments to try to make. We're not trying to undermine these bills. We're trying to help make them better so\n               we're not back here having an omnibus bill like this again and making all these little\n               tweaks along. But if we could work together in this House, and I think I've asked\n               for that before.... If we could just sit down together and work with these, we could\n               have some really solid bills that would come out of this House and our committees. But we need to be able to do that. We need to set aside some things and just get to\n               work. There's always a better way of doing things, and we can find that way. So if this government truly wants to address housing affordability, municipality capacity\n               and infrastructure delivery, then work with municipalities, not around them. Pair\n               policy changes with funding commitments. Embed transparency in legislation, not regulation.\n               Preserve the role of this Legislature in scrutinizing decisions, and work with this\n               Legislature. Good governance is not about speed alone. It's all about trust, and we\n               know that that's what we need here. We will not oppose progress where it is warranted and it's in good order, and we will\n               support measures that improve affordability, strengthen systems and address real challenges,\n               but we will also do our duty. That duty is to scrutinize the legislation, offer changes,\n               offer amendments, offer to work with this government so that we can have the best\n               policy going forward, the best legislation moving forward for the people. So I leave this chamber with a simple question. If decisions are increasingly made\n               by cabinet behind closed doors through orders in council, then what is the role of\n               this legislation? I think I've asked that question before — maybe just a little bit\n               different here or there, but the same thing. What's the point of this Legislature\n               if we're not being able to be part of this Legislature and doing the work with you? This is the people's House, and the people's business is the people's business, not\n               quietly moved into regulation, not shielded from review but brought into the light.\n               That is our responsibility as a Legislature. That's what we've been hired for by the\n               public.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720434","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Once again, it is a pleasure to stand before the House and debate Bill 16 here. So\n               I rise today to speak to Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.\n               A bill, like many of the bills we've seen in this House before, that on its surface\n               appears to be a routine legislative housekeeping exercise, but upon closer examination\n               reve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["311c316610f83e69504b9afbfbbd779bcfafa73d6ea2eaa70becbed01cd67fa4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["977a548680da7187fa4608ba559d0fa787932b397d770495f436bdff8cf7ac72"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ace997a4f423d6c7d6cf7085","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721526,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a pleasure to be able to speak to this bill. Well, I probably shouldn't use the\n               word \"pleasure.\" It's unfortunate that we have to speak to a bill like this, and I've\n               heard some of the statements and things that have been said around here. As someone who has had an amputation himself, I am somewhat understanding of what\n               the member from Prince George–North Cariboo is bringing forward today. Although my injury is in no way in comparison to someone\n               who loses a leg or an arm or something like that, I intimately understand the thought\n               process and the things that we go through if something like that happens. So I rise today in strong support of Bill M237 from the member for Prince George–North Cariboo. This bill has been moved because our current system is failing some of the very\n               people it was supposed to protect — not everyone, but the ones who matter the most. When British Columbia moved to a no-fault system under the Insurance Corporation of\n               British Columbia, we were told a very clear story that this will help make things\n               more efficient, move things along. We'll get much faster care for the people that\n               need it, which is really true because some people would wait for months, years before\n               they got the funding they needed to be able to take care of their problems. It would drastically reduce legal fees and the legal fighting that happens in the\n               courts and all the things that have to happen there. It was going to lower costs.\n               Of course, it would lower the cost of the system and both the insured as well and\n               bring more rational budgeting to ICBC. And it was a system that was focused on recovery\n               rather than delays. I think we all saw that in a system that was somewhat struggling\n               with getting costs under control and helping people get the expedited resources they\n               need to heal and recover as quickly as possible. So yes, there is a lot of truth to no-fault working better in some cases. For minor\n               injuries, for straightforward claims, the system is faster and more efficient. I don't\n               think anybody disputes that. It becomes simpler and is more predictable as well. But here is what we were not told clearly in the chat about what no-fault would do\n               — that the same system would limit justice for the most severely injured people in\n               the province. Some claims cannot and should not be on a compensation chart. No-fault\n               insurance is built on a trade-off. You get speed, but you give up your right to full\n               compensation. You get certainty, but you lose the ability to have your individual\n               case fully heard. You get efficiency. There's no question about that. You get the\n               efficiency that's needed in the system but at the cost of flexibility and fairness\n               in the most complex situations. For the average case, maybe that works. But for catastrophic injury, that trade-off\n               breaks down and falls short of the most serious injuries. Once again, cookie-cutter\n               applications for something that can't use a cookie cutter. Let me put this into more real terms. As a British Columbian involved in a crash,\n               they lose a leg. Their career is over. Their future income is cut substantially. Their\n               quality of life is most likely permanently changed forever. Under the old system,\n               that person could go to court and seek recourse. A judge would hear the story. Their\n               future losses would be calculated. Their pain and suffering would be recognized. Their\n               care needs would be assessed in full. Yes, it did take time, but catastrophic injuries\n               take time to resolve. But the outcome eventually would reflect their personal reality. Under today's system, that same person is placed into a structured benefit framework:\n               income replacement, capped; care, approved within guidelines; a lump sum impairment\n               payment, limited. No lawsuit. No individualized assessment. No full accounting of\n               what they had lost. So let me ask this House: is that justice, or is that And it gets worse. Let me talk about something that should concern every member of\n               this chamber. Under the current rules, losing one limb does not automatically qualify\n               as a catastrophic injury. Let that sink in for a minute, as we think about that. I'm\n               sure we all know somebody that has lost a limb. A worker loses a hand, a young person\n               loses an arm and the system says: \"That may not be catastrophic enough. You have to\n               lose two.\" That is not just a policy flaw. That is a moral failure. We are now seeing real-world consequences, cases where ICBC disputes aspects of care,\n               even for serious injuries; cases where treatment decisions are challenged within the\n               system; concerns raised about privacy and handling of medical information. And while\n               the system may be more efficient, efficiency is cold comfort to someone whose life\n               has been permanently altered. We aren't the only system that has gone to no-fault or has been looking at no-fault.\n               Other jurisdictions have tweaked their systems along the way, as they found little\n               bumps in the road and little imperfections — well, not so much little. Some of them\n               were major imperfections. Others have looked at some of the research and have learned\n               from some of the lessons and made the adjustments as necessary. It's good to hear that we've got a committee set up that's going to be looking at\n               this. Will that committee work fast enough to get some of this done for the people\n               that are suffering now? Let me just give you a couple of examples. In Ontario, there is no-fault but also\n               a hybrid system that allows a victim the ability to sue in serious cases. It's a bit\n               of a hybrid system. In Saskatchewan, drivers can choose their coverage model between\n               a tort system or a no-fault system. In Manitoba, the system provides broader recognition\n               of serious injury and long-term care needs. Those jurisdictions understood something that we are now starting to discover here\n               in British Columbia. Just a reminder that no system is perfect, especially when you\n               try to change something and get things under control and build some efficiencies in\n               the system.... It takes time to tweak those. But let's not drag that time out too long because there are people suffering, and\n               there are people that need to have resolution as quickly as possible so that they\n               can get on with their lives and receive the compensation that they're entitled to.\n               Efficiency cannot come at the expense of fairness for the most severely injured. Even parts of the United States have experimented with no-fault systems to reduce\n               litigation and improve efficiency. The logic is consistent across all of them: get\n               care to people faster, reduce friction and lower cost. And on those fronts, no-fault\n               systems often perform well for a large majority of people. But in this case, when it's catastrophic, they do not help the person that has had\n               the catastrophic injury heal, not only physically but emotionally. A lot of this is....\n               You lose an arm. You lose a leg or lose two legs. It's not always about just the physical.\n               It's about the emotional piece that we have to remember as well. Bill M237 does not tear down the old system. We're not saying: \"Get rid of the old\n               system.\" We're saying that there are benefits to it. But it does not bring back endless\n               lawsuits. That's not what this bill is meant to do. It's a very simple bill. I think\n               it's one page. The amendments to the Insurance Vehicle Act ensure that individuals with catastrophic\n               injuries have more time to make a claim. Because here is the reality. When someone\n               is recovering from brain trauma, undergoing multiple surgeries and learning how to\n               live again, they are not thinking about deadlines. They are thinking about survival.\n               This bill simply says that we will not punish you for that. Reducing the threshold from two amputations to one is not controversial. It shouldn't\n               be controversial. It is common sense, it is compassion, and it is a reality. The debate\n               is not about ideology. It's about something much more simple. Because if it works\n               for the easy cases but fails for the hardest ones, then it is not finished. The bill\n               is not finished. The bill makes a very necessary correction, and I don't believe Bill M237 is.... It's\n               not radical. It's not reckless. It is a correction. And we can admit that. Sometimes\n               we put a bill in place, and we like to make some corrections. There is a simple test for any system like this. If it were you or your family member,\n               would you believe it's fair? The answer There is a simple test for any system like this: if it were you or your family member,\n               would you believe it's fair? If the answer is no, then we have work to do. Bill 237\n               is part of that work. For those reasons, I will be supporting this bill emphatically, and I urge every member\n               of this House to do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721526","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a pleasure to be able to speak to this bill. Well, I probably shouldn't use the\n               word \"pleasure.\" It's unfortunate that we have to speak to a bill like this, and I've\n               heard some of the statements and things that have been said around here. As someone who has had an amputation himself, I am somewhat understanding of what\n               the member from Prince George","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["924a5f5c536223bc63a92e53b8114a12a3f8d00808913c6f941f4f921609d4a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcbc6d2092696103dd5db17b4abe00151e89b6d89c9cb4be49be3db707a18759"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0e6d5e38fb0e7ed2e475c1d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752281,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a real pleasure to be here this evening. It reminds me of the old days when\n               we used to do all-nighters and things like that. So here we are, an all-nighter. It's\n               been a long time. So I'm really looking forward to this, to being able to speak to\n               this motion that we've got on the floor here, this hoist motion. Tonight I want to say strongly that I do support the hoist amendment to Bill 9, the\n               Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. I think it's a very important thing we're looking at today, because it's one of\n               those little small things that define democracy in the end, right? Let me be absolutely clear at the outset about this hoist amendment, what it really\n               does, why it really matters in the long term and why it is absolutely necessary that\n               we move this as soon as possible. This hoist amendment proposes that the word \"now\"\n               be replaced with \"six months hence.\" I know we've heard that a lot today and the last\n               day or two, but once again, I'll repeat it for the viewers out there that have tuned\n               in late to this show tonight. I just want to make sure that they're very clear what\n               we're trying to do here. We're not trying to defeat this bill, kill the bill, do anything like that. What we\n               want to do is have a serious, second, sober look at this bill because there are some\n               gaps in it. What we want to do is just extend it for six months, bring it back in\n               the fall, allow the government to take some time over the summer vacation here — unfortunately,\n               they'll have to work a little bit of their vacation — come back, have another look\n               at this and fill in some of the gaps that we're really concerned about. It's not just us that are really concerned about the gaps. It's industry out there.\n               It's other businesses. It's FOI associations and groups that have sown some real concern\n               about it. I think in my original speech on Bill 9 I talked about that, and I made\n               it very clear. We're not here to talk about the bill tonight. We're here to talk about\n               the hoist amendment. So we just want to make sure that it's very, very clear that\n               we're talking about the hoist and what it wants to do here. Six months to do what this government has failed to do. What are some of the things\n               that it has failed to do? Well, it's failed to properly examine the bill, put it under\n               a microscope and look at some of the finer details. We know this is the history of\n               this government and what they don't do. That's properly consult. We hear that all\n               the time, everywhere we go. They haven't properly consulted. So we need to go back\n               and properly consult on this bill and properly understand the consequences of this\n               deeply flawed legislation because that is what a hoist amendment is for. It's to be\n               able to bring and shine the light on some things where there's some holes in it and\n               have a look at that and try to improve where we can. The hoist amendment is not about the delay for the sake of delay. We don't want to\n               do that. We all believe in properly effective, properly working freedom of information.\n               I think that's a really important piece of legislation that this House can do and\n               what we have in modern society today. I think it's really important to make sure we\n               get it right, make sure we have the right timelines and the right costs. If there\n               is a cost, there probably shouldn't be a cost, and that kind of thing, but some of\n               the right things we do here. It's about preventing bad laws from being passed in haste. That's what this actually\n               looks like. It looks like a bill that's being tried and passed in haste, rushed through.\n               So you have to ask the question. Why are we trying to rush this bill through? I'll\n               talk a little bit more about that, about rushing things, as I go along here. But it's also about forcing government to take a second, sober look when it has clearly\n               gotten it wrong the first time, and this government has gotten it wrong. As I mentioned\n               before, it's not just us saying this and other groups. This bill is not ready, and\n               that is why this hoist amendment is absolutely necessary as we move forward here. It is not refined, and it certainly is not a balanced bill, as we've seen, as we have\n               talked about, in the bill itself. It's not rooted in strengthening transparency. It\n               seems more to do with shutting down transparency. This hoist motion will be there\n               so we can go and look with clarity of how we can strengthen transparency because that's\n               what's This hoist motion will be there so we can go and look, with clarity, at how we can\n               strengthen transparency, because that's what it's all about — making sure everybody\n               understands exactly what's happening, how the process is to work. It is a bill that weakens access right, expands government discretion and tilts the\n               balance away from the public and towards the state, and that is precisely why this\n               hoist motion must be passed — to go in and have a look at how it does that and how\n               we can pull that back and rebalance the bill, moving forward here. If we allow this\n               bill to proceed now, we are knowingly allowing flawed legislation to pass into law,\n               legislation that will impact every journalist, every parent, every taxpayer and every\n               British Columbia seeking answers from their government. I may say this once or twice through my comments here, but the people's business is\n               the people's business. We always need to remember that when we sit in this House and\n               we do things in this House. We are here at the behest of our voters and of the people\n               that we represent out there. We believe and we feel that six months is not an unreasonable amount of time to ask\n               to have a second sober look at this bill and make sure that we all get it right. If\n               that side of the House gets it right, we will support it, but it has to be right,\n               moving forward. Six months is what good legislators do when a bill is not quite ready\n               here. We take some time to have a look at it. So what this hoist amendment is really about. This hoist amendment is about one thing\n               — giving this Legislature the time to do its job, because this bill, this deeply consequential\n               bill, has not been subjected to the level of scrutiny it deserves. Where was the full\n               consultation with transparency experts? Where was the deep engagement with journalists?\n               Where was the serious response to warnings from watchdog organizations? We mention those because we're not discussing the bill. We talked about that in the\n               previous bill, but these are some of the things we're concerned about, and it's why\n               we're looking at the hoist motion — to go back and answer the questions we didn't\n               get answers for in the previous discussion and debate of the bill, in the beginning. Instead, we are asked to accept the government's word that this is modernization.\n               Modernization — I'm not exactly sure what that word means in this respect. Is it updating?.\n               Is it digitizing? What is it doing with this bill to make it more transparent, easily\n               readable, that kind of thing? If weakening transparency is modernizing, then we have\n               lost the meaning of the word. This government has a track record, and it is not a good one. Once again, I detailed\n               that when I did my debate on Bill 9, so we won't reiterate that here. But we know\n               that is why we want the hoist motion, because some of those answers were not forthcoming,\n               and we're still trying to decide where this bill is going. They are attempting to make some modest amendments — the government on its own — to\n               change the bill and try to make it a little bit more transparent, but it's not working.\n               As some of my colleagues have mentioned in the past, they are simply a little bit\n               of housekeeping amendments and everything, not really changing the gist of the bill\n               to begin with. Hence our requirement, our ask for a hoist motion, to be able to take\n               the time to look at some of the things that aren't working in this bill. One of the things, as well.... The record from the government is deeply concerning,\n               and it should be. This is a government that has been called one of the most secretive\n               in Canada. We've heard that numerous times here. We've heard it a number of times\n               during the debate on Bill 9, and not only Bill 9 but previous bills that we have discussed\n               here — about the way the government is trying to change things, drop it in behind,\n               orders in council, those kinds of things. This is a government that received, obviously, the code of silence — a number of my\n               colleagues have mentioned that before — from the journalists. Of course, the journalists\n               are one of the largest groups that is showing some real concerns about where this\n               bill is and their ability to be able to get the access they need to find out things\n               like limo rides and things like that. It's been mentioned many times. So this is why\n               we need the hoist motion to be able to go in and review and see if journalists, the\n               general public, have ease of access. Remember that the people's business is the people's business, and we've got to make\n               these bills as transparent and as flexible and available as possible for the general\n               public. At the end of the day, we may sound like At the end of the day, we may sound like here.... I know some of the members on the\n               other side — not particularly tonight, but earlier on — have been kind of critical\n               of our thoughts on this and asking about this hoist motion to be able to go in and\n               review this bill a little bit more thoroughly. But it's not rhetoric. There are some concerns there. Like we're saying, we're in\n               here doing the people's business ourselves on this side, and this is what we're hearing\n               out there in the general public — their concerns. They're bringing it forward to us,\n               and we just want to make sure we're doing the right thing here and doing our work. We're here to work. That's why we're here. What time is it? It's almost 12:30, and\n               we're in the House here, doing the work to make sure we get it right for the people,\n               the people that we represent out there in the general public. So now this same government is asking us to pass legislation that further weakens\n               access to information. We don't want to weaken. We want to strengthen. We want to\n               give people the ability to be able to come in and access their information. It's their\n               information. I think sometimes, as legislators, we might forget about that, but that's\n               the most important. This is their information, and it should be accessible. They're\n               the ones that pay the bills. They should know what they're buying. That, I think,\n               is really important. Hence the hoist amendment so that we can go in and review that information and make\n               sure that it's functioning for the people, the voters, the people that put us here\n               in this House. That's what we're here for. I had a little note here, just reiterating\n               again. It says: \"The voters are wanting this.\" They are holding us accountable to\n               make sure we get this right moving forward. Let's talk about the substance of the bill for a few minutes. The government will\n               try to hide behind language like \"efficiency\" and \"streamlining.\" Well, it seems a\n               little clear. In our debate on Bill 9, which we're not debating here tonight.... We're\n               debating the hoist motion. But back then, we talked about this. We brought a lot of\n               this forward and centre to make sure that we could try to get answers that particular\n               time through the debate. But now what we need is.... It looks like we're going to need some more time to analyze\n               and review this and have a much deeper dive into the bill to make sure that we get\n               this right, give the government a chance here. We're asking for six months on this\n               hoist amendment so that we can go in and make sure it aligns properly. We want to modernize. We want to make sure of things here. We want to make sure that\n               we're using the most modern and useful technology so people can have easy access into\n               their own information. But I think this is some doublespeak for some language that's\n               trying to shut it down. As a number of my colleagues have talked about, it's more\n               about misinformation or disinformation or shutting the information down than it is\n               about making it more accessible for the general public out there. When you strip everything away, what are we left with? Well, we're left with a bill\n               that replaces \"without delay\" with \"without reasonable delay.\" That's just one of\n               the changes they fundamentally want to change in here, one of the small amendments. Now, I think a few of my colleagues have gone on and talked about this. We need a\n               definition of what \"reasonable\" is. Without delay, without reasonable delay.... We're\n               not really sure what unreasonable delay is. I think we've had some great examples. Somebody gets up out of the wrong side of the\n               bed, and he decides he wants to reasonably delay somebody just because he's having\n               a bad day or something. That's not the way we should be looking at using this information\n               or anything like that. I'm really concerned. We need to really make sure the definition of \"unreasonable\"\n               is here. With the hoist motion, we're going to be able to go in and look at these\n               words, probably change the words up, make sure they're much tighter and people understand\n               what that work really is. It'll expand the ability to disregard requests at the whim of somebody that, once\n               again, has a bad day or something. They can disregard requests. There's no real strong\n               definition around that. Let's go in and take the time and define that a little bit\n               more tightly and make sure that we understand what disregarding requests really is. And it's here: \"Increase discretion to reject or limit access.\" Well, that's not very\n               good. I hear about limiting access and not allowing people access in countries other\n               than Canada. We're a democratic country. We should be able to have it fairly wide\n               open so that people can come and access their information. This hoist amendment will allow us to go in and fix that. Look at how we should be....\n               How do we limit this without really limiting access? Once again, the people's business\n               is the people's business. They should not be limited to the access that they have\n               on their information. As well, it fails to address the real And as well, it fails to address the real problems within the system. There are a\n               number of problems in the system. It has been slowed down in efficiency. The technology has been slow. The staffing has been limited. Those kinds of things.\n               So this really hasn't been a lot of reform, it looks like. It just seems to be that\n               instead of fixing the front end, they're doing it with the back end and doing some\n               things to shut access down and make it tougher to get in to see the information that\n               they have. When the B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association reviewed this bill, they\n               said it clearly: Bill 9 weakens access rights in British Columbia and expands government\n               discretion to refuse, not just limit, requests. This is the verdict from the experts, once again, not from us. Don't shoot\n               the messenger. So here we are. We're listening to the public out there, and then they're saying:\n               \"No, we're listening to the public out there.\" Our concern is, and why we're asking for this hoist motion, an amendment.... Is the\n               government listening to the people out there? We're listening, because that's why\n               we're here today. That's why we're sitting here at 12:30 at night discussing an amendment\n               to a bill to slow things down so the government can go and listen to the people. Again I ask: why the rush? Why are we rushing this bill through? Why is it so important\n               to get this bill through? I think we have some ideas why they might be doing this.\n               But if this bill is so good, if it truly improves the transparency and access and\n               is doing everything right, why not accept this hoist amendment? Why not take the six\n               months to really tweak it, fine-tune it and clean it up? Unless, of course, the government knows what this bill actually does. The purpose of this hoist amendment is simple. Stop, pause, fix, reintroduce. Right\n               now this bill does not fix the real problems. The real problem is not that citizens are asking too many questions. The real problem\n               is that government is not responding fast enough. The real problem is poor recordkeeping, for one reason or another. And the real problem is backlog. They have got\n               a tremendous backlog here that they are struggling with to get to. I have no idea what's happening in the back end there. But we need to slow down. We\n               have to look at, find out what the backlog is, find what's going on. The real problem is a culture that sees transparency as a burden, not a responsibility.\n               And instead of fixing those problems, this bill seems to be lowering the bar. So hence we get a hoist amendment in here so that we can have a look at that, maybe\n               spend some time looking at the processes, the systems and finding out if there are\n               ways we can improve them rather than with legislation that appears to be clamping\n               down on everything, restricting access, charging fees that some people quite frankly\n               don't have the money to be able to go, but they have legitimate reasons for coming\n               and seeking information about their government, their business. I want to take a moment to reflect on something that was said in this very chamber\n               not that many days ago, because it goes directly to the heart of why this hoist amendment\n               is not only justified but absolutely necessary. During the debate on another bill\n               in this House, a government member stood in this House and said something that, at\n               the time, I agreed totally with. And I still agree with him. He said, and I am paraphrasing the sentiment from him, that we should take our time,\n               that we should slow down, that we should make sure we get it right. He was talking\n               about a bill that was already before the House, and this is what the member of the\n               other House said. Listen to what he said. He said: \"We need to take our time. We need\n               to slow down and make sure it's right.\" That is what we're asking on this side of the House, on this particular bill. Slow\n               down. Let's make sure we get it right.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752281","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's a real pleasure to be here this evening. It reminds me of the old days when\n               we used to do all-nighters and things like that. So here we are, an all-nighter. It's\n               been a long time. So I'm really looking forward to this, to being able to speak to\n               this motion that we've got on the floor here, this hoist motion. Tonight I want to say strongly that I do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hygiene","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","label":"Hygiene","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f8fce0b5164f205dc9057e149bdd8c32464d014b3df5c78b3f4bc12dc9ebecb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e8694248de1cda3dafec1fd8c6b5bce887256ae50510e28fc235b4cdf9b56e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d373cb5a927eedae25a898c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017406,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to recognize both the importance of honouring those who serve and the\n               extraordinary organizations that support them when service takes its toll. First, I want to commend my colleague from Prince George–Valemount for her work in getting the month of November recognized as a time to honour first\n               responders. That initiative sends a clear and important message that this House understands\n               and values the sacrifice made every day by those who serve. In that same spirit, I want to speak about a place that brings that recognition to\n               life. A number of colleagues and I recently had the opportunity to visit Honour Ranch,\n               hence the pin. Just outside of Ashcroft, it is a place that leaves a lasting impression,\n               not only for what it is but for what it represents — a quiet, compassionate commitment\n               to those who have given so much in service to others. The reality is this. Service often comes with a cost that is not always visible. First\n               responders run towards crisis, towards danger, towards moments that most of us would\n               never choose to face. They carry not only the physical demands of their work but also\n               the emotional and psychological weight that comes with it. Too often, that burden\n               does not end when their shift ends. Honour House and Honour Ranch exist to meet that reality. Honour House provides a\n               place to rest, recover, and dignity for first responders and their families. Honour\n               Ranch builds on that mission, offering a long-term path to healing through connection,\n               nature and community. Together, they send a powerful message that those who serve\n               us should never have to heal alone. At the heart of this work is a story that underscores why it matters so deeply. Captain\n               Trevor Greene, a Canadian soldier, was critically injured while serving in Afghanistan.\n               His journey of recovery, supported by the unwavering care of his wife Debbie, became\n               a powerful symbol for resilience and helped inspired the creation of Honour House\n               so that others facing profound challenges would have a place to turn. Honour House and Honour Ranch are more than facilities. They are a promise — a promise\n               that we will stand by those who have stood for us — and they remind us that behind\n               every uniform is a person who deserves not only our respect but our care.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017406","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I want to recognize both the importance of honouring those who serve and the\n               extraordinary organizations that support them when service takes its toll. First, I want to commend my colleague from Prince George–Valemount for her work in getting the month of November recognized as a time to honour first\n               responders. That initiative sends a clear and important messag","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","label":"Heritage buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4229cb2f01db93ea84785d0fa2ed92007126a0046ee4f567a13abecb5b392052","29e902f729186f789e33670c71bd4f20d1da18c4504bf3f408e350abe544458f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cd511e5822f4223be7bcfd8e3e779e647bc84ea3b7c9230b4ce04db405f42f6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1601915d511fcad6ac4ea387","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036516,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tony Luck","venue":"Hansard","text":"One of the great privileges we have as being members of this House is being able to\n               stand and recognize friends and families for birthdays, anniversaries and, today,\n               graduations. My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very\n               proud of them — Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year division 1 softball scholarship My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very\n               proud of them. Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack, and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year division 1 softball scholarship at Stetson University\n               in Florida, so we're very proud of her. She's worked very, very hard for that and\n               we're looking forward.... The last time I spoke to her, she wants to do medicine, hopefully\n               become a doctor. So I said: \"That'd be great, we need you in B.C. So you get that,\n               that'd be fantastic.\" I'd also like to recognize our granddaughter Josephine Sheldon, who graduated last\n               year. She's been called on a mission from her church to go to Sapporo, Japan for 18\n               months. We're really proud of her as well. So thank you very much, everyone, for allowing me to introduce them and we're really\n               proud of them as grandparents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036516","member_id":"bc-mla-371","member_name":"Tony Luck","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"One of the great privileges we have as being members of this House is being able to\n               stand and recognize friends and families for birthdays, anniversaries and, today,\n               graduations. My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very\n               proud of them — Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95fa84e66d5bac7c0af3599e7c49f0426a7cb7eb692af96b9bf7352bd3ed3510"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["853590935a645ad712140e75e5409d4eec2c5f95f7c830949312f4ad3cbca943"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccb0ddf6bc841bb755994f58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317159,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317159","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","label":"Accident prevention","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6211a3d0412d2f23ea9716dc8dffda6c22dd2dfb27b146213fede531a621f43a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4e3e18553a9ec01c202cf08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317160,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today in strong defence of Budget 2026, a budget that protects services people\n               rely on, invests in our future and takes responsible steps to strengthen the province's\n               long-term fiscal health. At its core, this budget is about safeguarding what matters: health care, education,\n               child care, safe communities and economic opportunity. It's about ensuring that British\n               Columbians, whether young families, seniors, workers or people in crisis can count\n               on their government to show up for them. Protecting and strengthening public education. This budget continues our commitment\n               to an inclusive, high-quality education system. We're investing $634 million in new\n               funding for teachers and student services, recognizing that enrolment of students\n               with inclusive learning needs continues to grow. We are expanding the classroom enhancement fund by $167 million, ensuring more teachers,\n               more specialist educators As our communities grow, we must ensure our schools grow with them. That's why Budget\n               2026 provides $3.9 billion in capital funding for seismic upgrades and new schools,\n               especially in the fastest-growing parts of the province. These investments are not\n               optional. They are essential. They protect our kids, support our teachers and build\n               the schools our communities will rely on for generations. Supporting and stabilizing child care. Child care is a fundamental for families, for\n               equity and for our economy. Budget 2026 strengthens the ChildCareBC system with a\n               $330 million stabilization investment, ensuring that lower fees, new spaces and supports\n               built over the past eight years are not lost as federal-provincial negotiations continue.\n               During this stabilization period, the province is pausing enrolment on new providers\n               into the operating funding model and the $10-a-day program, but families and providers\n               currently in the program will see no changes. Recognizing schools as community hubs, we are also expanding child care on school\n               grounds. Budget 2026 dedicates $25 million — $5 million in capital funding and $20\n               million in operating funding — to create more before- and after-school spaces. Families need child care they can count on. This budget keeps that commitment. Strengthening health care across the province. Budget 2026 invests $2.8 billion over\n               three years to meet the growing demand for health services. Of that, $2.3 billion\n               expands system capacity, hiring more doctors, nurses and health care workers and advancing\n               new hospitals and health facilities across B.C. We are investing $131 million to expand intensive mental health and addictions treatment,\n               including additional involuntary care spaces for those who need the highest level\n               of support. And for nearly 1,800 families every year, access to in vitro fertilization will now be publicly funded, providing new hope to those trying\n               to start and grow new families. Federal contributions will also support seniors care and expand free medications for\n               diabetes and enhanced menopausal care. This budget advances a health care system that is more accessible, more resilient\n               and more responsive to the needs of British Columbians. Supporting children and youth with disabilities. Budget 2026 dedicates $475 million\n               to transform supports for children and youth with disabilities. Three major initiatives\n               will deliver more equitable, flexible and family-centred care. The B.C. children and\n               youth disability benefit will provide direct funding to about 12,000 families. The\n               B.C. children and youth disability supplement will offer up to $6,000 per year for\n               low-income and middle-income families. Community-based services will expand by 40\n               percent across the province, improving health care and behavioural supports. This transformation recognizes what families have been telling us for years. They\n               need a system that meets children where they are at, not the other way around. Building safer communities. Public safety remains a top priority. That is why Budget\n               2026 invests $139 million to reduce repeat and violent offending and to strengthen\n               access to justice. This includes $73 million That is why Budget 2026 invests $139 million to reduce repeat and violent offending\n               and to strengthen access to justice. This includes $73 million to support the courts,\n               sheriffs, Crown counsel, legal aid and the judiciary; $16 million for a new chronic\n               property-offending intervention initiative, targeting vandalism and shoplifting hurting\n               small businesses; $26 million to continue the repeat violent offending initiative,\n               which is already reducing police interactions and speeding up charge approvals; $24\n               million for specialized investigative and enforcement programs to help address street\n               disorder and connect individuals to needed services. The province continues working\n               with federal partners to combat extortion and organized crime. Building an economy that works for everyone. Budget 2026 helps position B.C. as the\n               economic engine for Canada, creating more opportunities for skills training. We're\n               investing $283 million to open the door for more British Columbians to train for high-demand\n               and skilled trades. This includes $241 million to double skilled trades funding over\n               three years, enhancements to the employer training grant to help double apprenticeship\n               seats by 2028, $30 million to expand specialized training in fields like engineering,\n               geology, computer science, biology and aerospace. Attracting investment and supporting natural resource industries. A new $400 million\n               strategic investments special account will help B.C. seize opportunities in clean\n               energy, forestry, mining and clean tech. Budget 2026 also invests in streamlining,\n               permitting and supporting forestry communities through targeted investments and relief\n               measures. Supporting B.C. businesses. Budget 2026 introduces a temporary 15 percent refundable\n               tax credit for manufacturing and processing investments, helping businesses modernize,\n               innovate and become more productive. We're extending tax credits for the shipbuilding\n               and ship repair industry through 2027. We're also beginning work on a potential patent\n               box regime to support innovation and intellectual property development. Updating the tax system responsibly. To maintain essential services while navigating\n               global uncertainty, Budget 2026 introduces measured tax changes. The first personal income tax bracket increases modestly, resulting in about $76 more\n               annually for the average taxpayer, offset for many by increases to the B.C. tax reduction\n               credit. Tax bracket indexing is paused from 2027 to 2030. Speculation and vacancy tax rates rise for foreign owners and untaxed worldwide earners.\n               Additional school tax rates for high-value properties. The PST base expands to include\n               several professional services, aligning B.C. with other provinces. These decisions are not taken lightly. They're taken to protect education and health\n               care and other core services, without deep cuts. Investing in infrastructure. Budget 2026 includes nearly $38 billion in capital projects,\n               ensuring B.C. continues building the schools, hospitals and transit systems we need.\n               This includes 17 major hospitals and acute care facilities, major transit expansions\n               like the Broadway subway and Surrey-Langley SkyTrain, 66 school upgrades or additions,\n               3,900 new post-secondary To keep projects sustainable and affordable, the province is adjusting timelines on\n               select long-term and infrastructure projects to manage cost pressures while maintaining\n               quality and safety. Increasing government efficiency. Budget 2026 continues the province's commitment\n               to a responsible fiscal management. We've already reduced spending by $400 million\n               through travel, hiring and operational efficiencies. Over the fiscal plan, we will\n               save an additional $3.5 billion through expenditure management. Finally, the public\n               sector will be reduced by 15,000 FTEs, primarily through attrition and voluntary departures,\n               while protecting critical front-line services in health, education and other essential\n               areas. In conclusion, Budget 2026 is responsible, it is forward-thinking, and above all,\n               it is centred on people. It protects what British Columbians value most, it invests\n               where our province needs it most, and it lays the groundwork for a stronger and more\n               resilient future. I'm proud to stand today and defend this budget, proud of what it delivers, proud\n               of the stability it provides and proud of the hope it offers for communities across\n               this province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317160","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today in strong defence of Budget 2026, a budget that protects services people\n               rely on, invests in our future and takes responsible steps to strengthen the province's\n               long-term fiscal health. At its core, this budget is about safeguarding what matters: health care, education,\n               child care, safe communities and economic opportunity. It's about ensur","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e377ed70829508cf852aa14ff1b8749ae8b919ffa68ce924b914c9fba0a0a4f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bb88fed4f2db3eaff3ad86d711d70bccd8972ffef5d26702de204cc4b7416c15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6a7f48ad595ede7bf1e24d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327996,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I wish to recognize an extraordinary group of people who embody the very best\n               of community service in British Columbia — the 59 volunteers of the Sooke Food Bank,\n               led with unwavering dedication by President Kim Metzger. These volunteers support residents from Port Renfrew and the paaʔčiidʔatx̣ First Nation through to East Sooke and the SC'IȺNEW̱ Nation and all points in between, ensuring that no one is left behind. Each month\n               they provide food hampers to approximately 700 households, families, seniors and individuals\n               who rely on support to get through difficult times. Additionally, the Sooke Food Bank strengthens many other community programs, such\n               as the Amber Academy's snack program, Meals on Wheels client support, Vital Vittles\n               Friday lunches, the school fresh fruit program, the Sooke Shelter bag lunch program\n               and the Hummingbird Place rough living food hampers, just to name a few. Their work helps keep the Juan de Fuca region nourished, supported and connected. They also provide opportunities for collaboration\n               with vital partners, nursing services, including a nurse practitioner, financial outreach\n               workers from the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction and even Paws\n               at Home pet food bank, which ensures that beloved companion animals are cared for\n               as well. It is my honour to recognize Kim and her many volunteers who give their time, heart\n               and energy to the Sooke Food Bank. Their compassion, humility and hard work demonstrate\n               what it truly means to serve community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327996","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I wish to recognize an extraordinary group of people who embody the very best\n               of community service in British Columbia — the 59 volunteers of the Sooke Food Bank,\n               led with unwavering dedication by President Kim Metzger. These volunteers support residents from Port Renfrew and the paaʔčiidʔatx̣ First Nation through to East Sooke and the SC'IȺNEW̱ Nation and all p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd79b1255583d5963aea054ce4203728b69e6139293df139b53d7d92cf00f1d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["208b81e04c5890817352323f05b304738f45728a386c08f860d5f0c7ece644d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3bfb71e9a6d3148d0f073f5f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327997,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"A few years ago, while I was an elected member of the district of Sooke council, after\n               having presented their latest audit results to council, KPMG staff suggested that\n               the district's finance department deserved an award for their work. So today I wish\n               to recognize and congratulate the district of Sooke staff on receiving the Canadian\n               Award for Financial Reporting. This is a national honour that reflects rigorous standards, transparency and unwavering\n               commitment to public service. I want to thank you for your professionalism, your care,\n               your dedication to serving Sooke with excellence. This award is a testament to your\n               extraordinary work, and I want to thank you for your professionalism, your care, your dedication to serving\n               Sooke with excellence. This award is a testament to your extraordinary work and is\n               truly well deserved.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327997","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"A few years ago, while I was an elected member of the district of Sooke council, after\n               having presented their latest audit results to council, KPMG staff suggested that\n               the district's finance department deserved an award for their work. So today I wish\n               to recognize and congratulate the district of Sooke staff on receiving the Canadian\n               Awa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e741542cc1d3b7866b0fe60c0f586c38a90089c72566ee436bc9eaac3dae2868"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fdf4fcc07e5acbdf9df2f4cd1d56652edbac7b0e2158ef717762663add6f313"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43687ac44d758396a4c50e16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360396,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to introduce the work of two extraordinary individuals from my riding.\n               A few weeks ago I had the pleasure of meeting these folks in my constituency office\n               in Sooke. The South Island Primary Care Society is a non-profit organization that in two years\n               has taken over three clinics that were at risk of closing and subsequently opened\n               two new clinics on the south Island and are now hosting over 30 primary care providers. The South Island Primary Care Society is proud to announce the Metchosin primary care\n               clinic as their seventh clinic and will support rural residents in Metchosin and the\n               Sc'ianew Nation. The clinic will bring three nurse practitioners and a pediatrician to the\n               community. Joining us in the House today are Alyssa Andres and Jill Benton. Alyssa is the executive\n               director of the South Island Primary Care Society, and over the past two years, she\n               has worked with physicians, nurse practitioners, municipalities and community partners\n               to open several new community-based clinics and has helped attach thousands of patients\n               to ongoing primary care. Jill is the medical director at the Metchosin primary care clinic as it prepares to\n               open its doors. Jill has spent the past 15 years working across a range of health\n               care roles, including a decade as a family and palliative nurse practitioner. Throughout their career, they have developed a deep commitment to team-based care,\n               working collaboratively with patients, families and colleagues across disciplines\n               to support community health. Please join me and give Alyssa and Jill a warm House welcome. Please join me and give Alyssa and Jill a warm House welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360396","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I want to introduce the work of two extraordinary individuals from my riding.\n               A few weeks ago I had the pleasure of meeting these folks in my constituency office\n               in Sooke. The South Island Primary Care Society is a non-profit organization that in two years\n               has taken over three clinics that were at risk of closing and subsequently opened\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7de4033bc9b29808585658d79edeca3d33e4e883df52d5f12d48d665f5d2851c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["246fec42bca12312b2cefd0be73e2154934918c1f69567e9a1bae255ffa5c510"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17ac369380e69ed864c11704","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415756,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415756","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bddca9e65b25c585587a370afabdfbf015a286ae2196bbf3f5a1a68fc49ddca0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b00274f5db430b73c8f8b70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415757,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize an extraordinary milestone for one of our province's most\n               enduring and impactful community institutions, the Victoria Foundation, which this\n               year celebrates 90 years of service, partnership and philanthropy in our region. Although it's going to be difficult to cover 90 years' worth of service in just two\n               minutes, I'll give it my best. Founded in 1936, in the midst of the Great Depression, by Burges Gadsden, the Victoria\n               Foundation began its life in the Rainbow Soup Kitchen on Pandora Avenue in Victoria.\n               Its establishment was formalized on April 1, 1936, through an act of this Legislature,\n               making it the second-oldest community foundation in Canada. The foundation's very first gift, a modest $20 donation from Fanny Gadsden in 1937,\n               set in motion nine decades of generosity that have shaped the capital region. The foundation's very first gift, a modest $20 donation from Fannie Gadsden in 1937,\n               set in motion nine decades of generosity that have shaped the capital region. Since\n               that time, the foundation has granted more than $406 million to support local organizations,\n               including over $31 million in 2025 alone. From its early grants in 1969, when it administered $22,000 in assets to its leadership\n               in programs such as vital youth, the Gadsden initiative and Victoria circle, the foundation\n               has worked tirelessly to foster engagement and philanthropy across generations. A cornerstone of its community leadership has been Victoria's Vital Signs report, an annual evidence-based snapshot of well-being in our region, now entering\n               a new chapter after its 20th anniversary last year. This work has inspired significant\n               initiatives, including the Civil Society report of 2018 and the recent Architects of Belonging report, which highlighted that registered charities now contribute $5.4 billion directly\n               into our local economy, a remarkable increase of $1.4 billion since the first report. Today is the foundation's official anniversary with the government of British Columbia,\n               and we look forward to community celebrations throughout 2026, culminating in its\n               major 90th anniversary event at the Victoria Conference Centre on September 26. For 90 years, the Victoria Foundation has helped build a region where everyone can\n               belong. Today we acknowledge their legacy, their leadership and their countless community\n               members who have contributed to this remarkable journey. Thanks to the organization's incredible leadership, we look forward with gratitude\n               and optimism to the next 90 years of impact.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415757","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize an extraordinary milestone for one of our province's most\n               enduring and impactful community institutions, the Victoria Foundation, which this\n               year celebrates 90 years of service, partnership and philanthropy in our region. Although it's going to be difficult to cover 90 years' worth of service in just two\n               minutes, I'll give it m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf0ad12a60d7d50cfc10ec649a1f5ce37bb48627866408428dee1cb32729d0cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79bf504446c12e8587c36dc7d4423d4179f33572c540f3ca62f0d7b0d5aaaf2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3664e4b56404cb735c11aea","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720412,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Many of us will still remember gathering around the TV with family to watch grainy\n               video imagery of the Apollo moon missions. Now, 54 years later, over the past week\n               or so, the appropriately named Artemis II mission came to a successful completion. For those who may not be aware, according to Greek mythology, Artemis was Apollo's\n               twin sister, a symbolic reflection of how times have changed over the past half century,\n               a fact that is evident in this chamber. Artemis II's capsule, Integrity, transported its crew of four, which included Commander\n               Reid Wiseman, Pilot Victor Glover, Mission Specialist Christina Notably, Glover, Koch and Hansen not only represent the first black person, the first\n               woman and the first Canadian to travel safely to the moon and back but, in doing so,\n               also set another historic milestone. As the ship completed its arc around the dark\n               side of the moon, it reached a peak distance of 252,757 miles from Earth, a distance\n               greater than any human had previously travelled. Friday evening, as I watched Integrity splash down into the Pacific Ocean, memories\n               of gathering around the TV with family to witness Apollo missions came flooding back.\n               During a later press conference, the day after their safe return to Earth, the crew\n               of the Artemis II mission each delivered emotional speeches as they described their\n               experiences. When Canadian astronaut Jeremy Hansen stood to reflect on his experience, he concluded\n               by gathering his fellow crewmates together and relayed to the audience: \"You're not\n               looking at us. You're looking at a reflection of yourselves.\" I suspect what he meant was the Artemis II mission signifies the beginning of a new\n               era in space exploration, and it is a true indication of the unlimited potential of\n               our species when we endeavour to work collaboratively and when we refuse to place\n               limits on our capacity for innovation. As we celebrate historic as well as recent triumphs, let us also continue to expand\n               the boundaries of our ingenuity as we strive toward a future better for all humankind.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720412","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Many of us will still remember gathering around the TV with family to watch grainy\n               video imagery of the Apollo moon missions. Now, 54 years later, over the past week\n               or so, the appropriately named Artemis II mission came to a successful completion. For those who may not be aware, according to Greek mythology, Artemis was Apollo's\n               twin sister, a symbolic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036504","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ocean floor","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037025","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036504","label":"Ocean floor","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037025","label":"Salt water","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","label":"Space exploration","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d522c2eb2aa1df5e695b55c398bbd14ed4a818473f4db47abd111c86d35311f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6a8afaf0270838856dd8c34797b87f176b7503f7f26b58231ed6a3b88a462e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space exploration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:132058","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f77fe6ee42e76b2254dc91dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720415,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Each year, the Sooke Lions Club brings the community together through one of their\n               many well-organized and much-loved events, Sookarama. It's a celebration of community\n               and a powerful reminder of what's possible when people come together with a shared\n               purpose. This year, Sookarama takes place this coming Saturday, April 18, and I can't think of a better way to\n               spend a weekend afternoon. Nearly 100 local non-profits, community groups and businesses\n               will be on site, each with their own booth, proudly sharing the incredible work they\n               do in the community of Sooke and the surrounding region. It's a chance to connect,\n               to learn and to be inspired. I've had the pleasure of attending Sookarama for the past two years, and both times, I've been truly inspired by the dedication\n               of volunteers, by the creativity of local organizations and the deep sense of care\n               that people have for one another in the community. Sooke is often referred to as the\n               \"Volunteer capital of Canada,\" and this event certainly lives up to that reputation. Sookarama isn't just about displays and information. It's about relationships. It's about discovering\n               a new cause to support, finding a way to get involved and strengthening the connections\n               that make the community so resilient and welcoming. As the MLA for Juan de Fuca–Malahat, I'm proud to share that my constituency office staff and I will once again have\n               a booth at this year's event. I warmly encourage you to stop by, say hello, share\n               your ideas and let us know what's on your mind. If you're looking for something meaningful to do this weekend, I invite you to drop\n               by the SEAPARC Rec Centre, located at 2169 Phillips Road, between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m.\n               to support local organizations and experience firsthand the heart of the community\n               at Sookarama. I hope to see you there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720415","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Each year, the Sooke Lions Club brings the community together through one of their\n               many well-organized and much-loved events, Sookarama. It's a celebration of community\n               and a powerful reminder of what's possible when people come together with a shared\n               purpose. This year, Sookarama takes place this coming Saturday, April 18, and I can't think of a better","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","label":"Forestry technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["022c7f357d18b483328090b7b65cfa792630871fdafc2418700c44d77896e6e3","45c44e50862dc89f40a7c9c40b65e57a3b6be201f3e1a554893caf979fad9729"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["406f6b37992b166254e64059e83e7a8c78347dcbd120c7e6dd554ac8184f79bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9695410fe22873f25129f2cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720419,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's with a heavy heart that I wish to acknowledge the untimely passing of an extraordinary\n               member of my community. Steve Wright arrived in Sooke as RCMP detachment commander\n               in 2009, where his exemplary leadership and his commitment to community quickly became\n               apparent. Steve was a fierce advocate for Cops for Cancer, which compelled him to\n               participate as a rider for Tour de Rock. After his retirement in 2013, Steve and his incredible wife, Ailsa, chose to establish\n               their home in Sooke, where they both became active participants in all things community.\n               As a well-respected member of the Sooke Lions Club, Steve was also a member of Royal\n               Canadian Legion Branch 54. In 2018, Steve played an instrumental role in bringing the RCMP's musical ride to\n               Sooke. And, of course, never one to sit idly by, Steve also served as honourary aide-de-camp\n               to British Columbia's Lieutenant Governor. Most recently all of us in this House will\n               remember him adorned in his RCMP regalia as he escorted Her Honour Wendy Cocchia up\n               and down this very aisle. Please join me as I offer my sincerest condolences to Ailsa, Steve's family and all\n               those whose lives he influenced in such a positive way. He will be greatly missed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720419","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's with a heavy heart that I wish to acknowledge the untimely passing of an extraordinary\n               member of my community. Steve Wright arrived in Sooke as RCMP detachment commander\n               in 2009, where his exemplary leadership and his commitment to community quickly became\n               apparent. Steve was a fierce advocate for Cops for Cancer, which compelled him to\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6dc65f0a7e2b6937fa25836","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721512,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise to speak in strong support of Bill 9 and the proposed amendments\n               to British Columbia's Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. This legislation\n               is about something very simple but very important: making government work better for\n               people while continuing to protect their privacy and their right to access information.\n               These amendments reflect the reality that the way people interact with government\n               has changed dramatically over the past decades, while the systems underpinning those\n               interactions have not always kept pace. Today's amendments are a thoughtful, balanced response to two urgent, interconnected\n               challenges: the need to modernize government service delivery through connected digital\n               services and the growing strain on our freedom-of-information system, which must remain\n               strong, fair and accessible to everyone. At their core, these changes are about efficiency,\n               transparency and respect — respect for individuals' time, respect for public servants\n               and respect for the principles of privacy and access that British Columbians value\n               deeply. The proposed amendments are not about sweeping for the sake of change. They're targeted,\n               measured and intentionally structured around three clear objectives: enabling connected\n               services, improving FOI efficiency and making minor but necessary clarifications and\n               operational fixes. Each of these categories responds directly to long-standing challenges\n               identified by the FOIPPA special committee, by public bodies across the province and\n               by the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner. This is not legislation\n               developed in isolation. It reflects years of practical experience, consultation and\n               oversight. Enabling connected services for British Columbians. Let me begin with the connected\n               services provisions because they go right to the heart of how people experience government.\n               Too often government still operates as a collection of silos. Individuals are asked\n               again and again to provide the same information to different ministries and programs\n               — their name, their address, their eligibility documents, their personal details.\n               This is frustrating, inefficient and unnecessary. A government that works as one. The connected services provisions in this bill will\n               help to enable government to operate as one unified system rather than as disconnected\n               parts. These amendments will allow public bodies to securely share information within\n               government on the people's behalf and with their permission These amendments will allow public bodies to securely share information within government\n               on the people's behalf and with their permission so that services are simpler, more\n               predictable and more streamlined. This is about building a system that reflects how\n               people actually live their lives, not how government is organized internally — a single\n               gateway, not a centralized database. Let me be very clear, because I know this concern will and has been raised. Connected\n               Services B.C. does not create a massive new centralized database of personal information.\n               That is simply not what this legislation does. Instead, Connected Services are designed\n               to use existing systems; facilitate secure, appropriate sharing; and reduce unnecessary\n               collection of information overall. The goal is not consolidation; it is coordination.\n               Public bodies will continue to hold only the information they need to deliver their\n               programs. What changes is that with appropriate safeguards, information can be shared where\n               necessary to deliver services more effectively and more respectfully. Strong privacy\n               protections remain in place. Privacy protection remains foundational. FOIPPA already contains strong security requirements, and this bill goes further by\n               allowing the minister to publish specific privacy and security requirements for Connected\n               Services, requiring notification to the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner\n               when a Connected Services provider is established and providing discretion for the\n               OIPC to review privacy impact assessments. These safeguards ensure that modernization\n               does not come at the expense of privacy. It strengthens it. Part 3, \"improving the freedom-of-information system.\" The second major category of\n               amendments focuses on the freedom-of-information system itself, and this is essential.\n               FOI is a cornerstone of democratic accountability. Access to information rights is\n               non-negotiable, but it is also true that our FOI system is under significant strain\n               — a system under pressure. Across this province, in ministries, municipalities, school districts and health authorities,\n               public bodies, are facing increasing volumes of requests, growing complexity, administrative\n               backlogs. These pressures affect everyone — applicants waiting longer for responses,\n               staff pulled away from other vital duties. Delays that undermine trust in the system.\n               Doing nothing is not an option. These amendments are designed to relieve pressure\n               without reducing rights. Part 4, \"clarifying requests and improving communication.\" One of the most practical\n               and sensible reforms in this bill concerns clarity in FOI requests. Under the current\n               act, applicants are already required to provide enough detail to allow public bodies\n               to identify records with reasonable effort. What these amendments do is formalize\n               and improve the process for achieving that clarity — a formal clarification process. The bill introduces a clear, transparent process for public bodies to seek clarification\n               when a request is unclear. This is not about forcing applicants to narrow their requests. Let me repeat that clearly. Applicants are not being forced to narrow their requests. This is about ensuring that the public body understands what records are being sought\n               and the applicant receives information that actually meets their needs. Ambiguous\n               requests help no one. They slow the process and create frustration for both sides.\n               Clear communication improves outcomes Stopping the clock, responsibility and transparency. Some have raised concerns about\n               allowing the 30-day FOI clock to pause while an applicant is clarifying their request.\n               This is not stalling, it is about honesty and fairness. Currently, the clock continues\n               to run even when a public body is waiting for clarification. This creates unrealistic\n               timelines and unnecessary tension. Under this amendment, timelines become more accurate,\n               applicants are encouraged to engage promptly, and public bodies can focus their efforts\n               on meaningful searches. This reform supports transparency, not delay. Addressing abusive and malicious conduct. One of the most sensitive but necessary\n               aspects of this bill is the amendment allowing public bodies to apply to disregard\n               requests in cases of abusive or malicious behaviour. Let me be absolutely clear about\n               what this does and what it does not do. Oversight remains with the OIPC. Public bodies\n               cannot unilaterally disregard requests. They must apply to the Office of the Information\n               and Privacy Commissioner, which retains full oversight and decision-making authority. These circumstances are described clearly, narrowly and explicitly. Rare but real\n               situations, examples include patterns of harassment, intimidation, threats to staff\n               safety. These situations are extremely rare, but when they do occur, they're highly\n               disruptive and divert resources away from processing legitimate requests. This amendment\n               protects public servants while preserving applicants' rights through independent oversight. Part 7, proactive disclosure of personal information. Another important improvement\n               is the ability to proactively disclose personal information back to individuals. Currently,\n               approximately 60 percent of FOI requests are for personal information. This bill introduces\n               mechanisms to improve access for individuals seeking their own information, reduce\n               unnecessary formal FOI requests, particularly support former children in care and\n               others who rely on these records. This is a compassionate, practical reform that improves\n               service while easing system pressures. Part 8, fees and access. There has been significant public discussion about FOI fees,\n               and I want to address this directly. This legislation does not change application\n               fees. At the same time, important exemptions remain. There's no fee for individuals\n               requesting their own personal information. Indigenous governing entities are not required\n               to pay an application fee. Evidence shows that the existing fee structure has reduced\n               broad cross-government requests, while encouraging more targeted requests without\n               reducing access for individuals. At the same time, government has expanded proactive disclosure, making frequently\n               requested information available without the need for an FOI request at all. That is\n               meaningful access. Consultation and oversight. These amendments were not developed behind closed doors.\n               The ministry has consulted extensively with the Office of the Information and Privacy\n               Commissioner, engaged with the FOIPPA special committee, responded to long-standing\n               operational concerns from public bodies. The ministry has consulted extensively with the Office of the Information and Privacy\n               Commissioner, engaged with the FOIPPA special committee and responded to long-standing\n               operational concerns from public bodies. The commissioner has indicated comfort with\n               the amendments, and oversight remains firmly in place. This balance between access\n               and service delivery is essential if the system is to work fairly for everyone. Part 10, a bill about people. At the end of the day, this bill is not about systems\n               or statutes in isolation; it's about people — people trying to access services without\n               repeating themselves endlessly; people seeking information that they're entitled to\n               receive; public servants working under increasing pressure; families, seniors, businesses\n               and communities relying on timely, accurate government service. This legislation helps\n               meet those expectations responsibly and transparently. In conclusion, these amendments do not weaken FOIPPA; they strengthen it. They do\n               not diminish access; they improve clarity, efficiency and fairness. They do not compromise\n               privacy; they modernize safeguards in a digital world. This bill reflects good governance,\n               careful reform that responds to real challenges, while preserving the values we hold\n               dear. For those reasons, I'm proud to support this legislation and urge all members\n               of this House to do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721512","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise to speak in strong support of Bill 9 and the proposed amendments\n               to British Columbia's Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. This legislation\n               is about something very simple but very important: making government work better for\n               people while continuing to protect their privacy and their right to access information.\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a89fdd0c352da490f35e3a1260efba51ba5d7244b9b4268dd86299ede653338"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3251866ebdcaf1be756bfd6aa6cb40429d264c61594546ccb11e0a08f6a0086"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9dc467db44a8e4f2524d7d4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721514,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to introduce a school group to the House. Above the Speaker are Dan Walkem,\n               Casey Clinton, Maureen Froud and Laura Stevenson. These are members of my graduating\n               class from 1981, and over lunch today, I made them promise that if I could get them\n               a nice warm House welcome, they wouldn't share too many secrets with anyone here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721514","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I want to introduce a school group to the House. Above the Speaker are Dan Walkem,\n               Casey Clinton, Maureen Froud and Laura Stevenson. These are members of my graduating\n               class from 1981, and over lunch today, I made them promise that if I could get them\n               a nice warm House welcome, they wouldn't share too many secrets with anyone here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efb80ec8aa76387591509d2626f91ab2a9d5aa2411d6a6ea795e344e83d40c99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-194be51c53168033930ee442","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721515,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to recognize the Clements Centre Society, a cornerstone of support in\n               the Cowichan region since 1957. Clements Centre provides essential, person-centred\n               services for people of all ages with developmental disabilities, strengthening families,\n               fostering independence and building inclusive communities. Through early childhood\n               supports, adult living programs and a deeply holistic approach to care, Clements Centre\n               helps individuals thrive with dignity. Their work has recently been recognized by Her Honour Wendy Cocchia, Lieutenant Governor of British Columbia, who has accepted the role of honourary\n               patron. Here with us today representing Clements Centre Society are Leslie Welland, board\n               chair; and Dominic Rockall, chief executive officer. Please join me in welcoming them to the chamber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721515","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I want to recognize the Clements Centre Society, a cornerstone of support in\n               the Cowichan region since 1957. Clements Centre provides essential, person-centred\n               services for people of all ages with developmental disabilities, strengthening families,\n               fostering independence and building inclusive communities. Through early childhood\n               su","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["911905a6982df1b6a75e9d1cd2c7caf8aaba95ae5d497d7fcfc06c456fc84d94"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1c311849482919e5e4503b8055265090fd63ac50f84eb348530810e7583dc77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43e9136d4ca2fb8461ee964a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729189,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"A few weeks ago I had the privilege of visiting the folks at the Victoria Hand Project\n               in their lab at UVic and to look at and learn about the work that they're doing. The Victoria Hand Project uses locally developed technology to make a global difference,\n               providing custom, functional upper-limb prosthetics to people in low-resource and\n               conflict-affected regions around the world. By equipping partner clinics with 3D printers,\n               software, hands-on training and ongoing support, they empower communities to produce\n               prosthetics at no cost to recipients, right where they're needed. At the same time, their work here at home, training the next generation of engineers\n               at their base at UVic, ensures that this impact is sustainable, innovative and proudly\n               rooted in Victoria. Please join me in welcoming chief technology officer Nick Dechev, CEO Michael Peirone, mechanical engineer Kim Arklie and business development officer Becky Hof.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729189","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"A few weeks ago I had the privilege of visiting the folks at the Victoria Hand Project\n               in their lab at UVic and to look at and learn about the work that they're doing. The Victoria Hand Project uses locally developed technology to make a global difference,\n               providing custom, functional upper-limb prosthetics to people in low-resource and\n               conflict-affecte","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","label":"Assistive technologies"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","label":"Assistive technologies","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["60d8deb85baf757a14ef19a2317c988e57cf4699b5ae8b6d4e802be66f9e0b52"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3035708834271f4f31d946963db218a4be0216b3c6fe45e1db32747b0828fb86"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35a4c63670d5404826e99bc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729191,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals and reports progress on the Ministry of Labour and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729191","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Mining and Critical Minerals and reports progress on the Ministry of Labour and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23ed37e543eb5e7c8b2bf19751e0a0a3441a50c6fddf76c7f22afd8ebd2b119e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-baf078f0294e9e99f2d43d41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752275,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I can't support this amendment for the reasons that have already been noted by my\n               colleague. Liquor is already allowed to be served in larger theatres, and what we're\n               talking about here is helping to keep our small businesses and our local small community\n               assets viable. On its surface, we're talking about liquor licensing, but at its heart, this is about\n               something much larger. It's about who we are as a society, what we value and how we\n               support the arts as essential infrastructure for healthy individuals and healthy communities. Independent movie theatres are not just places where films are shown. They're cultural\n               anchors. They're gathering places. They're often the last remaining shared public\n               spaces in small towns and rural communities, places where people of all ages can come\n               together to experience stories that reflect who we are, challenge what we believe\n               and expand how we see the world. When we talk about health in this House, we rightly spend a great deal of time discussing\n               hospitals, doctors and emergency rooms. But health is also about mental well-being,\n               connection, belonging and joy. The arts contribute profoundly to all of these. Research and lived experience tell us that engagement with the arts reduces isolation,\n               supports mental health, fosters empathy and strengthens social cohesion. A community\n               with vibrant arts and culture is a community where people feel more connected, more\n               resilient and more helpful. This is especially true in small communities where access\n               is limited. This is not a luxury; that's a public good. Yet when we look at how public\n               funding is distributed, it's very clear the arts are still too often treated as an\n               afterthought. Across the province and, frankly, across the country, we invest heavily and proudly\n               in sports infrastructure, arenas, stadiums, training facilities and event complexes.\n               We justify those investments quite rightly by pointing to community benefit, economic\n               spinoffs, public enjoyment and health. But when it comes to arts infrastructure, local\n               theatres, performance spaces, galleries and cultural venues, the scale of investment\n               is often dramatically smaller and the scrutiny far greater. We would never question whether a hockey arena should be allowed to sell alcohol during\n               a game attended by families. We understand that those revenues help keep the lights\n               on, subsidize youth access and make the entire operation financially viable. Yet today\n               small independent movie theatres, many of which operate on razor-thin margins, are\n               prohibited from doing exactly the same thing during mixed-age film screenings. That disparity matters. Independent theatres are struggling. Global inflation, rising\n               rent, increased utilities, changing distribution models and the long shadow of the\n               pandemic have all taken their toll. In many rural communities, the local theatre is\n               hanging on by a thread. When it closes, it won't come back. The original motion offers a practical, low-cost, commonsense tool to keep those theatres\n               alive. We're not talking about mandating alcohol service. We're not talking about\n               large corporate multiplexes. We're talking about giving small independent theatres\n               the choice, the same choice that music venues, performing arts centres We're not talking about mandating alcohol service. We're not talking about large corporate\n               multiplexes. We're talking about giving small independent theatres the choice — the\n               same choice that music venues, performing arts centres and sports arenas already have.\n               The other arts and cultural spaces rely on liquor sales to remain viable. Mixed-age\n               concerts, theatre productions and community festivals across British Columbia serve\n               alcohol responsibly under existing rules. They do this while prioritizing safety, compliance and community standards. There's\n               no reason independent movie theatres should be treated differently. That extra income\n               could mean the difference between closing their doors and staying open. It could mean\n               upgrading seats, improving accessibility, paying local staff a living wage or continuing\n               to offer affordable tickets for seniors and families.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752275","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I can't support this amendment for the reasons that have already been noted by my\n               colleague. Liquor is already allowed to be served in larger theatres, and what we're\n               talking about here is helping to keep our small businesses and our local small community\n               assets viable. On its surface, we're talking about liquor licensing, but at its heart, this is abou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a1a3092d9f17a5045f33492bd6eea92ce2e7d2439e972fbefc9f38b51720395"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ba662780a4587e9d28805d2bb2b9ef87c8b193a3d8d1c6571a47219882781b6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5d4cec665bf204a30e4a7d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752276,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have two introductions I'd like to make. One, I recognize the significance of this day, May 4, to all Star Wars fans, but in\n               my family it has a higher level of significance. It's my mom's birthday. If she were\n               with us today, she'd be celebrating her 100th birthday. So Mom, may the Fourth be\n               with you. Secondly, I have another. I'll get it....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752276","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I have two introductions I'd like to make. One, I recognize the significance of this day, May 4, to all Star Wars fans, but in\n               my family it has a higher level of significance. It's my mom's birthday. If she were\n               with us today, she'd be celebrating her 100th birthday. So Mom, may the Fourth be\n               with you. Secondly, I have another. I'll get it....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e42c70a7375b229966d3bb7d3186b2615d17fced6f807c3d7e3e82253d251a26","8998dcbcd50dabd9f2a3f10b5c06fc6d20fcf470a5d77b8e1931056a9db27658"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d10a901a29ce3d021dfb54221490d541a68307a544a70859b1c240d3e5b2764"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e32754ff8cc4abca0a86488","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752277,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the House I have my two constituency advisers, Aakriti Rai, who looks after\n               the Sooke office, and Sarah Dinsdale, who is present every day in the Cobble Hill\n               office. Thank you for being here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752277","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the House I have my two constituency advisers, Aakriti Rai, who looks after\n               the Sooke office, and Sarah Dinsdale, who is present every day in the Cobble Hill\n               office. Thank you for being here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9675545ebdfce1cf2312f96e30aebf074119d1076fdb84b69761107a5b04bef1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b33ebbfa1f1aaba1be3dbc47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036508,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"Accessibility is about fairness, dignity and ensuring that everyone can fully participate\n               in the life of our province. I'm speaking today to recognize National AccessAbility\n               Week, which takes place from May 31 to June 6. This week is both a celebration and a call to action. It reminds us that accessibility\n               is not the responsibility of any one group. It requires commitment and effort from\n               all of us. Real progress is only possible when all levels of government work collaboratively\n               with public and private organizations to remove barriers and create lasting change. An accessible British Columbia means playgrounds that every child can play in, websites\n               that anyone can understand and workplaces that everyone can access. It means public\n               spaces that are designed for everyone, when information is accessible to all and workplaces\n               strive to design for accessibility rather than inadvertently creating obstacles. Most importantly, we must listen to the voices of people with disabilities in the\n               spirit of \"Nothing about us without us.\" Lived experience must guide our decisions,\n               our policies and our actions. Across B.C., advocates, leaders and community members are showing us what is possible.\n               Their leadership is helping to create a province where everyone has the opportunity\n               to participate and truly thrive. I invite all members of this House to join me next week in recognizing AccessAbility\n               Week and in recommitting to the work of building a more inclusive British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036508","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Accessibility is about fairness, dignity and ensuring that everyone can fully participate\n               in the life of our province. I'm speaking today to recognize National AccessAbility\n               Week, which takes place from May 31 to June 6. This week is both a celebration and a call to action. It reminds us that accessibility\n               is not the responsibility of any one group. It ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc3e0385b195989d0ab5ac0c95cf227bc413858d6c8a0e22365dcb4b8d3b7332"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db99b0e167da67c65a186b8866436f914f6031fdcd0afc30342e1f0b35a4333d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6460b6c6b329349db79ed2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036509,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dana Lajeunesse","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to take a moment to recognize a friend of mine and to thank her for keeping\n               us hydrated for the last few months in the House. My friend and yours, Jeni Gunn,\n               who's standing just to the Speaker's left right now. This is her last day with us\n               in the House. She's moving on to a full-time position as safety officer in this building. So, thank you, Jeni.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036509","member_id":"bc-mla-372","member_name":"Dana Lajeunesse","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to take a moment to recognize a friend of mine and to thank her for keeping\n               us hydrated for the last few months in the House. My friend and yours, Jeni Gunn,\n               who's standing just to the Speaker's left right now. This is her last day with us\n               in the House. She's moving on to a full-time position as safety officer in this building. So, thank you","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drinking water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47475","label":"Drinking water","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f6ae1724e72ccff63080f1ecbd898bdab12c9e838702353dd3d9e56c0702dfd1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-95795daf32407f7453af5b45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317204,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, our thoughts and prayers are still with everyone affected in Tumbler Ridge,\n               and wishes for a very speedy recovery for the injured. I'd also like to thank the member for Prince George–Valemount for bringing forth Bill 231, Veterans and First Responders Month Act and, again,\n               to thank the member for her own service on our Canadian Navy. As a former mayor of a small town, I had the privilege of witnessing something extraordinary\n               in ordinary people — the quiet courage of those who choose to serve. Today I want\n               to speak about our first responders and our veterans and about why setting aside a\n               month in recognition of their service truly matters. In a small town, service is personal. When the pager goes off for our volunteer firefighters,\n               they're not responding to strangers; they're responding to neighbours, family and\n               friends. When a paramedic arrives on scene, they often know the family member or the\n               name before they enter the home. When police officers patrol our streets, they recognize\n               the children riding their bikes and the seniors enjoying the evening walk. Across Canada, organizations like the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and local emergency\n               services work tirelessly to protect our communities, but here, in towns like ours,\n               the protection often comes from volunteers, people who leave birthday parties, family\n               dinners and warm beds in the middle of the night to answer a call. They do not hesitate.\n               They do not ask who it is. They simply go. To our veterans, including those who've served under the Canadian Armed Forces, we\n               owe a debt that cannot be measured. They wore our nation's flag with pride and stood\n               in defence of freedom, democracy and peace. Many served far from home, and all have\n               made sacrifices. In small towns, our veterans are not distant figures in history books. They are the\n               neighbour at the hardware store. They are the grandparent at the Remembrance Day ceremony.\n               They are the mentor, the coach, the volunteer who continues to serve long after their\n               military career has ended. That is why dedicating a month of recognition is so important. A single day of thanks\n               is meaningful, but a month allows us to reflect more deeply. It allows our schools\n               to teach the next generation about service and sacrifice. It allows community groups\n               to host events, to tell stories and to share those experiences, and it allows us to\n               slow down long enough to truly appreciate what these individuals give, not just in\n               moments of crisis but every single day. Recognition is not about ceremony alone. It's about awareness. It's about reminding\n               ourselves that the safety and freedoms we often take for granted come at a cost and\n               that that cost is carried by real people we know personally. Throughout B.C., we understand the power of community. We show up for one another.\n               We rally around families in difficult times. We celebrate milestones together. Dedicating a month to our first responders and veterans strengthens our spirit. It\n               reinforces the value of duty, sacrifice and resilience and service to others. It tells\n               our young people that character matters. Dedicating a month to our first responders and veterans strengthens our spirit. It\n               reinforces the value of duty, sacrifice and resilience and service to others. It tells\n               our young people that character matters, that stepping forward matters, that giving\n               back matters. To our first responders: thank you for your bravery, your readiness and your compassion.\n               To our veterans: thank you for your sacrifice and your enduring example of leadership.\n               On behalf of everyone in this chamber, we see you, we respect you, and we thank you.\n               Throughout this month of recognition and every month that follows, we stand with you\n               and your family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317204","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Again, our thoughts and prayers are still with everyone affected in Tumbler Ridge,\n               and wishes for a very speedy recovery for the injured. I'd also like to thank the member for Prince George–Valemount for bringing forth Bill 231, Veterans and First Responders Month Act and, again,\n               to thank the member for her own service on our Canadian Navy. As a former mayor of a smal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdbde36fc330a4df1c31a8842ecbc754350bae9c36899eaf0e4fe5f4da35010c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af7af47d4bdde8a082772349833f94fcbf826da091ca837d72ee7aed7f4ee99f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f38e8ae5e0902426d00d4977","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317205,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"On the anniversary of four years of war in Ukraine and the incredible harm and","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317205","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"On the anniversary of four years of war in Ukraine and the incredible harm and","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","label":"War memorials","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30a54a3b3a80e66a363cfa858c2a60399901fedc4bd72b456ebb0e1f33fd34cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-916d4e9602ddcd18272302c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317206,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Talking about accountability and transparency, former NDP cabinet minister George\n               Heyman quietly had his special labour advisory contract extended for the fourth time\n               recently, already paying him over $145,000 last year. The Finance Minister last spring\n               promised us that Mr. Heyman was hired for a maximum of $58,000, and his contract was\n               ending July 31, 2025. Can the Premier explain why his contract was renewed four times in secret?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317206","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Talking about accountability and transparency, former NDP cabinet minister George\n               Heyman quietly had his special labour advisory contract extended for the fourth time\n               recently, already paying him over $145,000 last year. The Finance Minister last spring\n               promised us that Mr. Heyman was hired for a maximum of $58,000, and his contract was\n               e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5fd898c7f5f0194701b8cb5888bb881a8062f64a1669ff046a9946265de6c569"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7022bd6e359038509e2b55414e7d24f7f8f9adbd5853f6db0e3f8fee1ddf639e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de36d589db731af3a0aa35a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317207,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Sorry for the.... Great news. My youngest just gave birth to a baby boy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317207","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Sorry for the.... Great news. My youngest just gave birth to a baby boy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["357f82eaa3f0256f6d1c473009a3d838eae1ab74ade3d9ab0ad4085fc6a892d5","9119f778e01820874908f273f7fcca95f2b34714aba64711fbe54299009fdae4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1845ae2aed4fb05307d6cb7642b6b94f3c85dad481f9a38fbb3070c03491e31"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1e78e48ffaefb3ffa783fcb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317208,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"My youngest daughter, Nicole, and husband, Connor, welcomed their second child and\n               first son and grandson to the extended family, Kellen John Robert Dollahan, 8 pounds,\n               15 ounces. Please join me in congratulating Nicole, Connor and big sister Sophie.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317208","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"My youngest daughter, Nicole, and husband, Connor, welcomed their second child and\n               first son and grandson to the extended family, Kellen John Robert Dollahan, 8 pounds,\n               15 ounces. Please join me in congratulating Nicole, Connor and big sister Sophie.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be34d142067d172e909c8effc405c0d3d94f3171b257fa216d0345a612fa8c2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3eb0eba104822ee7ecb6521a48dcac6c30e4dfb4d08614cab4aa22560a2d470"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-239bea8cda07094a0e07f92a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328050,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Peter Lister, the executive director of the B.C. Truck Loggers Association, has said:\n               \"I've never seen it this bad. I've been involved in the forest industry for 35 years,\n               and it's really on the edge of collapse.\" Under this government's watch, just in the last three years alone, 16 sawmills and\n               pulp mills have been closed, 15,000 jobs have been lost. And a direct drop in government\n               revenue of over $1.5 billion.... Can the minister explain to union workers that are here today in this chamber and\n               workers around B.C. how mill closures are protecting workers and their paycheques?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328050","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Peter Lister, the executive director of the B.C. Truck Loggers Association, has said:\n               \"I've never seen it this bad. I've been involved in the forest industry for 35 years,\n               and it's really on the edge of collapse.\" Under this government's watch, just in the last three years alone, 16 sawmills and\n               pulp mills have been closed, 15,000 jobs have been lost. A","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8f17d888570ac8187db293a765439692deba41f5d5906e9e1607303b049ec62"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["983a16ea46f14bc182f43e42c6c8b2d7b575339186228644ec00d9a7a5a2e937"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42eb84f9f240955743003141","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361020,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"British Columbia's forest industry has long been one of the pillars of our provincial\n               economy. For generations, forestry has provided stable employment, supported rural\n               communities and helped build the economic foundation of this province. From communities like Prince George, Quesnel, Williams Lake and Kamloops, the forest\n               sector has From communities like Prince George, Quesnel, Williams Lake and Kamloops, the forest\n               sector has supported families for decades. These are communities where forestry is\n               not simply an industry, it's the economic heartbeat of a region. But today that heartbeat is weakening. Across British Columbia we are witnessing a\n               troubling pattern of mill curtailments, permanent closures and layoffs. Families who\n               have worked in forestry for generations now face uncertainty about their future. Entire\n               communities are feeling the economic consequences. In communities such as Houston and Merritt, 100 Mile House and Crofton, mill closures\n               have had devastating ripple effects. When a mill shuts down, it impacts far more than\n               the workers inside that facility. Truck drivers, logging contractors, equipment operators,\n               mechanics, small business owners and their workers all suffer the loss. And that ripple\n               spreads across the entire community. And yet many in this industry feel that their concerns have not been heard by this\n               current government. Instead of providing certainty and stability for the forest sector,\n               government decisions have created growing uncertainty. Policy announcements have often\n               come without meaningful consultation with the workers and communities that depend\n               on forestry for their livelihoods. Companies need long-term certainty to invest in\n               modern mills, new technology and workforce stability. Unfortunately, the regulatory\n               environment today has made those investments far more difficult. We are also facing serious challenges relating to timber supply. The impacts of the\n               mountain pine beetle epidemic and the increasing severity of our wildfire seasons\n               have dramatically reduced fibre in many parts of B.C. Yet rather than implementing\n               strong and proactive forest management strategies, this government has too often allowed\n               uncertainty and delay to dominate the conversation. Active forest management, including responsible harvesting, reforestation and improved\n               wildfire mitigation, is essential to maintaining a sustained forest sector. Instead,\n               industry and communities are often left navigating lengthy permitting processes and\n               unclear policy direction. Forest workers are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for common sense.\n               They're asking for a government that understands that forestry is not just an industry,\n               it's a way of life in British Columbia. The reality is that forestry remains one of B.C.'s most important economic drivers.\n               It supports thousands of jobs and generates billions of dollars in economic activity\n               every single year. Our lumber producers and products are recognized around the world for their quality\n               and sustainability. British Columbia already has some of the highest standards in\n               the world, but current policies continue to push investment away from the province\n               and we risk losing more mills, more jobs and more opportunities for our communities. B.C. deserves better. Forestry helped build this province. It built our towns, our\n               infrastructure, our economies. People that work in this industry deserve to know that\n               their government supports them and understands the importance of their work every\n               single day. At the end of the day, we are left with a very clear choice. We can either have significant\n               change in forest policies from this government, policies that support timber supply,\n               investment and active forest management, or British Columbians may soon be calling\n               for something else: a change in government. Because if this government cannot recognize\n               the importance of this important industry and the communities that depend on it, then\n               it is those communities that will ultimately demand the leadership that will. Forest\n               workers, their families and communities across British Columbia deserve better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361020","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"British Columbia's forest industry has long been one of the pillars of our provincial\n               economy. For generations, forestry has provided stable employment, supported rural\n               communities and helped build the economic foundation of this province. From communities like Prince George, Quesnel, Williams Lake and Kamloops, the forest\n               sector has From communities li","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e27449e0dfe5a47fb461e911d5ba96fa3bb29dea0e75a5f6b56c44e76e3d7e2f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11bc8c5f631bb74d44d638bdd2fe2ba59c4aaaac67157ca61fbdf9b749a67479"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b9bb70bc6089e2ad0cc6b9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361021,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"This budget hurts seniors, cuts funding for autistic children and expands the PST,\n               pulling more money out of the pockets of businesses and hard-working British Columbians.\n               An economic","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361021","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This budget hurts seniors, cuts funding for autistic children and expands the PST,\n               pulling more money out of the pockets of businesses and hard-working British Columbians.\n               An economic","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d54f95d89944324e91366e65a2c6c679165b11e7db9ec6d90709a75221253841"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c72380d70c21ab4af77246849b570b78d77e22f084f9701c3488d58ec246767"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-297fa904eca1ec82ccad414f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415824,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise today in support of bill M201, clean water sovereignty act. Water is\n               not a resource in British Columbia. It is the lifeblood of our communities, our economy,\n               and our environment. From the smallest rural towns to our largest cities, access to\n               clean, reliable water is not optional. It is essential. And yet, for too many British\n               Columbians, especially in rural and remote regions, that certainty has not always\n               been guaranteed. This bill fixes that. From a Conservative perspective, bill M201 speaks directly to a principle we firmly\n               believe in, that critical resources, especially something as fundamental as water,\n               must be protected, managed responsibly, and kept firmly under the control of the people\n               of British Columbia. That is what sovereignty means. It means decisions about our\n               water are made here in this province with the best interests of British Columbians\n               in mind, not influenced by outside pressures, not compromised by short-term thinking\n               and left not vulnerable to mismanagement. Clean water sovereignty is about three key\n               things: protection, accountability, and local control. First is protection. British Columbia is blessed with abundant water resources, but\n               abundance does not equal invincibility. We have seen growing pressures from population\n               growth, industrial demand, climate variability, and aging infrastructure. Without\n               proper safeguards, even a water-rich province like ours can face shortages, contamination,\n               or inequitable access. Bill 201 recognizes that reality and puts forward a framework\n               to ensure that our water remains clean, safe, and secure, not just for today but for\n               generations to come. Second is accountability, because too often when things go wrong with water systems,\n               whether it's contamination, boil water advisories or infrastructure failure, communities\n               are left asking: \"Who is responsible?\" This bill strengthens oversight and clarifies\n               responsibility. It ensures the government cannot simply pass the buck and that there\n               are clear expectations on how water resources are managed, monitored and protected.\n               That matters deeply to the people that we represent because when it comes to water,\n               there is no room for uncertainty. The third is local control. One of the greatest frustrations we hear, especially from\n               rural and Indigenous communities, is that decisions affecting their water are often\n               made far away without adequate consultation or understanding of local conditions.\n               Bill M201 moves towards a more locally responsible model. It acknowledges that communities\n               must have a stronger voice in how their water is managed. From a Conservative perspective,\n               that is exactly the right approach. We believe in empowering communities, not sidelining\n               them. We believe that those closest to their resource are often best positioned to\n               protect it. Let's also be honest about the economic dimension of it. Clean water is not only a\n               public health necessity, it's a cornerstone of our economies. Our agriculture sector\n               depends upon it. Our forestry and resource industries rely upon it. Our tourist industry\n               is built on it. Protecting water is not a conflict with economic growth. It is a prerequisite\n               for it. Bill M201 strikes that balance. It reinforces that we can protect our natural\n               resources while still supporting responsible development and job creation. That is\n               a kind of practical, balanced approach that British Columbians expect from us. There is also broader principle at play. Around the world we are seeing increased\n               pressure on our water resources, whether through scarcity, privatization or geopolitical\n               tension. British Columbia must be clear that our water is not for exploitation and\n               is not for mismanagement. It is a public trust. Bill M201 sends that message clearly\n               and firmly. It says that we take responsibility for our water, that we will safeguard\n               it and that we will ensure it remains accessible and protected for future generations. Now with any legislation, there's always room for refinement. As we continue to listen\n               to stakeholders, to communities and to experts, this bill will hopefully be able to\n               move forward. Let's lose not sight of the picture. This bill is a step in the right direction. It reinforces conservative values, which\n               are responsible stewardship, local empowerment and government accountability. I encourage\n               all the members in this House to support bill M201 because it protects our water,\n               it protects our people, it strengthens our accountability, it strengthens our I encourage all the members in this House to support M201 because it protects our\n               water, it protects our people, it strengthens our accountability, it strengthens our\n               trust, and it also stands up for the sovereignty over our most vital resources. We\n               stand up for our water, and we stand up for the future of British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415824","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I rise today in support of bill M201, clean water sovereignty act. Water is\n               not a resource in British Columbia. It is the lifeblood of our communities, our economy,\n               and our environment. From the smallest rural towns to our largest cities, access to\n               clean, reliable water is not optional. It is essential. And yet, for too many British\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","label":"Water conservation","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d995d7b9c754b7e0f346d51e1ab99b6a7448f911434b0414fdf23a27755b270e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["25e98c4ea240638993a163f1e15aebfe3bd14fdfa59cc086277594dc50740e21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f49b05f1fe430a8556cb0e7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415825,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we gather to celebrate Easter, there's one special guest who always seems to hop\n               into our hearts this time of year. It's the Easter Bunny. Now, the Easter Bunny may not say much, but the message he brings is simple. He shows\n               up quietly, often before the sun rises, leaving behind small surprises, colourful\n               eggs, sweet treats and a little bit of magic for children and families to discover\n               together. Maybe that's the lesson in it all. The Easter Bunny reminds us that joy doesn't have\n               to be noisy and kindness doesn't have to be complicated. Sometimes it's the smallest\n               gestures, the ones done quietly, that mean the most. In Barriere we're fortunate to have a tradition that brings that spirit to life every\n               year, the annual Easter egg hunt hosted by the Barriere Lions Club. This event is\n               more than a hunt for chocolate eggs. It's the laughter of the children, the excitement\n               of the search and families coming together to share in those special moments. It's\n               what community is all about. It doesn't happen without effort. It takes volunteers, time and dedication. So I want\n               to sincerely thank the Barriere Lions Club and everyone involved for continuing this\n               wonderful 50-year-plus tradition and creating memories that will last a lifetime. Easter is a time of renewal. After a long winter, we begin to see the signs of spring\n               — longer days, warmer weather and a new life all around us. It reminds us that no\n               matter the challenges we face, there is always hope and a chance Because Easter is a time of renewal. After a long winter we begin to see the signs\n               of spring, longer days, warmer weather and a new life all around us. It reminds us\n               that no matter the challenges we face there's always hope and a chance for a fresh\n               start. And just like the Easter bunny, each of us can bring a little light into someone\n               else's day through a smile, a kind word or a helping hand. When the children search for the eggs and families gather, let's also think about\n               what we can give, not just what we can receive. Because in the end, the Easter bunny\n               isn't just about chocolate and candy. He's about kindness, community and bringing\n               joy to others. Happy Easter everyone, and safe travels to all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415825","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"As we gather to celebrate Easter, there's one special guest who always seems to hop\n               into our hearts this time of year. It's the Easter Bunny. Now, the Easter Bunny may not say much, but the message he brings is simple. He shows\n               up quietly, often before the sun rises, leaving behind small surprises, colourful\n               eggs, sweet treats and a little bit of magic ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","label":"Weather forecasts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","label":"Weather","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0763a7a9571ce81e50d5d9f465b00081d0bb4181ceab9ff8edb8b30ce35f3f32"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f7f2c741d35e971a27e8ee9762cb9e35a77c4fd3caceb004db25883ba8dc03f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab55f0b0de84c36774feb823","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415826,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"With regret, I want to announce the passing of Ted Arkell from Campbell River. Ted spent over 50 years in the forest industry, working with the B.C. forest service,\n               Evans Products and Ainsworth Lumber in Lillooet, B.C. before purchasing Dyer Logging\n               Ltd. in Campbell River in 1989. Ted served on many forest industry boards, including the Truck Loggers Association,\n               later serving as president, working tirelessly for the betterment of the forest industry.\n               Ted was an avid boater who enjoyed fishing with his family and his friends. We extend our regrets about Ted's passing to his wife and his family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415826","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"With regret, I want to announce the passing of Ted Arkell from Campbell River. Ted spent over 50 years in the forest industry, working with the B.C. forest service,\n               Evans Products and Ainsworth Lumber in Lillooet, B.C. before purchasing Dyer Logging\n               Ltd. in Campbell River in 1989. Ted served on many forest industry boards, including the Truck Loggers Association,\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06b0ab9789910a3f91d0a96ba7dafad0e4ef517b1cd593bc554f0a5259cd049f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a5a938ce1793749a0eb908ac02c7752c8e81f29c251f7568f06be9530299c02"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-868102dfd11cd577c63a3f4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415827,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to bring it to everyone's attention that the Williams Lake Mustangs were\n               fortunate enough — and good work on their part, hard work — to be able to beat the\n               Kamloops Storm in their series four straight. On behalf of MLA Milobar and myself, we'd like to congratulate the Williams Lake Mustangs. Good luck on going through the playoffs with your next opponent in Princeton. On behalf of MLA Millibar and myself, we'd like to congratulate the Williams Lake\n               Mustangs. Good luck on going through the playoffs with your next opponents in Princeton. From our perspective, and from the House, can we give them a great round of applause\n               for their win and carrying on in the playoffs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415827","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to bring it to everyone's attention that the Williams Lake Mustangs were\n               fortunate enough — and good work on their part, hard work — to be able to beat the\n               Kamloops Storm in their series four straight. On behalf of MLA Milobar and myself, we'd like to congratulate the Williams Lake Mustangs. Good luck on going through the playoffs with your next opponent in P","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ddfa3f22f67ffc49c1d6036","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720579,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the Forests Minister for his opening remarks. And yes, I am the designated\n               speaker. Seeing that we have a few minutes, I would certainly like to be able to start\n               our presentation. First off, the minister brought up a lot of really good points in moving our forest\n               industry forward when it comes to increases in reforestation, commercial thinning, wildfire fuel reduction, opportunities\n               for value added.... I can go through the whole list of what this is supposed to do. But Bill 14.... I've labelled on the very top of it \"unintended consequences,\" because\n               that comes to the crux of this, and we'll be able to get into that opportunity when\n               we get to committee, that many of the improvements that the minister is speaking of, of what their vision\n               of BCTS should be are already available through policy and regulation. There doesn't need to be any laws changed other than the ability of BCTS to spend money in their\n               existing budget, as the minister said. In his words, that is really the only reason\n               you would have to change the law — for that. I mean, we've got requirements in this bill when we talk about more stringent regulations.\n               Well, we've already got a bible this thick when we have a BCTS license that is purchased.\n               So now it's going to be this thick? Honestly, what is really the reasoning behind many of the things that are in this\n               bill that are not attached to just the requirements of the government to be able to\n               spend money on commercial thinning? The minister mentioned that BCTS has been successful of a grand total of three commercial\n               thinning projects so far that were bid successfully.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720579","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thank the Forests Minister for his opening remarks. And yes, I am the designated\n               speaker. Seeing that we have a few minutes, I would certainly like to be able to start\n               our presentation. First off, the minister brought up a lot of really good points in moving our forest\n               industry forward when it comes to increases in reforestation, commercial thinning, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036985","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036985","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Road construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036985","label":"Road construction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["35762d81772dfd0874f5cf7f022a1f1f94127b50cf9ceaadf2a8a31bb43e9458"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3c5fed4c617a9c46a19260d3c747401214dc30cb3c0cb9b49626fd795955558"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8e4fd679f0df2336528231d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720589,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome the entire board of the Truck Loggers Association, members that\n               were here earlier today. I know that they met with the Minister of Forests. They met\n               with our caucus. I'd like to recognize their new president, Bob Marquis, and the general\n               manager, Peter Lister. Would the House please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720589","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome the entire board of the Truck Loggers Association, members that\n               were here earlier today. I know that they met with the Minister of Forests. They met\n               with our caucus. I'd like to recognize their new president, Bob Marquis, and the general\n               manager, Peter Lister. Would the House please make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","label":"Photography","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10509a80ab5e3c3cce452b8de0e661e8aa00d9f8e247e7f00851904703a24efa","e4e9aa6426d817acd48a60c6ea9adc4e6a7e2144195c7d7b06c6efd59bbc313c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ec2e280950fbd8f846a7936d5a749c3507a673a2a1fbaca5a6ca093dbde0ca6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5a0c686222474346608bb6f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721685,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, legislation that strikes at the very core of our\n               democratic system, the public's right to know. At the end of the day, everything we\n               do in this legislature is supposed to stand on a simple principle. It's on the record.\n               It's accountable. And when it must be confidential, it's conducted in camera, with\n               clear rules, clear justification and clear limits. That balance between transparency\n               and necessary confidentiality is what sustains public trust. Bill 9 disrupts that balance. It does so in a way that should concern every member\n               in this House and every British Columbian we represent. Freedom of information is\n               not just another policy tour. It is the mechanism that ensures government remains\n               accountable to the people. It's how citizens verify what we say. It's how journalists\n               uncover what is not said. It's how democracy functions beyond election day. Without information, accountability becomes performative, transparency becomes selective\n               and trust begins to erode. In this Legislature, we understand the importance of being on the record. Debates\n               like this one are in public. Votes are recorded. Statements are scrutinized. And rightfully\n               so, because we are accountable to the people of British Columbia. And now, there are times when matters must be discussed in camera — sensitive negotiations,\n               legal considerations, personal privacy — but those instances are the exception, not\n               the rule. They are structured, they are justified, and they are not meant to become\n               a blanket approach to governance. What Bill 9 risks doing is shifting that balance,\n               moving more and more decision-making, more and more information into spaces that are\n               effectively out of reach — not formally in camera, as we understand it here, but functionally\n               just as closed. This bill is presented as modernization, as efficiency, as administrative reform,\n               but when we examine the details and more importantly, when we compare it to what is\n               already happening in practice, a different picture emerges: more barriers to process;\n               more discretion for government decide what is released; more delays; and more opportunities\n               to say, \"no\" or \"not yet.\" When you combine that with increased NDAs, heavily redacted\n               documents and declining bureaucracy transparency, the concern becomes clear. We are\n               not strengthening access to legislation or information. We are weakening it. Before we even consider the impacts of this bill, we must acknowledge the current\n               state of the system. Because British Columbians are already experiencing serious challenges\n               when it comes to accessing information: freedom-of-information requests that come\n               back with pages almost entirely blacked out; documents where the context is removed,\n               the meaning lost and the purpose defeated; timelines that stretch far beyond what\n               is reasonable, where information arrives long after decisions have been made, and\n               consequences have taken hold; and increasingly, a sense that the system is not designed\n               to provide answers but to manage them. Bill 9 does not exist in isolation. It builds on this reality, and that's what's becoming\n               so concerning. One of the most troubling trends we're seeing is in the growing use of non-disclosure agreements in the areas of public interest. Let's be clear. NDAs can serve a legitimate purpose in specific, limited contexts.\n               But their expanding use in government-related matters raises serious questions. Because\n               when NDAs are applied too broadly, they prevent information from even entering the\n               public domain. They restrict what participants can say, they limit what can be scrutinized,\n               and they create an environment where accountability is constrained before it even\n               has a chance to operate. Public business should not be shielded behind private agreements, yet this is increasingly\n               what we see with this government. Bill 9 does nothing to address this trend, and if\n               anything, it risks reinforcing it. Let's talk about redactions because this is where the rubber hits the road for many\n               British Columbians. A freedom-of-information system is only as good as the information\n               it provides, and right now too often what people receive is not information, it's\n               fragments — pages covered in black ink, sections removed entirely, key details withheld.\n               And at some point, we must ask: when does redaction stop being about protection and\n               start being about avoidance? Because when entire sections of documents are removed,\n               the public is left with more questions than answers. And this is not about transparency.\n               This is obstruction. Bill 9 does not restore confidence in our system. It risks entrenching the very practices\n               that are currently undermining it. Another growing issue is the paucity within the bureaucracy itself. Decisions are\n               increasingly made at levels that are difficult to access, difficult to understand\n               and difficult to challenge. Processes rarely lack clarity. The rationale is often\n               not disclosed, and responsibility becomes diffused across departments and agencies.\n               So when something goes wrong, the question becomes: who made that This is not acceptable. Transparency is not just about releasing documents. It's about\n               understanding decisions. And right now, that understanding is slipping away. I move to adjourn the debate and reserve my place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721685","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, legislation that strikes at the very core of our\n               democratic system, the public's right to know. At the end of the day, everything we\n               do in this legislature is supposed to stand on a simple principle. It's on the record.\n               It's accountable. And when it must be confidential, it's conducted in camera, with\n               clea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["208616caba2625f8b74da978d754b3e83e7ee787361ee79566107f98548bc0da"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9dc5e232b1f6451c4d0c83f0f5503d394b38f56b3af0caf1bfa228b6ca51b42"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-041e5ec27bba4c53b488e222","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721687,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning our caucus welcomed representatives from the Washington state Department\n               of Natural Resources and also representatives of the Truck Loggers Association. The Department of Natural Resources in Washington has many divisions, including forest\n               practices, forest resources, aquatic conservation, recreational resources and wildfire\n               management. Will the House please make them feel welcome in British Columbia and in this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721687","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This morning our caucus welcomed representatives from the Washington state Department\n               of Natural Resources and also representatives of the Truck Loggers Association. The Department of Natural Resources in Washington has many divisions, including forest\n               practices, forest resources, aquatic conservation, recreational resources and wildfire\n               management. Wil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5ef5797d2c1547d9dceec199d68bbce923a33c37c129010f3c38afbe446a577"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d06ebcdf038fc6c3a9bb832a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729459,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we turn the page to May here in British Columbia, we step into a season that reflects\n               the very best of our province. Hard work, community spirit and a deep connection to\n               the land we call home. From the coastal communities of Vancouver Island to the fertile\n               orchards of the Okanagan Valley, from the busy streets of Vancouver to the resource\n               towns across the north, May is the time when British Columbians come together and\n               get back to what matters most — community, opportunity and the great outdoors. As the days grow longer and the weather warms, people across the province head outside.\n               Parks and trails come alive again. Families are hiking, biking, camping and enjoying\n               everything this province has to offer. Whether it's exploring Garibaldi Provincial\n               Park, cycling along the Galloping Goose Trail in Victoria or spending a quiet moment\n               on one of our many lakes, May reminds us why British Columbia is truly one of the\n               most beautiful places in the world. May also marks the beginning of a busy and important season for all our local economies.\n               Tourism operators, small businesses and hospitality workers begin to see an increase\n               in activities as visitors return and British Columbians travel within our own province.\n               This is a critical time, especially for small, family-run businesses that rely on\n               the spring and summer months just to stay afloat. The May long weekend in Canada known as Victoria Day is the unofficial start of summer.\n               Campgrounds fill up, highways are busier than normal, and communities host events\n               that bring people together — markets, parades and local festivals that showcase the\n               unique character of each region. Agriculture is also front and centre during the month of May. Farmers across the province\n               are in the fields planting crops that will sustain our communities and support our\n               economy. In regions across B.C. Agriculture is also front and centre during the month of May. Farmers across the province\n               are in the fields planting crops that will sustain our communities and support our\n               economy. In regions across B.C., this is a critical time of year, one that underscores the importance of protecting farmland and supporting\n               those who feed our province. We also observe Emergency Preparedness Week, an important reminder for all British\n               Columbians that our province has faced significant challenges in recent years, from\n               wildfires to floods, and preparation is not optional. It is essential. This week encourages\n               families, businesses and communities to take practical steps to be ready for whatever\n               comes our way. May is also a time when community pride is on full display. Volunteers step forward\n               to organize events, clean up neighbourhoods, coach youth sports and support local\n               initiatives. During National Volunteer Week, we recognize those individuals who quietly\n               and consistently make our communities stronger. Across British Columbia, arts and culture begin to flourish again in the spring. Local\n               markets, performances and festivals return, showcasing the talent, creativity and\n               entrepreneurial spirit that exists in every corner of the province. What makes May so meaningful in British Columbia is not just the activities but what\n               those activities represent. They represent hope after a long winter. They represent\n               pride in all our communities across the province. And we all know what to do as British\n               Columbians: to support our local businesses as they enter their busiest season; to\n               ensure our communities are prepared for emergencies; to protect the natural beauty\n               that draws people here from around the world; and to continue building a strong, resilient\n               economy that works for everyone. So I encourage all British Columbians to take part in what this month has to offer.\n               Visit a local market. Support our local businesses. Get outside and explore. Volunteer\n               in your community. And take pride in the place that we are fortunate to call home.\n               In British Columbia, May is more than just a month. It's a fresh start for all of\n               us. To all British Columbians out there, let's get out there. Enjoy the warmer weather.\n               Let's enjoy the excitement of the kids and the grandkids. Let's enjoy the simpler\n               things — a walk, a coffee with friends, helping a neighbour — because, honestly, we\n               are truly blessed to call B.C. home. Let's do everything we can to make it better.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729459","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As we turn the page to May here in British Columbia, we step into a season that reflects\n               the very best of our province. Hard work, community spirit and a deep connection to\n               the land we call home. From the coastal communities of Vancouver Island to the fertile\n               orchards of the Okanagan Valley, from the busy streets of Vancouver to the resource\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d1add2a6618f2ca361d684d0ad46909dc4206ba634ae2e378fd1ce7516db0991"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a60e3f78c6e95ddc5175ea5822f37418ebdf831eb89371e833474079075f53ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57ac93778929197b9d30245e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729468,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to read something into the record: \"We're going to be as transparent as possible.\"\n               Those are the words of the Attorney General when being asked about the 20 court cases\n               as a result of the Gitxaała decision. She also said: \"The reason that the number is out there is because of the\n               art of transparency.\" I wasn't aware that transparency is an art. My question: if the Attorney General is\n               so committed to transparency, will she name those 20 court cases today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729468","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to read something into the record: \"We're going to be as transparent as possible.\"\n               Those are the words of the Attorney General when being asked about the 20 court cases\n               as a result of the Gitxaała decision. She also said: \"The reason that the number is out there is because of the\n               art of transparency.\" I wasn't aware that transparency is an art. M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["96ac897480060485b3a755f4c811fa312bbe176d40509aa7c085b1423ebc6c45"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["915864b9fb4449f467a543564bf015eb1f47a8c604db9ce7a34103c23632051a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2a0a2b5c008a5f12e585073c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752342,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that Bill M217 be instituted, Dashcam Cameras in Commercial Vehicles Act as\n               amended to be concurred in at a report stage. I'm very pleased to be able to stand here today and congratulate the committee on\n               all the good work that they've done to bring us to this stage. We all know that the\n               main reason why this bill was instituted in the first place was because of the improvements\n               to road safety. I believe this is a bipartisan bill. This is an opportunity for us\n               in the House to be able to come together and make meaningful legislation. Dashcams promote safe driving behaviour. Over 50 percent of our commercial vehicles\n               already have dashcams. Many businesses have already instituted into their safe work\n               procedures. They've already seen the tangible benefits of the reduction of collisions,\n               accidents and insurance claims because of dashcams, I'm quite confident that with\n               the ability to move this forward and having it as a bill will give us the necessary\n               tools to be able to make sure that all our commercial vehicles over that gross vehicle\n               weight of 8,200 kilograms will be in the province of British Columbia and hopefully\n               across the entire country. Some of the benefits, of course, we talked about. Safe driving habits, but also there's\n               also the efficiency side of things as well. There are opportunities of course of speeding\n               up insurance claims and investigations, reducing legal disputes and costs, and it also lowers the stress and the opportunities for people to make bad decisions. The other thing that I'd like to talk about, if I may, is the amendments that were\n               brought forth in the committee. I believe that those amendments strengthened this\n               bill. Those amendments had not only the description of the commercial vehicle in question\n               of 8,200 kilograms, but also what the operating requirements of the dashcams would\n               be, including night vision and forward-facing only, nothing inside the cab or any\n               privacy issues. Because that was the other thing that was brought up in committee time and time again:\n               were there concerns about privacy? We've got existing laws already on the books, specifically\n               when it comes to commercial and businesses to be able to not only, excuse me, not\n               only to be able to determine how that information is being used and stored, but also\n               how it's being destroyed. I believe that we have already got significant legislation\n               in place to make that work very effectively. So on behalf of myself, I'd like to thank very much for the opportunity to speak to\n               this bill, and I hope that we get unanimous support in the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752342","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that Bill M217 be instituted, Dashcam Cameras in Commercial Vehicles Act as\n               amended to be concurred in at a report stage. I'm very pleased to be able to stand here today and congratulate the committee on\n               all the good work that they've done to bring us to this stage. We all know that the\n               main reason why this bill was instituted in the first place ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01e5d6672c9043193e9c72fab3d5cda043746ce65f30a418f03bdd9a72420fcc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7bf1f4f7390c2a2528f2857c73bede66efad11d61576ba8d94cbada453ee0388"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3709f8120bc5433f2a7a4bf9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752343,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to recognize our youth lobby days here at the Legislature. We were fortunate enough to meet with the Canadian Parks\n               and Wilderness Society group this morning, a great bunch of folks. One of them has actually got her master's degree in OSTI. She looked like she just got out of high school. Great, great questions, and it\n               was so fortunate for us to be able to meet with them. Also, I wanted to mention that the private landowners forest group is here as well. We know how important it is for our industry to be able to rely\n               on private land as well as public land and woodlots and community forests and everybody\n               else across the province to be able to help sustain this forest industry. Will the House please give them a warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752343","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to recognize our youth lobby days here at the Legislature. We were fortunate enough to meet with the Canadian Parks\n               and Wilderness Society group this morning, a great bunch of folks. One of them has actually got her master's degree in OSTI. She looked like she just got out of high school. Great, great questions, and it\n               was so fortunate for us to be able t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["adea8fbbf19e4de8066c7248f185fda14bd2b9311a275237fcdf283bed328e28"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f0f3006d6f3d786cd9598dbea7c7f4200420bb22320db4d6d3cd178a36f5b77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8b3053340e37a25c0cabca1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752344,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my great pleasure to welcome Doug Haughton, who is our TNRD director, which is\n               electoral L Grasslands from Kamloops. I bestowed a designate of honourary Dr. Haughton\n               because of his opportunity to be able to prescribe medication to me, because he kept\n               reminding me that I get very excited sometimes in these meetings. So will the House please give a warm welcome to TNRD director Doug Haughton.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752344","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my great pleasure to welcome Doug Haughton, who is our TNRD director, which is\n               electoral L Grasslands from Kamloops. I bestowed a designate of honourary Dr. Haughton\n               because of his opportunity to be able to prescribe medication to me, because he kept\n               reminding me that I get very excited sometimes in these meetings. So will the House please give a w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09a3fc0e7e2d4f33f866d98ccca0984103c79b452e8da0cd5f7a7b199749d073"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a75cee8b3719fd2a7dad1d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752345,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today in support of the hoist amendment to delay the consideration of Bill\n               9, the Freedom of Information Amendment Act, 2026, for six months. Let me be clear at the outset. This amendment is not about obstruction for the sake\n               of obstruction, it's not about avoiding debate, and it's also not about preventing\n               reform. It's about accountability, and it's about transparency. It's about ensuring\n               that when this Legislature changes the rules surrounding access to information, public\n               oversight and government accountability, we actually understand the consequences before\n               we proceed. Once trust in public institutions is lost, it is incredibly difficult to rebuild.\n               British Columbians are already asking serious questions about transparency in our\n               government. That is exactly why we need this hoist motion. They are asking why freedom-of-information\n               requests are taking so long. Statutorily, it's supposed to be 30 days and then another\n               30 days in exceptional circumstances. The government would lead us to believe that\n               84 percent of the time, those requests are being met. But that is untrue. They are\n               not — 84 percent — being met in that timeline, not even close. I would offer that the average is probably anywhere between three and six months,\n               and that is totally unacceptable. As we get into this speech, when we start talking\n               about the reasons why we have a hoist and why we want to go back and have a pause\n               for six months, a delay, there are many in this room that have said that this is going\n               to outright kill the bill. As my colleague from Kamloops Centre has already alluded to, it doesn't necessarily have to do that. It doesn't say in the legislation that this will kill the bill. Maybe because of the\n               existing timelines. it may, in fact, do it this session. But as the member for Kamloops Centre said, there's no reason why this government, if they are still government in the\n               fall, can certainly bring this back on the very first day that we re-enter our third\n               session in this Parliament. There's nothing stopping this government from doing that. From all indications, from\n               what we've heard from not only the media but the public and all the other organizations\n               throughout the province, the only When we talked about how long it's taking in the freedom-of-information requests,\n               it wasn't that long ago when there was an all-party committee in 2022 that basically\n               spelled out a long list of recommendations that were to be implemented in a timely\n               fashion. Well, there are many of those recommendations that are still not implemented,\n               and now we have this brand-new bill that's supposed to fix everything. Yet everybody\n               outside of this chamber has exactly the opposite take on what this bill is supposed\n               to do. It's supposed to streamline the process. It's supposed to make it easier for us to\n               access the information. Instead, all we seem to get are longer and longer timelines,\n               changes in the wording in the law, and we'll talk a little bit about that when we\n               get to that section in my conversation. But now we've gone from \"withholding delay\" to \"withholding reasonable delay.\" I looked\n               it up. Reasonable is supposed to mean 30 days. Why are we changing it to reasonable?\n               If, statutorily, we've already got it in the law that it's supposed to be 30 days,\n               why are we changing it from \"without delay\" to \"without reasonable delay\"? To me,\n               that sounds either redundant or an opportunity to expand that timeline. We keep having to talk about the hoist amendment because that's exactly what we're\n               trying to do in this section of our opportunity to be able to speak to this motion.\n               But there's also a bunch of other language that is being added to this. I'll get to\n               that when we get through this a little bit further, because I have definitions that\n               I have found out online through Google, Wikipedia, encyclopedia. So I'm going to be able to ask the government side: why are we using those words,\n               and why are we allowing public servants to either interpret or misinterpret those\n               words? Words like \"frivolous,\" as an example. Now, the government is kind of laughing on the other side. My question is: why are\n               we adding that type of nondescript language? Because it can be interpreted many different\n               ways. Why do we not have strict guidelines on the freedom-of-information side of it?\n               There are many things in this amendment.... If it's supposed to streamline the process,\n               it should be allowing us to have better access to information. Again, the government doesn't own this information. The minister or the ministries\n               don't own this information. This information was paid for by the taxpayer. That's\n               whose information it is. This government is the gatekeeper of that information. They\n               don't own it. Then there should be very strict guidelines on what information is easily\n               obtained and what isn't. We've already seen multiple examples of some things that probably would have, should\n               have and could have been buried without our existing Freedom of Information Act. Again, everybody kind of shivers on the other side when we talk about $6,000 limo\n               rides or we talk about gift cards that may or may not be appropriate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752345","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today in support of the hoist amendment to delay the consideration of Bill\n               9, the Freedom of Information Amendment Act, 2026, for six months. Let me be clear at the outset. This amendment is not about obstruction for the sake\n               of obstruction, it's not about avoiding debate, and it's also not about preventing\n               reform. It's about accountability, and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["848d96d6d51b375a6f8bb2d1a470872cd63e725d163c00385624bb587cae8c07","cf3432b1834c9f420f3ba0b4538f9d2db7fb5ff4848f119dd9429117fbabfcad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba0ef491542cee852d9d8b65ce55ae2bdfb04b3355c7bd20f3798f687959911b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1af3ac755876fab0041028dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017636,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to continue remarks on Bill 20, the K'ómoks treaty, and to address what\n               I believe are some of the most important constitutional, democratic and governance\n               concerns facing this Legislature today. At the centre of this debate are two major issues. First, unresolved overlapping territorial\n               boundaries tied to this treaty process. And second, the growing legal and political\n               consequences arising from the provincial government's implementation of the Declaration\n               of Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, more commonly known as DRIPA. Much of the government's defence on DRIPA rests upon references to the United Nations\n               declaration on the rights of Indigenous Peoples, commonly known as UNDRIP. And this\n               is where we must begin having a more honest and mature conversation in this province. UNDRIP was never originally designed to function as an authoritative governing framework for provincial constitutional law in British Columbia. It was\n               not written as a detailed, operational blueprint for resource management in B.C. It\n               was not drafted as a binding administrative manual for provincial permitting systems.\n               It was not designed as a constitutional replacement for the democratic institution\n               of Canadian provinces. And it was certainly not written to resolve the extraordinary,\n               complex realities of overlapping territorial claims between First Nations in British\n               Columbia. UNDRIP emerged as a broad, aspirational, international declaration intended to establish\n               human rights principles and standards regarding Indigenous Peoples globally. Globally.\n               And that distinction matters, because international declarations are often intentionally\n               broad and aspirational in language. They are meant to establish moral principles and\n               objectives, not precise operational legal mechanisms. And there is a significant difference\n               between aspirational declarations and an authoritative domestic governance framework. But unfortunately, this government increasingly treats UNDRIP not as a guiding principle\n               but as an evolving authoritative reference point for provincial decision-making. That\n               shift carries enormous implications, and British Columbians deserve honesty about\n               those implications. One of the greatest dangers in governance occurs when broad, aspirational language\n               is converted into domestic law without clear operational boundaries. What sounds straightforward\n               politically often becomes deeply complicated legally. Words like \"consent,\" \"shared\n               decision-making\" and \"co-governance\" may sound collaborative in speeches and press The B.C. Conservatives believe in meaningful consultation and respectful relationships\n               with our Indigenous communities. But we also believe democratic authority in British\n               Columbia must remain clear, accountable and rooted in elected institutions answerable\n               to our public. That principle matters enormously, because democratic accountability\n               is one of the foundational pillars of responsible government in Canada. Citizens elect representatives, representatives debate laws publicly, and governments\n               answer to the voters. Authority ultimately flows through these democratic institutions,\n               and the accountability to all citizens is equally applied. But many British Columbians\n               increasingly fear that DRIPA is slowly eroding the clarity of that authority, not\n               through a single dramatic constitutional amendment, not through open constitutional\n               negotiations, not incrementally through policy evolution, legal interpretation and\n               expanding government or governance expectations. But this is precisely why many citizens feel uneasy in this province today. It's because\n               they sense fundamental changes occurring, but they are not receiving clear explanations\n               regarding the final destination of any of those changes. When government avoids defining\n               boundaries clearly, uncertainty inevitably grows. One of the most concerning aspects of DRIPA is that government often refuses to clearly\n               define the limits of provincial authority moving forward. Will the province always\n               retain final decision-making authority, and under what circumstances? Can the provincial\n               decisions proceed without consensus? If free, prior and informed consent is not achieved, what happens then? Can projects\n               move forward? Can they be delayed indefinitely? Can different nations reach different\n               conclusions regarding the same territory? That happens when overlapping claims exist. This government repeatedly avoids giving precise answers to these specific questions.\n               That is deeply concerning, because laws function through specifics, not slogans. The\n               B.C. Conservatives believe that elected governments cannot surrender clarity of authority\n               without weakening public accountability itself. If responsibility becomes undefined,\n               accountability becomes undefined. When accountability becomes undefined, public trust\n               is weakened. Citizens no longer know who ultimately governs in this province. B.C. already faces\n               serious challenges regarding our public confidence in our institutions. People are\n               frustrated by the bureaucracy. They're frustrated by permitting delays. They're frustrated\n               by the regulatory uncertainty, with changes happening almost daily. They're frustrated\n               by the government that increasingly seems unable to make timely decisions on major\n               projects and economic opportunities. DRIPA risks worsening that uncertainty further if operational governance structures\n               remain undefined. One of the core concerns many British Columbians....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017636","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to continue remarks on Bill 20, the K'ómoks treaty, and to address what\n               I believe are some of the most important constitutional, democratic and governance\n               concerns facing this Legislature today. At the centre of this debate are two major issues. First, unresolved overlapping territorial\n               boundaries tied to this treaty process. And second, th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1aa4faa80f2d6805e464fe33fb2e608520499573103239236138ea0fab821fd3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["75da824203af6417056b9085bbfdaf5ebb62a4f798e9a4b145f4be4911e57df2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a52eaf853b49744aa73aff08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017640,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also would like to express my gratitude to all the members of the committee for\n               their contributions, and in particular recognize the Chair, the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville, for her leadership and stewardship in our committee. In addition, I would like to acknowledge everyone who shared their perspectives on\n               the way to strengthen provisions of the Election Act and improve future elections.\n               The committee heard from many British Columbians about the vital importance of upholding\n               accountability and promoting transparency in our elections. We recommend appointing a parliamentary committee after every provincial general election\n               to review its administration and make recommendations for future improvements. We\n               believe the undertaking of this work could help to uphold public confidence in B.C.'s\n               elections and counteract misinformation and disinformation. Throughout our work, the committee also identified opportunities to streamline electoral\n               processes for candidates, campaigns and election officials while promoting accountability\n               and transparency. In this area, our recommendations include proactively addressing\n               gaps in the Election Act, increasing transparency and efficiency in nomination administration\n               and ensuring greater consistency in advertising. On behalf of the committee, I would like to extend our gratitude to Elections B.C.\n               for their cooperation and engagement throughout the committee's work and highlight\n               the important role the office plays in ensuring that elections are administered fairly,\n               accurately and transparently. In closing, I wish to express my sincere appreciation to the staff of the Parliamentary\n               Committees Office and Hansard Services for the support that they have provided throughout\n               our work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017640","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I also would like to express my gratitude to all the members of the committee for\n               their contributions, and in particular recognize the Chair, the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville, for her leadership and stewardship in our committee. In addition, I would like to acknowledge everyone who shared their perspectives on\n               the way to strengthen provisions of the Election Act","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e3da2499eb0cea5f5521a2088c2c44748e3167bb14f56c23d0ae6ff8a06c984"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["559f8a82259cb14fb0a8d620492312cc28fbc13148d8da96fd970d4cf9e85662"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa56dd0bddb3cafdf3831c84","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036581,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that Bill M217, intituled of Dashboard Cameras in Commercial Vehicles Act,\n               as amended, be concurred in at report stage. This amendment was really just a housekeeping amendment to adjust the gross vehicle\n               weight that was originally on the definition of a \"commercial vehicle\" from 8,200\n               kilograms' gross vehicle weight to 11,793 kilograms' gross vehicle weight. I certainly appreciate the quick work by not only the legislative staff but the selective\n               committee to make the necessary changes and to allow this important bill to be able\n               to move to third reading and hopefully pass in this session.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036581","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that Bill M217, intituled of Dashboard Cameras in Commercial Vehicles Act,\n               as amended, be concurred in at report stage. This amendment was really just a housekeeping amendment to adjust the gross vehicle\n               weight that was originally on the definition of a \"commercial vehicle\" from 8,200\n               kilograms' gross vehicle weight to 11,793 kilograms' gross veh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Automobile safety equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752452","label":"Automobile safety equipment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8371d4695b1025a50f895fc35f0e0f7260cd699ee2c5bd5fa7629cc557a57772"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a8ef179c22ab4ecacca81466b78697c8f34123baa2243c4921e37c8ea999c3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c8039c64e28cd466edc6ee8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036582,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"It was brought to my attention over a year ago, right after I had been elected and\n               took on the portfolio as the Forests critic, that there were some serious concerns\n               when it came to the Interior lumberman's pension plan. Now, in context, this plan\n               goes back, probably, over 30 years ago. I think it goes back, probably, to the '80s\n               — almost 40 years ago. To put it into context, I believe that even back then, as far\n               as 30 years ago, there was a thought that there was a possibility that the Interior\n               lumberman's pension plan may have a challenge when it comes to having enough workers\n               continually to put money into this plan to be able to pay out those pensions in the\n               future. It's very similar to the IWA pension plan that had the same challenges back in the\n               '80s and '90s with the significant changes in the amount of workers in the mills and\n               seeing a serious reduction in the amount of workers that were able to put money into\n               that pension plan. Now, I still have questions, and I'm hoping that the minister's staff can give us\n               a little bit more of an understanding on where we are today in this. A couple of things\n               that come to mind is the fact that I think we can all agree that this pension plan\n               was underfunded. There were red flags attached as far as 20, 25 years ago in having challenges with this pension plan. Through subsequent governments, they've tried to make changes in trying to get it\n               right. This government has had responsibility for this plan for, I think, over nine years.\n               And I'd like a bit more of an explanation as to how this occurred, why it was continually\n               underfunded, and where this last employer rule came about. And the reason I'm asking that question is that I've talked to many people in multiple\n               industries in trying to get an understanding how.... If I was an employer, like I was\n               with my father, and I hired somebody that worked for me for a couple of years and\n               then they went on to a different job, and then found out that that person a couple\n               years after that decided they were going to apply for their lumberman's pension, and\n               now I could be on the hook for possibly 20 years of an unfunded liability that I had\n               no responsibility over....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036582","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It was brought to my attention over a year ago, right after I had been elected and\n               took on the portfolio as the Forests critic, that there were some serious concerns\n               when it came to the Interior lumberman's pension plan. Now, in context, this plan\n               goes back, probably, over 30 years ago. I think it goes back, probably, to the '80s\n               — almost","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["809570c0c0f191b53d9a9d54bb29469a19fb60ab945c0ce1f13d74490758aaac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bfbcf3aece071456ce3fa11249501d0e312266d4a085c02374faeb76cedb28e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-938462c7ab2c877e8dffd98b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036584,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to present a petition from 171 residents of Whitecroft, just below Sun\n               Peaks. They are requesting the posted speed limit be reduced to 30 kilometres within\n               their residential area. This change would only apply to their roadway and would not\n               impact the main highway, which would remain unchanged.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036584","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to present a petition from 171 residents of Whitecroft, just below Sun\n               Peaks. They are requesting the posted speed limit be reduced to 30 kilometres within\n               their residential area. This change would only apply to their roadway and would not\n               impact the main highway, which would remain unchanged.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036750","label":"Private pensions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58968378238d7ab4a697cc6ddedcbc5efa516466cc9d6af7ef5c5ed12d8a9295"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["887d57b9610a237e5ea8e3b59405670f6694c06e1a38c78a0eb692968e6e5130"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fdf080db7a1625797b9cb01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036585,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"There is something special about summer vacations, especially when we are growing\n               up. Summer was freedom. It was the anticipation of that last school bell ringing in\n               June and knowing the days ahead would be filled with adventure, laughter and endless\n               possibilities. The days felt longer, the evenings warmer and life seemed simpler. For many of us,\n               summer vacations were built around those simpler moments — camping trips with the\n               family, swimming and fishing at the lake, road trips, backyard barbecues, campfires\n               with friends and staying outside playing until the street lights came on. But summer vacation wasn't only about vacations and relaxing. For many young people,\n               it was also the first taste of responsibility and hard work. Some of us cut grass\n               around the neighbourhood, sometimes three times in the same week just so we could\n               make a couple of bucks and go to the pool. Others ran lemonade stands on hot afternoons,\n               hoping enough cars and pedestrians would stop by. Some babysat, some delivered newspapers\n               and flyers or worked at odd jobs that earned a bit of spending money. Then came that first real job. Maybe it was working at a fast-food restaurant during\n               the lunch rush, maybe it was pumping gas at the local gas station, washing windshields\n               or stocking shelves at a grocery store, or maybe it was working in the bush with your\n               dad when you were 14 years old. Those jobs may have been glamorous at the time, but they taught important lessons:\n               responsibility, punctuality, teamwork and the value of earning your first paycheque\n               — that first paycheque. There is a real sense of pride that came from that first job,\n               and even most of it went to snacks or gas money or saving for something special. It\n               felt like independence. Summer vacations have always brought us together to spend more time outdoors, more\n               time with our family and friends, more time to enjoy ice cream and more time just\n               to kick back. We are incredibly fortunate to be surrounded by beautiful lakes, forests,\n               mountains and communities that truly come alive during the summer months, welcoming\n               friends and visitors from around the world. Let's share our summer and those vacation\n               opportunities with everyone and remind ourselves there's nowhere better to be than\n               B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036585","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There is something special about summer vacations, especially when we are growing\n               up. Summer was freedom. It was the anticipation of that last school bell ringing in\n               June and knowing the days ahead would be filled with adventure, laughter and endless\n               possibilities. The days felt longer, the evenings warmer and life seemed simpler. For many of us,\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f065cd34abb25fba29597e55be952c4a525f2fc8515018dc1803897abbd8726"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7feebff1d9214eb2046839d94d1a5f85e6458b14d5c20e773767913c4fcc4197"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e66adfbcebfd4e8616dcab1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036586,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ward Stamer","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am presenting a petition from 36 workers at the Stella-Jones pole facility in New\n               Westminster with a request for the Forests Minister to do his job and contact his\n               federal counterpart to expedite the use of DCOI so these workers don't lose their\n               jobs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036586","member_id":"bc-mla-373","member_name":"Ward Stamer","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am presenting a petition from 36 workers at the Stella-Jones pole facility in New\n               Westminster with a request for the Forests Minister to do his job and contact his\n               federal counterpart to expedite the use of DCOI so these workers don't lose their\n               jobs.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4e6740f5d917af0c0084e0756d74849db91b9395e4c1fde4f0f3282b1edb7671"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["059a4901ac3a4f025937a0210c618cc33054e09f2e60524af7f90364b7a3f376"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-957b47ccea33338e8d77b9b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316777,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled Human Rights Code Repeal Act, of which notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and\n               read a first time now. The purpose of this bill is to end the assault on freedom of speech by our Human Rights\n               Tribunal. Last week, they fined Barry Neufeld three-quarters of a million dollars for refusing to believe that a man could become a woman, for his own personal opinions. This bill will protect ordinary people with common beliefs from politically motivated\n               financial attacks. The Human Rights Code Repeal Act is the only solution to this assault\n               on our rights. This bill will protect the freedom of speech of Canadians. It will\n               abolish the Human Rights Tribunal, a kangaroo court, and repeal the human rights code\n               that the Left is using to punish and profit from anyone who doesn't adopt their views. The bill will terminate the position of a Human Rights Commissioner, who makes over\n               $300,000 a year to police speech, and it will invalidate any outstanding orders made\n               by the tribunal against Canadians like Mr. Neufeld. Freedom of speech is the cornerstone of our democracy. The judgment last week was\n               a wake-up call, and Canadians are demanding their freedoms back. To the members in this House, this is our chance to answer their call. Therefore,\n               I urge you to vote in favour of this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316777","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled Human Rights Code Repeal Act, of which notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and\n               read a first time now. The purpose of this bill is to end the assault on freedom of speech by our Human Rights\n               Tribunal. Last week, they fined Barry Neufeld three-quarters of a million dollars for refusing to believe that a man cou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b2941d8f7466654befc21f2b40711115e9ac871a30bffcc848adfe9b4703bbbf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9ab70e58b76a57f757c636a0007ff3b2a49d53958656f23f70d11e4309bb83db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-050d23a1ca5f8e0a6b2811bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327900,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled the Drug Recovery and Community Safety Act, of which\n               notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first\n               time now. If we want to fight drugs, we shouldn't pay people to use them. The purpose of this\n               bill is simple — to end all provincial funding and enablement for unlawful drug use. Today millions in taxpayer dollars fund government-sanctioned drug consumption sites\n               that permit the ongoing use of illegal substances. That will end. Under this bill,\n               all 58 provincially authorized drug consumption sites will be shut down within six\n               months. This government also turns a blind eye to the diversion of social assistance payments\n               toward illegal drugs. Current policy allows individuals to classify drug addiction\n               as a disability, unlocking benefits intended for those with legitimate mental and\n               physical disabilities. This bill closes Furthermore, there are presently no consequences when income or disability payments\n               are misused to purchase illegal drugs. This bill will change that too. If a person\n               receiving provincial benefits is convicted of a drug-related offence, their benefits\n               will be suspended and reinstated only after completion of an approved drug recovery\n               program. These measures mirror the licence suspension and rehabilitation requirements applied\n               to impaired driving conditions. By eliminating this provincial financing for unlawful\n               drug use, this bill will free up millions, if not billions, of dollars for recovery\n               programs, community safety and to increase support for people who, through no choice\n               of their own, rely upon income or disability assistance to make ends meet. I therefore urge all members to vote in favour of this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327900","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled the Drug Recovery and Community Safety Act, of which\n               notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first\n               time now. If we want to fight drugs, we shouldn't pay people to use them. The purpose of this\n               bill is simple — to end all provincial funding and enablement for unlawful drug use. Today mill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-nonconforming people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386373","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ultraviolet radiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035458","label":"Gender-nonconforming people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:386373","label":"Ultraviolet radiation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70a2775221ebf234c761000fc9eddf66e29963c42f913ca7df6eef23951d8aa9","2d25efe6cea69856b5b547347afe081b260416954308ac618142be8127037efb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5e471831181d770760198a59ddac54352a91cb49bd57d637382ef99fe86f569b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09979d5cb93bb8b4a5b5c1d6","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933905,"date":"2026-03-05T12:00:00+00:00","title":"DRUG RECOVERY AND COMMUNITY SAFETY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m235-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m235-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933905","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbf22e6f176d75345f4440e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358937,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that bill intituled Defunding Aboriginal Title Claims Affecting Private Property\n               Act, of which notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and\n               read a first time now. Aboriginal title claims over private property create chaos and uncertainty. They are\n               a serious threat to the stability of our economy. This bill will help the government\n               push back against the groups bringing these reckless claims. First, the bill will require the suspension of all non-essential provincial funding\n               to any Indigenous group that has commenced an Aboriginal title claim affecting private\n               property within British Columbia. In practical terms, this would immediately suspend all non-essential provincial funding\n               to the Cowichan Tribes, which were granted Aboriginal title over private properties\n               in Richmond last summer. It would also suspend all non-essential provincial funding to the Kamloops Indian\n               Band, which is currently pursuing an Aboriginal title claim affecting the private\n               homes of the city's 100,000 residents. By doing so, the bill ensures that the government does more than wring its hands and\n               offer empty gestures when private property comes under threat. The bill also prohibits the use of any provincial funding by any person for the purpose\n               of supporting an Aboriginal title claim over private property. This prevents non-governmental\n               organizations from supporting these claims using tax dollars they receive from the\n               province. This bill will only apply to Aboriginal title claims that include fee simple lands\n               owned by private businesses and citizens in B.C. So if the province's 200-plus Indigenous\n               groups wish to continue receiving funding from B.C.'s generous taxpayers, the solution\n               is simple. Leave the private properties of British Columbians alone. I commend the bill to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358937","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that bill intituled Defunding Aboriginal Title Claims Affecting Private Property\n               Act, of which notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and\n               read a first time now. Aboriginal title claims over private property create chaos and uncertainty. They are\n               a serious threat to the stability of our economy. This bill will help the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aea079050ddf95575292c10af4ab577cdd77dd69bc63fc0999eae9025c761f3a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c9662a61273ed1dfd8cdd18d28e8871172121bb3babf3e9d9593d936b5ec6209"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f5037c5c60f7ddedb7774a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358938,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, everybody knows that you should never judge a book by its cover, but that is\n               precisely what the government is asking the members of this House and the people of\n               this province to do. They think that just because they have a law with the phrase\n               \"human rights\" in its title, everyone will believe that this law actually protects human rights. But it doesn't.\n               It actually does the opposite. That is why every member in this House should oppose\n               this motion. The code, together with the commission and the tribunal, is taking human rights away\n               from people of this province. They are taking human rights away from women: the right\n               to fair competition in women's sports, the right to privacy in women's bathrooms,\n               the right to safety in women's shelters. They're taking those away thanks to section\n               7 of the so-called human rights code. So if you support the human rights of women,\n               you must oppose this motion. They are taking human rights away from white people as well, along with men. As I\n               explained last week in question period, the NDP-appointed Human Rights Commissioner\n               uses section 42 of the human rights code to intentionally exclude healthy white men\n               from university hiring. And the NDP's Attorney General says that the government is\n               \"proud of that.\" They are proud of taking human rights away from white people and\n               men. I am not. I will never accept the unequal treatment of any race or either sex. So\n               if you oppose discrimination on the basis of race or sex, you must oppose this motion. And how about the human rights of children who are being convinced that they need\n               harmful puberty blockers and surgeries? The human rights code is taking away their\n               right to go through puberty with their bodies intact and to one day have children\n               of their own. The code is taking away the reproductive rights of our children. So\n               if you support reproductive rights, as I do, you must oppose the motion. And let me address the right to free speech, which has come under great threat in\n               this same code. Free speech is a human right to....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358938","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Well, everybody knows that you should never judge a book by its cover, but that is\n               precisely what the government is asking the members of this House and the people of\n               this province to do. They think that just because they have a law with the phrase\n               \"human rights\" in its title, everyone will believe that this law actually protects human rights. But it do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65e4e3f3afbec442587e6e239bff4294737771d0e2a2732f96ccae11063f1dd0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4df1aa081eac9a22e1aea0a243329e5f2643fc7032531d3c361cfc6cea7ca078"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2390208daacd69188e1134e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413642,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled the Transparency of Advocacy Organization Act, of which\n               notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first\n               time now. In British Columbia today, there are thousands of organizations working to influence\n               public opinion and public officials — pride societies, Indigenous lobby groups, environmental\n               organizations and many others. Many are receiving money from the government or from\n               foreign sources, yet public often has no way to see who is funding them, how much\n               they receive or how that money is being spent. This bill changes that. It requires advocacy organizations receiving government or\n               foreign funding to publish annual reports divulging their funding sources, amounts\n               and the salaries of their five highest-paid employees. They must also disclose the\n               legal names of all affiliated organizations. Finally, they must post a notice on their\n               websites and social media admitting that they have received government or foreign\n               funding, along with a one-click link to those mandatory disclosures. If they refuse, the public can step in. The bill empowers any British Columbian to\n               take a non-compliant advocacy organization to court. If a violation is proven, courts\n               can impose large penalties of up to $10 million and award up to 30 percent of those\n               amounts to the applicant who brought the court action. This bill will drag shadowy lobby groups into the light of day. It will do this by\n               harnessing the democratic power of financial transparency and public accountability.\n               I welcome every member to express their support.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413642","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled the Transparency of Advocacy Organization Act, of which\n               notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first\n               time now. In British Columbia today, there are thousands of organizations working to influence\n               public opinion and public officials — pride societies, Indigenous lobby groups, environment","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["508e668253dff4fa3b4ec02f8659cc3ba60aafc5dc8b176b7e95f50754e119dd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8e2d5147bebe083e61a3d3321f5cafdc3e03b81963bbdcf7d84502948320924"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-001664d4d52fcf5429b73b3e","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187135,"date":"2026-04-02T12:00:00+00:00","title":"TRANSPARENCY OF ADVOCACY ORGANIZATIONS ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m240-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m240-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187135","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-787add78a165f40012429972","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720085,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled the Speculation and Vacancy Tax Repeal Act, of which notice has been given in my\n               name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. I rise to introduce a bill to repeal the speculation and vacancy tax. When this tax\n               was introduced in 2018, the government's theory was that it was needed to increase\n               rental vacancy rates, which were then sitting at around 1 percent. It set out to do\n               so by penalizing owners of more than one residence in the province. But today vacancy\n               rates in major B.C. markets have risen to around 4 percent. Rental units are opening\n               up, not because of this tax but primarily due to recent federal reductions in immigration. So this bill will remove a tax that is clearly not needed. It will also put an end\n               to an inefficient tax collection process that forces 1.7 million British Columbians\n               year after year to prove their innocence to government. These mandatory filing declarations\n               apply to fewer than 1 percent of the people required to fill out this paperwork. Public\n               reporting shows that the administration of this tax is so time-consuming that there\n               is now a five-year backlog in collections. This bill will allow those government resources\n               to be productively redeployed. And it will end what has functioned as a punitive tax on innocent British Columbians.\n               It responds to the people in my riding of Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream and communities across the province who are not speculative real estate investors.\n               These are people who maintain a second residence for work, to care for loved ones\n               or who are trying to maintain family cabins that were never meant to be market rentals. The people who live, work and invest in B.C. should not be punished for their success.\n               They should be appreciated for their contributions. They should be treated fairly.\n               And we can do this by repealing this unnecessary, inefficient and punitive tax.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720085","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled the Speculation and Vacancy Tax Repeal Act, of which notice has been given in my\n               name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. I rise to introduce a bill to repeal the speculation and vacancy tax. When this tax\n               was introduced in 2018, the government's theory was that it was needed to increase\n               rental vacan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43356","label":"Sexual harassment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d93f60732ae9c75e777f267cc1a230c3f928e2590808c5f8af63bd86e92bb6f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["86b95ae963af1469c1900f748640589b2202b1b8a36280e795abab62c873235b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fec8ea5d8837a9ecbc95c11c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187138,"date":"2026-04-16T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SPECULATION AND VACANCY TAX REPEAL ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m243-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m243-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187138","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5071d012b7fc50bf6ac4ee66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721155,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is with a deep sense of honour, duty and gravity that I rise to express my profound\n               concerns about the proposed K'ómoks Treaty. I urge my esteemed colleagues to vote against Bill 20, which would ratify\n               and constitutionalize this fundamentally misguided agreement. First, this treaty expands Indigenous claims. It does not settle them. A treaty is\n               meant to bring finality. This one does the opposite. It expressly admits to the existence\n               and ongoing force of Aboriginal title. The document describes itself as a living agreement\n               with mandatory periodic renegotiations and amendments. Far from extinguishing Aboriginal\n               title claims as it should, this agreement keeps the coals burning so that every breeze\n               that blows from the court or another negotiation table will revive K'ómoks claims and spark new ones. Even worse, this treaty expands these rights and the uncertainty they create. How?\n               Through the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People, UNDRIP,\n               whose objective and anti-Canadian claims are directly embedded into this treaty. Yes,\n               the same UN declaration that this NDP government gave the force of law with in this\n               province in 2019. The same law which the Premier himself now admits is an existential\n               threat to British Columbia. On its very first page, the treaty affirms UNDRIP and recognizes what are described\n               as inherent rights to land, law-making authority, and governance powers within a large\n               geographical area of Vancouver Island. These are the kinds of powers ordinarily reserved\n               for sovereign nations, but they are being given to a group of approximately 350 people,\n               only 100 or so of those that live on the reserve. A group this size is more of an\n               extended family than a local government, let alone a sovereign nation. And our government\n               is preparing to grant them a broad array of national governance powers over a region\n               that is roughly 7,000 square kilometres in the heart of the Comox Valley with approximately 70,000 non-Indigenous residents. With all due respect, granting the powers of a sovereign nation-state to an extended\n               family group is absurd. Furthermore, embedding UNDRIP into a treaty undermines any\n               legal certainty that a treaty might otherwise bring. It is legally schizophrenic to\n               recognize broad, undefined, inherent and thereby inalienable rights on the one hand\n               while purporting to define, limit or settle Indigenous rights on the other, which\n               is what this treaty does. This double meaning invites chiefs and their lawyers to\n               claim in the future that, while their Aboriginal rights may have been limited by the\n               treaty, their UNDRIP-inspired inherent rights can be retrieved whenever they feel\n               like it. In addition, this treaty does not even bar new court challenges. K'ómoks retains the ability to challenge permitting decisions where it says consultation has\n               been inadequate under the treaty framework. These consultation processes won't even\n               provide fixed, fast or final timelines for business and resource developments in this\n               province. So in sum, this treaty provides no certainty So in sum, this treaty provides no certainty whatsoever. In fact, it doesn't even\n               attempt to reconcile the K'ómoks band with the historical reality of Crown sovereignty. On the contrary, it promotes\n               UNDRIP's blood and soil theory that people with Indigenous ancestry have their own inherent rights, based\n               upon what are described as inextricable links to the land. That is why the first page of this bill says that British Columbia must reconcile\n               the past presence of Indigenous people with the assertion of Crown sovereignty. But\n               as recognized by the trial judge in the Delgamuukw court case, British sovereignty\n               was not merely asserted, it was undeniably established. Sovereignty was established\n               not through violent conquest, as in other parts of the world, but through the orderly\n               extension and adoption of British laws, settlement and institutions across this entire\n               province. Crown sovereignty within British Columbia was unquestioned for over 100 years. Indigenous\n               inhabitants were adopted by the Crown as subjects and supplied with food, medicine,\n               education and economic opportunities. It is true that colonial authorities entered\n               a few treaties from time to time to facilitate settlement, but Canadian governments,\n               at all times, welcomed Indigenous individuals to become full and equal subjects of\n               the Crown through the process of enfranchisement. The good and honourable objective was to grant them all the rights enjoyed by all\n               other citizens, regardless of racial ancestry. Enfranchisement offered the path out\n               of the Indian Act and its racial isolation from broader society. But tragically, this treaty would prolong the regrettable forms of race-based governance\n               that prevail under the Indian Act, only this time with the power of UNDRIP. It entrenches\n               a form of Indigenous racial supremacy, granting peculiar and additional rights not\n               belonging to other Canadian citizens. Even so, many tribes vehemently oppose this treaty process. The uproar we see now\n               from neighbouring groups proves the point. They say that these treaties before the\n               House impinge on their own demands for sovereignty. We now have threats of blockades\n               and other civil unrest as a result. Clearly, modern treaties are not a path to peace, stability or progress. These treaties\n               have enraged neighbouring tribes. But how should the British Columbian taxpayers feel?\n               They should be angry too. This treaty is a terrible deal. We already know that it\n               fails to provide legal certainty, by extinguishing Aboriginal title. Nevertheless,\n               it grants large and ongoing wealth transfers as if it did. B.C. taxpayers get nothing, but they pay anyways. This includes an upfront payment\n               of $70 million in cash; various forest licences and tenures; a commercial fisheries\n               allocation; subsurface mineral rights; taxation powers; and additional agreements\n               with B.C. regarding natural resource revenue, which are not included in the treaty\n               itself. Nowhere in this treaty or the bill before the House has the government provided even\n               an estimate of the total economic value of the cash, the land and other wealth being\n               transferred from British Columbians to the K'ómoks band council. Nowhere. We have no idea what this treaty will cost. Is it $250 million? Is it $500 million?\n               A billion? More? We don't know. This government over here, they won't say. What does\n               this treaty accomplish for the 350 individual K'ómoks band members? Let's ask that question. Treaties are supposed to replace the dysfunctional system of Indian Act reserves,\n               which require federal government micromanagement, and which do not give individual Treaties are supposed to replace the dysfunctional system of Indian Act reserves,\n               which require federal government micromanagement and which do not give individual\n               band members the right to own their own private properties. On an Indian reserve,\n               members are treated as wards of the federal government, which holds the title to the\n               land in trust for the band. The band council typically has a lease arrangement whereby\n               it manages the rental properties occupied by individual members. Land cannot be held\n               in fee simple. Private property cannot exist. But the K'ómoks Treaty does not solve this problem either. What it does is dictate that Indian reserve\n               lands will be transformed into K'ómoks lands. These lands are not distributed to the members directly in the form of private\n               property. They are given to the band council to control. There are no guarantees that\n               members will ever have the right to own their own homes — ever. This treaty just swaps one form of government-controlled housing with another form\n               of government-controlled housing. What it does is give more rights to the K'ómoks band government, not its members. Why do treaties give rights to band elites and not band members? Because our governments\n               and our courts have been captured by anti-Western, UNDRIP-inspired theories of inherent\n               collective rights, including laws, law-making authority and legal systems. There were, of course, no written laws when Europeans first arrived along the west\n               coast of B.C. There was no writing at all, in fact. No recorded history. No way to\n               verify which tribe had conquered another for the time when prior inhabitants struggled\n               for control over these lands after having arrived from the Bering land bridge 10,000\n               to 15,000 years prior.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721155","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is with a deep sense of honour, duty and gravity that I rise to express my profound\n               concerns about the proposed K'ómoks Treaty. I urge my esteemed colleagues to vote against Bill 20, which would ratify\n               and constitutionalize this fundamentally misguided agreement. First, this treaty expands Indigenous claims. It does not settle them. A treaty is\n               meant","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Slaughtering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037131","label":"Slaughtering","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b458b07a8ae9c3b1443836a986645dd320c96a326e798f0947db3f9a0de8ee16"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["31b9b77fa293e74391c17d78e324c1b21fde155cc450b12827bd912e0e1ddd67"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9759f5d8cfce9b0781741de3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721163,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I will say that the words that I spoke here....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721163","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I will say that the words that I spoke here....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7469ad78d49d7e972af20b26","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728735,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mark Carney's plan to confiscate guns from Canadian citizens is now entering its second\n               phase. He has asked the provinces to donate their own police resources to help him\n               disarm innocent farmers, hunters and sportsmen. It's an outrageous request. That's\n               why premiers from Ontario, the Yukon, Newfoundland, Saskatchewan and Alberta all said\n               no. Even Manitoba's NDP Premier said no. But our Premier said yes. He wants to help disarm innocent Canadians rather than locking\n               up criminals, and the people of our province deserve to know why. My question is this. Will the Premier announce today that British Columbia will terminate\n               all support for Mark Carney's authoritarian plan to disarm innocent Canadians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728735","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mark Carney's plan to confiscate guns from Canadian citizens is now entering its second\n               phase. He has asked the provinces to donate their own police resources to help him\n               disarm innocent farmers, hunters and sportsmen. It's an outrageous request. That's\n               why premiers from Ontario, the Yukon, Newfoundland, Saskatchewan and Alberta all said\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Arms control","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70509","label":"Arms control","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84575d2607b709b2c8a10bb24ef45189317ecbcdc3932099433b7f532907c236"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be33a9c25b26b8b193821fb95d86ac297ef7b2f215ebab4a49da0ef251fc8d53"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-64ae48835e32767310f523d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752144,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled the Home Rental Fairness Act, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This legislation mandates a comprehensive overhaul of our province's residential tenancy\n               laws to fix rules that are indisputably broken for homeowners and tenants alike. Today B.C. is the most expensive province in Canada, with rents nearly $400 above\n               the national average. Yet according to 2026 REIC reports, we remain one of the least\n               hospitable jurisdictions in North America for housing investment. This bill addresses the root causes of this tragic paradox. The Home Rental Fairness\n               Act mandates a total rewrite of the Residential Tenancy Act, short-term rental bans,\n               laws governing manufactured homes and all related regulations within 12 months. Recent surveys indicate that up to 30 percent of homeowners with secondary suites\n               now refuse to rent them. Why? Because homeowners live in fear that having a tenant\n               will turn into a hostage situation. The backlog for dispute resolution under the current\n               system is now up to eight months. A nightmare tenant — and yes, they do exist — could\n               occupy a home for nearly a year without paying a dime. This bill will also put an end to the failed short-term rental ban. Two years ago,\n               that legislation promised long-term housing. Instead, tens of thousands of suites\n               that could otherwise house our citizens sit empty. Owners would rather leave a unit\n               vacant than gamble their financial security on a system they cannot trust. There is no time for fiddling at the margins, which is why this bill initiates a complete\n               rebuild of our rental system from the ground up. This bill will benefit owners and\n               tenants alike because fairness and real reform will restore balance and benefit everyone\n               involved. With that, I commend this act to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752144","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled the Home Rental Fairness Act, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This legislation mandates a comprehensive overhaul of our province's residential tenancy\n               laws to fix rules that are indisputably broken for homeowners and tenants alike. Today B.C. is the most expensive provi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e74b0906c7f4a71fb527eb43b41ece3b5bb04b092ca00fe1504e2e4f4464592"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ca4ed9cb35c9513d0116da7b276236e245a5e8f6f64a763c43e2a8f5adf88f3a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a0d72848a377bb306bad597","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933906,"date":"2026-05-07T12:00:00+00:00","title":"HOME RENTAL FAIRNESS ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m244-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m244-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933906","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8aaf9b4cfe62622def182d66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017001,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled the Young Workers Tax Relief Act, of which notice has\n               been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This bill seeks to rectify the neglect that our youth have suffered on part of our\n               government's reckless spending and excessive taxation. Today home ownership is unattainable.\n               Unemployment is climbing. Wages are stagnating, and 77 percent of British Columbians\n               who have left the province have been under the age of 40 — millennials and Gen Z. The Young Workers Tax Relief Act will address this generational crisis. This bill,\n               firstly, will reduce the income tax burden of B.C. taxpayers that are under the age\n               of 40 by 50 percent. Older generations came of age in the most prosperous time of\n               western civilization, where success was the norm, not an exceptional story. Today\n               it is quite the opposite. This bill will reinstate the norm that B.C. youth deserve and that a living wage is\n               not a luxury. It will make life affordable again for young British Columbians by letting\n               them keep more of what is theirs. The second major component of this bill is a mandatory 50 percent reduction in public\n               spending over the next five years — the single biggest public spending cut in B.C.'s\n               history. The government has consistently been running the highest deficits in our\n               history, and they've been dropping this mounting debt on the laps of young people\n               to pay off for years. This bill will end the unsustainable loop of recklessly borrowing\n               on our children's credit, and it will finally invest in their future. It's the duty of a civilization to preserve its achievements for future generations.\n               The Young Workers Income Tax Relief Act will give Gen Z and young Millennials the\n               relief they need after years of neglect. I submit this bill to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017001","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled the Young Workers Tax Relief Act, of which notice has\n               been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This bill seeks to rectify the neglect that our youth have suffered on part of our\n               government's reckless spending and excessive taxation. Today home ownership is unattainable.\n               Unemployment ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037489","label":"Violence against children","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5054e6d69ae3ff1667705e06e0cb61c79d43d4e193aee56703c70d24c1568569"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e179a134926a81450842a30862877066cdacdbd2cb530ea00af9980d5d802fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-174f8d9b3bfdcfdaea62fdbd","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933907,"date":"2026-05-21T12:00:00+00:00","title":"YOUNG WORKERS INCOME TAX RELIEF ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m245-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m245-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933907","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","label":"Personal income tax"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-350b712a14b64ebe2813f7b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036373,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Tara Armstrong","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled \"The Pharmaceutical Risk Management and Accountability\n               Act,\" of which notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This bill is about big pharma. Large pharmaceutical corporations are distributing and profiting from drug products whose long-term safety and effectiveness is unknown or uncertain. This act will create a new class\n               of experimental drugs that are subject to robust new risk management and accountability standards. This new class of drugs will include COVID vaccines, harm reduction drugs, gender transition drugs and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. These drugs have been promoted for use\n               by youth and other vulnerable populations despite uncertainty regarding long-term\n               effects. In some cases, as with the COVID vaccines, pharmaceutical companies have\n               signed agreements with the government to excuse themselves from financial liability. This bill will change that. It will place the responsibility for safety and efficacy\n               of drugs back onto the pharmaceutical giants themselves. Wholesalers will enter into\n               new risk management agreements with the Minister of Health, and these will require: one, a victims' compensation program; two, indemnities forcing pharmaceutical corporations to pay\n               their fair share of health care costs; and three, strict monitoring and reporting disclosures. The time has come for B.C. to make pharmaceutical giants pay for the risks and costs\n               of their own drug products. I commend this bill to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036373","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled \"The Pharmaceutical Risk Management and Accountability\n               Act,\" of which notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This bill is about big pharma. Large pharmaceutical corporations are distributing and profiting from drug products whose long-term safety and effectiveness is unknown or uncertain. This act wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["951d80c9a9acbca7ce0b3d4633aa2a43e029b0e2ad8b71fbb116718fed091070"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b5bf277973b147ab20622be601954dd18426ec51d10217d1dfe62a7056b1aa3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-303bb0c13da4dcbbe24ba32d","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933911,"date":"2026-05-28T12:00:00+00:00","title":"PHARMACEUTICAL RISK MANAGEMENT AND ACCOUNTABILITY ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m249-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m249-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933911","member_id":"bc-mla-374","member_name":"Tara Armstrong","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22e5df3e286819fa7d0cf7d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316834,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to speak directly today to the people who make this province work. The people\n               who sign the front of the paycheques. The people who keep the lights on. To every\n               small business owner, every entrepreneur, every builder, every operator, every farmer,\n               every manufacturer, every tech founder, every professional who gets a call at 10 p.m.\n               because something went wrong and still shows up the next morning. We see you. British Columbia runs on your determination and drive. You embody the\n               spirit of enterprise that built this province. But we see the exhaustion in your eyes,\n               the frustration, the frayed end of the rope. And we hear the anger in your voices\n               because this government keeps coming back with the same tired line: \"Give us another\n               chance.\" But the Premier is not listening to you. Let's talk about what this government has done. They let small business B.C. die and\n               tried to bury it in the middle of an election. A decades-old institution that served\n               the people who hire, pay the bills and take the risks. Gone. They rolled out the securing\n               small business rebate after they unleashed a public safety crisis in our downtowns.\n               Then they botched it, with less than 20 percent of the money actually reaching small\n               businesses. They sidelined the Small Business Roundtable, and after nearly two years of radio\n               silence, the Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth shut it down on December 30, 2025,\n               with a Dear John letter to volunteer members. He said it was replaced by a trade and\n               economic security task force, but that task force had already been disbanded months\n               earlier. He said red tape work would be handled by the ease of doing business initiative,\n               a glorified online suggestion box. So what's left? Nothing. No round table, no task force, no serious structured voice\n               for the people who create most private sector jobs in a province where almost every\n               business is a small business. And now this government has tabled a budget that will\n               add about $500 million a year in in PST on professional services. That cost doesn't\n               just vanish. It gets passed on to housing projects, construction sites, manufacturers,\n               farmers and every balance sheet already under strain. When the Premier was asked last week on stage by the CEO of the board of trade about\n               companies packing up and leaving British Columbia, he brushed it off as an anecdote.\n               An anecdote. But the business community is not an anecdote or an afterthought. It\n               is the engine of this province. It is how we fund health care, schools and public\n               safety. It is not just business owners who pay the price. It is their employees. It's the\n               apprentice whose hours get cut because the next project is on hold. It's the young\n               family trying to buy a first home while government-imposed costs stack up at every\n               stage. It is seniors trying to stay in their homes while property tax deferral costs\n               rise and long-term-care projects are cancelled. It is donations to charities drying\n               up just as they face record demand like lineups at food banks. This budget is a wake-up\n               call. Here is what I want to say to the business community of British Columbia. Stop. Stop\n               pretending this is normal. Stop accepting lectures from people who have never made\n               payroll and never risked their own capital. You are not the villains. You are the\n               builders, the makers. You take the risk first and pay yourself last. You hire. You\n               invest. You stay late. You sponsor kids' sports teams. You donate to hospital foundations.\n               You keep our communities alive. You deserve a government that treats you as partners, not ATMs. You deserve stability,\n               predictability and a fair shot. You deserve a public safety plan that restores order\n               and a health system that gets people the care they need, including mandatory care\n               where it's needed. It is time to stop pretending things will get better under this government, because\n               they won't. It is time to start working in earnest toward the next government, a government\n               that will pull our province back from the brink and rebuild stability, predictability\n               and opportunity for the decade ahead. To the business community, hold your heads high, hold on to hope and help us hold\n               this failing government to account. British Columbia needs you. To the business community: hold your heads high, hold on to hope, and help us hold\n               this failing government to account. British Columbia needs you now more than ever,\n               and we are working to build a new government that gives you reason to keep believing\n               in the promise of this province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316834","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I want to speak directly today to the people who make this province work. The people\n               who sign the front of the paycheques. The people who keep the lights on. To every\n               small business owner, every entrepreneur, every builder, every operator, every farmer,\n               every manufacturer, every tech founder, every professional who gets a call at 10 p.m.\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a835cade7f5995d583c88d0fcf272a7e82510af5d8a3f3063332106989f8093"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fdb28dcf94a2bcef561d1114e6d548d15bdd7b7b38853b6f6751a328f1979285"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-423ef559441916768d0a1e39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316835,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Every budget tells stories, even when it pretends it is just numbers. Usually, the\n               stories come with names. The government","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316835","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Every budget tells stories, even when it pretends it is just numbers. Usually, the\n               stories come with names. The government","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4d4b5429c2f17bc549a52df149b6914476fa3ec0bd9ebd146616319067054db"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad5b093b2339325bfa13f9a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316836,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Unlike the Leader of the Opposition, I showed up on time, so I won't have to make\n               the member for Prince George–Mackenzie do this. I rise to welcome my mother, Martha Bassett, to the House. It takes a special kind of love to let heavy metal bands rehearse in your living room\n               for years. That was my mother. It takes a special kind of strength to survive cancer,\n               raise two kids, largely on your own, and keep them from self-destructing long enough\n               that one makes an honest living and the other ends up in the Legislature. That was\n               also my mother. It takes a special kind of senior to plan a backpacking pilgrimage\n               through Japan just months before your 80th birthday. That is my mother's next stop\n               after her visit today to the Legislature. I love you, Mom.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316836","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Unlike the Leader of the Opposition, I showed up on time, so I won't have to make\n               the member for Prince George–Mackenzie do this. I rise to welcome my mother, Martha Bassett, to the House. It takes a special kind of love to let heavy metal bands rehearse in your living room\n               for years. That was my mother. It takes a special kind of strength to survive cancer,\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083631","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Survival","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083631","label":"Survival","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b1b0db3178f13600435231efe6f768d86e54c4055ccd421cab50215c96225ff","1222f37d04b7e074553d600d1d60d44c5e33177bb22f7e3ed7a399d32948d294"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-352e420ec9ae29a9ac12432c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316837,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. Point of order. We do have a basis of alternating recognition, which would normally\n               suggest that after the government speaks, the opposition speaks. The member for Kelowna Centre was the first standing before the Speaker chose to recognize the member from Surrey. I would ask that we return to the appropriate speaking rotation by having the member\n               for Kelowna Centre speak next. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316837","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. Point of order. We do have a basis of alternating recognition, which would normally\n               suggest that after the government speaks, the opposition speaks. The member for Kelowna Centre was the first standing before the Speaker chose to recognize the member from Surrey. I would ask that we return to the appropriate speaking rotation by having the member\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e57a73522ebc51e6ddd2730","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316838,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I reserve my right of privilege.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316838","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I reserve my right of privilege.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e1d1bcc0b4e48286802f54a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316839,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It sounds like you can hear me now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316839","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. It sounds like you can hear me now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7bf32573feb3787fa80f35806e7904c04b50883f17e5bbd6a4ae5444c8b436c","0ca8afcb82e06a88b37efe19d25b8f9984f1e9f0bf76b818fdd4b7b217c345e4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6651f17bf62633a4fb832908","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327948,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak to Bill 7, the Post Secondary International Education (Designated\n               Institutions) Act. I find myself sharing some of the sentiments of the member opposite.\n               I am the proud son of two international students who met at UBC, and my Canadian dream\n               is possible because of their Canadian dream, because of international students. Let me begin with what should be straightforward. We support the principle of protecting\n               international students, we support strong standards, we support transparency, we support\n               accountability, and we support the idea that if an institution in British Columbia\n               wants to advertise, recruit, enrol, contract with and teach international students,\n               it should meet a serious and enforceable standard. That should not be controversial. International students are not just numbers on a spreadsheet. They're not just revenue\n               sources for institutions. They are not just abstractions in a briefing note. They\n               are people. They are young people and families who have often made one of the biggest\n               financial and personal decisions of their lives. They come to British Columbia, to\n               Canada, in good faith. They trust what they are told. They trust the institutions\n               that recruit them. They trust the public reputation of this great province. And they\n               trust that the system they are entering is real, credible and governed by rules. When that trust is abused, the damage is not abstract. Behind every application is\n               a human being. Behind every tuition payment is a sacrifice. Behind every promise is\n               a family somewhere in the world hoping that this province will deal honestly with\n               their son or their daughter. We know from community reports here in British Columbia that some students have paid\n               the ultimate price in a system marked by isolation, exploitation, addiction and mental\n               health crisis. In Surrey, community leaders reported dealing with dozens of deaths\n               of international students over a two-year period, including overdoses and suicides. Yes, government has a legitimate role here, and yes, the province has a legitimate\n               interest in protecting the integrity of international education and the reputation\n               of British Columbia. That is the right starting point. Bill 7 takes the existing education quality assurance framework and puts it into statute.\n               It requires institutions to hold a designated certificate before they can advertise\n               to, enrol, contract with or deliver instruction to international students. It creates\n               a public directory, gives inspection powers Bill 7 takes the existing education quality assurance framework and puts it into statute.\n               It requires institutions to hold a designated certificate before they can advertise\n               to, enrol, contract with or deliver instructions to international students. It creates\n               a public directory, gives inspection powers, creates enforcement tools, including\n               cancellation and reapplication bans and sets out an appeal process, although one in\n               which an appeal does not automatically stay the decision. This is not a minor technical bill. It is a real statutory enforcement regime. Because\n               it is real, this House has to treat it seriously, not performatively, not tribally,\n               not as a morality play in which one side clings the mantle of virtue and assumes that\n               anyone asking questions must, therefore, be defending abuse. That is not serious law-making. Serious law-making begins with a simple principle.\n               In a free society, good intentions are not enough. The state must explain not only\n               what power it wants but why it wants it, how it will use it, what limits constrain\n               it and what remedies exist when it gets things wrong, as it inevitably will. That\n               is not anti-government. That is the job. And it matters, especially in post-secondary\n               education, because institutions matter. They matter as repositories of trust, continuity,\n               standards and civic purpose. When governments govern institutions badly, they do not simply create inconvenience.\n               They weaken the very structures through which people plan their lives. Students plan\n               their lives around institutions. Families plan around them, communities plan around\n               them, employers plan around them, faculty and staff build careers within them. So when we legislate in this space, we should do so with humility, discipline and\n               a healthy suspicion of ideological impulse and administrative improvisation, because\n               the temptation of modern government is always the same. When a system is drifting,\n               governments reach for spectacle, gesture and motion, announce a review, maybe announce\n               two, launch a framework, re-brand an oversight system, promise a reset. Sometimes\n               that is necessary, but reviews are not a governing philosophy. Process is not a substitute\n               for policy. The appearance of action is not the same thing as institutional stability. The wider point matters here because Bill 7 does not arrive in isolation. It lands\n               on top of a sector that is already unstable. In 2024, after consultations with international\n               students and post-secondary partners, the province announced a package of international\n               education measures, including a pause on approvals for new institutions seeking to\n               enrol international students, more inspections, higher standards, minimum language\n               requirements and tuition transparency measures. Later, the province introduced a new EQA code of practice. Then, in late 2025, government\n               launched another independent review of the post-secondary system itself, saying institutions\n               are under severe financial pressure and that many are in a critical position, with\n               widening gaps between revenues and expenses. So we are not debating this bill against a backdrop of calm and settled confidence.\n               We are debating it in the middle of instability. That should shape how we think, because\n               if government is already intervening, already reviewing, already tightening, already\n               restating and already reorganizing, then this House is entitled, indeed obliged, to\n               ask a very basic question. What exactly is the governing philosophy here? Is it stable?\n               Is it evidence-based? Is it coherent? Or are we watching a sequence of reactions layered\n               on top of a system that has been allowed to drift for too long? The federal context matters too. Canadians and British Columbians were right to be\n               concerned by the explosive growth of what had begun to look in too many places like\n               an international student industrial complex. In too many cases, the system was being\n               exploited, students were being exploited and parts of the labour market were being\n               distorted by a model that had drifted too far from genuine education and too far toward\n               volume, revenue and pathway gaining. Ottawa responded with major changes in 2024 and 2025, including national caps on study\n               permits, provincial attestation letter requirements, new restrictions on post-graduation\n               work permit eligibility for some programs and tighter spousal open work permit rules.\n               For 2025, IRCC set a target of 437,000 study permits, down 10 percent from the 2024\n               cap. And for 2026, it announced a further reduction to 408,000 expected Now, the problem is that Ottawa responded with a blunt object. It addressed real abuses,\n               but it also punished many good actors along with the bad. That matters in British\n               Columbia because colleges were hit especially hard, including reputable public institutions\n               that were not the rightful source of public frustration in the first place. Okanagan College, whose main campus sits in the heart of my riding, reported that\n               only about 8 percent of its programs were eligible for postgraduate work permits under\n               the new rules, meaning roughly 92 percent were not. It also reported that new international\n               enrolment was down 40 to 50 percent in fall 2024 compared with fall 2023 and down\n               roughly 70 percent in winter 2025 compared with winter 2024. The college said the\n               changes were already resulting in fewer sections and reduced term faculty positions\n               in some areas. That is important because Okanagan College is not the caricature of the problem. It\n               is not the cartoon villain in the story government likes to tell when it wants to\n               justify broad and arbitrary intervention. It is a reputable public institution serving\n               students and communities in my region and beyond. So when we talk about cleaning up a system, we should remember that blunt policy does\n               not strike only its intended target. It hits real institutions. It hits good actors.\n               It hits people who did not create the mess. It risks overshooting and overreaching. That same caution applies to good private institutions. There are responsible private\n               post-secondary institutions in British Columbia that provide specialized training,\n               industry-aligned programming and flexible pathways for students. They also have every\n               incentive to want bad actors removed, because disreputable operators poison confidence\n               in the entire sector. When we build provincial law in response to a real problem, we have to take care not\n               to create a framework or an application of a framework that is biased against legitimacy\n               itself. A serious regulatory regime should be hostile to abuse, not hostile to legitimacy. That is one reason I approach Bill 7 with both support for its objective and caution\n               about its structure. In institutional life, overcorrection can become its own form\n               of damage. A state that governs by panic is not wiser than a system that drifted into\n               abuse. It is just making different mistakes with more paperwork. Now, there are numerous parts of this bill that make sense. It is sensible to require\n               a formal designation certificate in law. It is sensible to create more clarity around\n               who may operate in this space. It is sensible to have standards around continuity\n               of programming, clarity of information to students, student safety and well-being\n               and institutional integrity. Those criteria are set out in section 5 of the bill,\n               along with operational factors such as facilities, staffing, business practices, education\n               agents and compliance history. That is all very understandable. Some of it is, frankly, overdue. But the test of\n               a bill like this is not whether the aspiration sounds reasonable. The test is whether\n               the legal architecture is disciplined, whether it is clear, whether it distinguishes\n               well, whether it respects due process, whether it protects students not just in rhetoric\n               but in the consequences that follow from state action. That is where my concerns begin. The first concern is discretion. Section 5 allows the administrator to consider other\n               factors the administrator considers relevant. Section 8 allows the administrator to\n               impose, amend or remove terms and conditions on a designation certificate at any time. That is where legislators should sit up straighter. Discretion is, indeed, sometimes\n               necessary, but discretion is never self-justifying. The more the law relies on broad\n               administrative judgment, the more important clear safeguards become. If the state,\n               if the government, is going to say, \"Trust us, we need flexibility,\" then this House\n               should respond, \"Fine, show us the guardrails. Show us the standards Bill 7 leans heavily on future discretion. It allows the administrator to make binding\n               rules on substantive matters such as disclosure of student information, instructional\n               delivery, collaborations, reporting obligations, institutional policies and the use\n               of the designation mark. Cabinet is also given broad regulation-making authority over\n               fees, exemptions, education agents, publication requirements and other matters contemplated\n               by the act. In other words, a substantial part of the true operating regime is not fully in the\n               bill. It is deferred — deferred into rules, deferred into regulations, deferred into\n               future judgment. That matters because the difference between law debated here and\n               rules written elsewhere is not trivial. It is the difference between visible accountability\n               and managed opacity. It is the difference between standards this House can test and\n               standards institutions discover later, often the hard way, at high cost. My second concern is procedural fairness. Section 18 allows the administrator to impose\n               conditions, order corrective action, cancel designation and bar reapplication for\n               up to three years. Section 21 provides a right of appeal, but it also says \"the commencement\n               of an appeal does not operate as a stay\" and does not suspend the decision under appeal.\n               That matters. It means the penalty can bite first and be argued about later. Government will say speed matters when student protection is at stake. And in some\n               cases, that is obviously, self-evidently true. But mature law should be able to distinguish\n               between the rogue operator and the close case, the good actor who makes a mistake.\n               It should be able to distinguish between imminent harm and ordinary non-compliance.\n               It should be able to distinguish between the institution that must be stopped now\n               and the institution that may have grounds for temporary relief while an appeal is\n               heard and issues are resolved constructively in good faith. Without those distinctions, the right exists on paper while the real-world damage\n               occurs in the meantime in real time. A right of appeal without a timely process or without any mechanism for meaningful\n               interim relief can become a cardboard shield. It looks fine from a distance, but it's\n               less useful when arrows start flying. An enforcement action does not occur in a vacuum. It affects current students. It\n               affects future students. It affects staff and faculty. It affects local communities.\n               It affects confidence. It affects reputations immediately and often irreversibly.\n               Yes, section 19 says that if a designation certificate is cancelled, the institution\n               must notify enrolled international students and may continue providing the program to those students,\n               subject to administrator rules. That is helpful. But even there, the practical details\n               are still deferred into future rules. Again, it is reasonable for this House to ask. What happens to the students in real\n               life? What does communication look like? What does continuity look like? What transfer\n               support exists, if needed? What timelines apply? What service standard exists for\n               appeals? If the purpose of this bill is student protection, then student protection\n               must be factored into the consequences of enforcement, not merely invoked in the justification\n               for power. My third concern is inspection and coercive power. The bill authorizes inspectors\n               to enter business premises during business hours without a warrant, inspect records\n               and other things, remove records for copying and make video or audio recordings, as\n               well as question individuals. Some inspection power is plainly necessary, but when\n               the state grants itself warrantless inspection powers, legislators should pay close\n               attention. What training will inspectors receive? What limits protect confidentiality? How is\n               student information protected? How long may copied records be retained? What complaint\n               mechanisms exist if powers are used badly or are perceived to be used badly? Section 30 separately authorizes the Section 30 separately authorizes the collection, use and disclosure of personal information\n               for administering the act. That may indeed be necessary, but necessity is not a magic\n               word that dissolves the obligation to define legal limits carefully. My fourth concern is reputation and public sanction. The bill requires a public online\n               directory of designated and forward-designated institutions and allows publication\n               of enforcement information. Transparency matters. Students deserve to know whether an institution is in good standing.\n               Families deserve to know. The public deserves to know. But reputational sanctions\n               are powerful. Once government places something online, it is not merely informing\n               the public. It is branding the institution in a way that may have consequences far\n               beyond the moment that produced it. That includes consequences for its students and\n               alumni. So, in that instance, that means the criteria for publication matter, the duration\n               matters, and the distinction between serious misconduct and lesser breaches matter.\n               The process for correction matters, and it's very important that we ensure that if\n               we are sanctioning an institution, we're doing our utmost to protect students who\n               have, in good faith, proceeded through that institution. Here again, much of the detail is deferred, so the House is being asked once more\n               to trust future rule-making, to trust future calibration, to trust future administrative\n               judgment. There is a place for trust in government, but trust is not a substitute\n               for careful drafting. My fifth concern is institutional instability. This bill comes before a sector already\n               reeling from federal policy shifts, financial strain, domestic demographic pressures\n               and another major provincial review on top of one that had to be FOI'd to be released.\n               The province's own announcement on that review said that public institutions are under\n               significant financial pressure due in part to federal reductions in study permits,\n               inflation and declining domestic enrolment. So what should a wise legislature do in such a moment? It should be careful. It should\n               resist the impulse to govern primarily through suspicion. It should write law that\n               is clear enough for good institutions to live under with confidence, strict enough\n               for bad institutions to fear, and fair enough that students are protected not only\n               from abuse by operators but from disorder created by government itself in its response. Because the state can also destabilize. It can destabilize through ambiguity. It can\n               destabilize through delay. It can destabilize through constant policy churn. It can\n               destabilize through the habit of government by press release and then outsourcing\n               the hard parts into rules to be written later. When that happens, everyone loses. Students lose. Good institutions lose. Public confidence\n               loses. Our brand as a destination for international education loses. There is a deeper lesson here, too. Post-secondary systems are not strengthened by\n               ideological posturing. They are strengthened by durable policy. British Columbia has seen what happens when governments treat post-secondary education\n               as a stage for symbolic politics rather than as a serious institutional ecosystem\n               that requires long-term discipline. Across the 1990s and early 2000s, inflation-adjusted per-student funding in B.C. fell\n               sharply from earlier levels, even as institutions were expected to absorb pressures\n               and expand access. An NDP government froze tuition without providing compensatory\n               funding, starving the post-secondary system. The exact history is more complicated than a bumper sticker, but the lesson is not.\n               Symbolic politics without a durable funding and governance model can leave institutions\n               quietly hollowed out in real terms while government congratulates itself for the gesture. That is why we have heard repeatedly from student groups who are concerned and who\n               have been asking this government to commit to maintaining the domestic tuition cap\n               of 2 percent imposed 20 years ago. That is why it is somewhat concerning that the\n               Minister of Post-Secondary Education has not affirmed government's position and was\n               not able to answer that question in an informed way in question period. That ideological lurch is what we must not repeat. We do not need reviews designed\n               to create the illusion of action while the system frays. We do not need a politics\n               that alternates between permissive neglect and sudden overcorrection. We need evidence-based\n               policy. We need institutional seriousness. We need to That is why this debate must be bigger than whether everyone in this chamber is against\n               exploitation. Of course, we are all against exploitation. The real question is whether\n               this bill is disciplined enough to strengthen the system without deepening instability.\n               That means asking the government some basic questions. How will the administrator's discretion be guided and constrained? What enforcement guidelines will exist, and will they be public? How will institutions and students know the difference between a technical problem,\n               a serious compliance issue and an imminent risk situation? What appeal timelines will apply? Will there be published service standards? What process, if any, will exist for interim relief in cases where immediate enforcement\n               may cause disproportionate harm? How will the ministry ensure that enforcement protects students in practice, not just\n               in theory? How will responsible private institutions be reassured that oversight is aimed at\n               abuse, not at their mere existence? How will the government ensure that yet another review does not become yet another\n               placeholder for decisions deferred? These are not obstructionist or hostile questions. These are, I believe, the right\n               questions. They are the questions legislators should ask when the state seeks more\n               power in a fragile environment. Let me say something directly to the students who sit in many ways at the centre of\n               this issue. You deserve better than a system in which governments swing from neglect\n               to crackdowns and call that strategy. You deserve better than institutions that treat\n               you as inventory or work in progress. You deserve better than a public debate in which\n               your education, your future, your financial sacrifice and your trust are all reduced\n               to talking points. You deserve institutions that are stable. You deserve clear information. You deserve\n               honest recruitment. You deserve supports that actually exist. You deserve a Legislature\n               willing to ask hard questions before it hands broad tools to the state. That is what\n               seriousness looks like, not slogans, not self-congratulation, not ideological theatre,\n               serious policy-making. Now, I want to be constructive, because opposition that merely criticizes without\n               proposing a better standard is just theatrical disappointment. It's just admiring\n               the problem. So here is the standard that I would apply. If government wants this bill to command\n               confidence, it should commit to transparent enforcement guidelines. It should publish\n               appeal service standards. It should clarify the protections and communication requirements\n               for currently enrolled students in the event of cancellation. It should ensure that publication rules for the public directory are proportionate,\n               current and tied to clear thresholds. It should report publicly on inspections, enforcement\n               actions, appeals, reversals and timelines. It should make clear that legitimate private\n               institutions have a role to play in this province and will be judged on standards,\n               not ideology. Above all, it should understand that governance is not the same thing as movement.\n               To govern well is not merely to be seen doing something, anything. To govern well\n               is to build rules that endure. To govern well is to restrain one's own convenience.\n               To govern well is to resist both drift and panic. To govern well is to remember that\n               institutions, once destabilized, do not simply snap back because the minister has\n               announced a reset. Yes, we support the aim of protecting international students. Yes, we support action\n               against bad actors. Yes, we support stronger oversight than a purely administrative\n               framework can provide. But support for the objective does not relieve us of the duty\n               to scrutinize the means. In fact, it heightens that very duty, because the better\n               the objective, the more careful we should be about the power claimed in its name. That is the work before us. Not to deny the problem, not to romanticize the old system,\n               not to excuse for one moment exploitation, but not either to mistake discretion for\n               wisdom, motion for strategy or toughness for good law. Our duty is to make law that protects students, respects legitimate institutions and\n               restores confidence to a sector that has already absorbed enough instability. That\n               is the standard. Not merely stronger power but better law, a better system and better\n               outcomes for people who work, research, teach and That is the standard. Not merely stronger power. Better law, a better system and better\n               outcomes for people who work, research, teach and learn in our world-class post-secondary\n               institutions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327948","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to speak to Bill 7, the Post Secondary International Education (Designated\n               Institutions) Act. I find myself sharing some of the sentiments of the member opposite.\n               I am the proud son of two international students who met at UBC, and my Canadian dream\n               is possible because of their Canadian dream, because of international students. Let me begin with ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["72a91f6018c96a929cbfe53782ec67f13cb94b2461f4ef06c1cae0c126ba435a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["278f2d3b2905339ffdee0b06f0db2185a89aafc5c39d8f10acccff5723bdfed9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15f6ebaa8cf766e62db71b4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327949,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"NDP now stands for no doctors present. Yesterday we heard of yet another four-day maternity ward diversion at Ridge Meadows,\n               set to start tomorrow. In the last two weeks, that maternity ward has only been open\n               for two days. When will this Premier fire his Health Minister and find someone capable of delivering\n               health care for British Columbians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327949","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"NDP now stands for no doctors present. Yesterday we heard of yet another four-day maternity ward diversion at Ridge Meadows,\n               set to start tomorrow. In the last two weeks, that maternity ward has only been open\n               for two days. When will this Premier fire his Health Minister and find someone capable of delivering\n               health care for British Columbians?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["116fb55b6ecfbaeac9cabcecef9f959032ce51ebfed900a92b4528160a8e5900"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ad7dd78f447e118d415bdb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327950,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"At a critical time for reconciliation and land title, British Columbians need a Minister\n               of Indigenous Relations who is present, informed and empowered. So why was that minister\n               not briefed on the Haida litigation, and why was he not even at the xwməθkwəy̓əm signing ceremony for an agreement affecting his own riding? Can the Premier explain who is actually in charge of Indigenous relations in this\n               government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327950","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"At a critical time for reconciliation and land title, British Columbians need a Minister\n               of Indigenous Relations who is present, informed and empowered. So why was that minister\n               not briefed on the Haida litigation, and why was he not even at the xwməθkwəy̓əm signing ceremony for an agreement affecting his own riding? Can the Premier explain who is actually in charge o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4954517a7ce72902ba7bc5cdac8731418ef4ca6a5e95ad83e145556c692aace0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42bc55c7c5495fdc4fe1eb656ec0169b2ec0b16fe80245b8b90f07243d53db13"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-777e14489dbf13b820ff3f5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327951,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Bill 2 also contains a technical-looking amendment to the Assessment Act. That deserves much more scrutiny than it will probably get. It amends section 19 of\n               the Assessment Act by adding a new subsection, 19(6.1). Here is the government's wording. Subject to subsections (5) and (7), in determining actual value, the assessor is not\n               required to consider any restriction placed on the use of the land and improvements\n               by a person other than (a) the Crown, (b) a local government as defined in the schedule\n               to the Local Government Act, or (c) a local trust committee as defined in the Islands\n               Trust Act. Why does that matter? Because in the real world, property values are affected by risk.\n               They are affected by uncertainty. They are affected when buyers worry that unresolved\n               claims, disputes or assorted constraints could delay development, increase legal exposure\n               or reduce the practical use of land. This amendment appears to make it easier for B.C. Assessment to say: \"Unless that\n               restriction comes from government, we are not required to take it into account.\" That\n               raises an obvious question about clause 28. Does this mean a fee-simple property owner\n               could see the market value or appraised value of their land diminished because buyers\n               and lenders price in uncertainty on the land base from unresolved land claims, but\n               the assessed value is artificially propped up because the assessor is \"not required\"\n               to consider restrictions not imposed by government? In plain language, could British Columbians end up paying higher taxes on a paper\n               value that ignores real market uncertainty? This is not a small technical point. It\n               goes directly to whether people are being taxed on what their property is truly worth\n               in the market or on a cleaner, fictional value that is more convenient for government\n               revenue. To be fair, the act still requires assessors to consider certain registered covenants,\n               but that only sharpens the question the minister should answer clearly, and we will\n               ask in committee stage, when unresolved asserted claims impair market value in practice,\n               is B.C. Assessment expected to reflect that reality or pretend it doesn't exist? Bill 2 is also about protecting the discretion of the executive and reducing legislative\n               scrutiny. It extends the period through which deficits may be forecast. It raises\n               the threshold for capital projects that must be specifically stated to the Legislative\n               Assembly, from $50 million to $125 million. That scopes out a lot of projects, including\n               projects we've seen delayed in this budget. Bill 2 also quietly reduces accountability for capital spending by changing the Budget\n               Transparency and Accountability Act threshold, as I previously mentioned. On its face,\n               that sounds like a technical adjustment. In Bill 2 also quietly reduces accountability for capital spending by changing the Budget\n               Transparency and Accountability Act threshold, as I previously mentioned. On its face,\n               that sounds like a technical adjustment. In practice, it means fewer major projects\n               are singled out and scrutinized. It means fewer projects are forced into the sunlight\n               of this House as distinct line items that members and the public can track. We saw\n               how important that was in this budget, with the significant changes in the delivery\n               date, if ever, of a number of long-term-care facilities. The government will argue that inflation and construction costs justify this change,\n               but that argument is backwards. If project costs are rising and the risk of overruns\n               is rising, transparency should go up, not down. When the stakes get bigger, the reporting\n               should get sharper, not softer. This is not happening in isolation. This government's approach to infrastructure accountability\n               has a pattern. In the Ministry of Infrastructure service plan, the government does\n               not even publish a clear, measurable, on-time budget target. They acknowledge they\n               will develop specific objectives and performance measures later, to be determined. That is the opposite of what the public expects, especially from a ministry created\n               to deliver projects on time and on budget, which now can't even define a target for\n               delivering projects on time and on budget. British Columbians don't want a government\n               that comes back after the fact and says: \"We will decide what success looks like in\n               next year's document.\" Put those two choices together, and the direction is obvious. First, they avoid clear\n               targets on whether projects are delivered on time and on budget. Then they raise the\n               reporting threshold so fewer projects have to be specifically stated to this House.\n               That is not better governance. That is reduced accountability by design. If this government is truly confident in its capital management, it should be willing\n               to measure performance openly and report more, not less. A serious government sets\n               clear targets, reports consistently and accepts scrutiny. This bill moves in the opposite\n               direction. Then there is perhaps the most revealing part of this bill. After raising taxes on\n               paycheques, expanding the PST, squeezing homeowners and protecting the tax base wherever\n               it can, this government also decided to abolish the independent Office of the Merit\n               Commissioner. Not reform it. Not strengthen it. Not modernize it. Abolish it. An office created in 2001 to provide independent oversight of whether appointments\n               in the B.C. public service are actually based on merit is being folded into the very\n               machinery it is supposed to oversee. Bill 2 removes the Merit Commissioner as an officer\n               of the Legislature, redefines the Merit Commissioner as the head of the B.C. Public\n               Service Agency acting in that capacity, repeals the core independent oversight provisions\n               and routes reporting to a minister instead of this House. The government will try to dress this up as efficiency or cost savings, but the annual\n               budget for the office is about $1.7 million. That's a lot of money, but in the scale\n               of a provincial budget, it's pocket lint, and even the outgoing commissioner warned\n               publicly that the cost of losing independent oversight may far exceed the savings\n               from eliminating a small oversight body. He pointed out that a non-partisan, multiparty\n               legislative committee approved a three-year budget for the office only months earlier\n               and recognized its role in upholding merit-based practices. So this is not some obvious, commonsense cleanup of a stale institution. It is the\n               government wilfully choosing to get rid of an independent watchdog that the Legislature\n               had literally just affirmed. The timing is awfully convenient, is it not? Because this is not happening after a\n               long run of glowing audit results and perfect confidence in the system. The Merit\n               Commissioner's own materials noted an increase in \"merit not applied\" findings and\n               a decrease in \"merit\" findings. The office's reporting showed \"merit not applied\"\n               findings rising to 10 percent. The commissioner then said publicly that the most recent\n               audit found the highest rate of flawed hiring processes and outcomes in nearly a decade. So this government's answer to rising concerns about merit is not more scrutiny. It's\n               less. Their answer to a watchdog raising alarms is to take away the watchdog. That is what makes this so politically revealing. The government is not eliminating\n               an office because the problem disappeared. It is eliminating an office because the\n               office still mattered. When trust in institutions matters, when competition for jobs\n               is tighter, that is exactly when independent oversight becomes more important, not\n               less. Bill 2 does not merely rename the office. It guts the very architecture of independence.\n               It repeals the provisions dealing with appointment, audit, review and dismissal processes.\n               It strips away powers to compel answers and disclosure. It changes the annual report\n               so it goes to the minister, not the Legislative Assembly. And then, in the transitional provisions, it dissolves\n               the office and transfers its property, records, liabilities and unspent budget to\n               the Ministry of Finance. It defangs and neuters the watchdog. That is not an efficiency measure. That is a consolidation of control. It is the executive branch taking the files, taking the budget, taking the reporting line and taking the oversight\n               in-house. There's also a transparency problem here. Bill 2 removes the Office of the Merit Commissioner\n               from the list of public bodies under FOIPPA and creates a carve-out so records held by or for the Merit Commissioner, or related to the commissioner's\n               functions before this amendment, are outside the normal access route. The government will say privacy protections still apply, and technically, that's true.\n               But the political fact remains. This bill abolishes an independent office and at the\n               same time creates a special rule that makes access to its old records harder through\n               the ordinary public route. For a government already known for secrecy, that's not a good look. Not a good look\n               at all. They're burying the records, sweeping them under a rug, shutting down the\n               watchdog. That should tell you exactly what you need to know, and that is that this\n               government has something to hide. There's another layer of irony here. The office's mandate was expanded in 2018 to\n               include dismissal reviews. More recently, that work was affirmed as important and\n               meant to remain independent from government. Yet now, through a bill — a budget bill,\n               of all things — the government is scrapping that independent structure and handing\n               the function to the bureaucracy itself. That is not just inconsistent. It is cynical.\n               It says independence is important right up until independence becomes inconvenience. So let us be plain about what is happening here. This government is abolishing an\n               independent office that exists to make sure public service hiring is based on merit at the very moment that the office is reporting more problems in\n               the system. It is moving oversight from the Legislature into the executive, it is weakening transparency around the old records, and it calls that progress. British Columbia needs high-quality public servants chosen on merit, not a system\n               where friends and insiders can be rewarded with cushy jobs while taxpayers are told\n               to trust the same government that just fired the referee. Taken together, Bill 2 tells British Columbians exactly what this NDP government is\n               about. More tax on work. More tax on services people rely on. Less relief for rural\n               and northern homeowners. Higher carrying costs for people who defer property taxes so they can stay in their homes. More room for\n               government discretion. Less legislative scrutiny. And above all of that, the abolition\n               of an independent office that exists to make sure merit, fairness and accountability\n               still mean something in the public service. This bill is not just a budget implementation bill. It is a statement of priorities,\n               and those priorities are badly out of step with what British Columbia needs right\n               now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327951","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Bill 2 also contains a technical-looking amendment to the Assessment Act. That deserves much more scrutiny than it will probably get. It amends section 19 of\n               the Assessment Act by adding a new subsection, 19(6.1). Here is the government's wording. Subject to subsections (5) and (7), in determining actual value, the assessor is not\n               required to consider any restriction ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a0d78b62662c977f761c6dbe6b2be59d5e97e1c6f951857b26cc2377c519ef35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fedf56cd78890de75e811ac28df14d8382dcdc035ee2f5f759b80827a5abb5b2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04e21b68c6b8ea7892f02a8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360141,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's not just the NDP's approval ratings that are on life support. The Canadian dream\n               is dying in B.C. Eighty-six percent of 18- to 44-year-olds who don't already own a\n               home have given up — 86 percent. Housing prices are astronomical. We met yesterday with home builders who told us the PST hike will add up to $5,000 Eighty-six percent of 18- to 44-year-olds who don't already own a home have given\n               up. Eighty-six percent. Housing prices are astronomical. We met yesterday with home\n               builders who told us the PST hike will add up to $5,000 to every single-family home\n               and even more for multi-family residentials. What consultation and analysis did the government do on the affordability impact of\n               their PST hike, and will they table those reports today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360141","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's not just the NDP's approval ratings that are on life support. The Canadian dream\n               is dying in B.C. Eighty-six percent of 18- to 44-year-olds who don't already own a\n               home have given up — 86 percent. Housing prices are astronomical. We met yesterday with home builders who told us the PST hike will add up to $5,000 Eighty-six percent of 18- to 44-year-olds who don't ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c00677832942cbdd3d9e3f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360142,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin my speech, I would just like to say to Adam that, you know what? You\n               keep on going. The first time I ran for something, I got 9 percent of the vote. And here I am, here\n               in this Legislative Assembly. You keep on running. You keep competing. You keep on\n               leading. And one day, you'll be sitting down here, Adam. Thanks guys, appreciate you visiting. I rise to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. At one level,\n               this is a technical bill. It deals with complaint handling, dispute resolution, appeals\n               and enforcement under the Employment Standards Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker\n               Protection Act. But as is often the case in this place, technical does not mean unimportant. This bill goes to the heart of whether our employment standards system is actually\n               working for the people who depend on it, and the test of that should be pretty simple. If a worker is owed wages, can they get them in a fair and timely way? If an employer\n               is wrongly hit with a determination, can they get a fair hearing without being crushed\n               by process and cost before they can even get out of the gate? And does the system\n               actually work in the real world, not just on paper and in ministers' speaking notes? That is the lens we should bring to this bill because I think everyone in this House\n               agrees on the basic principle: workers deserve to be paid what they're owed. That\n               should not be controversial. Employment standards laws exist for a reason. They exist because wages earned should\n               be wages paid. They exist because vulnerable workers need protection. And they exist\n               because a race to the bottom helps nobody except the worst actors. But healthy workplaces also require something this government too often forgets, balance.\n               Responsible employers need rules that are clear, fair and workable. And that matters,\n               especially for small businesses, because, unlike government, they cannot just absorb\n               every new process, every delay, every administrative requirement and every upfront\n               cost as though cash flow is just some minor detail. For a small business, cash flow\n               is not a detail. Cash flow is survival. There's a reason they say cash is king. That is exactly why government needs to think harder about the cumulative pressure\n               it is putting on small employers, because this issue and this policy do not exist\n               in a vacuum. British Columbia has had some of the weakest small business confidence in the country. We have what some have called an entrepreneurial drought. At a time when we should be making it easier to start, grow and sustain a business,\n               too many people are looking at the landscape and deciding it's just not worth the\n               risk. Small businesses are already being squeezed from every direction. They're dealing\n               with higher insurance costs, higher borrowing costs, higher wages, higher lease costs\n               and, in too many communities, higher public safety costs as well, particularly in\n               our storefront small business downtown areas. When disorder rises, when theft rises, when vandalism rises, when staff do not feel\n               safe opening or closing a business, that is not some abstract social problem. It lands\n               on the balance sheet of a small business. It means more spending on security systems,\n               more spending on private security, more losses from theft, more damage from vandalism,\n               more staff turnover, more time spent managing crises that have nothing to do with\n               serving customers or growing the business. That is a cash flow hit. Then government adds the PST to professional services that small businesses rely on\n               to operate responsibly. Accounting, bookkeeping, other outside expertise that many\n               small businesses need because they do not have in-house specialists. These are not\n               luxuries. These are not optional extras. These are basic operating supports. So when\n               government taxes those inputs These are not luxuries. These are not optional extras. These are basic operating supports.\n               So when the government taxes those inputs, it's not taxing access. It's taxing the\n               machinery of compliance and basic business administration, and it is squeezing margins\n               to the breaking point for many small businesses. That is another cash flow hit. For a large company, maybe those hits are absorbable. For a small business, they stack.\n               They compound. They arrive before the revenue does. They arrive whether the month\n               is good or bad. They arrive whether or not the owner has paid themselves. That is\n               why this bill deserves closer scrutiny than the government may want to give it. Now, one of the big questions here is whether this system is delivering timely justice\n               now. On the government's own numbers, it clearly is not. The ministry's service plan\n               shows that over the past four years, only about 32 percent of complaints were resolved\n               within 180 days. Think about that. That means about two-thirds of workers filing complaints\n               are waiting more than six months — more than six months to recover wages they may\n               need for rent, groceries, gas, child care and basic life. Then the government pats itself on the back for setting a future target of 80 percent\n               within 180 days. But let us stop and think about that target for a second. Even if\n               they hit it, and they are nowhere close right now, that still means one in five workers\n               could wait more than six months. That is the definition of a system that is not working\n               well enough. There's another problem here. Government is measuring how quickly files are closed,\n               not necessarily whether justice is done. A file can be closed because it is dismissed.\n               It can be closed because it is withdrawn. It can be closed because somebody, under\n               pressure, takes a settlement. File closure is not the same thing as a fair outcome. So before the government congratulates itself for procedural reform, maybe it should\n               first explain why the existing system is still so slow. Because this is unfortunately\n               the pattern with this government. They under-resource the system, let it drift and\n               then come back with process changes and hope nobody notices the capacity problem underneath. And there is a capacity problem underneath. The ministry's own budget shows labour\n               program funding basically flat at about $22.3 million over the next three years. In\n               fact, it is slightly below last year's restated estimate. So here is the obvious question:\n               how exactly is the employment standards branch supposed to improve performance dramatically\n               with no meaningful increase in resources. That is not a serious plan. That is wishful\n               thinking with a press release attached. If the branch is expected to investigate better, resolve faster, protect vulnerable\n               workers and enforce the law more effectively, then it needs the staff and capacity\n               to do the work. Otherwise, what happens? Investigators get pressured to move files,\n               timelines become the priority and the temptation becomes to close complaints rather\n               than fully resolve them. That is not fair to workers, and it's not fair to good employers\n               either. Now, Bill 10 absolutely does contain some ideas that sound very reasonable at first\n               glance. A more formal complaint resolution process could help resolve straightforward\n               matters faster. In principle, that's absolutely fine. Nobody benefits from disputes\n               lingering forever. But we do need to think clearly about incentives and power imbalances\n               here. Where there is a vulnerable worker facing an employer with more resources, a settlement\n               process can become a pressure process. It can become a mechanism for resolving the\n               file rather than delivering the full justice the worker is owed. So yes, resolution\n               can be useful, but only if it is genuinely fair and proportionate. On the other side of the equation, government also needs to understand that what looks\n               like a modest procedural step from Victoria can feel very different on the ground\n               for a small business owner in Kelowna, Prince George, Surrey, Nanaimo, Richmond or\n               Abbotsford. A large corporation may have HR staff, legal counsel, payroll staff and compliance\n               people. A small business owner has none of that. They are the HR department. They\n               are the operations department. They are the one trying to make payroll on Friday and\n               still So when government adds a mandatory resolution process — another set of forms, another\n               appearance, another time-consuming step — it's not free and it's not no-impact. It costs time. It costs money. It costs attention. And for\n               small businesses, those costs are often front-loaded. That matters. It matters because large organizations can usually absorb front-loaded compliance\n               costs. Small businesses often can't. Some are operating on such thin margins that\n               a broken window is not a nuisance; it's a serious blow. One unexpected cost, one expense\n               that has to be paid immediately, can throw everything off. It can mean the difference\n               between getting a cheque from your small business that month and writing a cheque\n               to your small business. That is why front-loaded costs matter so much, especially\n               when this bill may require a small employer to put money up front before they can\n               even access an appeal. That brings me to the appeal deposit requirement, which is probably the sharpest issue\n               in this bill. Bill 10 would require an employer appealing a wage determination to\n               deposit the amount owing, or a smaller amount set by the tribunal, before the appeal\n               can proceed. Government will say this is about stopping frivolous appeals and making\n               sure workers are protected from delay tactics. And those are laudable goals. Fair\n               enough. There is logic there. But logic only takes you halfway. Then you have to ask what happens in the real world.\n               What happens when a small business believes the determination is wrong but does not\n               have the cash to post the full amount up front? What happens when the appeal may be legitimate but the cost of access to the\n               appeal process is itself prohibitive? That is not a theoretical problem. That is a\n               real access-to-justice problem. Appeals exist because decision-makers can be wrong. Systems need checks. Facts can\n               be disputed. Errors can happen. But if the price of entry is too high, especially\n               in upfront cash terms, then for some employers, the right to appeal becomes mostly fictional. And again, it is the front-loaded nature of the cost that matters. A small business\n               might survive an eventual liability. What it cannot survive is having a large amount\n               of cash tied up immediately, while also covering payroll, rent, supplier invoices,\n               taxes and everything else government keeps piling on, including a public safety crisis. This government consistently underestimates how damaging front-loaded costs can be.\n               It's not just the amount. It's the timing and the inflexibility. The timing is what\n               can kill you. Yes, the tribunal can reduce the deposit amount. But how that discretion\n               will actually work matters a great deal. Is it clear? Is it predictable? Is it accessible, or does a small employer have to incur yet more cost hiring a lawyer just to ask for\n               relief from a rule that is already choking them to death? Those are questions this\n               House should not just hand wave through. There's also a consultation issue here. Employer groups have indicated they were not\n               aware these changes were coming and were not meaningfully consulted in advance. That's\n               consistent with a lot of the changes that we see from this government, and it's not\n               a small point. Labour law works best when government actually bothers to talk to the\n               people who have to live under it, both workers and employers and advocates, people\n               on the ground. Instead, this government often behaves as though consultation is optional and as though\n               whatever good intention they claim at the front end automatically guarantees a good\n               result at the back end. Intentions versus effects. That's not how good policy-making\n               works. Good intentions are nice. Incentives, implementation and consequences matter\n               more. The fine print matters. We should also keep in mind the broader cost environment small businesses are operating\n               in right now. They are already dealing with higher costs, weak confidence and more\n               government-imposed burden, including a public safety We should also keep in mind the broader cost environment small businesses are operating\n               in right now. They're already dealing with higher costs, weak confidence and more\n               government-imposed burden, including a public-safety crisis exacerbated by this government's\n               reckless drug decriminalization experiment and exacerbated even further by their tone-deaf,\n               poorly timed addition of PST to the security services people are being forced to pay\n               for because police can't keep up with the vandalism and violence created by this government's\n               failed policies. When government piles on another procedural cost, another compliance hurdle, another\n               upfront financial barrier, it should not act surprised when small business owners\n               say: \"Enough.\" Temporary foreign workers also deserve real attention in this bill. They are often\n               among the most vulnerable people in our labour market. If government is serious about\n               protecting them, enforcement has to be real, timely and accessible. It cannot just\n               be theoretical. That means not only having rules on the books but having a system that actually works\n               for people. And that is really the larger question hanging over Bill 10. Is this government\n               truly fixing the system or just rearranging it? Is it improving justice or just changing\n               process? Is it building something more credible or is it trying to paper over weak\n               performance with technical amendments? Those are fair questions. Yes, workers absolutely deserve strong protections. Yes,\n               bad actors should not be allowed to game the system. Yes, temporary foreign workers\n               deserve meaningful enforcement of their rights. But employers, especially small businesses,\n               especially good actors who play by the rules, also deserve a system that is fair,\n               understandable and grounded in the economic reality they live with every single day. That means government has to think seriously about the cash flow implications of this\n               policy for businesses that are struggling just to get by; for businesses who are seeing\n               a rising cost of living as individuals and have no more money they can take out of\n               their companies; for businesses that are seeing their margins compressed; for businesses\n               who are seeing weak consumer confidence result in lower consumer discretionary spending,\n               affecting their businesses; for businesses who are seeing the effect of tariffs diminish\n               their revenues; for businesses that are struggling in a weak economy brought on by\n               nine years of failed economic and fiscal policies. Government has to think seriously about the front-loaded costs of this bill. It has\n               to think about administrative burden. It has to stop pretending that a small business\n               with two or three or ten employees is in the same position as a large corporation\n               with an HR department and outside counsel on speed-dial. Bill 10 raises real questions about balance, fairness, consultation, cost and capacity.\n               Those questions deserve careful examination in this House and in committee. We look\n               forward to that next step.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360142","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Before I begin my speech, I would just like to say to Adam that, you know what? You\n               keep on going. The first time I ran for something, I got 9 percent of the vote. And here I am, here\n               in this Legislative Assembly. You keep on running. You keep competing. You keep on\n               leading. And one day, you'll be sitting down here, Adam. Thanks guys, appreciate you vis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2407f83e284e6c590b3a3039fd77e2940073c0205d55bee4c95c8e4bd2f00b37"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31fb5d729ab32fa09418aa322c8c85ffbc74f23bf3e306b3881c9b0cfc9d819e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb6cdd9cf6b0cab2c7b74668","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360143,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"That's a hard one to follow, for my friend from Vernon-Lumby, but I'll do my best. Just at lunch, myself and the Please join me to welcome my family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360143","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"That's a hard one to follow, for my friend from Vernon-Lumby, but I'll do my best. Just at lunch, myself and the Please join me to welcome my family.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037349","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Textiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037349","label":"Textiles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a91efdc0888d9689aecb30b2d14a803b3eec250b19506ab4d03afdc9dae9b50b","86cf311917a6578d967067dfd357a7e10bebbadfd806711c5f92fba158369970","85111d12b9c4e3cf2ac0d546f438cdcb67c7de3ada7c868a8740f5a4eceb9c51"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f6ba85bc429a21107fcaff1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415707,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I join the member opposite for Surrey City Centre in welcoming my friends from the Vaapsi recovery home, especially my old friend Amar\n               Randhawa, my friend Kirit Chutla, as well as Gurmukh Ajla and Ropu Singh. Thank you very much for being here today. Thank you very much for the work that you\n               are doing to advance B.C.'s first culturally responsive sober living home for Punjabi\n               men. This is obviously very important work. I think that across this House, we share a belief that recovery is possible and that\n               your work is very important. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415707","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I join the member opposite for Surrey City Centre in welcoming my friends from the Vaapsi recovery home, especially my old friend Amar\n               Randhawa, my friend Kirit Chutla, as well as Gurmukh Ajla and Ropu Singh. Thank you very much for being here today. Thank you very much for the work that you\n               are doing to advance B.C.'s first culturally responsive sober living home for","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","label":"Commercial buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30b645a63dda427dacdeb1446a0dc496e43a6fc03bc5b04ac5d27714b932e37d","44b7234dfed53265957a66036497ad53d88115584371238e06c0a8af6467ed3a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a30391b6b4072f0d4e3c7e221d4630f9657f9bb6fbf631bf00628288d0f9c9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-128759b35763408f1a1bb65e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415708,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know she has already been acknowledged in a different capacity twice, but I would\n               just like to take a moment to acknowledge my friend M.J. Whitemarsh and to acknowledge\n               her long service on the Small Business Roundtable, her many years of contribution\n               in that regard and those of her fellow former members of that group.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415708","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I know she has already been acknowledged in a different capacity twice, but I would\n               just like to take a moment to acknowledge my friend M.J. Whitemarsh and to acknowledge\n               her long service on the Small Business Roundtable, her many years of contribution\n               in that regard and those of her fellow former members of that group.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69e1252c26dd5259b4b34877","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720234,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let's talk about jobs. A job is the best social program ever invented. It gives people\n               a paycheque, dignity, independence and the chance to build a life. It helps families\n               get ahead, gives young people their first rung on the ladder, and gives communities\n               stability. That is why jobs matter, and that is why private sector jobs matter. Private sector jobs are what build an economy that can actually sustain everything\n               else we care about. They create the tax base that pays for health care, schools, roads\n               and public safety. When the private sector is growing, families can get ahead, communities\n               can thrive, and government can fund public services on a stable foundation, but when\n               the private sector is weak, everything else gets harder. That is the story of British\n               Columbia under this failing NDP government. In February, B.C. lost 20,000 jobs; in March, it lost another 19,000. In February,\n               full-time employment fell by 32,500, while part-time employment rose by 12,300. In\n               March, full-time employment fell by 23,700, while part-time employment rose by 4,600. This is not just a story of jobs disappearing. It is a story of stronger, more secure\n               work being replaced by weaker and less secure work. B.C.'s unemployment rate has now\n               climbed to 6.7 percent, the highest non-pandemic level for this province since February\n               of BC's unemployment rate has now climbed to 6.7 percent, the highest non-pandemic level\n               for this province since February of 2016, a decade ago. The deeper problem is not\n               just two bad months. It's a longer pattern of failure, excuses and settling for mediocrity.\n               British Columbia has had the worst private sector job growth in Canada since 2019.\n               Even the Business Council of British Columbia has warned that BC's private sector\n               job engine has lost momentum. People are tired of this government talking about Trump, posturing on pipelines and\n               pointing the finger everywhere but themselves. This government loves picking winners\n               and losers and paying for photo ops with their taxpayer-funded slush funds. But they\n               have been inadequately focused on something even more fundamental: the underlying\n               conditions for broad-based, grassroots, bottom-up private investment and growth. Job creation does not start with government press releases. It starts with the corner\n               store, the restaurant, the contractor, the small manufacturer, the start-up and the\n               family business deciding whether to hire one more person. And what are those employers\n               telling us? CFIB surveys show that small businesses in British Columbia face some\n               of the highest concerns in Canada over labour laws, tax burden and local government\n               costs. And the problem is not any one single measure. It is death by a thousand small cuts,\n               including hidden costs like credit card fees and WorkSafe premiums on employee tips.\n               Some of these changes are obviously well-intentioned. Some are unquestionably positive\n               for workers, but balance and timing matter. This government never quite seems to understand that each additional requirement,\n               each extra payroll cost, each new administrative obligation lands on the same small\n               employer already trying to keep the lights on and make payroll. Small businesses cannot\n               create jobs if they can't survive. At exactly the wrong moment, this government is\n               expanding the PST to professional services. That means higher input costs for businesses\n               that rely on professional services. This government has kicked job creators when they\n               are down. You can't build an economy by endlessly increasing the burden on the very people expected\n               to do the hiring. You can't build lasting prosperity by growing government while the\n               economy that pays for it stalls. B.C. needs a real private sector jobs agenda that\n               restores confidence; cuts red tape; lowers the cost of hiring and growth; and understands\n               that prosperity must be unlocked and built, not simply announced. Because in the end,\n               private sector jobs are the foundation of opportunity for strong families, strong\n               communities and a strong province. British Columbians have every right to demand better. And soon a new Conservative\n               government will replace excuses with results and deliver the jobs, growth and opportunity\n               every day hard-working British Columbians deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720234","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's talk about jobs. A job is the best social program ever invented. It gives people\n               a paycheque, dignity, independence and the chance to build a life. It helps families\n               get ahead, gives young people their first rung on the ladder, and gives communities\n               stability. That is why jobs matter, and that is why private sector jobs matter. Private sector jobs","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24029a284296f35afe68df6c8e47bbcdfda3d1339f3a7e205870bf953e2bb341"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2d3792ced84681fbd677430370ae7eaf6938a413744b51c654367625b24d8b0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fce10551304cf7d8eaf5fce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720238,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 15, the Environmental Assessment Amendment Act of 2026. I think that, like many of my colleagues, I would start by establishing the basic\n               facts that the goals behind this bill are, of course, not unreasonable. We need to\n               strengthen alignment and coordination with Indigenous nations. We need to reduce conflict\n               and uncertainty in project reviews. Here as elsewhere, we need to create more stable\n               and predictable processes so that reviews can be understood, planned against and mapped\n               onto project management timelines, enabling greater certainty for projects as they\n               move forward. Those are eminently reasonable objectives that I think members all across this House\n               can very reasonably agree upon. I think, again, that the intent of this bill is certainly\n               very solid in that regard. For myself personally, and I think for those of us on this side of the House, we certainly\n               are very supportive of efforts to improve regulatory and process efficiency. We want\n               to see a coherent, functional, strong, institutionally oriented environmental assessment\n               process that can be looked to and relied upon with certainty and that positions British\n               Columbia as a jurisdiction, as a place in which our processes can be understood and\n               navigated in a reasonable fashion. So again, there is much to be pleased about in terms of the intention of this bill,\n               and that is certainly our disposition. With that said, those good intentions alone are not enough. It's important that we\n               obviously test through this process and through committee stage both the intent of\n               the legislation and also the effect of the legislation and whether it meets the test\n               of being clear, timely and workable in practice. I anticipate those are the kinds\n               of questions that we will canvass in further depths through the committee stage debate\n               on this bill. Centrally, I think the most salient issue that we really do still have some concerns\n               around is the absence of clear Centrally, I think the most salient issue that we really do still have some concerns\n               around is the absence of clear timelines. This set of changes creates new processes\n               but does not define how long they should take. That's crucially important. As someone who has been very involved in moving projects forward and in understanding\n               the financial implications of delay, it's very important that we understand that without\n               clear, predictable timelines, it's very difficult for projects to be planned, to be\n               mapped against seasonality, construction seasons, to even be clear from a financial\n               perspective. It is, of course, extremely important that project proponents are able\n               to understand what the kinds of project development costs might be. I've spent significant time working on major projects where delays in the permitting\n               process have resulted in very, very significant additional costs. When you're operating\n               on a burn rate that could be in the seven to eight figures a month and you encounter\n               unanticipated delays or unpredictable delays, that can be crippling for a project.\n               That can be extraordinarily difficult. In particular, it can be very, very difficult\n               to really understand the return on investment, the timeline, the commercial functions\n               of a project when you just don't know exactly how long processes will take. So while there are definitely some laudable efforts that are put forward by this legislation,\n               again, the concern is just around not having clarity at the outset around timeline. There are numerous references to the addition of new issue resolution protocols, technical\n               tables, leadership tables — a lot of processes, a lot of tables, a lot of meetings,\n               not a lot of firm timelines, not a lot of service standards, not a lot of clear deadlines\n               for decision-making. A lot of loose language: \"as soon as practicable,\" \"may enter into discussions,\" \"must\n               attempt to agree.\" I've negotiated a commercial contract or two in my day, and those\n               are the exact kinds of pieces of language that you see when somebody wants to sound\n               like they're committing to something while actually committing to nothing. These are not timelines. These are aspirations. Any reasonable counterparty who encountered\n               that kind of language in negotiating a commercial contract would very reasonably be\n               questioning the intent of that kind of language and wanting to understand just how\n               real the commitment being made actually was. As I say, these are somewhat slippery\n               weasel words that can allow a truck to be driven through them. They're good on intention\n               but very soft on actual binding, clear timelines that would provide individuals and\n               project proponents with the ability to understand exactly what they're getting into\n               from a timeline perspective. That matters because environmental assessments are not just abstract policy exercises.\n               They're not just fun conversations. They're extremely important, and it's very important\n               that they are diligent. It's very important that they fully consider all of the different\n               implications that could be there for projects. Certainly, we need to make sure that\n               we are diligent around the environmental assessments. It's also, of course, very important to understand that environmental assessments\n               are the gateway and the gatekeeper to major infrastructure projects, to natural resource\n               development, to clean energy projects and to economic growth in this province. That, I think, is the balance that is at the heart of this bill. Again, I think the intentions are there around trying to address that balance. It's\n               making sure that we are being fulsome and diligent in our environmental reviews while\n               also having greater clarity around the ways in which disputes can be resolved, around\n               the ways in which conflicts can be addressed and around the ways in which we move\n               forward. Those timelines are absolutely crucial because any proponent who is advancing a major\n               capital project is going to be looking at it through a series of risk gates and decision\n               gates and through considerations around timeliness. As they do so, it is going to\n               be consequential whether they can understand from government what the actual timelines\n               are. That again, I think, is an area that we'll have much more to say and much more to\n               ask about during committee stage on this in order to elicit a greater understanding\n               of the intent of government around those timelines. While that may well come forth in greater detail through regulation, as is the habit\n               of this government, we obviously will be asking questions in order to try to both\n               understand for our own purposes, but also provide While that may well come forth in greater detail through regulation, as is the habit\n               of this government, we obviously will be asking questions in order to try to both\n               understand for our own purposes but also provide clarity to individuals, investors,\n               project proponents and others who will be watching this debate very closely and looking\n               to understand exactly what they can reasonably expect in terms of any material changes\n               to the timeliness, the promptness, the clarity of timelines that are offered here. As members who have worked on projects, been on the governing side of projects, know\n               and understand, when timelines are unclear, projects stall. When timelines are unclear,\n               there can be knock-on effects that are extremely consequential, where a small delay\n               can become a long delay if it affects things like construction season and if it affects\n               loan covenants and other financial obligations. When there is uncertainty and when timelines are unclear, investment hesitates, because\n               anybody who has ever calculated an internal rate of return understands that time matters.\n               The discounted cash flow side of things matters. The time value of money matters. Being able to accomplish the same project and being able to do so on a timely basis\n               versus a basis that is delayed and unpredictable is very significant in terms of calculating\n               whether or not a project meets the hurdle rate that's necessary for it to exceed the\n               threshold of risk-adjusted return that would allow it to move forward. What I think, a lot of the time, people don't understand is that many of the projects\n               that are advanced in this jurisdiction and any other jurisdiction are being considered\n               by capital allocators who are deciding between different projects in different jurisdictions.\n               There might be a great project here. There might be a great project somewhere else.\n               If they cannot get clear certainty and timeliness in terms of the project that they're\n               advancing here, they're not going to do it, in many cases. Again, often that comes down to uncertainty. We are living, in British Columbia, at\n               a time of considerable uncertainty where, across Canada and in British Columbia in\n               particular, we have created greater and greater uncertainty on the land base. That's\n               very problematic. I think we have a tendency as Canadians to conflate safety and risk. Certainly, when\n               the Minister of Mines engages with international companies who are considering investing\n               in British Columbia, I'm confident that he makes the argument that we are a safe,\n               democratic, solid jurisdiction with rule of law. By comparison, other jurisdictions\n               that they might be contemplating mining in could be higher risk, higher possibility\n               of there being significant risks to the safety of individual workers. But the fact that there is a much lower likelihood of armed militias, the fact that\n               there is a much lower likelihood of threats to life safety or of kleptocratic regimes\n               in a jurisdiction like this does not necessarily mean that, from a quantifiable investment-risk\n               perspective, risk is lower. That's the great challenge that we have as a jurisdiction, as Canada and as British\n               Columbia. When individual companies, mining companies for example, are comparing their\n               jurisdictional risk analysis, when they're looking at country risk analysis, when\n               they're looking at subnational risk analysis, when they're looking at British Columbia\n               or at a region within British Columbia, they're evaluating all the different factors\n               that go into their decision-making. And that obviously includes other elements of\n               risk. Timeline is a huge risk. Uncertainty around environmental assessments, how disputes\n               are resolved, etc. — those are all very, very significant risks that can affect capital\n               allocation and can affect decisions to move toward final investment decisions. It's very important that we take a very fulsome look at this, which again, I think\n               is very much the intent of much of this bill — to try to create greater certainty,\n               to create those resolution processes, to create greater predictability. But there is more that we could do with this. There's greater clarity that we could\n               offer to markets, particularly in terms of the timeliness with which decisions are\n               made and the clarity of timelines, the clarity of service standards, the clarity against\n               which folks can reasonably expect that their projects will be evaluated. Again, investors don't make decisions based on goodwill. They don't make decisions\n               based on what a nice friendly guy the Minister of Mines is, although he is a nice\n               and friendly guy. They make decisions on the basis of the totality of factors, and\n               among that totality of factors, obviously, is the timeliness with which decisions\n               are made. We will, in the course of our questioning at committee stage, be asking detailed questions\n               that would drive toward a greater understanding of that timeliness. Again, British Columbia does not operate in isolation. We're not alone in the world.\n               We're not in a vacuum. We are not the only place where people could allocate capital\n               to move projects forward. We are competing with other Canadian jurisdictions, competing\n               with other Canadian provinces and territories. We're competing with U.S. states, and we're competing with global jurisdictions. In\n               every one of those places, companies that are moving forward are engaging in national\n               and subnational We are competing with other Canadian jurisdictions, we're competing with other Canadian\n               provinces and territories, we're competing with U.S. states and we're competing with\n               global jurisdictions. And in every one of those places, companies that are moving\n               forward are engaging in national and subnational risk analysis, which includes an\n               understanding of what the environmental assessment processes that they will be expected\n               to go through look like, how they fit together, what kind of timeliness they can expect\n               in moving through those processes. When they decide whether to invest, they're looking at how long will approvals take,\n               how predictable is the process, what risks exist of delay, and what precedents can\n               be seen in terms of unexpected risks and unexpected delays that could cause significant\n               heartburn or could cause significant increases in the overall capital costs required\n               to advance a project, whether that be greater costs that are required from a significant\n               capital side or simply needing to keep a team up and running for longer — a team of\n               consultants, a team of staff, a team of lawyers, a team of project management experts. When you're burning seven or eight figures a month, that's very, very significant.\n               Even if you're a small project, it can be very, very material in terms of just understanding\n               what your return on investment is and whether you still like that return on investment. So, if our answer to the questions being asked by those companies that are considering\n               investment here in British Columbia is that there's a process but there's no clear\n               timeline, that's just not good enough. That actually puts us at a disadvantage relative\n               to other jurisdictions that are moving in the opposite direction, where they're doing\n               their utmost to provide clear timelines, streamlined approvals and defined escalation\n               processes. If B.C. can't offer that same clarity, we obviously risk falling behind. Again, I think that an understanding of elements of that is certainly in this bill.\n               There are lots of positives in this bill, but we really just are not convinced that\n               there is quite enough there and that all those questions are adequately addressed. Looking deeper into the bill, obviously there are some other elements that we will\n               be examining further. That includes the new issue resolution protocol framework, which\n               on paper sounds very constructive. Certainly, having early engagement is important\n               and good. Having structured dialogue and an escalation pathway, those are good and\n               positive things that we certainly, I think, would all want to see. But I return again to that issue of timeliness. There is, as it stands, no requirement\n               that discussions conclude within a set time. Having discussions is great. Having processes\n               and structures and ways of going about discussing and trying to address issues or\n               address conflicts is certainly a very good and positive thing that we should endeavour\n               toward. But if there is no requirement, if there is no ticking time clock, no shot\n               clock, then that certainly is problematic in terms of our ability to give confidence\n               to project proponents that they can expect their projects to move forward on a timely\n               basis. If there is no deadline to finalize a protocol and if there's no consequence if negotiations\n               stall, then, again, that is significant delay risk in which there's a real risk that\n               pre-assessment phases could stretch indefinitely. We want to make sure that we're\n               actually getting clarity, we're actually getting timeliness, we're actually getting\n               a clear understanding of exactly how this will work from an investment perspective. Obviously, the bill also addresses technical tables and leadership tables, bringing\n               together a more formal structure. That is a reasonable idea. But again, we see no\n               timelines for meetings, no timelines for resolutions, no limits on how long issues\n               can sit unresolved. These are crucial questions that project proponents would reasonably\n               be asking if they were looking at this legislation. Hence, of course, we are asking\n               those questions. We'll be providing opportunity for the minister to provide greater clarity around\n               the thinking on that front, recognizing that we obviously expect that some further\n               detail will be fleshed out in regulation, fleshed out operationally. We do still want\n               to understand from the minister what the thinking and intention is there, or at least\n               just understand that there is an understanding of the importance of timeliness within\n               the process. As I look at the dispute resolution elements of the bill, this replaces the previous\n               system. It requires parties to agree on terms and on a facilitator, but if they can't\n               agree, the process doesn't proceed at all. That alone is obviously a major concern. But even where agreement is reached, there is no timeline for reaching agreement or\n               conducting the process. That is certainly challenging in terms of ensuring that there\n               is timeliness to the process, predictability of the process and an ability for both\n               project proponents and for the individuals who might be advising them to understand\n               what they're getting into and to understand how this will all proceed. Because in\n               the absence of that clarity, key project decisions could be delayed indefinitely. One phrase that certainly stands out that is used repeatedly in the bill is \"as soon\n               as practicable,\" which One phrase that certainly stands out that is used repeatedly in the bill is \"as soon\n               as practicable,\" which, again, is fairly conventional legal language. We've all seen\n               it in the gazillion contracts. But again, when you see that language in a contract\n               — or, frankly, when you introduce that language into a contract — what you are doing\n               is providing wiggle room. That is language that is subjective, flexible and difficult to enforce. It does not\n               provide certainty, it does not provide accountability, and it does not provide predictability.\n               In a complex regulatory environment, that ambiguity can become delay. That delay can\n               become risk, and that risk can become lost investment. So these are the kinds of questions\n               and details that we certainly hope to see more of as this proceeds forward. It's very important to recognize that those impacts, that those timeliness questions\n               are crucial to building good and strong relationships and good and strong Indigenous\n               partnerships. It's very important to recognize that clear timelines can, in fact,\n               strengthen those relationships, set expectations, prevent fatigue and make sure that\n               things are moving forward on a clear and time-bound basis. Now let's talk for a moment about the economic consequences of the bill. As I previously\n               alluded to, delays in environmental assessments can be extraordinarily consequential\n               in terms of delaying construction, job creation, economic development, tax revenue,\n               infrastructure all across different sectors. I think that we all share, I believe,\n               across the aisle and across all parties and all independents in this House, a desire\n               to see projects move forward on a timely basis. Again, that's where we want to make\n               sure that we are being clearer around this, because capital is mobile. Capital can\n               leave. Capital can go elsewhere. Capital makes decisions on the basis of a set of\n               different factors, including timeliness and predictability. I'm reminded of the words, actually, of a former Premier, Glen Clark, who, at a very\n               interesting event a couple of years ago, said: \"Capital is a coward.\" Mr. Clark, I\n               believe, is correct in that regard. Capital seeks risk-adjusted return. Capital seeks\n               clarity. Capital seeks timeliness. Capital seeks an understanding of exactly what\n               it's being allocated against. That's not an emotional decision. That's often a hyper-rational,\n               quantifiable decision. The way in which we often talk about projects, the way in which they are reported\n               on in the media, the way in which they would be talked about in this House is often\n               as if the projects are anthropomorphized. They're people. They're emotional. They're\n               filled with story. They're filled with narrative. That's important too. The stories\n               around what projects do for us, the stories around the opportunities they unlock,\n               the stories around the jobs they create are good and important things. But stories and photo ops alone do not a project make. Clarity, predictability, timeliness,\n               quantifiable ability to understand exactly what are you getting into, exactly what\n               your timelines are and exactly what the implications of risk-adjusted return are,\n               are absolutely crucial to projects being able to move forward. That's why we'll continue,\n               as we move forward with this bill, to ask questions designed to elicit improvements\n               to the bill, to elicit a greater understanding of whether or not timeliness has been\n               adequately considered by the drafters of the bill and whether and how it will be made\n               clear moving forward. I think it's crucial to establish that we're not alone in asking those questions.\n               We are mildly disappointed that government has not thought more about those questions\n               before because many other jurisdictions have been more proactive in establishing clarity\n               around timelines. Other jurisdictions have introduced legislated timelines, they've\n               introduced maximum review periods, and they've introduced binding decision deadlines. Those are all things that do not entirely eliminate complexity, but they do create\n               predictability. They create discipline. They create the ability to map a project budget,\n               to map an understanding of the financial reward of a project against really clear\n               and established timelines. Things slide. Stuff happens. Nothing's ever perfect. But\n               I do think that there is opportunity for this bill to be strengthened, either through\n               amendments or as it is enacted, to ensure that we're being clearer around that timeliness,\n               that predictability, the ability to provide clear expectations and understanding to\n               proponents so that they can model exactly what they should reasonably expect when\n               moving a project through processes here in British Columbia. Again, this bill is positive in its overall direction and intention. It's something\n               that I can certainly see us being broadly supportive of. But it is a bit of a missed\n               opportunity to fully modernize the assessment system, to continue to strengthen collaboration\n               and efficiency, and some of that is missed. Time discipline is the most important\n               aspect that is missed here. There are good efforts toward modernization. There are\n               good efforts toward collaboration. There are good efforts toward efficiency. There are good efforts toward modernization, there are good efforts toward collaboration,\n               there are good efforts toward efficiency, there are good efforts toward conflict resolution,\n               and we look forward to hearing more about those and about the ways in which they'll\n               be implemented during committee stage. But once again, without clear timelines, without\n               time discipline, even well-designed processes can fail or become cumbersome or become\n               so frustrating that despite the fact that they are well-constructed, they become ineffective,\n               they become sources of conflict, they become sources of delay, simply because no clear\n               timeline has been established. I don't raise these concerns to oppose the bill outright. I don't raise these concerns\n               in any spirit other than constructive examination of the bill and of what might be\n               possible if amendments are brought or if conversation elicits an understanding that\n               through the regulatory process to follow there will be a greater emphasis on time\n               discipline. But I do think that they are extraordinarily important. I do think that they are absolutely\n               crucial to the signals that we are sending for project proponents with the bill and\n               also the signals that we are sending to individuals who might be taking part in these\n               processes as third parties, as concerned individuals, as communities. We owe everybody\n               that obligation of timeliness. We owe everybody the ability to understand exactly\n               what they're getting into. We owe them a clear, predictable, timely process, and that\n               simply just is a better process for everybody. Regardless of whether they're advocating for a project, advocating against a project\n               or simply trying to understand a project, the more we can be really, really clear\n               with timing, again, the better that is and the more of an investable jurisdiction\n               we really make ourselves at the level of granular detail that increasingly people\n               are looking at our province with. Unfortunately, as I mentioned earlier, we are at a time of considerable uncertainty\n               on the land base, which we need to do everything in our power to mitigate. There are\n               other broader conversations. Yes, some of them very political, but also some of them\n               legal, some of them very policy wonkish around how we can try to return stability\n               on the land base, how we can try to return greater clarity around property rights,\n               which are the fundamental cornerstone of any market economy. But again, when we are in that situation where some of the macro-level risk considerations\n               are very fluid, are very uncertain, and there are mixed signals going out to markets,\n               it's so important that the kind of detailed incremental nitty-gritty adjustments that\n               are being made in processes like the EA process are dialled in and are really clear\n               and are really specific and are really responsive to the kinds of considerations that\n               are going to be really major at the level of capital allocation. Because again, it's sometimes easy to forget that it's not just.... When it comes to\n               these huge giant major projects or to smaller mid-sized projects that are proceeding\n               through these kinds of evaluations, it's not just the PR and GR people that make the\n               decisions, folks. It's a lot of bean counters with a lot of Excel spreadsheets implementing\n               a lot of variables and a lot of spreadsheets and Gantt charts. They're making decisions as to whether or not they see the projects as being viable\n               on the basis of a whole range of different risk considerations. Some of those are\n               costs and costs escalation. Some of those are what kind of conditions might be imposed\n               on a project and what the associated cost of those conditions might be, and some of\n               those are very much around timelines. That's why it is so incredibly important that we dial in the timeliness factor in\n               this legislation, make it clearer, make it so that the individuals who are going to\n               be reporting back to their respective companies, proponents, etc., are able to look\n               at those and see in British Columbia what they need to see in order to help them establish\n               a balanced scorecard relative to the risks that could be faced by any project attempting\n               to move forward here in British Columbia. The kinds of suggestions that we may have through amendments or through questions\n               are not radical. They're not wild. I don't think that the conversation around this\n               bill need be particularly politicized, but I do think it's important that we delve\n               into common sense governance changes that would allow this to just be a little bit\n               clearer, a little bit better and a little bit more focused on timeliness. As I begin to wrap up, at its heart, I think this bill reflects attention that is\n               important between flexibility and certainty. It reflects, I think, again, an earnest\n               desire to try to create greater clarity, to try to create stronger processes, more\n               collaborative processes, processes through which we can advance projects. But without\n               boundaries, flexibility becomes unpredictability. Again, I return to the fact that this bill is lacking in increased transparency. It's\n               lacking in publication of reports. It's lacking in public Again, I return to the fact that this bill is lacking in increased transparency. It's\n               lacking in publication of reports. It's lacking in public explanations for decisions.\n               Those are questions that we found ourselves asking of many bills over the last number\n               of months. We're really just looking to make sure there's greater disclosure for the\n               public. We're looking to make sure that individuals who are trying to understand and\n               navigate these kinds of processes are able to have a precedent-based understanding\n               of what they can expect as they move through the process. We asked some of the same questions and asked for some of the same reporting around\n               recent legislation brought forward on interprovincial trade barriers, legislation\n               that we supported, legislation we felt was solid legislation, legislation that stakeholders\n               reported back that they were generally comfortable with. We asked questions around\n               what kind of reporting would be made available, and ultimately, we were disappointed\n               that government did not accept amendments to allow for basic transparency and basic\n               reporting. We will be asking again a lot of questions, as we get into detailed analysis in committee\n               stage, that focus on the practicability of the bill, that focus on the ways in which\n               it will work on the ground for individuals, companies and organizations proceeding\n               through it. As I say, we'll be very focused on the timeliness of the bill. In summation, British Columbia has enormous potential. We all want to unlock that\n               potential. We want to make sure we can advance projects that bring prosperity to communities,\n               to nations, to individuals, that create the private sector jobs that have been sorely\n               lacking in a jurisdiction that has the worst private sector job creation record over\n               the last number of years in all of Canada. In order to do that, we need to make sure\n               that we get this right. We need a regulatory system that is fair, collaborative and\n               that is predictable, particularly around timeliness. As I previously said, Bill 15 certainly takes steps in the right direction. I think\n               there are many laudable aspects of this bill, but without clear timelines, it risks\n               undermining its own goals and leaving uncertainty just at a time when it's absolutely\n               crucial that we create certainty. Certainty equals competitiveness. Timeliness equals\n               competitiveness. It is being competitive in a world where capital is being allocated\n               all over the place that will allow us to really capture and grow the great opportunity\n               we have here in British Columbia. Thank you very much, Madam Speaker. With that, I'm done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720238","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 15, the Environmental Assessment Amendment Act of 2026. I think that, like many of my colleagues, I would start by establishing the basic\n               facts that the goals behind this bill are, of course, not unreasonable. We need to\n               strengthen alignment and coordination with Indigenous nations. We need to reduce conflict\n               and uncertaint","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a819ad8809a976536d0b0cd8aa3265cfe72ed6f1a067fb90de9f7a76d1c0e13d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fcb4f9fad69c8a5c8ad86f7036bf5686255d8c2bbb451c09fc66cd9cc1232cb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-660253db7c8b9c4d4c831563","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720250,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled the Brain Injury Support Act, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. British Columbia continues to face an overdose crisis of historic proportions. More\n               than 18,000 people have died. Five or ten times as many have survived non-fatal overdoses\n               but not without lasting consequences. When overdoses deprive the brain of oxygen,\n               the result can be severe and permanent brain damage, affecting judgment, memory, emotional\n               regulation and behavioural control. When it happens repeatedly, as it so often does\n               in the context of toxic drug use, that damage can accumulate over time. For some of these individuals, tragically, full recovery will never be possible. Yet\n               despite the seriousness of that impairment, people living with acquired brain injuries\n               can still fall into a gap between systems, diagnoses and statutory categories. This bill adds a definition of \"brain injury\" to the Mental Health Act and clarifies\n               that where a brain injury significantly impairs judgment, emotional regulation or\n               behavioural control, it can be recognized within the act's framework for treatment\n               purposes. This is a focused and measured effort, not a sweeping change. It does not remove safeguards,\n               lower thresholds or alter review panel or court protections. It is a definitional\n               clarification intended to support more consistent application of the law. At its core, this bill rests on a simple principle. Access to appropriate, structured\n               care should depend on the level of impairment a person is experiencing, not on whether\n               their condition fits neatly within an incomplete diagnostic label. As we mourn a decade of losing loved ones, I hope this House can unite around this\n               small change that can make a big difference.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720250","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled the Brain Injury Support Act, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. British Columbia continues to face an overdose crisis of historic proportions. More\n               than 18,000 people have died. Five or ten times as many have survived non-fatal overdoses\n               but not without las","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7514608ee8f5dc6d9b552e9335d6d639bcb6b1d83c181659394dc67b20a6ad74"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72c9516f2253ec520faa153bc8857d9fab1b1b4a5a63799c0d5a37dc909fd348"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-513525a3fdd8f91a26e3cc4a","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187137,"date":"2026-04-14T12:00:00+00:00","title":"MENTAL HEALTH (BRAIN INJURY) \nAMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m242-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m242-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187137","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-090b996c834d439c8400ef7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720252,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the precinct today, we have a group from Innovative Medicines\n               Canada, led by Charles Brown, director of government affairs. The work of Innovative\n               Medicines Canada focuses on building strong partnerships, supporting effective policies\n               and improving Canada's regulatory environment. They're committed to ensuring Canadians\n               can access the treatments they need, while helping to strengthen and sustain our health\n               care system for generations to come. I would ask members of this House to please join me in making them very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720252","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. On the precinct today, we have a group from Innovative Medicines\n               Canada, led by Charles Brown, director of government affairs. The work of Innovative\n               Medicines Canada focuses on building strong partnerships, supporting effective policies\n               and improving Canada's regulatory environment. They're committed to ensuring Canadians\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034394","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034394","label":"Capital markets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a6602a179919e5880844fbdc28b2cd88dc2741025e3d59d6c3a83de9a21d015","8cf6229ccdc7db31066c9a2d701b52bb11bbc8c5f6c5fb504da1253eb6d93219","13c4485fe809e2650f281c5dc4a36287ea3cfb9766280e6a39eedfae0eacb721"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d5f203342e24af8bbcb8a52ea1e8e7d41dd8a772975f933ec46dd9d18d02c75"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c657d19c29d817fdaaad717","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720253,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Crime and the cost of doing business are causing an entrepreneurial drought in B.C.,\n               with more business closures than openings in six straight quarters. Six quarters. According to the CFIB, 63 percent of small business owners would not recommend starting\n               a business in B.C. today. The Solicitor General likes to quote the crime severity\n               index, but the reality is that 83 percent of businesses say they won't consistently\n               report crime to the police, because they don't believe it will accomplish anything. In Kelowna, the officer in charge of the RCMP says they can't out-police bad policy. When will this government take some accountability, restore public safety and stop\n               our small business economy from bleeding out?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720253","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Crime and the cost of doing business are causing an entrepreneurial drought in B.C.,\n               with more business closures than openings in six straight quarters. Six quarters. According to the CFIB, 63 percent of small business owners would not recommend starting\n               a business in B.C. today. The Solicitor General likes to quote the crime severity\n               index, but the rea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed20ae6ae5105a76cd6852347c7a9a8ca04d997aef168710572cac1d6d6f621f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["745d333f69acee9fa26ee3e9c3cb343ec2f30213fd9a6de88c8ef756527e921e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f5f34632e9b22e6ec8556b1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721337,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you. I appreciate the pre-emptive applause for what will surely be my most effective\n               speech today. I rise to speak in support of Bill M237, the Insurance (Vehicle) Amendment Act of\n               2026. This is a modest bill in form, but it addresses something very significant in\n               substance. At its core, this bill recognizes a simple truth. The loss of a limb is\n               a catastrophic injury. That should not be controversial. For the person who suffers that injury, it is life-changing in every sense. It is\n               physically devastating. It is emotionally devastating. It can affect mobility, independence,\n               employment, family life, mental health and a person's sense of dignity and normalcy.\n               It changes how someone moves through the world. It changes daily routines that most\n               of us take for granted. It changes the future they imagined for themselves and for\n               their family. When a person suffers that kind of loss in a motor vehicle accident, the insurance\n               system should meet the seriousness of the injury with an equally serious level of\n               support. Bill M237 would make two key changes. Firstly, it would extend the period within which\n               an individual can make a claim for benefits in respect of a catastrophic injury. That\n               is set out in clause 1 of the bill. Second — and most importantly, in my view — clause 2 would reduce the number of amputations\n               required for an insured individual to be deemed to have sustained a catastrophic injury.\n               Right now, the threshold is two. This bill would change that to one. That is the heart of the matter. Under the current framework, a person can lose one\n               limb — a hand, an arm, a foot, a leg — and still not be classified as catastrophically\n               injured for the purposes of access to benefits. I think most British Columbians would hear that and be stunned, because in ordinary\n               language and in moral terms, losing a limb is plainly catastrophic. It is not a minor\n               injury. It is not a moderate injury. It is not something from which life simply returns\n               to normal after a short recovery period. It is a profound and permanent loss. So the question before this House is whether our law should reflect that reality.\n               And I believe it should. Insurance law and benefit structures inevitably rely on definitions, thresholds and\n               categories. I understand that. Systems need rules. Administrators need clarity. But\n               those rules should still align with common sense and basic fairness, basic empathy.\n               When the law draws the line in the wrong place, it is our job, as legislators, to\n               move it. In this case, the line is in the wrong place. A person who has suffered the amputation of one limb will often require extensive\n               medical care, rehabilitation, adaptive equipment, prosthetics, home modifications,\n               counselling, occupational support and long-term assistance in rebuilding a life that\n               has been permanently altered. The costs are real. The burdens are real. The barriers are real. Most importantly,\n               the human impact is real. We should not be telling those individuals that their injury\n               is somehow not serious enough. We should not be telling them that they fall just short\n               of a threshold that any reasonable person would assume they had already crossed. This bill corrects that. It does not attempt to rewrite the entire insurance system.\n               It does not attempt to I also think clause 1 deserves support on its own merits. When someone suffers a catastrophic\n               injury, life does not become simpler. It becomes more complicated. There are surgeries,\n               treatments, appointments, assessments, paperwork, family adjustments, employment disruptions,\n               financial stress and, often, a long period of physical and emotional recovery. In\n               those circumstances, we should be careful about overly rigid claim windows. Extending\n               the period for making a claim reflects the reality that people dealing with catastrophic\n               injuries are often navigating the most difficult period of their lives and the lives\n               of their families. That, too, is a matter of fairness. This House often speaks about compassion. We often speak about supporting people through\n               tragedy. We often speak about ensuring that systems serve the public, rather than\n               forcing the public to serve the system. This bill gives us an opportunity to act on\n               those principles in a concrete way. And I think it is worth saying clearly that supporting\n               this bill is not about politics. It is about recognizing the lived reality of people\n               who have suffered devastating injuries, and ensuring that our laws do not compound\n               that hardship. If someone loses a limb in a motor vehicle accident, they should know that their public\n               insurance system sees the severity of that loss for what it is: catastrophic. That\n               word matters because classifications matter, and classifications matter because benefits\n               matter. The designation determines the level of support a person may be able to access.\n               It affects what help is available as they adapt to a new reality. In a moment of intense\n               loss and uncertainty, that support can make a profound difference. It can help someone\n               regain mobility. It can help someone return to work. It can help someone remain in\n               their home. It can help someone live with greater independence and dignity. That is what this bill is really about. Not an abstract regulatory amendment, not\n               a technical wording change, but whether people facing one of the worst days of their\n               lives receive the recognition and support that they deserve. In my view, they should.\n               This bill reflects a humane principle and a commonsense one. Losing one limb is enough.\n               It is enough to change a life, it is enough to justify stronger support, and it is\n               enough to meet the threshold of catastrophic injury. For those reasons, I support Bill M237 and I encourage all members of this House to\n               give it careful and favourable consideration.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721337","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you. I appreciate the pre-emptive applause for what will surely be my most effective\n               speech today. I rise to speak in support of Bill M237, the Insurance (Vehicle) Amendment Act of\n               2026. This is a modest bill in form, but it addresses something very significant in\n               substance. At its core, this bill recognizes a simple truth. The loss of a limb is\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","label":"Physical disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","label":"Physical disabilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["636c5cba42557e3e498078e75bd460537caeaf4a71672539feb2c2fba5ffd1a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["daa18ea05a568c649336c88ea7e5fb69d77f5e47c220db4a7fcc282cf73703dd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e56b21dca011cfd34f354169","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721340,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hallway health care has become shockingly routine under this NDP government. Front-line\n               staff are doing all they can in inadequate facilities, and they are absolutely devastated\n               by what's happening in our hospital hallways. After I raised the issue last week, I was made aware by a whistleblower of a young woman who tragically\n               died this month in the hallway of Kelowna General Hospital, and another hallway patient\n               who went into cardiac arrest and ended up in the ICU. My question to the Minister of Health is simple. Exactly how many people have died in hospital hallways across this province\n               on her watch?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721340","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Hallway health care has become shockingly routine under this NDP government. Front-line\n               staff are doing all they can in inadequate facilities, and they are absolutely devastated\n               by what's happening in our hospital hallways. After I raised the issue last week, I was made aware by a whistleblower of a young woman who tragically\n               died this month in the hall","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","label":"Tax avoidance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["872aa276d2a6643e45f05d10c019e3a208cf409a4021680251de9016630e4aca","9da3fb3101e9cf6346983b771c3abd41c5893173b1c7665a173d95f26220a08b","1a7734d2fcd87cb5d1019102586d271df741053ec7c2199775c74d2927a555b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8dbc1f07a7786bff4a33290c0c143d6b7d90a8fbdcaebbef0e203a55f766b1de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5978941ed62d00df1156ed66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721342,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to acknowledge the birthday of former Kelowna-Mission MLA Steve Thomson, one of my predecessors and someone I have long admired for his\n               humble leadership and steady service. Steve brought to public life the same teamwork and discipline that earned him the\n               nickname the Blue Ox in his rugby career, including time with Canada's national team. He also served with distinction as minister of agriculture, energy and forests and\n               continues to give back, including through his work helping lead Kelowna's Memorial Cup effort. Happy birthday, Steve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721342","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to acknowledge the birthday of former Kelowna-Mission MLA Steve Thomson, one of my predecessors and someone I have long admired for his\n               humble leadership and steady service. Steve brought to public life the same teamwork and discipline that earned him the\n               nickname the Blue Ox in his rugby career, including time with Canada's national team. He also served ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["357c331813239fd57532081710b69c6d668eccf582b2cf04e89d5c60c4be85b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a281b75c1f4253ad8d4555db860804dde7f05c09d44a7803432c6dd76912b74"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f4685f2d7b5506b34f2c8fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721344,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Kids from all over B.C. come to B.C. Children's Hospital for specialized care. Every\n               year more than 500 families are forced to find hotel rooms, stay in shelters or even\n               camp in parking lots because there's not enough space for them to stay close to their\n               sick children. Ronald McDonald House has already raised more than $45 million for an expansion. The\n               community has stepped up. The city of Vancouver has stepped up. The feds have stepped\n               up. Even the Yukon government has stepped up. But the project is at risk because this\n               government has cut funding. Will the minister stand up today and commit to reversing this cut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721344","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Kids from all over B.C. come to B.C. Children's Hospital for specialized care. Every\n               year more than 500 families are forced to find hotel rooms, stay in shelters or even\n               camp in parking lots because there's not enough space for them to stay close to their\n               sick children. Ronald McDonald House has already raised more than $45 million for an expansion. The","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Refugees","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43100","label":"Refugees","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40653d2d40daa67402d32a194e5322e424625cb3c22c8dfa6c9f9b3053f3601d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["946f7034f579f41d14d45db7f0c2daa15a81e86dc3d09aa9c4b0c4fc767ff18f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90f793cacd4b622d2d454b40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729009,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move Motion 205, standing in my name on the order paper. This motion is simple, reasonable and constructive. It begins with a proposition that\n               should not be controversial in any serious Legislature. If elected representatives\n               are asking to make decisions on taxes, spending, debt and regulation, they should\n               possess a basic understanding of economics, public finance and numeracy — not expertise,\n               not a graduate degree and not ideological conformity. This motion is not about imposing ideology. It is not about turning member orientation\n               into a tug-of-war between the Fraser Institute and the Canadian Centre for Policy\n               Alternatives. It is about equipping members to make evidence-based decisions. It is\n               offered without judgment and in a practical spirit as a tool to help MLAs better understand\n               taxes, spending, debt, regulation, incentives and long-term fiscal choices. Even John\n               Kenneth Galbraith put it well: \"I'm in favour of whatever works in the particular\n               case.\" These decisions affect families, businesses, jobs, taxes, debt and opportunity. Too\n               often in politics, numbers are presented without context. Too often, the distinction\n               between a gross number and a net result is blurred. Too often, inflation and population\n               growth are ignored when governments present their plans and their records. Governments boast about spending the most ever without asking what that means after\n               inflation and population growth. Gross numbers are used when net outcomes are what\n               actually matter. Announcements sound impressive until someone asks the next question:\n               compared to what, at what cost, over what time frame and with what result? A headline\n               is not a result. A Legislature should expect its members to understand the difference between a nominal\n               increase and a real improvement, between a gross number and a net result, between\n               a one-time announcement and a structural obligation, and between spending more money\n               and actually solving a problem. A basic course in economics, public finance and numeracy would help members think\n               more clearly about incentives, the time value of money, the cost of delay, the consequences\n               of debt and the impact of regulation and rising payroll costs on hiring and growth.\n               As Thomas Sowell put it: \"There are no solutions. There are only trade-offs.\" That is exactly why economic literacy matters in this place. If members are going\n               to vote on taxes, spending, debt and regulation, they should understand the trade-offs\n               their decisions create, today and tomorrow. Too often, governments present numbers as though the number itself ends the argument.\n               It does not. A large spending figure is not, by itself, proof of success. A recruitment\n               number is not, by itself, proof of improved service. A new program is not, by itself,\n               proof of good policy. What matters is the context, the costs, the incentives and the\n               net effect on the people we serve. Public finance is not theatre, and taxpayers are\n               not props. A deficit is just a tax increase with a time delay. That is why economic literacy matters in this place. If members are going to vote\n               on borrowing, they should understand the burden that places on future taxpayers. If\n               members are going to vote on labour costs and workplace rules, they should understand\n               what that does to employers, hiring, expansion and opportunities for those very workers.\n               If members are going to vote on regulation, they should understand how incentives\n               shape behaviour and outcomes in marketplaces. This motion should not be partisan. This motion should not be partisan. It is a modest institutional reform. It says that\n               this House should expect a baseline of competence in the subjects that most directly\n               affect the prosperity of this great province and the stewardship of the public purse.\n               That is not too much to ask. In fact, it is the least we should ask. I earnestly hope that members from all sides of this House will support the motion,\n               and I look forward to the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729009","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move Motion 205, standing in my name on the order paper. This motion is simple, reasonable and constructive. It begins with a proposition that\n               should not be controversial in any serious Legislature. If elected representatives\n               are asking to make decisions on taxes, spending, debt and regulation, they should\n               possess a basic understanding of economics, p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23b8001f28df261a5fee7325f04d0ebfe32f7fde18b11b6f3ca5b15de83c4eb2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b92a0d2ed5e0c6062f241cd6ae729142551adc90e58057d4faa17779063cd63c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abe548f166b12833063b8a40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729013,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Interior Health is downplaying the number of hallway beds at Kelowna General Hospital\n               in the media, and the Minister of Health has so far refused to just give us a straight\n               answer. Multiple front-line workers tell me they've counted up to 50 hallway bed positions\n               with their own two eyes. Since we already know the numbers, will the minister stop dodging and put it on the\n               record today? What is the peak number of hallway beds at KGH in the past year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729013","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Interior Health is downplaying the number of hallway beds at Kelowna General Hospital\n               in the media, and the Minister of Health has so far refused to just give us a straight\n               answer. Multiple front-line workers tell me they've counted up to 50 hallway bed positions\n               with their own two eyes. Since we already know the numbers, will the minister stop dodging ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1562d08f454925d8c82a9369b022bd38000e047076039980c3c1672bdbcdf4b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f311e7326d48077ccba606817227fc6d23fce965351bd8a6360be37a01d076d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5744fa01cde094b9444c6973","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752210,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"The concern about broadening the intention of the motion is ironic in light of the\n               last vote that we just had. The reality is that I think folks on all sides of this\n               House want to support small business, and I do believe that the original motion is\n               laudable. I think that it is beneficial to allow small independent movie theatres\n               to serve liquor during mixed-stage showings. That's a common-sense policy. I think\n               that broadly we all want to enable people to have more flexibility in terms of the\n               experience that they have when they go to the movies. The intent of the amendment, which I think is equally laudable, is to expand that.\n               The approach that has been taken by the member is to bring a motion rather than a\n               bill, so simply to provide a general spiritual direction to be taken forward, which\n               may result in changes to be implemented by government. We think it is only appropriate\n               that the changes be of breadth, that the changes are focused on allowing movie theatres\n               to serve liquor during mixed-stage showings. Certainly that would be inclusive of\n               the member's original intent to support small, independent movie theatres implicit\n               in the motion, but explicit in his speech was the reference to small independent rural\n               movie theatres. We certainly recognize that there are significant economic and commercial challenges\n               faced by those small theatres in particular. However, broadening the motion to encompass\n               all movie theatres would allow for a more all-encompassing approach, which would allow\n               a balanced approach across the board. I think at this point it's relevant to speak about why this matters. What we have\n               seen over the last number of years has been a gradual movement both within B.C. and\n               across the country toward more common-sense liberalization of policies like this that\n               recognize that adults are adults and can be trusted to do adult things as grown-ups.\n               That includes being able to have a beer while you watch a movie. There is a really important balance to be struck here, obviously. The expectation\n               that we should have as a society is that people can comport themselves with dignity\n               in an appropriate environment. And that is exactly what the member has brought forth,\n               which is again a motion to allow movie theatres to serve liquor during mixed stage\n               showings. I hear some heckling from the other side about this happening with kids. I don't understand\n               why the member is heckling against her own member's motion, because the same fundamental\n               balance is there regardless. Whether it's an independent cinema or whether it is a\n               larger cinema, the same fundamental aspect is there. The same spirit that appears\n               to be embodied in the intent of the original motion is there. However, we're simply allowing for this to happen more broadly. The reason why this\n               is important is a couple of things. Independent cinemas, larger cinemas, no matter\n               what they are, they're actually very, very difficult facilities to adapt, the member\n               well knows. In many instances, once they've been built out, they're not a particularly\n               adaptable format which can easily be converted to another use. If they're not able\n               to remain commercially viable, that's a real challenge, especially when they are,\n               in many cases, a cornerstone anchor tenant for a larger development. So it's really\n               important that we try to make sure that our movie theatres can sustain. One of the reasons why movie theatres have come under increased strain, of course,\n               is that we saw a lot of different behaviours evolving, consumer behaviours evolving,\n               both prior to, during and after COVID, where in many cases when people were not able\n               to go out to the movies, they invested in home theatre systems, they changed their\n               behaviours, just as in many cases they started cooking more at home. So with those\n               changes, we have seen those cinemas, again, whether they're independent cinemas or\n               whether they're part of larger companies, come under real strain. I'm well aware, as the member I think has flagged in their original motion, that in\n               particular in small communities, small cinemas have taken that pressure particularly\n               hard. In many communities.... I think of cinemas I visited, theatres I visited, there\n               are real and smart Again, by broadening the motion through this amendment, we're allowing for broader\n               direction, we're allowing for broader conversation, and we are joining with the member\n               in encouraging government to enable movie theatres to serve liquor during mixed-age\n               showings. We, obviously, think that there ought to be the right kind of balance struck around\n               that. We, obviously, believe in people taking responsibility for their actions, and\n               we, obviously, believe that this is the kind of logical, commonsense liberalization\n               that would allow people to go about their business in a normal way, have a great time\n               and, also, keep those movie theatres alive.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752210","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The concern about broadening the intention of the motion is ironic in light of the\n               last vote that we just had. The reality is that I think folks on all sides of this\n               House want to support small business, and I do believe that the original motion is\n               laudable. I think that it is beneficial to allow small independent movie theatres\n               to serve ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f96fe6460f83ec2e618dc89f6d2241007adba87d3370022d7aba28741313171e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8702baad09dccf8d84fae9e6476cf9a808cf4df371bcfc558d4bfc46fc2b05fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-932800372cf65d5cb434ea25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752211,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I join the Minister of Finance in celebrating May 4, but I would draw attention to\n               the fact that while the government has changed the ministry from Jobs, Economic Development\n               and Innovation to Jobs and Economic Growth, I have kept my critic title. Jobs, Economic\n               Development, Innovation and artificial intelligence. That makes me the last Jedi in\n               this House, and let me be clear. They can have my blue lightsabre when they pry it\n               from my cold, dead hands. May the Fourth be with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752211","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I join the Minister of Finance in celebrating May 4, but I would draw attention to\n               the fact that while the government has changed the ministry from Jobs, Economic Development\n               and Innovation to Jobs and Economic Growth, I have kept my critic title. Jobs, Economic\n               Development, Innovation and artificial intelligence. That makes me the last Jedi in\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7efabb6dfde8e39e7d21c93f11a467f679ed23f92f2b80a6a545bed945d93942"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-698adc117852acc8eb5c06b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752212,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to an issue that requires our collective attention and care:\n               the growing risks facing young people online. As we reflect this week on the lives\n               of women, girls and Two-Spirit people who have gone missing or have been taken from\n               their families, we are reminded that vulnerability can take many forms, and that exploitation\n               often begins where isolation, silence and gaps in protection persist. Today, some of those risks are no longer found only in isolated places or on remote\n               roads. They can reach directly into a young person's phone, bedroom, classroom or\n               social circle. Online luring, trafficking, sexual exploitation and cyberbullying are\n               not abstract dangers. They are real threats affecting real children, families and\n               communities. A child who is lonely, struggling, bullied or simply looking for connection can become\n               vulnerable very quickly. This is not about blaming parents, teachers or young people.\n               It is about recognizing patterns early. Technology has changed the way exploitation\n               happens, but it has not changed our responsibility to protect those at risk. That\n               means better awareness for families, better tools for schools, stronger coordination\n               between police and service providers, and clearer supports for young people before\n               harm escalates. The lesson before us is simple but serious. When warning signs are ignored, vulnerability\n               can be exploited. When communities are informed and systems respond early, lives can\n               be protected. On days like this, we honour those who have been lost not only with remembrance, but\n               with action. We owe it to our children and youth to make sure they are safe, not just\n               in our streets and communities but in the digital spaces where so much of their lives\n               now unfold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752212","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to an issue that requires our collective attention and care:\n               the growing risks facing young people online. As we reflect this week on the lives\n               of women, girls and Two-Spirit people who have gone missing or have been taken from\n               their families, we are reminded that vulnerability can take many forms, and that exploitation\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["629592c2a15e26ea99fdd2ae40567b0b5cc565ec7a2a2af01ce7153aa7bd02b8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6911550d9616dcb9747314950b2eb9a58d34d58fad8d99eb40d7e1aa103a1a39"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba430e06691c2b7a09033d66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752213,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I'm pleased to introduce two different delegations from Victoria. Firstly, I'd\n               like to welcome the good folks from the Greater Victoria Chamber. Unfortunately, I\n               wasn't able to meet with them earlier. I was the only one from my caucus who wasn't,\n               I think. It's good to see you guys: Corey, Julia, Zara, Zoe, Nikki, Maddie, Ashley, Nicole,\n               Hannah and Cheryl. I hope I haven't missed anyone. Thank you so much for being here\n               today. Welcome. Speaking of Victoria, I'd also like to welcome a young man named Sebastian Horobon,\n               who I gather might just be running for Victoria school trustee. I'm always a fan of\n               young people stepping up to lead in politics, so it's great to see young people like\n               Sebastian getting engaged. I understand he's a Red Seal electrician. He's passionate about education, trades\n               pathways, apprenticeships, issues that are areas of passion to many members of this\n               House. Once again, I commend you for stepping up. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752213","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I'm pleased to introduce two different delegations from Victoria. Firstly, I'd\n               like to welcome the good folks from the Greater Victoria Chamber. Unfortunately, I\n               wasn't able to meet with them earlier. I was the only one from my caucus who wasn't,\n               I think. It's good to see you guys: Corey, Julia, Zara, Zoe, Nikki, Maddie, Ashley, Nicole,\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Oil spills","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elder abuse","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103975","label":"Petroleum","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","label":"Commonwealth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47603","label":"Oil spills","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99368","label":"Elder abuse","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c906feef347d72be843a721dd738cee7fe65661ffe33468a5bb1063f41573692","7a80aacab9e49ad67e933b0ace430e70aaaf64a526c9ba137cf3b358242354aa","6c4923a064fe13af2c907deba59cdb9c4f5db16455d3c39dd0e09e7b2e2fa986"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1b1b28b6c2964db4d29c6df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752214,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"We were all here until 4 a.m. last night because this government believes they are\n               above accountability. Last Friday, the Health Minister took an unannounced tour of Kelowna General Hospital,\n               including the 33,000 square feet of space that could accommodate 55 additional beds. When local media found out that she was in town, she refused to make herself available.\n               She wouldn't talk to media, but when she walked down the hall, I hope she talked to\n               some of the patients who were experiencing the hallway health care that she is going\n               to tell us in a minute that she continues to work on. By now, the minister knows that we are not going to stop pushing until patients in\n               Interior Health get the quality of care they deserve and front-line staff get the\n               respect and the working facility that they deserve. After weeks of dodging accountability and having communications people fudge the numbers\n               in the media, will the Health Minister stand up today, confirm the numbers and commit\n               that by the time this House sits in the fall, she will begin opening at least some\n               of the 33,000 square feet of unused space at Kelowna General Hospital?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752214","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We were all here until 4 a.m. last night because this government believes they are\n               above accountability. Last Friday, the Health Minister took an unannounced tour of Kelowna General Hospital,\n               including the 33,000 square feet of space that could accommodate 55 additional beds. When local media found out that she was in town, she refused to make herself available.\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7658384bbddde34956ab883437ca79dd92ae9f9f78906e0c3e0d857d44ad5ad3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d0314a1443b3f50ba6d0963cab236cbbb5beca35b1f523578f88c950750e7ef5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b543892f52087c4ed47f5c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017252,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am very pleased to welcome Tyler Zeeman to the House. Tyler is a fifth-generation\n               Kelowna resident and community advocate focused on public safety, safer neighbourhoods\n               and improving supportive housing policies across British Columbia. He has been an\n               active voice on issues impacting local families, businesses and communities. Please\n               join me in making him very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017252","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I am very pleased to welcome Tyler Zeeman to the House. Tyler is a fifth-generation\n               Kelowna resident and community advocate focused on public safety, safer neighbourhoods\n               and improving supportive housing policies across British Columbia. He has been an\n               active voice on issues impacting local families, businesses and communities. Please\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a77118594c5585c69a662abff2163124232862e4772fc5e09ad45f53781793a8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-881d3858406035d33cb35881","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017257,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Some of the sweetest moments in this House are when people acknowledge the people\n               without whom they would not be here today. I will take that very literally. Today\n               is my mother's 80th birthday. Happy birthday, Mom. I love you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017257","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Some of the sweetest moments in this House are when people acknowledge the people\n               without whom they would not be here today. I will take that very literally. Today\n               is my mother's 80th birthday. Happy birthday, Mom. I love you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","label":"Weather","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["33f2753f990c35b1bbdb7090dea170bec4749156d5ff6a844bfd7d1e018f3783","0ec609dc10460df9940601cf7669e76441acc073e58a1b032163bc30e5735b8f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-320dfb546e63684b99bc8b72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036446,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I close, I want to return to the words of my original motion, that the House\n               ensures elected representatives are accountable and supported to possess a basic understanding\n               of economics, public finance and numeracy as they make decisions on taxes, spending,\n               debt and regulation and, therefore, request that the Legislative Assembly Management\n               Committee institute a mandatory course in these subjects for all newly elected members\n               of the Legislative Assembly as part of member orientation. This is far from an extreme proposition. It is common sense. It does not ask every\n               member to become an economist or to share the same policy views. It asks something\n               much simpler — that before newly elected members are called upon to vote on matters\n               with billion-dollar This is far from an extreme proposition. It is common sense. It does not ask every\n               member to become an economist or to share the same policy views. It asks something\n               much simpler — that before newly elected members are called upon to vote on matters\n               with billion-dollar consequences, they receive a basic grounding in how public finance\n               works, how incentives work and how numbers should be understood in context. Because context matters. Without context, numbers can mislead. Gross figures can obscure\n               net outcomes. Nominal increases can be mistaken for real progress. Governments can\n               present a flattering picture that does not line up with what people actually experience\n               in their lives. British Columbians deserve a legislature that understands the cost of delay, the burden\n               of debt, the effect of rising payroll costs, the importance of investment and the\n               role incentives play in shaping behaviour. Is this sustainable? What is the net effect?\n               What does this cost in the long term? What behaviour does this reward or discourage\n               on the part of individuals, organizations, entrepreneurs and investors? Will it create\n               jobs and opportunities or drive them elsewhere? Those kinds of questions would improve scrutiny, debate, accountability and decision-making.\n               It is fair to say that some of the weakest decisions in public life reflect a failure\n               to think clearly about trade-offs, incentives and costs. Sometimes, governments act\n               as though spending more is the same as achieving more. Sometimes numbers are technically\n               true but incomplete in substance. Sometimes the economic consequences of policy choices are\n               treated as secondary, only to reappear later as higher costs, weaker growth or fewer\n               opportunities. That is exactly the pattern my original motion seeks, in a modest way, to improve.\n               I will say this. Government members actually began this debate with what could have\n               been an interesting and constructive approach, the suggestion that Conservatives could\n               benefit from stronger economic literacy too. Fair enough. Nobody has a monopoly on\n               economic literacy. British Columbians would be better served if they had a government and an opposition\n               competing to offer the best evidence-driven and economically sound policy possible.\n               That is why it was so disappointing to see the government then decide to get cute,\n               with an amendment designed to dilute my original motion. Instead of engaging substantively\n               with the subject of the motion on economic literacy, the government chose to fold\n               in a broad range of other matters, including \"evidence-based science, truth and reconciliation,\n               and human rights.\" At a time when B.C.'s small business confidence remains weak, when we have lost tens\n               of thousands of jobs over the last few months, and when recent court rulings have\n               created real uncertainty around the security of fee simple property rights, you would\n               think it would be uncontroversial for this Legislature to focus specifically on the\n               economy. Instead, the government seemingly will do anything to avoid that. Rather than keep\n               this debate where it belonged, on economic literacy, they chose to stir the culture\n               war pot and give provocative speeches in the hope of eliciting a reaction that would\n               let them change the channel. British Columbians do not need more channel-changing. They do not need more rhetorical\n               fog. They do not need a style of politics that is constantly searching for wedge issues\n               at the expense of serious and substantive debate about the fundamental operations\n               of government and the fundamental health of our economy. My original motion was offered in a practical and non-judgmental spirit as a tool\n               to strengthen how members assess financial impacts and communicate decisions to the\n               public. This side of the House will not play along with the government's political\n               games. We support my original motion, and we will not support an amended version designed\n               to dilute it and distract from the focused conversations on economic literacy that\n               British Columbians deserve. British Columbians deserve serious, grown-up government focused on fundamentals, and\n               that is exactly what Conservatives will give them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036446","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Before I close, I want to return to the words of my original motion, that the House\n               ensures elected representatives are accountable and supported to possess a basic understanding\n               of economics, public finance and numeracy as they make decisions on taxes, spending,\n               debt and regulation and, therefore, request that the Legislative Assembly Management\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c6dcb7dcaf7dc33e05966af4cba675c1eeb4ca7f6189dac00c915879c955ab6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40fe1d5263092e57ae90ef3fc604bdd1a5256d88c427ed6a52997a9a8221aab6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65155cd0d350fb750269ed85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036447,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"The CFIB has said, \"When we talk to small businesses around the province, one thing\n               is clear. The cost of doing business is too high. When costs go up for small businesses,\n               prices go up for everyday people, and jobs are put at risk.\" B.C. has already lost more than 40,000 jobs so far this year. When will this government\n               stop ignoring small businesses and reverse their poorly timed PST expansion?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036447","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The CFIB has said, \"When we talk to small businesses around the province, one thing\n               is clear. The cost of doing business is too high. When costs go up for small businesses,\n               prices go up for everyday people, and jobs are put at risk.\" B.C. has already lost more than 40,000 jobs so far this year. When will this government\n               stop ignoring small businesses an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business start-ups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033692","label":"Business start-ups","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b6c1e50ba480ddc5fea8e7e9e39bb0929ef0a5c051ff826630ca34bb6481f0c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01973d89b6029208f4bf8b226c29f4f3bd9c8b27aa796fa0ac43c1cd3aca86b6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78e4b9d13cd005ed4dce80aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036448,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mayor Tom Dyas of Kelowna is in the gallery, and with that being the case, I'd like\n               to take a moment to acknowledge the 106th Memorial Cup happening in Kelowna right\n               now, all of the fantastic work done by the city, the investment made by the city to\n               make that possible. I got on the phone this morning with Steve Thomson and David Rush, who are the co-chairs,\n               and they told me — they insisted — I had to recognize all the folks involved in organizing\n               the Memorial Cup and making it happen, Festivals Kelowna, the Downtown Kelowna Association,\n               Tourism Kelowna, GSL and the whole team at Prospera Place, the Kelowna Rockets, the\n               Canadian Hockey League for their confidence in Kelowna, and above all, most importantly,\n               the 500-plus volunteers who have made this amazing Memorial Cup possible. Thank you to everyone who has made this happen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036448","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mayor Tom Dyas of Kelowna is in the gallery, and with that being the case, I'd like\n               to take a moment to acknowledge the 106th Memorial Cup happening in Kelowna right\n               now, all of the fantastic work done by the city, the investment made by the city to\n               make that possible. I got on the phone this morning with Steve Thomson and David Rush, who are the co-cha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f79249d3a83200c303b3c62e4c805533b63daeb82e5c40c25ab056bb3c6f578"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b7055e14becbc3b65c276f097028757f68debd37405c94fe53158f5f273ba7d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcc240603920dd78e19de18d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036449,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday in this Legislature, the Minister of Education said: \"Safety is my number\n               one priority.\" On May 21, Springvalley Middle School in Kelowna went into lockdown after two people\n               were attacked with a knife on school grounds. A Crown prosecutor said: \"There have\n               been expressions recently and in the past that the accused wanted to kill someone\n               and had taken steps to find weapons and guns. Almost four months after the Tumbler Ridge tragedy, can the minister tell worried\n               parents today what changes have actually been implemented to school safety, threat\n               assessment, mental health response, lockdown procedures and communications with parents?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036449","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday in this Legislature, the Minister of Education said: \"Safety is my number\n               one priority.\" On May 21, Springvalley Middle School in Kelowna went into lockdown after two people\n               were attacked with a knife on school grounds. A Crown prosecutor said: \"There have\n               been expressions recently and in the past that the accused wanted to kill someone\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6d8742e261725fe69f3537671919bc591ea521d50ef6c17ce7c5891c6a56426f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ae2947ecbed939ee0fffe2de6b60e0e435e5a9e45ddf3f5ae25edf2942bba51"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-501e28446f9c6a92b16d056c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036450,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to get an 11-day head start on wishing a very happy eighth birthday to my\n               daughter Abigail Ariella Dew. I missed her French play this morning. I'm sorry. I miss you. I love you. I'll see you soon. Happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036450","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to get an 11-day head start on wishing a very happy eighth birthday to my\n               daughter Abigail Ariella Dew. I missed her French play this morning. I'm sorry. I miss you. I love you. I'll see you soon. Happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea069510a9bd63effa7b1a10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036451,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Gavin Dew","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to commemorate the lives and legacies of two men I did not have the privilege\n               of knowing personally but whose impact I have come to understand through the sons\n               who carry their names, their values and their examples forward. In this place, we often speak about legacy in public terms. We speak about buildings,\n               institutions, companies and communities, but the truest measure of a life is often\n               found much closer to home. It is found in the families people build, the character\n               they pass on, the work ethic they instil and the quiet standards they set for the\n               next generation. Bob Sutherland lived a life of quiet strength, steady love and deep devotion to family.\n               He married the love of his life, Faye, in 1972, and together they built a family rooted\n               in loyalty, laughter and respect. Bob was the proud father of Jim, Chris and Doug.\n               To his sons, he was not only a father but a best friend, a teacher, a helper and an\n               example. He showed his love by showing up, often with tools in hand, ready to fix\n               what needed fixing, build what needed building and help however he could. Bob helped build Sutco Transportation Specialists. He drove trucks, put in long hours,\n               and led not with speeches but by example. In doing so, he helped build more than a\n               company. He helped build a family legacy of integrity, grit and values. James Lyn Bannister's legacy is also one of family, enterprise and people. Born in\n               Saskatoon, educated in sport and teaching, Lyn began his career as an educator and\n               hockey coach before finding his way into the automotive business. He and his wife,\n               Joanne, built a life, a family and, eventually, a business that became one of the\n               largest retail dealer groups in western Canada. The Bannister Automotive Group grew\n               from its roots in Vernon into a major presence across British Columbia and Alberta. By all accounts, Lyn's greatest gift was not simply building dealerships; it was building\n               people. He loved the car business, but he loved the people in it even more. He brought\n               energy, optimism, humour and high standards to those around him. He reminded people\n               to enjoy the moment, and he lived that way himself. Bob Sutherland and Lyn Bannister built businesses. Most importantly, they built families,\n               cultures and standards that continue through the people who loved them and learned\n               from them. So many people and families have benefited from their legacies, not only\n               in business but in life. Their work created jobs, opened doors, built opportunities,\n               supported communities and gave others the chance to build futures of their own. The\n               next generation of both families can be proud not only of the legacies they inherited\n               but of the ways they have carried those legacies forward. To the Sutherland and Bannister families, and especially to my friends, I offer my\n               sincere condolences and all our gratitude for the legacy of lives well lived.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036451","member_id":"bc-mla-375","member_name":"Gavin Dew","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to commemorate the lives and legacies of two men I did not have the privilege\n               of knowing personally but whose impact I have come to understand through the sons\n               who carry their names, their values and their examples forward. In this place, we often speak about legacy in public terms. We speak about buildings,\n               institutions, companies and comm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b61449ba77220084b2ff5d00ff0781d19734b1a4c3ae6e5d1ff1e54d71664734"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2afa69e132389380cce189bda3166a7ae33e61b10046f160b74bb293bfdd898a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7d82d00e01c83acdc766a45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317179,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to the profound sorrow felt across British Columbia following\n               the tragedy in Tumbler Ridge, a close-knit community whose grief is shared far beyond\n               its boundaries. It has been heartwarming that all parties were drawn together in our sorrow and grief\n               for the victims, their families and the broader community. It reminded us we are first\n               and foremost humans drawn together by love. Political differences are just something\n               that we navigate to find the best way forward. A lot has been said about this tragedy, more eloquently A lot has been said about this tragedy, more eloquently than I can manage. But being\n               a lifelong rural resident, I can relate to Tumbler Ridge and share my rural perspective. Tragedy carries a particular weight in small communities. I know through lived experience.\n               I live in Fruitvale, and I once had the privilege of serving as its mayor. Fruitvale\n               is a community of similar size and spirit to Tumbler Ridge, a place where people know\n               one another, not as strangers, but as neighbours, colleagues, classmates and friends. In towns like ours, the connections between people are deeply woven. When sorrow touches\n               one family, it ripples through the entire community. In rural communities, loss is\n               never distant. It is felt in our schools, our workplaces, at the grocery store, on\n               the streets we walk every day. It is felt in the silence that follows shock and in\n               the quiet recognition that everyone carries a piece of the pain. Grief is not confined to headlines or statistics. It becomes personal, immediate and\n               shared. Yet there is also something extraordinary about rural communities in times\n               of hardship. When tragedy strikes, people do not turn away. They turn toward one another.\n               They show up. They gather. They cook meals. They sit together. They listen. They comfort.\n               They lean on the bonds that define community life. Support is not organized from afar. It rises naturally from neighbours helping neighbours,\n               from friends holding friends, from an entire town standing shoulder to shoulder. We cannot forget the first responders, the paramedics, the police, the medical staff.\n               They are all community members rushing toward the tragedy, treating people and families\n               they know. The trauma is immeasurable. I also want to acknowledge the immense responsibility placed upon local leaders in\n               moments like these. Our friend the MLA for Peace River South has shown the courage\n               to lead with empathy and strength. Thank you. My hat is off to Mayor Darryl and the council of Tumbler Ridge. Leadership in times\n               of celebration is one thing. Leadership in times of collective grief is something\n               far more difficult. Communities look to their elected officials not only for decisions\n               but for steadiness, compassion and reassurance. They look for voices that can unite,\n               guide and help people navigate the unimaginable. Those who have served in local government understand the weight of that duty. Leaders\n               are members of the community first. They share the same shock, the same heartbreak,\n               the same sense of loss. Yet they must also help others find strength and direction.\n               That is no small task, and it deserves recognition and respect. Tragedies such as this remind us of the fragility of life and the depth of our human\n               connections. They remind us that behind every community name are real people, real\n               families and real pain. They also remind us of the resilience that exists in places\n               where people care deeply for one another. To the people of Tumbler Ridge, we extend not only our condolences but our solidarity.\n               Your grief is seen, your sorrow is shared, and your strength born of community will\n               carry you forward in the days and months ahead. In rural British Columbia, communities have always drawn their strength from one another.\n               In times of darkness, they find light in compassion, kindness and unity. I have no\n               doubt that the people of Tumbler Ridge will support one another through this difficult\n               time, just as small communities always do. May we as a legislature hold them in our thoughts, honour those affected and remember\n               the enduring power of community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317179","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to the profound sorrow felt across British Columbia following\n               the tragedy in Tumbler Ridge, a close-knit community whose grief is shared far beyond\n               its boundaries. It has been heartwarming that all parties were drawn together in our sorrow and grief\n               for the victims, their families and the broader community. It reminded us we are fi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["399d29029051e47bc835879f4e78c3d5e02feb083c5a9f19187ff7e9c6d168e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0242c25af101e66603b4a6f8b1e118830e857ec3a1254bb3997b42523199391"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36c31e93e86cccf4d008f827","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317180,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to celebrate the 33rd B.C. Winter Games and the incredible opportunity\n               they bring to our province, especially this year to the host communities of Trail\n               and Rossland, with support from Castlegar and the Beaver Valley. From today through March 1, the hills, rinks and gyms of the area will showcase 15\n               sports and welcome as many as 1,700 athletes, coaches and officials from every corner\n               of B.C., supported by the same number of local volunteers. The B.C. Games are where dreams come alive. They are where young athletes discover\n               what they are capable of and take their first steps toward provincial, national and\n               even international competition. The games are extraordinary not just for the competition\n               but for the personal and community growth they inspire. Young athletes learn resilience,\n               teamwork, leadership and how to rise after Outside of the competition, the B.C. Games energize host communities. Volunteers step\n               up, local businesses thrive, and hotels and restaurants welcome visitors from throughout\n               the province. The result is meaningful rural economic impact and strengthened community\n               bonds that showcase the very best of who we are. That is why our government invests $50 million annually in sport to provide safe and\n               inclusive opportunities for more than 870,000 members of amateur sport organizations\n               in British Columbia. When we host an event like the B.C. Winter Games, we're investing\n               in healthy, connected communities. I ask all members of this House to join me in celebrating the B.C. Winter Games and\n               cheering on all the athletes, coaches and volunteers. Let the games begin.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317180","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to celebrate the 33rd B.C. Winter Games and the incredible opportunity\n               they bring to our province, especially this year to the host communities of Trail\n               and Rossland, with support from Castlegar and the Beaver Valley. From today through March 1, the hills, rinks and gyms of the area will showcase 15\n               sports and welcome as many as 1,700 athle","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d32ce58dbf965d7ada0f83b2309971a4f145458b66e24c3b1db532807fa4c9ad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71c6b6d5fae3d74e9f95185f3016bd2e426cb3f4f9ab0687a9192b46baff20ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd3d867c3373dab59e10ae85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317181,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am proud to rise today to acknowledge a constituent of mine who is here with us\n               in the chamber today. Linda Frew won a prestigious award last night at the B.C. Care\n               Providers Association awards ceremony. My apologies, Linda, that I couldn't be there. Linda Frew of Fruitvale was the recipient of the B.C. Care Provider of the Year Award\n               for Assisted Living, in recognition of the leadership and kindness she exemplifies\n               every day as a community manager at Castlewood Village in Castlegar. Linda is known for creating a welcoming, inclusive community for everyone. Linda is\n               innovative, developing an adult day program that blends clinical support for high-need\n               seniors with community engagement to reduce stigma and strengthen community. I would ask the House to join me in congratulating Linda for receiving this award\n               and for everything she does to make every day a special day for seniors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317181","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I am proud to rise today to acknowledge a constituent of mine who is here with us\n               in the chamber today. Linda Frew won a prestigious award last night at the B.C. Care\n               Providers Association awards ceremony. My apologies, Linda, that I couldn't be there. Linda Frew of Fruitvale was the recipient of the B.C. Care Provider of the Year Award\n               for Assisted Liv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8387d2c7eab5c303f1e24a87a9130d98d29716bce47ed3f0a51baf415a7ff283"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["917e6bea52643868b975269932a0e8371dea8e3a1e943f0b945fe62bfeded4ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a38293e746bab8f09b9baeb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328022,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in strong support of Bill 6, legislation that will amend British\n               Columbia's Motor Vehicle Act and take an important step towards modernizing driver\n               licensing and identification services in our province. At its core, this bill is about something very practical, making it easier for people\n               to renew or replace their driver's licence or provincial ID without unnecessarily\n               long trips, long waits or time away from work and family. This is critical for rural\n               British Columbia. If passed, Bill 6 will enable the Insurance Corp. of British Columbia\n               to offer simple renewals and replacements online through its secure website. That means that renewing a driver's licence, replacing a lost or damaged card, renewing\n               a stand-alone BCID, a stand-alone photo B.C. Services Card, or the combined driver's\n               licence–B.C. Services Card will become more convenient for eligible British Columbians. This is the first step in a long-term modernization plan to make ICBC's services faster,\n               easier and more accessible. It is also part of our government's broader commitment\n               to modernize and improve access to the services that people in British Columbia rely\n               on every day. This does not preclude in-person services for some seniors or others\n               that don't have access to internet services. Bill 6 amends the Motor Vehicle Act to enable ICBC, once development work and regulations\n               are complete, to accept online applications for replacing a valid driver's licence\n               that has been lost, destroyed or damaged, These changes will apply to eligible drivers with full B.C. driver's licences. Drivers\n               with a class 7 learner's licence will be able to replace a lost or damaged card online,\n               but renewals for learner licences will continue to require an in-person appointment\n               because of testing requirements. Renewals involving changes to a driver's personal information, such as a name change\n               or a new medical condition, will still require an in-person visit. Individuals with\n               outstanding fines, tickets, remedial program requirements or other violations will\n               also need to attend an office to address those matters before renewal. All existing\n               safety requirements and eligibility rules will remain in place. This legislation does not weaken standards. It simply allows straightforward, uncomplicated\n               renewals to be completed online. Once an eligible customer submits an online application\n               through ICBC's secure digital portal, and once that application is approved, ICBC\n               will issue an interim licence electronically. The new card will then be mailed directly\n               to the customer at no additional cost. These changes will save people time and transportation costs. They will eliminate\n               the need to stand in line or schedule an in-person appointment for simple paperwork.\n               People will not need to take time off work or arrange child care for a routine renewal. This is the first step in many upcoming moves to make access easier for people. This\n               will be particularly meaningful for people in rural and remote communities. This is\n               close to my heart because in many parts of rural British Columbia renewing a licence\n               can mean travelling long distances to reach the nearest ICBC office. That may require\n               hours on the road and additional expenses, simply to extend an expiry date or replace\n               a damaged card. By enabling online renewals for eligible drivers, we are recognizing\n               the geographic realities of our province. We are reducing barriers and making services\n               more equitable across regions. These changes will also benefit those who continue to require in-person services.\n               By moving simple transactions online, ICBC offices will have more appointment availability\n               for road tests and other services that must be delivered face to face. This is a smarter\n               use of public resources and a more efficient way to deliver service. If passed during this spring legislative session, amendments will be implemented once\n               development work and regulations are complete, with the online service expected to\n               begin operating in 2027. This phased approach ensures that systems are built carefully\n               and securely and that regulations clearly outline eligibility criteria and program\n               requirements. Road safety remains a top priority. Only eligible existing drivers in good standing\n               will be able to renew online. Current conditions for renewing a licence will still\n               apply. Anyone with outstanding violations or program requirements will need to resolve\n               those matters in person before renewal. ICBC is working closely with the Ministries of Health and Citizens' Services to ensure\n               that high standards of fraud prevention, identity verification and residency verification\n               are in place. ICBC has also consulted with the British Columbia Association of Chiefs\n               of Police traffic safety committee to ensure law enforcement perspectives are incorporated\n               into the design of these systems. Protecting against identity fraud and ensuring public\n               safety are foundational to this modernization. These changes will also bring British Columbia in line with eight other provinces\n               and territories that already offer some form of online driver's licence services,\n               including Alberta, Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick These changes will also bring British Columbia in line with eight other provinces\n               and territories that already offer some form of online driver's licence services,\n               including Alberta, Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland and Labrador,\n               Prince Edward Island and the Northwest Territories. British Columbia should not fall\n               behind when it comes to service modernization. We should ensure that our systems reflect\n               the realities of how people live today. I would also like to briefly note that Bill 6 concerns the renewal of existing licences.\n               It does not change how new drivers obtain their licences. Separate improvements to the graduated licensing program, coming into effect in this\n               summer of 2026, will remove the requirement for a second road test to obtain a class\n               5 licence. That second test will be replaced with a new extended 12-month period of\n               driving restrictions during which drivers must demonstrate safe driving behaviour\n               before earning their full unrestricted licence. Research shows that maintaining a\n               clean driving record over a longer monitoring period is a reliable predictor of future\n               driving behaviour. Most provinces and many countries have not required a second road test for decades,\n               and there is no evidence that having one improves safety outcomes. These improvements\n               will lower barriers to licensing for drivers in rural, remote and Indigenous communities,\n               where travelling to complete a second road test can be particularly challenging, while\n               continuing to prioritize road safety. Bill 6 is practical, responsible legislation. It saves people time. It reduces unnecessary\n               travel. It improves access in rural and remote communities. It frees up in-person\n               appointments for services that truly require them, and it maintains rigorous safety\n               standards and strong fraud prevention measures. Government services should reflect modern expectations. British Columbians conduct\n               many aspects of their lives online, and it is reasonable that simple driver's licence\n               renewals and replacements be available online as well. This is thoughtful, staged\n               modernization that improves access while safeguarding public safety. For those reasons, I am proud to support Bill 6 and encourage all members of this\n               House to do the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328022","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in strong support of Bill 6, legislation that will amend British\n               Columbia's Motor Vehicle Act and take an important step towards modernizing driver\n               licensing and identification services in our province. At its core, this bill is about something very practical, making it easier for people\n               to renew or replace their driver's licence o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d04575eaaf7dcdb9fc7ee7a70ec6f43771e55bd2092ff23bae0a260c355c3199"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c32a590f849f89bd19544cf224796b786bbdfbc1d13db95804d062db80577c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6b1721a9d19f1d57a456558","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360420,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to rise today in support of this motion, tabled by the member from Bulkley Valley–Stikine, calling upon the House to affirm its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an\n               important component of Canadian sovereignty. British Columbia takes a whole-of-government approach to water, with relevant ministries working closely together to deliver on the overarching goal of securing sustainable clean water for all needs. People in B.C. and our government know how important water is to everyday lives, and this is reflected in how well-legislated the topic of water is in our province. B.C. has three main laws regulating and protecting water. The Water Protection Act, which protects B.C.'s water by reconfirming provincial ownership of surface and groundwater, defining limits for bulk water removal and prohibiting the large diversion of water between provincial watersheds and locations outside of B.C. This law protects our water sovereignty explicitly. The Water Sustainability Act. This is the primary statute for managing and organizing our water resources in B.C.\n               The WSA sets out requirements for the transparent allocation and pricing of water, orderly\n               sequencing of rights to water and clear mechanisms for redistribution of water during\n               times of scarcity. And thirdly, the Drinking Water Protection Act, which sets out requirements for drinking water operators and suppliers to ensure\n               the provision of safe drinking water to consumers. The act Thirdly, the Drinking Water Protection Act, which sets out requirements for drinking\n               water operators and suppliers to ensure the provision of safe drinking water to consumers.\n               The act aligns oversight and accountability to the provincial health officer to ensure\n               there is safe and potable drinking water available for all British Columbians. B.C. also has other policies and clauses in various laws that ensure water is protected\n               and also affordable, equitable and accessible. In terms of affordability, British Columbians are protected from their water services\n               being increased in price solely for profit when they have an agreement with a private\n               water utility under B.C. law. These private water utilities are generally small community\n               services where there are no public water purveyors available. Water utilities are\n               required to explain to their ratepayers and the provincial water comptroller why a\n               rate increase is necessary. This helps protect everyday people from utilities unfairly\n               increasing the price of a rural community's only source of water. In terms of accessibility and equity, when developing policy, programs and initiatives,\n               provincial public servants are required to analyze a list of considerations to understand\n               who will be impacted by proposed changes and how. The unique circumstances of Indigenous peoples must be considered. The risk of racial\n               biases is considered, and gender-based analysis plus is employed to assess how various\n               groups of people may be impacted by any policy change. This includes any potential\n               impacts to privacy, businesses and the economy, affordability and marginalized peoples. The Constitution of Canada establishes the division of powers on water quite clearly\n               between different levels of government. While it is established that the federal government\n               is the primary authority with respect to water on First Nations reserves, the province\n               has committed to working and collaborating with First Nations when we look at policy\n               and legislative reform to better respect the social, cultural, economic and spiritual\n               value of water to Indigenous peoples. Historically, B.C.'s water resources have been seen as never-ending and abundant.\n               However, in recent years, the province has seen multi-year droughts exacerbated by\n               climate change. Water is increasingly being recognized as something that needs to\n               be carefully managed for the citizens of the province. The work to ensure our water is affordable, equitable, accessible, clean and sovereign\n               is ongoing, and there is always work to be done. We remain committed to responsibly\n               managing our water resources by working on new policies, legislation and programs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360420","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am pleased to rise today in support of this motion, tabled by the member from Bulkley Valley–Stikine, calling upon the House to affirm its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an\n               important component of Canadian sovereignty. British Columbia takes a whole-of-government approach to water, with relevant ministries working closely together to deliver on th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cb670b6cdcacfd0c642bd00fd63fe905dbeae47384427564d5a392797e580040"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5595c1a779aac30c0d99663b875007b42c2c42f8cfdcf244aeebb64e76376cc0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58e77b128ae62daebe55b71c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415785,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I was fortunate just last week to visit two outstanding rural colleges in the Kootenays,\n               Selkirk College in the West Kootenays and College of the Rockies in the East Kootenays,\n               alongside the Minister of Post-Secondary and Future Skills. What we saw reinforced\n               everything we know about the vital role rural colleges play in this province. At both institutions, there was a clear and powerful connection between education\n               and community. These are not distant, disconnected campuses. They are deeply embedded\n               in the regions they serve. They understand their communities, they respond to their\n               needs, and they deliver training that directly supports local people and local economies. We saw firsthand how these colleges are identifying regional labour market demands\n               and stepping up to meet them. Programs aligned with health care, the skilled trades\n               and local industries are not theoretical. They are practical, hands-on and designed\n               with direct input from employers and community partners. Students are gaining real-world\n               skills that translate immediately into jobs in their own communities. What stood out just as much was the sense of opportunity. At Selkirk College and College\n               of the Rockies, students are not just learning; they are building futures. For many,\n               these institutions are the first step into post-secondary education. They provide\n               a supportive environment where students can grow in confidence in rural areas, still\n               stay at home, develop independence and prepare for whatever path they choose next,\n               whether that is entering the workforce or continuing their studies. In regions like the Kootenays, these colleges are often the only post-secondary institutions\n               available. That makes their presence not just valuable but essential. Without them,\n               many students simply would not have the same access to post-secondary education and\n               training. I also want to acknowledge the people we met: the instructors, the staff and the students.\n               Their dedication, their passion and their pride in their institutions were evident\n               in every conversation. They are committed to their communities and to ensuring that\n               these colleges continue to serve as engines of opportunity and growth. Visits like this are an important reminder that the strength of our post-secondary\n               system is not just found in large urban centres. It is found in every region of this\n               province, in British Columbia, where rural colleges are doing extraordinary work every\n               day to train the workforce, support local economies and open doors for people from\n               all walks of life. I am grateful for the opportunity to have seen that work up close, and I am proud\n               to stand in this House and reaffirm our support for rural colleges across British\n               Columbia. Because what they do matters, and the impact they have is felt far beyond\n               their campuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415785","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I was fortunate just last week to visit two outstanding rural colleges in the Kootenays,\n               Selkirk College in the West Kootenays and College of the Rockies in the East Kootenays,\n               alongside the Minister of Post-Secondary and Future Skills. What we saw reinforced\n               everything we know about the vital role rural colleges play in this province. At both instituti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2cde091c2c70ece853ed647a6dee020f2a7ac50d24abdbe23910261fb2afd4fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3b2efb0ed6e446ec687f6bc496ecf359f5d1bc771f26cbb2abba89c1aa8214b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2fd0b6b162a69c00258f5f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415786,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today as a member of the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government\n               Services to highlight the committee's annual budget consultation. I want to let British\n               Columbians know that they can register right now to present at public hearings the\n               committee will be holding through June. Each year during the budget consultation, the committee hears from individuals, community\n               organizations, businesses and local governments across the province. The consultation\n               works best when people know it exists and understand how to take part, which is where\n               you, my colleagues, come in. I encourage all members to share information about the consultation through constituency\n               offices, social media, newsletters and community networks, so British Columbians know\n               how and when to have their say. This year the committee will be holding public hearings\n               in Burnaby, Castlegar, Cranbrook, Dawson Creek, Kamloops, Kelowna, Mission, Nanaimo,\n               Prince George, Smithers, Vancouver and Victoria. There is also an option to participate\n               virtually. As an MLA from a rural riding and a former mayor of a rural village, I can speak from\n               experience on the unique opportunity this consultation presents for rural areas. It's\n               a great opportunity for those who live outside of major cities to participate in the\n               proceedings of the Legislature. The deadline to register for public hearings is April 10. I encourage all of you to share the details of this consultation with your constituents.\n               For those who are unable to participate in a public hearing, the opportunity to participate\n               by submitting written recommendations will also be available in June. I appreciate\n               your support in helping ensure this consultation reflects the voices from every part\n               of the province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415786","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today as a member of the Select Standing Committee on Finance and Government\n               Services to highlight the committee's annual budget consultation. I want to let British\n               Columbians know that they can register right now to present at public hearings the\n               committee will be holding through June. Each year during the budget consultation, the committee hear","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec67daeb91b1450623578fa603cb4ab51960bdb6e1b0a361ff97236d70b4af22"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c64d883f4d49a9243f171290c154efe4a36e283a4294a7b1acdfeedd839c7fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bb1c9a228caa31c15726c815","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415787,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public\n               Worship Act, a legislation that goes to the very heart of what it means to live in\n               a free and democratic society. At its core, this bill is about something simple yet profoundly important — the ability\n               of people to live out their beliefs peacefully, safely and without intimidation. It's\n               about ensuring that when someone chooses to attend their place of worship, whether\n               that be a gurdwara, a church, a synagogue, a mosque or a temple, they can do so without\n               fear, without obstruction, without harassment and without being made to feel that\n               their presence, their beliefs or their community are somehow unwelcome. The wide variety\n               of diverse religions in British Columbia gives us different perspectives and makes\n               us a much stronger society. Places of public worship are more than just buildings. They are anchors in our communities.\n               They are spaces where people gather not only for prayer but for connection, for support\n               and for a sense of belonging. They are where families mark life's most important moments\n               — births, marriages and losses — and where individuals seek guidance, reflection and\n               peace. They are, in many ways, the quiet foundation of community life. Yet, increasingly,\n               we have seen instances where these very spaces have been targeted by disruptive and\n               harmful behaviour. Let me be clear. The vast majority of people in British Columbia respect one another.\n               They understand that freedom of religion is not conditional. It does not depend on\n               whether we agree with someone else's beliefs. Let me be clear. The vast majority of people in British Columbia respect one another.\n               They understand that freedom of religion is not conditional. It does not depend on\n               whether we agree with someone else's beliefs. It does not depend on whether we share\n               their traditions. It is a right that belongs to everyone equally. But we must also acknowledge an uncomfortable truth. For some, the idea of freedom\n               of religion has been narrowed into something exclusionary, something that means freedom\n               of my religion but not necessarily the freedom of others. And when that mindset takes\n               hold, it can manifest into behaviours that are intimidating, obstructive and, at times,\n               deeply harmful. This is where this legislation steps in. Bill 13 proposes a practical, measured and\n               thoughtful response to a real and growing issue. It establishes protections against\n               harmful, disruptive or intimidating behaviour around places of public worship. It\n               creates a framework that allows eligible places of worship to establish clearly marked\n               safe access zones — zones that are visible, understandable and limited in scope. Unlike other legislation, these zones are not imposed universally by regulation. Instead,\n               they are created when a place of worship chooses to opt in by posting clear signage. That signage must identify the place of worship, define\n               the boundaries of the access zone and outline the behaviours that are prohibited.\n               This approach ensures clarity for everyone — those attending worship, those in the\n               surrounding community and those who may wish to express their views nearby. Clarity matters. Laws must be understandable, they must be predictable, and they must\n               be fair. Bill 13 meets those standards. In most cases, these access zones will include the building itself, the property on\n               which it sits and a modest 20-metre buffer around the perimeter. They are not expansive.\n               They are not designed to push people far away. They are designed to do one thing:\n               ensure safe and unobstructed access. Within these zones, specific behaviours are prohibited — not expression but conduct.\n               This includes physically blocking entrances, using objects like barricades to obstruct\n               access, disrupting prayer or religious gatherings and engaging in threatening or intimidating\n               behaviour toward those trying to attend. And yes, it also includes attempts to pressure\n               or dissuade individuals from attending services within that defined space. This is not about silencing lawful protest. Let me say that again clearly. This legislation\n               does not outlaw protest. People will continue to have the right to express their views.\n               They will continue to have the right to gather, to demonstrate and to disagree, even\n               strongly. But rights must coexist. Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of our democracy,\n               but so, too, is freedom of religion. And neither right should come at the expense\n               of the other. This bill draws that line carefully and responsibly. It says: \"You may express your\n               views, but you may not intimidate others. You may protest, but you may not block access.\n               You may disagree, but you may not create an environment of fear for people simply\n               seeking to practice their faith.\" The need for this legislation is not theoretical. In recent years, we have seen a\n               rise in confrontations and targeted disruptions at religious institutions, not only\n               in British Columbia but across Canada and around the world. We have seen vandalism,\n               including political graffiti, targeting temples and gurdwaras. We have seen escalating We have seen vandalism, including political graffiti, targeting temples and gurdwaras.\n               We have seen escalating tensions, requiring court-ordered buffer zones. We have seen\n               communities of many different faiths express real concern for their safety. We have\n               seen how quickly peaceful spaces become sites of anxiety and division. The impact of these incidents is profound. They create fear, they create division,\n               and they undermine the sense of safety and belonging that places of worship are meant\n               to provide. For those attending, what should be a moment of peace becomes a moment\n               of concern. What should be a place of refuge becomes a place where people must look\n               over their shoulder. That is simply not acceptable. This legislation says clearly, in British Columbia, we will not accept that. We will\n               not accept that individuals should have to weigh their personal safety before attending\n               a service. We will not accept that communities should feel targeted or unwelcome in\n               spaces that are central to their identity and well-being. Instead, we will take responsible,\n               proportionate steps to ensure that access to these spaces remains safe and unobstructed. Bill 13 does not stand alone. It is part of a broader effort to protect safe access\n               to important community spaces. Alongside this bill, we are also advancing Bill 12,\n               which extends protections for safe access to schools, ensuring that students, staff,\n               parents and caregivers can access schools without disruption. These measures build on previous legislation, including protections around essential\n               services and health care access. They reflect a consistent principle, that certain\n               spaces in our society must remain accessible, safe and free from intimidation — schools,\n               health care facilities and now, places of public worship. Enforcement of this legislation is practical and measured. If prohibited behaviour\n               occurs within an access zone, places of worship can contact police. Officers may respond\n               in a range of ways, starting with de-escalation and, where necessary, issuing tickets\n               or making arrests. Importantly, violating this law is not in itself a criminal offence. But the underlying\n               behaviour — if it crosses into assault, criminal harassment or other offences — may\n               well be. Police will continue to exercise discretion, as they do in all situations,\n               and we have confidence in their ability to do so. This confidence is supported by\n               ongoing investments in public safety, including expanded resources for hate crime\n               units and community support programs. I also want to address the question of scope. This legislation applies to buildings\n               that are already recognized as places of public worship under existing property tax\n               frameworks. This ensures clarity and consistency while minimizing unnecessary intrusion\n               on charter rights. We recognize that there are other spaces and communities that may also face risks,\n               and we will continue to explore ways to support them. But this bill represents a focused\n               and balanced step forward. It applies equally, regardless of religion, regardless\n               of belief and regardless of who may be protesting. It does not target any one group.\n               It does not favour one faith over another. It does not distinguish between viewpoints.\n               It simply protects access. I also want to speak to an important feature of this legislation, the four-year sunset\n               clause. This is not a permanent measure. It is a targeted response to a specific and\n               evolving issue. The sunset I also want to speak to an important feature of this legislation, the four-year sunset\n               clause. This is not a permanent measure. It is a targeted response to a specific and\n               evolving issue. The sunset clause ensures that this Legislature will revisit the law,\n               assess its effectiveness and determine whether it remains necessary. This is good governance. It reflects humility. It reflects accountability. It reflects\n               a recognition that laws should evolve alongside the society they serve. British Columbia is home to an extraordinary diversity of faiths, cultures and traditions.\n               That diversity is one of our greatest strengths, but diversity also requires responsibility.\n               It requires us to ensure that every community feels safe, that every individual feels\n               respected and that no one is made to feel vulnerable because of who they are or what\n               they believe. This bill is part of that responsibility. It affirms that whether someone attends\n               a gurdwara, a mosque, a synagogue, a church or a temple, their right to do so safely\n               is equally valued. It affirms that freedom of religion is not selective. It is universal.\n               It affirms that our role as legislators is not only to protect rights in theory but\n               to ensure they can be exercised in practice. There may be those who raise concerns about balance. That is appropriate. In a democracy,\n               we should always examine laws carefully, especially those that touch on fundamental\n               freedoms. But I would submit that this bill strikes that balance. It is limited in\n               scope. It is clear in its application. It preserves the right to protest. It focuses\n               only on conduct that is harmful, disruptive or intimidating. In doing so, it protects\n               one right without unnecessarily infringing on another, and that is exactly what good\n               legislation should do. In closing, this is a bill that reflects our shared values: a commitment to safety,\n               a commitment to respect and a commitment to ensuring that fundamental freedoms are\n               not only recognized but protected in real and meaningful ways. We cannot take these freedoms for granted. We cannot assume they will always be upheld\n               without effort. And we cannot ignore the realities that some communities are facing\n               today. Instead, we must act — thoughtfully, proportionately and with a clear sense of purpose.\n               Bill 13 does exactly that. It provides a balanced, responsible and time-limited approach\n               to ensuring that people in British Columbia can access their places of worship safely\n               and without obstruction. For that reason, I am proud to support this legislation and commend it to this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415787","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public\n               Worship Act, a legislation that goes to the very heart of what it means to live in\n               a free and democratic society. At its core, this bill is about something simple yet profoundly important — the ability\n               of people to live out their beliefs peacefully, safely and without int","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74a3665ba67b061a6a48a13d4e9e8234a302307f68aaf5ec9da43ae4fd90eb01"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["030912323220599b10f663d81ac148a3e3268debdef9bd630f05e914ec5ce126"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8d2fc2a01f27c92c03dc8be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415788,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"It was with great sadness that we learned about the passing of an incredible human\n               this past Tuesday — former leader of the Ontario NDP and a proud activist, father,\n               husband, grandfather and much more, Stephen Lewis. Elected to the Legislative Assembly of Ontario at 26 years old and becoming the leader\n               of Ontario NDP at just 33, Lewis became known for his eloquent and passionate public\n               speaking skills and his dedication as Leader of the Official Opposition to hold the\n               government at the time to a high moral standard, fighting for compassion for all people. Lewis worked fiercely to protect, uplift and to improve human rights, and his advocacy\n               for gender equality, anti-racism and social justice are at the very heart of what\n               it means to be a New Democrat and a Canadian. Stephen wore many impressive hats throughout his career, all rooted in his passion\n               for human rights, including serving as an ambassador to the United Nations and working\n               for UNICEF. Lewis was an incredible activist and dedicated much of his life to bringing\n               awareness to and fighting against apartheid in South Africa and the HIV/AIDS epidemic. In 2003, he co-funded the Stephen Lewis Foundation, which works to deliver funds and\n               other resources directly to community-led organizations who are leading responses\n               to HIV and AIDS in Africa. He is survived by his three children, his grandchildren and his wife, Michele Landsberg,\n               an incredible leader, author and educator. Stephen Lewis changed our country for the better, and his impact will continue to\n               be felt here and across the globe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415788","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It was with great sadness that we learned about the passing of an incredible human\n               this past Tuesday — former leader of the Ontario NDP and a proud activist, father,\n               husband, grandfather and much more, Stephen Lewis. Elected to the Legislative Assembly of Ontario at 26 years old and becoming the leader\n               of Ontario NDP at just 33, Lewis became known for h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["155ca2b26af9c98d40e65827b82c0bd847dc8e2d6f777f20a03ea903d1f91841"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6194c007be14c3539605547103f3f5a3c74d259725c9831519e8bee93772e6a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce6d6d81893b9b292a27f704","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720465,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports progress on Bill 11 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720465","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section C reports progress on Bill 11 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71284ac3ba085d4b1b7a7fdd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721568,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to introduce my friend, and retired MLA in Kootenay-Monashee, Katrine Conroy. Katrine and her family gave their life to British Columbia, starting with her late\n               husband, Ed, for ten years. Katrine followed with 20 more and three ministries. When\n               elected, I wondered if I should hyphenate my name with Conroy in order to represent.\n               Katrine, thank you for your support and your service. Please join me in welcoming Kat to the House. Katrine, thank you for your support and your service. Please join me in welcoming Kat to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721568","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to introduce my friend, and retired MLA in Kootenay-Monashee, Katrine Conroy. Katrine and her family gave their life to British Columbia, starting with her late\n               husband, Ed, for ten years. Katrine followed with 20 more and three ministries. When\n               elected, I wondered if I should hyphenate my name with Conroy in order to represent.\n               Katrine, tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["375d2e72f04482ef26b1120fd51abf52638750675e396c73e304ac46978d6fec"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c33633c585400a4dceac6340","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721569,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in strong support of Bill 9, the proposed amendments to British\n               Columbia's Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, commonly known as\n               FOIPPA. These amendments represent thoughtful, balanced and necessary updates to legislation\n               that sits at the very heart of two core democratic values: the public's right of access\n               to information and the protection of personal privacy. Both of these principles matter\n               deeply, and this legislation strengthens both. FOIPA was created in a different era, before digital services were central to how\n               people interact with government. Today, British Columbians expect services to be seamless,\n               secure and accessible online. They expect the government to work together, not in\n               silos. The amendments before us do two important things. They improve the experience of people\n               using the freedom-of-information system; and two, they enable the next stage of connected\n               digital government services. These are not competing goals. They are complementary.\n               We can and must protect privacy while delivering better service. Let me begin with connected services. British Columbians do not think about government\n               in terms of ministries and program areas. They think in terms of needs. They need\n               to renew a licence. They need to access benefits. They need to update their address.\n               They need to support their family or business. Yet too often they are required to\n               provide the same information, repeatedly, across multiple programs. These amendments support the creation of Connected Services B.C., a single government\n               gateway that will allow people and businesses to apply for services and update their\n               information across programs in a streamlined way. Importantly, this is not about building a massive, centralized database. It is not\n               about consolidating everyone's personal information into one giant repository. It\n               is about allowing information, with a person's knowledge and permission, to flow securely\n               between public bodies so services can be delivered more efficiently. Public bodies will continue to hold and safeguard information within their own systems,\n               but where appropriate, they will be able to securely share information in a way that\n               reflects how people actually interact with government: not by department but by need.\n               Privacy protections remain robust. FOIPA already contains strong safeguards for collection, use and disclosure of personal\n               information. These amendments go further by allowing the minister to establish clear\n               data standards and privacy and security requirements specific to connected services. Additionally, the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner will be notified\n               when a connected services provider is established and retains the discretion to review\n               the associated privacy impact assessments. This is modernization with accountability. We also know that the volume and complexity of FOI requests have grown significantly.\n               Across ministries, school districts, municipalities and health authorities, public\n               bodies are experiencing real administrative pressure. We have a responsibility to\n               ensure that access to information remains timely and equitable for all applicants. These amendments improve process efficiency without diminishing access rights. For\n               example, they minimize duplicate disclosure processes, so time is not wasted processing\n               records that are already being released through other mechanisms such as legal discovery.\n               They enable proactive disclosure of personal information back to individuals seeking\n               their own records. Currently, approximately 60 percent of FOI requests are for personal information.\n               By allowing public bodies to proactively provide personal records directly to individuals,\n               particularly former children in care, we can improve access while relieving pressure\n               on the FOI system. That is not restricting access. That is improving it. Another key improvement is strengthening provisions around request clarity. The current\n               act requires applicants to provide enough detail to allow records to be identified\n               with reasonable effort. Another key improvement is strengthening provisions around request clarity. The current\n               act requires applicants to provide enough detail to allow records to be identified\n               with reasonable effort. However, there is no clear, structured process for clarifying\n               unclear requests. The amendments create a formal mechanism for seeking clarification.\n               Let me be clear, this does not force applicants to narrow their requests. It simply\n               creates a transparent process to ensure that when clarification is needed, it is requested\n               formally and responded to promptly. It serves no one if a public body is unsure what records are being sought while a\n               statutory clock continues to run. These changes provide accurate timelines and encourage\n               engagement, ensuring applicants receive the information they are actually looking\n               for. Stopping the 30-day clock during clarification is not about delay. It is about\n               fairness and accuracy. Clearer requests mean better responses. There has also been discussion about amendments that would allow public bodies in\n               extremely rare circumstances to apply to disregard a request that is abusive or malicious.\n               Let us be precise. There is already a process under which a public body can apply\n               to the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner to disregard a request.\n               These amendments simply clarify and expand the circumstances in which that application\n               can be made. The oversight remains entirely with the commissioner. A public body cannot\n               unilaterally disregard a request. It must apply to the OIPC, and the commissioner\n               decides. Abusive or malicious behaviour refers to patterns of conduct intended to harass, intimidate,\n               threaten or overwhelm. Examples include issuing death threats to public servants or\n               mailing suspicious substances with requests. These situations are extremely rare,\n               but when they occur, they are highly disruptive and divert resources away from processing\n               legitimate requests. Protecting public servants from harassment while maintaining\n               access rights is not controversial. It is responsible governance. I want to address consultation. The ministry has consulted extensively with the Office\n               of the Information and Privacy Commissioner on all these proposed amendments. The\n               commissioner has been engaged throughout the process. We value the OIPC's role in\n               protecting privacy and ensuring access to information. That oversight remains strong. Governments must balance two responsibilities, protecting access rights and ensuring\n               the system functions effectively so that all requests, regardless of size, can be\n               processed within reasonable timelines. This legislation supports that balance. There has been a discussion about the $10 FOI application fee. This legislation does\n               not change the fee structure. Individuals requesting their own personal information\n               pay no fee. Indigenous governing entities are not required to pay the application\n               fee. The application fee has contributed to more targeted requests rather than broad,\n               cross-government fishing expeditions. At the same time, we are expanding proactive disclosure, making commonly requested\n               materials available without the need for an FOI request at all. That is how we increase\n               accessibility. These amendments also introduce the ability to proactively disclose personal information\n               back to individuals. This is an important evolution. Instead of requiring someone\n               to file a formal FOI request for their own records, public bodies will be able to\n               provide that information directly. This improves access and reduces administrative\n               burden. It is a win for applicants and a win for the system. British Columbia is moving toward more connected British Columbia is moving toward more connected digital services. We are enabling\n               people to access government through secure digital identity tools like the B.C. Services\n               Card. To support that modernization, our legislative framework must evolve. But modernization\n               does not mean weakening privacy. It means embedding privacy into service design. It\n               means building systems that are secure, accountable and transparent. It means ensuring\n               that as government becomes more digitally connected, it remains grounded in democratic\n               values. These amendments do exactly that. They improve the efficiency and transparency of\n               the FOI process. They protect public servants from rare but disruptive abuse. They\n               enable proactive disclosure of personal records. They modernize information-sharing\n               frameworks to support connected services. They maintain strong oversight by the Office\n               of the Information and Privacy Commissioner. They reinforce privacy protections while\n               improving service delivery. This is balanced legislation. It responds to recommendations from the FOIPPA special\n               committee and operational realities across public bodies. It reflects extensive consultation,\n               and it prepares British Columbia for the next generation of digital government responsibly\n               and thoughtfully. Access to information and protection of privacy are not competing principles. They\n               are complementary pillars of public trust. These amendments strengthen both. I am\n               proud to support this legislation, and I encourage all members of this House to do\n               the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721569","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in strong support of Bill 9, the proposed amendments to British\n               Columbia's Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, commonly known as\n               FOIPPA. These amendments represent thoughtful, balanced and necessary updates to legislation\n               that sits at the very heart of two core democratic values: the public's right of access\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b922f2ff7ab2a06bf082b0b454663a0315ade370109c320aa44dd473e434189"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab25ceb1ffe4209dd3cf0196c5e97ad4cb3c285eddc6ae1d33a0fd8c14407a27"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d6fca54a795bf518257e446","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721575,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome three guests to the House who play a critical role in supporting\n               safety across British Columbia's film and television industry. Joining us today are Tamara Tulloch, industry health and safety specialist for Vancouver Island; Daniel Farley, director of industrial health and safety; and Trina Pollard, CEO of Actsafe safety association. Through their work, they help ensure that thousands of workers in the motion picture\n               and performing arts industries can do their jobs safely each and every day. Their\n               leadership, expertise and commitment to health and safety are essential to the continued\n               success of this important sector. Please join me in warmly welcoming them to the Legislative Assembly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721575","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome three guests to the House who play a critical role in supporting\n               safety across British Columbia's film and television industry. Joining us today are Tamara Tulloch, industry health and safety specialist for Vancouver Island; Daniel Farley, director of industrial health and safety; and Trina Pollard, CEO of Actsafe safety association. Through their work, they ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biological diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Multiculturalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012910","label":"Biological diversity","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","label":"Multiculturalism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4c2c427a78cbaf600fe395a2ef66afe4c0bdf1f9c52754ce82dc4326fa3d10b","1430c5ff4176f6cc2bfac2f1d50010638b63b5cdce3da294f1fb1c274882b7ab","a72927df91dfe7bb445d9ca5d151566cef2d543bcc5a90e0ce9185a556024a1a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41a8f621fca0ca6f041a961fea82f8b8d1a77eff0ea9f617f0e9571ba711847c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd90b1e079e2653a0f6277cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721580,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I, too, rise to present a petition. This petition of CUPE and BCTF staff from J.L.\n               Crowe Secondary School in Trail, B.C. They recommend that the government consider\n               a change to the current legislation regarding personal cellular devices. They ask\n               for a stricter and uniform policy across British Columbia to protect students.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721580","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I, too, rise to present a petition. This petition of CUPE and BCTF staff from J.L.\n               Crowe Secondary School in Trail, B.C. They recommend that the government consider\n               a change to the current legislation regarding personal cellular devices. They ask\n               for a stricter and uniform policy across British Columbia to protect students.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034417","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034417","label":"Communications equipment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5bf7de8566f4fb5b133900b686a30acda07d0f60d56a8af0b8226435b3e8d168"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aee56a55e481c340107d5c42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729313,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize and highlight an organization that quietly, consistently\n               and effectively strengthens the backbone of our province, rural British Columbia: I am speaking about Community Futures British Columbia. Across our province, from coastal communities to the Interior, from the North to the Kootenays, Community Futures offices are embedded directly in the communities they serve. There are 34 of these offices across British Columbia, each one locally run, each\n               one deeply connected to the people and businesses in their region. And that local\n               connection matters because in rural British Columbia, economic development is not\n               theoretical; it is personal. It is about whether a family can open a business on main street. It is about whether a young person can stay in their community and build a career.\n               It is about whether a town can adapt when a major employer changes or a resource sector\n               fluctuates. Community Futures exists to meet those challenges head-on. They are often the only organization in a rural community whose sole focus is small business development and local economic growth. They're the ones sitting across the table from entrepreneurs\n               with an idea, helping turn that idea into a business plan and that business plan into\n               reality. They provide practical, hands-on support, helping with business planning, market research, mentorship, and training. For someone starting out, that guidance can be the difference between success Just as importantly, they provide access to capital. In many rural communities, traditional\n               financing can be difficult to obtain. Community Futures steps into that gap. They\n               offer flexible lending, focused not just on collateral but on people, on potential\n               and on the strength of an idea. That means more businesses get off the ground, more\n               businesses grow and more jobs are created locally. That is real economic impact. It means more storefronts open on our main streets.\n               It means more services available close to home. It means stronger, more resilient\n               local economies that are less dependent on a single industry and better able to weather\n               change. And when challenges do arise, as they inevitably do, Community Futures is\n               there as a steady, reliable partner. Whether it is economic downturns, natural disasters\n               or shifts in global markets, they help businesses adapt, recover and move forward. The leadership behind Community Futures is awesome. Each Community Futures office\n               is guided by a local board of directors. These are volunteers. They are business leaders,\n               community members and individuals who care deeply about the future of their region.\n               They understand the unique opportunities and challenges of their area in a way that\n               no centralized system ever could, and because of that, the decisions they make are\n               grounded in local knowledge, local priorities and local values. Today I want to express my sincere appreciation, not only for the staff who work tirelessly\n               to support entrepreneurs but especially for those volunteer board members across British\n               Columbia. Your contributions matter, your leadership matters, and the impact you are\n               making in your communities is significant. When we talk about building a strong economy in British Columbia, we must remember\n               that strength does not come only from our largest cities. It comes from every small\n               town, every rural community and every entrepreneur willing to take a risk and build\n               something new. Organizations like Community Futures British Columbia ensure those\n               entrepreneurs are not alone. They are helping create jobs, they are supporting innovation,\n               they are strengthening communities, and ultimately they are helping ensure that rural\n               British Columbia not only survives but thrives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729313","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize and highlight an organization that quietly, consistently\n               and effectively strengthens the backbone of our province, rural British Columbia: I am speaking about Community Futures British Columbia. Across our province, from coastal communities to the Interior, from the North to the Kootenays, Community Futures offices are embedded directly in the communities t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a56fcfca24c988bf4b8658e4384c13bc23106de19f264fd918ced53dd75bb27"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d5d63ae6ec349fc840188ffcc4d0c4f01832a5955c5baf1415b7d8709e13ac9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a95957a0496802bfbfa134d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729319,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thanks to my colleague for recognizing and welcoming the Vernon Christian School here. I, too, would also like to thank Bailey. Bailey was born in Trail in my riding, and\n               she sent me a letter to ask some questions of me. Thank you, Bailey. It's great to have young people interact with us, and I really\n               appreciate it. Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729319","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks to my colleague for recognizing and welcoming the Vernon Christian School here. I, too, would also like to thank Bailey. Bailey was born in Trail in my riding, and\n               she sent me a letter to ask some questions of me. Thank you, Bailey. It's great to have young people interact with us, and I really\n               appreciate it. Thank you so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1ae2b2055cd2d7d2d254e7f735493e11ef74956abb3d83c3254c2db9e068b13"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5e236075f2b619d211028be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752304,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move Motion M207 standing in my name on the order paper: I speak to a simple, practical idea that supports small businesses, strengthens community\n               gathering spaces and reflects how people enjoy film in 2026. This motion supports\n               the fact that we know small business is the economic engine of British Columbia. Across British Columbia, small independent movie theatres are more than just places\n               to watch films. They are cultural hubs. They host local events, film festivals and\n               school screenings and gather community together. But many of these theatres are struggling\n               to compete in an era of streaming services and rising operating costs. At the same time, we've seen a shift in how audiences experience movies. Larger corporate\n               cinemas already offer expanded food At the same time, we've seen a shift in how audiences experience movies. Larger corporate\n               cinemas already offer expanded food and beverage services, including liquor in many\n               adult-only settings. Yet small, mostly rural, independent theatres, often the most\n               creative and community-focused, face regulatory barriers that limit their ability\n               to diversify revenue. I learned of this challenge from my own riding, where we have\n               two independent single-screen theatres, the Castle Theatre in Castlegar and the Royal\n               Theatre in Trail. By chance last year I ran into the owners of the Royal Theatre at the airport on their\n               way to Victoria for the cinema industry gathering. They explained that it's hard for\n               independent rural single-screen theatres to thrive and sustain operations. They asked\n               if I could support them in asking for changes to liquor laws to allow them to sell\n               beer and wine in mixed-age audiences. Currently for a live performance in the same\n               theatre, they would be allowed to serve alcohol in a mixed crowd — but for a movie,\n               no. This law originated in the U.K., back when film was first used commercially. Film\n               was affordable for everyone — all classes of people. Live theatre was for the upper\n               class. The law was instituted because you couldn't trust the common working person\n               to have alcohol. An example the theatre owners shared with me was regarding the recent Taylor Swift\n               Eras Tour. The tour came to B.C. Place. The venue was filled with 160,000 fans over three\n               nights. The vast majority were teenage fans. Alcohol was sold there every night. When\n               the local theatre replayed the concert for local fans that couldn't afford the time\n               or expense to attend the live shows, they could not sell alcohol to help sustain their\n               operations. This motion calls on government to modernize those rules. This change will support\n               and help to sustain the 50-plus independent theatres across British Columbia. Allowing\n               small independent theatres to serve liquor during mixed-age showings, while maintaining strict safeguards, would give these businesses a fair chance to compete. It would not mean unrestricted access. Responsible service requirements, age verification\n               and clear enforcement mechanisms will remain in place. This is about fairness. It's about economic sustainability. It is about supporting\n               small business in British Columbia. Most importantly, it's about preserving the unique\n               character of our communities. When a small theatre closes, we don't just lose a screen.\n               We lose a gathering place and a shared cultural experience. This is a modest, commonsense step that supports local small business, reflects modern\n               realities and keeps our communities vibrant. I encourage all members of this House\n               to support this motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752304","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move Motion M207 standing in my name on the order paper: I speak to a simple, practical idea that supports small businesses, strengthens community\n               gathering spaces and reflects how people enjoy film in 2026. This motion supports\n               the fact that we know small business is the economic engine of British Columbia. Across British Columbia, small independent movie theatres ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["23623f8d7cc183dfc009739312b370e84b26d85f651df39c04484b95ad1f9a49"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2aa7830566a6a0d5138a3841a3f78e437495ecf28dd34e8697fdcecb2192f35f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c99ff347d38f692279e20bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752305,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to recognize my two constituency advisers, Angelika Brunner, who has taken\n               a pass on joining us in question period, and Sarah Brownlee up in the gallery. The\n               two of them do their best with the challenging job of making me look good in the constituency.\n               I appreciate the work they do. Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752305","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to recognize my two constituency advisers, Angelika Brunner, who has taken\n               a pass on joining us in question period, and Sarah Brownlee up in the gallery. The\n               two of them do their best with the challenging job of making me look good in the constituency.\n               I appreciate the work they do. Thank you so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc76d72035d31cd9da485ccc7b7e600cb8a3a0aeaf3762cd75036886b44748d3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79fa33cd2db8121e5c82f8a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017475,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise in the House today to recognize B.C. Museums Week from May 17 to 23 — this\n               week. B.C.'s arts, culture and creative sector is a vital part of our province. It\n               employs more than 122,000 people","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017475","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise in the House today to recognize B.C. Museums Week from May 17 to 23 — this\n               week. B.C.'s arts, culture and creative sector is a vital part of our province. It\n               employs more than 122,000 people","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["932d6ac0261808ce2fdc6c7344414a1963ec157fb2943305d506a510b8a92aba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7e8cd46c080247d7ecb08f4f9a7cccce4313304dbf42bfccf5c2235a085dcb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ddb8c5c396f22f46f94b02c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036533,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we have the opportunity to support a simple, practical change that reflects\n               modern realities, supports small businesses and helps keep community gathering spaces\n               alive across British Columbia. Small businesses are the economic heartbeat of British Columbia, and in these challenging\n               global times, we must do all we can to support small business whenever we can. Independent\n               movie theatres are much more than places to watch films. They are cultural hubs where\n               neighbours gather, where local events and festivals are hosted and where families\n               and friends share experiences together. In many rural and small communities, they\n               are the only place that regularly gathers diverse members of the community together. Small independent theatres struggle. Rising operating costs and competition from streaming\n               services have made it increasingly difficult for small independent cinemas to survive.\n               This motion offers a reasonable, commonsense way to help them remain sustainable. In my own riding, theatre owners shared with me how the current liquor regulations\n               create an uneven playing field. A theatre can serve alcohol during a live performance\n               in a mixed-age audience but not during a film screening in that same venue. Meanwhile, larger entertainment venues and This motion is about fairness and modernization. It recognizes that responsible liquor\n               service can coexist with family-friendly environments just as it does in many other\n               entertainment settings today. Strong safeguards, age verification and responsible\n               service requirements will continue to apply. Most importantly, this motion supports over 50 independent theatres across B.C., many\n               of them small rural businesses that contribute greatly to the character and vibrancy\n               of their communities. This motion is targeted. It is targeted to small independent\n               theatres because they are the theatres whose sustainability is most challenged. Large chain theatres are great. I support their success as well. They do already receive\n               benefits far beyond the independents. They benefit from being the first to screen\n               new shows, from having the capital and space to add separate viewing areas to accommodate\n               alcohol sales. They can close off one screen for alcohol sales. This motion was kept simple to help sustain small theatres. We heard from independent\n               theatres that they did not like the amendment. They said it really dulls the impact\n               of the motion for small independent theatres. It does not create a level playing field\n               but, rather, continues the dominance of large corporate theatres. Quote from an independent theatre owner in the Okanagan, Scott John, again: When a local theatre closes, we lose more than a screen. We lose a gathering place,\n               a cultural space and a piece of community identity. Supporting these theatres means\n               supporting local jobs, local economies and the shared experiences that strengthen\n               our communities. This is a modest but meaningful step that supports small business, reflects how people\n               enjoy entertainment today and helps preserve important community spaces for future\n               generations. I encourage all members of this House to support this motion in support\n               of small independent theatres.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036533","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today we have the opportunity to support a simple, practical change that reflects\n               modern realities, supports small businesses and helps keep community gathering spaces\n               alive across British Columbia. Small businesses are the economic heartbeat of British Columbia, and in these challenging\n               global times, we must do all we can to support small business when","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f80e7f82bc0ff0fbb924155dceb1e098be69d2e491b231c19c2c4c59cd65b64"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73067e54e1c28cebcb5285fc1aee5ae9c5167aaf4072b9805f0266bad30cb852"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3109dbf3a2726cb7831ceed4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036535,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports progress on Bill 20 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036535","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section C reports progress on Bill 20 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eddae20dedc324a4b49b8931","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036536,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"Across British Columbia, we have seen firsthand the devastating impact wildfires\n               can have on families, homes and entire communities. In my riding of Kootenay-Monashee and many others, it is a reality and concern we face every summer. Yet in the face\n               of these challenges, we continue to see neighbours helping neighbours, communities\n               coming together and people showing incredible strength, compassion and resilience. That spirit is beautifully reflected in the fireweed flower. Fireweed is often one\n               of the first plants to bloom after a wildfire, bringing colour and life back to the\n               landscape. Its vibrant purple blossoms have become a symbol of renewal, hope and recovery. Much like fireweed, the people of British Columbia continue to stand strong, support\n               one another and rebuild together after difficult times. Today many of us are proudly\n               wearing the BCAA Fireweed Pin, featuring artists Much like fireweed, the people of British Columbia continue to stand strong, support\n               one another and rebuild together after difficult times. Today many of us are proudly\n               wearing the BCAA Fireweed Pin featuring artwork by Coast Salish artist Charlene Johnny.\n               These pins help raise awareness and support organizations working to strengthen wildfire\n               preparedness, protect communities and assist people recovering from disasters. I am pleased that tomorrow, May 27, has been proclaimed BCAA Fireweed Pin Day. The\n               Fireweed Pin is available for a $5 donation at BCAA service locations and auto service\n               centres, Kal Tire locations and London Drugs stores across British Columbia, with\n               all proceeds supporting wildfire resilience initiatives. I encourage everyone to wear\n               their pin with pride, support this important initiative and continue sharing the message\n               of resilience and community care throughout our province. To learn more, please visit BCAA's \"Ours to protect\" campaign.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036536","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Across British Columbia, we have seen firsthand the devastating impact wildfires\n               can have on families, homes and entire communities. In my riding of Kootenay-Monashee and many others, it is a reality and concern we face every summer. Yet in the face\n               of these challenges, we continue to see neighbours helping neighbours, communities\n               coming together and pe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035315","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Flora","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288316","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035315","label":"Flora","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288316","label":"Plants","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c25af721ca8473375d5566c2f81331b575ccae86be993284b4e738492dd80c01"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ef2756cf0e4b16ca259991f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036537,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Morissette","venue":"Hansard","text":"We're in the heart of spring celebration season across British Columbia. Communities\n               large and small are gathering together to celebrate the places they call home. In Kootenay-Monashee, I've recently had the pleasure of attending Silver City Days in Trail and Beaver\n               Valley May Days in Fruitvale, and I'm looking forward to soon attending upcoming events\n               like Sunfest in Castlegar, Montrose Family Day and Cherryville Days in beautiful little\n               Cherryville. These celebrations are deeply loved traditions in their communities. They bring people\n               together through parades, food, friendly sports competitions, car shows, local vendors,\n               live entertainment and rides for families and children. But more than any one event\n               or activity, they create something even more important: a sense of belonging. They\n               remind us to celebrate where we live, the people around us and the simple joy of coming\n               together as neighbours and friends. What many people may not see is the incredible amount of work behind the scenes. In\n               so many communities, it is often a small group of dedicated volunteers carrying the\n               load, planning, organizing, fundraising, setting up, hosting events and cleaning up\n               long after everyone has gone home. To every volunteer, organizer, service club member, sponsor and community champion\n               helping make these celebrations possible, thank you. Your hard work strengthens community\n               spirit and creates memories that families carry with them for years. These celebrations\n               truly showcase the very best of British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036537","member_id":"bc-mla-376","member_name":"Steve Morissette","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're in the heart of spring celebration season across British Columbia. Communities\n               large and small are gathering together to celebrate the places they call home. In Kootenay-Monashee, I've recently had the pleasure of attending Silver City Days in Trail and Beaver\n               Valley May Days in Fruitvale, and I'm looking forward to soon attending upcoming events\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["02d58c47dcef45e16cede412b7081c90acd36b2baf181213c002eb9db9204b55"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52be4b2482686dac51c4a7159a1404d7278e21f8b119c9a5fd3b2448eab5b1e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0f4e9b0645b2665d3087b12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327944,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Pete Davis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yes, I confirm I'm in a private place indoors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327944","member_id":"bc-mla-377","member_name":"Pete Davis","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Yes, I confirm I'm in a private place indoors.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["100334daeedb9bab05723f7a4fc2ceeacb9a22a857847bcb7a147fdc63cbbfee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee351b57ec91c2a7e25570770443295288fc93f3fcf4f488edb9349573e164fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbe78222809d3c903a89ac09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752204,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Pete Davis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour to speak in this House today. Not long ago, I didn't know if I would\n               ever have this privilege again. Today is day 130 since the stroke that almost took my life. In a matter of minutes,\n               everything changed. The stroke took my ability to walk. It took my use of my right\n               hand and my right arm and blurred my vision for almost five months. One moment, life\n               felt normal. The next, it was completely turned upside down. You hear the words \"stroke\" and \"heart attack\" all the time, but most people don't\n               truly hear it until it has happened to them or someone they love. And when it happens,\n               it happens fast. In stroke care, they say time is brain. I'm here today because of the incredible people who acted quickly: the health care\n               professionals who knew what to do and did not hesitate and the team at STARS air ambulance\n               who got me to a stroke hospital within 80 minutes. They didn't just transport me.\n               They gave me a fighting chance. To all of them, I owe my life, and I will never forget\n               it. The reality is this. Organizations like the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada\n               remind us that heart disease and stroke take a life every five minutes in Canada.\n               Here in British Columbia, around 2,300 people die each year from stroke alone. These\n               are parents, children, friends and neighbours, and it's happening younger and younger\n               nowadays. Stroke and heart disease does not discriminate. That's why awareness matters. We need\n               young people to understand the risks and take their health seriously now, not later.\n               Because later may be too late. Since my stroke, I've had the opportunity to connect with the Heart and Stroke Foundation,\n               and I am proud to stand with them as an advocate. In my riding, I'm working to create\n               a support group so that people going through recovery don't feel alone. Because I\n               can tell you this: recovery is hard, it's humbling, and it changes you. I am not the same person I was in December, but I'm here, and for that I'm very, very\n               thankful. I'm Pete Davis, and I'm a proud stroke survivor.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752204","member_id":"bc-mla-377","member_name":"Pete Davis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's an honour to speak in this House today. Not long ago, I didn't know if I would\n               ever have this privilege again. Today is day 130 since the stroke that almost took my life. In a matter of minutes,\n               everything changed. The stroke took my ability to walk. It took my use of my right\n               hand and my right arm and blurred my vision for almost five months. One ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ead17bfbc505ca41011967a16c665b64c399610e859b907775a912bc56f0d39d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["41f1b5cf16eaeb32263b6cd4356c956b3daa8c53117e44a0661155dd43b85613"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e957e22b37e9a95b8f8fe22","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036441,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Pete Davis","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's a pleasure to see you. Well, I can sit down. Thank you, guys. Today is a big deal for me. It's a big milestone. Today is exactly, to the day, five\n               months since my stroke that almost took my life. December 27 was the day I went into\n               the hospital. For me to be here today is a huge milestone. I wasn't sure if I was\n               going to get here, but here I am. I just want to thank some people. The constituents of Kootenay-Rockies, for all of\n               your warm wishes, your prayers, your help. My regional association, they were in our\n               house doing dishes, cooking food, doing the chores that I usually would be able to\n               do, but of course, I couldn't. They've just been there with us the whole time. And,\n               of course, my family. My wife Heather and my four kids — Kaylee, Alyssa, Dylan and\n               Tyler — thank you guys for looking after me when I couldn't look after myself. It's an honour to be here. It's an honour to be able to represent Kootenay-Rockies.\n               Thank you guys so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036441","member_id":"bc-mla-377","member_name":"Pete Davis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, thank you, Mr. Speaker. It's a pleasure to see you. Well, I can sit down. Thank you, guys. Today is a big deal for me. It's a big milestone. Today is exactly, to the day, five\n               months since my stroke that almost took my life. December 27 was the day I went into\n               the hospital. For me to be here today is a huge milestone. I wasn't sure if I was\n               going ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["beb9b7c1b34bdea8fe76c58e2cef1be22140129ed2d66cc7ea0b2e7180d1fd65"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31f92d8d7798d260310ccfd5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036442,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Pete Davis","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour to be here. When I came here, I didn't come alone. I had some regional\n               association members that followed me to make sure I made it down and watched me walk\n               into this House. I'd like to introduce to you our regional association president,\n               Mr. Vince Miller, his beautiful wife, Kim, and our membership chair, Jo-Anne Takala. Thank you, guys, so much for coming. I also wanted to shout out to a couple others that were actually going to come, but\n               they couldn't make it — Darcy and Mo. They're also part of our regional association\n               — great supporters. I wouldn't be here without these people, so let's welcome them\n               to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036442","member_id":"bc-mla-377","member_name":"Pete Davis","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's an honour to be here. When I came here, I didn't come alone. I had some regional\n               association members that followed me to make sure I made it down and watched me walk\n               into this House. I'd like to introduce to you our regional association president,\n               Mr. Vince Miller, his beautiful wife, Kim, and our membership chair, Jo-Anne Takala. Thank you, guys, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["513949ec7df2382a30a9f0319b752bdc5c55648a5a399e9dc8ce5eec986ce1e5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-952671a1ab2a70dde39dd13e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317146,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak on Bill M231, a bill to recognize Veterans and First Responders Month\n               in British Columbia. I want to start by acknowledging that we are speaking on the territory of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People of the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. Across our province, from the north Island to the Interior, from the Lower Mainland\n               to the Kootenays, there are people who choose lives of service. Some wear the uniforms\n               of our nations, some wear the uniforms of our communities, but all of them step forward\n               to serve our communities when we need them most. When we think of veterans in British Columbia, we think of those who served in conflict\n               overseas, in peacekeeping missions and in defence of the freedoms that we enjoy today. When we think of first responders, we think of firefighters, paramedics, police officers,\n               search and rescue volunteers, dispatchers and so many others who respond to danger,\n               allowing all of us to feel safe in our communities because of their service. In recent years, British Columbians have seen more clearly than ever what service\n               means. During the devastating wildfire seasons that have impacted communities across\n               our province, members of the B.C. wildfire service worked around the clock to protect\n               homes and lives. On Vancouver Island this past summer, local volunteer firefighters from across the\n               island served alongside B.C. wildfire service to protect people's most precious and\n               valuable possessions — their homes. Paramedics from B.C. emergency health services answer call after call to support British\n               Columbians who are experiencing the worst days or moments of their lives with grace\n               and professionalism. Police officers from departments large and small have faced complex public safety\n               challenges, while striving to maintain trust and community relationships. Firefighters, both career and volunteer, have shown up in every corner of this province\n               when the call goes out. Ladysmith-Oceanside is served entirely by volunteer fire departments, and I'm often struck by the fact\n               that when these folks show up, they're the first responders. When they show up, they're\n               facing and helping the families that they know, their neighbours, their children's\n               best friend. It's incredible service. Veterans and first responders share something fundamental: a willingness to place\n               the well-being of others above their own. The recognition cannot be symbolic alone.\n               It must be accompanied by action — actions like, when this government formed in 2017,\n               there were a limited number of illnesses that were listed as presumptive for firefighters:\n               heart injuries and disease and only ten types of cancer. But now, 18 types of cancer, along with heart injuries and diseases, are recognized\n               as illnesses that firefighters have an increased risk of developing, and yet they\n               still show up. Thank you for your service. In 2018, we amended the Workers Compensation Act to add new presumption for PTSD and\n               other mental health conditions for first responders, including dispatchers. That was\n               followed in 2019 by changes to expand the cancer, heart disease and mental health\n               disorder presumptions to wildfire fighters, fire investigators and firefighters working for First Nations and Indigenous organizations. Budget 2026 recognizes the critical service that volunteer first responders provide\n               to communities they serve by doubling the provincial tax credit for volunteer first\n               responders from $3,000 to $6,000 to match the federal tax credit. These actions demonstrate this government's commitment to supporting veterans and\n               first responders in British Columbia — a commitment to better mental health supports,\n               a commitment to comprehensive health care benefits and a commitment to ensuring that\n               when service ends, dignity continues. This past weekend, I was honoured to be invited to the Qualicum Beach Legion 76 Navy\n               Day. Legion 76 has been hosting Navy Day for over 30 years, and I was humbled to meet\n               veterans from across the province who had travelled to This past weekend, I was honoured to be invited to the Qualicum Beach legion 76 Navy\n               Day. Legion 76 has been hosting Navy Day for over 30 years, and I was humbled to meet\n               veterans from across the province who had travelled to Qualicum Beach to reconnect\n               with their Navy colleagues. I heard stories of their service and sacrifice, and I\n               watched with warmth as they gathered and shared stories and reconnected. This kind of courage and bravery is rare, and it deserves extended recognition. It\n               is vital that we find all the ways possible to support and recognize this courage\n               and bravery. Recognition of the lasting impact that this courage can have on physical\n               and mental health, recognition of the impact that shift work under extreme circumstances\n               has on family life, recognition to search and rescue volunteers who leave the dinner\n               table when the pager goes off. Service like this deserves recognition. Gratitude is powerful, but gratitude expressed through public recognition, education\n               and policy is transformative. British Columbians feel a deep respect for those who\n               serve, and they expect their government to show support. This government has done\n               so through past legislation and will continue to show respect through our actions. For the first responders and veterans who may be watching or who are in the audience\n               today, your service matters, your sacrifice matters, and British Columbia will not\n               forget.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317146","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise to speak on Bill M231, a bill to recognize Veterans and First Responders Month\n               in British Columbia. I want to start by acknowledging that we are speaking on the territory of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People of the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. Across our province, from the north Island to the Interior, from the Lower Mainland\n               to the Kootenays, there are people w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["28826e7e8198eb517f5904480146cf9a52dc6de71f12e16bbb94e362c1afe79b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78e09566f62a5c0db909c89dec9be0dbb76b9f97b34470208e157f58414a536b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec7f269c84faf7fd02b25b8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317147,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start by recognizing that we are doing our work today on the territory of\n               the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People of the Songhees and the Esquimalt Nations. I am grateful to them for their stewardship\n               of this land since time immemorial. I also want to recognize that I'm giving this budget speech under the umbrella of\n               grief that continues to cover the community of Tumbler Ridge and the entire province.\n               I want to extend my heartfelt condolences to the community and also to the member\n               for Peace River South. I'm thinking of you, and I think you are demonstrating outstanding representation\n               for your community right now. It feels awkward in this moment of provincial tragedy to move forward with the work\n               of government, but we have to, we need to, and that's why people put us here, and\n               British Columbians deserve it. So I rise today to speak in favour of Budget 2026, a budget that responds to an unprecedented\n               global economic repositioning that is facing every province in Canada, including British\n               Columbia. I want to thank the Finance Minister and her team for working hard to deliver\n               this budget during these extraordinary times. To listen to the members opposite, you would think that these unprecedented economic\n               circumstances are only happening in British Columbia, but this fracture in the global\n               economic way of being is happening around the world, and it's impacting every province in\n               Canada. The member for Kamloops Centre made a big deal about trying to compare our budget\n               to the proficiency scale, and he kind of bumbled around with the words. He couldn't\n               remember what the words were. The proficiency scale was introduced in B.C. schools as part of the modernized curriculum,\n               and the modernized curriculum was introduced in order to make sure that today's schools\n               are preparing today's students for a rapidly changing world. That's what was recognized\n               by the OECD when they looked at B.C.'s learning transformation. And if the current global context doesn't exemplify rapidly changing, then I'm not sure what else could. Just because the proficiency scale has come up\n               in so many of the members' opposite speeches.... It's only four words — emerging, developing,\n               proficient and extending. But back to the budget. This budget positions our province to safeguard the services\n               that people rely on, and at its core this budget reflects a clear understanding of\n               the challenges British Columbians are experiencing, and it responds with a steady\n               and practical investment and planning during rapidly changing times. Budgets are often discussed in technical terms, in revenue assumptions, in forecasts,\n               in capital envelopes and line items, but for the people that we represent, budgets\n               are not technical documents. They are their government's expressions of priorities.\n               They determine whether families can access health care when they need it, whether\n               young people see opportunities in their communities, whether infrastructure is going\n               to keep pace with growth and whether businesses have confidence in the future. Budget 2026 recognizes these expectations. It balances ambition with necessary discipline.\n               It protects core services while advancing strategic investment. It shows that government\n               can be prudent and proactive, safeguarding stability while creating opportunity. This\n               budget safeguards education, health care and child care, among other core services\n               that British Columbians rely on. It continues the unprecedented capital investments\n               necessary to support British Columbians with a sustainable pace and strives to future-proof\n               our economy with immediate investments in skills training to meet the moment that\n               we are at while being able to take advantage of emerging opportunities with the federal\n               government. Today I want to speak about this budget not only in provincial terms but through the\n               lens of the people I represent, the residents of Ladysmith-Oceanside, because ultimately that is where the impact of budgets are felt, across the ridings\n               of British Columbia. From Saltair to Dashwood, the people of Ladysmith-Oceanside share a practical outlook. They want government to be focused and accountable and\n               responsive. They want access to health care. They want attainable housing. While I have heard a lot of criticism from the members opposite about housing, I think\n               I think it's really important to note that B.C. is currently building almost half\n               of the non-market housing in Canada right now. Almost half in Canada. They want safe....\n               The members of Ladysmith-Oceanside want safe and reliable infrastructure, strong schools, thriving economies that protect\n               and promote the natural assets of our beautiful riding. reflects those priorities,\n               not in rhetoric but in action and in strategic and thoughtful investment. Budget 2026 arrives at a time when governments must navigate global economic volatility.\n               Demographic shifts, labour shortages and evolving supply chains continue to influence\n               local realities. Families are focused on affordability, employers are managing costs\n               and workforce needs, and communities are planning growth amid rapidly changing conditions.\n               In this environment, responsible fiscal management is not optional; it is essential.\n               But the members opposite this past week are simultaneously saying that we are spending\n               too much or not enough. And that is not a fiscal reality. This budget demonstrates the fiscal reality that we are in. It maintains a disciplined\n               approach to financial stewardship while ensuring critical services and investments\n               remain strong. It recognizes that cutting investments in uncertain times would undermine\n               long-term prosperity, just as unchecked spending would jeopardize stability. Instead, the government has chosen a steady course, one that recognizes that stability\n               matters. When residents feel secure in public service and economic direction, they\n               are better able to plan their futures. When businesses see predictability in policy,\n               they invest with confidence. When communities know infrastructure and services will\n               keep pace, they grow responsibly. For Ladysmith-Oceanside, this balanced approach provides reassurance that provincial planning aligns with\n               local needs, protecting today while preparing for tomorrow. Health care remains one of the most important issues raised by the constituents in\n               Ladysmith-Oceanside. Whether speaking with seniors or young families or front-line workers, I consistently\n               hear the same message. Access matters. People want timely care. They want continuity.\n               They want to know that professionals are supported and that facilities are equipped\n               to meet the demand. Budget 2026 continues meaningful investments in strengthening\n               the health care workforce, primary care access and supporting facilities across the\n               riding of Improved access to family health care practitioners strengthens preventative care\n               and reduces strain on emergency services. Supporting health care workers improves\n               retention and morale. Budget 2026 invests $2.8 billion in new funding for the health care system over three\n               years, including $2.3 billion to increase health care system capacity and support\n               a growing need for service, including supporting hiring more doctors, nurses, health\n               care practitioners and the planning and development and operation of new and expanded\n               hospitals and health care facilities across the province. For Ladysmith-Oceanside, this is represented and reflected in the generational investments in the central\n               Island region in health care infrastructure. This includes the recently completed\n               high acuity wing at the Nanaimo Regional General Hospital. Construction has started\n               on the $300 million Nanaimo cancer centre to ensure that the residents of Ladysmith-Oceanside can receive the care they need when they need it, where they need it. The new long-term care facility in Lantzville will see almost 300 new beds, including\n               a 20-bed hospice unit and 26-bed specialized population unit. Through careful work\n               with Island Health for a thoughtful redesign to bring costs down, and in line with\n               this current moment and, I will say, strong advocacy from the central Island MLAs,\n               this project has cleared planning hurdles and is scheduled to open its doors in 2029. Last week, we were pleased to announce the beginning of a concept plan for the replacement\n               of the Nanaimo Regional General Hospital tower. These are generational investments, and Budget 2026 will also include $121 million\n               for intensive mental health and addictions treatment. For Ladysmith-Oceanside, this means the opening of an addiction treatment facility that will be accepting\n               new patients in Parksville in the fall of 2026. The centre will have a Road to Recovery\n               model, which will include 19 overnight beds, as well as plans to provide counselling\n               services to those in need of post-treatment and transition supports. Continued infrastructure and service investment ensures regional accessibility for\n               people of the central Island region. To ensure that British Columbians have sustained\n               access to family health care practitioners, this government is planning for the future\n               by building Canada's first new medical school in 60 years, training the next generation\n               of doctors. This government is looking ahead, unlike previous governments who rejected\n               a plan to build this medical school. They rejected it. These measures contribute to tangible outcomes, shorter waits, better continuity and\n               stronger patient confidence. For the riding of Ladysmith-Oceanside, this has translated into more than ten new family health care practitioners in the\n               last year alone. We heard last week that 4,200 people a week across B.C. are being attached to family\n               health care practitioners. Just recently, the OurCare survey, a national project on\n               primary care, said that B.C. is the most improved province with access to primary\n               health care. We currently have an attachment rate of 83 percent, which is up 12 percent\n               in four years. I am receiving emails weekly from the people of Ladysmith-Oceanside who have been attached to a new family practitioner, and we know that there are more\n               coming in the next year. That is what it looks like when you prioritize the services\n               that people need. Investment in health care is a cornerstone of this budget, because we know that people\n               deserve access to the care they need when they need it, and we have continued to prioritize\n               that. It affirms that the public health care system will remain a pillar of equity\n               in access to health care. Education and child care are among the most important long-term investments that any\n               government can make, and they are critically important to the riding of Ladysmith-Oceanside. It shapes the opportunity, economic productivity and social well-being. For the young families of Ladysmith-Oceanside, the investments in child care allow families to plan for their future and know that\n               the days of child care costs being more expensive than mortgage payments are a thing\n               of the past. Budget 2026 provides a $330 million lift to ChildCareBC to stabilize programs and\n               services that families rely on as government works to modernize B.C.'s child care\n               system. This funding will maintain lower fees and the spaces and support for operators\n               and educators achieved over the past eight years. This budget also sees $25 million of new money to support the expansion of before-\n               and after-school care on school grounds, because we have heard clearly from families\n               that having the ability to receive child care and schooling in one site adds to a\n               stable learning environment for the children This budget also sees $25 million of new money to support the expansion of before-\n               and after-school care on school grounds, because we have heard clearly from families\n               that having the ability to receive child care and schooling on one site adds to a\n               stable learning environment for the children and creates more time for families by\n               eliminating multiple drop-off and pickup locations. For K-to-12 education, Budget 2026 includes $634 million of new funding over three\n               years, including $167 million in the classroom enhancement fund. This will result\n               in more teachers for students across British Columbia, including critically important\n               inclusion support teachers and teacher-psychologists and counsellors. We know that\n               when we have a system that supports those priority populations of students, all students\n               in the building will thrive. That's what maintaining a focus on core services and\n               supports looks like. This government has surged school construction by more than tripling the school capital\n               budget over the previous government — tripled the school capital budget. Because we\n               also know that students deserve safe and modern learning environments, Budget 2026\n               includes $3.9 billion in capital funding for seismic replacements and upgrades, as\n               well as projects to address enrolment growth in B.C.'s fastest-growing communities. For Ladysmith-Oceanside, for the PACs and the DPACs that have reached out, I am going to fight like crazy\n               to make sure that Ladysmith Intermediate and the town of Ladysmith are recipients\n               of some of that funding. The minister is right here. I am going to say it again: Ladysmith\n               Intermediate. That is to make sure that the riding of Ladysmith-Oceanside can benefit from other projects already completed in the school district by this\n               government, including the seismic upgrades of schools like Pleasant Valley, Solero\n               Elementary and the expansions of Hammond Bay Elementary and Dover Bay Secondary School.\n               Budget 2026 continues support for K-to-12 education by ensuring that classrooms remain\n               safe, inclusive and supportive. For Ladysmith-Oceanside, workforce readiness is especially important to our local industries, including construction,\n               the marine sector, tourism and small business. They depend on skilled workers. Supporting\n               trades training and accessible learning pathways ensures talent remains local while\n               opportunity expands. That's what Budget 2026 does, by opening the door for more British Columbians to be\n               trained for in-demand skilled trades. This budget has a total of $283 million in funding,\n               which includes $240 million to double skilled trades funding over three years, which\n               helps bolster ship repair and shipbuilding industries that we are supporting with\n               extended tax credits; and $12 million over three years to enhance employer training\n               grants, helping double apprenticeship seats by 2028-29. As a mom of a young person entering the workforce, battling the emergence of AI, hands-on\n               skills training through employer grants offers stability and opportunity to young\n               people during a difficult economic cycle. As a former school trustee, it would be\n               no surprise that I firmly believe that a strong and vibrant public education system\n               will cultivate civic participation, curiosity and resilience. That goes beyond just\n               K to 12s and includes educational opportunities beyond traditional school settings. Budget 2026 invests in educational opportunities for British Columbians, no matter\n               where they are in their educational journeys or where they are located in the province.\n               These opportunities will strengthen communities beyond economic contribution alone.\n               This budget's focus on education demonstrates a recognition that prosperity begins\n               with preparation, preparing individuals not just for employment but for this rapidly\n               changing world that we find ourselves existing in. I know that feeling safe in your home and on the streets is critical to the families\n               of Ladysmith-Oceanside. Constituents in this riding choose small-town life because they relish the feeling\n               of knowing your neighbour and leaving your door unlocked and your keys on the passenger\n               seat of your car. Budget 2026 provides $139 million more over three years to reduce repeat violent offending\n               and chronic property crime and support timely access to justice. This includes $16\n               million for new chronic property offending intervention initiatives that strengthen\n               monitoring and enforcement for crimes, such as vandalism and shoplifting, that are\n               hurting businesses. We know these measures are working. In Oceanside, we have seen an 80 percent reduction\n               in break and enters in local businesses over this time last year. Noting the hour, I reserve my place to continue at the next sitting and move adjournment\n               of the debate. Noting the hour, I reserve my place to continue at the next sitting and move adjournment\n               of the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317147","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I want to start by recognizing that we are doing our work today on the territory of\n               the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People of the Songhees and the Esquimalt Nations. I am grateful to them for their stewardship\n               of this land since time immemorial. I also want to recognize that I'm giving this budget speech under the umbrella of\n               grief that continues to cover the co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b388d6b3690246905c9e23d2124f76ce75e3fc0c027e5115117c42cefe886e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c834fa123223cc6d83fc2516de2bdbaafc2829d9b618c12b79c0f445c28039c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37da3b63c5662d1175bee0de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317148,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm trying to remember where I left off. We were talking about the importance of community\n               safety. The riding of Ladysmith-Oceanside is made up of a number of small towns in rural areas, where people choose to live the small-town life so that they can leave their doors unlocked and their car keys on the passenger\n               seat and know their neighbour. Budget 2026 provides $139 million more over three years to reduce repeat violent offending\n               and chronic property crime and supports timely access to justice. It includes $16\n               million for a new chronic property offending intervention initiative that strengthens monitoring and enforcement for crimes such as vandalism and\n               shoplifting that are hurting businesses. We know that these measures that we're implementing are working. In Ladysmith-Oceanside, we've seen an 80 percent reduction in break and enter to local businesses over this\n               time last year. Small businesses are central to the identity and vitality of Ladysmith-Oceanside. They provide employment, they foster creativity, and they sustain the unique community\n               character that is Ladysmith-Oceanside. Budget 2026 includes measures that encourage business stability and growth, helping\n               entrepreneurs adapt and thrive in evolving economic conditions. This includes a new temporary 15 percent manufacturing and processing investment refundable\n               tax credit for businesses investing in buildings, in machinery and in equipment used\n               in manufacturing and processing. We've also heard a lot about the $400 million strategic investment fund, which has\n               never been seen before in B.C.'s history and allows us the opportunity to respond We've also heard a lot about the $400 million strategic investment fund that has never\n               been seen before in B.C.'s history and allows us the opportunity to respond to the\n               moments we're in, the unpredictable, rapidly changing moments we're in. That strategic\n               investment fund is there for us to be able to make sure that we can respond to the\n               unique opportunities that are being presented to us during this time. Supporting small\n               enterprises ensures that communities retain their distinctiveness while generating\n               economic momentum. Tourism remains particularly important for Ladysmith-Oceanside. Visitors are drawn to us by our natural beauty, numerous cultural events and coastal\n               experiences. My calendar in the summer is so full because of all the incredible events\n               that happen in this riding, filled with tourists, that contribute greatly to our local\n               economy. This government's continued investment supporting tourism promotion and infrastructure\n               ensures that these opportunities will continue. When small businesses succeed, the effects ripple onward through employment, through\n               mentorship and community engagement. This budget recognizes their importance as the\n               engine of local prosperity. As a small business owner myself, a family supported by\n               a small business, we welcome these opportunities. British Columbia is served by over 15,000 volunteer firefighters and search and rescue\n               volunteers, including marine search and rescue. The Ladysmith marine search and rescue\n               station is one of the busiest in the province. We are so thankful to them for their\n               service. In order to recognize the critical contribution that these volunteer first responders\n               provide to the safety of British Columbians, this government has doubled the income\n               tax credit from $3,000 to $6,000. I'm particularly proud of this. This is an initiative\n               that started in Ladysmith-Oceanside with a local town councillor. Our local MP took it to the feds. He is the one who\n               got it changed to $6,000. I was so happy to pick up the torch and bring it to us, to the provincial government,\n               to see that tax credit doubled by matching the federal tax credit for volunteer first\n               responders. This government is saving families up to $900 a year when the provincial\n               tax credit and the federal tax credit are combined. Since Ladysmith-Oceanside is served entirely by volunteer and paid on-call fire departments,\n               search and rescue and RCMSAR volunteers, this is recognition of the critical work\n               those volunteers do for the people of Ladysmith-Oceanside. Also, I've heard from our local governments that the tax credit will help smaller\n               local governments recruit and retain volunteers at a time when those calls are increasing. Budget 2026 reflects steady leadership, thoughtful planning during unprecedented times.\n               It balances prudence with progress, ensuring that services remain strong while strategic\n               investments continue. For the people of Ladysmith-Oceanside, this budget signals recognition of growth, potential and the contribution to provincial\n               prosperity. It addresses priorities that matter locally while advancing broader provincial\n               objectives during rapidly changing times. I stand in support of Budget 2026 and the opportunities it represents for communities\n               throughout British Columbia and for the residents of Ladysmith-Oceanside, who I am honoured to represent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317148","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'm trying to remember where I left off. We were talking about the importance of community\n               safety. The riding of Ladysmith-Oceanside is made up of a number of small towns in rural areas, where people choose to live the small-town life so that they can leave their doors unlocked and their car keys on the passenger\n               seat and know their neighbour. Budget 2026 provides $13","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["354022c995cb693093c55d1f5f8db39cb68e6863e51b3140b69761b7495b46b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["02273a325581a3dd5ae915554a7d172d2b73ad2179bcda3250d26c50ba8fd9ed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2c2a7da47ee1d1c9d4d4300","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317149,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last week was Heritage Week in B.C. B.C. Heritage Week sets out to inspire people\n               to connect with local heritage and to raise awareness of the many ways it shapes our\n               communities, our identities and our daily lives. The theme for 2026 is \"Stir the Pot.\" \"Stir the Pot\" has two important meanings. It\n               recognizes the importance that food has in bringing us together, tying us to traditions\n               and families and ancestors. But \"Stir the Pot\" also suggests advocacy. It's a call\n               to create space for dialogue and conversation. This evening I am thrilled to be invited to attend the Ladysmith and District Historical\n               Society's seventh annual heritage awards. In Ladysmith, heritage is a key part of\n               the community profile and economy, and much of the credit for showcasing the community's\n               history belongs to the volunteers of the Ladysmith and District Historical Society. The event will not only be an evening to honour those who work on the preservation\n               of the town's history but, adhering to the theme of \"Stir the Pot\", will feature a\n               traditional Stz'uminus meal prepared and served according to Coast Salish protocol. This year four worthy recipients will be honoured with an award: Ladysmith Secondary\n               School's land and language program, which is an immersive cultural curriculum focused\n               on Coast Salish language and culture through land-based experiential learning; Bruce\n               Mason for his cultural contributions through the Ladysmith Little Theatre; Michael\n               Dean for documenting local heritage through his art; and Michael Robinson for his\n               heritage timeline in the Ladysmith and District Credit Union. Thank you to the people of Ladysmith for growing and learning together, expanding\n               their understanding of heritage beyond what was taught in school, and finding a way\n               to weave together the ancient heritage of the lands that we live on with the important\n               contributions that contemporary heritage plays on community. HÍSW̱ḴE SIÁM to the Ladysmith and District Historical Society for their courage and grace. I would\n               say that this year they've nailed the theme.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317149","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Last week was Heritage Week in B.C. B.C. Heritage Week sets out to inspire people\n               to connect with local heritage and to raise awareness of the many ways it shapes our\n               communities, our identities and our daily lives. The theme for 2026 is \"Stir the Pot.\" \"Stir the Pot\" has two important meanings. It\n               recognizes the importance that food has in bringing us ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ea5b59a91a3604af149774bdd373e692f4ac164370b4a675d7e7a37b92d28b0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bb1ed9e8be93895c321506936c25ce0dc41ca0b413a0efce1a49a814c9bb585"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3dc2200678bd91436c91c88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327982,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327982","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3dc90f90a5b64fe2d759888270e0a552997930a479042dbaf264e240dce5d171"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35ce3e10c38a9acde7d5e049","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327983,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start by recognizing that I am giving this address on the territory of the\n               lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. I want to recognize that debate in this House has become quite difficult, and it may\n               have been difficult for members of the First Nations locally, or any First Nation,\n               to be watching debate. It has been hard. I just want to acknowledge that. I feel and\n               my heart feels and recognizes that we are talking about people's rights when people\n               are screaming and yelling and banging on desks, and I just want to acknowledge that.\n               It would feel insincere to acknowledge the territory without acknowledging what's\n               happening right now in this House. So I rise today to speak in support of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendment Act. This is actually something that I know quite a bit about.\n               In fact, I might be able to trace my pathway to this podium to a terrible experience\n               with an FOI request to a public body. Many years ago — 2013, maybe 2012 — I was part of a grassroots group of people in\n               my community that were trying to save all the schools in the small community I live\n               in from being closed and having the students bussed out of the community. The member opposite talked about how these decisions are decisions that impact your\n               life and you have a right to see how those decisions are being made and the information\n               that is being used to make those decisions. And, boy, I couldn't think of a situation\n               that impacts people more than their children's schooling, that gets people more excited\n               and more active than your children's schooling. And this particular decision that\n               started my path to politics affected every family in our community with a school-aged\n               child. Local representation, through the process, refused to answer any questions. The engagement\n               was, in my opinion, a kangaroo court. And then decisions were made. And an entire\n               community lost its schools and we didn't know why. I didn't have one email returned\n               through that process. When we lost all our schools and we wanted to better understand why, by that point,\n               the only option that we had was to submit for an FOI request, which we did. We submitted\n               an FOI request. The process was repeatedly dragged out, waiting until the very last day to respond,\n               putting up enormous fees in hopes that we would back down, restarting the clock with\n               every back-and-forth. All the power in the process was held by the public body. And it was actually just a combination of community organizing and fundraising. There\n               was a floor hockey tournament to raise money to pay for the FOI fees that they were\n               asking us for. It was like sheer tenacity that we were finally able, after months\n               of requests, to receive the documents that we were after. In fact, the Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner ruled that our fees\n               were exorbitant and they had to be returned to us. This process led me to run for\n               school board, win, reverse the decision, reopen the schools and my son graduated from\n               that school last year. So I tell you that story because obfuscation, which is a word I like to say a lot\n               and I should be able to say it better, with regards to freedom of information requests\n               is something that I am familiar with and something that I care deeply about. These proposed changes are not made to obfuscate people's access to information. None\n               of the changes proposed here impact the oversight of the independent Office of the\n               Information and Privacy Commissioner, and that's really important for people to remember.\n               The independent Office of the Privacy That's really important for people to remember. The independent office of the Privacy\n               Commissioner — none of the changes impact their oversight. In fact, these proposed changes are part of a much-needed move of modernization that\n               is being led by the Minister of Citizens' Services and her team to create efficiency\n               and accessibility to many of B.C.'s processes, including freedom of information and\n               protection of privacy laws and access. It's time that we, as a province, embark on\n               this path of integrated services, one that matches the world our citizens are living\n               in, the world the next generation of decision-makers is way ahead of us on. We can't\n               back down from these necessary steps because of, in my opinion, political dog-whistles\n               about weakening access and unreasonable authority. None of these changes impact the oversight ability of the independent office of the\n               Privacy of Information Commissioner. I'm going to say that a lot in this speech because\n               it's a really important point. The public should expect that their government will utilize the most effective and\n               efficient processes available to serve them. The public should also expect that as\n               service levels change, government will adjust processes to ensure improved productivity\n               in order to meet increased needs and changing demands. That is exactly what Bill 9\n               does. In this digital era, and in this era of increased distrust in government, we have\n               seen increased requests for information along with increased complexity of these requests.\n               As the minister stated, the data and evidence shows a 28 percent increase in the number\n               of pages of information processed over the past four years, and a tripling of the\n               size of each file that's processed. In 2024-25, freedom of information operations processed 2.18 million pages, up from\n               1.64 million pages in 2021. Between 2020-2021 and 2024-25, the average general request\n               grew from 146 pages per file to 508 pages per file. As demands change, so too should the processes used to meet those demands. Anything other than an attempt\n               to improve efficiency and productivity would be wasting taxpayers' time and money. Change is not always bad. I think about the fact that as a kid, my dad — well, I guess\n               until he died — had this huge scar across his belly from having his appendix out.\n               And then when my sister had her appendix out, her scar was this teeny, tiny scar. My sister didn't go to the doctor and say: \"That process where you sliced open my\n               dad worked fine enough for him, so I want that one.\" She expected improved service\n               based on knowing how to do things better, and that's what Bill 9 does. The opposition bangs on the tables every day about the size of the public service.\n               Evidence shows that we have an increased demand, and we are looking to improve efficiency\n               and improve productivity with this bill. And they cry foul. It's hypocritical. That's what Bill 9 does. It improves productivity. It improves efficiency. It is the\n               evolution of service. The proposed amendments can be grouped into three categories. The first is connected services to streamline information-sharing and create the ability\n               to issue directions and standards with the end goal of providing the applicant with\n               a one-stop-shop approach to getting the information they need. What does this mean? The minister earlier spoke about how the general public doesn't\n               see the government as a series of ministries that they have to go to. They experience\n               the government through events in their lives, moments in their lives — welcoming a\n               child, navigating an illness, launching a business. Recently, my family, going through the process of trying to acquire death certificates\n               — I can't tell you how many times my mom was going from door to door trying to get\n               death certificates. Too often, these moments require people to move through disconnected\n               systems that treat each moment like it's a separate transaction. That's what we experienced\n               recently in my family. Connected services create the legal foundation for government to work as one Too often these moments require people to move through disconnected systems that treat\n               each moment like it's a separate transaction. That's what we experienced recently\n               in my family. Connected Services creates the legal foundation for government to work as one unified\n               system behind the scenes, enabling a more predictable and supportive system from government\n               for people. These amendments enable a single government gateway for people to apply\n               and receive their government services and update their information across multiple\n               government programs. Connected Services will improve service delivery by ensuring\n               that information is shared appropriately across programs, using existing systems. While Connected Services is designed to enable secure sharing of information between\n               public bodies, the legislation does not consolidate all personal information into\n               one central place. This allows for increased efficiencies while still maintaining\n               appropriate privacy levels and — maybe by the end, everybody will be saying it with\n               me — oversight of the independent Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner. The second category is FOI efficiencies. These are amendments to improve process efficiency\n               and transparency for applicants and to enable public bodies to better manage the administrative\n               workload associated with processing the changing nature of FOI requests. What does improving efficiency mean? With these amendments, we'll be able to limit\n               duplicate disclosure processes so people's time and taxpayer dollars aren't wasted\n               processing records that are already being released through other processes, such as\n               legal discovery. These amendments enable the proactive release of information to individuals who are\n               seeking their own personal information, including improving access for applicants,\n               especially — the one that tugs at my heart — former children in care. Imagine trying\n               to seek your own information and having to repeat your story over and over again.\n               This creates huge efficiencies within the system when you note that 60 percent of\n               FOI applicants are for personal information. That's what improvement looks like. In any field, in any sector, it's expected that\n               you review data, you understand the issues, and you respond with better processes.\n               That's what this bill proposes to do. The third category is miscellaneous efficiencies and clarifications, which allows\n               for minor miscellaneous and clarifying amendments that are needed to address operational\n               inefficiencies caused by the current Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Act requirements or misinterpretations of them. That happens a lot. It's like when you have a form at school, and it keeps coming\n               back when you're filling out those forms, and every single time it comes back, and\n               over half the families are filling this form out incorrectly. You look at the form,\n               and you think: \"Wow, maybe we didn't design a form very well, so we should change\n               the form to make it better for people.\" That's what miscellaneous efficiencies and clarifications does. It clears up those\n               misinterpretations that have contributed to administrative burdens. We hear a lot these days from the opposition about red tape and unnecessary delays.\n               Here we have amendments that actually address the issues of productivity, making the\n               process smoother and faster, and the other side pulls out their dog whistles and cries\n               foul. I find it exhausting, and I find it hypocritical. Some people have expressed concern that allowing the ability to disregard requests\n               based on abusive or malicious behaviour is simply an opportunity to disregard some\n               requests. This concern does not take into account that there is an existing process\n               where the independent Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner must approve\n               a request to disregard an FOI process. I'm familiar with this because the public body\n               I mentioned earlier attempted to have part of our request dismissed, and it was denied\n               by the commissioner. All these proposed changes do is add an additional circumstance in which that denial\n               can occur by the independent Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner. The Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner retains oversight over whether\n               the body can disregard the request. Any public body must seek approval from the independent\n               Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner before disregarding a request.\n               And let's be clear. The evidence and data show Let's be clear. The evidence and data show that these requests are rare. While they\n               are rare, repeated, abusive or malicious requests are disruptive, and they are costly.\n               Most importantly, they take time away from processing other, valid requests for people\n               such as, as previously mentioned, a former child in care who's trying to seek out\n               information about themselves. Any legislation is only as good as the consultation undertaken. In this case, the\n               ministry received praise from the province's expert, from the actual Information and\n               Privacy Commissioner himself, who said: He also said: I mean, that's a pretty great endorsement. In addition to working with the independent Office of the Information and Privacy\n               Commissioner, the ministry also undertook extensive consultation with key sectors,\n               including health, post-secondary, K to 12, local governments and Indigenous Peoples\n               on these proposed amendments. While there have been, in my opinion, unnecessary accusations that these amendments\n               are an attempt to weaken the FOI laws and to try to keep the public in the dark, nothing\n               could be further from the truth. FOIPPA plays an important role in protecting democratic governance. I think the member\n               opposite actually spoke really eloquently about the importance it plays in protecting\n               people's democracy and protecting people's privacy — in a digital world, it gets more\n               and more important — by setting clear rules for how people's personal information\n               must be protected. With these amendments, those principles remain unchanged. What has evolved is technology and, more important, how people interact with government.\n               Government must evolve as well if we are going to meet modern expectations and continue\n               to be able to serve the public. These amendments are essential to delivering modern,\n               digital services that are inclusive, efficient and, most importantly, worthy of the\n               public's trust. I want to finish by reading the rest of the statement given by the independent Privacy\n               Commissioner in response to these proposed amendments. Then there's a whole part that I already read earlier about being consulted. Then\n               they go on. The commissioner goes on to say: Increase transparency. I'll say that a lot too. They also said: They also said: It came up today in question period. Look at that. The independent office is asking\n               for that It came up today in question period. Look at that. The independent office is asking\n               for that. \"I am encouraged by the approach\" — still a quote — \"the government has taken here,\n               and I am optimistic about the opportunity to share our perspectives on those topics\n               over the coming months and years.\" That's a pretty great endorsement. If you look\n               at it, it actually takes up an entire page. With an endorsement like that, along with recognition that the world is rapidly changing\n               around us and that government must as well, these amendments are critical to ensuring\n               that government has the tools necessary to meet the moment we are at. I want to thank the minister and her team for their diligent work on this. I'm so\n               glad that she actually happens to be here right now. I don't think I'm supposed to\n               say that. These changes protect privacy, they uphold access to information, they enable better\n               services for British Columbians, and they support a more transparent, efficient, people-centred\n               private sector. None of these changes impact the oversight ability of the independent\n               Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner, and they are clearly supported\n               by the expert in the area.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327983","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to start by recognizing that I am giving this address on the territory of the\n               lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations. I want to recognize that debate in this House has become quite difficult, and it may\n               have been difficult for members of the First Nations locally, or any First Nation,\n               to be watching debate. It has been hard","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c81bd708cd7e7b0c2b262d09a3b281f74d7ba5e50b84b223bae07b9ab5d99a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3fbd0d797f7b5562d13581c9b0677d7c56e3d024630b2e907061f67c4a7f9b75"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fb07bcacfda815d70e82619c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327984,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports Bill 3 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327984","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Section A reports Bill 3 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-089f11146e15119294efa0b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327985,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports that Bill 5 is complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327985","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Section A reports that Bill 5 is complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e620c667a3c1bce9f03f0ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360168,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to honour International Women's Day by talking about this day from a\n               bit of a different perspective, as a feminist woman raising boys. When I became a mom of only boys, I wondered how I could raise my boys to be feminists.\n               It was an intentional but not radical choice that I made the commitment to raising\n               the next generation with the belief that every person deserves equality, safety When I became a mom of only boys, I wondered how I could raise my boys to be feminists.\n               It was an intentional but not radical choice that I made the commitment to raising\n               the next generation with the belief that every person deserves equality, safety, dignity\n               and opportunity. For decades, much of the conversation about gender equality has focused on empowering\n               girls, and that work is vital, but equality cannot be achieved with the participation\n               of only half of our children. If we want a future that is fair, that is inclusive,\n               then boys must be part of that journey and they must be raised with the tools, the\n               values and the confidence to help lead it. So what does it mean to raise feminist boys, or boys to be feminists? It means raising\n               boys who understand that equality benefits everyone, that respecting women and girls\n               is the foundation of strong relationships, of healthy communities and of a safer society. Boys are not born believing in inequality. They learn it through the world around\n               them — through media, through jokes, through peer pressure and sometimes even from\n               the adults they are taught to trust the most. A recent example of this is a spotlight\n               placed on the U.S. men's Olympic hockey team, laughing with the President of the United States as he makes jokes about\n               a women's hockey team, at the expense of the success of the women's team, despite\n               the fact that the women's team has a far more superior winning record over decades, despite far fewer resources than the men's team. What message did that moment send to young men? That is how boys learn inequality.\n               But they can also learn empathy. They can learn fairness. They can learn courage,\n               the courage to stand up rather than stand by. And those lessons begin early in the\n               smallest ways. When a boy is encouraged to express his feelings, he learns that vulnerability is\n               not a weakness; it is humanity. When he is taught to apologize sincerely and listen\n               with intention, he develops empathy. When he is trusted with responsibility and held\n               accountable for his behaviour, he learns respect. And when he sees a woman in leadership\n               — at home, at school, in the community — he internalizes the truth that leadership\n               is not determined by gender. Raising boys to be feminists is not about telling them they are the problem. It's\n               about showing them that they can be part of the solution. It's about teaching them\n               that strength and compassion are not opposites; they are partners. That consent is\n               not a rule; it is an expression of respect. That equality is not a threat to them\n               but a gift that opens doors to healthier friendships, closer families and workplaces\n               built on collaboration rather than competition. And this is not only about the well-being of women and girls, although that alone would be reason enough. It is also profoundly\n               about the well-being of boys themselves. For too long, boys have been boxed in by expectations that often harm them: \"Don't cry. Toughen up. Don't show fear.\" These\n               messages don't create strong men. They create isolated men. When we raise boys with feminist values, we give them permission to speak, to feel,\n               to grow. We also give them permission to be allies, to be the ones who intervene when\n               they hear a harmful joke or when a friend crosses the line. Imagine the impact that a young man, having the knowledge, the understanding and the\n               confidence to step in, would have had on EM in that London hotel room in 2018 after a celebration of the Canadian men's World Junior hockey team. Boys who are empowered to act with integrity become men who build safer environments\n               for everyone. This work belongs to all of us. It happens in conversations at home. It happens in\n               how we talk about history and consent and relationships. It happens in how we model\n               partnerships, how we respond when boys make mistakes and how we celebrate their successes.\n               Every moment is a lesson, spoken or unspoken, about what we value. As a mom of boys, I have learned through my own beautiful humans that boys are ready\n               for this. Today's generation is thoughtful, curious, more open than ever. They want\n               fairness. They want to live in a world where everyone has a chance to thrive. This\n               is not something radical. As a mom of boys today, my job is to guide them toward the\n               instincts they already have, help them carry those instincts into adulthood. Raising boys to be feminists is one of the most powerful investments we can make in\n               our future. It leads to healthier relationships, stronger families and communities\n               grounded in mutual respect. It ensures that the next generation grows up with the\n               belief that equality is not an aspiration but a responsibility. So I am raising my boys to foster empathy, respect and equity. By raising feminist\n               boys, I am giving them the tools to grow not just into good men but into fair men\n               who stand beside women and girls as equals, as partners and as champions of justice. Because when we raise boys to be feminists, we build a world that everyone can thrive\n               in.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360168","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to honour International Women's Day by talking about this day from a\n               bit of a different perspective, as a feminist woman raising boys. When I became a mom of only boys, I wondered how I could raise my boys to be feminists.\n               It was an intentional but not radical choice that I made the commitment to raising\n               the next generation with the belief ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95696f987e86f223d10a74c567051525970985169c4df54a6fdd89688fb935de","361174eb13237a7439cd000f1b6931a7ae11d64932449c326d0c2a84f4064773"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb475b5bb29ed8220f81b0cef2d59e1ed4d4b9900044c5038075987ac117c62a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c14a2fc768e1af8575b1087","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360169,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am thrilled to have two inspiring and award-winning constituents in the House today.\n               Janelle and Tegan are visiting from Oceanside. Stand up, you two; you deserve all the accolades. Janelle is the founder of Oceanside's 100 Kids Who Care and will be starting first-year\n               political science at Carleton in September. Tegan started Fridays for Future's youth\n               strike for climate crisis in Oceanside, continued to engage in these actions at the\n               Qualicum Beach town hall for many years, but has recently retired and will be attending\n               Queen's University to study sciences in the fall. Colleagues, these two young women inspire my work every day, and I'm fairly confident\n               that not too long from now, they will be sitting in this House, despite Janelle saying\n               no. I know it's in her blood. She's going to be here. I want you to know that I do this work every day to make the world a better place\n               for you, and I thank you for the inspiration that you give to me every day. I would\n               like my colleagues to help them feel very welcome and ensure that they leave this\n               place feeling as inspired and as valued as they did when they came. Thank you, everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360169","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am thrilled to have two inspiring and award-winning constituents in the House today.\n               Janelle and Tegan are visiting from Oceanside. Stand up, you two; you deserve all the accolades. Janelle is the founder of Oceanside's 100 Kids Who Care and will be starting first-year\n               political science at Carleton in September. Tegan started Fridays for Future's youth\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722889","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal migrations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fisheries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","label":"Women workers","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501196","label":"Fisheries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722889","label":"Animal migrations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","label":"Aquatic animals","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f45d882df0a6388bfb63f4e2d27033aab98085eeb2fe2527cfa1d63a3d9f1fa4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80bbadd9e92e375a165b2756","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360170,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I do not agree with the accusations and the characterizations of the members on this\n               side chuckling, and I would like the member to withdraw.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360170","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I do not agree with the accusations and the characterizations of the members on this\n               side chuckling, and I would like the member to withdraw.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7752c4910874dc807ba152ebe919ff4078eb3dcad125323f80014367a19b13cf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b198e6ab030e40e3c98cec67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415740,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to call a point of order that the reference to Bill 2 has already been\n               well covered by the Speaker, yet the members opposite continue to canvass it during\n               their speeches.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415740","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to call a point of order that the reference to Bill 2 has already been\n               well covered by the Speaker, yet the members opposite continue to canvass it during\n               their speeches.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50797dc363e0eabea775eb08","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415741,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 2 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415741","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 2 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0be340816e21cf1e0bc7b61a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415742,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports Bill 2 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415742","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports Bill 2 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de2d710c54c91af81b27b3b4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720366,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to talk about some incredible things that happen because of the power\n               of community coming together. When we talk about getting things done in our communities, it's so important to remember\n               that nothing meaningful happens in isolation. The real engine behind progress in community\n               is partnership — people, organizations and governments pulling in the same direction.\n               When that happens, big things become possible, even things that once felt out of reach. A powerful example of this is the recent acquisition of the Hamilton Wetlands and\n               Forests by the regional district of Nanaimo. For decades, volunteers, in particular\n               one volunteer named Ceri Peacey, environmental advocates, Indigenous partners, local governments, regional leaders\n               and even corporations worked together with one clear goal: to protect this vital ecosystem\n               for future generations. This took persistence, trust and collaboration across many tables, regional and provincial\n               and federal decision-makers and, oh, so many funding partners. Because of those partnerships,\n               Hamilton Wetlands and Forests is now protected and open for people to enjoy as the\n               regional district of Nanaimo's 13th regional park. This is what community-driven success\n               looks like. We see the same lesson recently in the town of Ladysmith. Last week I was thrilled\n               to announce $52 million in investments into Ladysmith schools to build a new K-to-7\n               school and expand an existing primary school to make it into a full K-to-7 school.\n               This generational project is about students having safe, accessible and modern spaces\n               to learn. It's about families coming together to feel confident in their community.\n               It's about planning for the future, not just catching up with the past. That school is becoming a reality because of strong partnerships between the town\n               of Ladysmith, the Nanaimo-Ladysmith school board, parents, educators and the province.\n               Years, decades of local advocacy and a shared vision aligned with provincial investment.\n               Each partner played a role, and together they delivered something no one could have\n               accomplished alone. These stories remind us that partnerships are essential to progress.\n               They help communities move faster, think bigger and create solutions that reflect\n               the people they serve. I am going to take the last part of my statement to talk a little bit about a different\n               kind of community and the impact that it can have — being part of a sports community.\n               Some people know that, in my house, we are a lacrosse family. Being part of the lacrosse\n               community is about more than just practices or games or scores on a scoreboard. It's\n               about belonging. When you join a lacrosse team or a club, you don't just put on a\n               jersey, you become part of an extended family. Lacrosse is often described as the fastest game on two feet, but anyone who has been\n               part of it knows that its heart is just as powerful as its speed. This game demands\n               toughness, commitment, resilience, but it also builds connection, loyalty and family.\n               When one member of that family needs support, the entire community steps forward.\n               The community is showing up for one of its own, for Hayden Yerbury. Hayden is a 15-year-old\n               player from the Ridge Meadows Burrards Lacrosse Association. Over the years, my son\n               has played both with and against Hayden. Two weeks ago, Hayden was accidentally struck in the head by a lacrosse ball during\n               warm-up. Despite wearing his helmet, he received a devastating injury and has been\n               fighting to recover at B.C. Children's Hospital ever since. Hayden Yerbury is not\n               just a player or a name on a roster. Hayden and his entire family, his mom, Jamie,\n               his dad, Ash, and his brother, Cohen, represent the spirit of lacrosse, of showing\n               up, of giving all your effort and being part of something bigger than yourself. Whether it's through dedication to the game or commitment to teammates, Hayden has\n               earned respect in this community, and that respect is being returned. It has been\n               incredible to witness how the lacrosse community has rallied around Hayden. Teammates, coaches, families, fans, professional players, people who may not even\n               know him personally have come together with one clear message: \"Hayden, we are with\n               you. To Hayden, your presence matters. The way you are being supported reflects the\n               respect that you've earned and the impact that you have on those around you. You remind\n               this community of who we are and what we stand for.\" To the lacrosse community, this is what leadership looks like. This is what family\n               looks like. The support shown proves that no matter the level, the league, the logo\n               on the jersey, lacrosse remains rooted in unity, in compassion and in heart. Hayden, all of us at the Legislature are rooting for you. You are strong To the lacrosse community, this is what leadership looks like. This is what family\n               looks like. The support shown proves that no matter the level, the league, the logo\n               on the jersey, lacrosse remains rooted in unity, in compassion and in heart. Hayden, all of us at the Legislature are rooting for you. You are strong. You are\n               a fighter. Jamie, Ash and Cohen, we are thinking of you, and we are sending you all of our love\n               and holding your entire family in our hearts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720366","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to talk about some incredible things that happen because of the power\n               of community coming together. When we talk about getting things done in our communities, it's so important to remember\n               that nothing meaningful happens in isolation. The real engine behind progress in community\n               is partnership — people, organizations and governments pulling","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60d9f24edacbf2ed9dc58e58d316a509defd001ac9ddc1d059fc5d490eed5a1e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b214e3e73ab95ac14e673d9d4737e1666a2eec03ecf5475e02683a7f7ecab50"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7add32eaec783c97b7ce0e86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720367,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720367","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95671cce3cf5376da9f7f0257d103a61a542e38d643941fdf021851769d2ff76"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d8a4ba53deb6577580993ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720373,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand today to help recognize members of Innovative Medicines Canada, who are joining\n               us in the gallery. Innovative Medicines Canada represents Canada's research-based\n               pharmaceutical sector and plays an important role in advancing innovation, supporting\n               clinical trials and improving patient access to new therapies. Please help me welcome their delegation to the Legislature and thank them for their\n               ongoing partnership in supporting a strong, sustainable and innovative health care\n               system in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720373","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I stand today to help recognize members of Innovative Medicines Canada, who are joining\n               us in the gallery. Innovative Medicines Canada represents Canada's research-based\n               pharmaceutical sector and plays an important role in advancing innovation, supporting\n               clinical trials and improving patient access to new therapies. Please help me welcome their delegat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","label":"Medical products industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc2fccab308ad2c06203801aa30d0f73e3df768f7218567df1bc5a5192a6fa6f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f51cf41ce901c1358dd6edc0cf0bfa4e81b96eaf09e96cca630e8139ba831b15"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036248","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e0737473288cafa5da8ba2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721471,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak on Bill M-237, the Insurance Vehicle Amendment Act, tabled by\n               the member for Prince George–North Cariboo. I want to begin by saying that automobile accidents, even those that can seem minor,\n               can have a profound and sometimes life-altering impact on a person's life. Many years ago — in fact, it can now be measured in decades — right after I graduated\n               from teachers' college in Ontario, I worked briefly as an educator for a health institute\n               that supported people living with traumatic brain injuries resulting from accidents. One client had a briefcase in the back seat of their vehicle, and during what was\n               deemed a minor accident, the briefcase struck them in the head. At the time, it seemed\n               like a minor injury, but over the course of time, subtle and incremental changes began\n               to appear. Ultimately, that individual was diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury\n               that permanently altered their life, all from what initially appeared to be a minor\n               accident. That experience has stayed with me. When a British Columbian is injured in a crash, they deserve access to care and support\n               immediately so that they can begin recovery without waiting years for a court case\n               to conclude. That is why this government introduced the enhanced care model to British\n               Columbia in 2021. That health institute that I mentioned earlier was actually created because of long\n               delays that accident victims historically faced between sustaining the injury and\n               receiving appropriate care, what was often referred That's why this government introduced the enhanced-care model to British Columbia\n               in 2021. That health institute that I mentioned earlier was actually created because\n               of long delays that accident victims historically faced between sustaining the injury\n               and receiving appropriate care. It was often referred to as the court gap. Enhanced\n               care was designed to eliminate that gap and to place recovery first. Importantly, when this model was introduced, there was also a clear recognition that\n               it would need review, and it was written directly into the legislation that we must\n               hear from those most affected by the changes, to ensure the system is working as intended.\n               Section 182 of the Insurance (Vehicle) Act requires the Legislative Assembly to appoint\n               a special committee to review parts 10 and 11 of the act. Part 10 governs the enhanced\n               accident benefits and limits on legal actions, and part 11 establishes the framework\n               for basic vehicle damage coverage. Accordingly, on February 19 of this year, the Legislature appointed the Special Committee to Review Provisions of the Insurance (Vehicle) Act. This multiparty committee is tasked with examining how enhanced care is functioning,\n               listening to public and stakeholder feedback, and considering potential improvements,\n               including ideas such as those outlined in this bill. The committee's work is underway\n               now, and it will report its findings and recommendations back to this Legislature\n               by February 18, 2027. The review is a crucial component of ensuring the act remains effective, evidence-based\n               and responsive to the needs of British Columbians. While I believe the ideas contained\n               in Bill M237 are worthy of discussion, I am struggling with the timing of this bill.\n               The legislation was tabled after the special committee had already been struck by\n               this assembly, specifically to review the same portions of the act that this bill\n               seeks to amend. That creates a significant procedural concern. Let me be clear. My concern is not with the intent of the bill itself. My concern\n               is with the awkward and, frankly, problematic decision to advance amendments to parts\n               10 and 11 of the Insurance (Vehicle) Act while the statutory review of those very\n               sections is actively underway. We now risk having two separate committees reviewing\n               overlapping issues at the same time. Yes, Bill M237 is narrower in scope than the special committee's mandate. However,\n               both committees will be calling for public input. The public is already aware of the\n               statutory review committee, often referred to as the ICBC committee in the media.\n               I worry about the confusion when there are two separate calls for input that appear\n               to be addressing the same issue. There is also a disparity in resources. The special committee has direct access to\n               ICBC experts and legal and policy support from the Attorney General's office. When\n               viewed side by side, it becomes clear that the issues raised in Bill M237 are more\n               appropriately examined within the comprehensive, well-resourced, statutory review\n               process that this Legislature has already put in place. What I'm struggling to reconcile is how the Legislature can reasonably consider amendments\n               to parts 10 and 11 of the Insurance (Vehicle) Act while that very legislation is undergoing\n               a mandated, evidence-based review. The member for Prince George–North Cariboo knew, or at least should have known, that this committee had been established when\n               this bill was tabled, as it was approved by the assembly earlier this year. The need\n               for the committee is written right into the legislation that the member is asking\n               us to review. I have approached the member opposite with many process options to have the issues\n               in this bill reviewed by the Special Committee to Review Provisions of the Insurance (Vehicle) Act, including having this bill referred directly to the special committee, which would\n               then undertake the same process and line-by-line review, with the support that I have\n               already mentioned, but all options have been rebuffed. It is unfortunate that the member won't engage with the options to refer to the special\n               committee, to see that these changes are made in a thoughtful manner that would help\n               understand the financial and overall impacts for British Columbians on the issues\n               brought up in the bill. I believe these proposed changes would be better served by\n               being brought forward to the special committee, where they would be examined in the\n               full context of the act and alongside other evidence and testimony. We would not have introduced amendments to legislation such as the Lobbyists Transparency\n               Act or the Public Interest Disclosure Act or the human rights code while those acts\n               were under statutory review by legislative committees, and the Insurance (Vehicle)\n               Act should be treated no differently. Before I close, I do want to recognize the individuals at the centre of this bill,\n               who I believe may be in the gallery today. Ms. Sutton, your accident and your injuries\n               are devastating, and my heart truly goes out to what you have endured and for how\n               profoundly your life was changed in April 2023. This story matters. Ms. Sutton, your accident and your injuries are devastating, and my heart truly goes out to\n               what you have endured and for how profoundly your life was changed in April 2023.\n               This story matters. Your story matters. They must be heard, and there may be good merits to this bill. But they must be examined\n               through the proper legislative process, one that ensures clarity, focus and meaningful\n               outcomes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721471","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak on Bill M-237, the Insurance Vehicle Amendment Act, tabled by\n               the member for Prince George–North Cariboo. I want to begin by saying that automobile accidents, even those that can seem minor,\n               can have a profound and sometimes life-altering impact on a person's life. Many years ago — in fact, it can now be measured in decades — right after I gradua","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c2cde17b9c5546a6ebf5cfdd3e5ca97c7a8920d059342c81f2b10103b06d3421"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["620dd904bd42db0a377c2572669fd8f4e5c9b881fd6778b2d51d553c85a61756"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8868cce872c707d6f793c79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721474,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Colleagues, I rise today to recognize B.C. Book Day, celebrated on April 21, and to\n               honour the people who bring British Columbia stories to life. British Columbia is home to a vibrant, independent publishing community that includes\n               both book and magazine publishers working across print and digital formats to inform,\n               inspire and reflect life in our province. In B.C., we have 28 Canadian-owned publishers\n               represented by Books B.C., which is supported by more than 270 publishing-related\n               businesses, from editors, printers to distributors and booksellers, all working together\n               to turn ideas into books. Alongside book publishers, B.C.'s magazine publishers play an important role in our\n               culture and creative economy, telling local stories, highlighting regional voices\n               and nurturing emerging creative talent. This past year, B.C. authors earned national\n               recognition for outstanding work across fiction, non-fiction, poetry and children's\n               books, including powerful Indigenous stories. From award-winning poetry to children's\n               books read around the world, B.C. stories continue to make an impact. We are proud to support B.C.'s book publishing community by making the book publishing\n               tax credit permanent and continuing strong programs through Creative B.C. and B.C.\n               Arts Council. We are supporting publishers to grow, ensuring B.C. remains a great\n               place to create and publish books. On B.C. Book Day, one of the best ways to show support is simple. Buy a B.C.-published\n               book, like the one I'm currently reading right now, Un c e d ed by a B.C. author, George Abbott, on a distinctly B.C. topic, published by a B.C.\n               publisher. Or the next one on my list, Rainbow Wisdom , recently published by one of my own kick-ass constituents, Misha Oak. I want to thank Creative B.C., Books B.C., Mags BC and everyone who supports B.C.'s\n               publishing community. Please join me in celebrating B.C. Book Day and the stories\n               that connect us all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721474","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Colleagues, I rise today to recognize B.C. Book Day, celebrated on April 21, and to\n               honour the people who bring British Columbia stories to life. British Columbia is home to a vibrant, independent publishing community that includes\n               both book and magazine publishers working across print and digital formats to inform,\n               inspire and reflect life in our provi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","label":"Children's literature"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poetry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","label":"Children's literature","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","label":"Poetry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["874f75d0d67f42a2e47f3fc8342870ebc5eb0e201dcc6b323561225dd9e7ed99"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ca4ac4d3d806155585e5a05ef265530f8e80a61e907eee7e8a1dc40752b9af1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034460","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-98895dc65583f70f8fe9d1d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721476,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to celebrate the extraordinary career of compassion and giving of Violet\n               Hayes, who is nearing retirement as the executive director at the Island Crisis Care\n               Society. Violet's career spans decades of caring and service. She began her career\n               in 1991 as a volunteer coordinator for home care services. In 2001, she moved to the\n               Salvation Army where she held numerous positions in many towns across British Columbia.\n               In 2010, she became the manager of Samaritan House before eventually becoming the\n               executive director of Island Crisis Care in 2011. Throughout her time as executive director, Violet brought patience, compassion and\n               an unwavering belief in the dignity and worth of people — all of this during an unprecedented\n               time of need in our communities. I witnessed her quiet fierceness during opposition to a community rezoning process\n               for a supportive housing project in Parksville. Violet was steadfast in her work to\n               bring this project to fruition, and it is now a successful 52-unit building supporting\n               people as they move from struggling to survive to being fully independent. Because\n               of Violet, countless individuals have found safety in moments of fear and hope when\n               it was often hardest to hold onto. Violet has not just touched lives. She has saved them. She has done all of this not\n               for recognition, but because she cared. Violet's legacy isn't just in the work she's\n               done but in the standards she has set for what compassion in action looks like. On behalf of our community, thank you, Violet, for your years of dedication, your\n               quiet leadership and your deep humanity. As you step into retirement, we wish you\n               joy and rest and every opportunity to enjoy the next chapter, knowing that your work\n               has made a lasting difference and will continue throughout our communities. Congratulations,\n               and thank you for all that you have done.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721476","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to celebrate the extraordinary career of compassion and giving of Violet\n               Hayes, who is nearing retirement as the executive director at the Island Crisis Care\n               Society. Violet's career spans decades of caring and service. She began her career\n               in 1991 as a volunteer coordinator for home care services. In 2001, she moved to the\n               S","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f56ff12e5d12a091d63fa0b4711e503ffbe3bbf8e5b045ffcca60fcecae58b34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["031f642355d3a8384f5eefec48e48d05b619cf6866d5c14934b175bb4f20b7bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4dc148f4d977a167fea23784","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721485,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Welcome to the students. We are currently in debate on a treaty for the K'ómoks First Nation, which is monumental. It's been decades in the making, and it's the first treaty\n               that our government has brought forward since we've been on this side of the House.\n               So welcome to the debate. I do rise to speak with profound support for Bill 20, the K'ómoks First Nations treaty. I want to thank the member from the Green Party for his words.\n               His experience in this area is unprecedented in the House. I want to recognize that the negotiating teams. K'ómoks First Nation, Canada and British Columbia have worked for decades to get to this\n               stage. The time it takes to build the relationships necessary to do this work span\n               beyond just political terms of office, and that can make it particularly difficult\n               to move this work through this House, because there is a sense of disconnection from\n               the work for those of us who might be new to this place. But what I do know is that many people worked for many years to build the relationships\n               necessary to do this hard and critical work. For that, I am filled with respect and\n               gratitude. I want to extend an invitation to all members of this House to build the\n               relationships with the nations in your riding. If you have not done that yet.... This\n               is a non-partisan statement; this is for both sides. If you have not started building\n               that relationship yet, it is critical to build that relationship so that when big\n               moments happen, you have the relationship to work through those difficult times together.\n               So I encourage all members of this House that if you have not started to build those\n               relationships, that you start. I was fortunate enough to do some work in the area of reconciliation when I was on\n               the school board in Nanaimo. One of the nations brought.... My knowledge of positions\n               in the Catholic church isn't very good, but I think they were like an archbishop or\n               a bishop, regional area. This bishop had built a tremendous relationship, a trusting\n               relationship with the local nation. You know, with the history of the church, I was\n               really impressed with the ability of this person. I wanted to learn from them. I said: \"How did you do it?\" He said, \"You show up, you sit down, and you shut up.\"\n               Those were his three pieces of advice. Show up. Sit down. Shut up. Every single time\n               there's a community event. When they finally say to you, \"What are you doing here,\"\n               that's when you know you've built some modicum of trust. If you're looking for a way\n               in, I pass that lesson on to you. It was a good teaching. The introduction of this treaty marks B.C.'s fifth modern treaty. Currently B.C. has\n               four modern treaties with eight nations. This will be the fifth. I think it's important\n               that we talk a little bit about how we got here, both as a province and also for the\n               K'ómoks community. The history teacher in me runs deep. I have not been in a classroom for\n               maybe two decades now, but it's still there. My history lesson. In 1763 —  we're going back, friends — the British Crown issued\n               the Royal Proclamation, a document that recognized Aboriginal title during European\n               settlement of what is now Canada. The proclamation states that ownership over North\n               America is issued to King George III, but that Aboriginal title exists and can only\n               be extinguished by treaty with the Crown. This is 1763. The proclamation further specifies\n               that Aboriginal land can only be sold or ceded to the Crown and not directly to new\n               people coming to settle on the land. In most of British Columbia, treaties were not negotiated between the government and\n               the First Peoples. The exceptions are the Douglas treaties on Vancouver Island and\n               Treaty 8 in the Peace River region. A quote from Chapter 4 of the book Unceded by George Abbott highlights the issues that A quote from chapter 4 of the book Unceded by George Abbott highlights the issues that British Columbia faced at the time. I\n               quote: \"Only three years after confederation, British Columbia and Canada were at\n               loggerheads on the issue of reserve allocations for First Nations. British Columbia's\n               small reserves stood in stark contrast to those east of the Rockies, and the province\n               resisted Canada's proposals to remedy that disparity.\" In correspondence with Prime Minister Macdonald in 1872, discussing the processes\n               used east of the Rockies for settling Indigenous title, then-Lieutenant Governor Joseph\n               Trutch stated: \"The Canadian system, as I understand it, will hardly work here. We\n               have never bought out any Indian claims to land.\" As First Nations leaders and organizations\n               would argue for decades, going on centuries now, Aboriginal title was therefore not\n               officially extinguished, and legally the nations retained jurisdictions over their\n               territory. Numerous court cases have gone on to affirm these rights. One of the most impactful\n               is probably Calder v. British Columbia , 1973. This landmark case unanimously agreed that Nisga'a title had existed on Nisga'a\n               land. Another is Delgamuukw, British Columbia, 1997. This case is often looked at as one of the most comprehensive\n               decisions about Aboriginal title. In 1997, Delgamuukw set out how the courts will deal with Aboriginal title by setting\n               a test to determine if title still existed, and if so, how the Crown might justifiably\n               infringe upon it. In that case, the court further ruled that Aboriginal title is different\n               from merely land use and occupation as it had previously been defined, but it also\n               incorporates Aboriginal jurisdictional authority over how the land is used. Delgamuukw\n               also acknowledged Aboriginal collective ownership of the land that includes a cultural\n               relationship to the land. Both of these cases would pave the way for addressing Aboriginal\n               title in Canada. As a result of the Calder case and Delgamuukw, and many and numerous other cases,\n               the federal government developed a claims process in the 1970s. The province of British\n               Columbia refused to participate in the process until the 1990s. So why did B.C. start\n               participating in the process? Well it was when resource development in the province\n               declined due to uncertainty over Aboriginal title that the province of B.C. decided\n               to engage in the treaty process. After decades of trying to run from or fight in court the incomplete land issue in\n               British Columbia, and primarily motivated by the actual or perceived economic losses,\n               the provincial government created the B.C. Treaty Commission in order to finally reach\n               agreements with First Nations over title. I keep hearing the other side say that this\n               side created this mess. But to be clear, we did not create this inconvenient truth.\n               We inherited it. And we are deeply committed to trying to do something different than\n               previous governments in order to try to solve these unresolved issues. If that history lesson, with reference to the reason that B.C. began to engage in\n               the treaty process in the 1990s, isn't a sound reason for doing things differently,\n               I don't know what else could be. Imagine if we were trying to do the same thing that\n               previous governments have been doing unsuccessfully, the criticism that we would be\n               getting from the other side. First Nations across British Columbia deserve the peace\n               of mind, but also so do all British Columbians. This is why we are bringing forward\n               this treaty. Imagine being a K'ómoks leader who has been at this work for decades, for generations, listening to the way\n               issues of title are currently talked about in this chamber. Imagine hearing members\n               opposite say: \"This really isn't the time for this. There's just too much other stuff\n               happening around reconciliation.\" Why now? Imagine decades, generations and people say: \"Why now?\" Because they can't\n               get over the hurdle. The K'ómoks Nation deserves it now. That's why now. It must be frustrating. It must be scary.\n               But it can also help justify the feelings of uncertainty that a nation may feel about\n               having a treaty go through these chambers? After generations of having rights stymied at every turn, the unease of looking at\n               this place to approve a treaty After my very brief history lesson, this now brings us to the modern treaty process,\n               the process that helped bring this K'ómoks treaty to the Legislature. I want to talk about this because I keep hearing people say\n               that they feel rushed. I just want to say that getting massive amounts of information and digesting them\n               in short periods of time and then coming up with really good questions that represent\n               the concerns of the constituents in your riding is actually the job. That is the job.\n               Insert any topic. Digesting massive amounts of information in a short period of time — if you didn't\n               have the experience necessary before you became an MLA to do that, then buckle up\n               and get on the treadmill and build those muscles, because that is literally the job,\n               and this is not the first time or the last time that you're going to be asked to digest\n               a lot of information in a short period of time. However, I take issue with the notion that people are being asked to digest a lot\n               of information in a short period of time here, and I'm going to tell you why. Modern treaties are negotiated amongst the governments of Canada, British Columbia\n               and First Nations in B.C. They are government-to-government relationships. The treaties\n               are grounded in the recognition of Indigenous rights. They reconcile pre-existing\n               Indigenous sovereignty with assumed Crown sovereignty. They do not extinguish the\n               rights, including title, in form or result, and they are able to evolve over time\n               on the coexistence of Crown and Indigenous governments and the ongoing process of\n               reconciliation pre-existing Indigenous sovereignty with assumed Crown sovereignty. There are six stages of treaty implementation. Stage 1, statement of intent to negotiate.\n               Stage 2, readiness to negotiate. Stage 3, negotiation of a framework agreement. Stage\n               4, negotiation of agreement in principle, known as the AIP. Stage 5, negotiation to\n               finalize a final agreement or treaty. Stage 6, implementation of treaty. All those\n               stages are not done in the moment that we table it in the Legislature. I encourage people who want to know more about each stage, or about what stage a local\n               nation may be at, to visit the B.C. Treaty Commission website. I will give it to you,\n               in case you aren't aware of it — bctreaty.ca. It couldn't be simpler. Here people will find full and transparent information regarding various treaty stages,\n               what's under negotiation, engagement opportunities available for those impacted by\n               the negotiations and at what stage that participation is appropriate, because it's\n               not appropriate at every stage, but there are stages where it is appropriate. There are interactive maps, so very many reports on the processes, reports on the\n               history of the processes and the evolutions of the processes. This includes information\n               on the 2019 recognition and reconciliation of rights policy , which has been brought up here by members opposite. You can also review the annual\n               reports of the Treaty Commission, which outline the work over the previous year. It\n               is full of open and interesting information. The information about the K'ómoks Nation can be found on this website and has been\n               recorded there since the commission started publishing information. Modern treaty nations like Tsawwassen, Maa-nulth, ɬəʔamɛn and Nisga'a are examples of the benefits for people and communities that\n               treaties can bring — new investments, partnerships, good jobs, land stewardship and\n               certainty. Across all modern treaties, we have seen clear trends. Higher wages, not\n               just for treaty nations but in the surrounding communities as well. Stronger local\n               relationships thanks to mechanisms for resolving matters and working together on shared\n               priorities. Diversified and stronger local economies that provide a strong net return\n               to the treaty nations and to B.C. Deloitte released a report last year — Deloitte is pretty trusted by some of the untrustworthy\n               folks that don't trust all the information; Deloitte is pretty well trusted — called\n               the Financial Benefits of Modern Treaties in British Columbia . That report is filled with further details on the trends that I just mentioned, so\n               if you don't believe me, you can go look at the well-audited version of this. The negotiating teams for the K'ómoks First Nations, for Canada and for B.C. have\n               worked for decades to get to this stage, and I want to thank them for their professionalism The negotiating teams for the K'ómoks First Nations, for Canada and B.C. have worked for decades to get to this stage.\n               I want to thank them for their professionalism, their attention to detail — building\n               the relationships on the ground necessary to bring this document at this time to this\n               House. Because I keep hearing that the members opposite feel rushed, let me reassure you\n               about the timelines associated with this particular treaty. The K'ómoks First Nation entered into treaty negotiations under the B.C. Treaty Commission process\n               in 1994 with the government of Canada and the province of British Columbia. In 2012,\n               negotiators reached an agreement in principle, establishing agreement on substantive\n               elements to be detailed in the completed treaty made public. In the years since, K'ómoks, British Columbia and Canada have engaged and informed K'ómoks members, people throughout their region, including neighbouring nations and all levels\n               of government and industry partners on the treaty. Engagement is an important aspect\n               of treaty and reconciliation negotiations and the ratification process. Engagement\n               is difficult, and it's hard to know how to get people's attention these days. People\n               don't often care until later in the process, despite efforts to proactively engage\n               people. That doesn't mean that people are hiding things. It means that the world is\n               busy. I remember on the school board when report cards were changing. If you want to see\n               a community get riled up, then try to do something with the education system. In my\n               school board, we tried to be proactive about the changes. We proactively, before any\n               changes were made, had meetings for families. We announced the meetings. Principals\n               made themselves available for meetings. They went to PAC meetings, and when they had separate meetings for these report cards\n               to say: \"Hey, this is what's going to happen. This is what it's going to look like.\n               What do you think? Let's get you comfortable with it,\" three people showed up to those\n               meetings that were done across about 30 schools. And then the report cards changed,\n               and then people engaged in the process. So no matter how hard you try to front-end-load that engagement, the world is busy,\n               and sometimes people just don't engage. It does not mean that people are hiding things. On July 22, 2024, chief negotiators initialed the K'ómoks Treaty. Initialing marked an important milestone in the treaty journey as it signalled\n               the conclusion of the substantive negotiations. Initialing was subject to important\n               caveats, including Canada and B.C. fulfilling their duty to consult other First Nations\n               and the completion of a final legal and technical review of the treaty. The legal\n               and technical review may answer some of the questions that have been asked from the\n               other side. In his address, the official critic, the member from Columbia River–Revelstoke, because we have more than one critic.... The member for Columbia River–Revelstoke expressed surprise at this process, expressed a sense of feeling rushed. But the process has been\n               ongoing publicly and transparently for decades. If I was the critic, which I'm not, because I'm on this side of the House, and I don't\n               know what it means to be one, so I'm just guessing. But if I was one, particularly\n               for this issue, I think one of the first things I would have done was ask for a briefing\n               on the active treaties in process, and I think I probably would have prioritized them\n               with the ones that are sitting at stage 5. Or I would have asked my colleagues to get informed about the treaties and the negotiations\n               that are happening in their ridings, and then I would have asked them to bring me\n               any information that they thought needed to be brought to my attention so that I didn't\n               feel surprised or caught off guard. That's what I would do. On the ground, the first step of ratification, eligible voters of the K'ómoks First Nation voted on whether to approve the treaty and a self-government constitution.\n               On March 8, 2025, eligible voters voted 81 percent in favour of ratifying the K'ómoks treaty and 83 percent in favour of ratifying the self-government constitution. Chief Councillor Nicole Rempel stated: \"This is an important milestone for K'ómoks First Nation. Our members have shown strong support for this treaty, and we are confident\n               in both the agreement and the process that has brought us here — confident in the\n               agreement and the process that has brought us here. The introduction of this legislation\n               moves us closer to implementation, strengthening our governance, recognizing our rights\n               and creating the long-term opportunities for our nation and our region If fully ratified, the K'ómoks treaty will provide the basis for a revitalized relationship\n               between the K'ómoks, their neighbours and all levels of government by fostering a\n               shared understanding, providing certainty — I know that word; we don't like to use\n               it around here for some reason — and supporting further work together in the region. It will lay out negotiated approaches to self-governance. It will describe how K'ómoks\n               rights will be exercised, ensuring that Aboriginal rights are recognized and not extinguished.\n               It will clarify that the treaty does not infringe or extinguish the rights of neighbouring\n               First Nations. It will confirm land parcels totalling approximately 34.42 square kilometres — that's\n               pretty specific — to be owned and governed by the K'ómoks, with an ability for the\n               K'ómoks to purchase up to 15.92 square kilometres of pre-approved additional land\n               over time. It will address existing interests and tenures on treaty lands. Interest holders have\n               been engaged on the proposed approach to their tenure or interest. There is really no reason for anyone to be surprised by this. There really isn't. There are still several steps to complete — so for people who are feeling rushed,\n               don't worry — before the treaty could come into effect. These include this debate\n               in the Legislature, committee stage. But upon passage here, there are still even more\n               stages. We need federal approval. Ratification is fully complete once a treaty is signed and\n               both the provincial and federal implementation legislation is brought into force.\n               This happens on the treaty's effective date, which is agreed on by all parties. The effective date is set by coordinated federal-provincial orders and typically occurs\n               following a transition period after royal assent has been granted. The transition\n               period allows all parties to be prepared for the treaty's implementation. The parties\n               will conduct ongoing public engagement during this period — there is a theme here\n               — so everyone who is potentially affected by the treaty is kept informed. Of importance for people to know is that the proposed treaty lands for the K'ómoks\n               treaty only include private property that was acquired on a willing-buyer, willing-seller\n               basis, which is a key tenet of the B.C. Treaty Commission. Private property is only acquired on a willing-seller,\n               willing-buyer basis. Adjacent landowners who may be impacted have been engaged extensively\n               through public open houses, public communications and direct correspondence over several\n               years. The news release for this treaty carried endorsements from numerous local community\n               leaders — including Will Cole-Hamilton, board chair of the Comox Valley regional district;\n               Doug Hillian, director of the Comox Valley regional district; Nicole Minions, mayor\n               of Comox; Vickey Brown, mayor of Cumberland; Bob Wells, mayor of Courtenay — with\n               unequivocal support, demonstrating: \"We stand with K'ómoks.\" Look, this isn't easy work. Treaties aren't easy work. Reconciling our past isn't\n               easy work. Wrestling with the information we've been taught in school, with a learning\n               and an understanding of what actually happened in history. I remember the day my dad had this realization, my dearly departed dad. He called\n               me in tears — in tears — with an understanding of what had been happening when he\n               was a boy growing up, trying to reconcile what he thought he knew with what he had\n               just learned. He never reconciled all of his feelings. My dad, through various adventures in his life, had his last rites read to him four\n               times. On the time that he actually died, I said: \"Dad, do you want a priest?\" We\n               were planning what he wanted when he was going to go. He said: \"No, I'm not there\n               yet. I'm not ready yet.\" He unfortunately passed away before he was able to reconcile those feelings with his\n               faith. He was faithful his whole life. Grand Chief Stewart Phillips said: \"Reconciliation is not for wimps. It's hard, and\n               it's messy.\" This quote was recently misattributed to former Premier John Horgan;\n               he was quoting the Grand Chief when he said it. If there's anyone who knows that,\n               it's the Grand Chief. History and courts have shown us that we cannot keep running from this. While it can\n               be scary, I would argue it doesn't need to be scary. We should not be scared of change.\n               We should not be scared of doing things differently, of evolving who we are as a province\n               and a nation. On this side of the House, our clear goal is to move forward in a way that provides\n               certainty, respects Aboriginal and private property rights, and supports shared prosperity\n               for all. Modern treaties create predictable relationships. They foster partnerships\n               and provide a framework for all people in B.C. to live together, to help build a better\n               future for everyone. I heard words recently from National Chief Cindy Woodhouse-Nepinak, of the Assembly\n               of First Nations. It was in response to the RCMP surveillance on First Nations. She\n               used words that have stayed with me: \"partners in this nation called Canada.\" I just\n               think we should stop and think about those words. What is British Columbia? What does\n               a Canada that walks together with the First Peoples of this land, in partnership,\n               look like? \"Partners in this nation called Canada.\" From Jody Wilson-Raybould — I read this in the newspaper today; it was from a speech\n               in 2014: \"Create a Canada that all Canadians aspire to live in, a country based on\n               shared values and principles that we have spent years as a nation fostering. Creating\n               a fair, caring and compassionate society that confirms our place on this planet as\n               a favoured nation and one of the best countries in which to live.\" That's what I aspire to. That's what I am here working towards. This treaty is a step\n               in that direction. It is that vision in action. It is partnership. Where I come from, Hul'q'umi'num' is the language spoken. There are two terms; I think I have used them before in\n               this House: [Hul'q'umi'num' was spoken], when you use your heart and your mind together, when you find that balance, and\n               [Hul'q'umi'num' was spoken], which means working together, doing it together. I hope we can take these ancient\n               teachings from the land that my riding is on, [Hul'q'umi'num' was spoken] and [Hul'q'umi'num' was spoken], to help us in this work. I look forward to supporting the bill in the House and moving it to committee stage\n               to have the questions of the members opposite answered, so that we can support the\n               K'ómoks Nation and the people of the Comox Valley in the next steps of this treaty enactment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721485","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Welcome to the students. We are currently in debate on a treaty for the K'ómoks First Nation, which is monumental. It's been decades in the making, and it's the first treaty\n               that our government has brought forward since we've been on this side of the House.\n               So welcome to the debate. I do rise to speak with profound support for Bill 20, the K'ómoks First Nations treaty","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6830f2a37c7938005e91f61a7a8f94c071579dc6584bba7174e1524cf925613a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b7d61ec8d824308568751047972333981eb8388c30a38d98c9669458ea125621"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c5380106f6d37c73af42f6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729130,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak to Motion M205, which proposes \"that the House ensure elected representatives\n               are accountable and supported to possess a basic understanding of economics, public\n               finance and numeracy, as they make decisions on taxes, spending, debt and regulation.\"\n               To that end, the motion requests \"that the Legislative Assembly Management Committee\n               institute a mandatory course in these subjects for all newly\" —that's an important\n               word — \"elected MLAs.\" At the outset, I just would like to understand how the member defines the terms \"basic\"\n               and \"numeracy\" because the motion itself offers no clarity on these things. In fact,\n               it lacks so much specificity that you could probably drive a truck through it. What does the member mean by \"basic\"? Is there a grade level attached? How would that\n               level be determined? Would members have to take, like, a test, like a math test, in\n               order to determine that they have said \"basic understanding\"? What does the member mean by \"numeracy\"? In the B.C. K.-to-12 system, numeracy is\n               defined as the ability to interpret, apply and communicate mathematical understanding\n               to solve problems in diverse, real-world contexts. It's a foundational, cross-curricular — which, I know, is a real struggle for some\n               members across the way — skill distinct from but inclusive of mathematics content\n               required for graduation or for daily life. Numeracy focuses on processes such as interpreting,\n               applying, analyzing, solving and communicating. By that very definition, numeracy already encompasses much of what the member is calling\n               for in this motion when he refers to a basic understanding of economics, public finance,\n               taxes, spending, debt and regulation. As numeracy is used in this motion, it is largely\n               redundant. After the members opposite dug their heels in so deeply last week in favour of a motion\n               to run two parallel processes examining the exact same issue — including forcing this\n               chamber through a motion, debating that motion and then calling division on it — I\n               suppose we should not be surprised to find such redundancy here as well. I want to be clear. I'm not opposed to the intent of the motion. However, I am perplexed\n               why it actually needed to come before this House at all. Any member can ask their\n               caucus to bring forward an item to the Legislative Assembly Management Committee.\n               So it raises the question of whether we should also be requesting a basic understanding\n               of how LAMC itself functions so as not to waste the collective time of members in\n               this chamber. That said, I do agree that some education in the basic principles of public accounting\n               itself could benefit members of this House, particularly the members opposite. During\n               question period, we frequently hear outrage about the province's deficit while often,\n               in the same breath, demands to increase spending. Strange. We also hear calls for expanding the public service while followed almost immediately\n               by calls to cut the public service. These positions are not easily reconciled without\n               at least a foundational understanding of public finance. I also agree that members opposite could benefit from a stronger grounding in economics\n               and public finance, given their election platform. That platform — released just four\n               days before the election, which is notable, given how often we hear complaints from\n               members opposite about feeling rushed — projected a larger deficit than ours and was\n               based on an assumed annual GDP growth rate of 5.4 percent. That rate was nowhere near\n               what any major financial institution or think tank was forecasting at the time. By comparison, the Conference Board of Canada was projecting a growth of approximately\n               2.1 percent. Their platform also recommended more than $2 billion in additional spending,\n               compared to the B.C. NDP platform, along with close to $4 billion in unaccounted-for\n               tax cuts. In that brief four-day period before the platform's release on election\n               day, multiple media outlets analyzed those numbers and found that the actual spending\n               commitments in that platform were nearly $4 billion higher than the party itself had\n               projected. Finally, at the time, the leader, then the member for Nechako Lakes, directed criticism at our platform's contingency allocation. He claimed: \"They've\n               got four billion dollars just in contingencies. They can't even explain where that\n               money goes.\" According to Webster's, a contingency is a future event, circumstance or emergency\n               that is possible but not certain. It often refers to backup plans or unexpected expenses.\n               In other words, by definition, contingencies are for what is possible but not known\n               or, unexpected. So while I remain puzzled as to why this motion was brought to the floor when an established\n               process already exists through LAMC, and while I find the wording of the motion both\n               vague and redundant for the reasons I've outlined, I'm not opposed to the idea of\n               the motion itself, also for the reasons I've outlined because it does feel that some\n               members opposite will benefit from a better education of the principles of public\n               finance. Maybe once they've taken this course, they can finally explain While I find the wording of the motion both vague and redundant for the reasons I've\n               outlined, I'm not opposed to the idea of the motion itself, also for the reasons I've\n               outlined, because it does feel that some members opposite will benefit from a better\n               education of the principles of public finance. Maybe once they've taken this course, they can finally explain the magic behind their plan to simultaneously expand services\n               while also cutting spending and the public service that offers those services.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729130","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to speak to Motion M205, which proposes \"that the House ensure elected representatives\n               are accountable and supported to possess a basic understanding of economics, public\n               finance and numeracy, as they make decisions on taxes, spending, debt and regulation.\"\n               To that end, the motion requests \"that the Legislative Assembly Management Committee\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21916be22d32c9228a03d34471ecad3127bb4c18dbb4b459bc977e21efe139fc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["eb7c132919834437f269765f80f5e95df68a323d0b6dd15450d64787c68fc9d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-88b715213eafde4875edb2a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729139,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on behalf of myself, the member for Columbia River–Revelstoke and the member for West Vancouver–Sea to Sky to welcome our 30 local scientists who are here with the Science Meets Parliament\n               program, which is a non-partisan initiative put on by the incredible team at the Canadian\n               Science Policy Centre. They're here for the third year running. I'm just looking around\n               to see where I can see them all. Today they're going to be meeting with MLAs, whether\n               it's attending our meetings, having meals. Some of you have already met with them. We can all agree that good and current research shapes good and current policy. I'd like to welcome Mehrdad Hariri, Wendi Zhou, Zainab Taleb, Matt McTaggart, Trushar\n               Patel, Chris Caputo and Andrea Mellor, who are the key organizers of this event. I\n               look forward to seeing all of the members here tonight at the reception in the Hall\n               of Honour I look forward to seeing all of the members here tonight at the reception in the Hall\n               of Honour. Would you please help me welcome them and make them feel welcome when you see them\n               in the House today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729139","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise on behalf of myself, the member for Columbia River–Revelstoke and the member for West Vancouver–Sea to Sky to welcome our 30 local scientists who are here with the Science Meets Parliament\n               program, which is a non-partisan initiative put on by the incredible team at the Canadian\n               Science Policy Centre. They're here for the third year running. I'm just looking aro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["529dd14f0a852ab60c42b3773dc4fa49e41ef1fb54a731707b80cd3147041ec7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0f41818e8fc6bc4ba93573cac37f7180b6d04571be6dcbcc1ac80533cb711ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13d0dc5319e90ad16455dfc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729144,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the House today are members of the team from Hope Air. We got to meet with you this morning. We have the chief hope officer, Mark Rubinstein.\n               We have the vice president of patient experience, Stephanie Aldridge. Thank you for\n               the time today. Thank you for everything you do to help make health care for British\n               Columbians more accessible and equitable. We are so pleased to partner with you in\n               the critical work that you do and provide to British Columbians. Would the House help me make them feel very welcome and thank them for the work they\n               do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729144","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joining us in the House today are members of the team from Hope Air. We got to meet with you this morning. We have the chief hope officer, Mark Rubinstein.\n               We have the vice president of patient experience, Stephanie Aldridge. Thank you for\n               the time today. Thank you for everything you do to help make health care for British\n               Columbians more accessible and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04a66bf58294bd530b1be4d4523e6788d8ac66db904bbf9f8294f4420598ab1d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c127692c1f607a7c82ec3b922b5d631de3497b7870c565d88c61619f36e5a0be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-897560f353cdb1ccca7f1d7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752254,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to recognize the work that the member opposite has done to bring this\n               bill to the House. I agree with pretty much everything that was just said. I also really appreciate the\n               work of the committee on this bill. I think we are all supportive of the intention\n               of this bill to make roads safer for all of those using them, especially commercial\n               drivers that are such an important part of our economy, moving goods around the province\n               inter-provincially, internationally. But I do have concerns about the bill as it's been reported back, specifically with\n               clause 1 and the current definition of commercial vehicle. The definition of commercial\n               vehicle, as it stands, is, in my opinion, too broad and should align with commercial\n               vehicles that also carry speed limiters. This creates clarity for all drivers who\n               use their vehicles for commercial purposes. As it stands right now, the current definition may unintentionally.... We think we know\n               what it means right now, but there are some unintended consequences when things aren't\n               clear, and we hear that consistently from the other side. It may unintentionally apply\n               to smaller commercial vehicles, such as delivery trucks, smaller delivery vehicles,\n               landscaping vehicles, and quite possibly anyone who ensures their vehicle through\n               a corporate or commercial means. Clarity in definition will help us avoid confusion and will create consistency among\n               federal and provincial regulatory frameworks, which is something that, if you recall,\n               was brought up at the beginning of debate in this Also, based on the submissions that I reviewed from the public, including feedback\n               from the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, I think the committee should be given\n               an opportunity to review these concerns regarding clause 1, and I'm also sure that\n               we may hear from the Minister of Transportation on this issue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752254","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just want to recognize the work that the member opposite has done to bring this\n               bill to the House. I agree with pretty much everything that was just said. I also really appreciate the\n               work of the committee on this bill. I think we are all supportive of the intention\n               of this bill to make roads safer for all of those using them, especially commercial\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2aa2aace804e1434caaa11484166469028154ae22cec21960a5ad5192a070aae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3b2539b4444a84491057f6bad230996f156d0a39d3b952ec7c64627e01df7711"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70fc246cbf588fd6f0291e56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752255,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is not often, despite being an MLA on the Island, that I have constituents in the\n               House. I would like everyone to help me welcome the mayor of Ladysmith, Deena Beeston; Couns.\n               Trish McKay, Duck Paterson, and Jeff Virtanen. I will say that Councillor Paterson has been a councillor in Ladysmith almost as long\n               as I've been alive. He deserves an extra round of applause for his time and dedication\n               to the town of Ladysmith. Good things happen when we work well together, like our recent announcement about\n               a new school for the town of Ladysmith. Would everybody please help me make them feel very welcome, and welcome them if you\n               see them today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752255","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is not often, despite being an MLA on the Island, that I have constituents in the\n               House. I would like everyone to help me welcome the mayor of Ladysmith, Deena Beeston; Couns.\n               Trish McKay, Duck Paterson, and Jeff Virtanen. I will say that Councillor Paterson has been a councillor in Ladysmith almost as long\n               as I've been alive. He deserves an extra ro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Municipal buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","label":"Municipal buildings","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["18a1a03f1cb0c118756b65bcfdf23cf93ed33eb7db1465aff203671f3bae8aa3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c6ddbe7ecec095204fefcc060cd969aa3a631300970d839eed364c4babf7934"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae010c1873cb88271964d70f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752256,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand up on a point of order. The Chair has said that the amendment will kill the\n               bill. The other side is speaking to the amendment and saying it will delay the bill\n               and that they want to make changes to the bill. I'm just seeking clarity on whether\n               this bill will be killed or it will be delayed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752256","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I stand up on a point of order. The Chair has said that the amendment will kill the\n               bill. The other side is speaking to the amendment and saying it will delay the bill\n               and that they want to make changes to the bill. I'm just seeking clarity on whether\n               this bill will be killed or it will be delayed.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37561aac4c172e4f3272245f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752257,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to thank and acknowledge all the committee members for their contributions\n               and engagement to the committee. I would like to also recognize the Chair, the member\n               for Kamloops Centre, for his work on the committee. Over the course of the last year, the committee considered reports across a broad\n               range of program areas, including legal aid representation services, carbon projections\n               and child care licensing capacity. The committee also reviewed the Office of the Auditor General's annual follow-up report\n               on performance audit recommendations from 2019 to 2023 and received follow-up presentations\n               on select reports. During our consideration of all reports and in following up with some audit organizations,\n               committee members engaged in constructive and valuable discussions on complex and\n               important issues, helping to promote public sector oversight and accountability in\n               B.C. I will say that committee work, despite what we witness in question period, often\n               reminds us that there is more that unites us than divides us. I would like to extend my appreciation to the Office of the Auditor General, the office\n               of the comptroller general and to the numerous senior public servants who took time\n               to appear before the committee and answer all of our questions. Finally, I would like to thank the staff from the Parliamentary Committees Office\n               and the Hansard Services who helped the committee in its work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752257","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to thank and acknowledge all the committee members for their contributions\n               and engagement to the committee. I would like to also recognize the Chair, the member\n               for Kamloops Centre, for his work on the committee. Over the course of the last year, the committee considered reports across a broad\n               range of program areas, including legal aid represe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65b85481ca74735feb7cf3f181b21c51500141145eabeea310a19c34b5d873e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1da9c962867bf6d81f5be1b7b90d0691251ec0b9f6cbe7d4ce3096f3a15bc156"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8135bf98560871d519bbda0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036494,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"We must be near the end of session with all these family members in the House. I am\n               so pleased to have two people visiting who are not my constituents but they're my\n               people: my parents are here. My stepdad, Len, and my mom, Susan — look, he's trying to get my mom to stand up; she won't. That's Len, beside him\n               is Susan, and they are the best parents and also the best campaign volunteers anyone\n               can ask for. Thank you for coming. Thank you for everything you do so that I can be down here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036494","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We must be near the end of session with all these family members in the House. I am\n               so pleased to have two people visiting who are not my constituents but they're my\n               people: my parents are here. My stepdad, Len, and my mom, Susan — look, he's trying to get my mom to stand up; she won't. That's Len, beside him\n               is Susan, and they are the best parents and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4f0a4270d23caab3c6da0256c1f14fdb0ace03e05966a38fcfe4cace5637e87"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7221c4dc451d3f119d49552331907727e78e8baa8958c376833faadc60bc36bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2940e0b221733e4b91720b85","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036496,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Stephanie Higginson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome the Cuthbert family, Thomas, Catherine, Connor and Mackenzie,\n               of South Coast Agrofarms and Island Farmhouse Poultry to the Legislature today. They\n               are part of the group feeding MLAs breakfast. Thomas is a fourth-generation farmer who is working to help strengthen agriculture\n               and local food production on Vancouver Island alongside his family. The Cuthberts\n               have built a respected farming operation in our community, and their dedication was\n               recently recognized when they were named the 2025 B.C.-Yukon Outstanding Young Farmers.\n               We are proud to recognize the Cuthberts and thank them for their contributions to\n               British Columbia's agriculture sector. Will everybody please help me make the Cuthberts feel very welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036496","member_id":"bc-mla-378","member_name":"Stephanie Higginson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to welcome the Cuthbert family, Thomas, Catherine, Connor and Mackenzie,\n               of South Coast Agrofarms and Island Farmhouse Poultry to the Legislature today. They\n               are part of the group feeding MLAs breakfast. Thomas is a fourth-generation farmer who is working to help strengthen agriculture\n               and local food production on Vancouver Island alongside","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168620","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","label":"Natural heritage","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168620","label":"Ecosystems","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["52f5e647c0df3b5a778cefe0c1f464cf7c167b8091ee237eeb8f7f4bc5020955"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cc5cddf3724c2fbcffb75c9732c2773dced8b1884d91fc7fb8c8cb1ba879a6e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b7cd17bdbf73fd03907ea7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316791,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Very rich, coming from the minister that destroyed our health care systems and now\n               is destroying our energy systems. They are overseeing themselves. It effectively eliminates the audit function. Those\n               are not my words. Those are the words of the BCGEU President Paul Finch. I don't always\n               agree with Paul, but I agree with him this time. Since 2018, the Merit Commissioner has been responsible for reviewing unjust dismissals\n               in the public service at a time when this government is reportedly preparing to cut\n               up to 15,000 public sector jobs. Will this Premier admit that eliminating the Merit Commissioner is a way to prevent\n               those workers from having an independent review of their dismissal?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316791","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Very rich, coming from the minister that destroyed our health care systems and now\n               is destroying our energy systems. They are overseeing themselves. It effectively eliminates the audit function. Those\n               are not my words. Those are the words of the BCGEU President Paul Finch. I don't always\n               agree with Paul, but I agree with him this time. Since 2018, the M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ddb9f23debd168e933b862de18226aabc52bf24088d80772515ceea44b32e83c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1665b32e02cb3cdfff169f384e397f801f5e9ee0b527d953a6392c56cc51d7c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1ddd7d6bb6f248f61d1cba0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316792,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"First and foremost, it is such a privilege and honour to speak in here and represent\n               the constituents of Langley-Abbotsford. On another note, I'd like to send my deepest condolences to the community of Tumbler\n               Ridge. It had a deep impact on me personally. You know, at the end of the week, going\n               home, I went back, I was able to hold my kids, and that actually.... I thought it would\n               bring comfort, but it sent chills to my spine knowing that there are families out\n               there that wouldn't be able to have that same moment there. But budgets tell stories. They tell us what a government values. They tell us who\n               carries the load. They tell us whether the people writing them understand the lives\n               of the people living under them. This budget tells a clear story. A record $13.3 billion deficit. Three more years\n               of double-digit deficits. Debt climbing to $183 billion, $50 billion added in the\n               last two years. Interest payments nearing $4 billion annually and rising at almost\n               25 percent. We are told this is steady management. Steady is not the word that comes to mind.\n               I come from a working-class background. I have worked jobs where overtime mattered.\n               I have made payroll when cash flow was tight. I've sat at the kitchen table with a\n               stack of bills and asked myself: \"What can wait?\" In the real world, when expenses outpace income year after year, you do not hold a\n               press conference and call it steady. You get serious. You review every cost. You cut\n               the waste. You find efficiencies. You focus on growing revenue the right way, through\n               productivity and opportunity, not by quietly raising taxes. You correct course before\n               the problem compounds. Here, spending rises roughly $4 billion this year alone. Revenue growth barely clears\n               1 percent. Borrowing fills the gap. This is not a temporary bridge through uncertainty. This is a structural imbalance,\n               and structural imbalance does not exist in spreadsheets. It shows up in how projects\n               are planned, sequenced, delayed and re-prioritized. It shows up in infrastructure.\n               It shows up in transportation. It shows up on Highway 1 Let's talk about the physical discipline and infrastructure. We hear record capital\n               spending numbers, but numbers alone do not equal delivery. Highway 1 runs straight\n               through Langley-Abbotsford. It is one of the most critical trade corridors in all of British Columbia, and after\n               nearly a decade, we still cannot say it is fully widen or complete through the Fraser\n               Valley. Fees are announced, timelines are revised, costs are adjusted. Businesses depend on\n               that corridor to get their products to market. Truckers depend on it. Farmers depend\n               on it. Manufacturers depend on it. Entrepreneurs depend on predictable travel times.\n               When congestion adds 30 minutes to delivery, that is not an inconvenience. That is\n               lost productivity. That is higher fuel consumption. That is missed opportunities,\n               more costs to the consumers, which are British Columbians. Infrastructure spending\n               without delivery discipline compounds deficits, and deficits compound debt. Borrowing\n               billions demands certainty. Certainty is missing. Let's talk about planning and discipline. There is a difference between running a\n               deficit during a downturn and building a fiscal model that assumes borrowing as routine.\n               Borrowing to ride out a storm is one thing, building your whole house on credit is\n               another. And when you borrow to fund projects that face delay after delay, cost escalations\n               follow. We see the pattern in every major infrastructure file across this province. The Pattullo\n               Bridge replacement is complete. I congratulate the workers, but it opened late under\n               this government. It did not open in the fall as suggested. It opened briefly on Christmas\n               Eve. It was not fully operational until February. After rising costs, it delivered the same number of lanes as before. Taxpayers paid\n               more, they waited longer, capacity did not expand, the Massey Tunnel replacement remains\n               uncertain. Costs continue to climb, permits are not finalized and environmental approvals\n               remain unresolved. Yet borrowing assumptions continue. We are layering fiscal risk\n               onto infrastructure uncertainty. That is not disciplined capital management. That\n               is exposure. This province does not end in the Lower Mainland. Let's talk a little bit about rural British Columbia. When a hospital is 20 minutes\n               away, that assumes the road is open. If a slide closes a highway, if winter conditions\n               shut down a mountain pass, if a bridge requires repair, that 20 minutes could easily\n               become an hour or more or longer. Sometimes it becomes inaccessible. Infrastructure is health care in rural British Columbia. can change the outcomes.\n               Emergency access depends on corridor reliability, and yet this budget does not accelerate\n               meaningful redundancy on our critical rural routes. It does not prioritize resilience.\n               It does not treat transportation as life-and-death infrastructure. It treats it as\n               a capital line item. Health spending increases, but three-quarters reflect caseload\n               pressure. That remains the status quo. It does not eliminate emergency room backlogs.\n               It does not solve the shortage of family doctors. It does not guarantee patients can\n               reach care in winter conditions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316792","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"First and foremost, it is such a privilege and honour to speak in here and represent\n               the constituents of Langley-Abbotsford. On another note, I'd like to send my deepest condolences to the community of Tumbler\n               Ridge. It had a deep impact on me personally. You know, at the end of the week, going\n               home, I went back, I was able to hold my kids, and that act","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0fdcbb79ea5d8bb0f33d3f9516872a6d1dd4412e7ab1db32571bc6448e940fd7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f891ce4e94adafadb3d4b4a9127a64ec939d8ec3eb2a7417a408d348d149bc7f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de01f0f979b8ce3cf2d6b2a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316793,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"This past Saturday, February 21, I had the honour of attending the memorial service\n               for Megan Rokeby-Thomas. It is heartbreaking to stand here speaking about her. One of my first major issues I worked on as an MLA was travelling to Eastshore during\n               the Kootenay Bay–Balfour ferry strike. That was when I came to know Megan. Everywhere\n               I went, people spoke about her, how she advocated for everyone, how she showed up\n               for her community and how she wanted what was best for people. She carried herself with quiet strength and genuine care. That wasn't just something\n               she said; that is who she was. It felt, though, as the entire town and surrounding\n               communities gathered, that people made the ferry crossing to the other side of the\n               lake just to be there. That alone speaks volumes. Voices were lifted in songs; stories\n               were shared. It was not just a time of mourning but a celebration of life that clearly\n               touched so many. It was an honour to meet Megan's husband, son Byron and Byron's young family. The\n               strength they carried through such a difficult day was deeply moving. Small communities\n               like Eastshore thrive because of people like Megan, people who deeply care, who put\n               others first and work tirelessly for their neighbours. Megan will be deeply missed. Our thoughts are with her family, her friends and the\n               entire Eastshore community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316793","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This past Saturday, February 21, I had the honour of attending the memorial service\n               for Megan Rokeby-Thomas. It is heartbreaking to stand here speaking about her. One of my first major issues I worked on as an MLA was travelling to Eastshore during\n               the Kootenay Bay–Balfour ferry strike. That was when I came to know Megan. Everywhere\n               I went, people spoke","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3665106110dbb083b60745041c4c6a2a14806a175c3fdccc797dde2c472c00f2","c632ed9c204d007b9dec5ad0bc0213a7569d44e9db1b631ccacf84741bd3a0c0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["91f6b8a87607123465f9fb823b8fd529aafadcef75ef3c08e323dd4242e29d24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c41064fbd359b50ddd2f2676","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327909,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"My mom isn't here today, but she's at home. I just want to thank her for everything\n               she has done for me. Today is a bit of a tough day for losing my dad nine years ago\n               today. I just wish the House would give her a virtual hug and make her feel comfort at this\n               time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327909","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"My mom isn't here today, but she's at home. I just want to thank her for everything\n               she has done for me. Today is a bit of a tough day for losing my dad nine years ago\n               today. I just wish the House would give her a virtual hug and make her feel comfort at this\n               time.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49f6f9e17638ee9fc98fec1cd4449dad31561c8ee8e90c98b1b95363951a503c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f537cbc961d7e98b1084c15b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327910,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak on the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act, 2026. I want to start off by highlighting that there is some good in this bill and there\n               is some bad. I'll give you the good first. I'll share a personal thing about myself. I actually have to renew my license this\n               year. I wish this bill was on the floor years ago so that I can speed up that process.\n               Especially being in the trucking industry, working for the family business, it's busy.\n               Life is busy. There is less and less time for more and more British Columbians. This\n               could really speed up the process. That is something that I just want to highlight. Moving along with a new digital age is very important, especially when you're going\n               to be able to speedline things, especially being in this line of work. When you're\n               here, our time is limited. It really helps when people can access services and move\n               on with their lives in an adequate amount of time. Waiting in lineups at ICBC, going\n               to the DMV.... Everyone knows the lineups and how long it takes. You know what? It's not just the stress on the consumers, the people going there for\n               this service. It actually helps the workers a lot. A lot of the abuse they face when\n               they're dealing with situations.... People are in a rush. They are always pushing them:\n               \"Hey, can I get this process done faster?\" This will help mitigate a lot of those\n               issues, and a lot of the workers at ICBC will have a lot more stress-free time at\n               work. The big thing here is the reduce in wait times. I really think that is going to be\n               something that will really help a lot of industries and be convenient for families\n               with busy schedules like myself, like my wife at home. She's at home right now, and\n               when she has to get a renewal, this would really help her. Having the kids around\n               the house, you have to take them to the DMV, waiting to line up, kids are getting\n               upset, crying, and the whole office is up in arms saying: \"Hey, calm down over there.\"\n               This could really help a lot for a lot of people. Also travelling British Columbia.... I've had the honour of travelling this province,\n               and one thing we need to wake up and realize is that the life here in the Lower Mainland\n               isn't the same in the rural parts. A lot of people would have to drive for hours just\n               to get a renewal. They'd have to set appointments. Sometimes there are traffic delays,\n               road closures, weather. Those are some issues that will be mitigated through this\n               process, and that's why I support this program for that cause. Also, now, this can actually really help modernize how ICBC can focus on road tests\n               and complex cases. It could really help maybe modernize some of the trucking ways,\n               the way they do the pre-trip inspections and a lot of things that they could focus\n               on and adapt and bring them up to standards. This bill will apply to use some of that\n               workforce in areas where it's really needed. Another thing I like with it too is when we implement a system that modernizes things\n               online, we can always develop on it and add things to it with scrutiny. That's why\n               we're here in this chamber today discussing these bills. We talk about the good, and\n               we talk about the bad, and that's the best way to actually come up with a bill that's\n               balanced for British Columbians. One thing that I would like to say is.... Some of the stuff I was reading in the bill,\n               I do feel there is a sense of safeguards in there for proper identity verification\n               and security safeguards There are a few things that I just want to touch upon that have been a little.... You\n               know, I like the way that it modernizes the BCID system and the service system, and\n               I think we can actually use this in other areas. Right now we're seeing extortion cases climbing. One thing that I had talked about\n               was an identification system right here in British Columbia that we can implement,\n               where we can have people go into online verification and get that facial recognition\n               so our CCTV cameras can pick them up in the future. That could help the police services\n               solve some of the crimes. That is something that I'm really passionate about, getting\n               some support systems in there. One thing we can also do is, if people are here in this country, in this province,\n               with foreign IDs, this could be a simple way to speedline that process, where they\n               can actually get a BCID so we have them in our database. Talking to police officers during this extortion crisis, they say, \"We can run across\n               a criminal. They'll have one ID. The next day they're released,\" or whatever it is,\n               \"and they can have three different IDs with different names on them for a different\n               country,\" which makes it hard for the police to actually identify and see if it is\n               a legitimate ID. That is a way that we can roll out this service to maybe have it added on for temporary\n               foreign workers who are here or students on permits and visas. It could actually help\n               us track some of those situations. Something that I do have a little bit of concern about is how are.... Noting the hour, I reserve my place to continue at the next sitting and move adjournment\n               of the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327910","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak on the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act, 2026. I want to start off by highlighting that there is some good in this bill and there\n               is some bad. I'll give you the good first. I'll share a personal thing about myself. I actually have to renew my license this\n               year. I wish this bill was on the floor years ago so that I can speed up that process.\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","label":"Digital technology","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcfcdc4751558e1a3575389ca2fc96bdee2f20f59fe2de55c980233ed85d1e5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["210f9b2392163d61971c60676811f5a70a20146e18237e5feb179e5f5cbd2acd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Digital technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034836","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-26252bb830c480b6247ccc98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327911,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act. Let me begin by saying clearly that I plan to support this bill, as long as there\n               are the right safeguards in place. At its core, Bill 6 is about modernizing how British Columbians renew and replace\n               their driver's licence and identification cards. It introduces a framework that will\n               allow many of these services to be completed online rather than requiring people to\n               go and visit an actual ICBC office. That is a positive step, but as I mentioned yesterday\n               it is also a step that is coming a little too late. I have to renew my driver's license this year, and quite frankly, I wish I could,\n               after this speech, walk into my office, log in, and have that renewal approved within\n               a couple minutes. That is the kind of convenience British Columbians expect in 2026. Government services should evolve with the times. People bank online, they file their\n               taxes online, they manage businesses and finances online. It only makes sense that\n               straightforward services like licence renewal should also be available digitally. For many British Columbians this will save time and reduce frustration. Right now\n               something as simple as renewing a license can require people to take time off work,\n               arrange child care and sit in long lineups at ICBC offices. For families with busy\n               schedules, those hours matter. For workers who are paid by the hour, that lost time\n               means lost income. Bill 6 recognizes that reality moves towards a system where routine\n               renewals can be completed quickly and efficiently online. Another benefit of this legislation is that it could reduce pressures on the ICBC\n               service centres. By moving routine transactions online, staff will have more time\n               to focus on services that genuinely require in-person interaction — things like road\n               tests, things like complex licensing issues, things that cannot simply be handled\n               through a digital form. That could help reduce bottlenecks and improve overall service\n               for the public. This bill also has the potential to improve fairness across the province. For people\n               living in rural and remote communities, visiting an ICBC office can involve long travel\n               times. In some areas, residents may need to drive significant distances simply to\n               complete a basic renewal. Allowing online renewals makes those services more accessible and more equitable for\n               the people across British Columbia. On the principle of modernization and convenience\n               and efficiency, this legislation makes sense. While I support the direction of this bill, there are also important concerns that\n               deserve attention. The first concern is transparency. Bill 6 establishes a legislative framework for\n               online renewals, but many of those key details are left to future regulations. Those\n               regulations will determine who qualifies for online renewals, what conditions apply The first concern is transparency. Bill 6 establishes a legislative framework for\n               online renewals, but many of those key details are left to future regulations. Those\n               regulations will determine who qualifies for online renewals, what conditions apply\n               and the safeguards that will be put in place. At this stage, those details are not\n               fully clear yet. As legislators and as representatives of the public, we should have\n               clarity about those rules — and before the system is fully implemented. Another concern relates to the digital divide. While many people are comfortable with\n               online services, not everyone is. Not everyone has the access to internet and also\n               the level of digital literacy involved in making and completing those forms. Seniors,\n               for example, may prefer in-person services. Some low-income households may not have\n               consistent internet access — and also in rural areas. For those individuals, it is\n               essential that in-person services remain accessible and adequately staffed. Security and identity verification are also important considerations. Drivers' licences\n               are a primary form of identification used in banking, travelling, employment and many\n               other aspects of our daily lives. That means the identity verification process for\n               online renewals must be robust and secure. The bill also introduces a requirement for individuals to notify ICBC if their email\n               address has changed. While that may sound straightforward, the practical implications\n               should be considered. People change email accounts frequently. Some people maintain\n               several email addresses. Others may not regularly monitor them at all. The government\n               should ensure that these requirements are reasonable and clearly communicated. Finally, the implementation timeline is another factor. The government has indicated\n               that the online renewal system is expected to launch around 2027. That means the full\n               benefits of this legislation will still be some time away. Modernization of government services is something most people can agree on. Bill 6\n               has the potential to move us in the right direction, but modernization must come with\n               transparency, strong safeguards and continued access for those who rely on in-person\n               services. While I will be supporting this legislation, I will also be watching closely to ensure\n               it is implemented properly, because the goal should always be better services and\n               greater convenience, in a system that works for all British Columbians and that they\n               can trust.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327911","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am pleased to rise today to speak to Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act. Let me begin by saying clearly that I plan to support this bill, as long as there\n               are the right safeguards in place. At its core, Bill 6 is about modernizing how British Columbians renew and replace\n               their driver's licence and identification cards. It introduces a framework that will\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","label":"Computer services","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9052c6cc56854b6e4429dfe3186762104209e302334aa0fe4f9120719df56ce7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e754ecde02a61b418007b496f58864c2db396fbc4260662eb0cd4dd5753498d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56d533c3cfc2a2ac88940549","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358952,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is clear the NDP won't protect private properties. It's because they've learned\n               nothing from their mistakes at Cowichan. They could have advocated for British Columbians\n               and made the fee simple private properties exempt in the agreement, but they chose\n               to stay silent. We have heard from members of the strata council in Victoria that this government's\n               PST expansion will increase costs. We have heard that it will cost CJA an extra $84,000\n               a year to protect their places of worship. We have heard this NDP government's housing policies increase costs. It has gotten\n               so bad that the average homebuyer in Vancouver is 46 years old. We have also heard\n               that 86 percent of people under 45 have given up on home ownership. Under this NDP\n               government, more and more people are using food banks. That includes 33,000 children. And one thing, I want to set the record straight. The other side campaigned and said\n               we would cut costs on health care. But you know what? That is the side that has cut\n               health care. I have a personal story from my riding.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358952","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It is clear the NDP won't protect private properties. It's because they've learned\n               nothing from their mistakes at Cowichan. They could have advocated for British Columbians\n               and made the fee simple private properties exempt in the agreement, but they chose\n               to stay silent. We have heard from members of the strata council in Victoria that this government's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034457","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Childhood diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034457","label":"Childhood diseases","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d7b74e2a029a1689d28f41727b196bd6d84bfc23934f004aa4997fe545e031a9","185bb262339dd40692ee7f7ae5a7905d9a08affd40ff88afead5bbf501b44daf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["191c32d583b49321feb0dab5726384e177b5a5f124f0708ec3279890452e830e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a08a2af50e92869b99777046","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359626,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"May I be excused to make an introduction?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359626","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"May I be excused to make an introduction?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e7a087cad10e6cf8379c85916f3f442661fbe52463c77c7955e63dcfe85bf38"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dfa345386d0fdb677bc6702e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359627,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to wish Ted Campbell, a constituent of mine who is an avid watcher of\n               the B.C. Legislature.... He's also a book writer and overall, just a great community\n               guy. He's been a great guide for me. Would the House wish him a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359627","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I just want to wish Ted Campbell, a constituent of mine who is an avid watcher of\n               the B.C. Legislature.... He's also a book writer and overall, just a great community\n               guy. He's been a great guide for me. Would the House wish him a happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Authors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","label":"Authors","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67234cdd22bd3a75057a85c8ac7b015800773d1e14194709b9963f18559fe1f6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de41e25a7d71a4289dfd6aa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413651,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Five credit downgrades under this NDP government. Five. That is not a technical issue.\n               That is a warning sign. Every downgrade means higher borrowing costs, billions more\n               in interest, money that should be going to health care, to families, to the most vulnerable","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413651","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Five credit downgrades under this NDP government. Five. That is not a technical issue.\n               That is a warning sign. Every downgrade means higher borrowing costs, billions more\n               in interest, money that should be going to health care, to families, to the most vulnerable","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["23a26d4e0b0f4dae18f74cf56a4a8198c565014912b865dc6e2cab7fb2045b86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33fc829b09a9dda222cbeaa4b632847d83b8dece6d5959f70ea5f875158d3ada"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02f0aa0ce068f0fbf4bfd026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413652,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Decrease, in other words, cuts, is exactly what that side of the aisle is doing to\n               health care. I've heard from a single mother in Aldergrove raising a child with autism. Her son\n               Reese is Métis. He doesn't qualify for First Nations supports and has aged out of Métis programs.\n               Now like many families across B.C., they are losing critical funding. She told me\n               they may have to leave B.C. just to access care. My question: is this government proud of the cuts and forcing families out of this\n               province?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413652","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Decrease, in other words, cuts, is exactly what that side of the aisle is doing to\n               health care. I've heard from a single mother in Aldergrove raising a child with autism. Her son\n               Reese is Métis. He doesn't qualify for First Nations supports and has aged out of Métis programs.\n               Now like many families across B.C., they are losing critical funding. She told","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c19845c030917598a4b9c069627f07a5c783c25218c7dd466c1a632a91a4bc7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d789ce43a73e509dfa56c4c7659cc45912693bbccbd906a60c18850c7ffdf890"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58e7b3e5705848e8d1f130fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720105,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last Friday, April 10, was my daughter, Audriana Bangu's, birthday, She's just been\n               a guiding joy throughout the whole time. Now she's six, but my son is seven. So you\n               all know what I'm going to hear non-stop is the six-seven. Would the House please\n               make her feel welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720105","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Last Friday, April 10, was my daughter, Audriana Bangu's, birthday, She's just been\n               a guiding joy throughout the whole time. Now she's six, but my son is seven. So you\n               all know what I'm going to hear non-stop is the six-seven. Would the House please\n               make her feel welcome?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e04e8f1d2e5fe389d1f2810df200e20bbfa3bda0917407350bdad2a2a2f160fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4c57c0660ccce21ecd8566c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720113,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"The NDP's hand-picked CEO, Nicolas Jimenez of B.C. Ferries, has overseen disruptions,\n               cancellations and breakdowns across the system, leaving British Columbians dealing\n               with delays, missed sailings, growing uncertainty, and there has been no real accountability.\n               Despite that, this CEO is earning a high six-figure salary with additional perks funded\n               by the taxpayers, including a car and housing allowance in Victoria. If he is truly\n               committed to leading B.C. Ferries, why isn't he living where he works and paying for\n               his own housing? My question: why is this government asking British Columbians to subsidize the living\n               expenses of a highly paid CEO while services continue to decline?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720113","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The NDP's hand-picked CEO, Nicolas Jimenez of B.C. Ferries, has overseen disruptions,\n               cancellations and breakdowns across the system, leaving British Columbians dealing\n               with delays, missed sailings, growing uncertainty, and there has been no real accountability.\n               Despite that, this CEO is earning a high six-figure salary with additional perks funded\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:119797","label":"Marine accidents","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d977044e53dbca4f636d1abefeae29d030800cd5d2b1037ef53768c555e0aa4d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b979d5be88c8539faa499bc107800cb0207519015c8526cf2fe57212aebf8ff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd332c8e472ac998505141e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721193,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we have Monica Achen's grade 5 class from St. Catherine's Elementary in Brookswood, and there are 30 students, and there are ten adults in there. Would the House please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721193","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today we have Monica Achen's grade 5 class from St. Catherine's Elementary in Brookswood, and there are 30 students, and there are ten adults in there. Would the House please make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc04ba52b92d36751de1945074dc5cc8231695dcc6015dc98744a9e242c659ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50a39690d9c3bc7dad1673df1231350aef4fe51d9ba99f9cec4002d8d320c04a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec1083e7c2b71ab95b62ec66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728783,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak about the men and women who keep our ports moving, our shelves\n               stocked and our economy running: our port truckers. These are hard-working people\n               who have been through a lot. Governments pushed a rolling truck-age program, asking\n               them to invest in newer lower-emission trucks. Many stepped up. They took on debt.\n               They modernized their fleets. Then the program was paused. Now they're dealing with another layer of uncertainty, the port truck tag system.\n               Right now those tags are issued for just two years. But the reality on the ground\n               — these trucks are not small purchases. Most operators finance over five years, sometimes\n               longer. They are making real commitments based on expectations of stable work. A two-year\n               truck tag does not match a five-year loan. Even a three-year truck tag that has been discussed will still not solve the problem.\n               What happens if a trucker invests, builds up a small fleet and then loses tags just\n               after a few years? They're left with trucks they still owe money on but without the\n               ability to earn. That is not just bad policy. That is a direct hit to small business\n               operators trying to do the right thing. A four- or five-year tag would bring alignment. It would give truckers a fair runway.\n               It would allow them to get close to paying down their equipment before facing a level\n               of risk, and it would provide the stability this sector desperately needs. If we want a reliable supply chain, if we want a strong truck port system, we need\n               to treat port truckers like partners, not placeholders. Give them certainty, match\n               policy to reality, and let them do what they do best.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728783","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak about the men and women who keep our ports moving, our shelves\n               stocked and our economy running: our port truckers. These are hard-working people\n               who have been through a lot. Governments pushed a rolling truck-age program, asking\n               them to invest in newer lower-emission trucks. Many stepped up. They took on debt.\n               They m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6d62b9b0e4305078ccf2b279e3bd7fdf7f017cbd119bf6947953442e660d947"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a732c7b58d298a2b133de7bdc2d87f451730b5ad363600abaa362b44bdf733de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65a1ae8d5e90e80f40054261","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752160,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in favour of the private member's Bill M217. One thing I want to clarify is.... On the weight stage that the member from Ladysmith-Oceanside had brought up, that was actually agreed upon, and there was an amendment made that\n               covered that aspect about gross weight. Being someone that came from the trucking industry, this bill will help. It will help\n               with ICBC if there are any accidents, and it helps with safety in a lot of ways. As\n               a trucker, you'd be driving straight ahead, and a lot of cars do drive erratically.\n               They would cut right in front of you. Most of the time, that would always be \"hey,\n               blame the trucker\" every single time. This would bring clarity. This would actually help the process of ICBC and everything\n               else that way. And I feel this bill does cover a lot of issues and a lot of erratic\n               driving. It does make people more honest when they're driving. I had a dashcam in mine, and it always reminded you that you need to be a professional\n               as a trucker, and this bill does bring professionalism to trucking and the process\n               that it is if there was any accident to happen. So I strongly speak in support of\n               this bill. As someone that comes from the industry, someone that's lived the life\n               of a trucker, this bill helps. I think all members in this House should be supporting a bill like this that actually\n               brings transparency if issues arise. It helps trucker safety and, most importantly,\n               helps all British Columbians' safety. That is the missing piece here that I would\n               like to highlight. This would bring a lot of clarity if anything was to go wrong. I really would like the whole House to support this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752160","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in favour of the private member's Bill M217. One thing I want to clarify is.... On the weight stage that the member from Ladysmith-Oceanside had brought up, that was actually agreed upon, and there was an amendment made that\n               covered that aspect about gross weight. Being someone that came from the trucking industry, this bill will help. It will help\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee0ef46111f9cfd28fc1674de337cb6dc3bc9b77cd8823971c5dbdc4e2019a9c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bbf60e7446c4a261b6d46799f0b8cc6f581b79984315c2a033c207b60604b550"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b9878f6c881fdc51a650d35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752161,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm here today to speak to Bill 9. I want to walk through it in a way that people\n               outside this building would actually understand it, because at the end of the day,\n               this is not about legal wording. This is about whether regular people in British Columbia\n               can still get straight answers from their own government. I'll say this right off the bat. When you go through this bill clause by clause, this\n               is not about improving access. It's about controlling access. People might not read\n               the legislation front to back, but they will feel it when they try and get answers\n               and are hit with a wall. Before I got here, I worked in trucking, construction, paving, building the projects\n               that we need — up at four or five in the morning, long days, real pressure, real accountability.\n               And in that world, things are simple. If someone asks you a question, you answer it.\n               If something goes wrong, you deal with it. And if you're late, you don't argue about\n               what late means. You fix it. That's how the real life works. But what I see in this bill is the exact opposite — more grey area, more wiggle room,\n               more ways to delay, more ways to say no. And that matters, because freedom of information\n               is one of the only tools people have to actually see what government is doing behind\n               closed doors. Journalists rely on it. Citizens rely on it. We rely on it here to hold\n               the government accountable. So when the rules around that start changing, we need\n               to pay attention. Let's start with clauses 2 and 26. This bill says that an FOI request has to be detailed\n               enough so the record can be found in a reasonable amount of time. Nobody is arguing against clarity. Of course, requests should be clear. But here's\n               the issue. What is a reasonable amount of time? It's not defined, so who decides this\n               — the person asking the questions or the government that might not want to go digging?\n               Because now the head of the public body gets to decide whether your request is detailed\n               enough. Before, that opinion didn't carry that kind of weight. Now it does. That's a gate.\n               That's someone deciding whether your questions even get through the door. Once you\n               start putting gates in place, fewer people get through. That's how it works. Now let's move to clause 3. This one matters. We go from without delay to without Now let's move to clause 3. This one matters. We go from \"without delay\" to \"without\n               unreasonable delay.\" That might sound small, but it's not, because \"without delay\"\n               is clear. It means get moving. \"Without unreasonable delay\" opens the door. What's\n               reasonable? A week, a month, three months, six months, a year? Now it becomes a debate,\n               and when it becomes a debate, it becomes delay. People are already waiting too long.\n               Instead of tightening timelines, this bill loosens them. That's backwards. Clause 5 and clause 6 keep going in the same direction. Instead of working with people\n               to fix a request if it's not perfect, we move towards rejecting it. Think about that.\n               Instead of helping someone get the information they're asking for, we're building\n               a system that makes it easier to say no. That's not service; that's avoidance. Now, clauses 13 and 28, this is where it really starts to matter. These clauses expand\n               the ability to disregard requests if they're considered frivolous, vexatious, too\n               broad or if they interfere with government operations. Now, I understand the idea.\n               No one wants the system abused. But here's the problem. None of those terms are clearly\n               defined. What's too broad? If someone is asking big questions about spending, is it too broad?\n               If a journalist digs deep, is that interference? If someone keeps asking questions\n               because they're not getting answers, is that vexatious? Without clear definitions,\n               those words get stretched, and when they get stretched, legitimate questions get pushed\n               aside. That is the concern. Clause 7 deals with judicial communications tied to policy. Now, I understand protecting\n               sensitive conversations, but again, where is the line? When lines aren't clear, they\n               move, and when they move, the public sees less. Clauses 8 through 12 expand on how personal information can be collected and shared\n               — more data, more sharing, more systems. I get it. Services are changing. But here\n               is the reality. Every time you expand that, you increase risk. People want to know\n               where their information is going, who's accessing it and what happens if something\n               goes wrong. Trust doesn't come from saying: \"Don't worry about it.\" Trust comes from\n               clear rules and strong safeguards. Clause 15 removes the 90-day limit on reviews, so now it can take longer — again,\n               longer timelines, more flexibility for the government, less certainty for the people,\n               same pattern. Clause 20 brings this idea of a centralized system. Now, maybe that's about efficiency,\n               but I've seen centralized systems before. Sometimes they help. Sometimes they just\n               make things harder to access and easier to control. So the question is simple: is\n               this about helping people or managing the flow of information? Clauses 21 to 22 say some records can be made available without an FOI request. That\n               sounds positive, but then there are fees attached. Now we have to ask: are we opening\n               access or putting a price on it? Access to your own government should not depend on\n               your wallet. I'll just make one quick point here. We've already seen proactive disclosure tools\n               paused, and it's still unclear when they're coming back online. When access tools\n               are being taken offline on one hand and more discretion is being added on the other,\n               people are going to connect those dots. Clause 19 removes early notification around privacy impact assessment. This one also\n               matters, because catching problems early is how you avoid bigger problems later. Why\n               remove that step? What is there to hide? Why remove an early check that protects people? When I step back and look at this bill as a whole, here's what I see. More When I step back and look at this bill as a whole, here's what I see. More discretion\n               from the government, more delay, more grey areas, more ways to just say no. At the\n               same time, I don't see anything that clearly makes the system faster or clearer or\n               easier to use. That is the issue. Because that is not just policy; this is power.\n               FOIs are how people keep government honest. It's how stories come out. It's how decisions\n               get questioned. When you make that harder, you shift that balance. People back home aren't asking\n               for perfection. They're asking for straight answers. They're asking for transparency.\n               They're asking for a system that works. They're asking for a government that doesn't\n               hide behind wording, process, when simple questions get asked. Right now this bill\n               moves us in the wrong direction. More control, less clarity, more delays, less accountability. I'll say this. This\n               bill is really about improving the system, then show people it's going to make responses\n               faster. Show people it is going to make access easier. Show people it strengthens\n               accountability, because right now that's not clear. What's clear is the government\n               gets more room to decide, more room to delay, more room to refuse. That is not what\n               people expect. That is not how trust is built, and that is not how accountability\n               works. The question is simple: are we making it easier for people to get answers or easier\n               for the government to avoid them? Because that's what it's coming down to. I just want to share a little bit about how open information has been a benefit for\n               me as an opposition MLA. I have been able to go and track calendars, briefing notes,\n               meetings and search them, and you can go back even further. Even when I came into\n               this Legislature.... I was elected October 19 of 2024. There was an issue happening\n               with the ferry strike at Kootenay Bay in Balfour. I was actually able to, after a\n               couple months being elected and in here, and when that situation arose.... I was able\n               to go back and look at what ministers, what meetings were happening. I knew there\n               was actually a real situation happening there. I actually could get on the ground, go out there, visit those areas and get that information.\n               It was very important that that information was accessible. You can also go on there\n               and see who ministers have met in the previous weeks, months, after the 60-90 day\n               delay when it actually gets posted on open information. You can actually go back and\n               research it a bit and figure out who were these ministers meeting with. It can tell\n               you what bills might come on the floor, what might happen in certain projects, certain\n               situations, and that is very key as an opposition MLA. You need to have access to\n               these means because that is how we do our work. When this is restricted, it causes\n               more delay in our work. The work that I have is important to British Columbians who have elected me to represent\n               them, keep the government to account. This is where the grey area hits in. This is\n               where the roadblocks hit. This actually restricts the work as an opposition MLA. It\n               slows you down on figuring out what's important in your file, what information you\n               need to dig up in certain projects, certain fields that you are actually researching.\n               When I came in here, this was a huge tool for me to get in and hit the ground running.\n               I was able to research transportation projects. Being the Transportation critic, I could go in there and figure out if there's a project\n               that's coming up in the future. I was able to see if the minister has met with people\n               who are part of that project. It lets the opposition actually have an insight into\n               what the government is doing. Now that is being taken away or delayed. What else is\n               it? Maybe we would uncover some more limo rides for ministers. Maybe that is the fear\n               on the other side. Maybe it's to hide, who knows.... The World Cup is coming around. There are going to\n               be tickets handed out. This would be a way that we could figure out that. But now\n               it is being taken away on this side of the aisle. It makes me beg. I've been making a lot of.... I'm very active on my social media. I actually have posted\n               the calendar notes. I have posted the briefing notes. At times I feel like this bill\n               is to restrict me personally in the work that I am doing This is a real issue. This is something that.... British Columbians, a lot of my friends,\n               when I came into this place, said: \"Hey, how are you going to hold the government\n               to account?\" This was one of the main tools. This was a very important tool. I have\n               actually gone out and helped explain to my constituents where I get my information\n               from, because I think being transparent to British Columbians is a huge reason why\n               a lot of the people on this side of the aisle actually stepped up, put their name\n               on a ballot and wanted to be in this place. Now all that's been taken away by this government that's afraid of their incompetence,\n               the things that they want to hide from us as the opposition, which is really concerning\n               to me. You can look at a lot of issues like the Highway 1 project. You can go in there\n               and figure out who the ministers are meeting, what's going to happen in the next phase\n               of that job. This is very important information. Even on the SkyTrain stuff I've been able to go on there and see who they're meeting\n               so I know the progress of it. I know what phase they'll be entering. Are they talking\n               to people from phase 2 to phase 3? How is that all connected? You can figure this\n               stuff out by looking at the calendar. Now there's a pause on a lot of it, and I wonder why that pause happened. Was it because\n               of my colleague from Abbotsford-Mission, who did an amazing job in estimates? The next thing you know, the next day, it's\n               shut down. That raises serious concerns on this side of the aisle, because we're here\n               to represent the people of our ridings, British Columbians, and now we're not being\n               able to do that fully. Every step of the way, where we're trying to make progress and get more efficient,\n               actually hold this government to account on some of the stuff that they're trying\n               to push through, this creates a serious roadblock on this side. That is something that we really need to think about when bills are being put in place\n               through this Legislature. How does it help everyone? How does it help the people at\n               home who are wondering why they can't put food on the table? They already feel this\n               is the most secretive government. Then when situations like this arise, when bills\n               like this get put on the floor, their thoughts and feelings feel confirmed. They are\n               afraid of what's going on. This really, really.... At the deep of this bill, I am really just blown away that we\n               are actually dealing with a government that wants to hide what they're doing from\n               British Columbians and the opposition. It is gravely disturbing. We have known the\n               Finance Minister taking limo rides — $6,000. Now I want to know: was there more? This\n               putting a pause on it, closing this, would actually restrict us from gaining that\n               information. With World Cup around the corner, who knows what kind of frivolous spending is going\n               to be done by the other side. We've seen it time and time again, tax dollars wasted\n               over and over. This access was a way for us to do our work, figure out.... Maybe if\n               there's a delay, so be it. At least the truth would come to light at some point. That is the key here. We want to keep this place accountable. We want bills that pass\n               through this House to be vetted and debated and actually have good purpose for British\n               Columbians. I don't see that with this bill. All I see is another roadblock, more\n               bureaucracy, more red tape, when British Columbians are already facing enough of this.\n               I have calls from constituents non-stop asking: \"What's going on with Bill 9?\" What\n               is going on? We've had this project right in the middle of our backyard, Highway 1, forever. We\n               want to find out information. Do they even have a proper crossing on 264? How is that going to work? How are the lanes going to work? You can actually try\n               and access some of that information through this process, and now that's being taken\n               away as well. There area lot of situations here, like FOIs that you can put on certain projects.\n               My colleague talked about the bridge in Quesnel. I've been there. I've visited that\n               bridge. I'm surprised it's even in operation. That FOI came back, and it showed numerous\n               things that are not up to date, up to par. Even with the Taylor Bridge, there were\n               FOIs that came in there. There have been numerous FOIs that have come out that have shown there have been situations,\n               issues with what's going on, and there is no accountability. When you get rid of this\n               process, you're pretty much giving them a free cheque to do whatever you want. That\n               is not what British Columbians want. It's not what my constituents want. They want When you get rid of this process, you're pretty much giving them a free cheque to\n               do whatever you want. That is not what British Columbians want. It's not what my constituents\n               want. They want accountability. They want transparency, especially out of the most\n               secret government that they've seen to date in British Columbia. I think these are\n               legitimate concerns that people have. I can go on and on, and there's more here. The situation here is British Columbians\n               are sick and tired of things being hidden from them, having to go jump through hoops.\n               Life is already busy, as it is. People have kids they need to drop off at school,\n               pick them up, go do their jobs, take them to sports and everything. And now when they're\n               trying to figure out maybe something that might be in someone's line of work, what\n               government's doing, you go on there, and there are more delays, more delays, more\n               delays. This doesn't help a lot of British Columbians. And in a lot of the situations here\n               I have seen the reasoning for, I don't buy it. I know if they were on this side of\n               the aisle, they'd be screaming and yelling from the rooftops, saying: \"This is a way\n               to hide what the Conservatives are doing.\" We've heard it time and time again from\n               the other side. This raises serious concerns, and that's why I'm here to speak on this. It's to actually\n               bring some accountability for British Columbians and my constituents who are deeply,\n               deeply troubled. I was just at an event on Friday, and I had six people come up to\n               me and ask me what is going on with Bill 9. To us, this seems a lot of parallel to\n               what the federal government is doing, restricting things on social media and other\n               aspects, so it is a big concern. Now, I know there are some amendments coming that we'll debate in the next stage.\n               We'll see how things are going to roll out, and we'll have some discussion around\n               it. But the thing is that British Columbians are looking for transparency in a time\n               where it seems to be nonexistent. That's why I feel this bill has been brought in\n               to hide what the government is doing. It's been brought in to mitigate the work the opposition has been doing. We have been\n               doing great work on this side of the aisle. Right now the reason why we were able\n               to do a lot of that work is by looking up the details of what's happened. Who are\n               these ministers meeting? What are their briefing notes? What are they actually doing? Now we can go in.... Right now we have accessibility, but in the future if we don't, this is going to hinder\n               the work that the opposition MLAs are here to do. That is why I will not support this\n               bill. I cannot support this bill, and a lot of issues continue to rise. Every time\n               one of these amendments gets put in that they say they will do, you can't take it\n               at face value here, because we just do not get how this government wants to continuously\n               hide things from British Columbians, hide things from us on the opposition. I know there was a word said,  \"Hey, that never happened, limo rides,\" but let's be\n               clear. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation has pulled the FOIs. They have made this\n               public knowledge, and we know it was a fact. We know it happened, but what are we\n               going to do in the future to try and mitigate these situations? That is the question\n               at hand here. In final, I cannot support this bill that would restrict the opposition. It would\n               make it harder for British Columbians to access information. That is just not a bill\n               that I can actually support in this House. I came into this House to bring transparency,\n               to change the way politics has been done, to talk to constituents, educate them on\n               bills, let them know what is coming down the pipeline in this chamber. I've seen it time and time again. Before I was a politician, I always wondered how\n               decisions are made here. Are British Columbians even consulted? This bill clearly\n               shows you they are not being consulted. They are being left in the dust. They are\n               being left to wonder what's going on, what their government is doing. Pretty soon they'll be wondering what their opposition is doing, because the opposition\n               won't have the information to access everything that the government is doing so we\n               can actually hold them to account. That is why I cannot support this bill, and I'm\n               really against this bill. I honestly, at times, feel like this bill was brought in place to restrict the work\n               that I've been doing, like I've said before on my social medias. I have brought in\n               threads. I've posted threads. I've put in all the work. The reason why I do that work\n               is because I truly believe British Columbians deserve to know what's going on. When\n               there are certain The reason why I do that work is because I truly believe British Columbians deserve\n               to know what's going on. When there are certain people being brought in the House,\n               and they're being introduced, then later on, a few weeks later, we see bills being\n               tabled. It's a great concern. That is why, once again, I will say it time and time again, for the record. I cannot\n               support this bill. I will not support this bill. This bill should never have been\n               put in place by the government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752161","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm here today to speak to Bill 9. I want to walk through it in a way that people\n               outside this building would actually understand it, because at the end of the day,\n               this is not about legal wording. This is about whether regular people in British Columbia\n               can still get straight answers from their own government. I'll say this right off the bat. When you ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10db8515a8325d6cc1b9b5fd8fe536b50a90a5dbeb1608956f8abb46b8aa81e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0944cc82caed236a159d0f35d1d8a28182dbf699324704288f1e9dab902cb557"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81284ec1fe9ab50b502e27ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752162,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would also like to welcome Brian from House of Q to the House. A few years ago,\n               way before I got into politics, CFOX, the radio show, used to have the drive-through\n               barbecues. I was always an avid listener of the CFOX show and a huge fan of Brian.\n               I actually have a lot of his rubs and barbecues at my house. I use them all the time.\n               He's always put on great events and stuff for the drive-through barbecue, and it's\n               great to connect with him and have him actually come to the workplace, finally. It's an honour having him here. Good friend, and he's a great person. He does a lot\n               for the community. Would the House make him feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752162","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would also like to welcome Brian from House of Q to the House. A few years ago,\n               way before I got into politics, CFOX, the radio show, used to have the drive-through\n               barbecues. I was always an avid listener of the CFOX show and a huge fan of Brian.\n               I actually have a lot of his rubs and barbecues at my house. I use them all the time.\n               He's","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f49a51d62347cbc149ea7705b36e89f7b3541a61a00230f497fac9f51e6349c3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68fa9b1deb33ca700c0c1ea0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752163,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the House we have Vinay Warich, who is a good friend and also happens to\n               be the constituency assistant for overlapping in my riding federal MP, Sukhman Gill.\n               Would the House make him feel welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752163","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the House we have Vinay Warich, who is a good friend and also happens to\n               be the constituency assistant for overlapping in my riding federal MP, Sukhman Gill.\n               Would the House make him feel welcome?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4f84aecfeaffa6c18998094","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017067,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to welcome today Joseph Latam to the House. Joe serves as my constituency\n               assistant, where he does excellent work supporting constituents, helping ensure that\n               people in our community are heard, assisted and served well. He is thoughtful, and\n               he is dedicated to public service and the future of this province. But he will unfortunately be leaving at the end of the summer. This fall, Joe will\n               be beginning his master of public policy at the University of Calgary — an impressive\n               achievement, and the next step in what I am certain will be a bright future. It's\n               always encouraging to see young, talented people continuing to commit themselves in\n               major studies and policy. Would the House really make Joe feel welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017067","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am pleased to welcome today Joseph Latam to the House. Joe serves as my constituency\n               assistant, where he does excellent work supporting constituents, helping ensure that\n               people in our community are heard, assisted and served well. He is thoughtful, and\n               he is dedicated to public service and the future of this province. But he will unfortunately be leav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98438a2400f6c090d2b595048f315b3bf74ea77c8b1156afec64268109996427"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbebbc1fa794665caa49397b9c0e04a13f748fc317e38bd18d2a48b6a030f99c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ed7f6e937d4989414331dcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017068,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to recognize Christine Alley, Carolyn Anderberg and Joel Black, from Enterprise\n               Rent-A-Car, who are visiting the Legislature today. While they're unable to join us\n               here in the gallery, I'll have the pleasure of meeting with them later today to discuss\n               Enterprise's work supporting transportation, tourism and communities across British\n               Columbia. Would the House please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017068","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm pleased to recognize Christine Alley, Carolyn Anderberg and Joel Black, from Enterprise\n               Rent-A-Car, who are visiting the Legislature today. While they're unable to join us\n               here in the gallery, I'll have the pleasure of meeting with them later today to discuss\n               Enterprise's work supporting transportation, tourism and communities across British\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc170be1c644ccac6a06c604a165dd637397bc3c8e580c28d792aac4d5bc28ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3ea66aea1b6c0364f98404e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036392,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I support this bill, and the reason why is that it came from the trucking industry.\n               I know","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036392","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I support this bill, and the reason why is that it came from the trucking industry.\n               I know","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94c19dde5342f15cbd448821016dacbaefd4774a93e27a0171009187a4677aa2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2901a78e5b9b0e804c7cf394","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036393,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know you've heard me speak a lot about my dad, but today my mom is in the House,\n               Jasvinder Bhangu. She's the reason why I'm here — all her sacrifices and everything.\n               Mom, I thank you very much. Also joining her is my wife, Courtney; my son, Bal Bhangu; and my daughter, Audriana. Me and my daughter, Audriana, had a great time\n               at the equestrian facility in my riding before we came over here yesterday. She loves\n               horses. Would the House really make her feel welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036393","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I know you've heard me speak a lot about my dad, but today my mom is in the House,\n               Jasvinder Bhangu. She's the reason why I'm here — all her sacrifices and everything.\n               Mom, I thank you very much. Also joining her is my wife, Courtney; my son, Bal Bhangu; and my daughter, Audriana. Me and my daughter, Audriana, had a great time\n               at the equestrian facility","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","label":"Commercial buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f7e99e5de149ded7feb56b876bf3ab2874012007b4a1070bb28db54522357c7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3f7a50e21e00679e83c185a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036394,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Once again, I have my family in the House. My daughter always gets a birthday shout-out,\n               but my son doesn't, having his birthday in July, so I just want to wish my son Bal\n               an early birthday. Once again, I want to introduce my mom, Jasvinder Bhangu. She is literally the reason\n               why I'm here, all her sacrifices. You see me working hard, staying up late, doing\n               all the work I do. I get that drive from my mom. She has truly been a pillar for my\n               family, especially when my father passed away — getting married and five months later\n               losing my dad. She has been there for me every step of the way. Would the House please make her feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036394","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Once again, I have my family in the House. My daughter always gets a birthday shout-out,\n               but my son doesn't, having his birthday in July, so I just want to wish my son Bal\n               an early birthday. Once again, I want to introduce my mom, Jasvinder Bhangu. She is literally the reason\n               why I'm here, all her sacrifices. You see me working hard, staying up late, do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c4e5d98b16f5c54f8662fab8a2e0e1fea4ab99dd89d936aa1aa469d0b2d1b16"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b54c5009abe9f01005749f939ab73d24ae4e809663b2e1c5413fc9c1a9530f0b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7dafbc328c9e951e0f88898f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036396,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to follow up on something from the transportation estimates. When we left that discussion, the Minister of Transportation made it that clear long-term\n               funding for TransLink is being worked on by the Ministry of Finance. That's why I'm\n               here asking today. Right now, there's been a short-term fix, but everyone knows there still needs to\n               be a real plan to pay for this going forward. That is supposed to be in place by 2027.\n               People want to know, especially with talk around a potential election later this year,\n               whether this is going to mean a road tax. My question  is: can the Minister outline what specific revenue tools are currently\n               under consideration by the Ministry of Finance to address TransLink long-term funding\n               requirements?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036396","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to follow up on something from the transportation estimates. When we left that discussion, the Minister of Transportation made it that clear long-term\n               funding for TransLink is being worked on by the Ministry of Finance. That's why I'm\n               here asking today. Right now, there's been a short-term fix, but everyone knows there still needs to\n               be a real pl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9a2b5cfddf9a5e1e7d426c315e2c54e2ce96c22be9eaf736a195816bcc959136"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b9eaa8f60434e7778a4476661d7004c88c1df5af6ef0129f0e5451723dcdb1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-32bfd0551a4858a81c62f468","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036397,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harman Bhangu","venue":"Hansard","text":"There are some hard-working young men in my riding right now that are training. They're\n               going to be doing two-a-days; football season is around the corner. The Langley Rams'\n               season will be starting in the Canadian Junior Football League, led by head coach\n               Kye Todhunter. And Dana Matheson has put together a really good program this year\n               — really good coaching staff. I want to wish them the best of luck in their upcoming season. I want to wish them the best of luck in their upcoming season.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036397","member_id":"bc-mla-379","member_name":"Harman Bhangu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There are some hard-working young men in my riding right now that are training. They're\n               going to be doing two-a-days; football season is around the corner. The Langley Rams'\n               season will be starting in the Canadian Junior Football League, led by head coach\n               Kye Todhunter. And Dana Matheson has put together a really good program this year\n               — ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48e0516684992f31396eaa1152dd3cb85b1c1e62f6f4d63e6209f0c0992fef98"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3407477cb94f41419eec0caa9441bd1b0428bfd9420225ca7f6014984f2c91c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aba68e17b58fee3e3bf35e49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317141,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"To the Minister of Finance, how many political staff are currently in her office?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317141","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"To the Minister of Finance, how many political staff are currently in her office?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb3830961dc016388da958a467db0139bbc1f16314d11b0571d6b88e15f1b21c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f745499e2e3b0c7c9fe1871","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317142,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Premier's office is being sued by a former executive director of international\n               relations, John Pratt. Now, the hiring of Mr. Pratt probably highlights the exact\n               reason why the Merit Commissioner needs to exist. He had been previously terminated\n               from his job with the federal government under suspicion of leaking sensitive materials. My question to the Premier is a direct one. Did the Premier know when he hired him\n               that this person was under investigation, or did he not even do the proper due diligence\n               of a background check?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317142","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"The Premier's office is being sued by a former executive director of international\n               relations, John Pratt. Now, the hiring of Mr. Pratt probably highlights the exact\n               reason why the Merit Commissioner needs to exist. He had been previously terminated\n               from his job with the federal government under suspicion of leaking sensitive materials. My question to th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["79c4999d6ee8856e85e63226e53fc32efa6a9d46b441a36de24c9e1299b1a7f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef0024abfc3f5901fe0ee4e522d420de37c6188cc4af6761defd9b794ccc45d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c07c3876e908221b8d9af6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317143,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"With great honour and great privilege, today I take my spot to rise to respond to\n               the budget. Before I do that.... Obviously, the last two weeks in our province, or a few weeks,\n               have been like no other, in a very unimaginable way. They have transformed our province\n               in a very unimaginable way. Obviously, I'm referencing what happened in Tumbler Ridge. The remarks that were made in this House today by my colleague, I think, are vitally\n               important. But more important than that, the actions shown by my colleague and by\n               other colleagues that are in this House, whether it's the Premier, whether it's the\n               Solicitor General, whether it's the Leader of the Third Party.... I want to thank them\n               for the work that they've put in, for putting the community on their shoulders at\n               an unprecedented time. It's an experience that I hope we never go through together, but the unification was\n               something I think we can take hope in. The fact that we actually got to bear witness\n               to a Prime Minister and a leader of the opposition, federally, that I saw working\n               together to help a father who had lost a child and help him find a way forward. That's\n               an image that will stick with me forever. We've canvassed some very serious issues in this House today and the days prior, and\n               I think none of those issues are more important than mental health and the supports.\n               I represent a riding that I can drive within about five minutes. There are some ridings\n               in this House that are bigger geographically than the country of Denmark. But those\n               ridings matter. They're vitally important. My riding in Surrey and other members' ridings in Vancouver are lacking supports when\n               it comes to mental health. Severe supports. Now, can you imagine what my colleagues,\n               and on both sides of the House, are experiencing in those lacks of services. I had one parent that I met with when I was up north that said they had to drive their\n               child 51⁄2 hours for their psychiatric appointments that they had to do once a week,\n               that they were wait-listed for. Five and a half hours they drive to get those appointments\n               in Prince George, but they do it because they understand how critical that is to their\n               child and as a parent. We've heard stories here where emergency room shut down in rural communities, where\n               a parent has to put their child in the back of a car and drive hours to just access\n               basic health care. Never in this province has health care been in such dire shape. It's not as a result\n               of the health care workers that are working every day on our front lines and doing\n               their level best — we know that — but it is the failure of this government, the failure\n               of this government's leadership where they cannot protect our basic access to health\n               care. No matter where you live — no matter if it's in Surrey, Vancouver, Prince George,\n               Kitimat No matter where you live — no matter if it's in Surrey, Vancouver, Prince George,\n               Kitimat, Fort St. John — it doesn't matter. Our health care system has crumbled, and\n               this government knows that. But what they don't know is that the public are suffering\n               every day, languishing in hallway beds not for hours but for days. That's their record. I represent a riding that is predominantly seniors. I'm proud of that. Our province\n               was built on those people. They're our volunteers. They're the ones that show up every\n               single day. I don't think any budget in the history of this province has shortchanged\n               seniors more than this one. Targeting basic cable. Most seniors have basic cable. Most seniors have a land line.\n               But to try and balance the incompetence of fiscal management on our most vulnerable\n               citizens.... That, to me, is an absolute embarrassment, and this government should be\n               ashamed of itself by trying to get away with it. You would think that with a record deficit level.... The fact is that I think we actually\n               spend $24 million a day on servicing that. You would think that with all the government\n               credit cards maxed out, our services would be at an impeccable level. Every government\n               service is producing some of the worst results that we've ever seen in this province's\n               history — full stop. Whether it's health care and the wait times, the emergency room\n               shutdowns, the fact that the maternity ward at Peace Arch Hospital....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317143","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"With great honour and great privilege, today I take my spot to rise to respond to\n               the budget. Before I do that.... Obviously, the last two weeks in our province, or a few weeks,\n               have been like no other, in a very unimaginable way. They have transformed our province\n               in a very unimaginable way. Obviously, I'm referencing what happened in Tumbler Ridge. Th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4f877f783bae39033f8cda04c09b01c5e7ed7c2b163136737898632f1c5b32b0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd364158ba12ca2b38bd1b5a3a268094ff7d5f9219985e0f58a5be06429f972b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f03408e1603301f42e94528","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327976,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here's part of the problem that lies within the minister's answer. He says: \"Take\n               it up with the federal government.\" We will, but the problem is that nobody is taking\n               anything up with the provincial government because they are so inadequate in terms\n               of response on such an important issue. This is ludicrous. On such an important issue, we are to believe in 12 days that nobody from the provincial\n               government was briefed, was talked to — phone call, email, nothing. We're supposed\n               to believe that they found out about it just like everybody else did, just like we\n               find out right now that the province is in negotiations with Cowichan. No statement, no nothing. What do we get?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327976","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Here's part of the problem that lies within the minister's answer. He says: \"Take\n               it up with the federal government.\" We will, but the problem is that nobody is taking\n               anything up with the provincial government because they are so inadequate in terms\n               of response on such an important issue. This is ludicrous. On such an important issue, we are to believe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic sanctions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43023","label":"Economic sanctions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5d78da6cd03c0eb82b1f5546872a8de4ba1b54ed905f68b6061941c5ede30a04"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59130ef3e219fcb3c31d50ccfbd9fd8dcaa79cb050c0edc4fa67e79e37c40a3a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4d7eb61ddef2456830e41d72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327977,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the Premier for his words and how poignant they were. As we walk through the halls of this building, we are surrounded by portraits that\n               remind us of the people and the moments that shaped both our province and our country.\n               Just downstairs on the first floor of the rotunda, there is a copy of the Canadian\n               Bill of Rights. It isn't just a historical document. It's a promise — a promise of\n               freedom of religion, freedom of speech, freedom of thought, freedom of debate. These\n               are rights we can take for granted in this country, but for those who live under tyranny\n               and oppression, these rights are not taken for granted. Right now they are dreams and they are aspirations. Freedom. Liberty. Justice. These\n               have been aspirations of humans around this world for thousands of years. Nearly 3,000 years ago, Cyrus the great enshrined a vision of universal freedom in\n               the Cyrus cylinder in what is often referred to as the first Charter of Human Rights.\n               He declared that all people should live free from oppression, that displaced communities\n               could return home, that religions would be respected and that dignity belonged to\n               every human being. For decades, Iranians have lived under a regime that has answered dissent with oppression,\n               violence and enforced silence. This weekend, that leadership of that regime was removed\n               and we are grateful for that. Across the world and here in British Columbia, people took to the streets to celebrate\n               the death of a leadership regime that had brutalized its own people and that had exported\n               its tyranny and terror around the world. As Iranians call for help, let me be clear. We are concerned about the escalation\n               of conflict. War is beyond tragic. History has shown us that and our present continues\n               to prove the devastation of war. But I don't think this moment is about the pursuit of war. It's about the pursuit\n               of freedom. It's about the people reclaiming their future. It's about pursuing freedom\n               for generations. Each time they rose up, they were trampled by tyranny. This time,\n               it's estimated over 30,000 people were murdered by the regime as they sought to shut\n               down protests. I attended the global day of action for Iran with the MLA for West Vancouver–Capilano and I want to thank her for the work that she's done to bring awareness to this global\n               issue, along with members from the other side of the House. Alongside an estimated\n               50,000 British Columbians who rallied for peace, for justice and human rights for\n               the Iranian people. It is startling to think that nearly the same number of people\n               that attended this rally have been killed by their own government. Today we recognize their courage, their resilience. We celebrate their hope, their\n               inspiration. For when a people rise and fight for their freedoms, it reminds us all\n               the rights we hold dear in this country. And I ask all members of this House to reflect\n               on the fact that we all have constituents that are hurting right now, that are scared,\n               that can't reach family members. And we cannot take that angst and that fear lightly. [Farsi was spoken.]","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327977","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to thank the Premier for his words and how poignant they were. As we walk through the halls of this building, we are surrounded by portraits that\n               remind us of the people and the moments that shaped both our province and our country.\n               Just downstairs on the first floor of the rotunda, there is a copy of the Canadian\n               Bill of Rights. It isn't just a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76542d306968a7654a1b08bcbe3ad2377ccaf904d3a12a376dfa3cb8fb328b3e","5fa2e35ad29cf12fddfec0e49368c1165a423ae055b74186586bafd7aa5c9526"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ed7984ff37c914244f90f2d7919c00b97b1a3f676ee960bbaa78842c972bea7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4166a9d41fd0010658a293e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327978,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Another day we learn more and another day the NDP's credibility is less. Let's be\n               clear. This government has a problem with the truth — a big one. On Monday, the Premier said, and I quote: \"To be absolutely clear, I received no briefings\n               about the content of this agreement, no heads-up from the federal government.\" He\n               doubled down again and again and again. Then we find out that the Premier was not\n               only invited to the signing ceremony with xwməθkwəy̓əm; he attended. He sat in the front row. Then we find out yesterday.... The federal minister says, and I quote: \"The federal\n               government did brief the provincial government, and it was a number of weeks ago.\" I have a very simple yet difficult question to this Premier, and I hope.... Well, I\n               know that the public is owed an answer. Is this government so incompetent on one of its most important files, or is this Premier\n               or this minister knowingly deceiving the public?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327978","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Another day we learn more and another day the NDP's credibility is less. Let's be\n               clear. This government has a problem with the truth — a big one. On Monday, the Premier said, and I quote: \"To be absolutely clear, I received no briefings\n               about the content of this agreement, no heads-up from the federal government.\" He\n               doubled down again and again and ag","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec96e65f80e57d1173f4e41dd5ee83d996d78684a281fbdfec6bde5b1718d3e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2f93d5290e6320e80af33ef6b7d53e8ab026183b3007e3e1851e9b4f3bb15f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca5f81c0a95fa57cc4ae9764","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360161,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd be remiss if I didn't highlight that in my office, Melissa McCaskill is in the House today, so I want to thank Melissa for all the work she does in Surrey–White Rock and here as well. I ask the House, please welcome Melissa.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360161","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd be remiss if I didn't highlight that in my office, Melissa McCaskill is in the House today, so I want to thank Melissa for all the work she does in Surrey–White Rock and here as well. I ask the House, please welcome Melissa.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42692","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sales taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42692","label":"Sales taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2db29fab0454a2c0456a5b1c50dc8b246303573281ddae2b2dea5eaf2929c3e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f37f545978bc2d84d46047a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360162,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a special day for me anytime I can welcome my family in the House — no stranger\n               to the House, Holly Halford. I want to introduce a family friend, Kayla Huber, and somebody that will be maybe\n               running this House one day but probably has bigger aspirations, my daughter, Alexandra\n               Halford. We're celebrating Francophonie Day in British Columbia. I want to welcome all of the\n               members of the House to the celebration in the noon hour. It's going to be fantastic.\n               Yes, I'll be speaking, but there will be things that you'll really want to see in\n               addition to that I'd say. Francophone communities play a huge role in British Columbia, as everybody knows,\n               and we're honoured to have a number of special guests with us today in the Legislature. Raphaël Dang, consul general de France à Vancouver, who is a very, very distinguished\n               and thoughtful individual. I hope members will have the opportunity to meet him. Marie-Nicole Dubois, pré sidente de la Fédération des francophones de la Colombie-Britannique — t he opportunity to meet Marie-Nicole this morning. Christiane Leclerc, présidente de la Fédération des parents francophones de la Colombie-Britannique. Marie-Andrée Asselin, ancienne directrice généra le de la Fédération des parents francophones de la Colombie-Britannique , accompagnée par son fils William . Jean-Benoît Deschamps, procureur administratif de la couronne , responsable des poursuites bilingues; h e works for the Attorney General. Julie Fafard, attachée à la Francophonie pour l 'ouest Canada et les territoires, antenne du Qu é bec à Calgary. We want to thank all of our guests here today and welcome you for our lunchtime celebrations,\n               especially you, hon. Speaker. I'd like all of us to wish our francophone guests welcome on this extraordinary —\n               extraordinaire, quand même — day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360162","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's a special day for me anytime I can welcome my family in the House — no stranger\n               to the House, Holly Halford. I want to introduce a family friend, Kayla Huber, and somebody that will be maybe\n               running this House one day but probably has bigger aspirations, my daughter, Alexandra\n               Halford. We're celebrating Francophonie Day in British Columbia. I want ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","label":"Mortgage insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716749","label":"Vaccines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["349799a43d9957a1b26db11466f5cc7c84de948eff92b3b8d25c949633511d21","9fdabd3d2f3a612d3d41ee31d1b4a6dd06cc1bb36c562b4ddb64945b737eae3b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0b891c7748eb7802ac94087547d62a30a5114c7f0d4a3429cd43bd925a017cf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e321c546c2d9d5e44c1d94d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360163,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank those that spoke before me in this House, on either side of the House. You know, I think this is an important conversation, but I want to preface this by\n               saying that I hope it's an important conversation for the right reasons. I really,\n               really do. I hope it's an important conversation with the right intentions. The members\n               on every side or wherever they sit in this House — I think they understand what I'm\n               saying by that. Human rights need to be supported. I support human rights — full stop. And if anybody\n               wants to challenge me on that record, they can go right ahead. And yes, on first reading,\n               since taking on as interim leader, I have said we were going to do a different path,\n               and we're going to be consistent about that path. Just like today. Members voted yes\n               on first reading until a division was called, then they changed their minds. That's\n               their prerogative to do. It's up to them, and that's their right in this House. But\n               they all voted yes until a division vote was called. We all need to protect against discrimination. We all need to protect against hate. You know, I've got a special audience today, and it's one that I take dearly, and\n               it's one every time I get up in this House and speak.... My daughter is here in the\n               gallery right now, and in some of this stuff she's well more versed than I am. And\n               when I come and I speak in this House, on this platform, I have her in my mind consistently,\n               in creating or helping create a world that shapes a safe place for her to grow up\n               in. It's important. I support a human rights code that protects vulnerable people and upholds human dignity.\n               Supporting human rights does not mean we must give any institution, whether it's the\n               Human Rights Commission or anyone, unlimited deference or treat any decision beyond\n               review — full stop. Let me be clear. This House can support human rights while still asking whether the\n               current system is balanced, fair, timely, respectful of fundamental freedoms. That\n               doesn't make you a racist. It doesn't make you a bigot. It doesn't make you any of\n               those things. And if you say different, that is incredibly lazy. I can say that this motion is drafted in ways that ask members to not only support\n               the human rights code. It also asks the Legislature to affirm unequivocal support\n               for the tribunal's powers as they currently exercise. That is a very different question,\n               and it's an important one. Now, I want to go back to the fact of what I just said. We are not here to rubber-stamp\n               any institutions — full stop. We are here to do important work. And I want to ask\n               everybody in this House: in the last couple weeks, have we been doing that important\n               work? Have we? Are we debating DRIPA legislation today? We're not. We're talking about human rights,\n               which is important, and human rights needs to be talked about in this House, outside\n               of this House, in the classrooms, on the streets, in coffee shops, at the dinner table.\n               Those are important conversations. That needs to happen. Those are important conversations. That needs to happen. But I will say this. This\n               House gets weaponized politically, and it's lazy. It is very, very lazy. And you know\n               what? Thankfully, I think the public sees through it now. I do. I'm not going to get\n               into polling numbers or anything like that, but I think they get it. I will gladly sit here and take my time and talk about human rights, and anybody else\n               that wants to get up, I encourage them to do so. Because it's an important conversation. But you know what else is an important conversation? I want to talk to my colleague\n               who got up from Langley-Willowbrook, somebody who has faced racism from the day she was born, and she talked about that\n               today. I know there are other members of this House that have faced that prejudice\n               as well. We need to call it out every single time. Every time. If they think that's\n               going to be done on a first reading, then I don't get that. What I will say is that consistency matters. Where was this debate for Selina Robinson?\n               We didn't get a chance to do it, because it was shut down every single time by this\n               government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360163","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to thank those that spoke before me in this House, on either side of the House. You know, I think this is an important conversation, but I want to preface this by\n               saying that I hope it's an important conversation for the right reasons. I really,\n               really do. I hope it's an important conversation with the right intentions. The members\n               on every side ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2758f27a080b656952002cd0c800e35dd22d105c2492cc06c639f0b75de49cd8","33b44e7c794cf5f7cccb1c944264ad1da20e7a95c53c62ad18fef2dd91358113"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c7924a8f03fd98955b9f5bdbde95aad17d50895ed41d17abb00a4a009ebe9d59"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-923fb8d9b964c77e81c9265e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415732,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I wasn't planning on getting up, but I feel the need to now. If this wasn't so serious,\n               it would be comical. The fact is that you've got a government that has overseen one\n               of the worst deficits in the history of this province at a time when British Columbians\n               are struggling to gain employment, when we have rapid exodus out of this province.\n               We're talking about a Merit Commissioner that is focused on making sure that there\n               is integrity and transparency when it comes to hiring in this province. I've heard other members throughout the opposition speeches. They've got comments,\n               which they are more than entitled to. I would challenge them to stand up with their\n               microphone on and speak on this motion. It's not that hard. They've got the time.\n               They've got the space. They're here. Why aren't they getting up in this House and\n               providing remarks and standing up against this? In fact, they're sitting there, and they're taking their comments. But they will not\n               put their comments on record. You know what? I don't blame them because they are embarrassing,\n               absolutely embarrassing. It's absolutely shameful that they would not support a motion\n               like this. What have we got? Let's talk about what this government does with friends and insiders. Jim Sinclair oversaw one of the worst times at the Fraser Health Authority. What was\n               Jim Sinclair's background in health care? Can anybody tell me? Zero, zero. And what\n               did he oversee? He oversaw emergency room closures. He saw maternity ward closures,\n               cost overruns, rapid exodus of front-line workers, all because this government, this\n               Premier, that Health Minister, that cabinet, those backbenchers thought that it was\n               better, in the interests of the public, to put their friends and insiders at high-level\n               positions, other than people that could capably do the job. I disagree. That is wrong. That's why we're standing up for this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415732","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I wasn't planning on getting up, but I feel the need to now. If this wasn't so serious,\n               it would be comical. The fact is that you've got a government that has overseen one\n               of the worst deficits in the history of this province at a time when British Columbians\n               are struggling to gain employment, when we have rapid exodus out of this province.\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a26fa116b2a8460d1bdd8a7c65fc9f1f6ec192c8bad5207a4a4ad5772ccc13e","3c5b4b4d7f6be4d145420461c93829780df35e425912fea3ab9327f91bb728b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0dbf7167da68a0deae685dfc840dacdf6d378d246c6021489e79d9faf228dcb5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4c078716a343ac386fa6e09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415733,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Another day, another example of how this government is allergic to transparency. We\n               have been promised by this Premier, by this government, for months that they would\n               deal in this House regarding DRIPA, that this Premier would make it a priority and\n               he would table amendments that would give British Columbians the certainty that they\n               deserve when it comes to some of the challenges that we are seeing in our province\n               today. What do we get from the Premier today? Absolutely nothing. In fact, we are actually\n               seeing some of the language regarding these changes, these amendments, in the media\n               that are now leaking out. Imagine that. Legislators in this room right here are actually\n               seeing legislation before, not under NDAs, which a bunch of people are already under\n               doing.... But we're actually learning about them from the media. This has completely been bundled from the Premier from day one. My question to him today. Where are the amendments? What's his plan? How is he going\n               to deal with it? How is he going to fix this mess that he created?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415733","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Another day, another example of how this government is allergic to transparency. We\n               have been promised by this Premier, by this government, for months that they would\n               deal in this House regarding DRIPA, that this Premier would make it a priority and\n               he would table amendments that would give British Columbians the certainty that they\n               deser","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","label":"Mortgage insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aa41f7b7365dc5c6d02f52f942cf41488ad6f6a674379cf4517d134e095cb34f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f944cfa4834875784e786a3393dbd6363b107fed86560bbcd8254e427c7a4d88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e567479618716788d274722f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415734,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let me just read into the record some of this correspondence that my colleagues received\n               from the mayor of Richmond and council. \"For months, residents and business owners\n               in Richmond have expressed concern over the uncertainty about private property title\n               as a result of the Supreme Court of B.C. decision pronounced in August 2025.\" Here's part of the problem. When legitimate questions are raised in this House, outside\n               of this House, and unfortunately this government, this Premier, this minister, multiple\n               ministers, don't have answers, their only answer is fearmongering. That is what they\n               fall back on, because they've got nothing else to say. That should scare every British\n               Columbian, and we're seeing that today. We are talking about uncertainty for property right owners, and that's just not my\n               opinion, because depending on what day the Premier wakes up, it might be his. Because\n               he will say: \"We will go to the wall for property right owners. We will actually go\n               as far.... We will backstop mortgages.\" That's what the Premier of this province is\n               prepared to do. But then it changes. Private property rights are never in question is what he'll say\n               in one room. Mr. Speaker, it is April 1. The public is waiting. The province is waiting. This Legislature\n               is waiting. First Nations are waiting. Where oh where are these amendments, and when\n               will this Premier, when will this government get on with it and actually do what the\n               public is expecting them to do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415734","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let me just read into the record some of this correspondence that my colleagues received\n               from the mayor of Richmond and council. \"For months, residents and business owners\n               in Richmond have expressed concern over the uncertainty about private property title\n               as a result of the Supreme Court of B.C. decision pronounced in August 2025.\" Here's part of the p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56655","label":"Mortgage insurance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c63d596730e8954e3c18330ca4f895360217a4e1e10eacd768fe6fb7991387ea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b3e9f7f65a821dfd9b305ed45e4e9c1d3ba6c10a62927c0d5444a6cb2af50b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7379b3b3d6df612cd199aadd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720339,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"In December 2025, the Premier says: \"A court decision creates a legal crisis requiring\n               immediate action.\" I want to stress the word \"immediate.\" April 1 of this year, the\n               Premier says: \"Amendments are non-negotiable.\" Non-negotiable. \"We have to get these\n               through.\" He said that three times. He also said: \"We are working with the chiefs to find a path forward.\" He also said: \"We are working with the Chiefs to find a path forward. We have to do\n               it, and we will do it.\" Then he says on April 2: \"Changing British Columbia's declaration\n               of the rights of Aboriginal People's act is non-negotiable — non-negotiable — and\n               it will be pushed into law.\" That's what the Premier said on Wednesday, April 2, 2026. Another word the Premier used multiple times was the word \"confidence\". I want to\n               stress that word, the word \"confidence\". I think it's important because it's very\n               clear that this Premier no longer has the confidence of members of this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720339","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In December 2025, the Premier says: \"A court decision creates a legal crisis requiring\n               immediate action.\" I want to stress the word \"immediate.\" April 1 of this year, the\n               Premier says: \"Amendments are non-negotiable.\" Non-negotiable. \"We have to get these\n               through.\" He said that three times. He also said: \"We are working with the chiefs to find a path fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e8b85f3673ab4f414f5c1bfd4c5b73488bfe84bc077a1a2362ad2b92711177a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d88fa9d3a9d7793521a69d186334f948cb7e93316109890aa540a123a166ed2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-461f61bfba0ce63135a8f550","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720340,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Another day, another contract extension for the government's friends and insiders.\n               Today we learned that Penny Ballem, who's actually billed taxpayers for over $2 million\n               in the past five years, has just received another contract extension for $180,000\n               to provide strategic advice on health care to government. Imagine that. You would think that nearly a $200,000 contract would be full-time. Not according\n               to this government. Her contract work is part-time. Imagine that, finding a part-time\n               job for $180,000 in this climate. Ms. Ballem was originally contracted due to a review of the health authorities. An\n               extension of her contract signals that review will not be completed any time soon. My question is simple. Why are the taxpayers being billed $180,000 for part-time advice\n               from Ms. Ballem when this government still has nothing to show for her work already?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720340","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Another day, another contract extension for the government's friends and insiders.\n               Today we learned that Penny Ballem, who's actually billed taxpayers for over $2 million\n               in the past five years, has just received another contract extension for $180,000\n               to provide strategic advice on health care to government. Imagine that. You would think that nearly a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c86ee595713f5a72688c9aec47549600be29afff6f7ea582eb356a91a0f72ec9","3cc3e464bdcc8262addfda7b4f286c146f466a9a1e88a5173761c52361bfd773"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a826c5c6e1e11a49fec551d0da3dc9a420c6235d5d7749e08492d28c8b3a574a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4d45dfec6ce4762e909001c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721438,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"It has been 136 days since this government and since this Premier said that DRIPA\n               must be amended. The Premier said back in December: \"We will fix this.\" The Premier\n               said he would go to the wall. The Premier even said he will go as far as backstopping\n               mortgages. Three weeks ago, what did the Premier say? The Premier said: \"We have to do it, and\n               we will do it.\" Another quote three weeks ago: \"Yes, we are going to get these amendments\n               through. We have to.\" Here is another one, and this one I think is actually the most important thing that\n               the Premier said over the last three weeks in his multiple statements: \"Significant\n               legal liabilities for the province.\" Then he said: \"More than 20 cases before the courts that could all have significant\n               ramifications.\" So here we are, and again, the Premier has changed his position. Again he has added\n               more chaos to an already chaotic situation. So here we are, and again, the Premier has changed his position. Again he has added\n               more chaos to an already chaotic situation. But he was the architect of this chaos.\n               Let's be clear on that. But now he has put the province in a position of co-governance. I want to know directly from the Premier at what point in this process, in the chaos\n               that he caused, did he decide that it was okay to abdicate the responsibility of the\n               province and start in co-governance?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721438","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It has been 136 days since this government and since this Premier said that DRIPA\n               must be amended. The Premier said back in December: \"We will fix this.\" The Premier\n               said he would go to the wall. The Premier even said he will go as far as backstopping\n               mortgages. Three weeks ago, what did the Premier say? The Premier said: \"We have to do it, and\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4617d99e4160b7b6f61e32f0d20ae012220d46d6b67cc089dd46d3bf4e82105"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd74560529affd5ca5233c2e027bce44e61bc861d633a7d0f67ae063f12e47a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4c74f4b7f429343b1e1e1b9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721443,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know a lot has been debated in the past couple of days, but I just\n               want to say, from our caucus and probably everybody in this House, and the fact that\n               we just had a vote — I am not sure how this vote happened, but it did happen — to\n               see the member from Vancouver-Strathcona on that screen, it's nothing short of an\n               inspiration that she shows up and does that work. I just want to let her know that we are thinking about her, but I want to thank her\n               for all that she has done. It is inspiring to see her on that screen. [Applause.]","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721443","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know a lot has been debated in the past couple of days, but I just\n               want to say, from our caucus and probably everybody in this House, and the fact that\n               we just had a vote — I am not sure how this vote happened, but it did happen — to\n               see the member from Vancouver-Strathcona on that screen, it's nothing short of an\n               inspirati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e7b90e38e81f2479cb5e40217ae43cebfe18bf057e64451a80c33d33c14aa2a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc14b6c690481553a4a83ea5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721446,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move a bill intituled Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Repeal Act, of which notice has been given in my name on the order of paper, be introduced and\n               read a first time now. I rise to introduce a bill to repeal the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples\n               Act because when this bill was passed in 2019, British Columbians were given a series\n               of promises. We were told it would not cast doubt on private property. It has. We\n               were told it would not create a veto over development. It has. We were told it would\n               never be used to strike down laws passed by this House. It most definitely has, including\n               the Mineral Tenure Act, throwing an entire sector into chaos and putting thousands\n               of jobs at risk. We haven't entered into reconciliation. We've entered into co-governance now, and\n               the Premier knows that. It's not my word. It's his. The Premier has said that this\n               presents significant legal risk. He said: \"It must be fixed as quickly as possible.\"\n               He called the amendments that he was going to put forward \"urgent.\" He called them\n               \"non-negotiable.\" He told this province that 20 court cases have already been amended\n               to cite the Gitxaała decision and that every one of those cases puts other B.C. laws at risk. Those are his words,\n               not mine. They have been telling British Columbians that they have frustrations, that he would\n               act decisively. He has changed his position again and again — amend it, suspend it,\n               delay it. More uncertainty. The solution is simple. We need to protect the legal liability that this Premier and\n               this Attorney General have clearly outlined, and I believe that this bill will do\n               that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721446","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move a bill intituled Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Repeal Act, of which notice has been given in my name on the order of paper, be introduced and\n               read a first time now. I rise to introduce a bill to repeal the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples\n               Act because when this bill was passed in 2019, British Columbians were given a series\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["052b9fc8a19bf2f4648cb4e794dd5355b77b65478f40b8900d70b4ca875fd24f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79241b3fb8ec13830df604a516dff500eb26e763bcf9a7c4b82efcd277b538ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03844da4dad81ba36ce6373c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729121,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the Premier for his words. It was one year ago in Vancouver. Eleven members of our community went to a street\n               festival to celebrate and did not come home. They were celebrating Lapu-Lapu Day,\n               a day to celebrate the Filipino heritage, resilience and community. Within seconds,\n               it became one of the darkest days of our history. I was there that morning. I was there with a number of my colleagues. What I do remember\n               is seeing the Premier there as well, because I think the Premier brought his little\n               girl to that event that morning, if I'm correct. It was nice to see that, but what\n               unfolded after was absolute tragedy. We pause to remember that, across this province, the families and communities gathered\n               to mark this tragedy. But for the families and survivors of this senseless act, they\n               live with that grief every single day. And that is why we speak their names again.\n               We say Maria Victoria Bjarnason, Jenifer Darbellay, Rizza Pagkanlungan, Kira Salim,\n               Jendhel May Sico, Glitza Daniela Samper and her parents Glitza Maria and Daniel Samper To the survivors and to the first responders, I can't imagine what they are going\n               through , with more than 30 injured and some still recovering. We think about the\n               pain that they endure every news cycle, where they have to relive the tragedy; the\n               bystanders, who so bravely apprehended the driver; the paramedics, the nurses, the\n               doctors, not only at Vancouver General Hospital but at hospitals throughout the Lower\n               Mainland. In the midst of that, we saw heroics. We saw the MLA for Vancouver-Kensington step up in a way that all members of this House are so grateful and so proud, and\n               continue to be proud, of the leadership that this MLA has shown for that community\n               and continues to show. Thank you for that. To the Filipino community who have suffered so much in the wake of this tragedy, a\n               lot of them came to Canada to build lives of dignity and have contributed immensely.\n               They have done so much. They have filled our hospitals, our classrooms, every walk\n               of life in British Columbia, with kindness. In the years since, they have grieved\n               with grace and refused to let hatred define their community. They have been an example\n               to us all. I want to say to the survivors, we're with you. To the people that lost their lives,\n               we remember you. To an entire community that will continue to grieve for generations,\n               we grieve with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729121","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank the Premier for his words. It was one year ago in Vancouver. Eleven members of our community went to a street\n               festival to celebrate and did not come home. They were celebrating Lapu-Lapu Day,\n               a day to celebrate the Filipino heritage, resilience and community. Within seconds,\n               it became one of the darkest days of our history. I was there t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["52bdb27af7fdc9c5ae3cfb3ad5fdb0fe5372bfde7352670eb5063d918a681be4","3232ff280af4d159a0746ec1b10f6a86cce79b67f276d3bcdc0c9139b4956ba9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4ddbc645a5612d276e79cb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729122,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Now I'm going to feel really bad about question period in about 20 minutes. No, I want to thank the members for that. I want to welcome, obviously, my mum to the House. It's always great to see mum. Lunch\n               will be on me, not her, but I don't mind that at all. Welcome, Judy. It's great to see you here today as well. I did actually want to quickly introduce the Canadian Finance and Leasing Association,\n               who's in the House today. Michael Roth, Hugh Swandal, Mike Rush and Marcel Bjorkler, I want to say welcome to\n               the House to you today. Happy to hear you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729122","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Now I'm going to feel really bad about question period in about 20 minutes. No, I want to thank the members for that. I want to welcome, obviously, my mum to the House. It's always great to see mum. Lunch\n               will be on me, not her, but I don't mind that at all. Welcome, Judy. It's great to see you here today as well. I did actually want to quickly introduce the Canadian Finance and Lea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3b6ff3631ea745befc575ab7260abc7ce4bfe11b093cf251e992f1cf041fb9e","27ce85fe3b1a1d555d7bf829be77991ee032d0636fb5f26360cf19077aa7e824"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e7a507cbf8b85020fa2e24a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729129,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"The premier-to-be said to pull out the red mittens, and let's just say this. I remember\n               in 2010, and I remember what a great time that Olympics was. Right? I remember in\n               2010. I also remember that in 2010, it was the now Premier of the province that was\n               following around protesters and criminals, passing out his business card to make sure\n               they got free legal advice. That was what the Premier was doing in 2010. We are 45 days out from inviting the world. The government is right on that. But what\n               they haven't been clear on is how they're going to execute that. What they haven't\n               been clear on is how much it's going to cost to keep British Columbians safe at a\n               time when this government can't even do that on its best day. What they haven't disclosed is who on that side is getting a ticket. They won't talk\n               about that. They say plans are coming in the coming weeks. The games will be here\n               in the coming weeks. My question to the minister.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729129","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The premier-to-be said to pull out the red mittens, and let's just say this. I remember\n               in 2010, and I remember what a great time that Olympics was. Right? I remember in\n               2010. I also remember that in 2010, it was the now Premier of the province that was\n               following around protesters and criminals, passing out his business card to make sure\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a3d7cf82ea5b9bf7021b61fcc2b303ef95a074e5dc83e164280ab59c5d25a0de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ffaccbd86b45a5bf952d8a702e5a9e55456482b6658db05576d63a44cc0e5a54"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22c5726998ac37b07c158568","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752244,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752244","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037025","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036197","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036197","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marine heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marine safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036197","label":"Marine heritage","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036199","label":"Marine safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037025","label":"Salt water","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00716350399d9509e559750a53e960a10a40a602a5df0e71ac3a74303e6479b4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cb85817651f269e3e7c9f97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752245,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"How bad has it gotten under this NDP government's recent decision to enter into co-governance\n               and failure to address DRIPA? Well, now the Eskay Creek project that has, as the Premier\n               says, potential to bring over 1,000 jobs into northwest B.C. is facing court action.\n               The Premier says that the mine is good for all British Columbians. He, in fact, brags\n               about this project every time he's standing at a podium. But here's the problem. While this government flip-flops on DRIPA, an Alaskan-based\n               tribal organization is using the exact same legislation that this Premier brought\n               in, once in 2019 and then with the Interpretation Act in 2020, to stop the project. Can the AG confirm that the legislation to address DRIPA will be brought in this fall,\n               yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752245","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"How bad has it gotten under this NDP government's recent decision to enter into co-governance\n               and failure to address DRIPA? Well, now the Eskay Creek project that has, as the Premier\n               says, potential to bring over 1,000 jobs into northwest B.C. is facing court action.\n               The Premier says that the mine is good for all British Columbians. He, in fact, brags\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8266f942b5c72f3e5a24204b9b4e7a7204f6477d3d32658e0c457f8a943ed6a2","569eb770be6480f56a2cebc2c79a5a0356718aa0eab430ad4c819cd72080f2a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f20ec97a3a64fa08f9088f88612a4b61faaaf4e4234e105a9e96c135695a286"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ad669b4a963035ffac26350","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752246,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday the former mayor of Vancouver, former NDP MP Kennedy Stewart, made some\n               startling accusations. He said: \"It's come to my attention that I've reported it,\n               and, in fact, was interviewed","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752246","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday the former mayor of Vancouver, former NDP MP Kennedy Stewart, made some\n               startling accusations. He said: \"It's come to my attention that I've reported it,\n               and, in fact, was interviewed","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9607a75c5a21bdf05e1fd89f72e159baafe9fbccb55b073c911ee0a5af0f77bd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecadc03c0a25141552450e7a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752247,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank my colleague for his remarks on Bill 9 and his comments that went\n               with it. Listen. It's going to be no secret. Obviously, I'm in opposition to Bill 9. I think\n               that it's a shortsighted piece of legislation that continues to set us back when it\n               comes to the importance of freedom of information. We have been in cases before where this government has completely failed to uphold\n               the FOI system. In that structure, when you look at what FOI is intended to do, it\n               is intended to actually give us the ability to seek information that is coming into\n               government. I think one of the challenges that we have is that this is a system that has been\n               basically overrun by political will. When you see things like the fee increases that\n               have come into effect, the frustration of the system, in fact, they're doing that\n               in different ways to circumvent the reality of actually providing British Columbians\n               with information that they are, basically, entitled to. There are certain elements of this bill that I think are incredibly troubling. When\n               you talk about the proactive release of personal information, yes, 60 percent of requests\n               are for one's own records. Streamlining that is fine on paper, but when the government\n               bundles it with centralized Connected Services B.C., a single gateway, that actually\n               means the data across the ministries. The minister has the power to dictate the data\n               standards, and we should all pause and take note of that. I think that that's massively\n               important there. I want to put forward a motion here that's a hoist motion. It says: that the motion for second reading of Bill 9, entitled the Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, be amended by deleting the word \"now\"\n               and substituting \"six months hence.\" Do you want to take a brief recess while we distribute?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752247","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to thank my colleague for his remarks on Bill 9 and his comments that went\n               with it. Listen. It's going to be no secret. Obviously, I'm in opposition to Bill 9. I think\n               that it's a shortsighted piece of legislation that continues to set us back when it\n               comes to the importance of freedom of information. We have been in cases before where this gover","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["972b34452571dc1bfc1a493d9a092faa18190b0b086f7d2cb85a1cebdeb9c175"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["339c3ee04fcb1f20e677e6f0322eaa6b134bdec5cbc126ff40155999bf7eb716"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4456cff2d11baa0096e22f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752248,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752248","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44186","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Blindness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44186","label":"Blindness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4533f146ae652c5203ed6b8e21c8db9ce99349abd15b174099ed6de634a00854"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5255fa1a5beb115e885685af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752249,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"We are joined by three of Lord Tweedsmuir's finest alumni. We've got Marie MacDonald,\n               who's here today; Darlene Hawkins; and somebody near and dear to my heart, my mom,\n               Patti Halford. They have joined us all the way from White Rock today. I ask that the House please make them all very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752249","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We are joined by three of Lord Tweedsmuir's finest alumni. We've got Marie MacDonald,\n               who's here today; Darlene Hawkins; and somebody near and dear to my heart, my mom,\n               Patti Halford. They have joined us all the way from White Rock today. I ask that the House please make them all very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["881c7e82a04dbaecd367fa7ea4a20cee292819b784aa4801d25eb5ddb6db1935"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c9443aa985024ff7f127b9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017350,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"On June 2, Surrey will gather to honour its inaugural Surrey Sports Hall of Fame class.\n               This is a pretty special moment for Surrey. It's a pretty special moment for those\n               being inducted and for their families. In your life, you're lucky to have people in it that are, I would say, larger than\n               life. For me, that has always been my uncle Terry — Terry Bailey, who is also known\n               in our family as Coach. Terry grew up in Surrey. He has never left Surrey. He has\n               been a lifelong Cloverdale and Ocean Park resident. He started his football career\n               at Lord Tweedsmuir, and went on to be a standout with the Surrey Rams. Then he played for SFU. Actually, at SFU, he's got his name on a plaque of NAIA champion\n               runner-up to Walter Payton in the 1970s. It was so cool to see my uncle with his name\n               next to Walter Payton on a plaque. From there, he went on to a great career with the\n               B.C. Lions, and then he returned back to coach SFU. Terry has been a hero to me and to my family, growing up. He has always been that\n               figure to have somebody to look up to, to actually call almost a second dad. I know\n               that the family is so proud of him, whether it's my aunt Jane, sons Brynn and Sean....\n               I know his family, his mom and dad, Jerry and Delsa, are looking down on him, as are\n               Maji and Baba. We are so proud that he is in the inaugural class of the Surrey Sports Hall of Fame,\n               and I wish him and all those being inducted on June 2 all the best. Congratulations,\n               Terry, and all those who will be getting their names on those plaques.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017350","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On June 2, Surrey will gather to honour its inaugural Surrey Sports Hall of Fame class.\n               This is a pretty special moment for Surrey. It's a pretty special moment for those\n               being inducted and for their families. In your life, you're lucky to have people in it that are, I would say, larger than\n               life. For me, that has always been my uncle Terry — Terry Bail","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be7827b651c017b7f040a5afc1f60be15d050301003f875efba02d268d6f49fb","d633e8c80168394bf0872d38acc8a6cb7814d8e6c219329ab7b77386528eeaaf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccf5af740c0acd026a9b6f1e0b71d2ccd81180a5a66a036d9ecce7335710c414"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-99c58f3bcf1c2871a578ac91","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017352,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is always good to see current or former Elgin Park alumni, fellow graduate, in\n               the House, fellow Orca. I knew her as Cecily Frost. I think we went to Crescent Park\n               Elementary, and then we went to Elgin Park Secondary. She had to suffer me for a number\n               of years. It's great to see Cecily Frost, now Cecily Lawrence, in the House today. I ask that\n               you please make her welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017352","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is always good to see current or former Elgin Park alumni, fellow graduate, in\n               the House, fellow Orca. I knew her as Cecily Frost. I think we went to Crescent Park\n               Elementary, and then we went to Elgin Park Secondary. She had to suffer me for a number\n               of years. It's great to see Cecily Frost, now Cecily Lawrence, in the House today. I ask that\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74a489e6557b0fbe7219361481d0598424110a1f1aee93a32d17269fc49c574e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e6e2816b7c49b04f8ea5d5d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017359,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday I asked two very direct questions to the Attorney General, and I want to\n               follow up on that again today. We are days away from the end of this legislative session, a session in which the\n               Premier got up and said that we would have legislation to deal with the fallout from\n               DRIPA. This minister has said yesterday.... She touted, in her mind, the benefits that\n               they've seen from DRIPA, albeit while they're in court dealing with the fallout from\n               DRIPA. I am somewhat skeptical that this House will be back in the fall to deal with DRIPA.\n               So my question is very specific to the Attorney General. Will she have legislation\n               ready to go for the fall session that will deal with DRIPA, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017359","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday I asked two very direct questions to the Attorney General, and I want to\n               follow up on that again today. We are days away from the end of this legislative session, a session in which the\n               Premier got up and said that we would have legislation to deal with the fallout from\n               DRIPA. This minister has said yesterday.... She touted, in her mind, the b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["004fbf61aa53d0218e40773c474d9cfdeeb7af1e9e8d8a8ca0019bba007829d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6fab3da3185cebe5b71538046f4953a52bbc43717445c303a008cb98d1c0bad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f715bbcc0e7b4435487a891c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036487,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"May 19, the Minister of Housing decided to send a letter to the mayor of Vancouver\n               on an issue before them, and we learned that the mayor of Vancouver quickly fired\n               off his own letter back to the minister. He says: \"It reads like an eleventh-hour attempt to intervene in an active Vancouver\n               city council debate on energy choice and affordability.\" He goes on to say: \"You are\n               advocating that the Vancouver council not pass a motion that would improve housing\n               affordability and energy choices for residents.\" What's interesting about the letter that was sent out by the Minister of Housing is\n               neither the Ministry of Energy nor the Premier were copied on it. My question is a direct one to either the Premier or the Minister of Energy. Did they\n               know about this correspondence and direction from the Minister of Housing to the city\n               of Vancouver?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036487","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"May 19, the Minister of Housing decided to send a letter to the mayor of Vancouver\n               on an issue before them, and we learned that the mayor of Vancouver quickly fired\n               off his own letter back to the minister. He says: \"It reads like an eleventh-hour attempt to intervene in an active Vancouver\n               city council debate on energy choice and affordability.\" He goes","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4fed1df0ec91551beb7185af56f56b792e505b55625b307e563ff35eabea2e72"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58d231a8caae3497fe42d6828e23580bb4b2cc39d4cc3ea401cfd7e9533fabcd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d1133a7f9b2c3df26bae3a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036488,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we wrap up spring session, my colleague just alluded to it, but we have been joined\n               and we have been supported by some fantastic interns. They're here with us today,\n               and I'd like to highlight them. We have Zofka Svec, Massimo Calabrese, Priya Minhas, Annika Clark and Emmanuel Adegboyega. Thank you for everything that you've been doing. They've been writing speeches, they've been helping with everything, estimate questions,\n               communications, research — all of it. They have been, really, the Swiss Army knife\n               of our caucus over the last session. I want to say thank you, and I look forward to.... You guys can pick out your desks\n               now because I'm sure that you will They've been writing speeches. They've been helping with everything — estimate questions,\n               communications, research, all of it. They have been really the Swiss army knife of\n               our caucus over the last session, so I want to say thank you, and I look forward to.... You guys can pick out your desks now, because I'm sure that you will be back here\n               in different fashion in the not too near future. So thank you for all you guys did. It was a joy to work with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036488","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As we wrap up spring session, my colleague just alluded to it, but we have been joined\n               and we have been supported by some fantastic interns. They're here with us today,\n               and I'd like to highlight them. We have Zofka Svec, Massimo Calabrese, Priya Minhas, Annika Clark and Emmanuel Adegboyega. Thank you for everything that you've been doing. They've been writing speeches","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Hygiene","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watercourses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Multilateral programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43830","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Abortion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036345","label":"Multilateral programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036981","label":"Watercourses","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:423203","label":"Hygiene","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43830","label":"Abortion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62647d22a845af1a6ab02ae2ebc31160382267a2e51624942aad7f20c445c6f3","12d846b20008289cf41d2f6bd7ebfe166b51558e978579b344401383cc73097c","7d6e064ed911a95dbc44cce91c23df0a924def20edbe2b231496f2d2d6d24e8f","75d3e60624a3926bb2a510078f48367c4967474437e670ba35a5e49f15d37685","8037833ce03e0ccb0a6b72be655a65c196f8d955c57de2829d9f9be9ac436d62","92834a0a0897e536eda11650d99a5c59adac4ffdf075cf501bea29b6f45f936d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e2a8b7f996695a4d90ecca6d3362c4c54b66920743df9e435c914189b6e37a6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8769440a3f65c662559b7568","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036489,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today, we have some very special guests that I want to single out. First is the press secretary to the Conservative Party of B.C., somebody who is very\n               familiar in this hallway and has, I'm sure, many big things ahead of her. That is\n               Francesca Guetchev. So Francesca, thank you for joining us here today. Also, our Director of Communications Jarret Coels, is in the House today. And our esteemed.... Somebody who has stepped in and done exemplary work, my Chief of\n               Staff Allie Blades. Allie is in the gallery today, I want to thank you. My colleagues My colleague did mention it. We have some very special guests from the party today.\n               Somebody who has been a backbone of this party and I'm proud to, even more than that,\n               call him a friend, and that's Angelo Isidorou. Philip Ditnier is here, as well, and\n               Jackie Prokopenko is here, and I want to thank them for being here with us today. Sometime in the next few minutes, we will be graced by the presence of probably one\n               of my biggest critics, but one of my best friends — and she'll be horrified to hear\n               that — my daughter, somebody who I'm immensely proud of, somebody who may be in this\n               House one day, and that is Alexandra Halford. I ask the House, please make them all welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036489","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery today, we have some very special guests that I want to single out. First is the press secretary to the Conservative Party of B.C., somebody who is very\n               familiar in this hallway and has, I'm sure, many big things ahead of her. That is\n               Francesca Guetchev. So Francesca, thank you for joining us here today. Also, our Director of Communications Jarret Coels,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bea500686cbf6fa786f9c42dfcc221a6502039080591042b488f82040b8676ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30b164be87133667fe051d87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036490,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Trevor Halford","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank my colleague for those kind words of remembrance. I think it was 1989, and I was sitting in the living room with my brother, and we\n               were watching as Hulk Hogan was getting devastated and taking chair shot after chair\n               shot, and we were completely upset and dismayed. What made it worse is that my dad walked into the living room as this was happening\n               and said, \"What is my buddy John doing on TV?\" And we all froze. What he meant was\n               that.... We know him as the man they call Earthquake. He was ending the career and,\n               I thought, life of Hulk Hogan as we saw it. That was my dad's childhood friend from\n               Lord Tweedsmuir, John Tanta, who he played rugby with and grew up with. John has since passed away a number of years ago but he will be taking his rightful\n               place in the Surrey Sports Hall of Fame on June 2. He was a standout rugby player\n               in Lord Tweedsmuir Secondary School in Cloverdale. He actually.... A remarkable life. After that, he actually became a sumo champion in Japan, and then he went into wrestling\n               as Earthquake and had many standout matches. I had the opportunity to meet John \"Earthquake\"\n               Tenta on a few occasions. My dad took me to a wrestling match, where he lost — because,\n               I think, Mr. Fuji threw something in his eyes, and he was disqualified. He was a good man. He was a proud British Columbian. He was a proud resident of Surrey.\n               We lost him at a young age. I believe it was bladder cancer. I just want to congratulate him and his family on this well-deserved recognition,\n               that he'll be taking his rightful place as an inaugural member of the Surrey Sports\n               Hall of Fame on June 2. Congratulations to the Tenta family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036490","member_id":"bc-mla-38","member_name":"Trevor Halford","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to thank my colleague for those kind words of remembrance. I think it was 1989, and I was sitting in the living room with my brother, and we\n               were watching as Hulk Hogan was getting devastated and taking chair shot after chair\n               shot, and we were completely upset and dismayed. What made it worse is that my dad walked into the living room as this was happening\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44242","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Earthquakes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44242","label":"Earthquakes","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a842c9c2501505bede241314ff35d66dc4465bcc04e1ec29ab441bf245b29a7","7f813214d5d1dbf770f5715d303f4b024c0f1e13c0a159144c362ad52be244b2","5d8bc1ba9edef2c0da84f3a2cb508f456c9a9203cd2849c919d9c349cd76e647","3fca589990c8cb7fbaa34212f377bfb3cd107ce6fcb177f3480ce8c17286764f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e5305f7773092168efb98a172a043221e81fdcd663c6a682665341ebb1456bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1de8dfe1a199eb243d8fa8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317220,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's not just long-term care on the chopping block with this budget. With ER wait\n               times over 12 hours at surrounding hospitals, the government has labelled the Burnaby\n               Hospital phase 2 project \"TBC\" — to be confirmed, to be continued, to be cancelled.\n               If you don't build the hospital, you don't have to worry about keeping it open. Due to this government's fiscal mismanagement, the urgently needed Burnaby Hospital\n               redevelopment, phase 2, and B.C. Cancer Centre has been delayed indefinitely. Why\n               doesn't this Minister of Infrastructure stand up for patients in B.C. and demand that\n               this project get reinstated and give us a date? Why doesn't this Minister of Infrastructure stand up for patients in B.C. and demand\n               that this project get reinstated and give us a date?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317220","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It's not just long-term care on the chopping block with this budget. With ER wait\n               times over 12 hours at surrounding hospitals, the government has labelled the Burnaby\n               Hospital phase 2 project \"TBC\" — to be confirmed, to be continued, to be cancelled.\n               If you don't build the hospital, you don't have to worry about keeping it open. Due to this government'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab316bf2adc8860c3504992a34d473949fb37a1b4ae243a2139cc79a191b7e51"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82f696ab3160d14948d7a1b3efceeb7d1db8c6f39eaf7252f75fd27a61e01d98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a89214c645e8330ce0caf28a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317221,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the House today we have four members from the B.C. Care Providers Association. They are doing important work of advocacy and are the leading voice of B.C.'s seniors\n               living, wellness and care sector. Today we have Lara Croll, Marc Kinna, Tiffany Trownson\n               and Langley legend Mary Polak here in the chamber. Will you please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317221","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"In the House today we have four members from the B.C. Care Providers Association. They are doing important work of advocacy and are the leading voice of B.C.'s seniors\n               living, wellness and care sector. Today we have Lara Croll, Marc Kinna, Tiffany Trownson\n               and Langley legend Mary Polak here in the chamber. Will you please make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02e85263bbf87c0d013ba7cb60c18779496dea46c1e15c109363f9b94dd71518"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ff4f0b73cb7cf8f33a19302","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328066,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"All of the long-term-care facilities that have been cancelled are in non-NDP ridings.\n               All of them. One project not cancelled nor started yet is the Richmond long-term care\n               in the Minister of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness riding, while Abbotsford\n               and Delta were stopped after millions of dollars were invested. Could the Minister of Infrastructure please justify her lack of equitable access to\n               long-term care for seniors in Fraser Health, or does a senior need to vote for the\n               NDP to get a bed to sleep in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328066","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"All of the long-term-care facilities that have been cancelled are in non-NDP ridings.\n               All of them. One project not cancelled nor started yet is the Richmond long-term care\n               in the Minister of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness riding, while Abbotsford\n               and Delta were stopped after millions of dollars were invested. Could the Minister of Infrastruc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0cbd3e44459e39e86dfa0587bb4f591a573f7e8df7719a0504ff9b6b8c24426"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["39046c484b90cd709730ff1a31a3f9ab6e29532ed83d329b482a435c27099478"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ccb39baec3799e537b555f42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328067,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Two of my favourite women in my life are in the House today. My CAs are Leda, who has been introduced here before, and new in my office is","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328067","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Two of my favourite women in my life are in the House today. My CAs are Leda, who has been introduced here before, and new in my office is","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e828fc87a2e93029991be6e7c361316cf3d3ad0eaef66d45232999f79698d9e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd4cfdf7c50186567f0d5306","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328068,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the House today, we have Dan Baxter from the Progressive Contractors Association.\n               With him also is Ryan Bruce from CLAC. Two strong voices in the construction industry\n               advocating on behalf of the contractors and skilled workers who build the infrastructure\n               and communities of our province. I want to thank them for all the hard work that they\n               do. Will the House make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328068","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the House today, we have Dan Baxter from the Progressive Contractors Association.\n               With him also is Ryan Bruce from CLAC. Two strong voices in the construction industry\n               advocating on behalf of the contractors and skilled workers who build the infrastructure\n               and communities of our province. I want to thank them for all the hard work that they\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd4ce8d7bb6512f5afb5ad8af7a10d7d6d71ebd36db1beb446ddbd3e20013ae8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3776f4f47432a394cfc5c9bc7dabb4b802bc5cb927bd9b46d054cbcfc69c44e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86e9602ed5a82c6cb2b0d360","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361202,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome back to the chair. I'm pleased to rise in the House today to speak at second reading of Bill 10, the\n               Labour Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. This legislation proposes a series of amendments\n               to both the Employment Standards Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act. On its face, the bill appears procedural and technical in nature. Indeed, several\n               of the clauses are described by the government itself as housekeeping amendments. However, in this House, it is our responsibility to examine even technical changes\n               carefully because changes to process often shape our outcomes. The provisions in Bill\n               10 primarily alter how complaints are investigated, how disputes are resolved and\n               how appeals are handled under British Columbia's employment standards regime. These are not trivial matters. The framework that governs employment disputes affects\n               workers, employers, our small businesses and the overall climate for investment in\n               job creation in this province. We must evaluate this bill through several key principles: fairness; accountability;\n               efficiency in government administration; and the protection of economic competitiveness\n               for employers, while maintaining basic protections for workers. Bill 10 introduces several major procedural changes. First, it revises the complaint,\n               intake and investigation process Bill 10 introduces several major procedural changes. First, it revises the complaint\n               intake and investigation process under the Employment Standards Act. Section 76 is\n               replaced with a more detailed framework governing when the director must accept a\n               complaint and when the director may refuse or discontinue an investigation. Second, the bill creates a formal complaint resolution process during investigations,\n               allowing the director to require parties to participate in a resolution process before\n               determination is issued. Third, the bill allows the director to prepare a written investigative report prior\n               to issuing a determination, giving parties the opportunity to respond. Fourth, the bill introduces a deposit requirement for appeals, where a determination\n               requires payment of wages or money. The employer must deposit the amount owing or\n               an amount the tribunal considers adequate before the appeal proceeds. Finally, parallel changes are applied to the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act,\n               particularly regarding appeals of determinations and deposit requirements. At first, these changes may seem administrative, but they reshape the balance between\n               workers, employers and the enforcement authority of the state. There are some elements of this bill that you can understand why these changes are\n               proposed. It allows for a greater screening of complaints. The revised section 76\n               provides clearer authority for the director to refuse or stop investigating complaints\n               that are frivolous, fictitious or lacking evidence. Government enforcement agencies\n               must focus their limited resources on legitimate cases, not waste time and taxpayer\n               dollars pursuing complaints that are clearly unsupported or made in bad faith. Small businesses in particular often lack the legal resources to defend themselves\n               against prolonged investigations triggered by weak complaints. Even if a complaint\n               is eventually dismissed, the process itself can impose heavy administrative costs\n               and reputational damage. By clarifying the director's discretion to stop investigations\n               where there is insufficient evidence or lack of participation by the complainant,\n               this bill could help ensure that enforcement resources are directed where they are\n               most needed. That is fairly common sense. This bill also encourages early resolution of disputes. Under the new section, 76.1,\n               the director may require both parties to participate in a resolution process and specify\n               how they must participate. Encouraging dispute resolution before formal determinations are made has some advantages.\n               First, it can lead to faster outcomes for workers seeking unpaid wages. Second, it\n               can reduce litigation costs for employers. Third, it can reduce the backlog within\n               the employment standards branch. In many labour disputes, the parties are not actually far apart. Miscommunication,\n               documentation errors or misunderstandings about statutory obligations are common.\n               Facilitated resolution can correct these problems quickly. There is also improved transparency through investigative reports. Bill 10 allows\n               the director to prepare and serve a written report before issuing a determination,\n               giving the parties an opportunity to respond. This step introduces an element of procedural\n               fairness. By allowing the parties to review the findings of an investigation before\n               a final determination is made, the process can become more transparent. Parties may\n               identify factual errors, provide additional documentation or clarify misunderstandings. From a rule of law perspective, this is a good improvement. Administrative decision-making\n               should not occur behind closed doors. Another provision is the deposit requirement Another provision is the deposit requirement for appeals. If a determination requires\n               payment to employees, the party appealing must deposit the amount ordered or a lesser\n               amount deemed adequate by the tribunal. That provision, for me, opens up the conversation about what is fair, and I do struggle\n               with that piece of this bill. But this reform addresses a long-standing problem. There are some bad actors out there that have abused the system. In some\n               cases, employers have filed appeals primarily to delay payment of wages. Workers who\n               have already gone through a lengthy investigation process then face months or even\n               years of additional delays. Requiring a deposit discourages frivolous or strategic\n               appeals and ensures that funds are available if the determination is upheld. For workers who rely on timely payment of wages, this is an important safeguard. My concern is just that it could be arbitrarily left to the tribunal, in terms of\n               the amount that is held back. Or deposited, sorry. While the bill contains some steps forward, it also raises several concerns that deserve\n               serious consideration. It expands bureaucratic discretion. One of the most significant issues is the expansion\n               of discretionary authority granted to the director. The new framework allows a director\n               to refuse to investigate a complaint, stop an investigation, broaden the scope of\n               an investigation to other employees, require participation in a resolution process\n               and determine whether complaints are sufficiently resolved. While discretion is sometimes necessary, excessive discretion risks inconsistent decision-making.\n               Small businesses and workers alike need predictable rules, not a system where outcomes\n               depend heavily on administrative interpretation. When government officials hold broad\n               discretionary powers without clear guidelines, the result can be uneven enforcement\n               across cases or even regions. The rule of law requires clear standards, not open-ended administrative authority. There's also risk of mandatory mediation becoming coercive. The new complaint resolution process also raises a potential concern. The director\n               can require parties to participate and specify how they must participate. In principle,\n               dispute resolution is positive, but when participation becomes mandatory and directed\n               by the same authority responsible for the investigation, the process could become\n               coercive rather than voluntary. A worker may feel pressured to settle for less than\n               they are entitled to. Conversely, a small business may feel compelled to settle simply to end a costly investigation. Effective mediation works best when it is voluntary and neutral. We should be careful\n               not to create a system where the administrative authority effectively pressures parties\n               towards settlement, simply to reduce its own caseload. And every government agency\n               seems to be under heavy caseloads right now. The appeal deposit requirement, while addressing frivolous appeals, also raises concerns\n               for small businesses facing legitimate disputes. Not all employers appealing a determination\n               are acting in bad faith. In fact, most small businesses are acting in a way that treats\n               workers with respect. Sometimes determinations are based on incomplete evidence or misunderstandings of\n               employment arrangements, particularly in industries with complex compensation structures\n               such as agriculture, hospitality or construction. For a small business operating Even though the tribunal may reduce the required deposit amount, this discretion again\n               creates uncertainty. We believe in accountability but also in ensuring that appeal\n               rights remain meaningful and accessible. Justice should not depend on the size of\n               one's bank account. Another provision allows a director to broaden an investigation if the complaint may\n               relate to other employees. On the one hand, this could uncover systemic violations\n               and protect vulnerable workers. But on the other hand, it may transform a single complaint\n               into a wide-ranging workplace investigation, significantly increasing regulatory burdens\n               on businesses. To put it in different terms, one small claim by one worker could open\n               a can of worms that ties up the one worker's rights to compensation. Small businesses already struggle with regulatory complexity. Expanding investigations\n               beyond the initial complaint could increase administrative demands, legal costs and\n               uncertainty for employers who believed they were addressing a single issue. If such\n               authority is used excessively, it could discourage entrepreneurship and investment\n               in the province. Finally, while Bill 10 modifies enforcement procedures, it does not address deeper\n               issues in the employment standards system. For years, employers and workers alike\n               have raised concerns about long complaint processing times, inconsistent enforcement,\n               limited education and compliance support for small businesses. Procedural amendments\n               alone will not solve these systemic challenges. We should be trying to prevent disputes\n               before they occur through clearer guidance, better compliance tools and faster administrative\n               processes. From a business perspective, the bill has mixed implications. Positive aspects include\n               stronger filtering of weak complaints and increased opportunities for early dispute\n               resolution. However, businesses may face greater regulatory exposure through expanded\n               investigations and mandatory dispute processes. For small businesses, which form the backbone of British Columbia and the economy,\n               predictability and simplicity in labour regulation are essential. One of my closest\n               and dearest friend's small business recently closed. The economic situation made a\n               very good, once thriving business become undone in these times. When we have bills that come through that could increase financial burden through\n               situations that may have arisen from misunderstandings in contracts and otherwise,\n               it just further really impacts a community. The loss of this business was a huge hit\n               in my community. It was kind of that death by a thousand cuts. I look at bills that affect small businesses through a slightly different, more personal\n               lens now, taking my friend's situation and trying to see how this may or may not have\n               affected that business. There are some things in here that are trying to fix a situation, but there are still\n               some things that could have unintended consequences. At a time when our province faces\n               economic challenges, labour policy should support At a time when our province faces economic challenges, labour policies should support\n               and not hinder the ability of businesses to create jobs, especially jobs that, in\n               my past, were the part-time jobs that I held outside of my career as a single mom,\n               keeping food on the table for my kids. But workers also stand to gain certain benefits from this legislation. Faster dispute\n               resolution, stronger protections against delayed appeals and the potential for broader\n               investigations into systemic violations could improve enforcement of employment standards.\n               For vulnerable workers, including temporary foreign workers, these protections are\n               particularly important. Quite frankly, in Langley, we have a lot of temporary foreign workers, a lot of agricultural\n               workers, a lot of migrant workers from Mexico, the same faces that I see come back\n               on routine contracts and go back to their home in the off-season. However, there is also a risk that mandatory resolution processes could pressure workers\n               into accepting settlements below their legal entitlements. Ensuring fairness requires\n               safeguards to ensure workers understand their rights and are not disadvantaged during\n               negotiations. Ultimately, the challenge in labour policy is achieving the right balance. Workers\n               deserve protection against wage theft and exploitation. At the same time, employers\n               deserve a regulatory system that is clear, efficient and fair. When labour policy\n               becomes overly bureaucratic or unpredictable, it discourages job creation and undermines\n               economic growth. Conversely, when enforcement is too weak, bad actors can exploit\n               workers and undercut responsible employers. The goal must be balanced regulation that\n               protects workers while supporting economic vitality. In conclusion, Bill 10 represents a series of procedural reforms to the enforcement\n               of employment standards in British Columbia. It contains several positive elements,\n               like stronger screening of weak complaints, expanded opportunities for early dispute\n               resolution, greater transparency investigations and measures to discourage frivolous\n               appeals. But at the same time, this bill raises important concerns: expanded administrative\n               discretion; potential coercion in mandatory resolution processes; financial barriers\n               to legitimate appeals; and increased regulatory exposure for small businesses, the\n               backbone of B.C.'s economy. The ultimate question is whether these amendments improve fairness while maintaining\n               a predictable and efficient regulatory environment. Some are clearly moving in the\n               right direction. Others require careful scrutiny to ensure that they do not unintentionally\n               increase bureaucracy or undermine the rights of either workers or employers. Second reading is the appropriate stage to examine the principles of this bill. It is our responsibility not simply to pass legislation but to ensure that it strengthens\n               the institutions that support both fair workplaces and a thriving economy in British\n               Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361202","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome back to the chair. I'm pleased to rise in the House today to speak at second reading of Bill 10, the\n               Labour Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. This legislation proposes a series of amendments\n               to both the Employment Standards Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act. On its face, the bill appears procedural and technical in nature. I","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["acfc89918901f9e69a47f5e4162a8fb12152b879db559a6401512494d0a64635"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8574ee6e47905bb9ce5be46710d7b27718c08b9c73faf0adb49ffe85bfe2bdcd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2afbe54b189afcc63297c2eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415844,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"At its core, Motion 203 is about one simple but essential concept: fairness. It's\n               about ensuring that public service hiring and promotions are based on ability, qualifications\n               and performance, not on personal or political connections. For over two decades, the Office of the Merit Commissioner has acted as a critical\n               safeguard of that fairness, providing independent review, accountability and transparency\n               in how government hires and promotes its employees. The merit principle is not a partisan\n               idea. It is a cornerstone of good governance and professional public service. But\n               under recent changes, this government is taking a deeply concerning step, eliminating\n               the independent Office of the Merit Commissioner. They call it a cost-saving measure, yet the entire annual budget of that office is\n               just $1.7 million, less than a rounding error in this government's finances. In reality,\n               what's being eliminated is independent accountability. The very oversight that ensures\n               hiring in government is not subject to favouritism or political interference will\n               now move under the Minister of Finance In reality, what's being eliminated is independent accountability. The very oversight\n               that ensures hiring in government is not subject to favouritism or political interference\n               will now move under the Minister of Finance — the same executive authority it is meant\n               to be independent from. Let's be clear, shifting this oversight inside government means government will now\n               oversee itself. That's not accountability. That's the opposite. The data speaks volumes. Since the Premier has been in office, the Merit Commissioner\n               has found \"merit not applied\" in 10 percent of all job appointments reviewed, the\n               highest level in nearly a decade. As the commissioner has said: \"The cost of losing\n               independent oversight may ultimately far exceed the savings from eliminating a small\n               oversight body.\" He also noted that the most recent audit: \"Found the highest rate of flawed hiring\n               processes and outcomes in nearly a decade.\" Those are not my words. They are the words\n               of the independent officer whose work this government is now cutting off. Other voices are raising the alarms too. The president of the BCGEU said bluntly:\n               \"They're overseeing themselves. It effectively eliminates the audit function.\" And\n               he's right. Without independent oversight, British Columbians can no longer have confidence\n               that hiring in their public service is based on merit. Let's remember, the Merit Commissioner's office was created in 2001, precisely to\n               separate merit-based hiring from politics. Interestingly, back then, the NDP opposed\n               the creation of the Merit Commissioner, with NDP members voting against it. Today\n               they are following through on that same instinct by abolishing it altogether. British Columbians expect better. They expect their public service to be non-partisan,\n               competent and fair. They expect jobs to be earned, not handed out. This motion is\n               not about questioning the professionalism of public servants. Quite the opposite.\n               It's about protecting their integrity. A strong, independent oversight system safeguards those who do their jobs honestly\n               and well. It ensures that every position, from the front desk to the executive office,\n               is filled by the best-qualified person. Public servants deserve assurance. The public\n               deserves that assurance. That's what builds trust. That's what makes government work\n               for everyone, not just those with political connections. By passing this motion, we affirm that merit must remain the guiding principle of\n               our public service and that its oversight must remain independent of government control.\n               Because once independence is gone, it is not easily restored. Once the public loses\n               trust in how their government hires and promotes, we all lose. I urge all members of this House, regardless of party, to stand for fairness, accountability\n               and public trust. Support this motion, keep merit-based hiring truly independent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415844","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"At its core, Motion 203 is about one simple but essential concept: fairness. It's\n               about ensuring that public service hiring and promotions are based on ability, qualifications\n               and performance, not on personal or political connections. For over two decades, the Office of the Merit Commissioner has acted as a critical\n               safeguard of that fairness, providing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["304e1f17f704d875de23983918b9dc734a714388cb31d5a9704cec00350a6a34"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df2dbe819631bc97ddbddf6d88177e43fa6f17b3c7d16f53dbd0283e16701cf5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-398a33b415221fcd6bc3f9e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415845,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Langley is the horse capital of B.C. but could soon be facing an identity crisis if\n               support to the equine industry further erodes. Like many young girls, I dreamt of\n               owning my own pony, and for a brief time, when I was ten, I had one gifted to me.\n               Her name, like mine, was Misty, and the two Mistys spent the summers of the 1980s\n               riding local rural roads and the great trails of Campbell Valley Park. Fast-forward 40 years, and Langley is one of the province's fastest-growing municipalities.\n               Where I once rode bareback down 16th Avenue is now an unofficial highway, and where\n               there were once small farmsteads, now subdivisions. Don't get me wrong, I'm a pragmatist that knows that change is a part of life. But\n               how we manage the pressures of densification and the protection of farmland is at\n               the centre of saving the culture of Langley. Recent changes have created a scenario\n               where it's more equitable to convert small farmsteads into multi-million-dollar parcels\n               instead of providing support to local But how we manage the pressures of densification and the protection of farmland is\n               at the centre of saving the culture of Langley. Recent changes have created a scenario\n               where it's more equitable to convert small farmsteads into multi-million-dollar parcels\n               instead of providing support to local governments and developers to focus on urbanized\n               locations. When times are tough for families to find fun and affordable things to do, low-barrier\n               tickets to a day of rodeo fun are a breath of fresh air, and the Valley West Stampede\n               has proven to be the organization to fill that gap in my community. With Thunderbird\n               Show Park's place on the world stage as a first-rate facility, it has been a collective\n               sigh of relief in its recent acquisition by the Matheson family, which has ensured\n               that it remains in local hands. Thank you for solidifying the future of equine culture of Langley. I know you have\n               big plans for the facility. We must support and balance today's pressures with our culture. We can build homes\n               and still protect the agricultural roots that define our communities, but that requires\n               an understanding of rural life, the value of local decision-making and a government\n               that sees agriculture not as an inconvenience but as a cornerstone of B.C.'s identity.\n               If we don't stand up now, we may see our cowboys and cowgirls riding off into the\n               sunset.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415845","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Langley is the horse capital of B.C. but could soon be facing an identity crisis if\n               support to the equine industry further erodes. Like many young girls, I dreamt of\n               owning my own pony, and for a brief time, when I was ten, I had one gifted to me.\n               Her name, like mine, was Misty, and the two Mistys spent the summers of the 1980s\n               riding loc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d77ddcebb438964851107003e443b6c7ffce762d2997e448c78cad2fc263754e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2acbe55cffd5dded1adc5e59341af354278f0598ce7551536762a95d5fa7e8b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d05ee034e88d29c0cbc0027","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415846,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the House today, we have members from the VRCA. We've got Chris Atchinson, Janine\n               Martin and Craig Larkin, who I hold a special place for, given that his podcast, The Builder's Bench , was the first podcast that I ever did. With them are the young construction leaders. There's a delegation of about, I believe,\n               two dozen. These are the up-and-comers in the construction industry. I'm looking super\n               forward to meeting with them later, as is our caucus. Will the House make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415846","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the House today, we have members from the VRCA. We've got Chris Atchinson, Janine\n               Martin and Craig Larkin, who I hold a special place for, given that his podcast, The Builder's Bench , was the first podcast that I ever did. With them are the young construction leaders. There's a delegation of about, I believe,\n               two dozen. These are the up-and-comers in the construct","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a2fab9c435c3d6bfedb3a02a64c62c96e323ca8a64ffafc1f178398074cf8690"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3bf55779c123cdc7ee7a5a868aa24bb3813a13c354c10503bea26e234c61009"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5600278d57ae6c26729db63f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415847,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am here today to speak to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, 2026,\n               a piece of legislation that at first glance seems responsive to the complex realities\n               of housing insecurity in our province. It is a bill that attempts to reconcile two\n               difficult truths: that housing systems must adapt to serve vulnerable populations\n               and that legal protections must remain firm, predictable and just. Yet as we examine this bill more closely, we find ourselves confronting a far more\n               complicated picture, one that demands not only cautious support in select areas but\n               also serious critique, scrutiny and, frankly, concern. Let me begin by acknowledging a few things. For too long, our legislative framework\n               has struggled to adequately account for supportive housing. The original Residential\n               Tenancy Act was built around traditional landlord-tenant models, one that assumes\n               independence, stability and relatively equal bargaining position between the parties. But supportive housing does not fit neatly into that framework. It involves individuals\n               who are often navigating homelessness, mental health challenges, addiction or systemic\n               marginalization. It involves operators who are not merely landlords but service providers,\n               caregivers and intermediaries between tenants and broader social supports. In this respect, Bill 11 performs an important function. It recognizes that supportive\n               housing is different. By formally defining supportive housing, supportive housing\n               rental units and housing stability support, the bill brings clarity where ambiguity\n               has long existed. It attempts to bring these arrangements into the legal fold rather\n               than leaving them in a grey zone of partial exemptions and inconsistent application.\n               That, in principle, is a positive step but has taken entirely too long to get here. Similarly, the bill's effort to retain certain outdated exemptions, particularly those\n               related to housing connected to health facilities, reflects a desire to ensure that\n               residents in those environments are not entirely outside the protections of tenancy\n               law. Moving from a model of total exclusion to one of conditional inclusion has the\n               potential to extend at least some degree of legal recognition to individuals who previously\n               had none. Yet this is where the bill's promise begins to unravel. What Bill 11 ultimately creates is not simply inclusion but stratification. It establishes,\n               in effect, a two-tier tenancy system, one for traditional renters and another for\n               those in supportive housing. And while differentiation in law is not inherently problematic,\n               the nature of that differentiation matters profoundly. In this case, the distinctions introduced by the bill overwhelmingly trend in one\n               direction, toward the dilution of tenant protections. Let us consider what that means\n               in practice. Under this bill, tenants in supportive housing may face reduced protections\n               in several key areas: entry into their units, access to their property, control over\n               their personal belongings, and even the stability of their tenancy agreements. Landlords redefined in this context to include supportive housing operators are granted\n               expanded authority, often through mechanisms that will be defined not in legislation\n               itself but in future regulations. And this brings us to one of the most troubling\n               aspects of the bill, the dramatic expansion of regulation-making power. Almost every piece of major legislation we've touched in the past year continues to\n               move important information into regulation where it doesn't get scrutinized. Traditionally,\n               core rights and obligations in tenancy law are set out clearly in statute. This ensures\n               transparency, predictability and democratic accountability. Changes to those rights\n               require legislative debate, public scrutiny and the consent of this assembly. Bill 11, however, shifts a significant portion of that authority away from the Legislature\n               and into the hands of the executive. It allows for the creation of rules governing\n               entry into rental units, restrictions on tenant access, seizure of personal property,\n               amendments to tenancy agreements, and even the circumstances under which tenants may\n               be evicted, all through regulation. This is not a minor procedural change. It is a\n               fundamental rebalancing of where power resides in our legal system. While flexibility is often cited as a justification for such shifts, and indeed there\n               are situations where flexibility is necessary, we must ask ourselves: flexibility\n               for whom and at what cost? For tenants, particularly those in supportive housing,\n               flexibility can translate into uncertainty. It can mean that the rules governing their\n               homes may change without the full weight of legislative oversight. It can mean that\n               protections they rely on today may be altered tomorrow, not through open debate but\n               through administrative decision-making. This is especially concerning, given the population that supportive housing is meant\n               to serve. These are not individuals with abundant resources, legal expertise or the\n               capacity to navigate complex and shifting regulatory landscapes. They are, by definition,\n               among the most vulnerable members of our society. Yet under this bill, Let us now talk about issues of tenant rates within supportive housing. The bill introduces\n               provisions that allow landlords to enter units under broader conditions than those\n               permitted under the original act. It enables restrictions on tenant access to residential\n               property. It creates the possibility of interfering with tenant property in ways that\n               were previously prohibited. Each of these changes may be defensible in isolation. One can imagine scenarios in\n               supportive housing where staff need to enter units more frequently, where safety concerns\n               necessitate restrictions on access or where intervention in a tenant's personal environment\n               is part of providing care. But the problem lies not in the existence of these powers;\n               it lies in the lack of clear enforceable limits on them. By leaving the specifics to regulation, the bill does not establish a firm baseline\n               of rights. Instead, it creates a framework in which those rights can be adjusted,\n               expanded or contracted over time. In doing so, it risks normalizing a lower standard\n               of tenancy protection for a specific class of residents. This raises a fundamental question. Should the level of legal protection one receives\n               in their home depend on their vulnerability? If anything, we might argue the opposite,\n               that those who are the most vulnerable should be afforded the strongest protection,\n               not the weakest. Another area I'd like to discuss is the expansion of eviction powers. Bill 11 introduces\n               new grounds for eviction, including provisions related to the possession or presence\n               of weapons. It broadens existing grounds by replacing specific references to landlords\n               and other occupants with a more expansive term, \"authorized person,\" which includes\n               a wide range of individuals. On the surface, these changes may appear reasonable. Safety is, after all, a legitimate\n               concern, particularly in shared or supportive housing environments. But we must be\n               careful with overreach. The introduction of weapon-related eviction grounds, for example, raises important\n               questions about proportionality and context. What constitutes a weapon? Under what\n               circumstances is its presence considered grounds for eviction? How will these provisions\n               be applied in practice, particularly in cases where individuals may possess items\n               for legitimate or non-threatening purposes? Similarly, the expansion of eviction grounds to include impacts on any authorized\n               person significantly broadens the scope of what may be considered disruptive or harmful\n               behaviour. This could lead to situations where tenants are evicted not for clear violations\n               of tenancy agreements but for conduct that is interpreted, perhaps subjectively, as\n               affecting a wide range of individuals. Again, the issue is not that these concerns\n               are invalid, but that the bill does not sufficiently constrain how they are addressed. It is also worth noting the changes to tenancy agreements themselves. Under the original\n               act, amendments to tenancy agreements generally require the consent of both parties.\n               This reflects a basic principle of contract law that agreements should not be altered\n               unilaterally. Bill 11 introduces exceptions to this principle, allowing for changes to standard\n               terms under certain conditions, particularly in supportive housing contexts. While\n               there may be practical reasons for this, such as the need to adapt agreements to evolving\n               support needs, it nonetheless represents a departure from While there may be practical reasons for this, such as the need to adapt agreements\n               to evolving support needs, it nonetheless represents a departure from foundational\n               legal norm. It shifts the balance of power further toward landlords and operators\n               and away from tenants. Finally, we must consider the broader philosophical implications of this bill. At\n               its core, tenancy law is about more than contracts and regulations. It is about homes.\n               It is about spaces in which people live, rest, recover and rebuild their lives. When\n               we create different standards for different types of housing, we are making a statement\n               about whose homes are entitled to what level of protection. Bill 11, intentionally or not, creates a hierarchy of housing rights. It suggests\n               that those in supportive housing, those who arguably need stability and security the\n               most, may receive a more conditional, more flexible and, ultimately, more precarious\n               form of tenancy. There are elements within this bill that are necessary, even overdue. The recognition\n               of supportive housing within the legal framework is one such element. The effort to\n               bring previously exempt housing into the scope of the act is another. The acknowledgement\n               that a one-size-fits-all approach to tenancy law may not be sufficient is in itself\n               a valuable insight. But support for these objectives does not require full acceptance of the bill in its\n               current form. If anything, it demands that we do better. It challenges us to ensure\n               that flexibility does not come at the expense of fairness, that efficiency does not\n               override dignity and that the needs of the system do not eclipse the rights of the\n               individual. At the same time, in that sense, this bill is not an end point. It is a beginning. We must ensure that the creation of a specialized framework for supportive housing\n               does not come at the expense of fundamental rights. We must ensure that flexibility\n               does not become a euphemism for reduced protection. We must ensure that the expansion\n               of regulatory power is accompanied by clear safeguards, transparency and accountability.\n               Above all, we must ensure that the people at the centre of this legislation, the tenants,\n               are not treated as an afterthought. A true measure of this bill will not be found in its definitions or in its clauses\n               but in its consequences. It will be found in how it shapes the daily lives of those\n               who depend on supportive housing. It will be found in whether it provides stability\n               or uncertainty, protection or vulnerability, dignity or diminishment. Let us proceed with caution. Let us amend where amendment is needed, and let us strengthen\n               where strength is lacking. Let us remember that in the pursuit of flexibility, we\n               must never lose sight of fairness.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415847","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am here today to speak to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, 2026,\n               a piece of legislation that at first glance seems responsive to the complex realities\n               of housing insecurity in our province. It is a bill that attempts to reconcile two\n               difficult truths: that housing systems must adapt to serve vulnerable populations\n               and tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7583443879e53a30aa755a89a2f5ab28bd4eb2b631043a909282917047c5647f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d6b3a3a759588ecc60d9702761681aa3e06c0dc981f00a63f5799dba97d87cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63dec85f5fdd35656e6df2a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720665,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I, too, want to make recognition of the fire and BCPFFA here today, but today I'd\n               also like to recognize in the chamber.... I am honoured to introduce Christina Austin\n               and Lynn Austin, the widow and mother of the late Neil Austin. Neil passed away in October from occupational cancer. Neil was a father of three,\n               a stepfather of two, and a 21-year member of the Vancouver fire rescue services. Christina and Lynn join us here today to witness the final stages of bills before\n               the House. In the face of her grief, Christina has started her journey in advocating\n               for improved working conditions and safety protections for firefighters. Their presence\n               here today reflects the importance of ensuring those who serve our communities are\n               properly supported and reminds us that behind every uniform is a family and behind\n               every policy a responsibility we must carry with care. Would the House please join me in extending a warm welcome to Christina and Lynn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720665","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I, too, want to make recognition of the fire and BCPFFA here today, but today I'd\n               also like to recognize in the chamber.... I am honoured to introduce Christina Austin\n               and Lynn Austin, the widow and mother of the late Neil Austin. Neil passed away in October from occupational cancer. Neil was a father of three,\n               a stepfather of two, and a 21-year member ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","label":"Accident prevention","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0aa3440b9acfc0690383d1cd7681d8a6c46b45f70845f1827eb6ae14e0e9be94","04f56545a8d14221bd9b02101dfea0e7a36aa103d6bd58f9b990d6e70b46218b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0457d6c0eec41e0e6b4804c1eb00084277104b76b9f369c6046515b77ea20b33"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b0c70e82e6aab8daccd8e59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720667,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Wow, it appears that some members of the government are not aware of the unintended\n               consequences of their policies. Jon Coleman is a direct result of how exclusionary\n               procurement has left out First Nations on contracts. We know this government has horrible track records when it comes to completing capital\n               projects, and now, instead of being transparent, this government is going to hide\n               all major projects that are less than $125 million. That's most schools, expansions into the health care system, now hidden from scrutiny. You know what this government's record is, though? It's $17 billion over budget and\n               158 years of delays. That's the legacy of construction policy under this NDP government. Will this government admit they failed at delivering projects on time and on Will this government admit that they failed at delivering projects on time and on\n               budget, like the Richmond Hospital redevelopment project that is $1.1 billion over\n               budget and two years behind schedule?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720667","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Wow, it appears that some members of the government are not aware of the unintended\n               consequences of their policies. Jon Coleman is a direct result of how exclusionary\n               procurement has left out First Nations on contracts. We know this government has horrible track records when it comes to completing capital\n               projects, and now, instead of being transparent,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["146a6a4be699067c8dc8be601a00711948e6d35cbd4b062206efe996f5608418","0331ae031caf9ece99024ee8d2df92a0f5bdd6e04dc24ce262195102f2653a33"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81b060893b4c1e6fc7684b0d259e7e1deb4bb935299eb61a218ac7988395fdeb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c637b296ef4cdf8a33ef21c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720668,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"On this side of the aisle, we're opposed to $6,000 limo rides, not to growing our\n               industries. Increasing pipeline egress for Canadian oil and gas to export ports is one of the\n               ways for Canadians and British Columbians to benefit financially from a world that\n               wants more responsibly produced Canadian oil and gas. Oil and gas can substantially\n               support our social investments, and it can be a wonderful opportunity for Indigenous\n               economic reconciliation. But when it comes to economic reconciliation, this government\n               has missed the mark. Will the minister get out of the way and support the prosperity of all British Columbians\n               and engage in more discussions to get more export pipelines to B.C.'s coasts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720668","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On this side of the aisle, we're opposed to $6,000 limo rides, not to growing our\n               industries. Increasing pipeline egress for Canadian oil and gas to export ports is one of the\n               ways for Canadians and British Columbians to benefit financially from a world that\n               wants more responsibly produced Canadian oil and gas. Oil and gas can substantially\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cfadce506e219a20addacd8a907e675c7d68eed664613daa9a0396c3d15d14a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b58cc5b4ceb9b93423aa7a27639d973d1bf65139d3e6c1598bf15b9c1d7e8846"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b9ad5adec5ea0b19e40ef45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720670,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720670","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11cb908c9baf9466aafa507c0bdbfb03fbfadfeaae7efbc2ebd239d8f088870d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-119beb4d1d6657a480ef26ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721739,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to recognize two important groups in the chamber today, both equally\n               important to building this province. No stranger here in this chamber is Chris Atchison\n               and about 20 delegates from the B.C. Construction Association, all up there. A couple\n               of Langley members, Will and Ashley, if they don't want to rise. April is Construction and Skilled Trades Month. To see these members in our gallery\n               is a sign of the good and continuous work that they do to advocate on how we can work\n               together to support a strong, stable construction sector that can continue delivering\n               for our communities across this province. Will the House please make them feel welcome. I have a second introduction. I would also like to make mention of another important\n               organization in this chamber, and that is CLAC. Last Monday words were spoken in this\n               chamber that I couldn't say on a job site. Although I won't apologize on behalf of\n               members on that side, I would like to apologize that they witnessed such disrespect\n               in this place of privilege. I hope that your time here today as representatives of\n               the thousands of British Columbians who choose to be represented by you is a positive\n               experience. Will the House make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721739","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to recognize two important groups in the chamber today, both equally\n               important to building this province. No stranger here in this chamber is Chris Atchison\n               and about 20 delegates from the B.C. Construction Association, all up there. A couple\n               of Langley members, Will and Ashley, if they don't want to rise. April is Construction and Skilled ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["994cc9b60b903923a3bd2092d1d3a2b58afbab804422885e48a9eeda863ba320"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36b5161edb9c1fdd8794b64b46ee2ee0fd8d09066be466f220ae4293e70ad4e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc76a942c85a200c7571a5c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721742,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to address Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. This legislation is not routine. It's not procedural. It is not a minor administrative\n               update. It goes to the core of how power is exercised and how it is scrutinized. Freedom-of-information laws are not optional features of a democratic system; they are structural safeguards.\n               They determine whether the public can see how decisions are made, how public funds\n               are used and how authority is exercised. When these laws are strong, government is visible. When they are weakened, government\n               recedes from view At its foundation, access to information serves a simple but essential function. It\n               allows the public to verify what its government does. It enables journalists to investigate\n               decisions that would otherwise remain opaque. It allows researchers to assess policy\n               outcomes with evidence. It gives opposition members the tools necessary to hold the\n               government to account. And most importantly, it gives citizens the ability to understand\n               the actions taken in their name. Without access, accountability becomes theoretical. Without access, oversight becomes\n               performative. Without access, trust becomes fragile. The strength of this system depends\n               not on what is promised but on what is permitted in practice. Bill 9 introduces changes that must be examined carefully and critically. The government\n               has framed these amendments as modernization. It has suggested they will improve efficiency,\n               streamline processes and adapt the system to contemporary realities. Those are reasonable\n               objectives. But efficiency cannot come at the expense of access. Streamlining cannot\n               become narrowing. Modernization cannot become restriction. Every amendment must be tested against a simple standard. Does it make it easier or\n               harder for the public to obtain information? If the answer is harder, then the justification\n               must be overwhelming. If it is not, then the change should not proceed. One of the central concerns with this bill is the expansion of conditions under which\n               access requests can be limited, delayed or denied. Any increase in discretion for\n               public bodies must be treated with caution. Discretion, by its nature, creates variability.\n               It introduces inconsistency. It opens the door to selective interpretation. And when\n               discretion expands without equally strong oversight, the balance shifts away from\n               transparency. The risk is not hypothetical. The risk is structural. When officials are given broader authority to determine what is released and what\n               is withheld, the system relies more heavily on internal judgment and less on enforceable\n               standards. That is a shift in power. And it is a shift that must be justified clearly\n               and convincingly. Another area of concern is the potential for increased delays in processing access\n               requests. Timelines is not a secondary issue. It is central to the effectiveness of\n               access to information. Information delayed is often information denied. If records\n               are released after decisions are finalized, after debates have concluded or after\n               public attention has moved on, their value diminishes significantly. Accountability requires relevance. Relevance requires timelines. Any legislative change\n               that risks extending timelines, whether directly or indirectly, must be scrutinized\n               with particular care. Because a system that produces information too late does not\n               function as an accountability mechanism. It functions as a historical archive. And\n               that is not its purpose. Fees and cost structures also play a critical role in determining whether access is\n               meaningful. If the cost of requesting information becomes prohibitive, access becomes\n               theoretical rather than practical. Barriers do not need to be absolute to be effective.\n               They only need to be high enough Barriers do not need to be absolute to be effective. They only need to be high enough\n               to discourage use. This is especially true for individuals, small organizations and\n               independent journalists who do not have the resources of large institutions. Access to information should not depend on financial capacity. It should depend on\n               the principle that public information belongs to the public. Any adjustment to fees\n               or cost recovery mechanisms must be evaluated through that lens. Does it preserve\n               access, or does it restrict access? The bill also raises questions about the scope of what is considered accessible information.\n               Well, definitions matter. Scope matters. Language matters. Small changes in wording\n               can have large consequences in application. If categories of records are narrowed,\n               if exemptions are broadened or if interpretations are left ambiguous, the cumulative\n               effect can be significant. Transparency does not disappear all at once. It erodes incrementally, through exceptions,\n               through exclusions, through reinterpretations. That is why precision in legislative\n               language is essential, and that is why vague or overly broad provisions must be challenged. Oversight mechanisms are another critical component of any access-to-information regime.\n               Without independent oversight, rules are only as strong as their enforcement. The\n               role of oversight bodies is to ensure that access rights are not only defined but\n               upheld. If this bill alters the capacity, authority or effectiveness of oversight,\n               that change must clearly be understood. Weak oversight leads to weak compliance. Strong oversight ensures consistency, fairness\n               and accountability. Any reform that affects this balance must be strengthened, not\n               weakened — the ability to enforce access rights. It is also necessary to consider the cumulative impact of these changes. Each individual\n               amendment may appear limited. Each change may be presented as reasonable in isolation.\n               But legislation must be assessed as a whole, because systems do not operate in fragments.\n               They operate as integrated frameworks. If multiple small restrictions are introduced simultaneously, their combined effect\n               can be substantial. What appears incremental can become transformative, and not in\n               a way that enhances transparency. The government has argued that these changes are necessary to manage volume, improve\n               efficiency and address administrative pressures. Those challenges are real, but they\n               are not unique. Every jurisdiction with access-to-information laws faces similar pressures.\n               The question is not whether the system requires improvement. It does. The question\n               is how those improvements are achieved. There are two paths. One path strengthens capacity, with more resources, better systems,\n               improved processes. The other path reduces demand. It narrows the scope, creates higher\n               barriers, greater discretion. Only one of these paths preserves the integrity of access.\n               The other compromises it. A modern access-to-information system should be proactive, not reactive. It should\n               focus on disclosure by default, not disclosure on request. And that's pretty reasonable.\n               That is what the public demands of us. It should reduce the need for formal requests\n               by making information available in the first place. I know all of us on this side have had, even, struggles with I know all of us on this side have had, even, struggles within our own capacity as\n               MLAs getting information that we need to do our job. If those of us who do this job\n               are having challenges with getting information, imagine what it's like for the public.\n               So let's just make information more accessible. That is what modernization looks like. It's not about limiting requests. It is about\n               eliminating the need for requests. If Bill 9 does not advance proactive disclosure\n               in a meaningful way, then its claim to modernization is actually incomplete. Trust is often cited in discussions about government transparency. But trust is not\n               built through messaging. It is built through verifiable action. Access to information\n               is one of the primary mechanisms through which that verification occurs. When information\n               is accessible, trust can be earned. When information is restricted, trust is weakened,\n               not because of perception but because of structure. Transparency is not symbolic.\n               It is functional. It is also important to recognize that access to information serves not only critics\n               of government but government itself. Strong access systems improve decision-making.\n               They encourage better recordkeeping. They promote clarity in communication. They create\n               an environment where actions are taken with the expectation of scrutiny. That is not\n               a weakness. That is a strength, and any reform should reinforce that principle, not\n               undermine it. There is also a broader context to consider. Public expectations around transparency\n               have evolved. Digital systems have increased the capacity to store, share and analyze\n               information. At the same time, they have increased expectations for accessibility.\n               People expect timely, clear and comprehensive information. They expect systems to\n               reflect the capabilities of the present, not the limitations of the past. Legislation\n               must meet that expectation, not by restricting access but by enabling it. If there are concerns about misuse of the system, those concerns should be addressed\n               with targeted solutions. If there are issues with volume, they should be addressed\n               with capacity. If there are inefficiencies, they should be addressed with process\n               improvements. But broad restrictions are not precise solutions. They are blunt instruments.\n               And blunt instruments often cause more damage than they resolve. The role of this House is not simply to pass legislation. It is to test it, to challenge\n               it, to improve it. That responsibility is especially important when dealing with laws\n               that define the boundaries of transparency. Once those boundaries are set, they shape\n               the behaviour of the entire system for years, for decades. This bill, as presented, raises significant concerns — concerns about access, concerns\n               about timeliness, concerns about oversight, concerns about scope. These are not minor\n               issues. They are foundational, and they require more than reassurance. They require\n               evidence. They require clarity. They require amendment where necessary. The path forward should be guided by a clear principle. Access to information should\n               be expanded, not restricted. Where barriers exist, they should be removed. Where delays\n               occur, they should be reduced. Where ambiguity exists, it should be clarified. Where\n               oversight is needed, it should be strengthened. That is the standard, and that is\n               the expectation. If this bill is to proceed, it must meet that standard — not the intent. As we can\n               tell, in the last couple of weeks, the intent with some previous legislation has not\n               been upheld by the court. So it needs to be very precise. In its current form, this legislation does not clearly demonstrate that it will strengthen\n               access. It does not clearly demonstrate that it will improve timelines. It does not\n               clearly demonstrate that it will enhance accountability. Without that clarity, it\n               cannot be supported without significant revisions. This is not about opposing change. It is about ensuring that change moves in the right\n               direction. It is about preserving the integrity of a system that underpins democratic\n               accountability. It is about ensuring that transparency is not reduced under the guise\n               of modernization. The public does not benefit from a system that is easier for government to manage\n               if it becomes harder for the public to use. Efficiency for government cannot outweigh\n               accessibility for citizens. That trade-off is absolutely not acceptable, and it should\n               not be embedded in this law. Ultimately, this comes down to a choice, a choice between openness and restriction,\n               a choice between strengthening accountability and weakening it, a choice between a\n               system that serves the public and one that serves administrative convenience. That\n               choice must be made deliberately, and it must be made correctly. For these reasons, this bill requires careful reconsideration. It requires amendments.\n               It requires a clear demonstration that it enhances rather than limits access to information.\n               Until that standard is met, I can't support it in its current form. I want us to take\n               away this information and decide what path we're going to take and really address\n               how we become more accountable to the citizens which have elected us here in this\n               House. We all take this job seriously. Let's make access to information better through providing\n               the information that should just be standard. We shouldn't have to be digging and\n               begging and emailing and following up just to get access to what this government does\n               on a daily basis. I want to thank you for allowing me to have this time, and I look forward to hearing\n               further conversation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721742","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to address Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. This legislation is not routine. It's not procedural. It is not a minor administrative\n               update. It goes to the core of how power is exercised and how it is scrutinized. Freedom-of-information laws are not optional features of a democratic system; they are structural safe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["812213f46c5e1745a44ba1ef178b7358ec107a966db7a6599b7e323d058573e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d173b10467de2c951e19d650fe409b6067b7cbe61e52d62690f6099efb9b0098"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-718b066c5b3c7ace7304f824","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721747,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Just this past weekend, a group of seven drama students from Langley's R.E. Mountain\n               Secondary School attended the Canadian Improv Games national festival. These seven\n               students won the Lower Mainland regional competition earlier this year and recently\n               jetted off to Ottawa to compete and participate in workshops with 15 other These seven students won the Lower Mainland regional competition earlier this year and recently jetted off to Ottawa to compete and participate in\n               workshops with 15 other teams from across Canada. This is the eighth time that Mountain has made it to nationals since the early 2000s, and the third time for some of these students under the great instruction of Gura Sidhu and UBC student teacher Miguel Thompson. As a self-confessed drama geek myself, we all know that life often requires improvisation, thinking on\n               our feet and reacting to the situations around us. The R.E. Mountain School's drama department is teaching those very skills to Langley youth now, valuable skills that these young people will use forever moving forward. Not all of these students will enter a career of acting, but I didn't expect to as\n               a teenager either. But yet, in this chamber today is a version of performance and\n               getting our message across to the province. Who knows if any of these students could\n               one day be standing here giving a passionate speech about the accomplishments of their\n               community as well. R.E. Mountain School is a school of over 2,500 kids in grades 9 through 12. It is a school of excellence in education, with Langley's only IB program, and robust sports and music programs. But most importantly, its students are also\n               winning volunteer of the year awards in Langley township. Special shout-out to Ruo Lee for winning the Pete Swenson award recently. Agatha, Ava, Gina, Jacob, Landon, Logan and Rylan: winning silver medal in the 2026 competition, which is also your graduating year,\n               is quite an accomplishment, and you should be proud of yourselves. While having fun in an unscripted art form, you are gaining an invaluable skill, setting\n               you up for success. Keep up the good work and make sure to invite me out to watch\n               one of your classes. I'm terrible at improv, but love to watch students learn their\n               craft.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721747","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Just this past weekend, a group of seven drama students from Langley's R.E. Mountain\n               Secondary School attended the Canadian Improv Games national festival. These seven\n               students won the Lower Mainland regional competition earlier this year and recently\n               jetted off to Ottawa to compete and participate in workshops with 15 other These seven students won the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cc2563343931566e5ace30d2d65b2ec2223e5f0359ea76362951720583217945"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d3c6592cf60e9b7727621ba11f2e8a9b55c7e0e50f263a869f968318c845e29"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f51260cead16ef36ca35a079","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729542,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to give recognition to Christina Gertsen in the House today. She is the wife\n               to Jason, who's our spiritual care provider and support system to many of us here. Christina is retiring this year from teaching. She's been a teacher in Langley for\n               15 years and most recently, 22 years here in Victoria. Will the House congratulate\n               her on a well-deserved career, and wish her luck in the years going forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729542","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to give recognition to Christina Gertsen in the House today. She is the wife\n               to Jason, who's our spiritual care provider and support system to many of us here. Christina is retiring this year from teaching. She's been a teacher in Langley for\n               15 years and most recently, 22 years here in Victoria. Will the House congratulate\n               her on a well-deserv","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea58d23c87a416cdd1082f27d97eb2e8aec50102ba4e1eeddeec7dd09ff962df"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e351180eb839d4709df7adf5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729548,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Finance Minister stood in this House and assured British Columbians that Burnaby\n               Hospital redevelopment phase 2 and other long-term-care projects \"weren't cancelled.\" In the past 48 hours, the staff and doctors at Burnaby Hospital received a letter\n               from their own executive director, with Fraser Health branding, that confirms in writing\n               that the alliance contract for the Burnaby Hospital redevelopment has been cancelled.\n               Not re-paced; cancelled. Not delayed; cancelled.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729548","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Finance Minister stood in this House and assured British Columbians that Burnaby\n               Hospital redevelopment phase 2 and other long-term-care projects \"weren't cancelled.\" In the past 48 hours, the staff and doctors at Burnaby Hospital received a letter\n               from their own executive director, with Fraser Health branding, that confirms in writing\n               that the alli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b390be8c197ac08d775b66c0f9d90a5e7fb9c984246a75216abcf6e8b765d774","83841b4b173b362a79934a7a7e849ecaad7cc4e04bc69d615792a0320c536ab5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["267a1a1f2b0e288cea526d63600fb91875d836444d3bb0eb47d5e67521c2893f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8abffb77c64a8f4fa16524e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752366,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"On Friday, the Premier confirmed that the Burnaby phase 2 redevelopment construction\n               contract has been cancelled. However, the Minister of Infrastructure continues to\n               tell the residents of Burnaby that their hospital, in fact, isn't cancelled. But a\n               hospital with no construction, no contract, no timeline is no hospital at all. Burnaby's mayor, Mike Hurley, said: \"I'm absolutely devastated and, frankly, horrified\n               by this decision.\" Why is this government incapable of taking responsibility for anything and just admit\n               that this project is cancelled and back on the shelf?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752366","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On Friday, the Premier confirmed that the Burnaby phase 2 redevelopment construction\n               contract has been cancelled. However, the Minister of Infrastructure continues to\n               tell the residents of Burnaby that their hospital, in fact, isn't cancelled. But a\n               hospital with no construction, no contract, no timeline is no hospital at all. Burnaby's mayor, Mike Hurl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5dd7ba5f6f5bdf22ae4f5701195ddd1bdb6fda0cfd56de3263cc370a8af8a92"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a983bce38761cec48f733c88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752367,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's interesting to hear from the Finance Minister talking about cuts when, in fact,\n               it was her budget that cut $3 billion of infrastructure projects from this year's\n               budget — not Conservatives. Earlier this week, the Minister of Infrastructure talked about being upfront with\n               the residents of Burnaby. The president of the Burnaby Hospital and Community Foundation\n               said: \"The assistant deputy minister confirmed that the final project proposal was\n               received in January 2026 and was within the approved $1.8 billion budget.\" Yet on\n               Friday, the Premier told reporters it was \"over budget.\" So which is it? According to the minister's assistant deputy minister, the project\n               was on budget, but the Premier said it was over budget. That's not being upfront with\n               the residents of Burnaby. To the minister: who is telling the truth? Does she agree with the comments made by\n               her assistant deputy minister or the Premier?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752367","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's interesting to hear from the Finance Minister talking about cuts when, in fact,\n               it was her budget that cut $3 billion of infrastructure projects from this year's\n               budget — not Conservatives. Earlier this week, the Minister of Infrastructure talked about being upfront with\n               the residents of Burnaby. The president of the Burnaby Hospital and Community ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc88efaaaab14d74958a4766351e7b19947c751d1588802e3e21052748379eb4","8e5a2f0674fbb42a7bc5a56ca62f777a3fd559e24730a6fb2dc89abffa38da7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b5fe42adc3e8a7231bf58f397d498a42dc4fb7a447768809b0ca1742d511a21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e8c53e5a63c8baf1d04d2ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017699,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"All right. I want to recognize that the minister is here today to listen. I've noticed,\n               actually, he's been here a lot.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017699","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"All right. I want to recognize that the minister is here today to listen. I've noticed,\n               actually, he's been here a lot.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bd138f1cad501ef9556e9a82a311bf2cb6b6f3238bc93078645a7fadfbc7725f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-687aa45e2a75274c34b24e5a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017701,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to just kind of give us a little synopsis of where I stopped yesterday, just\n               in regards to some topics that I'd covered, which was: what is reconciliation","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017701","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to just kind of give us a little synopsis of where I stopped yesterday, just\n               in regards to some topics that I'd covered, which was: what is reconciliation","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3630e1e0bedac6c7e377de175c2e73ec95072e296355ebc2faa1960fc08cf39"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-571ec22b0edd4b1199ed489a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036603,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate hearing the response from the member across the way on this amendment,\n               but it does speak to general concerns. From a municipal background, I have experience\n               in utility costs and the impacts to everybody on property taxes. One of the biggest\n               drivers is water and utilities, like wastewater. So I understand that it is important,\n               given that this is a motion and not a bill, to still recognize that we have an extreme\n               amount of pressures on our utility costs, also including waste removal. We all have very few opportunities to stand in this House to present a motion or a\n               bill, and I really do appreciate that this is something that you've thought significantly\n               about and are obviously advocating for residents in your community. But this is an\n               opportunity where we can take a motion and encompass.... You know, open it up just a\n               little bit more to make sure that the advocacy is for all British Columbians, just\n               adding in that water piece. The intent is there. This motion wasn't meant to kind of hijack it or make it not\n               intended for the purpose. I do want to recognize the impact of.... There are very few\n               of us that have had a bill or a motion on the floor, and this is a big opportunity.\n               I just really appreciate the member coming forward with this. But I still feel like\n               this small tweak, just adding these two words, \"water and,\" is something that makes\n               it just a little bit more robust. That is strictly because a lot of the time we don't experience our utilities separately\n               and, in the effort of recognizing affordability for British Columbians, just to highlight\n               the impacts that water also has on homes. You know, when we were discussing the motion itself, the original motion, and bringing\n               forward an amendment, there were conversations around: what does affordability mean\n               in the context of this motion? There are no guidelines. I understand the cost implications\n               when we present a motion or a bill to this House, but there was an opportunity for\n               us , in the amendment, to make it a little bit firmer on identifying what affordability\n               means and also encompassing more regional districts. I live in Metro, so there are lots of conversations on the impacts of especially wastewater\n               treatments — conversation quite a bit right now. But we can't just stop and take people's\n               bills and motions and just try to rework them into something else. I think the intent is still here with this amendment, highlighting the work that this\n               member has done on advocating and doing a little bit of cross-aisle tweaks to it,\n               just to make it a little bit more robust. That's the intent with my colleague here\n               from Boundary-Similkameen, and I'm really thankful that she brought this forward. What is that transparency requirement in the original So that's the intent with my colleague here from Boundary-Similkameen, and I'm really thankful that she brought this forward. And then what is that transparency requirement in the original motion? We made a conscious\n               effort just to kind of leave it as is, just add the water piece, because the bulk\n               amount of British Columbians, a significant part, are on private systems. So we'll\n               leave the amendment to highlighting private systems but just add the water piece. So I want to thank the member for the original the original motion, but I'll still\n               be supporting having water included in that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036603","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate hearing the response from the member across the way on this amendment,\n               but it does speak to general concerns. From a municipal background, I have experience\n               in utility costs and the impacts to everybody on property taxes. One of the biggest\n               drivers is water and utilities, like wastewater. So I understand that it is important,\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a24bfeb80927987cf56dedebecc7c741af3e140a86d5c31850cbd66ee00f6f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8c3e1c1c734cb80bc0740fc855e0faecdd8194187670b3f2ae178280a683127"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e74044f5c268708bcada490a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036604,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the chamber today is MP Tako Van Popta, Member of Parliament for Langley Township–Fraser\n               Heights. Yes, we are extended family, but he's clearly the more popular politician,\n               as I often get asked: \"Are you related to Tako?\" But somehow I don't think he often\n               gets asked: \"Are you related to Misty?\" He has been the federal shadow critic for Pacific Economic Development, often engaging\n               in businesses up and down the B.C. coast. As a lawyer by trade, he has recently been\n               assigned as chair of the Conservative Task Force on Property Rights. A fantastic grandpa to my daughters, a great representative to Langley — will the\n               House please make him feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036604","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the chamber today is MP Tako Van Popta, Member of Parliament for Langley Township–Fraser\n               Heights. Yes, we are extended family, but he's clearly the more popular politician,\n               as I often get asked: \"Are you related to Tako?\" But somehow I don't think he often\n               gets asked: \"Are you related to Misty?\" He has been the federal shadow critic for Pacific Econo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:125197","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:125197","label":"Cycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c43795af0a370416e195915fa85f2ab2cc5a4149e8ce821817f3e60f7595ab0e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28ae4ca13614145c91cce9cee22e841091d37ca7443e4802042d6e4273d341b6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a87809e53584950af52c9946","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036606,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday the Minister of Education admitted she cannot tell us how much taxpayers\n               will be on the hook for legal costs because she botched a court-ordered document disclosure\n               so badly that the Crown had to withdraw its entire case. Nine trustees were removed\n               from office. Eight days of court time were booked. Lawyers were hired on both sides. To the minister, how much are B.C. taxpayers on the hook for your incompetence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036606","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday the Minister of Education admitted she cannot tell us how much taxpayers\n               will be on the hook for legal costs because she botched a court-ordered document disclosure\n               so badly that the Crown had to withdraw its entire case. Nine trustees were removed\n               from office. Eight days of court time were booked. Lawyers were hired on both sides. To the mini","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["44638664100e2643c019f867e519b9ffb54bb519e96a2e2d088a1f9259e51dc3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e11d17f7897d37681af973dde14ceb7f7f9d13bb39b44bf1a15904f15b9444eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4862e8e028c582e2efac8522","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036607,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to my colleague for an opportunity to ask a couple of questions here. During question period today, the minister talked a lot about 1,100 new long-term\n               care projects coming online. This is at a time when we have 7,800 seniors on a waiting\n               list. The seven cancelled long-term cares account for around 900 net new beds, now\n               indefinitely on hold and creating a future lag in the delivery system roughly two\n               to three years from now. The NDP The NDP government promised 32 new or upgraded facilities in 2024, but to date we\n               have only seen Richmond approved to proceed while seven got the axe. The NDP also\n               promised to deliver 5,000 new beds by 2030. Given construction timelines, projects\n               would need to have shovels in the ground by 2028, with design work starting in 2026. My question to the minister is: what is the targeted, year-over-year capital plan\n               to address the lag that re-pacing of the seven long-term-care projects will create?\n               Can the minister confirm that her ministry will green-light an additional 4,000 beds\n               in next year's budget in order to hit the 5,000 beds target by 2030?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036607","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to my colleague for an opportunity to ask a couple of questions here. During question period today, the minister talked a lot about 1,100 new long-term\n               care projects coming online. This is at a time when we have 7,800 seniors on a waiting\n               list. The seven cancelled long-term cares account for around 900 net new beds, now\n               indefinitely on hold an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e4107885fa1ffe3bf7b7c2148c3f6ff88f1bd4743a2f722fb0e9b4279899499a","ce4d740c9ae3d7c71d45c374d0f17c4ae00c523ec10f471f5f501d6a9e4730ae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["250e3b1d3373d1aae87cdbe1e95db135698426f6b8e6033e858867b147d5ee3a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a3fead73e3d8d264e0b1c2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036608,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Misty Popta","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery up above me is the first class from Walnut Grove Secondary, one of\n               the three high schools in my riding. It's grade 9. Mr. Rogers is their teacher. The Gators is a fantastic school, with excellence in sports, music, theatre and academics. Will the House please make them feel welcome as they witness their first experience\n               — hopefully some question period.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036608","member_id":"bc-mla-380","member_name":"Misty Van Popta","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery up above me is the first class from Walnut Grove Secondary, one of\n               the three high schools in my riding. It's grade 9. Mr. Rogers is their teacher. The Gators is a fantastic school, with excellence in sports, music, theatre and academics. Will the House please make them feel welcome as they witness their first experience\n               — hopefully some question period.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","stored_speaker_name_differs_from_member"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ee5dbce7b259f5a64a575f113cc7d899b43d4e771eb1653871e9f4089f1b31b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b07800f9842eb3ff7a6d1f5ce4e06bd45e055e3080d711ce2f447163d4e25be"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8a34826216baa4ba191e36c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317213,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"This Solicitor General has the same talking points as the Premier. He has said: \"I\n               want you to know that this extortion issue is our most important public safety priority.\"\n               However, the budget allocates no new funding to combat the rampant extortion crisis\n               in Surrey, another example of this government overpromising and underdelivering. My question to the Premier, if extortion is truly his top public safety priority,\n               where is the money, or can this be added to the growing pile of the promises he never\n               intends to keep?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317213","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This Solicitor General has the same talking points as the Premier. He has said: \"I\n               want you to know that this extortion issue is our most important public safety priority.\"\n               However, the budget allocates no new funding to combat the rampant extortion crisis\n               in Surrey, another example of this government overpromising and underdelivering. My question to th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9ae77ddfe9db292f40878f59e96f680bcd27bd30a645f2317efaeabd0ac1e75"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["20bb55273e4083d5e8fea405d99eb438d550df4a2f37dead611f5005df5e1b67"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa7fc50a19d6b02c9cb4fc53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328057,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"At Langley Meals on Wheels, the mission is simple yet powerful — to ensure that everyone\n               in our community is fed, connected and supported. Serving nutritious meals to those\n               in need, it assures that no one in our community goes hungry, particularly our seniors\n               and individuals with mobility challenges. This organization goes beyond food delivery, as it also brings joy, companionship,\n               wellness checks and support to our community members. With the dedication and compassion\n               of the volunteers, they deliver meals while fostering connection and enhancing the\n               overall well-being of the clients. The service includes meal delivery assistance for those returning home from the hospital,\n               monthly healthy living bags, the Firehouse Cafe and the outreach program aimed at\n               nurturing the ones most in need in our community, among other offerings. Whether you seek meal delivery, a volunteering opportunity or a supportive community,\n               Langley Meals on Wheels and the Firehouse Cafe are here to serve Langley. During my recent shift, I had the privilege of working alongside an extraordinary\n               volunteer, Barb. As a senior herself, Barb is a shining example of selflessness and\n               community spirit, dedicated to ensuring that those who are unable to prepare meals\n               receive the nourishment they need. With each delivery, she warmly interacted with\n               the recipients, taking the time to chat and share a smile. It was clear for many that\n               these visits were not just about food. They were cherished moments of companionship. Seeing Barb in action reminded me of the profound difference one can make in the lives\n               of others. Her passion and dedication illustrated how simple acts of kindness can\n               transform a community. Langley Meals on Wheels embodies the spirit of not only delivering\n               meals but spreading kindness and joy through the dedication of volunteers. I'm grateful for the opportunity to experience this vital service firsthand, to give\n               back, even in a small way. Together we can make a meaningful impact. You are all invited to join us at Langley Meals on Wheels.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328057","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"At Langley Meals on Wheels, the mission is simple yet powerful — to ensure that everyone\n               in our community is fed, connected and supported. Serving nutritious meals to those\n               in need, it assures that no one in our community goes hungry, particularly our seniors\n               and individuals with mobility challenges. This organization goes beyond food delivery, as it al","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","label":"Nutrition","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c87319894435fa2940de6c3014bc0d87f3f7969772482bfb6cb8d6dbbb400e96"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af0adec81ff254ba269caf5f394f781e9ab9073b168644887d27db4455e20049"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48763","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-215364b0e802137b9015c97e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328058,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak on Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. There is one word that sits at the heart of the Canadian promise: freedom. Freedom\n               is the word that draws people from every corner of the world to this country. It is\n               a word that has defined generations of Canadians who believe that, in this land, individuals\n               could live openly, speak honestly and take part in shaping their future. Freedom is not simply the absence of control. It is the presence of rights. It is\n               the ability of citizens to ask questions without fear. It is the ability to take part\n               in decisions that affect their communities, their families and their livelihoods. But freedom cannot exist in darkness. Freedom requires knowledge. Freedom requires\n               transparency. Freedom requires the ability of citizens to understand how power is\n               exercised in their name. That is why access to information matters. When citizens can see how decisions are\n               made they are not simply observers of democracy, they are taking part in it. Freedom\n               of information is, in many ways, the practical expression of that larger promise of\n               freedom. It ensures that the citizens of this country are not kept in the dark about the decisions\n               that shape their lives, because democracy works best when citizens are informed, engaged\n               and free to see the truth of how their government operates. That is why the principle\n               behind freedom of information must always be protected. At a first glance, this bill — Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026 — appears procedural. It updates language. It introduces certain\n               administrative authorities. It adjusts how the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act operates in practice. But laws concerning access to information are never solely technical. Access to information\n               laws define the relationship between citizens and their government. They determine\n               whether people can understand how decisions affecting their lives are made. They determine\n               whether public spending can be examined. Ultimately, they determine whether citizens\n               can trust the They determine whether people can understand how decisions affecting their lives are\n               made. They determine whether public spending can be examined. Ultimately, they determine\n               whether citizens can trust the institution that governs them. Freedom of information belongs to the people of British Columbia. It belongs to parents\n               seeking answers about decisions affecting their children's education. It belongs to\n               seniors trying to understand changes to health services. It belongs to small business\n               owners seeking fairness in public procurement. It belongs to Indigenous communities\n               reviewing decisions that affect land agreements and governance. It belongs to journalists,\n               researchers and citizens who want to know how the government operates. Freedom of information was never designed to make life easy for governments. It was\n               designed to make democracy stronger, and that principle must guide our examination\n               of Bill 9. The purpose of access-to-information laws. Access-to-information laws exist because\n               democratic societies recognize that power must be accompanied by transparency. When\n               governments exercise authority, they do so on behalf of citizens. That record, created\n               through those decisions, belongs to the public. Unless there is a legitimate reason\n               for protection, access laws allow citizens to see how decisions are made. They allow\n               journalists to investigate public spending. They allow people to perform and ministries\n               to oversight. They allow communities to understand policies that affect their lives. Transparency protects democracy. It encourages responsible decision-making. It ensures\n               that mistakes can be identified and corrected. It ensures that government remains\n               accountable to the people they serve and those people of British Columbia. When we\n               amend regulations governing access to information, we must always ask whether those\n               amendments strengthen transparency or weaken it. Let me illustrate what that means in practical terms. Imagine a community association\n               trying to understand how a major transportation decision affecting their neighbourhood\n               was made. Residents may hear that studies were conducted, consultations occurred and\n               recommendations were provided to government. Without access-to-information laws, those\n               residents would have no way of seeing the documents behind those decisions. They would\n               be forced to rely only on summaries or public statements. Freedom of information allows\n               them to review the studies, the briefing notes and the recommendations that shaped\n               that decision. That ability to see the public record strengthens trust because citizens know decisions\n               are not hidden from view. Transparency is not an inconvenience to democracy. It is\n               a requirement of democracy. Responding to the language in Bill 9, let me refer directly to the text of Bill 9.\n               Bill 9 proposes amendments to provisions governing response timelines within the Freedom\n               of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. Particularly, the bill replaces the\n               obligation for the public bodies to respond to requests without delay, with the phrase\n               \"without unreasonable delay.\" This change appears within the operational provisions\n               governing access requests. At first glance, the change may appear subtle, but legislative language shapes the\n               forecast. The phrase \"without delay\" communicates urgency. It sets a clear objective\n               that the public bodies should respond immediately to citizens requesting information.\n               Replacing that phrase with \"without unreasonable delay\" introduces explanation. It\n               creates flexibility in defining what composes a timely response. You can add a simple everyday illustration like this so people in the chamber immediately\n               understand the difference in language. Precisely, Bill 9 replaces the obligation for the public body to respond to requests\n               without delay with the phrase \"without unreasonable delay.\" At a first glance, that\n               may sound like a small change in wording, but words matter in regulation. Words matter\n               in this House Let me offer a simple example that everyone in this chamber can relate to. Imagine\n               you take your car to a local body shop for repairs. You ask the mechanic: \"When will\n               the work be done?\" Just a very simple question. They should be able to tell you. The\n               shop's policy says the work will be completed without delay. You would reasonably\n               expect that the mechanic will begin the repair immediately and complete it as soon\n               as possible, because it's supposed to be without delay. Now imagine the policy instead says the repair can be completed without unreasonable\n               delay. Suddenly, the belief changes. Your thoughts change. The repair might begin\n               later. The timeline becomes flexible. The shop may determine that waiting several\n               days is still reasonable because they're busy, parts need to be ordered, other jobs\n               are ahead of yours or they're not working today. The words have changed, and with\n               them, the prediction of urgency has changed. Or consider something even simpler. Imagine going to a restaurant where the menu says\n               your meal will be delivered without delay. Most customers would assume their order\n               will arrive quickly. But if the policy instead says your meal will arrive without\n               unreasonable delay, the restaurant now has much wider room to decide what that means.\n               Ten minutes may be reasonable. Thirty minutes may be reasonable. Even longer may be\n               considered reasonable, depending on the circumstances. This may seem like a small shift in wording, but it illustrates a larger point. When\n               this government replaces clear urgency with flexible definition, the balance suddenly\n               shapes away from the citizens and towards the institution holding the information.\n               When it comes to transparency, clarity matters. No government should be afraid of clear timelines for transparency, because accountability\n               is not a burden of democracy. It is the proof that democracy is working. Clear timelines\n               re-form the idea that responding to citizens is a priority. Flexible language risks\n               weakening that projection. And when urgency fades, transparency can gradually weaken\n               as well. Let me illustrate what this change could mean for an ordinary citizen. Before this\n               change, a citizen submitting a request would know that the law required a response\n               without delay. That wording set clear belief that the process would move quickly.\n               The existing law says that they are supposed to get back to the applicant without\n               delay. The amendment changes that to \"without unreasonable delay\" and makes the officials\n               themselves the judge of what is and is not reasonable. For example, imagine a small business owner in Langley who submitted a request for\n               records related to a provincial procurement decision. They wanted to understand why\n               a contract had been awarded to another company and whether the scoring process had\n               been applied fairly. Under the current projection of responding without delay, the public body would immediately\n               begin to process that request. There would be a clear understanding that the request\n               should move forward as quickly as possible. But under the new wording of responding\n               without unreasonable delay, the experience for that same business owner could become\n               more complicated. The request might enter a longer review process. Officials might\n               determine that additional internal consultation is required. They may determine that\n               a longer processing time is reasonable given internal workloads. Instead of expecting a prompt response, the applicant may now face a longer period\n               of uncertainty. For a business owner trying to understand procurement decisions that\n               affect their livelihood, time matters. Why timelines matter in practice? Imagine a parent in Langley whose child has lost\n               access to a specialized educational support at school. That parent wants to understand Why timeline matters in practice. Imagine a parent in Langley whose child has lost\n               access to a specialized educational support at school. That parent wants to understand\n               how that decision was made. They file a freedom-of-information request seeking internal\n               communication, briefing notes and policy documents that lead to that change. Before changes like those proposed in this bill, the prediction of responding without\n               delay would push the request forward quickly. The parent would receive the information\n               while the school year was still underway. The information could allow the parent to\n               meet with administrators, advocate for their child and take part in a meaningful decision-making\n               process. Now imagine the same request process under a more flexible standard of responding\n               without unreasonable delay. The request may move through longer internal reviews.\n               The school year may continue. Weeks may pass. Months may pass. Eventually, the documents\n               may arrive, but by then the school year may be nearly finished. That's why that matters. The parents may finally learn why the decision was made, but the opportunity to influence\n               that decision may already be gone. That is why timelines matter. The importance of timelines and access to information cannot be overstated. Information\n               often has value because of when it becomes available. Consider a small community requesting records related to environmental impacts of\n               a proposed development project. If those records arrive after permits have already\n               been issued and construction has already begun, the opportunity for meaningful public\n               engagement may be lost. That's why timelines matter. Consider a journalist requesting records about government spending on a major infrastructure\n               project. If those records arrive after the public debate has passed, the opportunity\n               for research demolishes. Consider a parent requesting records about change to educational services affecting\n               their child. If those records arrive long after the decision has been implemented,\n               their ability to advocate effectively may be limited. In each case, the information may eventually be released, but if it arrives too late,\n               the right to know becomes less meaningful. Timely access is meaningful access. Delays\n               are not simple administrative matters. They shape real outcomes for citizens of B.C. Record creation and documentation. Another critical issue related to access to information\n               is record creation. Freedom of information can only work if records exist. If important\n               decisions are not documented, there is nothing for citizens to access. Modern government operates in an increasingly digital environment. Communications\n               occur through emails, messaging platforms and various digital systems. These tools\n               allow for rapid communication, but they also create challenge for record management.\n               Important decisions may occur informally. Decisions may be made quickly, and unless\n               those decisions are properly documented, the public record becomes incomplete. Consider how recordkeeping itself can affect transparency. Imagine a community group\n               requesting records about decisions that occurred before a major housing decision was\n               announced. They want to know what options were considered. They want to understand\n               which concerns were raised by officials and what advice was given to decision-makers. In a system where recordkeeping is strong, those decisions would be documented. Briefing\n               notes would exist. Emails and reports would show how the decision evolved. The community\n               group could review those records and understand the reasoning behind the policy. But imagine a different situation. Important conversations took place through those\n               informal messaging systems. Meetings occurred where notes were not taken. Key decisions\n               were never and formally documented. When the freedom-of-information request is submitted,\n               the ministry responds that few records exist. Meetings occurred where notes were not taken. Key decisions were never informally\n               documented. When the freedom of information request is submitted, the ministry responds\n               that few records exist. The decision may have involved months of discussion, but the official record appears\n               thin. The citizens asking questions are left with only fragments of the story. This\n               is why record creation matters. Transparency depends not only on access laws but also on the quality of the public\n               record itself. Transparency begins long before a request for information is submitted.\n               Transparency begins when decisions are recorded. When documentation practices are strong, access requests become easier to fulfil.\n               When records are incomplete or poorly organized, delays become unpreventable. Improving record creation practice would strengthen transparency remarkably. Clear\n               records protect citizens, but they also protect institutions. They ensure that future\n               governments, researchers and recorders can understand how decisions were actually\n               made. Administrative consistency across institutions matters. Another issue worth examining is consistency across public institutions. Most public\n               bodies in British Columbia are subject to freedom of information obligations: (1)\n               ministries must respond to requests, (2) health authorities must respond, (3) school\n               boards must respond and (4) various public agencies must respond. Let me offer one final example that speaks to consistency across institutions. Imagine\n               a citizen trying to understand how public funds were spent on a government initiative.\n               They may submit a freedom of information request to a ministry responsible for delivering\n               the program. The ministry must respond because it is subject to the act. But the citizen\n               may also wish to understand administrative decisions related to how the program was\n               organized within other parts of the government. If transparency standards differ between institutions, the citizen may receive detailed\n               records from one public body but be unable to access similar information from another.\n               This bill is unclear how this would operate seamlessly. To the citizens, the difference between those institutions may not be clear. From\n               their point of view, they are simply asking how public money was used. When transparency\n               standards appear uneven, it can create confusion. Consistency across public institutions\n               helps ensure that citizens can follow the public record wherever decisions are made.\n               Transparency should not depend on where inside government a decision happens. It should\n               follow the public interest. These obligations exist because these institutions exercise public authority and manage\n               public resources. Citizens expect transparency standards to apply consistency across\n               the public sector. This raises another important question about administrative functions within this\n               ministry. This decision is not about debate in this chamber. Parliamentary privilege\n               protects legislative speech. However, administrative matters such as recruitment,\n               operational spending and internal policies are similar to administrative functions\n               carried out by other public bodies. When transparency standards vary between institutions\n               performing similar administrative roles, it can create the understanding that openness\n               is applied unevenly. Consistency strengthens trust. If transparency strengthens accountability in ministries,\n               it strengthens accountability in institutional administrations as well. Transparency is a democratic principle at its core. This debate concerns a simple\n               democratic principle that this government fails to model. Information held by government\n               does not belong to the government. It belongs to the public. Quite honestly, I think\n               this government has forgotten this. Government institutions hold information in trust on behalf of citizens, on behalf\n               of British Columbians. Citizens rely on transparency to understand policy. They rely on access to information\n               to evaluate government actions. They rely on public records to take part in meaningfulness\n               in democratic debate. Freedom of information was never designed to make life easy for government. It was\n               designed to make democracy Freedom of information was never designed to make life easy for government. It was\n               designed to make democracy stronger. Governments change. Political parties move between\n               government and opposition. But democratic institutions endure. Strong access to laws\n               protects those institutions, regardless of who is in power. A forward-looking vision for modernization. Modernization can strengthen transparency\n               if it is approached thoughtfully. Digital tools can improve record management. Governments\n               can proactively publish regularly requested information. Public reporting systems\n               can provide clear insight into response times. I believe modernization could include several improvements: (1) clear service benchmarks\n               for responding to access requests, (2) public dashboards reporting response times\n               and backlog levels, (3) proactive publication of commonly requested documents, (4)\n               an improved digital system for managing records, and (5) training programs to support\n               public servants responsible for processing requests. These improvements would strengthen\n               transparency while improving effectiveness. Modernization should expand access rather\n               than narrow it. Trust and public confidence. It comes down to a very simple principle that hints at\n               this bill. Public trust is one of the most valuable assets a government controls.\n               Transparency helps maintain that trust. When citizens can see how decisions are made,\n               they are more likely to accept those decisions, even when they disagree with them. But when transparency appears to weaken, suspicions start to grow. Democracy works\n               best in the light. The moment government begins to dim that light, even slightly,\n               public trust begins to fade. Maintaining transparency requires laws that reinforce\n               openness. Access-to-information regulation is one of the key tools that protect the\n               openness. In closing, Bill 9 may appear technical, but the principles behind access-to-information\n               regulations are anything but technical. What is at stake here is not administrative\n               language. What is at stake is whether this government is prepared to defend transparency\n               or quietly dilute it. This debate is about whether citizens can see how decisions are made in their name.\n               It is about whether the public can follow the paper trail behind billions of dollars\n               in government spending. It is about whether transparency will remain a cornerstone\n               of governance in British Columbia or whether it will slowly be replaced with language\n               that gives government more control and the public less certainty and access. Instead of improving transparency, the government is rewriting the rules around how\n               and when the public can access information. British Columbians deserve a government\n               that is open and accountable, not one that controls what information the public can\n               see. Freedom of information is not an inconvenience for government. It is not a bureaucratic\n               hurdle to be managed. It is a safeguard that protects the public from secrecy. Yet with Bill 9, this government is asking that Bill 9 to accept softer language,\n               broader options and clear projections for how quickly citizens can access the information\n               that belongs to them, that belongs to British Columbians. That should concern every\n               member of this House. Freedom of information reminds governments of something very important. Authority\n               is temporary. Governments come and go. Parties rise and fall. But the public record\n               lasts. Transparency is what allows citizens, journalists, researchers and future governments\n               to understand how decisions were made and to hold those decisions up to audit. Strong access laws strengthen institutions because they ensure that government operates\n               in the light. Weakening those laws does the opposite. It invites suspiciousness, it\n               erodes trust, and it sends the message that transparency is optional rather than essential. So as we consider the amendments contained in Bill 9, the question before this House\n               and this chamber is simple. Are we strengthening transparency for the people of British As we consider the amendments contained in Bill 9, the question before this House\n               and this chamber is simple. Are we strengthening transparency for the people of British\n               Columbia, or are we weakening it for the convenience of government? Because transparency\n               does more than release documents. Freedom of information only works if government\n               can decide which requests they will answer.... The bill's proposed changes to B.C.'s FOI laws risk making it harder, slower and more\n               expensive for British Columbians to access information about this government. Transparency\n               protects democracy itself.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328058","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak on Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. There is one word that sits at the heart of the Canadian promise: freedom. Freedom\n               is the word that draws people from every corner of the world to this country. It is\n               a word that has defined generations of Canadians who believe that, in this land, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ed9111ea10ebeb6b701a2bbd71ad98a095c7b3cfb92d48b413f69ee3787a2a70"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4447a98fdaeb2f74bb4b4995f61b55bb449c17b46023070a03e25a5816590bda"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c97f41b5c002d089f8cc3789","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361196,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak on Bill 10, Labour Statutes Amendment Act, on behalf of the\n               residents of Langley-Willowbrook. As a member of the Conservative Party of British Columbia, it is always a pleasure\n               to stand in this chamber and speak on bills that will shape the rules governing workplaces\n               across British Columbia. The laws we pass here affect the daily lives of millions\n               of workers and employees throughout our province. They influence how businesses operate,\n               how employees are treated and how disputes are resolved when things go wrong. At the outset, I want to be very clear about something that should unite all members\n               of this House. Workers deserve to be paid what they are owed. The entire purpose of\n               employment standards law is to ensure that wages earned are wages paid. Those principles\n               are fundamental to the Employment Standards Act of British Columbia. Workers deserve to be paid what they are owed. The entire purpose of employment standards\n               law is to ensure that wages earned are wages paid. Those principles are fundamental\n               to the Employment Standards Act, British Columbia. They are principles that every\n               member of this chamber should support. When someone works hard, shows up for their shift, gives their time and energy and\n               fulfills their responsibilities, they should have confidence that they will receive\n               the wages they have earned. That is not a dispute statement. It is a basic requirement\n               in any fair and functioning economy. At the same time, we must recognize that healthy workplaces require balance. Workers\n               need strong protections, and they deserve clear mechanisms to recover wages or resolve\n               disputes. When problems arise, employers also need rules that are fair, predictable\n               and workable. Across British Columbia, and especially in the communities I represent in Langley-Willowbrook, small and medium-sized businesses are the backbone of the local economy. These businesses\n               are often family owned. They are the restaurants, construction companies, retail shops,\n               restaurants and service providers that create jobs and help communities thrive. Most of these employers want to do the right thing. They want to treat their employees\n               fairly. They want to follow the law. They want to maintain positive relationships\n               with the people who work for them, especially the foreign workers as they become their\n               families here. Our labour laws must recognize that reality. They must hold bad actors\n               accountable, but they must also support the vast majority of responsible employers\n               who are trying to follow the rules. The bill before us today proposes a number of changes to the Employment Standards\n               Act as well as the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act, B.C. Some of these changes\n               are administrative or technical in nature. Others introduce new processes or modify\n               existing enforcement. As legislators, it is our responsibility to carefully examine\n               these changes, understand their implications and ensure they serve the best interests\n               of workers, employers and the broader economy. One of the changes included in this bill relates to the handling of wages owed to\n               employees who cannot be located. Under the previous rules, the director was required\n               to attempt to locate the employee for a period of one year before taking possession\n               of those wages. Bill 10 removes that one-year waiting period. Under the proposed changes,\n               if reasonable efforts have been made to locate the employee, and those efforts are\n               unsuccessful, the wages may be transferred to the administrator sooner. The goal here appears to be administrative effectiveness. Unclaimed wages can be secured\n               and managed rather than remaining in limbo for an extended period of time. In principle,\n               ensuring that money owed to workers is safeguarded makes sense. Employers should always\n               be able to claim the wages they have earned hardly. However, the more major and potential dispute aspects of this bill related to the\n               appeals process is the introduction of new requirements for employers who wish to\n               challenge demonstrations made under the Employment Standards Act. Under the proposed\n               changes, if an employer wishes to file an appeal of a determination that requires\n               payment of wages or other fiscal amounts, they must deposit the amount owed with the\n               director before the appeal can be processed. In other words, the money must be paid\n               up front simply to access the appeal process. The legislation does provide some flexibility. The panel may, on a case-by-case basis,\n               determine that a lesser deposit amount is appropriate, but the default requirement\n               remains that the full amount must be deposited before the appeal can move forward. On the surface, this may appear reasonable. After all, if wages are owed to workers,\n               it makes sense that the funds should be secured while the appeal process unfolds.\n               But we must consider the practical suggestion of this requirement, particularly for\n               small businesses. Larger corporations may have the financial resources to deposit major sums of money\n               while pursuing an appeal, but small and medium-sized businesses operate on tight margins.\n               Cash flow can be unpredictable. Unexpected expenses can have serious consequences. For a small business owner who believes a determination is incorrect, requiring the\n               full amount to be deposited up front may effectively prevent them from exercising\n               their right to appeal. This raises an important question about access to justice within\n               our employment standards system. Appeal exists for a reason. They allow decisions\n               to be reviewed and corrected if errors have occurred. They provide an important safeguard\n               within regulated framework. If the financial barriers to filing an appeal become too\n               high, some employers may simply be unable to challenge decisions they believe are\n               wrong. Fairness in the system must apply to everyone involved. Workers deserve fair treatment\n               and timely solution of their complaints, but employers must also have fair opportunity\n               to present their case and seek review when necessary. Another aspect of Bill 10 introduces a new complaint resolution process during investigations.\n               The director may require parties to take part in this process while the investigation\n               continues. The intent appears to be encouraging early solutions of disputes, potentially\n               reducing the need for lengthy investigations or formal determinations. In theory,\n               alternate dispute solutions such as mediation can be beneficial. They can provide\n               opportunities for parties to reach mutual acceptance solutions without prolonged legal\n               processes, which can also be very expensive. However, we must again consider the practical realities faced by many small business\n               owners. Large organizations often have dedicated human resources departments and legal\n               counsel who can manage complex employment disputes. But small business owners rarely\n               have those resources. For many small business owners, navigating an employment standards\n               complaint is already a challenging and time-consuming process. Adding mandatory mediation or additional procedural steps may increase administration\n               burdens and create further complications. If these processes are implemented without\n               accurate support or guidance, they could place additional strain on employers who\n               are already trying to comply with complex regulated requirements. Perhaps the most major concern surrounding this bill relates not only to the specific\n               changes being proposed, but also to the broader context in which they are being introduced.\n               For several years now, the employment standards branch has faced major challenges\n               in the processing of complaints in a timely manner. Workers who file complaints often\n               wait months, sometimes far longer, before these cases are resolved, according to the\n               government's own service plans. Over the past four years, only 32 percent of employment standards complaints have\n               been resolved within 180 days. That means the majority of workers are waiting longer\n               than six months for solutions. For someone who believes they have been denied wages\n               they have rightfully earned, six months is a long time to wait. In many cases, the\n               money owed may represent rent payments, groceries, child care, expenses or other essential\n               costs. Delayed enforcement undermines the effectiveness of employment standards law. A system\n               designed to protect workers must be able to respond quickly when problems arise, and\n               not 180 days. The government has recognized this issue and has set a target of resolving 80 percent\n               of complaints within 180 days by 2027-2028 fiscal year. But even if the target is\n               achieved, one in five workers could still be waiting more than six months for a solution.\n               We should also ask ourselves whether that standard is truly acceptable. More importantly,\n               we should ask whether this bill changes alone will solve the problem of delayed complaint. The provincial budget currently freezes funding for labour programs at approximately\n               $22.3 million for the next three years. In fact, that amount is slightly lower than\n               the previous year's estimated spending of The provincial budget currently freezes funding for labour programs at approximately\n               $22.3 million for the next three years. In fact, that amount is slightly lower than\n               the previous year's estimated spending of $22.85 million. At the same time, the government\n               expects complaint solution times to improve majorly. Those outcomes raise serious questions about whether the employment standards branch\n               has the resources necessary to meet these targets. If we want complaints to be resolved\n               faster the branch responsible for investigating and enforcing employment standards\n               must have accurate staffing, proper training and the tools needed to do its job effectively.\n               Without those resources, the bill changes alone may not produce the improvements workers\n               and employers both want to see. Another issue that has been raised by stakeholders across the province is related\n               to consultation. Many employer organizations have indicated that they were not meaningfully\n               consulted before these changes were introduced. Labour policy, perhaps more than any\n               other area of law, benefits from broad consultation. Workers, employers, labour organizations,\n               business associations and legal experts all have valuable views to add to this. When policies are developed through inclusive consultation they are more likely to\n               reflect real-world conditions and practical considerations. When stakeholders feel\n               excluded from the process it can undermine the confidence in resulting legislation. It is important to remember that labour laws are not abstract policies. They govern\n               relationships between people, between workers and employers who rely on each other\n               every day. Effective labour regulations should strive to promote cooperation, fairness\n               and clarity. They should provide clear outcomes and a reliable process for resolving\n               disputes. In the riding of Langley-Willowbrook, I regularly speak with small business owners who are deeply committed to their employees.\n               They sponsor local teams, they donate to community organizations, and they provide\n               opportunities for young people entering the workforce for the first time. These businesses are not faceless corporations. They are run by families and individuals\n               who care about their communities. When we design labour policies, we must ensure that\n               they reflect the realities faced by these employers, while still protecting workers\n               from unfair treatment. The goal should always be balance. Workers must have the confidence that if they are denied wages or treated unfairly,\n               there's a system in place that will protect them and help them recover when they are\n               owed. Employers must also have confidence that the system is fair, transparent and\n               accessible, and that they will have the opportunity to challenge decisions they believe\n               are incorrect. Legislation like Bill 10 plays an important role in shaping that balance. That is\n               why it is essential for the House to carefully examine each provision and consider\n               its potential impacts. Some elements of this bill may improve administrative effectiveness\n               or clarify existing processes. Others may introduce new challenges that need to be\n               addressed through amendments, additional resources or improved implementation strategies. As members, our responsibility is not simply to pass laws but to ensure that those\n               laws work in practice and work for everyone in B.C. That means asking difficult questions,\n               it means listening to stakeholders and it means recognizing when additional support\n               or adjustments may be necessary. The people of British Columbia expect their government to create a fair and effective\n               labour system. They expect workers to be protected and employers to be treated fairly.\n               They also expect disputes to be resolved in a timely manner so that problems do not\n               drag for months or years. Ultimately, the success of employment standards bills should be measured not just\n               by the number of files processed or timelines reported in service plans but by whether\n               workers actually receive the wages they are owed and whether As this bill continues through the process, I hope this government will carefully\n               consider the concerns raised by employers, workers and community members across the\n               province. I hope they will ensure that the employment standards branch has the resources\n               it needs to enforce the law effectively. I hope they will remain open to improvements\n               that strengthen fairness, transparency and balance within our labour system. The residents of Langley-Willowbrook want a labour system that works. They want laws that protect workers while supporting\n               reasonable employers. They want policies that are developed through meaningful consultation\n               and implementation, with the resources necessary to make them effective. Those are\n               reasonable reaches that the community wants, and they are the requirements that every\n               member of this House should strive to meet. I understand that there is some other business for the House, so I move adjournment\n               of debate and reserve my right to continue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361196","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak on Bill 10, Labour Statutes Amendment Act, on behalf of the\n               residents of Langley-Willowbrook. As a member of the Conservative Party of British Columbia, it is always a pleasure\n               to stand in this chamber and speak on bills that will shape the rules governing workplaces\n               across British Columbia. The laws we pass here affect the daily l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1d47d5c6c7a83ac9540f5213abaf7d64b66ed6c9eb6fc4ebebaa554018f978fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d16a6044f00d521c125ca83276de42a6b955036bd36ee5be6797bed86260ac8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f8eb67aece32ba8b44051bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361197,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak in response to the government's Motion 13 and\n               the amendment that was put forward, which calls on the House to affirm its support\n               for the British Columbians' human rights and protecting all people from hate and discrimination. Let me begin by stating something very clearly. Human rights matter, and","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361197","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Madam Speaker, I rise today to speak in response to the government's Motion 13 and\n               the amendment that was put forward, which calls on the House to affirm its support\n               for the British Columbians' human rights and protecting all people from hate and discrimination. Let me begin by stating something very clearly. Human rights matter, and","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Isolated communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","label":"Isolated communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["358d2272250966a94b9fb3deff85dbc22d75ea2dc18aa2e3e9dfddc980b8297f","6d377538c5f9e1b1d9909fb079d13c94a68f2827e7210a838d20ddd5f075b2d9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d5c3fc326415d6a40eaeccc15252a074c9eb5c4bddb4e9ae4a6d0f9724f1f851"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-892d393aa377dcfaf8d403ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720614,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"As a cancer survivor, I know firsthand the emotional, physical toll this illness can\n               take. Cancer does not discriminate. It touches people of every age, every background,\n               every family. The reality is severe. One in two men and one in three women will face\n               a diagnosis in their lifetime. Right here in our community, there are individuals\n               and families walking this road today. Some are in the middle of treatment, some are\n               waiting for answers and some are learning how to live again. This is where I want us to stop for a moment and not just listen but truly take stock.\n               Think about someone you know — a friend, a family member, a neighbour and maybe even\n               yourself — and decide how you want to respond. Maybe you respond differently, because\n               this month is not just about awareness, it is about truly being aware, aware in a\n               way that asks you to pause and consider where you might not be paying attention right\n               now. It's about looking and booking that screening you may have been putting off. It is\n               about making that phone call to check in on someone who is fighting. It is about choosing\n               small daily habits that protect your health. I have seen firsthand how those small\n               decisions can make a meaningful difference. We also need to recognize that this journey is not just physical. It is emotional.\n               It is financial. It can also feel very isolating. That is why community matters, compassion\n               matters, and showing up for one another matters. As your MLA, I am committed to advocating for stronger support systems, better access\n               to care and continued investment in research that brings hope to those who need it\n               most. Progress happens when we keep pushing forward together. This month reminds us that every story matters. Every life matters, so let's not simply\n               acknowledge April being Cancer Awareness Month. Let's respond to it. Let's stand with\n               those who are fighting, support those who are grieving and take real steps to protect\n               our own health and the health of those around us. When we turn awareness into thoughtful, intentional action, we do more than just raise\n               awareness. We change outcomes, we strengthen one another, and we save lives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720614","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As a cancer survivor, I know firsthand the emotional, physical toll this illness can\n               take. Cancer does not discriminate. It touches people of every age, every background,\n               every family. The reality is severe. One in two men and one in three women will face\n               a diagnosis in their lifetime. Right here in our community, there are individuals\n               an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c8836047ed210b06d5aca698d07d5ca6ac2b9df8a4c39e68d862294798377efd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e481b0382c621e404c7a82c1431e69ec64bf58813aa6f43e635f9cb3c958b395"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-660fd88ab20f1579426efa66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720616,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let's look at the minister's track record","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720616","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Let's look at the minister's track record","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46603932ace2399c87d21227a0c68f955e0efcc1fb059d096926f560d05c9c31"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3996043b270547fb147b1c0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721709,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always an honour to be able to get up and speak on different bills in this House.\n               I am honoured to be able to speak on Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026, not just in general terms but from the view of the people I represent of\n               Langley-Willowbrook. At first glance, this bill is presented as routine, as an administrative measure,\n               as a collection of minor At first glance, this bill is presented as routine, as an administrative measure,\n               as a collection of minor updates, a standard exercise in legislative maintenance.\n               It is framed as technical, procedural — even understanding. It is the kind of bill\n               that might be easy to overlook, easy to pass quickly, easy to accept at face value,\n               as these kinds of bills are often seen in the Legislative Assembly. But as is often\n               the case with comprehensive legislation, the true impact lies not in how it is described\n               but in how it operates. When we take the time, as we should, to examine its provisions carefully, a consistent\n               and concerning pattern emerges. This bill expands executive authority, reduces transparency\n               and increases sensitivity behind closed doors and weakens important procedural safeguards\n               that British Columbians rely on. For communities like Langley-Willowbrook, where families are working hard to keep up with the rising costs, where small businesses\n               are navigating uncertainty, where farmers are managing risk season by season and where\n               commuters are already stretched thin, these changes are not abstract. They are real.\n               They are immediate, and they are consequential. This is not a simple housekeeping\n               bill. This is a shift in how power is exercised in this province. Let us begin with part 1, amendments to the Judicial Review Procedure Act. This section\n               introduces a new process allowing ministers, the cabinet secretary and other senior\n               officials to certify information as a confidence of the executive council. Once that\n               certification is made, that information can be compiled into a judicial review procedure.\n               This may sound like a narrow legal change, but it goes to the very core of how accountability\n               functions in a democratic system. In Langley, government decisions are not distant abstractions. They shape the everyday\n               lives of residents. They determine how land is used, whether farmland is protected\n               or repurposed. They determine how infrastructure is built, whether roads, transit\n               and services keep pace with the growth. They determine how businesses operate through\n               regulations, permits and enforcement. When those decisions are challenged, when people believe they are unfair, unreasonable\n               or improperly made, judicial review is one of those few tools available to ensure\n               accountability. Judicial review is not about politics. It is about the rule of law.\n               It ensures that the government does not operate above scrutiny. It ensures that decisions\n               are made within the legal boundaries. It ensures that individuals have a path to challenge\n               decisions that affect their lives. But this provision alters that balance by allowing government to certify information\n               as confidential and thereby shield it from disclosure. It limits what courts can see,\n               and when courts cannot see the full picture, their ability to access decisions is\n               constrained. Let us consider what that means in practice. Imagine a Langley farmer facing a decision\n               that affects their ability to use their land. Perhaps it is related to the environmental\n               regulations, the water access or zoning restrictions. That farmer may seek judicial\n               review, but if the key information, internal reasoning, policy decisions or decision-making\n               context is withheld, how can the court fully access whether the decision was reasonable?\n               How can justice be done if part of the story is hidden? I'll give you another example. Consider a small business owner in Langley dealing\n               with regulatory decisions that impacted their operations. That business owner deserves\n               a fair process. They deserve transparency. They deserve to know how decisions were\n               made. This provision makes that more difficult. Now, to be fair, there is a place for cabinet confidentiality. Governments must be\n               able to deliberate openly to consider options, to engage in candid discussions, but\n               that confidentiality must be balanced against accountability. It must be limited in\n               scope. Now, to be fair, there is a place for cabinet confidentiality. Governments must be\n               able to deliberate openly, to consider options, to engage in candid discussions, but\n               that confidentiality must be balanced against accountability. It must be limited in\n               scope, and it must not be used in a way that shields decisions from the proper scrutiny.\n               This bill expands that without clearly strengthening the safeguards that ensure it\n               is used appropriately. And that is a very big concern because in Langley people expect\n               transparency. They expect accountability. They expect when decisions affect their\n               lives that those decisions can be examined fairly and openly. When this prediction\n               is weakened, the trust is weakened. I will be turning to part 2. We see amendments to the Fuel Price Transparency Act\n               that allows the government to impose fees, charge interest and recover unpaid amounts\n               as debt through the courts. Most notable, these fees can be applied retroactively\n               within a fiscal year. Langley is a community that runs on movement. It is a part of a major transportation\n               corridor. It is a home to logistics operations, trucking routes and supply chains\n               that connect the Lower Mainland to the rest of the province. We have Highway 1, we\n               have Highway 10, we have Glover Road, we have Fraser Highway. It is also a home to a strong agricultural sector where fuel is essential for planting,\n               harvesting and distribution. And it is a community where many residents commute long-distance to work. Yes, the\n               SkyTrain will be coming to Langley soon, but we still can't get to other parts of\n               the Lower Mainland without having to travel long distances. Fuel is not optional in Langley. It is fundamental. When governments introduce new\n               costs in the fuel sector, those costs have a ripple outward effect. They affect farmers\n               who rely on the diesel for their equipment, their farming, their transportation. They\n               affect truckers who transport goods. They affect small businesses that depend on deliveries.\n               They affect families who rely on vehicles to get to work, school and essential services. Retroactive fees add another layer of concern. Business operators operate based on\n               known rules, and I'm going to give you another example. Just today I had placed an\n               order for a delivery and that delivery had a truck.... It's a small business that had\n               delivery services. And they told me that due to fuel costs they had to increase their\n               delivery charges, or you can opt out to have their services that are available on\n               select days. That's kind of the ripple effect that happens when you operate small businesses, because\n               businesses operate based on known rules. They plan, they budget, they make decisions\n               based on the information available at the time. When those rules change after the\n               fact, it creates uncertainty and uncertainty has consequences. It discourages investment.\n               It delays expansion. I'm going to give you another example. In my riding of Langley-Willowbrook, we have a non-profit society, Langley Meals on Wheels. In Langley, they are feeling\n               it. With fuel prices nearly up by 40 percent, our dedicated volunteers are feeling that\n               impact as they work tirelessly to deliver meals to about 2,600 clients every week.\n               Each of the 133 volunteers play a vital role: that nobody goes hungry. But with uncertainty\n               these consequences can be crucial because most of these people that are receiving\n               the meals have either disability or have been just discharged from the hospital. And\n               moreover, these are usually volunteers that are checking in on these clients to make\n               sure that they're okay. Based on that, we're having a lot of problems with how much they can expand, how many\n               more clients they can take on with the fuel prices. So it makes hiring decisions more\n               difficult. For a small business in Langley, that could mean putting off growth. For a farmer,\n               it could mean tighter margins. For families, it means higher costs because, ultimately,\n               these costs are passed along. They show up in fuel prices, they show up in grocery\n               bills, and they show up in costs of goods and services. At a time when affordability is already a major concern, this is not the direction\n               we should be taking. We should be reducing uncertainty, not increasing it. We should\n               be supporting economic We also see in this part, a major change to the Zero-Emission Vehicles Act, reducing\n               the target from 100 percent to 75 percent. The people of Langley care about the environment.\n               They want clear air, they want sustainable practices and they want a future that protects\n               natural resources, but they also live with practical realities. Langley is not a dense urban centre. It is a region where distances are longer. Transit\n               options are improving, but they are not always sufficient. Like I mentioned, the SkyTrain\n               is coming, but it's not there yet. Many residents rely on personal vehicles. Electric vehicles are part of the future,\n               but the transition must be realistic. One of my colleagues that spoke before me represents\n               a rural area and spoke about how rural areas can't even think about having second\n               charging stations. Stratas are having a hard time. Those are the real conversations that we must be having.\n               We have rural areas in our province where the temperatures are different and the fuels\n               are different. So stratas are having the real conversations. Infrastructure must be in place, like my colleague just mentioned. Charging stations\n               must be accessible. So having that second chargeable in a strata, in a building is\n               important if that's the route that we want to go. Costs must be manageable. So if the original 100 percent target was not achievable,\n               then that should be acknowledged. If the revised 75 percent target is more realistic,\n               then we should explain why. Credibility matters. In Langley, people value honesty. They understand that plans\n               can evolve, but they expect transparency when they do. Quietly lowering a target without\n               explanation raises serious questions, and those questions matter. Moving on to part 3, dealing with housing and municipal affairs, we see amendments\n               that allow the province to define categories of development for reduced or waived\n               development cost charges. Housing is one of the most pressing issues in Langley. We are one of the fastest-growing\n               communities. Growth is rapid. Demand is high. Families are struggling to find affordable\n               options. We all agree that more housing is needed, but the way we achieve that also\n               really matters. These changes centralize decision-making here in Victoria. They reduce the role of\n               local governments. They move decisions into regulation, away from legislative scrutiny. In Langley, local governments understand their communities. They understand their\n               needs. They understand the infrastructure needs. They understand how development fits\n               into our long-term planning. Our community understands that. When decisions are made without their input, we risk misalignment, we risk insufficiency\n               and we risk unintended consequences. Housing requires collaboration, it requires partnership\n               and it requires transparency. Centralization without clarity does not deliver that. Changes to tenancy legislation also raises concerns. Allowing broader evidence may\n               improve flexibility, but without safeguards, it risks inconsistency. For renters in\n               Langley, disputes can determine housing stability. For landlords, it can affect financial\n               security. A fair, predictable system is essential. Flexibility must not come at the\n               expense of fairness. The university endowment land provisions reflect a broader trend. More enforcement\n               power, less appeal and greater action. These changes can improve regulation, but they\n               risk reducing oversight. In Langley, people expect fairness. They expect the ability to challenge decisions.\n               They expect accountability. Those reasonings should not be compromised. In part 4, we see changes to corrections and oversight. Public reporting is a positive\n               step, but expanded sensitivity to refuse investigations raises real concerns. Accountability must be real, it must be accessible and it must be trusted. When we\n               step back and look at this bill as a whole, the pattern is very clear. More power\n               concentrated at the centre; less transparency. When we step back and look at this bill as a whole, the pattern is very clear: more\n               power concentrated at the centre; less transparency. Greater care; reduce safeguards\n               for Langley. This matters, because people are already dealing with enough uncertainty.\n               They're dealing with rising costs, they're dealing with housing challenges, and they're\n               dealing with economic pressures. They need stability, they need clarity, and they\n               need trust in this government. Let me be very clear. Not every provision in this bill is problematic, but the overall\n               direction raises serious concerns. In Langley, people value common sense. They value\n               fairness, they value accountability, they expect government to be transparent and\n               to do the same. They expect decisions to be explained, and they expect policies to\n               reflect real life. As the official opposition, we will continue to bring those voices forward. We will\n               ask those hard questions in the committee stages. We will push for transparency. We\n               will continue to advocate for affordability. We will continue to hold this government\n               accountable. In closing, this bill may be called miscellaneous, but for the people of Langley,\n               its impacts are anything but minor. It affects fairness, it affects affordability,\n               and it affects trust. For that reason, it deserves careful scrutiny throughout, debate\n               and meaningful improvement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721709","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's always an honour to be able to get up and speak on different bills in this House.\n               I am honoured to be able to speak on Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment\n               Act, 2026, not just in general terms but from the view of the people I represent of\n               Langley-Willowbrook. At first glance, this bill is presented as routine, as an administrative measure","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d6964c339db403b83e3e42a42bd0669b51e8522afdbad798fea24eec4f60be2d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d7b033f52dfdf75c1d01a1df98da9098a531940f7af697273184d1ded415b813"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f88ee91790da65983956ba93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721715,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to present a petition regarding Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendments Act, 2026. This petition is signed by over 10,000 B.C. taxpayers demanding that the government\n               end its assault on open information and scrap Bill 9.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721715","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to present a petition regarding Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendments Act, 2026. This petition is signed by over 10,000 B.C. taxpayers demanding that the government\n               end its assault on open information and scrap Bill 9.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["804f5eecf10eb30d1055d192e4319b5ee418155e2d516fbf78fae337b0154340"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d5a57456ee0ad667dd02f06","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729502,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we celebrate Sikh Heritage Month in British Columbia, I am both honoured and proud\n               to stand before you as the only elected Sikh woman within the Conservative Party,\n               in our province and at the federal level. This moment is not just personal. It is\n               a reflection of the journey our community has travelled and the remarkable strides\n               we have made. Sikh Heritage Month is a time for us to reflect on our rich history, our vibrant culture\n               and the unwavering values that guide us. For generations, Sikhs have added to the\n               social, economic and cultural fabric of Canada. Today we are witnessing a remarkable\n               validation of this heritage, from the early days when our Sikhs helped build the railways,\n               to now, being influential figures in various sectors, we are a testament to resilience,\n               determination and the spirit of hard work. I had the immense honour of taking part in the Surrey Vaisakhi Nagar Kirtan, where over 500,000 people attended. This event marks the largest Nagar Kirtan outside\n               of India in the world and showcases the strength and unity of our community. The spirit\n               of Nagar Kirtan embodies the values of [a language other than English was spoken], selfless service, sharing, giving and community. It reminds us that our gathering\n               is not just a celebration. It is an expression As we walked together in the spirit of love and unity, I was touched by the outpouring\n               of kindness and generosity in the community — volunteers offering food, drinks and\n               assistance to all who attended, regardless of background or belief. This selfless\n               giving is the essence of our faith and service, as a reminder that true strength lies\n               in our ability to extend a helping hand to others. Reflecting on how far we have come fills me with immense pride. Just last week we\n               celebrated our beloved Punjabi singer Diljit Dosanjh, who sold out B.C. Place not\n               once but twice in the past two years. His success on stages like Coachella symbolizes\n               the progress we have made as a community, showcasing the global acceptance and appreciation\n               of our culture and talent. This weekend, Karan Aujla will be taking stage at Rogers Arena for two days, adding\n               to the excitement in our vibrant community. Artists like Diljit and Karan are not\n               just entertainers. They serve as ambassadors of our culture, inspiring countless individuals\n               within our community with their achievements. However, as we celebrate, it is vital to remember the struggles that have led us to\n               this moment. Many years ago people who look like me were not only excluded from positions\n               of power, they were not allowed to enter buildings like this one — buildings of governance\n               and decision-making that define our society. In those times, my presence here today would have been unimaginable. The very act\n               of standing here speaking on Sikh Heritage Month symbolizes years of hard-fought battles\n               against discrimination, exclusion and injustice. As a Sikh woman in a political landscape that has historically been male-dominated,\n               I understand the importance of breaking barriers. Every step I take in my political\n               career is not just for me. It is for the countless women who have come before me and\n               for those who will follow. The stories of women in our community who have fought for\n               their rights, for their families and for their faith inspire me daily. It's also about\n               giving a voice to those who have often been silent. Our faith teaches us the principles of equality, justice and service. These principles\n               are the foundation of my work in public service. The values of Sikhism urge us to\n               stand up for our beliefs and to advocate for those who may not have the same voice. As we celebrate Sikh Heritage Month, let us recognize the offerings of everyone in\n               our community. From farmers to teachers, artists to activists, each individual effort\n               gives to this beautiful mosaic that is our heritage. Let us celebrate our youth, who are the torch bearers of our future, who are making\n               their own mark through various avenues — arts, science, technology and politics. I am proud to be part of this history, and I am proud to be a Sikh woman leading in\n               a space where our voices and stories matter. I am proud that we are continuing to\n               build a future where our culture, history and achievements are celebrated, not just\n               in our communities but across the nation and around the world. As we look to the future, let us keep in mind that our true strength lies in our unity,\n               our pride in our heritage and our dedication to uplifting one another. With May just\n               around the corner, marking Asian Heritage Month, it is essential that we continue\n               to share our stories, celebrate our achievements and support the generations to come. Together, we can ensure that the legacy of our community is not just remembered but\n               cherished for many years ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729502","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As we celebrate Sikh Heritage Month in British Columbia, I am both honoured and proud\n               to stand before you as the only elected Sikh woman within the Conservative Party,\n               in our province and at the federal level. This moment is not just personal. It is\n               a reflection of the journey our community has travelled and the remarkable strides\n               we have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0b8bd104d2d760cfee8faca9b1f789830959061b3de8b50df76d65429f9255f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b036d67606b5b19e714babc9111ad3f4b2ede06cc78a90b2f2c193e675c4b9e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5771a74262fb0176a57dcc5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729504,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I often don't get visitors from my riding of Langley-Willowbrook, but there is a young lady that's super smart, talented and has been an amazing volunteer\n               at my office, Rayna Walia, who is visiting here with the B.C. parliament council. I just want the House to please make her feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729504","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I often don't get visitors from my riding of Langley-Willowbrook, but there is a young lady that's super smart, talented and has been an amazing volunteer\n               at my office, Rayna Walia, who is visiting here with the B.C. parliament council. I just want the House to please make her feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcffb997108ebf47f795a5c8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729512,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank my colleague for allowing me to ask a question. Within the Fraser Health system, there are subregions experiencing unfair funding\n               and access to services. Langley Memorial Hospital serves a population of over 200,000\n               people, but it only has 1.04 beds per 1,000 residents and faces an ICU overflow rate\n               seven times higher than other hospitals in the region. Langley Memorial Hospital's\n               second CT scanner is located off-site, leading to delays in diagnostic services for\n               patients already admitted. Most notable, there is a lack of subspecialty availability, including neurology, stroke\n               care, pediatrics and many other subspecialties. As a result, many patients, around\n               200,000, are referred outside their community for necessary care. Furthermore, regarding the second CT scanner, it's important to clarify that this\n               is a regional scanner and not actually a second scanner for Langley Memorial Hospital. Also, the new hospital — that I know we mention quite often, it's close, it's in Surrey\n               — will not solve the imaging problem or the subspecialty care that Langley needs because\n               some of the subspecialties that I mentioned will not be serving out of that hospital\n               as well. So, my question to the minister is: when will the province take action to provide\n               Langley Memorial with the essential services and subspecialty coverage that it desperately\n               needs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729512","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank my colleague for allowing me to ask a question. Within the Fraser Health system, there are subregions experiencing unfair funding\n               and access to services. Langley Memorial Hospital serves a population of over 200,000\n               people, but it only has 1.04 beds per 1,000 residents and faces an ICU overflow rate\n               seven times higher than other hospital","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf599b289987388cf7cc92eae04f98c1a9ab1b0182889eca122893ef3831c7a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b528b91f77c6bdc63dd774b5f65ff1f6e1d56ceb276ea5e5acf73116019dbe6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1d791e9dedbd890c625c4dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752355,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour to speak on Motion M207, liquor service and movie theatres. As mentioned\n               by the member from across, movie theatres have been more than just places to watch\n               films. They are gathering spaces, what many call \"third places,\" where people come\n               together outside of home and work to share stories, emotions and experiences. In an\n               increasingly digital and isolated world, these spaces matter more than ever. Yet over\n               the past few years, movie theatres have been struggling to survive. In 2012, the B.C. government took a step forward towards modernizing by allowing liquor\n               services in movie theatres. However, that policy came with some limitations. Alcohol\n               could only be served in adult-only screenings and in the lobby areas. While well-intended, these restrictions have limited the potential impact of the change\n               and have not gone far enough to support theatres facing ongoing financial challenges.\n               Allowing movie theatres to serve alcohol to responsible adults during regular screening\n               is not a threat to society. It is a moderate, practical step that could help these\n               important cultural spaces remain visible. Adults are already trusted to make responsible choices in a wide range of environments,\n               and there is no compelling reason to treat movie theatres differently. Restaurants,\n               bars and cultural events, such as concerts, Restaurants, bars and cultural events, such as concerts, all successfully serve alcohol\n               in settings where people of different ages are present. These establishments manage\n               to enforce legal drinking age requirements every day without issues. The systems and\n               practices already exist. Theatres would simply be joining a well-established framework. Moreover, this is not an uncharted territory. Other provinces, such as Alberta, already\n               allow movie theatres to serve alcohol more freely. These authorities have demonstrated\n               that it can be done responsibly, without negative impacts on public safety. At its\n               core, this is about fairness, modernization and supporting local businesses that provide\n               to our communities. Movie theatres are part of our cultural fabric. Giving them the flexibility to adapt\n               to changing consumer outcomes could make a meaningful difference in their ability\n               to survive and thrive in today's society. If we value these shared spaces and the\n               role they play in bringing people together, then we should be willing to be responsible\n               to taking steps to support them. Expanding responsible alcohol services in all movie\n               theatres, not just in small, independent ones, is one of those steps. For that reason\n               I bring forward an amendment to the motion. I rise to support an amendment to motion M207. This amendment removes the words \"small\"\n               and \"independent,\" ensuring that all movie theatres in British Columbia have the option\n               to serve alcohol during mixed-age showings. This is a simple and reasonable change. It does not require any theatre to serve alcohol.\n               It only ensures that every theatre has the same opportunity to decide what works best\n               for their business and their audience. At its core, this is about fairness. The current wording creates an uneven playing\n               field, allowing some theatres to offer a service that others cannot, despite operating\n               under the same provincial regulation. Two theatres can follow the same rules, serve\n               the same communities, and meet the same safety standards, yet only one is permitted\n               to expand its offerings. That inconsistency is difficult to justify and confusing\n               for consumers. If we believe in equal treatment, we should not be prioritizing one\n               business model over another. This is also about enhancing the movie-going experience for many adults. Going to\n               the movies is not just about watching a film. It's also a social outing — date nights.\n               The option to enjoy a glass of wine or a local craft beer can make that experience\n               more enjoyable and more complete. Larger theatres with their advanced sound systems, premium seating and established\n               service practices are just as capable of providing safe, well-mannered environments.\n               There is no compelling reason to exclude them from offering the same experience. There are economic benefits as well. Expanding this option to all theatres would encourage\n               advancement across this industry. It would allow theatres to offer their offerings,\n               remain competitive and better respond to changing consumer experience. It also opens\n               the doors for stronger partnerships with local breweries, wineries and producers,\n               giving them more opportunities to showcase British Columbian products. That supports\n               not just the theatres but local businesses and regional economics throughout this\n               province. We should also be clear about safety. Reasonable and responsible alcohol service is\n               already governed by strict provincial regulations. Staff training, age verification\n               and service standards are well-established and enforced in B.C. This amendment does\n               not weaken those protections in any way. It simply ensures that all theatres operating\n               under those rules are treated equally. Ultimately, this amendment is about consistency, fairness and choice. It supports\n               theatres of all sizes, regardless of if they're small or independent, respects the\n               ability of businesses to make reasonable and responsible decisions, and gives consumers\n               more options in how they enjoy their experiences. The question before us is simple. Do we maintain an unnecessary restriction, or do\n               we create a level playing field? I urge this House to support this amendment and allow\n               all movie theatres, to allow this motion to take place and broaden the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752355","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's an honour to speak on Motion M207, liquor service and movie theatres. As mentioned\n               by the member from across, movie theatres have been more than just places to watch\n               films. They are gathering spaces, what many call \"third places,\" where people come\n               together outside of home and work to share stories, emotions and experiences. In an\n               in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3afbf375c4fdc867daa396d08bafe7fba6480f455dbf0204562db717c7510180"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9b606959c45946f20be721b1036cf6c349114b1e0db3eaa913cbbd1e26ae27b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8d443faf1fc12ea4a0a7f19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752356,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always an honour to be able to get up in this House and debate different bills.\n               I just want to thank the member for Abbotsford South for doing an amazing job and for speaking for two hours. I also want to thank my\n               colleague from Surrey–White Rock for bringing in this hoist motion earlier today. Today I want to take this time to talk a bit more on the hoist motion that has been\n               brought forward for amendment to second reading on the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026: \"That the motion for second reading of Bill 9...be amended by deleting the word 'now' and substituting 'six months hence.'\" At first glance, this amendment may appear moderate. It does not reject the bill,\n               nor does it attempt to halt the legislative process altogether. It does not deny debate,\n               nor does it prevent this House from alternating making any kind of decisions. What\n               it asks for is something far more measured and, I would argue, far more reasonable.\n               It asks for time — time to reflect, time to listen and time to ensure that what we\n               pass in this chamber is worthy of the principles it is meant to be upheld. This is not a procedural delay; this is not an obstruction. This is a necessary pause\n               — a pause rooted in responsibility, a pause grounded in respect for the people of\n               British Columbian and a pause that reflects the seriousness of what is at stake. Bill 9 is not simple. It's not another piece of bill moving through the routine processes\n               of this House. It is not an administrative housekeeping, nor is it a minor technical\n               adjustment that can be addressed without deeper consideration. It speaks directly\n               to the relationship between government and the public. It shapes how information is\n               accessed, how decisions are scrutinized and how accountability is exercised in practice.\n               In that sense, it is not just about process; it is about principle. As I said earlier in my debate, freedom of information does not belong to government;\n               it belongs to the citizens it seeks to serve here in B.C. That principle is not new;\n               it is rooted in the very foundation of democracy itself — the idea that government\n               is accountable to the people, that authority is not owned; it is entrusted, and that\n               those who govern do so on behalf of the public, not above them. Access to information is one of the clearest expressions of that principle. It is\n               how Access to information is one of the clearest expressions of that principle. It is\n               how citizens see decisions being made, not simply after the fact but in the way that\n               allows them to understand the reasoning behind those decisions. It is how they understand\n               how the public resources are made and used. It is how they hold institutions to account. Yet I cannot count the number of times I hear from people in my community of Langley-Willowbrook who say: \"My voice doesn't matter.\" That's why this motion is important. They feel\n               decisions are made without them. They feel the system moves forward whether they are\n               heard or not. That is why this moment matters. Pausing now, choosing to take that time to listen,\n               to reflect and to get this right, sends a different message. It signals that their\n               voices do matter, that their concerns are not an afterthought, that this House is\n               willing to hear them before moving forward. Without access, accountability weakens. Without accountability, trust erodes. Without\n               trust, democracy itself begins to fracture. When we change access-to-information laws,\n               even in the small ways, we are not simply adjusting process. We are reshaping the\n               relationship between government and the public. We are redefining how power is seen,\n               how it is questioned and, ultimately, how it is held to account. Why six months matter? The question before us is simple. Why six months? Why not proceed\n               now? The answer is equally simple: because we are not ready. This is not a partisan statement. It is an observation grounded, and the government's\n               own actions prove that. The minister has already brought forward amendments to this\n               bill during the course of this debate already. That alone tells us something, something\n               very important. It tells us that the bill originally introduced was not completely thoroughly thought\n               through. It tells us that the concerns raised in this House and across this province\n               were very valid and require response. It tells us that even now, the government is\n               still adjusting its approach. If this bill were as clear and as precise, as well as understood, as the minister\n               suggests, we would not be seeing amendments mid-debate. So the question becomes: if\n               the government recognizes the need for change, is it unwilling to recognize the need\n               for time? Amendments do not solve the problem. Let us be very clear on that. The amendments\n               that have been brought forward do not address the core concerns with this bill. They\n               move language. They adjust structure. They do not resolve the underlining issues. Clause 2 still leaves critical decisions in the hands of the head of the public body\n               without clear definition. Clause 3, even with proposed removal, highlights confusion\n               in the drafting itself. Clause 13 continues to expand the ability to deny requests\n               using terms that remain undefined: \"abusive,\" \"malicious,\" \"unreasonable,\" \"broad,\"\n               \"interference.\" None of these have any sort of definition within the bill. These are not minor wording issues. These are powerful, optional tools, and when those\n               tools are not clearly defined, they create uncertainty. Uncertainty in access to information\n               does not benefit the public. It benefits the institution holding that information,\n               and that is the NDP government right now. Let us not pretend that these amendments fix the problem. They do not. They reinforce\n               the need for pause, and that is why we brought in this hoist motion today for an extension\n               for six months for revision. Here are examples of how these terms, if left undefined or loosely written, can be\n               translated in ways that can cause real harm. \"Abusive\" could be understood as a requester\n               who files multiple requests or follows up. A journalist asking repeated questions\n               on the same issue or a citizen seeking clarification after incomplete answers could\n               be labelled as abusive simply for being persistent. The risk there \"Malicious\" could be translated as intent rather than behaviour. A request that is\n               politically inconvenient, critical by government or tied to an investigation could\n               be framed as malicious, even when it is entirely legitimate. The risk there? Motive\n               becomes a tool to deny access, allowing subjective judgment to override a citizen's\n               right to know and get the information they need. \"Unreasonable\" and \"broad\" could be understood based on the capacity of the public\n               body rather than the nature of the request. A request covering a wide time frame or\n               multiple departments could be rejected, not because it lacks merit but because it\n               requires effort. The risk there? Complex or systematic issues become harder to investigate,\n               especially when they require a broader scope to understand fully. \"Interference\" could be interpreted as anything that creates pressure, workload or\n               inconvenience. A request that exposes internal decision-making, requires coordination\n               or arrives during a busy period could be seen as interfering with operations. We know\n               how things get busy in this House, but that could be referred to as interfering with\n               regular operations. The risk there? The threshold for refusal becomes tied to operational\n               comfort rather than public interest. Why does all this matter? When these terms are not clearly defined in this bill, decisions\n               shift from objective standards to subjective understanding. Power rests within the\n               institution holding the information, which is this government. Citizens are left uncertain\n               about their rights. Transparency becomes inconsistency. In practice, this creates a chilling effect. People stop asking. Journalists narrow\n               their scope. Organizations hesitate to pursue accountability, and over time, access\n               to information does not disappear outright. It simply becomes harder, slower and more\n               uncertain. That is how trust erodes. In 2022, special committee report.... We do not have to guess what good reform looks\n               like. We already have a roadmap. In 2022, the Special Committee to Review the Freedom\n               of Information and Protection of Privacy Act brought forward a comprehensive report\n               — a report grounded in consultation, a report built on evidence, a report focused\n               on strengthening transparency and accountability. And yet, here we are debating this\n               bill that does not fully reflect that work, that does not uphold anything that was\n               reported in that 2022 special committee review. A six-month extension would allow this House to properly align Bill 9 with those recommendations,\n               ensuring that the changes we make are consistent with the evidence in the consultation\n               that have already taken place during that 2022 special committee report, not selectively,\n               not partially, but meaningfully, because modernization should not be rushed. It should\n               be right. We're already seeing with those amendments brought forward by the minister\n               that things are not right with this bill. Modernization is very important, but it must be done carefully. It must be done in\n               a way that strengthens the system rather than introducing new uncertainties. We need to listen to British Columbians. This debate is not happening in isolation.\n               Thousands of British Columbians have expressed concerns about this bill. A few weeks\n               ago, I tabled a petition with over 10,000 signatures from B.C. citizens. Their concerns\n               came from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. They got these signatures within a week\n               before I tabled them. We need to listen to those stakeholders, we need to listen to\n               those citizens, we need to understand their concerns regarding this bill. Journalists, advocacy organizations, Indigenous communities, legal experts and everyday\n               citizens are confused. Thousands of British Columbians have expressed concerns about\n               this bill. Thousands of British Columbians have expressed concerns about this bill. They are\n               not confused. They are not misunderstood. They are very much engaged, and they are\n               asking those hard questions. They're asking for something that is very reasonable:\n               time to be heard; time to understand how these changes will affect them; time to provide\n               input before decisions are finalized. A six-month pause creates space for that, because\n               bills that affect public rights should not move faster than the public understanding. Trust is built through process. This bill raises important questions about transparency.\n               But how we pass this bill is just as important as what is inside of it. If we move\n               forward too quickly — despite unresolved concerns, despite incomplete alignment with\n               prior recommendations from the special committee in 2022, despite ongoing amendments\n               and incomplete alignment with the prior work — we send a message that process does\n               not matter, that speed is being prioritized over substance. That message is that process\n               does not matter. But process does matter, because trust is not built by saying: \"We're transparent.\"\n               It is built by demonstrating it. A six-month delay is not a sign of weakness. It is a demonstration of confidence.\n               Confidence that this bill can withstand scrutiny, which will strengthen this bill.\n               Confidence that input will improve it when we listen to our stakeholders, when we\n               listen to B.C. citizens that can bring up their concerns. Confidence that getting\n               things right matters more than getting things done quickly. This is the government's position. The minister has stated that the bill maintains\n               strong access to information, that it does not change timelines and that it does not\n               restrict legislative requests. If this is true, then there should be no concern with\n               taking additional time. Strong legislation does not fear review. Strong legislation\n               welcomes it. Again, the question becomes: if there is nothing to fix, why were there amendments\n               needed? Why did the minister table amendments mid-debate? And if amendments were needed,\n               why is more time not justified? Real-world impact requires careful work. Earlier in the debate, we spoke about how\n               even small changes in language can have real-world consequences. My colleagues have\n               given many examples. We spoke about timing, we spoke about access, and we spoke about\n               accountability. Those impacts do not happen in theory. They happen to real people. A parent seeking answers. A parent files a request to understand why their child's\n               special education support was reduced mid-year. We've been seeing this right now with\n               autism funding. A lot of parents have a lot of concerns and are trying to access information\n               through FOI. They are told the responses will come without delay — unreasonable delay. Weeks pass, then months. By the time the records arrive, the school year is nearly\n               over. The opportunity to advocate is gone. That child has already gone without support,\n               and a decision that could have been challenged in real time is now a simple fact that\n               cannot be undone. Another example. A journalist investigating public spending. A journalist uncovers\n               early signs of a cost overturn on a major infrastructure project funded by taxpayers.\n               They file a request for internal communication and decisions record. The response\n               is delayed. Not denied but delayed — just delayed. In that time, that project moves\n               forward. Contracts are extended. Public messaging is sent. By the time the documents are released, the story has passed its moment. What would\n               have been front page accountability becomes a retroactive article. What could have\n               triggered scrutiny becomes footnote. And the public loses the chance to ask questions\n               when it mattered the most. A business trying to understand procurement decisions. A small local company believes\n               a government contract was awarded under unclear critic. They request documentation\n               to understand how the decision was made. A business trying to understand procurement decisions. A small, local company believes\n               a government contract was awarded under unclear critic. They request documentations\n               to understand how the decision was made. The response comes after the next round of\n               contracts has already been issued. They miss their chance to adjust, compete or challenge\n               the process. Larger players continue to dominate, and the confidence in fairness begins\n               to erode. Why this all matters? Delay is not neutral. It shifts outcomes. It limits\n               action. It reduces accountability in the moment when it matters the most. That is exactly why this cannot be rushed. That is exactly why the member for Surrey–White Rock has put in this hoist motion to make sure that we have the six months to understand,\n               to make sure that this bill is thoroughly examined and we have discussions with different\n               stakeholders and citizens put in their input and their concerns are actually being\n               reviewed and seen. That is what six months allows us. A six-month extension would allow for meaningful consultations with stakeholders,\n               proper review and implementation of the 2022 special committee recommendations that\n               haven't been taken into consideration with this bill right now, clear definitions\n               to be developed and debated, the alignment between government intent and legislative\n               language, transparency in how power will be applied. Most importantly, it allows for\n               reflection, not just within this government but across this House and across the province,\n               across all British Columbians. This is not about delay. It is about responsibility. We're not asking to stop this\n               bill. We're asking to strengthen it. We're asking to ensure that when it passes, it\n               reflects the values it claims to uphold — transparency, accountability and public\n               trust. Once this bill is passed, its effects will not be temporary. They will shape\n               how information is accessed for years to come. That is not something we should rush.\n               That is something we should definitely look through. I understand that the minister has also taken out clause 3, deleting clause 3 and\n               making changes to clause 13 and making changes to clause 2, but that's just not enough.\n               Clearly, the minister sees flaws in this bill and sees that there are things that\n               are of concern to citizens. Those things are not something small. As I just mentioned,\n               once this bill passes, it takes effect, it will not be temporarily. They will become\n               the law, and that is very worrisome for a lot of people and British Columbians that\n               have brought their concerns forward. This amendment is simple. Replace \"now\" with \"six months hence.\" This amendment is\n               simple in its wording, but major in its implication. It asks us to choose care over\n               speed, reflection over assumption and trust over convenience. In closing, what it represents is major. It represents a decision about how we legislate.\n               We do move quickly, or do we move carefully? Do we prioritize timelines, or do we\n               prioritize trust? Do we assume we are right, or do we take the time to make sure we\n               are? Freedom of information is not a technical matter. It is a democratic principle and\n               a democratic principle deserves careful consideration and a democratic principle deserves\n               the time required to uphold this government properly. Six months is not too much to\n               ask. We are doing this on other bills, as indicated, because we need that time. We need\n               that time in consultations. We need that time to discuss with different stakeholders.\n               In fact, given what is at stake, that is the least we can do right now. We can take that six months to thoroughly go over this bill and make sure that there\n               are no flaws, make sure that we do talk to the citizens of B.C., British Columbians,\n               and we talk to the stakeholders that have concerns. Clearly, the minister had concerns\n               with the language and clause in this bill, and that's why there were amendments that\n               were put forward mid-debate. I would really hope that we take this hoist I would really hope that we take this hoist motion into consideration and really have\n               the minister and the other side take direction of what we're asking for and why we're\n               asking for the six months. We really want to make sure that every citizen is heard\n               and their concerns are put forward and we clearly do that consultation and make this\n               bill stronger, not have it weakened.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752356","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's always an honour to be able to get up in this House and debate different bills.\n               I just want to thank the member for Abbotsford South for doing an amazing job and for speaking for two hours. I also want to thank my\n               colleague from Surrey–White Rock for bringing in this hoist motion earlier today. Today I want to take this time to talk a bit more on the hoist motion","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["141ef4c9de9ca066166a77d2f4b473a219d9b8de87f2b87ca787351c59f9c57d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6eb5348cda227e34eedcf52a2fd0f5901839ca55df32797cd6bf11ac106dee5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6488f3dede49e7bf2e9b9542","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752357,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions today. A school group from my riding of Langley-Willowbrook. The school's name is Belmont Elementary, visiting with their grade 5 students. There\n               are 26 grade 5ers and 6 adults visiting with their teacher, Mr. Ronald. Can the House please make them feel welcome. My second introduction. The World Sikh Organization of Canada is in the chamber today.\n               The organization serves as a vital platform for advocating for our rights, promoting\n               equality, ensuring that our voices are heard. Can the House please make them feel welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752357","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two introductions today. A school group from my riding of Langley-Willowbrook. The school's name is Belmont Elementary, visiting with their grade 5 students. There\n               are 26 grade 5ers and 6 adults visiting with their teacher, Mr. Ronald. Can the House please make them feel welcome. My second introduction. The World Sikh Organization of Canada is in the chamber today.\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b564c5d4a695d852938202d95de5fc7607207ab40c23b87fe08e91898ed268c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db75514a3c43bd7b343d543d079c99255b4c790fd406939759f66db7f1a8758d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34c16cb96074a4814b754582","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752358,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"As Mother's Day is this Sunday, May 10, I find myself reflecting not only as an MLA\n               but as a mother of two beautiful daughters, Nya and Jaya. Motherhood has taught me\n               many things, but perhaps the greatest lesson is this. Motherhood is not about perfection.\n               It is about showing up — showing up when you're tired, showing up when life feels\n               overwhelming, showing up when your children need strength, guidance, encouragement\n               or simply someone to listen. Often, the moments that shape a child most are not the grand moments. They're the\n               quiet ones, the everyday acts of love, sacrifice, patience and persistence that may\n               go unseen by the world but are never forgotten by a child. There is a poem by George Cooper that says: \"Hundreds of butterflies on the lawn but\n               only one mother the wide world over.\" As a mother myself, there are moments that remind\n               me just how deep that connection truly is. No matter how busy life becomes, no matter\n               how heavy the responsibilities of this role can feel, hearing the voices of my daughters\n               has a way of grounding me instantly. Their laughter, their words, even the simple\n               moments of conversations have a way of putting life back into outlook. I often think about my own mother and the example she set for me. Her strength, her\n               resilience and the way she carried herself through difficult seasons helped shape\n               the woman I am today. So much of who we become begins long before we realize, through the quiet influence\n               of mothers who teach us not only through words but through the way she lives, sacrifices\n               and loves. I want to recognize biological mothers who carried, nurtured, protected; the stepmothers\n               who chose love, patience and commitment, building trust over time and stepping into\n               families with grace; the adopted mothers who remind us that motherhood is defined\n               not only by biology but by devotion; grandmothers who hold families together through\n               wisdom, prayer and quiet strength. Motherhood in all its forms is rarely about perfection. It is about presence. Your\n               love shapes families, your strength shapes communities and your presence shapes generations.\n               Happy Mother's Day. Your love shapes families, your strength shapes communities, and your presence shapes\n               generations. Happy Mother's Day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752358","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As Mother's Day is this Sunday, May 10, I find myself reflecting not only as an MLA\n               but as a mother of two beautiful daughters, Nya and Jaya. Motherhood has taught me\n               many things, but perhaps the greatest lesson is this. Motherhood is not about perfection.\n               It is about showing up — showing up when you're tired, showing up when life feels\n               o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c0978ee001f67cd11d8507d4c2177c587641d91d82e027a46cce15333db928c6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["05e574325ede3b27b16a156c06e6f909795396f04ab8a7a3bd5ccd6ffb375838"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52ee7a046ce555e2c6ee8b52","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036592,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"Over the course of this discussion, one thing has become very clear. This motion is\n               not simply about serving alcohol in movie theatres; it's about how we balance modernization\n               with responsibility, economic opportunity with community standards, and consumer choice\n               with public confidence. The amendment to Motion M207 removes the words \"small\" and \"independent,\" ensuring\n               that all movie theatres in B.C. have the option to serve alcohol during mixed-age\n               showings. No one is denying that movie theatres have faced real challenges in recent years.\n               They are important gathering spaces in our communities, and many are working hard\n               to adapt in a rapid, changing entertainment landscape. No one is denying that movie theatres have faced real challenges in recent years.\n               They are important gathering spaces in our communities, and many are working hard\n               to adapt in a rapid, changing entertainment landscape. The question before us, however,\n               is not whether theatres matter. The question is whether expanding alcohol service\n               into regular mixed-age screening is the right solution. Do we maintain an unnecessary\n               restriction, or do we create a level playing field? Throughout debate, important questions were raised about public safety, family environments,\n               enforcement standards, economic impact and the long-term cultural shift this may create.\n               Those questions deserve thoughtful answers, because when government expands alcohol\n               service into mixed-age environments, it sets a standard that will certainly lead to\n               pressure for similar changes in other public spaces. At the same time, we also heard arguments about fairness and consistency from this\n               side. If theatres are already operating under provincial liquor regulations, then\n               government must clearly explain why some businesses are treated differently from others.\n               That inconsistency has been part of this debate as well. At its core, this is about fairness. The current wording creates an uneven playing\n               field allowing some theatres to offer a service that others cannot, despite operating\n               under the same provincial regulations. Ultimately, this discussion extends beyond movie theatres themselves. It is about\n               how we balance economic interests with the responsibility to maintain community spaces\n               that reflect the standards and values British Columbians expect. There are economic benefits as well. Expanding this option to all theatres would encourage\n               advancement across the industry. It would allow theatres to diverse their offerings,\n               remain competitive and better respond to changing consumer experience. As legislators, our responsibility is not simply to follow trends or assume every\n               expansion is automatically progression. Our responsibility is to ask careful questions,\n               examine consequences and ensure that any change we make genuinely serves the public. For that reason, I appreciate the discussion that has taken place here today and a\n               few weeks ago and the thoughtful input from all members of all sides of this chamber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036592","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Over the course of this discussion, one thing has become very clear. This motion is\n               not simply about serving alcohol in movie theatres; it's about how we balance modernization\n               with responsibility, economic opportunity with community standards, and consumer choice\n               with public confidence. The amendment to Motion M207 removes the words \"small\" and \"indepen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45be640f060ebf5db9071725180442b2848d68807c1a559f4c75566ca3d2c770"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e870b617746ea14a1101c5518c76b0ea0bda16cc6c405e35738adcc5a6d90d34"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55e2b8ba94bcfc843996ef16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036593,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"I don't often get visitors, especially family or loved ones, but today is a very\n               special day. My parents are visiting, and they're here watching question period for\n               the first time. I just want to take a moment to express my gratitude for everything that you guys\n               have done for me, being my parents — your love, your support and your guidance. Especially\n               when I felt that I doubted myself, you guys were always there to support me. For that\n               I am forever in gratitude and indebted to you guys. I want to thank you from the bottom\n               of my heart. There's not enough words to describe the love I have for both of you. Thank you for being amazing parents. I love you both.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036593","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I don't often get visitors, especially family or loved ones, but today is a very\n               special day. My parents are visiting, and they're here watching question period for\n               the first time. I just want to take a moment to express my gratitude for everything that you guys\n               have done for me, being my parents — your love, your support and your guidance. Especially\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06d41bc524c35c6cf71afd66","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036594,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jody Toor","venue":"Hansard","text":"On behalf of the Conservative caucus, we would like to take a moment to express our\n               gratitude to our hard-working and dedicated executive assistants and legislative assistants.\n               Your tireless efforts are truly valued and appreciated. Thank you for everything that\n               you guys do for each and every one of us and everything that you have done for us\n               this session. Without you guys, we would be lost. Thank you so much for everything\n               that you have done for everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036594","member_id":"bc-mla-381","member_name":"Jody Toor","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On behalf of the Conservative caucus, we would like to take a moment to express our\n               gratitude to our hard-working and dedicated executive assistants and legislative assistants.\n               Your tireless efforts are truly valued and appreciated. Thank you for everything that\n               you guys do for each and every one of us and everything that you have done for us\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["468878e572dbd2c6cb399a00794d2be9f8e6035e27fd48eb8ec204b24b485b8f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9bd7175dcce2966771d6654c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328019,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to pay tribute to an organization that has quietly and consistently shaped\n               the character of our community for decades, and that is the Meadow Ridge Rotary Club. In Pitt Meadows, Maple Ridge and across the province, service clubs form the backbone\n               of civic life. What sets Meadow Ridge Rotary Club apart is not just what they do;\n               it is how they do it with humility and dedication and also with an unwavering belief\n               that strong communities are built through service above self. Rotary's global motto, \"Service above self,\" is more than a slogan. It is a lived\n               principle. The members of the Meadow Ridge Rotary have dedicated themselves to countless\n               volunteer hours, to initiatives that strengthen families, support youth and uplift\n               those facing hardship. They are motivated not by recognition but by responsibility. Over the years, this club has supported local schools, youth leadership programs,\n               food security initiatives and community events that bring neighbours together. They\n               have invested in in the next generation, understanding that mentorship and opportunity\n               are among the greatest gifts we can offer to young people. Whether through scholarships,\n               sponsorships or hands-on volunteerism, they have demonstrated a steadfast commitment\n               to building brighter futures. Rotary brings together business leaders, professionals, retirees and community advocates,\n               all united by a common purpose. I want to thank the past and present members of the Meadow Ridge Rotary Club for continuing\n               to make Pitt Meadows and Maple Ridge a place we are all proud to call home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328019","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to pay tribute to an organization that has quietly and consistently shaped\n               the character of our community for decades, and that is the Meadow Ridge Rotary Club. In Pitt Meadows, Maple Ridge and across the province, service clubs form the backbone\n               of civic life. What sets Meadow Ridge Rotary Club apart is not just what they do;\n               it is how the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["574ca016118ada7a2f4bead788ca2e5aa61558db03eb65eb38708df6115dab8c","c25aae5b5997d97df7bfe929e3b2a033eb5879710bcebac06814dca58a619dcc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ddeb1dcc8f343332dc05f709e626b4d33169ff6227f1e51c84ddcc13b616c5a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2130f7638833dcc9a71da2f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328020,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today is my good friend Rick Cameron, who is visiting the Legislature\n               for the first time. Will the House please join me in giving him a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328020","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the gallery today is my good friend Rick Cameron, who is visiting the Legislature\n               for the first time. Will the House please join me in giving him a very warm welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-46f65363db32644904647e7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328021,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"Ridge Meadows Hospital is yet another case of mothers being left in limbo by this\n               government. Between February 26 and March 2, this hospital experienced a maternity\n               ward closure for 96 hours. Yes. This isn't the first time. This is the fourth time\n               in less than three months. How many more maternity ward closures does this Premier allow in my riding before\n               he fires the Health Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328021","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Ridge Meadows Hospital is yet another case of mothers being left in limbo by this\n               government. Between February 26 and March 2, this hospital experienced a maternity\n               ward closure for 96 hours. Yes. This isn't the first time. This is the fourth time\n               in less than three months. How many more maternity ward closures does this Premier allow in my riding befor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e0d17423a2fccb3c93e872e92923f26f48f2636f935256b860105c397524c771"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6100161e7aa50401501078553bd4d305f19278cbda3bd39c6a9e577e158a90d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4171f9f837793e969120f733","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360418,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery, I have three visitors from Maple Ridge. They are visiting the Legislature\n               for the first time. Over there,","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360418","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the gallery, I have three visitors from Maple Ridge. They are visiting the Legislature\n               for the first time. Over there,","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94ffbaa7f362f3f24c5d58059db60845a664681eb83be59452f1fdacb36733c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e174020ff4b9102c2458053e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360419,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to introduce my two good friends from Maple Ridge, Gordon Wilson and\n               his wife, Mary. Gordon was once an advisor to B.C. Premier Bill Bennett, and he was\n               also once a mayor of Maple Ridge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360419","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to introduce my two good friends from Maple Ridge, Gordon Wilson and\n               his wife, Mary. Gordon was once an advisor to B.C. Premier Bill Bennett, and he was\n               also once a mayor of Maple Ridge.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b17a19b3776ad62a240e8e98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415784,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the important work of Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows Community\n               Services, a non-profit organization that has been supporting our community for over\n               52 years. Last year alone more than one in five residents in Maple Ridge and Pitt\n               Meadows accessed support through community services programs. In total, the organization\n               served more than 28,000 individuals, delivered almost 24,000 meals to seniors, and\n               provided 3,500 visits and wellness checks to vulnerable people, a clear indication\n               of the growing need in our community and the trust people place in this organization. As a non-profit society, Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows Community Services relies on government\n               funding, community donations and strong partnerships with individuals, families, community\n               groups and organizations to deliver essential programs that thousands of residents\n               depend on every year. Through more than 30 vital programs such as the Neurodiversity\n               Week in March and the happy B.C. Family Day in February, Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows\n               Community Services provides mental health counselling, youth and family supports,\n               seniors services, legal and victim services and community rehab programs. Behind every one of these numbers is a person, a youth struggling with mental health,\n               a senior living alone, a family facing crisis, or someone experiencing homelessness.\n               Today I'd like to ask the House to please recognize and support the vital role of\n               Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows Community Services, who are committed to showing up for people.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415784","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the important work of Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows Community\n               Services, a non-profit organization that has been supporting our community for over\n               52 years. Last year alone more than one in five residents in Maple Ridge and Pitt\n               Meadows accessed support through community services programs. In total, the organization\n               se","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e1511f6df1b425ec5100a7e8329d89a3bcb98c0b04654890f6edef71fe7fffb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c386318f81ac199c08cc37515d15ee7ba276b8434e857507eabdb404ddb6d6a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d315d87657182dc04c51a9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721566,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have the privilege to introduce my two good friends John and Nancy. They are visiting the Legislative Assembly for the first time and also to watch\n               our parliamentary democracy working at its finest during question period. Will the House please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721566","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I have the privilege to introduce my two good friends John and Nancy. They are visiting the Legislative Assembly for the first time and also to watch\n               our parliamentary democracy working at its finest during question period. Will the House please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25f016c7c90e019078a3647054a382efa1ec0e0f8628384efe6cf88f3c700044"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3ca094e8b30046019da12f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752299,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak about the importance of the trade relationship within","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752299","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak about the importance of the trade relationship within","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034887","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Domestic trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034887","label":"Domestic trade","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44344","label":"Trade","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e69c39bc36f03dca208b80657a380f114ae278071138b9bdb18bb380d3ec988"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a13df7e583b261eb85836dd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752300,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is a privilege to rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At its core, this legislation asks us to\n               confront a fundamental tension in modern governance — how we as British Columbians\n               balance efficiency with accountability and innovation with privacy. For decades, British Columbia's access-to-information framework has rested on a simple\n               but yet powerful principle, and that is that government information belongs ultimately\n               to the public, except in clearly justified circumstances. Bill 9 does not abandon that principle, but it undeniably reshapes it. As Thomas Jefferson\n               once said: \"Information is the currency of democracy.\" And if that is true, and I\n               believe it is, then any change to how information is accessed or withheld is not just\n               merely technical. It is also constitutional in spirit. It affects not just how government\n               operates but how it is held to account. As we examine Bill 9 clause by clause, we must do so not only with an eye to administrative\n               convenience but also with a deeper question in mind. What kind of relationship do\n               we want between citizens and their government in this digital age that we live in? Let us begin with clause 1, which amends section 3. This clause removes access rights\n               under FIPPA, the acronym for Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act,\n               for records that are required to be produced as part of legal proceedings, even if\n               those records are only broadly categorized. On the surface, this may seem reasonable. After all, litigation processes already\n               include disclosure mechanisms. There is a legitimate argument that parallel FOI requests\n               could duplicate effort, increase cost or interfere with court processes. But let us be clear about the consequence. This amendment creates a new exclusion\n               category, not just a procedural refinement but a substantive limitation on access\n               rights. It means that certain records, once tied to a proceeding, are no longer accessible\n               through FOI at all. I can understand that the benefit here is efficiency. However, the risk is opacity.\n               Legal proceedings do not always guarantee the same breadth of public access as FOI\n               laws. In some cases, they may be narrower, slower or subject to strategic withholding. So while this clause may streamline government operations, it may also create a gap\n               in transparency, particularly for journalists, watchdogs or public interest researchers\n               who are not parties to the proceeding. Moving on to clause 2, which amends section 5. This change shifts the standard for\n               a valid request. It now requires that in the opinion of the head of the public body,\n               the request contains sufficient detail to locate the records in a reasonable time. There is a practical logic here. Government institutions handle thousands of requests\n               every day, and vague or overly broad submissions can be burdensome. But this clause\n               does something subtle yet significant. It introduces a subjective threshold. The decision\n               is no longer purely objective. It rests within the institution itself. That raises a real concern. What one official considers reasonable detail another\n               may not. And for applicants, especially ordinary citizens without legal or technical\n               expertise, this may create uncertainty or even discourage participation. Yes, this\n               provision may reduce administrative strain, but it also risks tilting the balance\n               of power toward the gatekeeper. Moving to clause 3, and clause 3 is perhaps one of the most consequential changes\n               in tone. The requirement to respond without delay is now replaced with \"without unreasonable\n               delay.\" At first glance, this may seem like minor wording, but I can assure you it\n               is not minor wording. Without delay is a clear directive. Without unreasonable delay\n               introduces interpretation. What is unreasonable delay? Does it mean 30 days, 60 days\n               or 90 days? This change provides flexibility to public bodies dealing with complex or high-volume\n               requests. That is a legitimate administrative need. But from the applicant's perspective,\n               it weakens a firm guarantee. In effect, it shifts the system from a duty-driven model\n               to a justification-driven one. The burden thusly moves from the government to explain\n               delay to the applicant to challenge it. Clauses 4, 5 and 6 refine procedural elements. They clarify what constitutes a valid\n               request, allow extensions with applicant consent and remove lack of detail as a reason\n               for extending timelines. I agree that there are genuine positives here. Allowing consent-based extensions introduces\n               flexibility and collaboration between applicants and public bodies. Removing lack\n               of detail as a reason for extension may encourage earlier clarification rather than\n               prolonged delay. But again, the pattern persists — greater discretion for institutions\n               coupled with less rigid timelines. We now arrive at clause 7, which introduces section 16.1. This provision allows public\n               bodies to refuse disclosure of communications from judicial officers regarding policies,\n               programs or legislation. There is a defensible rationale. Judicial independence is a cornerstone of our system,\n               and informal communications between judges and government could raise concerns if\n               disclosed. However, this clause creates a new and broad exemption. It does not merely\n               protect judicial decisions that are already well established but extends to communications\n               about policy and legislation. This raises several important questions. Where is the line drawn between legitimate\n               confidentiality and the public's right to understand how laws are shaped? Could this\n               provision shield discussions that ought to be subject to scrutiny? This is a clause\n               that, while grounded in principle, must be approached with great caution. Clauses 8 through 12 and especially clause 20 introduce perhaps the most transformative\n               element of the bill, the concept of a Clauses 8 through 12 and especially clause 20 introduce, perhaps, the most transformative\n               elements of the bill, the concept of a connected services provider. This is, in essence,\n               a framework for integrated digital government. Under these provisions, designated\n               entities can build centralized platforms, share personal information across public\n               bodies, identify eligibility for services and deliver programs more seamlessly. Let us acknowledge the promise here. This could mean fewer forms, faster service delivery\n               and a more citizen-centred experience. Imagine a system where applying for one benefit\n               automatically assesses eligibility for others. That is not trivial. It is meaningful\n               progress. The same system also raises profound concerns. This is large-scale data sharing, authorized\n               across institutions, potentially involving third-party service providers. The minister is granted significant authority to direct what data is shared, how it\n               is shared and under what conditions. The Privacy Commissioner is notified and may\n               review but is not always required to approve. So we must ask the important question\n               here. Are the safeguards proportionate to the scale of the system? Centralization increases efficiency, but it also amplifies risks, like the risk of\n               data breaches, the risk of misuse, the risk of function creep, where data collected\n               for one purpose is used for another. This is not an argument against modernization.\n               It is an argument for robust oversight to match technological ambition. Clause 13 amends section 43. It expands the grounds for disregarding requests to include\n               those deemed abusive or malicious, repetitious or excessively broad. That is a clear\n               benefit. Public bodies should not be overwhelmed by bad-faith requests that consume\n               disproportionate resources. The challenge lies in definition and application. What constitutes abusive? What is\n               excessively broad? These terms are so inherently subjective. Without careful oversight,\n               there is a risk that legitimate, persistent or investigative requests, particularly\n               from journalists, could be swept into these categories. The line between efficiency\n               and suppression is thin, and this clause walks that thin line. Clauses 12 and 14 allow the Privacy Commissioner to share information with counterparts\n               in other jurisdictions and enter into information-sharing agreements. This reflects\n               a modern reality. Privacy issues often cross borders. It is in many ways a positive\n               development, enabling coordination, consistency and shared experience and expertise.\n               But again, it introduces complexity. Information that was once confined within a single\n               jurisdiction may now move beyond it. Safeguards must ensure that this does not dilute\n               protections. Clause 15 allows the Privacy Commissioner to extend review timelines beyond 90 days.\n               This acknowledges operational realities. Complex cases take time, but from the applicant's\n               perspective, it may mean longer waits for resolution, particularly in contentious\n               cases. Justice delayed, as the saying goes, can be justice denied. Clauses 21 and 22 allow public bodies and ministries to proactively release categories\n               of records without requiring formal requests. This is in many ways one of the more\n               positive elements of the bill. Proactive disclosure reduces barriers, increases transparency\n               and aligns with best practices in open government. Even here, there is nuance. Public bodies may charge fees for access to these records,\n               and the decision of what to release remains within their control. While this may seem\n               like a step forward, in my view, it is not a substitute for a robust In conclusion, when we step back from the clause-by-clause analysis, a clear pattern\n               starts to emerge. This bill modernizes service delivery, increases administrative\n               flexibility and enables digital integration. But it also narrows access rights, expands\n               government discretion and introduces new privacy risks. Yes, it does not dismantle\n               FIPPA, but it certainly rebalances it. The centre of gravity has shifted from strict\n               accountability toward operational efficiency, from rigid timelines toward flexible\n               interpretation, and from siloed data toward integrated systems. The question is not whether these changes are entirely good or bad. They are neither.\n               The question is whether the balance is right. Do the efficiencies gained justify the\n               risk introduced? Are the safeguards strong enough to maintain public trust? Will British\n               Columbians feel more empowered, or do they feel more distant from the institutions\n               that serve them? These are not abstract concerns. They go to the heart of democratic governance because\n               access to information is not merely a procedural right. It is the means by which citizens\n               hold power to account. Privacy is not merely a technical issue. It is the foundation\n               of personal autonomy in the digital world that we live in. If we are to move forward with legislation of this scope, we must do so with caution\n               and vigilance. We must ensure that discretion does not become arbitrariness, efficiency\n               does not come at the cost of transparency, and innovation does not outpace accountability.\n               Because once public trust is eroded, it is not easily restored. Let us therefore approach Bill 9 not as a routine update, but as a defining moment\n               in how we govern information, privacy and power in this province. Let us ensure that\n               whatever reforms we adopt, they leave our institutions not only more efficient but\n               more accountable, more transparent and more worthy of the public's confidence. I rest my case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752300","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is a privilege to rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. At its core, this legislation asks us to\n               confront a fundamental tension in modern governance — how we as British Columbians\n               balance efficiency with accountability and innovation with privacy. For decades, British Columbia's acces","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2083b221052b6f52b70a8447bde3c9f9cd460f281b3227031b045a4869e21fad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6adfa12cd7edcf774ec2171ecbc7e110bde1bf514fe7e6d13a9b6f4609a1d9b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83fd17ab6d166d305735580a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752301,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise in support of the hoist motion on Bill 9. At the outset, I want to be very\n               clear about what this motion is and what this motion is not. This motion is not about\n               defeating Bill 9. I want to repeat again that this motion is not about defeating Bill\n               9. It is not about preventing government from pursuing reform. It is not about denying\n               that improvements to the freedom-of-information system may be needed. The hoist motion before this House is about something much more specific and much\n               more responsible. It is about pausing consideration of Bill 9 for six months, which\n               is not a long period of time, so that the legislation can be improved, can be clarified,\n               can be properly scrutinized before it proceeds further. That is why I strongly support this hoist motion. I have no intention to stop the\n               bill at all, but to ensure that when this House ultimately votes on it, it is doing\n               so on legislation that is precise, that is fair, and that is consistent with the democratic\n               right of British Columbians to access government information. A hoist motion exists for exactly this kind of situation. It is a procedural tool\n               used when members believe a bill requires further work, further consultation and further\n               examination before it can responsibly become law. It is not an obstruction tool. Instead,\n               it is a refinement tool. It exists precisely because this House should not confuse\n               speed with good law-making. Good legislation is not measured by how quickly it is being implemented. It is measured\n               by whether it withstands scrutiny, whether it protects rights and whether it earns\n               public confidence over time. Freedom of information is one of those rights. As former federal Information Commissioner John Reid once emphasized, secrecy in government\n               is not a neutral condition. It directly affects public trust and democratic accountability. Former Information Commissioner Suzanne Lagarde has similarly emphasized that transparency\n               only has meaning when access is timely and effective because delayed access is often\n               denied access in practice. These are not abstract principles. They are the very foundation of how British Columbians\n               hold their government accountable. British Columbians have a right to know what their\n               government is doing in their name and with their money. Journalists rely on that right\n               to investigate decisions. Researchers rely on it to evaluate public policies. Ordinary\n               citizens rely on it to understand decisions that affect their communities. Let's talk about definitions, because definitions matter. How do you present a bill\n               without definitions? What does \"reasonable time frame\" mean? What does \"without reasonable\n               delay\" mean? Is it 30 days? Is it 60 days? Is it 90 days? Or is it six months? I was an engineer. Presenting a bill without definitions is like telling a crane operator\n               to lift something without telling them how heavy the load is. How heavy is that weight?\n               \"Oh, no one defined it. We have no idea how heavy that weight is.\" If you don't know\n               how heavy that weight is, we will not know what tools we need to lift the load. We\n               don't know how to prepare for it. If we don't have clear definitions, a crane could\n               kill someone. The crane operator wouldn't know how to handle the machinery properly. Presenting a bill without definitions is irresponsible. It's more than irresponsible.\n               It is a risk to the public. The member for Cariboo-Chilcotin, my colleague, spent hours in this House asking about definitions. His questions\n               have gone unanswered. That's why I strongly support this hoist motion, because six\n               additional months will allow this legislation to be properly reviewed, to be properly\n               improved and to be aligned with the core democratic principle that access to information\n               should be the rule and not the exception. Former Information and Privacy Commissioner for British Columbia David Loukidelis has repeatedly emphasized — he has said time and time again — that access-to-information\n               laws must be interpreted and designed in a manner that favours disclosure, because\n               the public interest is served when government is open and transparent, not when it\n               is closed and hides in secrecy. Transparent government means a government that is\n               accountable, accountable to British Columbians, because they deserve it. That principle is at the heart of the concerns raised about Bill 9. This bill introduces\n               language changes and new discretionary powers that deserve very careful examination.\n               It replaces the obligation to respond without delay with a requirement Madam Speaker, I notice some distractions from the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752301","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise in support of the hoist motion on Bill 9. At the outset, I want to be very\n               clear about what this motion is and what this motion is not. This motion is not about\n               defeating Bill 9. I want to repeat again that this motion is not about defeating Bill\n               9. It is not about preventing government from pursuing reform. It is not about denying\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7d04989413cf192749aef9280075eab9d4b6409a16b5e4cb1fbe50df31a6dd3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cdd79ef0575a6b0f5274dbecb35d68e5c7a1cd9045223c9e1c81a3dc19817d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f3c933713c6213515a89a93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752303,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"B.C. taxpayers have been billed nearly $300,000 in the last five months to fly inmates\n               to and from court in rural and remote parts of the province. Since December 2025, the B.C. sheriff service has chartered 31 flights to transport\n               people accused of crimes back and forth from the detention centre and the courthouse. To the minister, is con air the newest service provided by this NDP government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752303","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"B.C. taxpayers have been billed nearly $300,000 in the last five months to fly inmates\n               to and from court in rural and remote parts of the province. Since December 2025, the B.C. sheriff service has chartered 31 flights to transport\n               people accused of crimes back and forth from the detention centre and the courthouse. To the minister, is con air the newest service provi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","label":"Air transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","label":"Airlines","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","label":"Air transport","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["16b75dff1a04ac0ca4d9a3c2b54c500ca8b72da630656da2699bf62a7698442f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02766f7b6e454ee336b269fcecfcab7aec96edacd9754c6b73655a1be3dfa0b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57e46eff1f8f265de250cbdb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017457,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I would like to recognize Partap Forest Products Ltd., a remarkable British\n               Columbia company that represents the strength, resilience and future of our forest\n               industry. Founded in Maple Ridge in 2004, Partap Forest Products has grown from a\n               small family-run operation into a leading producer of western red cedar and Pacific\n               hem-fir products. Even as the company has expanded, it has remained committed to the values that matter\n               most to British Columbians: hard work, innovation, sustainability and community investment.\n               Partap is exactly the kind of company our province should be proud to support. The\n               company provides skilled jobs for local families, contributes to the economic vitality\n               of Maple Ridge and the region and strengthens the supply chain that supports construction,\n               manufacturing, transportation and exports across Canada and abroad. Their two operations in Maple Ridge and Surrey demonstrate how modern forestry can\n               combine advanced technology with responsible resource management. What makes Partap\n               especially important is its commitment to maximizing value from every block while\n               minimizing waste. Their focus on sustainable forestry practices and renewable wood\n               products reflects the evolution of British Columbia's forest sector into one that\n               is both environmentally responsible and economically competitive. At a time when forestry communities across British Columbia are facing economic pressures\n               and uncertainty, companies like Partap Forest Products show us why continued provincial\n               support for the forestry industry is essential. By supporting companies like Partap,\n               we are supporting local jobs, sustainable growth, rural and urban economies and a\n               proud British tradition that continues to build our future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017457","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I would like to recognize Partap Forest Products Ltd., a remarkable British\n               Columbia company that represents the strength, resilience and future of our forest\n               industry. Founded in Maple Ridge in 2004, Partap Forest Products has grown from a\n               small family-run operation into a leading producer of western red cedar and Pacific\n               hem-fir p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","label":"Forestry technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","label":"Forestry technology","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11f484da28fe2659d3ff4fcc9b7b350cad8e8c9af12cccf1e98b561e32c543ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f4495276592253a46920c678e7866c9d0c14c4d4b31b271e3e6acb8965c5aed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035374","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8bca12b839604bef38764ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036531,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lawrence Mok","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my pleasure to introduce my three very longtime friends from Duncan who are\n               visiting the Legislature for the first time. We have Lan and Rose and their son Ian.\n               Lan is a retired schoolteacher, and Ian is still a high schoolteacher. Will the House please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036531","member_id":"bc-mla-382","member_name":"Lawrence Mok","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is my pleasure to introduce my three very longtime friends from Duncan who are\n               visiting the Legislature for the first time. We have Lan and Rose and their son Ian.\n               Lan is a retired schoolteacher, and Ian is still a high schoolteacher. Will the House please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["020847740bd12c0933eefce45eafd56db854b91366f7a7fd6e5bc0175fcfcdd2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d94c48b0fb779181308de568c1eaf8304d80996bc38807455026895544185652"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41f305ab18407835b62bdfcc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316592,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"There is a word from my ancestry that guides me about how I think about Black History\n               Month, and that's","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316592","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"There is a word from my ancestry that guides me about how I think about Black History\n               Month, and that's","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","label":"Ethnic minorities","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4797ee561eaf8e217844dd8041ebb5e137b5c59f2c5318c317908dc0094e5786"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-244111b5a990f2cdbf52a9d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316593,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize Grayson Ritzand, recipient of the Junior Male Team Athlete of the Year at the Nanaimo Sport Achievement\n               Awards. Apart from being 6'5\", not as tall as our Premier.... In 2025, Grayson delivered an\n               outstanding season, leading the Wellington Wildcats senior triple-A boys to the north\n               Island and Island championships and a fourth-place finish at the B.C. provincial championships. His leadership and performances earned him MVP honours at north Island and multiple\n               tournaments across British Columbia and has been recognized as a provincial first-team\n               all-star recognition. Grayson represents the dedication, discipline and excellence of young athletes in\n               our province. Please join me in congratulating Grayson Ritzand on an exceptional year\n               and a very bright future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316593","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize Grayson Ritzand, recipient of the Junior Male Team Athlete of the Year at the Nanaimo Sport Achievement\n               Awards. Apart from being 6'5\", not as tall as our Premier.... In 2025, Grayson delivered an\n               outstanding season, leading the Wellington Wildcats senior triple-A boys to the north\n               Island and Island championships and a fourth-pl","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","label":"Freight","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035950","label":"International markets","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["179b09e698cc1850eea14fec02e71560e22aac34dacc1e313c72fd96d0095402"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3593c0d666b50bd3487400fa7ca5ca7f88431e8f7bf4e64ba399a76eb37f2483"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-facc74d0ef706889d9dd6e73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316594,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"In January, I attended the Natural Resources Forum in Prince George, organized by\n               CEO Sarah Weber and C3 Alliance. As an Islander, I can tell you that there is nothing\n               more sincere than going to Prince George in January. What I felt there was something\n               powerful — determination and a clear belief that British Columbia's best days are\n               still ahead. This was not a gathering of people asking whether the future was possible; it was\n               a gathering of people ready to build it. I heard pride from a mineworker whose job\n               supports a family and community; from Indigenous leaders forging partnerships that\n               will create opportunity for generations; from innovators like Rolf Wenzel, of Rainstream\n               Wildfire Innovations, working to safeguard our forests; from leaders like McLean Welsh,\n               of A.B.C. Recycling, helping preserve the world's resources; and from tradespeople,\n               entrepreneurs and workers who don't just talk about the future; they build it. Natural resources are not just commodities; they're paycheques, apprenticeships. They're\n               the reason families can stay in the communities they live in and build a life with\n               dignity. The world needs our critical minerals, our forestry and our low-carbon energy.\n               British Columbia can reasonably power the global economy while creating good jobs\n               here at home. The message from the North was clear: people are ready to invest, ready\n               to build and to train the next generation. The commitment was reinforced in my conversations with Dr. Johnson, the president\n               of Simon Fraser University, and Dr. Airini, the president of Thompson Rivers University\n               — leaders advancing bold plans to align training with the jobs of the future — because\n               the strongest economic policy we have is our people, their skills, pride and work\n               ethic. If we match their pride with certainty and we meet their urgency with action,\n               then our natural resources will not just grow our economy; they will unlock prosperity\n               for workers today, for families tomorrow, and for generations to come. That is the message from the North. If we listen and act, we will build a future worthy\n               of the pride of British Columbians, who bring that pride to work every single day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316594","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"In January, I attended the Natural Resources Forum in Prince George, organized by\n               CEO Sarah Weber and C3 Alliance. As an Islander, I can tell you that there is nothing\n               more sincere than going to Prince George in January. What I felt there was something\n               powerful — determination and a clear belief that British Columbia's best days are\n               still","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5aee17669f94c6037db513670e0f4cc606d425568313f0b375f244026940893f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d5c32a3dd324830f632be44ea079d4cf323bd438d133968dc25b7c352f5996d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29cba66e3f4b604e8ac45198","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316595,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to honour the life of Fred Luvisotto, a beloved Nanaimo teacher, ballroom dancer,\n               musician, volunteer and true Renaissance man. For more than four decades, Fred shaped young lives in our classrooms, including mine,\n               with lessons, patience, humour and a belief in just being a good person. For generations\n               he was known as Mr. Luvy Groovy or Groovy Luvy. For over 60 years, he played the trumpet\n               and was part of the Nanaimo Concert Band. He coached and volunteered with the Cavallotti\n               Lodge where he held the position of vice president and president many times. Nanaimo feels a little darker without Fred, but because of him, thousands of lives\n               shine brighter. This is the mark of a life fully lived and that is the light he leaves\n               with all of us. I hope the whole House will join me in expressing our condolences to his wife Doris,\n               daughters Carmella and Fernanda and all of his loved ones.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316595","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise to honour the life of Fred Luvisotto, a beloved Nanaimo teacher, ballroom dancer,\n               musician, volunteer and true Renaissance man. For more than four decades, Fred shaped young lives in our classrooms, including mine,\n               with lessons, patience, humour and a belief in just being a good person. For generations\n               he was known as Mr. Luvy Groovy or Groovy Lu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf67ebecc93bbc51d37caf38a5dab875b4790d7958d59b0ea7c97a0e80044253"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e3cc35d7be0baa312d9650e59e765b38026bbc7ee1a44acea97cdf5cafff279"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5e488e8c50462bd8f582cee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316597,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to speak in support of Bill 5, the Trade Recognition Act. In November, British Columbia brought together 13 provinces and territories and the\n               federal government in an unprecedented collaboration. Together, we approved the Canadian\n               mutual recognition agreement on the sale of goods, mutually recognizing regulatory\n               measures to reduce barriers to the free movement of many goods across provinces. This\n               agreement makes it easier for B.C. businesses to sell products across Canada and for\n               people to buy Canadian-made goods. We are now building on that momentum. This bill seeks to modernize British Columbia's internal trade framework This bill seeks to modernize British Columbia's internal trade framework and advances\n               British Columbia's leadership in trade reform. I want to be clear. If you can build\n               it, make it or provide it somewhere else in Canada, you should be able to do it here\n               in British Columbia. Internal trade barriers don't protect British Columbians. They slow us down. They\n               raise costs. They hold back opportunity. In the world we are living in today, we cannot\n               afford to hold ourselves back. That's the moment we're in. These are not normal economic times. Global supply chains are uncertain. Protectionism\n               is rising. Economic nationalism is back. Every day, British Columbians are asking\n               a simple question. Is our economy strong enough to stand on its own? That's what this\n               bill is about. When uncertainty rises outside our borders, our strength must come from inside them\n               — inside our province, inside our country. Let me say this clearly. British Columbia's\n               future will be built in Canada and not negotiated away somewhere else. The B.C. Conservatives might want us to be the 51st state, but we will never be the\n               51st state. We are not an economic branch for another country, and we will never build\n               our prosperity by waiting for permission from somebody else. Let's talk about what this legislation does. Right now, businesses are facing unnecessary\n               duplication. They are facing different approvals, different certifications, different\n               administrative hoops. What's the result? The result is higher costs, slower timelines,\n               less competitiveness. This bill replaces temporary measures with a permanent framework that says that if\n               a good or service is approved elsewhere in Canada, it can be recognized here. That\n               means lower compliance costs, faster time to market, more consumer choice and stronger\n               competitiveness for British Columbia businesses. Critically, it does all of this without lowering our standards. There is no race to\n               the bottom. Our environmental protections remain the same. Our health and safety standards\n               remain. Our consumer protections remain. Economic strength and public protection are\n               not opposites. They are partners. This act replaces ESTRA part 1 with a permanent framework to reduce trade barriers\n               in B.C. Businesses and consumers need certainty, and this legislation provides it.\n               I know that the member for Prince George–Mackenzie has been talking about certainty. I'm glad that this legislation does exactly that,\n               because it reduces unnecessary duplication. If a good may be sold or used elsewhere\n               in Canada, it may be sold or used here in British Columbia. If a service may be supplied\n               in another province, it can be supplied in British Columbia. Bill 5 proposes to ensure that businesses will no longer need to do retesting, approvals\n               or certification for goods and services that may be sold, used or provided in another\n               province. Again, this lowers compliance costs, speeds up the time to market and ultimately\n               provides lower prices and more choice for consumers. B.C. proposed and chaired negotiations to conclude the CMRA. The parties may seek\n               to extend the agreement to cover services, as this is a major component of Canada's\n               economy. If the CMRA were to cover services, the bill would help to immediately bring\n               those elements of the agreement into force, as British Columbia will have a legislative\n               regime in place to recognize services that may be supplied in other provinces. This approach aligns with national commitments, complementing the Canadian mutual\n               recognition agreement and the Canadian free trade agreement and demonstrates British\n               Columbia's leadership in modernizing internal trade. This legislation maintains the\n               ability for British Columbia to This legislation maintains the ability for British Columbia to regulate health, safety,\n               the environment and consumer protection, ensuring our standards remain strong while\n               reducing unnecessary barriers. Our friends on the other side like to bring up the Canadian Federation of Independent\n               Business and the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade. Well, let me tell you. The work\n               that our government is doing directly responds to what business organizations like\n               the Canadian Federation of Independent Business have spoken about, what the Greater\n               Vancouver Board of Trade have spoken about — who support mutual recognition across\n               the country. We are committed to continuing the work with our partners to support the free movement\n               of labour, alcohol, financial services and other services to make it easier to trade\n               within Canada. This work also aligns with our Look West strategy and its goals of diversifying trade, expanding markets and ensuring British\n               Columbia remains a leader in Canada's economic future. So why does this matter to everyday British Columbians? It matters because this bill\n               isn't just about paperwork. It's about people. It's about the small manufacturer in\n               Nanaimo trying to ensure that goods can actually reach Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba\n               and the other provinces within our country. It's about the tradesperson who wants\n               to work where opportunity exists. I've gone and I've lived in other provinces, and\n               let me tell you, this bill will make it much easier for the next generation to be\n               able to thrive within our country. It's about the entrepreneur who doesn't have a compliance department. It's very easy\n               to often talk about the big company, but what I care about are the small businesses\n               within all of our communities that actually drive our economy. But every unnecessary barrier is a hidden tax on ambition. And when we remove those\n               barriers, we don't just improve efficiency. We actually unlock potential for our small\n               businesses. I want to address the debate we often hear, because when it comes to the economy,\n               there are two approaches. One approach is to talk about growth. The other is to actually\n               remove the barriers to it. One approach is slogans, and the other is solutions. If I might say, the opposition tells us they support businesses, and yet they don't\n               always support the work required to make that business easier for those small businesses.\n               They call for growth, but then they oppose the actual tools that are going to make\n               it possible for those businesses to be successful. I think we've heard it today. They\n               call for competitiveness, but then resist that modernization. And, Mr. Speaker, you'll know this, and I'd say for some of the people who are choosing\n               to watch Hansard today, that they'll call for leadership. The opposition will call for leadership,\n               but you know what they'll do? They prefer a press conference rather than progress. Economic growth doesn't come from press releases. It just doesn't. I know that my\n               friends on the other side are having a good laugh because they are thinking about\n               the next slogan that they're actually going to put out next in a press release. But what I can tell you is the great thing is that we're focused on actual policy\n               that's going to deliver results for British Columbians. I've been listening carefully to what the Conservatives have been talking about, and\n               as I mentioned already, the member for Prince George–Mackenzie talked about creating certainty. They'll say they want less red tape, but here we\n               are, actually bringing solutions that are going to make it better for everyday British\n               Columbians, that are going to make it better for small businesses, that are going\n               to make it easier for us to do the work that we need to in this province and across\n               the country. Then all of a sudden they'll have concerns They say they want a stronger economy. Here we are, streamlining internal trade. Guess\n               what happens next — delay. Some people have actually heard me say this before, especially\n               when I've talked about construction: the most expensive material in construction today\n               is delay. That's what we are experiencing from the Conservatives right now. They delay\n               the work that British Columbians are asking for, which is to stand up for our country\n               and to stand up in a way that makes sure that British Columbia is the most prosperous\n               place in our country. Every moment that we have had the opportunity to advance good work on behalf of British\n               Columbians, unfortunately, the opposition chooses to hesitate. At some point....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316597","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'm pleased to speak in support of Bill 5, the Trade Recognition Act. In November, British Columbia brought together 13 provinces and territories and the\n               federal government in an unprecedented collaboration. Together, we approved the Canadian\n               mutual recognition agreement on the sale of goods, mutually recognizing regulatory\n               measures to reduce barriers t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3c934aa6defd1c1c1e3c2b34d33f271bc144da1352433b2d44030e8c1e007554"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fcf7a9dcd184ff670deae822e8638f82259251f10fb86fbbeb54e54594049bf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d70cfdcdb6adb1c4b539986b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327896,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have the great pleasure of welcoming Jade Buchanan, a fellow lawyer, which\n               means he's great people of course. Thank you for someone actually laughing at that\n               joke. Also, he is one of the most recognized privacy and technology lawyers in British Columbia.\n               He's also a board member of Vision Zero Vancouver and a volunteer with Vancouver School\n               Streets. I hope that the entire House would make Jade feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327896","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I have the great pleasure of welcoming Jade Buchanan, a fellow lawyer, which\n               means he's great people of course. Thank you for someone actually laughing at that\n               joke. Also, he is one of the most recognized privacy and technology lawyers in British Columbia.\n               He's also a board member of Vision Zero Vancouver and a volunteer with Vancouver School\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e82857b61c6f8682bf40aec452b02dc42fe6186ef5367ff4b1142f743f8eefb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b7dad6858b3b84ef537f154","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327897,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to mark an important milestone: 100 days until the FIFA World Cup kicks off\n               here in British Columbia. Seven matches will be played at B.C. Place, welcoming more\n               than 350,000 fans while billions more watch from across the globe. This moment is about far more than what happens on the pitch, but what happens because\n               of it. Major global sports events shape how people see a place for decades. The research\n               is clear that when visitors come to British Columbia, they will return three or four\n               times over their lives for leisure, for business, for partnership. Between 2026 to 2031, we expect an additional one million out-of-province visitors,\n               generating $1 billion in new spending across our economy. That means full hotels,\n               busy restaurants, growing local businesses and good jobs for workers and communities\n               across British Columbia. This opportunity strengthens our role as Canada's gateway to the Asia-Pacific, building\n               relationships that will support our prosperity for decades to come. This moment belongs to the entire province. Residents and visitors will experience\n               the tournament, inside B.C. Place at the FIFA Fan Festival, at community celebrations\n               across British Columbia. We are supporting watch parties throughout the province and\n               working closely with local First Nations and partners to ensure the benefits endure\n               long after the final whistle. This is Team B.C., and on Team B.C., no community sits\n               on the sidelines. When the world arrives in British Columbia, they will see our stadiums, skylines,\n               mountains and oceans, and our cities. But what these visitors will remember is our\n               people — welcoming, creative, diverse and ambitious. The countdown has begun, so today I invite all British Columbians to join in celebrating\n               100 days to go, to be part of Team B.C. and to help us show the world the very best\n               of this province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327897","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to mark an important milestone: 100 days until the FIFA World Cup kicks off\n               here in British Columbia. Seven matches will be played at B.C. Place, welcoming more\n               than 350,000 fans while billions more watch from across the globe. This moment is about far more than what happens on the pitch, but what happens because\n               of it. Major global sports events","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f83f514ea859a9653f039d0695f79d34188b905d258af9faa0cce03d2c8fa43b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb97d25a7ce04a2341e149f1e8e07d0d281677feb7cf6f6779279ae226b4a154"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52769e4755c8aa43c537b138","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327898,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in support of the proposed amendments to B.C.'s Civil Forfeiture\n               Act. At its core, this legislation addresses a simple but profound principle of justice:\n               that crime should never pay. Organized crime, money laundering and illicit financial\n               networks do not survive on ideology; they survive on profit. They depend on houses\n               used to grow drugs, vehicles used to transport illicit goods, bank accounts used to\n               hide illegal proceeds. If government fails to disrupt the financial incentives behind unlawful activity,\n               then we leave intact the very engine that drives crime. Civil forfeiture exists to\n               remove that engine, and allows our government to pursue property connected to unlawful\n               activity as a means to provide a preventative legal remedy designed to protect the\n               public interest. I might first begin with a bit of a legal foundation regarding civil forfeiture. It's important to understand what civil forfeiture is and what it is not. Civil forfeiture\n               is not a criminal prosecution. It is a civil proceeding brought before the courts\n               under the well-established balance of probabilities. The focus is not on guilt or\n               innocence; the focus is on whether property is the proceeds of an instrument of unlawful\n               activity, and that distinction matters. Our courts have repeatedly recognized that governments have a legitimate interest\n               in preventing property from being used to facilitate crime. Civil forfeiture operates\n               alongside criminal law, but it serves as a distinct public purpose, preventing future\n               harm, disrupting criminal enterprise, removing the economic rewards of illegal conduct.\n               This approach has become an important tool used not only in British Columbia, but\n               across Canada and internationally in efforts to combat organized crime and financial\n               crime. Why are these amendments necessary? The reality is that criminal organizations evolve,\n               they adapt and they exploit procedural gaps. Over time, litigation has revealed areas\n               within the civil forfeiture framework that require modernization After years of court proceedings and operational experiences, several challenges have\n               become clear: procedural inefficiencies that create unnecessary delays, gaps in information-sharing,\n               increased sophistication in financial crime and rising costs associated with complex\n               litigation. Organized crime today does not operate in isolation. It operates through networks\n               that cross provinces and international borders. Money moves digitally. Assets are\n               hidden through shell companies and intermediaries. Information flows between agencies\n               become critical to ensuring enforcement is effective. If government does not adapt,\n               we risk creating a system where criminal proceeds remain protected by procedural obstacles,\n               and that is not something that British Columbians expect of us. What do these amendments do? The amendments before this House aim to strengthen the\n               act in several ways. The first area that I will talk about is civil litigation. These amendments help streamline\n               the litigation process. Civil forfeiture cases can be complex, involving multiple\n               parties, assets and jurisdictions. Just starting at a point of multiple party litigation,\n               you have individuals who could be in British Columbia, Alberta, anywhere in the country,\n               the United States and internationally, but actually going through the process of ensuring\n               that they are treated fairly under our systems, of ensuring that proper notice is\n               given, of ensuring that we go through the proper litigation processes even before\n               getting to the point of discovery.... To clarify the point of what a discovery is, it is essentially a deposition where\n               individuals are able to have a discussion, at least an examination, for discovery\n               of the pertinent pieces of evidence. By moving forward with the amendments that are suggested, I don't think that I am\n               debating the Ministry of Post-Secondary Education, but that being said, perhaps I\n               will be later on. Civil forfeiture is focused on reducing the procedural inefficiencies, lowering litigation\n               costs, reducing court burdens and allowing cases to be resolved more efficiently.\n               We know that our court systems are overburdened. There are several cases that are\n               going through the courts, and whatever we can do to ensure that we are reducing costs\n               is important. Importantly, if we allow the justice system to focus on resources where they matter\n               most.... I think of the responses to civil claims where individuals.... In this case,\n               you would have the director actually putting forward the case where they see property\n               that has been derived from illicit proceeds and then seeing general responses that\n               don't actually help advance litigation in any type of way. That is not how an efficient legal system is to move forward. An efficient legal system\n               requires particulars to be given. It requires both parties to be able to properly\n               defend their cases. That requires individuals properly detailing areas in which they\n               feel they need to defend or what the case is and where they actually believe that\n               there is a claim to be made. The civil forfeiture office continues to disrupt organized crime and invests those\n               proceeds into community safety. And what do we see? As I mentioned earlier, when you have material facts that are\n               clearly laid out, you see litigation move forward. Where you have vague, obfuscated\n               responses, which I have seen in my practice as a lawyer, you see litigation drawn\n               out for significant periods of time. The amendments that this bill provides ensure\n               that everyone is on the same playing field by requiring parties to identify their\n               interests and The amendments that this bill provides ensure that everyone is on the same playing\n               field by requiring parties to identify their interests in properties and whether or\n               not they are holding them for others. I believe that is one of the most integral parts\n               of this piece of legislation. It will give us the ability to really have that legal\n               discussion about where pieces of property came from and how an individual came to\n               acquire them. I think many British Columbians can think of situations where there is an individual\n               who is living in a multi-million-dollar home yet on their income tax, they say they\n               only make $5,000 a year. Or they're driving luxury vehicles which cost hundreds of\n               thousands of dollars. That's what British Columbians would say they are concerned\n               by. It's the fact that individuals who go to work, they work hard and pay their taxes,\n               they expect everyone to play by the same rules. What do we see as a problem with the current default judgment process? You will even\n               see uncontested cases requiring full hearings, which requires significant time in\n               the courts. You have lawyers. You have clerks. You have the judge who is in the courtroom\n               for a significant period of time, not advancing the issues that involve everyday British\n               Columbians. Let's move on to the second point, which is improved information-sharing. The amendments\n               enhance information-sharing tools, which are critical in modern financial investigations.\n               Law enforcement and regulatory bodies often hold different pieces of the same puzzle.\n               Allowing appropriate sharing of information strengthens the investigation, prevents\n               duplication and supports coordinated responses to organized crime. At the same time,\n               this particular legislation includes safe and clear safeguards regarding the type\n               of information that can actually be shared, which ensures transparency and accountability\n               and additional privacy considerations. Third, the amendments clarify and strengthen procedural fairness for property owners.\n               This is essential to maintaining confidence in our legal system. Civil forfeiture\n               must always operate within the boundaries of due process, fairness and judicial oversight.\n               These amendments provide clear procedures and protections that ensure respondents\n               have appropriate opportunities to participate in these legal proceedings. That balance\n               matters because when laws are both effective and fair, they ensure public confidence\n               throughout the province. From some members, we've heard that there may be concerns, but what I would say when\n               we're talking about these concerns.... Sure, there may be legitimate questions that\n               are brought up, but some asked whether civil forfeiture risks undermining the presumption\n               of innocence. That concern misunderstands the nature of civil proceedings. As I mentioned\n               earlier, civil forfeiture does not determine criminal guilt. The courts are solely\n               assessing property, not criminal liability. That distinction, again, has been recognized\n               repeatedly by Canadian courts. Others worry about the fairness to property owners, and that's why judicial oversight\n               remains central. Every forfeiture order must ultimately be reviewed and authorized\n               by the courts. Respondents retain the ability to challenge claims and present evidence,\n               and that is not arbitrary power. It's structured, civil legal process governed by\n               judicial scrutiny, and the amendments before us reinforce those safeguards. Now I would like to turn to the public benefit of civil forfeiture. A component of\n               this legislation that I would say is partially, and I would say often, overlooked\n               is that the funds recovered through civil forfeiture do not just disappear into the\n               general revenue. In British Columbia, these resources In British Columbia, these resources support community safety initiatives and victim\n               services. That means that proceeds of unlawful activity are redirected to supporting\n               victims, funding crime prevention programs and strengthening communities. There is\n               something profoundly just about that idea. I can speak to the riding that I represent, with the boys and girls club, where Nanaimo\n               youth early prevention program aims to help with crime prevention, bullying, improving\n               social cohesion. These are not small things, and I think it is a positive benefit,\n               at least from what I know of speaking with members in the community in which I represent.\n               That money, which was tied to criminal proceeds and ill good, actually ends up supporting\n               the public good and the public interest. British Columbia has faced real challenges related to organized crime and money laundering.\n               We have seen the impacts in real estate markets, casinos, illicit drug networks, and\n               these responses require more than criminal prosecution alone. It requires a whole\n               system approach. Civil forfeiture is one of the tools that allows the province to disrupt financial\n               incentives behind these activities, because when the profits disappear, the incentives\n               to operate also diminish. At the heart of these amendments is a simple principle that the law must evolve alongside\n               the challenges that we face. If criminal networks become more sophisticated, our legal\n               tools must become more effective. If litigation reveals gaps in legislation, we must\n               address them. If public confidence in the justice system depends on fairness and transparency,\n               we must strengthen those protections. These amendments do precisely that. They modernize British Columbia's civil forfeiture\n               network, they improve efficiency, they enhance fairness, and they strengthen our ability\n               to disrupt the financial incentives behind unlawful activity. In this province, we\n               believe in something very clearly — that crime should not be profitable. Laws like\n               this ensure that it isn't. As I've mentioned, the process of discovery is one that can take up significant amounts\n               of time, increase costs dramatically, and we, as a province, need to do what we can\n               to ensure that those costs are limited. I know that legal fees are significant and\n               the individuals who are profiting from crime.... We, as a province, can use those assets\n               and goods to end up delivering the public good. In closing, the Civil Forfeiture Act and the amendments that are being brought forward\n               are rooted in the public interest. They're rooted to ensure that our communities are\n               ones that end up looking at the best interests of everyone across this province. That\n               means making real amendments that address the speed in which those who are involved\n               in criminal activity recognize that they cannot proceed in that way in this province,\n               because should they do that, those assets will be collected. On that note, I appreciate the fact that the minister has brought forward these timely\n               amendments, and I look forward to the discussion at committee and the passage of this\n               bill, because it is necessary in order to ensure that our communities can be safe\n               and that we build the best British Columbia possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327898","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in support of the proposed amendments to B.C.'s Civil Forfeiture\n               Act. At its core, this legislation addresses a simple but profound principle of justice:\n               that crime should never pay. Organized crime, money laundering and illicit financial\n               networks do not survive on ideology; they survive on profit. They depend on houses\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fdac2d87cd3a1809c6d27ef61a3a9c0943da509ed17d7883b826c500496845ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9954f80639d043a6abaf9bb7928563576685598dc9920b35f0a22ee5701cc994"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f19e4cd1a2b6194c97f8f0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327899,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy birthday, Mr. Speaker. First, I'd like to welcome a constituent from Nanaimo-Lantzville, Jim Dickinson. He's a rancher. He's a builder and just a great British Columbian.\n               He has also volunteered for the past 23 years with the Vancouver Island Military Museum.\n               It's also his first time ever in the Legislature. I hope the entire House would make him feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327899","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Happy birthday, Mr. Speaker. First, I'd like to welcome a constituent from Nanaimo-Lantzville, Jim Dickinson. He's a rancher. He's a builder and just a great British Columbian.\n               He has also volunteered for the past 23 years with the Vancouver Island Military Museum.\n               It's also his first time ever in the Legislature. I hope the entire House would make him feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Isolated communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","label":"Isolated communities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["717027aec3523ee1e0e2fb689537fac02f6057c7374453ec0ddae4fef0e4f820","3de3fba718ac83a789e7172042d8a2b95b269d3478c3e00d13692a6190d58523"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d51a3a9341299eeb6449f31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358934,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to recognize a great member of Nanaimo-Lantzville, Jenn McPherson. She is the past president of the Nanaimo, Duncan and District Labour\n               Council. She has just finished her term. She started out as a youth representative, but her activism started on the labour\n               council through the facilitation with the B.C. Federation of Labour. Also, I would\n               like to just highlight the fact that she is one of the youngest-ever labour council\n               presidents. I hope that the entire House will help in recognizing the great work of Jenn McPherson.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358934","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to recognize a great member of Nanaimo-Lantzville, Jenn McPherson. She is the past president of the Nanaimo, Duncan and District Labour\n               Council. She has just finished her term. She started out as a youth representative, but her activism started on the labour\n               council through the facilitation with the B.C. Federation of Labour. Also, I would\n               like t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["37a238803c017b0dc2733bf216a9612a9a8fd305d8887a507cf20e238c77279f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb89ab7ea9fd9cc0894fd615546c4af5e31bad4e417eaa15625e400fc62c0677"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b216df14b4e888d78bd69dd0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358935,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports completion of Bill 7 without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358935","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Section A reports completion of Bill 7 without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27ed53fd360358a2521bd1ddb73ba5df6149230ad76305b48ddbffa14f7cdd5e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d97618baf33bd307727bfa6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358936,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I have not heard the member talk about the bill. I've been sitting here listening\n               to this diatribe go on, and I would really appreciate hearing a debate about this\n               bill rather than hearing a long pontification about when he was born. So it would be great if we could go back to speaking about the bill — the bill that\n               British Columbians expect us to be talking about. Thank you, Madam Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358936","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I have not heard the member talk about the bill. I've been sitting here listening\n               to this diatribe go on, and I would really appreciate hearing a debate about this\n               bill rather than hearing a long pontification about when he was born. So it would be great if we could go back to speaking about the bill — the bill that\n               British Col","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2c32a0d2a515d53c9226e33a79a56d8e95305afa2d6e8f52a5e153a8d4498fc9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0206a5775c20935be661f99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413638,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to recognize the outstanding achievement of the Dover Bay Dolphins basketball\n               team from Nanaimo, who brought home silver at the 2026 B.C. 4A provincial championships.\n               As the tournament's top speed, they show tremendous heart, discipline and skill. Joe Linder and Dane Schmidt were named first team all-stars, and players like Landon\n               Ross helped lead this remarkable run. I also want to recognize head coach Darren Seaman\n               for his leadership. To the players, coaches, families and the entire Dover Bay School community, Nanaimo\n               is proud of you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413638","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to recognize the outstanding achievement of the Dover Bay Dolphins basketball\n               team from Nanaimo, who brought home silver at the 2026 B.C. 4A provincial championships.\n               As the tournament's top speed, they show tremendous heart, discipline and skill. Joe Linder and Dane Schmidt were named first team all-stars, and players like Landon\n               Ross helped l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2d1e61476bf27c7b404af969cf49020794ed63c9dbfe36d1b19abe0a0ad41861"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cf05956f4fef70cc4bb04391ebc5e9ad66819fbebb54bfe2bb4dea445aa77e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5276d7c9283997cfdbc1fea0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413639,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"When people talk about prosperity, they are talking about something simple — good\n               jobs, growing businesses and the confidence that a person can build their future here\n               in British Columbia. That is why life sciences matter. In British Columbia, life sciences is not a niche corner of our economy. Life sciences\n               is an industry that will define the century, and British Columbia is already leading.\n               Our life sciences sector supports about 28,500 jobs across 1,800 companies, generating\n               $3.1 billion in GDP in 2022. The average compensation in the sector is 21 percent higher than wages across B.C.\n               We are leading because British Columbians are doing extraordinary things. At UBC,\n               Dr. Pieter Cullis helped pioneer the lipid nanoparticle technology that made modern\n               mRNA vaccines possible. Genome B.C. is supporting active life sciences research throughout\n               B.C., which is demonstrating the breakthroughs of today and defining the industries\n               of tomorrow. Then there are companies carrying that leadership forward. AbCellera, STEMCELL Technologies,\n               Aspect Biosystems, Acuitas Therapeutics — these are companies proving that British\n               Columbia is more than a place where ideas are discovered. B.C. is a place where ideas\n               are built, scaled, commercialized and sent out to the world. Take Xenon Pharmaceuticals, which recently announced positive phase 3 trial results\n               demonstrating a 53.2 percent median reduction in monthly seizure frequencies. For\n               families living with epilepsy, that is hope. For investors and workers, that is confidence.\n               And for British Columbia, that is proof. B.C.'s future is not to become an extension of somebody else's economy. Our future\n               is to build with B.C. researchers, workers, B.C. companies and on B.C.'s terms. That's\n               how we build prosperity, that's how we create jobs, that's how we strengthen paycheques,\n               and that is how British Columbia shows the world that we do not wait for the future\n               to arrive, we create it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413639","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"When people talk about prosperity, they are talking about something simple — good\n               jobs, growing businesses and the confidence that a person can build their future here\n               in British Columbia. That is why life sciences matter. In British Columbia, life sciences is not a niche corner of our economy. Life sciences\n               is an industry that will define the century, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1e61e6b4ff6b4588a5658787531a077654f2f54d6866f3f04c4c4d9af0111454"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["edd36fb37ddbd8bb7bcc2e6a7b95573675be7771182b2adf90a93e99d253bff6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9cf0e0f29cbfcca29c8fd046","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413640,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"As I begin, I would just like to say thank you to the communities that participated\n               in the consultation for this bill. I rise in support of Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act, and\n               I do so with a very clear understanding of what is before us. This bill is not about\n               choosing one religion over another. It is not about preferring faith over non-faith.\n               It is not about insulating belief from criticism. It is not about declaring that disagreement\n               as unlawful. It is something more basic than that. It is about whether a person in British Columbia\n               can approach a place of worship in peace. It's about whether a parent can walk a child\n               to a synagogue, a mosque, a mandir, a gurdwara or a church without wondering what\n               waits at the door. It's about whether an elder with a cane, a family member arriving\n               at a funeral, a young person coming for prayer or a newcomer seeking community must\n               first run through a gauntlet of menace before they may enter a sacred space. That isn't a small question because the freedoms that we celebrate in this country\n               are not abstractions floating above the ground. They are lived, they're embodied and\n               they're exercised by human beings in real places. Places where people worship are\n               not the places where protests should be taking place. A right that exists only in theory but fails at the threshold is weakened in right.\n               A democracy that cannot protect the walk to worship has a misunderstanding of what\n               freedom requires. In a free society, people will differ. They will differ passionately.\n               They will differ morally, politically, philosophically and spiritually. That isn't\n               a weakness of our democracy; that is one of the defining strengths of our democracy. But the line we must hold is this, that disagreement should never be and cannot be\n               intimidation, and protests cannot become domination over another person's access to\n               a protected civic and spiritual place. That's what Bill 13 recognizes. In my respectful\n               view, I recognize it with care because one of the most important things to understand\n               about Bill 13 is that, similar to Bill 12, it is not a broad instrument of suppression,\n               it's drafted with a very narrow instrument of access. That distinction matters because the state should not police theology. It shouldn't\n               be casting its judgment over who chooses what their faith is. The state should never\n               decide which prayers are worthy and which are not because the state does have a solemn\n               obligation to ensure that all British Columbians, regardless of their faith, can gather\n               in safety and dignity under the protection of the law. That is not the state taking\n               sides in religion. That is the state taking the side of public order and freedom under\n               the law. One of the things that did impress me about the different communities that came out\n               to participate in this particular press release was the variety of faith organizations\n               saying that this was the correct decision to make. Because when people target places of worship, they're not merely expressing a view,\n               they are striking at belonging. They are That's why it was impressive to me to see the variety of groups such as Reverend Dan\n               Chambers of the United Church of Canada and many others who came forward to say this\n               is the right direction and that British Columbia needs to ensure that places of worship\n               are respected. There has been some discussion about whether or not there is a need for this particular\n               type of legislation. Well, I'd like to lay out some facts and some statistics. Stats\n               Canada reported 1,342 police-reported hate crimes targeting religion in 2024, essentially\n               unchanged from 2023, but following 154 percent increase from 2020 to 2023. In 2024, most religion-targeted hate crimes were directed at Jewish and Muslim communities,\n               with the remainder including other faith communities, such as Sikh, Hindu, Buddhist,\n               and Christian communities. And we have to be careful with numbers, but we should not\n               be casual about what they reveal, and that is that the pressure on religious communities\n               in recent years has been real and it has not been confined to one tradition. That wider context matters because this bill should not be understood solely as a\n               response from one community alone. It should be understood as a statement of principle\n               for everyone. For the Jewish family who is headed to a synagogue, for a Muslim family,\n               for a Sikh family, for Hindus, for Christian families gathering at their place of\n               worship. For the person of deep faith or the person rediscovering their faith. For\n               the mourner, for the volunteer, for the person seeking meaning after loss. For the\n               child who does not yet have the words for theology, but knows whether or not parents\n               have made the entrance feel safe or frightening. That child matters in this debate because in law, we often speak in the language of\n               balancing proportionality and statutory interpretation, and those are important aspects\n               to consider. The question that I believe is very important when we take away those\n               legal tests is whether or not that child remembers the door to prayer as a place that\n               was welcoming or a place that was fearful. That is the human question beneath this\n               bill. And that is why I support it. What also persuades me is the architecture of the bill. Section 1 is more important\n               than it may appear at first reading. It doesn't leave the term \"place of public worship\"\n               hanging in there as an undefined abstraction. It ties the definition to existing categories under\n               the Community Charter, Vancouver Charter, and Taxation Act, which allow regulatory-making\n               authority to include or exclude classes of property. Section 1 also defines interference. Section 2 sets out the core prohibitions. Here, again, the bill is more disciplined\n               than some of the critics may suggest. It prohibits four things in access zones — impeding\n               entry or exit, disrupting activities, engaging in defined interference, intimidation,\n               including conduct or words that could reasonably be expected to cause concern for\n               a person's physical or mental safety. It also prohibits wilful participation in a gathering whose participants are engaging\n               in that conduct. That last feature matters because organized intimidation can be every\n               bit as coercive to an individual act, and the law should not be blind to that. But\n               just as importantly, Section 2 does not sweep Just as importantly, section 2 does not sweep everything into its grasp. It expressly\n               examines activities authorized by the owner or occupier, lawful strikes, lockouts,\n               picketing under the Labour Relations Code and any prescribed activities or classes\n               of activities, again a very clear delineation in this bill, which demonstrates restraint. When we look at sections 3 and 4, that conclusion is even furthered, in that there\n               are no traps in this particular bill. It's not an invisible offence zone that a person\n               stumbles into by accident. An access zone is established only when signs are posted\n               and clearly visible in daylight under normal weather conditions from specified approaches.\n               Those signs must identify the place of worship, indicate the areas included in the\n               zone and set out the relevant prohibitions. The bill even prohibits removal, alteration\n               or defacement of those signs by persons other than the owner or occupier. In other words, the law insists on notice, and notice matters because notice is part\n               of fairness. It is part of legality, again, as this bill, with its narrow focus and\n               sunset clauses that are included, demonstrates the intent of restraint. The multi-use building feature is also important because not every congregation occupies\n               a stand-alone building. Some lease spaces. Some share spaces. Some worship in mixed-use\n               facilities. Some are newer communities without the financial means to own large dedicated\n               properties. A bill that protected only stand-alone institutions would fail many of\n               the very communities most vulnerable to intimidation. Bill 13 does not make that mistake. It recognizes the practical realities of religious\n               life and a diverse, modern province. That, too, is part of equality. Then we will arrive at sections 5 and 6, which look at enforcement. Whenever a bill\n               authorizes arrest without warrant, legislators should pay attention. We should never\n               become casual about such powers, but neither should we pretend that ongoing obstruction\n               or intimidation at a site of worship can always wait for ordinary timelines to unfold. Section 5 authorizes warrantless arrests only where a police officer believes on reasonable\n               grounds that section 2 is being contravened. That is not a hunch. That is not a vibe.\n               That is a recognized legal threshold. It is there for a reason. Section 6 adds an injunctive remedy through the Supreme Court available on application\n               by the Attorney General or any other person, including interim without-notice relief\n               where the circumstances justify it. That tells me that this bill is not built on punishment\n               first. It's actually built on the prevention and restoration of access, which is the\n               intent and purpose of this bill. If the issue is that people cannot safely enter a\n               place of worship, then a legal response that arrives only after the damage is done\n               is incomplete. Injunctive relief matters because it allows the law to respond prospectively,\n               not retrospectively. It allows a court to say: \"This conduct must stop now.\" This\n               is what a serious access statute should do. Section 8, as I was mentioning earlier, is also significant. The act is repealed four\n               years after coming into force, unless repealed earlier by regulation. That means the\n               House is not being asked to write a permanent blank piece of legislation that will\n               go on, where some members of the opposition have raised concerns about whether or\n               not this is the right piece of legislation that will actually address the concerns\n               of different faith communities. It actually says this is time It actually says this is time limited, a right is being reserved, and we have an obligation,\n               as the Legislature, to revisit the measure to ensure whether or not it is necessary.\n               Similar to the Safe Access to Schools Act, another measure and marker of proportionality....\n               When a Legislature chooses to add a sunset clause, in my opinion, it acknowledges\n               that extraordinary or targeted measures need to be reviewed and not normalized forever. That brings me to the Charter as well, because we should confront it directly. Any\n               serious speech in support of this bill must do so. Canada's Charter of Rights and\n               Freedoms protects freedoms of conscience and religion, freedom of expression and freedom\n               of peaceful assembly, all of which are subject to reasonable limits that can be demonstrably\n               justified in a free and democratic society. That means we do not honour the Charter by invoking only the freedom we happen to\n               like in the moment. We honour the Charter by taking all of its guarantees seriously\n               and by doing the work of reconciling them through law. This is what I do not accept — a simplistic framing that says any restriction near\n               a place of worship must automatically be an affront to liberty. I would ask: liberty\n               for whom? Freedom for whom? The person speaking, of course, but also the person who\n               is walking in, the elder arriving for prayer, also the child entering a service, also\n               the family member attending a funeral, also the congregant whose right is not merely\n               to believe privately but to join a community and practice that belief safely. The Charter is not a hierarchy in which one person's liberty devours another person's\n               security. Section 1 of the Charter exists precisely because a mature democracy understands\n               that rights sometimes press against one another in real space. When they do, the answer\n               is not to abandon the law. The answer is to legislate carefully, and that, in my view,\n               is what Bill 13 does. It is a prescribed law. It is a geographically limited law.\n               It is a law that's activated only through posted notice, and it is tailored to access. It leaves open, broad alternative avenues for public expression beyond the zone. It\n               preserves lawful labour activity. It excludes private residences and non-public areas.\n               It includes judicial supervision through the injunction process, and it sunsets. There\n               is no incidental details. They are the very features that make the bill measured. Let us be honest about the distinction at the heart of this debate. There is a profound\n               difference between expressing disagreement with religion and confronting people at\n               the place in which they worship. Last year, I had the privilege of touring the Vancouver Holocaust Education Museum,\n               and I met with Niko Sobolewski. We were having this conversation about the rise in antisemitism and the challenges\n               that the people he knows, his community, is facing every day. I still remember the\n               comments that he made to me that people should and are free to protest. But why do\n               you need to protest at the place where I go to pray? That moment has continued to\n               stick with me since we met last year. I'm glad that we are moving forward with this piece of legislation or this particular\n               bill to ensure that people who are going to a sacred place know that they can feel\n               safe within the place that they go to worship. I've said this earlier that I don't believe that this bill in any way makes a criticism\n               of I've said this earlier, that I don't believe that this bill in any way makes a criticism\n               of religion that is unlawful, etc. It's not. People are free to argue, to write, to\n               organize, to preach contrary views, to protest elsewhere, publish articles, hold signs\n               in lawful places, advocate for reform, denounce institutions and contest ideas. Our\n               public squares remain open. But what this bill says is narrower and entirely reasonable: you may not convert the\n               immediate threshold of worship into an instrument of fear. That is civility backed\n               by law, and I think we should reject the notion that the only liberties worth defending\n               are the loud ones. There is a liberty in quiet arrival, and there is liberty in safe entry. There is\n               liberty in being able to step through a door without being harassed, jostled, surrounded,\n               taunted, photographed or made afraid. There is liberty in collective worship, unbroken\n               by calculated disruption. Sometimes the law must protect those quieter liberties precisely\n               because they are easier to overlook. There are many faiths throughout British Columbia, throughout Canada, throughout the\n               world, and I can think of the times of entering my own church and knowing that I could\n               walk through that space without fear. It wasn't until having, again, attended an event\n               with the Jewish community that I saw armed guards — to see a negativity around a space\n               in which people were trying to connect with their community. People deserve to be able to worship in whatever way they want without intimidation.\n               People should not have fear to pray in their sacred spaces for fear that others may\n               come and disrupt their moments of worship. That is something that I believe all of\n               us as legislators should be able to uplift, to ensure that people are able to pray,\n               to worship, to practice their faith in the way that is most meaningful to them. I mentioned earlier in my comments that the interfaith response to this bill is very\n               telling. You have leaders from the Sikh, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Christian communities\n               each describing in their own way the destabilizing effect of threatening or agitating\n               conduct around worship spaces and the value of clear access protections. That breadth\n               matters. It is an interfaith appeal for the ordinary conditions of belonging. That is what moves me about this bill. Places of worship are not only important because\n               they host formal religious observance. They're important because they are often among\n               the last places in public life where people can gather across generations, where children\n               see elders, where meals are shared, where grief is carried together, where loneliness\n               is interrupted, where newcomers find orientation, where traditions are passed on. In many communities, a place of worship is not only where people pray. It's where\n               they're fed, where they're welcomed, mourned, married, remembered, where they are\n               taught to serve a cause that is larger than themselves. Last year I gave a speech that I titled \"The Courage to Belong.\" I think that this\n               bill gives people that opportunity to have that courage to belong. And in that moment\n               I said: \"Courage is a bridge between fear and fairness. Courage is the act that precedes\n               compassion.\" And in that moment, I said that courage is a bridge between fear and fairness. Courage\n               is the act that precedes compassion. We cannot legislate love, but we can lead with\n               courage. We cannot erase the past, but we can face it with courage. We cannot stop\n               every act of hate, but we can drown it out with the sheer volume of courage and care. Hate divides easily, but courage unites us deeply. If hate spreads like fire, then\n               let courage spread like light so that in our time, let it be said that British Columbians\n               stood together, that we had the courage to see one another fully and to love one another\n               fiercely. That is, again, the basis on which we are speaking about this bill. I think it is\n               so important that we ensure that people who are also trying to live their everyday\n               lives can know that they don't have to worry to do something as basic and as profound\n               and as important to them as to be able to feel safe as they enter a place of worship. Intimidation works precisely by forcing the target to absorb the burden — to hurry,\n               to lower their eyes, to alter their route, to change their behaviour, to bring fewer\n               children, to skip a service or just to not go at all. To wonder whether today is worth\n               the stress, to begin slowly and quietly to withdraw. That's why the law must intervene\n               before exclusion succeeds in practice. Bill 13 responds to that reality. It says that in British Columbia, access to worship\n               cannot depend on a person's tolerance for harassment. It says that religious freedoms\n               will not be confined to the inside of a building when the state shrugs at what happens\n               at the perimeter. When we protect minority communities, we strengthen our democracy. When we insist\n               that a person may approach a place of worship in peace, we do not diminish liberty.\n               We deepen it. We deepen it by saying that neutrality amongst religious organizations\n               does not mean passivity in the face of intimidation. We deepen it by saying that equal\n               citizenship includes the right to arrive without fear. Let me say this as plainly as I can. You may disagree with a faith. You may reject\n               religion entirely. You may criticize institutions, doctrines, histories, belief. All\n               of that remains part of a free society, but you are not free to turn another person's\n               place of worship into a theatre of intimidation. You are not free to make the doorway\n               to prayer a site of coercion. You are not free to subordinate another person's security\n               to your chosen mode of demonstration when the law has made a narrow and reasonable\n               line. That line is what Bill 13 draws, not recklessly or permanently but clearly. And sometimes\n               that is what the law is meant to do, to draw a line clearly enough so that communities\n               know that they are protected and society knows that it will not accept it. I support this bill because it reflects a decent society's minimum promise to its\n               people that if they gather lawfully to pray, to mourn, to celebrate, to seek God or\n               stand simply in community with one another, they will not be forced to do so under\n               a cloud of intimidation. That is not a grand demand. It's a modest one. Once people lose faith that they can enter a sacred space in peace, we see the erosion\n               of trust. Belonging erodes. Pluralism erodes, and when pluralism erodes, democracy\n               is poorer for it. I support the bill because it, again, puts liberty.... It gives liberty a structure\n               in which there are practical protections. As I begin to close, I just want to say that I believe that in British Columbia, every\n               person should be able to walk through their doors of places of worship As I begin to close, I just want to say that I believe that in British Columbia, every\n               person should be able to walk through their doors of places of worship with dignity\n               and safety and with peace. I don't think that that is too much to ask of a province.\n               In my view, it is the least a province should guarantee. And for those reasons, I\n               support Bill 13. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413640","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"As I begin, I would just like to say thank you to the communities that participated\n               in the consultation for this bill. I rise in support of Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act, and\n               I do so with a very clear understanding of what is before us. This bill is not about\n               choosing one religion over another. It is not about preferring faith","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a35b63dfac7134af97d96c98f5c8971f9a90d23b386063a8bae74a9aead5d4eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["099f9e49a0de29046a6bb8ec52d15c5c928ba9e64c1dd28b5f2c21f39361ad1d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-313cb894db5da1c212028f6b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413641,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to recognize Chris Bush on his retirement and thank him for his years of service\n               to the Nanaimo News Bulletin . Local journalism matters. It tells the story of a community in real time. It helps\n               people stay informed. It preserves the moments that shape a city and it strengthens\n               our democracy by asking questions and keeping us all accountable. Through his reporting and photography, Chris helped capture the life of Nanaimo, its\n               challenges and its triumphs. So I want to thank him for his service, congratulate\n               him on his remarkable 28-year career. I hope that the entire House will join me in congratulating Chris and wishing him\n               every happiness in retirement. I hope that the entire House will join me in congratulating Chris and wishing him\n               every happiness in retirement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413641","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to recognize Chris Bush on his retirement and thank him for his years of service\n               to the Nanaimo News Bulletin . Local journalism matters. It tells the story of a community in real time. It helps\n               people stay informed. It preserves the moments that shape a city and it strengthens\n               our democracy by asking questions and keeping us all accountable. Thr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02faa59cd3822fa83e59e8d46f9b9ac45bd0c673f5fe21598efe86ac0bf9d947","22b129436784c2ec2459e55932322d3e751a320fd39c4368a8fcdaadedfa1859"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80212660439beb3da6f16416ccbf319628f08c0b0ad9c10e0a55ecf8d1475cd0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b5a9e53c125f67d8ad4e5fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720075,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Every generation asks a simple question of the place they call home. Is there a future\n               for me here? Not just a place to get by, but a place to build a life, to work, to\n               love, to thrive and belong. If we are serious about intergenerational equity, if we are serious about what many\n               now call the Generation Squeeze, then we must be serious about that answer. Because\n               the next generation should not inherit a British Columbia with less possibility than\n               the one that raised us. The next generation should inherit a province with more open\n               doors, more opportunities within reach and believe that they have a future here. I believe British Columbia has every reason to be proud. We are not a province without\n               options. We are a province with extraordinary assets, extraordinary people and extraordinary\n               possibility. The question is whether we are bold enough to see it. Giving young people a reason to stay in British Columbia means understanding that\n               affordability is more than just the price of a house. Affordability is also about\n               time and whether a commute steals an hour from a parent at the end of a day or whether\n               a young person needs to get a second car just to get to work. And that's why public investment matters. That's when the Broadway subway project\n               promises a trip from VCC-Clark to Arbutus in just That's why public investment matters. That's when the Broadway subway project promises\n               a trip from VCC-Clark to Arbutus in just 11 minutes, saving riders an hour a day.\n               Or the Surrey-Langley SkyTrain, which promises a 22-minute trip from Langley city\n               centre to King George. We should see more than a transportation project but rather,\n               family budgets, breathing room and precious time given back to ordinary people. We also need to talk about our existing rail corridors. They are not just relics from\n               the past or leftovers from a past era. They are corridors of opportunity. On Vancouver\n               Island, the Island Corridor is approximately 289 kilometres long, linking Victoria\n               to Courtenay and connecting our ports, a corridor that could actually move truck trips\n               to rail, creating synergies with connections to Duke Point. That matters, because connecting people across Vancouver Island is more than just\n               connecting communities. It's connecting people to education, services and creating\n               Vancouver Island's stronger economic future. That same imagination needs to be used\n               for the Sea to Sky corridor. We can also look to Red Chris mine and to Highland Valley Copper, to the next generation\n               of projects, mining projects, like north Island copper and gold, which demonstrate\n               that mining isn't just part of the past. It's essential to British Columbia's future,\n               and I am proud to be part of a government that is delivering on those projects. We also can look to the Port of Prince Rupert, which handles approximately $60 billion\n               in trade each year and supports an estimated 3,700 direct supply chain jobs in northern\n               British Columbia, along with roughly $360 million in annual wages. Those are not abstract\n               numbers. Those are paycheques, and those are livelihoods. Let us speak plainly and proudly about the trades. The trades are not a backup plan.\n               They are not about what happens when something else fails. They are honourable, intelligent\n               and indispensable. The trades build the homes we need, the transit we depend on, the\n               ports that move our economy. The trades are going to help us modernize our corridors to receive and revive manufacturing\n               strength and help make this province more affordable and more self-reliant. There are now more than 50,000 registered apprentices in British Columbia with more\n               than 11,000 youth participating in skilled trades, and that is something to be proud\n               about. BCIT is expanding its trades and technology complex, including new spaces for\n               marine, steel and mass timber trades. This is a province investing in people who know how to build. When we talk about giving young people a reason to stay in British Columbia, the answer\n               is not small. It means building a province where they can imagine to afford living\n               in this province, a province where public investment gives them time back. It's whether\n               or not we can build a future worthy of the people coming next. That is where we must\n               ground our ambition, grounding our ambition in a province that ensures that young\n               people know that there is room for them here. Let's build that province. Let's build a province that does not ask its young people\n               to lower their expectations. Let us build a British Columbia so dynamic, so connected,\n               so self-confident and so full of possibility that our young people stay, not out of\n               obligation but out of the belief that we are building the best province in Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720075","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Every generation asks a simple question of the place they call home. Is there a future\n               for me here? Not just a place to get by, but a place to build a life, to work, to\n               love, to thrive and belong. If we are serious about intergenerational equity, if we are serious about what many\n               now call the Generation Squeeze, then we must be serious about that answer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d8c73125fd928c11a17ef3baac571d54c2deaa94f84eadd1df51bfc4844a7527"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05c591a49488e1a47d10f07e2debbf3e64db9c30726b098c6b7f7b0c65f8cf63"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3999dc86fc8f8f02a22a78db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720077,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Brian McFadden, the president of Vancouver Island Military\n               Museum, who was fittingly honoured with the city of Nanaimo's honour and heritage\n               award yesterday. He is a former member of the British Royal Navy Reserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720077","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Brian McFadden, the president of Vancouver Island Military\n               Museum, who was fittingly honoured with the city of Nanaimo's honour and heritage\n               award yesterday. He is a former member of the British Royal Navy Reserve.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60e2a1a8e59c59495a48d15811801fafa4aea32b8aa514451a70767c88e59444"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34d386ea420539fc5585e16c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720079,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I recently visited Cueva Homes in Lantzville, and I left with something that can feel\n               rare in a housing conversation. I left with hope. In a moment when too many people\n               are asking whether they will ever be able to afford","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720079","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I recently visited Cueva Homes in Lantzville, and I left with something that can feel\n               rare in a housing conversation. I left with hope. In a moment when too many people\n               are asking whether they will ever be able to afford","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d24dfea7d20bdea97190c938983db0631711ec24b0e87736e53447c3be5ea717"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce99436ba9323a1119cbe009","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721141,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"British Columbia has always been more than a place on a map. We are a province that\n               faces the Pacific. We are the province that sees opportunity where others see distance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721141","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"British Columbia has always been more than a place on a map. We are a province that\n               faces the Pacific. We are the province that sees opportunity where others see distance.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coastal waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","label":"Construction materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","label":"Coastal waters","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["090e7bec4857acdc068a91e5a75f5f4461abb8a2f6003e5cfa05cabcf0a5ff75","6af5378a07ad8f8dda2a6c354aa0f1e7db4ea836caa02a00079eb159e26e60a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4111a46c96f80fcfd7cb18d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721144,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have the great privilege of welcoming Tyler Large to the Legislature. Yes, that's large as in big, just so you all know. I was hoping\n               you'd laugh, but anyway. That being said Tyler is a constituent, and he's also a good friend of mine. He's\n               a co-owner of Country Grocer. That's a chain across Vancouver Island. He's also just\n               a great human being. A fun fact is that when it comes to Strava points in Nanaimo-Lantzville, Tyler is one of the top people that you're going to have to beat, with 5K done in\n               17 minutes and 29 seconds. I hope the entire House would help me in welcoming Tyler to the Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721144","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I have the great privilege of welcoming Tyler Large to the Legislature. Yes, that's large as in big, just so you all know. I was hoping\n               you'd laugh, but anyway. That being said Tyler is a constituent, and he's also a good friend of mine. He's\n               a co-owner of Country Grocer. That's a chain across Vancouver Island. He's also just\n               a great human being. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70412","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Obesity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70412","label":"Obesity","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45d77005085598c1aa73a5e4860982d1be167be8589a8e376970f330ce1dd971"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-405f7d49b9e8bd9199fe0d90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721147,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports Bill 14 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721147","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports Bill 14 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-249d00c3524abe3f4592964f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721149,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize an extraordinary constituent, Raymond Salgado, whose voice\n               is carrying the spirit of our province onto the world stage. Raymond was born and raised in Lantzville. He started singing at the age of 11, and\n               since that time, his incredible talent and amazing voice has taken him pretty far.\n               Singing for the Canucks at Rogers Arena; becoming a finalist in season two, Canada's\n               Got Talent; and more recently to Cannes, France, where he participated in an epic\n               flash mob that has been viewed over 80 million times on TikTok alone. If you haven't\n               seen it, I've shared it on my TikTok. Raymond sang a sweeping rendition of Coldplay's\n               \"Viva La Vida,\" alongside a choir, violins, and flash mob creator Julian Cohen at\n               the grand piano. Raymond is amassing a global fan base and is set to release an EP of original songs\n               in summer 2026, proving again that world-class talent grows right here in British\n               Columbia. I hope that the entire House will join me in congratulating Raymond Salgado.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721149","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize an extraordinary constituent, Raymond Salgado, whose voice\n               is carrying the spirit of our province onto the world stage. Raymond was born and raised in Lantzville. He started singing at the age of 11, and\n               since that time, his incredible talent and amazing voice has taken him pretty far.\n               Singing for the Canucks at Rogers Arena; b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","label":"Music","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["662dfda2ad1b6b22f01c68e7e42471860ea66824e89b0f0c0d4d50ce7520e95b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6666df52e6f9c9d4f3c782d0766d2f480f6ec61ed7ffa6b9db6a8bfe2587c897"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715171","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b377db81ce0047a90b94ba4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721150,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Energy and Climate\n               Solutions and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721150","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Energy and Climate\n               Solutions and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e958c596b278b37e8eeff4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728720,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize and thank Tod and Jocelyn Maffin for their success of Nanaimo\n               Infusion, 2026, this past Saturday, an event that brought hundreds of Americans and\n               health care workers to our community and showed them the very best of Nanaimo. I spoke with Rachel, a nurse from Texas, who spoke about doctors and working collaboratively\n               here. Henrietta, a nurse from Michigan, shared the relief of knowing she does not\n               have to worry about whether insurance will be covered. Brandy arrived with a job offer,\n               her 13-year-old and their bird, because apparently even the bird heard Nanaimo and\n               decided it was time to migrate. Brandy said this is a place where diversity flourishes. Her son loves our schools\n               and is already swimming in the Summer Games. That is the promise of British Columbia,\n               a place where people can belong, contribute and build a hopeful future. I hope the whole House will join me in congratulating Tod and Jocelyn Maffin on a\n               successful 2026 Nanaimo Infusion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728720","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize and thank Tod and Jocelyn Maffin for their success of Nanaimo\n               Infusion, 2026, this past Saturday, an event that brought hundreds of Americans and\n               health care workers to our community and showed them the very best of Nanaimo. I spoke with Rachel, a nurse from Texas, who spoke about doctors and working collaboratively\n               here. Henri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722889","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal migrations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722889","label":"Animal migrations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd594b09f34327c7992a7c968752955551a2ff999825130307ce6f227efff771"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea679bf7db38655145daa3839a2a8c5513843715f48c1106c0a51784ce27d35e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cef53c969e2e3ec57dafc459","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728722,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today, on the National Day of Mourning, we remember workers who left home expecting\n               to come home and never did. In British Columbia last year, 138 workers lost their\n               lives because of workplace injury or illness. Behind every number is a name, a face\n               and a future that should still be here today. They left behind half-finished breakfasts,\n               text messages unanswered and families whose lives would be forever divided into before\n               and after. If we are going to honour them honestly, then we must speak honestly. Too often, the\n               people who profit most from work are the ones who are furthest away from its risk.\n               Too often, those in boardrooms speak of productivity and margins, while working people\n               carry that pressure in their backs, in their lungs, psychologically and sometimes\n               with their lives. And when something goes wrong, it is not the boardroom that pays the price. It is\n               the worker, the apprentice, the care aide, the truck driver, the person who gets up\n               early, works through pain and asks for nothing more radical than the chance to come\n               home safe. A worker is a human being, a family's source of stability and someone's whole world.\n               Today we do not just mourn the dead. We accept a responsibility to the living — a\n               responsibility to the young worker on their first shift, a responsibility to the tradesperson\n               on the scaffold, a responsibility to every person who leaves home believing they will\n               return. Because what does it say about us if the people who build our province are\n               the very people we fail to protect? What does it say about us if profit is counted\n               more carefully than pain? Let this day leave us with a truth that we cannot look away from — that a worker's\n               life is not the price of doing business, that mourning without change is hollow and\n               that no society can call itself just when wealth is built on preventable suffering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728722","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today, on the National Day of Mourning, we remember workers who left home expecting\n               to come home and never did. In British Columbia last year, 138 workers lost their\n               lives because of workplace injury or illness. Behind every number is a name, a face\n               and a future that should still be here today. They left behind half-finished breakfasts,\n               t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99378","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99378","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99378","label":"Occupational diseases","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b20f92cb70bf90639916f813842742f4f990712e962de96bb6fb9077de317d9f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a64183316fc07696aa70b144a558647dc55d9d5df2534ba0552635dc7e85e5a6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a759735cdb10600c8c004b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728725,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 16 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728725","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 16 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8cc8d75b9e51333d8152893","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728730,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to congratulate the Nanaimo Clippers on an outstanding championship season.\n               In game 7, the only thing louder than the crowd in Nanaimo was the sound of pucks\n               hitting the back of the net. And to my colleague from Cowichan Valley, I say this respectfully. There's To my colleague from Cowichan Valley, I say this respectfully: there's always next\n               year. We'll even save you a seat at the game, just maybe not in the winners section. All jokes aside, to the players of both teams, you've made your communities proud,\n               and you've given young people something to look up to. I hope that the whole House will join me in congratulating the Nanaimo Clippers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728730","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to congratulate the Nanaimo Clippers on an outstanding championship season.\n               In game 7, the only thing louder than the crowd in Nanaimo was the sound of pucks\n               hitting the back of the net. And to my colleague from Cowichan Valley, I say this respectfully. There's To my colleague from Cowichan Valley, I say this respectfully: there's always next\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b8d8f479eb8b451a0fee23016057458a1aee8e4b5163175773a68f3804a54037"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d7da198f51f52af1fdc706a2ed2081ce3a27546d980202a0035459e764612d9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c60a67eaff853615b7adc4e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728731,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Mining and Critical\n               Minerals and asks to leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728731","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Mining and Critical\n               Minerals and asks to leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c12d838b2ffa13bc67306b05","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752139,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Let me begin by saying this: road safety is not a partisan issue. Every member of\n               this House wants safer highways, safer commercial transportation and fewer families\n               receiving the kind of phone call that no family should ever receive, but our responsibility\n               is not simply to support a bill because its purpose sounds worthwhile. Our responsibility\n               is to make sure the law we pass is clear, targeted, enforceable and fair. As Parliamentary Secretary for Transit, I relay some messages from the Ministry of\n               Transportation and Transit that initially the bill, as drafted, was too broad. It\n               would have captured vehicles that were never the real focus of this legislation: smaller\n               delivery vehicles, landscaping trucks, contractors' vehicles and other small business\n               operators that are not the same as the heaviest commercial trucks operating across\n               the province and international borders. The Ministry of Transportation and Transit believes that the bill should be amended\n               so that it can address certain questions, such as who can access the footage, how\n               long it'll be retained, and other enforcement mechanisms. As we are going about trying\n               to draft better legislation, I believe it is important that we vote against this particular\n               bill and send it back to committee, in order for these questions to be addressed. At the end of the day, it's responsible for us, as legislators, to be putting forth\n               the best legislation possible. I'm sure the member agrees that where we can ensure\n               that there's clarity, we will be providing a better bill. For that reason, I believe\n               this bill needs further work. I believe it needs stronger safeguards and clearer rules.\n               As it stands, at report stage, I cannot support it. I will be voting against sending\n               it to report stage.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752139","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Let me begin by saying this: road safety is not a partisan issue. Every member of\n               this House wants safer highways, safer commercial transportation and fewer families\n               receiving the kind of phone call that no family should ever receive, but our responsibility\n               is not simply to support a bill because its purpose sounds worthwhile. Our responsibility\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["00cdcd475c507b06b89c3eca472df425f71265bd634eee647cd3ef8a4900175d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1803f0f87ca5c61c78559b298783d5262099bd5a8d4a92fa83d69435d79c6eed"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f57c50b13eb7e0a3e035895","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752140,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize an extraordinary young leader in British Columbia, Christopher\n               Lee. As the founder of Helping Hearts Youth Foundation, he has spent four years bringing\n               together student leaders to serve their communities and support local causes. His\n               impact has not gone unnoticed. He's also a past recipient of the Medal of Good Citizenship. About a week and a half ago, I met with Christopher and gave him a tour of the Legislature.\n               It was clear that he carries himself with the same purpose here as he does in his\n               community. After building this organization from the ground up, he's now stepped down\n               as the chair, leaving it stronger than how he found it. If this is what leadership looks like at the age of 18, then the future isn't ahead\n               of us. It's already here. I ask all members to join me in recognizing Christopher\n               Lee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752140","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize an extraordinary young leader in British Columbia, Christopher\n               Lee. As the founder of Helping Hearts Youth Foundation, he has spent four years bringing\n               together student leaders to serve their communities and support local causes. His\n               impact has not gone unnoticed. He's also a past recipient of the Medal of Good Citizenship. Abo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24401c24e4b484a972c15293801238e82ee00d25cbe84b5738e525ac20ec2deb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9dcdc2977dbbae681260cf9bc90e58d699ae51a4d66a2a401b09c89bd5d8298c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec3e67809ba8f257ec28f041","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752141,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the great privilege and honour to introduce a constituent of Nanaimo-Lantzville, a young leader, Kayla Okada, who has recently been named a recipient of the prestigious\n               Loran scholarship, one of Canada's most distinguished awards for youth who demonstrate\n               character, service and leadership. Beyond being an excellent student, Kayla is the founder and chair of the Teen Book\n               Club, where she has created a space for young people to come together, think critically\n               and share a love of reading. She captains her club soccer team, volunteers at her\n               local public library and mentors young athletes as a community soccer coach. She also\n               shares her creative talents on stage, performing in both school and community musicals. Kayla's dedication to her peers and her community is truly inspiring. She represents\n               the very best of the next generation, and we are all proud to see her accomplishments\n               and being recognized by the Loran organization. Will the whole House please join me in congratulating Kayla on her remarkable achievements\n               and her future journey to become an engineer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Performing arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752141","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have the great privilege and honour to introduce a constituent of Nanaimo-Lantzville, a young leader, Kayla Okada, who has recently been named a recipient of the prestigious\n               Loran scholarship, one of Canada's most distinguished awards for youth who demonstrate\n               character, service and leadership. Beyond being an excellent student, Kayla is the founder and chair of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","label":"Performing arts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Performing arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","label":"Performing arts","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5db5dcc3f02898c9736da908f8763085cf102a72dcb07fbe4f84c530df2f5446"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Performing arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3bc3fe183d11bffa1c0f8ebbdb5f5874dc53463d9a84ccdbef09e6ed3274b77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Performing arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034467","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10b9149f6ffa9ec64112a398","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752142,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Water, Land and Resource\n               Stewardship and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752142","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Water, Land and Resource\n               Stewardship and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b568eb9550962b625aa870765a80260963188b3498befaf27250c3419a7736e6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25606018fa89027bbe8d6912","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752143,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to introduce Warren Scullroot, who's joining us in the gallery today.\n               Warren is a lifelong Vancouver Island resident; a 35-year Royal Canadian Navy veteran,\n               including service in the Gulf War; and the founder and president of the Restore Island\n               Rail Society. Through his work, he has helped build a movement of more than 40,000 supporters calling\n               for the return of passenger and freight rail service on Vancouver Island, grounded\n               in sustainable transportation, partnership with First Nations, economic development\n               and long-term planning. Please join me in welcoming Warren to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752143","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm pleased to introduce Warren Scullroot, who's joining us in the gallery today.\n               Warren is a lifelong Vancouver Island resident; a 35-year Royal Canadian Navy veteran,\n               including service in the Gulf War; and the founder and president of the Restore Island\n               Rail Society. Through his work, he has helped build a movement of more than 40,000 supporters calli","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","label":"Sustainable transportation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","label":"Rail transport industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","label":"Rail transport industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","label":"Sustainable transportation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aa787667535d8d2e78453e106304b5112e907cad0e742cb240dfbc5d9ce1bde2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b7f7c89874d493a8ed2f34ba9937993d0c54f67ba4da41b2383d7c29072229ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036867","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e18d64f413d929ff3ebc8f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1016988,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016988","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports progress on Bill 9 and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60099a38893c25547f56b0f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1016996,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome Raymond Salgado and his mother, Anabelle Salgado, to the Legislature. Born and raised in Lantzville, Raymond discovered his passion for music at 11 years\n               old and has spent years sharing his remarkable talent through competitions, festivals,\n               concerts and musical theatre productions, which has always allowed him to show his\n               true, authentic self. In 2018, he competed in the Canadian reality television series The Launch , earning a top 30 spot out of 10,000 applicants. In 2023, he stood out amongst 6,000\n               applicants to become a top eight finalist in season 2 of Canada's Got Talent and delivered a powerful rendition of \"Heaven\" by Canadian icon Bryan Adams. Raymond's extraordinary voice and talent has earned praise from internationally renowned\n               artists such as Adele, Demi Lovato and Sam Smith. Most recently, he sang a rendition\n               of Coldplay's \"Viva La Vida\" in Cannes, France, and the rendition has received over\n               100 million views. While we may not be able to compete with entertainment superstars like Raymond, I\n               ask the whole House to join me in welcoming Raymond Salgado to the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016996","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome Raymond Salgado and his mother, Anabelle Salgado, to the Legislature. Born and raised in Lantzville, Raymond discovered his passion for music at 11 years\n               old and has spent years sharing his remarkable talent through competitions, festivals,\n               concerts and musical theatre productions, which has always allowed him to show his\n               true, a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Sustainable transportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037272","label":"Sustainable transportation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d98dcc7a7d802e4986b016d94cbbf93523084b9a88807ab1a13f59eb34bfece"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23dfde117d47b8eea76e12e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017000,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to congratulate a group of exceptional grade 12 students from Dover Bay\n               Secondary School in Nanaimo, Hai Tao Yuan, Thomas Grounds, Jack Banister and Cody\n               Croft. At the 2026 Skills Canada British Columbia provincials in April, these students\n               won a gold medal in the mobile robotics competition for secondary students. On May\n               28 and 29, they will be in Toronto, along with over 500 competitors from across Canada,\n               competing in over 40 skilled trades and technology competitions. Will the whole House please join me in congratulating Hai Tao, Thomas, Jack and Cody\n               on their provincial win and wish them the best of luck representing British Columbia\n               in Toronto.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017000","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to congratulate a group of exceptional grade 12 students from Dover Bay\n               Secondary School in Nanaimo, Hai Tao Yuan, Thomas Grounds, Jack Banister and Cody\n               Croft. At the 2026 Skills Canada British Columbia provincials in April, these students\n               won a gold medal in the mobile robotics competition for secondary students. On May\n               28 ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26ba3711d99b6aec6e168bfa3f6cff6f0c28f11815beac5a149d6497ee210e8c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c82feb44fea7aae679ce05b98ed50bf71e3d85343f2aa737a9d2349dbee484b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c2eda4ed1ce72764f3cd1c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036366,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"A few weeks ago I had the honour of giving a keynote address at the Nanaimo Model\n               United Nations. This was an event where high school students came together to discuss\n               global issues and engage in thoughtful debate. The topics debated during the simulation\n               included emerging issues, like artificial intelligence and warfare, as well as ongoing\n               human rights concerns, like child labour. It was inspiring to be among young people from my community of Nanaimo-Lantzville who were taking time out of their weekend to discuss important issues facing the\n               world today. There is a lot to learn from how these students approach the difficult\n               tasks in front of them. They listen closely to one another, challenge ideas with respect,\n               and work together to find common ground on complex and nuanced issues. In doing so,\n               they were embodying the very best of what our democratic institutions strive to be. I also recently learned about a project completed by political studies students at\n               Vancouver Island University. They created a model city that imagined what Nanaimo\n               might look like 60 years from now. Their work aimed to answer the question: \"What\n               kind of community do we want future generations to inherit?\" It encouraged them to\n               think about long-term effects of policy decisions and the role they play in shaping\n               our community's future. The vision for Nanaimo focused on sustainability, accessible public spaces, improved\n               public transit and building a community that remains livable and connected for generations\n               to come. Learning about these initiatives fills me with a great deal of optimism.\n               These young people demonstrated creativity, thoughtfulness and a strong sense of responsibility\n               for the future. They are not waiting on the sidelines for the world to get better.\n               They're already stepping forward, engaging in their communities and thinking about\n               practical ways to create a better future. As members of this House, we spend a great deal of time thinking about the future.\n               We debate legislation, discuss priorities and make decisions that will have lasting\n               impacts on the people of this province. But it's important to remember who will live\n               with the outcomes of those decisions long after our time here is done. The young people in our communities will inherit the province we are shaping today.\n               That's why it's so important that we continue to create space for youth to be engaged\n               in our democratic processes, not just in the future, but right now. Whether it's through\n               initiatives like the Model UN, academic projects like the one Whether it's through initiatives like the Model UN, academic projects like the one\n               at Vancouver Island University or through opportunities to work where legislation\n               is made, young people are already finding ways to make their voices heard. Throughout\n               this session, I've had the privilege of working along five legislative interns in\n               this building. Let me tell you. Their energy, insight and a fresh perspective in our\n               institutions is stronger for it. As this session comes to a close, we prepare to return to our communities at the end\n               of the week, and I want to encourage all of us to spend more time listening to the\n               young people in our communities. Talk to your children, your grandchildren, nieces, nephews and youth in your communities.\n               Ask them what concerns them, ask them what excites them, and ask them what they hope\n               British Columbia can look like 20, 30, 50 years from now. We often think about wisdom as something that comes with age and experience, but young\n               people bring something equally important. They bring fresh perspectives — they question\n               — that challenge our assumptions and force us to think differently. They are not afraid\n               to imagine possibilities that break norms. As a colleague of mine has said, sometimes with age, wisdom comes alone. The message\n               I'm hearing from young people, in my riding at least, is that they want to be part\n               of the future, and they're already ready to do so. It's up to all of us to ensure\n               that they are listening, that we are encouraging their participation and that we are\n               making decisions today with the future in mind. I have to say, with confidence, that\n               young people are already doing this work. They're building that future, and it's in\n               good hands. Often when we are looking at difficult decisions within our society, it's young people\n               who stand up, and they say: \"This is wrong. We need to make a concerted effort to\n               make sure that we're leaving this place better than how we found it.\" That's the type\n               of courage that we ought to emulate in this building — one that is fearless, one that\n               is tireless in trying to ensure that the world that we live in is best for everyone.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036366","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A few weeks ago I had the honour of giving a keynote address at the Nanaimo Model\n               United Nations. This was an event where high school students came together to discuss\n               global issues and engage in thoughtful debate. The topics debated during the simulation\n               included emerging issues, like artificial intelligence and warfare, as well as ongoing\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fbc5ac9c4f084a3d2950fced703bc7d6f7d03d83ed1449e56aee0441c10d237f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4250ac895c15f0db1150487d6b28071169fa9aec57e42971806a21f9a475d5b6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22d2a2d5fb3e2cbfe5eeba2c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036368,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Airport Workers' Day and the more than 224,000 dedicated\n               professionals who form the backbone of Canada's aviation sector. Here in British Columbia, our airports are economic engines and strategic gateways\n               connecting our communities, our businesses and our","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036368","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Airport Workers' Day and the more than 224,000 dedicated\n               professionals who form the backbone of Canada's aviation sector. Here in British Columbia, our airports are economic engines and strategic gateways\n               connecting our communities, our businesses and our","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","label":"Air transport industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","label":"Air transport industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ab4c8ddf2fb73cee5d296ad8894e780d61f2b5add7f45565628e9c0c3797e46"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8d586dd77bda8563ea6b4a53cdb435aa41e5f94db2bc7dcb54fde7917a845c1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Air transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718918","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c13c3f110f1bff06250f38e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036369,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to introduce Dr. Pamela Shaw. Dr. Shaw is a geographer and community planner and an award-winning professor, with\n               a 35-year career. In 2018, she was named a 3M teaching fellow. In 2019, she was inducted\n               into the Canadian Institute of Planners college of fellows and the Royal Society of\n               Canada. Dr. Shaw is the research director of the UNESCO Mount Arrowsmith Biosphere Research\n               Institute and is in the Legislature today for World Biosphere Day. Dr. Shaw's environmental stewardship has left a lasting impact on British Columbia,\n               and her commitment to fostering meaningful connections continues to inspire students,\n               colleagues and communities alike. Will the whole House join me in welcoming Dr. Pamela Shaw. Just one very quick introduction. There is a school with Will the whole House join me in welcoming Dr. Pamela Shaw. Just one very quick introduction. There is a school with Mr. Kotai visiting from Nanaimo,\n               Forest Park Elementary School. I hope that you all have a great time here in the Legislature, and I look forward\n               to communicating with you and having a conversation about what we do here today. I hope to all of my colleagues that they will be extremely respectful but ensure that\n               we all put on a great question period fight.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036369","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to introduce Dr. Pamela Shaw. Dr. Shaw is a geographer and community planner and an award-winning professor, with\n               a 35-year career. In 2018, she was named a 3M teaching fellow. In 2019, she was inducted\n               into the Canadian Institute of Planners college of fellows and the Royal Society of\n               Canada. Dr. Shaw is the research director of the UNESCO Mount","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","label":"Research institutes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","label":"Indigenous youth","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","label":"Research institutes","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc3438bc3d4382881134979d05bc79839d16e5ada337543fb82e65fd7ba35b82"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a5fe60b1207da33cf8f56d07e69d7dbdf317c61741791bff20b9c25615fb8ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b84c9a8994a7b722eda4e044","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036370,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section A reports completion of Bill 9 with amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036370","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Section A reports completion of Bill 9 with amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1b15b45e6193274249564558cd1dc085235b9e4fb43945b639d13d3b979e342"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cce16a28617238d9cfd1aacf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036371,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to introduce three guests in the gallery today. Joining us from White Rock\n               are Cara Cunningham and Kent Lissack, who crossed the Strait of Georgia with their\n               RV for some pre-summer island hopping. Cara is an editor, publisher, teacher and lifelong learner, now supporting people\n               through end-of-life transitions. Kent spent 34 years in the energy industry and now\n               volunteers with Bracelets4Buildings, helping build homes in Cambodia. Also joining us from Calgary is Rolf Wenzel, whose company Wildfire Innovations builds\n               mobile wildfire towers that help protect communities. I would hope that the whole\n               House will please join me in welcoming them to the Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036371","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to introduce three guests in the gallery today. Joining us from White Rock\n               are Cara Cunningham and Kent Lissack, who crossed the Strait of Georgia with their\n               RV for some pre-summer island hopping. Cara is an editor, publisher, teacher and lifelong learner, now supporting people\n               through end-of-life transitions. Kent spent 34 years in the energy in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f833c82be545f18fd853f82205eb0763b6d87ca129d5dc5a02c7f22f8ebf20f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ab6a8581d9a606a6c5c0907e969dbbcd6e7361bb193597b17dc318c47e9663e5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0479d7323bd9e0141e559204","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036372,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"George Anderson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise with sadness and gratitude to honour Loyd Sherry, a son of Nanaimo and our\n               city's longest-serving councillor. Born on March 19, 1938, Loyd was one of three sons of Evelyn and Jack Sherry. For 31 consecutive years, Loyd gave Nanaimo one of life's most precious gifts — his\n               time. Meeting after meeting, year after year, he showed up prepared, principled and\n               determined to protect the public trust and Nanaimo's fiscal integrity. He was known as Mr. No but that nickname never captured the deeper truth. Loyd's life\n               was one long yes — yes to accountability, yes to community, and yes to the city he\n               loved. His service is woven into Nanaimo's history, whether through Nanaimo Amateur\n               Radio club, the Loyal Order of the Moose, the Fraternal Order of Eagles. He and his\n               wife of 56 years, Beverly, volunteered for the Salvation Army and were members of\n               the Travelling Squares dance club. I was proud to be part of the council in 2012 that dedicated a Harewood Centennial\n               Park field to be named Sherry Fields. To his entire family — his children, Jennifer, Ellen, Gwendida, his five grandchildren\n               and nine great-grandchildren — thank you for sharing him with us. He was a true champion\n               of Nanaimo, and the history books will reflect a man and family who emulate the best\n               of British Columbia and Canada. May his memory be a blessing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036372","member_id":"bc-mla-383","member_name":"George Anderson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise with sadness and gratitude to honour Loyd Sherry, a son of Nanaimo and our\n               city's longest-serving councillor. Born on March 19, 1938, Loyd was one of three sons of Evelyn and Jack Sherry. For 31 consecutive years, Loyd gave Nanaimo one of life's most precious gifts — his\n               time. Meeting after meeting, year after year, he showed up prepared, principled and\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cace631388b962f18bb8cc19e085698e10e8d7f8f358c4edd60df32221077c1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ff06231377c5a88c55ca6bed55f7e78e545cc141b856c3fbb0493c133112127"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afdcb551aa9ac772776b8766","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187109,"date":"2026-03-31T12:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT  AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov15-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov15-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187109","member_id":"bc-mla-384","member_name":"Tamara Davidson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14f04ea6b76438375a67237e","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187110,"date":"2026-03-31T12:00:00+00:00","title":"ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT  AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov15-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov15-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187110","member_id":"bc-mla-384","member_name":"Tamara Davidson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3831fdb8143bda8259c8f56c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317154,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"Campbell River Hospital has been running seriously over capacity for many years —\n               a 95-bed hospital running at over 160 people. Our hospitals are filled with patients\n               waiting for a long-term-care bed. That means seniors are stranded for months in a\n               hospital bed or a stretcher. I'd like to stop here for a minute, because question period seems to be a bit of theatre,\n               and I want people to imagine what it's like to be in an emergency department, in a\n               stretcher waiting to be admitted. I want you guys to imagine what it's like to be\n               22 years old, psychotic, waiting for six days in an emergency department. It's unsafe\n               to the patient, it's unsafe to the staff, and this is happening everywhere in the\n               province. Psychiatric patients are waiting in every hospital for a bed. So those numbers that\n               you're quoting are meaningless if access isn't improved. And you've had ten years\n               to fix this. The reality is, on the ground, it's getting worse. The Premier himself came to my riding, promised a long-term-care bed, and now he's\n               cancelling that much-needed promise. That means seniors waiting in stretchers — and\n               I want you to imagine that, stretchers — waiting in hospital for a proper long-term-care\n               bed. So again, those platitudes are meaningless unless access is improved. To the Premier, what does he have to say to the seniors in my riding who were promised\n               a bed and deserve to be treated with respect and this issue that deserves to be treated\n               with urgency?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317154","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Campbell River Hospital has been running seriously over capacity for many years —\n               a 95-bed hospital running at over 160 people. Our hospitals are filled with patients\n               waiting for a long-term-care bed. That means seniors are stranded for months in a\n               hospital bed or a stretcher. I'd like to stop here for a minute, because question period seems to be a bit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2254c2e32f858087ab40ba3d9ad21e3849487d73ef625d747dbaab7b88435e2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39c9c75312e355f5a95bc7b9571b4c21048457220e4f9466950004f1532af5ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bef2b41d1bf46ea89969f941","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327992,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am going to stand here and try not to script anything, because I think this is really\n               important. I have been a physician for over 40 years, so I understand the system. I am actually\n               truly shocked that there is no accountability to what's happening when the biggest\n               hospital in British Columbia, the leading level 1 trauma centre in British Columbia,\n               doesn't have obstetrical coverage. The other side tried to spin it, saying that, well, you know, VGH doesn't do maternity\n               care. We're talking about level 1 trauma. We're talking about women that are pregnant,\n               that get into car accidents and need timely care. It's about life and death for women\n               and child. The spin continues. But I've got my tentacles on the ground. I'm a physician. I know\n               what's happening. What's happening is a communication breakdown. There has been staffing\n               issues for over a year, and this hasn't been addressed with. The front lines have\n               solutions, and they're not being listened to. That's the issue. That's mismanagement. Let's not script anymore, because we're talking about life and death. We're talking\n               about the only level 1 trauma hospital in Canada without obstetrical care.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327992","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am going to stand here and try not to script anything, because I think this is really\n               important. I have been a physician for over 40 years, so I understand the system. I am actually\n               truly shocked that there is no accountability to what's happening when the biggest\n               hospital in British Columbia, the leading level 1 trauma centre in British Columbia,\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7d2058455cf4b9f6ce5ed00059e3dee557d7479fa01c354134f01655ffaf651b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f032e9a91de0a3b42e19a2c132cf23233d86787f820cd6911b77c0f656ee1c40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c7b79582fc00b661c7babe8","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187131,"date":"2026-03-09T12:00:00+00:00","title":"HEALTH PROFESSIONS AND OCCUPATIONS REPEAL ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m236-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m236-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187131","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e9e6fff0575df63262a72ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360176,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to go over the Bill 9, which is the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I want to view it through the lens of British Columbians and how they would feel about this legislation that's been introduced by this government. Again, we live in a democracy. Part of a democracy is for government to be transparent,\n               and unless government's transparent, it's not accountable I think we live, again, in a democracy, and part of a democracy is for government\n               to be transparent. Unless government is transparent, it's not accountable. Since being\n               elected, I've sort of noticed that many things done by this government are behind\n               closed doors. To access information has become more and more difficult. FOIs are a way for British Columbians to be able to access information. The reason\n               we're hearing that there's an increase in FOIs is because the government is not transparent.\n               If a government is not transparent, sometimes the only way to get information is through\n               FOIs. Even if you go through the FOI process, a lot of it is blacked out. It can be\n               helpful, but it's difficult to get the information. I think British Columbians deserve\n               an open, transparent and accountable government. If we look at, for example, health care, we know we are in a health care crisis. British\n               Columbians sometimes are stuck not knowing what the data is in terms of.... For example,\n               if you have cancer, what is the wait time? The data is not transparent. The data is\n               not inclusive. Sometimes the only way you can get the data is through FOIs. For example, wait times. We can divide them into what are called track 1 and track\n               2. The government will say that, for example, cancer, track 2, is within a benchmark.\n               Track 2 is from specialist care to treatment, so that can mean surgery, and sometimes\n               that's within a benchmark. But we have to look at the entire wait time process, and\n               that includes track 1. Track 1 is, for example, when you finally access a primary care provider. Sometimes\n               it's difficult to do. You access a primary care provider. They put a referral in to\n               a specialist. That referral process can sometimes take.... If it's urgent, the average\n               wait time is, I believe, four weeks, and for non-urgent, it's up to ten months. That's\n               the average. People that don't know that have questions, and sometimes the only way you can find\n               out is through FOIs. We have been given information. For example, how many British\n               Columbians have died waiting for care? That wasn't necessarily released by the government.\n               That was gotten through FOIs. That educates British Columbians to know that there\n               is a wait time, and sometimes people die waiting. I think British Columbians deserve\n               to know. You need to make FOIs, first of all, not harder to get. You need to make it easier,\n               in a sense, when a government is secretive and non-transparent. FOIs are sometimes\n               the only way to get that information. I particularly feel strongly with health care, because much of the data that has been\n               gotten — be it through Fraser Institute or SecondStreet.org or other organizations\n               — is through FOIs. We shouldn't have to do FOIs, but we do, do them. The fact that, now, this legislation is being sold as a means to increase efficiency\n               and transparency in the FOI system.... But it has expanded the categories where FOIs\n               can be disregarded by government and applies fees to proactive disclosures. Now we\n               can actually disregard FOIs if they're deemed to be malicious, abusive, unreasonably\n               interfere with operations of government, repetitious and excessively broad. I think all of these are actually problematic. Malicious is.... I would say that it\n               depends on the person, what a person considers malicious. Sometimes people are quite\n               sensitive and would feel that an FOI has a malicious intent, when really an FOI is\n               actually just to get the information for peace of mind. That is such a subjective\n               term that I'm not sure why we're even using that. Abusive is, again, a very subjective term depending on who decides what is abusive\n               or not. The fact that nobody actually That is such a subjective term that I'm not sure why we're even using that. Abusive\n               is again a very subjective term depending on who decides what is abusive or not. And\n               the fact that nobody actually oversees this term I think is very problematic. I think one of the most problematic though is, \"unreasonably interferes with operations\n               of government.\" What does that mean? I mean, if we're actually doing an FOI, obviously\n               government has to respond and that would interfere in a sense, with operations of\n               government. So all the FOIs actually interfere with operations of government, if we\n               actually look at it, as to what it's saying here. So why did they even put that in\n               there? We live in a democracy and people that work for government work for the people. To\n               actually say that your request of information unreasonably interferes with operations\n               of government is insulting in a democracy to be honest. Repetitious. We have to remember that some people who do FOIs are quite, I would say....\n               People have different reasons to do FOIs, and people write differently. For some people,\n               they have different brains, and they can repeat things because that's how their brain\n               functions. So are we going to suddenly discriminate against people that are repetitive\n               because they have an anxiety issue and they tend to repeat things? What does that\n               mean? I heard from the other side about wanting to make FOIs more equitable, but we're actually\n               putting labels on people. How is that making FOIs equitable, when we're actually putting\n               labels on people? Excessively broad. Well, sometimes you don't know what you don't know. Should you\n               write 100 FOIs as opposed to one broad one? Where is it too broad? Again, it's so\n               vague that it's basically.... With those five categories, you can eliminate pretty well\n               every FOI. So I think it's very, very problematic. Over the last nine years, we've seen a government that has closed the doors to the\n               people. People deserve to know. Who are we elected by? We're elected by the people.\n               And so, why are we putting people in categories to deny their access to information?\n               I think sometimes when we sit in this House, we produce bills not looking at what\n               the results are. When dealing with a government that does a lot of its governmental\n               duties behind closed doors, FOIs are the only ways to get information. So there's another area as well. Again, I'm going to go back to when I heard that\n               this bill somehow makes it more equitable to get FOIs. And how does adding a fee make\n               it more equitable? Like how can you equate adding a fee to an FOI to equitable? To\n               me, it's the opposite. Sometimes I think this government is out of touch, not realizing that people are struggling.\n               Lineups to the food banks, we all know, have increased. Seniors are hurting, with\n               this last budget hurting even more. So $10 is a lot of money. Often FOIs.... Because\n               you can't make them too broad now, maybe to get your information, you have to do ten\n               separate FOIs. That's $100. That's $100. When you're on a fixed income, $100 is a\n               lot of money. This bill is actually hurting the poorest of the poor in British Columbia. Because\n               $10 for many of us may be not a lot of money, but $10 is $10. That can buy a meal\n               when people are struggling I'm not sure why this government decided to change the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Act and the FOI Act. I think a huge reason is because when a\n               government doesn't do well and people are angry, that's when the number of FOIs go\n               up, because people are asking questions. They're not hearing from this government.\n               They're not hearing why we are where we are. They have questions, and we have to respect\n               those questions because we do live in a democracy. I think it's paramount to repeat that word, because in a democracy, governments are\n               transparent and they're accountable. That's the only way, really. I mean, if you're\n               going to be voting, you need to know what you're voting for. You need to know why\n               you're here. Another example as well is that FOIs sometimes can make governments more accountable.\n               Why? Because FOI gives the people information, right? For example, going back to health care, over 25,000 people left British Columbia for\n               care last year in just one year. Some of these people had cancer. Knowing that, when\n               you're diagnosed with cancer and you're waiting.... Or you might have cancer, right?\n               An MRI has been ordered, and it's been already a month and you still have not had\n               your MRI, but you're wondering if you have cancer. Knowing that maybe you have cancer would lead you to do something to improve access.\n               You would look around. Where can I get an MRI in a more timely way? Information gives\n               people power, and it makes government accountable. I think every bill we have to review as to how it is making life more complex for\n               us. How is it making life more complex? To be honest, the more bills we put through,\n               the more life becomes more complex. So I'm looking at this bill. I'm looking at that\n               and saying: \"Is this making my life better? Is this a streamlining process? I know\n               that if I actually put an FOI in, because I'm a British Columbian and I pay my taxes\n               or whatever, I live here and I need some information, will the government treat me\n               with respect?\" But this bill actually does the opposite. It treats you, in a sense, with disrespect,\n               because it labels you potentially as malicious, abusive, that you're repetitious —\n               that's a big one, repetitious. Can you imagine? Repetitious — or excessively broad,\n               or that your demands are actually interfering with operations of government just because\n               you want to know what government is doing. I strongly feel that this bill should not pass. Because it doesn't matter what side\n               of the House you sit in. I think we all see how life has become more complex. Everything\n               takes longer. Nothing is simple. Rather than having a bill like this, it should have\n               been a bill to streamline the process, to make it easier for British Columbians to\n               access the information they deserve. On this note, I'd like to talk about a few quotes from the media. I think the great\n               thing is that the media is actually doing their job and looking at this bill I'd like to talk about a few quotes from the media, because I think the great thing\n               is that the media is actually doing their job, and looking at this bill.... Overall,\n               the media frames this bill as being controversial and potentially reducing transparency.\n               That's the media. The media actually is here to inform us, inform British Columbians.\n               They're telling us that it's controversial. Civil liberties and transparency groups also warned that the bill weakens access to\n               information. It expands the ground to ignore FOIs and does not address the systemic\n               FOIs delay. There have also been several political commentators that criticized the bill as a\n               step backwards for transparency. They say things like: \"It weakens access to information.\n               It undermines the public's right to know.\" So I think on this side of the House we're not sitting alone criticizing this bill.\n               The government needs to maybe revisit why it's doing this. Why are we making the government\n               less transparent? Transparency is a foundation to accountability. You cannot be accountable\n               unless the system is transparent. In health care — I'll go back to health care for a minute here — sometimes the only\n               way to get data is by the FOI. It forces the government to become accountable to the\n               data they're collecting. And if they're not collecting it, then the FOI forces them\n               to think about collecting it to be able to target their resourcing. I'd like to summarize. It doesn't matter what side of the House you sit. We do live\n               in a democracy. Information is power. People deserve to have that information. It\n               should be easier to get. We shouldn't.... Again, I'm going to repeat these words, because\n               it's unbelievable that words can be interpreted subjectively — malicious, abusive.\n               What is abuse for one person is not for another. And abuse can be used as a political\n               weapon, meaning that \"you're abusing me,\" when you're not, you're just requesting\n               information. Again, the one that I find the most unreasonable is the unreasonably interfered with\n               operations of government, which is so subjective. Noting the hour, I move adjournment of debate and reserve my right to continue at\n               a later date.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360176","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to go over the Bill 9, which is the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I want to view it through the lens of British Columbians and how they would feel about this legislation that's been introduced by this government. Again, we live in a democracy. Part of a democracy is for government to be transparent,\n               and unless government's transparent","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f96f93d4de802a93e784e0f704905e73fcc92b2b4cb15751ddeb7cda070ade93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16254ad372574330df64d6c1eb3d9238c610b90e31d90a0c34e5441b6822a6e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b891e0ffb2d7cae6cf8789cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360177,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm continuing the debate on Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act. I just want to summarize what I was talking about yesterday, about\n               living in a democracy. Freedom of information is fundamental to democracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360177","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm continuing the debate on Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act. I just want to summarize what I was talking about yesterday, about\n               living in a democracy. Freedom of information is fundamental to democracy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4534d01757eaf1b57c108c9d6636dcdc79541fa5c6097e45ba184b661272cc90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7bd1411f24ccba41adb4e954fcfd1777bec4cdb5bfdb8a3279740b41ca9d91c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4d38e0a0cccefc50a184507","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360178,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"Another diversion of pregnant women has begun at Peace Arch today. This is the sixth\n               time this year that there has been a diversion of obstetrical patients at Peace Arch.\n               There have been diversions for over three weeks in this year alone. This is unacceptable\n               for pregnant women in the area. When will the government stop failing mothers and make sure that all women across\n               B.C. can access safe and timely obstetrical care?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360178","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Another diversion of pregnant women has begun at Peace Arch today. This is the sixth\n               time this year that there has been a diversion of obstetrical patients at Peace Arch.\n               There have been diversions for over three weeks in this year alone. This is unacceptable\n               for pregnant women in the area. When will the government stop failing mothers and make sure tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3849281e7a75ae106ba026efd9fd77a44705f91fa0413a21e52f5ccb91ad3907"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ef6377df5cde297d6e0faae08d34a93a7f95ec4bad4e01e82baba02036360440"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a1800a56e5eeacec2eb4c50","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415749,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to make a point of privilege. The minister mentioned that we oppose recruitment\n               from the U.S., and I'm not sure why we would oppose it when we have one of the lowest\n               rates of doctors in the OECD countries.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415749","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to make a point of privilege. The minister mentioned that we oppose recruitment\n               from the U.S., and I'm not sure why we would oppose it when we have one of the lowest\n               rates of doctors in the OECD countries.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c8dcf798a776e456fb254a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415750,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I've heard from hundreds of health professionals concerning the Health Profession\n               and Occupations Act. They're telling me that they're planning to take early retirement or leave B.C. rather\n               than deal with NDP-appointed health colleges and government-appointed disciplinary\n               panels. I know the minister has received the same letters. So can the minister tell us how many health care professionals they expect to leave\n               B.C. or retire because of the HPOA?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415750","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I've heard from hundreds of health professionals concerning the Health Profession\n               and Occupations Act. They're telling me that they're planning to take early retirement or leave B.C. rather\n               than deal with NDP-appointed health colleges and government-appointed disciplinary\n               panels. I know the minister has received the same letters. So can the minister tel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0becb1ee6f94150a7624fc85b5a6edb9aefc21231eb81460373156378461f6ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be22a6eb0f6f610807ad2a24801e149293d815248276c0b3ecccf39e37e6cf6d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8303b64b316e86a09b66ca39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720393,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"The minister knows that harm reduction is not safe supply. Harm reduction is methadone.\n               It's cadian. It's Suboxone. So when she links safe supply to harm reduction, that\n               is misinformation. There is no data. There is no data. Supporting harm reduction,\n               there's data to the opposite. Talking about harm reduction, after three miserable years, this government ended their\n               failed decriminalization experiment. But yesterday the provincial health officer confirmed\n               she still supports legalizing illicit drug use in our communities. Let's be clear. This experiment — British Columbia saw record deaths of almost 2,600\n               people in 2023 alone, the worst year on record. So which is it? Does the Minister\n               of Health stand with her government who ended this failed policy or with the provincial\n               health officer who wants to bring it back?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720393","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The minister knows that harm reduction is not safe supply. Harm reduction is methadone.\n               It's cadian. It's Suboxone. So when she links safe supply to harm reduction, that\n               is misinformation. There is no data. There is no data. Supporting harm reduction,\n               there's data to the opposite. Talking about harm reduction, after three miserable years, this governmen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72397ae54193e2a2ca0e0bcf62b7f2d6bccf2560781698c480861bc927ba2a88"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9599596a04455d65876a5ff18d515ce2a29d26b0984d8c5bf332b5c0ebeabf4b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9bbb9bce08219b5c2900504","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720399,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome, as well, the representatives of the Gastrointestinal Society\n               who are in the gallery today. It is a pleasure to recognize Gail Attara — she is the\n               chief executive officer of the G.I. Society and president of the Canadian Society\n               of Intestinal Research — along with Jaymee Maaghop, who is the health policy and outreach\n               manager. Gail made an excellent presentation to our caucus this morning that was very informative.\n               I want to commend Gail and her team for their strong advocacy on behalf of those living\n               with inflammatory bowel disease, including Crohn's and ulcerative colitis. The G.I.\n               Society plays an important role in supporting patients and advancing practical solutions\n               to improve care across our province. Please join me again in making them feel welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720399","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome, as well, the representatives of the Gastrointestinal Society\n               who are in the gallery today. It is a pleasure to recognize Gail Attara — she is the\n               chief executive officer of the G.I. Society and president of the Canadian Society\n               of Intestinal Research — along with Jaymee Maaghop, who is the health policy and outreach\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be7c1c62542cc1654932067282d99e822f3e59c8711c8d7dfbd6e18f8deec416"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e85fd8475eecfae35f3e2b044964b83f174553baa8c473ee4334c88c47f6f48b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81e479d7bec8922357f5ce44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721494,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome the folks from the Kindy Foundation, who came to talk to us\n               today about a program called B.C. Donate Now — I think it's a very important program\n               that will save not only lives but also health care dollars — and also Dr. John Gill\n               from St. Paul's Hospital. Thank you very much for your presentation. It was very well received by us, and the\n               message is taken very seriously.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721494","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to welcome the folks from the Kindy Foundation, who came to talk to us\n               today about a program called B.C. Donate Now — I think it's a very important program\n               that will save not only lives but also health care dollars — and also Dr. John Gill\n               from St. Paul's Hospital. Thank you very much for your presentation. It was very well received by us, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0e3b6fa75aecbb5e1f2487905077693c266b3b389529c958e7e6adf263713fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e52b4b9ac93e8cb6d0d4bf78947e275275e528ab395f5af2bf201688ba72d4cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24dcad3c3794396b7c40cb0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729158,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce the love of my life, my husband, Dr. Peter Olesen. We met in\n               medical school 43 years ago. We both worked as GPs in rural areas, and he went back,\n               after doing some cardiac surgery assists, to train in plastic surgery and started\n               the plastic surgery program in the north Island. I remember those days on call, one-on-one, for three years. That's how hard we worked.\n               He is programmed now, he's got two partners and he covers the Nanaimo North. I don't\n               know of anybody who is a better surgeon and a better patient advocate and a better\n               father to our three children — the love of my life, Dr. Peter Olesen.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729158","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce the love of my life, my husband, Dr. Peter Olesen. We met in\n               medical school 43 years ago. We both worked as GPs in rural areas, and he went back,\n               after doing some cardiac surgery assists, to train in plastic surgery and started\n               the plastic surgery program in the north Island. I remember those days on call, one-on-one, for three yea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["032aaae2a44909532d7c8bbee0ec043092aba4e3be8c17bb19a5de94e1a7bdc8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c0bda54ac675f47e0a70c0416e2b68a49f64a3f86ea455a95b62cf2e18d6b7d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b57d09a6338926cb8f439b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729168,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the pleasure of introducing my two CAs, Charlotte Roth and Luanne Menzer. I\n               can say, truthfully, from the heart that I am in really good hands. Thank you for\n               being here today from the Campbell River.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729168","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have the pleasure of introducing my two CAs, Charlotte Roth and Luanne Menzer. I\n               can say, truthfully, from the heart that I am in really good hands. Thank you for\n               being here today from the Campbell River.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47e9ce16b5f397525bc7f0b83b23db1ad4f31f071400298cd79b4bf2adca9d33","a01e706b7219b1a57a1d36653c3c346bff52c98e3d323af13aaa93c397c96d85"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be7bf5959624472bac7ebf88","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729172,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"The all-party Select Standing Committee on Health is one of the permanent committees\n               in the Legislative Assembly of B.C. The last sitting of the standing committee was\n               in 2017, when they issued their report. In view that there is a health care crisis,\n               is the minister planning to start a select standing committee as soon as possible\n               to deal with this health crisis?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729172","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The all-party Select Standing Committee on Health is one of the permanent committees\n               in the Legislative Assembly of B.C. The last sitting of the standing committee was\n               in 2017, when they issued their report. In view that there is a health care crisis,\n               is the minister planning to start a select standing committee as soon as possible\n               to dea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c838ff49bbff0ddcc4228d1920b08550de43928c5449b07bcca9ca654d979c2a","6293d5543f3de0a81b29f3ad56ff0c3f24e28853e9a3ac6c688c0b49e263b7d6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["639aadf4fd019c8e336a9cd23185333731c8e7eee7c8e470a436e175f020cbba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23900081186f04150bedd511","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729175,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I didn't quite hear the answer regarding hospitals staying within budget within a\n               health authority. I understand it's the health authority that is actually doing the\n               budgeting, but I think as the Minister of Health, you get the numbers. I'm going to ask that you provide it in writing — the hospitals in British Columbia,\n               what their annual budgets were. Did they stay within the budgets or not? And if we\n               could get it for the last five years and the projections as well. I imagine there\n               are projections. Second, as well, I mentioned about maybe considering activity-based funding for hospital\n               budgeting. When we're looking at value for money, we want to look at efficiencies.\n               Hospitals without efficiencies actually cost more. Should the money follow the patients, keeping the quality of\n               the care while we do this? I think I'm just going to drop it there. My next question. I'll be going to primary care again. What is the mean and median\n               panel of patients per family doctor in B.C. in terms of a longitudinal family payment\n               model and fee-for-service? From that, how many more family doctors do we need?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729175","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I didn't quite hear the answer regarding hospitals staying within budget within a\n               health authority. I understand it's the health authority that is actually doing the\n               budgeting, but I think as the Minister of Health, you get the numbers. I'm going to ask that you provide it in writing — the hospitals in British Columbia,\n               what their annual budgets were. D","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Physical disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Seasonal employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036668","label":"Physical disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037059","label":"Seasonal employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6b6721bd521d2ad810d37c308ce0245f104816ca0fa38edc062339e1b54e55c","dbb22889d778eae4a94eb9ffbbbdceb7e7229627677043229fca72d0810f7999","9c588fc78e8ae13498042011e96b924c217ca13f0c6bcda01d7af3e2287e5151"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9340629f36890945f584e4b187a647e5e23cdc6466027882631c2e8beefdb479"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67592b49a1fff8bd92fb3c02","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752267,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"These solutions are not theoretical. They already have been studied, recommended and\n               even brought forward in legislation by our caucus. It's been over a year, and we have a duty in this House to move forward with legislation\n               that makes sense for families waiting for change. These families and their loved ones\n               are not theoretical. They're real. Every day that passes is a day of missed Every day that passes is a day of missed opportunity. At some point in this House,\n               we need to learn to move forward on legislation that makes sense. Empty words are\n               meaningless when a parent loses a child. The minister promised immediate action last\n               year, and we've seen nothing. And families continue to lose loved ones because of\n               this government inaction. At some point, our duty is to the British Columbians. This\n               is why we are elected, to move things forward. That makes sense.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752267","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"These solutions are not theoretical. They already have been studied, recommended and\n               even brought forward in legislation by our caucus. It's been over a year, and we have a duty in this House to move forward with legislation\n               that makes sense for families waiting for change. These families and their loved ones\n               are not theoretical. They're real. Every day","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","label":"Family law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d802d77791a156e52b4e0ff6f9e8b2fae130d8f16a7346b9ec281ddb37dede1d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-117809a63ebce28739e185ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752268,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to also welcome the British Columbia Radiological Society, especially Dr.\n               Wan Wan Yap, Dr. Brenda Farnquist, Dr. Vamshi Kotha, Dr. Blake Jamieson, Dr. Sally\n               Harvie, Dr. Washne Patel, Dr. Brendan Graber, Dr. Will Hsu, Dr. Silvia Chang, Dr.\n               Tyler Yan, Dr. Maharaj Haran, Dr. Vamshi Kotha, Amy Smith and Cheryl Prystanski. Thank you so much for advocating Thank you so much for advocating for timely radiological services, which are often\n               bottlenecks to timely treatments. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752268","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to also welcome the British Columbia Radiological Society, especially Dr.\n               Wan Wan Yap, Dr. Brenda Farnquist, Dr. Vamshi Kotha, Dr. Blake Jamieson, Dr. Sally\n               Harvie, Dr. Washne Patel, Dr. Brendan Graber, Dr. Will Hsu, Dr. Silvia Chang, Dr.\n               Tyler Yan, Dr. Maharaj Haran, Dr. Vamshi Kotha, Amy Smith and Cheryl Prystanski. Thank you so much for advo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036860","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Radioactivity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036860","label":"Radioactivity","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f986e6165b2c092e371d2bc05a074f302226e2837a95ab536c530c3431f0baf9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["11c59ed5c42ef7405f8c2762c8ba169ff72e569e61071772a6c822c1f9588f27"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34d107c25a1fda32face5545","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017377,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"This side of the House would also like to welcome the B.C. College of Family Physicians.\n               Founded in 1954, it's an organization of family physicians dedicated to improving\n               the practice of medicine and the health of Canadians. With over 8,000 members, the BCCFP is a passionate, independent champion of family\n               medicine, with the core purpose of bolstering the unique and irreplaceable role of\n               family physicians within the B.C. health care system. Welcome. Welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017377","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This side of the House would also like to welcome the B.C. College of Family Physicians.\n               Founded in 1954, it's an organization of family physicians dedicated to improving\n               the practice of medicine and the health of Canadians. With over 8,000 members, the BCCFP is a passionate, independent champion of family\n               medicine, with the core purpose of bolstering t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architectural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","label":"Architectural heritage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f4ab65d290e18cc53e44ba732268a91694717a6e5af39c690880bae4bff08cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f91c8359ee22506ba06741f735c6a42f56ff0480a7643d1700056d26dc40d7a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22fe44016f4852090b8fbad6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017378,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"Considering that this government's running a $13.3 billion debt, they'd be concerned\n               about spending over half a million dollars for one room without bathrooms. On that note, it's been more than 540 days since the fire at Carihi Secondary School, and over 900 students in Campbell River continue to face significant\n               disruption to their education. They are on a reduced schedule, travelling to other\n               schools for basic programs like PE and band and without essential facilities such\n               as athletics and culinary and theatre spaces. These are not extras but are foundational\n               to a healthy, connected high school experience, especially when we are seeing the\n               rate of mental health issues skyrocketing in our youth. The community has called for action, yet there is still no clear timeline for reconstruction.\n               Can the minister provide a date for when Carihi Secondary will be fully restored?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017378","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Considering that this government's running a $13.3 billion debt, they'd be concerned\n               about spending over half a million dollars for one room without bathrooms. On that note, it's been more than 540 days since the fire at Carihi Secondary School, and over 900 students in Campbell River continue to face significant\n               disruption to their education. They are on a reduced sc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c7d3d2b1b23fcd45f5ea8a2bcdb99de9ab135a115ec72be72d202bf3c32334b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d85b9d26596efb765e1b7b9126d4454abc0e5a188a3c65c5e21e68aa0d67f7fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a754402e5fa0cdd1a347784d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036500,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to take a moment to recognize and express deep appreciation for the beaver\n               lodge experimental forest, an area of immense historical, ecological, recreational\n               and community significance here in Campbell River. These lands hold a unique place\n               in British Columbia's forestry history. First gifted in trust to the province in 1931, the beaver lodge forest was established\n               specifically for the purpose of advancing reforestation and forest management practices.\n               Over the decades, the forest has continued to serve as a living classroom, supporting\n               research, resource management and environmental learning for students, professionals\n               and community members alike. Its trail networks, diverse lands and carefully managed ecosystem offer not only scientific\n               value but also a cherished green space that connects residents to the land and to\n               our shared natural heritage. Life for many people has become so busy and stressful, juggling work, family and so\n               many other responsibilities. Free time for leisure has become precious. The positive\n               impact of having beaver lodge lands as a place to walk, run, meditate and bring our\n               kids and pets cannot be overstated. Not everyone has the time or financial means to travel, and the ability to access\n               beaver lodge lands as a centre of Campbell River allows everyone to get close to nature,\n               which in so many ways helps us heal from the stressors of everyday life. Beaver lodge lands could not have happened without our dedicated community advocates,\n               volunteers and local partners, like the greenway land trust, who have worked tirelessly\n               to protect and uphold the original intent of the trust. Let us continue to honour this legacy by supporting ongoing learning, thoughtful use\n               and enduring respect for the beaver lodge experimental forest and all it represents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036500","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to take a moment to recognize and express deep appreciation for the beaver\n               lodge experimental forest, an area of immense historical, ecological, recreational\n               and community significance here in Campbell River. These lands hold a unique place\n               in British Columbia's forestry history. First gifted in trust to the province in 1931, the beaver lod","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035569","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Habitats","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43830","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Abortion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035569","label":"Habitats","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43830","label":"Abortion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["61103adac37598e0a7fe408943c054288971343d616d6df8949cbc4fbbf7829e","752d731d1b0067ee303d8b9a5680495b4ff8f290045b3d63bfaa284ade3428eb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7e6952e646006b865b415b1dcd7ede01032d7dd04329466d19a797ec2900c9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-435d56c902415e7fec435aa7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036501,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anna Kindy","venue":"Hansard","text":"As a woman and as a female doctor having to travel to get cancer care.... We're talking\n               about Fraser Health. It's the biggest health authority in British Columbia. Some 2.2\n               million people are without access — near access, I'm talking about — for ob-gyn oncology.\n               We're talking not just of cervical cancer; we're talking of uterine cancer, ovarian\n               cancer. It means multiple visits as well. I'm going to go to a different topic right now. I think it's important to talk about\n               it, because health care is a huge part of the budget. It's the largest part of the\n               budget. As such, with difficulty accessing care right now in British Columbia, resourcing\n               appropriately is extremely important. We need to know where to resource. Where do\n               we need to put the money? I'm going to actually bypass primary care. It seems we talk a lot about primary care,\n               but we don't talk a lot about specialty care, which is for the sickest patients, right?\n               The sickest patients need to see specialists. In order to resource, we need to know the wait times to see different specialties\n               — for example, neurology or to see a pediatrician. If your child is sick, you need\n               to see a pediatrician. If you have a mental health issue, primary care can deal with\n               mental health issues, but when they get very complex, they're referred to a specialty\n               — for example, psychiatry. I'm going to keep to those four, just for interest. I'm assuming, since it's the largest\n               portion of the budget, that there is tracking done in terms of wait times for referral\n               from primary care. What is the wait time to see a pediatrician in British Columbia?\n               What is the wait time to see a neurologist in British Columbia? What is the wait time\n               to see an endocrinologist in British Columbia? Very importantly, with the huge uptick\n               of mental health issues, what is the wait time to see a psychiatrist as an outpatient?\n               Not in the hospital, but in the community. What is the wait time to see a psychiatrist?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036501","member_id":"bc-mla-385","member_name":"Anna Kindy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As a woman and as a female doctor having to travel to get cancer care.... We're talking\n               about Fraser Health. It's the biggest health authority in British Columbia. Some 2.2\n               million people are without access — near access, I'm talking about — for ob-gyn oncology.\n               We're talking not just of cervical cancer; we're talking of uterine cancer, ovarian\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["636fd0916245dd62993b89e8b19aa86c2373c7e488703712bac7b7ede1e7d8a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["491b313dbac3412d3a1727f753b48be8b5e2462a9448c68f31f773a7c4879af8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c16f6311693ac3a460a37c31","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187096,"date":"2026-02-26T12:00:00+00:00","title":"FREEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PROTECTION OF PRIVACY AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov09-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov09-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187096","member_id":"bc-mla-386","member_name":"Diana Gibson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b78bdb2b85b4ee43631ec5fa","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187097,"date":"2026-02-26T12:00:00+00:00","title":"FREEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PROTECTION OF PRIVACY AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/amend/gov09-2.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/amend/gov09-2.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187097","member_id":"bc-mla-386","member_name":"Diana Gibson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd562a95c4a21cf586cf062c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187098,"date":"2026-02-26T12:00:00+00:00","title":"FREEDOM OF INFORMATION AND PROTECTION OF PRIVACY AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov09-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov09-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187098","member_id":"bc-mla-386","member_name":"Diana Gibson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e66a7911063a7d47d91d8178","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317152,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the minister for her kind words about Tumbler Ridge. That's close\n               to home from my riding. That's actually very close to home. It's left me with a heavy\n               heart since it's happened. I've got a lot of friends there. I've introduced the mayor, Darryl Krakowka, to this\n               House when he has been advocating for help for his community. You never expect that\n               to happen. I think that the one thing that they would ask.... They appreciate the supports\n               that have given so far, and they would ask that they continue to happen and that they\n               stay happening in the long term. Because in my region we have been asking for them\n               for a long time, and I thank you for your kind words. Today I rise in opposition to this budget. I do so on behalf of the people of Peace River North. Not from a spreadsheet perspective, from a lived perspective. Because budgets don't\n               show up in people's lives as line items. They show up as whether you can find a doctor,\n               whether your parent can get a long-term bed, whether your child has mental health\n               supports, whether your roads are safe to drive and whether your community still has\n               jobs. As for Peace River North, this budget delivers more of the same. Announcements without\n               outcomes, promises without timelines, spending without accountability. Let's be frank\n               here. People in the North are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for\n               fairness. They are asking for basic service that urban British Columbians take for\n               granted. They are asking to stop being treated like an afterthought. Let's start with health care. Residents across Fort St. John, Fort Nelson, Taylor,\n               Hudson's Hope live under the responsibility of Northern Health. I will say plainly\n               that the system is breaking, if not already broken. Pharmacy departments close and\n               run reduced hours, families drive hours for basic care, patients are sent out of area\n               for conditions that should be treated locally, cancer patients drive hundreds of kilometres\n               for treatment, mental health services are scarce, specialist care often requires leaving\n               the region entirely. This budget talks about billions in health spending but up north people don't experience\n               funding envelopes, they experience outcomes. In fact, an FOI request obtained by soundstreet.org\n               found around 80 Northern Health patients who died on wait-lists from 2024 to 2025.\n               Those were 80 people that were just waiting to get a specialist. The outcomes are\n               chronic doctor shortages, burnt-out nurses leaving, reliance on short-term locums,\n               ambulance delays, families living in constant uncertainty. There is no northern workforce strategy with enforceable targets in this budget, no\n               rural retention framework, no housing plan for health care workers, no guarantee that\n               new funding actually results in doctors and nurses showing up in our communities.\n               Just big numbers and press releases and broken promises. You cannot treat patients\n               with press releases. Now let's talk about seniors. For years, Peace River North has been promised a long-term-care\n               facility. Let's talk about seniors. For years, Peace River North has been promised a long-term-care facility in Fort St. John, scoped to deliver 84\n               long-term-care beds and a 30-space adult day program. That project mattered because\n               more than 70 seniors in our region are already waiting for care. Some are stuck in\n               hospital beds. Some are waiting in unsafe home situations. Families are stretched\n               thin, trying to fill the gaps. And what does this budget do? It removes the start timelines for that facility. In\n               plain language, the project is being placed on an indefinite hold. Our population\n               is aging, demand is rising, and instead of accelerating capacity, this government\n               has quietly taken the promise off schedule. That is not planning; that's abandonment. My father-in-law is sitting in Peace Villa right now, and the only way that he got\n               in there.... He was in the hospital on the second floor waiting for care. To be placed\n               into that seniors care facility for acute care, he waited 91⁄2 months. The only reason\n               he actually got in there is because five people chose MAiD and he managed to get past\n               the wait-list to get into that facility. Currently on the second floor, there are over 15 people waiting to get into the existing\n               facility. Outside on the wait-list, there are over 50 people waiting. That's just\n               what's existing. Where do we place those people if they can't get into that facility,\n               if they can't afford to live in their home, if they can't defer their property taxes?\n               Are we forcing them to live on the streets? They're going to the food banks. People in my riding, 12 percent of them are using\n               the food banks. We're at record-high numbers. Where's the practical solution? This\n               government isn't looking at it. I need to speak about mental health in Peace River North, especially for our children\n               and youth. Up north, mental health supports are scarce. Families face long wait-lists.\n               Travel is often required just to access basic care. Crisis services are limited. Preventable\n               supports are almost non-existent in smaller communities. When something goes wrong\n               in the North, there is often nowhere for the young people to go. Before Tumbler Ridge, we had two youth commit suicide in my region, in Fort St. John,\n               and they were within two weeks. One was an 11-year-old girl; the other one was a 13-year-old\n               boy. When I talk about having a heavy heart about Tumbler Ridge, this was a gut punch\n               right before it. It made me realize that for rural schools.... It's really sad. When I was a kid, each\n               school normally had a counsellor. For the rural schools now, one counsellor is allocated\n               for 800 students to the rural schools. There are no supports. When families were looking\n               for supports after those suicides, it was almost impossible to actually give them\n               any real, good solutions. Talk about Foundry. This is the main wraparound service that the province is focusing\n               on. The only thing that Foundry is able to offer right now is online. How do you properly\n               assess somebody online? How do you help a child if you can't actually see them face\n               to face and know what they're going through? We also saw that reality laid bare in Tumbler Ridge. It's not an isolated incident\n               but as the visible consequence of years of underinvestment in youth mental health.\n               That community has already been sounding the alarm. Local leaders, families and front-line\n               workers had been warning the government that supports were inadequate, that kids were\n               falling through the cracks, that early intervention programs were desperately needed. Instead of strengthening those services, this government moved to shut down one of\n               the few programs You've heard me in this House talking about it. It was a Saplings program. The funding\n               for it, when it came to the care in the ER department, got cut. It was going to be\n               cut for their outreach as well. Luckily, I've been told that it's being secured to\n               continue for the next contract, for the outreach portion of it. But Dawson Creek and Tumbler Ridge do not have a Saplings program. In Peace River,\n               we don't even have a child psychiatrist. You think about kids dying and the effects\n               on that, how it would affect everybody else. That whole town is going to have PTSD.\n               We don't even have a single child psychiatrist for a region of 88,000 people, somebody\n               that actually knows what they're doing with medications, if they need to be used. I personally worked alongside community members in Peace River North to explain to\n               this government how critical that program was for children who were struggling. We\n               made the case. We pleaded for the continuity of care, because if those services disappear,\n               children don't magically get better. They spiral. Mental health doesn't just collapse\n               overnight. It deteriorates slowly, quietly, while communities beg for help. This budget once again fails to provide a northern mental health delivery plan. There\n               is no actual dedicated youth treatment hub for Peace River North, no regional crisis\n               response team, no guarantee that new mental health funding actually lands in remote\n               communities. Just provincewide announcements with no accountability for outcomes in\n               the North. Our children deserve better than that. They deserve early intervention. They deserve\n               local supports. They deserve stability. And families deserve to know that when their\n               child is in crisis, there is somewhere to turn. Right now, too often, there isn't. This brings me back to the budget itself because this is exactly the problem. This\n               government will stand up and point to the provincewide funding totals, but those numbers\n               don't tell families in Fort St. John, Fort Nelson, Hudson's Hope and Taylor where\n               their child can go tonight if they're in crisis. They don't tell parents how long\n               they'll have to wait for counselling. They don't tell communities when treatment beds\n               will open. They don't tell schools when supports will arrive. They just tell us how\n               much money was announced. That is the fundamental failure of this budget. It measures success in dollars committed,\n               not lives improved. Up north, we don't need more press releases. We need doctors who\n               stay. We need youth mental health programs that aren't threatened with closure. We\n               need seniors beds that actually get built. We need roads and bridges that are safe\n               to drive. We need schools that can hire and retain staff. Instead, this budget offers generalized funding, shifting timelines and disappearing\n               commitments, while Peace River North is left competing with urban centres for the\n               same limited resources. That is neglect, plain and simple. Infrastructure has been left to decay in Peace River North. I think of energy, forestry,\n               agriculture, heavy haul. Everything depends on safe, reliable roads and bridges. Right\n               now too many of them are falling apart. Highways are riddled with potholes and temporary The bridges are aging out. Industrial routes that move goods to market are deteriorating.\n               Multiple hillsides are literally falling apart. Yet this budget contains no named\n               transportation upgrades. No Taylor Bridge — another failed promise. No highway reconstruction.\n               No targeted investment in the corridors that keep northern economies alive. I hear the minister talk about a powerhouse. That's this region — 38 percent of the\n               hydroelectric power; a big chunk of the LNG that goes to the coast. Forestry, agriculture.\n               It's great when the government can take the revenue from my region, but very little\n               comes back. It really can be a powerhouse. There are a lot of other projects that can be done\n               that help pay to reduce the debt, make your deficit smaller. I'd love to be able to\n               talk to you about them. I'll move on to education. It tells the same story. Northern districts struggle to\n               recruit teachers, educational assistants, counsellors and support staff. Classrooms\n               are stretched. Education funding does not keep pace with growing needs. Transportation\n               costs are higher. Housing shortages make it hard to attract professionals. Parents\n               fundraise for basic supports. Yes, this budget announces education funding, but there is no rural differential,\n               no northern recruitment strategy and no recognition that Peace River North faces fundamental\n               different conditions than urban districts. A provincewide increase means nothing when\n               northern communities start behind and continue to fall further back. In Peace River North, jobs are not just abstract economic indicators. They are family\n               supporting. They sustain schools, volunteer fire departments, minor hockey teams,\n               local shops and municipal tax bases, and this government continues to undermine them. Forestry is collapsing — mill closures, curtailments, layoffs, families forced to\n               leave towns they've lived in for generations. The sawmill that's operated in Fort\n               St. John since the '60s is shut. The pulp mill that I worked in, in Taylor, as a millwright\n               is shut now as well. Closure after closure after closure, job loss after job loss\n               after job loss. In the last few years alone, British Columbia has seen dozens of forestry facilities\n               shut down. Since 2020, at least 16 sawmills, three pulp mills, four paper mills have\n               closed across this province, many of those in the north. Every closure ripples outwards\n               — lost wages, lost services, lost students, lost volunteers. Municipalities lose millions\n               in tax revenue, and that loss doesn't disappear. It gets downloaded onto the homeowners\n               and small businesses. Industry leaders have been begging this government for certainty. Instead, they get\n               regulatory chaos, rising costs and policies made in Victoria with little understanding\n               of rural realities. This budget offers no credible forestry recovery plan for the\n               North. No urgency. No long-term strategy. Just more consultation while communities\n               are hollowed out bit by bit by bit. Agriculture up north is not being supported. In real terms, funding is flat while\n               costs rise. Farmers face higher fuel prices, higher inputs, higher transportation\n               costs and less provincial support. At a time when food security should be a priority, this government is leaving the\n               northern agriculture sector behind. They are neglecting food Farmers face higher fuel prices, higher inputs, higher transportation costs and less\n               provincial support. At a time when food security should be a priority, this government\n               is leaving the northern agriculture sector behind. They are neglecting food security.\n               Why? I heard, in question period, a question about agriculture, and it got returned instead\n               by a different minister. It's interesting — the response. I just had a constituent\n               ask me about crop loss in their region. They had 160 acres of crop loss, and the insurance\n               coverage was supposed to be 81 percent, and it came back that the coverage was 50\n               percent. What's the point of having insurance if the government isn't going to cover\n               it? Instead of fixing spending inefficiencies or growing the economy, this budget expands\n               provincial sales tax to new professional services and removes exemptions on everyday\n               items. That means families and small businesses now pay more for accounting, engineering,\n               real estate services, cable and basic necessities. People in Peace River North already pay more for groceries, fuel, heating and transportation. Now they are being\n               hit with expanded PST on top of it. This is nowhere near fiscal management. This can\n               only be classified as utter incompetence. It almost feels like a targeted attack on\n               British Columbians' way of life. Another pattern in this budget is putting the incompetence of not being able to balance\n               a budget.... When provincial decisions destabilize major employers, municipalities are\n               left holding the bag. When health care fails, families step in. When mental health\n               services aren't available, communities rely on volunteers and charities. When schools\n               can't get staffing, parents fill the gaps. Peace River North is doing more with less every year, and this budget does nothing to change that trajectory.\n               Constant promises, shifting timelines, broken trust — people in the North are tired\n               of announcements. They've heard them before. They've watched projects get announced,\n               re-announced, delayed, re-scoped and delayed again. They've watched timelines disappear\n               from capital plans. They've watched commitments quietly evaporate. What they want\n               is certainty. What they get is perpetual waiting. Under this government, Peace River North keeps hearing the same message: wait longer, travel farther, accept less. That is\n               not how you build a united province. Cost of living is higher in the North — being ignored. Everything costs more in the\n               North, groceries, fuel, heating, transportation. Families are paying a premium just\n               to live where they work. And yet this budget offers no targeted northern affordability\n               strategy, no transportation relief, no rural cost of living recognition. Policies are written as though everyone lives within transit distance of downtown\n               Vancouver. That is not reality for Peace River North. Electric batteries don't work when it's minus 46. This is not reality for Peace\n               River North. This budget lacks a northern health worker workforce strategy with measurable targets,\n               guaranteed rural health mental capacity, education funding that reflects northern\n               recruitment realities, a serious forestry recovery plan, protection for municipalities\n               facing tax base erosion, accountability for capital project delays and recognition\n               of higher operating costs in the North. Instead we get generalized provincial averages\n               and aspiring language. Peace River North cannot live off of aspirations. The North contributes enormously to this province\n               through energy, through forestry, through agriculture, through hydroelectric, through\n               mining The North contributes enormously to this province through energy, through forestry,\n               through agriculture, through hydroelectric, through mining, through hard-working families\n               who keep communities alive in some of the toughest conditions in British Columbia.\n               All they are asking for is a fair share of attention, resources and accountability. This budget does not deliver that. It leaves northern residents waiting again, out\n               in the cold. And we're waiting for doctors, for nurses, for seniors care, waiting\n               for infrastructure, waiting for jobs, waiting for mental health support. We deserve\n               better. Until this government starts treating Peace River North better as an equal partner in this province, not as an afterthought, these gaps will\n               continue to grow, just like the deficit and the debt. This province, if you look at the fundamental basis of it, just from a practical standpoint....\n               I grew up in the Lower Mainland. It's a different world down here compared to the\n               North and the rest of British Columbia. There's a very practical way that it can function as a business. We are rich in resources.\n               We need fresh revenue for British Columbians to survive and thrive. But right now\n               our fresh revenue sources are not being utilized to their fullest potential. Forestry is a great example of what's happening in that industry. It was a backbone\n               of how a lot of the towns were built in this province. If we want to see a balanced\n               budget and a debt being paid down, we need to focus on that backbone again. Instead, right now the revenues that this government is prospering off of are actually\n               our decline. As our way of life diminishes, we have vices that we turn to. People\n               struggle. They'll buy alcohol. They'll buy marijuana. They'll go gamble. Oh, but wait.\n               The government taxes those. Oh, there's no tax on alcohol? There's no tax on marijuana?\n               They're great revenue income streams. Sorry, I was just going off of facial recognition\n               on that. Right now when we look at the revenue streams that the government makes off of alcohol\n               and marijuana and gambling, these are all things that are actually bad for British\n               Columbians, for our mental health and our way of life. We need a government to focus on what is actually good for us. What's good for us\n               is going back to the practical fundamentals of how this province can work. That's\n               our resources. I can tell you right now, if I switched all of the engines on my farm\n               to electrification, I would be bankrupting my farm. It is not practical. There are\n               some things that don't work. This province and country have to go back to the practical nature of what we have,\n               to be able to bring in fresh revenue streams — not recycling the revenue that we currently\n               have in our system. Thank you very much. I want to thank my constituents that are listening and thank\n               them for being able to vote me in. I'll continue to fight as hard as I can for our\n               region.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317152","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I want to thank the minister for her kind words about Tumbler Ridge. That's close\n               to home from my riding. That's actually very close to home. It's left me with a heavy\n               heart since it's happened. I've got a lot of friends there. I've introduced the mayor, Darryl Krakowka, to this\n               House when he has been advocating for help for his community. You never exp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["941d38267fdfa623de38ee65101911837fb5ca1ace3a588111745f28e5e213e3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65c5d3f6181fa54239cdb6fecb1e8d3183bacfccbb2f319ca73aa0df7b1dfb28"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ac744fc18d28d942db149061","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317153,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"Currently we are seeing anarchy break out in Mexico because the cartels have solidified\n               positions within that society, and Canadians are stranded there. Right now British Columbians feel stranded as this government championed a failed\n               drug exemption and lowered enforcement thresholds. It doesn't matter where you live\n               in B.C. We are seeing escalated organized crime activity, from shootings in Fort St.\n               John to extortion in Surrey and a superlab in Falkland, all linked to the drug trade.\n               Just last week, the RCMP intercepted 2,700 kilograms of meth hidden in fake canola\n               jugs destined for Australia. My question to the Premier is: how do British Columbians trust this government to\n               find a solution to fix this when they are the ones who created these conditions in\n               the first place?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317153","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Currently we are seeing anarchy break out in Mexico because the cartels have solidified\n               positions within that society, and Canadians are stranded there. Right now British Columbians feel stranded as this government championed a failed\n               drug exemption and lowered enforcement thresholds. It doesn't matter where you live\n               in B.C. We are seeing escalated orga","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab95b7c8294cab6c5c8748834d16772e3d538853466c73ca3aa93e043049714d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a6a3e58b58b3c7ec964d6e43a2a704794e6721873dad05ee276a0d4e5d693e1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c684b318466060f565045d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327990,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome to the Legislature Brad Sperling and Leonard Hiebert. They\n               are from the Peace River regional district. Brad Sperling is the chair of the regional\n               district, and they are here for some minister meetings. I wish you luck.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327990","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to welcome to the Legislature Brad Sperling and Leonard Hiebert. They\n               are from the Peace River regional district. Brad Sperling is the chair of the regional\n               district, and they are here for some minister meetings. I wish you luck.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["294cb5ff055f9a0d4568685c2229daf4feb17d3a0eeeb1095c0fa31563b1b09a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb29130b2c20d64803573cba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327991,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled School Amendment Act, 2026, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. I rise today to introduce the School Amendment Act, 2026. The purpose of this legislation\n               is straightforward — to strengthen the safety of our children while class is in session. After the tragedy in Tumbler Ridge, it reminded us that the safety of our schools\n               cannot be taken for granted. No parent should worry that someone could simply walk\n               into their child's school without oversight while students are in classrooms trying\n               to simply learn. This legislation takes clear steps to strengthen the protections\n               of students by establishing controlled entry points, ensuring that access to students\n               and staff is properly monitored. Some schools across B.C. already operate this way today. Many elementary schools already\n               use controlled entry systems where visitors must check in before entering the building.\n               This legislation ensures that the level of protection is applied consistently across\n               the province. In truth, the safeguard proposed here is a simple one. Controlled entry points create\n               a critical moment of pause. They ensure that individuals cannot simply walk into a\n               school unnoticed. In an emergency, even those few moments can matter, giving staff\n               time to call 911, initiate a lockdown and protect children in their care. The truth is we already accept controlled entry as a basic safeguard in many parts\n               of our daily life. Courthouses, governments buildings control who enter. Even in our\n               own homes, we lock our doors and check who is outside before allowing someone in.\n               Yet the places where our children spend most of their days are often among the most\n               accessible buildings in our communities. I have spoken with many individuals closely connected to families affected in Tumbler\n               Ridge, and the message from parents is clear. No one should be able to access their\n               children during the school day without permission. The loss suffered in that community is a tragedy. I never want to see something like\n               that happen to another child in this province ever again. It would be my honour for\n               this to be my first bill to pass into legislation as quickly as possible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327991","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled School Amendment Act, 2026, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. I rise today to introduce the School Amendment Act, 2026. The purpose of this legislation\n               is straightforward — to strengthen the safety of our children while class is in session. After the tragedy in Tumbler Ri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3868affded2d82ec2b5c1daeda5df710a59fd3819684c43c50b4c5e9ea95295e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a104f244eed192516c62fc3033e213d74c9b37a0532a330867f7715b4c5df241"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6de00058d2488842cfcd5f55","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187130,"date":"2026-03-05T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SCHOOL AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m234-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m234-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187130","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96eb2c3b7e93635fcdbd3afa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360173,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a Bill intituled Health Professions and Occupations Repeal Act, of which\n               notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first\n               time now. I rise today not to play political games, but to introduce this bill to actually repeal\n               the Health Professions and Occupations Act, commonly known as Bill 36. I believe this\n               House should have the opportunity to debate this bill, and I have the private members'\n               time to bring it forward. With over 600 clauses, this enormous piece of legislation fundamentally changes how\n               health professions are regulated in British Columbia. The bill was forced through\n               legislature. Legislation of this size and consequence should never be rammed through\n               without full scrutiny and without legitimately consulting the professionals it affects. Under this act, the 16 health profession boards are condensed under government boards\n               that are not elected by the trained professionals they represent but instead appointed\n               by politicians. Health professionals can face penalties of up to $200,000 in fines\n               and up to two years in jail. It prevents doctors from being honest with their patients\n               for fear of contradicting health guidelines created by politicians, not health professionals.\n               It creates issues about confidentiality when allowing entry and seizure of records\n               without warrant of court order. The cabinet and ministers can adopt as law any regulation standard, codes or rules\n               enacted in foreign jurisdictions, bypassing legislature. In the middle of a doctor\n               shortage and health care crisis, we have legislation that many physicians tell me\n               they are afraid to even speak about publicly. Hundreds are planning to leave, retire\n               or have already left B.C. because of this legislation. On April 1, when the HPOA act\n               is enacted, thousands of British Columbians could be without a doctor. This repeal bill gives the Legislature the opportunity to fully examine this legislation\n               and address the concerns British Columbians and health professionals continue to raise\n               about it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360173","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that a Bill intituled Health Professions and Occupations Repeal Act, of which\n               notice has been given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first\n               time now. I rise today not to play political games, but to introduce this bill to actually repeal\n               the Health Professions and Occupations Act, commonly known as Bill 36. I believe this\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","label":"Fines","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1098395d1af98aff191c4177ffff117b107efd71d461dc5a8159dadb36872e0c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40e73cb48aebdd94df31cdae51ef89ea3446d7d1b8d577792eeb549bf0040158"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035262","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90a51e29d7f363b147ca57c0","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187133,"date":"2026-03-10T12:00:00+00:00","title":"HEALTH PROFESSIONS AND \nOCCUPATIONS REPEAL ACT (No. 2)","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m238-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m238-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187133","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c04bbff260b4cd4050a3d459","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360174,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to raise a point of order with the fact that bill did not pass first reading,\n               and not a single person in this House saw the details of that bill and the information\n               that's in that bill. You're passing judgment and assumptions on something that you\n               don't know. This House is supposed to be making decisions off of details and facts and voting\n               on them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360174","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to raise a point of order with the fact that bill did not pass first reading,\n               and not a single person in this House saw the details of that bill and the information\n               that's in that bill. You're passing judgment and assumptions on something that you\n               don't know. This House is supposed to be making decisions off of details and facts and voting\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["199a488ceb14d2a2198a71fc5c4b57da7a916694abdb521c53a277419e188b8e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-526985d599705e29e845c49e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360175,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll make this very quick. I'm in favour of this amendment with the intent of the\n               motion that's brought forward to this House. The intent of when it's brought forward\n               to the public is that it'll support the human rights code. It gives that impression\n               when this House votes on it, we will be displaying that intent to the public. Right now, with the way that it's phrased, it is not worded to reflect the whole human\n               rights code. This amendment clearly changes that and makes it represent that intent\n               to when it is voted on this House floor. That is how it will be displayed to the public. I am in favour of this amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360175","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'll make this very quick. I'm in favour of this amendment with the intent of the\n               motion that's brought forward to this House. The intent of when it's brought forward\n               to the public is that it'll support the human rights code. It gives that impression\n               when this House votes on it, we will be displaying that intent to the public. Right now, with the way th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cec01a5e3f24c7c3aa7d18cdd2d773edbbe002befea83999fcadf1e51ac31c07"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9cdc53a38080a8fee7cb54de5f55713133b8cd0d374dd5a3d9abeea731fbda4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2dd5df1b83df45510c4e92f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415748,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"Metal fatigue does not reverse, and when steel is cracked, welded and cracked again,\n               it does not return to its original strength. In fact, it creates more stress points,\n               which is stated in the reports obtained by the ICBA after they waited nine months\n               for an FOI request of inspection reports from 2020 to 2025 of the Taylor Bridge. We now know the Taylor Bridge has cracked steel that is being welded and recracked.\n               This cannot only happen so much to steel so many times until critical failure occurs.\n               The corrosion Even after all that, the records show that this government is still identifying a\n               preferred course of action, with reports leaning towards rehabilitation and more patchwork\n               instead of replacement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415748","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Metal fatigue does not reverse, and when steel is cracked, welded and cracked again,\n               it does not return to its original strength. In fact, it creates more stress points,\n               which is stated in the reports obtained by the ICBA after they waited nine months\n               for an FOI request of inspection reports from 2020 to 2025 of the Taylor Bridge. We now know the Taylor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["afb7f3883e6d1d39590a758ad2a00717f3750229a8c8bcf1b1a04df5f6917985"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e1433cbd23c0123e5ec4b133cccf7d1d3220f34d43412657969ca9d8227bc41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-54aab77c0379916f89f360f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720388,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to say happy birthday to my constituency assistant in Fort St. John. It's\n               her 30th birthday. So I please ask you to give them a warm welcome. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720388","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to say happy birthday to my constituency assistant in Fort St. John. It's\n               her 30th birthday. So I please ask you to give them a warm welcome. Thank you very much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb28b08927241a097282e530d95a6c2ca3a595570bb8e1ce32e6949208bccf7e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc66d475967ff7b3f5dfdd0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720391,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today on behalf of the hard-working families, loggers, truckers and mill workers\n               of Peace River North to speak on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. I\n               am not here to play political games or score points. I am here because of my riding Peace River North, and that is being hit hard by years\n               of NDP mismanagement of our resource sector. This bill is just one more of the same,\n               tinkering around the edges while our communities bleed jobs and opportunities. As a farmer and millwright, I live and breathe the realities of northern British Columbia\n               every single day. I know what it means when the mills go quiet, when the logging contractors\n               have to park their equipment and when families have to consider leaving because work\n               is scarce. I am one of the few MLAs that have worked in mills, and there is a good\n               chance that I would have been one of the ones out of a job too if I was still working\n               in that sector. In Fort Nelson, we lost mills. The pulp mill that I worked for in\n               Taylor closed. The sawmill in Fort St. John just previously, last year, closed. Thousands\n               of jobs lost. Let's be clear about what this bill actually does. The NDP government wants to expand\n               the role of B.C. Timber Sales, their own government-run timber sales program. They're\n               creating new contract logging authorizations so that the province can directly hire\n               contractors to cut down timber without giving anyone real tenure. They're letting the minister implement stricter-than-normal terms and conditions.\n               They're broadening the BCTS stewardship role and giving themselves more flexibility\n               to spend money from the Timber Sales account. They're calling it a win for fibre supply,\n               wildfire risk reduction and First Nations partnerships. If this was the bold action our industry needed after 31 mills closed in the last\n               five years, I'd be the first one cheering. But it isn't. This is the classic NDP progression.\n               More government control, more red tape, more uncertainty, dressed up as progress.\n               For the people I represent in the Peace For the people I represent in the Peace, it falls horribly short. In Peace River North, our region depends on forestry as a foundational industry. The combined timber supply\n               area for the Peace has an allowable annual cut of around 4.7 million cubic metres,\n               but we've watched the Canfor sawmill in Fort St. John shut down, costing over 220\n               direct jobs and thousands more in the supply chains. Truckers, fallers, equipment operators and small contractors in Taylor, Fort St. John,\n               Nelson, Hudson's Hope and up the Alaska Highway are the backbone of our economy. When\n               fibre doesn't reach the mills, those families feel it first. Yet this bill does not\n               fix the real problems choking our sector — chronically low harvest levels, endless\n               permitting delays, old-growth deferrals that lock up viable timber and investment\n               chill created by this government's own policies. Bill 14 entrenches more bureaucratic oversight through BCTS. Why should the government\n               be getting bigger in the logging business when private operators and tenure holders\n               are the ones who actually know how to run a sustainable, private or profitable operation? Northern operators already face sky-high transportation costs, harsh winters and thin\n               margins. Adding stricter terms and conditions that go beyond existing laws, whether\n               it's extra environmental standards, more consultation requirements or compliance with\n               outside standard bodies, only drives up costs and drives away investment. That's not\n               helping wildfire risk reduction. That's layering on more red tape that makes it harder\n               to get work done. Let's talk about what this bill conveniently ignores. It says nothing about keeping\n               logs in British Columbia for local processing. While our mills starve, raw logs still\n               head offshore. It does nothing to meaningfully raise the provincial harvest target\n               or slash the regulatory burden that has idled so much of our industry. And worst of\n               all, it does nothing to address the elephant in the room, the uncertainty created\n               by the NDP's Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, also known as DRIPA. I know this file well. Last year I stood in this House, and I introduced my own private\n               member's bill to repeal and reset DRIPA because this government has turned what it\n               was supposed to be, a path to unity, into a tool for division and delay. In Treaty 8 territory, right in my riding, cumulative effects rulings, overlapping\n               consultations and unclear jurisdictions have created a veto-like chill on resource\n               projects. Bill 14 talks about partnerships with First Nations. But without clear rules,\n               faster timelines and respect for existing treaties, those partnerships become just\n               more process, more lawyers and more uncertainties for contractors and workers on the\n               ground. The people of Peace River North want fair, transparent relationships built on respect, not endless red tape that\n               shuts down various projects that create shared prosperity. This bill also quietly expands ministerial powers over fees and spending from the\n               BCTS account. British Columbians want accountability, not blank cheques for more government\n               programs. Taxpayers and industries alike deserve to know exactly where the money is\n               going and whether it is actually creating jobs or just growing the bureaucracy in\n               Victoria. The NDP love to talk about sustainable forestry and climate leadership, but the results\n               in northern British Columbia tell me a different story. Investment and confidence\n               is in the toilet. Mills are closing. Young people are leaving, and families who have\n               worked in the bush for generations are wondering if there is a future here at all. I attended the COFI forestry conference recently. The room was packed with people\n               desperate for solutions, real solutions, not more government-managed salvage programs\n               while the core allowable cut stays suppressed and the rulebook keeps growing. What Peace River North needs, what all British Columbians need, is a government that trusts the private\n               sector, cuts the red tape, raises sustainable harvest levels What Peace River North needs, what all British Columbians need, is a government that trusts the private\n               sector, cuts the red tape, raises sustainable harvest levels where science supports\n               it, prioritizes local processing and provides regulatory certainty instead of ideological\n               experiments. We need to repeal DRIPA and replace it with legislation that actually works for all\n               British Columbians. We need faster approvals, not more ministerial discretion, and\n               we need to stop treating our resource workers like they're the problem and start treating\n               them like the solution that they are. Bill 14 is not the real answer. It is a modest administrative tweak that entrenches\n               more government involvement without delivering the fibre, the jobs or the confidence\n               of our industry that northern communities desperately need. The loggers, the truck\n               drivers, the mill families in Fort St. John, Fort Nelson and across the Peace deserve\n               better than another half-measure from a government that has already decimated this\n               sector. Let's stop tinkering, and let's start the real work of restoring forestry as the economic\n               backbone of this province and think about a future of forestry where instead of just\n               looking at it as forestry management, we can actually look at it as farming our forests.\n               It really is the only sustainable resource we have. Farmers, on a regular basis, harvest crops annually in my region. We do it sustainably,\n               we do it respectfully of the environment, and we do it very efficiently. We can do\n               the same with our forests. It's just a longer turnover for the crop. I look forward to seeing what this bill brings in the committee stage. I want to thank\n               the forestry minister for coming up to my riding and being able to meet with me to\n               discuss some of the concerns about this. I went to school to become a millwright. I hear the government praise how they're\n               promoting apprenticeships, and it took me a while to get my apprenticeship ticket\n               to be able to work in these mills, and they're disappearing. I took the time to get\n               a second trades ticket to make myself more valuable, and it would make it even harder\n               now to get into some of these mills because so many trades people are having to go\n               to other provinces to be able to find jobs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720391","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today on behalf of the hard-working families, loggers, truckers and mill workers\n               of Peace River North to speak on Bill 14, Forests Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. I\n               am not here to play political games or score points. I am here because of my riding Peace River North, and that is being hit hard by years\n               of NDP mismanagement of our resource sector. T","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7fe50aed249ebece36a49b7e1850b6f9bed2ef38339efcccea0a13fc3107bfef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c5a55d9a59b39334daf0d9962e426b134e6256c32bf3a45f8219514a1b38fae9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1950077c256e8f4c81b02219","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721491,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thought you were going to save the best for last. I would like to introduce my friend and fierce advocate for Tumbler Ridge, Darryl\n               Krakowka. He is in the House today. He has been here for a couple of days, as well as members\n               from the Peace River regional district. They have been here for a couple of days. I also want to thank the Minister of Transportation for fitting in an impromptu meeting\n               for a landslide that just happened in my community that isolated some families. It's\n               not an easy situation, so I just wanted to give a shout out to everybody. I wish you\n               luck in the rest of your meetings.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721491","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thought you were going to save the best for last. I would like to introduce my friend and fierce advocate for Tumbler Ridge, Darryl\n               Krakowka. He is in the House today. He has been here for a couple of days, as well as members\n               from the Peace River regional district. They have been here for a couple of days. I also want to thank the Minister of Transportation for fitt","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d4fd0397807b8a2a940e18a30c7b189243ad009d125643302d98ddf433dc98e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5f6f67fc4a39c7cbb11d79c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721492,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"You know, it's been a little over a year that I've been an Independent now, and I\n               represent my constituents first and foremost. I have to say it is sick when I see\n               partisan politics. Absolutely sickening. You should take a look at yourselves and\n               actually focus at the people that you represent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721492","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You know, it's been a little over a year that I've been an Independent now, and I\n               represent my constituents first and foremost. I have to say it is sick when I see\n               partisan politics. Absolutely sickening. You should take a look at yourselves and\n               actually focus at the people that you represent.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036076","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Landslides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036076","label":"Landslides","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9fd2133e7528ed0295e885bca3d425267170857dfe7d844b7b8f579324619961","d9998adfff68e3b707d69a978b60ddfef726d2c56270d511f4c9c116db316251"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-602b55d8a16c2dca8e954364","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752264,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to welcome the Cattlemen's Association, as we've heard previously. They do\n               an amazing job of advocating for cattle farmers across the province. As you celebrate\n               Beef Day today, I want to remind you that for cattle farmers.... They don't get a day\n               to celebrate. They work all year round. They've got those animals. Most of the time,\n               they don't get to go on vacation. Right now, as I'm here, my wife is calving out cattle\n               at home on the farm. I want to reach out and thank the Cattlemen's for showing up here, but I also want\n               to turn around and thank cattle farmers all across the province for putting in the\n               hard work that they do all year round.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752264","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to welcome the Cattlemen's Association, as we've heard previously. They do\n               an amazing job of advocating for cattle farmers across the province. As you celebrate\n               Beef Day today, I want to remind you that for cattle farmers.... They don't get a day\n               to celebrate. They work all year round. They've got those animals. Most of the time,\n               t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aade2e0662949bfe0cd841fb2f7748be9b6ea03939d69504c96d5b24c5a23950"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1cefb47a3a6a30891acbd11e2cfb3cb2c6c70dd1d68fc9c9cbfdb2d07fd60db8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-926ba07ee677a803b72ac49b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752265,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today in support of the hoist amendment to Bill 9. And I do so because I believe\n               this House needs to pause, a genuine pause, and seriously reflect on what is happening\n               here, because when these many people from these many different walks of life start\n               raising the same concern at the same time, governments should pay attention. And that\n               is exactly what is happening right now. This is not simply opposition criticism. This is not one political party disagreeing\n               with another political party. We are hearing very real concerns from journalists,\n               from taxpayer advocates, from watchdog organizations, from citizens, from rural communities,\n               from people who use the FOI system regularly, from ordinary British Columbians who\n               are looking at this legislation and asking themselves a very simple question: why\n               does this government seem so determined to make access to information harder instead\n               of easier? The government members may not like hearing that question, but people are\n               asking it more and more. Over the last number of years, British Columbians have become increasingly skeptical\n               of centralized power and increasingly skeptical of institutions that appear less transparent\n               than they once were. Government members may not like hearing that, but it is true. I think one of the biggest mistakes governments make, not just here but everywhere,\n               is dismissing public concern as background noise instead of recognizing it as a warning\n               sign. Because when distrust starts growing across multiple parts of society at the\n               same time, governments should pay attention, very close attention. That's what this\n               six-month hoist gives us the ability to do — to pay attention. What concerns me deeply about Bill 9 is that instead of responding to growing distrust\n               with more openness and more honesty, government appears to be responding by expanding\n               discretion and tightening control around the information itself. What a backwards\n               way to gain the trust of the people. I listened carefully to the government's defence of this legislation. I understand\n               the argument that they are making. The system is strained. There are more requests.\n               There are more digital records. There are more communications to manage. Artificial\n               intelligence is increasing the ability of people to file the complaints and review\n               requests more efficiently. The Information and Privacy Commissioner himself has acknowledged\n               that complaints and reviews are rising dramatically. I understand all of that. But the existence of administrative strain does not automatically\n               justify giving institutions more discretion over access to information. Those are\n               not the same thing, because if the system is under pressure, government has choices.\n               It can strengthen capacity. It can improve records management. It can improve responsiveness.\n               It can increase staffing. It can modernize documentation systems. It can improve proactive\n               disclosures so citizens do not need to file requests as frequently in the first place. Those would all be reforms designed to strengthen transparency. That's why we need\n               to take a pause to be able to analyze this information and take the time. One recent commentary in the Times Colonist put it plainly: \"B.C. should fix FOI system instead of restricting it.\" Honestly,\n               that is exactly the concern many British Columbians are raising right now. If the\n               system is strained, then strengthen the system, improve staffing, improve records\n               management, improve proactive disclosure. But when the response instead becomes broadened\n               refusal powers, softened language One of the most important things that I have learned representing northern British\n               Columbia is that trust in institutions is not automatic. It must be earned. And once\n               people have stopped believing what they are being told, it is very difficult to get\n               that trust back. That's why I believe that we need to take a pause and do this hoist. People in the\n               north of British Columbia already feel far removed from many of the decisions affecting\n               their lives. When you live in Fort St. John, Fort Nelson, Hudson's Hope or even smaller\n               communities across the Peace region, decisions made in Victoria can feel incredibly\n               distant, sometimes disconnected, sometimes completely detached from other regional\n               realities. When people feel that distance, the public's ability to get answers becomes even more\n               important. That is why freedom of information matters so much outside of major urban\n               centres. For many people, it is one of the only practical tools they have left to\n               obtain answers from institutions otherwise feeling unreachable. When hospital services change, when emergency rooms close, when permits are delayed,\n               when regulatory decisions affect livelihoods, when projects stall, when promises disappear,\n               people want to know why, and increasingly, they do not feel that they are getting\n               direct answers through ordinary communication channels, so they file FOI requests,\n               not because they are trying to attack the government, not because they are trying\n               to create chaos, but because they are trying to understand what is happening. And\n               I think members opposite underestimate how important that distinction is. One of the phrases we hear repeatedly from the government is that Bill 9 is about\n               modernization and efficiency. But transparency is not supposed to be convenient for\n               the government. It is supposed to require effort. It is supposed to require organization.\n               It is supposed to require the government to explain itself. If accountability begins to feel inconvenient for institutions, that is not evidence\n               the system is broken. That is evidence the system is functioning exactly as intended,\n               because the entire purpose of the access to information legislation is to rebalance\n               power between institutions and ordinary citizens. Government holds enormous amounts of information that the public does not have direct\n               access to. That imbalance exists naturally. The FOI process exists to correct that\n               imbalance, and we can't rush that system. This is one of the reasons why I support\n               this hoist. Government also holds enormous power, enormous amounts of taxpayers' money, and the\n               people paying those taxes have every right to know where that money is going, how\n               it is being spent, who decisions are being made for and what conversations are happening\n               behind closed doors using public dollars. These aren't unreasonable asks, and to dismiss them like they are, is very telling,\n               and the government appears to tighten control around information involving public\n               money. The heart of the public is going to push for answers because people are already asking\n               themselves: \"Why it is becoming more difficult to access information tied to taxpayers'\n               dollars? Why does this government seem more focused on limiting access to information\n               rather than improving transparency? Why are refusal powers expanding instead of narrowing?\n               Why is discretion increasing instead of openness?\" Government members may not like those questions, but people are asking them anyways. When citizens feel shut out of the process, they do not become less curious. They\n               become more suspicious, especially when it involves their money, and that is something\n               this government should think very One of the things I find most remarkable in this debate is that government appears\n               genuinely surprised by the public reaction. But honestly, why? Why would people not\n               react strongly to legislation affecting public access to information during the time\n               when trust in institutions is already weak? Why would people not question language\n               that softens obligations and broadens discretion? Why would people not become skeptical\n               when they already feel government decision-making has become increasingly centralized\n               and increasingly difficult to scrutinize? What concerns me most is that the government seems to believe that growing skepticism\n               is better messaging rather than deepening transparency. But messaging does not fix\n               this. Only openness fixes this. Only honesty fixes this. Only transparency fixes this.\n               The more government seems focused on controlling the conversation instead of expanding\n               openness, the more suspicious people become. That is just reality. That is why we\n               need to take the time to pause and do this hoist amendment. I also think government is underestimating how closely the public is watching now.\n               People are paying attention in a way that they were not ten years ago. People are\n               reading legislation. People are discussing procedural changes. People are questioning\n               institutional language. People are sharing information constantly, and many British\n               Columbians already believe governments and institutions operate too often behind closed\n               doors. When legislation appears that expands refusal powers or broadens administration discretion,\n               people immediately become suspicious. That is the environment that we are in. Pretending\n               people are not upset is not going to fix this, and this is precisely why this hoist\n               amendment is necessary. It's because a hoist amendment, at its core, says something\n               very simple. Pause to listen, to reconsider. Take seriously the level of concern emerging\n               from outside this chamber. It's not radical. It's responsible, especially when the\n               legislation deals directly with the public's ability to actually get answers from\n               this government. This is exactly why the hoist amendment makes sense. If government\n               truly believes this legislation is balanced, reasonable and necessary, then it will\n               still be balanced, reasonable and necessary six months from now. So why rush? Why the urgency to move this through while so many other concerns are\n               still being raised both inside and outside this chamber? Why the resistance to slowing\n               down? Listen carefully and allow fuller public debate to occur. British Columbians\n               are increasingly noticing a pattern in this place, a pattern where government consults\n               selectively, listens selectively and then ultimately proceeds exactly as it intended\n               from the very beginning, regardless of how much concern is raised publicly. People are getting tired of feeling like the decision was already made before they\n               ever open their mouths. People are already starting to feel like consultation means\n               that the government lets you speak for five minutes and then does whatever it already\n               planned to do anyway. I think many people watching this debate are asking themselves\n               a very simple question. If this bill is truly about strengthening transparency and\n               improving public confidence, then why does this government appear so uncomfortable\n               with extended scrutiny? Why not slow down? Why not allow more debate? Why not hear more from the people who\n               actually use the FOI system regularly? Why not hear more from journalists, watchdog\n               groups, rural residents, citizens and organizations who are clearly signalling concerns? Strong legislation should withstand scrutiny. In fact, strong legislation benefits\n               from scrutiny. If government is confident in its position, then it should not fear\n               additional time and additional debate. But increasingly, many British Columbians feel government is no longer governing with\n               the public. It is governing around the public. And there is a difference. People feel\n               decisions are becoming more centralized, more insulated, more controlled. When concerns\n               are raised, government often seems more focused on controlling the conversation than\n               actually addressing the issue itself. The government members should not fool themselves into thinking people are not noticing\n               this. People are connecting the dots. I think members opposite also need to recognize something else. Public frustration\n               does not emerge overnight. It builds gradually, one decision at a time, one controversy\n               at a time, one dismissal at a time, one moment where people feel ignored at a time.\n               I can just think of recently in this House, when I talked about the Taylor Bridge\n               and the FOI that revealed about so many defects with that bridge. What if it becomes\n               harder for residents in my region to be able to figure out about what's happening\n               in our region? Eventually, people begin connecting those moments together into a broader conclusion\n               about whether government still respects public accountability at all. This is where\n               the danger lies, because once citizens begin believing institutions no longer genuinely\n               listen to them, distrust accelerates very quickly. Frankly, I think that part of the reason there is such strong push-back to Bill 9\n               is because people no longer automatically assume government intentions are benign.\n               That trust has weakened, and government should be asking itself what has happened\n               instead of dismissing every concern as misinformation, obstruction or partisanship. These concerns are not isolated anymore. They are broad. They are growing, and they\n               are increasingly coming from ordinary people who simply feel that government no longer\n               hears them. Governments are always strongest when they remain connected to public sentiment —\n               not when they dismiss it, not when they bulldoze past it and not when they treat public\n               scrutiny as an inconvenience standing in the way of their goals. That approach may\n               work legislatively in the short term, but people remember it. Every time government\n               appears unwilling to pause and genuinely listen, more people start believing that\n               they are actually being heard.... That is exactly why this hoist amendment matters. It gives this House an opportunity\n               to stop, reflect and reconsider before moving forward down a path that many British\n               Columbians clearly do not trust. Members in this House are going to have to make a choice, because this vote is about\n               more than just procedure. It's about whether this House believes British Columbians\n               deserve more time, more scrutiny and more openness when it comes to accessing information\n               laws. If members are unwilling to even support a pause, unwilling to even support\n               six months of public scrutiny and debate on legislation this significant, then I think\n               the public is entitled to draw its own conclusions on where those members stand on\n               freedom of access to information. Ordinary British Columbians are not asking for less transparency right now. They are\n               asking for more, and they are watching very closely to see who in this chamber is\n               willing to slow down and listen and who is determined to push ahead. The government members should ask themselves honestly: if this bill is truly as beneficial\n               as they claim, then why are so many people from so many different walks of life warning\n               them to slow down? That question alone should justify a pause, and that is why I support\n               this hoist amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752265","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today in support of the hoist amendment to Bill 9. And I do so because I believe\n               this House needs to pause, a genuine pause, and seriously reflect on what is happening\n               here, because when these many people from these many different walks of life start\n               raising the same concern at the same time, governments should pay attention. And that\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cce332fc68472d720cc46c3438931ecb997dc70a1e9479b324a939ca036d2633"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a591f132abe47ffc2a7009d775465c954263fd67f24180694e36c59f63825a19"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-427cd446bf0a4a6e4c99d977","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752266,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce a good friend of mine, Charmaine Dunkley. This is the first time she has managed to come to the Legislature. She's one of\n               those people that brings warmth and a smile to everywhere she goes, and she spends\n               a lot of time volunteering and helping others. If everybody from the Legislature could welcome her and give her a smile as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752266","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce a good friend of mine, Charmaine Dunkley. This is the first time she has managed to come to the Legislature. She's one of\n               those people that brings warmth and a smile to everywhere she goes, and she spends\n               a lot of time volunteering and helping others. If everybody from the Legislature could welcome her and give her a smile as well.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2fb8a470ef935a36b5ff90c47b51491ff5d0eab1e476a249e9af235d99dab8f8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c63b83397f88446ef487bb1e7d67434b1d0501c6f00cd457f75bdd641a72d638"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-992ea0ec61a4315d9baecf56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017371,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"The reaction to a term used in this House made one thing very clear. British Columbians\n               do not support unequal treatment. So it's fair to ask: why are we seeing policies\n               to create different levels of certainty and control depending on who you are? Because\n               if fairness isn't a standard, it must be applied consistently. If it doesn't, people\n               have every right to question it. The reaction we saw last week and a half ago was immediate and intense. It would be\n               good to see the same urgency when British Columbians are asking real questions about\n               fairness and clarity in this House. There are certain words referred to with this treaty by another member of this House,\n               and there was a very quick reaction. The people called them very specific things.\n               And it wasn't even referred to in a way of how the member was using the words or how\n               they were even intended. In fact, it was the exact opposite manner. The Speaker asked for the member to retract, and the member did. But what was even\n               more interesting was that a motion was brought forward after the fact that didn't\n               actually make it successfully into the House. But the motion that is currently sitting\n               on the standing paper contradicts the Speaker's ruling. It makes you wonder whether\n               or not it strengthens what we stand for in this House, which is freedom of speech,\n               or whether or not it undermines it. This matters because the same mindset is showing up in how this government is approaching\n               this bill. We don't have to guess how difficult these issues can become. We can look\n               at other jurisdictions around the world, countries like South Africa, New Zealand,\n               Australia, and even parts of the U.S., where questions about land rights and governance\n               have taken decades to work through. The lesson isn't that these places are the same as B.C. It's that once you introduce\n               uncertainty, people begin to feel that the rules are not consistent. It becomes incredibly\n               difficult to rebuild trust and confidence. Those are the very concerns I hear from\n               the hard-working people of Peace River North, the farmers, the ranchers, resource workers, families who get up every single morning\n               and build this province with their own two hands. I rise today as the independent MLA for Peace River North, where we live every day\n               with the realities of reconciliation that's done right in Treaty 8 territory — not\n               behind closed doors, not through secret deals but through real partnership that works\n               through every single British Columbian. Today I stand to speak against Bill 20, K'ómoks Treaty Act. I will vote against it, and I will keep fighting it, because this is not the way\n               forward for British Columbians, and it has the controversy of DRIPA tied into it. This treaty hands over more than 34 square kilometres of Crown land in the Comox Valley,\n               free simple title, mineral rights, forestry tenures, self-government powers and $56\n               million in taxpayer money all signed, sealed and delivered with almost no public debate,\n               no real consultation with the majority of British Columbians and, most importantly,\n               no requirement for the K'ómoks Nation to fully surrender or pull back their underlying Aboriginal title claims. Who benefits from this decision? The majority of British Columbians? No. Homeowners\n               trying to keep their property secure? No. Government debt and fiscal But First Nations lawyers? Yes. First Nations consultants? Yes. Corrupt politicians\n               who love cutting deals in the back rooms? Yes. And the NDP and their federal Liberal\n               friends are smiling all the way to the next photo op. The B.C. NDP and the federal Liberals are not governing in the best interests of everyone,\n               and they're doing it on purpose. This is the same pattern we've seen with DRIPA. Operate\n               behind closed doors. Shut down real debate. Ram through agreements that sound good\n               in a press release but create uncertainty, division and erosion of confidence in private\n               property rights across this entire province. I brought forward my own private member's bill to repeal DRIPA to force real, transparent\n               discussions so that every British Columbian has a seat at the table.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017371","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The reaction to a term used in this House made one thing very clear. British Columbians\n               do not support unequal treatment. So it's fair to ask: why are we seeing policies\n               to create different levels of certainty and control depending on who you are? Because\n               if fairness isn't a standard, it must be applied consistently. If it doesn't, people\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bankruptcies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","label":"Corruption","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:790077","label":"Bankruptcies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbd53a84efb491c46a5f8f471d39525f5f517809bcaa735ea18210fb31bb9fae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["15f26db0ba3590f23f843cb8dee42b54ed482cab2a5dd70d1aa3a986e16d63b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea304c6ce2a271b6a53f2f01","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017376,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jordan Kealy","venue":"Hansard","text":"Imagine for a moment you are setting out on a midsummer drive, and you have never\n               been to my region before. You have heard about how beautiful the north is and want\n               to experience it for yourself on a new motorcycle. As you are cruising along Highway\n               97, listening to your music and taking in the scenery, you get to the mighty Peace\n               River and proceed across the bridge, but you never saw the hole in the grating on\n               the bridge. In that moment, one preventable moment, your life has changed forever. To give context\n               to the House, Taylor Bridge is not much smaller than the Port Mann by span or height,\n               but the deck is open-grading that is always having to be repaired. This is now the\n               third time in less than a year that I have stood in this house raising concerns about\n               the Taylor Bridge. I was just sent two pictures a couple of days ago of four new holes\n               in the bridge decking. The four of the grouping of the holes are no smaller than the\n               size of this podium.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017376","member_id":"bc-mla-387","member_name":"Jordan Kealy","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Imagine for a moment you are setting out on a midsummer drive, and you have never\n               been to my region before. You have heard about how beautiful the north is and want\n               to experience it for yourself on a new motorcycle. As you are cruising along Highway\n               97, listening to your music and taking in the scenery, you get to the mighty Peace\n               River a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["049e23fb0f72d1363db29b99286eef54b9677837f83f3a39d8a9c9945b416653"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ce1b1081067bda673ea6bb3856cec46e524ab8e9d955e07d3b4cefac4a337f9f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ca83dae6e1f6676ef5b48b5b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317184,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Tumbler Ridge — pain; loss; devastation; gut-wrenching, soul-tearing anguish. And\n               it's not the first community that has faced this in the last 12 months. My question to the Premier is, will he today commit to a public inquiry to gain every\n               bit of information that is possible to try and prevent this from happening My question to the Premier is: will he today commit to a public inquiry to gain every\n               bit of information that is possible to try and prevent this from happening to another\n               community?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317184","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Tumbler Ridge — pain; loss; devastation; gut-wrenching, soul-tearing anguish. And\n               it's not the first community that has faced this in the last 12 months. My question to the Premier is, will he today commit to a public inquiry to gain every\n               bit of information that is possible to try and prevent this from happening My question to the Premier is: will he today commit to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["631f421be2def49f9dadfe69b901f0f171153c67cab6a0cbe79c139622d6160f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acf61f9b1fbb1701ec00aaf2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328026,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery we are joined by a large contingent of members from the Canadian\n               Hydrogen Association. The Canadian Hydrogen Association is a national non-profit association, comprising\n               of industry, academia, research agencies and end-users, focused on advancing the use\n               of clean hydrogen and hydrogen technologies to help create a prosperous net-zero world. For those of us in this place of honour that have not yet seen so, please do take\n               an opportunity to visit the hydrogen-powered vehicles that are out on the front step\n               at this time. Please help me make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328026","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today in the gallery we are joined by a large contingent of members from the Canadian\n               Hydrogen Association. The Canadian Hydrogen Association is a national non-profit association, comprising\n               of industry, academia, research agencies and end-users, focused on advancing the use\n               of clean hydrogen and hydrogen technologies to help create a prosperous net-zer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac2360e652fb00925edb68e1640933a2e67fb962f9e83b0601d819b269bd40a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ad316c097eea40b3bda1dac24476e07dd0a49582b7716ba4cbc92d023b1ea07"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3acfdc3fe57163d83d23d4c9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360865,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Tumbler Ridge. It has been one month since that horrific event occurred in the community\n               — one month. I have called for a public inquiry. We have had no response. The community deserves more than vague answers and a lack of commitment to that essential\n               tool, which will provide information that we must have in order to prevent something\n               so horrific, so incredibly soul-tearing, from happening in another community again.\n               Even former judges and Attorneys General from this province are calling for this to\n               be done. My question to the government is: will they today commit to calling for a public inquiry\n               into the Tumbler Ridge incident — yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360865","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Tumbler Ridge. It has been one month since that horrific event occurred in the community\n               — one month. I have called for a public inquiry. We have had no response. The community deserves more than vague answers and a lack of commitment to that essential\n               tool, which will provide information that we must have in order to prevent something\n               so horrific, so i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8c22e90144e7d4880ec622fac021c34eddb3404ba0fade4cd96946d379ca586"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6625ba730d71a98331ab9c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360867,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"As I've mentioned a number of times in this place of honour, British Columbia does\n               not end at Hope. There's a whole heck of a lot more province to the north of that. Mile Zero of the Alaska Highway is one important component of that, and I'm pleased\n               to announce that today I have a very important constituent here with me that lives\n               at mile six of the Alaska Highway. I'd like the House to make my constituent feel very welcome, and her name is Farrell\n               Pathis.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360867","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"As I've mentioned a number of times in this place of honour, British Columbia does\n               not end at Hope. There's a whole heck of a lot more province to the north of that. Mile Zero of the Alaska Highway is one important component of that, and I'm pleased\n               to announce that today I have a very important constituent here with me that lives\n               at mile six of the Ala","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Arctic","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43435","label":"Arctic","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e365bbecc8afe783da804e2333d5f77716fe280f83e3cbf50aa19d0dbca0b6eb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e6a475f8cbb6b60d59d26e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415793,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's nice to be here today. For those that might be watching on television, they may not recognize me as the MLA\n               that represents Tumbler Ridge. But that being said, Bill 12, Safe Access to Schools\n               Amendment Act, how on earth could I speak against that? On its premise, the legislation\n               is something that, again, for me is very difficult to speak against as a critic. It\n               is my role to point out where I feel that there could be improvements made, and that\n               is the intent of what I'm going to be doing over the next few minutes. As I've already said, I can't imagine where a person could rationally decide that\n               protection of children is not something that is the absolute paramount and most incredible\n               responsibility of our society. Without question, every student deserves safety, respect,\n               and every parent expects and deserves that their child has Again, my role in this place of honour is to point out where improvements could be\n               made. In this particular case, there are some questions that I would have, with respect\n               to Bill 12. My main question would be that given that.... Many of the protections included\n               in Bill 12 already exist in existing legislation. So the main question in my mind\n               is, why do we need this extension? Why are we not enforcing the laws that we already\n               have? Why are we not empowering the police departments and the other law enforcement\n               agencies to enforce the laws that already exist? This bill does not create new offences. They're already covered by existing law. I, for one, am a fan of less, perhaps, paperwork. I don't\n               want to see laws passed for the sake of laws. If it's already there and it's already\n               not being enforced, I think that's our prerogative as legislators to ensure that existing\n               laws of all nature are enforced. This bill also does not expand enforcement authority. That already exists. Significant\n               and sufficient enforcement authority already exists. As has already been said in this\n               chamber, the bill simply extends the repeal date from 2026 to 2028. I do know that.... Before I move forward with the written word.... I was sitting thinking\n               as I, obviously, was listening to everyone speak before me, and I think it bears....\n               The colleague across the aisle spoke to it in her remarks — society has fundamentally\n               changed. I'm going to date myself with this reference, but anyone that sees the colour of my\n               hair would have a fairly good indication of.... I might be a little bit older than you.\n               The concern that I have is the overall fundamental shift in society — why we would\n               need something like this. And I'm not arguing that we don't. I'm not. I'm going to relate a story from my childhood. I grew up in a rural area in a different\n               province, and one of my classmates was very proud of having received a .22 rifle for\n               his birthday. He brought it to school. It wasn't a big deal. He wasn't allowed to\n               play with it. It was put.... We went out and shot stones and what have you afterwards.\n               In fact, I remember receiving a hunting knife and bringing that to school to show\n               off to my buddies. It's deeply concerning to me as I'm sure everyone else here that, and rightfully so,\n               today that is not acceptable. It would never happen, nor should it. But what has happened\n               to our society that it has gone from what I just described to what we have now. That's\n               a hard one for me. The other thing that I am concerned with, and again, not with the basis of Bill 12,\n               I'm truly not. I have three adult children. I have grandchildren who are going to\n               be in school, not imminently, but they will be. Having seen what I've seen on the\n               security side of things since I've become an MLA over the last 15 months, without\n               question, schools must be protected. My comment.... I don't know that I would necessarily call it a concern. I will use it\n               as a comment. It could be interpreted that Bill 12, as opposed to being legislation\n               that's required, is a diagnosis. Hopefully I've done a reasonable illustration of\n               the diagnosis of what's happened to our society. My comment around the need for Bill 12 is, does the existing government lack confidence\n               in existing law or existing law enforcement? So again, back to the same premise that I said earlier, do we actually need this when\n               existing laws, existing facilities are there and perhaps are not being properly enforced? So I would then ask the question, is the problem legal insufficiency or enforcement\n               failure? Being an engineer, I'm very much a root-cause person, I'm very much a.... I love to\n               fix things Being an engineer, I'm very much a root-cause person. I love to fix things. I'm a\n               backyard mechanic. I'm a farmer. I love fixing things, but I really need to understand\n               what is wrong with something before I try to fix it. I don't want to be fixing something\n               ten times. I want to figure out the root cause. In this particular circumstance, is the root cause being addressed adequately with\n               Bill 12? Again, I'm not arguing the need for it, but I'm suggesting that perhaps with some\n               amendments.... I do understand how our system of governance works. Standing on this\n               side, I'm not going to have.... This side's not necessarily going to have the say\n               as to whether this bill passes or not. But what I would suggest is that as a responsible\n               critic, I think we can offer, and I hope to offer, improvements or opportunities for\n               improvement. Again, it's not my decision whether those will be accepted or not, but\n               that's the role that we play. With respect to the existing law that I've already referenced, we already do have\n               Criminal Code provisions with respect to intimidation, section 423. We do have laws\n               around mischief and obstruction offences, section 430. The Charter section 2(c) protects\n               peaceful assembly. We also have at our disposal, as does law enforcement, provincial\n               trespass and public order laws. I think that is very important, just because I agree with everyone else in this House.\n               I adore the democracy that we live in for the fact that we can disagree and we can\n               do it peacefully. I know that folks that are watching us on television and watch what we do in question\n               period on occasion might question whether in fact we are disagreeing in a civil manner,\n               but I think society as a whole, for the most part, is able to still do that. I think\n               that's a benchmark and a hallmark of a strong democracy, and that's something that\n               I don't think any of us want to see given up. The concern.... Well, again maybe not necessarily a concern, but I'll make it as a comment that Bill\n               12 could be interpreted as potentially interfering with the right of assembly in that\n               warrantless arrests and the ability to not go through the typical jurisprudence steps\n               could potentially degrade that. I would suggest that the vast majority, if not all\n               of us in this place of honour, would not want to see that happen, and I'm certain\n               that the public would not want to see it happen. The act already provides 20-metre access zones, which we've talked about. I just did\n               reference the arrest without warrants and the prohibition of interference and intimidation.\n               One of my colleagues from across the way did speak earlier about the litmus test on\n               whether these were required or not. I know those weren't the words used, but in my\n               mind, that's what cropped up. My question would be: have those powers actually been used under Bill 12? It's been\n               in place for a number of years. Has it actually been needed? Has it actually been\n               used? Again, in my mind, I am a fan of efficiency, and I'm a fan of.... In my previous life, I worked with legislation extensively. I will freely admit I\n               am not a lawyer. I am an engineer, but I had to learn how to.... And for those here\n               or those that are watching that have a law background, no offence intended, and please\n               don't take it that way, but I really was forced to learn lawyer-ese or to learn to\n               be able to read lawyer, if that makes sense. I'll move on. The deterrence theory around the need for Bill 12 is that.... In fact,\n               I think, to me, that would be the basis for the need for Bill 12 — that behaviour\n               responds to certainty, not necessarily severity. Again, the fact that we already have these pre-existing laws, if the enforcement is\n               inconsistent, I would suggest that the law, to a certain extent, does lose its effectiveness.\n               I think that's, again, part of the root-cause scenario that I'm describing Again, the fact that we already have these pre-existing laws.... If the enforcement\n               is inconsistent, I would suggest that the law, to a certain extent, does lose its\n               effectiveness. And I think that's, again, part of the root cause scenario that I'm\n               describing. We do need to look perhaps a little bit deeper down. Why do we need Bill\n               12? In addition to that, I would say that adding more law does not address weak enforcement.\n               And if it's not being enforced, why? Do we need to talk to the people charged with\n               enforcement or with the responsibility of enforcement? Is there something flawed?\n               Is there something missing with the existing legislation that would require the need\n               for Bill 12? With respect to a Charter analysis, I would clearly state that section 2(c) of the\n               Charter does protect peaceful assembly. I've already spoken to that. I don't believe\n               anyone in this room, nor that would be bored enough to be watching what I'm saying\n               at the moment.... I can't imagine that anyone would want to see that infringed upon\n               or in any way diminished. And that, again, would be part of my concern with Bill 12. Certainly, and I will repeat this ad infinitum.... Noting the hour, I reserve my right to continue and move adjournment of the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415793","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's nice to be here today. For those that might be watching on television, they may not recognize me as the MLA\n               that represents Tumbler Ridge. But that being said, Bill 12, Safe Access to Schools\n               Amendment Act, how on earth could I speak against that? On its premise, the legislation\n               is something that, again, for me is very difficult to speak against as","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dfdca4f8e2235ac5e503e52881e95b4a74aae88eb8a47e2bfe0686c1965c3b54"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d6b490f1f7b88d9b8aaab4ce05b19da135b192de2515f88a4b3a8ca2d9c46f57"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d39dca4a6abd6e5741e75de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415794,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I've got 17 minutes left. Does everyone want to listen to me for 17 minutes?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415794","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I've got 17 minutes left. Does everyone want to listen to me for 17 minutes?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0431bc220794b9cb884d8499981722b380b09ab400d82121caef9a71125ad7d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15454b8de6dcdf833153d790","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415795,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"While my colleague from across the way did beat me to the punch, I feel remiss in\n               not acknowledging the presence of the British Columbia Common Ground Alliance, and\n               well done. My 30-year career prior to taking on this honourable position has in fact\n               shown me how incredibly important it is on a day-to-day basis, saving lives, literally\n               of workers and saving lives of the public, to ensure that we call before we dig and\n               that we do follow all appropriate procedures. Please help me join the minister in welcoming these individuals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415795","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"While my colleague from across the way did beat me to the punch, I feel remiss in\n               not acknowledging the presence of the British Columbia Common Ground Alliance, and\n               well done. My 30-year career prior to taking on this honourable position has in fact\n               shown me how incredibly important it is on a day-to-day basis, saving lives, literally\n               of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Allied forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720887","label":"Allied forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9def7a7c0fe01e517dc36a37f6bfd2a2dac922c9d6d02c23be243d19e40ea500"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8838bc3d194bfc01a6bf0cad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720467,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know that I've introduced my beautiful bride of — I like to say — 360 years. Those\n               of us that have been married that long might appreciate that inside humour. The last time that we sat in this beautiful place of honour, I was alerted on my phone\n               to a tragic event where my beautiful bride did attend the emergency room twice over\n               a very short period of time. At the fear of encroaching upon some type of a copyright\n               issue, I would say to the effect that you don't know what you've got until it's gone.\n               So please help me welcome Tammy Neufeld.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720467","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I know that I've introduced my beautiful bride of — I like to say — 360 years. Those\n               of us that have been married that long might appreciate that inside humour. The last time that we sat in this beautiful place of honour, I was alerted on my phone\n               to a tragic event where my beautiful bride did attend the emergency room twice over\n               a very short period of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47952","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47952","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Copyright","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034673","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Copyright","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034673","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Copyright","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034673","label":"Copyright","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47952","label":"Intellectual property","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c6993599483911eeb8ebca1cbcdc7d47dec309ce55ef2e4759caadf46447a9f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["200c335cc2b1bd5207da196c67e7a8c78b6f00cdb4c5b18c85b9ce9b43318db8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3383ceb280c049dc03201d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720470,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"It gives me pride today to stand in this House of honour and speak of the beautiful\n               jewel of a community of Tumbler Ridge. This is a positive. They deserve it, they need\n               it, and here it comes. There is a wonderful organization in my constituency of Peace River South that is in fact headquartered in the beautiful town of Tumbler Ridge, and it is in\n               fact called the Tumbler Ridge Outdoor Recreation Association, TRORA. During my most recent time in the community last week, I had the opportunity to spend\n               a significant amount of time with residents, speaking with community leaders — this\n               time not about politics, not about tragedy, but something equally important. Connection,\n               community During my most recent time in the community last week, I had the opportunity to spend\n               a significant amount of time with residents, speaking with community leaders, this\n               time not about politics, not about tragedy but something equally important: connection,\n               community and positive momentum of the path forward. TRORA is a non-profit organization that plays a unique and essential role. It does not\n               replace local recreation groups. It unites and strengthens them. It brings together\n               snowmobilers, mountain bikers, Nordic skiers and ATV users under one coordinated vision\n               in order to provide sustainable outdoor recreation. It supports tourism, and it promotes\n               safe access to our back country. Most importantly, it fosters stewardship, ensuring\n               that our natural landscapes remain protected for future generations. Beyond infrastructure, TRORA is about people. It's about youth engagement, volunteerism\n               and building a sense of pride and belonging in this beautiful rural community. This\n               spring TRORA is launching a bike bus, bringing children together to ride safely to\n               school, promoting health, confidence and connection. That is one of the many things\n               that they are involved with this summer. I am proud to recognize the extraordinary work of the Tumbler Ridge Outdoor Recreation\n               Association and the positive impact that it is having, which is exactly what the Tumbler\n               Ridge area needs now more than ever.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720470","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It gives me pride today to stand in this House of honour and speak of the beautiful\n               jewel of a community of Tumbler Ridge. This is a positive. They deserve it, they need\n               it, and here it comes. There is a wonderful organization in my constituency of Peace River South that is in fact headquartered in the beautiful town of Tumbler Ridge, and it is in\n               fact ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gasoline","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43499","label":"Gasoline","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28d82ad254b38183800295a921323f2b19fd166d1225d404f55d96df78cc59a3","b63bb81d878cd68908c86616c473d37a7ce98462030f3426edf6d04c4b55462f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4901c40b1e9733750ea3738b583d6810921c8830a167eea5e26f4e11e60a4a76"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fdf37110681e3d42e74f0b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720472,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. With respect to the minister, I would like to raise a point of order that we are speaking\n               to Bill 14, and I'm not hearing that in the conversation to the point where I think\n               we should. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720472","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. With respect to the minister, I would like to raise a point of order that we are speaking\n               to Bill 14, and I'm not hearing that in the conversation to the point where I think\n               we should. Thank you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","label":"Electrical equipment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efe13ed720fa63314628cb15405f8a78bed293102d7f633c96c0d04592e7961d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27319857ca56e204a522516b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721585,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Sorry, it's not my birthday, but I'll do my best. Thank you for the opportunity to\n               address this place of honour today. This is a subject, yet again, that is quite close\n               to my heart. I will state unequivocally that British Columbia is one of the most resource-rich\n               jurisdictions in the world. We sit atop vast reserves of natural gas — over 2,900\n               trillion cubic feet in place. We have the minerals, we have the forests, we have the\n               water, and we have the skilled workforce. We should be a global leader, not just in extraction but in responsible development\n               and export. And yet this province has failed to capture the full economic value of\n               its natural resources. For over a decade, British Columbia has had a clear strategic advantage, and we continue\n               to. We have direct access to Asian markets, shorter shipping routes and an abundance\n               of low-cost natural gas. We were in the lead. Unfortunately, while B.C. delayed, others acted. We lost time. We lost investment.\n               We lost market share. And unfortunately, today global competitors dominate the LNG\n               exports. Canada is now only just entering the market. It's more than just lost economic\n               opportunity. It's lost jobs. Lost tax revenue. Lost royalties. Markets and the equity that drive them do not wait. Long-term contracts are signed\n               years in advance. Once markets are secured, they are gone for decades. We are forcing energy policy into ideology as opposed to a balance. Environmental stewardship matters. I am an environmental engineer. My children live\n               here; my grandchildren live here. No question. My concern is that that rigid policy creates uncertainty. Uncertainty drives investment\n               away. This is a conversation that I've had many times, but without question, natural\n               gas only has value when it is developed and sold. Left in the ground, it has zero\n               economic value. Global demand shifts elsewhere, often to jurisdictions that have higher emissions\n               and much lower environmental standards than we do. And unfortunately, B.C. loses economically\n               to a significant amount. The world ends up being worse off environmentally, potentially\n               based on where the energy is produced. Canada entered LNG late. We face higher costs and stronger competition. I know the minister and I have discussed this on many occasions. I think for the most\n               part we're on the same page, in many respects, but the window is narrowing, and our\n               natural resources are an opportunity. Opportunities have a window. Delay Opportunities have a window; delay closes that window. We can have both prosperity\n               and environmental responsibility, but we need certainty, we need timeliness, and we\n               need respect for investment. The greatest risk is failing to develop our resources\n               and standing at the sidelines, watching the opportunity flow elsewhere.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721585","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Sorry, it's not my birthday, but I'll do my best. Thank you for the opportunity to\n               address this place of honour today. This is a subject, yet again, that is quite close\n               to my heart. I will state unequivocally that British Columbia is one of the most resource-rich\n               jurisdictions in the world. We sit atop vast reserves of natural gas — over 2,900\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1190f33d4e979b376ab5332512291c8558d72c518a4824ba04c39dae5ca33960"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1acaa606103609d74cab08e00d517408b434e01536bb00d5a0ec7d8b6932bc68"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da5ae612dca7fb6890dc847e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721586,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm here today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. There are a few things I'd like to make comments with respect to this bill. One is\n               that there's the fear that we can lose sight of some of our principles in this place\n               of honour. I would suggest that freedom of information is one of them. This is not a bureaucratic inconvenience. It's not an administrative burden. It's\n               not something that should be considered to be managed or filtered. It truly is the\n               foundation of democratic accountability. It's what our democracy is based on. It's\n               the mechanism that allows citizens to ask their government: \"What are you doing in\n               my name?\" We sometimes.... Well, I wouldn't say we. Perhaps there's a fear by some in the public\n               that people in this place could sometimes forget why we're here and who we're representing.\n               I think not being completely transparent runs the risk of confusing those who are\n               concerned with what we're doing. If we're doing things that are in the best interest of the public, I don't understand\n               why we would be fearful for them to understand what we are doing. With that, my concern would be that as we begin to erode the right, even incrementally,\n               which some would argue.... I have been listening. I would say some have argued that\n               this is incremental. I would suggest that we clearly begin to erode the very foundation\n               of public trust. That's the concern here. I would also suggest that I've heard it being said that this bill, Bill 9, is being\n               presented as modernization. There are terms used such as \"efficiency,\" \"streamlining\"\n               and \"digital adaptation.\" But when we move past this language and examine the substance\n               of the bill, we do see something different, those of us that have read it. We will\n               see expanded discretion. We will see reduced access. We will see a shift in power.\n               That, to me, is one of the concerns that I think many should have when they critically\n               review Bill 9. Bill 9 expands the government's authority to refuse or disregard access requests.\n               The bill introduces broader definitions of what constitutes things such as frivolous,\n               vexatious or abusive. On the surface, to a reasonable person, that does sound reasonable. I can't think of the word for having said the same word twice. Who's an English major\n               that can help me out with that one? I've lost the whole crowd, so I'll just move on. On the surface, it may sound reasonable, the problem being that those terms are clearly\n               not objective. They are in fact subjective. Two people hearing the same word are not\n               necessarily going to interpret those words in the same manner. When you give government subjective authority, you give it power. I would suggest\n               that even different members would exercise that power differently. I would say Bill\n               9 forces us to ask, as I've already alluded to, who decides what is frivolous, who\n               decides what is abusive and who decides when a request is too burdensome. Are those decisions made at one o'clock on a Friday afternoon? Is that decision perhaps\n               the same decision that would have been made had the request been reviewed at eight\n               o'clock on a Monday morning? Under this bill, the answer is increasingly and obviously government and government\n               representatives, which would also include non-elected individuals who are not directly\n               circumspect to the will of the public or accountable to the public. This is not a minor change. It represents a fundamental shift in the balance of power\n               from the public to the state. And without going into too much detail, I think it's\n               clear what history has taught us with respect to shifting power, excessive power to\n               the state. This government argues that the system is overloaded, and perhaps it is. I'm not in\n               a position to suggest otherwise. What I would suggest is that we look at the root\n               cause as to why it's overloaded. The government says that there are too many requests and that digital records are\n               increasing. Again, I'm not in a position to dispute that. I would suggest that the\n               solution is not restriction. The solution is improvement, and we need to look at why\n               those pressures are increasing. Why are the public...? Why is there so much need for\n               that information to be shared, and why isn't it being shared openly and freely? If timelines are too long, perhaps we should be looking at fixing the timelines. If\n               the systems are outdated, it would be reasonable to anyone to suggest that modernizing\n               the systems would be in order. If resources are insufficient, I would suggest investing\n               in resources is in order. I would suggest the wrong answer is to reduce access. The moment we start limiting\n               access in the name of efficiency, many could argue that we are no longer strengthening\n               democracy, but in fact we are weakening it. History teaches us something very important. The information that matters most is\n               oftentimes the most difficult to obtain. It is often the most sensitive information,\n               the most controversial information and, in fact, the most politically inconvenient\n               information. Freedom of information is not used when everything is working perfectly. It is used\n               when people have questions, when they are questioning what we are doing in this House\n               — when journalists investigate, when citizens raise concerns and ultimately when the\n               decisions made by those of us that have the honour to stand here do in fact require\n               scrutiny. If we are doing things openly and in the best interests of the public, one\n               could easily question why we would be concerned about scrutiny. We have seen time and time again that some of the most important revelations in this\n               province have come through freedom-of-information requests. When we weaken that system,\n               we are not fixing inefficiency. We are limiting accountability. There's another concern in this legislation that popped out at me, and that's centralization.\n               Bill 9 expands structures that consolidate control over data and information systems.\n               It introduces expanded authority around shared services and digital infrastructure.\n               Once again, I would suggest that we must ask what happens when control is centralized.\n               Many would respond that oversight is reduced, transparency is weakened, and ultimately\n               checks and balances are diminished. Those are all terms that are not conducive to\n               a strong democracy, in my opinion. I would go on to suggest that a broader pattern exists here, not just with Bill 9\n               but across policy direction overall. What we have seen is more discretion in the hands\n               of government, less independence in oversight and a greater ability to manage information\n               flow, particularly when the information is inconvenient. I would never suggest that I'm not one for efficiency. I adore efficiency. When we\n               justify these types of changes under the name of efficiency, I think we run the risk\n               of losing the power of that word. Democracy is not always efficient, accountability\n               is not always efficient, and ultimately transparency is not always efficient. Perhaps\n               some would argue that it's not supposed to be. I would suggest that Bill 9 is not just about process, but ultimately it's about trust.\n               Can the public trust in what this House is doing? I would go further to suggest that\n               public trust.... Or state, rather. I wouldn't suggest. I would state that public trust\n               is built on openness. It is built on access. It is built on the ability of citizens\n               to see clearly what their government is doing. When access is granted and access is\n               free, trust grows. When access is restricted or prevented, trust erodes. Once trust\n               is lost, it is incredibly difficult to rebuild. The government, in Bill 9, is asking us to accept this trade-off. More efficiency\n               in exchange for less access. I would ask: is that a trade-off that this House and\n               the members of this House are willing to make? Once we expand the power to deny, that\n               power does not easily shrink. Future governments of any stripe inherit that authority. I certainly am not, nor are any on my side, opposed to modernization. We are not opposed\n               to improving systems. We are certainly, without question, not opposed to addressing challenges. I would\n               suggest that modernization must strengthen access. It must not weaken it. If the government\n               had truly wanted to improve the system, one could suggest that all If the government had truly wanted to improve the system, one could suggest that options\n               include increase staffing for FOI processing, reduce response timelines, expand proactive\n               disclosure and find a method to digitize records more efficiently. Those are real\n               solutions. This bill, Bill 9, does something different. It gives the government additional tools\n               to say no, not now, not this request. I would suggest that this is not modernization,\n               yet restriction. In my mind, that is why Bill 9 raises concerns and, in some cases,\n               serious concerns. At its core, this bill changes how information flows in the province of British Columbia.\n               It is not a small change. It is a fundamental change. I would ask the members of this\n               House: are we comfortable moving in this direction? I am not. Transparency is not\n               something we scale back. It is something that we expand. Accountability is not something\n               that we reduce, yet it is something that that we strengthen. Public trust is not something\n               that we gamble with. It is something that we are obligated to protect. In conclusion, Mr. Speaker, at the end of the day, this comes down to a simple principle.\n               Information does not belong to the government. It belongs to the people that we represent.\n               Any law that moves away from that principle should give this House, and it gives me,\n               pause.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721586","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm here today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. There are a few things I'd like to make comments with respect to this bill. One is\n               that there's the fear that we can lose sight of some of our principles in this place\n               of honour. I would suggest that freedom of information is one of them. This is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["27b75d1f35f1afacb4aa4dd5fea1cc692573cb7d27ede186f24bc6938dd10d57"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55ca16cf9839f00417cef91669dbb98202a5d8109a5a7e4c5cc678cf4225db0f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ecaf80d6ee8bc58c73c6c51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729366,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to request a five-minute recess, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729366","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to request a five-minute recess, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0872a8c8d9c5164fbc33c928b8b1679b8a0562b6f132b4244ddcdc808884adc4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f69ceab5b56ad12c1a1998d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752309,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"While it may be considered inappropriate to ask this question with respect to the\n               massive failure of the Mental Health Act with respect to the incredible tragedy of\n               Tumbler Ridge, unfortunately there are far too many other examples to choose from. The one that I will speak to is that of Aaron Sanio. Aaron was admitted to Lions Gate\n               Hospital in North Vancouver, struggling with mental illness and a history of suicide\n               attempts. His family called the hospital repeatedly, desperate to share what they knew, but\n               were not able to speak to anyone one directly involved in his care. His father said,\n               \"He was fully aware of how ill he was, and he shared that with me. He used to say:\n               'Dad, I would rather you know everything.'\" His family were not notified when he was released, and shortly after, Aaron took his\n               own life. Will the minister commit to making the changes to the Mental Health Act today to ensure\n               that no family ever has to go through this pain again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752309","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"While it may be considered inappropriate to ask this question with respect to the\n               massive failure of the Mental Health Act with respect to the incredible tragedy of\n               Tumbler Ridge, unfortunately there are far too many other examples to choose from. The one that I will speak to is that of Aaron Sanio. Aaron was admitted to Lions Gate\n               Hospital in North Van","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["98aea12c5aa539f6a1a765089724a9ebddefa8e6ee1f93af89d823fdd39a0a00"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b335660f131f0a1965e82788accdad890090128e529f9d30d59c835c58b278e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f585ac4d33ef3be0fd3a603c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752310,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I am an engineer. I think I can count. I'm wondering if\n               we have quorum, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752310","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I am an engineer. I think I can count. I'm wondering if\n               we have quorum, please.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4e2f92714e54d66c9b09cc30937ea72597c21fa0f14b5a90aa923a142ee770a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e23661ddfea4dfc60aa70e93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752311,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"Regrettably, I'm out of time as far as waiting for my companion to come and introduce\n               his class. So I'd like to seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752311","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Regrettably, I'm out of time as far as waiting for my companion to come and introduce\n               his class. So I'd like to seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c4b0a901114b6aaf55bd9cc13cfbf20e3bcd6d881e315d6acfd5e2b08fe5baa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8028c5c3ed96962e693fbffb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017501,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"If B.C. Hydro loses this case, all 119 independent power projects are at risk of higher\n               costs if the supplier has Aboriginal ownership, which will fuel already existing economic\n               uncertainty in the province. To the Premier: will you ensure that B.C. Hydro customers...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017501","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"If B.C. Hydro loses this case, all 119 independent power projects are at risk of higher\n               costs if the supplier has Aboriginal ownership, which will fuel already existing economic\n               uncertainty in the province. To the Premier: will you ensure that B.C. Hydro customers...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed22d73207f577cd6010e2570c66df51b42a3e04b6c83c1fabcaa6672f40d730"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b03444ccdd5f3a9b7efd1f4e9bb88761eb3cfaf6959feee0d301f2a387620159"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-947ffedcfdab897b3e323350","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017511,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm here today to speak about Bill 20, and I think I can make comments that most,\n               if not all — certainly, I would think most, the vast majority — in this House would\n               agree with. I would say that without question reconciliation matters, treaties matter,\n               and without question the recognition of Indigenous rights is not optional. That's\n               section 35 of the constitution. Many would suggest, and I'm not saying that I would\n               disagree with it, that it's the foundation of the future of the province and perhaps\n               even the country. From a very pragmatic perspective, though, I would also suggest that supporting reconciliation\n               does not, in any way, suspend scrutiny, nor should it. In fact, I would say that it\n               demands the opposite. It requires that we examine both carefully and honestly whether\n               the mechanisms we are putting forward will actually achieve what those mechanisms\n               promise and what the future needs. That's the responsibility that is before us today. Certainly, we're not trying to decide whether reconciliation is important. Again,\n               that's been established. What is important for us to determine, when we're discussing\n               Bill 20, is whether the bill moves us closer to reconciliation or if it drives a wedge\n               and creates conflict and moves us away from that goal. I would say that good intentions are not enough, certainly not in terms of legislation\n               of this magnitude. We're not dealing with a short-term policy. As my colleague prior\n               stated, this work has been underway for 30 years — so certainly, not short-term policy.\n               We are dealing with agreements that will shape governance, not only in the province\n               but may even affect beyond those borders. We're dealing with agreements that will\n               shape land use, will affect economic opportunity and potentially affect legal relationships\n               for generations. The question is not: do we support reconciliation? I've already stated that. The question\n               is: are we building that admirable goal on a foundation that will hold? I believe that it's important for Bill 20 to be understood as part of a wider transformation\n               tied to the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. I know that that\n               raised some concerns from across the way, but bear with me, and I will attempt to\n               explain as to why I believe that's important. The framework has, to date, introduced\n               shifts in how decisions are interpreted in this province. I don't know that's.... Maybe\n               leave it right there.... What have we observed? We have observed uncertainty. We have observed evolving interpretations.\n               We have observed a lack of consistency in how principles are applied across sectors What have we observed? We have observed uncertainty. We have observed evolving interpretations.\n               We have observed a lack of consistency in how principles are applied across sectors.\n               One might even suggest the government has even acknowledged this. I wouldn't even\n               say \"suggested.\" It has been said in this House. Now, rather than resolving those uncertainties within statute, Bill 20 proposes to\n               elevate similar concepts into constitutionally protected agreements. I think that\n               that's something that is exceedingly important for us to establish and discuss as\n               part of the debate process. It's a significant escalation. This is moving toward constitutionally\n               protected agreements, and that is something that is at a magnitude that I don't know\n               everyone that has spoken to this has illustrated to the most effective manner possible. I would suggest that we need to pause and reflect on the difference between ordinary\n               legislation and treaties, represented by Bill 20 in this case. They are not compatible. Correction. I will correct myself and withdraw that word. They are not comparable. If a statute produces unintended consequences, the Legislature can revisit it. Everyone\n               that's in this place of honour is very aware of the mechanisms, or most of the mechanisms,\n               that are available to do that. We can amend it. We can fix it. However, when a treaty\n               is ratified, it becomes part of the constitutional architecture of Canada. This means\n               that it is far more difficult to change, its interpretation is largely shaped through\n               courts, and its effects extend far beyond the control of any single government. So we must ask: are we embedding clarity, or are we embedding uncertainty at the highest\n               level of law? Bill 20 introduces a model that relies heavily on interpretation over time, thereby\n               illustrating the risk of open-ended design. Some would describe this as flexibility. Others\n               would describe it as adaptability. There is another way to describe it: indeterminacy. When key elements are not clearly defined at the outset, they do not disappear. They\n               simply shift into other arenas. They shift into courts, tribunals, arbitration processes\n               and prolonged negotiations. This is certainly not theoretical. That is exactly what\n               happens when agreements lack precision. Many here would agree that that is exactly\n               what we've seen for so many years. The question could be asked: what are treaties supposed to do? I would suggest if\n               you ask ten different people, you might get ten almost slightly, if not even significantly,\n               different answers. Historically, modern treaties in Canada have been designed to accomplish something\n               very specific. They are meant to settle questions, not extend them. They are meant\n               to define rights, they are meant to establish jurisdiction, and they are meant to\n               create certainty moving forward. We have seen several examples of this approach. I would go further to say that these examples are not entirely without challenge,\n               but they do provide a level of predictability. They allow governments to function.\n               They allow communities to plan and economies to operate. Some would suggest that Bill\n               20 moves in a different direction, from certainty to continuous interpretation. It could be interpreted that instead of resolving key questions at the outset, the model\n               represented by Bill 20 anticipates ongoing interpretation and potential ongoing change.\n               Instead of clearly delineating boundaries, it leaves space for those boundaries to\n               evolve. Another critical issue is the process. I would suggest that reconciliation is not\n               only about agreements between governments, it is also about relationships between\n               nations. We are hearing legitimate concerns as we're listening to different speakers.\n               We're hearing about overlapping claims. We're hearing about competing interests. And\n               we're hearing about insufficient engagement with neighbouring communities. Clearly,\n               to me, those concerns cannot and should not be brushed aside, because unresolved overlap\n               does not resolve itself following ratification. It only intensifies. When agreements proceed without alignment, the consequences are certainly predictable\n               — legal challenges, fractured relationships and delays in implementation. Many would\n               suggest that that is not reconciliation, that in fact it is conflict deferred. We also have a responsibility to consider the economic implications of this legislation,\n               Bill 20. In regions like northeast British Columbia, where I live, economic activity\n               is closely tied to natural resource development, infrastructure investment and long-term\n               regulatory certainty. Some of the statements that I've certainly made in this House,\n               and I intend to make many more, are that I don't think many people fully appreciate\n               the economic engine to the province of British Columbia represented by northeast British\n               Columbia. If we are not utilizing something like Bill 20 to ensure that certainty is provided,\n               then the concern lies as to whether that economic engine and, ultimately, the province\n               is successful financially. Projects in these sectors are capital intensive. That's where I spent the majority\n               of my career, if not all of it. And it's clear from my experience, and from everything\n               that I've been told through that experience, that these capital-intensive projects\n               require some very clear timelines to be fully successful. They require defined authorities,\n               and they require stable rules. The question is: does Bill 20 provide those three items? Should those elements become unclear, investment decisions are potentially subject\n               to change. That change, should it ever occur, is certainly not because investors are\n               opposed to reconciliation, but because uncertainty, without question, carries a cost.\n               As we have established in this place of honour, capital is mobile. Does Bill 20 provide\n               the certainty that is required by the investment market? We have seen situations where opportunities in energy and resource development have\n               moved elsewhere, even when British Columbia has had a competitive advantage. I've\n               seen that on a daily basis where I live. It is challenging. The certainty, which.... Again, I'm questioning whether Bill 20 provides that certainty\n               to the billions of dollars of investment that we require in the northeast. I'm concerned\n               from that perspective as to whether or not the certainty is there for the billions\n               of dollars to be invested. I would clearly say that reconciliation cannot succeed in a vacuum. It requires public\n               understanding. Does Bill 20 provide that public understanding? People in the public\n               need to know what is being agreed to, how decisions will be made and how accountability\n               will be maintained. Should that understanding be absent, support may become fragile. Does Bill 20 check\n               those two boxes and provide what is needed? In the absence of broad support, clearly,\n               progress becomes difficult to sustain. Transparency is not a procedural detail. It\n               is a requirement for long-term success. One of the most important questions in this debate is, which is questionable as to\n               whether Bill 20 identifies it clearly.... The question would be: where does decision-making\n               authority ultimately reside? And in that case, again, attracting significant capital\n               to this province that's needed to push forward on these incredibly important projects\n               — does Bill 20 advance that fundamental need? If authority becomes increasingly distributed across courts, arbitration bodies and\n               evolving interpretive frameworks, then the role of this Legislature may change. Does\n               that provide certainty? Does the bill before us provide that certainty? With a potential change comes a question of accountability. This House is accountable\n               to the people of British Columbia. Every one of us here at some point in the future,\n               should we choose to continue down this path, will be facing our electorate once more,\n               and we will be held accountable for the decisions that are made here. I would suggest that many, if not the vast majority of the populace, would say that\n               that principle must remain intact, that principle of accountability. I would go further\n               to suggest that any shift in governance must be clearly understood and very clearly\n               justified. In no way am I calling for an abandonment of progress. I'm making a call to strengthen\n               it. We can move forward, but we must do so carefully. One would suggest that the meaning\n               of moving forward carefully would be ensuring overlapping claims are addressed before\n               agreements are finalized, reinforcing clarity in treaty language and maintaining transparency\n               throughout the process. It means learning from agreements that have worked and avoiding\n               unnecessary departures from previously successful models. It also means prioritizing\n               durability over speed. The decisions we make here will not be judged next year. They will not be judged during\n               the next election cycle. They will be judged decades from now. These decisions will\n               be judged on whether they created clarity or confusion, stability or uncertainty,\n               trust or division. The question before us this afternoon is: does Bill 20 represent\n               those three points? Reconciliation does deserve Reconciliation does deserve to succeed. Success is not guaranteed. It must be built.\n               And it must be built on a foundation that is clear, stable and understood by all parties\n               involved. We remain committed to working constructively, to improving the framework and to ensuring\n               that reconciliation in British Columbia is not only advanced but sustained. This work\n               is too important to rush. Let us take the time to do it properly. And with that, thank\n               you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017511","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm here today to speak about Bill 20, and I think I can make comments that most,\n               if not all — certainly, I would think most, the vast majority — in this House would\n               agree with. I would say that without question reconciliation matters, treaties matter,\n               and without question the recognition of Indigenous rights is not optional. That's\n               secti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d3d016e9728b19a974f067abce6822a793ec4083d9c67ad572eb6a51b1c6f8c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3cec7712b779ae729309e0629f53270fe2e69419df1d0f912259eb0931e4355c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1e764fdb805c8b633555d944","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017512,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak of something that's quite dear to my heart, and that of course\n               is the community of Peace River South, or the riding of Peace River South, and, more importantly, the beautiful people that live in that region. This region\n               is not only a wonderful place to live, work and raise a family but also one of the\n               true economic engines of British Columbia, and I think that's quite often forgotten. Every single day, the hard-working people of Peace River South help drive the provincial\n               economy forward. Our region produces the energy that heats homes and powers industries.\n               Our farmers and ranchers help feed communities across Canada and beyond. Our forestry\n               sector supports jobs, manufacturing, while our tradespeople, truck drivers, contractors\n               and small businesses keep northern British Columbia moving. From natural gas and forestry to agriculture, mining, tourism and transportation,\n               Peace River South plays a critical role in generating the wealth and economic activity that supports\n               services and infrastructure throughout this province. Our riding is also home to critical infrastructure that connects northeast British\n               Columbia, including the Taylor Bridge, an important transportation link relied on\n               every day by residents, workers and industry, and of course, in addition, the very\n               well-known Site C dam and the lesser known, perhaps, Peace Canyon dam. As I've said,\n               the true strength of Peace River South is its people. Northern British Columbia has always stepped up for this province. The people of Peace River South ask for very little in relation to what we provide. When Peace River South succeeds, British Columbia succeeds. Our region is more than a point on a map. It\n               is a major contributor to the prosperity of this province and a reminder that the\n               hard-working people of rural and northern British Columbia remain essential to our\n               collective future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017512","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak of something that's quite dear to my heart, and that of course\n               is the community of Peace River South, or the riding of Peace River South, and, more importantly, the beautiful people that live in that region. This region\n               is not only a wonderful place to live, work and raise a family but also one of the\n               true economic engines of Briti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["31f0811d6327912d12ef1b1d2625af3782c9ae112e940499ac18d384069f8630"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f7d39d9490c5f8db3a841d5016704932dc1638db54f82326af0f58196bddd754"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5acfc784f25703f1cd0cf699","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036545,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Larry Neufeld","venue":"Hansard","text":"My colleague from across the way beat me to it, but I would like to reiterate a welcome\n               for the Canadian Propane Association — Chris Crawford, Courtney Seir-Todd, Clint Hillman,\n               Kellan Foreman, Katie Kachur and Nancy Borden. As we all know, propane is one of the cleanest burning fuels available, and with world\n               events, certainly, there is a massive uptick in demand for the product. I believe\n               that British Columbia should be proud to be able to provide that very valuable fuel\n               to the world. Please help me make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036545","member_id":"bc-mla-388","member_name":"Larry Neufeld","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My colleague from across the way beat me to it, but I would like to reiterate a welcome\n               for the Canadian Propane Association — Chris Crawford, Courtney Seir-Todd, Clint Hillman,\n               Kellan Foreman, Katie Kachur and Nancy Borden. As we all know, propane is one of the cleanest burning fuels available, and with world\n               events, certainly, there is a massive uptic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","label":"Propane"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036498","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Ocean energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036498","label":"Ocean energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","label":"Propane","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b68a4cc134e88f5e6cf7d9fb65535d6fe2a6c2fbcbb732ad26ff8889b00cc7e7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42d2b6fc6c69d7fe7e9e09dc5a5de0d9359ca161a2b38e799238b440da124c73"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fea5640810eb5318842ef92","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316804,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin my remarks on Budget 2026, I want to take a moment to acknowledge the\n               heartbreaking tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. Our thoughts are with the families, first\n               responders and the entire community as they navigate unimaginable loss. In moments\n               like this, British Columbians are reminded of what truly matters — the safety of our\n               neighbours, the strength of our communities and the responsibility we carry in the\n               Legislature to make decisions worthy of the people we serve. It is in that spirit that I rise to respond to Budget 2026. This budget asks British\n               Columbians to accept a projected $13-billion-plus deficit as business as usual; it\n               asks families to accept mounting debt as inevitable; and it asks small businesses,\n               already struggling under inflation, rising input costs and public safety challenges,\n               to accept new taxes on the very services they rely on to survive. The issue before us is not whether government should invest in British Columbians.\n               We all believe in investing in health care, in schools and in public safety. The question\n               is whether this government has demonstrated discipline, focus and a credible path\n               back to balance. On that question, this budget falls short. This is now one of the largest deficits in British Columbia's history outside of a\n               global emergency. Debt is climbing. Interest payments — money that does not build\n               a single hospital bed or hire a single police officer — are consuming billions of\n               dollars that could otherwise go to front-line services. That is not sustainable, it\n               is not compassionate, and it is not responsible. Beyond the macro numbers, there are specific choices in this budget that should deeply\n               concern every small business owner and every working family in this province. One\n               of the most significant is the expansion of the provincial sales tax, the PST, to\n               a broad range of services that have historically been exempt — accounting services,\n               legal services, consulting, engineering, architecture and, notably, private security\n               services. This is not a minor administrative tweak; this is a structural change to how British\n               Columbia taxes its economy. For decades, the PST in British Columbia has primarily\n               applied to goods, tangible items people purchase. Services, particularly professional\n               services, were largely exempt. This government has now decided to expand the tax base\n               and apply the 7 percent PST to a wide array of services, effective later this year. Let us be clear about what that means. It means that a small business that hires an\n               accountant to file its taxes will now pay more. A family that needs professional advice\n               when starting a small enterprise will now pay more. A developer hiring engineers and\n               architects to build housing will face higher costs, costs that will ultimately be\n               passed on to homebuyers and renters. Then there is the most egregious: the issue of private security. Across this province,\n               businesses are hiring private security, not because it is a luxury but because it\n               has become a necessity. Retailers facing repeated shoplifting, construction sites\n               targeted by theft, community events requiring crowd management, and apartment buildings\n               dealing with safety concerns — these businesses are not hiring security because they\n               want to. They are hiring security because they feel they have no choice, yet this\n               budget adds PST to those services. At a time when we acknowledge ongoing concerns about public safety, at a time when\n               small businesses are already paying out of pocket to protect their staff and customers,\n               this government has chosen to tax that very protection. Think about the message that\n               sends. Instead of meaningfully addressing the root causes of crime, instead of ensuring\n               adequate policing resources or delivering timely justice through our courts, this\n               government is making it more expensive for businesses to protect themselves. When you apply PST to professional services, those costs ripple outward through housing\n               projects, infrastructure builds, small businesses and, ultimately, to consumers. The\n               government may see a revenue line, but British Columbia This budget also speaks to a broader pattern — record spending without corresponding\n               reform. We continue to hear announcements, we see press releases, but we do not see\n               the structural changes necessary to improve health care access, to accelerate housing\n               approvals, to streamline permitting in the resource sector or to unleash private sector\n               growth. Instead, we see deficits projected not just for one year but for years to\n               come. Every dollar borrowed today is a dollar that must be repaid tomorrow with interest\n               by our children and grandchildren. We are told that this is necessary, that there\n               is no alternative. But there is always an alternative to unchecked spending and ever-expanding\n               taxation. We could prioritize core services over administrative growth. We could focus on outcomes\n               rather than announcements. We could create an environment where investment is welcomed\n               rather than penalized. And we could recognize that small businesses are not an endless\n               source of revenue. They are the backbone of our communities. In ridings across this province, including Penticton-Summerland, I hear the same message. Costs are rising faster than revenues. Insurance, rent,\n               utilities, wages, compliance burdens and now expanded PST on essential services. At\n               some point, something has to give. A responsible budget should provide confidence, confidence to investors, to entrepreneurs\n               and to families planning their futures. Instead, Budget 2026 creates uncertainty,\n               uncertainty about the sustainability of our finances, uncertainty about the long-term\n               tax burden and uncertainty about whether this government truly understands the pressures\n               facing ordinary British Columbians. British Columbians deserve a government that lives within its means, that protects\n               essential services without layering on new taxes and that understands economic growth\n               is not a talking point. It is a foundation upon which all social progress rests. This\n               budget does not meet that standard. For that reason, I cannot support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316804","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Before I begin my remarks on Budget 2026, I want to take a moment to acknowledge the\n               heartbreaking tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. Our thoughts are with the families, first\n               responders and the entire community as they navigate unimaginable loss. In moments\n               like this, British Columbians are reminded of what truly matters — the safety of our\n               neigh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d08ef2e0160072ead3cd59950216861af8fa46c937497416a870060261dc0f84"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9bec174493e864f6b17e442c519e4a8c15fc4313a981a5957a863f42b1bde438"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a3fcf278e4c419ed710bf965","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359639,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"On a point of order, I believe we're supposed to be debating the amendment. If I'm\n               not mistaken, the other member is talking about a debate that happened days ago, and\n               the other members are often debating the original motion, not the amendment. In the interest of getting through this this afternoon, my point of order is just\n               that if I'm not mistaken, we are supposed to only be debating the amendment at this\n               time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359639","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"On a point of order, I believe we're supposed to be debating the amendment. If I'm\n               not mistaken, the other member is talking about a debate that happened days ago, and\n               the other members are often debating the original motion, not the amendment. In the interest of getting through this this afternoon, my point of order is just\n               that if I'm not mistaken, we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1767bb65fb3e9b6e7ca3ecb48d7334cfa829cf7c8a3f47c791161bde844aba24"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab8d81100eddfe5c5fd6bd64","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720159,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"On September 5, 2021, the body of a young man was found badly beaten to death at a\n               high school in Penticton. His injuries were so severe it took two weeks to identify\n               him as 22-year-old Taig Savage. Taig was a wonderful and positive young man, and he\n               is especially missed by his mother, Tracey Savage. It took two years to bring charges against the four accused, and now, nearly five\n               years later and numerous delays, Taig's mother has been told that the trial is being\n               pushed off yet again for another entire year. At best, Taig's alleged killers won't\n               see trial until 2027. My question is to the Premier. Does the Premier think it is acceptable for a grieving\n               mother to have to wait almost six years to see justice for her murdered son?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720159","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On September 5, 2021, the body of a young man was found badly beaten to death at a\n               high school in Penticton. His injuries were so severe it took two weeks to identify\n               him as 22-year-old Taig Savage. Taig was a wonderful and positive young man, and he\n               is especially missed by his mother, Tracey Savage. It took two years to bring charges against the four a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["194c01a8d9e9c8551f38ed257d580f4b0554fcb17eb02e04aa60cef6abe9a72f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["58719ce5b481016ee68a5722bceaadeafd9f62469af061484fb4728cd8b51655"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90ce179899f9a991ffcb7121","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721227,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am very excited to welcome two of my friends and constituents here to the House\n               today, Paul Crawford and Julie Fowler, who are both big proponents of the arts. Paul Crawford was the director of the Penticton Art Gallery for over 20 years, and\n               Julie also runs Ignite the Arts and is the executive director of the B.C. Music Festival.\n               They are both here today to also celebrate Creative Industries Week, and I want to\n               thank them both for everything they do for the arts in our community. Would the House join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721227","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am very excited to welcome two of my friends and constituents here to the House\n               today, Paul Crawford and Julie Fowler, who are both big proponents of the arts. Paul Crawford was the director of the Penticton Art Gallery for over 20 years, and\n               Julie also runs Ignite the Arts and is the executive director of the B.C. Music Festival.\n               They are both here t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42057b72a3a137376d32c41ffa76c068e7cce896eff9b1c879e5c970333766ad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["110b65efdc40604bf00927e88aa4710ec3581fec07b71502ff04f5bb797c979e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ea448309fae288031dde264e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752176,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand on a point of order. I have one point of order with two points. I would reiterate what my friend the member across the aisle has said, which is that\n               the member, respectfully, continuously is debating the merits of the bill, which is\n               actually what I thought committee was for. In addition, there are some factual inaccuracies\n               in there, such as there is no cost associated with proactive disclosure. I fear that\n               in getting into the merits of the bill without being in committee, where these corrections\n               can take place, that's a problem. We're also not hearing a lot about why we need a delay of six months. My last point is just that, for my clarity, the parliamentary practice book says that\n               it's currently held that the adoption of a six-months hoist or the negativing of a\n               motion on second reading of a bill is fatal as no future day is appointed for consideration\n               of the bill at that stage, and the introduction of a new bill in substantially the\n               same terms is out of order. So just a clarification, with my point of order. If there is a hoist motion successfully,\n               is it actually a delay or is the bill over?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752176","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I stand on a point of order. I have one point of order with two points. I would reiterate what my friend the member across the aisle has said, which is that\n               the member, respectfully, continuously is debating the merits of the bill, which is\n               actually what I thought committee was for. In addition, there are some factual inaccuracies\n               in there, such as ther","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cac406dae6e021bb0e371eba5bc67877d6573d574378fe2c3dead37a9835b695"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a3cdac80af6a3d29d7e213f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752177,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I stand","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752177","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I stand","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ddb7fcd19811e9f02e978abcf4bd60683a60cccdf8dd22daaebf8fa4fa215c31"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc6bb15bb45d8623cb277b51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752178,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am very proud today to welcome two constituents of mine, Jacki McPherson and Haley\n               Regan, to the House, from the Penticton Indian Band and Okanagan Nation. Yesterday\n               I was proud to watch them both receive B.C. Achievement Community Awards at Government\n               House. Our whole community is very proud of their achievement. Will the House please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752178","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am very proud today to welcome two constituents of mine, Jacki McPherson and Haley\n               Regan, to the House, from the Penticton Indian Band and Okanagan Nation. Yesterday\n               I was proud to watch them both receive B.C. Achievement Community Awards at Government\n               House. Our whole community is very proud of their achievement. Will the House please join me in maki","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083647","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Foster care placement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Foster children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035387","label":"Foster children","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083647","label":"Foster care placement","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5b1c1e8aca46accb35bcdd6a7c1eb96b2df668d1055c9ea2f556e99efb0430b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8eb2ee9e0d95ab753e2db943","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036410,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last night we had an unprecedented fire in Penticton-Summerland that resulted in the loss of 200 long-term-care beds, the evacuation of hundreds\n               of people, and I'd like to rise just to, first and foremost, thank our brave first\n               responders from the Penticton fire department and also the district of Summerland\n               who sent over eight of their fire trucks as well. We've never seen a fire like this. The highway had to be shut down, and constituents\n               were calling me from the roofs of their homes with hoses as burning embers flew for\n               many city blocks. I would also like to acknowledge the city of Penticton and local businesses and restaurants\n               who opened up their doors without a moment's hesitation to take in displaced people\n               in the middle of the night and my constituency office staff who got out of bed without\n               being asked to go and man emergency phones. While we are grateful that no one was seriously hurt or killed, we are devastated\n               at the loss of residential property, the long-term-care beds and the Kampe property.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036410","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Last night we had an unprecedented fire in Penticton-Summerland that resulted in the loss of 200 long-term-care beds, the evacuation of hundreds\n               of people, and I'd like to rise just to, first and foremost, thank our brave first\n               responders from the Penticton fire department and also the district of Summerland\n               who sent over eight of their fire trucks as w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Municipal buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","label":"Municipal buildings","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ecd70febd893dcc999eaa04ea5340235c521ff003ccc7ff492232f8ef5cb4be7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e19af9ff634bc4bb6af55c1eb8be4b556e52f5ffc83fa09533a02fdea2e75b37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90d97fe243d97e924e3634c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036411,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amelia Boultbee","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to reserve my right to raise a point of privilege.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036411","member_id":"bc-mla-389","member_name":"Amelia Boultbee","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to reserve my right to raise a point of privilege.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f9c8dc920bde8058eca0ff0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729327,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Randene Neill","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my pleasure to introduce four guests about whom we spoke during QP in the House\n               yesterday. They are all from the watershed security fund, and they are integral partners\n               with creating this $100 million fund with the province in 2023. A big round of applause to Mark Gifford, from the Real Estate Foundation of B.C.;\n               Leanne Sexsmith, from the Real Estate Foundation of B.C.; the wonderful, amazing Lydia Hwitsum, from the First Nations water caucus; and Janet Duncan, from the First Nations Fisheries\n               Council. Welcome to the House. Harwinder Sandhu: I am beyond thrilled and excited today to welcome one of the greatest schools in\n               Vernon-Lumby, Vernon Christian School students. They are here in the gallery, and they are joined\n               by their awesome teacher Amanda Gaythorpe, as well as Andy Overend, and, of course, chaperones. They play an important role — Courtenay, Rudy, Renee,\n               Louise. Many members of this House will agree with me that for many communities, it's not\n               just a ferry ride to come to Victoria. It takes lots of planning, effort, resources,\n               money to come to this gallery. I just want to say would the House please make them\n               feel very welcome, where they're learning about democracy. As well, they will be meeting with many of us. I think all of you have received an\n               email, so if you can please answer their brilliant questions, that would be fantastic.\n               I have had the opportunity to engage with them over the years, and they are exceptional\n               students. The school does such a good job with them. So would the members please join me to make my guests feel very welcome. Welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729327","member_id":"bc-mla-390","member_name":"Randene Neill","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is my pleasure to introduce four guests about whom we spoke during QP in the House\n               yesterday. They are all from the watershed security fund, and they are integral partners\n               with creating this $100 million fund with the province in 2023. A big round of applause to Mark Gifford, from the Real Estate Foundation of B.C.;\n               Leanne Sexsmith, from the Real Est","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55f76d398fb3b5030bad777b97efb636351b4ed1fd2ef3823e2c81680cb58d30"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e230ba02769d1623b76abc4e561351ae1ab59f7bfdd60159479e1b75b47e4f60"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-add1c076bca61b18fd02148f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317137,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"My boys experienced their first big hockey heartbreak yesterday morning, and I told\n               them that they'd better get used to it, because we're Canucks fans. But I really want to give a huge congratulations to the men's hockey team coach, Jon\n               Cooper, from Prince George, who led the team to such a strong performance, and congratulate\n               all of the British Columbians who coached, who competed in this year's Olympics, and\n               give them a big round of applause from the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317137","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"My boys experienced their first big hockey heartbreak yesterday morning, and I told\n               them that they'd better get used to it, because we're Canucks fans. But I really want to give a huge congratulations to the men's hockey team coach, Jon\n               Cooper, from Prince George, who led the team to such a strong performance, and congratulate\n               all of the British Columbi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1c4416aeb385088504671d22562ed4e27ef7b11404bca146e89c7d0a237b62c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a62adb61107d21b33be6f0c028e8ba3a7f30589794aff799d3dc6262bff33aaa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3bed061d887717817b20b03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317138,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"T here is more that we heard from the president of the BCGEU on public service jobs.\n               He also said: \"It's more important than ever to ensure these highly sought-after positions\n               are in fact being awarded on merit.\" I couldn't agree more. But whether it's board appointments or special advisors, this NDP party relies on\n               a very small group of Labour leaders, former NDP cabinet ministers, and friends of\n               the Premier. Laird Cronk has just been appointed chair of WorkSafeBC's board of directors\n               for a three-year term by the Minister of Labour. Mr. Cronk, as I'm sure the Finance Minister is aware, was a former president of the\n               B.C. Federation of Labour. How many more friends and insiders does the Premier plan\n               on hiring? Laird Cronk has just been appointed Chair of WorkSafeBC's board of directors for a\n               three-year term by the Minister of Labour. Mr. Cronk, as I'm sure the Finance Minister\n               is aware, was a former president of the B.C. Federation of Labour. How many more friends\n               and insiders does the Premier plan on hiring in the entire civil service now that\n               he can fire and hire at will without a Merit Commissioner?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317138","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"T here is more that we heard from the president of the BCGEU on public service jobs.\n               He also said: \"It's more important than ever to ensure these highly sought-after positions\n               are in fact being awarded on merit.\" I couldn't agree more. But whether it's board appointments or special advisors, this NDP party relies on\n               a very small group of Labour leaders,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47857","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Employment equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47857","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47857","label":"Employment equity","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["339a7055edfee6d1f47df66b870d44cf42cc136effc1aaee8dc67d5e746f630c","8b4f6a956c4d5ed5b2977938f6ac22450fe909bb188433c6f2f84f89a13f3456"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0c6f7c41dfa9e01927abbc41b263c6adee5e6accb831d3c9c619009c4a82294f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d0a910416698ddf24d1e9194","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317139,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I reserve my right on a matter of privilege.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317139","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I reserve my right on a matter of privilege.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d83e643241dd5a8021304d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317140,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is always an honour, of course, to rise on behalf of the people of Prince George–Mackenzie. Today I'll be responding to Bill 5, the Trade Recognition Act and, of course, speaking\n               for my constituents but also today in my capacity as the opposition critic for Labour.\n               I know there are a number of Labour components about this bill. But I want to start with a principle that I think every member of this House should\n               actually be united on, and that's that Canada should function as one economic country But I want to start with a principle that I think every member of this House should\n               actually be united on, and that's that Canada should function as one economic country,\n               not ten separate ones divided by unnecessary internal barriers. Too often we make\n               it harder to trade across Canada and actually easier to trade with our neighbours\n               down south. That's what this bill, I think, the topic overall of interprovincial trade\n               that we've been talking about for well over a year now, has been all about. We set up barriers just even here in our own province that hold back job creators.\n               I'll use an example. Our building code makes it almost impossible for a company like\n               East Fraser Fiber in Mackenzie to sell their value-added finger-joint products within\n               B.C., let alone across other provinces. So as a result, they sell their made-in-B.C.\n               product down south to the U.S. About 98 percent of their product goes down to the\n               U.S. Can you imagine if we put in the work to align our rules to support B.C.'s forest\n               products here at home and then also imagine if we put in that same time and effort\n               to make sure that those same products could be sold across Canada? We can do so much\n               better in our economic resiliency if we get out of our own way, and I think the example\n               of East Fraser Fiber would be one that would be well served. Of course, there's a lot of talk about that orange guy down south with terrible hair,\n               and he's going to be doing his thing. I am firmly against his tariffs. I'm against\n               his attack on institutions. But let's not worry about him. Let's actually look after\n               our fellow Canadians and work together for a change across this country. We had this\n               conversation a year ago already in this House, and we're still at it today. Workers should be able to go where the jobs are. Businesses should be able to sell\n               Canadian products to Canadian customers, and families should benefit from a strong\n               national economy built on cooperation from coast to coast to coast. Canadians should\n               be able to work with Canadians and sell to Canadians without hitting a wall at each\n               provincial border — full stop. That's where we need to get to in this country, and\n               interprovincial trade barriers are still a major factor and a major problem in our\n               economy. Reducing interprovincial trade barriers is not just sound economic policy. It strengthens\n               our resilience in these uncertain economic times. It strengthens our unity as a country,\n               and it strengthens our independence in a world where global economic conditions are\n               increasingly unpredictable. At a time when supply chains can be disrupted by events\n               beyond our control and trade tensions can emerge overnight, Canada's greatest economic\n               strength should be Canada itself. I have to say we've heard this movie on interprovincial trade barriers already before.\n               We had these conversations last year. The government told us that they didn't need\n               stand-alone interprovincial trade legislation. They told us that Bill 7 was what was\n               needed. I'll remind the House, of course, that the original iteration of Bill 7 had a Henry\n               VIII clause. The Premier wanted, at the time, the power of a king. But Conservatives\n               and everyday British Columbians pushed back, and the clause was removed. We went on to debate the rest of Bill 7, including the interprovincial trade components\n               in part 1 of that bill. Well, unfortunately, this government has squandered economic\n               opportunity. They've squandered time for businesses to pivot. We now have to wait\n               for this bill. Now we have to wait for regulations for businesses to actually get\n               clarity. And all the while this government just hit British Columbians with PST increases.\n               They hit small businesses with PST increases to accounting and professional services,\n               and this is making B.C. less competitive instead of more. It's more important than ever that we get interprovincial trade right because these\n               businesses need this right now. The global economy has entered into a period of profound\n               uncertainty. I understand that. I'm willing to look at this bill for its merits because\n               I want our province to recognize this and actually change how we look at our national\n               economic resilience. Countries around the world are adopting protectionist policies, and the tariffs that\n               contributed to the Great Depression in the 1930s, of course, are back, despite the\n               recent U.S. Congress's efforts to overturn them. Strategic competition between major\n               powers is reshaping trade relationships. Supply chains that once seemed stable now\n               look very fragile. I'll use again that example of East Fraser Fiber in Mackenzie. They rely on a supply\n               chain with the U.S. If we had a path for interprovincial trade barriers and our own\n               economic resilience for made-in-B.C., made-in-Canada solutions, then they would be\n               much better off. In this environment that we're in right now, Canada can't afford this past approach In this environment that we're in right now, Canada can't afford this past approach\n               that the government has taken on, and that includes opposing nation-building projects\n               like interprovincial pipelines. The government, unfortunately, has been a barrier\n               to Team Canada on that subject. In interprovincial trade, I want to see the government\n               doing more to support Team Canada overall. Given that we've been in this discussion for over a year now, and I said the same\n               thing last year, Canada can't afford to weaken itself with internal barriers that\n               make it harder to trade with our own country than it is with foreign partners. The\n               easiest trade barriers for Canada to remove are the ones that we put up against ourselves. Again, during debate on last year's legislation as part of Bill 7, I talked quite\n               a bit about interprovincial trade barriers because I thought that was the only important\n               factor within that legislation. I referenced a report from the C.D. Howe Institute\n               titled Eyes on the Prize, a game plan to speed up removal of internal trade barriers\n               within Canada. That report estimated that eliminating internal trade barriers could increase Canada's\n               GDP by up to $200 billion annually, simply by allowing Canadians to trade more freely\n               with one another. That's $200 billion, not from new taxes, not from new resource discoveries,\n               not from foreign markets, but from unlocking the potential of our own national economy. The report also highlighted how internal barriers contribute to some of the most pressing\n               challenges Canadians face. Housing shortages, labour shortages, productivity gaps\n               and supply chain inefficiencies. These are real potential benefits that can affect\n               affordability, job opportunities and economic security for families across the country.\n               Families in British Columbia, in an uncertain time that we are in right now, need\n               more economic security. For the people I represent in Prince George–Mackenzie and for communities across northern B.C., in particular, interprovincial trade barriers\n               and trade in general is an important topic. It's a region that is export-dependent,\n               global exports. But it could be an area where our region can open up with more trade\n               immediately to the east of us with our neighbouring provinces. Our resources are the foundation of our economy in the North. Our region produces\n               lumber that builds homes across Canada, energy that powers industries, agricultural\n               products that feed families, and equipment and services that support major projects\n               nationwide. We produce for the country, not just for local consumption. When barriers exist those goods become less competitive, and that's when projects\n               stall, investment flows elsewhere and jobs disappear, as we've seen in the forest\n               sector. Small- and medium-sized businesses feel these impacts most acutely. A contractor in Prince George does not have a compliance department to navigate ten\n               different regulatory regimes across the country, just like a trucking company can't\n               afford delays caused by inconsistent rules between provinces. A manufacturer cannot\n               redesign products to meet slightly different standards in each provincial jurisdiction. Red tape doesn't just slow down paperwork. It slows down paycheques for families in\n               communities like Prince George and Mackenzie. With the downturn in our forest sector,\n               people and businesses are really struggling. Much of this problem is stemming from\n               a lack of access to fibre and unsustainable policy from our own government. So for rural and northern communities, smoother interprovincial trade is important\n               for economic survival and long-term prosperity. I had a contractor in my office in January who was seriously considering moving his\n               business to Grande Prairie because they already worked in both provinces, worked in\n               B.C. and Alberta. He talked about the ease of doing business in that province compared\n               to B.C., with lower taxes and with less red tape. I told him simply that I didn't\n               want that to happen. I didn't want him to pack up and move. I wanted him to trust\n               in staying with B.C. B.C. should be a more competitive jurisdiction and he should\n               be able to work across these artificial borders freely while raising his family in\n               Prince George. We have to do better for people like this. Canadians encounter internal trade barriers in many aspects of their daily life. Perhaps\n               the most widely recognized example involves alcohol. Beer, wine and spirits is a common\n               example that the media cites every time this topic does come up. Canadians encounter internal trade barriers in many aspects of their daily life. Perhaps,\n               the most widely recognized example involves alcohol, beer, wine and spirits. It's\n               a common example that the media cites every time this topic does come up. Canadians\n               are often surprised to learn that it can be easier to import wine from Europe than\n               to ship wine directly from Ontario to B.C. and vice versa. Craft breweries, wineries and distilleries face complex provincial distribution systems\n               that limit their ability to sell in Canada. Obviously, this is the type of example\n               that I think people will be wondering about in the course of discussions of this bill.\n               These restrictions hurt small producers. They limit consumer choice and prevent Canadian\n               businesses from reaching their full potential within their own country. One of those producers is in my riding. Pacific Western Brewing has been employing\n               people in Prince George and brewing their great beer for 69 years now. But it's challenging\n               for them. So I ask: will this bill make it easier for PWB to send their products across\n               Canada? That's something that I hope the government has some clear answers for. I\n               would like the government to just provide businesses like PWB with certainty. One of their biggest issues is the requirement to send many of their products to the\n               liquor distribution branch warehouses in Kamloops or the Fraser Valley before the\n               product can be sold even within B.C. I'd like to break down the barriers that make\n               that liquor distribution system such a barrier to trade both within B.C. and across\n               Canada. Transportation is another example. Trucking companies operating across provincial\n               lines have to comply with different rules regarding vehicle weights, dimensions, permits\n               and safety standards. These inconsistencies increase costs. They cause delays and\n               ultimately raise prices for consumers. Construction is another sector greatly affected. Differences in building codes.... I\n               talked about that one already in the case of those finger joint products from East\n               Fraser Fiber. Material standards are different across provinces. These can complicate\n               projects that span provinces. They can increase costs for housing and infrastructure\n               at a time when affordability is already a major concern. Individually, these differences\n               seem technical, but collectively, I think, they represent significant barriers to\n               economic growth. As Labour critic, one of my focus areas with this legislation that I'll be continuing\n               to dive into, hopefully, when we get to committee stage as well is really about what\n               this legislation means for workers. A unified Canadian economy requires the movement\n               of people and not just goods. Across Canada, we face labour shortages in some regions and unemployment in others.\n               Skilled trades are urgently needed for infrastructure, housing, energy development\n               and resource projects, yet workers face barriers to employment because credentials\n               recognized in one province are not automatically recognized in another. A welder does not become less skilled at a provincial border. A nurse does not lose\n               their training when they move west. A heavy equipment operator doesn't forget how\n               to run machinery because paperwork differs in different provinces. A skilled worker\n               doesn't become unskilled just because they cross a provincial border. That's a fact\n               that we need to recognize and we need to try to harmonize across Canada. Bill 5 doesn't override occupational licensing systems. Those matters fall under the\n               Labour Mobility Act. I think that is an important point just to reference here. Worker\n               safety, training standards, apprenticeship systems and professional regulations exist\n               for very, very good reasons, but I do wonder if this bill could do more to align with\n               labour mobility. It's a topic we shouldn't forget about when we're talking about trade\n               and the world of work across Canada. Another issue directly connected to my critic portfolio is occupational health and\n               safety. Workplace safety rules are essential, and we should always be striving for\n               improvement each and every day. Every worker deserves to go home safe at the end of\n               every single day, and that's something that we can certainly all agree on. However, inconsistent safety regulations across provinces can create unnecessary complexity\n               for companies and workers operating interprovincially. That can actually hurt safety\n               as well when employers and workers struggle to navigate the different rules across\n               Canada. A construction company working in multiple provinces may need to comply with different\n               training requirements, reporting procedures, equipment standards or certification\n               processes depending on where the work occurs. These differences do not necessarily These differences do not necessarily improve safety, and often they create duplication,\n               confusion and administrative burden. Safety rules should work to protect workers,\n               not trap them in paperwork. Welcome to the chair, Mr. Speaker. Greater harmonization of occupational health and safety frameworks across Canada could\n               maintain high standards while reducing unnecessary differences that impede mobility\n               and project delivery. I hope that is an area that we can explore more in committee\n               stage as well with this bill. Harmonization must not become a race to the bottom at the same time when we talk about\n               these standards as well. Mobility, I think, should raise opportunity, not lower standards.\n               So worker protections have to remain strong, and safety requirements must remain robust.\n               Fair wages should also not be undermined through what we're looking at here. What we're looking at in terms of what this means for British Columbia's workers is\n               we're talking about reciprocity. If British Columbia recognizes goods and services\n               from other provinces, we must ensure that B.C. workers and businesses receive equal\n               treatment elsewhere. Free trade within Canada has to work both ways, and B.C. workers\n               deserve the same opportunities across the country that others will have here. I recall in Bill 7 debate last year the work that the Attorney General referenced\n               in meeting with other provinces. I'd like to believe that some of those discussions\n               can actually be enacted into action. In the course of their answers, I haven't heard\n               it clearly yet, I hope the government can speak a bit more in detail about that and\n               their responses to this bill, how this work has been happening across Canada with\n               other provinces right now and if we can actually do this in a meaningful and speedy\n               way. The bill also references Indigenous peoples and exempts matters relating to Indigenous\n               peoples from automatic recognition provisions. Economic development, of course, I\n               firmly believe, should include Indigenous communities, and implementation must respect\n               rights while creating opportunity for shared prosperity. But I think it's fair to\n               ask how this affects our trade across provinces. We want to make sure that Indigenous\n               communities and non-Indigenous communities alike can benefit from trade and not be\n               left behind, and we want to ensure that the public understands the need for this particular\n               reference. I think the government will have to talk about this a little bit more in\n               their during committee or perhaps in the second reading responses. Other provinces have moved ahead. While British Columbia has been debating this issue\n               over the past year, other provinces have taken concrete action. Nova Scotia introduced\n               landmark legislation this time last year designed to remove interprovincial trade\n               barriers through mutual recognition. Ontario has taken steps to improve labour mobility\n               and streamline regulatory differences, and Manitoba has also moved forward with initiatives\n               to facilitate trade and mobility with other provinces. These jurisdictions recognize that strengthening internal trade is one of the most\n               practical ways to support economic growth and resilience. So I think that other provinces,\n               from what I've seen are opening doors, but B.C. has been left behind, I think. We're\n               behind the times. We need to actually speed up what we're doing here. We shouldn't\n               be at a disadvantage compared to workers and businesses in provinces that have been\n               moving more decisively because we looked at tariff legislation that didn't tackle\n               this properly the first time. This bill, of course, replaces provisions from Bill 7, the Economic Stabilization\n               Act, that were supposed to address trade barriers through regulation. So no meaningful\n               action has been taken under those powers. We haven't seen the regulations form, and\n               we didn't just lose time in that we lost opportunity. We should be leading, not playing\n               catch-up. I'm glad to be talking about interprovincial trade in the context of this bill, but\n               we have to do this better. We have to be better as a province. This was an issue that\n               didn't suddenly emerge last year, interprovincial trade. We firmly said it should\n               have had stand-alone legislation, and members of the opposition introduced stand-alone\n               legislation last year specifically aimed at reducing interprovincial trade barriers. The member for Nechako Lakes introduced Bill M203, Free Trade and Mobility Within Canada Act. That proposal, of\n               course, was not advanced by the government. They could have called that bill The member for Nechako Lakes introduced Bill M203, Free Trade and Mobility within Canada Act. That proposal, of\n               course, was not advanced by the government. They could have called that bill. It was\n               modelled after the other provinces that we are actually trying to trade with here. Instead, we had a charade around Bill 7 that unfortunately wasted precious time that\n               businesses need, that British Columbians needed to actually get ahead. If action had\n               been taken earlier, British Columbia could be leading nationally on internal trade\n               reform. We could be.... At this point, we are catching up, and it's unfortunate. Bill 5 establishes a framework based on mutual recognition. We are going back to what\n               was in the member for Nechako Lakes' bill, A lot of this is standalone legislation\n               pulled out of Bill 7, but it does have exclusions and regulatory-making powers, and\n               that is important. The legislation alone does not remove the barriers; the implementation of it actually\n               does. Success of this bill will actually depend on how these regulations are developed,\n               how quickly they're enacted and whether they address real obstacles faced by workers\n               and businesses. The problem is we're now going to have to wait an unforeseen amount of time for those\n               regulations. That's why it's more important that we find out what the government intends\n               to do with regulations. We can't afford to have this delay. Our businesses are already falling behind, with PST now being applied to professional\n               services. Brigitte Anderson from the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade said this could\n               be the final straw for many businesses. Let's not keep letting them down. Let's hear\n               what these regulations actually are now so that businesses can have that certainty. I would have liked to see the government's full plan aligned with other provinces\n               rather than wait longer for these regulations to happen. I think it's incumbent upon\n               the government to explain more about that, and I'd like to see that very soon here. We also don't want to see that those regulations create unnecessary carve-outs or\n               exemptions. and that's something that we're only going to find out, by the looks of\n               this bill and how it's written, from the regulations. It could really water down this\n               bill. So what do those regulations mean for businesses like Pacific Western Brewing that\n               I've already mentioned? These are legitimate questions, and I think they would help\n               with overall enthusiasm for support for this bill. Now, of course, we are debating the principle of the bill, and we will get into whether\n               it will actually work in committee. As Labour critic, I am going to be looking closely\n               in that committee stage on that reciprocity. I am going to ask about worker protections,\n               labour market impacts, safety standards, Indigenous engagement and measurable outcomes. That is what, unfortunately, we haven't seen enough of from this government — outcomes.\n               We want results for British Columbians and not see them suffering and really moving\n               behind economically. Canadians believe in this country, its workers, its resources,\n               its innovation and its future, but we must remove the barriers we have placed in our\n               own path. When Canadians trade with other Canadians, I think everyone benefits. Canada is one\n               country. Our workers built it, power it, harvest its resources and keep communities\n               running from coast to coast. They should not be held back by unnecessary barriers\n               between provinces. If we trust Canadians to build this country, we should also trust\n               them to work anywhere in it. Workers and businesses cannot afford another year of\n               inaction that we've unfortunately seen. I look forward to examining this legislation in detail at committee stage and working\n               to ensure it delivers meaningful results for British Columbians and for Canadians\n               as a whole.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317140","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is always an honour, of course, to rise on behalf of the people of Prince George–Mackenzie. Today I'll be responding to Bill 5, the Trade Recognition Act and, of course, speaking\n               for my constituents but also today in my capacity as the opposition critic for Labour.\n               I know there are a number of Labour components about this bill. But I want to start with a principle ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f9644ec9a04f5297e85a479baa1aceef6c584d21d019c38ae8116c126492a532"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6b3beab67aaa7a13a424d4b2fab97bccb26709a1467e32632f88e487ccaefdf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-845483a89aaecb637acf1273","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327972,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Seniors deserve a choice when it comes to their health care and to live with dignity.\n               This government isn't giving them that choice as ALC patients wait. This budget is an all-out attack on seniors, with both tax increases and health care\n               cuts impacting them. Nearly 1,200 long-term-care beds are being cancelled. Can the minister please confirm how many long-term care beds in this budget would\n               have cost the $1.8 million price tag referenced by the Finance Minister?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327972","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Seniors deserve a choice when it comes to their health care and to live with dignity.\n               This government isn't giving them that choice as ALC patients wait. This budget is an all-out attack on seniors, with both tax increases and health care\n               cuts impacting them. Nearly 1,200 long-term-care beds are being cancelled. Can the minister please confirm how many long-term care ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["211cc4a07534eeec1a3c9fdca4c61fa5201d98b7ed098bddc8e78720f642f41f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["89701511ca0c97a997ad90a5f3cf77fee38bc6d129da9efd18f6366325da6324"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5efab7aab7ffc1b4131147b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327973,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to acknowledge the incredible courage and service of IAFF Local 1372\n               firefighters in Prince George and the many people who support them each and every\n               day. Every time that bell rings, a team walks into danger so that our families, our\n               neighbours and our communities can be safe. In 2025 alone, the Prince George area experienced 253 fires, including structural\n               fires and other serious incidents that tested our first responder capacity. Among\n               them were high-profile emergencies such as the Crossroads Brewing fire and Nechako\n               Bottle Depot, as well as many more incidents at homes and businesses where people\n               and properties needed to be protected. One particular challenging call came at the Boardwalk apartment buildings, where 24\n               of the 57 units suffered fire, smoke and water damage One particular challenging call came at the Boardwalk apartment buildings, where 24\n               of the 57 units suffered fire, smoke and water damage. At 5:40 a.m., 19 firefighters\n               from four halls responded with skill and urgency, evacuating dozens of residents to\n               safety before the full force of the blaze could take hold. Behind every successful response are not only these firefighters but also our dispatchers,\n               who stay calm under pressure, coordinate resources and get help moving when every\n               second counts. Their contribution, too, deserves our heartfelt thanks. Service like this shows what it means to look after one another, and our community\n               has noticed and appreciated it. On a lighter but still celebratory note, I note that I also want to congratulate the\n               Prince George firefighters on their recent Sirens Cup victory, where they brought\n               home the trophy in the annual charity hockey game against the Prince George RCMP,\n               helping to raise more than $16,500 for local causes, including Cops for Cancer and\n               the Prince George Firefighters Charitable Society. We are grateful for all of our first responders. To all the firefighters here today\n               and serving across the province, to all the dispatchers and support teams, our communities\n               thank you for your bravery, your professionalism and your service.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327973","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I want to acknowledge the incredible courage and service of IAFF Local 1372\n               firefighters in Prince George and the many people who support them each and every\n               day. Every time that bell rings, a team walks into danger so that our families, our\n               neighbours and our communities can be safe. In 2025 alone, the Prince George area experienced 253 fires, in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dcb90bce8450d3f63dc8d1b68aed620e0a4cb2078c4802016acef8c5784c8b36"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85cc143bfa1806b34f2b1937b53b7f858bde999fef90c53c201308bb4a263c56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-787a67e182f3d24810214ec4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327974,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know that the Minister of Forests introduced the United Steelworkers yesterday,\n               but there have been meetings over the past couple of days with the Wood Council. With members on both sides of the House, I want to thank the Steelworkers for standing\n               up for forestry families in this province. I just want, on behalf of the official\n               opposition, to thank them for the great discussions that we had, and we hope to continue\n               those conversations about working people in this province. Would the House give them another round of applause, please. Will the House please give them another round of applause, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327974","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I know that the Minister of Forests introduced the United Steelworkers yesterday,\n               but there have been meetings over the past couple of days with the Wood Council. With members on both sides of the House, I want to thank the Steelworkers for standing\n               up for forestry families in this province. I just want, on behalf of the official\n               opposition, to thank th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76824","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biomass","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76824","label":"Biomass","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7cafb8da21e86d31ec8ae96a19fe9f191560165841d888689c302930db366ed0","10115eba02276224a42b686da09255637dea0ea5b7047ab86efefec712329bc8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0a412c07facc2483df6830a1f2dfa35875316ac740eebaf0fb99cd0bec63bc78"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e59224d90b32a2f41ab9178f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327975,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 2, the Budget Measures Implementation Act. I do want to thank the previous speaker for her words about the work we all do in\n               our constituency offices. I fully agree that all of us are here to serve the public\n               and work on our constituents' behalf. Whether we agree with a policy or not, the intent\n               behind it and the care is real, I believe, as well. So I thank the member for her\n               comments. I want to start with what the Budget Measures Implementation Act, Bill 2, actually\n               is achieving, and that is something I did not hear from the previous member. There\n               was a lot of talk about spending, so what was actually in the budget. But I want to\n               get into what this particular bill actually means. When we hear the words \"budget implementation\", yes, that sounds like the administration\n               of the budget and the spending. It looks like a routine piece of legislation that\n               just adjusts the financial rules, and spending happens. But let's call this bill what\n               it really is. It's a tax bill. That's something that we didn't hear from the previous\n               comments. Bill 2 is the legislation that turns the tax increases from this year's budget into\n               law. Every tax increase that families and businesses will feel from this year's budget\n               is implemented through this bill. When we debate Bill 2, we're debating the real financial\n               consequences that British Columbians will face in their paycheques, in their household\n               bills and in the cost of running a business. Unfortunately, when we look at the contents\n               of this bill, what we see is government asking British Columbians to pay more at precisely\n               the moment when many of them can least afford it. Earlier this session, just a couple of weeks ago when we debated the budget, I spoke\n               about the people I represent in Prince George–Mackenzie. I spoke about the seniors who come into my office because they can't keep up with\n               the rising cost on a fixed income. I spoke about working families who are watching\n               their paycheques shrink as groceries, fuel, housing and child care are paid, but there's\n               too much month at the end of the money. I spoke about small business owners who are\n               exhausted from rising costs and regulatory pressure. Those conversations are the lens that I am looking at this legislation in Bill 2 with.\n               When I apply that lens of those families, the seniors, the small businesses, I see\n               a series of tax measures that will increase the cost of living and the cost of doing\n               business across the province. Let me begin with one of the most significant measures in this bill, and it's the\n               increase to the lowest personal income tax bracket. Bill 2, as it is in the budget,\n               raises the base provincial income tax rate from 5.06 percent to 5.6 percent. I know\n               that sounds like a very small amount, but this is significant. This is a 10 percent\n               increase in the lowest tax bracket. For the lowest earners in the province, this hits their wallets the hardest, and it's\n               broad-sweeping. That, in fact, impacts all families, because the lowest tax bracket\n               includes everyone, as well, at the first levels of their tax, so that's significant. This is the first increase in the lowest provincial income tax rate since 2008. For\n               nearly two decades, governments of different political stripes recognized that raising\n               the base income tax rate affects everyone and particularly those who can least afford\n               it. Because the lowest bracket applies to the first portion of income that every taxpayer\n               earns — that's what I just referenced — that means this tax increase affects workers,\n               seniors, young families and new entrants into the workforce. Those young workers are who I'm very concerned about. They're trying to make it. They're\n               trying to afford their first home, perhaps. They're trying to, perhaps, move out of\n               their parents' house, but it makes it much more difficult to do when we're taxing\n               them more. Everyone pays this. It comes at a time when British Columbians are already facing\n               the most significant affordability pressures in a generation. As I said, groceries\n               are more expensive. Housing costs still do remain extraordinarily high. Fuel costs\n               are high, particularly in It comes at a time when British Columbians are already facing the most significant\n               affordability pressures in a generation. As I said, groceries are more expensive.\n               Housing costs still do remain extraordinarily high. Fuel costs are high, particularly\n               in northern and rural communities where I represent. Insurance, utilities, transportation\n               costs — all high costs on families. The question British Columbians are asking is really a simple one. Why is the government\n               choosing this moment right now, when British Columbians are struggling, to raise income\n               taxes? The income tax changes don't stop there. Bill 2 also includes a policy that may sound\n               technical but has consequences. It's the freezing of the income tax bracket indexation.\n               Previously, income tax brackets rose with inflation. That means as wages increased\n               to keep up with rising prices, workers were not pushed into higher tax brackets simply\n               because inflation had increased their nominal income. The indexation was designed\n               to protect taxpayers from something economists call bracket creep. Bill 2 freezes that indexation. In practice, that means that as inflation continues\n               and as wages slowly rise to keep pace with the cost of living, more and more income\n               will be taxed at higher rates. Workers may receive modest wage increases simply to\n               keep up with rising prices, but instead of those increases helping them to get ahead,\n               they will increasingly be captured by the tax system. Even if someone's real purchasing\n               power doesn't improve, they will still pay more tax. That's not tax fairness. It's\n               simply a quiet way of increasing the tax burden year after year after year. A very glaring tax measure in Bill 2 is one of the most significant expansions of\n               the provincial sales tax in, I would say, a generation. For the first time, the PST\n               will apply to a wide range of professional and business services. This includes accounting\n               services, bookkeeping services, architectural services, engineering services, private\n               security and non-residential real estate management. All of these services will now\n               be subject to 7 percent PST. These aren't luxury services. They're the cost of doing\n               business. They're essential components of operating a business responsibly. I have spoken many times in the House about my own family small business that I grew\n               up with. My dad still runs Giddens Services, an appliance and electronics repair business.\n               This will go to the cost that my father and my uncle, the two business owners, pay\n               for bookkeeping, that they pay for all of their accounting, that they pay for the\n               things that they need fundamentally to run their business. Engineering and architectural services are required for the construction sector and\n               real estate development. Security services are increasingly necessary for businesses\n               facing vandalism, theft, property and crime. I'm going to touch on that a little bit\n               more. These are operational necessities. When the government adds 7 percent tax to\n               those services, it increases the cost of running a business across the province. This\n               comes at a time, as well, when the payroll taxes and the cost of doing business has\n               been added on many areas. I recall, obviously, the government.... When the NDP first came in, they didn't run\n               on an employer health tax, but it hit small businesses very hard, including my own\n               family business. This is all, of course, passed through in higher prices, reduced\n               investment and fewer jobs overall. I have talked about this in the House before, but before entering public life, I served\n               as president of the Prince George Chamber of Commerce. I spent a lot of time listening\n               to small business owners. I know how tight the margins can be because I've talked\n               to them about it. I know that many businesses operate on very small profit margins\n               as it is, while trying to keep their employees working and their communities thriving.\n               For those businesses, the expansion of PST to professional services is something major,\n               and it has real cost for them. Consider a business that hires private security, though. Because theft and vandalism\n               have become serious problems in communities, small businesses in Prince George have\n               had to do just that. Larger businesses in Prince George, like London Drugs, have security present at all\n               times in their store. They're paying this every day and then, of course, having to\n               pass that on. We've seen, obviously, in Vancouver that cost led to the closure of\n               the London Drugs location at the former Woodward's building. That business will now The city of Prince George pays for private security in our downtown, as a band-aid\n               solution, because of the growing cost of vandalism and theft and challenges that we\n               have talked about so many times in this House. Now we're actually going to be saddling\n               municipalities with that increased cost, and that goes on to people's property taxes.\n               Those are the taxes that each and every homeowner is going to pay. Every business\n               pays into property taxes. Layer after layer of cost is added when we add taxes like this, and it happens at\n               a time when business confidence in British Columbia is already fragile. When taxes\n               and costs rise faster than economic growth, it discourages investment. It discourages\n               entrepreneurship. Who wants to start a new business when they know that it's just\n               going to be harder and harder to get ahead? We heard the business surveys from the Victoria business improvement association,\n               and the majority of businesses would actually leave and shut down their business if\n               they weren't locked into leases. That's the dire situation that we are in in this\n               province right now when it comes to businesses and entrepreneurship. Ultimately, that's going to hurt us in the long run. It's going to hurt job creation.\n               It's going to hurt those opportunities for young people in this province. These tax measures, of course, as I've said, will not only affect businesses. They'll\n               affect homeowners. Many strata corporations rely heavily on professional services,\n               particularly accounting, engineering and property management. Those services are essential\n               to maintaining safe buildings and properly managed communities. But when these services\n               are suddenly subject to a new 7 percent tax, the cost of operating strata buildings\n               rises. We know that can often lead to disputes, when strata corporations are trying\n               to save to make sure that they can afford to pay for improvements to the building,\n               not just for the basic services that they need to operate as a strata. Condo owners in British Columbia will see their monthly costs increase. Strata fees\n               are going to rise for those who are in those buildings. These folks are not going\n               to receive any additional services in return for that extra tax that they're paying.\n               It's simply a new tax embedded in their monthly bills. When we were talking about the budget.... This is an area I talked about already, but\n               of course there is a measure in Bill 2 that will have a particularly significant impact\n               on rural and northern communities. This bill removes distinctions that previously\n               recognized the realities for northern and rural homeowners under the homeowner grant\n               program. For decades, those distinctions acknowledged that the cost of living in rural and\n               northern communities is different. Travel distances are longer. Heating costs are\n               higher. Fuel costs are higher. Access to services often requires significant travel,\n               yet under this legislation, those distinctions are removed. For homeowners in northern communities, including those in Prince George–Mackenzie, that change will translate into higher property tax costs. For some households,\n               that change is going to mean $200 more per year, and $200 might not sound like a lot\n               of money, but on a household budget, that's significant when it comes to tax time,\n               when we all pay our property taxes. When you combine it with higher energy bills,\n               higher grocery costs, higher insurance premiums and the higher taxes elsewhere in\n               the system, it adds up, and families notice. That's not to mention.... This is something that needs to be repeated time and time\n               again in this House. The wealth generated in this province — so much of it comes from\n               rural and northern B.C. The mines, and obviously the forest sector, still contribute\n               so much to the province. LNG and natural gas sector. Natural gas certainly did contribute a lot to this year's\n               budget, and that needs to be recognized. but that also should be recognized for the\n               natural gas workers who get up every single day to make sure we have safe, heated\n               homes in our province, everywhere in B.C. Bill 2 also expands PST to items and services that many people rely on every day.\n               The removal of certain exemptions means that services like basic cable and land-line\n               phone services will face higher taxes. Maybe some people might dismiss this as outdated\n               technology, but in rural communities, land lines remain The removal of certain exemptions means that services like basic cable and land-line\n               phone services will face higher taxes. Maybe some people might dismiss this as outdated\n               technology, but in rural communities land-lines remain an essential form of communication.\n               Of course, these long-standing services that PST didn't apply to previously, seniors\n               rely on them. Nearly all seniors, including those who may be watching at home today,\n               are watching on a basic cable package. They want access to see what we're doing here\n               in the Legislature, and they want access to information about the news and what's\n               happening in our province. Is that too much to ask? Rural households rely on these\n               services as well when cell coverage is unreliable. Emergency services rely on land-lines, and that's going to have a cost to volunteer\n               fire departments, for example. When those services become expensive, it disproportionately\n               affects those who are already on fixed incomes. That is why these budget measures\n               are such a massive impact to seniors. It is so challenging to see a demographic and\n               people who have given so much to our province, to have them on a fixed income being\n               saddled with these extra costs of their daily budgets. Of course, what makes these tax increases particularly difficult to justify is the\n               broader fiscal context. This year's government revenue is projected to reach approximately\n               $85 billion. That's the highest revenue level in the province's history. Despite all\n               of that, at all of these tax increases, we have a record deficit. The province is\n               projecting a deficit exceeding $13 billion, as we know. British Columbians are being asked to pay more in taxes, and the government finances\n               continue to deteriorate. It's a structural deficit that government is trying to basically\n               plug holes in the Titanic at this point with these measures. That raises a fundamental\n               question about the government's overall fiscal management. Instead of saddling it\n               on the backs of seniors and small businesses and families, government needs to look\n               at how it's managing its fiscal framework overall. If revenue is reaching record highs, and taxes are increasing, why are deficits still\n               growing? The answer, as many economists have pointed out, is that spending growth\n               has been outpacing revenue growth for several years. When that happens, deficits become\n               structural, as I have said. That leads to rising debt, and rising debt leads to higher\n               debt servicing costs. Those costs ultimately compete with funding for essential public\n               services like health care, education and infrastructure. Every dollar spent on debt\n               servicing is a dollar that can't be spent elsewhere. I want to talk a little bit about accountability. These budget measures also contain\n               provisions that eliminate something that we have talked about already extensively\n               in this House, mostly in question period. It is the elimination of the Office of the\n               Merit Commissioner and transferring, as the Finance Minister tried to argue, its responsibilities\n               to the public service bureaucracy within the public service. The Merit Commissioner played an important role in ensuring that hiring in the public\n               service followed the merit principle. Not only that, I want to point to the fact that\n               something else was added to the Merit Commissioner's responsibilities a number of\n               years ago. There were, obviously, wrongful dismissals that were something that were\n               added to the Merit Commissioner's responsibility. We need to have just service for\n               public sector workers. If they are wrongfully dismissed from their job, they need\n               recourse. The Merit Commissioner reviewing that is a proper check on government accountability. And indeed, I would say that the Legislature and all party committees did agree with\n               that. I'll quote David McCoy, the Merit Commissioner. He said, \"A non-partisan multiparty\n               committee of the B.C. Legislature recognized this in December when they approved a\n               three-year budget to our office to continue our independent oversight of hiring and\n               dismissals process in the B.C. Public Service. The committee expressed appreciation\n               for the office's dedicated commitment to upholding merit-based practices in public\n               service hiring.\" That is how important this was. All parties were involved in this. Members from both\n               sides of the House made that recommendation. And yet, on the same day, the budget\n               was introduced, and we had the committee stand up and that's where this report came I will also say that the Merit Commissioner's office, in their service plan, said:\n               \"It is notable that since '22-23 there has been an increase in merit-not-applied findings\n               and a decrease in merit findings.\" That's why this is more important than ever. We\n               can't run a government based on friends and insiders. This cannot happen. But the\n               Merit Commissioner is a check on that. I asked the government what they are trying to hide. This is such a small savings\n               in the budget measures and the overall fiscal framework. So what is going on in the\n               government right now that they need to get rid of an office and lay off these important\n               public servants that are doing the work to protect the public interest? I want to just highlight that point about dismissals again. Mr. McCoy also said: \"Our\n               mandate expanded to include dismissal reviews in 2018. Only recently, a non-partisan\n               committee, a multi-party committee, conducted a legislative review of that responsibility\n               and affirmed the importance of this work and that it remained independent from government.\" That goes back to recommendations that were made by Ombudsperson Jay Chalke because\n               of wrongful dismissals from the Ministry of Health that happened where health care\n               workers were dismissed and government was found in the wrong. The Ombudsperson supported\n               these workers. The important thing about that is the fact that one of these particular workers actually\n               took their life because of the wrongful dismissal, and that actually impacted their\n               mental health. That's how serious this is. Removing the Merit Commissioner's office\n               is something that is disrespectful, in my opinion. Government is obviously making choices in this budget, and rewarding friends and insiders\n               may be one of those choices. I sincerely hope not, but there's a pattern that's emerging\n               here. When we step back and look at this legislation as a whole, I want to reiterate\n               that this bill raises income taxes. It expands sales taxes. It increases property\n               tax burdens for rural homeowners, it increases operating costs for businesses, and\n               it does so during a period when affordability pressures are already intense. British Columbians are not asking for more taxes right now. They're asking for relief.\n               They're asking for stability. They're asking for a government that recognizes the\n               financial pressure that they are under, that seniors are under, that families are\n               under right now. People in Prince George–Mackenzie understand that governing involves difficult decisions. They understand that public\n               services must be funded. Yes, we have to have taxes. I'm not disputing that. But it\n               has to be fair. They understand that economic cycles change. But in return, they also expect responsible\n               fiscal management. They expect that when government revenue reaches record highs,\n               taxes will not continue rising. They expect that rural communities will not be asked\n               to shoulder a disproportionate burden of the tax burden in this province. They expect\n               that policies will strengthen the province's long-term economic competitiveness. As we've seen from what we're hearing from the business community, that's absolutely\n               not the case.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327975","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 2, the Budget Measures Implementation Act. I do want to thank the previous speaker for her words about the work we all do in\n               our constituency offices. I fully agree that all of us are here to serve the public\n               and work on our constituents' behalf. Whether we agree with a policy or not, the intent\n               behind it and the care is re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26829e5f4336b528343584c2580433ec346ea4689a43b7c12e18cf5717f2f475"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fe52e2e51972b7e76b10cbe50a8028536a70a94f90b6f4f1e3c61fcd3a4c6f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d7d49bd63472181d9f66a64c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187129,"date":"2026-03-05T12:00:00+00:00","title":"PUBLIC SECTOR CONSTRUCTION\n PROJECTS PROCUREMENT ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m233-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m233-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187129","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53834c440dfba7f82431598a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360157,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm very glad to speak in the House today in support of the Long Term Care Access and Transparency Act. Before I talk about policy, I want to talk about family and my family in particular.\n               My nonna, my grandmother on my dad's side, lived with Alzheimer's. Like so many families,\n               ours watched someone we loved slowly change in ways that were heartbreaking and beyond\n               our control. There came a point when caring for her at home was no longer safe or\n               possible, no matter how much love surrounded her. Long-term care became essential.\n               What mattered most to our family was knowing she was safe, treated with dignity and\n               cared for by professionals who understood what she was going through. Because of that care, my dad and his siblings were able to visit her simply as sons\n               and daughters, not as exhausted caregivers trying to manage an impossible situation\n               on their own. They could hold her hand, sit with her, talk to her, play music she\n               loved or recite Italian nursery rhymes that she loved. They could just be family.\n               That is what good long-term care makes possible. Across Prince George–Mackenzie in northern B.C., I meet families who are walking the same difficult road right now\n               — adult children worrying about their parents, spouses doing everything they can until\n               they simply cannot anymore and seniors themselves afraid of losing independence or\n               becoming a burden. What they want most is reassurance, so for when that time comes,\n               there will be a place for their loved one, that they will not be left waiting without\n               answers. This bill, I believe, speaks directly to that need. At its heart, it is about transparency,\n               about giving families clear, honest information so they can plan ahead and make incredibly\n               difficult decisions with some measure of certainty. The B.C. Seniors Advocate's report on rural seniors makes it clear that communities\n               like the ones I represent face unique challenges. Rural British Columbia has a higher\n               proportion of seniors than urban areas, and that number is actually growing very quickly. I think of a town like Mackenzie. The proportion of seniors, historically, that are\n               moving to Mackenzie in search of affordable housing is changing the community rapidly.\n               Seniors in rural regions often have fewer services, fewer care providers and longer\n               travel distances to access support. In some northern areas, life expectancy is actually\n               lower than in the south, and that is simply something that we cannot accept. At the same time, rural seniors are fiercely independent. They want to stay in their\n               homes and communities for as long as possible, but when their health declines, they\n               deserve timely access to appropriate care close to the people that they love. Right\n               now, that access is not always timely or predictable. Health care workers across the\n               North are doing extraordinary work under immense pressure. Nurses, care aides, physicians,\n               and support staff show compassion every single day. In my own community, at the University Hospital of Northern British Columbia, approximately\n               one-third of patient beds are occupied by alternative level of care patients. These\n               are individuals who no longer need acute hospital treatment but cannot be discharged\n               because they are waiting for long-term care placement. Behind that statistic are real\n               people — mothers, fathers, grandparents, neighbours — spending weeks or months in\n               hospital rooms that are not designed for long-term care living. Families visit them\n               there day after day, often not knowing how much longer the wait will be or where their\n               loved one will ultimately go. That is why reporting requirements in this bill are so important. Requiring monthly\n               data on wait-lists, wait times, alternate level of care patients, hospice access and\n               home support availability will give us a clear picture of what is happening on the\n               ground. Making that information public means families will no longer be left guessing.\n               Transparency builds trust and it allows families to plan, and I think that's really\n               important. When hospital beds are tied up this way, it affects everyone from seniors\n               waiting in placement to patients arriving in emergency who need acute care. The system is under strain and families feel that strain most acutely. When a loved\n               one begins to decline, families face agonizing questions. Should someone reduce work\n               hours, modify the home, move closer to services, prepare financially? How long might\n               the wait be? These decisions can't be made overnight, and they cannot be made without\n               information. So this bill requires, as well, the development of a plan to improve timely access\n               to long-term care and reduce These decisions can't be made overnight, and they cannot be made without information.\n               So this bill requires, as well, the development of a plan to improve timely access\n               to long-term care and reduce the number of patients waiting in hospital for placement.\n               Reporting is important, but it must lead to action as well. A plan that is reviewed\n               regularly ensures we remain focused on solutions. Above all, this legislation is about dignity, and it's why I will be supporting this\n               bill. Our seniors built this province. They cared for us when we were vulnerable.\n               Now it's our turn to care for them. When I think about my nonna, I'm grateful that\n               long-term care allowed our family to focus on love rather than logistics. For these reasons, I'm proud to support the Long Term Care Access and Transparency\n               Act. I thank you, Madam Speaker, for the time to speak to it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360157","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm very glad to speak in the House today in support of the Long Term Care Access and Transparency Act. Before I talk about policy, I want to talk about family and my family in particular.\n               My nonna, my grandmother on my dad's side, lived with Alzheimer's. Like so many families,\n               ours watched someone we loved slowly change in ways that were heartbreaking and beyond\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c125b4f4e140cdfb1414a15233e00d48b565609bfd47fabd736f37788c25ff76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd614d78ee532e4fc38074047d0170c72f517a7bbc925b357c9f88d5a19b6e80"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02339cb37a1d21393dac2db2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360158,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll remind the minister that the strata manager that was talked about here is paying\n               $6,000 more under this PST. That is adding costs for British Columbians who just want\n               an affordable home. Studies in B.C. show that building homes to net-zero standards can add up to 10 percent\n               to construction costs. At a time when people already can't afford a home, these costs\n               will simply be passed on to buyers. Will this government stabilize costs and pause\n               zero carbon step code to EL2 to prevent more added costs for hard-working British\n               Columbians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360158","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'll remind the minister that the strata manager that was talked about here is paying\n               $6,000 more under this PST. That is adding costs for British Columbians who just want\n               an affordable home. Studies in B.C. show that building homes to net-zero standards can add up to 10 percent\n               to construction costs. At a time when people already can't afford a home, t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6bca8e469b11cd99a2445f6af9541af378291cecf118901e3841be5e80d1ff93"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8db6a142fd5f72eb90371646b657910f50c9c8e3cb86f1b1b9b1ee8208b56840"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dab3a7d82829e441a7621a10","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360159,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm going to join the debate this evening on Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. No surprise that I will be also addressing my serious concerns with this particular\n               bill that's been brought before the House. We've heard quite passionate messaging\n               from members on this side of the House. I think there is a concern that we're hearing\n               from community members across British Columbia about secrecy and what that's doing\n               in eroding trust in public institutions. I'm going to get into that in my remarks. Access to information certainly has been debated at length in this House over many,\n               many years now. That alone, I think, tells us how important this actually is. I think\n               the main question before us today is pretty straightforward. Do these amendments strengthen\n               transparency and accountability in British Columbia, or do they move us further away\n               from our democratic foundations? I think that's what we're asking here. That's what\n               the public is wondering. I think we have heard certain things come out over the past number of years about\n               this government being labelled the most secretive government in Canada. I think that's\n               why, when we look at a bill like this and how important it is to get it right — what\n               we need to achieve in this legislation in access to free and open information — we\n               can't do things that are going to send us backwards. Of course, access-to-information legislation is used all across Canada and has evolved\n               over the years. It's become one of the primary tools citizens have to hold government\n               accountable. It allows journalists to scrutinize spending. It enables unions to obtain\n               workplace safety records. It helps communities understand how major decisions are\n               made and gives ordinary British Columbians a way to confirm that public institutions\n               are actually acting in the public interest. In my riding, in Prince George–Mackenzie, the consequences of some of these government decisions.... People see them each and\n               every day. They affect families. They affect workers. They are immediate, and, I would\n               say, they're tangible. They affect workers who have faced what they consider wrongful\n               dismissals. I'm sure all of us have had those case file examples in our offices, and\n               I'm going to touch on that a little bit later in my remarks. They also affect people worried about health care access and ensuring that their health\n               information is both transparent and protected. Government decisions affect municipalities\n               seeking infrastructure funding and small businesses competing for government contracts.\n               I think in those circumstances, access to information is practical to help with continuous\n               improvement for those local governments as they're looking.... If they're not successful,\n               they want to see, the next time, what they need to change. Maintaining that public\n               trust in that process is important. I think people want to understand that decisions are made fairly, equitably, responsibly\n               and in the public interest. For that reason, any amendments to this act should be\n               approached very carefully, cautiously and measured against the principle that government\n               information does not belong to government. It actually belongs to the public. I think\n               that it's not government's information, and that's something we have to really keep\n               in mind as we look at opening up a significant piece of legislation like this one. When this Legislature first adopted access-to-information legislation, members, I\n               think across party lines, emphasized one very simple idea. That's that public bodies,\n               as I've just said, are custodians of that information, the people's information, not\n               owners of it. There's a duty that comes with that, obviously. I recognize that this information is not easy to manage. It's not easy to set up the\n               systems that ministries need to use all across government agencies. It's actually\n               quite a complex undertaking. Sometimes it actually can be uncomfortable as well. But\n               over time, the idea or principle, I think Transparency is not granted simply at the pleasure of government. I think it is a\n               baseline expectation when the public knows we have this law in place. That's what\n               they believe already. This information is just going to be accessible by default.\n               Exceptions, of course, exist. We need to have those safeguards for privacy, security\n               and legitimate confidentiality of people's personal information. But those exceptions\n               must be clearly defined and very carefully limited. That's where our legislation has to hit the right balance. It's a standard against\n               which, I think, Bill 9 has to be measured. Does it narrow exceptions and improve service?\n               Or does it expand the discretion of certain individuals and create new barriers? I\n               think you've heard from many members on this side of the House that there are concerns\n               that we're hearing about new barriers being created here. When undefined terms, such as \"malicious,\" \"abusive\" and \"unreasonably interfere,\"\n               are introduced into legislation, as we've heard proposed here, we move away from clear\n               standards and towards subjective interpretation. I'm not actually sure why this isn't\n               defined. It could have been included right in the definitions to make this much more\n               clear. Perhaps government is including that in regulation, but even that has not been\n               properly explained. It looks like, to me and to members of the public, a loophole that government is creating\n               here. And loopholes are what undermine the process in the first place. Clause 2 of the bill amends section 5 of the act to provide that the head of a public\n               body determines whether an access request contains sufficient detail to identify the\n               record sought. It also introduces a requirement that the record must be capable of\n               being located within a reasonable amount of time. On the surface, I think, this sounds\n               like we're looking for something that's bureaucratically workable, but it is really\n               a meaningful shift in discretion. I think that it's something we have to look at and\n               examine very closely, this wording in the bill. The public body that holds the records will now actually be the ones to determine\n               whether a request contains enough detail and also what qualifies as a reasonable amount\n               of time. None of that is defined. So we're left wondering that. I think it's incumbent upon the government to have members explain that, to make sure\n               that that's clear for the public, because legislative language actually matters. The\n               language in this bill will be used in judicial processes, in appeal processes, and\n               I think that's something that we have to keep in mind. When standards are undefined,\n               discretion does expand, and when that happens, certainty also declines as well. Of course, we have heard on this topic from the dean of the legislative press gallery,\n               Vaughn Palmer, legislative columnist. I think he captured that particular concern\n               pretty clearly. he wrote that the bill grants public bodyheads \"the authority to decide\n               in their opinion whether the request provides enough detail to enable an experienced\n               employee with a reasonable effort and a reasonable amount of time to identify the\n               record sought.\" He continued: \"Again, the officials themselves will decide what is\n               enough and what is reasonable.\" I think that is the heart of this particular issue with the bill — that discretion.\n               When the institution being scrutinized also determines whether the scrutiny is properly\n               framed, the safeguards have to be very clear, and they are not clear in the way this\n               is currently written. Most applicants to freedom of information requests are not lawyers.\n               It has to be very obvious and very clear how this is going to work. If the threshold becomes uncertain, participation may decrease, not because the interest\n               has actually faded — because I think there's actually an appetite for more freedom\n               of information requests — but because the process has actually become more difficult\n               to navigate. We can't.... Again, this is not government's information. This is public\n               information. So it has to be.... I recognize that we have to have these bureaucratic\n               systems in place But it's also because the process has actually become more difficult to navigate.\n               We can't.... Again, this is not government's information; this is public information.\n               I recognize that we have to have these bureaucratic systems in place to manage this,\n               but it has to be workable for the public. Clause 3 of the bill changes the duty to respond \"without delay\" to a duty to respond\n               \"without unreasonable delay.\" Another adjustment, I think, that let's look at with\n               a very critical lens. It adds discretion or subjectivity to this. I think that's something that we're seeing, time and time again, as themes coming\n               up here — that British Columbians' FOI system, it already has faced significant delays. As of a couple years ago, applicants\n               experienced an average of 192 additional business days beyond statutory timelines\n               before receiving responses. That is not just a small administrative hiccup. That is\n               actually a systemic challenge. I understand wanting to create efficiencies, but make it in a way using tools that\n               are actually going to speed up that process. Or just open by default, making that\n               information just automatically accessible, where that's possible. In that context, changing the statutory language raises legitimate concerns. Rather\n               than reinforcing urgency, because I think that's what the last language actually did,\n               the amendment introduces interpretive flexibility. In previous sessions of the Legislature, members — actually, on all sides — have raised concerns about backlog and timeliness. Ministers have acknowledged those concerns and committed to improvements\n               through things like digitization and improved staffing. I think commitments.... Let's\n               make those commitments and hold ourselves accountable to them. But applicants are not asking for more flexible language; they're asking for more\n               timely responses. If the core problem is delay, the solution lies in resourcing and\n               management, not in redefining the obligation. Hopefully the government can answer\n               that more clearly in how this subjectivity is being used here. I'm going to drop down to clause 13, because it's one of the most consequential provisions\n               in the bill. It expands the grounds on which a public body may apply to the Information and Privacy Commissioner to disregard an access request. The bill adds, as I said, terms such as \"malicious,\" \"abusive,\" \"repetitious,\" and\n               \"excessively broad.\" It also allows requests to be disregarded if responding would\n               \"unreasonably interfere with the operations of the government of B.C.\" That is very,\n               very broad language. It refers not simply to the operations of a ministry, but to\n               the operations of the government as a whole. Again, Mr. Palmer highlighted this part, this provision, in his analysis that came out publicly. He\n               said: \"A third provision allows officials to disregard requests altogether if, in\n               their opinion, responding to the requests would unreasonably interfere with the operations\n               of the government of B.C.\" He emphasized: \"unreasonably interfere with the operations\n               of the entire government, no less.\" He went on to caution: \"Imagine how that power could be abused to ask a potentially\n               embarrassing request at a time of supposed fiscal restraint.\" While the commissioner must approve applications to disregard requests, expanding the categories under which\n               those applications may be made changes the balance. This is a critical, critical component\n               of the bill, this clause 13. Undefined terms widen interpretation, and wider interpretation increases discretion.\n               Of course, I've said, discretion can really be a challenge here when we're looking\n               at something like this. Transparency shouldn't depend on whether a request is convenient. Moving forward a little bit more. Clause 21 allows public bodies to require payment\n               for records that are otherwise available without the need to file an FOI request. Currently, proactively available records may be accessed without cost. Of course,\n               those are on the government website. This amendment introduces the possibility of\n               fees for obtaining copies of those records. So that This amendment introduces the possibility of fees for obtaining copies of those records.\n               That information that we have opened up we are now going to close, potentially. That\n               is seriously concerning. At a time when many British Columbians are also facing economic\n               pressure, even incremental fees should warrant some careful consideration. Again,\n               this is their information; it's not the government's. And of course, we've heard this many times already, but this is not the first time\n               the Legislature has debated these fees. In 2021.... That's the last time amendments\n               came in and introduced a $10 application fee for filing an FOI request. At the time,\n               it was described as modest and administrative, but critics cautioned at that time\n               that even small fees create barriers, particularly for journalists, for researchers\n               and individuals making multiple requests. I'm going to use journalists as an example. In a free and democratic society, obviously,\n               journalism is critical. Work that the folks do in the press gallery is actually critical\n               to the entire work of how this place functions. The debate back in 2021 also centred\n               on whether we were placing a price on transparency, and so exactly.... A price on the\n               work that those journalists are doing. Clause 21 reopens that question that we talked\n               about, the Legislature talked about back in 2021. Transparency should not depend on\n               an applicant's ability to pay. I know we're talking modest fees, but this is the public's\n               information. As the opposition critic for Labour, I do consider how these changes affect working\n               people, working families in this province. I think one of the things that it does\n               is support workplace accountability. It enables workers and unions to obtain inspection\n               reports, policy guidance, and communications relevant to employment standards and\n               occupational health and safety. If they are going into an employment standards tribunal\n               hearing, getting that information is actually critical for these workers who may have\n               a legitimate complaint. Maybe they have wages that they have owed from their employer,\n               and they need to actually access the information to be able to state their case. If procedural hurdles increase or requests can be dismissed more easily, the impact\n               is not something that is something to be dismissed. It affects individuals seeking\n               clarity about decisions that actually affect their jobs, it affects their livelihoods.\n               That's something very serious. Transparency also strengthens fair labour practices,\n               I think, and that even is fair labour practices within the government, for government\n               employees, public sector workers. It reinforces public confidence in institutions,\n               and those, I think, are outcomes that are worthwhile protecting. And it's one of the\n               of the things I'm very concerned about in this particular Bill 9 legislation. So the bill's provisions talk about regarding a connected services provider. I think\n               that's how the government has described this. They're going to offer efficiencies.\n               However, I do think that implementation details on that also matter. Will the participation\n               be mandatory for Crown corporations, for example? Will centralization improve response\n               times, and how will independence be preserved? Administrative reform should enhance\n               service and accountability and not merely consolidate control. I just want to point out the Freedom of Information and Privacy Association, the concerns\n               that they've had. They've recognized that the government has framed the bill as a\n               modernization effort to improve digital service delivery, but they go on to note that\n               the real source of FOI delays lies upstream in inconsistent record creation, classification,\n               retention and digitization practices across ministries. And so Jason Woywada, the FIPA executive director, said: \"Access delays are often\n               a symptom of record-keeping failures. You cannot fix systemic information management\n               problems by weakening public access rights.\" That's a serious quote from an important\n               organization that I think is critical to this conversation. I'm going to get to my biggest concern with reviewing this bill, and I'm going to\n               go back to the rights of workers. I'm going to get to my biggest concern with reviewing this bill, and I'm going to\n               go back to the rights of workers in speaking to that. I'm quoting Vaughn Palmer again\n               because I found that his analysis was pretty clear. He observed: \"Bill 9 is a piece\n               of legislation with the NDP drive to stifle independent oversight of government hiring,\n               promotions and firing by abolishing the independent Merit Commissioner.\" This is happening at the same time. We've canvassed this topic extensively in the\n               Legislature. The independent Merit Commissioner provided oversight to ensure public\n               service hiring and promotions adhered to merit-based principles. I talked about the fact that workers need access to information, whether that's a\n               dismissal, whether that's a wage dispute. But the government should also remember\n               that the Merit Commissioner also looked at wrongful dismissals. When a worker is wrongfully\n               dismissed, access to information through an FOI and review by an independent Merit\n               Commissioner are both extremely important. This was added under the previous Premier to rectify an issue when a wrongful dismissal\n               actually led to a tragedy in this province. I'm going to speak to that tragedy. In\n               September 2012, seven health researchers, including co-op student Roderick MacIsaac,\n               were fired from the B.C. Ministry of Health following a flawed investigation into\n               alleged data breaches. Of those individuals, the House will hopefully remember the name Roderick MacIsaac.\n               He was a 46-year-old PhD student on a work term. He was terminated just days before\n               his co-op ended. In January of 2013, he was found dead by suicide. The B.C. Coroners\n               ruled that the significant stress from the firing was a factor in his death. The incident prompted major changes to how the B.C. government handles internal investigations\n               and data access policies. The Merit Commissioner gained the power to examine dismissals\n               in 2018 after the release of a scathing report from B.C. Ombudsperson Jay Chalke investigating\n               this wrongful dismissal case, which eventually led to a legal settlement with the\n               other health care workers. I know this is a very serious topic that I'm bringing into this debate, but I have\n               to ask why the government is choosing to remove the types of transparency that were\n               brought up in this example. They're meant to protect people who were wrongfully dismissed\n               when they need that access to information. We don't want something like this to happen\n               again. I don't believe that that's at all the government's intent, but there is a serious\n               risk when people don't have access to their information. They can't file a proper\n               appeal. They feel they had an unjust dismissal. Taking away both the Merit Commissioner\n               and access to freedom of information, which can be withheld from them — that's something,\n               seriously, that we need to think about as a province. When oversight mechanisms are reduced, access to information becomes even more important.\n               Transparency serves as a safeguard when independent review structures are narrowed.\n               Public servants deserve confidence that hiring and promotion decisions are merit-based,\n               and they also deserve to know that dismissals were done fairly and ethically. I think that is something, within the context of FOI, that is worth having a conversation\n               about. Taxpayers also deserve assurance that public positions are filled fairly and\n               competently, and the same is to do with dismissals. Access to information is one of\n               the tools that allows the public to verify that integrity. That is my biggest concern with Bill 9. This bill regarding access to information\n               exists.... The legislation overall exists because democracy requires informed citizens.\n               It operationalizes accountability. Bill 9 may contain elements aimed at efficiency and modernization. However, as I've\n               said, it expands discretionary authority, introduces undefined standards, softens\n               response language and enables new fees. When you take in all of these things together,\n               these changes alter the balance between citizen access and government control. I think that over time there have been improvements to transparency, and that has\n               actually strengthened government. It has led to better decisions in public policy.\n               I think that's something we just need to hold to, to shine that light, to make sure\n               that we are looking for that access to information, so that we can make those improvements. For the people of Prince George–Mackenzie whom I represent, and for the people across British Columbia who value open and accountable\n               institutions, we have to ensure that freedom of information remains robust, accessible\n               and clearly defined. For those reasons, I cannot support Bill 9, in its current form, at second reading.\n               I thank you for the time, and I look forward to continued debate on this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360159","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm going to join the debate this evening on Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. No surprise that I will be also addressing my serious concerns with this particular\n               bill that's been brought before the House. We've heard quite passionate messaging\n               from members on this side of the House. I think there is a concern t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["209155fa173f72af1bb61f7b1e68d81c411b570db6fd7915b37be30877695d7c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["159d4e9bb32382b50a794609bff5a2526c8f0294253346f98c243f5427f88506"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3788f34ed64dbf6cc942aa0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360160,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm going to speak to the amendment put forward by the Opposition House Leader. I\n               respect the words that we've heard from the Minister of Indigenous Relations previously. I respect the passion he has brought to this. But I do want to turn the\n               temperature down in the room a little bit with this discussion as well. I recognize\n               the strong emotions, and it's for good reason. We're talking about, in the broader context of the government motion, support for\n               the B.C. human rights code and the powers under it. At its core, this motion asks\n               us to reaffirm something very fundamental: that people in British Columbia deserve\n               protection from discrimination and hate, and that our laws must provide meaningful\n               mechanisms to uphold those protections. I also want to acknowledge the comments made by the Attorney General, as well as the Opposition House Leader, in eloquently explaining how important those protections are.\n               I am going to get into a little bit about British Columbia's history and why this\n               amendment is actually part of the DNA of the code overall. I think the code reflects a basic principle that I would hope would unite members\n               of the House: that every person deserves dignity, fairness and equal opportunity.\n               Of course, as we've said, it protects people from discrimination based on race, including\n               Indigenous identity; colour; ancestry; place of origin; religion; marital status;\n               family status; physical or mental disability; sex; sexual orientation; gender identity\n               or expression; and age. That has been clearly talked about. To be honest, I am happy to affirm those particular views. I have no problem with\n               that whatsoever. But the code includes more provisions, as well, that need to be taken into account. Sections 13 and 14 of the code speak, in matters related to employment, to those who\n               have faced a criminal conviction or summary conviction. It also speaks to political\n               belief. These are other areas that need to be taken into account. Another area speaks,\n               in tenancy matters, to a lawful source of income. These are areas that are missing. I am going to get into a little bit of the history of the code and explain in context\n               why all of the protections in the code and support are actually quite important to\n               make sure that we are in fact protecting all people from hate and discrimination. The history includes many moments where individuals and communities have been treated\n               unfairly because of who they were. I'll just mention Chinese Canadians, for example,\n               who played a critical role in building the Canadian Pacific Railway and contributing\n               to the development of British Columbia. Yet they were later subjected to discriminatory\n               policies such as the Chinese head tax and the Chinese Exclusion Act. Japanese Canadians faced one of the most profound injustices during World War II when\n               thousands were forcibly removed from their homes, had their property confiscated and\n               were interned solely because of their ancestry. Indigenous Peoples in this province experienced and continue to confront systemic\n               discrimination and policies that sought to suppress their cultures, languages and\n               rights. Other communities indeed have faced barriers to employment, housing and public services\n               simply because of their race, religion, disability, gender or sexual orientation. These injustices affect real people, real families and real communities. I hope we\n               can agree on that. Over time, British Columbia came to recognize that preventing discrimination required\n               more than goodwill. It actually required laws. And that is what has led to the creation of the human\n               rights code. But it didn't happen overnight. The recognition led to a gradual development of human\n               rights protections in the province. Beginning in the mid-20th century, B.C. started adopting legislation to prohibit discrimination\n               in certain areas of public life. In the '50s and '60s, laws were introduced to address\n               discrimination in employment and public accommodations. Those early measures represented Over time, those protections were brought together into what we now know as the human\n               rights code. This code created a comprehensive framework protecting people from discrimination\n               in all of these key areas. It created mechanisms through which individuals could seek\n               remedies if they experienced discrimination. Later, the establishment of the Human Rights Tribunal strengthened this system by\n               providing an independent body capable of hearing complaints, evaluating evidence and\n               making binding decisions. I'm bringing this in because the history of the human rights\n               code and what is included in it is important here. Later, of course, with the adoption of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,\n               all of that is overlapping with our human rights code in B.C., and that goes right\n               to the Constitution of Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360160","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm going to speak to the amendment put forward by the Opposition House Leader. I\n               respect the words that we've heard from the Minister of Indigenous Relations previously. I respect the passion he has brought to this. But I do want to turn the\n               temperature down in the room a little bit with this discussion as well. I recognize\n               the strong emotions, and it'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:166036","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:166036","label":"Programming","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94c7b893a66c7cc29273f1d305379f12deb0d780df8a6e1f63fc0c409c4a4000"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1fa6f9dd544d1d403b66ee7255b44a3f6392d0efcc3a5feb40b5099edbcb8792"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3767620c6ce02c1140a101a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415729,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start by thanking the member for Fraser-Nicola for bringing forward Motion\n               M203. I believe this is an important motion to affirm the Legislature's support of\n               the merit principle in the public service and independent oversight by this Legislature.\n               Ultimately, as we've heard, this is about fairness for people working in the B.C.\n               public service. The merit principle is simple: hiring and promotion should be based on ability, experience\n               and qualifications, not personal or political connections. For public servants, I\n               think that matters. It's about knowing that if you do your job well, you'll be treated\n               fairly and have a real opportunity to advance. Political influence or partisan decision-making\n               shouldn't apply. Now, the Office of the Merit Commissioner has provided that independent oversight,\n               to help ensure that that principle is followed. The office reviews appointments and\n               reports to this Legislature, not to a specific minister or to the cabinet. That independence,\n               I believe, is important. It gives workers confidence that the system is fair, and\n               it gives the public confidence that decisions are made properly. Unfortunately, as we've heard, B.C. is moving away from the merit principle in the\n               public service. At the same time, the most recent report from the Merit Commissioner\n               shows that in about 10 percent of reviewed appointments, merit was not applied. Those\n               are facts and a concern for many British Columbians. The Finance Minister has recently stated that the Merit Commissioner's functions may\n               continue but within government. What I think that's missing is that it loses the importance\n               of maintaining strong, independent oversight. I think we need to support public servants\n               at this time. BCGEU President Paul Finch said: \"You cannot effectively oversee yourself. Independent\n               review exists for a reason — to ensure accountability, maintain public confidence\n               and protect from political or internal interference. Eliminating independent oversight\n               undermines transparency and risks eroding trust in the fairness of public service\n               staffing.\" Now, having oversight report to the Legislative Assembly rather than within the executive\n               ensures that we have transparency, and it builds trust. That's important for another\n               reason, and it's something that the Merit Commissioner's scope currently includes.\n               It's the lens for dismissals. A 2017 report of the Ombudsperson, Jay Chalke, called Misfire , reviewed the wrongful firings of Ministry of Health employees from 2012 that had\n               far-reaching and harmful consequences. In 2018, the government brought in amendments\n               that gave the Office of the Merit Commissioner responsibility for reviewing just cause\n               dismissals in the public service. At the same time, then Finance Minister Carole James said: \"While just cause dismissals\n               are not common in the public service, we want to ensure that when they do occur, there\n               are checks and balances in place. By fulfilling recommendation 27 of the Ombudsperson's Misfire report, we help to make sure that public servants' workplace rights are respected.\" Now, the merit principle and independent oversight were deemed critical for preventing\n               wrongful dismissals. Why would we move backwards from this as a province, and why\n               would the government, which brought this in, turn backwards on this as well? At a\n               time when the current Finance Minister has pledged to cut 15,000 public sector jobs,\n               ensuring this process is fair is absolutely critical. I would hope that public servants'\n               rights should be respected if any of these cuts should come through just cause This motion on the merit principle being applied to the public service is so important.\n               Government decisions should be fair, respectful and accountable. It's my hope that\n               this motion should reinforce a principle we should all agree on, that public service\n               jobs should be earned on merit and that this is best achieved by ensuring independent\n               oversight. As I have said, decisions on dismissals should be based on the exact same principles.\n               Independent officers of the Legislature ensure transparency for the public, and this\n               helps ensure fairness for the people who serve British Columbians every day. That's why I support this motion, and I thank the member for Fraser-Nicola for bringing it forward to the House at this time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415729","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to start by thanking the member for Fraser-Nicola for bringing forward Motion\n               M203. I believe this is an important motion to affirm the Legislature's support of\n               the merit principle in the public service and independent oversight by this Legislature.\n               Ultimately, as we've heard, this is about fairness for people working in the B.C.\n               p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036005","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job promotion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036005","label":"Job promotion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["53c89e38c84d985dc7a5098a34e8ce1afa1994ef665d3139d5d4a4b603a3f806"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73dc54ad2e33e984ce9d9cd11c94ce9c37a56fc1d50eb1c8c83fe421b8cfb1a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-666d9949d3bc9200288213c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415730,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"With the mortgage brokers in attendance, I wanted to pass on sincere condolences to\n               a member who was with the delegation last year, who was not with us this year. Christine\n               Bowman from Prince George recently passed away, on February 1, of breast cancer. She was a friend to many mortgage brokers across the province and many, many people\n               in Prince George. Hundreds of people attended her celebration of life recently, and\n               we honour her today. Thank you, and our condolences from the House to all those who knew her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Breast cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415730","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"With the mortgage brokers in attendance, I wanted to pass on sincere condolences to\n               a member who was with the delegation last year, who was not with us this year. Christine\n               Bowman from Prince George recently passed away, on February 1, of breast cancer. She was a friend to many mortgage brokers across the province and many, many people\n               in Prince George.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","label":"Breast cancer"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Breast cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","label":"Breast cancer","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["65441b65f5d9260faf939da53174823fd018654d1ad20a5f6dbdf2eeac570911"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Breast cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ecf6728ea7eaa80782e40601f38c62586a6f39d06b5c4dc6dbc707000e3dbbef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Breast cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49616","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc9b997f779e643f591c8f53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415731,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Over this past weekend, the World Cup snowboard finals took place in Mount Saint Anne,\n               Quebec. Evan Bichon from Mackenzie, B.C. took home the bronze medal, the first for\n               the community of Mackenzie in a major sporting event. Will the House please congratulate Evan on this massive achievement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415731","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Over this past weekend, the World Cup snowboard finals took place in Mount Saint Anne,\n               Quebec. Evan Bichon from Mackenzie, B.C. took home the bronze medal, the first for\n               the community of Mackenzie in a major sporting event. Will the House please congratulate Evan on this massive achievement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083611","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Snow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083611","label":"Snow","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40ef711db1c57ce16d0d24a5b12140165dc4f38f7d3f117c0bc03f157adebf2c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b953563cd8fb6ffda4b465747627a66c78e0a12b5026cabe9dae02f77b9a7a93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ef463e5f725be77f5714475","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720333,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"There are a number of guests here today I'd like to introduce. From CLAC, I'll introduce\n               Ryan Bruce, government relations director; Josh Pastoor, regional director; Jamie\n               Wade, provincial representative; Christine Cabey, provincial representative; Colin\n               Scott, CLAC member for 25 years in construction as an operator; Cassandra Campstra,\n               CLAC member for 15 years in construction; and Jeremy Crook, another CLAC member in\n               construction. From the Progressive Contractors Association, I'll introduce Paul de Jong, president\n               and CEO; Darrel Reid, VP, public affairs; Dan Baxter, regional director of B.C.; and\n               Natasha Westmore de Jong, events and membership coordinator. From the Independent Contractors and Businesses Association, I'll welcome Mike Davis,\n               regional vice-president; and Todd Comiskey, chief operating officer. From the First Nations natural gas alliance, I'll introduce my good friend Karen Ogan-Toews,\n               CEO. From John Coe Contracting, I'll introduce John Coleman. I also join the member for Esquimalt-Colwood in welcoming the members from the B.C. Federation of Labour and from the B.C. Building\n               Trades. I know everyone is here for a respectful debate this morning, and I appreciate\n               all of their presence in the House today. Will the House please join me in welcoming them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720333","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"There are a number of guests here today I'd like to introduce. From CLAC, I'll introduce\n               Ryan Bruce, government relations director; Josh Pastoor, regional director; Jamie\n               Wade, provincial representative; Christine Cabey, provincial representative; Colin\n               Scott, CLAC member for 25 years in construction as an operator; Cassandra Campstra,\n               CL","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99378","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99378","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99378","label":"Occupational diseases","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["642bb6f08a613b6ac35f49add54e148c1df7f3761995d321831fc4441de39d20","44f55f48981bf61b90b05b1d6764a3be3104c6f172a9a58a35089a59d158c027"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67dab5192bb0f16479d2d558","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720335,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Unfortunately, it's the workers...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720335","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Unfortunately, it's the workers...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Streams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","label":"Streams","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1251c61ea557a4ecb32fa2d0b0f09bb7bae628f934428c109f6c626673a0fdc8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a5884f61a5c34aa06760c51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720337,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"An October 2025 internal briefing note was recently obtained by the media. The FOI\n               revealed internal government documents that showed a secret, coordinated effort by\n               the B.C. NDP to stop a new Canadian pipeline project. These documents show that while this government was publicly dismissing a proposed\n               northern pipeline as fictional, staff were privately directed to mobilize opponents\n               to the project. Many of those opponents, I'm sure, are friends of many members of\n               the government benches. Can the minister confirm: is this government mobilizing staff to kill a pipeline while\n               at the same time telling the public that it doesn't exist?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720337","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"An October 2025 internal briefing note was recently obtained by the media. The FOI\n               revealed internal government documents that showed a secret, coordinated effort by\n               the B.C. NDP to stop a new Canadian pipeline project. These documents show that while this government was publicly dismissing a proposed\n               northern pipeline as fictional, staff were privately","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72af03ac9b57c886d7dc2954a453b4ed2a0f7197f1cd6ad4f78481ccfde854ca","f703fbd664c32ef5cd401deba97232d9f5dae8c9f04cd7c58acbb3e6a8187930"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d528035a6204a68468cce63460558c2d3d6d159d3081a2c88cd8e2ea99a642f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e7ccd322e08d25d916864b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721426,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. Bill M233 is about fair and open tendering on public sector projects to deliver results\n               for workers and the public and best value for taxpayers. Unfortunately, what we've\n               heard in the course of this debate from government members was some of the most disrespectful\n               commentary I've heard in this House towards workers and construction workers and leaders\n               in this province. All workers and construction skilled professionals deserve respect\n               and deserve a government that stands up for them, not simply the few that the NDP\n               government selects. Clearly, the members opposite didn't bother reading the bill. Nothing in this bill\n               precludes government from setting local hiring or apprenticeship targets. Instead,\n               we heard the smoke and mirrors of the NDP's version of restrictive CBAs. We heard\n               incorrect statements regarding progressive union workers and contractors I started out the debate explaining that I worked to advance the LNG industry in B.C.,\n               delivered through a managed open site construction model. Both the LNG plant and the\n               pipeline had a mix of building trades, progressive union and open shop contractors\n               and workers on site. The final 83 kilometres of pipeline for the LNG project, as an\n               example, was a success story, a B.C. success story, with a partnership between Ledcor\n               and Haisla First Nation, built with workers the NDP seems to disapprove of. If anyone is to suggest that this work was not done to the highest safety centres,\n               I can say that is categorically false. British Columbians and Canadians built this\n               section that is characterized by an ascent through the coast mountains to the highest\n               point nearly 1,500 metres above sea level down to Kitimat, including steep slopes\n               ranging all the way to 63 degrees. You have to have a strong safety focus with highly\n               trained skilled workers to accomplish a construction accomplishment like that. The point is that these skilled workers and all skilled workers deserve respect and\n               deserve to build the public infrastructure that their taxes pay for. Skilled workers,\n               no matter the affiliation, at the end of the day are just trying to support their\n               own families. We can't exclude 85 percent of construction workers. We also can't deliver\n               the projects that British Columbians need with the government's current path.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721426","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. Bill M233 is about fair and open tendering on public sector projects to deliver results\n               for workers and the public and best value for taxpayers. Unfortunately, what we've\n               heard in the course of this debate from government members was some of the most disrespectful\n               commentary I've heard in this House towards workers and construc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035796","label":"Incentives","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e8118a65d1a307083b82b9f724209534dceb6bad624cfa58da818ebc2445336","69f54f96c5643fed0d2bc0384d6c327e159750c6da7b2e341dd5bf9dec32525d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["891af91a5d11761f1348ed48fe94fe31773a93485e87870275c6a92335ba763a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f1284ad9a982a1e73e85d3a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721432,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery today, is a delegation from the great city of Prince George,\n               the northern capital. We've got a number of councillors with us, Councillor Susan\n               Scott, Councillors Garth Frizzell and Kyle Sampson, as well as City Manager Walter\n               Babich and Intergovernmental Relations Advisor Annie Doran. They're going to be meeting\n               with members on both sides of the House. I'd ask that the House give them a warm welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721432","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery today, is a delegation from the great city of Prince George,\n               the northern capital. We've got a number of councillors with us, Councillor Susan\n               Scott, Councillors Garth Frizzell and Kyle Sampson, as well as City Manager Walter\n               Babich and Intergovernmental Relations Advisor Annie Doran. They're going to be meeting\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Automobile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752432","label":"Automobile industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4dc575f843a621678f2e907bde52466ad3c4a4740ea76790898bed3dd42a10c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23451dab7e1075055f039b379dc9bb63fb3ad41e6282a0863534696b15fbfb24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9aeb887c5c1be760005cde90","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721434,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I know that they've been in the House already this week and they've been\n               introduced, but the intergovernmental affairs committee from the city of Prince George\n               is here again today. I want to sincerely thank every member of this House who has\n               met with them this week. They're doing important advocacy for the North. I hope that\n               some folks have come away with some more city of Prince George Mr. PG socks. Really,\n               I thank them for their time here this week. I also want to thank Coun. Cori Ramsay. Last night, UBCM held a reception. We've been\n               meeting with UBCM representatives. I know that Councillor Ramsay is not in the room,\n               but she's making the city of Prince George also very proud as the president of UBCM\n               this year. Will the House make them all, please, very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721434","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I know that they've been in the House already this week and they've been\n               introduced, but the intergovernmental affairs committee from the city of Prince George\n               is here again today. I want to sincerely thank every member of this House who has\n               met with them this week. They're doing important advocacy for the North. I hope that\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous reserves","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43901","label":"Indigenous reserves","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f81319d7c8255291e7241b0a225951e37df4a15ade88bca6fd44c3e4d568040e","a0da58886c78d9dc96588905701ce352cb97ca124fcbb677b270b3728e02d5ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["16833fe8b14dfe0cd1a6958d147ff96dd4249a3691271d89274172eedc67d6ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e6b87c566494a9b6b0bcee58","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721437,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I have listened intently to the arguments made from the members opposite, from the\n               government. I've listened intently to the arguments made from the critics on this\n               side of the House, from the very reasonable arguments put forward by the member for\n               Nechako Lakes and the member for Columbia River–Revelstoke. But I have to say that the comments from the member of Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream are deplorable. They were meant to incite hatred, and it has to be called out each\n               and every time. It's disrespectful for the people of the K'ómoks Nation, for all First Nations and for many minority cultures who have been I am going to take a different path. I'm going to return to order and decorum and\n               respectful dialogue on this bill, and I'm going to do that for the people in this\n               room today and for the people who are not in this room. I think that's important.\n               We owe them that. I want to begin by acknowledging the decades of work undertaken by the K'ómoks First Nation, their leadership and their community, to reach this point of discussion\n               we're at today. Treating negotiations, as we know, are not simple. They require persistence\n               across generations, leadership and difficult conversations within communities and\n               with governments. The work undertaken by K'ómoks reflects their commitment to governance, to economic participation and, indeed, to\n               reconciliation. That work deserves recognition in this House. I commend them for that\n               work. I want to acknowledge that on March 8, 2025, eligible voters of K'ómoks Nation approved the K'ómoks treaty with 81 percent voting in favour. I also want to acknowledge Chief Nicole\n               Rempel for her role as chief and for speaking to this House. I want to acknowledge\n               those that attended when Bill 20 was introduced, including the Elders and the young\n               people. I appreciated the cultural celebration of the day, as I know many other members\n               did. Treaties are a long and, most would say, winding road, and I know this particular\n               treaty has been the subject of many years of discussion in the region. I know the\n               previous Speaker had touched on that. The government's chosen way of bringing this\n               treaty into force is with this proposed bill before the Legislature. The government has called second reading debate only a week after bringing this in.\n               I will admit, as a legislator, I find that to be a challenge. I think there are flaws\n               in this process overall. I have a role as an official opposition MLA, and our role\n               is to scrutinize what has come before the House. To digest 30 years of work in this\n               short of a period is a problem. I do feel the need to state that for the record. I want to be clear at the outset, like my colleagues on this side of the House that\n               spoke before me, the members for Nechako Lakes and Columbia River–Revelstoke, I support treaties. I support treaties because they are the most appropriate and\n               durable way to define and finalize the relationship between First Nations, British\n               Columbia and Canada. I support treaties because they move First Nations out from under\n               the Indian Act, a piece of legislation that has imposed control, created dependency\n               and contributed to the suppression of Indigenous cultures and governance. I support treaties because Canadian courts have made it clear that reconciliation\n               is best achieved not through litigation but through negotiated agreements, something\n               that is reflected directly in the preamble of this legislation. Sometimes the courts\n               are necessary, but a treaty certainly presents another path. Supporting treaties does\n               not mean abandoning scrutiny in the duty of my role as the legislator in this House.\n               Supporting reconciliation does not mean ignoring legitimate concerns. And supporting\n               this process does not mean accepting that it has been carried out in the best possible\n               way. I'm going to go into a little bit of the details of B.C.'s treaty process over many,\n               many years now, because it's very unique to our province. It's very complex, and I\n               think it's important to put this bill in context. The treaty process over the many\n               decades has been the result of decisions made and decisions not made over that more\n               than a century now. Unlike many parts of Canada governed by the numbered treaties, most of British Columbia\n               entered Confederation without treaties covering the vast majority of its land. In\n               other regions, treaties were used, however imperfectly at the time, to facilitate\n               settlement and define relationships between the Crown and Indigenous peoples. In British Columbia, that didn't always occur. There were limited exceptions. Of course,\n               on Vancouver Island, Governor James Douglas negotiated the Douglas treaties between\n               1850 and 1854. These agreements, while brief and often contested in their interpretation,\n               recognized certain In British Columbia, that didn't always occur. There were limited exceptions, of course.\n               On Vancouver Island, Governor James Douglas negotiated the Douglas treaties between\n               1850 and 1854. These agreements, while brief and often contested in their interpretation,\n               recognized certain village sites and harvesting rights. But beyond those treaties, the Crown largely failed to, at the time, engage in treaty-making\n               across the province. Instead, first the colonial and later provincial governments\n               proceeded as though Indigenous title had been extinguished or did not exist at all.\n               I will acknowledge as a student of Canadian history that Indigenous nations never\n               did accept that particular position. So for decades, there were Indigenous leaders who traveled to Ottawa and even to London,\n               petitioning governments and asserting clearly that their lands needed more certainty.\n               In the course of my career, I've met some of those Indigenous leaders, and this was\n               and still has been an active and ongoing dispute. For some of that period, Indigenous\n               Peoples were even restricted from raising funds to pursue legal claims, limiting their\n               ability to challenge these assumptions in court. I think that history matters because it explains why British Columbia has entered the modern era with unresolved\n               questions of title across much of our province's area. There was a legal turning point, of course, in 1973 with the Calder versus British\n               Columbia decision. For the first time, the Supreme Court of Canada recognized that\n               Aboriginal title existed prior to colonization and continued unless lawfully extinguished.\n               While the case did not grant title in that instance, it fundamentally changed the\n               legal landscape. It forced governments to acknowledge that the foundation of land\n               ownership needed some more clarity added, and that's the process that we've been going\n               through. In the decades that followed, additional decisions reinforced that Indigenous rights\n               and title are constitutionally protected under section 35 of the Constitution Act\n               of 1982. But courts can only go so far. They can recognize rights and define legal principles,\n               but they can't build the detailed practical frameworks required for governance, land\n               use and economic development. And that's the role where.... Treaties are a mechanism\n               to uphold that. That brings us to the first major change in B.C.'s modern treaty era, coming with\n               the Nisg̱a'a final agreement, which came into effect in 2000. That agreement established\n               a framework for self-government, defined land-ownership and created mechanisms for\n               resource management and economic participation. It was not without its own concerns raised at that time and still an imperfect process, and concerns still remain to this day. But it has been in place for 26 years now, and\n               that is important as we enter into this discussion today. It demonstrated that negotiated\n               agreements could actually be possible, where litigation alone could not be the only other alternative. It is notable that the\n               Nisg̱a'a Treaty was negotiated outside the B.C. Treaty Commission process. I will\n               get into that. The B.C. Treaty Commission process was established in 1992 to facilitate negotiations\n               for these agreements. It was established as an independent body to facilitate negotiations\n               between First Nations, B.C. and Canada. The commission was intended to provide a structured, made-in-British-Columbia process, one that could move beyond litigation and towards\n               these negotiated agreements, grounded in mutual recognition and respect. The process\n               set out a clear pathway from statements of intent through to final agreements, with\n               the goal of achieving certainty and reconciliation through dialogue instead of conflict. But the existence of a process does not guarantee the outcome. Its success depends\n               on how it is carried out, on meaningful consultation, on addressing overlap between\n               nations and ensuring that agreements are durable and broadly supported. That's why\n               the reasonable concerns we've heard in the course of this debate have to be taken\n               seriously. If the process is not working as it was intended, it's our responsibility\n               to pause, to reflect and to ensure that it does. What we have learned over the past three decades in that treaty-making in British\n               Columbia is that it's not a linear process. It is complex, uneven and deeply dependent\n               on the circumstances of each nation and each community where they are situated. My own community knows that. In 2007, the Lheidli T'enneh First Nation rejected a\n               negotiated treaty in a ratification vote after years of work and again in a subsequent\n               vote, actually. Then there are other examples that have again fallen outside the treaty\n               commission process. In 2000, the McLeod Lake Then there are other examples that have fallen outside the treaty commission process.\n               In 2000, the McLeod Lake Indian Band adhered to Treaty 8 more than a century after\n               it was first signed. Treaty 8 covers a very big area in the northeast of the province,\n               and this is also in my constituency. These examples remind us that treaties take different\n               paths and can take different timelines. As I mentioned earlier, the courts have continued to shape this landscape as well.\n               In Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia , the Supreme Court of Canada recognized Aboriginal title to land for the first time.\n               It also reinforced a simple but important truth, that where treaties do not exist,\n               uncertainty also persists. So that's, again, a reason to try to move treaties forward\n               in the best way possible. It brings us directly to the issue before us today. Treaties are meant to provide\n               certainty. They are meant to provide that long-term, durable solution and not to perpetuate\n               the uncertainty that exists that we've heard from that Tŝilhqot'in case. That brings me to the items that have been raised in a respectful manner regarding\n               Bill 20. As MLAs, all in the House will know that we received a joint statement from\n               the Wei Wai Kum First Nation, the nine allied tribes and the Lax Kw'alaams band. Their message is supportive but also very cautionary. I think it's important\n               that members of this House all listen very carefully to it. They state: \"We support modern treaties and the inherent right of all First Nations\n               to self-government and self-determination within their territory. However, treaties\n               must be implemented in a manner that reflects Indigenous law, respects neighbouring\n               nations and upholds the honour of the Crown.\" I think this is obviously a very principled\n               position. It affirms treaties, but it also sets a clear expectation for how that work\n               must be done. Within the same letter, these nations go on to say, \"Before the Kitselas and K'ómoks treaties violate Indigenous law and claim territory in an overly broad\n               manner and with little or no legal or historical foundation. both treaties take overly\n               ambitious claim areas and turn them into treaty rights. Up to this point, provincial\n               negotiators have refused to engage in meaningful consultation and have refused to\n               require amendments to these treaties to adjust boundaries, require protocols in overlap\n               areas, as was done in the ɬəʔamɛn treaty, or include other mitigation measures.\" These are serious concerns. Obviously, 30 years of discussion, and these comments\n               have not been resolved. Again, this is a week after this has been introduced. It's\n               very difficult from a legal landscape to ascertain what to do here, but this is a\n               very legitimate comment about the integrity of the process. They are also pointing us to a very constructive path forward. Wei Wai Kum says the K'ómoks treaty claims nearly 80 percent of its traditional territory and has vowed legal action\n               if the treaty moves ahead as drafted. So that is not the certainty that we are trying\n               to get to that is needed with more legal action. The purpose of treaties is to create certainty, to avoid litigation and to establish\n               those stable, durable relationships. The ɬəʔamɛn final agreement included protocols to manage overlap and shared interests. I think\n               that tells us that these issues can be addressed when there is a willingness to do\n               so. The government has changed the mandates from the era of previous treaties signed\n               in the last 26 years, and I think that is something that as legislators, we have to\n               take note of. The question that has to be asked here is whether or not advancing treaty legislation\n               in the face of unresolved territorial and governance issues risks creating long-term\n               conflict and uncertainty. That is a very important issue that we all have to contend\n               with here. Reconciliation cannot be one-dimensional. I get it. It's very hard work. It cannot\n               be achieved by reaching agreement with one nation while creating conflict with another.\n               It cannot be achieved by asserting certainty where uncertainty remains. It cannot\n               be achieved by moving forward when those directly affect Bill 20 is not symbolic. It gives the treaty the force of law and makes it binding\n               on all persons. It transfers land ownership, alters forestry tenures, removes lands\n               from the ALR and, in some cases, limits compensation. These are permanent changes\n               with real consequences and very important ones. Again, I go back to the fact that we've had a week of this legislation before the\n               House, and now, after 30 years, we're rushing this process significantly without addressing\n               these concerns. That is precisely why I believe we must think this through, not to reject treaties\n               but to ensure that we get this right. Governments should be spending the time to properly\n               engage meaningfully with neighbouring First Nations who have raised legitimate concerns,\n               because if we don't resolve those concerns here, they won't disappear. They will move\n               to the courts. That is exactly what treaties are meant to avoid. I want to continue with the question of certainty, because that is ultimately what\n               we have been discussing significantly over the past couple of days. The preamble to\n               Bill 20 states: \"and whereas the K'ómoks treaty advances the objectives of the United Nations declaration on the rights of\n               Indigenous Peoples.\" That language is obviously aligned with what the government has brought forward in\n               DRIPA legislation, which, at that time, they said was aspirational, but as we have\n               learned now, today, it also raises serious and unresolved legal questions that we\n               need answered and need resolution to. We have seen, in recent months, that the application of the Declaration on the Rights\n               of Indigenous Peoples Act has created uncertainty — uncertainty significant enough\n               that this very government has been forced to revisit, reconsider and, at some points,\n               has said they want to attempt to amend their own approach, but we don't know exactly\n               what the plan is, going forward, because it hasn't been presented to the House yet.\n               It may come in the fall, but we're not sure. That tells us something important. The legal framework surrounding UNDRIP is still\n               evolving, still being interpreted and still being tested. It's important to note that\n               Indigenous rights are already protected in the constitution. That is the highest law\n               of the land, and it is very, very important that those rights have that protection\n               enforced there. At the same time, this legislation embeds the principles of UNDRIP that will carry,\n               despite the fact that we have constitutionally protected rights.... Those cannot be\n               amended, but the laws we have here can be amended. UNDRIP is, here, written into the\n               treaty itself, not just the Bill 20 reference we see. We have heard from legal experts who warned that this model does not eliminate uncertainty.\n               We hear some of the legal opinions. We've heard some read into the record already\n               in the course of this debate. But I will just read one comment that was noteworthy\n               from some legal experts — Joan M. Young, Radha Kurpan, Robin M. Younger, Sasa Jarvis,\n               Tom Theodorakis, David Burchart, Corey Kent — who wrote in a bulletin: \"UNDRIP appears to have influenced the language used in the new treaty agreements.\n               As a result, and in contrast to other modern-era treaties, the new treaty agreements\n               do not appear to provide the certainty found in prior modern-era treaty agreements.\" This particular comment, reference, was in relation to private property questions,\n               comparisons to the decisions in the Quw'utsun and Gitxaała court cases and questions about the effect this may be having on existing treaties\n               as well. This is something that we do have to pause on. I don't know the answer. Again, I've\n               only had a week to digest this, which is a lot to take in. A statute can be amended\n               by future governments. A treaty is much more difficult, and I don't know if this is\n               locking in uncertainty for generations. The government needs to explain this very\n               clearly. We've heard from neighbouring First Nations who are telling us clearly that unresolved\n               issues, if left unaddressed, will not disappear but instead will move to the courts.\n               That is not what treaties are meant to do. Treaties, as we've heard from all members\n               so far who've spoken for the most part, are meant to resolve conflict. They're meant\n               to provide clarity, and they're meant to build durable relationships. And I think\n               we actually agree on those principles. That's why this moment matters. It was the government's decision, I believe, to, I\n               would surmise, change the treaty mandate to include the UNDRIP language to not resolve\n               these territorial challenges that are still included here. But once this legislation\n               passes, this will all be very difficult to change course. So the question before us\n               is not whether we support treaties. I certainly do. The question before us is whether\n               we are prepared to ensure that this treaty and this model is right before we make\n               it permanent. I am requesting that the government actually responds to these specific issues. Obviously,\n               the language around reconciliation matters. I want to hear some of that, but I also\n               want the answers to these specific challenges to this legislation before the House.\n               Why didn't the government engage meaningfully enough with neighbouring First Nations?\n               Because that's what we're hearing from them as legislators, and we have to take that\n               at face value. How is the government planning to ensure that the legal framework we are embedding\n               will actually deliver certainty? Again, legal experts are telling us that they don't\n               believe it is right now. I get that this has been a long process, but this is the hard work of real reconciliation.\n               Is this government actually doing that hard work or are they just saying the things\n               that are easy in this process? We can't just say the easy things. It's about getting\n               it right and leaving behind agreements that will stand the test of time. The K'ómoks Nation deserves that, and so do the rest of British Columbians. Again, I support treaty. I want to vote in favour of the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I sincerely do. I support moving beyond the Indian Act. I support reconciliation\n               grounded in negotiated agreements. But reconciliation must be done properly. It must\n               respect all affected nations, and it must provide the certainty that British Columbians\n               desperately need. I think the government could show some more leadership. So this is about meeting the moment and taking a hard look at the legislation before\n               this House today. Let's make sure that we actually get this right for the K'ómoks First Nation, for the people on Vancouver Island, for the people across British Columbia,\n               as this is precedent-setting, and we need to make sure that that moment is that leadership\n               that British Columbians expect. Thank you for the time. I look forward to hearing from other members in this debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721437","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I have listened intently to the arguments made from the members opposite, from the\n               government. I've listened intently to the arguments made from the critics on this\n               side of the House, from the very reasonable arguments put forward by the member for\n               Nechako Lakes and the member fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36e8c02215b66ddb30dc46cefcb0edeb8f5d48ef204cf0ed69036847c7cb0ffd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["290397cba54d1c4fe3cc5282e08694db8914390aad5f25b2b524701518b6368c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-deec7ed1877b293ef8546973","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729114,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak to Motion M205. What we're hearing is a lot\n               of defensive comments from the members opposite, but what this topic really comes\n               down to is simply common sense. It's important for all of us as MLAs to understand the consequences of our decisions\n               on the economy and the financial position of the province. In the course of our work\n               as legislators, we're asked to make decisions on taxes, spending and debt that affect\n               every household in this province, so it's not unreasonable to expect that we understand\n               the basics before we vote. Last year, as a member of the Public Accounts Committee, I asked the Auditor General a simple question. I asked if we have ever seen debt in British Columbia rising this\n               fast compared to our economy or our revenue, and the answer was no. There is no historical\n               comparison. And that was last year; this year we're on track for the same thing. We've seen multiple\n               credit rating downgrades. S&P said B.C.'s fiscal trajectory means: \"the province's debt burden is also rising at\n               a fast pace, placing it on a per operating revenue basis at 255 percent. This is among the highest for Canadian provinces by fiscal 2029.\"\n               They went on to say that budgetary imbalances are expected to remain among the highest\n               of all rated non-U.S. local and regional governments beyond the outlook horizon. We are in new territory and that makes it even more important that we get the fundamentals\n               right. The basics of financial literacy are important because the basic principle\n               here is something that every family household deals with, managing their own finances. If your debt grows faster than your income, eventually something\n               has to give. A deficit is, put simply, a bill; it just hasn't come due yet. Or put another way,\n               a deficit is just a tax increase with a delay. And who pays for that delay? It will\n               be our kids trying to buy their first home. It will be our grandkids dealing with\n               higher taxes or fewer public services. It will be the next generation inheriting less\n               room to build, less room to invest and fewer choices. MLAs don't need to be economists, but we should have a basic understanding of how\n               debt works, how costs add up and what our decisions mean over time. We should understand\n               how businesses need to make payroll, and when payroll taxes increase — or when the regulatory burden increases — it has\n               an impact on a small business's ability to hire or increase wages. We're seeing that\n               with higher youth unemployment now, and we need an understanding of how that has been\n               the case. We've had the lowest private sector job creation in the country over the last number of years, and we can't have that to grow our\n               economy, to pay for the public services that the public depends on. Because when government\n               gets the economics wrong, there are consequences for British Columbia's families —\n               working families. This motion to give MLAs a better understanding of financial and economic literacy\n               is a modest, practical and commonsense step to make this place work better. If we're making decisions that our kids and\n               our grandkids will pay for, the least we can do is understand what we are doing. Thank you for the time to speak. I want to thank the member from Kelowna-Mission for bringing this motion forward and look forward to hearing more of the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729114","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak to Motion M205. What we're hearing is a lot\n               of defensive comments from the members opposite, but what this topic really comes\n               down to is simply common sense. It's important for all of us as MLAs to understand the consequences of our decisions\n               on the economy and the financial position of the province. In the course ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["14c58331cdbcefcad0837d3d385b2d67e48bb163ddd23a6a3f326b84e0b410cb","c9e128e7aa425967b9e8a6e3a2a10795c8ace6c72ebf865e557d1f707dc9c4a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9be575e8ca61feebd554ddf3dd7a9458e6039cdefa57f49af6b1fbcf146209ca"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d74b03e5da0a0b3128c6e0c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729119,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce a special guest today. The Leader of the Official Opposition's\n               mother is here, Patti Halford. I'd also like to introduce his aunt, Judy MacKenzie.\n               They're here to surprise the Leader of the Official Opposition, because today is his\n               birthday, so they're here to take him for lunch in the dining room.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729119","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce a special guest today. The Leader of the Official Opposition's\n               mother is here, Patti Halford. I'd also like to introduce his aunt, Judy MacKenzie.\n               They're here to surprise the Leader of the Official Opposition, because today is his\n               birthday, so they're here to take him for lunch in the dining room.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd89ca8d1d5be837f15fa7a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752241,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752241","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f641572130a45e58fc51d99974528042efed0d57e4766d67e7ce6dbddefd8f93"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a246a5c54e37b2306356e61a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752242,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government's attempt to update the Heritage Conservation Act needs to be abandoned.\n               Co-government, co-management, co-chaos. Union of B.C. Municipalities","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752242","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This government's attempt to update the Heritage Conservation Act needs to be abandoned.\n               Co-government, co-management, co-chaos. Union of B.C. Municipalities","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","label":"Rail companies","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1bd924c65ec41e7fa7fa3095c2737981604461a83034c4b35c1cd4f93e6f6adc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30abaffe4503ed88a76c3409","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752243,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752243","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af37a9b08e09ca4e45a2034e85a577ba305f8001085abe1a032a9123bfa941a2","626975ca950305e901e4a82f87238ba3d3419e123cb8d90935705b3d3e432251","afda3c0bca5db48adfd8a3c1bfd1886f7c535f098da1859420ab9094f747229a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-774bac79826812b89517dd43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017343,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize and celebrate the 60th anniversary of the district of Mackenzie,\n               a proud northern community built on hard work, resilience and resource development. In 1964, the world's largest tree crusher arrived on six railcars and was used to\n               clear the flooded plain of the Rocky Mountain Trench. Clearing of the land began during\n               a time of enormous change in our province, with the construction of the W.A.C. Bennett\n               dam. Flooding for the dam created the spectacular Williston Lake, now the largest freshwater\n               body of water in B.C. and one of the largest man-made reservoirs in North America. Mackenzie's story is stitched into this part of B.C. history as it was established Mackenzie's story is stitched into this part of B.C. history, as it was established\n               as an instant town to support British Columbia's fast-growing forest industry. British\n               Columbia Forest Products built a pulp mill and two sawmills to help develop the vast\n               resources in the area, and in June of 1966, the first families arrived to begin building\n               a new community from the ground up. Named after explorer Sir Alexander McKenzie, McKenzie\n               was officially incorporated on May 19, 1966, exactly 60 years ago from today. This past weekend I had the opportunity to join many residents, past and present,\n               in celebrating this milestone anniversary, from the welcome barbecue night at the\n               legion to Kraft Hockeyville events, the museum's walk-down-memory-lane photo displays,\n               the community dance and pancake breakfast. It was incredible to see so many people\n               come together to celebrate the history and spirit of Mackenzie. Former residents travelled\n               from near and far to reconnect with old friends, share memories and celebrate a community\n               that has meant so much to so many families over the last 60 years. Mackenzie has faced challenges that many resource communities know all too well, but\n               its people have always met those challenges with determination, pride and a strong\n               sense of community. I ask all members of this House to join me in congratulating the\n               district of Mackenzie on its 60th anniversary and wishing the community continuing\n               success for many generations to come.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017343","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize and celebrate the 60th anniversary of the district of Mackenzie,\n               a proud northern community built on hard work, resilience and resource development. In 1964, the world's largest tree crusher arrived on six railcars and was used to\n               clear the flooded plain of the Rocky Mountain Trench. Clearing of the land began during\n               a time of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","label":"Dams","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["718eac16ee50974d81126795ad8bf9db44c4b3d807f24202c387720102fafb11","f0bb25d63d37ec42bdae070cfc72b29b2ee63f9435ea24a3878c6d33537b41b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["78a362856e8bae2323a573a1c1b5042ba5dc513621ddec0ff0051e93816d11da"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Dams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64115","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaf52ab33eb52bf231001074","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017345,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, what we're hearing is just more uncertainty from this government. When investors\n               look at B.C., they want certainty. They want to know that projects can move forward,\n               and they want to know that they can move forward safely. Even that basic requirement\n               is questionable under this government. In 2022, a worksite on the Coastal GasLink pipeline was attacked by a group of masked, axe-wielding assailants. Workers on site\n               were terrorized. Anarchists purposely spread fear to try to shut the project down.\n               It caused tens of millions of dollars in damage and major delays. Shockingly, not\n               a single arrest has ever been made. To the Solicitor General, how can investors have the confidence to invest in British\n               Columbia if this government can't uphold the law and keep people and assets safe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017345","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, what we're hearing is just more uncertainty from this government. When investors\n               look at B.C., they want certainty. They want to know that projects can move forward,\n               and they want to know that they can move forward safely. Even that basic requirement\n               is questionable under this government. In 2022, a worksite on the Coastal GasLink pipeline was att","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Terrorism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501258","label":"Terrorism","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce7b2ddd142b21a2fdb713bb4d21fb60c9ec8d9db8ac7475a36881f6a12d7074"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["121e189ad13dc241629a8458dbe55df73330f7cba11d75e0db0f66602278246f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-149bbbf5ff49a29d07346dc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036482,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak about an important community health care service in Prince George.\n               The Emergency Dental Outreach Clinic — operated by the Prince George Native Friendship\n               Centre, in partnership with the Prince George and District Dental Society and Northern\n               Health — provides essential dental care to vulnerable residents in our community.\n               Led by Dr. Richard Wilczek and supported by volunteer dentists, hygienists and community\n               partners, this clinic helps people who would otherwise have nowhere else to turn for\n               urgent dental care. This clinic is an important training partnership with the College of New Caledonia.\n               Dental hygiene and dental assistant students provide hours of service, while gaining\n               valuable firsthand clinical experience working alongside community dentists and serving\n               vulnerable patients. Unfortunately, this service for low-income individuals is now\n               at risk of closing because of the government's shortsighted decision to eliminate\n               funding for not-for-profit dental clinics across B.C. The need for these services is actually growing, not shrinking. Across the province,\n               the number of not-for-profit dental clinics increased from 19 in 2021 to 25 last year.\n               In the last year alone, these clinics provided more than 53,000 patient appointments\n               to over 24,000 individuals, with nearly one-third of those patients living in rural\n               and remote communities. Yet despite this growing need, every one of these clinics\n               now has had their provincial funding pulled. In my community of Prince George, the Emergency Dental Outreach Clinic serves approximately\n               15 patients each and every week during a three-hour clinic session. Over the past\n               year, the clinic supported 223 clients, performing 331 extractions, and delivered\n               more than $85,000 worth of essential dental care services. All of this was achieved\n               with just $25,000 in annual provincial grant funding. That is an incredible return\n               on investment for the province. This is preventative health care service before patients need to seek higher levels\n               of medical attention in our health care system. The grant has paid the hours of work\n               for the coordinator of the program and is important for the clinic to operate even\n               at this modest amount. For many individuals experiencing poverty, homelessness and\n               other barriers to care, this clinic is their only option. The location is accessible\n               and connected to an organization that serves many of these individuals in other ways. Historically, the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction has supported\n               B.C.'s not-for-profit dental clinics by providing year-end grants to the B.C. Dental\n               Association, which had then disbursed the funds to local clinics. The ministry wrote\n               to the Dental Association on March 9 of this year, and the funding was not Historically, the Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction has supported\n               B.C.'s not-for-profit dental clinics by providing year-end grants to the B.C. Dental\n               Association, who would then disburse the funds to local clinics. The ministry wrote\n               to the Dental Association on March 9 of this year, and the funding was not renewed\n               for the fiscal year-end only weeks later. The ministry cited the expansion of the Canadian dental care plan, but this neglected\n               the fact that too many of the most vulnerable patients still fall through the cracks\n               with this federal program. Many cannot afford the upfront cost and still face too\n               many barriers to access. Without preventative and urgent dental care, people are often left suffering until\n               they end up in already overcrowded emergency rooms. In fact, low-income adults in\n               British Columbia are six times more likely to visit emergency rooms for dental issues\n               than other residents. Cutting modest funding for preventative community dental care will not eliminate the\n               need. It simply shifts costs onto other emergency departments and further strains\n               an already overburdened health care system. That's why I believe that supporting community-based\n               dental care is both compassionate and also fiscally responsible. According to the B.C. Dental Association, emergency departments cannot provide definitive\n               dental treatment. They manage pain, prescribe antibiotics and then discharge patients\n               often only to have them return when infection or pain worsens. If just 5 percent of\n               the 53,000 appointments delivered by not-for-profit clinics in 2025 had instead resulted\n               in emergency room visits, the cost would have been approximately $672,000 in hospital\n               triage costs and roughly 900 hours of ER physician time. That is physician time we\n               cannot afford to lose in a system already facing critical shortages. I've had the opportunity to meet with Barb Ward-Burkitt, executive director from the\n               Prince George Native Friendship Centre, as well as Nicole King-Smith, their director\n               of health. I want to thank them for their work. I've also met with Dr. Wilczek and\n               want to thank all of the volunteer dentists, hygienists and those who support patients\n               in Prince George. Lastly, I want to thank Quinn Mathiesen-Newcomb from the B.C. Dental\n               Association for meeting and for the important provincewide advocacy that they have\n               done on this file. I urge the minister to reconsider this decision and work with not-for-profit dental\n               clinics across British Columbia to ensure these essential services remain available\n               to the people who need them most. I would also invite the minister to meet with the\n               Prince George Native Friendship Centre to learn more.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036482","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak about an important community health care service in Prince George.\n               The Emergency Dental Outreach Clinic — operated by the Prince George Native Friendship\n               Centre, in partnership with the Prince George and District Dental Society and Northern\n               Health — provides essential dental care to vulnerable residents in our community.\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dental insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","label":"Oral health","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42643","label":"Dental insurance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd53c60b62ae7f875700cc520d4047a5193efaaea240d604078decd1d23f9820"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["079b1e1b2a96d96486e6f2a5f36ba4337e04ab3dd152ea4ae815e07419272ab5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Oral health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036549","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fefc7704ff3729c3ebd8c2d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036483,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"British Columbians have seen five credit rating downgrades in the past four years.\n               Taxpayer-supported debt will increase to nearly $200 billion by the end of the fiscal\n               plan. It was less than $45 billion when this government took office. This government doesn't have a revenue problem; it has a spending problem. British\n               Columbians know the truth. The NDP government has created this crisis through reckless\n               spending and zero discipline. Will the minister admit that government has completely lost control of B.C.'s finances?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036483","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"British Columbians have seen five credit rating downgrades in the past four years.\n               Taxpayer-supported debt will increase to nearly $200 billion by the end of the fiscal\n               plan. It was less than $45 billion when this government took office. This government doesn't have a revenue problem; it has a spending problem. British\n               Columbians know the truth. The NDP","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a2a3e5fb0f4be662499c70ffb218b3ae962b1556b224266a214eb58d235af56"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["40b0427a409aa4187a4e7cc9e1d59b039ac50e4c4a558d88dc3c4230d1fb7f3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d45e45a2334f93590cd7775f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036484,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the Finance critic for allowing me to enter the debate in the Ministry\n               of Finance estimates to ask a brief question. I want to ask a question about data centres in the province and how B.C. Assessment\n               treats data centres. The ministry staff may recall that during UBCM last year, the\n               district of Mackenzie met with staff from both B.C. Assessment and from the Ministry\n               of Finance to seek a change in how data centres are classified within B.C. Assessment's\n               classifications. Last week at NCLGA, they passed a resolution on this, and I'll just read the resolution\n               into the record. \"Therefore, be it resolved that NCLGA and UBCM request the province\n               of British Columbia and B.C. Assessment include high-energy digital infrastructure,\n               including, but not limited to, AI compute centres, high-performance computing data\n               centres and bitcoin and cryptocurrency mining facilities in utilities or class 5 light\n               industry.\" The reason this is important, that the district, Mackenzie, has been bringing this\n               forward.... They actually have a bitcoin operation within the district's boundaries.\n               They have ambitions and will be converting much of that to AI computing as well. They\n               have no problem with that. I think there is broad support in the community. It's been\n               a very good corporate partner that is there. The issue is that the classification for assessment is class 6, which is used for\n               office, retail, hotels and warehousing. There was a significant amount of power used,\n               obviously, with this facility. We're basically taxing, at the same rate that we're\n               taxing a coffee shop in Mackenzie, a data centre that is taking up power that could\n               be used for other industrial purposes and other, higher-value tax classifications. I was wondering if the ministry has any update from B.C. Assessment on that request\n               from the district of Mackenzie and if the ministry has a position on this. If not,\n               would they consider taking this forward to review at this time?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036484","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the Finance critic for allowing me to enter the debate in the Ministry\n               of Finance estimates to ask a brief question. I want to ask a question about data centres in the province and how B.C. Assessment\n               treats data centres. The ministry staff may recall that during UBCM last year, the\n               district of Mackenzie met with staff from both B.C. Assess","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["85a9a1d66aec4db061b802ec7452a95802d1de79b47d9ffc4a71c6ae001599b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1b313d7ece615bae18631470bde939ec0960a11d5b58d3bbfcbe2b9dededd224"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9018449a4cde45207bb33ce","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036486,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kiel Giddens","venue":"Hansard","text":"There are many graduations happening across the province in the next month here, but\n               tomorrow will be the UNBC convocation, where I'll be proud to witness hundreds of\n               students cross the stage. Among them will be one of my constituency advisors, Isabelle\n               Saunders. I want to wish her congratulations on graduating from UNBC. Congrats, Izzy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036486","member_id":"bc-mla-391","member_name":"Kiel Giddens","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There are many graduations happening across the province in the next month here, but\n               tomorrow will be the UNBC convocation, where I'll be proud to witness hundreds of\n               students cross the stage. Among them will be one of my constituency advisors, Isabelle\n               Saunders. I want to wish her congratulations on graduating from UNBC. Congrats, Izzy.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Royalties","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Monarchy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035849","label":"Industrial products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","label":"Monarchy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47808","label":"Royalties","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3943a66740fc56e1dae03c73206591b2839c7bbbbcab0585f7d9b4b0d44a809c","aa16e5bd2ffe1a4c0fb48fb3c3f323d36cebf59dae3e71cc50e4cd56f9772b26"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["409b173a91e1a7752b6ccde72ebc57e8a09ed448f3303774671dd79934270f56"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-483cae734d19bf3969079aac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316829,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in favour of Bill M231, the Veterans and First Responders Month Act,\n               put forth by my colleague the member for Prince George–Valemount, herself a distinguished veteran of our Royal Canadian Navy. Among our communities, there are a humble few who have volunteered to sign an unlimited\n               liability clause or to otherwise put themselves in danger for the security and safety\n               of us all. Our military veterans, our police, firefighters, ambulance paramedics,\n               search and rescue personnel, emergency dispatchers and others, many of whom are present\n               here today, both in the gallery and in this House, have done just that. Whether regular or reserve, paid professional or dedicated volunteer, all of them\n               have more than earned our respect, admiration and commemoration, which would be demonstrated\n               well through naming November Veterans and First Responders Month. This commemoration fits well with those acknowledgements of Remembrance Day and Veterans\n               Week. It is my hope that all provinces would follow our lead in recognizing those\n               who run to danger and their risks and sacrifices in so doing. For these reasons, I support Bill M231, and I encourage and thank the rest of the\n               House for doing the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316829","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise to speak in favour of Bill M231, the Veterans and First Responders Month Act,\n               put forth by my colleague the member for Prince George–Valemount, herself a distinguished veteran of our Royal Canadian Navy. Among our communities, there are a humble few who have volunteered to sign an unlimited\n               liability clause or to otherwise put themselves in danger for the secur","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63ee290d817fe66ce93c409532a418f11704d19550512608fca7938ef1fc848b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2099b1853121487032726a2f06947b3582fd11fb08f972b6507b32a73548e330"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-89e23f70f6e876de0a8cc4da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316830,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Point of order, Madam Speaker. I believe the member characterized this, our government.... That is simply not true,\n               and I think that that needs to be looked at very carefully. This party has not been\n               in government for nearly 100 years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316830","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Point of order, Madam Speaker. I believe the member characterized this, our government.... That is simply not true,\n               and I think that that needs to be looked at very carefully. This party has not been\n               in government for nearly 100 years.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a35f0e4b702244729c903a7a80dc088f48e83cf8c8960998eb3bffd69a17e05"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b81265541808ae42c8e436db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327942,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to wish my daughter Elise a very happy 23rd birthday, which she just\n               recently celebrated. Love you, sweetie. All the very best. I hope the House will join me in wishing her many happy returns.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327942","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to wish my daughter Elise a very happy 23rd birthday, which she just\n               recently celebrated. Love you, sweetie. All the very best. I hope the House will join me in wishing her many happy returns.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3793f2d2641554abe671ea3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327943,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and many happy returns. I rise today to acknowledge and thank the dedicated members of the Quesnel community\n               support round table. Last year my office brought this round table together to unite\n               the many organizations and individuals in Quesnel who work tirelessly to support those\n               who are often unheard, unhoused and unfed. By strengthening communication and collaboration, this group has enhanced coordination\n               of care and support for some of the most vulnerable members of our community. One\n               powerful example of this cooperation is the community meal initiative, hosted each\n               Monday at Northstar Church. Since its launch at the end of January, the initiative has served an average 180 meals\n               every week. Just as importantly, it has created a welcoming space of connection and\n               belonging for those living in isolation. The Quesnel community support round table includes the city of Quesnel, the Cariboo\n               regional district, the Quesnel Shelter and Support Society, Canadian Mental Health\n               Association Northern B.C., the Nourish food bank, Green Hope society, the Quesnel\n               Women's Resource Centre, Amata Transition House Society, the Elizabeth Fry Society,\n               Foundry Quesnel, Northstar Church, St. John the Divine Anglican Church, Two Rivers\n               Church and many passionate individuals who give their time and energy to help others. The challenges facing our communities are significant. One in eight British Columbians\n               lives below the poverty line. Food bank use has surged 79 percent since 2019. In Quesnel,\n               the homeless count has risen to 131 in 2025. In Williams Lake, it has increased 96\n               percent since 2020. Compared to the previous decade, intimate partner violence has risen sharply — up\n               32 percent among adults aged 25 to 64, 42 percent among seniors. Intimate partner\n               sexual assault is 163 percent higher. Paramedics have responded to 256 overdose and\n               poisoning calls in a single day. It's important that this House recognizes those who are filling these gaps, offering\n               compassion and helping people when and where most needed. Thank you to the members\n               of the Quesnel community support round table for your leadership and dedication. I\n               look forward to continuing our work on these essential efforts.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327943","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and many happy returns. I rise today to acknowledge and thank the dedicated members of the Quesnel community\n               support round table. Last year my office brought this round table together to unite\n               the many organizations and individuals in Quesnel who work tirelessly to support those\n               who are often unheard, unhoused and unfed. By stren","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36712a33b733f09971be53f8926371e90ec87e54e45c5fbd87c0fe81cd8190ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7b64195da42546745b67126a82724393bff78bd3b64c73e1af5143bf68a9526"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a08da524a4ec17c4034836dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359661,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to support the motion from the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine, M201, on water. On Tuesday, February 3, I was pleased to attend the Hixon Community\n               Hall for a meeting about exactly this topic. Water is essential to life. It's essential to many things. We use it for recreation.\n               We use it for watering crops. We use it for producing power. We take it for granted.\n               This House is resplendent with water. We use it all the time. We see the water coming\n               as rapidly as we would expect or need it. But in some communities, that is not reality. In Hixon, in my riding, before 2003,\n               a water supply system only needed an emergency response plan in case of water contamination\n               for legal operation. Water providers were not responsible for the quality of the water. In 2003, the Drinking Water Protection Act and drinking water protection regulations\n               were published, and in 2016, groundwater protection regulations were added. These\n               acts said that the water system operator is legally responsible for operating the\n               water system and the water quality. They talked about well construction, maintenance,\n               treatment, amount of water distributed and so on. The penalties for non-compliance\n               with those regulations are a fine up to $200,000 and 12 months of jail time. In 2025, Northern Health started the process of inspecting water suppliers in Hixon,\n               and they are still in the process of evaluating the water systems. Now, the Hixon\n               Community Hall used to supply water to approximately 100 to 125 families, nearly half\n               the population of Hixon. People would come, they would fill up at the tap at the hall,\n               and they would take the water away. Well, unfortunately, for legal operation, the Hixon Community Hall water system needs\n               from Northern Health a construction permit, an operating permit, and it has to satisfy\n               the Drinking Water Protection Act, the drinking water protection regulations and the\n               groundwater protection regulations. And that system no longer meets the legal requirements\n               to be an approved and legal water supplier for the community. What does that mean? That means that people needing water have to find another source.\n               That means they have to haul water. Some people are hauling 10,000 to 15,000 litres\n               per load of water, costing as much as $750 to $1,000 a load to move water every month. It's something many of us take for granted by paying our city utilities and dealing\n               with that, just water out of the tap. That's not the reality for many people. This\n               is a real problem in rural British Columbia for real people, and it affects their\n               lives. I heard it loud and clear from the people of Hixon that they need water and\n               they need it now. But that's not the only issue with water in my riding. We also have a severe problem\n               with water in lakes and rivers and streams being polluted. I think, for example, of\n               Bouchie Lake, in my riding, which has suffered from a great deal of pollution over\n               a long period of time. It's pollution that has come from no ill intent. It's just\n               the practices of agriculture, fertilizer, recreational use, sewage and all sorts of\n               other things that have gradually worked their way down the water table to be deposited\n               in the lake. What is happening is that lake is in jeopardy. The lake is dying, and\n               the people there are at a loss for how to solve that problem. When we start thinking about water, we need to take a macro approach as well as a\n               micro approach and understand that it is essential to life, it is essential to everything\n               we do and it is essential for the success of mankind — people-kind, if you like the\n               use of a term that was popular a few years ago in another group. I see my colleague\n               on the other side having a grin at that. I share the humour. I just want to emphasize that my colleague from Bulkley Valley–Stikine has brought forth a very important motion. I'm glad to hear that it is getting broad\n               support from all parties, and I want to support it as well. Noting the hour, Mr. Speaker, I move adjournment of the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359661","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to support the motion from the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine, M201, on water. On Tuesday, February 3, I was pleased to attend the Hixon Community\n               Hall for a meeting about exactly this topic. Water is essential to life. It's essential to many things. We use it for recreation.\n               We use it for watering crops. We use it for producing power. We take it for g","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a379d81db227f9c56516cba0b5b050f625c8f67c02e5503eac11a9050b6104b7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ab09e6a6657d16bab970f526fba8c06aa979832d1e41b85baa80ed6be476ab6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f46cad0ddd3b66882181e531","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187132,"date":"2026-03-09T12:00:00+00:00","title":"INSURANCE (VEHICLE) AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m237-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m237-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187132","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c0e7822cc5795d7958f9c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359662,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"This NDP government is out of touch with the businesses that keep our economy running.\n               Small businesses are being boarded up throughout Prince George–North Cariboo, and the ones that remain are now facing a 7 percent hike for security. When is someone\n               from this NDP government going to come to my riding, look business owners in the eye\n               and defend their business-killing budget?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359662","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This NDP government is out of touch with the businesses that keep our economy running.\n               Small businesses are being boarded up throughout Prince George–North Cariboo, and the ones that remain are now facing a 7 percent hike for security. When is someone\n               from this NDP government going to come to my riding, look business owners in the eye\n               and defend their b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f46d3c28d3c61d8198d69bace8a470d42a176cbcaff515dc05c9c7537e45a794"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["797405d45a01faa65be8ee398479ed5727dea58089b956ae6f266b48b1611488"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c39df72d7a6e44ff197d737","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415701,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to the critical importance of value-added manufacturing within\n               British Columbia's forestry sector, an opportunity that allows us to maximize the\n               full economic benefits of this foundational industry. Over the past few weeks, I've had the opportunity","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415701","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to the critical importance of value-added manufacturing within\n               British Columbia's forestry sector, an opportunity that allows us to maximize the\n               full economic benefits of this foundational industry. Over the past few weeks, I've had the opportunity","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55a4a41a48a7eefa4a505031cf154e87c6680069738ce0cdac99a614bb5ffca1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd7be57245e608b5907effd8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415702,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Bill 13 — Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act. Well, I rise today to speak\n               about some aspects of this bill that give me some concern, regarding the conflict\n               between fundamentally protected rights that this bill seeks to address. Clause 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms \"guarantees the rights and\n               freedoms set out in it subject to such reasonable limits in law that are justifiable\n               in a free and democratic society.\" Well, what are those conflicting rights and freedoms? Well, in the Charter, we have section 7, under \"Legal Rights.\" This is section 7,\n               and I quote: \"Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of the person,\n               and the right not to be deprived thereof, except in accordance with the principles\n               of fundamental justice.\" Section 8: \"Everyone has the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure.\" Section 9: \"Everyone has the right not to be arbitrarily detained or imprisoned.\" Now, that's an important set of fundamental freedoms that we have in our constitution.\n               I think that that's a pretty good basis to have a look at this. But there are other\n               things too like the freedom to worship. My colleagues have talked about this on both\n               sides of the House and how important that is, regardless of what your religion is. That is section 2. Everyone has the following fundamental freedoms, and I quote: \"(a)\n               freedom of conscience and religion; (b) freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression,\n               including freedom of the press and other media of communication; (c) freedom of peaceful\n               assembly; and (d) freedom of association.\" These are fundamental principles that we\n               have. What we have here is a problem that has at its essence, a conflict between fundamental\n               freedoms. Now, there is another problem, and I'll talk about this a little bit more as well.\n               But there is another problem here. When we look at our distribution of legislative\n               powers in the Constitution Act, 1982, as amended to the present day, including the\n               Charter of Rights and Freedoms, section 91 has a very interesting preamble, which\n               I think we need to be reminded of in the provincial legislature. I also want to look at a piece of Section 92 in relation to this bill. Section 91 says: That is to say, and I want to draw your attention to section 27. Section 27 is the\n               criminal law, except the constitution of courts of criminal jurisdiction, but including\n               the procedure in criminal matters. So the criminal law is in the purview of Canada\n               — the state, the federal government. Now, in these powers, we also have section 92, the provincial power. Section 92 says\n               in it, and I quote: \"In each province, the legislature may exclusively make laws in\n               relation to matters coming within the classes of subject next in here and after enumerating.\" That is to say, and I would draw to your attention Section 15: \"the imposition of\n               punishment by fine, penalty or imprisonment for enforcing any law of the province\n               made in relation to any matter coming within any of the classes of subjects enumerated\n               in this section When I read those sections — and I could do that, but it wouldn't be of much use —\n               I don't really see a section in this particular part of the Constitution Act that\n               is directly relevant to the purpose of Bill 13. That gives me some concern, as a legislator. I think we are all aware, in this House,\n               but it is worth stating that the main purpose of law is to change behaviour which\n               society finds abhorrent. It is pretty clear to all of us that behaviour blocking people\n               from places of worship and limiting their ability to worship freely is an abhorrent\n               behaviour. The question in my mind is: whose role is it to make laws about that behaviour? Well,\n               the Criminal Code of....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415702","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Bill 13 — Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act. Well, I rise today to speak\n               about some aspects of this bill that give me some concern, regarding the conflict\n               between fundamentally protected rights that this bill seeks to address. Clause 1 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms \"guarantees the rights and\n               freedoms set out in it subject to s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["401ae341889d6a90ce8cb83a976d7dd5b3411f80f90d40fa23ed360e215eae63"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ad9f217607f9c4aff8f4d7a06040a11dfad25036b2ecd3f469507d6ba1863af8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efee8f8155d92d344f1a4e70","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415703,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions to do today. The first, I want to extend my congratulations,\n               and I hope the House will join me, in welcoming Adriana and Aleandra Ramirez, who\n               have just achieved their Canadian citizenship. They were with us in the Legislature\n               here today. I was glad to be able to drop in at their ceremony this morning very briefly.\n               Three and a half years ago, they arrived here from Colombia in July 2022. Congratulations, and would the House please join me in congratulating them. Secondly, I also want to acknowledge the presence in the precinct of the B.C. Youth\n               Council members Massa Lo, Antonia Yanni-Donardo, Colin Sparks, Leo Chen, Sarah Black,\n               Declan Williams and Madison Perrault. They are visiting the Legislature here today,\n               meeting with government and opposition members to advocate on behalf of youth. I ask that the House make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415703","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have two introductions to do today. The first, I want to extend my congratulations,\n               and I hope the House will join me, in welcoming Adriana and Aleandra Ramirez, who\n               have just achieved their Canadian citizenship. They were with us in the Legislature\n               here today. I was glad to be able to drop in at their ceremony this morning very briefly.\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6de0779fbf8e33f69648d620fa2df16c03c1a6aac5fdad1d3b91ab902d01649"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a66b51e23184290a05429b6325168ff6b297adb9549b78e5d362e66e5674222"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-560d66b10aabca27ab36caa2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720226,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today as the official opposition critic for Environment and Parks, Emergency\n               Management and Climate Readiness regarding this legislation, the Environmental Assessment\n               Amendment Act, 2026, commonly referred to as Bill 15. I want to begin by stating something very clearly, because it is important that it's\n               not mischaracterized in this debate or subsequent to it. This is not an opposition\n               to consultation with Indigenous nations. Far from it. This is not opposition to reconciliation, and this is not opposition to improving\n               environmental assessment processes. Those are legitimate, necessary and constitutionally\n               grounded objectives under section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, and under the\n               jurisprudence of the Supreme Court of Canada, including decisions such as Haida Nation v. British Columbia, 2004, SCC 73, and Tsilqot'in Nation v. British Columbia, 2014, SCC 44. Those obligations are real. They are binding, and they must be respected. But what\n               we are dealing with here today is not simply a question of intent. It is a question\n               of legislative design. When we examine the design of Bill 15, what we find is not a strengthening of certainty\n               and environmental assessment. We find a fragmentation of process. We find a multiplication\n               of procedural layers. We find an expansion of discretionary authority without corresponding\n               statutory limits. We find, most concerning of all, a system that risks replacing clarity\n               with complexity at precisely the moment British Columbia can least afford it. British Columbia is entering a period of extraordinary economic and legal pressure.\n               We are facing global uncertainty in commodity markets. We are facing sustained inflationary\n               impacts on infrastructure development. We are facing capital competition from jurisdictions\n               that are actively streamlining permitting processes to attract investment. We are\n               facing ongoing trade pressures, including tariff risks, that directly affect British\n               Columbia's export-dependent resource economy. At the same time, we are navigating a rapidly evolving legal environment under section\n               35 of the Constitution Act, 1982. That legal environment is not static. It is expanding. It is deepening, and it is\n               increasingly being interpreted through complex and fact-specific litigation involving\n               land title, consultation adequacy and Crown decision-making authority. We have seen this trajectory over decades of jurisprudence, from the Haida Nation\n               to Mikisew Cree First Nation v. Canada in 2005, to the Tŝilhqot'in Nation. More recently, we have seen continued litigation We have seen this trajectory over decades of jurisprudence, from the Haida Nation\n               to Mikisew Cree First Nation v. Canada in 2005 to the Tŝilhqot'in Nation. More recently, we have seen continued litigation in British Columbia involving\n               assertions of Aboriginal title and competing claims over land use decision-making\n               authority, including high-profile decisions in the province that have raised serious\n               concerns about certainty of tenure and governance authority. In that context, legislation governing environmental assessment is not just administrative\n               housekeeping. It is foundational economic infrastructure. It determines whether British\n               Columbia is a place where major projects can be built, or whether it becomes a jurisdiction\n               defined by procedural risk. Bill 15 moves us in a direction that raises legitimate\n               concern on that front. Let us examine what this bill actually does. It first replaces an existing dispute\n               resolution framework with a new system built around issue resolution protocols, technical\n               tables, leadership tables and formal dispute resolution processes. It introduces new\n               mechanisms for engagement between the environmental assessment office and participating\n               Indigenous nations. It establishes structured forums for discussion and escalation of issues. It provides\n               for written protocols that govern how these issues are to be resolved. It creates\n               a dispute resolution system that can be triggered by either Indigenous nations or the chief executive assessment officer under specific conditions. And it\n               introduces publication requirements intended to increase transparency. On the surface, this appears comprehensive, and process complexity is not the same\n               as legal certainty. Because when we look more closely at how these mechanisms operate,\n               what becomes clear is that this is not a linear decision-making system. It is a layered\n               and conditional system where each step depends on agreement, discretion, timing and\n               procedural alignment between multiple actors. And when systems become dependent on\n               multiple discretionary triggers, the result is not predictability. The result is variability,\n               and variability in environmental assessment law is not neutral. It is the source of\n               legal and economic risk. Let us begin with the issue resolution protocols under section 18.1. These protocols\n               are not mandatory. They are initiated only if an Indigenous nation provides notice and the chief executive assessment officer agrees to enter discussions.\n               Even then, the content of the protocol is subject to negotiation and, critically,\n               subsection 4 provides that if notice is not given on the same day as participation\n               notice, the chief executive assessment officer may, but is not required to, enter\n               into discussions. That is discretionary participation in a foundational engagement\n               mechanism. We are therefore creating a system where access to structured engagement is not uniformly\n               available. It is conditional, it is discretionary and that raises a fundamental governance\n               question. How does a project proponent or participating nation predict whether they\n               will be able to access the full suite of engagement mechanisms available under this\n               act? The answer is under this bill they cannot. They can only wait to see how discretion\n               is exercised in each case, and that is not certainty. That is administrative variability\n               embedded into statute. We then move to part 4.2, the dispute resolution framework. Here we see a system that\n               appears formal but is actually structurally fragile. A dispute can only proceed if\n               parties agree on the terms of resolution, including participants and the facilitator.\n               If agreement is not reached, section 18.5(7) is clear: there is no dispute resolution\n               process. Let us pause on that. There is no fallback mechanism, there is no default\n               arbitration, there is no mandatory adjudication, there is simply no process. So what\n               we have is a dispute resolution system that is, in effect, opt in at multiple stages.\n               And if agreement fails at the procedural stage, the system collapses entirely. From a legal perspective, that is highly unusual in administrative frameworks that\n               govern complex regulatory approvals because it creates a structural risk that disputes\n               will not be resolved. They will simply persist, and unresolved disputes in environmental\n               assessment are not benign. They translate directly into delay, litigation and injunction\n               risk. The Supreme Court of Canada has repeatedly emphasized that consultation under section\n               35 must be meaningful, but meaningful consultation also requires structure. In Haida\n               Nation, the court made clear that consultation must be conducted in good faith, with\n               the intention of substantially addressing concerns. But the court also recognized\n               that governments must be able to make decisions. Consultation is not a veto. In Haida Nation, the court made clear that consultation must be conducted in good\n               faith, with the intention of substantially addressing concerns. But the court also\n               recognized that governments must be able to make decisions. Consultation is not a\n               veto. It is a process of reconciliation within the Crown's decision-making authority. What Bill 15 risks doing is blurring the line between consultation and procedural\n               dependency. By embedding multiple discretionary engagement layers and by allowing\n               dispute processes to be contingent on agreement, we risk creating a system where decision-making\n               becomes contingent not on statutory authority but on procedural alignment between\n               parties. And that is where legal risks begin to emerge. When statutory decision-making\n               becomes procedurally fragmented, courts are more likely to intervene to clarify obligations,\n               and judicial intervention in environmental assessment is not merely hypothetical.\n               It is well established in Canadian administrative law. We must also consider the absence of statutory timelines. Nowhere in the core dispute\n               resolution provisions do we see binding timelines for completion of issue resolution\n               protocols or dispute resolution processes. Nowhere do we see mandatory deadlines for\n               escalation. Nowhere do we see limits on how long a process may remain in limbo. This is not a minor omission. In environmental assessment law, timelines are central\n               to certainty. They are central to investment decisions. They are central to project\n               financing. And their absence creates what economists and legal scholars often refer\n               to as \"regulatory latency risk,\" the risk that approval processes become open-ended\n               and unpredictable. British Columbia already faces challenges in this area, to make an understatement,\n               as we all in this House know. We are mindful of the massive effect the Quw'utsun court\n               decision has had regarding uncertainty and how that is affecting not just investors\n               but all British Columbians. Capital investment decisions increasingly compare jurisdictions based on permitting\n               certainty. Competing jurisdictions are actively reducing approval timelines. In that\n               context, adding procedural layers without timelines is not neutral. It is a competitive\n               disadvantage. We must also address discretion. The chief executive assessment officer is given significant\n               authority under this bill. They may enter into discussions. They may decline to do\n               so. They may discontinue attempts to agree on dispute resolution terms. They may shape\n               the procedural pathway through which disputes are handled. All of this is subject\n               to consideration of internal policies and written reasons. But there is no independent\n               review mechanism outlined in the statute for these discretionary procedural decisions. That raises a fundamental administrative law concern, that of consistency. When discretion\n               is broad and oversight is limited, outcomes become variable. When outcomes become\n               variable, legal predictability declines. I want to emphasize again what the official opposition's position is not. We are not\n               arguing against Indigenous engagement. We are not arguing against structured consultation\n               processes. We are not arguing against reconciliation. We are in fact arguing that\n               reconciliation must be implemented within a framework that is legally coherent, economically\n               sustainable and administratively predictable. Without those elements, we do not strengthen\n               reconciliation. We weaken implementation, and we increase litigation risk for all\n               parties involved. Having outlined the structural features of Bill 15 and the procedural architecture\n               it creates, I want to now turn to the constitutional dimension of this legislation\n               under section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, and the legal risks that arise when\n               environmental assessment regimes become procedurally fragmented in the way that this\n               bill proposes. Section 35 is not aspirational language; it is constitutional law. It is binding on\n               the Crown, and it has been repeatedly interpreted by the Supreme Court of Canada in\n               a manner that requires both meaningful consultation and legally coherent decision-making\n               structures. In Haida Nation v. British Columbia (Minister of Forests) 2004 SCC 73, the court established the foundational principle that the Crown has a\n               duty to consult and, where appropriate, accommodate Indigenous interests when contemplating\n               conduct that may adversely affect asserted or established Aboriginal rights. But importantly, the court also emphasized that consultation is part of Crown decision-making.\n               It does not displace it; it informs it. In Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia , 2014 SCC 44, the court went further and confirmed Aboriginal title as a proprietary\n               interest in land, requiring that Crown decisions affecting title land meet a stringent\n               justification standard. In Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia , 2014 SCC 44, the court went further and confirmed Aboriginal title as a proprietary interest\n               in land, requiring that Crown decisions affecting title land meet a stringent justification\n               standard. In Mikisew Cree First Nation v. Canada (Governor General in Council) 2018 SCC 40, the court reiterated that while the duty to consult applies at the executive\n               level, courts retain a supervisory role where processes fail to meet constitutional\n               standards. Taken together, these cases establish a consistent principle. Consultation\n               must be meaningful, but it must also be structured in a way that produces decisions. What the courts do not accept is procedural ambiguity that effectively prevents decisions\n               from being made or obscures whether consultation obligations have been fulfilled.\n               This is where Bill 15 becomes legally significant in ways that go beyond administrative\n               reform, because the bill does not simply enhance consultation. It restructures the\n               decision-making environment in which this consultation occurs. It introduces issue\n               resolution protocols, technical tables, leadership tables and dispute resolution mechanisms\n               that are not strictly sequential, not uniformly mandatory and not bound by clear statutory\n               timelines. My colleague has spoken to the need for clear statutory timelines. The result is a system in which consultation is no longer anchored to a single coherent\n               process but, instead, distributed across multiple procedural layers that may or may\n               not be activated depending on discretion and agreement between the parties. From a section 35 position, that raises a critical question. If consultation is fragmented\n               across multiple optional or conditional mechanisms, how does the Crown demonstrate\n               that it has met its constitutional obligation in any given case? The answer is not\n               clear in this legislation, and legal uncertainty at the level of constitutional compliance\n               is not merely a theoretical issue. It is a litigation risk. We have seen in recent years that environmental assessment decisions are increasingly\n               subject to judicial review, where consultation adequacy is in question. Courts are\n               not reluctant to intervene where statutory frameworks are unclear, inconsistent or\n               fail to provide a coherent record of consultation. The danger with Bill 15 is not\n               that consultation is absent. The danger is that consultation becomes procedurally\n               diffused. And when consultation becomes diffused, the evidentiary record required\n               to defend Crown decisions becomes more complex, more contested and more vulnerable\n               to being challenged. That increases the probability of injunction applications against major projects.\n               It increases the cost of defending regulatory decisions. And it increases the likelihood\n               that the courts will be asked to interpret whether the process as a whole meets constitutional\n               requirements. This is not a desirable outcome for any government seeking to balance\n               reconciliation with economic development. I also want to address a broader governance issue, the role of discretion in environmental\n               assessment. This bill places significant procedural authority in the hands of the\n               chief executive assessment officer. That office determines whether discussions occur,\n               whether the dispute resolution process proceeds, or they may discontinue attempts\n               to reach agreement on process terms. They shape the procedural pathway by which issues\n               are escalated or resolved. Now, discretion in administrative systems is not inherently problematic. In fact,\n               it is often necessary. But discretion must be bound by clear statutory principles,\n               timelines and review mechanisms if it is to be consistent with the rule of law. Where\n               discretion is broad and procedural outcomes are contingent, the result is variability.\n               Variability in environmental assessment law translates directly into uncertainty. Mr. Speaker, now let's consider the dispute resolution mechanism itself. At first\n               glance, it appears to be a structured system designed to facilitate agreement, but\n               structurally it is conditional at multiple stages. First, a dispute can only be initiated\n               on specified matters. Second, it requires written notice with defined content. Third,\n               it requires agreement on procedural terms, including participants and facilitators.\n               Fourth, it requires that the chief executive assessment officer agree or not discontinue\n               discussions. Fifth, if agreement is not reached on terms, the process ends entirely. There is no mandatory arbitration. There is no statutory adjudication fallback. There\n               is no requirement that disputes proceed to resolution. This is not a complete dispute\n               resolution system. It is a conditional facilitation framework, and conditional systems,\n               by their nature, are vulnerable to non-completion. This matters. This matters because environmental assessment disputes are not abstract disagreements.\n               They are directly tied to whether projects proceed, whether or not permits are issued,\n               whether or not construction begins, whether or not capital is deployed, and whether\n               or not communities receive the economic benefits associated with development. If dispute\n               resolution mechanisms are incomplete or optional at critical stages, the system does\n               not eliminate conflict. It defers it, and deferred conflict in regulatory systems\n               tends to manifest as litigation. I want to turn now to the economic dimension of this bill because it cannot be separated\n               from the legal and procedural analyses. British Columbia's economy is highly exposed\n               to resource development cycles, infrastructure, investment and export markets. Major\n               projects require regulatory certainty before capital is committed. They require predictable\n               timelines, they require clear consultation pathways, and they require confidence that\n               disputes will be resolved within defined institutional frameworks. Bill 15 introduces some certainty in all four of these areas. There are no binding\n               timelines for dispute resolution, there is no guarantee that dispute processes will\n               proceed if agreement is not reached, there is significant discretion at multiple procedural\n               stages, and there is a lack of clarity around how overlapping engagement mechanisms\n               interact. From an investment perspective, this creates what is known as process risk,\n               the risk that regulatory approval timelines are unpredictable or extend beyond reasonable\n               planning horizons. Process risk is one of the primary factors that drives capital away from jurisdictions.\n               In an era where global capital is mobile, jurisdictions compete not only on resource\n               quality but on regulatory certainty. British Columbia must be extremely cautious not\n               to inadvertently position itself as a high-risk jurisdiction from a process standpoint. I also want to address the political context in which this legislation is being addressed.\n               Over the past several years, the province has been engaged in an increasingly complex\n               and sometimes strained relationship with Indigenous nations, particularly in the context\n               of land use, resource development and consultation obligations. This is not unique\n               to British Columbia. It is part of a broader national evolution in the interpretation\n               and implementation of section 35 rights. However, within British Columbia, there has\n               been growing public concern about uncertainty in land use governance, particularly\n               where overlapping claims, consultation disputes and litigation intersect with major\n               economic projects. Court decisions, such as those involving Aboriginal title claims in various parts\n               of the province, including recent litigation in the Lower Mainland and other resource\n               regions, have reinforced the reality that these issues are not settled. They are actively\n               evolving, and in that environment, legislative clarity becomes more important. Uncertainty\n               at the legal level translates into uncertainty at the investment level, and uncertainty\n               at the investment level translates into delayed or cancelled projects. That is a cycle\n               we must avoid. This is why the stakes of Bill 15 are so high. This legislation is not being introduced\n               into a stable, low-risk environment. We are teetering over a historic precipice in\n               this province regarding Indigenous land claims and the section 35 constitutional framework.\n               We have been witness to this government completely up-ending traditional treaty negotiating\n               processes, replacing them with legal uncertainty and political chaos. All this has been unleashed on the economic stability but moreover on the economic\n               goodwill of the reconciliation journey and the goodwill of it generally. It's all\n               very troubling. It affects a great many people who care deeply about the implications\n               of legislation like Bill 15, and I am one of those people who is deeply concerned. As I have stated, Bill 15 is being introduced into a high-complexity constitutional\n               and economic environment where clarity is absolutely essential, in light of the far-reaching\n               implications of the Quw'utsun decision. Yet throwing caution to the wind, what we see in this bill is an expansion of procedural\n               architecture without the corresponding expansion of statutory certainty. We see more\n               mechanisms but not enough certainty. We see more engagement points but not more resolution certainty. We see more discretion but not more structure, and in governance terms, that is a\n               dangerous imbalance. I want to conclude by addressing what this bill represents at its core, beyond its\n               clauses, beyond its procedural architecture and beyond its technical language. Legislation\n               is never about what it just says. It's also about what it I want to conclude by addressing what this bill represents at its core, beyond its\n               clauses, beyond its procedural architecture and beyond its technical language. Legislation\n               is never about what it just says. It's also about what it does in practice. We've\n               certainly seen that with DRIPA in this province, I would argue. So let me be clear again. What Bill 15 does in its current form is fundamentally reshape\n               environmental assessment in British Columbia into a system defined by layered discretion,\n               conditional processes and unresolved procedural dependencies. That is not a minor\n               adjustment. That is a Pandora's box structural redesign of how the province makes\n               decisions about major projects. When governments undertake structural redesigns of core economic governance systems,\n               they carry a heightened responsibility to ensure clarity, certainty, and constitutional\n               coherence. On that test, this bill needs to do better. It needs to meet the standards\n               that British Columbians should expect. So let us be direct about what this bill does to decision-making certainty. It replaces\n               predictable statutory pathways with negotiated procedural frameworks. It replaces\n               fixed timelines with open-ended engagement structures. It replaces mandatory resolution\n               mechanisms with conditional agreement-based processes. It replaces clarity and administrative\n               authority with expanded discretionary points. This is not modernization in the meaningful sense of the word. Modernization implies\n               simplification, it implies efficiency, and it implies clarity. This bill doesn't get\n               there. It layers process upon process, each dependent on agreement, discretion or\n               procedural alignments that may never materialize. When that happens, the system does\n               not become more functional; it becomes fragile. We are told that this is about improving relationships and supporting reconciliation.\n               Yet again, no one in this House disputes that importance of improving reconciliation.\n               We live it daily here. But reconciliation cannot be achieved through structural ambiguity,\n               it cannot be achieved through procedural uncertainty, and it cannot be achieved by\n               creating systems where outcomes depend on a discretionary alignment rather than clear\n               statutory pathways. When pathways are unclear, they do not strengthen relationships. They strain them,\n               and they create inconsistency. We do not need to generate more disputes. We must also\n               face the truth and reconcile it with the current economic reality of this province.\n               We do not operate in isolation in British Columbia. We compete for capital investment,\n               we compete for infrastructure funding, we compete for industrial development, and\n               we compete with jurisdictions that are actively streamlining regulatory processes\n               to reduce uncertainty and accelerate project delivery. Every additional layer of uncertainty introduced into our environmental assessment\n               system has a cost. This cost is borne by workers, it is borne by communities, and\n               it is borne by taxpayers. This bill has the potential to increase those costs. Not\n               intentionally, perhaps, but the road to Hades has been said to be paved with good\n               intentions. But structurally and inevitably, we cannot also ignore the constitutional risk profile\n               that this legislation could introduce. It's not static law. It's evolving, and it\n               is shaped by ongoing judicial interpretation. It imposes real obligations on the Crown\n               that must be met with clear, consistent and defensible processes. When legislation introduces fragmentation, it increases the burden on government to\n               demonstrate that consultation obligations have been met in each individual case. That\n               means more documentation, possibly more litigation exposure, more judicial scrutiny\n               and more uncertainty for all involved. These are not theoretical risks. These are\n               the lived realities of Canadian constitutional law, and these are the realities driving\n               tremendous upheaval and uncertainty in this government in British Columbia. So the principality of this question is why we would introduce additional complexity\n               into a system is already under constitutional, economic and political pressure. Why\n               would we introduce added discretional authority without simultaneously strengthening\n               statutory certainty? Why would we create dispute mechanisms that are conditional at\n               multiple stages without ensuring that disputes will actually be resolved? Why would\n               we introduce procedural uncertainty into a province that depends so heavily on major\n               project investment? We're not opposed, in the opposition, to improving environmental assessment. We are\n               not opposed to meaningful Indigenous engagement and consultation under section 35.\n               We are not opposed to reconciliation. In fact, we believe in economic reconciliation. We are not opposed to modernizing outdated systems. But we are opposed to legislative\n               frameworks that create further complexity, lack clarity, and create uncertainty. That's\n               what we need to prevent. If there's going to be discretion, there also has to be accountability.\n               If there are going to be regulatory structures. At the end of the day, good governance is not measured by how many processes are created.\n               It is measured by whether or not these processes work, whether they produce timely\n               decisions, that they withstand constitutional and legal scrutiny and that they bring\n               certainty, both to Indigenous peoples and industry in order to plan for the future. We are at a critical juncture in British Columbia. We have economic headwinds, legal\n               complexity, growing competition and increasing demands on infrastructure and services.\n               In that environment, stability is not optional. Certainty is not optional. Clarity\n               is not optional. These are essential elements of good legislation that governs environmental\n               assessment policies, so it must reflect that reality. Bill 15 needs to do better. We have concerns about the way this bill is presently\n               drafted, and we urge the government to have a close look at this, go back to the drawing\n               board to some extent to strengthen the statutory clarity of this framework, to introduce\n               binding timelines, to simplify procedural pathways and to ensure that constitutional\n               obligations under section 35 are met through clear and defensible processes. British Columbia cannot afford uncertainty in its environmental assessment regime\n               — not now, not in this climate and not in this constitutional landscape. We owe it to the people of British Columbia to get this right. We owe it to Indigenous\n               nations to ensure that the engagement processes are clear, consistent and meaningful.\n               We owe it to the workers and industry to ensure that investment decisions are done\n               well. We owe it to future generations that British Columbia is doing it right for\n               everyone's benefit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720226","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today as the official opposition critic for Environment and Parks, Emergency\n               Management and Climate Readiness regarding this legislation, the Environmental Assessment\n               Amendment Act, 2026, commonly referred to as Bill 15. I want to begin by stating something very clearly, because it is important that it's\n               not mischaracterized in this debate or sub","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8bc05e669ce163163f949db2b2de97c89827c456b2d07a9442a68e8e79f8ece5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bec503ad7ad383a810dffe174fe7f3cb3bdb607af58a8470d89da4a022f848e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-109a8d133174cbde0858e990","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721305,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions and another person to recognize this morning. I first would\n               like to introduce and ask that you make feel welcome Chantal Sutton and Serena Charters,\n               who are constituents of mine from Quesnel, British Columbia. Chantal was the inspiration for my private member's bill, M237, and she'll be here\n               today as we go through that process. They're in the House, and if you see the two of them around.... They drove all the way\n               down from the Cariboo to be here. I hope that you'll make them feel very welcome. My second is for James Murtagh. James is retiring today after 41⁄2 years as a sessional\n               officer, corridor supervisor and security procedures analyst with the Office of the\n               Sergeant-at-Arms and, prior to that, served seven years with the Ministry of Health\n               as executive director of regional operations and, after that, for 20 years as a health\n               care consultant. James is retiring today for good. So he says. I am not sure we can believe that. But I do wish that everyone, when you see James, will shake his hand and thank him\n               for his long and colourful years of service with the public sector and to this House. I'm not sure we can believe that. but I do wish that everyone, when you see James,\n               will shake his hand and thank him for his long and colourful years of service with\n               the public sector and to this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721305","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have two introductions and another person to recognize this morning. I first would\n               like to introduce and ask that you make feel welcome Chantal Sutton and Serena Charters,\n               who are constituents of mine from Quesnel, British Columbia. Chantal was the inspiration for my private member's bill, M237, and she'll be here\n               today as we go through that process. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2210a1a8c81eab2d146f33770de999c9ea9149ac7e74c3eb94c4677de025e9a1","413b535c721155228aa57c1c855050cfffedda393be5e2823c7e6c62caf8f30e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf3b59abafa1dd79803043f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721307,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"On Friday, April 17, I spoke at the 81st B.C. Trappers Association annual general\n               meeting in Quesnel. I had previously spoken at the 1995 AGM in Prince George to warn\n               them about the new Firearms Act, so this was a terrific opportunity to reconnect with\n               these friends who are venerable stewards of the land. The British Columbia Trappers Association was formed in 1945 as an association of\n               registered trappers, and it is the oldest trappers association in Canada. Their vision\n               is that trapping is British Columbia's renewable heritage, and their mission is that\n               the B.C. Trappers Association is a dedicated, compassionate community of trappers,\n               and as stewards in British Columbia, they manage fur-bearers responsibly and sustainably\n               through respect of our joint natural resources. Core values include dedication, compassion,\n               respect, integrity and responsibility. In 1926, to prevent species from overharvesting, British Columbia was divided into\n               registered traplines with the intent of protecting species from overharvesting. Traplines\n               are sold to a trapper so that he or she is the only person with the right to trap\n               fur-bearing animals inside that area. Trappers are well connected with the environment. Trapping built our country. Trappers\n               are well aware of their responsibilities as conservationists and stewards of the land.\n               When wanting to know how many fishers, martens and wolverines there are in British\n               Columbia, researchers would be well advised to include the steady wisdom, skills and\n               expertise of B.C. trappers. As people in tune with the environment, trappers are well positioned to advise government\n               and academics regarding fur-bearing animal populations and distribution. Today the B.C. Trappers Association educates new trappers, encourages ethical trapping\n               processes and keeps its members well informed about matters affecting them. Their\n               quarterly magazine includes articles on improved humane traps and sets, and information\n               on different species as well as the best way to maintain a healthy breeding population. Congratulations to the BCTA on 81 years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Trapping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721307","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On Friday, April 17, I spoke at the 81st B.C. Trappers Association annual general\n               meeting in Quesnel. I had previously spoken at the 1995 AGM in Prince George to warn\n               them about the new Firearms Act, so this was a terrific opportunity to reconnect with\n               these friends who are venerable stewards of the land. The British Columbia Trappers Association was fo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","label":"Trapping"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Trapping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","label":"Trapping","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c68adb75de3697b17bd6c103020570d26547254f8827fa9a770408c70a2268f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Trapping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0eed49f89be699bfa62e10afa6f22643cfe5e0671c82b9133885da7a27eb7e08"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Trapping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Trapping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016024","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a5b93e35a6365a383c29fd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721311,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would just like to remind the members of the House, and I thank you for the reminder\n               that I received today from one of the members on the other side, that its Administrative\n               Professionals Day. Thank your managers, your CAs, your LAs, all of those people who\n               make all of us look so great.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721311","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would just like to remind the members of the House, and I thank you for the reminder\n               that I received today from one of the members on the other side, that its Administrative\n               Professionals Day. Thank your managers, your CAs, your LAs, all of those people who\n               make all of us look so great.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fc4152e130863c8280e816d3df623aca5420228d9b873c8b237d2fc3ed34fee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9542d705fa08beb880a7081d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728958,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to close debate on Bill M237, the Insurance (Vehicle) Amendment Act, 2026. This bill would change the definition of a \"catastrophic injury\" from loss of two\n               or more limbs to one or more. It also retroactively extends the timeline during which\n               affected individuals are able to apply for benefits. I have taken a long, hard look at why the NDP wants Bill M237 sent to the special\n               committee, and let's not dress this up. This is not about process, and it is certainly\n               not about helping people. It is about ideology and political theatre. Everything this\n               government does seems to be filtered through those two lenses. Several months ago, when it became obvious that people were being shortchanged by\n               their insurance, and when what I believe to be a fixable oversight could have been\n               addressed with genuine cross-party cooperation, I spoke directly with senior officials\n               at ICBC. What they told me should concern every member of this House. They admitted\n               that no-fault insurance is not really as much about stopping fraud as it is about\n               limiting claims and keeping insurance rates artificially low. That's just plain wrong. The priority is not making injured people whole. The priority\n               is optics — keeping rates low enough to score political points. I said then to those officials, and I will say again now. Insurance rates should reflect\n               reality. They should reflect the real cost of properly compensating people for their\n               injuries. If the system is not doing that, then it is not insurance. It is a facade.\n               And the response I received was as blunt as it was troubling. If ICBC actually paid\n               what people deserved, it would make less money, and rates would go up. That was the\n               concern, not fairness, not justice, not people. That tells you everything you need\n               to know. Now we arrive here, where members opposite will likely stand and vote for this bill\n               at second reading. And why? Because they know exactly what comes next. They will know\n               it will be sent to their special committee where it can be buried, delayed and ultimately\n               killed — out of sight and out of mind. Just like what happened with the special committee\n               on freedom of information in British Columbia in 2021 and subsequently five-long-years\n               later, introducing that insult of a bill, Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. This is not leadership. This is not compassion. This is political cover. It is virtue-signalling\n               at its most cynical. Support the bill when it costs nothing, then quietly destroy\n               it when no one is watching. So yes, go ahead. Vote for it today. Put on the appearance\n               of concern. Say the right words. But do not come into this House and pretend that\n               you are standing up for people with catastrophic injuries when you are actively ensuring\n               that they will never see the help they deserve. On this side, we see this for what it is. It was never about process. It was never\n               about people. It has always been about virtue-signalling and protecting ICBC profits\n               over the needs of people. If people are going to lose an arm or a leg, then their\n               insurance should reflect the reality of that as a catastrophic injury. So my challenge to this House and to the government is to prove me wrong. Let's see\n               this bill come back from the ICBC committee. Let's see it put into effect so that\n               it can actually help people who have had a catastrophic injury to become, as possibly\n               as they can be, whole again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728958","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to close debate on Bill M237, the Insurance (Vehicle) Amendment Act, 2026. This bill would change the definition of a \"catastrophic injury\" from loss of two\n               or more limbs to one or more. It also retroactively extends the timeline during which\n               affected individuals are able to apply for benefits. I have taken a long, hard look at why the NDP wants Bill M237 sent ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","label":"Accident prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["101d0f5e8212385b75ebb49b7bab8230511fabbe6c8f2226e3132720e9515043"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8144ec52adee1678ad87de22ccc0aab2a09c4e00562c7ce3912cad3ad4e21d91"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-624c45fdcfd2806b4defbe09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728960,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"It gives me great pleasure to introduce two visitors from Prince George. We have in\n               the gallery Brent Laconi, who worked at CN Rail and the B.C. Rail since the 1980s,\n               and Sean Bortolan, who was a CUPE executive member and Indigenous education worker\n               with school district 57. I hope that the House will make my friends most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728960","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It gives me great pleasure to introduce two visitors from Prince George. We have in\n               the gallery Brent Laconi, who worked at CN Rail and the B.C. Rail since the 1980s,\n               and Sean Bortolan, who was a CUPE executive member and Indigenous education worker\n               with school district 57. I hope that the House will make my friends most welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rail companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036862","label":"Rail companies","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["be3a514d12d467564c67e08602ed65e8f0960ad8eb9e4946578cf7fcf1a7b6bf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e603c92775487d9fe9b71c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728976,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure to invite the members of this House, their friends, families, British\n               Columbians and — why not? — the rest of the world to come visit Quesnel in the riding\n               of Prince George–North Cariboo","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728976","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's my pleasure to invite the members of this House, their friends, families, British\n               Columbians and — why not? — the rest of the world to come visit Quesnel in the riding\n               of Prince George–North Cariboo","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fefda06bfc5e594e873a0a09ab5a208a36de689352634c4ad5589dec120d4d3","eb7c6b4a24a4d988ff9722a0751a95bab233c3a3123ecb1c34df8ecf3ac8cbb0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf539d611816995eb80fcec2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752202,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to begin my opposition to Bill 9 with a simple principle. There is a social\n               contract that exists that is the essence of legitimacy of government. In a democracy,\n               information produced by government does not belong to government. It belongs to the\n               public. The people of British Columbia pay for government. They fund the decisions\n               that are made in ministries. They fund the infrastructure projects that are built.\n               They fund the policy work that shapes our province. And because they pay for it, they have a right. They have a right, not a privilege\n               — a right to know how those decisions are made. That is why freedom of information\n               laws exist. They are not a bureaucratic inconvenience. They are one of the most important\n               accountability tools available to citizens. These tools allow journalists to investigate.\n               They allow citizens to hold government accountable. They allow opposition members\n               in this House to examine decisions that affect communities throughout British Columbia. That is why legislation that weakens freedom of information should concern every member\n               of this chamber. Unfortunately, Bill 9 challenges that Unfortunately, Bill 9 challenges that social contract. It moves us in the wrong direction.\n               Transparency is the foundation of accountability, and freedom-of-information laws\n               exist for a reason. They exist because governments control vast amounts of information\n               — information about spending, information about decision-making, information about\n               communications between ministers and bureaucrats. They contain information about projects\n               that affect communities across this province. Without access to that information, accountability becomes impossible. And without\n               accountability, public trust erodes. Transparency builds trust; secrecy destroys it.\n               It breaks down that social contract, and that is really the fundamental issue before\n               us today, because Bill 9 lowers the standard for transparency. One of the most troubling changes in this bill is the replacement of the duty to respond\n               to requests \"without delay\" with the much weaker standard of \"without reasonable delay.\"\n               Now, on the surface, that might seem like a small wording change. But as I've been\n               told over many years, words matter. Words matter. Grammar matters. All of it matters,\n               and it's particularly important in legislation. Freedom of information requests in British Columbia already take far too long. Applicants\n               routinely wait months, sometimes years. In fact, statistical data shows that in recent\n               years, applicants waited an average of 192 additional business days beyond the legislated\n               timeline to receive responses. That's more than nine months, and we all know that\n               nine months is a pretty long time, and a lot of things can happen in nine months.\n               That's nine months beyond the deadline that already exists in law. So instead of strengthening the requirement to respond promptly, the government is\n               weakening it. Instead of fixing the problem, they are lowering the standard. That\n               is not improving transparency. That is merely redefining delay. I have some experience with the current system. As a sitting MLA representing the\n               area where the Quesnel Bridge is located, I submitted a freedom-of-information request\n               last year seeking documents related to that bridge. It was not an unusual request.\n               There's nothing malicious about it. There's nothing abusive, nothing frivolous. It\n               was merely an attempt by this member as a Member of the Legislative Assembly to understand\n               decisions surrounding a piece of infrastructure affecting not merely the community\n               I represent but the entire province. Yet what happened next speaks volumes about the state of the system in British Columbia.\n               The request disappeared. It went into the abyss of requests. Months passed, then more\n               months. Requests for extensions of time. Eventually, a full year later, the response\n               finally surfaced. But when it did, it came with a hefty bill attached. After waiting\n               for about a year for information about a project in my own riding, I was told that\n               if I wanted the documents, I had to first pay the bill. Think about that for a moment. An elected Member of the Legislative Assembly trying\n               to obtain information about a public infrastructure project in their community has\n               to wait a year and then has to pay for the privilege of seeing it. Now, this raises an obvious question. If a member of this assembly has to have this\n               kind of difficulty to get information, how difficult is it already for ordinary citizens?\n               How difficult is it for journalists or for researchers? As an academic, I submitted\n               other freedom-of-information requests, and I had that request blocked. They didn't\n               want to give me the information. I thought to myself: \"Okay.\" I look at this bill. This bill actually talks about that,\n               and it would make that kind of blocking even more easy to do. That is not okay. How easy would this be for community advocates trying to understand How easy would this be for community advocates trying to understand decisions that\n               affect their lives? And those experiences raise even more troubling questions when\n               we consider the legislation before us today. If my requests were to be resubmitted under the provisions of Bill 9, would they even\n               be processed? Would they be simply dismissed out of hand? Or could somebody claim\n               that the requests lacked enough detail? Could someone say that it's going to take\n               too long to locate the records? Could it be argued that responding would interfere\n               with the operations of government? Well, these are precisely the kinds of new powers\n               this bill introduces, and that is why this legislation is so concerning. Freedom of information is already slow. It is already expensive. It already requires\n               persistence. But Bill 9 risks making it easier for government to delay requests, reject\n               requests or simply discourage someone from making a request altogether. That represents\n               a breakdown of that social contract. Accountability disappears, for it expands the\n               grounds to reject requests. It doesn't just expand them in a little way. It dramatically expands them. You can\n               disregard requests as being abusive, malicious, excessively broad or something that\n               would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the government of British Columbia.\n               Let us pause for a moment on that. Interfere with the operations of government — wow\n               — that's an incredibly broad concept. Responding to any request requires staff time.\n               Searching records requires effort. Reviewing documents requires resources. By that\n               definition, almost any request could be said to interfere with operations. What makes this change particularly concerning is that the language now refers to\n               interference with the operations of the government of British Columbia as a whole,\n               rather than the operations of a specific public body. That dramatically widens the\n               scope. When legislation creates vague categories like that, it inevitably raises the\n               question of how broadly they might be interpreted. This gives the government a tremendous\n               amount of power over requests. Another change in this bill gives the head of a public body the authority to determine\n               whether a request contains \"enough detail.\" It also allows them to determine whether\n               records can be located within a reasonable amount of time. Again, those phrases are\n               not defined. What qualifies has enough detail? What qualifies has reasonable time?\n               Those determinations will now be made by the very institutions being asked to release\n               the information. Well, that doesn't make any sense. It makes that body of government\n               both the judge and the gatekeeper of access to information. That is precisely the\n               concern raised by people advocating for transparency. Now, another problem here is that there were a number of expert recommendations made.\n               It's puzzling to me that it ignores many of the recommendations made in the 2022 special\n               legislative committee report titled FIPPA for the Future . That committee produced 34 recommendations to improve and modernize the freedom\n               of information system. Among those recommendations were creating a duty to document, requiring government\n               to properly record decisions and extending freedom of information rules to the administrative\n               functions of the Legislative Assembly. Those reforms would have strengthened transparency. Yet, where do we see them in this\n               bill? Well, we don't see them in this bill. Instead of strengthening accountability,\n               Bill 9 focuses on administrative convenience. There are a lot of people talking about this bill, folks advocating for transparency. There are a lot of people talking about this bill. Folks advocating for transparency\n               have been incredibly clear about their concerns. The Freedom of Information and Privacy\n               Association has warned that this legislation fails to address the real problems in\n               the system. Their executive director, Jason Woywada, put it plainly. \"Access delays\n               are often a symptom of recordkeeping failures. You cannot fix systemic information\n               management problems by weakening public access rights.\" That statement goes to the\n               heart of the issue. The solution to delays is not to weaken access. The solution is\n               to improve recordkeeping and provide adequate resources to process requests.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752202","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to begin my opposition to Bill 9 with a simple principle. There is a social\n               contract that exists that is the essence of legitimacy of government. In a democracy,\n               information produced by government does not belong to government. It belongs to the\n               public. The people of British Columbia pay for government. They fund the decisions\n               that","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6adfb873cc306e26b511970fc8539dce1fade9a88c043e1269eadf63324c45df"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["67d260f27a4a26ca8654c5639e0aeed77550419f6f4075604db0956bb320b512"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-822f4d1e3ebb270da51abd22","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752203,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a pleasure to be speaking in this House. I enjoy it immensely. I rise\n               today to support the hoist motion for amending the motion of second reading of Bill\n               9 by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting \"six months hence.\" I think it behooves us well to consider exactly what a hoist motion is and what it does. We've had some\n               discussion about that in this House, but to be clear, a hoist motion delays the second\n               reading of a bill for the purpose of careful examination in some time hence. Sometimes\n               it could be three months; it could be six months. That's typical. Such a motion removes the bill from the order paper. In this case, that would have\n               the effect of killing the bill, but that's not a terrible thing necessarily. What\n               that means is that this bill can in fact be carefully recrafted to meet the real needs\n               of what should be happening with freedom of information and protection of privacy\n               and making sure that what we're dealing with here is something that will better serve\n               everyone. It will serve the people of British Columbia, it will serve the members\n               of government, and it will better serve the members of opposition. As my learned colleague has pointed out in his previous remarks, what has to happen\n               here is that a consideration needs to be made that what happens in any act or bill,\n               although it may serve the purposes of government on one time, in one term, when a\n               particular government is in office, may not be all that convenient for the members\n               of that particular government, were they to be sitting in opposition. If we're going to be considering a bill like this, I think it goes back to looking\n               very carefully at why we want to change this to a six-month delay, which would effectively\n               kill the bill. When we're looking at the concerns expressed by various speakers about\n               why this delay, this hoist motion, is necessary, I think it goes back to words I was\n               speaking yesterday about the social contract and where the social contract comes from. The purpose of such a hoist motion is really to protect the social contract. Now,\n               what is the origin of the social contract that we're talking about here that affects\n               this particular hoist motion? Well, when we look at philosophers of political thought\n               and philosophy of how people interact with governance, we look at writers such as\n               Rawls or Hobbes or Rousseau Well, when we look at philosophers of political thought and philosophy of how people\n               interact with governance, we look at writers such as Rawls or Hobbes or Rousseau or\n               John Locke. They all represent fundamental differences in the relationship of people\n               to government. And if we're going to be considering those fundamental differences\n               of the relationship of people to government, we need to understand that in this House\n               there are considerably different philosophies about what that means. The social contract that exists that gives legitimacy to government is directly affected\n               by this motion to effectively kill this bill. When this bill is removed from the order paper, we need to understand that there are\n               a number of particular philosophical positions that do apply. Now, if we're looking\n               at Rousseau, for example, the life and being of the state is considered to be.... The\n               state, in Rousseau's thought, is a moral person, and it is to be subordinate to the\n               general will. He has a concept of citizenship as organic and social as compared to\n               a more individualistic view held by John Locke. Now, when we are looking at considering what happens to this particular bill and it\n               being delayed for a time six months hence, I think that we also need to consider the\n               role of surrendering independence and natural liberty to attain political liberty,\n               because this is Rousseau's central argument. It means that all individual rights must\n               be subordinate to the general will. He would argue, for example, that property rights\n               must be subordinated to the general will as well. This is something I fundamentally\n               disagree with. Rousseau basically supports equality of outcome. And the competing philosophy supports\n               equality of opportunity. So when we're looking at the social contract with regards to this particular hoist\n               motion and how it changes what would happen with this particular bill, I think we\n               need to understand that philosophical basis that is affecting the political desire\n               to put the bill forward in the first place. In Locke's social contract, the state of nature is characterized by the absence of\n               government but not by the absence of mutual obligation and responsibility, because\n               people do have responsibilities in a society to be able to fulfill their particular\n               roles as citizens in civics. And unlike Hobbes, Locke believes that individuals are\n               naturally endowed with the rights to life, liberty and property and that the state\n               of nature surrounding those things could be relatively peaceful. This is a difference, I think, between a philosophy which is more Rousseau-like, which\n               has been the essence of creating the particular bill before us, which I am arguing\n               needs to be laid for six months.... The natural rights that precede the establishment of civil society are really important.\n               I think they're important to British Columbians, not just in an abstract sense but\n               in a very real sense. Because we are seeing a lot of division in our province, our country, dare I say even the\n               world, over basic elements of how people interact with government and governance. These particular situations are affecting all of us, and they are affecting how we\n               are treating this particular bill. Because when we put a hoist motion forward to look at this bill, those essences of how\n               one views the world are central to how we are going to deal with that particular situation\n               and philosophy. What you get when people become unhappy is you get revolutionary movements. The American\n               Revolutionary War, for example, was arguably a direct result of this desire for people\n               to recapture what they felt were their natural rights that had been eroded by the\n               circumstances that they were under. Now, regardless of how one feels about that particular conflict and how good King\n               George was maligned at that time, it's an important thing to realize that when you\n               put a hoist motion forward on a particular bill, it will kill the bill that's before\n               the House. We need to understand that this does allow a pause — as my learned colleague\n               put it, a re-pacing — to rewrite the bill so that it actually performs We need to understand that this does allow a pause, as my learned colleague put it,\n               a repacing, to rewrite the bill so that it actually performs some useful purpose and\n               makes it so that the people who are going to be affected by this bill can actually\n               learn about its existence, learn about the changes that are proposed in it and make\n               due representation to government and to committees to ensure that this particular\n               bill gets the due hearing that it should have. When we are considering.... I mentioned Rousseau, and I mentioned Hobbes and Locke. If you compare Hobbes with\n               Rousseau, for example, on social contract, because that's what this is, a social contract,\n               Hobbes saw human nature as selfish and competitive. Rousseau, on the other hand, he\n               saw people as being naturally good but corrupted by society. The state of nations\n               under Hobbes was seen to be brutal and warlike, perpetual conflict.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752203","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's always a pleasure to be speaking in this House. I enjoy it immensely. I rise\n               today to support the hoist motion for amending the motion of second reading of Bill\n               9 by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting \"six months hence.\" I think it behooves us well to consider exactly what a hoist motion is and what it does. We've had some\n               discussion about th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29fb7d0e00c47615c5adfe4400d72916bf868873579bb130890421e1f14809b6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39ead1614e0c62a371cf287d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017245,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joffre Lakes is not the only provincial park on the block for potential closure for\n               exclusive cultural events. The minister indicated that she has had requests for Juan\n               de Fuca and Dunn Lake provincial parks for closure as well. To the Minister of Environment and Parks: how many B.C. provincial parks will be closed\n               this summer for exclusive cultural events?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017245","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Joffre Lakes is not the only provincial park on the block for potential closure for\n               exclusive cultural events. The minister indicated that she has had requests for Juan\n               de Fuca and Dunn Lake provincial parks for closure as well. To the Minister of Environment and Parks: how many B.C. provincial parks will be closed\n               this summer for exclusive cultural eve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Lakes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168629","label":"Lakes","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bf807ba212338948486b14801ca85dc7f2a7e6b27b06f8348f45f3f23d06e76"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9fe8bab78c083aaed2e0057e8d6d067a286ffec6a5d17b136f275b5f32aa4a9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00a99efd04cf0a956ba45b63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017248,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I, too, would like to welcome the Consular Corps.  I would also like to welcome those\n               delegates from Ethiopia, who I had the honour of meeting at the doorway this morning\n               outside when they were coming in. The Ambassador of the Federal Republic of Ethiopia,\n               Tewodros Girma Abebe; the Diaspora Affairs Minister for Ethiopia, Tarifa Echijima-Hundi; and the\n               president of the Ethiopian-Canadian Human Rights Association of British Columbia,\n               Kibibi Abate. Would you please make these folks feel most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017248","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I, too, would like to welcome the Consular Corps.  I would also like to welcome those\n               delegates from Ethiopia, who I had the honour of meeting at the doorway this morning\n               outside when they were coming in. The Ambassador of the Federal Republic of Ethiopia,\n               Tewodros Girma Abebe; the Diaspora Affairs Minister for Ethiopia, Tarifa Echijima-Hundi; and the\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083605","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Passports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083605","label":"Passports","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c140db24cda2b1177d4968dd168024172960c7216d1eaed76e0307ed88e2756"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a28a84c6f250b2ee9dd7656ed2bf4f9dd4968ae10a40ed15b7980d724ac26d4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dab1f5517a43191fdab7de2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036434,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to welcome representatives from the Canadian Propane Association who\n               are joining us here in the gallery. Propane is a vital part of British Columbia's\n               energy future, a reliable, low-emission fuel produced right here in Canada which helps\n               power our farms, industries, businesses and communities, especially in rural, remote\n               and Indigenous regions, where dependable energy access matters the most. We appreciate the opportunity to meet with members of the Canadian Propane Association\n               over lunch today and to discuss practical, commonsense energy solutions that support\n               affordability, energy security and economic growth across our province. I also want to thank the members of the Canadian Propane Association for once again\n               hosting a fantastic food truck lunch reception behind the Legislature, and for reminding\n               all of us that propane helps keep goods moving, food on our tables, and hard-working\n               British Columbians employed. Will the House please join me in making that delegation from the CPA most welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036434","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I rise to welcome representatives from the Canadian Propane Association who\n               are joining us here in the gallery. Propane is a vital part of British Columbia's\n               energy future, a reliable, low-emission fuel produced right here in Canada which helps\n               power our farms, industries, businesses and communities, especially in rural, remote\n               and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","label":"Propane"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","label":"Propane","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5f73dca845153b84d6070ff43ed1862b685492f3fad3205152dae871147dba70"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dd0e3e8ea9a8c205ec1892acd841d0cb5c8dd33574241a44463c948d60348137"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f59649e8aa9cd938484c9ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036435,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Visiting us today from the wonderful borough of Quesnel in Prince George–North Cariboo is my constituency assistant Adam Sean, who is joining us in the gallery here today. Adam provides invaluable assistance,\n               making me look absolutely fantastic, and occasionally listening to my lyrics and pre-screening them before I sing them in the House. Would you all please join in making Adam feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036435","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Visiting us today from the wonderful borough of Quesnel in Prince George–North Cariboo is my constituency assistant Adam Sean, who is joining us in the gallery here today. Adam provides invaluable assistance,\n               making me look absolutely fantastic, and occasionally listening to my lyrics and pre-screening them before I sing them in the House. Would you all please join in making Adam fe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-38471c634b152aa9bd2dd165","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036436,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday I introduced one of my staff from Quesnel. Today I'm very pleased to welcome\n               Johnathan Raine, who is my staff in Prince George. Johnathan will be looking after\n               my Prince George office, which I expect to see opening in a couple of weeks. Johnathan\n               is a very technologically savvy fellow who looks after a lot of those little things\n               that happen to make an office go awry. I just want everyone to make Johnathan very welcome, and here he is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036436","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday I introduced one of my staff from Quesnel. Today I'm very pleased to welcome\n               Johnathan Raine, who is my staff in Prince George. Johnathan will be looking after\n               my Prince George office, which I expect to see opening in a couple of weeks. Johnathan\n               is a very technologically savvy fellow who looks after a lot of those little things\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a4df700fe5ed29e14fb56dadbef03fee83df1d19a197ef06027705fc99c11f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-162bf6031106d4e1ff83b28f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036437,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions or observances to make. First of all, I would like to wish my senior constituency assistant, Adam Schaan,\n               a happy 40th birthday. He joins us in the gallery today, along with Johnathan Raine,\n               my other assistant from Prince George. Happy birthday. All the very best. Joining Adam, all the way from the Emerald Isle, Dublin, is Ronan Lynagh, a teacher\n               and therapist with the Integrative Psychotherapy Practice in Dublin, specializing\n               in working with at-risk boys and men. Ronan is Adam's cousin. I make you all very\n               welcome, and I hope the House will join me.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036437","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two introductions or observances to make. First of all, I would like to wish my senior constituency assistant, Adam Schaan,\n               a happy 40th birthday. He joins us in the gallery today, along with Johnathan Raine,\n               my other assistant from Prince George. Happy birthday. All the very best. Joining Adam, all the way from the Emerald Isle, Dublin, is Ronan Lynagh, a teac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f60c009f2f4dd49b26db5f7e932eaab588c9eec1b65e51c1ab0e9a201a8904af"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93476d124d186238f0871ac9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036439,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome Executive Director for the Conservative Party, Angelo Isidorou\n               and our other senior staff, Philip DePenar, who are in the gallery today. Would you please make them most welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036439","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to welcome Executive Director for the Conservative Party, Angelo Isidorou\n               and our other senior staff, Philip DePenar, who are in the gallery today. Would you please make them most welcome?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a71e3237fbc69f8e69d060e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036440,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheldon Clare","venue":"Hansard","text":"The question that I have might take a little bit of additional research, so I understand\n               that. I'll just let fly and see how it goes. On May 7, 2026, during estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, the\n               minister stated that the On May 7, 2026, during estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, the minister stated that the improvements to the Kersley-Dale Landing Road washout,\n               the project near Quesnel, will cost $40 million. It is our understanding that the contract value of the project was $6,073,906.70 when\n               it was awarded to West Horizon Contracting Inc. on 9 April, 2025, by the ministry. My question is: why is there a roughly $34 million difference between the contract\n               value and the updated cost estimate provided by the minister earlier this month?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036440","member_id":"bc-mla-392","member_name":"Sheldon Clare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The question that I have might take a little bit of additional research, so I understand\n               that. I'll just let fly and see how it goes. On May 7, 2026, during estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, the\n               minister stated that the On May 7, 2026, during estimates for the Ministry of Transportation and Transit, the minister stated that the improvements to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6fb0ca022a674edd5f66848f50c20938148331fec6717b399c824ca6a74f18d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a11e27c4eab32b125ffa859805b636f29e2eb23149995d31671a5124e4fbf65"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8045208a7003a1a77c90464","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187126,"date":"2026-02-19T12:00:00+00:00","title":"VETERANS AND FIRST RESPONDERS MONTH ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m231-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m231-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187126","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70ce4fb3ab0666af07c12957","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187127,"date":"2026-02-19T12:00:00+00:00","title":"VETERANS AND FIRST RESPONDERS MONTH ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/m231-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/m231-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187127","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9af4dd639d849d6bc0875ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316794,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"In 2026 the Royal Canadian Legion will mark a historic milestone, 100 years of service\n               to veterans, their families and communities across the country. For a full century, the legion has stood as one of the most enduring and recognizable\n               institutions in Canadian public life. It was founded in the aftermath of the First\n               World War, at a time when thousands of returning soldiers were struggling with wounds,\n               trauma, unemployment and a society that was not yet prepared to meet their needs. Out of that moment came a powerful idea that those who served Out of that moment came a powerful idea — that those who served should never be left\n               to navigate their sacrifice alone. Since 1926, the legion has played a central role\n               in advocating for veterans' benefits, supporting those injured in service, assisting\n               families in crisis and building a culture of remembrance that has shaped generations\n               of Canadians. From poppy campaigns, Remembrance Day services, peer support, housing\n               assistance and community programs, the legion has both a practical support system\n               and a moral voice for those who have served. But anniversaries are not just about celebration. They are also about moments of reflection\n               and renewal. In recent years, many veterans have expressed frustration and disappointment\n               with the legion. Some feel disconnected from its structures. Some feel it no longer\n               reflects the diversity of today's military. Others feel their experiences, particularly\n               those of younger veterans, women, Indigenous service members and those with operational\n               stress injuries have not always been fully understood or adequately represented. Those\n               concerns should not be dismissed. They should be heard. The reality is that the nature of military service has changed. The needs of veterans\n               have changed. Like any institution that reaches its centennial, the legion now faces\n               a choice — to remain rooted only in tradition or to evolve in ways that preserve its\n               purpose while adapting to a new generation. I would suggest that the future of the legion depends not on walking away from it\n               but walking back into it. This is a moment for veterans themselves to reclaim ownership\n               of the organization that was built for them. To bring their voices, their experiences\n               and their expectations into its leadership. To revitalize branches, modernize programming\n               and ensure that the legion once again feels relevant, responsive and representative\n               of those who serve today. At the same time, in late January we heard international commentary that reminds us\n               why institutions like the legion still matter so deeply. We have seen in various forums\n               language used that diminishes or disrespects the service and sacrifice of Canadian\n               military personnel. That kind of rhetoric may be easy to offer from positions of comfort\n               and power but it stands in stark contrast to the realities faced by those who wear\n               the uniform. Veterans around the world make extraordinary sacrifices, and many Canadian veterans\n               have made the ultimate sacrifice. Their service, their injuries, their lives should\n               never be spoken of lightly, dismissed or reduced to political talking points. Canada has always stood with its allies in defence of peace, security and democratic\n               values. From the beaches of Normandy to peacekeeping missions, disaster response and\n               modern international operations, Canadian service members have consistently answered\n               the call, not for recognition, but out of duty. We remain proud of that legacy. We\n               remain proud of our veterans. We remain committed to honouring their service with\n               respect, gratitude and meaningful support. The legion does not belong to history; it belongs to veterans. To strive for another\n               hundred years, it must continue to be shaped by those it exists to support, not just\n               by a symbol of remembrance but as a living, evolving institution. That means making\n               space for difficult conversations. It means addressing governance issues. It means\n               embracing new forms of peer support, mental health advocacy, family services and community\n               engagement. It means ensuring that younger veterans see the legion not as something\n               inherited, but as something worth building. At its best, the legion has never been about buildings or ceremonies or traditions.\n               It has been about solidarity, about veterans standing up for one another when governments\n               failed, systems fell short or communities did not understand. That purpose remains\n               just as urgent today as it did in 1926. As we approach this centennial, I hope it will not only be marked by commemorations\n               of the past but by a renewed commitment to the future, a future where the legion is\n               once again a place where veterans feel heard, respected, supported and empowered.\n               Because the true legacy of the Royal Canadian Legion is not measured in years, it\n               is measured in whether those who serve know the citizens of Canada, the true north\n               and free, will always stand with them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316794","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"In 2026 the Royal Canadian Legion will mark a historic milestone, 100 years of service\n               to veterans, their families and communities across the country. For a full century, the legion has stood as one of the most enduring and recognizable\n               institutions in Canadian public life. It was founded in the aftermath of the First\n               World War, at a time when thousands","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6562e1c3f49bc77ef894b0e5f00e8774ae2380c9fddd2c70da90bd622d776eed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aeb1421006f0982d01e3d7981e720835c54b6bb3d76e567770a75af8926c517f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-142befde98a2a09d82b15ae7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316795,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government's reckless spending and incompetence has led to yet another broken\n               promise. We have parents and families all over this province upset about the cuts\n               to autistic funding. We have had multiples make quotes in the news, including: \"It\n               is going to be a choice between feeding my family or accessing therapy for my kids.\" This government is going to cost families across this province thousands of dollars\n               a year and not being able to access therapy for their families. To this Premier, how does he sleep at night knowing he's responsible for stripping\n               the funding away from 10,000 families with diverse needs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316795","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This government's reckless spending and incompetence has led to yet another broken\n               promise. We have parents and families all over this province upset about the cuts\n               to autistic funding. We have had multiples make quotes in the news, including: \"It\n               is going to be a choice between feeding my family or accessing therapy for my kids.\" This government is goi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["65663d787edad42c7e9cf838c9f40f5e657ec8795fd2cbe5756477295608da3d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d793820d8dcfdf07feb6fac1e480c804dbbde9d1048774f4fe816c807296c5e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ccbad1201fe3185a4a96d6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327912,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"Housing for seniors with consumption sites. I'm sure they're thrilled that their years\n               of work are paying for that. On March 31, Joe's Place, a 40-bed emergency shelter in Terrace, will have their security\n               not renewed by B.C. Housing. One city councillor said: \"Removing security is ill-advised,\n               unappreciated and, frankly, not acceptable.\" The city will now be picking up the tab\n               for security. Between July and September of 2025, RCMP officers spent excessive hours at that shelter.\n               An RCMP staff sergeant said: \"Before they had security, the number of hours were a\n               lot higher than they are currently, and this last quarter they have gone down significantly.\"\n               He expects this number to increase again when the minister cuts funding less than\n               a month from now. Residents deserve to feel safe when they seek out emergency shelter. To the minister, will she stand up today and reinstate security funding for Joe's\n               Place?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327912","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Housing for seniors with consumption sites. I'm sure they're thrilled that their years\n               of work are paying for that. On March 31, Joe's Place, a 40-bed emergency shelter in Terrace, will have their security\n               not renewed by B.C. Housing. One city councillor said: \"Removing security is ill-advised,\n               unappreciated and, frankly, not acceptable.\" The city will ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3661d68fac2dab82466c7011a0bd77a0090c429469f93cffe765e3e5522d02fe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a5df6fc01f7b5bca988d85dd0c58420646d3fe17af37f8a303ef00246020aec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-337ca4721c232208584d0b8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327913,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Happy birthday. We don't have folks down from Prince George very often. It was my pleasure today to\n               meet up with and have lunch with Chief Dolleen Logan, from Lheidli T'enneh, and Todd Corrigall, the senior vice president of Central Strategies. Would the House please welcome them here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327913","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Happy birthday. We don't have folks down from Prince George very often. It was my pleasure today to\n               meet up with and have lunch with Chief Dolleen Logan, from Lheidli T'enneh, and Todd Corrigall, the senior vice president of Central Strategies. Would the House please welcome them here today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["30a0842e363ed5228285f54e94049287c6e7d44bf79a0f6c20380516fd94493e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-81b6f4a640aa87a690f324a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327914,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I start my statement, can I request leave for an introduction, please?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327914","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Before I start my statement, can I request leave for an introduction, please?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300442","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Decorative arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art works","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44256","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Submarines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","label":"Women workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:300442","label":"Decorative arts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44256","label":"Submarines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","label":"Art works","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3e6f725fab89ed921f830ff69d804b849d3f530ee5686ff4db2e4b35171b3f4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b24b097714b2d3290f1886f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413653,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"As much as I appreciate the minister's answer, the work is not working. Our Northern\n               B.C. Therapeutic Community, although open, is operating at half capacity, with 20\n               of the 45 beds occupied, and it no longer takes forensic psychiatric patients. They can't fill the other beds due to critical staffing shortages. If people cannot\n               access treatment, if they cannot stabilize, then they cannot safely transition from\n               hospitals and from correctional facilities. What is the minister's plan to support these patients, and how will she make up for\n               the critical capacity that has been lost?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413653","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"As much as I appreciate the minister's answer, the work is not working. Our Northern\n               B.C. Therapeutic Community, although open, is operating at half capacity, with 20\n               of the 45 beds occupied, and it no longer takes forensic psychiatric patients. They can't fill the other beds due to critical staffing shortages. If people cannot\n               access treatment, if they","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51111203cda4f5e81d55af7f75ff8ddecd8e6925c99c6737e1aa67624616b1a1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e5d3748345ff536e77b48fe3bb39b70200b26504b1328b77495e5cd13bcf4b6f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5efe4abaaddc81a440cdd761","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413654,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today the gallery is full of families whose children depend on autism supports. Amber wrote to us about her son, diagnosed with autism at just a year old. He is only now\n               beginning to speak, regulate and build the basic skills he needs because of early\n               intervention. However, her son may soon be considered not autistic enough to qualify\n               for support. To the minister. Why are you taking away funding from a child who is just beginning\n               to thrive?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413654","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today the gallery is full of families whose children depend on autism supports. Amber wrote to us about her son, diagnosed with autism at just a year old. He is only now\n               beginning to speak, regulate and build the basic skills he needs because of early\n               intervention. However, her son may soon be considered not autistic enough to qualify\n               for support. To th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a83b64b90e20a50853c2543f40d1b8f93ef2527b95b59b6eefd5f55d3551686"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bc58c1b292b96faa99f1702b63e38eaf83cf5d87a96f035c86638abefe754fef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-064548915a2545ca7a221d45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720115,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to acknowledge the 20th anniversary of the symposium on missing and murdered\n               Indigenous women and girls held in Prince George last week. This gathering brought\n               together families, survivors, community advocates and leaders from across northern\n               British Columbia, who continue to carry grief but also a determination to be heard. The stories shared were not abstract. They were deeply personal. They reflected lives\n               lost, families forever changed and communities still searching for answers. For many\n               in the North, this issue is not distant; it is part of everyday reality. Highways that connect our communities, like Highway 16, have also come to symbolize\n               risk, loss and unresolved justice. What stood out at the symposium was not only the\n               pain but the persistence. Families continue to call for meaningful action; for coordination\n               between agencies; and for systems that respond when someone goes missing, not days\n               later but immediately. This is about recognizing that despite years of reports, recommendations and announcements,\n               too many families still feel they are navigating this crisis alone. I want to acknowledge the families who attended the symposium, who shared their stories\n               and who continue to live with unimaginable loss. Parents should not have to become\n               advocates as a result of losing a child. Yet too many are forced into that role simply\n               to seek answers and accountability. Their courage in speaking out again and again is something that this House must never\n               take for granted. Because behind every statistic is a name, behind every name is a\n               family, behind every family is a call for action that cannot continue Behind every statistic is a name, behind every name is a family, and behind every\n               family is a call for action that cannot continue to go unanswered. My prayers and\n               thoughts are offered to the families, friends and communities that have lost their\n               loved ones. Your frustration and continued advocacy is acknowledged and respected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720115","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to acknowledge the 20th anniversary of the symposium on missing and murdered\n               Indigenous women and girls held in Prince George last week. This gathering brought\n               together families, survivors, community advocates and leaders from across northern\n               British Columbia, who continue to carry grief but also a determination to be heard. The stories sha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f0a8c06d7f77a34624ef5a331628bc5a981af6b2d231ba75550a178b12d9c24"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2355425446735f6c77cfef45","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720120,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"You're correct. They are seeing investments, investments in window bars, investments\n               in video cameras, investments in security. Mary, a business owner in my riding, has faced repeated break and entries and property\n               damage. On one occasion, she had an unhoused woman break into the back door of her\n               business and stuff dresses into garbage bags while she had customers in the store.\n               Protecting her customers, she wrestled the woman out until police arrived and detained\n               her. The woman had been arrested 39 times prior to this incident. The next day she found the same woman trying to break down the back door with a brick.\n               Once again, the police were called. This is just one story, one story that this business\n               owner has shared with me. When are business owners like Mary going to stop suffering from this government's\n               failed policies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720120","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You're correct. They are seeing investments, investments in window bars, investments\n               in video cameras, investments in security. Mary, a business owner in my riding, has faced repeated break and entries and property\n               damage. On one occasion, she had an unhoused woman break into the back door of her\n               business and stuff dresses into garbage bags while she ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6785f3cddab405738681373895aa621e7c91107c08636e0e616528f574e2e413"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9cb8d977cac96cc8d475fc9e1e7845fce1b8e3047280e87fecbfc4666223303d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-616da7c47e9c6ea5b057272b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721195,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"This person does not need an introduction for those of us that work in this House,\n               but for those in the gallery, I would like to introduce you to the Clerk of the Legislature,\n               Kate Ryan-Lloyd, who just completed her fourth Boston Marathon in person, with a time\n               of 3 hours, 54 minutes, 52 seconds. Mr. Speaker, I would just like to thank her for her incredible dedication and commitment,\n               not only to how this House runs and the support she gives the staff here but for showing\n               that to the community and the province. She does that for everything that she puts\n               her mind to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721195","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This person does not need an introduction for those of us that work in this House,\n               but for those in the gallery, I would like to introduce you to the Clerk of the Legislature,\n               Kate Ryan-Lloyd, who just completed her fourth Boston Marathon in person, with a time\n               of 3 hours, 54 minutes, 52 seconds. Mr. Speaker, I would just like to thank her for her incre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-479e69592d0f6c5406ea55ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728786,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm very glad that the other side actually heard something that somebody is saying\n               to them, and I have never heard doctors say they are co-governing. When the opposition asked yesterday if the province is co-governing, the Premier said:\n               \"The opposition is deliberately twisting this to spread fear.\" Mr. Speaker, this is not true. We are simply seeking clarity over this incredibly\n               important issue, as we cannot trust this government. We have just heard the abysmal\n               track record. The Regional Chief of the Assembly of First Nations says that they have entered into\n               co-governance. The Premier says they have not. Will the Premier publicly acknowledge\n               this co-governance is now the root of all of this chaos?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728786","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm very glad that the other side actually heard something that somebody is saying\n               to them, and I have never heard doctors say they are co-governing. When the opposition asked yesterday if the province is co-governing, the Premier said:\n               \"The opposition is deliberately twisting this to spread fear.\" Mr. Speaker, this is not true. We are simply seeking clarity over this","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["506d8ad9244ef944a350f720ae8cc9937ef6d4cae8b0572dd56f0e7a562abb86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["07b63a0b0cafaaf7a4a05e36f03fc2f8b297777fa18735e47224c06fdeaecd61"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6b5749e1b785dec1debea86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728792,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"Since 1949 the National Newspaper Awards have recognized excellence in newspaper\n               and online journalism. And for the second time in history, the Prince George Citizen , the work of one of our own, was judged to be the best by the NNA panel. Please welcome the House in congratulating the Citizen 's managing editor, Kennedy Gordon, as he has won the Claude Ryan Award for Editorial\n               Writing for his work in 2025.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728792","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Since 1949 the National Newspaper Awards have recognized excellence in newspaper\n               and online journalism. And for the second time in history, the Prince George Citizen , the work of one of our own, was judged to be the best by the NNA panel. Please welcome the House in congratulating the Citizen 's managing editor, Kennedy Gordon, as he has won the Claude Ryan Award for Editorial\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6c93986f7faf66f4b8fc54a648b5d9e2e417aa43b9674e95bddc5879e5522759"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-005ea43cdd52e8733536ce40","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752164,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to introduce some distinguished guests today. Up in the gallery we have\n               Const. Reuben Yance from VicPD, Const. Pierson York from VicPD, Const. Alex Erwin\n               from VicPD, Const. Ross Mackenzie, also from VicPD. We also have assistant fire chief\n               Michael Holliday from Prince George, along with one of his local firefighters, Carl\n               Krause. Jason Chan is also here. He is the president of the B.C. Police Association. Will everybody please make them feel welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752164","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to introduce some distinguished guests today. Up in the gallery we have\n               Const. Reuben Yance from VicPD, Const. Pierson York from VicPD, Const. Alex Erwin\n               from VicPD, Const. Ross Mackenzie, also from VicPD. We also have assistant fire chief\n               Michael Holliday from Prince George, along with one of his local firefighters, Carl\n               Kra","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d446a598156de4059fb7b767723cd44e75a82e353ea52d7ff4dccfd03d627eed"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a53459eceb07f0ff59a9557d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752165,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have several special guests joining us today. They are family and friends that have\n               been impacted by the Highway of Tears. They have travelled from the North to participate\n               in the Red Dress ceremony being held in the Hall of Honour today at noon. Joining us from Prince George is Darlene McIntosh. She is the Elder and Ambassador\n               for Lheidli T'enneh Nation, Tammy Meisey from the Red Dress Society, Brenda Wilson from the Highway of\n               Tears. From Smithers, we have two MMIWG2S advocates, Jackie Bose and Dhailly Nicall.\n               From Quesnel, we have Luanne Montgomery, and from Terrace, we have Denise Halfyard\n               from the Tears to Hope Society. Can everybody in the chamber and in the House, please make them feel welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752165","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have several special guests joining us today. They are family and friends that have\n               been impacted by the Highway of Tears. They have travelled from the North to participate\n               in the Red Dress ceremony being held in the Hall of Honour today at noon. Joining us from Prince George is Darlene McIntosh. She is the Elder and Ambassador\n               for Lheidli T'enneh Nat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","label":"Heritage buildings","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac7e0f406d1e27b4afc699f2027413e89d91c1a719892690a55b70b0edf9f1a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e619b7a31d25303463568b725951bb18c103c8e17eef2d0434b570ecf00b9fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b6abc673f80ca437021962c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036398,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rosalyn Bird","venue":"Hansard","text":"The only thing this government is doing is currently repacing long-term-care beds. Along with punishing seniors, this government is so desperate for revenue they're\n               eliminating the northern and rural tax homeowner benefit. This means a $200 increase\n               in property taxes for the majority of homeowners outside the Lower Mainland. Will the Minister of State for Local Government and Rural Communities stand up and\n               oppose this hike in property taxes directly impacting her and so many B.C. constituents?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036398","member_id":"bc-mla-393","member_name":"Rosalyn Bird","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The only thing this government is doing is currently repacing long-term-care beds. Along with punishing seniors, this government is so desperate for revenue they're\n               eliminating the northern and rural tax homeowner benefit. This means a $200 increase\n               in property taxes for the majority of homeowners outside the Lower Mainland. Will the Minister of State for Local Govern","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68150e12b6474a15837c5bfa723eb68e7ee700f96302bc644c6b5214a7c462bc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03a61c7871c748e558f1857b9d34e81afb4e4ab36a2cfc6f98575b1f4f71b8e4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97cf2c855ce8b03e334e2f20","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86149,"date":"2026-02-12T08:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Speaker and Members of the Legislative Assembly, in closing this first session\n               of the 43rd parliament of British Columbia, on behalf of all British Columbians, I\n               note that in this session we enacted 33 bills covering areas of substance and importance\n               to the people of this province. I wish to express my appreciation for the care and attention you have given to your\n               deliberations and the service that you have provided to our great and beautiful province. I now relieve you of your legislative duties. \"Splendor sine occasu.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86149","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Hon. Speaker and Members of the Legislative Assembly, in closing this first session\n               of the 43rd parliament of British Columbia, on behalf of all British Columbians, I\n               note that in this session we enacted 33 bills covering areas of substance and importance\n               to the people of this province. I wish to express my appreciation for the care and attention you ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc5e55e886559441452e1958c7e5ce7384647feb88ad80cc52ededc1d8f0a794"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f48b0ed2696d5084cb9dc212","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316808,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thanks to my colleague opposite. I too would like to welcome Chief Davis and the\n               whole group from the Doig River. I look forward to meeting with you tomorrow, and,\n               of course, former member Dan Davies as well. I'll give him a slight nod, but a bigger\n               nod to the rest. Thanks, everybody.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316808","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thanks to my colleague opposite. I too would like to welcome Chief Davis and the\n               whole group from the Doig River. I look forward to meeting with you tomorrow, and,\n               of course, former member Dan Davies as well. I'll give him a slight nod, but a bigger\n               nod to the rest. Thanks, everybody.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168630","label":"Rivers","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8899e6921e58441196c19b020bd06eb2cf6003d81c944016ac7b22b31d00d0c8","23a9d80e2e392934c4d33e1d71dbd5c90225ac85b3a95cc5b9072b85ac677d9f","0408f2e8e6dbdf79dd90ab799cde4c9f8af0cc97589b0546891dec6a1e200f95"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a796def78415b389cf7bbf44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316809,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've got representatives from one of British Columbia's largest companies. We've\n               got some folks from Telus here. We've got Juggy Sihota, vice-president, as well as\n               Richa Sharma from government relations. I also want to give a shout-out to Richa Sharma, who also serves on the board of governors\n               for Royal Roads University in my community of Langford and that of my colleague from\n               the West Shore. Will the House please join in this opportunity of making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316809","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"We've got representatives from one of British Columbia's largest companies. We've\n               got some folks from Telus here. We've got Juggy Sihota, vice-president, as well as\n               Richa Sharma from government relations. I also want to give a shout-out to Richa Sharma, who also serves on the board of governors\n               for Royal Roads University in my community of Langford and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e8d1d5f34df123ff235a3f842eed0f344cd1ab13712f2d243c6398640bb95b5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d6d72519fcdde0155539e3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316810,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to seek leave for an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316810","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I would like to seek leave for an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","label":"Personal income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84da3ae05c12138975ab0417fbf4d04061bff913f763287bd38aef10eee3b9d1","660bce0e698ba4646954dd34b0499deed7ca3f1b1d10832cd33e2e76ae9dbe21","42e479a85d7565f1f106d2211b5cbc15e7241ce30441e6e3f0c0fb244c14f573"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b4a511eebdcae52d1b55788","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316811,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to really point out to the members opposite that our redesign for children\n               and youth with support needs was necessary in our province — 475 million new dollars\n               for children and youth with disabilities. This has never been done before in this\n               province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316811","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I want to really point out to the members opposite that our redesign for children\n               and youth with support needs was necessary in our province — 475 million new dollars\n               for children and youth with disabilities. This has never been done before in this\n               province.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bea2b35a39a02c1208b64fa35f90722e1fb60a1a0c93a787cf497a18e30c48e","d20a1e2a4e2990307d95cdde77b986d5db902d6de1415071b620494fff95d082","feb168ed5e9c6e31057913256678f9cb8822ee831581ff61f915cfc7a874754b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["12681adac01674c3dfb175a5b8c9446e8ad8445687612358335709eb92b62545"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3f9422b30f000f9332cf2be0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316812,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill be introduced and read for the first time now. I'm pleased to introduce legislation to amend the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act. FOIPPA has two fundamental purposes. It protects people's privacy,\n               and it upholds the public's right to access information held by public bodies. These\n               principles are essential to public trust, transparency and accountability. The amendments before the House today are about ensuring this important legislation\n               continues to work for people in British Columbia in a modern digital environment.\n               These proposed changes will support more connected, people-centred government services\n               while maintaining strong privacy protection. They will also introduce practical efficiencies\n               to how freedom of information requests are processed, helping public bodies better\n               manage growing volumes These proposed changes will support more connected, people-centred government services\n               while maintaining strong privacy protection. They will also introduce practical efficiencies\n               to how freedom-of-information requests are processed, helping public bodies better\n               manage growing volumes and complexity without limiting people's rights to access. Many of the changes respond to recommendations made by the Information and Privacy\n               Commissioner's office and pass special committees to review FOIPPA. At their core,\n               these amendments are about improving how people experience government, making services\n               easier to access, reducing duplication and enabling more transparent, people-centred\n               service delivery. I look forward to discussing the bill further with members during the second reading.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316812","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I move that the bill be introduced and read for the first time now. I'm pleased to introduce legislation to amend the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act. FOIPPA has two fundamental purposes. It protects people's privacy,\n               and it upholds the public's right to access information held by public bodies. These\n               principles are essential to pub","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["32bafe901cb7d256536c26c4383616f06af9e3e454dffa67893ff56f7a764d31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6579ed4940688b229d53f6dbab1d95376532e45cbadea4bb5d71091e407af0f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b565c3309053b0e718d1afa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316813,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call second reading of Bill 5, Trade Recognition Act.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316813","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I call second reading of Bill 5, Trade Recognition Act.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb3a569c91b9642c8dbcf5bb34a0c9c83d8ac2181c0c2096080f0337a30ff0f8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-134e25fa5b9454c8a752d757","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327923,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question. I should be clear that the agreement that\n               the member refers to was an agreement signed with the federal government, not the\n               provincial government, so I did not sit at a negotiation table. I have not seen the\n               text of the agreement the member refers to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327923","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question. I should be clear that the agreement that\n               the member refers to was an agreement signed with the federal government, not the\n               provincial government, so I did not sit at a negotiation table. I have not seen the\n               text of the agreement the member refers to.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ef28f1a9e9818e027953eb9fe30bd2e89a900c45e025b4e99367f1a5653dffe","c33e61ed77e8553d69823a9e9c792688303067abe2ac36d1ba0d7d0af8e98128","df2c7dd1215b13bd0d4af1a65c6ac021c33b1d2f8120471c670e181a1980a5ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["352eb4ed182e89c19cd11af73dff6b091a9e8beca55f63ef71ec6b10a9917ba1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25133821aafebc19231aba7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327924,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome my aunt Kathleen Boyle and my uncle Rich Hall, who are here joining\n               us for question period, a retired health care worker–educator and our family's most\n               talented woodworker and carpenter — which is a low bar in my family, but still we're\n               delighted to have his skills. Mr. Speaker, I'm not allowed to have favourites, because I have a large family, but\n               let me just say that Aunt Kathleen and Uncle Rich have been so supportive and fun\n               through my entire life. I'm lucky to live so close to them, and my kids love spending\n               time with them. They're here with their friend Linda, who lives here locally. I'm\n               so glad to have them all. Will the House join me in making them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327924","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome my aunt Kathleen Boyle and my uncle Rich Hall, who are here joining\n               us for question period, a retired health care worker–educator and our family's most\n               talented woodworker and carpenter — which is a low bar in my family, but still we're\n               delighted to have his skills. Mr. Speaker, I'm not allowed to have favourites, because I have a la","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035804","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Independent living","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035804","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Independent living","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Air safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Municipal buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035804","label":"Independent living","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","label":"Municipal buildings","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42545","label":"Air safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2b5e55a8e6800fd903d4505e33a57c60692d820463019153462d6c0170e6853","422663e4be89e5981f920d9662312a6a436ba041820fe1991bfc6d362a44593b","e39c6d00c5a02eb2070fec86b8b4d59e7ccec2b2094aa1a2cc43ac96b33a2256"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d90f94dae75b5422c825f7b19a59d8e7e35e756f2a5ffd63de111e6c4873a43d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f58ab9649c9503f08d4dee60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327925,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to thank the AG for your time, and we'll move on to ICBC. Do you need like one minute to move?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327925","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I just want to thank the AG for your time, and we'll move on to ICBC. Do you need like one minute to move?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Stock markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034394","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034394","label":"Capital markets","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035604","label":"Hazardous materials transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037228","label":"Stock markets","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94c3543a2cd29d1c4e204e9d45a36376b9dad36b77110e3783d8837f4ce46c63","87b3e90b00fadd1b74b4837c1ef26d7334e79c329dad3004f5879358f20e4611","29aa34f1a6e810f886948fa14b13c26ed3c7507b97bbd42cb5e56b91f9e074b2","1795a2683c6d06cf3cb626c8c91420221b6e5279e90d2534003646968f0d9ec1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fe9969a1ed85845d91d0dd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327926,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy birthday to you, Happy birthday to you, Happy birthday, dear Speaker Happy birthday to you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327926","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Happy birthday to you, Happy birthday to you, Happy birthday, dear Speaker Happy birthday to you.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104304","label":"Equipment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b1527f2617a65c27768c571f781c3b184ea8fce2d4943028fc073b745234757","ae48cddf70ea5453ebc77a133613b0c7153e623a6ef7902e57abcee3770b6e01","b62d8893f84072256f4af694da408be7d0a93a708c5c02eb7a6095b748d15dd7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a898a1abaeb4f50d4f178ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327927,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, I invite the member to read the Hansard . We talked about this quite consistently through the estimates process. Now, the issue seems to be, though, that the opposition rejects working with First\n               Nations people, working with First Nations governments. When their party puts out\n               online that the xwməθkwəy̓əm is coming for your home, when they're coming for your land, when it couldn't be further....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327927","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Well, I invite the member to read the Hansard . We talked about this quite consistently through the estimates process. Now, the issue seems to be, though, that the opposition rejects working with First\n               Nations people, working with First Nations governments. When their party puts out\n               online that the xwməθkwəy̓əm is coming for your home, when they're coming for your lan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Steel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Parks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035413","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Full-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035413","label":"Full-time employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037219","label":"Steel","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501148","label":"Parks","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a751e00a60eaf8997240543b12b96870285acd92d525d4f49a1b34390e67cefa","815224a86d24cc74e5dd7fa183618985ad34e2b279cd70fe72dd38c270f29b4c","5b1dc1ad3e8f722329c1cd0d2c5b3f27e76f79f7d5e8f6c9640c79e1fd0fcff4","795e8c0c19717b3ba71c32fff20bad2d0baeab4dd0e9f0ad008e1480ca248292"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e0fb5aaccac0fee1b5248ade44a6aff0d83858d4a2a1dfe71f32d69a9ef21f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e04fb91b81ef924a734d04c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327928,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to represent the constituents and members across Oak Bay–Gordon Head, whom it is my great privilege and honour to represent, and to speak today to some\n               of issues that I know I've had questions about from members across the community,\n               whether that's such a diverse community of seniors, working families, businesses,\n               small businesses, and young students that are at the university and college. The issues I hear from them are common, of course — challenges with affordability\n               in these times of rising prices, concerns about caring for a loved one, a family member,\n               caring for aging parents. The issues across all of them are really the things that\n               I carry with me into this House every day, and I'm going to speak to some of the ways\n               that Budget 2026 helps to deliver for them. I'm really proud of the ways that this budget does help to deliver for community members\n               by protecting the programs and services that they need. The budget puts people at\n               the heart, tackling the challenges that families face, supporting businesses in uncertain\n               times, and laying the groundwork for a stronger B.C. Budget 2026 prepares us to move forward, to build a stronger economy while keeping\n               people at the centre of every decision. It invests in communities, strengthens essential\n               services, and ensures that the people in B.C. thrive today and into the future. To build a strong future, Budget 2026 outlines multiple measures that strengthen our\n               economy. It's about making thoughtful choices to protect the To build a strong future, Budget 2026 outlines multiple measures that strengthen our\n               economy. It's about making thoughtful choices to protect the services British Columbians\n               rely on, while we position the province to be resilient and strong in the long term. I want to start by talking about health care, because that's a key issue across our\n               communities. By expanding access, this budget is supporting health professionals and\n               strengthening mental health and addiction services. We're enhancing education and\n               supports for families and children as well, ensuring that young people have their\n               best start in life. We're investing in communities and infrastructure to make schools and hospitals, transit\n               and local facilities safer and more connected. We're supporting job-making opportunities\n               by helping businesses to innovate, grow and create meaningful jobs across our province.\n               Our government is committed to delivering this for the people of British Columbia. Since 2017, we've been working to strengthen the services that families rely on, expand\n               the opportunities for our young people and ensure communities are safer, healthier\n               and more connected. We're bringing child care costs down and expanding supports that\n               families need. Budget 2026 invests $330 million, over three years, to protect and stabilize the progress\n               we've made in child care. Let me restate that. We are investing more in our child\n               care because we know how critical that is for women and families. As we come closer\n               to International Women's Day, I know the emphasis that we need to be placing on ensuring\n               women have the supports they need. At the same time, we're continuing to strengthen supports for children and youth with\n               diverse needs. With $475 million in investment over three years, we're building a\n               more flexible, more equitable support system to ensure they can access the resources\n               they need to thrive and live full and happy lives. Budget 2026 continues the work our government has been doing to rebuild our K-to-12\n               system. After the devastating challenges and cuts under the Liberal government, our\n               budget is reinvesting both in building schools and in adequately funding the teachers\n               and the supports that are needed. With $634 million in new K-to-12 funding over three years, including much-needed investments\n               in the classroom enhancement fund, it will help bring more teachers, more special\n               education supports and more counselors into our classrooms. This is something I hear\n               from family members and from teachers across our community: it's so critical that\n               we're continuing to support these pieces of our education system. I want to turn to safety, something else that we hear across greater Victoria. There\n               have been concerns about safety for community members and businesses. I'm so grateful\n               to the city of Victoria for their community safety and well-being plan — which, I\n               have heard, from businesses and service providers, is making a difference on the ground\n               in Victoria. With $139 million in new funding for justice and public safety, our government, in\n               Budget 2026, is continuing to support this kind of work, reducing repeat and violent\n               offenders and supporting timely access to justice. We've been lobbying and working\n               with the federal government to ensure that we have the kind of protections we need\n               for our businesses and our community members, through that justice reform. On capital, there was a huge infrastructure deficit when we came into government in\n               2017 — a huge infrastructure deficit left by a government that hadn't built the kind\n               of investment in schools, hospitals and infrastructure that was needed over those\n               17 years. We've been building the capital, but it comes at a cost, because when you\n               don't build for decades and then you need to, it becomes quite a bit more expensive. Our government is continuing to invest in the capital that we need to support our\n               student housing, our hospitals, our schools, our transit, across communities from\n               Vancouver, Surrey and Mission to Prince Rupert, creating jobs, improving lives and\n               ensuring that we're building the services and infrastructure people need. We're also working to ensure, when people come to get the services they need, that\n               those services are there. In Budget 2026, health care was made a huge priority and\n               continues to be invested in with $2.8 billion in new funding, over three years, to\n               expand capacity and improve access for people in B.C. This includes $2.3 billion to grow our province's health care system capacity, hiring\n               more doctors, nurses and health care professionals. Because I've heard across our\n               community there are still members not connected to a family doctor or nurse practitioner,\n               we're connecting people every day, but we know there's more to do. That's why this\n               investment is in Budget 2026. We're advancing planning and development with the operation of more hospitals and\n               health facilities and, of course, the new training We're advancing planning and development with the operation of more hospitals and\n               health facilities. And of course, the new training facility for doctors that we opened,\n               the new medical school, is going to be opening its doors in September. This year Budget 2026 also introduces new investments in in vitro fertilization coverage,\n               supporting nearly 1,800 families to help build their families. We're securing hundreds\n               of millions of federal contributions, also, to expand essential medications, including\n               diabetes treatment and enhanced menopausal hormone therapy, which became covered just\n               last weekend. Also, we're improving supports for seniors outside of hospital settings,\n               ensuring they can receive high-quality care closer to home and in their homes, maintaining\n               independence in their communities as they age. I want to turn now to some of the things that are happening right here in our south\n               Island community of Oak Bay–Gordon Head. In Budget 2026, there are investments in post-secondary, with the University of\n               Victoria's engineering and computer science building, a new building that'll give\n               space for 500 more students, delivering on the province's commitment to new technology\n               seats throughout B.C. It's expected to support 604 direct and indirect jobs, and the\n               province is committing $97 million towards the cost of that project. Also, Camosun College. Students at Camosun will soon have on-campus student housing\n               for the first time at the Lansdowne campus. A new six-storey wood-frame building will\n               combine five floors of student housing alongside additional amenities and services. Other investments across the south Island that we're continuing to make in this budget\n               include long-term care in Colwood. We know that on the south Island long-term care\n               is needed, as our population has a high proportion of seniors. That's why we're investing\n               in a new facility in Colwood for a total of 298 residents. Additionally, our government\n               invested in the new centre for Indigenous law at the University of Victoria, a groundbreaking\n               investment in a university, the world's first joint degree program in Indigenous law.\n               It has a beautiful new building on campus. Other investments that this government has been making from 2008 to 2025 include schools\n               like Cedar Hill Middle School and Victoria High School, upgrading and making schools\n               safer and building new spaces. I want to speak for a minute about the housing side, because there have been concerns\n               raised around what this budget delivers for affordable housing. One of the things\n               that's really important to note is that since 2017, this province, our government\n               has been delivering more than 95,000 homes in communities throughout B.C. We are seeing\n               rents fall. Asking rents fell 4.7 percent compared to this time last year. That's\n               because our government has been doing the work to ensure that we're building non-market\n               and market housing that people need. B.C.'s renter tax credit is also part of this, helping renters with up to 400 per\n               year for low- and moderate-income renters, individuals and families. B.C. also capped\n               the maximum allowable rent increase and tied it to inflation, at 2.3 percent in 2026,\n               down from 3 percent in 2025. That rent control, when I talk to students and working\n               families in our community, has been a critical part of the affordability, helping\n               them tackle affordability. We continue to be committed to ensuring that we're helping\n               with housing affordability through that rent control. As part of the federal budget, GST has been eliminated on first-time home buyers on\n               homes up to $1 million to help with affordability for home buyers. Of course, there\n               are thousands of more units still coming, across our province, as we continue to work\n               on building the kind of housing that people need in terms of affordable, below market\n               and market. In the Oak Bay–Gordon Head area, there have been huge investments across housing and units that have been built\n               in a range of different types of affordable housing by our government. This includes,\n               for example, Balmoral Road development in Victoria, 56 new permanent homes with supports.\n               Princess Avenue, 28 units of transitional housing, in partnership with the John Howard\n               Society. Discovery Street, 94 of the former Capital City Centre Hotel rooms, 96 in\n               temporary supportive housing units. Nigel Valley housing, 70 new affordable rental homes for people with low or moderate incomes.\n               The Juniper, 48 self-contained furnished studio homes for people at risk of homelessness.\n               Meeres Street, 48 new permanent supportive homes for young adults 19 to 27. The Juniper, 48 self-contained furnished studio homes for people at risk of homelessness. Meares Street, 48 new permanent supportive homes for young adults 19 to 27. Kwum Kwum Lelum, 45 homes for Indigenous people experiencing homelessness. Linwood Court in Saanich, 98 one-bedroom affordable homes for seniors. SȾÁUTW̱ First Nation in Saanich, a five-storey building with 24 two-bedroom suites for working\n               families. Across town at Douglas Street, 100 affordable rental homes for individuals, seniors\n               and families and 54 supportive homes. Burnside at Cecilia Road, 88 new affordable homes for low- to moderate-income individuals,\n               families and people with disabilities. Our government is working to build the kinds of homes people need — working families,\n               seniors, young people, Indigenous people experiencing homelessness — across the range\n               of housing, and we're going to continue to do that work. I want to turn for a moment to the tax side of this budget. In order to deliver the\n               programs and services our community needs, we need to see a growing economy, and we\n               also need to focus on tax fairness. I've spent much of my career working on budget\n               analysis and tax fairness, and I'm proud of the work that this budget does to both\n               revenue generation and tax fairness. The government's been focused on keeping costs down for people, reducing taxes for\n               middle-income and working people. Global uncertainty is slowing growth for everywhere.\n               High costs, global instability and volatile commodity prices are putting pressure\n               on public finances.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327928","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to represent the constituents and members across Oak Bay–Gordon Head, whom it is my great privilege and honour to represent, and to speak today to some\n               of issues that I know I've had questions about from members across the community,\n               whether that's such a diverse community of seniors, working families, businesses,\n               small businesses, and youn","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3439259fc0b300038b106e23a7a75029a112dddced88bf28aa2a1c90a92110c7","2494f0e63b392b36ede8a4f0a0ab2349f396541318a8512788af265807dacf04"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eacdf42adc3b2d3136d5ba383d4163ca70598ef8e34ec55f3ca289d584b9be62"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24c8ba3e13f0fa8d4a9f6272","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359642,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday I had the privilege of introducing and welcoming representatives from the\n               Canadian Home Builders Association. There are more folks in the House today. I'm looking\n               forward to meeting with them later today. I also am again delighted to introduce and welcome members from the B.C. Real Estate\n               Association, who are in Victoria for their Government Liaison Days. It's a busy week\n               for housing here. So welcome to the Canadian Home Builders and the B.C. Real Estate Association. And I'm just going to add one personal plug of a welcome to Sam Wyatt, who is the\n               chair of the Greater Vancouver realtors and a constituent in Vancouver–Little Mountain and a dedicated community volunteer. Please join me in welcoming them all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359642","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Yesterday I had the privilege of introducing and welcoming representatives from the\n               Canadian Home Builders Association. There are more folks in the House today. I'm looking\n               forward to meeting with them later today. I also am again delighted to introduce and welcome members from the B.C. Real Estate\n               Association, who are in Victoria for their Government L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:202314","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Lead","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real property services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035697","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Home education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Estates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Estates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Estates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035157","label":"Estates","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035697","label":"Home education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083678","label":"Real property services","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:202314","label":"Lead","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f28f7e6b686ab56df87c5eea361f55f795f64a964ee72b95986e00a31e492e43","18de887af4b0dc108cfe6bb628f6472b19196cc1d1c28c714aa1a9084a4e4b9f","45919350d784a0b18393e1774221909ccfc8fdaab38c0c1849f4c93e8992be53","ff06e94a4a3802de95e7435c5505fbf048b5aaa0ea6212821531ec1f239c50cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec404f09e01a128a814dc7c45ec7b6eab4ca36e273c42790d26f7672428ca121"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a11fb7032c4ef484d1fc1d17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359643,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359643","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a1ad493e926f95e556a4876eb9fee2b91b1b745626f9be37a3cbeb6cfbf5a460"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03555b09ec91bb769e67372f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359644,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the member for the question. I will talk to any family and any parent who\n               has a question for me, and I have met with many of them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359644","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I thank the member for the question. I will talk to any family and any parent who\n               has a question for me, and I have met with many of them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59a7924627e9b4e8d3391f06a76ae60edc833068d81034c204ee3a937bc78e1d","4154f0fe18520630dbe0e9991516fa24a28a4becf087bd8ddb964cebfaba3d81"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b01c59f61ab63d4aea55f6b1273bb0b145cff4137b20edd346c5e6a9748c7b1e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02ffde2e9204028af1ea72ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359645,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm also delighted today to welcome members of our outstanding GCPE team, who are\n               joining us in the gallery: Caroline McAndrews, Matthew Borghese, Angela Soukoreff, Andrew Hughes, Mahias Reen and many other members of the team who weren't able to\n               join. I really want to recognize the tireless work that this team does on public engagement\n               and communications, their dedication and professionalism and their steady support\n               and good humour in everything that they do. Really grateful to get to work with them. I also have my chief of staff, Lauren Reid, here. Her mom, Colleen Reid, is visiting\n               from Ontario to the Legislature for the very first time. Colleen is a proud mom of\n               three and was a dental hygienist for 42 years before retiring and supporting her husband\n               and their family business in downtown Kingston. Colleen, your daughter is doing amazing work here. We're so grateful to get to work\n               with her. Will the House join me in Colleen, your daughter is doing amazing work here. We're so grateful to get to work\n               with her. Will the House join me in making all of them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359645","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm also delighted today to welcome members of our outstanding GCPE team, who are\n               joining us in the gallery: Caroline McAndrews, Matthew Borghese, Angela Soukoreff, Andrew Hughes, Mahias Reen and many other members of the team who weren't able to\n               join. I really want to recognize the tireless work that this team does on public engagement\n               and communicatio","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drinking water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47475","label":"Drinking water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","label":"Assistive technologies","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3ececaa34adce96abb8d3c7d6de1769be8e899ca31d06493f77781f9217186b","5c2802e213b429c5ac6f6453a36707b2cb0199b0ad7f92e36b2901c7165976bb","65186cdc4f09043e58df87e76243d5796b88f534e07ba3a18df1e9c3a4be3c53"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f3ae09eac52ec74c35cf34b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359646,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I listened closely to my colleague across the way's words. She's correct. Words are\n               important, and words are very much relevant to this debate, because we're talking\n               about B.C.'s human rights code. She shared concerns that maybe people who had a health issue might not be covered\n               in the code. Well, I can assure her that a quick google, a quick check on the internet,\n               a quick conversation would tell her that indeed they are. If that was a concern, I would hope that members would do research before coming into\n               the debate. Because these words matter. To suggest that people with health conditions\n               aren't covered by the code doesn't tell the reality of what actually is covered. She wanted clarity on words. The Conservatives wanted clarity on words, and they said\n               we need to be clear about who's covered and who's not. Yet their amendment completely\n               eliminates who is protected by B.C.'s human rights code. It makes what was explicit\n               invisible. So if the concern was that we don't know who's covered, she's done exactly that through\n               her amendment. She's deliberately taken out those people who are covered, and she\n               suggests that, well, maybe more people should be added to the list. Well, if she supports the human rights code, I would urge her to support it, not to\n               bring forward an amendment that would take out support for the covered grounds of\n               discrimination in the human rights code, or move an amendment to suggest more people\n               should be covered in the human rights code. But that's not what this is about. That's not what this is about. Of course, hate\n               against anybody is wrong. But you know what? We need But that's not what this is about. That's not what this is about. Of course, hate\n               against anybody is wrong. But you know what? We need to be specific when we're talking\n               about discrimination because people feel discrimination in different ways. I'm currently\n               being attacked online because I'm gay, and I have a family. Those are protected grounds\n               in the human rights code. This amendment would eliminate those grounds from this motion.\n               This amendment would suggest that race is gone, that religion is gone. Let me go through. Indigenous identity, race, colour, ancestry, place of origin, religion,\n               marital status, family status, physical or mental disability, sex, sexual orientation,\n               gender identity or expression and age. All of these are currently in B.C.'s human\n               rights code, and I don't know why the B.C. Conservatives can't endorse those covered\n               grounds. It doesn't make any sense to me. By trying to get us to amend this motion to eliminate those specifically covered grounds\n               that are in the law is sending a very clear message. The clear message is we won't\n               stand up for each one of those protected grounds because if they did, they would support\n               them being in here. They would support them being in the motion. But by voting to\n               eliminate them and trying to get the House to take out the protected grounds in the\n               B.C. human rights code on a motion specifically about supporting the B.C. human rights code, they're being clear, I believe, that they don't want the protected grounds to be\n               supported in the human rights code, otherwise they would support them. That to me is a problem. That to me is a big problem. It's saying we could move an\n               amendment to say: \"Why don't we just eliminate the whole thing, and say we all love\n               each other?\" We'll move a motion to say we all love each other, and we're against\n               people being mean to each other. That's basically what this comes down to if you support\n               this amendment. I like that idea. But the fact is that when one specific group — and this is something\n               maybe some Conservatives don't understand — is targeted for who they are, you need\n               a targeted response. You need a response that actually stands up for that person.\n               I think the tribunal does that. The current chair was appointed by a former government,\n               not this one, so suggests there's some sort of partisanship going on. Not correct.\n               Again, trying to muddy the waters of human rights. The tribunal stands up so that\n               when you get denied a job because of your race, that you have a place to go, that\n               you have an ability to stand up for yourself. So again, the Conservative motion eliminates the tribunal for consideration here.\n               Again, why is that? Probably because of a fellow named Barry Neufeld and OneBC trying\n               to eat the Conservatives' lunch in terms of which party is more radical. Well, Barry\n               Neufeld, he targeted staff in the Chilliwack school district by calling them things\n               like pedophile, by saying they were groomers trying to grab children up. This is not\n               somebody you want to be associated with. You don't want to be on the cheering squad\n               like OneBC is, but it seems this party has been dragged so far to the OneBC view that\n               they have to try and suggest they are much the same. It's wrong.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359646","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I listened closely to my colleague across the way's words. She's correct. Words are\n               important, and words are very much relevant to this debate, because we're talking\n               about B.C.'s human rights code. She shared concerns that maybe people who had a health issue might not be covered\n               in the code. Well, I can assure her that a quick google, a quick check on t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e16dfbd6138b082fe38d7d2f43553e83e7afa3a023b628b2399383a5ff9b62e","c1ad1e2e9f41436083d69970fc6350bd42c7cf63873b3c7f13b2166952c1a20f","f124723237682913f50a2a57eaeb11c2cee2ff3039d2034ba10943cc8f0006a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e64a8347d8cdbf288b8edc4b14de707f838964d42650d6bfc2c448f2ac1e3f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-915accfb596f8252b7394410","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414192,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to join my colleague across the aisle in welcoming the Canadian Mortgage\n               Brokers Association of B.C. I am looking forward to a conversation with them later\n               this afternoon and grateful for the work that they do. I also ask the House to join me in welcoming Jasmine Toor from the Mortgage Professionals\n               of Canada. Again, I'm grateful for good colleagues and good opportunities to learn\n               and work together. Thank you, Jasmine. Welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414192","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to join my colleague across the aisle in welcoming the Canadian Mortgage\n               Brokers Association of B.C. I am looking forward to a conversation with them later\n               this afternoon and grateful for the work that they do. I also ask the House to join me in welcoming Jasmine Toor from the Mortgage Professionals\n               of Canada. Again, I'm grateful for good c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Woodworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036749","label":"Private investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037659","label":"Woodworking industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c436e2b537c66a4e6bcbf62d6c883c0f40f5b37ae752f329e2cbf7111bfd4ad4","4a61725dd5338411db340beddc340343c10846353e1bda4be97123c2b16a9a87"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b108e17658d1b739f6478e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414194,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've got some truck loggers in the House today. Please join me in welcoming the new\n               president of the Truck Loggers Association of British Columbia, Bob Marquis, from\n               the Sunshine Coast, as well as Adam Coulos, who's the general manager of Talagan Forestry.\n               Two outstanding individuals. I'm looking forward to having lunch with them alongside\n               some other truck loggers this afternoon. Will the House please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414194","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We've got some truck loggers in the House today. Please join me in welcoming the new\n               president of the Truck Loggers Association of British Columbia, Bob Marquis, from\n               the Sunshine Coast, as well as Adam Coulos, who's the general manager of Talagan Forestry.\n               Two outstanding individuals. I'm looking forward to having lunch with them alongside\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Household equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035710","label":"Household equipment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47893","label":"Trucks","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eafd28ff49d193af5f16b09905da158569f65cd7d5adf412ee4cea224a9d2ece","c831fdb0317ddfcc34fdf3f15bdb4905f5647c76385faf5d4fb48a1b370109ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7e723d35846d135f13ba73a5beec83008abbf2eef68fd1f52c7073218aa7cd4d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4d6918515c558038e13092e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414195,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I would like to wish my very favourite high school teacher, Mrs. Day, a happy\n               80th birthday. She was my teacher, but now she is a dear friend. When I sang her happy birthday this morning.... She always reminds me that I am allowed\n               to call her Regina, but she will always be Mrs. Day to me. She has been an incredible\n               mentor. I love going over and visiting with her and hearing her stories. I look forward\n               to having dinner with her this weekend. Happy 80th birthday, Mrs. Day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414195","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I would like to wish my very favourite high school teacher, Mrs. Day, a happy\n               80th birthday. She was my teacher, but now she is a dear friend. When I sang her happy birthday this morning.... She always reminds me that I am allowed\n               to call her Regina, but she will always be Mrs. Day to me. She has been an incredible\n               mentor. I love going over and vi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a71ae52efed4a31147ad12f0da0ba87f1aa089c8d75d8bb7f1abb6068063f04","f8ccbed237884ae548ac0b78d946456c5ff66376070d7c3bb7702c5a1dc8ad5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["045e362256d1862796cfe4c9e00a0e68facaddd313ea4565041103890260fb76"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f840dca6137344450eab8127","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414196,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am delighted to welcome representatives from Canada's kindest city, Peachland.\n               Today in the gallery, we have Patrick Van Minsel, who is the mayor; we have Councillor\n               Dave Collins; and we have CAO Joe Creron. We had an absolutely wonderful meeting with the Premier earlier this week. They are\n               set to increase their housing by 10 percent. They're doing absolutely incredible work\n               in Peachland. I got to visit them. I think it was about two years ago. We had a really,\n               really wonderful tour. This time they provided me with a CD. This was Papa Tom. Papa Tom was one of their\n               councillors who passed away a few months ago, and he was such an incredible human\n               being. I just want to say I really appreciated the gesture of giving me the album from Keith\n               Pearson. It's such a tremendous loss — Papa Tom's loss from your community. It is\n               super wonderful to see you again and know that with Papa Tom's music, his legacy lives\n               on. I just want to thank you for all of the incredible work that you do for your community. Please let them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414196","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I am delighted to welcome representatives from Canada's kindest city, Peachland.\n               Today in the gallery, we have Patrick Van Minsel, who is the mayor; we have Councillor\n               Dave Collins; and we have CAO Joe Creron. We had an absolutely wonderful meeting with the Premier earlier this week. They are\n               set to increase their housing by 10 percent. They're do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5e3e0f5edd2b48ba979a30df1cf8ddb306d1b5d99d9ccc261282b6b0801ff16","208d42c25e7ed73ba2bfa34f3e1350881fb3ea07ef62d61d68b8c7bf4570dc57","5ae5892a9e69ce632793cc53f9d7b384e943fb4d09d0d6381839eafff23d5abe","b819172377187bba1529bbc5902c8d12042292e006072c1cc13f7d892dc47b6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ca4ae2f24257bc9eba6a9bad2224632ecb5bc39400c4ee72f018c922616dea6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c0ea3410753527d256c0f31","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":414197,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"In here, I call continued second reading on Bill 11, Residential Tenancy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. In section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 13, Safe\n               Access to Places of Public Worship Act. In section C, Birch Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 10, Labour Statutes\n               Amendment Act, 2026.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:414197","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In here, I call continued second reading on Bill 11, Residential Tenancy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. In section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 13, Safe\n               Access to Places of Public Worship Act. In section C, Birch Room, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 10, Labour Statutes\n               Amendment Act, 2026.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["119076b247018d0be8fb7bf6992b6c8ae499bb530101fda1172a408801a667a4","7fdb324126b5f07b03fbb6c03ac66d7fa53c56cc27a6e1b6cea51b24f3f5823d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73fedb65b2ba6dca98fbee9578fb507201ed1d7a08d67fc49732832d03c7a0bb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7f5941f80bc52c7feaa7b5a5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720161,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am happy to speak both to the historic investments that we've made and the path\n               forward. I was glad to be up in Squamish recently and Sea to Sky with the member, announcing\n               Squamish being part of phase 2 of the government's HEART and HEARTH programs, working\n               together with the district of Squamish to bring people out of encampments and indoors.\n               There are good, tangible programs that we're doing in partnership with Squamish on\n               that front. I don't think, and I don't mean to be glib here, it is skipping past to speak to the\n               significant investments that our government has made in delivering housing in communities\n               across this province, including Squamish. So 333 student housing beds, 54 supportive\n               and transitional homes, 84 low-income homes, 137 affordable rental homes, 31 shelter\n               beds, plus the HEART and HEARTH programs we're working on. After years and years of underinvestment from the members opposite when many of them\n               were in government, we are stepping up and investing because we know what a difference\n               it makes. I know there are projects that we're looking forward to funding out of last\n               fall's community housing intake. We continue to work with project proponents and in\n               our work with the federal government to see more dollars come in to continue those\n               investments because we know it matters.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720161","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am happy to speak both to the historic investments that we've made and the path\n               forward. I was glad to be up in Squamish recently and Sea to Sky with the member, announcing\n               Squamish being part of phase 2 of the government's HEART and HEARTH programs, working\n               together with the district of Squamish to bring people out of encampments and indoors.\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a56f55e678379f96b280f2b0d5a1fcd1faac23f3905e7c41dadff4cc3f8358d","9af319b1e3637c8dadbcd573730c71bc92893b6af037fbc4d1b7487aab89b19e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d5e3124bf97ad779594676ccc9b763c38fdf5f13b2779954930515e5a0d2bbb0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e5829cc3749d9b7151243444","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720163,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am absolutely delighted to be able to welcome Cyra Yunkws, who's the chair\n               of the regional district of Kitimat-Stikine. She is, I think, just sitting up there.\n               She and I are going to be meeting later today. She is a very passionate community\n               leader. I got to meet up with her in the Hazeltons. I'm really incredibly impressed\n               by all of the work that she does for her community and for her region. Will this House\n               please welcome Cyra today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720163","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I am absolutely delighted to be able to welcome Cyra Yunkws, who's the chair\n               of the regional district of Kitimat-Stikine. She is, I think, just sitting up there.\n               She and I are going to be meeting later today. She is a very passionate community\n               leader. I got to meet up with her in the Hazeltons. I'm really incredibly impressed\n               by all","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["237e98fb4e691c8ae22c98fe3a25cd2b4e21915f9b1cb9186ea2faa9f63cea99"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-148664e1cd80b0cbfc60e3bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720165,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the K'ómoks Treaty Act, 2026, be introduced and read a first time now. I wish to acknowledge, I want to acknowledge, the K'ómoks First Nations, the delegation in attendance, and indeed all of those who've worked\n               so hard over so many years to bring us to this momentous occasion of togetherness.\n               Indeed, that's what we are doing — coming together today. I want to acknowledge elected Chief Councillor Nicole Rempel, of course their Elders\n               and other negotiators, Hereditary Chiefs, council, the treaty team, the leadership,\n               the family members — all those who sacrificed to bring about this great day. I want to acknowledge chief negotiator Mark Stevenson; our friends at the B.C. Treaty\n               Commission — I know there's a number of commissioners here today; locally elected\n               representatives from local governments; federal representatives; of course, my team\n               with the Ministry of Indigenous Relations, and indeed all of the government folks\n               who put in the work to bring about this day. We've been working together, Hon. Speaker. Our teams have been working together for\n               over 30 years, bringing a path together, a shared journey together — instead of coming\n               at each other — walking together, as we are meant to do. It provides a first step, this act for the provincial ratification of the treaty.\n               It establishes the legal status of the K'ómoks treaty, with statutory provisions necessary to implement the treaty and consequential\n               amendments to other statutes. Of course, members will note, treaties are a comprehensive form of reconciliation\n               between First Nations, B.C. and Canada. They are negotiated and constitutionally protected,\n               and they provide a framework for reconciling Crown title and the inherent title of\n               First Nations. Like most other modern treaties in the province, this treaty was negotiated\n               under the B.C. Treaty Commission process. If fully ratified by all parties — that's B.C., that's Canada, and of course, it's\n               already ratified by the K'ómoks — this will be the first comprehensive treaty to come into effect since the Tla'amin treaty of 2016. It provides the basis for self-government, self-determination for the K'ómoks. It fosters certainty, partnership, economic and social benefits, cultural benefits\n               to the K'ómoks — but, I should say, to all the people in the region and indeed to all British Columbians. Treaties enrich all of us. They're a commitment to building our future together, and\n               I'm so honoured to work in partnership with the local governments, with of course\n               the K'ómoks Nation, with the federal government, and with just the broad general public in that\n               region, who so want this treaty to succeed. They've supported the treaty development\n               over many years and forged very strong They've supported the treaty development over many years and forged very strong relationships\n               with the K'ómoks People, and I know this treaty will lead to many, many, many good outcomes in the region and indeed for all of British Columbia. It secures a\n               bright future of walking in togetherness. It's my great honour to rise in this House today, on behalf of all those who've wanted\n               to see this dream come about, to bring forward this legislation. Members, I would like to move first reading of this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720165","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move that the K'ómoks Treaty Act, 2026, be introduced and read a first time now. I wish to acknowledge, I want to acknowledge, the K'ómoks First Nations, the delegation in attendance, and indeed all of those who've worked\n               so hard over so many years to bring us to this momentous occasion of togetherness.\n               Indeed, that's what we are doing — coming together today. I wan","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d161ca71384ada2724c22efa04ec52456884d871ae39b4e93d67defb02ff5bd5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdd7a2e305225bcf393c014da35b08e03f61eb64d4264f2aa237bbf26c0025eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4bf0a78801b603727bb9cf0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720167,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have not been able to locate him in the House yet, but joining us all the way from\n               McLeod Lake Indian Band is Chief Harley Chingee. I had an opportunity, as I know some\n               of my colleagues, to be able to meet with Chief Chingee, an outstanding partner, a\n               strong steward in the forest sector. Would the House please join me in making him feel very welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720167","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have not been able to locate him in the House yet, but joining us all the way from\n               McLeod Lake Indian Band is Chief Harley Chingee. I had an opportunity, as I know some\n               of my colleagues, to be able to meet with Chief Chingee, an outstanding partner, a\n               strong steward in the forest sector. Would the House please join me in making him feel very welcome h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Animal nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal nutrition","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723660","label":"Animal nutrition","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4090f3caaeac33e49aa0d4b6d41bfac46f64800392b6d5664ab5f5851ee5b42f","91837837875c7e094beaf14c27b9d151f20337a603c243cca6f5d604be0bb2de"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71022a90f9ebac45cd2989be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720181,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to ask the House to join me in welcoming a constituent from Vancouver–Little Mountain. I'm delighted to have David Diklongan here. David worked for several members of the House before joining the Centre for Israel\n               and Jewish Affairs where he advocates for combating hate and supporting diverse communities.\n               He is here with a group supporting the Filipino community as they seek to build a\n               cultural centre in Vancouver. Please join me in welcoming David.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720181","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to ask the House to join me in welcoming a constituent from Vancouver–Little Mountain. I'm delighted to have David Diklongan here. David worked for several members of the House before joining the Centre for Israel\n               and Jewish Affairs where he advocates for combating hate and supporting diverse communities.\n               He is here with a group supporting the Filipino commun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2de62b182c61f64f36c60f2c93ba01ae12f36fd41a7eafde408f693b4de4a10d","27c166fd1eda204be0b234060eec47c849ff56e0bf4331111b6c1759e53d8c26","6ade584ad145b99e6d651bc6c56a5bf6cfd1492e2b068fdc138056603be8c028"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3adaef5970912fe6c652cdf6d9105e70def6e97e5e51626321b51f380a8cf5df"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-279aaacc5be424a245b03908","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720185,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know some of my colleagues are eager to get on to the next piece of legislation,\n               which is very important, but I do want to provide an opportunity to be able to respond\n               to all of the comments and discussion that has occurred on Bill 14. Forestry is so much about people and place. I know that you've got lots of beautiful\n               trees in Langley. Langley is a very beautiful community, but British Columbia is a\n               beautiful province — 95 hectares covered in forests. It's a province that has a sector,\n               forestry, that built this province. Forestry I'm so very proud to be a part of a government, led by our Premier, that is working\n               hard every single day to restore confidence in this sector. I want to thank all of\n               my colleagues across the way, in particular the critic for forestry, for his words,\n               for his perspectives. It's fair to say that we don't agree on many things, but I will\n               never question his passion for the file. I say that from all of the comments. I had an opportunity to be able to either watch or read the transcripts of all of\n               the remarks, including the remarks from some of my own colleagues. In particular,\n               a shout-out to the member for Ladysmith-Oceanside, who has a deep, deep understanding of forestry as it relates to her community. I think of the member for Juan de Fuca–Malahat, who talked about the blood, sweat and tears that he has shed working in the logging\n               sector. I think of my colleague from Cowichan Valley and the work that she has done\n               in the last number of months to support her community through some really trying times.\n               Forestry, like I said, is about people and place. But let me be very clear. I was enjoying the conversation and enjoying the dialogue.\n               I will not be lectured by the member for Nechako Lakes. The member for Nechako Lakes, the former leader of the official opposition, knows nothing about forestry. We have\n               to get the guy to show up in his community to actually talk to forestry workers, to\n               actually talk to mill operators. That community has been devastated by mill closures\n               and curtailments. Let's remember that on the day that the Canfor mill in Vanderhoof closed, instead\n               of reaching out to the local mayor and council, instead of reaching out to the forestry\n               workers, what did the former Leader of the Opposition do?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720185","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I know some of my colleagues are eager to get on to the next piece of legislation,\n               which is very important, but I do want to provide an opportunity to be able to respond\n               to all of the comments and discussion that has occurred on Bill 14. Forestry is so much about people and place. I know that you've got lots of beautiful\n               trees in Langley. Langley is a v","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75b4808732ec1c9f5c025764b2224e7783f2fb2186cc5ab9dea1e6550249d899"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4234c2e511d6c668775c8f21c8657b91bf98f1b0359b52a1d8b2ab5dddceb195"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1818bc633694221eea6bd52f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721234,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Christine Boyle I'm delighted to have a number of family members in the chambers today. My husband,\n               Seth, is here. Seth does a wonderful job keeping our house running alongside doing\n               his own good and important work. He's here with my son Aaron, who is smart and kind\n               and funny. I'm so proud to be his mom. Also joining us — it's a professional day in Vancouver today — is my older sister,\n               Allie, who is a health care worker and one of my favourite people in the world, and\n               her daughter Rosie, who is turning eight years old today. Will the House join me in\n               making sure that they feel extra welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721234","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Hon. Christine Boyle I'm delighted to have a number of family members in the chambers today. My husband,\n               Seth, is here. Seth does a wonderful job keeping our house running alongside doing\n               his own good and important work. He's here with my son Aaron, who is smart and kind\n               and funny. I'm so proud to be his mom. Also joining us — it's a professional day in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","label":"Commonwealth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721588","label":"Climate","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fab6d168d8c0fc3d662c349ba62af5bb44afdd4eb44e56c04736a0b0e39ba469","2639bbf31dc39559b5420f33c880c654729c4907d4bcd2adecba89c3e6f10af4","eae32d44a14263285be6c4f4b6aa2bc5f4b6d668f5bae427894ccffbe80cfa20"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f22ebc26c7dbda5a3a54d80bfe23db5461f646c63c0d11dd3f33bb7f21658d8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f00bf3ce065c26a735386ddb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721241,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Further to B.C. Book Day, I want to welcome one of my constituents to the gallery\n               today. It's not often that happens. Known by probably most of the people in this House,\n               the mayor of Gibsons, Silas White is here as part of B.C. Book Day. He grew up in\n               publishing, with his mom and dad, in Harbour Publishing and now runs his own publishing\n               company, Nightwood Editions. It is my sincere hope that he will one day publish the\n               memoirs of a certain MLA for Vancouver-Renfrew. Please give him a big, warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721241","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Further to B.C. Book Day, I want to welcome one of my constituents to the gallery\n               today. It's not often that happens. Known by probably most of the people in this House,\n               the mayor of Gibsons, Silas White is here as part of B.C. Book Day. He grew up in\n               publishing, with his mom and dad, in Harbour Publishing and now runs his own publishing\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Municipal buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036358","label":"Municipal buildings","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b9a7723f37f616b0d968756dfbb8d28c2cdae6d3447793f72f50580f0ddc8ec","eebcc57dd0fe42451f10e01b8c913efe7864cb39e0f7e706c566ba140ac9861e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f004122879a051dacce7e6113ad97d50318815ef972f7e5cc39152bb84fa949"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9bd4b0a7a0d971bfe462bf1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721249,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. Freedom-of-information law exists for one fundamental reason,\n               to ensure that the government remains accountable to the people it serves. They are\n               not a privilege granted by the government. They are a right held by the public. When British Columbians seek information about the actions of their government, they're\n               not asking for a favour. They are exercising their democratic right to understand\n               how decisions are made, how public money is spent and how policies affect their lives.\n               That is why FOI legislation must always lean towards transparency. It must be on the\n               side of openness, not secrecy. Unfortunately, this legislation before the House moves us in the opposite direction.\n               The government has presented this bill as an effort to improve the efficiency in the\n               FOI system. They say the system is overloaded, that requests take too long and that\n               administrative improvements are necessary. On that point, I agree. This system should be faster. It should be more efficient.\n               It should work better for British Columbians. These are elements in this bill that\n               aim to modernize process and streamline administration. And on those aspects, I am\n               prepared to offer support. But buried in this legislation are several changes that fundamentally weaken access\n               to information in the province. Instead of strengthening transparency, this bill risks\n               restricting it. Instead of improving access to information, it risks making that access\n               more difficult, more expensive and easier for government to avoid. This is very similar to the approach taken by the NDP government with the GLP program\n               change. There was a huge backlog for the second road test. Instead of addressing the\n               problem, they simply cancelled it. One of the most concerning aspects of this legislation appears in clause 13, which\n               expands the categories under which the government can apply to the Information and\n               Privacy Commissioner to disregard an FOI request. Currently, there are already mechanisms to deal with these requests, and that protection\n               already exists in the law, but this bill goes much further. The government proposes\n               to add new categories such as malicious, abusive, repetitious, excessively broad or\n               requests that could reasonably interfere with the operations of government. At first glance, those terms may sound reasonable. But when we look closer, a serious\n               problem emerges. None of these terms are defined. There is no clear definition of\n               what constitutes a malicious request. There is no definition of what counts as abusive.\n               There is no objective standard for what might be considered excessively broad, and\n               there is certainly no definition of what it means to unreasonably interfere with the\n               operations of the government. An FOI request that is truly meaningful is often one that asks difficult questions.\n               It may request documents that expose mistakes, mismanagement or even wrongdoing within\n               the government. Those are precisely the kinds of requests that can create pressure and maybe interfere\n               on government operations. The reality is this. The most important FOI requests are\n               often the ones that make government uncomfortable. Recently, I know one of the members in the opposition actually made an FOI request\n               on the xwməθkwəy̓əm deal. The reality is this: the most important FOI requests are often the ones that make government uncomfortable. And recently, I know\n               one of the members in the opposition actually made an FOI request on the xwməθkwəy̓əm deal, on the xwməθkwəy̓əm ceremony,\n               and that exposes the government's flip-flopping. That makes the government uncomfortable. But that's also the beauty of FOI requests. When a journalist, a researcher or even an opposition MLA files an FOI that could\n               expose mismanagement or wrongdoing, of course it may interfere with the government's\n               operation. It may even force the government to answer difficult questions. It may\n               expose problems the government would rather keep hidden. But that is exactly how accountability\n               works in a democracy world If the standard becomes that a request can be ignored because it interferes with\n               the operation of government, then almost any serious investigation could fall under\n               that category. A request that uncovers a scandal could be labelled disruptive. A request\n               that demands thousands of pages of records could be called excessively broad. A request\n               that repetitively asks about the same issue could be labelled repetitive. Suddenly,\n               this government has a pathway to simply avoid answering. And that is a very dangerous precedent. There's a saying in Chinese, and I will translate that into English. It says: \"When\n               you cannot solve the problem, you remove the person who points out the problem.\" In\n               other words, instead of fixing the issue, you silence the person asking the questions.\n               That is the danger we see here in this legislation. This is exactly how authoritarian\n               and dictatorship systems operate. When scrutiny becomes inconvenient, they do not\n               fix the problem; they block the investigation. And here, in this bill, the NDP government\n               is doing exactly that. Democratic governments should do the opposite. When citizens ask questions, government\n               should answer them, and FOI laws exist to protect that principle. Very disappointingly\n               and frustratingly, instead of strengthening transparency, this bill risks creating\n               tools that allow the government to avoid scrutiny. When journalists, researchers or\n               even opposition members dig deeper into government actions, the response should be\n               to provide answers, not to make that request harder, not to label that request as\n               abusive, not to claim that it interferes with government operations. Governments do not exist for their own convenience. They exist to serve the public,\n               and part of that responsibility is to answer difficult questions, even when those\n               questions expose uncomfortable truth. If this legislation allows the government to\n               avoid releasing information simply because that information might create political\n               consequence, then transparency becomes conditional and democracy becomes weaker. FOI should empower citizens to uncover the truth about their government. It should\n               not give the government new ways to hide it. Without clear definitions, these categories\n               become open to interpretation. That interpretation will be made by the very government\n               that is being asked to disclose the information. That is a very serious concern. Imagine a journalist submitting an FOI request about communications within the Premier's office. Could the government claim that fulfilling that request would interfere with the\n               Premier's office operations? Imagine a researcher requesting documents of a policy decision. Could that request\n               be labelled excessively broad? Imagine an opposition MLA seeking records about government spending. Could that request\n               be described as repetitive because similar questions have been asked before? When these definitions are vague, the door opens for abuse. Now the government may\n               say: \"This request must still go before the Information and Privacy Commissioner.\" That is true. But the very fact that government can apply under such broad and\n               undefined categories creates an additional barrier to access. FOI requests have uncovered government decisions that otherwise have remained hidden.\n               They have revealed problems in public policy, exposed mismanagement and brought important\n               facts to light. They have helped journalists report accurately. They have helped researchers\n               understand government programs. They have helped citizens hold their government accountable.\n               And that is precisely why these rights must be protected. Yet Bill 9 expands the tools available for the government to avoid responding. Unfortunately, this is not happening in a vacuum. British Columbia has already been\n               criticized as one of the most secretive governments in Canada when it comes to access\n               to information. Reports have reportedly pointed out delays, reduction and barriers\n               within the system. Instead of fixing those problems, this bill makes them worse. Another troubling element appears in clause 21, which allows public bodies to Another troubling element appears in clause 21, which allows public bodies to charge\n               fees for records that are currently accessible without filing a formal FOI request.\n               This may sound like a small charge, but the principle behind is significant. Under the current system, certain information is made proactively available to the\n               public. These are records that governments have already determined should be accessible\n               without requesting a formal request. They're meant to be easily obtained. They're\n               meant to promote openness. They're meant to reduce the need for FOI applications. This bill introduces the ability to charge fees for those records. That fundamentally\n               undermines concept of proactive disclosure. Proactive disclosure should mean exactly\n               what? Information that is proactively available to the public, accessible, open and\n               free. If citizens must start paying for access to information that is already considered\n               public, then disclosure is no longer proactive. It becomes transactional, and that\n               raises a serious question. Is this about transparency, or is this creating another\n               barrier between the public and the government? We must remember this is actually not the first time that this government has introduced\n               fees into the FOI system. A few years ago, this government introduced a $10 application\n               fee for filing FOI requests. At that time, many observers already warned that even\n               small fees could discourage citizens from seeking information. Transparency should not be dependent on whether someone is willing or able to pay.\n               FOI should not come with a cover charge. And now we see another step in the same direction\n               under this NDP government. If the government truly wishes to improve the FOI system, then the first issue that\n               should be addressed is the backlog. British Columbians are waiting for too long to\n               receive response to their requests. According to the recent data, in the 2022-2023\n               period, applicants had to wait for an average of 192 additional business days beyond\n               the initial timeline to receive a response. Let that number sink in — 192 business\n               days. That's nearly a full year on top of the initial timeline. Information delayed is often information denied. Imagine: when a journalist must wait\n               nearly a year for documents, the story may no longer be relevant. When researchers\n               must wait months for records, their work is delayed. When citizens must wait indefinitely\n               for answers, trust in government erodes. If the goal of this bill is truly efficiency, we should expect to see measures aimed\n               directly at reducing those delays. We would expect to see investment in FOI processing.\n               We would expect to see stronger timelines. We should expect to see accountability\n               for missed deadlines. Instead we see border powers to disregard requests and new opportunities\n               to charge fees. I support using technology to improve access. I support streamlining administrative\n               process when it benefits the public. But efficiency must never come at the expense\n               of accountability, and transparency must never be sacrificed in the name of convenience. The right to access to information belongs to the people of British Columbia. It does\n               not belong to the government. Government records are created using public resources\n               in the cause of serving the public. Those records ultimately belong to the public. The foundation of democratic government is trust. Citizens must trust that their government\n               is acting in their best interests. When government begins to restrict access to information,\n               that trust begins to erode. Bill 9 expands the ability of government to avoid requests\n               and introduce new barriers to public access. Unfortunately, part of this bill moves\n               us away from that principle. British Columbians deserve a government that strengthens access to information, not\n               one that slowly takes the free out of the freedom of information.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721249","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. Freedom-of-information law exists for one fundamental reason,\n               to ensure that the government remains accountable to the people it serves. They are\n               not a privilege granted by the government. They are a right held by the public. When British Columbian","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037554","label":"Water conservation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ffc0823662a299749a001484931a5afc907f48430312bd67bbf77661b197d9d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8a47ef2679482231296d44fbd1a2e478ca8dac85592099b2033d6220568a363"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-137f0dda1e4940868651a90b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721254,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I've got a couple of introductions, both on either end of the House. First, a couple of constituents from Langford. We've got Melissa Ellis, who many will\n               know in the building as one of our fantastic political staffers, an Energizer Bunny,\n               keeping us all excited in the hallways. Her son, Grayson, is in the House, I think for the first time in question period.\n               Now, Grayson is a 15-year-old Royal Bay student who loves baseball, and We've got Melissa Ellis, who many will know in the building as one of our fantastic\n               political staffers, an Energizer Bunny, keeping us all excited in the hallways. Her son, Grayson, is in the House, I think for the first time in question period.\n               Now, Grayson is a 15-year-old Royal Bay student who loves baseball, and I think he\n               loves politics too. Will the House please join me in making Melissa and Grayson feel very welcome? Then, way on the other side of the House, I've got my constituency advisors in the\n               House. We've got Logan Nemet, Sawyer Pugh and Max Standridge. They keep me organized.\n               They are beloved by the people of Langford-Highlands because they fix problems every single day. Would the House please join me in making my incredible constituency office team welcome\n               here as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721254","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I've got a couple of introductions, both on either end of the House. First, a couple of constituents from Langford. We've got Melissa Ellis, who many will\n               know in the building as one of our fantastic political staffers, an Energizer Bunny,\n               keeping us all excited in the hallways. Her son, Grayson, is in the House, I think for the first time in question per","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","label":"Mining technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["219b755cfe4b2715c35a3450fe7ff2b418d93e5f436af9006a6854a9f7b86df4","a1a397c509dfdfccca8211acd9d18af547b3ca7eca31fdbfea07b06e72ac5d92","2fb7c7c81c1534daa72ffbc0105d45d9797b96d98edc57cc5983533ee495e11c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0356befb89b29c99de51a668","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721255,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I look up, and I have a few friends in the gallery. We have Louise Wallace Richmond\n               and her husband David Richmond from Salmon Arm. They are down for UBCM advocacy days.\n               We've had some great meetings so far, and so I hope that you enjoy when you're meeting\n               with UBCM. Their work is so critically important across our province. Of course, we have the mayor of Tumbler Ridge, Darryl Krakowka. He has done so much for his community in such an incredibly difficult time. So it's\n               really wonderful that all of our caucus have been able to spend time with Darryl this\n               week. I hope that you'll make my friends in the gallery feel very welcome. I hope that you'll make my friends in the gallery feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721255","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I look up, and I have a few friends in the gallery. We have Louise Wallace Richmond\n               and her husband David Richmond from Salmon Arm. They are down for UBCM advocacy days.\n               We've had some great meetings so far, and so I hope that you enjoy when you're meeting\n               with UBCM. Their work is so critically important across our province. Of course, we have the mayor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art works","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","label":"Art works","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cd0d9ca3996ef9814348e944a03407e2af9fdf4639091aa9143c73c8ada0301","4c4d9cfaefa2b5f548b0bc7fe5661771694711f5dfd45f06ac46693d3aa216c7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4af72db5db9c6a01e321c84a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721256,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call second reading on Bill 20, K'ómoks Treaty Act, in the chamber. And in Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of Supply\n               for the Ministry of Energy and Climate Solutions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721256","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call second reading on Bill 20, K'ómoks Treaty Act, in the chamber. And in Section A, the Douglas Fir Room, I call Committee of Supply\n               for the Ministry of Energy and Climate Solutions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a42908a89f1c19dfd1d5b85972407be551e7ddf85a2b93e6d58a2a366309cbfb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc6e5a8fb8cf2ca0d63c7111","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728844,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, we've been clear. The people we work for are British Columbians. We've been\n               clear that the nations within B.C., they're the ones that we also work with — as the\n               member mentioned, the Okanagan Osoyoos Indian Band — on these issues. We've been very....\n               The member can google it. He can read the Hansard . He can watch television. We've been clear in every court of law that our obligation is to British Columbia\n               and British Columbians. And no, the First Nations across the border, they may have\n               their arguments — just as they do in Alberta, just as they do in Alaska — and we'll\n               hear them just as we hear concerns from Washingtonians, Albertans and folks living\n               in Alaska. So that's our obligation. That's our duty. British Columbia is who we listen\n               to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728844","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, we've been clear. The people we work for are British Columbians. We've been\n               clear that the nations within B.C., they're the ones that we also work with — as the\n               member mentioned, the Okanagan Osoyoos Indian Band — on these issues. We've been very....\n               The member can google it. He can read the Hansard . He can watch television. We've been clear in e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5d3181a527279dbe65bf57c6ff5352f02d9e948fc59b5165307031e92acd7564"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e14d0e4be9f850642c00b1d0bf9fba6b7f8f797fce492aca9c2cea5587415439"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-67374487a0d85f30d07b3837","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728845,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome Dominic Lai, director of Dragon Boat B.C., to the chambers today. Dragon boat events are such an important cultural and athletic demonstration, and\n               Dragon Boat B.C. does such important work bringing these events to life. I know, as\n               the MLA for Richmond-Steveston, that the energy and excitement of Steveston's dragon boat races are an important\n               part of our summer, and they'll be back in 2027. I'm very excited about that. Please, can everybody help me make him welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728845","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome Dominic Lai, director of Dragon Boat B.C., to the chambers today. Dragon boat events are such an important cultural and athletic demonstration, and\n               Dragon Boat B.C. does such important work bringing these events to life. I know, as\n               the MLA for Richmond-Steveston, that the energy and excitement of Steveston's dragon boat races are an important\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb61cdc4af142ea769481f13fd446b205ccfe65957558cd25ff34bb55daa29d8","2d8359f4c5099c7c7e39da5f0ee5625e74c0c78acb58c551fa1cf3c9eafa9420","7516450e9fb3213ea84b22fa5baac3a1d95592135d54e378db64e95f5ece92a5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fdc62337b57cff50cd0eb8b153f736fb79d32269711b274c7f95f3a7042aaae4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76185209043b26862d9ac848","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728853,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my honour to welcome a delegation from school district 38, that is Richmond.\n               We are joined today by our trustees.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728853","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's my honour to welcome a delegation from school district 38, that is Richmond.\n               We are joined today by our trustees.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a716644c75f0175228f388d7437399512133e4dc56fe559616e8c4982d3b1357"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b63a399aaa7515a404fceee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728857,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the House, we have with us Better Transit YYJ, a group that is working to\n               advance improved and expanded public transit across the Victoria region. The group\n               focuses on promoting accessible, reliable, effective transit options for committee\n               members. We have Samuel Holland, Matt Lockshin, Jack Sander and Isaiah Renaud. These individuals aren't just passionate about transit; they're very well informed.\n               They can get deep into issues of transit funding models, of transit planning, of route\n               density. They are very informed and continuing to work across the region. Also, Public\n               Transit Alliance of B.C. recently launched April 28, a coalition provincewide to work\n               on ensuring that public transportation works for everyone across the North, the Islands,\n               urban centres, small towns, rural and remote Indigenous communities, because transit\n               is something we need across all of our communities. Thank you for your work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728857","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today in the House, we have with us Better Transit YYJ, a group that is working to\n               advance improved and expanded public transit across the Victoria region. The group\n               focuses on promoting accessible, reliable, effective transit options for committee\n               members. We have Samuel Holland, Matt Lockshin, Jack Sander and Isaiah Renaud. These individuals aren't ju","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","label":"Accessible transport"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","label":"Accessible transport","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c50045d6924b46dc7c89092946143b1a7226a98ebc16500a2b52960b8547cfa9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a0bc3ae09e3b9f3e31b043499558dd5cce3620c7b8855eaf522e0bec7cab8307"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6f2e6dd65af8635a1f195e2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752181,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am delighted to introduce two incredible women behind me. I've got Megan Dykeman\n               and Kelli Paddon. They were my colleagues, they did incredible work for their communities\n               as MLAs, and they continue to do incredible work. I just want the House to re-welcome them and make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752181","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am delighted to introduce two incredible women behind me. I've got Megan Dykeman\n               and Kelli Paddon. They were my colleagues, they did incredible work for their communities\n               as MLAs, and they continue to do incredible work. I just want the House to re-welcome them and make them feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Civil aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Monuments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airplanes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","label":"Civil aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083620","label":"Airplanes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","label":"Airlines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92452","label":"Monuments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f653fb998130ae8e54911c322f2b019d893728031d590f0a4d66a045fbd180c","b568c30675b97ddcb9d933afc2ca11adbdc466ce7cd04cd78200d051e049d07c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-567f5919ce6e2e0983368cd2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752182,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery, we have folks visiting from the Institute for Catastrophic Loss\n               Reduction, who are here in British Columbia for Emergency Preparedness Week. They'll\n               also be part of our emergency preparedness expo here at the Parliament Buildings tomorrow,\n               which everyone is invited to from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. We have with us today Dr. Keith Porter, chief engineer; Moira Gill, director of strategy;\n               Dan Sandink, senior director of resilience programs; Amelia Cameron, manager of climate-resilient\n               communities. I'd now ask the House to make them very welcome and thank them for the important work\n               that they do. I'd now ask the House to make them very welcome and thank them for the important work\n               that they do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752182","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the gallery, we have folks visiting from the Institute for Catastrophic Loss\n               Reduction, who are here in British Columbia for Emergency Preparedness Week. They'll\n               also be part of our emergency preparedness expo here at the Parliament Buildings tomorrow,\n               which everyone is invited to from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. We have with us today Dr. Keith Porter, c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","label":"Single parent families","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e8ea23247911c673c14afd3e0ea29e3b786fb18b5ee04849716c33d29a179e3","542e0f919baf7ba43d68e5c22c9072fc765529b31d9b37639f28638021aa14f0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ba5134cfe098ad712a0ac9f5ca67c62fec5e2532b570c934c02c14b8dcb5586"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bc79eefa5919048d70845da5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752184,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"We'll get back to the fun of my colleague's speech. In this House, we'll continue\n               second reading on Bill 9.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752184","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We'll get back to the fun of my colleague's speech. In this House, we'll continue\n               second reading on Bill 9.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4aa872536a3960fe9047317e418d27bdda6d8a04eff8370f13732f7c4daa28a4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-268d1328a5dd4080b36ae661","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752185,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Legislature's favourite guest is here for their biannual visit. You may remember\n               that it is Emergency Preparedness Week, and I'm here to introduce our emergency alert\n               systems test. These alerts are one of the ways that we keep people safe. In an emergency,\n               you would receive information and instructions on how to keep you and your family\n               safe. Today at 1.55 p.m., people across the province will receive an alert on their mobile\n               device, radio or cable television. Check your device settings. If your phone is on\n               do not disturb, you may not receive the alert. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752185","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Legislature's favourite guest is here for their biannual visit. You may remember\n               that it is Emergency Preparedness Week, and I'm here to introduce our emergency alert\n               systems test. These alerts are one of the ways that we keep people safe. In an emergency,\n               you would receive information and instructions on how to keep you and your family\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Cellular telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034419","label":"Cellular telephones","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a341cd79e7a70fa8bfbc733736edfb42bc7790faf548a895ef9cea2e9fb19090","eb40dc1afcdf11d626207661ffc94757d9b0584bc9ce09fb1fc8a1dc45d9b26f","8a4382015ebc05f340d7ce6071a1e1eeba06673822f9367e5356075d8b14320b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe31edc292896a7f375189e7778af169117274da038b57897fad47a6f8935a72"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b585fef6e425a42fa2040d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752186,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us today in the Legislature is a wonderful constituent of mine and a former\n               colleague, former MLA Jane Shin. Jane served in our Legislature","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752186","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Joining us today in the Legislature is a wonderful constituent of mine and a former\n               colleague, former MLA Jane Shin. Jane served in our Legislature","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b79191cb90d0940f339b522d421dff261d5f128aee7e63153bfa49bd75d90bf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edfdbf00b2d70d023e14d97f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752187,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last week we lost Don Prince. To know Don was to know Jackie and Don. They were together\n               on every daily walk in Port Moody and on every adventure around the world and every\n               moment they shared. He left us quietly, on his own terms, exactly as you'd expect of a man who lived his\n               life with such quiet dignity. And Jackie was right there where she always was, by\n               his side to the very end. Jackie shared these words with me. I knew Don for probably 20 years. He was a man of deep principle, someone who did\n               things his own way, on his own terms, but whose heart was so generous. He gave so\n               much of himself, quietly and without fanfare, to the people and to the causes that\n               he believed in. Port Moody won't ever be the same. Port Moody won't ever be the same. I'll miss him, and our community will miss him. Don, we will never forget you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752187","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Last week we lost Don Prince. To know Don was to know Jackie and Don. They were together\n               on every daily walk in Port Moody and on every adventure around the world and every\n               moment they shared. He left us quietly, on his own terms, exactly as you'd expect of a man who lived his\n               life with such quiet dignity. And Jackie was right there where she always was","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bdc5b399a48dff4b6c66e68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017171,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning I met with Mona Sakata Johnston who is currently here in the crowd. She\n               is from the Cowichan Valley and is currently completing her honours in history and political science from Huron University in London, Ontario. She is\n               passionate about social justice, education and global affairs and was recently awarded\n               the political science prize in Canadian politics from Huron University. We had a really wonderful chat this morning and I want everyone\n               to make her feel very welcome, and then I have another introduction. So, please, everyone\n               make her feel very welcome. Thank you. And the second introduction I want to make is I want to wish a very happy birthday\n               to someone who is incredibly special in my life. I'm so glad I was able to celebrate\n               her 95th birthday. That is my grandma, Shirley Anderson. She lives in her own home\n               still, a log house up in Whitehorse. She was a gold miner with my grandpa. She's a\n               vet from the Air Force, a really incredible feminist. She wins at bingo almost every\n               week. She is living a healthy life and it was so wonderful to spend some time with\n               her this weekend. So Grandma, happy 95th birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017171","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This morning I met with Mona Sakata Johnston who is currently here in the crowd. She\n               is from the Cowichan Valley and is currently completing her honours in history and political science from Huron University in London, Ontario. She is\n               passionate about social justice, education and global affairs and was recently awarded\n               the political science prize in Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3298ed4e4f3fa5d03ef87ee0273ebb4c953a16052e0c1a59d0a1df0246d239f5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-391cce8c9cd9e8c920ecd46d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017181,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call continued estimates of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017181","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call continued estimates of the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5840fb3310679e9dcbaae7636bb0b7ba19d133c8246bc4c3da8f7b9ab6e6d83"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-18d04674bd36a1f03ee336a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017184,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I wouldn't usually reintroduce someone, but it's very seldom that your life comes\n               full circle, and I think it's important to highlight it when it does. In about 2014, I put on my best dress, and I was incredibly nervous, to go to downtown\n               Vancouver to have a meeting for the very first time, the very first time I ever met\n               with an elected official, the then Minister of Education. I was nervous and incredibly\n               intimidated and had a half-hour meeting. I'm not sure that he remembers that meeting, but it sticks with me in the work that\n               I do. He inspired me out of that meeting to get involved in politics. That's why I'm\n               on this side of the House now. I also want to lend my welcome to Peter Fassbender. Thank you for inspiring me and\n               thank you for your time in the Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017184","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I wouldn't usually reintroduce someone, but it's very seldom that your life comes\n               full circle, and I think it's important to highlight it when it does. In about 2014, I put on my best dress, and I was incredibly nervous, to go to downtown\n               Vancouver to have a meeting for the very first time, the very first time I ever met\n               with an elected official, the th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","label":"Business services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7af45e3532ecde3dcc526143b0f9985317c2e703a88f39f1b5a7a0857f1209cd","227f4812c37346ed96a0b3fb19f733906abce6eab6e9213be43a3f0ed44d397f","80bb159af44c9537f818ae72db0f65a43bc79ab5d8b21e774664119bf2fb1089"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f4dff6aa3f0d778a6bb0958","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017188,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Spuh-uh.... I'm so sorry. I'm a little bit punch drunk.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017188","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Spuh-uh.... I'm so sorry. I'm a little bit punch drunk.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Internet","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Mining technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036313","label":"Mining technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42465","label":"Internet","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9d18a37eb2782dc4665b9466d019e2fd16d04684759ba55446ec440999524c14","0d85912f331a8f7c729079029e9a54fcd1c69c798fdb16434336577ddc5ffd46","d9c0b5671f964af4353177bf9875e58a66c8ba44faf3d35eeb3a18800b2c2ef4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-453a8bf1e59d9c759bc232e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017189,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to notify the House of the passing of an incredible leader in the human rights\n               struggle for gay and lesbian people in British Columbia, a man who I got to know well\n               as the MLA for the West End, but indeed just out and about in the community because\n               he was always interested in helping young people make their dreams come true. I've\n               known him for over 20 years: Rob Joyce. Rob was born September 23, 1948, in a small outport of Newfoundland. He arrived in\n               Vancouver in the '70s with another friend, Don Hann, and others welcoming him. But\n               he stood up from those early ages for equality. He was kissing his boyfriend at Humphrey's in the Denman Inn in Vancouver when he\n               was kicked out for kissing, for being in love. He took that through what then existed\n               of the human rights process, and it did not succeed because sexual orientation was\n               not protected. Later, he served as a social worker, serving our province, working with youth. Unfortunately,\n               at the time, homophobia was used against him to force him from his job. He took the\n               government of the day to court again and again, but because employment protections\n               for his sexual orientation, for being gay, did not exist at the time, he was not able\n               to achieve justice. But what he did do was he helped galvanize a community that got bigger and bigger\n               to stand up for the human rights, to stand up for love, to stand up for equality in\n               employment, in services, in the human rights code. He achieved that success in the\n               long run that he was not able to achieve for himself. He kept fighting for everyone\n               else. He passed away May 7. He was an out, proud realtor. Anyone that bought a condo in\n               the West End would have known of him because he served so well as a realtor, as a\n               community builder, as a human rights advocate. I just want to send my love out to everyone who knew him, everyone whose lives have\n               been improved because of him.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017189","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to notify the House of the passing of an incredible leader in the human rights\n               struggle for gay and lesbian people in British Columbia, a man who I got to know well\n               as the MLA for the West End, but indeed just out and about in the community because\n               he was always interested in helping young people make their dreams come true. I've\n               k","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0117ef6229bff1253e30a93c7414261065f7d29829baec2761361df73729fe63"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["796a97a479433350187eee8e1bbee4400b7b368029480d5c193d8318920a46dc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9459c1f5ba791d3aa9f5dbf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036412,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036412","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ee94d620b3266c84591c8c31b2e5172d792d38052719e97aee1a2c4b79a6484"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1664e5400253aa56487693e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036413,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have three special guests to introduce and welcome today. Kevin Harding is the director of innovation and safety policy within the Ministry of Housing","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036413","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have three special guests to introduce and welcome today. Kevin Harding is the director of innovation and safety policy within the Ministry of Housing","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Alternative fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Propane","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501323","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47473","label":"Propane","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501323","label":"Adolescence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721360","label":"Alternative fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a849adac8c65ad3aaa808797c08c1fbaeaf0b4af8c2752da09473beacaa56a11","aa4a83bb520d623e3e3a66379065052a5254e6125858b74c5aefdeae5706417e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7fc74aa59d11b0a754c3dd46","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036416,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am so excited to welcome the B.C. Urban Mayors Caucus, mayors from 16 of our largest\n               cities, representing over 60 percent of British Columbians. In the gallery, we have....\n               And I know people here want to introduce their own mayors. I've already been hearing\n               that, but I am delighted to get to introduce them. In the gallery, we have Mayors Marianne Alto from Victoria, Richard Stewart from Coquitlam,\n               Mayor Tom Dyas from Kelowna and Mike Klassen, representing Vancouver. Also with them\n               is Laura Parent, who some in the House will remember as a former staff who has served\n               our members a few years ago. They are here for a full day of meetings to share their recommendations and actions\n               from a municipal perspective as they approach the end of their terms. We're so grateful\n               for them as partners and leaders in their communities. Will the House join me in making them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036416","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am so excited to welcome the B.C. Urban Mayors Caucus, mayors from 16 of our largest\n               cities, representing over 60 percent of British Columbians. In the gallery, we have....\n               And I know people here want to introduce their own mayors. I've already been hearing\n               that, but I am delighted to get to introduce them. In the gallery, we have Mayors Marianne Alto","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disaster relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034855","label":"Disaster relief","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f449978776ffc86bec88f00e1e4925d39c397875da786b926603bbf0895be664"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66b1567c1402ae197fdfbddc650b5879fa50b0088173bdf1bca05856c964cfcf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e2d22a4f673a39840eba0613","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036417,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the committee rise, report progress and ask leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036417","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that the committee rise, report progress and ask leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ed7487e20b3c49a0ca7e9a037740c4c796222cfb2d72aa1799eb7b4704c5116"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f309874fd45ca85d170153e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036418,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"Welcome to the member. It's really great to see him. Game 4 is tonight. I'm a Canucks fan, a very proud Canucks fan, but like many in this\n               House, we're jumping on Team Canada. Go, Habs, Go! I've got, I think, the world's biggest Habs fan in the House. Chief Wilf Adam of the\n               Lake Babine First Nation is here. Chief, it's good to see you. He's joined by his daughter Thelma Susan. Will the House please join me in making them feel very welcome. And go, Habs, go!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036418","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Welcome to the member. It's really great to see him. Game 4 is tonight. I'm a Canucks fan, a very proud Canucks fan, but like many in this\n               House, we're jumping on Team Canada. Go, Habs, Go! I've got, I think, the world's biggest Habs fan in the House. Chief Wilf Adam of the\n               Lake Babine First Nation is here. Chief, it's good to see you. He's joined by his daughter Thel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Innu","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Innu","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035901","label":"Innu","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["528aec9a47f2d1f18fd65f6b51f606644e174e4cc7179a4b131d014ec2c65316","58a3bea3abb5fe63392b4076e27d7d9a8be0166e0eabf4c8aba8277cf6bb4b46","9030157b377f5462175c77e02135a499396eee4c79599028d0e5a8ea889fb97d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["09d495464048c2c0a25e491346865f18aab3d0d39175b19c915b82ca291ba31f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f6712d32ec34c8c5a79c51e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036419,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we all know, shift happens. There is a big shift happening with the people that\n               I am working with today. Today is Evan Brown's last day in the Legislature before\n               he goes on paternity leave. His wife, Petra, and he will be welcoming a baby very soon, and I want everyone in\n               this house to wish them all the best. I know they're going to be absolutely incredible\n               parents, and I look forward to welcoming Evan back after his paternity leave. I'm really grateful that I get to continue to work with Anna Bunchu, who's been my\n               CA for the last five years, who's now coming into my role as MLA. Can we please wish Evan and Petra all of the very best as they welcome a baby into\n               this world.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036419","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As we all know, shift happens. There is a big shift happening with the people that\n               I am working with today. Today is Evan Brown's last day in the Legislature before\n               he goes on paternity leave. His wife, Petra, and he will be welcoming a baby very soon, and I want everyone in\n               this house to wish them all the best. I know they're going to be absolutely inc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87e93a8f54082d756c7802d5930413277ae2106281cb7ff617a82f6043007ef2","6d8706a05ac75a0702ff1905946353e59797b69823508954e42004f8f8e626b1","3d095e19eebd6db3f7a1b0d275068c3855d707b4398f7cff923f1e2d94847a55"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c70a0225f79488018de785a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036421,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Hon Chan","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move third reading of Bill 20.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036421","member_id":"bc-mla-394","member_name":"Hon Chan","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move third reading of Bill 20.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f095be625093036a18046df89723207985d791713a0addec6925282f6d2bc1b4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60612fcc4e1a928d7f04ec17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317155,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill M226, the Motor Vehicle Act (No. 2), 2025, also known as Xavier's Law. This bill is named in the memory of 12-year-old, Xavier Rasul Jankovics, who was rollerblading\n               with his brother on a rural road in Shawnigan when he was struck by a 17-year-old\n               driver. The vehicle attempted to swerve, lost control, hit Xavier with such force\n               that he was thrown 185 feet. The car ultimately crashed into a pole 110 feet away. It's an unimaginable tragedy. No parent should ever have to endure the loss of a child\n               because of dangerous behaviour behind the wheel. As legislators, when we hear stories like this, we are reminded that road safety is\n               not an abstract policy discussion. It is about lives, families, communities forever\n               changed. The intent behind this bill is clear: to strengthen accountability for reckless\n               driving and to deter dangerous conduct on our roads. Bill M226 proposes to create an expanded statutory definition of reckless driving,\n               listing a series of specific acts — wheelies, drifting, dougnuts, spinning out, improper\n               passing on single-track roads, obstructing the left lane, extreme speeding thresholds,\n               driving with a passenger in the trunk, driving without being seated in the driver's\n               seat, and other prescribed conduct. It would also introduce an immediate 30-day licence suspension, requiring surrender\n               of a licence with no mechanism of appeal, and creates additional fine and custodial\n               consequences for offences committed on highways or industrial roads. At second reading, the question before us is the principle of the bill. In considering\n               the principle, we must ask: does this proposal meaningfully strengthen the law, or\n               does it risk duplicating provisions that already exist under the Motor Vehicle Act? Many of the behaviours listed in this bill are already captured under existing law.\n               Section 144 of the Motor Vehicle Act prohibits driving without due care and attention,\n               without reasonable consideration for other road users, or at a speed excessive relative\n               to the road, traffic, visibility or weather conditions. Section 148 already addresses excessive speeding, defined as more than 40 kilometres\n               per hour over the posted limit, and carries significant penalties. Dangerous stunts,\n               excessive speed, careless manoeuvres — these are not lawful today. They are already\n               offences. So we must carefully examine whether creating a new defined category of\n               reckless driving enhances clarity and enforcement or whether it risks overlap and\n               potential inconsistency in application. There are also important questions about procedural fairness. The bill contemplates\n               an automatic 30-day suspension with no avenue of appeal. Administrative suspensions\n               can be powerful and effective tools, but they must be grounded in clear evidentiary\n               standards and balanced safeguards. When a wide range of conduct can trigger immediate\n               suspension, we must ensure that framework is proportionate and defensible. Another issue that warrants scrutiny is the absence of exemptions for permitted and\n               supervised activities. British Columbia has a globally recognized film industry. Productions\n               often involve controlled driving scenes conducted under strict safety protocols and\n               municipal British Columbia has a globally recognized film industry. Productions often involve\n               controlled driving scenes conducted under strict safety protocols and municipal approvals.\n               As drafted, the bill does not appear to distinguish between unlawful street racing\n               and authorized safety-managed filming on public roads. Public safety must always come first. At the same time, legislation must be precise\n               enough to avoid unintended consequences that affect lawful economic activity. Honouring Xavier's memory requires seriousness and care. It requires that we ensure\n               that any legislative response is clear, enforceable, evidence-based and consistent\n               with the broader structure of our motor vehicle laws. If there are gaps, they should\n               be closed. If penalties need strengthening, that should be addressed. If enforcement\n               tools require refinement, we should examine them closely. Every member of the House wants safer roads. The responsibility before us is to ensure\n               that in pursuing that goal, we craft legislation that is workable, proportionate and\n               effective — legislation that truly advances public safety in a meaningful way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317155","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill M226, the Motor Vehicle Act (No. 2), 2025, also known as Xavier's Law. This bill is named in the memory of 12-year-old, Xavier Rasul Jankovics, who was rollerblading\n               with his brother on a rural road in Shawnigan when he was struck by a 17-year-old\n               driver. The vehicle attempted to swerve, lost control, hit Xavier with such force\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e0cdbdf25550c0f979ba9b95398c0e6c26895d53fdb7acfcd0958bb91b84b81a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["22db445a9ddb50d025ebce5ed1545c666c32ee67c1045be444d82b01d7549312"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c37ff4027909dbd571379f2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327993,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, 2026, which proposes\n               amendments to British Columbia's Civil Forfeiture Act. Let me begin clearly. Criminals and money launderers should not be allowed to live\n               in luxury off their ill-gotten gains. Crime should not pay. In British Columbia, where\n               money laundering and organized crime have caused real harm to our housing market,\n               our economy and our public confidence, we must ensure that illegally acquired assets\n               are pursued, seized where appropriate and returned to support communities and victims. At the same time, we do need accountability and transparency, as my colleague from\n               Surrey-Panorama was talking about. We need accountability and transparency to make sure the civil\n               forfeiture funds and assets, and the funds from those assets, get to proper community\n               safety groups and victim supports. That's absolutely crucial. The principle of the Civil Forfeiture Act and making it more efficient is something\n               that I support. British Columbians have lived through consequences of weak enforcement and slow institutional\n               response. The Commission of Inquiry into Money Laundering in British Columbia, the\n               Cullen commission, made it clear that organized crime and money laundering were significant\n               and pervasive problems in our province. One of the recommendations was to strengthen\n               proactive investigations, from the Cullen commission, and give the civil forfeiture\n               office the tools it needs to independently identify money laundering schemes and pursue\n               high value assets. Budget 2026 proposes expanding proactive operations of the civil forfeiture office\n               in line with those recommendations. Modernizing the civil forfeiture office so that\n               it can more effectively target organized criminals and money launderers is a step\n               in the right direction and it's a step forward. The government has framed this piece of legislation as improving fairness, clarity\n               and efficiency. Specifically, Bill 8 aims to streamline litigation while preserving\n               fairness, update timelines and dispute rules Specifically, Bill 8 aims to streamline litigation while preserving fairness, update\n               timelines and dispute rules, cut costs and preserve asset value, improve information-sharing\n               with safeguards, add fairness safeguards for record gathering. These are reasonable\n               objectives. Since 2006 the civil forfeiture office has generated over $221 million for the government.\n               Of that, approximately $93 million has gone towards crime prevention and community\n               safety grants and about $1.7 million towards victim compensation. Now, the intent of allocating funds towards community safety grants and towards victim\n               compensation, that's a well-served purpose and that should be facilitated, especially\n               in today's time. In today's time, we are seeing an increase in the amount of victims\n               as a result of crime that's running rampant throughout British Columbia. We are seeing\n               victims as a result of repeat violent offenders. We are seeing victims as a result\n               of repeat property offenders. We are seeing victims in the forms of businesses that\n               are just trying to keep up and stay afloat. We are seeing victims being re-victimized and we are seeing the extent of victims\n               increase throughout our province. So this is the time that we need to actually do\n               more for victims. And we need to make sure.... We need to step up the process to go\n               after these criminals and seize their property that they've gotten from illegitimate\n               purposes. And we need to help fund proper community safety grants, as well as victim\n               supports. But with the same token, we also need to have accountability and transparency to make\n               sure these community safety grants are properly allocated and victim supports are\n               properly allocated. So, these are reaching the individuals and the groups of victims\n               that actually need these supports. I just briefly went through some numbers in terms of how much has been generated through\n               the civil forfeiture office. These are meaningful numbers. Recovered criminal assets\n               should be redirected to strengthen community safety and support victims. However, it is not estimated.... Something that we don't know as a result of these amendments\n               is how much will these actual amendments generate further? How much of a difference\n               will they make? It would have helped to actually know the research behind this so\n               we could, in a more fruitful way, debate this bill because the purpose seems to be\n               that we need to get more funds to community safety grants and victim supports, and\n               we need to really deal with these criminals that are profiting off their illegitimate\n               business. But a crucial fact and a piece of information and research that would help us in this\n               purpose would be to actually know what sort of revenue would be generated as a result\n               of bringing forward these amendments by having more efficiency and clarity in this\n               legislation. That raises an important point. If the government is going to expand the powers and\n               efficiency of civil forfeiture, transparency about how those funds are used must increase\n               as well. We must make sure that the proper research is done. We must make sure that\n               these funds from the civil forfeiture is actually making it to the proper recipients\n               that it's going to benefit the most in terms of victim supports. Criminals are not transparent. Government should be transparent. Let me now walk through some of the major clauses of Bill 8. Clause 1 amends section 5 to require that a person filing a response must provide\n               full particulars of the nature and extent of their claimed interest in property. The original provision required particulars, but this amendment clarifies and strengthens\n               what must be included. Now The original provision required particulars, but this amendment clarifies and strengthens\n               what must be included. Now, I have a background in law. I've been a lawyer for approximately 191⁄2 years. I\n               know when you bring clarity to statutes, that takes away a lot of ambiguity, and it\n               really affects the efficiency of how to interpret a statute that really helps you\n               to streamline problem-solving. To the extent that these amendments now bring efficiency and they bring more clarity,\n               that's something that I support. We need to have more clarity, we need to have more\n               efficiency in our statutes and in our regulations, because that really helps the legal\n               profession. It really affects anybody that is relying on statutes to further the purposes\n               of the statutes that we look at. Going back to this clause that I'm looking at, clause 1, this brings some changes,\n               brings clarity for litigation. It ensures that the court and the director know precisely\n               what interest is being claimed and on what basis. Clarity brings a lot of benefits, as I just touched upon. Clarity reduces delay. Clarity\n               reduces legal costs. Clarity reduces gamesmanship. Just to touch upon legal costs, one of the ways that we do see legal costs increase\n               in litigation is that when someone attempts to bring a solution to a problem but it's\n               not the proper solution, the litigants have to keep trying to actually get to a safety\n               spot where they can actually solve the problem. But if the legal tools were clear\n               and the parties really knew exactly how to solve the problem and exactly which technique\n               to use, that would actually save a lot of time. We know with the wheels of justice, they kind of move slowly. As they move slowly,\n               that takes a lot of time, and as a result of the time, that's where.... The legal profession\n               bills based upon the time, and that's why the legal costs accumulate. If there's a\n               way to make the process more efficient, to understand the legislation better, and\n               to get to the root of the problem better, and to supply the solution to that problem,\n               that would make the process simpler and more efficient in terms of reducing legal\n               costs. Again, when I see words used such as clarity, efficiency, and reducing ambiguity in\n               statutes, that's something that really triggers me because I know it can really make\n               a difference if we deal with these items within our justice system. Going back to clause 1, if someone claims an interest in property, they should be\n               able to explain what the interest is and how it arose. This all promotes fairness\n               on both sides. So clause 1 does add some value here in terms of Bill 8. Clause 2. If we go further into clause 2, clause 2 introduces a new default judgment\n               mechanism where a party fails to file and serve a response. So a new mechanism where\n               a party fails to file and serve a response, when you know there's a claim but there\n               hasn't any response filed in relation to that claim. The original section 7 in the original act allowed a court to refuse or limit forfeiture\n               if clearly not in the interests of justice. That protection still remains, even with\n               this amendment in clause 2, but this new provision allows the court to proceed where\n               parties simply do not respond. If there's no good reason, and there's no response\n               filed, the court can proceed. And if the court can proceed, that allows for more efficiency Clause 2 really addresses a real litigation gap. When respondents fail to engage,\n               proceedings stall. Assets sit. Value deteriorates. Costs rise. This amendment streamlines\n               the process while maintaining judicial oversight. The court must still be satisfied that the requirements are met, so this is a safeguard\n               as well. There is still the ability to set aside or vary orders. Under this provision,\n               orders can still be set aside, so that's an important safeguard, although if a party\n               without no good reason doesn't file a response, action can be taken. That allows streamlining\n               civil forfeiture. Then going a little bit further into clauses 3 and 10, there are some updating of\n               timelines. The original statute talked about 30 days, and now these particular clauses\n               talk about 60 days. Clause 3 and 10 extend certain timelines from 30 days to 60 days\n               for the director to commence proceedings or withdraw notice. The original 30-day window may have been too tight given the complexity of modern\n               financial investigations. We know sometimes criminals can get, you know, a little\n               bit creative in how they hide assets. So investigations have to get even more significant.\n               As the investigations get more significant, they may take longer. So increasing the\n               time period from 30 days to 60 days makes sense. Money laundering cases are not simple. They involve layered transactions, shell entities,\n               cross-border components. That's a little bit of a gist of what could happen when we're\n               dealing with criminals that are trying to hide their money from illegitimate sources.\n               Extending to 60 days improves administrative clarity and reduces rushed litigation.\n               It ensures better preparation and more efficient proceedings overall. Now getting into clause 4 of this bill. Clause 4 clarifies language. As I stated earlier,\n               clarity, taking out ambiguity, in statutory language is very important. Clause 4 clarified\n               some language. This is a drafting clarification that improves precision. Precision\n               in legislation improves fairness and reduces interpretive disputes. I'll move into clause 6 next. Clause 6 formalizes how the director may be examined\n               for discovery. For the people listening to the word of discovery, discovery is an\n               examination under oath. It could be kind of a proceeding akin to something happening\n               in court. Usually, examinations for discovery are done under oath, just like court\n               proceedings are done, and usually before a court reporter. This clause 6 talks about\n               examination for discovery of directors. Clause 6 formalizes how the director may be examined for discovery, limiting examination\n               to one knowledgeable representative. We often see when we are looking at court rules and you want to examine, say, a company\n               or, say, an organization, usually that organization and company exists with a name,\n               but there are many people behind that organization or the company. It's not just that\n               you're dealing with one person. So you have to have a person who's a representative\n               or a person that is an authoritative voice from that organization or company that\n               you can ask questions to under oath. This clarifies who one would be asking questions\n               to This clarifies who one would be asking questions to. This clause 6 formalizes how\n               the director may be examined for discovery, limiting examination to one knowledgeable\n               representative. This promotes efficiency and reduces duplicative examinations, while\n               still preserving the ability to test a director's case. It's a practical litigation\n               modernization. Now, moving next to clause 7 of Bill 8, this clause 7 adds a presumption that motor\n               vehicles depreciate over time in interim preservation applications. And although many\n               people know that vehicles are usually depreciating assets, although there could be\n               some vehicles that are collectibles that accumulate value over time, most vehicles\n               do depreciate over time. It's important for legislation to put this presumption in the legislation because\n               if you don't have the presumption in there, you may have to resort to experts to kind\n               of decide what the value of that vehicle asset is. So this is an important tool in\n               terms of clarity and taking out ambiguity, having this presumption. A presumption, essentially, is a term used when.... Rather than presenting evidence\n               to prove something, you have a term such as presumption. The statute actually states\n               that is the evidence if you have that facts scenario. If you have vehicles, the presumption is that vehicle is depreciating, without having\n               to actually prove that. That's a legal term that is brought forward into this legislation.\n               To have this type of presumption for clarity purposes, it's just common sense. Allowing timely disposition preserves asset value so that proceeds can support community\n               safety grants. We really do need to know about if there are vehicles, and if they\n               are being confiscated and they are being forfeited, we do need to know that they are\n               depreciating. Why it's important for civil forfeiture purposes is we need to get the maximum value\n               to community safety grants, to victim supports. If we wait too long and a vehicle\n               asset depreciates, loses all its value, there may not be much there to actually give\n               in terms of a community safety grant or a victim support. So this particular clause\n               serves a very important role. It's about preserving public value, and it actually\n               serves a crucial purpose. Moving next to clause 8 of Bill 8, this clause authorizes a director to collect and\n               disclose specified information to jurisdictions inside or outside Canada where reasonably\n               required. Money laundering, as we know, is transnational. Criminals don't really operate within\n               borders. They try to expand where they're operating. Money laundering flows with those\n               criminals and is a transnational crime as well. If the civil forfeiture office cannot share information effectively with other jurisdictions,\n               it cannot effectively pursue high-value organized crime assets. There needs to be\n               an element for the director, under the civil forfeiture office, to be able to collect\n               and disclose information across jurisdictions, inside or outside Canada, for this\n               legislation to be effective in terms of getting at criminal illicit funds, in order\n               to forfeit those funds and in order to get those funds and assets and values from\n               those assets to community safety grants and victim supports. Clause 8, again, serves\n               an important purpose. Clause 9 talks about removing the fixed six-month limit on non-disclosure of a director's\n               information request but adds Now this talks about information that the director is trying to get in terms of civil\n               forfeiture. But the original act had a time limit on it. But sometimes a time limit\n               may not make sense because if the investigation is taking longer, if the process is\n               taking longer, if the director is not able to comply with a certain time limit, that\n               may kill the efforts to actually conduct civil forfeiture. So it's important that.... This clause is important that it moves away from an actual time period, but it actually\n               creates a different form of a safeguard as this particular clause does. It adds a\n               requirement that notice be given to the individual as soon as practical after the\n               six month period expires. So although the six-month period expires — now you're not\n               operating within the six-month period — there is still a requirement on the director\n               to provide disclosure of the director's information request as soon as practical after\n               the six-month period. So as long as the investigation doesn't get jeopardized, if it's not getting jeopardized,\n               that disclosure should be happening. This balances investigative integrity with eventual\n               notice. Investigations cannot succeed if subjects are tipped off prematurely. At the\n               same time, individuals are entitled to notice once secrecy is no longer required.\n               That is a reasonable safeguard. There are also some transitional and consequential clauses in this bill, as many bills\n               usually have, towards the end of the bill. The transitional clauses ensure procedural\n               consistency across ongoing matters. The consequential amendments to the Offence Act\n               and the Unclaimed Property Act align timelines and definitions to reflect the updated\n               60-day framework. These are technical but necessary to maintain coherence across statutes. So, in conclusion, money laundering and organized crime are not abstract policy discussions.\n               Money laundering distorts housing markets. Money laundering funds drug trafficking.\n               Money laundering empowers transnational criminal networks. Strengthening the civil forfeiture office so it can proactively identify and pursue\n               high-value criminal assets, as recommended by the Cullen commission, is a step forward.\n               Reducing litigation delays lowers taxpayer costs. Clarifying processes improves fairness\n               for respondents. Preserving asset value ensures more funds are available for crime\n               prevention grants, community safety initiatives, and victim supports. These amendments\n               move us in that direction. Well, I support these changes. I believe there must be greater transparency in how\n               recovered funds are allocated and returned to communities, as I stated at the outset.\n               Funds.... As the member from Surrey-Panorama was stating earlier, there needs to be some accountability and transparency to make\n               sure the funds collected from civil forfeiture do end up addressing victim supports\n               and real community safety grant initiatives. It can't be based on a partisan basis.\n               It has to be based upon the victims that need it. And as I stated earlier, the amount of victims that we are seeing in this province. As I stated earlier, the amount of victims that we are seeing in this province is\n               increasing. More and more crime is being committed. As a result, there's more and\n               more victims, and there's a diverse extent of victims right across this province. We need to make sure that the civil forfeiture funds are actually reaching victims\n               that actually need it. With that, we need to have proper transparency and accountability\n               to make sure that those funds are getting where they need to get. Over $221 million has been generated since 2006 through the civil forfeiture office.\n               That is significant. But British Columbians deserve clear annual reporting on amount\n               recovered, clear breakdowns of where funds are distributed, measurable outcomes tied\n               to community safety grants, transparent criteria for allocation. If we are expanding\n               efficiency and investigative power, we must expand public accountability. Criminals\n               operate in secrecy; government should not. All in all, civil forfeiture of funds and assets that criminals have accumulated from illegitimate\n               activity is a good thing, and we should make the process more efficient. But at the\n               same time, there needs to be more transparency to make sure the funds from civil forfeiture\n               are getting to the victims that actually need those funds.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327993","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, 2026, which proposes\n               amendments to British Columbia's Civil Forfeiture Act. Let me begin clearly. Criminals and money launderers should not be allowed to live\n               in luxury off their ill-gotten gains. Crime should not pay. In British Columbia, where\n               money laundering and organized crime hav","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9c2ce80408fdd891f9fec354b0f0ab86aa317891cdfbf604c64a1d56f363064"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["38a776f00c438cd2506742730814abbda389eae8764bc5294edb490e9ca15d5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c6e9e5f3bfd00a142fdf7a6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360393,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statues Amendment Act, at second reading\n               today. The Minister of Forests made some comments about protecting workers. I believe workers\n               should be definitely protected, but I want to also speak to this government's record\n               in terms of protecting workers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360393","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 10, the Labour Statues Amendment Act, at second reading\n               today. The Minister of Forests made some comments about protecting workers. I believe workers\n               should be definitely protected, but I want to also speak to this government's record\n               in terms of protecting workers.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["83c14531e2fd31da6fd51cf30fec1a56f9453eb02b3c7068fc7bc71b2ef2f1bb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c81c7adb987c12ae8a1694b5a8658732e0f012730433f1dc26eb87bf522e09d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b501ef80f9322ff5a50c720","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360394,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll be speaking to Bill 10. Okay. We're talking about the Labour Statutes Amendment Act. Although I highlighted that\n               the changes are welcome in regards to protecting workers, as I was stating earlier,\n               these changes don't go far enough. There are some flaws in the system that's designed to protect workers. Because there\n               are flaws in the system, these changes may not go far enough to actually protect workers. I was also, earlier, starting to talk about consultation. There were various groups\n               that had stated that they were not consulted. As I highlighted earlier, in order to\n               have a strong implementation of legislation, there need to be proper resources, there\n               need to be proper enforcement, and people need to be served. That's why it's absolutely\n               crucial that proper consultation should have been had on this particular bill. When governments move ahead without meaningful consultation, the result can be unintended\n               consequences that create new challenges rather than solving existing ones. So if there\n               was proper consultation, maybe there could have been more mechanisms set in this legislation\n               to actually make sure workers are protected in regards to complaints that they make\n               under the employment standards branch. Maybe their grievances could be dealt with in a more efficient manner. Rather than\n               having only 32 percent of the complaints being dealt with in a six-month period, maybe\n               all those complaints could be dealt with in an expedient manner Good labour legislation should bring stakeholders together, should build consensus\n               where possible and it should reflect the realities faced by workers and businesses\n               across the province. Earlier I touched upon workers and small businesses. I was touching\n               upon small businesses because small businesses also are the backbone of our economy\n               in this province. They are made up of families, everyday British Columbians, that\n               try to pursue entrepreneurism to put food on the table across this province, in their\n               homes. Small businesses, like I said, form the backbone of our economy. Across British Columbia,\n               small businesses employ hundreds of thousands of workers. And we are here talking\n               about protecting workers. Part of that equation is looking at the conditions or the\n               environment for workers and making sure that workers also have employment moving forward. Many of the small businesses operate with small margins and limited administrative\n               capacity. Unlike large corporations, they often do not have dedicated human resources\n               departments or in-house legal teams. When new regulatory requirements are introduced\n               those burdens fall directly on small business owners who are already juggling many\n               responsibilities. That's why it's essential that labour legislation carefully consider\n               the impact on small-business employers. We want to have a robust system that's not flawed, that actually protects workers.\n               If there are some grievances, if there are some complaints, those complaints need\n               to be dealt with expediently. In order to have a proper-functioning system, you need\n               to bring all parties together to figure out, how do we enforce these mechanisms, how\n               do we deal with these complaints in an efficient manner? That can only be done when you bring all the parties together to figure it out. When\n               you have an issue, it's just not one person or one party. It's another person and\n               another party right across from them. It's absolutely crucial to look at the whole\n               environment, especially when you're looking at.... There are issues within the system. The provincial government is stating that they recognize some of those problems. Thirty-two\n               percent of complaints being dealt with in 180 days is not good enough. They recognize\n               that. They're saying that they want to get the target up to 80 percent within six\n               months. I'm saying that 80 percent even is not good enough. You should have 100 percent\n               of those complaints dealt with. It's not even good enough for people to have to wait six months. Those complaints\n               should be dealt with expediently, especially when a lot of the workers that are accessing\n               employment standards branch dispute mechanisms are living paycheque to paycheque.\n               People may not be able to afford or they may not have the conditions to wait six months\n               when they actually need that paycheque to pay the bills, to put food on the table. Just to get a little bit more into this legislation, since I have a few more minutes\n               here, one of the most significant changes proposed in this bill relates to the appeal\n               process for determinations made by the director under the Employment Standards Act. Under the amendments in this legislation, an employer wishing to appeal a determination\n               would be required to deposit the full amount of money owed before the appeal can proceed.\n               The funds would be held and would accrue interest during the appeal process. The tribunal\n               would have the ability to allow a smaller deposit on a case-by-case basis. I understand the rationale behind this proposal of putting down the full deposit.\n               I understand it. You want to protect.... Make sure if there's any money owing or there's\n               any paycheque owing, you want to have it on hold, but there are circumstances where I understand it. You want to protect, make sure if there's any money owing or there's\n               any paycheque owing, you want to have it on hold. But there are circumstances where there's employers involved and there's a bit of\n               a due process for them, and they may have some legitimate concerns. On the most part, there may be legitimate reasons to actually have that deposit. But\n               there may be also circumstances where employers also have legitimate reasons to actually\n               state why their claims are valid. So when this legislation says that a complete deposit needs to be deposited — of a\n               full amount, and that's in dispute — that may not be taking into consideration where\n               there are legitimate employers that are legitimately disputing the claim amount. It\n               doesn't take that into consideration. And that's a little bit of an issue because we're going through bad economic times.\n               We've got the worst deficit in history. We haven't seen a worse deficit than we have seen in this province, than the one that we have seen brought\n               forward by this government. We have the worst debt. The private sector is struggling to just keep afloat. Private sector is struggling to keep the jobs\n               going so workers can have the work. If there are some legitimate concerns or complaints\n               that employers have, and they are operating just on a month-to-month basis, that may jeopardize certain work that workers need to have. So it's absolutely crucial that when you do a form of consultation, you need to look\n               at all angles, you need to look at all the parties, because when there's a dispute,\n               it's not just one-dimensional; it's multi-dimensional. If you want a solution, a proper solution to fix the system,\n               you have to listen to all the parties involved. So some angles of the legislation\n               could be a little bit difficult for employers that have some legitimate concerns or\n               legitimate disputes. In justice, appeals exist for a reason. It's due process. It's part of justice. And\n               we often see, when appeals are made, sometimes the decision that was rendered against\n               a party, it gets reversed because it was a wrong decision. That's how our justice\n               system works. There's an appeal mechanism that's there, so it needs to be fair to\n               everyone. In terms of consultation, the process should have included everyone, especially when\n               we are dealing with a system that has major issues and especially when workers' complaints\n               are essentially at only 30 percent, in terms of being dealt with in a six-month period. I'm just going to summarize now, since we have another couple of minutes left on the\n               clock here. The broader issue is making the system work. Legislation like this often\n               focuses on procedural adjustments — how complaints are filed, how investigations are\n               conducted and how appeals are handled. But the broader question remains whether the system is working effectively, and that's\n               been the theme of my speech today. We've got to make sure that the broader system\n               is working for workers. It's not enough just talking about the issue. It's not enough\n               just by merely tinkering with certain pieces of legislation. The broader system needs\n               to be fixed. If workers must wait months or even years to resolve complaints, that's the problem.\n               That's the flawed system. If small businesses struggle to navigate complex procedures,\n               that is also a problem. If the employment standards branch lacks sufficient resources to meet its responsibilities, that is a problem as well. Ultimately, the goal should be a system that delivers Ultimately, the goal should be a system that delivers timely, fair and accessible\n               justice for everyone involved. Workers should receive their wages quickly. Employers\n               should have clear rules and a fair opportunity to respond. The government should ensure\n               that enforcement mechanisms are properly resourced. The intent, the goal of the legislation is good here, but we are still dealing with\n               a flawed system, and that system needs to be fixed so workers rights are protected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360394","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'll be speaking to Bill 10. Okay. We're talking about the Labour Statutes Amendment Act. Although I highlighted that\n               the changes are welcome in regards to protecting workers, as I was stating earlier,\n               these changes don't go far enough. There are some flaws in the system that's designed to protect workers. Because there\n               are flaws in the system, these ch","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f9328551220d0b03b90d8305092784b5a11af95116beb9dfd7c397401afdeb38"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d981b904bb15c9400c6db04f8ab7f52401934f5bf595b37e6b663f1b8ccd87bd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d72c3549d917c951b131f0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360395,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Over 230 Queensborough students rely on the Queensborough bus service to get to New\n               Westminster Secondary School safely and in a timely manner. Advocacy has been relentless,\n               and two days ago New Westminster city council voted to permanently reinstate the bus\n               service. This NDP government campaigned on keeping the school bus running. Will this government reverse its cut, extend funding and honour their promise — yes\n               or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360395","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Over 230 Queensborough students rely on the Queensborough bus service to get to New\n               Westminster Secondary School safely and in a timely manner. Advocacy has been relentless,\n               and two days ago New Westminster city council voted to permanently reinstate the bus\n               service. This NDP government campaigned on keeping the school bus running. Will this government ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0960198a1a26db86cecc1a4651b4638c4c4f55eb61ae349c04da0c0a882259a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4dd452e9182bacefb74eee3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415751,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise as the Attorney General critic for the official opposition to speak to Bill\n               12, the Safe Access to Schools Amendment Act, 2026. We just heard the remarks of the Attorney General, and we heard that there was an\n               original enactment, the Safe Access to Schools Act, that, I believe, was brought forward\n               and enacted in 2024. We've heard remarks from the Attorney General that there shouldn't\n               be impeded access to schools, and there shouldn't be fear or safety concerns about\n               having access to schools. We've heard that, originally, this enactment was enacted a couple of years ago — two\n               or three years ago. Now we're back here in the Legislature. Fast forward two or three\n               years later, the government is trying to extend the time limit of this piece of legislation. We've also heard from the Attorney General that despite the government bringing forward\n               this legislation, the fears and the safety concerns in regards to access to schools\n               have not ended. In essence, we've heard that the legislation that this government\n               introduced has not solved the issue of fear and public safety issues in regards to\n               access to schools. That has not been addressed, and that's why we're here, hearing\n               from the government that they want to extend this piece of legislation. Those are my preliminary remarks. I'm going to get into my speech here. I rise today\n               to speak to Bill 12, the Safe Access to Schools Amendment Act, 2026. At its core, this bill is straightforward. If you look at this amendment act, it doesn't\n               really have too much wording. It just has a couple of clauses in there, and it specifically\n               deals with dating issues and extending issues in regards to the original enactment. This piece of legislation extends the repeal date of the Safe Access to Schools Act\n               from July 1, 2026 to July 1, 2028. It gives an extension of two years, specifically.\n               That is the entirety of the amendment before us today. Let me begin by stating clearly, I support safe access to schools. We support safe\n               access to schools. Every student in this province deserves to attend school free from\n               public safety issues and free from fear of being able to access their schools. Every\n               parent deserves confidence that their child can enter school safely. Every teacher\n               and staff member deserves a workplace free from fearful interference. There should\n               be no ambiguity on that point. However, there are some concerns with this legislation. Specifically, we have heard\n               from the Attorney General that the original public safety concerns have not been dealt\n               with, with the original enactment. We are still seeing public safety incidents. On a more common basis, we see real incidents. On a more common basis, we see real incidents. We see issues where students have felt\n               threatened. We've seen issues of lockdowns in regards to our schools. Having public\n               safety issues around our schools is entirely unacceptable. Schools are places of learning,\n               not places where children have to fear in terms of attending educational institutes. The key question here when we're now revisiting this legislation is: why is this happening?\n               We are seeing legislation being introduced, but we are not seeing the underlying issue\n               of what has been going on with our schools being addressed by this government. The underlying issue is enforcement. We do see other pieces of legislation, such as\n               the Criminal Code of Canada. It talks about if there's intimidation. It talks about\n               if there's fearful impeding. It talks about harassment, if there's criminal harassment.\n               Those mechanisms, those tools are there in that other piece of legislation, such as\n               the Criminal Code. So we've always had these tools of stopping fearful interference\n               with access. The problem seems to be that there's not efficient enforcement. That has allowed for\n               these fearful interruptions, these fearful impediments to our school system, to continue.\n               So the underlying cause needs to be dealt with, because we've heard from the Attorney\n               General, just right now, that despite introducing this legislation two or three years\n               ago, these incidents of where children fear to access their schools are still happening. They're still happening despite this legislation being enacted two or three years\n               ago. That is really concerning because this is happening with the backdrop of public\n               safety issues happening right across the province. Whether we're seeing it with our\n               school system or with religious places of worship or with retail shops or with just\n               everyday folk trying to walk in their neighbourhoods, we are seeing fearful impediments\n               for accessing different institutes or different services that British Columbians require. This is happening on an ongoing basis, so there seems to be an underlying cause to\n               the real root of these circumstances that are now resulting in this government trying\n               to extend this piece of legislation. Those underlying causes need to be dealt with\n               because public safety is paramount and not enough is being done. There is significant legislation out there, such as the Criminal Code, and we also\n               saw the original enactment of this piece of legislation. But the problem seems to\n               be that there isn't enough enforcement. If you do not enforce laws that currently\n               exist, the public is going to continue to see problems involving public safety issues. This is very concerning, because public safety should be a fundamental issue that\n               gets dealt with immediately. We need to have proper resources with the enforcement.\n               We need to make sure our law enforcement are properly resourced. We need to make sure\n               our justice system is properly resourced. If we have the proper resourcing, we will see that people that want to take the law\n               in their hands and cause fearful interruptions, we will see those actually decrease.\n               If we have effective enforcement and if we have as As the Attorney General just alluded to earlier, the incidents that the original legislation\n               was designed to stop are not stopping. If they're not stopping, that means that the\n               government is really missing the mark, and the mark seems to be that this seems to\n               be more of a public safety issue that we're dealing with in this province. That public\n               safety incident isn't just related to our schools; it's related to every aspect of\n               life in this province right now. When you are going out and talking amongst your colleagues, amongst neighbours, amongst\n               family, it's a common theme that the public is talking about public safety, and they're\n               saying that more needs to be done. They're saying that there is not an effective enforcement\n               of the laws that we currently have. We can keep creating more and more laws, but if\n               you don't resource the enforcement mechanisms, the public safety enforcement mechanisms,\n               the public safety enforcement tools, the problem will not be solved. We really do need to look at the underlying issues behind the legislation. Why is\n               the problem not stopping? We need to stop the problem. Our children, British Columbians'\n               children, are the future of this province. When we look at vulnerable people, we think\n               of children, we think about seniors, and we think about other groups. If we do think\n               about the vulnerable, we need to make sure that we are addressing the underlying causes\n               in terms of the issues that we are seeing. on a daily basis. We need to be asking ourselves: why are the situations escalating to the point that\n               we now have to look at creating new laws, when there are existing laws that deal with\n               harassment, interference, fear? Those have been long-standing laws. They have been\n               there for years and years. We need to be asking: how come we didn't have these problems\n               before, and they've become a new problem, when we've had these laws for a very long\n               time? What seems to be missing in the discussion? There seems to be a failure to recognize\n               there's a widespread public safety crisis that we are dealing with throughout this\n               province. Whether that involves repeat property offenders or repeat violent offenders,\n               or we have people that want to create fear for students, or create harassment for\n               students or create criminal impediment for students, it all seems to come down to\n               the same rubric. It comes down to an issue of public safety. If you are dealing with an issue of public safety, you have to deal with enforcement\n               mechanisms. You have to make sure the enforcement tools are properly resourced. At\n               the end of day, you can try creating more and more laws, but if you have lack of enforcement,\n               you're not going to get anywhere in terms of creating that safety for children. You\n               must properly resource. I currently serve as critic for Attorney General, and we recently had debates on the\n               budget in regards to Attorney General budgets. One of the concerns I had was that\n               the justice realm isn't properly funded in this province. We need to make sure our law enforcement, our justice system, is properly resourced. We need to make sure we are being proactive. We need to make sure we are providing\n               more resources, because if we have more visibility of our public safety enforcements,\n               you will have more of a deterrent effect. That's why the deterrent effect is If we have more visibility of our public safety enforcement, you will have more of\n               a deterrent effect. That's why the deterrent effect is a major, major element of looking\n               at criminal law or looking at the criminal code or looking at public safety statutes.\n               Deterrence serves a major purpose. One thing that seems to be missing right across this province is that public safety\n               is not properly resourced. Until we deal with that, there might be ongoing concerns.\n               You can create as many words as you like, but if you don't have the tools, if you\n               don't have the tools in motion, the problem is not going to disappear. So the answer to the underlying problem really matters. Do we have the enforcement\n               tools? I would suggest that we do have the enforcement tools, but they're not properly resourced.\n               And the question becomes.... If you don't properly resource the enforcement mechanisms,\n               are you going to solve the problem in regards to the fear that's preventing access\n               to institutions such as schools? You will not be able to do that if you don't properly\n               resource the actual enforcement mechanisms. So that's where this government seems to be not supporting students, children and\n               the vulnerable population throughout this province. And until we address that issue,\n               the ongoing issues that were mentioned earlier about fearful disruptions, about harassment\n               or about impediment won't be dealt with until you've got the enforcement mechanisms\n               that are mobilized, that are properly resourced, that are highly visible and they\n               are actually stopping the underlying public safety issues. This government has failed time and time again on public safety enforcement. That\n               is the reality. We see that constantly being discussed in the public domain. Public\n               safety is an ongoing issue on a daily basis in this whole province. With this piece of legislation, we saw another piece of legislation addressing a different\n               topic but also having to deal with access. Safe access. That's another aspect that\n               we are dealing with — the public safety crisis in this province. And to deal with\n               all situations, all different aspects that involve public safety.... If you do not properly\n               fund enforcement, public safety enforcement tools, that problem, the public safety\n               problem, will not be resolved. It doesn't matter which area we are dealing with, whether it's schools, whether it's\n               religious places that we worship, whether it's business venues or whether it's neighbourhoods.\n               This government needs to do better. Like I mentioned earlier, we already have laws. We've seen this law, the original\n               enactment. We also have the Criminal Code of Canada, which has been there forever,\n               that addresses the very behaviours such as intimidation, obstruction, causing disturbances,\n               interference with lawful activities. These are not new concepts. They are not gaps in the law. There are established offences\n               to deal with this type of conduct. So when we are seeing repeated public safety incidents,\n               the issue is not that the law is unclear. The issue is that the law is not being consistently\n               enforced. So instead of fixing that problem of enforcement, what are we seeing? We are seeing legislation being used to compensate for weak enforcement. We are seeing\n               words being introduced into statutes in lieu of enforcement. We are seeing the government\n               extend measures instead of strengthening the system. The system needs to be strengthened. And the supports around the system need to be\n               strengthened in order to get results, to make sure children are not We are seeing a reliance on new rules instead of ensuring existing rules are applied.\n               We have existing rules to address the exact conduct that the Attorney General referred\n               to earlier. We have had these rules for a very long time. How come we're not seeing\n               any meaningful action on that legislation that has existed for a very long time. That's\n               the question that needs to be asked. Bill 12 is attempting to solve a problem. It's a problem that needs to be solved,\n               because children need to feel safe, students need to feel safe, and they need to have\n               safe access. But the underlying issue is that we currently have laws to deal with\n               behaviour that is actually creating fear for students and children. But it's only\n               if those laws were enforced that we could actually get rid of that fear that our students\n               and children are seeing when they're trying to access their schools. Another point I'd like to make about the original enactment and this particular statute\n               is that this statute is now attempting to extend the previous statute by another two\n               years. There was originally a time limit put on the original statute. It was brought\n               into force in 2024. The time limit was until 2026. A couple of years were given. Why\n               did the government only give it a couple of years? Why did the government only give\n               it two years? They gave it two years because they were trying to bring a temporary solution until\n               they found a permanent solution — a permanent solution to a big problem. I would respectfully\n               submit that that big problem is our general public safety crisis in this province.\n               This government has not been effective in addressing that crisis in this province. It's already been two years. Now, since this government has not been able to deal\n               with the exact behaviours that need to be dealt with in terms of making sure our kids\n               feel safe and students feel safe accessing schools, we are now back here so that government\n               can come up with another temporary solution and just give another two-year time limit\n               on this legislation while they look for permanent solutions. Now, that's a little bit problematic, because that kind of shows that this government\n               is being reactive, not proactive. By now, there should have been some sort of framework\n               for a permanent solution. That should have been brought forward. So put it out there. It's very important to protect children. It's very important to protect students in\n               regards to their safe access to their learning places. Children are students, and\n               children are the future of this province. But we must do more than just give them\n               a temporary solution. We must give them a permanent solution, and that permanent solution\n               comes in the form of public safety enforcement in this province and making sure public\n               safety is properly resourced and funded. To the degree that our public safety enforcement\n               establishment needs further resources, those needs must be dealt with as well. This government must give time to address the real issue. It's had It shouldn't be acceptable that we are seeing more and more incidents of lockdowns\n               at our schools where children fear.... They've had one lockdown or another school's\n               had a lockdown. They fear to now attend school. That doesn't create a safe environment\n               for learning. I remember attending school when I was a child in this province. I don't think I've\n               ever heard of any lockdown happening. When I went to, say, elementary school in the\n               '80s, or went to high school in the'90s, I don't recall hearing these types of incidents\n               that we are hearing about today in this province. So, seriously, there has been something\n               that has changed. And we are seeing that, despite new legislation being introduced,\n               the problem isn't going away in terms of public safety issues in this province related\n               to schools. The government is now extending the original time aspect of the original legislation,\n               which is July 2026, to July 2028. So we will now be in a state of a temporary fix\n               to the underlying problem for another couple of years. But we must get to the bottom\n               of this. We must have a permanent solution. It doesn't send a good message to children\n               or students in saying, \"Hey, we're going to give you a temporary fix here. We'll relook\n               at the problem in a couple years.\" What about these students? They're probably in the school system right now. They're\n               thinking, \"Okay, what do I do in two years from now?\" If this government is serious about solving safety issues for students in regards\n               to accessing schools and education institutes, then this government must introduce\n               a real plan in funding and resourcing the public safety enforcement mechanisms that\n               exist in this province. Where is the plan? Increase in police presence may be needed. Where's the plan to\n               fund that even more? We need to make sure there's consistent enforcement across communities.\n               Is that happening? We need to make sure there's support for officers on the front\n               lines. Whether that be law enforcement or bylaw enforcement, we've got to make sure\n               that the people on the front line doing the enforcement have the support to actually\n               enforce laws to, in fact, make sure there's safe access to schools. And we also need to make sure.... We need to work with Crown prosecutors to ensure there's\n               proper follow-through if somebody is creating an infraction on the law, with the current\n               law that it sits with, involving access to schools without any fear. Without all these elements in terms of the justice system, law enforcement and consistency\n               in enforcement.... If all these mechanisms are not dealt with, nothing will change because\n               the enforcement will not change. The same public safety incidents will continue. The\n               same public safety issues will occur and we'll be back here again, extending this\n               legislation once more. And children will be wondering, where's the permanent fix? Children require stability. One of the things that, in family law, courts look at\n               is they want to make sure children are in stable situations. When you're just giving\n               temporary fixes every couple of years, that's not creating a stable environment. All in all, we've had laws that deal with these types of concerns for a long time\n               — such as harassment, intimidation, impediment — that prevent all this stuff. We've\n               had laws for a very long time. Now we are back here again, asking for a temporary fix, but we are not funding the\n               proper public safety enforcement. If this government only did, we would not be asking\n               for permanent fixes. We would be getting permanent solutions. And students deserve\n               permanent solutions. Children deserve permanent solutions, because stability matters\n               for this age group.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415751","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise as the Attorney General critic for the official opposition to speak to Bill\n               12, the Safe Access to Schools Amendment Act, 2026. We just heard the remarks of the Attorney General, and we heard that there was an\n               original enactment, the Safe Access to Schools Act, that, I believe, was brought forward\n               and enacted in 2024. We've heard remarks from the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a7c2eaf0ff3ad79afd4b49c6e74fb37a6189fe4b3d6f6c0d79c75130d8227df"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e52f4795e4822cb15017239ea5a60e6a426e796a1368220e02cd8992e9c0a684"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a5388e5e9ce8ac39d16ab25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415752,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act, Bill 13. Let me begin with something that is very important. Every British Columbian should\n               be able to attend their place of worship in safety, in peace, without fear. Whether\n               it is a synagogue, a mosque, a church, a gurdwara or a temple, these are sacred places.\n               These are spaces where people gather for their families, their communities and their\n               faith. There is no place in British Columbia for intimidation, harassment and disruption,\n               causing fear at these locations. That's the starting point. I'd like to also state that what we are seeing with the religious places, what we\n               are seeing with the concerns from religious places.... This is a public safety concern.\n               We are noticing that we have a significant public safety crisis in this province,\n               which is touching religious communities. It's touching schools. It's touching vulnerable\n               individuals. It's touching all aspects and all regions of British Columbia. We need\n               to be doing a lot more for public safety in this province. There are real concerns raised by religious communities across this province in terms\n               of public safety. There are significant issues with public safety in this province.\n               We have seen incidents where individuals attending places of worship have felt unsafe.\n               We have heard directly from community leaders who are asking for protection. Those\n               concerns deserve to be taken seriously. While we are having an honest debate today, we must also address the core underlying\n               issue to these concerns — the public safety concern and the issue of public safety\n               enforcement in this province right now. The core issue is whether this provincial government is enforcing the laws that actually\n               exist right now, because the reality is that many of the actions that this bill, Bill\n               13, seeks to address are already illegal under the Criminal Code of Canada. The Criminal\n               Code of Canada has existed for a very, very long time in this country. Under the Criminal Code of Canada, intimidation is illegal. Criminal harassment is\n               illegal. Uttering threats is illegal. Obstruction is illegal. Disturbing religious\n               worship is illegal. When these activities amount to criminal harassment, criminal\n               intimidation, criminal obstruction, the real question is: how come we are not seeing\n               action? How come we are not seeing public safety enforcement action on these laws?\n               That's the question. If we saw public safety enforcement action, we would be seeing less fear, seeing less\n               concern in the public about concerns visiting religious places of worship, concerns\n               visiting educational institutes, concerns visiting places of business. We have tools right now that have existed for some time. We have legal tools. What\n               has been missing is consistent, visible and effective enforcement of these public\n               safety tools. We can bring more legislation, but we must also bring enforcement of\n               that public safety legislation to have meaningful results, to make sure that our religious\n               communities can feel safe, that members of the public can feel safe in this province. There are costs related to government inaction. When enforcement fails, communities\n               are forced to step in. Now, we've heard the Attorney General mention, give examples\n               of some of the concerns about religious communities, what concerns the religious communities\n               are having. I want to speak about a real example. Members of the Jewish community have told us\n               that one synagogue in British Columbia is paying approximately $100,000 per month\n               for private security. Let us think about that; $100,000 per month for private security.\n               That's over $1 million in private security for a year. Private citizens shouldn't have to pay for their own security costs. The provincial\n               government should be enforcing public safety laws and having meaningful results in\n               public safety so that British Columbians would not have to pay for private security\n               on their own or even have to resort to those measures. While we're at it, while we're discussing Bill 13 and this new piece of legislation\n               and while we're discussing public safety enforcement, it doesn't really help religious\n               communities now when the government has brought forward a budget which puts an additional\n               7 percent on security costs. That adds extra cost to enforcement, and that does not\n               help public safety for religious communities. That's not how public safety is supposed to look like, when private citizens are having\n               to pay for their own private security and are burdened with even more expenses on\n               top of that private security. Public safety is a core responsibility of this provincial government, and when this\n               government Public safety is a core responsibility of this provincial government. When this government\n               fails to deliver it, the burden shifts onto families, onto volunteers and onto communities.\n               That's exactly what is happening today. We are seeing words being legislated, but where's the meaningful action that's going\n               to protect religious communities in this province? It's a simple question: where has this government been? Where has the enforcement\n               been? Where has the visible presence of public safety been when these communities\n               needed it the most? Passing a new law after the fact does not erase the reality that\n               communities were left to deal with these challenges on their own. There's a serious risk when there's substitution of legislation for action. Legislation\n               alone cannot solve the public safety problem. There must be action to solve the public\n               safety problem. This is a problem in terms of.... We are seeing a continued trend from this government.\n               We are seeing an increase of legislation, but when it comes to actually seeing action,\n               we're not seeing that. That seems to be a trend, whether you're looking at public\n               safety or you're looking at other areas. I've been seeing that through the debates, seeing that through the legislative work\n               here at the Legislature. I've been seeing a lot of legislation come through, but when\n               you actually try to see if that legislation is delivering results on the ground, that\n               seems to be something really, really missing. Every time a problem arises this government introduces more legislation, but legislation\n               is not the substitute for action. Religious communities deserve enforcement action.\n               Religious communities deserve public safety enforcement action. These crimes, crimes\n               that are done against religious communities, need to stop. They need to stop. We need a robust justice system. We need strong resources for our law enforcement\n               so there's strong enforcement on public safety issues, so communities don't have to\n               deal with these types of public safety issues in the first place. Although we're seeing the government moving on bringing this legislation, the hope\n               is that the government also considers enforcement, because legislation alone won't\n               solve the problem that religious communities are facing. We already have a Criminal Code of Canada, and it addresses all the elements that\n               are being addressed in this new piece of legislation that we have before the House,\n               which is Bill 13. The real question is: although we have the Criminal Code of Canada,\n               how come we don't have that public safety enforcement? Public safety enforcement is\n               the responsibility of this provincial government. How come we haven't had that enforcement? If we've had legislation that actually deals with intimidation, harassment, impediments\n               to access to religious places.... If we've had this legislation for a very long time,\n               why hasn't there been action? So we are in need for real public safety measures. We need more than new legislation\n               to address the problem, like I just mentioned. What is needed is a comprehensive approach\n               to public safety. That includes ensuring police have the resources they need, ensuring\n               laws are consistently enforced, ensuring there is a visible presence when risks arise,\n               ensuring communities are supported before problems escalate. Another trend we have seen is a reactive measure from this provincial government when\n               it comes to public safety crises throughout this province. This government has been\n               reactive in addressing public safety issues in this province. This government has\n               always been scrambling once the public safety crisis arrives. What needs to be done? There needs to be a comprehensive plan for public safety in\n               this province, for religious communities in this province, where proactive action\n               takes place in regards to public safety enforcement in this province. The goal should not be to react after the fact. The goal should be to prevent any\n               sort of fear, harassment, impediment to religious communities. The goal is to prevent\n               this type of activity, and if it does happen, the goal should be to do the enforcement\n               of public safety to make sure it doesn't happen again. We've heard from the Attorney General earlier when we just started discussing this\n               bill. In addition to the legislation, there's also responsibility on this government\n               to ensure that our justice system is functioning effectively. That includes enforcement.\n               It includes coordination with law enforcement. It includes ensuring that existing\n               laws are being used to their full extent. If those laws are not being enforced, then\n               the question becomes: why not? We have to get this right for religious communities and all British Columbians in\n               this province. A lot of people come to this province, and one of the top reasons that\n               they come to this province, they move to this province from other countries, is they\n               feel that this is a safe place to live. They come for safety. They come for security. If you don't have safety or security, everything else is put into question in life.\n               One must feel safe in order to live their lives. This question.... I have heard it firsthand.\n               People that have come from different countries have posed.... Some people have come to this province and now they're thinking about going back to\n               the country of their origin because they don't feel safe. That's not right. We can't\n               just have words being legislated. We have to have public safety enforcement. The public religious communities need to have the confidence that the provincial government And we often hear the words that there's a lot of talk. But where's the walk? Meaning:\n               where's the action? And when you ask people that have actually dealt with this type\n               of fear, these types of public safety incidents, they will tell you. They're like:\n               \"We're not seeing the results. We're not seeing the protection.\" So if people are\n               not seeing the protection, what good are just words being legislated? It's unacceptable. People on the ground, communities where they are, religious communities, British Columbians\n               need to see action where they once again feel safe again in this province. As legislators,\n               we have a responsibility to ensure that any law that passes here is clear, effective,\n               and workable. We must ensure that this bill is also properly drafted. We must ensure\n               that it can be enforced in a practical way. We must ensure that it actually improves\n               safety on the ground. Because the ultimate measure of legislation will not be what\n               is written on paper. It will be whether people feel safer when they walk into their\n               place of worship. So let me be clear. The goal of protecting access to places of public worship is important.\n               The safety of religious communities across British Columbia is important. We on this\n               side of the House will continue to hold this provincial government accountable for\n               their failure to enforce the laws that already exist. We must have public safety enforcement\n               in this province to make sure religious communities and British Columbians feel safe.\n               We will continue to raise the concerns of communities who have been left to carry\n               the burdens themselves. I explained earlier that one synagogue is having to pay $100,000 per month for private\n               security. That's over $1 million per year. The provincial government should actually\n               be taking public safety enforcement action, so communities shouldn't be left on their\n               own to provide their own public safety.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415752","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act, Bill 13. Let me begin with something that is very important. Every British Columbian should\n               be able to attend their place of worship in safety, in peace, without fear. Whether\n               it is a synagogue, a mosque, a church, a gurdwara or a temple, these are sacred places.\n               These are spaces ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c4445a9333982267c4319d769404b1c2d464400367272d7cb117f7f700914095"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bde83d405e1e894726dc0186f7b63b628c8e98f1ae26080a8d00909063c45060"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5776f2f39de65c2fa4b0e23c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415753,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Prior to the break, I was stating that there is a major public safety crisis throughout\n               this province. The public safety crisis has hit religious communities as well. I had\n               given one example of how big of a public safety crisis this actually is. The public safety crisis has hit religious communities as well. I had given one example\n               of how big of a public safety crisis this actually is. I learned that there's one\n               synagogue that is paying $100,000 per month for private security. That's over $1 million.\n               This is very concerning. It's concerning because, although we're having this legislation come through the House,\n               we've had legislation to deal with the very things that this legislation purports\n               to do as well. We've had the Criminal Code of Canada that makes it an offence to harass\n               individuals, makes it an offence to intimidate individuals, makes it an offence to\n               impede individuals from access to religious places of worship. Yet communities right\n               across this province, religious communities, have had to deal with fear, have had\n               to deal with interference, have had to deal with harassment, have had to deal with\n               intimidation and have had to deal with major public safety situations. The question is why? Why have these communities had to deal with this? The answer\n               is there's been public safety legislation, but it has not been enforced in our province.\n               It needs to be enforced so religious communities and British Columbians can be protected. I'm going to get into my concluding remarks. This debate is more than a debate over\n               a single piece of legislation. It is about whether government is fulfilling one of\n               its most fundamental responsibilities, and that's keeping people safe. Communities\n               should not have to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for their own protection.\n               That's not right. Communities should not have to wonder whether the laws that exist,\n               whether those laws will be actually enforced or not. And communities should not have\n               to wait for new legislation to feel safe. The tools exist. The public safety enforcement rules exist, but they're not being\n               enforced. In order to enforce those tools, we need to have a robust justice system\n               that's properly resourced, with ample amount of resources and budget and staffing.\n               We're not seeing that in this province right now. Justice system is underfunded. There are a lot more tools that can be provided to law enforcement to enforce public\n               safety legislation. If there are issues with enforcement, then it strongly needs to\n               be looked upon. What extra resources can you provide to enforcement to actually deal\n               with public safety enforcement? Because if there's already legislation in place that\n               deals with the subject matter of Bill 13, in the Criminal Code of Canada, but you're\n               still having the problem where communities are feeling unsafe, there seems to be a\n               bigger underlying problem. The underlying problem is with the enforcement. The responsibility exists on the provincial government to make sure there is a substantive,\n               organized manner and plan to deal with the actual enforcement of public safety enforcement.\n               What has been lacking is action on public safety in this province. As we consider this What has been lacking is action on public safety in this province. So as we consider\n               this bill, Bill 13 — that's Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act — let us also\n               focus not only on what is being proposed. Let's also focus on what has not been done.\n               Because British Columbians deserve more than words. They deserve safety.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415753","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Prior to the break, I was stating that there is a major public safety crisis throughout\n               this province. The public safety crisis has hit religious communities as well. I had\n               given one example of how big of a public safety crisis this actually is. The public safety crisis has hit religious communities as well. I had given one example\n               of how big of a publi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75f3d1ba6fb2d575d26e30f5a8a26623ae853671b06c6d6c254e0f0963701ddb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7e84e1cbd1b0041e665bdcaeb53eaa35e948e5931f61c92a0b9ba4ce6a6133a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5725aa1b855b0237f4acac9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415754,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday my colleague from Richmond-Bridgeport and myself received a letter from the city of Richmond. It showed that Richmond residents\n               and the city remain deeply concerned about the implications on private property around\n               the Cowichan decision. Despite assurances from this government and the Cowichan in a joint statement, uncertainty\n               persists. Will the Attorney General commit to Richmond city council to elevate the joint statement\n               to a legally binding agreement that protects private property owners, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415754","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Yesterday my colleague from Richmond-Bridgeport and myself received a letter from the city of Richmond. It showed that Richmond residents\n               and the city remain deeply concerned about the implications on private property around\n               the Cowichan decision. Despite assurances from this government and the Cowichan in a joint statement, uncertainty\n               persists. Will t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["827eb14ef5df501c08aca05e98252160db514f3f1eeb1f34a0e8918f9b93e006"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0e73191632bf048cc6a9ae0c4dc623a5aefeb53e2653bb4a1f297e0d0aa939d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b11f054993e61b8cabf7a9ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720401,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise as the official opposition critic for the Attorney General to speak to Bill\n               16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. I'd just like to state from the outset, when we're dealing with miscellaneous statutes\n               or miscellaneous amendment statutes, they're perceived as a good thing because what\n               we are doing is we are dealing with housekeeping legislation. A lot of times things\n               go missed or new situations pop up and older legislation may not address those new\n               situations. So a lot of times we have these housekeeping bills coming through the\n               Legislature where many different subject matters are taken into consideration and\n               some loose ends are actually tied up. To that extent, I think most people, most members of this House would agree that housekeeping\n               bills are a good thing, and we should encourage more of them to come to this House.\n               With better legislation.... A lot of times when you're involved in the court process\n               and you're involved with any sort of litigation, sometimes things come down to interpretation\n               and sometimes things come down to legislation that's not that clear. A lot of time\n               in the court gets wasted upon dealing with figuring out what was the meaning of the\n               law and trying to interpret that law. To the extent that we are bringing miscellaneous statutes housekeeping bills to this\n               House to address clarification issues, to address new situations that were not contemplated\n               when the original legislations were actually brought forward, is actually a good thing\n               because we do have a backlog in our court system. We do have a lot of inefficiencies\n               within our court system. There are issues with resources as well. One thing we can do to support the court system is make sure that we are making the\n               process with legislation the most efficient as possible. To that extent, whenever\n               we see miscellaneous statutes or miscellaneous statute amendment bills, it's always\n               a welcome thing to see. That's what I want to state from the outset. Miscellaneous statute amendment bills, when used properly, serve a legitimate purpose.\n               They are meant to tidy up legislation. Miscellaneous statute amendment bills, when used properly, serve a legitimate purpose.\n               They are meant to tidy up legislation. They action items such as housekeeping, technical\n               fixes and minor updates that improve clarity and the administration. Like I said earlier,\n               that is something all sides of this House can generally support. But there is one\n               aspect that was very concerning of this bill that really caught my attention. It was\n               part 1 of this bill. Now, part 1 of this bill deals with the Attorney General amendments. It specifically\n               deals with the Judicial Review Procedure Act. It's clause 2 that actually is the meat\n               and substance of this particular part. Clause 2 actually deals with this. It deals\n               with disclosure of confidence of the executive council. And there are definitions\n               in here. It talks about the cabinet. It talks about ministers. It talks about cabinet\n               secretaries. It talks about deputy cabinet secretaries. It also talks about secretaries\n               to the Treasury Board. Basically, what this clause does or is purporting to do is essentially any information\n               that gets certified as confidence of the executive council that's brought forward\n               by, say, a minister or a cabinet secretary or a secretary to the Treasury Board....\n               That information can be certified as confidence. What does that mean? That means if there is an application for judicial review in\n               our court, say if there is a regulatory body and there's a decision made by that regulatory\n               body and one of the parties wants to make an application for judicial review because\n               they do not agree with the decision of that regulatory body, they would be now dealing\n               with this particular clause that is now being put forward. It's very important when we're dealing with regulatory bodies and we're dealing with\n               mechanisms of judicial review.... It's very important to understand the aspect of administrative\n               law. The aspect of administrative law is a little bit different than.... Say you're\n               dealing with civil litigation matters that involve trial matters, where you have a\n               trial and then you can appeal that trial decision to a Court of Appeal. At the Court\n               of Appeal level, you will look at whether the decision was properly made, and you\n               can even canvass and look at some of the evidence. But when we're dealing with applications for judicial review, we're dealing with administrative\n               law measures. When we're dealing with regulatory bodies and having an appeal mechanism\n               that is judicial review, the extent of appealing, the mechanism appealing, becomes\n               a little limited in terms of if you're looking at it with a legal lens. So judicial\n               review seems to be more of a limited amount of an appeal mechanism. So now if we're looking at it from this lens, that now this clause is going to apply\n               to applications for judicial review that already have a limited extent of an appeal\n               mechanism, it's a little bit concerning, because what would happen in this case when somebody doesn't agree with a regulatory body's\n               decision.... They may want to rely on evidence that came out of a cabinet decision to\n               support their application for judicial review. And now what this particular clause will do is that anyone — a minister, a cabinet\n               minister, a secretary to the Treasury Board, a secretary to the cabinet — can just\n               certify information as confidence. Certifying information as confidence will automatically limit disclosure in regards\n               to what can be disclosed in an application for judicial review when a particular party\n               is looking to get at evidence that is in the realm of the cabinet. Just to go a little bit further into this clause, I've just kind of set the premise\n               of this clause, but what this clause does is....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720401","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise as the official opposition critic for the Attorney General to speak to Bill\n               16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. I'd just like to state from the outset, when we're dealing with miscellaneous statutes\n               or miscellaneous amendment statutes, they're perceived as a good thing because what\n               we are doing is we are dealing with housekeeping ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0429d2eb54f3132402d8ca1e64d8a680750edd3f543a6faf8b63e10e69c88dae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["469129c4d2e59bfbb9e65457125abb3d2b083ae15b19c12a99ac62ba5165816a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8779d4da10c7dc1fade5f576","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721500,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"We have heard about legal liabilities. We have heard about ongoing cases. British\n               Columbians are facing these issues right now because of this government. This government\n               introduced DRIPA. It was this Premier who introduced section 8.1 of the Interpretation\n               Act. It was this government that created this legal liability around DRIPA. This Premier\n               is out of ideas and does not have a further plan. Can this Premier guarantee legislation in the fall session about these DRIPA amendments?\n               Yes or no.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721500","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We have heard about legal liabilities. We have heard about ongoing cases. British\n               Columbians are facing these issues right now because of this government. This government\n               introduced DRIPA. It was this Premier who introduced section 8.1 of the Interpretation\n               Act. It was this government that created this legal liability around DRIPA. This Premier\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["294cd5897bb32bc8aa2cd671e0c6546cbed53b64618245710603fd5e02836b99"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c41fd726cc93aab3b20a1647a6817a502ac10ac262784efea101306bc1691aaf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-771bf4071a44751e189dccc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721502,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. I want to be clear from the outset. I'm deeply concerned about\n               this legislation, not just because of what it does on its own but because of what\n               it represents as a part of a broader and deeply troubling pattern we are seeing from\n               this government, a pattern of less transparency, less accountability and more control\n               over information. We have seen the use of NDAs — non-disclosure agreements used extensively by this\n               government throughout different ministries. And we have seen in the public domain\n               the complaints from the public and the media about the lack of transparency that is\n               happening in government negotiations, in government deals. This is very concerning. Just in the latest Just in the latest budget from this government, we saw an abolishing of the Office\n               of the Merit Commissioner. The Office of the Merit Commissioner is supposed to bring\n               transparency to decisions of hiring and firing, in terms of human resources. And yet\n               that office is now being taken out. That's another element of lack of transparency. And now we are seeing this bill, which is attempting to restrict information that\n               the public can receive in regards to government decisions. And this is very, very\n               concerning, because we are seeing a long-standing trend of lack of transparency and\n               secrecy on the part of this government. A troubling pattern is emerging. Like I said,\n               Bill 9 does not exist in isolation. It is a part of a pattern that we are seeing,\n               a pattern where this government is steadily closing doors that should remain open. I've mentioned three specific incidents about this pattern. One we see with this bill,\n               Bill 9, that deals with the restrictions of freedom of information. Another, I've\n               explained, is in regards to the removing of the Office of the Merit Commissioner.\n               And thirdly, I've mentioned extensive use of non-disclosure agreements. When you view the substance of this bill, Bill 9 will allow to charge a fee to access\n               information. That will further create an impediment for accessing information. We\n               have seen trends where there are less disclosure requests when there are fees involved.\n               And that takes away from accountability. This government has said that they're bringing this bill forward for efficiency purposes.\n               But in the language of this bill, there are aspects where you can extend the time\n               period of when disclosure must be made. And a significant factor is that there is\n               vague language used throughout this bill on where the government can now decide if\n               a request fits the bill of some of this vague language. Access can be impeded to information.\n               That does not serve the public. That does not serve public transparency of the government. Transparency is not optional in a democracy. It is essential. It is what allows the\n               public to trust their government. It is what allows this Legislature to function properly.\n               And it is what ensures that power is exercised responsibly. When transparency is reduced,\n               accountability suffers. When accountability suffers, public trust erodes. This is\n               why this bill and its contents matter so much to be debated. It is a core responsibility of the government to have transparency, to be accountable\n               to the public. But when you put restrictions through this legislation Secondly, a fee being payable creates a huge obstacle for accessing information to\n               hold the government accountable. That's a huge problem. At its core, Bill 9 limits\n               British Columbians' access to government information. It does so in a few ways. It\n               expands the government's ability to ignore or dismiss FOI requests. This is troublesome.\n               How can the government allow for behaviour that's going to ignore or dismiss FOI requests\n               from the public? That is deeply troubling and concerning. Also, this bill introduces new fees for accessing information. This information, the\n               government's information, is the public's information. The government governs for\n               the public. So it doesn't make any sense when the government is adding new fees to\n               impede the public from viewing government actions and decisions being made. It doesn't\n               make any sense. This legislation, Bill 9, weakens the standards and timelines for responses. The government\n               has argued that this bill will create some efficiency for accessing information. But\n               if you look at the essence of this bill, and you look at the language of this bill,\n               you will see there are also some discretionary measures where timelines can be extended.\n               When timelines can be extended, it defeats the purpose or the intent that the government\n               is saying that they're bringing forward this legislation. But we know what will definitely happen. It won't be efficiency in accessing information\n               or processing freedom of information requests. What this bill will actually do, despite\n               what the government is saying that this bill will do, is minimize scrutiny of the\n               government. It will minimize accessing information or evidence to hold this government\n               accountable. Now, just in the public domain, there was a media report that this government spent\n               $165,000 on coffee for a event in the U.S. That's $165 per coffee cup. And when that\n               came out in the public, there was uproar. The public doesn't agree with that. The\n               public does not agree with that. The public agrees that there needs to be transparency.\n               The public should have access to that information. That's the point. Public should\n               have access to that information. What this legislation is going to do is going to make it tougher for accessing information\n               such as that. The information that came about.... There were reports that this type\n               of legislation is going to make it more difficult to get that type of information.\n               That's the point. It's the process. It's the transparency. That's what I'm getting at. Providing transparency\n               is the utmost responsibility of the government. If you take that to the public, do\n               you think the government should be less transparent or more transparent? I'm pretty\n               sure the public is going to say the government should be more transparent. And that's\n               the point that I'm trying to make here. There are some real troubling issues with some of the language of this bill. Some\n               of the impediments I spoke about earlier. I was speaking to vague, undefined terms\n               that appear throughout this legislation, where information can be restricted. For example, the bill talks about information can be restricted where there are issues\n               of abusiveness, malicious or repetitious or excessive broad requests and requests\n               that may unreasonably interfere with operations of the government. When you look at\n               these words where information requests can be restricted, they can be restricted where\n               the government feels the requests are abusive, where the government feels the requests\n               are malicious, where the government feels that the requests are repetitive, where\n               the government feels the requests are excessively broad and where the government feels\n               that the requests may lead to unreasonably interfering with operations of the government. Now we've seen examples of legislation from this House that have resulted throughout\n               the court process. We've seen court cases that are interpreting legislation passed\n               from this House. We've seen the government state it wasn't the intent of the government\n               to have certain legislation interpreted how the courts are interpreting that legislation.\n               Now when you have overly broad terms used in this particular bill where the government\n               can prohibit access to information based upon certain categoric words that can be\n               interpreted quite broadly, there can be a significant restriction on how much information\n               the public gets access to. This is a problem. This is a problem when you have vague wording that can allow for\n               restricting of information. None of these terms that I just spoke about are well-defined. They are left entirely\n               open to interpretation. And who is actually doing the interpreting? Well, the interpreting\n               is going to be done by the government. So there are these broad words used, which\n               will allow for the restricting of information to the public. These broad words that are used for restricting information access, the interpretation\n               of those words will be left to the government. That's the issue, because on one hand,\n               there are transparency issues. There is an overall pattern of lack of transparency\n               happening. On the other hand, there is more legislation, such as Bill 9, that's being\n               brought forward, where there are restrictions put in place to future requests for\n               information. The interpretation of those restrictive words are going to be left to the government\n               to decide what those restrictive words mean and whether requests can be denied. At a time where we are seeing a pattern of lack of This bill is deeply troubling. There are huge risks involved in terms of the vague\n               language in this bill, as I've mentioned. I've enumerated the different words that\n               can be used to restrict access to information. I'll just give a few examples of how\n               the vague terms create a problem for accessing information in practice. The use of these vague terms, restricting information, means that requests that are\n               inconvenient to the government can be labelled in ways that justify ignoring them.\n               It means that persistent applicants, people who are simply trying to get answers,\n               can be dismissed as repetitious, can be dismissed for their persistence in trying\n               to access information. What these vague terms of restriction mean is that broad requests, often necessary\n               to uncover systematic issues, can be dismissed as excessively broad. These vague terms\n               of restriction also mean that any request that creates political discomfort could\n               be framed as interfering with government operations. We're dealing with a dangerous\n               precedent here in terms of unjustly restricting information to the public with this\n               bill. As I mentioned, we're dealing with a government that's already struggling with transparency\n               issues. This is where context matters, because this is not a government with a strong\n               track record of transparency. This is a government that has already faced criticism\n               for being overly secretive. When the same government brings forward legislation that\n               expands its ability to ignore information requests, we have every reason to be concerned. This legislation has a provision that allows the government to charge fees for records\n               that currently don't have an impediment of pricing involved or fees involved. This\n               is problematic. Bringing in new fees is problematic. Putting new fees on information\n               that is supposed to be information of public domain is problematic. This legislation also raises a simple but important question: should British Columbians\n               have to pay to access information that already belongs to them? That is what this bill enables. This bill creates a system where transparency can\n               be paywalled, and that's not acceptable. Again, this bill and what it brings in terms of lack of transparency fit into a broader\n               pattern. The government has already introduced fees into the FOI system. This government\n               was warned at that time that it would reduce access, and now, instead of removing\n               barriers, they are adding more. Step by step, access to information is becoming more\n               difficult, more expensive and more restricted. If the government were serious about improving the FOI system, which seems to be the\n               intent being put forward by the government, they would address the issue that people\n               care about the most — delays. We know that applicants have been waiting an average\n               of 192 additional business days beyond standard timelines. That is unacceptable. What\n               does this bill do? It weakens the requirement to respond without delay and replaces\n               it without unreasonable delay. This is not stronger accountability. This is weaker\n               accountability. Putting Bill 9 into the bigger picture, we are seeing a step back from transparency.\n               The government is expanding its ability to refuse information requests. The government\n               is introducing new costs for access. The government is weakening response timelines\n               and operating within a broader pattern of secrecy, from NDAs to removing independent\n               oversight to now limiting access to information. This is not a coincidence. This is\n               a direction of this government. Public trust is at stake. The real issue here is trust, public trust. Once people\n               start to believe that a government is hiding information, once the public start to\n               believe that access is being restricted, and once the public start to feel that they\n               are being shut out, that very public trust is very difficult to rebuild. Freedom of information is not a technical issue. It is a democratic principle. It\n               ensures that governments remain accountable to the people it serves. Bill 9 moves\n               us in the wrong direction. It limits access, it introduces costs, and it expands the\n               government's ability to avoid scrutiny. Perhaps most concerning of all, this bill\n               fits into a broader and troubling pattern of reduced transparency from this government. From NDAs to eliminating oversight to restricting access to information, British Commons\n               are seeing a government that is becoming less open, not more, and that should concern\n               every member of this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721502","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026. I want to be clear from the outset. I'm deeply concerned about\n               this legislation, not just because of what it does on its own but because of what\n               it represents as a part of a broader and deeply troubling pattern we are seeing from\n               thi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f27ff3c3e0f4b986de8932de20886965f4e09d72b6cbc47a1ece693ad8cf65d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["337721312954bd5b56dd3494c43111d3783ce08c5259282d6ff3b3814dfe10a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1153c0e0db5960ce65ebf49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721506,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thirty days before the ruling on the case of the killing of Const. Shaelyn Yang, the\n               National Police Federation wrote to the Attorney General to warn her office there\n               would be no victim impact statement by her family if the accused was found unfit to\n               stand trial. They even provided a solution. Despite that advance notice, this Attorney\n               General failed this family. Why did the Attorney General not respond to these concerns raised by the National\n               Police Federation and the family of Constable Yang?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721506","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thirty days before the ruling on the case of the killing of Const. Shaelyn Yang, the\n               National Police Federation wrote to the Attorney General to warn her office there\n               would be no victim impact statement by her family if the accused was found unfit to\n               stand trial. They even provided a solution. Despite that advance notice, this Attorney\n               Ge","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54bf022760afab9d4df446f7d4d8b3d422e926bdcaebd8d197fb335a7c8e4894"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36ea312ba3351498226701ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729177,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a couple of friends in the gallery, Amrit Dhot and Srikanth Mogulala from C\n               Face. They do great work in putting on folk and culture events. Can the House please welcome them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729177","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a couple of friends in the gallery, Amrit Dhot and Srikanth Mogulala from C\n               Face. They do great work in putting on folk and culture events. Can the House please welcome them.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035318","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Folk art","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035318","label":"Folk art","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26a813cc74ea2d2745a691202406388c8f0109dd0afb5c8bce0630c12e0a35d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c19ebb98f9494220b8d738ebb5256dbf21104668b51896b430cc671124198879"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0f037572a39f7d03e7706c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752269,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in support of the amendment brought forward by the member for Langley-Willowbrook. The original motion that was brought forward, M207, limits the changes to just independent,\n               small movie theatres. But it's important to note the business community is struggling\n               and theatres are struggling right now, right across the board. We need to keep the\n               theatre industry afloat, and we need the theatre industry to keep moving forward so\n               the population in British Columbia has access to entertainment to its fullest extent. If we limited the changes to only small, independent movie theatres, we would be limiting\n               the type of entertainment that British Columbians would have access to because the\n               bigger movie theatres have more selection. This is an important point. The other thing is that over the last decade, the business community has really been\n               struggling. The choices have been narrowed down in terms of what British Columbians\n               can actually access in terms of services. So we need to be doing more. If the amendment was allowed, it wouldn't limit the motion that was brought forward\n               by the member for Kootenay-Monashee. It would allow for liquor to be served in mixed-age categories in small, independent,\n               rural movie theatres as well as larger movie theatres that have a lot of selection.\n               We need to be encouraging businesses right across the board to have an environment\n               of success. There's an element of fairness. We shouldn't be discriminating against any sort of\n               business just because of their size or their quantity in this province. The law should\n               be clear and fair right across the board. The other thing is we currently have a precedent. You can go watch a hockey game over\n               at Rogers Arena. There's alcohol served there. You could go to a restaurant. Alcohol\n               is served there. You could go to a major concert. Alcohol is served there. So why\n               stop at just small, independent movie theatres? Why not extend that also to apply\n               to major movie theatres as well to its fullest extent? We shouldn't have restricted options. There's already a precedent in different hospitality\n               businesses, where we have restaurants and we have sports venues that are already providing\n               alcohol service, are already providing liquor service. So with this motion, why would\n               we be limiting the extent of businesses that could actually provide liquor services? For that reason, I'm supporting this particular amendment that's been brought forward\n               by the member for Langley-Willowbrook so we can have liquor services that can be provided by all movie theatres right across\n               the board in this province. The other thing is that it's just common sense. If there's an adult population here, they should be able to decide on their choices\n               rather than have the government tell them where they can purchase their liquor or\n               not in terms of, say, a small, independent movie theatre chain or a larger movie theatre\n               chain. I know the member for Kootenay-Monashee already said that the liquor services already exist for the larger chains, but he\n               did also mention that they only exist to a limited extent. If we are amending the laws, it should be fair right across the board. The member\n               from Kootenay or Comox, with his able submissions, also mentioned that the theatre\n               industry has been struggling and mentioned that 38 percent of the revenue for the\n               movie theatre chains comes from food and beverage. So if 38 percent comes from food\n               and beverage, we should be doing more to encourage these movie theatres to be supplying\n               or having access to supplying alcohol services. Noting the hour, I reserve my right to continue this debate, and I move to adjourn\n               the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752269","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to speak in support of the amendment brought forward by the member for Langley-Willowbrook. The original motion that was brought forward, M207, limits the changes to just independent,\n               small movie theatres. But it's important to note the business community is struggling\n               and theatres are struggling right now, right across the board. We need to keep the\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5f02eeb0fd7ea5b3b35ecfbd4198cb8ee86fb94f5b335f0c8eae4e50348c2f7d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58c257210997f50e105ba25913372aae38714582ea11b62052ce62c777f3ea11"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f6fc76938831c518d95aba6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752270,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise today to welcome a group of students visiting from Hugh McRoberts\n               Secondary School in Richmond. They'll be joining us at approximately 10:40 a.m. It's\n               a group of 30 grade-10 students along with their teachers led by an Angelica Ross-Cumia.\n               It's always a pleasure to see young people here at the Legislature taking the time\n               to witness our democratic system in motion. Please join me in making these students and their teachers feel very welcome. Please join me in making these students and their teachers feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752270","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise today to welcome a group of students visiting from Hugh McRoberts\n               Secondary School in Richmond. They'll be joining us at approximately 10:40 a.m. It's\n               a group of 30 grade-10 students along with their teachers led by an Angelica Ross-Cumia.\n               It's always a pleasure to see young people here at the Legislature taking the time\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["454165cac7754157d6dabde26c02e2721b1f994766d22aa7333f5181432693b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bd5958ef0c86f13d11822793d6b6cfb2a63231d9d4255a80bc52b2aa256eeb9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a17c78aca869f07264ffbbf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752271,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the outstanding contributions of Master Shi Xing Wu and\n               his Xing Wu Zen Temple Society in Richmond-Queensborough. On May 2, I had the privilege of attending the society's fourth annual multicultural\n               art and expo festival, held in celebration of the International Bathing Buddha Festival\n               and B.C. Buddhist Culture Day. This event was a powerful reflection of the society's\n               commitment to building community through culture, tradition and shared experiences. Under the leadership of Master Shi Xing Wu, the Xing Wu Zen Temple Society has become\n               a respected and welcoming presence in our community. Through martial arts, meditation,\n               Buddhist teachings and charitable initiatives, the society continues to create opportunities\n               for people of all ages and backgrounds to come together, learn and grow. Their events\n               are welcoming and community-focused, and they bring people together in the spirit\n               of respect, understanding and connection. At a time when strong communities matter more than ever, this kind of leadership and\n               dedication makes a real difference. One significant recent example of where Xing Wu Zen Temple Society made a real difference\n               was when they held a stage play and charity dinner. There were donation proceeds as\n               a result of those events last year. The society actually donated a portion of those\n               proceeds to the Richmond Hospital Foundation. That's an example of their significant\n               contributions within the riding of Richmond-Queensborough. Master Shi Xing Wu's society's community efforts go beyond organizing events. They\n               help foster a sense of belonging and ensure positive values and strengthen the social\n               fabric of Richmond-Queensborough. Master Shi Xing Wu Society's community efforts go beyond organizing events. They help\n               foster a sense of belonging and ensure positive values and strengthen the social fabric\n               of Richmond-Queensborough. I want to sincerely commend Master Shi Xing Wu and all members of the Xing Wu Zen\n               Temple Society for their ongoing contributions and their commitment to serving our\n               community of Richmond-Queensborough.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752271","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the outstanding contributions of Master Shi Xing Wu and\n               his Xing Wu Zen Temple Society in Richmond-Queensborough. On May 2, I had the privilege of attending the society's fourth annual multicultural\n               art and expo festival, held in celebration of the International Bathing Buddha Festival\n               and B.C. Buddhist Culture Day. This event ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["589061372da258c32715a4da7d7d1dbb8f90fb16ca21d89d8ae487832f316d0c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["325340bcabc56ba379a88b41a5dd93de3820eb5890721e180835c0cc5f4021a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7dd4744e327eb95a365f914c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752272,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I see a colleague from the legal profession up there, Amrit Narangi. So can the House\n               please welcome him?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752272","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I see a colleague from the legal profession up there, Amrit Narangi. So can the House\n               please welcome him?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b76588805221fa89a56e86e11c4527c90a14ad6583211b43c9471f310f8e2c65"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ceca3938ddb7dedebfb1d24d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017379,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd also like to welcome Raj Admi and Mannu Sandhu as well. I know them from the\n               community. So welcome, you guys.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017379","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd also like to welcome Raj Admi and Mannu Sandhu as well. I know them from the\n               community. So welcome, you guys.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d368d079fcc127ec03480593","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036502,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize two devoted parents, dentists Dr. Stalingit Gill and Dr.\n               Navpreet Gill, and their incredible team standing with them in support of their son\n               Gurmoh Gill. Gurmoh is here, along with their other child, as well. They have walked all the way from Vancouver to the Legislature, step by step, to raise\n               awareness and support for their son Germoh, who is battling a rare and fast progressing\n               neurodegenerative disease referred to as Spastic Paraplegia Type 4, often referred\n               to as SPG4. May the House please welcome them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Degenerative diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036502","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize two devoted parents, dentists Dr. Stalingit Gill and Dr.\n               Navpreet Gill, and their incredible team standing with them in support of their son\n               Gurmoh Gill. Gurmoh is here, along with their other child, as well. They have walked all the way from Vancouver to the Legislature, step by step, to raise\n               awareness and support for their s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","label":"Degenerative diseases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Degenerative diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","label":"Degenerative diseases","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3d76b499b90e21e95a80f6d78ce67d94aed79a31b2d293b8d22079fc395f0222","12ed0c72c75cf17ec746620c2192360df2685088d595d978aa1924933e583669"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Degenerative diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["113c5e4d3f60fdee9d2545d03a4fd0151b3fbe5023a025a3886787291cde5dfc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Degenerative diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721684","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20edfff01d2d957314f6d24f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036503,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Steve Kooner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Do you want to know how bad it is right now? No wonder the government didn't tell\n               us what cases are being amended by the Gitxaała decision. It's because it's embarrassing. Yesterday the Premier had a fleeting moment of transparency when he admitted that\n               this government's enhanced care no-fault is under threat under DRIPA. ICBC. Are you kidding me? To the Attorney General: what other Crown corporations have now ended up in court\n               because of DRIPA?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036503","member_id":"bc-mla-395","member_name":"Steve Kooner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Do you want to know how bad it is right now? No wonder the government didn't tell\n               us what cases are being amended by the Gitxaała decision. It's because it's embarrassing. Yesterday the Premier had a fleeting moment of transparency when he admitted that\n               this government's enhanced care no-fault is under threat under DRIPA. ICBC. Are you kidding me? To the Attorney Gene","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b45c35105dc1dd6d7a363ff2bc57e4385c1ce040e19a7bbeb876c8fb35ecffc6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.45,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["77abc20a6abcd3a86140d7bea5ced08f50a66398cfc00dcc9e84edbc9e0842b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2bfe08230c8c2bf99cb79a1f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316800,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316800","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c426acdc50664f3bf04a80dafad6de898f97259666894da0e56279b42641aff3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaf9bc93fd835bcfb1b4b419","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316801,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the House with us today are Pamela Wright and Joyce Budnick from the Pender Island\n               Food Bank. The Pender Island Food Bank Society is a B.C. society and federal charity\n               that provides food for Penderites experiencing food insecurity. They currently support 176 individuals, 32 of whom are children, who can visit the\n               food bank weekly to shop for non-perishables, dairy, meat and many other foodstuffs.\n               They also provide deliveries to homebound seniors as a distributor for B.C. farmers\n               market coupons. At Christmas, they provide gifts for children in need. Last year,\n               they had roughly 3,000 visits, a 34 percent increase from 2024. The food bank has\n               23 very active volunteers. More than two-thirds of the revenue comes from donations\n               from individual Penderites. Less than 1 percent of their funds come from a government\n               grant. May the House please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316801","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"In the House with us today are Pamela Wright and Joyce Budnick from the Pender Island\n               Food Bank. The Pender Island Food Bank Society is a B.C. society and federal charity\n               that provides food for Penderites experiencing food insecurity. They currently support 176 individuals, 32 of whom are children, who can visit the\n               food bank weekly to shop for non-peri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d82fe1f3cb9e8c9cfd8a37a2161b6888a1b249b7ac2e3003adea50fc90d61eff","fd00fa698746fbeb10a7f49d23337bfb80a5f4158aafd914f238eb8026793eab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1226ebb19a4025c4c496ba526d3275f117848145fd0df20e115f1bc5808b551b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b5eac445054de22f28aba89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316802,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"In 2023, this government announced $1 billion in federal and provincial funding to\n               conserve nature. Through tools like conservation financing, the government promised\n               to ease the transition of local economies away from old-growth harvesting while respecting\n               the sovereignty of First Nations. We know old-growth forests are worth more standing. Independent analysis shows if\n               we fully protect old growth in the Okanagan and Prince George areas, over the next\n               100 years we add $43 billion more than if we cut the old growth down. But talk and log is alive and well in B.C., and it has nothing to do with Trump. It\n               has nothing to do with trade wars or budget cuts. My question to the Minister of Forests: is this government going to take any action\n               to protect more old growth My question to the Minister of Forests, is this government going to take any action\n               to protect more old growth or will we keep cutting until big lonely Doug is the only\n               ancient tree in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316802","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"In 2023, this government announced $1 billion in federal and provincial funding to\n               conserve nature. Through tools like conservation financing, the government promised\n               to ease the transition of local economies away from old-growth harvesting while respecting\n               the sovereignty of First Nations. We know old-growth forests are worth more standing. Independent","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d3a69b583f7d518175b7fd39b0b20031d42cd2189dc36f19a492b5b0359149d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0131f1578233d8e0b301f89f10ee4aa10b1f0edb7e382407e18734fa3c46fba7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-184fe9e5b9e25dbd1f13393d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316803,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is with affection and sadness that I rise to wish farewell to our B.C. Green caucus\n               team member, G ud Takin Jaad, Rose Williams. Rose joined the caucus as a legislative intern and, thankfully, never left. As our\n               social justice policy advisor, Rose has been a constant voice for those who are too\n               often forgotten or overlooked. They have stood up for people across this province,\n               and we are all the better for their work. Rose is our resident baker and always made sure that we are well fed. We are privileged\n               to have been part of Rose's journey that is now taking her home to work for the Haida\n               Nation. Our loss is their gain. Thank you for everything, G ud Takin Jaad.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316803","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is with affection and sadness that I rise to wish farewell to our B.C. Green caucus\n               team member, G ud Takin Jaad, Rose Williams. Rose joined the caucus as a legislative intern and, thankfully, never left. As our\n               social justice policy advisor, Rose has been a constant voice for those who are too\n               often forgotten or overlooked. They have stood up for pe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6db2086e10a1a472e34fd8054e4700e267a7829354a030006b61e82994b5dd31"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-289332d16a91be3a9ff186a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327919,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my honour this morning to welcome representatives from three affordable housing\n               organizations from my riding, the Gulf Island Seniors Residents Association, the Mayne\n               Island Housing Society's Salish Grove project, and the Galiano Affordable Living Initiative\n               Society. These organizations have for years worked to bring affordable housing units to their\n               communities, and we are relying on the now-paused community housing fund to bring\n               more units to the low-income households in their communities. Will the House join me in making them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327919","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's my honour this morning to welcome representatives from three affordable housing\n               organizations from my riding, the Gulf Island Seniors Residents Association, the Mayne\n               Island Housing Society's Salish Grove project, and the Galiano Affordable Living Initiative\n               Society. These organizations have for years worked to bring affordable housing units to the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77f942a367f201d85a2a13481a70e345753fd4d896f0f4d82a37746fb7869380","bb23782f0167ad2f9bedc3366eb3ddc362744ba111153e9336ff75c6162ae2f7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc8182d422bdf88ece77ffb64c1c4a86886fbfbc1003183fca7366e8779a4d24"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-09aea7546ba0f9f8d2675fc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327920,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"And many more, Mr. Speaker. It's my pleasure to welcome Julie Luna, Theresa Coles and Deborah Bowman, my constituency\n               team, to the Legislature. They're visiting the Legislature for an all-day training\n               session with an amazing client care team we have, and are attending QP to watch us\n               in action. Please, may the House join me in making them welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327920","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"And many more, Mr. Speaker. It's my pleasure to welcome Julie Luna, Theresa Coles and Deborah Bowman, my constituency\n               team, to the Legislature. They're visiting the Legislature for an all-day training\n               session with an amazing client care team we have, and are attending QP to watch us\n               in action. Please, may the House join me in making them welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034716","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crafts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034716","label":"Crafts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e43c7ed26562bffde0d6c8476663285543185e0ee7062fd2e4a93d3e38d90804"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec3ec930576343e3f14f69b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327921,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"In North America, we are very good at taking simple solutions and making them very\n               complicated. Balcony solar is one such simple idea. Standard solar panels are easy to mount on apartments and condo balconies. The good\n               news is that the CSA has approved hard-wired, professionally installed, balcony-mounted\n               solar panels. The cost of everything is going up. Groceries, child care, transit. Bills keep getting\n               higher for all of us, but balcony solar makes electricity bills go down. The estimated\n               payback time with a rebate for balcony solar would be about nine years. Balcony solar is accessible to renters, not just homeowners, allowing for more equitable\n               distribution of rebates across our province. The dollars used in a single-family home\n               solar rebate would allow six households to gain access to balcony-mounted solar. Gives us energy independence from volatile fossil fuel markets and foreign corporation.\n               And it's clean energy, turning sunlight into money and power. Germany has seen the light. After Russia's war with Ukraine destabilized energy resources,\n               at least 1.5 million homes have registered as [German was spoken] \"balcony powerplants.\" Balcony solar is rapidly expanding in Japan, South Korea, Netherlands and France,\n               and more European countries are moving to adopt it in 2026. More than half of U.S. states. Republican and Democratic lawmakers have introduced\n               legislation that would boost adoption of do-it-yourself solar systems. British Columbia should be next and lead the move to balcony solar in Canada. I'm\n               very excited to be working with Salt Spring Island–based Skyblue products and the Minister of Energy and Climate Solutions to make this happen in 2026. This\n               is an exciting opportunity to move hundreds of Asian-based manufacturing jobs to B.C.\n               — green industrial development. Let's bring B.C. out of the dark ages and enjoy solar-powered freedom.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327921","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In North America, we are very good at taking simple solutions and making them very\n               complicated. Balcony solar is one such simple idea. Standard solar panels are easy to mount on apartments and condo balconies. The good\n               news is that the CSA has approved hard-wired, professionally installed, balcony-mounted\n               solar panels. The cost of everything is going up","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","label":"Solar energy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marine conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036195","label":"Marine conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","label":"Solar energy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["777bb85f2747e0cde2dfb678ecce00360939007b893787b289d8a77a482a74db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["927c4e28abe76986652d309ca402cfba35bf51e3bc7e7240560a605ed4d0ad72"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d39b7bec12a9ac2cbee19a67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359636,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am shocked by the inflammatory direction and nature of the Conservative opposition\n               questions this morning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359636","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am shocked by the inflammatory direction and nature of the Conservative opposition\n               questions this morning.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ea8ae1024b042636c8935ce7e2f9d996c65ee4f55fb05d56889a0f21c21f912"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1dd49c3e696673faab7ee1ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359637,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today are several members of the Saanich Peninsula Outreach Team, SPOT,\n               and other community members who are very familiar with and support the extraordinary\n               work that SPOT does providing health care for people living on the Saanich Peninsula\n               who do not have a family doctor. They are joined by church leaders from across my riding who work tirelessly to provide\n               food and shelter to the unhoused populations in Saanich North and the Islands and\n               also to support SPOT. Will the House join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359637","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the gallery today are several members of the Saanich Peninsula Outreach Team, SPOT,\n               and other community members who are very familiar with and support the extraordinary\n               work that SPOT does providing health care for people living on the Saanich Peninsula\n               who do not have a family doctor. They are joined by church leaders from across my riding who work ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Isolated communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035997","label":"Isolated communities","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c0de7d1b1ae9fa18c2f77eac9793ed236ccbebd51213bed02018debdb902400","ed9d323b158f52276eadc42d02e79baaab54da01f7ca8029ec3b7b27aa8c85c9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72eddeadcf4da6f0b898220b4c5ebbbc16ffe454d252d2f32882e5c8a16cd9d9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df5225f6d9eae1919f2e262e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359638,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin my remarks, I just want to note on the record that I have no intention\n               of responding to the statements made by the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream. I don't want to grace them with a reply, because they do not deserve a reply in\n               any way, shape or form. Instead, I wish to rise in support of the motion, from the Government House Leader,\n               \"that this House affirms its unequivocal support for the B.C. Human Rights Code and\n               the Tribunal's powers to enforce it, protecting people from hate speech and discrimination\n               based on Indigenous identity, race, colour, ancestry, place of origin, religion, marital\n               status, family status, physical or mental disability, sex, sexual orientation, gender\n               identity or expression\" — yes, gender identity or expression — \"and age.\" I just want to thank all the previous speakers who have risen to speak in support\n               of this motion and to draw on their lived experience to remind us how incredibly important\n               the human rights code of B.C. is. I'd like to start by thanking the Pride organizations from across British Columbia\n               who stepped forward to register the need for all members of this House to do more\n               to uphold human rights in British Columbia. My thanks to the Pride societies of Langley,\n               Kelowna, Chilliwack, Vancouver, Delta, Prince George, Fernie, North Island, Nelson,\n               Sunshine Coast, Nanaimo, Vernon and Cranbrook, the Northern Pride Advocacy Group,\n               Queer Centre Comox Valley, Northern Pride Centre and the UVic Pride Collective for\n               your powerful and important advocacy. We must always support those organizations in the community who work so hard to bring\n               forward their views and help us and support us to advocate for the protection of their\n               rights and their members' rights through the B.C. human rights code. I'd also like to thank the Government House Leader. Also the Attorney General for\n               her remarks. The House Leader in particular for bringing this motion forward, and\n               the Parliamentary Secretary for Gender Equity for her thoughtful written response\n               to these Pride organizations. The hate-fuelled actions of a member of this House have brought us all into disrepute.\n               Our democracy and this House should be a place that all British Columbians can look\n               to proudly, knowing that the people there are working for them and their best interests.\n               Instead, the public is witnessing racism, sexism, ignorance and disinformation from\n               this building. We must be better than this. As hate and fascism find traction around the world, we\n               cannot stand idly by. All of us — and that's what we are doing today — must recommit\n               ourselves to an active defence of human rights. We must stand up for all members of\n               our society, particularly those who continue to face marginalization and hate simply\n               for existing as they are in this world. This is no time for precedence to be more important than human rights. We must also\n               go further than words. Words are important, but we need to go further than words.\n               We need to take concrete action to improve the human rights situation in British Columbia. None of us can stand here and congratulate ourselves or consider it a job done while\n               we represent a province with incredible human rights failures. It's up to all of us\n               on all sides of the House to work together in unity to take the actions that bring\n               meaning to these words. I'd like to put on the record some of the types of areas that we need to work together\n               to focus on. Housing is a human right, yet British Columbia has the highest rate of unaffordable\n               housing in Canada. For people on social assistance, the provincial shelter allowance\n               rate is only around one-third of the median rental price. I am not making these comments to assign responsibility. I am making these comments\n               today so we can develop a shared vision and a shared effort as a unified House to\n               address these issues. In 2022, 342 people experiencing homelessness died due to violence, lack of nutrition,\n               sanitation or housing. And 40 percent of people experiencing homelessness are Indigenous,\n               11.3 percent are 2SLGBTQIA+, 3.2 percent are transgender. These are vastly disproportionate and a shame on all of us. The life expectancy of First Nations people in this province is 7.3 years shorter\n               than that for non–First Nations British Columbians. The life expectancy of First Nations people in this province is 7.3 years shorter\n               than that for non-First Nations British Columbians. Some 44 percent of women in Canada\n               have experienced some form of intimate partner abuse, whether physical, sexual, psychological\n               or emotional. For young women without homes, 63 percent have been assaulted and 37\n               percent sexually assaulted. And 16.7 percent of children in British Columbia live\n               in poverty. This is a shocking figure, and it rises to 34.8 percent for First Nations\n               children and 42.2 percent on rural reserves. Children with disabilities face numerous barriers to their full participation in education,\n               and nearly 18 percent of parents have indicated that their disabled child was secluded\n               or restrained at school. And 62 percent of 2SLGBTQI+ students across Canada report\n               feeling unsafe at school due to exclusion, harassment, intimidation and violence. The rate of death from the toxic drug crisis is six times higher for First Nations\n               people than other British Columbians and 12 times higher for First Nations women compared\n               with non-First Nations women. There were 43 incidents of human trafficking reported\n               to police in 2023, a figure that is grossly underreported. These are sobering, sobering facts, and they just remind us how important the human\n               rights code is as a guide for the work we have to do, the work we can do together\n               to change the lives of these people. This is not the time to weaken the human rights\n               code or the Human Rights Commissioner. It is a time today to reaffirm our strong support\n               for the human rights code and the Human Rights Commissioner. If anything, we need\n               to make them stronger. It is embarrassing that this House even needs to put this statement up for debate.\n               But here we are, and we all know how we got here, and today is an important opportunity\n               for us to reaffirm that support for the human rights code and turn the page on the\n               hate and the things we've experienced over the last few months and move forward together\n               to address these many challenges I've outlined. I urge all members of the House to support this motion. I urge them to go further\n               than this too, to work together across party lines to take meaningful action in support\n               of a province where all people's human rights are upheld every day of the year.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359638","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Before I begin my remarks, I just want to note on the record that I have no intention\n               of responding to the statements made by the member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream. I don't want to grace them with a reply, because they do not deserve a reply in\n               any way, shape or form. Instead, I wish to rise in support of the motion, from the Government House Leader,\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dbca196d622cfe2f895dae271803c64982a151977235f9b25d72534ddf53b6b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab0a5a0de3ccbbacfe2d6f2ccc742038c805266480aeedc97e4a07f3aa3d3635"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76fdc7835757feb3b14c38bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413662,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome the University of Victoria Green club who are visiting the\n               Legislature today to experience question period as future leaders of our province.\n               Their commitment to sustainability and civic engagement is exactly the kind of leadership\n               we need in B.C. May the House please help me make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413662","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome the University of Victoria Green club who are visiting the\n               Legislature today to experience question period as future leaders of our province.\n               Their commitment to sustainability and civic engagement is exactly the kind of leadership\n               we need in B.C. May the House please help me make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0980be8715609bd911ea9803198425b083861e6e4c3ddfd290e1aef69f166093"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b292bcc02893eb1236cbe999","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413663,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll be the designated speaker, although I don't expect to take the full time. I rise today to speak to Bill 11, legislation that seeks to amend the Residential\n               Tenancy Act by expanding landlord powers and government regulatory flexibility, giving\n               broad jurisdiction to modify tenancy agreements, seize property, restrict access to\n               housing and determine and intervene on \"weapons\" use. I put \"weapons\" in quotes for\n               reasons that will become apparent further along in my speech. Recognizing that the ministry's approach to the prioritization of housing safety guides\n               the development of Bill 11, we appreciate and understand the bill as a response to\n               concerns from members of the supportive housing sector about limited tools to address\n               violence against people and property. That being said, this bill holds potential to give broad discretionary powers over\n               and against populations that are already heavily regulated and policed. It reads as\n               a desperate and shortsighted response to the impacts of the housing crisis on front-line\n               workers at the expense of tenant rights and dignity. In this way, we understand this legislation as one that puts workplace safety up against\n               tenants' rights. This contributes to a cycle in which individuals are pitted against\n               each other, distracting us from the reality that both workers and tenants are experiencing\n               harm at the hands of increased housing and living costs, worsened mental health supports,\n               an ongoing toxic drug crisis and ever-deepening, overlapping inequities. In essence,\n               the government has selected one part of a systemic problem that has many elements. The central concern we have with this legislation rests in its capacity to claw back\n               tenant rights. These include section 14(2) of the Residential Tenancy Act, which clearly\n               states that amendment to a tenancy can only happen if both the landlord and tenant\n               agree. However, under clause 7, section 14.1, this legislation gives the government\n               regulatory power to make exceptions to this right, thereby making it more likely that\n               tenants will experience eviction and housing instability even in the midst of their\n               term. So we're sacrificing the rights of tenants in this way. Further, this legislation would allow landlords to make an application to the director\n               to restrict access to the residence without notice to any other party. This is a fundamental\n               departure from precepts of procedural fairness that others in society expect to be\n               respected and expect to have the protection of. Further still, clause 16 provides the ability to end a tenancy earlier if the landlord\n               convinces the director that a tenant is \"likely\" to adversely affect the quiet enjoyment\n               of another person who is authorized to be on the property. We wonder, in reviewing\n               this, how this is possible, considering that previous amendments to the Residential\n               Tenancy Act excluded supportive housing residents from the right to quiet enjoyment\n               in the first place. Further, this framing makes way for bias, discrimination and racism, considering that\n               a large number of supportive housing residents are Indigenous and racialized, and\n               leads us to wonder why tenants are to be punished when they haven't done anything\n               wrong. In regard to weapons, this legislation provides that a landlord can request an order\n               to end a tenancy if the tenant has been in personal possession of a weapon on residential\n               property or if the landlord has observed a weapon in plain view in the tenant's rental\n               unit. Considering that the definition of \"weapon\" is prescribed and that tenants would\n               risk eviction if the landlord observes a weapon, the power given to landlords and\n               housing operators to control tenants here is unbelievable, simply huge overreach. How many of us have objects in our house that have the potential to do any of these\n               things? Kitchen items, knives, scissors, forks, bottles, cleaning supplies, bleach,\n               mop and broom handles, things that can be thrown, cell phones, lamps, vases, things\n               that can be used as rope, clothes, cords, Christmas lights, pets if they have the\n               capacity to cause harm — for example, some dogs — sports equipment, bats, walking\n               or skiing poles, ice skates. The list goes on and on. We don't have the comfort in this legislation, the clarity, of how this is going to\n               be limited and how procedural safeguards will be in place to eliminate the very real\n               risk that a landlord could observe a weapon and it could result in these far-reaching\n               consequences for the tenant. Danielle Sabelli, a lawyer at the Community Legal Assistance Society, is quoted on\n               this proposed legislation: \"This isn't safety; it's control and surveillance. When\n               you give housing providers the power to exclude someone from their home and the power\n               to enter their unit with fewer safeguards, you create the conditions for abuse. You\n               create a pipeline to homelessness.\" This quote brings our attention to a gaping hole\n               in the government's approach to this legislation, that of attending to the issues\n               that make tenants vulnerable in the first place. Let me just stop here. Can you imagine anybody in this chamber, anybody viewing this\n               speech and viewing this on Hansard , being subjected to this type of arbitrary, subjective power by another individual\n               without safeguards? This is really, really concerning. And here we go again. What\n               we're doing is we're giving a degree of power in a relationship that is already asymmetrical\n               to the landlord and not building in the safeguards. Indeed, this piece of legislation does nothing — and beyond this, the weapons issue\n               and other issues I've mentioned — to attend to the current conditions that lead to\n               increased risk of violence, harm and eviction. An example of this includes consistent issues with elevator function, including one\n               at the Portland Hotel in Vancouver that had broken down for nine months, leading to\n               multiple residents, especially ones who use wheelchairs, being unable to leave their\n               floors for weeks and months at a time. To be clear, this means that residents were disconnected from community, unable to\n               access medications, even get groceries. Others were forced to actually crawl up and\n               down the stairs, sleep in the lobby. They were left to use the courtyard in the back\n               of the building to relieve themselves since there is no accessible washroom on the\n               ground floor. This is completely unacceptable. This is British Columbia. This is a wealthy province. This is a province that has\n               protected and aims to protect rights of the most vulnerable This is British Columbia. This is a wealthy province. This is a province that has\n               protected and aims to protect rights of the most vulnerable, and here we have legislation\n               that goes in exactly the opposite direction. Giving more powers to survey police and expel tenants does nothing to increase safety,\n               despite this government's claim through their introduction of this bill. To the contrary,\n               risk of violence and a vulnerability to harm are not inherent to individuals. They\n               are instead drafted into the systems we create, the same systems we have the power\n               to change. We ask whether this government is in fact interested in increasing safety, or simply\n               in solidifying a system that hurts supportive housing workers and tenants alike. And\n               that is the issue. This is going to impact in a very negative way both workers and\n               tenants alike. Once a person is denied access to their possessions, to their home, once they no longer\n               have a home, where do they go? How might they access support in actions taken against\n               them? We know that the people targeted in this legislation are already more likely\n               to experience poverty, addiction and barriers to service. What happens when another\n               stabilizing force, sometimes the only stabilizing force, is taken from them? And I know from personal experience, working for 25 years with First Nations across\n               this province, sitting on a housing panel to ensure that housing is made available.\n               Housing that is safe and accessible is at the very core of the wraparound support\n               that's needed to support the most vulnerable in our society. And it's not a question\n               of taking this type of measure. It's a question of building the supports so that there's\n               not even a thought that this type of measure is needed. So what guarantee can the NDP make that those evicted won't become homeless? That's\n               the question. What guarantee can the NDP make that those evicted won't become homeless?\n               A common answer to brush this question under the rug is that these people will have\n               to \"connect to other resources,\" but the reality is that resourcing is not only scarce\n               in housing. Our health care system is overburdened. Legal services are usually either\n               far too expensive or stretched thin. And addiction and mental health services are\n               under ever-increasing pressure. In short, other support services are at capacity. The answer of \"connecting people to other resources\" sidelines the reality that the\n               government are, at best, not equipped to deal with the fallout of ruining the lives\n               of people who have no recourse. B.C. cannot afford this. And when we don't deal with\n               the fallout, this is often the last step and it sets back the life chances, the safety,\n               the mental and physical health of the very tenants that we're trying to support to\n               move to a life that is much better than the circumstances that they've experienced.\n               It's just a mechanism to turn the clock back and undo the progress that's been made\n               without those additional services. And we have no evidence that this legislation is accompanied by increased services\n               to ensure that anyone evicted does not end up homeless, that it's seen as a way to\n               keep working at supporting these tenants and these individuals. While the government claims that they have engaged with multiple external parties\n               in developing this legislation, the lack of transparency about who these partners\n               represent, and the feedback we have received about this bill from those in community,\n               those with lived experience raises While the government claims that they have engaged with multiple external parties\n               in developing this legislation, the lack of transparency about who these partners\n               represent, and the feedback we have received about this bill from those in community,\n               those with lived experience, raises concerns about whose voices and experiences are\n               at the centre of this process. As a bill that holds such tremendous impact for tenants, we wonder what consultation\n               exists with those who have lived experience of living in social and supportive housing\n               and being evicted. In my riding, we have supportive housing, and there is an obligation\n               on the government, when it takes this sort of approach and proposes this sort of legislation,\n               to do extensive consultation, not just with those who are advocating for the change,\n               but those that are going to experience the impact of the change. This research need not be started from scratch, as those with lived experience have\n               been offering insight and solutions for decades. As we spend time debating whether\n               or not to make it easier for people to be homeless, and that is what this legislation\n               does, solutions such as those proposed by SUDU could be taken up and applied to the\n               roots of the issues we are facing. These include consulting people with lived and living experience of unregulated substance\n               use, and supportive housing residents, to inform policy developments in supportive\n               housing; fairly compensating training and resourcing positions in social and supportive\n               housing to prevent burnout and maintain working conditions; creating authentic peer-led\n               support, operational and emotional first aid and de-escalation roles for housing residents\n               and more. This type of step of eviction should be the very last resort. In the world of law, there's an expression: best efforts. What that means is no stone\n               unturned. There is absolutely no stone unturned in trying to find alternative solutions\n               to the ones presented and enabled in this legislation. These solutions are publicly\n               available. As SUDU board director Gina Egilson shares: \"It is abhorrent that the Minister of\n               Housing has established a task force to dismantle what scant rights still exist for\n               supportive housing residents. If the upstream solutions to the intersectional crises\n               of housing and toxic drug supply were adequately addressed through meaningful consultation\n               with residents, this incredibly harmful, punitive policy response would be unnecessary.\" Punitive. That's the fundamental way to describe this legislation in one word. Punitive.\n               Making it easier for landlords to evict tenants, prohibit their movement, seize their\n               property, does not make social housing sustainability safer. It's a band-aid on the\n               multiple gaping wounds left by a lack of resourcing for both tenants and staff. We\n               don't need a band-aid. We actually need to deal with the core causes and ensure that\n               we are making best efforts to find every other conceivable solution than this heavy-handed\n               type of legislative eviction response. With the emphasis of governmental powers in this bill protections for tenants will\n               come in through regulation, of course. That's standard practice for this government.\n               When in doubt, don't spend the time to lay out in detail the criteria that will guide\n               decisions that have huge impacts on British Columbians in this province. No, put it\n               in regulation. We'll put it in regulation. We'll figure it out later. Then we'll send it off to cabinet.\n               Then cabinet, meeting behind closed doors, subject to very broad exemptions from disclosure,\n               will decide what the regulation will do, will pass the regulation, and then, for those\n               of us who enjoy looking at the Gazette and spending hours It's a fait accompli — the regulation. The decision's made. That's not reassuring.\n               We're supposed to just believe the minister that this will occur in a thoughtful,\n               considered way, with full consultation and despite the fact we won't see, beforehand,\n               the criteria. We won't have an opportunity to debate the issues, the contents, because\n               it's all prescribed. That's the path forward that this government is taking in so many pieces of legislation,\n               and it fundamentally sidelines the role of this Legislature. It is completely disrespectful\n               of the public in this province, who deserve a right to have the opportunity to participate\n               in consultation — on either side, whether you're a landlord, a tenant or somebody\n               potentially impacted, like workers. That is the issue there. Why is the removal of rights enshrined in legislation and\n               protections tacked on with regulation? Let me repeat that. The removal of rights is enshrined in the legislation. And the\n               protections? They're in regulation. We're being asked to support a bill, and we don't\n               even know what some of the key criteria are that will guide this. I acknowledge that in limited circumstances, doing work by regulation is a completely\n               acceptable approach. But for things that are as fundamental as the items that are\n               left to regulation in this bill, it is deeply concerning that we are taking this approach. What would we do in first? The Green caucus, my colleague Jeremy Valeriote and I,\n               we're not about simply....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413663","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'll be the designated speaker, although I don't expect to take the full time. I rise today to speak to Bill 11, legislation that seeks to amend the Residential\n               Tenancy Act by expanding landlord powers and government regulatory flexibility, giving\n               broad jurisdiction to modify tenancy agreements, seize property, restrict access to\n               housing and determine a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ed552ac72d634689e55205001aa8c6a290f22f2bef231e93111723efbd142e3f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3f2add160737dd7a6b56fc3b6e64d481c558e556ccd80251ffbf71dea609dd0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b209fe9962f9736772f408b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413664,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I hope the House will indulge me. This is an extraordinarily special day for me. It's my daughter's birthday. She's a captain in the Coast Guard and she wouldn't want\n               me mentioning her age, but she's in her mid-30s. So will the House please wish her a merry.... Oh no, a happy birthday, not a merry Christmas.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413664","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I hope the House will indulge me. This is an extraordinarily special day for me. It's my daughter's birthday. She's a captain in the Coast Guard and she wouldn't want\n               me mentioning her age, but she's in her mid-30s. So will the House please wish her a merry.... Oh no, a happy birthday, not a merry Christmas.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Transgender people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035073","label":"Resources conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037409","label":"Transgender people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3cf83b5061cb2038bfacc55de12a830ecd60370f2f0a8006a48a0cb1b886de4","c16f07d6ab4e47e7840bb23d4b86e1fdcdf4b3fa29c14e589be5aaa39fb461e7","6aba881447976dd117dc55436d712d6984745f7457a5508b876bb840af0e3f58"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-74ef32155fdd046e344f06b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720139,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"The political moment has changed. Even the Prime Minister acknowledged that in Davos.\n               So will this government meet the moment with real action? The government committed to strengthening our democracy, including supporting the\n               work of the Special Committee on Democratic and Electoral Reform. This all-party committee\n               didn't just study the issue. I had the honour of being on that committee. It made\n               a clear recommendation: a citizens assembly to give British Columbians a direct say\n               on proportional representation. Even the federal NDP's new leader, Avi Lewis, said\n               he supports electoral reform. Will the Premier and his caucus respect the clear recommendation of the all-party\n               committee and take the next step toward a better electoral system for British Columbians\n               by striking a peoples assembly on electoral reform?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720139","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The political moment has changed. Even the Prime Minister acknowledged that in Davos.\n               So will this government meet the moment with real action? The government committed to strengthening our democracy, including supporting the\n               work of the Special Committee on Democratic and Electoral Reform. This all-party committee\n               didn't just study the issue. I had the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aa7ecc2c08acd01aeed8c113a4b5b56b88ba75dc422893d3d92199ed70c4bde1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["15dd244feeee819069c724503a7d26fa16c1fd841b31c3021dec9fd6358a6508"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-255fd26c3ec0199574005f28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720144,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is with excitement and gratitude that I speak to the introduction of the K'ómoks Treaty Act today. As we've heard, beginning in 1994, this collaborative endeavour\n               has involved over 30 years of engagement with government and the public alike. As\n               a living agreement built in partnership and good faith, this treaty represents one\n               of the highest forms of reconciliation between Indigenous nations and the Crown. This\n               agreement offers a guiding light by which we can all move forward in a good way. Thank\n               you. Thank you to all who put their time, heart and expertise into this treaty. In my years\n               as a lawyer involved in negotiations, including treaty negotiations at the Tsawwassen\n               and Minette tables, I have borne witness to the incredible hard work of nations when\n               building a bright future. It is not lost on the B.C. Greens or any of us that treaties\n               require an incredible amount of trust, labour and faith. It is with that trust, labour and faith in our hearts and minds that we move into\n               a future built on growth, self-determination and mutual respect. I hold my hands up to the K'ómoks Nation today. Heartfelt congratulations to Chief\n               Councillor Rempel, Hereditary Chiefs, the Elders, everyone, the K'ómoks People. This\n               is a very special day, and I want to offer you all of our congratulations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720144","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is with excitement and gratitude that I speak to the introduction of the K'ómoks Treaty Act today. As we've heard, beginning in 1994, this collaborative endeavour\n               has involved over 30 years of engagement with government and the public alike. As\n               a living agreement built in partnership and good faith, this treaty represents one\n               of the highest forms of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["84e863654c1f0640077ead4daf3c65be012bce0b59de206fcfd7943c43635add"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dad0f9148ce660db512415dd05384e179d566baf5ddd213562ae67c9367442cd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5ac9c0105986e4ed211f0a87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720148,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues, honoured guests. It is a true honour to bear witness\n               as the Kitselas Treaty Act is introduced in this House. Today is a proud day for this province. With this modern treaty, we are choosing collaboration\n               over conflict. We are addressing the past wrongs of the Crown, establishing a new\n               living agreement that will bring prosperity and a brighter future to everyone who\n               lives on these lands and for everyone throughout the region. As we've heard, work on the Kitselas treaty began in 1993. It has taken over 30 years of careful work, public consultation\n               and respectful conversation to bring us to this historic day. I offer my gratitude\n               and congratulations to all those who have dedicated their lives to this process. I won't by any means be able to name everyone, but I'd particularly like to recognize\n               Deputy Chief Councillor Cyril Bennett-Nabess, the B.C. and Kitselas treaty teams, the B.C. Treaty Commission and everyone in the Kitselas community who has supported this process over many years. I have borne witness to the incredible hard work of nations and treaty teams. I have borne witness to the incredible hard work of nations and treaty teams when\n               building a bright future for your people, so I want to congratulate you all on reaching\n               this milestone. This work, though, takes us away — all of us, when we do this treaty work, when you\n               do this treaty work — for days on end from our families, our partners, our children,\n               our loved ones, everyone who are the most important people our lives. I want to especially\n               thank them for supporting Kitselas and the teams that worked in this so hard so this\n               can be done through all those years. Treaties are a path forward. With these modern treaties, we're establishing a new\n               process for structured decision-making, consent, cooperation and a bright future.\n               We're showing the world what good neighbours can be and what good neighbours can accomplish. To the people of the canyon, congratulations. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720148","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, colleagues, honoured guests. It is a true honour to bear witness\n               as the Kitselas Treaty Act is introduced in this House. Today is a proud day for this province. With this modern treaty, we are choosing collaboration\n               over conflict. We are addressing the past wrongs of the Crown, establishing a new\n               living agreement that will bring ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f737f620582074494aa4fc43dc4948a8f532a7d008856cad6604ff8b8a010f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["894b02142db87306a8d4dde5870117f9fbe31dd5f9baecb8908f527a5674db06"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7016153624c7af6140def9ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720150,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Why is soccer the most popular sport in the world? One reason is that it doesn't cost\n               very much to play. You can make a ball by wrapping plastic bags in twine, set up goalposts\n               with a few well-placed stones. But if the sport of soccer is accessible and inclusive,\n               the FIFA World Cup is the polar opposite. Vancouver's seven matches are likely to\n               cost taxpayers $624 million. FIFA is charging as much as $11,000 for tickets to the\n               final. It's $1,000 a night for a hotel room. While soccer is a sport for everyone, the 2026 men's World Cup is only for a select\n               few. But Vancouverites are great hosts, and everyone is accommodating FIFA. Hospitals\n               are calling in extra staff and may postpone elective surgeries. Health authorities\n               are rolling out awareness campaigns about our toxic drugs. The Vancouver law courts are shutting down. Residents of the Downtown Eastside will\n               give up beds to host FIFA. The largest Dragon Boat Festival in North America is cancelled.\n               Businesses around B.C. Place will cover up signs and TVs. Air traffic controllers will be working overtime. Sex workers will navigate increased\n               surveillance in unsafe workplaces. All this to celebrate an organization with a horrific\n               record of fraud and human rights abuses, an organization, I may add, that recently\n               gave a peace prize to a man who just started a war with Iran. It's so important that we make space to gather, that we pause to have fun, build connections,\n               meet our neighbours. We should keep investing in community events where art, culture\n               and sport bring people together. Soccer is one way to do that, but the FIFA World\n               Cup is not.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720150","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Why is soccer the most popular sport in the world? One reason is that it doesn't cost\n               very much to play. You can make a ball by wrapping plastic bags in twine, set up goalposts\n               with a few well-placed stones. But if the sport of soccer is accessible and inclusive,\n               the FIFA World Cup is the polar opposite. Vancouver's seven matches are likely to\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ffe1411900a12ae562746a7cdaad864316d22102042ede4f63a4c906c30b0d1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66e62321abfde4a937abd654541b0fa4c8c3d3339b01879401ab4677e17478f0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-183a2cf0cbc22b9068d883be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720157,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to speak to the parts of this bill related to Attorney General information\n               and amendments. As someone who has practiced law in this province for over 25 years, I understand\n               and fully appreciate the importance of judicial review in our system of government.\n               Judicial review is a core way that courts ensure that decisions made by government\n               — and others, of course — are lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair and basically\n               ensuring that the government is following the law. For this to work properly, the court needs access to information to understand how\n               and why decisions were made. The court relies on the parties to a particular piece\n               of litigation or judicial review to ensure that's the case. The way in which the parties\n               do that is to seek production of documents. This bill proposes to allow a minister, the cabinet secretary or the deputy cabinet\n               secretary to certify in writing that information is part of a cabinet confidence and\n               then, through that measure, be able to withhold that information from judicial review.\n               The bill also extends similar treatment to information related to certain Treasury\n               Board functions. The protection of cabinet confidences itself is not new, and it has been applied to\n               both cabinet and Treasury Board to allow open deliberations on core government decisions.\n               Ministers need space for frank, candid deliberations, but that principle has always\n               had to exist alongside meaningful judicial oversight when government decisions are\n               challenged in court. This legislation states that a minister, the cabinet secretary or the deputy cabinet\n               secretary may certify in writing that information is a confidence of the executive\n               council or any of its committees. There is no apparent limitation on this clause governing\n               what types of information may be certified as being part of confidence and, therefore,\n               not subject to judicial review. This is very broad and can open up all sorts of information to being removed from\n               judicial review with very little oversight. I draw your attention to the fact that\n               this power is being exercised by a minister, the cabinet secretary or the deputy cabinet\n               secretary. Those positions within the ambit of the provincial government are potentially,\n               directly or indirectly, part of the parties that are defending a judicial review. For the record, I'm not suggesting in any way, shape or form any lack of good faith\n               on the part of those certifying the documents. But in our time and age, where openness\n               and transparency is the cure for growing distrust in government, we must take steps\n               to craft any exceptions or approaches like this as narrowly as possible. My concern is not with legitimate cabinet confidentiality, but this bill shifts powers\n               away from the courts and the important role of our judiciary in making decisions around\n               disclosure of documents and towards the executive, by allowing the executive itself\n               to certify what will be withheld from judicial review. Further, this part of the bill will also introduce a 60-day deadline to apply for\n               judicial review in most cases. This is being done in the name of reducing delay and\n               uncertainty, but I would argue that one person's red tape is another's cherished right.\n               I don't believe that this legislation appropriately balances the need for cabinet\n               confidentiality with that public interest. We are being asked to accept this as a narrow technical fix stemming from a specific\n               court case — a court case, I may add, that was the subject of affirmation by the Court\n               of Appeal in this province and where the Supreme Court of Canada, as I understand\n               it, refused leave to appeal. So we have a decision of the Court of Appeal on the appropriate balance to be struck\n               between the disclosure of cabinet confidences and the protection of the important\n               deliberations that executive council undertakes. That is now going to be potentially,\n               if this legislation proceeds, overridden through a statutory amendment, effectively\n               taking the courts once again out of the role that they play in When you look at the language of this bill, it's not narrow. It creates a broad, ongoing\n               power for the executive to shape what courts can see when government decisions are\n               challenged. I reflect on the lengthy deliberations that resulted in the provision\n               of section 12 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, which struck\n               a careful balance for access to cabinet documents outside of the court process. Frankly, I don't see that level of care taken here, and this is really a fundamental\n               part of making sure that our judicial system can appropriately and fairly deliberate\n               and rule on judicial reviews. For those reasons I've stated, I cannot support this\n               part of the bill as it is currently drafted.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720157","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to speak to the parts of this bill related to Attorney General information\n               and amendments. As someone who has practiced law in this province for over 25 years, I understand\n               and fully appreciate the importance of judicial review in our system of government.\n               Judicial review is a core way that courts ensure that decisions made by government\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8d34fe0d9780e6439efee1bdbe9650d33eb9004853ed100b70f2726ce05fccde"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["44c880f408af336a14c36a888eabfa38d0ca2fa76b9a9ab3243a2214dccd6aec"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bcd880a2d602d2ac1a2176c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721214,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the chamber today is my predecessor as MLA for Saanich North and the Islands, Adam Olsen. As members will know, former MLA Olsen played a pivotal role in getting\n               the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act enshrined into legislation with unanimous support. His seven years of work as an MLA and his time since as lead negotiator for the W̱JOȽEȽP Nation have been centred on ensuring the government lives up to the promises of partnership,\n               of co-governance and free, prior and informed consent. We are lucky to have Adam as\n               a mentor and confidant in the Green caucus and thank him for his ongoing wisdom. Will the House please make him very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721214","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the chamber today is my predecessor as MLA for Saanich North and the Islands, Adam Olsen. As members will know, former MLA Olsen played a pivotal role in getting\n               the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act enshrined into legislation with unanimous support. His seven years of work as an MLA and his time since as lead negotiator for the W̱JOȽEȽP Nation have been centred","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e8066742caccdfdcde421853f0cf25a5640ab3a3f2e3dc6f2d4cf6ae2ab4883"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a92b6115ddc8e0eb6f60014fa80ab5af0b162286c5221bdf18f71361663f3fd1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60760eb474c7772cdd10413c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721219,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"We know the best health care is preventive care. We also know that in this year's budget, there is still going to be 20 percent of\n               British Columbians who will remain unattached to a primary care provider. That's the\n               tip of the iceberg. Organizations like the Saanich Peninsula Hospital Foundation in\n               my riding, are cutting funding Organizations like the Saanich Peninsula Hospital Foundation in my riding are cutting\n               funding support and putting Saanich Peninsula Hospital at risk. It's hard to keep\n               a hospital open when you can't pay the doctors. My question is to the Minister of Health. Will the ministry or Island Health cover\n               the $150,000 shortfall for this year if the Saanich Peninsula Hospital Foundation\n               does not reverse its funding decision?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721219","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We know the best health care is preventive care. We also know that in this year's budget, there is still going to be 20 percent of\n               British Columbians who will remain unattached to a primary care provider. That's the\n               tip of the iceberg. Organizations like the Saanich Peninsula Hospital Foundation in\n               my riding, are cutting funding Organizations like the S","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e463a90f3f6ebd9096ce14140927c5ff43e56b869ad33a2d235c25ac9aff813f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1db44cc167bbd2ba60ee6d2ed159866f4db86291b68d23d75c97dd428e62672"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d9bebece3fad4a792d9370ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721220,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to welcome two guests from the Vancouver Island South Film and Media\n               Commission, a non-profit economic development office that attracts global film projects\n               to the south Island. In the gallery today are Annie Wong-Harrison, the president of\n               the board of directors and a resident of North Saanich, and Tara-Lee Novak, the film\n               commissioner for southern Vancouver Island. A few months ago, Annie and Tara-Lee took me on a set tour of a production being filmed\n               in my riding of Saanich North and the Islands, and I got to see firsthand how the film sector generates an annual regional spend\n               of approximately $60 million. In other really exciting news, the south Island has been recognized as an emerging\n               location at the Global Production Awards, along with Texas, Spain and Slovakia. The\n               winner will be announced in Cannes, France, during the prestigious Cannes Film Festival.\n               Tara-Lee and Annie will represent south Vancouver Island at that event. Please join me in wishing them the best of luck.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721220","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am pleased to welcome two guests from the Vancouver Island South Film and Media\n               Commission, a non-profit economic development office that attracts global film projects\n               to the south Island. In the gallery today are Annie Wong-Harrison, the president of\n               the board of directors and a resident of North Saanich, and Tara-Lee Novak, the film\n               c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","label":"Film industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["110008a48005ba7e9b00b59ae0ba033b53d8a6ffeb8b17d22d4e9bb5ac445fc1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7966bc2c62d94647f0594ce459be87e06ec35d6ff7a01b1ce41a2608542516a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Film industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47655","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00acc4b26a34b2d48823beba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721222,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Some journalists and politicos, almost always old white guys like me, are wondering\n               who's in charge in B.C., us or the First Nations? Well, spoiler alert: section 35\n               of the Constitution is the law. UNDRIP is an international commitment that helps inform\n               section 35, and DRIPA is the roadmap on how to do that work. Collaboration with First Nations is the law of the land. If you disagree, let me remind\n               everyone in this House that since Calder, First Nations are on a 53-year winning streak\n               in the court. Appealing cases like Quw'utsun and Gitxaała...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721222","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Some journalists and politicos, almost always old white guys like me, are wondering\n               who's in charge in B.C., us or the First Nations? Well, spoiler alert: section 35\n               of the Constitution is the law. UNDRIP is an international commitment that helps inform\n               section 35, and DRIPA is the roadmap on how to do that work. Collaboration with First Nations is the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["966b7e07300fb91f7d5389b631d3be0b57260f16c903e4f70ebdb9585f726c64","b399374a346171a0cba58509eb93d05557716ac9a9c7660ba86a8f2b7cf63d9f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["153ee1893e6db92ae2e83fd40376559bfbd30507d9c104edd89bb7a9492f45b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3e3b44553977930acaf9492e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721226,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I start by mentioning and\n               noting that I base my observations and comments on my 25 years of experience as a\n               lawyer working for First Nations negotiating treaties, being at the table with the\n               province, with the nation I was working for, with the federal government for hours\n               on end, for days on end. One thing we have to keep in mind is that this treaty and the resulting treaty act\n               are the result of over 30 years of negotiations involving three parties who have access\n               to experienced legal counsel, experienced policy advice and have come to the point\n               of having a treaty that they wish to proceed with and which the K'ómoks People support.\n               That is an extraordinarily important factor to take into account. Who are we to substitute our judgment of what should and shouldn't be in a treaty\n               when we see the outcome of over 30 years of negotiation in front of us? So as the\n               House Leader for the Third Party and the member for Saanich North and the Islands, I take strong exception to challenges made to this treaty As the member for Saanich North and the Islands and the House Leader for the Third Party, I take strong exception to challenges made\n               to this treaty in areas where the parties have laboured over many years, thousands\n               and thousands of hours of negotiation, with the benefit of expert advice to reach\n               an accommodation on the path forward. So I will certainly be speaking to specific\n               issues in due course that have been raised by my colleagues, but I will be approaching\n               it from the perspective that the issues that are raised have to be pretty fundamental\n               before we are going to turn back the treaty process that has been in the works for\n               30 years. I just want that to be on the record. I want to speak to the importance of the treaty process itself. As we know, treaties\n               hold the potential to be the highest form of reconciliation here in Canada and in\n               B.C. They are a fundamental mechanism for building enduring positive long-term relations\n               and turning the page on over 150 years of history, where the land question has been\n               not dealt with, where reconciliation has not been achieved, where nations have been\n               treated in horrific ways. We have an opportunity to turn the page on that history. These treaties are one form of approach to reconciliation but a very important part.\n               As we know, B.C. is also in a unique position in that this province established and\n               continued to establish itself in the absence of negotiated process with First Nations,\n               unlike other parts of Canada. This lack of partnership with nations, this lack of\n               consent, has informed our relational context in this province for far too long. We're\n               here today as a result of efforts to right that wrong. While recognizing the colonial history that has brought us to this point, it is equally\n               as important to highlight that partnership, alliance and negotiation have existed\n               on these lands since time immemorial, long before today and far outside of the Crown's\n               involvement, over thousands of years. Indeed, the skills of Indigenous communities\n               in negotiating access to resource sites, facilitating trade, resolving conflict and\n               navigating relations were so apparent to Europeans upon contact that they realized\n               it was in their best interest, even in the interest of their survival, to learn Indigenous\n               treaty protocols. Did you know, Mr. Speaker, that Peace River in Alberta, the province next door, came\n               into its name after a war was settled through a treaty between the Nehiyawak Plains\n               Cree and Dene? Or that further east, that the great law of peace led to multiple treaties\n               between the nations of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy after years of war? The Haudenosaunee\n               Confederacy is strong and sovereign to this day. It's important to appreciate the different approaches in different parts of the country.\n               It's important to remember this today as we speak in this House to the impacts that\n               this treaty may have on the future. It is important because treaties do not only impact\n               our future but also our present. Their impacts are felt in the relationships we value,\n               on the shape of the lands and the waters we live on, even on the names of the places\n               we may call home. I can say from my personal experience in working with the Maa-nulth Nations, Tsawwassen\n               First Nation, with Huweyat First Nation that treaty actually creates certainty. It\n               doesn't create uncertainty. We now have a living treaty type of model that is even more appropriate to the nature\n               of the relationship we're building. But the key point is that certainty is created\n               by treaty. But the key point is that certainty is created by treaty and the ability of the parties\n               to come together and find a path forward through extensive negotiations. And extensive\n               engagement with the non-Indigenous community, non-Indigenous businesses is the way\n               in which you create that path so that everybody understands what's involved and what\n               the path forward is. It's important because a treaty is not only, or even always, an agreement between\n               First Nations and Crown governments but a reflection of the relationships built over many years — the labour\n               spent and the care given by First Nations on these lands since time immemorial. The treaty we're talking about today, the treaty act, is also a reflection of changes made in recent years, particularly in its designation\n               as a living agreement. As defined by the B.C. Treaty Commission: \"a living agreement is a treaty that, while constitutionally protected, can evolve\n               and adapt in a way befitting a relationship grounded in the highest form of reconciliation.\" This is significant. It offers the opportunity to relate to this treaty in a new way,\n               in a way that recognizes the complexity and ever-changing realities that we all live and work within. And I know, from personal experience\n               working and being involved with the Maa-nulth treaty and its implementation, that\n               these treaties are living, and there is opportunity to address the evolving nature\n               of the relationship. In this way, this treaty holds the potential for hope, excitement\n               and right relations. Keeping this in mind, and keeping in mind that this is a treaty negotiated amongst\n               the parties over many years, we must not turn away from the fact that there are serious\n               concerns which have been raised by the Wei Wai Kum First Nation in regard to territory\n               infringement and access to significant sites, governance, harvesting and cultural\n               connection. I want to be clear. These are difficult issues. The success of the treaty and the\n               success of the process ultimately depend on coming to a resolution, and it is only\n               the First Nations involved who can address that, with the support — only if requested — of non–First Nations governments in the B.C. Treaty Commission. Ultimately, it is for those nations to\n               respectfully work out the path forward. As a lawyer who spent years working in treaty negotiations with First Nations here in B.C., I deeply understand that\n               there are often issues that are left unresolved at the time of treaty signing and\n               of treaty enactment, that those issues are attended to through nation-to-nation negotiation\n               and agreement. It's the nature of the relationship that those unresolved issues can\n               take time. I want to acknowledge the years and years of work that have gone into the treaty up\n               until this point. But I must also acknowledge and I want to thank the Chiefs and leaders of the Wei Wai Kum First Nation for taking the time to sit and share, with me and my caucus, their experiences. I must also acknowledge that the amount left unresolved for this treaty, in their\n               view, is significant. I want to share for the House a few of the concerns that have\n               been raised by the Wei Wai Kum with the Green caucus. I believe it's important to share some of them in this House\n               so they can be part of the public record and can be fully acknowledged, defined and addressed\n               in a good way. Wei Wai Kum have asserted there is an almost 80 percent overlap between this K'ómoks treaty area and their traditional territory. Concerns have been raised about the\n               Salmon River reserve, which would be transferred to the K'ómoks First Nation as fee simple land as part of this treaty. The Wei Wai Kum have stated that this area contains gravestones, big house sites and other places\n               of cultural and spiritual Concerns have been raised about the Salmon River Reserve, which would be transferred\n               to the K'ómoks First Nation as fee simple land as part of this treaty. The Wei Wai\n               Kum have stated that this area contains gravestones, big house sites and other places\n               of cultural and spiritual significance to their people. Then importantly, for a treaty\n               at this stage, the Wei Wai Kum have stated that, in their view, there has not been\n               adequate consultation or willingness to meet with their leadership on this treaty. Finally, while this is a living treaty that will change over time and it's intended\n               to do so, the Wei Wai Kum have raised concerns about aspects of this treaty that will\n               prevent them from significantly revisiting parts of the treaty once this is adopted.\n               Those are some of the issues that the Wei Wai Kum Nation are raising. I just want to note that, in the context of the treaties I've been involved in negotiating\n               and representing nations on, these issues do arise. This is not unusual. There are\n               often more than one shared territory or overlap type of issue, and they all need to\n               be dealt with. Having shared these concerns, I want to reiterate again that raising these points\n               is not an indication of me placing judgment on what has happened over the last 30\n               years of this treaty process to get us to today. It is not unusual when you are dealing\n               with complex issues with nations who are living and existing in a modern world where\n               European concepts of property and boundaries and dispute resolution are involved. But it does mean acknowledging that serious concerns have been raised, and I believe\n               they should be heard in this House and responded to as this treaty legislation is\n               considered. Now, we are placed as MLAs in this House in a position of voting on the\n               legislative approval of this treaty when these significant issues haven't had the\n               opportunity to be fully heard and attended to. I am left to wonder about the precedent\n               set if we are to pass a treaty bill with this much unresolved. And I have not reached my view, and the Green caucus have not reached our view, on\n               the path forward. So I don't want my comments to be taken as taking a position on\n               the path forward and the validity of these concerns, but I do believe that it's important\n               for these concerns to be on the public record. I certainly want to pass this treaty with full confidence in its capacity to address\n               issues that arise, including these. As someone...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721226","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I start by mentioning and\n               noting that I base my observations and comments on my 25 years of experience as a\n               lawyer working for First Nations negotiating treaties, being at the table with the\n               province, with the nation I was working for, with the federal government for hours\n               on end, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa7b86f4e4fe1b3792c30d9d3e9cc6c3f5d9218e6035255b047f03f23f26983f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fd9e7480d5841f87b8458bdf76255ffa8400120d6e3b7fa67f120659bdb9b2a6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75b1298605222444d17e2a8c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728815,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's starting to feel a little bit like Groundhog Day , so I'm going to try another form of question. One year ago the Premier announced his government would review the Mental Health Act.\n               It was a sliver of hope in the wake of tragedy. The Mental Health Act is archaic and embarrassingly out of step with modern understandings\n               of mental health. In 1964, when the Mental Health Act was written, residential schools\n               and Indian hospitals were operating under the colonial guise of care while conducting\n               non-consensual medical experiments. Involuntary sterilization was common practice\n               against people who were declared mentally defective. Being queer was considered a\n               mental disorder. The Mental Health Act must be reviewed and reformed, but a year after a review was\n               promised, we still don't know who is doing the review, who is being consulted or what\n               questions they're trying to answer. My question to the Minister of Health. What are the terms of reference for the review\n               of the Mental Health Act, and when will they be public?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728815","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's starting to feel a little bit like Groundhog Day , so I'm going to try another form of question. One year ago the Premier announced his government would review the Mental Health Act.\n               It was a sliver of hope in the wake of tragedy. The Mental Health Act is archaic and embarrassingly out of step with modern understandings\n               of mental health. In 1964, when the Mental ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cdab064ba46729bd061863fccdc5353f740d9233a1750c68b52224dbacfd1359"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["439fb198a0ffe102bae71cabee019f88d674b49a18405fd8abf4eeec6d17bb97"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b36c4b99fe8a8a730990ada","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728829,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to move motion M211, standing in my name on the order","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728829","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to move motion M211, standing in my name on the order","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86d3d477ff919bd6f2e2bdb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728831,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"April 28 was the National Day of Mourning for workers killed or injured on the job.\n               I want to add my thoughts to those of the member for Esquimalt-Colwood and the member for Prince George–Mackenzie, who have spoken so well in the House. We stand with the families who have lost a\n               loved one and co-workers who have lost a workmate due to workplace hazards. We also\n               stand with workers who have suffered a workplace injury or disease from hazards or\n               harmful exposures at work We also stand with workers who have suffered a workplace injury or disease from hazards\n               or harmful exposures at work; 138 workers died in B.C. in 2025 from workplace injuries\n               and diseases. This grim toll is unacceptable. B.C. saw 36 asbestos exposure deaths\n               in 2025. There have been seven crane-related deaths in B.C. in the last five years.\n               B.C. has seen growing incidents of psychological injuries from workplace violence,\n               bullying and harassment. We've also seen the concerning prevalence of illegal claim suppression. The National\n               Day of Mourning is a reminder that we can do better. We urge this government to implement\n               the proposed crane licensing and permitting requirements before the end of the year,\n               and the government must fully and fairly implement the Workers Compensation Act to\n               fight claim suppression. While this government, I acknowledge, has taken steps to safely contain and control\n               hazardous asbestos, more needs to be done. We must all work together, and this government\n               must deliver on its promise to recognize workplace health and safety as a fundamental\n               right. Every worker has a right to refuse unsafe work. Every worker deserves to feel\n               protected during their shift and come home safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728831","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"April 28 was the National Day of Mourning for workers killed or injured on the job.\n               I want to add my thoughts to those of the member for Esquimalt-Colwood and the member for Prince George–Mackenzie, who have spoken so well in the House. We stand with the families who have lost a\n               loved one and co-workers who have lost a workmate due to workplace hazards. We also\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68119e2a0d21ec2e77a2da166c27d4dee4fbca963734ccfc0dfa394ddc4eaf18","42d83144730ae2f7d0471ce834aa3ee79921fa798ad4026a298c95a9e474d701"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3437083a3778c5110226dc762c99501abfdf624bf076c41502c6d0740f2f96b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61461cf12345dd07b6ae8c89","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752173,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in support of this motion. As I have noted in this House before, this\n               is an area of legislation that I have significant experience in. I'd like to echo the concerns of my colleagues who spoke before me. I led the team\n               in the early '90s that developed this legislation, which my colleague from Abbotsford\n               South kindly pointed out. I see Bill 9 as being the culmination of 34 years of successive\n               governments attempting to water down and weaken that legislation. I noted just now the member for Prince George–North Cariboo casting a look this way, so I want to take the time to acknowledge the member and\n               his very helpful speech on the flaws in the current bill and the guidance a long-time\n               historian brings to this chamber. I have previously raised my concerns in this chamber and to the minister and to the\n               Information and Privacy Commissioner. I appreciate the time that has been made available\n               to explore the problems with this legislation and to have a very candid discussion\n               about the impact this legislation will have on freedom of information in this province. As you'll note, the minister has put forward some amendments to partially address\n               a few of the issues I've raised, a few but not many and only partially, and this brings\n               me to the motion before us today. I do not believe that enough amendments can be made\n               to this bill to support it. We know that freedom of information allows the public to see how decisions are actually\n               made. We know that this was a founding principle that drove our work on the original\n               legislation, and I believe that public trust depends on this transparency. When people\n               can access information, they're more likely to believe that government is acting fairly\n               and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that empowers journalists, researchers, citizens,\n               British Columbians to have direct oversight over government. This keeps decision-making\n               connected to the people it affects. This legislation, the purpose of this legislation\n               is to ensure the amount of information you have doesn't depend on who you know and\n               why you want it. It depends on the fact that you are a British Columbian, that you\n               paid the taxes to have this information created, and it's our job, all of us, all\n               British Columbians, to hold government to account. You can't hold government to account\n               when you don't have the information. This legislation includes a carefully crafted set of exemptions to that right of access,\n               recognizing that there are circumstances where information must be withheld or may\n               be withheld because of its impact on decision-making processes. It would be if cabinet\n               couldn't meet in private and have candid, frank conversations, that would defeat the\n               purpose of cabinet. You have to allow for that, but you have to balance it. This legislation\n               provides those checks and balances.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752173","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to speak in support of this motion. As I have noted in this House before, this\n               is an area of legislation that I have significant experience in. I'd like to echo the concerns of my colleagues who spoke before me. I led the team\n               in the early '90s that developed this legislation, which my colleague from Abbotsford\n               South kindly pointed out. I see Bil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b54a168da320b961de569f4d87c62408ff01b0d46b1e3449bbafc5dd7ba068cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebc6d64324aa68c730506726017fd9996e5cc96191cb069ed34797b43d332ded"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b134ad97eaf4ad34117d625","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752174,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Premier has been firm in his stance that there is no chance a pipeline will be\n               built to the North Coast. The B.C. Greens, oddly enough, agree. Meanwhile, this government\n               appears willing to leave communities exposed to the potential health risks of fossil\n               fuels and fast-track projects — places like Kitimat where asthma rates have risen\n               by more than 70 percent. The reality is we still don't have a full picture of LNG's impacts. The health impacts\n               have never been studied. Councils in Terrace, Squamish, Dawson Creek and Hazelton\n               are all calling for proper health assessments. Will the Premier So will the Premier explain to these communities why their health concerns are being\n               ignored?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752174","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Premier has been firm in his stance that there is no chance a pipeline will be\n               built to the North Coast. The B.C. Greens, oddly enough, agree. Meanwhile, this government\n               appears willing to leave communities exposed to the potential health risks of fossil\n               fuels and fast-track projects — places like Kitimat where asthma rates have risen\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Heating","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035439","label":"Gases","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","label":"Heating","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["34837b9bc6f77cb63b539cb999ca141abd84ec39951081909bf387d73dfcc071","49a17017cc7f8147b99eff0ad53fa3910148c477630d2c7c2ac9704bc77a3aa0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a47bb98d5985a4e45165b36e6a71563177015ce957037ce821b6c4cde43d599"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-86aea9f89dce2404212317a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752175,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure today to introduce my wonderful guests here in the gallery this morning.\n               Kari Huhtala and Linda Challis live on Pender Island and are two of my constituents\n               in North Saanich and the Islands. They both were exceptional planners in greater Vancouver\n               and are wonderful neighbours on the happiest island in B.C., Pender Island. Kari was\n               born in Finland. His family immigrated to Canada when he was four years old. Linda\n               was born in Vancouver and has lived most of her life here in B.C. They are joined by Kari's niece Anne Roeklenen and her daughter Rosa, who are visiting\n               us from Jarvenpaa, Finland. Anne has visited us twice before, but this is Rosa's first\n               visit to Canada. During the time on Pender, they have been captivated by the deer,\n               sea lions, otters, and they even spied a whale. Unlike me, they are tech-savvy and\n               have used apps to identify birds and vegetation that are not commonly seen in Finland. May the House please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752175","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my pleasure today to introduce my wonderful guests here in the gallery this morning.\n               Kari Huhtala and Linda Challis live on Pender Island and are two of my constituents\n               in North Saanich and the Islands. They both were exceptional planners in greater Vancouver\n               and are wonderful neighbours on the happiest island in B.C., Pender Island. Kari was\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Green products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Globalization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Authors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inequality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Solar energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723693","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal populations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035804","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Independent living","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035804","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Independent living","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035552","label":"Green products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035804","label":"Independent living","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44853","label":"Solar energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59493","label":"Globalization","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715054","label":"Inequality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","label":"Wildlife","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723693","label":"Animal populations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752339","label":"Authors","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f328fc3fe86a6b47f5879c8989dfbf5c4b40c8e136e7226dd133bb720a70e275","21a42ce502754b2571d096139ca9dc538cca2d50969d5df2917b63177bb074c3","8cac0610b569a5e7a4334d43012201ac219c85d6411f5553b138b7a93596db24"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["496ac679a4d72082fa4291deccaa2358cfcf55fa5eae93d1f54bd637c19ce695"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722667","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9004f27275bc80ffe47f3f93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017109,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government continues to talk about...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017109","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This government continues to talk about...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b069138cee016594c3b1c5dc634f2437fa6f567e5445322a77e9e729b11c8d97"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-957b5b947364f6f64801d5b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017113,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my honour and pleasure to introduce to the chamber former MLA Adam Olsen and\n               SȾÁUTW̱ First Nation and chair of the W̱SÁNEĆ school board, Chief Pelkey. I always appreciate their visits, and I hope the House will join me in making them\n               feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017113","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my honour and pleasure to introduce to the chamber former MLA Adam Olsen and\n               SȾÁUTW̱ First Nation and chair of the W̱SÁNEĆ school board, Chief Pelkey. I always appreciate their visits, and I hope the House will join me in making them\n               feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035423","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fungi","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Biological diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752620","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Microorganisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752620","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Microorganisms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288316","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012910","label":"Biological diversity","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035423","label":"Fungi","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288316","label":"Plants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752620","label":"Microorganisms","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d7152e478f66c630906f9126534e70d323c432145d7c6982b63a5f17cbe78aa"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3ac4a2beb0e0d32f6de0bd7d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036406,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to raise my hands too for all of your great work in modernizing security\n               and for our members and staff. I wish you the very best from the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036406","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to raise my hands too for all of your great work in modernizing security\n               and for our members and staff. I wish you the very best from the House.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0381469acf3544493274846350748779083a6be4c3f919bf96a8f4c765e7706f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e73532a02808ce4e523705d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036407,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's been 13 long years since British Columbia became the only province in Canada\n               to continue to allow the sale of tobacco in pharmacies. Almost all major pharmacy\n               chains in the province have voluntarily opted to no longer sell tobacco products,\n               but there's one exception. London Drugs, one of B.C.'s largest pharmacy chains, has\n               refused to limit the product sale in B.C. and continues to refuse to this date. Of\n               course, they can't sell the product in Alberta, but B.C., it's wide open. Last year I, alongside my constituent Leo Lavasseur, who has been advocating for ten\n               years on this issue, wrote to the Health Minister to address this concern. We later\n               received the Health Minister's response: \"Nada, no, nyet, non, c'est impossible. We\n               refuse to adjust this policy, but get this. We're committed to reducing tobacco- and\n               nicotine-related harms through provincial policies.\" Empty words. My question to the Minister of Health is: why is British Columbia the only province\n               to allow the sale of tobacco in pharmacies?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036407","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's been 13 long years since British Columbia became the only province in Canada\n               to continue to allow the sale of tobacco in pharmacies. Almost all major pharmacy\n               chains in the province have voluntarily opted to no longer sell tobacco products,\n               but there's one exception. London Drugs, one of B.C.'s largest pharmacy chains, has\n               refused to","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tobacco industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","label":"Tobacco industry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d796cfcb3d053f40b6826d8ca3517ed8f5062534e04dfe1cb9ba221107c633f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0105ad8dfe296d750b27272b2cf671cc87320358843a23d0e8e15c18b449658e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee1de88561fcbfc70a82fa99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036408,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is with gratitude and admiration that I rise today to say thank you to our interns,\n               who have been with us since the start of the session this February. Effectually known — non-partisanly, of course — as the Green-terns, Kaden and Jenna\n               have exceeded our expectations through their incredible dedication, strong work ethic\n               and genuine openness to learning and engaging with the legislative process. Simply\n               put, they are indeed goated. From supporting policy and communications work to estimates, late-night sittings,\n               even our cherished Treaty Tuesday, our interns have been an absolute delight to work\n               alongside, and quite frankly, they are very real for that. As they venture into the real world, the Green caucus wishes them nothing but success\n               in all that comes next. We hope they continue to carry the same energy, enthusiasm\n               and, of course, impeccable aura wherever they go. Please join me in giving them a hand.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036408","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is with gratitude and admiration that I rise today to say thank you to our interns,\n               who have been with us since the start of the session this February. Effectually known — non-partisanly, of course — as the Green-terns, Kaden and Jenna\n               have exceeded our expectations through their incredible dedication, strong work ethic\n               and genuine openness to learni","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a97f9210830a883b046811b04ad8dadcf256b4c5427a6b493380bec1d9551553"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe10f13fe0e6110f4d18f6c62d5a4c9c11a5b2972bcaeda8944fba46386f035a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43cf195106a6440ab29a887e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036409,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Rob Botterell","venue":"Hansard","text":"Environment Canada is forecasting temperatures above normal for May through to the\n               end of July, while some climatologists say we could be in for a super El Niño this\n               year — a weather event that brings much warmer temperatures and with it, drought. At the same time, that side of the House has only provided a limited top-up funding\n               for the FireSmart program, one of the main ways that local governments and First Nations\n               engage in proactive wildfire prevention. Without further funding, this program is\n               anticipated to run out of money after this season. To the Premier: municipalities and First Nations are worried about the long-term future\n               of this program. Can you guarantee that this essential program will not be cut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036409","member_id":"bc-mla-396","member_name":"Rob Botterell","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Environment Canada is forecasting temperatures above normal for May through to the\n               end of July, while some climatologists say we could be in for a super El Niño this\n               year — a weather event that brings much warmer temperatures and with it, drought. At the same time, that side of the House has only provided a limited top-up funding\n               for the FireSmart progr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","label":"Weather"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","label":"Weather forecasts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","label":"Weather forecasts","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","label":"Weather","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8ac775d73dc85d7a33de86d09c4a1fa56e9e83c1d350ce9bcba8734bf7187713"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06136c5f96aff2feb4cd7e06b70acf01a1794fa9c075c8b4f41a58a1ad629eaf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:731761","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61efb875dec44bd68633952a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317227,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize a visionary initiative in my riding of Salmon Arm–Shuswap that contributes to our local economy and supports entrepreneurs. That initiative\n               is a Zest Commercial Food Hub in Salmon Arm. Zest was made possible through the leadership of the Salmon Arm Economic Development\n               Society in response to a very practical challenge facing many small food producers\n               — access to low-barrier pathways to start or grow a food business without taking on\n               unrealistic expenditures. Whether they are farmers adding value to their crops, small\n               processors testing new products or entrepreneurs launching a food business, those\n               barriers can be the difference between an unrealized goal or becoming a viable employer. Zest addresses the challenge, providing access to a certified shared-use commercial\n               kitchen, processing space, storage equipment and a collaborative environment. It supports\n               food makers at every stage, from start-ups to established businesses, allowing them\n               to focus on what they do best — creating quality products, building markets and contributing\n               to the regional economy. The benefits of Zest extend well beyond the walls of the facility. It strengthens\n               local supply chains. It supports job creation and enhances food security and resilience\n               throughout the Shuswap and surrounding regions. We often speak in this House about\n               economic diversification, local food sustainability and practical, community-driven\n               solutions. Zest is a clear example of those principles in action. I ask all members to join me in recognizing the community leaders and the entrepreneurs\n               behind the Zest Commercial Food Hub for their contribution to regional food production\n               and the long-term economic health of our community.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317227","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize a visionary initiative in my riding of Salmon Arm–Shuswap that contributes to our local economy and supports entrepreneurs. That initiative\n               is a Zest Commercial Food Hub in Salmon Arm. Zest was made possible through the leadership of the Salmon Arm Economic Development\n               Society in response to a very practical challenge facing many small food p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["928252e7783c619b0245566d7bbc3741880d8458685174f91f158e4b6b3b87b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85cc1eb927c5b7e501990dd80444bd60828e554b017746123f309b58dfbe3db7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe1b95c44b322ab884ae4ab4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317228,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today my heart is heavy as I reflect on the tragic shooting in Tumbler Ridge. On behalf\n               of the residents of my riding of Salmon Arm–Shuswap, I extend the deepest condolences to the victims, their families and the entire community.\n               We stand with you in the grief and solidarity during this difficult time. Going on, budgets are not just accounting exercises; they're choices. They reveal\n               priorities. They show very clearly who government believes can afford to wait and\n               who cannot. Unfortunately, Budget 2026 makes a series of choices that will make life\n               harder for all British Columbians who already are struggling to get by — seniors on\n               fixed incomes, young people trying to build a future, working families, rural communities\n               and small businesses. This budget may attempt to address a serious deficit problem of the government's own\n               making, but it also does so by deferring solutions, narrowing opportunity and quietly\n               downloading today's costs onto the next generation. Unfortunately, this government\n               continues to choose hindsight over foresight, kind of like the movie Groundhog Day . A budget is not simply a ledger of revenues and expenses. It is also a statement of\n               values. It reveals who government chooses to protect, and it chooses who they prioritize\n               and who is asked once again to sacrifice or wait. It has been long said that a society is judged on how the government treats the elderly,\n               the young and the most vulnerable. Today as we debate the budget, the question before\n               this House is not simply whether the numbers add up but whether the choices made reflect\n               compassion, fairness and responsibility or whether they once again leave too many\n               British Columbians feeling forgotten, overburdened and most of all For seniors who built this province are now facing rising costs, shrinking services\n               and uncertainty in health care. A budget should offer dignity and security. For young\n               people and families trying to put down roots, afford a home or plan for the future\n               in British Columbia, a budget should offer opportunity and hope. And for the most\n               vulnerable, those struggling with disabilities, mental illness, addictions, housing\n               insecurity or living in rural or remote communities, a budget should be a lifeline,\n               not a hollow promise. Let's start with the elderly. I want to speak directly to seniors watching this debate.\n               Those people who built our communities, raised our families, and contributed for decades\n               to the province we enjoy today. I want seniors to know on this side of the house,\n               we are listening and we are speaking directly to you on matters that you care about. I realize many seniors living in Salmon Arm, Armstrong or the many communities in\n               this province, Budget 2026 is not just a fiscal plan. It is a signal about whether\n               this government truly understands the realities of British Columbians. Unfortunately,\n               this government either doesn't care or simply doesn't listen. Across this province,\n               seniors are facing a perfect storm. Rising costs, stretched health services, limited\n               housing options and a growing uncertainty about whether help will be there when they\n               need it. Budget 2026 does little to ease those priorities and pressures, and in some\n               cases it makes them worse. How can this NDP government justify taxing yarn and clothing patterns and natural\n               fibres that may be made into a fuchsia sweater for a grandson or a dress for a granddaughter?\n               How can this NDP government tax basic cable and landline telephone services when we\n               all know that that disproportionately affects seniors? The government will point to\n               its increases in overall health spending, but seniors do not experience health care\n               in the abstract. They experience it at home, in care facilities and through front-line\n               support services. Critics and seniors advocates have been clear. Additional health funding does not\n               sufficiently target long-term care, assisted living or home support services. That\n               means seniors needing help to remain independent still struggle to access home care.\n               I know in my riding there are lots living out in the country there that certainly\n               can't get home care. They would love to stay in their homes, but they can't get it.\n               Families trying to keep loved ones at home receive little relief. Again, families\n               struggling. They like to keep people at home, tough to do. Care homes remain understaffed and unable to expand capacity. I get numerous emails\n               in the constituency office regarding that. One of the most troubling aspects of this\n               budget is the decision to pause or \"re-pace\" long-term-care construction projects\n               around British Columbia. We already know that wait-times for long-term-care placements\n               in supportive and long-term care average months and, in some cases, far, far longer. Polson Extended Care in Vernon, as well as Mount Ida Mews, as well as Bastion Place\n               in Salmon Arm, to mention only a few, are stretched to the limit, with future demand\n               inevitable. Seniors who can no longer safely live at home are waiting in hospital\n               beds, emergency departments or housing that no longer meets their needs. When long care projects are delayed, the consequences are immediate and predictable.\n               Seniors wait for appropriate care. Families shoulder more and more responsibility With British Columbia's population aging faster than ever, this lack of targeted investment\n               is not just short-sighted; it is irresponsible. This is not compassionate care. This\n               is a system failure, and it is particularly damaging in communities with aging populations,\n               including rural and semi-rural regions, such as the riding of Salmon Arm–Shuswap. When infrastructure is delayed today, the shortage becomes a crisis tomorrow. Budget\n               2026 tells seniors with complex care needs and their care providers to just make it\n               work. Long-term-care projects across the province are delayed or postponed, as the\n               NDP word of the day states: \"Re-paste.\" There is no new investment for home support\n               services despite repeated warnings from advocates that this is where the pressure\n               could be relieved and dignity preserved. At the same time, the government quietly makes it more expensive for seniors to stay\n               in their homes. Property tax deferment interest rates are raised to prime plus 2 percent,\n               and interest now compounds monthly. For seniors on fixed incomes, that's not a technical\n               change. It is a financial squeeze that grows every single month. This budget makes\n               aging in place harder — much, much harder — not easier. Budget 2026 also includes plans to reduce the size of the public service through attrition\n               and hiring freezes. Sounds good. While these reductions may not be labelled as seniors\n               cuts, seniors will feel them first. Seniors rely heavily on health administration,\n               social service coordination, community support programs, caseworkers and system navigators.\n               When staffing levels drop, phone calls go unanswered, paperwork piles up, and wait\n               times grow. And seniors, often the least able to navigate complex systems, are left\n               to fend for themselves. This is how services erode quietly, without ever being called\n               a cut. Many seniors live on fixed incomes. They do not benefit from wage increases. They\n               cannot work extra hours to absorb higher costs. Yet the budget raises serious concerns\n               about tax fairness through paused indexation and bracket creep. That means seniors\n               pay more tax without earning more income. The purchasing power of pensions declines.\n               Essentials like food, utilities, medications and transportation become harder to afford.\n               For seniors budgeting carefully each month, this is just another squeeze. Changes to the property tax deferment program have not received nearly enough attention.\n               Under Budget 2026, the interest compounds monthly rather than simple interest, and\n               new deferrals become significantly more expensive. For seniors that are house-rich\n               but cash-poor, this erodes equity faster and discourages participation altogether. This has a profound effect on seniors living in rural and remote areas, which directly\n               speaks to many of the constituents in the North Okanagan and Shuswap. Many have retired\n               to the area and now face challenges to remain in their homes, or at least they will\n               face challenges in the future. Seniors are not commercial borrowers. Their homes are\n               not investment vehicles. They are places of Seniors are not commercial borrowers. Their homes are not investment vehicles. They\n               are places of stability, dignity and independence. This budget was an opportunity\n               to prepare for an aging population. Instead, seniors see delayed care, stretched services,\n               rising costs, shrinking support. Seniors are not asking for special treatment. They are asking for foresight, fairness\n               and a little bit of respect. Budget 2026 does not meet that test. What about the young? Well, when we examine the challenges of seniors compared to\n               young people, we see a different stage of life but the same pattern of delay and displacement. Let me begin with housing. The government speaks often about housing and affordability,\n               yet this budget quietly pulls back from the very programs meant to deliver supply.\n               The community housing fund is indefinitely closed. Capital delivery is re-paced, and\n               projects are delayed. Less supply does not mean affordability. It means higher rents, longer commutes and\n               the possibility of more young people leaving their communities altogether. I would like to see young families stay and contribute in my region rather than relocate\n               to Alberta. You cannot claim to be addressing affordability while slowing housing\n               delivery. Those two things do not reconcile. Budget 2026 also provides flat operating funding to colleges and universities while\n               the costs continue to rise. The resulting action is predictable: fewer course offerings,\n               larger class sizes, reduced student services, upward pressure on fees. When students face higher debt and fewer pathways, the entire province pays the price.\n               Education is an investment for a better future for all of us. Budget 2026 effectively freezes transit funding as well. Inflation alone erodes service\n               levels. Young people, students, apprentices, level-entry workers rely heavily on transit\n               to access education and employment. In rural and semi-rural communities like Scotch\n               Creek, Sorrento and Sicamous, limited transportation compounds isolation and reduces\n               workforce participation. Mobility is opportunity, and this budget restricts both. Budget 2026 raises the lowest personal income tax rate and pauses indexing. What does\n               that mean for younger residents, who are generally at the lower end of the tax bracket?\n               Well, that's easy. It means that young workers may pay more on their paycheque. Inflation\n               will quietly raise the effect of tax burdens, and government revenues will rise without\n               transparency — surprise, surprise. This is bracket creep, and it hits those least\n               able to absorb it. What about child care? Well, as for young families, this government long promised\n               affordable, accessible child care with a $10-a-day commitment. Yet Budget 2026 quietly\n               pauses the expansion of that program. Existing families keep their subsidies, but\n               no new spaces, and new provider enrolment is effectively frozen. We should take a moment to reflect. Only a small fraction of spaces actually met the\n               $10-a-day target announced by the NDP. Most families still pay far more than promised\n               and sit on wait-lists that stretch into the unforeseen future. A system that exists\n               in theory but not in practice is not affordability. It is a roadblock to meaningful\n               employment for many families in this province. There is no serious plan to restore affordability, no urgency in housing supply, no\n               bold investment in workforce development. The younger generation should not be asked\n               to accept There is no serious plan to restore affordability, no urgency in housing supply, no\n               bold investment in workforce development. The younger generation should not be asked\n               to accept a lower standard of living than the one before it. Yet Budget 2026 moves\n               us closer to that reality. Now, let's talk about the vulnerable. When we connect the impacts on seniors and youth,\n               we see the same pattern playing out, most harshly on the vulnerable. Mental health\n               funding is cut at MCFD. Autism supports are in jeopardy. Children in care receive\n               rhetoric without prevention. Seniors with complex needs face delayed care. Low-income\n               households face higher taxes. Those at risk and most in need live in our communities. They live in Falkland, Malakwa,\n               Blind Bay and near every one of us, wherever we reside. This budget fails them. When we look past the headlines in this budget, past the slogans, past the spin, we\n               are left with a troubling reality. This budget asks the most vulnerable British Columbians\n               and their caring families to carry more of the burden while receiving less in support\n               and not much in return. Community-based advocates have been prominently quoted in the media and organizational\n               releases urging the government not to overlook the broader health supports. The autism\n               funding program is being phased out by March 31, 2027, replaced by two new funding\n               streams plus expanded community services. Business in Vancouver commentary by Rob Shaw reports that the redesign could leave 10,000 B.C. kids with\n               less support — not one, 10,000 — arguing that fiscal mechanics effectively trade off\n               prior autism funding against new benefit costs. Child care directors note that well-staffed quality care for children requires adequate\n               funding for educators and that current struggles could affect access, going forward.\n               The B.C. Care Providers Association said this budget's lack of immediate funding for\n               seniors care is appalling, warning that about 7,000 seniors — not one, 7,000 — already\n               on long-term-care waitlists will face worsened delays and pressure on emergency rooms\n               as a result. The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives stated that the budget impacts\n               will fall on low- to moderate-income households. Budget 2026 fails them all. Mental health services are not a luxury; they are essential. Yet this budget cuts\n               $3 million from the Ministry of Children and Family Development's mental health budget.\n               And that's not trimming the fat. That's cutting preventative care. Those dollars pay\n               for early intervention, youth counselling and family supports — the very services\n               that stop people from ending up in emergency rooms, police cells or even worse. At the same time, there are no new investments in mental health services beyond what\n               already was announced last year — no expansion, no new capacity, no response to rising\n               demand. All three involuntary care facilities referenced by the government were announced\n               previously. Budget 2026 added nothing new. Yet emergency departments are overwhelmed,\n               police officers are doing mental health work they were never trained for, and families\n               are begging for help. That's not compassion. That's managed neglect. Families raising children with autism and developmental disabilities already carry\n               an extraordinary emotional and financial burden. This budget offers them silence.\n               There are no new autism-specific investments, only a new funding model; no increase\n               to therapy caps; no increase to unit funding; no plan for youth aging out of services\n               and an uncertain future when they turn 18. Inflation rises The government often speaks about protecting children, but protection requires prevention.\n               Cutting mental health funding undermines youth supports, family reunification efforts\n               and trauma-informed care, especially for Indigenous children who remain vastly overrepresented\n               in care. There are no new investments in youth transition housing, wraparound services\n               for complex behaviour needs or supports for neurodiverse children in care. When we fail these young people early, we do not save money. We simply delay the bill\n               until it shows up in the justice system, in the hospitals and in the homeless stats.\n               This is not responsible government. That's a very expensive indifference. Affordability is not improving; it's deteriorating. This NDP budget raises the lowest\n               personal income tax rate, the first increase in that bracket in more than two decades.\n               It pauses tax bracket indexation, guaranteeing that inflation will quietly push people\n               into higher taxes, even if their purchasing power never increases. It expands PST\n               into areas like professional and security service costs that do not get absorbed.\n               They are passed on directly to consumers. Who pays for tax preparation? Who pays strata management fees? Who pays security when\n               their business is vandalized? Many working families, seniors and small business owners\n               who are barely hanging on, that's who. This is a budget that raises revenue from the\n               people who can least absorb it. Housing insecurity is not solved by announcement or press announcements. Budget 2026\n               introduces no new enhancements to rental assistance programs for seniors or low-income\n               renters. One policy commentary notes that Budget 2026 does not add new increases to\n               SAFER, which is Shelter Aid for Elderly Renters, or RAP supplements, despite high\n               rates of unaffordable housing among senior renters. At the same time, capital projects that are tied to supportive housing, student housing\n               and community health infrastructure are delayed under the so-called repacing. For\n               some people on the margins, delay is denial. We all know when housing falls short,\n               homelessness grows, and when homelessness grows, pressure explodes across health care,\n               policing and social services. Yet this budget offers no structural response. British Columbians were told that decriminalization would improve outcomes. Instead,\n               this NDP government has committed roughly $19 million to monitoring and evaluation,\n               while admitting it moved ahead without reliable baseline data. Surprise, surprise. There are no meaningful new investments in long-term-treatment beds, no expansion\n               of recovery housing and no serious rural access strategy. Downtowns deteriorate, families\n               grieve, communities feel unsafe, and all this government calls it is a learning experience.\n               British Columbians deserve much, much better. It's abundantly clear that this budget fails the elderly, the young and the most vulnerable\n               among us. British Columbia is not a Third World jurisdiction. We should be a prosperous\n               province, one that has outcomes that reflect our shared values — caring for our neighbours,\n               protecting those who cannot protect themselves and providing a credible roadmap that\n               gives future generations confidence, opportunity and hope. I'm seeing I better cut along here. There's so much to go on here. I could go on forever. I'm seeing I'd better cut along here. There's so much to go on here. I could go on\n               forever. While the government points to a $15 million recapitalization for 2026, this funding\n               merely patches immediate gaps after communities were forced to compete for shrinking\n               resources, and it provides no certainty for the fiscal year. Earlier in the year,\n               funding constraints had already pushed FireSmart into a pause and a competitive education\n               model, stripping out fuel management work. The most effective on-the-ground mitigations\n               from eligible activities, intake periods and program scope have been narrowed to fit\n               constrained budgets, not the wildfire risk. At the same time, reports of a shift to a more centralized provincial wildfire mitigation\n               model have alarmed rural and municipal leaders, who fear local expertise and decision-making\n               will be sidelined as wildfire threats continue to escalate. The Insurance Brokers\n               Association of B.C. has warned that the FireSmart program is essential to insurers'\n               ability to mitigate wildfire risk and that without that meaningful risk reduction\n               program, rural communities could face higher premiums or lose access to home insurance\n               altogether. Having worked previously in loss control, I see firsthand the value of these programs.\n               These funding models have been decreased by the government as part of the strategy\n               of reducing a little bit of funding to some of the districts, right? The reason I\n               brought that up is because that's very, very important for my riding, where they've\n               suffered all kinds of fires in the past. I know the value that the FireSmart program\n               brings to everybody. Looking at the time, I'm just closing here. When we step back and look at Budget 2026\n               as a whole, not through a lens but across the full scope of government, it becomes\n               clear that this is not a budget of renewal, recovery or confidence. It is a budget\n               of decline. One more quick little mention here. One of the most deeply concerning things that\n               I have — it was quietly buried in the elements of this year's budget legislation —\n               was the decision to eliminate the independent hiring watchdog, the Office of the Merit\n               Commissioner. This operates....This office....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317228","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today my heart is heavy as I reflect on the tragic shooting in Tumbler Ridge. On behalf\n               of the residents of my riding of Salmon Arm–Shuswap, I extend the deepest condolences to the victims, their families and the entire community.\n               We stand with you in the grief and solidarity during this difficult time. Going on, budgets are not just accounting exercises; they're choi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2d4215c7ebb1661557902880a7b4f812ba0ec1fe49faa92bdc6debcdd32f0fdf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e29320454e7562c8012a05e41fb29d58dd3b4ef1811621fdee19dfab9b32b40a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5481f8e6e6cbc4855bb48442","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328072,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, sounds great,\n               but the bill is nothing like the title indicates. First reading allowed us to see\n               the entire bill, and this debate provides the opportunity to review the bill in detail,\n               which I intend to do. I would like to point out many of the overarching aspects and note numerous general\n               risks. First off, unlike the people across the way, I cannot support this bill. I\n               find that there's a lot of.... I don't see the bill, certainly, in the same way they\n               do. They must be reading something different. I see that it shifts power away from citizens and tilts toward government discretion.\n               It normalizes delay, refusal and gatekeeping of freedom-of-information requests. It\n               weakens independent oversight by the Information and Privacy Commissioner. It creates\n               vague, undefined thresholds that favour government convenience. It inappropriately harms the average citizens in my riding; journalists, whom we depend\n               on for information; researchers, whom we depend on for data; and watchdogs, whom we\n               depend on for everything. It erodes trust by quietly expanding refusal powers without\n               transparency. This bill does not modernize freedom of information; it justifies obstruction\n               and delay. I got into politics to be a voice for those who demand open and transparent democratic\n               values. I believe it is the responsibility of each elected MLA, as well as the government\n               of the day, to be held to account to the people they represent. This bill fails us\n               with this value and that objective. I honestly believe that freedom of information\n               is not a bureaucratic luxury; it is a democratic necessity. We need more freedom, not less, yet over time, many freedoms have been restricted,\n               and information that belongs to the public has been delayed, obscured or quietly withheld.\n               That trend must stop. Freedom of information is not about politics. It is a matter of trust and respect\n               for taxpaying citizens. It is about the fundamental right of those citizens to understand\n               what their government is doing, in their name, with their money, and how it affects\n               their lives. For the residents of Salmon Arm–Shuswap, this right is not theoretical. It is For the residents of Salmon Arm–Shuswap, this right is not theoretical. It is extremely important. In rural communities,\n               such as the many within my riding, decisions made behind closed doors have very real\n               consequences. They affect whether a permit is approved or stalled for years. They\n               affect whether a health service remains local or quietly centralizes elsewhere. They affects forestry workers, farmers, small business owners, volunteer fire departments\n               and families trying to build a home. When information is delayed or denied, residents are not just inconvenienced; they\n               are disadvantaged. Rural communities are already facing challenges that urban centres\n               don't often have: longer travel times, fewer services, limits to staff capacity and\n               thinner margins. When transparency breaks down, the usual outcome in rural British\n               Columbia is that the residents always pay the price. Freedom of information exists to level the playing field. It allows citizens, journalists\n               and elected representatives to ask simple but essential questions. Why was this decision\n               made? Who was consulted? What alternatives were considered? And why did this project\n               move forward or not? And when responses take months or years, when documents arrive\n               heavily redacted, or when fees and delays discourage legitimate requests, the spirit\n               of transparency is lost. Accountability delayed is accountability denied. Governments do not own information. They are temporary custodians of it. Public records\n               belong to the public, to the farmers in the North Okanagan managing land under challenging\n               regulations, to the families in Salmon Arm navigating health care wait-lists, to the\n               smaller municipalities trying to plan infrastructure, and to the rural taxpayers funding\n               all of it. In rural British Columbia, people expect straight answers. They expect decisions to\n               be explained, not hidden behind process, and they expect their government to act with\n               openness, not defensiveness. Transparency is not a threat to good government. It reaffirms responsible government.\n               A confident government does not fear scrutiny. A competent government does not suppress\n               information. And a democratic government does not restrict freedom unless absolutely\n               necessary and never without explanation. Yet we have seen a gradual normalization of secrecy under this NDP government. Key\n               decisions announced without supporting data. Policies implemented before consultation\n               results are released. Oversight offices weakened or eliminated completely. Information\n               requests treated as nuisances rather than a right. This is not healthy for democracy. Freedom of information empowers citizens to participate\n               meaningfully in public life. It allows rural communities to advocate for themselves\n               with facts, not rumours. When you live in a small place — lots of rumours — you want\n               facts. It strengthens confidence in institutions, and it reminds government who they\n               ultimately serve. Freedom is not something we slowly surrender and then hope to regain later. We've\n               seen that picture. Freedom of information is no different. Once transparency erodes,\n               rebuilding trust is far harder than preserving it. Rural British Columbians are not asking for special treatment. They were asking for\n               equal respect, equal access to information and equal accountability. They, as I do,\n               believe that openness strengthens democracy and governments work best when they remember\n               to answer to the people, not the other way around It is time to stop restricting freedoms. It is time to stop suppressing information.\n               It is time to recommit to transparency, accountability and the democratic principles\n               that built this province in every community, rural and urban alike. I'll take a little time here and I'll go through clause by clause here, just to go\n               over this bill, just to explain it to everybody in layman's terms what it really means. We'll start off with clause 1. This applies part 2 of the FOIPPA to records connected\n               to proceedings. It creates a large exemption loophole where records tied to proceedings\n               are shielded from access. Government can strategically link records to proceedings\n               to avoid disclosure. It reduces transparency around litigation strategy, settlements\n               and administrative actions. Now I'll put in layman terms. This clause strikes at the heart of public accountability.\n               Government records do not cease to belong to the public simply because litigation\n               or administrative proceedings are underway. In fact, scrutiny is most important when\n               government actions are being challenged. By carving out this exemption, the bill creates a pathway for politically sensitive\n               material to be shielded under the context of proceedings. That's kind of scary. Transparency\n               cannot depend on whether government is comfortable being examined. Let's move on to clause 2, section 5. This gives the head of the public body sole\n               authority to judge the request adequacy. It removes objective standard for whether\n               a request is sufficiently detailed. \"Reasonable amount of time\" is undefined, subjective\n               and unenforceable. It enables gatekeeping and arbitrary rejection, especially for\n               complex and historical records, and penalizes ordinary citizens who don't know internal\n               filing systems. It all sounds kind of scary to me. This provision fundamentally alters the balance of power between the citizens and\n               the state by granting sole discretion to the head of a public body to determine whether\n               a request is sufficiently detailed, and tying it to \"a reasonable amount of time,\"\n               the bill converts an objective right into a subjective gatekeeping exercise. The act was designed to assist applicants, not to test their drafting skills. Public\n               access should not depend on insider knowledge of government filing systems. It should\n               be simple, easy and transparent. Let's move on to clause 3, section 6. \"Changes without delay\" has been changed to\n               \"without reasonable delay.\" That normalizes slow responses with no clear benchmarks.\n               It encourages bureaucratic delay as a standard practice. It weakens enforcement. What\n               is reasonable becomes debatable and contestable. My concern would be replacing \"without delay\" with \"without reasonable delay.\" It\n               doesn't sound like much. It's just a word, but it makes a big difference. It lowers\n               the statutory standard for responsiveness. Words matter. The original language implied urgency. The amended language invites\n               interpretation and delay. When access timelines become elastic, accountability is\n               weakened. For journalists, rural advocates and citizens seeking time-sensitive information,\n               delay can effectively amount to denial. That's not democratic. Let's move on to clause 5, section 10. This allows deadline extensions by an applicant\n               consent. What does it mean? Well, applicants may feel pressured to consent or risk\n               retaliation or refusal. It creates unequal power dynamics between citizens and government. In the revised freedom-of-information process, that balance no longer exists. Applicants\n               often depend on the very institution they are requesting the information from. Introducing\n               the consent mechanism for extensions risks indirect intimidation, where citizens feel\n               compelled to agree to delays to avoid conflict or disadvantage. Administrative convenience\n               should not override procedural fairness. Never should. Let's move on. Clause 6, section 10. It removes a lack of detail as an extension reason,\n               because it's now a refusal tool. It confirms a policy shift towards rejection rather\n               than assistance and undermines the act's original duty to help applicants refine requests.\n               The original framework encouraged collaboration between government and applicants\n               to clarify requests. Instead of allowing time extensions to clarify requests, the\n               bill now allows the public body to determine whether that request is sufficiently\n               detailed in the first place. This amendment signals a shift from assistance to avoidance. Instead of helping refine\n               unclear requests, the government now gains the stronger tools to reject them outright.\n               That's not modernization; that's a reduction of service. Government is supposed to\n               be here to help its citizens, not to refuse them. Let's move on. Clause 7, section 16.1 expands the secrecy around policy influence\n               and advice. It blurs the lines between judicial independence and executive secrecy.\n               It prevents scrutiny of how policies are shaped behind closed doors. Have we heard\n               that? Too many times. Judicial independence must be protected, but independence is not synonymous with secrecy.\n               By broadly exempting policy communications involving judicial officers, the bill risks\n               concealing policy influence under the banner of independence. Public confidence depends on transparency, on how policies are shaped, particularly\n               where branches of governments intersect. I think that's foundational for democracy\n               and a transparent government. I don't know. Maybe it's just me. Clauses 8 and 9, sections 26 and 27. This has to do with personal information collection,\n               expanded collection and indirect collection of personal information. It broadens personal\n               data collection without proportional safeguards. It enables data sharing without direct\n               consent. Increased risk of data misuse and breach will be the result. The expansion of personal information collection powers without proportional safeguards\n               erodes public trust. Government must collect data only when necessary and with clear\n               limits. When collection authority broadens while oversight mechanisms shrink elsewhere\n               in the bill, citizens are left to trust assurances rather than protections. Privacy\n               must be strictly defended, not an administrative promise. Let's move on. Clause 10, section 33. This removes the requirement for the commissioner\n               to approve the research purpose itself. For what it's worth, it weakens independent\n               oversight of research use of personal data. It allows government-aligned or poorly\n               defined research to proceed unchecked. In layman terms, an independent review by the commissioner provides confidence that\n               the personal information used for research meets the genuine public interest standards.\n               Revision to that approval step weakens oversight at precisely the point where sensitive\n               data may be repurposed. Good intentions do not substitute for independent scrutiny. Revision to that approval step weakens oversight at precisely the point where sensitive\n               data may be repurposed. Good intentions do not substitute for independent scrutiny. Clause 11, section 33. This allows the disclosure of personal information for connected\n               services. I'll explain. It's a vague scope for disclosure. It expands data use without\n               clear consent or limitation. The term, \"connected services\" lacks precision. Vague authority to disclose personal\n               information creates uncertainty about scope and limits. Without explicit guardrails,\n               disclosure creep becomes a real risk, where information shared for one purpose gradually\n               expands into others without meaningful consent or awareness. Clauses 12 and 14. Information-sharing with other jurisdictions. British Columbians\n               lose control over where and how their data is used. Accountability weakens once information\n               leaves provincial oversight. Once personal information leaves provincial jurisdiction, accountability mechanisms\n               weaken and recourse becomes much more complex. British Columbians deserve clarity\n               about where their data travels and under what protections it remains safeguarded.\n               Far too often we have seen privacy breaches with secure information. Privacy becomes\n               a concern when information crosses a border. Clause 13. This expands grounds to disregard FOI requests. That doesn't sound good.\n               Major risks. It introduces undefined terms: abusive, malicious, unreasonably broad,\n               interference without government. It allows government to label inconvenient scrutiny\n               as \"interference.\" It creates a chilling effects on journalists, researchers and citizens. This clause introduces expansive and undefined language: abusive, malicious, unreasonably broad, interference with government — which can be subjective. Vague standards invite selective\n               enforcement. When government gains authority to characterize scrutiny as interference,\n               the chilling effect on investigative journalism and citizen oversight is immediate\n               and real. Clause 15, section 56. This allows the commissioner to extend review timelines beyond\n               the current 90-day limit. Here are some of the risks and the adverse effects. It weakens\n               the 90-day safeguard by allowing timelines to be extended beyond that limit. It allows\n               reviews to stretch indefinitely. It reduces confidence in the compliance process. Timelines are essential to justice. Revising the 90-day limit for the commissioner\n               reviews could result in indefinite delays that undermine confidence in the oversight\n               process. Reviews without time-constraint considerations become a right without a practical\n               remedy. Clauses 17 to 19. This has to do with changes to privacy impact assessment notification.\n               Here are some of the risks and the adverse effects of that. Modifying early-stage\n               notification potentially reduces early scrutiny and proactive oversight. Commissioner\n               involvement becomes reactive, not preventative. Proactive oversight prevents harm\n               before it occurs. Early-stage notification requirements shift the commissioner's role\n               from preventative to reactive. Once privacy breaches occur, damage is often irreversible. My former occupation in\n               loss control was to anticipate risk. Good governance does not manage fallout. It's\n               usually proactive, not reactive. Clause 20, section 69.3. This has to do with connected services provider, a centralized\n               platform. Centralization may reduce transparency, create single-point failure, distance\n               decision-making from local realities. It is unclear whether Crown corporation agencies will be forced into the system. Again,\n               a little bit of clarity would be nice. Centralization can improve efficiency, but\n               it can also concentrate control. A single, centralized Centralization can improve efficiency, but it can also concentrate control. A single\n               centralized platform may reduce transparency, create single-point vulnerabilities\n               and distance decision-making from local realities. For rural British Columbia, where\n               service access is already strained, centralized digital systems often fail first and\n               hardest. Clauses 21 and 22, sections 71 and 71.1. This has to do with fees for records made\n               available without an FOI. It introduces paywalls to information. It discourages informal\n               access. It penalizes low-income applicants. Access to public information should not depend on one's ability to pay. Introducing\n               fees for records that would otherwise be made available without formal FOI requests\n               creates a paywall around transparency. When transparency carries a price tag, low-income\n               citizens, small community groups and rural residents are disproportionately affected. Noting the hour, I move adjournment of the debate, and I reserve my time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328072","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, sounds great,\n               but the bill is nothing like the title indicates. First reading allowed us to see\n               the entire bill, and this debate provides the opportunity to review the bill in detail,\n               which I intend to do. I would like to point out many of the overarching aspects and note numerous","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b27d5c50bacb1520348e6de2373a342ab10d44e97d4a6a9d995175e9f596f830"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["063f258a4cd5c15cd0578fbe7ba9cf9db1ee9557c127a2f8c1562436b09475a9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62b502d483ca5db5f7c2b037","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361205,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll pick up where I left off the other day. Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026 sounds\n               really good, but like I specified the other day, not good. It's probably the opposite of what it sounds like. The Freedom of Information Protection\n               and Privacy Amendment Act is a bill nothing like the title indicates. I'm glad that\n               we have this second reading so we can actually sit here and debate it. I'll pick up where I had left off. I was going clause by clause, so we'll continue\n               on where I was, clause 21 and 22, which is sections 71 and 71.1. This has to do with\n               fees for access. And here's the thing, it introduces paywalls to information. It discourages\n               informal access This has to do with fees for access. Here's the thing. It introduces paywalls to information,\n               it discourages informal access, and it penalizes low-income applicants. Access to\n               public information should not depend on one's ability to pay. Introducing fees for\n               records that would otherwise be made available without an FOI request and requires\n               a paywall around transparency is unheard of and unconscionable. When transparency\n               carries a price tag, low-income citizens, small community groups and rural residents\n               are disproportionately affected. Many, many organizations and small entities depend on getting this information, and\n               they base a lot of findings around information that they receive, so this information\n               should be more readily available rather than more difficult to get. Let's move on to section clause 23, section 73. This expands the liability protection.\n               Broader immunity could also reduce consequences for poor disclosure practices. That\n               rewards rather than punishes poor disclosure. That's not good. So now it doesn't have\n               to be accurate? Clause 28, transitional application. This is retroactive section 43 powers. The major\n               concern here is the fact that it changes the rules mid-game. Nobody likes rules being\n               changed halfway through. It allows FOIs to be dismissed under a new, broader refusal\n               power. For instance, if I have a request in right now, which I probably do, they could\n               turn around and refuse it. Now they just changed the rules on me. That doesn't sound\n               very fair. Retroactive application of broader refusal powers undermines fairness and predictability.\n               Citizens who filed requests under one legal framework should not have the rules changed\n               mid-process. Retroactive restriction of access rights erodes the trust in both the\n               process and the institution. Already people don't trust government. In conclusion, Bill 9 systematically weakens freedom of information in British Columbia.\n               This NDP government has a history of hiding information, unreasonable delays and deciding\n               what information the public should be entitled to. This bill expands secrecy, it normalizes\n               delay, it concentrates discretion, it weakens oversight, and it penalizes citizens\n               for asking questions. I cannot support a bill that makes it easier for governments to say no. As a responsible\n               advocate for my constituents, I want it to be easier for citizens to get answers and\n               have government more accountable, not less accountable. Many in the past have fought\n               for our basic freedoms, and I believe in transparency, accountability, expanded oversight,\n               as well as that decentralization is foundational to democracy. It goes without saying\n               that I strongly oppose this bill. I am not alone though. Jason Woywada, the executive director for the Freedom of Information and Privacy Association, stated:\n               \"You cannot fix systemic information management problems by weakening public access\n               rights.\" Mike Larsen, president of the Freedom of Information and Privacy Association: \"This is worse\n               than a missed opportunity. Successive governments receive clear advice on gaps in\n               the act and then completely disregard the guidance.\" Another one. Let's skip down here. Canadian Association of Journalists: \"Restrictions\n               on access of information undermines freedom of the press and the public's ability\n               to monitor government actions.\" Canadian Association of Journalists: \"Access to information laws are essential tools\n               for holding governments accountable.\" Like I said, I definitely would have to oppose this bill, and I thank you for the\n               opportunity to debate it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361205","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'll pick up where I left off the other day. Bill 9, Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026 sounds\n               really good, but like I specified the other day, not good. It's probably the opposite of what it sounds like. The Freedom of Information Protection\n               and Privacy Amendment Act is a bill nothing like the title indicates. I'm glad that\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7ec8af8c915d021d18bca4942a833bcdb48e86f0c727c98058964ebbd45c7afd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6dbf604184a4560aebc4482757988ef5fdb085e2133cd21a81f61da127a923b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9ab21e7349348e4883b3c87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361206,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today marks World Plumbing Day, a day that recognizes something that many of us rarely\n               think about. Plumbing is foundational to modern public health and community infrastructure.\n               Clean water, safe sanitation and reliable plumbing systems are not luxuries. They\n               are essential services that prevent disease, protect our environment and keep our\n               communities functioning. World Plumbing Day was established to highlight the vital connection between plumbing,\n               sanitation and public health. Behind these systems are tradespeople whose work keeps\n               homes, schools, hospitals and businesses operating across B.C. Most of the time, we\n               don't even think about plumbing at all, but as any homeowner quickly learns when there's\n               a plumbing issue, it suddenly becomes the most important item on the agenda. Unlike\n               government, plumbing is a profession where people prevent leaks and cut red tape. Most of the time, the World Plumbing Council is encouraging plumbing professionals\n               to mark the day by wearing blue — which happens to be my favourite colour — to recognize\n               the essential work of plumbing professionals around the world. In rural communities,\n               these skilled trades are especially important. When something goes wrong with our\n               water systems, our septic systems or local infrastructure, it is often local plumbers\n               and trades professionals who step in to solve the problem quickly and safely. World Plumbing Day is also a reminder of the importance of encouraging young people\n               to pursue careers in the skilled trades. British Columbia faces labour shortages in\n               many trades, and plumbers are among the professionals who will help build and maintain\n               the infrastructure our province will rely on in the future. I would like to recognize and thank the plumbers and tradespeople throughout British\n               Columbia, including those working every day in Salmon Arm, Armstrong and communities\n               around the Shuswap and North Okanagan, for the essential work they do. On World Plumbing\n               Day, let's take a moment to recognize the people who keep our water clean, our communities\n               healthy and our province moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361206","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today marks World Plumbing Day, a day that recognizes something that many of us rarely\n               think about. Plumbing is foundational to modern public health and community infrastructure.\n               Clean water, safe sanitation and reliable plumbing systems are not luxuries. They\n               are essential services that prevent disease, protect our environment and keep our\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dd0739429c10aa95421d3873d3f34c45b19c03a4e8e4ae084e0b019e00a128a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["558174be89b1e3f902efcb0d3d49f7572843d4cac6c9a0a2d8491b6eaf5d32de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90cf5e8330ba4e8ab98ac1b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361207,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have three generations of family here. First off, my spouse, Denise, who does\n               all the work when I'm away here in Victoria. Accompanying her is her mom, Caroline.\n               It's Caroline's 90th birthday tomorrow. She'll be 90 years young tomorrow. Accompanying\n               her is her eldest granddaughter, Amanda. Please welcome them. Welcome. Also, happy birthday to Caroline.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361207","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I have three generations of family here. First off, my spouse, Denise, who does\n               all the work when I'm away here in Victoria. Accompanying her is her mom, Caroline.\n               It's Caroline's 90th birthday tomorrow. She'll be 90 years young tomorrow. Accompanying\n               her is her eldest granddaughter, Amanda. Please welcome them. Welcome. Also, happy birthday to Ca","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["756660483c98a04cadabc71844a8b345dd621f0d60eee1ee578d996cf6ac37e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd8fe02e7100a0d6c68d74a968143ee7670bc568b2902ffcf0727dc612b74897"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8320e7a6de7fb47f33a0983d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415857,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Wildfire has become one of the important challenges facing communities across our\n               province, especially in rural communities like those in the Shuswap and throughout\n               the Interior. In recent years, British Columbians have seen the devastating impact of wildfires.\n               Entire communities have faced evacuation. Families have lost homes. Businesses have\n               been disrupted. The economic and emotional toll has been enormous. In response to these growing risks, programs like FireSmart community funding and\n               supports program have become an important part of our wildfire prevention strategy.\n               FireSmart is built on a simple principle. Wildfire resistance requires preparation\n               at every level — governments, communities and individual homeowners. Through this program, local governments and First Nations can access funding for wildfire\n               risk assessments, public education, community planning and mitigation work designed\n               to reduce the risk to homes and infrastructure being lost during wildfire events. Research shows that FireSmart measures can significantly reduce the likelihood of\n               structure ignition. In other words, forest management and proactive mitigation matter,\n               but this requires sustained investment and long-term planning. Budget 2026 includes approximately $15 million in additional funding for the FireSmart\n               program. On the surface, this may sound great, but in reality, it functions largely\n               as a short-term top-up to a program that was already running out of funds. Recent changes have also moved the program toward a more competitive intake process,\n               limiting projects to a single-year funding cycle, and narrowed the scope of eligibility\n               activities in some areas. Short-term grants simply do not provide the certainty required\n               for long-term resilience. Demand for a Fire Smart funding far exceeds the available\n               resources, with organizations competing against one another for very limited funding. We must recognize that many of the communities facing the greatest wildfire risk are\n               smaller rural communities. These communities often have limited staff capacity, fewer\n               resources and smaller tax bases, yet they are directly impacted. In regions like the\n               Shuswap, communities are surrounded by forests that support tourism, recreation and\n               local economies, but those same forests also increase wildfire exposure. That is why the FireSmart programs are so important. They help communities reduce\n               the risk before disaster strikes. They help homeowners understand what steps they\n               can take to protect their properties, and increasingly, they also matter in another\n               area — insurance. The Insurance Bureau of Canada and others have warned that wildfire risk is beginning\n               to influence the availability and the affordability of home insurance in parts of\n               the country. Insurers are increasingly looking at risk reduction measures when accessing\n               coverage. There's another point that must be made. British Columbia's climate policy is increasingly\n               being driven by ideology rather than reality. Since the catastrophic 2017 wildfire\n               season, wildfires in B.C. have been releasing enormous amounts of carbon into the\n               atmosphere. In some years, wildfire emissions have exceeded B.C.'s total annual emissions\n               from transportation, industry and energy combined. Yet under current government accounting\n               rules, wildfire emissions are excluded because they are labelled \"natural disturbances.\"\n               But the atmosphere does not care about government frameworks. Carbon is carbon. While this NDP government focuses on emission and reduction policies that target families,\n               drivers and small businesses, catastrophic wildfires are one of the largest sources\n               of carbon released in severe years, yet they receive far less attention in climate\n               planning than they should. A single severe wildfire season can erase years, even decades,\n               of those reductions. If we truly care about the climate, then science tells us the solution must include A single severe wildfire season can erase years, even decades, of those reductions.\n               If we truly care about the climate, then science tells us the solution must include\n               serious forest management, fuel reduction and wildfire prevention. That is why communities\n               across this province continue to ask for long-term vision and investment necessary\n               to ensure that communities, both large and small, have the certainty and the fire\n               resilience ability.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415857","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Wildfire has become one of the important challenges facing communities across our\n               province, especially in rural communities like those in the Shuswap and throughout\n               the Interior. In recent years, British Columbians have seen the devastating impact of wildfires.\n               Entire communities have faced evacuation. Families have lost homes. Businesses have\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","label":"Forest fires","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01e96cd0aed27d891488f755bf6edcdf69dd3a806c53b41054b35d38b62ca0d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c588b31e67bebbf260cd6a0ef4b7432e96cb126339af62ca00eec736e0e3b6e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest fires","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41850","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7209a64fc07ba71ae8cc1be","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721759,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the truly special community initiative in my constituency\n               of Salmon Arm–Shuswap, the Sicamous Ferry Society and its free pedestrian ferry service across the Sicamous Narrows. What makes this service so special is that it is about more than simply getting from\n               one side to the other. It captures something of the country charm and welcoming spirit\n               that make small communities like Sicamous so remarkable. For residents, it offers a practical and enjoyable way to access Sicamous Beach Park and the Shuswap North Okanagan Rail Trail. For visitors, it adds a unique adventure\n               to their day, a scenic and distinct local experience on the water that reflects the\n               beauty, warmth and character of the There is something timeless and inviting about it. It is the kind of simple but meaningful\n               experience that feels right at home in rural British Columbia. It brings people together,\n               supports local businesses, encourages active transportation and gives both residents\n               and tourists a chance to enjoy a relaxed, friendly atmosphere that makes Sicamous\n               such a wonderful place to visit and live. What stands out the most is how this came together. In the face of a disruption and\n               change caused by the Trans-Canada Highway bridge replacement, the people of Sicamous\n               did what small towns so often do best. They stepped up, worked together and created\n               something special for the whole community. That speaks volumes about the generosity,\n               ingenuity and pride of the people who call Sicamous home. I want to thank the Sicamous Ferry Society, its volunteers, organizers and community\n               parties for making this possible. This ferry is more than a service. It's a reflection\n               of the country charm, the community pride, neighbourly spirit that makes small towns\n               so special. For the people of Sicamous, you should be very proud.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721759","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the truly special community initiative in my constituency\n               of Salmon Arm–Shuswap, the Sicamous Ferry Society and its free pedestrian ferry service across the Sicamous Narrows. What makes this service so special is that it is about more than simply getting from\n               one side to the other. It captures something of the country charm and welcoming spir","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf3652b9172b8a46da4b2759f36f10d191ff0b82e2a4554ccaa7c96486cfcb41"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee96da4adde2fdbce777faf198bdac347d4a11d69cc6fc9db7ef85d8832192f3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db7ad7b6611602c5487a9067","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721764,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's not often I have visitors coming from my riding, but I would also like to welcome\n               Salmon Arm councillor Louise Wallace Richmond and her husband, Dave. I certainly hope\n               they have enjoyed their trip, and I certainly hope they enjoy question period today. Please, everybody, give them a warm welcome. I would also like to make a second introduction. I would also like to welcome my friend\n               Andrew, better known as Drew Vancouver, to the Legislature today. Andrew has worked since 1998 as an addiction, alcohol and drug intervention advocate,\n               bringing more than 25 years of front-line experience to this important work. For 21\n               years, he was contracted with the Ministry of Children and Family Development in Vancouver,\n               where he helped to operate group and foster homes supporting more than 900 placements. Drew has become well known for speaking candidly about addiction, mental health and\n               homelessness in British Columbia. He has also helped shine the light on the work of\n               the police, firefighters and paramedics, while drawing greater public attention to\n               the challenges facing vulnerable people and the communities around them. He brings\n               valuable front-line insight, deep experience and a strong commitment to public awareness. Please join me in extending Andrew a warm welcome to this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721764","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's not often I have visitors coming from my riding, but I would also like to welcome\n               Salmon Arm councillor Louise Wallace Richmond and her husband, Dave. I certainly hope\n               they have enjoyed their trip, and I certainly hope they enjoy question period today. Please, everybody, give them a warm welcome. I would also like to make a second introduction. I would also like ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083647","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Foster care placement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083647","label":"Foster care placement","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9bed8acc1a0df7d4d051af6e75545587ccc8c9dd99f0fc459e020da8ef3a3dd7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c2a403d1f9ebca53ac0527a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752373,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to speak about the invisible people of British Columbia. Who are these\n               invisible people? They are present in every community, every town and in every riding. They are the people directly affected by government policy, taxation, service failures,\n               health care delays and the rising cost of living. Yet too often, their voices are\n               absent when decisions are made. They are not invisible because they do not matter.\n               They are invisible because government fails to see them. They are people on disability They are not invisible because they do not matter. They are invisible because government\n               fails to see them. They are people on disability assistance who are expected to survive in one of the\n               most expensive provinces in Canada on supports that do not reflect the real cost of\n               rent, food, transportation, medication and basic daily needs. This government often\n               speaks about compassion, but too many people with disabilities are left in a system\n               that is not compassionate, not realistic and not fair. They are families with children with autism and other special needs who face uncertainty\n               — long waits, confusing rules and constant pressure to prove their child deserves\n               support. These parents are not asking for special treatment. They're asking for stability,\n               fairness and support that meets the needs of their loved ones. They are seniors on fixed incomes who worked their entire lives, paid their taxes,\n               raised families and built our communities. Now they find themselves squeezed between\n               housing costs, medical costs, food costs and tax changes. Many simply want to age\n               with dignity in the homes that they worked so hard to afford. Under this government,\n               even that's becoming harder. They are low-income renters and people at risk of becoming homeless. The government\n               says it is fighting poverty, but more than words are required. For many people, this\n               is the difference between stability and eviction, between having a door to lock at\n               night and sleeping in a tent, a vehicle or a shelter bed that may or may not be available. They are people that are currently experiencing homelessness only noticed when they\n               are seen as a problem. They need housing, but they also may need special mental health\n               care, addiction treatment, safety and a path back to stability. They are people struggling with addiction and mental health challenges, too often\n               invisible until they are in crisis. Families are desperate, first responders are overwhelmed\n               and communities are frustrated, for those suffering are trapped between stigma, illness,\n               addiction and a government response that has failed to provide timely treatment, recovery\n               or hope. They are patients waiting for care, seniors, rural residents, struggling families\n               and those requiring specialized treatment. They are waiting for a family doctor; waiting\n               in emergency rooms, if those emergency rooms are even open; waiting for surgery, before\n               it's too late; waiting for mental health supports; waiting for care that is close\n               to home. The NDP government promised health care would get better, but too many British claimants\n               are still waiting for the results. In rural communities like the North Okanagan and\n               Shuswap, people know what being overlooked is like. They live it when services are\n               centralized elsewhere, health care is harder to access, transportation is limited,\n               affordable housing is scarce, broadband is unreliable and government programs are\n               designed in Victoria without fully understanding rural life. This is the problem. The NDP has become very good at announcements, slogans, press\n               conferences and photo opportunities. But compassion is not measured in announcements.\n               It is measured in outcomes. It is measured by whether people can find a doctor, afford\n               a home, access treatment and live with dignity. Too many invisible people are being left behind. The senior choosing between groceries\n               and medication is not better off. A person with a disability trying to find housing\n               is not better off. A parent with a child with autism fearing the loss of support is\n               not better off. The low-income renter facing eviction is not better off. The patient\n               waiting for care is not better off. The person suffering addiction who cannot access\n               timely treatment when they are ready is not better off. Leadership is measured by not how a government serves the loudest voices, the most\n               connected....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752373","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I rise to speak about the invisible people of British Columbia. Who are these\n               invisible people? They are present in every community, every town and in every riding. They are the people directly affected by government policy, taxation, service failures,\n               health care delays and the rising cost of living. Yet too often, their voices are\n               absent when de","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a7a2d9712293b1a6cd05c4d95d7760adfe86676578bc005d019a05d40cd8bd0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["068d56b99293fda8ae8b88aa226a43783a0fbd031799ccb8797501952758199a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9f6ddb5c15cf25821ddfbf2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752374,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise late this evening to speak in support of the hoist motion before this House.\n               The motion would amend the motion for second reading of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting\n               \"six months hence.\" In plain language, this hoist amendment asks that Bill 9 not proceed to second reading\n               today but, instead, be delayed six months. I think that's fairly reasonable. That\n               is a reasonable request. It's a responsible request. It's also a democratic request. This motion is not a rejection of the principle that our freedom-of-information and\n               privacy laws should be reviewed, it's not a rejection of modernization, and it's not\n               a rejection of the need for public bodies to operate efficiently. It is not a rejection\n               of privacy protection, digital service delivery or better administration. What this hoist amendment says is simple. When government brings forward legislation\n               that touches the public's right to know, the privacy of citizens and the obligations\n               of public bodies, the power of government to share personal information and the ability\n               of public institutions to refuse or disregard access requests, this House should not\n               rush. It should pause. It should review. It should consult. It should get the legislation\n               right. There are many examples in public life where a delay and a sober second thought or\n               further consultation will have prevented unintended consequences. I think we deal\n               with a lot of that lately in the news. When legislation affects democratic rights,\n               the duty of this House is even higher. British Columbians would understand that. In\n               fact, I believe most British Columbians would expect that. That is why this hoist amendment is appropriate. A six-month delay is not extreme,\n               it's not obstruction for the sake of obstruction, and it's not a delay for the sake\n               of a delay. It's a practical period of time that would allow government to do what\n               should have been done before this bill was introduced. It would allow meaningful consultation\n               with the Information and Privacy Commissioner, journalists, local governments, Indigenous\n               governments, public bodies, researchers, civil society organizations, privacy experts,\n               legal experts, and ordinary British Columbians who depend on access to information. It would allow this House to review government's proposed amendments carefully and\n               determine whether they actually solve the concerns that have been raised. It would\n               allow members to compare the bill against recommendations of the 2022 special committee.\n               It would allow us to ask whether this legislation strengthens transparency or weakens\n               it. Freedom of information is not a technical side issue. It is not a bureaucratic inconvenience.\n               It is not a favour the government grants to those requesting it when it feels like\n               doing so. Freedom of information is one of the practical ways citizens hold government\n               accountable between elections. Freedom of information is one of the practical ways citizens hold government accountable\n               between elections. It allows people to understand why decisions were made, who was\n               consulted, what alternatives were considered, how public money was spent, what risks\n               were identified and whether promises made publicly match decisions made behind closed\n               doors — much, much too much of that. When the right is narrowed, delayed, complicated\n               or made more difficult to exercise, the public loses more than access to documents.\n               The public loses confidence. Public records do not belong to the government; they\n               belong to the people of British Columbia. It gives this House the opportunity to pause and ask whether Bill 9 as drafted and\n               even as amended meets the standard that British Columbians should expect. Does it\n               make access clearer? Does it make government more accountable? Does it protect privacy\n               while preserving the public's right to know? Does it give applicants confidence that\n               public bodies will respond fairly? Does it provide precise definitions and objective\n               standards? Does it implement the work of the 2022 special committee in a serious and\n               balanced way? Or does it tilt the system further toward government inconvenience?\n               These are exactly the kinds of questions that justify a six-month delay. The hoist\n               amendment gives this House time to answer them properly, before changing the rules\n               that govern public access to public information. The government has already tabled amendments to Bill 9. That fact alone should give every member\n               in this House pause and reflection. If the government had to clarify its intent only\n               after a short period of public debate, then six months of proper consultation is not\n               unreasonable. It is the responsible thing to do. The problem is that the proposed government amendments do not resolve the fundamental\n               concerns. They may adjust wording. They may narrow certain phrases. They may attempt\n               to reassure the public. But they do not remove the broad discretion that Bill 9 creates.\n               They do not fully define vague terms. They do not restore public confidence that access\n               will be timely. They do not ensure that ordinary citizens will be protected, being\n               told that the requests are inadequate because they do not know the internal filing\n               system of a ministry, a health authority, a school district, a Crown corporation or\n               a municipality. They do not provide the clear safeguards that should exist before\n               government expands the circumstances in which requests can be disregarded. That is why the hoist amendment remains necessary, even after the government amendments.\n               The fact that the government has tried to patch the bill does not mean that the bill\n               is ready. It means that the bill needs more work, and six months would allow that\n               work to be done properly. Clause 2 is a clear example. The clause deals with the adequacy of a request. On its\n               face, that may sound administrative. It may sound like a minor technical matter. But\n               for an ordinary citizen trying to obtain information from government, it matters a\n               great deal. The concern is that the adequacy of a request is still left, in important aspects,\n               to the broad opinion of the head of the public body. It also relies on a standard\n               involving what an experienced employee could identify with reasonable effort and in\n               a reasonable amount of time. Those phrases sound practical, but they are not clearly\n               defined. They create uncertainty for applicants. They create discretion for the institution\n               holding the records. They create the possibility that a citizen may be told their\n               request is not good enough, not because the records do not exist but because the public\n               body decides that the request is not framed....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752374","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise late this evening to speak in support of the hoist motion before this House.\n               The motion would amend the motion for second reading of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting\n               \"six months hence.\" In plain language, this hoist amendment asks that Bill 9 not proceed ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8269183307997125d21240166c69d5a9e79484e0fac5aff21ba426fb6303ee0c","1054d02ad81f108874a30235c9cdba9704e940a96804476f3106c882e46d86b3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["111c8af04f8e81b91b1779ce0a73012c37c7e5de8f3fa7b9eb37d762d2d9a067"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21ba63c9052e915fb0ce21b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752375,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today up in the gallery I have someone very special here visiting, and that would\n               be my spouse. She's the one that takes care of everything when we're here back at\n               home. She came down early yesterday afternoon. We had a really great evening planned, but\n               we know how that went. It was kind of an epic journey. Please welcome her to the House today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752375","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today up in the gallery I have someone very special here visiting, and that would\n               be my spouse. She's the one that takes care of everything when we're here back at\n               home. She came down early yesterday afternoon. We had a really great evening planned, but\n               we know how that went. It was kind of an epic journey. Please welcome her to the House today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dad01d2589967d4a568d65ab93496fc45a2058dfce9f8bc15d5525e07a63b790"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39be8e78c7d7ac802dd8656f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017709,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"As everybody knows, when we're here in the chamber here and in Victoria, there are\n               people at home that do a lot of the work behind the scenes. I'd just like to wish\n               a happy birthday to my biggest supporter, and that would be my spouse, Denise. I am\n               wishing you a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017709","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As everybody knows, when we're here in the chamber here and in Victoria, there are\n               people at home that do a lot of the work behind the scenes. I'd just like to wish\n               a happy birthday to my biggest supporter, and that would be my spouse, Denise. I am\n               wishing you a happy birthday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d534c769900951195916ab2efa41f1b612036e40d2eb9cfe5a259db4013fef3d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b80723edb35a0e70eaf0fcd0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017718,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"David Williams","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill intituled Small Farms Act, of which notice has been given in\n               my name on the Order Paper, be introduced and read for the first time now. I rise today to introduce the Small Farms Act. Across British Columbia, small farms\n               are family livelihoods, local food producers, community anchors and an important part\n               of our food security. Too often, the rules governing agricultural land do not reflect\n               the realities facing small producers. This bill gives small farms and small farming cooperatives clearer, practical tools\n               to remain viable while keeping the primary use of agricultural land focused on farming.\n               The bill defines a small farm as one with annual growth revenues not exceeding $750,000,\n               derived from primary production or on-site processing. It also recognizes small farming\n               cooperatives, allowing small The bill defines a small farm as one with annual growth revenues not exceeding $750,000 derived from primary production or on-site processing. It also recognizes small farming cooperatives, allowing small producers to work together on production, processing and marketing. A key purpose of this bill is to support value-added agriculture. Many small farms cannot survive on primary production alone. They need\n               the ability to make jam from berries, cheese from milk, cider from apples, or other\n               farm-based products that help them earn a sustainable income. The bill also recognizes limited agritourism as a permitted use, providing that primary use remains farming and the activity is\n               directly connected to the farm's products or practices. That means farm tours, educational visits, tastings, workshops and similar activities\n               that help connect British Columbians with the people who grow their food. At the same time, the bill protects agricultural\n               land. For farms, agritourism accommodation would be restricted to three sleeping units and limited for seasonal or short-term use. The intent is farm support, not turning agricultural land into commercial accommodations. Finally, the bill requires the minister to publish an annual food production report outlining progress towards increasing B.C.-grown food and strategies to strengthen provincial food production capacity. This bill is about practical support for small farms, stronger local food systems and responsible stewardship of agricultural land. It gives farmers the room to innovate\n               while keeping farming at the centre. I look forward to consideration of this bill by the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017718","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that the bill intituled Small Farms Act, of which notice has been given in\n               my name on the Order Paper, be introduced and read for the first time now. I rise today to introduce the Small Farms Act. Across British Columbia, small farms\n               are family livelihoods, local food producers, community anchors and an important part\n               of our food security. Too of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be94cf4c54a6e7ea06c1db1119848a92d0fb16593e67a764dfad49e94b7a6246"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b764fe467b2f284b5d986f6a2bb058a4a985480d0268c014cd130b5402905ca5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-464fe944dd18d5a870993110","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933908,"date":"2026-05-21T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SMALL FARMS ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m246-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m246-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933908","member_id":"bc-mla-397","member_name":"David Williams","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d3729eb34f138af90873b7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317189,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Kitimat Valley Housing Society, which is run entirely by seniors, has spent over\n               a year trying to build seniors housing in a community with no long-term-care capacity,\n               where seniors are trapped in homes that are too large to manage or apartments that\n               they physically cannot access. They had to spend $18,000 on the mandatory audits that were required just to qualify\n               for the community housing fund, not to mention all of the other money that has already\n               been invested into this project. They were relying on that funding to make the project\n               viable. Now this government has cut $1.4 billion from that fund, effectively killing the seniors\n               housing project. Why did this government decide that housing for seniors in northern\n               B.C. wasn't a priority this year?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317189","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"The Kitimat Valley Housing Society, which is run entirely by seniors, has spent over\n               a year trying to build seniors housing in a community with no long-term-care capacity,\n               where seniors are trapped in homes that are too large to manage or apartments that\n               they physically cannot access. They had to spend $18,000 on the mandatory audits that were required ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f4183767b4e095ce976c102e8332c954542ae2841f6d923b432e7c420bdbdf7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["89c60520b138d15ddc3bb9e0adc11ed690b77ee224701ab4ffd27ce27e4b0e67"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cbcdbfcac09eecfbff7717cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317190,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today is the second time that I've had the privilege of speaking to the budget in\n               this House on behalf of the residents of Skeena. I'd like to start by sincerely thanking them for their trust in me and the ability\n               to represent them in this House and to fight for them. It's been a real honour to\n               serve them over the last year and a half. It's been a difficult adjustment for me, obviously, as a first-time MLA. I really\n               want to thank my family for their patience and their unwavering support; thank my\n               staff, both in my constituency office, all of my staff here in the Legislature and\n               the staff at home that are holding down the fort at our tattoo shop and making me\n               proud every single day. There are two people I want to thank specifically — my CA, Chelsea, for her hard work\n               and her dedication to this role, for jumping in headfirst. She's been my greatest\n               asset as I continue to serve my constituents. Most of all, I want to thank my spouse, Colton. He's the best man I've ever known,\n               and he has stood by my side during one of the most challenging and exciting periods\n               that we have ever experienced together. As we've adjusted to what this role means, including many long days away from home,\n               he has been my rock, and I cannot express how much that means to me. A year ago I\n               didn't think I could love him any more than I already did, but this past year has\n               shown me that that connection goes even deeper than I ever thought possible. I couldn't do this without all of you, and I am forever grateful for your faith in\n               me. I couldn't do this without all of you, and I'm forever grateful for your faith in\n               me and for all of your help. Sadly, today, as I'm rising to speak to the budget, it's a budget that makes the wrong\n               choices at the wrong time. It's a budget that raises costs while families are already\n               stretched. It delays housing when communities are desperate. It talks about growth\n               while abandoning forestry. It speaks about fairness while squeezing rural and northern\n               British Columbia. In my riding of Skeena, people are not looking for slogans. They are looking for delivery. The core test of any budget is simple. Does it make life more affordable, services\n               more reliable and community stronger? This one does not. Let's begin with affordability. The government has increased income taxes and frozen\n               bracket indexation. That means that even modest wage growth gets clawed back through\n               inflation-driven bracket creep. It means people pay more without even realizing it. Freezing income tax brackets for three years will undo any wage growth that we might\n               see. The minimum wage is set to increase this year, but what that might have meant\n               for people that are struggling to get by will no longer matter. Then we see the expansion of PST, not onto luxury items but onto basics — things like\n               landlines, basic cable, clothing and shoe repair. When families are trying to save\n               money by repairing instead of replacing, this government taxes the repair. When children's coats get holes in them, in my community, we have them mended. When\n               workers get holes in their boots, they have them mended. This is an attack on not\n               only a more sustainable choice but often a fiscally necessary one. When families in rural communities rely on landlines because cell service is unreliable,\n               this government adds 7 percent. When small businesses hire accountants, bookkeepers,\n               architects, engineers or security guards, this government adds 7 percent. This is not affordability. The Finance Minister said the other day that some people on our side of the House\n               claim to be business owners. I picked up on the insult that it was. I want to remind\n               that minister that I am a business owner. I actually know what it's like to struggle\n               to make payroll, and I actually know what it's like to struggle to understand our\n               tax system. Now small business owners will be penalized for trying to make sure that they are\n               tax compliant. Or worse, they will risk navigating this system themselves. Seven percent adds up. The fact that the Finance Minister so flippantly dismisses\n               that makes me think that she doesn't understand what it's like to run a business on\n               razor-thin margins like most businesses these days do. Adding 7 percent to the cost of security services is a particular slap in the face\n               to both businesses and apartment tenants alike, especially in urban areas. This soft-on-crime\n               government has allowed crime to run rampant. Now they see a golden opportunity to\n               dig into the pockets of British Columbians. Let's be clear about the housing implications of this budget. You do not lower the\n               cost of housing by taxing the services that are required to build housing. You do\n               not help renters by increasing the operating costs of rental property management and\n               security. These costs do not disappear. They get passed along. Adding another 7 percent to the cost of professional services that are crucial to\n               new construction does not encourage new development, and adding it to building and\n               strata management does not help renters. In this budget, the government also decided to effectively cancel the community housing\n               fund. In Kitimat, a volunteer-run seniors housing society worked for years to move\n               a project forward. The municipality put in $75,000 of municipal tax base for seed\n               money. The society spent $18,000 just to complete the mandatory audits that they had\n               to, to apply for the community housing fund. The community rallied, plans were drawn and momentum was building. Then the province\n               pulled the funding. You cannot solve housing by cancelling housing. This is a $1.4 billion cut. The minister\n               can call it whatever she wants, but the reality is that this is a cut. They are reallocating\n               $1.4 billion from this fund, which means that housing will not get built. In northern communities, seniors housing is not a political talking point. It is the\n               difference between aging in place and leaving town, leaving children, grandchildren,\n               the life that you've built, the community that you love. It is the difference between\n               dignity and isolation. When seniors housing is delayed or cancelled, the ripple effect\n               hits families, hospitals and entire communities. We have next to no long-term care capacity in my riding. These projects are the only\n               lifeline to save our hospitals from their breaking point. The government is not taking\n               that seriously. Housing is a provincial responsibility. It is one that this government is more than\n               happy to shirk off onto municipalities, yet another downloading of responsibilities. In Terrace, when B.C. Housing approached the municipality looking for land to build\n               housing on, the municipality gladly offered up every piece of residential land that\n               they had, for free and serviced, on the simple promise of making up In Terrace, when B.C. Housing approached the municipality looking for land to build\n               housing on, the municipality gladly offered up every piece of residential land that\n               they had, for free and serviced, on the simple promise of making up for the lost land\n               and potential revenues through taxation. What did B.C. Housing do? They turned around and they had all low-income housing designated\n               as zero value. Municipalities like Terrace can increase taxes all they want, but any\n               percentage of zero is still going to be zero. These are the thanks that they get for trying to support the provincial government\n               in the mess that they created. Now they're left with no undeveloped land for residential\n               use. The government won't even look at offering them any Crown land in return. Terrace is a community with an effectively zero percent vacancy rate. How are they\n               supposed to meet the demand that has been created by a cost-of-living crisis that\n               this government helped to create? There is nothing to address these issues in this\n               budget — just more cuts. Rates of homelessness in northern B.C. vastly outpace those in Vancouver and Victoria.\n               Here in Victoria, one in 252 people is homeless. In Vancouver, it's one in 278; in\n               greater Vancouver, it's one in 594. In Kitimat, it's one in 131; and in Terrace, one\n               in 94. One in 94 people living in Terrace do not have a home. They do not have a roof\n               over their heads. They live up north in one of the coldest and wettest climates in this province, and\n               yet they have to sleep unsheltered, in a vehicle or, in rare cases of luck, on someone\n               else's couch for a few nights. This is unacceptable. That means that a resident of Terrace is almost seven times more likely to be homeless\n               than a resident of greater Vancouver, yet this government figured it was a good time\n               to make affordable and low-income housing even harder to access. We can't even get\n               a permanent shelter in Kitimat, a community that is consistently cold with severe\n               weather three-quarters of the year. Again, this is not a government that is taking this crisis seriously. Cancelling this\n               year's intake for the community housing fund shows very clearly that this government\n               does not understand the gravity of this crisis, and it shows that they certainly do\n               not understand the gravity of it in northern B.C. When somebody living in Terrace\n               is almost seven times more likely to be unhoused than somebody living in the greater\n               Vancouver area, we have a very serious problem that deserves attention from this government. In this budget, we also see a large number of long-term-care projects that have been\n               shifted to TBC. We don't know if that means \"to be confirmed,\" \"to be continued\" or\n               \"to be cancelled,\" but TBC is not a plan. In northern and rural British Columbia, when long-term care is delayed, seniors don't\n               just wait longer. They travel farther. Families are forced to separate. Care beds\n               are occupied by people who should be in long-term care. Emergency rooms back up. This\n               puts strain on our hospitals, and it puts strain on our communities. This is not theoretical;\n               it is happening right now, in real time. Our hospitals have seen the burden of this firsthand. There's no capacity left between\n               the lack of long-term care and the need to house psychiatric patients in acute care\n               beds because there is nowhere else for them to go. We have people in Kitimat that\n               should be in a psychiatric bed and that have been taking up space in an acute care\n               bed in our hospital because there's nowhere for the health care professionals to send\n               them. Some of these people are ones that will be taken advantage of if they are turned out\n               and back onto the street. I know many of them. I've seen them get taken advantage\n               of. It should concern every single member of the government that there is nowhere\n               for people to go when they're in that situation, particularly in northern and rural\n               British Columbia. There was a very elderly couple in my riding recently that reached out for help. The\n               husband has terminal cancer. He's not doing well. He should be in a hospital setting\n               or in palliative care. There is nowhere for him to go right now in my riding. His\n               elderly wife is caring for him at home, with only one day a week of respite care.\n               Can you imagine being elderly and caring for your dying husband in your home, because\n               there is nowhere for you to go, and you get one day a week of respite care? One of the ministers made a comment yesterday — or maybe it was the Premier; I can't\n               remember — about how it used to be that seniors, when they were in long-term care,\n               were only getting one shower or one bath a week. This couple is getting one day a\n               week of respite care. So you can imagine what that means for them. This situation\n               has not improved. It's not something to take a victory lap on. The issues that we've had in my community around home care The issues that we've had in my community around home care and home nursing are appalling.\n               I know people with permanent brain injuries that only get to leave their house twice\n               a week because of the shortage of workers to be able to care for them, help them,\n               take them to go grocery shopping and go to medical appointments — the very basics. Both of the elderly people, both of this couple, are losing their memory, and their\n               health is suffering terribly. My office can't even get a reply from the minister's\n               office. So I have to ask: how is this a budget that is helping seniors? What am I\n               supposed to tell this elderly couple the next time I speak with them? \"Sorry, your\n               government doesn't care enough about you to make investments in the basics that you\n               need and that you deserve.\" The property tax deferral system is another place that we see seniors being shafted\n               in this budget. This is a program that was introduced to support seniors who are forced\n               to age in place, because this government has no other solution for them. Imagine being\n               a senior on a fixed income who paid their mortgage off years ago and bought their\n               home for hundreds of thousands of dollars less than what it is being assessed at right\n               now. Often these property taxes are enough that these seniors would not be able to\n               afford to stay in their homes. Now this government thought it was prudent to add an\n               extra 4 percent interest to those payments, and now it compounds monthly. The minister said that this was a good budget for seniors. I would like to know how\n               many have walked into her office thanking her for this. It's yet another slap in the\n               face to seniors. Homelessness among seniors is already at a record high. It's about\n               to get a whole lot worse, and this government should be ashamed of themselves. The government touts $131 million over three years for mental health and addictions.\n               They cite thousands of beds. But much of this is a continuation, not an expansion.\n               It says so in plain English in the budget. Just managing to keep up with the cost\n               of inflation is not making meaningful investments. Maybe the reason there is no investment\n               in net new beds in this budget is the same reason as the long-term-care cuts. The\n               government can't find a way to operate them at a cost per bed that they can afford.\n               Either way, tell that to the people that need these supports and services. Maybe if the government had made efforts to reduce the cost of doing business in B.C.,\n               new construction costs wouldn't be so heavily inflated. On the topic of beds, this budget cites roughly the same numbers of treatment beds\n               as there were last year. This is despite me repeatedly pointing out over the last\n               year and a bit that less than a third of them are actual treatment beds. Inflating\n               the numbers so it sounds better in a budget document or a press release, but with\n               no real substance.... It's very concerning to me that we're not seeing those investments. Like I said, this is just keeping up with rates of inflation. This is just continuing\n               to do the work that's already being done. It does not even begin to address the problems\n               that we're seeing right now in the way that publicly funded treatment beds are actually\n               being funded. The cost differs from health authority to health authority. Not one\n               of them actually covers the cost. Then we wonder why we have wait-lists as long as\n               we do. Those facilities have to prioritize private pay clients, because if not, they can't\n               keep the doors open. At the very least, that could have been addressed in this budget,\n               but it was not. At the same time, we see a $3 million reduction in mental health funding in the Ministry\n               of Children and Family Development's budget, a $3 million reduction, a $3 million\n               cut. This despite everyone on that side of the House knowing full well the crisis\n               that we find ourselves in right now. It is shameful where this government's priorities\n               are. Announcements are not beds. Headlines are not treatment. If we were serious about\n               mental health and addictions, we would see measurable net new capacity. Capacity in\n               detox, capacity in treatment, recovery beds that people can actually access today.\n               Instead, we see recycled announcements and incremental adjustments, a government that\n               likes to tinker around the edges but not actually accomplish anything meaningful. There is no plan in this budget to even begin to tackle the crisis that we face with\n               permanent brain injury, no plan to address the lack of psychiatric capacity, no mention\n               of the surgical and diagnostic wait times or a plan to address ER closures. These\n               things aren't even mentioned. In a riding like mine in Skeena, costs are simply higher. Construction costs more.\n               Heating costs more. Transportation costs more. Services are fewer, and alternatives\n               are limited. When the government removes rural supports and expands taxes onto basic\n               services, the impact is magnified. Outside of the Lower Mainland, you pay more, and this budget gives you less. The decision\n               to remove the rural and northern homeowner grant is a slap in the face to every single\n               British Columbian living outside of an urban centre; $200 a year means something to\n               most British Columbians. The rural-urban divide is a real problem, and these budget\n               priorities have clearly During question period I have frequently heard ministers responding to rural and northern\n               MLAs, including myself, by saying: \"Oh, well, we're even building things in ridings\n               that are held by the opposition. We're building things in ridings that are held by\n               members on that side of the House.\" What really kills me about that is.... As if that weren't already the bare minimum that\n               British Columbians should expect — that their government would provide them with the\n               same basic services and infrastructure as the rest of the province. But sadly, I suppose\n               it does need to be stated, because they certainly aren't delivering that right now. This cut takes away one of the small few things that actually benefited those of us\n               living outside of urban centres Again, this shows where the government's priorities\n               are. There are no new investments in this budget for my riding. Nothing to address\n               failing infrastructure, no upgrades to roads or to highways. I have residents in Thornhill who are out thousands of dollars right now trying to\n               save their property because the ministry didn't properly maintain drainage along the\n               highway. The ministry realizes and recognizes that this was their fault, but that\n               doesn't really do much to save the thousands of dollars that the residents of Thornhill\n               are now out for having to save their property. It took the Minister of Transportation three months just to respond to my letter inquiring\n               about the state of our highways. All I received was a copy-and-paste response after\n               sending multiple letters to his office. The minister should try driving my highways in the winter. He should try being a Nisg̱a'a resident of the Nass Valley and relying on Highway 113 to access groceries, or try\n               being a senior in Usk who relies on a cable car half the year, with no disability\n               access to reach basic medical care and medications, or a young family in the Kitimat\n               village that must be helicoptered out of their community when it snows too much because\n               the road is impassable and their child needs diapers This minister does not understand that reality, because he lives in a region where\n               transportation is rapid and accessible, where highway infrastructure is maintained\n               and where there are multiple routes to get to the same place. He cannot understand\n               the reality that my constituents face, or he chooses not to. Forestry revenues have fallen from $1.8 billion in 2022 to $500 million in this budget,\n               and 15,000 forestry jobs have been lost under this government. Not too long ago, this\n               government was touting that there would be 30,000 new jobs in forestry. The gap between\n               their wishful thinking and the reality is staggering. The forestry budget is cut by hundreds of millions of dollars. Fire-preparedness funding\n               is being reduced. The word \"forestry\" was not even mentioned in the budget speech.\n               This is an industry that built this province, and it wasn't even mentioned. You cannot grow the natural resource economy while ignoring forestry. Forestry is\n               not an abstraction in Skeena. It is paycheques. It is mortgages. It is whether small\n               towns survive, and forestry built communities like Terrace. Forestry is the resource\n               sector that many First Nations like Kitsumkalum and Kitselas are looking at to revive their community and drive revenues. This government\n               and this minister are not taking that seriously. Permit delays and photo ops seem to be the only thing coming out of that ministry\n               these days, and sadly, those photo ops seem to be the kiss of death for this industry.\n               I am sure that every mill that hears the minister is visiting must get a sense of\n               dread in their stomachs. On the topic of industry and resource development, this government loves to take a\n               victory lap whenever they can, but the reality right now is very simple. We have a\n               mismanaged budget, and we are in a fiscal crisis. Now, more than ever, we need a strong\n               resource and industrial sector. This is what will drive investment and good wages\n               that will help lessen the burden of the cost-of-living crisis and inject money back\n               into our economy. Sometimes that will require investment on the government's part. So I have to wonder\n               why this government didn't think it was prudent to invest in the airport industrial\n               lands owned by the city of Terrace and the Kitselas First Nation in this year's budget.\n               I know that the government is aware of the city of Terrace's ask to help them get\n               water to the property so that development could move forward. It's a great piece of\n               land that could be leveraged to drive investment. Yet again, my communities didn't\n               seem to make the cut in this year's budget. What this piece of land means for the Kitselas First Nation and for the city of Terrace\n               is monumental. This is the only piece of industrial-zoned property left in Terrace.\n               It is the only way for the city of Terrace to have some kind of industrial taxation. This is a community that is struggling due to the incompetence of this government\n               on the forestry file. They desperately need some new development in their community.\n               The only thing that's holding them back right now is the ability to get The Forests Minister also spoke, in his response to the budget, about $4.6 billion\n               invested in schools. He spoke about 140 new schools, and he spoke about 40,000 student\n               spaces. He spoke about duct-taped floors and mould and buckets catching water. And\n               I agree with him; it's unacceptable. So why is Mount Elizabeth Middle Secondary School in Kitimat, which has been flagged\n               for replacement since 2010 and is partially condemned, still waiting? Since 2010 this\n               is a project that has been flagged as needing to be replaced. It's been the top of\n               the list for our school district every single year since, but there is no plan. We're\n               waiting for some kind of review on it. I mean, this work should have started years\n               ago, but it didn't. If the minister can recite billions of dollars and dozens of projects, can he tell\n               the people of Kitimat when Mount Elizabeth Middle Secondary School will be built?\n               This is a school that is partially condemned. It has large steel structural support\n               beams in almost every classroom. The students themselves have told me that they are\n               embarrassed of their own school. I don't think that that impact can be overstated.\n               That's really unfair to these students. This is not a good learning environment for\n               them. They're embarrassed. Some of them are afraid. Parents have pulled their children from that school, and\n               major industries and health care have struggled to hire because of the egregious state\n               of that facility. It is our only middle and secondary school, and families do not\n               want to move to Kitimat because of it. The inability to recruit more staff has had\n               a significant impact on our community's viability. Don't lecture us about mould and duct tape while Kitimat students wait in a condemned\n               building. Again, at a time of fiscal prudence, where the government is concerned about revenues,\n               if ever there was a community that deserved some investment, it's communities like\n               Kitimat and Terrace. It's communities that are supporting these large resource development\n               projects that we need, that we rely on to be able to drive revenues, to create good\n               wage growth, good paying jobs. These revenues are so key to getting us out of this fiscal mess. When we don't even\n               have a school that parents want to send their children to in that community, how are\n               they supposed to recruit new people? How are they supposed to recruit the specialized\n               workers that they need to work in these facilities? How are we supposed to grow our\n               community? I wouldn't want to send my children there. I don't blame these parents\n               for making that choice. So why wasn't that school in this budget? Then there are the cuts to the individualized autism funding, cuts that this Premier\n               swore that he would never make. I want to be clear that I fully support expanding\n               access to include other children with diverse needs such as Down syndrome. I support\n               them being included in this funding, and frankly, this is work that should have been\n               done long ago. The issue is that it is at the expense of thousands of children that rely on that\n               funding and their families, families who are now determined by this government to\n               no longer need that funding. The minister said yesterday that this new system is fairer.\n               What is fairer about stripping a family of funding that they relied on for necessary\n               therapies to help their child succeed? I would like the minister to tell that to the hundreds of families that have reached\n               out to my inbox, pleading and terrified. We already have years-long wait-lists just\n               for diagnosis. The last thing we need to be doing right now is stripping these children\n               of their funding that they desperately need. It's not up to the government to determine\n               who has more needs versus others. If they have a diagnosis, they should be able to\n               access the funding. There's a fairer way to do this, and what's happening right now\n               by just cutting funding entirely for thousands of families is not it. Finally, I want to talk about the purpose behind this whole process of tabling a budget\n               and the opposition scrutinizing it. It's about transparency, ensuring that government\n               is held accountable by the people elected to represent the people that this budget\n               affects. Transparency is crucial. It's why changing completion timelines on projects from a\n               definitive year to TBC is so concerning. It erodes the trust that the public is meant\n               to have in their government in a functioning democratic society. That's why one of the most concerning aspects of this budget is the decision to scrap\n               the Office of the Merit Commissioner. It is sad that we are even in a position that one is needed, but based on the findings in his\n               reports, it is clearly That's why one of the most concerning aspects of this budget is the decision to scrap\n               the Office of the Merit Commissioner. It is sad that we are even in a position that\n               one is needed, but based on the findings in his reports, it is clearly more than necessary.\n               In fact, in a recent report, the Merit Commissioner stated that there was a significant\n               increase in non-merit-based hiring in the public sector since 2022. I'll say the quiet\n               part out loud. There was a significant increase in non-merit-based hirings in the\n               public sector since this Premier took office. I think that we've spoken a lot about the Office of the Merit Commissioner over the\n               last couple of days, and one thing that seems to have eluded the government on this\n               is that they think that we don't understand how the Office of the Merit Commissioner\n               works. But we do. I've met with the commissioner. We understand that it's to oversee\n               the public sector. The point we're trying to make is that not only should we not be removing it at this\n               point, but we should be expanding his powers to oversee these political appointments,\n               because clearly, most of them have not been hiring based on merit. Overall this is an austerity budget that helps no one, and hardworking, tax-paying\n               British Columbians are being asked to pay the price for this government's incompetence.\n               Projects have been shifted to TBC, reporting thresholds raised, contingency funds\n               expanded, new discretionary funds created. If this is fiscal discipline, why hide the details? Transparency builds trust, and\n               obscurity erodes it. This budget makes life more expensive. It delays housing. It\n               ignores northern industries. It leaves seniors uncertain. No strategy to address the\n               cost of living. No $1,000 grocery rebate that we were all promised, that this government\n               campaigned on and that helped them win an election. That's gone. No mention. Skeena deserves better. We deserve delivery, not drift. And we deserve timelines,\n               not TBC. We deserve policies that recognize northern realities, not one-size-fits-all\n               talking points. And we deserve relief. Relief from a disastrous government that has had nearly a decade\n               to start to meaningfully address the problems that they have created. Relief from\n               the constant and seemingly never-ending pressures of the rising cost of living. We will continue to hold this government to account, because our communities cannot\n               afford another year of excuses.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317190","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today is the second time that I've had the privilege of speaking to the budget in\n               this House on behalf of the residents of Skeena. I'd like to start by sincerely thanking them for their trust in me and the ability\n               to represent them in this House and to fight for them. It's been a real honour to\n               serve them over the last year and a half. It's been a diffi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b845a68c11203bd54cf64adf35a9ef1685e203f90588abe01ca951808814e945"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2871fc03c9aa3bdcbbdede9677d83ccdb69d938779757312d3605a96269a3da9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7af467cbca158f27edf97cf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317191,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"This Premier promised a $1,000 grocery rebate. He promised that we would have educational\n               assistance in every K-through-3 classroom. This Premier has promised a lot of things\n               that he hasn't delivered on. Instead, we've learned that this government has spent tens of thousands of taxpayer\n               dollars on gift cards for public service employees that are already making in excess\n               of $100,000 a year, far more in some cases, all while running a $13 billion deficit. This comes on the heels of the Minister of Instead, we've learned that this government has spent tens of thousands of taxpayer\n               dollars on gift cards for public service employees that are already making in excess\n               of $100,000 a year, far more in some cases, all while running a $13 billion deficit. This comes on the heels of the Minister of Finance taking a $44,000 taxpayer-funded\n               trip to Boston last year that included thousands on limos and fine dining. British Columbians are being told to tighten their belts. Why does the same discipline\n               never apply to this government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317191","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This Premier promised a $1,000 grocery rebate. He promised that we would have educational\n               assistance in every K-through-3 classroom. This Premier has promised a lot of things\n               that he hasn't delivered on. Instead, we've learned that this government has spent tens of thousands of taxpayer\n               dollars on gift cards for public service employees that are already","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f13e32b5cd02343f4863d6ca67d8c77404642932d64a06587c4bae33da42111"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9da61c150f0749786fc2b9be6f84f71df476ff4c8d5d670a745b906b6dc6b4f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8a0c280bb633cf1af5ffcf9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317192,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Ezra Cool was struck and killed by a semi-truck after he managed to somehow escape\n               from 24-7 supervision at Vernon Jubilee Hospital. He was only 22 years old, and he\n               voluntarily admitted himself to the hospital. He knew that he needed help. He underwent\n               an assessment, and he was certified under the Mental Health Act. Vernon's hospital experienced mass resignations of psychiatrists that have negatively\n               impacted patient oversight. Ezra did the right thing, and he asked for help, but this\n               government system failed him. B.C. desperately needs a dedicated psychiatric hospital. My question to the minister is, will she commit to building a psychiatric hospital\n               in B.C. today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317192","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Ezra Cool was struck and killed by a semi-truck after he managed to somehow escape\n               from 24-7 supervision at Vernon Jubilee Hospital. He was only 22 years old, and he\n               voluntarily admitted himself to the hospital. He knew that he needed help. He underwent\n               an assessment, and he was certified under the Mental Health Act. Vernon's hospital experienced mass r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a4b2453c2c5d39e6a9f60ee88b0a81ba5f06ad41b0eeaf72fce42392d256bf1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1dc638c608b1acb608fc150614f45d318d4d35a9ba6e7cd448f93d2810b49ab7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fbedb038a7dd93e003a3742b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328033,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"In November of 2024, this government decided to create a new Ministry of Infrastructure.\n               They moved the long-term-care responsibility out of the Ministry of Health into the\n               Ministry of Infrastructure, the building of them. Since then, not a single new long-term-care\n               facility has been completed, and nearly 1,200 beds have been cancelled now. To the Premier, if this new ministry cannot deliver even one completed long-term-care\n               home, can't provide a single solution to how to get the cost down or a single timeline\n               on when one will be built, why create an entirely new ministry and bureaucracy?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328033","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In November of 2024, this government decided to create a new Ministry of Infrastructure.\n               They moved the long-term-care responsibility out of the Ministry of Health into the\n               Ministry of Infrastructure, the building of them. Since then, not a single new long-term-care\n               facility has been completed, and nearly 1,200 beds have been cancelled now. To the Premi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["deb20c501bd0c1e0a619dfec78ce0f92c46e104036164605fcabb614dce9a178"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bcde2889bff5d372100bd2a0d921bb08106ed6a5c733f5f6a81cb222064dbbba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3a10e602681e79680d473fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328034,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"This weekend I participated in the Coldest Night of the Year walk in Terrace. The\n               Coldest Night of the Year is held in communities across Canada to raise awareness\n               and funds for local organizations that are serving those experiencing homelessness.\n               It's about walking together in solidarity with those who do not have the option of\n               going home to warmth at the end of the night. For me, this issue is not abstract. I have experienced homelessness myself. I understand,\n               personally, what it means to lack stability, to lack certainty and to lack a safe\n               place to sleep. I know how it feels to try to sleep when you're freezing cold, scared\n               and hopeless. Shelter is not simply about a roof. It is about dignity, safety and the foundation\n               that allows someone to rebuild their life. The inability to have a shower and a good\n               night's rest can be the barrier to employment opportunities, education and good mental\n               health. In northern British Columbia, the reality is stark. In many of our communities, people\n               are nearly six times more likely to be unhoused than in greater Vancouver. In Terrace,\n               it's one in 94 people. This is not just an urban issue. It is not confined to our largest cities. It is deeply\n               felt in small and rural communities, where housing stock is limited, costs are rising\n               and supports are stretched thin. Homelessness disproportionately affects the most vulnerable. Young people fleeing\n               abusive homes, seniors with no suitable housing options, young families who simply\n               cannot afford to make rent, people with disabilities on fixed incomes and individuals\n               suffering from severe psychiatric distress. Events like this remind us that behind every statistic is a human being. Homelessness\n               can, and often does, affect anyone — a family member, a neighbour or a colleague.\n               Awareness is important. Community compassion is powerful, but it must be matched with\n               serious policy attention and meaningful action from this Legislature. I hope that anybody in this House that hasn't participated in one of these walks would\n               do so next year, because no British Columbian should be left out in the cold.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328034","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This weekend I participated in the Coldest Night of the Year walk in Terrace. The\n               Coldest Night of the Year is held in communities across Canada to raise awareness\n               and funds for local organizations that are serving those experiencing homelessness.\n               It's about walking together in solidarity with those who do not have the option of\n               going hom","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011279","label":"Pests","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aefc3ecd76f40e12bba44ab8ebd1fbd5b890877da8d27963b5204db824c93c0e","eadd08b5beaeaca4020496e7574500eee66e6e8cf18d27f183c7a00712954277"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d6520768d315a8fe3b5e29c0595feff8828648f40084207352d12917ce6ebd1b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b0e9edcee5a27eb1a1a26287","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328035,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two different introductions that I want to make today. One of them is that we have, somewhere here, Bobby and Carla from Union Gospel Mission.\n               They were at the prayer breakfast this morning, but I also had the opportunity over\n               the lunch hour to go and visit them at one of their recovery houses, as they're kind\n               of breaking into the space here in Victoria and providing some really great service\n               for people that really need it. I want to thank them for the work that they do and welcome them here to the Legislature. The other introduction that I want to make is, really, somebody that needs no introduction\n               here. It's somebody that's known well across party lines because he does the hard\n               work of advocating for our communities, and he does it well. It's someone that I look\n               up to and that I respect a lot, and that's our mayor, Sean Bujtas.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328035","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have two different introductions that I want to make today. One of them is that we have, somewhere here, Bobby and Carla from Union Gospel Mission.\n               They were at the prayer breakfast this morning, but I also had the opportunity over\n               the lunch hour to go and visit them at one of their recovery houses, as they're kind\n               of breaking into the space here in V","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034856","label":"Humanitarian aid","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e3b5d35522ae63a02129ed1c1a8ead4bdf4c804bafb7a69f93b332de0495d1a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fd21723bb7b099408f77ec6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360873,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning I had the honour and the opportunity to go and speak at a breakfast for\n               Jewish community advocacy days, hosted by CIJA. A number of the representatives are\n               here in the chamber today to watch question period, and I just wanted to welcome them\n               and thank them for their time this morning and all the work that they do on behalf\n               of our community. I would ask that the House make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360873","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This morning I had the honour and the opportunity to go and speak at a breakfast for\n               Jewish community advocacy days, hosted by CIJA. A number of the representatives are\n               here in the chamber today to watch question period, and I just wanted to welcome them\n               and thank them for their time this morning and all the work that they do on behalf\n               of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a34d60f70ff374fc7dd8f234c57a9b412f3bd15dd4eb6169988c0dd3df250ec7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fa6179b9f001b49e8bfba7f0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360874,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"That was an incredibly tone-deaf answer. As a small business owner myself, I can tell\n               you that that's not cutting it for the other small businesses in B.C. right now. B.C.'s\n               Jewish community alone now spends $100,000 every month on security services to keep\n               their schools and their synagogues safe — $100,000 every single month. Now this government\n               is adding PST to those security services that's going to cost this community another\n               $84,000 a year. Does the minister really think it's appropriate to tax people for protecting themselves?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360874","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"That was an incredibly tone-deaf answer. As a small business owner myself, I can tell\n               you that that's not cutting it for the other small businesses in B.C. right now. B.C.'s\n               Jewish community alone now spends $100,000 every month on security services to keep\n               their schools and their synagogues safe — $100,000 every single month. Now this government\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["91abe518bff37a2caf850afddcb1ae9d7f75bc77afe539a53bdce4f6190ef193"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48663baa5324fa8f9d8f0d60b777c17f5bf088fa5c8becc82045b1b98d09dbb1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dcd7757b2f0a7e631b03f468","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415803,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Millions of taxpayer dollars have been spent on ideologically driven experiments by\n               this government when it comes to the toxic drug crisis. There were $19 million that\n               were budgeted for the decriminalization pilot, to study it, and now we're being told\n               that there were no results that were found. So I don't understand if British Columbians\n               should either not trust that that's accurate, or they shouldn't trust this government\n               to be able to manage their money. I'm hoping that one of the ministers will stand up today and tell us, is there any\n               usable data that came out of the decriminalization pilot, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415803","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Millions of taxpayer dollars have been spent on ideologically driven experiments by\n               this government when it comes to the toxic drug crisis. There were $19 million that\n               were budgeted for the decriminalization pilot, to study it, and now we're being told\n               that there were no results that were found. So I don't understand if British Columbians\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7c9d0cbc767cc7a31cff9296b426ef323c35c3adc405089a6b058f46bec4f470"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["740dd33637b2204288acba9bc70c86fd56c368ba44c749f99a3b5e5682a8cea1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6313d8260499d03cad1dea2f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415804,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to echo the welcome that my colleague just gave for the representatives from\n               the British Columbia Psychological Association. I'm also looking forward to meeting\n               with them later. As well as — I'm not sure if they're in the gallery today, but they are in the precinct\n               — representatives from Stenberg and Rhodes College, the mental health and counselling\n               program. I'm looking forward to meeting with Emma, Isabelle and Ben later today, and I'd ask\n               that the House make them welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415804","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to echo the welcome that my colleague just gave for the representatives from\n               the British Columbia Psychological Association. I'm also looking forward to meeting\n               with them later. As well as — I'm not sure if they're in the gallery today, but they are in the precinct\n               — representatives from Stenberg and Rhodes College, the mental health and counse","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aircraft","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43398","label":"Aircraft","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b78936a40f18494453d8f96ce346454c86a8478b8866b1de8b01e4957d12f9b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-530efb6ba1c9f04b9944e2a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415805,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"This bill is about something that should never be controversial in a free and democratic\n               society, and that is the simple right of British Columbians to attend their place\n               of worship in safety, without fear, without intimidation and without disruption. We\n               have a responsibility in this House to ask the obvious question, though. Why is this\n               necessary right now? We are not debating this legislation in a vacuum. We are debating it at a time when\n               antisemitism is rising at an alarming rate, when religious institutions are being\n               targeted, when families are afraid to attend services and when communities are being\n               forced to take safety into their own hands. Nowhere in this province is that clearer than in the Jewish community, where in British\n               Columbia today We are not debating this legislation in a vacuum. We are debating it at a time when\n               antisemitism is rising at an alarming rate, when religious institutions are being\n               targeted, when families are afraid to attend services and when communities are being\n               forced to take safety into their own hands. Nowhere in this province is that clearer than in the Jewish community, where in British\n               Columbia today, Jewish organizations are spending over $100,000 every single month\n               on private security just to protect their schools, their synagogues and their community\n               spaces. We should all pause and reflect on what that means, because that is not normal,\n               that is not acceptable, and that is not something any community in this province should\n               have to shoulder on their own. Yet at the very same time that these communities are being forced to spend hundreds\n               of thousands of dollars just to protect themselves, this government is taxing that\n               security, applying 7 percent PST to the very measures people are taking to keep their\n               families safe. So while this bill acknowledges a real problem, it also highlights a deeper failure.\n               If this government had done its job on public safety, if communities felt protected,\n               if law enforcement and resources were keeping pace with rising threats, then we would\n               not be in a situation where people are forced to hire private security just to be\n               able to attend religious services. This bill creates what are commonly referred to as \"bubble zones,\" establishing a\n               20-metre access zone around places of worship where individuals cannot block access,\n               disrupt services, intimidate individuals or engage in behaviour that causes fear for\n               physical or mental safety. These are not radical ideas. In fact, they are based on legal frameworks that have\n               already been upheld in this province. We have seen similar protections in place under\n               the Access to Abortion Services Act, and the courts have been very clear that rights\n               like freedom of expression are not absolute and can be reasonably limited, especially\n               when the goal is to protect vulnerable people accessing lawful services. And that\n               is exactly what this bill is attempting to do. It is trying to strike a balance between\n               the right to protest and the right to worship safely. Let me be clear. We strongly support the right to peaceful assembly. It is a fundamental\n               freedom protected under the Charter. But there is a line. There is a difference between\n               peaceful protest and intimidation, between expression and harassment, and between\n               dissent and deliberately targeting people as they try to enter a place of public worship.\n               When that line is crossed, government has a responsibility to act. But legislation alone does not create safety. You can draw a line on a map, you can\n               define a 20-metre boundary, you can pass legislation in this House, but if there are\n               not adequate police resources, consistent enforcement and meaningful consequences,\n               then those lines become purely symbolic. People are not asking for symbolism right\n               now. They are asking for safety. I also want to address another aspect of this bill that deserves attention, which\n               is that under clause 5, police are given the authority to make warrantless arrests\n               for violations of this act. While similar powers exist in other legislation, this\n               is still a significant tool that underscores the seriousness with which these offences\n               should be treated. But it also raises an important question, which is whether this power will actually\n               be used. We have seen time and time again in this province that laws exist on paper\n               but enforcement falls short in practice. So the question for government is not just\n               whether it will pass this bill. The question is whether it will ensure that it is\n               enforced, because without enforcement, this bill risks becoming yet another example\n               of government responding to a crisis with legislation without addressing the underlying causes. And those causes are real. We are seeing rising hate, increased polarization, a breakdown\n               in public safety and a growing sense among many communities that they are on their\n               own. If this government were taking this crisis as seriously as it requires, they would\n               address the underlying issues that are contributing to it. Rather than pointing the\n               finger at others, they would address this issue by example. When they were told that there was a problem with antisemitism within their own caucus,\n               rather than address it, they mocked the member that raised it and publicly shamed\n               her. Rather than addressing extremism and terrorism within our own province, they let Charlotte\n               Kates, the international coordinator for Samidoun who referred to the October 7 attacks\n               as heroic and brave, walk free and continue to spread hate and fear in our communities,\n               a choice that has directly contributed to the fear and violence that we are seeing\n               today. When faced with difficult choices on this matter, they always seemed to make the wrong\n               one. So this government could have prevented this from being a problem in the first place\n               if they had the courage to act when it mattered. None of this would have been necessary\n               if they had chosen to lead by example, to prosecute those who broke the law, to enforce\n               the laws that were already on the books. But they did not, and now we are here. Protecting places of worship should not be controversial. It should not be partisan,\n               and it should not take rising threats and targeted incidents to finally act. This\n               should be a basic function of government. And that brings me to my final point. If this government is serious about standing\n               against antisemitism, if it is serious about protecting faith communities and if it\n               is serious about public safety, then this bill cannot be the end of the conversation. We must support stronger enforcement, support better resourcing for police, support\n               real consequences and end policies that shift the burden of safety onto communities\n               themselves, including ending the taxation of security services that people are being\n               forced to rely on, because no one in this province should have to pay extra just to\n               feel safe attending their place of worship — not now and not ever. We will continue to hold this government accountable to ensure that this is not just\n               another symbolic gesture but a meaningful step toward restoring safety, dignity and\n               security for every British Columbian.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415805","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This bill is about something that should never be controversial in a free and democratic\n               society, and that is the simple right of British Columbians to attend their place\n               of worship in safety, without fear, without intimidation and without disruption. We\n               have a responsibility in this House to ask the obvious question, though. Why is this\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["463e2463755fd95822b696dd142f2652a27c4c34e709f6922e0fb23f0b9a753d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06180b2b4822d1d0d1a276f94564a48e6ffd18d01f1a7bb61c5dbb9ad4f525db"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cee8db4b8584e38331e6a352","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415806,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's really rich to hear the Minister of Transportation talking about how this side\n               of the House is against solutions for homeless encampments when I have been trying\n               for almost a year to get a permanent shelter in my community, and I have been turned\n               down every single time. Not to mention the three months it took me to get a response\n               from that minister's office when I am just asking for a bit of clarity around what\n               is going on on my highways. Since the minister refused to answer my question yesterday, I will try again in light\n               of the letter that she received this morning from Dr. Julian Somers. Dr. Somers spent over two decades building one of the most comprehensive databases\n               in the world on addiction, homelessness and public safety in British Columbia, tracking\n               real outcomes for more than 300,000 people. In his letter, he confirmed that just\n               as the province was preparing to move ahead with major policy changes, including decriminalization,\n               his team was ordered to destroy that data In his letter, he confirmed that just as the province was preparing to move ahead\n               with major policy changes, including decriminalization, his team was ordered to destroy\n               that data — data that he says would have allowed independent evaluation and could\n               have pointed this government in a very different direction. I'll ask again: why did this government order the destruction of critical addiction\n               and public safety data right before launching its decriminalization experiment, and\n               will she release all underlying data for independent review today? Or is this government\n               still choosing to control the evidence instead of being honest with British Columbians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415806","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's really rich to hear the Minister of Transportation talking about how this side\n               of the House is against solutions for homeless encampments when I have been trying\n               for almost a year to get a permanent shelter in my community, and I have been turned\n               down every single time. Not to mention the three months it took me to get a response\n               fro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["018758c908040b60991889df437fd76752f71441125ff69c01758eb93c7a4a83","2d74898907a4f48ad2ca8e9d5e32782b420fe911a477eb19358db46342225285"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["de6379088d4f5444bbd030b06d31be9c1c06732ddb2a8795c8245da7abe0dc10"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aaf11337ca306685cc9023aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415807,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today, we have a number of people that just came out front of the Legislature\n               with us for a rally for World Autism Day. Today we have April Johnman; Lynn Hopkins; Benita, Ryan and Ben Lindsay; Chelsea Gannam;\n               Nicole Imbriolo; Alina Lawson; Nicole Lancaster; Sarah Lindberg; Jacqueline, Charlotte,\n               Max and Piper Ferreira; Madison, Steven and Diane Ross; Michelle Clark; Ripley Davis;\n               Madison and Diane Paress; Patricia, Shane, Ava and Ivy Anderson; Nicholas, Lisa Marie,\n               Michelle, Diane, Patricia, Shane and Jackson Chai; Kayla Burnell; Sharon Banning;\n               Hailey Shade; Ashley Allan; Tessa Gunther; Michelle Clark; Patricia Anderson; Ed Court;\n               Jennifer Marcel; and Dylan McDonald. I would just ask that the House make them feel very welcome, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415807","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In the gallery today, we have a number of people that just came out front of the Legislature\n               with us for a rally for World Autism Day. Today we have April Johnman; Lynn Hopkins; Benita, Ryan and Ben Lindsay; Chelsea Gannam;\n               Nicole Imbriolo; Alina Lawson; Nicole Lancaster; Sarah Lindberg; Jacqueline, Charlotte,\n               Max and Piper Ferreira; Madison, Steven and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["076cbfe6382b75eba7143d2b46041d7a724580de8cc2b6ff5b3ce93778dcbc60","9d242f50bdec295ada2ff538b236bfe980e8a48499dc0327ba4a4f805d59970f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9e6de907478b3e0d7b257dd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415808,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm rising on a question of privilege. I reserved my right yesterday, and I am raising\n               this at the earliest opportunity. This matter concerns statements made in this House by the Minister of Health regarding\n               the destruction of addiction, homelessness and public safety data. During question\n               period, I asked the Minister of Health: The Minister of Health stated: Those are categorical statements. They go directly to the integrity of the information\n               being provided to this House. This matter is highly material. It concerns one of the\n               most comprehensive data sets in the world on addiction, homelessness and public safety,\n               a data set tracking outcomes for more than 300,000 individuals — data that relates\n               directly to major public policy decisions, including decriminalization. I'm now going to refer to a written directive issued by Leigh Greiner from the Ministry\n               of Public Safety and Solicitor General to Dr. Somers on March 5, 2021. Dr. Somers\n               received this letter one week after his deputy minister briefing \"incorrectly stating\n               that all our ISAs were about to expire and that the DIP could replicate all our data.\" It states: \"All data must be destroyed, and all media storage devices that housed\n               ministry data must be sanitized. This includes all backup copies, uploads and data\n               on any media devices.\" It further requires confirmation that this destruction has\n               taken place. \"Once complete, please send me a confirmation letter that these steps\n               have occurred and the data has been destroyed.\" This creates a clear contradiction. The minister told this House that the data was\n               not destroyed. The government directive states that the data must be destroyed. Both\n               of those statements cannot be true. I have confirmed with Dr. Somers that he never\n               transferred the data to the government. In addition, the data collected by Dr. Somers was the result of numerous research\n               projects designed by international collaborators and funded by external grants, not\n               under contract to the B.C. government. I will also place on the record Dr. Somers' statement: \"Any denial that scientific\n               data were irretrievably destroyed is demonstrably incorrect.\" He further indicates\n               that this included unique data sets, including randomized trial data, that cannot\n               be recreated. \"The data we were forced to destroy included data from randomized controlled\n               trials that were obtained with the consent of participants. There is no way to recreate\n               that data. Those studies alone are valued at more than $30 million in taxpayer funds.\" When Dr. Somers refers to data being irretrievably destroyed, he is not referring\n               to general information that could be recreated elsewhere. He is referring to linked\n               longitudinal data sets and randomized trial data developed by teams of scientists\n               over the course of decades — data that cannot simply be reconstructed after the fact. This is not a question of administrative transition or duplication. This is a question\n               of whether unique and irreplaceable research data was destroyed. The minister suggested\n               that this data was simply transferred to another system. However, the directive before\n               us does not describe a transfer of identical data sets. It explicitly requires destruction\n               of the data and sanitization of all storage devices. Instead of addressing that contradiction, the minister chose to dismiss the concern\n               and characterize it as misleading. She further chose to attack the credibility of\n               the researcher rather than address the substance of the issue. Dr. Somers is a trusted advisor to governments in Canada and internationally. He is\n               one of North America's most accomplished researchers regarding addiction policies\n               and services, and until this government launched our decriminalization and safe supply,\n               his expertise was regularly sought by the B.C. government.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415808","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm rising on a question of privilege. I reserved my right yesterday, and I am raising\n               this at the earliest opportunity. This matter concerns statements made in this House by the Minister of Health regarding\n               the destruction of addiction, homelessness and public safety data. During question\n               period, I asked the Minister of Health: The Minister of Health s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c97c00963d36a26775c2aa7d24db0b2e2d6bf6253957327e6f1c27edcd23859"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1a778a36a6fb8cb97b1edc029edd864a1845b696cff370d0e172b469f0b5b0a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-539cbd24012521eb00651244","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720525,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720525","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I also seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["150c81c623c4f1a3e738e950bd9b7309e50b9059d4149972add19056d321bb94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-908b75e9bacf412ccdb8a3c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720530,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I hope you'll indulge me, because it's not very often I get this many people from\n               my riding here in the chamber. I have quite a few that I'd like to introduce. I'd like to start off by introducing Cyril Bennett-Nabess. He is the Deputy Chief\n               of the Kitselas Nation. Unfortunately, the chief councillor, Glenn Bennett, was not\n               able to be here today, so he is here in his place. We also have Gerald Nyce, Jericho Collison, Jorden Squires and Cheryl Campbell — they\n               are all councillors for the Kitselas Nation — as well as Dr. David Try, who is a Kitselas\n               Elder and senior negotiator, and Linda Morven, who is also a Kitselas Elder and their\n               CAO. Sean Bujtas, who I said yesterday, of course, is the mayor of the city of Terrace.\n               We also have Stan Bevan from the Kitselas Nation, Roberta Kwak from the Kitselas Nation,\n               Susan Bevan, George Chin, Angeline Chin, Anne McDames, Crystal Wright, Mercedes Seymour,\n               Marissa Seymour, Audrey Bennett, Sharon Bennett, Stella Wright, Freda Wright, Matilda\n               Henry, Benita Young-Mercer and Debbie Moore, all from the Kitselas Nation as well.\n               Many of them are staff members with the Kitselas Nation, and I appreciate all of their\n               hard work for their community. We also have some members from Kitsumkalum here as well today. Troy Sam is the Chief\n               of the Kitsumkalum. And then we have, from their council, Ona Button and Wayne Bolton,\n               and from treaty communications, Julie Nyce and Jennifer Bolton. I would ask that the House all make them feel very welcome, please. I appreciate having\n               them here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720530","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I hope you'll indulge me, because it's not very often I get this many people from\n               my riding here in the chamber. I have quite a few that I'd like to introduce. I'd like to start off by introducing Cyril Bennett-Nabess. He is the Deputy Chief\n               of the Kitselas Nation. Unfortunately, the chief councillor, Glenn Bennett, was not\n               able to be here today, so he ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cf2314f0daa91b7ef0e55666b91a0527261f00a2fe8ba1251da7e03ca88d9ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21307b62a68730ae0add31c6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721614,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"In order for universal health care to work, people actually have to be able to access\n               health care. Increasing the health care budget does very little for British Columbians\n               if there are no meaningful results attached to it and things just continue to get\n               worse. Recently, I raised the tragic death of a young man who slipped through the cracks\n               after being left waiting without proper supervision or support in Vernon Jubilee Hospital's\n               psychiatric unit. He voluntarily admitted himself and was left for days in a hallway\n               bed, despite being certified under the Mental Health Act. And since then, I have had\n               numerous families reach out to me about loved ones that they have lost in that same\n               psychiatric unit. Now I have learned that that same unit is on diversion for the foreseeable future,\n               meaning that patients in crisis are being sent to the emergency department and left\n               in hallways while staff have been instructed to briefly assess and move on. To the minister, there are really only two options here. Does she admit that the current\n               system cannot safely hold people in acute psychiatric crisis, or does she believe\n               that the current system where patients are left in hallways is acceptable?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721614","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In order for universal health care to work, people actually have to be able to access\n               health care. Increasing the health care budget does very little for British Columbians\n               if there are no meaningful results attached to it and things just continue to get\n               worse. Recently, I raised the tragic death of a young man who slipped through the cracks\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb96597d69e307ca6f3b52a943df6c673a8432b05949ff7da30a964112da2e2f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd5d84fdfe6cb8c6079e4ca90b40bbf4e004f404d63c0c392dd258d515df50f2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-17ebfa39a15b1ee773c0a7c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721615,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last week I asked the minister whether she agreed with her","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721615","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Last week I asked the minister whether she agreed with her","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b095a849ee5b7a0b5621e0d133e4c0ad37986cad7a34e7fb3105f7513f8b7d02"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd8935c4f9b404ebf7771948","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721617,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we're speaking about Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act. I want to begin by grounding this conversation in something that I\n               think is absolutely fundamental to our role in this House. That is the understanding that freedom of information is not simply an administrative\n               tool, it is not a bureaucratic process, and it is not just about efficiency or timelines\n               or internal systems. It is one of the only mechanisms that British Columbians have\n               to understand what their government is doing, to verify that decisions are being made\n               in the public interest, and to hold those of us in positions of authority accountable\n               for the decisions that we make. At the end of the day, the information we are talking about does not belong to government;\n               it belongs to the people of British Columbia. Government is simply the custodian of\n               that information. We're entrusted with it, we manage it, we organize it, but we do\n               not own it. When we start to blur that line, when we start to treat public information as something\n               that government controls, rather than something that the public has a right to access,\n               we fundamentally change the relationship between government and the people that it\n               serves. That relationship is supposed to be built on trust. When people believe that they can ask questions and get answers, when they believe\n               that government is transparent, when they believe that information is accessible,\n               even when it is inconvenient or uncomfortable, that is what builds confidence in public\n               institutions. But when that starts to change, when people feel like they cannot get\n               answers, when they feel like information is being withheld, delayed, filtered or controlled,\n               that is when trust starts to erode. Once that erosion begins, it does not take long for people to lose confidence, not\n               just in government but in our entire system. That is what makes this bill so concerning.\n               For the last nine long years, the public's trust in this government has more than\n               eroded; it has collapsed. This legislation is the icing on the cake. I think a perfect example of why this is so important is something that happened this\n               morning in the chamber, in question period. My colleague from Columbia River–Revelstoke was asking questions about some FOI documents that our party had received from the\n               government, in regard to a signing that happened on xwməθkwəy̓əm territory, involving the Premier. The FOI that we'd received was so heavily redacted, and the Premier tried to pull\n               a gotcha: \"How did you not know that this was a letter that was in opposition to it?\"\n               Well, we didn't know, because the FOI that we received only told us that there was\n               a letter involved. Then when the Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth tried to heckle us over it, I said:\n               \"These are your documents. This is your information.\" Because government gets to decide\n               what is released and what is proactively disclosed to people and what is available\n               to us as opposition while we're trying to do our jobs, that's part of the problem. Making that weaker, making it so that there's even less information that we can access\n               or more things that the government is allowed to control whether or not opposition\n               can access or the public can access, is only going to make that problem Making that weaker, making it so that there's even less information that we can access\n               or more things that the government is allowed to control whether or not opposition\n               can access or the public can access, is only going to make that problem even worse\n               than it already is today. I want to acknowledge, because I think it's important to do so honestly, that there\n               are aspects of the FOI system today that are not working in the way that they should. We know that there are delays. We know that people are waiting far too long to receive\n               responses. We know that the system can be frustrating and, in some cases, incredibly\n               inaccessible. I've experienced it firsthand, and I recognize that there is a need\n               to improve this system. What is deeply concerning about this legislation is that instead of addressing those\n               problems and instead of fixing what is broken, it moves us in the opposite direction.\n               It does not improve access; it restricts it. It does not increase certainty; it introduces\n               ambiguity. It does not strengthen accountability; it weakens it. Right now, British Columbians are already waiting months — in some cases, close to\n               a year — to receive responses to freedom-of-information requests. That is not a small\n               issue. It's not a minor inconvenience, but it is a system that is fundamentally failing\n               to meet its most basic obligation. Instead of tackling that problem head-on, instead of asking why those delays exist,\n               instead of investing in the systems and processes needed to actually deliver timely\n               responses, this legislation lowers the standard. It replaces a requirement to respond without delay with a requirement to respond without\n               unreasonable delay. That might seem like a small change, but it is not. Because \"without\n               delay\" is a very clear expectation; \"without unreasonable delay\" is subjective. It\n               introduces flexibility for the institution, not certainty for the public. We see that same pattern repeated throughout this bill — more subjectivity, more discretion,\n               more room for interpretation. I want to ground this in something very real, because for me this is not theoretical.\n               It is not a hypothetical concern about what might happen if this bill passes. This\n               is something that I am already experiencing in real time. Since June of last year, I have had freedom-of-information requests in for Dr. Daniel\n               Vigo's quarterly reports. These are not obscure documents. These are not peripheral\n               reports. These are documents that are directly tied to government policy, particularly\n               in the context of the addiction, crisis and concurrent disorders. These are reports that are being used to justify decisions that are affecting communities\n               across this province — or not. I wouldn't know because I haven't been able to see\n               them. Not a partial disclosure, not heavily redacted records, nothing. I asked about it again in today's question period and received a non-answer, just\n               more obfuscation and attempts to distract, but the reality is that this is taxpayer-funded\n               work — work that is costing the taxpayer over $1 million in a salary plus expenses,\n               plus covering the salary cost from UBC. There is no justifiable reason why these reports should not already be a matter of\n               public record. To be honest, a freedom-of-information request should not have even\n               been necessary, but here we are. Nearly a year later, and I haven't even received\n               some heavily redacted version, just silence. How am I supposed to effectively do the job that my constituents elected me to do\n               if I can't even access the information that is required of me to be able to do it? This government is operating like the gatekeepers on information that belongs to the\n               public, and this legislation is attempting to close that gate even tighter than before.\n               If I have already been unable to access that information with the current system,\n               what will happen if this legislation comes into force? What other information will\n               the public not be able to access? At the same time, I have also had requests in for the work being done by Larry Campbell\n               on the Downtown Eastside, work that the government itself has publicly acknowledged\n               as being critical to understanding what is happening in one of the most vulnerable\n               communities in British Columbia, one that my critic portfolio is deeply intertwined\n               with — and, again, nothing. No transparency, no accountability, no answers. As I said before, what makes this even more concerning is that I should not even have\n               to be filing FOI requests for this information in the first place. These are reports\n               that taxpayers are funding. They are reports that are informing government decisions.\n               There is absolutely no reasonable explanation for why this information should not\n               be publicly available, none. Yet here we are, forced to file requests, wait months, pay fees, just to try and access\n               information that should have been proactively disclosed from the start. What's incredibly frustrating about both of these situations is that they're not one-offs.\n               This just happens to be something that's relevant to my critic portfolio. This is\n               happening all throughout our caucus. We have freedom-of-information requests in that\n               we haven't received any responses to. We haven't gotten any answers. These are just two examples of government contracts that the government has repeatedly\n               justified as being incredibly necessary to inform the work that they need to do. In the case of the Downtown Eastside, I believe it's work that sitting MLAs should\n               be doing, not an outside independent contractor, but here we are. These are just two examples of government contracts that the government has repeatedly\n               justified as being incredibly necessary to inform the work that they need to do. In\n               the case of the Downtown Eastside, I believe it's work that sitting MLAs should be\n               doing, not an outside independent contractor, but here we are. There has been zero justification for the taxpayers' money that has been spent on\n               it. We've reviewed the contracts. The contracts clearly state that there is a requirement....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721617","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today we're speaking about Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act. I want to begin by grounding this conversation in something that I\n               think is absolutely fundamental to our role in this House. That is the understanding that freedom of information is not simply an administrative\n               tool, it is not a bureaucratic process, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2fecd4e86fab22712e02bcea3f5b9c91522cea6898adc05fcbecc43be4cabb0a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb7064dc6448c3be2f9b80012fdbba188e2e355e000abbaa114f6816e08b2bc7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-042969c4afdfc0c70c942e43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721632,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am really grateful and really blessed to have a lot of amazing women in my life,\n               but today I have two of the most important in the gallery — my mom, Marjorie, and\n               my best friend, Chelsea. My mom asked a very simple thing of me. She asked me to say\n               something smart today, so I hope that I do while she's watching. I would just hope that the House would please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721632","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am really grateful and really blessed to have a lot of amazing women in my life,\n               but today I have two of the most important in the gallery — my mom, Marjorie, and\n               my best friend, Chelsea. My mom asked a very simple thing of me. She asked me to say\n               something smart today, so I hope that I do while she's watching. I would just hope that the House would p","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e242cbb054c59db7b54849c00f958dfbded3468f47d96628bf100461f46d866a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a148945d458e6ff38c70ed33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721637,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start out by saying that I prepared a speech, and I put a lot of time and\n               thought into how I was going to proceed with this. But unfortunately, I have to start\n               by stating a few things to correct the record. I don't really want to be doing this right now because I do think that this is important\n               work, and I don't think, personally, that it's particularly respectful to the K'ómoks\n               Nation that this has become as politicized as it has. But there have been a number\n               of comments that have been made today that are simply inaccurate. I'm going to start by saying that I absolutely support treaty. I've spent the last\n               year and a half in my communities working with the communities that are going through\n               the treaty process. I have always supported them in that. I absolutely support First\n               Nations getting out from under I'm going to start by saying that I absolutely support treaty. I've spent the last\n               year and a half in my communities working with the communities that are going through\n               the treaty process. I've always supported them in that. I absolutely support First\n               Nations getting out from under the Indian Act. I absolutely understand how alive and\n               well racism is.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721637","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to start out by saying that I prepared a speech, and I put a lot of time and\n               thought into how I was going to proceed with this. But unfortunately, I have to start\n               by stating a few things to correct the record. I don't really want to be doing this right now because I do think that this is important\n               work, and I don't think, personally, that it's pa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0f2840fdc8fffd55644702be478d124032496dae77ed1e071bb2ec7738bd1ca9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3fa746b96e3d173b5a5d2c66bab53f584d5c9c3f94ff262e31e9c0f6f904e9a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-774aa847fa4887e2eebb6419","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729402,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Chair. I appreciate it. Thank you to the minister and all of her staff. I'm appreciating your guys' time today.\n               I think we'll just kind of jump right in. I don't necessarily have any opening comments. The first thing that I wanted to cover off, though, is going back to last year's estimates.\n               I had made some requests around the number of treatment ads relating to substance\n               use and I was promised that I would get a copy of all of the beds broken down by health\n               authority, type of bed, all of those details. I was provided with it, and I really\n               appreciate it. I have it here from last year. I was hoping that I could start off by requesting.... It seemed like this was something\n               that was pre-prepared. If I could get a copy of that as soon as possible so that I\n               have time before my time is up today to be able to cross-reference the two. This one\n               was March of 2025, and I'm happy to provide that to the minister and her team if she\n               would like, just so that she has a copy of what I'm looking for. Basically, I'm hoping\n               that we can get that over to me and my staff as soon as possible. I believe I have roughly five hours for my I believe I have roughly five hours for my estimates portion, so I'm just hoping that\n               I could receive a copy of this in advance so that I have a bit of time to be able\n               to cross-reference the two. So I'm just hoping. If the minister can let me know, please.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729402","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Chair. I appreciate it. Thank you to the minister and all of her staff. I'm appreciating your guys' time today.\n               I think we'll just kind of jump right in. I don't necessarily have any opening comments. The first thing that I wanted to cover off, though, is going back to last year's estimates.\n               I had made some requests around the number of treatment ads relati","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Postal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","label":"Medicine","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49236","label":"Postal services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e164c63ce21b57d1f3c088383668656f82cb53af02794090566bfdb832588661","08bf0d25e6212d0dd3124693c3968e62eb56b0518e827258d4d4380998722d9b","8fa5a99444a0cf2d2d5f211e0fa1070136fe9e63a9318ec5fc729c939b056eff","892c1bc04442624f3d387ade933c2035fe8140c68fd302aa790cb60cb815b435","65da2d55d9280ac0bb467074ec617112fff544ddb25e721f9901fdd8347bad86","783f5b4d02c3758507610c17b51aedb56745a570d127bd57f086023586cd32dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["932a48d9a02169907cc39e96b64cd2acf89518b0f9b31a6ea7c1f2b3c4f67b9d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e246d4f540a94a0370c44e57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729403,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"On January 20 of this year: \"It is not for the courts to take over, and that's why\n               we're going to amend the declaration in the spring to make that intent explicit.\"\n               That was the Premier. The Premier was clear, on numerous occasions, that legislation\n               to amend DRIPA would be tabled this session, until he wasn't. Now we're being told it's being tabled in the fall session, maybe. Now, it sounds\n               like that's not the case. I don't disagree that the government should be consulting\n               with First Nations on this, but the reality is they should have started this last\n               year when these problems began. This government's track record is clear. They don't\n               properly consult until something ends up in court, and all British Columbians end\n               up paying the price for their incompetence. My question is to the Attorney General. Since the Premier's word obviously cannot\n               be trusted, what is the exact timeline for when these amendments will be tabled in\n               this House? Will it be in the fall session? And why should British Columbians trust\n               your government to actually deliver?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729403","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On January 20 of this year: \"It is not for the courts to take over, and that's why\n               we're going to amend the declaration in the spring to make that intent explicit.\"\n               That was the Premier. The Premier was clear, on numerous occasions, that legislation\n               to amend DRIPA would be tabled this session, until he wasn't. Now we're being told it's being tabled in t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","label":"Research institutes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce0363314d7553cdf1657e9455f8333944b3bfd8edac6be226f14eda6abe1aab","71237d8283b8902cd4e2268468c239143ae5a1fb894fc39c149f75317aecf2b4","1e80b86c00e8f5c0db83e9f1d8b568db396fe67d1cceac5b15b24fcab508320c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b29e6974637e51f0fdaa194e4a04a4e732c7612a5e312c8d45624753446cad5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f13bebd08c44548416bfe779","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729406,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I feel bad. The minister has had to repeat that so many times, she's already got it\n               memorized. So moving on with Red Fish Healing Centre, I just want to talk about this a little\n               bit further, and I appreciate that update. I'm hopeful that we'll hear some kind of\n               an announcement coming forward soon. But with the current Red Fish Healing Centre, I'm wondering what the average wait\n               time for admission at the Red Fish Healing Centre was for the fiscal year '24-25.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729406","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I feel bad. The minister has had to repeat that so many times, she's already got it\n               memorized. So moving on with Red Fish Healing Centre, I just want to talk about this a little\n               bit further, and I appreciate that update. I'm hopeful that we'll hear some kind of\n               an announcement coming forward soon. But with the current Red Fish Healing Centre, I'm wonder","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035147","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Equipment industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035147","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Equipment industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Metalworking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish farming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adolescents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035147","label":"Equipment industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035279","label":"Fish farming","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:205113","label":"Fish","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501332","label":"Adolescents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96252","label":"Metalworking industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf114dcdbb7cf05acead5b040076eedd080296e2caeab1bb8bf64e5d88270ff6","6c46134b3839bd18e9ac5d9f4d1c323130466b7d1193961f28fe1a372157accf","b9e3adf9419f706aa2531b9e7421a41d2a3bea6ca1ad06c123a2750c2d4ad0f3","4ca0f125dcc28b35f539baa75bd3dc42d09af08f1a81d286bd884c0f3a96fee6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb69cc7dbd64f4821b4f21ad8b4ee360d3cf48a36a2700294f603067a989f091"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d17a49089060710353dd0362","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729409,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Ksi Lisims LNG project has been called a nation-building opportunity that will\n               transform Canada's energy future — billions in investment, thousands of jobs, a generational\n               opportunity for the North, co-owned by the Nisga'a Nation. But today this project\n               is tied up in court, not because of the project itself but because this government\n               failed to do its job again. We are now hearing that the province refused to properly\n               consult, and after more than a decade, they still cannot get it right. Why is this NDP government putting a project like this and the future of the North\n               at risk through its own incompetence?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729409","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Ksi Lisims LNG project has been called a nation-building opportunity that will\n               transform Canada's energy future — billions in investment, thousands of jobs, a generational\n               opportunity for the North, co-owned by the Nisga'a Nation. But today this project\n               is tied up in court, not because of the project itself but because this government\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["96c1b0520e6e7fe12f343f7dfdaf42b542a6c4ca668c8fcb037b3b488132a4c1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b5482ba6fbd10fe7bf3ebed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752322,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is becoming clear that DRIPA is now a direct threat to our sovereignty in B.C.\n               It has been weaponized by U.S.-based tribes and put B.C. projects at risk. After the Gitxaała decision, the Premier admitted that at least 20 cases against the province have already\n               been amended, and the Minister of Mining and Critical Minerals acknowledged last week that a coalition of Alaskan tribes has filed to challenge\n               the approvals of the Eskay Creek mine, a project that this government has repeatedly\n               pointed to as being a DRIPA success in partnership with the Tāłtān Nation. Now, I understand we've canvassed this already and that the Attorney General has mentioned\n               bringing forward legislation that has been passed in this House that's going to address\n               this issue. What was interesting is that the Attorney General said very specifically\n               that this is to focus their attention and preference on B.C.-based nations but, referring\n               to these Alaska-based tribes, \"while they have rights.\" So my question to the Attorney General is: did she misspeak, or is she admitting that\n               U.S.-based tribes have rights in British Columbia under DRIPA?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752322","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is becoming clear that DRIPA is now a direct threat to our sovereignty in B.C.\n               It has been weaponized by U.S.-based tribes and put B.C. projects at risk. After the Gitxaała decision, the Premier admitted that at least 20 cases against the province have already\n               been amended, and the Minister of Mining and Critical Minerals acknowledged last week that a coalition of ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b63649b67523e98f93a219ce9df8f33cb6c7a0da927c8d52cb326f139382d92d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d50fb4f30f71db76fddc2db5b7af4cf36fac9bc96f929caf7a3cb2bf07bf26b3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0d427a7158b7b2183bd6f89e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752323,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Jesse Flowerdew's wife, Daisy, told me that he was a staunch advocate for men's mental\n               health. He had a documented history of prior suicide attempts, so when he was struggling\n               again, he self-admitted to the hospital and made it clear that he was struggling with\n               suicidal ideation again. He was released from hospital shortly thereafter, and within an hour of his release,\n               he was gone. His family was never notified, not when he was admitted, not when he\n               was discharged. To the minister, will she implement the changes to release procedures under the Mental\n               Health Act that could prevent this from happening again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752323","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Jesse Flowerdew's wife, Daisy, told me that he was a staunch advocate for men's mental\n               health. He had a documented history of prior suicide attempts, so when he was struggling\n               again, he self-admitted to the hospital and made it clear that he was struggling with\n               suicidal ideation again. He was released from hospital shortly thereafter, and within an hour","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","label":"Family law","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41d6426df15e73b3c157d468effaede484a91e9056f3fbab8eea1d344b3f8c5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e5c2953a1840aac52ee1681791f8f013270b30355667224a3504542c14e2b340"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ce004b7ec4f23e685ad93d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752324,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"The B.C. Business Council released a survey today, and the responses speak for themselves.\n               Nearly 75 percent of B.C. businesses plan to decrease investment due to uncertainty\n               over DRIPA. The president of BCBC said: \"The message from business leaders is clear. DRIPA isn't\n               working.\" B.C. businesses are pulling their money out of the province. Will the Minister\n               of Jobs stand up The president of BCBC said: \"The message from business leaders is clear. DRIPA isn't\n               working.\" B.C. businesses are pulling their money out of the province. Will the Minister of Jobs stand up for 75 percent of B.C. businesses today and address\n               this, or will he continue to downplay their concerns?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752324","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The B.C. Business Council released a survey today, and the responses speak for themselves.\n               Nearly 75 percent of B.C. businesses plan to decrease investment due to uncertainty\n               over DRIPA. The president of BCBC said: \"The message from business leaders is clear. DRIPA isn't\n               working.\" B.C. businesses are pulling their money out of the province. Will the Min","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a052dce37656a876a7e3432577b78684b5b6a0cd76b80535f27d16f9300240fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9794cc7f533165721fa8dfdbb40488410cb8e0ba14324ec9e2208e9d4b004ce3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b64fb9e297666c982861066f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017539,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to start by apologizing for disregarding your authority\n               in the House during question period today. I would also like to raise a point of order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017539","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I want to start by apologizing for disregarding your authority\n               in the House during question period today. I would also like to raise a point of order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural gas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083650","label":"Urban planning","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45778","label":"Natural gas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["686f570c75fedbaae3f19be254ab8a5a17513827c86a34ce19b5c5de7ded83a0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-178d4130aa3150da0c9c58ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017544,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last week, my community of Kitimat suffered an incredible loss with the passing of\n               Egil Ingleson. Egil was a person who embodied the spirit of Kitimat. Truly, he was\n               probably the kindest and most generous person that I ever met. Every person who had the pleasure of getting to know him in Kitimat and throughout\n               my region knows what a blessing knowing him was. He was a man who was deeply devoted\n               to his family and to his faith. He taught me so much about the importance of letting\n               the people that you love know how much you love them while you can. He had a remarkable gift for making you feel like you were the most important person\n               in the world. I can't even begin to explain how much he meant to me and how much I\n               learned from him over the last few years. He was a person who suffered a great deal of personal loss and tragedy in his life.\n               He battled cancer for several decades, but he never gave up. He always had a smile\n               on his face. When he lost his son, recently, to a drug overdose, it was a moment that\n               really brought the two of us together. He was always such a strong advocate for recovery,\n               for mental health supports, and he always did it with a smile on his face. He was just the most remarkable man. Knowing him certainly made me a better person.\n               I think it made everyone that knew him a better person. My deepest condolences to his family. I know how difficult this loss has been. It's\n               been a huge loss for our entire community. I was just so fortunate to have known him. He taught me that there was pretty much nothing that couldn't be fixed by a hug from\n               a person that you really loved, even if that person was maybe a cat, or a really bad\n               day that couldn't be fixed by a day out at the range shooting or going to church. He taught me an awful lot of things, but the most important thing that he taught me\n               was to make sure that you tell the people that you love that you love them. I'm going to miss him incredibly, but Valhalla gained another warrior. Until we meet again, Egel.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017544","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Last week, my community of Kitimat suffered an incredible loss with the passing of\n               Egil Ingleson. Egil was a person who embodied the spirit of Kitimat. Truly, he was\n               probably the kindest and most generous person that I ever met. Every person who had the pleasure of getting to know him in Kitimat and throughout\n               my region knows what a blessing knowing him","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035039","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035039","label":"Emigration","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["760dcc8018311b5f8f12df3d0691ba49be7edbca019b8c1302ffbc7c4610cc29"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bed94c1145cacf84a90c4865","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036563,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"Under this government's new autism funding model, a mother from Fernie told me that\n               her free services that are replacing the direct funding for her son would require\n               her to drive four hours each way through two mountain passes just to access, costing\n               her family more than $7,000 a year in fuel alone. How is forcing rural families into self-funded eight-hour round trips for care improving\n               access to services?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036563","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Under this government's new autism funding model, a mother from Fernie told me that\n               her free services that are replacing the direct funding for her son would require\n               her to drive four hours each way through two mountain passes just to access, costing\n               her family more than $7,000 a year in fuel alone. How is forcing rural families into self-funded eight-h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Suicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037252","label":"Suicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee833bfbe0ba01de9d9e41dd01360513a2126052995665e80e1bd3fc308154f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d81887e51b257becc87a09c44a6f39d3b08efa1f9296b91af0fa9557344bc061"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c40615699a0542093595a683","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036564,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a constituent in the gallery today, Ron Zuta, and his girlfriend Sue, who lives\n               here on the island. I would just ask that the House would make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036564","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a constituent in the gallery today, Ron Zuta, and his girlfriend Sue, who lives\n               here on the island. I would just ask that the House would make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b02ac225e8c3bfd05ba42490","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036565,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Claire Rattée","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to go back a little bit. Yesterday, at the end of the day, there was a question\n               around rising antisemitism in our province, and I really appreciated that the Premier recognized that antisemitism is on the rise in B.C. Given that the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement increases and encourages antisemitism\n               by seeking to delegitimize and isolate Israel, promotes the false narrative that Israel\n               is solely responsible for the conflict in the Middle East and demands self-determination\n               for Palestinians while denying that same right to the Jewish people, I'm wondering\n               what the government's position is on the fact that the B.C. Teachers Federation is\n               supporting and endorsing the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036565","member_id":"bc-mla-398","member_name":"Claire Rattée","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to go back a little bit. Yesterday, at the end of the day, there was a question\n               around rising antisemitism in our province, and I really appreciated that the Premier recognized that antisemitism is on the rise in B.C. Given that the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement increases and encourages antisemitism\n               by seeking to delegitimize and isolate Israel, promo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ac7d9b10220c8bd83967e7bfc2477e5c491514b3ad865e1fb2c96b6ef04cbf38"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0a981dae4a5ee251953aef6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317199,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I'll be fairly quick here. I just want to acknowledge Xavier's family here today, joining us in the gallery.\n               I can't imagine the pain of having to even sit through some of this as you're still\n               living through the loss. I think what's important at this point is the principle and the spirit and the intention\n               of the bill. I know that there have been some questions that have been raised about\n               due process, fairness. I know that every member in this House takes that very seriously\n               and respects that, but I say to that, let's take it to committee. Let's have those\n               discussions. Let's hear from experts. And let's really get to the nitty-gritty. I know that there have also been concerns brought up about wording definitions. Again,\n               I say let's bring that to committee. There are concerns about police discretion. Even\n               though those voices matter, we also have to balance concerns about processes with\n               our collective responsibility to the public. When there's a family, when there's an individual, when there's a community affected\n               by loss via reckless driving, you can't take that back. That's irreversible. As legislators,\n               it's our responsibility to protect the public from irreversible damage and harm. And\n               so, I urge all members in this House to support this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317199","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I'll be fairly quick here. I just want to acknowledge Xavier's family here today, joining us in the gallery.\n               I can't imagine the pain of having to even sit through some of this as you're still\n               living through the loss. I think what's important at this point is the principle and the spirit and the intention\n               of the bill. I know tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f4313951f4ff2ffc9121af725844d7e2102b781d9aa9b33e1d86c59016dd08f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da9af8971f08bbbae761e34af1b1ef892bbdcc83fb255e37fd2a949285c82c0f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06d3b999b86c422d3e7efeba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317200,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"On Family Day this year, families took one final walk across the historic Pattullo\n               Bridge. Opened in 1937, this steel through-arch bridge connected the legendary cities\n               of Surrey and New Westminster and served as a vital Fraser River crossing for generations.\n               For nearly 90 years, it carried commuters, commerce and community across our region.\n               It was also very pretty to look at. The bridge was quite literally a bridge to prosperity. And yes, many of us remember\n               holding our breath as we crossed it, gripping the wheel, hoping to keep our side-view\n               mirrors intact. But through every narrow lane and careful crossing, the Pattullo Bridge\n               served us well. As times change, so do the needs of our growing region. Today we gratefully welcome\n               the stal̕əw̓asəm Bridge, a name and structure that honours the deep and enduring ties of the qʼwa:n̓ƛʼən̓ First Nation and the xwməθkwəy̓əm Indian Band to this land. This modern cable-stayed bridge offers wider lanes, a centre\n               median barrier and protected multi-use pathways for pedestrians and cyclists so that\n               everyone can cross safely. I can attest it is a mirror-safe, breathtakingly smooth ride built for the future.\n               And as the Pattullo settles into memory, we remember that its steel carried footsteps,\n               headlights, laughter and long journeys home. It bore the weight of a generation becoming.\n               And now the stal̕əw̓asəm Bridge points us toward tomorrow, its foundations grounded in lessons learned and\n               relationships honoured. As we close the Pattullo Bridge, we honour the crossings that shaped us, and as we\n               open the stal̕əw̓asəm Bridge, we celebrate the trust that we are still becoming.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317200","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"On Family Day this year, families took one final walk across the historic Pattullo\n               Bridge. Opened in 1937, this steel through-arch bridge connected the legendary cities\n               of Surrey and New Westminster and served as a vital Fraser River crossing for generations.\n               For nearly 90 years, it carried commuters, commerce and community across our region.\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","label":"Bridges","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7662aaba3ccc47d1fa9a2a0c18607f3f7ebf8ad7ee059751a3bca662396b247"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bf788f67a154afe2bb847587fe2134f422719cf99ab7c7711182bfa05f8c2de"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Bridges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49363","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bea48d908fd418ee602c8be8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328044,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise today in support of an amazing foundation in our city of Surrey,\n               the Surrey Hospitals Foundation, who recently had a fundraiser titled Journey to Hope\n               to raise funds for the neonatal unit at Surrey Memorial Hospital. We heard incredible\n               stories from families who have gone through the NICU unit, who have received the support\n               of our amazing doctors and surgeons and nurses, who have literally saved the lives\n               of some of our most fragile young babies shortly after they're born. It was just incredible to see the type of support from community leaders, from community\n               members, from philanthropists and from everyday people just like you and I there for\n               a common cause, and that is to support life and to support love and to support the\n               families who bring amazing little bundles of joy to our communities. This year we saw the Surrey Hospitals Foundation raise over $1.8 million A point of note is.... What we found is that there are over 6,500 babies that are born\n               at Surrey Memorial every single year. That's basically the size of a little elementary\n               school. To see the dedicated staff and the employees of the hospital.... I cannot thank them enough, and I hope the House will also join me in thanking them\n               for their incredible work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328044","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise today in support of an amazing foundation in our city of Surrey,\n               the Surrey Hospitals Foundation, who recently had a fundraiser titled Journey to Hope\n               to raise funds for the neonatal unit at Surrey Memorial Hospital. We heard incredible\n               stories from families who have gone through the NICU unit, who have received the support\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["14156d6c53a8d0c99bad37ebe4b45f7dce4919d03066e385ef866222d0fa29ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9de83a8b4f809673425c521c24f5fb51c264fc78cff1a7d7eb4c5624095c6be2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91f518f3402e96bd213c0191","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328045,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328045","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2934fa2cee5d94fbdfa12b767b7735addd0ab49aae0ffeb9f83874f65b112285"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ecba13ec09db7458b6faf73","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328046,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order. I recognize that the standing orders that were agreed to by the House recently are\n               fresh, but I'm unclear on the procedural application applied. I'm looking for your\n               guidance and clarification for all private members as we mature in this new process.\n               Before I get into it, I seek that this clarification be on a go-forward basis, and\n               I hope that whatever ruling you provide does not affect members in a negative way. Specifically, I'm seeking clarification on Standing Order 27 on subsection 5 and subsection\n               6 of Standing Order 27a. Subsection 6 of Standing Order 27a says: \"If a member does\n               not have an eligible or designated item of business to advance in accordance with\n               Standing Order 27(5), the member shall be moved to the bottom of the placement list\n               for private members' business.\" Subsection 5 of Standing Order 27 says: It seems clear to me that \"shall be on the order paper when the member reaches the\n               third\" means that the item must be added to the order paper before they reach third\n               place to be on the paper when they reach third place. My reading of the standing order is that it does not mean that it can be added at\n               some point after they are already in third place. Further, I would like to see clarification\n               on when a private members' bill is considered \"on the order paper\" Further, I would like to seek clarification on when a private member's bill is considered\n               \"on the order paper.\" Is a private member's bill considered on the order paper after\n               notice of the bill is given, after first reading of the bill or is it after it has\n               been printed? Mr. Speaker, I hope you can provide the procedural guidance for all private members,\n               again, on a go-forward basis, only whether a member will get moved to the bottom of\n               the list if they do not have an item on the order paper already by the time they are\n               put in the third place.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328046","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order. I recognize that the standing orders that were agreed to by the House recently are\n               fresh, but I'm unclear on the procedural application applied. I'm looking for your\n               guidance and clarification for all private members as we mature in this new process.\n               Before I get into it, I seek that this clarification be on a go-forward basi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4ff1750994209c8344d2d31a2aca08aa5999c7cdf17e7bdb92d0216eac65c58f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5bf0f0e67bc4855dceb4070","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328047,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am quite pleased to rise today to speak in support of Bill 2, the Budget Measures\n               Implementation Act. Before I begin, I just want to acknowledge and thank all of the staff that make us\n               look good in our communities and the work that we do, who dedicate, really, their\n               lives to servicing our constituents, and also all of the people that stand with us,\n               whether we're in our constituencies or whether we're coming to this amazing chamber\n               to do the people's work. I extend my sincere gratitude to all of their service, because\n               it truly does transform lives. This budget that we're talking about, through the Budget Measures Implementation Act,\n               is about protecting the services that people really rely on. It's a bit more than\n               that. It's not just about protecting the services. It's about continuing to build\n               on the record level of investment in infrastructure, in health care, in education,\n               in housing, so that we can improve our communities, our standard of living, meet the\n               needs of the people across the province. I know that for the past eight years, this government has been investing in communities\n               across British Columbia, and it's to benefit everyday British Columbians, not just\n               the specific few but everyday British Columbians. I want to take a quick trip down memory lane for what prompted some of these key investments\n               that have truly changed the lives of people, including people that I love and that\n               I care about, the people that are closest to me. I take a trip back in my mind to\n               my brother's challenges crossing the Port Mann Bridge, at the time, which was tolled\n               quite heavily. And it was to the general discontent of the majority of my community. I mean, who wants to pay to use a bridge every single day just to get to your job\n               that provides you and your family sustenance? I don't think anybody ever wants to\n               do that. But as an individual, my brother, who was helping build this province, had\n               to go over that bridge every single day. He complained to me: \"You know what? Going over that bridge was something that affected\n               my preference and where I would like to take a job.\" Actually, I was quite young,\n               and I wanted to be cognizant, because it builds up over a year. It's in the multiple\n               thousands actually. I remember MSP premiums and my co-workers, my colleagues, having to pay that. It truly\n               was a burden. I think back to my mom, who's been an educator her entire career, an early childhood\n               educator, a Montessori teacher who's educating children in their most formative years\n               of their lives, a Montessori teacher with great hopes and aspirations to help shape\n               our future, who wasn't even making a decent wage at the time. It was heartbreaking\n               to see how much she put into it, as I know many educators do. It was difficult for\n               her, even, to see some of the parents who would struggle to pay their child care fees. It wasn't a good time. I saw a lot of people in my community, my closest loved ones....\n               I did see them struggle. That's why the investments that this government has made\n               over the years are really transformative on people's lives. I saw that happen. Just to get back to some of these challenges, look at the tolls on the bridge. When\n               we went out there and spoke to people and we heard that this was not what it is that\n               people wanted.... They couldn't afford it. The B.C. government of the day.... We removed\n               the tolls on the bridges. We got rid of the MSP premiums. Not just an inconvenience,\n               they were major burdens on people's families. My mom was the beneficiary of the wage increases for ECE teachers directly. The parents\n               that she knew who were putting their kids through child care were the beneficiaries\n               of the early stages of the child care plan from its inception. All of these investments\n               that we're talking about had a direct impact, and they matter. This budget is about\n               building on those investments. These investments have been poured in despite all of the challenges that we face.\n               We're talking about some of the most challenging times in our province's history,\n               in national history, global history. I mean things like COVID. COVID-19 really stopped\n               our lives. One day we realized, oh my gosh, this is something like we've never seen\n               before. The impacts of that are still felt today in our communities. I'm talking about floods, wildfires, and now we're still facing challenges. We're\n               talking about a trade war that's threatening attacks on us, dependent on what a certain\n               individual feels like when he wakes up in the morning. We're good, then we're not\n               good. You know, affecting our economy every single day. You know what? Looking back, I'm so grateful to be a British Columbian because we\n               have seen our communities come together, helping each other. We have seen our communities\n               lifting each other up. I want to take this moment to thank every single British Columbian who has stood up\n               to get us through some of these challenges. In the pandemic, we had heroic health\n               care workers, day in and day out, who spent time away from their families, put themselves\n               in harm's way to help others, to save lives. I want to thank the member for Vancouver-Kingsway, who at the time was the Minister of Health. He stood up every single evening,\n               every single day with Dr. Bonnie Henry to give us an in-depth analysis of what was\n               going on in the province. There was immense work that was put in through the Ministry\n               of Health, through doctors, through nurses, through all of the workers, the essential\n               workers in our hospitals, in our communities. I want to thank them. I just want to\n               thank them We had neighbours who were helping each other through floods, through wildfires, through\n               some of the most horrific moments of each other's lives. All of these things affected\n               us, and they still continue to do so. It's a difficult time. I completely feel that.\n               It is a difficult time all across Canada, in every single province in this country.\n               And you know what? Even though we have the second lowest net GDP-to-debt ratio, families\n               are still feeling it. Families are feeling it. With Budget 2026, it provides $37.7 billion over three years for capital projects\n               like schools, hospitals, roads, bridges, transit, because we know we have to keep\n               our economy going. I support a budget that cares for people in my community, in Surrey. It's about investing\n               in our kids. It's about investing in health care. It's about expanding opportunity,\n               figuring out creative and innovative solutions and partnerships with other sectors,\n               even non-profit organizations, the business sector so that communities have what they\n               need to thrive, and that again, we are working together. This year's budget continues\n               to deliver some of the most historic investment that Surrey has ever seen. I'll just start off with health care. We had this constant conversation about us needing\n               a new hospital in Surrey for many years, actually, probably for a decade. We knew\n               that we were about to expand in population and growth, and we needed that. It's unfortunate\n               that the place where it could have been was sold off. It's unfortunate. But we had\n               to get back to the drawing board. We had to fix the mistakes of that previous government.\n               So that's exactly what we did. We're continuing to deliver that new Surrey hospital\n               and B.C. cancer centre. It's a $2.88 billion project. It's not a small project. It's a state-of-the-art facility,\n               which includes 168 inpatient beds, advanced imaging, surgical suites, oncology services\n               and, yes, an emergency department as well. I've heard misinformation out there about\n               not having an emergency department. It certainly does. Let's just correct the record\n               here. I've been to the site multiple times to see the progress and to see how many skilled\n               trades workers, construction workers, are working at this site. For some of them,\n               this is their first job. They're being trained in partnership with the developer,\n               with the contractors, with the government to unlock opportunities for workers who\n               are just starting off in our skilled trades sector and our construction sector in\n               general. I'm incredibly excited to see this state-of-the-art facility come to life\n               when it's done. In my own riding of Surrey City Centre, we have made some enormous and continue to make some enormous investments in making\n               it a place of educational excellence. We're talking about the new medical school,\n               the first in over 50 years, coming to Simon Fraser University — in 55 years, to be\n               exact — which is going to train 648 future doctors in a 12-storey facility that includes\n               a family clinic and child care spaces. Because we're talking about education for the future. We know people want to have\n               families and still be able to go to school and still train to become doctors, and\n               we need to accommodate that. And so we build with that. This project in itself is going to create over 3,000 jobs. As we see it open in 2030,\n               we have an interim space This project in itself is going to create over 3,000 jobs. As we see it open in 2030,\n               we have an interim space that's ongoing, ready to accept new medical students this\n               coming year. I am so excited for the first cohort of 48 students that are going to be attending\n               the first medical school here in B.C. in over 55 years. I really am. And I know the\n               families in my riding, the families across Surrey, are happy about that too. Because\n               they want to be able to live, they want to be able to work, they want to be able to\n               play in their city and locally. And you know what? Also a special place in my heart is the cardiac catheterization\n               suites that were just opened in Surrey Memorial Hospital. A person who's very near\n               and dear to me just recently had a procedure at one of those cath lab beds. Just to\n               see that that transfer didn't need to happen to Royal Columbian.... Because that's what\n               needed to happen before. Patients had to be transported over the bridge to Royal Columbian,\n               and it just was not ideal for anybody getting treatment at cath labs that was living\n               south of the Fraser River. And we're not done. We're going to continue to invest through our acute care tower,\n               which is going to expand capacity. I heard members talk about that today. It's going\n               to expand capacity at Surrey Memorial Hospital, including specialized services, women's\n               health, pediatric services. So there is a lot more coming in terms of investments\n               for health to really expand and make health care services available to people living\n               south of the Fraser. I just want to speak quickly about mental health care and our investments in mental\n               health care with this budget, and protecting the health care services that people\n               count on. We want to make sure that we have the resources to keep hiring the doctors\n               and the nurses and the health care workers that we need so that people can rely on\n               getting care when they need it. This budget provides $131 million to support mental health and addictions treatment,\n               including expanding ACT teams all across the province, 100 new involuntary care beds\n               in Surrey and Prince George, and really expanding mental health supports across our\n               province and in Surrey as well. I was just at an announcement to open up ten new treatment\n               beds at a detox facility in my riding as well. I feel quite lucky. One of the things that really is so near and dear to me is our continued expansion\n               of Foundry centres all across our province. Surrey City Centre just opened a new Foundry centre, which was so needed in our community, a brand new\n               area of help and mental health supports for our youth aged up to 24 years of age. We're going to continue to expand, through this budget, new Foundry facilities across\n               the province. We have 19 open right now. I think we're going to get 16 more that are\n               on the way. These services, which are accessible in many different languages, which\n               are culturally safe and informed mental health care and primary health care, life\n               skills training, all under one roof.... These are transformative spaces for our community. So we're not going to just step back, because we understand the crucial need for these\n               services, especially during times of global instability, economic instability. We\n               understand the need for these very crucial services. I just want to pivot over to some of the investments in education in Surrey and the\n               historic investments that we've already made and continue to make. Clayton Heights\n               Secondary. We're doubling capacity there with new additions to the school that has\n               spaces for Indigenous learning, for child care Clayton Heights Secondary. We're doubling capacity there with new additions to the\n               school that has spaces for Indigenous learning, for child care, and this project that's\n               going to open its doors in 2029 is going to be a welcome addition to the Clayton Heights\n               community. And Fleetwood Park too. I see the member from Fleetwood is here in the chamber with us, who I know is very happy about expanding room for 800 more students at Fleetwood\n               Park Secondary, which is going to be completed in just a couple of years. Projects like this just mean less crowding in our classrooms, in our schools, at a\n               point where Surrey's population has really exploded in such a short period of time. We know that we\n               have to act and we have to act quick, and this budget ensures that we continue with\n               that type of work. Education, whether it be early childhood education or whether it be elementary, secondary....\n               We all know that our post-secondary students require extra assistance at times and extra care, and they do deserve that. When I was at Kwantlen Polytechnic University to unveil the new $143 million student housing and dining project, I just realized how many families that's ultimately going to impact. I mean, 358\n               beds, 161-seat dining hall, hundreds of jobs in the creation of that space — which\n               is almost up to, I would say, 800 direct and indirect jobs that it's going to create. It's going to be the first student housing that KPU has ever had, and we've seen the transformation of KPU from Kwantlen University\n               College to Kwantlen Polytechnic University. We can't stop there. It can't be stagnant.\n               It has to continue. It's important for families, especially during this time of global instability, to\n               be able to get around with ease. There are more and more families that are switching\n               from their car commutes to using public transit. I know that every time I have any\n               meetings or any events in downtown Vancouver, the SkyTrain is the way that I go downtown. I would not get into a car and drive downtown. Many\n               reasons why, but I fully support taking public transit because it's so convenient. We're trying to make it even more convenient for people outside of the Vancouver downtown\n               core to get there and back home, and so the Surrey-Langley SkyTrain extension, which is 16 kilometres of an expansion of the Expo Line, is so important to families in Surrey, families in Langley and beyond, because it really unlocks the opportunity for jobs, for opportunities. These are not just commutes; they're livelihoods. I referenced earlier in my speech\n               that even something as simple as tolls actually made me reconsider the opportunities\n               in my life. Really bridging that connection that previously wasn't there is going\n               to unlock economic opportunities and benefits for communities outside of Vancouver\n               and Surrey and Langley. This budget supports that development. It supports the very strong need for that type\n               of development and innovation that we need in our province right now. Really, when you take all of these things together, these projects, they represent\n               billions of dollars. Billions of dollars in investments. Tens of thousands of jobs.\n               And a future where our schools, our hospitals, our universities — that they're ready\n               for the next generation. That they're places of excellence, they're innovative, they're\n               creative, and that they're a draw for people, not just locally, not just out of town,\n               but a draw for the rest of the world. We have people in our communities who are leaders We have people in our communities who are leaders in different sectors and fields,\n               and we have to invest in them, which is why this budget doesn't just support core\n               services, doesn't just preserve them, but it looks to opportunity and advancing opportunity\n               for the amazing people in this province who are going to take us forward. So while\n               we protect our critical services, such as health care and education, we just want\n               to make sure that people get the support that they need, when they need it. As the Parliamentary Secretary for Mental Health and Addictions and Anti-Racism Initiatives,\n               that is the work that I do every single day. It's finding opportunities, creative\n               projects that bring our community together. So when I speak about things like Foundry\n               or mental health care, it comes from deep within me, because I see how many lives\n               it transforms every single day. Every single day I see it in the youth that use Foundry services, who say to me that\n               they never thought that they could feel so safe getting treatment, getting health\n               care — that things are so accessible that they just have to take out their phone.\n               They just have to look for appointments, in the comfort of their own room, feeling\n               like they can finally not be alone. These are the things that we need to ensure that we keep investing in, and that's\n               what Budget 2026 really does here, so I'm proud to support Bill 2 for the implementation.\n               There's so much here that we need to really highlight, because our commitment to British\n               Columbians has never wavered. It never has, and it never will. And at a time like\n               this, where there are multiple threats on the horizon.... We are going through that right now. We see what's happening in the world, and really,\n               I'm worried about what that may bring, just like the families of Surrey, British Columbia,\n               just like the families of British Columbia everywhere. But I know, and I am confident,\n               that we can get through this when we get through it together. We've done it before;\n               we can do it again. When we roll out a budget that protects what matters most to people, it strengthens\n               the system that people rely on. It builds a more resilient, more equitable, more caring\n               province, but it also recognizes that we have a lot more work to do. I don't think\n               that there's anybody on this side of the House that thinks: \"Drop the budget, we're\n               done, and yay.\" I don't think any of us believes that. We're fully in understanding of the challenges\n               that we face right now, and I commend all of the members in this House — all of them,\n               both sides — for the work that they do every day. We may not see eye to eye on things\n               but I truly feel as though all members of this House care for British Columbians. I'm looking forward to getting to know all of the other members more, to be able to\n               work with them on some creative and innovative ways on how we move forward, because\n               there is no other way. Today I thank you for entertaining my thoughts on this bill. Again, I just want to give a big thank-you to my staff here at the Whip's office,\n               my staff in my constituency office and all of the people who uphold the work that\n               comes, not just out of this chamber but out of the constituency offices, out of the\n               ministers' offices, out of the public service offices. I don't think that I could find a bunch that I could be more proud of, and it's been\n               an honour of a lifetime. I never thought I would be here, but I truly am thankful\n               for everyone that surrounds me.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328047","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am quite pleased to rise today to speak in support of Bill 2, the Budget Measures\n               Implementation Act. Before I begin, I just want to acknowledge and thank all of the staff that make us\n               look good in our communities and the work that we do, who dedicate, really, their\n               lives to servicing our constituents, and also all of the people that stand with us,\n  ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1cd1b5c07fc9c1569c1e14196680d0d6accff0f83d16b54d23772d1eb62dcc38"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5b318b1ab6716bce0c9e2f2514abe23263c32814580deb0d5dd3c8f50a37f4d6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbdc789ae195dd463830babe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360882,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360882","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01ffaf028c362c53716f524b69985ff64e5a9f7797eeea0ce6f8364852b7e044"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f123a2c0eb8ec236765e7005","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361014,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Children and Family Development and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361014","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Children and Family Development and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b60df70be1d1f14f5b8fadca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361015,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361015","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section A, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5b833e848e7dc3cd3a14b43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415816,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin, I just want to give a huge shout-out and a thank-you to our incredible\n               legislative intern, Abedah Siddiqui, for contributing her thoughts and words to this\n               statement. Uplifting the voices of young leaders like Abedah is a responsibility that\n               we can all share in this House. I have risen to mark Eid ul-Fitr, a celebration that follows a month of reflection,\n               discipline and renewal for Muslims in British Columbia and around the world. Eid reminds\n               us that faith is not only a private practice but also a public responsibility. The\n               lesson of the holy month of Ramadan calls on us to care for one another, to stand\n               against injustice and to actively contribute to the well-being of our communities. It is a time that teaches humility in moments of success, patience in times of hardship\n               and generosity even when we ourselves may feel uncertain. This year many celebrated\n               while carrying out the weight of global uncertainty and local challenges. Across the\n               world, families continue to navigate conflict, loss and displacement. Here at home, too many still confront Islamophobia and the quiet barriers that limit\n               belonging. Yet history has shown us that the Muslim community does not retreat in\n               the face of adversity. Instead, it builds, it serves and it uplifts everybody around\n               it. Across B.C., Muslims come from every corner of the world and various walks of\n               life. It is an incredibly diverse community. They bring with them languages, traditions\n               and lived experiences that enrich our shared society. Across this province, Muslims are already strengthening our society as educators,\n               health care workers, volunteers, entrepreneurs and community leaders. Their contributions\n               are essential to the progress and prosperity of British Columbia. As we celebrated, we were reminded of a few things. Eid calls us to reflect on what\n               more we can do on top of what we're already doing. It is a moment to encourage greater\n               civic participation, to support our youth in finding their voices and their paths,\n               to engage in public service and to ensure that our democratic institutions reflect\n               the diversity of the people that they serve. Representation matters. Let me repeat\n               that again. Representation matters. When communities fully participate in civic life, we build stronger, more inclusive\n               policies and a more just society for everybody. Our perspectives, experiences and\n               values are not only welcome in public life they are essential to building the institutions\n               that truly reflect the people that they serve. Faith teaches us that leadership is a form of service. Faith teaches us to respect\n               leadership. Faith also reminds us that shaping the future is not a responsibility\n               of a few but is a shared duty of everybody. Over the weekend, our Surrey NDP MLAs held our annual Eid ul-Fitr celebration, and\n               we saw an incredible show of unity Over the weekend, our Surrey NDP MLAs held our annual Eid ul-Fitr celebration, and\n               we saw an incredible show of unity and celebration with constituents of all faiths\n               and backgrounds. It wasn't just about Eid. It was about the joy, the laughter and\n               the love that we all share as we ate, as we sang and as we danced together — together\n               as a community. Because at the heart of celebration is community, regardless of which\n               faith is being celebrated or which event is being celebrated, and truly, at the heart\n               of faith is community. To all of those who celebrated Eid ul-Fitr, Eid Mubarak, I pray that this year's Ramadan\n               and Eid encouraged all of us to build a more just, compassionate and united British\n               Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415816","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Before I begin, I just want to give a huge shout-out and a thank-you to our incredible\n               legislative intern, Abedah Siddiqui, for contributing her thoughts and words to this\n               statement. Uplifting the voices of young leaders like Abedah is a responsibility that\n               we can all share in this House. I have risen to mark Eid ul-Fitr, a celebration that follows a mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["938d4187d5619a21ee2de04bbc7aea9b641cae7f57dbe13444ad6e96f9878bae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3106e3bc70e3b8020153e194d772e1f9ab557c8992c18947423fe397316638e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37b5f06a11d4df234f625dc4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415817,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am so pleased to see that in the gallery we are joined here today by Ammar Randhawa,\n               Gurmukh Silla, Roman Singh and Keerith Jutla. They are here from the Vaapsi Seva Society,\n               specifically the Vaapsi sober living program, which is a community-led, culturally-grounded\n               initiative that tackles addiction and the complex factors that sustain addiction. Now, vaapsi means \"return,\" and this program is specifically designed to support South\n               Asian men in their journey of return to health, to stability and to purpose. It combines\n               an evidence-based model and with wise principles from Sikhi, namely seva, simran It combines an evidence-based model and with wise principles from Sikhi, namely seva,\n               simran, and sangat. This reflects a model that is not only effective but also deeply\n               human. Will the House join me in welcoming these amazing men who do this noble work in our\n               communities?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415817","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am so pleased to see that in the gallery we are joined here today by Ammar Randhawa,\n               Gurmukh Silla, Roman Singh and Keerith Jutla. They are here from the Vaapsi Seva Society,\n               specifically the Vaapsi sober living program, which is a community-led, culturally-grounded\n               initiative that tackles addiction and the complex factors that sustain addiction. Now,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87626f8a97d0d5142f5253394056a56dc31362a629385aa02bdddd55bccda255"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1f7d563b1a8b9bc10a4a3149f86ad9f87f736719bc4cc6c5a36f55d5e1a6e469"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0709a28c77955dbb54f7c75a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415818,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am so pleased to rise to speak in favour of Bill 13, an absolutely essential tool\n               to protect places of worship across our province. I'm hoping that we can all agree\n               on the principle of this bill. I'm hearing quite a bit of agreement already, which\n               I'm pleased about. I'm hoping to dive into some of the principles behind why this is so important for\n               our communities. It's not something that was just dreamt up overnight. It's certainly\n               something that was as a result of significant consultation and feedback from communities\n               themselves, faith communities. Now, I just want to highlight that our democracy is built on the fundamental principles\n               of inclusion and of respect. This includes the ability for you to practise your faith\n               without fear, without intimidation, in safety, especially in sanctuaries like places\n               of worship. Really, places of worship are important centres of community in our broader communities.\n               They're especially important for immigrants. I was just recently speaking with a group,\n               a racialized group, who told me directly, and they said: \"Our folks who are newcomers\n               to this country, the first place that they will either reach out to is their local\n               church or their local community centre.\" These are some of the initial lines of connection\n               that people will have with their community. Of course, the burden and the expectation on these places are quite high, but these\n               are exceptional places to build connections. That's why people trust places of worship. Oftentimes, you will see that there will not just be faith services. There will be\n               community events. There will be classes. I've even seen people do yoga at masjids.\n               These are all-around feel-good places for people to come and connect with one another\n               and take care of themselves. Really, these are built on these fundamental principles\n               of inclusion and respect, and that is the heart of who we are as Canadians, as British\n               Columbians. But in recent years, we've seen these increased threats, increased harassment, targeting\n               places of worship in our communities. I'm saying all places of worship — churches, synagogues, masjids, gurdwaras, Hindu\n               temples, Buddhist temples. Across the board, we're seeing a very concerning trend,\n               and it's not letting up. That's why it was important for us to be able to And that's why it was important for us to be able to hear from communities, from our\n               faith leaders in our communities, and ask them, \"What can we do to help you? What\n               can we do to support you?\" And that is why this government has introduced this legislation\n               to strengthen the protections that preserve the safe access to these places of worship\n               for people who are attending their places of faith, because we know a lot of the fear\n               and the stress that they feel is when they are coming to their place of worship. I was actually quite proud to stand alongside faith leaders from masjids, synagogues,\n               churches, gurdwaras, temples, and support the introduction of this bill not too long\n               ago in the Hall of Honour. And we know that these new protections are going to ensure\n               that people can gather in prayer, in celebration, in peace, while respecting the right\n               to peaceful protest. And this is part of our government's ongoing efforts to protect\n               people in places that are meant to be safe, that are meant to be accessible for everybody. So back to just seeing the concerning trend of this increasing rise in hatred and\n               hate-motivated incidents targeted at such places of worship, I just want to share\n               how impactful it has been for people in my community to have to deal with some of\n               these hateful behaviours. You know, I've heard stories of people who intend to disrupt the entry of worshippers\n               to their place of worship, purposely ensuring that they're not openly trying to very\n               in-your-face block people but at the same time, pretending to just be in the way,\n               intimidating, using foul language, making people uncomfortable. And the worst part\n               is that they target our seniors, our kids, people who they feel are more vulnerable.\n               There are individuals who exist like that in our communities. That's not okay. People who hold up these places of worship really practice the values of love for\n               everybody, and they're not the ones to go out there and be just as nasty to people.\n               That's not who they are. And we know that. We have to step up. We have to be able\n               to protect them. We have to be able to put our foot down and say, \"That is not acceptable.\"\n               So we have to find a creative way to do this. And I hear from the other side that\n               there's agreement in principle, but that there are already ways to do it. But this is a way to do it. So I encourage everybody to support that, because when I hear from youth in my community\n               that they used to go to church with their grandparents every Sunday but are now afraid\n               to do so because they saw somebody with a loudspeaker saying all sorts of nasty things\n               near the entrance gate of their church, and now their grandparents don't want to go\n               anymore because they don't want to have to hear that vitriol, that's upsetting. That's\n               upsetting. That breaks the fabric of what brings our community together, and we can't allow that\n               to happen. That happens at our masjids too. That happens at our gurdwaras too in Surrey.\n               So it's a very serious issue, and we have to do all that we can do to protect these\n               places of worship. And that is what this legislation is intended to do, to protect eligible places of\n               worship while minimally impairing freedom of expression rights. And as government,\n               we are trying to find a balance between upholding people's Charter-protected rights\n               to free expression and allowing people to access their places of worship. Part of\n               the reason why we chose this existing We know that more needs to be done to help in other places, to help people and organizations\n               that are targeted by hate, and we're continually exploring ways to do so. I'll just\n               address that I heard that there are already laws in place to address this now, and,\n               you know, why do we need this? Well, if everything is rosy and happy and dandy.... I\n               don't think that's the case because, otherwise, faith communities would not be telling\n               us that, would not be disagreeing with that. Whatever we have now, it's not enough. That's why we need this legislation. We spoke\n               to communities. We spoke to faith leaders. We spoke to faith organizations, and this\n               is what they want. We heard loud and clear from them. We want to be able to have some\n               signage that tells people, that deters people from thinking that they can engage in\n               any form of behaviour. People should be educated to know what they can and what they\n               cannot do in sanctuaries. It should be made very clear to people. You can't assume that somebody knows. Yeah, somebody may actually not know that what\n               they're doing is harmful to another person too. Really, one could argue that, but\n               this clearly defines that. So that is why I am such a strong supporter of this legislation,\n               because this was a community-driven, community-led process informing us, to guide\n               us to where we are here today, debating the principle of this in this House — which\n               I'm again hoping that everybody agrees with that principle. We have seen and we have witnessed a worrying rise in police-reported hate crimes\n               over the last several years. Despite these increases in hate crimes, the ones that\n               I'm talking about right now, they remain amongst the least reported offences. Black,\n               Indigenous, people of colour, those of East and South Asian descent, other racialized,\n               Jewish, Muslim, LGBTQ2S+ British Columbians continue to be targeted. It's clear to\n               me that we have a lot more work to do to ensure that people feel comfortable even\n               reporting hate crimes to the police. I'm pleased to say that B.C. is the only place in Canada with a dedicated hate crimes\n               team, the RCMP B.C. Hate Crimes unit, which is responsible for investigating, for\n               responding to hate-motivated offences across the province. Again, we see that it works.\n               We see that it helps. So what do you do? You support. I was so glad that our government took expansion, to expand that unit, to provide\n               five additional officers. This just goes back to the community-led, the partner-encouraged\n               way in which we bring forth legislation and in the way in which we shape policy across\n               the province. Really, the goal is protection, protecting our communities. I want to thank all of those individuals, all of those organizations who took the\n               time out to have such difficult and heavy conversations about these issues, such difficult\n               conversation that that they were put to tears recalling some of the incidents that\n               they have had to go through just simply trying to get closer to God in a place that\n               they see as a house of God. I am a woman of faith, and I'm quite proud to say so. When I think of the protection\n               of my faith, I can't single that out as being the only thing that's important to me.\n               It has to be everybody's faith that should be protected not just mine. What hurts\n               somebody in a synagogue So I have a message to British Columbians: if you ever experience hateful behaviour,\n               if you ever witness or if you are the recipient of hateful behaviour or if you witness\n               a hate crime, please report it. Please report it to your local police. It is important\n               that we understand, that we record, that we give you the supports that you need and\n               then strengthen our legislation to protect you. Our government has no tolerance for any kind of hate, crime or discrimination against\n               any group or individual in B.C. We know that a single incident can even affect not\n               just one person but a group and also a larger community, and that hate can oftentimes\n               be targeted. That's why we have worked with police to expand accessible, online hate-reporting\n               options in multiple languages to reduce barriers to reporting, so that people can\n               access these services in a way that feels easier for them. These tools, these pieces of legislation are so important to people because there's\n               one thing that I've noticed about places of worship in my community. They're run by\n               elders, they are run by dedicated volunteers, they are run by youth, and all of these\n               individuals put the love in there. They don't have a lot of money. Yet they put in\n               everything that they have to not only sustain but to really expand their community\n               within that place and beyond. It was important to us when we had heard at the time that there were acts of vandalism,\n               that people were coming in the night, spray painting nasty words on walls, really\n               some things that are so disturbing.... I mean, I definitely can't repeat them in this\n               house. It would be unparliamentary language. I won't because I don't think anybody\n               needs to hear that. What we decided to do was to deliver grants to enhance safety for groups that are\n               targeted by hate or by violence. This was the anti-hate stream within the civil forfeiture\n               grant program, which provided grants to eligible places of worship that had experienced\n               such type of hate and who had sustained damages to their sites, and for those who\n               were seeking to enhance their security measures to protect themselves from these types\n               of things in the future. I'm quite pleased to know that there are many places of worship that actually utilized\n               that program. That program continues. Also, what I know, from my interactions with\n               my community, has been really helpful, especially in places of worship — because this\n               is where the conversations really simmer and get started — is the introduction of\n               our racist incident help line. Some of our communities, their faiths, their places of worship, are often targeted\n               by very racist behaviour. Some of the things that have happened to them have been\n               because of ignorance, because of arrogance, maybe not knowing who they are but nonetheless While I'm glad that the individuals, who have since then accessed supports via the\n               help line.... It's sad to see that this resource is needed in our communities. I agree with some of the members on the other side. We should live in a world where\n               none of this has to exist. I agree. I wish that we did not have to do this at all.\n               I wish everyone cared for each other. I wish people did not hate on each other. I\n               wish people helped make each other feel safe. But that's not the reality of where\n               we are. When we bring in legislation, it has to be thoughtful. It has to respect the Charter\n               of Rights and Freedoms. You can't just really do anything that you want and put down\n               words on a piece of paper. It has to be thoughtful. There are, yes, sometimes limitations with what it is that you can do. But the important\n               thing is that you're working with communities to be able to support them in what it\n               is that they want. There is no uneven application of this. This applies, again, to every place of worship\n               under the definition. So I really just want to stress why it's important for us to\n               see it that way, because I think that there is a notion out there that this somehow\n               only protects certain communities, certain places of worship. That's not true. Communities may have questions, and I know that we're happy to answer. But in this\n               stage, in this second reading, it should be a very easy yes. It should be a very easy\n               aye. I really can't imagine that somebody would disagree with the principle of this,\n               so it is really, in fact, very simple. Just looking to the future of how I see our places of worship really beautifying our\n               communities, which they already do.... But legislation like this gives me hope for them\n               to be able to continue to enrich our lives, not just as legislators but as human beings,\n               as members of the community, as family members, as parents, as daughters, as brothers,\n               as sisters. Really, that type of love you can't find in a lot of places. So for individuals in\n               our communities, our faith leaders.... Those who encourage love in our community deserve\n               love and much more. This is one of the ways in which we can express that, actually. I'm so pleased that this has made it to the floor and that we are engaging in debate\n               on this. But this is not over. This is, again, just one thing that can help us move\n               in the right direction to protect our communities. There's a lot of work to be done. I really caution anybody from minimizing the impact of something like this, because\n               when you minimize the impact of this legislation, you minimize the feedback of the\n               individuals who want this. Those were our faith leaders. Those were our faith communities.\n               They are our faith leaders. They are our faith communities. So we're going to continue\n               listening to them in the development of all subsequent legislation. But as of right now, I think that this is one of the most thoughtful ways in which\n               we could protect our places of worship. I encourage everybody in the House to join\n               me in supporting this and to work on solutions I encourage everybody in the House to join me in supporting this and work on solutions\n               together. You know, we don't have to constantly go back and forth in arguing about\n               everything in this chamber. There are some things that we can all agree on. It doesn't\n               need to be a fight. This is one of those things. We hear beautiful prayers in this House every single day. It's such a reminder for\n               me and, I think, everybody, all members of this House, about the principles, a faith,\n               that guide us through life or that, maybe, should guide us through life. It's beautiful\n               for all of us. But when we're talking about this right now, some of the very places of worship in\n               which that prayer or those prayers are repeated every single day, morning, noon, night,\n               why wouldn't we want to protect that? Why wouldn't we want to support this wholeheartedly\n               and say: \"You know what? Yes, we have more work to do, but this is going to get us\n               there? Absolutely.\" I encourage all of our colleagues to support this bill. Thank you for listening.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415818","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am so pleased to rise to speak in favour of Bill 13, an absolutely essential tool\n               to protect places of worship across our province. I'm hoping that we can all agree\n               on the principle of this bill. I'm hearing quite a bit of agreement already, which\n               I'm pleased about. I'm hoping to dive into some of the principles behind why this is so important for\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e33d333746330a410d384ddce986ad680ce18cdd9096a05ecf79eceda56e308d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87a973a7e16434cfb0a3822cd199e200e67b05eeea8281b2bdb72eb309f36380"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa570e70a1ac025ea71dc4d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415819,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm so pleased to welcome in the gallery here today Jeremy Sabell from Stenberg College\n               in Surrey, as well as Ben Colling from Rhodes Wellness College. Stenberg College's presence in Surrey has helped establish Surrey as a regional education\n               and workforce hub, with the college contributing directly to local talent development\n               and economic activity. I am so pleased to be able to meet with these gentlemen later\n               on today to see how they're are going to be contributing to my community and also\n               the accessible education pathways at Stenberg for students who go on to work as psychotherapists\n               and other jobs in this caring profession. Will the House join me in making them feel very welcome. Will the House join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415819","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm so pleased to welcome in the gallery here today Jeremy Sabell from Stenberg College\n               in Surrey, as well as Ben Colling from Rhodes Wellness College. Stenberg College's presence in Surrey has helped establish Surrey as a regional education\n               and workforce hub, with the college contributing directly to local talent development\n               and economic activity. I am","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f094a066b2425802f0550e087480836eba19543293da236f6a5e839b63ec58cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6fa622d01b489028ab103a765403b5beb41ab7b69a2e0e0c82b2c1b77df1a41c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ecad485ebe108c97886dfd67","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720546,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720546","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Part-time students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:387668","label":"Part-time students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["010338eebdc69abbb09cfa443c7d7141b218393eec23c11640b012974d1a92d2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7ccd31e1833937c9e9ed7e8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720548,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am absolutely honoured to introduce three very special people in this House. Today we are joined by my parents: my father, Seydashik Alisha; my mother, Shahar\n               Bano; and my brother Syed Rehan Alisha. I don't think that my parents nor I would have imagined that 20 years after we arrived\n               to this country, their mildly opinionated daughter would somehow end up in the B.C.\n               Legislature. As I examine their life, their sacrifices and their experiences, my challenges\n               and my experiences absolutely pale with regards to their sacrifices that they've made\n               for me, my brother and my sister in this country. I just want to give them a huge thank-you. Thank you for giving me the courage, the\n               strength and the teachings to always speak in the face of injustice and to stand for\n               what's right in every aspect of my life. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720548","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am absolutely honoured to introduce three very special people in this House. Today we are joined by my parents: my father, Seydashik Alisha; my mother, Shahar\n               Bano; and my brother Syed Rehan Alisha. I don't think that my parents nor I would have imagined that 20 years after we arrived\n               to this country, their mildly opinionated daughter would somehow end up in the B.C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["503a0df7fcac58d7bd98a4256783dfad5837c8e297fa50dbe5ccc6f4636f5608"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e9b28ffacc3967a4e21aa3faf005e048bc41ec6cee64d02c0102eb1f5e735ec0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-33bcd7c76c20b68c0707650e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720562,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Financial Literacy Day here in British Columbia. Financial\n               literacy affects every stage of life. It shapes how young people manage their first\n               paycheque, how families budget for housing and child care, how small businesses plan\n               for growth and how seniors prepare for retirement. When people have the knowledge\n               and the confidence to make informed financial decisions, they are better equipped\n               to weather challenges and plan for their futures. Rising costs of living, digital banking, online investing and the growing risk of\n               scams means that people are often asked to make high-stakes choices without having\n               all the tools that they need. Financial literacy helps people recognize risks, ask\n               the right questions and avoid decisions that could have lasting consequences. Here in British Columbia, financial literacy and financial education are already part\n               of the K-to-12 education system. These skills are embedded across learning areas,\n               such as mathematics, skills and technology, and career education classes. Through\n               these subjects, students are learning to plan, budget, analyze costs and make decisions\n               connected to real-world situations. I would like to recognize the many educators, community organizations, non-profits,\n               credit unions and volunteers who work year-round to support financial education. Their\n               efforts, whether through classroom teaching, community workshops or one-on-one support,\n               help make financial information more accessible and understandable for people of all\n               ages. Small steps like learning how interest works, setting a savings goal or planning\n               ahead can add up to greater security and resilience over time. On this Financial Literacy Day, I encourage all of us to reflect on our own financial\n               knowledge and share what we know with others, whether with a student, a colleague,\n               a family member or a neighbour. Even small conversations can make a meaningful difference.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720562","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Financial Literacy Day here in British Columbia. Financial\n               literacy affects every stage of life. It shapes how young people manage their first\n               paycheque, how families budget for housing and child care, how small businesses plan\n               for growth and how seniors prepare for retirement. When people have the knowledge\n               and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dde75952e9bfc7865114a7e8f7a1da5db354499d863963042bf5f8b9c8f8e243"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["560b8b9f11093abacd3575d425452c2aaf47f449975c60c8dd7b82a5ca07680e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f8fcea803fa4107dd133f71","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721654,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin, I just want to extend my thoughts and my well wishes to the members'\n               constituent, Ms. Sutton, and relay my sympathies for what has happened and the things\n               that she's had to deal with since in her recovery, and I wish her continued recovery.\n               I know it's not easy to at times listen to debate, especially when we're introducing\n               certain technical commentary. But I think I speak on behalf of all members of this side of the House when I say\n               that we truly do care and want to ensure that any changes or amendments made to legislation\n               are done in the appropriate way, which is why we're having a fulsome discussion here. Now with the member's intent of the bill, I thank the member for his advocacy, not\n               just for his constituent, but for others who may be in this particular type of situation,\n               and that he has chosen to make his private member bill about something that matters\n               to people. Under the previous government, we knew that the insurance model that we had was not\n               working. We heard that directly from people, from constituents, from British Columbians.\n               We understood that something does have to change. There were really horror stories\n               about people not being able to get the care that they needed when they needed it,\n               support to help them recover, support to help them heal. It really did not feel to them as though benefits were going to them. It felt like\n               it was going to costly legal....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721654","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Before I begin, I just want to extend my thoughts and my well wishes to the members'\n               constituent, Ms. Sutton, and relay my sympathies for what has happened and the things\n               that she's had to deal with since in her recovery, and I wish her continued recovery.\n               I know it's not easy to at times listen to debate, especially when we're introducing\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f01fb1db883640586ffc4b9b93870ce9efc58517320e5a1f252da29d9952e7ec"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["68bf1e60b096da242505bcb2446f20401f88268908de5ea4cc09b8ef566214a8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7990b78a36491b2930698353","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721657,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721657","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c154b72d64bd2c4b8429b40b08a54a97903d4e44e489fe245862592b6da8ffff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa6f26ec1cdc6cd4ee15bf28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721659,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an incredibly dark day here at the B.C. Legislature. I never thought that I would\n               hear such disgusting rhetoric from the member from Kelowna....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721659","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's an incredibly dark day here at the B.C. Legislature. I never thought that I would\n               hear such disgusting rhetoric from the member from Kelowna....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efa0042bb227a88306b64ea8aae5f15418063f43209443ffb64b550daabfc904"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c5eaaa206df27517dadc4bf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721661,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to continue debate on Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. Just picking up, maybe I can just briefly summarize where I left off in discussing\n               how important this bill is to deliver real and measurable outcomes, not just for the\n               K'ómoks First Nation but for the surrounding region and for British Columbia as a whole. We've talked about.... I've talked about how important it is to ensure that it supports\n               and delivers a stronger economy in the region; higher wages; better partnerships with\n               First Nations, with non-Indigenous communities — really serving as a foundational\n               aspect of all of those positive outcomes that it can bring. I just want to briefly reflect. We've had a solemn commemorative event in the Hall\n               of Honour today, which really reflected on the dangers of what can happen when hatred\n               is unchecked in our communities and the loss, the unimaginable loss and the outcome\n               of pain, an immeasurable pain that lasts for generations to come. And it all starts\n               with words that are uttered — words that are uttered by somebody or people who can't\n               stand the thought of promoting the success of not just their neighbour but of their\n               entire community. Unfortunately, we had to hear some of those words in this chamber today. And as I\n               reflect on the commemoration that we witnessed today, we do use the words that we\n               will not forget. And that's why this treaty act is going through this chamber right\n               now. It is because it respects the history. It acknowledges that none of us here would\n               be here if not for that history. So whatever rights or wrongs that may have happened\n               in the past, it is our obligation to at least recognize and acknowledge what happened,\n               where we are and what we can do better. This bill is the definition of what we can do better. Because it doesn't end with\n               this bill. It continues. And it continues to adapt to changing times, to changing\n               circumstances. That is important because we know that things that prevent our prosperity in this\n               province are things like racism, things or concepts that harm other people because\n               of their identity, that prevent the prosperity of this province by saying: \"No, no,\n               no, you can't give them special treatment\" but forgetting the fact that none of this\n               is about special treatment. It's about an obligation that we all have to the people\n               of this province and that includes the K'ómoks First Nations. And when we address things like racism, hurtful words, harmful rhetoric, we are affirming\n               that commitment that we will continue on with introducing bills just like this for\n               the benefit of all communities in our province. And how does that work? I mean, over\n               the 30 years that led to this point, there was a listening to Indigenous voices All of that happened because you can't just work together to get to a better place,\n               in a vacuum, without addressing some of the harmful rhetoric that exists in our communities.\n               Those two things go hand in hand. That is crucial. It is necessary for building trust.\n               Within that 30 years, I can imagine — actually I can't imagine, but I can assume —\n               that there have been ups, there have been downs, but none of that led to a place in\n               which communication collapsed. That's why we're here today, because it works. Some people, you know, having this\n               happen over the course of such a long period of time, it's significant, because treaties\n               are complex. They're complex, but they're also not final settlements that close the\n               door on any future discussions. They're living agreements. They're designed to evolve\n               over time, to adapt, to support ongoing relationships. So we see it in the treaty's provisions for governance and for cooperation, and we\n               see it in the use of side agreements that allow flexibility in the implementation.\n               We see it in practical arrangements like the Comox Estuary consent agreement. This\n               particular agreement established a consent-based decision-making process for certain\n               land use decisions in areas that have deep ecological and cultural significance. It's accountable, it's transparent, and it reflects a modern approach to shared stewardship\n               because it is everybody's responsibility in this province to ensure that we uphold\n               that. That is what reconciliation looks like in practice. We are witness to that today.\n               It's not symbolic; it's not abstract. It's concrete; it's detailed, grounded in real-world\n               outcomes. Some may actually ask: \"Why does this process take so long?\" The answer is simple.\n               It respects the history of this country, and it matters. Treaties, as I said, are\n               complex. They address land, governance, resources, culture, economic development.\n               They require extensive engagement, careful negotiation and commitment to get the details\n               right, but the length of the process should not be confused with lack of progress.\n               What we're seeing here is the result of a sustained effort and a clear path forward. I want to return to the choice that is ahead of us as we debate the principles of\n               Bill 20, because that's what we're doing here in second reading. Either we can continue\n               with uncertainty, with unresolved claims, with relationships that are defined by conflict\n               and by lack of trust, or we can continue to move forward with clarity, with cooperation,\n               with collaboration, with agreements that recognize — recognize, not give — the rights,\n               respect communities and create opportunities for everybody in this region. The K'ómoks Treaty Act chooses that latter path. It's about building stronger relationships. It's about\n               creating stability and certainty. It's about ensuring that reconciliation is not just\n               a concept; it's not a goal. It's not just something that we talk about but As we go through this debate, I would hope that all members in this chamber will engage\n               in respectful debate. Respectful debate. A bill like this is the only way for us to\n               move forward. It really is. We cannot live in the past of the harm that has been done\n               to Indigenous communities all across this province. We cannot engage in rhetoric in\n               this House. For the sake of our province, please. Injustice to one people is injustice to all peoples. I will say, I had a very brief\n               lunch today because I wasn't really hungry anymore after the session this morning.\n               But as we ended our break, I thought to myself, I said: \"You know what? I can dwell\n               on the words that were uttered in this chamber, but I'm not going to.\" I'm not going to because I'm going to look to the future, and I'm going to encourage\n               every member in this House to look for a path forward together. Together with Indigenous\n               communities, together with each other, together in this case with the K'ómoks First Nation. Together because a few people's hatred does not define us as a province. It never\n               will. As long as we are on this side of the House, it will not. And we will not do that by casting aspersions on people. No. We will do that by returning\n               ourselves to the basic principles and values of being human, what it means to be human,\n               a good human. I really cannot not stand here and ask for that, plead for that from\n               everybody in this chamber. I cannot not do that. It is my responsibility. It's my\n               obligation. So I hope that members and people who are listening today will use today's events\n               as an opportunity to reaffirm their commitment to each other, to all of the Indigenous\n               Peoples in this province, that there is a brighter future for all of us together,\n               hand in hand. We will discuss, we will collaborate, we will respect, and we will ensure\n               that we will not stand for the types of harmful rhetoric that we heard in this House\n               today. Not yesterday, not now, not tomorrow, not ever. And that is my commitment to\n               all of British Columbians in this province and to the K'ómoks First Nation. I urge every member in this House to support the K'ómoks Treaty Act and work together to deliver the type of province that we all want for each other.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721661","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to continue debate on Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. Just picking up, maybe I can just briefly summarize where I left off in discussing\n               how important this bill is to deliver real and measurable outcomes, not just for the\n               K'ómoks First Nation but for the surrounding region and for British Columbia as a whole. We've talked about.... I've talked about how i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["03e0ed54540d9b936a59450d0c1126eebd4673708e2ee251d7e8b40a1afcfc20"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d254004d92836d408e92329a5613c27125f994cbb7f945f94cf69ddadaf6d963"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6fbd43f02e9638b71ac17d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729436,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Great. I'm pleased to come back to debating at second reading for Bill M237. Just to recap my brief comments from last week and just to reiterate our support for\n               Ms. Chantal Sutton and her journey and the things that she is advocating for, and\n               also, again, a thanks to the member for Prince George–North Cariboo for bringing forth this bill. I left off last week talking about the old car insurance system that we used to have\n               in British Columbia where people felt quite abandoned when they suffered an accident,\n               and the way that the system was structured led to some costly legal battles and, quite\n               often, some of the outcomes left people unsupported over the long term, especially\n               pertaining to treatments or health benefits. In place of that would often be a lump\n               sum award from the courts. What we know is that when someone gets into an accident, they need support. They want\n               immediate access to care, and this care has to provide them the support that they\n               need when they need it — and that's not just for maybe six months or a year but could\n               be for two years, three years, even longer — so that they can focus on the recovery.\n               They can focus on healing and not on navigating court processes and then waiting to\n               hear after those lengthy court battles are over what their fate is and what the dollar\n               amount is tied to their injuries. And that's That's why in 2021, our government introduced the enhanced-care model here in British\n               Columbia. Really, at its core, enhanced care aimed to address what was missing, and\n               that is a system that puts people and their health first, ensuring that benefits go\n               directly to people who are injured rather than being tied up in the courts. It's a\n               system that is designed to provide timely care so that people don't have to fight\n               and to try and prove that they're hurting. They don't have to prove that they're injured.\n               They get that support, practical assistance when people need it most. Really, the results speak for themselves. I mean, since 2021, more than $1.5 billion\n               have been paid out in benefits, and these benefits go directly to things like medical\n               treatments, rehabilitation, income replacement, home and vehicle adaptations for people\n               who need it moving forward, support for daily living. These are real supports that\n               actually make the difference in people's lives. At the same time, with all of this, we've actually made auto insurance more affordable\n               in British Columbia. People are paying low rates. These rates are some of the lowest\n               in Canada, and drivers actually receive savings through multiple rebate programs.\n               So this is a significant turnaround compared to what we had before, which was the\n               highest rates in the country. We had ICBC that was facing significant financial challenges.\n               I think we remember the dumpster fire. Through thoughtful changes, we've stabilized\n               the system and we've moved from that deficit to stability in the system, while at\n               the same time improving service and savings to drivers. Now, I want to make very clear that the system has to evolve. Even if there are things\n               that are working, there may be things that may not be working, but we need to figure\n               out what those are. We have to make sure that a system that is of this scale can be\n               constantly improved on. So while ICBC takes feedback from customers, from clients\n               seriously, we also have to make sure, as legislators, that we can continue to meet\n               the needs of British Columbians. That's why, when the model was introduced, legislation actually included a requirement\n               for an independent review within five years, and that review is currently underway.\n               The Legislature appointed a Special Committee to Review Provisions of the Insurance\n               (Vehicle) Act, a multiparty committee that is tasked with figuring out whether enhanced\n               care is working and what are improvements. That is where this bill belongs. It belongs\n               in that committee. This committee.... Not only are they hearing from experts, but they're\n               also listening to stakeholders. They're considering ideas for improvement, including\n               the types of proposals that are actually reflected in this bill. That brings me to, then, what we do with this piece of legislation here today. I want\n               to be very clear. I do think that the ideas in this bill are important. They certainly\n               are. I think many of us actually agree with them, but we must ensure that we use the\n               right process to address them. We have to make sure that we do it in the right way\n               so that something holistically good can come out of this for all British Columbians. So rather than moving ahead in isolation of that discussion and that process, we have\n               the opportunity to consider these ideas in a more thorough, in a more coordinated\n               way, again, in a more holistic way. That committee is the appropriate forum to do\n               that work carefully. Our commitment is quite clear. We want an insurance model that puts people at the\n               centre of the care that they receive. I do believe that this bill is best addressed\n               at that committee.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729436","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Great. I'm pleased to come back to debating at second reading for Bill M237. Just to recap my brief comments from last week and just to reiterate our support for\n               Ms. Chantal Sutton and her journey and the things that she is advocating for, and\n               also, again, a thanks to the member for Prince George–North Cariboo for bringing forth this bill. I left off last week talking","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c1a35e9626f9c2c3fd33eeb342927075bb9b19dcd8dfc3b35ebedd37c01dd19e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3d487426fccba100e34eb31a87ceee2a60b6df0cbaa754085836047f2b3e048"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc9b13d2f790428bd413956f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729439,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the honour to present the report of the Select Standing Committee on Private\n               Bills and Private Members' Bills on Bill M217 intituled Dashboard Cameras in Commercial\n               Vehicles Act. The committee reports the bill complete with amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729439","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have the honour to present the report of the Select Standing Committee on Private\n               Bills and Private Members' Bills on Bill M217 intituled Dashboard Cameras in Commercial\n               Vehicles Act. The committee reports the bill complete with amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8dd94c29401fcb79e34f1b375de78a8759effe3fe6acb62c3a81a649f43be4f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-acd7a47a9942b59eba932fb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729441,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I recognize a trail-blazing publication in British Columbia, the Miracle newspaper. For 25 years, the Miracle has served as the first bilingual, biweekly newspaper dedicated to the Muslim community\n               in our province. This anniversary marks not only a remarkable milestone in publishing but a testament\n               to resilience, vision and community spirit. When Usraad Hussain founded the Miracle in 2001, he saw a growing Muslim community across the Lower Mainland that was vibrant\n               and full of potential yet fragmented and relatively unseen. There was no single platform\n               to share stories, highlight achievements Since then, this paper has become a bridge, connecting families, amplifying local\n               businesses and creating space for writers, leaders and voices that might otherwise\n               go unheard. It has helped foster pride, identity and belonging within the community\n               that it serves. When Mohammad Naseer Pirzada took on the responsibility of continuing this work, the journey was not always\n               easy. Like many community-driven publications, there were moments of uncertainty,\n               times when continuing to the next issue was not guaranteed, yet through determination\n               and with the support of the entire Pirzada family across generations, the Miracle endured and flourished. That matters, because without the Miracle , countless stories might have never been told, businesses might have remained unseen,\n               and connections might have never been formed. Its impact goes beyond ink and paper.\n               It has strengthened the social fabric of British Columbia. Today I offer my sincere congratulations to Naseer Pirzada and everyone who has contributed\n               to the Miracle newspaper over the last 25 years. Your work has uplifted a community and enriched\n               our province. I wish you continued success for the next 25 years and beyond. According to WorkSafe, last year alone 138 workers in our province lost their lives\n               due to workplace injury or illness; 79 of those deaths were caused by occupational\n               disease, many from exposures that happened may have happened decades before; 41 workers\n               died from traumatic incidents on the job; and 18 were killed in work-related motor\n               vehicle incidents. Behind every one of those numbers is a person, a family, a future\n               that was taken too soon. I know that many British Columbians are deeply mourning the\n               loss of community members, colleagues or loved ones. My own community has experienced that grief as well. Last week marked 14 years since\n               the Lakeland Mills tragedy in Prince George. Twenty-two workers were injured; two\n               workers, Alan Little and Glenn Roche, never made it home. They deserved to return\n               to their families on April 23, 2012. That truth must continue to guide us. The Day of Mourning calls on all of us, especially those of us in this House, to ensure\n               that workplaces are not only productive but safe, that workers are properly trained,\n               protected and empowered, and that safety is treated as fundamental, not optional.\n               Safety is a shared responsibility, and leadership matters. I want to thank the workers who stand up for their own safety and the safety of the\n               colleagues next to them. I want to thank the labour leaders for their important voice\n               on safety. I want to thank the employers who care for the well-being of their employees.\n               I want to thank the Speaker and all members of this House who have made contributions\n               to safer legal protections, and I want to thank all of those individuals that share\n               a commitment to workplace safety. Today, as we remember those we have lost, all of us together renew our own commitments\n               to workers, because every worker in British Columbia deserves to return home safely\n               at the end of the day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729441","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I recognize a trail-blazing publication in British Columbia, the Miracle newspaper. For 25 years, the Miracle has served as the first bilingual, biweekly newspaper dedicated to the Muslim community\n               in our province. This anniversary marks not only a remarkable milestone in publishing but a testament\n               to resilience, vision and community spirit. When Usraad Hussain ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec3b83d5480079a690b87cbc1677096cc05248a7d72e95e8c68cef75d518a892"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b11453aee4683385d430497ff4a36b2c7eae6f62454ef6334a451eb9bde30d98"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-581467e0ef1ecd22be284036","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729444,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm so pleased to welcome some very special guests in the gallery here today. We are\n               joined by the delegates of the NCCM, the National Council of Canadian Muslims. And\n               these are not just members of the National Council of Canadian Muslims. These are\n               advocates in our communities here in British Columbia and across the country. They\n               are here to speak with members about matters that are pertinent to the Muslim community\n               all across this country. Now, I don't want to mention names because we'll be here all day, but would the House\n               join me in making them feel so welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729444","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm so pleased to welcome some very special guests in the gallery here today. We are\n               joined by the delegates of the NCCM, the National Council of Canadian Muslims. And\n               these are not just members of the National Council of Canadian Muslims. These are\n               advocates in our communities here in British Columbia and across the country. They\n               are her","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87361","label":"Minorities","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["931754f73f9c042973417d540fd6cea35fee1e046ed3d149bd2b2e96f8333f4f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ec37282881f1b141b17eb07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752335,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to mark the beginning of Mental Health Week, taking place from May 4\n               to May 10, 2026. This year's theme, \"Come Together, Canada,\" reminds us that connection\n               is essential to our mental health and well-being, and by strengthening relationships,\n               we can make a difference.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752335","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to mark the beginning of Mental Health Week, taking place from May 4\n               to May 10, 2026. This year's theme, \"Come Together, Canada,\" reminds us that connection\n               is essential to our mental health and well-being, and by strengthening relationships,\n               we can make a difference.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4a3132675da04a5c702c84bef8829d210095ad2a318e2db67198e05fc47f3df"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ebaae7becf219103cbd633f65450c98323dd6092c26d3cc35c248ae975fdcbbd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00b325137127d2651a41eb30","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752336,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"Somewhere up in the gallery are two incredible young men who work in my constituency\n               office. We are joined by Ayush Saini and Mostafa Ramadan. I have so many good things to say about these two young men. They exhibit exceptional\n               compassion and care for my constituents and exceptional care and compassion with all\n               of my technological needs. Helping me open an email is apparently a lot more difficult\n               than you may think. I do want to congratulate Ayush on his recent post-secondary graduation. I hope that\n               their experience here in their Legislature for the first time is going to inspire\n               them and the members in here will show them what good democracy looks like.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752336","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Somewhere up in the gallery are two incredible young men who work in my constituency\n               office. We are joined by Ayush Saini and Mostafa Ramadan. I have so many good things to say about these two young men. They exhibit exceptional\n               compassion and care for my constituents and exceptional care and compassion with all\n               of my technological needs. Helping me ope","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104485","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Men","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104485","label":"Men","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2ab15ae71800741115e0fc0f9cdc3ad8f253403a326fe5d5dd77a23469261d00"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1eac26844c537b5b791ef33f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017593,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a pleasant surprise to see your constituency adviser in the gallery, along\n               with his lovely family and friends who are here to visit the B.C. Legislature. Ayush\n               Saini and his family are incredible pillars of our community, especially Ayush himself. He is such an incredible adviser to me and a community advocate who shows so much\n               compassion and impeccable judgment skills. I'm so lucky to have him. I promise I'm\n               not being paid to say this, but thank you so much. Will the House join me in welcoming Ayush Saini and his family today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017593","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's always a pleasant surprise to see your constituency adviser in the gallery, along\n               with his lovely family and friends who are here to visit the B.C. Legislature. Ayush\n               Saini and his family are incredible pillars of our community, especially Ayush himself. He is such an incredible adviser to me and a community advocate who shows so much\n               compassion an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035026","label":"Electronic monitoring","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02760bdd5641e537f2caea17a0278871ddab2d947bb02363f5c4eb0a47720ff5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05408ae45d56d33c2f4d6774","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017595,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call a point of order. I see that the member is engaging in a very wide debate around\n               a number of things under the sun. I'm not sure how that's relevant to what's before\n               us, which is the bill. Thanks.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017595","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I call a point of order. I see that the member is engaging in a very wide debate around\n               a number of things under the sun. I'm not sure how that's relevant to what's before\n               us, which is the bill. Thanks.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-933ea13d05af28d593eb85fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017596,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am quite pleased to welcome Tim Stevens to the precinct here today along with his\n               classes. I had the pleasure of meeting Tim at the B.C. Teachers' Institute on Parliamentary\n               Democracy last year. Tim is an incredible teacher who has such passion for education all across this province\n               and having his students involved in the democratic process here. Will the House also\n               join me in welcoming an incredible teacher from Vancouver?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017596","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am quite pleased to welcome Tim Stevens to the precinct here today along with his\n               classes. I had the pleasure of meeting Tim at the B.C. Teachers' Institute on Parliamentary\n               Democracy last year. Tim is an incredible teacher who has such passion for education all across this province\n               and having his students involved in the democratic process here. Will","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2518cfe97c01ac4df36505fa1ff86fd3c5e8a5209dad48df2900c7de530392b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00ef5434cbbee63b6328d079879d2dd78e689e903eeb4808a2748692122e96b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-953fb7da73d2065740c2c9c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036575,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036575","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["198705aca810cf448b785c67bb0d57ea405ba24381349b78f0418aada711f5fe"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f679361728062f5bcf293156","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036576,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my honour to introduce the former MLA for Surrey-Whalley Bruce Ralston, who\n               is here with us in the chamber. Bruce is a respected leader whose dedication to public\n               service and our provincial community has made a lasting impact across British Columbia.\n               With 20 years of service as an MLA and also, I think, five years of service on Surrey\n               city council, Bruce is known for his integrity, his community building and his desire\n               to create meaningful, positive change across this province. He's earned the admiration\n               of all of his colleagues and all those who've worked with him. I have a special place in my heart for Bruce. He is my mentor. He is a guide who helps\n               me be the most effective advocate I can be for my community. It's such a pleasure\n               to see him here today. Will the House join me in making Bruce Ralston feel very welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036576","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is my honour to introduce the former MLA for Surrey-Whalley Bruce Ralston, who\n               is here with us in the chamber. Bruce is a respected leader whose dedication to public\n               service and our provincial community has made a lasting impact across British Columbia.\n               With 20 years of service as an MLA and also, I think, five years of service on Surrey\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d76e0dbaae824c1f05c7c09d626896118af860d06b74a04877c4df8e02099727"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f54c42fedc938e25fb5be80","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036577,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Amna Shah","venue":"Hansard","text":"I actually have two introductions, but I'll do one at a time. I just want to welcome\n               Priyanka Krishna and Jasmeen Jaswal to the chamber today. These two women are the\n               future of our province, and I cannot stress how hard these young women work for our\n               caucus and for our government and for our communities. I thank you for your work, and welcome to the chamber. I hope the House will join me in doing the same.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036577","member_id":"bc-mla-399","member_name":"Amna Shah","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I actually have two introductions, but I'll do one at a time. I just want to welcome\n               Priyanka Krishna and Jasmeen Jaswal to the chamber today. These two women are the\n               future of our province, and I cannot stress how hard these young women work for our\n               caucus and for our government and for our communities. I thank you for your work, and welcome to the cha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","label":"Women workers","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1df5e68dac5749e7924563b37bd0783b56bd9b58a59c4a956e24cb14d704941f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df812f0a16b03cdd59fdf70a","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187088,"date":"2026-02-18T12:00:00+00:00","title":"TRADE RECOGNITION ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov05-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov05-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187088","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0df4cf5b4ed0a3b7d9d2d15c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187089,"date":"2026-02-18T12:00:00+00:00","title":"TRADE RECOGNITION ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov05-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov05-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187089","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed6cac44b3fd657ba14f1377","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317150,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a sad, sad day. We've lost a few important people, two people in my community. Firth Bateman was well known to myself and the member for Delta South. Firth passed away at Surrey Memorial Hospital on Christmas Day after an ongoing\n               battle with some health issues. He was fortunate to be surrounded by family when he\n               passed away. He was born in Belleville, Ontario, on August 2, 1947. He was raised\n               in Stirling, Ontario. He had such a large presence in our community. In his professional life, he was a\n               social worker for the Ministry of Social Services. Later in life, he moved on to financial\n               and estate planning. He loved outdoors. He was loved by his family and friends. He\n               had his dog. He loved his dogs, Jessie, Gamble, Festus, Jingles. He was a selfless man, a fierce supporter of those he loved. He leaves a large hole\n               in the lives of those who loved him. He's survived by his wife of 48 years, Jillian;\n               his son Toran and his daughter Kara, who I believe lives here in Victoria. He's also\n               survived by his sister Bonnie and his younger brother, Glen. He served on the Delta police board. The member for Delta South and I were just reflecting yesterday on our funny encounters that we've had with\n               him when he just randomly calls us and says, \"I need to talk to you about urgent politics\n               in Delta,\" and sure, he'll call me, and then he'll call him, as well, to get both\n               sides of the story. He will be really missed in our community. We also lost George Windsor. He was a long-time Delta community member, volunteer.\n               George passed away peacefully on February 6. Prior to his illness, George dedicated\n               himself to minor sports in Delta. He was very active in the refereeing space. He trained\n               and mentored referees. He was the president of the North Delta Minor Hockey Association. When his hockey duties were over, George, on the side, would build sets for the Sidekick\n               Theatre in Delta. Every time I saw George he would talk about community. He was just always smiling.\n               And every time I'd see him, I'd say, \"George, where's my bacon?\" because he used to\n               make his own bacon. Without a doubt, within four or five weeks, he'd be knocking on\n               my door and saying: \"Here you go, buddy.\" My love goes out to George's family, in particular Val Windsor, who was chair of Delta\n               school board for many, many years. Lastly, two years ago I was able to recognize my friend Paul Maas, who came to visit\n               me here. He came with his family to do heli-skiing. That was a passion for him and\n               his in-laws. Last week they were in Austria, when they were heli-skiing and unfortunately got hit\n               by Lastly, two years ago, I was able to recognize my friend Paul Maas who came to visit\n               me here. He came with his family to do heli-skiing. That was a passion for him and\n               his in-laws. Last week, they were in Austria, where they were heli-skiing, and unfortunately got\n               hit by an avalanche. Paul's family survived, but his father-in-law passed away and\n               was unfortunately not able to be found. I just want to send love to my friend Paul\n               and to his entire family in the Netherlands. It's hard to make sense of these types\n               of tragedies, and I want to ask the House to send condolences to this amazing family. Hon. Mike Farnworth : In this chamber, I call second reading on Bill 4, the Supply Act. In Section A, the\n               Douglas Fir Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry of Citizens' Services. When they are completed, I call the Attorney General estimates for the Douglas Fir\n               Room as well. In Section C, the Birch Room, I call the estimates for the Ministry\n               of Infrastructure.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317150","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise on a sad, sad day. We've lost a few important people, two people in my community. Firth Bateman was well known to myself and the member for Delta South. Firth passed away at Surrey Memorial Hospital on Christmas Day after an ongoing\n               battle with some health issues. He was fortunate to be surrounded by family when he\n               passed away. He was born in Belleville, Ontari","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","label":"Avalanches"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","label":"Skiing","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","label":"Avalanches","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7419df6b1fb07334d134df7c4b97583156650cd2e161ac75678af85f7385923b","41376893e9f818c80c4513ab2c366980d9a089906693aec26908603af1557aa6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["763d215b6ae99b32724ded3bcc5d9e77365af205ca481bc548d08d3f5e5b31ef"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skiing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Avalanches","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:185734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:412834","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1a27a7f40615af6dd28d997","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327986,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to recognize an individual today who, as a young man, left India. He was destined\n               to be in Bollywood. He had the opportunity of being in Bollywood, but he chose to\n               leave that opportunity and instead immigrated to Canada. He became an organizer in\n               the farmworker movement, an organizer in the labour movement. Today we call him the\n               Speaker of the House. Hon. Speaker, I want to wish you a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327986","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to recognize an individual today who, as a young man, left India. He was destined\n               to be in Bollywood. He had the opportunity of being in Bollywood, but he chose to\n               leave that opportunity and instead immigrated to Canada. He became an organizer in\n               the farmworker movement, an organizer in the labour movement. Today we call him the\n               Sp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0b18a7eb6108c51d7d5e62ab7877ed3132502e653afaa90b38bdf8a8f854ff3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b55cb33c0a97237221ae2f37647c456fbf07a23763176ffbbea62d2bed97883"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f75a6de8cc13fc7ec7123081","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327987,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327987","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7a7633da5131dc66ae4a58b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360171,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate my friend across the way for raising the concerns that some small businesses\n               face.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360171","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I appreciate my friend across the way for raising the concerns that some small businesses\n               face.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["286f896e6efafc7cd7ffb30f206d6ea8d9e12f0ab3c1158ac019b996fd5c174b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d84328a425c2281a29dee605","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360172,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to make two quick introductions. One, I want to join the Leader of the Official\n               Opposition in welcoming his family. He left, for the record, when I was going to do\n               this. I shouldn't have said that. I apologize. His lovely wife, Holly, and I have been friends for a long time. In fact, we've been\n               friends longer than they've met. Sometimes in question period, when he gets a little\n               fired up, I just whisper over to him that I'm going to tell Holly. Now that she's\n               literally here, he better be on good behaviour. I want to join him in welcoming her and the entire family today. Also, I've got folks from my GCPE team here today. I just want to thank them for the\n               work — many of them supported the Minister of Finance, as well, before — and recognize that they work hard every single day. I appreciate them. Todd Harmer is here with them, and he's leaving. I heard he didn't like to wake up early for labour force survey\n               days, so he's leaving the team. But he's joining another team within government. I want to appreciate him, thank them and welcome the Leader of the Official Opposition's\n               family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360172","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to make two quick introductions. One, I want to join the Leader of the Official\n               Opposition in welcoming his family. He left, for the record, when I was going to do\n               this. I shouldn't have said that. I apologize. His lovely wife, Holly, and I have been friends for a long time. In fact, we've been\n               friends longer than they've met. Sometimes in questi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71d81d30fdd6d235a6a6d408f02d38c3d8c8dc2c84ce76f08d1f5c1888c89d24","9e80f6e58746bdb18aeaa348bf90735634e65d75c9fbc9288073ffc98a232a31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dec73b2237e7fd865ca3a8d9752b1f33d151e6c04286af2f291fc55af87ee79f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3fe662be9043a2272fb7772e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415743,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the question from my friend across the way. My friend will know that since 2017, B.C. has seen one of the strongest GDP growths\n               in the entire country. We've seen 351,800 jobs created in British Columbia since 2017...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415743","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I appreciate the question from my friend across the way. My friend will know that since 2017, B.C. has seen one of the strongest GDP growths\n               in the entire country. We've seen 351,800 jobs created in British Columbia since 2017...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","label":"Laboratories","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","label":"Biotechnology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66e858b5562c2777e4f1e79994447255dd14f31860e59bf3dbad2ea0c29365f4","ce6a9790360280249a60c47c2988a42dcfe9ca470bd239b1382eae106aa9e8a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["942bf982ac3900a32194fc87d435aecc8274a726f2252a3cd901584d2dc4c3d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14c261dda71ae28990405382","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415744,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"In about a week, the Canadian men's junior national field hockey team will be heading\n               off to a competition in Chile, the junior Pan Am Games. I have forgotten what it feels\n               like. It's been so long since I had the opportunity to do so. I want to recognize a couple of individual athletes. First, I want to recognize Lachlan\n               Scuby, who is a son of my former teammate, Blair Scuby. The interesting thing is that\n               Lachlan is going to the junior national tournament. His son is. And Blair represents\n               Canada at the masters. Lachlan also happens to be the nephew of former MLA Nick Simons\n               and Slim, who we all know in this House very well. The second person is Karim Sandhu, who is from North Delta, who I've coached as a\n               little child, and now he's going to the junior national team. His dad, Cook Sandhu,\n               who was my teammate, is now going to the masters, representing Canada. I want to recognize all the players: Rajan Bhaiya, Gurnoor Bhullar, Caleb Fitch, Ajit\n               Gill, Paramdev Handal, Balit Mangat, Gavin Thind, Robin Thind, Abraham Yogsharan —\n               all of them from British Columbia. I want to wish them well at the Pan American Games.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Panamerican games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415744","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In about a week, the Canadian men's junior national field hockey team will be heading\n               off to a competition in Chile, the junior Pan Am Games. I have forgotten what it feels\n               like. It's been so long since I had the opportunity to do so. I want to recognize a couple of individual athletes. First, I want to recognize Lachlan\n               Scuby, who is a son of my former","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","label":"Panamerican games"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Panamerican games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","label":"Panamerican games","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3906d3063116c5ada85f421495f83bb7a756e4da69d2cc4175679f202fad9e1c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Panamerican games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["696087f9a5465d54bce3e01aceab6d8ea450c7b925e74703a943f7b1f6ab4369"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Panamerican games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036587","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-366e2e5e2bc09d4739d3d083","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415745,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's very rare that I get to talk about field hockey two days in a row. One of my former teammates from the Sydney Olympics, Ian Bird, is in the House today.\n               He tried to sneak into the building quietly without me noticing, but I have sources\n               who informed me he was here. If you had a poster child for what leadership should look like, from sport to business\n               to not-for-profit work, Ian is that poster child. I was so fortunate to make the junior\n               national team as a young man and then have mentorship from Ian. Ian has mentored a\n               lot of people, whether he knows it or not. I'm so excited for him in his new role. I was so fortunate to make the junior national team as a young man and then have mentorship\n               from Ian. Ian has mentored a lot of people, whether he knows it or not, and I'm so\n               excited for him in his new role, that he's coming back. I won't steal the thunder from my colleague who's going to share it, but I want the\n               House to join me in welcoming Ian Bird to the building today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415745","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's very rare that I get to talk about field hockey two days in a row. One of my former teammates from the Sydney Olympics, Ian Bird, is in the House today.\n               He tried to sneak into the building quietly without me noticing, but I have sources\n               who informed me he was here. If you had a poster child for what leadership should look like, from sport to business\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5578fcfac3f882e02caefa8972f5979296ecc70ba6d925a1931b200624581909"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b84b52495ad56d8c4ebcb1ada75cc4abdff19f884bcbeb946b28de2a1860f365"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ab0145dc57615aef8b1ea9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415746,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's some sort of record. I get to talk","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415746","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's some sort of record. I get to talk","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d36878bd3121be5dd232e8462770a444ad5d5d9ad1475aabd304911a5893da7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-22dc64079a7e57b36a4a847b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720376,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720376","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bf9e92a9876f72391f768e894f4c418ad93597590eb94b7cab546fc4f60fc30"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42f4286b7b46c46006241d69","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720378,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm just rising on a point of order. I know that you enforce the rules around no electronic devices in this place. The\n               member for Kamloops–North Thompson was caught on Hansard video using his device, it looked like taking photos, during\n               this chamber. I'm hoping that you can reinforce to this House that that's not a practice.\n               That is prohibited.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720378","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm just rising on a point of order. I know that you enforce the rules around no electronic devices in this place. The\n               member for Kamloops–North Thompson was caught on Hansard video using his device, it looked like taking photos, during\n               this chamber. I'm hoping that you can reinforce to this House that that's not a practice.\n               That is prohibited.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","label":"Photography"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media monitoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083616","label":"Media monitoring","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","label":"Photography","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da4e1dabb9a57442bb7225134ce6e3a827a5f389c83629046b811d78669b9ccc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76909249d6a1e5d093262def484260d54991e841b19e37b42a5b7042919f456c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3209c513fecef79d31a694bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720382,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I won't spend time refuting the facts that the member shared, but I can share with\n               the member that I've had the opportunity, my colleagues have had the opportunity to\n               meet with Surrey business leaders. We were recently hosting one of our caucus meetings.\n               We had an opportunity to bring different organizations together. What I heard from them, and what we heard from them, is not pessimistic perception that the member shared. What we heard was hope and optimism.\n               They believe that the future for Surrey is bright. You know why? Because they're seeing\n               the investments. They're seeing the investments in transportation expanding to the\n               region. They're seeing investments in a brand-new hospital. They're seeing the investments\n               in AI and quantum that's helping create new small businesses in the tech sector. Surrey has a promising future, and we are doing whatever we can to make sure investments\n               go there so that we can see the opportunities, not only for the community of Surrey\n               but for the province overall as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720382","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I won't spend time refuting the facts that the member shared, but I can share with\n               the member that I've had the opportunity, my colleagues have had the opportunity to\n               meet with Surrey business leaders. We were recently hosting one of our caucus meetings.\n               We had an opportunity to bring different organizations together. What I heard from them, and what we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Restaurants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131383","label":"Restaurants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["acac82e5ad05fefee46114a38834c7a724f6a99efda525521b45f4b8460236e0","dcf093f71b7a57f8a5a5fff77a97fb02637a3d09fde3a2ba74b6af46fbb22daa","2710368734a6e83fb337e3122cabc898d0849594ee9e54a8d4e2a7f352e800b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6366b191ac71a1c56903863de76b9b77e394e9f643bb652aeb911d52b0fcff28"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2572fd376e7ec952e1f19724","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729148,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the interest from colleagues around the World Cup, and I appreciate that\n               everyone wants to make sure their communities are safe when we welcome the entire\n               world. I also appreciate the members standing up, one by one, talking about the viewing\n               parties that they'll be having in their communities that we, by the way, are funding\n               on this side of the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729148","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the interest from colleagues around the World Cup, and I appreciate that\n               everyone wants to make sure their communities are safe when we welcome the entire\n               world. I also appreciate the members standing up, one by one, talking about the viewing\n               parties that they'll be having in their communities that we, by the way, are funding\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44308","label":"Travel","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["41368c70ae80c4894415ac5d9b8703ac2aed49ddd6f103237ae2a84fa82437d1","e67348f787d552eb5defc2b7a00d7942a0aa34762007f28a0c28a1a980295865"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2452fe98b8e92d6048075d3301244f87ace2d8f4374c4d15b5b8937434ca3f8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00cd3b143d02ac23d960e162","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729154,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the member for the question. We have more in common than just our\n               green ties today. We too have concerns around this type of technology being used in\n               negative ways. I can assure the member and the members of this House that we have met with both federal\n               government officials as well as Manitoba officials that are leading this work to both\n               understand what work they're doing, where we can learn from the work, but also to\n               do it from a national scale. It's critically important that as the federal government right now is looking at regulations\n               around AI and protecting the public, we have one system across the country. We can't\n               have a system where, on one side, we're trying to cut red tape and streamline and\n               create efficiencies and remove interprovincial trade barriers and, on the other side,\n               create one rule in one province and create different rules in other provinces. If\n               we want to have a strong economy and a strong country and protect our citizens, we\n               have to do it together. That's the work we're committed to. I want to assure the member that if we don't get action from the federal government,\n               we are prepared to take action here in British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729154","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank the member for the question. We have more in common than just our\n               green ties today. We too have concerns around this type of technology being used in\n               negative ways. I can assure the member and the members of this House that we have met with both federal\n               government officials as well as Manitoba officials that are leading this work to both","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","label":"Technology","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["564027831db3ce3519fb0ebe32ae25c91696deb4007fd23b0ee60adefbb16bf1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d33c8c8a8a4f9cc15b629941dcdf573325f0c385ca825bed170f46098f224256"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:869","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8412616ece664405c9ab4562","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752258,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two sets of announcements. One, I see Manajit and Tarannum up in this gallery today. They're my CAs. They do\n               incredible work in my community. I hear from people all the time about how fantastic\n               they have been to work with. I'm really lucky to have them part of my team, and they're\n               here today. I have a second set of introductions. Right behind them is Dan Davies, former MLA\n               in this chamber, and Mary Mitton is here as well. She is the Executive Director of\n               Northern Innovation Network. My friend Dan is on the board, and they're here talking\n               about innovation and opportunities in northern British Columbia. I'm hoping the House can join me in making both of them very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752258","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have two sets of announcements. One, I see Manajit and Tarannum up in this gallery today. They're my CAs. They do\n               incredible work in my community. I hear from people all the time about how fantastic\n               they have been to work with. I'm really lucky to have them part of my team, and they're\n               here today. I have a second set of introductions. Right behind the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Packaging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Artefacts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","label":"Soil","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751813","label":"Artefacts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945702","label":"Packaging","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3f4b1402ca375b8c6048be9e02f2fef247c27c469084a2840c5ad37235ac944"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57dae29f0962504adbbde2d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752260,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to thank the member for the question and also note that B.C. outperformed\n               what the B.C. Business Council projected was going to be the GDP growth for British\n               Columbia last year. In fact, the headlines read, \"B.C. led the country in economic\n               growth,\" and we're projecting that again for this next year. The member highlighted the question around investments in British Columbia. Four new\n               mines have been invested in. We have $8 billion of investment that has just come from\n               January to now. Within the last few weeks, we've seen billions of dollars of investment\n               in British Columbia, and we're expecting billions of dollars of more investment coming\n               to British Columbia in the weeks ahead. We'll continue to work with the B.C. Business Council. I know they're advocating for\n               certain measures, and that's great. They should do that. But let's not get the stats\n               mixed up. The stats are clear. We are continuing to lead the country, and we will\n               do that into the years ahead.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752260","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to thank the member for the question and also note that B.C. outperformed\n               what the B.C. Business Council projected was going to be the GDP growth for British\n               Columbia last year. In fact, the headlines read, \"B.C. led the country in economic\n               growth,\" and we're projecting that again for this next year. The member highlighted the question arou","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c2461c742e8f4b9b626851acca81d0e10661294392e81ecc2847d845e14daa1","e222ed8a64950072b47e449549c9c02d07c95e9fa7e8c3349ae692114876da90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a40ee40076cbf375f4bca33ce0b0fe12f2c1575dfda7baa83e21b1ee5e7f259"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-20ad3f87ada7488206274e8a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752261,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the member's question. There are different ways of tracking economic\n               success, and well-being is certainly one of those metrics. I can share with the member that we have been doing some work with First Nations communities\n               around new economic models that can capture learnings from First Nations but also\n               use traditional modelling to both identify and track economic success but also layer\n               in the importance of well-being of both workers and people in our communities. I look\n               forward to continuing to move that work along. I appreciate if the member has things that he would like to add to that conversation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752261","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the member's question. There are different ways of tracking economic\n               success, and well-being is certainly one of those metrics. I can share with the member that we have been doing some work with First Nations communities\n               around new economic models that can capture learnings from First Nations but also\n               use traditional modelling to both ident","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4eee01bbf748af2dcda8930e65a912b27c52aaf4659a125d3f54d0d06623a9b0","8b37f91429ae1efa41584253c60b35307c1c56939470a3089668325b7b5ec036"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2519d7d1d89ad47af84bd176e1470871812bb21ee43984ff7d818cdacf4db831"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97d58a0b18c272312c9aeae6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017368,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I'm happy I inspire such energy from the opposition. The member talks about certainty, and everyone on this side understands how important\n               it is to ensure that there is certainty for investors. That's why, just since November,\n               we've had Quintette coal mine, $500 million; Highland Valley Copper extension, $2.25\n               billion; Mount Milligan mine extension, $400 million; Eskay Creek mine, $713 million...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017368","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I'm happy I inspire such energy from the opposition. The member talks about certainty, and everyone on this side understands how important\n               it is to ensure that there is certainty for investors. That's why, just since November,\n               we've had Quintette coal mine, $500 million; Highland Valley Copper extension, $2.25\n               billion; Mount Mil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752655","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","label":"Coal","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752655","label":"Soil pollution","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1533234ad8ee015ee3a9789cc5b6b8a3ea9731717ccf55ff21b8a00a20ca94e4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c707607bf79e7d436ae4245ccd98634948be3f15fa3d7239f7078c1d3bd98ba3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coal","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47369","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7cb7ff850f5758f5e5a8971a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036497,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member and I canvassed this, as well, during estimates. It's vitally important\n               that we continue to support small businesses. We know due to global uncertainty that we're dealing with right now, due to the war\n               that we're seeing fuel prices push up, having a real impact on our businesses, and\n               then you add on top of that tariffs. It is a bit of a perfect storm. Despite the challenges, we still continue to be leaders in this province, leading\n               the country both in investments into our province, GDP growth. I met with the BIAs this morning, and we had an important conversation about things\n               that they're hearing from the front lines. What they're hearing is that they continue\n               to need skilled people. That's why this budget is doubling the funding for trades\n               training so that we can have people skilled up to take the employment opportunity.\n               They're seeing $88 billion of potential investment coming to this province which means\n               a lot of economic activity. They see the positive side of that. They want to see more\n               supports to protect storefronts from vandalism. The $16 million in this budget to\n               support communities and, in particular, target repeat offenders is welcomed. We're going to continue to do the work to support small businesses because they are\n               vital for the success of this province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036497","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The member and I canvassed this, as well, during estimates. It's vitally important\n               that we continue to support small businesses. We know due to global uncertainty that we're dealing with right now, due to the war\n               that we're seeing fuel prices push up, having a real impact on our businesses, and\n               then you add on top of that tariffs. It is a bit of a perfe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape reduction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083635","label":"Red tape reduction","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b3e118b3d6a29b08e2a6892b85ce55e9460e13f21823b0e9754ddbe120c3f98"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f5608ffab229c4ad274be76c694266e692ab7ff410ed397663b6f9fcb2695620"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8c2c4a588211fa98fa02aec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036499,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ravi Kahlon","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have the pleasure of welcoming a delegation from the Nepali-Canadian community\n               to the Legislature in recognition of Nepali Heritage Day in British Columbia. I would\n               like to thank and acknowledge members of the Nepal Cultural Society of British Columbia\n               and the Nepali Heritage Day organizing committee for their leadership across our province. Sitting in the gallery today, I want to recognize my dear friend from my community,\n               Raju  Bhattrai, president of the NCSBC. We have Gaurav Subedi, secretary. We have Mr. Christopher Considine, who is the Honorary Consul General\n               for Nepal in British Columbia, and we also have His Excellency Bharat Raj Paudyal, who is the Ambassador of Nepal to Canada. This is a historic moment, as B.C. is the first jurisdiction in Canada to proclaim\n               Nepali Heritage Day. I want to congratulate the Nepali community on this remarkable\n               celebration, as well as the contributions they make to this province. I'm hoping everyone\n               can join me in recognizing their commitment and service to the province. Welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036499","member_id":"bc-mla-40","member_name":"Ravi Kahlon","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I have the pleasure of welcoming a delegation from the Nepali-Canadian community\n               to the Legislature in recognition of Nepali Heritage Day in British Columbia. I would\n               like to thank and acknowledge members of the Nepal Cultural Society of British Columbia\n               and the Nepali Heritage Day organizing committee for their leadership across our province. Sit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8077ae6c9a783ac2ed322829f98f29ed85005201932de84ae6560fa4c48ad979"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ffee279d0d40b0c6e94460b154577f40be19201caed25861997196d3e8caa3fb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a8ee64551c2bf34abde2925","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317123,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Everyone deserves to feel safe. It does not matter if you are Hindu, Christian, Jewish,\n               Muslim or Sikh. Hardeep Singh Nijjar, president of Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara Society,\n               was murdered at a Sikh temple in Surrey, June 18, 2023. And now again, the police have issued a duty to warn two Why is this NDP government failing to protect B.C. families?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317123","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Everyone deserves to feel safe. It does not matter if you are Hindu, Christian, Jewish,\n               Muslim or Sikh. Hardeep Singh Nijjar, president of Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara Society,\n               was murdered at a Sikh temple in Surrey, June 18, 2023. And now again, the police have issued a duty to warn two Why is this NDP government failing to protect B.C. families?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc33b4e4f7fefaaf8aab77cc5eef9e44a246ed6aa2e07bb2ff71e93efc47d4d7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["95307e9c2244d182322ff34e82228aae30111b85adabe8cb41bdaf4bce7a6807"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b459b569af3e41c7b05e830","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415709,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I'm honoured to speak about Sikh Heritage Month and Vaisakhi. In British Columbia, the month of April is known as Sikh Heritage Month. It is a time\n               to learn about and celebrate the history, culture and contribution of the Sikh community.\n               The Sikh community is based on the teachings of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. He taught values\n               like equality, honesty, kindness and helping others. Sikhs also remember an important event in history, when the Khalsa was created in\n               1699 by Guru Gobind Singh. This teaches us to be brave, to stand for justice. During\n               this time, the Sikh community go to gurdwara to pray and serve langar, which is a\n               free meal for everyone. This shows equality and justice, because everyone sits together\n               and eats together, no matter who they are. Across British Columbia, communities also hold Nagar Kirtan parades that bring people\n               together in celebration. In Vancouver, the Nagar Kirtan parade will be held on April\n               11. In Surrey, which has one of the largest parades in the world, it will take place\n               on April 18. It will be celebrated across the globe in the month of April. Sikh Heritage Month gives all of us a chance to think about value like equality, respect\n               and community, which help build a strong and welcoming society. [Punjabi was spoken.]","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415709","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I'm honoured to speak about Sikh Heritage Month and Vaisakhi. In British Columbia, the month of April is known as Sikh Heritage Month. It is a time\n               to learn about and celebrate the history, culture and contribution of the Sikh community.\n               The Sikh community is based on the teachings of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. He taught values\n               like equality, honesty, kin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["551485a57ff167c5e4feb951991d3763285f0792f4d49a7fe858fd8edb34c8de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f6e4db9546d85478d83ad24299ae34f891a19df1a510e4ddc3b7ebff9a336e9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0562b42aa4ce8fca0217204f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720262,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to wish my son, Diltaj Singh Dhaliwal, a 12th birthday. So can the House please welcome and make him feel special.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720262","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to wish my son, Diltaj Singh Dhaliwal, a 12th birthday. So can the House please welcome and make him feel special.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-289f02c3a2a483bad8c3fddc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720266,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to introduce my two best friends, respected in my community: [name removed] and [name removed], who is very active on X. Please welcome them. Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720266","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to introduce my two best friends, respected in my community: [name removed] and [name removed], who is very active on X. Please welcome them. Thank you so much.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbe83ece9a27a0646628ab01c04265054a436bc786d27e9f7a4051fcb96687f4","6108d6b24cc8acd4db7eacbe26ac3cc6f2b0750533188a585f3d37ea840caf3b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b8d283cde580453d2128f87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721346,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"Starting from 2024, since I was elected, I continue to ask when this government will\n               stop extortion violence. Yesterday again another shooting in my riding, and 15 shootings\n               this year alone in Surrey — 15. When will the NDP government provide peace for Surrey families?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721346","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Starting from 2024, since I was elected, I continue to ask when this government will\n               stop extortion violence. Yesterday again another shooting in my riding, and 15 shootings\n               this year alone in Surrey — 15. When will the NDP government provide peace for Surrey families?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f5bfa29daa0bec7f895959873772c41aa668cb7b76e1a16c97c0b461d7ee103"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-52c82b2ab6d2f7e9dd6891eb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752215,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak on Bill 9. As someone who has used the Canadian public system\n               as an important and now represent the people of Surrey North, I see access to information as a basic test of how open and accountable government\n               is. This bill is being This bill is being presented as an improvement, but it is not. It is a shift of power\n               away from the public and towards the B.C. NDP government. This bill is not really\n               about better access to information. It is about more control over who can get information,\n               when they can get it and how. Once this kind of change happens, it is very hard to\n               reverse. Freedom of information is not just a rule or process. It is how the public checks\n               what the government is doing. If this system becomes weaker, accountability also becomes\n               weaker. Let's look at the facts. In 2024-2025, 7,063 FOI requests were received, and 6,818\n               requests were completed. This shows thousands of people are using this system every\n               year. These requests are not small. They involved about 2.18 million pages of government\n               records. So this is a large detailing dealing with a huge amount of information. Now let's look at how the system is working. The average time to complete a request\n               is 65 business days, but the legal standard is 30 business days. So it takes more\n               than double the expected time. Also 81 percent of requests can be completed on time.\n               That means one out of five is late. This shows the system is already under pressure. Now let's talk about Bill 9. It may be called a modern update, but the effect is what\n               matters. It makes delay easier to justify, gives more power to refuse requests, adds\n               more rules before people can ask, allows a fee in more situations, gives more choice\n               to government officers. Overall, it makes access harder. The bill changes \"without delay\" to \"without unreasonable delay.\" This means delays\n               are more acceptable now. People must now give more detailed requests, but what counts\n               as enough detail is not clearly defined. So government officers can decide more easily\n               to reject or delay requests. Government can refuse requests if they are called abusive,\n               repetitive or too broad, but these words are not clearly defined. This gives a lot\n               of power to reject requests. The bill also allows a fee even for the records that are already public. So people\n               may now have to pay for information that should already be available. In 2024-2025,\n               3,592 documents were shared publicly. But in earlier years, that number was higher.\n               So fewer things are being shared automatically. This means public must now file more\n               FOI requests to get information. In 2024-2025, 6,186 privacy breaches were reported, and 5,641 were confirmed. But\n               only a very small number were reported to the public. This raises concerns about transparency\n               and data safety. In 2024-2025, 70,000 was collected in processing fees, and 214 requests had extra\n               charges. This shows access is becoming more expensive. Bill 9 continues this trend. Other provinces are moving forward — faster access, more open data, fewer barriers.\n               British Columbia is moving in the opposite direction — more delays, more rules, more\n               fees, less Think about a parent. If someone goes wrong in the public system, they want answers.\n               They file an FOI request. Under this bill, they may be told: \"Your request is too\n               broad. It needs more detail. It takes too long.\" Or it may be refused. Eventually,\n               many people will stop trying, not because they got answers but because the process\n               is too hard. If this bill is about transparency, why make access harder? If it is about efficiency,\n               why are delays still so long? If it is about openness, why add more features? So I\n               ask the government, will you remove this fee on public records, yes or no? This bill does improve more administrative parts, but it also makes access harder.\n               A faster system that gives less information is not better. Good reform should make\n               timelines enforceable, clearly define refusal rules, reduce fees, improve oversight.\n               Bill 9 does not do this. Public trust depends on access to information. When access becomes harder, trust goes\n               down. Freedom of information is not a burden. It is a key part of government accountability. For these reasons, I cannot support Bill 9 in its current form.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752215","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak on Bill 9. As someone who has used the Canadian public system\n               as an important and now represent the people of Surrey North, I see access to information as a basic test of how open and accountable government\n               is. This bill is being This bill is being presented as an improvement, but it is not. It is a shift of power\n               away from the pub","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b2f9530db1b39d9e7972a754c9ee60c6cf655b17c6613ac5cae9ff9d26bf96e2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29d5bcdb146e22e1273346e8f4ffc41fa9a1238f38862da68d65fc32fad7d993"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4871e0270938313d3344dab2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752216,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am sick and tired of asking the same question again and again. Grant extortion situation\n               in Surrey — 96 calls reported on extortions; 16 shootings; 51 victims; 27 repeated\n               victims; two targeted killings, both murders in the daylight in Surrey within one\n               week. Within one week. The B.C. NDP government is failing to protect Surrey residents. Will the Premier protect Surrey residents, or will people leave Surrey and this beautiful\n               British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752216","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am sick and tired of asking the same question again and again. Grant extortion situation\n               in Surrey — 96 calls reported on extortions; 16 shootings; 51 victims; 27 repeated\n               victims; two targeted killings, both murders in the daylight in Surrey within one\n               week. Within one week. The B.C. NDP government is failing to protect Surrey residents. Will the Pre","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["835060dd81777fa0436b2c7d66c54dcc269b010183e35d8795e61dc9e8f3206b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad4a94859e3791fdf3a67ad9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017258,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to introduce members of the Sikh community who are here from the Lower\n               Mainland and are involved in community advocacy. Please join me in welcoming Rav Singh\n               Pandalhu, from Unan Dharaj Heritage Society; Jagmeet Singh Balh; Kanwu Singh Dhaliwal;\n               Hujat Singh; Aman Singh; Jarvinder Singh; Arch Singh; Moninder Singh; Mec Singh; Diwhal\n               Singh. Please join me in welcoming them in the Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017258","member_id":"bc-mla-400","member_name":"Mandeep Dhaliwal","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to introduce members of the Sikh community who are here from the Lower\n               Mainland and are involved in community advocacy. Please join me in welcoming Rav Singh\n               Pandalhu, from Unan Dharaj Heritage Society; Jagmeet Singh Balh; Kanwu Singh Dhaliwal;\n               Hujat Singh; Aman Singh; Jarvinder Singh; Arch Singh; Moninder Singh; Mec Singh; Diwhal\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Historical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035688","label":"Historical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6efaed224899d87884d8dbe6f675a821b270f92b801d6cdb36c371409070abce","b142816bc1d161d0ca1db58197457d3ee08fdb182ae6af4ac6ba31bddb0e57ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c5d8e5bdfcd3729ad3177cc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316818,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brent Chapman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am proud to acknowledge a wonderful seniors living community in my constituency,\n               Rosemary Heights Seniors Village. Their CEO Graham Freeman and general manager Christian\n               Bunts are here with us in the chamber today. Rosemary Heights won the Workplace of\n               the Year award last night at the B.C. Care Providers Association Care Awards ceremony. The Workplace of the Year award recognizes BCCPA members in the seniors living and\n               care sector who demonstrate exceptional staff engagement, recognition and positive\n               workplace culture. I would ask the House to join me in congratulating the team at Rosemary Heights for\n               building a culture of trust, collaboration and moments that matter for the staff and\n               of course the residents.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316818","member_id":"bc-mla-401","member_name":"Brent Chapman","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I am proud to acknowledge a wonderful seniors living community in my constituency,\n               Rosemary Heights Seniors Village. Their CEO Graham Freeman and general manager Christian\n               Bunts are here with us in the chamber today. Rosemary Heights won the Workplace of\n               the Year award last night at the B.C. Care Providers Association Care Awards ceremony. The Workplace","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["938ae602814ecb35058c8617395ac159fa644a613507e1f16820013f5476ef1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["776a64afa0175fa4b7ebf9dd0b258082415ba8f1653e5c9d63d957fe5c959b14"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-93cba915df032b3bb4215179","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359651,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brent Chapman","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Surrey Eagles of the BCHL were the 2023-24 Fred Page champions. Though the Eagles\n               made the playoffs the following year, '25-26 has been a tough one for the South Surrey\n               squad. The math is against them, so the Eagles will be watching the playoffs this\n               year — unusual for this reliable franchise. Anyone who follows sports understands what a rebuilding year can look like. There's\n               some disappointment game to game, but overall, the Surrey hockey fans always have\n               a positive outlook for this great group of local young men. The team has a dedicated coaching staff and strong management, but the heart of the\n               Surrey Eagles is in the ownership. Local business leader Ron Brar and his family have\n               their caring fingerprints all over the operations of the team. Don't get me wrong.\n               This is not a Jerry Jones kind of situation. Not that Ron doesn't have opinions on the gameplay. He leaves\n               the game's strategy and player personnel to his assembled coaching staff. The wonder of this club is the hard work on the ice, win or lose, and its dedication\n               to the community. Families and kids feel right at home in the boisterous, energetic\n               yet safe surroundings of the South Surrey arena. Live hockey for families in Vancouver might be out of reach these days, but not in\n               South Surrey. There are big screens at both ends of the rink to review the big goal\n               or a great play. The concession stand has a remarkable variety of drinks, treats,\n               hot dogs and Indian snacks. Oh yeah, and the popcorn is very popular. But the real treat is the kids. They are not on little screens. They go down by the\n               glass and watch the game. They run up to the concourse during the period breaks to\n               buy themselves a couple of player cards from the Surrey Eagles souvenir stand only\n               to track down players later to get those cards signed. The kids have their local heroes,\n               and the local heroes treat the kids like stars. If they could give an award for the club that provides great entertainment and a safe\n               surrounding at a reasonable price, Ron Brar and his family would be taking the cup\n               home every year. Go, Eagles!","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359651","member_id":"bc-mla-401","member_name":"Brent Chapman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The Surrey Eagles of the BCHL were the 2023-24 Fred Page champions. Though the Eagles\n               made the playoffs the following year, '25-26 has been a tough one for the South Surrey\n               squad. The math is against them, so the Eagles will be watching the playoffs this\n               year — unusual for this reliable franchise. Anyone who follows sports understands what a rebuilding ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36e565f0bfa501a1bcd686e75c5ce543c940ef409b22fcacaebc20eef184f651"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b0eaf4dd9e50841053b12318fa8615960d5dcec71a7c298afae6c8c9d12d9a7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff3175b7ef7e5681354022ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728882,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brent Chapman","venue":"Hansard","text":"About a year ago, I realized the growth on my neck wasn't going away on its own. I\n               really didn't think it was cancer. It was MLA Dr. Kindy who told me in no uncertain\n               terms that I had to get it checked. I did. I had cancer in my tongue, and it was presenting\n               on the right side of my neck. A further PET scan confirmed the cancer was confined\n               to my neck and tongue area. Admittedly, I was trying alternatives — keto, an array of supplements and visits to\n               a highly regarded naturopath who specialized in cancer. Nothing slowed the growth.\n               Actually, it was the naturopath that said: \"Brent, it's time to bring in the big guns.\"\n               So off to Surrey hospital I went. At the B.C. cancer clinic at Surrey hospital, Dr. Jazwell was in charge of my radiation.\n               Oncologist Dr. Yu supervised the chemotherapy. Both were absolutely perfect in tone\n               and instruction — nothing sugar-coated, yet they understood the emotions I would be\n               dealing with. My cancer is treated by an internationally recognized protocol: 35 rounds of radiation\n               and seven rounds of chemo. Seven weeks, you count down the days. They use as strong\n               a radiation as possible, and the chemotherapy is meant to sensitize the tumour to\n               the radiation. They try to avoid surgery, and so far, they avoided doing surgery on\n               me. During treatment, I lost about 45 pounds, and apparently, radiation burns 4,200 calories\n               a day. That's a lot of elliptical. It was critical that I didn't lose too much weight,\n               as there is a risk of altering the depth of the radiation. Also, I had to be strong\n               enough to keep the treatment going, and I got through. There's more, but it all brings me to here — this place, standing in front of all\n               of you as a cancer survivor. I would like to thank all the people here in this building\n               who found a way to let me know — and this is on both sides — and I can't tell you\n               how much that meant to me every day I was trying to get through the steps I needed\n               to take. I know there are years to go, but as of right now, I have been deemed cancer-free.\n               A lot of people ask me if I asked: \"Why me?\" I tell you sincerely that my response\n               was: \"Why not me?\" There are little kids with knitted caps on their heads facing radiation\n               and chemo before they even get to go to school. If they can persevere, then I have\n               to. A lot of people ask me if I asked: \"Why me?\" And I tell you sincerely that my response\n               was: \"Why not me?\" There are little kids with knitted caps on their heads facing radiation\n               and chemo before they even got to go to school. If they can persevere, then I have\n               to. I'm not sure how this will sound, but when I ponder the two wonderful women across\n               the way and all they're fighting so hard for, that is when I actually find myself\n               asking: \"Why me?\" I don't have an answer for that, but all I can say is, Joan and Grace, I am pulling\n               and praying for you as much as I can.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Radiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728882","member_id":"bc-mla-401","member_name":"Brent Chapman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"About a year ago, I realized the growth on my neck wasn't going away on its own. I\n               really didn't think it was cancer. It was MLA Dr. Kindy who told me in no uncertain\n               terms that I had to get it checked. I did. I had cancer in my tongue, and it was presenting\n               on the right side of my neck. A further PET scan confirmed the cancer was confined\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","label":"Radiation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","label":"Irradiation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Radiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","label":"Irradiation","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","label":"Radiation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1639f6d9594b6b2daa1492ffabcf8405c43bb5f5a4b8b32886afbdfc0432b08e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Radiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2002ba96d86e949282d038a01a29a3d00e505f5fc51d1999be8fbc0e869bca84"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Radiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Irradiation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035321","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:314775","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7529177b286385616a5c13f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752189,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brent Chapman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Bill 9 is a quiet but devastating assault on British Columbia's Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Act. While they call it streamlining, it is nothing less\n               than a rollback of the very transparency that British Columbians have fought for decades\n               to protect. Let us speak plainly about where this leaves us on the world stage. The authoritative\n               global rights to information rating, the international gold standard measuring legal\n               strength of access to information laws, ranks countries out of 150 points. Top of\n               the world is Afghanistan at 139, Mexico at 136 and Serbia at 135. These jurisdictions\n               have built regimes with minimal exceptions, swift timelines, ironclad appeals and\n               genuine proactive disclosure. Canada's federal law sits at a mediocre 93 points, 53rd place. British Columbia's\n               FOIPPA has long been among the strongest in Canada, a provincial leader that kept\n               us competitive internationally. Bill 9 changes all that. It would replace the duty\n               to respond without delay....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752189","member_id":"bc-mla-401","member_name":"Brent Chapman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Bill 9 is a quiet but devastating assault on British Columbia's Freedom of Information\n               and Protection of Privacy Act. While they call it streamlining, it is nothing less\n               than a rollback of the very transparency that British Columbians have fought for decades\n               to protect. Let us speak plainly about where this leaves us on the world stage. The authoritativ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a69ea07c355c50cbe7907f9d233a1161531419c37374973c2b7cb4ea51eebfb7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a543ec62b9493555b1a834b219148b0de5b0dc8f3f6bb45c1fbaa3687626e651"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4f263f39dd2ed28d47c3b35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752190,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brent Chapman","venue":"Hansard","text":"As if it wasn't bad enough already, the people in British Columbia have had nine\n               years of demoralization, but with the complete alteration in the relationship between\n               the government and the legal profession, the medical professions, parents, school\n               children, realtors, retailers, construction workers, miners, foresters, fishers, short-term\n               renters, farmers, ranchers, landlords, drivers and, of course, home- and property\n               owners. On top of that the Canucks finished last but still didn't get the first draft pick,\n               and it looks like the Whitecaps might be on their way to Vegas. The government never\n               being one not to pile on, decided now is the time to offer a lousy dessert after a\n               force-feeding of a nine-year bile buffet to the good people of British Columbia. And\n               what's on the menu for dessert? Changing the requirements for a freedom-of-information\n               request. The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act — what on earth did British\n               Columbia do to deserve this bill from this government? You would think, with the nightmare\n               that has befallen this province in the form of DRIPA and all the existential uncertainty\n               it brings, that this government might just put its feet up for a while and stop twisting\n               the thumbscrews even tighter. If I didn't know better, I would think that they have\n               a fascination with finding out just how much the people can take. The most recent polls might be an indication that British Columbians may have finally\n               had their fill. So I stand here today, this evening, to fight for a reprieve, albeit\n               very modest. I am fully supporting the hoist motion that is before the House. When\n               a government seems to derive so much delight from running roughshod over its own people,\n               something must be done to compel them to hit \"pause.\" Even if for a few months, for\n               the love of god, can't we give people a breather? It really is shocking to be a witness to such a flagrant use of legislative authority.\n               Of all things you would think a Western government could do with a majority, stifling\n               access to information that is generated in this House by the people that the hard-earned\n               tax dollars paid for is so cynical that only this callous NDP government would take\n               the time to foist it on British Columbians. In any event, watching them around here, they seem not ashamed or even embarrassed.\n               If they are, I'm not seeing it. I guess with all they've done over the past nine years,\n               in their eyes, this slap in the face must seem like small potatoes. Let's take a look at freedom of information in the world and how this hoist motion\n               might give everyone a chance to rethink this bill and the government. The British\n               Columbia Freedom of Information and Privacy Protection Act, while they call it streamlining,\n               is nothing less than a rollback of the very transparency that British Columbians have\n               fought for decades to protect. Let us speak plainly about where this leaves us on the world stage and why we need\n               the hoist motion. The authoritative Global Right to Information Rating, the international\n               gold standard measuring legal strength of access to information laws, ranks countries\n               out of 150 points. Top of the world, Afghanistan, at 139; Mexico, at 136; and The authoritative Global Right to Information rating, the international gold standard\n               measuring legal strength of access-to-information laws, ranks countries out of 150\n               points. Top of the world, Afghanistan at 139, Mexico at 136 and Serbia at 135. These\n               jurisdictions have built regimes with minimal exceptions, swift timelines, ironclad\n               appeals and genuine proactive disclosure. Canada's federal law sits at a mediocre\n               93 points, 53rd place. British Columbia's FOIPPA has long been among the strongest in Canada, a provincial\n               leader that kept us competitive internationally. Bill 9 changes all that. It replaces\n               the duty to respond \"without delay\" with the vague \"without unreasonable delay.\" It\n               hands public bodies new powers to dismiss requests they deem abusive or burdensome.\n               It weakens specificity rules and opens the door to longer extensions without real\n               oversight. These are not minor tweaks. They are deliberate restrictions that critics rightly\n               call a weakening of access. When Mexico and Serbia, nations once dismissed as less\n               open than ours, now outrank us on paper, and when even our own federal law lags behind\n               global best practices, this government is choosing secrecy over sunlight. They deserve\n               a province that leads the world in openness, not one that slides backwards into the\n               middle of the pack. I am pleased to speak about this hoist motion tonight, not simply to oppose Bill 9\n               but to defend one of the most important democratic principles we have in British Columbia:\n               the principle that government must remain accountable to the people it serves. I rise\n               to defend the principle that information does not belong to politicians, ministers,\n               bureaucrats or governments. It belongs to the public. I rise today in support of the hoist motion before this House because the concerns\n               surrounding Bill 9 are too serious, too numerous and too unresolved for this legislation\n               to proceed without a pause. Why the hoist motion? Because this is not a routine amendment. It is not a harmless\n               administrative update. It is not simply modernization, no matter how many times the\n               government repeats that word. Bill 9 fundamentally changes the relationship between\n               citizens and their government. It changes the balance between transparency and control,\n               which is why the hoist motion is absolutely necessary. It fundamentally alters the\n               balance between openness and secrecy. When legislation carries consequences of that magnitude, this Legislature has responsibility\n               to stop, reflect, scrutinize and reconsider. That is precisely why a hoist motion\n               exists, and that is precisely why this House should support a six-month pause on Bill\n               9. A hoist motion is not obstruction. A hoist motion is responsibility. It is a parliamentary\n               mechanism designed specifically for situations where legislation raises profound concerns\n               that require deeper public examination before moving forward. Bill 9 unquestionably meets that threshold because opposition to this bill is not\n               isolated. The concerns surrounding Bill 9 are broad, serious and completely credible.\n               Former architects of British Columbia's freedom-of-information legislation have raised\n               alarms. Journalists have raised alarms. Transparency advocates have raised alarms.\n               Accountability watchdogs have raised alarms.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752190","member_id":"bc-mla-401","member_name":"Brent Chapman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As if it wasn't bad enough already, the people in British Columbia have had nine\n               years of demoralization, but with the complete alteration in the relationship between\n               the government and the legal profession, the medical professions, parents, school\n               children, realtors, retailers, construction workers, miners, foresters, fishers, short-term\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc3ed75775aec7abccf29a8d690a5aa2e518bfec4569323de8a8306b819f12cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["877b7ec61bea3715be84de5bc5b929697b0e4564997cf0f11c5fc2bdeefc8368"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15a67fa127bdedd35be396e2","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187092,"date":"2026-02-19T12:00:00+00:00","title":"POST-SECONDARY INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION (DESIGNATED INSTITUTIONS) ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov07-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov07-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187092","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d37673594d3d1651aebe6c76","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187093,"date":"2026-02-19T12:00:00+00:00","title":"POST-SECONDARY INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION (DESIGNATED INSTITUTIONS) ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov07-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov07-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187093","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ad6e638c7bd8b0c5fb232e0b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317210,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin my remarks on the budget, I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge\n               the unthinkable tragedy that has affected the community of Tumbler Ridge and each\n               and every one of us here and across the province and country as a result. Our hearts\n               are with the families who are grieving, with the friends and neighbours whose lives\n               have been irreversibly shaken and with the community that is navigating this Amid this tragedy, heartbreaking loss, what we have seen in the days since is something\n               profoundly Canadian — neighbours showing up for one another, first responders stepping\n               forward with courage and compassion, local leaders offering steadiness and community\n               members wrapping their arms around those who need it most. To the people of Tumbler Ridge: you are not alone. This House stands with you. We\n               will continue to support you in every way we can in the days, weeks, months and years\n               ahead. I am honoured to rise today in support of Budget 2026 in my role as Minister of Post-Secondary\n               Education and Future Skills and as the proud MLA for Surrey-Newton. I'd like to start by acknowledging the lək̓wəŋən Peoples, the Songhees and Esquimalt\n               Nations upon whose lands we are gathered today. Let me start with a simple truth. Budget 2026 is about people. It's about making life\n               better for British Columbians, helping them build good careers, manage the cost of\n               living and feel safe in their communities. It's about opportunity, the kind that doesn't\n               just open a door but keeps it open for the next person. Because at the heart of this\n               year's budget is a simple idea: that people deserve opportunity — opportunity to learn,\n               opportunity to train and the opportunity to build a good life. Our government continues to invest in post-secondary education and skills training\n               so British Columbians can gain the skills and expertise that they need for the jobs\n               and careers of today and the opportunities of tomorrow. Budget 2026 provides our ministry with a total budget of $3.58 billion for 2026-2027.\n               That's not just a number. It's tuition covered. It's apprentices hired. It's a pathway\n               to the middle class. I have the privilege of seeing the work behind the numbers — the steadfast commitment\n               to lifting people up, the partnerships with institutions and unions and the conversations\n               with students forging their own path. And I can tell you that behind every single\n               dollar is a story — a student learning, getting one step closer to graduation; parents\n               retraining for a career change; workers training for new opportunities as our economy\n               evolves and strengthens. This investment will give people the tools to succeed and give our province the workforce\n               we need to grow our economy and become the economic engine of Canada. Over the next\n               decade, B.C. expects more than one million job openings, and with 40 percent of Canada's\n               priority projects happening right here in B.C., the stakes are high. This means opportunity\n               is coming fast, and we intend to make sure that people right here in B.C. are first\n               in line. We need a skilled workforce ready to seize those opportunities, and we are acting\n               on doing just that. My ministry and this government remain focused on investing in\n               people, education and training to build economic resilience, to support the workforce\n               needed for today and the opportunities of tomorrow. Across the province, 18 priority major projects, including construction, clean energy,\n               mining, critical minerals, infrastructure and advanced technology are moving forward,\n               and we are making sure that British Columbians benefit. So 77 percent of the over\n               one million job openings in B.C. over the next decade will require post-secondary\n               education, trades training or skills upgrading. That's why we're working closely with\n               post-secondary institutions, Indigenous partners, industry, businesses and unions\n               to make sure training matches what the job market actually needs. Programs such as the future skills grant and micro-credentials are designed to support\n               priority sectors in high-opportunity jobs, technical occupations and skills needed\n               for emerging technologies and a clean economy. I want to tell you about Mehret Ramkhan. He used a StrongerBC future skills grant\n               to complete a micro-credential at UVic in 2024. The essential soft skills training\n               micro-credential he completed helped him secure a job at UVic in B.C. with good pay,\n               benefits and pride in his work. This budget stands for people like him. It stands for potential. It stands for paycheques\n               earned through purpose. It stands for a B.C. that grows because its people grow and\n               prosper. That's why our government This budget stands for people like him. It stands for potential. It stands for paycheques\n               earned through purpose. It stands for a B.C. that grows because its people grow and\n               prosper. That's why our government launched the Look West strategy, a jobs and economic strategy\n               to make B.C. the powerhouse of Canada, to create good jobs and drive prosperity in\n               every single corner of this province. Look West builds on the StrongerBC future-ready action plan, which helped over 100,000\n               people across our province access skills training and supported 145,000 people with\n               more affordable education while guiding 300,000 people towards post-secondary pathways.\n               Those are our province's future workers. I visited a trades-training centre in the Lower Mainland and met with a young apprentice\n               from Surrey who told me that he was ready to give up because the wait-lists at institutions\n               were far too long. Then an intake opened. Today he's building homes, earning a great\n               wage and proud of the work that he's doing. He said something I'll never forget. He told me: \"I didn't just get access to a seat.\n               I got access to a better opportunity for me and my family.\" This is who we work for. In the last budget, the other side of the House voted against the $107 million that\n               our government provides to SkilledTradesBC to grow and support trades training. This\n               is despite their commitment to increasing funding to SkilledTradesBC by $70 million\n               over two years in their 2024 platform. I'm proud to say that our government will be investing $241 million over three years,\n               with $54 million being invested this year to strengthen B.C.'s trades-training system\n               in order to double funding to SkilledTradesBC by 2028-2029. This is a historic investment, the first of its kind in almost 20 years. This funding\n               will increase per-seat funding for apprentice programs; address wait-lists for critical\n               industrial trades; advance skilled-trades certification, beginning with crane operators;\n               and ensure workers can move easily between industries as opportunities evolve. I urge the other side to not vote against the historic funding to skilled trades in\n               B.C. I urge them to vote in favour of the aspiring tradespeople in Kamloops, in Courtenay,\n               in Langley, in Prince George, in Surrey and all across British Columbia, who simply\n               want to pursue a meaningful career and build the future of our province. This investment is not just about spending. It's building. It's building homes, building\n               infrastructure, building clean energy projects, building careers and building communities.\n               I urge the other side of the House to put aside partisan ideology, join us, and do\n               what voters sent us here to do – to work together, to solve problems and to make life\n               better for British Columbians. This $241 million investment will ensure that B.C. has the talent needed to deliver\n               our mutual economic priorities, from building more housing and major infrastructure\n               projects to advancing innovation in clean energy and emerging technologies. This investment\n               will allow us to create opportunities and deliver real results for people and businesses\n               across the province through Look West, our government's jobs and economic growth strategy. Through Budget 2026, our ministry is receiving an additional $283 million over three\n               years to support initiatives under the Look West strategy, including the historic\n               $241 million investment over three years to double B.C.'s trades-training system funding,\n               as well as an investment of $42 million over three years by adding targeted, highly\n               qualified professional training streams to existing short-term training programs in\n               priority sectors. This strategy will help B.C. lead the country in job creation, innovation and economic\n               growth. At its core is something simple – making sure every community from the Pacific\n               to the Rockies has the skilled workers needed to grow the economy and grow people's\n               paycheques. Our government will continue to lead in investing in the jobs of the future. Every year our ministry supports 4,000 more student spaces than we did in 2017, backed\n               by $77.7 million in annual funding. We've also provided Mitacs with $50 million to support 10,000 internships over five\n               years for students in priority sectors We've also provided Mitacs with $50 million to support 10,000 internships over five\n               years for students in priority sectors such as clean energy, life sciences, emergency\n               management, advanced timber and agritech. Through this funding, interns have helped grow businesses like Human in Motion Robotics,\n               Spannovation, Inverted AI, 1Qbit and D-Wave. Through our Look West strategy, B.C. is targeting AI and quantum computing as priority sectors for economic\n               growth. Over the next ten years, our goal is to double the size of these sectors,\n               grow tech employment to 400,000 jobs and increase their GDP contribution by 75 percent. We're investing in the electricity infrastructure needed for AI data centres, with\n               B.C. Hydro launching a competitive process in 2026 to allocate power specifically\n               for AI. We're fostering partnerships between universities and businesses to develop\n               real-world AI applications, from drug discovery and cancer screening to geospatial\n               analytics. The Quantum Algorithms Institute, with members from UVic, SFU and UBC, is helping\n               strengthen our capabilities in quantum computing and cybersecurity. We're preparing\n               people for careers that haven't even been invented yet. We know that a stronger B.C. starts by supporting the people who care for us and our\n               loved ones in our times of need. That's why we're expanding training programs across\n               our province. We need more doctors, nurses, paramedics, allied health professionals,\n               midwives and health care assistants. We're training them in every region across our\n               province, so everyone, no matter where you live, can access the care you need, where\n               and when you need it. Since 2017, over 66,000 graduates have been awarded credentials in health programs.\n               This is an 11 percent increase in the number of health program graduates in priority\n               areas. Every year, our government provides more than $250 million in targeted funding\n               for health education programs to public post-secondary institutions throughout B.C.\n               and has provided significant additional investments to respond directly to health\n               workforce needs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317210","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Before I begin my remarks on the budget, I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge\n               the unthinkable tragedy that has affected the community of Tumbler Ridge and each\n               and every one of us here and across the province and country as a result. Our hearts\n               are with the families who are grieving, with the friends and neighbours whose lives\n               have be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["11d3e27ccd099bb255147109baac0fe73efdcc03ab4e7cd83befffcf24731e78"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["24008d122a211341cf659ff82dedc30c7c372251a850bdb0e27b56893e46589d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-315a66fece6cb2c7c13b6248","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328053,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill, the Post-Secondary International Education (Designated Institutions)\n               Act, be read a second time now. I am proud to rise in the House today as the Minister of Post-Secondary Education\n               and Future Skills to speak to Bill 7, the Post-Secondary International Education (Designated\n               Institutions) Act. Before I begin, I'd like to acknowledge that I'm speaking today from the traditional\n               territories of the lək̓wəŋən Peoples, the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations. I stand before you today not only as the Minister of Post-Secondary Education and\n               Future Skills but also as someone who believes deeply in the value that international\n               education brings to our communities, our institutions and our province. For years, international students have chosen British Columbia, drawn by promises\n               of a high-quality education and a pathway for a better future. For most, that promise\n               holds true. The majority of our institutions deliver excellent education, strong support\n               for students and life-changing opportunity. But not everyone has had that experience. Students arrive in British Columbia looking forward to support from their school,\n               clear expectations, adequate facilities and a welcoming community. But what they sometimes\n               find instead are promises that aren't lived up to and conditions that don't deliver\n               the standards that we all expect from a post-secondary institution in our province.\n               When this happens, the impacts are profound to the individual student, to our communities\n               and to B.C.'s global reputation as a top destination for education and opportunity. With this proposed legislation, we're taking decisive action to prevent these experiences\n               from happening to anyone else, and if students have these experiences, government\n               will have the authority and tools to act swiftly and hold bad actors to account. This\n               is our commitment to quality education, the integrity of the sector and enhancing\n               the student experience. British Columbia's educational quality assessment program was established in 2009.\n               Currently, EQA operates in policy, alongside other existing regulations and statutes\n               governing private and public post-secondary institutions, providing an added layer\n               of quality assurance focused on the international student experience. EQA is the mechanism B.C. uses to assess if post-secondary institutions meet the criteria\n               established in agreement with the federal government for institutions to enrol international\n               students. Institutions that obtain an EQA designation are placed on the federal designated learning\n               institutions, DLI, list and are eligible to recruit and enrol international students. Currently, roughly 220 institutions — public, private, degree-granting, private training\n               and others — hold an EQA designation. These institutions are subject to existing oversight Currently roughly 220 institutions — public, private, degree-granting, private training\n               and others — hold an EQA designation. These institutions are subject to existing oversight\n               under different acts, depending on which category they fall into. In 2024, our government announced its international education framework with measures\n               to strengthen quality standards and protections for international students. Over the\n               past several years, the ministry has implemented these strengthened EQA requirements,\n               and the program has been effective. However, without the legislative foundation, there\n               are limitations on government's ability to fully enforce standards and conduct formal\n               inspections. This has created a gap that can be exploited by post-secondary and can\n               leave students vulnerable and also put the sector's reputation at risk. Bill 7 builds upon and codifies the work under this framework. This new act replaces\n               the existing, policy-based EQA program by formalizing it into legislation, tightening\n               expectations and strengthening enforcement for institutions that host international\n               students. Let me walk you through the key things that this new act will do. First, this legislation creates a clear prohibition. Institutions cannot recruit,\n               enrol or deliver programs to international students who require a study permit unless\n               the institution has a valid designation certificate under this act. This means institutions\n               must be designated before advertising programs, offering placements, enrolling or\n               delivering instructions to students who require a study permit to study in B.C. This\n               closes gaps that can lead to misleading or deceptive recruitment practices. Second, this bill establishes clear legal criteria that institutions must meet to\n               obtain and maintain their EQA designation. The criteria includes proving programs\n               and services are stable; providing clear, accessible information to students; offering\n               strong student supports; maintaining good standing with regulatory bodies; and upholding\n               B.C.'s global reputation for integrity and quality education. These criteria will\n               ensure international students receive the educational experience they were promised. Third, this legislation strengthens oversight and enforcement. The act gives government\n               the necessary tools for monitoring and enforcing compliance, to hold bad actors to\n               account. This includes the authority to conduct inspections, issue compliance orders\n               and attach terms and conditions to designation certificates. In addition, the act\n               implements a transparent appeals process and sets fees through regulation to support\n               the cost of oversight. This new legal foundation creates a legislative compliance\n               and enforcement framework that gives government the ability to act swiftly where concerns\n               and issues arise. Fourth, this bill establishes an administrator as an independent statutory decision-maker\n               over the program. It also establishes an appeal officer to review significant decisions. Finally, it supports flexibility and responsiveness. Key requirements for designation\n               will be set through regulation and administrator rules, allowing the legislative framework\n               to adapt to federal and other regulatory requirements or changes or if the broader\n               sector concerns evolve. This ensures that B.C. can respond quickly to bad actors and\n               reinforce our government's focus on maintaining a high-quality education system. These changes reflect our belief that the strength of B.C.'s international education\n               system depends on integrity, transparency and genuine support for students. International\n               students place immense trust in our institutions. Only those institutions that can\n               offer a safe, positive learning environment with the right wraparound support should\n               have the privilege of welcoming students to B.C. International education continues to play a valuable role in B.C.'s post-secondary\n               education system and in communities across our province. The sector has grown more\n               complex, and the need for clearer standards and stronger oversight has become increasingly\n               evident. Institutions benefit from the diversity and global connections that international\n               students bring, and students contribute academically, culturally and economically. International students can be uniquely vulnerable as they navigate their educational\n               journey here in B.C. Strengthening the designation framework reinforces student protection,\n               institutional accountability and B.C.'s reputation as a desired destination for international\n               education. By establishing a stronger foundation for oversight and accountability, this legislation\n               helps ensure the international education system remains sustainable I'm proud to be bringing forward this legislation, which reinforces the integrity\n               and stability of B.C.'s international education system. I'm equally proud of the progress\n               made to date through the international education framework and enhanced standards\n               implemented across the sector over the last several years. This legislation represents\n               meaningful progress, but there is so much more work to do ahead, and we will continue\n               to work every single day to strengthen this sector. Today I invite each of you in this House to join us and support this bill. Join us\n               in protecting international students and continuing to strengthen the integrity of\n               B.C.'s post-secondary system. Together we can ensure every international student who\n               chooses B.C. receives a positive, safe and meaningful education experience that they\n               deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328053","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that the bill, the Post-Secondary International Education (Designated Institutions)\n               Act, be read a second time now. I am proud to rise in the House today as the Minister of Post-Secondary Education\n               and Future Skills to speak to Bill 7, the Post-Secondary International Education (Designated\n               Institutions) Act. Before I begin, I'd like to acknowledg","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","label":"Corruption","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ab93bf11bae690168df6cb8e5a408136640eaa0c29516ccf9a9600fb612ccd3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["566854d78d655d3417ee0d87b4e53c7ea79af46b921185d1e5287570543fe817"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f9245d80aa80083a21b4f13b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328054,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise in this House in support of the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, Bill\n               8. These legislative amendments will improve fairness, clarity and efficiency, along\n               with supporting the pursuit of illegally acquired criminal assets. People in this province work hard. They build businesses, they raise families, they\n               follow the rules, and they expect one thing in return: that their government will\n               keep their communities safe, with action. Today I want to talk about that action, because organized crime and money laundering\n               are not abstract issues. They are not headlines that come and go. They affect housing\n               prices. They fuel crime. They hurt small businesses. They threaten families. For too long, criminal organizations have operated on one basic idea: if the money\n               is good enough, the risk is worth it. This government is here to change that calculation.\n               This government is here to take the profit out of crime. This government is doing\n               this by strengthening B.C.'s Civil Forfeiture Act through the Civil Forfeiture Amendment\n               Act, 2026. This is not about expanding power for the sake of power. This is not about cutting\n               corners. It's about being smarter, faster, fairer and tougher. It's about making sure\n               that crime does not pay in British Columbia. Let's be clear about what we're up against. Organized crime today is not what it was\n               20 years ago. It's sophisticated; it's international; it's technologically savvy.\n               It launders money across borders in seconds. It hides assets behind shell companies,\n               nominees and layers of paperwork. Because of our government, the days of the duffel bag full of cash are largely gone.\n               Today criminal proceeds are parked in luxury vehicles, real estate, corporate accounts,\n               cryptocurrency and high-end goods. When those assets sit untouched in storage, for\n               months or years, while cases wind through the courts, they lose value. Storage fees\n               pile up, legal costs rise, and court time is consumed. As the MLA for Surrey-Newton, I've met with constituents from my community who see this progress being made but\n               also ask: \"Why are these prosecutions taking so long?\" The answer I give my constituents\n               is that the law needs to keep up with the times. This is exactly what this legislation\n               does, and I'm glad that we are delivering for people across British Columbia. Before I go further, I want to talk about what civil forfeiture actually is. Civil\n               forfeiture is not a criminal conviction. It does not change the criminal standard\n               of proof. It does not eliminate court oversight. Every forfeiture still goes before\n               a judge. What civil forfeiture does allow is to give the province the ability to go after property\n               that is proven, on a civil standard, to be the proceeds or tools of unlawful activity. Noting the hour, I reserve my right to resume the debate and move to adjourn the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328054","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I rise in this House in support of the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, Bill\n               8. These legislative amendments will improve fairness, clarity and efficiency, along\n               with supporting the pursuit of illegally acquired criminal assets. People in this province work hard. They build businesses, they raise families, they\n               follow the rules, and they expect one","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af86b7896144445866cdcc2b46e12e404ca04c796ce641a129a6994d8a801cc0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f3689628b4529676e36a128a8a8f86780e7b849bcc43f242e234d586723d10ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d07133cabeb81b96d0e57f96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361023,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome Dr. Paula Burns, who is the president of Langara College and the\n               chair of B.C. Colleges. B.C.'s public colleges are the backbone of","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361023","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome Dr. Paula Burns, who is the president of Langara College and the\n               chair of B.C. Colleges. B.C.'s public colleges are the backbone of","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f3ba38b36500b383dcfb3849fdcd02dba575caf711238d2393b82c283c0f6174"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b5e58fef7c5672f4c54bf33c4d7cfe81303d24af35a45cde864452394996d46"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c079ff252e200d0c1ce6e8c4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361024,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. I recognize that we are having\n               conversations about this, and we will continue to do so. I just want to recognize that Quest University is a private university under the Sea\n               to Sky University Act. The government has little authority to intervene in the actions\n               of an entity under a private act, including providing direction to the university\n               or appointing members. As it's a private university, the ministry does not provide\n               any kind of operating funding to this institution. The Degree Authorization Act under\n               which it is operating.... It has consent until the end of May of this year. It is currently undergoing a quality assessment process, which is done by an independent\n               external review of its new organizational structure. Those recommendations will be\n               made to me as minister, and a decision will come in the coming months. I'm happy to\n               continue these conversations with the member.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361024","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. I recognize that we are having\n               conversations about this, and we will continue to do so. I just want to recognize that Quest University is a private university under the Sea\n               to Sky University Act. The government has little authority to intervene in the actions\n               of an entity under a private act, including ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Private schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","label":"Private schools","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["929b6f1f35a2d50c72c98d263e19e87f5c31447923f9e02f703ba2890e190285"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf002f8dc9d37976e6f5690db8319d9f805baf81c766b7a5735f98817dfbcb1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16a93700dc0ef63fed72a2de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361025,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today in strong support of the motion to affirm our unequivocal support for\n               the B.C. human rights code and the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal's powers to enforce\n               it. I recognize that the member that spoke before had really","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361025","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today in strong support of the motion to affirm our unequivocal support for\n               the B.C. human rights code and the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal's powers to enforce\n               it. I recognize that the member that spoke before had really","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9de56c4a3e57c986809555edc5d7269a22a65ac2f92a61457396dcf44f8da73b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["79eebf69375323d024e9f62f0424082c54edc81000ed002c856d6c7fb4b1c159"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8afadfcac9b70d21695e7b97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720603,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am really excited to recognize some very special guests here that are here from\n               Sikh Heritage B.C., and they're here to recognize Sikh Heritage Month today. Please\n               join me in welcoming Jasleen Kaur Sidhu, Monam Kaur Shergill, Eman Singh Shergill,\n               Kurban Singh Shergill, Harjit Singh Mondair and Karen Singh. Sikh Heritage Month is something that has been celebrated here in B.C. since 2018,\n               and Sikh Heritage B.C. was a big part of having that recognition in this House. We\n               know that Sikhs have been in B.C. and across Canada for over 125 years, giving contributions\n               in all different sectors of society. We are really excited that this lunch hour we\n               will be celebrating Sikh Heritage Month in the Hall of Honour, and I encourage everyone\n               that is able to please come join us. We look forward to that, and if everyone will please join me in making them feel very\n               welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720603","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am really excited to recognize some very special guests here that are here from\n               Sikh Heritage B.C., and they're here to recognize Sikh Heritage Month today. Please\n               join me in welcoming Jasleen Kaur Sidhu, Monam Kaur Shergill, Eman Singh Shergill,\n               Kurban Singh Shergill, Harjit Singh Mondair and Karen Singh. Sikh Heritage Month is something that has bee","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76614530ff64ea31152941fd810fe223fc145d71f3969f1f77fb4ace8e423ffd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ccad309c250d7a2006820e3b096516e0bf54dbf726299b6d881622aa9c19cc87"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1c36880203777c19f3af166","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721703,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for his advocacy as well as many members in this\n               House on both sides that have advocated for their communities when it comes to making\n               sure that we're recognizing the worker shortage that we're seeing across the province. This specific program is one that was implemented by the federal government, so the\n               one-year extension is from the federal government. There were two options in there\n               to allow individuals to maintain the 10 percent cap and then to increase it. We went with the first option because we recognize the impact that businesses are\n               feeling. We know that there's a lot of work that they are doing as well on the advocacy\n               front, and we appreciate their advocacy. But it's very important that recognizing this is only a one-year extension, this only\n               prolongs the issues that we're seeing, that the member has outlined here. The TFW\n               program has serious problems. We know that there's exploitation in the system when\n               we look at closed work permits. Individuals aren't able to move around. We know when\n               we look at LMIA programs that individuals are being sold LMIAs for upwards of $100,000\n               just to be here and then having ongoing concerns. These are individuals that are coming here to support our economy. We need to ensure\n               we're doing everything to support them. We do need to reform the program. We can't\n               just have one-off extensions. We need to reform the program and that is why our government\n               is advocating to the federal government regularly to say that we need to have greater\n               control over the economic immigration that we have in our province. We need to expand our PNP programs so that these individuals that are coming here,\n               that we so desperately need, have those pathways to citizenship, have the rights that\n               they were promised, are getting the treatment that they believed they were going to\n               get when they came here and are not being exploited.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721703","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for his advocacy as well as many members in this\n               House on both sides that have advocated for their communities when it comes to making\n               sure that we're recognizing the worker shortage that we're seeing across the province. This specific program is one that was implemented by the federal government, so the\n               one-year extensi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["789503efadd3638452fb735ee6702541763056c40d0e9ebd52659ad9d4c73c43"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c947355dc0e2c89be10447fdc8961c2d7186935b9b77dd5d312ed2436ddb11ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8eeae04e664d6725fc4473df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729472,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Also later.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729472","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Also later.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b983cddf25041d82aec85c3621ea936f4803163b78a0d2ea85b21d444a1aad22"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5853f5434638ee0c378e1158","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729484,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to recognize leaders today from the University of Victoria, which is a\n               university that provides made-in-B.C. solutions to priorities that are facing our\n               province. Today, joining us in the gallery, we have president Robina Thomas, along\n               with her colleagues that are strengthening our health care capacity, our clean energy\n               and the responsible use of artificial intelligence throughout our province, while\n               advancing B.C.'s capabilities in aerospace, in space systems, to support economic\n               growth and public interest. Under president Thomas' leadership, who is the acting interim president and will be\n               with the university until the end of June, UVic has advanced a strong model of Indigenous-engaged\n               research and education, grounded in partnership and shared priorities, and a tangible\n               community benefit. UVic is expanding access to education while positioning B.C. to\n               compete and collaborate internationally, in line with our province's Look West strategy. So if everyone would just join me in please welcoming Dr. Thomas, as well as her leadership\n               team from UVic here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729484","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to recognize leaders today from the University of Victoria, which is a\n               university that provides made-in-B.C. solutions to priorities that are facing our\n               province. Today, joining us in the gallery, we have president Robina Thomas, along\n               with her colleagues that are strengthening our health care capacity, our clean energy\n               and th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["485b542105f6e02645e9a2e0a04edb83ff38e9efdbfe6d8764db741edfa4d6cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["686ce2caf785dec2a10d567c0ee8821d3d166f059691bfef44ce79b76685f56b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-87bd8b498f0eb8e05dc6d577","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752348,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would just like to also introduce a constituent of mine who also happens to be my\n               constituency adviser — Angad Purva, who's also here with Mehdi Sangha. They're my\n               constituency advisers and amazing young people that are really the face and heart\n               of our offices. I just want to say thank you to them for all the hard work they do and ask the House\n               to please welcome them today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752348","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would just like to also introduce a constituent of mine who also happens to be my\n               constituency adviser — Angad Purva, who's also here with Mehdi Sangha. They're my\n               constituency advisers and amazing young people that are really the face and heart\n               of our offices. I just want to say thank you to them for all the hard work they do and ask the House\n      ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3a266cb359948e1a103704c407047c54e6cf3fe7d64cddb869eb0486c1302b5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba59db63ac485ed2f067637b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752349,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd also like to welcome a contingency of the World Sikh Organization of Canada that's\n               here today. We have Danish Singh Brar, the national president; Gurpreet Kaur Rai,\n               the B.C. regional president; Sandeep Singh Teward, the B.C. regional vice president;\n               and Guntaas Korjima, the national director of international affairs. They're also\n               accompanied by a large contingency of their B.C. regional members. The WSO is a leading national Sikh advocacy organization that's dedicated to promoting\n               and protecting the interests of Sikhs in Canada and around the world, while championing\n               human rights, equity, inclusion and protection of fundamental freedoms. They play\n               a vital role in upholding civil liberties and are at the forefront of advocacy efforts,\n               including in challenging Quebec's Bill 21. They do a number of initiatives here as well. I appreciate their advocacy. I know\n               they're meeting with members from both sides of the House today, and I look forward\n               to meeting with them later today. If the House will please join me in welcoming them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752349","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd also like to welcome a contingency of the World Sikh Organization of Canada that's\n               here today. We have Danish Singh Brar, the national president; Gurpreet Kaur Rai,\n               the B.C. regional president; Sandeep Singh Teward, the B.C. regional vice president;\n               and Guntaas Korjima, the national director of international affairs. They're also\n               acco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6dfb56aef918c11603ff4305ab90dd14f3ef6e39de5b06593f5bd64b1e67e042"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["730d0d959ab94b8ecd18c8ef7c90d6082575687d914bf0279795dc6c4014130b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c63e7afbc5e53a44cfe2032","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752350,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to recognize two very, very special people in my life: my parents, who\n               are celebrating their 40th wedding anniversary on Monday. They have built such a beautiful\n               life together, built on love, faith and unwavering partnership. They've given so much to my brothers and I and built such a beautiful life and showed\n               us every day what real commitment and partnership looks like. I use those values to\n               guide my own marriage, and I'm so thankful for everything that they do for us. Thanks will never be enough. I love you so much. If the House will please join me in congratulating them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752350","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I rise to recognize two very, very special people in my life: my parents, who\n               are celebrating their 40th wedding anniversary on Monday. They have built such a beautiful\n               life together, built on love, faith and unwavering partnership. They've given so much to my brothers and I and built such a beautiful life and showed\n               us every day what real commitm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72ae509e04e69a55c4dabdd2a32654934ef70e23badae7f07adee862f3fd5bac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ddf367a24c7e0d3fbce2c513fd959cb45f0431dca89494fc3fc69ffcdfa694b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8aad2242de529e74fd5f634","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017655,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017655","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6850055062891e605844323c672a026b736b95c350805585143340170b154dd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c1f63f1dbf965de601f1b56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017656,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome two members of our community that have done so much to build our\n               community. Mannu Sandhu is a community leader. She does so much work with International\n               South Asian Film Festival. She 's an incredible international actress in her own right\n               and now is also a fitness icon. I can't wait to get some tips, in a few months, from you. As well, her husband, Raj Aadmi, who is a fitness icon in his own right, as well as\n               a community builder, a philanthropist, a CEO. He has one of the coolest car washes\n               in our riding, Speedwash, as well. I just want to welcome them to the House. If the House will please join me in welcoming\n               them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017656","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome two members of our community that have done so much to build our\n               community. Mannu Sandhu is a community leader. She does so much work with International\n               South Asian Film Festival. She 's an incredible international actress in her own right\n               and now is also a fitness icon. I can't wait to get some tips, in a few months, from you. As we","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2abbee53b99c8773fdd25e25bdf34041283efe7d2c9ba31b1efffe41ea5381ce"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0910dddff2c444e2faee5cd685c300a97302818fe38b9ff6ff1caf1357e5c73"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8a5d2b774df4204a5d921411","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036590,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jessie Sunner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also would like to make a very special birthday wish to my father-in-law, Darshan.\n               It's his birthday today. He's one of the loyal YouTube viewers that, you know, when\n               there are 35 people watching, maybe, outside of this House, he's one of them, along\n               with his mom, Arnani. So I just want to wish you a very happy birthday. I hope you have a wonderful day\n               and if the House will please join me in wishing him a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036590","member_id":"bc-mla-402","member_name":"Jessie Sunner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I also would like to make a very special birthday wish to my father-in-law, Darshan.\n               It's his birthday today. He's one of the loyal YouTube viewers that, you know, when\n               there are 35 people watching, maybe, outside of this House, he's one of them, along\n               with his mom, Arnani. So I just want to wish you a very happy birthday. I hope you have a wonderful da","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9aa1eaa7435092fba298351be872fc3349fb4425820367146875abb3c8aacf8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-770dc8e7680a3df3fcf35398","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317211,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would start by saying that I do have some suggestions on what we could do further\n               on in this, to answer the previous one, but he'll have to wait. In the meantime, maybe\n               a quick example would be: \"Just throw out the budget and start again.\" But anyway, this NDP government tabled a budget that isn't just a fiscal failure I do have some suggestions on what we could do further on in this, to answer the previous\n               one, but you'll have to wait. In the meantime, maybe a quick example would be just\n               throw out the budget and start again. But anyway, this NDP government tabled a budget that isn't just a fiscal failure;\n               it's a declaration of war on the people of Surrey-Panorama. While my constituents\n               hide from extortion threats, while our police force is stretched to a breaking point,\n               while seniors watch their life savings get eaten away by government greed, this government\n               handed us a document of broken promises, reckless debt and deliberate neglect. Let's cut through the spin. Every line in this budget is a reminder that this government\n               has no guardrails, no plan and no respect for the people who elected them. A former\n               NDP Finance Minister, someone who knows this government's inner workings, put it best:\n               \"There were no guardrails. This is a pickle of their own making.\" And in Surrey, we're\n               the ones stuck in that pickle. The government talks about GDP growth, but they don't seem to understand or want to\n               put in GDP per capita. GDP goes up if we let in somebody with $100 in their pocket,\n               but it also drags down the GDP per capita and burdens all of our overstretched services. Let's start with the numbers this government buried in the back of their budget. A\n               $13.3 billion deficit this year, more than twice the deficit during the height of\n               COVID. Provincial debt set to climb from $154 billion to $235 billion in just three\n               years, nearly doubling as a share of our economy since this NDP leadership took over. Fifteen thousand public sector jobs cut over three years, with zero details on who\n               will lose their jobs or how critical services will survive. This isn't austerity;\n               it's incompetence. The former NDP Finance Minister said that under her, she fought\n               for balanced budgets, for guardrails, for caution. We all know what happened to her. This government threw those guardrails out the window. They spent like there was no\n               tomorrow, and now tomorrow is here, and we're all paying for it. You know, there's\n               a phrase, \"spending like a drunken sailor.\" When the head sailor starts saying, \"Maybe\n               we should look at what we're spending,\" we're all in trouble, especially if they keep\n               running up that debt. Let's talk taxes. This government claims B.C. is the lowest-taxed province for low-\n               and middle-income families. However, they're raising the universal income tax for\n               the first time since 2008. They are freezing tax brackets, which means every time\n               your salary goes up, you pay more in taxes. Starting October 1, they're adding PST to basic land-line service, cable TV and even yarn for seniors who knit to stay connected. All of this means we are definitely\n               not the lowest-taxed province. Let's not forget the job numbers they're touting — 36,000 jobs created in 2025. But\n               how many of those are private sector? How many are just temporary public sector positions\n               to pad their stats? They won't say because they know the truth. Their spending spree\n               hasn't built a sustainable economy. It has built a house of cards, and it's about\n               to collapse. I looked at a report from Stats Canada. Whether it's the truth about what they're hiding.... Last year British Columbia's private sector appears to have bled\n               8,000 jobs. The lifeblood of our economy is shrinking. Every single one of those new\n               jobs, and thousands more, were on the government payroll. I actually went further into that. It looks like, since this leadership of government\n               took over, the unemployment rate went from 4.2 percent to 6.6 percent. Youth unemployment,\n               far worse. Men 15 to 24, unemployment increased from 8.9 to 12.7. If you think that's\n               bad, women 15 to 24, unemployment increased from 6.3 to 14.9 percent. It says self-employed individuals saw a decrease of 6.6 percent of their jobs. That's\n               31,000 jobs. The lifeblood of our economy is shrinking. Every single one of those new jobs and\n               thousands more were on the government's payroll. They're borrowing billions to hire\n               bureaucrats, public sector workers, while the real job creators — the small businesses,\n               the tech firms, the builders — are laying people off. This isn't a jobs plan. It's\n               a bailout of their own failing reputation using the public credit card. They haven't\n               built an economy; they've built a government payroll. When the borrowing stops, the\n               NDP layoffs will begin. If there's one group that the budget targets with special cruelty, it's our seniors,\n               as I said earlier, with increases to cable, land-line telephones and even yarn. For\n               decades, seniors could defer their property taxes to stay in their homes — their largest\n               investment, their legacy for their kids and grandkids — but this government just changed\n               the rules. Starting in 2026, interest on deferred property taxes will jump from prime minus 2\n               to prime plus 2 and now compounded monthly. That's a 4 percent hike in interest rates.\n               Just a few years ago it was 1.7 percent. That today would be 5.7 percent, but with\n               the current prime rate, it's now 6.45 percent that they pay, again compounded monthly.\n               A retired investment adviser said: \"This isn't a deferral. It's a loan shark's deal.\"\n               I kind of wish I came up with that one myself, but.... Seniors will lose their equity faster than they can blink, and what do they get in\n               return? The government paused work on at least seven new long-term-care homes. The\n               B.C. seniors advocate says we're already 2,000 beds short. By 2036, that gap will\n               be 16,000. This government is making it more difficult for seniors to stay in their\n               homes while also driving them to no other option. The former NDP Finance Minister also said the perception was that the NDP couldn't\n               manage a popsicle stand. This government has brought that perception back with a vengeance.\n               For our seniors, it's worse than that. It's a direct attack on their dignity, their\n               savings and their right to age with respect. Let's talk about health care. So 1.4 million British Columbians don't have a family\n               doctor, and this government claims 4,200 people a week are getting new doctors. Sounds\n               great, but they don't mention how many are losing their doctors to retirement and\n               burnout. It's a shell game, and patients are the losers. Doing some quick math, if\n               it's correct, that's 61⁄2 years to get those people a doctor, although I highly suspect\n               that the retiring doctors and those leaving for more favourable work will take away\n               from that 4,200. What I find most intriguing about this government is that they can cut, cut and keep\n               cutting. Then they stand up in this very room and say that they are working, continuing\n               to work on health care. \"Not like those guys on the other side,\" as we just heard,\n               \"who are going to cut funding.\" They did this in the last election, knocking on doors\n               telling people that we're going to cut funding despite the budget platform showing\n               a huge increase in spending. As for addiction care, even worse. Last year this government managed to open just\n               28 functioning addiction treatment beds. They claim 123 more are coming, but they've\n               no plan, no timeline, no accountability. Our communities are drowning in addiction.\n               This is part of the reason people don't feel safe. They go out of their homes and\n               they find people on the streets, living homeless, becoming drug addicts. It's time that we need to start fixing things, and this government is handing out\n               band-aids. We just saw that there's extra funding for nasal naloxone, which is great,\n               but we have no more funding for treatment and addiction. I think it's far cheaper\n               to keep And autism funding? They're cutting that. While kids with autism need more support,\n               this government is taking it away. This is cruelty. Let's not forget the $10-a-day daycare promise that they made ten years ago. It's\n               still not here. Instead, they're now touting an affordable child care benefit that\n               doesn't come close to covering the cost of care for families. What about housing? This government says they're reversing damage to the overheated\n               market. But they're using a bulldozer, not a repair kit. They're driving up costs\n               for renters and homeowners alike while failing to build enough affordable homes to\n               make a difference. I can't stand to hear people say that the NDP care about people. This is a budget\n               completely devoid of empathy. They take away from people that produce and people who\n               genuinely need support and then enable those who make harmful choices in the belief\n               that those people have no choice. Let's get to the crisis that keeps my constituents up at night. Public safety in Surrey.\n               I remember back when the police transition was being proposed. It was supposed to\n               be two years. I remember looking at the situation without the benefit of inside documents\n               and overall figures, but I'd said: \"What they're proposing looks like a 14-year transition\n               plan.\" Although, I don't think it was a plan. Well, it looks like I was closer than\n               this government and the Solicitor General at the time. When Surrey voted for a new mayor and council, largely based on keeping the RCMP,\n               what did this government do? They changed the laws and then forced the change on the\n               people of Surrey and the municipal government. There was no plan, no forethought —\n               just an ideological urgency from this government. Now the people of Surrey suffer under an extortion crisis that this government is\n               doing nothing about. Last week, the Surrey police service chief released a statement\n               that should shock every British Columbian. This government is forcing the SPS to take\n               over policing in Cloverdale on April 1, four months earlier than planned, even though\n               the force says they don't have the officers to do it. The SPS says they need 70 officers\n               to police Cloverdale. But right now, 40 of their officers are redeployed to fight\n               the extortion crisis that this government has ignored for years.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317211","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I would start by saying that I do have some suggestions on what we could do further\n               on in this, to answer the previous one, but he'll have to wait. In the meantime, maybe\n               a quick example would be: \"Just throw out the budget and start again.\" But anyway, this NDP government tabled a budget that isn't just a fiscal failure I do have some suggestions on what we could do ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9f90563996962e2214b7c6d6b21e32972dd5a7d8a3dbac7b245b79882cdbb43a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67745101732fa6b0d64a5e5f6c648b307e96a5caeba44b65fc7e950ff191d8b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b15a1831c153864c6aa8e64e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317212,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"So 2,602, 14 years ago and now, is still 2,602. There's no inflation there. There's\n               no more officers. So I'm not sure what they're answering there, but it's certainly\n               not the question there. Also, the Surrey police chief requested a four-month transition delay into Cloverdale\n               while Surrey battles the extortion crisis, citing lack of capacity and resources.\n               This crisis has required the redeployment of over 40 Surrey police officers to specialized\n               investigative units. The chief said: \"The redeployment has significantly impacted\n               our staffing capacity.\" This reasonable request to delay the transition was denied by this government. Knowing lives could be at risk, why did the minister deny the request to pause the\n               expansion of the Surrey police service into Cloverdale?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317212","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"So 2,602, 14 years ago and now, is still 2,602. There's no inflation there. There's\n               no more officers. So I'm not sure what they're answering there, but it's certainly\n               not the question there. Also, the Surrey police chief requested a four-month transition delay into Cloverdale\n               while Surrey battles the extortion crisis, citing lack of capacity and resourc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8845b4df303183d5dfa012c9841101f81e9b217ad8877d446b5d116de6bd32fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82d2ce37957071bc25dbb0b09a83e03106169c7d67304688bbc1d877b501d91d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63663ef1fe1b1a4fe6f2fd33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328055,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I have two introductions. One, Gurmot.... Gurjot Cheema, who is one of my good\n               friends, and I can't say his name correctly. He's my riding president. He volunteers\n               everywhere throughout the Lower Mainland, well known to everybody. If we could give him a welcome. Then we have, who I'll say is our celebrity chef Bob Basi, known as the Bakra Chef.\n               He's a British Columbia native, and he's transformed his passion for cooking into\n               the celebrated brand, Bakra Chef, inspired by his mother's traditional goat curry\n               recipe. What started as a family favourite has become a signature dish at events nationwide,\n               uniting diverse communities through flavourful, authentic cuisine. With his distinctive logo and iconic championship belt, which, if somebody wants to\n               get photos with him afterwards, will be available.... It has actually inspired somebody\n               to get me my own as well, so if anybody wants photos, we're ready. Bakra Chef has\n               grown a strong social media following, especially on Instagram, connecting food lovers\n               across Canada and beyond. Please welcome him.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328055","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I have two introductions. One, Gurmot.... Gurjot Cheema, who is one of my good\n               friends, and I can't say his name correctly. He's my riding president. He volunteers\n               everywhere throughout the Lower Mainland, well known to everybody. If we could give him a welcome. Then we have, who I'll say is our celebrity chef Bob Basi, known as the Bakra Chef.\n               He","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","label":"Food processing","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad26b11fdef11a8d627cbc03bf743aaa207b5be49315600414e36999c8201499"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e271be67307112bbed30debb8ac104fa3231f110ab29cc27bdd19ef3500a365e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce6e9a63638cde9d1c1dfac8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328056,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise on behalf of the official opposition to address Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture\n               Amendment Act, 2026. Let me be clear from the outset. British Columbians deserve a government that relentlessly\n               pursues criminals, money launderers and organized crime so that crime does not pay. The civil forfeiture office has, since 2006, forfeited more than Let me be clear from the outset. British Columbians deserve a government that relentlessly\n               pursues criminals, money launderers and organized crime so that crime does not pay. The civil forfeiture office has, since 2006, forfeited more than $221 million in ill-gotten\n               assets. That money has funded $93 million in community safety grants and $1.7 million\n               in victim compensation. Those are real dollars taken from drug traffickers, gangsters\n               and fraudsters and, in theory, put back to work for law-abiding families. We support\n               strengthening those tools. The Cullen commission laid out the scale of money laundering in our province and called\n               for a more proactive civil forfeiture office. The core objective of Bill 8, expanding the office's ability to investigate independently,\n               target high-value assets and streamline litigation is something British Columbians\n               and, certainly, British Columbia Conservatives can and do support. But support is\n               not blind endorsement. This bill also hands the NDP government even more power over seized assets while doing\n               nothing, absolutely nothing, to increase transparency over what happens to the money\n               afterward. And that is the heart of the matter, because under this government, the\n               most secretive administration British Columbia has ever seen, civil forfeiture risks\n               becoming just another slush fund mechanism, another pot of cash funnelled through\n               opaque grant programs, staffed by party insiders and spent with minimal public scrutiny. Let us first walk through what the bill actually does by comparing the current Civil\n               Forfeiture Act with the amendments before us. Section 5 now requires anyone filing a response to a forfeiture proceeding to set\n               out particulars of the nature of the interest, including the extent of the interest.\n               The current act simply says you file a response. The new requirement is a technical\n               hurdle. Innocent owners, a grandmother whose car was stolen and used in a crime, a\n               small business whose rented premises housed a grow op without their knowledge, will\n               now face immediate procedural traps. One missing detail, and their claim can be dismissed. I think I should say that I did reach out to some subject matter experts on this to\n               get their opinion on some of these things. I have included that in my comments. Clause 2, new section 7.1, introduces default forfeiture orders. If a party fails\n               to file and serve a proper response, the court can forfeit the property without a\n               hearing on the merits. The current act gives the court discretion, under section 7,\n               to refuse forfeiture if it is clearly not in the interest of justice. That safeguard\n               is now bypassed by default. The government's own explanatory note calls this \"streamlining litigation while preserving\n               fairness.\" Fairness for who? Certainly not for respondents who miss a deadline because\n               they are in hospital or out of province or simply unaware. Clauses 3 and 10, sections 36 and 73, extend key timelines from 30 days to 60 days.\n               Under the current law, after a notice of dispute, the director must decide within\n               30 days whether to commence court proceedings or withdraw. After notice of intent\n               on personal property held by a public body, the same 30-day clock applies. The bill\n               doubles that window. The director now has twice as long to sit on assets. Let them\n               depreciate or decide at leisure whether to proceed. Meanwhile, legitimate owners wait\n               longer for their day in court. Clause 5, section 39, tightens the rules for innocent owners who miss the dispute\n               window. The current act already requires them to prove that their failure was not\n               wilful or deliberate and that they acted as soon as reasonably possible. The amendment\n               revises the circumstances in which they may even commence proceedings. The government\n               calls it updating dispute rules. Innocent British Columbians will call it moving the\n               goalposts. Clause 6, new section 45.1, does provide one genuine improvement. It allows examination\n               of the discovery of the director. Claimants can now question the very official seeking\n               to take their property. That is a fairness safeguard we welcome. Clause 7, section 59.1 adds a presumption that motor vehicles depreciate over time. When the government\n               eventually has to return value to a successful claimant, it can now argue that the\n               car is worth less. Again, the explanatory note frames this as: \"cutting costs and\n               preserving asset value.\" Preserving whose value? And we have clauses 8 and 9, section 67.01 and 67.1, expand information-sharing with other jurisdictions and entities, while removing\n               the six-month gag order on organizations that receive a director's request for personal\n               information. The director must now notify the affected individual within the specified\n               period. Broader powers to collect data across borders are reasonable in the fight\n               against transnational crime, but the permanent removal of the time-limited non-disclosure\n               rule tilts the balance further towards secrecy. Clause 11, section 95 adds regulation-making authority over notice and service of\n               certain orders. More rules written behind closed doors. Transnational provisions, which is clauses 12 to 18, ensure the new rules apply immediately\n               to ongoing files. The net effect of Bill 8 is clear. Easier defaults for the government, longer decision\n               windows for the director, higher procedural bars for claimants, broader information-gathering\n               powers, and one or two modest fairness concessions. These changes will almost certainly increase the volume and speed of forfeitures.\n               The government has given no estimate of additional revenue, but with the office now explicitly mandated to run proactive investigations, the inflow will rise. The 2023-24 grant report already shows $8.2 million distributed in a single year. More seizures\n               mean more money flowing into the civil forfeiture account. And here we reach the most critical issue, the one the government refuses to address.\n               Under the current Civil Forfeiture Act, part 8, all cash and sale proceeds go into the civil forfeiture account, a special account\n               inside the consolidated revenue fund. The director first pays the office's own operating\n               costs; it remains self-funding. Then comes compensation to eligible victims, capped\n               at net proceeds from the specified unlawful activity. Then grants for prevention of\n               unlawful activities and remediation of the effect of unlawful activities. Finally,\n               other prescribed purposes, but only with the approval of the Minister of Finance. That's a mouthful. In plain language, after the office pays itself and a few victims,\n               roughly half the money, according to the government's own report, is funneled into\n               the civil forfeiture grant program, which could be a great program and it has had great results, but that program is\n               run entirely by the government. Streams are chosen annually by the ministry. Applications\n               are scored internally. Awards go to community groups, Indigenous organizations, police\n               departments for equipment, restorative justice programs — all worthy on paper. But\n               the decision-making remains opaque. And in the grant selection process, there are a few questions to be asked. Who exactly\n               makes these decisions? Can we provide the organizational chart of the decision-making\n               body, the names of current members and their biographies? Are they public servants,\n               political appointees or independent experts? What is the detailed weighted assessment\n               rubric used to score applications? Committee members should be provided with a copy of the full application and scoring\n               manual. Are minutes kept of grant adjudication meetings? And if so, would the government\n               commit to publishing redacted versions to show the rationale for funding decisions? So there's a little heads-up on some of the questions that may be coming. Are minutes kept of grant adjudication meetings and, if so, would the government commit\n               to publishing redacted versions to show the rationale for funding decisions? There's\n               a little heads up on some of the questions that may be coming. The annual report gives totals and feel-good project summaries, not line-by-line accountability\n               showing exactly who received what, whether outcomes are measured or whether any recipients\n               have political connections to the NDP. This is not ring-fence trust money. It sits\n               inside the consolidated revenue fund. Any unspent balance, any other prescribed purpose,\n               can ultimately be directed by cabinet. Beyond the annual report's list of recipients, will the government provide for the\n               past five years a line-by-line data set showing the application, organization, the\n               amount requested, the amount granted, the stated purpose of the grant and the reported\n               outcomes or deliverables? What is the follow-up audit process? How many grants are\n               audited for compliance? What are the consequences for misused funds? Why is the compensation for victims of crime, a paramount and morally unambiguous\n               issue.... Use of these funds is only $1.7 million since 2006. A tiny fraction, less\n               than 1 percent of the total generated. Does this not suggest the primary function\n               of the fund has become community grants, not victim restitution? The Cullen commission itself recommended transitioning the office away from self-funding\n               precisely to remove the incentive to chase revenue. This ignores that recommendation.\n               Instead, this bill is expanding the office while keeping the same perverse incentive\n               structure. British Columbians have every right to ask, where is the rest of the money\n               going? Why no independent oversight board? Why no requirement for audited outcome\n               reports on every grant? Why no public database showing every dollar? Because this is the most secretive government British Columbia has ever seen. We have\n               watched the axing of the independent Office of the Merit Commissioner, the very body\n               tasked with ensuring public service jobs are awarded on merit, not connections. Just\n               last month, there was a move to dissolve it, despite a documented spike in flawed\n               hirings and complaints of favouritism. We have seen grant programs across housing,\n               climate and community safety repeatedly directed towards organizations with government\n               ties. We have seen freedom of information responses delayed or redacted. Now we are being asked to hand the same government even more untraceable cash from\n               civil forfeiture without a single new transparency safeguard. The pattern is unmistakable.\n               This government loves slush funds. They hate independent watchdogs. Bill 8 feeds that\n               machine. Let me be explicit. We are not opposed to community grants. We are not opposed to\n               victim compensation. We want victim compensation. I think everybody does. But we are\n               opposed to a government that treats seized criminal assets as general revenue and\n               can sprinkle around with minimal accountability. Criminals are not transparent. Government\n               should be. Yet this bill contains zero amendments to part 8, zero requirements for detailed public\n               reporting, zero independent audit provisions, zero fenced-in funds outside the consolidated\n               revenue fund. If the government truly believes these amendments improve fairness and\n               efficiency, then it should have no problem adding real accountability measures. Here are the minimum changes British Columbia deserves before this bill passes: amend\n               part 8 to create a truly independent civil forfeiture oversight board with representatives\n               from all parties, law enforcement, civil liberties groups and victims advocates to\n               approve all grants above a modest Require the director to publish, within 90 days of each fiscal year, a fully auditable\n               schedule of every grant recipient, amount, purpose and measured outcome. Move the civil forfeiture office to core government funding, as the Cullen commission\n               recommended, ending the self-funding model that incentivizes revenue-chasing. Prohibit the use of forfeiture funds for any purpose not directly tied to crime prevention,\n               remediation or victim support — no other prescribed-purposes loophole. Mandate that any regulations made under the new section 95 powers be tabled in the\n               Legislature and subject to affirmative resolution. Without these changes, Bill 8 is not modernizing civil forfeiture. It is supercharging\n               a secretive revenue tool for an already opaque government. Colleagues, organized crime does not respect due process, but neither does unchecked\n               government power. The fight against money laundering must never become an excuse to\n               erode the very rule of law we claim to defend. British Columbians expect us to take criminals' luxury cars, cash and mansions and\n               then expect us to account for every dollar afterwards with forensic precision. This\n               government wants the first part, as do we all. They resist the second part. That resistance\n               tells us everything about the priorities. We will support the principle of a stronger civil forfeiture office, but we will fight\n               at every stage of this bill for the transparency British Columbians have every right\n               to demand. I will say, while I wasn't a subject-matter expert, I did work with them in my time\n               with the police. This was always on the top of everybody's mind, where we still need\n               to protect the innocent. I call upon the minister to approach committee stage not as a defensive exercise but\n               as a collaborative one. Bring the data. Bring the policy rationales. Be prepared to\n               discuss amendments that strengthen safeguards. The shared goal of dismantling criminal\n               enterprises is too important to be undermined by a secretive process that is seen\n               as unfair, secretive or politically self-serving. Again, when working with the police, I was a very large proponent of this act. Everybody\n               that's involved in it has used it to great success. But if we allow this money to\n               disappear into the NDP's favourite black box labelled only \"Community grants\" and\n               administered by party insiders, then we have not defeated organized crime. We have\n               simply created a new state-sanctioned version of it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328056","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I rise on behalf of the official opposition to address Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture\n               Amendment Act, 2026. Let me be clear from the outset. British Columbians deserve a government that relentlessly\n               pursues criminals, money launderers and organized crime so that crime does not pay. The civil forfeiture office has, since 2006, forfeited more than Let me be clear fro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5d4772526a3c2fa82a0aab6a7982451cb0a571ed2dbda2683553259c56c9ac78"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d08c4437790f3ff5df204f6ad11a9846280cd4e2951e8def0fbb138882c65224"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b39773a734552bdc88b8b8e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361026,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act of 2026. The title of this bill contains a cruel irony. It contains the words \"freedom of information.\"\n               Yet as I stand here and review the clauses","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361026","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act of 2026. The title of this bill contains a cruel irony. It contains the words \"freedom of information.\"\n               Yet as I stand here and review the clauses","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architectural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","label":"Architectural heritage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3d21a0773740a4bbc6047be4af3ab3de7d4f25116e281dc5695584ff765bf5b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bce86d6d408810dc5bfe15b9884851424436f6ab49ca186898e0fc29dfab15b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-479e26d67bc4552558b2e7bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415830,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome Raman Bains, if he could stand up for us. Raman is a Punjabi-language Canadian singer born and raised in Surrey, B.C., a city\n               known for its grit but also the beauty that comes from it. Having been born into a\n               community where vulnerability isn't always easy to express, Raman leans into it. Raman\n               graduated with a degree in political science at Simon Fraser University and was accepted\n               into law school before he decided to pursue his career in music. Raman has collaborated with both the Vancouver Whitecaps and Vancouver Canucks, performing\n               at the iconic B.C. Place and Rogers Arena. His latest project and debut album, A Desi Love Story , is out, and Raman recently completed his U.K. tour and performed the album for the\n               first time locally at the SoMa Festival in Vancouver. Please welcome Raman Bains.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415830","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to welcome Raman Bains, if he could stand up for us. Raman is a Punjabi-language Canadian singer born and raised in Surrey, B.C., a city\n               known for its grit but also the beauty that comes from it. Having been born into a\n               community where vulnerability isn't always easy to express, Raman leans into it. Raman\n               graduated with a degree in politica","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Photography","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","label":"Postsecondary education","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725800","label":"Photography","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["14e67bf449d06a13cb8411c7e973abd0f905b024e2686e29d1274b4340ea72dc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f855410f797b63164c70690a4155d04e93bd4fd1521531fc4448e95b8006205d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Postsecondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036712","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2f04480d385e4bb9b7602d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415831,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome the Seehra family today. We have Sukhvir, Cindy, Logan and Ethan. I'd be remiss not to say I did work with his brother, internet\n               famous for chasing a motorcycle on an escalator.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415831","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like to welcome the Seehra family today. We have Sukhvir, Cindy, Logan and Ethan. I'd be remiss not to say I did work with his brother, internet\n               famous for chasing a motorcycle on an escalator.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["020b161a8c2f1cfbdf9e88f21274ee2c6bed967fc376c3837f2d997d1072c671"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2ec47eb0bb040c9192e20299","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415832,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Members of this House, I rise today on second reading of Bill 13, the Safe Access\n               to Places of Public Worship Act, 2026. I would like to comment on my friend's speech just now, and I do appreciate the strong\n               message that places of worship are places of community, where we should all come together\n               and would encourage everybody in this House to spend some time in places of worship. But let me be crystal clear from the outset. Every British Columbian — Jewish, Christian,\n               Muslim, Sikh, Hindu, any faith — deserves to attend their place of worship in safety,\n               free from intimidation, harassment, vandalism or disruption. The threats are not theoretical The threats are not theoretical. Since 2001, and especially in a shocking wave since\n               2021, churches across Canada, including many in British Columbia, have faced repeated\n               attacks. A murder right on the grounds of one of our gurdwaras. Vandalism, graffiti,\n               desecration and arson have scarred communities. Nationally, reports document over\n               a hundred churches vandalized, burned or destroyed since 2021, with at least 33 fully\n               burned to the ground between May 2021 and late 2023, the vast majority ruled arson. In British Columbia, churches were among the early targets. These incidents continued\n               alongside broader rises in hate crimes. The alarming surge in antisemitism since October 7, 2023, has compounded danger, with\n               synagogues facing fire bombings, shootings and vandalism. In 2024 alone, police reported\n               hate crimes targeting religion in Canada stood at 1,342 incidents nationally, with\n               Jewish communities accounting for 70 percent of them despite representing just 1 percent\n               of the population. In British Columbia, hate crimes rose 23 percent between 2022 and 2023, with religion-motivated\n               incidents surging more than 50 percent. Jewish Canadians are 25 times more likely\n               to be targeted than any other group. These numbers are not abstract. They represent real fear in our synagogues, mosques,\n               churches, gurdwaras and temples. But this bill is not that action. This is lipstick\n               on a pig. It is pure NDP symbolism, placating the faith community with its shiny new\n               provincial statute while doing absolutely nothing to address the root causes of the\n               safety crisis facing our places of worship. It creates 20-metre access zones around churches, synagogues, mosques, gurdwaras and\n               temples. It prohibits impeding access, disrupting activities, interference — which\n               is defined so broadly that it actually includes advising or persuading someone not\n               to participate — and anything that could reasonably be expected to cause concern for\n               a person's physical or mental safety. It allows warrantless arrests for those provincially regulated infractions and lets\n               the Attorney General or anyone seek injunctions. And it sunsets in 2030. Every single one of these enforcement clauses already exists in the Criminal Code\n               of Canada. Police and courts have had these tools for decades. This bill does not\n               add one new officer, one new dollar of spending, one new dollar for policing or one\n               new tool that wasn't already available. It is fake legislation designated to let the\n               NDP say they did something while their broader failure on public safety continues\n               to spiral out of control. Let's go clause by clause, because the devil is in the details. These details here\n               reveal a bill that is useless as it is redundant. Clause 1 sets out the definitions.\n               It defines an access zone interference as advising or persuading or attempting to\n               advise or persuade by any means, including graphic, verbal or written means, a person\n               to refrain from participating in an activity at a place of public worship. It defines place of public worship expansively to include any property exempt from\n               taxation under the Community Charter, Vancouver Charter or the Taxation (Rural Area)\n               Act plus anything cabinet prescribes by regulation. \"Occupiers,\" anyone with responsibility or control. Of course, \"a police officer\" includes provincial, municipal or designated constables. These definitions are deliberately broad and vague. Interference could capture a peaceful conversation. But these definitions are deliberately broad and vague. \"Interference\" could capture\n               a peaceful conversation, a pamphlet or even a sign. This is not targeted protection.\n               It is a dragnet that chills legitimate expression. And yet the Criminal Code already covers every harmful intent here without the need\n               for new provincial jargon. Section 423 criminalizes intimidation. Section 176 specifically\n               protects religious worship from wilful disturbance or interruption. These are real\n               criminal offences with real teeth, not provincial regulatory language designed to\n               create the illusion of action. Clause 2 in this bill is the heart of the prohibitions. Subsection (1) says a person\n               must not, in an access zone, impede access to or egress from the place of worship,\n               disrupt activities, engage in interference or intimidate or attempt to intimidate\n               or do or say anything that could reasonably cause concern for a person's physical\n               or mental safety. Subsection (2) bans wilfully participating in a gathering where\n               others are doing any of that. This is the NDP's big new protection. But again, every single prohibition is already a Criminal Code offence. Impeding access\n               or egress — that's covered by section 423, \"Intimidation,\" and section 430, \"Mischief.\" Disrupting activities at a place of worship. Section 176(2) makes it an offence punishable\n               by summary conviction to wilfully disturb or interrupt an assemblage met for religious\n               worship. Interference by advising or persuading. That falls under \"Criminal harassment\" in\n               section 264 or \"Intimidation,\" section 423. Intimidation or causing reasonable concern for safety. Section 264 is \"Criminal harassment.\"\n               And again, section 423, section 1 explicitly prohibits using threats, violence or other means to intimidate. And for the real threats — vandalism, graffiti, arson — section 430(4.1) provides\n               up to ten years for hate-motivated mischief against religious property. These are\n               indictable offences with real jail time. Indictable offences are the most serious offences in Canada. Police don't need a provincial\n               20-metre bubble zone to act. They already have the full force of federal law, federal\n               criminal law, under the Criminal Code of Canada. This clause doesn't strengthen safety. It duplicates it, creates confusion and wastes\n               legislative time on a problem the Criminal Code solved decades ago. I might add that under the Safe Access to Schools Act.... It has a further clause, which\n               at least attempts to do something, which says.... In those bubble zones, it prohibits\n               people from protesting. This doesn't even include that, although I would believe that if it was tested, it would be against the Charter. Clause 3 requires notice to establish an access zone. Signs must be posted so they\n               are clearly visible in daylight — it says — under normal weather conditions from the\n               approach to each ordinary point of entry. The signs must identify the place of worship,\n               describe the zone, list the prohibitions and include any other prescribed information.\n               No one but the owner or occupier can remove, alter or deface them. That was a lot just to say. It's a bureaucratic theatre. Real criminals who vandalize synagogues at night or harass worshippers don't read\n               the signs. Police responding to a disturbance don't need a laminated poster to know\n               that blocking a mosque door is already illegal under the Criminal Code. This clause adds red tape and paperwork for faith communities already stretched thin. Clause 4 defines exactly what is included in the access zone. For a stand-alone place\n               of worship, it's the entire parcel, plus 20 metres from the boundaries. For multi-use buildings, it gets even more complicated. It's\n               20 metres from entrances, exits or passageways. Unless cabinet, of course, prescribes\n               something different. Private residences and places the public doesn't ordinarily access are excluded. Again,\n               this is arbitrary geography, dressed up as protection. The Criminal Code doesn't need\n               a tape measure. Section 176 applies to the actual disturbance of worship, wherever\n               it occurs. Section 430 covers damage to the property itself. Section 423 prohibits\n               intimidation regardless of exact metres. The NDP is creating a provincial map of safe zones that overlaps with federal criminal\n               jurisdiction, all while the real threats — organized hate, online incitement, or midnight\n               vandalism and arson that have plagued churches for the last 25 years and intensified\n               dramatically since 2021 — operate far beyond any 20-metre bubble. This is fake legislation\n               at its finest. It looks tough on paper, but collapses under the weight of existing\n               law. Clause 5 allows a police officer to arrest without a warrant anyone they believe on\n               reasonable grounds is contravening section 2. This is the NDP's big enforcement win.\n               Yet section 495 of the Criminal Code already gives police broad warrantless arrest\n               powers for indictable offences like intimidation, criminal harassment and mischief.\n               For summary offences tied to religious worship under section 176, police have always\n               had the authority to act when they witness the disturbance. This clause doesn't expand police power. It just rebrands a provincial, ticketable offence as something that feels like criminal law. In practice,\n               it lowers the threshold while pretending to raise it. Real safety comes from officers\n               who can respond quickly to the kinds of arsons and vandalism that have destroyed dozens\n               of churches, not from duplicative arrest language that sits on the books unused because\n               police are already overwhelmed. Clause 6 allows the Supreme Court to grant injunctions, even without notice, restraining\n               anyone from contravening section 2, with interim injunctions possible. It applies\n               whether or not a penalty exists. Courts have been granted injunctions for harassment,\n               trespass and intimidation for generations under inherent jurisdiction and the Criminal\n               Code. This is not new. It is redundant paperwork for the Attorney General's office,\n               while faith communities wait for actual officers to show up at the scenes of burned\n               and vandalized places of worship. Clause 7 gives cabinet sweeping regulation-making power. They can prescribe classes\n               of property, designate policing units, add or remove exemptions for labour actions\n               or other activities, dictate exactly what signs must say and where they go, and change\n               the size of access zones for any place or class of places. This is the ultimate NDP\n               control clause, endless bureaucratic tweaks without coming back to this House. It\n               turns every place of worship into a regulatory experiment. Meanwhile, the Criminal\n               Code provides consistent, nationwide standards that don't change on a Lieutenant Governor\n               in Council whim. This clause exposes the bill for what it is, not bold protection, but a framework\n               for future ministerial fiddling while the real crisis of under-policing festers, and\n               churches continue to burn. Clauses 8 and 9 are straightforward. This entire bill is fake legislation. It is modelled after the 1994 Access to Abortion\n               Services Act bubble zones, which were narrowly tailored to a specific, highly charged\n               medical context. Those zones were upheld by courts because they protected patients\n               in a unique setting. But slapping the same model onto every place of worship, province-wide,\n               with broader prohibitions and no evidence that the Criminal Code tools are insufficient\n               is legislative laziness. Compare it to federal Bill C-9, introduced in October. It amends the Criminal Code\n               to ban hate symbols like swastikas with exemptions, adds aggravating factors for hate-motivated\n               offences, and creates a specific offence of intimidation at buildings for religious\n               worship. Importantly, it does not create fixed-distance bubble zones. It targets conduct,\n               not geography. The federal approach respects jurisdiction and focuses on real criminal\n               behaviour. Why is this NDP government duplicating and diluting federal criminal law\n               with provincial red tape? Because it's easier than fixing the real problem. There\n               are own failed policies that have left police hands tied and communities unprotected.\n               While faith leaders are begging for real protection, the NDP's response is signs and\n               20-metre zones. Meanwhile, across this province, crime is out of control in ways that directly threaten\n               everyone, including those trying to worship. The Auditor General's March 2026 report\n               laid it bare. The RCMP is short at least 3,400 front-line officers as of September\n               2025. Vacancy rates exceed the critical 7 percent threshold in nine of 11 provinces\n               and territories served by contract policing. Recruitment has failed for years. In\n               2025, they needed 2,700 new officers but hired only 892. That falls onto this province\n               for providing the members required to be trained. Officers are doing more with less\n               every single day, pulling from integrated teams, facing longer response times, and\n               watching repeat offenders cycle through the soft-on-crime bail system the NDP defended\n               for years. Clearance rates for property crime and hate-motivated mischief remain abysmal. Communities\n               are hiring private security — not because they want to, but because the NDP has left\n               them no choice. And what does this government do? Jewish communities in B.C. alone\n               are now spending over $100,000 every month on private security just to keep worshippers\n               safe. Back to: what does the government do? They slap 7 percent PST on those security services,\n               taxing the very measures communities are forced to take because public safety has\n               collapsed under their watch. This is not leadership. This is extortion by another\n               name. Small businesses, strata and faith groups, already spending thousands monthly\n               on guards, now face another 7 percent hit. The NDP creates the crisis, focuses private\n               solutions, then taxes the solution. This bill does nothing to stop that hypocrisy. The official opposition believes strongly in the right to peaceful assembly under\n               section 2(c) of the Charter. We also believe in freedom of expression. Bubble zones\n               can chill legitimate protests as we've seen with school access zones. But even setting\n               Charter concerns aside, this bill fails on its own terms. It does not deter the real\n               threats, vandalism at night, online harassment or organized hate, because those happen\n               outside the 20-metre zone, or when no one is there to post signs. It creates a false sense of security while the NDP continues to under-resource the\n               very police who are The faith community deserves better than this performative nonsense. They deserve\n               a government that treats public safety as a core responsibility, not a photo op. They\n               deserve more RCMP officers, more municipal officers, faster bail reform that actually\n               keeps repeat offenders locked up, higher clearance rates and an end to taxing the\n               private security they're forced to buy because this province's policing model is crumbling. The NDP can pat themselves on the back for introducing Bill 13 in unison with Bill\n               12. They can claim they're expanding protections, but British Columbians see through\n               it. This is not protection; it's abdication. It is the government admitting they cannot\n               enforce the Criminal Code effectively. It creates a parallel provincial regime that\n               duplicates existing powers while doing nothing to fix the resource crisis. We in the official opposition will always stand with faith communities against hate.\n               We support real tools for police. We support cracking down on antisemitism and every\n               form of religious hatred. But we will not pretend that this bill does any of those\n               things. Pure NDP theatre while the real crisis of crime, underpolicing and self-funded\n               security continues. I urge every member to reject this symbolic gesture. Demand real resources for police,\n               demand enforcement of the criminal code we already have and demand an end to the hypocrisy\n               of taxing the very safety measures this government's failures have forced upon our\n               most vulnerable communities. British Columbians of every faith deserve to worship without fear. They deserve a\n               government that delivers safety, not slogans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415832","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Hon. Members of this House, I rise today on second reading of Bill 13, the Safe Access\n               to Places of Public Worship Act, 2026. I would like to comment on my friend's speech just now, and I do appreciate the strong\n               message that places of worship are places of community, where we should all come together\n               and would encourage everybody in this House to spend","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cecacb52bf9db40d113de339125a6e942750aabbbf5ca142550e9e819aa2110e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["67630502190a97bf1348efbc29a7287fbdd145bfda97dc964690572b5d87eba9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-389d904a8d85fc7eee94d40b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415833,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise in this House today to address Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act,\n               2026. For far too long, single-room occupancies and supportive housing across British Columbia\n               have been plagued by chaos that ruins the very benefits these places are supposed\n               to provide for our vulnerable people trying to rebuild their lives — disruptive tenants,\n               unchecked drug use, weapons, fire started by butane torches or discarded cigarettes.\n               Threats and violence have turned what should be safe havens into danger zones for\n               the majority of residents, who simply want stability and a chance at recovery. Neighbours in surrounding communities have grown weary of the constant spillover effects.\n               Increased crime, needles scattered in parks and playgrounds, property damage and endless\n               emergency calls that drain already overstretched police, fire and paramedic resources\n               night after night. Municipalities have pushed back hard for years, often pausing, delaying or outright\n               cancelling proposed projects because they see the very real and ongoing costs to public\n               safety, community livability and local budgets. This bill is the government's latest response. On the surface, it talks tough about\n               safety and cracking down on problem behaviour in supportive housing, but when you\n               scratch beneath the surface and examine the details clause by clause, it does very\n               little to actually solve the deep, systemic problems we face every day in these facilities. It carves out a special legal framework for supportive housing inside the Residential\n               Tenancy Act, hands massive new regulation-making powers to cabinet, broadens some\n               eviction grounds and makes a few limited tweaks to tenant conduct rules. That is essentially it. No bold new investments. No comprehensive fixes. There are\n               no new mandatory staffing ratios, no guaranteed treatment beds or addiction services,\n               no requirement for meaningful on-site clinical supports and no clear protocols on\n               who actually responds when a tenant is armed and dangerous inside the building. It completely ignores the unsafe housing conditions that continue to breed these problems\n               in the first place: dilapidated buildings with faulty wiring; absent or inadequate\n               maintenance; poor ventilation systems; broken or missing sprinklers; and a total failure\n               to bring police, fire departments and paramedics into the planning and design process\n               for these facilities. This is not serious, meaningful reform that will make a lasting difference. It is\n               little more than a bureaucratic bandage This is not serious, meaningful reform that will make a lasting difference. It is\n               little more than a bureaucratic bandage designed to make the placement of vulnerable\n               populations, including elderly individuals with complex medical needs, mobility challenges,\n               dementia, or those who might otherwise end up in drug recovery-style environments,\n               more palatable to wary municipalities that have grown tired of the repeated fallout\n               and community complaints. The NDP is clearly trying to pull the wool over the municipalities' eyes with this\n               legislation, hoping no one notices the lack of real substance. By giving supportive\n               housing operators easier ways to evict disruptive tenants, seize certain personal\n               property or temporarily lock them out, the government hopes local councils will lower\n               their guard, stop resisting new projects so vigorously and quietly accept more supportive\n               housing developments in their neighbourhoods without demanding the hard, expensive\n               solutions that are actually needed. But palatable does not equal safe, effective or sustainable in the long run. It does\n               not fix the underlying crisis of open drug use, repeated fires, violence, overdoses\n               or the enormous strain these issues place on emergency services and neighbourhood\n               residents. It simply shifts the problem from one location to another while the government\n               pretends it has taken decisive, responsible action. To truly understand the shortcomings of Bill 11, we must compare it directly to the\n               current Residential Tenancy Act, which has long provided a balanced protection for\n               tenants while allowing evictions for serious misconduct. Under the existing RTA, section\n               47 already outlines grounds for ending tenancy, including serious damage, disturbing\n               others or illegal activity. But these require evidence, hearings and due process through\n               the residential tenancy branch. Bill 11 amends this in section 15 by expanding those grounds to include conduct by\n               \"authorized persons\" — a new, broad term — and guests, but it doesn't fundamentally\n               change the process. Evictions still go through the RTB, which can take weeks. Critically, the bill's much-touted weapons provision in new section 4.8 simply allows\n               a director to grant an order of possession if a weapon is in plain view or possessed\n               by a tenant or permitted person. But this is just another eviction tool, not an immediate removal or safety protocol.\n               Compared to current law, where weapons could already trigger eviction under dangerous\n               conduct or illegal activities clauses, this adds little beyond expedited paperwork.\n               There is no on-site authority for operators to act without residential tenancy board\n               involvement, no police integration, no protections for bystanders, and there are likely\n               elderly residents during the process. Now let us walk through the bill clause by clause so the record is crystal clear on\n               exactly what this legislation does and, more importantly, what it glaringly fails\n               to do. Clause 1 is purely structural. It repeals and replaces headings to reorganize part\n               1 of the act as interpretation. This is administrative housekeeping with zero impact\n               on safety, tenant protections or the daily realities in supportive housing. It changes\n               nothing for elderly tenants facing fire hazards or violence. Clause 2 adds a definition of authorized persons, which includes landlords, other\n               tenants, permitted individuals Clause 2 adds a definition of authorized persons, which includes landlords, other\n               tenants, permitted individuals and anyone lawfully on the property. It also amends\n               the definition of landlord by removing reference to service agreements — minor on\n               its own, but this sets the stage for later expansions that blur lines of responsibility,\n               potentially holding vulnerable tenants accountable for the actions of casual visitors,\n               far beyond the current Residential Tenancy Act's focus on the tenant themselves. Under\n               existing law, occupant conduct is already somewhat covered, but this broadens it without\n               safeguards. Clause 3 adds definitions for \"housing stability support,\" \"supportive housing,\" \"supportive\n               housing operator,\" \"supportive housing rental unit\" and \"transitional housing.\" This\n               establishes the terminology necessary for a separate supportive housing framework. However, assessment criteria for who qualifies may be prescribed by regulation or\n               even set by the operator if none are prescribed, giving enormous discretion while\n               leaving elderly tenants or those with cognitive challenge at risk of misclassification\n               or rushed processes, with no statutory safeguards. The current RTA has no such silos.\n               It treats all tenancies uniformly, providing consistent protections that this bill\n               starts to erode without replacement. Clause 4 creates a new heading called \"Part 1.1, Scope of Act, Division 1, Application of Act.\" Clause 5 removes reference to \"or a service agreement\" from section 3. Clause 6 simply removes an exemption for certain housing-based health facilities that\n               provide hospitality support services and personal care. These are mostly headings\n               and clean-up, funneling more units into the framework without adding real protections\n               or addressing unsafe conditions like faulty wiring that plague current facilities. Clause 7 gets to the heart of the bill, the new division 2 on special provisions for supportive housing. Section 4.1 confirms this division applies specifically to supportive housing rental\n               units and clarifies that it does not affect existing exemptions. Section 4.2 defines what qualifies as a supportive housing rental unit, requiring\n               operation by a supportive housing operator, tenant assessment as homeless or at risk,\n               and support available. But again, criteria are flexible via regulation or operator\n               discretion. This gives operators and cabinet significant leeway, contrasting with\n               current RTAs rigid tenant rights. Section 4.3 allows cabinet to permit landlords to amend existing agreements, to remove\n               or change standard terms, create exceptions to mutual agreement requirements and impose\n               conditions. This is a substantial expansion of executive authority over tenancy agreements\n               in supportive housing, undermining current RTA section 23's mutual consent rule for\n               amendments. Section 4.4 on personal property allows cabinet to create exceptions to protections\n               preventing landlords from seizing or interfering with tenant property. This reduces standard tenant protections under the current section 32, potentially\n               for items like butane torches that cause fires. But it says nothing about mandating\n               landlords fix the building where those items become deadly hazards. Section 4.5 restricts landlord entry to prescribed purposes Section 4.5 restricts landlord entry to prescribed purposes, tenancy agreement terms\n               or reasonable purposes with notice. Cabinet regulates conditions. Under current law,\n               entry is already regulated in section 29 with notice. This just adds flexibility without\n               enhancing safety. Section 4.6 will allow cabinet to permit landlords to restrict tenant access in, again,\n               prescribed circumstances, possibly with director approval or interim orders without\n               notice. This grants huge power over tenant movement, far beyond current Residential\n               Tenancy Act provisions, and risks elderly tenants being locked out from vital medications\n               or care. Section 4.7 lets cabinet create exceptions to cleanliness requirements on vacating. Section 4.8, order of possession on weapons, creates a specific ground for ending\n               tenancy if a tenant or permitted person possesses a weapon on the property or it is\n               in plain view. The director may grant an order. Cabinet defines \"weapon,\" and considerations.\n               This is the bill's big tough on safety headline. But compared to current law, it's\n               just a streamlined eviction path under section 47, still requiring RTB process. No\n               immediate police response, no operator training mandates and zero protection for elderly\n               or recovering residents caught in crossfire. It evicts people found with weapons but does nothing further. No de-escalation protocol,\n               no mandatory supports to prevent reoffending, no safeguards for our seniors. So if\n               we look at it, the one big thing in here is not providing safeguards for our seniors\n               or the vulnerable. Section 4.9 allows cabinet to prescribe minimum compensation for non-compliance. So\n               clauses 8 through 9 are organizational, adding headings and repealing minor ones. Clause 10 amends section 12 with minor wording, which is \"every tenancy agreement\"\n               to \"a tenancy agreement,\" potentially narrowing scope slightly from current law. Clause 11 makes section 23 obligations subject to regulations, increasing flexibility\n               beyond current fixed rules. Clause 12 amends sections 32 and 33 to include occupants in responsibility provisions,\n               expanding beyond the current tenant-focused accountability. Clause 13 makes section 35's obligations regulatable. Clause 14 repeals the occupant definition in section 45(1) to align with authorized\n               person. Clause 15 amending section 47 as grounds for ending tenancy by expanding conduct grounds,\n               replacing references with authorized persons and broadening illegal activity to include\n               permitted persons. This significantly expands eviction grounds from current law, but\n               still funnels through the residential tenancy board hearings. Clause 16 does the same for section 56. Clause 17 amends section 89 to include weapons and prescribed service methods, again,\n               bringing in really the most important point of this bill. Clause 18 massively expands regulation making under section 97, covering definitions,\n               inspections, weapons, compensation and differentiated rules by class. This dwarfs\n               current regulation powers, letting cabinet rule by decree without legislative scrutiny. Clause 19 repeals unproclaimed 2006 provisions. Clause 20 staggers commencement by regulation. So this clause by clause reveals a bill obsessed with operator tools but blind to\n               systemic failures. Bill 11 talks tough on safety but ignores unsafe housing conditions\n               that fuel the problems day to day. It targets tenants Bill 11 talks tough on safety but ignores unsafe housing conditions that fuel the\n               problems day to day. It targets tenants with broader eviction powers, especially the\n               narrow weapons clause while completely ignoring drugs, fire risk and lack of supports.\n               The weapons provisions in 4.8 simply allows evictions of people found with weapons\n               and nothing further. No mandatory police involvement, no risk assessments, no protections\n               for elderly residents nearby who could be endangered during removal. Our seniors in recovery deserve better than eviction only. They need prevention through\n               staffing and treatment. The government left police, fire and paramedics entirely out\n               of the room. No integrated protocols. Housing workers are put at risk without clear\n               rules or protection.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415833","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise in this House today to address Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act,\n               2026. For far too long, single-room occupancies and supportive housing across British Columbia\n               have been plagued by chaos that ruins the very benefits these places are supposed\n               to provide for our vulnerable people trying to rebuild their lives — disruptive tenants,\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["25037f54bec69010fa583bc4db614c2acfe0c7a95fbd85a8eabb9b8b6dbe02ad"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f9d671ae39d0176b6af7090a546389197849ad6825fce93fd8e562b4820cd07d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47053dc2e20502f832211f8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415834,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I was partway through my speech and was put off till today. I'd just finished actually\n               through clause 20, so moving on from that. I would actually, before I get started....\n               I had time to reminisce about what debate has gone on before myself. Note that I'm\n               very glad to see that there has been a lot of agreement from the third party, with\n               my comments that I had made after the fact, and even from some of the government speakers\n               that had agreed with a lot of my points. I will start again at Bill 11. It talks tough on safety, but it ignores unsafe housing\n               conditions that fuel the problems day after day. It targets tenants with broader eviction\n               powers, especially its narrow weapons clause, while completely ignoring drugs, fire\n               risk and lack of supports. The weapons provisions in section 4.8 simply allow eviction of people found with weapons\n               and nothing further. No mandatory police involvement, no risk assessments and no protections\n               for elderly residents nearby who could be in danger during removal. Our seniors in recovery deserve better than eviction only. They need prevention through\n               staffing and treatment. The government left police, fire and paramedics entirely out\n               of the room. No integrated protocols. Housing workers are put at risk without clear\n               rules or protection. Locking people out inflames conflict, especially for those in crisis. Who responds\n               when a tenant is armed? It's not clarified. Eviction takes time, unlike current 911\n               urgency. Bill 11 expands eviction but ignores smoke, fires and unsafe buildings Bill 11 expands eviction but ignores smoke, fires and unsafe buildings. Supportive\n               housing needs staffing, safety and treatment, not punishment. This is about looking\n               tough, not real work. Consider real stories. In Vancouver's Downtown Eastside, fires from butane torches have killed residents in SROs with faulty sprinklers. Current RTA doesn't fix buildings. Bill 11 seizes torches, but ignores wiring. Elderly tenants\n               with dementia wander into danger. Lockouts exacerbate this. Municipalities like Surrey and Burnaby report endless calls, needles, overdoses — yet no mandatory supports here. Compared to current law, Bill 11 weakens tenant property rights in section 32, without reciprocal landlord duties for safe housing. Eviction expansions under section 47 sound strong, but RTB backlogs mean delays. Actually, since I'm restarting, I will say residential tenancy branch backlogs — RTB — mean delays, displacing problems. Weapons clause: current danger grounds actually do cover it. This just rebrands without urgency. No protection for recovery folks. Eviction sends them back to the streets, worsening\n               cycles. If serious about safety, mandate 24-7 staffing ratios, fire retrofits, addiction services. There are none here. Fund treatment beds. Consult first responders.\n               We've had silence. The elderly deserve dignity, walkers, meds, safe spaces that we provide to our college\n               students, but government dodges costs, fools municipalities with eviction carrots.\n               Problems displaced, not solved. They say, \"Fix the system, enforce building codes, integrate services.\" This bill\n               fails. It's symbolic, not substantive. British Columbians demand more in 2026, but\n               this appears to be par for the course for this government: bills full of symbolic wording, but no real effect to those\n               words. This displaces risk rather than eliminating it at the source. I've found myself\n               saying that every day this week during speeches and debate. British Columbians expect far more than this kind of symbolic legislation from their\n               government in 2026. They expect homes that are genuinely safe and supportive for all\n               residents, not regulatory experiments that prioritize political optics over real outcomes\n               and try to fool municipalities into accepting more of the same failed approach that\n               has caused so many problems already. This bill fails that fundamental test. I have a little bit of time left, so I actually would like to say a couple of more\n               things. But on this bill, I've found that strengths are minimal and procedural. With clearer definitions, there's\n               some consistency in how supportive housing fits under the RTA, and it does have the targeted weapons language that operators have requested. But weaknesses dominate this entire thing. Everything of substance is delegated to\n               future regulation. We have no minimum staffing, no mandatory supports, no police integration\n               required at all. Tenant protections, looking through it, are diluted. We have property seizure, access restrictions, easier evictions with vague safeguards, left to cabinet though. This bill ignores root causes, underfunded treatment, crumbling buildings and absent\n               on-site clinical supports. It creates real risks of abuse or displacement of the very vulnerable\n               people it claims to help. This bill has had critics. Our tenant advocates, they're already warning it could\n               increase homelessness by making eviction easier This bill's had critics, which are tenant advocates. They're already warning it could\n               increase homelessness by making eviction easier which, I will note, the Third Party\n               mentioned. That exact scenario was their number one fear in this bill. But it has\n               become classic incrementalism. We respond to operator and municipal pressure with\n               regulatory tweaks and headline safety and measures while dodging the far harder and\n               more expensive work of funding actual supports, enforcement and treatment. No one wants to be seen as soft on weapons in supportive housing, but this bill solves\n               none of the underlying policy failures. To me it appears this is more political management\n               of municipal backlash than really genuine system reform. So I would thank you, Madam Speaker, and have my seat.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415834","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I was partway through my speech and was put off till today. I'd just finished actually\n               through clause 20, so moving on from that. I would actually, before I get started....\n               I had time to reminisce about what debate has gone on before myself. Note that I'm\n               very glad to see that there has been a lot of agreement from the third party, with\n               m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b3e12f2f5a70f37a87c60954ffc3ea5d29d10c1297011f6f851758e56b591f05"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9adea61c801f33e343caa28f5ab5d8eb57f7272fb0b972fb3ba55e5392c616a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-417ce107e57d04210b791c83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720608,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"The minister references the crime and severity index, but we've already heard the\n               numbers from Surrey exploding between murders and extortions. The rise in crime ripping into businesses across this province is nowhere more evident\n               than in Surrey. Surrey businesses have experienced a 72 percent increase in break\n               and enters since last year. Recently I attended an opening of a business, and the\n               first thing they did was hire private security. The government is bleeding businesses dry by expanding the PST and Recently I attended an opening of a business, and the first thing they did was hire\n               private security. The government is bleeding businesses dry by expanding the PST and\n               including private security. Why is the government expanding the tax to security services, businesses that have\n               been forced to hire because of this government's failures?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720608","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The minister references the crime and severity index, but we've already heard the\n               numbers from Surrey exploding between murders and extortions. The rise in crime ripping into businesses across this province is nowhere more evident\n               than in Surrey. Surrey businesses have experienced a 72 percent increase in break\n               and enters since last year. Recently I att","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6d19fb239996b17e6e3c6ed54fad2da276fbecf1226e3330a01935a9845becac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7789a60a8a4d0265b65c9625179b3b043b3f65da584381e4065530cd70b9d046"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-988dd89c3e11b490d2fd4a0e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721705,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm just checking my time there. I'm taking over. I'm just going to get started a\n               little bit before I left off almost a month ago now. The title of this bill contains a cruel irony. It contains the words \"freedom of information.\"\n               Yet as I stand here and review the clauses, the subclauses and the bureaucratic language\n               woven into this legislation, I see very little freedom, and I see very little information.\n               What I see is a wall, a wall being built brick by brick, clause by clause, designed\n               to separate the people of British Columbia from the truth about how their tax dollars\n               are spent and how decisions are made in this chamber. We're debating this bill in the context of a government that has already earned a\n               distinctive, if shameful, reputation. The NDP administration has been widely criticized\n               by journalists, by watchdogs and by the public as the most secretive government in\n               the history of this province. They have operated behind closed doors. They've centralized\n               control in the Premier's office to an unprecedented degree. And now, tired of the\n               inconvenience of transparency, tired of the nuisance of accountability, they've brought\n               forward Bill 9 to codify their secrecy into law. Now, before I dissect the draconian measures hidden in this legislation, I want to be\n               fair. I do acknowledge that there are elements here regarding connected services providers\n               and modernizing data sharing between public bodies to improve efficiency. Clause 20\n               and the related amendments regarding connected services are, on the surface, administrative\n               updates. We in the Conservative caucus support efficiency, we support a government that works\n               faster, but let us not be fooled. These few efficiency measures are the spoonful of\n               sugar designed to make the medicine go down. And this medicine is poison to a healthy\n               democracy. Let's look at the track record. This is the government that introduced the infamous\n               $10 application fee for FOI requests, a literal tax on transparency. At the time,\n               they told us it wouldn't impede access. They told us it was just administrative. Yet\n               we know that access has been stifled. We look at the wait times. From 2022 to 2023,\n               freedom-of-information applicants had to wait, on average, an additional 192 business\n               days to receive a response. That is nearly a year of delay on top of the standard\n               timelines. That is not a broken system. That is a system being broken on purpose.\n               Delay is the deadliest form of denial. Now we have Bill 9. This bill is the government is saying: \"We aren't blocking information\n               fast enough. We aren't ignoring enough requests. We need new tools to silence our\n               critics.\" I want to direct the House's attention to clause 13. This is, without a doubt, the\n               most dangerous section of the bill. Clause 13 amends section 43 of the act. It drastically\n               expands the grounds upon which the commissioner can authorize a public body, meaning\n               the government, to completely disregard a request for information. This new language allows the government to ignore a request if the behaviour of the\n               applicant is deemed abusive or malicious. It allows them to ignore a request if it\n               would unreasonably interfere with the operations of the government, particularly if\n               the request is excessively broad. These words sound reasonable at a dinner party. No one likes malice. No one likes\n               abuse. But in legislation, in the hands of a government desperate to hide its scandals,\n               these undefined terms are weapons. Now, these words sound reasonable at a dinner party. No one likes malice. No one likes\n               abuse. But in legislation, in the hands of a government desperate to hide its scandals,\n               these undefined terms are weapons. What is the definition of \"malicious\" in this act?\n               There isn't one. It is left to the interpretation of the government. Let me ask the Minister of Citizens' Services. Is it malicious for an investigative\n               journalist to ask why an emergency room was closed for the third weekend in a row?\n               Is it malicious for a member of the opposition to file an FOI regarding the ballooning\n               costs of a government infrastructure project? Is it malicious for a First Nation member\n               to ask for details regarding a deal signed by the government that affects their territory? Under this legislation, the government can claim that a request is malicious simply\n               because it embarrasses them. They can claim a request is abusive simply because the\n               applicant is persistent in demanding answers that the minister won't give. Let's look at the term \"unreasonably interfere with the operations of government.\"\n               Democracy is an interference. Accountability is an interference. When an FOI officer\n               has to look for documents that prove the Minister of Health failed to deliver on a\n               promise, that certainly interferes with the ministry's desire to have a quiet afternoon,\n               but that's the job. By expanding these categories, the NDP is creating a catch-all bucket to throw away\n               any requests they find difficult. If you ask for too many emails about a scandal,\n               they will call it excessively broad. If you file a follow-up request because they\n               redacted the first one, they will call it repetitious. If you ask why they failed,\n               they will call it malicious. This clause effectively allows the government to grade\n               its own homework and then burn the test paper if they don't like the score. To me, it gets worse. Clause 28 is a transition provision for these new grounds for\n               disregarding requests. It states that the amendments in clause 13 apply to requests\n               received before, on or after the date the section comes into force. Think about the\n               arrogance of that. There are FOI requests sitting in the queue right now, requests that have been waiting\n               for those extra 192 days I mentioned. This government has been sitting on them, delaying\n               them. And now with clause 28, they are giving themselves the power to look at those\n               existing backlogged requests and say: \"You know what? Under the new law we just passed,\n               this old request is now considered malicious.\" Deleted. Ignored. They're changing\n               the rules in the middle of the game to wipe the slate clean of inquiries they don't\n               want to answer. It is a betrayal of trust to every British Columbian currently waiting\n               for an answer. Let's move to clause 21. This section amends section 21 of the act regarding proactive\n               disclosure. Proactive disclosure is supposed to be the gold standard. It's information\n               given freely without someone having to fight for it. But the NDP looks at free information\n               and sees a missed revenue stream. Clause 21(b) repeals subsection 2 and substitutes:\n               \"The head of a public body may require a person who asks for a copy of a record under\n               subsection 1(a) to pay a fee to the public body.\" Currently, information accessible without an FOI is accessible without a fee. That\n               makes sense. It's public data. It belongs to the people. The NDP is introducing a\n               fee for proactive disclosures. They are putting a toll booth on the information highway.\n               Why? Why would you charge a citizen for a report that is already sitting on a shelf?\n               There is only one reason. It's a deterrent. They want to deter the public from looking. They are a nickel-and-diming democracy. They are taking the \"free\" out of freedom\n               of information. This is a government that taxes you when you earn, taxes you when\n               you spend and now taxes you when you ask what they did with the money. If we go back to clause 2, I have grave concerns regarding clause 2, which amends\n               section 5. Previously the opinion of the head of If you go back to clause 2, I have grave concerns regarding clause 2, which amends\n               section 5. Previously, the opinion of the head of the public body was irrelevant regarding\n               whether a request had enough detail. Now it explicitly states, \"in the opinion of\n               the head of the public body,\" and it adds that the request must provide enough detail\n               for the record to be found in a reasonable amount of time. A reasonable amount of time is not defined. To a government drowning in its own incompetence,\n               a reasonable amount of time to find a document might be five minutes. If it takes\n               six minutes, we can now reject the request under clause 2. This gives the bureaucracy\n               the power to say: \"We have organized our filing systems so poorly and have deleted\n               so many records that finding this document will take too long. Therefore, your request\n               is invalid.\" It rewards bad record keeping. If the Ministry of Forests or the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation\n               keeps messy files, it can now use the messiness as a legal excuse to deny an FOI request.\n               \"Sorry. Our office is a disaster, so it's unreasonable for you to ask us to find anything.\" I want to specifically address how this culture of secrecy impacts our relationship\n               with Indigenous Peoples and the management of land in British Columbia. This NDP government\n               loves to talk about reconciliation. They love the photo ops. Lord knows they don't\n               ask why they are at the photo ops. But just around that, just this morning, a freedom\n               of information request did reveal some very damning information. But when it comes\n               to the hard work of land negotiations, they've operated in the shadows. We have seen this repeatedly. Look at the way they handled the Land Act amendments.\n               They tried to push through massive changes to how public land is managed in this province,\n               changes that would have fundamentally altered tenure and access. Did they hold open\n               town halls? Did they proactively disclose their plans? No. They held closed-door meetings\n               with select groups and tried to bypass the public entirely. It was only when the opposition\n               and the public caught wind of it that they paused. Look at the Haida title agreement. Regardless of where one stands on the outcome,\n               the process was characterized by absolute secrecy. The negotiations happened in a\n               black box. Nobody knew. Stakeholders — fishing lodges, tourism operators, local residents\n               — were kept in the dark until the deal was effectively done. Under Bill 9, this secrecy will get worse. Imagine a local resident hears a rumour\n               about a new land transfer agreement being negotiated in secret. They file an FOI request\n               to the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation asking for correspondence\n               regarding this potential deal. Under clause 13, the ministry could look at that request\n               and say: \"This request is excessively broad, because you don't know the specific name\n               of the file. Rejected.\" Or they could say: \"Releasing this information would unreasonably\n               interfere with the operations of government, because we are in the middle of secretive\n               talks. Rejected.\" Or if the resident files three requests because they are worried\n               about their livelihood, the ministry could label them \"repetitious\" or even \"malicious\".\n               Rejected. This government treats the public land of British Columbia as if it's the private\n               property of the NDP cabinet. They believe they have the right to carve it up, rezone\n               it or transfer it without showing their work to the people who actually live there. Bill 9 is the shield they'll use to hide the next Land Act debacle. It is a shield\n               they will use to hide the next negotiation that Bill 9 is the shield they will use to hide the next Land Act debacle. It is the shield\n               they'll use to hide the next negotiation that excludes key stakeholders. Let's look at clause 7. This creates a new section, 16.1, allowing the refusal of\n               information that would reveal the substance of a communication by a judicial officer\n               about a proposed policy or enactment. Why is this necessary? If a judge or a justice of the peace has concerns about a law\n               this government is proposing, perhaps concerns that it is unconstitutional or unworkable\n               or dangerous, why should the public not know? We're seeing a pattern here. The government does not want debate. They do not want\n               input, and they certainly do not want criticism from the judiciary entering the public\n               sphere. They want to sanitize the record. They want to ensure that when they bring\n               a flawed bill into this House, no one can point to a memo from a judicial officer\n               warning them that it's a disaster. Now, I understand the importance of judicial independence. I understand the sensitivity\n               of communications between the judiciary and the executive. But this provision is extraordinarily\n               broad. It covers communications about proposed policies, proposed programs, proposed\n               enactments. It covers communications made on behalf of a judicial officer, which could\n               include staff, clerks, anyone claiming to speak for a member of the judiciary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721705","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm just checking my time there. I'm taking over. I'm just going to get started a\n               little bit before I left off almost a month ago now. The title of this bill contains a cruel irony. It contains the words \"freedom of information.\"\n               Yet as I stand here and review the clauses, the subclauses and the bureaucratic language\n               woven into this legislation, I see v","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cecea295a56523752b30e83367723af8e74aa0038e7cfeafbf9f0e74baba2ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d59e7a9021a0e6461630dfaf68a858608353c16ba1581d99319712fd59f573f7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b427ead153fd3b31e13fbbbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721707,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a bit of an emotional day, up and down today, but on the positive side, this\n               is the first time I get to wish somebody a happy birthday in my family. Emily Tepper,\n               my tiny baby girl, is 23. She's not very much bigger still at this point, but I want\n               to let her know how much I love her, how mom and dad are always proud of you. Since\n               Emily actually is right now in Mexico at a wedding, if she can stop bouncing long\n               enough to show the bride and groom, I would like to congratulate Tyra Byfert and Alexi\n               Alcock on their wedding today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721707","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a bit of an emotional day, up and down today, but on the positive side, this\n               is the first time I get to wish somebody a happy birthday in my family. Emily Tepper,\n               my tiny baby girl, is 23. She's not very much bigger still at this point, but I want\n               to let her know how much I love her, how mom and dad are always proud of you. Since\n               Emi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Censorship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pregnancy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43123","label":"Censorship","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:61492","label":"Pregnancy","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef27077e425f5851ad3be1fce5cc014dd3646b861049fc093cf651707dbae410"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a4a4ac54e999e8978eac04368c79ccdc58af6201620e23c1e86ac2af4b1595c6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc850fe7b9f2192fba443dc1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729491,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my great honour today to introduce Morgan Brewster, a lifelong volunteer whose\n               service to the people of Crescent Beach and South Surrey stands as a shining example\n               of what community dedication truly means. Morgan's family's roots run deep in this province. His great-great-grandfather arrived\n               from Ontario in 1885 and homesteaded a farm at Mud Bay between the Serpentine and\n               Nicomekl rivers, overlooked by all of Panorama. For generations, the Brewster family has returned to those shores. Morgan himself\n               has spent every summer of his life, 43 years, in Crescent Beach, a place his family\n               has called home since 1950. The deep connection shaped a lifetime of service. At age ten, Morgan volunteered in a search for a missing boy and a tragic drowning.\n               With a father who had been a lifeguard, those moments led a lifelong passion for guarding,\n               search and rescue, and helping others. Morgan lifeguarded at Crescent Beach. He began\n               volunteering as a boat instructor, and I have experienced firsthand his skill with\n               an outboard motor. He has served on the At age ten, Morgan volunteered in a search for a missing boy in a tragic drowning.\n               With a father who had been a lifeguard, those moments led a lifelong passion for guarding,\n               search and rescue, and helping others. Morgan lifeguarded at Crescent Beach. He began\n               volunteering as a boat instructor, and I have experienced firsthand his skill with\n               an outboard motor. He has served on the management committee of Crescent Beach Lifeguard Corporation\n               and, for the past five years, has proudly served as president. With the Crescent Beach\n               Swim Club, he started in progressive roles in 2005, and in September 2025, he became\n               president, a process that is both mystical and exciting every time it happens at the\n               club. He's the first third-generation president, proudly following both his grandfather\n               and father. Morgan's marine rescue record is remarkable. He first volunteered with\n               the Coast Guard Auxiliary on the north arm of the Fraser River. He returned to what\n               is now Royal Canadian Marine Search and Rescue, unit 5. As coxswain, he handled initial\n               responses and resource allocation on more than 100 rescue calls. Everyone who knows Morgan knows he would have loved to wear the uniform of the RCMP.\n               To this day, all summer long, he follows every emergency call in the Crescent Beach\n               area, ready to support our first responders in whatever way he can. I would be remiss for not mentioning that for the past ten seasons, he has also coached\n               and managed the South Vancouver Little League, from T-Ball right up to majors. Morgan Brewster is the very definition of quiet, consistent, community-first leadership.\n               Please join me in giving him a warm welcome to the British Columbia Legislature. Thank you, Morgan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729491","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is my great honour today to introduce Morgan Brewster, a lifelong volunteer whose\n               service to the people of Crescent Beach and South Surrey stands as a shining example\n               of what community dedication truly means. Morgan's family's roots run deep in this province. His great-great-grandfather arrived\n               from Ontario in 1885 and homesteaded a farm at Mud Bay b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083631","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Survival","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083631","label":"Survival","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","label":"Coast guard","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33689e6e0150fa1775c7ab122e7fe112d9727b499738d9abdf845d15612ac399"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43350aa64c900e9fb8970fa7156b655a6d74fb5b785afe45c0f512e53e4fab04"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Coast guard","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752125","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e723ed3b51ad3f6a78d37485","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729500,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to join in, in welcoming the NCCM, the National Council of Canadian Muslims.\n               It is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit organization dedicated to protecting\n               human rights and civil liberties in Canada. Founded in 2000, the NCCM has grown into\n               the country's largest Muslim advocacy organization, with a nationwide network of supporters\n               across Canada. I would like to thank, actually, our candidate from Surrey Centre as well, which was part of our last speaker there, for bringing him, Zeeshan Wahla, being part of the organization and helping organize this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729500","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to join in, in welcoming the NCCM, the National Council of Canadian Muslims.\n               It is an independent, non-partisan, non-profit organization dedicated to protecting\n               human rights and civil liberties in Canada. Founded in 2000, the NCCM has grown into\n               the country's largest Muslim advocacy organization, with a nationwide network of supporters\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","label":"Social structure","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["215040838f5800fdc58189b76de88e08f1f4e132a0db0dc3c8145305d81fa3b0","d8fbb45879ab0e76a5727a7474f702fb717fd0223602935f841a6cbccece98a6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ea1946ec928e5ff688d58a467233298daa01c1a1dd54e73617cbe8b19806556f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6ae751cd8510d13299b7254","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752351,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Just sitting here, I was a little confused at hearing some of the debate that we had.\n               As I'm aware, we do have an 8,200-kilogram gross vehicle weight in there, if that\n               answers that. Most of the other items that have been brought up are items that are generally dealt\n               with through regulation, and pushing this back to committee.... I will talk about that\n               when police bodycams came in, we dealt with all of these issues through regulation.\n               The bill is there and lays out the guidelines, but regulation is what we deal with\n               on a basis for any of these things that are being brought as what I see as roadblocks\n               to what's being pushed forward as a very cost-effective method of road safety. If we look at vision zero, which I think is an admirable program, it's been in for,\n               I think, 15 years now, and we're looking to bring down deaths and serious injuries\n               in this province. If we can place cameras in vehicles, first of all, it brings self-accountability\n               to the drivers of these vehicles, knowing that their actions are covered or recorded\n               by these dashcams. Again, financially nowadays, it is extremely, extremely inexpensive to put a camera\n               in your vehicle. We will go from there, but really, at that point, I don't see the\n               argument against passing this on, on items like this.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752351","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Just sitting here, I was a little confused at hearing some of the debate that we had.\n               As I'm aware, we do have an 8,200-kilogram gross vehicle weight in there, if that\n               answers that. Most of the other items that have been brought up are items that are generally dealt\n               with through regulation, and pushing this back to committee.... I will talk about that\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a3d9cf14f74d3254d8f9382718f9e793bd73a6031d8b6e2fc8debf1a24b8499"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a19c249c58f62b7b9b3cec18e5624b11a8526319bb60d2fa326d0c2f655e47f5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-feed25e6992bbaf4098c83b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752352,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yes, I'd like to seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752352","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yes, I'd like to seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fe83a2cb5a17518e9bff194a96788266b05bfeb523a6cc5350a3540d278679f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a8e73eb490988ff9b06c1759","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752354,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Hon. Chair, thank you very much. I appreciate that. And Chair, before I continue with\n               my questions, I think it's important that this House understand the perspective I\n               bring to this debate. I'm the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, but before I was elected to serve the people of British Columbia in this chamber,\n               I served them as a member of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. I didn't learn about\n               policing from briefing notes. I learned about it on the streets of Surrey and the\n               interior lands of the Williams Lake detachment. I served in E division in a counter-terrorism\n               unit, working to keep British Columbians safe from some of the most serious threats\n               our province has faced. I worked with the drug section in Surrey, investigating organized crime networks,\n               dismantling drug operations and understanding how these criminal enterprises function\n               from the inside. I worked in various plainclothes roles in Surrey during the gang\n               conflict. I was on the ground during some of the most violent periods in Surrey's\n               history. I know these networks. I know how they recruit. I know how they operate. I know their\n               tactics, their structures and their vulnerabilities. I retired as a sergeant in the Surrey RCMP, not behind a desk in Victoria but leading\n               officers on the front line of one of the most challenging policing environments in\n               Canada. I was in charge of a district office in Guildford, engaging directly with the community.\n               I sat down with business owners, with families, with community leaders. I listened\n               to their concerns. I worked with them to find solutions. I built the relationships\n               that are essential to effective policing. I partook in quality assurance reviews for Surrey detachment, auditing the files,\n               practices and policy of the largest RCMP detachment in Canada. That means I reviewed\n               complex investigations, assessed operational procedures, identified systemic gaps\n               and ensured accountability. I didn't just do police work. I evaluated it at the highest\n               level. Perhaps most relevantly to this chamber, I served as treasurer of the Mounted Police\n               Professional Association of Canada when we took the government to court for the right\n               to associate, and we won. I understand the intersection of policing and politics. I understand what happens\n               when governments make decisions that affect front-line officers without understanding\n               the operational realities. When I ask questions about policing, about organized crime, about community safety,\n               about the gang and extortion crisis affecting our communities, I'm asking from a foundation\n               of direct, hands-on experience. I've worked counter-terrorism. I've investigated drug\n               trafficking. When I ask questions about policing, about organized crime, about community safety,\n               about the gang and extortion crisis affecting our communities, I'm asking from a foundation\n               of direct, hands-on experience. I've worked counterterrorism. I've investigated drug\n               trafficking. I've disrupted gang operations. I've led officers. I've engaged communities.\n               I've audited the largest detachment in the country. I know what works and what doesn't. I know the difference between political announcements\n               and operational capacity. I know the difference between authorized positions and boots\n               on the ground. I know the difference between a task force that gets results and a\n               task force that gets press coverage. I bring that experience to this House not to grandstand but to ensure the decisions\n               we make here are grounded in operational reality, not political convenience. The people\n               of Surrey and the people of British Columbia deserve evidence-based policy informed\n               by people who have actually done the work. That's the standard I hold myself to, and\n               that's the standard I expect from this government. While I always strive for collegial discussion, I understand that this might get a\n               little bit spicy. I do understand that a lot of these problems came from the current\n               Minister of Transportation when he was Solicitor General and we had this transition\n               in Surrey that was a real problem. I have a lot of questions. I did give the minister a heads-up on a lot of the numbers\n               that we may need, so hopefully we can move just a little bit quicker while we're doing\n               this. My first question would be: how many provincial RCMP officers do we have in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752354","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Hon. Chair, thank you very much. I appreciate that. And Chair, before I continue with\n               my questions, I think it's important that this House understand the perspective I\n               bring to this debate. I'm the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, but before I was elected to serve the people of British Columbia in this chamber,\n               I served them as a member of the Royal Canadian Mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Warrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037530","label":"Warrants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["abed3b726328cc3c611d39d4f3591f39771089d8af14b087d6e05cffc9af0596","bfca2e93bb617691192ee7d116588b65e98e6a6308ad5685a9e1cf727ecd556f","5b58bd950d95b2d3a7dcb3d6592b06081b8e2126c4608ca7a468a6554fb36de4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3df4084fcfaccdbe48b3abefc516a4036df3bd6b6ec05d80861c30ba6519920"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-229b37fdc3f023b6a57c0f49","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017657,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think we finished up last session, about a week and a half ago.... We were talking\n               about the resources and what we're doing with the active deportation orders and the\n               overstays. So I will just ask..... From what I gather there, I think I probably know\n               the answer already. How much money or how many resources are we putting into allocating and apprehending\n               the people with active deportation orders in this province? I could probably speed\n               it up. From what I gather, it was zero.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017657","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think we finished up last session, about a week and a half ago.... We were talking\n               about the resources and what we're doing with the active deportation orders and the\n               overstays. So I will just ask..... From what I gather there, I think I probably know\n               the answer already. How much money or how many resources are we putting into allocating and apprehend","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718459","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Atmospheric emissions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","label":"Helicopters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","label":"Military aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","label":"Airlines","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","label":"Air quality","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718459","label":"Air","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","label":"Air transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752263","label":"Atmospheric emissions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f733eeb113e0c44a266301058384343956b780df4e6c69a8ce6e2cb7b6463f3","7e06e6c0e374091742bf1d30a53a1de010f5201e49a99377147b1ebafd1482e1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3bb46eeeb51933874ba99b1803939e6516fc6b892b8b94e3129e72ae6fd2840c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d63544659f206cf790f24d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017658,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the answer. I appreciate that. The three helicopters. Are they full-time helicopters in the Lower Mainland, or is\n               that one extra that was talked about during the extortion expansion of resources?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017658","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you for the answer. I appreciate that. The three helicopters. Are they full-time helicopters in the Lower Mainland, or is\n               that one extra that was talked about during the extortion expansion of resources?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","label":"Helicopters"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Airlines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military command","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","label":"Helicopters","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","label":"Military aviation","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036295","label":"Military command","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43405","label":"Airlines","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","label":"Air transport","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4096ccc98812f56e6b7edb8738d8b5718b8d31e2ee3d860d8fb9fce21b0b94f8","e54b426e420841d6b95a059ad7c60347a698d9d08513a517f18e2bb5d25633d0","cd2263f75180f8fc0300855fe79f151796ae8db2a9b896d99bef2d389749efe8","8f07d83e8093806556860b79f2c3690022ed2b7abcd60622a36b2b8d39636deb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fbda1bd8512d0a03b9a55f36c648c6e56c0ac2a02cf90adcbc5718394c64a5d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f53f45650ee507bc445ee68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017659,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017659","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["499b47e23ff8093ad78c5e83431a8912a233519bfaad205e05fd1b3c6cb10842"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-df6de3a31faccd45a40caf29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036591,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bryan Tepper","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last year I stood here and told you all it could have been worse. A few of you probably\n               wondered what I meant. Well, since then, my wife has been talked into running for\n               Surrey city council. I blame a lot of you for that, for encouraging her. So now I'm married to a politician, and, yes, it can always get worse, so I can empathize\n               with a lot of your spouses. But a happy 25th anniversary to Rona Tepper, the luckiest\n               bride in the world. Please make her feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036591","member_id":"bc-mla-403","member_name":"Bryan Tepper","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Last year I stood here and told you all it could have been worse. A few of you probably\n               wondered what I meant. Well, since then, my wife has been talked into running for\n               Surrey city council. I blame a lot of you for that, for encouraging her. So now I'm married to a politician, and, yes, it can always get worse, so I can empathize\n               with a lot of your spo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["69ed4b8a6d1da80f38fcee9c2a2c7427e9f6527865490ecea64b5e590a790356"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6691bdb110ba6b6b27be4bb1c61a38920436d88f61114ca519b5a8823eb7ac1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8707ccf536ce091d6bf08f53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317145,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"The community housing fund was designed to deliver below-market homes. The minister\n               is cutting thousands of those planned affordable housing units that are needed in\n               a time when people can't afford to pay for rent. To the minister, how many low-income British Columbians and their families will be\n               forced, god forbid, to seek out single-room occupancy to put a roof over their heads\n               because of her cut?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317145","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"The community housing fund was designed to deliver below-market homes. The minister\n               is cutting thousands of those planned affordable housing units that are needed in\n               a time when people can't afford to pay for rent. To the minister, how many low-income British Columbians and their families will be\n               forced, god forbid, to seek out single-room occupancy to ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c36a5234c96716d867a349d4a2d77e166e75599b3a41bb0a9fd220275ea5736c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0d96772822c93e727a15fb6256f8c9117aef9ef31064324d123ae242eb999525"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b77e4d7530c88556da5264dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327981,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Recently, I had the absolute privilege of attending an event called A Night to Shine\n               at Horizon Church in my riding. What an extraordinary evening it was — a true celebration\n               of joy, inclusion and community spirit honouring individuals with special needs. A Night to Shine is an unforgettable prom night experience, centred on God's love,\n               designed specifically for people with special needs age 14 and older. It all began a decade ago as a simple idea from the Tim Tebow Foundation to mark their fifth anniversary and a way to shine a light on those often overlooked\n               in our society. Tim Tebow and his team prayed for just 25 churches to simultaneously\n               host the event that first year, but 44 stepped up, creating the first magical prom\n               experience that has since become and blossomed into something truly remarkable. A Night to Shine has blossomed now into a worldwide movement involving over 600 host\n               churches in 56 countries. Seeing the walk down the red carpet, the smiles, the dancing, the balloon drop and\n               the crowning of kings and queens on young people often overlooked, or not as easily engaged, but getting to experience an amazing prom night, was a real highlight of my year. It showcased the best in our province, with compassionate\n               volunteers, supportive families and a shared commitment to equity. I want to give a special thanks to Horizon Church, who brought joy to so many young\n               people dressed in their prom-night finery. It was uplifting to be there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327981","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Recently, I had the absolute privilege of attending an event called A Night to Shine\n               at Horizon Church in my riding. What an extraordinary evening it was — a true celebration\n               of joy, inclusion and community spirit honouring individuals with special needs. A Night to Shine is an unforgettable prom night experience, centred on God's love,\n               designed specifi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d91179c5439b4db61a0e6fbf1c8e76a8de6308782cefa668bb2160e92ef0d084"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d828c82955e2355bc5a8387","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360167,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like the House to welcome two of my constituency assistants here today, Deborah\n               Colt and Kyla Colt. Yes, they are sisters, and they do an enormous amount of work,\n               as everyone here knows, at the constituency office. In fact, we are so excited because this next week, on Monday, I officially get the\n               keys to my office that I have been....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360167","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like the House to welcome two of my constituency assistants here today, Deborah\n               Colt and Kyla Colt. Yes, they are sisters, and they do an enormous amount of work,\n               as everyone here knows, at the constituency office. In fact, we are so excited because this next week, on Monday, I officially get the\n               keys to my office that I have been....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8efb41e6c24c3ae5e3bec3fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415737,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"When people think of a large urban centre in British Columbia, they picture housing,\n               transit and industry, but in my riding, like several across our province, we also\n               have productive agricultural land woven into the urban fabric. That gives us a unique\n               perspective on water. In British Columbia, we have long understood water to be one of our greatest natural\n               advantages, but abundance does not automatically mean affordability, and it certainly\n               does not guarantee resilience. For farmers operating within and adjacent to our cities,\n               reliable and affordable access to high-quality water is not optional. It determines\n               whether crops are planted, whether livestock operations continue and whether local\n               food remains on local shelves. Urban-adjacent farmers face unique pressures. Land values are high. Infrastructure\n               must compete with other urban priorities. During dry summers when water restrictions\n               tighten, agriculture can feel squeezed between residential and industrial demands.\n               Climate change compounds these pressures. Hotter summers, lower snowpacks and prolonged\n               drought conditions require investments in storage, in efficiency and in innovation,\n               simply to maintain production. I also want to speak directly to my colleagues who represent rural and small-town\n               British Columbia communities, where agriculture is not simply part of the landscape\n               but part of the identity and economic foundation. In many of those ridings, water\n               supports not only fields and orchards but fruit processors, local employers, small\n               businesses and entire town centres. It sustains ranches and family farms, yes, but\n               it also sustains the mechanics, the equipment suppliers, the truck drivers, the local\n               grocers and the schools that depend on stable local economies. You need assurance, and you deserve it, that as we modernize water policy, we will\n               protect British Columbia's sovereign responsibility to manage water in a way that\n               keeps it accessible and affordable for food production and the communities that depend\n               on it. Let me be clear that protecting affordability for agriculture is not about\n               favouring one region over another. It's about recognizing that rural and small-town\n               B.C. cannot absorb unpredictable cost increases or policy uncertainty in the same\n               way larger urban centres sometimes can. When water becomes unaffordable for producers, the consequences ripple outward. A\n               farm scales back. A processor loses supply. Seasonal workers are not hired. Local\n               businesses feel the contraction. Small towns, already working hard to maintain services\n               and population, feel further strain. True resilience means ensuring that water policy\n               reflects the reality, on the ground, that farming margins are often tight, that climate\n               adaptation requires investment and that the public benefit of local food production\n               must be factored into our decisions. Maintaining affordable access to water for agriculture strengthens rural economies,\n               protects small-town stability and reduces our dependence on imported food, grown under\n               standards that we do not control. British Columbia has always managed its own water\n               resources with independence. As pressures grow from climate change, population growth and competing demands, our\n               commitment must be clear. We will safeguard our watersheds and safeguard the communities\n               that rely on them. Water for food production in British Columbia must remain responsibly\n               managed, sovereign, reliable and affordable.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415737","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"When people think of a large urban centre in British Columbia, they picture housing,\n               transit and industry, but in my riding, like several across our province, we also\n               have productive agricultural land woven into the urban fabric. That gives us a unique\n               perspective on water. In British Columbia, we have long understood water to be one of our greatest nat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3c3264ec04a86322e9cc1ae1f022a2b2f7048f897ac922c2770b806cc512bc50"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90cf8f0b8aade0b653d16a6fd07131c134edfeeed68056db2f7bfc7bd416f7d5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-465fb60cdd2d8fd0edeaa71d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415738,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like the House to please welcome the Canadian Mortgage Brokers of British\n               Columbia, who are here today representing mortgage brokers from across this province,\n               professionals working every single day to help people find their homes. They're here\n               to talk to us and to share with us their perspective and their experiences on the\n               ground relative to the housing, accessibility and affordable market that they're trying\n               to navigate and, we know, everyone trying to find a home in our beautiful province. Thank you for being here today. May the House welcome them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415738","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would like the House to please welcome the Canadian Mortgage Brokers of British\n               Columbia, who are here today representing mortgage brokers from across this province,\n               professionals working every single day to help people find their homes. They're here\n               to talk to us and to share with us their perspective and their experiences on the\n               groun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1f63e0791cc08ae66f27b309106ae4759a7b4a8981256ed86723ec56fb4c6471"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["06ee5f9dbe17b3e4bc18dbe2684fdeb1bfb21545344f96dc2986b48673c0dd2c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-55a97216fd59639f479bcba4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415739,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak today on Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. As the MLA for Surrey–Serpentine River and the opposition critic for Housing, I rise in opposition to this bill, not because\n               I oppose the intent to improve safety and support of housing but because it represents\n               a timid, half-hearted response to a crisis born of years of poorly conceived and badly\n               managed and recklessly funded policies. This legislation implicitly admits the failures of past approaches to supportive housing,\n               which have left communities across our province up in arms over safety concerns, disruptive\n               behaviours and a shocking lack of accountability. Yet while corrective measures are desperately needed to make these facilities safer\n               and more palatable to the neighbourhoods they impact, Bill 11 fails and falls short.\n               It tinkers around the edges without addressing the root causes or providing robust\n               protections that operators, who are essentially landlords in this context, and everyday\n               landlords across British Columbia need against bad tenants. As a leader who demands results and fiscal responsibility, I see this exactly for\n               what it is, a band-aid solution on a wound they themselves have created, through bloated\n               budgets and ineffective spending and a policy model that puts at-risk tenants and\n               seniors often in a cohabitation free-for-all. Let me begin by outlining what Bill 11 proposes, based on the bill's text and government\n               explanations. This bill creates a new part 1.1 in the Residential Tenancy Act targeting supportive\n               housing subsidized units with on-site supports that don't often exist for those at\n               risk or experiencing homelessness. It defines key terms like supportive housing operator, housing stability support,\n               authorized person, expanding on who can intervene in tenancy matters. The changes\n               restrict landlord entry to prescribed purposes or with notice, but allow operators\n               to amend tenancy agreements unilaterally in some cases. It permits regulations for temporary access restrictions to de-escalate health and\n               safety risk and enables evictions if tenants or guests possess weapons — defined by\n               regulation, not defined within the bill. We don't know what is a weapon. A weapon\n               could be a fork. It could be any number of things. Who defines a weapon comes at a\n               later time. If weapons are in plain view, operators can then seek expedited orders. The bill sets minimum compensation for non-compliance while creating exceptions for\n               seizing property, unit cleanliness and ending tenancies for disturbance or illegal\n               activities. The government presents this as a balanced fix for rare, they say, but serious safety\n               issues in supportive housing. I would submit to you it is probably not rare. I have\n               a number of cases, as the Housing critic, around areas where supportive housing has\n               badly failed. They reference a 2025 working group and boast about investments on housing, including\n               the 9,900 supportive units. But this narrative glosses over the reality. Their consultation\n               excluded the very people who best describe the inadequacies and the issues around\n               supportive housing. It excluded law enforcement agencies. It excluded fire departments. It excluded paramedics\n               and neighbouring residents — first responders who deal with the emergencies that these\n               failed policies create every single day and then those that live in proximity to those\n               units. Supportive housing policies under this government have been rushed, underfunded and\n               poorly managed, resulting in facilities that exacerbate rather than alleviate community\n               concerns and put fragile lives in jeopardy. In my riding of Surrey–Serpentine River and across the province, I hear daily from landlords and operators who are exhausted\n               by this pattern of throwing money at problems with no accountability, only to deliver\n               chaos. We've seen projects plopped into neighbourhoods without adequate consultation,\n               leading to fears of increased crime, drug use and disorder near schools, parks and\n               family homes. Recently in Burnaby, a proposed 40-unit supportive housing and complex care project\n               was abandoned after intense process from residents worried about safety and lack of\n               input. Over 13,000 signatures opposed it, citing the potential for drug-related issues. In Abbotsford, council voted down a 42-bed modular facility due to its proximity to\n               an elementary school, and, again, concerns of off-site drug use and crime. Surrey\n               council blocked a project with supportive units, ordering a reassessment amid community\n               outcry over safety. New Westminster neighbours pushed back against transitional housing,\n               fearing impacts on local schools and families. Even in Vancouver, a Kitsilano project\n               was quashed after lawsuits and a resident challenge highlighted inappropriate siting. These aren't isolated incidents. They are symptoms of a flawed approach. Communities\n               are up in arms because supportive housing has too often become synonymous with unmanaged\n               chaos, violence, weapons, disruptive guests and the inadequate supports that fail\n               to address the needs like addiction and mental health, or we're combining these serious\n               needs and putting those at risk in a very ineffective system without the kinds of\n               supports that need to be in place to ensure both public safety and the safety of those\n               residents themselves. Worse, the bill ignores critical building safety hazards that landlords and operators\n               are left to manage: secondhand smoke from fentanyl and methamphetamine that poisons\n               the air for staff and neighbouring tenants, fire risks from butane torches and lithium\n               e-bike batteries, unsafe conditions with zero new standards or enforcement. This act\n               does not address any of those serious, serious things. Operators, including non-profits and Indigenous providers, have begged for reform.\n               Some have even called for the exemption Operators, including non-profits and Indigenous providers, have begged for reform.\n               Some have even called for the exemption from the Residential Tenancy Act entirely\n               in order to handle these issues effectively. The government's underfunding and lack of oversight, while the budget balloons, have\n               turned what should be lifelines instead into flashpoints, eroding public support and\n               stalling new projects. I speak from experience in delivering supportive housing into Surrey. I know what\n               it takes to deliver supportive housing. I know what it takes to make sure that they\n               are safe. I know what it takes to work with the operators. I know what it takes to\n               ensure that every single supportive housing tenant understands what is required of\n               them, but more importantly, that the operators know what those supportive housing\n               tenants need. I can tell you that it takes a lot of time. It takes a lot of personal individual\n               care, understanding. You can have one tenant that is by nature a hoarder. You can\n               have another tenant that needs a lot of mental health assistance. You can have another\n               tenant that needs both mental health and hoarding assistance. And drug use. There\n               are.... The plethora of what you can get in those environments is critical. What is needed is a much more definitive plan around how those can be more properly\n               addressed and how.... This bill simply does not go far enough. But does the bill deliver any strong protections that the landlords, the operators\n               and the communities deserve? Hardly. While it does offer some tools, like eviction for weapons and temporary restrictions,\n               it is a watered-down compromise. The weapons provision is so vague with no clear definition,\n               leaving operators uncertain, with unclear enforcement protocols thrust onto untrained\n               staff and putting them in dangerous situations. Who responds when a tenant is believed\n               to be armed? Will the operators face liability if something goes wrong? The bill stops short of the bold reforms needed. It ignores calls for better funding\n               of supports to prevent problems, leaving operators as de facto enforcers rather than\n               caregivers, all while the budget this year quietly suspended the community housing\n               fund, upending those projects provincewide. And it refuses to fund proper training\n               or cover rising WCB claims when front-line workers face traumatic incidents. It has\n               had no consultation with the first-responding agencies who have the best firsthand\n               knowledge, and I think that is one of the critical oversights of this bill. It does little, Bill 11, to address the broader need for landlord protections against\n               bad tenants, and those needs are not just in supportive housing but across the entire\n               rental market. Every day, landlords face rising challenges from disruptive or destructive\n               tenants. These tweaks don't solve the core issue. All landlords need faster, fairer tools, obviously, to evict bad actors who damage\n               property, disturb neighbours, or engage in illegal activities. But Bill 11's expansions are limited, and they're limited to supportive housing, leaving\n               general landlords in the lurch amid a housing crisis the NDP's spending failures has\n               only made worse. The shortsightedness of Bill 11 is part of an ongoing pattern of half-measures, proposed\n               changes that favour ideology over results and budgets that waste taxpayer dollars\n               without delivering safe communities or a stable housing supply. Safety in supportive\n               housing requires addressing the conditions inside those buildings — poor maintenance,\n               lack of security staffing, drug activity, fire hazards — not just tenant behaviour.\n               Yet this government refuses to respond to that. Instead of these half-measures, we do need some comprehensive reform. We need to invest\n               in trauma-informed supports and training. We do need to invest in mandated community\n               consultation for siting and stronger eviction tools for all landlords. Who suffers from this inadequacy? The communities continue to resist, stalling progress.\n               The operators burn out without real tools or clear safety protocols, the front-line\n               workers face unacceptable risks, and the landlords writhe under unbalanced laws that\n               this government has refused to fix. The government's defence that this balances safety\n               and rights rings hollow when their past and current policies create the imbalance. In conclusion, I can tell you that the supportive housing, the whole program around\n               how we deliver safety within a supportive housing environment, needs a whole rethink.\n               I think that Bill 11 demands bolder action. I think that we can get there. I think\n               we need to have a broader discussion with those across the aisle on why communities\n               are resisting and what it will take for communities to say yes. I know, when I was bringing in some supportive housing into my city of Surrey some\n               years ago and working with a former Minister of Housing, Selina Robinson, we took\n               a measured approach on how we were going to individually help each person that requires\n               the kinds of assistance that supportive housing should deliver. Right now it is not\n               delivering effectively for both the supportive housing tenants nor for the communities\n               in which we're asking it to be placed. So while I regretfully cannot support Bill 11, I can say wholeheartedly that I support\n               finding a way where supportive housing programs will work, and I thank you for the\n               opportunity to speak.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415739","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak today on Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment\n               Act, 2026. As the MLA for Surrey–Serpentine River and the opposition critic for Housing, I rise in opposition to this bill, not because\n               I oppose the intent to improve safety and support of housing but because it represents\n               a timid, half-hearted response to a crisi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b349b7fd19d7004f5129b626e00c5b87cc425d9326db6ca45cf14431c0b867b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6616afa73465877ec8d618ba78de4396ecb6404d1c10f3bfd50ebc6134e02952"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e2acdb66d8bcf47aa3ac4480","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720359,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Metro Vancouver has become an unaccountable, disorganized mess. This government promised\n               it would step in two years ago. Another broken promise. Now the mayor of Surrey is\n               calling for a public inquiry. Will the Minister of Housing do what this Premier won't? Answer the call. Order a\n               public inquiry into Metro Vancouver.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720359","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Metro Vancouver has become an unaccountable, disorganized mess. This government promised\n               it would step in two years ago. Another broken promise. Now the mayor of Surrey is\n               calling for a public inquiry. Will the Minister of Housing do what this Premier won't? Answer the call. Order a\n               public inquiry into Metro Vancouver.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["153a3c8253dd138d678e0123daf7cca9c4994deca55d21f9a18f444a5df4b58c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aef01dba60f4653e83d8787d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720361,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today as the member for Surrey–Serpentine River, the official opposition critic for Housing, to speak on Bill 16, the Miscellaneous\n               Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. Let me start off by saying this is not a housekeeping bill. This is the NDP burying\n               substantive, far-reaching changes in a miscellaneous bill because they lack the courage\n               to defend them in the full light of day. As a woman who has run a city, had to balance a billion-dollar budget, as local governments\n               must, and actually build housing for families, I see exactly what this government\n               is doing. It's kicking the can down the road while pretending they are solving issues\n               that have been created through spending, overregulation and ideological stubbornness. I'm going to start off my comments with the housing, since that is my area of critic\n               role. It is not a surprise to me that development cost charges have exploded as municipalities\n               all over this province try to build and grow under the legislated mandates. It is\n               not irony that those same charges are now one of the biggest barriers to new housing\n               supply. Clauses in this bill — 11, 12, 25 — and the related amendments to the Greater Vancouver\n               Sewerage and Drainage District Act, the Local Government Act, the Vancouver Charter\n               and the South Coast British Columbia Transportation Authority Act give the Lieutenant\n               Governor in Council the power, by regulation, to now designate projects and waive\n               or reduce those DCC charges. On that narrow point, I say it is certainly advantageous On that narrow point, I say it is certainly advantageous to the province's budget\n               to not have to contribute any DCC monies for needed infrastructure, particularly if\n               it's a hospital, a school, a bridge or other major provincial project. Of that, there\n               is no doubt. However, once again, the ones left holding that bag to make it happen with very little\n               resources are municipalities. The formula for how local governments get funding has\n               got to change before you can put in legislation that, again, hinders them. Development cost charges are not some optional luxury. They are one of only two realistic\n               revenue tools local governments have. Property taxes and DCCs pay for the roads, the\n               water, sewer, fire halls and the new housing demands. No one wants to see high DCCs,\n               and I support lowering those. But I cannot support it in the absence of understanding\n               what that funding formula would now look like for local governments. The people who actually risked their own capital to build the ownership homes in British\n               Columbia that British Columbians need have been crushed by ever-increasing policies.\n               Reducing both policy demands and development cost charges is the only sure way to\n               get those shovels in the ground faster and to bring more supply online. I am sympathetic\n               to those that have been trying resolutely over the years to tilt that scale to understand\n               that some of those policies are really adding to the dilemma we find ourselves in\n               today. Here is where I think the sleight of hand becomes egregious, however. The bill doesn't\n               identify which projects will receive relief. It simply hands the Lieutenant Governor,\n               effectively cabinet, the power to pick and choose. That leaves us in an untenable\n               position. Hopefully, before the bill is either in committee or regulations, we would\n               know what exactly is available to the Lieutenant Governor to make those decisions. When the province waves those charges away from perhaps its favourite projects — hospitals,\n               wastewater plants, schools or politically convenient developments in Metro Vancouver\n               — what happens to that infrastructure bill? Municipalities can't wave a magic wand.\n               They cannot go into debt. They cannot. It is not allowed. So the only avenue they\n               have is to raise property taxes on existing homeowners or beg the province for infrastructure\n               funding. We all know how reliable this has been, delivery time for infrastructure\n               funding — it has not. As a former mayor, of Surrey, I lived this reality every single budget cycle. Building\n               a mile of arterial road and accompanying sewers in a growing city like Surrey costs\n               millions, tens of millions of dollars. The NDP trying to claim credit for reducing\n               housing costs while quietly now off-loading that infrastructure burden onto cities\n               and then ultimately onto ratepayers. I reiterate that, honestly, this legislation requires an understanding of where that\n               infrastructure funding would come from. They must table, in writing, exactly how it\n               intends to backfill the lost revenue for municipalities. Otherwise, this is nothing\n               more than a promise that sounds good on paper but leaves local governments holding\n               the bag. Shifting now to the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act and the Residential Tenancy\n               Act, that allows a director to now admit oral or written testimony that would otherwise\n               be inadmissible under the laws of evidence. This is a procedural improvement that\n               does provide consistency within the act in relation to evidence This is a procedural improvement that does provide consistency within the act in relation\n               to evidence, providing both tenants and landlords with the latitude to have their\n               cases well delivered and deliberated. When the end result is not acceptable to either\n               the tenant or the landlord or the manufactured home, the matter can be referred to\n               the dispute resolution proceeding. Noting the hour, I suggest we adjourn, and I hold my position for the next sitting.\n               I reserve my space.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720361","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today as the member for Surrey–Serpentine River, the official opposition critic for Housing, to speak on Bill 16, the Miscellaneous\n               Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. Let me start off by saying this is not a housekeeping bill. This is the NDP burying\n               substantive, far-reaching changes in a miscellaneous bill because they lack the courage\n               to defend them","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33de2ca950ae32372746f526fcde0dd5020165231e027fd5b3faa15b09b6f8ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["648f15de34ee25646d4d37796935e772b4db6524303d584ebf2c5f29b99ddaf7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b931a9475910706581e4f4b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721455,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and thank you for allowing me to continue my comments on this\n               Bill 16. I had closed the session last Thursday talking about the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy\n               Act and the clauses that were shifting that into discussions that would allow disputes\n               to go to the dispute resolution committee. What I wanted to make clear on that is\n               that also within Bill 11, recently adopted by this House, the supportive housing complaints\n               and issues were also chosen to go through a dispute resolution process. I think it's going to be very, very important that we have a more fulsome discussion\n               on the capacity of that dispute resolution team, because I'm hearing from many in\n               my own riding that there are exaggerated timelines for hearing. Adding more to it,\n               as we just recently have done, may trigger some lags in decisions. But I'm going to move on now. While housing is my file, I can't ignore the rest of\n               this omnibus bill. Part 2 guts the NDP's own Zero-Emission Vehicles Act, the very\n               mandates they rammed through six years ago, doubled down on two years ago, and called\n               historic. Clauses 7 to 10 quietly slash the 2035 target from 100 percent to 75 percent,\n               eliminate the 2026 and 2030 targets from legislation altogether and shove them into\n               regulation, where cabinet can rewrite them behind closed doors. This is the second major retreat in this file in under a year. First they killed the\n               provincial EV rebate. Now they are dismantling their own law and hiding it in a miscellaneous\n               bill. In 2025, our Conservative caucus introduced legislation to repeal these unrealistic\n               mandates. The NDP voted it down and mocked us. Today, they are doing exactly what\n               we proposed, only they lack the courage to admit it. British Columbians deserve better than a government that sets flashy targets for press\n               releases, attacks anyone who questions those targets, and then quietly walks them\n               back when reality bites. Families in Surrey–Serpentine River told this government for years that EVs are still too expensive, charging infrastructure\n               is inadequate, and our electricity grid cannot handle this fantasy. The NDP cancelled\n               the rebate, watched sales collapse and now acts shocked. You cannot kick away the\n               ladder and blame people for not climbing. Even as they retreat, they have left the punitive credit trading system in place,\n               so manufacturers will still raise the price of gas vehicles or cut supply to B.C.\n               dealerships. That means working families still pay for a policy the government no\n               longer believes in. This is not leadership. It is ideological The numbers expose the fantasy. In 2019, the NDP said EV demand was higher than expected.\n               In 2023, EVs hit 25 percent of new vehicle sales, so the government got cocky and\n               accelerated the targets. Then reality hit.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721455","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and thank you for allowing me to continue my comments on this\n               Bill 16. I had closed the session last Thursday talking about the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy\n               Act and the clauses that were shifting that into discussions that would allow disputes\n               to go to the dispute resolution committee. What I wanted to make clear on that is\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","label":"Electric vehicles","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["50d386babcf252fcca6f6908522b6ca67be91269c4c05539e7b6c8e8f66eec3a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8e2157eff40d0ffbb59e5579d0b392e2ffdea0b8147bc8114b6fc903e5b70563"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44215","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8d4f57b6b1db8ac91ba07e7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721457,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I am the grandmother of five boys. One in rugby, one in basketball, two\n               in lacrosse and one in hockey. My riding has sports fields, arenas, a pool. I speak\n               today about something special, about the bond between young athletes and the people\n               who stand behind them, usually on the sidelines, in the bleachers or in the car at\n               5 a.m. on the way to a practice. When we talk about youth sports, we often focus on the scoreboard — the wins, the\n               losses, the championships. But the real story is quieter and far more powerful. It's\n               a commitment that doesn't always show up in the highlight reel. For children, sports\n               teaches discipline, resilience and teamwork. They learn how to handle pressure, how\n               to bounce back from disappointment and how to work toward something bigger than themselves. None of that happens in isolation. Behind every young athlete is a parent, guardian\n               or family member making sacrifices of their own. They are investing time, energy and\n               often significant financial resources, not for recognition but for the opportunity\n               to help their child grow. They show up rain or shine, win or lose, offering encouragement,\n               perspective and sometimes just a warm drink and a listening ear. For the children, that commitment is felt. It becomes part of their own sense of responsibility\n               to their So today, let's recognize that youth sports are about much more than competition.\n               They're about character, they're about community, and they are about shared commitment\n               between parents and children. Because long after that final whistle blows, those are\n               the lessons that truly last.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721457","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I am the grandmother of five boys. One in rugby, one in basketball, two\n               in lacrosse and one in hockey. My riding has sports fields, arenas, a pool. I speak\n               today about something special, about the bond between young athletes and the people\n               who stand behind them, usually on the sidelines, in the bleachers or in the car at\n               5 a.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72b05145d047561fa2ce9a98983af3c41026bdf253cfd24558155e367229319a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce9288e4a0000ad86bd937002599b78b4a7c67a2eadbc80be1a9f4f9af83dc5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5cb3a8e61c2c3c60f4eb7dc9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721460,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today with the clarity of purpose that comes from more than three decades in\n               public life, first as a bureaucrat, helping to build companies that deliver results\n               for the citizens of Surrey, then as councillor and then as mayor, where I balanced\n               budgets, created jobs and fought for housing that, at that time, you could actually\n               afford, and now as the Member for Surrey–Serpentine River. I speak not as a partisan but as a leader who knows that sunlight is the best disinfectant\n               for any organization, government or private, and as a mother and grandmother who believes\n               British Columbians deserve leaders who trust them with the truth and the openness\n               of transparent decision-making and access to data used in public to make those decisions. Today I speak against Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act, 2026, the bill the NDP quietly placed on the floor of this House February\n               26. This is not a technical housekeeping measure. This is a deliberate step backward for\n               transparency in British Columbia. As Housing critic, I can tell you with absolute\n               certainty that if this bill passes, the housing crisis we are all fighting will become\n               even harder to solve because the public will be kept further in the dark. Let me be crystal clear from the outset. Freedom of information is not a luxury; it\n               is the cornerstone of accountable government. Our FOIPPA, passed in 1996, was designed\n               to put power back into the hands of the people. It has allowed journalists to expose\n               wasteful spending, opposition members like me to hold ministers to account and everyday\n               families to discover background issues that have directly affected them or their businesses. In my time as mayor, we used FOI requests to benchmark against other cities, to cut\n               red tape and to deliver more accountable results. FOI requests are how we learn the truth when the government's press releases paint\n               a different picture. So what does Bill 9 do? Instead of investing in reassigning more staff to clear the\n               back load, it gets reactionary and gives public bodies new tools to say no, to delay\n               and to bury information. That flies absolutely in the face of the act's very title,\n               freedom of information. Let's walk through the provisions, because British Columbians deserve to know exactly\n               what is being taken from them. First, the government wants to expand the power to disregard requests it labels \"abusive\"\n               or \"malicious.\" Those words sound reasonable until you realize they are subjective.\n               Who decides? The same ministries that are already slow-walking requests? A persistent\n               journalist asking the same question six times because the first five answers were\n               incomplete — abusive. A constituent in Surrey–Serpentine River filing multiple requests about why the new provincial transit-oriented development\n               promise still hasn't broken ground — malicious. The Privacy Commissioner gets more\n               authority to rubber-stamp refusals. That is not efficiency. That is a shield for incompetence. Secondly, they are watering down the duty to respond \"without delay\" to \"without unreasonable\n               delay.\" That tiny word change is everything. It is the legislative equivalent of a\n               government employee shrugging and saying: \"We'll get to it when we get to it.\" We\n               already see average response times anywhere from 43 to over 100 days and climbing.\n               This change does not fix the problem. It codifies it. That is troubling. Third, new hurdles on the specificity of requests. Applicants will be forced to clarify\n               and narrow their asks even more, giving bureaucrats fresh grounds to reject or endlessly\n               loop back. I know what a clear request looks like. As Housing critic, I know what\n               a desperate family in my riding looks like when they ask: \"Why can't I get help from\n               a rat-infested B.C. Housing unit?\" They do not need a law degree to phrase it perfectly.\n               This bill tells them: \"Try harder or go away.\" And let's talk about the so-called proactive release of personal information. Yes,\n               60 percent of requests are for one's own records. Streamlining that is fine on paper.\n               But when the government bundles it with centralized Connected Services B.C., a single\n               gateway that will hoover up your data across ministries and hand the minister power\n               to dictate data standards, we should all pause. Centralization sounds modern until\n               you remember the privacy breaches that we have seen from many corporations and around\n               the province generally in a few places. Notice how the government is far more enthusiastic about sharing your personal data\n               than it is about sharing its own decision-making records. Colleagues, I have reviewed the briefings. I have read the government's press releases\n               touting consultation with the Information and Privacy Commissioner. Yes, the commissioner\n               has issued a polite statement saying this is one step forward, but polite does not\n               equal endorsement of the big picture. The B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association has it right. This bill ignores\n               2022 special committee recommendations that called for strengthening access, not diluting\n               it. Vaughn Palmer laid it out plainly in the Vancouver Sun . \"The NDP are quietly moving to give public servants more power to refuse information\n               and keep the public in the dark.\" Now let me bring this home to the issue I am tasked with every single day, housing.\n               In Surrey–Serpentine River, we are at ground zero for B.C.'s housing crisis. Young families priced out. Seniors\n               forced to downsize or leave the community Now, let me bring this home to the issue I am tasked with every single day — housing.\n               In Surrey–Serpentine River, we are at ground zero for BC's housing crisis: young families, priced out; seniors\n               forced to downsize or leave the community they built; small businesses, not able to\n               attract workers — nowhere for them to live. And I have constituents who have waited\n               a very long time for why provincial funding for units is not happening. FOI responses reveal the internal memos showing that ministers know of supply shortages\n               two years before they were admitted publicly. Bill 9 will make those revelations harder.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721460","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today with the clarity of purpose that comes from more than three decades in\n               public life, first as a bureaucrat, helping to build companies that deliver results\n               for the citizens of Surrey, then as councillor and then as mayor, where I balanced\n               budgets, created jobs and fought for housing that, at that time, you could actually\n               affor","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6f0b71681b28268a2b7a2a1c74dff7e30dff4c09393b980babf790a9da1deda"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87a159b6c9fc88a9cdadabafe06086dd5076bf84febb95286f3fa760fccea8b6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d8a2e947b5c1e21b38cd4ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721461,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Surrey school district was promised 99 things by this government, but the highest-paid\n               superintendent in the province wasn't one of them — half a million dollars last year,\n               car allowance included. This is the same district that cut busing for kids. That's how backwards it is under\n               the NDP. The minister is paying for the superintendent to get to work while cutting\n               the buses that kids need to get to school. My question to the Minister of Finance: why is it acceptable to cover a high-paid\n               executive's commute while Surrey kids lose their bus ride to class?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721461","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Surrey school district was promised 99 things by this government, but the highest-paid\n               superintendent in the province wasn't one of them — half a million dollars last year,\n               car allowance included. This is the same district that cut busing for kids. That's how backwards it is under\n               the NDP. The minister is paying for the superintendent to get to work","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","label":"Buses","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6ea6560780642dbd5e91d839f821bf784ea55a0c46ca55400d7fff4cf52d76a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d8fdf3b34c0b58aca90b118d1c0e8d7e0ac8f283c21841cb056dbbafe92f2b94"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Buses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70535","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f7b18f365a41c8c3904df10f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721465,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act of 2026, and I shall try to do so in the absence of any lecture, any snide remarks\n               or any condescending tone. Let me begin clearly by saying that I support treaties, and I support reconciliation.\n               I have a very clear understanding of, and have worked very closely with, Indigenous\n               groups. I brought water to the SEMYOME Nation in my community. I worked with the qʼwan̓ƛʼən̓ Nation on housing. I've worked with the Métis Nation. I support recognition of Indigenous\n               rights and self-government. British Columbia's history, marked by the absence of treaties across most of the province,\n               demands that we do better. Modern treaties are an essential path forward. I want everyone\n               to know that it would give me great joy to support a modern treaty, but supporting\n               treaties does not mean suspending judgment. Modern treaties, when done properly, bring\n               clarity and certainty. They define relationships. They enable economic Modern treaties, when done properly, bring clarity and certainty. They define relationships.\n               They enable economic opportunity. They recognize rights in a very meaningful way. I want to acknowledge the work of the K'ómoks First Nation, decades of negotiation, perseverance and community effort to reach this\n               point. That work matters, and it deserves full respect. Reconciliation is not just one agreement between one nation and the Crown. It's about\n               the broader web of relationships among nations, among governments and among communities.\n               When those relationships are incomplete or unsettled, we cannot simply legislate past\n               that reality. We are hearing concerns from neighbouring First Nations, concerns about overlapping\n               territorial claims. I am no legal expert, nor would I ever profess to be the Solomon\n               that is going to solve whose territory we're overlapping and what that looks like,\n               but what I do know is that concerns about that are unresolved. That last point is\n               critical, because consultation is not just a check box. It's a constitutional obligation,\n               and it must be complete. It must occur before implementation, not alongside it. Yet here we are, being asked to pass, implementing legislation while those discussions\n               are unsettled. And we have nowhere to establish what those rights really are. This\n               is not the standard that British Columbia would expect of us. Government will say\n               this treaty creates certainty, but certainty is not something you can simply declare.\n               It is something you build. It is built when all affected parties are heard, when overlapping\n               interests are addressed, when legal frameworks are clear and understood. Let's take a quick look at the outset of section 3 of the bill. It provides that the\n               K'ómoks treaty has the force of law, reflects a core feature of modern treaty implementation\n               statutes. It gives domestic legal effect to what will become a constitutionally protected\n               agreement under section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982. That dual character, statutory and constitutional, is very important. Canadian courts,\n               including the Supreme Court of Canada in cases such as R. vs. Badger and Mikisew Cree First Nation vs. Canada , have consistently affirmed that treaties must be interpreted purposefully in a manner\n               consistent with reconciliation. However, they have also emphasized that clarity of\n               legislative intent remains essential, particularly when statutes are used to operationalize\n               treaty rights. Section 3 is not merely declaratory. It is incorporative. It transforms the treaty\n               text into enforceable domestic law. This raises an important interpretive question.\n               Is a treaty, once given the force of law under section 3, to be interpreted strictly\n               as a statute or as a constitutional instrument under section 35? The answer in practice\n               is probably both. That duality creates complexity, for courts interpreting disputes,\n               regulators applying statutory authority and proponents seeking certainty in land and\n               resource decisions. For example, a decision-maker under the Land Act must now consider the statute itself,\n               the treaty as incorporated under section 3 and the constitutional protections afforded\n               that treaty. Yet, section 3 doesn't provide guidance on how those conflicts between\n               these interpretive layers are to be resolved in administrative practice. This complexity deepens when we turn to another section which states that in the event\n               of conflict, between the treaty and provincial law, the treaty prevails. This complexity deepens when we turn to another section, which states that in the\n               event of conflict between the treaty and provincial law, the treaty prevails. This\n               clause effectively creates a statutory paramountcy regime operating alongside constitutional\n               paramountcy under section 35. Here's where the red flags are going to generate a very important conversation in\n               this House on behalf of all British Columbians. It is purposeful, not an adversarial\n               conversation, and we have to have it. We owe that to the K'ómoks People and to the others engaged in the treaty processes throughout our province,\n               as well as our diverse population and the many affected stakeholders who are watching\n               this debate on Bill 20. It raises several specific concerns. Firstly, the scope of conflict. It doesn't define\n               what constitutes a conflict. In Canadian jurisprudence, in what I have read, conflict\n               can arise in two ways — operational conflict, the impossibility of dual compliance,\n               or frustration of legislative purpose. It does not clarify which standard applies. This matters, because it determines how broadly the treaty may displace provincial\n               statutes such as the Forest Act, the Land Act, the Agricultural Land Commission Act\n               and the Local Government Act, particularly when we're talking about delegated authorities,\n               because municipalities operate under delegated authority. But the section does not address whether municipal bylaws are captured within provincial\n               law for the purposes of treaty paramountcy. This creates, again, uncertainty for local\n               governments, particularly in regions adjacent to the treaty lands, who now must determine\n               whether zoning bylaws, development permits or environmental regulations affect their\n               lands. That brings me to what I think is the most serious issue in this bill — DRIPA, UNDRIP.\n               Bill 20 embeds and relies upon the very legislative framework, British Columbia's\n               Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, or DRIPA, that is currently under\n               active legal challenge and ongoing interpretation. We are being asked to ratify a treaty intended to last generations that is explicitly\n               tied to a framework we do not yet fully understand, a framework the courts are still\n               interpreting, a framework that is, in practice, still evolving and a framework that\n               this government itself continues to grapple with in terms of implementation. Across this province, there are numerous active legal challenges, more than 20, testing\n               how DRIPA is to function. Those cases are not minor. They go to fundamental questions.\n               What does free, prior and informed consent mean in practice? How does DRIPA interact\n               with established constitutional law? What happens when multiple nations assert overlapping\n               claims? How does decision-making actually work on the ground? These are foundational\n               questions, and they have yet to be resolved. At the same time, government continues to refine its approach to DRIPA implementation.\n               In other words, we are still defining the rules. And yet, despite all of that, this\n               bill proceeds as though those rules are settled. It takes an evolving, contested and\n               not yet fully understood framework, and it hard-wires it into a modern treaty. We have yet to hear from the government why existing successful treaties were not\n               good enough in terms of the language, why we had to embed UNDRIP into this treaty.\n               Otherwise, we would all be home and be happily signing a treaty. But this is such an egregious breach of what I think anyone who was supporting the\n               treaty, the modern treaty application, could foresee. This is not a caution. This\n               is not clarity. This is legislating in the middle of a moving target. Now, to make this concrete, consider a statutory decision under the land act involving a tenure in an area adjacent to treaty lands. The decision-maker must now consider the land act, the treaty as law under section 3, the paramountcy clause under section 6, applicable regulations under sections 25 and 26, DRIPA obligations and potentially UNDRIP as an interpretive framework. This is not a simple administrative exercise. This is a complex and uncharted journey\n               in treaty-making that this government bears a fiduciary obligation to getting right\n               the first time for all British Columbians. Without clearer legislative direction, different decision-makers may reach different\n               conclusions on similar facts. That is the definition of legal uncertainty. When you\n               embed unsettled legal framework into a permanent agreement, you do not create certainty.\n               You lock in confusion. You risk conflicting interpretations, future legal disputes\n               and instability in the very agreement meant to provide clarity. And that is not fair,\n               not to the K'ómoks Nation, not to neighbouring First Nations and not, certainly, to British Columbians\n               who expect stability and transparency. Reconciliation cannot be built on ambiguity. It cannot be built on shifting interpretations.\n               And it cannot be built on a framework that is still being tested in the courts while\n               we embed it into law. That's lunacy, because uncertainty does not advance reconciliation;\n               it undermines it. Treaties are not ordinary legislation. They are meant to endure for generations. If\n               we proceed while consultation is incomplete, while overlapping claims remain unresolved\n               and the legal framework itself is unsettled, then we are not strengthening reconciliation.\n               We are now putting it at risk. If this treaty becomes a subject of a future dispute\n               or challenge, the damage will extend far beyond this one agreement. It will affect\n               confidence in every treaty that follows. Modern treaties are the way that we need to go, but we need to make sure that we are\n               doing this one particularly correctly. We have models in this province already where\n               we have had success. So I would wonder: why? What is the possible reason the government\n               has to embed UNDRIP and create this uncertainty? I'll give you another example of where I think there could be some uncertainty with\n               respect to the treaty as well. Section 18 provides the K'ómoks law-making authority within a foreshore area. This clause reflects a move towards self-government and recognition and also introduces overlapping legal authorities. The foreshore is an area typically governed by provincial jurisdiction, like the land act, the environmental statutes and the resource management framework. But this clause\n               does not define how K'ómoks' laws and provincial statutes are to be resolved when The foreshore is an area typically governed by provincial jurisdiction like the Land\n               Act, the environmental statutes and the resource management framework. But this clause\n               does not define how K'ómoks laws and provincial statutes are to be resolved when there\n               is a different, a concurrent jurisdiction that needs coordinating. Since municipalities derive their authority from the Local Government Act.... I do know\n               a little bit about municipalities. They regulate zoning and developmental permits\n               and local environmental protections. So where a municipal bylaw conflicts with a K'ómoks\n               law, does the section in that treaty render the bylaw inoperative, or is there an\n               expectation of harmonization? The bill does not explicitly address that. And that\n               does create real uncertainty for municipalities who are trying to plan infrastructure\n               or to approve large developments or to even enforce bylaws in their adjacent areas. I see we're running out of time. I would like to finish my comments before we end\n               our session today, so I will try and wrap up. At the end of the day, it's not a call to abandon the treaty. It is a call to get\n               it right. It is a call that means pause it, get some understanding of what on earth\n               is the rationale for embedding UNDRIP into a treaty when we have good examples of\n               successful models that are already working, and we have the footprint for those. I would be very interested in hearing the government explain why this, which is a\n               model for uncertainty, needs to be in this treaty. So, pause that legislation until\n               we can get some clarity around that, provide clear and transparent direction of how\n               this would ever be applied in practice while the courts are doing their work, which\n               is beyond me how that would work. Only then could we move forward with an agreement\n               that is truly durable. Welcome, Mr. Speaker. I will wind up my comments for you today. We all want reconciliation to succeed. We all want treaties to succeed. But success\n               is not going to be measured by speed. When we've had less than.... I know it has been\n               30 years, but we've only had five days. Success is not going to be measured by speed.\n               It is going to be measured by clarity, by stability and, most importantly, by trust. Right now, this bill asks us to move forward in the face of unresolved consultation,\n               overlapping claims and a legal framework that is still in flux. We can do better.\n               We must do better. We cannot hardwire uncertainty into a permanent agreement and then\n               call it reconciliation. For those reasons, I conclude my remarks and I look forward to further discussions\n               at a committee stage. I adjourn the debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721465","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act of 2026, and I shall try to do so in the absence of any lecture, any snide remarks\n               or any condescending tone. Let me begin clearly by saying that I support treaties, and I support reconciliation.\n               I have a very clear understanding of, and have worked very closely with, Indigenous\n               groups. I brought ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78d7ddd26e87eca649347008a96a3b7f5efe2d1a34171d8cfd8aacdd4774e079"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b4a1f7eae39f83efe5ef59ba1fbc91b7af24be4a8210c0408af59f40ee2a1ec2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fceca40ea868b2a5be5c7403","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752252,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in strong support of the hoist motion before this House, the\n               one that proposes a six-month delay in the advancement of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. Frankly, I would prefer the bill were killed altogether. I believe it is one more\n               of administrative management than it is of legislative flaws. But given that we are\n               where we are, at its core, I support this motion, the hoist motion. It's not about obstruction. It's not about denying progress or resisting reform. Rather,\n               it is about responsibility. It is about ensuring that when we legislate on matters\n               as fundamental as access to information and the protection of personal privacy, we\n               do so with care, with clarity and with the full confidence of the people we serve. Freedom of information and privacy rights are not abstract principles. They are foundational\n               to a functioning democracy. They shape the relationship between citizens and the state.\n               They determine how power is exercised, how decisions are scrutinized and how trust\n               is built or eroded. Bill 9 proposes significant changes to that framework. I move adjournment of the debate and reserve my right to continue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752252","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in strong support of the hoist motion before this House, the\n               one that proposes a six-month delay in the advancement of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. Frankly, I would prefer the bill were killed altogether. I believe it is one more\n               of administrative management than it is of legislative flaws. But","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6742156b337f99b9b453776950cd0e047bad8d72fc771eba70f5658a7d2b37b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61db2436a68f18a2e3015c8535fc1865acdab1030d7039e86dcb3870509dfd85"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c88b0e3ab2c9ce66f436447c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752253,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am excited to talk about the Western Hockey League, a cornerstone of Canadian\n               sport and a proving ground for some of the best young athletes in the world. Founded\n               in 1966, it was a bold idea at the time but today makes up one of three major junior\n               leagues. It has a geographic footprint that stretches from northwestern USA — Washington,\n               Oregon — and includes Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia. The league has produced countless NHL players and Olympians while always emphasizing\n               education, leadership and life skills. For many players, it's a pathway not only to\n               professional hockey but to scholarships and to careers beyond the rink. As I outline the history of the WHL, I am today particularly excited. This year's\n               draft took place last night and continues today, but the first-round picks were last\n               evening, and that was a milestone our family will not forget. Parker McMillan, our 15-year-old grandson, was chosen second overall in the first round. He will\n               be playing for the Wenatchee Wild in Washington state. As proud as we are of Parker's No. 2 pick, we share celebration with another young\n               Surrey athlete. Parker's best friend, Eli Vickers, of South Surrey, was chosen third\n               overall by the Vancouver Giants, two extraordinary top choices in this year's draft. There are hundreds of young hopefuls in this league, and to see two Surrey choices\n               in such high ranking speaks of the coaching and the commitment and the incredible\n               achievement, And both as a legislator and as a grandma, more importantly, I could\n               not be more proud.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752253","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I am excited to talk about the Western Hockey League, a cornerstone of Canadian\n               sport and a proving ground for some of the best young athletes in the world. Founded\n               in 1966, it was a bold idea at the time but today makes up one of three major junior\n               leagues. It has a geographic footprint that stretches from northwestern USA — Washington,\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ea4a317b3a8eb292b5dae38f180b0edda7b93e8f6481e1432b584e1fd7f9e7f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90d445100f4f8401c5487aeac9139539e81b0952c8a3a43451f2db8cece7db00"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b9a0381ab9678cc69bda97f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017366,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"Almost two months ago, 11 of B.C.'s leading industry groups asked the Premier to pursue\n               the same federal housing deal that Ontario got. Today, an Ontario family buying a\n               home qualifies for up to $130,000 in combined tax relief. A B.C. family buying today\n               gets nothing. But this Premier has lots of time to fight Ottawa on pipelines. Today will the minister tell British Columbians if this government will fight for\n               an equivalent deal for B.C. families, yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017366","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Almost two months ago, 11 of B.C.'s leading industry groups asked the Premier to pursue\n               the same federal housing deal that Ontario got. Today, an Ontario family buying a\n               home qualifies for up to $130,000 in combined tax relief. A B.C. family buying today\n               gets nothing. But this Premier has lots of time to fight Ottawa on pipelines. Today will the ministe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207037","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Permafrost","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pipelines","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207037","label":"Permafrost","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721988","label":"Pipelines","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6a2b2c223f8a3efc06c971361faf813dd9de95aa384ae7a146de99b44b987e30","d9c9f7cf7d85d04dab29f6062d40e7b66a1f95270b9db96e25e9174902c21da1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c3014edc76f844cc787fce6cdbc4dc936c913399130b8f7a4dd2620272b2638"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59a4a7579778533b5e4d400b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036493,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Linda Hepner","venue":"Hansard","text":"We have today visiting the precinct, an international organization called, appropriately,\n               the Dispute Resolution Corporation. They represent the fruit and vegetable industry.\n               It's a member organization, and they have members all over Canada, the U.S., Mexico,\n               South America and Europe. I just want to give a very warm welcome to them as they tour the precinct. They are not yet in the gallery, but I hope that we can give them an international\n               welcome to our House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036493","member_id":"bc-mla-404","member_name":"Linda Hepner","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We have today visiting the precinct, an international organization called, appropriately,\n               the Dispute Resolution Corporation. They represent the fruit and vegetable industry.\n               It's a member organization, and they have members all over Canada, the U.S., Mexico,\n               South America and Europe. I just want to give a very warm welcome to them as they tour the prec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef6a9a7870796c0e75753da081bb66ecba84a21f0e718f675e0b80eb1a4e2741"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1216a46fad2bf6eeb592ee76a45a5d35bf0319e64d64417ba0024d32f0db67c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-580118ff841d66e942c89218","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317124,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today with a full heart to speak in support of the Motor Vehicle Amendment\n               Act (No. 2), 2025, a bill that British Columbians will come to know as Xavier's law. I want to begin by acknowledging the incredible courage of the Rasul-Jankovics family. They have taken the unimaginable grief of losing their child and turned it into a\n               call for change, a call that has brought all of us into this chamber today with a\n               shared purpose: to make our roads safer, to protect families and to prevent another\n               tragedy. As a mother of two sons and as someone who speaks with parents, grandparents and young\n               people in my community every single day, I cannot imagine the depth of their loss.\n               But I have seen firsthand the strength of families who decide that But I have seen firsthand the strength of families who decide that heartbreak will\n               not be the final story; advocacy will be. Xavier's family did exactly that. It's because\n               of them that we are here today debating a bill that will save lives. In my riding, I often meet families who worry every time their kids walk to school,\n               cross a busy intersection or bike to a part-time job. I remember one morning meeting\n               a mom outside a local elementary school. She told me that she stands at the corner\n               most days because drivers speed through that stretch as if it was a racetrack. She\n               said: \"I just need to know that people who drive dangerously are taken off the road\n               before they hurt someone's child.\" Her words have stayed with me. This bill speaks\n               directly to parents like her, parents who just want to know their community is safe. I have spoken with young people, too, teenagers who have lost a friend to reckless\n               driving or who themselves have felt unsafe walking along roads where speeding cars\n               fly by. Their voices deserve to be heard in this chamber. Xavier's law strengthens prevention and accountability in a way that British Columbia\n               has long needed. The bill introduces an immediate 30-day driving prohibition for reckless\n               driving. That means police will now have the ability to take a dangerous driver off\n               the road right away — not after paperwork, not after a lengthy process, but in the\n               moment when it matters. That is the essence of prevention, acting before another life\n               is lost. The bill also includes a crucial requirement. Police must report every reckless driving\n               incident to the superintendent of motor vehicles. Right now, that reporting is not\n               mandatory. That means patterns of dangerous behaviour can go unnoticed. It means someone\n               can repeatedly put lives at risk and the system may not flag them until it's too late.\n               Xavier's law closes that gap. It ensures that every serious instance of reckless driving\n               is documented, sent to the superintendent and reviewed. If a longer prohibition is needed, up to 36 months under the existing Motor Vehicle\n               Act, the superintendent can take that action. This is how we keep our communities\n               safe with timely intervention, strong oversight and real accountability. This bill does not leave room for interpretation or uncertainty. It defines reckless\n               driving using clear, evidence-based criteria, which includes extreme speeding — more\n               than 40 kilometres per hour over the limit in lower speed zones, more than 50 kilometres\n               per hour over in higher speed zones or driving 150 kilometres per hour or more anywhere\n               in the province. It also includes dangerous behaviours like deliberate lack of traction, circling or\n               spinning a vehicle, street racing or even things It also includes dangerous behaviours like deliberate lock of traction, circling or\n               spinning a vehicle, street racing or even things as shocking as driving with a person\n               in the trunk. These are not harmless mistakes. These are wilful, conscious decisions\n               that put lives in danger. And this bill gives police a clear, consistent standard\n               for when they must issue a 30-day prohibition. Some people have asked why this bill creates a 30-day prohibition instead of something\n               longer. That's an important question. British Columbia already has one of the strongest\n               administrative systems in the country. The superintendent can impose driving prohibitions\n               of up to 36 months for high-risk drivers. That authority exists today. What did not\n               exist until now is the mandatory reporting and the immediate consequence at the front\n               end. Xavier's law fills that gap. Others have asked why the bill does not include lifetime driving bans. The purpose\n               of this bill is prevention, not punishment after tragedy. And a lifetime provincial\n               ban could face constitutional challenges that could weaken or overturn the legislation,\n               something none of us want, especially families who have fought so hard for change. This bill is designed to be strong, enforceable and durable. And it works hand in\n               hand with Bill C-14, the federal legislation that gives judges more authority to impose\n               driving bans when reckless driving causes death or serious harm. The most important question is this: will Xavier's law make a difference? And the\n               answer is yes. It will make a difference because it ensures no serious, reckless driving\n               incident goes unnoticed. It makes sure police can act immediately. It ensures the\n               superintendent has the information needed to keep repeat offenders off the road. And\n               it honours a family's courage by turning their advocacy into concrete, life-saving\n               action. In my own constituency office, I hear from people who want to know that government\n               is doing everything possible to protect them and their loved ones. This bill helps\n               us do exactly that. Just last year in my riding, I met two sisters, teenagers, who told me that they no\n               longer walk along a certain stretch of road because of how often they see cars racing\n               there.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317124","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today with a full heart to speak in support of the Motor Vehicle Amendment\n               Act (No. 2), 2025, a bill that British Columbians will come to know as Xavier's law. I want to begin by acknowledging the incredible courage of the Rasul-Jankovics family. They have taken the unimaginable grief of losing their child and turned it into a\n               call for change, a call that has b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","label":"Accident prevention"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","label":"Accident prevention","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5f89ac00de911c958e5b1fa9238fe0b8ae452cb6be50ae4dccfaa82ebf44b07"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ea5c12c9386f82ccbd4e22b195f82cd79c290778b47ee1772bc299d8dc38d5a3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accident prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501177","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c27ac6028f02ac24411e953","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317125,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I would like to welcome in the house Mr. Bill Basra along with his wife, Mrs.\n               Baldish Basra from Vancouver. Bill is a long-time community advocate and the past\n               president of Guru Ravidass Sabha in Burnaby. Accompanying them is Mr. Gopal Lohia, who is my constituent and an active member in\n               the community. Along with these guests is a special group of Punjabi singers visiting\n               from Punjab, India, along with their families. Would the House please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317125","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today I would like to welcome in the house Mr. Bill Basra along with his wife, Mrs.\n               Baldish Basra from Vancouver. Bill is a long-time community advocate and the past\n               president of Guru Ravidass Sabha in Burnaby. Accompanying them is Mr. Gopal Lohia, who is my constituent and an active member in\n               the community. Along with these guests is a special group of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d947f1ea364d4fb101f578351b6232ff5ec24495512028fd810cda54e822b8dd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e2f36b5e9644057c09d06f11f395430e1dbb5adfa6fbb59fc03b5d097d43e7a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-506485ceb94df529fae1dcf5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317126,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am proud to celebrate two constituents of mine, Al and Jenny Jina, who received\n               the Ed Helfrich Long-Service Award last night at the B.C. Care Providers Association\n               Care Awards ceremony. Al and Jenny Jina live in Vancouver-Langara. More than three decades ago, Al and Jenny co-founded Park Place Seniors Living with\n               a simple but powerful mission — to create homes where seniors feel valued, respected\n               and truly at home. Together, Al and Jenny have built more than seniors residences.\n               They have built communities. I would ask the House to join me in congratulating Al and Jenny for receiving this\n               award and welcome Al Jina to the House today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317126","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I am proud to celebrate two constituents of mine, Al and Jenny Jina, who received\n               the Ed Helfrich Long-Service Award last night at the B.C. Care Providers Association\n               Care Awards ceremony. Al and Jenny Jina live in Vancouver-Langara. More than three decades ago, Al and Jenny co-founded Park Place Seniors Living with\n               a simple but powerful mission — to cr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["80f8acd6231439038865c94337677e5c52e5dbea73b259f3ac8a12e74611a422"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c3b146fee3c97166490a06001f1ebafbc671b7d7130fc41ce27af739a7e726ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d5bf369ff2f398e9834b6ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327952,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Infrastructure and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327952","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Infrastructure and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6640b7dad1d0f2e963ee7606","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327953,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of\n               Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327953","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C reports progress of the estimates of the Ministry of\n               Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7724c702d35bafa4909df454ec24c9d0502782f04ed3fc693148a572fc9285cf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a807afedeaaac90ae44c44b0c935e6e0b3b06df7090650658ecc3bb7de468b7e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb31e29932fc5ed5b0c4194d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327954,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize the incredible Metro Theatre in my constituency, a historic\n               and cherished non-profit organization that has enriched the community through the\n               magic of live theatre since 1963. Thanks to the hard work of the 15-person volunteer board of directors, the Metro Theatre\n               has become a vibrant community hub in the Marpole neighbourhood. Dedicated to producing\n               high-quality performances, I had the honour of meeting Matt Ramer, Mary Cleaver, Steve Dotto, Alison Schamberger, and Jo Sears of the board, who shared the great work they do. I have also had the pleasure of attending three live shows at the Metro so far: Lend Me a Tenor ; Miss Bennet: Christmas at Pemberley ; and Nunsense . Behind every production is a remarkable group of local artists, musicians, creatives\n               and volunteers whose dedication has helped Metro Theatre thrive for decades. This past fall, one of my constituency advisors, Kayla Charchuk, was in the cast of\n               Metro's production of This past fall one of my constituency advisors, Kayla Charchuk, was in the cast of\n               Metro's production of Rent . Metro Theatre also encourages community building with its upstairs lounge completed\n               with a licensed bar and piano. The Metro holds occasional post-show receptions and\n               singalong events where patrons can connect with each other and the cast and crew after\n               shows. During the opening night reception of N u nsense , I met their talented all-women cast, as well as the director, Shel Piercy. I look forward to continuing to support the Metro Theatre. I'd love to see some of\n               my fellow MLAs join me at a show there sometime soon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327954","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize the incredible Metro Theatre in my constituency, a historic\n               and cherished non-profit organization that has enriched the community through the\n               magic of live theatre since 1963. Thanks to the hard work of the 15-person volunteer board of directors, the Metro Theatre\n               has become a vibrant community hub in the Marpole neighbourhood.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","label":"Public buildings","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","label":"Public architecture","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8bb3c1e8f60706e31a31de8e655819fc415c382f4a6e1049314ab470bd573f87"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["170bde2b7ebab9c55e1f75e8176dc4a3835903eb77aa136603aa522bae36af37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9b2aae7dd577d822a14b2109","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327955,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Education and Child Care and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327955","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Education and Child Care and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9d3953a1266b266b325fb8f0e06243c3e0fddc3ad37482ab155fd366b23e77de"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36d2ff31aa9d644ac47efdba2299152d1c966fbb057208e5c6e84777ed5a7993"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97a7f8f85e80d09839b43c81","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327956,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today with profound sadness to honour the life of Mr. Kuldip Singh Thandi, a respected community leader who passed away peacefully at the age of 80 after a\n               courageous year-long battle with cancer. Mr. Thandi devoted many years of dedicated service to the Khalsa Diwan Society Vancouver,\n               where he served with distinction as both president and treasurer. In these roles,\n               he led with integrity, humility and deep commitment to seva, selfless service, inspiring\n               all those who had the privilege to work with him. He was a remarkable organizer and a trusted voice in the community. Through his leadership\n               and generosity, he strengthened the Ross Street gurdwara and supported countless families.\n               His wisdom, kindness and willingness to serve made a lasting and meaningful difference\n               in the lives of many. Mr. Thandi's contributions to the gurdwara and to the broader community will not be\n               forgotten. His legacy of service will continue to inspire future generations. A memorial service for Mr. Kuldip Singh Thandi will be held on March 8 at 12:30 pm\n               at Riverside Funeral Home in Delta, followed by Antim Ardas prayers at 2:30 pm at\n               Ross Street gurdwara. On behalf of the Legislative Assembly and the people of Vancouver-Langara, I extend my heartfelt condolences to the family, friends and the entire community\n               during this difficult time. May Waheguru bless his soul with eternal peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327956","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today with profound sadness to honour the life of Mr. Kuldip Singh Thandi, a respected community leader who passed away peacefully at the age of 80 after a\n               courageous year-long battle with cancer. Mr. Thandi devoted many years of dedicated service to the Khalsa Diwan Society Vancouver,\n               where he served with distinction as both president and treasurer. In these r","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99e1435b703b779afbabf885aa42123baaf693238b2590495dda6795cc906be5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf9fbb3d6e1ee06306e48874","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360144,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise in this House today in support of Motion M201, which affirms our\n               commitment to clean, affordable, equitable and accessible water as a vital component\n               of Canadian sovereignty. Water is fundamental to life. It sustains our communities, supports our ecosystems\n               and shapes the identity of our province. In British Columbia, we are blessed with\n               extraordinary natural beauty Water is fundamental to life. It sustains our communities, supports our ecosystems\n               and shapes the identity of our province. In British Columbia, we are blessed with\n               extraordinary natural beauty, from majestic rivers and lakes to vibrant coastal waters.\n               Whether people are drinking from the tap, swimming in our lakes, fishing in our rivers\n               or simply enjoying the outdoors, access to clean water is an essential part of what\n               makes our province such a special place to live. Water governance in British Columbia is strong and comprehensive. The province holds\n               responsibility for natural resources, including water use and development, while the\n               federal government plays an important role when it comes to boundary and transboundary\n               waters across Canada. This shared responsibility highlights the importance of collaboration\n               and stewardship at every level of government. Our province takes a whole-of-government approach to water stewardship, with clear\n               accountability through the Ministry of Water, Land and Resource Stewardship. This\n               ensures that the protection of water resources remains the top priority for our government\n               and for the people we serve. British Columbia has several key pieces of legislation that protect and regulate water.\n               The Water Protection Act ensures that both surface water and groundwater remain owned\n               by the province and prevents large-scale diversions of water outside of British Columbia\n               or between watersheds. It also sets strict limits on the export of water in containers,\n               helping safeguard this vital resource for future generations. The Water Sustainability Act provides the framework for how water resources are managed\n               in our province. It establishes requirements for water licensing, allocation and pricing,\n               and it also gives the province the ability to redistribute water during times of scarcity. Meanwhile, the Drinking Water Protection Act ensures that operators of municipal and\n               private water systems provide safe, drinkable water to residents, with oversight provided\n               by the provincial health officer. Beyond legislation, our government uses a range of practical tools to ensure water\n               quality, affordability and accessibility. These include requirements for potable water\n               in buildings, oversight of water utility rates, strong drinking water guidelines and\n               watershed protection efforts that safeguard our rivers, lakes and ecosystems. At the same time, we must recognize the growing challenges we face. Climate change\n               is already affecting water systems across British Columbia. In recent years, drought\n               conditions have impacted many parts of the province, reminding us how critical responsible\n               water management truly is. While conditions improved in parts of the province during the summer of 2025 compared\n               to the severe droughts we saw between 2022 and 2024, recovery has not been consistent\n               everywhere. Several basins still experienced high drought levels, meaning impacts\n               to the ecosystem, communities and local economies remained of some concern. Our government continues to take action to address these challenges. Investments are\n               being made to strengthen water infrastructure and build resilience for communities,\n               farmers, fish and wildlife. We have committed significant resources to watershed protection\n               and to programs that help farmers manage water more efficiently. For the health of our communities, the protection of our ecosystem and the security\n               of our future, I'm proud to support Motion M 201.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360144","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise in this House today in support of Motion M201, which affirms our\n               commitment to clean, affordable, equitable and accessible water as a vital component\n               of Canadian sovereignty. Water is fundamental to life. It sustains our communities, supports our ecosystems\n               and shapes the identity of our province. In British Columbia, we are blessed ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["08b883b19ddd2fb8914342345475b4221f8469e93fa13a532a138dd80de45386"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5114a94cf313d28f0d001b5397bd76d55a799b3fb7336896404449f555cdc7fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-83973792a8f8c5f186b9fbf6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360145,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome a distinguished group of leaders from the Jewish community\n               who are visiting the Legislature, organized by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs,\n               also known as CIJA. These community representatives come from across Metro Vancouver, Vancouver Island\n               and other parts of our province. They're here to meet with elected leaders to discuss\n               the important work of combating hate, strengthening community safety and protecting\n               culturally appropriate services. It's my pleasure to recognize the following individuals joining us today: Nico Slobinsky,\n               Shirly Berelowitz, David Decolongon, Liam Sasky, Shir Levi-Yair, Ezra Shanken, Mijal\n               Ben Dori It's my pleasure to recognize the following individuals joining us today: Nico Slobinsky,\n               Shirly Berelowitz, David Decolongon, Liam Sasky, Shir Levi-Yair, Ezra Shanken, Mijal\n               Ben Dori, Karen James, David Fox, Stephen Shapiro, Samantha Simpson, Jeremy White,\n               Corinne Zimmerman, Aaron Devor, Anat Gogo, Ohad Gavrieli, Russ Klein, Jeff Moss, Peter\n               J. Nadler, Jaime Stein, Tanja Demajo and Raquel Hirsch. Please join me in extending a warm welcome to these respected community leaders to\n               the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360145","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome a distinguished group of leaders from the Jewish community\n               who are visiting the Legislature, organized by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs,\n               also known as CIJA. These community representatives come from across Metro Vancouver, Vancouver Island\n               and other parts of our province. They're here to meet with elected leaders to di","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b4c0d8498b99867a997439595bccdf3129c7e54e2b74d2a086473fc210f2a6d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3d68e7168cdcba2708184e193bec1f2528df7b24d314b98e3b29d0242b2128b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e1da5fde8673b54a42b3413","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415710,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Section C reports Bill 6 complete without amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415710","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Section C reports Bill 6 complete without amendment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b0941a619631c08586b44e0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415711,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Sitting in the gallery, we have engineers and geoscientists, B.C. senior Will the House please congratulate Evan on this massive achievement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415711","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Sitting in the gallery, we have engineers and geoscientists, B.C. senior Will the House please congratulate Evan on this massive achievement.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d490f25dd60c8eb9fbc5fdb00ab226978378c0bbe791d0c327560734a094412"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec65094a822c53ba71aa441b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415712,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in strong support of Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public\n               Worship Act. British Columbia is a place where diversity is not just acknowledged; it is celebrated.\n               People from all walks of life, cultures and faith traditions have come here to build\n               their lives, raise their families and contribute to the strength of our province. In my constituency of Vancouver-Langara, that diversity is something I witness every single day. We are home to vibrant and\n               deeply rooted faith communities — Sikh, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Christian, Buddhist\n               and many others — each contributing in meaningful ways to the social and cultural\n               fabric of our communities. These communities do more than gather in prayer. They serve. They give. They support\n               those in need. They build bridges across cultures. Institutions like the Khalsa Diwan\n               Society gurdwara are not only places of worship; they are pillars of community life.\n               Through langar, through outreach, through open doors, they embody the values of compassion,\n               service and inclusion. Across the Lower Mainland, synagogues such as Temple Sholom, along with mosques, temples,\n               churches and other sacred spaces, play that same essential role. They are places where\n               people come together in moments of joy and in moments of grief. They are places where\n               traditions are preserved, where children learn their values and where individuals\n               find comfort and connection. At their core, these are spaces of sanctuary. But in recent years, we have seen that sense of sanctuary come under stain. Across\n               our province and our country, there has been a troubling increase in incidents targeting\n               places of worship. We have seen vandalism, harassment and acts of intimidation. We\n               have seen demonstrations that cross a line from peaceful expression into behaviour\n               that blocks access, disrupts services and creates fear for those simply trying to\n               enter and pray. These incidents do not just impact buildings. They impact people. They create anxiety\n               for families. They make seniors hesitant. They make parents think twice before bringing\n               their children. They erode that sense of safety that should be unquestioned in a place\n               of worship. No one in British Columbia should feel that fear. No one should have to look over\n               their shoulder when walking into a gurdwara, synagogue, masjid, temple or church.\n               No one should be intimidated, harassed or prevented from practicing their faith. This is not about one community. This is about all communities. It's about ensuring\n               that every person, regardless of their religion, background or identity, can gather\n               in This is not about one community. This is about all communities. It's about ensuring\n               that every person, regardless of their religion, background or identity, can gather\n               in peace and dignity. The freedom of religion is a fundamental right in Canada. It\n               includes not only the freedom to believe but the freedom to practice openly, safely\n               and without intimidation. Bill 13 is about protecting that right in a thoughtful and balanced way. This legislation\n               establishes access zones of up to 20 metres around places of public worship. Within\n               those zones, specific behaviours are prohibited, behaviours that impede access, disrupt\n               services or intimidate individuals seeking to attend. This ensures that people can\n               enter and exit safely without obstruction or fear. At the same time, this bill respects the rights that are also fundamental to our democracy:\n               the right to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly. People will continue to\n               have that right to protest. They will continue to have the right to express their\n               views. But those rights must be exercised in a way that does not infringe on the rights\n               of others to worship safely. This legislation strikes that balance. It's focused. It's measured. And it also includes\n               important safeguards, including a sunset clause that will require review, ensuring\n               that these measures remain appropriate and proportionate over time. Places of worship are far more than physical structures. They are spaces where newcomers\n               find their footing in a new country; where language, culture and traditions are preserved\n               and shared; where elders find community and connection; where young people learn not\n               only about faith but about service, respect and belonging. They are places where people\n               come in their most vulnerable moments, in times of loss, in times of uncertainty and\n               in times of hope. And in those moments, they deserve to feel safe. When we protect access to these spaces, we are protecting something deeper: the sense\n               of belonging and dignity that defines our communities and strengthens our province\n               as a whole. Bill 13 reflects the values we share as British Columbians: respect for one another,\n               inclusion across differences and a commitment to ensuring that everyone can live free\n               from fear. It sends a clear message that in British Columbia, there is no place for\n               intimidation at the doors of our sacred spaces. I am proud to stand in support of this legislation, and I encourage all members of\n               this House to join me in supporting Bill 13 to ensure that places of worship across\n               our province remain what they are meant to be: spaces of peace, safety and community\n               for all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415712","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in strong support of Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public\n               Worship Act. British Columbia is a place where diversity is not just acknowledged; it is celebrated.\n               People from all walks of life, cultures and faith traditions have come here to build\n               their lives, raise their families and contribute to the strength of our province.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["163f4e526ce27c64f17c736f73207c7c35369e0f47da56d6f7b43400b378a59f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1de30459fad0ea69efb85669ccd892c355fc5248cdbb09f0f681b7b5f98623ad"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-384b8145a48c99badab252e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415713,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Education Week taking place across British Columbia from\n               April 7 to 10. Education Week is a time to reflect on the vital role education plays\n               in supporting young people as they learn, grow and discover their potential. It's\n               also an opportunity to celebrate the students, teachers, education assistants, counsellors,\n               administrators, school trustees and support staff who make our K-to-12 system strong\n               and vibrant. In classrooms across our province, students are building skills that will shape their\n               futures, learning to read their first book, experiencing science and technology, discovering\n               the arts and sports and developing a lifelong love of learning. These moments are\n               foundational and they're made possible by the dedication, compassion and professionalism\n               of those who support students every day. Education is about more than academics. Our schools are safe, inclusive and supportive\n               spaces where students can access opportunities, build confidence, form meaningful\n               friendships and find care and guidance when they need it most. The tragic events in Tumbler Ridge have deeply impacted communities across British\n               Columbia, reminding us of the strength, resilience and compassion within our school\n               communities, especially in difficult times. There has never been a more important\n               time to recognize and thank those who are dedicated to supporting students and strengthening\n               our education system. I invite all members of this House to join me in celebrating Education Week and the\n               many individuals who make education in British Columbia so meaningful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415713","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Education Week taking place across British Columbia from\n               April 7 to 10. Education Week is a time to reflect on the vital role education plays\n               in supporting young people as they learn, grow and discover their potential. It's\n               also an opportunity to celebrate the students, teachers, education assistants, counsellors,\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63a17e6c28a67072ba3ded2be96c4184d1c665ade7117a9fc74144741a4de530"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce73e9545bb736926a118614c1d4acdff4b969f5fe484b26f77a1c3424692948"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4f728a8f9ed9f85cbe4e5d18","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415714,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today with profound sadness to honour the life of Mrs. Ram Labhai Sarpal, a cherished and respected member of our community who passed away on March 24 at\n               the age of 82. Mrs. Sarpal leaves behind a loving and devoted family — her husband, her four children\n               and their spouses, nine grandchildren, two great-grandchildren and many extended family\n               members who will continue to carry her legacy forward. Thirty-eight years ago, she immigrated to Vancouver with her family, and together\n               with her husband, Mr. Devraj Sarpal, she built a life rooted in love, hard work and\n               determination. In 1998, they opened a clothing business on Main Street that remains\n               a valued part of our community today. She will be remembered for her gentle nature,\n               her kindness, her hospitality and the warmth she extended to everyone she met. Mrs. Sarpal was also an active and valued member of the Sunset Senior's Society, where\n               she regularly participated in weekly gatherings, making new friends and strengthening\n               community bonds. Her passing leaves a deep void, but her love and kindness will always\n               be remembered. May her soul rest in eternal peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415714","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today with profound sadness to honour the life of Mrs. Ram Labhai Sarpal, a cherished and respected member of our community who passed away on March 24 at\n               the age of 82. Mrs. Sarpal leaves behind a loving and devoted family — her husband, her four children\n               and their spouses, nine grandchildren, two great-grandchildren and many extended family\n               mem","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","label":"Clothing industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Textile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037344","label":"Textile industry","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","label":"Clothing industry","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3fd4c959ec188a09e1a616b9d65b2b5f895f8ab864c27f9dad99f4961db1d9d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df388718ca2e7d7c56abbe41741a17e67862f037aa437fda3adb831e9032c73f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aa629c10e5e76db0cfc05f7f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720271,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, Culture and Sport and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720271","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, Culture and Sport and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a57e74c16be336c801ab3080","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720276,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, Culture and Sport, reports progress on the Ministry\n               of Agriculture and Food and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720276","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, Culture and Sport, reports progress on the Ministry\n               of Agriculture and Food and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-edede7ca605ab7837a5bbcf7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721347,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize National Volunteer Week and to honour the remarkable individuals\n               who give their time, energy and compassion to strengthen communities across British\n               Columbia. Volunteers are the quiet backbone of our society. They show up in moments\n               big and small, bringing care, connection and hope to those who need it most. In my constituency office, I see this spirit every day. Dedicated volunteers support\n               community outreach, help organize local events and contribute to youth initiatives,\n               cultural celebrations and food drives, ensuring that no one feels left behind. I have also witnessed volunteers step forward in times of need, supporting newcomers\n               as they build new lives, helping families navigate challenges and offering translation\n               so that language is never a barrier to accessing support. This month at the Vancouver Vaisakhi Parade, I saw hundreds of volunteers, including\n               those from Khalsa Diwan Society, Ross Street Temple and many others come together\n               in a powerful expression of service. They prepared and shared meals with thousands\n               of attendees, embodying the spirit of generosity and community. I was especially proud\n               of the volunteers at my Vancouver-Langara constituency booth, whose warmth, patience and dedication made a lasting impression\n               on everyone who visited. To every volunteer in Vancouver-Langara and across British Columbia, thank you. Your generosity uplifts us all and reminds\n               us of the strength we find in serving one another. This National Volunteer Week, let's\n               celebrate your invaluable contributions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721347","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize National Volunteer Week and to honour the remarkable individuals\n               who give their time, energy and compassion to strengthen communities across British\n               Columbia. Volunteers are the quiet backbone of our society. They show up in moments\n               big and small, bringing care, connection and hope to those who need it most. In my constituency ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28c8ee86cfe256f12db000786e994916656a44b379c7e6a919ce8df7a37d92db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cb25e900234bf984160d1a482bf056b79f56cc2be325a1470ca7bf21d0ab3bb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-231ab83a37b591d53f8d4151","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721348,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721348","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9216a0bace12f17dffe3c1ee87886dd800e7d98a00679f7287e403d24401b294"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7f02206e3804430cbf09f9b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721351,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery I have a very special guest, a proud husband, a very proud dad\n               and an even prouder longshoreman and union worker, my darling husband Navdeep. I want to take a moment to thank him for his support. It's not easy being married\n               to this job, and I could not do it without you. May the House please make him feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721351","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today in the gallery I have a very special guest, a proud husband, a very proud dad\n               and an even prouder longshoreman and union worker, my darling husband Navdeep. I want to take a moment to thank him for his support. It's not easy being married\n               to this job, and I could not do it without you. May the House please make him feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:105858","label":"Industrial development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dc56d4e092811a4fee4ece856a6aae8e741f075d158092b3140595d9d14e1760"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fcbd9042c9e3bd210e2172e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721353,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery we have my friend and volunteer, Mr. Ali Sapdari. Ali is a well-known\n               volunteer among our caucus. He is currently studying political science at Langara\n               College and hopes to transition into something new in the near future. He also serves\n               as a student representative on Langara College's board of governors. Ali is joined today by his cousins. I hope the House will make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721353","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today in the gallery we have my friend and volunteer, Mr. Ali Sapdari. Ali is a well-known\n               volunteer among our caucus. He is currently studying political science at Langara\n               College and hopes to transition into something new in the near future. He also serves\n               as a student representative on Langara College's board of governors. Ali is joined today by his ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a70ccc1a5a098abd1d417462a148fcf83fff68abc34945d6af470f4af4b7e15d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19a91c2776434d4ad040d3fa88fc2685793ff594be216ee90547462e1faa1b8e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-705d479666b9534b9357ad43","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729017,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I'm pleased to rise today to speak to Motion 205 in support of the amendment made\n               by the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729017","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Madam Speaker. I'm pleased to rise today to speak to Motion 205 in support of the amendment made\n               by the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035812","label":"Indigenous culture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90862f7b73fab897a3dedb8cc8b0621021a4804f466dcc97f822f02e6be093ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8924c1accc55b5e809d9695","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729020,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we have a group of representatives from Fairleigh Dickinson University, Vancouver\n               campus. They're extremely excited to announce their new campus coming to the Oakridge\n               centre mall in Vancouver this year. They're also meeting with all members to introduce\n               the humanics program in health care, which combines data and technology with empathy,\n               creativity, critical thinking and so on. Please welcome Michael Avotroni, Benjamin Rifkin, Mark Chiarello, Lester D. Guzman,\n               Ramin Shadmir and Seth Ali. Let's give them a warm welcome in the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729020","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today we have a group of representatives from Fairleigh Dickinson University, Vancouver\n               campus. They're extremely excited to announce their new campus coming to the Oakridge\n               centre mall in Vancouver this year. They're also meeting with all members to introduce\n               the humanics program in health care, which combines data and technology with empathy,\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4d644d3a28f783697511e117c4816554bd9dd54798593dbee057d7cf4d864ca"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d2151611cc69011c3b6473f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752217,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"There are very few places in life where I feel like I leave a piece of my heart behind","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752217","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"There are very few places in life where I feel like I leave a piece of my heart behind","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3e79d3471fbde82f2a1b58561407070876e436f10612afe1e5324e453d25ab08"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5feddff1d1d50487d917049e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752218,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Health and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752218","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Committee of Supply, Section C, reports resolution and completion of the estimates\n               of the Ministry of Health and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f94f09f21f9eab2fd357b680","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752219,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Labour and asks leave to sit again.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752219","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Committee of Supply, Section C, reports progress on the estimates of the Ministry\n               of Labour and asks leave to sit again.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f13eddaffbb27ef612793baac8aac6fb84906496933b8a19bba2744d6ca71aa0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2b1d90cbee89e199aca8996a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752220,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize May 6 as Naturopaths Day in British Columbia, as officially\n               proclaimed by the province, and to acknowledge the important role naturopathic doctors\n               play in supporting the health and well-being of people across our province. Naturopathic doctors are highly trained, regulated health professionals who complete\n               extensive post-secondary education and clinical training before entering practice.\n               Many British Columbians rely on them for ongoing patient-centred care, including prevention,\n               chronic disease management and support for complex health needs. Their work reflects key priorities of our health care system, helping people stay\n               well, supporting continuity of care and complementing the broader network of providers\n               delivering care across the province. In rural and remote communities, naturopathic doctors are pivotal in providing increased\n               access to care for patients. British Columbia has been at the forefront of regulating\n               naturopathic doctors in Canada, reflecting a long-standing commitment to ensuring\n               safe, qualified and accountable care for patients. Today is an opportunity to recognize the contributions of naturopathic doctors and\n               the important role they play in supporting healthier communities across British Columbia. I would also like to congratulate the association of British Columbia Naturopathic\n               Doctors on their leadership and ongoing commitment to patient care and community well-being.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752220","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize May 6 as Naturopaths Day in British Columbia, as officially\n               proclaimed by the province, and to acknowledge the important role naturopathic doctors\n               play in supporting the health and well-being of people across our province. Naturopathic doctors are highly trained, regulated health professionals who complete\n               extensive post-second","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3006d681f5019f889c57d9ea0694f19e5b5f0f16d148fe7ee9ff2810e9bfb105"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6340fc2052c389a983490b5a672fed086265e67f11b75fa0e66f632671e9c7c9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65219fbaa6c4ff7c64f38cac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752221,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"May is Child Care Month in British Columbia, a time to recognize and thank the dedicated\n               early childhood educators and child care providers who are at the heart of our child\n               care system. It's also a time to reflect on the important role child care plays in\n               our lives, our communities and our economy. When child care is strong, families are\n               stronger and communities thrive. Tomorrow, on Child Care Provider Appreciation Day, we have an opportunity to thank\n               those who show up every day with patience, care and commitment for our youngest learners.\n               They make a meaningful difference in the lives of children, parents, caregivers and\n               families across British Columbia. In the early years, children learn through play, relationships and guidance. They\n               build confidence, learn to share, solve problems and begin to understand who they\n               are and where they belong. These experiences last a lifetime. This work is made possible\n               by early childhood educators and child care providers, professionals who offer not\n               only supervision but comfort, reassurance and stability at a critical stage of development.\n               They also support parents and caregivers in pursuing their work and goals, knowing\n               their children are safe and well cared for. I know from experience that without access to quality, inclusive child care, families,\n               especially women, face real barriers to full participation in the workforce and community\n               life. So tomorrow I encourage all members of this House to take a moment to recognize\n               and thank child care providers for the role they play in shaping children's early\n               development and supporting families every day.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":null}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752221","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"May is Child Care Month in British Columbia, a time to recognize and thank the dedicated\n               early childhood educators and child care providers who are at the heart of our child\n               care system. It's also a time to reflect on the important role child care plays in\n               our lives, our communities and our economy. When child care is strong, families are\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","label":"Daycare","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4477de00c6b978535af4fb3d882695c290100bd8fd225791f9b0b49dfd10702"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d61d0989c952b1104315df5459c57778574708fe18ec0d1c3e468b8c904cb8e6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Daycare","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034776","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c87ed18407a9b1ddcb6b4f83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752222,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I would like to pay tribute to Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, lovingly remembered as Babasaheb Ambedkar, a visionary leader whose lifelong fight for inequality, injustice and human dignity continues to inspire generations\n               around the world. Born into a marginalized community and facing discrimination throughout his life,\n               Dr. Ambedkar rose to become one of the most influential social reformers in history.\n               He's best known as the principal architect of the Constitution of India, for his tireless work to end caste discrimination and advance the rights of marginalized communities, women and workers. He believed\n               deeply in the power of education, inclusion and equal opportunities for all. In Vancouver, the legacy of Babasaheb lives on through the dedication and service\n               of community organizations and leaders who continue to promote the teachings and values.\n               I would especially like to recognize Chetna Association of Canada and Shri Guru Ravidass Sabha Vancouver Gilley temple for their important work in bringing communities together, preserving\n               cultural heritage and advancing social harmony and empowerment. As we honour Babasaheb Ambedkar, let us recommit ourselves to building communities\n               rooted in compassion, equality and dignity for all. His legacy is not only part of\n               history; it remains a guiding light for a more just and inclusive future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752222","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I would like to pay tribute to Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, lovingly remembered as Babasaheb Ambedkar, a visionary leader whose lifelong fight for inequality, injustice and human dignity continues to inspire generations\n               around the world. Born into a marginalized community and facing discrimination throughout his life,\n               Dr. Ambedkar rose to become one of the most influentia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e1474da8ee419ae5d305a058da8a9388f0b2ac874b58cd668b20c073bb9a539b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2a533ec31ac423d77573a7de2f2f3c487f54336a915b37bcb0522449c50c037d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2edc409426e6130bedd14434","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017261,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today with great pride to recognize and celebrate the incredible work of Marpole\n               Oakridge Family Place, as they mark 48 years of caring for and supporting families\n               in our community. It was truly a joy for me to visit Marpole Oakridge Family Place\n               on May 8, during the anniversary celebration, present a certificate of appreciation\n               and meet with the children, families and seniors attending the many programs offered\n               there. From the moment I walked through the doors, I felt the warmth, kindness, and sense\n               of belonging that make this place so special. Seeing children smiling and singing,\n               families connecting and seniors gathering together was deeply heartwarming. What began in a private living room in 1978 has grown into a trusted and welcoming\n               community hub for children, parents, caregivers, seniors and vulnerable adults. Through\n               family programs, literacy initiatives and senior support services, Marple Oakridge\n               Family Place continues to uplift and strengthen lives every single day. I also appreciated the opportunity to tour the facility last year and speak with community\n               leaders about the growing needs of seniors and families in South Vancouver. Those\n               conversations reminded me how important it is that we continue working together to\n               build strong, connected and caring communities. Thank you to Executive Director Tracy\n               Beshara, Senior Outreach Coordinator Andrea Krombein, Program Coordinator Lindy Clarke,\n               dedicated staff, volunteers and everyone who helps make this organization such a treasured\n               part of our neighbourhood.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017261","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today with great pride to recognize and celebrate the incredible work of Marpole\n               Oakridge Family Place, as they mark 48 years of caring for and supporting families\n               in our community. It was truly a joy for me to visit Marpole Oakridge Family Place\n               on May 8, during the anniversary celebration, present a certificate of appreciation\n               an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a04bde40feada0daa1e6fd19e652d1304bfcbca84f12a9e1120088fb3bde20bf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["717fd57db109719b19ff4bda7102ded9baf5bfbbb83a179fc0203e360c0f92fe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c4f71166db5f82f34370f6fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017267,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek a leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017267","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek a leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment abroad","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035045","label":"Employment abroad","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28969989ccf2fd66e67adf233e41c9bf3b6df8eefb716280145212ff2c9cc417"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9eb4a5b0e437371a4e06d79a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036452,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery, I have some special guests. Without them, I would not be here,\n               literally. I have my parents. My dad, Dr. Prem Jethi, is a retired agriculture officer,\n               and my mom, Mrs. Surjit Kaur Jethi, she's a retired principal of a high school. The\n               values that are needed for this job — kindness, service, hard work — are taught by\n               my parents. Along with them is my little sister, Monika Dhir, and my brother-in-law Sundeep Dhir.\n               Monika and Sundeep have been through thick and thin with me, and they have supported\n               every decision, right or wrong, that I have taken in my life. I'm very happy to see\n               them here today. I welcome the House to make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036452","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the gallery, I have some special guests. Without them, I would not be here,\n               literally. I have my parents. My dad, Dr. Prem Jethi, is a retired agriculture officer,\n               and my mom, Mrs. Surjit Kaur Jethi, she's a retired principal of a high school. The\n               values that are needed for this job — kindness, service, hard work — are taught by\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c6fb4a65635b1eca357bed9ec9c4899a17aad3cc048a6a2920b91fca78410cd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ed7711480663b7696e0a8b911408630f5a4f6b58a2fb26297f8d3980b319e3d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7bc13b240a4a588bf42a4964","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036454,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize an outstanding young leader from Vancouver-Langara, Jasmine Corso Dee. She's a student at J.W. Sexsmith Elementary School and she is\n               one of 2025 Heritage Fair National Showcase winners, one of only four students in\n               Canada and the only student in British Columbia. Her award-winning project, The Militant Mothers of Raymur, tells the powerful story\n               of Vancouver mothers who fought really hard to build a safer railway crossing for\n               their children to travel to school in 1971 in Vancouver's Strathcona neighbourhood.\n               Her thoughtful research and presentation won her this prestigious award, and we are\n               all very proud of her. The whole House congratulates you on your national award. Thank you so much, and congratulations,\n               Jasmine.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036454","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize an outstanding young leader from Vancouver-Langara, Jasmine Corso Dee. She's a student at J.W. Sexsmith Elementary School and she is\n               one of 2025 Heritage Fair National Showcase winners, one of only four students in\n               Canada and the only student in British Columbia. Her award-winning project, The Militant Mothers of Raymur, tells the powerful st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34d160351bf09f9c17de1a62","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036455,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today is my dear friend David Berson who is a tireless advocate for\n               the Jewish community in British Columbia. I really value his friendship, support and guidance so I can serve my constituents\n               better in Vancouver-Langara. Please make my friend David Berson very welcome here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036455","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery today is my dear friend David Berson who is a tireless advocate for\n               the Jewish community in British Columbia. I really value his friendship, support and guidance so I can serve my constituents\n               better in Vancouver-Langara. Please make my friend David Berson very welcome here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6762c2d3adda8616bda474a9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036456,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sunita Dhir","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the gallery today is my dear friend Raju Bhattrai. He is the president of Nepal\n               Cultural Society of B.C. He's here with his fellow Nepali Canadians to celebrate the historic Nepali heritage\n               day proclamation event today. Please welcome Raju and his friends in the House today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036456","member_id":"bc-mla-405","member_name":"Sunita Dhir","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In the gallery today is my dear friend Raju Bhattrai. He is the president of Nepal\n               Cultural Society of B.C. He's here with his fellow Nepali Canadians to celebrate the historic Nepali heritage\n               day proclamation event today. Please welcome Raju and his friends in the House today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","label":"National heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","label":"National heritage","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6bb7c14b976f78cc1a4fcf5716a493cae6b310c3ffd0846dcdbdc774ae151ebe"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d180c117ef9f159d2e13f0d9054da541907a597afc7e8ea0b0659aa5ca9469b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"National heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036384","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b36a7170487130020d1d36d","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187101,"date":"2026-03-04T12:00:00+00:00","title":"RESIDENTIAL TENANCY AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov11-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov11-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187101","member_id":"bc-mla-406","member_name":"Christine Boyle","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42f87264db1494f8892d22fc","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187102,"date":"2026-03-04T12:00:00+00:00","title":"RESIDENTIAL TENANCY AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov11-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov11-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187102","member_id":"bc-mla-406","member_name":"Christine Boyle","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e22f93b56d1f43b5ee1710b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413665,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Christine Boyle","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill now be read a second time. The policy outcome under this bill provides new tools to more effectively respond\n               to urgent health and safety issues in supportive housing through amendments to the\n               Residential Tenancy Act. Although serious safety incidents are rare, when they occur, supportive housing operators\n               need the right tools to quickly de-escalate and address risks. The amendments are\n               designed to keep tenants, guests and staff safe, which is critical to continuing the\n               important work of addressing homelessness and helping people find stability in their\n               lives. Tenants will continue to have protections under the RTA and through the residential\n               tenancy branch's dispute resolution process, which was a priority for government as\n               well as groups engaged. The bill contains provisions that are specific to supportive housing, including creating\n               a new reason to end tenancy if a tenant or their guest possesses a weapon on the supportive\n               housing property or a weapon is found in a tenant's rental unit; and enabling regulations\n               to allow housing providers to temporarily relocate tenants to de-escalate situations\n               when there are significant health and safety risks to other tenants, guests or staff. Beyond supportive housing, the bill clarifies the applicability of the RTA by creating\n               a new authority to designate specific addresses as transitional housing. The bill\n               also builds on existing eviction provisions to better protect workers and guests on\n               all rental properties. Everyone deserves a safe place to live and work. This bill is a critical step towards\n               improving safety and stability for people who live and work in supportive housing\n               across British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413665","member_id":"bc-mla-406","member_name":"Christine Boyle","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that the bill now be read a second time. The policy outcome under this bill provides new tools to more effectively respond\n               to urgent health and safety issues in supportive housing through amendments to the\n               Residential Tenancy Act. Although serious safety incidents are rare, when they occur, supportive housing operators\n               need the right tools to qui","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5d8afb61d3cd8fc949f37e139c9c4b0eca56d0817db07c04bc8abae50ab13f86"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22100f5236914535cc3868ddd8a6fc10cf3fea1dab9bb1ca0e163c922d37a779"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-36c6015195b2628dfd0518ce","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187113,"date":"2026-04-02T12:00:00+00:00","title":"HOUSING AND MUNICIPAL AFFAIRS \nSTATUTES (CODES OF CONDUCT) \nAMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov17-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov17-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187113","member_id":"bc-mla-406","member_name":"Christine Boyle","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb70bd01bfb365177c426465","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187114,"date":"2026-04-02T12:00:00+00:00","title":"HOUSING AND MUNICIPAL AFFAIRS STATUTES (PARENTAL LEAVE) AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov18-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov18-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187114","member_id":"bc-mla-406","member_name":"Christine Boyle","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-068e7df527f85530bc13ade0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316807,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to begin by thanking God, our Creator, for the land on which we stand\n               and for the incredible resources with which he has endowed this great province. This budget is a complete fail. Of course, it is because it is rooted in socialism,\n               wealth redistribution and handouts to special interest groups and useless ideological\n               endeavours. It's a mockery to even call it a budget. It really should be called the diary of a\n               shopping addict. A budget should, by definition, contain the estimates of expenditures for the coming\n               year and proposals for financing them. Well, we see the spending plan, but what is\n               so sorely missing is the proposals for financing them. The fundamental problem we have in B.C. is the tanking of our natural resources industries.\n               Don't tell me that new shared projects with chiefs and councils are the ticket out\n               of this problem. These projects do not solve the problem at all. These groups are not using their own\n               money for these projects. They are using the money of other British Columbians, the\n               other 99 percent, who are the taxpayers of this province. These are more big government\n               projects. We need new capital to come into this province, not money that comes yet again from\n               the wallets of British Columbians. Herein lies the problem. Capital is not flocking\n               to this province. In fact, it is fleeing due to nine years of socialism. Over-taxation,\n               over-regulation and never-ending consultations and erosion of private property rights\n               have created a hostile environment for business. This is a problem that will take\n               years to resolve, perhaps over a decade. The Premier and the ministers can repeat the slogans as often as they want. But ask\n               any British Columbian: are they better off today than they were five years ago? Are\n               taxes any lower? Is disposable income any higher? Is health care more accessible?\n               Is life getting better? Are you feeling optimistic, or are you thinking about moving\n               to greener pastures? Has anything gotten better? I have been touring the province and speaking to hundreds of British Columbians, and\n               what I hear from them is a resounding \"no.\" The NDP, particularly The NDP, particularly under the current administration, is financially incompetent\n               and understands nothing about wealth creation. Flagrant abuse and waste of taxpayers'\n               money never gets checked or punished. The money flows regardless of whether the expenditure\n               or program yields net benefits to British Columbians. The gravy train never stops. They only care about wealth redistribution, regardless of how failed that approach\n               has been proven throughout history. Every left-wing administration believes it can\n               successfully implement socialist principles in a way that will finally work, but it\n               never ever does. Take from Peter to pay Paul, and hope that Peter never runs out of\n               money or stops working himself or simply leaves the country. This is a failed and\n               miserable formula. The key is wealth creation, attracting job creators and getting\n               government off the backs of the people. We need to reject the politics of jealousy, resentment and class warfare, but this\n               government has doubled down on high taxes, bloated bureaucracy, waste and useless,\n               costly ideological programs. And what has all of this led to? A record deficit of\n               $13.3 billion, a record debt of $154 billion, a record debt projection of $235.5 billion\n               by 2028 and our debt-to-GDP ratio crossing the 30 percent threshold for the first\n               time in over 40 years. Let's not forget that the last time it crossed this threshold, we had interest rates\n               that were soaring to 25 percent in this province, so it wasn't a surprise that it\n               was happening at that time. That was due to the United States implementing policies\n               under Paul Volcker and Ronald Reagan to correct the massive inflationary trend that\n               was existing at that time. We are nowhere near that situation, yet here we are. Crossing\n               this 30 percent threshold will undoubtedly lead to a fifth — fifth — consecutive credit\n               downgrade for British Columbia. These are not records that win medals. These are numbers that are crushing this province.\n               It is worth pointing out — and this is shocking — that California, a state with seven\n               times our population, is projecting a deficit of only $4 billion in Canadian dollars.\n               This is outrageous. We are running a deficit that is 330 percent larger than that\n               of California. As a result of these appalling numbers, our total debt-servicing payments, interest\n               alone — this isn't any principal payments; this is just interest — are now the third-largest\n               line item in the provincial budget. The government is running out of rich people to\n               tax, so now it goes on to this: raising the personal tax bracket for the lowest income\n               people from 5.06 percent to 5.6 percent. They are expanding the PST, charging PST\n               on things like shoe repairs, knitting wool, accounting and architectural expenses\n               for small firms, bookkeeping. All of this will just increase the cost of living in\n               B.C. There was no more room to tax people anymore. There was no more room. We already taxed\n               into oblivion. If this government actually took public finances seriously, maybe we\n               could actually lower taxes rather than constantly burning British Columbia with higher\n               costs from the government. What this budget is completely missing is any effort at rooting out waste and inefficiencies.\n               Why didn't this government create an office along the lines of DOGE that we saw in\n               the United States? Zero effort is put into finding waste and excesses. Why? In the coming days, I will be starting to highlight areas where there is massive waste\n               in this province. No one runs a household or a business like this. The government\n               is being irresponsible with taxpayers' money. For example, a quick review of some groups that are being funded.... Apparently, the\n               government is funding numerous environmental groups that use that funding to work\n               to shut down our resource extraction industries, the very industries that have supported\n               this province in an incredible lifestyle over the last 100 years. These are the very policies that got us into the dire economic situation we are in.\n               I repeat. This budget is a failure, and it is a lost opportunity to do a serious course\n               correction. No business, no family could run this way. It's too bad that the Premier and his Finance Minister couldn't find their spines\n               and do the right thing. As a final point, I am truly sorry to the people in my riding, the riding of Vancouver-Quilchena, who will once again be hit hard with an increase to the school tax, a tax that was As a final point, I am truly sorry to the people in my riding, the riding of Vancouver-Quilchena, who will once again be hit hard with an increase to the school tax, a tax that was\n               so cynically imposed on the ridings of Vancouver-Quilchena and Vancouver–Point Grey by this Premier right after he got elected. I am sorry to you because I know that\n               this tax will hit you on your homes and you will receive absolutely nothing in return.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316807","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I would like to begin by thanking God, our Creator, for the land on which we stand\n               and for the incredible resources with which he has endowed this great province. This budget is a complete fail. Of course, it is because it is rooted in socialism,\n               wealth redistribution and handouts to special interest groups and useless ideological\n               endeavours. It's a moc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["06ebfcfde6820dd9bf76d48b3348dd5af985b9f92ca85ef59d5ddcf4f6dfff65"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["408db7952999ac20bcdb0e09c46e7af2627c001dcb351c685ea0d3c7493a4c77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2fe0282b8e145b2d07e91ae2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327922,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and happy birthday. Next to the right of liberty, the right of property is the most important individual\n               right of all. United with the right of personal liberty, private property has contributed\n               more to the growth of civilization than any other institution established by the human\n               race. To my mind, these statements are a given, impossible to contradict or even challenge,\n               statements that are so obviously true that it would seem impossible that they need\n               reinforcing or that this Legislature would need reminding. But alas, it is time that\n               these fundamental concepts be once again proclaimed. Personal liberties and private\n               property rights are being everywhere infringed by government. Why is this dangerous to our way of life? Why should we care about private property?\n               These questions may seem silly, but my observation in this Legislature is that more\n               and more private property rights are not being as forcefully defended as they must\n               be and that although much lip service is paid, very little is actually being done\n               to draw a bright line around this cornerstone of our entire system. The great economist Milton Friedman said: \"Nobody spends someone else's money as carefully\n               as he spends his own. So if you want efficiency and effectiveness, if you want knowledge\n               to be properly utilized, you have to do it through the means of private property.\"\n               On the other side of the spectrum, Karl Marx said this: \"The theory of communism may\n               be summed up in one sentence — abolish all private property.\" We find ourselves drifting or being pulled towards land collectivization and communism.\n               We must fight this trend with all we've got. I am speaking to thousands of British\n               Columbians who are deeply concerned about their ability to retain full control over\n               the property they bought with their hard-earned money. We, as legislators, need to\n               dedicate ourselves to fighting for these British Columbians who are losing faith in\n               the government's ability to protect their private property. This should not be about partisan politics. Property rights are so fundamental they\n               should transcend the political persuasion of reasonable people. I invite all members\n               of the House to unify in a renewed and forceful defence of private property.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327922","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and happy birthday. Next to the right of liberty, the right of property is the most important individual\n               right of all. United with the right of personal liberty, private property has contributed\n               more to the growth of civilization than any other institution established by the human\n               race. To my mind, these statements are a given, i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85c9a418a93a17a7f6154690b6463175cc1afca498bd546cb81c5b812b67c45a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73db1d269e75460fd9f2be7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359640,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"We have heard many questions over the past week about the Musqueam Indian Band agreement\n               and the impact it will have on private property rights and title, but what has not\n               been discussed as yet is the remainder of the land and waterways that are covered\n               by this agreement that have been carefully developed, maintained and paid for by the\n               taxpayers of British Columbia over the past 100-plus years. These include parks, sports fields, schools, hospitals, beaches, seawalls, foreshores,\n               bike paths, pools, streets, sidewalks, boulevards, bridges, community centres, museums,\n               city halls, fire halls, police stations, power stations, courthouses, lighting, sewers,\n               water mains, traffic controls, ocean markers, lighthouses, wharves, docks, boathouses,\n               gas barges, naval reserves, breakwaters and on and on. All of this will now be under the decision-making authority of Chief Wayne Sparrow\n               and his family, a man who is essentially becoming a king under this agreement. My question to the Premier is this. Is he willing to stand up for British Columbia\n               and admit that this agreement has now gone too far?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359640","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We have heard many questions over the past week about the Musqueam Indian Band agreement\n               and the impact it will have on private property rights and title, but what has not\n               been discussed as yet is the remainder of the land and waterways that are covered\n               by this agreement that have been carefully developed, maintained and paid for by the\n               t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Monarchy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018525","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundary waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Waterways","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018525","label":"Boundary waters","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","label":"Monarchy","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945736","label":"Waterways","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0987279914bcc5b56e753fcf46cbdcd8dd04785e39103a17284f67d9f49fc73e","41ef783b4f795a9bcd441a30fd3770224a4477fd698863406771cec0e981d7af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50290af78c0c9d12bb09871c0687708442b4ce4d4ae907e08d68b9a6bb28b16d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-35c3ad2af5b537af0591320c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359641,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm being repeatedly now attacked personally and subjected to hatred by a member\n               on the other side of the House. It's ironic that right now we are discussing hatred\n               directed at people when I'm engaging in my job as a legislator and representing points\n               of view in this province that want to be represented. If you can't catch, then don't\n               pitch. I would like this member to retract the personal comments he keeps hurling at me in\n               the context of making — whatever he's doing today — this defence of comments on this\n               motion. This is way off topic, and he's using this as an opportunity to once again\n               come after me. And it has become an obsession.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359641","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm being repeatedly now attacked personally and subjected to hatred by a member\n               on the other side of the House. It's ironic that right now we are discussing hatred\n               directed at people when I'm engaging in my job as a legislator and representing points\n               of view in this province that want to be represented. If you can't catch, then don't\n               pit","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["45f915ff2bb4279a61df2410ee8788bf016703141fe4cd1ce9d13655a1966f53"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02f403b639108c2812481222","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721229,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to commend the MLA from Surrey–Serpentine River for one of the most amazing speeches I've ever heard on freedom of information. I rise today to speak also against Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendment Act. This bill is everything one might expect from this, the\n               most secretive and sneaky government in B.C.'s history and worse. This is the government\n               that ran on a promise of openness, and we see constantly, over and over again, closedness,\n               secrets, faits accompli, done deals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721229","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to commend the MLA from Surrey–Serpentine River for one of the most amazing speeches I've ever heard on freedom of information. I rise today to speak also against Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Amendment Act. This bill is everything one might expect from this, the\n               most secretive and sneaky government in B.C.'s history and worse. Th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ef8e866859eb4194903cb9a17de1add5b01ddd5dd771b1abf68ecdbdd04512f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["088a4758afbe60fab9b04b458bdb1f89b4cf90570cb1a203fce5b2efdc5f0139"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-30a64afd658f6072e2c41d25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721231,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"DRIPA is one of the most contentious pieces of legislation this province has ever\n               passed, and it's fair to say that until late last year almost nobody in B.C. even\n               knew about DRIPA and its profound implications for our lives. The Premier keeps saying\n               that there will be chaos and blockades if we touch DRIPA in any way. The Premier is\n               basically telling us that we are being held hostage and must submit to these demands\n               in their entirety or else. This represents a shocking lack of leadership. It is astonishing\n               that we are even in this position. Here's how seriously unbalanced this whole situation is. Indian lobby groups are lined\n               up on one side of the table, and the NDP government is sitting right alongside seemingly\n               agreeing with each and every demand. It appears that there was no one at the table\n               speaking for the rest of the people in British Columbia. My question to the Premier is this. While the Premier is cowering before the reconciliation\n               elite, who is at the table advocating for the rest of B.C.? Is there anyone in the\n               room at that table saying no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721231","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"DRIPA is one of the most contentious pieces of legislation this province has ever\n               passed, and it's fair to say that until late last year almost nobody in B.C. even\n               knew about DRIPA and its profound implications for our lives. The Premier keeps saying\n               that there will be chaos and blockades if we touch DRIPA in any way. The Premier is\n               basic","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63434192dba81a8b748c1dec771b31d47f4fe46d26fe410a03c2b2901e7478f4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["df4be46772d751cb4bb0f4442c3882a56dbc178a426bab4a0e01df677abaa062"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d8c40efd47bdc64be668d9c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728839,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today on a matter of privilege under Standing Order 26. I believe that my ability to function as a member of the Legislative Assembly has\n               been directly obstructed by the actions of an administrative body, namely the Vancouver\n               school board. Recently, my constituency office booked a public facility managed by\n               the VSB, the auditorium of Prince of Wales Secondary School, which is in my constituency.\n               I'm holding a town hall there to deal with private property rates, because I've been\n               inundated with letters from my constituents about this matter. The meeting was intended to fulfill my primary mandate to hear from the people I represent\n               and to discuss matters of importance to my constituents. Despite a confirmed booking,\n               the VSB unilaterally cancelled this event suddenly on late Friday night, and it's\n               supposed to happen this Saturday. This is not a mere contract dispute. It is an act\n               of deplatforming an elected official and a deliberate barrier of place between a member\n               and their constituents. I note that the letter sent to me by the VSB was not signed by anyone, let alone a\n               person in authority. So it is impossible to know whether the cancellation letter is\n               even legitimate, and clearly, someone is trying to avoid being named in this letter. Parliamentary privilege exists to ensure that members can perform their functions\n               without fear of interference or intimidation. By denying access to taxpayer-funded\n               public space for the express purpose of a political town hall, the VSB is effectively\n               silencing the dialogue between the provincial government and the citizens of Vancouver-Quilchena. When an administrative board, which derives its authority from provincial legislation,\n               acts to suppress the work of an elected member of that same province, it constitutes\n               a contempt of the constitutional role of this House. The VSB decision sets a dangerous precedent. If a school board can decide which MLAs\n               are allowed to speak in public halls based on outside pressure, then no member in\n               this House is truly free to serve their community. It is without question that VSB\n               must abide by the principle of neutrality in circumstances such as this. It is not\n               acceptable for any MLA, regardless of party, to be denied the use of public buildings\n               for MLA functions. Mr. Speaker, I move that this matter be referred to the Select Standing Committee\n               on Parliamentary Reform, Ethical Conduct, Standing Orders and Private Bills to investigate\n               this interference in my constituency role and to reaffirm that the rights of an MLA\n               to assemble with their constituents must remain inviolable and free from administrative\n               censorship. I have provided your office with the correspondence from the Vancouver school board\n               detailing their cancellation, along with all the details of the contract we had signed\n               and paid for in advance. We have had over 5,000 pieces of literature dropped by volunteers\n               to avoid the expense of mailing it out. So we didn't have to pay for it. We've had\n               volunteers dropping letters specifically to people's doors. It's supposed to happen\n               this Saturday. I have two esteemed guests coming to speak, two high-profile lawyers from British\n               Columbia. I can't believe this is happening. I ask that you find a prima facie case of breach of privilege.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728839","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today on a matter of privilege under Standing Order 26. I believe that my ability to function as a member of the Legislative Assembly has\n               been directly obstructed by the actions of an administrative body, namely the Vancouver\n               school board. Recently, my constituency office booked a public facility managed by\n               the VSB, the auditorium of Prince of Wa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6fdb64573dbbe3989ad5ecf0e332c0b69d959881b5dbfbb135fa084f85a9e68"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1c87bd1ac144756b5dcaddf86465ada837793b39a2876199c974a1924aa368a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7addab1566670b379fe671c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752180,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"I sit here week in and week out while the opposition asks about cuts to seniors beds\n               and autism funding. Both are very unfortunate, I agree, but these questions are missing\n               the larger point. The point is that we are in a financial crisis in this province, a $13.3 billion deficit\n               and a debt of over $155 billion and five credit downgrades. We are broke. We are bankrupt.\n               And it's a crisis of choice. The NDP is incapable of spending discipline. It seems\n               like I am the only one in this building who sees that spending is completely out of\n               control and that drastic cuts are needed. For example, why haven't mandate letters been written to every ministry demanding\n               at least a 20 percent cut or waste discovery? The Finance Minister and her many employees\n               should be working around the clock to save taxpayers money. Just because the budget\n               has been presented this year does not mean that the job is done for another year. My question for the Minister of Finance is this: what would you say you do here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752180","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I sit here week in and week out while the opposition asks about cuts to seniors beds\n               and autism funding. Both are very unfortunate, I agree, but these questions are missing\n               the larger point. The point is that we are in a financial crisis in this province, a $13.3 billion deficit\n               and a debt of over $155 billion and five credit downgrades. We are broke. W","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63d9eb5530c956f80aef81cb590d691948c74925d773a9c93aca9f1d7f053cba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3c31d359c2977be868a52288a1b5fcaa1efbc5c32fb9e3c3dcae9835d2e629c8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cab3913506332e7d517ac33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017154,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am here to speak in favour of this motion to push Bill 20 forward six months into\n               the future, but I support this motion for different reasons than have been argued\n               by my friends in this chamber so far. To my mind, the NDP government has put up an extremely poor-quality treaty with the\n               K'ómoks Band that is entirely bad for British Columbian taxpayers. The problems with this\n               treaty go far beyond DRIPA and UNDRIP or what another band thinks about the treaty. The treaty provides no closure on any issues for British Columbians and....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017154","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am here to speak in favour of this motion to push Bill 20 forward six months into\n               the future, but I support this motion for different reasons than have been argued\n               by my friends in this chamber so far. To my mind, the NDP government has put up an extremely poor-quality treaty with the\n               K'ómoks Band that is entirely bad for British Columbian taxpayers. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037153","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037153","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","label":"Personal income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037153","label":"Social equity","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5830d9c68cf87da10407afd21a8e79fa7c6b8b1f6e3ad29bff1247bc79dc99ba","60e5b5fcaeecd2c52eefe1a7a0046370dc22ebc0c870208c14979712f54d15df"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0919da92b99cf2e69fdbdcc886059e30165146689ebdbb0a06447a69c429963b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9855fcbb1339f46499fa2a03","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017156,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Dallas Brodie","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my very great honour today to introduce a group of young men who are seated\n               in the gallery. They are here with their teacher Tim Stevens, a social studies teacher.\n               His students are in grades 11 and 12. They are from St. George's School, which is a private day and boarding school for\n               boys in my riding of Vancouver-Quilchena. They are a mix of classes and are here today to watch question period and learn\n               about the B.C. provincial system in person as a year-end trip. Please welcome them into the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017156","member_id":"bc-mla-407","member_name":"Dallas Brodie","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's my very great honour today to introduce a group of young men who are seated\n               in the gallery. They are here with their teacher Tim Stevens, a social studies teacher.\n               His students are in grades 11 and 12. They are from St. George's School, which is a private day and boarding school for\n               boys in my riding of Vancouver-Quilchena. They are a mix of classe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104485","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Men","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:104485","label":"Men","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["46db4771bb691a29da0d7d2bdade0a111d53db1da40a2f1aa629441a77e2924b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5257f2ed17f48d27f9ced6e8c85c4d21caf551c5e11682ebaa84ccb95d5d6206"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1698e0d026a9880668a154c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317156,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill be introduced and read for the first time now. It is my pleasure to introduce Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, 2026. Far too often, people are lured into gang life with promises of fast cars, glamorous\n               homes and luxury goods. By going after property owned by high-level criminal organizations\n               and individuals, B.C.'s civil forfeiture office undermines the profit motive behind\n               unlawful activity and sends a clear message to organized crime. This bill makes practical changes to reinforce the province's ability to disrupt organized\n               crime and money laundering. It strengthens litigation processes by requiring parties\n               to fully disclose their claimed interests and by creating a streamlined default judgment\n               process for uncontested cases. It expands timelines and dispute rules, enhancing response\n               periods, clarifying deadlines and allowing relief for mail delays to reduce errors\n               and improve access to justice. The bill also introduces measures to lower costs and protect asset value, including\n               a presumption of vehicle depreciation to allow earlier liquidation. Finally, this bill updates notice and information-sharing provisions, adds safeguards\n               for investigative powers and limits unnecessary discovery to prevent misuse of court\n               processes. Together these changes make the law clearer, fairer and more efficient while reinforcing\n               the program's role in disrupting organized crime and money laundering here in British\n               Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317156","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I move that the bill be introduced and read for the first time now. It is my pleasure to introduce Bill 8, the Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act, 2026. Far too often, people are lured into gang life with promises of fast cars, glamorous\n               homes and luxury goods. By going after property owned by high-level criminal organizations\n               and individuals, B.C.'s civil forfeiture offi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f1e9aee276a2e5fa4fbb9bff64f63b07253d033c6350de6a06838a7e111769ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["228e47324659f0091364081b5ac61e88c1e636c5324a05f84266a53a4b2e7b40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b6562317dd16d135bb5cea6","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187094,"date":"2026-02-23T12:00:00+00:00","title":"CIVIL FORFEITURE AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov08-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov08-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187094","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a418db55c297cd860862633b","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187095,"date":"2026-02-23T12:00:00+00:00","title":"CIVIL FORFEITURE AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov08-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov08-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187095","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04341d9ff764b586e5027409","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317157,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the important question. The safety and protection\n               of all individuals, all communities in B.C., is our absolute priority. We are committed\n               to ensuring that police have the tools and resources that they have to protect communities. We know that, south of the Fraser, extortion crimes in particular are wreaking havoc\n               on communities in Surrey, Delta and Langley. We are continuing to take action, ensuring\n               that police have all the tools that they need to target these criminals and bring\n               them to justice, working with federal partners, as well, to close loopholes, to ensure\n               that our communities are safe. We'll continue to do this work, ensuring police have the tools that they need to keep\n               vulnerable people safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317157","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the important question. The safety and protection\n               of all individuals, all communities in B.C., is our absolute priority. We are committed\n               to ensuring that police have the tools and resources that they have to protect communities. We know that, south of the Fraser, extortion crimes in particular are wreaking havoc\n               on ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human trafficking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43448","label":"Human trafficking","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b11ad001aef84319575774b113a6cf68f86e84bfb3d544bdee9576e7cb3b1ce","7c3e43cf121c19c5a85834504d7875030a791add8dba9463d93e4b61afcc7c80","d86c6f956a5d43870397c61895be6a371584839fbc46781b6e3ce15dcbdfbf4c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d13b10579ed47142a4fb93fcbc0d03d06c0c2c041b74a621526783bfa0108ac8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53d8fbd290f8e88cc343ad9a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317158,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the questions. Gangs and organized crime are\n               what are fueling the toxic drug crisis and violence in our communities. While we're\n               fighting the toxic drug crisis by building more treatment options, highlighted by\n               the Minister of Health, we're also going after criminals that are making and trafficking\n               illegal drugs This includes historic investment in policing in our communities, over $230 million\n               to ensure that we have sufficient frontline officers in our communities. This includes\n               $100 million annually towards Combined Forces Special Enforcement Unit, the CFSEU,\n               the largest integrated policing unit in Canada. We also are going after organized crime in our own communities, going after three\n               more Hell's Angels clubhouses, taking away the proceeds of crime in initiatives such\n               as civil forfeiture. We will continue to go after organized crime in our province with all the tools available\n               to us to ensure that our communities are kept safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317158","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the questions. Gangs and organized crime are\n               what are fueling the toxic drug crisis and violence in our communities. While we're\n               fighting the toxic drug crisis by building more treatment options, highlighted by\n               the Minister of Health, we're also going after criminals that are making and trafficking\n               ill","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["20692503e701fa18e918087a803510fb655bcd8ffe2f052f00431671e0280283"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b29827a5cd252ff8a999893a8cc82f01571b1a9b0a05527755acaa2afeb655f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b64fec704a2ccac326eb591","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327994,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill titled","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327994","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that the bill titled","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9454de8696c72a753238a3d6d6182255ad2410fb48b0149ed02c001488768b62"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31f11210d5184783e1ab0356","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327995,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to thank all members in the House who contributed to this debate. Civil forfeiture\n               is a relatively simple idea with powerful implications and impacts","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327995","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to thank all members in the House who contributed to this debate. Civil forfeiture\n               is a relatively simple idea with powerful implications and impacts","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ba4b9236c3bb7531869450d80ba141d2258ba3b855f6039c35f6357bb2e1da1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56eb372466c4423a6c9d82ac","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415755,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm so pleased to be able to introduce members of the B.C. Police Association visiting\n               us today. These are 15 members of the 3,673 BCPA members that represent 14 police\n               associations and unions across our province. With us today are Jason Chan; BCPA president, James Hubert; Bill Naledine; Brandon\n               Steele; Sean Shipper; Dan Young; Adam Sutherland; Sebastian Fazzino; Arthur Wlodyka; Neal Schaffer; Kieran O'Reilly; Eddie Harper; Matt Sorensen; Adam Sutherland; and\n               Don Cogel. Please join me in welcoming them to the Legislature and thanking them for their service\n               and the work they do every day to keep our communities safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415755","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm so pleased to be able to introduce members of the B.C. Police Association visiting\n               us today. These are 15 members of the 3,673 BCPA members that represent 14 police\n               associations and unions across our province. With us today are Jason Chan; BCPA president, James Hubert; Bill Naledine; Brandon\n               Steele; Sean Shipper; Dan Young; Adam Sutherland; Sebastia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Holidays","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316193","label":"Holidays","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5e1068c35fcc92c54da9445a95c25062d3df55c771054b7c1e505f8b8765378c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-da059c2d515469161c06ff2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720405,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720405","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2670f6981def954151a2eba9047fb9f7d0c888117e7c2cddd29d3b256340903e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3b0a905fc0022902df6c5df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720406,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"My thanks to the member for the question. Combating extortion in Surrey is our top public safety priority. The province has\n               stood up...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720406","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My thanks to the member for the question. Combating extortion in Surrey is our top public safety priority. The province has\n               stood up...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Firearms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:125197","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:125197","label":"Cycling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42854","label":"Firearms","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d065cbd8eb71c3dc9af05d87c13cb0f947ac229e7e0bc3f8ed2e507d98766fd7","ba79d6085bdf735418f92e02db3be32e28a5c72cb4d1944ecd6df9bcebfd839d","f5566bafafe2e71ca985a0509e5a65ea7ec5ce7bc9533a21a4c2ec311d265d3b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec5e103cbcb1d648fab7e31458fd579c11899397ce06bc6591ae9d1eb8f03efb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4306c1b916b20b77f9fff24c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720411,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before turning to the specific provisions that relate to the Correction Act before\n               us within Bill 16, I'd like to take just a moment to situate this legislation within\n               the broader work that our government is doing to build a correction system that is\n               both safe and humane; to build a correction system that upholds the dignity of the\n               people in our custody while ensuring that the women and the men who work in our correction\n               centres in B.C. every day can do their jobs effectively and safely. British Columbia has been on a deliberate path, a purposeful path. British Columbia has been on a deliberate path, a purposeful path of corrections reform.\n               In recent years, we have invested more than $30 million to expand programming, socialization\n               and recreation space in our correctional centres. As part of this work, we have improved classification tools, strengthened community\n               transition supports and expanded culturally safe programming for Indigenous people\n               who are in custody. At the same time, we have been accelerating our work on involuntary mental health\n               care for people in the correctional system. Approximately 69 percent of individuals\n               in provincial custody have a mental health or substance use disorder. This is a significant\n               number, and far too many are cycling through the justice system without ever accessing\n               the treatment that they need. That is exactly why our government and Premier Eby announced new involuntary care\n               facilities in Surrey and in Prince George. That is why we established the dual-designation\n               model at Surrey Pretrial Services Centre. That is why we are discussing the amendments\n               to the Correction Act that we bring to this bill today, because the law has not kept\n               pace with the care model that we are building here in B.C., and this bill corrects\n               just that. To support the delivery of involuntary care for those held in custody of B.C. Corrections,\n               the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General proposes amendments to the Correction\n               Act being put forward as part of Bill 16. Currently, involuntary care is taking place at Surrey Pretrial Services Centre via\n               a model wherein a living unit is duly designated as both a correction centre and a\n               provincial mental health facility under the Mental Health Act. In some cases, health\n               care staff require help to support de-escalation or to assist with restraining a patient\n               during the administration of medication to ensure the safe provision of treatment\n               using non-harmful control techniques. B.C. Corrections staff are currently limited by the use-of-force authority that is\n               prescribed within the Correction Act. Because of this, correctional staff are currently\n               unable to assist the health care providers in delivering involuntary care under the\n               Mental Health Act in correctional facilities. Support for involuntary care within\n               B.C. correctional centres is currently provided by contracted non-corrections security\n               personnel. The proposed legislation expands the purposes for which a correctional staff member\n               may use force and/or restraining devices to include assisting health care providers\n               in delivering involuntary treatment in correctional centres in our province. Authorizing correctional staff to assist with involuntary care in B.C. correctional\n               centres removes the need for non-correction security personnel on the current living\n               unit at the Surrey Pretrial Centre on which involuntary care is currently provided\n               and within any future living units where a similar model is established. The proposed change to the Correction Act does not change how involuntary care is\n               administered in our province's B.C. correctional centres by health care providers\n               in accordance with the Mental Health Act. Rather, the proposed The proposed change to the Correction Act does not change how involuntary care is\n               administered in our province's B.C. correctional centres by health care providers\n               in accordance with the Mental Health Act. Rather, the proposed changes only affect\n               who is authorized to use force to assist health care providers with the delivery of\n               treatment. Separate from the use of force changes, the Ministry of Attorney General's investigations\n               and standards office, which is known as the ISO, has proposed changes that will do\n               a few things. They will better reflect their authority to conduct inspections and\n               investigations and to review disciplinary hearing appeals made by B.C. Corrections.\n               They reflect the ISO requirement to report to the Attorney General. They reflect the\n               ISO requirement to make reports public. Finally, they refine the inmate complaint\n               process to make it more accessible and to give the director broader discretion about\n               whether to investigate a complaint. The changes proposed by the investigation and standards office mirror wording that\n               is in other investigatory legislation and regulations, such as those which guide the\n               Office of the Ombudsperson. The people in our correctional centres are some of the most vulnerable in our province.\n               Many are living with serious mental illness, addiction, trauma and conditions that\n               the justice system alone cannot address. Here in B.C., we are building a corrections\n               model that takes these realities seriously. And we're building a system that can deliver\n               dignified, effective care alongside the security and accountability that the public\n               rightfully expects. This bill takes us one concrete step further along that path.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720411","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Before turning to the specific provisions that relate to the Correction Act before\n               us within Bill 16, I'd like to take just a moment to situate this legislation within\n               the broader work that our government is doing to build a correction system that is\n               both safe and humane; to build a correction system that upholds the dignity of the\n               people","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["469a4333c61beee31e6e33c6cd9166a2165199fc25bcd2a492db1fef878ebd96"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2fd00bc004ef65fe1d727a0c664c3ec1d163aee079435b562482b69c3bc46465"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d9410216760690863ef9dbe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721511,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. Let me be clear. Extortion has no place in British Columbia. When an incident like\n               we saw in Surrey takes place, this strikes fear in our communities. We have seen a\n               general decline in extortion threats and related violence over the last two months,\n               but when something like this happens, it shows why it is so important that we double\n               down and do not take our foot off the gas in terms of supporting police in their work. B.C. has, as we know, established the B.C. extortion task force, the largest multi-jurisdictional\n               coordinated police response in the country. We have seen now 19 charges, 25 removals\n               from Canada, thanks to the engagement of Canada Border Services Agency. One of the recent arrests announced by the task force was done in coordination with\n               the Alberta RCMP, which just shows that the threats of extortion know no bounds. They\n               are taking place across jurisdictions, and that is why the steadfast and coordinated\n               and strong approach of British Columbia is necessary and will continue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721511","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. Let me be clear. Extortion has no place in British Columbia. When an incident like\n               we saw in Surrey takes place, this strikes fear in our communities. We have seen a\n               general decline in extortion threats and related violence over the last two months,\n               but when something like this happens, it shows why it ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f26ccfcc3020c822e2715683b3d9cc700d646da62c620d1fe78e2c191eef3f41"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["97f08bae4ab794f27c4cea2cf856f39e8b9c1109433a0ca49e1c6085eb99bf4e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c3380d4eed6bb66b897ae77d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729184,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. British Columbia is very excited to welcome hundreds of thousands of visitors for\n               the FIFA World Cup and to realize the profound economic benefits to the region. As\n               Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General, ensuring the safety of all visitors,\n               athletes, all participants, fans and residents and communities is a top priority As Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General, ensuring the safety of all visitors, athletes, all participants, fans and residents in communities is a top priority for the province, for the host city and for all our\n               partners. The Vancouver police department is the police of jurisdiction, and they are working closely with the integrated safety and security branch, the B.C. RCMP and the policing and security branch of my ministry. The federal commissioner of the RCMP has also indicated their full support and engagement in ensuring that\n               our games here in B.C. are safe and successful.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729184","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. British Columbia is very excited to welcome hundreds of thousands of visitors for\n               the FIFA World Cup and to realize the profound economic benefits to the region. As\n               Minister of Public Safety and Solicitor General, ensuring the safety of all visitors,\n               athletes, all participants, fans and residents and co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Satellites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56469","label":"Satellites","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59ff87074232658ee5a570960e75e66e912c2b080a9ac1409d02d199476191d8","64cc6a9341f1af61bff3e22777aaa8ed8428f8b2aa8c1ece392ee8880d0faca2","7afe289b8e141a9cfd9db3c0818cbfa2a6dfeead12d51593627b5415579163a9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec399c3da843d3b84330cc0cba1da96f6c7b50b2f889ec19f44915006e83b287"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-591b64c4781c3f5bd6fe62b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729186,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"The assault style firearms compensation program is a federal initiative which is designed,\n               funded and administered by Public Safety Canada. Since the announcement of the program,\n               my ministry has worked continuously with Public Safety Canada and been advised by\n               the B.C. Association of Chiefs of Police to promote consistent delivery across the\n               province in a manner that does not interfere with our front-line policing and public\n               safety priorities in any way. We have shared the concerns of our policing partners, specifically the B.C. Association\n               of Chiefs of Police, with Public Safety Canada. Now the program's administration has\n               been streamlined significantly. We have left it up to independent police departments\n               to determine whether or how they participate in that program for compensation by the\n               federal government. The RCMP will continue to support the administration of the program and oversee the\n               collection of firearms in the province they are responsible for.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729186","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The assault style firearms compensation program is a federal initiative which is designed,\n               funded and administered by Public Safety Canada. Since the announcement of the program,\n               my ministry has worked continuously with Public Safety Canada and been advised by\n               the B.C. Association of Chiefs of Police to promote consistent delivery across the\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ca72b51c05dcffc507dce25eb8e9a8a16204c469a16b0985a3ee7cba3e7f7ed0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39897180af00815171d4d8a67e482e31f2678f1bd7642b529db1f33c645ff9ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14345bbc17abe24f6139b28b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752273,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. This week I had an opportunity\n               to connect with several residents of Surrey and know the deep concern whenever there\n               are shots fired. This has a profound impact on communities, on businesses, on families. In terms of\n               the shooting, referenced by the member, in Newton, I'd like to confirm that this is\n               an active investigation. There is no known link to extortion at this time, and it's\n               under investigation by the integrated homicide investigation In terms of the shooting referenced by the member in Newton, I'd like to confirm\n               that this is an active investigation. There's no known link to extortion at this time,\n               and it's under investigation by the integrated homicide investigation unit. But on the extortion front, earlier this week the Surrey police service issued a statement\n               where they noted a decline, steadily over the last four months, of extortion violence.\n               This, I think, reflects the targeted, proactive, sustained enforcement efforts of\n               the SPS, of the B.C. extortion task force, of all law enforcement partners who are\n               working to identify criminals, ensure that they are arrested, charged, and if they\n               are not here legally, removed from Canada with our partnership with CBSA. This work must continue, and the province will continue to support police in their\n               important work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752273","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. This week I had an opportunity\n               to connect with several residents of Surrey and know the deep concern whenever there\n               are shots fired. This has a profound impact on communities, on businesses, on families. In terms of\n               the shooting, referenced by the member, in Newton, I'd like to confirm that this is\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["05cc0312d1396ae95b821a57f6d2788d67c64706b8380604f019cc337afd6240"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2753919afeb92607d9b7478f9be9a4c9dac7a435961773e5f3d3e7e104126ed1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60b644c4b33273a2b51c0a0f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752274,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm going to keep my opening remarks brief because I'd love to dedicate as much of\n               our time together to the substance of the discussion and the debate. But I would just\n               like to begin with a couple of acknowledgements. First and foremost, I want to acknowledge my colleague across the aisle, the MLA for\n               West Kelowna–Peachland, the critic for Public Safety, and all of his colleagues that will be participating\n               in the estimates process for the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General. I have enjoyed the opportunity to engage in discussion during committee stages of\n               various bills. We've had the opportunity to meet with members of my team to offer\n               technical briefings and have really appreciated the collegial, constructive discussions\n               that we've been able to have around public safety, which is integral to the well-being\n               of people in our province. I'd also like to acknowledge the team from the ministry that will support me during\n               estimates and also that works tirelessly every day with tremendous expertise and a\n               dedication to advance public safety for British Columbians. Beside me, I'm joined\n               by Deputy Solicitor General Tara Richards; by the assistant deputy minister of the\n               policing and security branch, and the director of policing and law enforcement services,\n               Glenn Lewis. Also behind me are Brian Sims and Jamie Lipp from the policing and security\n               branch. Then, off to another room, but who will be joining me throughout our discussions,\n               are a number of assistant deputy ministers: Erin Gunnarson of B.C. Corrections; Taryn\n               Walsh of community safety and victim services branch; Dara Landry, who is ADM and\n               executive financial officer of the corporate management services branch; Toby Louie,\n               our ADM of Road Safety B.C., Dr. Jatinder, also known as Taj, Baidwan, our chief coroner with the B.C. Coroners Service; David Hume, the ADM with the liquor\n               and cannabis regulation branch; Megan Harris, the ADM with corporate strategic initiatives;\n               as well as Rachel Chan, who is executive director of gambling supports division in\n               the independent gambling control office. They are supported by teams in Victoria and\n               across the province that do their work with tremendous skill and commitment. With that, I look forward to this estimates process.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752274","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm going to keep my opening remarks brief because I'd love to dedicate as much of\n               our time together to the substance of the discussion and the debate. But I would just\n               like to begin with a couple of acknowledgements. First and foremost, I want to acknowledge my colleague across the aisle, the MLA for\n               West Kelowna–Peachland, the critic for Public Safety","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Space technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Decentralization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037198","label":"Space technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110785","label":"Decentralization","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45465","label":"Security intelligence","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f14555ea76e01e659e35356507094f661311730db82ad152cf4ac045f46fbd79","bd56d063063fa1fd82cc533a74c8c00ee3badf1d02342cced0aeb00a208debd1","c43561c17aa2f3fe6f4447cccd1799b5d1e3b0fff810fa7215852355eece8083","dc7637cf956d11312cb29cab8bbcccea386c44572401299552d3c249fc1e8fce","51cdafe6338e60194d0dd447fe87560a67c3b461c8e5934308ea00cdb5688ab3","e4bcecb7aa3ecf8d73f65bd59300013d48af9288d6185d9623f62076876960ba","c4b023fad0f78bfb20fab1942d0073f73a247d2bfcb8a480afa4a07f40cdf4a0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c489e5ffa09d5573a695a57c3227b84df529b8937b0d66c45ff7b85a0ad8b7e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ea38ea98eaeaeee9a2c9201","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017382,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Matters of immigration enforcement are within federal jurisdiction, involve Canada\n               Border Services Agency. Just to redirect the member's question to our federal counterparts. But what I will say is that the Canada Border Services Agency has been an integral part of the B.C. extortion task force and has been collaborating with police to a degree that we've never seen before in\n               this province, and indeed in Canada, on matters related to extortion. It was reported as of May 14 that the CBSA Pacific region has now opened 116 investigations into individuals linked to extortion activity and\n               issued 52 removal orders and removed 35 individuals from Canada. So that work, those\n               results, speak to the really important collaboration that the ministry, that local\n               and provincial law enforcement is doing with Canada Border Services Agency on extortion,\n               a matter of great priority for our ministry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017382","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Matters of immigration enforcement are within federal jurisdiction, involve Canada\n               Border Services Agency. Just to redirect the member's question to our federal counterparts. But what I will say is that the Canada Border Services Agency has been an integral part of the B.C. extortion task force and has been collaborating with police","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal territorial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","label":"Helicopters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","label":"Deportation","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035241","label":"Federal territorial relations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","label":"Air transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec35dbff4d8827c2d30b2d4355a7681de4a0b2155f838aef0bb19805aceeb178","9265821163ea565b013cbcfa57582cb26f53b9bfdbdfb335cc0fa0c974afcbcc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["96b0db310dc483acdc073126c4d155f27377786c38176a66fdfad879fe287953"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Deportation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034822","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-990e1eb259ad597bb29bd42a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017394,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member opposite asked a question when we broke for lunch. We are just finalizing\n               the answer and we'll be back to him in short order.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017394","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The member opposite asked a question when we broke for lunch. We are just finalizing\n               the answer and we'll be back to him in short order.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Air transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722814","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Military aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Assistive technologies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Military technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035320","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food inspection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death rate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:232166","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cemeteries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Helicopters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018277","label":"Helicopters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034784","label":"Death rate","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035320","label":"Food inspection","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036293","label":"Military aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036303","label":"Military technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083617","label":"Foreign aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","label":"Resources management","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:232166","label":"Cemeteries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718701","label":"Air transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722814","label":"Animal inspection","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751981","label":"Assistive technologies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e538d8215558f170f5ba082f2f40d11e245b7d588a6a36744984a05f3838479e","60bfecb87a60f81b9df1cb03525aa3a4c05aa1f1f8e2b33100a0e9aa2b603438","e28e13ae3d67020f4d405c0b9fecc636a49c06f9d05c6964cf1ee8fc7daa0112","719ad8001b79955887c190b718992de1a9e40cc8b9610c2b3ec070e9f00119ad","a410558aa95e43c07bb6194113d54d159f15f737af27b99b606ea0d37a31f3d7","cf0caf2b93bb7ad88640973ea0d6fb227fb272e4cb4500556a41d36420716ec9","74413a6abd304cf9e41db5be9a0219e067f4db130adc23ff8590128870daec04"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-60b6035f116cfe32107c5598","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017395,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the question and want to make it very clear that police in British Columbia\n               enforce the law. This government is committed to providing police with the tools that\n               they need to engage with the challenges of our time. That's why we have made a historic investment in policing in our province — over $230\n               million, hiring 256 officers, with an emphasis on rural and remote communities. That's\n               why we've increased training for police, and that's why we are standing up dedicated\n               programs to provide police with the tools to go after repeat violent offenders and\n               property crime that we know are causing such challenges in our communities. We are committed to continuing this strong action, providing police with the tools\n               that they need to do their vital work to keep British Columbians safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017395","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the question and want to make it very clear that police in British Columbia\n               enforce the law. This government is committed to providing police with the tools that\n               they need to engage with the challenges of our time. That's why we have made a historic investment in policing in our province — over $230\n               million, hiring 256 officers, with an emp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f0900298eaa6d8670f6cd77de0bc98bdd9a38db07fec80785a978f110910680"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["47c6d64471a091543bb9a3b7836cf3c61ef3465d7721c6535f984dee9eeb7636"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c30c739f22d76df9e1540f74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017397,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thanks to the member opposite for the question. The critical response unit supports situational awareness and cross-government coordination\n               on public safety, employee safety and the protection of critical infrastructure. This\n               work is coordinated through the critical incident secretariat of government. This group does not monitor lawful advocacy or political activity, does not monitor\n               specific groups, climate initiatives or treaty negotiations. The province fully respects\n               the right to peaceful, lawful protest and the constitutional independence of First\n               Nations in their negotiations with government. I would be pleased to speak further with the member opposite about any further questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017397","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thanks to the member opposite for the question. The critical response unit supports situational awareness and cross-government coordination\n               on public safety, employee safety and the protection of critical infrastructure. This\n               work is coordinated through the critical incident secretariat of government. This group does not monitor lawful advocacy or political activity, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["07fe7d03eea27961596d8f2e765f3ee3dedfdc005ddaf2f3a9c30a6184eed39b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f81e24dc5dbf8c687ad0328a3af0a154635b5d89f34040b9ec8cff28401d53d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a34c52fd5a2726e32af14e87","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036505,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery today are 45 students, grades 9 to 12, from Reynolds Secondary,\n               which is a school in my community well known far and wide for excellence in its robotics\n               club, band, sports and also as the former high school of Premier John Horgan. I hope that all my colleagues can make our guests feel very welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036505","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery today are 45 students, grades 9 to 12, from Reynolds Secondary,\n               which is a school in my community well known far and wide for excellence in its robotics\n               club, band, sports and also as the former high school of Premier John Horgan. I hope that all my colleagues can make our guests feel very welcome today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["509d5b8ab80e428d2baef0d555cb25af57da5bd620d9742e44d63a3bb50b4edf"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2128f25d8e0aa0f205f8c54caf9fecb39ecab0852b66ccd3567c6ed55559c22b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-00dabe556091b2ec6f4f9053","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036506,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery are two members of our ministry team: Carly Parry, director\n               of executive operations; and Alexis DiGeorgio, manager of executive operations. They\n               keep our office running and our ministry moving, and I'm so grateful for the work\n               that they do each and every day for British Columbians. I hope the House will please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036506","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery are two members of our ministry team: Carly Parry, director\n               of executive operations; and Alexis DiGeorgio, manager of executive operations. They\n               keep our office running and our ministry moving, and I'm so grateful for the work\n               that they do each and every day for British Columbians. I hope the House will please join me in making","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55759673a940f9ed319655586e742630dc89169f0a677f0f8c706c116b8c4f53"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61e875afca7b56db4902a35c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036507,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Nina Krieger","venue":"Hansard","text":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. We know that businesses are the\n               backbones of communities in our province. Business owners, workers and community members\n               need to feel safe. That's why we have been responding to municipal leaders, to business owners and police\n               in standing up programs that they have been asking for. These include programs such\n               as SITE, the special investigation and targeted enforcement program, that allows police\n               to apply for funding to invest in specialized equipment, funding for overtime work\n               and to really ensure that they have the tools to go after repeat violent offenders\n               and also street disorder crimes in our communities. These investments are having a result, including in Kelowna. Kelowna applied for SITE\n               funding and conducted a seven-month investigation that led to 121 arrests, 163 charges,\n               456 new police files and the seizure of significant drugs and weapons. This speaks\n               to the results of the programs, that we are taking action to ensure that they continue\n               to support communities and support police in targeting these criminals and to keep\n               communities safe.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036507","member_id":"bc-mla-409","member_name":"Nina Krieger","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My thanks to the member opposite for the question. We know that businesses are the\n               backbones of communities in our province. Business owners, workers and community members\n               need to feel safe. That's why we have been responding to municipal leaders, to business owners and police\n               in standing up programs that they have been asking for. These include program","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aaa2f73d9ef2b937f9ee79945538de843951fd0401ee8112baf4a04bab5913ed"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["edbb4305a6ebbfa971e615dfbc06791c8ada91bab624424d3ae844f299c5b5f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b99f2f28970e5fb10435abdd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317151,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is an honour to respond to the 2026 budget here today as the Minister of Tourism,\n               Arts, Culture and Sport and the MLA for Burnaby Centre. I would like to begin by acknowledging that the B.C. Legislature is on the territory\n               of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations. Before I begin, I want to acknowledge the recent tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. My heart\n               goes out to everyone in the community, especially the families who have lost a loved\n               one. This is a deeply shocking and painful time for so many, both at a local level and\n               across the country, and we are committed to ensuring there is timely, coordinated\n               support available to the people in Tumbler Ridge, including counselling services,\n               health resources and community assistance. Supports will remain in place as long as\n               they are needed. As we stand with Tumbler Ridge, our commitment to all British Columbians\n               remains steadfast. I would like to take this opportunity today to talk about Budget 2026 and what that\n               means for the province and what my ministry has to offer. Budget 2026 comes at a time\n               when many families, communities and sectors throughout British Columbia are feeling\n               the impact of global uncertainty and rising costs. Over the past eight years, we've built strong foundations in our tourism, arts, culture\n               and sports sectors, and those foundations matter now more than ever, because we have\n               to be realistic and disciplined about the choices ahead, because every dollar must\n               count. That's why we're taking responsible steps to strengthen revenues, grow the\n               economy and secure long-term benefits for major projects. With the Look West strategy, we're moving fast, cutting timelines, unlocking major projects and creating\n               good jobs across the tourism, arts, culture, sport, and creative industries. Tourism, arts, culture and sports are pillars of our economy and essential to the\n               cultural, social fabric of this province. The people who work in these sectors are\n               the heart and soul of communities throughout British Columbia. These sectors generate\n               jobs, support local businesses, strengthen local economies, build resilient communities\n               and attract visitors and talent from around the world. These industries fuel creativity,\n               inspire innovation and spark solutions that benefit every region. They help young\n               people find their path, help communities express who they are and help us stay connected\n               to one another during difficult times. When COVID hit, British Columbians turned to these sectors, to local trails and parks,\n               community sport, books, music and film, for connection and hope. In today's hard times,\n               people are turning to them again. These sectors also support reconciliation by uplifting\n               Indigenous artists, athletes and cultural leaders and by creating programs where communities\n               can heal, learn and build together. In a year where government must be careful with\n               spending, our message is clear. These sectors remain vital, and we will continue to\n               prioritize them. Tourism continues to be a strong contributor to B.C.'s economy. This sector is one\n               of the largest small business generators and employers in the province, with almost\n               17,000 businesses directly providing services to visitors in B.C. It also supports\n               more than 113,000 direct jobs. When we include indirect jobs, that number increases\n               to almost Last year we saw resiliency, incredible entrepreneur spirit, and communities working\n               hard to welcome visitors from around the world. Tourism generated nearly $9.4 billion\n               to a provincial GDP and $23 billion in revenue in 2024. In 2024, B.C.'s tourism industry produced nearly $2.1 billion in federal taxes, nearly\n               $1.8 billion in provincial taxes and more than $300 million in local government taxes. We continue to see growth in international visitors to B.C. with 5.4 million overnight\n               visitor arrivals in 2024, up 7 percent from the previous year. This is good news.\n               Last year's hotels recorded an average provincial occupancy rate of 70 percent. YVR landed its biggest year ever with a record 26.9 million travellers passing through\n               the airport in 2025, which was supported by over 230 full-time jobs. We recognize that a skilled, stable labour force is essential for strengthening communities\n               and driving long-term economic prosperity through tourism. That is why through \"Look\n               West,\" we will be delivering a tourism growth strategy to position B.C.'s tourism\n               sector for long-term growth and success by creating the conditions needed to attract\n               investments in tourism infrastructure and experiences, by exploring opportunities\n               to grow and diversify the industry, by extending seasons and expanding tourism offerings\n               and by leveraging the global exposure from FIFA World Cup 26 to generate jobs and\n               deliver benefits to communities throughout British Columbia. B.C.'s outdoor recreation is a cornerstone of this growth, attracting visitors from\n               around the world to experience B.C.'s mountains, forests, rivers and coastline. These\n               experiences not only drive visitation but also sustain local economies and small businesses\n               in rural and Indigenous communities. We're committed to supporting our mountain resorts, adventure tourism operators and\n               commercial recreation providers who deliver safe, world-class experiences that connect\n               visitors with B.C.'s natural landscapes. Together, these efforts strengthen our economy, and tourism is ready to lead the way.\n               That's why it's critical we continue to work with our partners like Destination B.C.\n               to support a strong sustainable visitor economy. In Budget 2026, we will be taking steps to ensure tourism operators — large and small,\n               rural and urban — have the support that they need. This investment is supporting our government's broader strategy to modernize permitting\n               and regulatory frameworks, ensuring continued focused efforts to advance investment\n               and the growth of our world-class mountain resource sector. Ski resorts drive investments\n               in rural communities throughout B.C., including $2.02 billion invested in ski areas\n               on Crown land. To support our future workforce and economic development needs in key sectors such\n               as tourism, we are investing in post-secondary institutions to help build capacity.\n               These investments will build capacity to support future workforce and economic development\n               needs in key sectors, including tourism. This includes a $58 million investment at Kelowna's Okanagan College campus for a\n               four-storey, hybrid mass timber centre for food, wine and tourism, expected to be\n               completed by 2027. This year we will also continue to support B.C. as a world-class destination, working\n               with our Crown corporation, Destination B.C., and other tourism partners to promote\n               local travel, strengthen international markets, support major events and help tourism\n               businesses remain competitive. People are fascinated by culture, our history, our heritages. Our museums do an excellent\n               job sharing B.C.'s story to the world. The province is committed to the conservation and protection of its historical and\n               heritage resources. I am so proud of the incredible work our government is doing with\n               our partners to preserve our history through the conservation of provincial heritage\n               sites. Since 2020 the province has Since 2020, the province has provided a record investment of more than $55 million\n               to preserve and protect B.C.'s heritage assets. Heritage sites are powerful tourism\n               drivers, attracting visitors who seek authentic culture experiences and encouraging\n               travelers to explore beyond major urban city centres for deeper, more meaningful connections\n               to B.C.'s history. Speaking of making history, as we look to host FIFA World Cup, the world's largest\n               single sport event, we must capitalize on this unprecedented opportunity for British\n               Columbia. Through the Look West strategy, we are positioning B.C. as a reliable and competitive destination for Canadians\n               and global investors, leveraging the FIFA World Cup to showcase our expertise, strategic\n               location and key sectors of strength to a worldwide audience. With the eyes of the\n               world upon us, the tournament will shine a powerful global spotlight on British Columbia\n               as a premiere destination for tourism, trade and long term investment. And beyond the seven matches being played in Vancouver, the tournament will leave\n               lasting legacies that extend well beyond the pitch throughout British Columbia with\n               an exciting announcement coming this March. This is about supporting local businesses, good jobs for British Columbians, attracting\n               new investment and strengthening B.C.'s place on the global stage for decades to come.\n               The seven matches are expected to attract more than 350,000 soccer fans to B.C. Place\n               during the tournament and generate over $1 billion in visitor spending for B.C.'s\n               economy from 2026 through 2031. And in the five years following, we are expecting to see more than one million additional\n               out-of-province visitors and potentially up to $224 million in direct, indirect and\n               other related provincial tax revenues. We are supporting communities across the province\n               to bring the excitement of FIFA to community celebrations throughout the province\n               in addition to the FIFA fan festival. Research shows that visitors often return three\n               or four times over their lifetimes. By showcasing our province during the moment, we ensure that people come back again\n               and again for business, for travel, for trade and for investment. It's clear that\n               we're making strategic investments, harnessing the social and economic benefits of\n               these matches, and making sure people all over the region of B.C. share in the benefits\n               of hosting this sport. Sport is one of the most powerful tools we have to bring people together. Whether\n               it's high performance competition or weekend recreation, sport builds healthier communities\n               and supports young people in every corner of B.C. Our government remains committed\n               to making sport in British Columbia safe, inclusive and accessible for all. That is\n               why the provincial government invests approximately $50 million annually in sport\n               to help bring healthy living and community economic benefits to the entire province.\n               This investment directly supports over 70 sport organizations and over 718,000 members\n               of amateur sport organizations to get active and engaged in their communities. When playing sports, everyone deserves to feel safe. And that's why we are committed\n               to strengthening safe sport measures, including the development of the PlaySafe B.C.\n               program and establishing sport safeguarding, B.C. Sport is helping young athletes\n               throughout British Columbia turn potential into achievement from competing at the\n               B.C. Games to representing Canada on the Olympic stage. By supporting sport, we're not just funding competition, we're strengthening communities,\n               creating jobs and driving local spending that stays right here at home, while bringing\n               people together through the shared pride and spirit that only sport can inspire. The same passion that fuels our sports sector, fuels our artists, bringing our communities\n               together. Arts and culture reflect who we are. They help us understand our history,\n               celebrate our communities, and share our stories with the world from museums and galleries,\n               theatre companies and festivals, to grassroots organizations that keep culture alive\n               in every region of Over the years, we've built a strong foundation of programs that British Columbians\n               can count on, and we will continue to support the people who make arts and culture\n               possible, because their work strengthens communities and enriches lives across the\n               province. At the centre of this support is the B.C. Arts Council. Through the B.C. Arts Council,\n               we support programs that help artists and organizations thrive, from operating funding\n               that keeps theatres, galleries and cultural centres open to arts training and community\n               festivals that give kids their first chance to dance, sing, paint or perform on a\n               stage, and we will continue these supports. Programs like the destination events program\n               also help festivals and cultural experiences grow, reach new audiences and strengthen\n               B.C.'s cultural landscape. I want to highlight the important role of community gaming grants. These grants reach\n               deep into communities throughout B.C. Each year the province invests as much as $140 million through community gaming grants,\n               supporting approximately 5,000 non-profit organizations and strengthening communities\n               throughout British Columbia. Supporting arts and culture groups — such as youth programs,\n               food banks, parent advisory councils, local sport clubs, capital projects and front-line\n               human service organizations — the grants help keep the doors open at the places that\n               families rely on every day. They make sure that people stay connected, supported and\n               able to participate in community life. Just as our arts and culture sector reflects who we are, our creative industries demonstrate\n               what British Columbians can achieve. B.C.'s creative industries — film, television,\n               music, publishing, animation and digital media — are recognized globally as leaders\n               in innovation and production excellence. Together, these industries form a powerful, cultural, economic engine, one that inspires,\n               employs and elevates talent across the province. They employ tens of thousands of\n               highly skilled people and attract major productions like Shōgun and The Last of Us , which fuel local economies. We've seen incredible recognition this year, with B.C. talent front and centre. From\n               Nanaimo's Cameron Whitcomb, a five-time Juno nominee, including Album of the Year,\n               to the Golden Globe–winning animated film, KPop Demon Hunters — powered in part by B.C.'s animation teams, who also contributed to Oscar-nominated\n               titles like Zootopia 2 and Avatar: Fire and Ash — our creative industry showcased B.C.'s talent, diversity and technical experience\n               on the world stage. Last year we boosted support for the motion picture industry, including increased\n               tax credits for our domestic sector and for productions coming from other jurisdictions,\n               and we introduced a new bonus incentive for major productions. We also increased interactive\n               digital media tax credits to support a strong digital media industry and to ensure\n               that B.C. remains competitive. These investments are working. B.C. continues to attract major productions such as\n               from Sony, HBO and Disney. Through Budget 2026 and in response to industry feedback,\n               we introduced important improvements to the film and television tax credit programs.\n               These include simplifying filing and certification requirements and removing the pre-certification\n               requirement. We also strengthened our broader creative sector by making the book publishing tax\n               credit permanent, providing stable long-term support for B.C.'s publishers and authors.\n               Together, these changes make it easier for productions and creative companies, both\n               locally and internationally, to access the supports they rely on, while keeping B.C.\n               competitive and production-ready. This support is critical in creating high-paying jobs in the sector and expanding\n               opportunities for thousands of people living in British Columbia. To build on this\n               momentum, we are working with cross-ministry and industry partners to develop a provincial\n               film and television strategy. The strategy will help To build on this momentum, we are working with cross-ministry and industry partners\n               to develop a provincial film and television strategy. The strategy will help the sector\n               stay strong and competitive as global markets continue to shift. It will build on\n               the strength of our people and our studios so B.C. stays a place where productions\n               want to film and where our own creators can succeed. I want to take this opportunity to talk about Burnaby-related projects and to emphasize\n               that budgets don't just announce projects; they deliver them. The most meaningful\n               measure of a government's commitment is whether the things we promised in past years\n               are built, opened, staffed and used by the public, especially when times get tough. Global uncertainty is not just a headline. It is a reality that shows up in grocery\n               bills, in rental cheques and anxiety about the future. That's exactly why our approach\n               matters. In this moment, the province has chosen to make careful, disciplined choices\n               to protect what matters most, like education and health care, and to keep building\n               a stronger future. We are protecting core services and continuing to build across\n               the province, including my riding of Burnaby Centre. We are safeguarding health care and education, supporting people who need care and\n               assistance, and moving forward with a substantial and sustainable capital plan that\n               creates jobs and meets the real needs of British Columbians. It means being honest\n               about fiscal pressures we meet and that we are facing while refusing to compromise\n               on essential community needs. In Burnaby, one of the clearest examples of that commitment is BCIT. BCIT has a special\n               place in my community as one of the cornerstone institutes that help shape our community\n               and the future of our workplace and workforce in British Columbia. Everyone has a\n               place in BCIT, from a newly graduated high-schooler to a mid-career professional looking\n               to change careers or advance in their own career. As a proud MLA for BCIT, I can confidently\n               say that when we talk about the future-proofing of our economy and creating more opportunities\n               for skills training, BCIT is an example of what it looks like on the ground. That is why I'm proud to highlight the south campus infrastructure renewal project\n               at BCIT. The province has committed $48 million for this work, replacing aging electrical,\n               stormwater and other critical infrastructure. Construction is expected to be completed\n               in 2029. This is foundational work. Renewing the backbone of a campus is exactly what\n               responsible governments do when they say they will safeguard what we have built. Another exciting project happening at BCIT is the announcement of the trades and technology\n               complex, a collection of new and renovated buildings that will add 1,200 student trade\n               and technology seats in modernized learning spaces. The province is providing $151.6\n               million, and it will be completed in 2027. It is expected to generate 738 direct jobs\n               and 406 indirect jobs, those numbers representing paycheques, apprenticeships, contracts\n               for local suppliers, and years of economic activity. The bigger point is this. Every seat in a trade program is a concrete response to\n               labour shortages that are holding back housing construction, infrastructure projects\n               and business expansion. It is a plan to secure good-paying jobs and economic prosperity\n               for people and families. If we want to talk honestly about affordability, we also need to talk honestly about\n               student housing. British Columbian families know how tight the rental market has been\n               for years — low vacancy rates, rising rent and a high demand in rental housing. When\n               students can't find housing they can afford, it pushes demand into the surrounding\n               neighbourhoods. That is why the Tall Timber student housing project at BCIT is so\n               important. It creates 470 new affordable student housing spaces with a provincial\n               investment of $129 million, helping reduce pressure in local private rental housing. Alongside the student housing investment, I want to highlight an accomplishment that\n               will matter to thousands of Burnaby families, the 4277 Norland Avenue. This project\n               delivers 155 affordable homes Alongside the student housing investment, I want to highlight an accomplishment that\n               will matter to thousands of Burnaby families, 4277 Norland Avenue. This project delivers\n               155 affordable homes for seniors and seniors with disabilities. The province provided\n               $16.9 million through B.C. Housing's community housing fund, and the project was completed\n               in 2025. This means that a senior who wants to stay in Burnaby can do so, and a couple\n               living on a fixed income can remain close to their friends, their cultural community\n               and their family. These investments matter to the families and communities directly affected, but they\n               also matter to every British Columbian, because we are starting to see the impact\n               of the housing supply across the region. The CMHC reports that the greater Vancouver\n               rental vacancy rate more than doubled in 2025, rising from 1.6 percent to 3.7 percent. Projects like Tall Timber and 4277 Norland Avenue are part of the reason we can point to progress, because when we invest in affordable and student housing, we ease pressure,\n               slow rents and help people tackle everyday costs. If there is one project in Burnaby that captures the heart of what people want from\n               the government, especially in uncertain times, it is the Burnaby Hospital redevelopment\n               and the construction of the B.C. Cancer Centre. When people talk in Burnaby about\n               health care, they talk about the emergency department. They talk about the surgery\n               wait times. They talk about the crowded hallways and about whether their loved ones\n               can get care close to their home. This redevelopment is transformative. It will add two new patient care towers with\n               new units and operating rooms, resulting in 399 beds, a bigger emergency department\n               and a new cancer treatment centre. This province is investing $633.3 million in phase\n               1 and $1.7 billion in phase 2, which includes the B.C. Cancer Centre. The second patient\n               care tower is expected to have 160 new beds and a state-of-the-art cancer treatment\n               centre and a new six-storey pavilion, which will house the new surgery centre. Together, both phases are expected to create 17,548 direct jobs and 6.5 thousand indirect\n               jobs. Even when budgets are under pressure, we will protect the most critical services\n               people rely on every day by strengthening health care and ensuring the system remains\n               responsive to the needs of people. I want to underline something from the province's strategic direction. We are facing\n               global uncertainty and high cost that puts pressure on public finances. But disciplined\n               choices are being made so that we can prevent cuts to critical services and focus\n               resources on what people depend on. This government is choosing to step forward with\n               investments that expand access to modern equality and care. I am incredibly proud of the work that people across our sectors and our province\n               do every day. Their creativity, their resilience and their passion are the reasons\n               British Columbia is known across the world for its culture, its people and its experiences.\n               Even in uncertain times, our province remains strong, diverse and full of opportunity. Our government is taking a careful and responsible approach to this year's budget.\n               But we are not stepping back from the work that makes people's lives better. We will\n               continue to stand with our partners, our communities and our sectors, and we will\n               continue listening, learning and collaborating. Together we will build a strong, sustainable future for tourism, arts, culture and\n               sport in British Columbia, because when we invest in this sector, we are not only\n               making strategic investments to our economy; we are also investing in the well-being\n               and pride of this province. No matter what challenges come our way, British Columbians\n               will meet them together. I support this Budget 2026, and so does my ministry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317151","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is an honour to respond to the 2026 budget here today as the Minister of Tourism,\n               Arts, Culture and Sport and the MLA for Burnaby Centre. I would like to begin by acknowledging that the B.C. Legislature is on the territory\n               of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations. Before I begin, I want to acknowledge the recent tragedy in Tumbler ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["62a0522187edbbfcef3cfd535fb663356f32a40a479924ff0d674de4385a3a38"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["190a6917709e2e719266c286b4e95c78c893e4ef1656a9a6db2385f57e00cb83"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4361ba3ad857dab8a2b1659","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327988,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a privilege to rise in the House today to speak in support of Bill 7, the Post-Secondary\n               International Education (Designated Institutions) Act. As many of us may know in the House, my father came to this province, came to Canada,\n               as an international student, so I am a proud daughter of an immigrant and also international\n               student. I am very thankful for the opportunity that we have, and that's why this\n               bill is very important. Also, as the previous Minister of Post-Secondary and Future Skills, I want to express my continued passion and support for this sector and that it has\n               been a true honour to have worked with the students, faculty, staff, leadership and\n               stakeholders of this sector. Serving in that role has been one of the greatest honours\n               of my public life. Post-secondary education sits at the heart of opportunity for British Columbia. It\n               opens doors for all learners, and it equips people with skills to build careers. It\n               also strengthens communities. It is an economic driver, and it connects our province\n               to the world. We welcome international students in British Columbia. We want them here, and we want\n               them to succeed. We want them to have a life-changing experience when they come to\n               study in our province. Even with the federal government's recent limits on international\n               student allocations, British Columbia remains committed to attracting top learners\n               and delivering an educational experience that is second to none. International students enrich our campuses and our communities. They bring cultural\n               diversity, global perspectives and lifelong connections to all that they meet here. Many become leaders in their fields. Some\n               stay and contribute to our economy and society for the years to come. But while the vast majority of institutions in British Columbia provide high-quality education and act with integrity, we also have seen a minority of bad actors,\n               who have But while the vast majority of institutions in British Columbia provide high-quality\n               education and act with integrity, we also have seen a minority of bad actors who have\n               misled students and damaged our province's reputation. Students have invested their\n               savings, left their families, travelled thousands of kilometres, only to find that\n               the experience they were promised did not match the reality. That is unacceptable. Protecting students and protecting British Columbia's reputation has been a central\n               focus of our government, and in fall of 2024, the Ministry of Post-Secondary Education\n               and Future Skills launched the international education framework. It is a comprehensive\n               plan to strengthen B.C.'s international education sector. That framework included\n               policy changes to raise quality standards, protect our reputation as a destination\n               of choice and enhance supports for international students. The legislation before us today is the next critical step in this work. The Post-Secondary\n               International Education (Designated Institutions) Act will establish a clear legal\n               framework for British Columbia's education quality assurance program, known as EQA. Currently, the EQA program operates through policy. While that policy guides how the\n               program is managed, it is not legally binding. The EQA policy manual and code of practice\n               are not enforceable in law. Government did not have clear legal authority to require\n               institutions to follow them or to take strong enforcement action when institutions\n               fail to comply. This legislation changes that. It turns policy into law. Under this proposed act,\n               institutions will be prohibited from recruiting, enrolling or delivering programs\n               to international students who require a study permit unless they hold a valid designation\n               certificate. The act will set clear legal criteria that institutions must meet to receive and maintain\n               that designation. It will provide government with the authority to conduct inspections.\n               It will establish compliance and enforcement tools, including orders, terms and conditions\n               and, ultimately, cancellation of designation when necessary. It will create a fair\n               and transparent appeals process with an independent appeals officer appointed by the\n               minister. This legislation does not change the quality of standards themselves, but it gives\n               government the legal tools to ensure those standards are met. It strengthens governance,\n               it strengthens transparency and it strengthens protection for students, and that is\n               very important. Let me be clear about what problem we are solving. The EQA program currently operates\n               through policy, not law. That means requirements are not legally binding and enforcement\n               tools are limited. Legislation is needed to ensure that government can fulfil its\n               commitment to stronger oversight and accountability. It is not about adding red tape\n               for the sake of it. It is about ensuring that institutions who benefit from enrolling\n               international students are meeting clear, consistent standards and that students can\n               trust the system that they are entering. The act defines an international student as one who requires a federal study permit\n               because their program is longer than six months. These longer programs typically involve\n               significant academic and financial commitments. They are precisely the situations\n               where strong oversight matters most. Short-term programs of six months or less are\n               not included because they do not require a study permit or designation and generally\n               involve lower commitments for learners. The member opposite asks: \"Is this duplicative?\" Well, it is not. The Degree Authorization\n               Act oversees new degree programs and the use of the term \"university.\" The Private\n               Training Act regulates career training programs offered by private institutions. This\n               new act establishes the standards that both public and private post-secondary institutions\n               must meet and maintain in order to be eligible to enrol international students on\n               study permits. Each act serves a different purpose, and together they create a coherent\n               oversight framework. Others also have asked whether this is the right time given financial pressures on\n               institutions. As Each act serves a different purpose, and together they create a coherent oversight\n               framework. Others also have asked whether this is the right time, given financial\n               pressures on institutions. As government, we recognize those pressures. Institutions\n               are facing global inflation, shifting domestic enrolment patterns and federal caps\n               on international student visas. That is precisely why this legislation matters. When international student allocations\n               are limited, we must ensure that those spaces go to institutions that meet high standards\n               and provide high-quality educational experience. Strengthening oversight reinforces\n               integrity. Integrity reinforces reputation, and reputation is essential for long-term\n               sustainability. Approximately 220 institutions currently hold EQA designation, both public and private.\n               To minimize disruption, all existing designations will automatically transition when\n               the act comes into force. Institutions will continue their designation status and\n               reapply through their normal renewal cycle. New institutions will be able to apply\n               under the new legal framework once it is in effect. The legislation also allows for the introduction of application and annual fees to\n               recover the cost of delivering the designation program. These fees will be set through\n               regulation, guided by principles of reasonableness, transparency and sustainability.\n               They are expected to represent only a small portion of the institutional operating\n               budget. This act also clarifies roles between federal and provincial governments. The federal\n               government oversees immigration, who requires a study permit, caps on intake and who\n               may enter or remain in Canada. British Columbia is responsible for education, for\n               institution quality assurance and student protection. An institution can only be added\n               to the federal designated learning institutions list if it holds British Columbia's\n               official designation. By strengthening our provincial framework, we reinforce our\n               shared responsibility and demonstrate leadership in oversight and accountability. Only one other jurisdiction in Canada, which is Manitoba, has dedicated international\n               education legislation. British Columbia is choosing to lead. We are choosing a legally\n               binding framework rather than a policy-only approach. We are choosing transparency\n               over ambiguity. We are choosing strong governance over reactive cleanup. Throughout\n               the development of this legislation, we have engaged with public and private institutions. We have engaged with Indigenous partners, including the First Nations Education Steering\n               Committee, the Indigenous Adult and Higher Learning Association, and Metis Nation\n               British Columbia.  Their feedback has helped shape a framework that is firm, fair\n               and forward-looking. Quality matters. Integrity matters. Reputation matters. When students choose British\n               Columbia, they are choosing more than just a classroom. They are choosing trust. They\n               are choosing safety. They are choosing opportunity. We have a responsibility to honour\n               that trust, and this legislation is about protecting students. It is about protecting institutions that do the right thing, and it is about protecting\n               British Columbia's global reputation for excellence. We welcome international students,\n               and we value the contribution that they make to our province. We are committed to\n               ensuring that the experience here reflects the very best of who we are, and I am proud\n               of the work the Ministry of Post-Secondary and Future Skills has done to strengthen\n               this sector. I am confident that this legislation positions British Columbia for a strong, responsible\n               future in international education. I support this bill. Thank you for this opportunity\n               to provide my reflections.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327988","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's a privilege to rise in the House today to speak in support of Bill 7, the Post-Secondary\n               International Education (Designated Institutions) Act. As many of us may know in the House, my father came to this province, came to Canada,\n               as an international student, so I am a proud daughter of an immigrant and also international\n               student. I am very thankful","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","label":"International programs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c3f49f7e1b9e8ee915778f0bdcf2e1dbcd2c13dba9e5725356d3e2264d5ab26d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["75c123a75804f576567fb0dd90b871e2af7e2d854422ff54300762ebca3dfa40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035954","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff5f9e85b3a50136187f93f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327989,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327989","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["26674263efa7424e905f283837eb2ea7ab96ad648d57c4edf80c1376e1d92bb5"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b5aadce7756ff5e36c4fbb8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415747,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two sets of introductions today. Today I have some very special friends here: Debbie Pudek, President of B.C. Soccer,\n               and their CEO Gabriel Assis. They are here in celebration today with us. The FIFA\n               Canada Celebrates test event will be going on from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. B.C. Soccer plays\n               a vital role in our communities across our province. As a governing body for soccer\n               in B.C., they support thousands of players and coaches and volunteers. Thank you so much for your work. With B.C. preparing to host matches during the FIFA World Cup '26, organizations like\n               B.C. Soccer are instrumental in building excitement, supporting participation, and\n               creating lasting legacy that extends far beyond the tournament itself. Please join me in welcoming Debbie and Gabriel to the Legislature. My second introduction is.... They couldn't make it into the gallery because of their\n               size, but Maple the moose, Clutch the bald eagle and Zayu the jaguar are here, the\n               mascots and biggest cheerleaders of the FIFA World Cup games. They are outside right\n               now cheering and really getting the environment going. So would the House please make Zayu, Clutch and Maple feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415747","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have two sets of introductions today. Today I have some very special friends here: Debbie Pudek, President of B.C. Soccer,\n               and their CEO Gabriel Assis. They are here in celebration today with us. The FIFA\n               Canada Celebrates test event will be going on from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. B.C. Soccer plays\n               a vital role in our communities across our province. As a gov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21b6b0414f3b8fc6c9d8785e82ca497a7090462b8d37309071accd419385a773"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["082c09f35d1e769942d3596960f827b11b3cf1f085f95b2467e12a537e29fbc8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-db38c9e61074c3982310fd5e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720387,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I sing this song, the song I'm going to share with you is the peace song. The\n               peace song is very sacred to our community, our members. We think of those that are hurting right now. It could be you. It could be you, but\n               you're holding it in. This is the peace song for you to know that you're not alone.\n               You're not alone. We are here for each other. We uplift each other. We give each other\n               strength. So with this peace song, I think of all of you and the ones that we have lost in our\n               communities. We think of the families. So I share this peace song with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720387","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Before I sing this song, the song I'm going to share with you is the peace song. The\n               peace song is very sacred to our community, our members. We think of those that are hurting right now. It could be you. It could be you, but\n               you're holding it in. This is the peace song for you to know that you're not alone.\n               You're not alone. We are here for each other.","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Peacekeeping","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752490","label":"Peacekeeping","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd6ee755434aa4d580d8f6e7164c0797d8d9da0ddadf85e4240c0a3b69fa53cb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c0a186e83f1afa7a2dce4f811f4a5954f49dd9cf1bf94d3ac05878319e9c1c2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a42cac4081b6b3f5bd232c82","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721487,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome a group of guests who are joining us today for B.C. Book Day. With us in the gallery, we have Laraine Coates, the chair of Books B.C. and assistant\n               director of marketing and business development of UBC Press; as well as Michelle Simms,\n               vice-chair of Books B.C. and director of digital initiatives, Orca Book Publishers;\n               and Sarah Faulkner, the executive director of Books B.C. Books B.C. is an amazing\n               advocate for our local publishers, and I'm very excited to see their display today\n               at the reception during lunch hour at the Hall of Honour. Everyone is welcome. Also with us today are Michele Austin, president of Motion Picture Association Canada,\n               and Sydney Grieve, vice-president of public affairs at the Motion Picture Association\n               Canada. MPA-Canada is one of the leading advocates of the film, television and streaming\n               industry around the world. They help Canada secure many big film projects, from Netflix\n               to Disney, Amazon and Paramount studios, and we're so excited to have them here with\n               us. Would the House please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721487","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome a group of guests who are joining us today for B.C. Book Day. With us in the gallery, we have Laraine Coates, the chair of Books B.C. and assistant\n               director of marketing and business development of UBC Press; as well as Michelle Simms,\n               vice-chair of Books B.C. and director of digital initiatives, Orca Book Publishers;\n               and Sarah F","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083675","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083675","label":"Electronic publishing","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["af8e1c597562dd4105218fc041491e6a1f2b39e4cd21d5640eaf1392e7217673"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["909780e59615778a0b489dba3a15e0c06433882e73452a4f63181d2a9df543aa"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-65efb41a5f27c6f640fae4c5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721488,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is Creative Industry Week in the Legislature this week, and I would like to welcome\n               a group of guests to the House who represent the strength and leadership of B.C.'s\n               creative and screen sector. Joining us are Leslie Wooten, executive director of Screen\n               B.C., and Liz Shorten, chief operating officer of the Canadian Media Producers Association. Screen B.C. serves as a strong voice for the motion picture industry, bringing together\n               partners across the sector to support growth, workforce development and collaboration. The Canadian Media Producers Association represents independent producers across the\n               country advocating for a strong... I'm also pleased to welcome Michelle van Beusekom, president and CEO of the Knowledge Network. Knowledge Network plays a unique and\n               important role as B.C.'s public educator broadcaster, supporting and commissioning\n               high quality, commercial-free programming, investing in B.C. creators and sharing\n               stories that reflect the diversity, history, culture of our province. Through its\n               work, it helps ensure that local voices and perspectives are accessible to audiences\n               across British Columbia. We also welcome producers Tyler Hagen and Trish Dolman, whose work continues to showcase the creativity and talent of B.C. Together, these\n               leaders and creators are helping to build a strong, innovative and globally recognized\n               green sector in our province. Please help me welcome all these folks to the B.C. Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721488","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It is Creative Industry Week in the Legislature this week, and I would like to welcome\n               a group of guests to the House who represent the strength and leadership of B.C.'s\n               creative and screen sector. Joining us are Leslie Wooten, executive director of Screen\n               B.C., and Liz Shorten, chief operating officer of the Canadian Media Producers Association. Screen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034590","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034590","label":"Networks","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76981cfafae83ffbec6e3617f88c4c5b4a40dbb158face2c77f4c86ddc981c70"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-995ab6b6c6fdc5949c301d42","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752262,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Anne Kang","venue":"Hansard","text":"On the floor today, I have the pleasure of introducing a colleague and a friend that\n               I have made throughout the years of service. I met Jane Shin when she was running\n               for MLA in 2012-2013 and got to work with her closely in my days as a Burnaby city\n               councillor. We've become very close friends. I also do want to recognize that with her is her beautiful and precious son River,\n               who she had shortly after she retired. Amazing things happened when she retired. She's\n               now currently the VP of students and community development at Vancouver Community\n               College. As well, I want to also make her family feel very welcome here. Her brother Jimmy\n               is in the gallery as well as Mr. and Mrs. Shin. Would the House please make them all feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752262","member_id":"bc-mla-41","member_name":"Anne Kang","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On the floor today, I have the pleasure of introducing a colleague and a friend that\n               I have made throughout the years of service. I met Jane Shin when she was running\n               for MLA in 2012-2013 and got to work with her closely in my days as a Burnaby city\n               councillor. We've become very close friends. I also do want to recognize that with her is her beautiful a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["becd6b6e7a94075c37737b1cff8e730d3752281a58ebed47d9d01daca581b403"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0eec5d23badbee4812a806b227ca2fc82681942c748c8f3934b8819a7dcecc5e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ed0c05c9fdd954eed244773","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317170,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is an honour to rise in support of Bill M231, the Veterans and First Responders\n               Month Act. November is already a month that carries weight in this province and across our country.\n               On November 11, we stand in silence to remember those who served in Canada in uniform,\n               veterans who defended our freedoms abroad, who endured separation from their families,\n               hardship, uncertainty and sacrifice so that we could live in peace and security. They\n               did not serve for recognition. They served because duty called, because their country\n               asked and because freedom, as we know, is not self-sustaining. It is preserved through\n               sacrifice. Designating November as Veterans and First Responders Month builds on that solemn\n               tradition. It recognizes that service does not end overseas. It continues here at\n               home every single day, in communities across British Columbia. As the critic for Public Safety and Solicitor General and as someone who has worked\n               within emergency services, I have seen firsthand what that service looks like. Across\n               British Columbia, in the Lower Mainland, on Vancouver Island, and As the critic for Public Safety and Solicitor General and as someone who has worked\n               within emergency services, I have seen firsthand what that service looks like. Across\n               British Columbia, in the Lower Mainland, on Vancouver Island, in the Kootenays, in\n               northern communities and throughout the Okanagan, first responders operate in very\n               different terrain, but with the same level of professionalism, discipline and courage. In the Lower Mainland, emergency services respond to high-rise structure fires, complex\n               industrial accidents, gang violence, major collisions, overdoses and large-scale public\n               events that require coordinated planning and rapid response. Dispatchers manage overwhelming\n               call volumes while coordinating police, fire and ambulance resources across multiple\n               jurisdictions in real time. On Vancouver Island, responders deal with rugged coastline rescues, highway fatalities,\n               marine incidents, wildfires and domestic violence calls that can escalate without\n               warning. Police, firefighters and paramedics work side by side in communities where\n               geography and weather add complexity to every response. In the Kootenays and Northern British Columbia, distance and isolation change the\n               nature of public safety. Volunteer fire departments protect small towns, and police\n               may travel long distances between calls. Search and rescue teams operate in mountainous\n               terrain, in deep snow, in extreme weather, tracking missing persons and bringing them\n               home safely. Backup may be far away, but the expectation of professionalism never\n               changes. In the Okanagan, rapid growth intersects with rural geography. Firefighters battle\n               interface wildfires that threaten neighbourhoods. Police respond to violent incidences,\n               drug trafficking investigations and marine enforcement on our lakes. Paramedics manage\n               increasing calls linked to mental health and addiction. Dispatchers coordinate emergency\n               traffic across expanding communities. Different regions, different terrain, same commitment. Across all services there are common realities. Long shifts that rarely end when scheduled.\n               Calls that move from routine to life-altering in seconds, exposure to trauma that\n               must be absorbed quietly and professionally. They attend fatal collisions, they respond\n               to overdoses, they enter burning structures, they secure violent scenes, they evacuate\n               neighbourhoods during wildfires, they stand in freezing rain at roadblocks during\n               floods and storms so other emergency personnel can operate safely. They miss birthdays,\n               they miss anniversaries, they leave Christmas dinner because the pager sounds or the\n               radio calls them back. Behind every uniform, turnout gear, a paramedic uniform, a police vest or a dispatcher\n               headset is a family that understands that service often comes first. I have stood\n               in the middle of a residential street in the dark blocking traffic with my patrol\n               vehicle while a home was fully engulfed in flames. There is nothing more impressive\n               than watching a fire department operate at the full extent of its training and ability,\n               the discipline, the coordination, the trust. Firefighters moving into a structure\n               that everyone else is moving away from, focused entirely on protecting life and property. I have been alone on calls in rural British Columbia, where a situation that began\n               as a medical concern escalated without warning into violence. I cannot tell you how\n               many times paramedics who arrived to provide care stepped forward and stood beside\n               me when things became unpredictable. They were there to provide medical treatment,\n               but when the situation changed they did not hesitate. This is not something that appears\n               in headlines. It is simply what first responders do. They protect one another, and\n               they protect the public. I have worked alongside search and rescue volunteers in remote terrain, where no other\n               service could operate effectively. Watching them track a missing person through snow-covered\n               mountains, navigate steep and dangerous conditions, provide medical care in isolation\n               and carry someone out safely is extraordinary. Most of these individuals are volunteers.\n               They leave their homes, their workplaces, their families without hesitation. Emergency dispatchers, too, deserve recognition. They are the calm voice guiding someone\n               through CPR. They are the steady reassurance to a caller hiding in fear. They coordinate\n               multiple agencies in moments of chaos, making rapid decisions that affect lives. They\n               hear trauma through a headset and remain composed shift after shift. Policing is part of this broader public safety system. Police officers, RCMP members\n               serving as provincial contract and municipal officers alike enforce the law, maintain\n               public order and respond to situations involving crime, violence, addiction and mental\n               health crises. They work closely with fire and ambulance services daily. They often\n               secure scenes to so other emergency responders can perform their duties safely. An officer may go from assisting at a motor vehicle collision to managing a violent\n               domestic incident in the span of an hour. An officer may go from assisting at a motor vehicle collision to managing a violent\n               domestic incident in the span of an hour. They may knock on a door to deliver devastating\n               news to a family. They may sit in a hospital room guarding a violent suspect so medical\n               staff can work safely. They may stand at a wildfire evacuation perimeter for hours\n               to protect the neighbourhood. Across all services, what defines them is not only the\n               incidents they attend; it is the consistency with which they show up. Shift after shift, call after call, year after year, they train constantly. They adapt\n               to new threats. They operate under scrutiny. They carry experiences most people will\n               never fully understand, and they carry them quietly. What connects veterans and first responders is not simply the uniform. It is the acceptance\n               of risk in service to others. Veterans accepted risk in defence of our country. First\n               responders accepted risk in defence of our communities. Both understand duty. Both\n               understand sacrifice, but understanding that service is not about recognition. It\n               is about responsibility. This legislation matters because recognition still matters. It creates space for reflection.\n               It allows communities to honour service. It gives schools the opportunity to teach\n               young people about duty, sacrifice and the human commitment behind public safety.\n               It reminds British Columbians that the systems we rely on every day function because\n               men and women are willing to step forward when others step back. Service is not loud. It is not performative. It is often unseen, but it is foundational. I am proud to support Bill M231. I extend my sincere gratitude to every veteran and\n               every first responder across British Columbia — firefighters, paramedics, police officers,\n               search and rescue volunteers, emergency dispatchers and all emergency service workers\n               — who continue to serve with courage, discipline and professionalism. This Legislature has an obligation to recognize that service, and this bill does exactly\n               that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317170","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is an honour to rise in support of Bill M231, the Veterans and First Responders\n               Month Act. November is already a month that carries weight in this province and across our country.\n               On November 11, we stand in silence to remember those who served in Canada in uniform,\n               veterans who defended our freedoms abroad, who endured separation from their families","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ac573254e38e64af5ecb067a24ceaefbae478eb9328cba055846571f1943c36"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8f4a4d293fb4fa2d36052cd7140b05c9d7cdb99648dd6e504d62228e44e56548"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ba088b337c47b25fd4694df","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317171,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to take a moment to recognize two incredible members of my constituency team\n               in West Kelowna–Peachland, Jane Inkster and Nicole Day. Jane and Nicole are often the first point of contact for constituents who are navigating\n               complex issues, whether it's government services, local concerns or simply needing\n               help finding the right direction. They handle those conversations with professionalism,\n               compassion and patience. Every single day, the work they do behind the scenes makes\n               a real difference to the people we serve. I'm grateful for the dedication and proud\n               of the support they provide to our community. Will everyone join me in welcoming them to the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317171","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I'd like to take a moment to recognize two incredible members of my constituency team\n               in West Kelowna–Peachland, Jane Inkster and Nicole Day. Jane and Nicole are often the first point of contact for constituents who are navigating\n               complex issues, whether it's government services, local concerns or simply needing\n               help finding the right direction. They ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5dc2e3c066102dfd57e45c59ce07e7194fb0ffd3cc124dfdc3e75c3696ba0ad"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1cc25dad25da717b1a62027","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317172,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to introduce two representatives from the National Police Federation,\n               the certified bargaining agent representing the members of the Royal Canadian Mounted\n               Police, who serve communities across British Columbia under our provincial policing\n               model. Joining us is Chris Voller, a currently serving member of the RCMP and the director\n               for the Pacific/north region of the National Police Federation. In 2021, Mr. Voller\n               was appointed to the Order of Merit of the Police Forces. He has also been recognized\n               by the International Association of Chiefs of Police as part of their 40 under 40,\n               and he is a recipient of the British Columbia Reconciliation Award. His recognition\n               reflects not only professional excellence but leadership at a time when policing across\n               our province faces increasing demands and expectations. Also joining us is Colin Buschman, the western government relations adviser for the\n               National Police Federation. Since 2021, Mr. Buschman has worked with government partners\n               and stakeholders on issues directly affecting RCMP members and the sustainability\n               of provincial policing. The RCMP provide frontline policing in the vast majority of communities in British\n               Columbia. Their members respond to emergencies, support disaster deployments, and\n               uphold public safety in both rural and urban regions of our province. The Conservative\n               caucus is grateful to have the National Police Federation here today to discuss matters\n               that affect their members and the strength of provincial policing in British Columbia. I ask all members to join me in welcoming them to the Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317172","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to introduce two representatives from the National Police Federation,\n               the certified bargaining agent representing the members of the Royal Canadian Mounted\n               Police, who serve communities across British Columbia under our provincial policing\n               model. Joining us is Chris Voller, a currently serving member of the RCMP and the director\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["36bcd76db80cec2d63a9499c57d9346cf236562f60c5f739ae19888e8e3d3995","76f282d541e441fe68f14366543c9666bb6c416b39c87a7694f62add8f30a945"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e16390a36f77d9cdf70ec3702323ee6a61636e0fc5a8ebffb9d095739e045e72"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-472eddd41c869c080782a1ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328009,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"In my riding, we have a constituent who pays $8,500 per month for a private long-term-care\n               bed and received a notice that it is increasing to","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328009","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In my riding, we have a constituent who pays $8,500 per month for a private long-term-care\n               bed and received a notice that it is increasing to","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Civil law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56348","label":"Civil law","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32416c7e5c7168fea4ece8d8641d2956339f1a2d27808a4ce1eeeaf5a98ce056"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8ee57dbcea1367fc41ea64c683354d6dd8bbf3df317e277a02c319cbe05ded7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-358ecf11918c14f68833a6f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328010,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act 2026. At its core,\n               this legislation is about modernizing how British Columbians interact with ICBC when\n               it comes to basic licensing services. The bill proposes to establish the framework that would allow people to renew or replace\n               certain drivers' licences and identification cards online through ICBC's website and\n               digital services platform. On the surface, that sounds simple and in many ways it\n               is. For many people in British Columbia, renewing a licence should be something that can\n               be done quickly and conveniently without needing to travel to an ICBC office, wait\n               in line, or take time away from work or family obligations. If we can make routine\n               services more accessible and more efficient, that is a positive step. For people living in rural and remote communities, this is particularly important.\n               Many residents in smaller communities have to travel long distances just to complete For people living in rural and remote communities, this is particularly important.\n               Many residents in smaller communities have to travel long distances just to complete\n               what should be a straightforward transaction. In those cases, the ability to renew\n               a licence or replace a damaged or lost card online can make a meaningful difference.\n               It saves time, reduces travel, and allows people to access services that urban residents\n               often take for granted. The intent behind this legislation is understandable. The government is trying to\n               modernize ICBC services that bring British Columbia more in line with other jurisdictions\n               that already offer some form of online driver licensing renewal. Other provinces have moved in this direction and there is value in ensuring that our\n               systems keep pace with modern expectations. However, modernization always comes with\n               responsibility. A driver's licence is not just another government document. It is\n               one of the most commonly used forms of identification in this province. It contains\n               a person's name, address, date of birth, licence number and photograph. In many situations,\n               it is used to confirm identity, verify age or access services. In other words, it\n               carries some of the most sensitive personal information that individuals have. When government proposes to move parts of that system online, the conversation cannot\n               be limited to convenience alone. We also need to consider security, privacy and how\n               personal information will be handled once it enters the digital systems. As the Public Safety and Solicitor General critic, and as someone who has spent many\n               years working in law enforcement, I approach legislation like this with two priorities\n               in mind. First, we should absolutely support improvements that make services faster\n               and more accessible for the public. Second, we must ensure that any modernization\n               protects the personal information of British Columbians and maintains public confidence\n               in the system. Technology can improve service delivery. It can make government more efficient. But\n               technology also introduces new risks if it is not implemented carefully. If we are\n               going to move licensing services into a digital environment, we need to be clear about\n               how that system will operate, how personal data will be stored, who will have access\n               to it and what safeguards are in place if something goes wrong. These are not minor\n               questions. They go directly to public safety, privacy and trust. And those are the\n               questions we must examine carefully as we consider Bill 6. Before getting into some of the concerns I will raise later, it is important to clearly\n               explain what this bill actually does. Bill 6 proposes amendments to the Motor Vehicle\n               Act that would allow certain driver licensing services to be completed online through\n               ICBC's digital platform. In practical terms, it means that many British Columbians\n               would be able to renew or replace their drivers' licences without having to attend\n               an ICBC office in person. Under the framework proposed in this bill, eligible drivers with full licences — classes\n               1 through 8 — would be able to apply online and renew their licence when the renewal\n               simply involves extending the expiry date. In other words, if nothing has changed\n               about the driver's identity or licensing status, that renewal could be completely\n               digital. The same applies to replacing licences that are lost, damaged or destroyed. The bill also allows ICBC to offer online replacement or renewal for B.C. identification\n               cards, for standalone B.C. Services Cards and for the combined driver's licence and\n               B.C. Services Cards. These are everyday transactions that thousands of people in this\n               province complete every year. There are still limits built into the system. Learner licences, for example, will\n               still require in-person visits. That makes sense because those licences are tied to\n               testing and progression through the graduated licensing program. Renewals that involve\n               changes to personal info, such as a change of name or address, would also require\n               a visit in person. That is appropriate. Identity verification still matters and certain\n               transactions should continue to be handled face to face. The legislation also provides authority for ICBC to establish rules about how applications\n               can be made. Applications could be submitted in person, online, or through other prescribed\n               means. It also allows for regulation-making powers related to how licences may be\n               mailed and how interim licences can be issued. There are other housekeeping amendments throughout the bill that update language in\n               the Motor Vehicle Act and align certain provisions with other legislation. Taken together,\n               the changes are intended to support ICBC's broader modernization program. ICBC has\n               been working toward expanding digital services for some time. This bill is part of\n               that longer effort to move routine services online while keeping more complex services\n               available in person. If implemented properly this could reduce wait times at driver licensing offices,\n               particularly for services that require staff attention such as road tests or licensing\n               reviews. By moving basic If implemented properly, this could reduce wait times at driver licensing offices,\n               particularly for services that require staff attention such as road tests or licensing\n               reviews. By moving basic renewals and replacements online, the government hopes to\n               free up appointment capacity for those more complex transactions. In theory, that is a reasonable objective. Anyone who has spent time waiting for an\n               appointment at a driver's licensing office understands the frustration that can come\n               with delays. If routine services can be completed online safely and securely, that\n               could improve the experience for many people. But that is where the word \"safely\"\n               becomes important, because once these services move online, the system will rely heavily\n               on digital records, digital photographs and digital verification of identity. That is where the discussion must be moved beyond convenience. Modernization is good.\n               Efficiency is good. But when identity documents move into digital systems, the security\n               and control of that information becomes a much bigger issue. That is the part of this\n               bill that deserves careful examination. Once we move licensing services into a digital\n               environment, the discussion changes. We are no longer talking about convenience. We\n               are talking about identity information, how it is stored and who has access to it. The driver's licence is one of the most widely used identifying documents in the province.\n               People use it to verify their identity when opening bank accounts, accessing services,\n               boarding flights, picking up prescriptions, renting vehicles and completing countless\n               everyday transactions. It contains a person's name, address, date of birth, licence\n               number and photograph. In many cases, it also links to other services or identity systems. When that information exists on a physical card, the risk is relatively contained.\n               A person controls the card. If it is lost or stolen, the loss is localized to that\n               single item. When the same information exists inside large digital systems, the risk\n               changes. Instead of a single card, you now have databases. Instead of a physical document,\n               you have images and personal information stored electronically, transmitted through\n               networks and accessed through computer systems. That is not inherently a problem. Modern government services depend on digital systems,\n               but the risks that come with those systems need to be taken seriously. As someone\n               who has spent many years working in law enforcement, I have seen how valuable identity\n               information can be to criminals. Identity theft is not rare. Organized groups actively\n               look for ways to obtain personal information that can be used to impersonate individuals,\n               open accounts or commit financial fraud. When large collections of personal information are stored in one place, they become\n               attractive targets. The more complete the data set, the more valuable it becomes.\n               If a database contains names, addresses, dates of birth and photographs, that is essentially\n               a complete identity profile. That is why security matters. When government asks British Columbians to trust a digital system with that information,\n               it has to be confident that the safeguards are strong enough to protect it. People\n               will reasonably ask questions. Where is this information stored? Is it stored within\n               Canada? Is it stored on ICBC systems, or does it rely on outside service providers?\n               How long are digital images retained after a renewal or replacement transaction is\n               completed? Are copies created in backups or archives? What happens if a breach occurs? These are not minor technical questions. They go to the core of public trust. When\n               identity information is compromised, the consequences are serious and long-lasting.\n               Unlike a password, a date of birth cannot simply be changed. A photograph cannot be\n               replaced the way a credit card number can. Once that information is exposed, the damage\n               can follow a person for years. That is why digital identity systems require careful design from the beginning. Security\n               should not be an afterthought. It should not be something addressed later through\n               policy adjustments. If the province is moving toward online driver licensing services,\n               then the architecture of that system — how data is stored, protected and accessed\n               — must be clear and robust from the start. British Columbians should not have to assume that everything will work out. They should\n               be able to see that the safeguards are in place. That is where this bill leaves some\n               important questions unanswered. There is another part of this conversation that deserves careful attention, and that\n               is the handling of digital images. Driver licensing systems rely heavily on photographs.\n               That image is a central part of how a driver's licence functions as identification.\n               It allows police officers There's another part of this conversation that deserves careful attention, and that\n               is the handling of digital images. Driver licensing systems rely heavily on photographs.\n               That image is a central part of how a driver's licence functions as identification.\n               It allows police officers, businesses and other officials to confirm that the person\n               presenting the licence is actually the person to whom it was issued. In the traditional system, that photograph is captured during an in-person visit to\n               a licensing office. It becomes part of the physical card and part of ICBC's internal\n               records. When services move online, the handling of those images changes. Instead\n               of being captured and controlled entirely within a licensing office, photographs and\n               signatures begin to exist within digital workflows. They may be transmitted through\n               online systems. They may be stored, copied, backed up or processed with multiple layers\n               of infrastructure. Anyone who works with digital systems understands a simple reality. Once an image\n               enters a digital environment, control over that image changes. It can exist in multiple\n               places at once. It can be stored in backups. It can pass through systems that handle\n               authentication or verification. It may remain in records long after the original transaction\n               is complete. None of that is automatically unsafe, but it does mean the responsibility\n               to protect those images becomes much greater. A photograph tied to a driver's licence is not just a picture. It is part of a person's\n               identity record. When combined with a name, address and date of birth, that photograph\n               becomes part of the complete identity profile, in that if that information were ever\n               compromised, it would be extremely valuable to someone engaged in identity fraud.\n               This is why the security around those images matters so much. British Columbians want to know how those images are handled in a digital system.\n               Are photographs stored permanently in the same database as other personal information?\n               Are they stored in multiple locations for redundancy? Are they encrypted? Are they\n               ever transmitted outside Canada for processing or storage? If a person uploads or\n               confirms an image through an online process, does that image remain in the system\n               indefinitely, or is it removed once the licence renewal or replacement is completed? These questions are not about opposing modernization. They are about making sure modernization\n               is done properly. If this bill passes, and if ICBC begins offering online renewals and replacements,\n               the government will effectively be asking millions of British Columbians to trust\n               a digital system with more of their most sensitive identifying information. That trust\n               cannot rest on assumptions. It must rest on safeguards that are clearly understood\n               and consistently applied. People should know where their information goes. They should know how long it is stored.\n               They should know what protections exist if something goes wrong. The reality is that once identity information enters digital systems, the consequences\n               of a breach become much larger than the physical card. A stolen wallet affects one\n               person. A compromised database can affect thousands. That is why these questions deserve\n               careful attention before the system is fully implemented. Modernization should make\n               services easier for everyone, but it should never make their personal information\n               vulnerable. There's another issue that needs to be discussed when we talk about moving driver's\n               licensing services into the digital system. It is not just about where the information\n               is stored. It is also about who inside the system can access it. ICBC is a large organization. Thousands of employees interact with licensing systems,\n               customer files and internal databases every day. Most of those employees are professionals\n               who take their responsibilities seriously. But when you build a system that stores\n               identity information for millions of people, you have to design it with the assumption\n               that access must be tightly controlled. That means asking some basic questions. Who inside ICBC can access the information?\n               Can any employee who works in the licensing system search for a person's record and\n               pull up their photograph, or is access restricted to a limited group of employees\n               with specific roles? Are those accesses recorded? Are they audited? Are there systems\n               in place to detect unusual or unauthorized searches? In policing, we deal with these issues constantly. Police officers work with extremely\n               sensitive databases — criminal records systems, police information systems and intelligence\n               databases. Those systems contain personal information, photographs and investigative records.\n               Because of that, access is tightly controlled. Officers cannot simply search those systems out of curiosity. Every query is logged.\n               Every search can be reviewed. Supervisors and auditors can determine Those systems contain personal information, photographs and investigative records.\n               Because of that, access is tightly controlled. Officers cannot simply search those\n               systems out of curiosity. Every query is logged. Every search can be reviewed. Supervisors\n               and auditors can determine who accesses a record, when they accessed it and why. Those\n               controls exist because the information is sensitive and the potential for misuse must\n               always be taken seriously. When we talk about a digital driver's licensing system, the same principle should\n               apply. A driver's licence database contains the identity information of millions of\n               British Columbians. In many ways, it is one of the most complete databases in our\n               province. If that information is accessible internally without strict controls, it\n               creates risk. Across Canada and internationally, there have been cases where employees within organizations\n               accessed personal information without authorization — sometimes out of curiosity,\n               sometimes for personal reasons, sometimes for criminal purposes. This is why internal\n               safeguards matter. If ICBC is going to operate an online system, British Columbians\n               deserve to know what controls exist. Are employees limited to only viewing records if it's necessary for their job? Are\n               there automatic alerts for unusual search patterns? Are access logs reviewed regularly?\n               Are employees trained and monitored to ensure the system is used properly? These are\n               the kinds of safeguards that protect both the public and the institution itself. Without\n               them, even a well-designed digital system can become vulnerable. This bill sets the groundwork for moving driver's licensing services online. That\n               may be a positive step, but the success of that step depends not only on the technology\n               but on the discipline around how the technology is used. Protecting personal information\n               is not only about defending against outside threats. It is also about ensuring that\n               access inside the system is controlled, monitored and accountable. British Columbians should have confidence that their identity information is treated\n               with the highest level of care. That means strong systems, clear rules and real oversight.\n               Those are the kinds of questions we need answers to as this legislation moves forward. Bill 6 moves British Columbia toward a more modern licensing system. It reflects the\n               reality that people expect services to be accessible online. They expect routine transactions\n               to be simple and efficient, and government should be working toward that where it\n               makes sense. Allowing eligible drivers to renew or replace licences online could reduce\n               lineups, improve access for people in rural communities and free up appointment spaces\n               for services that truly require an in-person visit. Those are practical improvements,\n               and they are worth pursuing. But modernization cannot come at the expense of security. A driver's licence is not just another piece\n               of plastic. It is one of the most important documents people carry. It contains the\n               core information that confirms who someone is — their name, their address, their date\n               of birth and their photograph. When that information is moved into a large digital\n               system, the responsibility to protect it becomes greater, not smaller. Government is asking British Columbians to trust that their identity information will\n               be handled safely in this system. That trust cannot rest on assumptions. It has to\n               be built on clear safeguards, strong security practices and strict control over who\n               can access that information. People will want to know where their data is stored.\n               They will want to know how long their photographs are retained. They will want to\n               know who inside the system can view their information and what protections exist if\n               someone attempts to misuse it. Those are not unreasonable questions. They are questions responsible people ask when\n               their identity information is involved. Modern digital systems can improve service delivery, but they also increase the consequences\n               when something goes wrong. A lost card will affect one individual. A compromised database\n               will affect thousands. That is why safeguards around this system have to be strong\n               from the start. The questions raised today are not arguments against modernization, but it's about\n               doing it properly. British Columbians should not have to wonder whether their identity information is\n               protected. They should know that it is. As this legislation moves forward, those are\n               the questions we need answers to. If modernization is the goal, security and privacy\n               must move forward at the same time. If we get that balance right, this system can improve service delivery while protecting\n               the personal information of the people who rely on it. That is the standard British\n               Columbians expect, and that is the standard we should insist on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328010","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 6, the Motor Vehicle Amendment Act 2026. At its core,\n               this legislation is about modernizing how British Columbians interact with ICBC when\n               it comes to basic licensing services. The bill proposes to establish the framework that would allow people to renew or replace\n               certain drivers' licences and identification cards online t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","label":"Licensing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","label":"Licensing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33b651aa90e39938869e620bac60c25a880fa1303cd61f903be3e11c043fe4fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f1cfc23eade75b27d2bc91b1796b4e02f6582a3fab84a6e35cccdc10da6a410"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d4d7de4b818162f6eaa5383d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360410,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"Freedom of information is not an administrative convenience. It is not a procedural\n               courtesy extended by government. It is a structural restraint on power. The Freedom\n               of Information and Protection of Privacy Act exists for a reason. It recognizes that\n               public bodies do not own information in the ordinary sense. Government holds information in trust. Records created, collected and maintained by\n               public institutions are not the property of a political party or cabinet. They are\n               part of the public record of a government that operates on behalf of the people. FOIPPA establishes two core principles. First, that citizens have a right of access\n               to records held by public bodies, subject only to limited and clearly defined exceptions.\n               Second, that government must protect personal information it collects. These two principles\n               work together. They are not in tension. They are the foundation of accountable administration. Access to information is not meant to be comfortable for government. It is meant to\n               ensure scrutiny. It allows journalists to investigate. It allows researchers to analyze.\n               It allows members of this Legislature to examine the actions of the executive. It\n               allows citizens to verify what they are told. Transparency is not ornamental; it is\n               functional. When a government operates transparently, public confidence grows. When access narrows,\n               even incrementally, confidence weakens. That is why amendments to FOIPPA are never\n               minor. They shape the relationship between citizens and the state. They define how\n               easily information can be obtained. They determine how much discretion rests with\n               public bodies. They establish the boundaries of accountability. Bill 9 proposes to amend FOIPPA in several significant ways. It expands the categories\n               under which a public body may apply to disregard a request. It introduces the possibility\n               of charging fees for records that were previously available without cost. It creates\n               a framework for centralized information-sharing through a designated connected services\n               provider. Each of these changes may be defended individually as administrative refinement.\n               Each may be described as modernization. But taken together, they shift the balance\n               between access and discretion. Freedom of information exists to ensure that power is visible. It exists so that decisions\n               made behind closed doors can be examined in the light of day. It exists so that citizens\n               are not dependent solely on official narratives. The question before us is not whether\n               government requires efficiency. Of course it does. The question is whether efficiency\n               is being pursued at the expense of access. When we alter FOIPPA, we are not just adjusting a routine statute. We are recalibrating\n               the boundaries of transparency. If we narrow access, if we broaden undefined discretion,\n               if we make it more costly to obtain records that were previously available without\n               charge, then we are not simply improving process. We are changing the structure of\n               accountability. Government authority in a free society is delegated, it is limited, and it is accountable.\n               FOIPPA is one of the instruments that enforces that accountability. This debate is\n               not whether government should function efficiently. It is about whether the mechanisms\n               that allow citizens to examine government actions remain strong. Freedom of information\n               is not a favour granted by the state. It is a right established in law. That is the\n               lens through which this bill must be examined. Legislation must be examined, not only in isolation but in context. If this were the\n               first time we were debating a bill that expanded executive discretion, perhaps it\n               could be viewed narrowly. If this were the first time concerns were raised about undefined\n               language or concentrated authority, perhaps it could be dismissed as technical disagreement.\n               But it is not the first time. Over the past sessions in this Legislature, we have seen a recurring pattern. Government\n               introduced bills that expand discretionary power. Official opposition raised concerns\n               about constitutional compliance. Amendments were Over the past sessions in this Legislature, we have seen a recurring pattern. Government\n               introduced bills that expand discretionary power. The official opposition raised concerns\n               about constitutional compliance. Amendments were proposed to ensure Charter compliance.\n               Those amendments are continually rejected. At first, one might conclude that these were isolated decisions. A drafting oversight\n               here, an interpretation dispute there, a disagreement over scope. But when the same\n               pattern repeats itself, when warnings about rights are brushed aside, when reasonable\n               amendments are voted down without meaningful engagement, when discretion steadily\n               expands, it stops looking incidental. It begins to look deliberate. The issue is not whether government should have authority. The issue is whether that\n               authority is being extended carefully. In a constitutional system, power is not meant\n               to accumulate without resistance. It is meant to be checked, questioned and justified.\n               When members stand in this chamber and raise concerns about the scope of authority\n               or protection of rights, those concerns should be met with careful reasoning, not\n               dismissal. We have seen legislation where the risks to individual rights were identified early.\n               We have proposed amendments aimed at tightening language and clarifying limits. Those\n               amendments were rejected outright. Not revised. Not refined. Rejected. One could view\n               that once as a disagreement, twice as coincidence. Repeatedly, it becomes something\n               else. Now we are presented with amendments to the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act, the very statute designed to limit executive power by ensuring transparency.\n               This bill expands the categories under which government may seek to disregard a request.\n               It introduces undefined terms. It broadens discretion. Each of these changes may be\n               defined as administrative. Each may be described as necessary for efficiency. But\n               when placed in the broader pattern of expanding executive authority and resisting\n               corrective amendments, they take on greater significance. There is a line between strengthening administration and consolidating power. There\n               is a line between protecting government operations and shielding government from scrutiny.\n               When legislation steadily moves discretion toward the executive while narrowing access\n               for citizens, that line begins to blur. When it blurs repeatedly, eventually it is\n               crossed. Freedom of information exists to ensure that government remains accountable to the\n               governed. If we expand the government's ability to ignore requests, redefine what\n               is excessive, and introduce new barriers to access, then we must ask whether we are\n               still strengthening transparency or whether we are stepping beyond that line. This debate is not about administrative tidiness. It is about the direction in which\n               power is moving. It is our responsibility to say clearly that that direction concerns\n               us. There is another issue that must be addressed in this debate, and it is not partisan.\n               It is institutional. It is legislative literacy. In prior debate in this chamber,\n               members opposite stated that they could not support legislation because other acts\n               prevented it. They claimed that existing law made the proposal impossible. They cited\n               statutory conflict as the reason for rejecting it. But when the text of the legislation\n               was examined carefully, that claimed conflict did not exist. The bill in question applied in clearly defined circumstances. It did not apply broadly\n               to private citizens. It did not override privacy protections. It did not create the\n               sweeping consequences that were asserted in debate. The statutory interpretation offered\n               in opposition to it was simply wrong. That was not a policy disagreement. It was a\n               failure to read and interpret the act correctly. Why does that matter here? It's because we are now debating amendments that introduce\n               undefined and highly discretionary language into the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act. Terms such as \"malicious,\" \"abusive,\" \"repetitious,\" \"excessively\n               broad\" and \"unreasonably interfere with operations\" are being added as grounds upon\n               which a request may be disregarded. These terms are not defined in the act. Their\n               application will depend entirely on interpretation, and interpretation matters. If clearly limited statutory language can be mischaracterized in debate, if members\n               can assert that legislation does something it plainly does not do, then we must ask\n               how undefined discretionary terms will be implemented in practice. Freedom of information depends on careful reading of text. It depends on understanding\n               what is and is not within scope. It depends on discipline and interpretation. If interpretation\n               becomes loose, access becomes uncertain. This is not about scoring political points.\n               It is about institutional responsibility.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360410","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Freedom of information is not an administrative convenience. It is not a procedural\n               courtesy extended by government. It is a structural restraint on power. The Freedom\n               of Information and Protection of Privacy Act exists for a reason. It recognizes that\n               public bodies do not own information in the ordinary sense. Government holds information in trust. Rec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083684","label":"Charter of rights and freedoms","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8644aeeb2d0f4aa289bfe9e132d88042c9c1086ea44d3bbc03862589c5e753d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54e3bd042bbc9f000645bad0092c5b23d31ea1346c5ccd220f52e0689c144dbd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96c4357a60532ec0d00de7c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360411,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"Since the 2023 McDougall Creek wildfire, Lake Okanagan Resort hasn't had potable water\n               and essential utility services. I have been urging this government to use its powers\n               under the Emergency and Disaster Management Act to restore these services. The water\n               system is on private land, and the owner still has not restored, provided access to\n               or made regulatory applications for essential utilities. The government has the power to fix this today. Will the minister, today, commit to\n               using those powers under the act to restore water services to Lake Okanagan Resort?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360411","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Since the 2023 McDougall Creek wildfire, Lake Okanagan Resort hasn't had potable water\n               and essential utility services. I have been urging this government to use its powers\n               under the Emergency and Disaster Management Act to restore these services. The water\n               system is on private land, and the owner still has not restored, provided access to\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f66a16c29175b3f4dc535e6a36e41ab4a5a2ef6b537c0ebedeed1878ea4f491d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9073286b0c15aa0d6ecd841d170f114a16b84b77f5aee43403ee58d33277fcf5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23af7b7ccf8f2f657ef8ecbd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415771,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start in a place where I think everyone in this House agrees. Students should\n               be able to go to school without being disrupted, without being intimidated, without\n               being caught in the middle of conflict. That's not controversial. It's not political.\n               That's just common sense. I don't think there's anyone here who would stand up and\n               say that protests interfering with children getting to school is acceptable. It's\n               not. And I want to be clear about that from the outset, because this matters. There is a responsibility on all of us, regardless of where we sit in this chamber,\n               to ensure that schools remain safe, stable environments for students and for educators.\n               That's the baseline. That's the expectation. And when that expectation is not being\n               met, government does have a role to play. There's no question. That's not really where\n               the debate is. The debate is not about whether students deserve to be protected. They do. The debate\n               is about how government chooses to do that and whether the approach being taken is\n               the right one, because when we talk about legislation like this, it's easy to focus\n               on the intent. The intent sounds reasonable. Protect access, prevent disruption, maintain safety\n               — all things that people would support. But in this place, our job is not just to\n               agree with intent. Our job is to look at the structure behind it, to ask whether the\n               tools being used are necessary, whether they are precise and whether they respect\n               the broader framework of rights and laws that already exist, because good intentions\n               alone don't make good law. And that's where I think this conversation needs to go. That's really where this starts to shift because this bill isn't creating something\n               entirely new. What it's doing is extending something that was always meant to be temporary.\n               When this legislation first came in, it was in response to a specific situation: a\n               rise in disruptions, concern from parents, concern from schools and a need for government\n               to step in. That's fair. That's what government is supposed to do when something is\n               happening in real time. But when something is introduced as temporary, that comes with an expectation that\n               it will be reviewed, that it will be measured and that government will come back and\n               explain clearly why it still needs to be in place. This is where I think we need to\n               slow down a bit because we're being told that the number of disruptions has decreased.\n               We're being told the situation has improved. But at the same time, we're being asked\n               to extend these powers further, and those two things don't quite line up. The issue is declining. If the situation is stabilizing, then the question becomes:\n               what is the justification for continuing and expanding these restrictions? That's\n               not an unreasonable question. That's exactly the kind of question this stage of debate\n               is supposed to answer, because temporary measures aren't just about responding quickly.\n               They're about responding carefully. Temporary measures aren't just about responding quickly; they're about responding\n               carefully. They're about making sure that once the immediate issue is addressed, we\n               don't simply normalize those powers without a clear reason. That's the concern here,\n               not that government acted but that government is now choosing to continue that action\n               without clearly defining what success looks like, without clearly stating what threshold\n               needs to be met for this to no longer be necessary. If that's the threshold — it isn't clear — then what we're really doing is shifting\n               something from temporary to expected, and that's a different conversation entirely.\n               That's why I think it's important that we move beyond just the intent of the bill\n               and really start looking at whether the approach itself is the right one. This is where I think we need to ground this conversation a bit, because this is being\n               framed as a public safety issue. And I agree; it is. If people are being intimidated,\n               if access is being blocked, if there's disorder outside a school, that is a public\n               safety issue. But if it's a public safety issue, then we should be honest about something.\n               We already have the laws to deal with it. They already exist. Police already have the authority to step in, to intervene and, if necessary, to arrest.\n               That's not new. That's not something we're missing. That's already under the Criminal\n               Code of Canada. There are offences that cover this kind of behaviour: intimidation,\n               causing a disturbance, obstruction, harassment. These are not new concepts. They've\n               been around for a long time. They've been tested in the courts, and they have been\n               applied in real situations over and over again. Importantly, they are Charter-compliant. They strike that balance between enforcement\n               and rights. They allow police to act when behaviour crosses the line, but they do\n               it within a framework that has already been challenged and upheld. So when I look\n               at this, the question I have isn't: do we need to act? Of course we do. The question\n               is: why are we acting like there's a gap in the law? There isn't. If someone is blocking access to a school, that can be dealt with. If someone is intimidating\n               others, that can be dealt with. If someone is creating a disturbance, that can be\n               dealt with. Those tools are already in place. What this bill is really doing is not\n               filling a gap. It's changing the approach. Instead of dealing with behaviour through\n               existing criminal law, we're moving to a system where the location itself triggers\n               the restriction. Zone is created, and within that zone, certain behaviour is automatically prohibited.\n               That's a different model, and I think we need to be clear about that. When you move\n               away from conduct-based enforcement, where actions are judged based on what someone\n               is doing, and move toward location-based restriction, where actions are judged based\n               on where someone is standing, you've changed how the law works. I'll say this as simply as I can. I want to live in a province where strong laws that\n               already exist are actually used, where police have the tools and the support to enforce\n               those laws properly, and where people's rights are protected within that system, not\n               in a province where the answer is to bring in new legislation that risks stepping\n               on those rights, because we're not fully using what we already have. Once you start\n               going down that path, it becomes easier to do it again. I think we need to be careful about that. At the end of the day, this is not a situation\n               where police are standing there with no authority. That's not reality. They have authority.\n               They've always had it. The issue isn't whether the law exists. The issue is whether\n               it's being used and whether there are enough resources to actually enforce it. This is where I want to bring up my own experience, because I think it matters in\n               a discussion like this. Before being here, I spent nearly two decades in policing.\n               Part of that time was in general duty, which is patrol, basically out on the road\n               responding to calls. I also served on the RCMP tactical team and was involved in public order deployments\n               across British Columbia. Those are the situations where protests But I also served on the RCMP tactical team and was involved in public order deployments across British Columbia. Those are the\n               situations where protests, demonstrations and large gatherings are actually managed\n               on the ground, not in theory, not in policy but in real time with real people and\n               real consequences. I can tell you that those situations are not simple. They are often tense. Emotions\n               are high. People feel strongly about what they're there for, and they have a right\n               to. That's something that is drilled into you early — that in Canada, people have\n               a right to assemble, they have a right to protest, and they have a right to express\n               themselves. At the same time, there are limits when behaviour crosses into intimidation, obstruction\n               or public safety concerns. So the job of police in those moments is not just to enforce\n               the law. It's to manage that balance. That balance is not something you figure out\n               on the fly. It comes from training, extensive training. We were trained specifically\n               on how to operate in public order situations, how to interpret and apply Canadian\n               law in dynamic environments and how to do that while respecting and upholding the\n               Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. You learn very quickly that clarity in the law matters. You need to know where the\n               line is, and you need to be able to explain that line to the people you're dealing\n               with. When people understand the boundary, most of the time, situations can be managed\n               without escalation. But when the law is vague or when it relies too heavily on interpretation, that's\n               when things become difficult. Different officers may see the situation differently.\n               Different people may understand the rules differently. That's where inconsistency\n               starts to show up. That's not a criticism of police. It's the reality of putting people\n               in a position where they are expected to make judgment calls in grey areas. In my experience, the most effective situations were the ones where the law was clear,\n               where expectations were clearly communicated and where everyone, police and public,\n               understood where that line was. That's what allows for both enforcement and the protection\n               of rights to exist at the same time. So when I look at this legislation, I don't look at it from a policy perspective first.\n               I look at it from what it will look like on the ground, what it will look like for\n               the officers standing there trying to make a decision in real time, what it will look\n               like for the people involved trying to understand what they can and cannot do. From that perspective, the question isn't whether we should act. Of course we should\n               act when there are issues affecting public safety. The question is whether this approach\n               gives the kind of clarity, consistency and balance that is actually needed in those\n               situations. Because if it doesn't, then we're not making the job easier; we're making\n               it more complicated. When I look at this legislation through that lens, not just what it says on paper\n               but how it will actually play out, there are a few concerns that stand out. The first\n               is the language being used. Terms like \"interference,\" \"intimidation\" and \"disruption\"\n               are central to how this legislation works. On their face, those words sound clear\n               enough. Most people would have a general sense of what that means, but when you move\n               from general understanding to enforcement, those terms start to become much less precise. What one person sees is interference, another might see as expression. What one officer\n               interprets as intimidation, another may not. When you're asking police to make those\n               kinds of determinations in real time in a dynamic situation, that lack of precision\n               matters, because the more room there is for interpretation, the more likely it is\n               that enforcement becomes inconsistent. Once enforcement becomes inconsistent, public\n               confidence starts to erode. People don't just look at whether the law exists. They\n               look at how it's applied and whether it feels fair. The next concern is the extension itself. This was not designed to be permanent. It\n               was brought in with a sunset clause, a built-in end date, which is an important safeguard.\n               It forces government to come back to reassess and to justify whether those powers\n               are still needed. What we're seeing now is that timeline being pushed further out. I think it's fair to ask: \"Based on what?\" If disruptions are decreasing, if the situation\n               is improving, then what is the clear threshold that justifies extending these powers\n               for another two years? Without that clarity, what we're doing is shifting something\n               from temporary to ongoing without clearly defining why. That's where concerns start to build — not about the intent. Again, I don't think\n               the intent here is the issue. That's where concerns start to build, not about the intent — again, I don't think\n               the intent here is the issue — but about the structure. Structure is what determines\n               how a law is used, how it's enforced and how it's perceived. If that structure isn't\n               right, if it leaves too much room for interpretation or if it extends beyond what\n               is clearly necessary, then even well-intentioned legislation can create problems. This brings me to something that I think sits underneath all of this and doesn't get\n               talked about enough when we discuss legislation like this: enforcement capacity. At\n               the end of the day, laws don't enforce themselves. You can pass legislation. You can\n               define zones. You can expand authority on paper. But if there aren't enough officers\n               to be present, to respond and to actually enforce those laws, then the impact of that\n               legislation is limited. That's just the reality. This is where I have a real concern, because we're talking about introducing and extending\n               new enforcement tools while at the same time we have not addressed the underlying\n               issue of capacity. Since 2012, the provincial RCMP contingent has not increased. This\n               government hasn't added one additional police officer to the provincial complement. So when we talk about public safety, we need to be honest about what actually makes\n               a difference on the ground. It's not just the law itself. It's whether there are officers\n               available to enforce it, to be present, to respond when something is happening, not\n               after the fact. If there's no one there, or if resources are stretched thin, then\n               it doesn't matter how many powers exist on paper; they don't translate into real-world\n               outcomes. That's why I come back to this point. This is not a situation where police lack authority.\n               The authority is already there. The question is whether we have the capacity to use\n               it effectively. Public safety is built on two things: clear law and the ability to\n               enforce it. You can't separate those. Right now, what I see is a focus on adding or extending legislation without addressing\n               the resourcing that actually makes enforcement possible. If we don't deal with that\n               piece, then we risk creating a situation where expectations are raised but the ability\n               to meet those expectations isn't there. This is where I think it is important to talk about rights, but in a practical way.\n               Sometimes these conversations can drift into theory or legal language that doesn't\n               really connect to how things play out in real life. At a basic level, people in this country have the right to gather. They have a right\n               to protest. They have the right to express themselves. Those are fundamental freedoms,\n               and they're protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. At the same time, those rights are not unlimited. They've never been unlimited. There\n               are clear boundaries when behaviour crosses into intimidation, obstruction or creates\n               a risk to public safety. Again, that's not new. That balance already exists in law.\n               It's something police are trained and understand how to apply. This isn't a question\n               of whether limits should exist, because they already do. The question is how those\n               limits are applied. What this legislation does is shift that balance. Instead of focusing on behaviour\n               that crosses a line, it focuses on where someone is standing. It creates a space,\n               and within that space, certain activities are restricted. I think it's fair to pause on that. Once you move into restricting expression based\n               on location, you're taking a different approach than what we've traditionally relied\n               on. Again, I'm not suggesting there should be no limits. There should be. But those limits\n               should be grounded in clear, established law that has already been tested and understood.\n               I think most people would agree with that. They want to know that there are rules.\n               They want to know those rules are fair. They want to know those rules are applied\n               consistently. From my perspective, that's best achieved by relying on strong existing law applied\n               properly rather than moving toward new layers of restriction that may not be as clear\n               in how they're used. I think it's also important that we don't look at this in isolation, because this\n               isn't the only place where we've seen this kind of approach. We've seen similar measures\n               in other contexts, around health care facilities, around places of worship and in\n               other areas where government has stepped in to create defined spaces and restrict\n               certain types of activity within them. This isn't the only place where we've seen this kind of approach. We've seen similar\n               measures in other contexts — around health care facilities, around places of worship\n               and in other areas where government has stepped in to create defined spaces and restrict\n               certain types of activity within them. Each one on its own is presented as reasonable.\n               Each one is tied to a specific concern. Each one can be defended on its own set of\n               facts. But at some point, we have to step back and look at the broader pattern, because when\n               you start layering these approaches, one after another, you begin to change how public\n               space is regulated. You move from a system where behaviour is the focus to one where\n               location increasingly determines what is allowed. Again, I'm not suggesting there should be no restrictions. There should be, but we\n               need to be mindful of the cumulative effect, because rights don't usually disappear\n               all at once. They narrow. They shift. They get pushed further away from where people\n               actually are. And that's why it's important that each time we consider legislation\n               like this, we don't just look at the immediate issue. We also look at where it fits\n               in the bigger picture, because the decisions we make here don't just apply to one\n               situation. They set a direction. So when I look at this bill as a whole, I come back to a few simple points. No one\n               is arguing against protecting students. That is not in question. Students should be\n               able to get to school safely. Teachers should be able to do their jobs without disruption.\n               And when behaviour crosses the line, there should be consequences. That's a given. But how we get there matters. We already have strong laws in place that deal with\n               this kind of behaviour. We already have authorities that are clear, established and\n               Charter–compliant. And we already have a system that balances enforcement with the protection\n               of rights. This is not about whether government should act. It's about whether government is\n               choosing the right approach. From where I stand, this is not a gap in the law. It's a gap in how we are using the\n               law. And it's a gap in ensuring that enforcement is properly resourced and supported.\n               Public safety doesn't come from adding more layers of legislation. It comes from clear\n               laws applied consistently, with the capacity to enforce them. At the same time, we have to be careful, because when we move toward restricting activity\n               based on location, when temporary measures begin to extend without a clearly defined\n               end, we start to shift how rights are exercised in this province. And those shifts\n               matter. They matter not just in this case but in what they signal going forward. I believe we can protect students. I believe we can enforce law. And I believe we\n               can do both without stepping away from the principles that have guided us for a long\n               time. That's the balance. That's the standard. And that's what British Columbians\n               expect from this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415771","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I want to start in a place where I think everyone in this House agrees. Students should\n               be able to go to school without being disrupted, without being intimidated, without\n               being caught in the middle of conflict. That's not controversial. It's not political.\n               That's just common sense. I don't think there's anyone here who would stand up and\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b6e97938b939b940944afa9ce6c8368fc42cf4166c964b7f1aded730385b4e57"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f5ba817839aff395961189b0e87ae83b6af1e4bbde226a71c64d5e8f6bd21425"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0f86f695e61191133d5a3e27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415772,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to take a moment to recognize that we have a delegation here today from Peachland\n               and West Kelowna, representing communities across the Central Okanagan, including\n               Mayor Patrick Van Minsel and Mayor Gord Milsom. They're here in the legislative precinct\n               today meeting with both government and opposition members to discuss issues that matter\n               to their communities and, quite frankly, the region. These are important conversations,\n               and it's good to see the engagement happening here today. Would the House please join me in welcoming them today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415772","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to take a moment to recognize that we have a delegation here today from Peachland\n               and West Kelowna, representing communities across the Central Okanagan, including\n               Mayor Patrick Van Minsel and Mayor Gord Milsom. They're here in the legislative precinct\n               today meeting with both government and opposition members to discuss issues that matter\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19c3d01520a1f226c807bfeb993aff7f9067962a1852f885fd23f9f3e77d54f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf96eb8abccdb7e0c701393c3ec3e73a4d5bc39020adc45ec4d175358a4ee6ba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-57244f6d64a68d777021f441","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415773,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm going to keep this pretty straightforward. People should be able to go to their\n               place of worship and not have to think twice about their safety. That's it. That's\n               the baseline. But that's not where we are right now. There are people in this province, families,\n               who are making decisions about whether it's safe to attend a service. They're thinking\n               about what might be happening outside before they even get there. That's not normal,\n               and we shouldn't accept that as normal. We've all seen what has been happening. There has been an increase in targeting of\n               religious communities and, in particular, a real rise in antisemitism. That's not\n               something distant. That's happening here in British Columbia. When that's happening, people expect more than statements. They expect action that\n               actually changes the situation. So I don't think there's any disagreement in here\n               about the goal. People should be able to attend worship safely. They should not be\n               intimidated, and they should not be blocked from getting in. That's not a controversial\n               position. Where this starts to matter is how we get there. If we're going to bring in legislation\n               like this, then we need to be clear about what it's actually doing and whether it's\n               dealing with the real issue or just reacting to what we're seeing on the surface. That's what I want to walk through, and this is where I think we need to take a step\n               back for a second. This bill didn't come out of nowhere. Government is responding\n               to something real. There have been incidents. There has been pressure to act, and\n               communities are saying they don't feel safe. That part is clear. But the question I keep coming back to is this: how did we get here? When people are\n               having to worry about their safety just to attend worship, that's not just a one-off\n               issue. That points to something bigger. It tells you that somewhere along the way,\n               the system that's supposed to prevent that from happening isn't doing what it's supposed\n               to do. Now we're here bringing in legislation to deal with it. Again, I'm not saying don't act. Of course, act. But we should also be honest about what this represents. This is government stepping\n               in after the fact, trying to manage a situation that has already escalated to the\n               point where people don't feel safe. I think that matters, because if we don't look\n               at how we got here, then we're just going to keep responding the same way every time\n               something like this happens. There are communities right now that are spending significant money — their own money\n               — just to make sure people can attend services safely. That shouldn't be the expectation.\n               Public safety is not something communities should have to fund on their own. So yes, government is acting here. But at the same time, I think it's fair to say\n               this didn't need to get to this point in the first place. That's why, as we go through\n               this, I think it's important we don't just look at what this bill is trying to do;\n               we also look at whether it's actually getting at the root of the problem. Now, I want to be clear about something before I go any further. We support this bill.\n               People should be able to go to their place of worship without being intimidated, without\n               being blocked and without having to worry about what's happening outside. That's not\n               something anyone should have Now, I want to be clear about something before I go any further. We support this bill.\n               People should be able to go to their place of worship without being intimidated, without\n               being blocked and without having to worry about what's happening outside. That's not\n               something anyone should have to argue for. The idea behind this, creating a way to protect access, to deal with disruption, that\n               part makes sense. But supporting this bill doesn't mean we stop asking questions,\n               because this can't be the only answer and it can't be treated like it solves the problem\n               on its own. This is one piece, and if we're being honest, it's a piece that comes\n               in after things have already gotten to a point where people don't feel safe. What concerns me is when legislation starts to become the go-to response instead of\n               looking at whether the system we already have is being used the way it should be.\n               Because we already have laws, we already have enforcement tools, and we already have\n               the ability to deal with behaviour that crosses the line. While I support what this bill is trying to do, protecting people, protecting access,\n               I think it's important that we don't treat this as the solution. It's not. If anything,\n               this should be a signal that something else isn't working the way it should. And if\n               we don't address that, then we're just going to keep coming back here, adding more\n               legislation, trying to deal with the same issue from a different angle. That's why\n               I think we need to look a little deeper at what's actually happening and how we're\n               choosing to respond to it. That is where I think we need to bring this back to something pretty basic, because\n               this is being talked about as a public safety issue. I agree with that. If people\n               are being intimidated, if access is being blocked, if there's a disruption outside\n               a place of worship, that is a public safety issue. There's no question about that. But if that's the case, then we also need to be honest about something else. We already\n               have the laws to deal with that kind of behaviour. They already exist. Police already\n               have the authority to step in when things cross the line. That authority comes from\n               the Criminal Code of Canada, and it covers the exact types of behaviour we're talking\n               about here. Intimidation, harassment, causing a disturbance, obstruction, mischief,\n               causing fear — these are not new concepts. These are established offences that have\n               been around for a long time. They're not just written down somewhere. They've been used. They've been applied in\n               real situations. They've been tested in court, and they've been shaped over time to\n               make sure they align with the Charter. When I hear that we need to bring in new legislation to deal with this type of behaviour,\n               the question I have is: why? Because from a policing perspective, there isn't a gap\n               here. If someone is crossing the line into intimidation, there are already consequences\n               for that. If someone is blocking access, there are already ways to deal with that.\n               If someone is creating a disturbance that affects public safety, that can be already\n               addressed. That's the system that's in place. It's a system that's designed to balance enforcement\n               with rights. This isn't about whether we have the tools. We do, and we've had them\n               for a long time. The issue isn't the existence of those tools. The issue is how they're\n               being used and whether they're being used effectively. Because when behaviour like this is happening, and communities are still feeling unsafe,\n               that tells you something. It tells you that either those laws aren't being applied\n               the way they should be, or there aren't enough resources to apply them consistently.\n               That's a very different problem than a gap in legislation. When I look at this bill,\n               I don't see something filling a hole in law. I see something stepping in where existing\n               law should already be doing the job. That's why I think it is important that we don't just assume more legislation equals\n               better outcomes. Because if the underlying issue is enforcement or capacity, then\n               adding another layer doesn't fix that. It just changes how we approach it. Before\n               we move further down that path, I think it's worth taking a closer look at what that\n               actually means in practice. This is where I think it's important to understand what this actually looks like from\n               a policing perspective, because there's a real difference between enforcing a criminal\n               offence and enforcing a provincial act. Those are not interchangeable. No matter what authority a province gives police, whether it is the ability to arrest\n               or issue a ticket, it does not carry the same weight as a criminal offence. It just\n               doesn't. A criminal offence operates at a higher standard. It has to be proven beyond\n               a reasonable doubt. An officer needs reasonable and probable grounds to believe that\n               an offence has been committed before taking action. There is a process that follows A criminal offence operates at a higher standard. It has to be proven beyond a reasonable\n               doubt. An officer needs reasonable and probable grounds to believe that an offence\n               has been committed before taking action. There is a process that follows that is structured,\n               well understood and consistent across the country. More importantly, it has been tested\n               over decades in courts, under scrutiny, with challenges that have shaped how those\n               laws are applied. So when a criminal charge is laid, everyone understands what that means. The public\n               understands it. The courts understand it. Police understand it. There is weight behind\n               it. There are real consequences attached to it. And there are tools that come with\n               it that allow that situation to be managed properly beyond just the moment. Provincial ticket is different. It operates at a lower threshold. It's designed to\n               address behaviour quickly and efficiently, usually for regulatory or lower-level offences. Again, there is a place for that. We use those tools every day. The Motor Vehicle\n               Act is a good example. The Liquor Control Act is another. Immediate roadside prohibitions.\n               Those are all examples of where a provincial framework makes sense. Those are situations\n               where the goal is compliance, not escalation. They are not designed to replace criminal\n               law. They are designed to sit alongside it for specific types of behaviour. But what we're talking about here is different. This is not about convenience or efficiency.\n               This is about conduct that, in many cases, already meets the threshold of criminal\n               behaviour. If someone is intimidating an individual trying to access a place of worship, if someone\n               is blocking entry, if someone is creating a situation where people fear for their\n               safety, those are not minor regulatory issues. Those are serious. And if they meet\n               that threshold, they should be treated as such, because once you move away from that,\n               once you start addressing that kind of conduct through a provincial framework, you\n               are lowering the standard of response, and that has real consequences. With a criminal charge, an officer has additional tools. They can release a person\n               on conditions. They can impose restrictions not to return to that location, not to\n               have contact with certain individuals, not to engage in certain behaviour. That creates\n               ongoing protection. It doesn't just deal with the moment. It manages what happens\n               after. This legislation doesn't provide that same level of protection. It allows for an arrest,\n               it allows for a ticket, but it doesn't carry the same follow-through. That matters\n               because public safety is not just about what happens in the moment. It's about preventing\n               it from happening again. There's another point here that I think is important. In British Columbia, it is not\n               common for provincial legislation to grant police the authority to arrest in this\n               way. Typically, those powers come from the Criminal Code of Canada, which is a much\n               stronger and more established legal framework. And there's a reason for that. An arrest\n               is one of the most serious actions the state can take. It is the state limiting someone's\n               liberty. It directly engages the right to life, liberty and security of the person.\n               That's not something that is taken lightly. In our system, that kind of intrusion is justified when someone commits a criminal\n               offence, within a framework that has been tested, challenged and upheld over time.\n               This bill doesn't come with that same history. It hasn't been tested in the same way.\n               And yet it is extending that level of authority into a different context. From a practical standpoint, I'll say this. If an officer is on scene and the behaviour\n               meets the threshold of a criminal offence, they are going to use the criminal charge\n               every time, because it gives them stronger authority. It gives them clearer direction,\n               and it gives them better tools to actually protect the people involved. So when I look at this, I don't see something that strengthens policing. I don't see\n               something that simplifies decision-making. If anything, it creates a parallel option\n               that doesn't carry the same clarity or consequences as what already exists. That doesn't\n               make the job easier. At the end of the day, if someone commits a criminal act, they should be dealt with\n               through criminal law. That's what the system is there for. The response should match\n               the seriousness of the behaviour, because the punishment should fit the conduct. I want to talk about something that I think sits at the centre of this, because this\n               bill doesn't exist in a vacuum. It exists because communities don't feel safe. When\n               you get to a point where people are relying on legislation like this just to be able\n               to access a place of worship, you have to ask why. Right now there are communities in this province, particularly Jewish communities,\n               that are spending significant money on private security — not occasionally; every\n               month. We're talking about over $100,000 a month being spent just to make sure people\n               can attend services safely. Now think about that for a second: families going to worship, and security has to\n               be part of the plan. That shouldn't be the expectation in British Columbia. Now, think about that for a second: families going to worship and security has to\n               be part of the plan. That shouldn't be the expectation in British Columbia. And what\n               makes it worse is this. They're not just paying for that security. They're being taxed\n               on it — 7 percent on PST. Something they are being forced to put in place because\n               they don't feel protected otherwise. That's not right. Public safety is not something that should be downloaded onto communities. It's not\n               something people should have to fund themselves just to feel safe doing something\n               as basic as attending worship. That's the responsibility of the government. So yes, this bill is a step. It acknowledges that there's a problem, but it doesn't\n               address why communities are in the position to begin with. Because if people still\n               feel the need to hire private security after this passes, then what has really changed?\n               That's the question. You cannot solve a public safety issue by shifting the burden onto the people who\n               are being affected by it. You cannot treat legislation like this as the solution when\n               the underlying issue hasn't been addressed. Because at the end of the day, people\n               don't want access zones. They don't want security barriers. They don't want to think\n               about any of this. They just want to be able to go to their place of worship and feel\n               safe. And right now, too many people don't. I think we also need to talk about what's happening underneath all of this, because\n               situations like this don't just show up on their own. When communities start to feel\n               less safe, when people start changing their behaviour, thinking twice about where\n               they go or what they do, there's usually a reason behind it. Right now, the provincial RCMP contingent sits at 2,602 officers. That number hasn't\n               changed since 2012. Over a decade, not one additional officer has been added to the\n               provincial contingent. Think about everything that has changed over that same time period. Population has\n               grown. Communities have expanded. The demands on policing have increased. The complexity\n               of the work has increased. But the number of provincially funded officers has stayed\n               exactly the same. So I think it's more than fair to ask, has that had an impact? Has\n               that contributed to what we're seeing now? Because policing isn't static. You don't just hold the line at the same level and\n               expect the outcome to stay the same when everything around it is changing. When capacity doesn't keep up with demand, pressure builds. And eventually that pressure\n               shows up somewhere. It shows up in response times. It shows up in how quickly police\n               can get to a situation when something is happening. It shows up in visibility, whether\n               there are officers present in communities in a way that people can actually see and\n               feel. That visibility matters because policing isn't just reactive. Presence alone\n               changes behaviour. It deters. It reassures. It creates a sense that someone is there\n               and that something will happen if the line is crossed. When that presence starts to thin out, people notice. They may not always be able\n               to explain it in technical terms, but they feel it. And when people feel that absence,\n               they adjust. They start looking for ways to fill the gap themselves, which is exactly\n               what we're seeing here — places of worship bringing in private security and communities\n               organizing their own security measures, spending significant amounts of money just\n               to create a level of security that should already be there. This is not how this is\n               supposed to work. Public safety is a core responsibility of government. It is not something that should\n               be downloaded onto communities, especially communities that are already dealing with\n               being targeted. And if there had been a sustained effort over the years to increase\n               that provincial complement, even gradually, more officers, more presence, more capacity,\n               that would have had an impact. More officers on the ground means more visibility.\n               More visibility means stronger deterrence. Stronger deterrence means fewer situations\n               escalating to the point where people feel unsafe. That's the connection. I believe that would go a long way toward what we're talking about here: people being\n               able to attend their place of worship without hesitation, people feeling secure in\n               their communities without needing to think about additional measures. Because at the end of the day, public safety isn't built through legislation alone.\n               It's built through presence. It's built through capacity. It's built through making\n               sure that when something happens, there are people there to deal with it. And if we\n               don't address that piece, then there's always going to be reacting after the fact,\n               instead of preventing it in the first place. So when I look at this bill, I see something that is necessary. But I also see something\n               that shouldn't have been necessary. People should not be in a position where they\n               need added protections just to attend worship. It should already be given The fact that we're here tells us something. It tells us that something in the system\n               isn't working the way it should. People need to be protected. Access needs to be protected.\n               When there are real concerns about safety, government has to step in. But we shouldn't pretend that this is the solution, because it's not. If the underlying\n               issues aren't addressed, if enforcement isn't consistent, if resources aren't there,\n               if communities are still left to protect themselves, then nothing really changes.\n               That's what I keep coming back to. People in this province should not have to think about security when they go to worship.\n               They shouldn't have to wonder what's happening outside. They shouldn't have to rely\n               on private measures just to feel safe. That's the standard, and right now we're not\n               there. Yes, this bill is a step, but it's not the answer. The answer is making sure\n               that the systems we already have are working the way they're supposed to, that the\n               laws that already exist are being enforced and that the resources are there to support\n               that. At the end of the day, this comes down to something simple. People want to feel safe\n               where they live, they want to feel safe practising their faith, and they want to know\n               that the system is there to support that. That's the expectation, and that's what\n               we should be delivering.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415773","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm going to keep this pretty straightforward. People should be able to go to their\n               place of worship and not have to think twice about their safety. That's it. That's\n               the baseline. But that's not where we are right now. There are people in this province, families,\n               who are making decisions about whether it's safe to attend a service. They're thinking\n   ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["119325b6c5bb5059a1ba16d42b4f4b89217646bcff0da1f98719e836694f008b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ced945e56ad18847a04c0b7c753b63615d0e162206ec24f336506538b61a84f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ba8ec8c53c4474d063d2c961","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415774,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to recognize a delegation here today from the B.C. Police Association. This\n               organization represents front-line municipal police officers serving across British\n               Columbia, including in Vancouver, Victoria, Saanich, Abbotsford, New Westminster,\n               Delta, Port Moody, West Vancouver, Central Saanich, Oak Bay and Nelson. They are here today meeting with the B.C. Conservative caucus to discuss issues impacting\n               their members and the state of public safety across British Columbia. These are important\n               conversations as we, on this side of the House, look forward to engaging with them. Would the House please join me in welcoming them to the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415774","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to recognize a delegation here today from the B.C. Police Association. This\n               organization represents front-line municipal police officers serving across British\n               Columbia, including in Vancouver, Victoria, Saanich, Abbotsford, New Westminster,\n               Delta, Port Moody, West Vancouver, Central Saanich, Oak Bay and Nelson. They are here today meeting with t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["439fcbf3dcad09bb4749b1535d57d5010a9e11deb9323582a64c4800ac5807ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d838169b93b99d25cac5a4c06b5114238ff8ddca260565ffd67b4eb256f382f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7de0b9001f849836ac45e172","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415776,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I, too, would like to introduce my Peachland delegation that's here, as the minister\n               across the aisle did. I'll start off with Patrick Van Minsel, the mayor of Peachland; CAO, Joe Creron; and\n               Councillor David Collins, all here with us today. I just want to recognize that they've been here for a week having meetings with ministers\n               and official opposition critics on all things important to Peachland. Will the House please join me in welcoming them to the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415776","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I, too, would like to introduce my Peachland delegation that's here, as the minister\n               across the aisle did. I'll start off with Patrick Van Minsel, the mayor of Peachland; CAO, Joe Creron; and\n               Councillor David Collins, all here with us today. I just want to recognize that they've been here for a week having meetings with ministers\n               and official opposition","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28718a5d9f46f5a7824fb9d1dec3259367cb2ddfb50a13e700dc8b54a0cb6825"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e7834887c30ac14623ffcf4f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415777,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, and specifically\n               to the parts of this legislation that are being presented as addressing safety within\n               supporting housing. Let me say this at the outset. Safety in supporting housing matters. It matters to the people who live there. It matters to the workers who show\n               up every day. And it matters to the communities around these buildings who are relying\n               on the system to function properly, because when it doesn't, we don't see small consequences.\n               We see escalation. We see instability. And in many cases, we see real risk, both to\n               the people inside those buildings and the people responding to them. Now, this bill is being framed as a step toward improving safety. But when you actually\n               read it, when you look at what it does, and just as importantly, what it does not\n               do, a very different picture starts to emerge. This legislation creates new powers. It creates new mechanisms and, in particular,\n               it introduces a pathway to end a tenancy based on the presence of a weapon. On its\n               face, that sounds reasonable. Most people would hear that and think: \"Of course, that\n               makes sense.\" But legislation isn't judged on how it sounds; it's judged on how it\n               works. And the moment you move from how this sounds to how this actually would be applied on the ground, you run into a very real problem. Because this bill does not\n               clearly define what a weapon is, and that is not a small oversight. That is the foundation\n               of the entire provision. If you are going to create a law that allows someone to be removed from their housing,\n               you need to be absolutely clear about what triggers that consequence. Not vague, not\n               left open, not deferred to regulation at some other date. Very clear. Because without\n               that clarity, you are not creating safety. You are creating uncertainty for tenants,\n               for staff and for the people who will ultimately be expected to respond when something\n               goes wrong. That's where I want to focus, because the difference between something that looks\n               like safety in legislation and something that actually functions as safety in the\n               real world comes down to whether the people on the ground understand exactly what\n               they're dealing with and exactly what they're expected to do. And right now, this\n               bill does not give them that. This is where the problem becomes very real, because when we talk about a weapon,\n               most people picture something obvious: a firearm, a large knife, something clearly\n               designed to cause harm. But that's not how this actually works in the real world,\n               and it's not how the law treats it either. Under the Criminal Code of Canada, section 2, a weapon is defined broadly, and intentionally\n               so. It is not limited to firearms and knives. It includes anything used, designed\n               to be used, or intended to be used to cause injury or to threaten or intimidate another\n               person. That means a weapon is not just about what something is. It's about how it's\n               used. That distinction matters because a knife on its own is not necessarily a weapon. It\n               depends on the context. It depends on the intent, and the law recognizes that. In\n               fact, we see this play out very clearly in the courts when conditions are imposed\n               on someone after they are released. A judge doesn't just say \"do not possess a knife,\"\n               because everyone understands that a knife can mean many things. It could be a machete.\n               It could be a large combat-style knife. Or it could be something as simple as a butter\n               knife. So the courts are precise. They will say \"you are not to possess a knife, except for\n               a knife used in the preparation of food or except under The courts are precise. They will say: \"You are not to possess a knife except for\n               a knife used in the preparation of food or except under specific, clearly defined\n               circumstances.\" And that level of clarity is not accidental. It exists so that police\n               know when a condition has actually been breached. The individual understands what\n               is allowed, and what is not. And a judge after the fact can fairly determine whether\n               an offence occurred. Because without that clarity, you create confusion. You create inconsistency. And\n               you risk punishing behaviour that was never intended to be captured in the first place.\n               Because without that level of clarity, you create absurd outcomes. A person preparing\n               food in their unit, using a knife for its intended purpose, should not be put in a\n               position where the same subject, without context, could trigger enforcement or eviction.\n               That is why the courts are precise. Because they understand that the object is not\n               the issue; the behaviour is. Take that reality and apply it to this bill. Because here, we are not talking about\n               a criminal charge; we were talking about someone losing their housing. And yet the\n               legislation does not clearly define what a weapon is. It leaves that to regulation.\n               It leaves that to interpretation. And that creates a very real problem. Because in supportive housing environments, the distinction between a tool and a weapon\n               is not a theory. It happens in real time. A kitchen knife used to prepare food is\n               not a weapon, but that same knife held in a threatening way during a conflict becomes\n               one. A piece of broken furniture, a tool, even something as simple as a rock can become\n               a weapon depending on how it is used. That's the reality that the law has to account for. Because if you don't clearly define\n               what triggers action, then the people on the ground are left to guess. And in situations\n               involving potential violence, guessing is not acceptable. And this is where the issues move beyond definition and into real-world risk. Because\n               once you accept that a weapon is not always obvious, that it can be anything depending\n               on how it's used, the next question becomes unavoidable. Who is expected to deal with\n               that? Because this bill creates the condition, but it does not clearly define the response.\n               It does not say who makes the call that something is a weapon, who is responsible\n               for intervening and what that intervention is supposed to look like in the moment.\n               And that matters because in supportive housing environments, those situations do not\n               happen in a controlled setting. They happen quickly. They escalate unpredictably.\n               And they often involve people who are already in crisis. Now, I have dealt with these kinds of calls, and I can say this clearly. A situation\n               involving a weapon, real or perceived, is not a low-risk situation. It is a high-risk\n               call. It is the kind of call that requires training, equipment and backup. When police respond to someone who is armed or potentially armed, they do not walk\n               into that situation casually. They assess. They coordinate. They rely on their training.\n               They have tools available to them: a firearm; a baton; OC spray; communication skills;\n               and most importantly, backup. Because even with all that in place, those calls are\n               still unpredictable. They can turn in seconds. Now, compare that to who is actually present in supportive housing: housing staff,\n               support workers, in some cases volunteers. People who are there to provide support,\n               not to manage violent encounters, not trained to assess threat levels in the moment,\n               not equipped to intervene safely and not backed by immediate support when something\n               escalates. And yet under this framework, they are the ones most likely to be first on scene.\n               They are the ones who will see the behaviour. They are the ones who will have to decide.\n               Is this a weapon? Is this a threat? Do I act? Do I wait? Do I call police? Those decisions\n               are being made without clear legislative guidance. Let me walk through how this actually\n               plays out. A staff member observes a tenant in distress. There's an object in their hand. Maybe\n               it's a knife. Maybe it's something else. It's not immediately clear whether it meets\n               the threshold of a weapon. Now, that staff member has to make a decision. Do they\n               intervene? Do they wait? Do they call police immediately? Because once police are\n               called, this is no longer a low-level situation. This becomes a high-risk response.\n               If that call is delayed because the situation wasn't clearly understood, then by the\n               time the police arrive, the risk has been escalated. That is how these situations unfold — not in a controlled, clearly defined way, but\n               in real time with incomplete information and real consequences. That is not a safe\n               system because hesitation in those environments can lead to escalation, and overreaction\n               without clear standards can lead to unnecessary conflict. Either way, the people placed in that position are being asked to manage risks that\n               they Either way, the people placed in that position are being asked to manage risks that\n               they were never trained to manage. That is not fair to them, and it is not fair to\n               the tenants. It is not fair to the first responders who will ultimately be called\n               when something goes wrong, because by the time the police are brought in, the situation\n               has already escalated. Now we are no longer dealing with prevention; we are dealing\n               with response. This brings us to the core issue with this bill. When you step back and look at it\n               as a whole, what it is really focused on is removal, ending a tendency, removing someone\n               from a unit, creating a mechanism to push risk out of a building. Again, on its face,\n               people hear that and think that makes sense. If there's a problem, remove it. But\n               that's not how safety actually works. Removing someone after a situation has escalated,\n               after a weapon is involved, after a threat has been made, is not prevention. That\n               is response. Often it's a late response, because by the time you are invoking these provisions,\n               the risk has already materialized. The situation has already reached a point where\n               someone feels threatened, where staff are concerned, where police may already be involved.\n               The question becomes: what has this bill done to stop that from happening in the first\n               place? The answer, when you look at it carefully, is: very little. The reality in supportive housing is this. The behaviours that lead to these incidents\n               do not appear out of nowhere. They're connected to unmanaged addiction, untreated\n               mental health issues, unstable environments and a lack of consistent, structured support.\n               Those are the drivers. That is where risk begins. This legislation does not address those drivers. Instead, it focuses on what happens\n               at the end of the chain. It creates a mechanism to remove someone from the situation\n               if it becomes serious enough. And what happens next? That individual does not disappear.\n               They do not suddenly become more stable. They are simply moved to another building,\n               perhaps another neighbourhood, another part of the system that is dealing with the\n               same pressures and often without the supports they needed in the first place. The behaviour continues, the risk reappears, and the cycle repeats. We remove someone\n               from one building, but we do not remove the underlying issue. What happens? That individual\n               ends up somewhere else — another building, another neighbourhood, often the same conditions,\n               the same pressures and the same lack of support. And the behaviour does not disappear.\n               It follows them, and now another group of staff, another group of residents, are dealing\n               with the exact same risk. This is not resolution; this is repetition. This is not a solution; this is displacement.\n               We have seen this pattern before. We move the problem instead of solving it. We respond\n               to the outcome instead of addressing the cause. Then we wonder why these same issues\n               continue to show up in different places under the same conditions. If the goal of this legislation is truly safety, then it cannot stop at eviction.\n               It has to address what is happening before that point. It has to reduce the likelihood\n               that these situations occur at all. Right now this bill does not do that. This is where the gap in this legislation becomes even more clear. While this bill\n               focuses heavily on the idea of weapons, it largely ignores the risks that are most\n               commonly present in these environments — the risks that actually drive calls for service,\n               the risks that put people in danger on a daily basis. One of the biggest of those risks is fire — not theoretical risk, real risk. We're\n               talking about open flames inside units, butane torches being used indoors, improvised\n               heating or cooking methods and electrical setups that are unsafe. These are not rare\n               situations. These are the kinds of conditions that lead to fires that put entire buildings\n               at risk, not just one unit. That puts other tenants at risk, that puts staff at risk,\n               and that puts fire crews in danger when they have to respond. Yet when you look at this legislation, those realities are not the focus. Instead,\n               see an emphasis on control measures tied to individuals rather than addressing the\n               conditions that create the danger in the first place. It doesn't stop at fire risk.\n               There are also ongoing issues tied to drug use within units — the storage of substances\n               and the presence of materials that can be volatile or hazardous. Again, these are\n               not isolated issues Again, these are not isolated issues. They are part of the day-to-day reality in many\n               of these buildings, and they require coordinated response, not just from housing operators\n               but from fire services, paramedics and police officers, because each of those services\n               sees a different part of the problem. Fire sees the hazard, paramedics see the medical\n               impact, police see the escalation and the risk to others. But this bill does not bring those perspectives together. It does not create a framework\n               that reflects how these situations are actually managed on the ground. Instead, it\n               narrows the focus. It identifies one type of risk, labels it in broad terms and builds\n               a response around removal. In doing so, it misses the bigger picture. Safety in supportive housing is not defined by a single factor. It is the result of\n               multiple risks interacting at the same time. Fire risk, health risk, behavioural risk,\n               environmental risk. If you do not address those together, you are not improving safety.\n               You are only addressing part of the problem and leaving the rest in place. When we talk about safety in these environments, we cannot ignore the people who are\n               there every day — the staff, the support workers, the people tasked with managing\n               these buildings and supporting the individuals who live in them. Right now, under\n               this framework, they are being placed in the middle of all of this. They are expected\n               to observe behaviour, to assess risk, to determine when something crosses a line,\n               and in the case of this bill, to recognize when something constitutes a weapon and\n               to decide what to do next. But let's be clear about what we are asking of them. These are not police officers.\n               They are not trained to respond to high-risk, potentially violent situations. They\n               do not have the tools, the authority or the backup that is required to safely intervene\n               when someone is armed or acting in a threatening way. Yet they are the ones who will be the first to encounter these situations. They are\n               the ones who will have to make that call. That puts them in an incredibly difficult\n               position, because if they hesitate, if they are unsure whether something meets the\n               threshold, the situation can escalate. And if they act without clear guidance, they\n               risk inflaming a situation that could otherwise have been managed differently. Either way, they are being asked to manage risks that the legislation has not properly\n               defined. That is not fair to them. It is not fair to place that level of responsibility\n               on individuals without giving them the clarity, the structure and the support they\n               need to do it safely. And it is not just about physical safety. There is also the\n               reality of what they are exposed to on a daily basis — high-stress environments, unpredictable\n               behaviour, situations that can shift very quickly. Adding uncertainty on top of that, especially around something as serious as potential\n               weapons, does not improve safety. It increases pressure, it increases risk, and it\n               increases the likelihood that something will go wrong. Because when systems are unclear,\n               the burden does not disappear, it gets pushed down. On to the people on the front\n               lines, the people with the least authority to change the situation but the most exposure\n               to its consequences. If this legislation is serious about safety, then it needs to\n               reflect the reality of who is actually carrying that responsibility, and right now\n               it doesn't. When you step back from the individual provisions in this bill, there is a broader\n               issue that cannot be ignored. Because this legislation does something very deliberate.\n               It creates powers and law, but it leaves the details to regulation. Over and over\n               again, key elements of how this weapon will actually function, what qualifies as a\n               weapon, how tenancy agreements can be changed, when access can be restricted, what\n               procedures are followed are not clearly set out in the legislation itself. They are\n               deferred, left to be determined later by cabinet. That matters, because there is a fundamental difference between what is written into\n               law and what is left to regulation. When something is in legislation, it is debated\n               in this chamber, it is scrutinized, it is visible to the public. But when it is placed\n               in regulation, those decisions can be made without the same level of transparency,\n               without the same level of debate, and without the same level of accountability. In some cases, regulation is appropriate, but not when you are dealing with things\n               like this. Not when you are creating powers that can remove someone from their housing.\n               Not when you are dealing with safety, risk and the responsibilities of people on the\n               ground. Those are not minor administrative details. Those are the core elements of\n               how this system will operate. Yet instead of Those are not minor administrative details. Those are the core elements of how this\n               system will operate. Yet, instead of clearly defining them in law, this bill pushes\n               them out to be decided later. That creates two problems. First, it creates uncertainty because the people who are expected to work within this\n               system — staff, operators and first responders — do not have a clear framework to\n               rely on. They are being asked to operate within rules that are not fully defined. Second, it creates a lack of accountability because if the system does not work as\n               intended, if there are unintended consequences, if people are put at risk, those decisions\n               were never fully tested here. They were never fully debated. That is not how legislation\n               dealing with safety should be structured. If the government is confident in these powers, then they should be clearly laid out\n               in this bill so that everyone understands them; so that they can be properly examined;\n               and so that the people affected by them, both tenants and workers, know exactly where\n               they stand. Because clarity is not optional in a system like this, it is essential.\n               Right now, that clarity is missing. When we talk about safety, especially in environments like supportive housing, we\n               have to be honest about what that actually means. Safety is not created by broad language\n               in legislation, it is not created by leaving key definitions unresolved and it is\n               not created by introducing powers that only take effect after a situation has already\n               escalated. Safety is created through clarity — clarity in what constitutes a threat,\n               clarity in who is responsible for responding and clarity in how that response is carried\n               out. In the absence of that clarity, what you do not get is flexibility. What you do not\n               get is consistency. You get hesitation in moments where decisions need to be made\n               quickly. You get uneven application from one building to the next. Ultimately, you\n               get a system that does not function the way it was intended. This bill had an opportunity. An opportunity to bring forward a framework that reflects\n               the realities on the ground. A framework that recognizes the risk in supportive housing\n               is not defined by a single factor but by a combination of behaviour, environment and\n               available support. It could have brought together the perspectives of those who actually respond to these\n               situations — police, fire, paramedics and the workers who are there every day. It\n               could have provided clear definitions, clear roles and a coordinated approach to managing\n               risk before it escalates. Instead, what we have is a piece of legislation that focuses on one outcome, removal,\n               without fully addressing how we prevent situations from reaching that point; without\n               clearly defining the threshold that triggers that outcome; and without ensuring that\n               the people responsible for managing these environments have the tools, the guidance\n               and the support they need to do it safely. The consequences of getting this wrong are not theoretical. They are very real. They\n               affect the safety of tenants, they affect the safety of workers and they affect the\n               safety of the broader community. If we are serious about improving safety in supportive housing, then we need to do\n               more than create mechanisms to respond after the fact. We need to build systems that\n               reduce risk in the first place; that provide clear direction; that support the people\n               on the front lines; and that ensure that when something goes wrong, there is no confusion\n               about how it is handled. Safety is not defined by what we intend. It is defined by what actually happens when\n               the system is put to the test. Right now this bill leaves too much uncertainty in\n               the moments that matter most.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415777","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 11, the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, and specifically\n               to the parts of this legislation that are being presented as addressing safety within\n               supporting housing. Let me say this at the outset. Safety in supporting housing matters. It matters to the people who live there. It matters to the workers who show\n               up every day. ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","label":"Weapons","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["01c5a324b0ef651c95e14ffe872dd9d885bd4525747404687695bdfe6b9ca614"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e18c0e1dece76cd4e1b01b5b1a2080427da25cdf633fc3e5f8c06bad91b582ac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Weapons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52680","primary_category_id":"concept-43397","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-add1b075c44e5edc85253e21","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721548,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize two organizations doing important work supporting seniors\n               of West Kelowna–Peachland, the west side health network and the Peachland Wellness Centre. In communities like West Kelowna and Peachland, one of the things we hear consistently\n               from residents is how difficult it can be to access services, not just health care\n               but the broader supports that people rely on every day. It's not always one issue.\n               It's navigating a system that can feel disconnected, where people are trying to figure\n               out where to go, who to call and how to get the help they need. That's where these\n               organizations step in, not as replacements for the system but as something just as\n               important — connectors, supports and community anchors. The west side health network plays a key role in bringing people and organizations\n               together. It's about coordination, making sure services are aligned, that information\n               is shared and that gaps are identified before people fall through them. That kind\n               of work often happens behind the scenes, but it has a real impact. When organizations\n               are connected, outcomes improve, people get help sooner, and they don't get lost trying\n               to navigate the system on their own. At the same time, the Peachland Wellness Centre is delivering something just as important,\n               local, accessible support right in the community. It's a place where people can go,\n               a place where they can connect, a place where support isn't abstract. It's right there,\n               right in front of them. For many residents, especially seniors and those living alone At the same time, the Peachland Wellness Centre is delivering something just as important\n               — local, accessible support right in the community. It's a place where people can\n               go, a place where they can connect, a place where support isn't abstract. It's right\n               there, right in front of them. For many residents, especially seniors and those living alone or dealing with complex\n               needs, that kind of local access makes all the difference. It's not just about services.\n               It's about connection, prevention and making sure people don't reach a crisis point\n               before they get help. And that's something we should all recognize, because strong\n               communities aren't built only through large systems. They're built through local leadership,\n               volunteerism and organizations that understand the people they serve. That's exactly\n               what we're seeing here in West Kelowna and Peachland. So today I want to recognize and thank everyone involved with both the Westside health\n               network and the Peachland Wellness Centre, the staff, the volunteers and the partners\n               who are doing this work every day. You are strengthening our communities of West Kelowna\n               and Peachland in a very real way, and I thank you for that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721548","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize two organizations doing important work supporting seniors\n               of West Kelowna–Peachland, the west side health network and the Peachland Wellness Centre. In communities like West Kelowna and Peachland, one of the things we hear consistently\n               from residents is how difficult it can be to access services, not just health care\n               but the br","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53b89b63b67bc89d83c4291c7ef4b1ffefb14f6b76c7c66e62a34b11447d94e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba572260421cc0bf66021fb1a098ebb7c07a0022f5d828366f57b64c4598860d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d6db1f70994136751d25e83a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729280,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"In 43 days, British Columbia hosts one of the largest events in its history, the FIFA\n               World Cup. Now, how is this government going to keep hundreds of thousands of attendees safe?\n               A family in Burnaby taking their kids to the Fan Festival doesn't know the plan. A\n               small business owner in downtown Vancouver doesn't know the plan. British Columbians\n               deserve to know this government's plan for safety and security. Will the minister stand up today and explain how the government plans to keep hundreds\n               of thousands of attendees safe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729280","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In 43 days, British Columbia hosts one of the largest events in its history, the FIFA\n               World Cup. Now, how is this government going to keep hundreds of thousands of attendees safe?\n               A family in Burnaby taking their kids to the Fan Festival doesn't know the plan. A\n               small business owner in downtown Vancouver doesn't know the plan. British Columbians\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a7a47b2804f46d657ac6396d3e25bf957e1ef96bcb865712a3324681993edc7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0504dd5315dc6c4e53255a6600733ccc643d9ffec683fc8c1822900f7def6326"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5f41f01972b732417932fa92","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752289,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise briefly at report stage to reiterate my support for this legislation. This\n               is a practical, commonsense measure that will improve safety on our roads. The core\n               of this bill is straightforward. Better evidence leads to better outcomes for investigators,\n               for drivers and for the public. We've already spoken in this House about the real-world value of dashboard camera\n               footage. It provides clarity where there would otherwise be uncertainty. It helps\n               determine what actually happened, especially in serious collisions, often in rural\n               and remote areas where there are few if any witnesses. Ultimately, it supports safer\n               roads and more effective investigations. I also want to acknowledge the concerns that were raised earlier in this process,\n               about privacy and the protection of personal information. Those are valid concerns,\n               and they were taken seriously. What we saw at committee was a thoughtful, non-partisan\n               effort to address those issues in a balanced way. Members from different sides of this House engaged in constructive discussions, proposed\n               amendments and worked through the details to ensure this legislation strikes the right\n               balance. Those amendments strengthened the bill. They clarified how information is\n               handled, reinforced protections around personal data and ensured that this tool is\n               used for its intended purpose — public safety. The bill before us today is better because of that process. It now reflects an approach\n               that protects public safety, while also respecting individual rights and ensuring\n               that this footage is not misused. That matters because public confidence depends on\n               getting that balance right. This is the kind of legislation that should bring this House together. It supports\n               commercial drivers, it supports law enforcement, it supports families who deserve\n               clear answers after serious incidents, and it does so in a way that is measured, reasonable\n               and fair. At the end of the day, this bill is about improving safety, providing clarity\n               and ensuring accountability on the roads. It's practical, it's effective, and it's\n               ready. I encourage all members of this House to support it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752289","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise briefly at report stage to reiterate my support for this legislation. This\n               is a practical, commonsense measure that will improve safety on our roads. The core\n               of this bill is straightforward. Better evidence leads to better outcomes for investigators,\n               for drivers and for the public. We've already spoken in this House about the real-world value of","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7893e326c91c8db74c2a413f8af52576ca97fc63a610f8ea28d70c1bfd4b014c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["599cdec5f7cab9258738a31b00aeef74d369b1e4f0e15b2cb1f8ba7395c05e91"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e1832c7c804f1bcb78e0e0c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752290,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"The allegations raised by Mr. Stewart are serious, and his comments are not protected\n               by privilege on radio, but the Attorney General is. What information can the Attorney\n               General tell this House on the allegations raised by Kennedy Stewart that a cabinet\n               minister is under investigation for working with the government of China?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752290","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The allegations raised by Mr. Stewart are serious, and his comments are not protected\n               by privilege on radio, but the Attorney General is. What information can the Attorney\n               General tell this House on the allegations raised by Kennedy Stewart that a cabinet\n               minister is under investigation for working with the government of China?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Foreign interference","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035345","label":"Foreign interference","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c067102c74d4dbbb367f2ef0bff7d6a12bad5edb5161178cd734959530323398"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f596f0627f2cc47fc0893f17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752291,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, this PST will cause business owners to pass additional costs onto their customers.\n               René Rossignol, with Themis Security, said: \"For us, for our pricing as well, we are\n               going to have to take into account that bills are going up substantially, more than\n               a normal inflation rate.\" That ripple effect will be felt by everyone. Can the minister explain to business owners across British Columbia how expanding\n               the PST on essential security services is helping British Columbia?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752291","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, this PST will cause business owners to pass additional costs onto their customers.\n               René Rossignol, with Themis Security, said: \"For us, for our pricing as well, we are\n               going to have to take into account that bills are going up substantially, more than\n               a normal inflation rate.\" That ripple effect will be felt by everyone. Can the minister explain t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8cd9cddc10f8be2eb23e0979a9c8a2aff4f979cb0b3f3199cd2412942f152f67"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-62c73bba3f95a3f4ef38e60c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752292,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to take a moment to welcome three guests from my constituency of West Kelowna–Peachland, Dave, Jen and Charlotte Birchmore, who are joining us here today for their first\n               visit to the Legislature. They're here to see firsthand how this place works, to watch question period, spend\n               some time in the building and get a better sense of how both government and opposition\n               carry out their roles in this House. It's always valuable when people take the time\n               to come here, see the process up close and experience what happens inside this chamber.\n               I hope they enjoy their stay here today. Please join me in welcoming them to the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752292","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to take a moment to welcome three guests from my constituency of West Kelowna–Peachland, Dave, Jen and Charlotte Birchmore, who are joining us here today for their first\n               visit to the Legislature. They're here to see firsthand how this place works, to watch question period, spend\n               some time in the building and get a better sense of how both government and oppos","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb009854d274bd12399fb933a60dff7127c150fae563b8761d3d6c941e213ab6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1c79e18eef5b96800a46a1394874a39602e6e9f0e8fdfc447989b0d3cdb095e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8289faabc4018de67fa579a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752293,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and\n               her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget\n               2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor\n               General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my\n               background with policing. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my\n               background with policing and public safety, which is perhaps why my side of the House\n               sought fit to assign me to serve as critic for Solicitor General and Public Safety. For those who are not aware, I served 19 years with the RCMP in Penticton, Kelowna,\n               West Kelowna and Lake Country detachments. I was mainly involved with general duty\n               policing. I was on bike patrol and downtown enforcement in Kelowna, where I dealt\n               with the homeless population, nuisance calls in the downtown core related to small\n               businesses and ensuring they were safe, as well as drug and liquor enforcement, all\n               while dealing with street-level drug addiction and drug trafficking. I was on the crime reduction unit dealing with problem residences across Kelowna,\n               specifically dealing with property crime offences, where significant stolen property\n               was being trafficked out of the residences, and specifically targeting prolific offenders. I was also involved with the police and crisis team, or PACT, or the mental health\n               car, where I rode around with a mental health nurse responding to mental health calls\n               in Kelowna. I was also on the RCMP tactical team, or public order, where I received\n               significant training and experience in dealing with public order events, such as protests\n               and riots. This also resulted in emergency deployment for natural disasters all across\n               B.C. Finally, I was a road supervisor in Kelowna, supervising six constables. I know a\n               little bit about front-line policing in British Columbia. I would also like to recognize my colleague the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, in his capacity as critic for community safety and transnational crime, with whom\n               I have collaborated with in our preparations for these estimates, also formally with\n               law enforcement with the RCMP, which I know he will be able to explain himself. Today we will start the work of oversight on the ministry operations vote in Budget\n               2026, with a focus on policing expenditures, public safety planning and the broader\n               fiscal risks facing British Columbia. This includes not only ongoing policing costs but also major event pressures, such\n               as the upcoming FIFA World Cup. This will place significant and complex demands on\n               our public safety system. Across the province, we are seeing policing costs rise steadily\n               year over year. At the same time, municipalities are raising serious concerns about\n               affordability. Staffing shortages remain persistent, and communities are questioning\n               whether service levels are keeping pace with demand. These pressures are not occurring in isolation. They are compounded by large-scale\n               event obligations that require substantial security planning, coordination and funding. The World Cup provides a clear example of these challenges. Vancouver is set to host\n               seven matches. While early projections place total event costs in the range of approximately\n               $240 million to $260 million, there remains a significant lack of transparency around\n               one of the most critical components — safety and security. Historically, security represents one of the largest and most volatile cost drivers\n               for events of this scale, yet there is no clear defined public breakdown, no detailed\n               risk adjustment estimate and no clear contingency framework. We have seen this pattern before. During the 2010 Olympic Winter Games, security costs\n               escalated significantly beyond early projections, ultimately exceeding $900 million\n               nationally. Internationally, FIFA World Cup events have also demonstrated a consistent pattern\n               of underestimating security expenditures early in the planning cycle. With costs rising as risks evolve and operational requirements become clearer, at\n               the same time, comparisons with other host jurisdictions raise further questions.\n               Toronto, which is hosting six matches, has a higher overall projected cost range,\n               and typical planning assumptions suggest that security can account for between 20\n               percent and 30 percent of total event costs. In the United States, host cities often appear to carry lower local security costs,\n               but this is largely due to the ability to draw an extensive federal security infrastructure,\n               which reduces visible local expenditures but does not eliminate the underlying costs. What this means for British Columbia is that taxpayers are likely more directly exposed\n               to security cost risks, particularly if those risks are not fully disclosed or adequately\n               planned for. Transparency is essential not only to ensure accountability but to allow municipalities,\n               stakeholders and the public to understand the full scope of financial exposure. The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.\n               They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability\n               of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that police public funds are being The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.\n               They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability\n               of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that public funds are being used\n               effectively, that risks are clearly understood and that decisions made today do not\n               create greater financial pressures in the future. With that, I'd like to proceed with\n               my questions. Vancouver is scheduled to host seven FIFA World Cup matches at B.C. Place in 2026.\n               Public reporting and government disclosures have placed total event costs in a broad\n               range of approximately $49 million to $98 million and, in some cases, $260 million\n               or more across all levels of government. Updated projections in comparable jurisdictions suggest that costs continue to evolve\n               as planning advances. Security is widely recognized as one of the largest cost drivers\n               for mega-events, often representing between 20 percent and 30 percent of total expenditures\n               in Canadian planning assumptions and in some international cases, exceeding initial\n               projections significantly. At present, there is no publicly released stand-alone security budget for the Vancouver\n               matches. Security-related costs are expected to be embedded across multiple categories\n               including policing, counterterrorism, venue security and crowd management. Historical precedent — including the 2010 Olympic Games, where security costs exceeded\n               $900 million nationally — demonstrates that early estimates frequently underestimate\n               final expenditures due to evolving risk conditions, operational requirements and federal\n               involvement. Comparative analysis shows that Toronto, hosting six matches, has projected total\n               costs in the range of approximately $300 million to $380 million, implying a substantial\n               security component even without detailed public breakdowns. In the U.S., host cities often rely on federal agencies and existing Homeland Security\n               infrastructure, which can reduce the visibility of local costs, but does not eliminate\n               the overall expenditure. This creates a structural difference where Canadian jurisdictions\n               may face more direct and transparent fiscal exposure. Given these factors, the primary concern is not that Vancouver's costs are necessarily\n               out of line with peer cities, but that the level of transparency, risk disclosure\n               and contingency planning does not reflect the known volatility and scale of security\n               expenditures for events of this magnitude. So in the context of this budget, and taking into account FIFA events having a history\n               of policing and security-cost overruns, will there be cost overruns for FIFA in the\n               policing and security context?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752293","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and\n               her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget\n               2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor\n               General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["40ec58f5cf6f520477a5379d7b28e51d467eedef875034df39091ba65a06e1b1","bd39c43765aaa9b39afbf63fcc6565abc327bdc7f3639423cba0064133037a6a","0bfa253340e145c5a815770c1f7ff570d9d9e9408cf74bb1dce1505b930f192d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f0c2634fc695f6d3b874df0da220dcab13b0fcf255c7719b3d98ae351fc5404"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5047b274ca546ef39d0dd1b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017437,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Minister. Now I'd just like to switch gears into some.... I have a few other questions in other\n               areas I'd just like to go into, but perhaps the minister might be able to assist me\n               just in my first line of questioning here. My first thing I have is the sheriff service. Now, I don't know.... I think the minister\n               has the policing team. Is it a new team for sheriffs, or can I go into those with\n               you yet?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017437","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Minister. Now I'd just like to switch gears into some.... I have a few other questions in other\n               areas I'd just like to go into, but perhaps the minister might be able to assist me\n               just in my first line of questioning here. My first thing I have is the sheriff service. Now, I don't know.... I think the minister\n               has the policing team. Is it a n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e3cc6458b67c5a957ab8a2bee4683ccf0bb83e02640b8b608cb8f4569cfee8ae","0ad09059c0e9617af81bcf520dbb849a5e73fed60ea22033b1576fa32355a6ba","6ff2a2ea7aa741803ca15d0518649f9142be8f86c1d34e39e558360319c8295f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a352a08a620ed3e578bb2367edeb973a8eea655f6a84e02b2fbd601dd398f7fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fc85131dac8702a84afc2911","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017439,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Macklin McCall","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to welcome two constituents of mine visiting here today from the riding\n               of West Kelowna–Peachland: Thomas Hogue and Deborah Lynn McGregor. It's great to have them here to see the\n               work we do in the House and the democratic process in action. Will this House please join me in welcoming them to the Legislature today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017439","member_id":"bc-mla-410","member_name":"Macklin McCall","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to welcome two constituents of mine visiting here today from the riding\n               of West Kelowna–Peachland: Thomas Hogue and Deborah Lynn McGregor. It's great to have them here to see the\n               work we do in the House and the democratic process in action. Will this House please join me in welcoming them to the Legislature today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4552e0a42106d9a43d23533560ca082d7e8e3e634524cfc276015b416abefe8a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c79554fc0fe93b98d3492648","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316797,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we are called upon to debate Budget 2026.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316797","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Today we are called upon to debate Budget 2026.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c19737d2a3f23977e583a0bc206d222e0321b749ac794dfa53813c299b698032"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8010831116ced55c5da6b032","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316798,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"This morning, I want to wish my eldest grandson, Harrison, a very happy birthday.\n               He turns nine today. Because we are not sitting for his brother's and sister's birthdays,\n               I'm going to just mention that Alana turned four on January 25 and Fraser will turn\n               seven on May 24. If you could wish my grandchildren a very happy birthday today, I'd appreciate it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316798","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This morning, I want to wish my eldest grandson, Harrison, a very happy birthday.\n               He turns nine today. Because we are not sitting for his brother's and sister's birthdays,\n               I'm going to just mention that Alana turned four on January 25 and Fraser will turn\n               seven on May 24. If you could wish my grandchildren a very happy birthday today, I'd appreciate it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f295084569052a6ec58dabc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316799,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I reserve my right of privilege.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316799","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I reserve my right of privilege.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a9aeb85c672b81ae297992b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327918,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am so delighted and honoured. I have my sister in the gallery, Alyx Patterson, who\n               is the most wonderful sister I could possibly have, and her husband, a terrific brother-in-law,\n               Dave Patterson, and their grandson, Lincoln","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327918","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am so delighted and honoured. I have my sister in the gallery, Alyx Patterson, who\n               is the most wonderful sister I could possibly have, and her husband, a terrific brother-in-law,\n               Dave Patterson, and their grandson, Lincoln","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c76892b455e8ebf09f756271d4b7269d8bcc0d7358fc49cd18d1935bd1572db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a8502845ddeb87261a248f899024de565405c72ff70f78163ee09e368ad0e04"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9d1082ef8291278b20bdac28","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359631,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"The American diplomat Madeleine Albright once said: \"It took me quite a long time\n               to develop a voice, and now that I have it, I'm not going to be silent.\" That statement\n               captures something profound about age. A voice is not developed overnight. It is built through experience, through hardship,\n               through decades of learning, contributing and leading. And yet despite that We rightly condemn discrimination based on race, gender, disability and many other\n               characteristics, but age is different. It is often dismissed with humor or casual\n               remarks. You hear it in everyday conversation, \"Okay, boomer,\" \"She's too old for\n               that\" or \"He's past his prime.\" If those phrases targeted almost any other group,\n               we would immediately recognize them as offensive. Yet, when directed at seniors, they\n               are often treated as harmless jokes. In Canada, age is recognized in law as a protected ground. Section 15 of the Canadian\n               Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees equality before the law and human rights\n               codes, including here in British Columbia, protect individuals from discrimination\n               based on age in areas such as employment, housing and services. But laws alone cannot eliminate cultural attitudes. Ageism persists in ways that are\n               subtle but deeply damaging. Older workers are often pushed out of the workforce despite\n               decades of knowledge and skill. Seniors are underrepresented in conversations about\n               innovation, technology and leadership. Too often older voices are treated as though\n               they are no longer relevant. For women, the challenge can be even greater. Ageism and sexism combine to create\n               what many scholars call double invisibility. Women who spent much of their lives navigating\n               expectations about appearance and youth often find that as they grow older, society\n               simply stops seeing them at all. Yet history repeatedly proves the opposite of this\n               stereotype. Some of the most influential women in modern history made extraordinary contributions\n               well into their senior years. Ruth Bader Ginsburg became a global symbol of legal courage and equality in her 70s\n               and 80s, shaping constitutional law and inspiring generations. Maya Angelou continued writing, lecturing and influencing global conversations about\n               justice and humanity well into her later decades. Angela Merkel guided Europe's largest economy through financial crises and global\n               uncertainty during the later years of her leadership. Margaret Atwood, one of our own, saw one of the most powerful cultural resurgencies\n               of her work in her 70s when The Handmaid's Tale once again shaped international conversations about democracy and human rights. These women remind us that wisdom does not diminish with age. In many ways, it deepens.\n               Experience builds judgment. Experience builds resilience. Experience builds perspective.\n               Yet, despite this, society operates on the mistaken assumption often that innovation\n               belongs only to the young, that relevance has an expiration date and that aging somehow\n               means decline. But the truth is the opposite. Societies depend on the knowledge accumulated over\n               a lifetime. When we dismiss seniors, we are not simply overlooking individuals. We\n               are ignoring decades of insight, leadership and understanding. As Canada's population continues to age, this issue becomes even more important. By\n               the end of this decade, seniors will make up a significant portion of our population.\n               The question before us is not whether they still have something to contribute. The\n               real question is whether our institutions, workplaces and communities are prepared\n               to recognize the value they bring. More than 2,000 years ago, the Roman statesman Cicero wrote something that remains\n               remarkably relevant today: \"Old age, especially when honoured, can be a time of great\n               influence.\" Our responsibility as a society is simple. Not to treat age as a reason to dismiss\n               a voice but as a reason to listen more carefully to it, because the voices that have\n               taken the longest to develop are often the ones that have the most wisdom to offer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359631","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The American diplomat Madeleine Albright once said: \"It took me quite a long time\n               to develop a voice, and now that I have it, I'm not going to be silent.\" That statement\n               captures something profound about age. A voice is not developed overnight. It is built through experience, through hardship,\n               through decades of learning, contributing and leading. And y","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Humour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035752","label":"Humour","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b446413a94858455539ec91f599cb050ccc0a73026e8275db0170cc078196287"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ab71ff7d8ca905aca97655ff3936395e42e205d3f4144631be9250bfd8e1c08c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d29a0f1949da43f55efdae3a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359632,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to do two introductions this morning. One is Mark Cooper from the Canadian\n               Home Builders Association, as well as all the rest of them who are here today ... the\n               real estate. I am looking forward to our conversations in the future. The second introduction is my CA, Ashten Young, who is visiting for the next couple\n               of days. I wish you could all welcome them all to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359632","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to do two introductions this morning. One is Mark Cooper from the Canadian\n               Home Builders Association, as well as all the rest of them who are here today ... the\n               real estate. I am looking forward to our conversations in the future. The second introduction is my CA, Ashten Young, who is visiting for the next couple\n               of days. I wish you could all w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real property services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083678","label":"Real property services","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba59e29e505af5509f87260b98c7c97da39c1c67ca0ebf1f02acbf94ad26f93d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-731f05ac607e0475588b2719","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359633,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"First of all, I thank you for the opportunity to speak today and represent my riding\n               and the constituents of my riding, West Vancouver–Capilano. It really is an honour. I have many small businesses in my riding. In fact, there are no huge industrial complexes\n               or anything like that. For me, this bill was intriguing because I looked at it very\n               closely in the context of people I know — the wonderful little restaurant that has\n               patisserie, then you've got the hardware store and you've got the pub, all doing their\n               very, very best to make a living. So, I have a few comments. I'm rising today to speak to the Labour Statutes Amendment Act, 2026, introduced by\n               the hon. Minister of Labour. At its core, this legislation amends two important laws\n               in British Columbia, the Employment Standards Act and the Temporary Foreign Worker\n               Protection Act. As the words of Martin Luther King Jr. remind us: \"No work is insignificant.\n               All labour that uplifts humanity has dignity and importance.\" These statutes that we are discussing today govern some of the most fundamental aspects\n               of work in our province: how employees are paid, how disputes are handled and how\n               vulnerable workers are protected. That principle is exactly why employment standards\n               exist, to ensure that when work is done, wages are paid. Every member of this House understands that employment standards are not theoretical\n               ideas. They affect real people. They affect the single parent waiting for a final\n               paycheque. They affect the small business owner trying to navigate a complex system.\n               They affect temporary foreign workers who may be thousands of kilometres from home\n               and dependent on the fairness of our laws. Healthy workplaces require balance. Workers must have strong protections. Employers\n               must have rules that are fair, predictable and workable. That balance is the standard\n               by which we must measure this bill. While this legislation contains provisions that\n               aim to improve efficiency and ensure workers receive wages owed, there are several\n               significant concerns that deserve scrutiny. The purpose of the bill.... It introduces three main policy changes. First, it changes\n               how unpaid wages are handled when an employee cannot be located. Second, The purpose of the bill. It introduces three main policy changes. First, it changes\n               how unpaid wages are handled when an employee cannot be located. Second, it creates\n               a new complaint resolution process that can require parties to participate in mediation\n               during investigation. Third, and perhaps most significantly, it requires employers\n               to deposit the full amount of a monetary determination in order to appeal it, unless\n               a tribunal allows a smaller amount. Each of these provisions carries implications not only for employees but also for\n               businesses and the administrative capacity of government. Let me begin with something every member in this House should agree on. Workers deserve\n               to be paid the wages they earn. Simple. Employment standards laws exist for a reason.\n               They established the minimum floor of fairness in the workplace so that when wages\n               are not paid, the consequences are not abstract. For many workers, missing wages mean\n               missed rent payments, missed grocery purchases and missed paying of bills. Investigations across Canada have repeatedly shown that wage theft remains a real\n               issue in the labour market. In British Columbia alone, thousands of complaints are\n               filed with the employment standards branch each year. For example, in Whistler, several workers at a local Domino's franchise filed complaints\n               after discovering they had been underpaid. After investigation, the employment standards\n               branch ruled in their favour and ordered more than $10,000 in unpaid wages returned\n               to the employees, along with penalties against the employer. Cases like that illustrate\n               why enforcement matters. Across Canada and here in British Columbia, migrant worker organizations have documented\n               cases where workers were charged illegal recruitment fees, denied overtime pay or\n               threatened with job loss if they complained. That is precisely why the Temporary Foreign\n               Worker Protection Act exists, and it is why any legislative change affecting enforcement\n               must be considered carefully. Let us start with clause 2. Currently, if wages are owed to an employee who cannot\n               be located, there must be an attempt to locate that employee for one year before transferring\n               the money to the provincial administrator. Bill 10 removes that one-year requirement.\n               Under the amendment, wages could be transferred immediately after reasonable attempts\n               to locate the worker. Now, on its face, this may seem like an administrative improvement. After all, the\n               government argues that it will allow funds to be held safely by the administrator\n               rather than remaining with employers. But there are important questions regarding\n               this. What constitutes a sufficient attempt to locate the employee? Who decides that?\n               Where's the scale? How quickly will funds be transferred? Again, who decides that?\n               What process is in place? How easily will workers be able to reclaim those wages afterward? This issue matters because employment mobility is extremely high in some cases. Workers\n               often change jobs, move cities or return to other countries. In sectors, as we've\n               heard, such as agriculture and tourism, many workers leave the province at the end\n               of a season. I know many people who come from Australia to ski here in Canada, particularly in\n               British Columbia, and after the ski season is finished here, off they go back down\n               to Australia and New Zealand to ski and take jobs down there. If the recovery process becomes too complex, workers may simply never reclaim money\n               they earned. Another significant change appears in clause 4, which introduces section 76.1. This\n               creates a complaint resolution process during an investigation. The Another significant change appears in clause 4, which introduces section 76.1. This\n               creates a complaint resolution process during an investigation. The director may require\n               both parties to participate in that process and can specify how they must participate. Now, I have been in a lot of mediation processes and early dispute resolution and\n               they can be valuable tools, but it depends on what kind of mediation and what kind\n               of early dispute resolution. And unless they're very clear and the steps very clear,\n               they don't work as well as they should or could. In many legal systems, mediation allows disputes to be resolved faster and with less\n               cost than formal litigation. But the language in this bill raises concerns. If a party\n               fails to participate in the process, the director may continue the investigation or\n               stop investigating and proceed directly to a determination. That is a significant\n               power. For large organizations with human resource departments and legal counsel, participating\n               in mediation may be straightforward. Not a big deal. However, for small businesses it can be a very different time. A small restaurant\n               owner, a contractor or a family-run retail store may not have dedicated staff to handle\n               these proceedings. In fact, I would suspect that probably 95 percent of the small\n               businesses do not. Requiring mandatory participation in a formal resolution process\n               could create additional administrative burdens. And we know disputes in the system\n               can be complicated. In one recent case before the B.C. Employment Standards Tribunal, a worker alleged\n               he had been paid $16 per hour instead of the $22.50 per hour agreed to in his contract,\n               eventually resulting in a dispute worth more than $40,000 in unpaid wages. That's\n               a huge amount. Cases like this demonstrate that employment disputes can involve complex\n               evidence and competing claims which may not always be easily resolved through a quick\n               mediation process. And if the consequences for non-participation include losing the\n               opportunity to fully present a case during investigation, that raises fairness concerns. Another issue raised by employer groups is the question of consultation. Many employer\n               associations have indicated they were not consulted before these changes were introduced.\n               That is indeed really troubling. If you really are sincere in making a new process\n               work or something that supposedly benefits all sides, then should you not consult\n               all sides beforehand and reach agreement? That's the best way to move forward on any\n               process. Labour policy works best when both workers and employers are part of the conversation\n               equally. When governments legislate without adequate consultation, they risk creating\n               unintended consequences. Good labour policy should bring people together. It should\n               not deepen divisions between employers and employees. Perhaps the most consequential provision in this bill is found in clause 9. It amends\n               section 112 of the Employment Standards Act to require that anyone appealing a determination\n               involving money must deposit the full amount owed with the director. The tribunal\n               may approve a small amount, but only at its discretion. Now let me be clear about this. This provision is intended to prevent bad actors from\n               using appeals to delay payment, and that goal is understandable. There have been cases\n               where employers used very lengthy appeals just to postpone paying wages and they could\n               afford to do that. But the question we must ask is this: does requiring a full But the question we must ask is this. Does requiring a full deposit up front create\n               barriers to legitimate appeals? For large corporations, the answer may be no. For\n               small businesses, however, the answer may be quite different. We have seen situations in British Columbia where employment disputes involve significant\n               amounts of money. In one Okanagan case, a security company was ordered to pay more\n               than $80,000 in unpaid wages and compensation to ten former employees after a tribunal\n               dismissed the owner's appeal. Imagine a smaller business facing a determination of that magnitude. They wouldn't\n               survive. Even if they believed the ruling was incorrect, they might not have the financial\n               capacity to deposit tens of thousands of dollars immediately to pursue an appeal.\n               In effect, the right to appeal could become conditional on the ability to pay. That raises fundamental questions about access to justice. Appeals exist precisely\n               because administrative decisions can sometimes be wrong. Heavens to Betsy. Wrong sometimes.\n               They allow errors to be corrected. There's an opportunity there. If the cost of appealing\n               becomes too high, we risk undermining that safeguard. Another concern relates to the capacity of the employment standards branch, and we've\n               heard a lot about that today. According to government service plans and research into\n               the system, many workers wait long periods before receiving decisions or payment.\n               Advocacy groups report that in some cases, complaint investigations can take many\n               months or even years to fully resolve. So, when you have only 32 percent of the complaints completed within six months, how\n               does that affect the workers? How does it affect the employers? That is an absolutely\n               abysmal data statistic because that delay can be devastating for workers who rely\n               on those wages to pay rent, who rely on those wages to buy groceries, who rely on\n               those wages to support their families. As we know, in British Columbia right now, many more families are using food banks\n               because they cannot afford housing. They can't afford to put food on the table or\n               cannot afford to pay their bills. We're in dire circumstances. The government has set a goal of resolving 80 percent of complaints within 180 days\n               by 2027-2028. Now, 80 percent, as a teacher, is mastery. 80 percent and above is called\n               mastery. So that's a great goal to aspire to. It is an ambitious goal, too. But it\n               raises an important question. How will it be achieved? There is a word for it, when\n               you keep doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.\n               If you continue to process things exactly the same way and expect yourself to get\n               80 percent or better mastery, we've got an issue here. Because according to this provincial budget, funding for labour programs is frozen\n               at approximately $22.3 million for the next three years. In other words, the government\n               expects complaint resolution times to improve dramatically, while resources remain\n               essentially unchanged. I don't understand how that will be done. It's a great goal. It truly is, but it's\n               the how it will be achieved? How will this goal of 80 percent or better be achieved? Has this government or will this government be hiring a specialist, an external company,\n               to review what's happening? How will this goal of 80 percent or better be achieved? Has this government or will\n               this government be hiring a specialist, an external company to review what has happened\n               in the past, to point out the discrepancies or the flaws in the present process so\n               that they can analyze the holdups, where the glitches are, where the obstacles are?\n               Is that what they can do, or are they going to continue the same process on and on\n               and on and just say, \"We're going to go for 80 percent,\" when they're only reaching\n               32 percent right now? Are there suggestions right now as to how to fix this system, or are they just going\n               to continue to repeat exactly the same processes again and again, expecting different\n               results, expecting 80 percent or better? Unless this government knows why and where\n               and how these impediments are arising so that they're only achieving 32 percent, how\n               can they fix this flawed process and achieve their 80 percent goal? Well, I have a thought. I do love reading. I love reading fiction and non-fiction.\n               One particular area which I really find fascinating is about leadership. I know government\n               processes have been around for years. I keep getting told: \"Well, that's how we've\n               done it for years.\" Yes, I get that. But perhaps there are some new ways that are\n               better, more efficient, that can help you get to the 80 percent. I just wanted to probably give an idea of perhaps how they can approve with the 80\n               percent, because improving enforcement typically requires more investigators, more\n               adjudicators and more administrative support. Without those resources, the risk is\n               that legislative changes alone will not deliver the improvements workers need. I propose for the government, moving forward, so they can achieve their 80 percent\n               goal, something called the TASC approach. It's new, so maybe it's not old enough,\n               but it's T-A-S-C. It's called the accountability and success checklist. I found it\n               really relevant for this process. T is: who owns the task? That's No. 1 step. A: the person or persons who own the task or tasks, do they have the authority to\n               be held accountable for that task? S: do they all agree that they are set up for success? Do they have the time or the\n               resources or the clarity about the task? And the last part, the C, is: is there a checklist of what needs to happen to accomplish\n               the task? The last part is an interesting one. If they say, \"Done,\" what does done look like?\n               What does that finished task look like? They do something, another term, which I really\n               enjoy. It says: \"Paint done for me.\" In other words, colour in the dots. Tell me what\n               paint done looks like. I would offer that to this government moving forward. If they really do want to attain\n               the goal of 80 percent, I would suggest that they look at other processes like TASC\n               because that would fit perfectly into that little niche. Without TASC or any resources to change the system the way it is right now, the risk\n               is that legislative changes alone will not deliver the improvements workers need or\n               the 80 percent goal that they have. Bill 10 also amends the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act. Temporary foreign\n               workers, as we've heard, are among the most vulnerable participants in the labour\n               market. Many arrive in Canada under employer-specific permits. That means their legal\n               right to work is tied to a single employer. If problems arise — unpaid wages, unsafe conditions or unlawful deductions — they\n               may fear retaliation or even deportation. I do know of circumstances where passports\n               have been taken away. This is why strong protections are essential. But it also means\n               that the enforcement system must be accessible and responsive This is why strong protections are essential. But it also means that the enforcement\n               system must be accessible and responsive. If complaints take months or years to resolve,\n               the workers affected may already have returned to their home countries. That makes\n               recovery of wages far more difficult. Returning to the new complaint resolution process. It is important to consider the\n               balance between mediation and investigation. Mediation can be effective when both\n               parties have relatively equal bargaining power. But when there is a significant imbalance,\n               such as between an employer and a vulnerable worker, mediation may not always produce\n               fair outcomes. In some situations, workers may feel pressured to accept settlements below what they\n               are owed simply to resolve the dispute quickly. That is why any mediation process\n               must be carefully designed and monitored. What mediation process and what model to be used? If the goal of this legislation\n               is to resolve complaints faster and recover wages more effectively, then one conclusion\n               becomes clear. The employment standards branch must have the resources necessary to\n               do its job. Investigators must be able to conduct thorough investigations. Tribunals\n               must be able to hear appeals without long delays. Workers must have access to clear\n               information about their rights. Without those elements, legislative amendments alone\n               will not fix the system. In closing, employment standards laws exist to protect the integrity of our labour\n               market. They ensure that honest employers are not undercut by those who break the\n               rules. They ensure that workers receive the wages they have earned. They ensure that\n               disputes are resolved fairly. The challenge before us, however, is to ensure that the Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act 2026 achieves those goals without creating new barriers or unintended consequences.\n               Legislation must not only be well-intentioned, it must also be well-designed. That requires listening to workers, employers and the experts who operate within the\n               system every day. At the end of the day, the success of our labour laws will be measured\n               not by the words written in statutes but by the fairness experienced in workplaces\n               across British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359633","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"First of all, I thank you for the opportunity to speak today and represent my riding\n               and the constituents of my riding, West Vancouver–Capilano. It really is an honour. I have many small businesses in my riding. In fact, there are no huge industrial complexes\n               or anything like that. For me, this bill was intriguing because I looked at it very\n               closely in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bfdccaa74678a56d2487b6b1c28c9348106466175a95da74ff2a43c9d610b72"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["82924423b915b250087299629e50d3ed111b8015155f5bd5c18016b89bfda73d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-912944dd7af4e26eaf2dab41","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359634,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to recognize someone very special who is with us in the gallery today, my\n               extraordinary constituency assistant, Ashton Young. Ashton first came into my life\n               as my campaign manager, and from the very beginning, she proved herself to be tireless,\n               organized, compassionate and deeply committed to the people we serve. Today she is the steady hand in our constituency office, someone who always has my\n               back, has earned my complete confidence and has become not only a trusted colleague\n               but also a dear friend. Ashton and her family are expecting their third child in June,\n               and she will soon be taking some well-deserved time away from her CA duties to focus\n               on her growing family. Please join me in welcoming Ashton here today and in wishing her every joy and blessing\n               in this wonderful new chapter for her family.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359634","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to recognize someone very special who is with us in the gallery today, my\n               extraordinary constituency assistant, Ashton Young. Ashton first came into my life\n               as my campaign manager, and from the very beginning, she proved herself to be tireless,\n               organized, compassionate and deeply committed to the people we serve. Today she is the steady hand in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8da6010e6a279852c59aa682","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":359635,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to open with a very wise man's quote. I'll explain a little bit about him,\n               but his quote aptly describes what is needed here. He said: \"Sunlight is said to be\n               the best of disinfectants; electric light, the most efficient policeman.\" These words\n               of Louis Brandeis have never been more relevant than they are today, as we gather\n               to debate the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026,\n               Bill 9. Brandeis, who served on the United States Supreme Court from 1916 to 1939 as its first\n               Jewish justice, was known as the people's lawyer before his appointment, a relentless\n               advocate for workers, consumers and the public interest against concentrated corporate\n               power. He was also a pioneer of modern privacy law, which is incredibly important and relevant\n               today. He co-authored the seminal 1890 Harvard Law Review article, \"The Right to Privacy,\" which articulated the enduring principle that individuals\n               possess a \"right to be let alone.\" Even as he defended personal privacy, Brandeis championed transparency in public life,\n               insisting that democracy depends upon open institutions and informed citizens, warning\n               that secrecy breeds corruption and inefficiency. This Bill 9 is not just a matter of legal phrasing or procedural updates. It affects\n               the lives of students, parents and every British Columbian who relies on transparency\n               to hold public institutions and this government accountable. While Bill 9 claims to\n               modernize our access-to-information laws, it quietly introduces a series of what I\n               would call trapdoors, which risk undermining the very principle Justice Brandeis championed:\n               that democracy thrives only when government operates in the light, not behind veils\n               of secrecy. That is precisely what is at stake today. This debate is not abstract; it is not theoretical.\n               It is not confined to statutory language buried in legislative binders. We see a lot\n               of big binders around here. This bill is about power.  I'll say that again: this bill\n               is about power — who holds it, how it is exercised, and whether the public retains\n               the ability to scrutinize it in real time. As the critic for Education, I examine Bill 9 through a particular lens. I see it\n               through the eyes of a parent in Prince George, trying to understand school board spending\n               decisions that affect classroom supports. I see it through the eyes of a teacher in\n               Surrey, concerned about how student data is being transferred between ministries.\n               I see it through the eyes of trustees, attempting to reconcile ministry directives\n               with local accountability. And I see it through the eyes of journalists and citizens,\n               who rely on freedom-of-information laws to ensure that government decisions are made\n               in the open. Bill 9 promises modernization, it promises efficiency, and it promises digital integration,\n               but woven through this bill are structural changes that risk diminishing the immediacy\n               of transparency, expanding discretionary power and narrowing independent oversight. Let us begin with the most fundamental shift – timing. Currently the law requires Let us begin with the most fundamental shift: timing. Currently, the law requires\n               public bodies to respond to access-to-information requests \"without delay.\" Bill 9\n               proposes to replace the standard with \"without unreasonable delay.\" At first glance, this may appear modest, but words in legislation are never modest.\n               They carry intent. They shape culture. They guide conduct. \"Without delay\" is directive.\n               It establishes urgency. It affirms that access to public information is not a favour\n               but a right. \"Without unreasonable delay\" introduces elasticity. It creates interpretive space.\n               It allows argument of whether a delay — weeks or months — is justified. Who determines\n               what is unreasonable? The citizen seeking information or the institution being asked\n               to disclose it? For parents seeking documents related to school safety, funding allocations or inclusion\n               supports, timing matters. Decisions about budgets and policy are not static. They\n               unfold in cycles. If disclosure comes long after decisions are finalized, the opportunity\n               for meaningful engagement disappears. A right delayed becomes a right diluted. This\n               shift risks transforming the public's right to know into a procedural negotiation. Clause 2 compounds this concern. It grants the head of a public body sole authority\n               to determine whether a request contains \"enough detail\" to enable records to be located\n               within a \"reasonable amount of time.\" This creates a subjective — not an objective;\n               a subjective — gatekeeping mechanism. If a parent requests \"all records relating to school safety in a district,\" a superintendent\n               may deem the request too broad. If a teacher seeks communications between the ministry\n               and a district regarding policy implementation, that request may be characterized\n               as insufficiently specific. The burden shifts. The citizen must not only seek information but must do so with\n               drafting precision. Democracy should not require legal craftsmanship. Clause 13 adds yet another layer. It allows the commissioner to authorize a public\n               body to disregard requests deemed \"excessively broad\" or \"abusive\" or \"malicious\"\n               or those that \"unreasonably interfere with operations.\" Certainly, public bodies should not be paralyzed by harassment. Absolutely not. But\n               definitions matter. Is being persistent malicious? If a parent advocacy group files\n               multiple requests about special education funding because their children are not receiving\n               services, are they systematic? Or are they responsible? If a whistleblower files detailed\n               and repeated access requests to uncover irregularities, are they abusive? Or are they\n               courageous? Throughout history, uncomfortable scrutiny has often been mislabelled as disruption.\n               We must ensure that mechanisms intended to prevent abuse are not repurposed to suppress\n               accountability. Bill 9 also introduces a profound structural change: the creation of \"connected services\n               providers\" and an online platform enabling personal information to be shared across\n               public bodies. Under sections 26 and 69.3, the minister may designate a public body\n               to facilitate the sharing of personal information to determine program eligibility. Under sections 26 and 69.3, the minister may designate a public body to facilitate\n               the sharing of personal information to determine program eligibility. Efficiency is\n               cited as the objective. Citizens will be identified as eligible for benefits more\n               seamlessly. Administrative barriers will fall. But efficiency must not eclipse privacy. That's really important in this day and age.\n               We have seen so many times when there have been data breaches, and that will happen.\n               So if efficiency is cited as the objective, we have to be extremely careful. We really\n               do. Section 69.3(4) grants the minister, again, authority to determine not only the type\n               but also the quantity and circumstances under which personal information may be shared. Now, in education, personal information is deeply, deeply sensitive. You've got health\n               data on students. You have psychoeducational assessments on students. You have individual\n               education plans on students. You have behavioural records. And you have family financial\n               information as well as private family information. These records all concern children,\n               our children. Children cannot meaningfully consent. Parents deserve clarity. Data, once centralized, becomes attractive, very definitely, to cyber threats and\n               vulnerable to misuse. Is there a clear opt-out for families who do not wish their\n               child's information to circulate across a centralized platform? Are safeguards robust\n               enough to withstand sophisticated breaches? Will there be transparent reporting of\n               data sharing volumes and incidents? I don't know. Who does? Yes, centralization does\n               create convenience, but it also creates concentration of risk. Perhaps most troubling is the alteration of oversight mechanisms. Currently, privacy\n               impact assessments must be provided to the Privacy Commissioner. Bill 9 changes this\n               requirement. The government need only notify the commissioner that a privacy impact\n               assessment exists. The commissioner must request it to review it. Oversight by invitation is not oversight. It is accommodation. Why create an additional\n               procedural step between the watchdog and the records necessary to protect citizens'\n               privacy? If the government is confident in its safeguards, automatic disclosure to\n               the commissioner should not be burdensome. Trust in public institutions is strengthened\n               not by limiting scrutiny but by embracing it. Bill 9 further introduces a new refusal provision under section 16.1, permitting public\n               bodies to withhold the substance of communications from judicial officers regarding\n               proposed or existing policies. If members of the judiciary raise concerns about the\n               legality of an education policy, should the public not be aware? Transparency about\n               legal risk strengthens governance. Concealing such concerns diminishes informed debate. Additionally, section 3(5)(e) excludes records required by law to be produced in legal\n               proceedings from freedom of information access entirely. This removes a category of\n               documents from public access simply because they are connected to litigation. The public interest does not evaporate when a court file opens, and yet it would be\n               unfair to ignore positive elements. Clause 5 Clause 5 empowers applicants by requiring their consent for deadline extensions. That\n               is meaningful. Section 71 and 71.1 mandate proactive disclosure of categories of records.\n               That is progress. True modernization means making information public by default, reducing\n               the need for formal requests. But proactive disclosure cannot compensate for weakened\n               response standards or expanded discretion and reduce oversight. As we move to committee, I have a few questions. How will \"unreasonable delay\" be\n               defined to prevent misuse? I'd like that to be defined. Question 2. Why not automatically\n               provide privacy impact assessments to the commissioner? Number 3. What safeguards\n               ensure that persistent citizen engagement is not mislabelled as abuse? Another question,\n               is there a genuine opt-out for families within connected services? What cybersecurity\n               investments accompany centralized data sharing? And that's something that is absolutely\n               critical in this day and age of technology. Let's be clear. These are not partisan questions. matter from where they come. They\n               are democratic questions. Democracy requires friction. It requires questions. It requires\n               oversight that may be deemed inconvenient. Justice Brandeis understood that tension\n               between privacy and transparency was a good thing. He defended the individual's right\n               to be let alone while insisting that public institutions must operate in the open.\n               Bill 9 stands at that intersection. It modernizes, but it also obscures. It streamlines,\n               but it also centralizes. It discloses, but it also at the same time withholds. And so we return to the sunlight that I mentioned in the beginning. Sunlight is not\n               hostile to government. It is protective of it. It protects institutions from suspicion.\n               It protects citizens from overreach. It protects democracy from decay. If we weaken\n               clarity around response times, if we expand discretionary refusal powers, If we soften\n               independent oversight and if we centralize personal data without ironclad safeguards,\n               we dim that light. We truly do. Modernization should bring transparency, not blur\n               it. Let us together on both sides of this House amend this bill so that efficiency\n               strengthens accountability rather than substitutes for it. Let us together ensure that oversight is automatic, not optional. Automatic. Let us\n               together guarantee that privacy protections are explicit, not implied, and that brings\n               clarity. Justice Brandeis warned that secrecy breeds corruption and inefficiency.\n               He truly believed democracy depends on informed citizens and open institutions. If\n               we are to honour that principle, we must ensure that Bill 9 does not become a shadow\n               cast across the very transparency it claims to modernize. Because at the end of this debate, the question is simple. Will British Columbia move\n               toward greater openness or toward greater discretion? Will we accelerate sunlight\n               or filter it? For the parents in Prince George, for the teachers in Surrey, for every\n               British Columbian who believes that public institutions belong to the public, let\n               us choose the light.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:359635","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to open with a very wise man's quote. I'll explain a little bit about him,\n               but his quote aptly describes what is needed here. He said: \"Sunlight is said to be\n               the best of disinfectants; electric light, the most efficient policeman.\" These words\n               of Louis Brandeis have never been more relevant than they are today, as we gather\n               to d","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e5b7d281880c0e86239d3e44f1f6a39493a8e90f241eb1e9cc93b8b37744666"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb99afb2e0cd3a103f0de3a7ae0d011bb870fca4c13729dcd1b305d43261b101"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a24cd10307243b764b35d27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413658,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak in support of Motion 203, a motion grounded in a principle that\n               should never, ever be controversial: that hiring and promotion in the B.C. Public\n               Service must be — must be —based on merit. At its core, the merit principle is simple. It means selecting the best person for\n               the job based on ability, qualifications and performance, not political loyalty, not\n               personal relationships and certainly not convenience. This is not an abstract idea.\n               It is the foundation of a professional, effective and trusted public service. British Columbians expect this. They expect that when someone is hired or promoted\n               within government, it is because they earned it. They expect fairness. They expect\n               transparency, and above all, they expect that their government serves the public interest,\n               not insiders or well-connected individuals. That is why independent oversight matters. When hiring decisions are reviewed by an\n               officer who reports to the Legislative Assembly rather than to the executive, we create\n               a system that is accountable, not to power but to the people. Independent oversight\n               ensures that decisions are scrutinized fairly, free from political pressure or favouritism.\n               It strengthens the integrity of the system and protects it from erosion. Let us be clear. Public trust is fragile. It takes years to build and moments to lose.\n               When British Columbians see that hiring is done fairly and transparently, trust grows.\n               But when oversight is weakened, when accountability is removed, that trust begins\n               to crack. And once it is gone, it is incredibly difficult to restore. That is why the decision to eliminate the Office of the Merit Commissioner is so deeply\n               concerning. We are told this is about cost savings, but at a time when findings of\n               \"merit not applied\" are increasing, when the need for oversight is clearly growing,\n               we are choosing to eliminate the very office responsible for ensuring accountability,\n               all for a fraction of the provincial budget. As Merit Commissioner David McCoy himself warned, the cost of losing independent oversight\n               may far exceed the savings, and he is right, because the true cost is not measured\n               in dollars. It is measured in lost confidence, weakened institutions and diminished\n               trust in this government. Even more troubling is that these changes shift oversight functions into the hands\n               of the executive, effectively allowing government to oversee itself. That is not accountability.\n               That is the complete opposite. That is the absence of accountability. Motion 203 offers a better path. It does not tear down the public service. It strengthens\n               it. It does not question the professionalism of public servants. It protects it. By\n               reinforcing independent oversight, we ensure that those who serve B.C.... People are\n               selected based on merit, and they take pride in a system that is fair and just, because\n               a strong merit-based public service delivers better outcomes. It leads to better decisions,\n               better services and better results for every single person in this province. This principle is not new. It is rooted in a broader truth about fairness and justice.\n               As Martin Luther King Jr. once said: \"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.\"\n               When merit is ignored, when fairness is compromised, even if it's something as seemingly\n               procedural as hiring, it creates a ripple effect. It undermines confidence. It weakens\n               institutions. As Martin Luther King Jr. once said: \"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.\"\n               When merit is ignored, when fairness is compromised, even if it's something as seemingly\n               procedural as hiring, it creates a ripple effect. It undermines confidence, it weakens\n               institutions, and ultimately, it threatens the very idea that government can act in\n               the public's best interests. That's why this motion matters. It is about protecting fairness, about restoring accountability\n               and about ensuring that the people of B.C. can trust that their public service works\n               for them. Let us stand for merit and transparency, and let us stand for the principle\n               that public service must always serve the public first, last and always.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413658","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak in support of Motion 203, a motion grounded in a principle that\n               should never, ever be controversial: that hiring and promotion in the B.C. Public\n               Service must be — must be —based on merit. At its core, the merit principle is simple. It means selecting the best person for\n               the job based on ability, qualifications and performance, not","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3bfb9963d0ea0232bcac32c6aa2e237c6ec9cb915bbcf8d9bbec9ee88fd8e1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["566030c5ce6068b4c5f0d246f571825dd379f56802b721a5e3d0258ac3aef989"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e4193c1390ca8a1b134dfc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413659,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 12, the Safe Access to Schools Amendment Act, 2026. Now, at first glance, this legislation appears modest, indeed almost administrative\n               in nature. It contains no sweeping new provisions, no expanded powers, no recalibration\n               of rights or obligations. It does one thing and one thing only. It extends the repeal\n               date of the existing act by two years, from July 1, 2026, to July 1, 2028. Yet, as is often the case in this chamber, what appears simple is not necessarily\n               insignificant. Let me begin with a foundational observation, one that should guide our deliberations.\n               This amendment does not change what the law is. It changes how long we are willing\n               to live with it. That is the essence of this bill. It is procedural, not substantive\n               reform. It does not revisit the architecture of the Safe Access to Schools Act. It\n               does not refine its definitions, recalibrate its scope or respond to evolving concerns.\n               It simply prolongs its life. That raises a fundamental question before this House. Is continuation without reconsideration\n               justified? Let us remind ourselves why the original act was enacted. The Safe Access to Schools\n               Act was introduced to ensure that students, parents and school staff could access\n               educational environments free from intimidation, obstruction and disruption. It created\n               \"safe access zones\" around schools, spaces where certain expressive activities could\n               be restricted in order to protect the well-being and security of children and staff. This objective is not controversial. Indeed, it is deeply compelling. We are speaking\n               about children, about their right to learn in safety, about parents' confidence in\n               sending them to school and about educators' ability to do their jobs without fear\n               or interference. Students need to feel safe and be safe when entering their schools. Parents dropping\n               their children off at school don't want to run a gauntlet to ensure their children\n               are safe within the school. On that principle, there's broad agreement, but I'd like to tell a little bit of a\n               personal story. Before this act happened, there used to be I'd like to tell a little bit of a personal story. Before this act happened, there used to be quite a bit of back and forth between certain\n               groups — BCTF, CUPE — and the school districts. I remember very vividly a CUPE strike\n               many years ago before this legislation. And truly, it was terrifying, because the\n               teachers, BCTF, had decided to support the CUPE in what they wanted. It would not\n               benefit the BCTF, none of the teachers, but it benefited the CUPE, so they were on\n               strike. So we had people coming from all over at several schools. Not all the schools. So\n               you're looking at 100 adults yelling, screaming, placards, blocking cars, blocking\n               people, yelling at everybody. It really was terrifying. And at that time, because I knew that the majority of students were going into the\n               school and there was not the full staff, I crossed the picket lines, because it wasn't\n               for the teachers' benefit, and it wasn't for anybody else's. It certainly wasn't for\n               the students, and it certainly wasn't for the parents. So I crossed the picket lines\n               along with quite a few other teachers and principals. When we were in there, we had probably 90 percent of the students arrive. The parents\n               expected them to go to school, to be in school, to be safe and to be taught. Well,\n               that was a time when I had 60, 70 kids in one classroom. It was fun. We had a great,\n               great day. It only lasted for one day. What was interesting.... Two things. A few years later, the BCTF went on strike, and\n               the CUPE did not support them. The second interesting thing was that after that particular\n               day, I had a visit — talk about harassment — from the president of the teachers association,\n               admonishing me. Why didn't I support the teachers? I said: \"I'm supporting our children. They are my first priority, and that's why.\" Well, that did not go over well. But to this day, I am so glad I did that for the\n               students' welfare and for the parents' peace of mind too. They knew. So I'm glad that there is this legislation, but I have a few positives and a few comments\n               about that. Another example: SOGI. SOGI has been sort of a litmus test, pro or con. As a school\n               trustee, we had a lone SOGI protester. This was after the legislation. No, it was\n               before. They were outside the school, one particular school, and we asked that gentleman\n               to move outside the area, and he did. But what was really interesting.... He didn't live in our riding. He didn't live in\n               our school district, didn't have a child in school. So he was there as a sort of professional\n               protester, I guess. Anyway, thankfully, we didn't have more. But it was scary for the children. They didn't understand. And neither did the parents.\n               Even though the parents, a lot of them, did agree with SOGI, some did not. So the\n               reality was that was not the time or place, particularly for the children. So what are the positives of this amendment? It has definitely carried several clear\n               advantages. Continuity and stability is the main one. It does ensure continuity. Allowing\n               the act to expire in 2026 without replacement would create a legal vacuum, one in\n               which protections disappear overnight. This amendment prevents that outcome. It maintains\n               a stable framework that schools and communities have already adapted to. So continuity\n               and stability are paramount. Another positive of this is protection of vulnerable populations. The most vulnerable\n               are our children. This amendment continues protections for vulnerable populations, namely students,\n               in balancing rights courts have consistently recognized — that the state has a legitimate\n               interest in safeguarding children. Extending the act preserves that protective function. What's another positive? There's time for evidence-based evaluation. The extension\n               provides that addition What's another positive? There's time for evidence-based evaluation. The extension\n               provides that additional time. Public policy, particularly where it intersects with\n               constitutional rights, should be informed by evidence. So a longer timeline allows\n               for that. What does it allow for? More or even some data collection, especially longitudinal\n               data collection. It also provides impact assessment, an opportunity for objective assessment — where\n               is the framework for something like that? — and meaningful consultation with impacted\n               groups. It could be even student groups, as well as parents, as well as teachers,\n               as well as staff. Rushed decisions rarely produce good laws. What's another positive? Avoidance of legislative urgency. It does avoid the pressure\n               of an impending deadline. Without this extension, the Legislature would be forced\n               to revisit the act under time constraints, which can compromise the quality of debate\n               and scrutiny. This is an issue that has come up and appeared before us in the Legislature,\n               lack of quality of debate and scrutiny on certain things. Those are the positives. Here are the negatives. There are some concerns regarding this amendment. The first one is that it involves\n               the possible delay of democratic accountability. The original sunset clause was not\n               incidental. It was intentional. It reflected a recognition that this law engages fundamental\n               freedoms and should therefore be revisited within a defined time frame. Extending\n               the deadline risks diluting that accountability, and I think that's incredibly important.\n               Should we not take the time to review the original law and see if there are areas\n               that need improvement or revision as they may now be out of date with today's societal\n               needs and norms, data collection, impact assessment, especially in light of evolving\n               pressures in society today? A second concern is one of prolonging contested restrictions. The act limits certain\n               forms of expression and assembly within designated zones. While these limits may be\n               justified, they remain constitutionally sensitive. By extending the law without modification,\n               we are effectively prolonging those restrictions without reassessing whether they\n               remain necessary, proportionate or properly tailored. Again, where is the data or statistics? I love data and statistics. To me, that informs,\n               but where is the data or statistics to confirm whether this law is working as intended?\n               Does it need refinement? Are the restrictions enough or too much? Reflection and review\n               would be a positive step. So perhaps in that extended period, maybe we can do that. There is another negative, the risk of temporary becoming permanent. And that's a\n               broader institutional concern. When sunset clauses are repeatedly extended, they risk\n               becoming symbolic rather than substantive. A temporary measure can evolve into a de\n               facto permanent one, not through deliberate decision but through incremental deferral.\n               And shouldn't this law be just as thorough and impactful in the future, even in two\n               years, as it has been in the past? Shouldn't it be? I think it should be. How can\n               we assure that it is, if what we do is continually extend the date? Another missed opportunity here is for improvement. Anything and everything should\n               be looked at through the lens of improving. How can we refine it? How can we polish\n               it? How can we make it better? This amendment does not engage with any criticisms or lessons learned since the act's\n               implementation, and I think that's critical. Lessons learned. As an educator, lessons\n               learned are paramount for me. It does not ask: \"Are the zones appropriately sized?\n               Should they be increased?\" It does not ask: \"Are the zones appropriately sized? Should they be increased? Should\n               they be decreased? Are they working as envisioned? Are enforcement mechanisms fair\n               and consistent?\" This is a huge issue today as we see the increase of weekly rallies and protests.\n               We see them daily, weekly. Everybody wants to rally. We've got another one coming\n               up this week. So are the enforcement mechanisms fair and consistent? Do they need\n               to be changed, reviewed, refined, polished? We see the increase of weekly rallies and protests, some with no issues or repercussions,\n               while others can result in violence and property damage. Do we have impact assessments?\n               Are enforcement mechanisms robust enough, or too robust, depending on the circumstances?\n               Are they appropriate for each incident? Should there be a review of enforcement mechanisms\n               to see if they are appropriate, adequate or befitting the needs of today? Are there unintended consequences? Is there longitudinal data that we should begin\n               to collect right now? If so, what kind of framework would we use? What kind of best\n               practice would we use? What kind of data collection would we use? Is there a desire\n               for a review panel of experts, community members, interested parties, along with teachers,\n               students, staff, parents, community members, who would be valuable in determining\n               unintended consequences? And where's the meaningful consultation? I think that's key to anything we do. We\n               should have meaningful consultation. In that sense, this amendment represents not\n               just an extension but a much-missed opportunity. I want to just do a little concern here. No discussion of this legislation is complete\n               without considering the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Safe Access to\n               Schools Act engages several Charter rights, most notably section 2(b), freedom of\n               expression, and section 2(c), freedom of peaceful assembly. By restricting activities within safe access zones, the act imposes limits on these\n               freedoms. The key constitutional question is not whether rights are limited — they\n               clearly are — but whether those limits are justified under section 1 of the Charter.\n               That is, are they prescribed by law, pursuing a pressing and substantial objective\n               proportionate in their effects? The protection of children and access to education\n               is undoubtedly a pressing and substantial objective. The courts have often been sympathetic to such goals or aims. However, proportionality\n               requires ongoing scrutiny. Are the restrictions minimally impairing? Do they go further\n               than necessary? Is the balance between individual rights and collective safety still\n               appropriate today? Even though it's only been a couple of years, are they still appropriate\n               today? By extending this act without review, this amendment effectively assumes that the\n               original balance remains valid. That may be true, but it is not self-evident. It is\n               something that ought to be examined, not presumed. This brings us to a broader principle of governance. Good law is not only about what\n               we enact; it is about how we revisit what we enact. Sunset clauses exist for a reason.\n               They are instruments of humility. They acknowledge that legislators do not have perfect\n               foresight — we don't — and that laws affecting fundamental rights should not persist\n               indefinitely without reconsideration. That's what I believe is extremely important\n               in this House. In that light, this amendment invites us to reflect on our role as MLAs. Are we extending\n               this law because it has been rigorously evaluated and found effective? How do we know?\n               Or are we extending it because it is easier than Let's strike a balance here. The challenge before us is to strike a balance between\n               two legitimate concerns. One, the need to protect students and ensure safe access\n               to education. Two, the obligation to uphold and continually reassess fundamental freedoms.\n               These are not mutually exclusive objectives, but they do require careful calibration. In closing, let me return to the central point. This amendment is not about redefining\n               policy. It is about deferring a decision. It extends a framework that may well be\n               justified but does so without revisiting its foundations. And those foundations may\n               not be as strong and solid as they once were. The question for this House is not simply whether we support the Safe Access to Schools\n               Amendment Act, it is whether we are comfortable extending the school act as-is, for\n               two more years, without undertaking the deeper review that such legislation deserves.\n               Because in the end, legislation that touches on fundamental rights should not merely\n               endure; it should earn its endurance.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413659","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 12, the Safe Access to Schools Amendment Act, 2026. Now, at first glance, this legislation appears modest, indeed almost administrative\n               in nature. It contains no sweeping new provisions, no expanded powers, no recalibration\n               of rights or obligations. It does one thing and one thing only. It extends the repeal\n               date of the exi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2b4dd4fa3795aa7f78e5767d296e28cfe37e6d112199b073256afee5070145f6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["092bf980ba59971f86d4324890e62547a90db80ff73968948497bf6960544e1d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2908661a441c3577cfd9f7b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413660,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to say that there are still cuts to many families, thousands of families,\n               through this new model. We heard from Katrina Kirk, a mother of two autistic children, one child receiving\n               $22,000 and the other receiving $6,000. Under this new system, Katrina was told that\n               her family will receive absolutely nothing. Nothing. How can the minister justify a plan where families, like Katrina's, go from receiving\n               vital supports for their children to receiving absolutely nothing?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413660","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I just want to say that there are still cuts to many families, thousands of families,\n               through this new model. We heard from Katrina Kirk, a mother of two autistic children, one child receiving\n               $22,000 and the other receiving $6,000. Under this new system, Katrina was told that\n               her family will receive absolutely nothing. Nothing. How can the minister jus","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Domestic waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034892","label":"Domestic waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["babf0cb129b23723098340a07e94a8f21c86efee31a9135ca656835fe8e40637"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4dd2e7906972e6412e663212a4b6410d02eb8a28d7d20819ff0e1553b3d1b283"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ffeca631bd9af1a3c97c6d25","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413661,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"Actually, I sit here, and it's such a privilege to be in this chamber. And I am reminded\n               every day that what we debate, what we say, is extremely important because it has\n               repercussions and consequences not just for us but every single person in this province.\n               So I feel sometimes the pressure, but I feel that it's also an honour. So today we are gathered here to deliberate on a piece of legislation that touches\n               the very foundation of our society's duty to its most vulnerable citizens. Bill 11,\n               the Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, 2026. Now, at first glance: best motives, I'm\n               sure. This bill presents itself as a framework, a good framework for supportive housing,\n               a structure intended to protect residents, maintain safety and address the urgent,\n               the really urgent, housing crisis that affects so many in our province. Its language\n               suggests a commitment to stability, to rehabilitation and to guidance for those in\n               transitional or supportive housing. But like all things, you have to look at it closely. You can't just take it for what\n               it is. You have to look at it and examine it carefully, line by line, clause by clause,\n               because a different picture emerges: a framework riddled with uncertainty, executive\n               overreach and a troubling preference for punishment over support. And that's something\n               that is really, really critical here. It's more prohibitive and punishing than it\n               is supportive. It is our responsibility to look beyond the surface promises of this legislation and\n               ask. Does Bill 11 provide homes, or does it provide sites of surveillance? Does it\n               empower tenants, or does it leave them vulnerable to arbitrary authority? Now, I always look for the good, and I also look for where we can improve. So I want\n               to outline some of the flaws in Bill 11, and then I offer at the end some possible\n               positives because I always like to finish on a positive. Today outlining the critical flaws in Bill 11 demonstrates how its approach undermines\n               stability — exactly what it wanted to do — and highlights the global best practices\n               around the world that offer viable alternatives. And one of my favourite countries for best practices, not only in health, not only\n               in education, not only in affordable One of my favourite countries for best practices, not only in health, not only in\n               education, not only in affordable housing, is Finland. That's one of my places I'd\n               like to visit because I am so in awe. This is not merely a technical or legal discussion today. It is a matter of what I\n               would call human dignity. It is also about safety and the trust we owe our citizens\n               — not just the most vulnerable but all our citizens. What is one of the most systematic flaws of this bill is what I would call the transparency\n               deficit. Legislation is meant to provide clarity. It is meant to provide predictability,\n               and it is meant to provide certainty. Yet Bill 11 relies almost entirely on future\n               regulations to define its most critical elements. That's the cart before the horse. Key terms such as \"housing stability support\" — sounds good — or \"supportive housing\n               operator\" and \"transitional housing\" are not defined in the act itself. Why not? They\n               should be. They definitely should be, because my idea or my view of housing stability\n               may be very different from yours, Madam Speaker, or my colleagues' across the aisle.\n               Transitional housing. What I envision may be totally different from even my fellow\n               MLAs on my side of the aisle. Instead of defining and ensuring clarity and predictability, this act defers these\n               definitions to future prescriptions by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. Now, I don't think that this is a minor drafting oversight. It is a fundamental failure\n               of legislative responsibility. We are responsible. We are. A law that tells tenants\n               what they might be entitled to instead of what they are entitled to definitely creates\n               uncertainty. It also creates confusion. It also creates fear. For our most vulnerable, because oftentimes they have issues — perhaps with substance\n               abuse, mental illness — they need clarity. They need definitive, definitive definitions. Imagine a tenant signing a lease today, believing they understand their rights, only\n               to discover tomorrow that new regulations have changed everything. Their access to\n               services has changed. The conditions under which they may be evicted have changed\n               — or even the definition of their eligibility. That's a huge issue for these people. Besides the people who want that housing, the operators, too, are often left in the\n               dark. How can a staff member educate tenants about rules that do not yet exist? As\n               an educator myself, I would like to know the rules so I can tell my students exactly\n               what my expectations and the expectations they should have of me and the classroom\n               are. So they go along, and then I go, \"You broke the rules\"? \"Well, I didn't know\n               what they were.\" How can they prepare for crises without knowing the limits of their\n               authority? This is a recipe for inconsistency, misapplication and, ultimately, failure. And we\n               don't want to see failure here. This is so important. Often the people for this supportive\n               housing have had failure after failure. Let's have them be successful. Compare this to one of my favourite jurisdictions, New Zealand, where tenancy laws\n               clearly codify rights and obligations up front. Regulations provide operational detail,\n               but do not replace the law's fundamental clarity. There, tenants and operators can operate with confidence. Everybody knows the rules.\n               Everybody knows the regulations, and they agree to them. But this Bill 11, by contrast, leaves its most important rules in shadow, creating\n               what I But this Bill 11, by contrast, leaves its most important rules in shadow, creating\n               what I call a \"rule by regulation\" system, a system where authority is granted but\n               guidance is withheld. This transparency deficit is not a trivial flaw. It is a failure\n               to provide the educational foundation that supportive housing requires. Housing is not only a roof over one's head. It is a learning environment for these\n               people. It teaches individuals their responsibilities, their rights and how to navigate\n               society. By leaving critical definitions undefined, Bill 11 undermines this function. Erosion of contractual stability. Another alarming aspect of Bill 11 is its erosion\n               of that contractual stability. Clause 7, section 4.3 grants the Lieutenant Governor\n               in Council the power to override tenant agreements unilaterally. In practical terms,\n               this means that tenants who believed they had signed a binding, stable lease may find\n               that the government has altered the terms without their consent. The \"teachable moment\"\n               of understanding responsibilities in signing a lease is absolutely erased. I would offer that the person signing the lease in all good faith, very excited, finds\n               that the next time it's all changed.... That is not the right way to do it. Housing\n               stability is not just about the physical roof. It is about predictability and security\n               of one's life. Now back to Finland. It's called housing-first model. Why I love it? It emphasizes\n               this principle. Tenants enter into agreements with clear, stable terms, creating the\n               foundation for rehabilitation and integration. What I love about that — they are what\n               we call dry housing. People go there. They have no issues because the rules and regulations\n               are very, very clear and they have people who are educated and trained in crisis management,\n               in absolutely everything. So everything is safe. It's predictable, and it's clear\n               to everybody — the operators, the councillors and the tenants. Bill 11, however, removes that foundation, replacing it with uncertainty. Surveillance\n               and restrictions on rights is the next area which is of concern. Bill 11 further undermines\n               tenant autonomy through broad powers of surveillance and restriction of access. Section 4.5 limits landlord's access but then introduces vague exceptions for \"prescribed\n               purposes\" or \"reasonable grounds.\" Who determines what's reasonable? What some person\n               thinks is reasonable may not be what the tenant feels reasonable, and he might feel\n               that: \"Gee, you're imposing on my home. What right do you have to come in here? I\n               did not give you permission.\" Section 4.6 allows restrictions on tenant access to their own homes, sometimes without\n               notice. Can you imagine someone — they are so excited, they're home, they bring their\n               little plants home, they feel safe, they feel secure, and all of a sudden they come\n               back and they're locked out? How is that going to help them? How is that going to\n               improve their lives? They've been betrayed. This represents a profound departure from due process. Isn't that what we're supposed\n               to have in this Western world, in a democracy? Supportive housing should be empowering, not coercive. Under Bill 11, the most vulnerable\n               tenants risk being surveilled, restricted or displaced without Supportive housing should be empowering, not coercive. Under Bill 11, the most vulnerable\n               tenants risk being surveilled, restricted or displaced, without clear safeguards.\n               We know that disproportionate impacts are most likely to fall on all those people\n               already marginalized: individuals facing mental health challenges, disabilities or\n               language barriers. A system that treats tenants as potential liabilities right from\n               the onset, rather than as human beings deserving respect, undermines the very principles\n               of support and dignity. Perhaps the most troubling feature of Bill 11 is its emphasis on punishment rather than support. We've gone away from punishment\n               as parents, as teachers, and yet somehow or other, our most vulnerable — we are choosing\n               to punish them rather than support them. Why? Section 4.8 introduces expedited eviction for the mere observation of a weapon. Someone\n               may have been playing baseball down the block. Comes back with a baseball bat. Is\n               that perceived as a weapon by the operator? Could be. Safety is paramount, yes, but this approach addresses symptoms, not root causes, and\n               that's the key here. It's the symptoms, again, that we're putting band-aids on, but the root causes, we're not addressing at all. Supportive housing is not a zero-tolerance enforcement mechanism. It is meant to provide guidance, rehabilitation and pathways\n               towards stabilities. Yet Bill 11 expects housing operators to act simultaneously as law enforcement, mental health responders and social workers. How can you expect one person to be having to do law enforcement,\n               health and social work without training, without clinical support or integration with\n               first responders? That's a recipe for disaster. Again, in Finland, they have everything.\n               They have absolutely all the foundation, and it all works together because they all\n               want to be successful. So here we have it. So we have Bill 11. It is a recipe for disaster, just like so\n               many other failed experiments we've been listening to. Good intentions, absolutely,\n               without a shadow of a doubt, but certainly no clear and consistent processes or frameworks. Global best practices tell us a different story. I want to go back to Finland. In\n               Finland, integrated support services and harm reduction education accompany each housing unit. And I do know that when they're housed there, some are\n               there for the rest of their lives, because their mental health or their physical health\n               is not conducive for them living on their own without protective environments. And\n               what do they do each day? Some cook. Some clean. Some do gardening. Some do carpentry.\n               They have good lives. Quality lives. Eviction is also rare in Finland. Crises are prevented proactively. It's not reactive;\n               it's proactive. Tenants are supported to develop safe behaviours — and that's key.\n               If the expectations are so low that we expect them to continue to drink, take drugs\n               and be mentally ill, and set fires, then they're going to do that. Now, another great model is in the Netherlands. It follows a similar model, training\n               operators in conflict resolution, mental health crisis intervention, and social service\n               integration. There's a whole network, a whole framework, supporting these vulnerable\n               people. Why, then, does this government keep repeating the same mistakes and expecting different\n               results? Why doesn't this government learn from past mistakes, learn from best practices\n               around the world? Bill 11, in contrast, risks creating a climate of fear. Tenants are treated as problems\n               to be removed rather than individuals to be supported. Homes risk becoming sites of\n               surveillance rather than stability, undermining the very purpose of supportive housing The legislation also shifts undue liability to tenants. Clause 12 and clause 15 state\n               that tenants are responsible for damages caused not only by themselves — they're accountable\n               — but also by occupants they allow onto the property. This creates an environment\n               of constant risk. A tenant may find their home threatened due to the behaviour of\n               a visitor or even another tenant. Supportive housing should focus on systemic solutions,\n               including building safety, staff support and community education, rather than punishing\n               tenants for factors beyond their control. Now, authority without support is hollow. Bill 11 grants operators expansive powers\n               — eviction, access restrictions, property seizure — but, and here's the absolute worst\n               part of it, it does not provide funding for mental health staff, social workers or\n               housing navigators. No support. This is another huge recipe for failure. It is so disheartening to observe this government repeat the same mistakes over and\n               over again, and it can be fixed before we go down that path. This is not hypothetical.\n               Without resources, tenants face crises alone, and operators are left to enforce laws\n               they are not equipped to manage. Back to Finland. Finland's housing-first approach demonstrates that pairing authority\n               with dedicated support staff and crisis intervention funding significantly reduces\n               evictions and promotes long-term stability, not just for the tenants but also the\n               operators. Bill 11 ignores this lesson entirely. It expects success without providing\n               the tools or resources to achieve it. Bill 11 lacks robust oversight mechanisms. There is no structured process for auditing\n               compliance, tracking evictions or evaluating tenant satisfaction. Without these checks,\n               arbitrary decisions, bias and neglect are inevitable. That is huge. I see, not only\n               in this bill but in other bills, the data is not there. Whether it be on education\n               or health or now for housing, you need data. You need to take statistics. You need\n               longitudinal data to see what's working, where it's not working. How do we fix it?\n               That is really important. If you don't have any auditing framework for compliance or tracking evictions, then\n               how can we improve it? How can we find the mistakes? How can we find the issues that\n               are happening? Moreover, vulnerable populations, those with mental health conditions, substance use\n               challenges or marginalized identities, face compounded risks. Expedited evictions\n               may disproportionately affect those most in need of support, entrenching inequity\n               rather than addressing it. Global best-practice models mitigate these risks through\n               transparency, reporting and cultural competency training, ensuring interventions are\n               safe, fair and equitable. Those are the negatives. Let me make some suggestions for reforms. To transform Bill\n               11 into legislation that truly supports tenants, I would encourage this government\n               to look at the following. One, codify rights in the act. Move critical definitions from regulations to law,\n               ensuring transparency and stability and no misunderstandings. Two, equity and accessibility. Provide plain-language guides. Also make them multilingual\n               resources and accommodations for cognitive challenges. Make sure that the people understand. Three. I love this one because it's my bailiwick. Shift from seizure to education.\n               Education is my very Three. I love this one because it's my bailiwick. Shift from seizure to education.\n               Education is my very reason for living. You have to educate people on anything and\n               everything. So, shift from seizure to education. Replace punitive measures with mandatory\n               harm reduction and fire safety education. Four, mandatory collaborative training. Another thing I just love — collaboration,\n               cooperation. Integrate training for operators, first responders and mental health\n               professionals. Five, protect contract stability. Remove cabinet powers to unilaterally override leases. Six, address systemic safety. Focus on infrastructure, and that's what my colleague\n               was talking about today. Focus on infrastructure and building safety, not only tenant\n               behaviour. Seven, tenant participation. Establish advisory boards or councils for policy input.\n               That is really important. Give them a say. Give them responsibility. Give them accountability.\n               Believe it or not, they will rise to the occasion. So tenant participation. Eight, have clear eviction pathways. Ensure neutral review, safeguards and accessible\n               accommodations. I think that's really key. Not only neutral, but also objective. I\n               think there's the slight delineation between the two terms. A lot of the things we\n               have right now in education or health are subjective — subjective reviews, subjective\n               safeguards — and I think that's really important to have it objective so that then\n               we can all agree what that looks like. I want to go back to my best practices, I just love Finland. I think I should go there,\n               don't you? Housing First provides guaranteed tenancy, social service support and harm\n               reduction education. Evictions are extremely rare. Netherlands. Operators receive mental health and conflict resolution training integrated\n               with social services. New Zealand, Kiwi Land. Tenancy laws codify rights up front, avoiding reliance on\n               regulations. These examples demonstrate that clarity, integration and education are far more effective\n               than punitive measures in creating housing stability. Bill 11, while framed as supportive housing legislation, risks creating a two-tier\n               system, one in which the most vulnerable have the fewest rights, least support and\n               greatest exposure to uncertainty and fear. I don't have time today, but I have several\n               examples, one on the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation, one in North Vancouver and then one that is being proposed also in North\n               Van. The pros and the cons. Perhaps I'll have a chance in committee stage. If this government is serious about safety, if it is serious about stability and serious\n               about dignity, it must do more than appear tough. It must educate — please educate\n               — support and empower. A truly effective residential tenancy amendment act manages people with clarity, manages\n               people with support and manages people with resources, not with arbitrary authority\n               and fear. Tenants must understand their rights. Operators must be trained and supported.\n               Buildings must be safe. Homes for our most vulnerable must remain spaces of learning,\n               not uncertainty. On this side of the aisle, we advocate for legislation that does justice to its name,\n               one that educates, protects and empowers rather than punishes, destabilizes or confuses.\n               Let's make this truly supportive housing legislation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413661","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Actually, I sit here, and it's such a privilege to be in this chamber. And I am reminded\n               every day that what we debate, what we say, is extremely important because it has\n               repercussions and consequences not just for us but every single person in this province.\n               So I feel sometimes the pressure, but I feel that it's also an honour. So today we are gathered","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","label":"Lease","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["880937d0f5548186c666506588a108002f0cd6bbb6d7790a6b57c2f0c6af944f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["619d89f3a5086825310773a5f9c8dc26cf1c74b83e649655cb76da25482b34e2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Lease","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036093","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9feec619d566881384722b4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720128,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to take a moment to acknowledge an extraordinary place in my riding,\n               a sanctuary, a lifeline, a true haven for women and children in crisis — Sage Transition\n               House. For decades, Sage Transition House has quietly provided safety, support and hope to\n               women and children fleeing situations of abuse and violence. Its exact location remains\n               confidential — even I had trouble finding it; it's so well hidden — because safety\n               is paramount. This is a place where women can finally breathe, feel secure and begin to rebuild\n               their lives without fear. At Sage, the focus is on healing and empowerment. Women\n               and children are welcomed into a warm, supportive environment with access to comfortable\n               living spaces, counselling, educational programs and essential resources to help them\n               regain independence. From meals to mentorship, from emotional support to practical guidance, every aspect\n               of Sage is designed to nurture both safety and self-confidence. What makes Sage truly\n               remarkable is not just the services it provides but the people who bring it to life,\n               the dedicated staff and volunteers who offer compassion, guidance and hope when it's\n               needed most. For the women and children who arrive, often at their lowest points, Sage is more\n               than a shelter. It's a lifeline, a place where fear begins to lift and hope takes\n               root. The work of Sage Transition House reminds us of the power of community and care. It's\n               a quiet, steadfast hero on the North Shore, saving lives and giving families a chance\n               to start over, stronger and safer than before. For anyone visiting or supporting Sage, the message is simple. This is a place of\n               courage, compassion and transformation. And for the women and children who call it\n               home, it is nothing short of life-saving.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720128","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to take a moment to acknowledge an extraordinary place in my riding,\n               a sanctuary, a lifeline, a true haven for women and children in crisis — Sage Transition\n               House. For decades, Sage Transition House has quietly provided safety, support and hope to\n               women and children fleeing situations of abuse and violence. Its exact location remains\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Confidentiality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716752","label":"Confidentiality","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["decc1d32bce1686f11dd8a20790a9a531408936dbbe82f27a21550f4eb5ece6f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["267850e0b0dc289d1721d93de3959d29598cbe592a89e0a984d05b470123b48c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-815160eb09866bf872cbb4e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720131,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"[French was spoken.] It's a pleasure to welcome the students, staff and parents from\n               Cedardale, a French immersion school in my riding of West Vancouver–Capilano, and to welcome them to the Legislature today. I'd especially like to recognize the\n               principal, Kristina Hayes, and teachers Sarah Fee, Jo Ross and Elena Schroots, for\n               guiding and supporting these students. I'd especially like to recognize the principal, Kristina Hayes and teachers Sarah\n               Fee, Jo Ross and Elena Schroots, for guiding and supporting these students. A heartfelt thank-you as well to the parents accompanying this school group — actually,\n               there are going to be three groups today — your involvement makes opportunities like\n               this possible. [French was spoken.]. To all the students, welcome, and I hope your visit is inspiring and memorable.\n               [French was spoken.].","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720131","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"[French was spoken.] It's a pleasure to welcome the students, staff and parents from\n               Cedardale, a French immersion school in my riding of West Vancouver–Capilano, and to welcome them to the Legislature today. I'd especially like to recognize the\n               principal, Kristina Hayes, and teachers Sarah Fee, Jo Ross and Elena Schroots, for\n               guiding and supporting the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083668","label":"Language education","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fd35e670775015066aa827bcd89cd1922e5f6f06917dda4a2950f4d51d42ef5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a30471c13bd81cb2b1539f78e407815236310cd861e8d68854a0ea1387444388"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-42af3f7b5e91676ba2d535bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720134,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"This was a very interesting speech, because I did not know so much about the forestry\n               sector. I've learned a great deal from doing all the research. I'm indebted to two\n               people who are experts in this area. One was my colleague, the Forestry critic, who\n               spent his whole life in the forestry sector and knows it inside out. The other person is a lovely gentleman named George in my constituency. He is in his\n               90s. I asked him because he has spent his whole life in the forestry sector, ground\n               up one of the heads of one of the forestry companies for years. He now lives in my\n               riding. I'm indebted to his valuable advice. He read my speech. He read the bill.\n               He gave me some sage advice, so I've included that, along with my fellow MLA, the\n               critic for Forestry as well. So I learned as much. So I'm hoping that the new Minister of Forestry does listen to some of the speeches\n               in this debate because I think that they would be helpful moving forward, because\n               everybody wants to be successful in their role. I do rise today to speak on Bill 14, the Forest Statutes Amendment Act 2026, legislation\n               that claims to modernize forestry governance but, in truth, does not. It doubles down\n               on bureaucracy and uncertainty at a time when our forestry sector desperately needs\n               clarity, stewardship and long-term vision. I want to come back to that theme — long-term vision. For generations, forestry was the undisputed engine of British Columbia's economy.\n               At its peak, in the early 2000s, forestry accounted for nearly 25 percent of the provincial\n               GDP — boy, do we need that now — and sustained tens of thousands of jobs in every\n               region of the province. It was not simply an industry. It was part of our identity, our heritage and the Today forestry does remain vital, accounting for roughly 24 percent of B.C.'s exports\n               and supporting approximately 40,000 direct jobs and hundreds of thousands of indirect\n               jobs. Yet it is also a sector in managed decline. Its relative contribution to our\n               economy has diminished, consistent with decades of underinvestment, policy uncertainty\n               and shifting mandates that have suppressed, rather than supported, stability and growth. Now, to fully understand where we are today in this sector, we must look honestly\n               to how we got there. Over the past two decades, British Columbia's forestry sector\n               has been shaped by two distinct policy eras, each with different intentions but neither\n               of them delivering long-term stability. Under the B.C. Liberals, from 2001 to 2017, the focus was on maximizing output. High\n               allowable annual cuts, aggressive mountain pine beetle salvage logging and a market-driven\n               approach produced record harvest levels, strong rural employment and significant export\n               revenues in the short term. However, those gains came at a cost. Overharvesting in some regions and reliance on\n               beetle-killed timber created a fibre supply cliff once that resource was exhausted.\n               The result was a less resilient forest base and communities that became dependent\n               on volumes that could not be sustained. In effect, policy expanded the peak but deepened\n               the eventual decline. Since 2017, the B.C. NDP has shifted direction toward conservation, reconciliation\n               and a transition to a higher-value, lower-volume forestry model. While these goals\n               are important, they have been implemented during an already declining timber supply. Old-growth deferrals, reduced harvest levels and expanded land protections have accelerated\n               mill closures, reduced harvest output and introduced significant uncertainty for investment.\n               While this government did not create the downturn, its policies have made this downturn\n               and contraction more immediate and more visible, particularly in rural communities. The reality is that neither approach established a stable, long-term framework for\n               this sector. One prioritized short-term expansion without sufficient sustainability.\n               The other, the NDP approach, is managing the decline with added constraints but without\n               a clear transition plan. Compounding this is a fundamental structural issue — the absence of long-range planning\n               and the persistence of bureaucratic and administrative barriers that slow decision-making\n               and undermine confidence. Why is that? Forestry operates on timelines measured in\n               decades, yet policy continues to shift in very short cycles, creating instability\n               across the entire values chain. We must also recognize a critical operation reality. Every time a sawmill is shut\n               down, we do not just lose lumber protection. We lose residual fibre, particularly\n               wood chips, which are the primary feedstock for pulp mills. This creates a cascading\n               effect across the sector, tightening fibre supply even further and placing additional\n               pressure on pulp and paper operations that depend on that material. Now, unbeknownst to me, I learned something on a wonderful field trip with Screen\n               B.C., where they film one of Where Plays the Heart . I haven't watched that series, but I plan on doing so over the summer. But what was very interesting, part of their acreage, they had planted acres of cottonwood\n               to sell for toilet paper What was very interesting, part of their acreage, they had planted acres of cottonwood\n               to sell for toilet paper. Did I know that? No, I didn't. However, they've had to pivot,\n               because that's no longer viable. The decline in the forestry sector has been significantly accelerated by recent policy\n               shifts — specifically, old growth deferrals, reduced harvest levels and expanded protected\n               areas. Now, these changes have caused an immediate reduction in available timber,\n               creating a structural supply shock layered on top of existing shortages. Now, while\n               some level of fibre shortage was inevitable due to historical over-harvesting and\n               pine beetle damage, the NDP's policies were introduced faster than this industry could\n               adapt and without a transition plan to replace the lost fibre. Bill 14, as currently written, does not reverse this trend. It further entrenches\n               uncertainty and adds more layers of rigid new control rather than addressing the root\n               causes that have weakened our forests and the communities that depend on them. The\n               NDP has introduced real constraints regarding land and regulation without ensuring\n               that this sector can still function economically. One of the most profound challenges facing our forests today is leadership, instability\n               within the Ministry of Forests. In just under a decade, British Columbia has had at\n               least three different ministers of Forests, overseeing a sector where policy impacts\n               unfold over decades not fiscal quarters. Such frequent turnover disrupts continuity,\n               weakens institutional memory and undermines the long-range planning essential for\n               sustainable forest and resource management. What compounds this problem is that none of these ministers brought deep, boots-on-the-ground\n               forestry expertise to the job. We have seen ministers with backgrounds in power engineering,\n               labour relations and political advising, all talented public servants, but none who\n               are career foresters, silviculture specialists or forestry managers with lifelong\n               experience in the technical and ecological realities of forest management. The current minister may have the best of intentions, but he is essentially learning\n               the ropes as he's going and governing on one of the most complex economic portfolios\n               in B.C. While his political and government operational experience is strong, he possesses\n               no experience in the forestry industry or in actual logging and mill operations right\n               now. Furthermore, no matter how well intentioned, no provincial policy can control the\n               external global forces that dominate this sector, such as U.S. housing demand or global\n               lumber prices. So the minister may have the best of intention, but he can't control\n               outside external forces, and those impact us. This is not a trivial point, the difference\n               between theoretical policy knowledge and practical lived forestry experience. Knowing\n               how harvesting blocks are chosen, how regeneration cycles work, how markets respond\n               to fibre supply, how wildfire behaviour interacts with forest age and fuel loads —\n               lived forest experience is the difference between stability and dysfunction. Unfortunately, the current leadership in B.C. timber supply and MDF too often feels\n               disconnected from the very operational realities it claims to govern. That disconnect\n               shows up in every single mill closure, every delayed timber supply permit and every\n               rural community left behind. The impacts of this leadership vacuum and regulatory uncertainty are not abstract.\n               They are felt deeply in the valleys and towns across British Columbia. In 100 Mile\n               House, the permanent closure of the local mill resulted in the loss of 165 direct\n               jobs and over 1,000 indirect jobs. In Crofton, the closure of the pulp mill eliminated roughly 350 positions, stripping\n               away not just paycheques but decades of local heritage, intergenerational careers\n               and community resilience. I want to come back to that. This permanent closure resulted\n               in $1 billion lost to the Vancouver Island economy. These are not isolated statistics. And they are facts; they are statistics. These\n               are real families, empty streets, businesses closed, and young people forced to leave\n               their hometowns for a possible future elsewhere. This NDP government did not cause\n               the global market downturn. They didn't, but their policies have undeniably deepened\n               the short-term impact and reduced industry flexibility. Permitting timelines, once a predictable rhythm of long-term planning, have become\n               a bottleneck and a barrier. Industry now describes the permitting and regulatory process\n               as a \"slow, complex, and costly ordeal,\" where added layers of environmental review\n               and consultation requirements prevent timber from being harvested in time. Planning\n               costs, as an example, have tripled in the last five years — tripled in the last five\n               years. Permit submissions have declined dramatically, as industry participants struggle with\n               a system that frequently fails to align annual allowable cut targets with actual timber\n               supply. The result is a chronic fibre shortage that makes it economically impossible\n               for mills to operate profitably or even to plan years in advance with confidence,\n               yet instead of addressing these core, structural issues in Bill 14, government has\n               chosen once again to layer on complexity that only deepens the perception of unpredictability. Furthermore, the movement towards shared decision-making and co-management under DRIPA\n               has introduced uncertainty over final authority and project timelines. When investors\n               face unclear rules and constant strategy shifts, they delay or cancel projects, as\n               uncertainty alone can kill investment, even before regulations do. What are the specific flaws of Bill 14? At the heart of Bill 14 is a fundamental problem.\n               It adds new authorities and discretionary powers that go beyond what existing forest\n               legislation already allows. Clauses 2, 3, 5 and 10 grant the minister and timber sales\n               managers the authority to impose terms and conditions that are \"tougher than the law\"\n               — standards that exceed provisions in existing acts such as the Forest Act, the Forest\n               and Range Practices Act and the Wildfire Act. This sounds technical, but its impact is clear. It gives bureaucrats unbounded regulatory\n               discretion that, again, can shift from year to year, from region to region, with little\n               transparency and no guarantee that stakeholders will know what rules they must meet\n               until after the fact. For contractors and forestry operators trying to plan multi-year\n               investments, this is the very definition of uncertainty. The bill also introduces \"contract logging authorizations,\" a new mechanism that allows\n               government to contract harvesting activity without allowing the harvester to own the\n               timber. The sale and disposition of the timber will be handled by B.C. Timber Sales,\n               a government-run entity — and this mystifies me — that is not required to operate\n               for profit anymore. This shifts forestry away from market-driven efficiency and private capital investment\n               and places more control in a publicly managed entity with vastly expanded discretion.\n               I don't understand that one at all. Clause 8 This shifts forestry away from market-driven efficiency and private capital investment\n               and places more control in a publicly managed entity with vastly expanded discretion.\n               I don't understand that one at all. Clause 8 of Bill 14 is perhaps the most concerning for taxpayers and industry alike.\n               It expands the B.C. Timber Sales account to cover a wide range of costs, from road\n               construction and bridge maintenance to silviculture, well beyond the minimum requirements. More concerning still, the bill includes a subsection that overrides the Financial\n               Administration Act, effectively giving BCTS the authority to spend without the same\n               financial safeguards that apply to other government agencies. No regular audits, no\n               clear accountability and no benchmarked performance outcomes. Even me, who is very\n               new to understanding this forestry sector, looks at that and is quite concerned about\n               the costs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720134","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This was a very interesting speech, because I did not know so much about the forestry\n               sector. I've learned a great deal from doing all the research. I'm indebted to two\n               people who are experts in this area. One was my colleague, the Forestry critic, who\n               spent his whole life in the forestry sector and knows it inside out. The other person is a lovely gent","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036985","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036985","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Road construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036985","label":"Road construction","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d38b359f0dcb32882695973875794ceb2f582aee49a0f1d6cc8427da9109c1a3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b92e89ced4afbc6a88c73754c88fc03355fe986d70674ab63467f1573d5df899"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7c52c68a0e880e09eb6d2f74","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720137,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would appreciate finishing my speech on forestry.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720137","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would appreciate finishing my speech on forestry.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6af8f916824fa26bcf57116cbd0c77f339b713816d3090e638edd8cd96a9f002"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b5d70e9fab84d9be022c80ee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721205,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I do want to add on to the Creative Industries Week some brilliant people who really\n               enhance British Columbia to the world. Specifically, I want to really highlight Screen B.C. I had a tour about a month ago\n               of all these different places in B.C. that were filming some very well-known series,\n               including Tracker, which is one of my favourites. I just want to make sure that they feel very, very welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721205","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I do want to add on to the Creative Industries Week some brilliant people who really\n               enhance British Columbia to the world. Specifically, I want to really highlight Screen B.C. I had a tour about a month ago\n               of all these different places in B.C. that were filming some very well-known series,\n               including Tracker, which is one of my favourites. I just want ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vacations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037458","label":"Vacations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["431fd0d24ac388b5daf2445cb3d7b551d4f6baf851811a10681a331d1afa2357"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b0a3d7a3cfac4f0eaa570d9ef8bf106d9d3c668f489996b83385328ee7a5f8f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69844c41ebde9eb68284f878","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721213,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I do rise today to speak to this Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I want to begin by saying something clearly, because clarity matters\n               in this House, and often it's overlooked. Reconciliation matters. It's not something\n               to be feared, so I will repeat. Reconciliation matters. Treaties matter. They are\n               a positive way forward. Treaties matter. Negotiated settlements matter. The recognition\n               of Indigenous rights matter. For generations, governments in this country failed Indigenous peoples. That is not\n               in dispute here today. The courts have reminded us again and again that reconciliation\n               is best achieved not through endless litigation but through negotiation, respect and\n               honour. That principle is sound. That principle is just. That principle deserves legislation\n               that is transparent, accountable and durable. I am not a racist. I do not hate anybody. In fact, I find it difficult to hate anyone,\n               but to be labelled a racist or to be deemed hateful solely because I want to point\n               out the flaws in this bill, the flaws that can have a negative impact on all citizens\n               in B.C., both Indigenous and non-Indigenous, is disappointing. Through reconciliation,\n               real collaboration, honest conversations cannot be had when a person's attitude is\n               negative toward any constructive criticism. To reiterate, reconciliation matters. Treaties matter. Negotiated settlements matter.\n               the recognition of Indigenous rights matter. The courts have reminded us again and\n               again that reconciliation is best achieved not through endless litigation, but through\n               negotiation, respect and honour. Again, that principle is sound. That principle is\n               just. Again, that principle deserves legislation that is transparent, accountable\n               and durable. Bill 20 does not meet that standard. This is not simply a disagreement over policy. This is a structural, legal transformation\n               with cascading consequences across British Columbia. It fundamentally alters the relationship\n               between treaty law, provincial law, local government authority, resource rights, agricultural\n               protections and investor certainty. It does so in ways that are unclear, feel rushed\n               and in some cases, retroactive. As someone who has spent years in the classroom before entering this chamber As someone who has spent years in the classroom before entering this chamber, I have\n               learned that clarity matters. As a teacher, I learned long ago that when a student\n               hands in work that is unclear, feels rushed, incomplete, the kindest thing you can\n               do is not simply put a passing grade on it and move on, because that does not help\n               the student grow. It does not teach accountability, and it does not teach excellence.\n               Sometimes the responsible thing to do is to hand it back and say: \"This needs more\n               work.\" Bill 20 needs more work, because the consequences of getting this wrong are not theoretical.\n               They are immediate, they are structural, and they are long-lasting. And they affect\n               all citizens of British Columbia — Indigenous and non-Indigenous. Under section 6 of this act, the K'ómoks treaty prevails over provincial law in cases\n               of inconsistency. Provincial treaty implementation legislation also overrides other\n               provincial enactments where conflicts arise. This effectively creates jurisdictional\n               paramountcy and a multi-tier legal hierarchy. Businesses, municipalities, investors\n               and ordinary British Columbians will be left asking a basic question: which law applies?\n               And when the answer to that question becomes uncertain, confidence begins to erode. Under section 8, any legal challenge involving treaty validity requires notice to\n               the Attorney General of British Columbia, one of the same people that proposed this\n               bill; the Attorney General of Canada as well; and the K'ómoks Nation at least 14 days\n               in advance. All parties may intervene. That means possibility of increased litigation\n               complexity. It also could mean increased costs. It could also mean increased delay,\n               particularly when you've got several Indigenous Nations not wanting this treaty to\n               pass. Under section 24, this act applies retroactively to July 22, 2024. It retroactively\n               validates enrolment, eligibility and ratification decisions. If the process was lawful\n               and clear the first time, why is retroactive validation necessary? That is really\n               incomprehensible. I don't understand. If it was lawful there and clear the first time,\n               why do we need retroactive validation at all? Retroactive law-making undermines certainty, both for Indigenous and non-Indigenous\n               citizens of B.C. It raises serious questions. And it creates the appearance of legal\n               shielding rather than legal clarity. There's that term again — clarity. The consequences for British Columbia's economy are profound. Businesses respond to\n               uncertainty. And uncertainty is exactly what this bill creates. When treaty supremacy\n               is combined with broad, regulatory discretion and the denial of compensation in key\n               areas, investors are forced to price that uncertainty into every single decision that\n               they make. Capital. Capital becomes more expensive. Projects become more cautious, if they happen\n               at all. Long-term investments become more mobile. The result may not be immediate\n               collapse, but it is a steady re-pricing of British Columbia as a higher-risk jurisdiction.\n               In a global economy Under this government, British Columbia faces soaring annual deficits, a ballooning\n               provincial debt now measured in the tens of billions, repeated credit rating downgrades\n               that increase borrowing costs, and billions of dollars each year in interest payments\n               alone — money spent servicing the debt instead of funding classrooms, hospitals and\n               public services. Any uncertainty caused by this bill will only exacerbate our already\n               precarious financial position in British Columbia. Nowhere are the negative consequences of this bill more immediate than in forestry.\n               Under sections 15 and 16, timber harvesting rights under Forest Act agreements are\n               cancelled. Area-based licences are partially deleted where they overlap treaty lands.\n               Road permits are cancelled insofar as they apply to K'ómoks lands. Specific woodlot licences, W0085 and W1677, expire in 25 years and are non-replaceable.\n               Allowable annual cut reductions may be opposed on W2030, and former tenure holders\n               remain liable for road deactivation and environmental obligations. Think about that. Rights are extinguished. Liabilities remain. The obligation survives,\n               but the asset does not. That is not balance. That is distortion. Under section 17, these impacts do not constitute expropriation. And that is a very\n               important part. There is no compensation, no traditional recourse under the Expropriation\n               Act. This sends a chilling message to anyone who invests in British Columbia in good\n               faith. Why would they take the risk? Another major concern is agriculture. At a time when food security matters more than\n               ever, this act removes K'ómoks lands from the agricultural land reserve. The Agricultural Land Commission Act no\n               longer applies. Provincial oversight....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721213","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I do rise today to speak to this Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I want to begin by saying something clearly, because clarity matters\n               in this House, and often it's overlooked. Reconciliation matters. It's not something\n               to be feared, so I will repeat. Reconciliation matters. Treaties matter. They are\n               a positive way forward. Treaties matter. Negotiated s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b3c5ce4502da2bcf6dbf4b6d79a6bd6016f3a11d4e78d0612c1fe8c083040d2e","57eff6312a39ebd51f701e364df58a4b2cac9a18acf0e101115b743ccf33eb53"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0dd34e8edeee8bf2cb5fc06e22cdfebf6edbe26d4344cd8db995e92bb76d9422"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdef0ad3a4246f20eee96cb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728810,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am thrilled today to have a very dear friend and former teaching colleague, who\n               is here today along with her two sons: Sandra Sokugawa, her son Cayden and her son\n               Sebastian. She is an extraordinary teacher. She has done professional development\n               and Tribes training, cooperative learning, research-based learning throughout B.C.\n               with me. She has written numerous articles for very different education manuals. She\n               has a master of science in psychology and neuroscience in mental health from King's\n               College London, England. Cayden is studying in mathematical sciences at UBC, and Sebastian is in grade 10 and\n               enjoying sciences at his secondary school. I am honoured to have them here today, and I thank them for their inspiration, their\n               guidance, their mentoring. Amazing. Please make them feel very, very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728810","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am thrilled today to have a very dear friend and former teaching colleague, who\n               is here today along with her two sons: Sandra Sokugawa, her son Cayden and her son\n               Sebastian. She is an extraordinary teacher. She has done professional development\n               and Tribes training, cooperative learning, research-based learning throughout B.C.\n               with me. S","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Science education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:189515","label":"Science education","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cff3fc5ae08243f648ab1fadf38573c16b758068a252fadb7c71b12d7a736e11"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["372f2aa4177632f2653e718050401ee5b67539647a1d8f5f8b698d932d462f29"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-29501b3a5b704edddb898616","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728813,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728813","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1a740f614aed4d77831133bbb4b5bcff07ca39f8ea3712c97d1b5eb7eb776163"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-955ebacf0ce29090c5054f98","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752170,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"When we are","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752170","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"When we are","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7a526c8f3d6feb7714e16af1062394d20b9da19aeb6c38c01e58a77d6b8540c8"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d3e1133b2a69e3051822202","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752171,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"Ah, that was lively. I appreciate the words of my colleague before me, making it very\n               clear what the hoist motion is all about. I rise today to speak in support of the hoist motion that the motion for second reading of Bill (No. 9) intituled Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026 , be amended by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting \"six months hence.\" This is a straightforward procedural change in wording, but it carries profound legislative\n               significance. It is, in essence, a motion to defer consideration of Bill 9 for six\n               months, and that deferral is both necessary and justified. This motion to delay for six months is not about obstruction. It is about responsibility.\n               It asks this House to recognize that when we amend legislation in real time, when\n               government itself brings forward corrections to its own bill, it is, by definition,\n               acknowledging that the original version was incomplete or even flawed. That reality alone supports the logic of a six-month pause. We are not being asked\n               to perfect a finished product here. We are being asked to continuously repair one.\n               A six-month deferral allows this House to step back, assess the full scope of those\n               deficiencies and ensure that what ultimately proceeds is sound in law, clear in meaning\n               and durable in practice. Once legislation is enacted, it ceases to be theoretical. It becomes operational.\n               It governs real decisions, real disclosures and real consequences for British Columbians\n               seeking access to information and protection of privacy. That is precisely why this\n               motion to defer for six months is so critical. In this field of law — and it is in the field of law — errors are not abstract drafting\n               problems. They are barriers to transparency, barriers to accountability and, most\n               importantly, barriers to public trust. When the stakes are access to information and\n               privacy rights, rushed correction is not good governance. It is risk accumulation. As Benjamin Franklin wisely said, and it's a very old saying: \"An ounce of prevention\n               is worth a pound of cure.\" That principle is really accurate today, and it's not rhetorical.\n               It is structural. The motion before us to substitute \"six months hence\" for the word \"now\" is the legislative\n               expression of prevention. It recognizes that it is far easier to correct deficiencies\n               before enactment than to repair or band-aid systemic issues after implementation. Let's be frank. This is not delay for its own sake. It is discipline in the service\n               of better law. The central question before this House is not whether Bill 9 proceeds, but whether\n               it proceeds in a form that is complete, in a form that is coherent, in a form that\n               is consistent with its own stated objectives. The government's willingness to bring forward amendments already signals that refinement\n               is definitely required. That fact strengthens, it does not weaken, the case for a\n               six-month deferral. If amendments are necessary today, then it is reasonable to conclude\n               that deeper issues may still remain beneath the surface. This motion to defer for six months ensures that those critical issues are addressed\n               comprehensively rather than incrementally under pressure. Now, modernization has been cited as justification for urgency. This is not logical\n               because modernization is not defined by speed. It is defined by clarity This motion to amend second reading of Bill 9 by substituting \"six months hence\" for\n               the word \"now\" reflects that understanding. Taking additional time now is what ensures\n               that modernization is meaningful rather than superficial. Without that time, we risk\n               producing legislation that may be modern in appearance but definitely unstable and\n               lacking in application. This motion to defer for six months is justified by the extensive work already completed\n               by the 2022 Special Committee on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Act. I refer back to that. It was in 2022. That committee produced a multiparty....\n               All people giving their input. It also produced an evidence-based roadmap, very important\n               here. It called for stronger timelines, it called for improved access, it called for\n               enhanced oversight, and it called for proactive disclosure — all laudable and important\n               enhancements. If the current bill already requires amendment, this raises a reasonable concern that\n               those recommendations issued in 2022 have not been fully applied or integrated. A\n               six-month pause would allow this House to properly align Bill 9 with that existing\n               body of work rather than attempting to retrofit alignment after the fact. This concern is underscored when we examine the substance of this Bill 9. The 2022\n               Special Committee on the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act emphasized\n               clear, duty-driven standards. Yet, clause 3 replaces the requirement to respond \"without\n               delay\" with \"without unreasonable delay.\" This is not a minor drafting change. It\n               represents a fundamental shift from a clear obligation to a more subjective, justification-based\n               standard. \"Without delay\" provides a firm directive whereas \"without unreasonable\n               delay\" introduces ambiguity, subtly shifting the burden from the government, to justify\n               delays, onto applicants, to challenge them. A six-month deferral would allow the House to reconcile this departure and ensure\n               consistency with the committee's recommendations. Why not? Why reinvent the wheel\n               when it is going to fall off? Why not use this committee's recommendations to make\n               sure that this bill is the best it can be? Another compelling reason for this motion lies in the need for precision in legislative\n               language. I want to come back to that in a little while too. When statutes rely on\n               open-ended or subjective terms such as \"reasonable amount of time\" or \"experienced\n               employee\" or \"abusive\" conduct without clear definitions of any of those terms, they\n               create subjective interpretive instability and ambiguity. This is not merely theoretical. It leads to uneven application across public bodies,\n               where identical requests may be treated differently depending on the individual looking\n               at them and reading them, and their interpretation. Clause 2 illustrates this risk by introducing a subjective threshold for what constitutes\n               a valid request, based on the opinion of the head of a public body, regarding what\n               constitutes a \"reasonable\" time to locate records. Well, to me, reasonable Well, to me, reasonable is two days to get back to a constituent who is asking for\n               information, two days. But maybe someone says that a month is reasonable time. There\n               is no definitive clarification on what is reasonable time, and that's open-ended.\n               What is reasonable to one official may not be reasonable to another. By making reasonableness\n               a matter of opinion rather than an objective standard or definition, the balance of\n               power shifts toward the gatekeeper and away from the citizen. This concern is reinforced in clause 13, which expands the grounds....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752171","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Ah, that was lively. I appreciate the words of my colleague before me, making it very\n               clear what the hoist motion is all about. I rise today to speak in support of the hoist motion that the motion for second reading of Bill (No. 9) intituled Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026 , be amended by deleting the word \"now\" and substituting \"six months hence","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2179c89d2e094315788634b8bf335c3f82ece58255adfe3292f7863fcc663644"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f2bda7b2ecf447d26231f6797892608e1e98c32bbda1c96ddeafbc9860fc6059"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-863fac01282ea6b837b0bacd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752172,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"In Ontario, the Toronto Transit Commission police are being allowed to arrest open\n               use of illegal drugs. We know one of the barriers to increasing ridership on public\n               transport is people not only feeling unsafe, but they are unsafe. Will this government follow Ontario's lead and require that transit police arrest\n               those that are openly using illegal drugs?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752172","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In Ontario, the Toronto Transit Commission police are being allowed to arrest open\n               use of illegal drugs. We know one of the barriers to increasing ridership on public\n               transport is people not only feeling unsafe, but they are unsafe. Will this government follow Ontario's lead and require that transit police arrest\n               those that are openly using illegal drug","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","label":"Arrests","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["200fd375fd71bff1cccd6c9c70ef34a3912d9c6b01a9010b63420ed067316f24"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["32215ff2492b7eebe506f0823799ea513b0fb1de332c864d00124d7e9c5667ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Arrests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47399","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6687493bf8a0882a06ec64ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017091,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I love coming to the Leg the day before we are in session because it's very quiet\n               and I can do a lot of work in my office. But I didn't realize that it was open to\n               the public yesterday, and it was exciting to meet wonderful people. I met a lovely family, a gentleman who is a doctor originally from Nigeria and his\n               three children. I'd like to do a shout-out to Austin, Jasmine, Jayden and Jesse and\n               welcome them. I hope they come to the Legislature today too.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017091","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I love coming to the Leg the day before we are in session because it's very quiet\n               and I can do a lot of work in my office. But I didn't realize that it was open to\n               the public yesterday, and it was exciting to meet wonderful people. I met a lovely family, a gentleman who is a doctor originally from Nigeria and his\n               three children. I'd like to do a shout-o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["46ab7db23c0513c2983eeddacfa29eee7d44fd65e1993bfae67ffa4400147bfc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-afbe0f63e5a5b288e71a74b7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017098,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"This coming Sunday is my wonderful grandson Fraser's seventh birthday. He is such\n               a keener and an absolute duck to water with ice hockey. Passionate about it. Will the House please help me wish him a very happy birthday on Sunday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017098","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This coming Sunday is my wonderful grandson Fraser's seventh birthday. He is such\n               a keener and an absolute duck to water with ice hockey. Passionate about it. Will the House please help me wish him a very happy birthday on Sunday.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","label":"Aquatic wildlife","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ead18509d6a4d4d6423fcef099759a44d10fd8fc9f4add54a705869bed737539"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e168a524b9dbffbf2e2f6fce20a90f92456e7f10c8affa44c2bcaab4e6cf4059"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ed7c9d98f62c476612fbf39a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036402,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"In a democracy, accountability does not end on election night. It begins there. The\n               decisions made in this Legislature affect every family, every worker and every future\n               generation. They shape taxes, spending, debt, health care, infrastructure and human\n               rights. That is why it is both reasonable and responsible that newly elected members\n               of the Legislative Assembly receive mandatory training in economics, public finance\n               and numeracy. These are not partisan ideas. They are essential tools for informed decision-making.\n               We would never expect a pilot to fly without training or an engineer to design a bridge\n               without understanding physics. Yet elected officials are asked to make enormously\n               complex decisions involving billions of public dollars and the well-being of millions\n               of people, without being informed. Good intentions alone are not enough. Public service requires preparation, humility\n               and a willingness to learn. As former South African President Nelson Mandela said:\n               \"Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.\" Mandatory orientation courses would not dictate ideology or political belief. They\n               would simply ensure that all members, regardless of background or party, possess a\n               basic understanding of the responsibilities of governing in the public interest. At\n               a time when misinformation and distrust are rising, strengthening the knowledge and\n               competence of elected officials is not elitist. It is democratic. Citizens deserve\n               leaders who are prepared not only to speak passionately but to govern responsibly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036402","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In a democracy, accountability does not end on election night. It begins there. The\n               decisions made in this Legislature affect every family, every worker and every future\n               generation. They shape taxes, spending, debt, health care, infrastructure and human\n               rights. That is why it is both reasonable and responsible that newly elected members\n               o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cb77d7e1e8d098a5191f220f118a81509149f861f5050400960acb7fac6ad3cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b765dc1a7d904f08664613f811c22a05fd52ce8253597c6195f96601f8e6675e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-08cbb1a9f0fc7d8bc20c94de","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036403,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am delighted to introduce Ella Van Enta, my newest CA, who is beginning in June. How much does she love the Legislature? Well, there was a newscast being filmed right in front of the Legislature, in front of the fountain. All of\n               a sudden, the camera got diverted because Ella's fiancé was down on bended knee, asking for her hand in marriage. And she said yes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036403","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am delighted to introduce Ella Van Enta, my newest CA, who is beginning in June. How much does she love the Legislature? Well, there was a newscast being filmed right in front of the Legislature, in front of the fountain. All of\n               a sudden, the camera got diverted because Ella's fiancé was down on bended knee, asking for her hand in marriage. And she said yes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Television","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727276","label":"Television","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ad7f0efae057afa8a075cbbbd0b8e1171d91fc236af17f2943d8220e714546a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1cf6f26744c7ee884e04e211a8dcf775e310ef429b4dfc07f2379402644e5591"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5043bd38a6c102c03a1cd7f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036404,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"Imagine it is a gorgeous summer's day with the sun shining down on exquisite flowers\n               dotted around lovely gardens, pristine greens, graceful trees and all overlooked by\n               a gracious heritage clubhouse, with a wide veranda filled with onlookers, laughing\n               and having fun, children as young as nine years old and seniors in their 90s all sharing\n               the same greens, all enjoying the simple pleasures of lawn bowling together. The West Vancouver Lawn Bowling Club has been a cherished part of the West Vancouver\n               community for generations. Since the early 20th century, it has grown alongside West\n               Vancouver itself, not just as a sporting club but as a gathering place where friendships\n               are formed, neighbours connect and people of all ages feel welcome. What makes this club so special is not only its history but its spirit of inclusion.\n               Through lessons, tournaments, open houses and youth programs, it has kept a proud\n               tradition alive while making it accessible to new generations. It is a place where\n               young people learn from seniors, where seniors remain active and engaged, and where\n               everyone feels a sense of belonging. In a fast-changing world, the West Vancouver Lawn Bowling Club reminds us of the importance\n               of community, of connection and of healthy living. It enriches West Vancouver not\n               simply as a place to play a sport but as a place where people truly come together,\n               where friendships are born, stories are shared, laughter echoes across the greens\n               and generations connect with one another. It is a welcoming home away from home, where\n               everyone is greeted with kindness, everyone is valued and everyone belongs.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036404","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Imagine it is a gorgeous summer's day with the sun shining down on exquisite flowers\n               dotted around lovely gardens, pristine greens, graceful trees and all overlooked by\n               a gracious heritage clubhouse, with a wide veranda filled with onlookers, laughing\n               and having fun, children as young as nine years old and seniors in their 90s all sharing\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715827","label":"Accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dfd157c8c40b168442c400c747e246bfdb01adc16a5ea0dc1b665720e54ee89b","efa50b11e2e4bd0dd56ec5154dd418cc3af8095cdf4bd5d21f94cbe34516de14"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["70a5c364ec1bb392891b9a0edd0a1ddeda7e0c4aee84453c12eae5d03a3401ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15195862193bebf199d907db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036405,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lynne Block","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to warmly recognize my CA Raquel Francis and her family in the gallery\n               today. Raquel's dedication, professionalism and steadfast support are truly exceptional.\n               I would also like to recognize my outstanding CA Ashten Young, who, beginning tomorrow,\n               will be starting a year of maternity leave. Ashten is the epitome of grace, compassion\n               and excellence in her role, and she will be deeply missed. Will the House please welcome Raquel and her family and join me in wishing Ashten\n               and her growing family every joy in this special new chapter.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036405","member_id":"bc-mla-411","member_name":"Lynne Block","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to warmly recognize my CA Raquel Francis and her family in the gallery\n               today. Raquel's dedication, professionalism and steadfast support are truly exceptional.\n               I would also like to recognize my outstanding CA Ashten Young, who, beginning tomorrow,\n               will be starting a year of maternity leave. Ashten is the epitome of grace, compassion\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e7705fe37c688bb141ddc4afd45a5a445e0a50383898b5e6e85f55e0d439c77"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3423e36853f602ae7ab0827","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317161,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"This budget is brought to you by the NDP, and it reflects more fiscal mismanagement\n               and deficits. The best predictor of future behaviour is past behaviour, and that is\n               what we're seeing in this budget. I rise today to respond to Budget 2026, a budget that the government says is about\n               sustainability, stability I rise today to respond to Budget 2026, a budget that the government says is about\n               sustainability, stability and security. But in Kelowna Centre and across the B.C. Interior, people are asking a different question. Stable for\n               whom, and secure for whom? What I'm hearing from seniors and from families caring for their loved ones with disabilities,\n               small business owners and working parents, from those struggling to stay housed, is\n               not about security. It is strain. That's what I'm hearing. This Premier inherited a surplus of over $5 billion, and his party now predicts another\n               record-breaking deficit. This budget has us hurtling towards a path of deep debt and\n               interest payments that will take away from families, seniors and social programs,\n               and have our great-grandchildren paying the price. And for what? Who can say that\n               life is better in 2026? Do people have family doctors? Are wait times lower in our\n               ERs? How about surgery wait times? Youth unemployment is skyrocketing. Crime is out of control. Businesses are fleeing\n               British Columbia because, under this government, margins just keep shrinking. On top\n               of slim margins, small business owners are asked to put up with and pay for smashed\n               windows, defecation and open drug use in front of their stores. Life in B.C. is becoming\n               unbearable, and it is showing in a mass exodus of our citizens and our businesses. In the Interior, we face unique pressures. We are growing rapidly. People move to\n               the Okanagan because they love the quality of life, the beauty and the promise of\n               opportunity. But growth without infrastructure is not prosperity. Growth without health\n               care access is not compassionate or humane. Growth without affordability is not security. Kelowna has become one of the most expensive mid-sized cities in Canada, yet wages\n               in B.C. have not kept pace. Rents remain high. Home ownership is out of reach for\n               many young families, and seniors who thought they had planned responsibly are now\n               relying on programs that are becoming less and less affordable. This government has managed to gift Kelowna with a 6 percent rental vacancy rate,\n               yet prices remain high. They bankrupted moms and pops who owned a condo for retirement\n               purposes and simply created a glut of two small apartments that no one wants to live\n               in. This government likes to pride themselves on being courageous enough to try things,\n               no matter how colossal the failure. This budget is, at best, a status quo of the past\n               few years and, at worst, an absolute failure to British Columbians today and for generations\n               to come that will pay for it. Let me begin with seniors. For months, I've heard from seniors in Kelowna who feel\n               invisible, people who've worked their entire lives, paid their taxes and built this\n               province. Many are now relying on the property tax deferment program to remain in\n               their homes. This program was originally designed to provide relief, a bridge to stability. But\n               changes that increased borrowing costs, particularly at rates above prime and compounded\n               over time, fundamentally alter the nature of this program. When interest costs rise,\n               the deferment stops being a lifeline and starts looking like a liability. The question seniors are asking me is simple. Will this policy quietly push more of\n               us out of our homes? This is not alarmism. This is math. At a time when seniors are\n               facing rising grocery costs, higher insurance, higher utilities and stagnant fixed\n               incomes, the last thing they need is increased borrowing costs on the very program\n               designed to help them age in place. Our caucus believes this budget is egregiously unfriendly towards seniors, and we\n               will continue to call that out, because dignity in aging should not depend on your\n               ability to absorb new interest penalties. Let's talk about persons with disabilities. Across British Columbia, individuals receiving\n               disability assistance remain living well below the poverty line. Even with previous\n               increases, the support does not match the real cost of living, particularly in communities\n               like Kelowna. Rent alone can consume nearly all of one's disability payment. That\n               leaves nothing — nothing for transportation, food security, medical equipment or participation\n               in community life. I am hearing from people with disabilities who feel completely forgotten by this government.\n               When a government claims progress but leaves people unable to afford basic necessities,\n               that is not meaningful reform. It is incrementalism in the face of urgency. We should\n               be aiming to lift people out of poverty, not manage their survival within When a government claims progress but leaves people unable to afford basic necessities,\n               that is not meaningful reform. It is incrementalism in the face of urgency. We should\n               be aiming to lift people out of poverty, not manage their survival within it. This\n               budget fails to move the needle in a meaningful way. In the Interior, we continue to struggle with access to health care. Kelowna General\n               Hospital is a critical hub for the entire region, yet patients continue to face long\n               emergency room waits, specialist shortages, family doctor scarcity and delays in surgeries.\n               We have seniors waiting for long-term care placement, families stretched thin, providing\n               unpaid caregiving. Cottonwoods — that was a campaign promise. The then Health Minister visited Kelowna\n               in June of 2024, an election year, and made a beautiful announcement, something that\n               this government does so well, only to put this project on an indefinite hold last\n               week. The people of Kelowna will remember this as a failed campaign promise, and this\n               is only one of six other long-term care projects in B.C. also halted. Rural communities surrounding Kelowna have even fewer services. This budget speaks\n               broadly about system investment, but Interior residents are still asking: when will\n               we see measurable improvements? When will recruitment and retention strategies translate\n               into actual doctors in clinics and actual family doctors? When will seniors stop waiting\n               months or even years for appropriate care placements? Announcements are not access,\n               funding lines are not outcomes, and interior British Columbians deserve both. Kelowna is at a crossroads. Compassion and accountability must go hand in hand. Downtown\n               businesses are struggling. Residents feel unsafe in areas that they once enjoyed.\n               Front-line responders are exhausted, and we continue to see the consequences of policies\n               that prioritize decriminalization and safe supply without sufficient treatment capacity,\n               recovery beds or judicial reform. I spent the last two months in my community door-knocking, engaging with small business\n               owners in Kelowna and discussing the devastating impact of crime in our downtown.\n               On my walk-arounds, I encountered many locked doors and business owners actively installing\n               buzzer systems, gates, shutters and bars in Kelowna, business owners who told me stories\n               of criminals who smash a window and then turn around and say: \"What are you going\n               to do about it?\" This is what is happening under this government. The stories that I heard all held common threads. Kelowna is loved. It's beautiful.\n               The business owners are committed to the community and to their businesses, and many\n               have been there two and three decades. But we are at a tipping point, a crossroads.\n               Crime and open drug use, social disorder — it is overshadowing the beauty and the\n               livability in our downtown, and it is not okay. It is overshadowing the ability to\n               move and do business with reasonable ease. Once vibrant businesses are now struggling financially. Once compassionate individuals\n               are wondering how much more they can care. Once forward-thinking business groups are\n               saying: \"Enough is enough. We cannot do more without the support of our province.\" We need, we are asking for, we are demanding this government to provide a clear path\n               to treatment, timely access to recovery services, housing that doesn't lump everyone\n               together without thought to individual needs and vulnerabilities, mental health supports\n               that intervene early and often, judicial systems that protect communities. This budget does not adequately recalibrate that balance. It continues spending but\n               without structural reform, and spending without reform does not restore public confidence.\n               Until we get there and get those things from our province, our downtowns, Kelowna\n               included, will continue to languish. Small businesses in Kelowna are resilient, but resilience has limits. Insurance costs\n               are high. Commercial rents are high. Labour shortages persist, and red tape continues.\n               Yet this budget offers little in targeted relief for mid-size urban centres like ours.\n               We need policies that allow small businesses to thrive, not just survive, because\n               thriving British Columbia's forestry sector is in crisis. As Peter Lister of the B.C. Truck\n               Loggers Association recently said, he's never seen it as bad in over 35 years, describing\n               an industry on the edge of collapse. Yet this budget cuts $400 million from forestry.\n               In 2022, government stood alongside the Council of Forest Industries and promised\n               15,000 new forestry jobs. But instead, since 2022, we've lost 30,000 jobs. Royalty revenues have fallen from $1.8 billion in 2022 to just $500 million in '26,\n               a staggering decline in four years. Sadly, what the loss of the forestry industry really translates to in a community\n               are dads who lose their jobs, families losing the ability to care for themselves.\n               In communities that are forestry-dependent, it often means an impossibility of selling\n               or renting out your home. If there is no industry, who could move there? Who wants\n               to? Families become stuck. Families become impoverished, leading sometimes to addiction\n               and/or depression. This is not speculation. This is happening, and it's happening in our northern communities\n               where they depend on forestry, and they have less provincial resources, like the things\n               the other side of the House likes to speak about, like Foundry and food banks. Our\n               smallest British Columbians are often the ones who suffer the most, the children. At the same time, this budget cuts $2 million from fire preparedness. From fire preparedness?\n               I live in Kelowna. We cannot be cutting from this line. I almost lost my home in 2023\n               to the fires. Myself and my neighbours know what it's like to be threatened by wildfire,\n               and we believe in the importance of prevention. Spending money now on management and\n               being proactively prepared will go much further and cost far less than having to rebuild\n               homes and infrastructure that is lost. Never mind that. It's almost three years later, and this government still hasn't cleared\n               out the burned trees. Can you believe that? What is the holdup? Perhaps there should\n               be a line in this budget that finishes this process so that we can get people back\n               into nature, hiking trails and feeling mentally well again. Instead of a clear, comprehensive\n               strategy, workers and communities are getting endless reviews and endless uncertainty,\n               and rural British Columbia is paying the price. Mining is another cornerstone industry facing growing pressure. As Todd Stone of the\n               Association for Mineral Exploration has warned, British Columbia is already one of\n               the least cost-competitive jurisdictions in the world for mining and mineral exploration.\n               Yet this budget adds costs, while cutting $433,000 from mine health, safety and enforcement,\n               despite multiple fatalities and miners trapped just last year, and reducing responsible\n               mining and competitiveness funding by $1.6 million. The warning signs are clear. Mineral claim applications are down 29 percent compared\n               to the seven-year average, and the total area applied for or registered has fallen\n               60 percent. Instead of strengthening incentives, like the mining exploration tax credit,\n               to reflect mineral quality and competitiveness, government is narrowing eligibility.\n               At a time when global demand for critical minerals is rising, British Columbians should\n               be competing for investment, not driving it away. And might I remind this government\n               that mining and forestry can both be huge drivers of our economy, providing both high-paying\n               jobs and funding the many social programs that British Columbians rely on. This budget does not unlock our massive potential for revenue, and therefore it does\n               not serve British Columbians well. If we unlocked our potential, perhaps we would\n               not be projecting a deficit, or at least not one of these proportions. Perhaps we\n               wouldn't need to tax bookkeepers for doing the books of small businesses. This budget projects significant deficits. British Columbians understand that deficits\n               can be necessary during crises, but structural, ongoing deficits without a credible This budget projects significant deficits. British Columbians understand that deficits\n               can be necessary during crises. But structural, ongoing deficits without a credible\n               plan for long-term balance erode confidence. Future generations will pay for decisions made today. If we are going to borrow, it\n               should be tied to measurable reform, capital investment and structural improvements,\n               not simply program expansion without accountability merit. Taxpayers deserve transparency,\n               they deserve performance indicators, and they deserve measurable results. We should be protecting seniors from rising borrowing costs in essential programs.\n               We should be raising disability supports to reflect actual living costs. We should\n               be expanding long-term-care capacity in the Interior. We should be accelerating doctor\n               recruitment with measurable targets — measurable targets. We should be rebalancing public safety policy with treatment-first models. We should\n               be supporting small business growth and ensuring fiscal discipline and long-term stability.\n               This is not radical. This is responsible governance. Behind every single line item is a person. A senior choosing between groceries and\n               medication. A person with a disability skipping meals to afford rent. A caregiver\n               burning out while waiting for respite. A business owner wondering if they can renew\n               their lease. A downtown resident avoiding streets they once loved. Budgets are moral documents. They reveal priorities, and too many people in Kelowna\n               feel they are not the priority in this document. British Columbians are resilient.\n               Kelowna is resilient. But resilience should not be exploited. It should be supported. This budget misses the opportunity to meaningfully address affordability for seniors,\n               lift persons with disabilities out of poverty, restore balance in community safety,\n               grow our resource sector and allow it to flourish and deliver tangible improvements\n               in Interior health care access. Our caucus will continue to hold this government accountable respectfully, rigorously\n               and persistently because British Columbians deserve better than announcements. They\n               deserve better results.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317161","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This budget is brought to you by the NDP, and it reflects more fiscal mismanagement\n               and deficits. The best predictor of future behaviour is past behaviour, and that is\n               what we're seeing in this budget. I rise today to respond to Budget 2026, a budget that the government says is about\n               sustainability, stability I rise today to respond to Budget 2026, a bu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["dbc427679c8371ada127458bd36df9acccf12be87f4636d38bb565ab12326d85"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["94fdb4f8cc928aafdf53b0ca1a304538ea85241cd9fe684fd3631675bf61bb01"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ff07b8a5809d6d27e63fa2b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317162,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"When my kids were in elementary school at Rose Valley, they had a special bench on\n               the playground. It was a bench you could go to and sit on if you were feeling lonely.\n               It was a signal to the other children that you were looking for someone to play with,\n               someone to connect with. I loved that for my children. I loved that one of my kids would go and watch for others\n               to sit down and then go and befriend them. And I loved it for the kids who felt sad,\n               lonely or left out, because it took away the stigma and the sting. It made it socially\n               acceptable to say: \"Hey, I need a buddy. I'm not thriving today.\" But it did something else. It gave that child a voice. It gave them an opportunity\n               to advocate for themselves and to ask for a friend. There were no victims. There were\n               no bullies. There was only opportunity on both sides. I think about that today on a day when we talk about anti-bullying, and I wonder:\n               where would you be on that playground? Where would I be? What if the playground is\n               your caucus or this chamber? Would you dare to sit on that bench and show your vulnerability?\n               Would you dare to cross the field and extend that friendship? It is not lost on me, and I don't believe that it's lost on any of you, that what\n               happens in this chamber and the way that we treat each other is reflected in the greater\n               community, in our province, in our families and amongst our neighbours. Every member\n               in this chamber is elected. We are elected to make life better for British Columbians,\n               and they are depending on us to do just that. This is about perspective. It's about putting ourselves in the shoes of others, recognizing\n               that we never truly know the struggles someone else may be facing or the personal\n               circumstances they may be carrying. Every day members highlight beautiful stories of our ridings, stories of generosity,\n               innovation and community. Every day we speak about kindness, inclusion and equality.\n               But at times, we fail. We fail British Columbians when we do not model these same\n               values here in this chamber, in the bathrooms, in the hallways, in the dining rooms\n               and in our caucus rooms, even in how we follow parliamentary procedure. So let us\n               do better today because that is what British Columbians elected us to do, and their\n               lives depend on it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317162","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"When my kids were in elementary school at Rose Valley, they had a special bench on\n               the playground. It was a bench you could go to and sit on if you were feeling lonely.\n               It was a signal to the other children that you were looking for someone to play with,\n               someone to connect with. I loved that for my children. I loved that one of my kids would go and watc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c548a49d3457536dbf6ddf588c987a75b075a2f308eb1fa99b93a4fb6fce748"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ef6c04547936baeaf8a053e34cb8ed933f5664f72501431aebd22d2f7dd6955d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4651e0df0212b9af3eb39bcf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317163,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to mention Gloria Larson from Kelowna, who won the B.C. caregiver award\n               of the year. It was an honour to meet her last night at the awards ceremony, and her\n               spirit, her personality, her character came through just in the conversations that\n               I had. Her 51 years of service is incredible, and I can see that she's an exemplary Her 51 years of service is incredible, and I can see that she's an exemplary person. So just help me in honouring her again today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317163","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I just want to mention Gloria Larson from Kelowna, who won the B.C. caregiver award\n               of the year. It was an honour to meet her last night at the awards ceremony, and her\n               spirit, her personality, her character came through just in the conversations that\n               I had. Her 51 years of service is incredible, and I can see that she's an exemplary Her 51 years of ser","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4a26e1c6217afeef2778a897","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327998,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today it is a privilege to welcome back to the Assembly one of my constituency assistants\n               and, for the first time, my other constituency assistants. They are more than assistants\n               to me. They are very special women, both of them. They are advisors, managers, vision-casters,\n               proactive, forward-thinking ladies and incredible advocates for the people of Kelowna Centre. Please join me in giving a warm welcome to Kathrine Gountas and Debbie Duncan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327998","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today it is a privilege to welcome back to the Assembly one of my constituency assistants\n               and, for the first time, my other constituency assistants. They are more than assistants\n               to me. They are very special women, both of them. They are advisors, managers, vision-casters,\n               proactive, forward-thinking ladies and incredible advocates for the people of Kel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3dc904f49e2f339156b2569ab41b48d66af2f8d3983e8b1b1c2af489dd336bdc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9be4e4325912ceb3535ba734","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360397,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's been a pleasure this week to welcome the B.C. home builders and the realtors\n               from all across the province. We really enjoyed meeting with them over the last couple\n               of days, and we just want to thank them for their advocacy. Today I just want your support in welcoming to the chamber Kim Heizmann, Seth Scott,\n               Ryan Main, Gavin Thomas and Kayden Rainville, all from the Interior.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360397","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's been a pleasure this week to welcome the B.C. home builders and the realtors\n               from all across the province. We really enjoyed meeting with them over the last couple\n               of days, and we just want to thank them for their advocacy. Today I just want your support in welcoming to the chamber Kim Heizmann, Seth Scott,\n               Ryan Main, Gavin Thomas and Kayden Rainvi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Home-based businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083670","label":"Home-based businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.67,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b743597d71cd68e6bd1fc657cf0f3a65a99981ccded8b0563486dd04c9f27fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["065dbd7422463892b362501c1255a994adc0de62f45c87ce49907a023fd0b460"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b2fb48739593cdbfd88d18aa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360398,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"It sounds like the answer is no. She will not repeal it in good faith. The lines have become so long at our food banks that they now need to hire private\n               security. Food banks should be a last resort, but under this government, we've seen\n               an 80 percent increase in food bank usage. Also under this government, food banks\n               now have to pay PST for security. Meanwhile, the head of Community Living B.C. made\n               $330,000 last year and has a vehicle allowance of $12,000. How does this Minister of Social Development and Poverty Reduction find it acceptable\n               to pay a $12,000 vehicle allowance when people in B.C. can't afford food?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360398","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It sounds like the answer is no. She will not repeal it in good faith. The lines have become so long at our food banks that they now need to hire private\n               security. Food banks should be a last resort, but under this government, we've seen\n               an 80 percent increase in food bank usage. Also under this government, food banks\n               now have to pay PST for security. M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["399144dfe3d10d049645ab5144c84a9ecd960b72a33a918096769339237a05b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9ef11150cdff24cac182dc8ac740629fae5baa25031135d685670d61e9d8dc40"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0de1817d61a089265c13c6c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360399,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize BrainTrust Canada. For individuals and families living with\n               acquired brain injury, life can change in an instant. A fall, a car accident, a stroke,\n               and suddenly the path forward is uncertain, isolating and overwhelming. What those at BrainTrust understand is that recovery is not just medical. It's social,\n               emotional and communal. Multiple studies show that more than half of people experiencing\n               homelessness have a history of traumatic brain injury, an injury that often occurred\n               before they became homeless. Brain injury is also disproportionately present among\n               those involved in the justice system, struggling with substance use and living in\n               poverty. The team at BrainTrust builds community and connection. They advocate for those who\n               struggle to advocate for themselves. BrainTrust offers case management, peer support,\n               life skills, employment assistance and education. They offer dignity. They offer belonging\n               and community. They offer hope. System designs often do not account for cognitive impairment. Individuals may be labelled\n               non-compliant, when in reality, they are living with memory loss, impaired emotional\n               regulation or executive functioning challenges. Survivors of intimate partner violence\n               may not even know they have sustained a brain injury. Youth exposed to violence may\n               carry invisible neurological impacts into adulthood. People cycle through shelters,\n               probation and treatment programs, often without screening, without accommodation and\n               without understanding. When BrainTrust steps in, they walk alongside individuals and families navigating\n               life after injury. They recognize the person beyond the diagnosis. Amanda McFarlane,\n               Kaitlyn Stuley and their team see the person behind the injury. When they meet the\n               client, they meet them with compassion and genuine care, not bureaucracy. They are\n               supported to live full and meaningful lives. The BrainTrust team reminds us that strong communities are built through people, people\n               who choose to care, to advocate and to stand alongside others in their most vulnerable\n               moments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360399","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize BrainTrust Canada. For individuals and families living with\n               acquired brain injury, life can change in an instant. A fall, a car accident, a stroke,\n               and suddenly the path forward is uncertain, isolating and overwhelming. What those at BrainTrust understand is that recovery is not just medical. It's social,\n               emotional and communal","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["002e67a82560ab0499c3cd374bc8212efca5f122176b82dd3e04a93d30853d35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["95f2178406995a93976eb8782b5f49659980949305c6e8a4c6d8576f4d70beb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0e08562191a21bf6c0d8741e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415758,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased today to rise in support of Motion 203, brought forward by my colleague.\n               At its core, this motion is about something that should unite every member of this\n               House, trust. Trust that the people hired to serve British Columbians are selected\n               because they are the best qualified, the most qualified. Trust that promotions are\n               earned, not given. And trust that government decisions are made fairly, transparently\n               and without favour. That is the merit principle. It is simple. It is essential. The merit principle ensures that individuals are hired\n               and promoted based on their ability to perform the job, not because of who they know,\n               not because of political alignment and not because of personal connections. British\n               Columbians expect nothing less. They expect that the public service, one of the largest\n               and most important institutions in our province, operates with integrity. They expect\n               fairness. They expect accountability. And that's exactly why independent oversight\n               matters. Motion 203 affirms that the application of this merit principle in B.C.'s public service\n               should be overseen by an independent officer of this Legislature, not by government\n               itself, because when oversight is independent, it's credible. When it reports to the\n               Legislature, it's accountable to all members, not just the executive. And when it\n               operates transparently, it strengthens public confidence in the system as a whole. Let me be clear, this motion is not a criticism of the professionalism of public servants.\n               British Columbia is home to thousands of dedicated individuals who serve our province\n               with excellence every single day. This motion is about protecting them. It's about\n               ensuring the system that they work in is fair, that their efforts are recognized and\n               that advancement is based on merit not influence. Unfortunately, the direction we're\n               seeing from this government moves us away from that standard. Through the Budget Measures Implementation Act, the government is eliminating the\n               Office of the Merit Commissioner, an office whose sole purpose is to ensure that appointments\n               to government positions are based on qualifications, an office with a modest annual\n               budget, just $1.7 million. Yet despite its small cost, its value is immense, because\n               it provides something that cannot be replaced easily, independent accountability. The timing of this decision is deeply concerning. According to the Merit Commissioner's\n               own reporting, there has been a noticeable increase in cases where merit was not applied.\n               In the most recent year reviewed, 10 percent of appointments examined did not meet\n               the merit standard. The commissioner himself noted that since 2022-23, there has been\n               an increase in merit-not-applied findings. Further, the most recent audit found the\n               highest rate of flawed hiring processes and outcomes in nearly a decade. Those aren't minor observations. Those are warning signs. And instead of strengthening\n               oversight and response, government is choosing to eliminate it. We have also heard\n               directly from the Merit Commissioner, who cautioned that the cost of losing independent\n               oversight may ultimately far exceed the savings from eliminating a small oversight\n               body. This is a powerful statement. It's not just about dollars. It's about public\n               confidence. It's about ensuring that British Columbians believe in the fairness of\n               their government. It's not just the commissioner raising concerns. The president of the BCGEU stated\n               clearly they were not consulted and that they oppose this move. He noted that removing\n               this office effectively eliminates the audit function, leaving government to oversee\n               itself. At a time when competition for public service roles is increasing and when\n               hiring processes must be above reproach, this is the wrong direction. We should be\n               strengthening oversight, not weakening it. At a time when competition for public service roles is increasing and when hiring\n               processes must be above reproach, this is the wrong direction. We should be strengthening\n               oversight, not weakening it. It's worth remembering that this office was not created lightly. It was established\n               in 2001 to ensure that merit-based hiring was protected and upheld. In fact, its role\n               was expanded in 2018 to include dismissal reviews, recognizing the importance of fairness\n               across the entire employment life cycle. More recently, a non-partisan, multiparty\n               committee of this Legislature affirmed the importance of maintaining that independence. This motion does something very reasonable. It does not reinvent the system. It doesn't\n               undermine the government. It reinforces what should already be a shared commitment\n               that merit matters, that independence matters and that accountability matters. Because\n               when we get hiring right, we get better outcomes for British Columbians. We get stronger\n               public services and better decision-making, and we get greater trust in government. I would urge all members of this House to support Motion 203 to affirm that merit-based\n               hiring must be protected and to ensure that oversight remains where it belongs, with\n               an independent officer of this Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415758","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am pleased today to rise in support of Motion 203, brought forward by my colleague.\n               At its core, this motion is about something that should unite every member of this\n               House, trust. Trust that the people hired to serve British Columbians are selected\n               because they are the best qualified, the most qualified. Trust that promotions are\n               earne","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18a59a2250faec55cfb28f1acc5c518672e313f744db7dbf0590e466f1f1b7e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5fe37d516c4a09c94afc07fc08dcb9a76bde63853955f441eebd711707856597"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e332d5156802cd7178d337f9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415759,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to introduce somebody that I don't need any notes for. I know this person\n               quite well. In fact, I met him about 30 years ago when he was just a young 20-something\n               and he was sporting a full beard. And I can assure you that he looked older then than\n               he does now. My husband, Andrew Loewen. Together we've been married almost 30 years,\n               and we raised four kids together. I am excited to say that he accompanied me to Victoria\n               without any of those children this weekend, and we had a good time together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Couples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415759","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I want to introduce somebody that I don't need any notes for. I know this person\n               quite well. In fact, I met him about 30 years ago when he was just a young 20-something\n               and he was sporting a full beard. And I can assure you that he looked older then than\n               he does now. My husband, Andrew Loewen. Together we've been married almost 30 years,\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","label":"Couples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Couples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","label":"Couples","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63a5d242d7436d9dbf9b16ff11c48a2ecbfa7f898c6d36e03e663f22c94ffa3f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Couples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["422169b4434e2f1c3fe550f6cedc81e244836e534948c617ad530c2c27795053"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Couples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034708","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd41332cc9be5becca8d36ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415760,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today it's a pleasure to welcome to the chamber my new friend. She is a human rights\n               activist and author. Her book Unveiled has been translated into 19 languages. She's an incredible human being, a podcaster.\n               She has a charity called Free Hearts Free Minds and she's co-founder and co-director\n               of the Clarity Coalition. Amongst raising her two daughters and just being an amazing human and doing a million\n               interviews, she's just an all-around incredible human, please join me in welcoming\n               Yasmine Mohammed to the chamber today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415760","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today it's a pleasure to welcome to the chamber my new friend. She is a human rights\n               activist and author. Her book Unveiled has been translated into 19 languages. She's an incredible human being, a podcaster.\n               She has a charity called Free Hearts Free Minds and she's co-founder and co-director\n               of the Clarity Coalition. Amongst raising her two daughters a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037165","label":"Social rights","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e69f35563a2b5ea80fbf8e622a94fef21a995fd1b2d94d6765d09c4f9633a590"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["141ac9e79295d414e2d78b34bc3974d9dca2dd8bd04fb3373467c51882d59589"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bf1caec882235d69fd4875c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720421,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to speak about an organization in my community that represents the very\n               best of what it means to care for one another, Metro Community Hub. Metro is more\n               than a building or a program. It's a place where dignity is restored and where people\n               are seen and where practical help meets genuine compassion. Five days a week Metro Community Hub opens its doors to individuals experiencing homelessness\n               and vulnerability. They provide hot lunches and fresh coffee – simple things, yes,\n               but they're offered with consistency and care, and that builds trust and stability.\n               They offer things that we take for granted: access to showers, laundry, computers,\n               phone charging and safe storage. These are the basic building blocks of dignity: the ability to clean your clothes,\n               check your email, store your belongings and take a shower before a job interview or\n               a meeting. But what makes Metro truly remarkable is the people behind it. The staff\n               and volunteers are extraordinary. Many of them serve not from a distance but from\n               lived experience, themselves But what makes Metro truly remarkable is the people behind it. The staff and volunteers\n               are extraordinary. Many of them serve not from a distance but from lived experience\n               — themselves or the struggle of a loved one. They know what it means to struggle.\n               They know what it means to rebuild. Some have been unhoused themselves or have walked\n               alongside loved ones who were. That lived experience creates something powerful, not\n               just service or programming, but connection and trust. Metro allows a place for Interior Health and social workers to connect with those\n               who have no fixed address but need access to medication and services. It's a place\n               where families can reach out to potentially find their loved ones. Trust is what allows\n               Metro to reach people and consistency and community is what allows them to catch those\n               who fall through the cracks in the system. Metro is also deeply rooted in its neighbourhood. They do not ignore the very real\n               concerns of nearby residents and businesses. Instead, they engage with them. They\n               listen. They work to mitigate disruption. They understand that compassion for those\n               in crisis must exist alongside respect for the broader community. And the broader\n               community is feeling the consequences of the increase in social needs. This balance\n               is not easy, but Metro strives for it every single day. Metro also stands in the gap, offering support to those in danger of becoming homeless.\n               Sometimes they cover rent or groceries. Metro knows that it only takes 14 days for\n               an individual to become entrenched in homelessness. And they know that intervening\n               to prevent this saves lives, dignity and money in the long run. Metro invites those looking for purpose yet still living on the streets or in shelters\n               to come and serve. I've served coffee alongside those trying to improve their lives.\n               I recall the pride with which they signed in to serve the coffee and sandwiches. Metro\n               lets them participate. They give them purpose. I see the individuals take great pride\n               in being able to lend a hand. Everyone needs a place to belong, a purpose and connection. Metro invites individuals still in the struggle into their community and into their\n               church. This is exactly the kind of grassroots, community-driven response to the homelessness\n               that we should be celebrating, supporting and partnering with. And yet that is not\n               what is happening. Despite meeting eligibility requirements, Metro Community hub has been denied gaming\n               grant funding, not once but twice. Let me be clear, this is a Christian organization,\n               but it operates with an independent board. It meets the criteria. It delivers measurable,\n               meaningful impact in addressing homelessness, poverty and community well-being. Metro\n               did their due diligence and confirmed eligibility prior to applying for gaming grants,\n               and yet they have still been turned away. At the same time, Metro was incorrectly classified as an art gallery and hit with\n               a $45,000 tax bill in 2025, despite being tax-exempt every year prior and every year\n               since. This is not just a bureaucratic error. This is a failure that has real consequences\n               for a front-line organization doing essential work. When organizations that are feeding\n               the hungry, supporting the vulnerable and stabilizing communities are forced to fight\n               through red tape and incorrect assessments, we have to ask ourselves, \"What are we\n               doing?\" And when those same organizations happen to be faith-based, we must also ask\n               whether they are being treated fairly. This government often speaks about inclusion, about equity, about supporting vulnerable\n               populations, but inclusion must include everyone. Equity must be applied consistently\n               and support must be based on the value of the work, not the beliefs of those doing\n               it. Metro does not turn away people based on who they are or what they believe. They serve\n               everyone who walks through their doors with dignity and respect. They are living out\n               the very values that this House so often claims to champion. If we're serious about addressing homelessness, not just talking about it, but actually\n               making a difference, then we need to support organizations that are already doing\n               the work. I have written to the Ministers of Finance and of Tourism, Arts and Culture, and I urge them to help this incredible organization\n               to reverse the charges and grant the grants.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720421","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I rise to speak about an organization in my community that represents the very\n               best of what it means to care for one another, Metro Community Hub. Metro is more\n               than a building or a program. It's a place where dignity is restored and where people\n               are seen and where practical help meets genuine compassion. Five days a week Metro Community Hub opens","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4a1bf82bbc76a4ff4ced3b08399e27c344092bbce5196e36df1645746be9da4d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["034290d5d35a0ef6e1c38334bc6b3191798bf4cb37b3d7c3f131b76f4f0dfb49"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25c442e2e77d1d5d753ddab3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720422,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Okanagan Forest Task Force began ten years ago, simply and powerfully. A group\n               of outdoor enthusiasts refused to accept the growing crisis of illegal dumping in\n               our forests. On their very first cleanup, just 15 volunteers, removed over three metric tons of\n               garbage from a single site. Today this entirely volunteer-driven organization has\n               grown into a Today, this entirely volunteer-driven organization has grown into a movement. Over\n               1.3 million pounds of garbage and scrap metal from the Okanagan backcountry, waste\n               pulled out of forests, lakes and natural spaces that should never have been polluted\n               in the first place.... They are restoring ecosystems, protecting wildlife and preventing forest fires by\n               removing flammable debris and hazardous materials left behind in our backcountry.\n               They are safeguarding communities across the Okanagan. Their impact is so profound\n               that wildlife has returned, and places are safe, clean and thriving again. Through their documentary, What Lies Behind the Trees , they are shining a light on what many people never see: the hidden environmental\n               damage in our forests and the power of everyday citizens to step up and make a difference. There's a dark side to this story: the fact that the housing crisis and the opioid\n               crisis has pushed some of our homeless into the forest. It sounds wonderful, in a\n               way, but the truth is that housing is far below adequate, and they leave behind abandoned\n               vehicles, trailers, garbage, clothing, sewage — so much waste and destruction, born\n               out of very real need and desperation. One couple chose to squat in the forest in\n               order to afford their medication. She drove out daily to work. OFTF volunteers give up their weekends to haul out garbage. They care deeply about\n               the land we all share. They are driven by responsibility. They show us what is possible\n               when a community comes together with grit, grace and heart. They aren't just cleaning\n               up forests. They're bringing awareness and telling the story with compassion and authenticity. Thank you to Kane Blake, David Owendike, James Mayers, Eli Coburn and the many, many\n               volunteers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720422","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The Okanagan Forest Task Force began ten years ago, simply and powerfully. A group\n               of outdoor enthusiasts refused to accept the growing crisis of illegal dumping in\n               our forests. On their very first cleanup, just 15 volunteers, removed over three metric tons of\n               garbage from a single site. Today this entirely volunteer-driven organization has\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["59250e6587c199bfabbb6e20c1859d7501c82f6b4d63f69e48da9130ff39edae"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d712954857c590830d07fee07f91f0bd449691eb4b1dd09abc96b12fb61d8e91"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c5536928b898c1512def2b19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721519,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a privilege for me to recognize a member of my family today. In speaking with\n               the member for Surrey-Panorama, we discovered that we both had tiny baby girls on the exact same day 23 years ago,\n               effectively twins. Mine wasn't so tiny, though. She was nine pounds five ounces, and she's been making\n               a big splash ever since. It's no secret to this House that she's gone through a lot\n               of struggles in the last couple years. I don't know where those struggles are going\n               to take her, but I'd be lying if I said I wasn't unbelievably proud of her and all\n               of the things that she has overcome. She has been through two psychoses from PANDAS. She's been through relationship partner\n               violence struggles. She is just an incredible young woman healing. She's going to\n               be a strong advocate. She's going to share her story one day, and I'm just so proud\n               of her. Would the House just join me in wishing my Gabriella Anne Brielle Loewen a really happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721519","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a privilege for me to recognize a member of my family today. In speaking with\n               the member for Surrey-Panorama, we discovered that we both had tiny baby girls on the exact same day 23 years ago,\n               effectively twins. Mine wasn't so tiny, though. She was nine pounds five ounces, and she's been making\n               a big splash ever since. It's no secret to this House ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035242","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fertility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035242","label":"Fertility","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97f0581c8f6a9e4b98560d304a627be4ea9d33a9c4f857808c42a065ddab7a1e","874e820f4405893e38f21f76ef202c7124486033ace3604408477bf2b11124ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d537ca037578b3630ff8d1e57d97b15da7c0b36166efca9ad6ea3e643fd47d1f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bbd3896c2d2b8da6fb52b282","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721524,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, and welcome to the chair — my third Chair today. Just before the break, I was saying that transparency is not a partisan issue; it's\n               a democratic one. In fact, in displaying that it's not partisan, I'm going to quote\n               one of my colleagues from the Green Party, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who said that the commissioner's support for this bill, in part, is part of a steady\n               degradation of our democracy in this province. No other commissioner in Canada would\n               ever countenance some of the amendments that are proposed in this legislation. A case in point: in recent weeks, we've already seen developments that raise questions\n               about the strength of oversight in our province. One example is the government's move\n               to eliminate the Office of the Merit Commissioner, an independent office responsible\n               for ensuring that hiring across the provincial public service is based on merit and\n               fairness. The purpose of that office is simple and essential. It provides the public\n               with confidence that hiring decisions across government are conducted fairly and without\n               political influence. Independent oversight bodies exist for a reason. They exist because governments should\n               not be left to police themselves. When those oversight structures are weakened or\n               removed, public interest is inevitably affected. Now in this very same period, we\n               see legislation that would make freedom-of-information requests easier to dismiss\n               and, potentially, more expensive to obtain. When multiple transparency mechanisms are weakened at the same time, it creates a\n               troubling picture, because each of these systems — oversight offices, freedom-of-information\n               laws and independent watchdogs — plays a role in ensuring accountability. Remove enough\n               of them, or weaken enough of them, and accountability begins to erode. We do not have\n               to look far to see why transparency matters so deeply to communities across British\n               Columbia, including in my own region. In Kelowna and across the Okanagan, residents regularly seek information about decisions\n               that directly affect their communities. One area where this has become particularly\n               important is development and land use planning. As our region continues to grow rapidly,\n               residents want to understand how decisions are being made, what studies were conducted,\n               what internal communications took place and how proposals were One area where this has become particularly important is development and land use\n               planning. As our region continues to grow rapidly, residents want to understand how\n               decisions are being made, what studies were conducted, what internal communications\n               took place and how proposals were evaluated. In many cases, those answers are only\n               available through freedom-of-information requests. Residents use FOI to access internal reports, staff communications and background\n               documents related to development proposals. Those records help communities understand\n               the full context behind decisions that may reshape their neighbourhoods. Without freedom\n               of information, many of those records would remain inaccessible to the public. Citizens\n               would simply be asked to trust that decisions were made properly, without ever seeing\n               the documentation behind them. We've also seen many examples across the Okanagan where journalists and residents\n               rely on access to records to better understand how public institutions are operating.\n               Local media outlets such as Kelowna Now , Castanet, Black Press and other regional publications frequently rely on access\n               to public records when reporting on municipal spending, infrastructure planning and\n               government communications. The records allow the public to see how decisions are made,\n               and sometimes those records raise difficult questions. It's not a flaw in the system.\n               It's exactly how the system is supposed to work. Transparency can occasionally be uncomfortable for governments. Internal discussions\n               may become public. Policy debates may be revealed. Spending decisions may be scrutinized.\n               But that discomfort is not a weakness of democracy. It's one of its safeguards. When\n               public institutions know their decisions may be examined by citizens, journalists\n               and opposition members, it encourages better decision-making. It encourages accountability. We should be asking ourselves: why is this government seeking less transparency and\n               accountability? The erosion of transparency rarely happens overnight. It happens gradually\n               — a new fee here, a new administrative hurdle there, expanded powers to dismiss requests.\n               Each individual change may appear modest, but over time, those barriers accumulate.\n               Each one discourages a few more people from filing requests. Each one limits access\n               to a few more records, and slowly the system shifts. What was once a culture of openness can begin to drift towards a culture of secrecy.\n               This is why legislation like Bill 9 deserves careful scrutiny. Transparency does not\n               disappear all at once. It erodes piece by piece. Bill 9 may appear to introduce only modest changes, but those changes matter because\n               they alter the balance between government power and public access to information.\n               In a democracy, that balance must always lean toward the public. British Columbians deserve a government that welcomes scrutiny; a government that\n               recognizes transparency strengthens institutions rather than weakening them; and a\n               government that understands that when citizens ask questions about public decisions,\n               they're not interfering with government operations. They're participating in democracy,\n               in their democracy. That's why maintaining strong freedom-of-information laws remains\n               so important. Sunlight remains one of the most powerful tools we have for protecting\n               accountability in public life. Another reason this debate matters so deeply is that British Columbians are asking\n               more questions than ever about how public money is spent. Across this province, families\n               are facing rising costs — housing, groceries, fuel, insurance and utilities. Communities\n               are watching budgets closely, and people want to know whether their tax dollars are\n               being used responsibly. British Columbians are also asking a deeper question. What is behind the numbers presented\n               to them? When government announces the cost of a housing unit, does that number include\n               layers of taxes, development charges, regulatory costs and admin expenses built into\n               the project? When we're told the price of a public program, do we know what assumptions\n               were used to calculate that number? The public deserves more than a headline figure.\n               They deserve the details behind the data. Without those details, citizens cannot evaluate\n               whether public funds are being truly used effectively. Freedom of information allows the public to see background documents, internal reports\n               and financial assumptions that help answer those questions. That transparency becomes\n               particularly important when we look at some of the most challenging policy areas facing\n               this province. We often hear compelling stories used to justify certain policy approaches. Many British\n               Columbians have heard the example of million-dollar Murray, a case often cited to\n               suggest that a person experiencing homelessness may cost the public nearly $1 million\n               over years through emergency services, policing and hospital visits but far less than\n               that $1 million once they're placed in supportive housing. It's a powerful story, but responsible public policy requires more than powerful stories.\n               It requires transparent data. How were those numbers calculated? What assumptions\n               were included? What services were counted? Equally important, what are the long-term\n               costs of operating supportive housing once it is built It's a powerful story, but responsible public policy requires more than powerful stories.\n               It requires transparent data. How were those numbers calculated? What assumptions\n               were included? What services were counted? And equally important, what are the long-term\n               costs of operating supportive housing once it is built? In Kelowna, residents have asked and raised questions about facilities such as Ellis\n               Place, where serious damage rendered parts of the building uninhabitable for extended\n               periods of time — actually, I believe, the whole building. When situations like that\n               occur, there are legitimate questions. What are the repair costs? What happens to\n               the operational budget? What happens to the residents who were living there? Is Million-Dollar\n               Murray still less expensive housed? I'm not suggesting we shouldn't house people,\n               but what are the true costs? The public deserves to know. Without access to internal records and financial documents, the public cannot fully\n               understand the real costs and challenges involved. Transparency allows those conversations\n               to be based on facts rather than assumptions. That's exactly what we should expect\n               in a healthy democracy. When governments spend public money, the public has the right to ask questions about\n               where that money goes, what programs it funds and whether those programs are achieving\n               results. Freedom of information is one of the ways citizens get those answers. That's\n               why legislation that restricts access to information inevitably raises concerns about\n               accountability. We've also seen similar examples across the wider Okanagan.... Transparency in spending is especially important at a time when the province is facing\n               record levels of debt and deficit. British Columbians are carrying historic levels\n               of public debt. Government spending has reached record levels, and yet many British\n               Columbians are asking why outcomes in critical areas such as housing, health care\n               access and affordability are not improving at the same pace. Those are legitimate questions. They are questions any responsible government should\n               be prepared to answer. Freedom of information plays an important role in helping the\n               public get those answers. Journalists also play a crucial role in examining public spending. Investigative reporting\n               often relies on access to government records, expense reports, internal briefing notes,\n               contracts and procurement documents. Without access to those records, journalists\n               would be forced to rely solely on government press releases and public statements. That's not accountability. Accountability requires the ability to verify. It requires\n               access to the records that explain how decisions were made. That's exactly....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721524","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, and welcome to the chair — my third Chair today. Just before the break, I was saying that transparency is not a partisan issue; it's\n               a democratic one. In fact, in displaying that it's not partisan, I'm going to quote\n               one of my colleagues from the Green Party, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who said that the commissioner's support for this bil","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Environmental education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752547","label":"Environmental education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["992b8031e2df522eac2806309dc0cfd08ca672b9b5bd693fb29858484dda0a4a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c5e066694a4e6f4c6abe6e309e35e824e756e571547f916e66638c515b8325b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b652243d01be0a34091a5bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729195,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to make an introduction, as well, today. We have the good people from\n               Take a Hike visiting today. I just want to applaud them for the work that they do\n               in our school districts with youth and mental health and getting them out into the\n               great outdoors. Will the House please join me in welcoming them today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729195","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to make an introduction, as well, today. We have the good people from\n               Take a Hike visiting today. I just want to applaud them for the work that they do\n               in our school districts with youth and mental health and getting them out into the\n               great outdoors. Will the House please join me in welcoming them today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["48389a3029e2818257ca6e19435f9e7d567d7735a84229931a92556dfe7c807b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cefd8c69621071d2e8c5083a74cde3cbfc000bb1b68012eeccaad74665460858"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-12be34e41977aa02e866f39f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729196,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Kelowna is hosting free public watch parties at Waterfront Park on June 24 and July\n               2 — thousands of fans, outdoor crowds, in the heart of tourism season.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729196","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Kelowna is hosting free public watch parties at Waterfront Park on June 24 and July\n               2 — thousands of fans, outdoor crowds, in the heart of tourism season.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d0bdf5e4a531494bf2c7f2d51d0fd5e02b8d243e749279110f7da1a5ee8e02d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-538ca2d395ba400bba7d3006","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729199,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a pleasure this morning to welcome my friend Nahal Kara to the chamber this\n               morning. He's an incredible member of the community and quite involved in politics.\n               Would the House please help me make him feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729199","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a pleasure this morning to welcome my friend Nahal Kara to the chamber this\n               morning. He's an incredible member of the community and quite involved in politics.\n               Would the House please help me make him feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cd8967b3b4c7139df11a00746552af5e9ea34764a82c055cec6c732a0c95a7b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c0a78ad856e3fc413d335678","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729200,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729200","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2957c7144d58519e84a096ead0c0c486902e5ddbed122052ac4632ee7d015b8c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7ec3b14488f675af73f31feb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752278,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Respectfully, the system will always fail. The system will always have gaps. That's\n               why it's so important that family members are included. And that is not even remotely\n               the first thing that any hospital or any system asks the family members. In Vernon, Ezra Kool self-admitted under the Mental Health Act and was placed in a\n               hallway bed, despite being in what was supposed to be supervised care. Ezra did the\n               right thing — he asked for help — but this government system failed him. He was somehow\n               able to leave the unit, and within hours he was dead. To the minister, when Ezra left the unit, did the hospital even know he was gone?\n               And if they did, why was his family not immediately notified?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752278","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Respectfully, the system will always fail. The system will always have gaps. That's\n               why it's so important that family members are included. And that is not even remotely\n               the first thing that any hospital or any system asks the family members. In Vernon, Ezra Kool self-admitted under the Mental Health Act and was placed in a\n               hallway bed, despite being in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cbb2c6ce952fa222fa313c1a4e8a7687153981f3061f8edf4f815495786216d2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71d7d575991ed650c68fc46ce8a2cd3d2fdbd2961930adcc8b04868ada51dac9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4146c22e140844a2f011dd4b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752279,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to rise for a few moments to talk about this report and the work of the committee. I had the privilege of joining this committee last fall. I very much value its important\n               role in raising awareness of challenges across the child-and-youth-serving system.\n               The presentations that we have received have been insightful, and I appreciate the\n               ability to seek further information from the representative. This has helped me to continue to advocate for children and youth in British Columbia. This has helped me to continue to advocate for children and youth in British Columbia,\n               and this is not something that I take lightly. Children and youth are a precious gift.\n               At a time when social and economic pressures are increasing, social media is taking\n               a toll, and mental health issues are on the rise, I feel that it is more important\n               than ever that we work together in the committee in a non-partisan manner. I'm proud\n               to do that work. On that note, I want to thank the member for Burnaby East for her leadership and guidance, as well as the previous deputy chair, the member\n               for Penticton-Summerland, and all members of the committee for their commitment to this work. I, too, want to extend my gratitude to Dr. Jennifer Charlesworth, the Representative\n               for Children and Youth, and her team for their expertise and passion in this field.\n               On top of the reports they have provided, they presented to the committee a wealth\n               of information allowing committee members to have meaningful discussions about ways\n               to improve services and supports to children and youth in British Columbia. Lastly, I'd like to recognize the staff in the Parliamentary Committees Office and\n               Hansard Services for their support.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752279","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to rise for a few moments to talk about this report and the work of the committee. I had the privilege of joining this committee last fall. I very much value its important\n               role in raising awareness of challenges across the child-and-youth-serving system.\n               The presentations that we have received have been insightful, and I appreciate the\n               ability ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3d7a404894f7e6dc8c6a5ddf37f1807fdecf6633ab22e40b4bebe967d7770db9","4f9d3f5cc94d88b56e1a5ed819fcd985951745f5f5d6fbbe9f0105bbc0a95b09"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2215ad479d98a6fd392ce65","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752280,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"It feels like we were just here, doesn't it? I'm very pleased to introduce Aaron Gairdner to the Legislative Assembly today. Aaron\n               is a fourth-generation British Columbian who was born in Prince George, studied B.C.\n               politics at the University of Victoria and received a master's in political science\n               from U of T. Aaron began his career working for the admiral commanding Maritime Forces Pacific\n               in Esquimalt. Always involved in politics, Aaron also served as the chief of staff\n               to federal Conservative ministers of national defence, foreign affairs and agriculture\n               during the Harper government. Aaron is also the volunteer fundraising chair for the\n               Caroline Elliott leadership campaign. Please help me make them feel very welcome this morning.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752280","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It feels like we were just here, doesn't it? I'm very pleased to introduce Aaron Gairdner to the Legislative Assembly today. Aaron\n               is a fourth-generation British Columbian who was born in Prince George, studied B.C.\n               politics at the University of Victoria and received a master's in political science\n               from U of T. Aaron began his career working for the adm","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Marine installations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035583","label":"Marine installations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0bfb8901bf3746ce9eb6557139e505ac91f24c22e3e42a2df165b8a230235fae"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ebcf90de175a9d79e31ed83b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017398,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to welcome my constituent, Tyler Zeeman, to the House today. He's a good\n               friend and a colleague as well. I am going to be honest. I know my colleague for Kelowna-Mission is going to introduce him, and I am, just in the spirit of rivalry, rising a little\n               faster. I am going to leave the formal introduction to him. Thank you, and welcome\n               to Tyler.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017398","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to welcome my constituent, Tyler Zeeman, to the House today. He's a good\n               friend and a colleague as well. I am going to be honest. I know my colleague for Kelowna-Mission is going to introduce him, and I am, just in the spirit of rivalry, rising a little\n               faster. I am going to leave the formal introduction to him. Thank you, and welcome\n               to Ty","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2f058462b5ab6d768efd875","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017405,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today it's a pleasure to welcome Livvy McMahon and Brandon Castor to the House. I\n               met Livvy about a month ago at a conference in Kelowna, Inspired City Summit, and\n               we had a great connection. It turned out she lived nearby here and had never been. We're happy to welcome her and her colleague. They work with M3 Development, specializing\n               in affordable and supportive housing development projects in British Columbia. I know\n               she is looking forward to her tour today. Would the House please join me in welcoming her and Brandon to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017405","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today it's a pleasure to welcome Livvy McMahon and Brandon Castor to the House. I\n               met Livvy about a month ago at a conference in Kelowna, Inspired City Summit, and\n               we had a great connection. It turned out she lived nearby here and had never been. We're happy to welcome her and her colleague. They work with M3 Development, specializing\n               in affordable and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0ef9796b21cc7c703cfb3655cab9a51c61dd372c2120afd0a0b215a97e9269f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03de64780197a86d79dd337a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036510,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Two minutes — oh. I rise today to speak to the amendment to this motion. I want to briefly recognize\n               the member who brought it forward, the MLA for Kootenay-Monashee, for doing something that every MLA in this House should be doing, listening carefully\n               to the people they represent and bringing those real-world concerns into this chamber.\n               This is the heart of representative government and something that is the foundation\n               of what we should be doing in this place. I do appreciate the amendment, removing the word \"independent\" from the motion. Conservatives\n               believe government policy should be fair and consistent for all businesses, not designed\n               to favour one category of business over another. Governments should not be in the\n               business of picking winners and losers. If a policy makes sense, it should apply fairly.\n               If a regulation no longer makes sense, governments should be willing to review it\n               openly and honestly. If businesses are being treated differently without a compelling\n               public reason, we should ask why. That principle matters. Too often in B.C., businesses feel like they're navigating a maze of inconsistent\n               rules, exemptions and special carve-outs that seem arbitrary and difficult to justify.\n               Small businesses feel it, communities feel it, and the public feels it. Do we really\n               want to create a scenario where the public have to ask themselves which rules apply,\n               based on whether a theatre is independent or not? What theatres are really asking for is not special treatment. They're asking for fairness.\n               This motion opens the door to a broader conversation about whether our liquor policies\n               are modern, consistent and rooted in common sense, and the amendment applies new legislation\n               equally and across the board. I want you all to know that all three of my daughters worked their first job at a\n               local theatre just five minutes from our home. To each of them, it was a place where\n               they all received real work experience, learned customer service, had co-workers for\n               the first time, and began to see what it meant to live in and serve community. At the end of the day, people want fairness, they want consistency, they want to be\n               heard, and they want a government willing to listen. By removing the word \"independent\"\n               from this motion, we can apply the same fairness to all.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036510","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Two minutes — oh. I rise today to speak to the amendment to this motion. I want to briefly recognize\n               the member who brought it forward, the MLA for Kootenay-Monashee, for doing something that every MLA in this House should be doing, listening carefully\n               to the people they represent and bringing those real-world concerns into this chamber.\n               This is the hea","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9b480837db47ded5e41a2bcccb56f3ca2b84e4a7a4afd547446fa3ec65f838e9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13bffa77f14bbdf305ea25ae7b965306bf2c38333dbaadb56406909151a76d69"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37d744335f706c250b4bb4ab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036512,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, I'm really glad that my daughter is here because with all these family members,\n               if she wasn't, I think I'd be feeling a little bit lonely. So would the House please help me to welcome my daughter, Brielle Loewen. Brielle is an incredible girl. She's beautiful, she's funny as heck, she's smart,\n               and she keeps me going. She's my biggest cheerleader and encourager, and she's actually an inspiration to me. For those of you who followed\n               our story a little bit, she's been through a lot of struggles. But she is doing so\n               well, and I couldn't be more proud of her. Please join me in welcoming her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036512","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, I'm really glad that my daughter is here because with all these family members,\n               if she wasn't, I think I'd be feeling a little bit lonely. So would the House please help me to welcome my daughter, Brielle Loewen. Brielle is an incredible girl. She's beautiful, she's funny as heck, she's smart,\n               and she keeps me going. She's my biggest cheerleader and encourager, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d6afb27280ed29de895cac8e63da974e034dfd4c368cdd3c41145eafbec6c72"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7b24529d7979117abecad478","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036513,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, there are so many people visiting the Legislative Assembly today. First of all, welcome to our mayor from Kelowna, Mayor Tom Dyas. My daughter is also joining us again today. She's just lighting up my entire day here,\n               so happy to see her smiling face back there. Last, I have some incredibly important family members here representing victims of\n               intimate partner violence. I'd like to welcome to the chamber today, Steph Hartwig and Lauren Zolpis, both friends\n               of Laura Gover, who was killed here in Victoria by.... I don't know if I can say \"allegedly.\"\n               We just want to honour her life and death today and honour the presence of her friends.\n               I'm just so grateful, the advocates that they are turning into. Also, in that, Debbie Henderson, Bailey McCourt's aunt, is here today. I am so honoured\n               to be here with her and to help to amplify Bailey's voice. Bailey had a strong voice\n               in life and even stronger in death, perhaps. I know Debbie's travelled all the way\n               to Ottawa and has been an incredible advocate. I just want to do my best today as a legislator to amplify that and to bring attention\n               to their visit. Would the House please join me in welcoming all of those wonderful humans here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036513","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, there are so many people visiting the Legislative Assembly today. First of all, welcome to our mayor from Kelowna, Mayor Tom Dyas. My daughter is also joining us again today. She's just lighting up my entire day here,\n               so happy to see her smiling face back there. Last, I have some incredibly important family members here representing victims of\n               intimate partner v","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","label":"Gender-based violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","label":"Gender-based violence","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["69047c75a7740c9a68cf90fd9ce7d41c5e60f17aedc01b9094c2ce7b148d11ca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5694575b616085d1e61cd1456a2bced1ab6708757c23667be6ae992a6633139e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender-based violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43626","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2cec7abf9afed1067b0f0624","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036515,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Kristina Loewen","venue":"Hansard","text":"My constituent Walter delivers day-old bread to seniors in an apartment in the heart\n               of Glenmore, Kelowna. Last week an older lady told Walter: \"We don't eat until we\n               see you.\" Days later, another senior woman called Walter from the hospital because\n               she couldn't afford her prescription. Our seniors have worked hard for everything\n               that they have. This minister's mandate was to reduce poverty by 60 percent, and quite frankly, that\n               is not happening. This minister loves to talk about how she is reducing poverty with\n               free birth control and affordable child care, but quite frankly, that is useless to\n               seniors. To the Minister of Social Development and Poverty Reduction: will you admit today that your ministry is failing seniors?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036515","member_id":"bc-mla-412","member_name":"Kristina Loewen","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My constituent Walter delivers day-old bread to seniors in an apartment in the heart\n               of Glenmore, Kelowna. Last week an older lady told Walter: \"We don't eat until we\n               see you.\" Days later, another senior woman called Walter from the hospital because\n               she couldn't afford her prescription. Our seniors have worked hard for everything\n               that the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["700203a998c9d3a451b3493564d9aed4d386dd36f3c14c30d09bfaa62ab9e5ee"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.22,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e6b99b12aa9cfcfe338bab794e32717b79ca198c520556bf0d246827565a091"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f01ed0b40d345a8c86595de2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317164,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I see that we are joined by a grade 10 social studies class from Vic High. The students\n               are here with their teacher, Mr. Dunstan. I understand that Mr. Dunstan encourages\n               political engagement and welcomes debate and conversation in the class, like yourself,\n               Mr. Speaker, though I suspect he has better behaved students. I want to single out a particular student, Arden, who is an actor and musician, but\n               really want to thank her for a moment of kindness I saw with my children in the difficult\n               moments outside the Legislature at the vigil recognizing the loss in Tumbler Ridge.\n               We all came together, but I just want to share that also some young people came together\n               in that moment as well. I look forward to connecting further with this class. I always think it's important for you to be here to watch this and for us to share\n               with you, so thank you for joining us. I hope the House will help me make them welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317164","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I see that we are joined by a grade 10 social studies class from Vic High. The students\n               are here with their teacher, Mr. Dunstan. I understand that Mr. Dunstan encourages\n               political engagement and welcomes debate and conversation in the class, like yourself,\n               Mr. Speaker, though I suspect he has better behaved students. I want to single out a particular s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social structure","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083662","label":"Social structure","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1cd74714253bff22a1cf1e165566aa0375d7eba74ec9ca48af34f242a2e2f3c4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62fce6c1f177a4e85f313adbf62e4b23c60e7db36e45e27353ed3d4580d99796"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3f1562121afba4c667c4943","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360400,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I wanted to take the opportunity to share with folks that it is Colorectal Cancer\n               Awareness Month in March. I want to thank colleagues from all sides of the aisle for\n               wearing a pin today. It is the second-deadliest cancer in the province, it is routinely one of the leading\n               causes of death, and it's extremely treatable caught early. Screening for folks in\n               traditional ages, 50 to 75, is still low, at 60 to 70 percent. Colorectal cancer is\n               increasingly common among younger folks under 50, 40 and even 30. Not always the cutest\n               symptoms or cancer to talk about, yet we must. I wanted to take the opportunity to thank everybody again for wearing a pin and hope\n               that folks in this House will join me in talking to their friends and family about\n               it, making sure folks know the signs and symptoms and that you are getting screened. Thank you very much, colleagues and Mr. Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360400","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I wanted to take the opportunity to share with folks that it is Colorectal Cancer\n               Awareness Month in March. I want to thank colleagues from all sides of the aisle for\n               wearing a pin today. It is the second-deadliest cancer in the province, it is routinely one of the leading\n               causes of death, and it's extremely treatable caught early. Screening for folks i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Young adults","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037696","label":"Young adults","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","label":"Cancer","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5015f29bec6e8a5cb590d35cfce0194da74e2acd06361632514d8cf231aebb83"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43ec6e63cc26ea52d38bd993894397482fec2c63b422e2116465f1c27a5376bb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cancer","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43658","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8db04190a9d58ef3094cb0af","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360401,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the chance to speak to this briefly. I rise to speak against the amendment,\n               and I have significant concerns. My first concern is what happens to some of the most vulnerable people at this or\n               any point in time. Trans people, queer people, people who are discriminated against\n               based on their gender identity or expression are facing unprecedented attack. They\n               would not have protection in the absence of this explicit recognition. Members opposite should know that. They must know that at this point in time. They\n               should know that the rights, safety, opportunity for expression, employment, sport\n               and joy are at stake and need to be explicitly listed as a protection. There are many others that require explicit recognition, and those needs change over\n               time. I mentioned it today, but I've seen some of the worst attacks I've seen in politics\n               before today against a friend in this House. It should be a reminder of the importance\n               of explicit recognition. Second, not only was the explicit list removed, but you'll notice that the amendment\n               removes the tribunal's power to enforce. Their amendment either contains a significant\n               error or reflects an intention to end the tribunal and its enforcement, to end the\n               tool that keeps people safe and accountable. Finally, if the members are concerned about what is missing.... I hear criminal conviction,\n               political belief, source of income, and I share a belief in the rights of people to\n               be free from discrimination on these bases. I believe that people should be able to\n               access employment and support and housing regardless, for example, of their source\n               of income. I ask members why the amendment did not add the pieces missing instead\n               of removing all. The member referenced also antisemitism. The Jewish community, including my community\n               where the synagogue has faced graffiti, where threats and attacks have been real....\n               Religion is in that direct list. If members think that that's not sufficient, that\n               it needs to be explicit, then I would encourage a motion to add, not take away, religion\n               as an explicit protection. I hear the concerns on the basis of source of income — low-income seniors, those on\n               assistance. I agree. Those protections are important. As a believer in the rights\n               of sex workers, I also believe that discrimination on the basis of conviction or source\n               of income is important. Again, I ask why the motion did not add. We've been asked not to pick and choose among the protected rights. To me, the solution\n               of that is not to remove all. It is to add the ones that you are concerned about. Again, I just draw a note to also, once again, the removal of the tribunal and its\n               powers to enforce. This amendment could have expanded the list, could have addressed\n               the concerns of the people that members opposite are worried about. It could have\n               supported the enforcement and the power to use tools. It did not. That is why I do\n               not support this amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360401","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I appreciate the chance to speak to this briefly. I rise to speak against the amendment,\n               and I have significant concerns. My first concern is what happens to some of the most vulnerable people at this or\n               any point in time. Trans people, queer people, people who are discriminated against\n               based on their gender identity or expression are facing unprecedent","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","label":"Gender discrimination","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b90bcc8ab607143119eb57e47edfb1d8f7880a26cfccc960965d43cc3219cd88"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["259de43a59cecc3a10d2bed4d7e48133728ff9eeb62b873325a0a366fa334b07"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035448","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05dde60a69250d8ca6ade8d4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415761,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have several introductions to make today, so I thank you in advance for patience.\n               First, I am really thrilled to welcome Vancouver Island senior ladies, who are a group\n               of women up and down the island, aimed at making connections, new friends, and being\n               engaged in community. I love the idea. I loved even more the chance to talk to some\n               of them today in the Hall of Honour. I learnt a few things. I've got a few ideas and\n               really appreciate the chance to connect. I'd like to give a warm welcome to Ruth,\n               Sandy, Cindy, Caroline, Rhonda, Linda, Diane and Wendy. Second, I'd like to welcome Dr. Catherine Lowe. Dr. Lowe is a recent immigrant to\n               Victoria and comes to us from London via South Africa and Switzerland. She's a respected\n               academic engaged in feminist-led research using arts and theatre to support doctors\n               in their training. She's at the faculty of medicine at King's College. Her work is\n               creative and transformative. There are many things that could have brought us together.\n               Reading her bio to you, there's many opportunities for overlap. But what brought us\n               together was being the mom of boys who love tackle football. And here we are. And last but certainly not least, my mom is here today. My love of politics and community\n               comes in part from following my mom around when she worked as a producer at Global\n               Calgary. I have early memories of election night and party convention coverage. My\n               mom is joined by her lifelong friend and auntie to me, Janie Dale. I'm grateful to\n               have her here filling my bucket as well. Will the House please help me make all of\n               these incredible women welcome today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415761","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have several introductions to make today, so I thank you in advance for patience.\n               First, I am really thrilled to welcome Vancouver Island senior ladies, who are a group\n               of women up and down the island, aimed at making connections, new friends, and being\n               engaged in community. I love the idea. I loved even more the chance to talk to some\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97f338a9d800139dd8d344bf513ced701312198b64ce19cc1c34f3bf5345922a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["605d4460d34f8d09dfa06fd5cf20e8b0f7dc68a2456987f44a37c94571d6f671"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a6fd1ded37c9cb574bdba736","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415762,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm just seeking your guidance on relevance, given that this\n               is geographically bound in a very clear area around places of worship.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415762","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'm just seeking your guidance on relevance, given that this\n               is geographically bound in a very clear area around places of worship.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036926","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036926","label":"Religious architecture","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67dffc437a569ec2c1bbcf47e3837b26d211e3e522faad52859578c94666bec7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7366428a2c06b66e72eb32da","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415763,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a few introductions, for the second time this week, so thank you for your patience. First, I am beyond thrilled to welcome some of the incredible team from the Victoria\n               Foundation who are joining us today, celebrating the foundation's 90th anniversary.\n               You will have a chance to hear more about the foundation from my colleague from Juan de Fuca–Malahat, but let me say that this organization is the second oldest in Canada. It started\n               with $20 during the Great Depression and it has changed and transformed lives and\n               communities and connected people across generations to causes that the community cares\n               about. Will the House please help me welcome Rob Gareau, who is the foundation's board chair.\n               He's been with the foundation for 13 years. I had a chance to hear about what keeps\n               him over lunch. Sandra Richardson, the CEO of 25 years, a quarter of a century of lifting Victoria\n               up. He's already been introduced by the Minister for Jobs, but Ian Bird is the Victoria\n               Foundation's incoming CEO. What a vote of confidence from my colleague. I'm grateful\n               to have you joining us. We have 90th anniversary committee volunteer co-chairs, Bruce Williams and Lori Elder. We have Jonathan Dyck, Victoria Foundation senior director of marketing, communications\n               and facilities and Brin Morgan, who is senior director of governance and executive\n               operations. I'm grateful to have them here and for all their work. Will the House please help me make them very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415763","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a few introductions, for the second time this week, so thank you for your patience. First, I am beyond thrilled to welcome some of the incredible team from the Victoria\n               Foundation who are joining us today, celebrating the foundation's 90th anniversary.\n               You will have a chance to hear more about the foundation from my colleague from Juan de Fuca–Malahat, but let ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Citizenship","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501124","label":"Citizenship","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0019b537b5e6e92c81d2a951e65eb7b4d0b5caafee852bf946d81beeb577c260"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2b096a0e120772c17e37841c7aba21f30fddd1318fc785ef04c2af95478f11d8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5135985962e02625b17d8b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415764,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's been a good week for introductions for me. I'm pleased to welcome Angus Matthews,\n               who's here today with the Maritime Museum Society. He's an advocate and volunteer\n               working really hard with a vision and drive for our local waterfront. He'll be joined later today by Alicia Thomas from the Esquimalt Nation. We're going\n               to have a few meetings around community. I am really grateful for his work and vision in the community and for my ministerial\n               colleagues who are going to join us for some meetings today. So will the House please help me make Angus very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415764","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's been a good week for introductions for me. I'm pleased to welcome Angus Matthews,\n               who's here today with the Maritime Museum Society. He's an advocate and volunteer\n               working really hard with a vision and drive for our local waterfront. He'll be joined later today by Alicia Thomas from the Esquimalt Nation. We're going\n               to have a few meetings around co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e3565e6ddbca9abfa4674d9c72c9c890c12346a043a1474e94c605ec9aa5bb8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01cc740dffd45876ef77ca88b915a05e337dd3247f0322daaa972df543815509"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-954216948acb806f6e1cebb6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415765,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Grace Lore","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm grateful to be here today and to have a chance to speak to this legislation. I'm\n               also grateful to the Minister of Housing for bringing the work here forward. A lot\n               was done to thread a needle to balance really difficult questions, and this legislation,\n               in my opinion, does this. As the MLA for Victoria–Beacon Hill, I represent a lot of communities with supportive housing in them, and I represent\n               a lot of people who need and have benefited from supportive housing. That includes\n               the provision of meals, available supports, life skills training and other care and\n               services that sometimes people need. There is a lot of this supportive housing in\n               the community I represent. And unlike some, I think this is a good thing; I don't\n               think it's a bad thing. I think my community benefits from this supportive housing.\n               It means that people in my community are in this housing instead of, for example,\n               sleeping rough or in encampments. That's good. One thing has been clear. Supportive housing is housing. It is people's homes. It\n               is meant to offer to people that sense of home, that sense of stability, and the services\n               and supports that our community members often need. Supportive housing, however, for\n               all the same reasons that it's essential, especially for those who need additional\n               supports that they can access in market or low-income housing, for those facing substance use, mental\n               health, or concurrent disorders, for those who have experienced brain injury or addiction,\n               or any number of other reasons that people need supportive housing.... Supportive housing can have its own challenges. This is what these changes are about.\n               It's about giving practical, usable tools, tools that reflect the reality in supportive\n               housing, while still protecting the rights of tenants and keeping supportive housing\n               under the RTA. It's not about choosing between safety and rights. It's about doing\n               both and doing both well. Frankly, that's what providers need. It's what communities\n               need. It's also what tenants themselves deserve. They deserve protection of their\n               rights as tenants, and they deserve the safety and security in their own buildings. So let me walk through what some of these changes actually do. I do this because some\n               of these changes reflect conversations I've had with community providers who are looking\n               for new tools, who are looking to do something other than eviction. First, and very importantly, this legislation provides a clearer, stronger tool to\n               deal with weapons. Of course, supportive housing has always had rules around weapons.\n               The ban is not new. Until now, though, providers have often had to prove not just\n               that a weapon was present but that it was used or intended to be used to cause harm.\n               That can create delays and uncertainty and risk. This legislation, these amendments, fix that change. Now, the presence of a weapon,\n               whether it's a firearm or a replica, whether it's Tasers or other dangerous items....\n               The existence of them themselves can be sufficient Now, the presence of a weapon, whether it's a firearm or a replica, whether it's a\n               taser or other dangerous item.... The existence of them themselves can be sufficient\n               grounds to end a tenancy. That's a practical shift. It means providers can act earlier. It means less time spent\n               building complex evidence when providers know and the neighbours of someone with a\n               weapon in their supportive housing know that the whole building community would be\n               better served. Now, this concrete change, this practical, usable change, is one of many. I'm going\n               to share a few others. But I also want to ground us in something really important.\n               The vast majority of people living in supportive housing are doing exactly what all\n               of us want. They're working towards stability, healing and building a sense of home.\n               They're our neighbours, community members, people trying to build or move their lives\n               forward. When I talk about the challenges, say, of weapons in supportive housing, I do so to\n               talk about the tools that are available and what supports might need to be there to\n               help someone do just that — to rebuild their lives. But in doing so, it's important that we don't suggest that people in supportive housing\n               are inherently dangerous or not worthy of safety and security. We need to be able\n               to ensure that folks have safety in their own units to pursue that life improvement,\n               to find that stability. This is the balance that this legislation is seeking to find. In those cases where something difficult happens, where there's a real and immediate\n               risk to other tenants, to staff, to the broader community.... When those moments happen,\n               we know that in the past, providers have not always had — and they tell us they have\n               not had — the tools that they need to respond quickly and safely. So this is about\n               those practical, usable tools. I need to say that, for myself, in my community with significant amounts of affordable\n               and supportive housing, there have been real tragedies. There has been violence. There\n               has been loss. But there has also been hope. There has also been recovery. There has\n               also been connection. We add these practical tools so that there can be more of the\n               latter and less of the former. These changes also provide a continuum of response, not just eviction. This is a direct\n               ask I've had from my community. These are conversations I've had with housing providers,\n               particularly those who've dedicated their lives to creating housing, to ensuring everything\n               is done possible for those folks that we might call \"hard to home, hard to house.\" I hate that language. People need services and supports. They are not inherently hard\n               to house. Folks have had experiences, violence, brain injury. There are folks in our community who dedicate their lives to wrapping around these\n               neighbours, to making sure everything is done possible, that they can be housed and\n               stay housed. Part of this, part of their ask, is a continuum of options and not just\n               eviction. Before these changes in the status quo, it can be difficult to manage a dangerous\n               situation with limited tools, or it can force moving straight to eviction. Neither\n               of these options work well in complex human environments with complex neighbours and\n               tenants, like supportive housing. Housing providers in our community that I know are not in the business of housing\n               to evict people, though of course it is a necessary tool. It's an important tool.\n               But I think of one housing provider in particular who told me about the nature of\n               the work, the work to support people with harm reduction, with care, with recovery. They need the tools and opportunities to keep folks connected in their housing. They\n               need the tools and opportunities so they can share and provide those tools and opportunities\n               with their neighbours. That is what these changes offer. Amendments will create, essentially, a cooling-off period. Not every situation should\n               result Amendments will create, essentially, a cooling-off period. Not every situation should\n               result in someone losing their housing. Sometimes what is needed is time, space, de-escalation. This tool allows providers, again, to respond immediately to safety risks because\n               we must stabilize a situation and, where possible, preserve tenancy. People who are\n               living, say, with addiction or concurrent addiction and mental health who have had\n               brain injuries don't disappear when they are evicted. They remain in our communities,\n               and they do so with less support, less security, less stability. This is not about forcing staff and tenants to remain in an unsafe situation either\n               while trying to keep someone housed or while a complex process unfolds to move towards\n               eviction. It's about something different altogether: alternative tools. There are also faster, clearer pathways for urgent action because sometimes these\n               situations do require speed and clarity. Providers have told us when serious incidents\n               occur — violence, fire setting, repeated threats — the system can be too slow to respond.\n               These changes support faster access to the residential tenancy branch in these high-risk\n               cases. Instead of prolonged uncertainty, there is a clearer path forward: immediate\n               safety measures followed by a fair and expediated process. That's the balance: quick action and due process. Both are essential. And they are\n               essential to staff doing the work and to tenants — both the tenant involved and their\n               neighbours. Again, I want to ground all of my comments here in two realities. Most folks, I would\n               say all folks, in supportive housing are trying to rebuild or build lives, to move\n               forward, to get the security, hope and connection and services that all people deserve.\n               And yet these are complex environments. These are situations in which we need to be\n               able to react to someone quickly. The second thing I want to ground my remarks in, once again, is the reality of some\n               instances in supportive housing. Again, in my community, that has been violence in\n               cases, that has been the loss of people. Providers need these tools, and their neighbours\n               deserve quick action as well. Several tools to manage guests. Sometimes the risk doesn't come from a tenant. It\n               comes from someone brought into the building. The amendments provide stronger abilities\n               to enforce guest policies, limit access when needed and respond to non-residents when\n               they are creating unsafe conditions. I know some of the situations here in Victoria\n               that have raised significant concern were the result of guests, not tenants. Residents\n               don't want to live in buildings that aren't secure themselves. They don't want to\n               live in places that aren't safe from the guests of their other tenants. These tools\n               are necessary. We're also talking about protection for workers and others. These changes strengthen\n               these broader protections. Because while tenants need a safe place to live and people\n               deserve housing, staff also have a right to work in safety, to go to work and know\n               their safety is an equal consideration. So now providers will have clearer authority\n               to act when anyone on site, not just a tenant, is put at risk. Finally, these changes bring clarity — more clarity, greater clarity — between supportive\n               and transitional housing. That may sound technical, but it has real-world impacts.\n               Transitional housing is meant to be that: transitional, temporary. It's not meant\n               to be a forever home. So clarifying the difference provides understanding of what\n               rules apply, when and where; ensures tenants can understand their rights; and ensures\n               that response is quick and appropriate to the type of housing involved. Let's also be clear what this bill is not doing. These changes are not about making\n               it easier to evict people. In fact, creating additional tools is about the exact opposite. When we have tools to de-escalate and preserve housing, we're talking about less eviction, not more. When eviction\n               is necessary though, it should have both quick results and due process. Also, supportive housing remains, of course, under the Residential Tenancy Act, so\n               tenants keep their rights. Due process remains in place, but it is about more tools Also, supportive housing remains, of course, under the Residential Tenancy Act, so\n               tenants keep their rights. Due process remains in place. But it is about more tools\n               for cooling off or accountability. It is about being able to act fast, especially\n               when tenants or staff are unsafe. This bill, these amendments are part of a broader commitment. This bill is about improving\n               a system, one that we have been investing in. In my community alone — I've mentioned\n               my community a number of times specifically — 742 units of supportive housing since\n               2017. That's huge. There are 304 more supportive housing units under construction.\n               These are folks who are not camping in Beacon Hill Park, who are not among the folks\n               who are still making Pandora or other locations their home. Those housing units are the right kinds of homes, with supports. They're meant to\n               support people in such a way as.... Additional efforts have been made to ensure they're\n               person-specific. So we have youth-specific supportive housing. I can see it from my\n               downtown office, my community office, and I love it. I love when I see it across the\n               street. That is supportive housing for youth who may otherwise be unhoused and extremely\n               vulnerable. The vast majority of them have had experience with MCFD. It's about doing\n               what's right. We also have recovery-oriented housing that opened just this week and culturally grounded,\n               Indigenous-led supportive housing. I connect regularly with service providers and recently met with neighbours, police\n               and providers all at once. This is about collective work, community work. At the end of the day, it's not just about policy. It is about the place we call home.\n               It's about our neighbours, and it's about getting it right by those neighbours, by\n               housing providers, by the broader community. I'll close with this. Supportive housing works. It is a gift to have it in my community.\n               I welcome all 742 units. I look forward to the remaining 300. It helps people stabilize,\n               improves health outcomes. A provider in my community always tells me that they took photos of folks when they\n               first moved in, and six months later they had to take them again. People were unrecognizable.\n               They did not look the same. They had their photos taken for ID so staff could get\n               to know them. They were unrecognizable. It works. It builds stronger community. But for it to work, it has to work for everyone. It has to be safe. It has to be safe\n               for the people who live there, for the people who work there, for the surrounding\n               communities. So these changes are about making that possible, improving the system\n               with practical tools, balanced policy and through a continued commitment to doing\n               this work thoughtfully, responsibly and together. I am thrilled to support this bill and appreciate the opportunity to speak to it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415765","member_id":"bc-mla-47","member_name":"Grace Lore","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm grateful to be here today and to have a chance to speak to this legislation. I'm\n               also grateful to the Minister of Housing for bringing the work here forward. A lot\n               was done to thread a needle to balance really difficult questions, and this legislation,\n               in my opinion, does this. As the MLA for Victoria–Beacon Hill, I represent a lot of communities wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6b0c58ca859a8c3ae19c9fb43d80f7b3612fefc48e7fe95470e49c45ade0cd1d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2e0b8cf43cda4964c3497705c25e91ea491430e030b311e926e0f9ef5d33d88e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6a00a08374e742fd5628917a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317167,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We're proud of the investments that we have made in major capital infrastructure projects\n               in the health care sector across the province. We have implemented and built and have\n               underway the most number of hospital projects ever conceived in B.C. history. That being said, there are projects that need more work done, and Burnaby Hospital\n               project is actually one of them. The project came in significantly over budget. We\n               are wanting to work with the Fraser Health Authority to get those costs down so that\n               we can continue to deliver the important infrastructure projects that British Columbians\n               need, in a sustainable way.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317167","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"We're proud of the investments that we have made in major capital infrastructure projects\n               in the health care sector across the province. We have implemented and built and have\n               underway the most number of hospital projects ever conceived in B.C. history. That being said, there are projects that need more work done, and Burnaby Hospital\n               project is actuall","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Student labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Student labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036797","label":"Public architecture","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037241","label":"Student labour","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7cebc063cece2b75902d0556725d9f4935055380be4ee5066f1507c1b600b40f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a7219431817f553b0f1357d44a4751289481baa19191236c556c40803434a523"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c1e0a763bdeee61f05228d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317168,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the member opposite for bringing the human reality to the circumstances\n               on the ground. The member is absolutely correct that we need many more long-term-care beds. Over\n               the last many years, our province has engaged in the largest investment program into\n               health care capital in B.C. history. We have so far completed 16 long-term-care projects,\n               opening over 1,600 long-term-care beds, and we have an additional six long-term-care\n               beds underway, despite fiscal challenges here in this province. But we also know that it is not enough, and that is why the work that we are doing\n               right now, to take a pause and re-evaluate how we deliver long-term-care beds, is\n               so incredibly important. When we have projects coming in at an estimated cost of $1.8 million a bed or more,\n               we know that we will not be able to deliver at the scale that is required to actually\n               serve communities. We need to be able to deliver at scale, and that is why the work\n               that we're doing right now to re-evaluate how we deliver those beds is so important.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317168","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I want to thank the member opposite for bringing the human reality to the circumstances\n               on the ground. The member is absolutely correct that we need many more long-term-care beds. Over\n               the last many years, our province has engaged in the largest investment program into\n               health care capital in B.C. history. We have so far completed 16 long-term-care proje","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c02010a8637d6f713da917f17718506236e7ea224df99537685b014c8ba5633f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5cb6098038583753d0340a148b4d231c9690f40f932493235981ef33116c5996"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3929639b0abe922361c3ba35","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328001,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've heard countless times from members of both sides of the House how important\n               it is that we deliver expanded access to long-term-care beds. Long-term-care beds in British Columbia are so critical to people who need them and\n               the families that care for them as well. This is why the work that we are doing to\n               put a pause on our long-term-care program is so incredibly important, because we are\n               starting to see those escalating costs in construction move beyond what is reasonable\n               for British Columbians to be able to pay in order to deliver at the scale that we\n               require. We are starting to see, or we have been seeing, long-term-care beds come in at estimates\n               of more than $1.8 million per bed. It is not sustainable, and that's why we're doing\n               this work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328001","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We've heard countless times from members of both sides of the House how important\n               it is that we deliver expanded access to long-term-care beds. Long-term-care beds in British Columbia are so critical to people who need them and\n               the families that care for them as well. This is why the work that we are doing to\n               put a pause on our long-term-care program is","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035670","label":"Heritage buildings","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["844665454cc59099d952f94b0beeb622ca5318b7b2bd5c2bcf5a195ae1ba1a4d","b3efc908a65c296ebd32e6da9f739c21e4948c49ddb6612b1e10c01b64d20e57","298e90dadd2e49587e1169b4f3c4fc5f777b356078cbe3d6d5f127046204fe3c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bec89e53c43cb95c8dc69e824de5f11377344cf66693c26a1c522d968d432f1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-43b266a170eb9344ee142e8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328002,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Ministry of Infrastructure is not involved in the delivery of transportation infrastructure, including rail.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328002","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The Ministry of Infrastructure is not involved in the delivery of transportation infrastructure, including rail.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1302961d6b11f6bd0679e53805ae37667eee34247c2be3e094de3cbe58f796e1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d38c125a86ed6ebdcda470d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328003,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Surrey has been a fast-growing community for many, many years. It is one of the fastest-growing\n               cities in our province, and we are making the investments that are necessary to meet\n               their needs. I am so pleased that the member across the way was able to take a site visit to the\n               new project, new hospital being built in Surrey-Cloverdale. This new hospital and cancer centre is under construction now. It means a second\n               emergency room and B.C. cancer centre for Surrey. A new kidney and cardiac cath lab\n               at Surrey Memorial has also been delivered. We're expanding maternity and NICU capacity at Surrey Memorial and strengthening care\n               at Surrey Memorial, including boosting physician coverage, expanding internal medicine\n               capacity and emergency department support and more. There is so much work already\n               underway in Surrey, and there is more to come. We are in the midst of a development of an additional acute care tower at Surrey Memorial\n               Hospital, and we look forward to providing more information when that's complete.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328003","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Surrey has been a fast-growing community for many, many years. It is one of the fastest-growing\n               cities in our province, and we are making the investments that are necessary to meet\n               their needs. I am so pleased that the member across the way was able to take a site visit to the\n               new project, new hospital being built in Surrey-Cloverdale. This new hospital","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b28a2261f0f58551a691b4d8d97fc4955a7f21b224a3212e1fa43e15b03688c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6955e8c1fade1b7f12ae884deb3b68351a5a0ec1cad4c801fed7e52db9a64ab1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-039e12058c318bb1b3910694","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360405,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We are joined in the gallery today by Bronwyn Phillips, who is a project manager with\n               the Ministry of Infrastructure who is celebrating 25 years of service with the public\n               service. She is here today with her husband, Jim Phillips. I ask the House to please join me in thanking her for her wonderful service to British\n               Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360405","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We are joined in the gallery today by Bronwyn Phillips, who is a project manager with\n               the Ministry of Infrastructure who is celebrating 25 years of service with the public\n               service. She is here today with her husband, Jim Phillips. I ask the House to please join me in thanking her for her wonderful service to British\n               Columbians.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["343f719358499c11fe8d7e4b9ea5ccef0d15ddb65a1edce16b22b9ea000bbce1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4c5c5a1b4f13619dbaea84f6ca6927f63c28f6aeb5feedbce961474670726c1b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3991f78ccf7099fc7049baaa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360406,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I get to wish my grandmother a happy birthday today. In my nine years in the House,\n               this is the first time I've actually managed to get it right on her date. It's not\n               just forgetfulness, though. I will explain. My grandmother was born, on the lunar calendar, on January 24, 1930, which is the\n               equivalent of February 22, 1930, in the western calendar. She prefers to count her\n               age by the lunar calendar, so this year her birthday falls on March 12, 2026, and\n               she will be turning a solid age of 96 years old, or a nominal traditional Chinese\n               age of 97 years old. Would the House please join me in wishing my grandmother a happy birthday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360406","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I get to wish my grandmother a happy birthday today. In my nine years in the House,\n               this is the first time I've actually managed to get it right on her date. It's not\n               just forgetfulness, though. I will explain. My grandmother was born, on the lunar calendar, on January 24, 1930, which is the\n               equivalent of February 22, 1930, in the western calendar. She ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94aefff997fe9f69f182cd8d8264f4d8e9d71f4b84f02a5ab45c35ea43b83112"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6bdcec11f11f49cd18f00b32","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415768,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Hon. Speaker. I want to thank the member from across the way for recognizing\n               the amazing people here from VRCA. In keeping with your instructions to not be repetitive\n               on all of the names, I just want to call out Chris Atchison and thank him on behalf\n               of the B.C. government for all of his work that he is putting towards the development\n               of our regulations around prompt payment legislation and his leadership around that. Welcome to all the young construction leaders here in the B.C. Legislature. I'm happy\n               to join my colleague in welcoming them to the precinct.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415768","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Hon. Speaker. I want to thank the member from across the way for recognizing\n               the amazing people here from VRCA. In keeping with your instructions to not be repetitive\n               on all of the names, I just want to call out Chris Atchison and thank him on behalf\n               of the B.C. government for all of his work that he is putting towards the development\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cd6b1076521dbd8225b5e7c2c83d969bb1f66d996c3e154b564b0429b0501d0a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fac163ec4064c3929e01b20f26c4b52b72c43717bd8a090a5bdca06544e52de4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab77d41f440086bce80a5237","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720437,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the member opposite for his question, for standing up for his community\n               and advocating for the seniors in his community. I absolutely agree, and our government also agrees, that seniors need support, and\n               communities right across the province require more long-term-care beds. That is exactly\n               why the work that we're doing right now is so incredibly important, because when we\n               have projects coming back with cost estimates of upwards of $1.8 million per bed,\n               we know that we can't deliver at the scale that communities really need. We're looking forward to the work that is already underway with health authorities,\n               within my ministry and in partnership with the Ministry of Health, to get those costs down, to find ways so that we can actually deliver the number\n               of beds that communities require.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720437","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank the member opposite for his question, for standing up for his community\n               and advocating for the seniors in his community. I absolutely agree, and our government also agrees, that seniors need support, and\n               communities right across the province require more long-term-care beds. That is exactly\n               why the work that we're doing right now is so i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1249a49a6191064ed7c285a772b73a32a655359bbc09b913a31b990d3c1d602","3b1853e18c249ba8e056fd1f7a344eba87c4ff2ea9a3c5835618010eba6e3960","fe894d54a282a84f5839f1e9d8b54c9e50821dc3e7f5f4183295ede5f24b357d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fee79cb49c9cba459412002ba3f0d35de9fd0e49a863074f17740d3bc432246"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c942bfb06f4467d480fcdfb7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720441,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the member for raising an important issue in his community. We have\n               heard stories like this, in communities right across the province, when we formed\n               government in 2017.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720441","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to thank the member for raising an important issue in his community. We have\n               heard stories like this, in communities right across the province, when we formed\n               government in 2017.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98741212d4dc03554f7c80ef28a347243fbd420f69a46ca5981a3d72eb338752","fed435d91a08ff2e028aa466022f3dd38f2b4adefe3da98d5d68d7e6c56a3414"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-435b6d056bcfc8078f58410e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721527,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We're joined in the gallery today by Miles Bissky, visiting all the way from Hope,\n               British Columbia. He enjoyed it so much the last few times that he visited us to watch\n               question period that he has decided to make it an annual appearance. I'm not entirely\n               sure why, but I noticed that this year he is not joined by his family, so I guess\n               there's some disagreement in that family about whether this is a good place to spend\n               their time. Would the House please join me in making Miles, at least, feel very, very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721527","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We're joined in the gallery today by Miles Bissky, visiting all the way from Hope,\n               British Columbia. He enjoyed it so much the last few times that he visited us to watch\n               question period that he has decided to make it an annual appearance. I'm not entirely\n               sure why, but I noticed that this year he is not joined by his family, so I guess\n               th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aef2159818d97424b9c59288b83d343aeb39db77f8f174dff74fb95aa8a01d25"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-261b94d3b965276816ef4870","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729210,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Hon. Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729210","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Hon. Speaker.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1fbffab75747aba2b1686f9358e9df6be839647b2539505cae59803df089f19c","c486b0e28054892e430a5dd5c2ae3f92720000189670fff83ed276001a7df2a3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c08eac7afd8204e13792b619","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752282,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We have been transparent and forthright from the beginning, since we released Budget\n               2026, that the Burnaby Hospital project has had to have its timeline reassessed because\n               of cost overruns. However, we recognize how important However, we recognize how important phase 2 of the Burnaby Hospital project is to\n               the community and the region as a whole. It will continue on, recognizing that there\n               were some contracts that were cancelled because of the changes in timeline, making\n               them currently not required. There is still work happening with Fraser Health Authority\n               to get that project ready to go, and we're committed to delivering it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752282","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We have been transparent and forthright from the beginning, since we released Budget\n               2026, that the Burnaby Hospital project has had to have its timeline reassessed because\n               of cost overruns. However, we recognize how important However, we recognize how important phase 2 of the Burnaby Hospital project is to\n               the community and the region as a whole. It wi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db5eed060e3922aaf860556f8aab8b3bac80fa9ae4f60446a5ec43d69504aa77","9c26338ffa882eec9080425bee7ba461843a72a31fb2f58c1526c8a8c9ad883a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["85625adb3961a297dc62f511998b7146256aba8ccb9176b15d08d1468c8058b5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9365e52f53203e508cda586d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752283,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I was in that meeting with the associate deputy minister and the hospital foundation,\n               and that is not the correct characterization of what the associate deputy minister\n               said. What we said is the latest fully-funded, properly cost-counted plan that we received\n               was over budget. There was an additional plan that was presented that had not been\n               fully costed but had the intention of bringing the total project cost down to below\n               $1.8 million. However, upon review by the independent peer review board, it was also determined\n               that that plan was not going to be successful in doing what it was hoping to achieve. I apologize. I'm taking a bit of time. My lungs are compressed, and I'm sick. What we had from Fraser Health in regards to Burnaby Hospital, phase 2, was either\n               a project budget that was well over budget or an alternative plan that included scope\n               reductions that we did not believe would successfully meet the service needs of the\n               community. That's why we're going to be working with Fraser Health to come up with\n               a renewed plan that can do both.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752283","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I was in that meeting with the associate deputy minister and the hospital foundation,\n               and that is not the correct characterization of what the associate deputy minister\n               said. What we said is the latest fully-funded, properly cost-counted plan that we received\n               was over budget. There was an additional plan that was presented that had not been\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["226e64de0851690f8102c95ffc2dbb2c3c94a1e33e5ed679f856b6a012200824"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1b1263745e87a5993e9333f2881fc87816cc9506e22bb1d136c3dbcddd070d3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-14fc8c59902d5efc57cb0554","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017408,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"What happened at Carihi High is truly tragic. We have seen so many situations, so many examples of where\n               fire has ravaged our valued school system across the province. On November 21, 2024,\n               as the member said, a structural fire led to the closure of two wings of Carihi High. I can assure the member that the project to restore the school is supported in Budget\n               2026, and my ministry has been working with the school district on a business plan\n               for this project. I spoke with the school district chair, Craig Gillis, a couple of\n               times in the last few weeks. I was very grateful to him for giving me an update on\n               the progress of this work. I agree that this kind of work, often when it comes to\n               structural fires, can be very frustrating and complex for school districts. I've committed to him that my ministry will expedite this. We expect to be able to\n               provide an update before the summer.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017408","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What happened at Carihi High is truly tragic. We have seen so many situations, so many examples of where\n               fire has ravaged our valued school system across the province. On November 21, 2024,\n               as the member said, a structural fire led to the closure of two wings of Carihi High. I can assure the member that the project to restore the school is supported in Budget\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["52220e05e69f413a8b80aa03d193b7959d879e9e8135940a1a0f72d24d6a6a0d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0540a0346ca89c11b666e9b7264a02f6916ba0336c7fc631d9f34b772a40e07"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-53fdbe7d9ff65c51e87f775c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036517,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've canvassed this question and this topic many times","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036517","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We've canvassed this question and this topic many times","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f037b7f295964fa41c94c5eedceea0e80063c11a7cdd4eb5ca65497a9f17cd0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b59799c50d0308277c064a77","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036518,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bowinn Ma","venue":"Hansard","text":"What happened last night was, as the member correctly described in her introductory\n               remarks, devastating. It was devastating to the families that had to be evacuated from their homes because\n               of their proximity to this massive fire. It is devastating to the families who were\n               looking forward to this project being completed on time, in 2028, so that their loved\n               ones could occupy some of the spaces that it would provide. It is devastating to the\n               project teams that worked so hard to get that project to where it was. I am incredibly grateful to the emergency responders. I understand that the Ministry of Emergency Management and Climate Readiness has activated emergency support services for those members of the community who were\n               displaced. We are in contact with the service delivery provider. It's being built by a private\n               sector partner, Kaigo Senior Living, and they have already activated their insurance\n               policy for this event. I understand that the member and members of the community will be very eager to understand\n               what the impact of this fire will be on the completion date of the project. It's still\n               too early to tell, but we'll make sure that we provide updates to the member as soon\n               as they're available.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036518","member_id":"bc-mla-48","member_name":"Bowinn Ma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"What happened last night was, as the member correctly described in her introductory\n               remarks, devastating. It was devastating to the families that had to be evacuated from their homes because\n               of their proximity to this massive fire. It is devastating to the families who were\n               looking forward to this project being completed on time, in 2028, so that their ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","label":"Evacuations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87c7f648d82c98ac46d828a305212a5143b9a31526a238373374604931b97652","d2627aa6071009d99a3af3c1681fe44414824bce1e69f31ec62e43897ce04c16"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4f179f0eaac29d2d272758add4acefe54e044ae83a1849f452d5c398d17fa5c3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Evacuations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035181","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-40c25f0e7d1e5502c0c4c57f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317169,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions. First, I invite the House to extend congratulations to the 81 workers at Social Development\n               and Poverty Reduction and Community Living B.C. Last night at Government House, they were honoured for long service, 81 individuals\n               collectively having contributed 2,470 years of work dedicated to serving the most\n               vulnerable people in the province. Will the House please extend their thanks to them. Also, extend a welcome to Brent Frain and Sonia Grendel, in the gallery, self-advocates\n               whose advice is continuing to help build a better system of care and income assistance\n               program. Will the House please extend congratulations and thanks to all those people.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317169","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I have two introductions. First, I invite the House to extend congratulations to the 81 workers at Social Development\n               and Poverty Reduction and Community Living B.C. Last night at Government House, they were honoured for long service, 81 individuals\n               collectively having contributed 2,470 years of work dedicated to serving the most\n               vulnerable people in th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe0ec3d40e5521fdbd13b2fdd110c24500580f9e751959768ce7a196afc7e6a0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf37e98b947b44907819b1246d0785dd47bf710bb77e12f7756e3573be0c0ff0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d44e90bb84816ba19a2c66fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328005,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"In case there are students that were listening to my colleague's speech across the\n               way, just a big thanks for all the ways that we've been able to work together to build\n               back the post-secondary system. Our government eliminated interest on student loans,\n               the Christy Clark–Gordon Campbell government having put it in place. We restored grants,\n               not loans, for students, again something that had been cancelled by the previous government.\n               So 71,000 students have benefited from our government returning grants so that people\n               can access education. I'm so proud that the free tuition waiver, first introduced at Vancouver Island University,\n               the tuition waiver for youth in British Columbia who had formerly been in foster care\n               — 2,300 people have benefited from that. Then also, the old government having cancelled\n               free adult basic education, our government brought it back in — 108,000 people. I appreciate my colleague across the way, some of his support for the legislation\n               that's before us today, but I just want to make sure we're clear about investing in\n               post-secondary education. We're debating legislation on increasing the standards and protecting the quality\n               of experience for international students studying in British Columbia. We want international\n               students to be here. We know how they benefit and participate and become part of our\n               communities in many cases. I've certainly seen that in Nanaimo. We want to make sure\n               that they have a positive, high-quality experience when they are studying here. As many other speakers today have noted, there has been.... Because of a real failure\n               of federal regulation, we've had some bad actors, a minority of service providers.\n               There's no question. But some bad actors have really misled students and have really\n               damaged British Columbia's reputation. I am encouraged that, starting in fall 2020, the new frameworks to protect the integrity\n               of the international student experience in British Columbia have been underway, and\n               the legislation that is before us today is the next step, following many other steps. This proposed Post Secondary International Education (Designated Institutions) Act is intended to establish that clear legal framework in British Columbia for our existing\n               educational quality assurance program. It sits right now in policy, those existing\n               standards, and Bill 7 is designed to set those standards that will make sure private\n               and public institutions meet standards in order that they can receive designation\n               and be eligible to host international students with study permits. The framework of the proposed legislation: first, to prohibit an institution from\n               recruiting, enrolling or delivering programs to international students who need a\n               study permit unless the institution has a valid designation certificate; second, to\n               set clear legal criteria that institutions must meet in order to become designated,\n               giving them greater transparency and certainty; and then third, to strengthen oversight\n               and enforcement by creating a new legal authority for inspections and enforcement\n               actions with a fair and transparent appeals process. This is following through on our government's commitment to raise educational quality\n               and integrity standards and to strengthen protections for international students. I certainly know this in Nanaimo. In the year '23-24, there were 1,600 international\n               students from 85 different countries. Our graduation ceremonies are amazing, to hear the variety of voices and variety of\n               languages being spoken, people that would travel from so far and choose our community\n               in Nanaimo to be their home for a couple of years. The student population is, I believe, closer to 1,000 now. Last year 11 percent of\n               the student body at Vancouver Island University were international students, and they\n               become a major part of our community Last year 11 percent of the student body at Vancouver Island University were international\n               students, and they've become a major part of our community. They contribute to campus\n               life, they contribute to local businesses and, certainly, the cultural vibrancy of\n               the region. Other institutions that are designated learning institutions in my community. The\n               Academy of Learning College. It has operations in Kamloops, Kelowna, Nanaimo and Victoria.\n               Discovery Community College, which is right next door to my constituency office and\n               a partner on a lot of training programs across the continuum health care to community\n               outreach workers to licensed practical nurses. There's so much that they do on our\n               community's behalf. Granville College, Sprott Shaw College and, again, Vancouver Island\n               University. These are the designated learning institutions in Nanaimo to which this\n               bill will apply. The new framework will ensure that any private institutions operating in our community\n               must meet the same rigorous standards, preventing any low-quality operators from undermining\n               our region's reputation or taking advantage of students. In these institutions in\n               my community of Nanaimo, I really see it as protecting their standing as a trusted\n               destination for global learners and supporting long-term enrolment stability. We know, because of the studies that have been done, the economic and workforce impacts\n               for our region contribute in the area of millions annually, and we recognize students\n               that do stay in Nanaimo after their training have helped fill really critical labour\n               gaps, really strengthening the local talent pipeline. And beyond the local benefits,\n               absolutely seeing the need to protect our province's reputation as a world-class place\n               to study, to work and to build a future. So this work is vital, and I'm really glad to see the existing framework being locked\n               into legislation for enforceability and transparency. I was really pleased to be able to get feedback on the bill from the Vancouver Island\n               University Students Union. I think that this summary.... I'll put this in quotation\n               marks, but it really does encapsulate the intention of our government and certainly\n               the hope and promise of Bill 7. So from James Bowen, who is executive director of\n               the Vancouver Island University Students Union: I did hear from Vancouver Island University Students Union two areas of concern. One,\n               that costs associated with enhanced compliance don't have negative impact on students,\n               and I certainly hear that. I've talked specifically with the minister about this.\n               It's understood that there will be a fee structure in place, but it will be fair and\n               it will be applied only to the administration, making sure that Bill 7 gets the outcome\n               that we intend. Secondly, just to make sure — again, this is a concern raised by the student union\n               — that for students, the implementation process is well understood, clearly communicated,\n               supported with resources to help students understand what changes mean for them. Again, I am in agreement. Very much the intention of Bill 7 and the legislation and\n               regulations that will follow is to have a transparent process, an accessible process,\n               to have students know that what is promised to them will be delivered on to really\n               remove the risk of bad actors in the sector taking advantage of people that are away\n               from their ordinary supports in community. I will finish by saying at the time I will finish by saying that it's a time of our real recognition of the talent pool\n               that we need to be able to train up in our post-secondary institutions, the people\n               that we need to serve and grow the province in a way that builds economy and that\n               generates revenue for the services that we are determined to provide. Supporting British\n               Columbia's reputation as a welcoming, safe and high-quality destination for global\n               learners is a very important part of that mix. With Bill 7, we're strengthening that\n               oversight, we're protecting students, safeguarding British Columbia's reputation as\n               a world-class place to study, work, and build a future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328005","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In case there are students that were listening to my colleague's speech across the\n               way, just a big thanks for all the ways that we've been able to work together to build\n               back the post-secondary system. Our government eliminated interest on student loans,\n               the Christy Clark–Gordon Campbell government having put it in place. We restored grants,\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36395e5edfad55912770e48d5a28ca21936081f039b27c4090d33b08cc6d2cb5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86ab29738daae6565d46d52a057c56492c7bc5018afeb66042f37d197a9bfd71"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8125fca6157e248fcd87a0bc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328006,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Everyone deserves to live a life of dignity with the services and supports that they\n               need not just to survive but to thrive. Addressing poverty and inequality is the right\n               thing to do for people, for families and for communities. We're stronger when we take\n               care of each other. We're working to build a province where everyone feels safe, welcomed and included\n               in their communities, where people can find and get the help that they need. We brought\n               in a lot of change for people, but there is more to do. Violence and related trauma can lead people to lose their homes, their jobs, their\n               support systems. This loss of resources and stability is a real factor in poverty,\n               so I'm going to speak to Bill 8 from that perspective. The Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act makes changes to the Civil Forfeiture Act to streamline\n               processes and ensure more funds are returned to community. Since its inception, the\n               civil forfeiture office has seized over $221 million from the proceeds of crime. Approximately half the funds from all forfeitures go back directly to B.C. communities\n               and community-serving organizations. The civil forfeiture grant program provides one-time\n               funding to support community safety-related initiatives throughout the The civil forfeiture grant program provides one-time funding to support community\n               safety-related initiatives throughout the province. Funding's allocated through streams\n               chosen on an annual basis that align with government priorities. These grants have been used to help support those struggling with intimate partner\n               violence and sexual exploitation. We're taking broad action to address gender-based\n               violence, including through providing stable funding to sexual assault response services. These acts of violence can cause traumatic brain injury, damaging part of the brain\n               that can organize tasks, remember important events, control emotions and impulses.\n               I'm particularly grateful to the Nanaimo Brain Injury Society for bringing in academics\n               and forums to raise the profile and understanding of the links between gender-based\n               violence and brain injury. Ending violence, supporting survivors and creating safe communities is crucial. In the 2023-24 year, over $2.3 million was provided to programs to end gender-based\n               violence. This includes programs to support victims of gender-based violence, like\n               a Warmland Women's Support Services Society's project called \"Calling Ourselves Home.\"\n               It's located in the Cowichan Valley, and it delivers Indigenous-informed, culturally\n               competent outreach programming for young, street-entrenched, equity-deserving, perinatal\n               Indigenous women, survivors of intimate partner violence, through 35 strength-based\n               weekly group workshops. Another program funded through the proceeds of crime is the Covenant House in Vancouver's\n               supporting homeless exploited youth project. It engages 70 trafficked and exploited\n               youth, aged 16 to 24, homeless or at risk of homelessness. Projects from United for Literacy in Surrey to VI Counselling Centre for Immigrants\n               and Refugees on Vancouver Island — these provide supports for mothers and children\n               living in transition homes while fleeing domestic violence. During the same period, the civil forfeiture office provided nearly half a million\n               dollars to programs designed to prevent domestic violence and intervention programming.\n               The Nicola Family Therapy's men's counselling program delivers trauma-based counselling\n               sessions for men who have used, or are at risk of using, violence in their relationships. As part of my ministry's poverty reduction strategy, we recognize that Indigenous\n               people are disproportionately impacted by poverty, due to intersecting colonialism,\n               historical and ongoing practices and impacts of colonialism. That recognition is foundational\n               to our updated poverty reduction strategy, and it will help ensure that British Columbia\n               is a place where the inherent rights of Indigenous people are recognized and Indigenous\n               peoples thrive by leading the way forward. The updated poverty reduction strategy includes actions that were identified by and\n               for Indigenous people, reflecting their priorities and unique needs related to poverty\n               reduction, including economic, social and cultural development. The civil forfeiture office has an Indigenous healing funding stream that awarded\n               $1.43 million, 2023-24 year, for 37 projects. The Indigenous healing fund provides\n               grants to support healing of Indigenous people from the impacts of intergenerational\n               trauma, crime or victimization. Projects focused on healing approaches reflective\n               of or aligned with Indigenous cultural and world views, including healing for the\n               individual, the family and the broader community; the emotional, mental, physical\n               and spiritual aspects of healing; and other culturally identified practices that contribute\n               to healing. One example is the resiliency program, a provincewide program delivered by Pacifica\n               Treatment Centre Society. It provides people from Indigenous communities who are undergoing\n               treatment for substance misuse with essential skills and coping strategies. In '24-25, they integrated resiliency practices into their Indigenous treatment services\n               through the 2024 resilience project. The project engaged 68 clients in biweekly healing\n               circles led by Elders and Indigenous alumni, emphasizing strength, connection, harmony\n               and cultural renewal. Another example in Nanaimo was funded through a grant to the Island Crisis Care Society,\n               an organization that just has such enormous capacity, reaches their arms around people\n               in so many ways. They operate several supportive housing projects for us in community\n               and a lot of employment and skills development work. This particular program is called lifeskills Indigenous women's healing centre. This particular program is called life skills Indigenous women's healing centre. It\n               offers culturally-rooted support for Indigenous women, ages 19 to 79, in Nanaimo and\n               Oceanside, people who have faced homelessness or housing insecurity. They have weekly\n               one-hour workshops led by an Indigenous facilitator or Elders, and they reconnect\n               with cultural practices, building skills to support well-being and integration to\n               the broader community. That's just a $40,000 grant, but I hear it has a real impact\n               on people's lives. Not only does the civil forfeiture office return money through grants, but it has\n               also developed the victim compensation package to provide financial assistance to\n               people who have suffered a financial loss due to unlawful activity linked to property\n               forfeited by the civil forfeiture office. To date, almost $1.7 million has been distributed\n               to support eligible victims across B.C. Now, Bill 8 introduces new measures to cut costs and protect asset value, including\n               a presumption of vehicle depreciation to allow for earlier liquidation. This means\n               greater value for forfeited items and that more money can be returned to the community\n               through grants. About half of the funds recovered from forfeitures go back into B.C.\n               communities. But there are ways to find more efficiencies so that more of the dollars\n               go directly to serving people. Currently about 85 percent of civil forfeiture cases are uncontested and result in\n               a default judgment. Even though most cases are uncontested, they still require, right\n               now, a full hearing, consuming valuable court time and legal resources. Bill 8 changes\n               that default order power to quicken uncontested cases while preserving judicial discretion.\n               This change will speed up the process so the province is able to liquidate forfeitures\n               before their value depreciates, while simultaneously reducing labour costs associated\n               with long, uncontested hearings. Bill 8 also introduces presumption of vehicle depreciation. Cars often sit in storage\n               for months or years, losing value and costing the programs hundreds of thousands of\n               dollars annually. Currently the act does not require judges to consider depreciation\n               or storage costs, so by the time a case concludes, the vehicle's value may well be\n               very low or gone. This presumption is consistent with the best practices in other jurisdictions internationally.\n               The presumption prompts courts to consider early liquidation, and this is intended\n               to reduce storage costs, preserve value and ensure proceeds can be reinvested in community\n               safety. That doesn't mean that judges lose authority to decide on sale of forfeited\n               vehicles. Presumption simply informs the court's decision so that judges retain full\n               discretion to refuse sale where fairness requires. While Bill 8 streamlines liquidation of forfeited assets, it also extends statutory\n               timelines from 30 days to 60 days. This will be helpful to the system because the\n               current 30-day window is too short for complex cases, leading to rushed filings and\n               errors sometimes. Extending timelines will align British Columbia with other provinces\n               and improve accuracy. Mistakes in the proceeding can result in longer cases or reversal\n               of the forfeiture, and our goal is to reduce errors and ensure lawful retention of\n               property. The amendments improve fairness and reduce procedural challenges, ensuring property\n               is held under lawful authority while giving people a fair chance to respond. Providing supports to victims in the community is just one aspect of civil forfeiture.\n               The civil forfeiture office is giving our province one more tool to combat crime in\n               our communities. We've gone after drug dealers and organized criminals, seizing the\n               proceeds of crime, like in Nanaimo where the Hell's Angels clubhouse was seized and\n               then demolished. The Hell's Angels clubhouse had been used to coordinate criminal\n               activities and leaves the courts to seize illegally obtained assets. That was a very\n               long court case. I'm so glad the Attorney General's office pursued it with such diligence. This action today is possible thanks to the brave undercover officers, anti-gang officers\n               and police agencies who referred their case files to the civil forfeiture office and\n               worked tirelessly to see justice done. Not only did the province seize the Nanaimo\n               Hell's Angels clubhouse but also Hell's Angels clubhouses in Vancouver and Kelowna. Our government will continue to go after gangs, guns and toxic drugs that are hurting\n               loved ones and will continue to take away their illegally acquired assets and protect\n               British Columbians. Funds gained from liquidated assets are distributed to the crime\n               prevention funding stream from the civil forfeiture office. It awarded Funds gained from liquidated assets are distributed to the crime prevention funding\n               stream from the civil forfeiture office. It awarded $1,643,000 to 44 projects dedicated\n               to crime prevention. Far too often, young people are lured into gang life with tempting images of fast\n               cars, glamorous homes and luxury goods. These initiatives focus on preventing criminal\n               activity through direct interventions for vulnerable people at risk of criminal activities\n               or behaviour. This includes a program that we're funding in Nanaimo, the youth early prevention\n               program run by the Boys and Girls Clubs of Central Vancouver Island. I visited this\n               place. They're doing child care, after-school programming across the whole range of\n               children's lives, but I love how they've identified here delivering programming on\n               crime prevention, reducing bullying and improving social connections for participant\n               ages 8 to 12. They invite into their centre at the boys and girls club positive adult\n               role models and RCMP officers. In closing, we can't know what the future will bring, but together we will build a\n               stronger future that is ready to respond to new and emerging drivers of poverty. The\n               Civil Forfeiture Amendment Act introduces practical changes to reinforce the province's\n               ability to disrupt organized crime and money laundering. With these changes, British\n               Columbia's civil forfeiture office can continue to take the profit out of unlawful\n               activity, prevent property from being used to cause harm and support victims and crime\n               prevention. For these reasons, I fully support Bill 8.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328006","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Everyone deserves to live a life of dignity with the services and supports that they\n               need not just to survive but to thrive. Addressing poverty and inequality is the right\n               thing to do for people, for families and for communities. We're stronger when we take\n               care of each other. We're working to build a province where everyone feels safe, welcomed and inc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ac2248a8ef6eec650f9aaaa0eb2504740b7745025d9259d7b69bc2904c5081ac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7f5d2206236db0daa2972853d86e0e4e05ef2ffb9ffddca40ec96c2285efb93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1051f31757b0f5ed45415c47","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328007,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've heard a lot in the House about support for Bill 6, the way that it will increase\n               efficiencies and ease of access to government services. I won't belabour the point.\n               It sounds like we've got consensus on this, which is terrific to hear. I wanted to take the opportunity, though, to get on the record some of the really\n               good work that we've been doing in partnership to actually get more young people getting\n               driver's licences and people that have particularly been alienated from this work. Through my Ministry of Social Development and Poverty Reduction, we've been funding\n               on the commercial side. For example, commercial truck driver licences, lots of programs\n               there, which have been great, especially in the North, filling in-demand jobs and\n               having really terrific outcomes. People that had faced barriers moving into a higher-paying\n               job and with the support of our WorkBC programming and being able to get them training\n               wage and helping support them with training that was really specific to the region,\n               we're able to get more people into the sector. That's not what this legislation is\n               about, but I wanted just to name it. In partner ministries, directly applicable to getting people with a licence to be\n               able to drive a car that haven't been able to do that before. Post-secondary, future-ready\n               skills has been funding driver's licence training through the Indigenous skills training\n               education program. Approximately $300,000, which is not a big expenditure, through 12 different agreements\n               supporting First Nations of MÁLEXEŁ, [an Indigenous language was spoken], all nations that are partnered together to be able to deliver training programs\n               to Indigenous people that hadn't, to that point, been able to get access to driver\n               training. I also have a really great list from Nanaimo. Hands raised to Nanaimo Youth Services\n               Association, who's doing similar I also have a really great list from Nanaimo. Hands raised to Nanaimo Youth Services\n               Association, who is doing similar kind of work but in a more urban setting. If you\n               follow @nysa, the Nanaimo Youth Services Association, on their Facebook feed, you\n               will see regular reports on young people, especially Snuneymuxw and other Indigenous youth, who have been able to access driver training and coaching. The program is called Get the L Out, which is a knowledge test prep workshop, and\n               then also learners to novice L2N driving practice program. This is a free program\n               with one-on-one driving coaching to help youth overcome barriers to obtaining their\n               full license, which can make future employment easier. Over 165 young drivers have completed the program since this started in May of 2021,\n               with a first-time road pass test rate of over 80 percent. This is a really strong\n               partnership with Snuneymuxw First Nation, who is really committed to removing barriers to clearing the path for\n               youth to be able to access employment. You'll see just regular shout-outs and congratulations. Brooke and Ben are twins who\n               got their driver's license in February. Louise got 95 percent on his ICBC knowledge\n               test. That was January 15. Justice from Snuneymuxw First Nation got a perfect road test on December 8. On and on, we'll see, one at\n               a time, these young people being celebrated and elevated. They got access to this\n               free training program. Again, an example of a partnership clearing the path for young\n               people to be able to get a driver's license that they would not have been able to\n               otherwise. Then, of course, the link to Bill 6 is when they get to the point of renewal of their\n               license, it's easier to do, removing barriers also to keeping people's credentials\n               afresh and legitimate. With that, thanks for the opportunity for me to add my voice to the chorus of support\n               for the passage of Bill 6, modernizing our system, bringing British Columbia into\n               line with the majority of other provinces around how this program is administered.\n               Thank you for the opportunity to speak.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328007","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We've heard a lot in the House about support for Bill 6, the way that it will increase\n               efficiencies and ease of access to government services. I won't belabour the point.\n               It sounds like we've got consensus on this, which is terrific to hear. I wanted to take the opportunity, though, to get on the record some of the really\n               good work that we've been doing","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","label":"Driver education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","label":"Training","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","label":"Driver education","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4c29111c9a6553a1eed2821a5d96f95c08cadd1d3c7d078584ce94efaecfcc7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51052b5c37d925267eab5c781b25affda73a381a94c8ee7f6a9e848bf345aef2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Driver education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017729","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034907","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ebcd98932b27ea9ae794f97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328008,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to give homage to Doug Creba. This tribute knits together the words of Jan\n               Pullinger , John Little and Sue Creba. Sue and Doug were a partnership. They helped build a fairer and more just community,\n               and our region will be poorer now that one of the partners is gone. Our deepest condolences\n               to Sue, their terrific kids and grandchildren. Doug was a person who made things happen. He met life, including political life, head\n               on. Doug was a constituency and ministerial advisor to both Jan Pullinger and then\n               Evelyn Gillespie, both MLAs and ministers. He organized for Bob Skelly and, with the\n               BCGEU, bargained the NDP constituency assistants' first collective agreement. Doug\n               served on the B.C. NDP's provincial council and on the Nanaimo Riding Association\n               executive, including mine. Jan Pullinger was Nanaimo's first female MLA. I'm the second. Doug worked very hard to elect us\n               both, again and again. This political work was built on a strong social justice foundation. Doug and Sue\n               volunteered in Africa for four years. In Nanaimo in the '80s, Doug worked for unemployed\n               workers, then as a support worker, then as a social housing manager. Doug lived his\n               values in every way in his life — of sharing, of inclusion, of supporting one another\n               — sometimes fighting peacefully for justice, fairness and the greater good of all. Doug single-handedly rescued our Mid Island Co-op. Or better, he gathered a team of\n               dedicated folks who together rescued the co-op and made it a thriving, profit-making\n               business. If you get a yearly profit rebate, his friends say it's because of Doug\n               Creba. Doug was in charge of backstage security at both the Musicfest in Courtenay and Islands\n               Folkfest in Duncan for many years, providing a secure and safe place for organizers,\n               performers and volunteers. This summer, Howie and I loved seeing him hold court at\n               the Providence Farm Beer Garden for the last time. His astonishing bucket list this past 12 months took Doug and Sue to Scotland, to\n               Cape Breton. They took the train across the country. Fiddle music dominated each brilliantly\n               optimistic tour. In true Doug fashion, over his last 13 days, he was serenaded daily in the Nanaimo\n               Regional Hospital by musical visitors from near and far, to the benefit of those in\n               the adjacent rooms in palliative care. I heard Doug's hospital bed was pulled into\n               the NRGH courtyard for a huge Fiddelium show. True or not — legend. Doug spent his life giving all he could to the people and the community around him.\n               He fed us, literally. He was fun, hard-working, caring and richly human. Doug died surrounded by friends and family through the evening, exactly the kind of\n               full house he would have appreciated. Huge thanks to the wonderful NRGH palliative\n               care team. They were exceptional. Doug lived and died Huge thanks to the wonderful NRGH palliative care team. They were exceptional. Doug lived and died with courage and a great deal of love for and from those closest\n               to him. May we all live life so large, be so loved and leave such impact.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328008","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to give homage to Doug Creba. This tribute knits together the words of Jan\n               Pullinger , John Little and Sue Creba. Sue and Doug were a partnership. They helped build a fairer and more just community,\n               and our region will be poorer now that one of the partners is gone. Our deepest condolences\n               to Sue, their terrific kids and grandchildren. Doug was a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501215","label":"Ethics","probability":0.32,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["270c75faa7785912112cbcbba7374a05f39d9d53558e4f72f5282156c1c9a5a7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e12fbbe3aee5ecad9ded381cd1a9b849808feac0ef26b2b4366a940cafe3ceb0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-79e58070e5caa349a97891d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360408,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"We all want adults with developmental disabilities to have the most dignified, independent,\n               supported life that they can. We all want people to have the best access to food that\n               gives them the very best","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360408","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We all want adults with developmental disabilities to have the most dignified, independent,\n               supported life that they can. We all want people to have the best access to food that\n               gives them the very best","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44169","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax refunds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44169","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax refunds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44169","label":"Tax refunds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2866250540240438af09d743c323934b53a218d23781fcdaea8123fc7c546758","4d9836f38cba89c11fe8aee202396a74e0642710800398fb3e013cd0ae459b75"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb9b7830f6366599ce22f168","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360409,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I invite the House to welcome here again anti-poverty activists and accessibility\n               advocates Brent Frain and Sonia Grendel to the house.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360409","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I invite the House to welcome here again anti-poverty activists and accessibility\n               advocates Brent Frain and Sonia Grendel to the house.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9497fda4693b01e718e2004a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720444,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the honour to table today the annual report on British Columbia's poverty reduction\n               strategy. This report describes actions taken across government and provides a comprehensive\n               list of programs and services that contributed to reducing poverty in the 2024 calendar\n               year as required by legislation. The 2024 Poverty Reduction Strategy Annual Report shows overall poverty in British Columbia is down 30 percent, and child poverty is\n               down more than one-third since the 2016 benchmark.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720444","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have the honour to table today the annual report on British Columbia's poverty reduction\n               strategy. This report describes actions taken across government and provides a comprehensive\n               list of programs and services that contributed to reducing poverty in the 2024 calendar\n               year as required by legislation. The 2024 Poverty Reduction Strategy Annual Report ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1ab3f8f01c7d925b2a5fa997eb02432ed11b2cc837a82e4671988fa064c02fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["72be9dde91176e16cdc8f0ce90b9fa87f5d1093a1f4d02146ae2cbf0b362e63e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70ce61f62e011e6090afcf8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729253,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to make a point of order. I believe this subamendment negates the original\n               amendment. If the member does not like the amendment that we proposed, they should\n               vote against it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729253","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to make a point of order. I believe this subamendment negates the original\n               amendment. If the member does not like the amendment that we proposed, they should\n               vote against it.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e434c44b13a09c5aa7616999f1c38ae34e5b1c4a42dacda32d0c1e929f131843"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2029a48506556d4c9d9c685c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729254,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member and I share a concern about the cost of groceries, the terribly increased\n               cost of everything as a result of global inflation and, now laid onto it, the impact\n               of Trump tariffs. That's why it's been so important for our government, across the continuum, to have\n               increased income assistance, to have increased affordable child care, affordable housing,\n               increased supports for seniors, free prescription birth control — everything that\n               we can do on this side of the House to help people with the cost of living. That investment\n               over the last nine years has been important, and it continues to be a priority of\n               our work. The member is certainly aware of the work that we've done as government to invest\n               in food security infrastructure, which is what the sector has asked us to do. Across the province, thanks to the very innovative work of not-for-profits and community\n               organizations using the support that we gave to open up food warehouses, refrigerator\n               trucks, all kinds of food security infrastructure that is helping people right now\n               with the cost of living, with the cost of food and community resiliency — that's work\n               that we're grateful to the not-for-profit sector to have partnered with us on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729254","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The member and I share a concern about the cost of groceries, the terribly increased\n               cost of everything as a result of global inflation and, now laid onto it, the impact\n               of Trump tariffs. That's why it's been so important for our government, across the continuum, to have\n               increased income assistance, to have increased affordable child care, affordable ho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8fb923f1ac416104406d937e9dc254956c9962cf63fa44b428a5220e362a9b2d","5fb2c1d06803ecfbd384e167a368c8f2465f65555b264e2ed967a6946e6f5d48"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9c08be2e760053043aad3fa2208a57c97d590194acb907eb22fb9572f8c52b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e08463c930f528137aa9e802","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729261,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729261","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a066c400ed9efbb472abf234c48233fced4852a19786ba6f5b5baa9f5ee7e71a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a64ed12cab7c15ac09522fb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752286,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move this House to now adjourn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752286","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move this House to now adjourn.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfe2f4d24672df03333e4e72","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752287,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to introduce to you and to the chamber my constituency adviser, Lucy Morel,\n               third-generation constituency adviser, following in the footsteps of her grandmother,\n               Sharon Olsen, and Darcy Olsen, her amazing mom. Lucy is terrific. Even without that\n               lineage, she would be terrific. I also wanted to flag, joining us also in the gallery, are Rosa and Ryan Montgomery.\n               They are here as a guest of the Agriculture Minister. Members will remember Wayne\n               Montgomery performed at B.C. Beef Day every year. He's passed away since last time\n               that we gathered, so they're here to recognize his memory. I hope that the House will make the Montgomerys very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752287","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to introduce to you and to the chamber my constituency adviser, Lucy Morel,\n               third-generation constituency adviser, following in the footsteps of her grandmother,\n               Sharon Olsen, and Darcy Olsen, her amazing mom. Lucy is terrific. Even without that\n               lineage, she would be terrific. I also wanted to flag, joining us also in the gallery, are Rosa and Ry","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["17f3e561f9bcd3eac9e820feaa52feeb1989acaf83c7a9c34d8af24bc2b2d798"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-41f8a4e328baa85e27359fe3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752288,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery today is my uncle, Paul Barber. Paul and his late wife,\n               my aunt, Kim Malcolmson, were the cool aunt and uncle when I was growing up. They\n               got married, my aunt wearing a pink pantsuit with her kid on her hip, Alex Barber,\n               who works for our government now. She was one of the first commissioners for pay equity\n               in Ontario. They supported both the NDP governments provincially in Manitoba and Ontario.\n               I am formed by Kim every day, and I love that Paul is here to visit and to keep her\n               memory alive. Welcome, Paul.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752288","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery today is my uncle, Paul Barber. Paul and his late wife,\n               my aunt, Kim Malcolmson, were the cool aunt and uncle when I was growing up. They\n               got married, my aunt wearing a pink pantsuit with her kid on her hip, Alex Barber,\n               who works for our government now. She was one of the first commissioners for pay equity\n               in On","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","label":"Pay equity"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","label":"Pay equity","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["972c150ed91cd6569135b6f9aef467f17c8e99a219bb1f08b6dad0bb66934bff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55de0af1724839a9c90e91dbb2c192772294c686ef8b914bc221507fd79e7af4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pay equity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47312","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-abf00f1f833b1269581fe208","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036519,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much to the member for giving the opportunity to talk about the work\n               that we have been able to do. Guided by our poverty reduction strategy, throughout the course of that work, income\n               assistance rates have gone up 74 percent in British Columbia. We've also increased\n               earning exemptions three times and invested considerably into designing the kind of\n               employment programs that meet people where they are so that they can lift income in\n               addition to assistance rates, so that they can be supported to do work that's meaningful\n               in their communities. We know that both of these supports and both of these investments are important. I\n               am grateful to the work of the Third Party for accelerating our implementation of\n               changing the spousal rule, something that the disability community had long called\n               for. That also included raising earning exemptions so that people can keep more of\n               their earned income in addition to having the supports of income and disability assistance. That work is vitally important. It's work that we're committed to do and will continue\n               to do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036519","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you very much to the member for giving the opportunity to talk about the work\n               that we have been able to do. Guided by our poverty reduction strategy, throughout the course of that work, income\n               assistance rates have gone up 74 percent in British Columbia. We've also increased\n               earning exemptions three times and invested considerably into designing t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c8fec29956f9d9302f31e6582a3621d405361ebedb64d24b2fe9a91eb08e2502"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b9e36d792fb9d8562b1e210646d4f900d87ec5828e153ebb619aa74ccdc1d49"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aceb2ebdb2cc0b74eb9871ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036520,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Sheila Malcolmson","venue":"Hansard","text":"Kevin Moroso is in the House. He's a neighbour on Gabriola Island. He leads my riding\n               association. He volunteers with Gabriola Pride, and he protects the workers. Would the House please make him welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036520","member_id":"bc-mla-49","member_name":"Sheila Malcolmson","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Kevin Moroso is in the House. He's a neighbour on Gabriola Island. He leads my riding\n               association. He volunteers with Gabriola Pride, and he protects the workers. Would the House please make him welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0893fe63a59877a0cbd6b632461c1d4ef54a828f31a54573fbfbf5bf4b56ae7b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c39207af894b75bef1447c136e827e48e48041f1a938ec2ff0061fb0ec10a62f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-901f653e3f8cae878e7085a2","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187083,"date":"2026-02-17T12:00:00+00:00","title":"","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov02-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov02-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187083","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c9b1b7b84c7589c2dfb106c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187084,"date":"2026-02-17T12:00:00+00:00","title":"BUDGET MEASURES IMPLEMENTATION ACT (No. 2), 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov03-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov03-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187084","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9edbd5d5b0f1a6fa03dfee63","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187085,"date":"2026-02-17T12:00:00+00:00","title":"BUDGET MEASURES IMPLEMENTATION ACT (No. 2), 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov03-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov03-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187085","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-414a80a33e12adcd60d3c456","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187086,"date":"2026-02-17T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SUPPLY ACT (No. 1), 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov04-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov04-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187086","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9aa797ad5132702e3d71e80f","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187087,"date":"2026-02-17T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SUPPLY ACT (No. 1), 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov04-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov04-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187087","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8c774560ab35ae8e2eeb9477","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187811,"date":"2026-02-17T12:00:00+00:00","title":"","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov02-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov02-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187811","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","label":"Engineering"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Engineering","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718901","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6449e49b0d3cd7767ba8fecc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316781,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Budget 2026 protects what is most important to seniors, health care services that\n               seniors depend on, investments to hire more doctors, more nurses. We're making a $35\n               million investment over three years to continue to support independent living to help\n               low- and moderate-income seniors stay in their homes. I have explained, and I'll explain to the member again, that when we have long-term-care\n               beds coming in at an estimated $1.8 billion per bed, it is incumbent upon us to look\n               at how to do this differently, cheaper and in a way that we can build more beds faster.\n               That is the work that we're doing to serve seniors.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316781","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Budget 2026 protects what is most important to seniors, health care services that\n               seniors depend on, investments to hire more doctors, more nurses. We're making a $35\n               million investment over three years to continue to support independent living to help\n               low- and moderate-income seniors stay in their homes. I have explained, and I'll explain to the member","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2620a8e9dcb7576ea593634260da3ac347d30835b43813b57713ff009201bae9","a49b10d5634d35d45934d442dde059bf7f48164f89cd6c521cafd198e37da805"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cab8e1013fec91dd772dd4ed4f045d3b252c3a39e458feb5625d83c6c713f627"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0095a1b825ff3e282476846f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316782,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"As the member opposite knows, the Merit Commissioner does not review OIC appointments,\n               and they do not review appointments on boards. The Merit Commissioner is focused on\n               hirings within the Public Service Agency. It's also important to know, and I'll point out to you, in the words of the commissioner\n               from page 32 of their most recent annual report.... When reviewing dismissals, the commissioner\n               said: \"Due process is being followed, with process steps being completed, interviews\n               being fairly conducted and employees having full and fair opportunities to respond\n               to issues.\" We are in very unprecedented....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316782","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"As the member opposite knows, the Merit Commissioner does not review OIC appointments,\n               and they do not review appointments on boards. The Merit Commissioner is focused on\n               hirings within the Public Service Agency. It's also important to know, and I'll point out to you, in the words of the commissioner\n               from page 32 of their most recent annual report.... W","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trade negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Global warming","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","label":"Financial audit","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035518","label":"Global warming","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037383","label":"Trade negotiations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f4a3c962923da3fd6aec25062733397810c7752e274a5ec6fc5fed7932323d3d","857c6a512cfc10323bc50f4fa8a595ac3e93a276277107d9830d06a400f3ac91","fee59a9c23bd7f7056a03045538fab236c9697cf8ebeb256751cc8e9eee2fc1b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6912b4cd3c8f9f9dd6ee9e7dbfc02d71a416036a8abe154fde901dcc508be9e3"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7de147b76840274d84b8cdc5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316783,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. There are two things that are primarily\n               the source of why these gift cards are used. The first one is that gift cards are sometimes used as recognition for folks working\n               in the public service. There is a guideline that the gift card be no more than $100,\n               and they're used for recognition, often for long service or for a particular thing\n               that someone in the public service has done. The second way that gift cards are sometimes used: when there has been, for example,\n               a new website and we have volunteers from the community who are testing that website,\n               the honorarium is sometimes a gift card. It is true that sometimes these gifts The second way that gift cards are sometimes used is when there has been, for example,\n               a new website and we have volunteers from the community who are testing that website,\n               the honorarium is sometimes a gift card. It is true that sometimes these gift cards might be a coffee shop that is a Starbucks\n               or a Tim Hortons owned by an American company, but of course, in small communities,\n               many people are employed at these spots, so that's important to recognize. It is true that this government is devoted to making sure we spend our taxpayer dollars\n               wisely, but I do want to say that it is very, very clear to us that our public service\n               works very hard to deliver services for British Columbians. A small recognition of\n               the hard work that they do is not something that I'm embarrassed about. It is something\n               that I'm proud of. These people do great work, and these are small recognitions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316783","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. There are two things that are primarily\n               the source of why these gift cards are used. The first one is that gift cards are sometimes used as recognition for folks working\n               in the public service. There is a guideline that the gift card be no more than $100,\n               and they're used for recognition, often for long ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Boundaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1018501","label":"Boundaries","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f78d792450b1da9434faf6962a7fe489c9b52433561f45a99e2f260bc2559e97","0457d66e497b01482dcf6afde63c8b72f355c244ea9614914f6ae56f0d27f0ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d13263db50e3a436f0ae55736409ed357602e9badbb324dd99ea4e988b459b9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7d6ffd21bdf16ade3d4fbd59","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316784,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to take a moment, if I could, to wish my mom a happy birthday — Rhonda\n               Bailey of Nanaimo, B.C. We're going to have a very B.C. birthday. She's coming over\n               to join me in Vancouver to see the Emily Carr exhibit at the Vancouver Art Gallery,\n               110 Emily Carrs on display. Can't wait for it. Happy birthday, Mom.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316784","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I just want to take a moment, if I could, to wish my mom a happy birthday — Rhonda\n               Bailey of Nanaimo, B.C. We're going to have a very B.C. birthday. She's coming over\n               to join me in Vancouver to see the Emily Carr exhibit at the Vancouver Art Gallery,\n               110 Emily Carrs on display. Can't wait for it. Happy birthday, Mom.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resources management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Minimum wage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental emergencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035113","label":"Environmental emergencies","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083664","label":"Resources management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43407","label":"National security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","label":"Minimum wage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db4df88782728c32b64f0d2e0e5dc53fc9ea11041b01359bd7d08049a29a50f5","09c60b4bcadc7cf9744ea8748525b2f42519615cd5b07e91b6e7c84f1ed1dc7b","89687c750c4c84d0e8f3cf931f6c85a8c336df63e058d8cc7bdd47a12515c8f6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bdec0995d03f050f1ed556d6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316785,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that Bill 4, the Supply Act (No. 1), 2026, be read a second time now. Existing voting appropriations will expire on March 31, 2026. Bill 4 provides interim\n               supply for ministry operations and other appropriations for approximately the first\n               three months of 2026-2027 while the House completes debate of the appropriations presented\n               in the 2026-2027 estimates. Interim supply for ministry operations and other appropriations is required to ensure\n               continuation of government services until the final supply bill comes into force.\n               Bill 4 also provides one-third of the combined voted amounts in schedule C and schedule\n               D of the 2026-2027 estimates for disbursements related to capital expenditures, loans,\n               investments and other financing requirements. The one-third authorization provided for in relation to these disbursements is higher\n               than proportion authorized in relation to ministry operations, as the disbursements\n               described in schedules C and D are not evenly distributed throughout the year. Therefore,\n               the higher level of interim supply is required to accommodate the payments that will\n               be made under these schedules. Bill 4 also authorizes the full amount of the disbursements referred to in schedule\n               E of the 2026-2027 estimates. Schedule E of the estimates outlines the revenue collected\n               on behalf of and transferred to specific programs or entities. There is no impact\n               on the operating results, borrowing or debt resulting from the collection and transfer\n               of this revenue. These interim supply appropriations are based on the accountabilities and allocations\n               outlined in the 2026-2027 estimates. The final supply bill for the 2026-2027 fiscal\n               year will incorporate these amounts to ensure that it reflects the sum of all voted\n               appropriations to be given to government in that fiscal year.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316785","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I move that Bill 4, the Supply Act (No. 1), 2026, be read a second time now. Existing voting appropriations will expire on March 31, 2026. Bill 4 provides interim\n               supply for ministry operations and other appropriations for approximately the first\n               three months of 2026-2027 while the House completes debate of the appropriations presented\n               in the 2026-2027 ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logistics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720874","label":"Logistics","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3847ff27d7ad9f47080c375436ece417d4cd1b06fcc6bb5362ae8f7272d4f519"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efa9e2c3921ac9d86e5a958e6d66168645f6974c13686ec9249bcf149a1c9035"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5eb0f549fa99214f728d568c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327902,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that Bill 2, Budget Measures Implementation Act, 2026, be read a second time\n               now. Bill 2 consists of two parts. Part 1 of the bill makes a number of amendments in relation\n               to non-tax measures. The bill amends the Budget Transparency and Accountability Act\n               in three ways. First, the bill amends the Balanced Budget and Ministerial Accountability Act to include\n               the 2028-2029 fiscal year in the period of fiscal years that may contain a deficit\n               in the main estimates. Budget 2026 includes a three-year fiscal plan extending to\n               '28-29 and it includes deficit forecasts for each of the three years of the fiscal\n               plan. This proposed amendment ensures that the fiscal plan as presented in Budget\n               2026 is in line with legislation and past practice. Second, the Budget Transparency and Accountability Act is amended to bring forward\n               the reporting requirements with respect to public accounts and related reports from\n               August 31 to July 31. This change will be in effect for the 2026-2027 public accounts\n               and supports the timely release of year-end fiscal results. The bill also amends the\n               Financial Administration Act and the Insurance Corporation Act to keep the year-end\n               reporting requirements harmonious. Third, the bill amends the Budget Transparency and Accountability Act to increase\n               the threshold requirement for reporting major capital projects from the current amount\n               of $50 million to $125 million. This update is to reflect inflation since the current\n               threshold was originally set in 2000. The bill also amends the Public Service Act to close the Office of the Merit Commissioner\n               during this coming fiscal year and transition key functions into Public Service Agency.\n               This change recognizes that the PSA has strengthened its work to create a hiring culture\n               that is transparent, accountable and upholds the principle of merit — a culture that\n               attracts and retains top-level talent. The PSA will continue to provide public annual\n               reports on hiring, promotions and dismissals in the public service. The avenue for\n               public service employees with questions or complaints about promotions or dismissals\n               is and will continue to be through the PSA. The bill also amends the Economic Stability Tariff Response Act to remove the sunset requirements for part 2 of the act related to procurement directives.\n               The intention is for the Minister of Citizens' Services to assume responsibility of\n               the act. Part 2 of Bill 2 amends several statutes to implement tax measures. As announced in\n               Budget 2026, the tax measures in Bill 2 represent careful choices to protect core\n               services that British Columbians rely on. The bill amends the Land Tax Deferment Act to change the terms of property tax deferment\n               loans so that other B.C. taxpayers are no longer subsidizing these loans. To achieve\n               this for 2026 and later years the loan terms will be more closely aligned with commercial\n               lending terms with an interest rate of prime plus 2 percent and monthly compounding. The deferment program will continue to give seniors and families flexibility to help\n               manage their expenses. It remains an affordable way to help people, particularly those\n               on fixed incomes, and we're making sure it works as intended. These changes don't\n               impact people's day-to-day finances. Homeowners can use the program to have a bit\n               of relief as they pay the province back later, like when they sell their house. The bill also amends the homeowner grant to remove the extra $200 grant to homeowners\n               outside the capital, Metro Vancouver and The bill also amends the homeowner grant to remove the extra $200 grant to homeowners\n               outside the capital, Metro Vancouver and Fraser Valley regional districts. The extra\n               amount was meant to offset increased fuel costs that were associated with the carbon\n               tax, which has now been repealed. The general homeowner grant of $570 remains available\n               across the province. In fact, 92 percent of homeowners in B.C. remain eligible for\n               this amount. The bill amends the speculation and vacancy tax to increase the tax rate in 2027 from\n               3 percent to 4 percent for foreign owners and untaxed worldwide earners. The new rate\n               will apply to the speculation and vacancy tax payable by property owners based on\n               the use of their residential properties during the 2027 calendar year and onward. Increasing the speculation and vacancy tax rate for foreign owners and untaxed worldwide\n               earners will help turn more vacant and underutilized homes into housing for people\n               rather than empty investments. With the federal government ending its national underused\n               housing tax, it's important for B.C. to continue to discourage speculation. All of\n               the revenue from the speculation and vacancy tax will continue to help pay for affordable\n               housing initiatives right here in British Columbia. The bill also amends the School Act to increase the additional school tax. For the\n               2027 and later tax years, the rate applied to the portion of the property valued between\n               $3 million and $4 million will increase from 0.2 percent to 0.3 percent. The rate\n               for the portion of the property exceeding $4 million will increase from 0.4 percent\n               to 0.6 percent. The bill also modernizes the Provincial Sales Tax Act by extending its application\n               to professional services, notably accounting and bookkeeping services, architectural\n               services, engineering and geoscience services, non-residential rental property and\n               non-residential strata management services, and commissions related to buying and\n               selling non-residential real estate and security and private investigation services. Expanding the PST to these services is generally consistent with how the tax applies\n               these services in most provinces. As an example of consistency, similar to Saskatchewan,\n               B.C.'s PST will apply to 30 percent of the purchase price of architectural engineering\n               and geosciences services instead of the full purchase price. In order to help protect core services, the bill amends the Income Tax Act to increase\n               the personal income tax rate on the first $50,363 of income. The rate will increase\n               by 0.54 percent to 5.6 percent starting in the 2026 tax year. This higher rate will\n               also apply when calculating B.C.'s basic credits, like the personal amount and the\n               age amount. To further mitigate the effects of this change for people with lower income, the bill\n               also increases the value of the B.C. tax reduction credit from $575 to $690 for the\n               2026 and later years. More than 40 percent of taxpayers will see savings as a result. For the 2027 through 2030 tax years, Bill 2 amends the Income Tax Act to freeze personal\n               income tax brackets and non-refundable tax credits at their 2026 levels. Bill 2 also\n               creates new tax programs as well as renews existing ones to support a more innovative\n               and productive B.C. Case in point, this bill creates a new temporary manufacturing and processing investment\n               tax credit to support capital investments made in B.C. over the next ten years. It\n               provides a 15 percent refundable tax credit to Canadian-controlled private corporations\n               that acquire machinery and equipment, or buildings used for manufacturing and processing,\n               up to a maximum investment of $2 million per year. The full amount of the credit is\n               available for acquisitions within the first five years of the program, April 1, 2026\n               to March 31, 2031.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327902","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that Bill 2, Budget Measures Implementation Act, 2026, be read a second time\n               now. Bill 2 consists of two parts. Part 1 of the bill makes a number of amendments in relation\n               to non-tax measures. The bill amends the Budget Transparency and Accountability Act\n               in three ways. First, the bill amends the Balanced Budget and Ministerial Accountability Act","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Disability pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034852","label":"Disability pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87069a0cc227dcda8a3c0564331c81fe4f2f959fed2eb1091a0502cf14e5d3e6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0a2822903e82f97c1a3e8f9bec99a51b7b45efe108fb8f0af7e67f68bb6e50a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f506bc85f805d3a9c032a948","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358942,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"We have taken significant measures to support British Columbians with affordability\n               in this budget and many others, and we're seeing rental prices come down 14 percent\n               across the province. These are important measures. We continue to do the work to protect low-cost child care. We're keeping auto insurance\n               low, reducing the cost of rent, zero-interest student loans, free birth control. We\n               can go on and on. These are important measures. And we know what would happen on the other side. We also know what the history is\n               of taxes, so let's just take a little look. In 2016, a family making $30,000.... Let's\n               talk about affordability. In 2016, a family making $30,000....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358942","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We have taken significant measures to support British Columbians with affordability\n               in this budget and many others, and we're seeing rental prices come down 14 percent\n               across the province. These are important measures. We continue to do the work to protect low-cost child care. We're keeping auto insurance\n               low, reducing the cost of rent, zero-interest st","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architectural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","label":"Architecture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:732108","label":"Architectural heritage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aea2ad3ca75f37b4583bc02c7abf7aaf0b6475cc8b52b97e2dd9e720e8554b61","477ed9f73d06c30367c6148c5ec2038d56898ce4abc9bdf5bd4d1b1330c7246c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6252b9ae20d678628408ccfccfef23dfcf2a131e32dab34692cfc4c8b1e32a41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f276adf890666c3cee70b881","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358943,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I wish to stand on a point of clarification. I want to correct an error that was made this morning outside of this place. I want\n               to be clear that I am not presuming that Bill 2 will become law. That is for this\n               House to decide. I want to be unequivocal in my respect for the authority of this\n               House and that any public communication has been immediately corrected.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358943","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I wish to stand on a point of clarification. I want to correct an error that was made this morning outside of this place. I want\n               to be clear that I am not presuming that Bill 2 will become law. That is for this\n               House to decide. I want to be unequivocal in my respect for the authority of this\n               House and that any public communication has been immediately c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-026aa0fa84b85a63b6ebf5b8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358944,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Since the PST was brought in, B.C.'s economy has shifted significantly towards services.\n               I'll be frank, updating the PST means that we can continue hiring doctors, hiring\n               nurses, hiring teachers and supporting the important services for British Columbians.\n               We are not out of step with other provinces. This aligns B.C. with seven other PST\n               provinces. It's important to note that in Budget 2026, we're investing in programs for small\n               businesses, like the $16 million that we're investing in the chronic property offenders\n               intervention initiative to help police fight property crimes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358944","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Since the PST was brought in, B.C.'s economy has shifted significantly towards services.\n               I'll be frank, updating the PST means that we can continue hiring doctors, hiring\n               nurses, hiring teachers and supporting the important services for British Columbians.\n               We are not out of step with other provinces. This aligns B.C. with seven other PST\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retirement","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501310","label":"Retirement","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2f1b8a4e8333baa6242c4896160a7a164b6d355368cdd32c676b59d5c03d6749","0ef63051b9d2675e46b855f801f12dc11b07ea89ff17a4b70a8d944f20f5bcc1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6694e3a912d4dc9a11754243e68dd0658071549672b84855e9f35dbbc146aa7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-70c051f42f5d25a0c3441ba3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358945,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just very quickly would like to also add some accolades to the GCPE group in the\n               House — two people in particular, Carolyn and Angela, who took a very inexperienced\n               minister, terrified of the world and trained her up a bit. We had some great times together. Thank you very much for everything you did when\n               I was the Minister of JEDI.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358945","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I just very quickly would like to also add some accolades to the GCPE group in the\n               House — two people in particular, Carolyn and Angela, who took a very inexperienced\n               minister, terrified of the world and trained her up a bit. We had some great times together. Thank you very much for everything you did when\n               I was the Minister of JEDI.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["065d8ad937330e25336c091f25cd5359e528706227d9d95e6df18a13c462df6a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f640de41bd3d3fa1184681ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413644,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Moody's has highlighted what we already know, that the economic circumstances, because\n               of this trade war, have diminished economic growth in Canada and elsewhere, and it's\n               having an impact. Provinces across this country are posting record deficits. Alberta just doubled their\n               deficit in their budget. We're seeing this across this country. What we're doing here\n               in B.C. is two things at once. We're protecting services that are most important to\n               British Columbians, and we're working to continue to bring down our deficit. We still\n               have the most favourable ratings of any province across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413644","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Moody's has highlighted what we already know, that the economic circumstances, because\n               of this trade war, have diminished economic growth in Canada and elsewhere, and it's\n               having an impact. Provinces across this country are posting record deficits. Alberta just doubled their\n               deficit in their budget. We'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6add1de831c97ee6c068aebcf630a7b77dd927e6aa656981ae8a79e02cf355e","f90f333216d60c13d4ef512742ed508ee2e87a2c102871eb81db9f571ec8610b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4272e46c1cd68dc92b44bf40e984bc64f2a84ee403d6bc22119182a686ab9ddf"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bdb0ada460f9030938d2f7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721169,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member opposite makes reference to an article by the Canadian taxpayers association\n               that looks at a long-standing policy from 2013, where executives in the public service\n               receive opportunity for a car allowance. To be clear, this is a long-standing policy, and our government....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721169","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The member opposite makes reference to an article by the Canadian taxpayers association\n               that looks at a long-standing policy from 2013, where executives in the public service\n               receive opportunity for a car allowance. To be clear, this is a long-standing policy, and our government....","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa1ee29815d85240e3f10562ad5b0c3b39f5b4182e41fcb3abc6ba3b9a6b9359","d813f37b053cb47d0a5b76b041b898f98b8022a3346a6aa740f17720d9172125"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb8c16e7336f5cea1b7f6336b0cd50b9d45a85fab65de52574a5b0a23e4f444c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-97e7fa5361c48fc8bd60dc17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721171,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to invite people today to help me welcome two extraordinary guests here on\n               the precinct, Leonard Schein and Barbara Small. Leonard Schein is one of the recipients this year of the Order of Canada, and no surprise.\n               He has contributed so much to British Columbia, not only through his amazing volunteer\n               work through the Canadian Cancer Society, the David Suzuki Foundation and much more\n               but in being a fierce advocate for independent cinema. Leonard is an extraordinary British Columbian. I'm proud to say he's been a mentor\n               of mine for many, many years. He's here with his wife, Barbara Small Leonard is an extraordinary British Columbian. I'm proud to say he's been a mentor\n               of mine for many, many years. He's here with his wife, Barbara Small, whose contribution\n               to our community and her giant heart are anything but small. Would the House please join me in making them most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721171","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to invite people today to help me welcome two extraordinary guests here on\n               the precinct, Leonard Schein and Barbara Small. Leonard Schein is one of the recipients this year of the Order of Canada, and no surprise.\n               He has contributed so much to British Columbia, not only through his amazing volunteer\n               work through the Canadian Cancer Society, the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Language training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083622","label":"Language training","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","label":"Mentoring","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8552fca8d7c2a6c4dd769f37125a286af4d75ceeb86dbfed34a7b288b0150d87"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0705e886bc961aa80a2de4d13db1e427a651c59167b2c7330238f231d7167a18"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Mentoring","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128185","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3b94378935e40bf7811dfeed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728772,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to invite the House to join me in welcoming Kelly Favro, who of course is\n               an employee in this place, in the east annex, and a happy greeting face as we go into\n               the east annex. Importantly, Kelly has been really involved in the My Voice, My Choice movement and\n               really focused on the question of how NDAs are used for sexual assault survivors and\n               has done some extraordinary work in Ottawa, is such a powerful voice on this issue. We're very lucky to have her voice. Would the House please join me in making her most\n               welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728772","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to invite the House to join me in welcoming Kelly Favro, who of course is\n               an employee in this place, in the east annex, and a happy greeting face as we go into\n               the east annex. Importantly, Kelly has been really involved in the My Voice, My Choice movement and\n               really focused on the question of how NDAs are used for sexual assault survivors and\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privatization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47355","label":"Privatization","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4a7ae371a8fd1fab8f76f543400f7c28678e9d9a644ca5f5ab847ec584136d0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4e7f4493c5408e1e444ed20e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728775,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Two introductions, if I may, today. I wanted to join my colleagues to welcome the students that are here from Vernon,\n               and especially Evalina, who was a student who wrote to me. I want to congratulate\n               the teachers for organizing this. It's so lovely to hear directly from these students\n               and to get to talk a little bit about our work. It's important that we all recognize\n               that we were grade 7 students once, and you, too, could be here participating in democracy.\n               I hope you take that as a learning and congratulations to your students. Lovely to\n               have you here. I also just wanted to add my voice to welcoming Dominic Lai into the House. Dom is\n               an incredible person in our community who does so much. Dragon Boat B.C. is more than\n               just a physical activity. It's a cultural activity. They've done so much to contribute to building community in Vancouver and far beyond.\n               It is a wonderful organization. Lovely to have you here, Dom.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728775","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Two introductions, if I may, today. I wanted to join my colleagues to welcome the students that are here from Vernon,\n               and especially Evalina, who was a student who wrote to me. I want to congratulate\n               the teachers for organizing this. It's so lovely to hear directly from these students\n               and to get to talk a little bit about our work. It's important that w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["510dbb9a89aaf566eea0e59a742273a14a25d74a0a83e9e6967984ad337b918f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f888382e033300bdd43fbe424cc08fc65db8092e7cd721f7660f89fde867b7b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe0af4f31b7ea315f5d3f3d9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752150,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today is a very important day in the geek calendar, Star Wars Day. I thought I'd just\n               take a moment to really give a shout-out to the many hundreds of people that have\n               worked on these properties here in British Columbia, from The Mandalorian to Obi-Wan Kenobi and of course Andor — hundreds of talented British Columbians giving people a world-class experience\n               in entertainment. Mr. Speaker, may the Fourth be with you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752150","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today is a very important day in the geek calendar, Star Wars Day. I thought I'd just\n               take a moment to really give a shout-out to the many hundreds of people that have\n               worked on these properties here in British Columbia, from The Mandalorian to Obi-Wan Kenobi and of course Andor — hundreds of talented British Columbians giving people a world-class experience\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9a46d5f45b1bd2ebe86a842e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752151,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I, too, have a constituency assistant who's in the House today, Kathleen Serrano,\n               who's been taking great care of the people in Vancouver–South Granville for a couple of years now. She's a true political nerd, has previously worked in\n               Ottawa as an intern. We're very lucky to be served by her. Would the House please join me in making her most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752151","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I, too, have a constituency assistant who's in the House today, Kathleen Serrano,\n               who's been taking great care of the people in Vancouver–South Granville for a couple of years now. She's a true political nerd, has previously worked in\n               Ottawa as an intern. We're very lucky to be served by her. Would the House please join me in making her most welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["60c46c99fe8d6ecf93f243a9d140f98277ae90d2e5049084e773bf3ddcf2cf61","6634163467f1be16134597162dee0759cfee9c5d9c0a141da295af10d5c8ec79"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5d952e1bcfcdbc4f63846f5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752155,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have some folks joining me online today from Web Summit Vancouver. Web Summit is\n               next week. This is the Olympics of tech, 35,000 people coming into British Columbia\n               to celebrate all that we have to offer from our tech companies, investors, media,\n               partners. It's a huge deal for our companies, and I wanted to welcome everyone to\n               British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752155","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have some folks joining me online today from Web Summit Vancouver. Web Summit is\n               next week. This is the Olympics of tech, 35,000 people coming into British Columbia\n               to celebrate all that we have to offer from our tech companies, investors, media,\n               partners. It's a huge deal for our companies, and I wanted to welcome everyone to\n               British C","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035950","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035950","label":"International markets","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47745","label":"Personal income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c215423a8bc17303f8cd08180b2b36d0a834f9e1f3b35e74f135ecf7a2cfb67c","4e7a24234e847fd999d7de2e0faab2979520ad6876f9c155bde095024e830ce2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ae4ebe49a0ae86160d4d083","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017007,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also have students in the House today visiting us from Vancouver. These are the\n               students from the Blessed Sacrament School and their teacher Reine Mykyte. These are\n               grade 5 students. This is a Roman Catholic French immersion school serving kids between\n               K to 7. Please forgive my French, but I'll make an attempt: [French was spoken.] If you'd please welcome these students.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017007","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I also have students in the House today visiting us from Vancouver. These are the\n               students from the Blessed Sacrament School and their teacher Reine Mykyte. These are\n               grade 5 students. This is a Roman Catholic French immersion school serving kids between\n               K to 7. Please forgive my French, but I'll make an attempt: [French was spoken.] If you'd please wel","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cede88627826c4ca58501cebe8da3f48ca22b7720e988179df182d379b2644fa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f1f6b9e401c56bc6220c6f07c2f8210f93a9f814fef693a48869aa32fa6e2657"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-04a75dc41a9c715f9cc02f3c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017009,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"It was a pleasure to come into the House today and look up and see that Liz Shorten\n               is here with us today. Liz Shorten is an incredible contributor to British Columbia,\n               to our domestic film production across Canada as the lead of the Canadian Media Producers\n               Association. Would the House please join me in both thanking Liz for her incredible contribution\n               and welcome her to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017009","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It was a pleasure to come into the House today and look up and see that Liz Shorten\n               is here with us today. Liz Shorten is an incredible contributor to British Columbia,\n               to our domestic film production across Canada as the lead of the Canadian Media Producers\n               Association. Would the House please join me in both thanking Liz for her incredible contribution","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-91e8bf7294073654356241f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017024,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Our PST program is one of the most narrow PST programs in Canada, and expanding the\n               PST program carefully is work that we undertook in Budget 2026. It's important to recognize how valuable small businesses are to British Columbia,\n               and we continue to support small businesses in a number of ways. We have one of the\n               lowest small business rates. In fact, it's 25 percent lower than it was when we began\n               in government and changed the rate. We've reduced the EHT payments that small businesses\n               have to make. We know that small businesses are feeling the impact of these tariffs and this challenging\n               economic time, and that's why we didn't make those changes, even though they were\n               attached to the carbon tax credit. We'll continue to work with the small business\n               community. They're so important to us.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017024","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Our PST program is one of the most narrow PST programs in Canada, and expanding the\n               PST program carefully is work that we undertook in Budget 2026. It's important to recognize how valuable small businesses are to British Columbia,\n               and we continue to support small businesses in a number of ways. We have one of the\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Business services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083644","label":"Banks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501180","label":"Business services","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6e6b01daff959c108dc8d4ea0e1fcaf5a2025261dc5bb045944a7a792ffb557d","a69eb6b37d63049ec5ac48190a4de3784813809641affb6053e5d6ef7ca5ac24","d5a0ee5b4337088727a0bd29410b7ad09991904000f863b3f2b6adce28a45aa8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2bb6bcae3396af0780e90bc420d395c47efd0bcb42ead7c3ea15f10ac3ac43eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-beec7b80c1291cf8fbd7c122","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017042,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Could I just ask the member to state the last part of the question? I heard \"Does\n               the minister feel that this three-year fiscal plan starts us on the way to balance?\"\n               but I didn't catch the next part.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017042","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Could I just ask the member to state the last part of the question? I heard \"Does\n               the minister feel that this three-year fiscal plan starts us on the way to balance?\"\n               but I didn't catch the next part.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Transport industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035484","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Geographic information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Non-repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Trucking industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035568","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Growth capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Domestic markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Accessible transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Migration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","label":"Computer services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","label":"Domestic markets","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035114","label":"Environmental hazards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035252","label":"Financial assistance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035484","label":"Geographic information systems","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035568","label":"Growth capital","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","label":"Non-repayable contributions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037423","label":"Trucking industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47284","label":"Natural disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501176","label":"Accessible transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718912","label":"Transport industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720353","label":"Migration","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724567","label":"Regions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cd89fce222f63593bf6161e7ba432844c6579c68b245dee008c14b3f2c32172a","24efe9b2c4f1af06f16c2e9137f3eae80157500318de5713b8b0809d878d24a5","b6edb4e71193053ea848d23575fffb93fd6b41fda4bb0ad49d283fd21bd2ddfb","59228b524e979a6c65f1900fd523b1b24e9c091a94fc6cedb77bdf7c9e5ec12c","3058740fc15ed8876255cfc6b0bc9177b6b46aa960c2e6ab256e96966d9334c7","475b78e96be8985bbf2be1f0313055d58564bd49387393c4a94352a3a3c00483","37597dc461be9bd3e440b95918eb5b614f426ba55881c06ac85b3ec5069544c5","4ea4acec662226431cbe31fb1d207b79d3179e8a8e214f6b658642ffefd1e354","8adad359cb899cf2613d5e5ae93a961a3a1df1721da140563d09148665ddc1cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fa240cc6b148a3f7d930f9324bf304d76f9f1fa1d4b3c7aad601279f379d4ef6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-31e2e0f2ecee8a8575cf8fee","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036378,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Recognizing that the Green Party may be asking questions beyond the vote that I called,\n               we'll go ahead and call the larger sum so that we can have a broader area for the\n               Greens to be able to ask their questions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036378","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Recognizing that the Green Party may be asking questions beyond the vote that I called,\n               we'll go ahead and call the larger sum so that we can have a broader area for the\n               Greens to be able to ask their questions.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Vaccination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tariffs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Weather forecasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crop insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037349","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Textiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Clothing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biotechnology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Private sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Wind energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103075","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Casinos","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watercourses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Marketing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083623","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Sales","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Communications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telecommunications","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037344","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Textile industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036756","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Product development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036756","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Product development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercialization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012794","label":"Renewable resources","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","label":"Broadcasting industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103075","label":"Casinos","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034728","label":"Crop insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","label":"Health care products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034942","label":"Economic crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035483","label":"Information systems","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035830","label":"Indigenous programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","label":"Personal income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036750","label":"Private pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036756","label":"Product development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036981","label":"Watercourses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037161","label":"Social media","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037344","label":"Textile industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037349","label":"Textiles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037619","label":"Weather forecasts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083623","label":"Sales","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179556","label":"Beverages","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44834","label":"Biotechnology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47535","label":"Wind energy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47589","label":"Private sector","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","label":"Marketing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49243","label":"Clothing industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501159","label":"Telecommunications","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714459","label":"Investigations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715106","label":"Tariffs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719931","label":"Vaccination","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723193","label":"Communications","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752259","label":"Commercialization","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a63a8c23e5c0d68dfef8ee5a3ae5b3687d20b45aaf8602058d2543ad30be7211","fd70a52818037a41f51dca5c8174c240a17a7fd5d82f3ad64ff944016fa0c48b","c5cc387fef2e1c30b58ffc5991f5c63b70e0d59ed7c67cf6b72f4272e671cdd3","192543902f6e6f3fdd41f7ea6782d3ba06003082623139c6220f86ffa09226ef","458b9acf000d793d5c66150698742cb484f4b39698e350f4aaa13dcae9dab0b8","b545f1b72786a5c75dde5fab16ebb79076088858a847db957469fba9b3e3f852","c23a1e9996b333af8f42c76ac131470d2a54b556330b306f4ecf7359387d4ee8","6ad168efac90eae24ad115f7b2d65030f925e14eba0d25654152c03ce792b682","255412e8a8134b79cf5d1d604489f64f3a081f1a5285a0bd24b0c3a73f2b3a5c","888cb64c9c1368b7a19b877b84b9b70da99708824a7d1f1c0b8950d999482ea7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-68236644c969b6d53fa8d0f6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036379,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"Budget 2026 takes serious action on this issue. We know that British Columbia, other\n               provinces across Canada and jurisdictions around the world are posting record deficits.\n               We are in an economic downturn. We are in a trade war. There is a war happening in\n               the Middle East. These are real issues that are impacting our economy. British Columbia benefits from a diversified economy and will remain resilient. That's\n               identified in all of the write-ups, actually, from the credit rating agencies. We have to continue to take measures to bring down our spending. That is work that\n               is contained in Budget 2026. We're reducing the size of the public service by 15,000\n               people. These are hard things to do, but necessary. We're increasing, modestly, tax\n               rates, while protecting the lowest-income earners in British Columbia. We take this\n               very seriously, and that's the work we're doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036379","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Budget 2026 takes serious action on this issue. We know that British Columbia, other\n               provinces across Canada and jurisdictions around the world are posting record deficits.\n               We are in an economic downturn. We are in a trade war. There is a war happening in\n               the Middle East. These are real issues that are impacting our economy. British Columbia benefits fr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Domestic markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse effect","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Logging industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax avoidance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752655","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034884","label":"Domestic markets","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035554","label":"Greenhouse effect","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035713","label":"Household income","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036153","label":"Logging industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41820","label":"International trade","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","label":"Greenhouse gases","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47746","label":"Tax avoidance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752655","label":"Soil pollution","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9c5e2005909f1eb0cb5bcf3c37f61a045b7f5ec79b8d2d3f0619da20e9b0e1b","01aa1349359093cfc17bb1e414b9b85fb1e31e0fcf0cc384a1d281670fc8b000","98f345c4dca45fd61619f8ba5df0920c4d8216cb8dc1540cd3f96b5af43ebb87","981e77ecea302b52ef4b4eec0624d4661224a8b9e04d6f79cd4392e4f29a326f","7de0558c2c2e3dc256d8da00061b3e83c988acac6d33554ba230bc225d59d871","72dd0265d5abb233051981782b2661ba05b19b0db89da51d7cd1bde0453e7795"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5ae56c8d398bfaf25817a4c5291fe3c3d5768e1a71450d9cad900739d80daa88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c210f2d41f266adad13b91a2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036380,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036380","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foreign students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Personal income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Minimum wage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tobacco industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inflation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Energy technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International travel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Renewable energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Non-repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Energy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035406","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruit crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012593","label":"Renewable energy","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034493","label":"Environmental technology","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034985","label":"Energy technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035406","label":"Fruit crops","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","label":"International development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035962","label":"International travel","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036158","label":"Personal income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036415","label":"Non-repayable contributions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41861","label":"Inflation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42747","label":"Foreign students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","label":"Minimum wage","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","label":"Fruits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79306","label":"Income security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:862","label":"Energy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","label":"Tobacco industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8a6b2ac1b1ec602c5728530c91e7acaa5082e40f8cae72b3f8e724b5392b0329","40ef2c5b4e33b1983bdea59dcdd7879f7ea42a78dcd39609d88f46f067eadd96","f835e6958803eed87a422b188236af2c308d84f7e7d0b4c61e4e3bbc027ee3f6","3020df8c7bd968fca96b5338ffa902e234c6856f9874e4431d741dd1b69535d1","f46fcd02701a9b545b30ff7738aa933ea782b0f55d1b8e1dd424fc6969a5171b","10f60cf78f193d804bb44cb6c8dca478c031bdc6ef9ea01d7c093001a63ec432","4ab267ed796b5831c78edf2a7dcac8456736ad894c45707263030252a44123aa","8dee5e9c01335ff94bd112b92bc607ed20996bf2309e9234bf11cd20889bc810","caa8b4f0f5a7564ab0cde580e4be27ca626a777d83056c097d18a9d2147487f1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0b0f850958bea8a74106f8fc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036382,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to indulge upon the House to allow me just to give a special shout-out to my\n               youngest child who is graduating from U of T with their master's degree next week.\n               I couldn't be more proud. Congratulations, Esme.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036382","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to indulge upon the House to allow me just to give a special shout-out to my\n               youngest child who is graduating from U of T with their master's degree next week.\n               I couldn't be more proud. Congratulations, Esme.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.58,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3179fe043b6afcdd511baf2ec8717858798e46e2459f97201a0323d23a8375e4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dd9b391648636c67034ec6cb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036385,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Brenda Bailey","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the reports of resolutions from the Committee of Supply on February 26,\n               March 3, 4, 9, 12, 30, 31, April 14, 15, 21, 27, 30, and May 4, 5, 6, 19, 26 and 28\n               be now received, taken as read and agreed to.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036385","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that the reports of resolutions from the Committee of Supply on February 26,\n               March 3, 4, 9, 12, 30, 31, April 14, 15, 21, 27, 30, and May 4, 5, 6, 19, 26 and 28\n               be now received, taken as read and agreed to.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0f63b8c3610abc4fbc4e7c4e610f391257815676a4caf036a25e3ab557435d8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["54c6db03f5f610d3bdea99bf3b3b7adbada8c313e939f3ea18b23fd155e850b2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b95ebcf2ff2a67e3969581de","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933904,"date":"2026-05-28T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SUPPLY ACT, 2026–2027","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov22-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov22-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933904","member_id":"bc-mla-5","member_name":"Brenda Bailey","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b1306b789f056050053dc89a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317176,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday we discovered that yet again, this Premier and this government is a government\n               that says one thing and does another. They say we need fiscal restraint. They say they're cutting out all unnecessary spending.\n               They say they're going to send a message to the public service and the public that\n               they're going to get things under control. Then an FOI reveals that gift cards are\n               getting purchased, not just from your local coffee shop but also from predominantly\n               American companies like Amazon, Walmart and Starbucks, while the Premier touts a buy-B.C.\n               policy. There is absolutely zero accountability for this government's finances. In fact, I\n               think people at home would have preferred to get a $500 grocery gift card from this\n               government, but that was withdrawn shortly after the election as well. Since 2022\n               — when the member for Vancouver–Point Grey, the Premier, became the Premier — the government has spent, on purchase cards, $6.3\n               million on Amazon alone. A simple question to the minister: just how much money was actually spent on these\n               gift cards by government?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317176","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Yesterday we discovered that yet again, this Premier and this government is a government\n               that says one thing and does another. They say we need fiscal restraint. They say they're cutting out all unnecessary spending.\n               They say they're going to send a message to the public service and the public that\n               they're going to get things under control. Then an FOI ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3f18def452546a55ad4f08708efc500ff43a4f19609928e27d30cb204c68714"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2c404b17167413a632ce186803b5254677eab81d29da7b6af56f831feddba066"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-493905754c8c8f54f6933721","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317177,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Given the litany of statements the minister made there, I reserve my right of privilege,\n               and I would encourage every member that was named in that diatribe to do the same\n               thing at this moment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317177","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Given the litany of statements the minister made there, I reserve my right of privilege,\n               and I would encourage every member that was named in that diatribe to do the same\n               thing at this moment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e780cc6f4f5c99eac51a074ef22150e5f3faecd73cb1bc2a1942c4d68ce95565"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f983b438069286c43655be93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317178,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak to the Supply Act (No. 1), 2026, Bill 4. I agree with much of what the minister has laid out. Normally I only pretty much say\n               that on this bill, and then we move on. Frankly, given the given the minister's diatribe to end the budget debate right before\n               lunch though, I think it's important that we don't, in the future, wind up having\n               the minister think by any means I'm trying to mislead this House when it comes to\n               budgetary bills Frankly, given the minister's diatribe to end the budget debate right before lunch,\n               though.... You know, I think it's important that we don't, in the future, wind up having the minister think\n               by any means I'm trying to mislead this House when it comes to budgetary bills or\n               the numbers within it, and I certainly wouldn't want to mischaracterize what the minister\n               just said. I know she said \"approximately one-quarter.\" I'm not trying to quote her, saying that she said \"one-quarter,\" because I believe it's important to actually have the full quote\n               if one's going to use that inside of this chamber in terms of the context of what\n               is being said within this bill. So in clause 1, when the minister says \"approximately one-quarter,\" I can understand\n               that, and I certainly would not want to ever accuse her of misleading this House by\n               using such language by shortening that quote up in this debate or in future committee\n               stage, saying, \"But you said one-quarter,\" because that's actually not what was said. And that's the importance not only of budget debate but of these documents and the\n               numbers within them. We have to make sure as an opposition that we're properly scrutinizing,\n               and although the government may not like that scrutiny from time to time on this bill\n               or other budget bills or other pieces of legislation in this place, that is indeed\n               the role and the responsibility of the opposition, whether the minister of any ministry\n               or the Premier agrees with that or not. Certainly we will embark on, and I will embark on, full and thorough scrutiny much\n               longer than I normally do on a supply bill, when we get to committee stage, to ensure\n               that there is full, transparent and 100 percent accuracy on any and all calculations\n               that got us to the \"approximately one-quarter\" — not one-quarter — of expenditures\n               in clause 1 or in clause 2, which is the one-third, approximate one-third, and then even in clause 3. So again, it is a little disappointing, I guess, that sometimes members' words get\n               shortened up to serve political interests in this place, especially when it's at the\n               close of a debate. I think I'm our only speaker, so the minister may be able to close\n               again, and Lord only knows where that goes if it's based on the response to the budget\n               close. But we will, obviously, as an opposition, support this one — and only one — budgetary\n               bill, because we do recognize this is about keeping the doors of a hospital open and\n               operating, keeping the doors to schools open and operating while we continue to actually\n               thoroughly scrutinize and lay bare what is actually in the budget, much as we did\n               with all of our budget responses, which is actually the core of how these numbers\n               in this bill have been calculated, as the minister said. It's based on the overall budget. That's why this one particular fiscal bill we will\n               actually support as an opposition, because we do believe that that should move forward. But as we scrutinize this at committee stage and figure out where exactly those numbers\n               are interrelated.... I'll give one example: when the minister incorrectly quoted the assertion that Public Safety was seeing a cut. Now, that's operations, and so that would be part of clause\n               1, which is operations and comes into this calculation. It actually does indeed have\n               a $4 million drop in its overall budget this year. That is indisputable. It's the\n               minister's own budget documents. What was actually characterized in our speeches is that we didn't know what service would pay the brunt because of that cut. Now, the minister talked about, in her budget response to close, how other internal\n               areas within public safety were actually seeing increases. That actually proves the\n               point that the opposition was trying to say. If you have an overall cut of $4 million\n               and there are operational shifts to try to account for extortion in other areas —\n               we were simply pointing out in a speech, certainly not in the scrutiny of committee\n               stage or the scrutiny of budget estimates — where exactly would the other changes\n               happen within Public Safety? Now, the minister feels that was a mischaracterization. We certainly think it was\n               just trying to lay bare the facts for the public, and the minister instead decided\n               to layer on other political rhetoric, I guess maybe because the budget has not been\n               as well received as the government may have thought it was. Somehow that is now the\n               opposition's fault, because we created the budget mess that they just delivered. Point being, we will delve into, with great detail, just how much of that $4 million\n               cut is accounted for in clause 1, during committee stage, because again, I would not want to offend the minister or any of the government ministers, thinking\n               that we were deliberately or otherwise trying to mislead the public or stakeholders\n               or user groups or senior citizens or any With that, Madam Chair, I thank you for this time. We do look forward to committee stage. It will be a much more robust and thorough\n               investigative look into the various clauses this year. Again, I want to respect the\n               comments, as egregious as they were, during the close to the budget debate from the\n               Minister of Finance, but I'll deal with that with my parliamentary privilege response\n               in future days. But really, this is about, on the Supply Act, making sure that we actually have assurances\n               from the government that things they have made cuts in have been properly accounted\n               for and reflected in the supply bill so we make sure that they actually are being\n               properly funded for that approximately one quarter of the year, or for the one third\n               of the year as it relates to other operations or other expenditures that are front-loaded\n               in a calendar year and exactly how that calculation came and the great detail that\n               we will require as opposition. I guess this is just a forewarning for the minister and her staff so that they come\n               prepared with that level of detail because, again, in the spirit of getting to the\n               truth for the public and the electorate, I think it's critically important that we\n               actually do that work. So we will this year with the supply bill. We will support\n               it, but we will make sure it has the full force and effect of the opposition fully\n               scrutinizing and challenging all the assumptions made in these calculations by the\n               minister. I thank you for the time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317178","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise to speak to the Supply Act (No. 1), 2026, Bill 4. I agree with much of what the minister has laid out. Normally I only pretty much say\n               that on this bill, and then we move on. Frankly, given the given the minister's diatribe to end the budget debate right before\n               lunch though, I think it's important that we don't, in the future, wind up having\n               the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cbe135ba559221b46cab565ee31f4129ab20acd987353e34346bba6bfce382b4","9f086e8c3d8026832043f5eb1e87fcfbc735da4c1d1b7f436eb5419ff4f2b82c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92da1a9b7b9310d4565784ff374b785eaea6b8e7b786d3a11667fb609b37457f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b492b7884daade6eb089346d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328016,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, here's the problem with this government. You have a budget document that says\n               the long-term-care homes are TBC. They no longer even want to put a date to when they\n               might be delayed till. They're just saying the never-ever plan. In that document, it actually very clearly says that they have been previously approved,\n               yet last week we had a Finance Minister that said: \"They've never been approved. They\n               weren't cancelled. They've just never been approved.\" Then we have an Infrastructure\n               Minister saying, despite the fact that they're already spending literally millions\n               of dollars on these sites, they've decided to pause that site for value proposition,\n               while they're having other sites that haven't even started still move ahead in this\n               budget. That is why there's no faith that this government actually knows how to manage a capital\n               budget, a government that is 25 percent overspending right now on capital projects\n               and 158 years delayed. That is the problem. Seniors that were looking forward to those six long-term-care facilities have a very\n               basic question they would like to have answered by this government. Why were these\n               the projects, when every other project in that budget just gets extended out by a\n               year...? It says 2027 to 2028, and then the next year you say, oh, 2028, 2029. Why were those six long-term-care facilities, a hospital project and student residences\n               deemed by this government to suddenly be TBC instead of actually just putting another\n               year of completion on them and let the projects continue on?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328016","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Well, here's the problem with this government. You have a budget document that says\n               the long-term-care homes are TBC. They no longer even want to put a date to when they\n               might be delayed till. They're just saying the never-ever plan. In that document, it actually very clearly says that they have been previously approved,\n               yet last week we had a Finance M","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf3c304c13df282f6575cbb50c176fab119200c378767df4592da016c9e311ba"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fe226932501d321eb3fdebaf55710beaadc02887437556a930bca868a4d0b66"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c1b024c7cc5035975f16903c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328017,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have three people to introduce today. One is Michelle Reith from Kamloops. She is\n               a newly retired nurse who — I found out today when I bumped into them on the grounds\n               — actually worked with my father back in the day in the hospital. But of more interest\n               is, apparently, her grandmother Mary English was the galloping grandma that went across\n               Canada in the 1960s gathering signatures in favour of the legalization of lotteries\n               to fund health care. Joining Michelle is her mother from Revelstoke, Elaine Ralph, and her brother from\n               Creston, Michael Ralph. Will the House please make them all welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328017","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have three people to introduce today. One is Michelle Reith from Kamloops. She is\n               a newly retired nurse who — I found out today when I bumped into them on the grounds\n               — actually worked with my father back in the day in the hospital. But of more interest\n               is, apparently, her grandmother Mary English was the galloping grandma that went across\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ce566ba5736f5017ebfe6360334187515922926d74c79f155fa3ea515e02f73e"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-61d3ede1271e8b115b3706c1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328018,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"This week, we've discovered that the Premier has a very interesting grasp of versions\n               of events with the xwməθkwəy̓əmdeal that keep unravelling every day on him. So let's recap. Over the last year and a half, this government has had to walk back Land Act changes\n               that were proposed because the Premier realized how controversial those were. Then\n               we had the Pender Harbour situation at the same time. We've had the Heritage Conservation\n               Act changes that have to be repealed. We've had the Cowichan ruling, which has understandably created a lot of concern for\n               the public. We've had the Gitxaala judgment that has created a lot of issues in the\n               public. We've had salmon allocation meetings with the federal government and people\n               worried about what's going to happen with the salmon allocations. Under the backdrop of all of that and all the discussion.... Oh, and the Premier is\n               insisting he's bringing forward DRIPA amendments, although no one in this House has\n               actually seen that legislation yet, as the clock is ticking. Under the backdrop of\n               all of that, the Premier expects us to believe that he went to witness a signing ceremony\n               with the federal government and the xwməθkwəy̓əm with zero briefing, zero knowledge ahead of time, zero understanding of what he was\n               walking into. A simple question to the Premier. I've been to signing ceremonies, First Nations signing\n               ceremonies. They typically take a little bit of time, an hour, an hour and a half.\n               The Premier is a busy person after all. Does the Premier routinely make a practice\n               of going to events, committing that block of time and having absolutely no idea what\n               he is walking into and about to take part in?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328018","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This week, we've discovered that the Premier has a very interesting grasp of versions\n               of events with the xwməθkwəy̓əmdeal that keep unravelling every day on him. So let's recap. Over the last year and a half, this government has had to walk back Land Act changes\n               that were proposed because the Premier realized how controversial those were. Then\n               we had th","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Harbours","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Salt water fish","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035585","label":"Harbours","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037028","label":"Salt water fish","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c71898cd0f2c4836346bfa595fb050201b7948c4a72ddc00b343e8260f351879"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db047d2c41987dc09f35a136e1ad2921d910e1d7cfea4a1022aad30b5b65bd6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78bfb36c12dccdfbd1f334d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360416,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to highlight two members from the home builders that actually happen to\n               be from Kamloops that are here. One is a legend within the home-building ranks across this country. Everyone knows\n               that if Rose Choy suggests you do something, you are to do it. And that is across\n               this country. Always a powerhouse from Kamloops on a national level. We have Rose\n               Choy here. Sitting with her today is Ryan Kurzak, who you may have recognized from the Home Hardware\n               ad fame across this country. He and his family have long owned the Home Hardware in\n               Kamloops. In fact, my son was able to get through university by working in their lumber\n               yards. So long community supporters. Will the House please make them both welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360416","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I just want to highlight two members from the home builders that actually happen to\n               be from Kamloops that are here. One is a legend within the home-building ranks across this country. Everyone knows\n               that if Rose Choy suggests you do something, you are to do it. And that is across\n               this country. Always a powerhouse from Kamloops on a national level. We ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6872729061f6e00996bca7fcf79c24663eaa7967f19535bdbc2714394a25a0ee"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c90ac7489dc5dc6224a0a9cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360417,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I take my place to speak to Bill 10, Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act. As I think we've heard from speakers on our side of the House, we're in full agreement\n               that, of course, you have to have good labour standards in this province to make sure\n               that employees are properly protected and employers have a clear set of guidelines\n               and rules to follow. It's that balance that creates a healthy workplace and those\n               protections as well, not just a healthy workplace in the physical sense in terms of\n               injury rates and physical and mental but also just the overall feel of a workplace\n               for employees. Those protections do need to be strong, absolutely. They need to be fair. They need\n               to be, most importantly, easily understood both for the employee but also for the\n               employer, especially as you get to a smaller operation of employment, because those\n               employers typically do not have professionalized human resources departments. They\n               want to do right by their employees, but they're kind of left to their own to interpret\n               and to figure out what the rules and labour standard codes are. So, the easier it is to understand, the less complicated, the less crossover there\n               is for those smaller operators of smaller businesses, the more adherence to the rules\n               we have. And that is not because they would want to be wilfully breaking the rules,\n               but sometimes it would be unintentionally by not clearly understanding what the role\n               of the employer actually is. Again, Bill 10 hopefully will provide further clarity and further guidance for employers\n               in that regard, as well as for employees. Of course, employees are always deserving of being paid everything they're owed. Of course, employees are always deserving of being paid everything they're owed and\n               being paid everything they're owed in a timely fashion. In the case of temporary foreign\n               workers, if they happen to be a bit harder to track down, employers certainly still\n               need to make sure that those funds are available for payment, as they can track the\n               person down. As we look through this bill, we have to keep that in mind, that most employers do\n               want to follow rules. Most employees want the basic tenant of their employment, which\n               is their time, their labour traded in exchange for a preset and predetermined rate\n               of pay that does not turn into a wrestling match to acquire from your boss. But again, the small business side of this equation.... Unfortunately, as we've seen\n               with the latest budget, this government does not seem to pay a lot of mind to small\n               businesses in our province, in terms of the impacts of things that they are doing. Small business sector is around.... 80 percent of the jobs in British Columbia is what\n               you would consider out of a small business. They have concerns, and we have concerns,\n               making sure that they don't struggle with the appeal deposit requirements in Bill\n               10, in terms of paying the full amount before a ruling is even rendered just so you\n               can challenge something that would come as a result of Bill 10. Again, I say that in the backdrop of.... This will require more expertise, more accounting\n               being done. Bill 10 in a small business, which.... That accounting under this government's\n               budget, will require 7 percent more cost to the small business. The small business\n               once again has concerns, as it looks at Bill 10, wondering if they were truly taken\n               into account and as I say, predominantly because they don't have a human resources\n               department. I know when I had my own small business and when I worked in the family business,\n               even though we had.... At Christmas time and catering, you could have upwards of almost\n               100 employees filtering in and out, trying to manage that.... Now, this is going back\n               a little ways, before there were as many human resource contractors out there to access\n               easily.... But those contractors come at a cost as well. But even in a business the size that we were running, as it would fluctuate, I was\n               tasked with doing payroll. You would have a computerized payroll system. You would\n               try to figure out what statutory holiday payments would be. You would have to figure\n               all of that out. You'd have to live within the rules and the guidelines of the labour\n               code to make sure people were being fairly paid, and all those rules were being followed. It's a lot of burden on a small business. It is complex. It can be cumbersome. And\n               the rules need to be clear and consistent. Again, with Bill 10, the worry is that\n               this may add to that burden as well. If it actually truly accomplishes what it's purported to accomplish, that is one thing.\n               But as we've seen all too often in this House, this government brings forward legislation\n               that says it's going to accomplish one thing and tends to accomplish the exact opposite.\n               Then this government is back here within a session or two, making amendments to their\n               legislation that we have suggested needed to be made when we're at this stage or at\n               committee stage, and they brushed it off as unnecessary worry. So mandatory mediation in this bill could create some extra administrative work for\n               small businesses, especially without HR support or needing to have contract legal\n               support come in to make sure that things are being done properly within the mediation\n               process and that the small business is being treated fairly within that process as\n               well. Good employers are good employers. That doesn't mean that they get it right all the\n               time. It doesn't mean that they willfully are trying to break rules. And so there\n               is a needing that doesn't help the employee that maybe winds up on the wrong side\n               of an employer legitimately making an honest error.  Those good employers will still\n               correct that honest error quickly. I can remember many a time I would have an employee that would get a hold of me right\n               after — and you can tell they worked previously for an employer that maybe wasn't\n               as easy to get along with because payday would come — and they'd say: \"I'm missing\n               hours.\" And you'd have to say, \"Well, just hold on. It's okay. Just let me double-check\n               the timesheet,\" and say, \"Oh yeah, there it is. No problem. I just transposed the\n               number, or your finger slipped when you And I recognize that not all employers act that way, unfortunately, so again, the\n               employees do need proper access to proper process to make sure it's done. But good employers also can still be.... Again, it cuts both ways. Not all employees\n               are trying to game the system. They're just legitimately looking for missing hours\n               or missing statutory holiday pay or things of that nature that were an honest error\n               by an employer. Those relationships are built on trust and conversation. And then\n               corrections are made, and people move forward. Some employers, as I say, may try to take advantage and hope that the employee doesn't\n               understand the rules and what they are entitled to. So we do have to safeguard against\n               that. But just as there is the occasional employer that might try to take advantage of that,\n               there is the occasional employee. They may try to trigger mediation or a dispute that\n               really is maybe even well-intentioned but not based on any actual shortcoming by the\n               employer in terms of what was owed to that employee. And the mediation process under\n               this bill, again, could turn into that administrative legal cost pressure for the\n               small employer operating under no fault of their own and ultimately being indicated\n               that they did nothing wrong and moving forward. Now, I bring all that up because the government's target of trying to resolve complaints\n               is laudable; however, they're not making those targets right now. And when you look at the budget, despite putting the tax collector's firm grip around\n               the neck of small business and drawing an extra $550 million of extra PST charges\n               in PST that they're going to pay on their security personnel that are in a store or\n               the PST they're going to pay for their bookkeeper or their accountant moving forward\n               as a small business.... It's $550 million they're going to collect off this extra PST.\n               It's not a small amount of money. Despite the government collecting all that extra money on the backs of small business\n               and seniors and hard-working families, we see that the labour program's funding has actually essentially been frozen, and it's been frozen at $22.3 million\n               for the next three years. So despite the fact that they're going to pull in an extra\n               $1.6 billion over the next three years at minimum, on this extra PST, they're freezing\n               the funding on a program that would actually help employers and employees see a more\n               timely resolution when they go to the mediation process. And why it's even more concerning is last year it was actually at $22.85 million dollars\n               — the budget. So this year they've actually cut the budget for a program that is underperforming\n               in response times. Now, why that's concerning is.... And the government seems to be thinking that Bill 10 will more than double the complaint\n               resolution in speed. But we're not sure how you're going to double the speed while\n               increasing the number of files while actually decreasing the budget, all on the backs\n               of small businesses that are paying half a billion dollars more in taxation while receiving literally less service for the money they're\n               being extra-taxed for. So at a time when the small business community has been pleading for help, pleading\n               for support — be it on crime and safety, be it on the disorder in our streets, be\n               it on a wide range of issues going on that are impacting their livelihoods and their\n               ability to operate properly — this government's response is to cut budget to a program\n               for disputes and actually put more pressure, more cost pressures on those same disputes\n               onto the feet and onto the lap of small businesses in the form of extra HR support,\n               contracted HR support, as well as legal support. Now again, if you're a good employer, you don't have as much to worry about, but it\n               doesn't mean there won't still be the odd case that comes through. In my case, we operated a hotel. My family operated a hotel, and then later my wife\n               and myself operated a hotel for decades in Kamloops. I think we were the only full-service\n               hotel that didn't wind up being unionized, because we treated our staff well, and\n               we took care of those types of issues as best we could, and everyone knew they were\n               being treated fairly and well. But that didn't mean we didn't have the odd file go to the labour board about a dismissal\n               or anything else like that, because that is the natural ebb and flow of the employer-employee\n               relationship, where despite good relationships and good working conditions and everything\n               else and trying to follow the rules, there are sometimes employees and there are sometimes\n               employers that have a difference of opinion on how things are being interpreted, how\n               payments are being made, the timeliness of it, severance. Because sometimes, yes, you do have to move on from each other. Sometimes it's just\n               not a good fit for the style of work, for the person. They wind up finding employment\n               in a different line of work, and they thrive, and they quite enjoy it. But the employer\n               needs to sometimes take those steps, for their protection or the improvement of their\n               own business, with that employee. If the employee doesn't agree with some of those\n               situations, of course, we're going to see more things come forward. In terms of the clauses, clause 2 removes the time limitation of: within one year\n               for wages owed to an employer, if a director cannot locate the employee, then the\n               wages are owed and are transferred to the administrator. Prior to this change the\n               wages could only be transferred after one year. Again there is some worry, and we'll seek better clarification at committee stage\n               around clauses like this as to what it really means in practical terms and what consultation\n               has really been taken and listened to in a meaningful way with employers. You know, clause 3 repeals and replaces clause 76 of the Employment Standards Act.\n               This change is a formatting change, but the clause itself does not materially change.\n               So that's a good thing in terms of the government deciding that they need to update\n               and modernize language, making sure it better reflects consistency with legislation\n               across the board. There was clause 6, previously section 78.1, that said a director \"must make a report.\"\n               That has now changed to \"may make a report.\" A lot of times.... I say this quite often.\n               I think back to the failed attempt by the government to bring in Land Act changes. They wouldn't bring them forward, and they wouldn't show us what they were. At first,\n               it turned out they were being drafted, and they were going to be quite extensive.\n               Then the minister said they weren't even being drafted yet. Then the minister said,\n               at the time: \"Well, there are really only a couple of paragraphs, once we drafted\n               it. It's not a substantive change.\" So the story from government kept changing on what the Land Act changes were or weren't\n               going to be. At the time, we kept insisting we were opposed but also because we didn't\n               take at face value what the government was saying the Land Act changes were going\n               to be or not, because you can't do that unless you read the legislation. It's similar to what we're hearing about Bill 1 debate or not in this place, where\n               it's kind of hard to define whether or not you agree with a piece of legislation or\n               not when you haven't actually read said legislation. In the case of the Land Act changes, the example I kept using was — and it was the\n               easiest way to explain to people — reading the legislation is critically important\n               because the use of — I would literally use this — \"may\" versus \"must\" in a piece of\n               legislation dramatically changes what that clause actually means to the government\n               and, in this case, to employers or to employees. So changing what \"the director must make a report....\" Changing that now to \"may make\n               a report\" gives a lot of latitude to a director to potentially not make a report. Now, in the backdrop of a government that is removing a Merit Commissioner, not wanting\n               to have their own employment issues, having a bit of a spotlight on them but wanting\n               the private sector to have a bit more employment oversight on them is one thing. But\n               the fact that they are now saying that the director doesn't actually have to tell\n               in a report what is going on — it's only at their discretion — again is on brand for\n               a government that is continually finding ways to be secretive. Is the public better served or employers better served by that report being a \"may\"\n               versus a \"must\"? Time will tell. Certainly, questions in committee stage will shine\n               a light on that into whether or not that is indeed something that is palatable and\n               workable and understandable why that that needs to be made. There's a lot of other more housekeeping-type changes to the clauses. A lot of it\n               is formatting, a lot of it is because if you rework the numbering in one section,\n               the next sections down the line have to get renumbered as well. So that's pretty standard\n               for this type of legislation. Again, I think at its core, and I hope what the government is hearing from opposition\n               is that, fundamentally, we do agree that workers need proper rights, proper protections,\n               proper workplace environments, proper payment, timely payment and the ability to find\n               those funds when they've left a job in a reasonable fashion. But we also have to balance that out with what the employer needs to have in terms\n               of an HR system that is not unwieldy or a labour system that's not unwieldy for in-house,\n               homegrown HR-type decisions. To not put an onerous burden on small businesses as it\n               relates to forcing them to have to go out and find independent HR advice and help\n               that they don't use on a regular basis. For them not having to go out and unnecessarily\n               have to get complicated legal help and legal advice on files that should be very reasonably\n               easy to move through a system of adjudication and mediation without over complicating\n               it with layers and layers of legalese and HR-ese, I'll call it. There is a very defined\n               skill set and complexity when it comes to HR issues. That's the underlying piece, making sure that, in the backdrop of a budget that is\n               very punitive to small businesses, Bill 10 doesn't layer on yet another layer. We\n               keep hearing from small businesses about death by a thousand cuts from this government.\n               Let's hope Bill 10 is not the 1,001 cut because that is not what anyone in the small\n               business community would expect or want. I think for the vast majority of small business operators, their employees are like\n               family to them. We're talking about a lot of operations that have five or six employees\n               at most. A lot are long term. Some are multigenerational, where their parents or grandparents\n               worked with the same store and they get hired in school as well because they're from\n               a trusted almost-family member that they hire on and continue working on. It's about making sure that those styles of businesses are not being unduly impacted\n               while still protecting that balance of the worker and the employer. Because of course,\n               we want to hold bad actors accountable and again, bad actors that cut both ways in\n               terms of that. So I thank you for the time on Bill 10. I look forward to hearing other debates on\n               Bill 10 and I do look forward to committee stage where again, unfortunately, as has\n               become the norm, we keep hearing: \"Left for future regulation, left for future regulation.\"\n               We're unclear how much extra regulation will be needed in Bill 10 or if it can be\n               fully enacted full stop. We do, as an opposition, sincerely hope on all bills.... Unfortunately with this government,\n               it has been the practice to do the reverse. That is, to not answer the questions;\n               to avoid giving a clear line of sight as to what the true intention of a piece of\n               legislation is or isn't; and how to move forward in a way that is understandable for\n               the public, for the employer, for the employee in the case of Bill 10, and make sure\n               everybody is well-protected with that employer-employee relationship balance. I thank you for the time and I look forward to other speakers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360417","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I take my place to speak to Bill 10, Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act. As I think we've heard from speakers on our side of the House, we're in full agreement\n               that, of course, you have to have good labour standards in this province to make sure\n               that employees are properly protected and employers have a clear set of guidelines\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ac6f666a07c4d8e0219d50045ac1e1048ac7d2260f8c66766394e5fcd5882d3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["21a16b7b2e5a68f2c3c83dd84b1913d2d5f40150760c9e5737ffa457d7075592"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fb6fd7842158d77e85479e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415783,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thought the minister was going to say they set a record for emergency room closures. The Minister of Children and Family Development has demonstrated a master class today of the expression, \"That was then; this is\n               now.\" In 2021, the minister and other members of that government that weren't in government\n               at the time had no problem protesting the exact same cuts to autism that we are seeing\n               this government implement now. Reggie is a child in my riding who has been receiving autism supports for the past\n               several years. Reggie's mom, Heather, describes him as a bright, humorous and inquisitive\n               child who likes history, trains, Lego and video games. Reggie was first diagnosed\n               at three years old and non-verbal. At ten, he could not read or write. Reggie is now\n               in middle school and thriving. Reggie's mom says this progress is largely due to the ongoing funding and therapy\n               Reggie has been receiving. Reggie, however, is now one of the 10,000 children whose\n               funding will be slashed to zero by this government, putting his progress at risk. Now, Reggie's mom did meet with the minister on Wednesday, and it was a circular meeting\n               with no outcome other than niceties being exchanged. Why is the minister putting the future of kids like Reggie at risk with these funding\n               cuts?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415783","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thought the minister was going to say they set a record for emergency room closures. The Minister of Children and Family Development has demonstrated a master class today of the expression, \"That was then; this is\n               now.\" In 2021, the minister and other members of that government that weren't in government\n               at the time had no problem protesting the exact same cuts to a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:133457","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Toys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:133457","label":"Toys","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["54202ae24445609c740f1812e58e7676895573a3fd0c7ef9cd6aa1ac155912e5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["803ffe8d61f845f36e8335afea4b729e19ee48bd997d817299d5c831fd19e38e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f4e7f6d11651fc74aeaf5f9c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721559,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we all know, we all lead very busy lives in this career that we've chosen — or\n               that the public has chosen for us, I guess. Some of us quite recently have been a\n               little busier than others, for strange reasons, but it's come down to my wife, Lianne,\n               deciding that spending some quality time with her husband will be coming to question\n               period. Will the House please make Lianne welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721559","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"As we all know, we all lead very busy lives in this career that we've chosen — or\n               that the public has chosen for us, I guess. Some of us quite recently have been a\n               little busier than others, for strange reasons, but it's come down to my wife, Lianne,\n               deciding that spending some quality time with her husband will be coming to question\n               peri","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec8924b0dd189f541a3a25a348ffccf55147160d2d35ce263e272b2bc6b4c05b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-02cc1a0be1d85d320417cabb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721560,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's been interesting today that both the Premier, who's a lawyer, and the Attorney\n               General, who's a lawyer, have been using very exacting language when they talk about\n               the courts and the original intent around DRIPA. But the questions have actually been\n               about the 2021 14-minute amendment to the Interpretation Act that was brought in by\n               the Premier when he was then the Attorney General and what exactly the courts got\n               wrong with that ruling. So can we get very clearly on the record from the Attorney General, based on the Interpretation\n               Act changes from 2021 that impacted how the courts and how ministers are to interpret\n               DRIPA in relation to decision-making, very clearly one of the few answers that was\n               provided in those 14 minutes by the then Attorney General, now Premier, what","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721560","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's been interesting today that both the Premier, who's a lawyer, and the Attorney\n               General, who's a lawyer, have been using very exacting language when they talk about\n               the courts and the original intent around DRIPA. But the questions have actually been\n               about the 2021 14-minute amendment to the Interpretation Act that was brought in by\n               t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f14612bcdb8e4bca8e42a415fa90ed8db55cbef6a52e9335c2ef9f668c16eac6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b1d64307d0f0a3ea80cc3276e39d4dc7d91d9d752e709dd422a6f0b6d786f9b7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ce49203d25041e31f1fea33","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721565,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, I guess we found one of the ten in the caucus that didn't support the Premier\n               last week. The Attorney General has recommended that essentially, DRIPA be reworked over the\n               next six months, but there's a lot of things hanging in the balance. The Heritage\n               Conservation Act reworking, the Water Sustainability Act, rangeland tenures, Mineral\n               Tenure Act, the old growth deferral. Is the Attorney General suggesting that all of those potential changes are on hold\n               until DRIPA has had the conversations with Indigenous communities, or are those going\n               to proceed as if nothing has changed all of a sudden?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721565","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Well, I guess we found one of the ten in the caucus that didn't support the Premier\n               last week. The Attorney General has recommended that essentially, DRIPA be reworked over the\n               next six months, but there's a lot of things hanging in the balance. The Heritage\n               Conservation Act reworking, the Water Sustainability Act, rangeland tenures, Mineral\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Veterans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Natural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"War memorials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036395","label":"Natural heritage","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41816","label":"Veterans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49288","label":"War memorials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80c9c427a64c542a48990172a930cdb01dd16502cbdd4c588c8720e87ceddd8a","642bf39a9c2e1e79ce0f2c0138dfc83e26a430b25912638e111a9be9b77af898"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c02b51fbb1835996b1101c09cd7d93306e992ae4268036e74cb0279f2af7b8a4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-15898a6078a7171c611cda53","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729303,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"So much to unpack on that last speech. It's interesting. I don't want to dwell on\n               it, but I would point out that the NDP is running a record deficit, and they actually\n               have walked away from all of their campaign promises at the same time. If we want to talk about the campaign promises, like, I don't know, a teacher assistant\n               in every K-to-grade-3 classroom that is non-existent, a $1,000 grocery rebate.... The\n               list goes on and on and on of unfulfilled, unfunded and unaffordable campaign promises\n               that the government made as a sitting government who would have had access to all\n               of the financial data and information when they were making those promises to the\n               public and yet were more than willing to flat out say whatever it took to get themselves\n               elected with no intention of actually following through. If they did have that intention, then they really do need basic numeracy courses,\n               because they ought to have known what they were promising was an impossibility, given\n               the short time frame that they then walked away from those promises. The member opposite is blaming us for talking about a bloated public service. I would\n               point out, again, in the spirit of the motion around reading budgets, to perhaps read\n               their own budget, where their own Premier is talking about cutting 15,000 public service\n               employees that have bloated under their watch, not under our watch. We weren't the\n               ones with the keys to the Indeed account posting job listings for the public service.\n               This was the government that was, in fact, posting these extra 15,000 jobs, despite\n               years of the opposition pointing out that the public service was getting too large\n               and that it was simply unsustainable. That is the key piece to all of this. Again, we heard of the training modules that we've had as MLAs in this place, procedural\n               training but not training around what this motion is talking about — understanding\n               the core fundamentals of the interplay of the budget and the real-world consequences\n               that that has, and what questions should rightfully be asked. I don't expect the government members to be standing up in this place and challenging\n               the Finance Minister. Maybe they could actually get an answer. I never seem to get\n               one, but maybe they could get an answer if they did. But I don't expect them to be\n               challenging the Finance Minister openly and in public. That we can realize would not\n               happen. But one would hope that with the motion in front of us, that extra level of training\n               would create that confidence that, in those caucus meetings, those challenges could\n               happen, those discussions could happen so that we don't see ever-increasing deficits. Again, the member opposite was talking in good faith about how they are taking the\n               deficit seriously. The deficit has grown every single year that this Premier has been\n               the Premier. They are taking it seriously, but they are taking it seriously in the\n               wrong direction. Unfulfilled promises and ever-growing deficit — that is at the core\n               fundamental piece that we are talking about with this motion in front of us today. Why it's important that there is an understanding of that is because we do not have\n               the financial flexibility as a province any longer to continue down the paths we are\n               on. There is nothing more important in this place than all of us as a collective to have\n               a shared understanding of just what those consequences are to the decisions being\n               made, to the answers being provided or not provided, and why those are important,\n               and why when constituents are coming to your offices asking these very important questions,\n               outside of the lights of this place, you can actually provide a more in-depth and\n               thoughtful answer back than parroting talking points provided by the Premier's office\n               or the Finance Minister's office. That's why it's critically important, because these are the types of conversations\n               we should all be having with our constituents in a non-partisan way in our constituency\n               offices when they come forward. The constituents deserve to know that MLAs have at\n               least had some level of training, especially when you consider the list that was just\n               read off by the member opposite of the other subject areas we've been trained in or\n               at least provided some guidance in. I don't understand why that would be a problem\n               for the government to want to agree to add one more piece of training for us as MLAs. I do hope they actually take this in the non-partisan spirit it has been presented.\n               I do hope they take it in the serious way it has been presented. I don't understand\n               how more education would be a bad thing for MLAs instead of how the government members\n               currently have been advocating, which would be less education for members.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729303","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"So much to unpack on that last speech. It's interesting. I don't want to dwell on\n               it, but I would point out that the NDP is running a record deficit, and they actually\n               have walked away from all of their campaign promises at the same time. If we want to talk about the campaign promises, like, I don't know, a teacher assistant\n               in every K-to-grade-3 classr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["86f5ad2247fc29879ca8bd3074d0df74d2c1d075a8ed5e28e7b0a639a4005c12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["076c1e67a91d09c5658a74df405050e0597949008141333b185a22bda7e14ee7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-03998c57d65ff2f95fe17f8f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729310,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to recognize the Mechanical Contractors Association of B.C., their CEO, Kim\n               Barbero, and her board and the 53,400 highly skilled jobs that they do represent in\n               and around British Columbia. I had a great meeting with them earlier today. Will the House please make them welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729310","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to recognize the Mechanical Contractors Association of B.C., their CEO, Kim\n               Barbero, and her board and the 53,400 highly skilled jobs that they do represent in\n               and around British Columbia. I had a great meeting with them earlier today. Will the House please make them welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.71,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c30fb30cbec4d8804fb887807a14218ba01e24b1341f576d96868ab38ba4a172","18bba38193fbf4c249bd1f18781a17b72044dfd177fc8f5f117e6ce9d00146b1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2509806a8761f8ab13f26af1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752297,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm happy to take my place in the debate. Although my colleague before me may have\n               been not clear on whether he was opposed to this bill or not, I certainly am. Yes,\n               that's a little Zoom humour because he was most definitely very clear in his opposition,\n               as I have been as well. The reality of this bill is that we've seen this with this government repeatedly.\n               I'm going to take a little bit of the time to go back down memory lane when it comes\n               to FOI with this government. It was not that long ago that a minister spent days defending\n               changes to the FOI Act, defending changes to making it where you have to pay a fee\n               to file an FOI. There was a lot of concern legitimately raised at that point. There was a lot of concern around what would that fee be. And the answer for days\n               was: \"We don't know what the fee will be because we still have to consult. And so\n               we're not sure if it'll be $5. We're not sure if it'll be $10. We're not sure if it'll\n               be $20, but there will be a fee, and we're going to consult.\" Day after day, question\n               after question that was asked about this, that was the deflection. It was an admirable\n               performance by the minister at the time, I must say, in terms of being able to stick\n               to a speaking point. It may have felt good in the moment inside the chamber for that minister to continue\n               down that path. It certainly didn't play well out in the general public. It didn't\n               play well in the media. And it certainly didn't play well when we discovered that\n               within a few minutes of the bill being passed, an order in council was signed in the\n               hallway of the Legislature setting the fee at $10. Apparently, those multiple days\n               on end of questions but no answers during committee stage qualified as consultation\n               and checking in to see with stakeholders what the fee should be. That is fundamentally the core problem with this government. They repeatedly hide\n               and evade information. Now, if this was a government that actually, I don't know,\n               even answered questions in question period directly, maybe people wouldn't be as concerned\n               about Bill 9 and changes to FOI to make it even harder to access government information.\n               Maybe if ministers when they were asked direct questions in budget estimates or in\n               committee stages of bills, very straightforward, sometimes actually routine procedural\n               questions about a piece of legislation, answered it upfront and didn't take five different\n               questions to get a very basic answer out of them, perhaps people wouldn't be as worried. I can think back to one time. It was when LNG was being brought forward. I was the\n               environment critic at the time and, then, Minister Heyman. There was very simple language\n               in the bill, and it was about setting the emission standards for LNG moving forward.\n               It very clearly had, basically, boilerplate language in it that said that the minister\n               through orders in council could set emission levels for LNG projects. All I simply\n               asked was: does that mean to set the LNG emission profile, that would not have to\n               come back to the Legislature, that would just could be done over summertime by an\n               order in council signature? The minister repeatedly answered: \"Well, I don't have lawyers here. I can't answer\n               legal questions about this bill.\" That was a ridiculous question in the first place,\n               because every piece of legislation is a legal document. But it was because, frankly,\n               the minister didn't want to be seen to be responsible as the one setting LNG emissions. Obviously, as the former head of Sierra Club, he was probably not thrilled that he\n               was going to have to be the signatory not only to the massive tax breaks that were\n               given to LNG Canada but also to developing and signing off on what the emission profile\n               for LNG was going to be. Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion\n               of access to basic information. The minister eventually acknowledged that, yes, indeed,\n               that's exactly what that language means. We all know it. We see it in every piece\n               of legislation. We don't need lawyers to tell us that's what it actually means, but\n               that was the first four or five answers from the minister. Around and around we had\n               to dance to try to get an upfront answer. So if you're a member of the public or if you're a member of the media.... Imagine how\n               frustrating it must be for them to try to get a straight answer out of members of\n               government. That's why we have FOI in the first place. We have FOI because if government\n               chooses to not be proactive with their disclosure, if government chooses to pick and\n               choose when they want information to come out, if they want to try to redact, if they\n               want to try to otherwise hide what is going on in government, it is critically important. I can think back to budget estimates last year when I was asking questions about online\n               gaming and lobbying efforts that were happening, and the minister insisted that there\n               hadn't been meetings. In a follow-up question, I was able to provide an actual date\n               that a senior bureaucrat met with online gaming. And then the minister had to say:\n               \"Oh, oh yeah, actually we did have some meetings.\" Had I not had that document and that understanding of those calendars, the follow-up\n               question wouldn't have been asked. We would have simply taken the first question at\n               face value, which was a question that later turned out — literally, by later, the\n               next question or two — to not be entirely accurate and not paint an accurate picture\n               of something as fundamentally important as the expansion of online gaming or not and\n               the regulatory framework that would look like for online gaming in British Columbia. To the average person at home, you might think: \"Well, what's the big deal around\n               that?\" Well, there are pros and cons with gaming, and there are pros and cons with\n               online gaming, especially, in terms of addiction, in terms of gambling problems and\n               issues that come forward in that way. I think those are fair questions to ask. Where\n               exactly industry is headed, where government is headed for any potential expansion\n               or not on something that can be as addictive as online gaming, understanding what\n               those timelines are, understanding who's lobbying and what they're lobbying for —\n               all of that is critically important. If you had a government that was proactively releasing information, proactively talking\n               about things, not always making you jump through hoops trying to get the most basic\n               information, you might have a little less heartburn or apprehension about Bill 9.\n               But that's not the case. Sadly, we have a government that has routinely been acknowledged\n               as the most secretive government in Canada. We have a government, even on something as simple and basic as a $6,600 limo bill....\n               The minister.... No, she was not the Minister of Finance at the time, but she was a\n               minister. She was in Boston, and there were car charges for $6,600. Yet this government\n               wants to try to pretend it didn't happen. And members of the opposition will hoot\n               and howl and say that it's not true, that it didn't happen. Well, then why was it\n               claimed? Using the excuse, \"Well, it was a town car; it wasn't a limo,\" doesn't really matter\n               to the taxpayer. The taxpayer wants to know why $6,600 was spent on that limo ride\n               for the weekend instead of a few Ubers to get around. No one begrudges that staff\n               and ministers have to travel and have to get around and be transported around large\n               cities. That makes perfect sense. A $6,600 limo ride to accomplish that does seem\n               a tad excessive. There's been a wide range of other FOIs on these types of issues. When you look at\n               the state we're in right now and issues around DRIPA, meetings that would be happening\n               around DRIPA, I think the public.... More daylight is much better than less. You know,\n               this is why the government that keeps taking steps on Bill 9, especially in the backdrop\n               of all that's unfolding right now and ever-tanking popularity numbers by a Premier\n               and his government, makes one second-guess and ponder. Just what exactly are they afraid is going to be discovered through FOI that they're\n               scrambling to try to get new laws in place before those FOI filings get filed? I think\n               it's a legitimate concern. I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy\n               theorist or goes over the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that\n               the timing of this I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy theorist or that goes over\n               the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that the timing of this legislation,\n               given all the other issues going on in British Columbia right now and all the serious\n               nature of things, is being brought forward at a time where we can't see a tangible\n               benefit for it, other than restricting the public's, the media's and the opposition's\n               access to information. You know, when we're looking at the past practice of this government, when we're looking\n               at past pieces of legislation, when we're looking at actions taken — again, not just\n               on travel but on decisions that this government has made, things like briefing notes\n               or estimates binders, a wide range of issues — a lot of times what happens is that\n               when you pull on the thread, you get a bit of a path. So you start heading down one way, and then you say: \"Oh, hang on. Now with that piece\n               of information, I never imagined that that would have been the answer. So I guess\n               we'd better start looking over here as well now.\" That's the critical importance of\n               FOI. Sometimes we're fortunate enough that we stumble upon that when we're in budget estimates.\n               So we have a piece of an FOI document, or we have a series of questions, and the answer\n               comes back, different than we were expecting. That actually engages a whole series\n               of FOIs that might happen, because what we assumed was happening in government is\n               in fact not what's happening. An example I'll use on this is that a few years ago, when I was questioning around\n               the budget and the government made a big, big deal that there were $70 million for\n               reconciliation efforts put into the budget. Now I was asked on budget day what to\n               point out as something good in the budget. I said: \"Oh, that sounds like it's a good\n               thing, if there's more capacity for municipalities and nations to work together to\n               actually move projects forward quickly and get things accomplished.\" Then you fast-forward to budget estimates, and I thought I would ask a few questions\n               of the Minister of Indigenous Relations. I said: \"Well, how did we come to that dollar\n               figure? Frankly, I was going to be a bit of a smart aleck with a couple of those questions,\n               because the minister, before he became part of government, between being an MP — he\n               was Minister Rankin at the time — and a minister in an election, had resigned as an\n               MP. His placeholder work, granted to him by the NDP, was to be a highly paid First Nations\n               consultant, and Nathan Cullen had the same deal. It was a very convenient work transition,\n               for both of those gentlemen — to be able to resign as an MP, wait to run to become\n               an MLA, and get very highly lucrative consulting contracts to work with the government\n               and First Nations. I was going to basically do a calculation of how much they were getting paid per hour\n               back in their consultant days and figure out how many hours of consulting this $70\n               million was going to accomplish. What surprised me was actually the answer. The answer\n               was: \"Well, this is what we've historically always spent.\" At that, I instantly switched gears and said: \"Well, this is supposed to be new money.\n               This is supposed to be expanded money. What do you mean that this is what has always\n               been spent?\" It turns out that all it was, was that instead of taking it out of contingencies\n               every year, government just decided to make it a permanent line item. Fine, except\n               don't start marketing it as \"new, expanded, never been done before, enhanced and going\n               to provide extra\" — all that type of language that was used. Why it matters is because in this case, we were able to get to an answer during budget\n               estimates. However, with these changes to FOI, had we wanted to follow up with an\n               FOI based on those lines of questioning to see exactly how they got to a historic\n               average of $70 million of reconciliation spending in any given year, this Bill 9 would\n               have made that next to impossible, after budget estimates are over, for the opposition\n               to follow up, fact-check, verify and dig deeper into some of the answers ministers\n               give. Now, let's remember we have limited time in budget estimates to actually fully question,\n               especially when ministers start to be evasive with their answers. It starts to chew\n               up the clock, and they sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with\n               staff. You can hear them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking\n               about holiday plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. They sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with staff. You can hear\n               them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking about holiday\n               plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. Then they turn around, and they\n               give you a non-answer and hope that you'll move on to a different subject because\n               they know that we're up against a clock. They do that quite frequently, frankly, and it gets worse the farther we go into a\n               session and the more desperate a government becomes with reduced polling numbers.\n               So I fully expect, as we continue on with budget estimates, that will probably continue. The key to it, though, is that, as opposition, that means if we don't get through\n               all of our material or we get answers that we wanted more follow-up on but we don't\n               have the time in that current moment to follow up, we would actually access and leverage\n               an FOI to try to actually get that information or see, again, if the minister is being\n               forthright with the public about what's truly going on behind the scenes. Now, Bill 9, when I heard that the government was bringing in a bill around FOI reform\n               and changes, I was actually hoping they would've learned from the last go-around and\n               actually been bringing in changes to improve FOI access, not make it even harder and\n               make it essentially nonexistent. It's a way to basically have something on the books\n               that says you have freedom of information but that, in fact, it doesn't actually exist. Now, when I was the mayor of Kamloops, I got FOI'd a lot, as did council, as a matter\n               of practice for media and others. In fact, our disclosure and our turnaround and our\n               expectation of providing and redacting was much more open and transparent than what\n               the provincial government operates under. Interestingly enough, it's rules the provincial government forces upon municipalities\n               to operate that way. I don't have an issue with that. When I say \"forces upon,\" I\n               say that because the provincial government ultimately sets the rules and the laws\n               that municipalities operate under. In this case, though, every time this government in particular has a chance to make\n               their own rules, it's always \"rules for thee and not for me.\" That is where we're\n               at again with these FOI changes in Bill 9. We have a government that is desperate to hide what they're actually doing, a government\n               that does not want the public to know who they're meeting with when and about what,\n               a government that certainly doesn't want to provide any clarity or line of sight as\n               to what is going on, on the DRIPA file, who they are meeting with, what the timeline is. Again, it's not just DRIPA. This impacts all sorts of other areas. We've heard from\n               the member from Kelowna and myself, who've met with distillers regularly who have\n               had many promises and many meetings with the government and timelines broken and not\n               met. Without the ability of FOI'ing and calendar access and understanding just how serious\n               the government is or isn't taking a file, it makes having those types of conversations\n               with people that are being impacted by government rules, regulations and tax policies\n               very, very difficult to understand what exactly the government is truly doing to move\n               an issue forward and what issues they're just simply deciding to go through the motions\n               and not actually ever intend to take meaningful or serious action on for any type\n               of industry that is critically needed. When you look at the mess that forestry is right now in the complete shambles and\n               the complete.... Well, it sounded like today that the Premier just gave up. He apparently\n               doesn't know how to work with Ottawa. He doesn't know how to negotiate with Ottawa.\n               He doesn't know how to get a benefit for British Columbians out of Ottawa. He essentially\n               shrugged and said that, well, there's nothing more he can do. He doesn't know what\n               else he can do to try to get Ottawa's attention on softwood. Well, here's the tip. Maybe the government shouldn't have walked away, letting a maritime\n               province for a lot of years be the head of the softwood table on behalf of all of\n               the provinces. Just one little suggestion as a sidebar there. But when you look at the mess that forestry is in, when you look at the concerns that\n               unions are bringing forward, when you look at the concerns that industry is bringing\n               forward, I think having more daylight, again, on issues around forestry without having\n               to go through the hoops of even further-restricted FOI documents would provide better\n               peace of mind and certainty if the government is truly intending on trying to action\n               or get results that they keep saying they're trying to do. But the results are not\n               matching the actions. When we hear in 2021, 2022 that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in forestry\n               while they're projecting When we hear, in 2021-2022, that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in\n               forestry while they're projecting $1 billion in revenue drop, and now we're at $1.3\n               billion in revenue drop in that time frame, yearly, and we have 15,000 job losses,\n               not 30,000 job gains, FOI would be a very helpful tool to have to find more certainty\n               around what decisions the government was rejecting while they were watching the forest\n               sector completely implode upon itself. It's not just the FOIs that we rely upon on what decisions were made. It's the FOIs\n               around what advice was being given or what suggestions were being provided that are\n               critically important, as well, to get a better sense of where the government actually\n               is on any given file, how serious they actually are on actually trying to solve the\n               issues of our time and how performative they're trying to be. If you look at the challenges in health care and the wait times, be it surgical wait\n               times, be it diagnostic wait times, be it cancer treatment wait times, all of those\n               types of situations.... Again, when was the minister briefed? How frequently does the\n               minister get briefed? What action did the minister take from those briefings? Did\n               the minister even care to pay any attention or enact anything that is being suggested\n               to try to change the system for the better? All of that gets discovered by freedom\n               of information. I think it's safe to say, if you're watching me speak right now at home, you probably\n               watch the odd question period, and you would know none of those questions will ever\n               get answered in question period. We'll ask. We'll keep doing our job as an opposition,\n               but let's not be under any illusions that this government routinely takes the question\n               and then answers on something completely off topic. If I tried doing that on this bill debate around Bill 9, the Chair, rightfully so,\n               would interrupt me and tell me: \"Member, you need to be speaking to the bill.\" In\n               question period, it seems that this government, in an effort to hide and distract\n               away, not only completely avoids the question. They're talking about something completely\n               unrelated to what was even being asked. That's why we need FOI, because it used to\n               be you could reasonably get some direction and answers out of a government in question\n               period, but those days have long since passed. So when I see the provisions in Bill 9, when I see the government's excuses, frankly,\n               for why they say they need Bill 9, the governments want constantly to try to hide\n               information, try to make things more difficult, not be willing to get back to media\n               to answer their legitimate questions that they might have. It's interesting how quickly a minister's office will decide they actually can make\n               comment if they find out that the opposition has already made comment on a news story.\n               Well, if they're being that difficult just to get a 15-second sound clip, imagine\n               how difficult they're being to opposition and other people that are looking for information\n               when we start asking for information on any given file. A good example would be the speculation of vacancy tax, where the ministry had their\n               own audit done, and at least that was released, but it didn't have to be. We could\n               have actually found ourselves in a situation where, again, we're struggling and looking\n               for that information. Really, I guess at its core.... What's the expression about \"fool me once\"? You know,\n               we pushed back hard the last time they brought in FOI changes, and the government\n               insisted that they were still going to forge through and do them. It simply wasn't\n               acceptable. It wasn't good enough. They managed to do it. Now we've already seen the Premier back down multiple times on legislation. He's done\n               it with DRIPA. He's had contorted conditions on all sorts of legislation in this place\n               over the last couple of years. A bill like this — one would hope the government actually sees the writing on the\n               wall. They can actually.... They don't seem to care or want to understand why this is\n               such an offensive piece of legislation. They must think that it is nothing more than\n               political theatre by the opposition. But I can assure the government members that this is not political theatre on our\n               part. It's the government that tries to do more performative actions across the board\n               on a regular basis than actual tangible deliverables for the public. The fact that\n               their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us The fact that their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us seems to\n               be Bill 9, an FOI restriction act where it actually makes it much harder for the public,\n               opposition and media to gain access to government information, government decision-making,\n               government thought process.... That is their underlying, signature piece of legislation,\n               it seems, in this session. I mean, we did deal with a weighty miscellaneous stats bill last week, so they had\n               that going for them, I guess. But that's simply not something that works well. I thank you for the time on this bill, and I look forward to further debate.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752297","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm happy to take my place in the debate. Although my colleague before me may have\n               been not clear on whether he was opposed to this bill or not, I certainly am. Yes,\n               that's a little Zoom humour because he was most definitely very clear in his opposition,\n               as I have been as well. The reality of this bill is that we've seen this with this government repeat","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["63f197723bdfe7418bfbad7d8102683084882f002068583db2a093aaf5a9ff31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["386f67382e342e505d1e955278eda6aaebfdaa3c1a97db8437457ac47bd28896"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-80a23e19b4303d6851e538ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752298,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, before the Green interlude, the minister was getting quite the round of applause\n               from the Mutual Admiration Society across the way, so I'll give them another chance\n               for an applause line about their economic track record. Fastest deficit growth.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752298","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, before the Green interlude, the minister was getting quite the round of applause\n               from the Mutual Admiration Society across the way, so I'll give them another chance\n               for an applause line about their economic track record. Fastest deficit growth.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adoption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Furniture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Entrepreneurs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035102","label":"Entrepreneurs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70318","label":"Adoption","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715741","label":"Furniture","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b7f0b848cd08b0e8c0882fae6a347b242df764cfafc66eedf8200b6876d2800","e90853d894878be416ba6e14d14962cbf804ee1f657b9b01e133f0ede7739aa5","957e8dc2959e4cfbaa24d88b4c7e83b8e8fbc5cfdd158808425656f23b50dc44"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4e4a9b88da19727cede0a4347248d1bd8eea01998ac865920234394df493e439"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e8d6fc8624bf164e207ff15d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017447,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here is a 20-day snapshot from this Premier. There is a significant concern among\n               the public following a couple of major court decisions, and I have to say I share\n               that","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017447","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Here is a 20-day snapshot from this Premier. There is a significant concern among\n               the public following a couple of major court decisions, and I have to say I share\n               that","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036381","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Hockey","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036381","label":"National Capital","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48473","label":"Hockey","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c70af5dbc26f8ffe79529e8f29c333009db6150b3ad6090e70082e958b72f063","b0414b8534c03958a61525bd7305d8fe9113f28c2aa582c03a9bf61eeae627d4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-78b591abaf3b8b35e0b93cba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017451,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy to take my place in this debate on Bill 20. It's troubling, watching how events have unfolded over the last little while with\n               this government and how badly they have now handled even the treaty process. I say\n               that because we know that treaties do bring stability into regions where treaties\n               have been in place. We see that in other parts of the province where longer-standing treaties have been in place. But only this government could manage to mess up a system that has taken 30 years\n               to get us here, and yet they have still managed to completely bungle it when it comes\n               to talking and trying to better understand and have a treaty that can be better supported\n               by surrounding nations. I say that because this is a government that repeatedly over\n               the last little while — when we're talking about repealing DRIPA; when we're talking about the need to repeal DRIPA — insists that they are going\n               to do it by having conversations and talking and not just taking those types of steps. Yet here we have a treaty where other nations have very clearly said that not only\n               are they not being listened to, they're not being talked to by this government. It\n               seems very opposite of everything that this government has been trying to say to us. And so again, when they want to try to wag the finger and lecture us about proper\n               process and respectful conversations and moving documents forward and getting agreements,\n               that has not happened in this case. It is very clear by virtue of the hoist motion\n               we attempted as an amendment previous to this That has not happened in this case. It is very clear, by virtue of the hoist motion\n               we attempted as an amendment previous to this, that we are sincere about putting the\n               brakes on this so that further dialogue and discussions can actually happen. That's\n               what we are hearing from many in association with this particular treaty. There is\n               no harm in doing that. The government wants to walk the walk? Then they can do that. They can actually say\n               that they are true and sincere in their attempts. But unfortunately, political theatre\n               is what this government seems intent on. Political theatre around DRIPA — whether\n               it's going to be amendments, a three-year pause, a one-year pause, a pause until the\n               fall with amendments, or maybe it's a repeal.... \"We're not really sure, because we're going to do the right thing, and we're going\n               to have those conversations. Yet we're going to rush through.\" I say \"rush\" in the\n               context of a 30-year document. I understand how that can sound a little bit contradictory. But a document 30 years in the making that this government has been responsible for,\n               for the last nine years of that 30 years, a third of this time.... And they've managed\n               to deliver a document that is rife with controversy and rife with lack of consultation,\n               lack of understanding of agreement of neighbouring nations with the treaty nation\n               that would be the beneficiary of this treaty. So I can't in good faith move forward with the document, knowing that that is the\n               backdrop on this. It's not about the fundamental principle of a treaty. It's about\n               just how badly this government yet again — time and again; it seems it doesn't matter\n               what topic we're talking about — sets a whole new bar for incompetence. And yet again,\n               they have done it on this. So I'm hard-pressed. I would welcome the government to point to any other treaties\n               that took 30 years to get negotiated, wound up in front of this chamber, started to\n               be debated and then had multiple, multiple groups saying: \"Put the brakes on it. This\n               hasn't been done properly.\" But only this government, in their incompetence, could\n               manage to pull that off. Again, after nine years.... Nine long years of the last 30 years has been directly at\n               the hands of this government negotiating this treaty. So they can't talk and point\n               the finger back to the start. They can't even point the finger back, although that\n               30 years, I guess, they would have been in government even at the start of this or\n               close to it. They can't point the finger back there, nor can they even point it to\n               the midpoint. The reality is if they can't deliver a document in a nine-year period that was already\n               well underway, 21 years underway, with some certainty and some confidence and some\n               buy-in by the other nations, how does anyone have any faith that they could negotiate something between now and the\n               fall in regards to DRIPA? This is the insanity that is watching this unfold in front\n               of us with this government in terms of how they are handling the Indigenous file in\n               general. Every time they touch something it gets worse. Every single time. And this treaty\n               is just another example of that. I feel for the K'ómoks. They were understandably very excited around this, wanting\n               to see closure and a moving forward. But they ought to have known, or probably were\n               figuring out over the last nine years, that the government wasn't dealing with a full\n               deck. We need to make sure that this actually has had the proper oversight, overview, which\n               was the premise of the six-month hoist. It was not to try to kill the treaty completely;\n               it was about trying to give that breathing space as the minister has indicated, the\n               Attorney General has indicated, is much critically needed for DRIPA — the same time\n               frame as what our hoist motion was. And that suddenly was unacceptable to this government,\n               but on DRIPA, it's totally acceptable. Again, totally contradictory language — totally contradictory actions, more importantly.\n               It leads to uncertainty, not just within the project world and communities. It's leading\n               to a lot of uncertainty within Indigenous nations as to just what this government\n               actually truly believes in terms of working with Indigenous nations in good faith.\n               Is it that they only work in good faith with the ones that they deem to be acceptable\n               in working with them, or will they work truly with all 204 First Nations? So I can't find myself in a position of not being able to support this treaty. I truly\n               feel that I'm fortunate that the government decided to try to ram it through and not\n               support the hoist motion. They will have to deal with the consequences of yet another\n               mishandled file on their part of utter incompetence when it comes to dealing with\n               issues around Indigenous relations. Thank you for the time. Thank you for the time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017451","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Happy to take my place in this debate on Bill 20. It's troubling, watching how events have unfolded over the last little while with\n               this government and how badly they have now handled even the treaty process. I say\n               that because we know that treaties do bring stability into regions where treaties\n               have been in place. We see that in other parts of the prov","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8617fb81c173405516c2164a5e59189074913f038c1a12aead6458b95f4becd3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a802d4bb4e96a1ed2227cef83666b8bc5fbb9f323289ea132de67d524b778c9c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9aafbdafd16ee5f99305869","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017452,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'll endeavour to have the minister still be looking forward to my questions as we\n               hit hour 15, but we'll see where that goes. In terms of the overall budget, I have been looking through and searching and searching\n               and searching, and I'm unable to locate.... I've had many, many property owners and\n               people in Richmond with great interest asking where exactly the mortgage backing program\n               the Premier has promised for people in Richmond would be in this budget. Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment pre-budget\n               that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond\n               based on the Cowichan ruling resides? Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment prebudget\n               that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond\n               based on the Quw'utsun ruling resides?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017452","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'll endeavour to have the minister still be looking forward to my questions as we\n               hit hour 15, but we'll see where that goes. In terms of the overall budget, I have been looking through and searching and searching\n               and searching, and I'm unable to locate.... I've had many, many property owners and\n               people in Richmond with great interest asking where exac","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Banking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","label":"Mortgage assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","label":"Mortgage loans","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501199","label":"Banking","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71d41de308ab653ea965a55003a13baa42db8bfb364d63ca714d40cfa0ee657b","2424e2418c2f4db50c498a58983e3a40541f4584f9cd2b46ea7b69f41cb18e6e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.74,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93cf685bfcb67ed36c5a18f80ab1c6890d19a55d6ba2e76510ff226390530751"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mortgage assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036336","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036337","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbb25d701574a86360ae49fb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017454,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Does the minister feel that this year's three-year fiscal plan lays out the start\n               of a pathway to a balanced budget? How confident is she, if that's the case?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017454","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Does the minister feel that this year's three-year fiscal plan lays out the start\n               of a pathway to a balanced budget? How confident is she, if that's the case?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Internal audits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Audit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Monarchy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012305","label":"Audit","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035253","label":"Financial audit","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035937","label":"Internal audits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036330","label":"Monarchy","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036386","label":"National income","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66380e077d96edf11e5ef641a3e050806eecd6c8d45d7ccdded80182bdb664c3","f67ede795363a1125d2845bc4424e0bbc4843fd3a6c74b1190c6dfdc4c557720","66b3ef9582cbd40cf9a36063bdba75c657658bbf27ce00cf6bf14e036093570c","52e5e8cec1f0986cd1c0b53777959a80ff911fa2a016f9cf4fdb6b85a8288a43"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0ca97f72729d67eb759ca1f70e4e7bdaa340b33f929f9132417c0793ffe0f99e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ebdf9c9d310a2f45a656d0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036524,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mindful that all these introductions are chewing into my estimates time this afternoon, which.... I think the Finance Minister looks very happy. I wasn't sure whether it would be three or four days early or one day late with this,\n               but it was my oldest granddaughter Zoe's fourth birthday yesterday","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036524","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Mindful that all these introductions are chewing into my estimates time this afternoon, which.... I think the Finance Minister looks very happy. I wasn't sure whether it would be three or four days early or one day late with this,\n               but it was my oldest granddaughter Zoe's fourth birthday yesterday","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gambling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous lands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Marketing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pulp and paper industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Licensing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103075","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Casinos","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Propaganda","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036157","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Lotteries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103075","label":"Casinos","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035819","label":"Indigenous lands","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036157","label":"Lotteries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131335","label":"Recreation","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44850","label":"Propaganda","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47522","label":"Pulp and paper industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47720","label":"Marketing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501342","label":"Gambling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721817","label":"Licensing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8471c162c82b680c7549d3f5898f389511f74bf7d0bf5b839b94d65d5ef69e91","2bff7b3266e620fa07243caf466fe46017ac76bef0d92133b4a72034a78d7ddb","8b7a9376274fbeba3783602c340a708ed5afe9fe6965aaab67ea5312eea9fccc","64fa4576d54be0441da55799226b3259f176bd2dc088413bc7e3c0634e29d2f7","d3c136a48caa77837c8393cd7c5e5cc425a7db189710aacf2d11fa6129d3c22f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7dd80f13bafc84b7bc4b46d7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036525,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I was feeling a little left out of \"take your family to work\" week, so I thought I'd\n               rectify that. Will the House please make my wife, Lianne, very welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036525","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I was feeling a little left out of \"take your family to work\" week, so I thought I'd\n               rectify that. Will the House please make my wife, Lianne, very welcome here today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["daf3516792e90775a4d2490c296e7b532a6e2b04bfd12f90ed4207270ef84b82","3320b654667d1c25d2d7d1ac81bdcdc65bb8e5160291a44df39c4825a01327a6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1f44d41c1f75211220095e8e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036527,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I guess Thursday when I was questioning around contingencies the minister said, in\n               response to the member's question, that it is true that the negotiations took longer\n               than expected and that the cost of the mandate did go up. That is captured in the\n               increase in the contingency fund. The contingency fund last year was projected to\n               be $4 billion this year. It is now $5 billion moving forward, and last year was projected\n               to be $4 billion, not just this year but the subsequent year. Can the minister confirm then by her answer that means that the mandate, the negotiations\n               with the public sector, has been $1 billion more than the government expected?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036527","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I guess Thursday when I was questioning around contingencies the minister said, in\n               response to the member's question, that it is true that the negotiations took longer\n               than expected and that the cost of the mandate did go up. That is captured in the\n               increase in the contingency fund. The contingency fund last year was projected to\n               be $4 bi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Household finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Retail trade","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Regional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tobacco industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Travel documents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax credits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Minimum wage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207037","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Permafrost","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035711","label":"Household finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035949","label":"International finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083619","label":"Travel documents","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:207037","label":"Permafrost","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43836","label":"Tax credits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49322","label":"Regional development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70542","label":"Minimum wage","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78947","label":"Retail trade","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","label":"Tobacco industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7f3a5565887122cea33f511f40472078aa295a7cb8cb977904c3d293c9cd6bdd","67fdbbb80bb7500cf1f4ec370bb7aa30d9c3bdbfb052f856251ff2c82cf3869f","6e8d9bc4dd35902733b696c81b1afa083265b1e57e54edf5426c6dabbd0aeaa7","b04be5160b6b0224a62d86be9d03951627a4bcfdcc711f55146731660d445952","44df5d7a2e7d16cace95b59eebb770139a6a0bfcd53a4b29cdbafc6acc86d310","27338860ba549bab6a4aca284e21db0282272c027b279d3b126e914a7db8b560"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["63ec513c78748b645d43b8bbb94fbaae0b98b96f28910f3f4436ff7241c25b8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6cab658c9fbaab76279399ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036528,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, I'm no lawyer, but that certainly sounds like the Interpretation Act changes\n               that the Premier brought in as the Attorney General have made one confusing legal\n               mess of things in British Columbia. At the beginning, in the Premier's opening statements, he waxed poetically about the\n               Westminster system and how wonderful it is to be in budget estimates where the public\n               can hear full scrutiny and disclosure from the government on things of importance\n               to the public. Yesterday when I was in budget estimates with the Finance Minister, I was actually\n               heartened by some proactive disclosure at the same time as we were debating Bill 9\n               in a different chamber, which is FOI legislation which would severely restrict people's\n               access to information from the government. The minister proactively disclosed a document\n               to me, the Treasury Board directive she signed off on, on April 30, while I was questioning\n               around costs of FIFA. Part of the directive she signed off on, on page 5, is 5(b): if the government of\n               B.C. or a government organization is subject to a purchase agreement in relation to\n               provincial FIFA World Cup 26 tickets, it will strictly comply with the terms of that\n               agreement. So the minister signed off on this directive, Treasury Board directive.\n               It's got her signature on it. She provided it, fully and wholly, over to me. The problem is that then I asked a question in relation to the document she then provided.\n               I said the minister signed off on these directions. I'm asking what the cost is of\n               what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost was when she signed off on the\n               directive that says the government of B.C. is subject to purchase agreement in relation\n               to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms of that agreement, that sounds like\n               a blank cheque. So did the minister know I'm asking what the cost is of what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost\n               was when she signed off on the directive that says the government of B.C. is subject\n               to purchase agreement in relation to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms\n               of that agreement, that sounds like a blank cheque. So did the minister know when she signed off on this directive April 30, 2026, which\n               was not that long ago, what the cost of the suites were going to be? Or did she not\n               know what the cost of the suites would be, which would fall under \"strictly comply with the terms of agreement\" around ticket allocations for FIFA World Cup 2026? It has to be one or the other. Either on April 30 the minister knew what the cost\n               of the suites were going to be and she should be able to provide that figure today,\n               or she didn't know and she signed off on a directive that creates a blank cheque for\n               obligations under FIFA that the government was unaware of on April 30, 2026. To which the minister shockingly replied — again, proactive disclosure: \"I suggest\n               to the member there is a third option, which is that the minister does know and is\n               deferring to the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, and Culture to give their update, which they plan to do in the coming days.\" Which to the outside\n               world might sound like a reasonable answer. In fact, I believe Madam Chair was in the chair when I asked her whether or not ministers\n               are expected to answer questions that they've actually fully acknowledged they have\n               the answer to in the middle of budget estimates which, based on her signed directive,\n               she is directly responsible for. But the minister refused. So I would like to give the Premier the opportunity, as the head of government, to\n               answer that question which, obviously, government does have the answer to. It may\n               be in government's convenience to release it as a package with the minister after\n               this House rises, conveniently not before the Premier's estimates. But his own minister.... By all accounts, everyone agrees in most.... You have the Attorney General and you have\n               the Finance Minister. Those are kind of the two big heads of ministerial roles. She has acknowledged she signed a directive on April 30 of this year to make sure\n               you fully participate in all ticket packages required by FIFA. It was a direct question\n               around what the cost of the suite package is. Not how they were being allocated, not\n               who was going into the suites — the cost. And she replied she has the answer but refused\n               to give the answer. That is not acceptable. I hope the Premier would think that's\n               not acceptable, as well, for the public. So what is the actual cost of the suite package for these seven games that this government\n               has agreed to under the provisions of the FIFA contract and the Treasury Board directive\n               signed by his own Finance Minister on April 30?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036528","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Well, I'm no lawyer, but that certainly sounds like the Interpretation Act changes\n               that the Premier brought in as the Attorney General have made one confusing legal\n               mess of things in British Columbia. At the beginning, in the Premier's opening statements, he waxed poetically about the\n               Westminster system and how wonderful it is to be in budget estimates ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax fraud","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Commercial law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Dance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034548","label":"Commercial law","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037282","label":"Tax fraud","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:179541","label":"Dance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725553","label":"Games","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["74df8529cf3913fcb2972a0e64ae9987dbc6f5ca44a05832cce7f1e8ba8b7f1a","0e4ad11627cc887313e4c530b15254a25f06d51c11bff5ad7d12bcd1146679b8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c39cdf781a715d37b70c23abd69c5499b8e00d516cf136c88f59e639c98e94c2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-511bb365639011774097c049","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036529,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Peter Milobar","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036529","member_id":"bc-mla-52","member_name":"Peter Milobar","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:187157","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Skating","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:187157","label":"Skating","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42466","label":"Security","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["892f7d0bbe475552b51851868b83e822ce89dbbcc8e0dee04f61aa8af313403c","02ea4c74e272b7874afba9487f8159df6920bcb0fa3a8c3d69fc80d060f12bdb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f97bce3b7580ab6b31807258","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317185,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Mental health care is health care.\n               This government is making record investments in early intervention, in prevention,\n               in supporting children and youth in our schools and home settings. This is the work that we were doing with the Green Party. Unfortunately, that agreement\n               came to an end, and we no longer have the opportunity to continue to discuss the work\n               that we have been doing to integrate mental health supports into our primary care\n               system. Already, over 355 full-time-equivalents are embedded throughout the primary care system,\n               because team-based primary care, including mental health supports, is part of the\n               holistic care that people deserve. They deserve it when they want it, when they need\n               it and to get it close to home. This government remains committed to that work. We will continue to work with the B.C. Psychologists Association, and we'll do that,\n               unfortunately, with or without the Greens.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317185","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for the question. Mental health care is health care.\n               This government is making record investments in early intervention, in prevention,\n               in supporting children and youth in our schools and home settings. This is the work that we were doing with the Green Party. Unfortunately, that agreement\n               came to an end, and we no longe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Preschool education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57316","label":"Preschool education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.38,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["43fe1d0232bd0cb63b731c766aed34e547c51f8fa1f972331f602e79184c5053"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50b9b6433828a021be5ce8bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317186,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions to","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317186","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I have two introductions to","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e8490a516940d2911cd13921d3ff796be7189de3092981bf7c23c04c11e1102e","37aff783420724482e63b70625a70fbbff7fe20cb4d6a32a03130abecde57000","b906fb896c521f0799759ae269d0ecaa5485739c2f1580c00f419a206a9bc03f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a2cf7735ff0c362e7019ba29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328027,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much to the member for the question as well. Vancouver General Hospital provides some of the most excellent care to pregnant women\n               and their babies. In the very, very rare circumstance that a woman who is past 20 weeks gestation experiences\n               severe trauma and is in requirement of trauma 1 level services. Nothing could be more\n               important than the safety of that mother and her baby, which is why there are other\n               facilities like Royal Columbian Hospital who provide these services as well. I urge any person who needs to go to an emergency room or faces an emergency to call\n               911, where a reliable and dependable system of emergency transport, patient transport\n               and connection and communication between hospital facilities exists so that people\n               can get the care that they need at the most urgent time when they need it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328027","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you very much to the member for the question as well. Vancouver General Hospital provides some of the most excellent care to pregnant women\n               and their babies. In the very, very rare circumstance that a woman who is past 20 weeks gestation experiences\n               severe trauma and is in requirement of trauma 1 level services. Nothing could be more\n               important tha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d1e1ea9d19e665887d29117ec03655a3f04bcf7b48aec1309561c8b44fb433b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5f6abda0597f252f0922fcfe939abb0979845761e3c958ae7da030980aa2c39f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4b4537632a662a39b74f5a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328028,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"In Section C, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 4, the Supply Act. Here, I call second reading on Bill 6.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328028","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In Section C, I call Committee of the Whole on Bill 4, the Supply Act. Here, I call second reading on Bill 6.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1283be3c13eb7ccd27b88dc0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328029,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am honoured today to introduce the Alzheimer's Society of B.C. and Yukon. Dementia\n               is something that touches every part of our health system. It touches the core of\n               our communities. Addressing this requires research, education, clinical leadership,\n               compassionate, community-based support and listening to people with lived experience.\n               It's challenging but important work, and we're partners in doing this work together. I want to say thank you to the members of the board and staff, who are here with us\n               in the gallery today, for your leadership, for your advocacy, for the work that you\n               do not only for people living with dementia but those who walk alongside them. I would ask all members of the House to please join me in welcoming them and making\n               them feel very appreciated for the work that they do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328029","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I am honoured today to introduce the Alzheimer's Society of B.C. and Yukon. Dementia\n               is something that touches every part of our health system. It touches the core of\n               our communities. Addressing this requires research, education, clinical leadership,\n               compassionate, community-based support and listening to people with lived experience.\n               It'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Computer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034608","label":"Computer services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fbce1cb781bf24772db6144884492b3762dffa5eb2597f134c35243e6ef9620a","48a9571d2c76774f8def168216d46f90a90d7fb3af3fb2caac21b0807baa9bc4","d8bbb3c381784af2544393d9ed151a04ae40dbec6a419dcca64f440a387f6b42"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["71c946b3d01f01e53dc1a589a237988ec741b892e1a05186345580669c3e6c46"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-640e393de746ee07d644dd0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328030,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question and pointing out the incredible importance\n               of providing home supports for people of any age, but particularly seniors. That's\n               why this government has taken steps in improving long-term care at home, improving\n               community-based home supports for seniors, because we know that people want to live\n               independently, that they are healthier when they live independently and that that\n               results in better health outcomes. That's why we invested over $300 million in last year's budget to support, through\n               United Way, home supports for seniors. It's why this year's budget provides $35 million\n               to Independent Living B.C. to help keep seniors in their homes. We're dedicated to this work. We understand just how important it is, and we're going\n               to continue doing it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328030","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question and pointing out the incredible importance\n               of providing home supports for people of any age, but particularly seniors. That's\n               why this government has taken steps in improving long-term care at home, improving\n               community-based home supports for seniors, because we know that people want to live\n               indepe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["46a12f520152f2b230e2c12f0d5a8ecc1160fda08d9381bb75892ed3489122ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d38d24739478680de82a431ce4d8a3c5743a49b692f2491203488d3d72325235"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9ef9c11fa3d2dd986c11e18e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328031,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call continued debate on Bill 2.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328031","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I call continued debate on Bill 2.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50292b1ca273fed49c098e34","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360868,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Now, Mr. Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360868","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Now, Mr. Speaker.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035372","label":"Forestry products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9a8f8a75063e20d9fe7d6ca977f4f20174a582199b3393e3799f865980bafae4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ef900a1052d2651500903e09","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360869,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased today to introduce a group of more than 20 medical students from UBC School\n               of Medicine who are joining us in the gallery today. These are students who are members of a political advocacy committee. They're here\n               in the Legislature to raise awareness about the health and well-being of migrant farmworkers,\n               people who play a vital role in B.C.'s food and agriculture sectors. They're advocating\n               for strong supports in areas like health care access, safe housing, language services\n               and transportation, recognizing that these are factors that are critical to the health\n               and well-being of workers who help feed our province. Their commitment is truly admirable. I would like the House to please join me in making them feel most welcome here today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360869","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm pleased today to introduce a group of more than 20 medical students from UBC School\n               of Medicine who are joining us in the gallery today. These are students who are members of a political advocacy committee. They're here\n               in the Legislature to raise awareness about the health and well-being of migrant farmworkers,\n               people who play a vital role in B.C.'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Leasing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036094","label":"Leasing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eb784560c8a9a6f29fdb134f25a1118de80959bb83bdf7b6c3604b1ea0ecda13","0f959a8d20e6af572ead44e1f37b990f90584fff75949a1261faa20dbc823bd3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae8e14c9c825830396d4e045626a3cd1a80bbcb572036710dd0fe9438d1824f5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05b9e970bda36605933a7101","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360870,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for her question. Stable, predictable access to maternity\n               services is something that every pregnant person in this province expects and deserves.\n               That's why, together with the health authorities, we are working hard to do just that.\n               It's very challenging in the global setting of workforce challenges, and challenges\n               in maternity services and with physicians, to have been able to keep those stable\n               services at certain sites. That's why the responsible thing for the health authority to do, after exhausting\n               every option that they have to fill gaps in staffing, is to work directly with pregnant\n               patients to make sure that they have a safe place to deliver their babies, because\n               the safety of the mom and the baby is the paramount responsibility of the health authority,\n               with the Ministry of Health standing at their back to do this. Fraser Health is working hard. They are aggressively recruiting new physicians. They've\n               got six new physicians joining maternity teams across the health authority. There's\n               a new physician joining this spring at Peace Arch Hospital. We are not going to stop\n               in our work to provide these stable, predictable services across the province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360870","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for her question. Stable, predictable access to maternity\n               services is something that every pregnant person in this province expects and deserves.\n               That's why, together with the health authorities, we are working hard to do just that.\n               It's very challenging in the global setting of workforce challenges, and challenges\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Security investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083657","label":"Security investigations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d67fb0b9496ed1b4be006cdc751b9895d2925d4b74966abe5ff500b3055f3cd9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d67131f4722123338d9c9cb5264a8f8ca63132c7603581e3744070b18316edd9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-19f7d19e7a1df4a214fc9d96","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415796,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question and for the continued conversation that I've\n               been able to have with her in her role as a critic around what is truly one of the\n               hardest crises this province has ever faced around the toxic drugs and the increasing\n               contamination of that drug supply, and our government's efforts. I would like to thank every member in this House, the efforts of every member in this\n               House, to do everything that we can to separate people from that drug supply, to be\n               able to enforce and come down on the people who peddle these drugs, and to build out\n               a continuum of care so that people get access to the help and the supports that they\n               need. That is what this government has been focused on. That's why we undertook the\n               pilot project around decriminalization. As members in this House know, and as we've\n               talked about, it didn't result in what we had hoped for. What we know that needs to be done is to continue to increase those supports for people,\n               ensure that they get access through Access Central, through the growing Road to Recovery\n               that is coming out across the province. The member was just in her riding, in fact, announcing a new detox withdrawal management\n               facility in Terrace, something desperately needed in the North. This government is\n               going to stay focused on those supports, on access to treatment and recovery, the\n               work that needs to be done to save lives.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415796","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question and for the continued conversation that I've\n               been able to have with her in her role as a critic around what is truly one of the\n               hardest crises this province has ever faced around the toxic drugs and the increasing\n               contamination of that drug supply, and our government's efforts. I would like to thank every member ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["42de48357494fbab43f96575339d542edd0b23350d309009f65fb55226441dfa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["862bf7c7a105c1047e47d58e06f3850c477e0d7085f65b3a678c84ba2cf9e97b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a637cfecf056fd8bec9ef3e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415797,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery today are representatives from the B.C. Psychological Association.\n               Dr. Erica Horwitz is president of the association and a registered psychologist with\n               more than 30 years of experience. She is joined by Laura Darch, the association's\n               executive director. Founded in 1938, the BCPA represents registered psychologists across British Columbia\n               working to advance professional standards, public education and access to psychological\n               services. I am really looking forward to meeting with them later today and would ask the House\n               to please join me in welcoming them to the gallery today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415797","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery today are representatives from the B.C. Psychological Association.\n               Dr. Erica Horwitz is president of the association and a registered psychologist with\n               more than 30 years of experience. She is joined by Laura Darch, the association's\n               executive director. Founded in 1938, the BCPA represents registered psychologists across Britis","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Civil aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Aviation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Aviation industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083604","label":"Civil aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501202","label":"Aviation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752552","label":"Aviation industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8813471c2c6b54a3b3353fbad7f611c9e1e71f48248d9762e65ed9e4f3e24e40","65022299cdc5470a8dede08eb40174209d1c021ad6474057b761f8108705c295","0430bb59ccfd6a99d05fbc33792c1035a52aab5d8e76c5b11ea898a6c882a098","007e90262806ebb121873240bbd535006573a02840720f3d0c5ade3228186830"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.12,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7375e8924f8410ef558e50156f25521cb23e6f484a427daec5068c12164eeeda"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-654cfe1321d9e2d9b029c82e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415798,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"First of all, any claim that the Health Professions and Occupations Act is going to\n               make health professionals leave the province is unfounded. It is simply untrue. The\n               Health Professions and Occupations Act is about strengthening and protecting patient\n               safety and the public interest. We put our confidence and trust in health care The Health Professions and Occupations Act is about strengthening and protecting patient\n               safety and the public interest. We put our confidence and trust in health care professionals,\n               and we need to ensure that the transparency and accountability is there in regulating\n               health professionals that deliver these critical care services to us. Regulatory bodies are there to protect the public, not to protect the profession.\n               That is why, for the first time in 30 years, after years of work, after reviews that\n               showed that the regulatory framework needed to be strengthened, we have taken the\n               steps to modernize this framework. Today is the first day that this new framework comes into force. The new health regulatory\n               colleges are stood up. Their board members are appointed through a merit-based process.\n               They are ready to take the work forward to ensure that that transparency and accountability\n               is there for the trust in their health professions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415798","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"First of all, any claim that the Health Professions and Occupations Act is going to\n               make health professionals leave the province is unfounded. It is simply untrue. The\n               Health Professions and Occupations Act is about strengthening and protecting patient\n               safety and the public interest. We put our confidence and trust in health care The Health Professions ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037046","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientific equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Websites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management information systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Bioethics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012796","label":"Bioethics","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","label":"Colleges","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036176","label":"Management information systems","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037046","label":"Scientific equipment","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037623","label":"Websites","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dbb26e8b947f160aa3852b6daee4c8a8618a6be153ce911e407fcb83e4c6ad86","84232494f8d13dd8af665920c62df17d4884ff7f8664c85e05ca65c7444c2072","f8a7262447b917c836c680b169c76526bae956f863566467a7633018b5b155ca"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55552e466c54fc7f9e61785e9508e9895d28aa3d2647ebb6166c5bc241ed8eff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Colleges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034541","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-952446b71d8d22694da77189","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415799,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Again, data is a very critical component to understanding how government policies\n               and services are affecting people. And Dr. Somers was contracted by government to undertake research. The data from his research have been transferred into a government database where\n               they are available for academics and for other researchers to access. I stand by the statements that I made yesterday and that the data are in the hands\n               of government and available for those academics, researchers and government staff\n               — again, a very important component to evaluating programs to being able to make informed\n               decisions moving forward.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415799","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Again, data is a very critical component to understanding how government policies\n               and services are affecting people. And Dr. Somers was contracted by government to undertake research. The data from his research have been transferred into a government database where\n               they are available for academics and for other researchers to access. I stand by the statements that I m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Transfer payments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Transborder data flow","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036414","label":"Transfer payments","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037399","label":"Transborder data flow","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c4c5f7f14070b2baeda6111f7e3f80b38e06f6996c1e1922f6b69aeacaa07391","19532631e7bba3028522d4696e7e3d05278bf0c7981796b393551fe642995bcb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ef46fb270b034bb44a736697e503eaedd4439e9e73787fc836f9fd7c83391f8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d5cfadf1657c0bdb02ef148","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415800,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I call second reading on Bill 14.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415800","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I call second reading on Bill 14.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0c83e0d63e81ab12b1597eb5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720475,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to respond to the question of privilege that was raised by the member for\n               Skeena. The raising of a question of privilege and the finding of a prima facie breach of\n               the individual and collective rights of this place is the most serious undertaking\n               that you must consider. Mr. Speaker, I ask that you provide me with a little bit of\n               latitude to outline the two elements in my reply for your consideration. The issue at hand is regarding Dr. Somers and previous Speakers' rulings around the\n               form and completeness of engaging in Standing Order 26. Regarding Dr. Somers's research\n               data, since 2005, the Inter-Ministry Evaluation Database, or IMED, was an integrated\n               dataset consisting of governance from a multi-ministry steering committee of B.C.\n               citizen data that was housed at Simon Fraser University and shared with Julian Somers. In March 2021, following months of discussion and in alignment with the expiry of\n               IMED information-sharing agreements and with the Freedom of Information and Protection\n               of Privacy Act section 33(h), the data was transitioned to the province's new data\n               innovation program. This action was taken to ensure appropriate stewardship and because\n               it is standard practice with all research agreements that provide access to and the\n               use of B.C. Any published findings produced with this data and any data Dr. Sommers personally\n               collected were not impacted by this order, and they remain in Dr. Sommers' possession.\n               The principal effect of the transition is governance-related. Dr. Sommers is no longer\n               the sole custodian of the data, consistent with public sector data stewardship and\n               equitable access principles. To be clear, the data continues to exist. The request was for Dr. Sommers to transition\n               the data to the DIP and to destroy his copy of this data housed within the IMED, consistent\n               with general practices around provincial data on B.C. residents at the end of a research\n               project. As I stated in the House, the data set continues to exist in the data innovation program\n               and is now, in fact, accessible to other researchers. It is being used by researchers\n               both inside and outside government to this day. Now, regarding the procedures around a question of privilege, I believe that I've\n               addressed the concerns the member for Skeena raised in an effort of being transparent\n               and open and not by engaging in debate. However, I would be remiss to not address the procedure for raising a question of\n               privilege under Standing Order 26. Parliamentary Practice in B.C., fifth edition, lays out the procedure and essential elements of raising a question\n               of privilege in chapter 17, pages 399 and 400. And I quote: In addition, Parliamentary Practice in B.C. continues on page 400: \"If a question of privilege...involves another Member or includes an allegation of another Member, that Member should be present when the question is raised,\" as found in the B.C. Journals, June 26, 1991, p. 62. Further, Mr. Speaker, Parliamentary Practice in B.C. , 17.8.4 on page 404....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720475","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to respond to the question of privilege that was raised by the member for\n               Skeena. The raising of a question of privilege and the finding of a prima facie breach of\n               the individual and collective rights of this place is the most serious undertaking\n               that you must consider. Mr. Speaker, I ask that you provide me with a little bit of\n               la","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6963200f66def5c8e683d5ee60702683352f58f97907a99a7ac9aed8cadfa43a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3f93030d88b9d703300907cc32232ae7caa00de9fdf7dc9ee7accf22e5d7bebd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0ce8c9e23ddd4f238187c22d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720480,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery joining us are representatives of the Hospital Employees Union.\n               We have Betty Valenzuela, financial secretary, and Barb Nederpel, president, along\n               with many other hard-working and very valued health care workers who are members of\n               the executive of the HEU. Today they boast more than 60,000 members, all of whom are absolutely essential to\n               delivering quality care to people, to patients here in British Columbia. For more\n               than 80 years, HEU members have been working hard to speak out in favour of our equitable\n               public health care system and the favourable working conditions for the people who\n               serve British Columbians each and every day. I'd ask the House to please join me in welcoming our guests in the gallery with a\n               warm round of applause.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720480","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today in the gallery joining us are representatives of the Hospital Employees Union.\n               We have Betty Valenzuela, financial secretary, and Barb Nederpel, president, along\n               with many other hard-working and very valued health care workers who are members of\n               the executive of the HEU. Today they boast more than 60,000 members, all of whom are absolutely essenti","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083631","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Survival","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Death","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Narcotics","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034782","label":"Death","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036187","label":"Narcotics","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083631","label":"Survival","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cfb39143c1ac152793dab653b3cc392d75c6596d4e3ad1c1fe4fc1efb465225c","0e45a04f92b4537e4fdf59828e7045035a40f601654226f08d6f85f5b9c2d288","839d23400309f42b165f6868dc54ccdff37093f73497ef35e000d6f4e86d15fd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fda8711d71b37de3da3b076306c7861d61c1fabb0d7311233bffc5d68a545c0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b330acaf35abbdcbf13f48b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720485,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery, we have two representatives from the Gastrointestinal Society\n               here today to meet MLAs. Joining us are CEO, Gail Attara, and health policy and outreach\n               manager, Jayme Maaghop. The G.I. Society supports people in B.C. who are living with digestive and liver diseases,\n               through evidence-based education, advocacy and collaboration with their health care\n               system. You can learn more about them at badgut.org The G.I. Society supports people in B.C. who are living with digestive and liver diseases\n               through evidence-based education, advocacy and collaboration with their health care\n               system. You can learn more about them at badgut.org. Would the House please help me make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720485","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today in the gallery, we have two representatives from the Gastrointestinal Society\n               here today to meet MLAs. Joining us are CEO, Gail Attara, and health policy and outreach\n               manager, Jayme Maaghop. The G.I. Society supports people in B.C. who are living with digestive and liver diseases,\n               through evidence-based education, advocacy and collaboration with t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7f780c1177e7f7f9d7946ee91dbd49fe3f7daf6544e3d10ecae763eae3cbfc7a","58b4ad1803310a2ebbc8688015d5c5649d3450b52a6e9f2ac48a994f9899dc62"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["409b1c4d81db3c2011ef2cdd42e608cb5ee7fc2512c2c6e2556826dc15fabd37"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-25a378fecd6e31b14f3c9fbc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721587,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure to welcome today in the gallery, representatives from the Kidney\n               Foundation of Canada, who many of us had the pleasure of joining earlier for breakfast. Today we have Dr. John Gill, a transplant nephrologist at St. Paul's Hospital. We\n               have Deborah Tucker, Kate Chong","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721587","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's my pleasure to welcome today in the gallery, representatives from the Kidney\n               Foundation of Canada, who many of us had the pleasure of joining earlier for breakfast. Today we have Dr. John Gill, a transplant nephrologist at St. Paul's Hospital. We\n               have Deborah Tucker, Kate Chong","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.81,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["47ec1412bbdca5b76bee0e6594873fecc4020aabe3c4793367f379cd565b24a6","3581684abcc63beefe90e249f3157d4c7804a91cec0f2a0bcfefd67ef6ec7423"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c191c6a63377ad7b2a2846c600eea0fc16c554ac0e1e38de7a7115c63b8c379"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e84ac495dcd13faf4c30ff7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721599,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question. It's been an extraordinary and somewhat\n               unique relationship on the Saanich Peninsula between the health care foundation, primary\n               care providers and the primary care network, working together to ensure that community\n               physicians are able to fill shifts at the Saanich Peninsula Hospital, an important\n               part of delivering care, particularly for those people who are not attached to a primary\n               care provider but still need that care while in the hospital. The Saanich Peninsula Hospital and Health Care Foundation has taken an independent\n               decision to focus their efforts on recruitment and retention, which we all know is\n               equally important. The society at Shoreline, where a number of these primary care\n               providers have been providing this doctor-of-the-day service at San Pen Hospital,\n               have been filling those positions. Island Health is in direct contact with the society and monitoring this, really valuing\n               the work that doctors continue to do to support the hospital. Of course the ministry\n               stands ready to support and serve should we be called upon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721599","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question. It's been an extraordinary and somewhat\n               unique relationship on the Saanich Peninsula between the health care foundation, primary\n               care providers and the primary care network, working together to ensure that community\n               physicians are able to fill shifts at the Saanich Peninsula Hospital, an important\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disadvantaged persons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034853","label":"Disadvantaged persons","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.27,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31f5327271104209ffc997de37263b016efc64ffff03dc2e94415847b464a3bc","cf19936bdd3fadd62c27dfed174e44a4b0bc1b74aadc7906d1ea75c41e7d0d00"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9289177a3c364d859a0517f9d1ae64134c5011814a833355257e37d639b34a92"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-21cdee77de386bf1f577951d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721600,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Now.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721600","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Now.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a0ca91776444804e810efe39","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721608,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question and highlighting the incredible role that\n               Ronald McDonald House has played supporting families, particularly those of sick children\n               who find themselves in the situation of having to come to Vancouver or the Lower Mainland\n               to receive the specialized care that they need. The services that Ronald McDonald provides are phenomenal. We know that they have\n               intentions to expand and they have work underway. It's important to continue to provide\n               that support for families, continue to work with Ronald McDonald House. I really value\n               the long-standing partnership that we have had with them. I think everybody understands I really value the long-standing partnership that we have had with them. I think everybody\n               understands, currently, the province is under some financial constraints, and we do\n               consider every proposal that comes forward to us. I continue to maintain that relationship\n               with Ronald McDonald House, continue to work with Ronald McDonald House to understand\n               the project and the approaches that they're taking to it, and I'll continue to extend\n               that commitment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721608","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question and highlighting the incredible role that\n               Ronald McDonald House has played supporting families, particularly those of sick children\n               who find themselves in the situation of having to come to Vancouver or the Lower Mainland\n               to receive the specialized care that they need. The services that Ronald McDonald provides a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","label":"Medical products","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["81360ab22acef11ba3f6430c460d4e6be89a1a4477bc0944c054cfa1d17a0667","655df8d0fdf12bc67eae6cf8d08fe7b7c4659d88b7999ebd49c6f40a23370c2f","fe12a73e305a243df66c84ea8db6747e2adda5ca36a903cf85e4d8516e3b995a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fcceb9b3e5ebf930a96019c3707f6ad25997d147e25c356be9241b9c6b30fed9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3c871b8a84e32d1930302d8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729367,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much, Chair. I'll just keep it very simple. I want to introduce the team that I have with me today.\n               I have Cynthia Johanson, deputy minister of the Ministry of Health. Rob Byers, who\n               is acting associate deputy minister in the ministry. Behind me I have Karina Sangha,\n               who is the acting assistant deputy minister for corporate services and executive financial\n               officer, and Ross Hayward, the assistant deputy minister for substance use, treatment\n               and recovery.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729367","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much, Chair. I'll just keep it very simple. I want to introduce the team that I have with me today.\n               I have Cynthia Johanson, deputy minister of the Ministry of Health. Rob Byers, who\n               is acting associate deputy minister in the ministry. Behind me I have Karina Sangha,\n               who is the acting assistant deputy minister for corporate services and e","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Part-time employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036598","label":"Part-time employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720460","label":"Addiction","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["781fb3cb7f493de33aba8008967ccba6c64a125d76245ab5d6ebc7844a091993","4a12cd500dd6a2c74b04b868132e6232584c0863fd95a4eda770552fb495e626","5100e61087720a74ccfc76061a9a765c41615fc9374447383019cee08c5a91f9","21591efc7517c5a839a41d3246fa18bb72657b3ed3c66c000b590b28562b451b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8e312e86a159d9e26a90bc8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729369,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question. There's no doubt that the Mental Health Act, as an older piece of legislation, needs\n               significant reform, and the member outlines many of the reasons why. That's why we've\n               made the commitment to do that work with a review of the Mental Health Act. The work is underway in the ministry right now to determine the scope and the terms\n               of reference, as the member talks about, while we wait for the results of the Charter\n               challenge. It's very important that as this work progresses, we want to incorporate\n               the voices that need to be at this table — people with lived and living experience,\n               people who work with families, Indigenous voices. That is all part of it, and when\n               the work is ready to be announced, of course we will do just that. In the meantime, though, we haven't waited to make some important changes to the Mental\n               Health Act, one of them being the provision of Independent Rights Advice Service for\n               people who are detained under the Mental Health Act. That's an important modernization\n               of it, providing people with the opportunity to provide that independent legal advice\n               that they need and deserve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729369","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question. There's no doubt that the Mental Health Act, as an older piece of legislation, needs\n               significant reform, and the member outlines many of the reasons why. That's why we've\n               made the commitment to do that work with a review of the Mental Health Act. The work is underway in the ministry right now to determine the scope and the ter","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Therapy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pharmaceutical industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Federal contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035226","label":"Federal contracts","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","label":"Research institutes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43643","label":"Pharmaceutical industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:60161","label":"Therapy","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d20b1767ede751aa32b5fc1c8b73866fd76b41b2762d42272fdce7aaa66765ac","5033777c25ed9802c4e3cc7d44f1a57c0ed5d9ef1559a25c5b74442d1b28db7c","8caeaf3bbd7c07121debeb237368989a101ee2e40ad665896cc11fea454c08a3","fab9439a9d9b0ec82f353c4f59bb2426d093c27ff259afe58a7553e29ff8fff2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a399e5189b2a3d1f4cbf8e7b6ad7fcb0ab6af5a7155cd89291c89d70a6a952d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-90f66fd18c819b83e6f1fed9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729372,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's going to take a few moments to get that information, so I just wanted to give\n               the member an opportunity to ask another question if she wishes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729372","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's going to take a few moments to get that information, so I just wanted to give\n               the member an opportunity to ask another question if she wishes.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rehabilitation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Telephones","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Surveys","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752353","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Automation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Advertising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47326","label":"Advertising","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:56022","label":"Surveys","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718703","label":"Rehabilitation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752353","label":"Automation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76451","label":"Telephones","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:863","label":"Immigration","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92d1650e42098bb23bf99183a5870cde3f5db0202fabb049d6f76d59dd030f3e","e2cc9a2f2ea7878c3f4b88f89a6ef897c773d9532782b5f266bd76a18c4a849f","75683247acb5415b0c6721ccaf6f6838aad395b0ef497ae61f46c74d772e3d37","7f4976c5aa0fb1cda25cc8792731f3d1d769232622c58fb47912e6f29eb4dafa","fcf9dc412c73ce7ab3de72442be8c19d1db78bf3c1fd5634447e3ccb3de5dda6","5cd4a9083e24ee640480757f5e88fc49082193fc74d11e6cf7b310d2534eb47a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc873f2e0a12bf423ed0ce17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729382,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I may have misheard the question. My apologies for that. So 7,829 clients were wait-listed —sorry, just let me check the date, here —as of Q2, '25-26.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729382","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I may have misheard the question. My apologies for that. So 7,829 clients were wait-listed —sorry, just let me check the date, here —as of Q2, '25-26.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Hospitality industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Salaries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035707","label":"Hospitality industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44212","label":"Poverty","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44259","label":"Rural communities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715126","label":"Salaries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9af46a8a1873caf3a3a02cf61528601da58b222a03dee644e035726c6182b424","eec68d0abf14ffdc2d456361193a603ec95f1e5b2a6fcd541d120e12fa6751b7","36321ffe896c2a0664082ab55c080b50dae039f2d8053b94e9511ff8697f17f2","803a69acc1fc15b0681185264e23b143ef940385d147696eaa1e03f3d33c2ab0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8bae2f6563854263bf40e6e4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729386,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question. I certainly will be the first to acknowledge that there are pressures throughout the\n               health care system that have resulted in decisions where hallways and other spaces\n               in hospitals are being used to deliver the care that British Columbians depend on. Looking at the flow and access in hospitals and doing everything we can to move people\n               quickly out of emergency, to move people Looking at the flow and access in hospitals and doing everything we can to move people\n               quickly out of emergency, to move people appropriately from acute care beds into other\n               settings, is a focus of Interior Health and, indeed, all health authorities across the system. We are working to reduce the pressure on emergency rooms by adding staff, by providing\n               alternative pathways for people to reach care through UPCCs, for example, by encouraging\n               people to be able to access other forms of care, like expanded scope of practice in\n               pharmacy, as well as doing everything we can to build the primary care workforce to\n               do the things that keep people out of emergency rooms, that help keep people out of\n               hospitals. We're going to continue with the investments that we are making through the Ministry of Infrastructure into health care facilities across British Columbia to continue to reduce that pressure,\n               reduce the need for hallway medicine, and make sure that British Columbians get the\n               care that they need.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729386","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question. I certainly will be the first to acknowledge that there are pressures throughout the\n               health care system that have resulted in decisions where hallways and other spaces\n               in hospitals are being used to deliver the care that British Columbians depend on. Looking at the flow and access in hospitals and doing everything we can to mo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Medical products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","label":"Construction materials","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036244","label":"Medical products","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["55aa70ad0c7aa629d867dab79351dda3eea6f616e9c2a3aaac61ab1309977a12","a3e7a9695b9814f5e69dcd337cb2b2c6bcba93bdd38115c18ca4716c28137697","9c28d08515ad1782c10f5e005201c480d6da5c5c4175387c5562a00a9132ca02","9662a2684326cd4781895e57b9fab9f0e45926c2124bdec125ab59e72c01a89a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f752300f6f0d0a9e049b8978b0eb92e0eb0d8eaf9db84995c1669a38b267bd44"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c7de2efe8cb029137f055e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729393,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"To address this question around panel size of physicians under different payment models,\n               I'm going to start off just to recap a little bit of what I talked about earlier around\n               the longitudinal family physician payment model, the model that we brought in three\n               years ago in collaboration with the Doctors of B.C. and B.C. Family Doctors, again,\n               recognizing that this model.... It recognizes that there is a complexity of patients in a panel in long-term patient\n               care, that the model compensates family doctors for their time that is not direct\n               patient care but is still part of the work that they have to do. And it accounts for\n               the complexity of their panel as well as their panel size and the number of interactions\n               they have with patients in their practice. The longitudinal family physician model. The expectation for a panel of average complexity\n               is 1,250 patients, but it bears noting that there are different situations where that\n               panel size can be smaller. For example, for family physicians working in rural areas\n               who are also doing shifts in the emergency department of the local hospital, their\n               panel size may be adjusted downwards to be smaller to reflect that other commitment\n               to the type of work and settings that they're working in. For example, it might be\n               1,000 or it might be 800. Further, a family physician working in a community health clinic serving more vulnerable\n               populations typically of higher complexity or very specialized needs — those panels\n               can be even less. So being able to serve 800 patients, for example, or 600 patients\n               is not abnormal. I say all of this just to provide context for what I can talk about with the longitudinal\n               family physician model. We currently have 3,497 family physicians on right now. The\n               average panel size, actually as of today, is 1,026. I do not have the median, so I'm\n               just going to be reporting means or averages. There are physicians in different payment models — for example, contracted physicians,\n               of which there are 311, and their average panel size is 776. Again, just taking into account while there isn't.... I don't have a number to report\n               strictly for fee-for-service. One of the reasons why the longitudinal family physician\n               payment model has been so helpful for government is we actually So again, just taking into account while there isn't.... I don't have a number to report\n               strictly for fee-for-service. One of the reasons why the longitudinal family physician\n               payment model has been so helpful for government is we actually, for the first time,\n               do have direct insight into the panel size of family physicians. That, together with\n               the provincial attachment system that I have been speaking about, provides us with\n               that enumeration, so that we know which patient is attached to which provider and\n               that panel size is very helpful information to be able to have. We know, too, that attachment and panel size is not everything, and the member has\n               also acknowledged that access is very important, and so knowing that patients can\n               visit a place where primary care is delivered. So I want to take a moment just to\n               talk about some of the progress that's being made in different settings where primary\n               care is delivered and the increased number of visits that we are seeing. For example, in urgent and primary care centres year over year from fiscal '25-26\n               compared to fiscal '24-25, we've seen a 21 percent increase in visits. In community\n               health centres, we've seen a 46 percent increase in visits. In family practice settings,\n               we've seen a 2 percent increase in visits. In pharmacy settings, for minor ailments\n               and contraception services, we've seen an increase of 1.4 percent over the same, comparing\n               '25-26 to '24-25. Again, that tells a story of access for patients who are in a UPCC, for example, getting\n               that same-day primary care service for urgent and non-life threatening illnesses or\n               injuries, and for attached and unattached through community health centres, access\n               to both longitudinal and episodic primary care service with a focus really on reaching\n               those priority populations in a community. In addition, First Nations primary care centres, which are stood up to meet the needs\n               in a particular way for the Indigenous patients that they serve, blending both Western\n               and traditional approaches. Nurse practitioner-led primary care centres, again offering a nurse practitioner-led\n               model of care. Patient medical homes, which are sometimes referred to as family practice, supporting\n               the team-based care. I do want to pause on team-based care again, too, to note that\n               the interaction between panel size of a primary care provider and access that the\n               patient has to primary care services and visits that a patient makes to the family\n               physician, noting that in a team-based setting, a patient can come in and receive\n               care from any one of a number of members of the team that may actually not include\n               the family physician that day. So despite the fact they are on the panel, they aren't making a visit to that family\n               physician, but they are still receiving very valuable primary care. The member also asked about how many more family physicians, therefore, we need. The math in this.... If we look at the attachment rate of people in British Columbia\n               to a primary care provider, we need to make some assumptions for the number or percentage\n               of people who are not seeking a primary care provider at this time, and then we'd\n               have to take into account this complexity of different panel sizes depending on the\n               patient population and the type of care or the type of attachment that they have —\n               community health centre versus a family practice, for example, or First Nations primary\n               care centre. So it's not possible to take the variability and that complexity and come up with\n               a simple answer to say: \"This is how many more family physicians we need.\" I think\n               it's fair to say, however, we need more family physicians. We know that. We want every\n               single person in British Columbia that wants a family physician or nurse practitioner\n               for that longitudinal primary care to have one. That's why there has been so much work focused on increasing the number of family\n               physicians and nurse practitioners here in British Columbia, expanding medical school\n               at UBC, building a new medical school at SFU in Surrey, and the work to streamline\n               credentials and make it easier to attract internationally trained or internationally\n               based physicians and nurse practitioners to move to British Columbia, again, to provide\n               that opportunity for British Columbians to seek attachment. In addition to that, with the evolution of In addition to that, with the evolution of team-based care, providing the type of\n               care that people are looking for in a way where they have access to a physician who\n               has a greater ability to focus on their scope of practice and the particular expertise\n               that they have and for that patient to be able to access the expertise or scope of\n               practice of other providers in that health care team.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729393","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"To address this question around panel size of physicians under different payment models,\n               I'm going to start off just to recap a little bit of what I talked about earlier around\n               the longitudinal family physician payment model, the model that we brought in three\n               years ago in collaboration with the Doctors of B.C. and B.C. Family Doctors, again,\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","label":"Medicine"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgery","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Surgeons","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Natural resources","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coastal waters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Screening (Medicine)","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012678","label":"Natural resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034923","label":"Drug use","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037054","label":"Screening (Medicine)","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037260","label":"Surgeons","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083628","label":"Coastal waters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","label":"Medicine","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725195","label":"Surgery","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["48a5212a941fafe74ac030cdd4818702e6e2813d4b3986bda655058ad1e6df9b","d928206e9135d4f775f5df362662798dd5c8c88af37f61df31b547fa736d6223","884221d18827aa5a655b6334ede3e58ba972676862cd5a726b88042757443f09","79a99d2a18367defc9c9e1e79471520bd2c32592363ccf31d481655835b019f2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["51f0b02773a52c6f3978831a1eeda0af0053097af2c3e72ba1e9cc8690db250a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medicine","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:265433","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-693b0b5a82cca24df138ae27","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752312,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"We have two special guests joining us in the gallery today from the Canadian Mental\n               Health Association, B.C. chapter. Kim Mackenzie is CMHA's senior director of policy\n               and systems transformation, and Jonny Morris is the CEO. Both of these incredible\n               human beings have spent the entirety of their careers in service of others and, together\n               with their teams, developed groundbreaking programs like community-led crisis response\n               teams, which are changing the way we respond to mental health crises in our communities\n               with a more compassionate and effective approach. Would the House please join me in making Kim and Jonny most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752312","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We have two special guests joining us in the gallery today from the Canadian Mental\n               Health Association, B.C. chapter. Kim Mackenzie is CMHA's senior director of policy\n               and systems transformation, and Jonny Morris is the CEO. Both of these incredible\n               human beings have spent the entirety of their careers in service of others and, together\n               w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98da50bdb132f314b4f123eb68aab04a78f4a3c69de46f102c1d3054eaff5c81"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ba26d9a773463898319739ed01cf27c546153fe575799e0e01e751e7fae396d0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-50fcf85a020b99e6fe7659a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752313,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Behind every minister's office is a team of very hardworking people from government\n               communications and public engagement. They help us with media, with public affairs\n               and with really reviewing the issues of the day and the issues, in my case, in health\n               care throughout British Columbia. They are incredibly dedicated public servants who\n               care deeply about the health of British Columbians and our health care system. Today they've joined me here in the Legislature to understand a little bit more about\n               how this place works, to witness question period, many of them for the very first\n               time. They're here in the gallery, and they are under the very able direction of our\n               communications director Crystal Thompson. Would the House please join me in making them all feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752313","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Behind every minister's office is a team of very hardworking people from government\n               communications and public engagement. They help us with media, with public affairs\n               and with really reviewing the issues of the day and the issues, in my case, in health\n               care throughout British Columbia. They are incredibly dedicated public servants who\n               car","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1749970c71a82a90529595d608fa5c25ed498987a47f785311b78facb829e7cd","028972477dce30447f7eba196e7352980f9b249aaa9cd1fe5c1834001d4c62f8","622ce2c216eb60a607029faa58aabdbc147162ee88c8c9e18839059a8d31d333"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4dc3f2f8e38cd1aba4767d480e5d55532f727a698ba91cc3427bb5934ee8ad2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f67c94969cbdf422bbdce5ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752314,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to introduce some friends who are joining us today in the gallery from\n               the Heart and Stroke Foundation. They just hosted many of us for lunch, and to have\n               a discussion about women's heart and brain health. We learned that heart disease and\n               stroke are the leading cause of premature death in women, and that historically, two-thirds\n               of clinical research has focused on men. We also learned of the Heart and Stroke's new screening tool that targets key risks\n               that are unique to women and the foundation's investment of $20 million over five\n               years to fund research that's focused on women's heart and brain health. Would the House please join me in welcoming Would the House please join me in welcoming Robyn Jones-Merrell, Mary Stambulic and\n               Rebecca Ponting from the Heart and Stroke Foundation, along with Dr. Jennifer Yao\n               from UBC and an extra-warm welcome for Lily Law, who shared with us so openly about\n               the journey that she has been on.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752314","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm pleased to introduce some friends who are joining us today in the gallery from\n               the Heart and Stroke Foundation. They just hosted many of us for lunch, and to have\n               a discussion about women's heart and brain health. We learned that heart disease and\n               stroke are the leading cause of premature death in women, and that historically, two-thirds\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","label":"Cardiovascular diseases"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Family businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child poverty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","label":"Cardiovascular diseases","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083645","label":"Family businesses","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:53161","label":"Child poverty","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b15e3b4e46ada37ad2773b1533f68c98316dbf66b4093068b94b918b5bbb3c3d","344598fc4ce2417c41a8854864bd09e6779e931d91cb6f9f9924a6d1b4d4e5e0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.2,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["768e39fe527a2aef6c1d08814dd15ab617a842b682c454304ffa76d77c723895"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5b53deb6e3371be68ce34605","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752315,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am honoured today to introduce the B.C. Radiological Society to the House. They\n               are a non-profit professional association that represents radiologists across British\n               Columbia. They are committed to advancing patient-centred medical imaging by advocating\n               for timely, high-quality and equitable access to care for all British Columbians,\n               and that includes rural, remote and Indigenous communities where equitable access\n               remains a critical priority. We have, I think, about 15 members in the House. I'm not going to introduce everybody,\n               but would everybody please join me in making them feel most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752315","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am honoured today to introduce the B.C. Radiological Society to the House. They\n               are a non-profit professional association that represents radiologists across British\n               Columbia. They are committed to advancing patient-centred medical imaging by advocating\n               for timely, high-quality and equitable access to care for all British Columbians,\n               an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nongovernmental organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036420","label":"Nongovernmental organizations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["805ccd23dfbd417c7cd3a5ae71b1b387ee1daccf679b0a520da8c635e568e81c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["84b7168fac7d91fb4f6efe731059883b3c4b7f0298842adf7f9e243904eb83a5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aab554394f75d4946e00ad7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017517,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today is B.C. Family Doctor Day, and it is World Family Doctor Day. We are so privileged\n               to have the B.C. College of Family Physicians join us in the gallery today. Dr. Jennifer\n               Lush is the president. Kendra Johnston is the executive director. They've brought\n               a team of staff and family doctors from around British Columbia to talk with us as\n               MLAs. I deeply appreciate their work in strengthening our public health care system. I know\n               they'll be meeting with a lot of different MLAs in the House today. Would you all please join me in making them feel most welcome. Would you all please join me in making them feel most welcome?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017517","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today is B.C. Family Doctor Day, and it is World Family Doctor Day. We are so privileged\n               to have the B.C. College of Family Physicians join us in the gallery today. Dr. Jennifer\n               Lush is the president. Kendra Johnston is the executive director. They've brought\n               a team of staff and family doctors from around British Columbia to talk with us as\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f9617aaa06e6e6caeca25267b65977aba34d877c29c86ca4d08cf44799ff0662"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3c96f20275520964a216ce8544f3012cec2ac42cd57632036b2f178dad25cec4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd8522ddb7dbad4ceeee97ba","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036546,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036546","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1ae13aa6a8f46a127590888f925db7dbf56168671d17ba97e7d952df8cd863fb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-72a96156958a467dcb997a68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036547,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to welcome the Gill family to the gallery today, and I'm looking forward to\n               having my own personal opportunity to meet with them later this afternoon. I think we've all been very deeply moved by the journey that the Gill family is undertaking\n               to do something that we know that every parent in British Columbia who has a child\n               suffering from a rare disease or an ultra-rare disease, as is in this case.... It is\n               going to take every effort they possibly can, and we want to be there to support them\n               in every way that we can too. That's why I directed my staff, upon learning about this, to meet with the researcher\n               at McGill University. They have done that to understand the type of infrastructure\n               that is required, the type of research and processes that are required to bring in\n               specific gene editing therapies. We are making remarkable advances in medicine and\n               in research every single day. They provide the promise of hope, but we have to go\n               through the steps in developing this, and that's why the ministry has undertaken that. Further, the officials at the ministry have met with officials in the province of\n               Quebec to understand what kind of interprovincial partnerships are possible in standing\n               up the infrastructure for this very, very specific type of gene editing therapy that\n               is needed. Of course, everybody wants to do everything that is possible to help this young child\n               and provide the promise of hope for other families whose children are suffering from\n               conditions like this. Again, I look forward to meeting with the Gill family and doing\n               everything we can.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036547","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to welcome the Gill family to the gallery today, and I'm looking forward to\n               having my own personal opportunity to meet with them later this afternoon. I think we've all been very deeply moved by the journey that the Gill family is undertaking\n               to do something that we know that every parent in British Columbia who has a child\n               suffering from a rare ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Prescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036424","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Nonprescription drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal provincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035237","label":"Federal provincial relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036424","label":"Nonprescription drugs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43639","label":"Prescription drugs","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","label":"Medical research","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","label":"Interprovincial relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","label":"Medical technology","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["885de1e1cb38495caf492ae16e493ffe3b1db2a3ce31ea971caeda0b87f1570a","9a0931ace0bb6779e7a005a934f1050f5932ac5ead120403b13f3a0ecece6e35"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cad76f11edc97cf7709a20fbe6e864756c1ae479665e863f85c6523cba2d2088"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Interprovincial relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Medical technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43671","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70288","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2739a90b17d891b0b4f8c9ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036548,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question, although I will take issue with the characterization\n               of the conversations that I have had with the member over the past year talking about\n               a really serious issue, which is the use of tobacco by people and the known harmful\n               health effects about that and the policy work that our ministry is undertaking to\n               reduce tobacco use, particularly amongst youth but also amongst people of any age\n               in this province because of those known impacts. I'm committed to continuing to work with the member, hopefully in good faith here,\n               around this conversation. Pharmacies also provide aids for cessation of smoking. An\n               important part of that is the ability for a person to be able to have the contact\n               with a pharmacist and a person in order to be able to have those conversations. Very\n               happy to continue that work with the member.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036548","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question, although I will take issue with the characterization\n               of the conversations that I have had with the member over the past year talking about\n               a really serious issue, which is the use of tobacco by people and the known harmful\n               health effects about that and the policy work that our ministry is undertaking to\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Drug insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tobacco industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034915","label":"Drug insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","label":"Smoking prevention","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","label":"Smoking","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:99353","label":"Tobacco industry","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4a0198c3e8d971c7e1ac32fae4ae8f21bcb6e9de5483e8353fc6c12dbaadc26e","ee17fadf91e371c52c648d7ad5c27fb903921f4410f34a6310bd69d398112d1f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.8,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0b339b4d7e370d9739893220781d70c10484cf583777b79b9694a4b6442dfab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Smoking","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Smoking prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037145","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43633","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-45a29cc06b5be09c8549ad44","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036550,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"I can assure the members' constituents that we will always put the safety of expectant\n               parents and their babies first. That's why in the very challenging situation of health\n               care worker shortages that we have seen, difficult decisions have been made to put\n               that safety as the top priority and ensure that a mom and her baby get the very best\n               care possible. That's why the Health Authority works with expectant mothers and families\n               to ensure that they know where services are available. Fraser Health and other health authorities where these shortages have been experienced\n               are doing everything they can to fill these gaps with locums and with other coverage.\n               I am very happy to report that for Peace Arch Hospital, a new obstetrician is coming.\n               This spring, a job contract has been signed, and that person is coming from the United\n               States of America. We are welcoming that person. We know that that is one step toward stabilizing maternity services for Peace Arch\n               Hospital. In the meantime, we will continue to work with those families to ensure\n               that they get the best care possible at one of the many surrounding hospitals.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036550","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I can assure the members' constituents that we will always put the safety of expectant\n               parents and their babies first. That's why in the very challenging situation of health\n               care worker shortages that we have seen, difficult decisions have been made to put\n               that safety as the top priority and ensure that a mom and her baby get the very best\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Alcoholic beverages","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Women workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037653","label":"Women workers","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42614","label":"Alcoholic beverages","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720695","label":"Alcoholism","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2a55472743887deadf428deb581d80b0e0aad1eaf220652b96a2ea61e7542826","f66e1b80efee2a6560335397758209763d7ae58262482bd96dcf263e433c3bbc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["07b9ffb12cfb6636c82889a0df7a0778e27df311cd89aaf37c00fd15c2bbc2f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9c2c4548b76b70f8d585fd3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036551,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Josie Osborne","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member for the question and really raising the issue that overdose\n               prevention services, safe consumption sites, are a critical part of the continuum\n               of saving lives and connecting people to the care","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036551","member_id":"bc-mla-56","member_name":"Josie Osborne","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to the member for the question and really raising the issue that overdose\n               prevention services, safe consumption sites, are a critical part of the continuum\n               of saving lives and connecting people to the care","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036682","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Poisoning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036682","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Poisoning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Toxic substances","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumer protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Drug education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034653","label":"Consumer protection","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036682","label":"Poisoning","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:195716","label":"Drug education","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44819","label":"Toxic substances","probability":0.56,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["21c1ad619bee9ce049600d6295f79c38ea193ffd4e2c3bcf4be4cf26ab5137b2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf85d06e326eb2350c3309994f388f5b6b143b855931a14101a95f8c3b6aff92"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-aabce3bfad8b863fcff5f0fd","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187107,"date":"2026-03-30T12:00:00+00:00","title":"FORESTS STATUTES AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov14-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov14-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187107","member_id":"bc-mla-58","member_name":"Ravi Parmar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1d0ec3ffdb0bf9e0ab4c24c8","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187108,"date":"2026-03-30T12:00:00+00:00","title":"FORESTS STATUTES AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov14-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov14-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187108","member_id":"bc-mla-58","member_name":"Ravi Parmar","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fccce1d29048ec7ed6f6e91a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317187,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government is cancelling the long-awaited long-term-care project in my riding\n               of Delta, which, by the way, is already in progress. The Beedie long-term care centre\n               is a 200-bed facility that would have provided seniors in Delta with the beds they\n               so desperately needed. The Delta Hospital and Community Health Foundation has done their part by raising\n               $18 million for this project. In 2023, the current Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth\n               said: \"We're making sure seniors in Delta have access to the right care and services\n               in spaces designed for them close to their loved ones.\" Seniors in Delta will no longer\n               be getting the care and services promised to them. Why did government promise this to Delta seniors only to leave them languishing in\n               a 50-year-old facility that sits there now?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317187","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This government is cancelling the long-awaited long-term-care project in my riding\n               of Delta, which, by the way, is already in progress. The Beedie long-term care centre\n               is a 200-bed facility that would have provided seniors in Delta with the beds they\n               so desperately needed. The Delta Hospital and Community Health Foundation has done their part by raisin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56382c66d095377b97f81b8dcae718f5dc347d53aceeeb8cacb2e06b82afc16a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e60a49414f5c0716a5c7a80626989d1e8b7ee3421889303c9fc090342c6a274f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a4c1b15ec1763ebd32334e63","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317188,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the opportunity to get up today and speak to Bill 5, the Trade Recognition\n               Act. I think we've proven it here this afternoon on this side of the House that we're actually\n               in favour of getting moving with recognizing that we have too many trade barriers\n               across the provinces in British Columbia. Rather than throw out grade 5 derogatory\n               comments to the other side of the House about a bill that we actually all are probably\n               going to agree on, it's important we move forward. Taking Bill 7 and making it into Bill 7-lite, as to Bill 5, I think it's time that we move on with getting this done rather\n               than standing here for another term and talking about how we can remove interprovincial\n               trade barriers. As the critic for Agriculture for my party, and as a farmer myself living on our family\n               farm in Delta, I find it extremely important to the agricultural trade business in\n               Canada and British Columbia to move forward with removing barriers to trade for such\n               things as vegetables, fruit, vegetable and fruit packaging, meat, inconsistent meat\n               inspection regulations, the wine industry, moving equipment and farm equipment across\n               provinces in this country, moving livestock and the trucking industry and the regulations\n               about trucking going back and forth between our provinces. Also, safety regulations and weights when it comes to agriculture and to health and\n               safety when it comes to agriculture and livestock.... This is costing Canada $1.7 billion\n               a year in agricultural trade by not being able to open up trade between provinces\n               for agricultural products. Let me begin clearly. The B.C. Conservative caucus supports removing interprovincial\n               trade barriers. We support making it easier for goods and services to move across\n               Canada. We support economic growth, competition Let me begin clearly. The B.C. Conservative caucus supports removing interprovincial\n               trade barriers. We support making it easier for goods and services to move across\n               Canada. We support economic growth, competition and lower costs for British Columbians. Hot off the press, just this morning from the Business in Vancouver article, and I quote: \"B.C. wineries press premiers to allow direct wine sales across\n               our country.\" Christa-Lee McWatters is among B.C. winery executives lobbying to be able to sell\n               wine directly to consumers across Canada. They want provincial governments to remove\n               interprovincial trade barriers and allow direct-to-consumer wine sales from out-of-province\n               wineries. I quote: \"We're always looking for other markets and to be able to increase\n               sales,\" says McWatters, vice-president of Osoyoos' Adega On 45th Winery and Surrey's\n               Gate 22 Winery. To not be able to ship within our own country, really, this is ludicrous. Being able\n               to sell direct-to-consumer wine across the country would enable her wineries to sell\n               more wine and have a larger slice of overall sales, being in the more profitable DTC\n               sales channel. Wine Growers B.C. CEO Jeff Guignard was among wine industry leaders who recently signed\n               a letter to the premiers on January 27 demanding that they act on their commitment\n               to reduce interprovincial trade barriers. This bill is a response to the federal government and all provinces and territories\n               signing a new Canadian mutual recognition agreement designed to break down internal\n               trade barriers so that goods legally sold in one province can be sold in another.\n               The agreement is intended to help businesses market their products across Canada more\n               easily and give Canadians greater access to Canadian-made goods without facing redundant\n               standards or approvals. This all seems reasonable, but when we look closely at Bill 5, B.C.'s response to\n               this larger federal agreement, we still see a lot of protection, provincial red tape,\n               prohibitive tax structures and protection of monopolies that make this bill less effective.\n               Of course, we can't ignore just how long it's taken to get here. This bill requires serious scrutiny to ensure it's actually effective and not just\n               a promise, like last year's Bill 7. Members will remember last year's Economic Stabilization\n               Tariff Response Act, commonly known as Bill 7. Part 1 of that act granted government\n               the authority to create regulations to reduce interprovincial trade barriers. The\n               authority was there. The tools were there. The urgency was declared. Yet, after 12 months, not a single order was issued to reduce trade barriers on goods\n               or services. Not one. It took a year to write 835 words, and now we wait again. A\n               new bill. Heaven knows how long these regulations will take. A year lost. What happened? We were told Bill 7 was urgent. We were told it was action. We were\n               told it was necessary to respond to economic pressures. But it turns out it was political\n               theatre. Now we are told Bill 5 is the real solution, after a year. If this was so urgent last\n               year, why the delay? British Columbians are disappointed that interprovincial trade hasn't happened yet.\n               So let's take a look at the new so-called interprovincial trade bill and see if it's\n               going to get us any closer to being able to enjoy goods and services from across Canada. At its core, Bill 5 establishes a straightforward principle. If a good can be bought,\n               sold or used in another province of Canada, it can be bought, sold or used in British\n               Columbia. If a service can be supplied in another province, it can be supplied here\n               in British Columbia. That is common sense. Canada is one country, and we support that principle. But principles\n               only matter if they are implemented. Implementation requires regulations, which brings\n               me to the central themes of Bill 5 debate, which are delay, red tape and overregulation. Let's look at some of the clauses in the bill to see how these themes play out. Clause\n               2, sale and use of goods. Division 1 of Bill 5 says that a good legally sold or used\n               in another province can be sold or used in British Columbia despite any existing regulatory\n               measure. That sounds strong, but there are two important limits. It's subject to division 2,\n               and it's subject to regulations. Division 2 sets out the exceptions and exclusions,\n               the situations where mutual recognition does not necessarily apply. That includes\n               areas like That sounds strong, but there are two important limits. It's subject to division 2,\n               and it's subject to regulations. Division 2 sets out the exceptions and exclusions,\n               the situations where mutual recognition does not necessarily apply. That includes\n               areas like monopolies, taxation, Indigenous rights and other protected regulatory\n               measures. In other words, even if a product is legal elsewhere, division 2 allows\n               the government to decide that it can't be used here. Division 2, clause 4, post-entry rules. Now let's dig deeper into division 2 part\n               of this bill. Clause 4 preserves regulatory measures about how a good is sold or used,\n               how a service is supplied, who may sell, purchase or use a good, whom a service may\n               be supplied. The breadth of this language matters. If interpreted expansively, it could significantly\n               narrow the automatic recognition promised in clauses 2 and 3. For example, let's talk\n               about something practical — fruits and vegetables. Right now a grower shipping produce\n               across provincial lines can face different packaging and labeling rules in different\n               provinces. That means separate packaging runs, separate inventory, separate compliance\n               costs for fruit and vegetable producers. Those costs are not theoretical. They come\n               straight off the bottom line from a farmer. In principle, Bill 5 should help. If produce is legally packaged and sold in another\n               province, it ought to be sellable here in British Columbia without forcing growers\n               to redesign boxes or reprint labels just to cross a provincial border. But here is the concern. This bill is subject to exclusion. It is subject to post-entry\n               rules, and more importantly, it is subject to future regulations that we don't even\n               know exist yet. If other provinces or B.C. chooses to preserve B.C.-specific packaging\n               requirements under regulation, then nothing changes. Growers will still face duplication,\n               consumers will still pay more, and we have passed a framework without delivering relief. The question is simple. Will this bill truly eliminate unnecessary packaging barriers\n               for our fruit and vegetable producers? Or will they still be waiting for regulations\n               while costs continue to rise? It's a thoughtful consideration to how this will be\n               implemented and the ramifications of post-entry rules that make the difference between\n               symbolism and results for all sectors facing duplicate post-entry ramifications. Clause 5. I want to focus specifically on clause 5, because while it may look technical,\n               its implications are very real for farmers, health care, seniors, businesses and consumers\n               in this province. Clause 5 excludes regulatory measures relating to the maintenance\n               of a monopoly, taxation and incorporation. Each of those words carries weight, and\n               each of them narrows the reach of this bill. Let's begin with taxation. Under this bill, it doesn't say that goods produced in\n               B.C. will have competitive tax advantages to similar products coming from other provinces.\n               Let me provide an agriculture example. The exclusion for taxation means this bill\n               does nothing to address provincial sales tax on critical farm inputs. A B.C. farmer purchasing some equipment or emerging tools like precision agricultural\n               system still pays PST even though competitors in other provinces do not. So you can\n               get an agricultural drone in Alberta, while a B.C. company trying to sell the same\n               drone pays tax. I wonder where people will buy their agricultural products. Likely\n               not in B.C. That cost difference affects competitiveness as well. It affects margins. For many\n               family farms operating on tight budgets, it affects survival. If we are serious about\n               making British Columbia more competitive across Canada, we cannot ignore the taxation\n               carve-out that includes PST sitting right in clause 5. Looking at PST and how it affects B.C. businesses who produce products is a must,\n               or else we just open up our borders to competition without giving our own businesses\n               the same competitive advantages, essentially disadvantaging them in the national economy. Now let's consider monopoly protections. British Columbia maintains monopolies in\n               areas like liquor distribution, cannabis distribution, insurance through ICBC, electricity\n               transmission and distribution through B.C. Hydro and B.C. Ferry Services. Clause 5\n               explicitly protects the maintenance of a monopoly. That means entire sectors can remain\n               closed or tightly controlled despite the rhetoric of open trade. Why does this matter? Because it shows that the government is choosing to preserve\n               its control rather than promote competition. Our B.C. craft breweries, wineries and\n               distillers will all be exempt because this still doesn't allow for direct sales to\n               the consumers in other provinces. Where government decides the monopoly Where government decides a monopoly should remain, this act simply steps aside. That\n               sets a precedent that limits how broadly mutual recognition can apply, leaving entire\n               sectors shielded from the benefits of open trade. And then there are the issues of preserving existing regulatory frameworks. This is\n               why we must scrutinize clause 5 carefully and demand clarity. Who benefits? Who remains\n               excluded? Let's look at things like health care supplies and seniors. We need to look at as\n               if provincial purchasing systems, hospital formularies or seniors care supply frameworks\n               are treated as protected regulatory structures. If they are, then the benefits of\n               mutual recognition may never reach the people who need them most, care homes and seniors\n               who could continue facing higher costs, limited choice and unnecessary red tape under\n               this trade bill. Labour mobility. Clause 9, says this bill doesn't apply where the Labour Mobility\n               Act already governs extraprovincial occupations. So clause 9 essentially says that\n               where these regulated occupation mobility systems already exist, with processes to\n               assess and transfer certification, Bill 5 defers to that model instead of creating\n               a new one within this act. That avoids duplication, sure, but it doesn't guarantee\n               automatic right to work across provinces for professionals. While many skilled trades and professional roles are included, not everyone is, and\n               it relies on a patchwork of existing rules that vary by occupation. This affects people\n               that work as electricians, plumbers, carpenters, welders, engineers, architects, accountants,\n               veterinarians, professional biologists, agrologists, notaries, lawyers, paramedics,\n               nurses, LPNs, etc. All these people still have to navigate B.C.'s separate certification or regulatory\n               processes, even if they're fully qualified elsewhere. They still need to meet B.C.'s\n               professional standards, insurance requirements and other regulatory rules. This clause\n               slows down critical health care staffing, delays construction and infrastructure projects\n               and keeps skilled workers from contributing where they are needed. It's a clause that\n               tells skilled workers to continue to wait. Internal trade barriers cost Canadians billions of dollars every year. Removing them\n               is a good policy. It's common sense, and we support it. But leadership requires urgency.\n               This government had the authority under Bill 7 for a full year and did nothing. Now\n               it presents Bill 5 and asks us to celebrate while implementation still waits on regulations,\n               cabinet discretion and protections for monopolies and taxes that block real competition. In this bill, we must scrutinize the exclusions. We must know what the post-entry\n               rules actually mean for businesses in this province. British Columbians cannot afford\n               another year of waiting. We need regulation that won't continue to cripple interprovincial\n               trade. Let's get things moving, and let's create and remove the barriers from province\n               to province for all products and professions across Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317188","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I appreciate the opportunity to get up today and speak to Bill 5, the Trade Recognition\n               Act. I think we've proven it here this afternoon on this side of the House that we're actually\n               in favour of getting moving with recognizing that we have too many trade barriers\n               across the provinces in British Columbia. Rather than throw out grade 5 derogatory\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","label":"Taxation regulations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5dbc1e661d651239ef81f6e73cca1159e6189120ee965b1375436c7c30b97b31"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["551b53ca0a193372bdbe4e0026423a6ac66cef0b165ad3b90bbdb49a305a757b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxation regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037284","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff6dc891081bbd0efa9bf884","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360871,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to get up and speak today on observations to the Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act, Bill 10. I want to begin today with some observations from an agricultural perspective,\n               because the temporary foreign worker program and the seasonal agricultural worker\n               program are so vital to our agricultural industry throughout Canada, but especially\n               here for us in British Columbia. Whether you're in the Okanagan growing grapes or growing tree fruits, whether you're\n               running a grain operation in the Peace country or a dairy farm in Delta, temporary\n               foreign workers are exceptionally important in today's agricultural workings in British\n               Columbia. Temporary foreign farm workers play a crucial role in sustaining agriculture in British\n               Columbia. Many farms in the province rely on seasonal labour to plant, maintain and\n               harvest crops such as berries, apples, vegetables and greenhouse products, especially\n               our greenhouses in Delta, where hundreds and hundreds of foreign workers are employed\n               and live in Delta in temporary housing at these greenhouses. Local labour shortages often make it difficult for farms to find enough workers during\n               peak growing seasons. Temporary foreign workers help fill this gap, ensuring that\n               crops are harvested on time and do not go to waste. Their contributions help maintain\n               the productivity and stability of B.C.'s agricultural sector. When farms can operate efficiently, they supply food to local markets, grocery stores\n               and export markets, supporting both food security and economic growth. Agriculture is an important part of the provincial economy, generating jobs not only\n               for farms but also in transportation, food processing and retail — all different types\n               of businesses and professions that temporary foreign workers participate in here in\n               British Columbia. The presence of temporary foreign workers helps keep this system\n               functioning smoothly. In addition to their economic value, these workers bring skills and experience in\n               farming that can improve efficiency and productivity. Many return In addition to their economic value, these workers bring skills and experience in\n               farming that can improve efficiency and productivity. Many return year after year,\n               becoming familiar with farm operations and building strong relationships with farmers\n               and their families and the local communities. We see this very evidently in my riding\n               of Delta South with so many temporary foreign farm workers living in Delta now. B.C. farmers play a crucial role in fairly treating foreign farm workers by ensuring\n               legal wages, safe housing, proper working conditions and respect for workers' rights.\n               These responsibilities help prevent exploitation and maintain a sustainable agricultural\n               workforce throughout Canada. Overall, temporary foreign farmworkers are essential partners in B.C. agriculture.\n               Their labour supports farm viability, strengthens rural economies and helps ensure\n               that Canadians continue to have access to fresh, locally grown food. However, we must be careful when talking about the reduction of temporary foreign\n               workers in Canada, specifically for the agricultural sector. What a disaster it would\n               be if we were to suddenly eliminate the number of temporary foreign workers that we\n               have in British Columbia working in our agricultural sector. As I said earlier, so many temporary foreign workers from places such as Mexico, the\n               Caribbean nations, Jamaica, Guatemala and India are all actively working now throughout\n               British Columbia. In my riding specifically, in Delta South, I can name, even on my\n               farm road where I live.... The dairy farm right next to me has probably five to six\n               foreign workers. Finding young people nowadays that come out of high school here in British Columbia\n               that are eager to get up at 5 a.m. to milk cows and pick berries and do those kind\n               of hard, laborious jobs with our agriculture in B.C. are pretty hard to find, so we're\n               very honoured and pleased to be able to have temporary foreign workers come to us\n               from places like the Caribbean and Mexico. The farmers in British Columbia do their part as well to bring these temporary workers\n               up. The farmers have to do their part in arranging for airfare, arranging for hotels\n               and accommodation when the workers arrive. And of course, they have to have proper\n               accommodation with proper washroom facilities, all the different things that are offered\n               to temporary foreign workers on our farms. We must certainly abide by the rules of the temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act,\n               and we must be aware of situations of vulnerability and exploitation to some of our\n               workers. As I said, we need to approve and provide them with safe, adequate housing,\n               with regular inspections, which get done throughout British Columbia, to the conditions\n               and the working conditions of temporary foreign workers at agricultural facilities. Agriculture would be lost without the TFW program and the seasonal agricultural farm\n               workers program, and we certainly need those folks in our agricultural business in\n               B.C. I speak in support of the principles behind the Labour Statutes Amendment Act, Bill\n               10. At its core, this legislation attempts to address an enduring challenge in labour\n               policy: how we maintain a fair balance between the rights of workers to organize,\n               the rights of employers to operate stable businesses and the broader public interest\n               in a strong and productive economy. Labour law is rarely simple. It sits at the intersection of economics, workplace rights\n               and social policy. Every amendment to our labour statutes inevitably shifts that balance\n               slightly one way or another. Our responsibility in this chamber is not simply to choose\n               sides but to ensure the system remains fair, transparent and workable for everyone\n               involved. Bill 10 introduces several important changes to the labour relations framework in\n               British Columbia. I would like to speak about an important component of this legislation\n               that has not received as much attention as the certification provisions. Bill 10 also\n               makes amendments to the Employment Standards Act of British Columbia and the I would like to speak about an important component of this legislation that has not\n               received as much attention as the certification provisions. Bill 10 also makes amendments to the Employment Standards Act of British Columbia and the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act. These changes deal with something fundamental, ensuring that workers receive the\n               wages they have earned. Employment standards laws exist for a very simple reason. Workers deserve to be paid\n               what they are owed. Wages earned must be wages paid. One of the changes in this legislation addresses situations where an employer owes\n               wages to an employee but cannot locate that employee. Previously, the director responsible\n               for enforcement could only take possession of those wages after attempting to locate\n               the worker for a full year. Bill 10 removes that one-year waiting period. If reasonable\n               efforts have been made and the employee cannot be located, those wages can now be\n               transferred sooner to an administrator who holds them on behalf of the worker. On its face, that may sound like a technical administrative change, but in reality,\n               it improves the system's ability to ensure that money owed to workers is protected\n               rather than sitting indefinitely in limbo. This legislation also introduces changes to the appeal process when a determination\n               is made requiring payment of wages. Under the new provisions, if an employer wishes\n               to appeal a decision requiring payment, the amount owed must generally be deposited\n               with the director before the appeal proceeds. Those funds will accrue interest while the appeal is underway. The tribunal does retain the discretion to\n               allow a smaller deposit amount on a case-by-case basis. The intent behind the provision is clear. It discourages frivolous appeals and ensures\n               that workers are not forced to wait years to receive wages that have already been\n               determined to be owed. However, we must also recognize the concerns raised by many small businesses about\n               this requirement. For large corporations, depositing the full amount of a wage determination may not pose a serious challenge, but for a small business, particularly one operating\n               on tight margins, that requirement could make it difficult to exercise their right\n               to appeal a decision they believe is incorrect. Healthy workplaces require balance. Workers need strong protections. Employers need\n               rules that are fair and workable. The vast majority of employers in this province\n               want to follow the rules. Labour laws should support good employers while holding\n               bad actors accountable. We must be careful that in trying to strengthen enforcement\n               mechanisms, we do not unintentionally create barriers that make it difficult for legitimate\n               businesses to defend themselves when disputes arrive. The bill also introduces a new complaint resolution process during investigations\n               conducted by the employment standards branch. Under these provisions, the director may require the parties involved in a complaint\n               to participate in a resolution process while the investigation continues. If a party\n               fails to participate, the director may continue the investigation or may proceed to\n               make determination with consequences. The goal of this approach is to resolve disputes earlier in the process rather than\n               allowing complaints to sit unresolved for extended periods of time. And that goal\n               is important. Employment standards complaints must be resolved faster if we want healthier\n               workplaces. Over the past four years, government service plans show that only about 32 percent\n               of complaints have been resolved within 180 days. That means the majority of workers\n               filing complaints currently wait longer than six months. Even the government's target\n               for resolving 80 percent of complaints within 180 days by 2027 still means that one\n               in five workers could be waiting longer than six months for a resolution. Ultimately, success should not be measured only by how quickly files are closed. Success\n               should be measured by whether workers actually receive the wages they are owed. That brings us to another important issue: resources. The provincial budget currently\n               freezes labour program funding at roughly $22.3 million for the next three years,\n               which is actually slightly lower than the previous estimate of $22.8 million. At the same time, government expects complaint resolution times to improve dramatically.\n               That raises an obvious question. Does the employment standards branch have the resources\n               necessary to meet those expectations? If we are serious about enforcing employment\n               standards, then the agencies responsible for that work must have the capacity to do\n               it effectively. These issues are particularly important in sectors such as agriculture, where many\n               workers are seasonal or part of federal migrant worker These issues are particularly important in sectors such as agriculture where many\n               workers are seasonal or part of federal migrant worker programs. In communities like\n               mine of Delta and specifically in the riding of Delta South, agriculture remains a\n               central part of our local economy. Much of the farmland in Delta South lies within the agricultural land reserve. Over\n               26,000 acres of farmland is being farmed in my riding of Delta South, which protects\n               some of the most protective agricultural land in Canada, referring to the agricultural\n               land reserve. Farm operations in the region produce vegetables, berries, greenhouse\n               crops and dairy products that supply families across the province. My riding of Delta South probably has the most greenhouses growing cucumbers, tomatoes\n               and peppers than any other parts of British Columbia, with hundreds and hundreds of\n               seasonal foreign agricultural workers at these greenhouses. They've put up wonderful\n               temporary housing units stacked. Some of them have as many as 100 foreign workers\n               living on a greenhouse, such as Windset Farms, which is quite famous for their products\n               in Delta. You know, I think the people of my riding enjoy seeing these young men and women from\n               Guatemala, from Jamaica, from Mexico, that ride.... They all ride bikes. They love their\n               bicycles. Every Sunday is their day off, and we see these seasonal workers at the\n               bus stops because they want to go into Richmond or they want to go into Vancouver\n               and experience what it's like to be in British Columbia. We've even set up in Delta some wonderful things for our foreign workers. These folks\n               from Central America and Mexico and Jamaica, they love their soccer. We'll set up\n               a Sunday soccer match between seasonal foreign workers right in Ladner, and they all\n               get the day off from their greenhouse jobs or their dairy farm jobs. A goal I have of mine is to set up.... We're going to block off a main street in the\n               village of Ladner and have a seasonal foreign worker night with mariachi bands and\n               some food trucks and whatnot. We want to make these young men and women feel very,\n               very welcome here in Bridge Columbia. Much of the farmland in Delta South lies within the ALR, which protects some of the\n               most productive farmland in Canada. Farm operations in the region produce vegetables,\n               berries and greenhouse crops, as I said. But those farms depend on a reliable workforce.\n               Agriculture in British Columbia relies heavily on seasonal labour and on workers who\n               arrive under temporary foreign worker programs. These individuals perform demanding\n               work under tight production guidelines. Their rights must be protected. At the same time, farms operate under a very narrow seasonal window. When harvest\n               season arrives, crops must be picked immediately. A delay of even a few days can result\n               in the loss of an entire crop. That is why labour policy must recognize the operational\n               realities of agriculture. Farm workers deserve fair treatment and protection under\n               the law. Farmers deserve clear, predictable rules that allow them to operate viable\n               businesses. Both things can be true at the same time. There is one final concern that has been raised by many employer groups during discussions\n               about Bill 10. A number of stakeholders have said that they were not meaningfully\n               consulted before these changes were introduced. Labour policy works best when both\n               workers and employers are part of the conversation. When one side feels excluded from\n               the process, confidence in the legislation inevitably suffers. Public policy, particularly\n               labour policy, is rarely improved by rushing past the people most affected by it. Ultimately, labour relations policy works best when all sides believe the system is\n               legitimate. Workers must believe their voices are respected. Employers must believe\n               the rules are predictable and fair, and the public must believe that our economy remains\n               stable and productive. That balance is not always easy to achieve. But it's worth remembering that strong labour relations systems benefit the entire\n               economy. Stable workplaces reduce disputes, improve productivity and create environments\n               where businesses and workers can succeed together. Bill 10 represents a deliberate effort to strengthen worker protections and modernize\n               aspects of our labour framework. The improvements I have outlined today are not meant\n               to weaken the legislation. They are meant to strengthen it. Better verification processes,\n               clear information for workers about their rights, consideration for small businesses The improvements I have outlined today are not meant to weaken the legislation. They\n               are meant to strengthen it. Better verification processes, clear information for workers\n               about their rights, consideration for small businesses navigating the appeal process,\n               adequate resources for enforcement and broader consultation with both workers and\n               employers. If we take those steps, we can ensure this legislation achieves its goal,\n               protecting workers while maintaining a fair and workable system for employers. The history of labour policy in British Columbia has always been cyclical. Governments\n               adjust the rules, economies change and workplaces evolve. But through all those changes,\n               one principle remains constant. Labour legislation works best when it seeks balance\n               rather than advantage. For those reasons, I support the intent of Bill 10, and I encourage\n               this House to continue refining the legislation so it delivers fair and effective\n               results for workers, employers and communities across British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360871","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm pleased to get up and speak today on observations to the Labour Statutes Amendment\n               Act, Bill 10. I want to begin today with some observations from an agricultural perspective,\n               because the temporary foreign worker program and the seasonal agricultural worker\n               program are so vital to our agricultural industry throughout Canada, but especially\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c2558ed771c7847afa1ea5285db758167678eb0eabbc7d408e520d71d7d66f8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8cddd6060cbaf33260b0cf006534b0ce09ae9053a91ba8ee479f56a07223e614"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7a09d3fd3083a088e97b0f7c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360872,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to welcome today Surrey resident Bradley Budden and his daughter Emily here.\n               Bradley came to our caucus this morning and presented on something we don't think\n               much about. But he's the executive director of the B.C. Insulation Contractors Association,\n               and everything underneath us and inside of our walls has to be insulated. Welcome, Bradley and his daughter Emily.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Insulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360872","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to welcome today Surrey resident Bradley Budden and his daughter Emily here.\n               Bradley came to our caucus this morning and presented on something we don't think\n               much about. But he's the executive director of the B.C. Insulation Contractors Association,\n               and everything underneath us and inside of our walls has to be insulated. Welcome, Bradley and ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","label":"Insulation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Insulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","label":"Insulation","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bd353c575566cd46dfb68683e786b93e47d6a4cd0cd5e50976f346343e466da5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Insulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["febe6f9ce114a8a24959a3b326063682e356334f583292509f8b62674ebca89c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Insulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035908","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-34796423cd691170a9a475f2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415801,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm happy to support motion 201 brought forward by the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine: \"That this House affirms its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an important component of Canadian sovereignty.\" What are three of the most important necessities to human existence? Sun, food and\n               water. Agriculture doesn't exist without sunshine and water. Ensuring universal access\n               to clean, potable water for all residents of British Columbia is both a public health\n               necessity and a cornerstone of sustainable development. While the province is often perceived as water-rich, due to its abundant rivers, lakes\n               and snowfall, reliable access to safe drinking water and consistent water supply for\n               agriculture is not guaranteed across all regions. Climate variability, aging infrastructure,\n               population growth, and competing water demands increasingly challenge water management\n               systems. Addressing these issues requires coordinated policies that prioritize equitable\n               access, resilient infrastructure and sustainable water allocation. For many communities in British Columbia, particularly rural and Indigenous communities,\n               access to safe drinking water remains inconsistent. Small or remote systems often\n               lack the financial resources and technical capacity required to maintain modern treatment\n               facilities and monitoring systems. Ensuring safe, potable water requires sustained\n               investment in water treatment plants, distribution infrastructure and regular testing\n               programs. Provincial and federal governments must continue to support infrastructure\n               upgrades and provide technical training to local water operators. Expanding watershed protection initiatives is also essential, as protecting source\n               water from pollution and environmental degradation is often the most effective way\n               to maintain long-term water quality. Equally important is the need to secure consistent\n               water availability for agriculture, which is vital to British Columbia's food security\n               and rural economies. Regions such as the Caribou, Chilcotin, Peace River, Vancouver\n               Island, Okanagan Valley and parts of the Fraser Valley rely heavily on irrigation\n               to support fruit orchards, vineyards, dairy farms and vegetable production. These\n               agricultural systems depend on predictable water supplies, particularly during the\n               increasingly dry and warm summer months. Climate change is intensifying seasonal droughts and altering snowpack patterns which\n               historically acted as a natural water reservoir. Reduced snowpack and earlier spring\n               melt mean that less water is available later in the growing season when crops need\n               it most. To address these challenges, the province must invest in modern irrigation\n               infrastructure and improved water storage systems. Reservoir expansion, aquifer recharge projects and on-farm water storage can help\n               capture winter and spring runoff for use during these dry periods. At the same time,\n               promoting efficient irrigation technologies such as drip irrigation, 360 rain irrigation\n               systems, soil moisture monitoring, and precision agriculture can significantly reduce\n               water waste while maintaining crop productivity, financial incentives, and technical\n               support can encourage farmers to adopt these. As a former dairy farmer, I know all too well the volumes of water a dairy cow or\n               a beef cow consumes daily. Did you know that a dairy cow producing high volumes of\n               milk during the summer months will easily drink up to 100 litres of water per day? Ultimately, ensuring access to clean drinking water while maintaining sufficient irrigation\n               resources requires forward-thinking water governance. Overall, the lack of free and\n               accessible water threatens food production, farmers' livelihoods and the global food\n               security. Ensuring fair and sustainable access to water is crucial for supporting\n               farmers and maintaining stable agricultural systems. The lack of free and accessible water threatens food production, farmers' livelihoods\n               and global food security. Ensuring fair and sustainable access to water is crucial\n               for supporting farmers and maintaining stable agricultural systems.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415801","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm happy to support motion 201 brought forward by the member for Bulkley Valley–Stikine: \"That this House affirms its commitment to affordable, equitable and accessible clean water as an important component of Canadian sovereignty.\" What are three of the most important necessities to human existence? Sun, food and\n               water. Agriculture doesn't exist without sunshine and water. Ensurin","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5dfd4da0cd66340ce2e06486481261143cedef3071b0b05e8a45445a52e7c936"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7ceaf32437588598f65a2db698bfdc10a7c00e3e19bb9586dde036c4cda88a2a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96685729c695df88d3bfa6db","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720489,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, I have two sets of guests here today from my riding of Delta South. The\n               first is Alan and Barbara Baydala; there they are. They've been living for 35 years\n               in my riding of Delta South. Barbara has been a leader in heritage, cultural and social services organizations.\n               She received Queen Elizabeth II's certificate and King Charles III's Coronation Medal for extraordinary contribution and service to our community. Alan, her husband, has been very involved as the chair of the Delta Hospital Foundation.\n               He was the inventor of West Coast Air, and he was also the chief financial officer\n               for the Vancouver Port Authority. Please welcome Alan and Barb Baydala. Just as importantly, my older brother, Dave Paton, is here today. Dave is a very well-known\n               equine veterinarian. He's here with his wife, Janet, with Janet's brother Robert,\n               and Kaya Clark from Ontario, and Dave's high school friends Terry and Marilyn Clayton. Please welcome my brother, Dave, and his guests today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720489","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, I have two sets of guests here today from my riding of Delta South. The\n               first is Alan and Barbara Baydala; there they are. They've been living for 35 years\n               in my riding of Delta South. Barbara has been a leader in heritage, cultural and social services organizations.\n               She received Queen Elizabeth II's certificate and King Charles III's Coron","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Coasts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crop insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034521","label":"Coasts","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034728","label":"Crop insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1cb4d8f9e6e1c3aa8167c85def3edf6a008ac8c17a94749dd03045c89112b2eb","cca9b07795003c144edbb5407cd3737c3ca7294b5f5f26c0c7654fec3913cc57"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6032b2dee54988255f3315d0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720491,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the minister for a short spell we had before lunchtime. We're back at\n               it here, and hopefully, we can complete Agriculture estimates by the end of day. I know you're waiting for some of your staff members to arrive. I'd like to read out a quote from Country Life magazine. My question to the minister. Based on this budget and based on introducing PST to\n               engineering services, to architectural services, these are all things that farmers\n               are going to have to make use of if they're building a new barn, if they're putting\n               in a lagoon for irrigation. There's a myriad of things that farmers are now going to be taxed on with PST, which\n               has been added to farming through this recent budget. Could you please explain to\n               me why this has been added and how it'll affect agriculture in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720491","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you to the minister for a short spell we had before lunchtime. We're back at\n               it here, and hopefully, we can complete Agriculture estimates by the end of day. I know you're waiting for some of your staff members to arrive. I'd like to read out a quote from Country Life magazine. My question to the minister. Based on this budget and based on introducing PST to\n               eng","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036076","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Landslides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Petroleum industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Financial crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Rural environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Floods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Recycling","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037333","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Terrestrial ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Gas industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Broadcasting industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Commercial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Diesel fuel","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034762","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse effect","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural technology","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Contaminated sites","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Poaching","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1019828","label":"Broadcasting industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034546","label":"Commercial buildings","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034762","label":"Dairy cattle","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035062","label":"Employment programs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035136","label":"Environmental services","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","label":"Farm buildings","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035438","label":"Gas industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035554","label":"Greenhouse effect","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035608","label":"Hazardous waste","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036076","label":"Landslides","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036658","label":"Petroleum industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036989","label":"Road networks","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036995","label":"Road transport","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037004","label":"Rural environment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037088","label":"Service contracts","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037333","label":"Terrestrial ecosystems","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:255569","label":"Contaminated sites","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","label":"Greenhouse gases","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43898","label":"Floods","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44910","label":"Waste management","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47408","label":"Diesel fuel","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64086","label":"Financial crisis","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716767","label":"Agricultural technology","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733848","label":"Recycling","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","label":"Poaching","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9b0ec629baa4701fcd8da0c8b7e9a608c08507f7640141dc576c0ebd6c3c9241","5164b8604998a6a508b5f9446f86a4a2da3bf4cca096d2626cb9357ea2d07621","856963141a520ed746503c859e9e276e61e32d4b9b13f790fac48d91224eb9fe","2ea8c70589823aea957a0d401ee414f5366b1be73745b1993a24569d1f0c42c7","c7171a2ee3a2a6254fd7c0c2e0a56f59db8891ab66fff10c45bd5ecf35a1af13","8998bce0763452f7eac4eb20b095cb8517e578bdf78d4305bae2821a0cad22d1","ad47bfab6c3bdb4c2b28b09e25c78cbe068541b82a58093f3f9e89d25806b19b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["56af418b2d29c848f6b1afa28fa8ba8f762c02a7e2fbcbebcc8b9993d68d31ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fd80c60f07762aba3e62eae4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720492,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"If you'll indulge me, I have three introductions this morning. First, I have the honour of introducing a distinguished guest in the House today,\n               Dr. Andrew Weaver, who is seated in the House today behind me. Some of you may recognize\n               him from a few billboards put up several years ago with myself, Dr. Weaver and John\n               Horgan duking it out about whether it should be a bridge or a tunnel to replace the\n               George Massey Tunnel. Dr. Weaver is a professor in the School of Earth and Ocean Sciences at the University\n               of Victoria and previously served as the Canada Research Chair in Climate Modelling\n               and Analysis. He also served as a member of the Legislative Assembly here for Oak Bay–Gordon Head, having been elected in 2013 as a member of the B.C. Green Party He also served as a member of the Legislative Assembly here for Oak Bay–Gordon Head, having been elected in 2013 as a member of the B.C. Green Party and leader of the B.C. Green Party. Dr. Weaver is widely recognized for his significant contributions to climate science,\n               for his public service to the people of British Columbia. Please join me in welcoming Dr. Andrew Weaver to the House today. We have a celebrity in the House as well today from Tsawwassen, from my riding: Filipino-Canadian Warren Dean Flandez, who is also a good friend of our MLA from Vancouver-Kensington. Warren Dean Flandez is a multi-award-winning, two-time Juno-nominated recording artist, educator, and cultural leader based in Tsawwassen, Delta. He teaches at Capilano University and serves as vice-chair of the Delta police board, president of the Tsawwassen business improvement association, and chair of the Filipino Legacy Society, a non-profit organization dedicated to building a Filipino cultural centre in Vancouver. In June of last summer, Warren Dean Flandez put on the most magnificent concert, with\n               1,000 people attending, in Tsawwassen, to bring hope and support the impact to all\n               the people that were devastated by the Lapu-Lapu tragedy, and the funds all went towards survivors of the Lapu-Lapu tragedy. Please welcome Warren Dean Flandez this morning. And finally, my third introduction. I have three gentlemen from Abbotsford that I've known for several years. One of them, for sure, is a retired dairy farmer: Ken Dahl, Al Unruh, and Alfred Stater. Please welcome these three gentlemen from Abbotsford.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720492","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"If you'll indulge me, I have three introductions this morning. First, I have the honour of introducing a distinguished guest in the House today,\n               Dr. Andrew Weaver, who is seated in the House today behind me. Some of you may recognize\n               him from a few billboards put up several years ago with myself, Dr. Weaver and John\n               Horgan duking it out about whether it","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0ce250327a6a7af116c754b6fdb70260efd954ace717829084408cb708cc6199"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0eb6bfecdf3d95be83de76b6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721612,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also present a petition, of 158 signatures from residents of Delta South. The petition from the residents of Delta South and Tsawwassen respectfully requests\n               that this House call on the Ministry of Forests and Agriculture and Food to cancel\n               the 2026 plans to aerial spray in Tsawwassen, Beach Grove and Squamish for spongy\n               moth and to reform the program permanently to prohibit all aerial spraying over B.C.\n               communities.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721612","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I also present a petition, of 158 signatures from residents of Delta South. The petition from the residents of Delta South and Tsawwassen respectfully requests\n               that this House call on the Ministry of Forests and Agriculture and Food to cancel\n               the 2026 plans to aerial spray in Tsawwassen, Beach Grove and Squamish for spongy\n               moth and to reform the program","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","label":"Pesticides","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","label":"Environmental management","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["db84e572a412107dba9f33df1467d51c622b5a20dc0da00086d4d7475517763a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c2b251a00df0ae3fbf237be4a532fdddaf0263f86e2ba9b81a3c5523ec2f8ff1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Environmental management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Pesticides","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47404","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715114","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2837cad84834e5345522721d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729395,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"At a time of global inability, securing our province's food supply must be a priority\n               for the B.C. government. After decades of stability, we can no longer count on fair\n               and free trade with our closest neighbour. War in the Ukraine and the Middle East\n               further threatens trade stability. As global tensions rise, countries are turning\n               inward, with tariffs on goods becoming the new normal. British Columbia cannot afford to fall behind. This is a matter of preserving our\n               food sovereignty. British Columbia cannot be reliant on foreign powers like the United\n               States for something as fundamental as our ability to feed our citizens. The ability\n               to feed ourselves must be a core priority of any government that takes resilience\n               seriously. And yet at the very moment we should be redoubling our efforts to strengthen local\n               agriculture and protect our food systems, this government has gone backwards. B.C.'s agriculture and food sector is massive. It spans more than 200 commodities\n               and supports over 230,000 jobs across our province. But behind those numbers are real\n               people, farmers and ranchers who are under increasing pressure and receiving less\n               support when they need it most. Let's start with the Agricultural Land Commission. The ALC is responsible for protecting\n               4.6 million hectares Let's start with the Agricultural Land Commission. The ALC is responsible for protecting 4.6 million hectares of land in the agricultural\n               land reserve, the foundation of our food system. Yet staffing cuts and a lack of meaningful\n               investment have led to serious delays in decisions that farmers depend on to keep\n               their operations running. And the agricultural land reserve was the golden child of the NDP; they actually brought it in, in 1973. Yet lack of staff, lack of bylaws enforcement and lack of funding are making the ALC a shadow of what it once was.\n               At a time when we should be strengthening the ALC, this government is weakening it. Farmers are also facing rising costs across the board: fuel, feed and fertilizer.\n               Fertilizer prices have surged due to global instability, including the war in Ukraine and conflict in Iran, as well as supply chain disruptions and rising natural gas costs. Feed prices continue to climb due to drought conditions in the Prairies and the lasting impacts of extreme weather here in British Columbia. And fuel costs,\n               particularly diesel, are putting enormous strain on farmers who rely on heavy equipment\n               to produce and transport food. The cost of diesel is outrageous, the cost of fertilizer is outrageous, and the cost\n               of equipment and parts is outrageous. These are not small increases. These are structural\n               cost pressures that threaten the viability of farming in our province. At the same time, farmers are being hit with reduced access to insurance and risk management programs. After years of climate-related disasters, from wildfires to floods that\n               devastated communities like Sumas Prairie, Merritt and Princeton, producers are being asked to shoulder more risk with less support. This is not a\n               recipe for food sovereignty; it's a recipe for decline. We are also hearing directly from farmers about the challenges they face accessing\n               water for irrigation and livestock, delays in approvals for basic operational needs\n               and barriers to expanding or adapting their farms to meet modern demands. If we are serious about protecting B.C.'s food sovereignty, then we must support the\n               people who produce our food. That means restoring funding and capacity at the Agricultural Land Commission; ensuring farmers have access to affordable insurance; addressing rising input costs\n               where possible; and making it easier, not harder, to farm in this province, because\n               the stakes could not be higher. B.C.'s prime agricultural lands are a treasure. As responsible citizens, we must continue to steward them as such.\n               In doing so, we cannot forget about the rights of a farmer. Farmers are the best stewards\n               for these lands because they interact with them every day. In order to perform their\n               duty to protect the land, farmers must be able to make a decent living, accommodate\n               secondary housing for family, receive real and adequate protection from trespassers\n               and be given reasonable access to local processing and water. In my critic role, I will continue reminding the NDP government that it's not farmland without the farmer. Farming and preserving farmland has a long history in my family,\n               and I will persevere on behalf of my B.C. Conservative Party to ensure farmers, ranchers and their future generations have the opportunity to\n               prosper and continue working this noble profession.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729395","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"At a time of global inability, securing our province's food supply must be a priority\n               for the B.C. government. After decades of stability, we can no longer count on fair\n               and free trade with our closest neighbour. War in the Ukraine and the Middle East\n               further threatens trade stability. As global tensions rise, countries are turning\n               inward","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f66f54ab737b50bbd702ef1b642ef8703f7efac49629b5542fc5731aabf57cd9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["87cab8090fe470c0f533130897703a6d77c49f3365fbe054ca588962f1ea7bd5"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c090e007744c01a735e4dab","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729400,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"The people of Delta rolled up their sleeves and raised nearly $20 million to build\n               a long-term care facility for their community. This was a government-approved project.\n               Apparently, getting approval from this government is no longer credible. Today the\n               contracts to build that facility have been cancelled. This is not re-pacing. Will the minister stand in this House today and tell the families of Delta when this\n               cancelled project will start again?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729400","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"The people of Delta rolled up their sleeves and raised nearly $20 million to build\n               a long-term care facility for their community. This was a government-approved project.\n               Apparently, getting approval from this government is no longer credible. Today the\n               contracts to build that facility have been cancelled. This is not re-pacing. Will the minister stand i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["77eda1c56f78aebad3cf6e6619ad8b1fc0189ec9ae55ac836873eb672bcd1904"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c5e7ef21d76832ce5432fb8e893568edb6c686561c8740d3ce5a32764badfc06"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-47213d437757f7e4ad0941cd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752316,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government claims that these seven long-term-care projects are just re-paced.\n               In Delta, this was an approved project. This isn't a pause. This is an actual betrayal.\n               Delta Mayor George Harvie said: \"Instead of just taking a pause, they've killed the\n               project. They can use whatever words they want. They have killed this project. It\n               has been cancelled.\" Seniors and families in this province don't see a pause. They see fewer beds and longer\n               waits. This is not just a south Delta hospital; this is a hospital for all Delta residents.\n               Will the Jobs Minister from North Delta stand up and tell the people of Delta why\n               he has gone silent after such a grand ribbon cutting and project approval three years\n               ago?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752316","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"This government claims that these seven long-term-care projects are just re-paced.\n               In Delta, this was an approved project. This isn't a pause. This is an actual betrayal.\n               Delta Mayor George Harvie said: \"Instead of just taking a pause, they've killed the\n               project. They can use whatever words they want. They have killed this project. It\n               has","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","label":"Construction materials","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501155","label":"Media","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76b86c33476f739a81440d23446d4a2484280db5cbc370312bf0ca28389b88f9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3e860752dfaf1ffb0edd3179906ad132f1a22f38ab8c5fd14e6a70dd2348ac51"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-69df62be4a2d79ea637bfb29","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752317,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the Minister of Agriculture for a great introduction of all the folks\n               here from B.C. Cattlemen's Association today. I especially want to point out Kevin\n               Boon, who is the general manager, and Werner Stump, who's president of B.C. Cattlemen's. They've been coming here year after year after year for many years, and they seem\n               to like I have to say, Minister, so that's a good thing. I also want to point out that I can see, up in the gallery, a good friend Paul Devick\n               from Kamloops, Brad Chappell from Courtenay and Dougie Haughton from up in Kamloops\n               as well. Please make them all feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752317","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to thank the Minister of Agriculture for a great introduction of all the folks\n               here from B.C. Cattlemen's Association today. I especially want to point out Kevin\n               Boon, who is the general manager, and Werner Stump, who's president of B.C. Cattlemen's. They've been coming here year after year after year for many years, and they seem\n               to like I have ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["83ea03c946a52eb612d406538e181212c1f88b9c2a912b863b32214706b48066"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0bcba40bd604a090ec799a7e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752318,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I've been here in this wonderful place for nine years now. I've had a few late nights\n               over the years. I can't recall doing a speech at 1:15 in the morning. But I think\n               the B.C. Conservative caucus, if people are watching.... We didn't actually bring this\n               on. At 6:55 tonight, the House Leader of the Government refused to adjourn the House and\n               suggested that we continue debate on the hoist motion of Bill 9. And on behalf of\n               my B.C. Conservative caucus and on behalf of the people of British Columbia that I\n               represent, we're here to debate well into the early, wee hours of the morning for\n               fairness, for transparency and for freedom of information for people in this province. I rise in favour of a reasoned amendment, one that goes to the heart of responsible\n               law-making, that the motion for second reading of Bill 9 be amended by deleting the\n               word \"now\" and substituting....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752318","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I've been here in this wonderful place for nine years now. I've had a few late nights\n               over the years. I can't recall doing a speech at 1:15 in the morning. But I think\n               the B.C. Conservative caucus, if people are watching.... We didn't actually bring this\n               on. At 6:55 tonight, the House Leader of the Government refused to adjourn the House and\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eda3581105a6bc9682f64eb6b64ddc57f1c250fae3ae32232aa004a2e734c459"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc436cb4f34b5a4c05106456","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752319,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"In my riding of Tsawwassen, we have a tremendous independent school called Southpointe\n               Academy, and they are here today with two classes of grade 4s and 5s. They're actually\n               getting a tour with the legislative tour guides right now as we speak. I want to welcome them and their teachers, Ms. Hammerberg and Mr. Carson. For some of us on our side of the aisle, Mr. Carson is the son of Frank and Primrose Carson, who we all know. Thank you. Please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Private schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752319","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"In my riding of Tsawwassen, we have a tremendous independent school called Southpointe\n               Academy, and they are here today with two classes of grade 4s and 5s. They're actually\n               getting a tour with the legislative tour guides right now as we speak. I want to welcome them and their teachers, Ms. Hammerberg and Mr. Carson. For some of us on our side of the aisle, Mr. Carson","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","label":"Private schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724339","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Animal testing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Private schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","label":"Private schools","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724304","label":"Animal rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:724339","label":"Animal testing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3a567c1ab52ce4b52cbf01f3352ba8d8ebe600c6074b50117d97eb2c9162ab00","06211ba8f0e5420225c270ea684eb72a1cde4c57c952e28b18dc34d5abda0b4d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Private schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee5663b6ce6540c95d27a36e0a1a7784c33788ed54c1935da51eb574d65e818c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Private schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036751","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-281587a61dd2a1b3d5881b93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017529,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Here's a quiz for everyone: what noble profession requires a routine of getting up\n               at 4.30 a.m. every day, seven days a week, 365 days a year, milking cows at 5 a.m.,\n               then again at 5 p.m. while, in between your 14-hour day, you're feeding, cleaning,\n               planting, harvesting and taking on the de facto roles of a veterinarian, a mechanic\n               and an environmentalist? Well, you'd be correct if you guessed a dairy farmer, and\n               I know only too well this lifestyle, as I lived it for a good many years. Today we recognize and celebrate British Columbia Dairy Day at the Legislature, an\n               opportunity to honour the hard-working family farmers who help feed communities across\n               our province every single day. Dairy farming is more than an industry in British Columbia.\n               It is a way of life built on dedication, resilience and a deep commitment to quality.\n               Across British Columbia, dairy farmers work long hours in every season to produce\n               safe, nutritious and high-quality dairy products for families to enjoy. From fresh milk and cheese to yogurt and butter, these products reach kitchen tables\n               because of the tireless efforts of local farm families and processors who take immense\n               pride in what they do. Behind every dairy farm is a strong commitment to animal care and environmental stewardship.\n               Farmers invest countless hours ensuring At the same time, dairy farmers continue to face significant challenges. Rising costs\n               of feed, fuel, equipment, transportation and labour are placing increasing pressure\n               on family farms and cutting deeply into their profits. Many farmers are working harder\n               than ever simply to maintain the viability of their operations while continuing to\n               provide the high standards consumers expect. On this British Columbia Dairy Day, we thank our dairy farming families for their\n               unwavering dedication, their care for their animals and their continued commitment\n               to producing exceptional dairy products for all British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017529","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Here's a quiz for everyone: what noble profession requires a routine of getting up\n               at 4.30 a.m. every day, seven days a week, 365 days a year, milking cows at 5 a.m.,\n               then again at 5 p.m. while, in between your 14-hour day, you're feeding, cleaning,\n               planting, harvesting and taking on the de facto roles of a veterinarian, a mechanic\n               and an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["87eb814e03c4d59bf88b11184b0348e462c5d9149b2c339bddf2c102b4b60527"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b21f69bf0f5229d9c2c843ec94da6866ef5d28cbb94029282e80d270561bddc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b9834caf353ccaae80e88078","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017530,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"One of the oldest elementary schools in my riding, in Tsawwassen, is South Park Elementary.\n               We have a total of over 70 students, grades 4 and 5, here today. They're up in the\n               gallery. I don't know why they want to look at the government side, but anyways. They're\n               up in the gallery, and they're under the guidance of teachers Krista Alvano, Laura\n               Axon and Brea Maurice. Please welcome all the students from South Park Elementary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017530","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"One of the oldest elementary schools in my riding, in Tsawwassen, is South Park Elementary.\n               We have a total of over 70 students, grades 4 and 5, here today. They're up in the\n               gallery. I don't know why they want to look at the government side, but anyways. They're\n               up in the gallery, and they're under the guidance of teachers Krista Alvano, Laura\n        ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","label":"Elementary education","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bc4cae335905710a4e268adf4f54728a59e625fd9bcae7a84076e506a8dceda0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["672cc506b52a6994049da455e02e3a47a825a4bfda231eb0d27add4d303dd1eb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035031","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-66eb3b4b08771333d1677e7b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017531,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017531","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66fd8781c24ac80bbf2b9e0aa26c2a38ba676674503b1c29751a7733d393e5ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f1c4719f61290a97034ff97d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036553,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Being the last week here of our spring session, I'm really pleased to have my beautiful wife, Pam, join me for a couple of days. With her are our good friends, from Tsawwassen, Roy and Monica Toigo. Please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036553","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Being the last week here of our spring session, I'm really pleased to have my beautiful wife, Pam, join me for a couple of days. With her are our good friends, from Tsawwassen, Roy and Monica Toigo. Please make them feel welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53a36d4e82b7f19f22c353e860564d6659f521eae0d9df96a2ba9706a7379dcd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6ae93c10d36d2970bf7c0988","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036555,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm so pleased to have a long-time farming family here from Delta. Les Hoggard and\n               his wife, Marie, and their three daughters, Renee, Tanya and Amy. Les and I go way back. He's a farmer from Delta. They used to be over in Sea Island,\n               the Hoggard family. When the Vancouver Airport expanded, they got expropriated, and\n               they moved to Delta. Les and I have been to Kentucky together in the thoroughbred\n               horse–racing industry. It's Les's birthday today. Please welcome the Hoggard family. Happy birthday, Les. Good to see you, buddy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036555","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'm so pleased to have a long-time farming family here from Delta. Les Hoggard and\n               his wife, Marie, and their three daughters, Renee, Tanya and Amy. Les and I go way back. He's a farmer from Delta. They used to be over in Sea Island,\n               the Hoggard family. When the Vancouver Airport expanded, they got expropriated, and\n               they moved to Delta. Les and I have b","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Horses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48410","label":"Horses","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["28b57c3c6fb8c7c9ccb56ce995bffa081c0066854cfbb3ca42c8551cfa095f39"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["98dc0fa8d77348f4d02b72e8cb4e267c7d5f20e6f71a496b6a7cc296730d47e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10266cf681e1cccd76bf9963","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036557,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Ian Paton","venue":"Hansard","text":"Sorry, this is a little bit corny, but my mom watches question period every day from\n               our farm in Delta. I never get to wish her a happy birthday because it's always in\n               August, on August 3. She's going to be 99 years old this coming August 3. And up until\n               five months ago, she was still volunteering every Friday at the Delta Hospital Auxiliary\n               thrift shop. So everybody say \"happy birthday\" to my mom.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036557","member_id":"bc-mla-59","member_name":"Ian Paton","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sorry, this is a little bit corny, but my mom watches question period every day from\n               our farm in Delta. I never get to wish her a happy birthday because it's always in\n               August, on August 3. She's going to be 99 years old this coming August 3. And up until\n               five months ago, she was still volunteering every Friday at the Delta Hospital Auxiliary\n           ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","label":"Aging","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af0a7608c7834648f2c673b93b99060e3082ebbdac3723576bb80f8219c90a07"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a895574683e9832042aa75921774692ccca82739267a0dacc4a24f9a098b7208"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Aging","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728298","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6f1c28568f38c933d1104866","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328032,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm seeking leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328032","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm seeking leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47fe712585c8b6356b027b682a0eda14caf53deb82aebc0aa9b22858a24c5e40"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-10878a1974c6b27c39ac63e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415802,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker, you have a very special person who works in your office by the name of\n               Tabitha Bernard. Tabitha is also a constituent of mine. Her parents are visiting here today, in the gallery, from Ottawa, and I would like\n               to introduce the House to Sandy and Ken Bernard. Sandy is a retired early child educator,\n               and Ken is also retired, but he's taken on a second career as a volunteer firefighter\n               and has community boards coming out his ears. Would the House please welcome them to British Columbia.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415802","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker, you have a very special person who works in your office by the name of\n               Tabitha Bernard. Tabitha is also a constituent of mine. Her parents are visiting here today, in the gallery, from Ottawa, and I would like\n               to introduce the House to Sandy and Ken Bernard. Sandy is a retired early child educator,\n               and Ken is also retired, but he's taken on","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e273ceb8e51d1e677abc53a1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720496,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thanks to the opposition member. I'm looking forward to starting our estimate process\n               today. We'll have five hours to get into all of the nitty-gritty. But to the member's question, he's not wrong. The ALC is facing some tough times right\n               now. Their budget has not","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720496","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thanks to the opposition member. I'm looking forward to starting our estimate process\n               today. We'll have five hours to get into all of the nitty-gritty. But to the member's question, he's not wrong. The ALC is facing some tough times right\n               now. Their budget has not","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Accounting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716723","label":"Accounting","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7756ef4d7d6afa37d25866ba616cc46cb1c9bf34710497055f5a92532f86df77"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8beaa601a33f955a7d14adb1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720508,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's a good question. The reason why the things were added under the column of PST\n               was really to harmonize items across the entire jurisdiction of Canada. It brings things in line to where they are charged PST in other areas. I take the member's point that, especially as new barns are being constructed, etc.,\n               there are costs to be considered. I know that's very apparent right now with the amount\n               of But I take the member's point, especially as new barns are being constructed, etc.,\n               that there are costs to be considered. I know that's very apparent right now with\n               the amount of activity, positive activity, with our ag barns. There are a lot of barns\n               being built, and so that is something to consider. I can say that we do have programs in the Ministry of Agriculture which, I guess,\n               counteract those new charges, specifically $100 million in the ag water infrastructure\n               program. It's $100 million to help with issues of the cost of engineering, permitting,\n               any of the considerations when building a new barn, a new greenhouse. So there are\n               programs that offset those changes, and I have a lot more details if the member is\n               interested.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720508","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's a good question. The reason why the things were added under the column of PST\n               was really to harmonize items across the entire jurisdiction of Canada. It brings things in line to where they are charged PST in other areas. I take the member's point that, especially as new barns are being constructed, etc.,\n               there are costs to be considered. I know that's very appare","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","label":"Farm buildings"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Biomedical experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Biomedical experiments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Animal research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Animal research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Assets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax incentives","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Poaching","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Foreign investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse gases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fuels","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106998","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Animal diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Manufacturing industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752655","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Streams","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Artificial intelligence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Research grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Soil quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poultry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035554","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouse effect","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016066","label":"Biomedical experiments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034616","label":"Construction materials","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","label":"Farm buildings","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035328","label":"Food processing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035347","label":"Foreign investments","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035554","label":"Greenhouse effect","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035837","label":"Industrial buildings","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036616","label":"Soil","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036955","label":"Research grants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037176","label":"Soil conservation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037179","label":"Soil quality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037238","label":"Streams","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037283","label":"Tax incentives","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:106998","label":"Animal diseases","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42737","label":"Greenhouse gases","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43441","label":"Artificial intelligence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","label":"Programs","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49310","label":"Manufacturing industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501106","label":"Assets","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716680","label":"Contracts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","label":"Greenhouses","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721395","label":"Fuels","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723905","label":"Animal research","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725309","label":"Architecture","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752655","label":"Soil pollution","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76981","label":"Poaching","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80586","label":"Rural development","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","label":"Buildings","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","label":"Poultry","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d4cba8b7d080aece837804457b40214d5acba8b6c7b350380a8c6da2871817df","9c61948222d8a2399232d279caad61c446afeaba8b2198cfd40176365b86a611","cf83faefffd72b41b85c50317913b4f049713eb40824be266c83405e6cd13fb0","5852b4692eda3f938b0b905859e4eb05a6228fb5f04d0d4fde9fc347ba652b07","b04bc09d597b9d776a2da71f9030031a76390220d190f9dd97bd7f8a9d9864a3","676e9dbeea741b95b1fab09259040f340c071c1e50b6a8d711c98a377500b12e","903042dc60a0bce28a7044fc80b2fbaa3c430f616c0fdb8ae2efbfb58a05ce01","62df327146fe4f0c01acee5eaf974b4d91e11bf0ff2edf8c5a911090d75b8bb9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0db8758eb2da5a76d811b76685e9a9c9f8a3edb046eb70d192715f2e747497e8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Greenhouses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43681","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718656","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:85753","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4df8da536e656ffcfbc44402","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752320,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"I didn't ask permission to wear this lovely hat, but I'm going to assume that because\n               it's B.C. Beef Day, today I'm going to be allowed to wear it. All right, chamber. Can I get a yee-haw?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752320","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I didn't ask permission to wear this lovely hat, but I'm going to assume that because\n               it's B.C. Beef Day, today I'm going to be allowed to wear it. All right, chamber. Can I get a yee-haw?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Clothing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Animal husbandry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034507","label":"Clothing","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:722510","label":"Animal husbandry","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4beccef0049ceea39b78639f303e5a6717dd095342f367b35c056251869839ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-085bd8381e91732e64c560b3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752321,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have three folks that I'm going to introduce today. The first two are Jagir Virk and Parminder Virk. They're here in the gallery with\n               us. These two wonderful people started out as constituents, but I now consider them\n               dear, dear friends. They're the most generous folks that I know in Saanich South. They continually give back to community, and I'm just so happy to be able to spend\n               some time with them today. They're accompanied by the woman who runs my constituency office, Kathleen Burton. I don't know what I'd do without you, Kathleen. I'm glad to see you today as well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752321","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have three folks that I'm going to introduce today. The first two are Jagir Virk and Parminder Virk. They're here in the gallery with\n               us. These two wonderful people started out as constituents, but I now consider them\n               dear, dear friends. They're the most generous folks that I know in Saanich South. They continually give back to community, and I'm just so happy to be","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5693a66f4ba4760f7d2d75e910d4af2c605320c92528d26ed11ecdf9592eb762"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-07505f8ee73d61036b7dfe83","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017533,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today at the B.C. Legislature it's B.C. Dairy Day, which means — are you ready? —\n               I scream, you scream...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017533","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today at the B.C. Legislature it's B.C. Dairy Day, which means — are you ready? —\n               I scream, you scream...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036306","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Milk","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034717","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cream","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Dairy products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1033769","label":"Dairy products","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034717","label":"Cream","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036306","label":"Milk","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59475","label":"Dairy industry","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a9c80fd2a6d5bd198a71d6ec330afd7892c99757acdf309a0e75f74ccc621f41"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b3f6ecb1344bd18384a74171","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017536,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce Julia Cameron, Walker Payton, Emma Andrews and Joe de la Plante\n               from the B.C. Craft Cannabis Association and the Cannabis Cultivators of British Columbia. Fun fact: licensed cannabis contributed $1.75 billion to B.C.'s GDP in 2024. Their\n               national exports increased by 120 percent, and the sector directly supports 5,300\n               jobs. You know what? Cannabis producers, at the heart of it, are farmers.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017536","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce Julia Cameron, Walker Payton, Emma Andrews and Joe de la Plante\n               from the B.C. Craft Cannabis Association and the Cannabis Cultivators of British Columbia. Fun fact: licensed cannabis contributed $1.75 billion to B.C.'s GDP in 2024. Their\n               national exports increased by 120 percent, and the sector directly supports 5,300\n               jobs. You kno","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","label":"Marijuana"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","label":"Exports","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","label":"Marijuana","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["459d092f49614a62f39655c317dc133bffa7e0fd1a839495151bf8bf3f2a7c5e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a2a5574d6ceed5468c7468c167e817474d8963d054cd905e84b35b3d18d5f0b4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Exports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Marijuana","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43024","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:78948","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a8f256326545b1fff03c3c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036560,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my great pleasure to welcome the B.C. Poultry Association and their representatives\n               here today. They treated us to breakfast in the back of the Legislature this morning.\n               We want to thank them for that. We know they're set up to meet with many MLAs all\n               day to talk about all of the things that they're concerned about as a poultry association. The poultry association is four different types of poultry — broiler chickens, turkey,\n               eggs and broiler hatchers. They represent $1 billion in farm-gate sales. We can't\n               thank them enough for being part of B.C.'s food security and, of course, our economy\n               here. Mr. Speaker, normally you're not allowed to use props in the Legislature, so I'm just\n               saying that this little chick hanging from my hand here.... This is not a prop; this\n               is a way of life.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poultry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036560","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is my great pleasure to welcome the B.C. Poultry Association and their representatives\n               here today. They treated us to breakfast in the back of the Legislature this morning.\n               We want to thank them for that. We know they're set up to meet with many MLAs all\n               day to talk about all of the things that they're concerned about as a poultry association. The po","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","label":"Poultry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poultry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:168598","label":"Birds","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","label":"Poultry","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["941bfe28d8e860f2cb91c36d12f241df1b420eb5d84987e6b0a400cb419f0415"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poultry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["684d054ea2bc45b26f63ff454e5de6d2a41d71a5aedf5ed5152e6da7d80902ee"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Poultry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97626","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-157afe66605a23ce6f4b5bf3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036561,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lana Popham","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the member bringing up this question. It's a concern to our government as well and to me as Minister of Agriculture. Protecting\n               farmland is essential, obviously, for food security, but it's also essential to protect\n               the integrity of rural communities and for having a place for future farmers to learn\n               how to grow food for us. The concerns I'm hearing are similar to the concerns the member is hearing. We're\n               hearing about corporations investing in agricultural land. This includes concerns\n               about hedge funds, large corporations and non-farm investors purchasing that farmland\n               for activities that do not qualify for farming and also taking that land out of production\n               for farming, even to the extent that there are corporate farms that are planting bait\n               crops for illegal trophy hunting. So I think that the member does have a valid concern. I'm working with the Minister\n               of Finance to better understand the extent of foreign ownership in B.C. My staff have\n               been reaching out and working with the senior officials in Ontario and Saskatchewan\n               to understand the changes that are underway there to address the same situation. We have added tools into our toolbox through the Minister of Finance to understand\n               who is owning land in B.C. and ending the hidden ownership of land in the province,\n               and that does include farmland.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036561","member_id":"bc-mla-61","member_name":"Lana Popham","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I appreciate the member bringing up this question. It's a concern to our government as well and to me as Minister of Agriculture. Protecting\n               farmland is essential, obviously, for food security, but it's also essential to protect\n               the integrity of rural communities and for having a place for future farmers to learn\n               how to grow food for us. The concerns I'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501120","label":"Finance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a43fa5d33c58a41b650b82598c5468668fdc383d701607f3cf63cb9517b85cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.26,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25aeed4bf4f599309b5a788213a13331235eb6fce6f99d0c19b2769e2edfeb77"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c7fd352d521b68ab3884b004","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328039,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm very pleased today to welcome 30 grades 5, 6 and 7 students and their teacher,\n               Crystal Smith, from Aubrey Elementary in Burnaby North. Please join me in making them feel very welcome and to have a really good time here\n               today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328039","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm very pleased today to welcome 30 grades 5, 6 and 7 students and their teacher,\n               Crystal Smith, from Aubrey Elementary in Burnaby North. Please join me in making them feel very welcome and to have a really good time here\n               today.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034926","label":"Health care products","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.84,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a30cdcacbe8634f0d09a650da68856f6baf40145a09685bbabc638e8806edc57"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f0090926421a2972edd83bcf4d6f3f0960868fc3e3472b18126d2b33dc26f16a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b8dcd3fadb559066fa6a7888","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360878,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce seven incredible young women in the gallery today who are part\n               of the Indigenous youth internship program within the government of British Columbia. They are being hosted at the Legislative Assembly on a one-day twinning program by our British Columbia branch of the Commonwealth Women Parliamentarians. While the group is here, they have an opportunity to spend time with women MLAs\n               to learn about our roles and life as women parliamentarians. They are T.J. Dutton, Shania Hills, Angel Houle, Alexis McGilvary, Ashley Stanley, Julia Su\n               and Riley Swan, and they are accompanied by the team leader, Amanda Sylvester. Please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360878","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce seven incredible young women in the gallery today who are part\n               of the Indigenous youth internship program within the government of British Columbia. They are being hosted at the Legislative Assembly on a one-day twinning program by our British Columbia branch of the Commonwealth Women Parliamentarians. While the group is here, they have an opportunity to spend ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","label":"Internships","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","label":"Commonwealth","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a8b787585dd5bbd8ca355af561870adec93c91f90e5735b8e665b310e59393b9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9047d3531f79865a3b1417d81177252ad1d1f9f2a37df977c5bebc7120d29316"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Internships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:112076","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2af74167aaafe92498efedf4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415813,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us today in the gallery from the Lower Mainland is the public policy sector\n               of FortisBC. Please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415813","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Joining us today in the gallery from the Lower Mainland is the public policy sector\n               of FortisBC. Please join me in giving them a very warm welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Food safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Food security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103065","label":"Food safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035334","label":"Food security","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083613","label":"International security","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d0f0b4d60156ab46584ded1ad2dbf01375c2d86ee1299dcbf9afe65ccd90548a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1ebbca17174c13d735f40b79","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721646,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"This is B.C. Creative Industries Week, and we are celebrating a sector that reflects\n               who we are and showcases British Columbia to the world. From music and publishing\n               to video games, film and television, B.C.'s creative industries enrich our lives every\n               day. They are the stories we tell, the music we share, and the experiences that connect\n               us. Together, they provide work for more than 170,000 people, and they contributed $7.4\n               billion to our economy in 2024. They fuel local businesses, draw visitors to our communities\n               and create opportunities for our people. This past year, B.C. talent earned national and international recognition. Cameron\n               Whitcomb won a Juno. B.C.'s animation and visual effects artists contributed to the\n               Oscar-winning films KPop Demon Hunters and Sinners . This year B.C. talent will be featured at the FIFA fan fest, another moment for made-in-B.C.\n               performances to connect with a global audience. Our skilled crews, creators, strong infrastructure, innovation and tax incentives\n               continue to attract film and television productions like The Last of Us . Interactive digital media experienced strong growth this past year. Several titles by B.C. authors and publishers were featured on CBC's best Canadian\n               books of 2025. None of this happens without strong partnerships. I want to thank Creative B.C. and\n               their many partners — Screen B.C., Music B.C., books B.C., Mags BC, DigiBC and many\n               others — for championing this sector. Please join me in celebrating Creative Industries Week. They have made British Columbia\n               shine.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721646","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is B.C. Creative Industries Week, and we are celebrating a sector that reflects\n               who we are and showcases British Columbia to the world. From music and publishing\n               to video games, film and television, B.C.'s creative industries enrich our lives every\n               day. They are the stories we tell, the music we share, and the experiences that connect\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","label":"Cultural industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3c5807ffecd9d19755b06be9d0087167c1697305e198a03daf973581368f7b1c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["349769dbcbb9de0d7957fd3cc4eedf9c77be95275de1379b9c0fd2d17f36221e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42749","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3dcfa4dc7762d53b804feb86","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729420,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729420","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Secondary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037067","label":"Secondary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57683","label":"Secondary education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bff8a4571e1c2047d67b79309d862bc6651324b4db6edf1c41a48427d07950a1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bf7c2f2618b86bbf4be20a1a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729424,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to share the story of a local hero. Pat Curley is a lifelong Burnaby\n               resident and a retired firefighter. He retired from the Coquitlam fire department\n               in 2021, and ever since, he's been enjoying a quiet life in Burnaby North. On October 5, 2025, Pat was busy watching baseball on TV when he heard a loud noise.\n               He went out to see what was going on. A small crowd was gathered around a car that\n               had crashed into a large tree. Inside, behind the driver's wheel, was a woman. She\n               appeared elderly. She appeared unconscious. Had she lost control of the car while\n               driving down Dundas Street? Pat could see that the airbags had deployed. The car had\n               caught on fire, and the fire was already spreading to the tree. The crowd of bystanders remained a safe distance away and seemed paralyzed, except\n               for the one person who was filming what was going on. Pat quickly understood that\n               the woman was trapped inside the car and kicked into action. Equipped with only a\n               garden hose and without hesitating, Pat tried to rescue the motionless woman from\n               her burning car. He soon discovered that the driver's side door was crushed and not\n               accessible. He was able to gain access through the passenger door, which had been\n               pushed open from the impact of the massive tree. Pat climbed into the smoky car, unbuckled the driver's seatbelt and dragged her out.\n               A bystander grabbed hold of her legs, and together they carried her to safety. The\n               Burnaby fire department, station No. 5, soon arrived as did the RCMP and the paramedics\n               who took the driver to hospital. Please join me in thanking Pat Curley for his fast thinking and commitment to the\n               preservation of human life. Once a firefighter, always a firefighter. Even in retirement,\n               his instincts are to run towards a fire so that others can escape it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729424","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to share the story of a local hero. Pat Curley is a lifelong Burnaby\n               resident and a retired firefighter. He retired from the Coquitlam fire department\n               in 2021, and ever since, he's been enjoying a quiet life in Burnaby North. On October 5, 2025, Pat was busy watching baseball on TV when he heard a loud noise.\n               He went out to see what was goi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","label":"Road accidents","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["16a50a38d3d9d729228509fe95c0dd3a549aa17b6ddfd5e11aae8e2aef65e0b7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b110d033036c88abdaaef4fc1c4b13d9bde39f28aaaeb3d7a39e9691323eb10e"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036984","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c6e928e5eb2313f046e9956a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752329,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize Mining Month and to thank the people who help build British\n               Columbia and our economy. Across our province, more than 40,000 people work in mining.\n               They are equipment operators, tradespeople, engineers, geologists, safety professionals\n               and many others who keep this sector booming. They earn an average annual salary of\n               $130,000 and help support families and communities throughout B.C. But mining is not only about numbers. It is about the early mornings, the long shifts\n               and the chance to build a good life close to home. It is also about partnership. During\n               Mining Month, we thank our union partners, like the United Steel Workers, Unifor and\n               the International Union of Operating Engineers, for their advocacy and work to ensure\n               that mining remains the safest heavy industry in B.C. We also thank our Indigenous partners and First Nations, local governments, exploration\n               teams, contractors, suppliers, small businesses and community leaders who all play\n               an important role in the success of our world-leading mining and critical minerals\n               sector. And there is real momentum. In 2025, more than $750 million was spent exploring new\n               mines in British Columbia, an historic high and a strong sign of confidence in our\n               province and in the people who make this work possible. So today, we recognize every worker, every partner behind mining in our province.\n               Their work helps power our economy, strengthen our communities and build B.C.'s future.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752329","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize Mining Month and to thank the people who help build British\n               Columbia and our economy. Across our province, more than 40,000 people work in mining.\n               They are equipment operators, tradespeople, engineers, geologists, safety professionals\n               and many others who keep this sector booming. They earn an average annual salary of\n          ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53dd87ec390f806a382f3c32bca91c08a429e6979ca4d047b748d0caeb5d53fa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8a01e417eafc5154adc2805d064a574b3a03e5e0b8099fe72d7f59f71d05d93"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e3c2ac1ef0123dd833fe24e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752330,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752330","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2957c7144d58519e84a096ead0c0c486902e5ddbed122052ac4632ee7d015b8c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-59de99ba1758c9e776096398","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752331,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's really great that so many members got to introduce their constituency staff\n               in the chamber this week. But of course, our dear friend the member for Vancouver-Strathcona has not been able to do that. In fact, her staff were not able to come to the CA\n               conference because they have been at her side throughout her illness, at home, at\n               the office and in the hospital. So please join me in thanking Tyler Petersen, Mason Kerr, and Sylvia Wu for their\n               kindness, their loyalty, and their commitment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752331","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It's really great that so many members got to introduce their constituency staff\n               in the chamber this week. But of course, our dear friend the member for Vancouver-Strathcona has not been able to do that. In fact, her staff were not able to come to the CA\n               conference because they have been at her side throughout her illness, at home, at\n               the office and in ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45497","label":"Charitable organizations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["daea6e38f72f66fc497aceffdfea045ee582916450b0dbecfd04a78be22354ff"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-242ca454105a4558acdaf51e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017581,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017581","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42ef593676629f6d4fe1f8d14a0f69b3ac57eb28e6b58306b8ad842a73dc8b61"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f344cfaa0694e2ba79fda2ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036570,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to introduce you to Penny Leclair. Penny is deaf and blind, but she doesn't\n               let herself be defined by either sensory challenge. Penny is a tireless advocate for\n               the rights and needs of the deafblind. In fact, that's how I met her. For nine years, Penny had a guide dog who helped her navigate the world and kept her\n               safe, both privately and in public. He was a golden Lab, and his name was Jefferson.\n               According to Penny, Jefferson For nine years, Penny had a guide dog who helped her navigate the world, kept her\n               safe, both privately and in public. He was a Golden Lab, and his name was Jefferson. According to Penny, Jefferson was more than a guide dog. She describes him as an extraordinary\n               being and their relationship as complicated. Over the years, Penny got to know the\n               inner workings of Jefferson's mind, whose thoughts might best be revealed when he\n               was doing something one might consider wrong. Jefferson could multi-task and set aside his canine instincts. For example, he made\n               a conscious decision to overcome his fear of escalators so he wouldn't jump and throw\n               her off balance. He figured out how to help pick up his toys every night so their\n               robotic vacuum could clean up excessive amounts of his dog hair. He learned how to\n               find her reserved seat on a train. Penny remembers him as having remarkable self-control. She recalls him being taunted\n               by a bunch of cats, but he knew he was on duty and couldn't engage with them. Jefferson\n               was very self-disciplined. He had a plan for managing his food and water intake and\n               control of his bodily functions. Penny remembers how strategic he was in his fluid\n               management during a cross-Canada train trip. After Jefferson's recent passing, Penny and her husband Paul felt compelled to share\n               his story with the world, so they wrote a book. It's called Life with Jefferson . I've read it. I enjoyed it, and I learned lots about interspecies relationships.\n               I hope you will too.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Deafness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036570","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I'd like to introduce you to Penny Leclair. Penny is deaf and blind, but she doesn't\n               let herself be defined by either sensory challenge. Penny is a tireless advocate for\n               the rights and needs of the deafblind. In fact, that's how I met her. For nine years, Penny had a guide dog who helped her navigate the world and kept her\n               safe, both privately and in pu","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","label":"Deafness"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Rail transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Deafness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","label":"Deafness","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036864","label":"Rail transport","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cae7c6b6af8298a1c3bc74ad0c5456dfb69b8c2ca6d54383a888ee6f93e503b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Deafness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["53f1c9f741fe6feb91945d59f7986379ad90ab63cd9eb71634730335ecbfaa39"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Deafness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034781","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-51367ab9f2414f1dade16261","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036571,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Janet Routledge","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is such a pleasure that I have today to welcome and introduce Keiran Ellis, the\n               assistant to the Deputy Speaker and government caucus events coordinator, and Helena\n               Keenliside, who is the government Whip's assistant. They work behind the scenes to\n               hold our caucus together. They do their work under unprecedented and unpredictable\n               circumstances and make important, last-minute decisions. I really want them to know how much I, and we, appreciate their support, their commitment,\n               their quick-wittedness, their kindness and their humour. They are a team, and they\n               are part of a larger team.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036571","member_id":"bc-mla-67","member_name":"Janet Routledge","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is such a pleasure that I have today to welcome and introduce Keiran Ellis, the\n               assistant to the Deputy Speaker and government caucus events coordinator, and Helena\n               Keenliside, who is the government Whip's assistant. They work behind the scenes to\n               hold our caucus together. They do their work under unprecedented and unpredictable\n               circum","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083603","label":"Organizations","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a863cb5ba9cd554581aaf8b3775c89e6e02504372ca1fdd48016afbc93ff7aa9"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-569b2bf7b775c7aad956ddaf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316786,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is to speak to the budget, Mr. Speaker, so I will wait my turn.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316786","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"It is to speak to the budget, Mr. Speaker, so I will wait my turn.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bb01d03872121e9f6bc391b51abc77ac35264398fada37f263bf82ae7e6d425a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c9285f5c6adcdb7607ad21fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327903,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Well, it's been a stellar day here in question period. Let's review for a minute.\n               We got a Minister of Indigenous Affairs who wasn't invited to the table with the feds\n               while they were negotiating. It's been 12 days, almost two weeks. Still has no idea\n               what's going on. While we were rearranging clocks, because that is what British Columbians really,\n               really need.... You know you're desperate for votes when you talk about clocks and daylight\n               saving time. It's incredible.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327903","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Well, it's been a stellar day here in question period. Let's review for a minute.\n               We got a Minister of Indigenous Affairs who wasn't invited to the table with the feds\n               while they were negotiating. It's been 12 days, almost two weeks. Still has no idea\n               what's going on. While we were rearranging clocks, because that is what British Columbians really,\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Perinatal care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","label":"Daylight saving time","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:288344","label":"Perinatal care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ec8a3a5d99e10674df5f2fed9c794678026dbb544005a7401af067a01076ec58"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["50feb74854d7be32224384ddb6b073a278e1a85e525b65a554d596cd8635ff36"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Daylight saving time","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083681","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e9a15d5f1bcdbb550c792d2e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327904,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much, and happy birthday, Mr. Speaker. I would like to introduce two guests joining us in the gallery today, Mr. Neil Dobson,\n               director for British Columbia with Clean Prosperity, and Mr. Adam Sweet, vice-president\n               for Western Canada. For those who don't know, Clean Prosperity is a Canadian organization focused on advancing\n               practical solutions that reduce emissions while supporting economic growth. Their\n               work contributes to important conversations around climate policy and innovation right\n               here in British Columbia and across Canada. Would the House please welcome them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327904","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you very much, and happy birthday, Mr. Speaker. I would like to introduce two guests joining us in the gallery today, Mr. Neil Dobson,\n               director for British Columbia with Clean Prosperity, and Mr. Adam Sweet, vice-president\n               for Western Canada. For those who don't know, Clean Prosperity is a Canadian organization focused on advancing\n               practical solut","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Climate change","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034499","label":"Climate change","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035130","label":"Environmental programs","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c56def2a45ef8fdf6b3c2b7296719e385186d16abf39ea67b916470d27f005d6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4e9d0bd16a0abdabfd6e20d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327905,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"This House has heard me talk often about my grandchildren, and one of them, it is\n               her birthday today. She's half a world away fulfilling her dream as a marine biologist. I just want to say happy birthday, Kenadee. I love you. I'm proud of you. And who\n               knew that buying the Disney mermaid stuff would make you into a marine biologist?\n               I hope you're happy under the sea.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327905","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"This House has heard me talk often about my grandchildren, and one of them, it is\n               her birthday today. She's half a world away fulfilling her dream as a marine biologist. I just want to say happy birthday, Kenadee. I love you. I'm proud of you. And who\n               knew that buying the Disney mermaid stuff would make you into a marine biologist?\n               I hope you're happy u","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic ecosystems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic animals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Aquatic wildlife","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726667","label":"Aquatic animals","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727340","label":"Aquatic ecosystems","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728297","label":"Aquatic wildlife","probability":0.33,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["023c43662c1006512c372440318117a861ff63088d5acda252913a34bffcf59b"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-622be406120249cc255d52e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327906,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's always a pleasure to be able to respond to a bill. In this case, it's Bill 2.\n               I'll be speaking about the failures and concerns surrounding the 2026 British Columbia\n               Budget Measures Implementation Act. While budgets are intended to guide a province towards economic stability and improved\n               public services, this particular bill, this legislation in front of this House, raises\n               several very serious concerns. Rather than strengthening British Columbia's long-term\n               financial health and improving affordability, critics argue that the 2026 implementation\n               act introduces policies that actually may increase financial pressure on residents\n               and businesses, delay important infrastructure and create uncertainty about this province's\n               economic future. Now, I know that we talk an awful lot in this building, and there is always sort of....\n               Well, one side spins, and then the other side counter-spins. But I think it's important\n               to hear what those from outside of this building actually have to say, and I would\n               like to read into the record some of them. Let's start with the media. Rob Shaw says: \"B.C.'s new budget hikes taxes to generate more than $800 million in\n               revenue, with increases to personal income tax and the PST scope, but still projects\n               a record-breaking $13.3 billion deficit and skyrocketing debt levels, and it holds\n               line on education, health and spending.\" That was Rob Shaw. \"B.C. is raising personal income tax on the first $50,363 to try and generate new\n               revenue as the budget sinks in red,\" also Rob Shaw. \"It's the first time the lowest\n               income tax bracket has been raised since 2000, when the B.C. Liberals first took power,\"\n               Rob Shaw. The Times Colonist : \"The B.C. budget brings public service cuts, delays to Vancouver Island projects.\n               Highlights from 2026 B.C. budget? Growing deficit, tax hike and PST changes.\" Les Leyne: \"Tax adjustments coming to offset projected deficit jump in B.C. budget.\" The CBC: \"The B.C. budget increases tax increases — 15,000 public job cuts projected\n               and a $13 billion deficit.\" The CTV: \"This fiscal year B.C.'s deficit is expected to reach $13.3 billion, the\n               highest it has ever been.\" The Vancouver Sun The CTV: \"This fiscal year, B.C.'s deficit is expected to reach $13.3 billion, the\n               highest it has ever been.\" The Vancouver Su n : \"Higher taxes, more debt: five ways the 2026 B.C. budget will affect you.\" The Globe and Mail .... Not really, so far, a stellar review thus far, on this budget, from the press. The Globe and Mail : \"B.C. budget projects record-breaking $9.6 billion deficit, rising to $13.3 billion\n               next year.\" I could go on and on. Mo Amir: \"David Eby's entire premiership can be summarized by\n               B.C.'s 2026-27 budget: no vision, just managed decline, self-contradictory, no principles,\n               no consistency....\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327906","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's always a pleasure to be able to respond to a bill. In this case, it's Bill 2.\n               I'll be speaking about the failures and concerns surrounding the 2026 British Columbia\n               Budget Measures Implementation Act. While budgets are intended to guide a province towards economic stability and improved\n               public services, this particular bill, this legislation in fro","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"National debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Drought","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036383","label":"National debt","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41849","label":"Drought","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","label":"Income tax","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","label":"Debt","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f442326fcd3b78dcd72468d7bf53f502f54c8eaeca1464a6a2e00af7cd50a1af"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b47659a2eef9fc2e13cc1d27046d91d9fbd3cad88b82ad74cf57bbbfec5f5f21"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Debt","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43471","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715726","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ee4b911169a17e9c21eb2638","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358946,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"In my riding of Abbotsford South, temporary foreign workers are a huge component of what goes on in Abbotsford South because of its large agricultural base. Quite frankly, I don't know that the work that needs to be done could be done without\n               them. And while I'm speaking on Bill 10, Labour Statutes Amendment Act, I think it's\n               important that we pay tribute to the temporary foreign workers that come up and help\n               feed us. Some of these workers.... I believe the longest case that I have heard is the same worker\n               had been returning for over 30 years to work on the same farm. I've talked with the\n               farmers, and they become family. Their birthdates are celebrated. There are events\n               that happen and they become not just employees, but trusted members that really are\n               part of the farm itself. And most of the farmers that I would speak to would say,\n               absolutely, the rights of temporary foreign workers need to be protected. Like in most things in life, there are good employees, there are good employers and\n               then there are those that are not so good. The vast majority, however, are employers\n               that want to do the right thing. They value.... You know, if you're going to bring someone\n               back for 30 years running, clearly you value that work ethic that comes with that.\n               The fact that that employee literally becomes a vital part of how your operation works,\n               and that's just on a farm. We also know that we have temporary foreign workers that do other jobs, whether that\n               be in seasonal.... We take a look at here in Victoria. We've gone out for lunch or dinner\n               and it's been a temporary foreign worker that's looked after us. Sometimes they bring other languages with them, which are particularly important when\n               you get into resorts such as Whistler-Blackcomb or other areas. Sometimes they have some distinct advantages. For instance, if they come from the\n               wine industry themselves, we'll see them sometimes in areas of the Okanagan. They're not always low-paid jobs either. Some of them are brought in because of the\n               high skills that they possess. So we have a tendency to think of temporary foreign\n               workers as those that somehow fulfil a need that nobody else really wants to do. In\n               some cases, it's because of the very skills that they have that they're brought in\n               to fill a niche here in British Columbia that would otherwise go unfilled. They are\n               an incredibly important part of our economy. And this side of the House, for the most part, celebrates the strengthening of those\n               to make sure that those very few bad actors that either purposely take advantage of\n               someone or, more often I would say, inadvertently, that there should be a dispute\n               mechanism for both the temporary foreign workers, and workers for that matter, and\n               employers so that justice is actually served. We want to make sure that the employees have timely access to being paid for what\n               they did, the labour that they put in. They deserve to be paid and compensated for\n               what they did, and it needs to happen in a timely manner. Employers also deserve to have in a dispute — and quite often there can be disputes\n               for many different reasons — also deserve a timely manner in which that dispute is\n               settled. I think both sides of the House would agree that if there is a claim, especially\n               if you are, and we have heard stories.... If you are a worker that needs to Sadly, that has not been happening. Shame on this government for not figuring that\n               out. It takes — what was it? —180 days for.... So thirty-two percent of the cases take\n               more than six months. That is a failure by this House to ensure that those disputes\n               are settled in a timely manner. And I applaud the ability to try and speed this up. However, there are some issues. One of the issues is that this budget freezes the\n               labour program's funding at $22.3 million for the next three years. That's actually\n               a decrease, if you include inflation, over the next three years. And it's actually\n               lower than last year's budget of $22.85 million. That was in the estimates. So, this\n               is NDP logic or NDP math: they somehow expect to get better results and not actually\n               fund it to be able to get the results. They're actually lowering the funding and somehow\n               magically expecting that this process is going to speed up. It defies logic. It defies common sense. And it defies what is most likely going to\n               be possible. I would suspect that things are going to get worse, not better. It's\n               kind of like the budget itself. It got worse, not better. I also heard that there has been a 95 percent rise in complaints. Well, let's just\n               absorb that for a minute. So there's been a rise in complaints. We're going to spend\n               less money, and expect better results. And they want a target rate of 80 percent.\n               It just doesn't add up. It just doesn't seem to work if you take and apply the logic. Results are not made on wishes and best hopes. Good results are made on good planning.\n               And what this side of the House will say to you is there is a lack of good planning\n               to get the desired results that are wanted. Does not make sense, and it doesn't add\n               up. Because it just plain doesn't. It's totally illogical. And wishes don't necessarily\n               make things happen. There's a few other things. So let's start off with that: that I believe that this\n               particular vehicle that they want to use has already got a gas tank that's pretty\n               much empty. We're not going to get to the destination that we want because we have\n               not bothered to put in what is required to actually make it work. I believe it's destined\n               to fail, with the best of intentions. But the best of intentions don't get the job\n               done, sadly, much of the time. In the event that an employer owes an employee wages, and they're unable to locate\n               that employee, the director may now then take possession of the wages after attempting\n               to locate them themselves. Previously, the director could only take the wages after\n               a year of attempting to locate them. And we have already heard this economy is in dire straits. The vast majority of this\n               will be small businesses, for one reason or another, because small businesses make\n               up the vast majority of businesses. It makes logic that the number one complaint is\n               going to be through small businesses. Small businesses are the backbone of our economy. Small businesses are struggling\n               right now for a number of reasons, whether that be, as we have heard, theft through\n               shoplifting. We had London Drugs recently close down its Vancouver location because\n               the amount of theft that was going on has forced them to close a location. They are not alone. We have had places like Williams Lake announce a state of emergency.\n               I believe it was Williams Lake. It could be a number of small towns, actually. Things\n               are so bad. This government has not managed to fix that. As a matter of fact, under\n               its watch, it's gotten much, much worse. For small businesses to then increase this and say, \"You know what, you have to buck\n               this up now,\" it actually could put an unintended consequence on a business. It's\n               not that the business doesn't want to pay them. Sometimes it's an inability to do\n               it at that particular moment. I think that what it does is that it makes it a little\n               bit too rigid on some small businesses, as we have heard by other speakers. I'm not so sure that I agree with the director being able to immediately go while\n               the employer themselves is looking for that particular employee. I don't know that\n               we need to go to that drastic step. I have not heard evidence that that was a particular\n               problem. I'm not so sure why this particular piece of legislation was put in at a time when\n               and businesses are already under hardships. We've heard the term \"death by a thousand\n               cuts.\" Is this just one more paper cut, one more cut that's going to put a burden\n               unnecessarily on some small businesses? Right now losing one is one too many. Employees deserve to be paid. This side of the House is in 100 percent agreement on\n               that. But where is the latitude for businesses that are clinging on? It may or may\n               not happen in a particular case, but what in the case that it is? Is there any latitude\n               at all so that a business could, say, throughout the year, as an example, pay up for\n               that if they're having hard times? And then you also don't understand sometimes why an employee will necessarily disappear,\n               never to come back. For that money to just vanish into basically government coffers,\n               it's a hidden tax, in a way. It's actually never going to get to the intended person\n               that it was supposed to benefit. What is government going to do with all that money? Is it going to just go into general\n               revenue so that it can go towards gift cards the government was passing around to\n               employees? If it's general revenue, it potentially could go towards that. So I think\n               that that particular one is probably a little bit too rigid. The other one that is, is that if an employer.... Not all employees will necessarily\n               file a claim that is necessarily accurate. Yet, in this particular case, if an employer\n               wants to actually appeal the case, they have to put up the entire amount up front.\n               Now, if this is a low-wage issue and it's a few hundred dollars, well, that's not\n               a big deal. But what if it goes to one of those high-profile, highly educated individuals that\n               I was just talking about? Some of them are making hundreds of thousands of dollars,\n               because there is no niche for them. There is no place for them within.... There is there\n               is a lack of an educated skilled employee to take that particular issue. Now, there\n               could be a case where that could be a huge amount of money that now the business has\n               to put up front just to appeal it Now, there could be a case where that could be a huge amount of money that now the\n               business has to put up front just to appeal it. In those cases, it could very well\n               cause that business to go: \"We can't afford to fight this. We're just going to have\n               to take it. We're just going to have to put up with it because we do not.... Because\n               we've got to put the money up front, we just do not have the cash flow right now to\n               be able to dispute this.\" It puts an unnecessary burden.... I would much prefer to see some kind of amount.... A\n               maximum, a threshold of some kind, I think, would be perhaps in better keeping with\n               the spirit of this law. And again, the spirit of the law is to make sure that those\n               that are owed wages get them. The spirit of the law is not.... Where I go with this is, if the appeal is successful,\n               that business has now had to put up a considerable amount of money, perhaps, depending\n               on the case. Like I said, it's not always minimum-wage jobs that we're talking about.\n               And that could put that business at an unnecessary hardship. What requires in this, as in many things in life.... What I've seen as a trend within\n               this government is a lack of balance, a lack of fairness. We have a tendency to treat\n               employers, of which the vast majority are good employers, as if somehow they are nefarious\n               and that they are always trying to find a way to mess somebody over and not have to\n               pay what they agreed to. In some cases, there's that balancing act required where there are also employees\n               who either intentionally or unintentionally think that they are owed money. That's\n               why we have a tribunal of this sort. It's why we have a director to make these decisions\n               in these particular cases. It is not always in favour of the employee. Sometimes the\n               decision is in favour of the employer. We want to make sure that it is balanced and fair and lightning speed in cases like\n               this. Especially, as I said, if it is about an employee that has payments of some\n               kind due. And we don't know what those payments are. Waiting six months to get paid is not timely under anyone's standards. We can do better\n               than that. It needs to be quicker. It needs to be faster. And as I said, reducing\n               the budget, not accounting for inflation, with a 95 percent increase in complaints\n               — according to the minister that just spoke — there just doesn't seem any way that\n               we can go from A to Z to get that and speed it up. Now, even if that target that government has laid out is achieved, it still means\n               approximately one in five workers, based on what I've heard, could still wait longer\n               than six months to see a resolution. How is that protecting vulnerable workers? It\n               isn't. It's an epic failure. We have to do better than that. And you have to ask yourself: \"Is this remotely just or acceptable?\" And, as was mentioned,\n               if now the pressure comes on, \"you've got to solve this, you have to have a decision,\"\n               will you then have a director that's a director or an adjudicator that is now making\n               decisions based on a timeline versus on what's actual and required? We look forward\n               to digging deeper into this as this bill moves forward. You know, the vast majority of employers not only follow the rules but want to follow\n               them. The vast majority of employers not only follows the rules but wants to follow the\n               rules. And I believe that good legislation supports both employers and employees yet\n               holds the few bad apples or bad actors accountable, be they employers or employees. Now, the other thing that seems to happen an awful lot with this particular government\n               is they come up with a great idea — at least, they think it's a great idea — and they\n               forget to do that one vital thing, which is to get stakeholders in a room and actually\n               consult. Actually say: \"Okay, if we do this, what's the downside? What are we missing? Is this\n               even a good idea at all? Who are we going to hurt if we...? This is the goal we want.\n               How do we get there, and how do we do it without some unintended consequences?\" The smartest individual I ever worked for always used to say: \"The devil is always\n               in the details.\" And the best way to get those details is by having meaningful, wholesome discussion. It's partly why we do what we do here. This side of the House's job, while negative in nature, is to say: \"Look, we see some\n               shortcomings with this particular legislation, and has government thought about this?\"\n               Has government, for instance, thought about the unnecessary burden it's going to put\n               on employers if they have to pay money up front? Has it thought about the horrific burden it's putting on an employee if they've\n               got to wait over six months to get their money? Consultation would go to both parties and say: \"How do we speed this process up? And\n               what's the best way to achieve the results we want?\" Something that happens within\n               60 days, let's say. Sometimes even that's too long for some employees. \"How can we\n               get the desired results...?\" Yet what's missing once again is consultation. So part of that consultation could have been when they were talking to small businesses, who may struggle with the new appeal deposit requirement and having to pay the entire\n               amount up front just to appeal it, versus.... Perhaps a portion of it up front would be a much better way. Perhaps there could have been a scaling, depending\n               on what that amount is. Again, I think the assumption in this is that this is going to be minimum-wage-type stuff. And as I said before, there are temporary foreign workers that are highly\n               skilled, and actually their remuneration is quite.... They're well-paid for what they\n               do. So we would like to see, on this side of the House, a way to make this legislation\n               actually better. We are most likely going to put forward a few amendments, and we\n               hope that that side of the House sees in the nature in which it is. We value, as I said to you before, Madam Speaker.... In my riding of Abbotsford, we\n               could not survive without temporary foreign workers. Crops would literally rot and\n               would not get harvested. Cows would not get milked. And the feather industry would\n               also be in trouble as well, in some cases. It is a vital component of the backbone of my riding, which is agriculture. We want\n               to make sure that these temporary foreign workers are well compensated for what they do and that they want to come back, as I mentioned. And my example of 30 years actually is not unusual. I have heard time and time again\n               when I talk to some of the temporary foreign workers when I go out on the fields....\n               \"How long have you been here?\" Ten-plus years is not uncommon. It's not like they come here for one year and then never come\n               back. So these employers want them. They want those valuable skills, because they know that\n               the crops are in good hands with the people that actually know what they're doing,\n               familiar with the operation. They want to keep them here. And they do not Making sure these temporary workers have decent standards, have decent pay and are\n               compensated for what was the agreement — both sides of the House have no argument\n               with that. Again, I think that there are, just to surmise, a few things.... We need to make sure\n               that this is timely in manner. Six months is not okay, in anybody's world. It's not\n               okay to employer. It's not okay to employee. We want to make sure that it does not\n               put an unnecessary burden on the employer. There are cases in this where you don't\n               want to see any cracks, and it could do that. We want to make sure that we speed the\n               process up and that, most importantly, it's just and it's fair. This side of the House wants to support this. We will probably make some recommendations\n               that go forward to improve upon it. And I hope that that side of the House takes it\n               in the true spirit in which it will be intended, which is to make sure that it's fair\n               to both sides of this party, because from that you actually get true justice and you\n               get good legislation. It's always a pleasure, Madam Speaker, to speak in this House and thank you very much\n               for your time.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358946","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In my riding of Abbotsford South, temporary foreign workers are a huge component of what goes on in Abbotsford South because of its large agricultural base. Quite frankly, I don't know that the work that needs to be done could be done without\n               them. And while I'm speaking on Bill 10, Labour Statutes Amendment Act, I think it's\n               important that we pay tribute to the tempo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","label":"Employers","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c708bde145b0390c26093ab7e082605eb17d67d0b144e0279ba3f2deda58225e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.51,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4d7f2ecd83597305271e98e68e8ac65d9ab5cd5d59df2cd297087d65c0fd526b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Employers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51772","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cddbb9e23830047ef36a9a0d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358947,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"For those at home that enjoy watching the Legislative Assembly, we are discussing\n               Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026.\n               I highly recommend they take the two hours, not quite, to listen to the member from\n               Saanich North and the Islands. Probably one of the most succinct speeches I have seen in here on privacy and importance\n               of this legislation and what's before here. And just to give people.... Like, why would you want to sit through one hour and 45\n               minutes of this? I will just bait them with a few things. You're going to hear amazing\n               words, such as \"gobsmacked.\" I believe \"balderdash\" was in there. There is an Academy\n               Award, I believe, that was put down for one of the sections in this. But in all sincerity, it actually impresses upon us.... The member took us through a\n               history because he was there. And he stressed upon the importance of why freedom of\n               information actually matters. And it is important. And transparency in government.... We are at an all-time high for mistrust in government. An all-time high. And not in\n               a good way. It's nothing to be proud of. And what this legislation does, is it will\n               further increase the mistrust, I believe, in this institution, in democracy itself. Freedom of information is often embarrassing. It's often not in government's best\n               interest. But every now and again it actually has an unintended consequence. So I\n               want to share with this House what happened to me personally and why freedom of information\n               is important and how it relates to Bill 9. It's been used in this House by members opposite to try to embarrass, to point a finger\n               at me and to basically sully my name or my character. And it hasn't just been done\n               by members opposite, it's been done by others as well. It goes back to when I was a mayor. I think I was a mayor all of about six months.\n               Six whole months, sitting in the chair. I'd never been in public office before. I remember the day I was sitting in my office\n               and I was still practising chiropractic at that point. I remember I put in a few hours\n               at my practice, and then I went running to city hall as I normally did I remember the day I was sitting in my office. I was still practicing chiropractic\n               at that point. I remember I put in a few hours at my practice, and I went running\n               to city hall as I normally did. I got a phone call from someone from the Salvation\n               Army. I will leave them out of it. They said: \"Hey Bruce, are you in your office right\n               now?\" I said: \"You know I'm always here for you. Come on up.\" They said: \"Great. I'm\n               in the parking lot. I'll be right up.\" What happened is the next question when they got there and we exchanged pleasantries....\n               They said: \"Do you have any idea what's going on across the street from the Salvation\n               Army right now?\" I said: \"No. Please tell me.\" \"Well, city staff is actually spreading\n               manure, chicken manure, where a homeless encampment had been, where a homeless encampment\n               actually had been dismantled,\" which was a cat and mouse game that had been going\n               on for long before I got there. I was absolutely horrified. I said: \"You've got to be kidding me.\" They said: \"No,\n               no. I kind of wish that I was kidding.\" That was the response. Sure enough, that's\n               exactly what was going on. Here's how it relates to freedom of information. Well, it became a massive public\n               embarrassment for the city, and it became a massive embarrassment for myself. I was\n               the mayor. Everybody expected that somehow the mayor had said: \"That's what you've\n               got to do. Get them out of there and do something so they don't come back.\" I ended up being in front of a scrum of cameras. This is again my first.... Really,\n               I was still kind of new at this. A scrum of cameras as you can imagine.... Actually,\n               the first day, city manager said: \"Look, you've got nothing to do with this. Bad news\n               comes from staff, good news comes from mayor and council. We got this.\" I said: \"I\n               don't think so, not in this case.\" I ended up having to stand in front of cameras and apologize on behalf of the city,\n               because I was the one responsible at the end of the day for the actions of all the\n               employees of the city. I was the mayor. Now here's where an FOI, actually, as embarrassing and as horrible as that particular\n               event was.... Here was the unintended consequence for myself. Although it doesn't get\n               talked about much, you can imagine that I had to turn in my phone, I had to turn in\n               my computer, because the FOIs came hard, quick and rapid from every single newspaper\n               that was looking for a way because they figured for sure this had to have come from\n               a politician. The mayor had to have ordered it. It turned out, no. I was exonerated, although I still wear it to this day. It turned\n               out that it was actually staff members that had done it. They had gotten together.\n               As an elected official, you can't name a staff member, because you know what happens\n               if you do that? The city would end up having to pay damages because you make someone\n               unhirable and they will not be able to get a job anywhere else. There are those that say, well, perhaps that's exactly what should have happened.\n               But I ended up standing there apologizing on behalf of the city, which I would do\n               again today. I apologized on behalf of the city. I took responsibility for it, even\n               though I didn't do it. Later on, it was the FOIs that actually proved that I did not. Now, how that relates to this bill is what's buried in here. As we heard from the\n               member from Saanich North and the Islands, it's that being embarrassed is not a good enough reason not to have freedom of information. It could very well have gone that people said: \"Aha, we were right.\" They weren't,\n               not in this case. But I believe to this day that the press had a right to figure out\n               who was ultimately responsible for that, and they did that through freedom of information.\n               It was highly embarrassing. It was perhaps what we have seen in this is that this government has used the things\n               malicious or abusive. There were a few reporters that were absolutely abusive in their\n               insistence of digging deeper and deeper and deeper and the broad scope in which they\n               had looked for.... That's not good enough. I'm living proof that that is not good enough. The public had a right to know, and\n               the press had a right to know how that decision was made, what got to that decision.\n               It eventually did come out. And yes, city management tried to do what they could.\n               This is what governments do. They try and pivot and push and find a different reason\n               to say: \"Well, there's nothing to look at here.\" But in this particular case, the\n               truth did come out. Now, I'm not thrilled with it, because I still to this day end up wearing that. I\n               have had members on the other side here use that, and we've heard insults that have\n               been hurled across. That's okay. I took this job on, and this is part of the history\n               that goes on. Sometimes we inadvertently get blamed for things that really are not\n               our fault, but that's the life we chose. The very nature of government is to try and hide embarrassing things from seeing the\n               light of day. And as we heard from the previous speaker, or the speaker prior to them,\n               there are valid reasons why democracy needs to understand how decisions are made,\n               whether or not there was wrongdoing, who was responsible for the wrongdoing, or even\n               if it's to gather information as to how government came to make its decision. I've got to tell you my life was put through absolute hell during that time frame.\n               I was accused of things that I did not do, and I just stood there, and I had to take\n               it. Especially in a case where you don't have the ability to name a staff member.\n               Nor do you have the ability to even name if that staff member was sanctioned or punished\n               for that, for whatever incident it may have been. In this case, it turned out there were more than one involved in the ultimate decision.\n               But the public and the press have a right to transparency. They have a right to know\n               what the truth is. They have a right to know how we get to decisions, what the advice\n               of staff was in a particular case in a decision, whether we, the politicians, like\n               the results of that or not. It's what keeps democracy transparent and truthful, and that's an important principle.\n               What we have heard in here is that there are words such as — and I want to go over\n               a couple of them, which I think are the most outrageous — the term \"malicious.\" Well,\n               malicious, based on whom and on what opinion? I'll tell you what. At the time, I thought that was pretty malicious, having I'll tell you what. At the time, I thought that was pretty malicious having to turn\n               in my phone. I thought it was abusive, and I thought it unreasonably interfered with\n               the operations of my city. It's not a good enough reason, ever. We need to be certain that we use our powers that we have in here to actually build\n               trust with the public, to actually build the openness and transparency upon which\n               decisions are made. We do some good work here. Sadly, what most people experience when they listen to\n               what happens is they catch the question of the question period of the day. They don't\n               actually hear necessarily the joint committee work, as was discussed by the member\n               for Saanich North and the Islands. They don't hear about the good joint work and the recommendations and the hard work\n               that's done, because what catches everyone's eye is the 30 minutes of question period,\n               not the 30 minutes of answer period, by the way. Rarely is there a good answer, in\n               my experience thus far. And that's really not what goes on most of the time in the\n               committee work. This particular act.... It's the natural instinct of government and of staff to protect\n               us. I know that's what my staff try to do. Good news comes from mayor and council;\n               bad news comes from staff. Good news comes from Premier and ministers; bad news comes\n               from staff. It's how the system works, because the very nature of staff is to try\n               and protect those they work for, to try and shield them because quite often in this\n               business, we are under a microscope. But protecting us who have chosen this life,\n               have chosen public service, is in no way, shape or form a good enough reason to reduce\n               freedom of information. As was mentioned, protecting privacy of individuals, especially children.... This side\n               of the House won't have a problem with some of that, if any of it. But we certainly\n               have a problem with reducing the public and that other unofficial opposition, which\n               is the press, or businesses. We heard a number of really good, worthwhile reasons why this legislation is flawed.\n               It goes against the very nature of when the Freedom of Information Act was put into\n               being back in 1993, if I recall hearing him correctly. It was amazing to hear from\n               someone that actually was originally there, the intent of what this legislation was\n               supposed to do and now where we've come to. Basically, what I heard him say and I agree with 100 percent, is that this no longer\n               is about freedom of information. It's about protecting, it's about hiding, and it's\n               about putting up as many roadblocks as we possibly can to make that more difficult\n               when in fact, in democracy, what we should be doing is making things less difficult\n               for the public to get at the truth, to get to the heart of how we get to where we\n               are, how we make the decisions on legislation. Sometimes, as mentioned, and for privacy reasons, yes, we need to tighten some things\n               up, especially now where people can use your personal information in a very malicious\n               way. But the Timelines should not be extended because, as we heard, to delay or to charge is actually\n               a way of denying. But the public have already paid for this information. They paid\n               for it with their taxes. What goes on in here, what goes on in this building, is funded\n               by taxpayer dollars, who have already paid with their sweat and their toil in the\n               taxes that they pay. To then further charge them and increase charges and fees to\n               get at the information that they should be entitled to in the first place is insulting\n               and a slap in the face. It's fundamentally wrong. We say that we need to do this because staff have to go to all this work, and therefore\n               government has a right to recoup the costs through fees, to be able to recoup the\n               time that staff are going to spend. Really, what this House should be doing is instead\n               of making that more difficult, instead of making ways for a bureaucrat to decide whether\n               or not they're going to give that information out.... What the goal of this House should\n               be is: how do we make things even more transparent? How do we get to the point where\n               a freedom-of-information request is not required at all? Sometimes, yes, they're embarrassing. I remember talks of expensive glasses of orange\n               juice. I remember talks recently of the cost of a limo and the cost of a little soiree\n               that someone put on. That should never, however, be the reason we tighten things up\n               and say: \"No, this is malicious. This is abusive. It's repetitious,\" or, \"it's excessively\n               broad.\" Sometimes you have to be excessively broad, because sometimes, when you're\n               going through something, it's.... I don't know. It's kind of like.... I'll put it this way. Sometimes when you go through\n               the back of the index of a particular.... I'll use medicine for instance. When you go\n               back into the thing, and you start looking into a particular disease, you start with\n               a rash. Well, there are many things that can give you a rash. But if you make it so\n               that you have to be right into the very, very heart of it, it can become so narrowly\n               scoped that you will never actually find out what the cause of that actually is, especially\n               when it comes to government. Who gets to decide what is excessively broad? That's an excessively unclear definition.\n               Sometimes the only way you can do that, and you want to try and find out the heart\n               of something, is if you're from the press or opposition. I can see, on the other side\n               of the House, the job that opposition does is annoying because we're holding you accountable.\n               Nobody really likes to be held accountable. In my house, it's my wife that holds me\n               accountable. It's annoying. But I'm glad she does, because those that know me and\n               love me know that I need to be held accountable once in a while. We all mess up. The very job of this side of the House is to hold that side of the\n               house accountable. But if you start narrowing it in so that it becomes excessively\n               broad, you're now getting to the point where you will never find it. It's like trying\n               to find a needle in a haystack. I go back to my example of I go back to my example that there are many, many diseases that start with a rash\n               and flu-like symptoms, overall malaise. If you tell me I am not allowed just then\n               from going from that to figure out.... It gives me what's called a definitional diagnosis\n               of all the different diseases that start off.... Some are cancers, by the way. If I\n               have to figure it out by symptoms that are very similar in nature and not be able\n               to then go into a differential diagnosis by narrowing it down — which is really similar\n               to a freedom-of-information act, in a way, because what you're doing is you're looking\n               for clues — it's annoying. But it's a necessary annoyance. It is part of what keeps us accountable. And if we are to restore trust, if we are\n               to restore faith in these institutions, which I repeat is at an all-time high, that's\n               the price we have to pay. We now live in an era of database collection, where there's really no excuse for why\n               it takes as long as it does. And what this side of the House, based on this, cannot\n               take and further erode is freedom of information and the ability for the opposition,\n               the public, businesses that want to do business with the government, who want to know\n               how it is a decision is made on building a bridge, for instance.... \"What are the parameters\n               in there? What were the parameters that were done before, because we suspect there\n               was something wrong?\" It could be that they suspect that there was an insider condition.\n               I'm not saying that goes on. But only through transparency and things like freedom of information are you able\n               to ensure it's the backstop and the safety valve of government. And we should never\n               make it harder, ever. We should be working diligently to make it more and more transparent\n               and easier. I've got to go back. This government got blamed for being the most secretive government\n               in Canada over freedom of information. They tightened it up so much, they charged\n               the fees so much that it was the press, not this side of the House, that labelled\n               this government the most secretive ever. What does this do? It says: \"Hey, that was\n               nothing. Take a look at what we can do now.\" This is way worse. This no longer becomes secretive. This becomes the equivalent of\n               locking freedom of information basically into a vault compared to what was done in\n               the original time. And I remember debating with the minister at the time over: \"Well,\n               what are the fees going to be? Tell us what the fees are.\" \"Oh, we can't tell you.\n               We can't tell you. We can't tell you. We haven't determined that yet.\" Yet within\n               two hours after the legislation had been passed, literally, the fees were announced. So were the fees already determined? The freedom of information, if it's allowed to\n               do it properly, would actually get to the heart of that. Were the fees already discussed?\n               Did government already know what they were and they were avoiding having to answer\n               the opposition questions because they were difficult and they were awkward and they\n               were embarrassing? Maybe they were. That is, in part, why this government got labelled as being the most secretive ever,\n               because they made it more and more difficult for the public and the press to get to\n               the information that they have already paid for through their taxes. They own this\n               building, they pay for this building, and they pay for us to do our jobs. I think that this legislation adds one more layer of disrespect, and it will further\n               erode the trust that people have in the institution of democracy. And when we are\n               at an all-time high of mistrust, I believe I will not support this bill unless, as the member from North Islands and Saanich\n               has mentioned, there are significant changes, which I doubt will happen, because that's\n               the way this government seems to roll. It does not matter what any of us come up with\n               on this side. Very rarely, if at all, do any of the amendments pass. I think it's a mistake, especially when it comes to freedom of information. It's the\n               foundation of democracy. It's the foundation of trust. I would ask that side of the House to think very long and hard. Don't make it easy\n               on yourselves. This isn't supposed to be easy. It's supposed to be hard. It's supposed\n               to be difficult for a reason. We have to restore trust in these systems and restore\n               trust in our democracy and, especially, restore trust in this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358947","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"For those at home that enjoy watching the Legislative Assembly, we are discussing\n               Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026.\n               I highly recommend they take the two hours, not quite, to listen to the member from\n               Saanich North and the Islands. Probably one of the most succinct speeches I have seen in here on privacy an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7368ad1d35c547f398dcc090adba84f134af04af54c18b0cf7078c17c5b17d1a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3529bac3a398c23f5d954f90afc3174af72300257bba36f787b82dba9cd02804"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6c53577fc39d684e47baa77b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358948,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"We listened to the Finance Minister talk about there needed to be some very tough\n               cuts in this budget, some tough decisions that had to be made. One of the toughest\n               of which was the layoff of 15,000 government workers and public sector workers. My question is simple. To the Finance Minister, how many political appointees in her\n               office does she plan to cut, or does she believe So my question is simple. To the Finance Minister: how many political appointees in\n               her office does she plan to cut, or does she believe in \"do as I say, not as I do?\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358948","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We listened to the Finance Minister talk about there needed to be some very tough\n               cuts in this budget, some tough decisions that had to be made. One of the toughest\n               of which was the layoff of 15,000 government workers and public sector workers. My question is simple. To the Finance Minister, how many political appointees in her\n               office does she plan to c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["cf53c8bddbcf251be5db87a9138601860c2c836ce99d650dcfc234c20f0f5bf8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["537805bf7be4980ecfdc8a1f594b54e74e037e1389d8f0ca109b651c0d115bb4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-946eec766b1cf9511f2817dd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413645,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is indeed a pleasure and an honour to stand up and speak in favour of my colleague's\n               motion \"that the House affirms that the application of the merit principle within\n               the B.C. Public Service be overseen by an independent officer of the Legislature.\" I think being hired on qualifications, on merit, on one's ability to do the job at\n               hand is highly important. Far too often in this House, in governments across the world,\n               it's easier to hire an insider that agrees with you, to hire a friend, to hire someone\n               that has worked on your campaign, to hire someone that agrees with you politically. Actually, what's needed is merit. What's needed, and what was put into this House\n               to stop that very thing, was the Merit Commissioner, an independent overseer, so that\n               taxpayers' money was going towards qualified individuals that did not necessarily\n               have a political bias. That's highly important. Now, I hear chirps from the other side. If they think that hiring political insiders\n               and friends is a great idea, I encourage them to stand up and say their piece. But\n               they won't. They will sit there, chirp away, which I would encourage you to shut down,\n               Madam Speaker, because it's inappropriate, in my opinion. What's important, in my opinion, is the fact that merit principles are essential in\n               hiring and promoting individuals based on their ability to actually perform the job,\n               not based on someone's personal political ties to a politician or a party. British Columbians have come to expect and rely on the fact that hiring and promotions\n               within the B.C. Public Service are, above all things, fair, transparent and based\n               on qualifications rather than personal or political connections. It makes total sense.\n               We need to know that within the public service, it's not based on who you know. It's\n               based on your merit to be able to do the job on behalf of the taxpayers. Independent oversight, which was created and needs to be maintained, strengthens the\n               public's trust by ensuring that decisions that are made within that particular department\n               are free from political influence or favouritism. It's an important principle of It's an important principle of government that those within the public service are\n               able to do their jobs without political interference. I give you one of the ones.... Off the top of my head would be the Agricultural Land\n               Commission as an example of areas where people are put in place that are beyond public\n               interference because they have a job to do. They do that job well for the most part.\n               Even though sometimes there are those of us who will disagree with an independent\n               decision of any political employee, they need to be above the ability of having their\n               job put at risk because they disagree with the government at hand. I would remind that side of the House that they won't always be in power. This is\n               a slippery slope. If they are all of a sudden allowed to hire their insiders to do\n               jobs, what happens on the other side when we become in power? Is that what they really\n               want? I don't think it is. We want to make sure that it is independent. I appreciate the time to be able to speak\n               in favour of this bill.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413645","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It is indeed a pleasure and an honour to stand up and speak in favour of my colleague's\n               motion \"that the House affirms that the application of the merit principle within\n               the B.C. Public Service be overseen by an independent officer of the Legislature.\" I think being hired on qualifications, on merit, on one's ability to do the job at\n               hand is highly impo","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0183de0815ecbe1611938b9bbd6bfece371314c997ee0cbd0572d40da16ebdf6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a41fc975a8ab7814c2440752279705ef2713e6d8d7ebd185208abc18f796b08a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-76c1f7a3ef791826394b8e0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413646,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Canadians are known as being warm and welcoming and friendly. I had a chance to have\n               breakfast this morning with Karen Ward from Huntington Beach. I would like this House\n               to prove how welcoming, how warm we are and please welcome Karen for her first time\n               up here in the House and having a chance to look at the Legislature. Please welcome\n               her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413646","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Canadians are known as being warm and welcoming and friendly. I had a chance to have\n               breakfast this morning with Karen Ward from Huntington Beach. I would like this House\n               to prove how welcoming, how warm we are and please welcome Karen for her first time\n               up here in the House and having a chance to look at the Legislature. Please welcome\n               h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Intellectual disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035916","label":"Intellectual disabilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0be1609482f46c539f07d344e48b88187e3e6d7b224d40b9fad14efb393c0f94"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0eb72891ecbdce9464f39188","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413647,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"You know, no matter how hard this government tries to hide their housing failures,\n               encampments are growing across the province and, in my community of Abbotsford, prove\n               in real time how incompetent they really are. There are encampments on Cole Road rest stop, Whatcom Road park-and-ride, McCallum\n               park-and-ride and the Peardonville underpass. And what do they all have in common?\n               They're all on Ministry of Transportation land. They're posted with no trespassing,\n               no camping over 24 hours. Yet local police and the RCMP have been told they are not\n               allowed to enforce the area, unless it's a 911 call. So, can the Minister of Transportation explain to the police officers in the gallery\n               why he is So can the Minister of Transportation explain to the police officers in the gallery\n               why he is prohibiting law enforcement from policing these encampments to make the\n               public safe?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413647","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"You know, no matter how hard this government tries to hide their housing failures,\n               encampments are growing across the province and, in my community of Abbotsford, prove\n               in real time how incompetent they really are. There are encampments on Cole Road rest stop, Whatcom Road park-and-ride, McCallum\n               park-and-ride and the Peardonville underpass. And what do","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Fire","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035263","label":"Fire","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fef2193b158399e4317c5cc7d99be2cf6ded695021efeea8568fe2c68091d541"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["9e9b0f76827a9b1fa203be61ecbe94c12167e82fe38892dae6da686a953de598"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-efc15b2010ad509d600ab58e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413648,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand in this House with a heavy heart. I learned that one of British Columbia's\n               outstanding agricultural legends passed away last night. Lawrence Joiner passed away last night. For those who don't know Lawrence, there is\n               probably not a section of agriculture that Lawrence or his family were not involved\n               with. Mink farming. Chicken farming. Joiner's corn barns were scattered throughout\n               the valley every year. Most importantly, he also ran the OK Ranch up in the southern Cariboo. I believe the\n               personal acres of that were somewhere in the neighbourhood of 16,000 acres. We have\n               probably had a beef steak that was grown on that ranch at one time in our lives, if\n               you are British Columbian. Lawrence has forgotten more about agriculture than most\n               people will ever know. My condolences go to his family, to those who know him. May we take a moment to reflect\n               on the great life that Lawrence lived and what he has contributed to agriculture and\n               feeding British Columbians. May he rest in peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Corn","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413648","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I stand in this House with a heavy heart. I learned that one of British Columbia's\n               outstanding agricultural legends passed away last night. Lawrence Joiner passed away last night. For those who don't know Lawrence, there is\n               probably not a section of agriculture that Lawrence or his family were not involved\n               with. Mink farming. Chicken farming. Joiner's c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","label":"Corn"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Corn","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farm buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Meat","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","label":"Corn","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035212","label":"Farm buildings","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48411","label":"Meat","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","label":"Livestock","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["71191a2724a0ed9e6700f4a80184e48f16f331bf2a884a23e52b1c5d07030c2e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Corn","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b6861836402cfc22ae2e7e98814683d53d10c476ca961cecf993d4581cae8f2f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Livestock","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Corn","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034675","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:92970","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b608df2bc90c40c90a164e00","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720090,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to revisit a topic from a couple of years ago.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720090","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to revisit a topic from a couple of years ago.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["853ddd3c54101d5ed9c0e976452bd8100599699763dc910ce37717f3a906a3c2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4dcbab6f1e5881a890e4c481","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720091,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thought, for a minute there, when my colleague from Delta South was going to talk\n               about old things, he was going to pull out his curriculum vitae and talk about how\n               long ago it was he started dairy farming. But that aside, I do have a question, at\n               the risk of not being allowed to ask another question now. Sort of following up on what my colleague was saying, there have been a lot of properties\n               in the ALR that were orphaned off back in the days by being subdivided so that mom\n               and dad had a place to live. It was what was done. Some of them are two acres or smaller. The issue now is that those two acres.... If\n               you have anywhere from two to thousands of hectares, I believe the threshold is $2,500,\n               and you qualify for farm status. Yet if you have two acres or smaller, you have to\n               produce $25,000 worth, I believe it is. It's $10,000. All right, I stand corrected. It's $10,000. I knew it was in thousands.\n               It's considerably.... Well, now with new farming techniques, with microfarms, with greenhouses, with things\n               that we can do.... We have all kinds of smaller pieces of property that are now put\n               at a huge disadvantage. They'd like to farm, but they won't get the farm status. It\n               seems blatantly unfair. Has there been any If you've got hundreds and hundreds of acres, if you can only produce $2,500 worth....\n               It just seems blatantly backwards. Is there been any discussion about getting these\n               smaller pieces of farmland actually to be productive farmland? They should be able to produce, in many cases.... As I say, we've got types of vertical\n               farming, greenhouses. There are all kinds of modernization of farming that have occurred.\n               It could be aqua farming, for instance. Is there any way that we can get that threshold\n               the same for some of these smaller pieces so that they can actually produce valuable\n               food to help feed this nation as well?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720091","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I thought, for a minute there, when my colleague from Delta South was going to talk\n               about old things, he was going to pull out his curriculum vitae and talk about how\n               long ago it was he started dairy farming. But that aside, I do have a question, at\n               the risk of not being allowed to ask another question now. Sort of following up on what my colleague was ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035406","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruit crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Crops","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034731","label":"Crops","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","label":"Farmlands","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035406","label":"Fruit crops","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1b1a24486431279c76a66afae8241b418e46b2b336a6bfd35e1bc396362902e8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.42,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0d0e19efa141d9a2e5cee12a874b654e25c0fe6368623a24594a1c54df6d990c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farmlands","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035219","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5d9e30bdd9d5d25252d92702","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720094,"date":"2026-04-15T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Silversmith Power and Light, Canada's longest continually operating green hydroelectric\n               facility for 129 years, is at risk of closure in less than five months. They are a\n               locally owned, run-of-the-river hydroelectric utility in Sandon, British Columbia,\n               yet today they are being pushed rapidly toward shutdown due to a series of government-controlled\n               policies and decisions that have left them with no sustainable path forward. This is not just about one facility. It reflects a broader and growing problem in\n               British Columbia's electrical system. At a time when B.C. faces electrical shortages and increasingly importing power from\n               the United States, why is this government forcing out local clean, green energy producers\n               like Silversmith Power and Light?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260415pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720094","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Silversmith Power and Light, Canada's longest continually operating green hydroelectric\n               facility for 129 years, is at risk of closure in less than five months. They are a\n               locally owned, run-of-the-river hydroelectric utility in Sandon, British Columbia,\n               yet today they are being pushed rapidly toward shutdown due to a series of government-controlled\n    ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electrical equipment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","label":"Electric power stations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034997","label":"Electrical equipment","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","label":"Electricity","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","label":"Hydropower","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["3dfab6ee609d4889ced654032a4a1b8a0cdfe264bdd1237607f78fc8a23044ab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.31,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4b0da1d0e57402c1da435993b3e926fcac30ff164e53363883123a8fe907bbfe"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydropower","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electric power stations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Electricity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034988","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720403","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752525","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-49331cd66b1f59ccf0eecc93","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721174,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to join my colleague from Kamloops Centre. My wife, also, Sharon, is here in the gallery with us. I'm not so sure that I would\n               call QP quality time either. She's given me instructions to be on my best behaviour\n               — so nothing like setting me up for failure. Would the House please welcome her.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721174","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to join my colleague from Kamloops Centre. My wife, also, Sharon, is here in the gallery with us. I'm not so sure that I would\n               call QP quality time either. She's given me instructions to be on my best behaviour\n               — so nothing like setting me up for failure. Would the House please welcome her.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.39,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3959f1af2c74cd03294f62753401d878af9bfa77babd4f07ec1315462ade1cd"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2c32aa2c41ff1eb154755a12","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721176,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"This side of the House, too, would like to welcome the ambassador from Ukraine. Andrii and I and a few of the others — we got to share that we're actually, like him, probably\n               banned for life from going to Russia. But there has always been a special place for Ukraine and Ukrainians in Canada's hearts.\n               We have a special bond. As I mentioned to him, my grandparents came from the area\n               that is now Ukraine when they escaped here. Canada has always opened its arms to Ukrainians,\n               and we will continue to do so. We want to thank you and for being here. We look forward to.... This is not your first\n               but it certainly won't be your last visit to British Columbia. Thank you for your\n               presence.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721176","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This side of the House, too, would like to welcome the ambassador from Ukraine. Andrii and I and a few of the others — we got to share that we're actually, like him, probably\n               banned for life from going to Russia. But there has always been a special place for Ukraine and Ukrainians in Canada's hearts.\n               We have a special bond. As I mentioned to him, my grandparents came ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumerism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035039","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emigration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Corruption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Consumers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Automobiles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034654","label":"Consumerism","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034656","label":"Consumers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034842","label":"Foreign service","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035039","label":"Emigration","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42455","label":"Corruption","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:723379","label":"Automobiles","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d31bd7f2fe70047803233ba7fccd069c5bcb718fd6f1844a84a7ffd10dac228a"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4566a841715f4213d1a5affe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721178,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize an individual whose story reflects the very best of what\n               it means to call British Columbia home, Dao Tran. Dao Tran came to Canada as a Vietnam refugee in the mid-'80s. Before arriving in Abbotsford,\n               he spent years in a refugee camp in Hong Kong, uncertain of what the future would\n               hold. Like so many who come to this country seeking safety and opportunity, he arrived\n               with little more than hope, dreams and determination. What he built from that beginning\n               is nothing short of remarkable. For more than 40 years, Dao has been a steady and familiar presence in the Abbotsford\n               cycling community. Through his work at Abby Bike Shop, he has not only run a successful\n               small business but he created a place where relationships are fostered, where families\n               are served and where community truly comes first. But what stands out most is not just what he has built but how he has given back. But what stands out most is not just what he has built, but how he has given back.\n               In addition to the countless donations over the years, this year Dao made a significant\n               contribution to the Abbotsford Regional Hospital by funding an ECG heart monitoring\n               machine, helping ensure patients have access to timely and accurate cardiac care. He has also volunteered his time through the Fraser Valley Health Care Foundation\n               and supported hospital initiatives directly, giving back in both visible and in quiet\n               ways. Dao is a fiercely proud Canadian. He has never forgotten the community that\n               welcomed him, and in return, he has spent a lifetime strengthening it. Dao Tran's story is one of resilience, gratitude and service. It is a reminder that\n               the strength of our communities is built not only through hard work, but through kindness\n               and a commitment to giving back. On behalf of this House, I will ask all members to join me in recognizing Dao Tran\n               for his extraordinary contributions to Abbotsford, British Columbia and Canada.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721178","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize an individual whose story reflects the very best of what\n               it means to call British Columbia home, Dao Tran. Dao Tran came to Canada as a Vietnam refugee in the mid-'80s. Before arriving in Abbotsford,\n               he spent years in a refugee camp in Hong Kong, uncertain of what the future would\n               hold. Like so many who come to this country see","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","label":"Donations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["10d8e98a39b4d68aaa5f39aa8ef356ef0c3d99fc73a5d6a14a4b2cabd2d36236"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ddf0b26ee44dd10ec92299a73f491c3a219dc761fd9250181f95a0085b8ea28d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501358","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-63cfec1027ba60eec2b2d2ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728780,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stood up on April 1 and I told the Minister of Transportation about a fatal shooting\n               at an encampment on Ministry of Transportation lands in my riding. I told the minister\n               there were numerous dangerous encampments on MOT lands. On Friday","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728780","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I stood up on April 1 and I told the Minister of Transportation about a fatal shooting\n               at an encampment on Ministry of Transportation lands in my riding. I told the minister\n               there were numerous dangerous encampments on MOT lands. On Friday","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Humanitarian crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035743","label":"Humanitarian crisis","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["607c863f49b5383e76600d9c1fa202673c5ff6d391dac3874af0400471d8a9b1"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c15b381d1c212629cbb5e6ac39270e71814ee97f6cf5d10dec4cdc165ea4023b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b906632cdb05387a97849d16","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752156,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is actually an honour and a privilege to stand here as the designated speaker for\n               this motion. I believe this is the first time I've been a designated speaker to respond\n               to a motion, so I look forward to that, and I believe that I have up to two hours\n               upon which to make some points. I'd like to start by explaining the motion in plain\n               language. I rise to speak to the amendment for the motion for the second reading of Bill 9.\n               The amendment, which I have in front of me, says: \"delete the word 'now' and substitute\n               the words 'six months hence.'\" For those that are watching at home or are unfamiliar, or watching late tonight and\n               perhaps have insomnia, a hoist motion, as this is called, is one of the oldest tools\n               in parliamentary tradition. I would explain to people that a hoist motion is not a\n               motion to actually kill a bill. That's not its purpose. A hoist motion is a chance....\n               Whenever there is legislation that comes on the floor that there have been problems\n               with — as an example, in this case — a hoist motion is a motion to pause it, to send\n               it back and get it right. Already there have been, which I will get into in a few moments, a number of changes\n               by the minister herself where they've realized: \"Oops. In our rush to get it here,\n               there have been a couple of errors already.\" A hoist motion is now, in this case, going to give us six months, which is the bare\n               minimum. We could have asked for longer, but FOIs are so important and getting freedom-of-information\n               requests right is so important that this side of the House wants to make sure that.... The minimum amount of time allowed in a hoist to get it right is six months. What\n               that will do is allow them, over the summertime, as an example, to be able to ponder\n               this particular motion, look at it carefully, sort out the errors that are in it and\n               actually get it right. Now, I think that this Legislature owes this to the people we serve. Now, I was the\n               critic for Citizens' Services. It was actually my first critic role when elected back\n               in 2020. And FOIs were one of the things that were hotly debated then. I think it's important for the public to understand what's at stake here. Freedom\n               of information is a request that people put into their government, and it allows them\n               to get access to the decisions either that were made or how that decision Freedom of information is a request that people put in, to their government, and it\n               allows them to get access to the decisions, either that were made, or how that decision\n               came to be, or what's important when it comes to finding out how government has been\n               acting. It is that safety net that has been put in there to ensure that government\n               is acting responsibly. It is that ability to make sure that government is not using\n               funds in an inappropriate way. My interim leader just spoke of a few embarrassing things that were brought up from\n               an FOI. Government's natural tendency is to say, \"No, no, we really don't want to\n               have anything embarrassing.\" Sometimes it's an innocent enough thing that has happened,\n               but it's embarrassing nonetheless. Now, I spoke in this House about a very embarrassing incident that happened to me\n               personally, when I was the mayor of Abbotsford, and that side of the House has used\n               that example many times, to use it as an example, to try and embarrass me. Well, I'm\n               not embarrassed by it, because an FOI actually, in this case, exonerated me. Yeah, if you've done something inappropriate, it may not always exonerate you. I am\n               sure the Minister of Finance absolutely hates hearing about her $6,000 limo ride —\n               which, she has pointed out, was actually an SUV, but it was a $6,000 bill nonetheless.\n               In my case, what had happened was that chicken manure had been used to deter a homeless\n               encampment from coming back. It was FOI'd to death, because there's nothing more juicy than that one. The press\n               and people in the public wanted to make sure that I was the mayor. So they were convinced\n               that I had ordered that to be done, that I knew about it and that I didn't put a stop\n               to it. Nothing could be further from the truth. My cell phone was taken, my computer\n               was taken, and every shred of paper that they could get their hands on there was taken,\n               because it made international news. An FOI actually is a double-edged sword. While people were looking to literally tar\n               and paper me with this — not feather — they found out, at the end of the day, that\n               I actually did not know about it. Upon further FOI requests, they found out that there\n               was actually a bunch of intermediate staffers that had gotten together and come up\n               with this horrific idea to do, and spread chicken manure on a homeless encampment\n               after it had been cleaned up, because they were frustrated with the cat-and-mouse\n               game. It was a bad idea. I wore it because I was the mayor. I took responsibility for it\n               because I was the mayor. In fact then what I did, to ensure that that would never\n               happen again.... I implemented a committee to deal with the issues of homelessness in\n               Abbotsford, so that it would never, ever, ever happen again. My point on this is that an FOI, while embarrassing, actually can prove that government\n               did no wrongdoing. It's not always going to embarrass government. It is a healthy\n               tool that has been put in place to ensure that the press, the public and the opposition\n               can request an FOI, a freedom-of-information document, get it in a timely manner and\n               hold government accountable. It is, I believe, one of the foundations of democracy. Now, with regard to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this\n               debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Now, with regards to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this\n               debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Well, it does.\n               Everybody agrees. On both sides of the House. That's in fact why this bill is here\n               and why this amendment is here now. We know that the FOI system is broken. It does\n               not serve the public as well as it could, and it needs to be addressed. It's not about whether the public bodies are facing pressure. Well, clearly, they\n               do. Public bodies are under enormous pressure. And FOIs, quite frankly, when I was\n               the mayor of Abbotsford, were an absolute pain to deal with. It gobbles up staff time.\n               They have to find out where the information is. They have to photocopy it. They have\n               to retract certain things and certain names on it. It does take up time. You know what else takes up time? An absolute pain in some people's minds that cities\n               have to deal with is building inspections. They're there for a good reason. We want\n               to make sure they're safe. We want to make sure that the buildings are done correctly. So the reason that the Information and Privacy Commissioner agrees that reform is\n               needed The BCFIPA agrees, and the 2022 all-party committee agreed unanimously. There\n               was already a committee that dealt with the bill that is in front of this House, and\n               it came up with recommendations. So the debate is not whether or not we need to reform\n               FOIs. That is clear, and that is why this bill is here. The secret now is we must\n               ensure that we get it right. We owe it to the public to get it right. We owe it to\n               democracy itself, in fact, to get this right. So what this debate is really about, and why we have put this hoist here is to answer\n               the question: does this bill weaken the public's right to know, or does it strengthen\n               the systems that deliver on that vital democratic right? On that question, the evidence\n               is overwhelming. Bill 9 is the wrong answer. There have been mistakes that have been\n               pointed out already. And that is why we are asking for a very legitimate pause to\n               be able to strengthen it. And six months, the minimum time, because this is of the essence, is the time this\n               Legislature needs to find the right solutions to this bill. It is a reasonable request,\n               and I believe a very much required request, especially when one considers that in\n               the democratic process, checks and balances are required. Government without checks and balances is not a healthy thing at all. That is why\n               we are called His Royal Majesty's opposition. We're not here to stop government. We\n               are here to oppose bad legislation and suggest ways to which and improve it, to keep\n               government accountable and to actually come up with better legislation than what's\n               been placed. This hoist will allow us that time to do this. Now, part of why we have done this is because the minister herself made the case for\n               the hoist. Let me go over a few reasons as to why. So the first thing is, the minister\n               actually amended her own bill in mid-debate. The minister.... That is worth repeating.\n               The minister amended her own bill in mid-debate. The Minister of Citizens Services\n               tabled amendments to her own legislation two weeks into the second reading. That clearly\n               states that there was problems within the bill already. I didn't say amendment, I said amendments. Do you need me to pause Do you need me to pause for a minute, Mr. Speaker? All right, fair enough. In her words, they were minor adjustments to provide additional clarity. Well, I think\n               that this hoist will help, in fact, to define what those minor adjustments and what\n               additional clarity will mean. I would say part of the reason why the minister has made the argument or the case\n               for this hoist is.... If a bill is ready for this House, if it is clearly ready, if\n               it has been well-thought-out, one does not need to amend a bill that is ready. The\n               bill was not ready. The bill had errors and flaws in it when it was presented on this\n               floor. You do not need to provide additional clarity on legislation that was clear\n               when you tabled it. The minister realized that there were problems in the bill. She said: \"We need to\n               make some minor adjustments. It's not clear. We've made a mistake already.\" That is\n               one area, so the act of tabling those amendments is itself an admission the bill just\n               was not ready for debate. That's okay. It's okay that the bill was not ready, because this system has in its\n               place this exact motion, a hoist, to be able to go: \"You know what? Hang on a minute.\n               We've messed up. Let's think about this in a better term. Let's allow a wholesome\n               debate on this. Let's send it to a committee to figure out what else may be wrong\n               with this bill and go at it so that we can come back with a bill that is before this\n               House that is ready.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752156","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is actually an honour and a privilege to stand here as the designated speaker for\n               this motion. I believe this is the first time I've been a designated speaker to respond\n               to a motion, so I look forward to that, and I believe that I have up to two hours\n               upon which to make some points. I'd like to start by explaining the motion in plain\n               l","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban communities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Urban environment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Media relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Red tape burdens","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Repayable contributions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","label":"Public buildings","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036931","label":"Repayable contributions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037441","label":"Urban communities","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037446","label":"Urban environment","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083614","label":"Red tape burdens","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083640","label":"Media relations","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","label":"Homelessness","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6f89370eb558162b5a2485c6050131cab28d98123f685b3214a00057136fb948","025a944bb27dbd21bd4429b6f101398892e7931d2dca717b9afaa1aba2f70794","44fc87a7bd0d50d58e03106f59d831d81d9ff001dd1dabf61e254635d4c7e0b9","cc256328662374e1d78317024b82dd2d751799b27949eab9b4aac58da7f05213"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eda145736de480ab1c942edcced14272c024986f48390ac53a8b238906628fd2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homelessness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714465","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3bd019cc401c9f36be06aa2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752157,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Sometimes as we march these hallways, we get to meet some very interesting people.\n               I would like to draw attention up in the gallery. We have some students from Western\n               Washington University. They're poli-sci students. I know they're heartbroken that I won't ask a question today, but I promised them\n               our very best when it comes to heckling, etc., so that they get a good chance of experiencing\n               a true question period. Will this House please make them very, very welcome — our guests from Washington state?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752157","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Sometimes as we march these hallways, we get to meet some very interesting people.\n               I would like to draw attention up in the gallery. We have some students from Western\n               Washington University. They're poli-sci students. I know they're heartbroken that I won't ask a question today, but I promised them\n               our very best when it comes to heckling, etc., so that ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Universities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art exhibitions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art works","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037438","label":"Universities","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751698","label":"Art exhibitions","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","label":"Art works","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3961c6a34b79dca9ea94f10924d2803e15f0fc3a469b8118d4ad09fc64f38f8b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["aea242f52e36ae6b1bac9b2b27013f5f6e56b15cb771ef54c5f5aa5340554b91"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9fb3c77c9a195a8d6083a4a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017044,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand on a point of privilege, personal privilege. During the statements, the Premier said that the member for Abbotsford South was elected during Christy Clark's era. I would like to give the Premier an opportunity\n               to correct himself and retract his remarks. I was elected in 2020. She was long gone\n               by then.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017044","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I stand on a point of privilege, personal privilege. During the statements, the Premier said that the member for Abbotsford South was elected during Christy Clark's era. I would like to give the Premier an opportunity\n               to correct himself and retract his remarks. I was elected in 2020. She was long gone\n               by then.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02777d27a09a2bfa6e812eb3d478427ae470b5344eed19564b01154d81103d51"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2ab6681e274794eda7214d3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017048,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is always a pleasure and an honour to introduce a former MLA to visit this House.\n               I would like for the House to welcome Peter Fassbender, a former minister and MLA,\n               and his wife Charlene. My understanding is that they've been married for 58 years\n               today. I do not know whether that puts Charlene in the running for the Order of British\n               Columbia, but it has got to put her for an honourable mention at least. Would the House please give them a very warm welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017048","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is always a pleasure and an honour to introduce a former MLA to visit this House.\n               I would like for the House to welcome Peter Fassbender, a former minister and MLA,\n               and his wife Charlene. My understanding is that they've been married for 58 years\n               today. I do not know whether that puts Charlene in the running for the Order of British\n               Co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Heating","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035657","label":"Heating","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f8339ada9bda4f7b6cfab2f3f8c3ce78c27808a76d98dafdabc3cd913ce81f4c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ae98262b906d48826f688997ee71d22a7624d5dcd45eed215dd74c74a509dd0d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dafbcd44bf69fc1d3de55808","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036387,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Bruce Banman","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I rise to talk about one of Abbotsford South's finest exports, one of British Columbia's great agricultural treasures and one\n               of the most versatile foods you can find. I'm talking, of course, about blueberries.\n               Now blueberries may seem small, but they're mighty. You can put them in pancakes,\n               muffins, smoothies, pies, jams, salads, sauces, yogurts, oatmeal, ice cream or simply\n               eat them by the handful while pretending you're only going to have one. Abbotsford blueberries are not just a snack; they are what and part of who we are.\n               Our community is known as the Berry Capital of Canada, and that title was built on\n               generations of hardworking families. These growers are up early, working long days,\n               managing weather, labour challenges, rising costs and marketing pressures, all to\n               produce a crop that is enjoyed here at home and around the world. British Columbia is known for its highbush blueberries, and depending on the season,\n               you may find varieties such as Duke, Blue Crop, Draper, Liberty, Elliott, Aurora and\n               Calypso. Each has its own flavour, timing and purpose, from sweet fresh eating to\n               baking, freezing and processing. They are also good for you. Blueberries are high in fibre, rich in antioxidants and\n               linked to benefits for heart health, brain health and overall wellness. In other words,\n               this may be one of the rare times where you can taste something that tastes fantastic\n               and is actually good for you. In Abbotsford South, blueberry farms support local jobs, suppliers, processors, markets,\n               tourism and roadside stands. They also bring people together through events like Berry\n               Fest where our community celebrates the farmers, families and flavours that make Abbotsford\n               so special. All the good news is that the blueberry season is just around the corner. Fresh B.C.\n               blueberries are usually at their best in the summertime months, especially in July\n               and August. This year, farmers are expecting a bunker crop, so I encourage everyone\n               to come on out to Abbotsford, bring the family to a U-pick, stop at a roadside stand,\n               fill a bucket, fill your freezer and support our local farmers right here at the source.\n               Small berry, big impact, very Abbotsford.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036387","member_id":"bc-mla-7","member_name":"Bruce Banman","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I rise to talk about one of Abbotsford South's finest exports, one of British Columbia's great agricultural treasures and one\n               of the most versatile foods you can find. I'm talking, of course, about blueberries.\n               Now blueberries may seem small, but they're mighty. You can put them in pancakes,\n               muffins, smoothies, pies, jams, salads, sauces, yogurts,","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","label":"Fruits"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Functional foods","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083660","label":"Functional foods","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","label":"Fruits","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["80f852cab0b066d129f551ed2f27375d3756f3992569db6a9ebe952f6e758f12"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c7329992505b343dc2b7893c1adce88cff844ef3eb5c40b00ca8f45ff9ad67b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fruits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:725389","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-192c0e6c875dcfe1643208a7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328040,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328040","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2782d7263c4e4f33e993f1ff","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360879,"date":"2026-03-09T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm very pleased that this motion has come forward from the member from Stikine. Water\n               is essential. We're hearing it now from both sides of the House, and I think that's\n               good to see the recognition of what needs to be done in this province to support water\n               and the vital role that water plays. Clean drinking water, agriculture, wildlife.\n               There are so many components, of course. It's often said that if you make sure that you take care of water, the land will take\n               care of itself. I think that's true. Water is critical. It's one of the reasons why,\n               in this last election, we ran on a platform that suggested that we needed $1 billion\n               dollars annually to be invested in water infrastructure, whether that is your drinking\n               water, whether that's the sewage side of it. We need that infrastructure around the\n               province, because it is sorely lacking. There is a huge need in all communities, especially in small communities and rural\n               areas. The investment that is required is tremendous. You need to be able to have\n               a consistent investment, an annual amount of money coming in that just flows through\n               and allows the communities to be able to save up as well as to invest in this critical\n               infrastructure that we all have come to rely on. In addition to that, it's also important to think about the relationship between surface\n               water and, of course, our subsurface or the aquifers. Some communities are relying\n               on surface water. Many communities tap into the aquifers with their wells to be able\n               to pump water into storage. We need more research in terms of that relationship. A couple of years ago, there was a significant drought. Farms were having problems.\n               They had wells to be able to use to water their fields, but they were actually told\n               not to use that on a precautionary measure, because they were worried about the dropping\n               level of a river that was close by. We don't know exactly what that relationship is, and so this was a precautionary,\n               but in the meantime, by doing that, now you're hurting our agriculture sector and\n               the very food that's being produced that we need within this province. So we need\n               money to go into research so that we have a better understanding, so that we're not\n               just making knee-jerk reactions to the situations, but we're actually being able to\n               do proper planning. Associated proper planning is making sure we actually invest in things like dams.\n               The member from the Cariboo talked about the need for the investment in dams, a need\n               for us to be able to be able to build and maintain those dams. But I would suggest\n               we also need to work at storage, because at the end of the day, we are going to have\n               variations in our weather. We're going to have some years we're going to have lots of water, some years where\n               we're not going to have as much water, but we're still going to need to be able to\n               irrigate our crops. We're still going to need to make sure we've got water available\n               in our communities. So we need that investment in critical infrastructure of storage of water so that\n               we can take more of the runoff that comes, we can store it, we can make sure it's\n               there and available. These are things that, quite frankly, we haven't been investing\n               in as a province for quite some time now, and it's something that needs to be done. I want to bring this back to the needs in my riding of Nechako Lakes. I think about,\n               for example, the government has a piece of property that is a trailer park in Fraser\n               Lake. It's gone over two years without any water. It's had to have bottled water come\n               in because water has not been provided by the landlord, in this case the province. We've got a situation in Fort St. James where there have been discussions between\n               the community and the First Nations and they're trying to figure out how you deal\n               with the sewage side of things, the lagoons. There needs to be a new lagoon put in,\n               and yet this challenge coming forward in terms of how this is going to be funded and\n               what are the options that they're going to look at. This is critical infrastructure. Right now in Granisle, for example, they're on a \"do not consume\" water order for\n               their water supply. It's a serious issue for the people up in Granisle, and there\n               are issues going on associated with that. I won't go into the great details on it,\n               but these are the types of things that we need to make sure we have this investment\n               fund on an annual basis so that we can provide those waters. Houston, of course, spent years waiting to be able to get the funding to build a water\n               tower. They finally got the water tower, which is great for a community like that. But it goes on and on all the way across. Whether it's the water quality, whether\n               it's the storage, whether it's making it available, whether it's investing in the\n               pipes and infrastructure, we need significant investment because as the member from\n               Stikine says, this should be a right. This should be something that we recognize that\n               has to be done for all of our communities, for the people of this province. So I'm\n               very pleased that she brought forward this motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260309am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360879","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm very pleased that this motion has come forward from the member from Stikine. Water\n               is essential. We're hearing it now from both sides of the House, and I think that's\n               good to see the recognition of what needs to be done in this province to support water\n               and the vital role that water plays. Clean drinking water, agriculture, wildlife.\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water demand","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","label":"Water","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037556","label":"Water demand","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ffdc96c3ae29ead52e48b19cdccba6bd24c47f126773e8b2ee342326997e7ecc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6e6bc8e68955caeb98fe8326e1fa600b11bf4314686ab034e5f23c660bfb1c4f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011254","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c734a8761d83d4aa83de87c2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415814,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order. Language that was used by the Attorney General in her first response today I found\n               to be offensive, insulting and unbecoming of a minister of the Crown, and unacceptable\n               language to be used in this Legislature. I ask that you request for her to withdraw and apologize for the use of that language\n               in this Legislature.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415814","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order. Language that was used by the Attorney General in her first response today I found\n               to be offensive, insulting and unbecoming of a minister of the Crown, and unacceptable\n               language to be used in this Legislature. I ask that you request for her to withdraw and apologize for the use of that language\n               in this Legislature.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["22a4fb45c0aba6f3f0416dc38d024e311ddd49dbe0b15937f2bb4884376a40fc"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-37c08230a5beda255d006246","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720540,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"Happy to get up and speak to Bill 14. I appreciate the applause, especially from my\n               longtime friends from the other side of the House. It's a pleasure to get up and share\n               a few words. Bill 14 is another version of forest legislation coming forward from this province\n               with lots of promise, as the member previous just said. You know, it's going to be\n               sustainable forest management. It's going to create jobs. It's going to have fibre\n               flow. It's going to do all these wonderful things for our forest sector. It's been a decade of hearing these from the NDP, and I just want to go a little bit\n               down memory lane. Way back then, they used to talk about secondary manufacturing.\n               Imagine that. How did those results turn out? Well, we've seen secondary manufacturing\n               plummet after policy and policy and policy come forward by this government. Then they said: \"Oh, it's all about value added. We're going to make sure we add value\n               to the logs.\" Well, you've got to actually log to actually add value, and the logging\n               is cut in half. There has been no value added. All we've seen is jobs lost and mills\n               closed. They promised they were going to get rid of log exports. Well, how has that worked\n               out? Yeah, they have stopped some log exports simply because they haven't made any\n               wood available, but it certainly hasn't declined the amount of wood that's actually\n               being exported from this project. And then there was the promise of more jobs per cubic metre. We've got to be getting\n               our true value and generating all those jobs. Well, how did that turn out? Clearly,\n               we've seen a massive loss of jobs in the forest sector. We have seen policy after policy after policy come forward from this government with\n               no measurable results, only negative results, to the place today where our chief forester\n               says we should be logging 62 million cubic metres. That's what is sustainable in the\n               forest today — 62 million cubic metres. And yet in this budget that this government\n               has brought forward, they're estimating that they're going to cut 29 million. I actually think they're being optimistic. I don't even think they're going to get\n               to that — less than half of what is allowed to be cut sustainably, properly, under\n               world standards in this province — because of policies like this one that have been\n               brought forward. Policy after policy has driven up prices and killed our forest sector\n               in British Columbia. We've seen....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720540","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Happy to get up and speak to Bill 14. I appreciate the applause, especially from my\n               longtime friends from the other side of the House. It's a pleasure to get up and share\n               a few words. Bill 14 is another version of forest legislation coming forward from this province\n               with lots of promise, as the member previous just said. You know, it's going to be\n     ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","label":"Forestry industry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","label":"Lumber industry","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","label":"Forests","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","label":"Forestry","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["19c73a42ad832ec8368959118c3ad34267d4e0ccacbf16cb836fc4421cd1e4d3","721c69f74267bd3bde8ab625e2767d2bb5eeaf849d63de06d7d0d09924e917be"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e79a015734dce8a5ae33e7b8bd4c4fbd3cbed49c41083cd43bbb9b71e5d72c90"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forestry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Forestry industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Lumber industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forests","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035367","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103965","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44967","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96206","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1b71570c28fc3ad5fc8aaffc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721648,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Apologize for not being able to be there in person; unfortunately, I put my back out over the weekend, so I'm in the process of healing.\n               But regardless of that, I'm still very honoured to have the opportunity to rise and\n               speak with regards to Bill 20 and the K'ómoks treaty. I have a little bit of a unique situation here, associated with this, simply because\n               I had many discussions with the K'ómoks Nation back when I was the minister. The agreement-in-principle was signed the year before I became the minister, but I do remember having conversations\n               about treaty and about how to proceed with treaty. I remember, at the time, the chief and council had made a decision not to proceed with beyond the agreement-in-principle. I asked\n               them why, and they said because they were concerned about their rights. They're concerned\n               about section 35 I see now, in this treaty coming forward, that section 35 rights are still fully upheld.\n               They're not defined on a treaty in measurable ways that previous treaties were, and\n               the taxation exemption exists beyond. In other words, the province and the federal\n               government conceded on both those issues. Now maybe that's what they needed to do to get to an agreement, but I still wonder,\n               and it leaves a question in my mind, why the shift. Why did we need to get there?\n               What was it that we secured as a province in relation to these treaties? Did we secure\n               what the minister had described — a certainty? Did we provide the certainty for the\n               people in B.C.? Did we provide the certainty for the people in the Comox Valley? Did\n               we provide the certainty for the K'ómoks Nation and its people? It makes me really wonder about this treaty brought forward, in particular because\n               of the language of UNDRIP that is now being implemented as part of this. UNDRIP was\n               never part of the original treaties, two of which I had the honour of speaking to\n               in the Legislature as they moved forward. I had the honour of signing agreement principles,\n               particularly with the Kitselas and Kitsumkalum. I'm looking forward to those discussions to come up. I wonder about this whole idea of certainty that's being created. Because UNDRIP is\n               in the language, it's worthwhile looking at some of the sections of UNDRIP, in particular\n               DRIPA, which is the implementation of UNDRIP, the Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous\n               Peoples Act, which, quite frankly, the Premier has been on again, off again, on again,\n               off again, six times, because of the legal uncertainty that has been created through\n               the Interpretation Act and through DRIPA. DRIPA, of course, is the implementation\n               of UNDRIP. I look at this and I think, \"Okay. Let's have a quick look at Article 32 of UNDRIP,\n               where it talks about free, prior and informed consent.\" Well, do we have free, prior\n               and informed consent from the nations that overlap with K'ómoks Nation? Doesn't appear to. This treaty coming forward, is it actually in violation of DRIPA,\n               of the very act that has created so much controversy and shock problems and issues\n               in British Columbia? Yet, we're moving forward a treaty that may actually be in direct\n               contravention with the very act itself? We're looking at bringing in this piece of legislation, which is equivalent of a constitutional\n               level document, which will enshrine UNDRIP into law, into how the courts will interpret\n               laws in British Columbia. So what is it that the Premier has said that he needs to\n               suspend, because he needs to figure out how to deal with the court cases and how to\n               deal with all this uncertainty and issues that are being created in British Columbia? On one hand, okay, I get it. Right, he's lost some court cases, tons of court cases\n               coming forward, tons of uncertainty, exactly the opposite of what the Premier had\n               said it would be. On the other hand, he's wanting to bring forward these treaties. Well, I could guarantee you as we move forward these treaties.... If this government\n               insists on moving them forward in the current state with the language of UNDRIP in\n               there, what do you think the chances are that the very language that's in this treaty\n               will be used against the government as it tries to fight the court cases that it is\n               currently struggling with? The very language that the Premier thinks needs to be suspended because of the way\n               it's being interpreted is now going to be enshrined and used against the Premier.\n               How is it that this Premier and this government is bringing forward these treaties\n               at this time when they have not resolved the issues of DRIPA, when they have not resolved\n               the issues that are outstanding? This makes no sense to me whatsoever. When we talk about, once again, the certainty that this minister has talked about,\n               it makes me think about the neighbouring nations once again and the K'ómoks People itself. Because UNDRIP is now enshrined or will be enshrined as part of this, you would have\n               to assume that UNDRIP is also enshrined for its neighbours, because clearly that's\n               the intent of the government. UNDRIP allows for nations to have distinct political, legal and economic opportunities So UNDRIP allows for nations to have distinct political, legal and economic opportunities.\n               It allows them to have the right to develop other economic activities within the nation,\n               to freely determine and pursue their economic interests and considerations. So what\n               do you think is going to happen here? On Vancouver Island, with all the nations and all the overlaps that are in there,\n               you're going to have neighbouring nations being forced to try to put forward their\n               court cases for their rights under DRIPA and UNDRIP, and, of course section 35 of\n               the constitution. So you could conceivably have a treaty being put in place, the K'ómoks treaty, and the neighbours, Wei Wai Kum or other neighbours, putting forward title\n               cases within the treaty territory. If the government says that can't happen, then the government is making an argument\n               that treaties extinguish the Indigenous rights of other nations. Well, clearly, that's\n               not in the language. Clearly, that is not what's in the treaty. So you're going to\n               be sitting in a situation where you don't have agreement with your neighbours. They're\n               going to be able to move forward title cases. Quite frankly, given the way the courts\n               are going and the way this government has put DRIPA as a priority, what they've done\n               with Haida Gwaii, with the issues that we've seen with Quw'utsun and others, clearly you're going to see title cases that will be successful within\n               treaty territories. How will that work? What kind of certainty does that bring? What happens if, now,\n               you're in a situation where for the next 15 years these sort of issues are going to\n               be fought out through the courts rather than sitting down and negotiating and dealing\n               with how you need to address the overlaps. Now, I saw treaties come forward, and I've seen challenges over treaty boundaries\n               that have not been successful. I get it. I understand that once the treaty is in place,\n               it has a certain level of, I guess, authority, you might say, that the courts look\n               at. But that was before DRIPA and UNDRIP. Now that you have these enshrined in the\n               treaty that you're bringing forward here, you've got a serious issue because you don't\n               have the same level of certainty that you may have had with the existing treaties,\n               with the ones that were done through the modern treaty process before the government\n               brought this information in, before they brought this process in. So how will these things work? Once again, free, prior and informed consent. Was that\n               followed? Likely not. I'm looking forward to asking that question of the minister\n               and watching how many times he dances to different answers, because I know he's not\n               going to be able to answer that question appropriately. I sort of look at it, and I think.... I'm a true believer in treaties. I mean, I've\n               negotiated them. I've been part of the teams that negotiated them. I've signed them.\n               Very honoured to be there. I was there doing the final ceremony for ɬəʔamɛn when it came and was implemented. I've been talking to the treaty nations, making\n               sure they understand that as a party, should we have that on our form of government,\n               that finds us as partners that will want to work and bring life to the treaties to\n               make sure they're successful.... I want to see that happen. But I'm in a very conflicted situation right now because\n               of language and how these are being implemented. I'm not sure this is the right path\n               anymore. I think maybe we should be thinking about a different approach. But I am\n               open to sitting down with the nations, with these treaty nations — particularly the\n               K'ómoks, the one we're negotiating here — and talking about if it's possible to remove this\n               DRIPA language, this UNDRIP language, and still implement the treaty. After all, who brought forward the idea that this needed to be in the treaty in the\n               first place? I suspect strongly it was this government. I don't think this was a demand\n               of the nations. I've talked to a number of the nations that are in the treaty process.\n               They haven't demanded this language. So why does it need to be in there? Why is this\n               government insisting on putting it in there, especially given all of the uncertainty\n               that is there around DRIPA currently in the court cases that are happening in B.C.? So I look at all of this, and I think: \"Wow, what a time to be bringing this forward.\"\n               When treaties were previously brought forward in the Legislature, there was lots of\n               long debate, lots of good discussion. It was important to do that, because you want\n               to set the tone for how treaties will be perceived by the courts, how they'll be looked\n               at, should they be challenged in the future. The treaties that were brought in were\n               basically unanimously supported. The treaties that were brought in were, basically, unanimously supported. There were\n               a couple of NDP MLAs who did decide to speak against the treaties and vote against\n               the treaties. You know what the NDP did? They kicked them out of their party. They weren't allowed\n               to have an individual voice. They were kicked out of their party and forced to sit\n               as independents. Sorry, they weren't kicked out of their party; they were kicked out\n               of their caucus. They were forced to sit as independents for a period of time. I guess\n               it was considered a punishment for them daring to stand up and have an individual\n               perspective.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721648","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Apologize for not being able to be there in person; unfortunately, I put my back out over the weekend, so I'm in the process of healing.\n               But regardless of that, I'm still very honoured to have the opportunity to rise and\n               speak with regards to Bill 20 and the K'ómoks treaty. I have a little bit of a unique situation here, associated with this, s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["18168e99e26b730f5b7818222a456bdc07c7b4e6adba7a04f0488ca91eb7fe8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ce4bd144cd402f1ce9f881d365b800f1d201379a2aaa4e1904815f7b575e122b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2038b36444b2683a8efe0db6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721652,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's an honour to be able to carry on with the conversation started yesterday around\n               Bill 20. There's been lots of rhetoric, lots of accusations, and I just want to summarize\n               some of the things I said yesterday before I carry on here. Treaty is, ultimately, for a large form, the best form you could of reconciliation.\n               The intent of treaty was to be able to create certainty around Section 35, to be able\n               to bring certainty for the people in British Columbia, certainty for the people of\n               a nation like the K'ómoks Nation and to allow them to be able to move forward in a good way as partners with\n               Canada, with British Columbia to building success and building a future for its people.\n               This is the goal that I think should be achieved. The uncertainty, though, of how this treaty has changed from the other modern treaties\n               that were created is the big issue here. The adoption of UNDRIP as in the language; the fact that UNDRIP is \"an authoritative source for the implementation of the treaty;\" the fact that UNDRIP itself leaves many, many questions and has created court challenges\n               and issues in this province.... I think, quite frankly, it's done the People of K'ómoks a huge disservice by this government actually putting it into the treaty. There's\n               too much uncertainty that has been created there. It doesn't bring the opportunity\n               and the potential that I know the K'ómoks people would like to see happen. There's been lots of debate around the general public being up in arms. You see things\n               like the Quw'utsun decision. You see things like what's going on with Haida — even the xwməθkwəy̓əm agreement. There are so many high-profile issues that many, many people are starting\n               to raise serious concerns. So I look at it, and I think: \"Okay, so what is this government actually doing? Why\n               do we have Indigenous-only health care? Why do we have Indigenous-only child care?\n               Why do we have these things that, quite frankly, give the opportunity for division\n               in this province?\" And I understand Section 35. I understand the rights. I understand\n               what we need to be doing to repair many of the wrongs of the past. But when you look at it from a lens, from the average public looking at it, they kind\n               of wonder and start thinking: \"Wait a second here. What about the rest of us?\" There\n               are five million people in this province who are not Indigenous. Where are their concerns\n               being raised and thought of? This government, when it goes and negotiates things like\n               treaty or any other sort of agreements that it's done, goes and negotiates This government, when it goes to negotiate things like treaty or any other sort of\n               agreements that it's done, goes and negotiates them, finalizes them, then they go\n               to the public and inform them. There isn't an engagement there. You wonder why the\n               public then starts pushing back. To blame a political party for reflecting what's\n               already been going on in the public I think is quite wrong. When I look at, once again, a treaty, at this, I understand what the K'ómoks Nation is trying to do. I really do, and I support what they're trying to do. This is what\n               leaves me with such a difficult decision to make. Do I support a treaty that I know\n               is flawed, a treaty that, quite frankly, is going to create untold problems down the\n               road, so many unintended consequences? Or do I oppose something that I believe in,\n               is a good thing, particularly for the K'ómoks People and, quite frankly, for the province? So let's just take this out and look at what would happen if we had treaties covering\n               all the nations in this province, 204 treaties. Well, the model that is here, with\n               UNDRIP being in place, is a co-governance model or a joint decision-making model.\n               Essentially, that means all decision-makers, the province as well as the First Nation,\n               need to agree or nothing happens. That is what free, prior and informed consent is\n               being interpreted as in the province of British Columbia. If all the treaties, all the nations in the province were all treaty nations, and\n               the government was now in the situation where it had joint decision-making everywhere,\n               why do we even have a provincial government except to fund the decisions that would\n               ultimately be made by the First Nations? There is a line that is being crossed here.\n               There's a line that's being crossed in the approach that this government is taking. What does reconciliation mean? How does reconciliation conclude? You can't achieve\n               reconciliation if you don't know what it is that you're actually trying to achieve.\n               You can't achieve reconciliation if there isn't a conclusion because then it becomes\n               this forever-changing target. I think the people in British Columbia need to know and they deserve to understand\n               what exactly this government is trying to do. This treaty, of course, lays out another\n               piece of the vision in terms of how this government sees reconciliation moving in\n               this province. Why doesn't this government come forward and actually say what reconciliation\n               does mean? Why doesn't this government come forward and actually put forward a plan\n               saying this is how reconciliation will be concluded in British Columbia? We need to\n               see that conclusion, I believe, if we want to be able to move forward in a good way. Now, I look forward to talking to the Chiefs of K'ómoks. I've talked with some of the other chiefs. I look forward to more meetings with\n               the Chief of Kitselas and Kitsumkalum because I'd like to know from them, would they\n               be willing to complete these treaties if we were to remove the UNDRIP language that\n               is in them? Is the UNDRIP language the hill to die on? Is it the straw that breaks\n               the camel's back? Is this the thing that has to be in these treaties? Because if it doesn't, let's sit down and talk about how we remove it so that it isn't\n               a barrier to moving forward with the success of treaty. This is where we should be\n               going, and this is the question that I have in terms of whether I support this treaty\n               or not. Are the Chiefs willing, particularly the Chief of K'ómoks, because this is the treaty that we are discussing here with Bill 20...? Is the Chief\n               of K'ómoks willing to consider removing the UNDRIP language from the treaty so that we can move\n               forward with this treaty in a good way and be able to achieve the results that I believe\n               they want to achieve and I think, quite frankly, people in British Columbia want to\n               achieve in terms of finalizing the reconciliation for the K'ómoks People? If we're able to do that, then why don't we just pause this treaty, get it done, remove\n               that language now and then move forward and complete it? The alternative, of course, is to have an agreement to renegotiate after the treaty\n               is implemented, but of course, that could take a tremendous amount of time with untold\n               potential damages from a legal perspective. As we were talking about yesterday, we've\n               got a government that is in court fighting against its own legislation of DRIPA, which\n               is the implementation of UNDRIP, and now you're going to be passing a treaty which\n               brings in a constitutional-level protection and implementation of UNDRIP. It's going to be used against the government in its own arguments in court, or maybe\n               that's what the government is trying to do here. Maybe that's why the government hasn't\n               brought forward changes to DRIPA, because it knows it wouldn't stand the test of time\n               with the implementation of these treaties. There is no question There is no question that there are a lot of things we need to do in this province.\n               Economically, we're in serious trouble. Socially, we've got a tremendous number of\n               problems and friction forming. We need to find this path to reconciliation. It is\n               the elephant in the room. You can't achieve anything else unless we're able to find\n               the path forward with First Nations. Treaty is one of those paths that can work, but we need to be able to find a way that all\n               British Columbians can accept. We need to find a way that moves forward and creates\n               those opportunities. And you know, the government says, \"Oh, we wouldn't be able to do this. We're going\n               to risk all kinds of economic activity if we were to move DRIPA.\" I want to remind people in this House, I signed 435 agreements. Those were mining\n               agreements, pipeline agreements, LNG agreements, agreements for clean energy, agreements\n               for forestry. Those were agreements for all kinds of economic activity, investing\n               billions of dollars in British Columbia, including agreements on Site C, on power\n               lines, on all kinds of activities in this province. All of that was done without DRIPA. All of that was done without UNDRIP. Surprise,\n               surprise, the world didn't just start because we've introduced this. However, what\n               we have introduced is a tremendous amount of uncertainty. This government said by doing this we would eliminate or reduce court cases and all\n               of these things because we would have this great relationship. Well, how has that\n               turned out? It hasn't turned out very well for the people of British Columbia. It\n               certainly hasn't turned out well for the certainty for the people in Richmond that\n               are under the Quw'utsun case. How much more uncertainty and unintended consequences is this government willing\n               to implement on its reckless path of pursuing UNDRIP? Treaties are an important process in British Columbia. I was very proud to sign agreements-in-principle. I was very proud to be there for celebrating the implementation of treaties. I've\n               spoken favourably of treaties for many, many years. And I still am in favour of that\n               form of reconciliation but I think, quite frankly, in British Columbia, we need to\n               be thinking even bigger. We need to be looking at what New Zealand has done with the\n               Maori. We need to be thinking about how we approach reconciliation to bring it to\n               conclusion so that we don't have this ever-changing target. The only way we're going to be truly able to unleash the economic potential of this\n               province to solve our budget problems, to solve the problems of health care, to solve\n               the problems with addictions, and the investments that we need in safety and fighting\n               crime in this province is to be able to have a strong economy. And the only way to\n               do that is to find a path forward to conclude reconciliation so that we can bring\n               the certainty and we can drive the investment that's needed in British Columbia. Treaty is one form, but with the way that this treaty is written, with all the uncertainty\n               that is created now because of UNDRIP, I'm just not sure that it's going to achieve\n               what we are hoping it would be and, certainly, what the promise of treaty was. The folks in the K'ómoks Nation have waited a long time to be able to do this. As I mentioned yesterday, I\n               remember after the agreement-in-principle signing sitting down with them and them\n               doubting whether they want to move forward with the treaty because of some of the\n               challenges that were there. I'm glad to see that they've done that. I'm not certain\n               though that what is being put in place is actually going to create what they're hoping\n               for, particularly with the overlap and the challenges now, the court cases that are\n               going to come forward, the risk now of title being declared within treaty territory.\n               This has created an unbelievable situation in this province. And I think, quite frankly, any government, any reasonable, rational, intelligent\n               government would want to say we need to figure out how this is solved before we move\n               forward recklessly again in this approach of UNDRIP. So with that, I look forward to more of the debate that's going to come. I look forward\n               to the relationships that are going to continue to need to be built in this province.\n               I look forward, quite frankly, to a day where we can sit down with First Nations and\n               agree on how to conclude reconciliation for the benefit of all British Columbians.\n               Because without that, the uncertainty that's created and the problems and the friction\n               that is building is not going to lead to a good path. I'll just conclude by saying this. There's nowhere in the world that has introduced\n               legislation that has created rights for one people and not another that has ended\n               well. We need to find a way to be able to reconcile those different rights and those\n               differences so that we can move forward together. And if that means everybody is unhappy,\n               Indigenous and non-Indigenous alike, maybe that's the right We need to find a way to be able to reconcile those different rights and those differences\n               so that we can move forward together. And if that means everybody is unhappy, Indigenous and non-Indigenous alike, maybe that's the right answer. But right now, what we are doing in this province\n               is creating too much friction. I've heard from too many people across this province that are fed up, that are frustrated.\n               They want to conclude this. They want to live well with their neighbours. Both Indigenous\n               and non-Indigenous alike have told me this. We need to find the path to do that. So I hope to see more dialogue happening around these treaties. I hope to see we have\n               that opportunity to remove UNDRIP, because I would dearly love to be in a position to be able to support this treaty. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the time to be able to respond to this. I know the folks\n               in my riding of Nechako Lakes care deeply about their neighbours, about First Nations, about finding the solution,\n               but there needs to be solution and not uncertainty that is being created.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721652","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's an honour to be able to carry on with the conversation started yesterday around\n               Bill 20. There's been lots of rhetoric, lots of accusations, and I just want to summarize\n               some of the things I said yesterday before I carry on here. Treaty is, ultimately, for a large form, the best form you could of reconciliation.\n               The intent of treaty was to be able ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8398ff1d390af6d4544d7f27116057b69e1257186a5682bf22e3db32e7f50428"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c768a01433b7a7731ef4064f767c414765faf717d3ace3b8ac1a950d3dfcc7e7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0819e9543484c6feb10cb97","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017582,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"John Rustad","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start, with regards to the motion, just addressing some of the things that\n               the hon. member from the Green Party has brought forward. I understand the reluctance\n               and his suspicion around this. The actions of opposition often use things like hoists\n               to delay projects, to try to talk things out, to eat up time, these types of things.\n               But in this particular case, when you're looking at what the intent was here, there\n               are serious issues associated with overlap. Now, when modern treaties were first brought in — and I remember debating some of\n               these treaties in the Legislature — the issue of overlap was there as well, but it\n               wasn't as acute. Because of DRIPA, UNDRIP, the court cases that have come forward,\n               the issue of overlap is far more critical today than it was in the original treaties,\n               whether it was the Maa-nulth treaty or whether it is some of the treaties that failed\n               — ɬəʔamɛn. Tsawwassen, of course, had been successful. I'm thinking particularly about the Lheidli T'enneh treaty, which did not get ratified because of overlap issues. So what we are seeing today is a significant difference between those treaties that\n               were brought in and this treaty here and the other two treaties yet to come, being\n               the Kitselas and Kitsumkalum. Because of the significance of the environment that's\n               changed in B.C. because of what's happened with DRIPA, with the introduction of UNDRIP\n               as part of that, the expectations are much higher. The legal ramifications are much\n               more significant, and we are seeing that playing out. For those reasons, I think it's important that we send this to a committee, that we\n               have an opportunity to actually play these things out, to talk about this, to understand\n               how this goes in, to have the input and try to find a path forward. Because the world\n               has changed from 30 years ago, from 20 years ago, from ten years ago. The world has\n               changed. It has changed intentionally by this government, for better or for worse. I would\n               say for worse. But it has intentionally changed, and so we need to take that into\n               context when we're talking about treaty and the advancement of treaty. I've been a proponent of treaty for many, many years, and I've come to the conclusion\n               that we need to be talking much more about how we conclude reconciliation entirely,\n               but that's a different conversation. There needs to be this avenue to be able to address this because of how things have\n               changed in British Columbia, and how else can you do that? Because in committee stage,\n               we can have this discussion back and forth, but it's not the opportunity of time and\n               to be able to have the input and engagement between the nations, giving them the ability\n               to actually work this thing through with the help of government and opposition, through\n               committee, working these things through.... After all, as the member of the Green Party said, this is the whole purpose of why\n               they're there. We want to be able to pass and bring things forward that make sense,\n               that can achieve results, that are going to improve the opportunities for First Nations\n               — self-determined, self-governance, these types of things. If we're going to do that, if we're going to do that right, let's find a way to avoid\n               the huge pitfalls that, quite frankly, have become major barriers, major stumbling blocks to how we\n               advance modern treaties today. It's not just about the K'ómoks treaty, because we have the other treaties and other nations of the province who\n               are looking at it. The issue of overlaps is far more significant right across this province. So if we\n               can get it right here, if we can find a way to be able to address it and deal with\n               it today, through a process, we're not only helping to solidify and strengthen the\n               opportunity for the K'ómoks People, but we're also setting the stage for how we might be able to do things across\n               this province in addressing this. So this is a very timely and important discussion to be able to bring forward in terms\n               of this motion, and I really thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove for So this is a very timely and important discussion to be able to bring forward in terms\n               of this motion, and I really thank the member for Langley–Walnut Grove for opening up this debate around moving it to a committee, creating that avenue\n               to deal with it. Now, there are some things that the Green Party and I may agree on. There are some things that we may not agree on. One of the things,\n               of course, is UNDRIP and the implementation of UNDRIP. When I first looked at the treaty, and it says\n               it's an authoritative source, I kind of looked at it and went: \"Well, is this huge?\n               Is this significant? What does this mean?\" But I've come to the conclusion that with the problems of DRIPA.... And we don't even\n               know exactly what they all are because government isn't forthcoming with these issues.\n               They haven't brought forward legislation and the changes that they believe are necessary to be able to resolve these things. Cementing UNDRIP into a constitutional document creates a tremendous amount of unknown\n               factors. And so I went to all the sources I could find. I've talked to First Nations about it. I've talked to lawyers about it. I've talked to judges and former judges\n               about it. What does it mean, an authoritative source? It doesn't say it's the authoritative\n               source; it says it's an authoritative source. What it means is that it is authoritative. In other words, it is at the same equivalent law to all other law in this country, including section 35 of our constitution. It is an authoritative source. When you go back and look at the original debate of UNDRIP in the United Nations, that was never what the intention was. It was never the intention of that as it\n               was passed, and certainly not in the context of Canada, which has Aboriginal rights protected in the constitution. So the importance of this motion to move this to committee is to be able to create\n               that venue, that opportunity for discussion of overlap, but it's also to allow for\n               more information to come forward of the unintended consequences of having UNDRIP directly\n               in this treaty. Because as I'm sure you know, the member who spoke before me from the Green Party,\n               other members have talked about — what's the purpose of doing treaty in the first\n               place? The purpose of doing treaty is to find a path forward, for nations to be successful,\n               to prevent things from going to court, to create that sort of stability or certainty\n               that we've all talked about. That's the intent of doing treaty. It's a way to address these long outstanding issues and be able to move forward in a good way as partners — not as divorced but\n               as partners, married, going forward, moving this forward to be successful. But how\n               do you do that when there's this kind of uncertainty that is being created, and how\n               do you do that with these issues of overlaps with their neighbours? You think about this. It's been 30 years working on to get this treaty to this point\n               — 30 years. Multiple generations have been working at this to get this thing passed. And I know the K'ómoks People are excited about moving this forward. They want to see their opportunity to\n               advance. We've seen the success of other modern treaties that have come forward for\n               this. I believe that the First Nations want this to be successful and they don't want this to generate conflict or they\n               don't want this to generate court cases. They don't want to have the conflict of unintended\n               consequence as well. There's a simple change that could have happened. Instead of making it an authoritative\n               process, they could have done it like UNDRIP was supposed to be. They could have just\n               said it is a guiding principle. How does...?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017582","member_id":"bc-mla-70","member_name":"John Rustad","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to start, with regards to the motion, just addressing some of the things that\n               the hon. member from the Green Party has brought forward. I understand the reluctance\n               and his suspicion around this. The actions of opposition often use things like hoists\n               to delay projects, to try to talk things out, to eat up time, these types of things.\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental impact","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035117","label":"Environmental impact","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["063a4656735c63bc466e857fb2eb1f4847e8d82b22b0284922217a9d53541f8a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.72,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58411b8316768eb31fc0bbc02691012b8395454e22699ee7b08c8e2528b547d7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e27eaf2b0cd360e53112783a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317198,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just want to acknowledge our beloved community members and friends, Ryan Michael\n               Sheepwash and Jeremy Robert Alexander. They just got married on February 14 in Puerto\n               Vallarta. This wedding was so special because both of them overcame lots of hurdles, like discrimination.\n               Last year, when they decided to get married, they got kicked out, facing homophobia\n               and discrimination. So the Hilton Vallarta Resort did the right thing. They stepped\n               in to show love over hate, and acceptance, and offered to cover their entire wedding. Would the House please join me to wish Jeremy and Ryan a very happy a married life\n               as well as their safe return home from Mexico, along with other Canadians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual orientation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317198","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I just want to acknowledge our beloved community members and friends, Ryan Michael\n               Sheepwash and Jeremy Robert Alexander. They just got married on February 14 in Puerto\n               Vallarta. This wedding was so special because both of them overcame lots of hurdles, like discrimination.\n               Last year, when they decided to get married, they got kicked out, facing homopho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","label":"Sexual orientation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Festivals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual orientation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","label":"Sexual orientation","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.54,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","label":"Marriage","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716734","label":"Festivals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["35056a99f178e72cde932b1fbb2885bafd21429dcc19b29f442f4f0b5e0ec7b4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual orientation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["820de61a010b01628cc421d8dc196c49198216343439f98637b6d9deac70c9ae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Marriage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual orientation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:103068","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501256","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cc853779d7944fd7f76fceb9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328041,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand here today with immense pride to celebrate extraordinary achievement by the\n               senior girls basketball team from Vernon Secondary School. For the first time in the\n               school's history, these remarkable student athletes captured a provincial championship\n               banner, capping off a truly historic season. Last Saturday, Panthers beat out Langley Christian Lightning 71-62, led by tournament\n               MVP Chloe Collins who scored 32 points, including three-pointers. This victory is\n               about more than the banner. It reflects countless early mornings, late practices,\n               the support of coaches, families and classmates and the resilience these young athletes\n               showed every step of the way. This team's dedication and tenacity inspire the entire Vernon, and we're all celebrating\n               proudly. On behalf of this House, may I ask the members to please join me in congratulating\n               the Vernon Panthers senior girls basketball team on their outstanding accomplishment\n               by being also the top team in B.C. for 3A. Congratulations.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328041","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I stand here today with immense pride to celebrate extraordinary achievement by the\n               senior girls basketball team from Vernon Secondary School. For the first time in the\n               school's history, these remarkable student athletes captured a provincial championship\n               banner, capping off a truly historic season. Last Saturday, Panthers beat out Langley Christian Lig","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["bafa0142e3ba3b01a07a9173b2fbb7e1644e634fd4cc9b2d22d27fdf54d97db5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8e84df9d64212f35511f7a68e11465f55cb21cd11a7cd6ad433bbef463ec7427"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b995d2319ca5855b57f2dbcd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328042,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Since the Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth has beat me to it, but I had my hand\n               up, I too would like to acknowledge an extraordinary individual who's very inspiring,\n               a trail-blazer and a champion of human rights and workers rights. He is a favourite\n               among children to adults to seniors, and also across the world, in the South Asian\n               diaspora and beyond. I, too, would like to take a moment to wish you, Mr. Speaker, a very happy birthday.\n               Thank you for all you do.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328042","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Since the Minister of Jobs and Economic Growth has beat me to it, but I had my hand\n               up, I too would like to acknowledge an extraordinary individual who's very inspiring,\n               a trail-blazer and a champion of human rights and workers rights. He is a favourite\n               among children to adults to seniors, and also across the world, in the South Asian\n               dia","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-482e480d890ca3bcf358b2bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328043,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today my son Avishaan turns ten. Avishaan is a very kind, loving and deeply caring\n               person. He stands up proudly against bullying, and he cares for everyone around him.\n               He does admit when he makes mistakes, and he strives to be a better person. As a mom, I cannot be prouder of him. I started this work, he was less than a year,\n               and I got elected when he was only four. I miss him so much, as many members can relate.\n               But when I talk to Avishaan with this mom guilt, he tells me and reassures me, \"Mom,\n               I'm proud of the work you do for people in our community,\" and those words mean a\n               lot. Besides being my French tutor, he also joins me for most of the community events and\n               asks the meaning behind it. Recently he joined me for Coldest Night of the Year. Not\n               only he joins; he is getting to the point he recruits his friends to come join and\n               tells them the meaning of these events. That is who Avishaan is. May I ask the House, please join me to wish my son Avishaan a very happy birthday. Happy birthday, Avishaan.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328043","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today my son Avishaan turns ten. Avishaan is a very kind, loving and deeply caring\n               person. He stands up proudly against bullying, and he cares for everyone around him.\n               He does admit when he makes mistakes, and he strives to be a better person. As a mom, I cannot be prouder of him. I started this work, he was less than a year,\n               and I got elected when he w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Gender equality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Francophonie","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Bilingual services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1003978","label":"Bilingual services","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035451","label":"Gender equality","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083633","label":"Francophonie","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fe4c09437a2fec8a5fb82b274bf7fc5d217734ba727c659d337d0335a7b49aa7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-27d12f3da6845f1a9e76f87a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360880,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two quick introductions to make. The first one is our incredible community\n               members who make our community so beautiful. Jeff Fisher and Ingrid Fisher are celebrating\n               their 25th anniversary today and they do so much for our community. They have two beautiful children and one of their children is our Vernon-Lumby constituency advisor. Would the House please join me to wish Jeff and Ingrid a very happy 25th anniversary.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360880","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I have two quick introductions to make. The first one is our incredible community\n               members who make our community so beautiful. Jeff Fisher and Ingrid Fisher are celebrating\n               their 25th anniversary today and they do so much for our community. They have two beautiful children and one of their children is our Vernon-Lumby constituency advisor. Would the House please join ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Real estate industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036884","label":"Real estate industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43468","label":"Real estate","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["42e51f6506cf5b0492f7d7283924fed8661831cac4503dacff709b785ec07c49"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-930785585a0631cbb508b0f8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":360881,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today my nephew, Avinoor Singh, is turning 19. He's graduating this year as well, and he wants to pursue his career\n               in medicine. He's the one who started cricket team in his school, the school where he was so nervous\n               to go because he has long hair and wears turban, but school students and teachers\n               accepted him with open arms, as that's who true Canadians are, and now he's thriving\n               there. I just want to say thank-you to everyone for the last few years for the love and kindness you've showed and which\n               helped Avinoor to thrive. So happy birthday Avinoor, and welcome to the adulthood.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adulthood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:360881","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today my nephew, Avinoor Singh, is turning 19. He's graduating this year as well, and he wants to pursue his career\n               in medicine. He's the one who started cricket team in his school, the school where he was so nervous\n               to go because he has long hair and wears turban, but school students and teachers\n               accepted him with open arms, as that's who true Canadian","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","label":"Adulthood"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parenting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adulthood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Parents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035205","label":"Family education","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501316","label":"Parenting","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","label":"Adulthood","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70434","label":"Parents","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6bf3dc7cb8ed4dfe2204112d8ecefd9b5c90ece9931ffebd23ffbe4c9e1e2e90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adulthood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.19,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5b6ddea56b6d6e9ddec82e03996838974fa8144301fe89d04d8c499dd5f444ce"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Adulthood","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501343","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f62f4853b9c4ac8c18f1a74b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415815,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am pleased to rise to recognize an extraordinary athlete from our community,\n               Ina Forrest. Fresh off the Milano-Cortina 2026 Paralympic Winter Games, Spallumcheen's Ina Forrest and her team made history as the first wheelchair curling team to go undefeated\n               on their way to a gold medal. This marks her fifth Paralympic medal, having competed\n               in every game since 2010. What an incredible record of three gold and two bronze medals. Ina is now the most decorated wheelchair curler in the history, and we are incredibly\n               proud to call her a member of Vernon Curling Club and our community. She will be celebrating\n               at the home club this evening. While I can't join you in person, Ina and team, I am here with you in spirit. Please join me in congratulating Ina Forrest and her entire team for their remarkable\n               achievement.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415815","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today I am pleased to rise to recognize an extraordinary athlete from our community,\n               Ina Forrest. Fresh off the Milano-Cortina 2026 Paralympic Winter Games, Spallumcheen's Ina Forrest and her team made history as the first wheelchair curling team to go undefeated\n               on their way to a gold medal. This marks her fifth Paralympic medal, having competed\n               in eve","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Fire prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Olympic games","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Forest management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Wheelchairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","label":"Winter sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036542","label":"Olympic games","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","label":"Gold","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:110081","label":"Wheelchairs","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","label":"Athletes","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47468","label":"Emergency services","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715119","label":"Forest management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:948818","label":"Fire prevention","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["03c1e98ed10a2197dde28c1a5a06e15f1089a05b455b4114c6cfbf3e198da279"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a0e316878554ab1ef8612ed18c644e5287b682cfc4144624e8e73c672597b2b1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Athletes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Gold","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Winter sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035690","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083641","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43065","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bd4e6c37ec6f0aeb75b4fdbf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720543,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am honoured to recognize the B.C. Association of Health Care Auxiliaries as\n               they prepare to gather in Vernon for the 2026 provincial conference, celebrating an\n               incredible 81 years of service to communities across our province. Since 1945, health care auxiliaries have been a quiet but powerful force in our health\n               care system. Their impact is remarkable, and at the end of 2025, there were 62 auxiliaries\n               across our province made up of more than 5,000 adult volunteers and more than 400\n               student volunteers. Together they contributed over At the end of 2025, there were 62 auxiliaries across our province, made up of more\n               than 5,000 adult volunteers and more than 400 student volunteers. Together they contributed\n               over 1.1 million hours of service and raised more than $10.4 million to support the\n               health care system across our province. These numbers are extraordinary, but what they represent is more powerful. Their contribution\n               fund essential equipment, improve patient comfort and strengthen community support\n               outreach. Because of you, hospitals are better equipped and patients and families\n               feel supported during the most difficult times in their life. As a long-time registered nurse, I have had the privilege of getting to know many\n               of these wonderful people in our hospital auxiliary. I remember walking into the hospital\n               to begin long shifts and being greeted by the auxiliary store workers with beautiful\n               smiles and welcome and their eagerness to help no matter who came through the door.\n               Those simple moments lifted my spirits and made my day before it had even begun, along\n               with many other people. In the Interior region and across our province, auxiliaries continue to play an important\n               role in doing the work alongside care teams to enhance patient care in communities\n               like Vernon and across the region. To every health care auxiliary staff, thank you from the bottom of my heart for your\n               dedication, generosity, and your compassion. You are the heart of our hospitals, and\n               our communities are stronger, beautiful and better just because of you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720543","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Today I am honoured to recognize the B.C. Association of Health Care Auxiliaries as\n               they prepare to gather in Vernon for the 2026 provincial conference, celebrating an\n               incredible 81 years of service to communities across our province. Since 1945, health care auxiliaries have been a quiet but powerful force in our health\n               care system. Their impact is rema","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0c25adc50c631f50a64e22b52eadc71ce206a91bef4fc87e501b441dd211edfd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f55a6802200ab5294a66e5908ea56c3fcccf87f2394510263a355daafdefcab2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4b3b3e4f640d8dcf82977ce1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729426,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Every year in our beautiful province, there is a quiet moment when you can feel the\n               season shifting. The days stretch a little longer, and trees begin to bud. Our communities\n               gently move into a new rhythm. For me, one of the clearest signs of spring is the return of our local farmers markets.\n               Vernon Farmers Market opened on April 16. There is something truly special about that\n               day back — the sound of familiar voices, smell of fresh baking and neighbours reconnecting\n               after the season. I was born and raised in a farming family, and those roots stay with me. In farming\n               families, we learn the value of hard work, caring for the land and the importance\n               of supporting those who feed our communities. As Parliamentary Secretary for Agriculture and food, I also want to recognize that\n               our farmers markets and our local food systems are strengthened through strong partnerships.\n               Through programs that support local food production, market developments and initiatives\n               like Buy B.C., we are helping connect farmers, producers and families and strengthening\n               our local food economy across the province. Every week, I see that connection in action: farmers bringing their harvest early\n               in the morning, artisans sharing their craft and families teaching their children\n               where their food comes from. Those are simple moments, but they are what hold our\n               communities together. In the weeks ahead, the spirit continues to grow. The Lumby Farmers Market returns\n               over Mother's Day weekend, and Davison Orchard opens again on May 1 — places where\n               traditions are built and memories are made. As spring turns to summer, the Polson Night Market will once again fill our evenings\n               with the music, laughter and energy that makes this region so special. These places\n               matter. They remind us that behind every table, there is a person, a family, a story\n               all connecting us to the land, to one another and to the hearts of our communities. I encourage everyone to visit your local market, support our farmers and small businesses\n               and take a moment to simply enjoy being part of your beautiful communities that we\n               all have the honour to represent.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729426","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Every year in our beautiful province, there is a quiet moment when you can feel the\n               season shifting. The days stretch a little longer, and trees begin to bud. Our communities\n               gently move into a new rhythm. For me, one of the clearest signs of spring is the return of our local farmers markets.\n               Vernon Farmers Market opened on April 16. There is something ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","label":"Farms","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","label":"Agri-food industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","label":"Agri-food products","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","label":"Agriculture","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["53f6634e8c296e1c624c2abba743445c7cfce973796c53969e99317b8d845a08"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.5,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4fdacd7c2ef69c08b1ac38dec97dfcba944e8f8358bed4327452665b6acef084"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Farms","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agriculture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agri-food products","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:70430","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715190","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715735","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:859","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ae5970a479333ae1f8cfe57c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729428,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to take a moment to recognize some very special guests at the precinct\n               today from Vernon-Lumby, who are here in Victoria attending the CUPE convention. Joining us today is my dear\n               friend Sherry Kineshanko, who served as an educational assistant with school district 22, and she is a counsellor\n               with the village of Lumby. She's accompanied by Tracy Best, vice-president of CUPE,\n               and Michelle Skillnik, president of CUPE Local 5523. School district 22 employs dedicated educational assistants Kim Carlson, Lisa Kramer\n               and Barb Nerling. In addition to their work supporting students, several of them also\n               take an important role of coordinating meal programs in their schools, helping students\n               feel supported both inside and outside the classroom. These individuals play a very\n               important, vital role to support students and families and our communities. I want\n               to take a moment to thank them for the work they do. Please join me in making them feel very welcome. They will be joining us here later.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729428","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to take a moment to recognize some very special guests at the precinct\n               today from Vernon-Lumby, who are here in Victoria attending the CUPE convention. Joining us today is my dear\n               friend Sherry Kineshanko, who served as an educational assistant with school district 22, and she is a counsellor\n               with the village of Lumby. She's accompanied by ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.52,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["db674f456f5494ed22b6258218f2057d5c2714f1cd333dffeeff7668bcd108d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["411b3e75d43dc1cf71fba9123df7d381479e7181f353eb5326d808c7742469f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4c1961daabbe99a5552055fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752332,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am excited and thrilled to introduce my dear friends, my health care family and\n               colleagues, Sarah Mitsy and Vincent. They are here at the Legislature today. They're\n               both a power couple. Vincent is a psychiatric nurse at Vernon Jubilee Hospital, also\n               worked at Kelowna before that, and Sarah, an LPN, for more than 11 years. Between\n               Vincent and Sarah, they both have served and helped people in health care for more\n               than two decades, and they're so close to me. I get very excited whenever I introduce people from the health care sector because\n               there's reason. In Vernon Jubilee and in Mills Memorial, Terrace, those were the only\n               families. They were with me and my family through thick and thin — through tough,\n               difficult times and happy times, so I hold them near and dear to my heart. Would the House please join my friends to feel very welcomed here?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752332","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am excited and thrilled to introduce my dear friends, my health care family and\n               colleagues, Sarah Mitsy and Vincent. They are here at the Legislature today. They're\n               both a power couple. Vincent is a psychiatric nurse at Vernon Jubilee Hospital, also\n               worked at Kelowna before that, and Sarah, an LPN, for more than 11 years. Between\n               Vincen","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","label":"Health care industry","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501130","label":"Family","probability":0.53,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c4ae196be72f37f11bd42e4cccbd42fd9247f7613cc25dff97a19405eb7417c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c7d92642cd8c55b543a46d6c31f548c0d41f6f4a3c191d84a2204eddc9bb24b8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health care industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035624","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-73a7f71148da913b02117fe2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752333,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am excited to introduce my constituency adviser Amy, here, and Caitlin is joining\n               virtually because it takes quite the effort to make a trip here. I am very grateful to have Caitlin, Amy and Ella. They show the world how to work\n               collaboratively in a very non-partisan.... They serve my constituents and constituents\n               across in the neighbouring riding, whoever walks through the door, with utmost care I want to extend my thanks to you all, and I want to welcome all the CAs here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752333","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I am excited to introduce my constituency adviser Amy, here, and Caitlin is joining\n               virtually because it takes quite the effort to make a trip here. I am very grateful to have Caitlin, Amy and Ella. They show the world how to work\n               collaboratively in a very non-partisan.... They serve my constituents and constituents\n               across in the neighbouring riding, wh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Distance education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034870","label":"Distance education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8befe02e3fd40d2dd5e1768376b21a5f363a89ea883f1bbdb818e154241ac989"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b3f5e9d904e89eeaed953f68d49caa2bb6d1f90090b77bf4e2ffa350d0cc7ebb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-547d3952d7b56eb4e3434643","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752334,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Once again this year I am standing here proudly to recognize our amazing community\n               members and friends, Brian Misko and his wife Corinne, as well as their entire team\n               from House of Q in Vernon. They are here on the precinct, busy barbecuing for us. House of Q, as I shared in previous years, started by using mom's stock pot, I believe,\n               in 2005. They make award-winning barbecue sauces and spices. One of the most awarded\n               barbecue sauces and rub companies around, who won over 200 prizes in 17 years. Brian\n               and his team will barbecue again today. It's their 14th year of doing this and making\n               B.C. Beef Day very special. If you're more curious to know about them, I highly encourage\n               you to check houseofq.com. Would the House please join me to welcome Brian, Corinne and their team, not only\n               to welcome but also thanking them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752334","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Once again this year I am standing here proudly to recognize our amazing community\n               members and friends, Brian Misko and his wife Corinne, as well as their entire team\n               from House of Q in Vernon. They are here on the precinct, busy barbecuing for us. House of Q, as I shared in previous years, started by using mom's stock pot, I believe,\n               in 2005. They make","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["76768fdd758f00ab815a4bfdf9984f04e8509afb6ae1114cd7443110f6eb473e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["eeaa110e20a2d28242c4cb5363ac9f404a8fdfff2dfe184be8f01eadff26830d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-102563ddfc8cf62a327486b0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017591,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I want to recognize and celebrate the Vernon-Coldstream chapter of Cycling Without\n               Age, a program that is making a profound difference in the lives of seniors in our\n               community. Since Dr. Lauren Lypchuk launched the chapter in 2019, thousands of seniors have been\n               able to reconnect with the community through free trishaw rides, powered by volunteers,\n               compassion and care. These rides do far more than provide transportation. They help\n               reduce social isolation, improve mental and emotional well-being, and bring memories\n               of joy, connection and belonging to seniors who'd otherwise feel alone. After a pause during the pandemic, the program returned in 2022 with incredible momentum,\n               running seasonally from mid-May to October 31. In that time, close to 2,800 seniors\n               have been taking off for free rides, covering almost 22,000 kilometres, including\n               804 passengers, just last year alone. These are moments of fresh air, conversations,\n               memory and joy that many participants might otherwise not experience. I also had the opportunity to ride on their trishaws with my son during one of the\n               Christmas community events. It was so much fun and a memorable experience. Seeing\n               the smiles, the connections and creating created really showed how hard behind this\n               program. I want to thank the Schubert Centre Society and, for doing so much to support this\n               cause, the many community partners, volunteers, trishaw pilots, coordinators and program\n               lead Erin Burgess, and everyone involved in the Vernon-Coldstream Cycling Without\n               Age chapter, from the bottom of my heart. Your work is helping to ensure that aging\n               is defined not by isolation but by dignity, inclusion, well-being and community connection.\n               Thank you so much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017591","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I want to recognize and celebrate the Vernon-Coldstream chapter of Cycling Without\n               Age, a program that is making a profound difference in the lives of seniors in our\n               community. Since Dr. Lauren Lypchuk launched the chapter in 2019, thousands of seniors have been\n               able to reconnect with the community through free trishaw rides, powered by volunteers","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Pensions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","label":"Elderly care","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501274","label":"Pensions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d85aa108570ae2ff06fc8bb3bf6c32b37651c22e06bf9316d87778011661464"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93ff0b69e9ed0591166350253090c0999c28bf07052627ccfe160cbae250a962"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Elderly care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034979","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f8610f7377dbf9c50af6318a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036572,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"I stand in this House as a proud representative for Vernon-Lumby to oppose the amendment presented by the B.C. Conservative member from the opposition. In addition to the concerns that have already been raised and discussed in the previous\n               days, I want to share comments directly from local Vernon Towne Theatre owner, Scott\n               John, who is also one of the strongest community pillars in our community. Scott shared how this amendment would actively hurt them versus the current state.\n               \"Large corporate cinemas are multiplexes with many screens and already have the ability\n               to designate one for liquor service. Small independent theatres are usually single\n               or double screens and do not have that ability. Large chains already have major advantages,\n               including first choice of movies, while smaller theatres are often left behind. I\n               hope this adds some context from our point of view.\" These comments highlighted why the original motion matters without the amendments.\n               That is why I oppose this amendment. I want to thank the member for Kootenay-Monashee for his continued advocacy for rural communities and for bringing the original motion\n               forward. As we know, independent theatres are more than places just to watch movies.\n               They are gathering spaces where people connect, support local culture and share experiences\n               together. In Vernon, we are fortunate to have Towne Theatre. Since opening in 1938, it has remained\n               as an important part of our community. Today it hosts films, concerts, live music\n               and community events while also supporting independent filmmakers and local artists.\n               What stands out most is how much theatres like this give back. They host fundraisers,\n               create spaces for community groups and bring people together. They are not just businesses.\n               They are part of the fabric of our communities. Through conversations with theatre operators, it has become clear that the current\n               rules create a real inconsistency. If a theatre hosts a live concert, it can serve\n               alcohol during mixed-age events, but if it shows film, it must either restrict the\n               audience or eliminate alcohol services entirely. That does not reflect how these venues\n               operate, and it creates unnecessary barriers. In most cases, it is simply about allowing\n               somebody to responsibly enjoy a glass of wine during a movie while supporting a local\n               theatre. Independent theatres are already facing significant challenges, rising costs, competition\n               from large chains and continued growth of streaming services. Across Canada, many\n               independent theatres are struggling. When these spaces disappear, we lose more than\n               a business. We lose gathering places that help build community Across Canada, many independent theatres are struggling. When these spaces disappear,\n               we lose more than a business. We lose gathering places that help build community connection.\n               One of the barriers they face in British Columbia is the restriction on liquor sales\n               during mixed-age screenings. Meanwhile, the other venues do not face the same restrictions. We saw this clearly\n               during the Taylor Swift Eras film tour. Concert venues could serve alcohol during\n               mixed-age events, while smaller theatres showing the same could not. That creates\n               an uneven playing field. My debate opposing this amendment is about fairness, opportunity\n               and supporting local businesses. The motion without the amendment does not require theatres to serve alcohol. It simply\n               gives them the option to do so responsibly within existing laws. For a small theatre,\n               every revenue stream matters. This change could help them remain sustainable, continue\n               supporting local artists and keep their doors open. It is also worth noting that British Columbia currently is the only province in Canada\n               that does not allow this. Passing this motion without the amendment would bring us\n               in line with the rest of the country. But ultimately, this is about community. In\n               many smaller towns, independent theatres are among the few places where people can\n               gather, connect and share experiences together. By us opposing the amendment, it offers\n               a practical and balanced solution. It recognizes the challenges these theatres face\n               and give them a tool to adapt to succeed. When we support places like this, we are supporting connection, fairness and community\n               itself. For those reasons, I am proud to support the original motion, and I encourage\n               all members to do the same. I strongly oppose this amendment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036572","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I stand in this House as a proud representative for Vernon-Lumby to oppose the amendment presented by the B.C. Conservative member from the opposition. In addition to the concerns that have already been raised and discussed in the previous\n               days, I want to share comments directly from local Vernon Towne Theatre owner, Scott\n               John, who is also one of the strongest commun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste water","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Scientists","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Laboratories","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water pollution","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Research institutes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Price regulation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036733","label":"Price regulation","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036956","label":"Research institutes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037050","label":"Scientists","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037552","label":"Waste water","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037568","label":"Water pollution","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:227368","label":"Laboratories","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","label":"Alcohol consumption","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a6ed7bf637f7d9c2ffb01eff00b818203b91bf4f32efb0ac04382e2f90cef315","aead5c6c98024f896abc151a95d1ecf737f520a800d21d1ae04eefaeaa23b5f8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b8ad148b24448eae48705a621f11007045fd9c4c8f881933482bbc5e726a6607"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Alcohol consumption","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719911","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-58ded5016819341d241fa967","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036574,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Harwinder Sandhu","venue":"Hansard","text":"As we are welcoming grad season, I would like to acknowledge 2026 grads to the graduating\n               class of 2026. Your graduation is more than just a ceremony; it is a celebration of\n               your journey, your resilience and the incredible future that lies ahead. I want to extend my heartfelt congratulations to the graduates of W.L. Seaton, Charles\n               Bloom, Clarence Fulton, Vernon Secondary, Vernon Christian School, Kalamalka Secondary, the Montessori program, Okanagan College, UBCO and grads across our province,\n               along with their families, teachers, staff and friends who supported you at every\n               step of the way. Each of you has faced challenges, uncertainty and moments where the road ahead may\n               not have seemed clear, but you kept going. You learned. You grew. You proved that\n               you Each of you has faced challenges, uncertainty and moments where the road ahead may\n               not have seemed clear, but you kept going. You learned. You grew. You proved that\n               you are stronger than you realize. As you walk across the stage, remember this: never let anyone else define what you're\n               capable of. Do not allow others to limit your dreams, your voice, your future. You\n               have the ability, the talent and the potential to become who you want and to do what\n               you want to do. Some of you will continue your education. Some will begin careers, travel, learn trades\n               or discover an entirely new path. No matter where life takes you, believe in yourself and trust the person you're becoming. You are the future of our communities, the future of the Okanagan and the future of\n               this province. The world needs your ideas, your compassion, your leadership and your\n               courage. So dream big and bold, work hard, and lift others up. Along the way, be kind and accepting, and never forget how far you have already\n               come. Most importantly, be proud of yourself, because we certainly are. To the graduating class of 2026, I wish you nothing but success, happiness and fulfilment\n               in the year ahead. Keep shining. Congratulations, all the best, and thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036574","member_id":"bc-mla-71","member_name":"Harwinder Sandhu","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"As we are welcoming grad season, I would like to acknowledge 2026 grads to the graduating\n               class of 2026. Your graduation is more than just a ceremony; it is a celebration of\n               your journey, your resilience and the incredible future that lies ahead. I want to extend my heartfelt congratulations to the graduates of W.L. Seaton, Charles\n               Bloom, Clarence Fulto","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Professional development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Job creation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Vocational training","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036761","label":"Professional development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037520","label":"Vocational training","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44217","label":"Job creation","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["66f339aa1a615e102fde623b445ceef6ebbca93012798ae6ac13dc88f7178faf"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e445758410cc74146669d202","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":86152,"date":"2026-02-12T08:12:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Mr. Speaker and Members of the Legislative Assembly, it is Her Honour the Lieutenant\n               Governor's will and pleasure that the Legislative Assembly be prorogued until 2 p.m.\n               today, and this Legislative Assembly is hereby prorogued accordingly.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd1st/20260212am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:86152","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Mr. Speaker and Members of the Legislative Assembly, it is Her Honour the Lieutenant\n               Governor's will and pleasure that the Legislative Assembly be prorogued until 2 p.m.\n               today, and this Legislative Assembly is hereby prorogued accordingly.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cee99f0a7dbe672f14d649bb","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187082,"date":"2026-02-12T12:00:00+00:00","title":"AN ACT TO ENSURE THE SUPREMACY\nOF PARLIAMENT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov01-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov01-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187082","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0702b87a3a4940017188f40","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187090,"date":"2026-02-19T12:00:00+00:00","title":"MOTOR VEHICLE AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov06-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov06-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187090","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-16191c28fb2a68c37e712892","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187091,"date":"2026-02-19T12:00:00+00:00","title":"MOTOR VEHICLE AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov06-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov06-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187091","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","label":"Contracting"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Contracting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718376","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-785d1213f9db5fa6f6a2787a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317201,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"As this matter is before the courts, we won't be commenting on it in question period.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317201","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"As this matter is before the courts, we won't be commenting on it in question period.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f372fc33250d75e20d1b32fe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317202,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just wanted to take a moment, before I got into the content of my speech, to let\n               the residents of Tumbler Ridge and those that have lost loved ones know that our hearts\n               are still with them as they go through what we can only imagine as a deep amount of\n               grief. I'm grateful for all the counselling supports and the people that are out there\n               to provide them support. As they move through it, we'll continue to have them in our\n               hearts. It's my pleasure to speak in favour of the budget speech. Before I do, I have to say\n               that it's been an honour for me to serve the riding of Vancouver-Hastings and to serve as Attorney General. It has been a real honour to be part of a great\n               team, and I wanted to spend a moment to thank the people that work with me, both in\n               my constituency office and here in the Attorney General's office. It takes a tremendous amount of work, compassion, empathy and dedication to show up\n               for a community every single day, and I'm so grateful to have the team that I do in\n               my constituency office, that every day show up for the citizens of Vancouver-Hastings\n               and that, I know, change lives. Whether it's housing, medical care or insecure immigration\n               status, they are changing lives every day, and I couldn't be more proud of them. So\n               a big thank-you to Kathryn Mandell, Patrick Colvin and Sylvia Wu for the work that\n               they do in my constituency office. It has also been a real honour to be Attorney General over the years, and it's never\n               boring. It's never a boring day, and I have such a great team in my minister's office\n               that supports me every day and help me help everybody manage through all the different\n               issues that come through every day. I will be forever grateful for the work and the\n               commitment that they do, and I think they deserve a moment of recognition before I\n               move on. That's Derrick Harder, my chief of staff; Kiefer Pellefer, Raunaq Singh and Claire Stechishin. I will be forever grateful for the work and the commitment that they do, and I think\n               they deserve a moment of recognition before I move on. That's Derrick Harder, my chief of staff, Kiefer Pellefer, Raunaq Singh, and Claire Stechishin. I am so grateful for the work that you do. I also have a team that keeps me organized and keeps me fed and keeps me supported.\n               Tamera Nanninga, Paula Demelo and Candice Hughes — so grateful for your work and corresponding to people and keeping my office such\n               a great place to work. I know the people of the province are grateful for the work\n               that you do as well. In response to Budget 2026, I just want to spend a moment talking about the work that\n               we've done as a government over the last few years. We've seen it in our communities.\n               We're building hospitals. We're building schools. We're investing in transit. We're\n               investing in housing and clean electricity. There is a transformation happening on\n               the ground with the largest number of capital projects that are there to increase\n               the level of services for people of this province. We have a lot to be proud of because of that work and because of the work that will\n               continue to happen with the investments in this budget. The fastest-growing attachment to family doctors in the country. So 350,000 people\n               are now attached to a family doctor when they weren't before because of the work of\n               our government and our commitment to improving the health care of all British Columbians.\n               That's better than any other province in the whole country and something we can all\n               be proud of. I want to spend a moment just to let the people of Vancouver know that the investments\n               that we're making in all of those capital projects and services are also showing up\n               in their communities. Whether it's through investment in housing, St. Paul's Hospital,\n               a new clean tech centre at Vancouver Community College, whether it's the investments\n               that we're making in transit that are coming online soon, student housing at UBC,\n               all the investments in health care that are expanding, including expanded surgery\n               capacity in our hospitals in Vancouver, it's tremendous. And it's going to benefit\n               so many people with the work that we're doing to improve services. A few things that I wanted to spend some time on in this budget that mean a lot, not\n               only to me but, I know, to the people of my community. I've had parents very often\n               speak to me about how important it is that our education is strong for their children.\n               And I agree. We need to keep making sure that our kids have the best opportunities possible in\n               their schools every day. We're investing $634 million in K to 12. What's included\n               in that, which I think is very important, is $167 million with a classroom enhancement\n               fund. That's to make sure that we can increase the supports in our classrooms. I made a commitment to some parents that have come to me and my constituency about\n               how we could show up to have better supports in classrooms for them and how we would\n               work together with the Vancouver school board to make sure that that support is showing\n               up in their classrooms across my riding and across the city. And I continue that commitment.\n               I think with this budget, it shows that as a government, we're also committed to improving\n               that and doing the work necessary to make sure every kid, no matter what their needs\n               are, gets a really good start and the best education that we can offer them. That includes the supports that.... I'm so proud of the Minister of Children and Family Development, who I know is so committed to this work and has done a tremendous job of transforming\n               a system that will provide $475 million of new money for kids in this province. It's\n               just breathtaking to think about those kids that didn't have access to services that\n               will now and what that will do for their families and what that will do for their\n               futures. I know that that was a lot of work to get where we are today and it was a lot of working\n               together. I'm just so proud of that work and I know it's going to make a difference. Child care. We made a commitment when we came into government to expand affordable,\n               accessible child care across this province. That's a commitment that required investment\n               and we put our money to it, close to $1 million of investment into child care along\n               with the federal money. We've been able to make a real difference for families across\n               this province, making it so they can save money on child care, they have better access\n               to child care, and we know we have more work to do. This budget commits $330 million\n               to child care and This budget commits $330 million to child care, and the Minister of Education and Child Care is working hard right now. I'm so grateful for all the advocates, all of the people\n               on the front line that are sitting down with us to figure out the future of child\n               care so we can continue to expand that access and that affordability across this province. It's such important work. It puts women back to work. It changes lives. It puts money\n               back into the pockets of families so they can put it in other ways to support their tightening cost of living that's\n               happening across the country. It's such important work, and this budget shows our commitment to continuing to\n               grow that work. It's really important. Another really important part that I am proud of in this budget is our investment\n               in skills trade. We just heard a rousing speech from the Minister of Energy and Climate\n               Solutions about the impacts that AI and other uncertainties are happening to our young\n               people and how our job market needs to change to respond. I know a lot of the labour movement have been asking for more investment in skilled\n               trades so we can get the skills into the hands of the workers in the province, to\n               be there for all the jobs of the future and all the jobs that we need them to help\n               us with when it comes to building out our province, building out our clean energy\n               grid, building housing, growing our economy. So $241 million in SkilledTradesBC is tremendous, and I know that will impact and\n               improve lives across this province. I'm really, really looking forward to that work\n               as it rolls out across this province. I've been so honoured to serve as Attorney General for a few years now, and I wanted\n               to focus a little bit on the budget that we have in our ministry and the work that\n               we're going to continue to do with the investments that are made. There are a lot\n               of really good investments into our justice system in this budget. We've had a commitment\n               to making our justice system timely, effective and centred on people, including improving\n               access to justice across this province. This budget includes a $22 million investment in staffing for Crown counsel judges and lawyers to improve access to\n               justice. The more we can get matters dealt with and done in a timely way, the better\n               it is for everybody. A big investment in our sheriff service — $5 million to support sheriffs. I want to\n               take a moment to say thank you to all the sheriffs out there. I get to go to your\n               graduations. I get to see you in the courthouses across this province. I see the good\n               work that you do and how you show up to keep our courtrooms safe, but also our system\n               of justice working in such an incredible way. And you tell articling students and\n               other people lost in courthouses where they have to go. So grateful for that work. And $1.2 million for independent investigations office to ensure transparency and\n               oversight of our policing. They play a really important role in our justice system\n               and our enforcement system, so if there's a serious bodily harm or injury by a police\n               officer, our IIO is there. Over the last few years, we've been on a journey to make\n               sure the investments we're making in them help them get to timely resolutions of their\n               investigations. They've done a great job of turning some of those timelines around\n               and investing in their resources to be training investigators and doing the important\n               work that they do with integrity. So improving access to justice is one of my priorities as Attorney General. The justice\n               system impacts so many people's lives, and we want to make sure that it's available\n               to people in ways when they most need it, or else there can be very significant impacts\n               upon their lives and their rights and their futures. We are working to modernize our justice system, so it's about making sure we have\n               the right investments at the right time for people to access services, like a virtual\n               counter service that provides people with remote access to registrar experts so they\n               can understand what they need to file and what the processes are. We've moved traffic\n               court online so it enables end-to-end digital dispute resolution to make those processes\n               easy. We've provided money to make sure there are online booking systems to help ensure\n               that we're helping to use technology to improve access to justice. We've also been committed as a government to improving public safety, and that requires\n               systems working together in new ways. Our ReVOII program, the repeat violent offender\n               initiative that was launched a few months after I became AG, has resulted in those\n               12 hubs operating around the province to circle around the most violent repeat offenders\n               and solve for them, whether it means increased incarceration or Our ReVOII program, the repeat violent offender initiative that was launched a few\n               months after I became AG, has resulted in those 12 hubs operating around the province\n               to circle around the most violent repeat offenders and solve for them, whether it\n               means increased incarceration or solving for the mental health or other needs that\n               they have, so they are no longer causing harm to themselves or communities. The results of that program have been quite remarkable. I'm really proud of the work\n               that everybody has done in that system. What it showed is a decrease in recidivism.\n               People that were responsible for 100 calls a month are stable and no longer resulting\n               in calls to the police. A reduction in violence, reduction in addictions. It's just\n               been such an incredible program to just show up to make our streets safer. That's why in this budget, we're expanding that program and changing it to chronic\n               property offending initiatives. This is $16 million over two years that will have\n               our system circle around those repeat offenders that may not be in the violent category\n               but are causing that street disorder. What I hear from mayors across the province\n               is that usually they know it's the 15 or 30 people that are maybe not in the ReVOII\n               program that are causing most of the challenges. I'm confident that with the model that we used for ReVOII applying to that chronic\n               property offender program, we'll be able to tackle that together with our partners. We've also invested in the prosecution service — $40 million more in the prosecutions,\n               to ensure they have stable resourcing levels, along with positions related to bail\n               and facilities expansion. That represents a 28 percent increase since 2024 in our\n               prosecution service funding. I've been aggressively advocating for changes to our Criminal Code that will help\n               our system work better. We're calling for those changes with Bill C-14, that has now\n               passed through the House and is with the Senate. I'm hopeful that those will help\n               when comes to strengthening our bail system, particularly when it comes to intimate\n               partner violence and making sure that.... When somebody seeks safety from the system and they come forward to say that they're\n               experiencing intimate partner violence, it is the most dangerous time for them often.\n               So the system needs to respond with that safety. It's something that's been a really high priority for myself in the reforms that we're\n               doing through Dr. Stanton's report that she has given me about how to reform the whole\n               justice system when it comes to sexual assault and intimate partner violence. I have\n               a whole team in my ministry that has been hard at work doing that, with regular updates\n               on how we're able to transform that system. Another key focus of ours is holding multinational companies that operate to either\n               engage in deceptive practices or cause widespread harm at significant cost to people\n               in this province without facing any repercussions.... We have a great legal team in\n               my ministry that has been leveraging every tool available, whether it's legislation,\n               regulation or litigation, to make sure that the bad actors are accountable for the\n               harms that they create. B.C. is leading across North America when it comes to successfully taking the world's\n               largest tobacco, opioid and vaping manufacturers to the highest courts to recover\n               health care costs. In 2025, a national settlement was reached in the tobacco litigation,\n               also led by B.C. and on behalf of all the provinces and federal governments. Under\n               the settlement, B.C. received and will receive $3.6 billion — $3.6 billion because\n               of litigation that started right here in B.C. and us having the leadership and the\n               forcefulness to take on these companies that were causing harm, and we were paying\n               the bills. That benefited our budget, and it benefits all of the services that we know British\n               Columbians rely on. Not only that, provinces across this country, including Canada,\n               also received billions of dollars into their health care systems, which is, I think,\n               a remarkable achievement that we can all be proud of that started here in B.C. Another part of the work in my ministry is anti-racism. We're working every day to\n               make sure that we remove the racism that exists in systemic ways in our systems. The\n               budget that is from last year and today continues investments in our racist incident\n               helpline, which I know is helping people every day that are reporting incidents and\n               getting referred to the right resources across this province. We also have a Resilience B.C. Anti-Racism Network, and I know the parliamentary secretary,\n               who's sitting right here, has been really doing a lot of great work going around the\n               province to meet with the Resilience Anti-Racism Network and hear the needs that they\n               have and help us work on our anti-racism action plan, which will be coming. We've seen a tremendous We've seen a tremendous expansion in First Nations justice across this province, with\n               key investments that include funding for the First Nations Justice Council to set\n               up Indigenous justice centres across this province, with 15 now serving Indigenous\n               people. It's a remarkable thing to offer access to justice. I'm really grateful for\n               that work. This budget continues that investment. Every day, people are showing up at those centres\n               and getting the services that they need, whether it's with child and family services\n               or with criminal matters, and getting the culturally appropriate supports that they\n               need for that. We've been able to invest in expansive ways in legal aid. Legal aid in this budget\n               has $162 million. That also includes an expansion to family law legal aid, one of\n               the largest, I think, in history, in terms of money, to the expansion of family law\n               legal aid over these last few years and the opening of a family violence clinic that\n               is there to serve people that need particular supports related to family violence\n               and complex matters they're dealing with, getting free legal advice and free legal\n               support for those matters. It's been just great work that I think we should all be proud of. I'm proud of the\n               work that we have been doing to show up for people. If we can get people to get the\n               support they need at the right time in family law, we know it changes lives. A lot\n               of people across this province have experienced the family law justice system in different\n               ways throughout their life, and we know it can be traumatizing. It can be, sometimes,\n               longer than what people want it to be, and it can affect the children and the relationships\n               that we know we need to make sure are strong in the future. The early resolution process was something that was introduced to help resolve these\n               matters outside of court. We're expanding that across the province because we saw\n               a huge level of success for this program. When we piloted in Surrey, we saw that 57\n               percent of the families that were using the early resolution process resolved their\n               matter without going to court — a 61 percent decline in new family cases at the courthouse.\n               We know that this process works, and I'm really glad that this budget has the investment\n               that will bring it across the province in more registries, because it'll help families\n               when they need it. Online safety has been a real focus of mine since I've been Attorney General. It's\n               my view that laws across the world have not kept up with the harms that people experience\n               online, particularly our young people, and that is something that, as legislators\n               and as policy-makers across the world, we need to reckon with. We launched the IIPA, the Intimate Images Protection Act, with victim support services\n               attached to it. This is a program that helps people take hold of intimate images themselves,\n               that are being distributed without their consent. We continue to invest in the supports\n               that the CRT, the Civil Resolution Tribunal, needs to run this program and the victim\n               supports that are necessary for people that are coming forward with this type of harm. The victim support services have now helped hundreds of people and no doubt have saved\n               some people's lives, because we know that sometimes the most tragic outcomes come\n               from not having the right intervention at the right time. On top of that, the speed\n               of their resolution — and the CRT deserves full credit for this — is so fast, record-breaking,\n               in the justice system, where you can get an order, or an image taken down, sometimes\n               the same day, which is a quite remarkable feat. When it comes to the speed of things that happen online, the justice system also needs\n               to be just as quick. I've been advocating directly with the federal government. I\n               know they are working on online harms legislation. It's my expectation and request with the federal government, as the body that has\n               the most tools to deal with online harm as their jurisdiction over telecommunications\n               and other constitutional matters that they have more powers over, that they should\n               put in place legislation that makes sure that children are protected from the dangers\n               online. Some jurisdictions have age restrictions, which I think are important, on\n               social media use and what is also just not available for them unless the platforms\n               can show that they are safe. This is an important issue, not only for young people but every parent across this\n               province. I speak for myself, but I think I speak for many parents when we talk about\n               the struggle of screen time and the struggle of working with your Every parent across this province in this world is dealing with that and, in my view,\n               we should not be letting these social media companies experiment on the minds of our\n               children without regulation. So my ask is for the federal government to move on that,\n               and if they don't, then we certainly will in this province. Budget 2026 protects the justice and public safety services that British Columbians\n               rely on. It makes key investments in those services and helps to make sure that there\n               are the tools that all the actors need in place to make sure timely resolution of\n               our system, of our justice matters, but also supports growth in different areas like\n               access to justice. We are investing in so many things in this budget and continue to invest over the\n               years. I talked about some of the things that people of Vancouver can see that come\n               online like St. Paul's Hospital, transit, new schools, housing in a lot of communities....\n               We are building so much non-market housing in Vancouver and across this province. We've been through a lot as a province and continue to be through going through a\n               trade war and a lot of serious impacts on people across this province that are feeling\n               the effects of that. I want to assure everybody that we stand together in fighting\n               and protecting services and fighting for British Columbia in every way that we can,\n               fighting for the economy that we know we need in order to support the services that\n               everybody relies on. We're not backing down from the services like health care, hospitals,\n               schools that make British Columbia what it is. We will continue to stand up for that,\n               including investing in the future, like our children and the different areas that\n               I talked about related to schools and more supports for kids that need it. I'm really proud of the strides that we've made in government, and it's really a deep\n               honour for me to serve as Attorney General of B.C. We'll continue to do the work that\n               British Columbians need to advance all of the things that make this province strong\n               and make all of us united in a common cause for British Columbians.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317202","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I just wanted to take a moment, before I got into the content of my speech, to let\n               the residents of Tumbler Ridge and those that have lost loved ones know that our hearts\n               are still with them as they go through what we can only imagine as a deep amount of\n               grief. I'm grateful for all the counselling supports and the people that are out there\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["04f8a9701f75b9a7096e019407a6665846009185bd4462252a113bf16c67be1d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["5a0520a584eaf7ec48b946017b4e269ece89380869f81135ec3486f7ec774be6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb4688fa308b0c2f6b2809dc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317203,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"This government has been focused solely on increasing our public safety and making\n               sure that our court system is functioning as it should. We've been leaders across\n               this country in strengthening our criminal code to make sure that our laws and our\n               bail laws and our laws around repeat offenders that are wreaking havoc on our communities\n               are strong. We have the strongest bail policy in the whole country, and Bill C-14, which has a\n               lot of ideas straight from B.C. in it, has passed the House. I'm looking forward to\n               that bill passing the Senate, and I call upon all those members of the Senate to make\n               sure that they pass it quickly so we can have stronger Criminal Code laws across this\n               province. We're going to keep at it. We're going to keep being leaders across this country and\n               strengthening our safety across the whole country.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317203","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"This government has been focused solely on increasing our public safety and making\n               sure that our court system is functioning as it should. We've been leaders across\n               this country in strengthening our criminal code to make sure that our laws and our\n               bail laws and our laws around repeat offenders that are wreaking havoc on our communities\n               ar","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b1d4a6f056e965d2b59536bf9e1c1a82c8bde0f9185aa02d912b49f7d95276fb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["46a4166cd784654f1292b5a85a4628a46b9d8584984cb6da2b84cd6803762fb6"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b017efc47275048923b5b63e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328048,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"First of all, we don't track that information. And the second part is that the determination\n               of what is or isn't a hate crime under the Criminal Code would be by police and, in\n               turn, if there was an RCC, Crown counsel about pursuing it and, eventually, a court\n               of law.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328048","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"First of all, we don't track that information. And the second part is that the determination\n               of what is or isn't a hate crime under the Criminal Code would be by police and, in\n               turn, if there was an RCC, Crown counsel about pursuing it and, eventually, a court\n               of law.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Insurance companies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Service industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Market development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Forecasting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Survivor benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Multiculturalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic minorities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Young offenders","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035726","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Human capital","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Markets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Customer services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Vandalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Driving","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1011259","label":"Driving","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1015910","label":"Forecasting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034253","label":"Rates","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034393","label":"Capital","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034758","label":"Customer services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034945","label":"Economic forecasting","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035272","label":"Fiscal assistance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035726","label":"Human capital","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036213","label":"Market development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037267","label":"Survivor benefits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083677","label":"Insurance companies","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:344215","label":"Young offenders","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","label":"Multiculturalism","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43376","label":"Insurance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47377","label":"Vandalism","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501145","label":"Youth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59509","label":"Ethnic minorities","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59510","label":"Markets","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715117","label":"Permits","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718902","label":"Service industry","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718969","label":"Vehicles","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["19e7df44541b93e3679f496b115fc8c4119826383ef29fae9ca5e1e155db65de","fe7c3a5786272a0f58141492dcb862f1370c3532d160d1dca544e86dbef2292c","6a9c7a53da6d4fddd4c1f1d7852a204cc430a2b5e078445234d8e176806271df","3f7a4e9d871013faa48beeae3b4136583e5cbc7e5e8e598b6f3f04bea7db5a89","422323a99038ec892e1031ecb5505c00c0ca9a68ddff528a705a2b900e9bf94e","659bc1b48295d32f42809b6a4c25985dff8411d62ec6f019bef1d71bddff170c","5dd0d4be80b87e560d49d4e4790cc7d7964af4b5566ec77ed950405c401e99f3","7bdaed55f7e7dc259eb8c7f75373cd5010d27c93e53fe8dd02d73fa58d52784d","ced4d152161e55ed951a7bbf4ca00e185572037d528f2605af029f201bc66f61"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e993066712e38b95afcac2e5cb08bfec5af9561810cdaebdfa6a6acad6bbc6e0"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d95de4c537e8dccba74ea7f4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328049,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm often at a loss for words when this member asks questions, and I find myself in\n               that place again. I would ask the member to seek to understand how racism and discrimination show up\n               in our communities and what the barriers are for people that they've faced in this\n               country and continue to face based on their race and identity. Our human rights code, we're so proud of it on this side of the House. It's what prevents\n               women from being paid differently than men. It's what prevents somebody from being\n               fired based on the colour of their skin or their religion. It's what prevents people\n               from being treated differently across this province based on their identity. That\n               is something we stand for unapologetically in this House, and we will not be making\n               changes to that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328049","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm often at a loss for words when this member asks questions, and I find myself in\n               that place again. I would ask the member to seek to understand how racism and discrimination show up\n               in our communities and what the barriers are for people that they've faced in this\n               country and continue to face based on their race and identity. Our human rights code, w","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035893","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inheritance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035893","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Inheritance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035893","label":"Inheritance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.13,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["bf57313a54af734a5ebab8ee4d50ecf41f1fbea951ff111b6ad9ccf6e6b24f53"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["0e0410877f4fae6ed88f2e36c0108c7f33fef587709dfd0ba6614e933fe8fac1"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e96effa7aff61b85a607f6a","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187103,"date":"2026-03-09T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SAFE ACCESS TO SCHOOLS \nAMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov12-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov12-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187103","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1a4c8e325353dac39bf37432","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187104,"date":"2026-03-09T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SAFE ACCESS TO SCHOOLS \nAMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov12-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov12-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187104","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3c90dab3cfe78f14f599dd88","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187105,"date":"2026-03-09T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SAFE ACCESS TO PLACES OF\nPUBLIC WORSHIP ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov13-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov13-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187105","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","label":"Public buildings"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6eb29a72e8537489ced946b9","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187106,"date":"2026-03-09T12:00:00+00:00","title":"SAFE ACCESS TO PLACES OF\nPUBLIC WORSHIP ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov13-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov13-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187106","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","label":"Signs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","label":"Public buildings"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Signs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036359","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97210","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d1e37248fb06776293572df0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361016,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"The member asked a very important question. We have all heard the rise in anti-Indigenous\n               racism because of the rhetoric that's coming out. I'm sure the members across the\n               way have heard about it. The Premier talked about death threats that are coming upon\n               the xwməθkwəy̓əm after the rhetoric that's coming out of there. It is unacceptable. We as a government are working on anti-racism plans. I'm working on an anti-Indigenous\n               racism plan with my ministry, with the act that I led last time. The member talked\n               about misinformation and how harmful it is when you spread it. What happens when it's\n               leaders of a political party that are doing it? What happens when it's leadership\n               candidates that are doing it? Where is the shame for the harm that's happening to\n               real people in this province? We are going to focus on bringing people together. We're going to focus on standing,\n               Indigenous, non-Indigenous, respecting people's rights, whether it's private property\n               or Indigenous rights.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361016","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The member asked a very important question. We have all heard the rise in anti-Indigenous\n               racism because of the rhetoric that's coming out. I'm sure the members across the\n               way have heard about it. The Premier talked about death threats that are coming upon\n               the xwməθkwəy̓əm after the rhetoric that's coming out of there. It is unacceptable. We as a govern","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health hazards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035632","label":"Health hazards","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","label":"Race relations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","label":"Racial discrimination","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fca5df1466d59ec269b854631b4a95051fa15fa1c885e46a62791cd42b49ce73"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["a2522c5c73b63848e46cb552261b35a637f7139929839521f35bf716f0d98def"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Race relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Racial discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036846","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036849","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e300e360b3cf033730cb796","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361017,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Over the last few weeks and years, we have been meeting with the Jewish community\n               to understand what's needed and what they need on the front line to keep their places\n               of worship and schools safe. I can't talk about a bill that is before the House, but\n               I will say that we are responding with legal steps and resources to make sure they\n               have the money for security that they need, but also legal protections to make sure\n               that anybody that goes to a place of worship is protected, anybody that goes to schools,\n               students, teachers are protected. We'll continue to do that work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361017","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Over the last few weeks and years, we have been meeting with the Jewish community\n               to understand what's needed and what they need on the front line to keep their places\n               of worship and schools safe. I can't talk about a bill that is before the House, but\n               I will say that we are responding with legal steps and resources to make sure they\n               have","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.76,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f4d4315bbd4bf7447a514e802450f9758850a539442251f90792acc5eb27fe97"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b24f9b087e5970e779559358bac0afc0887cd3befb0cf41aeccad5d8dccc0771"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-24059a14502c6a714d793630","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361018,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm happy to meet with the member and get the details of this. I'll take that on notice.\n               I'm happy to follow up afterwards.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361018","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I'm happy to meet with the member and get the details of this. I'll take that on notice.\n               I'm happy to follow up afterwards.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1010925","label":"Property","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["49c4eda5fd3385c07399c7123057d224fbbd40bcd402d7f7bf3b640a8f2d36a7"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d3891e143fe689d79535b89a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361019,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my pleasure to speak in support of this motion. I believe that this motion is an opportunity for every party, every member of this\n               House to be clear on where they stand on human rights. A couple of weeks ago, I have\n               to say, I would not have imagined that this would be necessary. The human rights code is pretty simple. It protects people from discrimination based\n               on the colour of their skin, their religion, sexual orientation, gender identity,\n               disability, age and more. The human rights code has existed in various forms since 1969. It has almost always\n               been a matter of cross-partisan consensus. The B.C. Liberals, including some members\n               still in this House, added \"gender identity or expression\" to the code in 2016. It\n               was passed unanimously. The Human Rights Tribunal enforces the code. It investigates complaints to find out\n               if discrimination has occurred. Without it, the code essentially has no effect. Again,\n               support for the tribunal has almost always transcended parties. The B.C. Liberals\n               strengthened the tribunal, and they appointed the current chair. The code is different than the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Charter protects\n               people from the government. The code prevents organizations and people from discriminating\n               against other people. For example, in 2024, the tribunal ruled on a case involving\n               a man who was denied service at a massage business because he was Muslim. The business demanded that he \"certify you are not of the Islamic faith, which, as\n               you know, has earned a bad reputation for raping and killing of infidels in Canada\n               and elsewhere.\" Then that business turned him away. The tribunal ruled that this behaviour violated the code, and directed the business\n               to compensate him. Without the code and tribunal, he would have Unfortunately, fighting hate is as important now as it ever was. We've seen spikes\n               in hate and white supremacy across this province. We've seen far-right commentators\n               and activists, including members of this House, attempt to co-opt the tragedy in Tumbler\n               Ridge to advance a shameful and completely false agenda against the trans community. Both the code and the tribunal have come under attack since a recent decision regarding\n               the former trustee Barry Neufeld. The tribunal found that: \"Contrary to his arguments\n               that he was merely expressing his opinion about legitimate topics of political and\n               social debate, his expression went beyond a critique of a government program. Mr.\n               Neufeld's publications are replete with negative stereotypes and pejorative assumptions\n               about LGBTQ people, which undermine their inherent dignity and discriminate against\n               them.\" The member for Kelowna–Lake Country–Coldstream's objections go well beyond the queer community. She has said: \"Multiculturalism\n               is anti-Canadian.\" I am in this House from parents that immigrated from India, left\n               their family to come here to build a life for us. I am so grateful that they made\n               that decision. We are a country and a province that takes pride in people coming from all over the\n               world to set up their home here. Unlike many jurisdictions across the world, we welcome\n               them. We build a good life for them. We respect their identity, their religion and\n               who they are, and we call them neighbours. I am just so profoundly offended by that comment that she made about multiculturalism\n               being anti-Canadian, and I think we all should be. She has said Canada needs \"mass\n               deportations,\" and that we have to end and reverse mass migration. The member should\n               clarify what she means by reversing immigration. Say it to the members of this House\n               who come from families, all of us, that immigrated here to build a life. White supremacists advocate for what they call re-immigration, which means deporting\n               legal immigrants, including Canadian citizens, based on their ethnic background and\n               skin colour. It's racism, pure and simple. We at this side of the House will not stand\n               for it. It's no wonder that she wants to abolish the Human Rights Code entirely. But she's not the only one in this House who has attacked the code. The member for\n               Chilliwack North introduced a motion this week that targets section 7 of the code, which is a section\n               about discriminatory publications — hate speech. She has strongly defended Barry Neufeld\n               on social media. The member for Langley-Abbotsford has said about the tribunal: \"When I become Premier, it's gone on day 1.\" That's\n               what his leadership would bring to this province. Gone on day 1. What would he say to that Muslim man who was denied access because of his religion?\n               What would he say to women who have been fighting for pay equity for years when they\n               are paid, because of their gender, less than their male counterparts? What would he\n               say to all the immigrants who fought for equal rights in this country since the founding\n               of this province? I would love to know. A candidate for the opposition party's leadership, Caroline Elliott, called the tribunal\n               a playground for NDP activists to live out their social justice dreams. What would\n               she say to those people that I was talking about? What would she say to women across\n               this province who have fought for their pay equity? It's really ironic, given that it was her own party, the B.C. Liberals, who first\n               appointed the current chair of the tribunal in 2016 and that all appointments to the\n               tribunal are made in consultation with that chair. I know many of the opposition members dispute the meaning of their first reading votes\n               and have been working to clarify their position. Well, here's their opportunity. But when prominent members of their own party are openly attacking the code and the\n               tribunal, it's natural. I know many of the opposition members dispute the meaning of their first reading votes\n               and have been working to clarify their position. Well, here's their opportunity. But\n               when prominent members of their own party are openly attacking the code and the tribunal,\n               it's natural for everybody in this province to wonder where they stand. It's also right for the public to expect them to not only vote for this motion, but\n               ask all of their colleagues to do the same. I genuinely, genuinely hope that that's\n               where we get to today. Too much is at stake. Too much is at stake. For too long we have let this far-right, racist ideology take root in this province.\n               For too long, we've seen members of this House bring in bill after bill that attacks\n               who are vulnerable, that deserve equal rights. Where is their line, Speaker? Where\n               is their line? There's no reason that this motion should not be supported by every other member in\n               this House. This is about standing up against hate. But at the heart of it, it's about\n               freedom. The idea that you can work to build a good life for yourself without overt\n               discrimination. Isn't that what we all want? That you can't be denied a job because\n               of your skin colour or be denied renting an apartment because of who you love. That\n               you can go to work without being attacked for your identity. My hope for today is that all of us send a strong message to those British Columbians\n               who are watching that we will stand up for their human rights and will never give\n               up ground to those who are seeking to compromise them.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361019","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's my pleasure to speak in support of this motion. I believe that this motion is an opportunity for every party, every member of this\n               House to be clear on where they stand on human rights. A couple of weeks ago, I have\n               to say, I would not have imagined that this would be necessary. The human rights code is pretty simple. It protects people from discrimination based\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["64c6c03a94386fdc5e0aa623a77dc2d724392030cabaf5e6ec31393ce44f47a2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["45c2a4433fd25e0a952c568fd573cd898b0b52dbb08e0d79debb87c520a053fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-305e703e79fd232314289b19","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415820,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's really important that every member of this House understand the important role\n               of the conflicts commissioner. I just would like to urge everybody to do as the minister\n               of AI did. If you need advice on whether something is a conflict or not, they are\n               the resource for you to go to, and they will issue you letters that clarify what side\n               of the rules you're on, as the member did in this circumstance. It's invaluable for this, and it helps to keep the integrity of our democracy.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415820","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's really important that every member of this House understand the important role\n               of the conflicts commissioner. I just would like to urge everybody to do as the minister\n               of AI did. If you need advice on whether something is a conflict or not, they are\n               the resource for you to go to, and they will issue you letters that clarify what side\n              ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children's rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034463","label":"Children's rights","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c797df81ecf02407d384aea82c4c361d5d9c42984154105ab55c15ae42c3ded6"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-82a813ac5b80443a42cfbebe","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415821,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"With that, I move second reading.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415821","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"With that, I move second reading.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Accessibility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718494","label":"Accessibility","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["045870656ea68c444d945c09d4b02544e487f4e0474c34f7b22e962fa695e8d3"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4beb681aea267379bf7b4f6a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415822,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill be committed to a Committee of the Whole to be considered at\n               the next sitting of the House after today. Oh, we have to move second reading first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415822","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that the bill be committed to a Committee of the Whole to be considered at\n               the next sitting of the House after today. Oh, we have to move second reading first.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8051a6c40c7e64732cc1373e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415823,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to introduce Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. This bill amends the following statutes: Judicial Review Procedure Act, Fuel Price\n               Transparency Act, Zero-Emission Vehicles Act, Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage\n               District Act, Local Government Act, Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act, Residential\n               Tenancy Act, University Endowment Land Act, Vancouver Charter Correction Act. This bill also makes consequential amendments to other statutes.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415823","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am pleased to introduce Bill 16, the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, 2026. This bill amends the following statutes: Judicial Review Procedure Act, Fuel Price\n               Transparency Act, Zero-Emission Vehicles Act, Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage\n               District Act, Local Government Act, Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act, Residential\n               Tenancy Act, Univer","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Public opinion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036806","label":"Public opinion","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:76847","label":"Public relations","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cff4141574255a61e6a828730c95d8ed8ffdf867ea97ac4876c0a8cc3c26ae41","9a0160d54cde73acec413f76c485b7387b032ab11927d5f9ad1276c7194f7dff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["73e0fc10af08caacf073a2d9da74e320d08c4820a2eeb9bbad0e014c389cdf22"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b7b9599e0787d1c560a2647e","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187111,"date":"2026-04-01T12:00:00+00:00","title":"MISCELLANEOUS STATUTES \nAMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov16-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov16-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187111","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-13acc0912179895b08ddf304","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187112,"date":"2026-04-01T12:00:00+00:00","title":"MISCELLANEOUS STATUTES \nAMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov16-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov16-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187112","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","label":"Management"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","label":"Excise taxes"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Excise taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42615","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:714434","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-eb34a70e375b0345f123b83a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720563,"date":"2026-04-14T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to start by appreciating the members that sat on the Special Committee on Democratic\n               and Electoral Reform. It's so important, and I know every single member of that committee\n               understood this member's very deep passion for making sure that our democracy is strong.\n               I appreciate that work. We are currently in receipt of that work, also waiting for the Chief Electoral Officer's\n               final report and a following report from that committee as the work continues. We\n               take it super seriously because it is important that our democracy is strong, that\n               we have the tools that we need to keep adapting with the changing pressures on our\n               democracy. We've done good work together across parties when it came to the referendum that was\n               in 2018, where British Columbians decided that the current voting system was where\n               they wanted to stay. That doesn't mean there isn't other work to be done when it comes\n               to making sure that our electoral system is strong in this province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260414am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720563","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I want to start by appreciating the members that sat on the Special Committee on Democratic\n               and Electoral Reform. It's so important, and I know every single member of that committee\n               understood this member's very deep passion for making sure that our democracy is strong.\n               I appreciate that work. We are currently in receipt of that work, also waiting for t","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Civil rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral districts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Research","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034482","label":"Civil rights","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034981","label":"Electoral districts","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","label":"Electoral system","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715100","label":"Research","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fb433f9d519471bfdc97b0f9ef39dd2ea589512c842f7a2720771124567d1901"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.7,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0834b9bf068a874723174891b388d1d57913ea4dff1fca10b7a023adad43bad4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Electoral system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44251","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c8543302144fe31798e18040","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720567,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"This is a continuation of really quite terrible questions from this member about denying\n               residential school and the harms that that type of rhetoric has on people all across\n               this province and this country. The way she's phrased the question, the way she's\n               posed it — offensive in so many ways. We cannot forget that the reason that those two members are in the House right now\n               is because of the party opposite, because of those members that included that in their\n               tent. We have to answer to this stuff over and over again, and it does harm to people.\n               That's all I have to say.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720567","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"This is a continuation of really quite terrible questions from this member about denying\n               residential school and the harms that that type of rhetoric has on people all across\n               this province and this country. The way she's phrased the question, the way she's\n               posed it — offensive in so many ways. We cannot forget that the reason that those two members are i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Systems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034609","label":"Systems","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","label":"Residential schools","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["93e0be4e23c4b59766033729415d2943932d7e5f2960f19922a24982fe67a1ff"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c08efa5ae045282ace7940fd26a5c57ca8266ea99ad2a704a1292eb3a37ef0a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Residential schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036958","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de9bc75600b973f83e67e6fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720576,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill now be read a second time. This bill amends several statutes. I will begin with two amendments to the Judicial\n               Review Procedure Act. The first: a new section is being added to respond to recent\n               court decisions that risk intruding on cabinet confidentiality by requiring government\n               to produce a list of cabinet materials in certain judicial review proceedings. This\n               section I will begin with two amendments to the Judicial Review Procedure Act. First, a new section is being added to respond to recent court decisions that risk\n               intruding on cabinet confidentiality by requiring government to produce a list of\n               cabinet materials in certain judicial review proceedings. This section is similar\n               to legislation in other jurisdictions, including the Canada Evidence Act, but narrower\n               in scope as it only applies to judicial review proceedings, not to all litigation. This section allows a designated person to certify that information is a confidence\n               of the executive council or Treasury Board, and once this certification is made, no\n               one can be compelled to disclose the information. This section ensures that cabinet\n               can continue to maintain a sphere of confidentiality that the Supreme Court of Canada\n               has recognized is essential to good government. Second, section 11 of the JRPA is being repealed. This provision is being repealed\n               to make it clear that the timeline for bringing a judicial review should be governed\n               either by the common law or the governing statutory scheme. This change will bring\n               predictability and certainty about the applicable timelines for bringing a judicial\n               review. Proposed amendments to the Fuel Price Transparency Act support the continued delivery\n               of the act by enabling a shift to a sustainable, industry-funded model for administration.\n               Since its enactment in 2019, the act has improved transparency, competitiveness and\n               public confidence in British Columbia's transportation fuel market by requiring fuel\n               suppliers to report pricing data to the B.C. Utilities Commission, which publishes\n               information to help the public understand fuel price movements. The amendments do not change the act's core purpose. They enable the recovery of administration\n               costs from industry by authorizing the Lieutenant Governor in Council to make regulations\n               and the B.C. Utilities Commission to set and collect fees from fuel market participants,\n               creating a sustainable funding model for the program. Next, amendments to the Zero-Emission Vehicles Act increase the supply of ZEVs in\n               British Columbia, to reduce emissions and air pollution. It will also encourage automakers\n               to offer more affordable and accessible ZEV options, supporting a clear transportation\n               transition for all British Columbians. The province recognizes the need to recalibrate targets considering recent market\n               changes. The proposed amendments lower the 2023 ZEV sales targets from 100 percent\n               to 75 percent and remove the 2035 prohibition on the sale of non-ZEVs to give British\n               Columbians more choice in finding a vehicle that best suits their needs. The amendments also remove the 2026 and 2030 ZEV sales targets from the legislation,\n               keeping these targets in regulation to allow for greater flexibility to respond to\n               emerging federal policy and future market fluctuations. Overall, the amendments ease short-term ZEV sale requirements while retaining a pragmatic\n               long-term target that aligns with the Canada automotive strategy, balancing pressures\n               on automakers with the need to sustain progress towards a cleaner transportation future\n               in British Columbia. The proposed amendments to the University Endowment Land Act will provide the University\n               Endowment Lands with a modern bylaw enforcement tool, namely municipal ticketing,\n               that is commonly used by local governments in British Columbia. Currently the UEL\n               lacks effective tools for enforcing minor bylaw contraventions such as parking violations\n               or nuisances, which means that many of these offences that are routinely ticketed\n               across local governments are not enforced under the UEL. The proposed amendments will allow the UEL to set out ticketing offences and penalties\n               up to $3,000 in a bylaw, in accordance with the municipal ticketing framework established\n               in the Community Charter and regulation. Fines collected via ticketing may offset\n               some of the operational costs of enforcement through ticketing in the UEL. This legislation addresses a community request for improved bylaw enforcement in the\n               UEL and will recognize better compliance with the UEL bylaws. Amendments are being proposed to the Local Government Act, an act to incorporate the\n               greater Vancouver sewerage and drainage district, Vancouver Charter and the South\n               Coast British Columbia Transportation Authority Act. These amendments will give the province regulatory authority to designate any additional\n               types of development for which local governments and TransLink could choose to waive\n               or reduce development cost charges. These charges are one-time fees on new development\n               that help pay for essential infrastructure, transportation, water, sewer and parks\n               so that the costs of growth are shared fairly between new development and existing\n               taxpayers. Advancing the amendments now ensures the province is ready to act quickly on the federal\n               government's provincial and territorial stream of the build communities strong fund,\n               announced as part of Budget 2025, which commits funding across Canada for housing-enabling\n               and post-secondary infrastructure. The proposed federal requirements are that provinces and territories must match federal\n               contributions, significantly reduce development charges and avoid new taxes or fees\n               that could hinder housing supply. The goal is to Currently British Columbia only allows development cost charge waivers for affordable\n               rental housing and green building projects. The specific criteria for future provincial\n               regulations under the new authority will be shaped through ongoing federal-provincial\n               discussions. The bill also includes two housekeeping amendments to the Residential Tenancy Act\n               and the Manufactured Home Park Tenancy Act that clarify the admissibility of evidence\n               in residential tenancy branch administrative penalty proceedings and replace inoperative\n               amendments that affect the RTB's authority to review decisions in orders rendered\n               in a facilitated settlement process. Finally, proposed amendments to the Correction Act will support the facilitation of\n               involuntary care for those held in custody of B.C. Corrections. In some circumstances,\n               clinical staff require assistance from security staff during the administration of\n               involuntary treatment. The proposed amendments to the Correction Act will formally\n               authorize correction officers with the ability to assist health care providers when\n               delivering involuntary psychiatric treatment under the Mental Health Act. Proposed amendments to the Correction Act will also seek to better reflect the authority\n               of the Attorney General's investigations and standards office to conduct inspections,\n               investigations and review disciplinary hearing appeals made by B.C. Corrections, reflect\n               the ISO requirement to report to the Attorney General and to make reports public,\n               refine the inmate's complaint process to make it more accessible and give the director\n               broader discretion about whether to investigate a complaint. With that, those are my comments.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720576","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I move that the bill now be read a second time. This bill amends several statutes. I will begin with two amendments to the Judicial\n               Review Procedure Act. The first: a new section is being added to respond to recent\n               court decisions that risk intruding on cabinet confidentiality by requiring government\n               to produce a list of cabinet materials in certain jud","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Motor vehicles","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47471","label":"Motor vehicles","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["aa57e969882c1ec4840a455d7fb069d84b007589769000c79f1b8100f9ba8d7e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.57,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9cc6895e6e3cfa321f3f63d23a1cde89e47d7e78eb96d88665044f502daf2d66"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9195564275f6f1e14e8b63c3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721663,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think the Premier and this side of the House have been clear about what we're advocating\n               for and what we...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721663","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I think the Premier and this side of the House have been clear about what we're advocating\n               for and what we...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Domestic architecture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034883","label":"Domestic architecture","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035274","label":"Fiscal law","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["00a3231d86159066394df6b08f424b5f199a2687a2386338149f84ed3a2512cd","9d7fac9f6c95e8a7b2ae3b231634e49a26070f5a5d5b34399117c719f2592735"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dbec79b8da237c1e96f504bb","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721665,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've been nothing but clear about our interpretation and take on the Gitxaała decision. What we see is a difference of opinion in what the court found and what\n               our intent of the original legislation was. It's in our court, arguments before the\n               court. It's in everything that the Premier said.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721665","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We've been nothing but clear about our interpretation and take on the Gitxaała decision. What we see is a difference of opinion in what the court found and what\n               our intent of the original legislation was. It's in our court, arguments before the\n               court. It's in everything that the Premier said.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Judges","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43845","label":"Judges","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["448de147739a7d919179f0324fae9814d245fb4496b4ffd3f32211e4234723d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.18,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23229a09406e4c5e01578c56d28b5750b21e0cf010452fc9a166f9e7f5fd27d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e4aaf6349f705554b901a122","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721668,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's precisely why we are moving with First Nations and other stakeholders to solve\n               this problem through addressing it at the tables that we're bringing together right\n               now, because of the identified risks that the Premier has articulated and so have\n               I. I have legal teams that are actively assessing and making sure that we respond to\n               all claims, and we will be seeking appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada to clarify\n               the law.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721668","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"It's precisely why we are moving with First Nations and other stakeholders to solve\n               this problem through addressing it at the tables that we're bringing together right\n               now, because of the identified risks that the Premier has articulated and so have\n               I. I have legal teams that are actively assessing and making sure that we respond to\n               all c","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water use","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social problems","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water management","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Water supply","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Foreign affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083642","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Social innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083642","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083642","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Social innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035341","label":"Foreign affairs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037565","label":"Water management","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083627","label":"Water use","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083642","label":"Social innovation","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501240","label":"Social problems","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51814","label":"Family law","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59472","label":"Water supply","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0f4eb93919a3ba0f656bcf44f53330b63257e928b4151eb6aec13bf95d934ecc","dbbcf52ce228ed5840b497c8ec0c16ac534a5a9a93138d97544016f50a6d255c","08f6abef0ff66fb42042572b2c0295a112a02a715d0824b94ff23bfea7fc3eb3","0056a0da721b8d6d8f17f5e699fb9a66c64f0186f560c519d72b07c5b3683494"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b379ef950325c920a106dce5aef328af0d6bd24fec9c9dfb954f51fb2ff7e41d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3322dc8e273af6096bb745bd","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721681,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I appreciate the member's passion and explaining of what the law is and has been since\n               the Constitution's been put in place, that every government is subject to in this\n               province. I think it's informative, certainly for our members across the way that\n               don't seem to appreciate that. I will say that we are open to all ideas, and I've met with this member a few times.\n               We are now engaging in solutions to the challenge to the Gitxaała decision and how we move forward on reconciliation as promised. I think it's clear to many members that because of the political rhetoric that has\n               been rooted in misinformation and targeted against Indigenous people that has been\n               led by the party across the way, we have an issue with making sure that people understand,\n               in this province, that private property rights are not on the line and we will protect\n               them. We are going to move forward together lifting all boats, because that's what\n               British Columbians want. They want prosperity. They want us to work together to solve complicated problems\n               so we can all move forward together.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721681","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I appreciate the member's passion and explaining of what the law is and has been since\n               the Constitution's been put in place, that every government is subject to in this\n               province. I think it's informative, certainly for our members across the way that\n               don't seem to appreciate that. I will say that we are open to all ideas, and I've met with this member a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Water transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034551","label":"Ships","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037582","label":"Water transport","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["218aef9b952caff826506368a2445b83ddb0502782651aabeadb14ec2f8dc138"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.6,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f87540a9edfde734385af6b6639d816f457acb7dc9188ed467c134bb602fef27"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1c2d9e93286c7d64d1af0a48","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729447,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We're a team over here, and we work closely together to solve what are really important\n               challenges to address for the province. I've been working with the Premier on this\n               file since the beginning. What we are approaching now is a durable solution to what\n               is a serious challenge that we've been very open about. Unfortunately, the opposition has taken a different tact when it comes to how they\n               approach this issue. They're all about slogans without any real solution. But what\n               is the most troubling for me is the fearmongering, because they're using that fear\n               to raise money for political purposes. I just have a few quotes right here — I could go on all day — from leadership candidates\n               that are telling mistruths about DRIPA and Indigenous People coming after property\n               rights. Peter Milobar.... Sorry. The member for Kamloops Centre.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729447","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"We're a team over here, and we work closely together to solve what are really important\n               challenges to address for the province. I've been working with the Premier on this\n               file since the beginning. What we are approaching now is a durable solution to what\n               is a serious challenge that we've been very open about. Unfortunately, the opposition has taken a di","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083675","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Electronic publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Planning","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Negotiations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Collective bargaining","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Publishing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083672","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Radio","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sovereignty","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016196","label":"Prevention","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035823","label":"Indigenous law","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083652","label":"Publishing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083661","label":"Planning","probability":0.27,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083672","label":"Radio","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083675","label":"Electronic publishing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083682","label":"Indigenous businesses","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41875","label":"Collective bargaining","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42443","label":"Sovereignty","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:727856","label":"Negotiations","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["efd1a28266dc7d63d2a1e592d048639fbe7998a0a9259df81eb3b25963e0d985","2faa16b0880d246d881a43841f59825d102737cafa194024a79907a43aa2eea4","25e5fb67a12b897ba89275a7d3a7626120c68de83790cc178cda38adcc353f81","704198b2f858f4242d3486be4b22fa26b6143f25c89679f96b8896f205c85be8","d9a527cc669063426f8d2c70538a119a4cf107a6f3c24e234662e1eb7579f705"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.69,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5ff64b25d7340db72d705bc8d3baa1cbaa71bf15700d3bddb22561b2643f79f4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3d32b97f4dd8aa9d592333f1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729451,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I am pleased to have two introductions today. I'll start with the first one. A dear\n               friend is visiting that I went to law school with, who is an engineer and a lawyer\n               — what a combo. So if everybody could make my friend Robert Joseph feel very welcome. And I also have a class visiting from Van Tech, which is a pretty awesome school in\n               my riding. They have a great teacher named Chris Moon, who is very passionate about\n               teaching that generation about democracy and governance. I had a chance to meet with\n               them not only in Van Tech, but also just a few minutes ago in my office. I don't know if they're here. I can't see them, but please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729451","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I am pleased to have two introductions today. I'll start with the first one. A dear\n               friend is visiting that I went to law school with, who is an engineer and a lawyer\n               — what a combo. So if everybody could make my friend Robert Joseph feel very welcome. And I also have a class visiting from Van Tech, which is a pretty awesome school in\n               my riding. They ha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.66,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["25ebd3b45444d694189bcb8cd94b67761be9b5faaca8e67ba333ac7da6ed53bb"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5e4b25166da9939997515d4c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752337,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've had a chance to canvass this issue quite a bit in this House about our commitment\n               to working through the issues of the Gitxaała decision, appealing to the Supreme Court of Canada and sitting down to figure out what the\n               fix is going to be to the challenges we face. We are about taking action and understanding\n               what needs to change and working with our partners to arrive at that. The issue of U.S. tribes in Canada.... Well, we're a government that came up with a\n               legislative fix here in the House for that. The Minister of Environment recently introduced\n               legislation to support the environmental assessment office's ability to differentiate,\n               with consultation with First Nations in Canada and tribes in the United States. This is what we do. We come up with solutions to fix challenges that we're facing\n               in B.C.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752337","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We've had a chance to canvass this issue quite a bit in this House about our commitment\n               to working through the issues of the Gitxaała decision, appealing to the Supreme Court of Canada and sitting down to figure out what the\n               fix is going to be to the challenges we face. We are about taking action and understanding\n               what needs to change and working with o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Misappropriation of funds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"International cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Constitutional law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Lobbying","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","label":"International development","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035953","label":"International organizations","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036318","label":"Misappropriation of funds","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083679","label":"International cooperation","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:258755","label":"Constitutional law","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718450","label":"Lobbying","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b7a580366f6c294da0e887d45c682d48eb964611179fe84265c31d1fbc866efc","8582643adedd5101db98cc7777cc7a4fa8f581f2ee63c98698d390b517531d47","816653d569c09840a885809219a86dfc7773ab28ca249eceb252302f530856ea"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["47c9e0e24db3b993b2f75d74936d17c26c0b7be9e2b9863fe45417329649899c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4dc611d83c5073f26bbd5e99","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752338,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Premier has answered this quite thoroughly, and I can say for my part as Attorney\n               General I have no information at all about any of the allegations put forward by the\n               former mayor of Vancouver.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752338","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Premier has answered this quite thoroughly, and I can say for my part as Attorney\n               General I have no information at all about any of the allegations put forward by the\n               former mayor of Vancouver.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036790","label":"Provincial institutions","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.61,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d21f3b88ec08af6d3be05acb3ba35a6a06773cbb2f4274d9b7a0da32ffe7df3c"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-754b306c57fafa6a5b02a966","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752340,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'll just go.... We've talked about this line of questioning before. We've talked about\n               our decision and the work that we're doing to address the Gitxaała decision and that we're hard at work doing that. I'm not going to speak about a matter\n               that is before the courts, and that's been something that I've said over and over\n               again in this House. But I will say that the obligations that we have, or may or may not have, to U.S.\n               tribes is something that is a matter before the court and was a matter before the\n               court in 2010, when the first decision came forward related to that, when we were\n               not in government. We did bring a fix forward in this House to make sure that our EA process can distinguish between U.S. tribes and the First Nations of this province\n               who we stand behind, and they did not support that legislation. So I'm really confused\n               with the continual line of questioning — that if they're unable to support a legislative\n               fix to the problem, but they keep asking questions about it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752340","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I'll just go.... We've talked about this line of questioning before. We've talked about\n               our decision and the work that we're doing to address the Gitxaała decision and that we're hard at work doing that. I'm not going to speak about a matter\n               that is before the courts, and that's been something that I've said over and over\n               again i","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["f1ff774a2c3979b7d53b165edc5b8883cb90b562f6bed712e5f80a6cf9d1ea2e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["acfc264bfcda407872384474afc4fcc61f6e2e22238f40be28b810a00483f2bc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6d7eb9696c8e713d55f7d3c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752341,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I don't speak about things that are before the court, and there is a good reason for\n               that. But what I will say is that I have had the chance to meet with the Cattlemen\n               a couple times when they were in town whenever that day was — because we're all tired.\n               It was for over half an hour that we sat down. I got to hear their perspectives. It's my job as a government representative to understand everybody's perspective and\n               the challenges that they see in the province and to come up with solutions. That's\n               what we're doing.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752341","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I don't speak about things that are before the court, and there is a good reason for\n               that. But what I will say is that I have had the chance to meet with the Cattlemen\n               a couple times when they were in town whenever that day was — because we're all tired.\n               It was for over half an hour that we sat down. I got to hear their perspectives. It's my job as a go","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Equal opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Conservation areas","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Resource development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beef cattle","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Provincial governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034491","label":"Claims processing","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034630","label":"Conservation areas","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036960","label":"Resource development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083632","label":"Provincial governments","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42596","label":"Equal opportunities","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945669","label":"Cattle","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:945678","label":"Beef cattle","probability":0.49,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4708d79211f79dc601e1a6be6202e1c196ec3604cdc5a152f6ff531ff19b3097","be6dfa9cccedd220885057451116e97fa939dceef1c162e4f0d257b667f6caa2"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-017fafc7f920db7d28d17690","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017605,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We've canvassed this issue many times. We talked about a decision...","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017605","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We've canvassed this issue many times. We talked about a decision...","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"International development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035945","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035945","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"International courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035945","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"International law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035945","label":"International courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035946","label":"International development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43027","label":"International law","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3fdb015191566afcabac80437ea49756cbb25ecfaf71b939fb7594ee5317ef4b","844d4df0faea584e50b0546ef9833103f7b8ec7ef720aabae841eb2f7e67ccb1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ec67500e20621264806a14f3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017607,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"We're hard at work right now coming up with a durable solution to the challenge in\n               DRIPA. I expect to hear from our appeal application soon from the Supreme Court of Canada. That will be one avenue to fixing the legal challenges that we face. We're working\n               with our partners right now to come up with a solution. We are looking forward to\n               that happening shortly, and we'll keep doing that work. Our approach is about bringing people together to solve really challenging problems.\n               Very different than the approach of the other side that would just repeal, rip up,\n               go back to court for long, protracted battles related to not sitting down and solving\n               challenges. We'll continue to do that work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017607","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"We're hard at work right now coming up with a durable solution to the challenge in\n               DRIPA. I expect to hear from our appeal application soon from the Supreme Court of Canada. That will be one avenue to fixing the legal challenges that we face. We're working\n               with our partners right now to come up with a solution. We are looking forward to\n               that happening s","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Minerals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Beverage industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Mining industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Prospecting","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Elections","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036779","label":"Prospecting","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","label":"Cooperation","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:128177","label":"Beverage industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.62,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44296","label":"Mining industry","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501091","label":"Elections","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:719071","label":"Minerals","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["0b780bf13f30b3539149f2ca8b3732959cb87036fa6517d7d3177f873c4ab69f","51da205e5740e86e4da146ca1f024f88c760d08aeda7ef406eac644e0301753a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9db70e0829576fe4fd3db95c94eaaf692f588d10c683bf68f546263e35a01370"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083658","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2e82f0072c0b4a31c30575d1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017610,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I think they ran out of questions over there. We're recycling some from yesterday. I'm really happy, actually, to give an update to the House on some news that we heard\n               this morning, that the Supreme Court of Canada granted our leave application. We were\n               successful in getting leave to appeal at the Supreme Court of Canada. This is an avenue to address the legal challenges that is open to us now, along with\n               the discussions that we're having various stakeholders about solving DRIPA. We're\n               going to get there, and we're working hard at doing that.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017610","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I think they ran out of questions over there. We're recycling some from yesterday. I'm really happy, actually, to give an update to the House on some news that we heard\n               this morning, that the Supreme Court of Canada granted our leave application. We were\n               successful in getting leave to appeal at the Supreme Court of Canada. This is an avenue to address the legal challe","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal aid","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47723","label":"Legal aid","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.68,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["590bcb1d1522294a71c6e3152889781fc57587c19a4395bf53abe60da113105c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.34,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["402f3dfb4c3342ec837ee409c10fca1ec68ff6674757d6506904c35ca4613feb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e3c0f21cec19c01ef82e7b2","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036578,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I just noticed that Amelia Hill is in the House right now. Amelia used to work as\n               part of my team at the ministry office. She had so much spirit and passion for the\n               work that she did, and we miss her around my office. Please make her feel welcome. I know she loves QP, so she's probably happy to be here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036578","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I just noticed that Amelia Hill is in the House right now. Amelia used to work as\n               part of my team at the ministry office. She had so much spirit and passion for the\n               work that she did, and we miss her around my office. Please make her feel welcome. I know she loves QP, so she's probably happy to be here.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["02151362bfc4da58bb628ec226ad228cb7a39fec43c265f12b87dae4b594e74f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-06eac206a01364ecbcec9420","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036579,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"Clearly, that's a disturbing case. It's one of the reasons that we've been so strong\n               on calling for bail reform across this country. B.C. has led the way to ensure that\n               our Criminal Code across this country has the right tools necessary to keep prolific\n               offenders off the streets, to keep them from harming people and keep them from reoffending.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036579","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Clearly, that's a disturbing case. It's one of the reasons that we've been so strong\n               on calling for bail reform across this country. B.C. has led the way to ensure that\n               our Criminal Code across this country has the right tools necessary to keep prolific\n               offenders off the streets, to keep them from harming people and keep them from reoffending.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","label":"Criminal code","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","label":"Crime prevention","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56aa3ca3d26cc88a8f16eb6a89074c2bffeeb446c1d167e84275ab07273e32bb"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e00c87d39b314fd82526ee3fc68f59f40f7c40a3632c9175ce38451ed13d7619"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime prevention","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034723","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43161","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-75e59e8e9bbe89b3321200f7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036580,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Niki Sharma","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to table two reports.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036580","member_id":"bc-mla-72","member_name":"Niki Sharma","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I seek leave to table two reports.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f11520960e7f2e6e626cb94a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316787,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"We are very sad today in my minister's office. We are losing Diego Cardona. He is\n               moving on to work with IATSE, some of our wonderful film friends. Diego started as an executive assistant to the Minister of Advanced Education and\n               Skills Training in May 2019 and has gone through a number of ministries and a number\n               of ministers — myself and the Minister of Agriculture. I'm particularly sad to see him go, as he's worked with passion and commitment in\n               this building for years, helped with the film tax credit, built the film file. He's\n               worked with child care advocates to grow and protect our child care system. We are\n               truly going to miss him but are very excited for his new opportunities. Thank you, Diego.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316787","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"We are very sad today in my minister's office. We are losing Diego Cardona. He is\n               moving on to work with IATSE, some of our wonderful film friends. Diego started as an executive assistant to the Minister of Advanced Education and\n               Skills Training in May 2019 and has gone through a number of ministries and a number\n               of ministers — myself and the Minister o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Child support","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crisis","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Children's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Child development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034449","label":"Child development","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034454","label":"Child support","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034459","label":"Children's health","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","label":"Cinema","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715184","label":"Crisis","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fc3a820156199ed4a8572271fb6144421cb07803cf4d9b82ebf2b09a07ec36f","ca613e2b8c1946d86aadb69a8c5eb363a1158f4e366227bf139aff57fd8b7d7e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c6bcd84e0ecb27cd39736da1cee3ae8f072640fa94914df7d7c51e72d07e6356"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034468","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cinema","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a9fcdf29336e5a10cefbe497","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316788,"date":"2026-02-25T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have two introductions today. Joining us in the gallery right now are grade 6-7\n               students from Alouette Elementary, alongside their teacher Shirley Bice and some other\n               guardians","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260225pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316788","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I have two introductions today. Joining us in the gallery right now are grade 6-7\n               students from Alouette Elementary, alongside their teacher Shirley Bice and some other\n               guardians","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","label":"Children","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.75,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4cb940e1a9defb04f23139b84bbf8400c23e4c6ca8178553f6ade47f229e4a2b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9e8a7adf79773f7edbb28a8cd0c20b464830ae938662b9930c2dfb3fa338f8d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Children","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43045","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-072b608ea4af7f69e4876944","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316789,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have said continually to this member and to every person in this House that B.C.\n               schools and B.C. communities need to remain safe. They need to remain welcoming for\n               everyone. To use the horrible actions of one person to attack an entire group is simply unacceptable.\n               This kind of rhetoric is dangerous. The fact that this member is using a tragedy like\n               Tumbler Ridge.... To exploit this tragedy and use it to advance their personal political\n               agenda is just appalling. This member's fixation on our Honestly, MLAs are supposed to represent every single person in their community. This\n               member is clearly unable to do that, and she should resign.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316789","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I have said continually to this member and to every person in this House that B.C.\n               schools and B.C. communities need to remain safe. They need to remain welcoming for\n               everyone. To use the horrible actions of one person to attack an entire group is simply unacceptable.\n               This kind of rhetoric is dangerous. The fact that this member is using a tragedy like\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Population","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Disasters","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Discrimination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083669","label":"Population","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","label":"Resignation","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44254","label":"Discrimination","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752481","label":"Disasters","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.48,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8d50b62e67d2fd9f0ce5250fcafe0dd0fb647c40fca19ffd280aedc72b577bac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b0721b93a823e495851620f2f410a58d18521251f604c723530211f04cac1a48"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Resignation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43624","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be35d1c0815ccf0430ee6f3d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327907,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Joining us in the gallery are representatives from the Centre for Family Equity's\n               lone mothers economic inclusion initiative, led by executive director Viveca Ellis.\n               Founded as the Single Mothers Alliance in 2014, they continue to build leadership\n               and capacity among families impacted by inequality. I am looking forward, as are many\n               of my colleagues, to meeting them later today and discussing their work in the child\n               care sector. I ask all members to make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":null},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327907","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Joining us in the gallery are representatives from the Centre for Family Equity's\n               lone mothers economic inclusion initiative, led by executive director Viveca Ellis.\n               Founded as the Single Mothers Alliance in 2014, they continue to build leadership\n               and capacity among families impacted by inequality. I am looking forward, as are many\n               of my ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","label":"Single parent families"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","label":"Child care","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","label":"Single parent families","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715780","label":"Development","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e6b8b5e4688fe4438cfbc35e4956d5ed4ec661f01b7a2c1b57d04e80aa712190"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ec770f52195575fc4edc36e638b640c3431980350c004331ff6ca25fa4415fae"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Child care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083671","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Single parent families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034448","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff3938ff44a55a1d544d439e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358949,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today we have some amazing leaders from Maple Ridge in the gallery. We have Gordy\n               and Mary Robson, who are strong community leaders, including Gordy being a former\n               mayor and city councillor. Mary has been the executive director of the Friends in Need Food Bank in Maple Ridge\n               for the past 13 years. She said she's retiring. Not many of us believe it. But they've had many, many accomplishments together. One of the most notable Mary has been the executive director of the Friends in Need Food Bank in Maple Ridge\n               for the past 13 years. She said she's retiring. Not many of us believe it. But they've had many, many accomplishments together. One of the most notable was that\n               they founded the Maple Ridge News in 1984. These are the kind of leaders that Mary and Gordy are, and I hope that the House will\n               please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358949","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Today we have some amazing leaders from Maple Ridge in the gallery. We have Gordy\n               and Mary Robson, who are strong community leaders, including Gordy being a former\n               mayor and city councillor. Mary has been the executive director of the Friends in Need Food Bank in Maple Ridge\n               for the past 13 years. She said she's retiring. Not many of us believe it. But ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art galleries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083673","label":"Art galleries","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a874e4fa5f0b63d6217b1da158299a8a455b6702fecd672fec18ed454c1f173"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e4237825690bcc8ef90058a1e46f280ea6f534ba1adda27f3f262fe817f1dce8"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cdbf227de1ca41bbc7bc8ac8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358950,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"To the member: there is no cut. I find it very unfortunate that the member is scaring\n               families and making them worry. We are continuing to work closely with our partners,\n               with the district, with the municipality, with TransLink. I'm actually really excited to see that the councillors and city council are involved\n               in this. This is great, because the school district, the municipal council and TransLink\n               all need to be working together alongside us to provide those transit solutions in\n               their community. We, as a government, have prioritized education We as a government have prioritized education investments at a record level. We have\n               $8 billion going directly into school districts next year, and that includes funding\n               for transportation. Every other community in this province provides their own transportation.\n               We have water taxis in the gulf. In the North, we have buses that run on train tracks.\n               We have a wide range of diverse transportation needs that are met by the local districts. We're working together with the district to provide that permanent solution for Queensborough.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358950","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"To the member: there is no cut. I find it very unfortunate that the member is scaring\n               families and making them worry. We are continuing to work closely with our partners,\n               with the district, with the municipality, with TransLink. I'm actually really excited to see that the councillors and city council are involved\n               in this. This is great, because the scho","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4ad479513838cc6e838f09aaf12652a2de25e8f0349a887afa9d8a4eeae8f2db"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["58352a0a57a3b1365779f90f577e0bec0c8bc9e48343f855f6a1e3dea1950b48"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3eda9e6e5a01b86b13253e57","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413649,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to honour the life and service of Michael Sather, a member of the Legislative\n               Assembly for Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows, who passed away on March 27 at the age of 78. Michael was a good friend to so many\n               of us here in this House. He was a fierce advocate for the people of Maple Ridge and\n               Pitt Meadows and a passionate environmentalist. Before serving in public office, Michael led a life of community advocacy in many\n               forms. Alongside the Pitt Polder Preservation Society, he helped drive preservation\n               of the Blaney Bog and Codd wetland regional parks. He was also involved in fighting\n               wildfires, studying wildlife as a biologist and being a wilderness tourism guide with\n               Hummingbird Nature Tours. He fought for both nature and its preservation. Outside of his advocacy, Michael remained connected to the world around him, often\n               spending his days fishing for salmon on the coast of B.C., or birding. In fact, in\n               speaking with his wife, Annette, she shared fond memories of his hiking together with their daughter on the Santa Rosa trails in Palm Springs and the work that they all did to protect the land around them. And while his love for the environment ran deep, it was his desire to help people,\n               coupled with his strong respect for community, that drove him to public office. He\n               started with an eight-year tenure as a constituency assistant to former MLA Bill Hartley,\n               and in 2005, Michael was elected to the B.C. Legislature, where he was able to represent\n               his constituents with perseverance, thoughtfulness and a deep sense of responsibility. Throughout his time as MLA, he was known as someone who listened carefully, spoke\n               honestly and approached public service with integrity and an independence of mind.\n               Michael never shied away from thoughtful debate. He was reflective and committed to\n               evidence-based decision-making, guided by the belief that public office exists to\n               serve people, particularly those whose voices are often unheard. He was a different type of politician. Michael was not afraid to uphold his values\n               and provoke his colleagues with conversation and a difference of opinion. After all,\n               it was his community that he was fighting for. This included reaching across the aisle\n               at times to achieve the greater good or being present for tough conversations. Annette shared a time with me where Michael worked with over 30 charities that were\n               cut off from funding, and he took action, working directly with the minister to reinstate\n               the funding, protecting all those services for people in our community. Perhaps the strongest we saw Michael was in his public battle with frontotemporal\n               dementia and aphasia later in life. Michael held a master's degree in psychology and\n               was able to self-diagnose his disease, catching it at an early stage. While vacationing\n               in Hawaii, he realized he was not able to recall the names of the birds that he loved. Later in life, this resulted in aphasia-related shortcomings in communication and\n               impairment of language. As a result of this diagnosis, Michael founded another community through the Maple\n               Ridge Purple Angel dementia support group. Annette shared that they supported As a result of this diagnosis, Michael founded another community through the Maple\n               Ridge Purple Angel dementia support group. n shared that they supported him with grace\n               and kindness. I've been so privileged and honoured to participate in the community\n               walks that the Purple Angel organized help carry on Michael's story and legacy. But to be clear, this disease never slowed Michael down. He continued to return to\n               nature and admire his environment. Beyond his professional accomplishments, Michael\n               must be remembered as a kind, curious, deeply humane individual. His compassion for\n               others and his enduring commitment to public life left lasting impressions on colleagues\n               on all sides of this House and on the community he served. His impact to Maple Ridge's ecosystem is clear. Thanks to Michael, agricultural land\n               was protected. He left a lasting impression on colleagues on all sides of the House\n               and in the community that he served. Regional parks were stewarded and an ongoing\n               awareness of dementia grew. While we mourn Michael Sather's passing, we also give thanks for his years of service\n               and the legacy that he leaves behind. And given his passion for nature, I want to\n               leave the House with a funny story shared to me by the member for Port Coquitlam. During the hike one day, Michael came across two baby bears, and he immediately thought\n               to himself: \"Uh-oh. Where could the mother bear be?\" No sooner than the thought had\n               crossed his mind, Michael turned around and was smacked down by a big mama grizzly.\n               When Michael came to, he later reflected that he could tell he was still alive because\n               he could immediately feel the pain. It was a story he would tell time and time again\n               in this building. On behalf of all the members, I extend our sincere condolences to his wife of over\n               30 years, Annette, his family and his friends, who all had the privilege of working\n               with him. And I want to thank Annette and his whole family for sharing Michael with\n               us, for sharing Michael with the province. May his memory continue to inspire a moral\n               and thoughtful service in this Legislature and beyond. We will all miss you, Michael.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413649","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to honour the life and service of Michael Sather, a member of the Legislative\n               Assembly for Maple Ridge–Pitt Meadows, who passed away on March 27 at the age of 78. Michael was a good friend to so many\n               of us here in this House. He was a fierce advocate for the people of Maple Ridge and\n               Pitt Meadows and a passionate environmentalist. Before se","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035672","label":"Heritage conservation","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","label":"Environmental protection","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","label":"Nature conservation","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b0fbfc9cd756a8afa10019b3f7c8425f5734dbad508f921cf8d77ea40a275cbd"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.35,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7bcc61fb1ec4eabb42b5b93dbfbadf134b4d36f184dad0125793838f66a3a750"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Nature conservation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42629","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44897","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cb8f8e2714642497163646ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":728782,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:728782","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I seek leave to make an introduction.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Visits of state","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083606","label":"Visits of state","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42665","label":"Public health","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d68fd17fabcf3acdea8ae343df44b94a0acc99e405132d09df97c318530b903"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e0c3538af71747f0886395b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752158,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to join the member from Kelowna in welcoming CEFA to the House today. He did\n               beat me to it, so I wish them all the best. I also have guests from the city of Maple Ridge who are here today. We have the mayor, His Worship Dan Rumi here, along with intergovernmental, Katerina Anastasiadis, who is here today. Would the House please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752158","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to join the member from Kelowna in welcoming CEFA to the House today. He did\n               beat me to it, so I wish them all the best. I also have guests from the city of Maple Ridge who are here today. We have the mayor, His Worship Dan Rumi here, along with intergovernmental, Katerina Anastasiadis, who is here today. Would the House please make them feel very welcome.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["301467f8bd79bdcef825b29c4364b5540b464b17c1c6fe4ecf45d2daae7ccfa4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cacb474a6ae8c921f3bf075b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752159,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the honour today to introduce the youngest elected official here in British\n               Columbia. We have Hudson Campbell with us, who is a school trustee out of SD 42. He\n               is the youngest elected official here in the province. Accompanying him is McKenna\n               Grace, who also is from Maple Ridge, who happens to work in my office. Would the House please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752159","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have the honour today to introduce the youngest elected official here in British\n               Columbia. We have Hudson Campbell with us, who is a school trustee out of SD 42. He\n               is the youngest elected official here in the province. Accompanying him is McKenna\n               Grace, who also is from Maple Ridge, who happens to work in my office. Would the House please make them f","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["159c650820d6c48b75361247cb1afe19f5359a6c0763727400c94f17bd005573"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cd55fef82d2965ca5ad20728","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017053,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I rise today, actually, to acknowledge some really exciting\n               news in your life, Speaker, that I know the members of this House will all want to\n               join me in celebrating. This past weekend, Mr. Speaker, you were honoured with a prestigious Ellis Island\n               Medal of Honor from the Ellis Island Honors Society in New York City. This award was\n               bestowed in recognition of your humanitarian efforts as founding president of the\n               Canadian Farmworkers Union, work that improved the lives of thousands of vulnerable\n               farmworkers across this country, and your lifelong devotion to fighting racial inequity\n               and for injustices. I know the entire House will want to join me in saying congratulations, well done\n               and well deserved, Speaker.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017053","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. I rise today, actually, to acknowledge some really exciting\n               news in your life, Speaker, that I know the members of this House will all want to\n               join me in celebrating. This past weekend, Mr. Speaker, you were honoured with a prestigious Ellis Island\n               Medal of Honor from the Ellis Island Honors Society in New York City. This award ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1542d991dd8ace71c4c2b608f6c39075f6b1e69e137cac926547b22883eec170"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.17,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1e0ff9fdf2ccf50b9fb0bd35dcbb5a278c7eb69f3a83c24041ffdf4f20b1c401"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-dc7eee53109b94960f8cc757","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017055,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today in the gallery we are joined by members of the Junior Achievement B.C. It's\n               a non-profit that has operated for 70 years, delivering free programs in financial\n               health, work readiness and entrepreneurship to more than 80,000 B.C. students annually. Behind this great work and with us today are President and CEO Wendi Campbell, Vice-President\n               Cecily Lawrenson, Glenn Dodge and Delreen Motiwalla. I look forward to meeting with them later today and ask all members of this House\n               to please make them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017055","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today in the gallery we are joined by members of the Junior Achievement B.C. It's\n               a non-profit that has operated for 70 years, delivering free programs in financial\n               health, work readiness and entrepreneurship to more than 80,000 B.C. students annually. Behind this great work and with us today are President and CEO Wendi Campbell, Vice-President\n               Cecily L","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Scholarships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:791158","label":"Scholarships","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8c37a999c64c17a654fe227edb948bab8ad76f284dde754ed5398ddcc1994264"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["76b68e9aece16756e0ac2a51526f44250aeefdd93f0a976628ac24f36394625d"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-951b05e3287866094f107cfc","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017058,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"First off, absolutely, I want to clarify the comment. It was inappropriate that I\n               called the Leader of the Opposition gross. I do withdraw that comment.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017058","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"First off, absolutely, I want to clarify the comment. It was inappropriate that I\n               called the Leader of the Opposition gross. I do withdraw that comment.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6063395037248b5ac4a5c999","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036388,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the member for the question. We've been very clear on this side of the House that protecting education, public\n               education, is a top priority for us. That's reflected in the budget that you have\n               before us this year. In light of incredibly difficult financial circumstances, we\n               made the decision as a government to continue to invest and increase investments in\n               public education. This is significant. The member well knows that local boards make local decisions, and so these are conversations\n               to have with the local board. But we at the province are going to continue year after\n               year after year to invest in public education, as we have done over the last nine\n               years, because we value it.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036388","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to thank the member for the question. We've been very clear on this side of the House that protecting education, public\n               education, is a top priority for us. That's reflected in the budget that you have\n               before us this year. In light of incredibly difficult financial circumstances, we\n               made the decision as a government to continue to invest and incr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Interpersonal relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Bonds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48748","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer networks","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Training centres","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","label":"Educational funding","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035049","label":"Employment centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035969","label":"Interpersonal relations","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","label":"Public funding","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037397","label":"Training centres","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.34,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","label":"School boards","probability":0.81,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.28,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48748","label":"Computer networks","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","label":"Education","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:963393","label":"Bonds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","label":"Public schools","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["af3b30afd52de6dc00a0f4bdbcb6f9a58edde93b08c7d4d3e784bf7a29d1c149","6a0d8453e3bb3e66aa1079876023a916cc380df5c7154cfa2a02091ec6cee50c","ab929393b66288359992fd0524aa3530d8e9d668ed6eb2ea977c4a9571106afa"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["62bdac55e238c9357c4b96d769d9fad194096e11c12d8c76ca56c69b3f156099"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Public schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Public funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"School boards","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034967","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036802","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:136394","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:858","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:97845","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ab01775c3b1d239133a6fd8d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036389,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to thank the member for the question. I have been very clear as the Minister\n               of Education from minute one that safety is my number one priority for students, for\n               families and for staff in schools and for all of those who work there. Yesterday I did say that I would be providing the information around costs. We don't\n               have a number to date to provide the member. We're still reconciling that information,\n               but I am working to get the information for the member and for the media that asked\n               yesterday.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036389","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to thank the member for the question. I have been very clear as the Minister\n               of Education from minute one that safety is my number one priority for students, for\n               families and for staff in schools and for all of those who work there. Yesterday I did say that I would be providing the information around costs. We don't\n               have a number to date to provi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.61,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.79,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["39a83ed2ccb0725a792c5ed14025a1815d28ab8bd5aa455dba62768e20e4f4ab","94e3bb0b714e26ed058aeca1c6969958f5907d39550c65984c33c83337038b60"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["2e1a3b0cac36cd2ef19ba324e283fbce51196cad623280977a75a83a1c35a588"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-357f7513bafb08b1714db3c7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036390,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Lisa Beare","venue":"Hansard","text":"I thank the member for the question because it's always important to be able to talk\n               to families here in British Columbia about student safety. Here in B.C., we are a leading jurisdiction when it comes to safety for students in\n               our care. We as a government want, like every single parent, to know that when our\n               kids go to school, they come home safe. We have safety coordinators in every single\n               school who are responsible for ensuring that they have safety plans in place for each\n               school and in every district. When we look at the tragedy that happened in Tumbler Ridge, I made it very, very clear\n               to the community and to the province that there are multiple investigations taking\n               place right now. We are waiting to see the results of those investigations so that\n               we can coordinatedly take action to ensure that we continue to make safety our number\n               one priority. But I want families to know that we take trauma-informed, community-led, school- participated\n               safety planning very seriously. What works in Victoria or Vancouver or Surrey does\n               not work for north coast or Revelstoke. We need to ensure that we are taking local\n               communities' needs into account when building out safety plans.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036390","member_id":"bc-mla-8","member_name":"Lisa Beare","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I thank the member for the question because it's always important to be able to talk\n               to families here in British Columbia about student safety. Here in B.C., we are a leading jurisdiction when it comes to safety for students in\n               our care. We as a government want, like every single parent, to know that when our\n               kids go to school, they come home safe. We h","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Safety education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037006","label":"Safety education","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","label":"Safety","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["be11b0398a8da85f4359d0ea39caeddabf9978c40a0b223a0cf9bee989fa791d"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d60f3ab3943b8bd1f782b8c49ae9045107d0681ae831b19e9299937c87a5332f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42493","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e48130afe44eabfbfffa3890","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317209,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you for this opportunity to speak to Budget 2026. My constituents in Surrey-Cloverdale are diverse families. We have seniors and small businesses. We have business owners and leaders from large companies,\n               all of whom deserve a government that manages our province's finances responsibly This budget projects a staggering $13.3 billion deficit, the largest in British Columbia's\n               history, with the provincial debt skyrocketing to $234.5 billion by 2028-2029. It's\n               a plan riddled with tax hikes, hidden cuts and delays that will burden families and\n               seniors while failing to ignite the economic growth that our province needs. This government claims to be making disciplined choices to protect core services,\n               yet what we're seeing is a ballooning deficit, $3.1 billion higher than last year's\n               projections. And despite raising taxes and slashing 15,000 public sector jobs over\n               three years, the debt-to-GDP ratio climbs to 37.4 percent, increasing borrowing costs\n               and risking further credit downgrades. It's not only Independents and opposition MLAs who are pointing out the shortcomings\n               of the 2026 budget. Business organizations and leaders across the province have come\n               out very strongly to voice their disapproval. The B.C. Chamber of Commerce calls this\n               budget \"a sobering economic outlook\" with \"little in the way of needed economic incentives.\"\n               They highlight the alarming deficit increase and the debt climbing from $154 billion\n               to $235 billion. Jen Riley, the chamber's president and CEO, noted that the budget\n               offers no meaningful plan to kick-start our economy or generate prosperity for citizens\n               and businesses. Similarly, the Vancouver Board of Trade gave this budget a failing D grade, the lowest\n               in over 20 years, citing slow growth, higher taxes, runaway spending. Bridgitte Anderson,\n               the CEO, warned that it confirms \"slow growth, higher taxes and continued runaway\n               spending.\" Business groups, like the B.C. Business Council, echo these concerns, saying that\n               the budget fails to stabilize our fiscal trajectory by restraining spending or improving\n               conditions for private sector investment. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business,\n               or the CFIB, criticizes the expansion of the provincial sales tax to additional professional\n               services, calling it \"a move in the wrong direction.\" It adds that cost pressures\n               to small businesses are already struggling. The Independent Contractors and Business Association describes this budget as a \"mess\"\n               and \"awful for construction.\" They point to delays in major projects like hospitals.\n               I believe that the hospital that the minister for tourism and sport was just talking\n               about in her own riding is in fact one of the projects that's delayed. While it's\n               a source of pride for her, I think it's, frankly, embarrassing for this government\n               that they would have to \"re-pace projects\" that they then go on to brag about in their\n               own speeches. I'd also add that the NDP's decision to add community benefit agreements in their\n               decisions added an estimated 4 to 7 percent onto the cost of every government infrastructure\n               project. Over the last couple of years, B.C. has had a record number of people migrate out\n               of the province, citing the high cost of living. A significant number of those who\n               are choosing to leave our province are young people. They don't see a future for themselves\n               here, and this budget's projected modest economic growth of just 1.3 percent in 2026\n               means fewer opportunities for young people starting out and more uncertainty for those\n               trying to make ends meet. I'd like to talk for a moment about public safety. I was very disappointed to see\n               a lack of greater investment in public safety. Cloverdale residents have been targeted\n               by violence with multiple extortions, multiple extortion-related shootings. I was\n               very disappointed, frankly, that I didn't see a greater investment both to fund the\n               police for special teams that deal with enforcement against gang activity, but also\n               without an even greater investment to combat illegal firearms. Extortions have had a tremendous impact on people who live in Cloverdale. We've had\n               some victims of extortion that have been hit multiple times in their same residence.\n               Just, actually, a couple blocks from where I live, we had a home that was Extortions have had a tremendous impact on people who live in Cloverdale. We've had\n               some victims of the extortion that have been hit multiple times in their same residence.\n               Just, actually, a couple of blocks from where I live, we had a home that was targeted\n               for a shooting, and a gardener got a bullet lodged in their face. There is no doubt that this government is actually taking the extortion crisis seriously,\n               but the way in which they are funding public safety is not going to be adequate to\n               address the depth of the problems that we currently have. One of the ways that they are failing is by not increasing the number of provincially\n               funded RCMP officers. A couple of years ago, the government did make an investment\n               in increasing the number of police officers on the provincial business line, but this\n               simply filled vacancies that they had let go vacant for years. The fact is that the\n               provincial business line of the RCMP in B.C. has been stuck at 2,602 members since\n               2012. These are the members who respond in communities like Tumbler Ridge, for example.\n               Small communities but also are part of provincial teams — provincial teams that have\n               been tasked with joining the provincial extortion task force. When we keep the number\n               of police officers at the provincial business line stagnant, it actually also puts\n               a disproportionate cost onto municipalities who then themselves have to pay for a\n               larger number of RCMP if that is who is supporting their community in rural areas. I also want to address something that the member for Panorama had brought up, and\n               that is the Surrey policing transition. I can tell you that the residents of Surrey-Cloverdale are ready for the SPS to come and transition us over to their services. We welcome\n               the transition to continue on time on April 1. I think that the concerns that are raised over whether or not the review that the\n               director of police services has done would be giving confidence to citizens that there\n               are, in fact, enough human resources to take over the transition.... I would ask the\n               government to be more clear on how they can provide assurances that the transition\n               is adequately staffed with personnel on the front line. I would also point out that the municipal police force says it needs over 70 members\n               to move the transition forward into our community when the RCMP is doing it with just\n               over 30 at this time. So we do welcome the transition to continue. We're supportive of the minister wanting\n               to advance the transition on April 1. I've heard concerns from members of the public,\n               businesses, the chamber of commerce and the business improvement association that\n               we've actually seen a reduction in police services since the scaling back of the RCMP\n               as part of the transition. They were asked to decommission special teams, and so we've\n               actually, in Cloverdale, seen a reduction in services. We welcome SPS to continue to transition into our area. We're proud to have our new\n               police force coming to our area April 1. I just want to reiterate that, for my constituents,\n               this is an important thing to go forward. But yes, we definitely need more resources\n               on the provincial business line of the RCMP and for public safety overall, and this\n               budget isn't delivering it. If our municipal police need more officers for extortion, then I would like to hold\n               the government accountable for its promise at the end of November to provide a surge\n               capacity of RCMP officers into Surrey to help fight extortion. Let's move our brand\n               new and hard-working members of the SPS to our front line and let's bring in those\n               supplements that this government promised to my community. I can't talk about crime and funding without actually talking about health funding\n               as well, specifically to talk about funding for mental health and addiction, which\n               was pretty much nothing in this budget. A re-announcement of 100 beds that the Premier had disclosed under pressure at the\n               end of the UBCM meetings in September after mayors held a rally on the steps of this\n               Legislature to talk about the absolutely crisis amounts of street disorder that people\n               are experiencing in communities all across British Columbia.... Recent surveys have been done by a number of different groups — Save Our Streets coalition,\n               business improvement Recent surveys have been done by a number of different groups — Save Our Streets coalition,\n               business improvement areas of British Columbia — and time and again, the results come\n               back to say over half of British Columbians currently feel unsafe in their neighbourhoods. These types of feelings, wellness and safety, are not always reflected in crime stats.\n               The reason for that is that people don't always report to the police. They don't always\n               call in, particularly if it's a persistent problem like street disorder, and they've\n               called time and again, and in their perception, nothing happens. Or they're a business\n               that has experienced a high level of shoplifting, and the person who steals from them\n               on an almost daily basis never gets charge approval and comes back again and again. I think it's important when.... I'm talking about the underfunding of public safety\n               ministries by this government in the 2026 budget, but it is also directly linked to\n               their underfunding of mental health care, in particular, in British Columbia, in the\n               2026 budget. One of the examples that I'll give you is a recent news story about an individual.\n               It's really sad. They were in Nanaimo. They broke into a tugboat. Many people saw\n               this on television. It was reported that this is a person who suffered from drug addiction. They had been\n               struggling. They had tried to go into voluntary addictions treatment. They struggled.\n               They relapsed, and they ended up in the situation where they spent over 30 hours on\n               a tugboat, absolutely smashed it. They're seen in a video, smoking, at one point, illicit drugs from what looks like\n               the same kind of bubbler pipe that they're giving out in NDP government harm reduction\n               sites. What happens is they end up in a standoff with police, arrested, released.\n               Then the first thing the person does.... They come back to the tugboat. They get picked\n               up again by the police. This time the police actually go and find them. They're in a business where they're\n               committing a theft. The person gets held in custody. The following day, Nanaimo RCMP\n               come out in public, and they give a warning to residents in Nanaimo, and they say:\n               \"We're giving you tips on how to prevent break and enter. We're giving you tips on\n               how to secure your home against someone breaking in and what to do if you come home\n               and you find somebody in your tugboat or your home.\" And that's backwards. I respect the RCMP for giving those warnings, and it's sad that\n               we have to be in this place. But why should it be, under this government — and I pose\n               this question to all British Columbians — that a person who is sick and who is addicted\n               with an obvious mental illness because of drug use is free on the street and without\n               adequate care, while citizens who are just minding their own business, trying to live\n               a happy life here in B.C., have to batten down the hatches and barricade themselves\n               in their homes? It's backwards. It's an extreme disappointment to me to see how these two issues, which are connected....\n               Our problem that we have in this province with public safety issues, the ones that\n               cause people the most distress, I would say, apart from.... Obviously, extortions are causing a lot of distress, but people can see, on the street,\n               the street disorder. Business owners are experiencing the shopliftings. Many of these\n               issues that we have are directly linked to health issues, mental health, addictions,\n               and we are failing. I actually really like the ReVOII program. I think that B.C. prosecution service and\n               the bail supervisors and the police, the RCMP and municipal police, are doing a great\n               job at administrating this program, and it does have some good outcomes. But the reality\n               is that there is a huge number of people that do not meet the criteria of that program\n               and that the services that we're providing are ineffective. One of the ways in which.... I would have loved to see in this budget, which is a connection,\n               actually, between justice and public safety and health care, funding to create live-in\n               treatment units within B.C. Corrections, meaning that anyone who would be sentenced\n               to two years less a day would be eligible to live in a unit within B.C. Corrections\n               and receive treatment. Maybe we'll get there. I think other provinces are doing this. I was heartened to\n               see that, especially in Surrey Pretrial, there are ten beds that were funded, created\n               last year, to help if there's someone who's in psychosis that gets brought in by the\n               police. They're able to go then, instead of waiting for a space at the forensic psychiatric\n               hospital. They can go into one of these beds. They can receive treatment immediately to help\n               alleviate the symptoms of the mental illness that they're diagnosed with and help\n               that person. But that's only ten beds out of this humongous province. We have a lot of pretrial centres in B.C. We have a lot of correctional facilities\n               where these services could help so many people break this terrible cycle. I can tell\n               you that we would be going a long way in this province to addressing that 50 percent\n               of people that keep coming back on the surveys who don't feel safe. It is a completely\n               solvable problem. But we can't solve it unless we're putting the programs in place\n               that will address the root of these issues. I spoke briefly, too, about the firearms, wishing to see.... I know that the government....\n               I was actually pleased, I'll say, to see, I think, that a $600,000 investment in the\n               gun lab in Surrey was given to help further investigations into firearms, particularly\n               in light of the extortion crisis that we're going through. But I still believe that\n               this is too little funding. We need to have a greater amount of funding. We need to see that we're going to actually increase our firearms program to look\n               for three types of things that we need to actually be addressing in this province.\n               We need to be addressing illegal firearms that are coming from the United States.\n               CSIS reports and other government reports show that over 95 percent of guns used in\n               crimes are illegal firearms coming from south of the border. We're also seeing a rise in 3D printed guns. Some federal legislation actually came\n               into effect in 2024 that helped us deal, at least legally, if people are caught with\n               either the plans or downloading or in possession of 3D printed guns. But this is an\n               emerging issue that actually will require us to have more resources. I'd like to see\n               dedicated resources going, even, to reviewing provincially and seeing some more analysis\n               on how often we're seeing these occurrences and what we can do to get ahead of this\n               problem. The third way in which illegal firearms are making their way into the hands of criminals\n               in this province is through straw buyers. That's where someone with a possession and\n               acquisition licence in our province buys firearms legally, but then illegally sells\n               them, gives them or distributes them otherwise to people who are not able to have\n               guns, who either are prohibited from having firearms or just simply don't have a possession\n               and acquisition licence. These are three fairly significant issues that I think that most British Columbians\n               would agree are a good investment in this at a time when, in my opinion, we have a\n               gun and firearm crisis in British Columbia. I've spent a lot of time speaking about mental health and crime because it's a huge\n               problem. So I'm going to skip ahead on some of my budget speech. I guess I'll move to something that I also found really disturbing in the budget.\n               That's the repacing — the cancellation, really — of some long-term-care projects.\n               Apart from very strongly advocating for better mental health policies, better drug\n               policies, law enforcement supports, health care is like, for all of us.... I think we\n               can all agree that we want to be able to provide British Columbians the best health\n               care possible, and we want it to be free and accessible for everybody. At the end of last year, the media had acquired from the Ministry of Health the statistics\n               on overcrowding in hospitals. They published at the end of last year, in the Tyee , a list of 20 hospitals. So last year, at the end of last year, the media had acquired from the Ministry of\n               Health the statistics on overcrowding in hospitals. And they published at the end\n               of last year in the Tyee a list of 20 hospitals in the province that consistently ran over 110 percent capacity.\n               The data also talked about how for all of those hospitals there is an average.... Between\n               10 and 15 percent of those beds in those hospitals have people who are awaiting an\n               alternate level of care. So whether it is some form of therapy that they need, they need to go for rehabilitation\n               services.... The most significant portion of those people are actually seniors waiting\n               for long-term care. So the list of 20.... It was a long list. Some of the most significant\n               were, for example, Abbotsford Regional Hospital, 128 percent beyond capacity; Chilliwack\n               General Hospital, 117 percent over capacity. These are consistently running, the average\n               for them. Delta Hospital, 128 percent on average over capacity. Surrey Memorial, on\n               average 115 percent over capacity. Abbotsford, Chilliwack and Delta are all locations where their long-term care facility\n               is re-paced. It's delayed. Or cancelled. It's indefinite. And this just doesn't make\n               sense. Because when we have hospitals that are over capacity this way, it doesn't\n               just impact the seniors who are waiting for care and their families. It impacts the\n               other patients in the hospital who are experiencing hallway medicine, overcrowding,\n               people who are actually in the emergency department but they can't go into another\n               department of the hospital because there's no bed. So they actually are forced to\n               stay in the hospital in the emergency department. I can't say that it's related, but we recently heard of a young person in Vernon,\n               at Vernon Jubilee who had taken themself voluntarily and were certified under the\n               Mental Health Act. And according to their family, because of no capacity in the psychiatric\n               unit, they were kept in the emergency room for six days before they walked out and\n               were hit by a vehicle and they died tragically. All of these issues, keeping people in the emergency department who need to go to\n               other spaces in the hospital.... All of this adds up. Not just for the patients, it's\n               the health care professionals too. And we're on a huge campaign, rightly so in British\n               Columbia, for recruiting and bringing doctors, nurses, going to the United States\n               to invite people to come and become British Columbians and work here in our province.\n               But to retain people, we have to make sure that we're addressing these capacity issues.\n               I mean, the math does not add up on delaying care. I see that I've dwindled my time down to five minutes. I'm going to go to another\n               topic in this budget that I found just absolutely confounding. My partner and I, Melissa,\n               we have a daughter who is very high functioning, but she has autism. And these changes\n               will take place starting in 2027. But I'm just really, really surprised and, frankly,\n               disappointed. I'm upset. I feel sad with the changes that are made to disability funding. The part I'm happy about is that more children with different diagnoses are included\n               under the umbrella of receiving services. And that's completely something that should\n               have probably happened a long time ago, to give more kids in B.C. a chance to be supported\n               and cared for by the government. But what this change does is it actually strips care away from kids who are considered\n               \"high functioning.\" But I can tell you as someone who has a child with autism who\n               is considered high functioning, that it was already difficult to find services. It's\n               very difficult to get approval for things even when you have funding. To know that potentially 10,000 families now can be without that extra funding that\n               might have been the little boost that their child needed is devastating. I'm in a position with my spouse or we're in a position where we may be able to help\n               our daughter more than other people. But that's not everybody. Even when there are\n               sliding scales, it is never painting a true picture of someone's financial situation. These cuts, even on a sliding scale, are going to disadvantage some kids. That is\n               unfortunate. I've received dozens upon dozens of emails and letters to my office.\n               I'm sure that other MLAs in this place also have. I hope that the government will\n               re-evaluate this program and this spending formula to make sure that every kid in\n               B.C. is getting the funding that they need. I have three minutes and 36 seconds left. So on Sunday, I went to the Chinatown parade in Vancouver to celebrate Lunar New Year.\n               Saw many of my colleagues, leaders in the Chinese community, Vancouver city council,\n               the mayor, lots of people down there. We went to a reception. In between the parade and the reception, one of my staff and\n               I decided to go for a coffee. We just went around the corner from the gardens, walked\n               in and the first thing we see is a fully uniformed security guard. That security guard\n               is employed. To be clear, we did walk through a gauntlet of people openly consuming drugs. I am\n               probably guessing that this individual is employed to keep people from coming inside\n               and causing a disturbance or stealing stuff. That's the reality that business owners\n               are dealing with. But how many cups of coffee do you think you have to sell to pay for a security guard\n               at a coffee shop? That is a lot of coffee. And now with changes to the PST, the government\n               is adding PST to the cost of having a security guard. I just find this absolutely\n               mind-blowing, mind-boggling that the government would.... It's created a situation through,\n               as I said earlier, underfunding in mental health services, underfunding in addiction\n               services, underfunding in a collaboration between our correctional institutions and\n               our law enforcement and health care, dealing with people with severe mental health\n               and addiction. They've created this perfect storm where the business community is facing rampant\n               shoplifting, people coming into their businesses causing a disturbance. We know London\n               Drugs is closing because their staff had feces being thrown at them, people threatening\n               them on a daily basis. They have to hire security. So the government's created this environment and now stands to profit off of the absolute\n               need that people have to hire security guards. Outrageous, outrageous. There's just so much in this budget that I've left unsaid here. But I hope that my\n               constituents can tell from my passion about what's really missing here, in terms of\n               spending and funding for core services that they say that they're protecting. It's a disappointment. I don't support this budget. I'm extremely disappointed in\n               the way that it lets some of the most vulnerable in our province down. Seniors, kids\n               with disabilities, people with severe mental illness, business owners, family members.\n               Name any person that lives in this province and I can guarantee there's a way that\n               Budget 2026 is letting them down. But I thank you for this opportunity to speak to the budget. I wish you well.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317209","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you for this opportunity to speak to Budget 2026. My constituents in Surrey-Cloverdale are diverse families. We have seniors and small businesses. We have business owners and leaders from large companies,\n               all of whom deserve a government that manages our province's finances responsibly This budget projects a staggering $13.3 billion deficit, the largest in British Columbia's\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["d2c936d0a28805d7220a3a52ba7ab7caf8add8ca1858b1686a8f13d58e35ede8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e302b02d1e3f10d7600912715608ccd638fda88d2ee76597468272dc272968a2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-de67c79450037dbd33b40eef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328051,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the Deputy Premier and Attorney General and her staff for the opportunity\n               to ask a few questions. I'd also like to just start off by thanking the employees, the government workers\n               who work under this ministry. A particular shout-out to B.C. Crown prosecutors because\n               I think that the work that they do can often be really complex, can be traumatizing\n               for those prosecutors to deal with some of the most serious criminal complaints and\n               prosecutions that our province has. I think sometimes we often think about first responders and the kinds of situations\n               they deal with on the front line. They're the first responders. But when they're dealing\n               with prosecutions, they're also experiencing that vicarious trauma. I'm grateful to\n               the work that they do. I'm grateful to everybody who, actually, decides to dedicate their life as a prosecutor\n               or a lawyer to working in the B.C. prosecution service. I think it goes unrecognized\n               at times, too, that lawyers can make a lot of money, probably a little bit more than\n               they make at the B.C. prosecution service, in certain jobs, but it's a dedicated calling\n               to want to work in our justice system. I thank every member out there who is doing\n               this work on behalf of the province. I have only a few different topics here, and I think I want to start off by asking\n               a little bit about bail reform. In December of 2023, the first set of federal bail\n               reforms, Bill C-48, the Bail and Sentencing Reform Act, received royal assent and\n               came into effect in January of 2024. Bill C-48 of 2023 was supposed to fix catch-and-release justice in B.C. The act was\n               going to make bail stricter and harder to get, including cases of repeat and violent\n               offending. It would also create new circumstances of reverse onus. When considering whether to grant bail, the amendments would direct police not to\n               release an accused when it's against the public interest or when detention is needed\n               to protect victims or witnesses. Courts would be required to consider specific factors,\n               including if the allegations involved random or unprovoked violence and if the accused\n               had any outstanding charges and set stricter conditions, including weapons bans. The changes would make clear that in reverse onus cases The changes would make clear that in reverse onus cases the courts must scrutinize\n               the bail plan of the accused who would be required to clearly demonstrate that their\n               plan was reasonable and credible to be released on bail. This act was also supposed to toughen sentencing laws for repeat and violent crimes,\n               including car thefts and extortion, meaning those found guilty could spend more time\n               in prison. Proposed amendments would require consecutive sentences for violent auto\n               thefts, and break and enter, and extortion and arson, and allow them for violent repeat\n               offending as well, meaning that one person could serve their sentence one after another\n               instead of serving their sentences for multiple offences at the same time. In March of 2024, the B.C. prosecution service released a report with further data\n               on bail. They reviewed 4,800 bail hearings between November 2022 and December of 2023.\n               They found that Crown counsel sought restrictive bail conditions in nearly three-quarters\n               of these hearings and sought detention in a quarter of the hearings. Judges ordered\n               detention, however, in less than half of these hearings, approximately 41 percent. Crown counsel sought pretrial detention in less than a third of bail hearings for\n               violent crimes and judges ordered detention in less than half of those cases, approximately\n               43 percent. Those stats came from the media statement and the information that was\n               released at the time by the B.C. prosecution service. The stats were compiled for the period of time actually just prior to the Bail and\n               Sentencing Reform Act of 2023 taking effect. And since that time, another bail reform\n               bill has been introduced in Parliament and Bill C-14, I believe, has passed its third\n               reading. So my question, based on this information, is: has a subsequent review of bail hearings\n               in British Columbia been conducted by the B.C. prosecution service, similar to the\n               one that was conducted in the period I just described, to gauge the effectiveness\n               of bail reform? And are there funds allocated in our 2026 budget to do this type of\n               assessment, given that we have further amendments coming?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328051","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the Deputy Premier and Attorney General and her staff for the opportunity\n               to ask a few questions. I'd also like to just start off by thanking the employees, the government workers\n               who work under this ministry. A particular shout-out to B.C. Crown prosecutors because\n               I think that the work that they do can often be really complex, can be trau","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Family violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public access","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence against women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data processing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Imprisonment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug laws","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Grants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Inmates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Fugitives from justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Literature","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Drug addiction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034570","label":"Community justice","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034572","label":"Community programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034584","label":"Fugitives from justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034769","label":"Data processing","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034911","label":"Drug addiction","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034922","label":"Drug laws","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035207","label":"Family violence","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035795","label":"Imprisonment","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035898","label":"Inmates","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036792","label":"Public access","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44374","label":"Violence against women","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.71,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501366","label":"Literature","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716722","label":"Grants","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718397","label":"Diseases","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4397db61293b51a3354c6d455b19eb7556e6a3b409b88d6ed8fd584010caa44b","c47fc47e03400b91058cd7fa5cd3d848679433039f34170f2ca719548f951c6e","364069a312ffae0d4463e8e9766b3f1ac11cb691c9ac216ee9aac2b83ff14ed5","c6d70d03e2452b673b1de5294c7f311dbe67fa8e6a00ecb96cbb3ab859200429"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["52aa062ef023f30e23560294636292421ea14ff5930810dc993ee0a9c20bc06f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4aee8189b109b25e7686bc17","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328052,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"Last year more than 6,000 babies were born at Surrey Memorial Hospital. The Mata Tripta\n               family birthing unit is an exceptional unit, but it was built to accommodate one family\n               per room. Now because of capacity issues, every room has been turned into a cramped\n               double room. Women are forced to share a toilet. The Mata Tripta family birthing unit is an exceptional unit, but it was built to accommodate\n               one family per room. Now, because of capacity issues, every room has been turned into\n               a cramped double room. Women are forced to share a toilet, impacting their privacy and infection control.\n               New moms are also getting less rest after giving birth now that there are two crying\n               newborns in every room. These overcrowded conditions are unacceptable and made worse\n               by maternity diversions from hospitals across the region. In 2024, Surrey residents were promised a new acute care tower to help alleviate the\n               strain on maternity services.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328052","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Last year more than 6,000 babies were born at Surrey Memorial Hospital. The Mata Tripta\n               family birthing unit is an exceptional unit, but it was built to accommodate one family\n               per room. Now because of capacity issues, every room has been turned into a cramped\n               double room. Women are forced to share a toilet. The Mata Tripta family birthing unit is an exc","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Maternity benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Persons with disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Infant care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Disabilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","label":"Birth","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035868","label":"Infant care","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036229","label":"Maternity benefits","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","label":"Women's health","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44816","label":"Persons with disabilities","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501208","label":"Disabilities","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:71241","label":"Infants","probability":0.73,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5822cd9a230adf98dcd9ab52b9ac778dca4f25ce2014943e8aee34c065c0819c"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.82,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["002529557ca08a064031c4616a9cbf640888eb838a46783657f12de355043f1a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Women's health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Birth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1016365","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037654","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8fa31e46cb3eadb11a537d07","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361022,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"She just said that she was saying to address the concerns of her constituents. She's\n               supposed to be addressing her concerns with the amendment to the motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361022","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"She just said that she was saying to address the concerns of her constituents. She's\n               supposed to be addressing her concerns with the amendment to the motion.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036101","label":"Legal rights","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["61357f78f6d42ca5fd0a35bf94455f9e1193a04760f1838088ba2a1d2255c9f0"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05dadc7927635f1afd1ac657","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415828,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to present a petition. I have a petition with over 500 signatures of Cloverdale\n               residents who oppose the construction of B.C. Hydro's Willoughby substation on residential\n               property in their neighbourhood.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415828","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise to present a petition. I have a petition with over 500 signatures of Cloverdale\n               residents who oppose the construction of B.C. Hydro's Willoughby substation on residential\n               property in their neighbourhood.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Watersheds","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Hydroelectric plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035761","label":"Hydroelectric plants","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47480","label":"Watersheds","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e36f8ede8422b4398c11410204eab9323d207b2ff3bd6f949d41b1135f306651"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-366aa338c8ddaf0c306a3c6c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415829,"date":"2026-04-02T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"On March 8, a patient suffering from a heart attack was en route from Surrey to Royal\n               Columbian by advanced life support ambulance when they were diverted due to a staffing\n               shortage. EHS was rerouted to Surrey Memorial Hospital, which does not provide the\n               same level of cardiac care as RCH, and the diversion cost precious minutes. The patient died. Perhaps they would be alive today if they were able to get treatment\n               at RCH's cardiac intensive care unit. Or if Surrey had these resources, perhaps their\n               chance of survival may have been higher. But that wasn't an option for them or any\n               other resident south of the Fraser. Even with the cath labs in Surrey, cardiac patients\n               in critical condition must be transported to access cardiac intensive care. My question is: when will this government deliver timely and equitable access to health\n               care for underserved communities south of the Fraser?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260402am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415829","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"On March 8, a patient suffering from a heart attack was en route from Surrey to Royal\n               Columbian by advanced life support ambulance when they were diverted due to a staffing\n               shortage. EHS was rerouted to Surrey Memorial Hospital, which does not provide the\n               same level of cardiac care as RCH, and the diversion cost precious minutes. The patient died. Perha","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","label":"Cardiovascular diseases"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Emergency relief","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","label":"Cardiovascular diseases","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034854","label":"Emergency relief","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["990e7c004259237e28c721c32c1f79f527fe8a2b1e54e0b80b3639377734104b"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["36526e50aaaed296ce2986791b3d6e21c823cb955fdd40e197cd4ea2e8ec3302"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Cardiovascular diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034396","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-71dbdf176176df4c7e027517","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720599,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to introduce the Amendment Act, which is on the order paper in my name, the\n               Interpretation Amendment Act, 2026. I ask that it be read a first time now. The Interpretation Amendment Act, 2026, aims to repeal section 8.1 of the Interpretation\n               Act. The Interpretation Act is a crucial piece of legislation in British Columbia\n               that outlines how laws should be interpreted and applied. It includes definitions\n               and rules that apply to all statutes and regulations in the province. In 2021 the\n               act was amended to include section 8.1, which makes it a legal requirement that every\n               act and regulation must be interpreted in a way that does not derogate from the declaration. Section 8.1 has already contributed to court decisions, including the Quw'utsun decision. While the Interpretation Act was not the only basis on which she reached her decision\n               on Cowichan Tribes v. Canada , Justice Young relied on this to support her conclusion that the Land Title Act does\n               not protect property owners from Aboriginal title claims. Her exact words were: \"I find support for the view that the indefeasibility provisions\n               in the LTA do not apply as against Aboriginal title in section 8.1 of the Interpretation\n               Act, which directs that legislation be interpreted in a manner that does not derogate\n               from Aboriginal rights. To construe it otherwise would also Interpreting all laws and regulations so that they must be consistent with the Declaration\n               on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act will fundamentally change how reconciliation\n               is carried out. It is taking the power away from negotiations with government and\n               placing it directly into the courts. For this reason, I believe section 8.1 of the\n               Interpretation Act must be repealed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720599","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise to introduce the Amendment Act, which is on the order paper in my name, the\n               Interpretation Amendment Act, 2026. I ask that it be read a first time now. The Interpretation Amendment Act, 2026, aims to repeal section 8.1 of the Interpretation\n               Act. The Interpretation Act is a crucial piece of legislation in British Columbia\n               that outlines how laws sh","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Land claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036065","label":"Land claims","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["33e8089c66162f6b43ce7a15a33d5408767ca0815a7ef9345092b02b7c5163c5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["00d327249138017cf65ec57f118f890e33b1b5ced133831af799a558b84a2cf4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1316dc3dfffb61f0bc8c0c4c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187136,"date":"2026-04-13T12:00:00+00:00","title":"INTERPRETATION AMENDMENT  ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m241-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m241-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187136","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8e96bbfefcdf1d409cfca8ca","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721700,"date":"2026-04-23T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise on a point of order, but I'm willing to wait until the end of the speech, if\n               that's preferred.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260423am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721700","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise on a point of order, but I'm willing to wait until the end of the speech, if\n               that's preferred.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous peoples","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42652","label":"Indigenous peoples","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44286","label":"Indigenous rights","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d1c1af5034957fee750976b0a9425e99b5f333b4b7de009e149a68315078c08f"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-7e211c30d0063b61b36df443","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729469,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I don't see them in the gallery yet but it does give me great pleasure to introduce\n               a group of visiting students from Simon Fraser's master of applied legal studies program,\n               also known as notary school. Each year, British Columbia commissions a small number\n               of new notaries who practice non-contentious law. I wish to highlight also the work of one of their professors, who is someone that\n               we see here in the chamber on a daily basis. He just finished instructing the most\n               recent notary cohort on wills, estates, personal planning, and he is, of course, the\n               member for Burnaby South–Metrotown. The students in the House today: we have Amy Niddle, Jody Lamb, Ashley Chong, Mackenzie\n               Anderson, Sarah Miller, Megan Cawthorn, and a familiar face, my CA, Sam Schaap. Will the House help me please make them feel welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729469","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I don't see them in the gallery yet but it does give me great pleasure to introduce\n               a group of visiting students from Simon Fraser's master of applied legal studies program,\n               also known as notary school. Each year, British Columbia commissions a small number\n               of new notaries who practice non-contentious law. I wish to highlight also the work of one of the","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Teachers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44387","label":"Teachers","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.83,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["b8756337afc9dbccb5f0b58de76bcea624b11835639a80426c0ed1b4d2bbbfab"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["829952f7c5bf1b9d7786d7b7fb9ac29d788767e65eef06ffb3a0d4f82aaa8245"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2df3544760d166253462bbe6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729471,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"In a ten-month period, 19 innocent people were murdered. Eleven people murdered at the Lapu-Lapu Day street festival last April. Eight murdered in Tumbler Ridge in February. The suspects in both horrific events had a history of involvement with B.C.'s mental health system. Mental health industry experts say systemwide changes are needed to respond to the structural gaps revealed by these cases and\n               prevent future tragedies. CMHA CEO Jonny Morris said: \"I think those tragic incidents can illuminate, within the mental health system\n               and also within mental health law, critical areas for investigation, review and improvement.\" Will the Premier commit to a review of B.C.'s mental health care system today?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729471","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"In a ten-month period, 19 innocent people were murdered. Eleven people murdered at the Lapu-Lapu Day street festival last April. Eight murdered in Tumbler Ridge in February. The suspects in both horrific events had a history of involvement with B.C.'s mental health system. Mental health industry experts say systemwide changes are needed to respond to the structural gaps revealed by these cases and","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Educational institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Students","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Health insurance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035639","label":"Health insurance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","label":"Mental health","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44363","label":"Students","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","label":"Crime","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:80924","label":"Educational institutions","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["6ed38afbafd0482e255ba9b39f537452b27e8f7a25a1081d8578842f23128149","d75798ef0c948b340a60b286b6530f862aa019ed35f656277a673d34799b81ef"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.4,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b82a974b417c82cdcfd9623a927c27d8c86075e06d2bfe7642caaf6ec8c1360c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Mental health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Crime","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41871","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501096","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2f84f2803639c1e6270ddbf8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752346,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday was the BMO Vancouver Marathon. With 25,000 participants from countries\n               all over the world, 9,499 of them did the actual marathon, including my spouse, Melissa.\n               My kids and I got up early in the morning to get behind all the traffic closures,\n               to be able to cheer her on. We're incredibly proud of her. Will the House join me in congratulating Melissa Sturko and everyone who participated\n               in the Vancouver Marathon.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752346","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Yesterday was the BMO Vancouver Marathon. With 25,000 participants from countries\n               all over the world, 9,499 of them did the actual marathon, including my spouse, Melissa.\n               My kids and I got up early in the morning to get behind all the traffic closures,\n               to be able to cheer her on. We're incredibly proud of her. Will the House join me in congratulating Me","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Child safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Road safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034451","label":"Child safety","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47414","label":"Road safety","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["112f2704a2754fea76d02eb274a9447189679ac6890f31554d62cd0dd552aae4"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-533c77412c5a3b031a726f0a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752347,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"Good morning, Madam Speaker. Thanks to my colleagues. I rise this early morning to speak to the hoist motion, which I do not support. I want to be clear. I won't be getting into the various amendments, or I won't be\n               getting into the different parts of the bill. But I would like to explain to my constituents,\n               perhaps, that might.... I don't probably think there are too many Elenore Sturko : I want to be clear. I won't be getting into the various amendments, or I won't be\n               getting into the different parts of the bill, but I would like to explain to my constituents,\n               perhaps, that might.... I don't, probably, think there are too many watching right now, but those who would\n               perhaps watch this through Hansard, maybe tomorrow or in the coming days.... I've done\n               my due diligence on this bill. I spoke with members of the government. I listened\n               to briefings, and I even went so far as to reach out to the independent office of\n               the Privacy Commissioner so that I myself could know a little bit more about how this\n               would work if one of my constituents, for example, which I'm sure they do on a regular\n               basis, would submit a freedom-of-information request or access to private information\n               from their own records or even from the record of somebody else. I think one of the things that's been missing from this debate and why I don't support\n               this motion is that in all cases where a request under FOIPPA would be denied, that\n               would go to the Privacy Commissioner, who is the head of an independent office here\n               in British Columbia. The decisions made by that independent officer are made using\n               case law from previous instances where requests have been denied, and it's also based\n               on just other jurisprudence from instances that this office, which is a very experienced\n               office, has dealt with. You'll have to pardon me for being a little bit tired, Madam Speaker. How it works is.... If someone puts in a request for information from a government body\n               or from the government and that request is denied, any British Columbian can actually\n               complain about that and can complain to the Privacy Commissioner and have that looked\n               at again and have the explanation as to why that request has been denied. They can also.... Or they should take heart in knowing that even with these new definitions,\n               that doesn't change. This legislation doesn't take away. This is something that I\n               actually really wanted to make sure that I would find out on behalf of my constituents\n               and other British Columbians before I would see this bill go to committee, which.... I do want it to go to committee, and I'm not ashamed of that, because I think that,\n               while not a perfect bill, there's room for amendment here and that there's also room\n               to ask important questions during the committee stage and have them answered, which\n               is something that we don't get to do even in second reading, as you know. When I wanted to find out more about this process.... What would happen if, for example,\n               someone put in a vexatious request or they were considered to be malicious? Even with\n               the new changes in the legislation, that decision is not made by a person, a head\n               of a government agency alone, because every request that would be not fulfilled by\n               government or by the governing body has to be approved by the independent Privacy\n               Commissioner. Those protections for British Columbians to make sure that they're not losing the\n               right to access to information but actually protecting government workers also from\n               the reality that sometimes people do put in vexatious requests or do sometimes not\n               provide enough information on what it is that they're seeking or sometimes do repetitive\n               requests.... This wouldn't even be the first time that those types of issues are being dealt with,\n               and that's why this hoist motion, which.... It does essentially kill this bill. It's\n               not about a delay. If you go into our standing orders, which every member in this House has, and actually\n               look at what that says.... And I know that my colleague from Penticton had read that\n               into the record and had spoken about that during her speech. You would see that this\n               kills it, and honestly, I don't think that that is a justifiable delay for British\n               Columbians, because I think that we have something workable here with this bill. Getting more understanding on behalf of my constituents that.... Look, nothing is changing.\n               The Privacy Commissioner still maintains that final say and has so much case law and\n               so much other jurisprudence surrounding these decisions. It's not an arbitrary decision.\n               They don't lack definitions. These things are defined, because there have been other\n               cases before where requests for information have been And those reasons.... If British Columbians want to have a look at what the legislation,\n               as it stands now, says and even have a look at what Bill 9 is proposing, they're actually\n               not that dissimilar. There's only a little bit of change in some of the wording. Some\n               of the wording I actually had some concerns with. During my ability to meet with the\n               minister and to express those concerns.... I think that there's some really good amendments\n               that have come forward that can address some of those concerns. I think the ultimate consideration for British Columbians really needs to be that\n               the oversight and the assurance that British Columbians need to be able to rely on\n               is the fact that we have the independent office of the Privacy Commissioner, who oversees\n               access to information, and legislation with respect to privacy is overseen by this\n               independent officer of British Columbia. That's not going to change. So I don't see any reason for us to kill this bill, which is what the hoist motion\n               does. I'm not supportive of killing the bill. I also don't see anything within the\n               legislation that would require us to have six months. I heard my colleague from Cariboo-Chilcotin. He had talked about some very compelling circumstances where people had issues getting\n               access to information, very important and personal information on issues that obviously\n               severely impacted them. I think that we need to look at those types of circumstances\n               and continue to work towards making it so that people can understand what happened\n               in those types of circumstances. But the changes that I've seen brought forward in Bill 9.... I don't think they're going\n               to impede people. I don't think that they will stop people from accessing. This isn't,\n               in my view, the doomsday bill as has been presented by members of the opposition.\n               This isn't an affront to democracy. It's some legislation that, in my opinion, modernizes\n               what we've had. I really respect, too, that the member of the Green Party worked on this legislation\n               decades ago. That is awesome to be able to work with someone with that much knowledge\n               about freedom of information and protection of privacy in this province. Some of the\n               pioneering legislation has been made by lots of different, cool people that I've actually\n               had the opportunity to work with. But sometimes we need to be able to modernize and change. We're in an extremely digital\n               environment right now. I just don't think, especially as we see AI make such a huge\n               impact on the province, that we should be delaying legislation that is workable legislation. So I'm not going to be supporting the hoist motion, because I want to be able to see\n               this go into committee. I think that we'll have the ability to actually.... Instead\n               of just standing here with dozens of ChatGPT speeches, how about asking some questions\n               and having them answered, maybe even adding some amendments that could satisfy members\n               of the opposition or improve, in ways that they might see, this legislation for their\n               constituents? But I think for me, the key here to why I'm going to not support the hoist and I want\n               to see this bill continue to progress in the House is that fundamentally, that oversight\n               on who really is overseeing whether or not a request for information is fulfilled\n               is with the Privacy Commissioner. Even with these changes, that oversight still remains,\n               and British Columbians can be assured that this isn't some trickery to somehow protect\n               people's reputations. If you're entitled to information, I think that it's important that we get it. Especially\n               if it can be used to.... I don't want to get into the realm of debating the bill, but\n               I'm one of the first ones who has demanded information from this government and not\n               gotten it at times and had to work really hard to be able to prove my points of things It was actually with a great deal of skepticism that I looked at this bill. You know,\n               I have every reason to be skeptical of a government that, in my opinion, hasn't been\n               as transparent as it should with some really critical files. But when it comes to\n               the oversight of making sure that people are treated fairly in terms of getting access\n               to information in this province, that doesn't change. The independent Office of the Privacy Commissioner is overseeing that. There's other\n               case law to refer to, so I want to see this bill progress. I'm not going to support\n               the hoist motion. I appreciate this time to speak.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752347","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Good morning, Madam Speaker. Thanks to my colleagues. I rise this early morning to speak to the hoist motion, which I do not support. I want to be clear. I won't be getting into the various amendments, or I won't be\n               getting into the different parts of the bill. But I would like to explain to my constituents,\n               perhaps, that might.... I don't probably think there are too","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Technological innovation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083666","label":"Technological innovation","probability":0.31,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","label":"Modernization","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ba02c649c53efe4bb3488a2774bfaa0520c165f3f37beb463c306ad4a98a4326"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["dee0e08d3b1f93f2cece9daf9d8d7264d40354e0b63503ef1bc34774fada3dff"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Modernization","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47622","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-af5c681809edf49e659a299c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017648,"date":"2026-05-19T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to ask questions about police services, if you need to take a five-minute\n               recess to get the other people back.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260519pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017648","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I would like to ask questions about police services, if you need to take a five-minute\n               recess to get the other people back.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Hazardous materials","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Harassment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Sexual offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Armed forces","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Violence","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Offences","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Gangs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Homicide","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035192","label":"Hazardous materials","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035437","label":"Gangs","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036511","label":"Offences","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037099","label":"Sexual offences","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42820","label":"Homicide","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43890","label":"Harassment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501254","label":"Violence","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:733676","label":"Armed forces","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a99fcd08b6f13b0a40c300fb89feddc6e0031b4c2c894e955861f32ed2afe738","7a99e73de600ce8f39c86ecbe71ab18b4b199a7e400f7acf3099f0827bf57e47"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6b5edae6529bd51f3676e1a4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017650,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise to speak in favour of the motion to not continue with second reading but to\n               refer Bill 20 to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I've put a lot\n               of thought into what I wanted to talk about, with regard to why I support this motion\n               and why I think it's important that we do that in this House. My remarks won't be long this afternoon, but I do think that they make important points.\n               I hope that it resonates with people from my community. I hope that it resonates with\n               the parties who are seeking to see this treaty ratified but also to those who have\n               taken issue with the ratification of the treaty. Specifically, I'm talking about the Wei Wai Kum First Nation. I did meet with their Chief Roberts. I did receive correspondence from the First\n               Nation as well, because they are raising concerns that they have with a dispute over\n               territory that is being claimed as the territory under the treaty that we are going\n               to legislate through Bill 20. It's also the traditional territory of the Wei Wai Kum. I'm going to just be really specific. At issue in this K'ómoks treaty, in the opinion of the Wei Wai Kum First Nation, is that it contains portions of land overlapping traditional territory.\n               The primary concern is that the Wei Wai Kum will be required to seek free, prior and informed consent on what they consider to\n               be their own territory. It has been expressed to me that this is already causing some disputes with a natural\n               resources project, a wind farm that is already in discussions and the planning phase.\n               Because of this dispute over territory, it's actually causing a problem already. There's\n               no framework in the treaty to resolve the dispute. Furthermore, if we pass this implementation legislation and the treaty is ratified,\n               First Nations who are in conflict over the territory that is overlapping within the\n               treaty agreement have already said that they would take immediate court action. I'm\n               not sure whether or not any other direct action by the First Nation will be taken.\n               As my friend and colleague the critic for Indigenous Relations had said, there has\n               been talk about blocking things like infrastructure, blocking railways, blocking highways,\n               blocking important trade corridors or ports. Nobody wants to see that. I think that is why it's of paramount importance that we support the motion to give\n               ourselves the opportunity, in this place, to have a better understanding of, first\n               of all, the process that went into trying to resolve the dispute between these First\n               Nations. I know that considerable effort was made on behalf of the Crown, on behalf\n               of First Nations, to resolve the dispute about this territory that's overlapping,\n               but despite the fact that it has been decades of negotiating this treaty, this still\n               hasn't been resolved. The point of having a treaty is so that we can have some measure of certainty. I think\n               that my colleagues in this place have done a good job, on both sides of the floor,\n               in expressing that certainty is something that we need to have, but passing legislation\n               that allows for the ratification of a treaty that in itself will become wrapped in\n               uncertainty because of immediate court action is not creating the certainty that we\n               would expect from this process. I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by\n               now in this place — is DRIPA. Of course, there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on\n               both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber, that there are serious legal I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by\n               now in this place — is DRIPA.... Of course there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on\n               both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber that there are serious legal\n               liabilities in this province related to DRIPA. When DRIPA was passed in 2019.... I think there have been consequences since then that\n               were probably not necessarily foreseen, especially the way after the 2021 implementation\n               of the Interpretation Act, section 8.1, that the courts would interpret DRIPA, taking\n               the negotiations out of the hands of government and putting those decisions into the\n               court. This government has said time and again that negotiations are best done nation to\n               nation, government to government, so that means the Crown at the federal level, that\n               means the Crown at the provincial level, working directly with First Nations, and\n               First Nations to First Nations. But if we ratify the treaty before this issue is resolved with the overlap of this\n               territory, then we're again going to be headed potentially into multi-million-dollar\n               legal action that will be drawn out for decades, that will have decades of uncertainty\n               attached to it, that at the end of the day will take that ability for negotiation\n               away and put it again back into the courts, which is something that this government\n               is actually trying to avoid. Our Attorney General talks about a durable solution and not wanting to have to see\n               things decided in the courts, which is the unintended consequence of section 8.1 of\n               the Interpretation Act. Having the courts decide the Gitxaała decision, making DRIPA the law of the land here so that basically the government's\n               hands are tied in terms of their ability to negotiate, and those things are dictated\n               by the courts. I don't think that that is where this government wants to go. They can correct me\n               if I'm wrong. I think that there is plenty of opportunity for members of the government\n               to dispute what I am saying, but it has been said over and again that we need certainty.\n               There is definitely legal liability with DRIPA, which is actually also a significant\n               part of the K'ómoks treaty. I think that we do not really know yet what the consequence of having that\n               as part of this treaty also involves.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017650","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise to speak in favour of the motion to not continue with second reading but to\n               refer Bill 20 to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I've put a lot\n               of thought into what I wanted to talk about, with regard to why I support this motion\n               and why I think it's important that we do that in this House. My remarks won't be long this afternoon","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"External relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034384","label":"External relations","probability":0.69,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","label":"Intergovernmental relations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","label":"Indigenous governments","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.72,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","label":"Indigenous affairs","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a56b33e795b22ae6655a2593d16ad5afc96426151b5af01ae473dd8415b5e2e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.64,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cf5e93699f85cd37e042ad5927f04f2fe7656c6d02554e0eb1c230c225a71440"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Intergovernmental relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous affairs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035234","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083680","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:64116","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-0fcc6fec06376b05bc45646b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017652,"date":"2026-05-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"My office has been inundated with letters from business owners and constituents who\n               are struggling to make ends meet. Rising costs are forcing businesses to put plans\n               for new hiring and expansion on hold, as spending habits change and sales decline. As financial pressures rise, this government is adding insult to injury by choosing\n               to add PST onto services that businesses are legally required to use. One constituent\n               said: \"It seems like this government is punishing small businesses for hiring accountants.\"\n               At a time when our economy is struggling, businesses and consumers need some good\n               news, and they need a helping hand. My question is to the Premier. Will he do the right thing and pause his plan to expand\n               the PST on October 1?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260521am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017652","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"My office has been inundated with letters from business owners and constituents who\n               are struggling to make ends meet. Rising costs are forcing businesses to put plans\n               for new hiring and expansion on hold, as spending habits change and sales decline. As financial pressures rise, this government is adding insult to injury by choosing\n               to add PST onto servi","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human beings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Elementary schools","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Outdoor recreation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","label":"Economic regulations","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035723","label":"Human beings","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036562","label":"Outdoor recreation","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44409","label":"Schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501364","label":"Income","probability":0.41,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:96208","label":"Elementary schools","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c64e776088e91be8daf478973aea289f8073385ce3cfe597e64f2eb88daab7f9","526d202d38612937fb850f4a1a96386e2ffa1fe8c1de246c3a014ba960190ed9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f55868e9d11c83c47c5374d7590c031d4adacd86873525b79beaa6a557088151"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034949","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-714f437d35d6445b2a20523d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036589,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Elenore Sturko","venue":"Hansard","text":"I want to join with the member for Richmond-Queensborough in welcoming Stalinjeet and Navpreet Gill and their son Gurmoh and his little sister,\n               who is five years old, to this Legislature. As my colleague mentioned, they walked from Canada Place in Vancouver all the way\n               here this morning to the B.C. Legislature. I had the opportunity to join them on the\n               last leg of that journey from the Gurdwara Singh Sabha Sahib. It was a really meaningful\n               walk. Not only are they raising funds for their son who needs treatment of his rare\n               genetic disorder, but also they have identified other gaps for families who are experiencing\n               the same thing dealing with rare diseases. I thank them so much for their advocacy. I thank them for their strength, for the\n               courage they're showing. I encourage all British Columbians to help out if they can. Would the House please join me in making them most welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036589","member_id":"bc-mla-82","member_name":"Elenore Sturko","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I want to join with the member for Richmond-Queensborough in welcoming Stalinjeet and Navpreet Gill and their son Gurmoh and his little sister,\n               who is five years old, to this Legislature. As my colleague mentioned, they walked from Canada Place in Vancouver all the way\n               here this morning to the B.C. Legislature. I had the opportunity to join them on the\n               ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Volunteer work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037526","label":"Volunteer work","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","label":"Fundraising","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5430ca50718a2930991534e00c6c80d8614c5608d257a31a6438b3e3e70bccc3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1947bacedaa45c1aedbd104a48121d67812812d293c07e279a991f411bccbbd9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fundraising","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718485","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-e238faee2aec45b849b1e7e1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317222,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"Yesterday marked Yan Yat, the seventh day of the lunar new year, traditionally known\n               as \"everyone's birthday\" — including all of you. For centuries, people have observed\n               everyone's birthday by wishing one another health","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317222","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Yesterday marked Yan Yat, the seventh day of the lunar new year, traditionally known\n               as \"everyone's birthday\" — including all of you. For centuries, people have observed\n               everyone's birthday by wishing one another health","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Social development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Peace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43088","label":"Peace","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.83,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:867","label":"Health","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87498","label":"Social development","probability":0.21,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["875b191d2a5ee2d1d143c3f474c148f3a2d230368c2f21b8a27f892ed28546d0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["94f3ae5748fc2747fe8b29040b7b79d5cde78b318a303f9acc16992e6da79cc7"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-fe3487c0b50775059c8aa2e9","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317223,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 5, the Trade Recognition Act. In plain language, this bill is meant to make it easier for goods and services that\n               are legally sold or supplied in other provinces to be sold or supplied here in British\n               Columbia. The idea is mutual recognition, to cut down on duplicate certifications,\n               duplicate approvals and needless barriers that make it harder for businesses to expand\n               and harder for consumers to benefit from real competition. We support that concept. We support the goals of reducing interprovincial trade barriers\n               and making Canada's internal market work better for British Columbians. That is good\n               for workers, it is good for businesses that want to grow, and it is good for families\n               who have been paying too much for too long, but supporting the concept does not mean\n               giving this bill a free pass. We have questions about the mechanics. We have questions about how this will actually\n               work in practice, especially given the significant discretion that is left to regulation\n               and implementation, and we have questions about whether this government is prepared\n               to do the hard follow-through required for a bill like this to deliver real We have questions about whether this government is prepared to do the hard follow\n               through required for a bill like this to deliver real-world results. It is also impossible to discuss Bill 5 without discussing the context because the\n               government is not arriving at this issue fresh. Bill 5 comes in the shadow of Bill\n               7, which was one of the primary pieces of legislation in this House last year. Bill 7 was introduced with a lot of urgency and a lot of tough talk, including demands\n               for aggressive powers in the name of immediate action. People will remember what happened\n               next. Bill 7 landed with sweeping language and sweeping authority. It immediately\n               triggered widespread concern about overreach and a lack of legislative oversight.\n               Critics warned it went far beyond a targeted tariff response. Then, as the backlash grew, the Premier publicly walked back a major chunk of the\n               bill, announcing the removal of what many describe as the most extraordinary section\n               and acknowledging it did not strike the right balance between fast action and democratic\n               safeguards. When the government now comes forward with Bill 5 and asks the House to trust the\n               follow through, it is fair and necessary to remember the Bill 7 pattern. Urgent rhetoric\n               first, controversy second, retreat third, and still very little evidence of real-world\n               action that matches the scale of the powers they demanded. Bill 7 was sold to this province as urgent. It was wrapped in emergency language,\n               moral certainty and a promise of decisive action. Then, after all that noise, British\n               Columbians have seen basically nothing. We are still awaiting evidence that this government used those aggressive powers to\n               drive meaningful regulatory changes. We are still awaiting evidence that this government\n               actually followed through in a serious way on the procurement rhetoric that surrounded\n               Bill 7. We are still awaiting proof that this government did more than posture. That is why\n               we keep coming back to Bill 7. Under Bill 7, this government insisted it needed extraordinary tools because everything\n               was urgent. Fine. But where is the public scoreboard? Could specific regulatory measures\n               actually change using those powers? Could barriers actually be removed? Could ministries\n               issue directives and follow them through? Where is the evidence that procurement rules\n               were materially altered in a way that actually changed purchasing decisions on the\n               ground? We heard the tough talk. We saw the controversy. We watched the retreat. What British\n               Columbians have not seen is transparent proof of results. If this government wants\n               trust on Bill 5, it needs to start by showing that it used the powers it already asked\n               for. This matters to Bill 5, because Bill 5 is another bill where this government will\n               make big claims and then ask British Columbians to trust that the follow through will\n               come later. But British Columbians have learned that later too often means never or not in any\n               way that changes life outside this chamber. So yes, we will support this bill. We\n               will support it because we agree with the objective. But we will also insist on something\n               that this government Now let's turn to what Bill 5 actually does. At its core, Bill 5 creates a mutual\n               recognition rule. Goods and services that are legally sold or supplied in another\n               province can generally be sold or supplied here. This should reduce formal entry barriers.\n               It should help some businesses avoid duplicative testing, duplicative approvals and\n               duplicative certification. It is also worth noting that industry has identified some positive features of this\n               bill. One is that it makes mutual recognition permanent and removes the uncertainty\n               of a sunset clause. Businesses plan investments and expansions based on stable frameworks\n               and temporary measures that could disappear. Another is that it is unilateral. It does not depend on B.C. negotiating reciprocity\n               agreements province by province. It is a default approach that, in theory, should\n               lower barriers more quickly. Industry also pointed out that Bill 5 generally aligns B.C. law with the Canadian\n               mutual recognition agreement, CMRA, framework, which is a direction many in the business\n               community support. All of that is constructive, but the strongest areas for focus is what is not included,\n               what is not guaranteed and what may still prevent real market access, even if paper\n               entry becomes easier. Because there is a risk, and it is a real one, that Bill 5 makes\n               entry easier on paper while leaving practical barriers in place. This is where it\n               helps to separate two concepts that get mashed together in government talking points. The first is formal market entry. Can a product be sold here at all? Can a service\n               be supplied here at all? The second is practical market access. Can a company actually operate here in a commercially\n               realistic way? Can it distribute? Can it market? Can it meet licensing rules? Can\n               it navigate retail restrictions? Will enforcement practices effectively block it anyway? Bill 5 focuses heavily on the first concept, but the bill also very explicitly preserves\n               B.C.'s authority over post-entry rules. Under division 2, particularly sections 4\n               and 5, the bill preserves B.C.'s authority over how goods and services are sold, used\n               or delivered once they are in the market. It also contains carve-outs, including monopolies,\n               taxes, Indigenous Peoples and incorporation. Now, there are legitimate reasons to preserve some post-entry rules. Nobody wants\n               mutual recognition to override local rules in assertive ways. But as industry has flagged, the way section 4 is written can operate as an escape valve. If post-entry rules are interpreted broadly, then barriers may simply relocate rather\n               than disappear, so a business may avoid a redundant certification requirement at the\n               front end, but still face a maze of operational requirements once inside — distribution\n               rules, licensing rules, retail rules, marketing rules and enforcement practices that\n               still shape whether it makes commercial sense to serve B.C. Entry may be easier on paper, but practical market assets can still depend on those\n               operational rules and their enforcement. Entry may be easier on paper, but practical market assets can still depend on those\n               operational rules and their enforcement. Here is what I mean by the difference between\n               paper entry and practical assets. Imagine a small manufacturer in Alberta that makes a building product, something boring\n               but essential, like insulation, fasteners or components used in HVAC. If it is already\n               lawfully sold there, mutual recognition should mean they do not have to redo the same\n               testing and certification just to serve customers in B.C. That is the promise. But if, once the product is in, they face a thicket of post-entry requirements around\n               distribution, labelling, retail rules and approvals that functions like a second gate,\n               the practical outcome is the same: higher costs, fewer suppliers and less competition.\n               We can pass a bill and declare the door is open, but if the hallway is still blocked,\n               families and businesses will not see lower prices. On services, think about a specialized service that businesses rely on, like equipment\n               inspection, technical maintenance or certain kinds of consulting. If a firm can legally\n               supply that service in another province, mutual recognition should help them offer\n               it here without running into duplicate hurdles. That could mean more competition and\n               better pricing for B.C. businesses. But again, if the post-entry rules around licensing, permitted scope of work or who\n               can serve whom are interpreted broadly, then recognition becomes theoretical again.\n               A company may be allowed to supply the service but not in a way that is commercially\n               workable. That is why the mechanics matter and why section 4 must not become a loophole. That is a key point. The government will be tempted to declare victory the moment\n               this bill passes, but businesses do not live in the statute bulk. They live in day-to-day\n               operations. If this government wants to claim this bill reduces barriers, it needs\n               to prove that those post-entry rules are not being used to preserve the same obstacles\n               under a different label. Now, this is also where the comparison to Bill 7 matters again. A key difference between\n               the interprovincial trade framework that was being discussed in Bill 7 and what is\n               being done in Bill 5 is how regularly change is likely to happen. Bill 7 pushed regulators\n               toward amending or removing rules that conflicted with the recognition framework.\n               It was more forceful, more aggressive. That was part of why it triggered push-back. Bill 5 keeps a similar tool. Ministers can still ask regulators to change rules and\n               can step in if they do not. But Bill 5 also explicitly preserves B.C.'s authority\n               over how goods and services are sold or delivered once they are in the market. So\n               the extent of regulatory change will depend on how broadly those post-entry rules\n               are interpreted and how actively ministers actually use these powers to resolve conflicts. Let me put that in one sentence because it is the heart of this critique. Bill 5 may\n               open the door, but it does not guarantee the hallway is not still blocked. Now, there's another theme we need to put on the record. Limitations remain even under\n               the national mutual recognition approach. There are major categories that have been\n               excluded or limited under the CMRA Now, there's another theme we need to put on the record. Limitations remain even under\n               the national mutual recognition approach. There are major categories that have been\n               excluded or limited under the CMRA framework, including categories like food, live\n               animals, alcoholic beverages, cannabis, tobacco and plants. In addition, governments\n               can adopt specific carve-outs that allow them to retain requirements in areas they\n               choose to exempt, listed under annex A in the CMRA agreement. If the government wants to talk about affordability, it should also acknowledge that\n               this bill will not touch some of the categories that matter most to the cause families\n               feel every week. And if this government wants to talk about leadership, it should\n               also explain what carve-outs B.C. intends to give and why and how we will ensure those\n               carve-outs do not become permanent excuses for inaction. Trade barriers are not just about whether something is allowed in theory. They are\n               about whether something is allowed in practice. That brings me to another missing\n               piece — trucking and logistics. Trade is movement. Goods do not magically teleport\n               between provinces. If we do not align rules that affect interprovincial trucking and\n               the movement of goods, then internal trade remains expensive and fragmented, regardless\n               of the legal framework. Industry is telling us B.C. has not clearly signalled intent to join the MOU partnership\n               on interprovincial trucking. If that is true, it raises a basic question for this\n               government: is B.C. serious about reducing internal trade costs or is B.C. only serious\n               about passing bills that sound good only? If B.C. is engaged, what's the timeline and what changes will British Columbians actually\n               see? If B.C. is not engaged, why not? Now, I want to return to section 4 because this is where the mechanics really matter.\n               Section 4 appears to preserve government's ability to regulate products and services\n               after they have entered the province. There are legitimate reasons for some post-entry\n               rules, to prevent absurd results and protect public interest. But as industry has\n               highlighted, section 4 is broadly written. Let me linger on section 4 for a moment, because this is where a lot of the real-world\n               impact will be decided. I understand why the government wants a provision like this.\n               You do not want mutual recognition to accidentally override sensible local rules.\n               But if post-entry is defined too broadly, it becomes an escape valve that can preserve\n               almost any barrier so long as someone can describe it as operational. That is exactly\n               how you end up with reform that looks bold on paper but feels unchanged in practice. So when I ask the minister about the intended boundary of section 4, I'm not asking\n               for a weak reassurance. I'm asking for clarity that business can plan around and that\n               this Legislature can hold this government to. So I want to put clear questions to the minister and invite answers either in this\n               debate or at committee. First, what is the intended boundary between an entry barrier that is overwritten\n               by mutual recognition and a post-entry rule that is preserved? Second, will the government publish guidance to regulators on how section 4 is meant\n               to be interpreted so that it does not become the escape hatch that swallows the reform? Third, does the government agree that a post-entry rule that has the practical effect\n               of Third, does the government agree that a post-entry rule that has the practical effect\n               of blocking market participation should be treated as a trade barrier and addressed\n               under this framework? Fourth, how will conflicts be identified and resolved? Will there be a transparent\n               process so businesses can see which barriers were raised, which barriers were removed,\n               and why? Fifth, when ministers request regulators to amend or remove measures, will those requests\n               be made public with reasons so British Columbians can see whether this bill is driving\n               real change. Those are not hostile questions. They are the basic questions that determine whether\n               this is meaningful reform or just a change in branding. Because again, Bill 7 is a\n               credibility test. This government demanded aggressive powers under Bill 7, framed\n               it as urgent and then retreated when controversy erupted. And British Columbians have\n               yet to see convincing evidence that those powers produce real change. So, this government\n               does not get to ask for another leap of faith. It gets scrutiny. It gets conditions.\n               It gets questions on the record. It gets a demand for proof. Now I want to bring this back to the people this bill should help. This matters to\n               workers. An apprentice who wants to follow work should not be told that skills are\n               valid in one province and suddenly questionable in another. This matters to small-\n               and medium-sized businesses. A manufacturer or service provider should not have to\n               pay for duplicate testing or duplicate approvals that do not add safety but do add\n               cost. This matters to consumers. Competition is how you get better pricing and better choice.\n               In a time when families are watching every single dollar, government should not defend\n               duplication and friction that in freight costs. This matters to the broader economy.\n               A province that is serious about growth does not tolerate barriers, that separates\n               Canadians from Canadians. So we will support Bill 5 because we agree with that direction. But we will also be\n               honest about the government's track record and the risk that this bill becomes cautious,\n               symbolic and incomplete. Now let me be constructive and specific about what we expect from this government\n               to ensure Bill 5 is more than a slogan. First, an implementation plan with dates,\n               not an open-ended by regulation, a clear schedule. Second, transparency on exclusions\n               and carve-outs. Publish what is excluded, what is exempted and why before the bill\n               comes into force, not after. Third, measurable reporting. How many barriers were identified?\n               How many were removed? How many conflicts were resolved? How many regulatory changes\n               were made? If this government claims this reduces costs, show the scoreboard. Fourth, guidance on section 4. Define the boundary, constrain the loophole and make\n               it clear that barriers cannot simply be re-labelled as operational to avoid mutual\n               recognition. Fifth, disclosure of ministerial interventions. If ministers are going\n               to ask regulators to change rules, disclose it. If they step in, disclose it. If this\n               government is using strong power, it should not be invisible. And finally, a review clause If this government agrees to those commitments, it will go a long way toward building\n               confidence that Bill 5 is real, because without those commitments, the risk is obvious.\n               The government will pass a bill, declare victory, and then implementation will be\n               slow, quiet and limited. British Columbians, unfortunately, will be left with another\n               statute that sounds strong and delivers little. This is exactly what many people believe\n               happened with Bill 7. I will close with this. We will support Bill 5 because British Columbians benefit\n               when we reduce internal barriers and improve competition. But we will not pretend\n               this government has earned trust on implementation. We will not allow them to rewrite\n               history on Bill 7. We will not let them claim urgency when their track record has\n               been sound and fury followed by silence. We will support this bill for British Columbians,\n               and we will demand the follow-though that this government has too often failed to\n               deliver.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317223","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 5, the Trade Recognition Act. In plain language, this bill is meant to make it easier for goods and services that\n               are legally sold or supplied in other provinces to be sold or supplied here in British\n               Columbia. The idea is mutual recognition, to cut down on duplicate certifications,\n               duplicate approvals and needless barriers","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47811","label":"Legal services","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.46,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["551a2611aa9b9442b8d4c44a931e075e040fe6b9d8595b42b450be1d43593a90"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["23bdefed5ef39a81e221df04cf9eabb9f8052292df685b081cb8257c00528399"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-23d471c69f9ad254f674f0fa","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328069,"date":"2026-03-03T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"Just now, the minister was saying that 52 cases were asked by the callers to report\n               to the police. I know that the minister told me that this will be handled by the Solicitor\n               General. But I still want to ask: of these 52 cases, how many of them are actually hate crimes,\n               and how many of them are just discriminatory in nature?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260303pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328069","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Just now, the minister was saying that 52 cases were asked by the callers to report\n               to the police. I know that the minister told me that this will be handled by the Solicitor\n               General. But I still want to ask: of these 52 cases, how many of them are actually hate crimes,\n               and how many of them are just discriminatory in nature?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Multiculturalism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Fiscal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035273","label":"Fiscal issues","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42515","label":"Multiculturalism","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501259","label":"Construction","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cfb9885e35a108b50c5667a93376f8227c0d80e485368b7563122a21d3369a64"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-948c8d77fea414c3b466cc6e","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361203,"date":"2026-03-10T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would also like to join our members in welcoming the Centre for Israel and Jewish\n               Affairs, in particular my two good friends Nico Slobinsky, the vice-president of the\n               Pacific region, and David Decolongon, associate director of policy and communication\n               for the Pacific region. David is no stranger to this building. Earlier in his career, he served as a caucus\n               researcher, and it's always nice to see familiar faces continuing their work in public\n               policy and community engagement. Since I was elected in 2013, I have had the privilege of working with Nico at CIJA\n               to learn more about the Jewish community and the important issues that matter to them.\n               I'm very proud of the work they do to strengthen understanding, advocacy and dialogue\n               in our province and across Canada. Please join me in warmly welcoming Nico and David to this chamber.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260310am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361203","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I would also like to join our members in welcoming the Centre for Israel and Jewish\n               Affairs, in particular my two good friends Nico Slobinsky, the vice-president of the\n               Pacific region, and David Decolongon, associate director of policy and communication\n               for the Pacific region. David is no stranger to this building. Earlier in his career, he served as a ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regional cooperation","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Two-spirit people","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037431","label":"Two-spirit people","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083663","label":"Regional cooperation","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["92d5f637d815a5402abcadb67cc025d5f69a3481a224966f933e951106b60ae1"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-be0782c1699e78312f31b944","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":361204,"date":"2026-03-12T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"The legislative director for B.C. CFIB: \"When we talk to small businesses around the\n               province, one thing is clear. The cost of doing business is too high.\" Small businesses\n               are telling this government exactly what will happen. Higher costs for them mean higher\n               prices for everyone. Instead of listening, this NDP government is choosing to ignore\n               them. My question is to this NDP government. Why do they keep ignoring small businesses\n               and making life more expensive for British Columbians?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260312am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:361204","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"The legislative director for B.C. CFIB: \"When we talk to small businesses around the\n               province, one thing is clear. The cost of doing business is too high.\" Small businesses\n               are telling this government exactly what will happen. Higher costs for them mean higher\n               prices for everyone. Instead of listening, this NDP government is choosing to ignore\n         ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","label":"Businesses","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","label":"Small businesses","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["89edb4a88658dc6b2c09a1227ce06f8ab9110f9abe30d22a008807036b3dd8c9"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c871f4de4f2613f0701e489944aa36cdef72d459f7aa05496e49b6dad52e0b76"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Small businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Businesses","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083618","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083629","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4766ed3286efb77fba95a52f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415849,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"We are now only two days away from April 1, the day on which the website of the College\n               of Complementary Health Professionals of British Columbia states, and I quote: \"Prescribing\n               herbal formula will be removed as a restricted activity,\" and then asks, I quote,\n               \"Does it mean unregulated persons can prescribe herbal formula?\" And the answer given\n               is: yes. In plain terms, the public is being told that prescribing traditional Chinese medicine\n               herbal formula would no longer be a restricted activity. This is deeply concerning.\n               This situation highlights a broader pattern that British Columbians have seen too\n               often, decisions that lack clarity, disregard front-line expertise and create confusion for the public. It defies common sense to suggest\n               that unregulated individuals could prescribe herbal formula. This is not a minor or\n               technical issue. It goes directly to patient safety, professional standards and public\n               confidence in our health care system. Equally troubling is the fact that the traditional Chinese medicine community has\n               been raising concerns as early as February 2024. These are trained professionals working\n               on the front lines, yet their voices were not meaningfully addressed for an extended\n               period. Two months ago in a media interview, the minister stated, and I quote, \"I understand\n               there's been some misunderstanding and confusion about the way the new ordinance is\n               laid out, which is why it's very important we do the work together with the college\n               and with practitioners to understand what changes might be needed in order to provide\n               clarity.\" But if concern were raised as early as February 2024, why did it take a public rally\n               for these issues to receive serious attention? Why are we only now hearing about the\n               need for clarity? The concerns expressed by the traditional Chinese medicine community\n               were not hypothetical. They were based on the wording published by the college itself.\n               So it is fair to ask, where does the responsibility for this confusion lie? Even now, conflicting messages persist. On the day of the traditional Chinese medicine\n               rally, when the petition was delivered to the Premier's office, the minister stated\n               publicly that individuals without appropriate training are not able to prescribe Chinese\n               herbal formula. However, the college's website continues to state clearly and unequivocally\n               that prescribing herbal formula will no longer be a restricted activity and that unregulated\n               persons can do so. Only afterwards does it note that the ministry has been directed to make\n               regulatory changes to clarify that such activities should remain restricted to licensed\n               practitioners. But April 1 is only two days away, and the public is being told that these regulatory changes are still in progress. What then is the public supposed to believe? If\n               an unregulated individual were to prescribe traditional Chinese medicine herbal remedies\n               on April 1 If an unregulated individual were to prescribe traditional Chinese medicine herbal\n               remedies on April 1, would that \"yes\" on the college's website shield them from responsibility,\n               from accountability, if harm were caused? This is not a matter of semantics. It is an immediate and practical concern. It is\n               about patient safety, the integrity of professional regulation and maintaining public\n               trust. I'm calling on the Minister of Health and the College of Complementary Health Professionals\n               of of British Columbia to issue without delay a clear and joint written statement\n               confirming that as of April 1, unregulated individuals are not permitted to prescribe\n               traditional Chinese herbal medicine.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415849","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"We are now only two days away from April 1, the day on which the website of the College\n               of Complementary Health Professionals of British Columbia states, and I quote: \"Prescribing\n               herbal formula will be removed as a restricted activity,\" and then asks, I quote,\n               \"Does it mean unregulated persons can prescribe herbal formula?\" And the answer given\n       ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036256","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Medicinal plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036256","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Medicinal plants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Drugs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034927","label":"Drugs","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036256","label":"Medicinal plants","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["2465af1453c9b8dd0632f651a4c99e0653cef2b1d8db1e9293ea88de9c8f6736"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a5d0f22e01f337abcd9a402e7e59b2bbdc655a8ec39744315c2c541ad8a68697"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-56ac3a17515ce18b1fe8c71d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415850,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"Despite the fact that the Jobs Minister is trying to paint a rosy picture of what\n               this government has done, the fact is that B.C. lost 33,000 full-time jobs in February\n               alone. That's over 40 percent of all monthly job losses in the whole country. B.C.\n               is supposed to be a leader, not in unemployment growth. The only thing this Minister of Jobs has overseen since he took over this portfolio\n               are job losses. It seems the only job he focuses on is the one he hopes to get next. When is this government going to abandon its job-killing agenda and keep British Columbians\n               gainfully employed in B.C.?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415850","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Despite the fact that the Jobs Minister is trying to paint a rosy picture of what\n               this government has done, the fact is that B.C. lost 33,000 full-time jobs in February\n               alone. That's over 40 percent of all monthly job losses in the whole country. B.C.\n               is supposed to be a leader, not in unemployment growth. The only thing this Minister of Jobs has overse","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","label":"Labour market","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","label":"Economy","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","label":"Unemployment","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["78df7b3941526f0a54fceb7c79af61f3d3cb298be8e66ad236b229e3c46b5109"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8319d5b1dd837523fbe897cb2ae2f9820a726ab322284f96ce3b93484c2affb2"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour market","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unemployment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43478","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501192","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721235","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ce6a49065ef108fcda3c48e5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415851,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognise Qingming festival, also known as Tomb Sweeping Day. This\n               year, Qingming falls on Sunday, April 5, a time when families gather to honour their\n               ancestors, reflect on their roots and express gratitude for those who came before\n               them. Qingming is a tradition that spans generations. It is a moment of remembrance, of\n               respect and of connection between past and present. It reminds us that the opportunities\n               we have today are built on the sacrifices of others. Here in B.C., Chinese Canadians have a long and profound history, one marked by resilience,\n               perseverance and contribution in the face of hardship. In the 19th century, thousands\n               of Chinese labourers came to Canada and played a crucial role in building the Canadian\n               Pacific Railway, a project that helped unite the country from coast to coast. They\n               worked under dangerous conditions, often for no wages, and many lost their lives.\n               Yet their contributions were essential to the foundation of modern Canada. Beyond the railway, Chinese-Canadian pioneers have built communities, established small businesses and contributed to the economic\n               and cultural fabric of B.C. Despite facing discrimination, including the head tax\n               and exclusion laws, they remained steadfast and determined to build a better future\n               for their families and for this province. Today this legacy lives on in these vibrant and diverse communities across our province.\n               As we mark Qingming festival, we honour not only our ancestors but also the pioneers\n               whose courage and sacrifice helped shape who we are today. Their stories are part\n               of B.C.'s story. Let's take this moment to reflect, to remember and to express our gratitude.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415851","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to recognise Qingming festival, also known as Tomb Sweeping Day. This\n               year, Qingming falls on Sunday, April 5, a time when families gather to honour their\n               ancestors, reflect on their roots and express gratitude for those who came before\n               them. Qingming is a tradition that spans generations. It is a moment of remembrance, of\n               re","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Unpaid work","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.42,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:77502","label":"Unpaid work","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["346c8516ff5e4114622b9278192c5d00206bc62459addab39849cecdc539d5d4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["833823c95b2b580dbfc8783f88cbfccca9ae931cc19e8747041360e672814e08"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b23c3519ae8a682b6d9d00ef","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415853,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Worship Act. At the heart of this discussion is a fundamental principle. No person in British Columbia\n               should ever feel intimidated, harassed or fearful when walking into their place of\n               worship. It is about dignity, fundamental freedoms and the kind of province we want\n               to be. Yet for many British Columbians today — members of Jewish, Muslim, Sikh, Christian,\n               Hindu and other faith communities — their sense of safety is no longer guaranteed.\n               What should be a place of peace has for some become a place What should be a place of peace has for some become a place of anxiety. We are seeing\n               tensions, often driven by global conflicts, spill out of the public square and onto\n               the doorstep of our most sacred spaces. As a Buddhist myself, who regularly pays respects to many temples in my riding across\n               Richmond, I feel truly blessed to have never experienced any harassment when visiting\n               a place of worship. In our beautiful province, one that has long upheld the values of inclusion, peace,\n               freedom of religion and freedom of assembly, it is deeply concerning to know that\n               some faith communities do not feel safe when walking into their own places of worship.\n               Everyone deserves to feel secure, respected and welcome in spaces meant for reflection,\n               faith and community. As noted at by political commentator Rob Shaw in his recent coverage, governments\n               are increasingly being called upon to act when protest activity crosses the line from\n               lawful expression into intimidation and disruption. That observation reflects what\n               many British Columbians are seeing firsthand: a growing tension between the right\n               to protest and the right to feel safe in deeply personal spaces. Let's be clear. Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of our democracy. It allows\n               Canadians to speak, to protest and to challenge authority, but it is not absolute.\n               It does not include the right to obstruct access. It does not include the right to\n               harass. It does not include the right to deny others the peaceful exercise of their\n               own freedoms. Freedom of religion is equally protected. When individuals are forced\n               to pass through intimidation to attend worship, their rights are being compromised. The principle behind Bill 13 is sound. It responds to calls from faith leaders across\n               British Columbia. It proposes access zones, commonly referred to as bubble zones,\n               to prevent obstruction, harassment and intimidation near places of worship. We have precedent for this approach. Courts in British Columbia have already upheld\n               similar protections in the context of abortion access, recognizing that while expression\n               is protected, reasonable limits are justified when necessary to protect vulnerable\n               individuals and ensure safe access to lawful services. Bill 13 extends that concept to religious spaces. It will allow eligible places of\n               worship to establish clearly marked access zones — typically would be a 20-metre perimeter\n               where specific harmful behaviour would be prohibited. Police would be empowered to\n               issue tickets or make arrests, including without a warrant, where there are reasonable\n               grounds to believe the law is being contravened. The bill also includes a sunset clause\n               in 2030, acknowledging that these are targeted measures responding to a specific and\n               concerning moment. But principle alone is not enough. The true test of this legislation will not be how\n               it is written. It will be how it is enforced. Because legislation without enforcement\n               is not protection; it is symbolism. We must confront that reality directly. Commentary in British Columbia public discourse, including analysis from voices like\n               Rob Shaw, has pointed out that laws governing protest activity often face real-world\n               challenges when it comes to consistent enforcement. Drawing lines in legislation is\n               one thing. Applying them fairly, clearly and consistently on the ground is another. First, there is the issue of clarity. Enforcement depends on definitions that are\n               precise and understandable not just to legal experts but to frontline officers and\n               the general public. What constitutes intimidation? When does a protest become obstruction?\n               These are decisions that must often be made in real time in What constitutes intimidation? When does a protest become obstruction? These are decisions\n               that must often be made in real time in emotionally charged environments. If those\n               thresholds are unclear, enforcement becomes hesitant. If officers are unsure where\n               the line is, they may default to inaction. And if enforcement varies from one situation\n               to another, public confidence will erode. There is also the issue of consistency. Laws like this rely heavily on police discretion.\n               Without clear guidance and provincewide standards, that discretion can lead to uneven\n               outcomes. One community may see strong enforcement while another does not. That is\n               not just a legal issue; it is a question of trust. We must consider scope. The bill's reliance on tax-exempt status and statutory definition\n               to determine what qualifies as a place of worship may be administratively simple,\n               but it does not reflect reality. Many faith communities gather in rented halls, storefronts\n               or shared spaces. Some are newly established. Some lack formal recognition. If protection\n               depends on paperwork rather than people, then we risk excluding those who may be most\n               vulnerable. From an enforcement perspective, ambiguity about what qualifies creates\n               hesitation and uncertainty in applying the law. The exclusion of private residences raises similar concerns. Many faith groups gather\n               in homes. These are legitimate expressions of religious practice. If they become targets\n               of harassment, what recourse exists? Does that create a loophole? How would such a\n               situation be handled in practice? We must also consider how this legislation fits within the broader legal framework.\n               Federal efforts to address hate-motivated conduct near places of worship focus on\n               criminalisation, intimidation and hateful symbols but do not establish defined buffer\n               zones. This creates a distinction between conduct-based and location-based protections.\n               If these frameworks are not well aligned, there is a risk of confusion. Police officers\n               should not have to interpret overlapping or inconsistent standards in the moment.\n               Effective enforcement requires coherence across jurisdictions. Another concern is that this legislation stops at the sanctuary door. Faith is lived\n               through service in food banks, shelters and community programs. These spaces can also\n               become targets. If they fall outside the scope of protection, then we are addressing\n               only part of the problem. There is also the question of capacity. Even the best law will fail without the resources\n               to enforce it. Do police services have the training, the personnel and operational\n               clarity required? Are there clear protocols in place? Without this, enforcement will\n               be uneven and communities will continue to rely on private security to fill the gap. We are already seeing that reality. Some communities are bearing significant financial\n               burdens just to ensure basic safety. Security costs across all Metro Vancouver Jewish\n               institutions have risen to more than $100,000 per month. That is not sustainable,\n               and it is not acceptable. Public safety must remain a public responsibility. We support the spirit of Bill 14. We recognise the urgency. We acknowledge the voices,\n               both from faith communities and from commentators like Rob Shaw, who have highlighted\n               the need for government to act thoughtfully not just quickly. If this law is to succeed, it must be clear, enforceable and supported by the resources\n               necessary to make it real. It must apply fairly across all communities. It must reflect\n               how faith is actually practised. It must give both the public and law enforcement\n               the certainty they need. Because if it does not, Every British Columbian, regardless of faith, should be able to walk into their place\n               of worship with peace, dignity and safety, not just in principle but in practice.\n               That is the standard we must meet. While I agree with the intention of the bill, I know that we must be thoughtful whenever\n               we limit the actions of individuals and groups. Peaceful assembly is a protective\n               freedom, but intimidation, harassment and blocking access to places of worship are\n               not. Protecting the right to worship safely must be treated as a basic public safety\n               responsibility. If government is serious about standing against antisemitism and hate, it must go\n               beyond symbolism. Strengthen policing, increase resources and stop taxing security.\n               Communities facing targeted hate should not be forced to rely indefinitely on privately\n               funded security to fill gaps in public safety. It is expressly wrong that this government\n               is charging 7 percent PST on the security services that the Jewish community is being\n               forced to purchase to keep itself safe. Governments should not be taxing the very\n               measures communities need because of rising hate and threats. The Criminal Code of Canada has already provided protection for people walking to\n               places of worship who face harassment, but we hardly see any enforcement. As we are\n               now considering and debating Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship\n               Act, we must ensure that Bill 13 is not just another additional piece of legislation\n               sitting in the statute vault, with no real protection for the British Columbians who\n               attend their places of worship. I sincerely hope that the Attorney General will address all these concerns and those\n               raised by my colleagues and support the opposition party's meaningful amendments to\n               Bill 13.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415853","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Worship Act. At the heart of this discussion is a fundamental principle. No person in British Columbia\n               should ever feel intimidated, harassed or fearful when walking into their place of\n               worship. It is about dignity, fundamental freedoms and the kind of province we want\n               to be. Yet for many Br","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Subsidized housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037251","label":"Subsidized housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","label":"Religious buildings","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["4fdf473ed4888c2cb55fbad2a63ee07f9c415ee04205d74d0cb26d185c07f984"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.93,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["531dd5c25c775d24921c0abb5540cf2f68078bf3910d36e62d4cfd1c6a686ce9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious buildings","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:51686","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5a02178139e5dae523e52c51","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415854,"date":"2026-04-01T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 11, legislation that the government claims to improve\n               safety and accountability in supportive housing, but could, in reality, expose the\n               very failures of their current approach. Let's be clear about what this bill does. It amends the Residential Tenancy Act to\n               create a separate legal framework for supportive housing. It expands the powers of\n               cabinet, granting the Lieutenant Governor in Council sweeping authority to regulate\n               nearly every aspect of supportive housing operations: tenant access, landlord entry,\n               inspections, compensation and even the ability to amend tenancy terms. It also broadens\n               the grounds for eviction and makes it explicit that the actions of occupants or permitted\n               guests can lead to termination of a tenancy. On the surface, the bill talks tough on safety. But talking tough is not the same\n               as doing the hard work required to actually make housing safer. After years of mismanagement\n               by this government, we are now left with a system that is strained, unsafe and, in\n               many cases, failing both residents and the surrounding community. Let me take you to my riding of Richmond-Bridgeport. At Alderbridge temporary modular housing, we have seen firsthand what happens when\n               low-barrier supportive housing is implemented without adequate safeguards. Residents\n               in the surrounding neighbourhood have raised repeated concerns. Incidents of crime\n               and disorder, open drug use, fire risk, threats to personal safety. What's been the response from this government? Too often, silence. Too often, deflection. Too often, a refusal to acknowledge that\n               their model is not working as intended. Now, with Bill 11, instead of fixing the system Now, with Bill 11, instead of fixing the system, they are attempting to legislate\n               around its failures. For far too long, single-room occupancies in supportive housing\n               have been environments where a small number of individuals are allowed to ruin the\n               benefits for everyone else, both residents within those buildings and the broader\n               community. This bill acknowledges that problem, but it does not solve it. Yet it introduces provisions that will allow for the seizures of dangerous personal\n               property, items like butane torches that can start fires or weapons used to threaten\n               others. Let me be clear. Those are necessary tools. But where was the government when\n               these risks were first identified? Where was the proactive planning? Where was the\n               investment in staffing? Where was the coordination with first responders? This is what this bill does not address. It does not address the reality of drugs\n               inside supportive housing. It does not address the persistent fire hazards that residents\n               and neighbours have been raising for years. It does not address the unsafe physical\n               conditions of some of these buildings. Instead, it places a heavier burden on tenants, expanding eviction powers, broadening\n               enforcement, focusing on punishment rather than prevention. That is the contradiction\n               at the heart of Bill 11. It targets tenants while ignoring the systemic issues that\n               created this unsafe condition in the first place. We must also ask who was consulted in the drafting of this legislation. Because from\n               what we are hearing, police, fire services and paramedics — the very people who are\n               called when things go wrong — were left out of the room. Housing workers who are on the front lines every day continue to operate without clear\n               rules, without adequate protection and without the support they need to manage high-risk\n               situations. This bill does not clearly answer a fundamental question. What happens\n               when a tenant is armed or dangerous? Who responds? Under what authority? With what\n               protections in place? Silence. And that silence is dangerous. Without clear protocols, we are not just failing\n               tenants; we are putting workers and first respondents at risk. Now let's talk about evictions. Bill 11 expands the grounds for eviction and makes\n               it easier to terminate tenancy based on the actions of occupants or guests. But what\n               happens when someone is in crisis? What happens when someone is struggling with addiction\n               or mental health challenges? Locking people out in those moments does not resolve the problem. It inflames it.\n               It pushes individuals further into instability, further away from support and, often,\n               into more dangerous situations. That is not safety. That is displacement. It does\n               nothing to address the underlying issues that brought them into supportive housing\n               in the first place. Supportive housing should be exactly that: supportive. It should include proper staffing\n               levels, strong safety protocols, access to treatment and recovery services, clear\n               expectations and consistent enforcement. Instead, what we have seen under this government is a model Now Bill 11 attempts to retrofit rules onto a system that was never properly built.\n               That is not leadership; that is damage control. This government wants to appear tough.\n               They want to say they are taking action. But this bill is more optics than outcomes. If this government was serious about safety, they would fix the system at its core.\n               They would invest in treatment and recovery. They would ensure facilities are properly\n               staffed and resourced. They would work hand in hand with municipalities, law enforcement\n               and emergency services. They would listen to communities like those around Alderbridge,\n               in my riding, who have been raising concerns for years. Instead, they are expanding\n               their own powers, centralizing decision-making while leaving communities to deal with\n               the consequences themselves. Compassion without structure is not compassion, it is negligence. Accountability without\n               support is not fairness, it is failure. We can and must do better. We need a model\n               of supportive housing that actually supports people, one that stabilizes lives, reduces\n               harm and creates real pathways to recovery. We need to restore balance so that community safety and individual dignity are treated\n               not as competing priorities but as shared responsibilities. We need a government that\n               is willing to listen, not just legislate. To the residents in my riding and to the communities across this province: your concerns\n               are valid, your safety matters and your voices deserve to be heard in this Legislature. One more point. Bill 11, Residential Tenancy Amendment Act, 2026 significantly expands\n               cabinet's regulation-making authority, particularly in areas such as tenant access,\n               landlord entry and eviction provisions. It also broadens the grounds for eviction and makes it clear that the conduct of occupants\n               or permitted guests can trigger the termination of a tenancy. These are substantial\n               changes. They raise important questions about balance, fairness and how this power\n               will be exercised in practice. On one hand, this government has consistently taken a very strict approach toward\n               private residential landlords, emphasizing the protection of every tenant's rights\n               and holding landlords to a higher standard of compliance and accountability. But on the other hand, when the government itself acts as a landlord, particularly\n               in the context of supportive housing, there appears to be different applications of\n               this principle. Concerns have been raised by neighbouring communities and residents\n               about safety, oversight and responsiveness. Yet the same level of enforcement and\n               transparency does not always seem to apply. This raises a fundamental question. How can the government justify imposing increasingly\n               stringent rules and expectations on private landlords while appearing to operate under\n               a different standard in its own role as a housing provider? If these expanded powers are truly about fairness, safety and protecting communities,\n               then they must be applied consistently, regardless of whether the landlord is private\n               or government. British Columbians deserve a system that is not only robust but also equitable and\n               accountable British Columbians deserve a system that is not only robust but also equitable and\n               accountable across the board. Bill 11, as it stands, falls short. It identifies problems\n               but avoids accountability. It expands powers but neglects responsibility. It talks\n               about safety but fails to deliver it. So I urge this House, do not settle for legislation that looks strong but acts weak.\n               Let us do the hard work. Let's fix the system. Let's ensure that supportive housing\n               in British Columbia is truly safe, truly supportive and truly worthy of the people\n               it is meant to serve.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260401pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415854","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 11, legislation that the government claims to improve\n               safety and accountability in supportive housing, but could, in reality, expose the\n               very failures of their current approach. Let's be clear about what this bill does. It amends the Residential Tenancy Act to\n               create a separate legal framework for supportive housing. It exp","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","label":"Public safety","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","label":"Safety regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.99,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["43f99f1fc2ee5d1823f63481d3e4235fc09734141c7bff71f35c95dfb97e4e16"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.59,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.78,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7b5fbe2d816ef1cc5ae0f36858cdfe503cf3560a965836b4684fa283179e9101"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Safety regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Public safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036810","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037014","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-722960750dac1c284f69a275","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720677,"date":"2026-04-16T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would also like to recognize the delegation of leaders and volunteers from the Filipino\n               community. Over the past weekend, many of us attended ceremonies honouring the victims of last\n               year's Lapu-Lapu Day tragedy and raised funds to support their families. As this community continues to\n               heal, it has also begun to advocate for important services and space to help the 170,000\n               people thrive. The group with us today represent the Filipino Legacy Society, which is working to help the community realize its nearly four-decade dream of building a cultural centre in Vancouver. Please welcome Warren Dean Flandez, Maj Yee, Christine de Castro, Lorentz Sy, Matthew Remedios, David Decolongon, and Ellen Jiang.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260416am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720677","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would also like to recognize the delegation of leaders and volunteers from the Filipino\n               community. Over the past weekend, many of us attended ceremonies honouring the victims of last\n               year's Lapu-Lapu Day tragedy and raised funds to support their families. As this community continues to\n               heal, it has also begun to advocate for important services and spa","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Nonprofit organizations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034434","label":"Nonprofit organizations","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034574","label":"Community services","probability":0.74,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7a860f269ca506572ebd8895d7eb1fe590045b329765a8a7b2a4a7e2a5e64622"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.11,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["01e4f6841530d8954cfba3d69c3cee35661cec32ba049a65f0531f33e0ef9e51"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e3632eb1a70584cabd894e7","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721749,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act. At its core, this legislation touches something fundamental to a functioning democracy,\n               the balance between government transparency and the protection of citizens' personal\n               information. That balance is not abstract. It directly affects public trust, accountability\n               and the relationship between people and the institutions that serve them. This bill must be evaluated against a simple but vigorous standard. Does it strengthen\n               transparency, protect individual privacy and limit unnecessary government overreach?\n               Or does it tilt the balance toward centralized control, reduced accountability and\n               diminished public access to information? Because if we get this wrong, the consequences\n               are serious. A government that cannot be scrutinized is a government that cannot be trusted. A\n               system that does not safeguard personal data is one that risks exposing citizens to\n               misuse, breaches or exploitation. Let me begin with transparency. Freedom of information legislation exists for a reason.\n               It is not a bureaucratic inconvenience. It is a democratic necessity. It ensures that\n               journalists can investigate, that citizens can ask questions and that opposition members\n               can hold government to account. However, over time, we have seen a steady erosion of that principle. Delays in responses,\n               excessive redactions, rising fees and the increasing use of exemptions have made it\n               harder, not easier, for people to access information. The question before us is this: does Bill 9 reverse that trend, or does it entrench\n               it? From what we can see, there are serious concerns. While the bill introduces certain\n               administrative updates, it does not meaningfully address the systemic barriers that\n               people face when filing freedom of information requests. For example, timelines are only meaningful if they are enforced. Without real accountability\n               mechanisms, deadlines become suggestions rather than obligations. British Columbians\n               deserve a system where requests are answered promptly and fully, not delayed indefinitely\n               or returned with pages of blacked-out text. We believe reforms should prioritize faster response times, fewer unnecessary exemptions\n               and stronger oversight. If this bill does not deliver on those fronts, then it falls\n               short of what the public expects and deserves. Now let me turn to privacy, an equally important pillar of this legislation. In today's\n               digital age, personal information is one of the most valuable and vulnerable assets\n               people have. Governments collect vast amounts of data from health records to financial\n               details to personal identifiers. With that responsibility comes an obligation to protect\n               that information with the highest possible standards. Bill 9 includes provisions related to how data is stored, accessed and potentially\n               shared. Here again we must proceed with caution. There is always a temptation for\n               governments to expand data-sharing capabilities in the name of efficiency or modernization.\n               But efficiency cannot come at the expense of privacy. Once personal information is\n               collected and centralized, the risks increase, whether from cyberattacks, internal\n               misuse or unintended disclosure. We must ask: are there clear limits on how data can be used? Are there robust safeguards\n               to prevent breaches, and are individuals fully informed about how their information\n               is handled? If the answer to any of those questions is unclear, then the legislation\n               needs to be strengthened. We also need to consider the principle of data minimization. Government should only\n               collect what it truly needs and retain it only for as long as necessary. Expanding\n               data collection without clear justification is not modernization. It is overreach. Another key issue is oversight. Strong laws are only as effective as the mechanisms\n               that enforce them. Independent oversight bodies must have the authority, resources\n               and independence to investigate complaints, audit compliance and hold government accountable. If Bill 9 increases responsibilities without strengthening oversight, then it creates\n               a gap between intention and reality, and that gap is where public trust is lost. We\n               must ensure that oversight bodies are not only reactive but proactive, that they can\n               identify risks before they become problems, rather than after damage has been done. There is also a broader philosophical question at play here. What kind of government\n               do we want? Do we want a government that defaults to openness, where information is\n               accessible unless there is a compelling reason to withhold it? Or do we want a system\n               where information is controlled, filtered and released only when convenient? Do we\n               want a government that treats personal data as something to be protected at all costs\n               or one that views it as a resource to be managed and leveraged? From our perspective, the answers are clear. We believe in open government. We believe\n               in limited responsible use of personal data. And we believe that citizens, not institutions,\n               should ultimately From our perspective, the answers are clear. We believe in open government. We believe\n               in limited, responsible use of personal data. And we believe that citizens, not institutions,\n               should ultimately have control over their own information. That is why we approach Bill 9 with skepticism. Not because we oppose reform; in fact, reform is needed. But reform\n               must move us in the right direction. It must enhance transparency, strengthen privacy\n               protections, and rebuild public confidence. If this bill does not clearly achieve\n               those goals, then it must be amended. Let me outline a few areas where improvements could be made. First, enforceable timelines. Requests should be processed within clear, reasonable\n               time frames, with consequences for unjustified delays. Second, reduce barriers. Fees should not discourage legitimate requests, and the process\n               should be accessible to all, not just those with legal expertise or financial resources. Third, stronger limits on exemptions. While some information must remain confidential,\n               exemptions should be literally defined and carefully applied. Fourth, enhance privacy safeguards. Clear rules must govern data collection, storage\n               and sharing, with strict penalties for misuse. Fifth, independent oversight. The body responsible for enforcing this legislation\n               must have real authority and sufficient resources to do its job effectively. These are not radical ideas. They are commonsense principles that reflect the expectations\n               of British Columbians. Trust in government is not built through words alone. It is built through actions,\n               through transparency, accountability and respect for individual rights. Legislation\n               like Bill 9 plays a critical role in that process. It sets the rules that govern how\n               information flows and how privacy is protected. It shapes how citizens interact with\n               their government and how they perceive its integrity. If we get it right, we strengthen democracy. But if we get it wrong, we weaken it.\n               So I urge this House to carefully consider the implication of this bill; to listen\n               to stakeholders, including privacy experts, journalists and members of the public, as well as members\n               of the opposition; and to ensure that any changes we make truly serve the interests of the people we\n               represent. In closing, let me be clear. We are ready to work constructively. We are ready to\n               support measures that improve transparency and protect privacy. But we will not support\n               legislation that moves us in the opposite direction. British Columbians deserve a\n               government that is open, accountable and respective of their rights. That should be the standard we hold ourselves to and the standard\n               by which we judge Bill 9. Thank you.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721749","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today to speak to Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy\n               Amendment Act. At its core, this legislation touches something fundamental to a functioning democracy,\n               the balance between government transparency and the protection of citizens' personal\n               information. That balance is not abstract. It directly affects public trust, acco","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Computer security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.53,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034599","label":"Computer security","probability":0.26,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","label":"Data protection","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","label":"Personal information","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c84eb4d2d84268e374b216b3d87bfe23a70821e2944516d6b042c07e46603021"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5c11c0bae5706ef294af4d339a7918214565830d5fd0711461ae37b4dd58a243"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Data protection","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Personal information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034771","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036627","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-667d80b78fa464080efe3aa4","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729571,"date":"2026-04-29T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"Does this government even apply for major event status with the federal government for FIFA? A simple yes or no?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-Hansard-n167.html","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260429pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729571","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Does this government even apply for major event status with the federal government for FIFA? A simple yes or no?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Federal programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Commonwealth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Federal institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035232","label":"Federal programs","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:262805","label":"Commonwealth","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41887","label":"Federal institutions","probability":0.37,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.44,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["29455740fd5c0ab01b289af232e93dd8cded1994dbe0d38ab337e6c32439ec34"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-963b8ce455f448e01a5f8704","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729572,"date":"2026-04-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I would like to also acknowledge and express my gratitude to all members of the committee\n               for their contributions, as well as to both the previous Chair, the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville, and the current Chair, the member for Vancouver-Kensington, for advancing our work throughout this process. In addition, I would like to echo the acknowledgement of everyone who shared their\n               perspectives on ways to strengthen the provisions of the human rights code. During\n               our review, committee members heard about the valuable role that the Human Rights\n               Commissioner plays within B.C.'s human rights system. On behalf of the committee,\n               I would like to extend our gratitude to the commissioner for the important work to\n               promote and protect human rights in B.C. In closing, I wish to also express my appreciation to the staff of the Parliamentary\n               Committees Office and Hansard Services for the support they provided for our work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260430am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729572","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I would like to also acknowledge and express my gratitude to all members of the committee\n               for their contributions, as well as to both the previous Chair, the member for Coquitlam-Maillardville, and the current Chair, the member for Vancouver-Kensington, for advancing our work throughout this process. In addition, I would like to echo the acknowledgement of everyone who shared their\n","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["31889e627f06eaa7d605c683f400d1e77cf97f778f3af4c60b4dbbde9a61dbdc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.3,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b59db950aa28731c415386eaab3cb5b19690408bd4b344ce94640ca4a8961507"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4969a4fa2b22598a52a302ed","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752368,"date":"2026-05-04T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is my great pleasure to rise and host today to introduce some very special guests\n               who have joined us in support of the 4th annual B.C. Buddhist Day. Joining us in the gallery is my dear friend, Madam Liu, along with distinguished members\n               of the North America Artists Association and the North America Calligraphy and Painting\n               Research Institute. This morning, the more than 100 member delegation this morning\n               all woke up at 4 a.m. to make sure that they can get on the two busses, the coaches,\n               to come here and take the 7 a.m. ferry not to miss the celebration of the fourth annual\n               B.C. Buddhist culture day in the Hall of Honour. Thank you for your amazing performances. Through your dedication to art, culture and\n               community, you have made meaningful contributions Please join me in extending a very warm welcome to Madam Liu and all of the 100 honoured\n               guests of this delegation.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260504pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752368","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is my great pleasure to rise and host today to introduce some very special guests\n               who have joined us in support of the 4th annual B.C. Buddhist Day. Joining us in the gallery is my dear friend, Madam Liu, along with distinguished members\n               of the North America Artists Association and the North America Calligraphy and Painting\n               Research Institute. This m","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Intercity transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Ferries","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Public transit","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Art works","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Transport","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035928","label":"Intercity transport","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.51,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:45493","label":"Public transit","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501171","label":"Transport","probability":0.52,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:751783","label":"Art works","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:87171","label":"Ferries","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.95,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e66f4564c64fcc22d456e01220c15af12d33477c65ad78bbc915f0b29e94aae3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["f3a94d8a419ffe6fedfb5f5b315197eb3f8d725423d2e1f42cd01aa29d15118f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-6e0727aa0cdf7a76d4da9c56","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752369,"date":"2026-05-05T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today to recognize May as Asian Heritage Month, a time to celebrate the rich\n               culture, history and contribution of the Asian community across British Columbia and\n               Canada. As an MLA of Asian descent, I'm proud to stand in this House and honour the\n               generation who have helped shape our province through resilience, hard work and deep\n               commitment to community. From building our economy to enriching our cultural fabric, Asian Canadians continue\n               to play a vital role in our shared future. I ask all members of this House to join\n               me in celebrating Asian Heritage Month and recognizing the many contributions of the\n               Asian community across our province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260505am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752369","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today to recognize May as Asian Heritage Month, a time to celebrate the rich\n               culture, history and contribution of the Asian community across British Columbia and\n               Canada. As an MLA of Asian descent, I'm proud to stand in this House and honour the\n               generation who have helped shape our province through resilience, hard work and deep\n               co","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Cultural development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034745","label":"Cultural development","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","label":"Cultural diversity","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.37,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5073ca9f8ff216a3c14bdeceb47b752da0ba0beb5e601d7772e353d6b88dbb4a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.24,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["99cb41a29c47ee1f97e09b31537219702ac07ce15db7430b8aebd676c906cc6c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural diversity","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42661","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cbfe2cee18de9b37cfcaa44b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752370,"date":"2026-05-06T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is a great honour for me to rise today in the House on behalf of my constituents\n               in Richmond-Bridgeport to support the motion for second reading of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, to be amended by deleting the word \"now\"\n               and substituting it with \"six months hence.\" This is not a procedural tactic. It's not an attempt to delay for delay's sake. It\n               is a deliberate and necessary step to ensure that legislation of this magnitude is\n               examined with the seriousness, diligence and care it deserves. This is called a hoist\n               motion, which is one of the oldest tools in parliamentary traditions. I would like to explain to my constituents what a hoist motion is so that they clearly\n               understand why the Conservative caucus of British Columbia has to move a six-month\n               hoist of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act,\n               2026. Whenever there's legislation that's introduced in this House that opposition\n               parties see serious problems in, as in this case, a hoist motion is necessary to pause\n               it, to send it back and get it right for the benefits of all British Columbians. This is what this hoist motion is about. It would set Bill 9 aside for six months,\n               effectively halting it for this session. That time should be used to consult British\n               Columbians, define sweeping new powers left dangerously vague When the report was released in 2020, the executive director of the Freedom of Information\n               and Privacy Association, FIPA, Jason Woywada said: \"Despite government actions which\n               undermined committee efforts, they received and made recommendations that would improve\n               government transparency and accountability. If enacted, these recommendations could\n               go a long way to restore trust in public bodies and better protect the privacy rights\n               of British Columbians.\" FIPA president Mike Larsen said: FIPA added that the key step forward and test will be whether the provincial government\n               acts on this recommendation. It's extremely puzzling to see this government ignore the recommendation made in the\n               2022 special legislative committee report. This recommendation would have strengthened\n               transparency. Yet we don't see them in Bill 9. Instead of strengthening accountability,\n               Bill 9 focuses on administrative convenience. Why would we move forward without fully\n               incorporating the work of this special committee? That's why this six-month pause will allow the government to seriously review the\n               recommendations of this special committee and act in good faith to incorporate the\n               recommendations into the bill and ensure that they are not overlooked. At its core, Bill 9 is not technical. It is not administrative. It is foundational.\n               It governs how power is exercised, how information is controlled and how trust is\n               maintained between government and the people we serve. When we are dealing with something as fundamental as access to information and the\n               protection of personal privacy, we must be absolutely certain that we are strengthening,\n               not weakening, the democratic principles that underpin this province. That is why\n               our whole caucus supports this hoist motion. There are two pillars at the heart of this legislation — transparency and privacy.\n               They are not competing values. They are complementary ones. Transparency ensures accountability. It allows citizens to understand decisions, scrutinize\n               actions and hold government to account. Privacy, on the other hand, protects individuals.\n               It ensures that personal information is not misused This amendment for a six-month delay is grounded in a very simple question: does Bill\n               9 strengthen openness and accountability, or does it consolidate control and restrict\n               access? That question has not yet been satisfactory answered, and until it is, we\n               should not proceed. We have heard this government describe this bill as modern, effective and necessary,\n               yet at the same time, we are told that amendments are already being introduced to\n               correct gaps. That contradiction should concern every member of this House, because\n               legislation that requires fixing before it has even passed second reading is not fully\n               formed legislation. It suggests that consultations may have been incomplete, it suggests that stakeholder\n               concerns may not have been fully incorporated, and it suggests that scrutiny required\n               for a bill of this importance has not yet been fully exercised. That is why this pause\n               is needed. Let me now turn first to the issue of access to information. Freedom-of-information\n               laws exist for a reason. They are not a convenience; they are a cornerstone of democratic\n               governance. They allow journalists to investigate. They allow citizens to ask questions.\n               They allow opposition members to fulfil their duty, our duty to hold government accountable. Unfortunately, over time, we have seen troubling trends. Response times have lengthened,\n               redactions have become more extensive, exemptions have been applied more broadly,\n               and in many cases, the process has become so slow and so complex that it discourages\n               people from even trying. This is not openness; this is not accountability; this is\n               erosion. My colleague representing Prince George–North Cariboo, in his comments yesterday in support of this amendment motion, went at length to\n               talk about his firsthand experience as a sitting MLA, in submitting an FOI request\n               last year, seeking documents related to the Quesnel bridge, located in his riding. By the way, I was so grateful for this member for Prince George–North Cariboo having taken me on a walking tour of this Quesnel bridge last summer, because it\n               really shocked me how terrible the condition of this bridge was. It took my colleague\n               a full year to get a response from this government. But when he got the response,\n               you know what? It came with a hefty bill attached. My colleague was told that if he wanted the document, he had to first pay the bill.\n               As an elected MLA, trying to obtain information about a public infrastructure project\n               in We should all applaud our colleague for doing his job for his constituents. Instead,\n               this government places so much obstacle in his line of responsibility. We can see how ridiculous and troubling it is in the current FOI legislation, and\n               now, Bill 9 makes it even more difficult to do that. It is not helpful at all to transparency, not helpful at all for all our elected officials\n               to do our jobs. It certainly isn't helpful to the people of British Columbia, who\n               deserve to know what we are doing here, how we are doing it and why we are doing it. We should all thank our colleague from Prince George–North Cariboo for sharing this very frustrating and challenging personal experience. That's why\n               this hoist motion deserves the support of each and every one of us sitting in this\n               House. The bill before us does not adequately reverse these trends. It maintains timelines\n               but does not meaningfully enforce them, and a timeline without consequence is not\n               a safeguard. It is a suggestion. If requests can be delayed without accountability,\n               then access becomes uncertain. And when access becomes uncertain, transparency becomes\n               optional. That's not acceptable. A six-month extension will allow us to properly address these systemic issues; to\n               ensure that timelines are not only clear but enforceable; to ensure that delays are\n               the exception, not the norm; to ensure that the right to access information is meaningful\n               in practice and not in theory. Let me now turn to privacy, which is equally critical. We live in a time where data is power. Governments today have unprecedented capacity\n               to collect, to store and to share personal information — health records, financial\n               data, location information, personal identifiers. The scope is vast and growing. With that power comes responsibility, a profound responsibility. Bill 9 introduces\n               provisions that expand how data can be managed, shared, often framed under modernization.\n               But modernization cannot come at the expense of fundamental rights. We must ask: are there clear limits on how personal information can be used? Are there\n               strong safeguards to prevent breaches? Are there strict and enforceable rules governing\n               retention and disposal? Are individuals fully aware of how their data is being handled? If the answers are unclear, then this legislation is incomplete, because once data\n               is centralized, the risks multiply. A single vulnerability can expose thousands, sometimes\n               millions of individuals. We have seen this happen in jurisdictions around the world.\n               Data breaches are not theoretical. That is why the principle of data minimization must be central. Government should collect only what is necessary, use it only for legitimate purposes,\n               and retain it only for as long as required. Anything beyond that is not efficiency;\n               it is overreach. That is why to set aside Bill 9 for six months is necessary — to\n               ensure that government has enough time to come up with proper procedure to collect\n               data for legitimate purposes. Another critical issue is oversight. No law, no matter how well-written, is effective\n               without enforcement. Oversight bodies must have real authority. They must have sufficient\n               resources. They must operate independently. If we expand government powers without\n               strengthening oversight, we create imbalance. And imbalance leads to misuse, intentional\n               or otherwise. Oversight should not be reactive; it should be proactive. It should identify risks\n               before harm occurs, not after. That requires capacity, that requires clarity, and\n               that requires commitment. A six-month extension will give us the time to ensure that\n               oversight mechanisms are robust, effective and capable of meeting the demands of this\n               evolving landscape. There is also a broader issue we must confront. What kind of government are we building?\n               Do we believe in a government that defaults to openness, where information is accessible\n               unless there is a compelling reason to withhold it? Or do we accept a system where\n               information is controlled, filtered and released selectively? Do we believe that personal\n               data should be protected at all costs or treated as an administrative resource? These are not abstract questions. They go to the heart of public trust. From our perspective,\n               the answer is clear. We believe in open government. We believe in strong policy protection.\n               And we believe that citizens, not institutions, should ultimately have control over\n               their own information. We must also consider the practical barriers that continue to exist. Fees, administrative\n               complexity, delays — these factors discourage participation. They create inequality\n               in access, and they undermine the very purpose of freedom-of-information legislation. A six-month period will allow us to address these barriers in a meaningful way. We\n               will also have the opportunity to engage more thoroughly with stakeholders, privacy\n               commissioners, legal experts, journalists, civil society organizations and the public.\n               Legislation of this importance should not be developed in isolation. It should be\n               informed by those who understand the real-world impact. Let me be clear. We are not opposed to reform. We recognize that laws must evolve.\n               Technology has changed how information is created, stored and shared. Our legal framework\n               must reflect that reality. Evolution must be guided by principle. Not convenience. Not expediency. Principle.\n               Rushing forward this legislation that contains large gaps does not serve the public\n               interest. It risks entrenching problems rather Rushing forward this legislation that contains large gaps does not serve the public\n               interest. It risks entrenching problems rather than solving them, and it risks weakening\n               trust rather than strengthening it. A six-month delay is not a setback. It is an investment,\n               an investment in getting this right, an investment in building legislation that is\n               durable, effective and worthy of public confidence. British Columbians expect transparency. They expect accountability, they expect their\n               personal information to be protected, and they expect this House to do its job properly.\n               That means taking the time necessary to ensure that this legislation meets the highest\n               possible standard. We stand ready to work constructively. We are prepared to cooperate, and we are committed\n               to strengthening this bill, but we cannot support moving forward without addressing\n               the concerns that have been clearly identified. This amendment provides the opportunity to do just that, to pause, to reflect and\n               to improve, and ultimately to deliver legislation that truly serves the people of\n               British Columbia. If we get this right, we strengthen democracy. That's why I immigrated\n               to this country. If we get this wrong, we weaken it. The choice before us is very\n               clear. For all these reasons, I urge each and every one of the members of this House to support\n               this amendment. In particular, I ask members on the other side to ponder very carefully.\n               One day, it will be pretty soon, you will be on this side of the House. And you definitely\n               don't want to see the government of the day hold back all the information so that\n               you can't do a proper job of representing your concern to hold the government of the\n               day to account. I urge each and every one of the members on the other side of the House to give some\n               deep and conscious thought to the rationale of the hoist motion. If all of us take\n               up this political mission to serve British Columbians with our heart and with our\n               conscience, I can't see how members on the other side would not support this hoist\n               motion.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260506pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752370","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is a great honour for me to rise today in the House on behalf of my constituents\n               in Richmond-Bridgeport to support the motion for second reading of Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and\n               Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026, to be amended by deleting the word \"now\"\n               and substituting it with \"six months hence.\" This is not a procedural tactic. It'","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.58,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","label":"Information dissemination","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","label":"Privacy","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c564974c425fd0bc35424e35edb0a384c16dc9f4cb67ff6f792052e8332d380a"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.76,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","probability":0.08,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3f3393f7fbce091dec5422ebe23f9af8c08f681f29d9b52704e5359b6e426fd"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information dissemination","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Privacy","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43048","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501266","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4145e050f8a8df6cd04d33e3","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752371,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"A notice from the Supreme Court of British Columbia warns that criminal trials may\n               be delayed, moved or even see accused persons released from custody because this NDP\n               government cannot reliably transport them to court due to staffing and facility shortages.\n               The B.C. Supreme Court is clear there is no long-term solution in place. Will the Attorney General admit this is a failure of management and tell British Columbia\n               exactly when a permanent transportation and in-custody capacity plan will be in place?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752371","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"A notice from the Supreme Court of British Columbia warns that criminal trials may\n               be delayed, moved or even see accused persons released from custody because this NDP\n               government cannot reliably transport them to court due to staffing and facility shortages.\n               The B.C. Supreme Court is clear there is no long-term solution in place. Will the Attorney Gener","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.87,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["56b926f844f002bc7f2841ab2c3dc65334e79d3afcd013f3cfe06589d94c0fe7"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7fd4e5a0eeaa3692e0f5d82eafb2a5b9782d3ae55f02bead2a49fc9f7c4e0239"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d5d6f7b35e7fb92bd998256a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1017706,"date":"2026-05-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"The Premier's office has said that the Premier will be attending two FIFA 2026 matches\n               at B.C. Place. But we don't know why. Simple question to the Minister of Tourism, not to the House Leader or the Minister\n               of Transportation: which NDP cabinet minister will be attending FIFA games and for\n               what purpose?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260520pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017706","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"The Premier's office has said that the Premier will be attending two FIFA 2026 matches\n               at B.C. Place. But we don't know why. Simple question to the Minister of Tourism, not to the House Leader or the Minister\n               of Transportation: which NDP cabinet minister will be attending FIFA games and for\n               what purpose?","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tax benefits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Music industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037278","label":"Tax benefits","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.06,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49276","label":"Music industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501318","label":"Benefits","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["ee02787dcf82e7e2226f83cc13c5c1f7b3921e40bad9611e230bb62e51e9419d"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-ff74725ff1e18e6af8c52a92","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036610,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today ahead of Airport Workers Day on June 25 to recognize and thank the thousands\n               of dedicated airport workers who keep British Columbia connected to Canada and the\n               world. As MLA for Richmond-Bridgeport, I am especially proud to represent Vancouver International Airport and the many\n               hard-working people on Sea Island who make YVR one of the best airports in the world. For many residents in Richmond, YVR is more than an airport. It is part of our community.\n               It is where people work, where families reunite, where visitors arrive and where goods\n               that support our economy move in and out of our province every single day. Last year, YVR welcomed a record 26.9 million passengers and handled more than 365,000\n               tonnes of cargo. It was once again recognized as the best airport in North America,\n               an achievement made possible by the extraordinary people working behind the scenes\n               every single day. From engineers and ground crews to security personnel, emergency\n               responders, airline staff, logistics teams and customer service workers, airport workers\n               play a vital role in keeping travellers safe and ensuring our economy continues to\n               move. This recognition extends beyond YVR. Across British Columbia, from Victoria to Kelowna,\n               Prince George and communities throughout our province, airport workers serve with\n               professionalism, dedication and pride. On Airport Workers Day, I urge all members of this Legislature to join me in recognizing\n               and thanking the remarkable airport workers for everything they do for our communities\n               and our province.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036610","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I rise today ahead of Airport Workers Day on June 25 to recognize and thank the thousands\n               of dedicated airport workers who keep British Columbia connected to Canada and the\n               world. As MLA for Richmond-Bridgeport, I am especially proud to represent Vancouver International Airport and the many\n               hard-working people on Sea Island who make YVR one of the best ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public finance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Low income","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Taxes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Interest rates","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Loans","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Property tax","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Freight","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Seniors","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035397","label":"Freight","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.16,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41856","label":"Loans","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","label":"Airports","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42685","label":"Property tax","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42750","label":"Public finance","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43466","label":"Interest rates","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44239","label":"Low income","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501152","label":"Seniors","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501283","label":"Taxes","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["c46ac3939bc984db3fb8a9e77b8ba5d4e245ab9bc1f89f2f093d4dd2ae5df626","5e71b7e6ca162a19a2e6afff0c24af4730cc7260bd5fcecb68ca7152be698fb3"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","probability":0.25,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["90b424a1922d56816af857bb30736c82b8a9d112a1ef5133dc704e8b1849b267"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","topic_id":"concept-501100","label":"Transportation","fine_topic_label":"Airports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501100"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42546","primary_category_id":"concept-501100","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-541ddd58f11d03bfda4612ae","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036611,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Teresa Wat","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that a bill intituled Chinese Heritage Month Act, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This bill is plainly written but it's very historical and emotional. It has a clear\n               and meaningful purpose to proclaim the month of February each year as Chinese Heritage\n               Month for all of British Columbia. The history of the Chinese-Canadian community in this province is one that demands\n               our recognition and our honesty. Chinese Canadians have been part of British Columbia\n               since the mid-19th century. They helped build the Canadian Pacific Railway under conditions\n               of systemic discrimination, laying the very tracks that connected the country from\n               coast to coast. Yet, rather than recognition, they were met with injustice. From 1885 to 1923, Chinese\n               immigrants were subjected to a discriminatory head tax — a burden placed on no other\n               group. Then, from 1923 to 1947, the Chinese Exclusion Act effectively barred Chinese people\n               from coming to Canada at all. These are among the darkest chapters in the history\n               of our province and this country, and we must not look away from them. In 2014, the province of British Columbia apologized to the Chinese community for\n               historical wrongs. Today British Columbia is home to approximately 500,000 people of Chinese origin,\n               one of the largest such communities anywhere in Canada. They are a vital and vibrant\n               part of our social, cultural and economic fabric of our province. They are our constituents,\n               our colleagues, our business owners and our health care workers. They have enriched\n               every corner of British Columbia. February holds deep cultural significance for this community. It is the season of\n               lunar new year, a celebration of renewal, family and community that is increasingly\n               embraced by all British Columbians. Designating February as Chinese Heritage Month\n               reflects this significance. This bill is about memory, gratitude and celebration. It is an opportunity for all\n               British This bill is about memory, gratitude and celebration. It's an opportunity for all\n               British Columbians to reflect on the remarkable history and lasting contribution of\n               the Chinese-Canadian community. I look forward to discussing this bill with all members of this House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036611","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I move that a bill intituled Chinese Heritage Month Act, of which notice has been\n               given in my name on the order paper, be introduced and read a first time now. This bill is plainly written but it's very historical and emotional. It has a clear\n               and meaningful purpose to proclaim the month of February each year as Chinese Heritage\n               Month for all of British","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","label":"Ethnic groups","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.22,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083655","label":"Cultural groups","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","label":"Culture","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["26fd4cd7af4507b3d0cf6fdd0edf727e192b38e2cbd9a8c1acfac7ddf12f8613"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.43,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e7346cd1b46b4751bb7426f03a92069e5b23537ebd51238ac0e6aca534e85c29"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Ethnic groups","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Culture","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035167","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:872","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8cd17ed27cd88af34b09ba9c","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1933910,"date":"2026-05-27T12:00:00+00:00","title":"CHINESE HERITAGE MONTH ACT","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m248-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/m248-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1933910","member_id":"bc-mla-85","member_name":"Teresa Wat","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-979bbc1d79a4e3f1b37d33b5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317224,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I acknowledge the question from the member. I will say that every worker deserves to come home safe and sound at the end of their\n               shift. In 2025, 138 workers didn't make it home, and many more suffered injuries at\n               work, some that were life-altering. Every single member of the Workers' Compensation Board understands the incredible\n               gravity of their role, both from a statutory perspective and the moral imperative\n               to ensure that workers come home safe at the end of their shifts, because we know\n               that when safety standards fall short, workers pay the price. We know that on this\n               side of the House. I will just say this. In this question, we actually see the mask of the Conservatives\n               fall away, and we see the true contempt for working people that lies beneath.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317224","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I acknowledge the question from the member. I will say that every worker deserves to come home safe and sound at the end of their\n               shift. In 2025, 138 workers didn't make it home, and many more suffered injuries at\n               work, some that were life-altering. Every single member of the Workers' Compensation Board understands the incredible\n               gravity of their role, ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Human security","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour mobility","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035734","label":"Human security","probability":0.6,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036041","label":"Labour mobility","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","label":"Occupational health","probability":0.93,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","label":"Occupational safety","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["6676933c8bdad136cef342b31a368b2a83dee923ebe6dc94c53d090c602897ac"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.56,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.2,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.54,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["13978f079f1edd596079b1e529c22c78658da9950ff6bd1e2563490ee8267c31"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational safety","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational health","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036485","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036491","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-969addfb302d006feaa8a6ec","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317225,"date":"2026-02-24T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"Before I begin my remarks, I just want to take a moment to reflect and express my\n               deep grief at the unimaginable tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. We stand, of course, in solidarity\n               with everyone affected in Tumbler Ridge. We will commit to supporting them through\n               this profoundly difficult time. As a former Minister of Education, I can understand that a tragedy of this scale really\n               impacts the community in ways that defy understanding. It's an act of violence that's\n               truly beyond comprehension. I know all of our thoughts across this entire chamber\n               are with the community, those recovering, those whose lives have been changed forever. It's a privilege to rise in this House on the territory of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People, the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations, to speak to my support for our budget. Budget 2026 arrives in a period of global uncertainty and economic headwinds. Here\n               in British Columbia, we're investing in economic growth by unlocking job creation,\n               investing in major projects, training a skilled workforce and supporting resource\n               development. Now, I want to situate this in some context for us because we could not have predicted\n               the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, of Russia's attack on Ukraine — a war the Ukrainian\n               people certainly didn't ask for, now in its fourth year — the global instability and,\n               of course, a completely unjust trade war launched by the U.S., which puts the economic\n               stability of our province and our country at risk. It is in this context that Budget 2026 takes disciplined and thoughtful steps to protect\n               the services that British Columbians count on while securing the future of our province\n               through an unprecedented investment in skilled trades training, in strategic investments\n               to foster investment in our resource and tech sectors, and to ensure that the public\n               services that people rely on, like education and health care, remain Indeed, it is working people who are at the centre of our government's work and at\n               the centre of this budget. I'm talking about the people who keep our hospitals running,\n               who build and maintain our communities, who teach our children, support our classrooms,\n               who innovate, who care and who keep us safe. We know that government services matter and that we all need strong communities and\n               strong institutions. These are not optional, but they are essential. That is the responsibility\n               that this budget carries. This budget is about protecting the key services that people\n               depend on while making careful choices to manage spending. I would say that our priorities\n               are clear, protecting core services like health care, education, child care and public\n               safety. This includes $634 million in additional money over three years to strengthen our\n               K-to-12 education system, with $167 million for the classroom enhancement fund, which\n               will support the hiring of additional teachers, special education teachers, psychologists,\n               counsellors, as well as adding $5 million for First Nations reciprocal tuition. Our government understands how critical it is for the health of our communities and\n               our economy to grow and integrate our early learning and child care program. I just\n               want to take a moment to reflect on the extraordinary success of our work so far,\n               because it has been substantial. Nearly 60,000 new spaces opened and $3 billion back\n               in the pockets of families through fee reduction programs. We have cut child care\n               fees by an average of 50 percent, saving families on average about $7,200 a year.\n               Since 2018, overall fees have dropped from an average of $47 a day to $19 a day. I hear this from families in my community in New Westminster, mothers who tell me\n               they wouldn't be able to work or they would only be able to work part-time if they\n               didn't have our program to support them. Their lived experience was in fact tested\n               in a recent report on our early learning and child care program that analyzed the\n               economic impact of our investments and found increased labour force participation\n               by women, particularly increased full-time employment for core-aged women, such that\n               B.C.'s provincial labour supply increased by some 3,300 full-time equivalent workers\n               from 2019 to 2024. This report further estimates that provincial GDP was $5.8 billion higher in 2024,\n               measured in real 2024-dollar terms, than would have been the case without the expansion\n               of early learning and child care services after 2019, of course reinforced by the\n               national $10-a-day program. This is why our budget includes $330 million over three\n               years to continue our historic investment in child care and our work to reduce fees\n               for families. We know that there is more work to do. We will ensure that we chart the next phase\n               of development of the program so that it is here for families for generations to come.\n               We know these investments strengthen families and they strengthen our economy. We\n               are taking the next steps to ensure that British Columbians have access to the care\n               that they need when they need it. Our budget invests $2.3 billion in new health care funding to ensure people can get\n               the care that they need, whether it is surgical or primary care or cancer care or\n               PharmaCare or whatever other care or support they need. There is $131 million to support mental health and addictions treatment, and that\n               has been a subject of much debate in this House, and appropriately so. But I will\n               note that since 2017, we have added 829 new addiction treatment beds, vastly expanded\n               youth mental health supports through opening 19 Foundry centres. We've expanded integrated child and youth teams, increased access to outpatient opioid\n               agonist therapy, and launched the first seamless substance use treatment, from detox\n               to transitional housing, in the Road to Recovery program. We've expanded integrated child and youth teams, increased access to outpatient opioid\n               agonist therapy and launched the first seamless substance use treatment, from detox\n               to transitional housing, in the Road to Recovery program. I want to shout out to Dr. Seonaid Nolan and Cheyenne Johnson from St. Paul's Hospital,\n               who were just recognized for their work in developing Road to Recovery in Vancouver Magazine , and, really, the entire team at Providence Health Care and Vancouver Coastal and\n               those in every health authority as we roll the Road to Recovery out across the province.\n               There are so many health care workers on the front line saving lives every single\n               day and building the Road to Recovery. We are investing $102 million for in vitro fertilization and $653 million to expand\n               public coverage of free medication for diabetes and enhanced coverage for hormone\n               replacement therapy to treat menopausal symptoms. In addition, we are securing $447 million in federal funding to support complex acute\n               health needs for seniors. We are also investing $185 million to strengthen seniors'\n               care. I just want to take a moment here to reflect on the critical importance of this last\n               funding point. It will ensure that 5,000 workers who care for the most vulnerable\n               seniors in residential long-term care homes are brought back into a collective agreement\n               that is bargained by the Health Employers Association. This change reverses the perverse impact of one of the most draconian and destructive\n               laws brought in by the B.C. Liberals in the 2000s, which fragmented our long-term\n               care system. It resulted in the firing of thousands of workers across the province,\n               mostly women, many racialized, as operators contracted out care and support work in\n               long-term care. Now some of those workers were rehired with lower wages, and many were subjected to\n               repeated firings as operators flipped contracts to further drive wages down. Workers\n               were deprived of benefits and pensions for a generation. It was a shameful episode\n               in the history of this province. It resulted in a fragmented long-term care system where a care aide at a health authority-operated\n               site on one street would earn a family-supporting wage with benefits and a pension,\n               but on the other street, at a private site, the care aide might earn as much as $7\n               an hour less, with few benefits and no pension. If there is anyone who thinks that\n               our health care workers don't deserve a dignified retirement, then I don't know what\n               to say to you about that. I would say that our experience during this period was that caring for vulnerable\n               seniors became a business, subject to commercial procurement rules. The problems with\n               the lack of sufficient and administrative oversight, frankly, became very apparent\n               at the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic. I can tell you that I clearly remember the first death. I remember the resident at\n               the Lynn Valley Care Centre who was the first to die. At that site, the care staff\n               were employed by one contracted agency, and the support staff were employed by a different\n               contracted agency. You can imagine the challenges that poses for communication. This story was repeated across the long-term care sector. It meant that implementing\n               the provincial health officer's order that staff could only work at one site was very\n               difficult, because workers had been forced over the course of this destruction of\n               our long-term care system to take up jobs at multiple sites, just in order to put\n               together one full-time wage. The standards and terms of conditions of work that existed before mass privatization\n               and contracting out, in fact, ensured the stability of care for frail seniors. That\n               was taken apart by the previous government, and that stability had been lost. Bringing back a standard wage was, in fact, the only way to ensure the safety of seniors\n               and workers. Now, our government is taking the next step. We are taking the next step\n               to ensure that care workers who do the same work and make the same contributions to\n               caring for seniors have the same compensation, the same chance at a dignified retirement\n               through a pension, because we understand that seniors' care is not a business, and\n               it should not be treated as such. I am so proud and grateful for the efforts of so many workers who fought for a generation\n               for this change and who understand that working conditions are caring conditions.\n               This is not only the right thing to do. It is in the best interests of the clinical\n               care and oversight and the administrative oversight that is fundamentally important\n               in providing these care services to frail seniors. We know that collective social goods like access to quality health care and education\n               are key economic drivers. On the economic front, we are laser-focused on ensuring that we can leverage the strength of B.C.'s resources and people\n               to grow our economy and diversify our markets. I'll just give you one example of this. Mining and mineral revenue is forecast to\n               increase by 32.6 percent in '26-27 and 28.2 percent in each of the next two years. You may have heard that the new Inger Bell expansion at Copper Mountain mine near\n               Princeton has received its permits. That extends the operation of that mine by 12\n               years, providing 800 good, family-supporting jobs for workers in that region. That is the third major mine permit approval so far this year — and we are just past\n               the mid-February — and the sixth approval in the last 12 or so months, bringing jobs\n               and prosperity to our province. We're making investments to grow B.C.'s economy and to create good-paying jobs. We're\n               setting up a $400 million strategic investment fund to ensure that we're ready for\n               investment in major projects in our province in partnership with the federal government.\n               We're investing more than $40 million to speed up permitting and boost capacity in\n               the natural resource and tourism sectors. We've introduced a 15 percent tax credit\n               for manufacturing businesses who invest in buildings and equipment in B.C. And we\n               are growing the economy by helping people train for in-demand jobs. Budget 2026 invests $283 million over the next three years through our Look West strategy. This includes $241 million for SkilledTradesBC, $30 million for the integrated\n               marketplace initiative and the B.C. manufacturing jobs fund and $12 million to enhance\n               the employer training grant. In '24-25, nearly 17,000 people registered as apprentices, bringing the total number\n               of apprentices in B.C. to nearly 50,000, the highest in our province's history. Now,\n               apprentices really are foundational to the economy that we're building, because ensuring\n               that workers have the education and experience they need to work safely and with expertise\n               is just a simple necessity. And that's what apprenticeship training does. It ensures\n               good-paying jobs, safe work environments and a high quality product at the end. B.C. is working with SkilledTradesBC, B.C. Building Trades, post-secondary institutions\n               and industry partners to expand access, stabilize the skilled-trades system, reduce\n               wait lists and implement skilled-trades certification, which will help support mobility\n               and create a more inclusive workforce. And we need that workforce. We need those workers. Because we have the most ambitious\n               capital plan this province has ever seen. And this, too, is about investing in people\n               and investing in our communities. Budget 2026 builds on B.C.'s long-term infrastructure\n               plan, investing $37.7 billion over three years to deliver the schools, the hospitals,\n               the housing and the transportation infrastructure that our communities need — projects\n               that will help create 130,000 jobs over the next three years. I can tell you, I see how we're building our province every day in my own community\n               in New Westminster. The new stal̕əw̓asəm Bridge opened a couple of weeks ago. It's a beautiful, modern, safe crossing that\n               replaces the Pattullo Bridge. I just have to stop for a moment to thank my colleague the member for Surrey City Centre for such an eloquent elegy this morning to the Pattullo Bridge. It's been really heartwarming to see the whole community turn out to take a last walk\n               across the bridge and say goodbye, because that bridge certainly served us well over\n               its 89-year life. But I'll tell you, when I look at the new bridge, I see the ironworkers, the surveyors,\n               the carpenters, the electricians, the labourers, the engineers, all of the workers\n               who brought this bridge to life in sometimes miserable weather under difficult circumstances.\n               But listen, this project created 931 jobs, including 864 jobs for B.C. residents.\n               That workforce was 93 percent local, and that is an important achievement. Likewise, the new tower at Royal Columbian Hospital brings a major expansion of acute\n               care beds, an expanded ER, state-of-the-art medical technology to improve the care\n               environment for both patients and health care workers. Now, Royal Columbia Hospital is my community hospital. It's where I was born. It's\n               where my family members have been cared for and died. It is a truly special place.\n               I want to express my deepest gratitude to all of the staff at the hospital, who do\n               extraordinary work together as a team, from the care staff to the support staff, to\n               take care of people in our community and across our province. And to the Royal Columbian\n               Hospital Foundation, a thousand thank-yous for the work that you do, your steadfast\n               advocacy for public health care and for our community. From the rebuild of Skwo:wech Elementary to the 525-seat expansion at Queen Elizabeth School and the new downtown elementary school\n               that we'll be, hopefully, breaking ground on very soon, we have made such significant\n               investments in places for our children to learn. On housing, we know that New Westminster is in fact the densest community in the province,\n               I think next to downtown Vancouver. We are growing at an unprecedented rate in Metro\n               Vancouver. We have made the investments that are necessary for people to have places\n               to live in our community. We've built a new integrated student housing and academic building, in partnership\n               with Douglas College, which adds 368 student beds at 8th and Royal. We've built 52\n               supportive and affordable homes in New Westminster. Those will be delivered very soon.\n               On Marine Way, we have a project in collaboration with Aunt Leah's to provide housing\n               for focusing on youth, particularly young mothers, leaving care. We're very excited\n               about this opportunity. We've built 66 new, affordable homes in downtown New Westminster. In all, we've delivered\n               over 630 units in my community. We know that there's more to do. Of course there's\n               more to do. But I will tell you, as well, in a city that has a higher-than-average\n               percent of renters than in Metro Vancouver — 45.3 in New West compared to 37.8 in\n               Metro Van — it matters. It matters a lot to everyday people that our government's renters tax credit is estimated\n               to return $232 million to renters in B.C. in '26-27, and it matters that our work\n               on housing is helping to bend the curve on rental costs and that in 2025, rent declined\n               by over 16 percent in my community. Those are measures that help people in these times. Investing in infrastructure and skills, of course, is only part of the story. Protecting\n               workers and ensuring fair workplaces is equally critical. We have worked to level\n               the playing field. Demand for support through the employment standards branch has\n               increased in recent years. In response, the province added staff, expanded investigation\n               capacity, modernized intake systems and reduced administrative barriers. The goal, of course, is timely resolution of disputes and better access to rights\n               for workers and appropriate supports for employers with respect to their responsibilities\n               under the act. We brought in protections for temporary foreign workers, an important part of our\n               provincial labour force. More importantly, these are people with families and communities\n               who care for them. We must ensure that their contributions to our economy are recognized\n               and their rights are protected. A fair economy must support those who face the greater barriers or risks so workers\n               dealing with domestic or intimate partner A fair economy must support those who face the greater barriers or risks. Workers\n               dealing with domestic or intimate-partner violence, life-threatening illness or precarious\n               immigration status deserve timely, responsive support. Employment laws are being modernized\n               to ensure that workers have access to employment protections without fear of reprisal.\n               We are evaluating right now our current protections for app-based ride-hail and delivery\n               workers, to ensure that those regulations are doing what we intended to do and that\n               they are providing meaningful and effective support for those workers. Linking the annual minimum-wage increases to B.C.'s average inflation rate provides\n               predictability for employers — which, we've heard, is very welcome and valuable —\n               and stability for workers. B.C. has one of Canada's highest minimum wages, and it\n               helps low-wage earners to keep pace with the cost of living. As workplaces evolve,\n               of course, so must our labour laws. The continued review of the Labour Relations Code\n               will help maintain stable labour relations and collective bargaining. Folks will know that workplace safety is really close to my heart. Protecting workers\n               on the job is key, also, to our economic success. I have to say that we lost 138 workers\n               last year who died on the job, and many more workers were injured, some of whom sustained\n               life-altering injuries. I am grateful for the ongoing work that we are doing with WorkSafe and with partners\n               in different industries, including employers, to work on improving conditions in our\n               construction sector through the development of our crane safety framework. I'm grateful\n               for the work and support of the health care sector in tackling, again, a sector where\n               we see, really, unacceptably high injury rates. I know also that we're very thankful to all of our local first responders for the\n               work that they do to protect our communities. I want to just take a moment to express\n               my gratitude to the New Westminster and Coquitlam firefighters, paramedics and police.\n               Of course, New Westminster is home to the Justice Institute, and this budget continues\n               the increased support for the JI by providing 50 percent more funding for more police\n               training seats. I want to take just a moment to speak about New West in particular and the extraordinary\n               work of our police department in New Westminster. When Stats Canada released their\n               2024 crime severity index last year, it showed that in New Westminster, crime severity\n               had declined to its lowest level since 2018. The overall CSI for the city dropped\n               by 16.9 percent, with a 23.3 percent reduction in violent crime severity and a 14.1\n               percent decrease in non-violent crime severity. This is possible because of the work that our local police department does, supported\n               by our community. We have an approach that really brings together all partners to\n               support this work, including investments by the province of $187,000 in CSTEP and\n               site funding, which supports the police with their enhanced downtown foot patrol,\n               ensuring that they have a presence. We've invested in a situation table for youth.\n               We know that it takes a village, and we need to work together to get these results. Budget 2026 provides essential public services with new investments in education,\n               health care and social supports, and it also introduces updated revenue measures and\n               careful capital spending to maintain our long-term fiscal stability. It's important\n               to all of us, and it's important for people in our communities. In my community, a community I am so deeply honoured to represent in this place, I'm\n               grateful for the opportunity to be here and speak about New Westminster. We live on\n               the banks of the Fraser River, where Coast Salish Nations have gathered, worked and\n               stewarded resources, made a living and built communities since time immemorial. Now it's a place where over 90,000 people live. We have an incredible array of organizations\n               that lift our community up, from minor sports teams — thank you to all the coaches\n               and the folks who are supporting our kids to play — to a thriving arts scene. Much gratitude to Arts New West for nurturing the talent and creativity in our community,\n               and to the not-for-profits that do such heavy lifting to support people — like Elizabeth\n               Fry, Family Place, Purpose, Dan's Legacy, Aunt Leah's, Senior Services Society, the\n               Umbrella Multicultural Health Society, New West Pride and many others that I want to take a moment to thank the work that our Chamber of Commerce does and that\n               our local business improvement associations do. They do such incredible work advocating\n               for the small businesses that are the lifeblood of our community, whether it's an\n               independent bookstore — New Westminster has three — a restaurant or a coffee shop\n               or a specialty store. New Westminster truly has everything that we need. I know how important it is, particularly these days, to lift up small businesses,\n               to support small businesses, to buy local and to make sure that we are always highlighting\n               the incredible services and products that our local small businesses provide. These are extraordinary times we're living in. Budget 2026 is indeed a budget built\n               for serious times. It ensures that front-line services will be there for people. Around\n               the world, households, businesses and governments are navigating such uncertainty\n               and volatility. This plan takes a disciplined approach to protecting what matters the most – health\n               care, education and the core services British Columbians rely on. It secures British Columbia's future with investments in skills, major projects and\n               a strong economy. It strengthens the foundation of a fair, safe and resilient system.\n               And it positions our province for long-term economic security that really leverages\n               the best that we have to offer. It's about our people and our resources. And we will always have the backs of British\n               Columbians. In uncertain times, we choose a path that protects services, that stands up for British\n               Columbians, that is grounded in stability and responsibility and where we care for\n               what happens to people in our communities. Thank you very much.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260224pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317225","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Before I begin my remarks, I just want to take a moment to reflect and express my\n               deep grief at the unimaginable tragedy in Tumbler Ridge. We stand, of course, in solidarity\n               with everyone affected in Tumbler Ridge. We will commit to supporting them through\n               this profoundly difficult time. As a former Minister of Education, I can understand that a tragedy","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.98,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["8c3775acd608de204cee2f9211d0a18594b5bfb1b79c8b697d37ad33670cd550"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.19,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9c7b45ba2729095abf1c694933a03373eb8e331feb5e436f4dbdb5cbdccc4a68"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-914ff1aa4ee0fce8fc514910","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":317226,"date":"2026-02-26T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I also had a chance to join with colleagues and friends at the B.C. Care Awards celebration\n               last night. I wanted to take a moment to introduce and welcome Judy Calhoun to the House today.\n               She was the recipient of the 2025 B.C. Care Providers Family Champion Award. I just\n               have to say, anybody who has had a loved one in care — my mother lived her last time\n               in long-term care — knows how important advocacy is and knows how important family\n               and resident councils are to ensuring that there are connections, that there is compassion,\n               that there's a friendly voice of advice there for what is often a very difficult period\n               for families and their loved ones. Judy, thank you so much for the work that you do at Royal City Manor in my community\n               of New Westminster. You have been active on the family resident council there for\n               a long time and have cared for your family members there, as well as helped others'\n               families through difficult times. Thank you very much. Would the House please join me in welcoming Judy to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260226am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:317226","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"I also had a chance to join with colleagues and friends at the B.C. Care Awards celebration\n               last night. I wanted to take a moment to introduce and welcome Judy Calhoun to the House today.\n               She was the recipient of the 2025 B.C. Care Providers Family Champion Award. I just\n               have to say, anybody who has had a loved one in care — my mother lived her last tim","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Community partnerships","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Foster families","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035386","label":"Foster families","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083610","label":"Community partnerships","probability":0.33,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.06,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1d6c205b8f472c58eb5e18ad930e8a6d2d715dad8d4fb4d136593a8edf375c70"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.18,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.23,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a3518c1d14bbf0c0da0fb48d3ec01c152b310c70af30d6fdb0109c7037d082ab"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1844b06f453b9f716f118455","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328070,"date":"2026-03-02T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I might have to have a competition with the member for West Van–Capilano about whose sister is better, because it must be Sister Day in the House today. I'm so pleased. You know, it's not often that I get a chance to have family come and\n               visit me on the precinct. My big sister, Nancy Whiteside, is here today, which I'm\n               really, really thrilled about. We got to have lunch in the dining room this afternoon.\n               After a long career in telecommunications in British Columbia, after retirement, Nancy\n               got to pursue her dream of studying art and is now one of New Westminster's most renowned\n               artists, and is such an incredible, smart and creative talent. Please welcome my big sister, Nancy, to the House.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260302pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328070","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I might have to have a competition with the member for West Van–Capilano about whose sister is better, because it must be Sister Day in the House today. I'm so pleased. You know, it's not often that I get a chance to have family come and\n               visit me on the precinct. My big sister, Nancy Whiteside, is here today, which I'm\n               really, really thrilled about. We got to have lun","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Food","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501112","label":"Food","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","label":"Arts","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7060771439530af0c2ed66682b19fb09fbc31099e8feb1862d28ed1a4adc52c4"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a6b3f2121f65efb932252c2e7e93e1fb460a7f176569aca6180dbecc99a402ea"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Arts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501346","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8f6b1a2e15bf2e84af8791b1","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":328071,"date":"2026-03-04T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I move that the bill be introduced and read a first time now. I am pleased to introduce Bill 10, the Labour","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260304pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:328071","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I move that the bill be introduced and read a first time now. I am pleased to introduce Bill 10, the Labour","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour code","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.35,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.38,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.57,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.12,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49263","label":"Labour code","probability":0.4,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.59,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["d129ac457023fa2b5e5694c5871cb30315daa761813f090154c0bd0ccdb95816"]},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cf6e21d189b78498e8ebc230","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187099,"date":"2026-03-04T12:00:00+00:00","title":"LABOUR STATUTES AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov10-1.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/1st_read/gov10-1.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187099","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","label":"Work permits"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Work permits","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43103","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-39a9f409f03c4a7109e63ae5","kind":"bill","graph_record_id":1187100,"date":"2026-03-04T12:00:00+00:00","title":"LABOUR STATUTES AMENDMENT ACT, 2026","speaker":"","venue":"","text":"","text_scope":"stored bill summary","text_available":false,"source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov10-3.htm","source_status":"unverified_reference","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/parliamentary-business/overview/43rd-parliament/2nd-session/bills/3rd_read/gov10-3.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1187100","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","label":"Information"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","label":"Waste"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","label":"Criminal investigations"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","label":"Claims"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build","sponsorship_and_jurisdiction_not_independently_verified"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","topic_id":"concept-501089","label":"Science & Technology","fine_topic_label":"Information","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501089"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Waste","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Criminal investigations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Claims","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034489","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034724","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034890","primary_category_id":"concept-397184","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083667","primary_category_id":"concept-501089","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-d2db4a7073888e89076351a0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415855,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I offer today a reflection, a poem by local New West poet Jónína Kirton. I just send so much love to Yonina and her husband, Gary, today, who is recovering\n               from surgery. \"Fraser River Forgetting.\"","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poetry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415855","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"I offer today a reflection, a poem by local New West poet Jónína Kirton. I just send so much love to Yonina and her husband, Gary, today, who is recovering\n               from surgery. \"Fraser River Forgetting.\"","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","label":"Poetry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poetry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","label":"Poetry","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["da61c73f606b92bdb9f369e8607aa572febb7b6993fc47ffb92b5320c76ba8cc"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poetry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.03,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["67c475e76f6a9e5a0667930a2355c8c145193318a01c964ec3beb25ecd3c83af"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Poetry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720542","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8699868a0b6d05f380c8b04a","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":415856,"date":"2026-03-31T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"In the tiny House, I call committee stage on Bill 8. In this chamber, I call continued debate on Bill 13.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260331pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:415856","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"In the tiny House, I call committee stage on Bill 8. In this chamber, I call continued debate on Bill 13.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Caregivers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1012614","label":"Caregivers","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.03,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","label":"Law","probability":0.86,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["187f63d764f2459bc8d2228500a87e3b470dadf200c751194a8a3b2199e262a8"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9e71a025ee84447d929b558775c64bbe40f6c81c15fda8c8d0b74f1131602129"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48776","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-05523ba0936f468308e40d1c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720684,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have a few sets of introductions today. First, I would like to introduce somebody who is a fierce, fierce advocate for working\n               people in this province. Karen Ranalletta, the president of CUPE B.C., is here with\n               us today. CUPE is literally in every community, in every sector, helping us to build strong\n               communities. I am so grateful for the work that every single CUPE member does across\n               our province. I want to thank Karen for being here. She's joined today by the new legislative coordinator for CUPE B.C., Caitlin Gilroy. Would the House please join me in making them feel very welcome. Also, somewhere in the House — I don't see him yet, but I know he's going to be here\n               — is somebody who is a very Also, somewhere in the House — I don't see him yet, but I know he's going to be here\n               — is somebody who is very special to me, a dear friend and former colleague, Baljit\n               Sandhu. He is the regional vice-president of the Interior for the Hospital Employees\n               Union. Baljit works at Vernon Jubilee Hospital. He is a care aide. He has been a good\n               friend and a strong ally for many, many years. Would the House please join me in making\n               him feel very welcome. Finally, I have to say I see the secretary-treasurer of the B.C. Federation of Labour\n               in the House, Hermender Singh Kailley. Welcome, Hermender.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720684","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I have a few sets of introductions today. First, I would like to introduce somebody who is a fierce, fierce advocate for working\n               people in this province. Karen Ranalletta, the president of CUPE B.C., is here with\n               us today. CUPE is literally in every community, in every sector, helping us to build strong\n               communities. I am so grateful for the work that ev","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Investments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Construction industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public administration","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Immigrants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Employment opportunities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour disputes","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034566","label":"Community development","probability":0.3,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034573","label":"Community relations","probability":0.46,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034643","label":"Construction industry","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.43,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035790","label":"Immigrants","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42510","label":"Employment opportunities","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47673","label":"Public administration","probability":0.09,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:48398","label":"Labour disputes","probability":0.11,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501117","label":"Employment","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501221","label":"Investments","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["9f5220a4571243ce5e5d4e1703019e401805ef5f41e215686499b50ef92be1e8","d2e50a3360c5fbc531d2bd2f227e68e41df7de098bb9c4fb3b6f3f4d3c7069b6"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.04,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["5a599e794b6c84a1372469d0ff8550f4af71fb61bd2a2c4cf405237c9a03a03b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-1124d9395fa276193283c9d5","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721753,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you very much to the member for the question. I think we all understand that\n               when people come from other places to do important work in our province, we want them\n               to be treated appropriately, we want them to have access to the same rights that other\n               workers in the province have, and we want to ensure that there is enforcement of those\n               rights. That's why our government brought in the Temporary Foreign Worker Protection Act,\n               which requires that employers are certified before they apply for an LMIA with the\n               federal government. We have provisions in the Employment Standards Act to ensure that\n               temporary foreign workers who are here are protected. We work very closely with groups like the Migrant Workers Centre and other migrant\n               worker organizations to ensure that we have appropriate outreach to a very important\n               part We work very closely with groups like the Migrant Workers Centre and with other migrant\n               worker organizations to ensure that we have appropriate outreach to a very important\n               part of our labour force. I will just say that it certainly is a view of this government when it comes to the\n               rights of individuals that if folks are good enough to work here, they're good enough\n               to stay here. We strongly advocate with the federal government for pathways to citizenship\n               for people who are here under temporary work permits.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721753","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"Thank you very much to the member for the question. I think we all understand that\n               when people come from other places to do important work in our province, we want them\n               to be treated appropriately, we want them to have access to the same rights that other\n               workers in the province have, and we want to ensure that there is enforcement of those\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","label":"Migrant workers","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","label":"Temporary employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","label":"Labour law","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["065506c92b1483e248cd0d46397dd44af4625599c7dac3cc933ad5c88056eb26"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.85,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.17,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.94,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["c333157f68c55afaa08240ea3bb6b761d281fea6211033c2a8d2f246cdc50a88"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Migrant workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Temporary employment","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Labour law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036284","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037321","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43063","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-cee1812cb2398b334dc794c0","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721755,"date":"2026-04-22T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I know that for all of us in this House, Creative Industries Week is one of our very\n               favourite weeks of the year. I'd like to take a moment to introduce and welcome members\n               who are here from the Council of Film Unions, the Union of British Columbia Performers\n               and the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees. It was a pleasure to\n               join them last night at a wonderful reception at the Provincial Museum. I just want to take a moment to note that these unions and their members represent\n               thousands of skilled workers who literally power B.C.'s film and entertainment industry.\n               They tell our stories both from behind the camera and in front of the camera. With\n               more than 20,000 members across these groups, their contribution to our province's\n               economy is enormous. In the gallery, I am pleased to welcome members of IATSE 891, including the president,\n               Amanda Bronswyk; business representative, Crystal Braunwarth; sergeant-at-arms, Michael\n               Billings; and from UBCP, I'm pleased to welcome Keith Martin Gordey, president of\n               UBCP and ACTRA national vice-president; along with Aliza Vellani, Henry Williams,\n               Ariel Reed, Leslie Bradley and Phil Clapwyk. Finally, from the B.C. Council of Film\n               Unions, we're honoured to be joined by Nicole Luther, the executive director. Thank\n               you so much for being here today with the House. Please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260422pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721755","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I know that for all of us in this House, Creative Industries Week is one of our very\n               favourite weeks of the year. I'd like to take a moment to introduce and welcome members\n               who are here from the Council of Film Unions, the Union of British Columbia Performers\n               and the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees. It was a pleasure to\n            ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.44,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083654","label":"Cultural institutions","probability":0.39,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:736704","label":"Cultural events","probability":0.73,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.01,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a91e0b7baf455bc01ea5f021859f0a89bd3aba15a1f94adc87f85ad503e76400"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e68a88f5c1636145d7d69ed665edab763a6b179f273c76ef4a11038189f6dcac"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-bfd5ed4915d0a28cf284794d","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729574,"date":"2026-04-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to join my colleague in welcoming the Mechanical Contractors Association\n               of B.C. in the gallery today. MCABC represents 11 primary trades in the construction\n               sector here in British Columbia. They are primarily concerned with clean air, clean\n               water, with quality-built environments, with safe and high-quality working environments. Their sector includes more than 25,000 skilled tradespeople in an industry that contributes\n               $10 billion to British Columbia's GDP. You can think of any project in the industrial,\n               commercial, institutional or residential sector, from HVAC systems to medical gas\n               in our hospitals, and it is mechanical contractors who are responsible for ensuring\n               the safety and quality of those functions. Please join me in welcoming CEO Kim Barbero, Conor Brendan Dunne, Kyle Wisniewski,\n               Brittany Manulak, Keith Pearce, Maddie Davidson, Simon Miller, Steve Robinson and\n               Rob Nagai to the House. Thank you so much for being here.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260427pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729574","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to join my colleague in welcoming the Mechanical Contractors Association\n               of B.C. in the gallery today. MCABC represents 11 primary trades in the construction\n               sector here in British Columbia. They are primarily concerned with clean air, clean\n               water, with quality-built environments, with safe and high-quality working environments. Their sector in","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718584","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Environmental quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Air quality","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.55,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:50374","label":"Air quality","probability":0.65,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:718584","label":"Environmental quality","probability":0.77,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3ed744e78e6e01a609413dfd4b75c803486734f1754f880bcb58f2058d986094"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.41,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["cc45afd50f82e863e5ccaf3de69785c7972ed9a650b6613a9da4cff94e835b41"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9c1923a53cf2fb268d7fb927","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":729585,"date":"2026-04-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'd like to note that we are joined in the gallery today by representatives from\n               the Canadian Labour Congress. We have Orion Irvine, who is the regional director;\n               and Lily Chang, the secretary-treasurer of the Canadian Labour Congress. Of course, they're here because today, April 28, is the Day Of Mourning. I invite\n               all members of the House to join us on the front stairs to commemorate this day over\n               the lunch hour. I also want to express my deep gratitude for the work of the Canadian Labour Congress\n               in really being an important partner as we move through some of the most volatile\n               times our country has ever experienced. The voice of labour is so critical in that.\n               Thank you for your work. Would the House please join me in making them feel very welcome.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260428am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:729585","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'd like to note that we are joined in the gallery today by representatives from\n               the Canadian Labour Congress. We have Orion Irvine, who is the regional director;\n               and Lily Chang, the secretary-treasurer of the Canadian Labour Congress. Of course, they're here because today, April 28, is the Day Of Mourning. I invite\n               all members of the House to join us o","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour relations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","label":"Labour unions","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.67,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:49277","label":"Labour relations","probability":0.64,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","label":"Labour","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["fed1f8e00a98b510ccd62ad338ff468d7ed7c21d44b8590b1f547ba7322f6ad0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e421005d4246f30c214f6f77448cb5a5c6a5e611517245cb00d3e0a3776e8a8c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour unions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083625","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715743","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-b4d72a8c199c3521219da9a8","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":752372,"date":"2026-05-07T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I wanted to send a big hello and shout-out to folks in my community at the Elizabeth\n               Fry Society. This week is Elizabeth Fry Week, and since 1939, folks at EFry have been\n               standing up for vulnerable girls and women. Their head office is located in New Westminster.\n               I want to say to Azra Hussei and the whole team at eFry, thank you so much for everything\n               you do, from the shelter to running the social enterprise in our community. Would\n               everybody please help me in celebrating Elizabeth Fry Week?","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260507am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:752372","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I wanted to send a big hello and shout-out to folks in my community at the Elizabeth\n               Fry Society. This week is Elizabeth Fry Week, and since 1939, folks at EFry have been\n               standing up for vulnerable girls and women. Their head office is located in New Westminster.\n               I want to say to Azra Hussei and the whole team at eFry, thank you so much for everything\n ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workplace","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037677","label":"Workplace","probability":0.24,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","label":"Women","probability":0.85,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["180111fd248c94538541c6e5b4f999cbaa101da8069d2d2c07a2061070c6372e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.14,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["b9ca61becda81893c9d47c8456a7dbe89812185846905993ee0d6a50aa1610d4"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Women","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41872","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-a1fd60fc2d2e5ea2e6c5bc5c","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036612,"date":"2026-05-26T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to my friend the Minister of Housing for allowing me to introduce the mayor\n               of New Westminster, Patrick Johnstone, who joins his colleagues here this morning. In New Westminster, we are the second-densest city in all of western Canada. We feel\n               that very acutely. With the leadership of Mayor Johnstone and the team at the city,\n               we are building affordable housing, we are building student housing, and we are building\n               supportive housing. We're getting so much done, and I'm so grateful for the work that\n               Mayor Johnstone and his team do. Would the House please join me in making him feel very welcome today.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260526am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036612","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Thank you to my friend the Minister of Housing for allowing me to introduce the mayor\n               of New Westminster, Patrick Johnstone, who joins his colleagues here this morning. In New Westminster, we are the second-densest city in all of western Canada. We feel\n               that very acutely. With the leadership of Mayor Johnstone and the team at the city,\n               we are building a","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","label":"Housing assistance","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.77,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","label":"Urban development","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","label":"Local governments","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","label":"Housing","probability":0.97,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["1ca6d9cdfab1ccc335bae562283d3fa0f0272f682cab32bc33c2962170c6df8f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.62,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["1acadc8fdd3d18bc24d2d5ae41d5193c214bfa68ac1e0044ba6d5f37f8e95d7f"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Urban development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Housing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Local governments","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035718","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037442","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083683","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:866","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-8b40e2ef2131ec66dd8dbd14","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036613,"date":"2026-05-27T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"Today I am so thrilled that we have joining us in the gallery a whole group of shop\n               stewards and representatives from the Compensation Employees Union.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260527pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036613","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"Today I am so thrilled that we have joining us in the gallery a whole group of shop\n               stewards and representatives from the Compensation Employees Union.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Industrial workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Labour force","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupational accidents","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Working conditions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035861","label":"Industrial workers","probability":0.45,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036307","label":"Occupational accidents","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037671","label":"Working conditions","probability":0.29,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42637","label":"Labour force","probability":0.65,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["fc34faf1b113772e2b54d044182e9d9521f25d84596966d16e12131486a8970f"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["a29be7621df06915bde0f2eaff07c05c92d4c8d6247f3d5c2e1e2df8f48e8451"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-4df5e5b8f647f08aa5e2a004","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036614,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"I have the honour to table the 2025 annual report and 2026-2028 service plan for WorkSafeBC.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036614","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"I have the honour to table the 2025 annual report and 2026-2028 service plan for WorkSafeBC.","excerpt_is_truncated":false,"concepts":[],"data_issues":["no_analysis_concept_links","source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"jev_review":{"status":"no_existing_tags","model":null},"jev_category_review":{"status":"no_accepted_detailed_tags","model":null,"applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[]}},{"record_id":"contribution-5c5a4233c494688f75e4d04f","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036615,"date":"2026-05-28T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Jennifer Whiteside","venue":"Hansard","text":"It is an honour to rise in this House on the traditional territory of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People of the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations to pay tribute to Chief\n               Rhonda Larrabee of the qiqéyt First Nation, who passed over on April 4. Rhonda was my friend. She was a beloved mentor and a leader in our community at New\n               Westminster. She was an incredibly strong woman, rooted in her family, her ancestors\n               and her nation. It is hard to lose our matriarchs, and Rhonda was a matriarch in every\n               sense of the word. She was a force of nature. She brought the wisdom of a matriarch and incredible generosity\n               to her work of bringing reconciliation to life in New Westminster. She led this important\n               work with compassion, resilience, patience, courage and grace. She had an extraordinary\n               and an innate sense of justice. She was in her 20s when she learned her family history. Her mother said to her: \"I\n               will tell you once, but never ask me again.\" With those words, her mother told her\n               for the first time that she was a survivor of the Kamloops Residential School, and\n               for the first time, Rhonda learned of her Indigenous heritage. We can only imagine\n               the life-altering impact of learning history as an adult. It wasn't until 1985, after her mother had passed over, that she was able to begin\n               to explore her heritage. Her journey and her advocacy for that heritage led her to\n               the federal government, who had placed the qiqéyt Nation on the list of inactive Indian bands. Rhonda applied for her status card,\n               and she began the work of rebuilding her nation. The New Westminster Indian Band was\n               reinstated and became one of the smallest and only landless First Nations in the country. Her courage and her determination to tell her mother's story, to restore her family\n               history and connection, both past and present, to this land are awe-inspiring. This\n               story has been told many times, but in 2005, the National Film Board documentary pulled\n               all of those threads together in a compelling documentary called A Tribe of One , which I highly recommend for viewing. She gave frequently and generously of her time and knowledge, whether speaking to\n               school kids or welcoming us all at community events. She was always there. She particularly\n               championed Indigenous youth, and her work with the New Westminster school board was\n               invaluable in advancing reconciliation in education. It is a testament to her positive\n               influence that the Qayqayt Elementary School bears the name of her nation. For decades she provided advice, counsel and extended friendship to members of the\n               Legislative Assembly from our community. My predecessors Chuck Puchmayr, Dawn Black, Judy Darcy, myself and, of course, my colleague the Speaker, the MLA\n               for Burnaby–New Westminster, all have learned so much from her and have deeply valued that relationship. In our community, it was a very moving day when, supported by the Rotary club, the\n               grave of her ancestors finally received respect and recognition with the placement\n               of proper markers at the grave of her grandparents in St. Peter's Cemetery in New\n               Westminster, overlooking the Fraser River. She, of course, was not alone in this work. Her loving and supportive family have\n               been there every step of the way with her. Our community has benefited greatly from\n               their contributions, as well, and that relationship, and these will continue. To her family: her husband, Bryan; to her children Cheryl, Stacey and Shelly; her\n               grandchildren; her large and beautiful extended family, I offer my deepest condolences.\n               I know you grieve profoundly her indescribable loss, and our community grieves with\n               you. It is hard to lose our matriarchs. I will miss my friend and teacher. I will always\n               be searching for the cedar hat and the blue shawl that signalled Rhonda's presence.\n               But we need only to go to the river to feel her essence, to look to the sun and the\n               moon to find her, gently urging us along the path to create a stronger and more inclusive\n               community. On behalf of the province of British Columbia, we are deeply grateful for Chief Larrabee's\n               guidance, her work, her commitment to helping build reconciliation in our community\n               and to helping us learn. You will be deeply missed.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260528pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036615","member_id":"bc-mla-86","member_name":"Jennifer Whiteside","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"It is an honour to rise in this House on the traditional territory of the lək̓wəŋən-speaking People of the Songhees and Esquimalt First Nations to pay tribute to Chief\n               Rhonda Larrabee of the qiqéyt First Nation, who passed over on April 4. Rhonda was my friend. She was a beloved mentor and a leader in our community at New\n               Westminster. She was an incredibly strong woma","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","label":"Indigenous youth"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Charitable donations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Counselling services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","label":"Community education","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","label":"Indigenous youth","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083637","label":"Charitable donations","probability":0.07,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","label":"First Nations","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44195","label":"Counselling services","probability":0.15,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["10960c74438879bd0f1f03bc8b8dac35253053a34ce8d831def0f92e86462152"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.21,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","probability":0.47,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","probability":0.16,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["08ab21d9f325f92a9a23e8af4163d40cf71aa209c1bcd8d9683fd7b2326d91fc"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Indigenous youth","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","topic_id":"concept-52838","label":"Education","fine_topic_label":"Community education","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:52838"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"First Nations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034567","primary_category_id":"concept-52838","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035836","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:41843","primary_category_id":"concept-501084","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3967719b9d5237607b63069b","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":316790,"date":"2026-02-23T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. It's an honour today for me to speak to this House about\n               the budget, which helps and outlines our government's plan to build a stronger, better\n               B.C. to help British Columbians get through these very challenging times. As has been\n               said many times, all of us here in this amazing province have endured years unlike\n               any other — the fires, the floods, the global pandemic, economic instability. Now that we're in recovery, we have been building the strongest economic recovery\n               in Canada, and we've demonstrated that we can accomplish as much as we can when we\n               work together. Donald Trump has truly changed Donald Trump has truly changed the new world order. There is much to be done, but\n               we now know that there are many brighter days ahead. I think it's important that we pause for a few moments to consider the dark days that\n               are now happening in Europe, where a brutal dictator is engaged in brutal war in Ukraine\n               and millions of people are fearful every day for their lives. All of our lives are impacted in some way by this war, and I'm proud to say that I\n               stand with all others in this House to condemn in the strongest possible way the egregious\n               and unlawful intrusion into Ukraine. It's important that the people of Ukraine know\n               that they are in our thoughts and prayers and that we will, in whatever way we can,\n               provide whatever is needed to protect them and to support them. There is much suffering around us and all over the world, and we must be mindful of\n               those who have so much less than we do. It would be remiss of me not to take the opportunity to salute the good folks of Surrey-Guildford who have honoured me by sending me here to represent them as their MLA in this House. And to my support at my office in Guildford, the dedicated, talented, enthusiastic\n               and, some would say, long-suffering constituency assistants who every day support me through their hard work and desire to also help the residents\n               of Surrey through their efficient and effective work at my constituency office in\n               Guildford. They're an amazing advocate for all of the people who avail themselves\n               of the services provided by my office there. So to Ben and Candy and Tanveen, the newest addition to my staff, thank you. The residents\n               of Surrey-Guildford are well served by your personable and understanding, helpful demeanour. For those of you who don't know, Surrey-Guildford is located in the northeast corner of the city of Surrey. Fraser River surrounds\n               the northern edge of the community, with Whalley to the west, Langley to the east.\n               And the southern border jogs down 96 to 88 Avenue. This speech that I'm talking about today centres on what has been a core principle\n               of what this government is all about. We believe in putting people first. It highlights\n               our government's plan to support British Columbians dealing with the everyday realities\n               of their lives. It is, by its design and intent, an aspirational document that points\n               to a brighter tomorrow for all of us. It is this government's plan to tackle the big\n               challenges now and build a stronger, more secure future for everyone. The message is simple yet profound. In a time of uncertainty and challenges, our government\n               has your back. Now, there are alternatives. Some would say that we should be pulling back, cutting\n               services and making people pay out of their pockets for things like private health\n               care. That's not the choice that we have made or will make. We're putting the surplus back\n               to work for people. We believe that taking that action today will build a much stronger\n               tomorrow. We're helping people with costs by introducing new measures to help everyone\n               and targeted support for those hardest hit, including those with lower incomes and\n               families with children. By far the biggest source of anxiety for people in British Columbia right now is the\n               rising cost of living. B.C. is the best place in the world to live, but that also\n               means it's expensive to live here. Global inflation and long-lasting impacts of the\n               pandemic are not only making things harder when you pay for gas and food and housing,\n               but we've already taken significant action to help put more money back in your pocket. I want to take a few moments to talk about the people of Tumbler Ridge. My heart goes\n               out to everyone in that beloved community, especially those who have lost loved ones.\n               My thoughts I want to take a few moments to talk about the people of Tumbler Ridge. My heart goes\n               out to everyone in that beloved community, especially those who have lost loved ones.\n               My thoughts are with the entire community, who are experiencing heart-wrenching grief\n               and tragedy. We are also thankful for the work of the hard-working first responders — the policemen,\n               the emergency service workers. All of them acted to protect students as best they\n               could. These dedicated British Columbia workers have steadied their commitment to\n               the most frightening times. Their commitment reflects the very best of who we are\n               in B.C. British Columbians are not alone. Support and love have poured in from across Canada\n               and from people around the world. Counsellors are there, on the ground, helping the\n               community members and local leaders. The school district and so many others have been\n               tireless in their efforts to support the entire community. Our government will always continue to help to surge support into Tumbler Ridge, including\n               counselling services, health resources and community assistance. Again, this government,\n               in our support, will remain there as long as it takes. To return to the budget, it's important that we understand that in a world of economic\n               uncertainty, we have to make careful choices to protect what matters most. In doing\n               so, we will secure the future of this province. Since I've been in government over\n               the past eight or nine years, we've built, already, a strong foundation that people\n               can depend on. Hospitals, schools, roads, transit, housing and clean electricity are being delivered\n               to support communities and good jobs across B.C. We made these investments while guiding\n               people and businesses through extraordinary challenges — again, a global pandemic,\n               devastating floods and wildfires, and now a direct attack on our economy and our sovereignty\n               by our neighbour closest to us in the south. When we came into this problem, we came from a position of strength. Our economy stayed\n               resilient, and a low debt-to-GDP ratio gave B.C. the capacity to respond when it mattered\n               the most. That work is what now is making a difference. Major job creation projects\n               are moving forward. We have more family doctors than ever before. Rent prices are\n               dropping from their peaks, and everyday costs are eased, through the B.C. family benefit,\n               more affordable child care and lower car insurance rates. This budget defends those gains. It is a tough economic reality that we face with\n               clarity and vision. Global uncertainty is slowing growth everywhere. High costs, global\n               instability and volatile commodity prices are putting pressure on our public's finances.\n               We, I think, have to be realistic and definitive in the choices that we make in these\n               circumstances. I believe that Budget 2026 makes disciplined choices to protect what\n               people care about the most. Our priorities are clear: protect core public services like health care and education,\n               keep B.C. as one of the lowest-taxed provinces for working families, and reduce the\n               deficit responsibly over time. To achieve this, we're taking three key steps. We are going to make the public sector\n               smaller and more efficient so that more dollars can be used wisely. We are going to\n               pace infrastructure projects carefully, delivering them efficiently without driving\n               up costs, and by generating new revenue, while taking action to grow the economy and\n               secure the long-term impact on major projects. At the same time, we continue to invest in B.C.'s future, At the same time, we continue to invest in B.C.'s future, doubling trades training,\n               supporting major job creation projects, and ensuring families and communities benefit\n               from what we have built. Budget 2026 is serious work for seriously critical times.\n               We're focused on what matters most, protecting services, keeping taxes low for working\n               families, and strengthening B.C.'s finances for the long term. I think it's important that we highlight as well that we're strengthening health care.\n               Some $2.8 billion more over three years, including $2.3 billion to increase capacity\n               in the health care system, $131 million to support mental health and addictions treatment,\n               $185 million to strengthen seniors care and $102 million for in vitro fertilization. In fact, we've secured $447 million in federal funding to support services for seniors\n               and $653 million to expand public coverage for free medication for diabetes and enhanced\n               coverage for hormone replacement treatments to treat menopausal symptoms. We are securing\n               the economic future of this province. It's $283 million over three years to support commitments made through Look West , including $241 million double funding for SkilledTradesBC over the next three years\n               to train more people for good jobs here in B.C., $30 million for highly qualified\n               professionals and $12 million to enhance the employer training grant to double apprenticeship\n               seats by 2028-2029. Some $400 million dollars for InBC strategic investment fund to\n               seize opportunities for economic collaboration with the federal government. More than\n               $40 million to build on progress made in streamlining, permitting and increasing capacity\n               across the natural resource and tourism sectors. In 2025-2026, $50 million in provincial\n               and reallocated federal funding to support the forestry sector. We are creating a more efficient public sector. This province is committed and has\n               committed to addressing our challenging fiscal situation through workforce reductions\n               and reviewing program delivery through Budget 2026 with nearly $3.5 billion in savings\n               over a three-year fiscal plan and targets to reduce the greater public sector workforce\n               by 15,000 full-time equivalents over the fiscal plan — $2.8 billion dollars in additional\n               savings. Of these 15,000 FTEs, 2,500 will be in the public service. We're supporting education across the province. Before I run out of time, I want to\n               highlight what we're doing in Surrey in particular. Surrey, as all of you know, is\n               the fastest growing place in the province. Our future is very bright, but we have\n               great needs, as do other areas of the province. The Surrey school district's 2025-26 capital plan submission requested over $5 billion\n               in capital funding. They will get 19 additional projects, 26 new schools, two seismic\n               upgrades and 24 site acquisitions. The budget 2025-26 does not provide any new funding\n               for major capital projects, but existing projects with significant cash flows will\n               continue over the next three years, including Fleetwood Park Secondary, an addition;\n               Clayton Heights Secondary, an addition; and Grandview Heights, an addition that has\n               not yet been announced. The health authority. Surrey, of course, is building a brand new hospital The health authority. Surrey, of course, is building a brand-new hospital, and that\n               is going to continue. Existing projects with significant cash flows over the next\n               three years include the Surrey Memorial priority actions project, the renal hemodialysis\n               centre, MRI expansion and others. Of course, as I mentioned, the new Surrey hospital\n               and B.C. cancer centre. The Road to Recovery funding envelope. The site acquisition\n               for that is underway, and a secure care funding envelope. Site purchases there are\n               complete, and our business planning is underway. In post-secondary, Surrey has been underserved for years. We are continuing in this\n               budget with student housing and dining at Kwantlen Polytechnic University, the interim\n               School of Medicine at Simon Fraser University and a permanent school of medicine at\n               Simon Fraser University. I think it's important, in ending, that we look at this budget as it is meant to be.\n               It is an aspirational budget that looks forward. I know that the future is bright.\n               I know that if we continue along the course that has been set for us, that future\n               will continue.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260223pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:316790","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-02","excerpt":"Thank you, hon. Speaker. It's an honour today for me to speak to this House about\n               the budget, which helps and outlines our government's plan to build a stronger, better\n               B.C. to help British Columbians get through these very challenging times. As has been\n               said many times, all of us here in this amazing province have endured years unlike\n               an","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","label":"Budgets","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","label":"Economic issues","probability":0.98,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","label":"Health care facilities","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","label":"Funding","probability":0.96,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["e2ee1ebc7a4370fe04718e1be0c685125cf89ebcf45a8bf3371524c5e519fb4e"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.68,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","probability":0.89,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["751001115193fc858c756b8306510edc07c1fa8abc66653b0562ed7fd9ffadc9"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Budgets","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-501082","label":"Public Finance","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501082"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Funding","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1020045","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034948","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035618","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:715063","primary_category_id":"concept-501082","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-000fe31908f85d580487e719","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":327908,"date":"2026-03-05T08:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"Our world has become an increasingly complex and confusing place in which we live. We awaken one day to the news that war has broken out in Iran. There are global conflicts\n               in the Ukraine that continue in Syria and Israel. We're worried about financial pressures, our caregiving responsibilities and our obligation\n               to our families. Issues of isolation and grief and the constant and ever-present information\n               from the electronic and digital world keeps our bodies and minds in a constant state\n               of hyper-vigilance and constant awareness. Anxiety and depression have become increasingly prevalent in health care complaints.\n               Ordinary people are presenting at doctors' offices, complaining about a racing heart,\n               tight shoulders, poor or lack of sleep, restlessness, or a mind that simply will not\n               shut down even when the body is tired. For many the hardest part is not the symptoms,\n               it's their fear that something is wrong with them for feeling the way they do. Having spent many years in crisis and emergency management, I'm here to give you some\n               hints. Anxiety and depression are not character flaws or personal failure. It is the\n               nervous system doing exactly what it is designed to do — to notice imminent danger\n               and prepare your body for response. The problem, of course, begins when the system stays switched on too long. Our nervous\n               systems are designed to endure short systems of stress, followed quickly by recovery.\n               A threat appears, the body reacts, and once again, once the danger passes, our systems\n               return to normal. Our modern lives today rarely allow that to happen. You oversee your life and your destiny. Stress and anxiety are normal. Our bodies\n               experience moments of safety and rest. Change happens. Your sleep will improve. Your\n               tense muscles will soften. Your thoughts become less urgent. Your anxiety may not\n               disappear, but recovery will be easier. If you live with anxiety and fear, there's nothing wrong with you. Your body is trying\n               to protect you. Let your body allow your mind to do its work. If you live with anxiety and fear, there's nothing wrong with you. Your body is trying\n               to protect you. Let your body allow your mind to do its work.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260305am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:327908","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Our world has become an increasingly complex and confusing place in which we live. We awaken one day to the news that war has broken out in Iran. There are global conflicts\n               in the Ukraine that continue in Syria and Israel. We're worried about financial pressures, our caregiving responsibilities and our obligation\n               to our families. Issues of isolation and grief and the ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"War","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health professionals","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Chronic diseases","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Emergency preparedness","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","label":"Health care","probability":0.89,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035648","label":"Health professionals","probability":0.48,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42486","label":"Emergency preparedness","probability":0.23,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42526","label":"War","probability":0.63,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:79689","label":"Chronic diseases","probability":0.09,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["97574a716ff6598a3f0d0d5e6f452b76d4baa5f803fcec0f1d5c07307e514d96"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["7d94c1092cccc957b2d42f336b7d35272f47ef8aa49d4a2123f42e95403b1fba"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","topic_id":"concept-501076","label":"Health","fine_topic_label":"Health care","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501076"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035613","primary_category_id":"concept-501076","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-9df9ca9b126102e3fe7c2c60","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":358951,"date":"2026-03-11T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"It's my honour today to recognize March 8 to 14 as Social Work Week in our province.\n               We proclaim this week every year to honour the dedication shown by thousands of social\n               workers and front-line staff who have some of the hardest jobs in our province. These\n               dedicated individuals support British Columbians in our schools, hospitals, through\n               senior services, within local health authorities, non-profits, private practice, community\n               organizations, Indigenous child and family service agencies and through our public\n               service. No matter where they practise their profession, these are people who make a real difference\n               in the lives of people of all backgrounds, children, youth, families and communities\n               across the province. We know that social workers are helping people cope with some\n               of society's most challenging and heartbreaking problems — toxic drugs, homelessness,\n               cost of living, mental health issues and intimate partner violence, just as a few\n               examples. These are complex problems with no simple single solution. Yet social workers are\n               there, steady and strong, through thick and thin. For some of the most vulnerable\n               in our society, they offer critical support, bringing empathy and calm and often providing\n               hope when it seems like there is no one left. They frequently play a pivotal role\n               in helping someone rebuild their life or chart a new path, and their support is often\n               remembered with admiration long after the crisis has passed. This week shines a light on their work, but our hearts are full of thanks for them\n               day after day all year. On behalf of the government, please join me in thanking social\n               workers and front-line staff throughout our province for their kindness, passion and\n               commitment to putting people first.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":null}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260311pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:358951","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"It's my honour today to recognize March 8 to 14 as Social Work Week in our province.\n               We proclaim this week every year to honour the dedication shown by thousands of social\n               workers and front-line staff who have some of the hardest jobs in our province. These\n               dedicated individuals support British Columbians in our schools, hospitals, through\n             ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations"}]},{"topic_id":"product-SOC","label":"Social Services","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social assistance","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public service","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","label":"Social services","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","label":"Occupations","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036821","label":"Public service","probability":0.78,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037149","label":"Social assistance","probability":0.25,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1037164","label":"Social programs","probability":0.79,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a23e5a4a0a5069809f137085766827b4ed360d655ea17af1225d905e63cf0c2"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.1,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.05,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["e5410020b975803d5ae464e74392bcc79bd7e65ca681bc1e0677b9708b7aaf70"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]},"pre_product14_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036495","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Occupations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Social services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"product_taxonomy_review":{"version":"product-public-issues-14-social-services-20261022","status":"applied_to_demo","source":"reviewed_social_services_proposal","changes":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1035717","previous_category_id":"concept-42437","primary_category_id":"product-SOC"}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2d03fb5e11738cabf5f897e6","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":413650,"date":"2026-03-30T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"Thank you to the member opposite for some of the things he brought up. He, like I,\n               spent many years as a police officer. In my case, I spent many years as a police instructor,\n               so you will forgive me if I stray a bit to talk about some things that we were taught\n               as policemen and I taught as a police instructor. What we're talking about today are two pieces of legislation designed to enhance safe\n               access to important places for British Columbians. Bill 12, which is the Safe Access to Schools Amendment Act, extends the 2023 Safe\n               Access to Schools Act to July 1, 2028, simply to ensure students, staff, parents and\n               caregivers can access schools without obstruction. Bill 13, the Safe Access to Places of Public Worship Act, establishes protection against\n               harmful, disruptive or intimidating behaviour around places of worship like gurdwaras,\n               temples, synagogues, mosques and churches. On its face, none of us in this House would disagree with the intent of that legislation.\n               Schools, we all believe, should be safe places for children, and the ability to practice\n               your faith without fear or intimidation is fundamental to who we are as Canadians\n               and as British Columbians. We all know that in recent years, there has been a dramatic increase in threats and\n               harassment targeting places of worship and schools across the province. That's why\n               we are introducing the legislation. As I refer back to my days in policing, I taught, and I am sure he learned, that the\n               most dominant thing in policing is the respect that we have for the law and that as\n               a matter of practice, we apply, in our daily lives, tact to how we enforce the law.\n               We do not enforce every law. We enforce laws with what we call discretion, and in\n               my view, discretion is the biggest policy that we have. As a policeman driving down a street, you may see many things, and you may selectively\n               enforce laws that you see. You're not required to. You can't ignore it, but you do\n               what you can. So when we talk about places of worship, places where people go to practice their\n               faith, the question that must be asked is: should they be free, in a democratic society,\n               to do that? The answer....","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260330pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:413650","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-03","excerpt":"Thank you to the member opposite for some of the things he brought up. He, like I,\n               spent many years as a police officer. In my case, I spent many years as a police instructor,\n               so you will forgive me if I stray a bit to talk about some things that we were taught\n               as policemen and I taught as a police instructor. What we're talking about today are two piec","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal law","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Police services","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","label":"Criminal justice","probability":0.82,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","label":"Legal issues","probability":0.9,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","label":"Policing","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42712","label":"Police services","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.75,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:57722","label":"Criminal law","probability":0.5,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","label":"Religion","probability":0.88,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["74c85dea761f662c3cd083fa476b4bc233309676fe188f9296c153e520fa3f75"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.32,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.36,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.9,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["ee229f6df63df0d35634b7c9713915a031ef5be0376c7b33a80b02154b424deb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Criminal justice","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religion","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Policing","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Legal issues","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034725","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036099","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083659","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:59486","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-f3a8741d0ff2e6ecd13476ad","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720098,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"I'm pleased to rise in response to this private member's bill, Bill M233, entitled\n               The Public Sector Construction Projects Procurement Act. This bill purports to be\n               about requiring labour-neutral procurement for publicly funded construction projects,\n               and it does so by prohibiting public sector entities from requiring union-only labour\n               or requiring a contractor to enter a specific collective agreement as a condition\n               of bidding. The affect of a requirement like that would be to place a ban on the province from\n               using labour models like PLAs or the community benefits agreement for any future public\n               infrastructure project. It's a ban on requiring that certain major projects, like\n               Highway 1, the four-laning and the Pattullo Bridge replacement, employ local workers\n               who are guaranteed good-paying, family-supporting jobs. It's a ban on ensuring our\n               government's historic infrastructure investments also deliver the benefits that communities\n               need, like good local jobs, increased apprenticeship opportunities and an expanded\n               and skilled workforce. We reject such a ban, because now more than ever these benefits are exactly what British\n               Columbians need. As we face trade and economic headwinds, our government is proud of our record to\n               invest in British Columbians by building the infrastructure that people need and the\n               services that people depend on. In fact, our government is delivering the largest\n               capital plan in B.C. history, with thousands of projects completed or underway in\n               every corner of this province. These projects are building the infrastructure that\n               growing communities need, like hospitals, schools, transit, housing and so much more. Budget 2026 also invests nearly $38 billion in capital projects, and it's estimated\n               these projects will help create 130,000 jobs over the next three years. We believe\n               British Columbians should benefit from these investments, not only from the services\n               that will be delivered but also through the jobs they create and the support they\n               bring to local economies during construction, because none of these projects would\n               be possible without the skilled work or trades of construction workers. To deliver the infrastructure that our growing province needs, the next generation\n               of trades and construction workers needs to be trained. As I've said, this bill would ban the province from delivering major projects that\n               also achieve benefits for the communities they're built in, like prioritizing local\n               workers and creating good family-supporting jobs. We've seen the old B.C. Liberal-Conservative approach that undermines standards for\n               workers. They didn't build the infrastructure communities needed, and when they did,\n               they allowed lower paid workers, including temporary foreign workers, to get jobs\n               ahead of tradespeople who live in the very community where the project was being built.\n               These projects were often delayed and over budget and failed to deliver benefits to\n               people and communities during construction. While previous right-wing governments prioritized a race to the bottom, our government\n               knows that better is possible, that the people in the province deserve better. When we were elected, we made a commitment to deliver good-paying jobs and better\n               training and apprenticeship opportunities that will build B.C.'s next generation of\n               skilled, trained workers. We can see very plainly from this legislation who the B.C.\n               Conservatives are standing up for — not the workers, not our communities, not the\n               good-paying jobs that people here at home need. They're standing up for big It's important that the government continue to use every tool available to deliver\n               these projects responsibly and effectively. That includes applying different labour\n               models. On select major projects, government is utilizing project labour agreements\n               and the community benefits agreements. PLAs and CBAs are helping deliver important\n               projects that thousands of people will rely on every day — projects, for example,\n               like the Surrey-Langley SkyTrain, the Cowichan district hospital and highway improvements\n               and expansions across the province. These models will all help us build infrastructure, while we're also building opportunity\n               — training trades and construction workers, supporting families, creating pathways\n               for underrepresented groups, and keeping economic benefits here close to home.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720098","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I'm pleased to rise in response to this private member's bill, Bill M233, entitled\n               The Public Sector Construction Projects Procurement Act. This bill purports to be\n               about requiring labour-neutral procurement for publicly funded construction projects,\n               and it does so by prohibiting public sector entities from requiring union-only labour\n               or ","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Aid programs","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","label":"Infrastructures","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","label":"Community infrastructures","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","label":"Workers","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","label":"Public sector","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716822","label":"Aid programs","probability":0.1,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["4deeaf60af15600494b3f14c798fe5ee841e36b57c5b91997e4013558a525ae5"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","probability":0.02,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.05,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.87,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.13,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.07,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8ce450fad24bd7948ffef34e45294c714f321067b96bf357fd1f51eb472e968c"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Public sector","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Community infrastructures","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034568","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034569","primary_category_id":"concept-501080","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42433","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:47728","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-3a02021e0ec3d76bc5134dcf","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":720103,"date":"2026-04-13T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"They have been to the World Series seven times — 1947, 1973, 1978, 1997, 2005 and\n               2024. They are recognized well as the powerhouse in Canadian baseball. They, of course,\n               are the proud members and alumni of the Whalley Little League, and the World Series\n               they have participated in are Little League World Series. On Saturday, I was pleased and proud to attend the opening of their 70th season for\n               those dedicated athletes and their parents and friends at the Whalley Athletic Park.\n               The atmosphere was electric and festive. Hosted by president Clint Stewart, I know\n               it meant a great deal to the players, families and volunteers who showcased to Surrey\n               the strength of our community and the positive impact of youth in sports. The official Little League motto is \"Character, Courage and Loyalty.\" Added to the\n               official logo in 1960, this motto serves as a guiding principle to develop well-rounded\n               citizens and instil lasting values through baseball and softball. The motto emphasizes building good character, fostering courage, and promoting loyalty\n               in participants. The courage and commitment of the supporters from all over Surrey\n               are a testament to the value of that sport. Often recited Often recited before games, there is a pledge that reinforces those values. \"I trust\n               in God. I love my country and will respect its laws. I will play fair and strive to\n               win. But win or lose, I will always do my best.\" Whalley Little League, you always do your best, and I hope that this is the best year\n               ever.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260413pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:720103","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"They have been to the World Series seven times — 1947, 1973, 1978, 1997, 2005 and\n               2024. They are recognized well as the powerhouse in Canadian baseball. They, of course,\n               are the proud members and alumni of the Whalley Little League, and the World Series\n               they have participated in are Little League World Series. On Saturday, I was pleased and proud to att","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Recreational facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Theatre","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","label":"Sports events","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:123750","label":"Theatre","probability":0.01,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","label":"Sports","probability":0.97,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:726461","label":"Recreational facilities","probability":0.47,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["8b171e8a74d8e5d384ba4034f87409fcad191373556f770bdb5736cdb7aa8a82"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.28,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["34ecb11afd5f059aff6856bce75f9be583f65e616d8eeb89c842c09670e7242a"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Sports events","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036541","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43810","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-2692a1e530d58b6c27772b36","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721183,"date":"2026-04-20T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"I, too, will address all sections of this Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, as\n               did the member before me. I know it gets quite repetitive, but it's important that\n               we address the issues inherent in the act. As she did, I'm going to talk about the\n               changes in the Endowment Lands, the development cost charges, Residential Tenancy\n               Act, Correction Act, Judicial Review Procedure Act, Fuel Price Transparency Act and\n               the Zero-Emission Vehicles Act. This is legislation that is being passed now. For example, in Endowment Lands, if\n               passed, the legislation enables the enforcement of UEL bylaws through ticketing, in\n               accordance with the municipal ticketing framework established in the Community Charter.\n               In other words, it will allow the UEL to set out ticketing offences and penalties\n               of up to $3,000 in a bylaw. It also establishes that fines collected via ticketing may offset some of the operational\n               costs of enforcement through that ticketing. And it allows University Endowment Lands\n               bylaw enforcement officers to prosecute tickets in provincial court. It speeds up\n               the process for that purpose. We're making this change now because people expect and deserve good governance no\n               matter where they live in this province. It creates a mechanism of bylaw enforcement\n               which was identified as a high priority for the community during public consultations\n               of the UEL services structure and governance study. The amendments to the act will enable the enforcement of UEL bylaws by ticketing,\n               similar to what already goes on in other municipalities and local governments. We have consulted with First Nations. The xwməθkwəy̓əm Nation was notified. We've consulted with the xwməθkwəy̓əm Nation staff to discuss the proposed amendments. Consultation also included the B.C. prosecution service and the judiciary of British\n               Columbia. Next on the list is development cost charges. Here, we are proposing legislative changes\n               that give the province the authority to establish new categories of project types\n               that qualify for reduced development cost charges and development levels. These new\n               categories and project types will be created through future provincial regulations. They'll give local government and TransLink flexibility to choose to reduce or waive\n               DCCs and DCLs for additional types of housing and infrastructure to allow under current\n               provincial legislation. This is important now, at this time, to meet Canada's proposed\n               build communities strong fund, which is requiring provinces to reduce development\n               charges on multi-unit housing and cost match federal contributions, among other conditions,\n               to access federal infrastructure dollars. Making these changes at this time will put B.C. in a very strong position to engage\n               Canada in its proposed programs and quickly implement any conditions required to enter\n               a future agreement once Ottawa finalizes the project details. This allows local governments\n               access to funding that supports core public infrastructure that enables housing. With these changes, the province will be able to expand the eligible categories of\n               developments, so local governments and TransLink can lower upfront costs where it\n               makes most sense for the communities. And lower upfront costs, of course, can make\n               stalled or marginal projects viable and speed up construction timelines, helping get\n               homes built for people in the time of financial insecurity. Home builders, local government\n               and TransLink will want and will get harmonized, predictable rules that streamline\n               the process and help reduce the barriers for getting homes built. The outcome, we hope, is that the legislation will position B.C. to remove barriers\n               so more homes can be built in challenging times while helping communities fund the\n               infrastructure people rely on. Our new actions will help unlock more housing while\n               supporting the housing enabling infrastructure communities need through the new, Canada's,\n               builds communities strong fund. B.C. will also bring new categories into force by regulation once federal program\n               details are finalized, ensuring the province can align the changes with federal support\n               and avoid leaving local governments at risk. Local governments and TransLink will continue to decide whether to waive or reduce\n               DCCs and DCLs. The bill only creates authority to name additional eligible categories.\n               If lost development cost charges revenue is not offset by federal-provincial grants,\n               local governments or TransLink must then top the DCC, DCL reserve rules that are unchanged\n               from our With regard to tenancy statute amendments, the first amendment aligns the evidence\n               rules for administrative penalty proceedings with the existing dispute resolution\n               process. It provides clarity that those proceedings use evidence designed for administrative\n               decision-making rather than the court rules of evidence. It makes the whole process\n               more fair and efficient. The second amendment corrects an error in both the acts, the RTA and the MHPTA, by\n               clearly confirming the director's authority to review decisions and orders from facilitated\n               settlements. If approved, this amendment will apply retroactively to reflect how the\n               RTB has been conducting these reviews since 2024, ensuring that people can have confidence\n               in RTB decisions made during that time. The rules of evidence are formal rules designed from case law governing the admissibility,\n               weight and presentation of evidence. Under the common law, these rules are generally\n               not strictly applied to administrative proceedings. They will be here. The act expressly\n               disapplies the rules of evidence to residential tenancy branch dispute resolution\n               proceedings but are silent with respect to compliance investigations. It clarifies\n               explicitly in the act to ensure that the same rules of evidence apply in both processes. The acts were amended in 2023 to allow the RTB to conduct facilitated settlements.\n               This involves updating amendments originally passed in a 2015 bill that have never\n               been brought into force. One provision was intended to give the RTB director authority\n               to review facilitated settlement decisions or orders, but because of an oversight,\n               that provision could not come into force. The amendment clarifies the RTB director's\n               authority and confirms the validity of reviews already carried out. Moving on to the Correction Act, the proposed amendments there formally authorize\n               correctional officers to assist health care providers when delivering involuntary\n               psychiatric treatment under the Mental Health Act. At present, health providers must\n               rely on non-correctional security officers because correctional staff lack the statutory\n               authority to do so. The amendments close the legal gap and bring practice in line\n               with operational needs. Additionally, in the AG's ministry, their investigative and standards office, the\n               ISO, proposes legislative changes that better reflect their authority to conduct inspections\n               and investigations and review disciplinary hearing appeals. They also include the\n               requirement to report inspection findings to the AG's ministry and the public, as\n               well as to refine the inmate complaint process to make it more accessible and to give\n               the director broader discretion when complaints are investigated. That's an important change because it ensures timely and appropriate responses during\n               mental health crises in correctional centres by allowing trained correctional officers\n               to support health care providers directly. It also improves the effective use of public\n               resources by reducing dependence on non-correctional security officers. The ISO, the\n               investigations and standards office, amendments better reflect the authority and the\n               process taken when the ISO investigates and responds to complaints by individuals\n               in custody, thereby increasing access and accountability. These amendments support a more consistent and coordinated approach to involuntary\n               psychiatric care and custody and prepares the system for the potential expansion of\n               involuntary treatment spaces in other correctional centres. They reflect consistency\n               and approach for individuals interacting with the investigation and standards office Correctional officers are highly trained to manage high-risk and complex situations,\n               and they're very well equipped to support individuals in crisis. The amendments ensure\n               officers can assist health care providers as required, improve continuity and consistency\n               of care, and support coordinated responses during psychiatric emergencies. The amendments\n               provide clear statutory authority only for the specific purpose of assisting health\n               care providers during involuntary psychiatric treatment under the B.C. Mental Health\n               Act. Going on to the Judicial Review Procedure Act, the amendments there modernize the\n               procedure to keep judicial reviews fair, timely and affordable. The changes clarify\n               how sensitive cabinet information is protected during court challenges, while ensuring\n               judicial reviews remain streamlined and focused on accountability rather than becoming\n               expensive trial-like proceedings. The amendments also introduce a clear 60-day deadline\n               to apply for judicial reviews, in most cases, reducing delay, uncertainty and legal\n               costs for individuals, tribunals in government. It's important that we make this change now because of a recent B.C. Court of Appeal\n               decision regarding the mink breeders confirming that courts can require the government\n               to produce a list of cabinet documents during the judicial review even though cabinet\n               discussions are confidential. Being forced to disclose lists of cabinet documents\n               creates legal risk, undermines public interest, immunity and adds another cost as\n               well as delay to court proceedings. Other governments in in this country, Canada and Alberta, already have stronger legal\n               tools to protect cabinet confidentiality, and B.C. by comparison is exposed. The outcomes,\n               we hope, of these amendments will lead to faster, more predictable judicial reviews,\n               stronger protection of cabinet and Treasury Board confidentiality and reduced costs\n               and delays in the entire process. In the Fuel Transparency Act, the act, as set out in 2019, promotes transparency,\n               competitiveness and public confidence in the transportation fuel market. The new amendments\n               will enable an industry-funded model where the administrator, the British Columbia\n               Utilities Commission, can recover the costs of administering the legislation from\n               fuel producers and wholesale fuel importers. It creates the authority for government to make regulation that authorizes the administrator\n               to set fees payable by fuel producers and wholesale fuel importers during a fiscal\n               year. It specifies that unpaid levies would be recoverable as a debt owing to the\n               government and would accrue interest on the amount outstanding. The legislation further creates authority for government to make regulations that\n               require the commission to hold a hearing before setting fees. That enables affected\n               parties to have the opportunity to express their views on a fair fee allocation framework.\n               Regulations will also set interest rates payable for unpaid fees. Why are we doing this now? Since the transparency act came into force in 2019, costs\n               have been paid by government. The shift to an industry-funded approach will alleviate\n               that cost, ensuring that resources continue to be made available for other government\n               priorities. This is similar to the long-standing practice of public utilities like B.C. Hydro\n               and Fortis funding the BCUC for their oversight through an energy levy that is set\n               each year. The BCUC, as you know, is an independent regulatory body responsible for\n               regulating B.C.'s energy utilities, basic auto insurance rates and interprovincial The BCUC, as you know, is an independent regulatory body responsible for regulating\n               B.C.'s energy utilities, basic auto insurance rates and interprovincial pipeline rates. The commission has also been appointed by government as the administrator of the fuel\n               transparency act. Why the change? Currently the Fuel Price Transparency Act doesn't\n               allow government to recover admin costs from fuel suppliers. As a result, all administration\n               costs are currently being funded by government. Amending the act allows costs to be\n               recovered directly from industry. The B.C. Utilities Commission, in its role, will design, set and collect the fee.\n               The BCUC was appointed as administrator of the Fuel Price Transparency Act in 2019.\n               The allocation methodology for collection will be determined by the BCUC in a public\n               process. With regard to zero-emission vehicles, the proposed amendments reduce the 2035 target\n               from 100 percent ZEV sales to 75 percent ZEV sales. It removes the prohibition on\n               the sale of new internal combustion engine vehicles from January 1, 2035. It shifts\n               the 2026 and 2030 ZEV sales target to the ZEV regulation alone to allow greater flexibility\n               to adapt to changing market conditions. There are new regulations that implement the details of these legislative changes,\n               which will be updated in due course. The updated regulations will retain the 26 percent\n               ZEV sales target for 2026. They will also include the 2030 target, which will be determined\n               following emission standards proposals by the federal government for 2030, which are\n               expected to come later this year. It's important that we make the changes now. We're making amendments to revise our\n               sales target in response to evolving market conditions. We are aligning the ZEV mandates\n               with the federal government's goals, which provides certainty for automakers; reduces\n               their regulatory burden; and supports them in addressing challenges, such as slowing\n               consumer adoption driven by high purchase costs, supply chain disruptions and the\n               U.S. tariffs. How do they affect profitability and affordability? The proposed changes address affordability\n               of vehicles by ensuring that the targets are achievable, avoiding the potential of\n               automakers artificially reducing the supply of internal combustion engines in the\n               province, which could increase the price of new and used vehicles. Although ZEVs currently have higher upfront purchase costs, their maintenance and\n               operation are significantly lower, often making total cost of ownership for ZEVs less\n               than conventional internal combustion engines. Gas is the major contributor to household fuels. Transporting to electrified transportation\n               significantly reduces household fuel expenditures. A typical EV driver in B.C. saves\n               $2,600 to $3,400 per year, compared to a driver of an equivalent gas vehicle, or up\n               to $34,000 over a decade. This is sensible information. It is important that we address these issues as they\n               emerge.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260420pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721183","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I, too, will address all sections of this Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, as\n               did the member before me. I know it gets quite repetitive, but it's important that\n               we address the issues inherent in the act. As she did, I'm going to talk about the\n               changes in the Endowment Lands, the development cost charges, Residential Tenancy\n               Act, Corr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions"}]},{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","label":"Courts","probability":0.84,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","label":"Correctional institutions","probability":0.96,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","label":"Regulatory agencies","probability":0.91,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","label":"Justice system","probability":0.86,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","label":"Regulations","probability":0.92,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["7053e70f43c1b96d756294e2e668ae340bd76a147c2df151a4b10db541b260c0"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","probability":0.15,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","probability":0.63,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["152e9a20004b34f92fd9c01d2fad00112d6adfce66a4f80a03451823720d751b"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Courts","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulatory agencies","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Regulations","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Justice system","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501071","label":"Governance","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501071"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Correctional institutions","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1017954","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034697","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036924","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43666","primary_category_id":"concept-501083","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501078","primary_category_id":"concept-501071","needs_review":true}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-96034e9b2b13b321a3cc5d68","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":721184,"date":"2026-04-21T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"I rise today in recognition of Tourism Week in British Columbia, April 20 to 24. Tourism is a cornerstone of B.C.'s economy and a source of pride for communities throughout\n               our province. This week we celebrate the people whose dedication, creativity and hospitality\n               power one of the most dynamic and sustainable sectors, helping make B.C. a destination\n               travelers aspire to visit, return to and recommend to the world. With year-round resorts and lakeside campgrounds, outdoor adventures, vibrant urban\n               centres and Indigenous cultural experiences, tourism offers visitors authentic, four-season\n               and uniquely British Columbian experiences rooted in people, places and culture. Through\n               locally owned restaurants, world-class food and beverage producers, attractions, museums\n               and heritage sites, visitors connect with stories that can only be found here and\n               with communities that proudly share them. Together, this industry delivers real economic\n               and social benefits for people in every region of this province. Tourism generates $23 billion in annual revenue, contributes $8 billion to provincial\n               GDP and supports more than 113,000 jobs across nearly 17,000 businesses, the vast\n               majority of them being small businesses. Nearly 40 percent of this activity occurs\n               outside the Lower Mainland, making tourism essential to rural and remote communities. In March, this government launched the Look West tourism sector action plan with industry\n               partners as we prepare to welcome the world for the FIFA World Cup. This plan is our\n               roadmap to leverage global attention, showcase B.C. as a world-class destination and\n               ensure long-term sustainable growth that benefits people throughout the province. This Tourism Week we thank the workers, business owners and partners who make visitors\n               feel welcome and strengthen our communities every day. I ask members of this House to join me in celebrating their contributions.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260421am-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:721184","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-04","excerpt":"I rise today in recognition of Tourism Week in British Columbia, April 20 to 24. Tourism is a cornerstone of B.C.'s economy and a source of pride for communities throughout\n               our province. This week we celebrate the people whose dedication, creativity and hospitality\n               power one of the most dynamic and sustainable sectors, helping make B.C. a destination\n               tr","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131383","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Restaurants","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","label":"Tourism facilities","probability":0.8,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:131383","label":"Restaurants","probability":0.7,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","label":"Economic development","probability":0.95,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","label":"Tourism","probability":0.99,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","label":"Industry","probability":0.91,"accepted":true}],"request_sha256":["57e4b670f11785bb1e5f70a22653151e370ab0550a812c0a502e7fdfb0db2142"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.08,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","probability":0.04,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","probability":0.88,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","probability":0.02,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["96ff91a813f55ab6b7eccdec39f9abf36938c2746afd661301108eca180f9248"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"}],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-43397","label":"Defence & Foreign Affairs","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:43397"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Industry","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism facilities","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-501080","label":"Housing & Development","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501080"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Economic development","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Tourism","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1083646","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44330","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44418","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501317","primary_category_id":"concept-44948","needs_review":false}]}},{"record_id":"contribution-c597ef5a54c3ef0e6034e026","kind":"transcript","graph_record_id":1036391,"date":"2026-05-25T07:00:00+00:00","title":"Hansard","speaker":"Garry Begg","venue":"Hansard","text":"On the 14th day of May, I was honoured to join members of the Fiji Canada Association\n               in their hall in Surrey celebrating together Girmit Day. The government of British\n               Columbia officially proclaimed May 14 as Girmityas Remembrance Day to honour the historical contributions and resilience of indentured\n               Indian labourers, the Girmityas, particularly those who migrated to Fiji. Girmit refers to contracts under which tens of thousands of Indians were transported\n               by the British Empire between 1834 and 1920 to work on sugar plantations in Fiji.\n               May 14 marks the 1879 arrival of the Leonidas , the first ship carrying indentured labourers. We gathered to honour the history, courage and legacy of the Girmityas, the men, women\n               and children who left their homeland under the indenture system and journeyed across\n               oceans in search of a better future. The word \"girmit\" comes from the mispronunciation\n               of the English word \"agreement\". But for those who signed those agreements, the journey\n               was far more than a contract. It was a story of sacrifice, hope, resilience. Beginning in the late 19th century, thousands of Indians were taken to countries such\n               as Fiji, Guyana, Trinidad, Mauritius and South Africa to work on plantations. They\n               endured separation from their families, difficult working conditions and uncertainty\n               about their future. Yet despite these challenges, they preserved their culture, language,\n               faith, music and traditions. Girmit is not only a remembrance of suffering. It's also a celebration of endurance\n               and achievement. It reminds us all of the importance of unity, dignity, equality and\n               human rights. It teaches, I hope, future generations to value freedom, opportunity\n               and cultural heritage. May we always remember their journey, honour their legacy and inspire future generations\n               to build a world rooted in justice, understanding and peace.","text_scope":"stored contribution text","text_available":true,"source_url":"https://lims.leg.bc.ca/hdms/file/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","source_status":"archive_reference_not_rechecked","classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"stored_source_url":"https://www.leg.bc.ca/hansard-content/Debates/43rd2nd/20260525pm-House-Blues.htm","database_record_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1036391","member_id":"bc-mla-9","member_name":"Garry Begg","month":"2026-05","excerpt":"On the 14th day of May, I was honoured to join members of the Fiji Canada Association\n               in their hall in Surrey celebrating together Girmit Day. The government of British\n               Columbia officially proclaimed May 14 as Girmityas Remembrance Day to honour the historical contributions and resilience of indentured\n               Indian labourers, the Girmityas, particularly those","excerpt_is_truncated":true,"concepts":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","matched_fine_topics":[{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage"},{"id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage"}]}],"data_issues":["source_contents_not_reverified_in_this_build"],"source_contents_independently_verified":false,"legacy_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-44948","label":"Economy & Employment","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:44948"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","topic_id":"concept-397184","label":"Environment & Resources","fine_topic_label":"Agricultural workers","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:397184"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Religious heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501084","label":"Rights & Inclusion","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501084"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","topic_id":"concept-501083","label":"Public Safety & Justice","fine_topic_label":"Human rights","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501083"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:1034462","label":"Human rights","probability":0.66,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","label":"Cultural heritage","probability":0.94,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","label":"Heritage","probability":0.92,"accepted":true},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:716813","label":"Agricultural workers","probability":0.49,"accepted":false},{"topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:88245","label":"Religious heritage","probability":0.14,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3b354e8634c4c1c9f51bb51b363bf3e8810472f30a560eaee8e4547b322d7140"]},"pre_category_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_category_review":{"status":"complete","model":"jev-1.14.0","threshold":0.8,"scores":[{"topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","probability":0.29,"accepted":false}],"request_sha256":["3a93b47a8f22f1c38e1ac62f1eb676458f30dfa2c6dc689ac66ea70cb709abbb"],"policy":"Count a transcript/category association only when its detailed tag and the category itself independently pass Jev at their configured cutoffs. Require contextual support for each category; multiple substantive branches are allowed. Keep the full detailed-tag review for audit.","applied_to_display":false},"category_audit_classifications":[],"pre_primary_classifications":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","topic_id":"concept-42437","label":"Community Life","fine_topic_label":"Cultural heritage","database_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42437"}],"jev_primary_category_review":{"run_id":"primary-bf3925178c22b958d8e30d3b","policy":"Display each existing detailed topic under exactly one of its existing category parents. Jev ranks ambiguous parents by the topic meaning; preserve all alternatives and audit scores. This ranking does not reject already accepted detailed topics.","choices":[{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:42456","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false},{"fine_topic_id":"4:b64ad855-0928-41d5-ae91-50fae70bb162:501126","primary_category_id":"concept-42437","needs_review":false}]}}]}
